A CMO’s Brand Implementation Playbook
Dear Leaders of Change, Over the past two decades I’ve been fortunate to meet with senior executives charged with safeguarding the world’s most valuable brands during times of change. It’s the part of my job I love the most. I’ve learned that leaders, especially CMOs, are searching for insights, proven processes, and tools to help their teams implement rebrands effectively. That’s why I’ve developed this CMO Brand Implementation Playbook of best practices based on our firm’s 25 years of experience focusing exclusively on the strategy, financial analysis, and logistics of rebrand implementation and brand and marketing operations. Use it to lock in the many rewards of a successful rebrand: increased brand impact, cost savings, better processes, resource efficiency, and global quality and consistency. I hope you find this guidebook helpful. As always, I am here to answer questions and discuss thoughts or topics you would like to explore. Sincerely, Philip Guiliano Partner, BrandActive p.guiliano@brandactive.com
Table of Contents 01
Understand the ecosystem ........................................... 07
02
The art and science of powerful questions .................. 13
03
The strategic blueprint ................................................... 17
04
Assess strategic options ............................................... 25
05
From high-level scoping to flawless execution ............ 37
06
Design the perfect team ................................................ 43
07
Leverage your rebrand to improve operations .............. 49
08
Seek specialized help .................................................... 61
3
What’s your end game? A rebrand presents both opportunity and risk, whether it’s in response to a merger or acquisition, or a new direction for the organization. It’s not enough to show the rest of the C-suite and the board your end game. They want—and deserve—justification. How much will it cost to get there? How long will it take? What metrics prove the value of the endeavor? That’s where our blueprint comes in. In this roadmap, we will illustrate how professional rebrand implementation works and how to make it a critical success factor in how you achieve your end game. We’ll dive into fundamental questions that every CMO needs to consider and answer to execute an effective rebrand. We will reveal the opportunities and hazards, and suggest the safe passages that can hasten the journey. Let’s begin.
5
01
Understand the ecosystem.
Understand the ecosystem. Rebrand implementation is a highly specialized endeavor that can rarely be accomplished with internal resources alone. Seldom do your current team members have the knowledge and experience to optimize it. Indeed, dealing with a rebrand could almost double the workload of your team. You’ll need a village – ideally, of rebrand veterans.
“
Experience is a master teacher, even when it’s not our own. – Gina Greenlee, Author and Organizational Development Professional
Left Hemisphere, meet Right Hemisphere. Logic and creativity. Analysis and intuition. While branding agencies will bring research and strategic expertise to the table, you need more. To successfully operationalize your rebrand, you also require deep analysis of your organization’s strengths and weaknesses, the ability to fully scope the potential savings and opportunities, and the foresight to develop a long-term roadmap to success.
Rebrand Implementation
Creative Agency
Asset scoping
Brand/consumer research
Scenario modeling
Customer experience mapping
Cost analysis and savings
Brand strategy
Opportunity analysis
Identity/creative design
Operational brand governance structure
Communications planning
Optimal planning and execution
Employee engagement
Procurement support
Launch events
9
Parallel paths. Two distinct disciplines. These are not linear activities that happen after the brand is developed. They happen along parallel tracks and timelines.
Creative Agency Scope and Assess
Plan and Prepare
Rollout and Manage
Close and Maintain
Research
Application guidelines
Brand strategy
Templates and asset families
Brand culture and training
Brand culture and training
Launch events
Brand engagement
Brand tracking
Brand toolkits
Brand experience improvement
Ongoing measurement
Identity/logo design Brand architecture Brand guidelines Brand messaging
Marketing and advertising Corporate communications Brand tools Websites
Rebrand Implementation Scope and Assess
Plan and Prepare
Rollout and Manage
Close and Maintain
Technical/financial audits
Transition strategies
Project management
Transition options
Detailed transition plans
Reporting tools
Post-implementation audit
Project communications
Process automation
RFP creation management
Manufacturing and installation
Budgets and timelines Prioritization Rationalization Value engineering Process improvement Vendor strategies Project organization
Procurement optimization Technical specifications Implementation tools
Field support help desk
Vendor management Project governance Direct procurement of assets Brand operational governance
Brand management technology Asset maintenance Brand operations help desk Ongoing governance Merger playbooks Agency analysis management Close out rebrand project
11
02
The art and science of powerful questions.
Asking the right questions. The most effective rebrands begin with a process of answering a range of critical questions. You need to start with due diligence—from proper scoping to defining what you have and the options that exist to convert them, to understanding interdependencies and risks, to defining project structure. If you don’t, the benefits can remain hidden, outcomes can be fuzzy, and the entire process can be costly and painful, not to mention a drag on your resources. On the other hand, applying rigor in answering the tough questions provides early insight and the clarity to gain executive buy-in, determines exactly how you will execute and manage the program, defines how to most effectively use resources, and saves money. This ultimately maximizes the impact of your brand change.
“
Success is where preparation and opportunity meet. – Bobby Unser, Three-time Indy 500 Winner
Questions for clarity What is the complete scope of this project?
Which launch strategy is right for our rebrand?
What business strategies and goals must our rebrand support?
What resources and/or technology will be required?
Which stakeholders need to be part of the process?
How much will this cost?
What are the biggest obstacles to your success? Who are the vendors you currently work with to produce assets, collateral, signage, and other branded touchpoints? Are there legal implications to keep in mind for this rebrand?
What are the options? When will the various stages of the rebrand happen? What are the interdependencies and/or risks of rebranding? How will this rebrand move our company forward? Who should be on our core rebranding team and how can we support them?
Powerful outcomes Gain buy-in and align expectations.
Improve time-to-market.
Save millions of dollars (20-35% typically).
Achieve operational efficiencies.
Reduce year-over-year spend (10-25%).
Rationalize and standardize the process.
Maximize brand impact and ROI.
Improve employee and consumer quality and engagement.
Reduce resource strain.
Finish what you start on-time.
Simplify rebrand execution.
15
03
The strategic blueprint.
Create a strategic blueprint. Rebranding is more than a process leading to a one-off event where you flip a switch, cheer, and then life returns to “normal.” It’s the one time you’re going to be touching everything, everywhere your brand lives. And everything could mean thousands of branded assets distributed across multiple operational areas. A rebrand affords a perfect opportunity to look for strategic and tactical efficiencies in what you do every day, how you do it, who you do it with, what you pay, and how standardized and repeatable it all is. It’s also not just about getting to and through launch – it’s about having a plan to maintain momentum and finish what you start. It’s about the right strategies and prioritization, the right degree of centralization for decentralized execution, how you will control and support it, and much more. If you look at the process from this perspective, the rebrand itself sets up structures that provide payback in operational efficiencies week in and week out, year in and year out.
A typical rebrand of a large enterprise might have over 600 touchpoints across 25 major asset groups. Advertising Billboards Blue book directories Co-op advertising Direct mail Lamp post advertising Magazine ads Online ads Online banner ads Outdoor ads Print ads Radio ads Sandwich boards Third-party advertising Trade publications Transit advertising TV advertising signatures White/yellow pages directories Branded Environments Brand wall panels Branded murals Brochure racks Cafeteria/dining rooms Customer waiting areas Display cases Donor walls Elevator interiors Exterior building walls Furniture Glass vinyl graphics Interior brand walls
Interior walls Kiosks Libraries Lobbies Meeting rooms Notice boards Office desk mats Painted walls Podiums Stair treads Super graphics Themed areas Visitor arrival areas Visitor centers Visitor routes Window film Business Forms Accounts payable checks applications Appointment cards Appointment slips Bill of lading Checks Consent forms Contracts Corporate checks Electronic forms Estimate forms External use form Information forms Inserts Internal forms
Invoices Lab requisition forms Operations forms Order forms Participant forms Patient charts Patient forms Prescription forms Purchase orders Quality reports Records Referral forms Reports Requisitions Returns Shipping forms Volunteer applications
Invitations Labels Letterhead Mailing labels Maps Memos Microsoft Office templates Notepads Notices Patient cards Patient education booklets Patient education pamphlets Patient fact sheets Patient information sheets Patient instruction sheets
Business Papers
Annual reports Backgrounders Corporate overviews Corporate presentations Email alerts Employee broadcasts Employee communications plans Employee events Employee magazines Executive messages External e-newsletters External print newsletters Fact sheets Financial reports
Account statements Agendas Appointment sheets Bank machine receipts Binders Business cards Confirmations Corporate checks Envelopes Express checks Facsimile templates File folders Greeting cards Information sheets
Corporate Communication
19
… and yes, there’s more... Internal e-newsletters Internal print newsletters Internal publications Investor news Leadership communications toolkits Magazines Media consent forms Media releases Newsletters Presentation templates Quarterly reports Quick facts Retiree communications Stockholder communications Summary reports Educational Materials Graduation certificates Training booklets Training materials Equipment Bins/containers Catering kits Construction tools and equipment Drums Field tanks Industrial equipment (lifts, cable laying equipment) Industrial materials (pipes, cable, etc.)
Instrumentation Intermediate bulk containers (IBCs) ISO containers IV bags Keys Mailing equipment Nursing chairs/wheelchairs Office supplies Patient diet kits Portable toilets Time cards Time clocks Tray covers Exhibits Self standing displays Badge holders Badges Display cases Event backdrops and podiums Exhibit banners Floor displays, hospitality and VIP centers Promotional material Table cloths Trade show exhibit/booths Exterior Signs Awnings Banners Box signs Building identification
Canopies Corporate flags Digital displays Directional ground mounts Directional wall mounts Directories Door decals Door identifiers (rollups, man doors) Emergency signs Exterior wayfinding signs Fascia signs (flat panel) Flat panel signs Gobo lighting Historical plaques Illuminated channel letters Information signs Interior wayfinding signs Monuments Parking signs Portable signs Post and panel signs Pylons Regulatory signs Safety signs Security signs Traffic control signs Vinyl graphics Temporary exterior signs Finance Credit cards Financial reports
Human Resources Adhesive name badges Auxiliary communications Awards Badge clips Badge reels Benefits materials Central employee message boards Certificates Departmental/employee directories Employee badges Employee recognition awards Employment applications Generic badges HSE materials Insurance certificates Job descriptions Newsletters Orientation materials Parking stickers Payment cards Payroll service screens Pension details for retirees Plaques Policies and procedures Policy wallet cards Recruiting materials Research paper/thesis Security and access badges
Service pins Talent management programs Time cards Time clocks Visas Volunteer badges Information Technology Antenna Audio systems Back-up storage Black fibers Business applications Cable testers Call center systems Cameras Cisco call manager Cloud computing Clusters/servers Coax cables Computer screen wallpapers Conduits Configuration Customer-facing systems Data rooms Desktops Direct email programs Electrical panels Electronic calendars Electronic presentation materials Electronic templates
Email addresses and signatures Emergency telephones Employee-facing systems Ethernet Cables Cat5 Cat 6 Extranet Fax server Fiber optics indoor/outdoor Fire systems Graphical interfaces Headsets Health hotlines Identity manager Internet URL Intranet URL IOS IP cameras IP phones Junction boxes Juniper Keypads access control Laptops Layer 2 testing equipment Linux Microsoft Office templates Multimedia presentations Network diagrams Online forms Online shipping Order entry forms
Phone screen displays PowerPoint presentations Printers Program icons Programmed fax headers Routers Screensavers Server names Software programs Sound paging intercom Switches Telecom lines Telnet sessions Test equipment Thermal efficiency equipment Third-party websites Topology diagrams Video conferencing Voice response units Messages and scripts Web servers Windows Wireless access points Interior Signs Bulletin boards Corporate directories Display cases Elevators directories Entrances Facility maps Flags
Floor identification Floor standing signs Information signs Kiosks Main lobby signs Name plates Plaques Podium signs Portable signs Reception signs Regulatory signs Restroom identification Room identification Room plaques Rugs/door mats Stairs identification Temporary interior signs T-stand posters Wayfinding signs Window vinyl graphics Workspace identification Legal Articles of amendment Company name (international entities) Company name (legal entity) Contracts, agreements, licenses Corporate registrations Corporate stamps Governance documents Insurance certificates
21
…still more… and there’s even more than this. Insurer payments Leases (equipment rentals) Medical governing organization accreditations Medicare/Medicaid/HMO materials Notice to partner organizations Products registrations Stock exchange listings Trademark databases
Patient billing inserts Patient gifts materials Posters Presentation covers Product catalogs Product materials Sales catalogs Sales materials Sales videos Scripts, plans, tools White papers
Marketing Communication
Operational
Booklets Brochure racks Brochures Business folders Calendars Capabilities brochures Corporate videos Customer case studies Digital images Electronic direct mail Executive briefs Flyers Greeting cards Hardcover books International communications International doc formats Investor communications Maps Newsletters Partner/dealer magazines
Bulletin boards Operational manuals Rubber stamps Packaging Adhesive tape Bags, binders Boxes Hang tags Inserts, in-store displays Membership cards Holders Product boxes Product labels Shipping cartons/crates Shopping bags Software installation User manuals Warranty cards Wrappers
Products and Packaging Adhesive tape Bags Binders Hang tags In-store displays Membership cards, holders, etc. Product boxes Product labels Shipping cartons/crates Shopping bags Wrappers Retail gift shops Plastic bags Point-of-sale products Third-party vendors Promotional Merchandise Apparel Bags Balloons Ballpoint pens Bandages Baseball caps Binders Calculators Calendars Can/bottle openers Card holders Chewing gum Clocks Drink ware
Event merchandise Flashlights Golf balls Golfing equipment Hats Jackets Key chains Lapel pins Laundry bags/nets Luggage tags Mouse pads Mugs Online stores Pens and pencils Pins Portfolios Rulers and tape measures Serviettes Sporting equipment Standard clothing items Stress toys Sugar packets Tire gauges Umbrellas and rain coats Retail Gift shops Licensed product distributors Plastic bags Point-of-sale products
Security Asset tags Contractor passes ID badges Parking stickers Patient ID bracelets Security and risk offices Visitor badges Visitor logs Visitor passes Visitor safety videos Social Media Facebook Instagram LinkedIn Reddit SnapChat Social media management systems Social media plans TikTok Twitter Sponsorship Associations Business event sponsorship Charity sponsorship materials Corporate events Co-sponsorship Cultural events Local events
National events Partnerships Sports sponsorship Trade show materials Vehicles Airplane Ambulance Blimp Commercial vehicles Delivery vehicles Fleet graphic wraps Fuel cards Golf carts Health mobile units Helicopter Landscaping vehicles Passenger cars Pickup trucks Promotional vehicles Shuttle buses Special event vehicles Trailers Trucks Vehicle magnet signs Vessels
gowns, sheets, diapers, etc.) Jackets Lab coats Laundry hampers Non-medical staff scrubs Patches Safety equipment (hard hats, vests, etc.) Scrubs Seasonal uniform style Security uniforms Service standard uniforms Smocks Vests Volunteer uniforms
Workwear and Uniforms Aprons Casual standard uniforms Coveralls Hard hat decals Headgear (hats, caps, etc.) Hospital linens (towels,
23
04
Assess strategic options.
You’re about to spend millions. Consider your options for better payback. However many assets your rebrand touches, considerations of time, scope, asset strategy and segmentation, quality, and global implications, dependencies, and other complexities should ultimately inform your decisions on how best to roll out your brand. How much of the rebrand needs to be complete when you launch? How could switching out branded assets over time save money? What assets are simply not needed? Where can quality never be sacrificed, and where can lower quality still produce an effective and acceptable result? Working with substantiated data to assess strategic options becomes the most valuable exercise you will ever undertake as a brand leader in the company. It will give you the assurance of true due diligence and empower you with options. It will win over skeptics. And it will drastically lower the risk of unpleasant surprises.
“
Completing a $25 million, marketing-focused project ahead of schedule and under budget is truly a notable feat and one that the branding industry can learn from. – Angie Specic, Director of Marketing, Allstream
27
Dozens of major decisions must be made that affect cost return. Factors of time, scope and quality all need to factor into the development of your brand implementation plan.
TIME Launch Period Weeks
Completion Speed Months
Months
Years
SCOPE Brand Scope Rebrand All
Branded Assets Selective Rebrand
All Branded Assets
Selective Branded Assets
QUALITY Production Quality Gold
Silver
Brand Application Bronze
High
Medium
Low
Region / Affiliate Timing All Brands Simultaneously
Touchpoint Prioritization Individual Schedule
Prioritized HighSpeed Transition
Launch and Completion “Big Bang” Launch
Operational Replacement
Resourcing Soft Launch
Additional
Existing
Quality Prioritization Equal Quality
Lower Quality
29
Asset prioritization, segmentation and strategy evaluation. Healthcare system example: Cost by complexity and brand impact It’s important to understand the impact/value you get out of each branded asset, as well as the complexity of chaning them. This can help identify opportunities for neutralization, increased ROI of under-leveraged assets, must-haves, and areas where you need additional support. This gets even more powerful when you segment each asset type and develop different strategies for each segment. High-profile locations may get a different level of signage application than others. You may invest in converting only 30% of your products that account for 85% of your revenue – leaving the others for operational cycles. And so on.
COMPLEXITY
HIGH
IT Applications
Signage Legal / Regulatory
Uniforms / PPE & Workwear
Websites Marketing Comms
Branded Env.
Events / Sponsorship Biz. Forms
BRAND IMPACT
LOW
Internal impact/visibility
ID Badges
External impact/visibility
*size of the bubble indicates the typical approximate proportion of rebrand cost estimates.
HIGH
31
Detail each scenario with asset conversion timelines. Once you define the asset strategies, timing, quality, vendor strategies, and other variables, you can then build a timeline for each scenario including all dependencies.
Year 1 Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Brand
Dec
Remaining brand templates & portal
Marketing Sales
Nov Phase 1 collateral Phase 1 assets
Sample welcome kits for Sales team
Events
Priority banners
Civic Affairs
Logo swaps
Digital & IT
Email domains, priority websites and portals
CRNS & Provider
Phase 1 assets
Supply Chain
Phase 1 assets
Legal & IP
Contracts and remaining trademarks Security vehicles Signage and environmental branding (design playbook and site surveys)
Legend Planning activities Division launch assets Phase 1 – priority assets in market Phase 2 – majority assets in market Phase 3 – remaining assets in market
Year 2 Q1
Q2
Phase 2 collateral
Year 3 Q3
Q4
Phase 3 collateral
Phase 2 collateral
Phase 3 collateral
Remaining assets Scholarship Remaining digital properties
Lower impact
Remaining assets Remaining assets
All 16 vehicles Top 5 sites
Remaining 20 sites
33
Scenario pricing / planning (example) Pricing out options removes theoretical roadblocks and replaces them with defined and very real line items. It shifts the conversation from “we couldn’t possible afford that,” or “we can’t change our name because it’s too expensive” to a realistic assessment of cost vs. benefit. Options can help you secure more budget and disarm your CFO from blindly cutting the budget down without understanding the implications of doing so.
Asset Category
Scenario 1
Scenario 2
Scenario 3
Administration (finance and human resources)
$369,460
$200,044
$40,766
Branded environments (brand walls)
$444,955
$322,039
$114,792
Business forms and papers
$693,753
$264,852
$78,585
Interior and exterior signage
$3,945,042
$2,046,227
$1,049,931
Information technology and telecom
$2,806,644
$2,552,622
$1,297,799
Legal and regulatory
$660,000
$495,000
$165,000
Marketing collateral and promotional items
$76,884
$48,755
$15,000
Security (includes ID badges)
$16,158
-
-
Web and social media
$6,143,334
$4,754,583
$2,611,200
Event materials
$115,326
$109,974
$75,000
Brand identity, architecture and guidelines, and design (concepts and advertising campaign)
$2,560,000
$2,360,000
$1,760,000
Branding incentives
$1,295,651
$863, 768
$431,844
Brand engagement (launch activities)
$2,757,900
$2,750,700
$2,701,100
Brand identity management system
$1,050,000
$960,000
$645,000
Specialized implementation support
$1,588,064
$1,327,012
$1,087,715
$19,055,576
$12,073,732
$4,763,894
$3,018,433
$23,819,470
$15,092,165
Subtotal $24,523,171 Contingency (25%) $6,130,793 TOTAL $30,653,963
Cost estimate by CapEx and OpEx Another useful lens you can use to assess your brand implementation plans is through CapEx versus OpEx. Every rebrand entails a blend of capital and operational expenses, and the decisions you make relative to asset strategy impact how much of the cost can be accounted for in each bucket. Understanding these dynamics, and the decisions used to arrive at them, can not only improve ROI, but is also very important financial information that will help people weigh the options vs. true financial impact of the cost.
SCENARIO 01 16% 84%
CapEx: $4,959,757 OpEx: $25,694,207 Total: $30,653,963
SCENARIO 02 11% 89%
CapEx: $2,551,590 OpEx: $21,267,881 Total: $23,819,470
SCENARIO 03 9% 91%
CapEx: $1,316,716 OpEx: $13,775,449 Total: $15,092,165
35
05
From high-level scoping to flawless execution.
From high-level scoping to flawless execution. It’s time to get into the nitty-gritty. In the next few pages, we’ve provided some examples of the process diagrams, spreadsheets, and dashboards that will ensure the devil never has a hand in the details of a rebrand implementation. The more detailed and precise you are in making sure every aspect of operations and execution are covered, the better the result.
“
From up-front planning and strategy, to execution and follow through, BrandActive was thorough, accurate and forward-thinking which helped us successfully rebrand ourselves and continue to serve our community in their time of need. We couldn’t have done it without them. – Rob Lee, Executive Director, Marketing and Corporate Communications, Garnet Health
Transitioning from high-level scoping to detailed planning. The Scope and Assess phase lays the foundation with a deep dive into different implementation scenarios, aligning expectations surrounding cost, timing, quality, and other factors. From there, with the right implementation scenario selected, the real work of detailed planning and optimization begins. BrandActive works with clients to establish overall project governance, engage the operational area workgroup leaders in planning every asset, and then integrates it all into the CMO’s single holistic plan. Ideally, this will occur at least six months before launch.
Scope and Assess
Branded Asset Conversion
Scoping Signage
IT systems
Branded environement
Websites
Products & packaging
Detailed Planning
Marketing collateral
Prioritzed asset inventories Transition strategies Refined budgets
HR materials
Project Plans
Business cards
Launch materials
Integrated schedule
Forms & papers
Workwear
Interdependencies
Fleet
Communications Risk identification
Timing Wave 1 > Wave 2 > Wave 3
Organization Project structure
Costing
Stakeholder identification
Cost estimates
Vendor engagement
Opportunities Brand expression Brand consistency Brand governance Branded materials refresh
Governance Processes Brand compliance Progress tracking Reporting Budget governance
39
Good plans need to be supported with good systems, processes, and details to provide clarity and keep the project on track.
Sample product dashboard
# of items completed
Marketing Collateral N/A
Marketing Collateral - North America
$131,055
Total # of items
150
Estimate cost
155
100 50 0
Budget
155
250
$109,994
Total # completed
3/10 3/13 3/20 4/3 4/10 4/17 4/24 5/1 5/9 5/15 5/22 5/29 6/5 6/12 6/20 7/1 7/14 7/22 8/1 Dates
Items Completed - Plan
Actual cost
Marketing Collateral - Latin America
$21,061
23
Items Completed - Actual
Variance
Total # of items
23
Technical Publications
IT Assets
# of items completed
Total # completed
8
250 150 100 50 0
Total # of items
Technical Publications
3/10 3/13 3/20 4/3 4/10 4/17 4/24 5/1 5/9 5/15 5/22 5/29 6/5 6/12 6/20 7/1 7/14 7/22 8/1 Dates
Items Completed - Plan
3
231
Neutralized
231
Rebranded
Total # of technical publication assets
5
Total # completed
Items Completed - Actual
Facilities Facilities (Signage)
Facilities (ID badges)
Total locations
Total locations
IR branding assets
Need to be neutralized
Neutralized
Neutralized Rebranded
Rebranded 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0
7
Uniforms Bloomington
Freemont
No
No
Has IR branding
Has IR branding
No
Rebranded to TT
N/A
Neutralized
No
Rebranded to TT
3
4
5
6
7
Hastings
Hastings
No N/A
2
Products
Has IR branding
Neutralized
1
N/A
Neutralized
No
Rebranded to TT
Total locations IR branding assets Neutralized 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Sample packaging and labels rebrand dashboard Submission Que
Rebranded 1st Proofs Delivered to Date:
258
Proofs Moved to Approval Workflow:
170
Total for submission: 452 Already submitted: 224
Final Proofs Approved (BA)
62
75
91% of 186 submitted
Submitted by Item Type
Returned to cluster: 38
44% of 170 submitted
Total in Smartsheet: 5,938
Average Time per Item to Date
42 days
Average Revisions
By process step: Avg wait time for 1st proof: 19 days
Cluster B Cluster C Cluster D Cluster E Cluster F
Onboarded 2 new temporary resources to help with artwork request process Initiated weekly meeting between requesters and designers to facilitate workflow
Avg. X revs/item to bring to completion
Avg wait time for approval: 7 days
Cluster A
Headlines
2.5
Avg wait time for submission: 16 days
Submitted by Cluster
Boxes Labels Documents Packaging Other
Progress Status Overview
Progress Impediments
200 150 100
Additional resources needed to submit job requests for clusters (issue resolved)
50 0
Initiating approval process between designers and job requesters was initially cumbersome, have reworked the process *Dashboard does not include label templates being redesigned by IT team
Jan-18 Feb-18 Mar-18 Apr-18 May-18 Jun-18 Jul-18 Aug-18 Sep-18 Oct-18 Nov-18 Dec-18 Ready for Studio M
Submitted to InMotion
Proof created
Proof approved
Financial management workflow (example) START
Workgroup
Reviewer*
Identify need and associated cost
Does request align with brand strategy and budget?
END
Provide additional information and resubmit for approval
Submit funding request/quote to approved Reviewer
NO
Share PO with vendor
Send back to workgroup and align on strategy
Receive notification of PO release
NO YES
Share with workgroup
Raise PO for approved amount
Brand Management Group
Raise to Executive Leadership, if needed
Executive Leadership
Review and approve any escalated requests or large expenditures (typically for signage)
Review the request
Is request approved?
Process invoices towards PO
YES
Release the PO
Set up project cost center
Finance
Track POs and spend against overall budget in cost center Provide frequent reports
41
06
Design the perfect team.
Design the perfect team. It will come as no surprise that a team that includes a cross-section of corporate stakeholders can lead to a greater embrace of a rebrand among your employees. But how the project team is organized has a huge impact on how much time you will spend moving forward versus time spent herding cats. Here are three things to consider:
1
Define the right level of centralized control and decentralized execution that is unique to your objectives and operating model, and how you will support operational areas, regions, business units, etc.
2
Create explicit roles for different contributors, from the executive level to your core brand team, to implementation teams.
3
Map out the project organization in a way that reveals the interdependencies and how you will leverage internal resources, outsourced conversion with vendors, and your agency partners to play to their strengths.
Top level organization. Every team in your organization has skin in this game and skills to contribute. But just as you wouldn’t ask your special teams coach to call the plays for your quarterback on third-and-long, it’s up to the CMO to determine and direct the overall strategy. Here are the six teams needed to successfully implement a rebrand.
Executive Leadership Team
Business Advisors Team
Provides overarching business strategy in which to align brand strategy.
Guides alignment of brand to all divisions and audiences using the overarching business strategy set by the Executive Leadership Team.
Brand Core Team Partner in development of brand objectives and strategy.
Brand Management Team
Provides business unit viewpoints and expertise.
Executes macro strategies to create detailed strategies for rebrand.
supported by agency partners
Reviews funding requests and brand application as needed.
Central Workgroups Gathers information as required. Finalizes asset and location-specific strategies.
Coordinates dependencies and activities between all key agencies. Receives ongoing support from Finance, Procurement, Accounting, and Legal.
Creates detailed plans. Identifies risks, escalates issues and reports progress.
Local Implementation Teams
Tracks budget and manages suppliers and asset quality.
Assists the above groups in data gathering and implementation activities by providing information and resources at a site level. Executes brand workgroup plans. Tracks spend and reports it to workgroups.
45
Develop the project organization. Roles. Responsibilities. Lanes. How do internal functions and external partners support the project? A thoroughly considered project organization ensures control, simplicity, the smooth flow of information, and most importantly, no surprises at any level.
Executive Steering Committee
Agency Support (brand agency, BrandActive)
Updates
Rebrand Implementation Team (marketing and brand senior leaders)
Executive Leadership
Functional Support (legal, finance)
Implementation Leads (IL) / Project Management (PM)
Physical Assets
Customer Communications
signage
marketing & communications
finance
health & safety (PPE)
security
business forms & papers
IT & telecom
operations management
facilities related
community third party agency & organizations
legal gov’t & regulatory
work wear & rental uniforms
customer group
procurement
fleet & equipment
Administrative
human resources
Operations
Process definition ensures clarity and control. Processes need to be defined centrally, otherwise it’s challenging to ensure operations and the field are doing things the right way, at the right time. Processes need to be in place to control approvals, finances, quality, and project communications and reporting.
Helpdesk
Communications & reporting
Issue and risk escalation process
Budget approval process and financial governance
Project structure and clearly defined roles and responsibilities
Quality control and brand compliance
47
07
Leverage your rebrand to improve operations.
How to leverage your rebrand for operational improvement. One of the most overlooked opportunities in any rebrand is how to leverage it to improve ongoing operational efficiency – not just for the rebrand – but year over year well into the future. After all, this is the one moment in time when you are going to be looking over everything. There are tactical opportunities to rework how you collaborate with agencies and partners, rationalize vendors, reduce the number of assets you manage, and many other operations. And, there are strategic opportunities to finally realize a future state of simplified, standardized, and repeatable brand and marketing operations. Clear and effective brand governance is an essential bridge between brand strategy and brand deliverables, and a critical success factor. Many CMOs and senior marketers have a vision for how marketing should operate, and many others haven’t had time to evaluate and capture the opportunities and efficiencies they know must be there. Leveraging a rebrand to look at what your teams do, who they do it with, and how they do it can unlock clarity, save money, focus resources on activities that drive business value, improve time-to-market, and increase ROI. Rigorously examining your processes for approvals, agency management, vendor optimization and pricing, technology usage, and more, can unlock 10-35% efficiency in any of these brand and marketing operatoins.
Operations is an important link between strategy and delivery. Most organizations put significant emphasis on brand strategy and execution. Operations is often overlooked in achieving brand delivery, yet it drives efficiency and the CMO can leverage it to make a compelling case for investment.
Brand Strategy
Brand Governance
Brand Delivery
Strategy
Operations
Execution
Brand positioning
Roles and responsibilities
Customer experience
Processes and approvals
Social media
Brand attributes Brand architecture Visual/verbal identity guidelines Key messages Go-to-market strategy
Help desk and feedback channels
Advertising Marketing programs Sponsorships
Vendor strategies
Websites
Agency management
Events / fundraisers
Training and engagement
Media relations
Tools, resources, and technology
51
What to assess. Branded assets is just one of four areas we recommend you consider to have the larget long-term impact on ongoing operatoinal savings. You should also include people and processes, technology, and training.
Assets
People & process
Technology
Training
How standardized, repeatable and efficient are you? How could implementing a digital asset management system increase efficiency during the rebrand and beyond? What are the components of a training program that will move the needle internally?
People & Process
Technology
Staff roles and responsibilities
Existing technology vs. opportunities for new
Activities, hours, costs Documentation / playbooks Brand standards Agency map Agency management Transparency, tracking, dashboards Centralization vs. decentralization Decision making and communication
Brand management Workflow management Project management Campaign management Collaboration Agency/vendor management Costs and opportunities
Support structure
Training
Assets
Training materials
Quality and consistency
Training plans
Vendors
Team understanding
Outsource vs insource
Empowerment
Costs and opportunities
Employee onboarding
Rationalization
Agency and vendor onboarding/cadence
Simplification
Brand culture
Maintenance plans Marketing influence/role
53
ROI Opportunities. They’re out there, if you know where to look. Start with an opportunity analysis to understand all of the broad opportunities and then focus on the most compelling areas for improvement.
Opportunity Analysis
Branded Asset Optimization
Agency/Vendor Optimization
Identify the gaps and opportunities in your current brand operations and develop a roadmap to realize an optimized future state that protects the investment you make in your brand and marketing initiatives, and frees resources to focus on activities that drive business value.
Rationalize, simplify, and improve the quality of assets, and unlock repeatable, sustainable improvements in how you create, manage and use your branded assets, including everything from building signage to printed and digital materials and everything in between.
Map agency capabilities and scopes of work against marketing objectives to identify gaps and overlaps in service needs, costs and resource efficiencies; develop an evaluation process to measure performance; and document working principles and agency expectations in an agency management playbook.
Integrated Program Management
Process Redesign & Implementation
Enhance your team’s productivity by tapping into specialized skills and shortterm resources that deliver best-in-class internal and external brand and marketing programs.
Improve your brand operations moving forward by finding smarter ways of doing things that cost less time, money, and effort, and empower your internal teams to spend more time on activities that really impact your brand and marketing initiatives.
55
Tangible ROI vs. Investment is critical to the equation. It’s essential to question what opportunities truly produce ROI. It is also essential to evaluate that answer against how implementable that change is within the organization, as well as how it might align with your strategic direction or values. Some opportunities are just worth investing in for employee engagement, brand equity, improved customer experience, and standardization.
Asset Type
Investment
ROI
FTE Savings
Processes
$350,000
$950,000
800 (hrs)
Opportunity 01
$75,000
$500,000
200
Opportunity 02
$75,000
$300,000
300
Opportunity 03
$200,000
$150,000
300
Assets
$650,000
$550,000
650 (hrs)
Opportunity 01
$100,000
$50,000
150
Opportunity 02
$200,000
$50,000
245
Opportunity 03
$350,000
$250,000
255
Vendors & Agencies
$550,000
$650,000
900 (hrs)
Opportunity 01
$50,000
$100,000
300
Opportunity 02
$250,000
$200,000
400
Opportunity 03
$250,000
$350,000
200
Technology
$950,000
$350,000
400 (hrs)
Opportunity 01
$500,000
$75,000
100
Opportunity 02
$300,000
$75,000
200
Opportunity 03
$150,000
$200,000
100
Training
$1,000,000
$0
750 (hrs)
Opportunity 01
$350,000
$0
0
Opportunity 02
$250,000
$0
0
Opportunity 03
$400,000
$0
0
ROI 26%
14%
Processes Assets 22%
Vendors & Agencies Technology
38%
29%
Investment
10%
Processes Assets 18%
Vendors & Agencies Technology
27% 16%
Training
57
Cost vs. Benefit (market return + efficiencies – cost = ROI) Viewing your rebrand as an investment and adjusting plans accordingly can help you determine where to target your efforts and track achievement. And, based on the scenario you choose to move forward with, it is possible to create a payback model that shows the ROI you will achieve by doing things more efficiently post-rebrand.
$4B $3B $2B $1B
$335M 15-yr Operational Savings*
$400M
(Marketing & Brand Mgmt)
$350M
$285M Total Implementation Costs
$300M $250M $200M $150M
12-year payback operational savings
$100M $50M $M 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Year
*Operational Savings Include: Implementation costs: total cost of implementation across all branded assets Operational savings: XYZ Agency marketing ops efficiencies (assumed $4.1M/year efficiency ongoing past year 5) Improved branded asset management efficiencies (signage, fleet, uniforms, and collateral)
11
12
13
14
15
59
08
Seek specialized help.
Specialized help is available. Our goal with this booklet is to provide a rebrand roadmap that will empower you in conversations with your finance and operations-minded leadership through clear and actionable financial analysis, operational strategy, and the logistics of rebrand implementation and marketing operations. But you don’t have to do it alone. For over 24 years, BrandActive has focused exclusively on effective and efficient rebrand implementation. That is all we do and all we have ever done. We are the perfect complement to your branding agency and business consultants, because while we don’t come up with creative or design customer experience, what we do bring to the table – the financial analysis, strategy and logistics of brand implementation – is just as critical to the hundreds of companies we’ve worked with. Those companies have typically realized savings of 10–35% over the cost of doing everything internally, while also reducing their ongoing operational spend. We can manage the entire rebranding process, so you don’t have to divert your team members from the primary responsibilities. Maximum ROI and impact. That’s what we deliver. Opposite are just a cross-section of the organizations we’ve helped. Looking to rebrand or improve your brand and marketing operations? Contact us to put our experience to work.1.720.446.5632 contact@brandactive.com brandactive.com © 2022 BrandActive
Rebrand implementation experience.
63
brandactive.com
2022