Resilient Design: Coexist with urban flooding LAND7313 Landscape Capstone Studio 2 - Final Design Research Report Yumeng Jiao z5293646 August 2021
CONTENT
Introduction
3
Theoretical Frameworks and Assumptions
6
Site Context and Rationale
10
Precedents
20
Design Process
25
Design Concept and Narrative
28
Design Resolution
32
Research Conclusions
52
3
01 Introduction
4
1.1 What are we facing now?
Climate Change in Sydney Dust storm
The city was blanketed in dust carried east by winds up to 100kph. (Amber Hooper: User submitted) 2009.
Haze
Smoke caused by the bushfire haze over Sydney in 2019. Image: Getty
Floods
People paddle their boat through flood waters at Londonderry on the western outskirts of Sydney, March 22, 2021 (AP Photo/Mark Baker)
Flooding events in urban settings have become a common climate change- induced disaster this century (Ashley et al. 2007, p.10). On average, each major flood event can cause thousands of deaths and hundreds of millions of dollars in economic damage (Johnson et al.2016, p.22).
Floods in Wolli Creek and Bardwell Creek basins with great loss
1.2 What should we pay attention to?
Mission In view of the increasingly serious urban flood problems, designers and planners all over the world have proposed various solutions, and resilient design is one of the most popular concepts at present. Meerow, Newel and Stults (2016, p. 45) defined urban resilience as an adaptive ability to meet disturbances, adapt to changes, and transform the systems to adapt to the present and future environment. This conveys that adaptive capacity is the essence of resilient design in complex urban context, and the adaptive design for building adaptive ability becomes one of the important strategies of resilient design (Novotny, Ahern & Brown 2010, p.146).
Goal Coexist with urban flooding
Design Research Question
How to adapt urban environment to urban flooding by resilient design?
Research methods and techniques Methods: Case study and system thinking. Through the case studies, I can get a clear understanding of the common methods and landscape performance of resilience design in dealing with urban flooding. Using the systematic thinking method, I was able to comprehensively consider different influencing factors and pay attention to the dynamic development of the site. Techniques: GIS, digital drawings and models.
5
6
02 Theoretical Frameworks and Assumptions
2.1 Main theoretical concepts Urban Flooding According to Ashley et al. 's book, urban floods are increasingly frequent. They are usually caused by heavy rains or subsequent runoff and mainly occur in the built-up areas of cities (2007, p.30). In Hamin et al. 's book, a more detailed list of the causes of urban flooding is given: “Urban flooding is caused by a combination of forces, including the predominance of impervious surfaces in cities (i.e., buildings and pavement); changes in the hydrologic system from natural rivers, floodplains, and wetlands to hard-surfaced channelized rivers; and underground drainage pipes of the modern engineered stormwater system”.
Resilient Design In the book ‘Resilience Thinking: Sustaining Ecosystems and People in a Changing World’ (2006, pp.1-2), Walker and Salt position resilience as an ability to deliver current services in a way that is able to satisfy the possibilities of future development, as well as a concept related to sustainability. This statement, when interpreted from the perspective of landscape and planning, can be understood to mean that the environment has the ability to adapt and recover in response to disasters and challenges (Ahern, 2011, p.343).
Green Infrastructure Green infrastructure was defined by Benedict and McMahon (2006, p. 1) as “an interconnected network of natural areas and other open spaces that conserves natural ecosystem values and functions, sustains clean air and water, and provides a wide array of benefits to people and wildlife.” On the basis of this definition, Ahern (2007, p.268) interprets GI as “spatially and functionally integrated systems and networks of protected landscapes supported with protected, artificial and hybrid infrastructures of built landscapes that provide multiple, complementary ecosystem and landscape functions to a broad public, in support of sustainability”. It can be seen from the above two definitions that GI is systematic, with connectivity, sustainability, ecological protection functions, and providing the enhancement of air, water and other natural resources.
Adaptive Design Novotny et al. (2010, p.145) summarized five resilient design strategies, one of which was building adaptive capacity that was interpreted as an action that provides opportunities for innovative “learn-by-doing” and “safe-to-fail” design experiments (2010, p.146). This implication suggests that the adaptive design approach can provide a pattern in which design actions can be parallel or even ahead of knowledge, and have the ability to tolerate risk in the event of failure. To reduce this risk, how do we build adaptive capacity? Novotny et al. (2010, p. 158) made three points based on previous research: first, understanding the dynamic characteristics of the systems; second, constantly looking for the most effective interventions, which is the experimental aspect of design; and third, learning by design. According to all above, adaptive design can be proved a suitable match for the uncertain and dynamic urban flooding.
Relationship of Green Infrastructure and Adaptive Design The design concept of GI focuses on the multifunctional potential of the site, not only on flood prevention or resettlement (Lennon et al. 2014, p.750). This dovetails with the first adaptive strategy -- multifunctional land use (Palazzo 2019, pp.141). Green infrastructure is positioned as a key part to achieve this strategy. The green network that it provides is of great importance for sustainable stormwater management. Thus, green infrastructure can be a means to achieve adaptive design.
7
8
2.2 Conceptual diagram
impermeable surfaces
construction of urban structures
cause
Urban Floods to cope with
Previous way construction first, flood control later
Better new way
Adaptive design
Build a landscape that is tolerant of flooding
Green infrastructure
9
2.3 Theoretical Framework
Resilient Design for Urban Flooding Green infrastructure
Adaptive design
How to design GI for flood mitigation within the framework of adaptive design?
Theoretical position (Herrington) Systems theory and cybernetics Infrastructure(GI)
System thinking ways of adaptive design in flood mitigation GI people(activities) local condition(natural environment/connections/communities) flood flora and fuana materials flood damage benefits maintenance
10
Project Vision
03 Site Context and Rationale
11
3.1 Surburban Context - Bardwell and Wolli Creek Green Corridor
N Aboriginal Sites Bardwell Valley Parklands and Wolli Creek Turrella Reserve Waterworth Park
Turrella Station Wolli Creek Regional Park
Girrahween Park
Coo
ks R
Bardwell Park Station
eek
r
C olli
Coolibah Reserve
W
Shepherd Parade Reserve Off Leash Dog Exercise Areas ek
re
w
rd
Ba
C ell
ive
r
Arncliffe Station
Bardwell Valley Golf Course Silver Jubilee Park
Bardwell Creek Reserve
Bexley Pool
Bexley Golf Course
Bexley Park
Coolibah Reserve The Coolibah Reserve is located in the middle of the Bardwell and Wolli Creek Green Corridor and adjacent to the East Hills Railway. It is at the confluence of Wolli Creek and Bardwell Creek, as well as the connection between Girrahween Park and Bardwell Valley Golf Course. So it is of great value at the planning level.
12
3.2 Social and Cultural Context Current provisioning and cultural ecosystem services
Age-sex pyramid, 2016
Birthplace, 2016
Bayside Council Area
Bayside Council Area
5%
4%
3%
2%
1%
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
Coutry of birth(top 10 largest, 2016)
85 and over 80-84 75-79 70-74 65-69 60-64 55-59 50-54 45-49 40-44 35-39 30-34 25-29 20-24 15-19 10-14 5-9 0-4
AGE
85 and over 80-84 75-79 70-74 65-69 60-64 55-59 50-54 45-49 40-44 35-39 30-34 25-29 20-24 15-19 10-14 5-9 0-4
In 2016, 46.0% of people in Bayside Council area were born overseas, compared with 36.7% in Greater Sydney.
N
Cultural heritage values. China Nepal Greece
Food products for animals
Cultural communication
Bangladesh UK Philippines
provide biological materials sources of energy
Indonesia Lebanon
Education values
North Macedonia India 0
5%
% of persons
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
% of the population
As can be seen from the chart, the largest population group in this region is the young adults aged 25-34. There are fewer old people, more newborns and a balanced ratio of men and women.
As can be seen from the figure, the composition of overseas population in this region is complex, among which the population from China is the largest.
The Estimated Resident Population of Bayside Council area was 2019. The population density is 35.73 persons per hectare.
178,396
How do the site perceived and valued by the local community?
as of the 30th June
Elements of natural environment
#
1
#
50
Elements of natural environment
Sense of personal safety
#
2
#
49
Sense of personal safety
Welcoming to all people
#
3
#
48
Welcoming to all people
Sense of belonging in the community
#
4
#
47
Sense of belonging in the community
#
5
#
46
There are people like me
There are people like me
(age, gender, interests, ethnic backgrounds etc.)
Space and activities
(age, gender, interests, ethnic backgrounds etc.)
The natural environment is of greatest importance to the local community, so efforts should be made to improve natural elements such as vegetation and water quality.
Nature of space Space for domestic use
Historical sites
Sports space
Leisure space
N
Users
Characteristics
SITE OF DAM ACROSS WOLLI CREEK Family
Residents
Visitors
Open space Good sun exposure Play grounds for kids
Open or half open space Rest facilities available Beautiful scenery
WOLLI CREEK WEIR
(No visible remains, partly covered by East Hills Railway
Teenagers
embankment. )
SITE OF SMALL FARM (Small farm covered by landfill. )
Open space/ Wide area Flat terrain Sports facilities
SITE OF DAM ACROSS BARDWELL CREEK (Beneath East Hills Railway )
Activities picnic
Children play
Get close to animals
Photo taking
Walk the dog
Take a walk
Take a rest
Social activities
Outdoor drawing
Ball games
Jogging
Yoga
Possible The drawing shows some historical sites adjacent to the site. These are in danger of being damaged when the flood comes.
13
3.3 History Socio-economic history YUMENG jIAO
1850s - the construction of a limekiln next to the dam in Wolli Creek by the 1850s brought industry to this part of the river.
FUTURE
1804 - European settlement - land being used mainly for farming Original inhabitants - Aboriginal uses of the Wolli Creek catchment from the 1820s to the 1870s
1830s - Market gardening
The Wolli creek catchment was essentially still a natural river interspersed with cleared patches, houses and small wharves, linked by the river and a network of cart tracks and walking trails.
Late 1800s into the early 1900s Railway lines/ Sydney Airport site selection/ Botany Bay - Residential and industrial growth
1950s to 1960s medium-density housing 1990s to 2010s urban renewal - Population growth
Flooding history 2
Flooding to a level of 3-4 m in park on several occasions
3 1
4
Flooding reaches the rear of properties on Edith St
Flooding to a level of > 1 m caused ignificant damages of property on annan St.
Observed flooding at Coolabah Reserve
5 6
Flooding reached the fence of 50 Hannan St
Flooding on Bardwell Rd at Coolibah Reserve
7 e
eserv
hR oliba
Co
Flooding over Bardwell Rd by Bardwell Creek
Main Flooding Events
1983
1984
Source: 1. https://economy.id.com.au/baysidensw 2. Local Strategic Planning Statement- a land-use vision to 2036. Bayside Council, 2020. 3. Millennium Ecosystem Assessmen. 2005. Ecosystems and Human Well-being: Synthesis. I sland Press, Washington, DC.
1986
1988
1991
1992
1996
1998
2005
2014
2015
14
3.4 Geographical Context Terrain
N 1 2
3
2
3
1
EDITH
HANNA
M ST
4
ST
4
5.0m 3.2m
3.5m
2.5m
1.6m
5
5m
1
9m
4
11
4
4
East Hills Railway
1.5m 4
0m 20m
26m
riparian zone
grove and lawn
22m
14m
riparian zone
riparian zone
natural watercourse
4
C'
4
D'
JOHN S
3
T
1: 500
2
Section A - A'
31m
14m
natural watercourse
DA EY
RL 4
12
RD
A 13
A'
6 7
11
10
5
2
2
5
8
2
4
5.0m
6
5m
2
2
B
6.9m
3
9
3
10m
3
2
3
3
12m
4
7
B'
1.7m
Section B - B'
60m
20m
grove and lawn
riparian zone
24m
12m
natural watercourse
BARDW
ELL RD
riparian zone
D
1: 500
DARLE
5m
4.0m
4.1m
3.7m
2.6m
1.0m 0m
4m
riparian zone
20m
10m
107m
riparian zone
natural watercourse
Section C - C'
grove and lawn
1: 500
5m
4.0m 1.7m
2.0m
3.3m 1.8m
1.5m
0m
31m
grove and lawn
Section D - D'
1: 500
2
0m
ORTH ST
WENTW
20m
riparian zone
16m
22m
natural watercourse
riparian zone
28m
natural watercourse
Y RD
Perimeter: 1km Area: 3.79ha The time it takes adults to walk around the boundary: 14min (1.2m/s)
15
3.4 Geographical Context Topography
Facilities
Context lush vegetation
playground
E
1m
lush vegetation
Coolibah Reserve
E
E
45m
N
playground
riparian area
lawn and groves
N
The exit to the residential area
N
pavilion with tables and chairs
overgrown weeds
13m
S
W
high 45m 1m low
The terrain of the site is higher in the east and west part and lower in the middle. The terrain in the west varies greatly and is steeper than that in the east.
Water condition intersection
W
S A pavilion with seats
① lush vegetation ② The water quality of rivers needs to be improved ③ Weeds in the riparian
There is only one playground in the site, but there are few facilities which are not well constructed and lacks attraction.
Catchment E
S
W
Circulation
wetland
E
N
N
Site area
W
S
W
flow direction
The Bardwell River Way runs north-south through the site and joins Wolli Creek at the northern end of the site. Although Sydney has had more rainfall in the first half of years, the river flow on the site is still low (when there is no flood). The wetlands in the middle are almost dry. Water quality is poor and ground cover plants are sparse in the riparian zone.
S entrance
The land use within the catchment consists primarily of medium density urban residential development and commercial developments (including some light industrial areas), together with areas of open space such Bexley Golf Club, Bardwell Golf Club and several parks. The site is located downstream of Bardwell Creek and has the largest number of tributaries and the highest flood control pressure. When the upstream flood control pressure is too large, the site will also face a huge flood threat.
current common route (not constructed)
There are no well-built roads in the site, but there are dirt roads formed by people walking frequently. There are 3 entrances connecting Darley Road and Hannam Street respectively and one connecting the residential area.
16
3.5 Site Evolution (channels and vegetation)
1943
1951
1955
1961
1965
① Water flow in the site was small. ② The channel of Bardwell Creek on the site was not obvious. ③ The site was sparsely wooded. ④ Vegetation as sparse along Wolli Creek.
① Water flow in the site was small. ② The channel of Bardwell Creek on the site was not obvious. ③ Trees began to grow at the north end of the site. ④ Increased vegetation in the Wolli Creek riparian zone.
① Increased water flow in the site. ② The width and depth of the channel in the site increased, and the shape can be clearly seen. ③ The vegetation in the riparian zone of the site extended from north to south. ④ Reduced vegetation in the Wolli Creek riparian zone.
① Water flow in the site was small. ② The slope of the channel was gentle, and the shape was not as obvious as before. ③ The land cover of the riparian zone was increased and the trees were concentrated in the northern part of the site. ④ Increased vegetation in the Wolli Creek riparian zone.
1975
① Water flow in the site was small. ② The shape of the creek channel became obvious, and the riparian area showed signs of artificial construction. ③ The land cover of the riparian zone was increased and the trees were concentrated in the northern part of the site. ④ Increased vegetation in the Wolli Creek riparian zone.
① Water flow in the site was small. ② On the site, a new curved channel was extended on the basis of the original channel route. ③ The traces of artificial construction in the riparian zone disappear and become natural. ④ Expansion of residential areas in the southeast and northwest directions outside the site.
CHANGE 1 - River channels widened and increased in number.
To cope with the floods CHANGE 2 - Greening increased in the site.
1978
1986
1991
1998
① The water flow in the site increased significantly. ② The width of both the original channel and the new curved channel are widened, and a small island with lush vegetation was formed in the area enveloped by the two channels . ③ As the channel deepens, its shape becomes more pronounced. ④ Vegetation on the north bank of Wolli Creek was increased while trees on the south bank was decreased .
① The flow of the river was high and the island in the center were partially submerged. ② On the site, a new curved channel was extended on the basis of the original channel route. ③ The northern part of the site lost trees and the southern part was heavily wooded. ④ Vegetation on the north bank of Wolli Creek was increased. ⑤ The water quality is poor in the site.
① Trees grew on the site. ② Increased vegetation in the Wolli Creek riparian zone. ③ The water quality is poor in the site.
① Trees grew on the site. ② The vegetation along the banks of Wolli Creek has increased significantly, both sides of the creek were basically covered with green. ③ The water quality is poor in the site.
2005 ① Vegetation on the site is in good condition. ② Play facilities for children have been added to the site. ③ The water is cleaner than before, though it still needs to be improved.
Site changes have been closely linked to flood solutions.
To cope with the floods and urban heat island effect. CHANGE 3 - Water quality improvement
Aimed at habitat and ecological restoration
17
3.6 Flood Condition
Watercourse and Pit/Pipe Stormwater Network
Peak Flood Depths 1% AEP EVENT
N
N
Depth (m) 0 - 0.15 Watercourses/ Channels Culverts Pits
0.15 - 0.25
Pipes
>2
As shown in the figure above, the site owns a natural river course, and the pipes are located on the east and north sides of the site, which corresponds to the worst-hit area of 100-year flood in the site.
Overground flood control measures need to be combined with underground pipelines and pits
0.25 - 0.5 0.5 -1 1-2
As can be seen from the figure, the eastern part of the site and the river channels in the middle will face a serious crisis of inundation when facing 100-year flood. The depth of the flood reached more than two meters at its deepest. This is because the site is downstream of Bardwell Creek, which has more tributaries and therefore more water to flood.According to the terrain of the site, the lower the position, the deeper the water.
Intercept and storage water from upstream
18
3.6 Flood Condition
Peak Flood Velocities 1% AEP EVENT
Provisional Hydraulic Categories 1% AEP EVENT
N
N
Velocity (m/s) 0 - 0.25 0.25 - 0.5 0.5 -1 1 - 1.25 1.25 -1.5
Floodway Flood Storage
> 1.5
Flood Fringe
As shown in the figure, when 100-year flood occurs in the site, the fastest flow velocity is at the southern end of the site, because the width of the lowland here is narrow and the surrounding slope is large (see Section D-D'). Flood flows into the site through two pipes under the road. However, due to the limited capacity, flood overflow will spread to Bardwell Rd.
Low-lying terrain is conducive to flood discharge
Hydraulic Categorisation
The figure shows the designated floodways for 100-year flood, which basically flows into Wolli Creek along the natural watercourse.It also shows the flood storage area in the east of the site, which aims to attenuate an incoming flood peak to a flow level that can be accepted by the downstream channel and flood fringe area.
Extensions of floodway and flood storage area
19
3.7 Vegetation Natural areas
Endangered ecological communities and known and potential habitat for threatened flora
Known and potential habitat for threatened fauna and shorebirds N
N N
Site area
Site area
Site area
Bushland
Green Golden Bell Frog Habitat
Acacia pubescens and Dillwynia tenuifolia habitat
Known Grey Headed Flying Fox Roosting Habitat
Syzygium paniculatum habitat
Grey-headed Flying Fox, Select Microbats and Powerful Owl Habitat
Swamp oak floodplain forest
Watercourse and wetland LEP-2011 - Natural Resources - Wetland LEP-2011 - Natural Resources - Biodiversity Aboriginal Sites
Freshwater wetlands
The site has high habitat value, habitat protection needs to be considered when designing floods.
There is swamp oak floodplain forest in the site. Floods and soil will affect the species composition of the vegetation community.
The site of well-maintained native vegetation. Located at the intersection of two biodiversity corridors, Bardwell Creek and Wolli Creek.
Main Flora Hierarchy Trees
Riparian zone revegetation recommendation
Fern Acacia binervia
Angophora floribunda
Banksia serrata
Callicoma serratifolia
Corymbia gummifera
Eucalyptus punctata
Melaleuca styphelioides
Adiantum aethiopicum
Syncarpia glomulifera
Shrubs
Asplenium australasicum
Calochlaena dubia
Histiopteris incisa
Hypolepis muelleri
Main Fauna species Acacia linifolia
Acacia suaveolens
Baeckea linifolia
Correa reflexa
Grevillea buxifolia
Hakea dactyloides
Jacksonia scoparia
Melaleuca erubescens
Birds
Mammals
Frogs
Grass Calyptorhynchus funereus.
Juncus planifolius
Lomandra longifolia
Microlaena stipoides
Poa affinis
Themeda australis
Lomandra filiformis ssp. coriacea
Lomatia silaifolia
Oplismenus imbecillis
Ptilinopus superbus
Ninox strenua
Malurus lamberti
Herpetofauna
Pteropus poliocephalus
Limnodynastes peronii
Fish
Climer Billardiera scandens
Clematis glycinoides
Eustrephus latifolius
Glycine clandestina
Hardenbergia violacea
Hibbertia scandens
Kennedia rubicunda
Pandorea pandorana
Eulamprus tenuis
Eulamprus quoyii
Amphibolurus muricatus
Physignathus lesueurii
Hypseleotris compressa
Bird attractor Bursaria spinosa (2m prickly shrub) Callistemon sieberi (4m weeping shrub) Callestemon viminalis (8m weeping shrub) Leptospermum polygalifolium (Bushy 3m shrub) Muehlenbeckia florulenta (Tangled 2m shrub) Eucalyptus melliodora (Tree to 20m)
Galaxias maculatus
Soil stabiliser Bolboschoenus fluviatilis (1m tall sedge) Microlaena stipoides (30cm grass) Melaleuca bracteata (Large shrub to 6m) Acacia stenophylla (Small tree to 5m) Flood resistant Cyperus exaltatus (1.5m sedge) Lomandra longifolia / hystix (1m tufted rush)
20
Project Vision
04 Precedents
21
4.1 Buffalo Bayou Park Main Flood Resilient Design Strategies
Project Type: Park/ Open space/ Waterfront redevelopment (riverfront) Designer: SWA Group Former Land Use: Drainage corridor Location: Houston, Texas, USA Size: 68.4 ha; 3.7 km long Climate Zone: Humid subtropical Budget: $58 million Completion Date: 2015
(Watson & Adams, 2010, p.78) (Ahern, 2011, pp.342-343)
Store rainwater in suitable water storage area to release pressure from run-off during moderate rainfall
Downtown Houston
3.7km Reduce Impervious Land Cover
68.4ha Buffalo Bayou Park is an urban green space located upriver from downtown Houston, Texas, along the Buffalo Bayou Estuary, a major drainage system for much of the city. Its ten acres of trails wind past seven major public art installations, three gardens of native flora, and over four pedestrian bridges; two festival lawns, a dog park, a skate park, a nature play area, a restaurant, and an art exhibit hall draw visitors from afar. By restoring the original engineered lawn drainage corridor to the original natural drainage corridor for river restoration and reforestation, Buffalo Bayou Park has successfully responded to three extreme weather challenges, including floods and hurricanes (ULI 2018).
Protect and restore the floodplain, wetland and riparian buffer zone
(Masterplan of Buffalo Bayou Park, SWA Group)
22
4.1 Buffalo Bayou Park Flood Resilient Design Methods Cisterns to capture and reuse water
Performance in Flooding Control
(Watson & Adams, 2010, pp. 103-125 - p.261)
Stormwater retention
Riparian buffers
Ecological wastewater treatment systems
Native planting Riparian buffers
Riparian zone
(LAF 2019) (LAF 2019)
1. Withstood significant flooding and avoided an estimated $2 million in damages from Hurricane Harvey with custom-designed site fixtures and furnishings. 2. Avoided an estimated $735,900 in flood repair costs from Hurricane Harvey through installation of coir lifts.
The Buffalo Bayou Partnership restored and repurposed the Cistern into a public space to house art installations, tours, and meditation sessions (ULI 2018).
Stormwater retention
The slopes of the bayou banks were laid back to create both additional capacity for flood water movement and recreational space (ULI 2018).
Elevation and floodresistant design/ stormwater retention
New bridges and pathways were added to the park to provide access to Texas’s longest paddling trail. The added green infrastructure along the trails offers flood protection and other recreational benefits (ULI 2018). Porous paving with infiltration bed Bioretention area
Johnny Steele Dog Park, which has been around for more than a decade, has been expanded, and Its water features are filtered through a recirculating system intended to incorporate a nearby constructed wetland (ULI 2018). Urban forestry and reduction of lawnscape
Reintroducing native landscapes and restoring diversity and balance to the terrain - over 14,000 native trees were planted in the park over the course of construction (ULI 2018).
We t l a n d p r o t e c t i o n a n d restoration
The water course was redesigned in order to reverse much of the streamlining that had been made in the 1950s, following intensive study of the bayou’s “fluvial geomorphopology.” Meanders were restored with “flood benches,” like speed humps where fast-moving floodwater can spread out and drop silt and debris. After high water events, cleanup crews can focus their attention on these few locations (ULI 2018).
Flood-resistant design
3. Increases habitat quality within 25% of the park by providing fruit and seed sources for wildlife in 53% of newlyplanted native groundcover and shrub species, nectar sources in 63%, and habitat sources in 27%, with 23% of these species designated as having Special Value for native pollinators. 4. Sequesters 9.19 tons of atmospheric carbon and intercepts approximately 84,000 gallons of stormwater runoff annually in approximately 9,800 newlyplanted trees.
Findings
The facilities include sunken spaces that can store water.
Site fixtures and furnishings within Buffalo Bayou Park were custom-designed to withstand submersion during flood events and the impact of floating debris (LAF 2019).
Main Materials and Fixtures 1.Custom concrete light pole 2.Custom Stainless steel oversized handrails and guardrails 3.Pavilions of board-formed concrete 4.Concrete-filled galvanized steel bridge abutments
The nature playground uses paving materials such as sand and stones, combined with the low-lying terrain to promote infiltration and retention of rainwater (LAF 2019).
Lawn areas can be nearly as impervious as pavement (Watson & Adams, 2010, p. 110). Reestablishment of forest with understory can help restore natural hydrologic functions.
Lost Lake garden. Not only does it provide good views, i t a l s o h e l p s m i t i g a te t h e heat island effect, improves water quality during h e a v y ra i n s a n d p rov i d e s habitats for some species.
The concrete columns of the pedestrian and bike bridges c ro s s i n g t h e b a y o u h a v e a hydrodynamic profile to minimize turbulence of water moving through the channel d u r i n g f l o o d e ve n t s ( L A F 2019).
1. Green infrastructure is the main response to floods. 2. In the face of irresistible hurricanes and rainstorms, adaptive design should be adopted to accommodate flood and reduce losses. 3. The repair of the site after the flood should be taken into account in advance, that is, the facilities, pavement, plants, etc. should own the ability to recover quickly. Therefore, the application of materials and selection of species need to be carefully considered. 4. The use of native plants is of great value in cementing soil, restoring riparian zones, and preventing floods.
23
4.2 Hunter's Point South Waterfront Park, Phase 1
Main Flood Resilient Design Strategies (Watson & Adams, 2010, p.78) (Ahern, 2011, pp.342-343)
Intercept small rainfalls in the upstream
0.2 8
km
Project Type: Park/ Open space/ Waterfront redevelopment (coastal) Designer: SWA/Balsley, Weiss/Manfredi Former Land Use: Industrial Location: Long Island City, New York, USA Size: 3.84 ha Climate Zone: Humid subtropical Budget: $66 million Completion Date: 2013
3.84ha
N
Store rainwater in suitable water storage area to release pressure from run-off during moderate rainfall
Hunter's Point South Waterfront Park is part of a mixed-use community development in a former abandoned industrial district in Long Island City, Queens, New York.The site is a former railroad warehouse, coal yard and swampy wetland with no public access to its iconic views of Manhattan's skyline along the East River.In response to the impacts of climate change, the project incorporates bulkheads and stone cutters to better withstand future flooding of the East River. It is not only public amenity, but also the first line of defense against storms in the area. (Landscape Architecture Foundation, 2019).
Reduce Impervious Land Cover
PHASE 1
PHASE 2 (Masterplan of Hunter's Point South Waterfront Park, Phase 1, Landscape Architecture Foundation, 2019)
24
4.2 Hunter's Point South Waterfront Park, Phase 1 Flood Resilient Design Methods Flood-resistant design
Consideration of climate change,its shoreline is significantly augmented, e m p l oy i n g b u l k h e a d s a n d riprap to better withstand future flooding in the East River (LAF 2018).
Performance in Flooding Control
(Watson & Adams, 2010, pp. 103-125 - p.261)
Rain gardens and small bioretention area
The park nods to the site’s history, transforming former railroad tracks into garden beds to in order to hold up the rain and relieve the pressure when the flood comes.The area of infiltration basins are up to 22% (LAF 2018).
Stormwater interceptors
Rock-filled gabions are set in a planted swale along Central Boulevard to interrupt and slow large volumes of rain and storm surge from the neighborhood as well as filter sediment before it drains (LAF 2018).
Native planting
Innovative materials include native and flood-tolerant plants (LAF 2018).
Porous paving
The use of synthetic turf on the playing field which is likely to be flooded and natural grass could be badly damaged by salt water on the surrounding five-foothigh berm is sensible (Dunlap 2013).
Porous paving with infiltration bed Bioretention area
The permeable pavement area of the site is up to 73% (LAF 2018).
Stormwater retention before
after
(LAF 2019)
1. According to the results calculated by the final National StormWater Calculator (the US EPA's StormWater Management Tool), the annual precipitation infiltration rate of the site was 58.61%, and the evaporation capacity was 14.16%. Intercepts, infiltrates, and evaporates 73% of average annual rainfall in permeable pavers and a biofiltration swale. 2. Increases flood storage capacity by approximately 557,800 gallons, accommodating up to a 6-ft stormsurge flood event.
Findings 1. Unlike the riverfront, the coastal site need to be designed with more space to hold rainstorms when it is at risk of both flooding and sea level rise. 2. The design of green infrastructure is integrated with the historical memory of the site.
Current high tide
100-year flood
The 29,825-sf central oval lawn was designed to provide temporary water storage in the case of storm-surge or large tidally influenced flood events.It is surrounded by a sloping retaining wall, reaching 30 inches in height on its highest side. It can detain up to 74,562.50 cf (557,766 gallons) of stormwater during a flood event and because it is graded to slope down to the East River, it allows the collected water to recede back into the river (LAF 2018).
Main Materials and Fixtures 1.Gabion box formed by crushed rocks in wire cages 2.Terrace framed by precast concrete walls 3.Synthetic turf fabricated using synthetic fibers 4.Beach sand for playgrounds 5.Site furniture made of environmentally sustainable southern yellow pine
3. The application of materials is localized and adapted to the function of the site. 4. The use of native plants is of great value in cementing soil, restoring riparian zones, and preventing floods.
25
Project Vision
05 Design Process
26
5.1 SWOT analysis narrow tunnel for flood discharge
N SWOT Analysis
lush vegetation
surrounded by residential areas obsolete playground
poor water quality
birds and fauna protection
ecological science education high terrian
overgrown with weeds
erosion of riparian zones
lack access to cross the creek
wetlands
less connected to the external context space for recreation
Strengths 1. Lush vegetation 2. As the land rises to the east and west, flooding in this area is not a serious problem. 3. Wetlands resources Weaknesses 1. The site is located downstream of Bardwell Creek, there are frequent severe floods and property damage in surrounding residential areas. 2. Water quality is poor. 3. The thicket of weeds along the creek is squeezing out space for native plants. 4. Erosion of riparian zones has led to narrow and deeper channels in the north. 5. People lack access to cross Bardwell Creek and lack access during the flood. 6. Lack of reasonable route circulation in the site. 7. The site is less connected to the external context. 8. Lack of essential infrastructure such as lights, seats, trash bins and so on. 9. The playground facilities for children are obsolete. Opportunities 1. The site is surrounded by residential areas, community activities can be held. 2. Space for recreation. 3. Ecological science education. 4. Birds and wetland fauna protection. Threats 1. Climate change. Storms are frequent. 2. The tunnel under the railway to the north of the site is too narrow to allow for flood discharge. 3. Many tributaries upstream from Bardwell Creek bring large amounts of water to the site during heavy rains.
27
5.2 Process Severely flooded areas
Due to the relatively flat terrain, the western residential area can be flooded during heavy rains, and drainage is still poor despite more than ten pipe pits. When the flood overflows, due to the high west and low east terrain, the water flows into the site from this direction, increasing the pressure on the north side of the site. Therefore, it is still necessary to maintain plant roots and soil.
Water from upstream tributaries pours into the site through two culverts under the bridge, and as a low point in the terrain, it also draws water from the east and west. So there's a lot of water flowing and moving fast. At this point upstream flooding should be cut off to ease the flow and reduce the erosion of the downstream banks.
This is the only way that flood water from the site flows into Wolli Creek, so the water flows very fast here. Erosion of the concave side of the river bank is serious and plant root penetration need to be considered.
According to the high east and low west terrain of this side of the site, the flood of residential areas all pours into the site. This site is located at the junction of the site's two watercourses, with only one spillway to its north. So weir should be set up here to regulate the flow of water while the flood is still under control.
Inner traffic improvement planning
1
I t is clear that the existing entrances face north, east and south respectively, and the western border lacks access. 4
2
3 5 7
6
1
A route close to the river, along which the attractions can be set.
2
Set up a route on high ground to facilitate passage in case of standing water.
3
A ro u te a c ro s s t h e c re e k , i t i s convenient for east-west pedestrians.
4
Although there are no attractions to visit, due to its high elevation, it will become a passway in case of floods.
5
When the flood water level is high and ground access routes are inundated, an elevated facility is needed to ensure east-west access, as well as to accommodate views.
6
Along the stream line, a hydrophilic way.
7
A walking route of the rest area.
8
The outside tour route of the rest area is convenient for browsing the street scene.
8
Direction of flow Core inundation area
Main routes
Severely flooded area
Existing entrances
Proper flow control point
Planning new entrances
Site
Site
Ecological improvement planning
Activity area improvement planning
According to the current situation, the main activity areas are located to the northeast and southeast of the site due to their proximity to the existing entrance.Therefore, the promotion of the activity area will expand to the middle on this basis, connecting the eastern area into a whole, mainly for children and young people's lively activities. To the west, the terrain is steeper and not suitable for sports and other activities, but with dense tree canopy and spare space, it is a saperate and quiet area and is suitable for residents to walk and rest.
The riparian ecosystem needs to be rebuilt because of soil erosion caused by flooding, weeds need to be removed, and native plants are needed to repair and stabilise the soil. Native plants also contribute to the construction of the wetland ecosystem and the ecological restoration of the site.
Root penetration needs to be strengthened in order to stabilize the banks and the soil.
Rapid flow region
'Active' area
Proper flow control point
'Quiet' area
Site
Site
28
Project Vision
06 Design Concept and Narrative
29
6.1 Design Concepts
Coexist
Before floods
Restore and treat
When floods come
After floods
intercept and retain
Adapt and use
Remove to safer areas
Node
30
6.2 Principles and Strategies
Principle 1
Principle 2
Principle 3
Adapt the land to floods
People live with water
Water nourishes ecology
Chain of stormwater filtration wetlands
New playgrounds at secure location
Restricted areas for animal protection
Key area of increasing root penetration
Elevated wooden way
Ecological protection education sites
Restore Bardwell creek and treat water
Strengthen the circulation on the site and to adjacent communities
Area of native planting increasing for fauna habitats
New amenities and facilities
Strategies - Increasing root penetration of large canopy of trees within - Restore and repair Bardwell Creek as well as clean and treat water onsite - Change landform to increase low-lying areas to improve the flood capacity of the space (wetlands, ponds, broadening the channel, etc.)
Social benefit: Residents adjacent to the reserve have filtered rainwater as their primary water source. Environmental benefit: Catch over 40% of stormwater combined sewer system annually. Economic benefit: avoiding a projected A$30,000 in future capital costs to upgrade stormwater infrastructure.
Views
Strategies
Strategies
- Adjust the location of the facilities according to the terrain and the flood discharge line (security)
- Increase native planting at the edges of the naturally occurring water system to improve habitats for fauna.
- Broaden the view of the landscape and improve the infrastructure of the site, including seating, lighting, amenities, etc.
- Create protected areas for wetland animals with restricted access
- Improve the connection to adjacent communities and water accessibility, and guaranteed accessibility in case of floods.
Social benefit: 1. Increased the total visible area of the natural environment by 30%. 2. The number of residents visiting the sites regularly increased by 30%. Environmental benefit: over 300 m2 of land was reclaimed as activity area. Economic benefit: Catalyzed a 5% increase in aggregate land value within 500m of the reserve.
- Educate people about the impact of floods on habitats such as wetlands and ponds under rainstorm retention systems and raise their awareness of conservation.
Social benefit: With 80% of nearby students improved the knowledge about the site's waterfront habitats. Environmental benefit: Increased critical bird-breeding habitat for at least 4 species. Economic benefit: Saves A$20,000 in annual maintenance costs by introducing native plant species at the creek bank instead of weeds.
31
6.3 Relevant Policies
Policies for Principle 1
International level
SDG 13 - Climate Action SDG 15 - Life on Land THE NEW URBAN AGENDA - Planning and managing urban spatial development
Metropolitan National level
Objective 5: Improve conservation management of Australia’s landscapes, waterways, wetlands and seascapes (Australia’s Strategy for Nature 2019–2030) Objective 8: Use and develop natural resources in an ecologically sustainable way (Australia’s Strategy for Nature 2019–2030) Priority for action 2 - Building ecosystem resilience in a changing climate (Australia’s Biodiversity Conservation Strategy 2010–2030)
Local Government level
Planning Proposal- Bayside Local Environmental Plan (BLEP) Bayside council plan of management for community land and public open space 2016
Policies for Principle 2
International level
SDG 3 - Good Health and Wellbeing SDG 11 - Sustainable Cities and Communities SDG 15 - Life on Land
Metropolitan National level
Liveability (South District Plan – connecting communities) Infrastructure and collaboration (South District Plan – connecting communities) Goal 1: Connect all Australians (Australia’s Strategy for Nature 2019–2030)
Local Government level
Planning Proposal- Bayside Local Environmental Plan (BLEP) Bayside council plan of management for community land and public open space 2016 Local Strategic Planning Statement a land-use vision to 2036
Policies for Principle 3
International level
SDG 3 - Good Health and Wellbeing SDG 6 - Clean Water and Sanitation SDG 13 - Climate Action
Metropolitan National level
2.2 Maintaining and re-establishing ecosystem functions (Australia’s Biodiversity Conservation Strategy 2010–2030) 2.3 Reducing threats to biodiversity (Australia’s Biodiversity Conservation Strategy 2010–2030) 3.1 Improving and sharing knowledge(Australia’s Biodiversity Conservation Strategy 2010–2030) PRINCIPLE 4. Participation (Greener Places)
Local Government level
Planning Proposal- Bayside Local Environmental Plan (BLEP) Bayside council plan of management for community land and public open space 2016
32
Project Vision
07 Design Resolution
33
7.1 Masterplan
N
The project aims to create a resilient place that can coexist with floods, focusing on the ecology and human activities during and after floods, and creating a multi-functional park that adapts to the life of surrounding communities based on restoration, drainage and utilization. 1
5 3
2
7 6 2
5 9
4
3 3
1
Children's playgrounds
2
Open lawn
3
Wetlands
4
Picnic area
5
Ecological protected area
6 Elevated wooden bridge
1:1000 0
10
20
50
100m
7
Weir
8
Rest and walking area
34
7.2 Panorama Diagram W S
N E
This picture shows a panoramic view of the site.As a shared green space for surrounding residential areas, it has been reasonably improved in terms of infrastructure and traffic circulation, while its ecological value has also been enhanced. The elevated wooden bridge in the center of the site forms the core symbol of the site, which not only connects the east and west sides of the site, but also serves as the best view point of the site.It offers a 360-degree view of the site, offering visitors an opportunity to enjoy the dense forest and watch birds without entering the middle island.
35
7.3 Design Analysis Functional partition analysis
Riparian restoration area Rest and walking area Open lawn(temporary events holding area) Children's playground Picnic area Central viewing area
The site is divided into six parts from west to east, which are rest and walking area, riparian restoration area, central viewing area, children's playground, open lawn(temporary events holding area) and picnic area. The riparian restoration area mainly focuses on native planting and wetland animal protection, and also has the function of promoting wetland protection education. Children's playground, the picnic area and the open lawn make up the eastern part of the site. The Open lawn is used primarily for temporary community activities or sports. The western part of the site is quiet with less human activities, while the eastern part is busy with human activities.
Route analysis
E1 E5
Recreation area route Route of passage during floods
E4
E2
Main circulation Wetland visit route
E3
In the event of flood, the bridge is responsible for pedestrian passage. Both sides of the bridge are connected with the normal road of the park. Pedestrians can safely leave the park from exits E1, E2, E4 and E5 along the roads at the edge of the site. When there is no flood in the field, the park roads lead to five exits in four directions, and the passage is easy and unobstructed. The children's area has its own tour route. In addition to the above, there is a tour route along the wetland to facilitate popular science education.
36
7.3 Design Analysis Elevation
±2.0m
±10.0m
±4.0m
±3.0m
±2.0m
±4.0m
±5.0m ±4.0m
±5.0m
±5.0m
±10.0m
±4.0m
±3.0m
±2.0m
±3.5m
±6.0m
±4.0m
±7.0m
The topography of the site has not changed much.The height of the children's playground is about 4 meters above sea level and the terrain is flat. The three entrances of the elevated wooden bridge are naturally connected to the terrain at an elevation of 3.5m, 4m and 5m respectively. According to Peak Flood Depths diagram, the depth of the 100-year flood along the river is more than 2 meters, and the depth of the flood along the river bank is between 0.5 and 2 meters. The entrances meet the need of flood prevention.
Flow Direction
flood flow
As the water flows into the field, it enters the wetlands, which results in less flow northward into Wolli Creek and less pressure for the water to flow through the tunnel under the railway. Children's playgrounds use permeable materials such as sand and gravel to help water filtration and infiltration.
37
7.4.1 Zones - Central Viewing Zone The central view area is composed of the elevated wooden bridge and the central island, with good traffic and scenery. The three entrances of the bridge are connected to the site naturally, ensuring access in the event of floods, and the gentle ramps provide convenience for the disabled.
stepping stone weir
permeable paving E-1
E-2
native planting
±5.0m
±3.5m
Bardwell Creek elevated wooden bridge E-3 ±4.0m
Wetlands
Elevated wooden bridge E-1 ±5.0m Bridge column Bridge pier
±5.0m
E-3
±3.5m ±4.0m
E-2
38
7.4.1 Zones - Central Viewing Zone
elevated wooden bridge bench
native planting
±5.0m
±3.5m
39
7.4.2 Zones - Children's Playground The children's playground has been upgraded. It is located on the flat ground with an altitude of 4m. The area is recorded to be submerged at 0-0.15m when the flood comes, so it still has a certain degree of safety when the rainstorm comes. At the same time, the site uses sand, gravel and other permeable paving materials to ensure children's safety and promote water infiltration and filtration.
native planting
±4.0m
permeable paving
±2.0m
playground
wetlands
Playground
Users
40
7.4.2 Zones - Children's Playground
coloured pervious plastic paving
sand pit
gravel
41
7.4.3 Zones - Open lawn and Picnic Zone The open lawn connects the picnic area with the children's playground, a relatively flat area where people can exercise or do sports most of the time, and can be used for temporary community activities when needed. Picnic area is designed for young people and families. Located in the southeast corner, it is relatively quiet and allows people to picnic in a semi-shaded area.
elevated wooden bridge open lawn
native planting
wetlands
permeable paving picnic area
Facilities
Users
picnic set
trash bin
bench
lighting
42
7.4.4 Zones - Rest and Walking Zone The area is sloping but has good shade and space for nearby residents to walk and rest.It's quieter than the active area to the east.
trash bin
lighting
bench
permeable paving
wetlands
elevated wooden bridge
native planting
Facilities
trash bin
Users
bench
lighting
43
7.5 Riparian Restoration and Water Cleaning
Under flood conditions When severe floods occur, both riparian and wetland areas are submerged. Native plants stabilize the soil and reduce erosion on the creek banks, while the under layers of different materials beneath the wetlands help the water to seeping down and out of the site through underground pipes. Plant roots also absorb water.
Unflooded zone
Root ab s
orption
Mulch
Engin
eered
Coars
Flooded zone cover
soil
Infiltration
e grav el
Infiltration Pipes
Root ab s
orption
44
7.5 Riparian Restoration and Water Cleaning After floods
Native Planting Trees
Shrubs
Trees Corymbia gummifera
Eucalyptus punctata
Syncarpia glomulifera
Bursaria spinosa
Melaleuca styphelioides [Soil stabiliser]
Eucalyptus melliodora [Bird attractor]
Shrubs
Acacia stenophylla [Soil stabiliser]
Melaleuca quinquenervia [Flood resistant]
Lomandra hystrix
Casuarina glauca
Shrubs
Isolepis nodosa
Lomandra longifolia
Wetlands
[Bird attractor] Callistemon sieberi
Callistemon viminalis
Leptospermum polygalifolium
Melaleuca bracteata [Soil stabiliser]
Muehlenbeckia florulenta
Grass
Melaleuca linariifolia [Bird attractor]
Melaleuca salicina [Bird attractor]
Doryanthes excels
Melaleuca ericifolia [Bird attractor]
Melaleuca thymifolia
Acmena smithii
Leptospermum lanigerum [Soil stabiliser]
Grass and sedges
Juncus kraussii [Soil stabiliser]
Bolboschoenus fluviatilis [Soil stabiliser]
Microlaena stipoides [Soil stabiliser]
Cyperus exaltatus [Flood resistant]
Lomandra longifolia [Flood resistant]
Crinum pedunculatum
Grass Oplismenus imbecillis
Microlaena stipoides
Lomatia silaifolia
Microlaena stipoides [Soil stabiliser]
Correa alba
Crinum pedunculatum
Westringia fruiticosa
tree canopy interception
a chain of stormwater filtration wetlands
Bardwell Creek
retain debris and slow the flow
plant irrigation
evaporation
Mulch
Engin
eered
Coars
evaporation
cover
soil
filtration 20cm
Infiltration
permeable
paving
Infiltration
e grav el
filtration Infiltration
Maintain a healthy grass layer to filter water
Pipes
The sto rmwate by we r colle tla c subsu nds is fed in ted rface to flow th the p ip e s , w h ic ro h th e n ugh the ex ternal pipes. m e e t
gravel filter
Root a b
sorpt
Non-flooded area
Wetlands (Flood basin)
ion
Waterway (Flood basin)
Eleocharis sphacelata
45
7.6 Fauna and Flora Main Fauna species Birds
Calyptorhynchus funereus.
Mammals
Ptilinopus superbus
Ninox strenua
Malurus lamberti
Frogs
Herpetofauna
Pteropus poliocephalus Limnodynastes peronii
Eulamprus tenuis
Fish
Eulamprus quoyii
Amphibolurus muricatus
Physignathus lesueurii
Hypseleotris compressa
Galaxias maculatus
Native Species
Eucalyptus melliodora Form: Tall Tree (>10m) Height: 25-30m Spread: 20-30m Position: Part Shade/ Full Sun Flower: White, Cream, Yellow Tolerates: Drought, Moderate frost Origin: VIC, NSW, QLD Purpose: Ornamental, Habitat, Timber Type: Evergreen
Microlaena stipoides Form: Grass Sedge or Flax Height: 0.1-0.7m Spread: 0.2-1m Position: Part Shade/ Full Sun Foliage: Green Tolerates: Drought, Lime, Moderate frost, Soil salinity Origin: SA, Vic, NSW, WA, Qld, Tas Purpose: Ornamental, Habitat, Erosion Type: Evergreen
Melaleuca styphelioides Form: Tall Tree (>10m) Height: 4-10m Spread: 2-3m Position: Full Sun Flower: White, Cream Tolerates: Drought, Lime, Moderate frost, Light frost, Heavy frost Origin: NSW, QLD Purpose: Ornamental, Habitat, Screen Type: Evergreen
Cyperus exaltatus Form: Grass Sedge or Flax Height: 0.3-1m Spread: 0.8-1m Position: Full Sun Flower: Brown Tolerates: Heavy frost Origin: SA, WA, Vic, NSW, Qld, NT, ACT Purpose: Habitat, Ornamental, Erosion
Acacia stenophylla Form: Tall Tree (>10m) Height: 5-15m Spread: 3-6m Position: Full Sun Flower: Yellow Tolerates: Drought, Soil salinity, Moderate frost, Heavy frost Origin: SA, Vic, NSW, WA, Qld, ACT, NT Purpose: Ornamental, Wind protection, Timber, Habitat Type: Evergreen
Melaleuca ericifolia Form: Large Shrub (>3.6m) Height: 3-4m Spread: 2-3m Position: Full Sun Flower: White Tolerates: Drought, Light frost Origin: NSW, Vic, Tas Purpose: Ornamental, Screen, Habitat Type: Evergreen
Juncus kraussii Form: Grass Sedge or Flax Height: 0.6-1m Spread: 0.5-1.5m Position: Full Sun Flower: Brown Tolerates: Drought, Moderate frost Origin: SA, Vic, NSW, WA, Tas, Qld Purpose: Habitat, Ornamental Type: Evergreen
Casuarina glauca Form: Tall Tree (>10m) Height: 8-20m Spread: 8-15m Position: Full Sun Flower: Reddish-brown Tolerates: D rought, Flooding, Water logging Origin: NSW, QLD Purpose: Ornamental, Screen, Timber, Erosion Type: Evergreen
Bursaria spinosa Form: Small Tree (>7m) Height: 2-4m Spread: 1-3m Position: Full Sun Flower: White Tolerates: Drought, Fire Origin: SA, Vic, NSW, Qld, Tas Purpose: Ornamental, Screen, Hedge Type: Evergreen
Lomandra longifolia Form: Grass Sedge or Flax Height: 0.5-1m Spread: 0.8-1m Position: Part Shade/ Full Sun Flower: Cream Tolerates: Drought, Moderate frost Origin: NSW, Qld Purpose: B u s h fo o d, O r n a m e n ta l, Habitat, Erosion Type: Evergreen
Callistemon sieberi Form: Medium Shrub (1.2-3.6m) Height: 1-2m Spread: 1-1.5m Position: Full Sun Flower: Cream, Yellow Tolerates: Moderate frost Origin: SA, NSW Purpose: Habitat, Ornamental Type: Evergreen
Eleocharis sphacelata Form: Grass Sedge or Flax Height: 0.5-2m Spread: 2-3m Position: Full Sun Flower: White Tolerates: Moderate frost Origin: SA, Vic, NSW, Qld,Tas, NT, New Zealand, New Guinea Purpose: Habitat, Ornamental
Callistemon viminalis Form: Tall Tree, shrub Height: 10-12m Spread: 5m Position: Part Shade/ Full Sun Flower: Red Tolerates: Drought, Lime, Moderate frost Origin: NSW, QLD Purpose: Ornamental, Screen Type: Evergreen
Isolepis nodosa Form: Grass Sedge or Flax Height: 0.5-1.5m Spread: 0.6-2m Position: Part Shade/ Full Sun Flower: Brown Tolerates: Drought, Lime, Moderate frost, Soil salinity, Salt spray Origin: SA, VIC, NSW, QLD, WA, TAS Purpose: Habitat, Ornamental, Erosion Type: Evergreen
Leptospermum polygalifolium Form: Medium Shrub (1.2-3.6m) Height: 1-1.5m Spread: 2-3m Position: Part Shade/ Full Sun Flower: Cream, Green Tolerates: Drought, Moderate frost Origin: NSW, QLD Purpose: W i n d p ro te c t i o n, S c re e n, Ornamental, Habitat, Erosion Type: Evergreen
Doryanthes excelsa Form: Strap-leaved Height: 1.5-2m Spread: 1-2m Position: Part Shade/ Full Sun Flower: Red Tolerates: Drought, Heavy frost Origin: NSW, Purpose: Habitat, Ornamental, Bush food Type: Evergreen
Muehlenbeckia florulenta Form: Medium Shrub (1.2-3.6m) Height: 1-2m Spread: 1-2.5m Position: Part Shade/ Full Sun Flower: Cream Tolerates: Drought, Moderate frost Origin: SA, Vic, NSW, WA, Qld, NT Purpose: Screen, Ornamental, Habitat Type: Evergreen
Melaleuca thymifolia Form: Low shrub Height: 0.5-1m Spread: 0.5-1m Position: Full Sun Flower: Mauve Tolerates: Drought Origin: Qld,NSW Purpose: Ornamental, Habitat, Screen Type: Evergreen
Melaleuca bracteata Form: Medium Tree (5-11m) Height: 3-8m Spread: 3-6m Position: Full Sun Flower: Cream, Yellow Tolerates: Drought, Moderate frost Origin: SA, NSW, Qld, WA, NT Purpose: Ornamental, Screen, Habitat Type: Evergreen
Acmena smithii Form: Medium Tree (5-11m) Height: 3-8m Spread: 3-6m Position: Part Shade/ Full Sun Flower: Cream Tolerates: Drought, Fire, Moderate frost Origin: Qld, Vic, NSW, Tas Purpose: Winter sun, Shade, Wind protection, Ornamental, Noise reduction, Screen Type: Evergreen
Melaleuca linariifolia Form: Medium Tree (5-11m) Height: 5-7m Spread: 3-5m Position: Part Shade/ Full Sun Flower: White, Cream Tolerates: Drought, Lime, Moderate frost Origin: NSW, Qld Purpose: Ornamental, Habitat, Wind protection, Screen Type: Evergreen
Correa alba Form: Low shrub Height: 0.5-1m Spread: 1m Position: Part Shade/ Full Sun Flower: White Tolerates: Drought, Moderate frost Origin: Eastern Australia Purpose: Habitat, Ornamental
Leptospermum lanigerum Form: Medium Tree (5-11m) Height: 2-8m Spread: 5m Position: Full Sun Flower: White Tolerates: Lime, Moderate frost Origin: SA, Vic, NSW, Tas Purpose: Ornamental, Screen Type: Evergreen
Westringia fruiticosa Form: Low shrub Height: 0.8-0.9m Spread: 0.8-1m Position: Part Shade/ Full Sun Flower: White Tolerates: Drought, Moderate frost Origin: Eastern Australia Purpose: Habitat, Ornamental, Screen, Hedge Type: Evergreen
Flowering Period/ Growing Period(Grass Sedge) January
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
N
7.7 - 7.7.1 Detailed Plan - Node 1
Node 1
- Principle 1 - Adapt the land to floods - Principle 2 - People live with water
Sandpit
Wetlands 3m
It is responsible for water storage, filtration and infiltration during and after the floods.
2m
4m
Fine sand
Gravel
Coloured pervious concrete
Anticorrosive wood 1:100 0
1
2
5
10m
One of the paving materials for children's playground, which is not only conducive to the safety of children, but also conducive to the infiltration of rainwater.
Swings Flowerbed
46
47
7.7.2 Node 1 - Section A-A' A
When floods come A- A' 1:100
rain
absorb ±4.0m
±4.3m
water storage
±2.0m
infiltration 3.5m
watercourse
±4.5m
±4.3m sand
±3.5m
±3.0m
6m
permeable pavement
riparian zone
infiltration
infiltration
pipes
8.5m
5.5m
wetlands
infiltration
riparian zone
2.0m
7.0m
main road
12.0m
lawn
playground for children
After floods A- A' 1:100
habitat for fauna ±4.0m
±4.5m
±4.3m
water storage
±4.3m
±3.5m
±3.0m ±2.0m
infiltration 6m watercourse
3.5m riparian zone
8.5m wetlands
pipes
5.5m riparian zone
2.0m main road
7.0m lawn
12.0m playground for children
A‘
48
7.7.3 Node 1 - Perspective - Principle 1 - Adapt the land to floods - Principle 2 - People live with water
wetlands
popular science education
native planting
permeable pavement
gravel edge filtration
sand
infiltration
wetlands
infiltration
During flooding
After flooding
No flooding for a long time
7.8 - 7.8.1 Detailed Plan - Node 2
Stepping stone
49
N
- Principle 1 - Adapt the land to floods - Principle 3 -Water nourishes ecology
Node 2
Weir Regulate the river flow when the water flow increases to ensure the safety of the downstream.
4m
2m
3m 2m
native planting
flagstone
Elevated wooden bridge It has the function of allowing pedestrians to pass in flood and visitors to view the scenery.
Anticorrosive wood
1:100 0
1
2
5
10m
50
7.8.2 Node 2 - Section B-B' When floods come B- B' 1:100 B
elevated wooden walkway
native planting
±5.0m
±4.3m ±3.0m ±2.0m
infiltration
infiltration
7.0m
15.0m
riparian area
12.5m
watercourse
island
8.0m watercourse
After floods B- B' 1:100
elevated wooden walkway
native planting
±5.0m
±4.3m
habitat for fauna
±3.0m
±2.0m
7.0m riparian area
15.0m watercourse
12.5m island
8.0m watercourse
B‘
51
7.8.3 Node 2 - Perspective - Principle 1 - Adapt the land to floods - Principle 3 -Water nourishes ecology
elevated wooden bridge
native planting
stepping stone weir
root penetration
Use engineering methods to enhance roots penetration are important for reinforcing soils and preventing erosion.
52
Project Vision
08 Research Conclusions
53
8.1 Site Evolution Vision Shade increased
Aquatic animals don't stay here to breed
Poor water quality with eutrophication
0 year
N E
Increase of aquatic animals
Water quality improved
5 years
N E
Clean the weeds Inadequate facilities
facilities are well equipped
Weeds strewn the bank
W
penetration of roots system is not enough
S
Severe erosion of creek banks
Shade increased
Weeds are cleared and native plants are increased
W Roots developed
S
The trees are shady and the birds are resident
Increase of aquatic animals
Water quality improved
N
10 years
E
Clean and clear water
Increase of aquatic animals
N
20 years
E
facilities are well equipped
facilities are well equipped
Weeds are cleared and native plants are growing well
Riparian zones have been restored
Weeds are cleared and native plants are growing well
W S
Roots developed
Riparian zones have been restored
W S
Roots developed with good penetration fit for activities
54
8.2 Before and After Before (flooding)
After (flooding) Wetlands intercept and retain rainwater, slowing flood velocity and reducing the amount of water flooding downstream.
Lack of access
permeable pavement
fast water flow
Existing roads are flooded
still passable during the flood
native plants solidify soil and reduce river bank erosion
river bank erosion muddy road
Before (after flooding)
Gravel along the banks help to filter the water
After (after flooding)
when the flood waters recede, people can pass through
Lack of access
flood water recede slowly
native plants attract animals
when the flood water level is low, the weir helps slow the flow of water
Flood waters recede faster Water pollution
river bank erosion Filtration and infiltration of water in wetlands
References
Ahern J., 2011. ‘From fail-safe to safe-to-fail: Sustainability and resilience in the new urban world’, Landscape Urban Planning. 100(4): 341–343. Ashley, RM., Garvin, S., Pasche, E., Vassilopoulos, A & Zevenbergen, C 2007, Advances in urban flood management, Taylor & Francis, Leiden; New York. Benedict, MA & McMahon, E 2006, Green infrastructure: linking landscapes and communities, Island Press, Washington, DC. Hamin, EM., Abunnasr, Y & Ryan, RL 2019, Planning for climate change: a reader in green infrastructure and sustainable design for resilient cities, Routledge, New York, NY Lennon, M., Scott, M & O'Neill, E 2014, ‘Urban Design and Adapting to Flood Risk: The Role of Green Infrastructure’, Journal of urban design, vol. 19, no. 5, pp. 745–758. Meerow, S., Newell, JP & Stults, M 2016, ‘Defining urban resilience: A review’, Landscape and urban planning, vol. 147, pp. 38–49. Novotny, V., Ahern, J & Brown, PR 2010, ‘Planning and design for sustainable and resilient cities: theories, strategies, and best practices for green infrastructure’ in Water centric sustainable communities: planning, retrofitting, and building the next urban environment, Wiley, Hoboken, N.J. Palazzo, E 2019, ‘From water sensitive to floodable: defining adaptive urban design for water resilient cities’, Journal of urban design, vol. 24, no. 1, pp. 137–157. Walker, BH & Salt, D 2006, ‘Living in a Complex World: An Introduction to Resilience Thinking’, Resilience Thinking: sustaining ecosystems and people in a changing world, Island Press, Washington, DC., pp.1-2.
55
56
Thank you