Hometown Oneonta 01-19-23

FOIL Request Results

Demystify Super’s Abrupt Resignation

By DARLA M. YOUNGS SCHENEVUS

The road ahead continues to be rocky for Schenevus Central School District, as documents requested via the New York State Freedom of Information Law reveal former superintendent Theresa Carlin had filed a complaint through the state’s Division of Human Rights against the district. According to its website, the New York State Division of Human Rights “is dedicated to eliminating discrimination, remedying injustice, and promoting equal opportunity, access, and dignity through enforcement of the Human Rights Law.”

According to the “Release and Resignation Agreement” secured through a FOIL request by Schenevus Central School taxpayer Nicole Miskell to the district, “It is expressly understood and agreed that Ms. Carlin withdraws the complaint filed by Ms. Carlin through the State Division of Human

Rights under Case No.: 10218738.”

The agreement also states, “It is understood and agreed that this settlement is a compromise of disputed claims and is not to be construed as an admission of liability on the part of any persons named herein, including the Schenevus Central School District, its officers, Board Members, employees, agents.

“The agreement is not to be considered or construed as an admission of a liability on the part of the above-named persons, nor is it an admission that the District, its officers, Board Members, employees, or agents took any unlawful act or that its conduct in any way violated any State, Federal or Local Law, Rule, or Regulation.”

In a missive delivered to the Schenevus Board of Education and released as part of the FOIL request, Carlin wrote, “I am resigning from my position as Superintendent of Schools effective December

Continued on page 7

Dynamic Dozen Distinguished in December COOPERSTOWN—The contributions of 12 staff members were honored by Fenimore Art Museum and The Farmers’ Museum at the annual recognition event held on Wednesday, December 21. Jane Forbes Clark, chairman of the Board of Directors of The Farmers’ Museum, presented the awards and Dr. Paul S. D’Ambrosio, president and CEO of the two institutions, presided. A 35-year award was presented to Bob Thompson. Patrick MacGregor received a 30-year award and 25-year awards were given to Meg Preston and Chris Rossi. Kevin Gray and Pete Wiswell received 20-year awards, and 15-year awards were presented to Christine Olsen, Walter Ashley, Mark Simonson, Joelle LaChance, and Todd Kenyon. Lynne Mebust accepted a 10-year award. Pictured above, standing from left, are: Jane Forbes Clark, chairman of the Board of Directors of The Farmers’ Museum; Christine Olsen, registrar; Lynne Mebust, museum teacher; Walter Ashley, interpreter; Kevin Gray, manager of arts education; Mark Simonson, interpreter; Paul D’Ambrosio, president and CEO; and Todd Kenyon, director of marketing and communications. Seated: Meg Preston, agriculture events coordinator; Bob Thompson, associate director of agriculture facilities; Patrick MacGregor, manager of interpretation; and Chris Rossi, director of exhibitions. Not in attendance: Pete Wiswell, superintendent of building services, and Joelle LaChance, interpreter.

5K Finishes 2022 on High Note

By DARLA M. YOUNGS

ONEONTA

Results are in for the Oneonta Family YMCA’s annual Frostbite 5K race held on New Year’s Eve day. Jon Hendley of Oneonta placed first for the men and was the overall winner at a pace of 5:58 per mile, with a gun-time finish of 17:48. Brandon Gardner (Oneonta) was second overall at 19:33. Lydia Dillon (Oneonta) was the first woman to cross the finish line, at the 22:53 mark, with a pace of 7:21 per mile, followed directly by Melissa Emilio (Oneonta) who posted a time of 24:07.

This year’s event was held in honor of the late John Hayen, a YMCA fixture widely known as the area’s “ugly sweater fashionista.” According to organizers, 145 participants walked, ran or strolled the race route, including Hayen’s wife, Sue, and his children and grandchildren.

Other interesting statistics: The youngest Frostbite 5K participant was 4 years old and the oldest was 84. The farthest distance a contestant traveled to take part was from Houston, Texas.

The Peachin Group and Hayen’s family sponsored this year’s race bibs, which included the sign language icon for “I love you” followed by “41.”

Continued on page 6

Jersey’s Warriors To Visit in February

By TED MEBUST COOPERSTOWN

The New Jersey Warriors, a hockey team composed of disabled U.S. military veterans, are set to visit Cooperstown from February 17-19. Hosted by the American Legion, a benefit will be held on the team’s behalf at VFW Post 7128, 60 Main Street, on that Friday evening. After a police escort from their hotel, the team will enjoy catering from area businesses including Council Rock Brewery, Brewery Ommegang, and Chobani, and an auction will take place with the proceeds going to the Warriors. On Saturday, the group will get a tour of the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, and then play a game at Badger Park at noon, inviting all community members to join them on the ice.

“It should be a fantastic event,” said Barry Shelley,

Carnival Returning Next Month

By DANIEL FRANCIS COOPERSTOWN

ow in its 55th year, the Cooperstown Winter Carnival blows back into our community on the cold, wintery winds that February brings year in and year out. Luckily, the volunteer-based Winter Carnival Committee has plans to warm the spirits of carnival goers with both fresh and familiar offerings throughout the duration of this year’s event.

Hard Times at Schenevus High

Photo by Milo Stewart Jr.

Photo provided Abigail Dent of Oneonta placed first in the YMCA’s Frostbite 5K female 20-29 category.

Certified Passive Chestnut Crossing Open House Slated for Jan. 28

By DAn SULLIVAn

RICHFIELD SPRInGS

Josh Edmonds has decided where he will work to make a difference in the fight to reduce greenhouse gas emissions worldwide.

“The built environment accounts for 40 percent of global emissions,” said Edmonds in a recent interview. “Furthermore, two thirds of existing buildings will still be in use in 2050.”

Thus, the mission of Edmonds and his company, Simple Integrity, is to turn

Carnival

After what felt like an eternity, albeit just two years of dormancy, the Winter Carnival returns during the first week of February.

Kicking off on Thursday evening, February 2 with hot

standing buildings into high-performance structures and build new ones that are carbon-neutral. With 80 percent of their projects consisting of existing retrofits, it’s clear where the passion lies.

“Our area has a wealth of beautiful, historic homes. It makes sense to bring them into the 21st century,” Edmonds said.

Edmonds, a managing partner at Simple Integrity and a Certified Passive House Consultant© and Passive House Builder©, was born and raised in

chocolate-fueled fireworks over a lakeside viewing party at The Otesaga Resort Hotel—and continuing until Sunday, February 5 with “Grilled Cheese for a Good Cause”—there is plenty fun and enjoyment to be had by all who attend. The schedule includes such fan-favorites as “The Bob

The job scene

Cooperstown.

According to the Simple Integrity website, it is “a local company comprised of artisans from the Cooperstown area. Founded in 2013, it has expanded to include many talented and experienced craftsmen. We live in the greater Cooperstown community in which we work,” the website continues. “You are likely to see team members in the grocery store, at school plays and other civic functions. We are more than just a construction company, we are your neighbors.”

Smullens 5K/10K Race” and the “Lions Club Pancake Breakfast,” as well as firsttime additions “Meet Your Local Heroes” and “Open Pickleball Play.”

This year’s carnival finds its theme in the expression, “There’s Snow Place Like Home,” delivering a sense of homecoming for the event as well as the community it serves. A focus, and emphasis, on the community not just as an institution, but also a living and evolving entity, was at the forefront of the committee’s planning.

“I’m hoping that people come out. I hope that a lot of people who are new to the community will come out and meet new people,” explained committee member Keith Gulla in professing aspirations for his first Winter Carnival experience.

Gulla, who has lived in

Achieving high performance in existing buildings is far more challenging than in new construction, but that does not faze Edmonds and his staff. The most recent example of Simple Integrity’s work will be available for all to see on January 28 from 2-4 p.m. at 10 Chestnut Street in Richfield Springs.

Chestnut Crossing is a multi-unit, market-rate apartment complex in the center of the village. The project is the result of a collaboration of three companies: River Architects, a Cold

Spring, new York firm that specializes in passive house construction; Zaed Sustainable Buildings; and Simple Integrity.

The building contains 13 apartments divided between one- and twobedroom units. According to the project’s website, rents will range between $1,850.00 and $2,700.00, and cover both utilities and Internet. Other amenities include trash and recycling pickup, laundry facilities at no charge, state-of-the-art security, off-street parking, electric vehicle chargers,

and bike racks. Some units feature access via two doors; others have access by internal stairs only. All units are age-in-place ready.

Chestnut Crossing is a certified Passive House building, which means that it uses 90 percent less energy than conventional buildings and has superior indoor air quality. The public is invited to view the complex on Saturday, January 28 from 2-4 p.m.

“Stop by to see what a carbon-neutral building looks like,” invited Edmonds.

Mackie’s sentiments— greetings amongst fellow carnival goers, both familiar and unfamiliar, and there being lots to do—are shared by almost anyone you speak to about the carnival. Another common thread is the annual support from businesses and organizations stepping up to lend a helping hand, whether as a venue, a supplier of resources, or to provide shelter for those seeking respite from the cold.

“The whole village got behind it,” said Hank Phillips, chairperson of the first Cooperstown Winter Carnival Committee in 1968.

Cooperstown for about two years, understands the importance of a sense of community. This is what propelled him to seek out

THE Heritage at The Plains at Parish Homestead COMMUNITY Sonida Living Community

IMMEDIATE OPENING AVAILABLE

MAGNOLIA TRAILS DIRECTOR (Memory Care Activities)

Management, activity programming and hands-on experience working with those with dementia

Apply online at heritagetheplains.com (careers)

163 Heritage Circle Oneonta, NY 13820 EOE

the carnival committee and become one of its many dedicated members.

“Without even finishing this one [this year’s event], I already feel the impact within the community, and the feedback has been wonderful,” Gulla added.

The sense of the CooperstownWinterCarnival as a communal melting pot has always been linked to its core, even if sometimes only as a byproduct of enjoying the hustle and bustle the fourday seasonal celebration has to offer.

Angus Mackie, Cooperstown Winter Carnival chairperson of 1972, said his best carnival memory was the feeling of excitement in town.

“Everybody said ‘hi’ to each other and there was a lot of stuff to do,” he recalled.

nancy Angerer, both a past and present member of the planning committee, expressed her gratitude— and likely that of many others—by summarizing, “Our community as a whole, the merchants and businesses, are so gracious. They don’t get enough accolades for how good they are.”

Marcy Birch, also a past and present committee member, explained, “There’s a lot of history in this event, and a lot of community members through the generations have participated.

“People want to see it continue,” Birch said.

The Cooperstown Winter Carnival is a staple of the village, owing to its rich and significant history, and the motivation and soul behind this popular winter gathering has remained unchanged year after year— the desire to have fun.

Fun was “baked” into the Winter Carnival at its inception and has proven to be an essential ingredient to its continued success and preservation.

“We wanted to get some fun in the wintertime,” explained Phillips.

OTSEGO COUNTY SOIL AND WATER CONSERVATION DISTRICT

SECRETARY TO THE SOIL AND WATER CONSERVATION DISTRICT BOARD

This administrative position serves as an officer to the Board of Directors and is a member of an interdisciplinary team responsible for the implementation and administration of Soil and Water Conservation District (SWCD) programs. The SWCD Secretary is primarily responsible for all fiduciary and financial functions of the Soil and Water District. Work shall be performed independently and professionally. The SWCD Secretary shall report directly to and receive direction from the SWCD District Manager and SWCD Board of Directors. Does related duties as required. Annual salary $45,000 to $55,000 commensurate with experience.

For complete descriptions of typical work activities, skills and abilities requirements, qualifications and special requirements go to otsegosoilandwater.com/job or call 607-547-8337 ext. 4.

Ed Hobbie, Cooperstown Winter Carnival chairperson of 1971, echoed this thought when asked what had motivated him to step up as event chair.

“I just wanted to be involved. And we had a lot of fun. Oh, my Gosh, we had a lot of fun,” Hobbie said.

Phillips and Hobbie were instrumental in the organization of the Cooperstown Winter Carnival during its early, formative years. Their stories, their motivations, and their advice for future generations over the years have all revolved around the act of having fun.

Embarking on its 55th year, the Cooperstown Winter Carnival is proof positive that when an invested and involved community comes together to beat the winter doldrums, the results are well worth repeating.

Photo by Terry Seamon

The 2023 Cooperstown Winter Carnival Committee includes, from left: Keith Gulla, Nancy Angerer, Larissa Ryan, Marcy Birch, Cay Franck and Carina Franck. Committee members not present: Caspar Ewig, Tom Farkas and Claire Kepner. According to organizers, one of the central ideals in the formation of this committee was that no chairperson(s) be appointed, promoting a level ground for members to share ideas and information as well as provide an equal sense of responsibility in the production of the event.

Bassett Advancing Healthcare in Central New York and Beyond

Dear friends, neighbors and colleagues,

At Bassett, we are welcoming 2023 with a renewed energy and refreshed perspective. As we look at the year ahead, we are incredibly optimistic for the future of healthcare in our region. The new year will inevitably bring challenges—this is the case for all hospitals and health systems right now. But Bassett caregivers are adaptable and embrace each new opportunity with determination and enthusiasm. I’d like to share a few examples of the ways Bassett is advancing healthcare in our Central new York region and beyond. I’m thrilled to announce

that Bassett Medical Center has recently earned prestigious Primary Stroke Center Certification with The Joint Commission’s Gold Seal of Approval® and the American Heart Association’s Heart-Check Mark. This outstanding accreditation recognizes hospitals that meet superior standards to improve outcomes for stroke patients. Stroke is the fifth leading cause of death in the U.S.—providing advanced care to our rural communities is essential. In addition to the neurologists on staff in Cooperstown who also serve our entire network, Bassett has a successful TeleHealth partnership with Strong Memorial

Hospital in Rochester, providing 24/7 advanced neurology care on-call. When we hear “TeleHealth,” many of us think of consulting with a doctor over a video or phone from home. But virtual health is comprised of much more. Bassett’s E-Consults allow patients to connect with specialists at partner institutions from the convenience of their local Bassett hospital or clinic—besides neurology and other sub-specialties, our newest offering is a cardiovascular clinical services partnership with world-class physicians at Columbia University Irving Medical Center using live video and electronic stethoscopes. Other

Polar Bear Jump to Return in February

GOODYEAR LAKE

The Goodyear Lake Polar Bear Jump will return at 12:30 p.m. on February 18 this year for the first time since 2020. After participants take a plunge into Goodyear Lake in this, the 25th year of the event, an awards ceremony will take place in the Oneonta Elks Club, 84 Chestnut Street, Oneonta at 6:30 p.m. In preparation for the event, participants will raise money on an individual basis, though there will be an auction and raffles at Milford Central School on January 29 at 12:30 p.m. Proceeds from this year’s jump will benefit Clara Baker, Joshua Byma, Frankie Castardi, Braydon Decker, Hopeful Hearts, Kieara Hoyt, Troy Lutz and Waylon Snellbaker. For more information, visit pbjump.com or contact Brenda or Jamie Waters at (607) 286-7101.

FoVL Present Immigration Programs

COOPERSTOWn

On Sunday, January 22 from 3-4 p.m., Friends of the Village Library will present “Community Voices: Our Immigrant Stories,” featuring a panel of local and regional neighbors who will share stories of their immigration experiences. The program is in the third floor Ballroom of the Village Hall, 22 Main Street.

On February 1, the Village Library will install a traveling exhibition from the new York State Library called “The Immigrant Experience,” which spans 100 years of stories and photographs about the state’s immigration history. Both the speaker program and the exhibition are free and open to the public. For more information, call (607) 547-8344.

options, like E-Visits, allow patients to access online examination and treatment tools that are mobile-friendly and automatically send prescriptions to your preferred new York State pharmacy once approved by a practitioner. Learn more about all the virtual care options available to you by visiting www.bassett. org/get-care-now.

Bassett is continually enhancing and tailoring our care to the needs of our patients while exploring and embracing highly advanced technology and treatment options. Last fall, Bassett began offering Lutathera, a special-

ized radiotherapy used to treat rare neuroendocrine cancers. For those with the need, it is an essential treatment, and Bassett offers it close to home.

We strive to make new therapies like this accessible to patients without the need to drive across the state to a larger city. This is just the first of several breakthrough pharmaceuticals in this class that will be offered through our network.

Finally, in recent months, Bassett Medical Center has added Robotic-Assisted Bariatric Surgery to its suite of surgical weightloss options. This innovative procedure provides

our bariatric patients with shorter recovery times, less postoperative pain and shorter hospital stays, offering our patients the same options available in large urban areas.

I know 2023 is going to be a good year for innovative thinking, removing boundaries and embracing each new opportunity together. I can’t wait to share more of the exciting things happening at Bassett with you throughout the coming year. Happy new Year to you and your loved ones!

Dr. Tommy Ibrahim is president and CEO of Bassett Healthcare Network.

EDITORIaL

This Is for the Birds

Last year, more than 57 million birds, including poultry, perished in the U.S. from a surge of avian influenza (H5N1), a killer disease that has been increasingly effective in attacking wild birds, especially migrating waterfowl. Mallards and Canada geese seem to be the most susceptible. The disease, which has flared up sporadically since its discovery, as fowl plague, in 1878, is caused by infections that occur naturally in wild aquatic birds. These infections are transmitted to other birds, domestic and wild, through bodily discharges as well as through contact with contaminated surfaces. Until last summer, Avian Flu has been seasonal, proliferating from September to March and then disappearing during the warmer months. The current outbreak, however, has not fallen off over the last two summers.

The last major outbreak, in 2014-15, killed an estimated record 50.5 million birds in 21 states. Last year the disease, which was first detected at the end of 2021, popped up in nearly every state, with the morbidity count increased proportionally.

Avian flu does not affect all types of birds equally. While waterfowl and wild birds often carry and transmit the disease, they rarely get sick and die from it; raptors, on the other hand, are highly susceptible, and domestic poultry not only pick it up quickly but spread it immediately to their entire flock, leading to an almost 100 percent mortality rate. Of course, these little cluckers also spread it easily to their barnyard neighbors—geese, ducks, ostriches and turkeys.

Huge numbers of poultry—44 million laying hens, in fact—have perished or been culled since early 2022. Egg prices have shot up and grocery stores have limited the amount of eggs per customer.

Now there are signs the morbidity count is going down in the commercial egg-laying facilities, signaling a possible letting up of the current epidemic. Egg supplies most probably will remain constrained until spring; it takes three to four months to get back to peak productivity, 24 eggs per month per hen, after the facilities have been sanitized and re-stocked.

Avian flu is not a severe threat to humans. Although a small number of people have contracted it in the past (the 2022 flu has stricken one person, last April, in Colorado), the disease has never shown any propensity to transmit between people. The symptoms are mild and flu-like, and the worst-case scenario is pneumonia. The best possible defense is to not handle any stricken or dead bird, and to wear protective clothing and use a lot of soap and water if such handling is necessary.

As for the lucky songbirds, they are at low risk of exposure to or transmission of H5N1, and therefore they should still be allowed to visit their usual bird feeders, which should be regularly cleaned. Since last January, the United States Department of Agriculture has discovered the strain in 5,552 wild birds, and in a mere 63 songbirds. It has been found in 251 birds in New York, not one of which was in Otsego County, though a bald eagle was lost in Schoharie.

Avian flu will not likely disappear in the foreseeable future, and it will remain a threat to wildlife and domestic birds, but its spread and death toll are manageable. The Easter bunny should be pleased.

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR POLICY

“Hometown Oneonta” welcomes letters to the editor that reflect the writer’s thoughts on an article or other item appearing in the paper. They must include the writer’s name, address, email and telephone/ mobile number; the opinions expressed must be the writer’s own. Hostile, offensive, factually incorrect or excessively inflammatory content will not be published. The length must be no more than 250 words. The editors reserve the right to accept, reject or edit letters for clarity and space. Please send letters to: info@allotsego.com.

LIFE IN THE TIME OF COVID

Current Concepts and Constant Change

Things in the world of COVID are rapidly and constantly changing. This week’s column is a brief compendium of some of these changes.

The alphabet soup of COVID variants and subvariants grows daily. Four weeks ago, we were talking about the new Omicron variant XBB. Now we are reading about the subvariant daily. A month ago, we were starting to discuss the properties of the original XBB. Now XBB.1.5 is considered the most infectious version of COVID yet. It’s not clear if symptoms are going to be worse than previous versions, but it does appear that regardless of previous infectious or vaccine status, almost everybody is going to be infected. It is not even clear how useful masking is, since very few people use masks properly and consistently, and this variant seems to be able to get around simple protections like surgical masks. It already makes up more than 75 percent of COVID infections in the northeast United States, and deaths per day—which is the most accurate indicator of the effect of the virus—continue to increase. Some sources feel that unless somebody has been recently infected or appropriately boostered, they are going to have very few defenses against XBB.1.5. There is already a new CDC recommendation to increase precautions; masks, distancing, avoidance of groups, and get the latest boosters. The number of fatalities daily has been spiking upward and in the United States is now over 400 per day. Two weeks ago, in a column

we called “The China Syndrome,” we pointed out that the Chinese government was releasing amazingly low numbers of COVID cases and COVID deaths. This week they’ve decided to come clean, or at least reasonably so. The Chinese government is now saying there were 60,000 deaths from COVID in the previous month and unofficial statements from Shanghai state that 70 percent of the population has been infected recently. This number may be as high as 80 percent in Beijing. It is estimated that more than 100 million people in China have recently had COVID. This, of course, is an unfortunate outcome of the Chinese government failing to take advantage of the delay provided it by its total lockdown program. Very few Chinese have been recently vaccinated and less than half of 1 percent have had boosters in the past six months. Considering that about 250 million people in China are over 60 years old and, by definition, all of these are high risk, the possibility of as many as 5 million deaths in the near future is possible. The Chinese government has refused to approve the mRNA vaccines developed in the U.S. and Europe for its own citizens (though it allows it for foreign nationals), and has not obtained a significant inventory of Paxlovid. COVID, for the second year in a row, is the leading cause of death of active duty police officers, though the number is improving from 2021. The improvement is felt to be due to better treatment, reduced infection rates, and availability of vaccines and their acceptance.

Research from Kaiser

Permanente suggests that exercise in almost any regular amount is protective of COVID. The CDC has reported that “physical activity is associated with a decrease in COVID-19 hospitalizations and deaths, while inactivity increases that risk. Other research also has linked regular physical activity with a lower risk of infection.” Of course, whether this an effect or just a correlation is not known. It’s possible people who exercise have better vaccination rates or take better precautions (though my experience at the Clark Sports Center suggests otherwise).

Scientists are performing experiments to see if Paxlovid can improve Long COVID symptoms. It was observed that some people with suspected reinfection who were treated with a course of Paxlovid reported a decrease in their Long COVID. The theory is that, in some cases, the virus persists in the body after the initial infection and round of symptoms.

The reported case rate for Otsego County last week was approximately 1 percent. As opposed to last month, when the transmissibility was low, this is now high, probably representing the spread of XBB.1.5. Only 63 percent of the county has been fully vaccinated. It is very clear that the risks of serious complications from COVID is orders of magnitude higher than the risks of vaccination. I’m tired of writing this but wear a mask properly, keep vaccinations up to date and avoid crowds.

Dr. Richard Sternberg is a retired Bassett Hospital orthopedic surgeon.

PaRTIaL OBSERVER NaTHaN SEaMON

Town of Columbia Residents Wary of Project

The Town of Columbia is being pitched a 350 megawatt solar and 20 MW battery storage project by French owned, and San Diego based EDF Renewables. The project outreach to local landowners began quietly in 2019 and will require approximately 2,200 usable, contiguous acres—equal to 10 percent of the land in the Town of Columbia, which is known to have some of the most fertile farmland in the state.

The flood of large solar projects around New York State popping up over the last few years is fueled by the state’s aggressive goal of using 70 percent renewable energy by 2030. In 2019, the state passed and signed into law the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act, which led to the creation of the Office of Renewable Energy Siting and, through executive law, the 94-c process, in efforts to speed up and ease the permitting process that project developers had long sought.

The new siting process allows ORES to issue the permits. This overrides the state’s long standing

Home Rule Law, which historically has provided local towns the ability to regulate and handle the permitting process themselves.

The Columbia Solar Project, as proposed, is in violation of the Town of Columbia’s local laws and imposes on its comprehensive plan.

Over the past several months, a concerned citizen’s group, Protect Columbia, has sprung up in opposition to the solar project for a variety of reasons. More than 400 lawn signs have been displayed throughout town as concerns about and sentiments against the solar project continue to grow.

While we are not against solar panels per say, many of us are concerned that a project of this size will take prime tillable and pasturable farmland off the table at a time where food production is becoming more challenging than ever. There are serious health and safety concerns, along with negative visual impacts it would have on the town, as well as concerns about the threat that it would bring to our environment, such as to the soil, our drinking water, wildlife, and the

ecosystem in general. All things considered, we think the negative issues related to a solar and battery storage project of this size and scale far outweigh the positives.

There is on-going litigation in the New York State Supreme Court pertaining to solar projects similar to the Columbia Solar Project, focused on the 94-c siting process and environmental concerns that have been brought up by municipalities and local civic groups. This leads one to believe that the 94-c siting process in general, its relation to Home Rule Law, and other aspects will likely be challenged in court in the years to come. There are also bills in the New York State Senate that are being discussed which would change or eliminate the siting process, given it silences local voices and town laws. As of this date, EDF Renewables has not applied to ORES for the permit it would need to be approved in order to move ahead with the Columbia Solar Project.

Nathan Seamon is a resident of the Town of Columbia and a Protect Columbia member.

PaRTIaL OBSERVER THOMaS kaNE jR

Key Factors May Help Decide Next President

MEMBER OF:

National Newspaper Association, New York

Published Thursdays by Iron String Press, Inc. 21 Railroad Ave., Cooperstown NY 13326 Telephone: 607-547-6103. Fax: 607-547-6080. Email: info@allotsego.com • www.allotsego.com Contents © Iron String Press, Inc.

Discussion about the next presidential election no longer begins a year or so before Election Day. It begins four years before the election! Because of this, it might be appropriate—21 months before the next election—to highlight the six factors regularly cited by political scientists and histo-

rians in gauging the performance of a president. An appreciation of these factors should be helpful to citizens as they discuss the fitness of 2024 presidential candidates.

Communication: The great majority of Americans come to know a president through television, newspaper and the Internet.

Effective communication through these outlets is important for a president who seeks to gain the support of citizens for a legislative proposal or during a foreign policy crisis such as a prolonged military engagement. A president whose gifts as a communicator

DR. RICHaRD STERNBERG

Publisher

Barnwell General Manager / Senior Editor Darla M. Youngs

a publication of Iron String Press, Inc.

Staff Writer Ted Mebust Business Manager Larissa Ryan Columnists and Contributing Writers

Terry Berkson, Maureen Culbert, Richard deRosa, Caspar Ewig, Daniel Francis, Ian Kenyon, Tom Shelby, Dr. Richard Sternberg, Dan Sullivan, T. Stephen Wager and Jamie Zvirzdin

Editorial Board

Tara Barnwell, Faith Gay, Michael Moffat, Elinor Vincent, Darla M. Youngs

Web Architect Ivan Potocnik Historian Tom Heitz/Sharon Stuart Legal Counsel Jill Ann Poulson

Press Association The Otsego County Chamber

135 YEARs AGo

The Local News: Michael sullivan of osborn Hollow died recently. The deceased had been in the employ of the D & H Company for the past 18 years and had lost in that time but two or three days. He was track walker between osborn Hollow and Port Crane, and his daily trip covered twenty miles. During his 18 years of service he walked a trifle over 131,000 miles.

A.N. Deuel, formerly a railroad conductor and later a grocery-man of oneonta, is reported to have left town with the wife of Geo. Vanderson, a railroad employee. Vanderson is reported to be after them with a blunderbuss. The popular impression appears to be, however, that Deuel has done him a good turn.

January 1888

110 YEARs AGo

Fifty years ago the petroleum industry in the United states, and in the world for that matter, was in its infancy; and in our own country was confined to a small area around Titusville and oil City, in Pennsylvania. Now, the world consumes a million 42-gallon barrels of petroleum per day. of the petroleum products of the world, more than half are in the United states, where the output in 1912 was over 220,000,000 barrels, practically the same as in 1911. Prices however, have greatly increased. oil which sold a year and a half ago for $1.30 per barrel now brings $2.00 or more in a ready market.

January 1913

70 YEARs AGo

some 50 million Americans with personal incomes of $600 or more must file federal income tax returns this year. There is only one consolation – the rates have not gone up, although neither have they gone down. And, the same exemptions and deductions you used last March apply when figuring the tax on 1952 income. The rate increase November 1, 1951 averaged about 11 percent for most taxpayers. But, since the boost was effective for only one-sixth of the year taxpayers will feel its full impact for the first time when paying their 1952 taxes. Returns are due on or before March 15. It’s to your advantage to file a return even if you made less than $600 last year in a job covered by the withholding tax. such income is tax-free, and you’ll get a refund check from the treasury.

January 1953

50 YEARs AGo

oneonta would have more parks and open spaces if recommendations made by the Anti-Pollution and Environmental Board are accepted by the city. The report recommends the wooded area between Woodside Avenue and sUCo, already owned by the city, be used for nature trail studies to be used by college and oneonta school district classes. “Because of its steep slopes,” it was recommended that “the area should be left in its natural state.” The Parish Farm, west of the city, and north of the new sewage treatment plant, should be developed into a historic park, exhibiting the Revolutionary War cemetery located there. That property is already owned by the city. Another land parcel, owned privately in the sixth Ward, is recommended for use as a park and picnic grounds. The report suggests this park could be used by the Riverside school which lost playground land to the state for the construction of Interstate 88. Big Island, near Neahwa Park offers 90 acres of uninhabited land covered with second growth flood plain forest and river scenery untouched by development. The report concludes that Big Island should be used as a public nature study area and public picnic ground. A fifth property located above Table Rock and Hartwick College should remain untouched and undeveloped as forest land. However, these 100 acres are currently being considered as the site for a 200-unit town house complex.

January 1973

City of the Hills: Out With the Old and in With the New

Welcome to oneonta. Welcome new businesses and new members of our community.

We’ve been waiting for you, and we are so glad you’re here.

Welcome to the Apple Express, which finally fills the empty space that was Friendly’s.

The ice cream shop was an anchor for the neighborhood, and the Apple Express is a terrific candidate to fill that role for the future. Providing convenient, small grocery shopping to an area that doesn’t have it, is bound to make it popular. And as a high-traffic space it will play a role in bringing together neighbors, new and old.

Harry singh, welcome. It’s so nice to have you.

And hello, Dazzo’s Kitchen!

What a gift it is to our community to have such a stellar dining experience suddenly join us. Respectfully reimagining the Foti’s Bakery building and adding to its quality of character, this restaurant has the potential to become as iconic as a Foti roll. There’s no doubt that it will add another layer of luster to the already impressive array of oneonta dining options. And the bonus? Eric and Danielle, two new oneonta residents!

Would everybody agree? NAGs Bar and Kitchen is a very pleasant sight in what was an embarrassment of an empty restaurant space. NAGs is evidence of the affection of a Canadian visitor who’s been smitten by our downtown. We love his confidence and believe that the community’s support, and the patronage of dozens of new residents in the Lofts on Dietz, will ensure the success of the business.

By MERL REAGLE

so, that’s another empty storefront filled. There are many others to follow, but this is progress.

on Water street, there’s more. Asian Cuisine and Bar is a well-lit, sparkling clean, and inviting new dining option with a few geographic twists to their offerings. With entrances on Main and Water, it’s another nice addition to both streets.

New businesses and new neighbors are coming, and they are arriving in one’s and two’s and three’s.

It’s not the stream that we’ll begin to see soon, but it’s a good number for now; and just enough to allow us to get our ducks in a row. All of us, as a community.

There’s a shared consensus. We need new residents. Most everyone is agreed that an infusion of a thousand new people is exactly the shot in the arm we need.

so, it’s important that folks step up to lead an effort to welcome our new neighbors and jump-start their connection to the community. And… (more good news) they have!

As important as the embrace of new arrivals may be, it’s also vital to our recruitment efforts to know who’s joined us, and why they’ve chosen to live here.

Here’s a question: Have you just moved to oneonta in the last year?

If that describes you or someone you know, our Welcome Wagon committee would love to meet you. It’s an easy connection to make, too. You can say “hello” at all4oneonta.com.

speaking for all oneontans, “We’re so happy you’re here!”

Mark Drnek is the mayor of the City of Oneonta.

Catch of the Day…We’ll get you hooked

Compiled by Tom HeiTz/SHARoN STUART with resources courtesy of The Fenimore Art museum Research Library

Alan J. Curran

1949-2023

AFTOn—Alan James Curran, 73, passed away on January 8, 2023, in Afton, new York, with his family and loving dog, Max, by his side.

Born on August 21, 1949 in Youngstown, Ohio, Alan was the son of James Leroy and Marilouise (Hill) Curran. He joined the United States Air Force in 1969, where he worked as a jet aircraft mechanic. He served with honor and distinction until 1973, at which time he was honorably discharged with the rank of sergeant.

In 1988, Alan and his family moved from California to Hartwick, new York, where he lived until his retirement from the security department of Bassett Hospital. He loved sharing his passion for playing the drums, painting landscapes and portraits, history, current events and nearly every genre of music. He was an avid sports fan, particularly football, baseball and auto racing. He was a lifelong Las Vegas (Oakland) Raiders and California (Anaheim) Angels fan and was overjoyed to watch the Angels 2002 World Series victory.

Alan loved and was intensely proud of his family. He is greatly missed by his wife, Linda (nèe Barown); children and stepchildren Jennifer DeHaven, Jeremiah Brooks (Tara), Katie Curran and Scott Curran (Jessica); his brother, Raymond Curran; his sister, Peggy Kelly (John); grandchildren Austin DeHaven, Anthony DeHaven, Tyler Columbo, and Jamison Curran; as well as a host of nieces and nephews.

A graveside service will be held at a future date.

Judith A. Krumpus 1945-2022

“I will be always there with you, right there in your heart.”

Mickey Mouse

On December 31, 2022, Judith A. Krumpus joined her parents, James and Louise, and brother, Richard, in eternal happiness. Born november 9, 1945 in Plainfield, new Jersey, Judy lived a life of love and kindness, supported by the strong bonds of family and friends.

Losing her parents at a young age, Judy was raised by her aunt and uncle, Kathleen and Edwin Phillips, in Cooperstown, new York. Surrounded by her Phillips and Clark families, she flourished there and graduated from Cooperstown High in 1963.

She studied at Cobleskill College and Brockport State, graduating with a degree in elementary education teaching.

Judy began her career as an elementary teacher at Ichabod Crane school in Kinderhook, new York in 1970, where she taught until her retirement in 2003. There she cultivated close friendships with her colleagues and made a lasting impression on her students.

She maintained a remarkable and marvelous friendship with her college friends, Donna, Elaine, Mona, Maxine, and Pat, and they all held fast to their Second Tuesday of the Month Lunch date for more than 45 years. They will miss her dearly. Mickey Mouse and all things Disney were a central part of Judy’s enjoyment. She so loved her flower gardens and her feline companions, Rosie and Ruby.

Judy leaves behind her cousins, Joan P. Clark of Cooperstown, new York, and Jack Meyer of Greenland, new Hampshire. She was particularly close to her second cousins, Paul A. Clark (Mary Claire) of Whitesboro, new York and Peter E. Clark of Baldwinsville, new York, who considered her like a big sister. She also leaves many Phillips, Clark and Bushby cousins.

A very special thank you to nick Wood, Amy Ringen and family, and the staff of the Columbia-Greene Dialysis Unit, Ghent, new York for

Grandma loved her farm, her family, and playing her old guitar.

Lester R. Grummons Funeral Home will take the time to find out what made your loved one special. Whether it’s finding just the right flowers, or finding a musician to play her favorite tunes on her old guitar, we’ll do what’s necessary to make her service as unique as she was.

Lester R. Grummons Funeral Home

14 Grand Street, Oneonta • 607-432-6821 www.grummonsfuneralhome.com

OBITUARIES

the unwavering support, assistance, and care they all provided for many years.

A memorial mass will be held January 21, 2023 at The Church of St. Joseph, Stuyvesant Falls, new York at 11 a.m. Interment at St. Mary’s Cemetery, Cooperstown, new York will follow in the spring.

Please plant flowers in Judy’s honor every chance you get and always remember what Mickey Mouse said: “Laughter is timeless, imagination has no age, and dreams are forever.”

Lions Club Richfield Springs; Rod and Gun Club, Richfield Springs; Richfield Springs Sportsman’s Club; Richfield Springs Grange; Otsego County Representative (District 9) for 10 years; Otsego County Solid Waste Board; Southern Tier East Regional Planning Board; 1991 Otsego County Bicentennial chair; natural Gas Study in Otsego County; Otsego County Feasibility Study; Otsego County Development; MOSA County Waste Authority Board; glass recycling in Oneonta; and chairman of the committee for Bassett’s Richfield Springs clinic. Alex was very active in Christ Episcopal Church in Cooperstown.

He liked to share his life experiences to help others, especially mentoring young adults.

His final resting place will be in a Columbarium Wall at Christ Episcopal Church, Cooperstown.

Alexander J. Shields 1936-2023

RICHFIELD SPRInGS—

Alexander J. Shields, 86, passed away on January 9, 2023 at home with his loving wife by his side.

He was born in Oneonta on October 2, 1936.

Alex is survived by his loving wife of 45 years, Barbara A. Shields; a daughter, Ursula (Ralph) Thompson of Canandaigua, and their three children and four greatgrandchildren; sons Gregory of Albany and Christopher of Washington, D.C.; stepchildren Harvey (Evonne) Elliott of Oak Hall, Virginia and their three children, and Charles (Mary Lou) Elliott of Binghamton, their nine children and six grandchildren.

He is also survived by nephew and nieces Lewis (Joann) Shields, Oneonta; Patty (Michael) Audino, Albany; Maureen (Chris) Reed, Glenville; Brenda (Ray) Laselle, Chilliwack, British Columbia and W. Richard Tuch of Ottawa, Ontario.

He was predeceased by his parents, Andrew and Alexandria Shields; brothers James Shields, William (Mary) Shields, Kenneth (Margaret) Shields; and step-son Michael Elliott.

Alex received an AAS Business Administration degree from SUnY Delhi and a BS from SUnY Oneonta. His first job was at an Oneonta grocery store delivering groceries. He also worked for Bendix in Sidney.

Alex joined the Air Force at age 18. He went on to Richfield Springs Post 616 as county commander and color guard. He was involved with the Otschodela Council Boy Scouts as troop leader. Alex was president and state director of the Jaycees in Oneonta, involved with the Junior Chamber of Commerce in Oneonta, PTO president of an Oneonta elementary school, director of mental health for Otsego County, master mason for the Shriners Lodge 482 in Richfield Springs, and Cooperstown Masonic group Eastern Star District lecturer.

Other affiliations include: Rotary International; Mohawk Valley World Trade Council;

A celebration of life will be held at Christ Episcopal Church in Cooperstown, 69 Fair Street, on Saturday, May 20, 2023, at 11:00 a.m.

All are invited to a lunch following the service.

In lieu of flowers, please make contributions to Richfield Youth Sports Inc., PO Box 458, Richfield Springs, nY 13439. Contributions also appreciated to your local hospice or a charity of your choice.

David W. Thorn 1938-2023

MILFORD—David W. Thorn died on January 6, 2023. He was born on December 19, 1938 in Cooperstown, new York. He was predeceased by his three brothers, Richard, Donald, and Dean, and his sister, Joyce.

After graduating from Milford Central School, Mr. Thorn received his BS and MS degrees in Education from SUnY Oneonta. Additional graduate study from Syracuse University led to certification to work with children having special needs. His certification in School Administration and Business came from SUnY Plattsburgh. Additional study was done at Ithaca College and Utica College.

Mr. Thorn taught for one year in South Colonie and, from 1961 to 1994, worked in the Cooperstown Central Schools; eight years as an elementary principal and as a classroom teacher.

There will be no calling hours or services.

Those wishing to make a donation can do so in Mr. Thorn’s name to: St. John’s Foundation, 150 Highland Ave., Rochester, nY 14620 or to Woodside Hall, 1 Main Street, Cooperstown, nY 13326.

Share condolences with the family at: www.Miller1889. com

Well Wow! That was an exhilarating ride! What a privilege.

My body! My constant companion. Her fortitude. She gave me everything I asked of her! And now she will rest deeply as she has long deserved. She & I are ready.

To have the education I received!

To have the freedom to decide the exact shape my family and my work would take.

The magic of loving my daughter, Jesse! Our twenty-nine years together!

Watching her grow and create a family of her own. Meeting Mercedes!

The sound of slow steady rain on the roof!

A sky thick with stars!

A long run!

The smell of coming snow!

A perfectly sharpened pencil!

The thrill of cold water on my skin!

A paper lantern floating up through the darkness! The tastes! The smells!

And to all of you, thank you, thank you, thank you. I’ll see you in the stars!

Love, Alex

(no flowers please. Thank you for understanding that I do not want a memorial service. Give generously to your local reproductive health clinic. Thank you!)

5K

Continued from page 1

“This was requested by the Hayen family,” explained YMCA HR/ Operations Leader Susan Kurkowski. “John would always do that gesture to his loved ones and the 41 was his number. They loved it and it was such a nice touch.”

Benson Agency Real Estate, the Clark Sports Center, Community Bank nA, Country Club Motors, “The Daily Star,” Delaware national Bank of Delhi, Liquor Depot, new Asbury Gardens, and the Oneonta Boys and Girls Club also sponsored this year’s event.

For complete 2022 Frostbite 5K results, visit oneontaymca.org.

Dignity, Respect, Tradition

Dignified and Caring Service since 1925 Peaceful grounds. Home-like atmosphere. Suitable for large or small gatherings.

Peter A. Deysenroth 82 Chestnut Street, Cooperstown | 607-547-8231 www.cooperstownfuneralhome.com

Funeral Home

Alexandra Ferrebee Gehring May 21, 1970-January 12, 2023

Photo provided

Photo provided Lillian McGonigal of Delhi, just 12 years old, was the third-place female finisher overall in this year’s Frostbite 5K.

Photo provided ALAN JAMES CURRAN

Photo provided ALEXANDER J. SHIELDS

Graphic provided Frostbite honoree John Hayen was well known for using sign language to say “I love you” and 41 was his number. Both were incorporated into this year’s race bibs.

thought to be superb was Franklin Roosevelt.

Political Skill: Presidents have to be good politicians in the sense of understanding what it takes to “get things done.” Most critical here is being effective in working with both houses of Congress. Congress is a complex institution with a variety of people holding power on a particular issue. Presidents must know who these people are and how to gain their support. Lyndon Johnson was considered to have a high level of political skill.

Decision Making: The most important activity a president engages in is decision making. Whether it is, for example, the Ukraine war, COVID, or inflation, presidents make critical decisions. These decisions need to be made with serious contemplation of the issue based on accurate information and consideration of all alternatives. Dwight Eisenhower is considered to have been an outstanding decision maker.

Vision: A president should always be concerned with articulating broad goals for the nation and then attempting to enact policies that reflect those broader goals. It is very easy for presidents to get sidetracked with daily pressures, losing sight of broader goals. Ronald Reagan has gotten high marks for vision.

Personality: Presidents differ in personality. For example, a high-strung president may become upset easily, losing the ability to calmly consider all alternatives before making a decision, or an insecure president may not be willing to make the right decision for fear of intense criticism. Gerald Ford never suffered from

either of these difficulties. He is an example of an exceptionally stable president very able to meets the demands of the presidency.

Character: A president should be honest. Of course, presidents are political leaders who are involved with difficult situations that often require compromise and adjustment. This, though, is different from dishonesty.

When problems of integrity begin to mark a presidency, a president’s capacity to lead the nation is seriously eroded. This has occurred during three presidencies since the end of World War II. A president who was thought to be very honest was Harry Truman.

While the factors above are quite important, they are not equally so. Decision making, personality, and character are especially critical for the success of a presidency and the future of our nation. While it is common for citizens to vote on the basis of a candidate’s party affiliation and position on key issues, it is very important that voters also consider the six factors just identified as they go about deciding on which candidate they will vote for in 2024.

Tom Kane Jr. is a professor emeritus of political science at St. Joseph’s University in Philadelphia and a long-time summer resident of Cooperstown.

warriors

Continued from page 1

the team’s local contact who has been a longtime hockey fan, even setting up a small ice rink in the attic of his Fly Creek home.

“Saturday is mostly just a fun skate, so if people want to come down, meet the veterans and skate with them, they are welcome to,” Shelley said.

Shelley explained that his involvement with hockey while serving in

the Air Force had been a very helpful outlet for him. From the connections he made during that time, as many as 100 veterans from across Maine, Pennsylvania, Connecticut, new Hampshire, Ohio and Ottawa, Canada will come to Cooperstown to meet with the Warriors next month, he said.

The new Jersey Warriors hockey program is a 501c3 nonprofit organization dedicated to providing rehabilitation opportunities for wounded veterans from new York, new Jersey and Pennsylvania. Founded in 2019 and affiliated with the new Jersey Devils, the team plays at the Prudential Center in newark, new Jersey. The Warriors compete in regional and national tournaments across the country, most recently in St. Louis, and are led by President Mark Puttenvink and Executive Vice President Ted Curtin.

“Our mission is simple: to provide a therapeutic community for veterans… at the end of the day, it’s about the community,” said Puttenvink, a former strength and conditioning coach for various professional teams, who founded the team and organizes their charity events and activities.

Puttenvink said that in addition to the Cooperstown events, the team will catch a Utica Comets hockey game on Saturday night, another new Jersey Devils team affiliate. They will be accompanied throughout the weekend by a film crew from Montclair State University.

To learn more about the new Jersey Warriors and to support their mission, visit njwarriors.org.

Schenevus

31, 2022 contingent upon the signed and adopted separation agreement dated December 27, 2022. I am resigning from my position with regret as I have enjoyed working with the students and staff of Schenevus for the past 41/2 years but take with me a great deal of knowledge and experience from my time at Schenevus.”

According to the agreement, the district will pay Carlin the salary of $137,000.00 through December 31, 2023 on a biweekly schedule and will compensate Carlin for 30 unused vacation days and 30 unused sick days, “on or before January 15, 2023, at the rate of 1/240th of Ms. Carlin’s salary.” Other stipulations of the agreement focus on the terms of health, dental and vision insurance, and retiree coverage.

“In exchange for the agreement contained herein and the promises and covenants contained herein,” the document reads, “Theresa Carlin, on behalf of herself and her family, agents, executors, administrators, heirs and assigns, shall fully release and forever discharges the Schenevus Central School District, the Board of Education thereof, and all officers, employees, and agents of the District, as well as its predecessors, successors and assigns, from any and all claims, complaints, causes of action, whatsoever exist as of the date of this agreement.”

The agreement reached between Carlin and the Board of Education regards the release and resignation as confidential and a privileged communication between the parties. neither party is allowed to disseminate or release information regarding the agreement

LEGALS

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE OF PUBLIC SALE

Public notice is hereby given Under Sec. 182 nYS Lien Law, that property described as contents of storage unit, will be sold at public auction at 1:00 PM on January 28th, 2023 at Rt.

23 Self Storage of Oneonta, 8745 St Hwy 23, Oneonta nY. The sale of such property is to satisfy the lien of Rt 23 Self Storage of Oneonta on property stored for the accounts of:

Unit # 607

Barbara Rico

Unit # 627

Carmen Sullivan

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE OF DEmOCrATIC PArTy CAUCUS VILLAgE OF COOPErSTOwN

A caucus of the enrolled members of the Democratic Party in the Village of Cooperstown will be held at the Village Hall, 22 Main

Street, Cooperstown, nY on Monday, January 30, 2023, at 7pm. (Please enter through Fair St entrance and follow signage to the caucus). The purpose of the caucus is to nominate candidates for the following offices (or any offices that may become vacant) to be voted upon at the General Village Election on March 21, 2023:

Trustee: 3-year term Trustee: 3-year term Lynne Mebust Chair, Cooperstown Democratic Committee

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE

OF FOrmATION OF LLC.

Janes Garden LLC (LLC) filed Arts. of Org. with Secy. of State of nY (SSnY) on 1/11/2023.

Office location: Otsego County. SSnY designated as agent of the LLC upon whom process may be served and SSnY shall mail process to the LLC at c/o William

Weinert, 337 County Highway 34, Schenevus, nY 12155.

Purpose: any business permitted under law.

6LegalFeb.23

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE OF FOrmATION OF Highway 48 Property LLC.

Art. of Org. filed Sec’y of State (SSnY) 12/15/22. Office location: Otsego Co. SSnY designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served SSnY shall mail process to: The LLC, c/o Bradley Tillbrooks, 2831 Marsala Court, Orlando, FL 32806.

Purpose: any lawful activities.

6LegalFeb.23

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE OF FOrmATION OF BOB’S JOB’S LLC, A Limited Liability Company. Articles of Organization were filed with the new York Secretary

of State on October 7, 2022.

The office of the LLC is to be located in Otsego County.

The Secretary of State has been designated as the agent of the LLC upon whom process against it may be served. The Secretary of State shall mail a copy of any process against the LLC to: Robert nistad, PO Box 817, East Worcester, nY 12064.

The purpose of the LLC is to engage in any lawful act or activity.

6LegalFeb.23

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE OF FOrmATION OF Geoffrey Foster, LLC.

Articles of Org. were filed with the nYS Sec’y State on 01/03/2023.

The office of the LLC is to be located in Otsego County. The nYS Sec’y of State has been designated as agent for service of process against the LLC. nYS Sec’y of State shall mail a copy of any such

process to the LLC at: 383 Pink Street, Cooperstown, nY 13326.

The purpose of the LLC shall be general.

6LegalFeb.16

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE OF FOrmATION OF Johnson Contracting & Trucking LLC.

Filed 5/4/22. Office: Otsego Co. SSnY desig. as agent for process & shall mail to: Po Box 492, Cooperstown, nY 13326. Registered Agent: United States Corporation Agents, Inc., 7014 13th Ave, Ste 202, Bklyn, nY 11228.

Purpose: General. 6LegalFeb.16

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE OF FOrmATION OF A Ny LImITED LIABILITy COmPANy.

name: V&H RAnCH LLC.

Articles of Organization filing date

with Secretary of State (SSnY) was 6 January 2023. Office location: Otsego County. SSnY has been designated as agent of LLC upon whom process against it may be served and SSnY shall mail copy of process to 20 W Main St, Milford, nY 13807. Purpose is to engage in any and all business activities permitted under nYS laws.

6LegalFeb.16

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE OF FOrmATION OF DAnTE’S PIZZERIA, LLC.

Articles of Organization were filed with the nY Secretary of State on 11/28/22. The office of the LLC is to be located in Otsego County. The Secretary of State has been designated as agent of the LLC upon whom process against it may be served. The Secretary of State shall mail a copy of any process against

except to “Ms. Carlin’s immediate family, her attorneys or her accountants provided that this confidentiality provision shall not be construed to prohibit a disclosure required by law.”

Carlin may, however, discuss and respond to questions regarding the agreement with a potential employer and/or search consultant, so long as she makes no statement disparaging of the district, the Board of Education or employees of the district.

Finally, point 13 of the agreement reads, “It is understood and agreed that Theresa Carlin waives and releases any and all claims which she had, may have, or have at the present time, up to the date of this agreement for any claim related to age discrimination or discrimination in violation of … the ADEA [Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967].

Miskell had requested this and other documents as per Freedom of Information Law, to determine why the district had hired a second law firm.

“My interest was sparked initially back in April or May of 2022. It was brought up at a board meeting that a special counsel had been hired by the Board of Education, and I wanted to know what that was about. If taxpayers are paying for a special counsel, we deserve to know why,” Miskell recalled.

Then rumors about a lawsuit begin to circulate.

“I’ve had to FOIL constantly to get information being withheld from the taxpayers. First I received vague information on the board paying over $10,000 on special counsel.

After reviewing Theresa Carlin’s agreement with the board, it’s now clear the two were related,” Miskell continued.

“I FOIL documents once a month now, because it is the

only way to get information.

If I ask questions, I don’t get answers,” Miskell said. Miskell also researched the process of petitioning for a revote on the Schenevus/ Worcester school district merger originally rejected by Schenevus residents on December 1, 2021 by a vote of 509-254. She submitted a petition calling for a revote on December 2.

According to the Schenevus Central School website: “The district has received an order, signed by Commissioner Rosa, setting the date of the merger annexation revote. The revote will take place on February 15, 2023. Please continue to check the website for updates concerning this revote. Also check the Voting Information page on what needs to be done to obtain [an] absentee ballot.”

Carlin’s term at Schenevus was riddled with problems. Stepping into the role of superintendent in 2018, she inherited a financial crisis— the district was facing a deficit of $750,000.00, with no money in savings or reserves. This ultimately prompted the grant-funded study which recommended that Schenevus and Worcester should merge, followed by a contentious lead-up to the Schenevus vote.

In a recent interview, Carlin said the Schenevus Central School District’s annual operating budget is $9 million and confirmed that the $2 million in reserves secured during her administration would not make a difference if the school were to find itself in financial trouble again.

“I was seen as promerger,” Carlin explained, “but I simply promoted what the data showed me to be a good idea.”

No members of the Schenevus Board of Education, or Theresa Carlin, had responded to inquiries as of press time.

the LLC served upon him to: The LLC, 416 1/2 Chestnut St., Oneonta, nY 13820.

The purpose of the LLC is to engage in any lawful act or activity.

6LegalFeb.9

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE OF FOrmATION OF

Optimize Advertise LLC.

Filed 7/21/22. Office: Otsego Co. SSnY desig. as agent for process & shall mail to: 1541 Mckoons Rd, Richfield Springs, nY 13439. Registered Agent: United States Corporation Agents, Inc., 7014 13th Ave Ste 202, Brooklyn, nY 11228.

Purpose: General. 6LegalFeb.2

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE OF FOrmATION OF Dragonfli Properties, LLC Articles of Organization were

filed with the nY Secretary of State on 7/5/22. The office of the LLC is to be located in Otsego County.

The Secretary of State has been designated as agent of the LLC upon whom process against it may be served.

The Secretary of State shall mail a copy of any process against the LLC served upon him to: The LLC, 1826 E. Parkridge Dr., Salt Lake City, UT 84121.

The purpose of the LC is to engage in any lawful act or activity.

6LegalFeb.2

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE OF FOrmATION OF Smol Fish Digital LLC

Arts of Org. filed SSnY 10/17/22, Otsego Co. SSnY design agent for process & shall mail to Zenbusiness Inc. 41 State St #112 Albany, nY 12207 General Purpose 6LegalJan.19

nOtice

NOTICE OF FOrmATION OF Cutting the Cheese LLC.

Filed 11/4/22 Office: Otsego Co. SSnY designated as agent for process & shall mail to: 155 Dorr Edson Rd, Oneonta nY 13280 Purpose: all lawful 6LegalJan.19

LegaL nOtice

NOTICE OF FOrmATION OF ZROWKA’S CREEKSIDE FARMS LLC.

Art of Org. filed with the SSnY on 12/05/2022.

Office: Otsego County. SSnY designated as agent of the LLC upon whom process against it may be served. SSnY shall mail copy of process to the LLC, LEGALCORP SOLUTIOnS 1060 Broadway Suite 100 ALBAnY, nY 12204 Purpose: Any lawful purpose

LegaL

LegaL LegaL

LegaL LegaL LegaL LegaL LegaL LegaL LegaL

ART CLUB 10 a.m. Bring art to share and the materials

make your art with the group. Springfield Library, 129 Co. Rd. 29A, Springfield. 315-858-5802.

SENIOR MEALS 11:30 a.m. Seniors are invited to enjoy a delicious meal. Suggested donation is $3.50 for seniors, $8.60 for guests accompanying a senior. Today, enjoy lemon chicken, oven-roasted potatoes, green beans and peanut butter cookies. Richfield Springs Community Center, 6 Ann Street, Richfield Springs. (607) 547-6454.

SENIOR GAMES 12:302:30 p.m. Seniors are invited to play games with the Otsego County Council of Senior Citizens each Monday and Thursday, including cards, cribbage, puzzles, and more. Held at the Clark Sports Center, Cooperstown. connectionsatcsc@gmail.com

TEEN ZONE 4-6 p.m. Teens aged 12-15 are invited for this after-school program to de-stress, enjoy a nutritious snack and play games with their peers in a safe environment. Held Tuesdays and Thursdays at the Richfield Springs Community Center, 6 Ann Street, Richfield Springs.

BOOK CLUB 4 p.m. The book club comes together to discuss this month’s read, “The Change,” by Kristen Miller. Village Library of Cooperstown. (607) 5478344.

AUDITIONS 5 p.m. Love to sing? Have prior choral experience? The Catskill Choral Society is seeking new members for their 2023 performances. Upcoming dates include a concert of Brahms choral works to be performed April 21 and 23 as well as a collaboration with the Catskill Symphony Orchestra

on famous Hollywood movie scores. Rehearsals are held from 7-9 p.m. Thursday evenings starting 1/26. Auditions are by appointment at the Unitarian Universalist Soceity Chapel, 12 Ford Avenue, Oneonta. (607) 435-7008.

GARDEN CLUB 6:30 p.m. Join the Richfield Springs Garden Club for a presentation on the benefits of adding native plants to the landscape, plant selection for Otsego County and more with Connie Tedesco from The Fernery in Hartwick. Snow date is 1/26. Memorial Room, Richfield Springs Public Library, 102 Main Street, Richfield Springs. (315) 858-0230.

►Friday, Jan. 20

STATE OF THE COUNTY 811 a.m. Join elected officials, business leaders, and many more for informative breakfast featuring presentations on the state of Otsego County, and discussion of legislation and initiatives that may affect local businesses. Tickets, $40/non-member. Presented by Otsego County Chamber of Commerce at Otsego Grille, Morris Hall, SUNY Oneonta. (607) 432-4500 ext. 2.

NATURE GROUP Noon.

Join the Otsego County Conservation Association for a fun day exploring the paths around the Gilbert Lake. This group, geared for homeschooled students but open to everyone, will wander the trails, learn about the trees, identify birds and play nature

games. Please dress for the weather. Meet at Briggs Pavilion, Gilbert Lake State Park, 18 CCC Rd. Laurens. (607) 547-4488.

BLOOD DRIVE Noon to 5 p.m. Save up to three lives with the American Red Cross. Springbrook, 103 County Highway 44, Oneonta. Register at redcrossblood.org

AWARENESS 3-7 p.m. January is Cervical Cancer Awareness Month. Stop by the HPV vaccination site to protect yourself and learn about safeguards. Health insurance not required. Southside Mall, Oneonta. (607) 432-4401.

CABIN FEVER 7 p.m. The Cabin Fever Film Series returns with “Everything Everywhere All At Once,” about Chinese immigrant Evelyn who, while grappling with middle age, discovers she can traverse time and space, and her subsequent adventures. Free admission, donations gratefully accepted. Auditorium, Fenimore Art Museum, Cooperstown. (607) 547-1400.

TEEN ZONE 7-10 p.m. Students in grades 7-12 are invited for a fun night of games and activities each Friday. Games range from air hockey to Xbox games to board games, with arts and crafts, baking, movie nights, and more also offered. Held at The Richfield Springs Community Center, 6 Ann Street, Richfield Springs.

COMEDY 7-10 p.m. Enjoy an evening of standup comedy from the North Country Comedy Tour, featuring laughs, cocktails and a roaring good time. Tickets, $20/person. Foothills Performing Arts and Civic Center, Oneonta.

AUDUBON SOCIETY 7:30 p.m. Join the DelawareOtsego Audubon Society for a presentation, “Puffin and Bird Adventure,” from Board Director Landa Palmer about her journey to Grimsey Island, Iceland, above the arctic

circle, and the puffins and snow buntings she met there. Hosted online by Zoom. Visit facebook.com/DelawareOtsegoAudubonSociety/ for info. ►s

aTurday, Jan. 21

GUN SHOW 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Public is invited for show featuring over 450 tables. Admission, $8/person. Empire State Plaza, Convention Center, Albany. (607) 748-1010. Also held Sunday, 9 - 3. ZUMBA-A-THON 10 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. Dress up as your favorite superhero and join the instructors for a fun Zumba session where all the proceeds go to the American Cancer Society to help stomp out cancer. Tickets, $10/person. Includes giveaways, fun and fitness. Laurens Central School Multi-purpose Room, 55 Main Street, Laurens. Visit facebook.com/TheOtsegoCountyChamber/ GARDENING 10-11 a.m. Join Master Gardener Francine Stayter for a workshop, “Gardening: Choose Your Own Adventure,” to learn to use the resources from the Cornell Cooperative Extension to select the best seeds for our area out of the numerous catalogues. Held online and at the CCE Education Center, 123 Lake Street, Cooperstown. (607) 547-2536.

SNOW TUBING 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. Weather permitting, Glimmerglass State Park will be open for snow tubing on the hill. Admission is $5/person. Snow tubes are provided; there is a warming hut with snacks and hot chocolate available for purchase. Check the Facebook page or call the park office to confirm the slope is open. Glimmerglass State Park, 1527 County Highway 31, Cooperstown. (607) 547-8662.

ART OPEN HOUSE 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. View “Kelley’s Carved Convoy,” a surroundsight of trucks carved 1950s1990s by acclaimed Oneonta

farmer and folk artist Lavern Kelley. Also includes mugs and ornaments by Marcie Schwartzman and wooden Kenyan miniatures (proceeds benefit Mukuru Art Collective). Free admission. The Art Garage, 689 Beaver Meadow Road, Cooperstown. (315) 941-9607.

EXHIBIT TOUR 1 p.m. Learn what goes on at the museum when the doors are closed at this “Behind Closed Doors” tour presented by Curator of Education Mary Alexander. Free, no registration. Begins promptly at 1 p.m. The Arkell Museum, 2 Erie Boulevard, Canajoharie. (518) 673- 2314.

ART PROGRAM 3:30 p.m. Explore the use of watercolors to paint the night sky or a wintery scene. Free to children, tweens and teens, no registration needed. In the classroom, the Arkell Museum, 2 Erie Boulevard, Canajoharie. (518) 673- 2314.

LIFESKILLS 4-6 p.m. Teens are invited to learn to cook with Lynn. Menu posted to FB. Seating limited, reservations required. Presented by The Oneonta Teen Center. 50 Dietz Street, Suite L, Oneonta. (607) 441-3999.

JUNIOR MUSICAL 7 p.m. The CCS Thespians present “Honk!” the 2023 Junior High School musical. Tickets, $10/adult. Auditorium, Cooperstown Central School. (607) 547-8181.

ASTRONOMY 7-8:30 p.m. Join the Otsego County Conservation Association to see what can be seen in the winter sky. This “Naked Eye Astronomy” session will include an introduction to the night sky, the locations of Mars and Jupiter, the winter constellations, and more surprises that are visible this time of year. Free; registration required. Recommended to bring a camp chair to sit on and to dress warmly. Held at Mohican Farm, 7207 State Route 80, Cooperstown. (607) 547-4488.

SNOW TUBING 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. Weather permitting, Glimmerglass State Park will be open for snow tubing on the hill. Admission is $5/person. Snow tubes are provided; there is a warming hut with snacks and hot chocolate available for purchase. Check the Facebook page or call the park office to confirm the slope is open. Glimmerglass State Park, 1527 County Highway 31, Cooperstown. (607) 547-8662.

JUNIOR MUSICAL 2 p.m. The CCS Thespians present “Honk!” the 2023 Junior High School musical. Tickets, $10/adult. Auditorium, Cooperstown Central School. (607) 547-8181.

SUNDAY SPEAKER 3 p.m. The Friends of the Village Library present “Community Voices: Our Immigrant Stories,” in which a panel of local and regional neighbors tell their recent and not-so-recent stories of immigration experiences. Upstairs Ballroom, Village Library of Cooperstown. (607) 547-8344.

WINTER CONCERT 3 p.m. The Little Delaware Youth Ensemble presents their winter concert featuring a program ranging from Mendelssohn to the “Super Mario” theme. Free. Held at The United Ministry of Delhi, 1 Church St., Delhi. (917) 902-9301 or visit ldye.org

►Monday, Jan. 23

DRAGON DATES 5-6:30 p.m. Teens are invited to hop online for a virtual cook-along of the FRN Chili Bowl 2023. Presented by the Family Resource Network of Oneonta. (607) 432-0001 or visit https://www.facebook. com/FamilyRN/

SHARON SPRINGS 7 p.m. Hop online for “The Healing Waters of Sharon Springs, NY,” a presentation on the town’s past as a health retreat of international fame that featured not only beautiful surroundings but also five different types of mineral water to treat the ailments of the day. Space limited, registration required. Presented by the Sharon Springs Historical Society.