Frank Rinn - Technical Tree Inspection by Jon Picker

Technical tree inspection Dipl.-Phys. Frank Rinn, Heidelberg, Germany

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

2 / 148

Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Urban green. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Inspection, assessment, examination, evaluation. Successful trees. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pre-requisites. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Load to trees and other stress factors. . . . . . . . .

. . . . . .

Wood anatomy, tree biology and mechanics.. Wood anatomy. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Decay. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Some typical tree growth symptoms. . . . Tree failure. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

. . . . .

10 11 23 25 31

Technical methods. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Height over diameter ratio. . . . . . . . Drill resistance measurements. . . . . Stress wave tomography. . . . . . . . . Wind load analysis.. . . . . . . . . . . . . Error calculation in tree assessment. Pulling tests and safety calculations.

. . . . . . .

. 41 . 43 . 49 . 87 113 126 139

. . . . . . .

3 3 4 5 6 7

Application examples: expert reports on trees. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 146 Final conclusions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 147

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

3 / 148

Introduction Urban green Urban green has more positive effects than just making cities looking nice. Urban trees positively influence micro-climate, filter dust and air pollution, provide sun and wind shadow. And they have a positive influence on economic value of shopping and housing areas too. Yet, urban trees have to stand a lot of stresses. Nature does not like air pollution and does not need crown cutting. But urban green has to be adapted to boundary conditions of urban life style, including the needs of buildings and traffic. However, the most dangerous stresses to urban trees are affecting their roots. Urban stress factors accelerate typical aging effects of trees, such as decay in stem and roots. Stems can break, branches can be lost or trees fall over. Therefore urban trees have to be inspected regularly in order to identify hazardous trees and to minimize risks.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

4 / 148

Inspection, assessment, examination, evaluation Urban tree inspection is normally done visual - mainly based on knowledge from more than 100 years of forestry and arboricultural research, enriched by modern approaches better understand the body language of trees. Depending on tradition, laws, and standards, in some countries there is a clear line between visual inspection and technical examination of trees. In Germany, for example, all urban trees should be inspected visually (old trees at least one time a year). If there is any doubt about safety, these potentially dangerous trees should be tested technically. To distinguish the different procedures, technical inspection is called ‘examination’. Because evaluation of the same tree can be very different by different experts, insurance companies and judges more and more ask for neutral technical evidence rather than subjective opinions.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

5 / 148

Successful trees Structure, size and functional capabilities of trees have overcome various difficult climatic periods and diverse local conditions throughout the centennials. Thus trees can be called biologically and evolutionary successful creatures of nature. They obviously have developed successful concepts of how to deal with difficult surrounding conditions. They seem to know how to react to external stress factors limiting their possibilities to develop and grow. Otherwise they would have been diminished in the evolutionary process by other plants. And in fact, we find urban trees more than 100 years old even in cities strongly destroyed several times by war. Trees from high altitude mountain areas are other examples for being able to survive unfriendly climate and even severe mechanical damages. The first step of learning how to inspect trees therefore is to understand their concept of growth and of repair mechanisms to compensate internal or external stress factors.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

6 / 148

Pre-requisites Proper technical tree inspection requires deep knowledge about ! wood anatomy and tree biology ! wood mechanics and wood physics ! wind load and other stress factors ! limitations and possibilities of technical methods ! laws and standards. The formal price of an inspection device is mostly less than the correspondingly required investment into education, to learn how to apply the system, how to interpret and evaluate the results.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

7 / 148

Load to trees and other stress factors Loads First of all the tree crown is a load to the stem. Big crowns can weight 20 tons or even more. As long as the stem is vertically upright, it can carry big loads. Lengthwise compression strength of wood is quite high. Theoretically, an oak stem without any defects and 1 meter diameter can carry more than 2.000 tons of vertical load1. However, usually the main load a tree has to carry, is wind load.

Assuming compression strength of grren wood of 20N/mm², cross section area of 3.14*0.5*0.5m² (. 0,8m²)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

8 / 148

Wind load Static load to a single tree

F = 0.5 * A * Cw * v² * ñ

Example: F = 0.5 * 40m² * 0.5 * (30m/s)² * 1.25kg/m³ . 11.000 kgm/s² = 11kN 1.1to

Variable Measure

Depending on

wind speed

Time, height above ground, local stand topology, ...

crown area

Wind direction, foliage, wind speed, temperature, ...

drag coefficient

Tree species, foliage, wind speed, temperature, ...

air density

Temperature, altitude, ...

Cw ñ

Porosity? + Dynamics? + Precision? + Swaying? + Torsion? + Damping? + Errors? => wind load calculation of urban trees contains many uncertainties to be specified!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

9 / 148

Other urban stress factors Although urban climate is often influenced by air pollution, this is not the main stress factor affecting trees. Most urban tree problems are coming from other origins: ! wrong tree architecture from nursery(co-dominant stems and other potential defects) ! wrong treatment / missing preparation in nurseries for urban tree requirements ! wrong planting procedure (small place, un-adequate soil, ...) ! wrong pruning ! root cutting by ground / soil works ! stem damage (by car or work accidents, for example) Most of these stress factors can be re-constructed by tree ring analysis (except for tropics)

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

10 / 148

Wood anatomy, tree biology and mechanics ! We distinguish between three major species groups of similar wood anatomical properties " conifers " ring porous " diffuse porous ! Trees within these groups often react quite similar to external load and stress factors.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

11 / 148

Wood anatomy

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

12 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

13 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

14 / 148

Age trend Decreasing ring width with tree age is not automatically correlated to decreasing vitality of the tree.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

15 / 148

Density trends Conifers, ring porous, diffuse porous

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

16 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

17 / 148

Tree growth genetics, biology, soil, stand, competition, climate, weather

determine the amount of possible wood growth

determines local distribution of growth: where the tree builds up his new wood

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

mechanical stress on the tree surface

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

18 / 148

Compression wood Conifer trees react against static mechanical stress.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

19 / 148

Typical ‘reaction wood’ (General overview, may be different in individual cases depending on conditions)

Load

Static

Dynamic

Tree group Compression wood

Bigger tree rings (low wood quality)

Conifer trees In extreme cases: spiral growth.

Broad leave trees

Tension wood

? Bigger tree rings ?

mature trees: broad rings on compression side

(still subject to research)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

20 / 148

Natural tree design? ! Each structure first breaks on its weakest point (‘notches’). ! Trees try to avoid notches (= points of maximum surface stresses). ! Trees accept higher stresses in roots and branches but not on the trunk. ! Safety factor of tree design is about ~4.5 (Mattheck)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

21 / 148

! Because the stem is the most important part of the connection between roots and crown, the repair growth speed is maximum there. ! The repair growth can be simulated mathematically: it follows the stress line. The higher the mechanical stress (compression or tension), the faster the growth [as long as the tree is able to do so].

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

22 / 148

‘Adaptive growth’ ! The cambium growth request depends on local stress. ! Contact to stiff materials cause compression stress.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

23 / 148

Decay ! Fungal decay is a natural process, necessary for re-cycling wood for new growth! ! Reasons / origins of decay in urban trees: " roots (soil works) " stem base (direct damages) " branches (wind or cutting) ! Different tree species react different to decay due to their possibilities in compartimentalization (Shigo). (Shigo 1985)

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

24 / 148

! Root based fungi often do not affect the stem but totally destroy the mechanic root system, without weakening vitality correspondingly. ! Points to be inspected technically depend on " tree species " fungus " origin of injury " local stand conditions

(Shigo 1985)

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

25 / 148

Some typical tree growth symptoms ! Reactions to decay are mostly reactions to stress. !

The natural shape of tree stems is mostly round or regular (there are some exceptions especially in the tropics).

! Irregular forms mostly are a sign for decay.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

26 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

27 / 148

Elliptical growth deviations from a circle mostly indicate internal decay.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

28 / 148

! The cambium reacts to (internal) decay, as soon as the mechanical stress is significantly higher and if the tree is vital enough to do so. ! As long as the decay only affects parts of the tree, that are not required for stability, there is no visible outside symptom on the tree’s shape. ! Thus trees can be decayed without visual symptoms because of different reasons!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

29 / 148

! If you see a tree with obvious decay but no reaction wood, the reason can be " the tree is not any more vital enough to react and to build compensatory wood (you can check this by looking into the crown and measuring shoot length) or " the decay area is small and not dangerous for stability or " the decay is brown or wet rot in early stages, only affecting bending strength but not density and stiffness (dangerous!). => Technical inspection required!

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

30 / 148

! Such an early stage of brown rot can reduce density and stiffness by 10% and at the same time bending strength by about 90% (Wilcox 1978). ! The cambium can not recognize this defect because it ‘observes’ stiffness. Bending strength can only be observed by breaking the tree or branch until failure. ! Extension of early stages of such decay patterns can only be detected technically. ! If you find brown rot fungi at a tree, be careful evaluating the tree without technical assistance!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

31 / 148

Tree failure Why and when do trees break or fall over? (Mattheck & Bethge 2004)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

32 / 148

Trees are designed to withstand wind until approx. 100km/h:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

33 / 148

Vogel 1996

(Eucalyptus paniculata, Lavers 1983)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

34 / 148

Skatter & Kucera 2000: Data that were originally collected to study systematic asymmetries in the canopies of Scotch pines (Pinus sylvestris) were used as input in previously developed models. These models predict whether a tree will break due to bending loads or torsional loads during critical wind exposure. Data from four pine stands were used in the study—two lowland stands and two mountainous stands. For each of the stands there were large amounts of both categories of trees: those predicted to break due to bending and those predicted to undergo torsional failure. Moreover, there was no significant difference between any of the stands when it came to the distribution of predicted failure modes. These two facts suggest that the risk of bending failure and torsion failure is balanced so that neither is more likely than the other.

The fact that torsion may be as critical as bending is a new finding. (For. Ecol. Manage. 2000. 135:97–103)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

35 / 148

Numerical failure criteria? ! How hollow is a tree allowed to be? ! How many roots can be missing until the tree in un-safe? ! There are some numerical approaches helping us to understand " tree stability " uprooting safety

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

36 / 148

The more hollow a tree is, the higher the risk of bending breakage:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

37 / 148

Statistical approach: natural failures in forests (Mattheck 1993):

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

38 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

39 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

40 / 148

Conclusion ! Trees react to decay " by compensatory growth (adaptive growth) " as long as they are vital enough ! As soon as the residual intact wall is less then 1/3 of the radius " the tree is not automatically hazardous, but " breakage safety of the fully crowned tree drops down " risk should be assessed " and probably load reduced ! Determination of residual intact wall thickness can be complicated, often technical methods are required.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

41 / 148

Technical methods There are many different physical principles that can be used to inspect trees: ! mechanical (most commonly used) " sound / stress waves: knocking, stress wave timing, ultra-sound " drilling / pin-pushing, increment coring, resistance drilling " inclination and elongation (observing under wind-load and/or pulling) ! electrical: 2-point or multipoint impedance (electrical resistance) ! electromagnetic: radar, x-ray, nuclear magnetic resonance, thermography Most popular methods in urban tree care: drill resistance and stress-wave timing.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

42 / 148

Measuring the tree?

! Each measurement is related to errors " Using even simple technical equipment is always related to encounter errors " When giving numerical results, an error evaluation should be included ! The more complex the numerical approach, " the more errors add up " the more difficult to explain the result to the customer

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

43 / 148

Height over diameter ratio ! From forestry, it is well known and accepted, that slenderness is a valid criteria for characterizing storm resistance of dens forest stands. ! It is assumed that trees within stands are of higher risk, as soon as

tree height / trunc diameter > 70

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

44 / 148

For solitary trees, this ratio shall be about 50. Trees with h/d>50 are assumed to be of higher risk for storm breakage of the stem.

(Mattheck 2001)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

45 / 148

(Mattheck 2001)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

46 / 148

Increment coring Often done for tree ring analysis.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

47 / 148

Climate reconstruction is often based on tree ring density analysis by of increment cores

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

48 / 148

using x-ray, optical or other scanning techniques.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

49 / 148

Drill resistance measurements Continuous measurement of penetration resistance of thin needles entering the wood until ~1.5m depth.

Kamm & Voß 1984

Rinn & FEIN 1987

Kipp 1990

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

50 / 148

History and origin of the RESISTOGRAPH® drill-resistance method 1970 Pin-penetration depth ~ wood density (Liechtenstein) 1972 In-sizing of wooden utility poles => needle penetration resistance (Germany) 1973 Resistance drilling by torque-measurement of particle boards (Germany) 1978 Recording soil penetrometer (USA) 1983 Recording motor power as measure of mechanical resistance (Japan) 1984 Spring-loaded recording of needle drill resistance with scratch pin on wax paper 1985 Needle drill resistance by motor power (Germany) 1986 Diploma thesis: tree ring analysis by resistance drilling (RINN, Heidelberg, Germany) 1987 First portable series of drills to inspect trees and timber (Rinn & FEIN, Germany) 1990 Patent on electronic drill resistance measurements (Rinn) and needle geometry 1993 RESISTOGRAPH® as registered trademark (mw. in more than 30 countries, Rinn)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

51 / 148

The ‘real story’ ! To make wooden utility poles more resistant against fungi, a German engineering company started 1972 pushing thin needles into the wood in order to get the chemical preservatives deeper in. Two retiring engineers of that company got the idea as a gift for being applied as a patent (although it was not their personal idea). The patent was later rejected by the German Patent Supreme Court due to older publications describing similar devices (from Japan). In addition, several other experts contributed ideas how to encounter the penetration resistance of needles, pins or borers into wood. ! 1986-88, in my physics diploma thesis at Heidelberg University, I checked if it is possible to obtain information about tree-ring density variations based on the patent application. It did not work in oak due to specific wood anatomical features but in conifers. The profiles clearly revealed tree rings in conifers and showed typical differences between intact and decayed wood in forth and backward drillings. ! All subsequently shown graphs, correlations and statements are valid only for these electronically regulated, electronic and linear recording drill resistance devices!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

52 / 148

Technical basics An electric motor drives a fast rotating needle into wood. The mechanical torque at the needle’s tip is proportional to wood density if the needle’s tip has a specific geometry. The power consumption is proportional to the torque, if recorded electronically (linear axis!).

If these conditions are fulfilled, the measured value can reliably be correlated to material properties (such as wood density)!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

53 / 148

Typical profiles in intact conifer and oak wood:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

54 / 148

In conifers, compression wood can be identified by a broader latewood band:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

55 / 148

Tree rings of diffuse porous species can be clearly visible (Fagus)

but can be invisible as well:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

56 / 148

Poplar:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

57 / 148

Platanus:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

58 / 148

Tilia:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

59 / 148

Tree-ring structure and ring width age-trend determine stem trends of density:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

60 / 148

Typical profile from oak with high density in the center:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

61 / 148

Complete drilling through beech (Fagus) with a nearly constant density profile:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

62 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

63 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

64 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

65 / 148

Tree rings can only be identified in the resistance profile if the needle penetrates the borders perpendicular!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

66 / 148

Defect and decay detection and evaluation in resistance profiles ! Defects are not always related to decay: " included bark between co-dominant stems ! Depending on drilling point, the profile may appear as showing defect but " it can be soil " empty space between roots ! Thus it is important to " first visually check the tree " then evaluate the best position to drill " then drill and cross-check the result with visual symptoms!

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

67 / 148

Included bark

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

68 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

69 / 148

Finding strong decay is mostly easy:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

70 / 148

Decay my be small and missed by drilling.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

71 / 148

Ring shake (fungal decay in one early wood band only), only visible by small depressions:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

72 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

73 / 148

Strong decay is easy to identify but a low profile does not automatically mean ‘hollow’:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

74 / 148

Compensatory growth is not always easy to evaluate (even in conifers):

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

75 / 148

Decay is not always concentric

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

76 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

77 / 148

The transition from intact to decay tells us something about compartimentalization:

Trends of decay expansion can be estimated but, here we found two different types of transition in the same stem disk!

Compartimentalization may work on one spot but not on another one!

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

78 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

79 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

80 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

81 / 148

‘Difficult’ transition from intact to decay in early stages of brown rot and soft rot.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

82 / 148

! A tree without defined residual wall thickness. ! Drilling does not help evaluating safety of such a cross section. ! Many drillings would be required to obtain the real situation.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

83 / 148

Residual wall thickness?

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

84 / 148

Drilling provides information valid for one spot!

Where and how often should we drill?

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

85 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

86 / 148

Decay by drilling? ! Since 1987 I am drilling standing trees. ! Until now we did not find any case where decay started by drilling or extended significantly. ! In most cases, there is a dis-colouration around the drilling hole.

(Mattheck&Weber 2000)

=> ! Resistance drilling is not non-destructive! Therefore, we should drill " only if necessary and only on the optimum spot " and we should extract as much information from the profiles as possible. ! Therefore many people now use stress wave tomography before drilling.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

87 / 148

Stress wave tomography ! ... using chains of electronically independent sensors was developed in the 1990ies in order to make " tree and timber inspection less destructive and " deliver a more descriptive presentation of the internal state of the tree. ! The first publication describing combined stress wave tomography in wood came out in May 1999 (Rinn: international Patent in EU and USA on stress wave and electrical impedance tomography). ! Application is nearly non-destructive but due to physical properties of the method(s) it does primarily not show the internal state of a tree! ! => Understanding wood anatomical and physical properties is one of the basic prerequisites for a proper application of these technical tree inspection methods and for a reliable interpretation and evaluation of the results.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

88 / 148

Basics of stress wave tomography ! First put the sensors around the tree " The distance between and the total number of sensors is free but should reflect the geometry of the cross section. ! Then note their position in a table. ! Select height, location and tree species. ! Connect all the sensors by a cable. ! Knock on each sensor several times. ! That’s it.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

89 / 148

Measurement principle Speed of impulse = length of path / time of flight Stress wave tomographs only measure time of flight. Travel path and speed of the impulse are unknown!

There is no solution for the equation!

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

90 / 148

! The computer program re-constructs the inner situation of the measured cross-section based on " scientific knowledge and " experience (of the manufacturer). ! Thus there are sometimes big differences between the different products!

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

91 / 148

Stress wave tomography is ! using only short impact pulses ! no ultrasound! ! only encounters the travel time of the beginning of the first incoming wave! ! not distinguishing between longitudinal and transverse waves ! strongly depending on wood anatomical influences by different species, such as: " age trend " species specific properties " anisotropy ! thus depending on climate, stand, wheather, season, ...

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

92 / 148

Typical travel paths in wood with defects

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

93 / 148

Example tomograms Intact oak

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

94 / 148

Intact spruce

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

95 / 148

Extended decay in horse chestnut

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

96 / 148

Compartimentalized decay

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

97 / 148

Spatial resolution and precision?

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

98 / 148

No resolution defined in decay parts!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

99 / 148

Colour games? Subjective impression of colour scale influences evaluation!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

100 / 148

Do stress wave tomograms of trees reveal wood condition?

! Generally NO !. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (luckily!)

! Sometimes YES!. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . (helpfully!)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

101 / 148

Example

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

102 / 148

Residual wall thickness from stress wave tomograms? Sometimes YES, often NO!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

103 / 148

Comparison with RESISTOGRAPH® profile Stress-wave tomography of Kapok-tree at HortPark, Singapur Resistograph® drilling at sensor #7.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

104 / 148

Conclusion Stress wave tomography mainly reveals mechanical compactness of the wood in the cross-section. This information is more important for stability evaluation than wood condition because it correlates to moment of inertia (and subsequently strength of the cross section)! Therefore we can calculate the most dangerous wind direction from relative determination of moment of inertia of the cross section!

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

105 / 148

Root analysis by stress waves (in use in expert reports since 2004) ! Finding roots " to prevent damages by constructions " to check for damages by construction works afterwards ! Identifying the tree who is " responsible for damages to footpaths or walls or tubes ! Estimating anchorage weight for stability evaluation.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

106 / 148

Simple application

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

107 / 148

Typical results

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

108 / 148

3 of 16 trees (similar stand conditions but different root distribution)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

109 / 148

Here we had to check to which tree the roots belong that destroy the footpath.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

110 / 148

Building permit? (red=planned building size, green = canopy area of trees)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

111 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

112 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

113 / 148

Wind load analysis ! During the last years some experts are trying " to calculate real wind load to the tree and " to combine pulling tests in order " to calculate tree safety. ! A closer look to the formulas and procedures inhibits " systematic errors " basic restrictions " and potential reliability. ! First we have to evaluate real wind load, then material properties.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

114 / 148

Vertical wind profile

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

115 / 148

Drag coefficient of trees Varies with wind speed.

(Ruck 2008)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

116 / 148

Drag coefficient of trees Varies between species

(Ruck 2008)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

117 / 148

Turbulence around a tree

(Ruck 2008)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

118 / 148

(Ruck 2008)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

119 / 148

(Ruck 2008)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

120 / 148

Stand effect on wind-load (Ruck 2008)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

121 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

122 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

123 / 148

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

124 / 148

Structured thinning at the forest edge helps prohibiting wind breakage.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

125 / 148

Dynamic swaying of crown parts dissipate energy and helps prohibiting failure.

Cutting branches can even increase total wind load although crown mass and wind sail area are reduced!

James 2003

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

126 / 148

Error calculation in tree assessment Errors affect all measurements Tree diameter

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

127 / 148

Tree height

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

128 / 148

Residual intact wall Ît + Îr $ 30 - 50% =>

Î (t/r) >> 50%

be careful evaluating a tree by one measurement only!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

129 / 148

Example measurement of one tree by 15 experts:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

130 / 148

Error calculation and cumulation

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

131 / 148

Each measurement is related to stochastic and systematic errors, an assessment of tree height and diameter too:

ÎS = ÎH + ÎD

=> ÎS = (~±10%) + (~±5%) = ±15%

±15% is the mean error and does not necessarily cover the real value. Mostly, if you regard one measurement, the real value is covered within the interval of the doubled mean percentage error => ÎS . ±30%

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

132 / 148

Concepts of error description

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

133 / 148

Mean precent error (MPE) describes mean percentage deviation of the actual value from the mean value. The corresponding error beams do not necessarily cover the mean for all individual values.

=> x ±MPE may not contain mean

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

134 / 148

x ±2*MPE mostly covers real value => if you make one measurement and you do not know about the expected error, take x ±2*MPE as an easy and correct span!

Example for height/diameter h=25m, d=50cm => h/d = 50 ±30% = 50 ±15 . 35..50.. 65

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

135 / 148

Stress wave tomography of the same cross section: different machines => different results

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

136 / 148

Drill resistance profiles from the same sample: different device versions, different profiles

(M attheck&Bethge 1997)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

137 / 148

Density profiles from x-ray and high-frequency measurements

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

138 / 148

Moment of inertia of cross section: critical influence of shape measurement!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

139 / 148

Pulling tests and safety calculations Wind force Simple

F = 0.5 * A * Cw * v² * ñ

a bit more precise ...

v(x,y)

wind speed

ñ(x,y,T,p) air density n(x,y)

canopy porosity

drag coefficient

tu, gf

turbulence, stand and roughness factors

Wind load at the stem base:

HARDTSTR. 20-22

Windforce * length of lever arm = 0.5 * A * Cw * v² * ñ * L

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

140 / 148

Precision of tree safety calculation by pulling tests?

Variance of bending moment B at stem base ªB = ªA + ªCw + 2* ªv + ªñ + ªL

ªB

$ (±20%) + (±30%) + (±2*30%) + (±5%) + (±10%)

=> ªB >> ±100%

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

141 / 148

Tree strength? Pulling tests determine MOE (modulus of elasticity) by measuring stress and elongation, but we need MOR (modulus of rupture) to assess tree safety. MOR of wood can only be measured directly by bending until failure! Thus many people are looking for non-destructive methods for MOE => MOR correlation. The best wood grading machines achieve r²~0.6 for correlation from MOE to MOR for small size timber without knots and decay. Non-laminar fibres, knots and decay bring r² down to 0.1 or even less (Wilcox 1978). =>

More than 90% of the variance of MOR can not be explained by MOE measurements in real trees with decay and irregular inside and outside shape.

MOE by pulling tests do not allow to evaluate MOR of stems.

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

142 / 148

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

143 / 148

(Niemz 1993)

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

144 / 148

Assuming the simple equation:

Tree safety = Tree strength / Wind load =>

ª Tree safety = ª Tree strength + ª Wind load

ª Calculated static tree safety $ ±200%

For static wind load without taking into account dynamic behaviour and torsion effects! => Estimation error for real dynamic safety will even be much higher!

Every expert claiming more precise values for tree safety has to clearly prove how he achieves this - independent from methods and persuasions!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

145 / 148

I think, tree experts should be honest and clearly point out in reports that the evaluation may be based and/or guided by precise measurements or calculations but at the end can not be precise at all and is influenced by individual subjective decisions - yet still much better than doing nothing and evaluating without objective results! ! Conclusions: " relative assessments of similar trees on similar stands under similar conditions work " absolute determination of wind load, stem strength and safety is nearly impossible.

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

146 / 148

Application examples: expert reports on trees

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

147 / 148

Final conclusions ! A well trained visual tree inspection " is the most important base for proper risk evaluation. ! Technical equipment helps in many cases, " but deep knowledge is required about trees, wood and techniques -

before selecting the appropriate method and device

for application at the tree

for interpretation of the results

and for evaluation of the potential risk.

! As Shigo already said: read, read, read, get educated and trained, and hurry up, because who comes to late ...

ÂŠ DIPL.-PHYS. FRANK RINN

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88

WWW.RINNTECH.COM

2008

TECHNICAL INSPECTION OF TREES

148 / 148

! will face a problem catching the arboricultural train in time ...

Thank you for your attention!

HARDTSTR. 20-22

D - 69126 HEIDELBERG

GERMANY

TEL +49 6221 3143 -87

FAX -88