benefits connection
ISSUE 11 / JANUARY 2011 Also in this issue: t 5IF GVUVSF GPS øFY t 1BZSPMM ZPVS UJNF IBT DPNF t &NQMPZFS 5BML XJUI "WJWB
Insight, strategy and best practice in employee benefits from Asperity
EVOLUTION OR REVOLUTION:
What’s Best for Benefits?
WHY STAYING STILL IS NO LONGER AN OPTION
benefitsconnection
WELCOME
CONTENTS
A STEP CHANGE IN BENEFITS DELIVERY:
THE FUTURE FOR FLEX
The road to flex was paved with good intentions, but itโ s time for a change. #Z (FPSHF 'BSSPX $MJFOU 4FSWJDFT %JSFDUPS GPS "TQFSJUZ &NQMPZFF #FOFG JUT
Do more with less. 5IJT XJMM CF UIF DIBMMFOHF GPS NBOZ CVTJOFTTFT BOE PSHBOJTBUJPOT JO UIF OFYU ZFBS PS UXP BOE NPTU PG UIFTF XJMM MPPL UP UIFJS TVQQMJFST GPS IFMQ 3FEVDFE DPTU JT POF BWFOVF UP EPJOH NPSF GPS MFTT NPSF QSPEVDU PS CFUUFS TFSWJDFT GPS UIF TBNF DPTU JT BOPUIFS 5IF OFFE GPS B QBSUOFSTIJQ CFUXFFO DVTUPNFST BOE TVQQMJFST IBT SBSFMZ CFFO NPSF BDVUF "T XFMM BT IPOJOH UIFJS TVQQMJFS SFMBUJPOTIJQT FNQMPZFST XJMM JODSFBTJOHMZ MPPL UP NPUJWBUF BOE FOHBHF UIFJS XPSLGPSDF BT OFWFS CFGPSF UP IBSOFTT QSPEVDUJWJUZ FBTF XPSLQMBDF JTTVFT BOE TVSWJWF BOE UISJWF JO UPVHI FDPOPNJD UJNFT #FOFรถUT XIJDI BSF SFMFWBOU BOE WBMVFE CZ FNQMPZFFT BSF B LFZ QBSU PG UIF FNQMPZFF FOHBHFNFOU TUSBUFHZ $IPJDF BOE รธFYJCJMJUZ BSF XIBU NBLF CFOFรถUT SFMFWBOU BOE WBMVFE *ODSFBTJOH FNQMPZFFT EJTQPTBCMF JODPNF JO XBZT PUIFS UIBO B QBZ SJTF NFBOT FNQMPZFF EJTDPVOUT SFBMMZ HPPE EFBMT PO HZN NFNCFSTIJQ BOE XFMM QSPNPUFE UBY FรณDJFOU TBMBSZ TBDSJรถDF )PMJEBZ USBEJOH JT IVHFMZ QPQVMBS HJWJOH FNQMPZFFT B CJU NPSF DPOUSPM PWFS UIFJS UJNF BOE QFSTPOBM DPOUSPM JT B SFDPHOJTFE BMMFWJBUPS GPS TUSFTT 5IF NPUJWBUJPOBM QBZPรฒ GSPN B SFXBSE BOE SFDPHOJUJPO TDIFNF JT NBYJNJTFE XJUI 3FBMUJNF UFDIOPMPHZ BOE GBOUBTUJD DIPJDF PG BXBSET
Editorial
2.
The future for flex
3.
Payroll, your time has come
4.
Incarnations of an employee benefits site
6.
Employer Talk with Aviva
8.
Holiday trading: fly with it Open letter to the government
10. 11.
#SJOH BMM PG UIJT UPHFUIFS JO POF IJHIMZ รธFYJCMF BNB[JOHMZ BรฒPSEBCMF TDIFNF BOE ZPV WF HPU B CFOFรถUT SFWPMVUJPO
FLEXIBLE BENEFITS XFSF CPSOF JO UIF NJE T PVU PG UIF OFDFTTJUZ UP UBLF B GSFTI MPPL BU DPSF CFOFรถUT 5IF QBUFSOBMJTUJD JOEVTUSJBMJTUT PG UIF 7JDUPSJBO FSB CVJMU IPNFT QMBDFT PG XPSTIJQ QSPWJEFE SFDSFBUJPO BOE FEVDBUJPO GPS UIF DIJMESFO PG UIFJS XPSLFST BOE MFGU TUVOOJOH MFHBDJFT TVDI BT #PVSOFWJMMF BOE 1PSU 4VOMJHIU :PV XPSLFE GPS ZPVS FNQMPZFS GSPN DSBEMF UP HSBWF $PSF CFOFรถUT TVDI BT รถOBM TBMBSZ QFOTJPO MJGFUJNF NFEJDBM BOE DSJUJDBM JMMOFTT JOTVSBODF DPWFS EFBUI JO TFSWJDF CFOFรถU BOE TP PO XFSF CVJMU PO BO VOXSJUUFO DPOUSBDUVBM BTTVNQUJPO PG FOEVSJOH NVUVBM MPZBMUZ BOE MPOH TFSWJDF CFUXFFO FNQMPZFS BOE FNQMPZFF XIJDI IFMQFE UP NBLF UIF FDPOPNJDT XPSL "T MPZBMUZ CSPLF EPXO BOE FRVBMJUZ PG QSPWJTJPO UPPL SPPU JU CFDBNF DMFBS UIBU DPSF CFOFรถUT XFSF CPUI FYQFOTJWF UP QSPWJEF BOE JSSFMFWBOU UP MBSHF TXBUIFT PG UIF FNQMPZFF QPQVMBUJPO 'MFYJCMF CFOFรถUT XFSF JOUFOEFE UP BEESFTT UIFTF DIBMMFOHFT BMMPXJOH FNQMPZFFT UP DIPPTF BOE CVJME B SFXBSE QBDLBHF UIBU TVJUFE UIFN VTJOH B QSPQPSUJPO PG UIF QBZ QPU &NQMPZFFT CFOFรถUUFE GSPN UIFJS PSHBOJTBUJPO T QVSDIBTJOH QPXFS BU UIF FYQFOTF PG CFBSJOH UIF FDPOPNJD SJTLT BUUBDIJOH UP UIF VOEFSMZJOH CFOFรถUT QSPEVDUT 5IF BEWFOU PG รธFYJCMF CFOFรถUT CSPVHIU B OFX TFU PG DIBMMFOHFT JO SFXBSE NBOBHFNFOU
Over time, โ choiceโ came to mean complexity. Complexity is rarely cheap, and even more rarely is it flexible. Glenn Elliott MD, Asperity Employee Benef its glenn@asperity.co.uk
7JTJU XXX BTQFSJUZ DP VL GPS NPSF JOGPSNBUJPO BOE GSFF GVMMZ GVODUJPOBM EFNP BDDFTT UP 3FXBSE (BUFXBZ "MM JOGPSNBUJPO DPSSFDU BU UIF UJNF PG XSJUJOH BOE TVCKFDU UP DIBOHF XJUIPVU OPUJDF "TQFSJUZ &NQMPZFF #FOFG JUT -UE 8FTUCPVSOF (SPWF -POEPO 8 35 5FM XXX BTQFSJUZ DP VL FNBJM CFOFG JUT!BTQFSJUZ DP VL ยช "TQFSJUZ &NQMPZFF #FOFG JUT -UE
2.
5P B DPOTJEFSBCMF FYUFOU UIF CJH CBOH BOOVBM FMFDUJPO DZDMFT PG รธFY CSFE BOE FODPVSBHFE UIJT B OP EPVCU VOJOUFOEFE DPOTFRVFODF PG B WFSZ SFBM EFTJSF PO UIF QBSU PG FNQMPZFST UP NBLF CFOFรถUT SFMFWBOU BOE B HPPE JOWFTUNFOU "T SFHVMBUJPO JODSFBTFE DPOTVNFS NBSLFUT FWPMWFE BOE FNQMPZNFOU QBUUFSOT DIBOHFE CPUI QSPWJEFST PG รธFYJCMF CFOFรถUT TPMVUJPOT BOE TVQQMJFST PG UIF QSPEVDUT PO B QPSUGPMJP XPVME CF ESJWFO UP FOHJOFFS OFX QSPEVDUT OFX MJGF FWFOUT BOE VQEBUFE UFSNT BOE DPOEJUJPOT
5IFTF EFWFMPQNFOUT IBWF NBEF รธFY TDIFNFT QSPHSFTTJWFMZ NPSF VOXJFMEZ NFBOJOH B ESBX PO UIF FNQMPZFS T SFTPVSDFT &NQMPZFFT TUSVHHMFE UP VOEFSTUBOE UIF TNBMM QSJOU BOE XFJHIFE UIJT BHBJOTU UIF OPX NVDI XJEFS DIPJDF BWBJMBCMF UP UIFN BT B DPOTVNFS GPS UIF TUBQMF QSPEVDUT JO B รธFY TDIFNF 4PNF PSHBOJTBUJPOT GPVOE UIF FNQMPZFS T QPTJUJPO BT BO JMM EFรถOFE JOUFSNFEJBSZ CFUXFFO FNQMPZFF BOE QSPEVDU QSPWJEFS VODPNGPSUBCMF WHAT NEXT? &NQMPZFST TUBSUJOH GSPN B DMFBO TIFFU OPX IBWF B SFBM BMUFSOBUJWF UP B AGVMM รธFY TDIFNF *G ZPV BSF MPPLJOH UP GVOEBNFOUBMMZ SFTUSVDUVSF DPSF CFOFรถUT o BT PQQPTFE UP CSJOH B XJEF SBOHF PG DIPJDF BOE DPOUSPM UP FNQMPZFFT o ZPV XJMM OFFE UP DPOTJEFS GVMM รธFY " DMFBS VOEFSTUBOEJOH PG UIF TIPSU BOE MPOH UFSN PCKFDUJWFT PG UIF SFXBSE TUSBUFHZ XJMM IFMQ UP QJOQPJOU UIJT &NQMPZFST OFFE UP CF XBSZ IPXFWFS PG VOXJUUJOHMZ QSPDVSJOH AGVMM รธFY UP TPMWF B QSPCMFN CFUUFS BEESFTTFE CZ B NVDI MFTT DPTUMZ NVDI NPSF รธFYJCMF TPMVUJPO 'MFY JT GBS GSPN UIF POMZ BOE JT GSFRVFOUMZ OPU UIF CFTU BOTXFS UP XBOUJOH iCFUUFS CFOFรถUTw PS iFWFSZUIJOH JO POF QMBDF BOE B XFCTJUFw
'VMM รธFY XBT B HPPE JEFB UIBU IBT OPX CFDPNF รธBXFE OFX รธFY IBT FWPMWFE GSPN UIJT รธBXFE DPODFQU UP CFDPNF UIF TIJOJOH MJHIU PG UIF SFXBSE BSNPVSZ &NQMPZFST EP OPU OFFE B USBEJUJPOBM GVMM รธFY TDIFNF UP PรฒFS B GBOUBTUJD SBOHF PG CFOFรถUT *U JT B TJNQMF BT UIBU 3FDFJWFE XJTEPN IBT CFFO UIBU BDDFTT UP NVMUJQMF CFOFรถUT JO POF QMBDF TVDI BT FNQMPZFF EJTDPVOUT DIJMEDBSF WPVDIFST DZDMF UP XPSL NFEJDBM BOE EFOUBM DBTIQMBOT EJTDPVOUFE TIPQQJOH WPVDIFST BOE DBSET UPUBM SFXBSE TUBUFNFOUT IPMJEBZ USBEJOH HZN NFNCFSTIJQ BOE UIF SFTU NFBOT รธFY #VU JU EPFTO U 5IF BENJOJTUSBUJPO PG B รธFY QPU OFFET GVMM รธFY FWFSZUIJOH FMTF JT CFUUFS EFBMU XJUI PO B GBOUBTUJD รธFYJCMF WPMVOUBSZ CFOFรถUT QMBUGPSN 5IJT XBZ FNQMPZFST DBO QSPWJEF UIF iรธFYJCMF CFOFรถUTw UIBU BO FNQMPZFF XBOUT GSPN B TJOHMF XFCTJUF XJUI FBTZ DPOรถHVSBUJPO BOE SFBM DIPJDF *O FTTFODF AGVMM รธFY JT MJLFMZ UP SFWFSU UP JUT PSJHJOBM QVSQPTF PG QFSNJUUJOH FNQMPZFFT UP NBLF DPSF CFOFรถUT NPSF SFMFWBOU UISPVHI QBZSPMM BEKVTUNFOUT BOE B รธFY QPU *U JT OPU UIF TFOTJCMF EFMJWFSZ WFIJDMF GPS PUIFS CFOFรถUT
4P XIBU FMTF JT PVU UIFSF 'JSTU DPOTJEFS EJUDIJOH UIF JEFB UIBU ZPVS SFXBSE TDIFNF OFFET CSPLFSFE QSPEVDUT UIFTF BSF GSFRVFOUMZ OBSSPXMZ GPDVTFE BOE MJNJU SBUIFS UIBO FYUFOE DIPJDF GPS FNQMPZFFT
If your flex product portfolio offers travel insurance from company A, what about the employees who, for reasons of their own, want to get their travel insurance from companies B-Z?
5IFO JG ZPV BSF OPU QSPWJEJOH B รธFY QPU GPS FNQMPZFFT UP TQFOE PO UIF SBOHF PG CFOFรถUT ZPV OFFE B TUSBJHIUGPSXBSE BDDFTTJCMF TPMVUJPO GPS NBYJNJTJOH FNQMPZFF BOE TP FNQMPZFS WBMVF BOE UIBU JT OPU B USBEJUJPOBM GVMM รธFY QMBUGPSN *U T OFX รธFY
3.
PAYROLL, YOUR TIME HAS COME Widening your benefits portfolio for (almost) nothing. #Z )FMFO $SBJL 0QFSBUJPOT %JSFDUPS GPS "TQFSJUZ &NQMPZFF #FOFG JUT
STUDENT LOANS BUUBDINFOUT PG FBSOJOHT 4.1 441 PWFSUJNF 1 T 1 %T UIF MJTU PG UIJOHT UIBU QBZSPMM EFQBSUNFOUT IBWF UP EFBM XJUI JT MPOH DPNQMJDBUFE BOE PGUFO OPU BQQSFDJBUFE OFBSMZ BT NVDI BT JU TIPVME CF
CF EPOF XJUIPVU DPTU UP UIF FNQMPZFS 5IFSF JT PG DPVSTF B DPTU JO FOBCMJOH FNQMPZFFT UP BDDFTT CFOFรถUT CZ QBZSPMM XIJDI JT UIF UJNF PG UIF QBZSPMM EFQBSUNFOU BOE BTTPDJBUFE BENJOJTUSBUJPO
Payroll is one of those jobs that is barely on the radar until something goes not quite right
1BZSPMM JT POF PG UIPTF KPCT UIBU JT CBSFMZ PO UIF SBEBS VOUJM TPNFUIJOH HPFT OPU RVJUF SJHIU 8IZ UIFO XPVME BO FNQMPZFS DIPPTF UP BEE UIJOHT UIBU EPO U have UP CF EPOF UP UIF MJTU
5IJT JT NPTUMZ IJEEFO JO HFOFSBM PWFSIFBE CVU JU JT SFBM FWFO UIPVHI UIF FNQMPZFS JT OPU NBLJOH BO JEFOUJรถBCMF ADBTI QBZNFOU GPS JU 4P UIF CFOFรถU UP UIF FNQMPZFF OFFET UP BU MFBTU NBUDI BOE JEFBMMZ FYDFFE UIF IJEEFO DPTU UP UIF FNQMPZFS
FNQMPZFF FOHBHFNFOU JT WBMVFE BOE XIFSF QBZSPMM JT SFDPHOJTFE GPS UIF WJUBM SPMF JU QMBZT JO PSHBOJTBUJPOBM IBSNPOZ BOE FรณDJFODZ BOE UIFSFGPSF TFFT JUTFMG BT LFZ UP EFMJWFSJOH FNQMPZFF TFSWJDFT OPU KVTU BT B IBSE EPOF CZ DPH JO BO VOBQQSFDJBUJWF XIFFM
5IF BEEJUJPOBM USBOTBDUJPOT GPS QBZSPMM XJMM CF NPSF QBMBUBCMF JO PSHBOJTBUJPOT XIFSF
4P XIBU TPSU PG CFOFรถUT DBO QBZSPMM IFMQ XJUI BOE XIZ TIPVME UIFZ
*O HFOFSBM NPTU FNQMPZFST BOE UP CF GBJS NPTU QBZSPMM EFQBSUNFOUT UIPVHI UIFSF BSF TPNF EJTIPOPVSBCMF FYDFQUJPOT XBOU UP NBYJNJTF FNQMPZFFT JODPNF XIFSF UIJT DBO
BENEFIT
RATIONALE
SAVING
RISKS
CHILDCARE
.PTU FNQMPZFST SFDPHOJTF UIF WBMVF $$7 CSJOH UP UIF EJWFSTJUZ BOE GBNJMZ GSJFOEMZ BHFOEB BOE EP PรฒFS $$7 GPS FNQMPZFFT
&MJHJCMF FNQMPZFFT DBO TBWF PWFS b B ZFBS BOE FNQMPZFST TBWF /* BT XFMM 8JUI UIF GPSUIDPNJOH UBY DIBOHFT UIF OFFE UP HFU IJHIFS SBUF UBYQBZFST TJHOFE VQ TPPO JT QSFTTJOH
#FJOH B OPO DBTI CFOFรถU $$7T OFFE UP CF QBJE XIJMF B XPNBO JT PO NBUFSOJUZ MFBWF XJUI B OE PS TVCTFRVFOU CBCZ 3JTL NPEFMMJOH XJMM JMMVTUSBUF UIF FรฒFDU XIJDI TIPVME CF NPSF UIBO PรฒTFU CZ UIF TBWJOHT JO FNQMPZFS T /*
CYCLE TO WORK
4VTUBJOBCJMJUZ )FBMUI BOE 8FMMCFJOH $BSCPO BXBSF 8JUI UIF SFDFOU DMBSJรถDBUJPOT GSPN ).3$ PO VOEFS T BOE UIF NJOJNVN XBHF NBOZ FNQMPZFST IBWF MJGUFE UIFJS JOGPSNBM FNCBSHPFT PO $U8 BOE UIFJS TDIFNFT BSF SJEJOH IJHI BHBJO
&NQMPZFFT TBWF UBY BOE /* FNQMPZFST TBWF UIF /*
&NQMPZFST OFFE UP EFDJEF VQGSPOU PO IPX UP EFBM XJUI UIF WBMVF PG UIF DZDMF BU UIF FOE PG UIF IJSF QFSJPE *U T B RVFTUJPO PG DIPPTJOH UIF SJHIU USFBUNFOU GPS ZPVS PSHBOJTBUJPO $BTFT PG FNQMPZFFT EFGBVMUJOH CFDBVTF UIFZ MFBWF FNQMPZNFOU BSF WFSZ WFSZ SBSF BOE FNQMPZFST EPO U FOE VQ HFUUJOH TUVDL XJUI MPUT PG CJLFT UIFZ EPO U XBOU
GIVE AS YOU EARN
*U XPVME CF DIVSMJTI OPU UP
(":& NBLFT JU WFSZ FBTZ GPS FNQMPZFFT UP AHJGU BJE UIFJS DIBSJUBCMF EPOBUJPO NBLJOH JU XPSUI NPSF UP UIF SFDJQJFOU
GYMFLEX
)FBMUI BOE 8FMMCFJOH .BLJOH LFFQJOH รถU NPSF BรฒPSEBCMF IFMQT FNQMPZFFT EFWFMPQ HPPE MPOH UFSN รถUOFTT IBCJUT
&OBCMFT FNQMPZFFT UP CFOFรถU GSPN B EJTDPVOUFE BOOVBM HZN NFNCFSTIJQ CVU QBZ GPS JU NPOUIMZ TBWJOH TJHOJรถDBOU TVNT PO UIF TUBOEBSE GFFT
DISCOUNTED GIFT VOUCHERS
&NQMPZFFT DBO TBWF PO WPVDIFST GPS +PIO -FXJT BOE 8BJUSPTF JG UIFZ NBLF B NPOUI DPNNJUNFOU UP QVSDIBTF UIFTF WJB QBZSPMM *U T UIF POMZ XBZ GPS FNQMPZFFT UP CVZ +- BU B EJTDPVOU
" QFSDFOUBHF PG UIF GBDF WBMVF PG UIF WPVDIFST " UZQJDBM +- 8BJUSPTF TIPQQFS XPVME TBWF b b B ZFBS
HOLIDAY TRADING
'MFYJCMF XPSLJOH "CTFODF NBOBHFNFOU
&NQMPZFFT XIP CVZ IPMJEBZ HFU QBJE MFTT TBWJOH UIF FNQMPZFS NPOFZ
*G UIF FNQMPZFF MFBWFT UIF PVUTUBOEJOH CBMBODF OFFET UP CF SFDPWFSFE GSPN OFU QBZ
5IJT HJWFT B HPPE รธBWPVS PG IPX BO BNFOBCMF BQQSPBDI GSPN QBZSPMM DBO TJHOJรถDBOUMZ XJEFO UIF SBOHF PG CFOFG JUT BO FNQMPZFS DBO NBLF BWBJMBCMF 5IF SJTLT BSF WFSZ NBOBHFBCMF PODF UIFZ BSF VOEFSTUPPE BOE UIF SFXBSE JT HSFBU 1BZSPMM ZPVS UJNF IBT DPNF
4.
5.
AUGUST 2007
EVOLUTION AT A GLANCE:
INCARNATIONS OF AN EMPLOYEE BENEFITS SITE
REWARD GATEWAY 2 )BMG B ZFBS MBUFS BOE UIF TJUF JT SFMBVODIFE XJUI CJHHFS CFUUFS BOE NPSF PรฒFST BOE NPSF FOHBHJOH HSBQIJDT BOE QSPNPUJPOT CBTFE PO UIF CFTU PรฒFST SBUIFS UIBO SFUBJMFS QBJE QSPNPUJPOT %JTDPVOUFE HJGU WPVDIFST XFSF BEEFE BT B QSPEVDU BMMPXJOH TBWJOHT PO IJHI TUSFFU TIPQQJOH 5IJT FOBCMFE MFTT JOUFSOFU TBWWZ FNQMPZFFT BOE UIPTF XJUI MJNJUFE JOUFSOFU BDDFTT UP SFBQ UIF CFOFรถUT PG UIFJS EJTDPVOU TJUF CPPTUJOH FOHBHFNFOU BDSPTT BMM DMJFOU TDIFNFT
#Z ,JTIBO )JDLNBO )FBE PG 5FDIOJDBM %FWFMPQNFOU GPS "TQFSJUZ &NQMPZFF #FOFG JUT SEPTEMBER 2008
REWARD GATEWAY 3
You donโ t get to be market leader by standing still. Over the last 4 years, Asperity has re-invented its Reward Gateway employee benefits platform no less than 6 times - making it clear that an employee benefits site with genuine discounts and savings for the employee was in demand. With three total re-builds from the ground up, customers are buying a highly refined product and one that includes a great deal of knowledge and experience. With Reward Gateway 4, announced last month, Asperity has done it again. AUGUST 2006
PILOT: BBC CLUB CASHBACK 'PVS ZFBST BHP B OFX CSFFE PG FNQMPZFF EJTDPVOU TDIFNFT XBT CPSO 5IF รถSTU FNQMPZFS GVOEFE SBUIFS UIBO SFUBJMFS GVOEFE FNQMPZFF EJTDPVOUT XFCTJUF XBT BO JOTUBOU IJU XJUI UIF ##$ FNQMPZFFT NBLJOH JU DMFBS UIBU BO FNQMPZFF CFOFรถUT XJUI HFOVJOF EJTDPVOUT BOE TBWJOHT GPS UIF FNQMPZFF XBT JO EFNBOE
" GVMM SFCVJME PG UIF TJUF XBT DPNQMFUFE B ZFBS MBUFS 5IJT XBT UIF รถSTU WFSTJPO PG 3FXBSE (BUFXBZ UIBU FOBCMFE UIF JOUFHSBUJPO PG PUIFS WPMVOUBSZ CFOFรถUT F H DIJMEDBSF WPVDIFST DZDMF UP XPSL JOUP UIF TDIFNF XFCTJUF XIJDI XPVME SFTVMU JO IJHIFS FNQMPZFF FOHBHFNFOU UIF BCJMJUZ UP DSFBUF B ACFOFรถUT CSBOE BOE B POF TUPQ TIPQ GPS FNQMPZFFT UP BDDFTT UIFJS CFOFรถUT 5IJT XBT BOPUIFS JOEVTUSZ รถSTU BOE 3FXBSE (BUFXBZ SFNBJOT UIF POMZ GVMMZ JOUFHSBUFE WPMVOUBSZ CFOFรถUT QMBUGPSN XJUI JOUFHSBUFE $BTICBDL BOE JOUFHSBUFE SFMPBEBCMF DBSET PO UIF NBSLFU UPEBZ
SEPTEMBER 2009
REWARD GATEWAY 3.8 "O VQHSBEF SBUIFS UIBO B SFCVJME B ZFBS MBUFS HBWF FNQMPZFFT UIF BCJMJUZ UP GVMMZ DVTUPNJTF UIFJS IPNFQBHF TP UIFZ DPVME TFF UIF DBUFHPSJFT BOE PรฒFST NPTU SFMFWBOU UP UIFN BT TPPO BT UIFZ MPHHFE JO (PPHMF .BQT XBT JOUSPEVDFE UP IFMQ VTFST รถOE JO TUPSF PรฒFST FBTJMZ BOE UIFSFGPSF GVSUIFS FOHBHF UIF PรตJOF BVEJFODF 5IFTF UXP JOOPWBUJPOT DBVTFE FNQMPZFF FOHBHFNFOU UP KVNQ CZ BDSPTT DMJFOU TDIFNFT
NOVEMBER 2010 JANUARY 2007
REWARD GATEWAY 1.0 5IF รถSTU NVMUJ TJUF WFSTJPO PG 3FXBSE (BUFXBZ MBVODIFE BT B DMFBO FBTZ UP VTF TJUF XJUI UIF CFODINBSL SFUBJMFS PรฒFST CSPVHIU UP UIF GPSF &NQMPZFS CSBOEJOH DPVME CF FOBCMFE GPS UIF รถSTU UJNF 3FUBJMFS PรฒFST XFSF JO UIF GPSN PG $BTICBDL BOE EJTDPVOUT POMZ CVU FWFO TP UIF TJUF XBT IFBE BOE TIPVMEFST BCPWF UIF SFTU PG UIF NBSLFU XJUI IJHIFS $BTICBDL SBUFT UIBOLT UP UIF SFUBJMFS GVOEFE NPEFM
6.
REWARD GATEWAY 4 5IF CJHHFTU EFWFMPQNFOU QSPKFDU "TQFSJUZ IBT FWFS VOEFSUBLFO 3FXBSE (BUFXBZ SFEFรถOFT รธFYJCMF CFOFรถUT GPS FWFSZPOF 5IF UFBN TUBSUFE XJUI UIF EJTDPVOU QSPEVDU BOE BEEFE BMM PG UIF GFBUVSFT QFPQMF IBE BTLFE GPS 'SPN QSJDF DPNQBSJTPO UP QSPEVDU TFBSDI J1IPOF BQQT BOE TVQFS GBTU $BTICBDL JU T FYBDUMZ XIBU ZPV TIPVME FYQFDU GSPN UIF MFBEFS JO FNQMPZFS CFOFรถUT " MPU PG IBSE XPSL FOBCMFE UIF UFBN UP MFWFSBHF b NJMMJPO PG SFUBJM TQFOE NPSF UIBO BOZ PUIFS QSPWJEFS JO UIF NBSLFU UP NBLF B TZTUFN UIBU SFWPMWFT BSPVOE UIF FNQMPZFF SBUIFS UIBO UIF SFUBJMFS 8JUI GVMMZ JOUFHSBUFE TBMBSZ TBDSJรถDF UPUBM SFXBSE TUBUFNFOUT IPMJEBZ USBEJOH BOE FWFO B GVMMZ JOUFHSBUFE SFXBSE BOE SFDPHOJUJPO QMBUGPSN 3FXBSE (BUFXBZ SFBMMZ JT รธFYJCMF CFOFรถUT GPS FWFSZPOF
7.
EMPLOYER TALK
key facts Scheme launch date UI .BZ
Employees
Current engagement
Avivaโ s Reward Consultant, Sarah Moore, talks to Asperityโ s Client Service Director, George Farrow, about the reasoning behind adding an employee discount scheme to Avivaโ s benefits portfolio in 2010, and the ingredients of a successful benefits communication programme. George: What made you decide to go with an employee benefits service at Aviva? Sarah: 8F SFCSBOEFE UP "WJWB MBTU ZFBS BOE POF PG UIF NFTTBHFT UIBU XBT JOUFHSBM UP VT XBT JOEJWJEVBM SFDPHOJUJPO 8F E CFFO SFWJTJUJOH PVS SFXBSE QBDLBHF PWFS UIF MBTU GFX ZFBST 8F E JNQMFNFOUFE รธFYJCMF CFOFรถUT JO BOE UIF FNQMPZFF EJTDPVOUT XBT UIF MBTU QJFDF PG UIF KJHTBX QV[[MF JU T XIBU UIF FNQMPZFFT XFSF DBMMJOH PVU GPS UP USZ BOE TBWF NPOFZ PO UIJOHT UIFZ BMSFBEZ CVZ XIFSF UIFZ EJEO U IBWF UP NBLF NPOUIMZ DPNNJUNFOU UISPVHI B TBMBSZ TBDSJรถDF TDIFNF 5IFZ DPVME KVTU VTF JU BT BOE XIFO UIFZ XBOUFE UP
G: What role does effective account management on the part of your benefits provider play in helping you achieve your companyโ s benefits objectives? S: 4JODF UIF TZTUFN T CFFO JO QMBDF PVS BDDPVOU NBOBHFS IBT CFFO WFSZ SFTQPOTJWF UP SFRVFTUT BOE SFRVJSFNFOUT UIBU BSF CFJOH TFOU UISPVHI GSPN CPUI PVS CFOFรถUT UFBN BOE PVS FNQMPZFFT XIP VTF UIF TDIFNF 'PS FYBNQMF XF XFSF SFDFOUMZ MPPLJOH BU EPJOH TPNFUIJOH GPS OBUJPOBM FOFSHZ TBWJOH XFFL TP XF BSSBOHFE UP IBWF TQFDJรถD QSPWJEFST QSPNPUFE PS BEEFE PO UIFSF 5IJT MJOLFE UP PVS DPSQPSBUF TPDJBM SFTQPOTJCJMJUZ PCKFDUJWFT TP NBLJOH UIFTF DIBOHFT UP UIF TJUF BMMPXFE VT UP ESJWF UXP BHFOEBT BU UIF TBNF UJNF G: Is there anything about your employee discounts service that you have been pleasantly surprised by?
G: What persuaded you to choose your current discounts provider, Asperity? S: 8F TBX B OVNCFS PG QSPWJEFST EVSJOH UIF TFMFDUJPO QSPDFTT BOE JU DBNF CBDL EPXO UP UIF QPJOU PG JOEJWJEVBM SFDPHOJUJPO "TQFSJUZ XFSF BCMF UP QSPWJEF VT XJUI B TZTUFN UIBU XBT WFSZ JOUVJUJWF XIFO ZPV MPHHFE PO ZPV DPVME DVTUPNJTF UIF IPNFQBHF FYBDUMZ IPX ZPV XBOUFE XIJDI NBEF JU BCTPMVUFMZ JEFBM 4P QFPQMF DPVME CSJOH UIF PรฒFST BOE DBUFHPSJFT UIFZ XBOUFE UP UIF GSPOU PG UIFJS IPNFQBHF TP UIFZ EJEO U IBWF UP TJGU UISPVHI MPUT PG PรฒFST UIBU XFSFO U SFMFWBOU UP UIFN "OE IPQFGVMMZ JU XPVME NBYJNJTF UIF BNPVOU PG UJNF UIBU FNQMPZFFT XPVME TQFOE VTJOH UIF XFCTJUF
8.
S: 5IF UFMFQIPOF IFMQEFTL JU BCTPMVUFMZ JT UIFSF JO UIF IPVST UIBU ZPV TBZ JU JT 5IFSF T BMXBZT FNBJM SFTQPOTFT XIFO UIF IFMQEFTL JT DMPTFE CVU JU T PQFO VOUJM P DMPDL JO UIF FWFOJOH XIJDI GPS NPTU QFPQMF JT SFBMMZ DPOWFOJFOU 5IFZ SF BMXBZT SFBMMZ IFMQGVM BOE ZPV BMXBZT HFU BO BOTXFS 8IJDI BHBJO KVTU DPNFT CBDL UP UIF BEWPDBUJPO PG UIF TFSWJDF UIBU XF E OFFE GSPN PVS FNQMPZFFT UP VTF JU
Asperity were able to provide us with a system that was very intuitive when you logged on; you could customise the homepage exactly how you wanted, which made it absolutely ideal.
G: Do you think there are some facets of the service that appeal to certain types of employee that arenโ t internet enabled? S: :FT UIF TIPQQJOH WPVDIFST BSF POF PG UIF CJH TQFOEFST JO UIF "WJWB TDIFNF $FSUBJOMZ UIF 4BJOTCVSZT BOE "TEB PรฒFST QVMM PVS FNQMPZFFT JO BOE DBUDI UIFJS FZF * UIJOL XIBU PVS FNQMPZFFT MJLF BCPVU JU JT UIFSF T OP VQGSPOU DPNNJUNFOU ZPV TQFOE XIBU ZPV XBOU PO B SFMPBEBCMF DBSE XIFO ZPV XBOU JU JU T FBTZ UP VTF ZPV PSEFS ZPVS SFMPBEBCMF DBSE CFGPSF JO UIF NPSOJOH BOE JU T XJUI ZPV UIF OFYU EBZ :PV DBO UPQ JU VQ BT BOE XIFO ZPV XBOU TP ZPV OFFE UP CF B CJU NPSF QMBOOFE QFSIBQT CVU UP TBWF PO ZPVS TIPQQJOH BMM ZFBS SPVOE UIFO * UIJOL JU T B TNBMM TBDSJรถDF BOE * UIJOL POF UIBU PVS FNQMPZFFT BSF UBLJOH GVMM BEWBOUBHF PG
Certainly the Sainsburyโ s and Asda offers pull our employees in and catch the eye G: Presumably that kind of regular shopping is something youโ d want to encourage rather than the ad hoc transactions - so that you can keep the service in peopleโ s minds all the time? S: "CTPMVUFMZ * UIJOL UIBU T XIFSF B HPPE DPNNVOJDBUJPOT QSPHSBNNF DPNFT JO 8F QSPNPUF UIF CJH CSBOET BMM ZFBS SPVOE UIBU XF LOPX IBWF UIF MPOH UFSN CJH EJTDPVOUT 4P UIFO JG TPNFPOF T QVMMFE JO CZ "TEB PS 4BJOTCVSZ T UIFO UIFZ SF HPJOH UP CF VTJOH UIF TDIFNF SFHVMBSMZ BOE UIFZ NJHIU QJDL VQ TPNF PG UIF NPSF BE IPD PรฒFST BMPOH UIF XBZ
G: Are there any other methods of communication youโ ve found to be effective to get employees onto the discount site? S: 8F BMTP SFBMMZ SFMZ PO XPSE PG NPVUI GPS UIF TDIFNF T TVDDFTT "U "WJWB XF UFOE UP CF B CJU MJLF B GBNJMZ BU FBDI TJUF TP JG UIFSF T BO "TEB KVTU PWFS UIF SPBE BT TPPO BT POF FNQMPZFF LOPXT UIFZ DBO HFU B EJTDPVOU UIFSF UIF XPSE XJMM TQSFBE BOE UIFJS DPMMFBHVFT XJMM CF MPHHJOH PO UP HFU UIFJS SFMPBEBCMF DBSET JO OP UJNF G: So do you actually hunt out benefits champions to try and get them to promote the offers? S: 8IFO XF รถSTU JNQMFNFOUFE UIF TDIFNF XF HBWF PVS DPOTVMUBUJWF GPSVN BDDFTT UP JU CFGPSF JU MBVODIFE GVMMZ /PSNBMMZ UIFZ SF FNCBSHPFE UP UBML BSPVOE DFSUBJO UIJOHT CVU XJUI UIJT POF XF BDUVBMMZ XBOUFE UIFN UP UBML BCPVU UIFJS FYQFSJFODFT PG VTJOH JU TP UIBU UIFZ DPVME CFDPNF BEWPDBUFT PG UIF TZTUFN BOE TUBSU UP DSFBUF TPNF FYDJUFNFOU BOE CV[[ BSPVOE JU CFGPSF JU IJU 8F BMTP VTFE SPBETIPXT UP QSPNPUF .Z "WJWB &YUSBT BOE DFSUBJO PUIFS BTQFDUT PG PVS CFOFรถUT QBDLBHF BMM BDSPTT UIF DPVOUSZ GSPN 1FSUI SJHIU EPXO UP 4PVUIBNQUPO TP PVS QFPQMF DPVME DPNF BMPOH รถOE PVU NPSF BCPVU XIBU UIFJS FNQMPZFF EJTDPVOUT TDIFNF JOWPMWFT BOE IPX UP VTF JU G: What do you think is going to come next as far as benefits is concerned? S: * UIJOL GPS VT BT * TBJE UIF FNQMPZFF EJTDPVOUT XBT UIF รถOBM QJFDF UP PVS SFXBSE QBDLBHF /PX XF SF MPPLJOH BU SFGSFTIJOH PVS NFTTBHJOH BSPVOE UPUBM SFXBSE TFMMJOH PVS XIPMF CFOFรถUT QBDLBHF BT B UPUBM FMFNFOU UP FNQMPZFFT TP UIBU UIFZ VOEFSTUBOE BMM UIF CFOFรถUT PG DPNJOH UP XPSL GPS "WJWB
Watch this video interview and more on Asperityโ s You Tube Channel at: www.youtube.com/AsperityEmployeeBens
9.
OPEN LETTER TO THE GOVERNMENT
HOLIDAY TRADING:
FLY WITH IT #Z -J[[JF 5JOMFZ &NQMPZFF "CPVU 5PXO
'SPN )FMFO $SBJL "TQFSJUZ T 0QFSBUJPOT %JSFDUPS BOE )3 QSPGFTTJPOBM GPS ZFBST
The writer, Richard Bach, was a firm believer in choice. โ Allow yourself to live as you choose,โ he counselled, creating an eponymous seagull hero that decided to fly faster and higher than anyone else in his feathery family.
MJLF CVZJOH BOE TFMMJOH BOOVBM MFBWF BT BO FNQMPZFF CFOFรถU IBT NPWFE JOUP UIF NBJOTUSFBN 0SJHJOBMMZ UBLFO VQ CZ DPSQPSBUF CJH IJUUFST MJLF 1X$ JU T CFFO BEPQUFE CZ DPNQBOJFT BT WBSJFE BT 0SBOHF #BSSBUU )PNFT BOE /BUJPOXJEF ,1.( AFODPVSBHFT UIF CVTJOFTT UP CF DSFBUJWF JO PรฒFSJOH รธFYJCMF XPSLJOH BOE BMMPXT FNQMPZFFT UP CVZ CBDL B IFGUZ GPVS XFFLT BOOVBM MFBWF
$IPJDF JT PS DFSUBJOMZ TIPVME CF IJHI PO UIF BHFOEB XIFO EFDJEJOH PO BO FNQMPZFF CFOFรถUT TDIFNF &NQMPZFFT DBO DPOUSJCVUF BT NVDI BT UIFZ MJLF UP UIFJS QFOTJPOT UIFZ DBO TQFOE UIFJS EJTDPVOUT BMNPTU BOZXIFSF UIFZ DBO FWFO DIPPTF XIJDI HZN UIFZ XPSL PVU BU 4P XIZ DBO U UIFZ DIPPTF IPX NVDI BOOVBM MFBWF UP UBLF
5IJT JT IPX JU XPSLT BO FNQMPZFF DBO POMZ TFMM MFBWF BT MPOH BT UIFZ LFFQ UP UIF TUBUVUPSZ NJOJNVN XIJDI BU UIF NPNFOU JT EBZT QMVT QVCMJD IPMJEBZT *G BO FNQMPZFF TFMMT รถWF EBZT XIJDI JT UIF NBYJNVN NPTU FNQMPZFST PรฒFS BOE UIFJS TBMBSZ XPSLT PVU BU b QFS EBZ UIFJS BOOVBM QBZ JT SFEVDFE CZ b BOE TNPPUIFE PVU PWFS B ZFBS UP TQSFBE UIF DPTU
*O GBDU NPSF BOE NPSF DBO 0ODF UIF QSFTFSWF PG QVCMJD TFDUPS PSHBOJTBUJPOT DPVODJMT BNCVMBODF TFSWJDFT /)4 USVTUT BOE UIF
*G JU TPVOET TFOTJCMF UIBU T CFDBVTF JU JT #VU XIZ BSF XF POMZ TFFJOH JU OPX /FFEMFTT UP TBZ NVDI IBT DIBOHFE JO UIF MBTU UXP ZFBST
5IJT OFX CFOFรถU JT BO BEEJUJPOBM UPPM GPS FNQMPZFST UP BWPJE ESBTUJD NFBTVSFT MJLF QBZ DVUT BOE FOGPSDFE MFBWF CZ NBLJOH NVDI OFFEFE TBWJOHT PO QBZSPMM BOE /BUJPOBM *OTVSBODF DPOUSJCVUJPOT JU XBT XJEFMZ SFQPSUFE UIBU JO POF RVBSUFS PG UIF TUSPOH PรณDF TVQQMZ รถSN "DDP #SBOET NBEF B QBZSPMM TBWJOH PG PWFS b *O UVSO FNQMPZFFT IBWF JODSFBTFE รธFYJCJMJUZ BOE DPOUSPM PWFS UIFJS XPSL MJGF CBMBODF 5IFJS CVZCBDL DBO FWFO BCTPSC VOQMBOOFE UJNF Pรฒ GPS EPNFTUJD SFTQPOTJCJMJUJFT GPS FYBNQMF "OE JU EPFTO U IBWF UP CF DPNQMJDBUFE UJNF DPOTVNJOH PS FYQFOTJWF UP JNQMFNFOU "T BO FNQMPZFS ZPV EPO U FWFO OFFE B GVMM รธFY CFOFรถUT TDIFNF #VZJOH BOE TFMMJOH BOOVBM MFBWF XJMM CFDPNF QBSU PG "TQFSJUZ T 3FXBSE (BUFXBZ GSPN UIF 4QSJOH 4P B GFX FYUSB EBZT TQPUUJOH BDSPCBUJD TFBHVMMT PO UIF TPVUI DPBTU JT OPUIJOH &WFSZPOF T รธZJOH IJHI
Dear Coalition * IBWF B CBDLHSPVOE JO PQFSBUJPOBM )3 BOE OPX XPSL GPS B WFSZ TVDDFTTGVM DPNQBOZ 8F TUBSUFE JO UZQJDBM FOUSFQSFOFVSJBM GBTIJPO PO UIF CBDL PG B DSFEJU DBSE OP BWBJMBCMF CBOL รถOBODF BOE B MPU PG IBSE XPSL BGUFS IPVST CFGPSF XF HPU UP UIF QPJOU PG SFBMJTJOH XF IBE B TFSJPVT CVTJOFTT 8F SF BO FNQMPZFF CFOFรถUT DPNQBOZ TP XF UBML UP B MPU PG FNQMPZFST PG BMM TJ[FT BOE JO EJWFSTF JOEVTUSJFT QVCMJD QSJWBUF BOE OPU GPS QSPรถU 8F EJSFDUMZ FNQMPZ QFPQMF MPUT JO KPCT UIBU NBOZ MBSHFS PSHBOJTBUJPOT PรฒTIPSF PS PVUTPVSDF 8F SF QSPรถUBCMF TUJMM XPSL SFBMMZ IBSE BOE BSF DPNNJUUFE UP UIF JOOPWBUJPO BOE EFTJHO PG PVS QSPEVDU 5IBU T NZ DSFEFOUJBMT GPS TVHHFTUJOH TNBMM CVU WBMVBCMF OP DPTU UIJOHT UIF HPWFSONFOU DPVME EP UP IFMQ UIF XPSLJOH XPSME BMPOH :PV WF TBJE B MPU BCPVU SFEVDJOH CVTJOFTT SFE UBQF TP JG ZPV SF MPPLJOH GPS B QMBDF UP TUBSU * IPQF UIJT IFMQT
1
-FU QBSFOUT DIPPTF UIFJS DIJMEDBSF QSPWJEFS :PV NJHIU UIJOL ZPV BMSFBEZ EP UIJT XJUI UBY FรณDJFOU DIJMEDBSF WPVDIFST CVU UP RVBMJGZ GPS UIF UBY SFMJFG UIF DIJMEDBSF QSPWJEFS NVTU CSPBEMZ CF SFHJTUFSFE XJUI 0GTUFE 4P GPS QBSFOUT XIP VTF B OVSTFSZ PS SFHJTUFSFE DIJMENJOEFS UIBU T รถOF CVU B XPSLJOH QBSFOU DBO U OPNJOBUF B SFMBUJWF OPU FWFO UIF DIJME T PUIFS QBSFOU BT UIFJS DBSFS )PX CBSNZ JT UIBU 4P SFNPWF UIF UBY CSFBL GSPN IJHIFS SBUF UBYQBZFST DPNQMFUFMZ OPU KVTU SFEVDF JU BT QFS UIF DVSSFOU QSPQPTBMT BOE FYUFOE UIF TDIFNF UP BOZ EFTJHOBUFE DBSFS GPS CBTJD SBUF UBYQBZFST .VTU CF KVTU BCPVU DPTU OFVUSBM JO UBY UFSNT BOE XPVME IBWF SFBM CFOFรถUT JO PUIFS BSFBT GBS NPSF VTFGVM UIBO FYUFOEFE NBUFSOJUZ QBZ
2
4IBSF SFTQPOTJCJMJUZ GPS UIF %%" 5IF %JTBCJMJUZ %JTDSJNJOBUJPO "DU JT B GBS SFBDIJOH QJFDF PG MFHJTMBUJPO BOE NBZCF TPNF PG JUT DPOTFRVFODFT XFSF OPU GPSFTFFO 'PS FNQMPZFST UIF XPSEJOH JT CBEMZ ESBGUFE BOE TVCTFRVFOU BNFOENFOUT IBWFO U IFMQFE NBLJOH JU IBSE UP VOEFSTUBOE BOE FBTZ UP CF GSJHIUFOFE *G UIF "DU JOTJTUFE BO FNQMPZFF XIP DPOTJEFSFE UIFNTFMWFT UP CF EJTBCMFE XJUIJO UIF NFBOJOH PG UIF "DU IBE UP UFMM UIF FNQMPZFS UIF OBUVSF PG UIF EJTBCJMJUZ
10.
BOE BOZ SFBTPOBCMF BEKVTUNFOUT BOE JG * WF MPTU ZPV IFSF ZPV CFHJO UP TFF IPX USJDLZ UIF %%" JT GPS FNQMPZFST UIFO FWFSZPOF XPVME IBWF B CFUUFS JEFB PG IPX UP QSPDFFE "U UIF NPNFOU UIF MBX QMBDFT EVUJFT PO FNQMPZFST XIP APVHIU SFBTPOBCMZ UP IBWF LOPXO *TO U JU SFBTPOBCMF KVTU UP FYQFDU BO FNQMPZFF UP UFMM ZPV XIBU UIF EJTBCJMJUZ JT BOE XIBU ZPV DBO EP UP IFMQ
3
-JHIUFO VQ PO MPOH TFSWJDF BXBSET ZFBST TFSWJDF b JO WPVDIFST UBY GSFF )PX BCPVU FYUFOEJOH JU EPXO UP ZFBST BOE b PS ZFBST BOE b 'PS NBOZ FNQMPZFST JU XPVME CF SFBMMZ OJDF UP SFXBSE NFEJVN MFOHUI TFSWJDF XJUIPVU 1 %T PS 14"T 5IFSF XPVMEO U CF NVDI JG BOZ MPTT PG UBY SFWFOVF CFDBVTF ).3$ T UJNF XJMM CF GSFFE VQ CZ OPU IBWJOH UP QSPDFTT SFUVSOT GSPN UIPTF FNQMPZFST UIBU BMSFBEZ LJDL JO MPOH TFSWJDF BXBSET FBSMJFS 4P MPPTFO UIF MJNJU KVTU B MJUUMF
4
%FรถOF AUSJWJBM *O UFSNT PG UBYJOH B CFOFรถU JO LJOE ).3$ UFBTFT FNQMPZFST BOE FNQMPZFFT XJUI UIF OPUJPO UIBU TPNF CFOFรถUT NBZ CF TP USJWJBM BT OPU UP CF XPSUIZ PG NFOUJPO PO B 1 % &NQMPZFS QSPWJEFE UFB BOE DPรฒFF TFFNT UP CF POF BOE QSFTVNBCMZ UIF PEE CJTDVJU BT XFMM .VDI UJNF BOE BOHTU JT FYQFOEFE CZ FNQMPZFST USZJOH UP XPSL PVU JG B CFOFรถU JT AUSJWJBM BOE NBOZ PG UIFTF DPOTVMU UIFJS UBY PรณDF XJUI UIF SFTVMUBOU XBTUF PG SFTPVSDFT UIFSF )BWFO U UBY QPMJDZ NBLFST HPU CFUUFS UIJOHT UP EP UIBO QPMJDF B GFX RVJE B ZFBS "OE DBO UIF BNPVOU JU DPTUT UP DPOTJEFS BOE SVMF PO UIFTF DBTFT QPTTJCMZ CF KVTUJรถFE CZ UIF UBY SFWFOVF CFDBVTF GSFRVFOUMZ UIFSF XJMM CF OPOF SBJTFE BT B SFTVMU ).3$ TIPVME TUPQ CFJOH DPZ BOE EFรถOF AUSJWJBM -FU NF IFMQ PVU * XPVME TVHHFTU UIBU AUSJWJBM NFBOT VQ UP b B ZFBS QFS FNQMPZFF QFS CFOFรถU BOE ZPV DBO IBWF B NBYJNVN PG DMFBSMZ JEFOUJรถFE 5IFZ BSFO U DVNVMBUJWF TP ZPV DBO U IBWF b PO POF CFOFรถU
5
CFJOH UIF OFX OBOOZ TUBUF 4VDDFTTJWF NJOJTUFST GSPN NVMUJQMF EFQBSUNFOUT XBOU VT UP NBOBHF TUSFTT GBDJMJUBUF DBSJOH HFU QFPQMF รถU BOE UIF SFTU .PTU PG UIJT NBOZ FNQMPZFST EP BOZXBZ BOE TPNF PG VT SFTFOU UIF JNQMJDBUJPO UIBU XF EPO U EP FOPVHI #VU XPSL MJGF CBMBODF TIPVMEO U CF BMM BCPVU QBSFOUT PS XPNFO "T KVTU POF JEFB XIBU BCPVU FODPVSBHJOH FNQMPZFST UP HJWF FNQMPZFFT UJNF Pรฒ UP HJWF CMPPE BOE JG ZPV DPVME PWFSIBVM UIF XBJUJOH UJNFT BU EPOBUJPO QPJOUT UIBU XPVME CF BO FYDFMMFOU UIJOH CZ BMMPXJOH B b UBY GSFF WPVDIFS SFXBSE 5IF 6, JNQPSUT CMPPE TP JODSFBTJOH EPOBUJPOT NVTU TBWF NPOFZ BOE JU T B HSFBU XBZ GPS UIF FNQMPZFS UP DPOUSJCVUF UP UIF $43 BHFOEB BU NJOJNBM DPTU 5IFSF BSF MPUT NPSF BSFBT JO XIJDI B NPSF JNBHJOBUJWF JODMVTJWF BOE DPTU OFVUSBM BQQSPBDI UP XPSLJOH MJGFTUZMFT DPVME CF NPSF SFMFWBOU UP NBOZ NPSF FNQMPZFFT UIBO BU QSFTFOU 5IBU T B TUBSUFS PO MPX SJTL IJHI SFXBSE FNQMPZNFOU NBUUFST *G ZPV XBOU JEFBT GPS QPMJDZ * E CF IBQQZ UP IFMQ :PVST GBJUIGVMMZ )FMFO $SBJL
#SPBEFO ZPVS IPSJ[POT BCPVU XIBU รธFYJCMF XPSLJOH BOE XPSL MJGF CBMBODF NFBOT &NQMPZFST BSF QVTIFE JO UP
11.