Tips for a Successful Evaluation

BY LANCE CAIN ATPE Managing Attorney

Employee evaluations occur throughout the school year via walkthroughs and classroom observations. But the spring semester is when the evaluation process really intensifies. Teacher evaluations are compiled and finalized into summative annual appraisals, and other employees typically receive end-of-year evaluations during this time. Our website atpe.org contains detailed information regarding evaluations, but the following is practical advice on what to expect and how to deal with unforeseen evaluation results.

Be Prepared

Reviewing your district’s evaluation policy is a good way to prepare. Many districts use the Texas Teacher Evaluation and Support System (T-TESS), but districts can use their own system as well. The T-TESS generally only applies to teachers, so non-teachers will likely be evaluated differently.

Good communication is a key component in preparing for any evaluation. The T-TESS takes it a step further by requiring collaboration between the teacher and appraiser in goal setting and professional development, as well as requiring a pre- and post-evaluation conference. Those evaluated under the T-TESS should take advantage of these opportunities to discuss shared goals and learn your appraiser’s expectations. The pre-conference can be especially important in discussing the upcoming lesson and gauging what your appraiser is looking for.

That is not always easy. Administrators can be busy or hard to pin down, and this can come off as being uninterested or even rude. But do your best to follow up with them and have a professional discussion about wanting to succeed at your job. Hopefully, finding common ground with your appraiser will reflect positively on your results.

The same goes for employees not evaluated with the T-TESS. It may not always be feasible or necessary to have a pre-conference, but that makes it even more crucial to keep lines of communication open with your appraiser throughout the year. Evaluations should be based on what your appraiser knows about your performance, so let them know about the positive contributions you make. This is not to suggest daily updates. But if your appraiser is familiar with your good work, you are less likely to be surprised with a negative evaluation.

Don’t Overreact

So what happens if you disagree with the results?

It is always difficult for anyone to read negative criticism of their work, especially if you feel it is unfair. But it can be helpful not to overreact and instead take a few hours or perhaps a day to reflect.

Although evaluations are based on objective metrics, they are also based in part on your appraiser’s opinion of your performance. So all may not be lost.

One practical option is discussing the evaluation with your appraiser. It is entirely possible they may have missed aspects of your lesson or aren’t fully aware of all your contributions. Teachers can use the T-TESS post-conference as an opportunity to discuss the results. Otherwise, you may need to schedule a meeting.

Bring supporting data and remain professional as you make your case. Not taking the evaluation personally can help you remain objective. The T-TESS—in particular—is a system that stresses continuous growth. Therefore, many appraisers are cautious not to initially award scores that would be hard to improve on.

Hopefully, a conversation with your appraiser will allow you to find common ground where you can feel comfortable with the final results. If not, there are several approaches for you to consider.

continued on page 28

There are more than a thousand school districts in Texas and each one has success stories. Regional Roundup highlights some of the achievements happening in our public schools. When something special happens in your school district, let us know! Send news to

Gulf of M