Infiniti of Norwood ��

from August 2021 Northeast Edition

Classifieds ��

Liberty Mutual Holding Company Inc., State Automobile Mutual Insurance Company and State Auto Financial Corporation announced July 12 they have signed a definitive agreement pursuant to which Liberty Mutual would acquire State Auto Group, a super-regional insurance holding company headquartered in Columbus, OH. State Auto mutual members will become mutual members of Liberty Mutual and Liberty Mutual will acquire all of the publicly held shares of common stock of State Auto Financial for $52 per share in cash.

The acquisition will significantly expand Liberty Mutual’s position as an industry leader for personal lines and small commercial insurance. Liberty Mutual today distributes its Safeco Insurance personal auto, homeowners and specialty products, and Liberty Mutual small business insurance. The deal is expected to close in 2022.

Source: Liberty Mutual Insurance ing board’s decision to deny RAV’s request to operate its auto body shop as a continuation of a nonconforming use on Doyle’s property.

Doyle, who had purchased his borough property in the early 1980s, operated Joseph J. Doyle Machine Tool Sales, Inc., a heavy equipment business, on his property since that time, and had been grandfathered to use the property that way even though zoning had changed over the years to the point where the business was no longer an approved use at that location.

A timeline of events provided by the court show RAV began leasing land across from Doyle’s property in 2014, but eventually desired additional space because of business expansion, and wanted to secure a lease on Doyle’s land to use his property for the auto business.

The auto repair shop was not a permitted use on Doyle’s property so RAV sought a determination from the local zoning hearing board that its business was a lawful continuation of the grandfathered machine sales business, according to the July 15 Commonwealth Court opinion.

Public hearings were held in Hatboro on the matter in December 2018 and January 2019, the record shows.

The zoning board ultimately determined the auto repair business was not a continuation of an existing nonconforming use of the property housing the machine sales business. It also ruled RAV had not met the burden needed to obtain a variance to operate the business at the property.

RAV filed an appeal in state court, but a Montgomery County judge sided with the zoning board.

RAV then appealed to Commonwealth Court, arguing the zoning board abused its discretion in determining the proposed use of operating an auto repair shop was not a continuation of Doyle’s existing nonconforming use to operate his machine sales business.

Last week, the middle-tier appeals court said neither Doyle, who has since passed away, nor RAV cited any case law to support their assertion a machine sales shop is a “sufficiently similar use to an automobile repair shop use to permit a continuation of a nonconforming use.”

“Although auto repairs and machine sales uses are contained in a broader category of uses, here automotive and allied sales and services, they remain different uses, as Applicant’s [RAV’s] counsel admitted,” the Commonwealth Court panel wrote.

The panel also found no error in the zoning board’s conclusion that RAV failed to prove its case for a variance.

Your leading source for NORTHEASTERN Collision Repair News!

northeastern.autobodynews.com