Reports

CIC Committee Looking at How Estimates End Up on Vehicle History Reports

The Collision Industry Conference (CIC) Data Access, Privacy and Security Committee in April continued its ongoing discussion related to auto body shop estimates resulting in entries on vehicle history reports.

One key point discussed at the CIC held in Oklahoma City: is the VIN being too widely shared within the industry?

“The underlying piece for us is there’s no vehicle build data” included in the VIN, committee co-chair Dan Risley said. “A lot of people assume if you have a VIN number, you probably have build data, but that is not the case.”

Pete Tagliapietra of DataTouch shared a slide showing his view of which entities in the industry actually need access to the VIN during the repair and claims process, noting “the list is not that long.” A company doing vehicle diagnostics, for example, needs the VIN in order to obtain the needed vehicle build data, he said.

“However, if I’m a dealer and I’m selling parts, I only need the last eight of the VIN,” Tagliapietra said. “What’s really important is the industry getting to the point of controlling the VIN, making sure it’s protected and information isn’t shared where it shouldn’t be shared.”

Aaron Schulenburg of the Society of Collision Repair Specialists agreed, noting one of the shops that raised this issue nearly faced litigation from a customer who assumed the shop had shared information with a vehicle history reporting company.

“He stopped that from happening, because he stopped putting the VINs into repair plans,” Schulenburg said. “He’d put it in, decode the vehicle, pull it out and not have it in there. But that’s not practical.”

Sharing the VIN as part of getting parts pricing during the estimating process is one of several theories on how merely writing an estimate on a vehicle can result in an “incident” entry on a vehicle history report; the dealers getting that information could have agreements to share that data with CARFAX or

Shop Showcase others. Tagliapietra said another comwith Ed Attanasio mon way to capture estimate data is if there is a data pump running on a shop’s computer system, extracting data for a third party. “Data pumps have become proSocial Media for Shops lific,” Tagliapietra said. “It’s gotten out of hand, from my point of view, with Ed Attanasio because the data has become so valuable. Most shops probably have a data pump, or more likely multiple data pumps, that are sucking the repair line information and personally SEMA Show Goes On identifiable information off of every estimate they write.” with Ed Attanasio Pete Tagliapietra of DataTouch said many At past CIC meetings, CCC Intelligent Solutions has said it shops may be unaware of data pumps running does not share data with CARFAX. Media and Publicity for Shops on their shop’s computer system, extracting data for a third party During April’s meeting in Oklahoma City, Jack Rozint of Mitchell International delivered a similar with Ed Attanasio message. Rozint shared the relatively

Shop Strategies

with Stacey Phillips

Body Shops Giving Back

with Stacey Phillips

The Best for Much Less.

Tips for Busy Body Shops2X Free Daily Deliveries to Northern California and Reno, Nevada We Offer Very Competitive Pricing and Discounts Professional, Friendly and Efficient Wholesale Parts Staff 2XFreeDailyDeliveriestoNorthernCalifo

with Stacey Phillips

Purchasing Nissan OEM parts has never been easier and more cost effective. Our new factory-backed program allows us to compete with aftermarket pricing on thousands of collision parts. It’s a huge benefit to your customers to offer OEM parts at My SEMAFuture Nissan aftermarket prices! with Stacey Phillipsof Roseville 600 Automall Dr. Roseville, CA 95661-3022

916-677-5251

Shop Strategies916-786-0743 24 hr Fax

Parts Hours: Mon – Sat 7:30 am – 6 pm wholesale@futurenissan.com Parts.FutureNissan.com

NISSAN GENUINE SERVICE AND PARTS Order Parts Online at: www.futurenissanparts.com

with Victoria Antonelli Driving What’s Good Your Trusted Audi Dealer Since 1969

• Large Inventory and Quick Access to 200,000+ Audi Genuine Parts • We Offer Monday-Friday Delivery to Vallejo-Redding-Reno-Fresno and Turlock • Dedicated Staff of Professionally Trained Audi Wholesale Parts Specialists Ready to Help You

Niello Audi

Phone: 916-480-2851 Fax: 916.483.1963 Hours: Mon.-Sat. 8am-5pm audi.parts@niello.com www.audi.niello.com 2350 Auburn Blvd. Sacramento, CA 95821

short list of companies that receive access to a VIN through his company’s system during the estimating process. He said no VIN data is shared outside of Mitchell Cloud Estimating unless the user enables third-party integrations or EMS/ BMS outputs, which a user can shut off at any time.

“If you use our estimating system in a standard configuration, as most of our users use it, without enabling any of those third-party integrations, we don’t send the data anywhere,” Rozint said. “It’s been brought to my attention there may be other information providers that, in the course of writing an estimate, bounce the VIN off a number of dealerships to get pricing information, and that just writing an estimate in another system may actually share the VIN with multiple parties that you may not even be aware of.

“But that does not happen with Mitchell Cloud Estimating,” Rozint said. “If just the act of writing an estimate is causing CARFAX to get the data, I’m guessing the estimate wasn’t done in Mitchell. Now we do allow our customers to export BMS and EMS [data files] to whomever they choose. They can do that without Mitchell’s involvement. We allow our customers control of our data as they see fit for their business. So there’s things that can happen outside of Mitchell’s control, but that’s in the control of the user.”

Trent Tinsley, who co-chairs the CIC committee, said the committee has been having ongoing discussions with several vehicle history reporting companies for months, inviting them to speak, and hopes to have that happen at CIC in July.

“What we want to aim for is: can a shop explain to a customer, if they were asked, where their data goes,” Tinsley said. “That is what as a committee we are trying to work toward.”

“It’s a huge issue for consumers, and we don’t know how to explain to them how [a vehicle history company] got that information,” New Mexico shop owner Scott Benavidez told the committee.

Benavidez owns a collision repair shop and a vehicle inspection company, two separate businesses, using the same estimating system in both.

For the inspection business, his company writes a “reconstructive estimate,” showing what work had previously been done on a used vehicle based on the company’s inspection. At some point he discovered even that reconstructive estimate, with no parts ordered, would trigger a new incident report on a vehicle history report for a vehicle already repaired.

Benavidez’s concern is shared widely, based on some polling at the CIC meeting.

The committee in 2020 developed a set of five Golden Rules for those entities accessing and using shop estimate data; they can be viewed on the “work products” page on the CIC website, www.ciclink. com. The goal was that by getting companies to agree to abide by the rules, the industry could deter data being used without a shop’s awareness and permission.

At CIC in Oklahoma City, attendees were asked if they feel those Golden Rules are being adhered to by the majority of their trading partners; 68% said no. Among just collision repairers at the meeting, 88% said they did not believe they were in control of their company’s data and how it’s being shared.

Schulenburg said he was surprised by that, because while he understands shops’ frustration, he thinks the data-sharing problems may be caused by a relatively few bad players.

“As skeptical as I am about the exchange of data, I believe most companies are doing the right thing,” Schulenburg said. “I think most companies doing the right thing are getting a negative implication because there are some companies choosing to make data aggregation an ancillary business model to their core function.

“Everybody in this industry should be concerned about that,” Schulenburg said. “It’s impacting the view of the collision repair facility, and impacting the view that collision repairers have of products [in the industry] that exchange data. We should all be really vigilant so we can trust one another with that exchange.”

TRUST FORD PARTS

CERTIFIED PARTS WHOLESALING DEALERS

Caruso Ford Lincoln

LONG BEACH

800-353-7224 562-492-9452 Fax

www.carusoford.com parts@carusofordlincoln.com

Colley Ford

GLENDORA Wholesale Parts

800-253-3807 909-592-8577 Fax

E-mail your orders parts@colleyford.com

SO. CALIFORNIA Fairview Ford

SAN BERNARDINO Wholesale Direct

909-386-0220 909-889-1741 Fax

Galpin Ford

VAN NUYS

818-778-2005 818-778-2090 Fax Penske Ford

LA MESA

800-648-7431 619-668-7765

NO. CALIFORNIA Sunnyvale Ford Lincoln Mercury

SUNNYVALE

408-738-1530 408-738-3125 Fax

www.fordautodirect.com.com

NEVADA Friendly Ford

LAS VEGAS

702-877-6546 702-870-6280 Fax

WASHINGTON Bowen Scarff Ford Lincoln

KENT

800-942-0712 253-852-3340 253-813-5050 Fax

M-F 8-5:30 parts@bowenscarff.com