benjamin bromberg gaber harvard gsd master in architecture I candidate
data
interactive webmap | ‘aphrodite and the rabbis’ marjorie lehman | spring 2015
http://www.benjaminbg.com/wheninrome.html
interactive webmap | ‘aphrodite and the rabbis’ marjorie lehman | spring 2015
http://www.benjaminbg.com/wheninrome.html
static map | ‘aphrodite and the rabbis’ burton visotzky | published september 2016
http://a.co/7EIgOYC
educational attainment static map | datascapes leah meisterlin | fall 2014
educational attainment interactive webmap | datascapes leah meisterlin | fall 2014
http://bit.ly/bbgeducationalattainment
multiple datasets | introduction to gis leah meisterlin | fall 2014
zooming through time static map | datascapes leah meisterlin | fall 2014
zooming through time webmap | datascapes leah meisterlin | fall 2014
http://cool.barnard.edu/datascapes/zooming-through-time/
static map representing multiple data types | introduction to gis leah meisterlin | fall 2014
static map from analog data | introduction to gis leah meisterlin | fall 2014
static map combining large datasets | introduction to gis leah meisterlin | fall 2014
static map incorporating spatial analytics | introduction to gis leah meisterlin | fall 2014
multiple datasets | introduction to gis leah meisterlin | fall 2014
final project | introduction to gis leah meisterlin | fall 2014 Summary of Key Findings
ANALYZING THE 1996
• Quality of Life generally improved in Georgia between 1990 to 2010 • Quality of Life index increased more between 2000 and 2010 than 1990 and 2000, but no patterns or conclusive findings • No spatial-based patterns or conclusive findings • Index requires more detailed data and further testing to determine utility as a tool • Larger outside patterns and trends may be affecting quality of life in the areas studied • Lack of pattern may be due to the Atlanta Games’ use of preexisting venues and their locations
OLYMPIC GAMES AND
ITS EFFECT ON THE
QUALITY OF LIFE
Photo 3: The Olympic Flag10
Quality of Life Index Quality of Life Index = ( Age Index x Income Index x Education Index ) (1/3) Median Age
Age Index = Income Index =
Education Index =
34.34 ( LN(Median Household Income) - LN(107721) ) ( LN(107721) - LN(100) )
√((
# of people in category x years 13.2
13 ) ( 20.6 )
Primary Data Sources • US Census Bureau 1990 Decennial Census Data • US Census Bureau 2000 Decennial Census Data • US Census Bureau 2010 American Community Survey 5-Year Estimate Data • US Census Bureau 2010 Census boundaries • UN Human Development Index
.951 34.34 = Georgia Median Age
Attainment Category / Years for Index Less than high school / 11
(Dropout (16) Enrollment age (5))
High school / 13 Less than BA / 15 BA / 17 More than BA / 20
Methodology
Benjamin Bromberg Gaber
GIS Methods & Case Studies Final Project December 2013
107721 = Median income of country with the highest median household income 100 = Median income of country with the lowest median household income 13 = Expected educational attainment for Georgia (high school diploma) 13.2 = Expected educational attainment for country with the lowest expected attainment 20.6 = Expected educational attainment for country with the highest expected attainment .951 = Given
Photo 4: The Olympic Torch11
For the purposes of this project, the most essential conclusions were based on how the quality of life index changes over time. In order to understand the data and organize it in a systematic way, the 1990 and 2000 US Census data and 2010 ACS data were spatially organized according to 2010 census boundaries. Due to the Modifiable Aerial Unit Problem, it had to be assumed for the purposes of this project that the data is consistent across the census tracts when reconciling differences in shape, size, and number of census tracts. After the data was fully organized, the quality of life per census tract was calculated for each year, and then the datasets were merged together. The quality of life calculation used here is based off of the UN index and assumes that the data used and index changes made are close enough to the original index. Change over time within the index was calculated and then compared spatially based on distance from the Olympic venues as compared to the state-wide mean.
Key findings, Primary Data Sources, Quality of Life Index, Methodology
http://www.benjaminbg.com/gis-methods-case-studies/
5
final project | introduction to gis leah meisterlin | fall 2014
http://www.benjaminbg.com/gis-methods-case-studies/
final project | introduction to gis leah meisterlin | fall 2014
http://www.benjaminbg.com/gis-methods-case-studies/
professional
• • • • • •
6 runways; 136 gates (A=37, B=77, C=22) 53 million passengers 511,000 sqm terminal and concourse area over 4 buildings Connection via underground train and pedestrian bridge (to Concourse A) Main terminal amenities: Food, retail, chapel, post office, financial services branch Concourse amenities: Food, retail, airline lounges, spa
Denver International Airport Fentress Architects
• • • • •
4 runways; 75 gates (49 available) 8 million passengers 195,000 sqm Connection via train or bus Terminal: retail, food, lounge, historical displays,
Pittsburgh International Airport Tasso Katselas Associates
massing analysis for beit amir, jerusalem | pei cobb freed & partners new york, ny | summer 2016
Pros: • Good apartment layouts • Good views • Form fits city • Corners tucked in • Building appears as narrow • Private rooftop garden • Podium with private access route for apartments • Terraced apartments
633 m2
OBQLIQUE PINWHEEL TOWER WITH TWO STORY PODIUM AND TERRACED APARTMENTS BEIT AMIR | DESIGN ALTERNATIVES | AUGUST 3, 2016 27
OBLIQUE PINWHEEL TOWER BEIT AMIR | DESIGN ALTERNATIVES | AUGUST 3, 2016 28
massing analysis for beit amir, jerusalem | pei cobb freed & partners new york, ny | summer 2016
New building rights based on the new policy document “Density Along Light Train Route:”
1 Tower (30 Apt Floors + 2 Floor Podium)
1 Tower + Terraced Apts (3 Apt Floors + Commercial)
% or no.
m²
Total (m²)
Rights - Beit Amir (Plot 128)
1200%
1,891
22,692
Rights - Sliver Lot (Plot 136)
1200%
Rights - Parking (Plot 141)
1200%
1,417
17,004
Lobby & Commercial Floor (Double height)
1
458
458
1
458
458
Rights - All (Plots 128 + 136 + 141)
1200%
3,419
41,028
Commercial (Podium)
2
1,891
3,782
2
1,891
3,782
1
633
633
111
1,332
% or no.
m²
Total (m²)
% or no.
633
18,990
30
m²
Total (m²)
633
18,990
Beit Amir (Plot 128) Typical Apartment Floors
Technical Floor
30
633
1
23,863
34
5,673
3
1,891
Commercial (Podium)
1
111
111
Lobby & Commercial Floor (Double height)
2
111
222
Technical Floor
1
111
Total (Sliver Lot)
4
Parking (Not included in rights)
3
Total (Beit Amir) Parking (Not included in rights)
34 3
1,891
633 23,863 5,673
Sliver Lot (Plot 136)
111 444
111
333
Parking Lot (Plot 141) Terraced Apartment Floors
3
430
1,290
Commercial (Podium
3
400
1,200
Technical Floor
1
430
Total (Parking Lot)
7
Parking (Not included in rights) Total (Plots 128 + 136 + 141) Total Parking
3 34 3
1,891
23,863
34
5,673
3
430 2,920
1,417
4,251 27,227
3,419
10,257
Unused Beit Amir:
-1,171
Unused Beit Amir:
-1,171
Developed %:
1262%
Developed %:
1262%
Unused All:
17,165
Unused All:
13,801
Developed %:
698%
Developed %:
796%
Apartment Tower Floors (without Terraced Apts): Total Apartment Floors (Gross area)
18,990
18,990
Core and Service Area (+ Technical Floor)
30
125
4,383
30
125
4,383
Total Apartment Floors + Balconies
30
633
14,607
30
633
14,607
4
6
720
4
6
13,887
73%
Total Balconies Total Apartment Area (net - w/o Balconies & Core) No. of Apartments (Max density) No. of Small Apartments Total Area of Small Apartments
73% 95
146
20%
29
75
2,193
720 13,887
95
146
20%
29
75
2,193
More Data: Offices/Hotel/Elderly Accomodation/Student Dormitories Setback Toward Agron Street
CONCEPTUAL SECTION BEIT AMIR | DESIGN ALTERNATIVES | AUGUST 3, 2016 30
25% 0
5,966
25%
6,807
0
BUILDING DEVELOPMENT RIGHTS BEIT AMIR | DESIGN ALTERNATIVES | AUGUST 3, 2016 48
1:200 study model for benin, jerusalem | pei cobb freed & partners new york, ny | summer 2016
1:200 study model for benin, jerusalem | pei cobb freed & partners new york, ny | summer 2016
local law 11 analytics | experion design group new york, ny | 2014-2015
arcgis analysis of hundreds of buildings across nyc
automated parking research | experion design group new york, ny | 2014-2015
http://edgnyc.com/
concrete facade research | experion design group new york, ny | 2014-2015
facade designs & 3d print tests
airport typology research | fentress architects shanghai, china | summer 2013
• • • • • •
6 runways; 136 gates (A=37, B=77, C=22) 53 million passengers 511,000 sqm terminal and concourse area over 4 buildings Connection via underground train and pedestrian bridge (to Concourse A) Main terminal amenities: Food, retail, chapel, post office, financial services branch Concourse amenities: Food, retail, airline lounges, spa
• • • • •
3 runways; 74 gates 39 million passengers 551,000 sqm concourse area Connection via Intra Airport Transit train Terminal amenities: Hotel, food, kids zone, movie zone, shower room, internet room, relax zone, massage, gallery, cultural experience, tour of airport, ice rink, cinema, concert hall, golf course, casino • Concourse amenities: Lounges, children’s nursery, pharmacy, traditional center, museum, relax zone (many of same activities)
Denver International Airport Fentress Architects
Incheon International Airport Fentress Architects
• • • • •
• 4 runways; 65 gates (expansion) • 61 million passengers • Connection via CDGVAL - light rail shuttle
4 runways; 75 gates (49 available) 8 million passengers 195,000 sqm Connection via train or bus Terminal: retail, food, lounge, historical displays,
Pittsburgh International Airport Tasso Katselas Associates
Charles de Gaulle Paris Airport Paul Andreau
other design work | fentress architects shanghai, china | summer 2013
project analytics | greensulate, llc new york, ny | summer 2012
crm database management | federation of jewish men’s clubs new york, ny | 2013-2014
https://www.fjmc.org/
graphics | columbia daily spectator newspaper senior graphics associate | 2012-2013
http://columbiaspectator.com/contributors/Benjamin-Bromberg-Gaber/
graduate studios
doha research and manifesto image | core III elizabeth christoforetti | fall 2016
DOHA | CITY DEVELOPMENT
SITE | PRIMARY BUILDING USES Residential Commercial Health Hotel Parks & Museums Restaurant
1956
1977
1995
Empty Lot Future Art Mill (1.1km)
Museum of Islamic Art (1km)
Salata Park
Future Qatar National Museum
Site
International Airport (1.8km) 0
25m
50m
100m
0m
225m
450m
900m
1,800m
200m
2016 (2040 - when oil reserves are depleted)
Residential
20
Commercial Health Hotel Tourism Restaurant Empty Lot
12
mixed-use hotel tower in doha | core III elizabeth christoforetti | fall 2016
mixed-use hotel tower in doha | core III elizabeth christoforetti | fall 2016
Typical floor - back of house
Gallery - 17th floor
Cafe - 42nd floor
Diagram - outdoor / public / semi-private / private
Fitness - 37th floor
Conference - 49th floor
mixed-use hotel tower in doha | core III elizabeth christoforetti | fall 2016
mixed-use hotel tower in doha | core III elizabeth christoforetti | fall 2016
boston demographics | core II max kuo | spring 2016
0 1-500
DEMOGRAPHICS
PEOPLE PER BLOCK GROUP
501-1000
0-39%
1001-1500
40-49%
1501-2000
50-59%
2001+
60-100%
Source: US Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2014 5 Year Estimate
DEMOGRAPHICS
PERCENT FEMALE BY BLOCK GROUP
Source: US Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2014 5 Year Estimate
musashino library analytique | core II max kuo | spring 2016
circulating + rare book library | core II max kuo | spring 2016
circulating + rare book library | core II max kuo | spring 2016
circulating + rare book library | core II max kuo | spring 2016
circulating + rare book library | core II max kuo | spring 2016
cancer club | core II max kuo | spring 2016
cancer club | core II max kuo | spring 2016
cancer club | core II max kuo | spring 2016
ground floor
2nd floor
cancer club | core II max kuo | spring 2016
ouagadougou bus shelter network | j-term studio d. francis kĂŠrĂŠ | winter 2016
quad neighborhoods dorm | core I cristina parreno | fall 2015
quad neighborhoods dorm | core I cristina parreno | fall 2015
quad neighborhoods dorm | core I cristina parreno | fall 2015
extensive/intensive | core I cristina parreno | fall 2015
extensive/intensive | core I cristina parreno | fall 2015
undergraduate studios
1950
1960
population growth millions of people 20
15
10
5
0 1900
1910
1920
1930
1940
1950
1960
1970
resource research | design 3 studio karen fairbanks | fall 2014
THE COST OF LIGHT
=
THE EFFECTS OF NATURAL LIGHT
0
4
= CO
NY
N TA
U C T WITH N AT
RE
NY
=
=
HI
GH
E R P R O D U C TIVI
TY
GLASS WINDOW
RE
1851- THE CRYSTAL PALACE
1952 - LEVER HOUSE
2010 - PV MIXED WINDOWS
LIGHT SPECTRUM
THE EFFECTS OF NO NATURAL LIGHT
EX
PEN
SI V E LIG H TI N
G
NATURAL OUTDOOR LIGHT COMPARED TO... ...FULL-SPECTRUM LIGHT SOURCE
AVERAGE MICROWATTS PER 10 NANOMETERS PER LUMEN
...STANDARD INCANDESCENT LIGHT ...COOL WHITE FLUORESCENT
H IG
H ER FATIGU
E
WAVELENGTH (NANOMETERS)
“DAYLIGHT...MOST CLOSELY MATCHES THE VISUAL RESPONSE THAT, THROUGH EVOLUTION, HUMANS HAVE COME TO COMPARE WITH ALL OTHER LIGHTS.”
with rhea schmid
M
OR
E ERR O RS IN W O
RK
TA M
E D E YES T R A
VI
1680 - CAST GLASS
DUC
5
IN D
/ IM MUNE S
IN
YS
TE
M
resource research | design 3 studio karen fairbanks | fall 2014 SUNSHINE IN CITIES
73%*
1901 TENEMENT HOUSING REGULATION
58%
1
47%
*PERCENTAGE OF TIME B/W SUNRISE AND SUNSET THAT SUNSHINE REACHES THE GROUND
AVERAGE MONTHLY HOURS OF SUNSHINE OVER THE YEAR
EQUITABLE BUILDING SHADOW
2
= NEW YORK (58%) = ISTANBUL (55%)
SHADE 8AM
NORTH
PARK AVE
12PM
PARK AVE
4PM
PARK AVE
with rhea schmid
1916 HUGH FERRIS ZONING SETBACK DRAWINGS
3
istanbul city development research | design 3 studio karen fairbanks | fall 2014
1900
1910
1940
1960 2010 2012
2013
1950 1980
1960
2010
first gecekondus
gecekondus settlements
gecekondu “landed over night�
population growth
area of development compared to prior years & current roads
millions of people 20
15
10 1807
5
0 1900
with rhea schmid
1910
1920
1930
1940
1950
1960
1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
2020
1899
1950
2013
2014
biennial extension midterm proposal | design 3 studio karen fairbanks | fall 2014 kit of parts packaging and constructing the pavilion for rebuild 3 ft.
1 ft.
bulbs
metal meshing
attachments
lighting
poles: 9 ft.
packaging
with lauren espeseth, rhea schmid + sara shalam
corrugated metal sheeting
biennial extension midterm proposal | design 3 studio karen fairbanks | fall 2014
with lauren espeseth, rhea schmid + sara shalam
new public spaces final proposal | design 3 studio karen fairbanks | fall 2014
with lauren espeseth, rhea schmid + sara shalam
new public spaces final proposal | design 3 studio karen fairbanks | fall 2014
with lauren espeseth, rhea schmid + sara shalam
university hardware analysis | design 2 studio peter zuspan | spring 2014
university hardware analysis | design 2 studio peter zuspan | spring 2014
library research | design 2 studio peter zuspan | spring 2014
library research | design 2 studio peter zuspan | spring 2014
library design | design 2 studio peter zuspan | spring 2014
library design | design 2 studio peter zuspan | spring 2014
times square analysis | perceptions studio nicole robertson | spring 2013
times square analysis | perceptions studio nicole robertson | spring 2013
times square analysis | perceptions studio nicole robertson | spring 2013
seating analysis | abstractions studio todd rouhe | fall 2012
other classes
Devel opi ngCi t i es, Mega Event s, andTr anspor t at i on Analysis of the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games & Beijing Transportation System
Figure 8: Main Prayer Hall with Torah Ark on Right Side (Runesson, “Th Ancient Ostia” 57)
Figure 9: Mindius Faustus Inscription (Runesson, “The Synagogue at Anc
cathedral of saint thomas more | making sacred spaces christine smith | spring 2016
confessional daily chapel sacrament chapel deacons clergy light from skylight (aligns with altar on Feast of Saint Thomas More)
bishop gospel baptismal font
narthex
congregation
altar epistle choir master organ choir communion
back of house
http://www.benjaminbg.com/gsd-making-sacred-spaces/
java programming | introduction to computer science paul blaer | spring 2015
final research project | cities in developing countries susan gladstone | spring 2014
Devel opi ngCi t i es, Mega Event s, andTr anspor t at i on
Roads2008
Analysis of the 2008 Beijing Olympic Games & Beijing Transportation System
Benj ami nBr omber gGaber
Roads2008
Figure 1 (Liu X., Jifu, and Zhuangzhi 21)
https://www.dropbox.com/s/3jen26pmdxa9m6z/Final%20Presentation.pptx?dl=0
Bar cel ona, 1 992
final research project on syngagogue flexibility | synagogue art & architecture vivian mann | fall 2013
final paper | 20th century cities gergely baics | spring 2013
Bromberg Gaber 1
Benjamin Bromberg Gaber May 14, 2013 20th Century Cities: Americas and Europe Final Paper
Bromberg Gaber 17
Appendix
Atlantic City Goes Double or Nothing: Playing Through the Resort Cycle To grow up in Atlantic City is to grow up in an paradise—there are beautiful beaches no more than a mile away, there are casinos, shopping, and events available 24/7, and there is a constant stream of visitors and new friends to be made. For over 150 years, Atlantic City has been this hub of fun and recreation, developing from a beach resort to a center for vices to one of the largest gaming resorts. When one looks at the resort cycle model, explained in detail below, Atlantic City’s continued success is abnormal and has defied the nature of a tourist resort. This paper will take a look at the development and concept of the resort cycle, analyze the history of Atlantic City, argue that Atlantic City is in the final stage of its second resort cycle, and look to the future of the resort to assess whether Atlantic City has the potential to revitalize itself or fade into the ocean. In discussing Atlantic City with Israel Posner1 via telephone, he kept insisting that Atlantic City was first and only ever a resort city—a city whose sole purpose is to attract tourists. Several articles2 written in the 1960s and 1970s continued the work of earlier tourism scholars and began finding a pattern within the life of tourist resorts. This led to the development of the term ‘resort cycle’ in 1978 by Charles Stansfield in “Atlantic City and the Resort Cycle,” and a
Co-editor of Casino Gaming in Atlantic City: A Thirty Year Retrospective (2009), and Executive Director of the Lloyd D. Levenson Institute of Gaming, Hospitality, and Tourism in the School Business at the Richard Stockton College of New Jersey 2 Such as those written by W. Christaller in 1963, J.E. Brougham and R.W. Butler in 1972, S.C. Plog in 1973, among others (Referenced in Butler, “The Origins of the Tourism Area Life Cycle” 18-20) 1
Figure 1: Richard Butler's TALC Model
final research project on synagogue in ostia, italy | roman preindustrial metropolis marco mauiro | fall 2013
Bromberg Gaber 14
Bromberg Gaber 15
Bromberg Gaber 17
Figure 4: Drawing of Original Synagogue (Runesson,“The Synagogue at Ancient Ostia” 80)
Figure 8: Main Prayer Hall with Torah Ark on Right Side (Runesson, “The Synagogue at Ancient Ostia” 57)
Fig. 3: Synagogue Plan After Final Renovation (Runesson,“The Synagogue at Ancient Ostia” 68)
Figure 5: Synagogue and Ostia (Runesson, “The Synagogue at Ancient Ostia” 38)
Figure 9: Mindius Faustus Inscription (Runesson, “The Synagogue at Ancient Ostia” 86)
thanks!
1950 1980
1960
2010
first gecekondus
gecekondus settlements
http://www.benjaminbg.com/