3 PROPERTIES | 89 UNITS
ELIZABETH, NEW JERSEY
a Berkshire Hathaway and Jefferies Financial Group company
INVESTMENT ADVISORS
NAT GAMBUZZA
Senior Managing Director
NJ DRE #0123988
973.809.1755
nat.gambuzza@berkadia.com
TREVOR FIEBEL
Senior Director
NJ DRE #1431448
908.285.6921
trevor.fiebel@berkadia.com
NICK BALANCIA
Associate Director
NJ DRE #2322128
908.642.1905
nick.balancia@berkadia.com
BRIAN ANTOGNINI
Senior Transaction Manager
NJ DRE #1111667
201.739.2331
brian.antognini@berkadia.com
MORRISTOWN,
NEW JERSEY
17 Headquarters Plaza West Tower
8th Floor
Morristown, NJ 07960
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Team Capabilities 10 The Opportunity 18 The Location 24 Sales Comparables 26 Rent Comparables 28 The Financials 40 Create & Negotiate
4
TEAM CAPABILITIES | NEW JERSEY INVESTMENT SALES
Berkadia New Jersey Investment Sales, led by Nat Gambuzza, provides a depth of advisory and transaction services for income generating properties that is unparalleled in the industry. Their clients include private investors, partnerships, lenders and institutions of various net worth. The team has specialized
expertise and excels in the most complex transactions, including portfolio sales, distressed property sales, note sales and time-sensitive 1031 tax exchange transactions. Prior to joining Berkadia in 2022, the team worked at another national real estate investment services firm.
4 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO
TEAM OVERVIEW 7 TEAM MEMBERS 19,900+ TOTAL UNITS SOLD 75 Years COMBINED EXPERIENCE $2.8B+ TOTAL CONSIDERATION NEW JERSEY INVESTMENT PROPERTIES TEAM
O’REILLY Senior Financial Analyst
MIKE
Senior Director
SPENCER BERIONT
Senior Managing Director
NAT GAMBUZZA
Senior Transaction Manager
BRIAN ANTOGNINI
Senior Director TIM BLASHFORD Director
BALANCIA Associate Director COUNTY UNITS VALUE Atlantic 549 $52,075,000 Bergen 1,643 $301,610,765 Burlington 1 $6,060,000 Camden 1,250 $92,415,300 Essex 5,391 $651,145,086 Gloucester 348 $41,215,000 Hudson 1,295 $281,988,000 Hunterdon 159 $47,880,000 Mercer 200 $33,127,500 Middlesex 1,039 $211,457,000 Monmouth 1,213 $203,647,722 Morris 499 $142,003,000 Ocean 105 $10,600,000 Out of State 930 $125,382,000 Passaic 861 $127,794,000 Somerset 780 $134,471,500 Sussex 44 $6,650,000 Union 3,549 $353,292,700 Warren 46 $2,490,000
TREVOR FIEBEL
NICK
UNION COUNTY
3,549 Units | $353,292,700
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 5
TEAM CAPABILITIES | TEAM CLOSINGS
TEAM CAPABILITIES | RECENT TRACK RECORD (UNION COUNTY)
611 W BLANCKE
Linden, NJ
Units: 8
Sales Price: UNDER CONTRACT
574 JEFFERSON
Elizabeth, NJ
Units: 28
Sales Price: UNDER CONTRACT
RAHWAY & LINDEN PORTFOLIO
Rahway & Linden, NJ
Units: 52
Sales Price: $11,150,000
Price Per Unit: $214,423
RAHWAY PORTFOLIO
Rahway, NJ
Units: 51
Sales Price: $7,500,000
Price Per Unit: $147,058
MARLAW APARTMENTS
Elizabeth, NJ
Units: 36
Sales Price: $4,800,000
Price Per Unit: $133,333
BELLA VISTA
Elizabeth, NJ
Units: 82
Sales Price: $9,750,000
Price Per Unit: $118,902
ROSELLE & LINDEN PORTFOLIO
Roselle & Linden, NJ
Units: 35
Sales Price: $6,200,000
Price Per Unit: $177,142
THE EL MORA
Elzabeth, NJ
Units: 21
Sales Price: $3,307,500
Price Per Unit: $157,500
6 BERKADIA /
ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO
TEAM CAPABILITIES | 2024 CASE STUDIES
The case studies below are examples of how our team has excelled for our clients in maximizing value for their assets.
574 JEFFERSON ELIZABETH, NJ
Units 28
Property Marketed by Other Firm for 12-Months
Seller Tasked Berkadia to Sell Property in Late 2023
Berkadia has Property Under Contract
611 W BLANCKE LINDEN, NJ
Units 8
Seller Purchased for 1.34MM in August 2023
Seller Tasked Berkadia to Sell Property in Early 2024
Berkadia has Property Under Contract for a 15% Increase on Price within 6-Months of Seller Ownership
51 E MAIN BERGENFIELD, NJ
Units 26
New Construction Property Previously Listed with Two Other Firms
Seller Tasked Berkadia to Sell Property in February 2024
Berkadia Currently Negotiating Two Separate LOIs with Seller
11 DEHART MORRISTOWN, NJ
Units 59
Property Previously Marketed by Other Firms
Berkadia Sourced an All-Cash Buyer
Berkadia Sold at Start of 2024 for Highest Price per Unit in Morristown
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 7
TEAM CAPABILITIES | MARKET FACTORS
The following market factors influence investor decisions while evaluating opportunities. We take this into consideration when assembling our valuations.
Elizabeth Just Underwent 1st Tax Reassessment in 50 Years; Portfolio’s Taxes are Projected to be Increasing 22.53% in 2024
Investors are Being Cautious Short Term While Maintaining Long Term Optimism Specifically in Multifamily
Historically Low Rates Have Increased Substantially
Higher Interest Rates Prevent Homeownership Which Bodes Well for Rentals
Inflation Driving Up Operating Expenses, Including Utilities, Labor, and Materials
Lenders Restricted by Debt Service Coverage Ratios
Rents in Market up 6.4% YoY and 29.2% Since 2018
Current Market Occupancy at 96.2% 4Q23 Projected to Reach 97.2% by End of 2024
Elizabeth has Prohibitive Rent Control Ordinance
8 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO
TEAM CAPABILITIES | SUPPLY AND OCCUPANCY
Fundamentals remain strong with absorption, rents, and occupancy.
Absorption is Outpacing New Deliveries/Vacancy
Market Occupancy Close to 99% Coupled with Significant Rental Growth
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 9
(1,200) 0 1,200 2,400 3,600 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024* Supply vs. Demand New Deliveries Net Absorption *Projection $1,789 $1,822 $1,845 $2,019 $2,173 $2,312 $2,365 80% 85% 90% 95% 100% $1,400 $1,650 $1,900 $2,150 $2,400 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024* Rent vs. Occupancy Effective Rent Occupancy Rate *Projection
** **Rent Includes all Asset Classes and Bedroom Types
THE OPPORTUNITY | INVESTMENT SUMMARY
662
151-157
145-149
from an overwhelming demand for renters to live in Elizabeth, upside in current rents, and an unbeatable location to large office hubs, nightlife options, and mass transportation.
INVESTMENT HIGHLIGHTS
THE INVESTMENT: Spanning three properties, this garden-style apartment portfolio comprises of 89 units and offers a substantial value-add opportunity.
UNIQUE UNIT-MIX: This 3-property portfolio has an ideal overall unit mix of 4 studio apartments, 77 one-bedroom apartments, and 8 two-bedroom apartments.
LONG TERM OWNERSHIP: This garden-style apartment portfolio has been owned, cared for, and managed by the same ownership group for a collective 50 years.
VALUE-ADD: Portfolio presents a significant value-add opportunity for an investor with the current rent roll 57% below market.
MARKET PERFORMANCE: The City of Elizabeth boasts a 3.8% vacancy rate, with rents up 6.4% YoY and up 29.2 % since 2018.
STRATEGIC LOCATION: Ideal location with access by car and train to the region’s major employment centers in New York City, Newark, and Jersey City.
10 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO
The Elizabeth Portfolio presents an investor with a rare opportunity to purchase a total of 89 apartments in Elizabeth, NJ. The Elizabeth Portfolio sits adjacent to public transportation, is situated near stable employment centers, and is within a few blocks of numerous dining, shopping, and nightlife options. The investment benefits
STILES STREET
STILES STREET
SALEM AVENUE
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 11 THE OPPORTUNITY | AERIAL OF PROPERTIES MORRISAVE NBROADST WESTFIELD NEWARK AVE 151-157 STILES STREET 145-149 STILES STREET 662 SALEM AVENUE
THE OPPORTUNITY | 145-149 STILES STREET
145-149 STILES STREET
ADDRESS 145-149 Stiles St
COUNTY Union County
MUNICIPALITY Elizabeth
LAND AREA 0.50 Acres
YEAR BUILT 1962
# OF UNITS 34 Apartments
PARKING SPACES 37 Surface Parking Spaces
145-149 STILES STREET
STRUCTURAL
FOUNDATION Cinderblock
FRAME Wood Frame
EXTERIOR Masonry
WINDOWS Double Hung- Vinyl
ROOF Pitched Asphalt
MECHANICAL
UTILITIES Separately Metered
HOT WATER Central Hot Water Heater
COOLING Through Wall A/C Sleeves
HEATING Central Boiler with Baseboard Distribution
SECURITY SYSTEM
FIRE SAFETY
Controlled Entry w/ Full Camera Surveillance System
Hard-Wired in Common Areas w/ Central Monitoring System, Fully Sprinklered
LAUNDRY Leased Laundry Facility
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 13
PROPERTY DETAILS * Select Property Details Assumed Based on Asset Vintage
THE OPPORTUNITY | 151-157 STILES STREET
151-157 STILES STREET
ADDRESS 151-157 Stiles Street
COUNTY Union County
MUNICIPALITY Elizabeth
LAND AREA 0.68 Acres
YEAR BUILT 1972
# OF UNITS 32 Apartments
PARKING SPACES 35 Surface Parking Spaces
151-157 STILES STREET
STRUCTURAL
FOUNDATION Cinderblock
FRAME Wood Frame
EXTERIOR Masonry/Wood Accents
WINDOWS Double Hung- Vinyl
ROOF Flat
MECHANICAL
UTILITIES Separately Metered
HOT WATER Central Hot Water Heater
COOLING Through Wall A/C Sleeves
HEATING Central Boiler with Baseboard Distribution
SECURITY SYSTEM
FIRE SAFETY
Controlled Entry w/ Full Camera Surveillance System
Hard-Wired in Common Areas with Central Monitoring System
LAUNDRY Leased Laundry Facility
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 15
* Select Property Details Assumed Based on Asset Vintage
PROPERTY DETAILS
THE OPPORTUNITY | 662 SALEM AVENUE
642-650 SALEM AVENUE
ADDRESS 662 Salem Avenue
COUNTY Union County
MUNICIPALITY Elizabeth
LAND AREA 0.38 Acres
YEAR BUILT 1962
# OF UNITS 23 Apartments
PARKING SPACES 21 Surface Parking Spaces
662 SALEM AVENUE
STRUCTURAL
FOUNDATION Cinderblock
FRAME Wood Frame
EXTERIOR Masonry
WINDOWS
Double Hung- Vinyl
ROOF Pitched Asphalt
MECHANICAL
UTILITIES Separately Metered
HOT WATER Central Hot Water Heater
COOLING
Through Wall A/C Sleeves
HEATING Central Boiler with Baseboard Distribution
SECURITY SYSTEM
FIRE SAFETY
Controlled Entry w/ Full Camera Surveillance System
Hard-Wired in Common Areas with Central Monitoring System
LAUNDRY Building Owned Equipment
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 17
PROPERTY DETAILS
* Select Property Details Assumed Based on Asset Vintage
THE LOCATION | ELIZABETH, NEW JERSEY
Elizabeth, New Jersey, is a culturally diverse city located in Union County. It is a bustling urban center that offers its residents a mix of historical charm, economic opportunities, and convenient access to transportation hubs. Elizabeth offers its residents a vibrant community atmosphere with a range of cultural, recreational, and educational opportunities. The city boasts several parks, including Warinanco Park and Mattano Park, providing green spaces for outdoor activities and relaxation. Elizabeth is home to various cultural institutions, such as the Boxwood Hall State Historic Site and the Museum of the Historical Society of Elizabeth, which offer insights into the city’s rich history. The city is home to several major employers, including: Port Newark-Elizabeth Marine Terminal, Trinitas Regional Medical Center, as well as Elizabeth Public Schools. The city is served by NJ Transit buses, which connect residents to destinations throughout New Jersey and New York City. Additionally, Elizabeth is located near Newark Liberty International Airport, offering air travel options for both domestic and international journeys. Elizabeth is served by NJ Transit’s Northeast Corridor rail line, providing commuter rail service to destinations such as New York City, Newark, and Trenton. The city also has access to the PATH train system, facilitating travel to Manhattan and other parts of New York City. Elizabeth, NJ, offers its residents a diverse and dynamic living environment with a range of amenities, employment opportunities, and transportation options, contributing to a high quality of life for its residents.
18 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 19
| MAP OF PROPERTIES
THE LOCATION
145-149 STILES STREET
151-157 STILES STREET
662 SALEM AVENUE
THE LOCATION | TRANSPORTATION
Through the NJ Transit Authority, residents have access to the region’s expansive public transportation options. Residents’ choices vary from NJ Transit bus system, the NJ Transit rail system, and multiple regional highways.
NJTRANSIT BUS SYSTEM: The massive NJ Transit Bus system extends residents mass transportation reach to the entire Metro New York area. NJ Transit provides bus service locally as well as to the New York Port Authority Bus Terminal. Elizabeth has bus stops scattered throughout the town with multiple different service lines.
REGIONAL HIGHWAYS: Elizabeth provides immediate access to multiple local and regional highways such as Routes 1, 9, 22, 27, 28, 78, I-95 & The Garden State Parkway.
NJTRANSIT: Northeast Corridor Line: NJ Transit commuter rail service connecting Elizabeth to destinations such as Newark, Jersey City, and New York City. Stops include Elizabeth Station and North Elizabeth Station.
REGIONAL AIRPORTS: Newark Liberty International Airport: Located nearby in Newark, NJ, Newark Liberty International Airport offers domestic and international flights, providing residents of Elizabeth with air travel options for both business and
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 21
| TRANSPORTATION
THE LOCATION
E LIZABETH , NJ
22 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO
One-Mile Radius Three-Mile Radius Five-Mile Radius Union County 2023 Estimated Population 48,464 259,023 649,790 563,555 Projected 2028 Population 48,788 260,843 654,634 570,305 Population Growth (2023 – 2028) 0.7% 0.7% 0.8% 1.2% 2023 Estimated Median HHI $57,120 $62,873 $64,076 $91,964 Projected 2028 Median HHI $64,207 $70,200 $72,155 $103,136 Median HHI Growth (2023 - 2028) 12.4% 11.7% 12.6% 12.1% Households Earning $100,000+ Annually 25% 29% 31% 46% Key Renter Age Group (18 to 35) 22% 22% 22% 22% Bachelor's Degree or Higher (Age 25+) 21% 20% 25% 38% Renter-Occupied Housing Units 65% 55% 53% 38% White-Collar Workers 42% 48% 52% 62% Workplace Establishments 982 5,335 14,991 15,353 FTE Employees* 17,436 103,008 312,064 247,021
*Full-time equivalent workplace employees
DEMOGRAPHICS
KEY TAKEAWAYS 1-MILE RADIUS (TMA )
RENT VS. OWN
Average mortgage payment: $4,188*
Effective rent: $2,312
Difference: $1,876
LEASING ACTIVITY
1,291 net move-ins in 2023
3,218 net move-ins projected in 2024
Would be highest annual absorption on record
APPRECIATING HOME VALUES
According to Realtor.com, the median home price in Elizabeth grew 12.0% to approximately $560,000 in February 2024
AFFLUENT HOUSEHOLDS
The median HHI within three miles of the subject property ($62,873) is projected to reach $70,200 by 2028, equating to an 11.7% increase from 2023
EFFECTIVE RENT
56 net move-outs during 2023
243 net move-ins expected during 2024 *($560,000
NEW SUPPLY
1,811 new units came online in 2023
2,428 new units projected to come online in 2024
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 23
home price, 30-year fixed, 20% down, 6.61% interest rate, 2.33% NJ property tax, $1,635 homeowner’s insurance)
24 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO SALES COMPARABLES Address 1270 Clinton & 204 Westfield Elizabeth, NJ 32-44 Stiles Street Elizabeth, NJ 129, 233, 435 W Grand & 1247 Clinton Elizabeth, NJ 115 Orchard Street Elizabeth, NJ 432-440 Maple Avenue Elizabeth, NJ Sale Date 7/19/2023 3/21/2024 10/25/2022 6/3/2022 2/9/2022 Year Built 1930/1966 1965 ~1960s 1965 1972 Units 44 36 110 23 24 Sale Price $6,037,500 $4,800,000 $13,340,000 $3,550,000 $3,300,000 Price per Unit $137,216 $133,333 $121,273 $154,348 $137,500 Notes Two Building Portfolio 4.9% Cap Rate Four Building Portfolio Sold by Long Term Ownership Direct Off-Market Purchase
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 25
SALES COMPARABLES MAP
435 W GRAND STREET
233 W GRAND STREET
1247 CLINTON PLACE
129 W GRAND STREET
432 MAPLE AVENUE
115 ORCHARD STREET
1270 CLINTON PLACE
204 WESTFIELD AVENUE
32-44 STILES STREET
145-157 STILES STREET
662 SALEM AVENUE
26 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO RENT COMPARABLES Name Subject Portfolio Stiles Manor Aberdeen Arms Apartments Turtle Village Cambridge Manor Address 145 Stiles & 662 Salem Avenue Elizabeth, NJ 171 Stiles Street Elizabeth, NJ 730 N Broad Street Elizabeth, NJ 461 Morris Avenue Elizabeth, NJ 539 N Broad Street Elizabeth, NJ # of Units 89 96 52 40 69 Built/Renovated 1962/1963 1966 1965 1965 1963 Stories 2 2 2 2 2 TOTAL/AVERAGES STUDIO Range Low High Low High Low High Low High Low High Low Average High Rent $845 $995 $1,525 $1,750 $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,470 $1,470 $1,470 $1,554 $1,750 Average Rent $920 $1,638 $0 $0 $1,470 $1,470 $1,554 $1,638 ONE BEDROOM Range Low High Low High Low High Low High Low High Low Average High Rent $825 $1,370 $1,745 $1,820 $1,610 $2,100 $1,721 $1,846 $1,800 $1,900 $1,610 $1,818 $2,100 Average Rent $1,098 $1,783 $1,855 $1,784 $1,850 $1,783 $1,818 $1,855
Range Low High Low High Low High Low High Low High Low Average High Rent $1,080 $1,600 $2,070 $2,215 $2,094 $2,100 $2,155 $2,155 $2,000 $2,000 $2,000 $2,099 $2,215 Average Rent $1,340 $2,143 $2,097 $2,155 $2,000 $2,000 $2,099 $2,155 Note: Subject property rents are ranges observable from RR; for all other properties, rents are ranges available at time of survey.
TWO BEDROOM
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 27
RENT COMPARABLES MAP
STILES MANOR
ABERDEEN ARMS APARTMENTS
TURTLE VILLAGE
CAMBRIDGE MANOR
145-157 STILES STREET
662 SALEM AVENUE
THE FINANCIALS
145-157
|
STILES STREET
IMPORTANT INFORMATION & DISCLAIMER: The information contained herein is assumed to be correct and market-supported. Output produced from this model should not be considered an appraisal. Projections are forecasts and are not to be considered fact. The information contained in this file is privileged and confidential; it is intended only for use by Berkadia® and their clients. This file may not be reproduced physically or in electronic format without the express written consent of Berkadia. Not responsible for errors and omissions.
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 29
Unit Type Total Average Rent Current Monthly Rent Market Rent Market Monthly Rent Percent Upside Studio 3 $920 $2,760 $1,350 $4,050 46.74% 1 Bedroom 55 $1,155 $63,515 $1,800 $99,000 55.87% 2 Bedroom 8 $1,388 $11,107 $2,100 $16,800 51.26% Total 66 $77,382 $119,850 54.88% $920 $1,155 $1,388 $1,350 $1,800 $2,100 $0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 Studio 1 Bedroom 2 Bedroom Monthly Rent Upside
145-157 STILES STREET | RENT ROLL ANALYSIS
30 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO Number of Units 66 INCOME Current Berkadia Pro Forma Berkadia Notes Gross Potential Rent $928,584 $1,438,200 Estimated Market Rent Less Vacancy ($27,858) ($43,146) -3% of GPR Estimate Effective Rental Income $900,726 $1,395,054 Laundry Income $9,600 $9,600 Based on Contract at $800/Month Total Other Income $9,600 $9,600 Gross Potential Income $938,184 $1,447,800 Effective Gross Income $910,326 $1,404,654 EXPENSES Property Taxes* $160,352 $2,430 $165,162 $2,502 2024 RE Tax Estimate plus 3% Utilities $103,619 $1,570 $103,619 $1,570 Based on Seller's Financials Total Fixed Expenses $263,970 $4,000 $268,781 $4,072 Insurance $39,600 $600 $39,600 $600 $600 Per Unit Estimate Contract Services $13,200 $200 $13,200 $200 $200 Per Unit Estimate Superintendent $49,500 $750 $49,500 $750 $750 Per Unit Estimate Repairs and Maintenance $34,650 $525 $34,650 $525 $525 Per Unit Estimate Management Fee $27,310 $414 $42,140 $638 3% of EGI Estimate Total Variable Expenses $164,260 $2,489 $179,090 $2,713 Total Expenses $428,230 $6,488 $447,871 $6,786 Percent Upside Net Operating Income $482,096 $956,783 98.46% 145-157 STILES STREET | INCOME AND EXPENSES 47% 53% Income/Expense Comparison Total Expenses Effective Gross Income 32% 68% Pro Forma Income/Expense Comparison Total Expenses Effective Gross Income *2024 Property Taxes are Estimates Based on New 2024 Assessments and Estimated Tax Rate
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 31
4.70% 4.80% 4.90% 5.00% 5.10% 5.20% 5.30% 5.40% 5.50% 5.60% $8,200,000 $8,400,000 $8,600,000 $8,800,000 $9,000,000 $9,200,000 $9,400,000 $9,600,000 $9,800,000 $9,642,000 $9,183,000 $8,765,000 Cap Rate Value Current Value Current Valuation Price Cap Rate Valuation Actual Pro Forma Net Operating Income $482,096 $956,783 Current Valuation Price $9,642,000 $9,183,000 $8,765,000 Price Per Unit $146,091 $139,136 $132,803 Cap Rate 5.00% 5.25% 5.50%
145-157 STILES STREET | VALUATION
FINANCIALS | 662 SALEM AVENUE
THE
IMPORTANT INFORMATION & DISCLAIMER: The information contained herein is assumed to be correct and market-supported. Output produced from this model should not be considered an appraisal. Projections are forecasts and are not to be considered fact. The information contained in this file is privileged and confidential; it is intended only for use by Berkadia® and their clients. This file may not be reproduced physically or in electronic format without the express written consent of Berkadia. Not responsible for errors and omissions.
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 33
Unit Type Total Average Rent Current Monthly Rent Market Rent Market Monthly Rent Percent Upside Studio 1 $845 $845 $1,350 $1,350 59.76% 1 Bedroom 22 $1,099 $24,170 $1,800 $39,600 63.84% Total 23 $25,015 $40,950 63.70% $845 $1,099 $1,350 $1,800 $0 $200 $400 $600 $800 $1,000 $1,200 $1,400 $1,600 $1,800 $2,000 Studio 1 Bedroom Monthly Rent Upside 662 SALEM AVENUE | RENT ROLL ANALYSIS
34 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO Number of Units 23 INCOME Current Berkadia Pro Forma Berkadia Notes Gross Potential Rent $300,180 $491,400 Estimated Market Rent Less Vacancy ($9,005) ($14,742) -3% of GPR Estimate Effective Rental Income $291,175 $476,658 Laundry Income $5,382 $5,382 Based on 23 Units at $4.50/Week Total Other Income $5,382 $5,382 Gross Potential Income $305,562 $496,782 Effective Gross Income $296,557 $482,040 EXPENSES Property Taxes* $52,183 $2,269 $53,748 $2,337 2024 RE Tax Estimate plus 3% Utilities $29,944 $1,302 $29,944 $1,302 Based on Seller's Financials Total Fixed Expenses $82,126 $3,571 $83,692 $3,639 Insurance $13,800 $600 $13,800 $600 $600 Per Unit Estimate Contract Services $4,600 $200 $4,600 $200 $200 Per Unit Estimate Superintendent $17,250 $750 $17,250 $750 $750 Per Unit Estimate Repairs and Maintenance $12,075 $525 $12,075 $525 $525 Per Unit Estimate Management Fee $8,897 $387 $14,461 $629 3% of EGI Estimate Total Variable Expenses $56,622 $2,462 $62,186 $2,704 Total Expenses $138,748 $6,033 $145,878 $6,343 Percent Upside Net Operating Income $157,808 $336,162 113.02% 662 SALEM AVENUE | INCOME AND EXPENSES 47% 53% Income/Expense Comparison Total Expenses Effective Gross Income 30% 70% Pro Forma Income/Expense Comparison Total Expenses Effective Gross Income *2024 Property Taxes are Estimates Based on New 2024 Assessments and Estimated Tax Rate
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 35
|
4.70% 4.80% 4.90% 5.00% 5.10% 5.20% 5.30% 5.40% 5.50% 5.60% $2,700,000 $2,750,000 $2,800,000 $2,850,000 $2,900,000 $2,950,000 $3,000,000 $3,050,000 $3,100,000 $3,150,000 $3,200,000 $3,156,000 $3,006,000 $2,869,000 Cap Rate Value Current Value
Valuation Price Cap Rate Valuation Actual Pro Forma Net Operating Income $157,808 $336,162 Current Valuation Price $3,156,000 $3,006,000 $2,869,000 Price Per Unit $137,217 $130,696 $124,739 Cap Rate 5.00% 5.25% 5.50%
662 SALEM AVENUE
VALUATION
Current
COMBINED FINANCIALS
COMBINED FINANCIALS | RENT ROLL ANALYSIS
IMPORTANT INFORMATION & DISCLAIMER: The information contained herein is assumed to be correct and market-supported. Output produced from this model should not be considered an appraisal. Projections are forecasts and are not to be considered fact. The information contained in this file is privileged and confidential; it is intended only for use by Berkadia® and their clients. This file may not be reproduced physically or in electronic format without the express written consent of Berkadia. Not responsible for errors and omissions.
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 37
Unit Type Total Average Rent Current Monthly Rent Market Rent Market Monthly Rent Percent Upside Studio 4 $901 $3,605 $1,350 $5,400 49.79% 1 Bedroom 77 $1,139 $87,685 $1,800 $138,600 58.07% 2 Bedroom 8 $1,388 $11,107 $2,100 $16,800 51.26% Total 89 $102,397 $160,800 57.04% $901 $1,139 $1,388 $1,350 $1,800 $2,100 $0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 Studio 1 Bedroom 2 Bedroom Monthly Rent Upside
38 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO Number of Units 89 INCOME Current Berkadia Pro Forma Berkadia Notes Gross Potential Rent $1,228,764 $1,929,600 Estimated Market Rent Less Vacancy ($36,863) ($57,888) -3% of GPR Estimate Effective Rental Income $1,191,901 $1,871,712 Laundry Income $14,982 $14,982 Based on Seller’s Financials Total Other Income $14,982 $14,982 Gross Potential Income $1,243,746 $1,944,582 Effective Gross Income $1,206,883 $1,886,694 EXPENSES Property Taxes* $212,535 $2,388 $218,911 $2,460 2024 RE Tax Estimate plus 3% Utilities $133,562 $1,501 $133,562 $1,501 Based on Seller's Financials Total Fixed Expenses $346,097 $3,889 $352,473 $3,960 Insurance $53,400 $600 $53,400 $600 $600 Per Unit Estimate Contract Services $17,800 $200 $17,800 $200 $200 Per Unit Estimate Superintendent $66,750 $750 $66,750 $750 $750 Per Unit Estimate Repairs and Maintenance $46,725 $525 $46,725 $525 $525 Per Unit Estimate Management Fee $36,206 $407 $56,601 $636 3% of EGI Estimate Total Variable Expenses $220,881 $2,482 $241,276 $2,711 Total Expenses $566,978 $6,371 $593,749 $6,671 Percent Upside Net Operating Income $639,905 $1,292,945 98.46%
FINANCIALS | INCOME AND EXPENSES 47% 53% Income/Expense Comparison Total Expenses Effective Gross Income 31% 69% Pro Forma Income/Expense Comparison Total Expenses Effective Gross Income *2024 Property Taxes are Estimates Based on New 2024 Assessments and Estimated Tax Rate
COMBINED
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 39
FINANCIALS |
Valuation Actual Pro Forma Net Operating Income $639,905 $1,292,945 Current Valuation Price $12,798,000 $12,189,000 $11,635,000 Price Per Unit $143,798 $136,955 $130,730 Cap Rate 5.00% 5.25% 5.50% 2024 City of Elizabeth Property Tax Reassessment Address 2023 Assessment 2023 Tax 2024 Assessment 2024 Tax* Estimated Tax Increase (%) 145 Stiles $200,000 $62,860 $3,566,800 $74,903 19% 151 Stiles $220,000 $69,146 $4,047,400 $84,995 23% 662 Salem $131,000 $41,173 $2,484,900 $52,183 27% 138 Lincoln (Vacant Land) $900 $283 $21,300 $447 58% Total $173,462 $212,528 *Projection Based on Confirmed 2024 Tax Assessment and Estimated 2024 Tax Rate (2.10%) 2023 Tax Rate 31.43% 2024 Estimated Tax Rate 2.10%
COMBINED
VALUATION
CREATED & NEGOTIATE | THE BERKADIA PROCESS
Secure and Transparent Process
Controlled Document Center with Tiered Access to Due Dilligence
Clear Guidance on Core Fixed Expenses
Tracking Clients who have Signed Confidentiality Agreements
Tracking Buyer Activity within the Document Center
Manage Distribution of Due Diligence to be Done before Contract Signing
40 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO
CREATED & NEGOTIATE | THE BERKADIA PROCESS
Weekly Marketing Reports with Ownership Group throughout Selling Process
Maximum Reach by Utilizing New Jersey Berkadia’s Database and the National Berkadia Platform
To Ensure a Robust Response we Will go to Market Unpriced to Drive Attention
Marketing Process will Finish with a Call for Offers to Spur Action and Competition
Transparent Process Reduces Seller Risk in Volatile Market
BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO 41
CREATED & NEGOTIATE | TIMELINE TO SUCCESS
14 DAYS 30-40 DAYS 10-14 DAYS 5-14 DAYS 28-35 DAYS 15-30 DAYS
Kickoff meeting
Thorough property due diligence
Detailed underwriting & evaluation
Professional photography and video walkthrough
Marketing materials created
Set up weekly marketing updates with client
Distribute executive summary and teaser to national & international investors
Distribute comprehensive marketing package
Ongoing discussion with buyers
Create competitive environment
Conduct property tours
Collect initial offers
Evaluate offers
Dissemination of due diligence materials
Best & final bid
Buyer interviews
Counter best & final offers
Modify seller’s prepared purchase & sale agreement with buyers best & final comments
Open escrow upon delivery of contract & deposit
Force significant non-refundable deposit
Comprehensive property review including:
Title & survey
Zoning & city compliance
Environmental
Structural
Coordinate transfer of funds & prorations
Close of escrow
42 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO
CLOSING PROCESS
DISCOVERY& PRELIMINARY MARKETING CONTRACT BUYER’S DUE DILIGENCE
contingencies
transition to new ownership 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 8 9 10 10 11 12 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 WEEKS Initial Offers Select a Buyer Buyer is Non-Refundable Close of Escrow INITIAL OFFERS BEST & FINAL MARKETING PROCESS
Reduce buyer’s due diligence & potential for retrade Creates competitive environment/limits buyer
Maximize value Seller controls terms of transaction Minimize seller’s risk Successful
MARKETING STRATEGY
Dedicated Property Website
Dynamic, user-friendly websites.
Speed-to-market with round-the-clock support for immediate changes.
Online document center with integrated activity tracking.
Online Lead Registration
Instant access to secure documents.
Interested buyer tracker and reporting.
Enables advisors to prioritize and follow up on inquiries immediately.
Seller Access
View prospects, buyer feedback, offer activity and status updates.
Effective team communication and coordination during process.
Peace of mind knowing your data is secure.
Real-Time
Nationwide Database
Buyer and sale information.
Current historical market information.
Tracking of assets and loans.
Email Campaign
Customized to reach every potential buyer, wherever they may be.
Mobile-friendly emails to reach buyers on the go. Reach thousands of qualified buyers with targeted lists that drive traffic to the property website.
Print Campaign
Visually compelling, data-driven marketing materials customized for your asset.
Local, regional and national assignment coverage.
Reach more potential buyers through re-engagement strategies.
BEST IN CLASS SUPPORT
A LONG TRADITION OF TAKING THE LONG VIEW.
44 BERKADIA / ELIZABETH PORTFOLIO
Not your typical CRE firm.
Before we tell you what we are, we’d like to tell you what we’re not. We’re not tied to quarterly earnings reports, because we’re privately held. Our ownership structure is unique, so we can think, solve, and react differently.
We’re a joint venture of Berkshire Hathaway and Jefferies Financial Group – both of which are renowned for their capital strength and sophisticated investment strategies. We have Investment Sales, Mortgage Banking, and Servicing seamlessly integrated so we can adapt in real time—which means we’ll craft custom, long-term solutions that deliver the best outcomes.
We’re Berkadia. A different kind of CRE firm. With industry-leading investments in technology, and data-driven insights from the country’s most skilled CRE experts, we’re built to be more flexible, creative, and innovative. Deal after deal. Year after year.
INVESTMENT ADVISORS
NAT GAMBUZZA
Senior Managing Director
NJ DRE #0123988
973.809.1755
nat.gambuzza@berkadia.com
TREVOR FIEBEL
Senior Director
NJ DRE #1431448
908.285.6921
trevor.fiebel@berkadia.com
NICK BALANCIA
Associate Director
NJ DRE #2322128
908.642.1905
nick.balancia@berkadia.com
BRIAN ANTOGNINI
Senior Transaction Manager
NJ DRE #1111667
201.739.2331
brian.antognini@berkadia.com
MORRISTOWN, NEW JERSEY
17 Headquarters Plaza West Tower
8th Floor
Morristown, NJ 07960
DISCLAIMER
The material contained in this document is confidential, furnished solely for the purpose of considering investment in the property described therein and is not to be copied and/or used for any purpose or made available to any other person without the express written consent of Berkadia Real Estate Advisors LLC and Berkadia Real Estate Advisors Inc. In accepting this, the recipient agrees to keep all material contained herein confidential.
This information package has been prepared to provide summary information to prospective purchasers and to establish a preliminary level of interest in the property described herein. It does not, however, purport to present all material information regarding the subject property, and it is not a substitute for a thorough due diligence investigation. In particular, Berkadia Real Estate Advisors LLC, Berkadia Real Estate Advisors Inc. and Seller have not made any investigation of the actual property, the tenants, the operating history, financial reports, leases, square footage, age or any other aspect of the property, including but not limited to any potential environmental problems that may exist and make no warranty or representation whatsoever concerning these issues. The information contained in this information package has been obtained from sources we believe to be reliable; however, Berkadia Real Estate Advisors LLC, Berkadia Real Estate Advisors Inc. and Seller have not conducted any investigation regarding these matters and make no warranty or representation whatsoever regarding the accuracy or completeness of the information provided. Any pro formas, projections, opinions, assumptions or estimates used are for example only and do not necessarily represent the current or future performance of the property.
Berkadia Real Estate Advisors LLC and Berkadia Real Estate Advisors Inc. and Seller strongly recommend that prospective purchasers conduct an in-depth investigation of every physical and financial aspect of the property to determine if the property meets their needs and expectations. We also recommend that prospective purchasers consult with their tax, financial and legal advisors on any matter that may affect their decision to purchase the property and the subsequent consequences of ownership.
All parties are advised that in any property the presence of certain kinds of molds, funguses, or other organisms may adversely affect the property and the health of some individuals. Berkadia Real Estate Advisors LLC and Berkadia Real Estate Advisors Inc. recommend, if prospective buyers have questions or concerns regarding this issue, that prospective buyers conduct further inspections by a qualified professional.
The Seller retains the right to withdraw, modify or cancel this offer to sell at any time and without any notice or obligation. Any sale is subject to the sole and unrestricted approval of Seller, and Seller shall be under no obligation to any party until such time as Seller and any other necessary parties have executed a contract of sale containing terms and conditions acceptable to Seller and such obligations of Seller shall only be those in such contract of sale.
For more information on these and other Berkadia® exclusive listings, please visit our website at www.berkadia.com
Berkadia®, a joint venture of Berkshire Hathaway and Jefferies Financial Group, is an industry leading commercial real estate company providing comprehensive capital solutions and investment sales advisory and research services for multifamily and commercial properties. Berkadia® is amongst the largest, highest rated and most respected primary, master and special servicers in the industry.
© 2024 Berkadia Proprietary Holding LLC
Berkadia® is a trademark of Berkadia Proprietary Holding LLC
Investment sales and real estate brokerage businesses are conducted exclusively by Berkadia Real Estate Advisors LLC and Berkadia Real Estate Advisors Inc. Commercial mortgage loan origination and servicing businesses are conducted exclusively by Berkadia Commercial Mortgage LLC and Berkadia Commercial Mortgage Inc. Tax credit syndication business is conducted exclusively by Berkadia Affordable Tax Credit Solutions. In California, Berkadia Real Estate Advisors Inc. conducts business under CA Real Estate Broker License #01931050; Adrienne Barr, CA DRE Lic. # 01308753. Berkadia Commercial Mortgage LLC conducts business under CA Finance Lender & Broker Lic. #988-0701; and Berkadia Commercial Mortgage Inc. under CA Real Estate Broker Lic. #01874116. This proposal is not intended to solicit commercial mortgage company business in Nevada. For state licensing details for the above entities, visit www.berkadia.com/licensing.