Zeek | Jewish Mysticism in the University: Academic Study or Theological Practice? |... Page 1 of 4
December 07
Jewish Mysticism in the University: Academic Study or Theological Practice? by Boaz Huss p. 2 of 2
December 2007 Moreover, there is certainly no common element between the socalled “mystical” cultural
Why Social Justice Needs
formations within Jewish culture,
Religion
and the so-called “mystical”
Jo Ellen Green Kaiser
phenomena in other cultures. I do not see any significant commonality between a Kabbalist hearing the voice of the Shechina, a Catholic nun who is spiritually
It's the Deep Structure, Stupid Jay Michaelson
betrothed to Christ, or a Buddhist monk who aspires to attain
Jewish Mysticism in the
Nirvana. The reductionist
University: Academic Study
assumption that all these
or Theological Practice?
phenomena have a common
Boaz Huss
denominator, which stands in stark contradiction to the self perception of the so called `mystics` themselves, is not
Light Fell Evan Fallenberg
based on any fact, other than the pre-existing assumption of the
Three Poems by Alicia
researchers.
Ostriker Alicia Ostriker
In other words, the problem with using the category “mysticism” in
Festival of Cant: The
scientific study is not only that it
“Israel Lobby” and
is opposed to the perception of
Abraham Foxman
the subjects of the research, but
Gordon Haber
also that is puts together many different cultural formations, which have no connection other than scholars’ assumption that behind them lies a common, universal phenomenon. This is already sufficient reason to avoid using the category “mysticism” in academic scholarship. However, even beyond the fact that the term is an inappropriate essentialist term, there is also a third problem: that the very use of it supports a
History for the Untrained: A Look at Six Days Ron Nachmann
particular theological position. Another Place, A Foreign As I have argued above, the use of the term mysticism implies that people, in all
City—An Excerpt
cultures, sometimes experience an encounter with the Divine, or a transcendent reality.
Maya Arad
Using this assumption to categorize cultural formations and to establish academic fields that are devoted to their study is based on the assumption that the cause of various historical, cultural and social phenomena is the encounter with the Divine or the
Boaz Kadman: A Selection Boaz Kadman
Transcendent reality. Any assumption that God, or a transcendent entity, or a metaphysical reality, is the cause of natural, historical, social or cultural events is a theological assumption, which is fundamentally opposed to the way that academic
Against Mourning
research is conducted in the study of natural science, the humanities, or the social
Anne Goldman
sciences. Just as academic study in the natural sciences rejects the theory of intelligent design, and the academic study of history and social sciences cannot accept the will of
Cover:
God as a valid explanation for historical and social events, we, too cannot accept that
It's Thrilling
encounters with the Deity or a transcendental reality can explain cultural phenomena—
Daniel Greene
neither in Judaism, nor in other cultures. Thus, in my opinion, there is no place in the academy for the category “Jewish mysticism,” and consequently, no place for the debate whether to teach `Jewish Mysticism` in a theoretical or an experiential manner. I would like to emphasize that I do not deny the existence of the texts and practices that scholars include in this problematic category; nor do I oppose their study as significant
http://www.zeek.net/712academy/index.php?page=2
Upcoming events Book Launch Party for Righteous Indignation: A
07/02/2008
Zeek | Jewish Mysticism in the University: Academic Study or Theological Practice? |... Page 2 of 4
historical and social formations. I do not deny that people have indeed put their heads
Jewish Call for Justice
between their knees, whispered hymns and praises, repeated names of angels, spent
January 9, 2008
time in solitude, or prostrated themselves upon the graves of saints; I do not doubt that the people who employed these techniques experienced exceptional events which they described as “Descending to the Chariot” [yerida la-merkava], prophecy [nevu’a], or “cleaving to Nothingness” [devequt be-ayin]. I do not reject the important studies that
Found In Translation March 2, 2008
have examined these descriptions within their historical and social context. Rather, my argument is directed against the assumption that these are all expressions of “Jewish
Praise, Grumble, Schmooze,
mysticism”, and against the research practices that ensue from this assumption, mainly
Lament
the use of comparative and phenomenological methods that are common in the study of
January 31, 2008
religions. I doubt that all these cultural formations, as well as other phenomena that modern scholarship perceives as “mystical” in various cultures (Christian, Muslim, Chinese, Japanese, Indian, American, and others) have any common factor (or factors) that is exclusive only to them, which justifies categorizing them as “Mystical” and establishing fields of study and methods of teaching and research, that are unique to them. [9]
The Teaching of Theology in an Academic Context
Archive 850 Back Pages of Zeek... for free
Subscribe Now To our print edition
Although I am arguing that the term “mysticism” is theological in nature, and inappropriate as a category to be used in the framework of an academic research of historical and sociological phenomena, I would like to emphasize again that I am not opposed to theology, but only claim that it should not serve as the basis for academic
About Zeek Recommended Books
study, whether in the natural sciences, the humanities, or the social sciences. The only
Advertise on Zeek
question that remains is whether there is anywhere else to fit theological study into the
Support Zeek
academy, outside the fields of natural sciences, humanities, or social sciences. Mailing List As we all know, leading and prestigious universities in the United States and Europe have
Contact Us
“divinity schools.” These schools teach theology, and train clergy. Should we establish
Tech Support
such divinity schools, or programs for the teaching of spiritual studies and the training of Kabbalists within Israeli academic institutions? Should we set up academic frameworks which will deal with spiritual and theological questions (such as the nature of encounters
Partners Links
with the Divine in various religions) and with mystical and religious practices— prayer, meditation, and the experiential study of Kabbalistic texts, on the assumption that these texts are an expression of some kind of universal mystical or spiritual experience? The suggestion to set up study programs, departments, or schools for theology and spirituality raises two basic questions. The first is what types of theology or spirituality should be taught in academic frameworks: only Jewish theology, or also Muslim, Christian, Buddhist, New Age, and other theologies? Furthermore, when teaching Jewish theology and spirituality, should the “school for spirituality” teach liberal Orthodox, Reform, and Conservative theologies, or the doctrines and practices of Merkaz Harav, the Chabad movement, or the Kabbalah Centre? What methods of religious praxis should they employ: meditation and experiential reading of texts, or also prayer, writing amulets, and visiting the graves of saints? In brief, the question is: what criteria should be used to decide what theologies and spiritual practices belong in an academic context, and what should be the distinction between the theologico-spiritual activity in the academy and the theologico-spiritual activity in yeshivot or other non-academic institutions? The second question, which is related to the first, is: what should be the criteria for evaluating students, or hiring and promoting instructors, in the framework of a theological school in the academy? What training should be required for an instructor of theology or spirituality? Is an academic degree in liberal arts or social sciences at all relevant for such an instructor, or should we prefer to hire theologians and spiritual
University of Wales British Validated BA, MA Degrees Bible, Theology, Ministry, online www.trinitysem.edu
masters, such as Yitzhak Ginzburgh, Ohad Ezrachi, or Philip Berg? On what basis should grades and degrees be granted to people who choose to attend a continuing education program in theology or spiritual in an academic context? I have no answers to these rather rhetorical questions. As I have said, my field is the historical and social study of Kabbalah; I am neither a theologian nor a mystic. As an
http://www.zeek.net/712academy/index.php?page=2
07/02/2008
Zeek | Jewish Mysticism in the University: Academic Study or Theological Practice? |... Page 3 of 4
academic scholar of Kabbalah, I find it important to examine the theological assumptions that have shaped my discipline, and to critically analyze the category “Jewish mysticism” and the “mystification” of Kabbalah.
Search n zeek.net m i j k l m n Web j k l
Footnotes [9] For a similar argument concerning the term `Religion,` see T. Fitzgerald, `Playing Language Games And Performing Rituals: Religious Studies Ideological State Apparatus`, Method & Theory 15 (2003), p. 249.
Professor Boaz Huss teaches in the Department of Jewish Thought at the Ben-Gurion University of the Negev « Previous 1
| 2
Related A BuJu Responds to Sam Harris Jay Michaelson November 2007
A Hymn of Praise to Sabbatei Zevi Translated by Gavriel Wasserman June 2007
Creeds are the Ashes from the Fire of Religion Joshua Liebman (and colleague) September 2006
Free Will: The Last Gasp of the Unenlightened Mind Jay Michaelson July 2007
Zionism, Anti-Semitism, and the Boundaries of Dissent: Round 2 of the Alvin Rosenfeld Debate Shaul Magid and Paul Bogdanor April 2007
http://www.zeek.net/712academy/index.php?page=2
07/02/2008
Zeek | Jewish Mysticism in the University: Academic Study or Theological Practice? |... Page 4 of 4
The History of "Tikkun Olam" Jill Jacobs June 2007
The Power and the Glory: A Critique of "New Age" Kabbalah Dr. Jonathan Garb April 2006
Save this article Add to del.icio.us Digg it
Subscribe to feed
Google Reader or Homepage
Subscribe in FeedLounge
http://www.zeek.net/712academy/index.php?page=2
07/02/2008