Captivating Children by A Blue Drum Evidence Room

!"#$%&"$%'()!*%+,-.')/)0*-12(*)3-144/32--%32+"-) $."3*%'()15)6-$7)83%.'3.)"',)0.3*'1+1(9) ) ) ) 6)#-13.44)4$2,9)-.#1-$)1')#*"4.)$:1)15)$*.);"<1-=/) ;>680?)@-1A.3$) D R A F T No. 1

A uthors: 0V 3DWV\ 2Âś6XOOLYDQ D r. L isa Moran D r. Cormac For kan 15th November 2013 School of Political Science and Sociology, N U I, G alway 1

School of Political Science and Sociology National University of Ireland, Galway Tel: 00 353 91 492290 Web: www.nuigalway.ie/soc

The School of Political Science and Sociology at the National University of Ireland, Galway, undertakes research on a wide range of areas such as, education, the environment, work, crime and deviance, family care and welfare and public policy. The views expressed in this report are those of the authors, and not necessarily those of Babor贸 Management.

A cknowledgements Our sincere thanks to all the young people, teachers, the artist, science and computer technology practitioners and parents who took part in this research. Without their participation and open contributions, none of this would have been possible.

Ms. Patsy O'Sullivan Dr. Lisa Moran Dr. Cormac Forkan

"#$%&!'(!)'*+&*+,! ! ! -.&/0+12&!3044#56! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! " " " "" ! ! )7#8+&5!9*&:!!!!;*+5'<0/+1'*!+'!=->3"?!@5'A&/+!#*<!B&,/518+1'*!'(!@5'A&/+!C'<&%! ! ! ! )7#8+&5!"E':!!!!F1+&5#+05&!G&21&E! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! )7#8+&5!"75&&:!!G&,&#5/7!C&+7'<'%'J6! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! )7#8+&5!L'05:!!"75&&!)#,&!3+0<1&,!'*!@#5+1/18#+1*J!3/7''%,! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! )7#8+&5!L12&:!!G&,&#5/7!L1*<1*J,! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! )7#8+&5!31.:!!B1,/0,,1'*!#*<!G&/'44&*<#+1'*,! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! G&(&5&*/&,! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! >88&*<1.!H! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

!"#$%&'()$*% %

!D!

HI!

! !

KK! !

KD!

! !

MN! !

OI!

! !

IM!

IO!

#$%&'()*%"+',,-./" ! "71,!1,!+7&!,&/'*<!5&8'5+!1*! +7&!85'/&,,!,+0<6!+7#+!('/0,&,!'*!+7&!%&#5*1*J!(5'4!+7&!=->3"?!@5'A&/+! E71/7! 1,! #*! &<0/#+1'*#%! #5+,! #*<! ,/1&*/&! 85'A&/+! +7#+! 7#,! $&&*! <&2&%'8&<! #*<! '8&5#+&<! $6! =#$'5P! VLQFH WKH SURMHFW¶V FRQFHSWLRQ LQ KQHK:!! ! =#$'5P!;*+&5*#+1'*#%!&KLOGUHQ¶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y¶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µORZ FDUERQ¶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µ0DJLF FDQ KDSSHQ $ 3URFHVV 6WXG\ RI %($67 3URMHFW¶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

H!µ67(0¶ VXEMHFWV LQFOXGH VFLHQFH WHFKQRORJ\ HQJLQHHULQJ DQG PDWKHPDWLFV!

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`&%%6!TKQHKVS!G',&!TKQQNV!#*<!>%&.#*<&5!TKQHKV! 1<&*+1(6!+7&!$&*&(1+,!'(!/5',,_/0551/0%#5!+&#/71*J:!!X))>!KQQOS!9(,+&<!KQQKS!B&8#5+4&*+!'(!-<0/#+1'*! #*<!3/1&*/&!KQHMS!8'1*+!+'!+7&!$&*&(1+,!'(!0,1*J!#5+,!1*!+&#/71*J:!!7KH ORQJ WHUP 8. VWXG\ Âµ&UHDWLYH 3DUWQHUVKLSVÂ¶ _KQHHV!E#,! #! J'2&5*4&*+! (0*<&<! &<0/#+1'*#%! 1*1+1#+12&! +7#+! E#,! <&%12&5&<! 1*! 4'5&! +7#*! KS^QQ! ,/7''%,!#*<! E'5R&<! E1+7! 4'5&! +7#*! '*&! 41%%1'*! 6'0*J! 8&'8%&:! ;+! &.#41*&<! +7&! 148#/+! '(! 0,1*J! &.+&5*#%S! /5&#+12&! 85#/+1+1'*&5,! 1*! +7&! +&#/71*J! '(! +7&! ,/7''%! /0551/0%04! #*<! <&4'*,+5#+&<! +7#+! +7&5&! E#,! #! 4&#,05#$%&! 1485'2&4&*+! ('5! +7&! 6'0*J! 8#5+1/18#*+,! 1*! +&54,! '(! 1485'2&<! #++&*<#*/&S! $&7#21'05! #*<! 8&5('54#*/&! T`&*<#%%! $+% ",-! KQQDV! /'48#5&<! +'! +7&! 5&,+! '(! +7&! Y`! ,/7''%! J'1*J! 8'80%#+1'*:! ! G&8'5+,! '*! #5+1,+! #*<! +&#/7&5! /'%%#$'5#+1'*! T>;)-! KQHKS! B&8#5+4&*+! '(! -<0/#+1'*! #*<! 3/1&*/&!KQQIV!71J7%1J7+!+7&!148'5+#*/&!'(!85&8%#**1*J!4&&+1*J,!+'!(#/1%1+#+&!+7&!4'5&!&((&/+12&!<&%12&56! '(! #5+,! E'5R,7'8,:! 3+0<1&,! '*! +7&! 0,&! '(! ;)"! 1*! +7&! <&%12&56! '(! &<0/#+1'*! 85'J5#44&,! $6! a#%%! #*<! 3/7#2#51#*!TKQHHV!('0*<!+7#+!ÂµZKHUH WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V FXULRVLW\ ZDV WKH HQJLQH IRU WKHLU OHDUQLQJ SURIRXQG XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH WRSLF HYROYHGÂ¶ TKQHHbObV%#*<!@#,,&6!$+%",:!TKQQbV!('0*<!+7#+!;)"!7#<!#!4'+12#+1*J! HIIHFW RQ FKLOGUHQÂ¶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ÂµVKLQHÂ¶ DQG DOVR IDFLOLWDWHG PRUH DEOH FKLOGUHQ WR VKDUH +7&15!%&#5*1*J!'5!&.8&51&*/H Âµ7KDWÂ¶V WKH EHDXW\ RI LW ,W FDWHUV IRU HYHU\ OHYHOÂ¶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

)71%<5&*! %&#5*&<! *&E! ,R1%%,! ,0/7! #,! /5&#+12&! E51+1*JS! <5#E1*JS! /'480+&5! 85'J5#441*J:! "7&6! #%,'! <&4'*,+5#+&<! J''<! 5&/#%%S! 1485'2&<! 5&/'5<1*J! #*<! /51+1/#%! +71*R1*J:! @#5&*+,! *'+&<! #! 4'5&! 8',1+12&! #++1+0<&!+'E#5<!,/1&*/&S!+'E#5<,!+7&!8',,1$1%1+6!'(!,/1&*/&!#,!#!/#5&&5!#*<!#%,'!4'5&!#E#5&*&,,!'(!+7&15! HQYLURQPHQW DQG ÂµKRZ WKLQJV ZRUNÂ¶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ÂµFKLOG_OHGÂ¶ DQG WR LQFRUSRUDWH PRUH RI WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V ÂµOLYHG H[SHULHQFHVÂ¶ LQ RUGHU WR /5&#+&!4'5&!&*+70,1#,4!#*<!8#5+1/18#+1'*!$6!+7&!/71%<5&*:!!!! ! G&,&#5/7! 8#5+1/18#*+,! ,+#+&<! +7#+! 85#/+1+1'*&5,! E&5&! 71J7%6! &*+70,&<! $6! +7&15! ,0$A&/+,! #*<! +71,! &*+70,1#,4S!/'08%&<!E1+7!+7&!#$1%1+6!+'!&*J#J&!E1+7!+7&!6'0*J!8&'8%&S!E#,!,&&*!#,!#!R&6!&%&4&*+!'(! WKH HIIHFWLYHQHVV RI WKH PRGHO 7HDFKHUV GLVFXVVHG WKDW FKLOGUHQ KDG PRUH ÂµRZQHUVKLSÂ¶ RI WKH ZRUN E7&*!+7&6!7#<!,1J*1(1/#*+!1*80+!1*+'!<&/1,1'*,!#$'0+!+7&!E'5R:!"7&6!(&%+!+7#+!1+!E#,!#!2&56!E'5+7E71%&! #*<! &./1+1*J! 85'A&/+! E71/7! /7#%%&*J&<! +7&4! +'! 1*+5'<0/&! +7&! /5&#+12&! #5+,! 1*! ,/1&*/&! #*<! %1+&5#+05&! +&#/71*J!1*!+7&!/%#,,5''4:!a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ÂµEX\ LQÂ¶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a1J7!%&2&%,!'(!&*J#J&4&*+!E&5&!'$,&52&<!1*!+7&!/71%<5&*!E7&*!+7&6!E&5&!1*2'%2&<!E1+7!4'5&! 1*+&5#/+12&!&%&4&*+,!'(!E'5R,7'8,:!"71,!7#,!$&&*!'*&!'(!+7&!4',+!,0//&,,(0%!'0+/'4&,!'(!+7&! 85'A&/+!DV LW KDV IDFLOLWDWHG ÂµGHHS OHDUQLQJÂ¶ LQ WKH FODVVURRP ,+!1,!5&/'44&*<&<!+7#+!E'5R,7'8,! 6

1*!KQHb!,7'0%<!/'*+1*0&!+'!$&!<&,1J*&<!+'!1*/%0<&!#!E1<&!5#*J&!'(!'88'5+0*1+1&,!('5!1*+&5#/+1'*! #*<!,7'0%<!$&!/71%<_%&<!E7&5&!8',,1$%&:! ! ! )'%%#$'5#+1'*! ,7'0%<! /'*+1*0&! +'! 7#2&! #! 71J7! 851'51+6! #+! &2&56! %&2&%! '(! +7&! 85'A&/+! #*<! 4'5&! '88'5+0*1+1&,!+'!/'%%#$'5#+&!,7'0%<!$&!$01%+!1*+'!85'A&/+!148%&4&*+#+1'*:!! !!

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b:!

!!!

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µ7R EH KRQHVW ,¶G KDY$%+*'.+%/&%01"+%2")3*4%03',5%63($%'7% ZLWK ,WV YHU\ ZHOO UXQ DQG ,¶P YHU\ LPSUHVVHG DQG LW¶V D JUHDW SULYLOHJH IRU WKH FKLOGUHQ DQG P\VHOI WR EH LQYROYHG ZLWK LW ¶T"&#/7&5!MV! !

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c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y &KLOGUHQÂ¶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b +7!Â±!KQ+7!9/+'$&5!KQHM:! ! %DERUy &KLOGUHQÂ¶V $UWV )HVWLYDO EHJDQ DV RQH HOHPHQW RI WKH *DOZD\ $UWV )HVWLYDO LQ DQG WKH '5J#*1,#+1'*! <&2&%'8&<! 1*+'! 1+,! 'E*! <&<1/#+&<! (&,+12#%! 1*! HNN^K:! ;*! +7&! ,&2&*+&&*! 6&#5,! ,1*/&! 1+,! &,+#$%1,74&*+! 1+! 7#,! ('/0,&<! '*! 4#R1*J! #5+! #//&,,1$%&! +'! #%%! /71%<5&*! 1*/%0<1*J! $#$1&,S! +'<<%&5,! #*<! WHHQDJHUV ,Q %DERUy KRVWHG D FRQIHUHQFH Âµ1DWXUDO %RUQ $UWLVWV _!$UWV IRU (DUO\ <HDUV LQ ,UHODQGÂ¶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Âµ8"#/6%6"&%9"77$&%Â±%:%!*36$..% 6WXG\ 5HSRUW RI WKH %DERUy %($67 3URMHFWÂ¶ <&21,&<! #! ,&/'*<! 87#,&! '(! =->3"?! +'! $&! <&%12&5&<! 1*! ,/7''%,!1*!KQHM:!"71,!5&8'5+!1,!+7&!,&/'*<!85'/&,,!,+0<6!'(!=->3"?!#*<!<'/04&*+,!+7&!85'/&,,&,!#*<! '0+/'4&,!'(!+7&!85'A&/+!1*!KQHM:! ! ! DEDEF"G-()74-C%" K!B&+#1%,!'*!&,+#$%1,74&*+!'(!=#$'5P!#*<!=->3"?!@5'A&/+!(5'4!@5'A&/+!B'/04&*+#+1'*W8&5,'*#%!1*+&521&E,:! M!7KH WHUP ÂµVFLHQWLVWÂ¶ LQFOXGHV UHVHDUFKHUV DQG DFDGHPLF VWDII WKDW FDPH IURP ELRORJLFDO DQG PDULQH VFLHQFH,S!/'480+&5!

,/1&*/&!#*<!&*J1*&&51*J!<1,/18%1*&,:!

=#$'5P!1<&*+1(1&<!+7&!5#+1'*#%&!$&71*<!+7&!&,+#$%1,74&*+!'(!+7&!=->3"?!@5'A&/+\! ! Âµ:*+.% "&5% 6*$"+/;$% "6+/;/+/$.% "*$% 3<% $&3*(3'.% )$&$</+% <3*% =3'&#% 61/,5*$&% ".% +1$=% $&#$&5$*% 63&</5$&6$>%$&63'*"#$%6*/+/6",%*$<,$6+/3&%"&5%6*$"+/;$%+1/&?/&#%"&5%7*3;/5$%"%730$*<',%)".$%<3*% WHDP ZRUNLQJ SUREOHP VROYLQJ DQG IXWXUH GHYHORSPHQW Â¶!T@5'A&/+!85'8',#%V! ! 7KH RULJLQDO LGHD IRU WKH %($67 3URMHFW ZDV LQVSLUHG E\ D SURMHFW LQ WKH 8. FDOOHG Âµ7KH $5. 3URMHFWÂ¶ E71/7!E'5R&<!E1+7!+&/7*'%'J1,+,S!#5+1,+,!#*<!/71%<5&*!+'!/5&#+&!#!%1(&_,1d&<!>G`!#5+!1*,+#%%#+1'*!#*<!1*!+7&! 85'/&,,! 1*,815&<! #*! &./1+&4&*+! #*<! 1*+&5&,+! 1*! ,/1&*/&! #*<! #5+! 1*! +7&! 6'0*J! 8#5+1/18#*+,:! B1,/0,,1'*! #*<!5&(%&/+1'*!$5'0J7+!=#$'5P!+'![0&,+1'*!+7&!5&%#+1'*,718!$&+E&&*!,/1&*/&S!#5+!#*<!7'E!$&,+!+'!<&,1J*! #!85'A&/+!+7#+!E'0%<!0,&!#5+!+'!/5&#+&!*&E!E#6,!'(!%&#5*1*J!,/1&*/&!#*<!+&/7*'%'J6!('5!8514#56!,/7''%! /71%<5&*:!!! ! Âµ:H ZDQWHG WR JLYH WKH FKLOGUHQ DQ H\H@37$&/&#% $A7$*/$&6$>% 01$*$% +1$% 03*,5% 37$&.% '7% B+3% +1$(C%"&5%+1$=%#$+%+1$%$A6/+$($&+%+1"+%3&$%#$+.%<*3(%&$0%,$"*&/&#%"&5%+1$%.$&.$%3<%03&5$*-% BD$%0"&+$5%+1$(C%+3%)$%"),$%+3%+"?$%+1$%&$0%?&30,$5#$%"&5%$A7,3*$%"&5%6*$"+$%+1$%1")/+%3<%"% ,/<$+/($-%:&5%0$%0"&+$5%+3%)*/&#%?&30,$5#$%/&%"%.'773*+/;$%0"=>%63&+$A+'",/.$%?&30,$5#$>%.3% WKDW SUDFWLWLRQHUV ZRXOG DFW DV IDFLOLWDWRUVÂ« ZRXOG ! E3'*&$=% B0/+1% +1$% 61/,5*$&C>% % ,$"*&/&#% "&5% H[SORULQJ >WRJHWKHU@ Â¶ T=#$'5P!B15&/+'5V! ! 7KH Âµ$UWV LQ (GXFDWLRQ &KDUWHUÂ¶ '(6 KDV LQIRUPHG WKH ZRUN RI WKH %($67 LQ DQG %DERUy #5&!1*2'%2&<!1*!+7&!/'*,0%+#+1'*!85'/&,,&,!'(!+7&!/7#5+&5:!!"7&!J'#%,!'(!+7&!/7#5+&5!#5&!+'!8%#/&!+7&!#5+,! #+! +7&! /&*+5&! '(! +7&! &<0/#+1'*! ,6,+&P 7KH PHDQV RI GRLQJ WKLV LQFOXGH FUHDWLQJ ÂµDUWV_ULFK VFKRROVÂ¶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ÂµGRVH HIIHFWÂ¶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

DEDE!"@.7A%&("3IA%&()*%:" _ "'!4#556!3/1&*/&S!"&/7*'%'J6!T3"-CVb!DQG WKH $UWV LQ H[SORULQJ D Âµ/RZ &DUERQ )XWXUHÂ¶ ZLWK 8514#56!,/7''%!/71%<5&*!+7'0J7!#!,&51&,!'(!E'5R,7'8,!<&%12&5&<!$6!3/1&*+1,+,!#*<!>5+1,+! _ 7R FUHDWH DQ DUWLVWLF UHVSRQVH XVLQJ WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶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b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Â¶V VHQVH RI EHORQJLQJ DWWLWXGHV +'E#5<,! ,/1&*/&! #*<! *#+05&! #*<! +7&15! (&&%1*J,! #$'0+! ,/7''%:! >,! E&%%! #,! +71,S! 1*_<&8+7! <#+#! /'%%&/+&<! +75'0J7!1*+&521&E,!#*<!@#5+1/18#*+!9$,&52#+1'*!T@9V!&*#$%&<!+7&!5&,&#5/7&5,!+'!5&2&#%!,'4&!/'48%&.! 8#++&5*,!XQGHUSLQQLQJ FKLOGUHQÂ¶V UHDFWLRQV WR WKH GLIIHUHQW WRSLFV DQG WKHLU VHQVH RI HQJDJHPHQW LQ WKH /5&#+12&!85'/&,,:!" ! DEF"@.7A%&("9%(-)C:" " DEFED">1%"<#=+>?"FMDH"@.7A%&("+(-;;)4N" 9*&! 4&4$&5! '(! =#$'5P! ,+#((! E#,! <&<1/#+&<! +'! 4#*#J&! +7&! 85'A&/+! 8#5+! +14&! '2&5! +7&! 85'A&/+! +14&! (5#4&:! 9*&! 4&4$&5!'(! ,+#((! 85'21<&<! #<41*1,+5#+12&! ,088'5+!+'!+7&! 85'A&/+! '*! #!8#5+!+14&!$#,1,:! "E'! (05+7&5! 4&4$&5,! '(! 4#*#J&4&*+! ,+#((! E&5&! 1*2'%2&<! 1*! +7&! 85'A&/+! <&,1J*! #*<! 148%&4&*+#+1'*:! 9*&! b!Âµ67(0Â¶ UHIHUV WR WKH LQLWLDO JRDO RI LQFUHDVLQJ LQWHUHVW LQ \RXQJ FKLOGUHQ LQ 6FLHQFH 7HFKQRORJ\ (QJLQHHULQJ DQG!

C#+7&4#+1/,!,0$A&/+,:!

87'+'J5#87&5!E#,! &48%'6&<! +'! 5&/'5<! +7&! E'5R,7'8,!0,1*J! ,+1%%! /#4&5#!#*<! 21<&'! /#4&5#! +'! ('54! #! YLVXDO UHFRUG RI WKH ZRUN GRQH ZLWK WKH FKLOGUHQ 2QH SHUVRQ ZDV HPSOR\HG WR FXUDWH WKH FKLOGUHQ¶V #5+1,+1/! E'5R! ('5! +7&! =->3"?! KQHM! -.8%'5#+'5104! 1*+&5#/+12&! &.71$1+1'*:! ;*! #<<1+1'*! #! (05+7&5! &1J7+&&*! 85#/+1+1'*&5,! (5'4! <1((&5&*+! <1,/18%1*&,! E&5&! 1*2'%2&<! 1*! <15&/+! <&%12&56! '5! 1*! ,088'5+1*J! 5'%&,:! "71,! /'4851,&<U!('05!XY;Z!5&,&#5/7&,\!('05!3/1&*+1,+,\!+E'!)'480+&5!3/1&*+1,+,\!'*&!>5+1,+!#*<!(12&!+&#/7&5,! $#,&<!1*!+7&!M!,/7''%,!85'21<1*J!,088'5+!+'!+7&!,/1&*/&S!#5+!#*<!/'480+&5!,/1&*/&!85#/+1+1'*&5,!#,!+7&6! <&%12&5&<!+7&15!E'5R,7'8,!+'!+7&!/71%<5&*:!>!+'+#%!'(!KM!8&'8%&!E&5&!1*2'%2&<!1*!+7&!85'A&/+!#*<!#%%!'(! +7&,&!E&5&!1*2'%2&<!'*!#!8#5+!+14&!$#,1,:! ! DEFEF"O'48)4N" =#$'5P!5&/&12&<!(0*<1*J!('5!+7&!=->3"?!KQHM!@5'A&/+!(5'4!+7&!('%%'E1*J!$'<1&,U!_!! _ 18, *DOZD\ µ%ULJKW ,GHDV ,QQRYDWLRQ )XQG¶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b+7!'5!O+7!)%#,,!#*<!#J&<!(5'4!&1J7+!6&#5,!+'!&%&2&*!6&#5,:!!!

" " DEH">1%"<#=+>?"B78%C"""

"7&!<1,/0,,1'*!#*<!8%#**1*J!('5!+7&!85'A&/+!+''R!8%#/&!'2&5!4'5&!+7#*!#!6&#5!(5'4!KQHH!#*<!1*2'%2&<! /'*,0%+#+1'*!E1+7!+7&!G6#*!;*,+1+0+&!#+!XY;!Z#%E#6S!,/1&*+1,+,!#*<!'+7&5!#5+,!85#/+1+1'*&5,!1*!;5&%#*<!#*<! 1*!+7&!Y`:!>(+&5!+7&!5&,&#5/7!87#,&!#!4'<&%!'(!<&%12&56!E#,!<&,1J*&<!#*<!+''R!+7&!('%%'E1*J!('54#+:! "71,!4'<&%!E#,!(05+7&5!5&(1*&<!#(+&5!=->3"?!KQHK!#*<!1,!'0+%1*&<!7&5&!T,&&!L1J05&!H!$&%'EVU!

O)N'.%"DE"<-I7.P"<#=+>?"B78%C"FMDH" "

" " " " " " " " " " " " " " " "" " " " " " Project Model " " " Process " Study Reports to "cover the 3 years of " BEAST!

Collaborative Relationship between Baboró and Ryan Institute Development of Brief for STEM Projects.

Matching of Schools with STEM and Art Practitioner using logistical and topical criteria.

Scientists deliver 4 x 1 ! hr Workshops to selected Primary School children. Participant Observation by social researchers (NUIG)

Artist delivers 4 x 2 hr Workshops to the same selected Primary School children. Participant Observation by social researchers (NUIG) Computer scientists deliver 5 x 70 min SCRATCH programming workshops to same school groups. Participant Observation by social researchers (NUIG)

E X PE C T E D O U T C O M ES

New Knowledge and Attitude to STEM subjects in young participants. Development of creative self/ behavioural changes

Teacher engagement and increased awareness of using art in science curriculum

Increased awareness and involvement of parents

Exhibition/ µ([SORUDWRULXP engage with Public Audiences

" " " " DEHED">1%"+&)%4();)&"#4N-N%,%4(! ;*!&#5%6!KQHK!=#$'5P!#885'#/7&<!+7&!G6#*!;*,+1+0+&!TXY;ZV!+'!/'%%#$'5#+&!1*!+7&!<&%12&56!'(!+7&!85'A&/+:!! "7&!G6#*!;*,+1+0+&!,&*+!'0+!#!/#%%!+'!#%%!0*12&5,1+6!<&8#5+4&*+,!E71/7!<&+#1%&<!+7&!$51&(!('5!85'8',#%,!+'! 50*!M!,/1&*/&!T3"-CV!E'5R,7'8,!THe!+'!K!7'05,!&#/7V!E1+7!8514#56!,/7''%,!1*!)'0*+6!Z#%E#6:!"7&5&! E#,! #*! &*+70,1#,+1/! 5&,8'*,&! (5'4! +7&! #/#<&41/! /'440*1+6! #*<! +7&! 85'A&/+! '0+/'4&,! 7#2&! $&&*! GHWDLOHG LQ µ8"#/6% 6"&% 9"77$&% @% %HDVW 3URMHFW 3URFHVV 6WXG\ 5HSRUW 2QH¶ L'%%'E1*J! '*! (5'4! +7&! (1*<1*J,!'(!+7&!85'/&,,!,+0<6!=#$'5P!<&/1<&<!+'!('/0,!+7&!85'A&/+!'*!+7&!+75&&!,/7''%,!#*<!,&%&/+&<!M! ,/1&*+1,+,!+'!E'5R!E1+7!1*<121<0#%!,/7''%,:!! ! ! ! 12

DEHEF

>1%"+&)%4&%"@.7A%&(">72)&:"" " "7&!,/1&*+1,+,!E&5&!#%%!5&,&#5/7&5,!(5'4!XY;Z!#*<!E&5&!&.8&5+,!1*!+7&15!(1&%<!'(!5&,&#5/7:!>%%!7#<!851'5! &.8&51&*/&!'5!R*'E%&<J&!'(!+7&!85'A&/+!(5'4!+7&!E'5R!1*!KQHK!#*<!('5!+71,!,&+!'(!E'5R,7'8,!+7&!$51&(! E#,! $5'#<:! ;+! E#,! +'! <&,1J*! #! ,&51&,! '(! ('05! H! e! _! K! 7'05! E'5R,7'8,! +7#+! E'0%<! +&#/7! /'*/&8+,! '(! ,/1&*/&!0,1*J!#,!1%%0,+5#+1'*!+7&15!#5&#!'(!5&,&#5/7!1*!#!E#6!+7#+!E#,!#J&!#885'851#+&!#*<!+7#+!E'0%<! LQFOXGH GLVFXVVLRQV DURXQG WKH HQYLURQPHQW DQG DÂ¶ ORZ FDUERQ IXWXUHÂ¶ )URP H[SHULHQFH LQ ,/1&*+1,+,! R*&E!+7#+! +7&! /71%<5&*! 5&,8'*<&<! 2&56!E&%%!+'! 7#*<,! '*!&.&5/1,&,:! "7&! 3/1&*+1,+,! +''R! +7&! +'81/!'(!&*&5J6!J&*&5#+1'*!#,!#*!'2&5#%%!+7&4&!#*<!/5&#+&<! #!%1*R!$&+E&&*!+7&!+75&&!<1((&5&*+!,&+,!'(! E'5R,7'8,! $6! R&&81*J! 1*! 41*<! +7&! [0&,+1'*! Âµ:KDW LI \RX DUH VWUDQGHG RQ WKH $UDQ ,VODQGV ZLWKRXW $,$6+*/6/+=----01"+% 53% =3'% 53F! "7&! 85'A&/+,! 0*<&5+#R&*! 1*! &#/7! '(! +7&! ,/7''%,! E71/7! +''R! 8#5+! 1*! +7&! =->3"?!KQHM!85'A&/+!#5&!'0+%1*&<!1*!L1J05&!K!T$&%'EV\! ! O)N'.%"F5"Q):("7;"+&177C:"-48"@.7A%&(:"9%:&.)2()74:"

+&177C" Z#%E#6!-<0/#+&!"'J&+7&5!X#+1'*#%!3/7''%! X&E/#,+%&S!Z#%E#6:!

@.7A%&("9%:&.)2()74" 3&#E&&<!#*<!-.8%'51*J!=1'!(0&%,:!BX>!"&,+1*J!Â±! "71,!85'A&/+!&.8%'5&<!+7&!1*+&5/'**&/+&<*&,,!'(! 4#51*&!%1(&!'((!+7&!/'#,+!'(!)'0*+6!Z#%E#6!$0+!#%,'! 1*,815&<!6'0*J!8&'8%&!+'!+71*R!#$'0+!1*+&5*#+1'*#%! 4#51*&!&*215'*4&*+,:!)71%<5&*!E&5&!&.8',&<!+'! <1((&5&*+!2#51&+1&,!'(!,&#E&&<!#*<!#%J#&!#*<!+7&15! 5'%&!1*!1*+&5*#+1'*#%!&/',6,+&4,:!! 3/'f%!;*,&!Z0#15&S!Z'5+! >%+&5*#+12&!-*&5J6!Â±!-*&5J6!J&*&5#+1'*!#*<! 8&5,'*#%!8'E&5!85'<0/+1'*:!3+'51*J!#*<!/'*2&5+1*J! &*&5J6!#*<!7#52&,+1*J!&*&5J6!(5'4!*#+05#%! 5&,'05/&,!#*<!(5'4!#*<!8&'8%&!<051*J!4'+1'*! !3/'f%!#*!)014f*!#J0,!)7#+5f'*#S!Y#/7+#5!>5<S!)'! 34#5+!<&21/&,!('5!,4#5+!&*&5J6!/'*,048+1'*! Z#%E#6! Z5&&*!#*<!,0,+#1*#$%&!1*('54#+1'*!+&/7*'%'J6:! &DUERQ XVDJH VFLHQFH DV ÂµDOO DURXQG XVÂ¶ DQG FKLOGUHQÂ¶V UHSUHVHQWDWLRQV RI VXVWDLQDEOH IXWXUHV ! " DEHEH"64)()-C"@.7A%&("<.)%;)4N" =#$'5P!$5'0J7+!+'J&+7&5!+7&!,/1&*+1,+,S!#5+1,+!#*<!'*&!+&#/7&5!#+!#*!1*1+1#%!$51&(1*J!4&&+1*J!1*!>851%!+'! 85'21<&! +7&! $#/RJ5'0*<! +'! +7&! =->3"?! KQHM! @5'A&/+! #*<! +'! #J5&&! E'5R,7'8! ,/7&<0%1*J! #*<! '+7&5! '5J#*1,#+1'*#%!<&+#1%,:!!!!"7&!,'/1#%!5&,&#5/7&5,!(5'4!+7&!3/7''%!'(!@'%1+1/#%!#*<!3'/1#%!3/1&*/&!!XY;Z! E&5&!#%,'!85&,&*+!#+!+71,!$51&(1*J:!"71,!E#,!('%%'E&<!$6!#!4&&+1*J!$&+E&&*!+7&!,/1&*+1,+,!+'!#J5&&!#*! '2&5#%%!+7&4&!1*('541*J!+7&!E'5R,7'8,!+7#+!+7&6!E'0%<!<&%12&5!<051*J!E'5R,7'8,:! ! DEHE!">1%"=.():()&"#4N-N%,%4(E"" =#$'5P!7#,!<&2&%'8&<!5&%#+1'*,718,!E1+7!#5+,!85#/+1+1'*&5,!E7'!7#2&!&.8&51&*/&!'(!E'5R1*J!E1+7!,/7''%! /71%<5&*! '2&5! 4#*6! 6&#5,! '(! &*J#J&4&*+! E1+7! +7&! #5+,! /'440*1+6:! L'5! +7&! KQHM! 85'A&/+S! =#$'5'! ,&%&/+&<!'*&!#5+1,+!,R1%%&<!1*!+&#/71*J!/5&#+12&!E51+1*J!+'!/71%<5&*!+'!<&%12&5!('05!HKQ! 41*0+&!E'5R,7'8,! WR HDFK RI WKH WKUHH VHOHFWHG VFKRROV 7KH EULHI IRU WKH DUWLVW ZDV WKDW KH ZRXOG ZRUN ZLWK WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V 1*+&585&+#+1'*!'(!+7&!,/1&*/&!+'81/!+'!7&%8!+7&4!+'!<&2&%'8!#!,+'56!'5!J#4&!0,1*J!+7&!,/1&*/&:!"7&!#5+1,+! #14&<!+'!/5&#+&!#*!1*+&5&,+!#*<!&*+70,1#,4!1*!+7&!/71%<5&*!$6!,+140%#+1*J!#*!&4'+1'*#%!#*<!/'48&%%1*J! 1*2'%2&4&*+!E1+7!+7&!E'5R,7'8!+7&4&,!+7#+!E'0%<!7#2&!#*!%#,+1*J!148#/+:!!"7&!+7&4&,!E&5&!#5'0*<! +7&!,/1&*/&!+'81/,S!&*215'*4&*+#%!1,,0&,!#*<!5&*&E#$%&!&*&5J6S!/'*/&8+,!'(!,+'56!E51+1*J!#*<!<5#E1*J! +&/7*1[0&,:!!a&!$&J#*!E1+7!'0+%1*1*J!+7&!851*/18%&,!'(!,+'56!E51+1*J!<&,/51$&<!#,!ÂµWKH EXLOGLQJ EORFNV RI VWRU\WHOOLQJ FKDUDFWHU GHYHORSPHQW VHWWLQJ DQG SORW VWUXFWXUHÂ¶ #*<! ('%%'E&<! +71,! E1+7! #! ,&,,1'*! '*! 13

<5#E1*J! ,R1%%,:! "71,! E#,! +'! (#/1%1+#+&! +7&! /71%<5&*! +'! <&2&%'8! 1*<121<0#%%6! #*<! 1*! J5'08,S! +7&! /5&#+12&! '0+80+!#*<!14#J1*1*J,!+7#+!E'0%<!$&!0,&<!1*!+7&!+715<!,+#J&!'(!+7&!E'5R!E71/7!1,!+'!0,&!+7&!,+'51&,!#*<! <5#E1*J,!+'!<&,1J*!#!/'480+&5!J#4&!'5!#*14#+&<!(1%4:! " DEHEJ"">1%"07,2'(%.">%&147C7N/"#4N-N%,%4(" "7&!+715<!,+5#*<!'(!+7&!85'A&/+!1*2'%2&<!+E'!/'480+&5!,/1&*+1,+,!<&%12&51*J!(12&!^Q!41*0+&!E'5R,7'8,!+'! +7&! ,&%&/+&<! ,/7''%,:! "7&6! <&4'*,+5#+&<! +7&! $#,1/,! '(! 3)G>")a! 85'J5#441*J! #*<! (#/1%1+#+&<! +7&! /71%<5&*!+'!+5#*,(&5!+7&15!#5+E'5R!1*+'!+7&15!/'480+&5!85'J5#44&:!"7&!5'%&!'(!+7&!3)G>")a!+0+'5,!E#,! GHVFULEHG DV ÂµG3%1$,7%+1$%61/,5*$&%+3%'.$%.6*"+61%".%"%+33,%+3%63&;$=>%/&%"%5/#/+",%<3*("+>%01"+%+1$=%1";$% FUHDWHG ZLWK >WKH DUWLVW@Â¶ "71,! /'*,+1+0+&,! #! 71J7%6! 1**'2#+12&S! #*<! 1*+&5#/+12&! 4&#,05&! ('5! +&#/71*J! 6'0*J!8&'8%&!#$'0+!+7&!1*+&5,&/+1'*,!$&+E&&*!,/1&*/&!#*<!#5+!#*<!+7&!5'%&!'(!/5&#+121+6!1*!3"-C!#5&#,:! ! DEHEL">1%"+&177C:"#4N-N%,%4(" 3/7''%,! 85'21<&<! /'*,1<&5#$%&! ,088'5+! +'! +7&! 85'A&/+! 1*! +&54,! '(! +14&+#$%1*J! /71%<5&*! +'! $&! (5&&! ('5! E'5R,7'8,S!85'21<1*J!&<0/#+1'*#%!#*<!'+7&5!(#/1%1+1&,!#*<!1*!$&1*J!#<#8+12&!#*<!(%&.1$%&!,088'5+,!+'!+7&! SUDFWLWLRQHUV 2QH RI WKH REMHFWLYHV RI %($67 LV Âµ7R GHPRQVWUDWH LQ VFKRROV DQG WR WHDFKHUV WKH XVH RI WKH $UWV LQ WHDFKLQJ WKH VFKRRO FXUULFXOXPÂ¶ RU LQ WKH Z'5<,! '(! +7&! ! =#$'5P! B15&/+'5! ÂµDUW SUDFWLWLRQHUV GHPRQVWUDWH WR WHDFKHUV KRZ DUW FDQ EH XVHG WR GHHSHQ WKH OHDUQLQJ DURXQG VFLHQFH DQG WHFKQRORJ\Â¶!:! "7&5&!E#,!/'*,1<&5#$%&!1*+&5&,+!1*!+7&!85'A&/+!E1+71*!+7&!,/7''%!/'440*1+1&,!#*<!'(+&*!+7&5&!E#,!4'5&! +7#*!'*&!+&#/7&5!85&,&*+!#+!E'5R,7'8,:!"&#/7&5,!E&5&!*'+!+7&5&!1*!#*!'$,&52#+1'*#%!/#8#/1+6!$0+!#,!#! VXSSRUW WR WKH SUDFWLWLRQHUV RIWHQ FRQWULEXWLQJ E\ PDNLQJ OLQNV ZLWK WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V H[LVWLQJ OHDUQLQJ 7KH WHDFKHUVÂ¶ LQVLJKWV RQ WKH WHDFKLQJ DSSURDFKHV XVHG E\!+7&!85#/+1+1'*&5,!#*<!'(!+7&!8',,1$%&!148#/+!'*! +7&!,/7''%!/0551/0%04!#5&!<&+#1%&<!1*!+7&!+75&&!/#,&!,+0<1&,!#*<!1*!+7&!<1,/0,,1'*!,&/+1'*!'(!+71,!,+0<6:! !!! DEHER">1%"@'IC)&"#4N-N%,%4(" "7&!/0%41*#+1'*!'(!+7&!85'A&/+!E'5R!E1%%!$&!#*!1*+&5#/+12&!&.71$1+1'*!FDOOHG WKH Âµ([SORUDWRULXPÂ¶ LQ D ZHOO /7',&*S!#//&,,1$%&!,1+&!1*!Z#%E#6:!!"7&5&!E1%%!$&!,/7''%!#*<!J5'08!+'05,!#*<!1*+&5#/+12&!&%&4&*+,!1*!+7&! &.71$1+1'*!E1+7!E71/7!#0<1&*/&,!E1%%!$&!1*21+&<!+'!&*J#J&:!"71,!&%&4&*+!'(!+7&!4'<&%!1,!*'+!1*/%0<&<!1*! +7&!85'/&,,!,+0<6!#,!1+!7#,!*'+!+#R&*!8%#/&!<051*J!+7&!,+0<6!+14&,/#%&:!! ""

DE! G%27.("+(.'&('.%"7'(C)4%"

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f%! )014f*! #J0,! )7#+5f'*#! S! Y#/7+#5! g5<S! Z#%E#6!-<0/#+&! "'J&+7&5! X#+1'*#%!3/7''%!TZ-"X3V!#*<!3/'f%!;*,&!Z0#15&S!Z'5+S!)'0*+6!Z#%E#6:!"71,!/7#8+&5!#%,'!<&,/51$&,! +7&!85'A&/+,!+7#+!E&5&!5'%%&<!'0+!7&5&:! !

01-2(%."O)*%5"G%:%-.&1"O)48)4N:5""7&!4#1*!(1*<1*J,!'(!+7&!85'A&/+!#5&!'0+%1*&<!1*!+71,!,&/+1'*:!;*! 8#5+1/0%#5S!+71,!,&/+1'*!('/0,&,!'*!1,,0&,!+'!<'!E1+7!&*J#J&4&*+!#*<!#++1+0<&,!+'E#5<,!/5&#+121+6!'(! #%%!,+#R&7'%<&5,!1*!+7&!85'A&/+:" ! 01-2(%." +)$5" 9):&'::)74" -48" G%&7,,%48-()74:5" "71,! 8#5+! ('/0,&,! '*! +7&! &.+&*+! +7#+! +7&! =->3"?!KQHM!85'A&/+!4'<&%!4#*#J&<!+'!#/71&2&!1+,!#14,!#*<!4#R&,!5&/'44&*<#+1'*,!'*!7'E!+7&! 85'A&/+!41J7+!$&!&*7#*/&<!1*!+7&!(0+05&:! " ! "

01-2(%.">S75"Q)(%.-('.%"G%*)%S" " FED"64(.78'&()74" "71,!%1+&5#+05&!5&21&E!/51+1/#%%6!&.#41*&,!,'/1#%!,/1&*+1(1/!%1+&5#+05&!'*!+'81/,!+7#+!5&%#+&!+'!/'48'*&*+,!'(! +7&! =#$'5P! =->3"?! C'<&%:! ;*! +7&! (15,+! 85'/&,,! ,+0<6! 1*! KQHKJ! +7&! %1+&5#+05&! 5&21&E! 1<&*+1(1&<! +7#+! 8514#56!,/7''%!,/1&*/&!/0551/0%04,!#5&!'(+&*!71J7%6!85&,/518+12&S!%#/R!#//&,,!+'!+#/+1%&!&.8&51&*/&,!#*<! 1*+&5#/+12&!#,8&/WV FRQWDLQ UHSHWLWLYH WRSLF UHYLVLRQ DQG WKHUHIRUH IDFLOLWDWH µVXUIDFH OHDUQLQJ¶ 0XUSK\ #*<! =&JJ,! KQQMV:! ;*! /'*+5#,+! +'! +71,S! h#5%&6! $+% ",:! TKQQDV! #<2'/#+&,! +7&! 148'5+#*/&! '(! 1*/%0<1*J! '88'5+0*1+1&,! ('5! /'%%#$'5#+1'*! +&#4E'5R! #*<! &*J#J&4&*+! 1*! E71/7! /71%<5&*! #5&! #/+12&%6! 1*2'%2&<! 1*! <&,1J*1*J! /%#,,5''4! #/+121+1&,! ('5! +&#/71*J! +7&! ,/1&*/&! /0551/0%04:! a&*/&S! 4'5&! 5&/&*+! %1+&5#+05&! '*! ,/1&*/&! +&#/71*JS! +7&! /0551/0%04! #*<! &<0/#+1'*! #5J0&,! ('5! 4'5&! 1*+&5#/+12&! 4&+7'<,! '(! ,+0<&*+! HQJDJHPHQW ZKLFK DGRSW D µZKROH OHDUQHU¶ DSSURDFK E\ QXUWXULQJ WKH µPXOWLSOH LQWHOOLJHQFHV¶ RI \RXQJ 8&'8%&:! ! "71,! %1+&5#+05&! 5&21&E! &.8%'5&,! 5&,&#5/7! +7#+! /#*! (05+7&5! ,088'5+! #*<! 1*('54! +7&! %&#5*1*J! (5'4! +7&! %DERUy PRGHO ,W ZLOO H[SORUH UHVHDUFK VWXGLHV IURP WKH µ&UHDWLYH 3DUWQHUVKLSV¶ VFKHPH WKDW RSHUDWHG LQ +7&! Y`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¶V HGXFDWLRQ LV RI VLJQLILFDQW YDOXH EXW LV DOVR D FRQVWDQW FKDOOHQJH IRU +&#/7&5,! #*<! +7&! (1*<1*J,! (5'4! ,+0<1&,! '(! /#,&,! E7&5&! +71,! 7#,! $&&*! #/71&2&<! ,0//&,,(0%%6! #5&! /'*,1<&5&<:! ! FEF"07CC-I7.-()74"I%(S%%4"*):)()4N"-.(:"2.-&()()74%.:"-48"&C-::"(%-&1%.:" =&,+!85#/+1/&!#5'0*<!1*2'%21*J!#5+,!85#/+1+1'*&5,!1*!,/7''%,!7#,!$&&*!5&,&#5/7&<!1*!+7&!Y`!$6!)5&#+12&! @#5+*&5,718,W>;)-!TKQHHV!#*<!1*!;5&%#*<!$6!+7&!B&8#5+4&*+!'(!-<0/#+1'*!#*<!3/1&*/&!TB-3VTKQQIV!E1+7! +7&!>5+,!)'0*/1%:!!! ! "7&!)5&#+12&!@#5+*&5,718,!,/7&4&!E#,!/'48#5#$%&!E1+7!+7&!=->3"?!#,!1+!$5'0J7+!,/1&*/&S!+7&!,/7''%! /0551/0%04!#*<!#5+!+'J&+7&5!1*!&(('5+,!+'!7&%8!/71%<5&*!&*J#J&!E1+7!,0$A&/+!4#++&5!1*!<&&8&5!E#6,!1*!+7&! FODVVURRP &UHDWLYH 3DUWQHUVKLSV ZDV DGYHUWLVHG DV WKH 8.¶V µIODJVKLS FUHDWLYH OHDUQLQJ SURJUDPPH¶ I! #*<! +7&! 85'A&/+! $5'0J7+! 8&'8%&! E7'! E&5&! 1*2'%2&<! 1*! <1((&5&*+! ,&/+'5,! '(! +7&! /5&#+12&! 1*<0,+51&,! 1*+'! FODVVURRPV VXFK DV DUFKLWHFWV VFLHQWLVWV DQG DUWLVWV WR ZRUN ZLWK WHDFKHUV µWR LQVSLUH \RXQJ SHRSOH DQG KHOS WKHP OHDUQ¶ ^!"7&!85'J5#44&!E#,!70J&%6!,0//&,,(0%:!92&5#%%S!1+!E'5R&<!E1+7!KS^QQ!,/7''%,S!NQSQQQ! +&#/7&5,! #*<! '2&5! '*&! 41%%1'*! 6'0*J! 8&'8%&! E&5&! 1*2'%2&<! 1*! +7&! 85'A&/+:! "7&! 85'J5#44&! #14&<! +'! <&2&%'8! +7&! ,R1%%,! *&/&,,#56! +'! 7&%8! ,+0<&*+,! &./&%! #/#<&41/#%%6! #*<! +'! 85&8#5&! +7&4! ('5! +7&! ZRUNSODFH &UHDWLYLW\ ZDV DW WKH YHU\ KHDUW RI WKH µ&UHDWLYH 3DUWQHUVKLSV¶ LQLWLDWLYH ,W ZDV GHILQHG DV µWKH ZLGHU DELOLW\ WR TXHVWLRQ PDNH FRQQHFWLRQV LQQRYDWH SUREOHP VROYH DQG UHIOHFW FULWLFDOO\¶ )RVWHULQJ /5&#+121+6!#4'*J!6'0*J!8&'8%&!E#,!,&&*!#,!$&1*J!148'5+#*+!('5!7&%81*J!+7&4!+'!5&_14#J1*&!E7#+!+7&! E'5%<! ,7'0%<! $&! %1R&! #*<! +'! &*#$%&! +7&4! +'! 4#R&! /7#*J&! 7#88&*:! a&*/&S! +7&4&,! ,0/7! #,! /121/! &*J#J&4&*+S!6'0+7!&48'E&54&*+!#*<!8#5+1/18#+1'*!%#6!#+!+7&!7&#5+!'(!+7&!)5&#+12&!@#5+*&5,718,\!6'0*J! SHRSOH¶V DUWLVWLF DELOLWLHV DQG WKHLU NQRZOHGJH RI KRZ VFLHQFH KDSSHQV LQ WKH KRPH DQG LQ WKH VFKRRO E&5&!4#551&<!+'J&+7&5!1*!71J7%6!1*2&*+12&!E#6,:! 5

µ0DJLF FDQ KDSSHQ¶ ± A Process Study of the Baboró BEAST! Project. 2012 3&&!7++8UWWEEE:/5&#+12&_8#5+*&5,718,:/'4W ^!3&&!7++8UWWEEE:/5&#+12&_8#5+*&5,718,:/'4! 6

! $ ZLGH UDQJH RI UHSRUWV DQG JXLGHV KDYH EHHQ SURGXFHG DV DQ RXWFRPH RI WKH Âµ&UHDWLYH 3DUWQHUVKLSVÂ¶ ,/7&4&:!!;*!#*!#*#%6,1,!'(!/#,&!,+0<6!#*<!,052&6!<#+#!S!C/)%&%%#*!$+%",:!TKQHK!V!('0*<!+7#+!#+!8514#56! %&2&%S! #,,LVWLQJ SXSLOV WR H[HUFLVH WKHLU ÂµVWXGHQW YRLFHÂ¶ ZDV YLWDO LQ IDFLOLWDWLQJ ZHOOEHLQJ DQG LQ ,088'5+1*J!+7&4!+'!$&/'4&!8&5,'*#%%6!#*<!,'/1#%%6!4'5&!&((&/+12&:!!;*!#%%!+7&!8#5+1/18#+1*J!,/7''%,!+7&! &487#,1,! E#,! '*! 7&%81*J! ,+0<&*+,! +'! +71*R! ÂµIOH[LEO\ VWUDWHJLFDOO\ DQG FUHDWLYHO\Â¶ ! TKQHKUOV:! 30/7! &487#,1,!'*!,+5#+&J1/!%&#5*1*J!#*<!/51+1/#%!&*J#J&4&*+!E1+7!,/1&*/&S!+7&!#5+,!#*<!,'/1&+6!#5&!/'5&!+'! +7&!=->3"!85'A&/+!E71/7!&*/'05#J&,!6'0*J!8&'8%&!+'!+71*R!#$'0+!,'/1&+6_*#+05&!1*+&5<&8&*<&*/&!#*<! 7'E!+7&!&*215'*4&QW LQVSLUHV VFLHQWLVWV DQG DUWLVWV WR WKLQN ÂµRXWVLGH WKH ER[Â¶ ! ! >;)-!TKQHHV!7#2&!<&2&%'8&<!#!J01<&!('5!#5+1,+,!#*<!+&#/7&5,!(5'4!%&#5*1*J!J#1*&<!+75'0J7!+7&!)5&#+12&! @#5+*&5,718,!,/7&4&!&*+1+%&<!Âµ$UWLVWV LQ &UHDWLYH (GXFDWLRQ 8QORFNLQJ FKLOGUHQÂ¶V FUHDWLYL+=%Â±%:%7*"6+/6",% JXLGH IRU $UWLVWV Â¶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ÂµHQULFK WKH VFKRRO FXUULFXOXPÂ¶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h#5%&6! $+%",-! TKQQDV!1*!8#5+1/0%#5!,&&,! +7#+! /71%<5&*! <'! *'+! 0*<&5,+#*<! +7&! 5&%&2#*/&! '(! ,/1&*/&! +'! +7&15! &2&56<#6! %12&,:! 3/1&*/&! 1,! 1*! (#/+! 5&4'2&<! (5'4! +7&! ÂµOLIHZRUOGVÂ¶ RI PRVW FKLOGUHQ Âµ,Q JHQHUDO SULP"*=%.6133,%61/,5*$&%"*$%&3+%&$6$.."*/,=%*$,"+/&#%+1$/*%.6133,% VFLHQFH H[SHULHQFH WR WKH ZLGHU ZRUOG RU IXWXUH DVSLUDWLRQVÂ¶ TKQQDUDV:! "7&! X))>! TKQQOV! *'+&<! +7#+! 5&J#5<%&,,! '(! ,0$A&/+! 4#++&5S! /71%<5&*! 5&8'5+&<! +7#+! +7&! #/+121+1&,! +7&6! 21&E! #,! 4',+! &*A'6#$%&! #*<! #88&#%1*JS! #5&! '*&,! +7#+! 1*/%0<&,! /'%%#$'5#+1'*S! #0+7&*+1/! %&#5*1*J! #*<! 1*[0156_$#,&<! %&#5*1*J:! 3+5&*J+7&*1*J! +7&! 5'%&! '(! ,/1&*/&!'*! +7&! /0551/0%04! 1,! *'+! #! ,+5#1J7+('5E#5<! 4#++&5\!&*,051*J! +7#+!+7&! +&#/71*J! 4&+7'<! 1,! #885'851#+&! ('5! /71%<5&*! #*<! +7#+! LW FDWHUV WR FKLOGUHQÂ¶V OHDUQLQJ LV H[WUHPHO\ LPSRUWDQW *UHDWHU HPSKDVLV LV QRZ JLYHQ WR WKH ÂµYRLFH RI WKH FKLOGÂ¶ LQ SROLF\ DUHQDV DQG UHVHDUFK 17

*LYHQ FKLOGUHQ¶V SUHIHUHQFH IRU VRFLDO LQWHUDFWLRQ DQG D PRUH FUHDWLYH ZD\ RI OHDUQLQJ LV LW WLPH WR PRYH $&6'*<!#<0%+_/&*+5&<!*'+1'*,!'(!+7&!/0551/0%04!+'E#5<,!/71%<_(51&*<%6!4'<&,!'(!/0551/0%04!<&,1J*!#*<! <&%12&56i! ! `&%%6! TKQHKV! ,+#+&,! +7#+! /5',,_/0551/0%#5! +&#/71*J! 1,! 71,+'51/#%%6! #,,'/1#+&<! E1+7! 4'5&! /'*,+50/+121,+! 4&+7'<'%'J1&,! 1*! /71%<! &<0/#+1'*:! 37&! <1,/0,,&,! +7#+! 6'0*J! /71%<5&*! <'! *'+! *&/&,,#51%6! #,,'/1#+&! <1((&5&*+!#/+121+1&,!1*+'!<1((&5&*+!,0$A&/+!#5&#,!#*<!#<2'/#+&,!+7#+!+71,!1,!*'+!+7&!E#6!+7#+!4',+!/71%<5&*! %&#5*:!B&E&6!THNMMV!#%,'!#5J0&,!+7#+!+7&5&!#5&!4#*6!%1*R#J&,!$&+E&&*!#5&#,!'(!R*'E%&<J&!+7#+!E'0%<! 41%1+#+&!#J#1*,+!+7&!+&#/71*J!'(!,1*J%&!,0$A&/+,!'*%6:!;*!+7&!Y`S!9(,+&<!TKQQKV!5&/'J*1,&!+7#+!,0//&,,(0%! 8514#56! ,/7''%,! 0+1%1,&! /5',,_/0551/0%#5! +&#/71*J! #*<! G',&! TKQQNV! #*<! >%&.#*<&5! TKQHQV! 5&/'44&*<! WKDW VXEMHFW WHDFKLQJ FRPELQHG ZLWK µZHOO SODQQHG¶ FURVV FXUULFXODU DSSURDFKHV DFKLHYH KLJK VWDQGDUGV +70,!,7'E1*J!+7#+!,0/7!#885'#/7&,!(#/1%1+#+&!71J7&5!#/#<&41/!'0+80+,!('5!6'0*J!8&'8%&!TG',&S!KQQNUKV:! .HOO\ GHILQHV FURVV FXUULFXODU WHDFKLQJ LQ VFLHQFH DV µ130% "&3+1$*% .')E$6+% 6"&% .'773*+% "&5% $&1"&6$% FKLOGUHQ¶V OHDUQLQJ LQ VFLHQFH¶! TKQHKU! MV:! ;*! '5<&5! +'! #/71&2&! 4'5&! ,0//&,,(0%! '0+/'4&,! E7&*! 0,1*J! /5',,_/0551/0%#5! #885'#/7&,! 5&,&#5/7&5,! 7#2&! 1<&*+1(1&<! +7&! *&/&,,1+6! '(! 85'21<1*J! #! /%&#5! ('/0,! ('5! FKLOGUHQ¶V OHDUQLQJ E\ OLPLWLQJ WKH QXPEHU RI VXEMHFWV X,&<!('5!#!J12&*!+7&4&!T9(,+&<!KQQK\!]#521,!KQQN\! =#5*&,!KQHHV:!! ! "7&!4'+12#+1'*#%!#,8&/+,!'(!/5',,_/0551/0%#5!+&#/71*J!#5&!<1,/0,,&<!$6!C01A,!#*<!G&6*'%<,!TKQHHV!#,! +7&6! 5&#,'*! +7#+! 1+! &*J#J&,! E1+7! +7&! &4'+1'*#%! &%&4&*+,! '(! %&#5*1*J! #,! /71%<5&*! #<'8+! 4'5&! 1*<&8&*<&*+!#*<!,&%(_%&<!&.8%'5#+1'*:!)055#*!TKQQDV!%''R,!#+!+7&!E#6!+7#+!&4'+1'*!1,!1*&.+51/#$%6!%1*R&<! E1+7!%&#5*1*JU! ! µ/HDUQLQJ LV GLUHFWHG DQG FRQWUROOHG E\ WKH HPRWLRQDO DQG OLPELF EUDLQ > @ WKH HPRWLRQDO VHOI LV 6$&+*",,=%/&;3,;$5%/&%+1$%;".+%("E3ULW\ RI WKH WKLQJV \RX OHDUQ¶ TKQQDU!IH_IV!! ! "71,!5&%#+&,!,8&/1(1/#%%6!E1+7!+7&!=#$'5P!4'<&%!#,!85#/+1+1'*&5,!#*<!+&#/7&5,!1*!=#$'5P!=->3"?!KQHK! 5&/'J*1d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µ$UWV LQ (GXFDWLRQ &KDUWHU¶ ODXQFKHG E\ WKH 0LQLVWHU IRU (GXFDWLRQ DQG 6FLHQFH DQG +7&! C1*1,+&5!('5! >5+,S! a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

µ0DJLF FDQ +DSSHQ¶ ± A Process Study of the Baboró BEAS T! Project. 2012

FKLOGUHQ FDUULHG RXW E\ %DUQHV DQG 6KLUOH\ 7KH\ SRLQW WR WKH Âµ#*$"+%73+$&+/",%3<%.1/<+/&#%+1$%,36'.% 3<%63&+*3,%+30"*5.%61/,5*$&Â¶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ÂµQHWZRUN VRFLHW\Â¶ DQG WKH HIIHFWV WKDW PRPHQWRXV /7#*J&,! +'! +&/7*'%'J1/#%! <&2&%'84&*+,! 7#2&! '*! ,'/1#%! 1*+&5#/+1'*,! $&+E&&*! 8&'8%&! '(! #%%! #J&,:! a#%%! #*<!3/7#2#51#*!TKQQHV!1*!#!,1.!4'*+7!,+0<6!/#551&<!'0+!1*!+7&!Y3!E1+7!8514#56!%&2&%!8081%,!('0*<!+7#+! ZKHQ XVLQJ ,&7 LI WKH FKLOGÂ¶V LQWHUHVW ZDV HQJDJHG WKH LPSDFWV ZHUH JUHDWHU DV WKH\ VWDWH Âµ01$*$%+1$% FKLOGÂ¶V FXULRVLW\ ZDV WKH HQJLQH IRU WKHLU OHDUQLQJ SURIRXQG XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH WRSLF HYROYHGÂ¶! TKQQHUbObV:!"7&6!1<&*+1(1&<!+7#+!E7&5&!+7&!%&#5*1*J!'(!,/1&*/&!#*<!+&/7*'%'J6!E#,!('/0,&<!#+!'5!*&#5! +7&15!7'4&!'5!/'440*1+6!#*<!1*!WKH FKLOGÂ¶V RZQ SHUVRQDO FRQWH[W WKH HQJDJHPHQW RI FKLOGUHQ ZDV PRUH PHDQLQJIXO DQG FKLOGUHQÂ¶V LGHDV ÂµGHHSHQHGÂ¶!T1$1<V:!92&5#%%S!+71,!,7'E,!+7#+!/'**&/+1*J!,/1&*/&!%&#5*1*J! WR \RXQJ SHRSOHÂ¶V ÂµOLYHG H[SHULHQFHVÂ¶ LV D FULWLFDO SDUW RI \RXQJ SHRSOHÂ¶V VRFLDO G&2&%'84&*+!#*<!+7&15! %&#5*1*J:! ! @#,,&6! $+! ",-% TKQQbV! ('0*<! #! /'55&%#+1'*! $&+E&&*! ;)"! 0,&! $6! 8081%,! #*<! +&#/7&5,! #*<! 8',1+12&! 4'+12#+1'*#%!'0+/'4&,!E1+7!1*/5&#,&<!('/0,!'*!,/7''%!+#,R,!1*!#!,+0<6!/#551&<!'0+!1*!#!5#*J&!'(!/#,&! ,+0<6! ,/7''%,! #/5',,! +7&! Y`:! ! "7&6! ('0*<! +7#+! 4'+12#+1'*! E#,! 1*/5&#,&<! E7&*! $'+7! /71%<5&*! #*<! +&#/7&5,!&*J#J&<!E1+7!+7&!;)"!1*!7#*<,!'*!#885'#/7&,:!!"7&!,+0<6!#%,'!8'1*+&<!+'!8',1+12&!148#/+,!'*! 8081%!$&7#21'05!E7&*!1*!,/7''%!#*<!,'4&!1*<1/#+'5,!'(!8',1+12&!148#/+,!'*!$&7#21'05!'0+,1<&!,/7''%:!!! ! h#%&*+1*&!TKQQDV!('0*<!+7#+!8#5&*+,S!+&#/7&5,!#*<!8081%,!5&8'5+&<!+7#+!+7&!0,&!'(!;)"!7#<!#!4'+12#+1*J! HIIHFW DQG UDLVHG FKLOGUHQÂ¶V VHOI_&,+&&4:!"7&6!#%,'!('0*<!+7#+!+7&!0,&!'(!+&/7*'%'J6!&*#$%&,!/71%<5&*! E1+7!,8&/1#%!*&&<,!#,!E&%%!#,!71J7!#/71&2&5,!+'!<1,8%#6!+7&15!,R1%%,!#*<!/#*!+70,!$&!$&*&(1/1#%!('5!8081%,! E1+7! E1<&5!5#*J&,!'(! #$1%1+1&,:! ! Z''<1,'*! TKQQKV!#%,'!1<&*+1(1&,! +7#+! ,'4&! /71%<5&*! /#*! <1,8%#6! #! 2&56! ,'871,+1/#+&<!0,&!'(!+&/7*'%'J6!E71/7!148%1&,!+7#+!,'/1&+#%!R*'E%&<J&!'(!+7&,&!,0$A&/+,!1,!&.8#*,12&! #*<!&2&5_/7#*J1*J:! ! "7&! 2#,+! 4#A'51+6! '(! 8514#56! ,/7''%,! 1*! ;5&%#*<! *'E! 7#2&! 1*+&5#/+12&! E71+&$'#5<,! 0,&<! ('5! +&#/71*J! 8058',&,!$0+!#,!Z''<1,'*!TKQQKV!#*<!X))>!TKQHQV!7#2&!#/R*'E%&<J&<S!+&#/7&5,!*&&<!4'5&!,088'5+! 1*!'5<&5!+'!0,&!;)"!#*<!+71,!,7'0%<!$&!#<<5&,,&<!1*!+&#/7&5!+5#1*1*J!#*<!1*_,&521/&!+5#1*1*J:!Z''<1,'*! TKQQKV! #%,'! *'+&,! +7#+! +7&! +#,R! ('5! +&#/7&5,S! E7&5&! +7&5&! 1,! #! E&#%+7! '(! E&$_$#,&<! 5&,'05/&,S! 1,! +'! 1<&*+1(6! +7&! $&,+! ;)"! +''%,! ('5! 8#5+1/0%#5! +#,R,:! "7&! X#+1'*#%! )'0*/1%! ('5! )0551/0%04! #*<! >,,&,,4&*+! TX))>V!TKQHQV!85'<0/&<!#!J01<&!('5!0,1*J!;)"!#+!8514#56!%&2&%!E71/7!1<&*+1(1&,!7'E!+'!,088'5+!/71%<5&*! 1*! +7&15! 0,&! '(! ;)":! "71,! 1*/%0<&,! 1<&*+1(61*J! ('5! /71%<5&*! #J&! #885'851#+&! #*<! %#*J0#J&! #885'851#+&! E&$,1+&,! T,0/7! #,! 6#7''%1J#*,:/'4S! 3/'f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Â¶V OHDUQLQJ ! ! ! ! ! 19

FEJ"64*7C*)4N"2-.%4(:"" "7&! 2#%0&! '(! 8#5&*+#%! ,088'5+! 1,! 71J7%1J7+&<! 1*! 4#*6! ,+0<1&,! #*<! <1,/0,,&<! $6! B&,('5J&,! #*<! >$'0/7##5!TKQQMV!1*!#*!&.+&*,12&!%1+&5#+05&!5&21&E!1*+'!+7&!148#/+,!#*<!1*(%0&*/&!'(!8#5&*+,!'*!+7&15! FKLOGÂ¶V HGXFDWLRQ 7KH\ FRQFOXGHG WKDW HIIHFWLYH DQG ÂµJRRG SDUHQWLQJÂ¶ LPSDFWV WKH FKLOG E\ LQIOXHQFLQJ +7&15!,&%(!/'*/&8+!#,!#!%&#5*&5!#*<!+75'0J7!,&++1*J!71J7!J'#%,!'5!#4$1+1'*,!TKQQMUOV:!!h#%&*+1*&!TKQQDV!1*! #!,+0<6!E1+7!+E&%2&!Y`!,/7''%,!'*!+7&!+&#/71*J!+75'0J7!;)"!,7'E,!+7#+!4#*6!8#5&*+,!E'0%<!%1R&!+'!$&! PRUH LQYROYHG LQ WKHLU FKLOGÂ¶V HGXFDWLRQ DQG ZRXOG OLNH WHDFKHUV WR LGHQWLI\ KRZ WKH\ FDQ EHVW VXSSRUW WKHLU FKLOGÂ¶V OHDUQLQJ LQ ,&7 LQ WHUPV RI UHFRPPHQGLQJ DSSURSU1#+&!E&$,1+&,!'5!$6!&,+#$%1,71*J!,/7''%_ 7'4&! E&$,1+&,:! "7&6! 5&/'44&*<! +7#+! #<0%+! %1+&5#/6!85'J5#44&,! ,7'0%<! 1*/%0<&! 4'<0%&,!'*! 7&%81*J! 8#5+1/18#*+,!+'!,088'5+!+7&15!/71%<5&*!E1+7!+7&15!;)"!('5!,/7''%E'5R:!! ! 3DIIRUG DQG 2Â¶6XOOLYDQ LQ D VWXG\ RQ SDUHQWÂ¶V UHVSRQVHV WR WKHLU FKLOGÂ¶V LQYROYHPHQW ZLWK &UHDWLYH @#5+*&5,718,!1*!,/7''%,!1<&*+1(1&<!+7#+U! ! Âµ$! /5&#+12&! /0551/0%04! 7#,! #! 8',1+12&! 148#/+! '*! 7'4&_,/7''%! /'440*1/#+1'*:! &KLOGUHQÂ¶V!&*+70,1#,4!('5!/5&#+12&!85'A&/+,!%&#<,!+7&4!+'!+#%R!#+!7'4&!#$'0+!E7#+!+7&6! <'!1*!,/7''%S!#*<!8#5&*+,!<&2&%'8!*&E!8&5,8&/+12&,!'*!+7&15!/71%<5&*j,!%&#5*1*J:! @#5&*+,! (&&%! +7#+! /5&#+12&! 85'A&/+,! 4'+12#+&! /71%<5&*! +'! $&! 1*! ,/7''%! #*<! ,088'5+! /71%<5&*!#,!1*<121<0#%!%&#5*&5,:!@#5&*+,!$&%1&2&!+7#+!/5&#+12&!85'A&/+,!7#2&!#!,1J*1(1/#*+S! %'*J_+&54!148#/+!'*!FKLOGUHQÂ¶V!/'*(1<&*/&S!,R1%%,S!E1<&5!%&#5*1*JS!'2&5#%%! >! /5&#+12&! /0551/0%04! '((&5,! %'E_51,R! 1*21+#+1'*,! +'! 8#5&*+,! +'! $&/'4&! 1*2'%2&<! 1*! ,/7''%:! &KLOGUHQÂ¶V! &*J#J&4&*+! #%,'! %&#<,! 8#5&*+,! +'! 5&(%&/+! '*! +7&15! 'E*! ,/7''%! &.8&51&*/&,!#*<!+'!+#R&_08!/0%+05#%!#*<!'+7&5!%&#5*1*J!'88'5+0*1+1&,!('5!WKHPVHOYHVÂ¶! T3DIIRUG DQG 2Â¶6XOOLYDQ UMD_bQV! ! "7&!(1*<1*J,!(5'4!+7&,&!,+0<1&,!1*<1/#+&!#!2&56!8',1+12&!<&4#*<!(5'4!8#5&*+,!+'!$&!4'5&!1*2'%2&<!1*! WKHLU FKLOGÂ¶V HGXFDWLRQ DQG VKRZV WKDW SURJUDPPH,! ,0/7! #,! =#$'5P! =->3"?! /#*! $&! 2&56!&((&/+12&! 1*! 7#5*&,,1*J!+71,!1*+&5&,+!#*<!&*+70,1#,4!1*!#!2#51&+6!'(!E#6,!+'!85'<0/&!4'5&!8',1+12&!'0+/'4&,!('5!+7&! &<0/#+1'*!'(!8514#56!,/7''%!/71%<5&*:!;+!#%,'!,0JJ&,+,!+7#+!5&%#+1'*,718,!$&+E&&*!8#5&*+,!#*<!+&#/7&5,! /DQ EH JUHDWO\ HQKDQFHG DQG WKDW VXFK UHODWLRQVKLSV FDQ LPSDFW LQ YHU\ SRVLWLYH ZD\V RQ FKLOGUHQÂ¶V %&#5*1*J:!! ! FEL"+',,-./" "71,!,&/+1'*!5&21&E&<!%1+&5#+05&!0*<&5!#!*04$&5!'(!<1((&5&*+!7&#<1*J,!E71/7!5&%#+&!+'!5&%&2#*+!(#/+'5,!1*! +7&!=->3"?!@5'A&/+!4'<&%:!;+!5&21&E&<!%1+&5#+05&!'*!/'%%#$'5#+1'*!$&+E&&*!#5+,!#*<!,/1&*/&!85#/+1+1'*&5,! #*<! +&#/7&5,S! /5',,_/0551/0%#5! +&#/71*J! '(! ,/1&*/&! #+! 8514#56! %&2&%S! +7&! 0,&! '(! ;)"! 1*! +&#/71*J! #*<! 5&,&#5/7! '*! ,+0<1&,! +7#+! ('/0,&<! '*! 4'5&! #/+12&%6! %1*R1*J! 8#5&*+,! +'! +7&15! /71%GUHQÂ¶V HGXFDWLRQ @5&21'0,%6S! +7&!#0+7'5,!1<&*+1(1&<!+7#+! +7&5&! 1,!#! ,8#5,&! 5&,&#5/7! #2#1%#$%&! 1*! +7&! ;51,7! /'*+&.+!'*!+7&! 148#/+,!'(!0,1*J!<1((&5&*+!4&+7'<'%'J1&,!1*!+&#/71*J!3"-CN!,0$A&/+,!#*<!05J&!+7&!85'<0/+1'*!'(!4'5&! ,+0<1&,!'*!,/1&*/&!&<0/#+1'*!#*<!E7#+!1+!4&#*,!+'!<1((&5&*+!,+#R&7'%<&5,:!;*!8#5+1/0%#5S!+7&!#++1+0<&,!'(! 8#5&*+,! #*<! +&#/7&5,! +'E#5<,! ,/1&*/&! #*<! &4&5J1*J! 5&%#+1'*,718,! $&+E&&*! +7&4! /#*! 7#2&! 71J7%6! EHQHILFLDO HIIHFWV RQ FKLOGUHQÂ¶V OHDUQLQJ 5HFHQW UHVHDUFK HPSKDVLVHV WKDW ÂµUHDO OHDUQLQJÂ¶! 7#88&*,! 1*! 71J7%6!1*+&5#/+12&! E#6,! #*<! +7#+! 1,!/'*+1*J&*+! '*! ,'/1#%!1*+&5#/+1'*,!$&+E&&*! 40%+18%&! ,+#R&7'%<&5,!1*! WKH OHDUQLQJ SURFHVV SDUHQWV VFLHQWLVWV DUWLVWV \RXQJ SHRSOH DQG WHDFKHUV 7KLV LV HYRFDWLYH RI ÂµWKH ZKROH OHDUQHU DSSURDFKÂ¶ ZKLFK VHHPV! +'! $&! #! 4#1*,+#6! '(! 5&/&*+! 5&,&#5/7:! "71,! &487#,1,&,! +7&! VLJQLILFDQFH RI IRVWHULQJ PXOWLSOH DVSHFWV RI \RXQJ SHRSOHÂ¶V GHYHORSPHQW DQG WKH QHHG WR LQWHUUHODWH WKH ,/1&*/&,!#*<!+7&!#5+,!1*!#!,8151+!'(!/5&#+121+6S!R*'E%&<J&_/5&#+1'*!#*<!40+0#%!5&,8&/+:! ! 9

3"-C!Â±!3/1&*/&S!"&/7*'%'J6S!-*J1*&&51*J!#*<!C#+7&4#+1/,!30$A&/+,! 20

"7&5&! 1,! #! ,1J*1(1/#*+! *&&<! 1*! +7&! ;51,7! %1+&5#+05&! ('5! 4'5&! %#5J&_,/#%&S! [0#*+1+#+12&! E'5R! '*! 6'0*J! SHRSOHÂ¶V DWWLWXGHV WR VFLHQFH DQG WKH DUWV 7KLV LV HVSHFLDOO\ DSSURSULDWH JLYHQ WKH HPSKDVLV JLYHQ WR GLVFRXUVHV DURXQG WKH ÂµNQRZOHGJH EDVHG HFRQRP\Â¶ DQG WKH ÂµNQRZOHGJH EDVHG VRFLHW\Â¶ VLQFH WKH &HOWLF "1J&5! &5#! THNNO_KQQDV! #*<! /7#*J&,! +'! +7&! 3&/'*<! F&2&%! C#+7&4#+1/,! /0551/0%04:! a'E&2&5S! +7&5&! 1,! DOVR D QHHG IRU PRUH TXDOLWDWLYH ZRUN RQ FKLOGUHQÂ¶V IHHOLQJV DERXW VFLHQFH DQG LWV LQWHUVHFWLRQV ZLWK #5+1,+1/! <1,/18%1*&,! #*<! 7'E! +7&6! 5&#/+! +'! ,/1&*+1(1/! R*'E%&<J&S! 4'5&! J&*&5#%%6:! 30/7! 5&,&#5/7! E'0%<! 4#R&! ,1J*1(1/#*+! 1*80+,! +'! +7&! %1+&5#+05&! '*! /71%<5&*S! R*'E%&<J&! #*<! ,/1&*/&! 1*! ;5&%#*<! #*<! 1*+&5*#+1'*#%%6:! ! "7&! *&.+! ,&/+1'*! '(! +71,! ,+0<6! '0+%1*&,! +7&! =->3"?! 85'/&,,! ,+0<6! 4&+7'<'%'J6! #*<! 7'E! #! 41.&<_ PHWKRG DSSURDFK IDFLOLWDWHG D GHHSHU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI \RXQJ SHRSOHÂ¶V UHDFWLRQV WR VFLHQFH WKH DUWV #*<!+7&15!(&&%1*J,!#$'0+!+7&!&*215'*4&*+!#*<!;)":! !!

01-2(%.">1.%%5""G%:%-.&1"B%(1787C7N/"7;"(1%"<#=+>?"@.7&%::"+('8/! " HED!9%:)N4)4N"-48"6,2C%,%4()4N"(1%"@.7A%&("B%(1787C7N/"! "7&!5&,&#5/7&5,!0+1%1,&<!#!41.&<_4&+7'<!#885'#/7!E7&*!/'%%&/+1*JS!#*#%6,1*J!#*<!1*+&585&+1*J!<#+#!('5! +7&!=->3"?! 85'/&,,! ,+0<6:! k0#%1+#+12&! #*<![0#*+1+#+12&! 4&+7'<'%'J1/#%! +&/7*1[0&,! E&5&! &48%'6&<! 1*! '5<HU WR DFFHVV FKLOGUHQÂ¶V VRFLDO ZRUOGV DQG WR WDS LQWR WKH H[SHULHQFHV RI PXOWLSOH VWDNHKROGHUV LQ WKH =->3"! 85'A&/+! T+&#/7&5,S!=#$'5P! 5&85&,&*+#+12&,S! ,/1&*+1,+,S! 8#5&*+,! #*<! #5+1,+,V:! ;*! +71,!/'*+&.+S! +7&! /'4$1*#+1'*! '(! 1*_<&8+7! [0#%1+#+12&! #*<! [0#*+1+#+1YH GDWD SURYLGHG PXFK GHWDLO DERXW \RXQJ SHRSOHÂ¶V 5&#/+1'*,! +'! ,/1&*/&! #*<! #5+! #*<! +7&15! (&&%1*J,! #$'0+! ;)":! C1.&<_4&+7'<,! 5&,&#5/7! +&/7*1[0&,! (5&[0&*+%6! 61&%<! 71J7%6! /'485&7&*,12&! <#+#! #*<! +71,! /'*+&.+S! #88%61*J! #! /'4$1*#+'56! #885'#/7! J&*&5#+&<! 1*_<&8+7! [XDOLWDWLYH DQG TXDQWLWDWLYH PDWHULDOV RQ SHRSOHÂ¶V GLVFRXUVHV DERXW FUHDWLYLW\ ,/1&*/&!#*<!+7&!#5+,!#*<!+7&15!#++1+0<&,!#$'0+!+7&!=->3"?! ! !"#$%&'#()*+#,$%-$)"#$./%(#,,$0)123$4#/#$5,$-%66%4,7$ % _ _ _ _ _

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

HEFE"9%:&.)2()74"7;"+&177C:"S17"(77V"2-.(")4"<#=+>"@.7&%::"+('8/" G&85&,&*+#+12&,!(5'4!=#$'5P!/7',&!+7&!+75&&!,/7''%,!+#R1*J!8#5+!1*!+7&!=->3"?!85'/&,,!,+0<6:!"7&,&! ,/7''%,!#5&!3/'f%! )014f*! #J0,! )7#1+51'*#S! Y#/7+#5!g5<S! 3/'f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

O)N'.%" H5" +',,-./" 7;" <#=+>" 2.7&%::" :('8/" -),:W" .%:%-.&1" Y'%:()74:" -48" ,%(1787C7N)&-C" -22.7-&1%:"'()C):%8"" ! =),! G%:%-.&1"Y'%:()74:! 9%:&.)I%" -48" =4-C/:%" (1%" <-I7.P" Æ&#x201D;:KDW GRHV WKH =->3"?! @5'A&/+! <#=+>?"@.7A%&("B78%C"! C'<&%!/'*,1,+!'(i!! Æ&#x201D;:KDW DUH LWV DLPV DQG REMHFWLYH,! #*<!<&,15&<!'0+/'4&,i!! Æ&#x201D;:K\ ZDV LW HVWDEOLVKHG" ! Æ&#x201D;:KDW DUH WKH VWUXFWXUHV DQG 85#/+1/&,!'(!+7&!85'J5#44&i!! Æ&#x201D;+RZ PDQ\ VFKRROV \RXQJ SHRSOH 1*2'%2&<i!! Æ&#x201D;:KDW LV WKH NH\ UHVHDUFK HYLGHQFH '*! 0,1*J! #5+,! 1*! +7&! ,/1&*/&W+&/7*'%'J6!/0551/0%04i! ! #:(-IC):1" (1%" 2%.:2%&()*%" 7;" Æ&#x201D;:K\ GLG VWDNHKROGHUV FKRRVH WR 2-.()&)2-4(:ZV%/" :(-V%17C8%.:" &*J#J&!E1+7!+7&!85'J5#44&i!! .%N-.8)4N"(1%"2.7N.-,,%"! ! Æ&#x201D;:KDW RXWFRPHV DUH SHUFHLYHG WR 5&,0%+! (5'4! +7&! 85'J5#44&! ('5! 6'0*J! 8&'8%&S! +&#/7&5,S! 85#/+1+1'*&5,S! 8#5&*+,i! ! ! Æ&#x201D;:KDW DUH WKH YLHZV RI VWDNHKROGHUV 5&J#5<1*J! +7&! 85'J5#44&! 148%&4&*+#+1'*i!! !! !

97&',%4(" =(()('8)4-C" -48" Æ&#x201D; c7#+! #5&! +7&! '81*1'*,! '(! R&6! <%1-*)7'.-C" 01-4N%:" (7S-.8:" ,+#R&7'%<&5,! 1*! =->3"! 85'A&/+! +&)%4&%"-48"=.("" +'E#5<,! ,/1&*/&! #*<! #5+! #+! +7&! /'44&*/&4&*+!'(!85'A&/+i! ! ! ! ! ! ! Æ&#x201D; :KDW FDQ EH FRQFOXGHG DW HQG RI 85'A&/+! #$'0+! $&7#21'05#%! /7#*J&! #,! #!5&,0%+!'(!=->3"i! ! !

B%(178:! Æ&#x201D;5HYLHZ RI SURJUD44&! 5&8'5+,! l! '+7&5!5&%&2#*+!<'/04&*+,!! Æ&#x201D;,QWHUYLHZV ZLWK %DERUy $UW 'LUHFWRU @5'A&/+!)'_'5<1*#+'5! L'/0,! J5'08! E1+7! =#$'5P! C#*#J&4&*+!3+#((!!! ! ! Æ&#x201D;'RFXPHQWDU\ UHYLHZ! ! ! Æ&#x201D;/LWHUDWXUH UHYLHZ ! ! Æ&#x201D;,QWHUYLHZV DQG )RFXV *URXS ZLWK =#$'5P! B15&/+'5W><41*1,+5#+'5W! =->3"!)'_'5<1*#+'5! Æ&#x201D;$GPLQLVWUDWLRQ RI 4XDQWLWDWLYH GDWD /'%%&/+1'*!1*,+504&*+!+'!/71%<5&*!1*!+E'! 8#5+1/18#+1*J!,/7''%,! ! Æ&#x201D;2EVHUYDWLRQ RI ZRUNVKRSV LQ HDFK '(!+7&!/#,&!,+0<6!,/7''%,!#*<!#+!(1&%<! +518!+'!4#51*&!%#$'5#+'56:! ! Æ&#x201D;,QWHUYLHZV ZLWK WHDFKHUV 3/1&*+1,+,W"&/7*'%'J1,+,S!M!>5+1,+,! !! Æ&#x201D;)RFXV *URXS ZLWK \RXQJ SHRSOH LQ '*&!,/7''%! ;*+&521&E,!E1+7!8#5&*+,! ! Æ&#x201D;4XDQWLWDWLYH 6XUYH\ TXHVWLRQQDLUH T=#,&%1*&!,+0<6V! Æ&#x201D; ,QWHUYLHZV DQG SDUWLFLSDQW '$,&52#+1'*! Æ&#x201D;4XDQWLWDWLYH VXUYH\ TXHVWLRQQDLUH %DVHOLQH VWXG\ RI \RXQJ SHRSOHÂ¶V 5&#/+1'*,!+'!;)"!! ! ! Æ&#x201D;4XDQWLWDWLYH VXUYH\ TXHVWLRQQDLUH T5&8&#+!'(!$#,&%1*&!,+0<6!/'*<0/+&<!1*! c&&R!HV! Æ&#x201D; 4XDQWLWDWLYH VXUYH\ TXHVWLRQQDLUH! T5&8&#+! '(! $#,&%1*&! ,+0<6! '(! 6'0*J! SHRSOHÂ¶V UHDFWLRQV WR ,&7 ! Æ&#x201D; ,QWHUYLHZV DQG 3DUWLFLSDQW 9$,&52#+1'*! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 23

G%-&1" -" :%.)%:" 7;" &74&C':)74:" Æ&#x201D;:KDW LV WKH FRUH SXUSRVH RI WKH .%N-.8)4N"(1%"<#=+>?"2)C7("2.7A%&(! 85'A&/+i!! Æ&#x201D;:KDW RXWFRPHV DUH SHUFHLYHG WR 5&,0%+! (5'4! +7&! 85'J5#44&! ('5! /71%<5&*S!+&#/7&5,!#*<!85#/+1+1'*&5,i!! Æ&#x201D;:KDW DUH WKH YLHZV RI VWDNHKROGHUV 5&J#5<1*J! 85'J5#44&! 148%&4&*+#+1'*i!! Æ&#x201D;:KDW UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV FDQ EH 4#<&!+'!J01<&!+7&!(0+05&!<&2&%'84&*+! '(!+7&!=->3"?!@5'A&/+i!!

Æ&#x201D;,QWHUYLHZV ZLWK =#$'5P! >5+! B15&/+'5W! @5'A&/+!)'_'5<1*#+'5! Æ&#x201D;)RFXV JURXS ZLWK =#$'5P! C#*#J&4&*+!3+#((!!! Æ&#x201D;$QDO\VLV RI ILQGLQJV IURP k0#*+1+#+12&! <#+#! /'%%&/+1'*! 1*,+504&*+! ! ! Æ&#x201D;5HYLHZ RI DOO SULPDU\ DQG VHFRQGDU\ <#+#!! @5'/&,,!,+0<6!5&21&E! !

% % HEFEH"07CC%&()4N"9-(-"':)4N"+(-48-.8):%8"B%-:'.%,%4(">77C:" ! ;*! @7#,&!;! '(! +7&! =->3"?! ,+0<6 WKH VRFLDO UHVHDUFKHUV GHYHORSHG DQ LQVWUXPHQW WR JDXJH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V #++1+0<&,!+'!+7&!=->3"!85'A&/+S!,/1&*/&!#*<!#5+S!+7&15!(&&%1*J,!#$'0+!,/7''%S!+7&15!(51&*<,!#*<!5&,1%1&*/&! #*<! E&%%$&1*J:! "71,! ,052&6! E#,! 5&8&#+&<! E1+7! /71%<5&*! <051*J! @7#,&! ;;! '(! +7&! =->3"?! 1*! KQHM:! "71,! [0#*+1+#+12&!1*,+504&*+!E#,!8#5+%6!<&2&%'8&<!(5'4!5&,&#5/7!+7#+!E#,!85&21'0,%6!/'48%&+&<!$6!+7&!)71%<! #*<!L#41%6!G&,&#5/7!)&*+5&S!XY;!Z#%E#6!T)LG)V:!"71,!+''%!E#,!+&,+&<!#*<!2#%1<#+&<!('5!4&#,051*J! FKLOGUHQÂ¶V ZHOOEHLQJ WKHLU IHHOLQJV RI UHVLOLHQF\ WKHLU VRFLDO QHWZRUNV DQG VRFLDO VXSSRUWV ,Q WKH %($67 VXUYH\ VXFK LWHPV ZHUH LQFRUSRUDWHG WR ÂµPHDVXUHÂ¶ FKLOGUHQÂ¶V VHQVH RI ÂµEHORQJLQJÂ¶ DW VFKRRO DQG DW 7'4&!1*!'5<&5!+'!/7#5+!#++1+0<1*#%!#*<!$&7#21'05#%!/7#*J&,!T>88&*<1.!;V:! ! F#5,,'*! $+% ",-! LWHPV RQ FKLOGUHQÂ¶V IHHOLQJV RI HFR_#((1*1+6! #*<! &/'_! #E#5&*&,,! E&5&! #%,'! 1*/'58'5#+&<! 1*+'! +7&! 1*,+504&*+:! >,! +7&! ,/1&*+1(1/! 85'A&/+,! 148%&4&*+&<! 1*! ,/7''%,! E&5&! ('/0,&<! '*! FKLOGUHQÂ¶V LQWHUSUHWDWLRQV RI D ÂµVXVWDLQDEOH IXWXUHÂ¶ WKH LQVWUXPHQW ORRNHG DW KRZ \RXQJ SHRSOH UHDFW WR +7&! &*215'*4&*+:! ;+! E#,! #%,'! &*21,#J&<! +7#+! #+! +7&! &*<! '(! +7&! 85'A&/+S! 5&,&#5/7&5,! E'0%<! $&! #$%&! +'! PDNH VRPH VXJJHVWLRQV DERXW FKLOGUHQÂ¶V HQYLURQPHQWDO EHKDYLRXUV DQG DWWLWXGL*#%!/7#*J&,!E71/7!4#6! +#R&!8%#/&!#,!#!5&,0%+!'(!+7&!=->3"?!,+0<6:! ! "7&![0&,+1'**#15&!E#,!<121<&<!1*+'!(12&!<1,/5&+&!,&/+1'*,!T,&&!>88&*<1.!;V:!)71%<5&*!E&5&!#,R&<!#$'0+! +7&15!&.8&51&*/&,!1*!,/7''%\!E7&+7&5!+7&6!(&&%!%1R&!+7&6!$&%'*J!1*!,/7''%!#*<!1(!+7&6!IHOW ÂµFRQQHFWHGÂ¶ WR +7&15!+&#/7&5,!#*<W'5!'+7&5!8081%,:!"7&!,052&6!#%,'!%''R&<!#+!7'E!+7&!/71%<5&*!(&&%!#$'0+!+7&4,&%2&,! LQFOXGHG LWHPV VXFK DV Âµ, IHHO JRRG DERXW P\VHOIÂ¶ Âµ, IHHO ZRUULHGÂ¶ DQG Âµ, IHHO YDOXDEOHÂ¶ 7KH IRXUWK VHFWLRQ #,R&<! #$'0+! +7&! /71%<5&*Â¶V IHHOLQJV WRZDUGV WKHLU IULHQGV ZKLOH VHFWLRQ ILYH IRFXVHG RQ WKHLU DWWLWXGHV +'E#5<,! *#+05&:! "7&! 5&,&#5/7&5,! #<41*1,+&5&<! +7&! ,052&6! E1+7! +7&! /71%<5&*! <051*J! +7&! (15,+! E'5R,7'8! E1+7!+7&!,/1&*+1,+!#*<!5&8&#+&<!1+!#J#1*!<051*J!+7&!(1*#%!,&,,1'*!1*!'5<&5!+'!/7#5+!#*6!/7#*J&,!+7#+!41J7+! 7#2&!+#R&*!8%#/&!1*!$&7#21'05,!#*<!#++1+0<&,!<051*J!+7&!85'A&/+:HQ!"7&!*04$&5!'(!/71%<5&*!E7'!+''R!8#5+! 1*!+7&!,052&6![0&,+1'**#15&!1*!$'+7!,/7''%,!1,!,044#51,&<!1*!+7&!+#$%&!$&%'E!TL1J:!bV:! ! " "

HQ! "7&! ,052&6! [0&,+1'**#15&! E#,! /#551&<! '0+! #+! "H! #*<! "K! 1*! 3/'f%! ;*,&! Z0#15&S! Z'5+! #*<! 3/'f%! )014f*! #J0,! )7#+5f'*#S!

Y#/7+#5!g5<:!"'!<#+&S!1+!7#,!$&&*!/#551&<!'0+!'*%6!'*/&!1*!Z-"X3:!"71,!87#,&!'(!+7&!<#+#!/'%%&/+1'*!1,!+#R1*J!8%#/&!7'E&2&5! 1*!9/+'$&5!KQHM:! 24

O)N'.%"!5"[',I%."7;"2-.()&)2-4(:")4"@.%"-48"@7:("X'%:()744-).%:"\<#=+>?"@.7&%::"+('8/K" " ! ]#>[+" +&7^C"64:%"]'-).%" +&7^C" 0'),^4" -N':" 01-(.^74-" @.%TY'%:()744-).%"\4',I%." FL" 7;"2-.()&)2-4(:K" @7:("Y'%:()744-).%" TTT" \4',I%."7;"2-.()&)2-4(:K"

FF"

FM"

DL"

FM"

" HEFE!"0HDVXULQJ &KLOGUHQÂ·V 5HDFWL74:"(7"60>"-48"+0G=>0_"@.7N.-,,)4N" " ;*!+71,!,&/'*<!6&#5!'(!+7&!85'A&/+S!1+!E#,!<&/1<&<!+'!<&%12&5!O!E'5R,7'8,!1*!3)G>")a!85'J5#441*J!#*<! +7&! 5&,&#5/7&5,! E#*+&<! +'! 1<&*+1(6! +7&! 148#/+,! '(! 0,1*J! +71,! #885'#/7! E1+7! +7&! /71%<5&*:! "7&! ;)"! [0&,+1'*,!E&5&!+#R&*!(5'4!#!,+0<6!$6!@#,,&6! $+%",-%TKQQbV!G1$%83+/;"+/3&",%H<<$6+%3<%IJG%3&%!'7/,.-! F#*/#,+&5! Y*12&5,1+6U! B&8#5+4&*+! '(! -<0/#+1'*! #*<! 3R1%%,:! "7&! ,+0<6! $6! @#,,&6! $+% ",-! TKQQbV! E#,! /#551&<!'0+!1*!H^!,/7''%,!#*<!E1+7!4'5&!+7#*!HKQQ!8081%,:!;+!1<&*+1(1&<!+7#+!;)"!7#<!8',1+12&!4'+12#+1'*#%! &((&/+,! '*! \RXQJ SHRSOHÂ¶V %&#5*1*J! E7&*! 1+! E#,! 148%&4&*+&<! E1+7! #*! #885'851#+&! 8&<#J'J6:! C'5&! 8',1+12&!4'+12#+1'*!'//055&<!E7&*!;)"!E#,!0,&<!#,!#!+&#/71*J!#*<!%&#5*1*J!+''%:!! ! "7&,&![0&,+1'**#15&,!E&5&!/#551&<!'0+!1*!3/'f%!;*,&!Z0#15&!#*<!3/'f%!)014f*!#J0,!)7#+5f'*#!#+!"H!#*<! "K!+'!+5#/&!#*6!$&7#21'05#%!'5!#++1+0<1*#%!/7#*J&,!+'!;)"!E71/7!4#6!$&!#++51$0+#$%&S!#+!%&#,+!1*!8#5+S!+'! SDUWLFLSDQWÂ¶V H[SRVXUH WR WKH 6&5$7&+ ZRUNVKRSV 7KH GDWD FROOHFWLRQ IRU 6&5$7&+ LQ *(716 LV WR $&!/'48%&+&<!1*!9/+'$&5!KQHM!#,!#!*04$&5!'(!+7&!3)G>")a!E'5R,7'8,!E&5&!,/7&<0%&<!+'!+#R&!8%#/&! <051*J! >0+04*! KQHM! 1*! Z-"X3! <0&! +'! <1((1/0%+1&,! ,055'0*<1*J! +14&+#$%&,! 851'5! +'! +7&! KQHM! ,044&5! $5&#R:!L1J05&!O!/'*+#1*,!+7&!*04$&5!'(!/71%<5&*!1*!$'+7!,/7''%,!E7'!+''R!8#5+!#+!"H!#*<!"K\! ! ! 8VLQJ )RFXV *URXSV ,QWHUYLHZV DQG (WKQRJUDSK\ WR $FFHVV &KLOGUHQÂ·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Â¶V EHKDYLRXUV DQG WKHLU OHDUQLQJ 3DUWLFL8#*+! 9$,&52#+1'*! 1,! &.+5&4&%6! #<2#*+#J&'0,! #,! +7&! 5&,&#5/7&5,! E&5&! #$%&! +'! <15&/+%6! #*<! #,R! 8#5+1/18#*+,! #$'0+! +7&15! (&&%1*J,!+'E#5<,!<1((&5&*+!8#5+,!'(!+7&!=->3"?!85'A&/+:! ! L'",/+"+/;$%I&+$*;/$0.%% "71,!&+7*'J5#871/!5&,&#5/7!E#,!#%,'!/'48%&+&<!1*!+#*<&4!E1+7!'(![0#%1+#+12&!1*+&521&E,!E71/7!61&%<&<! &./&8+1'*#%%6!51/7!<#+#!'*!7'E!8&'8%&!T5&V_/'*,+50/+!,'/1#%!4&#*1*J,!T,&&!('5!&.#48%&S!c#+&5+'*!#*<! HH!%DOODQW\QH 5 - 3DFNHU DQG 0 (YHUHWW ÂµC&#,051*J!-*215'*4&*+#%!-<0/#+1'*!@5'J5#4!;48#/+,!#*<!F&#5*1*J!1*!+7&!

L1&%<U!Y,1*J!#*!>/+1'*!G&,&#5/7!)6/%&!+'!B&2&%'8!#!"''%!('5!Y,&!ELWK <RXQJ 6WXGHQWVÂ¶":'.+*",/"&%M3'*&",%3<%H&;/*3&($&+",% H5'6"+/3&>!2'%:!KHU!KM_M^!

c6**&! HNNN\! C#/*#J7+&*! KQQbV:! "7&! #5+1,+,S! ,/1&*+1,+,! #*<! +&#/7&5,! 1*! +7&! +75&&! ,/7''%,! E&5&! 1*+&521&E&<!0,1*J!+7&!1*+&521&E!J01<&!#*<!1*_<&8+7!1*+&521&E1*J!+&/7*1[0&,:!"7&!1*+&521&E,!E&5&!/#551&<! '0+! (#/&! +'! (#/&! #*<! '2&5! +7&! 87'*&:! "7&! /71%<5&*! (5'4! 3/'f%! ;*,&! Z0#15&! #*<! 3/'f%! )014f*! #J0,! )7#+5f'*#!+''R!8#5+!1*!('/0,!J5'08,!#*<!E&5&!2&56!('5+7/'41*J!E1+7!+7&15!1*<121<0#%!#*<!J5'08!5&#/+1'*,! +'!+7&!85'A&/+:!><<1+1'*#%%6S!8#5&*+,!'(!/71%<5&*!1*!3/'f%!)014f*!#J0,!)7#+5f'*#!E&5&!!1*+&521&E&<:!"7&! 5&,&#5/7&5!1*!Z-"X3!4#<&!&(('5+,!+'!/'*+#/+!8#5&*+,!+'!+#R&!8#5+!1*!1*+&521&E,!('5!+71,!,+0<6S!$0+!*'*&! '(!+7&!8#5&*+,!&.85&,,&<!1*+&5&,+!1*!+#R1*J!8#5+:!3/'f%!;*,&!Z0#15&!7#,!#!8'%1/6!'(!*'+!5&[0&,+1*J!8#5&*+,! +'!+#R&!8#5+!1*!,052&6,:!"7&!+'+#%!*04$&5!'(!,+#R&7'%<&5,!E7'!E&5&!1*+&521&E&<!1,!J12&*!$&%'E\! ! ! O)N'.%"J5"@#5+1/18#*+,!1*+&521&E&<!#,!8#5+!'(!=->3"?!85'/&,,!,+0<6\! ! 3DUWLFLSDQW·V UROH LQ %($67 SURMHFW" [',I%."7;"2-.()&)2-4(:")4(%.*)%S%8"" >5+1,+,!! H! 3/1&*+1,+,! O! =#$'5P!5&85&,&*+#+12&,! b! @#5&*+,!! b! "&#/7&5,! O! ! ! HEH"X'-C)(-()*%"-48"X'-4()(-()*%"9-(-"=4-C/:):"! "7&!1*+&521&E,!#*<!&+7*'J5#871/!5&,&#5/7!E#,!#*#%6,&<!0,1*J!B1,/'05,&!>*#%6,1,!TB>V:!"71,!1,!#!71J7%6! 2&5,#+1%&!4&+7'<!'(!#*#%6,1,!#,!1+!/#*!$&!0,&<!+'!#*#%6,&!+&.+,!#*<!87'+'J5#87,!#,!E&%%!#,!+#%R!T,&&! =564#*! KQHKU! OKDV:! "7&! 5&,&#5/7&5,! /'48%&+&<! #! /%',&! 5&#<1*J! '(! +7&! (1&%<! *'+&,! #*<! 1*+&521&E! +5#*,/518+,! #*<! &.+5#/+&<! +7&4&,! (5'4! +7&,&! +&.+,:! Y+1%1,1*J! B1,/'05,&! >*#%6,1,! TB>V!E#,! 0,&(0%!#,! 1+! &*#$%&<! +7&! 5&,&#5/7&5,! +'! #885&/1#+&! 7'E! <1((&5&*+! ,+#R&7'%<&5,! 1*! +7&! 85'A&/+! *&J'+1#+&<! <1((&5&*+! 0*<&5,+#*<1*J,!#$'0+!,/1&*/&S!#5+!#*<!/5&#+121+6:!>0+7'5,!,0/7!#,!>%%<5&<!#*<!=054#*!TKQQOV!#%,'!,+#+&! +7#+! +7&! B>! #885'#/7! 1,! 148'5+#*+! ('5! 5&,&#5/71*J! /71%<5&*:! "7&6! #<2'/#+&! #*! #885'#/7! +'! 5&,&#5/7! E7&5&! 85&/&<&*/&! 1,! J12&*! +'! +7&! 2'1/&! '(! +7&! /71%<! #*<! E7&5&! +7&6! #5&! %1,+&*&<! +'! +75'0J7'0+! +7&! 5&,&#5/7!85'/&,,:!! ! "7&![0#*+1+#+12&!,052&6,!E&5&!#*#%6,&<!0,1*J!+7&!,+#+1,+1/#%!8#/R#J&!3@33!E71/7!1,!E1<&%6!0,&<!1*!+7&! ,'/1#%!,/1&*/&,:! ! HE!"#(1)&-C"6::'%:" -+71/#%! 1,,0&,! E&5&! #%,'! J12&*! +7&! 71J7&,+! 8514#/6! <051*J! +7&! 85'A&/+:! ! >! %1+&5#+05&! ,&#5/7! '*! &+71/#%! 1,,0&,!+7#+!148#/+!'*!5&,&#5/7!E1+7!/71%<5&*!E#,!/'*<0/+&<!<051*J!=->3"?!@7#,&!;!#*<!@7#,&!;;!#*<! WKH UHVHDUFKHUV DGRSWHG D µFKLOG_FHQWUHG¶ DSSURDFK WR WKH SURFHVV RI GDWD FROOHFWLRQ $ FRQVHQW <'/04&*+! E#,! 85&8#5&<! E71/7! +7&! /71%<5&*! ,1J*&<! $&('5&! +#R1*J! 8#5+! 1*! +7&! 1*+&521&E,! #*<! +71,! /'*+#1*&<! 81/+05&,! E71/7! +7&! /71%<5&*! /'0%<! 5&%#+&! +':! G&85&,&*+#+12&,! (5'4! =#$'5P! #*<! +7&! ,/7''%,! FRQWDFWHG SDUHQWV WR DVN SHUPLVVLRQ IRU WKHLU FKLOG¶V LQYROYHPHQW LQ WKH VWXG\ SULRU WR LWV /'44&*/&4&*+:!='+7!'(!+7&!5&,&#5/7&5,!E&5&!2&++&<!$6!Z#5<#f!$&('5&!/'48%&+1*J!+7&!,+0<6:! ! ! ! HEJ"074&C':)74"! "71,! /7#8+&5!'0+%1*&<! +7&!41.&<_4&+7'<!#885'#/7! +7#+! E#,! 0+1%1,&<!<051*J! +71,!,+0<6:! C1.&<_4&+7'<,! &*#$%&<! +7&! 5&,&#5/7&5,! +'! /5&#+&! #! 40/7! (0%%&5! 81/+05&! '(! +7&! 5&#/+1'*,! '(! /71%<5&*! #*<! '+7&5! ,+#R&7'%<&5,! T+&#/7&5,S! ,/1&*+1,+,! #*<! #5+1,+,V! +'E#5<,! +7&! 85'A&/+:! "7&! [0#%1+#+12&! #*<! &+7*'J5#871/! 5&,&#5/7! ,+5#+&J1&,! 61&%<&<! 1*_GHSWK GDWD RQ UHDFWLRQV WR WKH SURMHFW DQG WKH FKLOGUHQ¶V EHKDYLRXUV 26

a'E&2&5S!+7&![0#*+1+#+12&!,052&6![0&,+1'**#15&!&*#$%&<!+7H UHVHDUFKHUV WR WDS LQWR FKLOGUHQÂ¶V IHHOLQJV '(!5&,1%1&*/&S!E&%%$&1*JS!,'/1#%!,088'5+!#*<!+7&15!5&#/+1'*,!+'!*#+05&:!!! ! C1.&<_4&+7'<,! /'0%<! $&! #<2#*+#J&'0,! ('5! '+7&5! &2#%0#+1'*,! '(! +7&! =->3"?! 85'A&/+! +7#+! 41J7+! $&! /'48%&+&<!1*!+7&!(0+05&:!a'E&2&5S!+7&5&!#5&!,'4&!%141+#+1'*,:!"7&!(#/+!+7#+!+7&!=->3"?!E#,!/'48%&+&<! '2&5!,0/7!#!,7'5+!+14&_,/#%&!4&#*,!+7#+!+7&!<#+#!1,!%141+&<!1*!+7&!&.+&*+!+7#+!1+!/#*!/#8+05&!$&7#21'05#%! /7#*J&,! 1*! /71%<5&*:! "7#+! ,#1<S! +7&! 0+1%1,#+1'*! '(! [0#%1+#+12&! #*<! [0#*+1+#+12&! 4&+7'<,! 1*! +71,! /'*+&.+! IDFLOLWDWHG D ULFK GDWDVHW RI FKLOGUHQÂ¶V UHDFWLRQV WR ,&7 VFLHQFH WKH HQYLURQPHQW DQG WKH DUWV 7KH QH[W /7#8+&5!'(!+71,!5&8'5+!'0+%1*&,!+7&!4#1*!(1*<1*J,!(5'4!+7&!+75&&!/#,&_,+0<6!,/7''%,:" !

01-2(%."O7'.5">1.%%"0-:%"+('8)%:"7;"@-.()&)2-()4N"+&177C:" " !ED"64(.78'&()74" ;*! +71,! /7#8+&5S! $#/RJ5'0*<! <&+#1%,! '*! +7&! +75&&! 8#5+1/18#+1*J! ,/7''%,! #5&! 85'21<&<:! "71,! ,&/+1'*! 85&,&*+,! /51+1/#%! <#+#! '*! 7'E! +7&! =->3"?! 85'A&/+! E#,! ! '8&5#+1'*#%1,&<! 1*! &#/7! '(! +7&! ,/7''%,:! "71,! 1*/%0<&,!<&+#1%,!'*!+7&!/'*+&*+!'(!+7&!1*<121<0#%!E'5R,7'8,!+7#+!E&5&!<&%12&5&<!$6!+7&!,/1&*+1,+,S!#5+1,+! #*<!/'480+&5!+&/7*'%'J1,+,\!E7#+!+7&6!E#*+&<!+'!#/71&2&!+75'0J7'0+!+7&!85'A&/+!#*<!+7&!%&#5*1*J!'(!+7&! 8#5+1/18#*+,!E7'!+''R!8#5+!1*!+7&!85'A&/+:!!"71,!1*/%0<&<!+7&!21&E,!'(!/71%<5&*S!+&#/7&5,S!,/1&*+1,+,!#*<! +7&!#5+1,+:! ! "7&!(15,+!/#,&!,+0<6!E71/7!1,!'0+%1*&<!7&5&!5&%#+&,!+'!3/'f%!)014f*!#J0,!)#1+5f'*#S!Y#/7+#5!g5<!E71/7!1,! ,1+0#+&<! 1*! #! 85&<'41*#*+%6! 505#%! #5&#! *'5+7! '(! Z#%E#6! )1+6S! *&#5! +7&! ,7'5&,! '(! F'0J7! )'551$:! "7&! ,&/'*<!/#,&!,+0<6!<'/04&*+,!+7&!=->3"?!4'<&%!#,!1+!E#,!148%&4&*+&<!1*!3/'f%!;*,&!Z0#15&S!Z'5+!#*<! +7&!+715<!/#,&!,+0<6!('/0,&,!'*!+7&!148%&4&*+#+1'*!'(!+7&!85'A&/+!1*!Z#%E#6!-<0/#+&!"'J&+7&5!X#+1'*#%! 3/7''%!TZ-"X3VS!X&E/#,+%&S!Z#%E#6!)1+6:! !

0-:%"+('8/"DE"+&7^C"0'),^4"-N':"01-)(.^74-"W"U-&1(-."`UG 'LVFRYHULQJ &KLOGUHQÂ·V LGHDV DERXW Â¶6PDUW 'HYLFHVÂ· &DUERQ 8VDJH DQG Â¶6XVWDLQDEOH )XWXUHVÂ·" $ 85(9:/%1;2$ 3/'f%!!)014f*!#J0,!)#1+5f'*#!1,!%'/#+&<!1*!+7&!+'E*!'(!Y#/7+#5!g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Â¶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a&!E#*+&<!+7&!/71%<5&*!+'!<&2&%'8!+7&15!1<&#,!#5'0*<! VFLHQFH EHLQJ YDOXDEOH DQG ÂµEHLQJ HYHU\ZKHUH LQ OLIH Â¶ +H WDONHG DERXW LQVSLULQJ FKLO<5&*! 1*! 8514#56! ,/7''%,!+'!$&/'4&!+7&!ÂµVFLHQWLVWV RI WKH IXWXUHÂ¶T3/1&*+1,+!HV!#*<!7&!<1<!*'+!E#*+!+7&!/71%<5&*!+'!(&&%!+7#+! WKH\ ZHUH ÂµUHPRYHGÂ¶ IURP VFLHQFH ! ! "7&! ,/1&*+1,+! <&%12&5&<! +75&&! E'5R,7'8,! '(! NQ! 41*0+&,! &#/7:! a&! <1,/0,,&<! 71,! E'5R! #,! #! /'480+&5! ,/1&*+1,+! #*<! 71,! %1*R! E1+7! XY;Z! #*<! E1+7! B-G;! TB1J1+#%! -*+&5851,&! G&,&#5/7! ;*,+1+0+&V:! a&! (05+7&5! <&2&%'8&<! +7&! /'*/&8+! '(!&%&/+51/1+6! /5&#+1'*! #*<! 0,&<! 21<&',! +'! ,7'E/#,&! 7'E! &*&5J6! 1,!J&*&5#+&<! #*<! <&%12&5&<! +75'0J7! +7&! *#+1'*#%! J51<:! 90+<''5! #/+121+6! '(! ÂµMXPSLQJ MDFNVÂ¶ IRU D VKRUW WLPH SHULRG ,7'E&<!1*!#!/'*/5&+&!E#6!7'E!%'*J!E'0%<!7#2&!+'!&*J#J&!1*!+71,!#/+121+6!+'!/5&#+&!H!E#++!'(!&*&5J6:! "7&6! ,#E! 7'E! %'*J! +7&6! E'0%<! 7#2&! +'! A048! 1*! '5<&5! +'! 85'<0/&! &*'0J7! E#++,! +'! 8'E&5! /'44'*! #88%1#*/&,! ('5! '*&! 7'05 7KH\ ZHUH VKRZQ FDUWRRQ YLGHRV RI Âµ(GÂ¶V :RUOGÂ¶ ZKLFK GHPRQVWUDWHG WKH /'*,&[0&*/&,! ('5! +7&! E'5%<! '(! &./&,,12&! &*&5J6! /'*,048+1'*! 1*! #*! #40,1*J! E#6! #*<! +7&! /71%<5&*! <1,8%#6&<!#!+7'5'0J7!0*<&5,+#*<1*J!'(!+7&!(1%4,!4&,,#J&,:!!!"7&!/71%<5&*!$5'0J7+!+#,R,!7'4&!+'!E'5R! '*!E1+7!+7&15!(#41%1&,!#*<!E&5&!#$%&!+'!/#%/0%#+&!+7&!#885'.14#+&!&*&5J6!0,#J&!'(!+7&15!7'0,&7'%<!#*<! 1<&*+1(6!E7&5&!&*&5J6!/'0%<!$&!,#2&<:!@#5&*+,!&*J#J&<!E1+7!/71%<5&*!1*!+7&!&.&5/1,&!#*<!%&#5*&<!4'5&! 28

#$'0+!&*&5J6!/'*,&52#+1'*!#*<!#%,'!4'5&!#$'0+!+7&!85'A&/+:!"71,!148%1&,!+7#+!+7&!=->3"!85'A&/+!7#<! ,1J*1(1/#*+!%&#5*1*J!'0+/'4&,!('5!/71%<5&*!#*<!#<0%+,:! ! "7&! /71%<5&*!#%,'! 21,1+&<! +7&! "&/7*'%'J6! #*<! 3/1&*/&! C0,&04! $#,&<! 1*! B-G;! #+! XY;! Z#%E#6:! "7&6! E&5&! 2&56! &*J#J&<! E1+7! +7&! &.71$1+,! +7#+! /7#5+! +7&! <&2&%'84&*+! '(! /'440*1/#+1'*,! #*<! 1*('54#+1'*! +&/7*'%'J6!(5'4!&#5%6!+14&,:!"7&6!E&5&!8#5+1/0%#5%6!1*+&5&,+&<!1*!+7&!'%<!,/7''%!/%#,,5''4!&.71$1+!#*<!1*! +7&! &#5%6! 2&5,1'*,! '(! /'480+&5! J#4&,! #*<! /'480+&5! +&/7*'%'J6! ,#61*J! Âµ,Â¶P D KDFNHU Â¶! "7&6! #,R&<! 4#*6![0&,+1'*,!'*!'%<&5!2&5,1'*,!'(!+&/7*'%'J6!<&2&%'8&<!$&('5&!+7&6!E&5&!$'5*!,0/7!#,!ÂµKRZ GLG WKH ILUVW ODSWRS GHYHORS"Â¶ % % c7&*!+#%R1*J!#$'0+!+7&!,/1&*+1,+!+7&!/71%<5&*!,#1<!Âµ, OLNHG WKDW KH GLGQÂ¶W VKRXW Â±%$;$&%+13'#1%.3($3&$% LQWHUUXSWHG KLP KH GLGQÂ¶W JHW DQQR\HGÂ¶ Âµ+H GLG WKLQJV WKH IXQ ZD\ MRNHU KH ZDV EROG Â¶ % ;*!5&%#+1'*!+'!,/1&*/&!#,!#!,0$A&/+!+7&!/71%<5&*!,#1<!Âµ,WÂ¶V UHDOO\ IXQ EHFDXVH VRPHWKLQJ FRXOG H[SORGH OLNH "%;3,6"&3%"&5%I%OLNH WKH ZD\ VFLHQFH LV IXQ EHFDXVH \RX GRQÂ¶W NQRZ WKH HQGLQJÂ¶ Âµ<RX JHW \RXU K"&5.% ($..=%"&5%I%,3;$%53/&#%+1"+-%I+Â¶V UHDOO\ UHOD[LQJÂ¶% $ <"5)$)"#$=/)*,)$45;)#2$)%$5("*#+#$ "7&!#5+1,+!<&%12&5&<!('05!NQ_HKQ!41*0+&!E'5R,7'8,!+'!+7&!J5'08:!"7&!#5+1,+,!$51&(!E#,!+'!&.+5#8'%#+&!+7&! FKLOGUHQÂ¶V UHVSRQVHV WR WKH FRQWHQW WKDW ZDV GHOLYHUHG E\ WK&!,/1&*+1,+:!>*<!7'E!+7&6!/'*/&8+0#%1,&<!#! ÂµORZ FDUERQ IXWXUHÂ¶ DV H[SUHVVHG E\ WKH TXHVWLRQ Âµ:KDW ZLOO \RX GR LI \RX DUH OLYLQJ RQ WKH $UDQ >,65;2,$5;2$)"#/#$*,$;%$#6#()/*(*)3?$@%4$4*66$3%1$,1/+*+#?$"71,!85'$&<!/71%<5&*!+'!+71*R!'0+,1<&!'(! WKHLU RZQ ÂµOLIHZRUOGVÂ¶ WR WKLQN DERXW FKLOGUHQ DQG DGXOWÂ¶V OLYHV LQ RWKHU SODFHV DQG WKH LPSDFWV RI VFLHQFH '*!#%%!'05!%12&,:!! ! 7KH DUWLVWÂ¶V DLP ZDV WKDW WKH FKLOGUHQ ZRXOG #%,'!0,&!+71,![0&,+1'*!+'!4'+12#+&!+7&4!+'!J#1*!+7&!,R1%%!'(! ,+'56!E51+1*J:!a&!8%#**&<!+'!<'!+71,!+75'0J7!/5&#+1*J!&*+70,1#,4!#*<!&*J#J&4&*+!,'!+7#+!+7&6!E'0%<!$&! ÂµSHUVRQDOO\ LQYROYHG LQ WKH SURFHVV LQ DQ HPRWLRQDO FUHDWLYH DQG FRPSHOOLQJ ZD\Â¶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Âµ/.%/+%01$*$%=3'%0$*$%)3*&%3*%01$*$%=3'%0$*$%)$<3*$%=3'%0$*$%)3*&"Â¶ 7KH DUWLVW #%,'! ,7'E&<! +7&! /71%<5&*! 7'E! +'! <5#E! /7#5#/+&5,! +7#+! /'0%<! $&! #<#8+&<! ('5! /'480+&5! J#4&,:! "7&6! 85'<0/&<!,'4&!2&56!'51J1*#%!<5#E1*J,!+7#+!+7&!#5+1,+!+7&*!,148%1(1&<!,'!+7#+!+7&6!E'0%<!$&!#$%&!+'!#<#8+! +7&4!('5!+7&!*&.+!,+#J&!'(!+7&!85'A&/+!E71/7!E#,!+'!%&#5*!3)G>")a!85'J5#441*J!1*!'5<&5!+'!<&,1J*!#! /'480+&5!J#4&!$#,&<!'*!+7&!'51J1*#%!,+'56%1*&:! ! c7&*!#,R&<!#$'0+!+7&!#5+!E'5R,7'8,S!+7&!/71%<5&*!#885&/1#+&<!+7&!<1((&5&*/&!$&+E&&*! +7&!,/1&*+1,+Â¶V! DQG DUWLVWÂ¶V SUHVHQWDWLRQ VW\OHV DQG WKH\ HQMR\HG WKH MRNHV 7KH\ SUHIHUUHG WKH VHVVLRQV ZKHUH WKH\ E&5&! &*J#J&<! 1*! E51+1*J! +7&! ,+'56%1*&! #*<! <5#E1*J! /7#5#/+&5,:! "7&6! #885&/1#+&<! E7&5&! +7&6! %&#5*&<! #$'0+!+7&!148'5+#*/&!'(!8%#**1*J!('5!$&++&5!,+'51&,!#*<!('5!$&++&5!<5#E1*J,:!"7&!&#5%6!,+#J&,!E7&5&!+7&! #5+1,+!<1,/0,,&<!#*<!<&,/51$&<!+7&!85'/&,,!'(!,+'56!E51+1*J!E&5&!&*A'6&<!%&,,!$6!,'4&!'(!+7&!/71%<5&*S! '*&!'(!E7'4!,#1<!+7#+!1+!E#,!ÂµOLNH #3/&#%+3%FKXUFKÂ¶!:!"7&6!#%,'!,#1<!+7&6!85&(&55&<!1+!E7&*!+7&!#5+1,+!ÂµOHWV XV GR WKH ZRUN LQVWHDG RI GRLQJ LW DOO KLPVHOIÂ¶-%30/7!(1*<1*J,!,&&4!+'!/'55'$'5#+&!+7&!(1*<1*J,!(5'4!+7&! %1+&5#+05&!<1,/0,,&<!85&21'0,%6!1*!+71,!5&8'5+!E71/7!,+#+&,!+7#+!/71%<5&*!%&#5*!1*!71J7%6!1*+&5#/+12&!E#6,! DQG WKDW GLGDFWLF PRGHV RI WHDFKLQJ DQG LQIRUPDWLRQ WUDQVIHU RIWHQ VWLIOH \RXQJ SHRSOHÂ¶V HQJDJHPHQW LQ /5&#+12&!85'/&,,&,:! 29

$ <"5)$)"#$(%AB1)#/$)#(";%6%:*,)$45;)#2$)%$5("*#+#C$ "E'!/'480+&5!+&/7*'%'J1,+,!<&%12&5&<!(12&!^Q!41*0+&!3)G>")a!85'J5#441*J!E'5R,7'8,!+'!+7&!J5'08! +7#+! #<#8+&<! +7&! '51J1*#%! ,+'56%1*&! <&2&%'8&<! E1+7! +7&! ,/1&*+1,+! #*<! +7&! #5+1,+:! "7&! /%#,,! +&#/7&5! #*<! #*'+7&5!+&#/7&5!,088'5+&<!+7&!%&,,!DEOH FKLOGUHQ DV WKH\ IROORZHG WKH WHFKQRORJLVWÂ¶V GLUHFWLRQV ,QLWLDOO\ +7&!/71%<5&*!E&5&!,7'E*!7'E!+'!'8&5#+&!+7&!85'J5#44&!#*<!+7&6!81/R&<!08!+7&!85'/&,,!2&56![01/R%6:! "7&!/71%<5&*!E&5&!2&56!R&&*!#*<!&./%#14&<!+7#+!1+!E#,! ÂµFRROÂ¶!4#*6!+14&,:!"7&6!E'5R&<!'*!%#8+'8,!1*! J5'08,!'(! +E'W+75&&! +#R1*J!+05*,! +'! '8&5#+&! +7&! R&6,!#*<! E&5&!&./&%%&*+! #+! ('%%'E1*J! <15&/+1'*,:! "7&6! E&5&! 1*+&5&,+&<! 1*! E7'! 7#<! 1*2&*+&<! 3)G>")a! TC#,,#/70,&++,! ;*,+1+0+&! '(! "&/7*'%'J6V! #*<! E7'! 'E*&<!1+!T98&*!>//&,,V:!"7&!/71%<5&*!0,&<!+7&!<1J1+#%!<5#E1*J!+''%,!+'!<5#E!+7&!/7#5#/+&5,!+7&6!7#<! <&2&%'8&<!E1+7!+7&!#5+1,+!#*<!+7&*!+7&6!<&,1J*&<!$#/R<5'8!#*<!#/+1'*,!('5!+7&!/7#5#/+&5,:!3'4&!'(!+7&! /71%<5&*!1*/%0<&<!&%&4&*+,!(5'4!+7&!,+'56!%1*&!,0/7!#,!+7&!&*&5J6!,'05/&!+7#+!E#,!4#%(0*/+1'*1*J!'*! +7&!>5#*!;,%#*<,:!"7&!/71%<5&*!&*A'6&<!&.8&514&*+1*J!E1+7!+7&!8#1*+!8#<!#*<!<5#E1*J!&%&4&*+,!'(!+7&! 3)G>")a!85'J5#44&:! ! c7&*!#,R&<!#$'0+!+7&!E'5R,7'8,!+7&6!,#1<!Âµ, OLNH WKDW ZH JRW WR GR VRPHWKLQJ LQVWHDG RI >VFLHQWLVW@ GRLQJ DOO WKH ZRUN Â¶ Âµ<RX KDYH WR SD\ "++$&+/3&%+3%,$"*&%01"+%+3%53%---%*$",,=%7"=%"++$&+/3&--%/+%0".%1"*5% "&5%61",,$&#/&#-Â¶ Âµ:H OLNHG WKDW ZH KDG FRRO FRPSXWHUV WR ZRUN RQ DQG LW ZDV MXVW OLNH ZRUNLQJ DQG SOD\LQJ Â¶ Âµ,WÂ¶V D ELW FRQIXVLQJ 3%1%0$*$%+1$%13($@PDGH FRPSXWHU JDPH \RXUVHOI Â¶ Âµ\RX J3+%+/($%Â±%,3"5.% 3<%+/($--%+1$%3+1$*.%B03*?.137.C%0$*$%*'.1/&#%=3'-%G1$%13'*%<$,+%.13*+%"&5%/+%0".%#*$"+%<'&-Â¶% 92&5#%%S!,0/7!(1*<1*J,!148%6!+7#+!+7&!/71%<5&*!&*A'6&<!$&1*J!,+140%#+&<!$6!+7&!1*+&5#/+12&!&%&4&*+,!'(! +7&!=->3"!85'/&,,!#*<!+7#+!+7&!85'/&,,!,+140%#+&<!+7&15!/5&#+121+6!#,!E&%%!#,!+7&15!%&#5*1*J:! ! 8#;#-*),$)%$)"#$("*62/#;$%-$B5/)*(*B5)*%;$*;$)"#$8D=0!$>>$./%'#()$ H&#"#$($&+%"&5%/&6*$".$5%"++$&+/3&%.7"&% % "7&!+&#/7&5,!(&%+!+7#+!+7&!/71%<5&*!E&5&!2&56!&*J#J&<!1*!#%%!&%&4&*+,!'(!+7&!E'5R,7'8,%Âµ7KH FKLOG*$&% 0$*$%;$*=%$&#"#$5%+1*3'#13'+%"&5%;$*=%$A6LWHGÂ¶ T"&#/7&5!MV! %%Âµ7KH FODVV KDG D VLJQLILFDQW SURSRUWLRQ RI FKLOGUHQ ZLWK ODQJXDJH GLIILFXOWLHV RU OHDUQLQJ GLIILFXOWLHV 01$*$%+1$=%%%%%1";$%$A7$*/$&6$%"%,3+%3<%<"/,'*$%"&5%B+1$.$%61/,5*$&C%0$*$%"),$%+3%$&#"#$%/&%+1$% 6&5$7&+ SURJUDPPLQJ DQG LQ DUW RQ DQ HTXDO EDVLV WR WKH RWKHUV LQ WKH FODVV 7KDWÂ¶V WKH EHDXW\ RI LW LW FDWHUV IRU HYHU\ OHYHOÂ¶ 7HDFKHU Âµ,W JLYHV WKH OHVV DFDGHPLF FKLOGUHQ D FKDQFH WR VKLQHÂ¶ T"&#/7&5! MV:!)71%<5&*!<&,/51$&<!+7&!E'5R,7'8,!#,!ÂµIXQÂ¶ ÂµH[LWLQJ DQG DPD]LQJÂ¶ ÂµIXQN\ DQG FRROÂ¶ #*<!,7'E&<!+7&15! 1*+&5&,+!+75'0J7'0+!+7&!4#A'51+6!'(!,&,,1'*,:!! "7&!+&#/7&5,!<1,/0,,&<!+7#+!+7&!/71%<5&*!E&5&!,+1%%!+#%R1*J!#$'0+!+7&!E'5R,7'8,!'*!+7&15!5&+05*!+'!,/7''%! 1*!#0+04*!KQHM!#*<!'*!7'E!+7&6!7#<!0,&<!3)G>")a!#+!7'4&!'2&5!+7&!,044&5:%% % N$;$,37($&+%3<%O$0%P?/,,.%% "&#/7&5,!#885&/1#+&<!+7&!,R1%%!%&2&%,!'(!85#/+1+1'*&5,:! Âµ,WÂ¶V JUHDW WR KDYH VXFK GLIIHUHQW H[SHUWV LQ WKHLU ILHOGÂ¶ T"&#/7&5!MV:!"7&6!#%,'!1<&*+1(1&<!+7#+!+7&!/71%<5&*!J#1*&<!J''<!E51+1*J!,R1%%,!#*<!+7#+!+7&6!+''!#,! WHDFKHUV KDG ÂµSLFNHG XS ORDGV IURP >WKH DUWLVW@ DQG IURP WKH 6&5$7&+ ZRUNVKRSVÂ¶:!"&#/7&5,!1<&*+1(1&<! +7#+! /71%<5&*! <1,8%#6&<! J''<! 5&/#%%S! 1485'2&<! /51+1/#%! +71*R1*J! #*<! 5&/'5<1*J! ,R1%%,:! "7&! /'480+&5! +&/7*'%'J1,+,! &*J#J&<! 2&56! E&%O ZLWK WKH FODVV Âµ+1$=% 0$*$% <"&+".+/6% 0/+1% 5$(3&.+*"+/&#% +1$% 63(7'+$*% VNLOOV DQG WKH FKLOGUHQ UHVSRQGHG ZHOO DQG WKH WHDPZRUN GHYHORSHG JRRG VRFLDO VNLOOV LQ WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶ T"&#/7&5!bV:!;*,+1%%1*J!,0/7!#!E1<&!5#*J&!'(!,R1%%,!1*!6'0*J!8&'8%&!1,!148'5+#*+!('5!1485'21*J!#/#<&41/! '0+80+,:! a'E&2&5S! +7&,&! #5&! #%,'! %1(&! ,R1%%,! E71/7! E1%%! $&! <&2&%'8&<! #*<! *05+05&<! +75'0J7'0+! +7&! %1(&! /'05,&:! !

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¶V UHSRU+! E71/7! ,7'E&<! +7#+! R*'E%&<J&! #*<! #++1+0<&,! +'E#5<,! ,/1&*/&!E&5&!,1J*1(1/#*+%6!&*7#*/&<!+75'0J7!+7&!=->3"?!85'/&,,:! % !#5("*;:$A#)"%2$E$F/%,,$(1//*(165/$5BB/%5("#,$ 9*&! +&#/7&5! (&%+! +7#+! +7&! /71%<5&*! E&5&! 2&56! #/+12&! +75'0J7'0+! +7&! E'5R,7'8,:! "7&! ,0$A&/+,! /'2&5&<! OLQNHG ZHOO ZLWK HDFK RWKHU DQG DOVR OLQNHG ZLWK WKH FKLOGUHQ¶V RZQ OLYHV 7KH\ VDZ D JUHDW GHDO RI 1*+&J5#+1'*!#/5',,!,0$A&/+!#5&#,:!9*&!+&#/7&5!(&%+!+7#+!+7&!E'5R,7'8,!,7'E&<!+7&4!+7#+!#5+!/#*!$&!0,&<! 1*!4'5&!,0$A&/+,!+7#*!A0,+!-*J%1,7!#*<!(&%+!+7#+!+7&6!%&#5*&<!#!%'+!(5'4!+7&!E'5R,7'8,!#*<!µWKDW WKHUH LV .637$%+3%'.$%(=%30&%6*$"+/;/+=%"&5%+1/.%1".%.130&%($%130-%I+%1".%/(7*3;$5%(=%+$"61/&#%.+=,$%+3%)$% >PRUH@ FUHDWLYH DQG UHOD[HG DQG LQ JHWWLQJ WKH FKLOGUHQ WR H[SUHVV PRUH¶!T"&#/7&5!b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a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µ:H ZRXOG OLNH % %%%%%%%%%%PRUH ZRUN ZLWK FRPSXWHUV¶ µ , ZRXOG OLNH WR KDYH DUW HYHU\GD\ µ µ, ZRXOGQ¶W GR LW WKH ZD\ WKDW WKH % %%%%%%%%%%DUWLVW GLG LW DW WKH VWDUW¶ %"7&6!85&(&55&<!+7&!1*+&5#/+12&!,&,,1'*,!E7&5&!+7&6!E&5&!<'1*J!4',+!'(!! !!!!!!!!!!+7&!E'5R!5#+7&5!+7#*!+7&!&#5%6!,&,,1'*,!E7&5&!+7&!#5+,!85#/+1+1'*&5!E#,!<'1*J!#!%'+!'(!+#%R1*J:! ! " !

0-:%" +('8/" FE" +&7^C" ,QVH *XDLUH *RUW 1DWLRQDO 6FKRRO Â¶$OWHUQDWLYH HQHUJ\ 6RXUFHV DQG KDUYHVWLQJ HQHUJ\ IURP SHRSOHÂ· " $ 85(9:/%1;2$ 3/'f%!;*,&!Z0#15&!1,!#!,4#%%!+75&&!+&#/7&5!,/7''%S!%'/#+&<!'*!+7&!'0+,R15+,!'(!Z'5+:!"7&!8081%,!#5&!#%%! 4#%&! #*<! +7&! /0%+05&! '(! +7&! ,/7''%! 1,! '*&! E7&5&! ,8'5+! 1,! 2&56! 148'5+#*+! #*<! +7&5&! #5&! 4#*6! '88'5+0*1+1&,!+'!&*J#J&!1*!,8'5+1*J!#/+121+1&,:!"7&!,/7''%!8'80%#+1'*!1*/%0<&,!#!,1J*1(1/#*+!85'8'5+1'*!'(! 8081%,!(5'4!*&E/'4&5!(#41%1&,!#*<!+7&5&!#5&!%#*J0#J&!/7#%%&*J&,!('5!*&E!8081%,!#*<!('5!+7&15!+&#/7&5,:! "7&!8#5+1/18#+1*J!/%#,,!1*/%0<&<!KQ!$'6,!E7'!E&5&!1*!M5<!#*<!b+7!)%#,,!#*<!#J&<!$&+E&&*!&1J7+!#*<!+&*! 6&#5,:! ! <"5)$)"#$0(*#;)*,)$45;)#2$)%$5("*#+#$ "7&!,/1&*+1,+!<&%12&5&<!+75&&!NQ!41*0+&!E'5R,7'8,!+'!+7&!/%#,,:!37&!7#<!E'5R&<!E1+7!+7&!,#4&!J5'08!'(! /71%<5&*!1*!+7&!(15,+!87#,&!'(!=->3"!#*<!7#<!+7&!#14!'(!(05+7&5!<&2&%'81*J!WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V NQRZOHGJH RI ,/1&*/&S! 1*! 8#5+1/0%#5S! +7&15! 0*<&5,+#*<1*J! '(! 5&*&E#$%&! &*&5J6! #*<! &*&5J6! 7#52&,+1*J! <&21/&,:! 37&! 7'8&<! +'! (05+7&5! <&2&%'8! +7&! 1GHD WKDW VFLHQFH LV HDV\ DQG HQFRXUDJH WKHP Âµ&3+% +3% )$% "<*"/5% 3<% TXHVWLRQLQJ WKLQJV DERXW VFLHQFHÂ¶ #*<!ÂµWKDW PDWKV WKH\ DSSO\ >1*!+7&!E'5R,7'8,@ LV LQWHUHVWLQJ DQG HDV\Â¶ QP6/$&+/.+%RS%"7&!,/1&*+1,+!#%,'!5&J0%#5%6!5&41*<&<!+7&!8#5+1/18#*+,!#$'0+!+7&!8',&<!85'$%&4!'(!7'E!+7&6! E'0%<!,05212&!E1+7'0+!&%&/+51/1+6!'*!#*!1,%#*<!#*<!E7#+!+71,!E'0%<!4&#*!#+!#!8&5,'*#%!%&2&%:!"7&!#14!'(! +71,! &.&5/1,&! E#,! +'! &*/'05#J&! 6'0*J! 8&'8%&! +'! +71*R! #J#1*! #$'0+! &*&5J6! /'*,048+1'*! #*<! ,0,+#1*#$1%1+6:! ! <"5)$)"#$=/)*,)$45;)#2$)%$5("*#+#$ "7&! #5+1,+! <&%12&5&<! ('05! NQ_HKQ! 41*0+&! E'5R,7'8,! +'! +7&! J5'08:! "7&! $51&(! E#,! +'! &.+5#8'%#+&! +7&! FKLOGUHQÂ¶V UHVSRQVHV WR WKH FRQWHQW WKDW ZDV GHOLYHUHG E\ WKH VFLHQWLVW $QG WR ILQG RXW KRZ WKH\ FRQFHSWXDOLVHG D ÂµORZ FDUERQ IXWXUHÂ¶ DV H[SUHVVHG E\ WK&![0&,+1'*!Âµ:KDW ZLOO \RX GR LI \RX DUH OLYLQJ %;$)"#$=/5;$>,65;2,$5;2$)"#/#$*,$;%$#6#()/*(*)3?$@%4$4*66$3%1$,1/+*+#?$7KH DUWLVWÂ¶V DLP ZDV WKDW WKH /71%<5&*!E'0%<!0,&!+71,![0&,+1'*!+'!4'+12#+&!+7&4!+'!J#1*!+7&!,R1%%!'(!,+'56!E51+1*J:!a&!8%#**&<!+'!<'!+71,! +75'0J7!/5&#+1*J!&*+70,1#,4!#*<!&*J#J&4&*+!,'!+7#+!+7&6!E'0%<!$&!ÂµSHUVRQDOO\ LQYROYHG LQ WKH SURFHVV LQ DQ HPRWLRQDO FUHDWLYH DQG FRPSHOOLQJ ZD\Â¶ T>5+1,+!HV!a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a!85'J5#44&!E'5R,7'8,:!B051*J! WKH HDUO\ FUHDWLYH ZULWLQJ ZRUNVKRSV WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V OHYHO RI HQJDJHPHQW WHQGHG WR GURS RII DV WKH '88'5+0*1+6!+'!&*J#J&!E#,!%&,,!#*<!+7&!E'5R,7'8,!%#,+&<!+E'!7'05,:!c7&*!#!$5&#R!E#,!1*/%0<&<!+7&! &*J#J&4&*+!1485'2&<!#*<!E7&5&!+7&!/71%<5&*!7#<!+7&!'88'5+0*1+6!+'!85#/+1/&!+7&15!'E*!/5&#+12&!E51+1*J! #*<!<5#E1*J! +#,R,! &*J#J&4&*+! E#,! 40/7! 1485'2&<:!"7&! /71%<5&*! ,#1<!+7#+! +7&!,/1&*+1,+! ÂµPDGH ZRUN (3*$%/&+$*$VWLQJÂ¶ "7&6!85&(&55&<!40/7!4'5&!1*+&5#/+12&!,+6%&,!'(!+&#/71*J!E7&5&!+7&6!/'0%<!%1*R!+7&! SRLQWV PDGH E\ WKH DUWLVW WR WKHLU RZQ H[SHULHQFHV Âµ7KH\ VKRXOGQÂ¶W MXVW VKRZ XV >SLFWXUHV@ ZH ZDQW WR .$$%VWXII QRW MXVW KHDU DERXW LW RU >VHH LW@ RQ YLGHRÂ¶:!!"7&!#5+1,+!('0*<!+7#+!+7&!/%#,,!#,!#!J5'08!E&5&!2&56! %12&%6! E1+7! ,7'5+&5! #++&*+1'*! ,8#*! +7#*! +7&! '+7&5! +E'! J5'08,! 7&! E#,! E'5R1*J! E1+7! #*<! #+! +14&,! +71,! 1*+&5(&5&<!E1+7!+7&!%&#5*1*J!8',,1$1%1+1&,:!"71,!71J7%1J7+,!7'E!8&&5!<6*#41/,!#*<!+7&!2&5,#+1%1+6!'(!6'0*J! 8&RSOHÂ¶V OHDUQLQJ VW\OHV LPSDFW RQ WKH HIIHFWLYHQHVV RI SURJUDPPH GHOLYHU\ ! % 33

P?/,,%5$;$,37($&+% 3'4&!'(!+7&!6'0*J!8#5+1/18#*+,!E&5&!2&56!7#886!+'!7#2&!%&#5*&<!7'E!+'!E51+&!,+'51&,!#*<!+#%R&<!#$'0+! OHDUQLQJ DERXW WKH µWKUHH 3V¶ RI VWRU\ GHYHORSPHQW 7KH\ HQMR\&<! %&#5*1*J! +'! <5#E! #*<! ,#1<! +7#+! +7&! DUWLVW µPDGH LW HDV\¶:!"7&6!7#<!5&+#1*&<!#!%'+!'(!+7&!,/1&*/&!5&J#5<1*J!5&*&E#$%&!&*&5J6!#*<!5&*&E#$%&! &*&5J6!<&21/&,!(5'4!+7&15!E'5R,7'8,!1*!KQHM!,0/7!#,!87'+'2'%+#1/!/&%%,!'5!,'%#5!8#*&%,!#*<!7'E!&*&5J6! 1,!4#<&!#*<!,+'5&<:!"7&6!E&5&!8#5+1/0%#5%6!&*+70,1#,+1/!#$'0+!+7&!3)G>")a!E'5R,7'8,!#*<!(&%+!+7&6! 7#<!%&#5*&<!#!%'+!#*<!E#*+&<!+'!<'!40/7!4'5&!E'5R!E1+7!/'480+&5,!1*!(0+05&:! ! "7&! +&#/7&5! *'+&<! +7#+! +7&! /71%<5&*! E&5&! 8%&#,&<! +7#+! +7&6! 7#<! J#1*&<! *#55#+12&! ,R1%%,! #*<! <5#E1*J! ,R1%%,!#*<! '$,&52&<! +7#+! +7&6! E&5&! 1485&,,&<! #*<! 85'0<! '(! +7&15! ,+'51&,! E7&*! +7&6! 5&#<! +7&4! +'! +7&! FODVV 6KH DOVR REVHUYHG JRRG LPSURYHPHQWV LQ WKH FKLOGUHQ¶V YRFDEXODU\ DQG ZULWLQJ VNLOOV DIWHU WKH #5+,! E'5R,7'8,:! "7&! +&#/7&5! #%,'! <1,/0,,&<! +7#+! ,7&! 7#<! J#1*&<! *&E! ,R1%%,! 1*! E51+1*J! /'*/&5*1*J! 85&8#5#+1'*! ('5! <&2&%'81*J! +7&! ,+'56! %1*&S! /7#5#/+&5! <&2&%'84&*+S! +7&! 0,&! '(! $5#1*,+'541*J! #*<! 3)G>")a!85'J5#441*J:! ! J1"&#$.%/&%"++/+'5$%+30"*5.%.6/$&6$% "7&!,/1&*+1,+!*'+&<!+7#+!+7&!/71%<5&*!4&*+1'*&<!+7#+!+7&6!7#<!#88%1&<!+7&!R*'E%&<J&!+7&6!7#<!#/[015&<! 1*! +7&! E'5R,7'8,! #+! 7'4&:! L'5! 1*,+#*/&! 5&4'21*J! +7&! 4#J*&+! (5'4! $5'R&*! &%&/+51/#%! #88%1#*/&,! #*<! &.8&514&*+1*J! #*<! +#R1*J! #8#5+! +7&15! 5&4'+&! /'*+5'%%&<! <&21/&,:! ! "7&! /71%<5&*! ,#1<! +7#+! ,/1&*/&! E#,! µZDFN\¶ #*<! #%,'! *'+&<! +7#+! +7&5&! E&5&! 8',,1$%&! /#5&&5! '8+1'*,! ('5! +7&4,&%2&,! #,! &1+7&5! &*J1*&&5,W,/1&*+1,+,! '5! #,! #5+1,+,! #*<! 1+! E#,! 8',,1$%&! +'! &#5*! #! %121*J! #+! +7&,&! '//08#+1'*,:! TL1&%<! '$,&52#+1'*! *'+&,! ]0*&! KQHMV! "7&! /71%<5&*! ,#1<! +7#+! +7&6! &*A'6&<! +7&! 3)G>")a! 85'J5#441*J! E'5R,7'8,! +7&! $&,+:! µ6&5$7&+ ZDV WKH EHVW E\ IDU IROORZHG E\ GUDZLQJ¶ "7&6! E'0%<! %1R&! ;)"!#,! #! ,0$A&/+!#,!µLW¶V IXQQLHU DQG PRUH LQWHUHVWLQJ DQG HQMR\DEOH¶ TL'/0,!J5'08!KV!! ! !#5("*;:$A#)"%2$5;2$F/%,,$±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µSUHWW\ KDSS\¶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Â¶V VFLHQFH OHDUQLQJ! !$ ! !

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Â¶V HWKRV ZKLFK LV VXPPHG XS LQ WKH SKUDVH ÂµOHDUQ WRJHWKHU DQG OLYH WRJHWKHUÂ¶ 7KLV \HDUÂ¶V %($67 SURMHFW DV LW ZDV UROOHG RXW RQ WKH VFKRRO ('/0,&<! '*! +7&! 1*+&5/'**&/+&<*&,,! '(! 4#51*&! %1(&! '((! +7&! /'#,+! '(! )':! Z#%E#6:! a'E&2&5S! 1+! #%,'! &487#,1,&<! +7&! 1*+&5<&8&*<&*+! E&$,! +7#+! &.1,+! #4'*J! 4#51*&! ,8&/1&,! 1*+&5*#+1'*#%%6! #*<! E7#+! +71,! PHDQV IRU VXVWDLQDEOH GHYHORSPHQW DQG FKLOGUHQÂ¶V OLYHV LQ WKH :HVW RI ,UHODQG ! $ <"5)$)"#$0(*#;)*,)$45;)#2$)%$5("*#+#$ "7&! ,/1&*+1,+! E#*+&<! +'! GHHSHQ FKLOGUHQÂ¶V DSSUHFLDWLRQ RI VFLHQFH DQG +7&15! R*'E%&<J&! '(! 4#51*&! %1(&! #5'0*<!+7&!Z#%E#6!/'#,+:!"7&!5&,'0*<1*J!4&,,#J&!(5'4!+7&!E'5R,7'8,!E#,!+7#+!#%%!%1(&!1,!1*+&55&%#+&<! DQG WKDW WKH ÂµQDWXUDOÂ¶ DQG KXPDQ ZRUOGV DUH LQWULQVLFDOO\ LQWHUFRQQHFWHG:! "71,! 1*,815&<! +7&! /71%<5&*! +'! +71*R!/51+1/#%%6!#$'0+!+7&!E'5%<!#5'0*<!+7&4!#*<!#$'0+!+7&15!8%#/&!1*!1+:!"71,!#%,'!5&(%&/+,!,'4&!'(!+7&! 4#1*!+71*J,!E71/7!+7&!,/1&*+1,+,!E#*+&<!+'!#/71&2&!E1+7!+7&!85'A&/+:!C'5&'2&5S!<051*J!+7&!E'5R,7'8,S! +7&! ,/1&*+1,+! /'*+LQXDOO\ FKDOOHQJHG WKH FKLOGUHQ WR WKLQN DERXW WKH ÂµQDWXUDOQHVVÂ¶ RI WKH *DOZD\ FRDVW ,7'E1*J!81/+05&,!'(!40,,&%!(#54,!1*!1*+&5#/+12&!,%1<&!,7'E,:!;*!&,,&*/&S!,7&!,7'E&<!+7#+!+7&!,&#,/#8&! DURXQG *DOZD\ FDQQRW EH FRQFHSWXDOLVHG DV ÂµQDWXUDOÂ¶ DV WUDFHV RI KXP#*!1*+&5(&5&*/&!E1+7!+7&!876,1/#%! E'5%<! #5&! &2&56E7&5&:! "7&! /71%<5&*! <1,8%#6&<! #! 71J7! /'*/&8+0#%! R*'E%&<J&! #$'0+! +7&! E'5%<! #5'0*<! +7&4!#*<!+7&15!,/1&*/&!&<0/#+1'*!08!+'!+7#+!8'1*+!/%&#5%6!7&%8&<!+7&4!+'!<1J&,+!+7&!/'*/&8+,!1*!#!40/7! (0%%&5!E#6:!! ! "7&! /71%<5&*! <&4'*,+5#+&<! 71J7! %&2&%,! '(! &*J#J&4&*+! +75'0J7'0+! +7&! E'5R,7'8,! #*<! +7&6! E&5&! H[FHSWLRQDOO\ HQWKXVLDVWLF DERXW WKH VHVVLRQV $V RQH FKLOG VDLG ÂµI%*$",,=%,3;$%+1$.$%.$../3&.-%G1$=%"*$% VR FRROÂ¶S! E71%&! '+7&5,! ,#1<! ÂµZLFNHGÂ¶! #*<! ÂµDZHVRPHÂ¶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a&5&!+7&6!4&+! E1+7! +7&! ,/1&*+1,+,! E7'! #,R&<! +7&4! +'! +71*R! #$'0+! +7&! ,055'0*<1*J! &*215'*4&*+! #*<! +7&! +68&,! '(! ,&#E&&<!E71/7!E&5&!#%%!#5'0*<!+7&4:!"7&!/71%<5&*!E&5&!&*/'05#J&<!+'!+71*R!#$'0+!+7&!,&#!#,!#!+68&!'(! %1(&!J12&5!#*<!#,!#!/5&#+12&!('5/&!E1+7!1+,!'E*!*#+05#%!576+74,!$0+!+7#+!8&'8%&!#5&!/'*+1*0#%%6!7#5*&,,1*J! WKH ZRUOGÂ¶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Âµ,WÂ¶V VR LQWHUHVWLQJ DQG VR QLFH WR EH EDFN KHUH DQG PDNLQJ DOO WKHVH WKLQJV DQG JHWWLQJ WKH FKDQFH WR SOD\Â¶Â¶ %% $ 36

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ÂµIUDPHÂ¶ WR WKLQN DERXW VFLHQW1(1/!85#/+1/&,!#*<!+7&15!1*+&55&%#+1'*,718,!E1+7!+7&!E'5%<!#5'0*<!+7&4:! ! B051*J!+7&,&!E'5R,7'8,S!+7&!#5+1,+!1*+&5#/+&<!8&5,'*#%%6!E1+7!+7&!/71%<5&*S!#,R1*J![0&,+1'*,!'(!+7&!/%#,,! #$'0+!"h!85'J5#44&,!+7#+!+7&6!E#+/7!#*<!4'21&,!+7#+!+7&6!4#6!7#2&!,&&*:!"71,!&*#$%&<!+7&!/71%<5&*! +'!,&&!+7#+!,+'56+&%%1*J!1,!#%%!#5'0*<!+7&4!#*<!+7#+!+7&15!%12&,!#5&!/'4851,&<!'(!*#55#+12&,:!"7&!#5+1,+!#%,'! 85'<0/&<!<5#E1*J,! '(! /#5+''*! /7#5#/+&5,!('5! +7&! /%#,,:! c&&R!$6! E&&RS! +7&! #5+1,+!E'5R&<! +75'0J7!+7&! <1((&5&*+! ,+#J&,! '(! E51+1*J! #! ,+'56! #*<! +7&! /51+1/#%! &%&4&*+,! +7#+! #5&! 1*2'%2&<! 1*! ,+'56! E51+1*J! #*<! ,+'56+&%%1*J! ,0/7! #,! +7&! ,1J*1(1/#*/&! '(! /7#5#/+&5,! #*<! &2&*+,! #*<! 7'E! +7&,&! +681/#%%6! 85'/&&<! 1*! FKLOGUHQÂ¶V QRYHOV 0RUHRYHU WKH DUWLVW KDG D KLJK GHJUHH RI NQRZOHGJH DERXW ERRNV E71/7!+7&!/71%<5&*! #5&!5&#<1*J!#*<!+7&!/7#5#/+&5,!#*<!+71,!(',+&5&<!#!71J7!<&J5&&!'(!&*J#J&4&*+!1*!+7&!85'/&,,!('5!+7&! /71%<5&*:! ! $W WKH VDPH WLPH KRZHYHU LW VKRXOG EH VDLG WKDW WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V OHYHOV RI HQJDJHPHQW VHHPHG WR ZDQH #+!8#5+1/0%#5!+14&,!<051*J!+7&,&!,&,,1'*,:!"71,!E#,!8#5+1/0%#5%6!&21<&*+!E7&*!+7&!#5+1,+!,8'R&!('5!%'*J&5! 8&51'<,! '(! +14&! E1+7! %1++%&! '5! *'! 1*+&5#/+1'*! (5'4! +7&! /71%<5&*:! "7&6! &*A'6&<! +7&! ,&,,1'*,! #*<! +7&6! %&#5*&<! #! %'+! (5'4! +7&4! E1+7! '*&! $'6! ,#61*J! +7#+! 7&! E'0%<! %1R&! +'! $&! #! E51+&5! E7&*! 7&! J5'E,! 08:! a'E&2&5S!1*!,1+0#+1'*,!E7&5&!+7&!%&2&%!'(!/5&#+121+6!#*<!1*+&5#/+1'*!E#,!%'ES!6'0*J!8&'8%&!,&&4&<!+'! Âµ]RQH RXWÂ¶ IRU SHULRGV RI WLPH IURP WKH VHVVLRQV ! ! $ <"5)$)"#$(%AB1)#/$)#(";%6%:*,)$45;)#2$)%$5("*#+#C$ )'480+&5! ,/1&*+1,+,! (5'4! B-G;! XY;! Z#%E#6! <&%12&5&<! 3)G>")a! 85'J5#441*J! E'5R,7'8,! +'! +7&! J5'08:! 9*&! /'480+&5! ,/1&*+1,+! ,#1<! +7#+! 7&! E#*+&<! +'! 1*,815&! +7&! 6'0*J! 8&'8%&! +'! +71*R! #$'0+! 7'E! +&/7*'%'J6!#((&/+,!+7&15!%12&,:!>//'5<1*J!+'!+71,!,/1&*+1,+S!+7&!148'5+#*/&!'(!85'J5#44&,!%1R&!3)G>")a! 1V WKDW LW IDFLOLWDWHV FKLOGUHQÂ¶V OHDUQLQJ DERXW WHFKQRORJ\ DQG LWV LPSDFWV RQ VRFLHW\ 6WXGHQWV DW *(716 <1<!*'+!5&/&12&!#%%!'(!+7&!3)G>")a!+5#1*1*J!$&('5&!+7&!KQHM!,044&5!$5&#R!#*<!,'4&!'(!+7&,&!,&,,1'*,! E&5&!/#551&<!'2&5!+'!3&8+&4$&5!KQHM:!"7&!Z-"X3!+&#/7&5!E7'!E#,!1*+&521&E&<!,+#+&<!+7#+!1+!1,!*'E! 2&56! <1((1/0%+! ('5! +7&! /71%<5&*! +'! 5&/#%%! +7&! ,&,,1'*,! E1+7! +7&! #5+1,+!#*<! #88%6! +7&4! +'! 3)G>")a:! "7&! 1,,0&! '(! +141*J! #5'0*<! +7&! <&%12&56! '(! E'5R,7'8,! 1,! #! /51+1/#%! 1,,0&! #*<! ,7'0%<! $&! #<<5&,,&<! $6! +7&! =->3"?!#<41*1,+5#+'5,!<051*J!+7&!8%#**1*J!,+#J&!'(!(0+05&!85'A&/+,:! ! 8#;#-*),$)%$)"#$("*62/#;$%-$B5/)*(*B5)*%;$*;$)"#$8D=0!$>>$./%'#()$ H&#"#$($&+%"&5%/&6*$".$5%"++$&+/3&%.7"&% % "7&!+&#/7&5!(&%+!+7#+!+7&!/71%<5&*!E&5&!&*J#J&<!1*!+7&!,/1&*/&!#*<!#5+1,+1/!E'5R,7'8,!ÂµN$</&/+$,=%I%<$,+% +1$=%0$*$%$&#"#$5-%G1$=%0$*$%$A6/+$5%)=%/+Â¶ T"&#/7&5!OV:!a&!#%,'!(&%+!+7#+!+7&!/5&#+121+6!&%&4&*+!'(!+7&! SURMHFW ZDV DQ H[FHOOHQW ZD\ RI HQJDJLQJ FKLOGUHQÂ¶V LQWHUHVW LQ WKH VFLHQFHV DQG WKDW LW LV VRPHWLPHV ÂµYHU\ GLIILFXOW WR HQJHQGHU FUHDWLYH DSSURDFKHV LQ WKH FODVVURRPÂ¶ 7HDFKHU ! ! N$;$,37($&+%3<%O$0%P?/,,.%% "7&!Z-"X3!+&#/7&5!#%,'!/'44&*+&<!'*!+7&!R*'E%&<J&!#*<!,R1%%,!+7#+!+7&!6'0*J!8&'8%&!7#<!%&#5*&<! (5'4! +7&15! =->3"?! &.8&51&*/&,! #*<! 7&! (&%+! +7#+! 40/7! '(! +71,! E#,! <0&! +'! +7&! #885'#/7! +#R&*! $6! +7&! ,/1&*+1,+,!<051*J!+7&!,+0<6:!>+!+7&!,#4&!+14&!7'E&2&5S!7&!#%,'!/'44&*+&<!+7#+!R*'E%&<J&!#*<!#$1%1+6! %&2&%,! '(! +7&! 4#A'51+6! '(! /71%<5&*! 1*! Z-"X3! 1,! 71J7! #*<! 4#*6! /71%<5&*! 1*! +7&! ,/7''%! #5&! 2&56! 37

#//'48%1,7&<!#*<!&*J#J&<!1*!+7&!/5&#+12&!#5+,!#*<!+7&!,/1&*/&,:!a'E&2&5S!,0/7!%1(&!,R1%%,!#5&!148'5+#*+! IRU FKLOGUHQ¶V SHUVRQDO GHYHORSPHQW ! ! 7KH WHDFKHU DOVR IHOW WKDW WKH FKLOGUHQ¶V HQJDJHPHQW ZLWK WKH DUWLVW DQG ZLWK WKH FRPSXWHU VFLHQWLVW ZDV KLJK DQG WKDW WKLV LQWHUDFWLYH DSSURDFK IDFLOLWDWHG µGHHS OHDUQLQJ¶ LQ WKH FODVVURRP !! ! J1"&#$.%/&%"++/+'5$%+30"*5.%.6/$&6$% "7&!+&#/7&5!1<&*+1(1&<!+7#+!+7&!/71%<5&*!+#%R&<!#$'0+!+7&!85'A&/+!1*!+7&!/%#,,5''4!,1*/&!+7&!/'*/%0,1'*!'(! +7&!85'A&/+!#*<!+7#+!+7&6!&*A'6&<!+7&!=->3"?!a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a&!+#%R&<!#$'0+!+7&!1*+&5#/+12&!%&,,'*,!E1+7!+7&!,/1&*+1,+!1*!8#5+1/0%#5!#*<!+7&!&(('5+,!4#<&! $6!+7&!#5+1,+!+'!#++&*<!+7&!,&,,1'*,!1*!Z#%E#6:!a&!,+#+&<!+7#+!+7&5&!/'0%<!7#2&!$&&*!4'5&!/'%%#$'5#+1'*! #+!+14&,!$0+!(5'4!71,!8&5,8&/+12&S!+7&!,6,+&4!E'5R&<!8&5(&/+%6!E&%%!#*<!7&!(#2'05&<!+7&!#885'#/7!+#R&*! $6! +7&! #5+1,+S! E7&5&! +7&! /71%<5&*! #5&! &.8%'51*J! +7&15! 'E*! 1<&#,! '*! +7&15! 'E*! +&54,S! E1+7'0+! #<0%+! 1*+&5(&5&*/&:!! a&! <1<! ,#6! 7'E&2&5! +7#+! 4'5&! /'_'5<1*#+1'*! 1,! *&&<&<! E1+7! +7&! 8%#**1*J! #*<! 148%&4&*+#+1'*! '(! +7&! 3)G>")a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¶V OHDUQLQJ DQG WKHLU &*A'64&*+!'(!+7&!,0$A&/+:!"7&!#885'#/7!'(!+7&!#5+1,+!#%,'!4&#*+!+7#+!+7&!/71%<5&*!E&5&!5&%#.&<!E7&*! %&#5*1*J!#$'0+!,+'51&,!#*<!,#E!+7&4,&%2&,!#,!,+'56+&%%&5,!'(!+7&!(0+05&:! ! "7&!Z-"X3!+&#/7&5!/'44&*+&<!+7#+!+7&!+&#/71*J!4&+7'<'%'J6!1,!0,&(0%!#,!1+!4#551&,!<1((&5&*+!+68&,!'(! /5&#+121+6!T#5+1,+1/!#*<!,/1&*+1(1/V!+'J&+7&5! !

01-2(%."O)*%5"G%:%-.&1"O)48)4N:" " JED"64(.78'&()74" "71,! ,&/+1'*! 85&,&*+,! +7&! 5&,0%+,! '(! +7&! [0#%1+#+12&S! [0#*+1+#+12&! #*<! &+7*'J5#871/! <#+#! E71/7! E#,! /'%%&/+&<! $6! +7&! 5&,&#5/7&5,! 1*! +7&! ,/7''%,! 1*! Y#/7+#5! g5<S! Z'5+S! #*<! Z#%E#6! )1+6:! ;+! 1*/%0<&,! +7&! 1*+&521&E,! +7#+! +''R! 8%#/&! E1+7! /71%<5&*S! +&#/7&5,S! #5+1,+,S! ,/1&*+1,+,S! /'480+&5! +&/7*'%'J1,+,S! 8#5&*+,! DQG PHPEHUV RI %DERUy VWDII 7KH UHVHDUFK SURGXFHG ILQGLQJV RQ LVVXHV VXFK DV WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V OHYHO RI &*J#J&4&*+! #*<! +7&15! /7#*J1*J! 21&E,! #$'0+! ,/1&*/&:! ;+! #%,'! 85'<0/&<! (1*<1*J,! 5&%#+1*J! +'! +7&! R&6! 1,,0&,! +7#+! E&5&! $&1*J! 1*2&,+1J#+&<! #*<! ,'4&! '(! +7&! /'5&! +7&4&,! E71/7! E&5&! 5&2&#%&<! +75'0J7! &+7*'J5#871/!#*<![0#%1+#+12&!5&,&#5/7:! "7&!1*+&521&E![0&,+1'*,!T,&&!#88&*<1/&,V!/'*+#1*&<![0&,+1'*,! DERXW WKH %($67 PRGHO WKH WHDFKLQJ PHWKRG DQG SDUWLFLSDQWÂ¶V YLHZV RQ FROODERUDWLRQ DQG FUHDWLY1+6! +7#+!&4&5J&<!<051*J!+7&!,+0<6:!"71,!,&/+1'*!J'&,!1*+'!,'4&!<&+#1%!5&J#5<1*J!+7&!(1*<1*J,!E71/7!E1%%!#%,'! $&!/'*,1<&5&<!1*!+7&!<1,/0,,1'*!#*<!5&/'44&*<#+1'*,!,&/+1'*,!'(!)7#8+&5!,1.:! "" JEF"a)%S:"7;">%-&1%.:W"+&)%4&%"-48"=.(:"2.-&()()74%.:".%N-.8)4N"<#=+>?">%-&1)4N"B%(178"" >,!1*!+7&!(15,+!6&#5!'(!+7&!85'A&/+S!+7&5&!E#,!E1<&,85&#<!,088'5+!#4'*J!+&#/7&5,!('5!+7&!=->3"?! +&#/71*J!4&+7'<:!"7&!(12&!+&#/7&5,!1*+&521&E&<!E&5&!2&56!8',1+12&!#$'0+!+7&!&*J#J&4&*+!'(!+7&! /71%<5&*!#*<!+7&!8',1+12&!148#/+,!'*!+7&!/71%GUHQÂ¶V OLYHV 7KH\ FRPPHQWHG WKDW WKH WHDFKLQJ DSSURDFK #%%'E&<!/71%<5&*!+'!%&#5*!#*<!<1,8%#6!#!E1<&!2#51&+6!'(!#$1%1+1&,:!9*&!+&#/7&5!,#1<!+7#+!1+!#%%'E&<!0,0#%%6! %&,,!#/#<&41/#%%6!#$%&!/71%<5&*!+'!,71*&:!L'5!&.#48%&!1*!<5#E1*J!'5!0,1*J!3)G>")a!85'J5#441*J!#*<! +71,!5&,0%+&<!1*!1*/5&#,&<!,&%(_&,+&&4:!"7&!85'A&/+!#%,'!#%%'E&<!4'5&!#$%&!/71%<5&*!E1+7!85&21'0,! R*'E%&<J&!+'!,7#5&!+7&15!&.8&5+1,&!E1+7!'+7&5,:!!Âµ7KDWÂ¶V WKH EHDXW\ RI LW LW FDWHUV IRU HYHU\ OHYHOÂ¶! T"&#/7&5!bV!! % JEFED"<%4%;)(:"(7">%-&1%.:")4"(%.,:"7;"C%-.4)4N"-48":V)CC"8%*%C72,%4(E" @#5+1/18#+1*J!+&#/7&5,!,8'R&!'(!+7&!$&*&(1+,!+7&6!7#<!5&/&12&<!(5'4!85'A&/+!1*2'%2&4&*+:!!9*&!+&#/7&5! ,8'R&!'(!+7&!7'E!+7&!85'A&/+!E#,!148#/+1*J!'*!7&5!+&#/71*J!,+6%&U! Âµ7KH SURMHFW KDV VKRZQ PH KRZ FUHDWLYLW\ FDQ EH OLQN$5%/&+3%$;$*=%.')E$6+%"&5%".%"%*$.',+%I% *$",/.$%+1"+%I%('.+%)$63($%(3*$%6*$"+/;$%".%"%+$"61$*-%8=%+$"61/&#%.+=,$%1".%)$63($%(3*$% 6*$"+/;$%"&5%(3*$%*$,"A$5%"&5%B+1$%"*+/.+C%.130$5%($%+3%#$+%+1$%61/,5*$&%+3%$A7*$..%B+1$/*% ;/$0.C%(3*$-%:.%"%+$"61$*%=3'%"*$%63QVWDQWO\ ORRNLQJ DW WKH FORFN ZKHUHDV WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V YLHZV ("++$*-%G1$%"*+/.+%",.3%.130$5%($%+1$%/(73*+"&6$%3<%7,"&&/&#%/&%+$*(.%3<%0*/+/&#%.+3*/$.%01$&% KH GHVFULEHG KRZ KH ZHQW DERXW ZULWLQJ Â¶T"&#/7&5!MV:! ! >*'+7&5!+&#/7&5!E7'!E#,!1*+&521&E&<!,#1<!+7#+!7&!1,!2&56!#E#5&!'(!/5&#+121+6!1*!+7&!/%#,,5''4!#*<!7'E! LW IDFLOLWDWHV FKLOGUHQÂ¶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Â³JHWWLQJ WKH EDODQFH ULJKW ZLWK FUHDWLYLW\ WDNHV D ORW RI WLPHÂ´!T"&#/7&5!OV:! ! 9*&!8#5&*+!1<&*+1(1&<!+7&!148#/+,!'(!/5',,!/0551/0%#5!+&#/71*J!'*!7&5!/71%<:!! Âµ,WÂ¶V DPD]LQJ KRZ KDYLQJ DQ LQWHUHVW LQ VRPHWKLQJ OHDYHV WKHP RSHQ WR DFFHSWLQJ PRUH DQG OHDUQLQJ PRUH ,WÂ¶V HDVLHU WKHQ WR WHDFK RWKHU VXEMHFWV EHFDXVH LQYDULDEO\ WKH VXEMHFWV DUH ,/&?$5-%9";/&#%+1$%$A73.'*$%+3%.3($+1/&#%3'+./5$%+1$%6'**/6','(%0".%"%1'#$%)$&$</+B---C"&5% +1$*$%/.%(3*$%"0"*$&$..%"&5%+1/&?/&#%3'+./5$%3<%+1$(.$,;$.%/&%"%#$&+,$%"&5%.')+,$%0"=%"&5%1$% 39

KDV PRUH DZDUHQHVV RI ZKDW¶V JRLQJ RQ DURXQG KLP DQG PRUH XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI KRZ WKLQJV ZRUN¶ T@#5&*+!MV!!

JEFEF"U:)4N"&.%-()*)(/")4":&)%4&%"S7.V:172"8%:)N4E" "7&! 85'A&/+! E#,! 21&E&<! $6! '*&! 85#/+1+1'*&5! #,! µ(QMR\DEOH DQG FKDOOHQJLQJ LQ WKH EHVW VHQVH RI WKH ZRUG¶ T3/1&*+1,+!MV:!"71,!&/7'&<!+7&!5&,8'*,&,!'(!'+7&5!8#5+1/18#*+,!1*!+7&!=->3"?!T#5+1,+,S!,/1&*+1,+,S! +&#/7&5,!#%1R&V:! ;*!+71,!,&/'*<!6&#5!'(!+7&!85'A&/+!,/1&*+1,+,!/7#%%&*J&<!+7&4,&%2&,!4'5&!#5'0*<!7'E!+7&6!E&*+!#$'0+! +7&!85'/&,,!'(!<&,1J*:!9*&!,/1&*+1,+!,+#+&<!+7#+!7&!E#,!#E#5&!'(!+7&!8'+&*+1#%!('5!0,1*J!/5&#+121+6!#/5',,! +7&!/0551/0%04:!a&!,#1<!+7#+!7&!/'*,/1'0,%6!+51&<!+'!$&!/71%<_%&<!1*!71,!<&,1J*!#*<!0,&<!+7&!(&&<$#/R!1*! +7&! (15,+! ,&,,1'*! +'! <&2&%'8! /'*+&*+! ('5! +7&! 5&,+! '(! +7&! E'5R,7'8,! T3/1&*+1,+! bV:! 9+7&5! ,/1&*+1,+,! E7'! E&5&!1*2'%2&<!#%,'!/'44&*+&<!'*!+7&!7&1J7+&*&<!&*J#J&4&*+!'(!+7&!6'0*J!8&'8%&!1*!+7&!E'5R,7'8,! #*<!+7#+!/5&#+121+6!#*<!1*+&5#/+1'*!E#,!+7&!5&#,'*!('5!+71,\!³, ZDV DPD]HG DW ZKDW WKH\ NQRZ DQG WKH\ DUH VR HQJDJHG´ % >/5',,! +7&! +75&&! ,/7''%,! +7&5&! E#,! #! E1<&! 5#*J&! '(! E'5R,7'8! #/+121+1&,:! -#/7! ,/1&*+1,+! <&%12&5&<! #! <1((&5&*+! ,&+! '(! E'5R,7'8,! 1*! +7&15! #,,1J*&<! ,/7''%S! #*<! #/+121+1&,! 1*/%0<&<! 85'<0/1*J! $1'! (0&%! (5'4! ,&#E&&<S!,7'E1*J!/71%<5&*!7'E!+'!/#556!'0+!#*!1*2&*+'56!'(!+7&15!7'4&!&*&5J6!/'*,048+1'*!TE1+7!+7&! 7&%8! '(! #! 8#5&*+V! #*<! 0,1*J! &*&5J6! 7#52&,+1*J! <&21/&,! #4'*J,+! #! E1<&! 2#51&+6! '(! #/+121+1&,:! ! 9*&! ,/1&*+1,+!,#1<!+7#+!µ>WKH FKLOGUHQ@ UHPLQGHG PH KRZ PXFK , HQMR\HG WKLV VWXII , HQMR\HG WKH WUDQVODWLRQ RI .6/$&6$%/&+3%03*?.137.%".%,3&#%".%I%1"5%"%6,$"*%#3",%"&5%+1$%61/,5*$&%'&5$*.+335%01"+%+1$=%0$*$%#3/&#% WR GR¶%T3/1&*+1,+!MV:" !" !! JEH"@HUFHSWLRQV RI VWDNHKROGHUV DERXW FKLOGUHQ·V SDUWLFLSDWLRQ LQ %($67 " @#5+1/18#*+!/71%<5&*!E&5&!2&56!&*+70,1#,+1/!#$'0+!+7&15!1*2'%2&4&*+!E1+7!+7&!85'A&/+!#*<!<&,/51$&<!1+!#,U! ! µ)XQ DQG DPD]LQJ¶% % µ([FLWLQJ DQG LQWHUHVWLQJ¶% % )XQN\ DQG FRRO¶% % µ%ULOOLDQW DQG DZHVRPH¶% µ7KH\ ZHUH YHU\ QLFH WR EULQJ XV LQWR WKH GLJLWDO >'(5,@¶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·V DWWLWXGHV WRZDUGV 6FLHQFH" @081%,! #88%1&<! +7&! %&#5*1*J! (5'4! +7&! E'5R,7'8,! +'! &.8%'5&! 1*! +7&15! 7'4&! /'*+&.+,:! "7&6! <1,/0,,&<! <1,4#*+%1*J!$5'R&*!#88%1#*/&,!+'!&.8%'5&!+7&!E'5R1*J,!#*<!%''R!('5!4#J*&+,!+'!&.8&514&*+!E1+7:!"7&6! +#%R&<!'(!7'E!+7&6!7#<!0,&<!+7&!%&#5*1*J!1*!+7&!1*+&52&*1*J!8&51'<!$&+E&&*!=->3"?!KQHK!#*<!=->3"?! KQHM:! )71%<5&*! ,#1<! +7#+! ,/1&*/&! E#,! µ:DFN\¶ #*<! µIXQ¶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µUHQHZDEOH HQHUJ\¶ µZLQGPLOOV¶ µVRODU SDQHOV¶ µWKH FRLO¶ DQG SKRWRYROWDLF FHOOV¶ 7KH\ VDZ WKH SHUVRQDO EHQHILWV RI VFLHQFH µ ,W PDNHV \RX VPDUWHU¶ TL'/0,!J5'08!KV:! 40

! )71%<5&*!%1R&<!+7#+!+7&6!/'0%<!$&!4'5&!1*('54#%!#*<!E7&*!+7&!85#/+1+1'*&5,!A'R&<!#*<!7#<!(0*!E1+7!+7&4:! Âµ>VFLHQFH@ /.%UHDOO\ IXQ EHFDXVH VRPHWKLQJ FRXOG H[SORGH OLNH D YROFDQR Â¶ Âµ ,WÂ¶V IXQ EHFDXVH \RX GRQÂ¶W NQRZ WKH HQGLQJÂ¶ Âµ<RX JHW \RXU KDQGV PHVV\ DQG , UHDOO\ ORYH GRLQJ WKDW DQG LWÂ¶V UHDOO\ UHOD[LQJÂ¶ TL'/0,! Z5'08!HV:!! ! 9*&!+&#/7&5!+#%R&<!#$'0+!7'E!+71,!+&#/71*J!4&+7'<!4#<&!/71%<5&*!4'5&!#E#5&!'(!8',,1$%&!/#5&&5! /7'1/&,!('5!+7&4:! ! Âµ7KH VFLHQWLVW SXW WKRXJKWV LQWR WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V KHDGV 7KH\ QHYHU OLQN PDWKV DQG OHDUQLQJ ZLWK 01"+%+1$=%6"&%53%/&%,"+$*%,/<$-%K'*%.6133,%/.%;$*=%5/."5;"&+"#$5-%I+%7'+%+13'#1+.%/&+3%+1$% 61/,5*HQÂ¶V KHDGV WKH\ ZRXOG QHYHU JHW IURP DQ\RQH HOVH DERXW EHLQJ DQ HQJLQHHU 7KH\ WDONHG "%,3+%")3'+%/+%"&5%,".+%=$"*%0$%;/./+$5%+1$%63,,$#$%/&%H&#/&$$*/&#%D$$?%"&5%/+%)3'#1+%/+%+3%,/<$%<3*% +1$(-%G1$=%."0%+1"+%"&%"*+/.+%63',5%("?$%"%,/;/&#%"&5%/+%("5$%+1$(%+1/&?%("=)$%I%63',5%)$%"&% DUWLVWÂ¶ T"&#/7&5!HV!! ! JEHEF"@%.&%2()74:".%N-.8)4N"FKLOGUHQÂ·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Â¶ Âµ+H WDXJKW XV WR GUDZ DQG VNHWFK EHWWHU DQG WR GUDZ PRQVWHUV DQG KH PDGH LW HDV\@Â¶ !TL'/0,!J5'08!KV:! ;*! J&*&5#%! +7&! /71%<5&*! SUHIHUUHG WKH ODWHU ZRUNVKRSV ZKHUH WKH\ ÂµJRW WR GR WKH ZRUNÂ¶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ÂµDFWLQJÂ¶ ! 9*&!8#5&*+!,#1<!WKDW ZRUNVKRS FRQWHQW ZDV YHU\ JRRG DQG WKDW Âµ0\%61/,5%"53*$5%B"*+/.+C-%9$%+1/&?.%+1$% VXQ VKLQHV RXW RI KLPÂ¶ 3DUHQW 7KH DUWLVW ZDV VHHQ DV Âµ/&.7/*"+/3&",Â¶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Âµ, KDWH ERRNVÂ¶%TL1&%<!'$,&52#+1'*!*'+&,!]0*&!KQHMV! !!Âµ, GLGQÂ¶W OLNH ZKHQ KH GLG DOO WKH ZRUN DW WKH VWDUWÂ¶ TL'/0,!J5'08!HV% %Âµ>DUWLVW@ WDONHG D ORW Â±%, ZDQWHG WR JR WR VOHHS LW ZDV ERULQJ OLNH FKXUFKÂ¶%TL'/0,!J5'08!KV! % "7&,&!/'44&*+,!1*<1/#+&!+7#+S!('5!+71,!J5'08S!+7&5&!1,!#!*&&<!('5!4'5&!1*+&5#/+12&W85#/+1/#%!#885'#/7&,:!! ! "7&!/71%<5&*!1<&*+1(1&<!+7#+!+7&6!E'0%<!%1R&!4'5&!0,&!'(!/'480+&5,!#*<!('5!+7&15!7'4&E'5R!+'!$&!<'*&! '*!/'480+&5,:!"7&6!E'0%<!#%,'!%1R&!+7&!1*/%0,1'*!'(!4'5&!#5+!m,0/7!#,!<5#E1*JW8#1*+1*JW4'<&%%1*Jn! 41

"7&!,#4&!J5'08!1<&*+1(1&<!+7#+!+7&15!'E*!$&7#21'05!/'0%<!7#2&!$&&*!$&++&5!Âµ2XU DWWLWXGH FRXOG EH EHWWHU JLYH KRQRXU JHW KRQRXUÂ¶ TL'/0,!J5'08!KV:!"7&!#5+1,+!E#,!2&56!8%&#,&<!+'!$&!1*2'%2&<!E1+7!+7&!85'A&/+! #*<! (&%+! +7#+! '2&5#%%! 1+! E'5R&<! 2&56! E&%%\! 7&! '$,&52&<! +7#+! +7&! /71%<5&*! E&5&! #%%! 2&56! &*+70,1#,+1/#%%6! 1*2'%2&<!#*<!7&!(&%+!7&!5&/&12&<!J''<!,088'5+!(5'4!=#$'5P!4#*#J&4&*+:!a&!E#,!E'5R1*J!#/5',,!+7&! +75&&! ,/7''%,S! #%%! E1+7! <1((&5&*+! &+7',S! /0%+05&! #*<! #$1%1+1&,! #*<! ('0*<! +7#+! #(+&5! /'*,0%+#+1'*! E1+7! +7&! WHDFKHUV KH LQFOXGHG PRUH EUHDNV DQG DGDSWHG KLV WHDFKLQJ DSSURDFK WR VXLW VRPH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V DWWHQWLRQ %&2&%,:! "7&! #5+1,+! #%,'! /'44&*+&<! +7#+! +7&! /5&#+121+6! '(! +7&! 85'A&/+! #*<! +7&! 1*+&5%1*R#J&,! $&+E&&*! ,/1&*/&!#*<!#5+!E&5&!#!0*1[0&!,&%%1*J!8'1*+!'(!+7&!=->3"?!#*<!+7#+!1+!&*#$%&,!/71%<5&*!+'!,&&!+7&!#5+,!1*! *&E!E#6,:! % JEHEH"@%.&%2()74:"FKLOGUHQÂ·V SDUWLFLSDWLRQ LQ"+0G=>0_"S7.V:172:" >%%!/71%<5&*!E1+7'0+!&./&8+1'*!E&5&!2&56!8',1+12&!#*<!&*+70,1#,+1/!#$'0+!+7&!3)G>")a!E'5R,7'8,:! ! Âµ I!,/?$5%+1"+%0$%1"5%633,%63(7'+$*.Â¶ Âµ ,W ZDV OLNH ZRUNLQJ DQG SOD\LQJ DW WKH VDPH WLPHÂ¶ % TL'/0,!J5'08!KV!! ! "7&6! ('0*<! %&#5*1*J! /'480+&5! 85'J5#441*J! /7#%%&*J1*J! #+! +7&! ,+#5+:! ! 9*&! /71%<! ,#1<! Âµ:H JRW WR GR .3($+1/&#%/&.+$"5%3<%B63(7'+$*%+$61&3,3#/.+C%53/&#%",,%+1$%03*?-%T3'%1";$%+3%7"=%"++$&+/3&>%*$",,=%7"=% DWWHQWLRQ WR VHH ZKDW WR GRÂ¶ TL'/0,!J5'08!KV:!"7&!/71%<5&*!#885&/1#+&<!+7#+!+7&6!E&5&!#$%&!+'!0,&!+7&! /'480+&5! +'! <5#E! +7&! /7#5#/+&5,! +7&6! 7#<! <&2&%'8&<! 1*! +7&! #5+,! ,&,,1'*,:! ;+! E#,! 1*+&5&,+1*J! #*<! /'*(0,1*J! ('5! +7&4! #,! +7&6! E&5&! &*J#J1*J! E1+7! ,'4&+71*J! +'+#%%6! *&E!#*<! +7&6! +51&<! +'! (1*<! E#6,! +'! <&,/51$&!+71,:!Âµ,WÂ¶V D ELW FRQIXVLQJ <RX ZHUH WKH KRPH@PDGH FRPSXWHU JDPH \RXUVHOIÂ¶!TL'/0,!J5'08!HV% "7&6!%1R&<!+7&!E#6!+7#+!+7&!/'480+&5!+&/7*'%'J1,+,!J#2&!+7&4!8%&*+6!'(!+14&!+'!&.8%'5&:! Âµ7KH ZD=%1$% KDG >RI H[SODLQLQJ@ ZDV VLPSOHU JLYLQJ \RX WLPH ORDGV RI WLPH Â¶! TL'/0,! J5'08! HV:! ! )71%<5&*! ,#E! +7&! (0+05&!$&*&(1+,!'(!%&#5*1*J!/'480+&5!+&/7*'%'J6!ÂµFRPSXWHUV KHOS \RX LQ WKH IXWXUHÂ¶ TL'/0,!J5'08!KV! ;*! 1*+&521&E,! E1+7! =#$'5PS! 4#*#J&4&*+! '$,&52&<! +7#+! +7&6! E&5&! ,05851,&<! +'! ,&&! +7#+! 3)G>")a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a'E&2&5S!1*2'%2&4&*+!1*!#!85'A&/+! ,0/7!#,!+7&!=->3"?!E'0%<!7&%8!+'!#<2#*/&!+71,:! ! ! JE!E"@-.%4(-C"2%.&%2()74"7;"(KHLU FKLOGUHQÂ·V SDUWLFLSDWLRQ LQ WKH SURMHFW" >%%!8#5&*+,!1*+&521&E&<!('0*<!+7#+!+7&15!/71%<5&*!E&5&!2&56!&*J#J&<!#*<!&*+70,&<!$6!+7&15!8#5+1/18#+1'*! 1*!+7&!85'A&/+:!Âµ,WÂ¶V DQ H\H RSHQHU IRU WKHP DQG VKRZV WKHP ZKDW WKH\ DUH FDSDEOH RIÂ¶ T@#5&*+!bV:!9*&! 8#5&*W QRWHG WKDW WKHLU FKLOGÂ¶V VWRU\ ZULWLQJ KDG LPSURYHG LQ WHUPV RI WKH ZD\ WKH\ FRQVWUXFWHG WKHLU ,+'51&,:!T@#5&*+!MV!>%%!8#5&*+,!1*+&521&E&<!7#<!*'+1/&<!+7#+!+7&15!/71%<5&*!E&5&!40/7!4'5&!1*+&5&,+&<!1*! /'480+&5,S! 0,&<! +7&*! 4'5&! /'48&+&*+%6! #*<! 7#<! 0,&<! 3)G>")a! 85'J5#441*J! #(+&5! +7&! 85'A&/+! &*<&<:! 9*&! 8#5&*+! ('0*<! 7&5! /71%<! E#,! $'5&<! '2&5! +7&! ,044&5! #*<! ,&+! 7&5! #! 85'A&/+! +'! <'! '*! +7&! /'480+&5! E71/7! +7&! /71%<! &*A'6&<! #*<! /#551&<! '0+! /'48&+&*+%6:! Âµ'HILQLWHO\ LPSURYHG FRPSXWHU XVH './&#%/+%(3*$%3<+$&%"&5%(3*$%FRQILGHQWO\ DQG DV D WRRO IRU KRPHZRUNÂ¶ T@#5&*+!KV! 42

2QH SDUHQW LGHQWLILHG KRZ WKH SURMHFW ZDV FKDQJLQJ KHU FKLOGÂ¶V DWWLWXGH WRZDUGV ZKDW KH FRXOG DLP IRU #,!#!/#5&&5:!Âµ+H GLG HQMR\ WKH SURMHFW DQG ORYHG KHDGLQJ LQWR WKH LQVWLWXWH '(5, DQG IHOW WKDW LW ZDVQÂ¶W 3'+%3<% )3'&5.-% :&5% /+%$&63'*"#$.%+1$(% +1"+% +1$*$% "*$% "*$".%3'+% +1$*$%+1"+% +1$=%6"&% 03*?%/&% +1"+% "*$% LQWHUHVWLQJ Â¶T@#5&*+!MV%% @#5&*+,!&*A'6&<!+7&!7'4&E'5R!#/+121+1&,!+7#+!/71%<5&*!$5'0J7+!7'4&!#*<!/#551&<!'0+!E1+7!+7&4:!"7&6! #885&/1#+&<!+7&15!1*2'%2&4&*+!#*<!J#1*&<!#!$&++&5!0*<&5,+#*<1*J!'(!+7&!85'A&/+:!! % % JEJ"a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Âµ,W KDV DFKLHYHG WKHP <HV , DP TXLWH KDSS\ WR VD\ WKDW LW KDVÂ¶!T3/1&*+1,+!MV:! ! Âµ7R EH KRQHVW ,Â¶G KDYH WUXVW LQ ZKDW %DERUy ZRXOG FRPH XS ZLWK ,WV YHU\ ZHOO UXQ DQG ,Â¶P YHU\ LPSUHVVHG DQG LWÂ¶V D JUHDW SULYLOHJH IRU WKH FKLOGUHQ DQG P\VHOI WR EH LQYROYHG ZLWK LW Â¶ 7HDFKHU US-% % Âµ, WKLQN LW GLG DFKLHYH WKH DLPV WKDW LW VHW RXW WR LQ JHQHUDO DOWKRXJK WKH WLPLQJ RI 6&5$7&+ &$HGV WR EH ORRNHG DW DJDLQÂ¶ 7HDFKHU % % % JER"Q%-.4)4N";.7,"<#=+>?"FMDH";7."(1%"2.7A%&(",78%C" @5#/+1+1'*&5,! 1<&*+1(1&<! +7#+! '*&! ,+5&*J+7! '(! +7&! =->3"?! C'<&%! 1,! +7&! (%&.1$1%1+6! '(! +7&! 85'J5#44&:! 3/1&*+1,+,!5&/&12&!#!2&56!$5'#<!$51&(!#*<!<&2&%'8!+7&15!E'5R,7'8,!1*!5&,8'*,&!+'!+7&!/71%<5&*!#*<!1*!+71,! ZD\ DUH DEOH WR WDS LQWR WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V LQWHUHVWV DQG OLYHG H[SHULHQFH VR WKDW WKH\ EHFRPH PRUH &*+70,&<! #*<! 1*2'%2&<:! L'5! ,'4&! /71%<5&*! E1+7! %&#5*1*J! <1((1/0%+1&,! '5! ,7'5+&5! #++&*+1'*! ,8#*,S! +7&! 1*/'58'5#+1'*! '(! PRUH WHDFKHU VXSSRUW RU PRUH ÂµKDQGV RQÂ¶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

%1++%&!0*(1*1,7&<!#+!+7&!&*<!'(!+7&!6&#5!#*<!*&&<&<!#*'+7&5!,+#J&!µLQ ZKLFK WR WLH XS ORRVH HQGV¶T"&#/7&5! KV:!a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µEX\_LQ¶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

JEb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bED"+-,2C%"01-.-&(%.):()&:" >,!,7'E*!1*!L1J05&!O:HS!'(!+7&!bM!/71%<5&*!E7'!+''R!8#5+!1*!+7&!<#+#!/'%%&/+1'*!#+!"14&!HS!*&#5%6!+75&&! [0#5+&5,!'(!+7&4!E&5&!4#%&!T^b:boS!*!pMKV!E71%&!(&4#%&,!#//'0*+&<!('5!+7&!5&4#1*1*J!'*&![0#5+&5! TKO:IoS!*!p!HHV:!!"7&!$5&#R<'E*!$6!,/7''%!1,!,7'E*!1*!L1J05&!O:K! ! !!!!!L1J05&!O:H!

! ! L1J05&!O:K!±!3&.!'(!)71%<5&*!1*!8#5+1/18#+1*J!,/7''%,!1*!90J7+&5#5<!#*<!Z'5+!

! "

JEbEF"c%/"X'-4()(-()*%"O)48)4N:" "'!4#R&!,&*,&!'(!+7&!<#+#!&4#*#+1*J!(5'4!+7&!2#51'0,!,+#*<#5<1,&<!4&#,05&,S!+7&!5&,&#5/7!+&#4! 0,&<!'*&![0&,+1'*!+'!('/0,!+7&!E'5R!_!D1"+%#"/&.%0$*$%("5$%)=%61/,5*$&%7"*+/6/7"+/&#%/&%+1$%2H:PGV% )$+0$$&%G/($%W%QGWS%"&5%G/($%R%QGRS-%%D1$*$%73../),$>%7#15&<!,#48%&,!+_+&,+,!E&5&!0,&<S!E71/7! #%%'E&<!+7&!5&,&#5/7!+&#4!+'!+7&*!5&8'5+!+7#+!#*6!J#1*,!('0*<!+'!$&!,+#+1,+1/#%%6!,1J*1(1/#*+!E&5&!0*%1R&%6! +'!7#2&!$&&*!/#0,&<!$6!/7#*/&:! ! d1-("N-)4:"S%.%",-8%"I/"&1)C8.%4"2-.()&)2-()4N")4"(1%"<#=+>"@.7N.-,,%"<%(S%%4">),%"D"-48" >),%"Fe" G&,0%+,!(5'4!&#/7!'(!+7&!,1.!,+#*<#5<1,&<!4&#,05&,!#5&!*'E!85&,&*+&<!$&%'E:! ! >77C"D5"="B%-:'.%"7;"<%C74N)4N")4"f7'(1"9%*%C72,%4("@.7N.-,:"\<f9@KDF" ;*! KQQK! >*<&5,'*_=0+/7&5S! l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b! #*<! ,+#*<#5<! <&21#+1'*! E#,! Q:^MO:!! Z12&*!+7#+!+7&!4#.1404!4&#*!,/'5&!8',,1$%&!'*!+71,!,/#%&!1,!bS!+7&!2#,+!4#A'51+6!'(!+7&!/71%<5&*!,/'5&<! &.+5&4&%6!E&%%S!E1+7!^^o!'(!+7&4!'$+#1*1*J!#!4&#*!,/'5&!$&+E&&*!M!#*<!b:!!"71,!E'0%<!1*<1/#+&!+7#+! +71,! J5'08! '(! /71%<5&*! (&%+! /'4('5+#$%&S! 8#5+! '(! /'441++&<S! ,088'5+&<! #*<! #//&8+&<! E7&*! 8#5+! '(! +7&! =->3"?!@5'A&/+:! " >-IC%"JED"Â˛+&7.%:";7."-"B%-:'.%"7;"I%C74N)4N")4"/7'(1"8%*%C72,%4("2.7N.-,,%:"-(">F";7." 2-.()&)2-()4N"&1)C8.%4" 3/'5&,! L5&[0&*/6! h#%1<!@&5/&*+! )040%#+12&! @&5/&*+! H:bQ! M! D:M! D:M! H:DQ! H! K:D! HH:H! K:IQ! K! O:I! HI:^! K:DQ! K! O:I! KK:K! M:QQ! N! KO:Q! b^:K! ! M:KQ! O! HM:N! IH:H! M:bQ! H! K:D! IM:N! M:IQ! O! HM:N! ^^:D! b:QQ! D! KK:K! HQQ:Q! "'+#%! MI! HQQ:Q! ! " " "

12 13

Questions 1 to 5 on the BEAST questionnaire, p.1 The remaining 7 children involved a T1 did not participate in data collection at T2. 46

O)N'.%"JEH"T!+&7.%:";7."-"B%-:'.%"7;"I%C74N)4N")4"/7'(1"8%*%C72,%4("2.7N.-,,%:"-(">F";7." 2-.()&)2-()4N"&1)C8.%4"

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p!M:DNS!3B!p!:NbHV!+'!"K!TC!p!M:IDS!3B!p!H:QbV!#*<!+7&,&!,/'5&,!E&5&!('0*<!*'+!+'! $&!,+#+1,+1/#%%6!,1J*1(1/#*+!T8!p!:HHMV:! ! "7&!4#.1404!4&#*!,/'5&!8',,1$%&!('5!#!8#5+1/18#*+!'*!+71,!4&#,05&!1,!I:!!c7&*!+7&!5#*J&!'(!,/'5&,!#+! "14&!K!E#,!+#R&*!(5'4!"#$%&!O:K!#*<!/#+&J'51,&<!1*+'!,/'5&!$#*<,S!1+!5&2&#%,!+7#+!O:Io!'(!+7&!/71%<5&*! ,/'5&<!1*!+7&!%'E&,+!$#*<!TH_H:NNV:!!>!(05+7&5!bb:^o!,/'5&<!#/71&2&<!,/'5&,!1*!+7&!41<!5#*J&!$#*<!TK_ M:NNV!E71%&!OQ:Ko!#/71&2&<!#!,/'5&!1*!+7&!71J7&,+!$#*<!Tb_IV:! ! " "

Questions 6 to 11 on the BEAST questionnaire, p.1 47

>-IC%"JEF"²"G-4N%"7;"3*%.-CC"B%-4"+&7.%:";7."(1%"0<+"-(">F";7."(1%"2-.()&)2-()4N"01)C8.%4" ! ! L5&[0&*/6! h#%1<!@&5/&*+! )040%#+12&! @&5/&*+! H:MM! H! K:D! K:D! H:OQ! H! K:D! O:I! K:QQ! H! K:D! D:M! K:H^! H! K:D! HH:H! K:MM! K! O:I! HI:^! K:I^! H! K:D! HN:b! M:QQ! K! O:I! KO:Q! M:H^! K! O:I! MQ:I! M:MM! H! K:D! MM:M! M:OQ! K! O:I! MD:N! ! M:I^! M! D:M! b^:K! M:DM! H! K:D! OQ:Q! b:QQ! I! HI:^! II:^! b:H^! H! K:D! IN:b! b:MM! H! K:D! ^K:K! b:OQ! K! O:I! ^^:D! b:I^! H! K:D! DQ:I! b:DM! H! K:D! DM:M! O:QQ! I! HI:^! HQQ:Q! "'+#%! MI! HQQ:Q! ! ! L1J05&!O:b!,7'E,!+7&!5&%#+12&!4&#*!,/'5&,!#+!"H!#*<!"K!('5!$'6,!#*<!J15%,!#*<!1%%0,+5#+&,!+7&!'2&5#%%! <&/5&#,&!(5'4!M:N!+'!M:O!('5!$'6,!T_Q:bV!#*<!b!+'!M:N!('5!J15%,!T_Q:HV:!!c71%&!$'+7!J5'08,!<&/5&#,&<S!+7&! &.+&*+!'(!+71,!/7#*J&!1,!41*14#%:!!"7&5&('5&S!1+!1,!(#15!+'!,0JJ&,+!+7#+!E71%&!8#5+1/18#+1'*!1*!+7&!=->3"! /#**'+!$&!,#1<!+'!7#2&!/#0,&<!+71,!(#%%S!$&1*J!1*2'%2&<!1*!+7&!85'J5#44&!('5!/71%<5&*!E#,!#,,'/1#+&<! E1+7! +71,!/7#*J&:! ! "7&! R&6! 8'1*+! 7&5&! 1,!'(! /'05,&!+7#+! /7#*J&! #,! 41*14#%!#,! +71,!1,!#*! 1*<1/#+1'*! '(! =->3"!$&1*J!#,,'/1#+&<!E1+7!+7&!4#1*+&*#*/&!'(!J''<!&.8&51&*/&,!('5!/71%<5&*!1*!,/7''%:! " " " "

O)N'.%"JE!"²"01-4N%:")4"-",%-:'.%"7;"&1)C8"I%C74N)4N")4":&177C"\0<+K";7."I7/:"-48"N).C:" 2-.()&)2-()4N")4"(1%"<#=+>?"I%(S%%4">),%"D"-48">),%"F" ! $#+! $#*! $! "#)! "#(!

0123!

"#'!

4-563!

"#&! "#%! "#$! "#"! ,-./!*!

,-./!+!

! ! ! >77C"H5"@%.&%)*%8"+7&)-C"07,2%(%4&%"+&-C%"\@+0+KDJ" "7&!+715<!,+#*<#5<1,&<!+''%!#<41*1,+&5&<!+'!+7&!/71%<5&*!E#,!<&2&%'8&<!$6!>*<&5,'*_=0+/7&5S!F#/71*1!l! >4'5',&!TKQQ^V!#*<!1,!/#%%&<!+7&!!$*6$/;$5%P36/",%J3(7$+$&6$%P6",$%T@3)3V:!"71,!4&#,05&,!,'/1#%! /'48&+&*/&! #4'*J! /71%<5&*S! 8#5+1/0%#5%6! +7',&! 1*2'%2&<! 1*! ,&++1*J,! &487#,1,1*J! 85&2&*+1'*S! &#5%6! 1*+&52&*+1'*!#*<! 6'0+7! <&2&%'84&*+:! ! )'48&+&*/&! 1,!<&(1*&<! #,! ³ WKH GHJUHH WR ZKLFK FKLOGUHQ DQG =3'+1%$&#"#$%/&%7*3.36/",%)$1";/3'*.%"&5%"*$%"),$%+3%.'66$..<',,=%6*$"+$%"&5%("/&+"/&%73./+/;$%.36/",% /&+$*"6+/3&.%0/+1%3+1$*.´ LELG 6RFLDO FRPSHWHQFH LV OLQNHG ZLWK U&,1%1&*/&!1*!/71%<5&*!#*<!6'0+7!#*<! +7&!<&2&%'84&*+!'(!+71,!#++51$0+&!1,!21&E&<!#,!#!85'+&/+12&!(#/+'5!('5!/71%<5&*:! ! "'!1*2&,+1J#+&!#*6!/7#*J&!1*!+7&!8&5/&12&<!,'/1#%!/'48&+&*/&!%&2&%,!('5!+7&!=->3"?!/71%<5&*!$&+E&&*! "H!#*<!"KS!#!8#15&<_,#48%&,!+_+&,+!E#,!/'*<0/+&<:!"7&!,/'5&,!,7'E&<!#!,%1J7+!1*/5&#,&!(5'4!"H!TC!p! M:I^S!3B!p!:^bNV!+'!"K!TC!p!M:DKS!3B!p!:DKbVS!$0+!+7&!5&,0%+,!E&5&!('0*<!*'+!+'!$&!,+#+1,+1/#%%6!,1J*1(1/#*+! T8!p!:KO^V:! ! "7&!4#.1404!4&#*!,/'5&!8',,1$%&!('5!#!8#5+1/18#*+!'*!+71,!4&#,05&!1,!b:!!c7&*!+7&!5#*J&!'(!,/'5&,!#+! "14&! K! E#,! +#R&*! (5'4! "#$%&! O:M! /#+&J'51,&<! 1*+'! ,/'5&! $#*<,S! 1+! 5&2&#%,! +7#+! Hbo! '(! +7&! /71%<5&*! ,/'5&<!1*!+7&!%'E&,+!$#*<!TK_K:NNV:!!>!(05+7&5!K^:Do!#/71&2&<!,/'5&,!1*!+7&!41<!5#*J&!$#*<!TM_M:NNV! E71%&!+7&!4#A'51+6!'(!OD:Mo!#/71&2&<!#!,/'5&!1*!+7&!71J7&,+!$#*<!Tb_OV:! ! " "

Questions 1 to 4 on the BEAST questionnaire, p.2 49

>-IC%"JEH"²"G-4N%"7;"3*%.-CC"B%-4"+&7.%:";7."(1%"@+0+"-(">F";7."(1%"2-.()&)2-()4N"01)C8.%4" ! ! L5&[0&*/6! h#%1<!@&5/&*+! )040%#+12&! @&5/&*+! K:QQ! H! K:D! K:D! K:KO! H! K:D! O:I! K:OQ! H! K:D! D:M! K:Ô! K! O:I! HM:N! M:QQ! b! HH:H! KO:Q! M:KO! H! K:D! K^:D! M:OQ! b! HH:H! MD:N! ! M:Ô! H! K:D! bH:^! b:QQ! ^! HN:b! IH:H! b:KO! K! O:I! II:^! b:OQ! b! HH:H! ^^:D! b:Ô! ^! HN:b! N^:K! O:QQ! H! K:D! HQQ:Q! "'+#%! MI! HQQ:Q! ! ! L1J05&!O:O!,7'E,!+7&!5&%#+12&!4&#*!,/'5&,!#+!"H!#*<!"K!('5!$'6,!#*<!J15%,:!!;+!1%%0,+5#+&,!+7&!0*/7#*J&<! ,/'5&,! ('5! $'6,! TM:NK! +'! M:NHVS! E71%&! +7&! ,/'5&,! ('5! J15%,! 1*/5&#,&<! (5'4! M:K! +'! M:IO! TqQ:bOV:! ! "7&,&! 5&,0%+,! ,0JJ&,+! +7#+! $&1*J! 1*2'%2&<! 1*! +7&! =->3"! 1,!#,,'/1#+&<! E1+7! +7&,&! /7#*J&,! ('5!+71,!J5'08! '(! /71%<5&*:! " " O)N'.%"JEJ"²"01-4N%:")4"@%.&%)*%8"+7&)-C"07,2%(%4&%"\@+0+K";7."I7/:"-48"N).C:"2-.()&)2-()4N")4" (1%"<#=+>?"I%(S%%4">),%"D"-48">),%"F" ! $! "#)! "#(! "#'! "#&! "#%!

0123!

"#$!

4-563!

"#"! "#+! "#*! "! +#)! ,-./!*!

! ! "

,-./!+!

>77C"! &KLOGUHQ·V (QYLURQPHQWDO 3HUFHSWLRQV 6FDOH &(36 DL" "7&!('05+7!,+#*<#5<1,&<!4&#,05&!E#,!<&2&%'8&<!$6!F#5,'*S!Z5&&*!#*<!)#,+%&$&556!TKQHQV!('5!0,&!E1+7! I_HM!6&#5!'%<!/71%<5&*:!!"7&!+''%!/'*,1,+,!'(!+E'!,0$_,/#%&,S!+7&!(15,+!'*&!4&#,051*J!$63@"<</&/+=S!E71/7! «!µ*$<,$6+.%7$*.3&",%/&+$*$.+%/&%&"+'*$%"&5%/&+$&+/3&.%+3%$&#"#$%/&%7*3@$&;/*3&($&+",%)$1";/3'*¶:!!"7&! ,&/'*<!,0$,/#%&!4&#,05&,!$63@"0"*$&$..!E71/7!µ«UHIOHFWV D FRJQLWLYH JUDVS RI HQYLURQPHQWDO LVVXHV *$,"+$5%+3%+1$%#$&$*",%/(73*+"&6$%"&5%.'.+"/&")/,/+=%3<%&"+'*",%$63.=.+$(.¶!T1$1<!U!DMV:! ! "'!1*2&,+1J#+&!#*6!/7#*J&!1*!+7&!%&2&%,!'(!&/'_#((1*1+6!('5!+7&!=->3"?!/71%<5&*!$&+E&&*!"H!#*<!"KS!#! 8#15&<_,#48%&,!+_+&,+!E#,!/'*<0/+&<:!"7&!,/'5&,!,7'E&<!#!<&/5&#,&!(5'4!"H!TC!p!M:ObS!3B!p!H:QQV!+'! "K!TC!p!K:DHS!3B!p!H:ObV:!!"7&!5&,0%+,!E&5&!('0*<!+'!$&!,+#+1,+1/#%%6!,1J*1(1/#*+!T8!p!:QQNV:! ! ;*! +&54,! '(! +7&! &/'_#((1*1+6S! +7&! 4#.1404! 4&#*! ,/'5&! 8',,1$%&! E#,! O:! ! c7&*! +71,! 4&#*! ,/'5&! E#,! /#%/0%#+&<!0,1*J!+7&!5#*J&!'(!,/'5&,!#+!"14&!K!1*!"#$%&!O:b!1+!E#,!('0*<!+'!$&!M:MI:!!>*#%6,1,!,7'E,! +7#+!OQo!'(!+7&!/71%<5&*!#/71&2&<!,/'5&,!0*<&5!+71,!4&#*!,/'5&S!E71%&!bH:ô!#/71&2&<!,/'5&,!1*!+7&!M_ M:NN!4&#*!,/'5&!5#*J&!#*<!Kô!,/'5&<!1*!+7&!b_O!5#*J&!'(!4#5R,:! ! >-IC%"JE!"²"G-4N%"7;"3*%.-CC"B%-4"+&7.%:";7."(1%"#&7T=;;)4)(/"-(">F";7."(1%"2-.()&)2-()4N"01)C8.%4" ! ! L5&[0&*/6! h#%1<!@&5/&*+! )040%#+12&! @&5/&*+! H:QQ! K! O:I! O:I! K:HM! H! K:D! D:M! K:KO! K! O:I! HM:N! K:OQ! H! K:D! HI:^! K:IM! H! K:D! HN:b! K:Ô! H! K:D! KK:K! K:DD! M! D:M! MQ:I! M:QQ! K! O:I! MI:H! M:HM! M! D:M! bb:b! M:KO! K! O:I! OQ:Q! M:MD! M! D:M! OD:M! ! M:IM! M! D:M! II:^! M:Ô! H! K:D! IN:b! M:DD! H! K:D! ^K:K! b:QQ! K! O:I! ^^:D! b:HM! H! K:D! DQ:I! b:MD! H! K:D! DM:M! b:OQ! H! K:D! DI:H! b:IM! H! K:D! DD:N! b:DD! H! K:D! NH:^! O:QQ! M! D:M! HQQ:Q! "'+#%! MI! HQQ:Q! ! ! L1J05&!O:I!,7'E,!+7&!5&%#+12&!4&#*!,/'5&,!#+!"H!#*<!"K!('5!$'6,!#*<!J15%,!('5!&/'_#((1*1+6:!!;+!1%%0,+5#+&,! +7&!(#%%!1*!,/'5&,!('5!$'6,!(5'4!M:^Q!+'!M:KI!T_Q:bbVS!E71%&!+7&!,/'5&,!('5!+7&!J15%,!1*/5&#,&<!(5'4!M:b!+'! 16

Questions 5 to 20 on the BEAST questionnaire, p. 4 51

M:ON!TqQ:HNV:!!"7&,&!5&,0%+,!,0JJ&,+!+7#+!$&1*J!1*2'%2&<!1*!+7&!=->3"!1,!#,,'/1#+&<!E1+7!+7&,&!/7#*J&,! ('5!+71,!J5'08!'(!/71%<5&*:! " O)N'.%"JEL"²"01-4N%:")4"C%*%C:"7;"#&7T=;;)4)(/";7."I7/:"-48"N).C:"2-.()&)2-()4N")4"(1%"<#=+>?" I%(S%%4">),%"D"-48">),%"F" ! "#(! "#'! "#&! "#%! 0123!

"#$!

4-563!

"#"! "#+! "#*! "! ,-./!*!

,-./!+!

! ! ! ;*!+&54,!'(!+7&!&/'_#E#5&*&,,S!+7&!4#.1404!4&#*!,/'5&!8',,1$%&!E#,!O:!!c7&*!+7&!4&#*!,/'5&!E#,! /#%/0%#+&<!0,1*J!+7&!5#*J&!'(!,/'5&,!#+!"14&!K!1*!"#$%&!O:O!1+!E#,!('0*<!+'!$&!M:N:!!>*#%6,1,!,7'E,!+7#+! OQo!'(!+7&!/71%<5&*!#/71&2&<!08!+'!bS!E71%&!+7&!5&4#1*1*J!OQo!,/'5&<!$&+E&&*!b!#*<!O:! " >-IC%"JEJ"²"G-4N%"7;"3*%.-CC"B%-4"+&7.%:";7."(1%"#&7T=S-.%4%::"-(">F";7."(1%"2-.()&)2-()4N" 01)C8.%4" ! ! L5&[0&*/6! h#%1<!@&5/&*+! )040%#+12&! @&5/&*+! H:QQ! H! K:D! K:D! K:MD! H! K:D! O:I! K:OQ! H! K:D! D:M! K:IM! H! K:D! HH:H! M:QQ! K! O:I! HI:^! M:KO! K! O:I! KK:K! M:MD! K! O:I! K^:D! ! M:OQ! H! K:D! MQ:I! M:IM! K! O:I! MI:H! M:DD! M! D:M! bb:b! b:QQ! K! O:I! OQ:Q! b:HM! K! O:I! OO:I! b:KO! M! D:M! IM:N! b:MD! M! D:M! ^K:K! b:OQ! H! K:D! ^O:Q! 52

b:^O! b:DD! O:QQ! "'+#%!

K! H! I! MI!

O:I! K:D! HI:^! HQQ:Q! !

DQ:I! DM:M! HQQ:Q!

! L1J05&! O:^! ,7'E,! +7&! 5&%#+12&! 4&#*! ,/'5&,! #+! "H! #*<! "K! ('5! $'6,! #*<! J15%,! ('5! &/'_#E#5&*&,,:! ! ;+! 1%%0,+5#+&,!+7&!(#%%!1*!,/'5&,!('5!$'+7!$'6,!#*<!J15%,S!E1+7!$'6,!(#%%1*J!(5'4!#!4&#*!,/'5&!'(!b:KQ!+'!M:NH!T_ Q:KNVS!E71%&!+7&!,/'5&,!('5!J15%,!(&%%!(5'4!b:M!+'!M:NM!T_Q:bIV:!!"7&,&!5&,0%+,!,0JJ&,+!+7#+!$&1*J!1*2'%2&<! 1*!+7&!=->3"!1,!#,,'/1#+&<!E1+7!+7&,&!/7#*J&,!('5!+71,!J5'08!'(!/71%<5&*:! " O)N'.%"JER"²"01-4N%:")4"C%*%C:"7;"#&7T=S-.%4%::";7."I7/:"-48"N).C:"2-.()&)2-()4N")4"(1%"<#=+>?" I%(S%%4">),%"D"-48">),%"F" ! $#$! $#"! $#+! $#*! 0123! $!

4-563!

"#)! "#(! "#'! ,-./!*!

! "

,-./!+!

>77C"J5"B%-:'.)4N"(1%"B7()*-()74-C"#;;%&("7;"60>"74"@'2)C:" "7&!(1*#%!+''%!0,&<!E1+7!+7&!/71%<5&*!8#5+1/18#+1*J!1*!=->3"!E#,!'*&!<&2&%'8&<!$6!@#,,&6!&+!#%!TKQQb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

JEg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

;*!+&54,!'(!+7&![0#*+1+#+12&!<#+#!/'%%&/+&<!0,1*J!+7&!,+#*<#5<1,&<!4&#,05&,S!J12&*!+7&!5&%#+12&%6!,7'5+! +14&!(5#4&!$&+E&&*!"14&!H!#*<!"14&!KS!1+!1,!'*%6!8',,1$%&!+'!,&&!&4&5J&*+!+5&*<,!1*!+7&!<15&/+1'*!#*<! ,7#8&!'(!+7&!<#+#:!!c7#+!1,!4'5&!148'5+#*+!+7#+!('/0,1*J!'*!+71,!%&2&%!'(!<&+#1%!1,!('5!=>=9G9!+'! /'*,1<&5!7'E!$&,+!'0+/'4&,!+5#/R1*J!,0/7!#,!+71,S!/#*!$&!$01%+!1*+'!+7&!*&.+!6&#5¶,!8%#**1*J!('5!+7&! =->3"?!;;;!85'A&/+:!!"71,!1*!+05*!E1%%!&*#$%&!+7&4!+'!&*J#J&!1*!5&#%!&21<&*/&_$#,&<!8%#**1*J!#*<! 85'J5#44&!148%&4&*+#+1'*:! ! "7&!*&.+!,&/+1'*!/'*+#1*,!+7&!4#1*!<1,/0,,1'*!#*<!5&/'44&*<#+1'*,!'(!+7&!5&8'5+!#*<!,0/7!1,,0&,!#5&! #<<5&,,&<!1*!4'5&!<&8+7!7&5&:

01-2(%."+)$"

9):&'::)74"-48"G%&7,,%48-()74:"

" LED"<-I7.P"<#=+>?"@.7&%::"+('8/5"07.%"@'.27:%" "7&!/'5&!8058',&!'(!+71,!85'/&,,!,+0<6!1,!+'!<&,/51$&!+7&!85'A&/+!4'<&%S!1+,!4'<0,!'(!'8&5#+1'*!#*<!+7&! 21&E,! '(! ,+#R&7'%<&5! J5'08,! #$'0+! 1+,! 148#/+:! ! @5&21'0,! /7#8+&5,! 7#2&! 1<&*+1(1&<! +7&! 21&E,! '(! +7&! 1*<121<0#%! ,+#R&7'%<&5! J5'08,! 1*2'%2&<! #*<! 7#2&! $&&*! 85&,&*+&<! 1*! '5<&5! +'! 85'21<&! /%#51+6! '*! +7&! ,'05/&,!'(!<1((&51*J!8&5,8&/+12&,:!;*!+71,!/7#8+&5!+7&,&!21&E,!#5&!/'%%#+&<!1*!'5<&5!+'!#*,E&5!+7&!1*1+1#%! 5&,&#5/7![0&,+1'*,!#*<!+'!#5512&!#+!+7&!/'*/%0,1'*,!#*<!5&/'44&*<#+1'*,:!! ! "7&!('%%'E1*J!#*#%6,1,!1,!$#,&<!'*!+7&!1*+&521&E,S!('/0,!J5'08,S!'$,&52#+1'*!,+0<1&,!#*<![0#*+1+#+12&! ,052&6!E1+7!,+#R&7'%<&5,!1*!+7&!+75&&!,/7''%,!+7#+!8#5+1/18#+&<!1*!+7&!5&,&#5/7:!!"7&5&!1,!+70,!#!/#2&#+! +7#+!#%+7'0J7!#!,1J*1(1/#*+!#4'0*+!'(!<#+#!7#,!$&&*!J&*&5#+&<S!1+!1,!,+1%%!#!5&%#+12&%6!,4#%%! #*<!5&#<&5,! ,7'0%<!$&#5!+71,!1*!41*<:!! "7&!5&,&#5/7![0&,+1'*,!+'!$&!#<<5&,,&<!1*!+71,!/7#8+&5!#5&!+7&!('%%'E1*J\!

c7#+!1,!+7&!/'5&!8058',&!'(!+7&!=#$'5P!=->3"?!@5'A&/+i!!

c7#+! '0+/'4&,! #5&! #,/51$&<! +'! +7&! 85'A&/+! #,! 8&5/&12&<! $6! +7&! 6'0*J! 8&'8%&S! +&#/7&5,S!8#5&*+,S!,/1&*/&!#*<!#5+!85#/+1+1'*&5,!#*<!=#$'5P!4#*#J&4&*+!,+#((i!

c7#+! #5&! +7&! 8&5,8&/+12&,! '(! ,+#R&7'%<&5,! 5&J#5<1*J! 85'A&/+! <&%12&56! 1*/%0<1*J! 1+,! ,+5&*J+7,S!/7#%%&*J&,!#*<!#5&#,!('5!1485'2&4&*+i!

;,! +7&! 85'A&/+! 4'<&%! ,0((1/1&*+%6! 5'$0,+! +7#+! 1+! /#*! $&! 5&8%1/#+&<! 1*! '+7&5! 8514#56! ,/7''%,!('5!+&#/71*J!3"-C!,0$A&/+,i!!!

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µ/RZ &DUERQ )XWXUH¶ ZLWK SULPDU\ ,/7''%!/71%<5&*!+7'0J7!#!,&51&,!'(!E'5R,7'8,!<&%12&5&<!$6!3/1&*+1,+,!#*<!>5+1,+,! _ "'!/5&#+&!#*!#5+1,+1/!5&,8RQVH XVLQJ WKH FKLOGUHQ¶V XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH WRSLF! _ "'!<&,1J*!#*<W'5!,'05/&![0#*+1+#+12&!#*<![0#%1+#+12&!+''%,!+'!/'%%&/+!<#+#! _ "'! '$,&52&! E'5R,7'8,! #*<! <'/04&*+! $&7#21'05#%! #*<! #++1+0<1*#%! /7#*J&,! +'! &2#%0#+&! +7&! 148#/+!'(!+7&!85'A&/+:! 56

"'! E51+&! #! 85'/&,,! ,+0<6! 5&8'5+! '((&51*J! /51+1/#%! +7'0J7+,! '*! +7&! 85'/&,,! #*<! 8',,1$%&! (0+05&! <&2&%'84&*+,!('5!=->3"?!@5'A&/+!

! "7&,&!#14,!#*<!'$A&/+12&,!E1%%!$&!+7&!5&21&E&<!1*!+71,!/7#8+&5!0*<&5!+7&!5&,&#5/7![0&,+1'*,!#%5&#<6! 71J7%1J7+&<!#+!+7&!,+#5+!'(!+71,!,&/+1'*:! !

LEF"3'(&7,%:"-:&.)I%8"(7"<#=+>?"</"+(-V%17C8%.:" "

LEFED"3'(&7,%:";7."(1%"&1)C8.%45"<%1-*)7'.-C"01-4N%:W"=(()('8%:"(7S-.8:"+&)%4&%"-48"0.%-()*)(/" 9*&!'(!+7&!4#1*!'$A&/+12&,!'(!+7&!,+0<6!E#,!+'!4#R&!,0JJ&,+1'*,!'*!E7&+7&5!'5!*'+!+7&5&!E&5&!#*6! $&7#21'05#%! /7#*J&,! ('5! +7&! /71%<5&*S! ,0/7! #,! +7&15! ,&*,&! '(! $&%'*J1*J! #+! 7'4&! '5! #+! ,/7''%S! +7&15! 5&,1%1&*/&!#*<!+7&15!#++1+0<&,!+'E#5<,!+7&!&*215'*4&*+:!c71%&!+7&![0#%1+#+12&!8#5+!'(!+7&!,+0<6!7#,!,7'E*! +7#+! +7&5&! 1,! J''<! &21<&*/&! ('5! /7#*J&,! 1*! #++1+0<&,! '(! +7&! /71%<5&*! +'E#5<,! ,/1&*/&! #*<! 1*/5&#,&<! /5&#+121+6 LW LV H[WUHPHO\ GLIILFXOW WR JDXJH LI DQG WR ZKDW H[WHQW WKDW FKLOGUHQÂ¶V DWWLWXGHV WRZDUGV 67(0 VXEMHFWV KDYH LPSURYHG DQG LI WKHUH DUH DQ\ FKDQJHV WR \RXQJ SHRSOHÂ¶V UHVLOLHQFH 7KH WLPH_,/#%&!'(! +7&! 85'A&/+! 1,! #*! 1,,0&! 7&5&\! J12&*! +7#+! +7&! 85'A&/+! 5#*! '2&5! #! 4#++&5! '(! E&&R,S! 1+! 1,! <1((1/0%+! T1(! *'+! LPSRVVLEOH WR SUHGLFW VLJQLILFDQW GLIIHUHQFHV LQ FKLOGUHQÂ¶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ÂµRSHQÂ¶ DQG ÂµIOH[LEOHÂ¶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ÂµWR VKLQHÂ¶ #*<!,+#+&!+7#+!+71,!#885'#/7!1,!,0//&,,(0%!1*!&*J#J1*J!/71%<5&*!E7'! 4#6!0,0#%%6!(&&%!%&(+!'0+!'(!#/+121+1&,:!Âµ7KDWÂ¶V WKH EHDXW\ RI LW LW FDWHUV IRU HYHU\ OHYHOÂ¶!T"&#/7&5!bV:! !! 3/1&*+1,+,! +#%R&<! '(! 7'ES! +75'0J7! 1*2'%2&4&*+! E1+7! +7&! 85'A&/+S! +7&6! 7#<! $&/'4&! #E#5&! '(! +7&! 8',,1$1%1+1&,!'(!0,1*J!/5&#+121+6!+'!+&#/7!,/1&*/&!/'*/&8+,:!"7&6!/7#%%&*J&<!+7&4,&%2&,!+'!#88%6!4'5&! /5&#+121+6!+'!ZRUNVKRS FRQWHQW WKDW ZRXOG KDYH PRUH DSSOLFDWLRQ DQG UHOHYDQFH WR WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V OLYHG H[SHULHQFH VR WKDW WKH\ ZRXOG EHFRPH PRUH HQJDJHG ÂµG1$% 61/,5*$&% *$(/&5$5% ($% 3<% 130% ('61% I% $&E3=$5% +1/.% .+'<<-% I% $&E3=$5% +1$% +*"&.,"+/3&% 3<% .6/$&6$% /&+3% 03*?.137.% ".% ,3QJ DV , KDG D FOHDU JRDOÂ¶ T3/1&*+1,+!MV!"71,!8'1*+!1,!5&%#+&,!+'!(1*<1*J,!'(!h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

E'5R,7'8! /'*+&*+! +'! +7&! *&&<,! '(! ,8&/1(1/! J5'08,! '(! /71%<5&*! #*<! 1*! '5<&5! +'! #J5&&! +7&! 5'%&,! #*<! 5&,8'*,1$1%1+1&,!<051*J!E'5R,7'8!<&%12&56!'(!+&#/7&5!#*<!21,1+1*J!85#/+1+1'*&5:! "7&!3)G>")a!85'J5#441*J!E'5R,7'8,!E&5&!2&56!&*+70,1#,+1/#%%6!5&/&12&<!$6!/71%<5&*S!+&#/7&5,!#*<! 8#5&*+,:!"7&!/71%<5&*!('/0,&<!E&%%!Âµ<RX KDYH WR SD\ DWWHQWLRQ UHDOO\ SD\ DWWHQWLRQ WR VHH ZKDW WR GRÂ¶ TL'/0,! J5'08! KV:! "7&! /'480+&5! +&/7*'%'J1,+,! 81+/7&<! +7&! 5#+&! #*<! /'*+&*+! '(! +&#/71*J! 2&56! DSSURSULDWHO\ DQG WKH FKLOGUHQ DSSUHFLDWHG WKLV ÂµG1$%0"=%1$%1"5%3<%$A7,"/&/&#%0".%./(7,$*>%#/;/&#%=3'% WLPH ORDGV RI WLPHÂ¶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Â¶V OHDUQLQJ! ! LEFEH"01-4N%")4"-(()('8%"(7S-.8:":&)%4&%"-48"(%&147C7N/!! ;+!#88&#5,!+7#+!+71,!+&#/71*J!#885'#/7!7#,!5&#%!$&*&(1+,!1*!+7#+!1+!E#,!#$%&!+'!#/71&2&!+7&!4#1*!85'A&/+! JRDO RI FKDQJLQJ FKLOGUHQÂ¶V SHUFHSWLRQ RI VFLHQFH WHFKQRORJ\ VXEMHFWV DQG FUHDWLQJ DQ LQWHUHVW DQG &*+70,1#,4!('5!+7&!%&#5*1*J:!!,W LV Âµ"&%$=$%37$&$*%<3*%WKHP DQG VKRZV WKHP ZKDW WKH\ DUH FDSDEOH RI Â¶ T@#5&*+!bV:!!)71%<5&*!#88%1&<!+7&!%&#5*1*J!1*!+7&15!7'4&!/'*+&.+,!/#5561*J!'0+!,148%&!&.8&514&*+,!#*<! &.8%#1*1*J!/'*/&8+,!+'!+7&15!8#5&*+,W(#41%1&,:! !"&#/7&5,!#%,'!&*J#J&<!E1+7!+7&!,/1&*/&!#*<!&.+&*<&<! +7&!%&#5*1*J!#/5',,!/0551/0%04!,0$A&/+,!$&+E&&*!E'5R,7'8,!#*<!#(+&5!+7&!85'A&/+!87#,&!E#,!'2&5:!! 6FLHQWLVWV HQGHDYRXUHG WR GHVLJQ WKH FRQWHQW VR WKDW LW KDG UHOHYDQFH WR WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V OLYHG H[SHULHQFH #*<!/71%<5&*!(&%+!+7#+!+7&15!'81*1'*,!7#<!E'5+7!#*<!+71,!/'*+51$0+&<!+'E#5<,!+7&15!%&2&%,!'(!&*J#J&4&*+! #*<! 'E*&5,718:! ! "7&! 85'/&,,! '(! /71%<5&*! ,&&1*J! ,/1&*+1,+,! E1+71*! +7&15! E'5R! &*215'*4&*+! /5&#+&<! #! <&&8&5!0*<&5,+#*<1*J!RI WKH VFLHQWLVWÂ¶V UROH DQG SURPSWHG VRPH RI WKH FKLOGUHQ WR H[SUHVV DQ LQWHUHVW LQ ,/1&*/&! #,! #! /#5&&5:! )71%<5&*! (&%+! 2#%0&<! E7&*! +7&15! [0&,+1'*,! #*<! '81*1'*,! E&5&! E&%/'4&<! $6! +7&! 85#/+1+1'*&5,! '*! +7&15! 21,1+! +'! +7&! B-G;! 1*,+1+0+&! #*<! +7&6! &.85&,,&<! +7#+! +7&6! E'0%<! %1R&! +'! ,+0<6! 1*! XY;Z:!!3'4&!/71%<5&*!,#E!+7#+!,/1&*/&!E#,!#!8#5+!'(!&2&56<#6!%1(&!#*<!#!/5&#+12&!#/+121+6!A0,+!#,!40/7! #,!#5+!#*<!#%,'!7#<!5&#%!2#%0&:!;+!ÂµPDNHV \RX VPDUWHU Â¶ TL'/0,!J5'08!KV:!"7&,&!(1*<1*J,!1*<1/#+&!+7#+!+7&! '$A&/+12&!'(!5#1,1*J!+7&!85'(1%&!'(!,/1&*/&!,0$A&/+,!E1+7!+7&!/71%<5&*!E#,!2&56!,0//&,,(0%%6!#/71&2&<!#*<! #%,'!7#<!+7&!148#/+!'(!/7#*J1*J!+7&!E#6!+7#+!/71%<5&*!&*J#J&!E1+7!,/1&*/&:! ! LEFE!"[%S"+V)CC:"=&Y'):)()74" ;*! #%%! +75&&! /#,&! ,+0<6! ,/7''%,! +7&! /71%<5&*! %&#5*&<! 5&#%! ,R1%%,! +7#+! 1*/%0<&<! <&,1J*1*J! +7&15! 'E*! &.8&514&*+,S! /5&#+12&! E51+1*J! ,R1%%,S! <5#E1*J! ,R1%%,!#*<! /'480+&5!85'J5#441*J:! "&#/7&5,!#*<! 8#5&*+,! *'+&<!+7#+!/71%<5&*!<&4'*,+5#+&<!1485'2&<!5&/#%%S!/51+1/#%!+71*R1*J!#*<!5&/'5<1*J!,R1%%,:!!!"7&!+&#4E'5R! DQG FROODERUDWLRQ LQFRUSRUDWHG LQWR ZRUNVKRSV KDYH GHYHORSHG WKH FKLOGUHQÂ¶V VRFLDO VNLOOV 7HDFKHUV #*<!,/1&*+1,+,!<1,/0,,&<!7'E!+7&6!E&5&!/'*,+#*+%6!%&#5*1*J!+75'0J7!'$,&521*J!'+7&5!85#/+1+1'*&5,!#*<! +75'0J7! +7&15! 'E*! 5&(%&/+1'*! '*! +7&! 85'A&/+! 85'/&,,&,! #*<! E&5&! 1*/'58'5#+1*J! +7#+! %&#5*1*J! 1*+'! +7&15! +&#/71*J!,+6%&,:! ! LEFEJ"B-)4(-)4)4N"-48"+(.%4N(1%4)4N"#$):()4N"Q)4V:"S)(1"<-I7.P"-48"[U6"]-CS-/" "&#/7&5,!&.85&,,&<!&*+70,1#,4!('5!&*J#J1*J!1*!+7&!85'A&/+!#J#1*!E1+7!=#$'5P!#*<!E&5&!#885&/1#+12&!'(! +7&!,/7''%,!1*2'%2&4&*+:!7R EH KRQHVW ,Â¶G KDYH WUXVW LQ ZKDW %DERUy ZRXOG FRPH XS ZLWK ,WV YHU\ ZHOO UXQ DQG ,Â¶P YHU\ LPSUHVVHG DQG LWÂ¶V D JUHDW SULYLOHJH IRU WKH FKLOGUHQ DQG P\VHOI WR EH LQYROYHG ZLWK LW Â¶T"&#/7&5!MV!:! ! Âµ,Â¶G OLNH WR EHFRPH LQYROYHG DJDLQ , ZRXOG VXSSRUW WKLV \HVÂ¶!T"&#/7&5!OV:! 58

! "7',&!+&#/7&5,!+7#+!E&*+!'*!(1&%<!+518,!+'!XY;Z!(&%+!+71,!+'!$&!#!2&56!E'5+7E71%&!#,8&/+!'(!+7&!85'A&/+! #*<! E'0%<! %1R&! +'! 5&8&#+! +71,! &.8&51&*/&! #*<! &.+&*<! +7&15! 5&%#+1'*,718! E1+7! ,'/1#%! #*<! &*215'*4&*+#%! 5&,&#5/7&5,!1*!XY;Z:! ! !

LEH"c%/"@%.:2%&()*%:"7;"+(-V%17C8%.:".%N-.8)4N"2.7A%&("8%C)*%./"

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µ&UHDWLYH 3DUWQHUVKLSV¶ 85'J5#44&! E71/7! 1<&*+1(1&<! '*&! '(! +7&! R&6! /7#5#/+&51,+1/,! '(! /5&#+12&! 8&'8%&! +'! $&! +7&! #$1%1+6! +'! FROODERUDWH ZLWK RWKHUV ,QFUHDVLQJ FKLOGUHQ¶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¶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µQHJRWLDWH¶ WKHLU UROHV LQ WKH SURFHVV DQG WKH SUDFWLWLRQHU VKRXOG SURYLGH DQ '0+%1*&!'(!E7#+!E1%%!$&!/'2&5&<!#*<!1+!1,!1<&#%!1(!+71,!/'**&/+,!E1+7!+7&!,/7''%!/0551/0%04:!"7&!,+0<1&,! 1<&*+1(6!+7#+!1+!1,!21+#%!+7#+!+&#/7&5,!#5&!85&,&*+!<051*J!E'5R,7'8,!1*!'5<&5!+'!%&#5*!+7&4,&%2&,!#*<!+'! <5#E!'0+!+7&!%&#5*1*J!('5!+7&!8081%,!#*<!$01%<!'*!+7&!E'5R!$&+E&&*!,&,,1'*,!#*<!#(+&5!+7&6!(1*1,7:! "

" LE!"6:"(1%"@.7A%&("B78%C":';;)&)%4(C/".7I':("(1-(")("&-4"I%".%2C)&-(%8";7."(%-&1)4N"2'.27:%:e" "

9*&! ,+5&*J+7! '(! +7&! =->3"?! C'<&%! 1,! +7#+! 1+! 1,! 2&56! (%&.1$%&! #*<! E'5R&<! E&%%! 1*! '8&5#+1'*:! =#$'5P! 85'21<&<!+7&!1*,815#+1'*!('5!+7&!85'A&/+!#*<!+7&!<5121*J!('5/&!+'!4'2&!+7&!85'A&/+!('5E#5<!#*<!+'!,'05/&! +7&!(0*<1*J:!=#$'5P!85'21<&<!,0((1/1&*+!(%&.1$1%1+6!+'!,088'5+!#5+,!#*<!,/1&*/&!85#/+1+1'*&5,!#*<!,/7''%,! 59

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b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b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

"7&5&!1,!#!8',1+12&!#*<!,088'5+12&!#++1+0<&!+'E#5<,!/'%%#$'5#+1'*!#*<!R*'E%&<J&!,7#51*J!#+!#%%! %&2&%,! '(! +7&! 85'A&/+! E1+7! '88'5+0*1+1&,! ('5! 85#/+1+1'*&5,! +'! 4&&+! +'J&+7&5! +'! ,7#5&! 1<&#,! #*<! %&#5*1*J:! "71,! ,+0<6! 7#,! 1<&*+1(1&<! #! *&&<! ('5! 4'5&! /'*,0%+#+1'*! $&+E&&*! +&#/7&5,! #*<! #5+,W,/1&*/&! 85#/+1+1'*&5,! 5&J#5<1*J! /71%<5&QÂ¶V QHHGV VFKRRO FXOWXUH DQG HWKRV WKH UROH RI +&#/7&5!#*<!85#/+1+1'*&5!<051*J!E'5R,7'8!<&%12&56!#*<!'+7&5!#,8&/+,!<&+#1%&<!1*!)7#8+&5!L12&:! ;*! #<<1+1'*! +7&5&! 1,!#*! 1<&*+1(1&<! *&&<! $6! ,/1&*+1,+,! '(!4'5&! /'%%#$'5#+1'*! E1+7! #5+1,+,! +7#+! E1%%! ,088'5+!+7&4!1*!+7&15!E'5R,7'8!<&,1J*!#*<!0*<&5,+#*<1*J!'(!+7&!85'A&/+:! " "7&! %'*J&5! +14&,/#%&! '(! +7&! 85'A&/+! T'2&5! M! 6&#5,V! 1,! &*#$%1*J! +7&! 148#/+,! #*<! %&#5*1*J! +'! <1((0,&!'2&5!#!E1<&5!+&#/7&5!8'80%#+1'*!#,!<1((&5&*+!+&#/7&5,!1*!+7&!/#,&!,+0<6!,/7''%,!$&/'4&! 1*2'%2&<!E1+7!85'A&/+!85'/&,,&,:!"71,!&.+&*<,!+7&!%&#5*1*J!+'!#!E1<&5!+&#/7&5!/'7'5+:" " ;+!1,!148'5+#*+!1*!#!/5&#+12&!85'A&/+!%1R&!=->3"?!E71/7!1,!,85&#<!'2&5!#!*04$&5!'(!,/7''%,S!+7#+! #!/'_'5<1*#+'5!1,!&48%'6&<!+'!+5#/R!+7&!<&2&%'81*J!85'/&,,&,\!+'!&*,05&!+7#+!'8&5#+1'*#%!1,,0&,! #5&! #<<5&,,&<! ,8&&<1%6\! +'! +14&! +#$%&! ,/7''%,! #*<! 85#/+1+1'*&5,! ('5! +7&! <&%12&56! '(! #! %#5J&! *04$&5!'(!E'5R,7'8,!'2&5!#!,7'5+!+14&!8&51'<!#*<!&,+#$%1,7!J''<!%1*&,!'(!/'440*1/#+1'*!#*<! J''<!E'5R1*J!5&%#+1'*,718,:!! ;*! +71,! ('54! '(! 85'A&/+! 1+! E1%%! #%E#6,! $&! #! /7#%%&*J&! +'! &*,05&! +7#+! 85#/+1+1'*&5,! #5&! *'+! A0,+! ,088'5+&<! E1+7! J''<! 1*('54#+1'*S! #<&[0#+&! 5&,'05/&,! #*<! '88'5+0*1+1&,! +'! /'%%#$'5#+&! E1+7! RWKHUV EXW DUH DOVR VXSSRUWHG WKURXJK WKH LQLWLDO VWDJH ZKLFK FDQ IHHO ÂµPHVV\Â¶ EXW ZKLFK LV RIWHQ 60

#!21+#%!8#5+!'(!+7&!/5&#+12&!85'/&,,:!=#$'5P!#5&!&.8&51&*/&<!1*!E'5R1*J!E1+7!+71,!('54!'(!/5&#+12&! 85'/&,,!#*<!#5&!E&%%!8%#/&<!+'!85'21<&!+7&!#885'851#+&!,088'5+:!"

"7&5&!,7'0%<!$&!J''<!$51&(1*J!<&+#1%,!#+!+7&!1*1+1#%!,+#J&,!'(!+7&!85'A&/+"

" "

"7&5&!1,!&21<&*/&!+7#+!+7&!4'<&%!1,!5'$0,+!1(!+7&!#$'2&!5&[015&4&*+,!#5&!(0%(1%%&<:!=#$'5P!7#,!#/71&2&<! +7&!85'A&/+!J'#%!#*<!4',+!'(!+7&!85'A&/+!'$A&/+12&,!#*<!#5&!1*!#!J''<!8',1+1'*!+'!4'2&!('5E#5<!+'!+7&! (1*#%!87#,&!'(!+7&!85'A&/+!1*!KQHb:!! ! LE!EF"d1-("87%:"(1%"X'-4()(-()*%"9-(-">%CC"':e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¶,!8%#**1*J!('5!+7&!=->3"?!;;;!@5'A&/+:!! "71,!1*!+05*!E1%%!&*#$%&!+7&4!+'!&*J#J&!1*!5&#%!&21<&*/&_$#,&<!8%#**1*J!#*<!85'J5#44&! 148%&4&*+#+1'*:! !

LEJ"@.7A%&("G%&7,,%48-()74:" "

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µEX\ LQ¶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a1J7! %&2&%,! '(! &*J#J&4&*+! E&5&! '$,&52&<! 1*! +7&! /71%<5&*! E7&*! +7&6! E&5&! 1*2'%2&<! E1+7! 4'5&! 1*+&5#/+12&! &%&4&*+,! '(! E'5R,7'8,:! "71,! 7#,! $&&*! '*&! '(! +7&! 4',+! ,0//&,,(0%! RXWFRPHV RI WKH SURMHFW DV LW KDV IDFLOLWDWHG µGHHS OHDUQLQJ¶ LQ WKH FODVVURRP ,W LV 5&/'44&*<&<!+7#+!1*!6&#5!+75&&!'(!+7&!85'A&/+S!E'5R,7'8,!,7'0%<!/'*+1*0&!+'!$&!<&,1J*&<!

! _ !!

+'! 1*/%0<&! #! E1<&! 5#*J&! '(! '88'5+0*1+1&,! ('5! 1*+&5#/+1'*! #*<! ,7'0%<! $&! /71%<_%&<! E7&5&! 8',,1$%&:! )'%%#$'5#+1'*!,7'0%<!/'*+1*0&!+'!7#2&!#!71J7!851'51+6!#+!&2&56!%&2&%!'(!+7&!85'A&/+!#*<!4'5&! '88'5+0*1+1&,!+'!/'%%#$'5#+&!#*<!8#5+1/18#+&!,7'0%<!$&!$01%+!1*+'!85'A&/+!148%&4&*+#+1'*:!!

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b:!

B1,,&41*#+1'*! '(! +7&! 85'A&/+! (1*<1*J,! ,7'0%<! $&! (05+7&5! /'*,1<&5&<:! >+! 85&,&*+! +7&5&! #5&! 21<&',! '(! =->3"! KQHK! #*<! #! <'E*%'#<#$%&! (1%&! '*! +7&! =#$'5P! E&$,1+&! E71/7! 1*+&5&,+&<! 8#5+1&,!/#*!#//&,,!$0+!1+!1,!5&/'44&*<&<!+7#+!#!/'86!'(!+7&!5&8'5+!'5!&.&/0+12&!,044#56! ,7'0%<! $&! ,&*+! +'! 8#5+1/18#+1*J! ,/7''%,! #*<! 85#/+1+1'*&5,! 1*! '5<&5! +'! <1,,&41*#+&! +7&! (1*<1*J,!+'!+7&!E1<&5!,/7''%!#*<!0*12&5,1+6!8'80%#+1'*,:!

!!!

! _ ! _ ! _

>!,+5'*J!5&/'44&*<#+1'*!1,!+7#+!=>=9G9!E'5R!E1+7!+7&!,'/1#%!5&,&#5/7&5,!+'!$01%<!08'*! +7&!,6,+&4!'(!'0+/'4&,!+5#/R1*J!#%5&#<6!1*1+1#+&<!#*<!,'!+7#+!&21<&*/&<_$#,&<!85'J5#44&! 8%#**1*J!#*<!<&%12&56!/#*!$&!0,&<!('5!=->3"!;;;:! ;+!E'0%<!$&!$&*&(1/1#%!+'!(05+7&5!&*J#J&!8#5&*+,!<051*J!+7&!1*+&52&*+1'*!8',,1$%6!1*/%0<1*J! 4'5&!&.&5/1,&,!('5!/71%<5&*!+'!<'!#+!7'4&:!! @#5+1/18#*+,! E'0%<! %1R&! +'! /'*+1*0&! #*<! ,+5&*J+7&*! +7&15! %1*R,! E1+7! =#$'5P! #*<! X#+1'*#%! Y*12&5,1+6!'(!;5&%#*<S!Z#%E#6:!

! !

G%;%.%4&%:! ! >;)-:!TKQHHV!:*+/.+.%/Q &UHDWLYH (GXFDWLRQ 8QORFNLQJ FKLOGUHQÂ¶V &UHDWLYLW\ $ 3UDFWLFDO *XLGH IRU $UWLVWV >2#1%#$%&!#+!7++8UWWEEE:#5+1,+,1*/5&#+12&&<0/#+1'*:/'4!!m>//&,,&<!HOWDWKQHMn! ! >%&.#*<&5S!G:!TKQHQV!J1/,5*$&>%+1$/*%D3*,5>%+1$/*%H5'6"+/3&X%Y/&",%Z$73*+%"&5%Z$63(($&5"+/3&.%3<%+1$% J"()*/5#$%!*/("*=%Z$;/$0-%T&<V!F'*<'*U!G'0+%&<J&! ! =#5*&,S!]:!TKQHHV!J*3..%Â±%J'**/6',"*%[$"*&/&#-%U@W\-3&/'*<!-<1+1'*:!F'*<'*U!3#J&! ! %DUQHV - 6KLUOH\ , Âµ6WUDQJHO\ IDPLOLDU &URVV &0551/0%#5! #*<! )5&#+12&! "71*R1*J! 1*! "&#/7&5! (GXFDWLRQ Â¶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a&#+7!l!)':! ! *RRGLVRQ 7 Âµ/HDUQLQJ ZLWK ,&7 DW SULPDU\ OHYHO SXSLOÂ¶V SHUFHSWLRQV Â¶ M3'*&",% 3<% J3(7'+$*% :../.+$5%[$"*&/&#S!HDU!KDK_KNO:! ! a#%%S! G:S! 3/7#2#51#*S! F:! TKQQHV! )DPLOLHVÂ¶% HQJDJHPHQW ZLWK WKHLU FKLOGUHQÂ¶V VFLHQFH DQG WHFKQRORJ\ ,$"*&/&#%"+%13($-%F&&<,U!B(-3!@0$%1/#+1'*,! ! -DUYLV 7 Âµ3URPRWLQJ FUHDWLYH VFLHQFH FURVV_/0551/0%#5!E'5R!+75'0J7! #*! 1*_,&521/&! 85'J5#44&:! P6133,%P6/$&6$%Z$;/$0>%NQTMMKVU!MN_bI! ! `&%%6S! F:S! 3+&#<S! B:! TKQHKV! H&1"&6/&#% 7*/("*=% .6/$&6$-% N$;$,37/&#% $<<$6+/;$% J*3..@J'**/6',"*% [/&?.-% 9Y@U!C/Z5#E!a1%%! ! C/)%&%%#*S!G:S!Z#%+'*S!C:S!3+&E#5<S!3:!#*<!@#J&S!):!TKQHKV:!G1$%I(7"6+%3<%J*$"+/;$%!"*+&$*.1/7.%3&%+1$% D$,,)$/&#%3<%J1/,5*$&%"&5%T3'&#%!$37,$-%X&E/#,+%&U!))-WY*12&5,1+6!'(!)#4$51<J&! ! C05876S!):!TKQQMV![/+$*"+'*$%Z$;/$0X%!*/("*=%P6133,%"&5%IJG-%=&%(#,+U!k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r#*<r>,,&,,4&*+W-#5%6r)71%<7''<r#*<r@514#56r-<0/#+1'*W@514#56 r3/7''%r)0551/0%04W@3Xr)0551/0%04r92&5%'#<W92&521&Er*#+1'*#%r1*+&5*#+1'*#%r&.8&51&*/&,:8<(! m>//&,,&<!HKWDWKQHMn! 63

! 9(,+&<!TKQQKV!G1$%J'**/6','(%/&%P'66$..<',%!*/("*=%P6133,.-%F'*<'*U!9(,+&<! ! @#,,&6S! B:S! G'J&5,S! ):S! C#)7&%%S! ]:S! a0J7&,S! Z:! ! TKQQbV! G1$% 83+/;"+/3&",% H<<$6+% 3<% IJG% 3&% !'7/,.-! F#*/#,+&5!Y*12&5,1+6U!B&8#5+4&*+!'(!-<0/#+1'*!#*<!3R1%%,:! ! G',&S!]:!TKQQNV!I&5$7$&5$&+%Z$;/$0%3<%+1$%!*/("*=%J'**/6','(X%Y/&",%*$73*+-%F'*<'*UB)3L:!>2#1%#$%&! #+! 7++8,UWWEEE:&<0/#+1'*:J'2:0RW80$%1/#+1'*,W,+#*<#5<W80$%1/#+1'*B&+#1%W@#J&HWB)L3_QQbNN_KQQN! m>//&,,&<!HKW^WKQHMn! ! 6DIIRUG . 2Â¶6XOOLYDQ 2 G1$/*%,$"*&/&#%)$63($.%=3'*%E3'*&$=-%!"*$&+.%*$.73&.$.%+3%61/,5*$&% 03*?/&#% /&% J*$"+/;$% !"*+&$*.1/7.-% F'*<'*U! )&*+5&! ('5!F1+&5#/6! 1*! @514#56!-<0/#+1'*:! EEE:/%8&:/':0R!! m>//&,,&<!HKWDWKQHMn! ! h#%&*+1*&S! Z:! TKQQOV! <RXQJ 3HRSOHÂ¶V KRPH XVH RI ,&7 IRU (GXFDWLRQ 3XUSRVHV F'*<'*U! B(-3! @0$%1/#+1'*,! ! !

A ppendix 1 T H E B E AST Project Index for C hildren

I D Number of C hild / Name ____________ Date 2013

T2 M /F

M y Involvement in these A ctivities I want you to think about the activities that you have been involved with in the workshops . I will read out five statements and there are four ways you can answer about what you think about being involved. Items 1. I feel comfortable at the programme/activity 2. I am a part of the programme/activity 3. I am committed to the programme/activity 4. I am supported at the programme/activity 5. I am accepted at the programme/activity

1. 1. 1. 1. 1.

N O! N O! N O! N O! N O!

2. 2. 2. 2. 2.

O ptions no 3. no 3. no 3. no 3. no 3.

yes yes yes yes yes

4. 4. 4. 4. 4.

Y ES! Y ES! Y ES! Y ES! Y ES!

M y E xperiences in School I would now like you to think about this school. I am going to ask you some questions about school and the friends you have here. For the next six statements, you can tell me how much you agree or disagree with things about your school. 6.I feel like I belong at this school

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

7. This school fits me well

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

8. I feel connected to this school

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

9. I feel welcome at this school

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

10. This school makes me feel like I belong

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

11. This is definitely my school

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

M y F riends Can you think about the friends you have and probably see most days? How would you say you get on with them? . 1. 2. 3. 4.

I am good at making friends I help other people I ask others if I can be of help I get along well with others

1. Not at all

2. A little

3. Some

4. A lot

5. Very much

1. Not at all

2. A little

3. Some

4. A lot

5. Very much

1. Not at all

2. A little

3. Some

4. A lot

5. Very much

1. Not at all

2. A little

3. Some

4. A lot

5. Very much

How I feel about Nature? The next set of questions ask you how you think and feel about nature and the world around you. 5 I like to learn about nature. 6 I like to read about plants and animals. 7. I would spend time after school working to fix problems in nature. 8. I like to learn about plants and animals. 9. I am interested in learning new ways to help protect plants and animals. 10 I would give some of my own money to help save wild plants and animals. 11. I like to spend time in places that have plants and animals. 12. I would help to clean up green areas in my neighbourhood. 13. My life would change if there were no plants and animals. 14. My life would change if there were no trees. 15. Plants and animals are important to people. 16. It makes me sad to see homes built where plants and animals used to be. 17. People need plants to live. 18. Nature is easily harmed or hurt by people. 19. Plants and animals are easily harmed or hurt by people. 20. We need to take better care of plants and animals.

1. Strongly disagree 1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

1. Strongly disagree 1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree 5. Strongly agree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

2.Disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree 5. Strongly agree

M y E xperiences with I C T in School I would like you to think about using ICT (Computers) in school. I am going to ask you some questions about ICT. For the next statements, you can tell me how much you agree or disagree with things about ICT in school. 1.School work with ICT is more interesting

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

2. School Work is more fun without ICT

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. I pay more attention when lessons involve the use of ICT

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

4. I find all my school work interesting

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

5. Using ICT helps me choose the best place to start a piece of work

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

6. ICT lets me work whenever I want to

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

7. Work without ICT grasps my attention better

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

8. I get more involved with my work when , GRQÂśW KDYH WR WKLQN DERXW QHZ ,&7 VNLOOV

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

9. ICT helps me to understand things better because I see pictures and videos

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

10. ICT helps me to understand things better because I can listen to examples that are given in sound 11. Using ICT makes me keen to go to every lesson

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

12. I mess around more in class when I use ICT

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

13. Using ICT makes me keen to go to school every day

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

14. Using ICT now will be better for my future career

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

15. ICT helps me to finish a piece of work that sometimes would be difficult to finish without it 16. ICT makes me want to work more by helping me to make my work look better

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

17. I work better with ICT because I can change things I have already written without making my work look a mess 18. ICT helps me to work with other people

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

19. I work better with ICT because it helps me put my ideas together

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

20. I work better with ICT because it helps me to see things more easily

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

21Using ICT helps me get better marks

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

22. I work harder with ICT because it helps with my writing

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

23.I work harder with ICT because it helps me work better with other people

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

24. I like working with ICT because it helps me work better with other people

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

25. Working with other people when using ICT helps me to learn better

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

26. I like being able to show other people how to do things when I am using ICT

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

27I can work longer without losing my concentration when using ICT

1. Strongly disagree

2.Disagree

28. If you can work longer with ICT, tell us how much longer in minutes you can work

3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree 3. Neither agree nor disagree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

4. Agree

5. Strongly agree!

_____ Minutes

29. What do you mainly use the computer for in school? __________________________________

30. Would you like to make any comments about any of the workshops that you have taken part in? If so please write on the lines below.

Thank you very much for completing this questionnaire. ,7/!8/3/95:7!,/9.!9;!<=>?!496@92! 70