Hearts & Wallets is a magazine of BrandLoyalty - Edition 3, October 2014
Barcelona A melting pot of retail formulas and food experience, and the location for the RLC 2015
Making Sainsbury’s great again Justin King recalls ten years of positive change
Climbing up Maslow’s Pyramid Bryan Pearson describes how Maslow’s insights can be applied to everyday grocery shopping
Three of a kind BrandLoyalty, Icemobile and Precima: working in unison to achieve more
WHICH WHICHFORCE FORCEDEFINES DEFINESYOU? YOU?
JOIN JOIN THE STAR THE STAR WARSWARS EXPERIENCE EXPERIENCE AT THE ATRETAIL THE RETAIL LOYALTY LOYALTY CONGRESS CONGRESS 2015 2015
The more we give, the more we get As you know, there’s never a dull moment in food retail. With the fast pace of mobile and social media developments, we see shoppers’ behaviour changing almost from day to day. And as we all know, today’s consumer is more demanding than ever. This is partly due to the recession – which continues to have an effect on shopping budgets – but also because consumers want to feel recognised and addressed in a relevant way. The more personally this is done, the better they feel about it. The era of just firing off generic messages is now behind us, and anyone who doesn’t ‘go with the flow’ is about to miss the boat. Customer data is the key to treating each person as an individual, but to get it you need to give the customer something in return. That’s why we’re going to talk more about the ‘Give to Get’ principle at the Retail Loyalty Congress 2015. We’ve decided to hold the event in Barcelona this time as the city has so much to offer: it´s an unique location full of character and history, with an amazing, enthusiastic atmosphere and a very advantageous feature: Barcelona is a melting pot of retail formulas and food experience in the greatest possible sense. I very much look forward to welcoming you to Barcelona – and in the meantime, would like to offer you this magazine as a taster of everything you can expect there.
WE TAKE CASUAL SHOPPERS AND TRANSFORM THEM INTO LOYAL CUSTOMERS
www.brandloyalty-int.com
BrandLoyalty is part of LoyaltyOne, an ADS company. The main LoyaltyOne banners are AIR MILES, BrandLoyalty, Precima, ICEMOBILE and Colloquy. Together, we are the global leader in data-driven loyalty solutions.
Enjoy the read! Robert van der Wallen CEO BrandLoyalty
6
Content
content
26
7
content
INTERVIEWS 12 Three of a kind: BrandLoyalty, Precima & IceMobile Robert van der Wallen, BrandLoyalty 22 Personal relationships in the mobile era Jeroen Pietryga, IceMobile
54
30
34 Customer analytics: the facts Brian Ross, Precima 72 Enjoying the era of the new thrift Philip Spanton, BrandLoyalty
Barcelona special
loyalty INSIGHTS
26 Barcelona: Catalonian capital and Mediterranean magnet 30 Unique food retail concepts
8
42 Neighbourhoods in Barcelona
40 Who knows what loyalty means?
94 Restaurants to remember
86 Stikeez: Opening the discounters’ doors 98 7 definitive loyalty trends
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015 54 Making Sainsbury’s great again Guest Speaker Justin King, ex-CEO of Sainsbury’s
86
59 Meet our host Alex Thomson, Moderator of the RLC 2015 76 The Spanish food retail landscape 81 Inspiring retail tours 101 Loyalty beyond reason Guest speaker Kevin Roberts, CEO Worldwide of Saatchi & Saatchi
Climbing up Maslow’s pyramid Bryan Pearson, LoyaltyOne
NEWS IN THE MARKET 18 Retail all over the world
lifestyle
76
70 Catalonia’s finest
12
GADGETS 82 Smart, functional, or both?
COLUMN
DIGITAL LOYALTY PROGRAMMES
93 ‘Lifestyle’ meets ‘blurring’ Art Frikus, Shopper Marketing expert
62 Bright Stamps: King of stamps
62
98
8
Loyalty Insights
Climbing up Maslow’s pyramid How moving shoppers up the hierarchy of needs is a win-win strategy
Bryan Pearson, President and CEO of LoyaltyOne, describes how Maslow’s insights can be applied to everyday grocery shopping. Aiming for the top
For example, at the most basic level (which in Maslow’s terms
At the World of Business Ideas Innovation Forum in New York
is ‘Survival’), employees want to have a job and get paid. At the
recently, I had what I would call a “lightbulb moment” when I
next level (‘Succeed’), social factors and self-esteem become more
heard Chip Conley speak. Founder of the Joie de Vivre hotel chain,
important, being expressed in job status, promotions and career
Chip talked about how he had transformed his business by focusing
tracks. Employees progressing to the top level (‘Transform’) are
on core motivation theory, and specifically the work of psychologist
highly motivated to express the values of the organisation, and
Abraham Maslow. In brief, Chip had simplified Maslow’s hierarchy
empowered to realise them. For customers and shareholders,
of needs (often graphically expressed as the ‘Maslow triangle’) from
the basic value exchange also progresses through a social and/
5 to 3 levels, and had worked out what each level meant to 3 core
or commercial recognition’ stage before reaching the top of
groups of people: employees, customers and shareholders. Then he
the triangle: the level at which they feel that the aims of the
concentrated on steering each group upwards towards the top level.
organisation align with their own.
10
11
Loyalty Insights
Loyalty Insights
Putting Maslow to work in the supermarket
Improving the food experience
Chip’s talk inspired me to see if Maslow’s insights into human
If you think of the emotional connection between the triangle
psychology could also be applied to food retailing. In fact there are
and the consumer, you can say that the bottom level is about
many direct parallels, particularly if you look at our own business
meeting the consumer’s existing expectations in order to create
model – which also happens to be in the form of a triangle. We aim
basic satisfaction. At the next level – ‘Recognition’ – you're
to take customers from the most basic level (‘Reward’) to the next level (‘Recognition’) and then to the highest level (‘Relevance’) which is the most profitable level for the retailer.
reward
beginning to address the consumer’s desires: such as to feel more special and successful. If you can do this, you create a level of commitment that takes you towards the top ‘Relevance’ level. Here, you can go further by identifying and meeting
The three ‘R’s
a consumer’s unrecognised needs in the way they shop or
At the most basic level, customers are rewarded very simply:
the way they tackle the food experience. If you can do this,
the value exchange is a financial one. Goods are selected, and
you can awaken real passion in the consumer, for instance by
money is handed over. Rewards from loyalty programmes make
empowering them to create the kind of meal they thought
this exchange more attractive and move the customer up a
they could only get in an expensive restaurant. Retailers can
level to ‘Recognition’, whereby a good customer is individually
definitely move the consumer up the triangle, tapping into
acknowledged for their spend level and frequency. Airlines do
the desire to constantly improve the experience around food,
this with frequent flyer programmes and lounge access; food
which is such a central part of everyone’s lifestyle. That’s why
retailers can do it with loyalty programmes or other special value
a lot of the programmes that BrandLoyalty operates, with top-
offerings that highlight the customer’s status. Both these levels offer
quality cookware, Zwilling knives and so on, are designed to
retailers the opportunity to learn more about individual customers
enhance that experience over time.
through intelligent use of data, enabling the relationship to reach the top level: ‘Relevance’. Here, the customer offer is much more
Building on the basics
personalised, making the customer feel more committed and
Of course, you need a foundation of data in order to get to the top
connected to the brand. This is a great level to reach, because this
level where you’re really relevant to your customers. This requires
sort of customer is now very loyal to your store, spends more of
customer information, connected to some meaningful form of
their food budget there, and often communicates positively about
segmentation and analysis. BrandLoyalty gains this information
it on social media. To use Maslow’s language, this is the level of
through its loyalty programmes, and IceMobile’s Bright Stamps
self-actualisation and transformation: the customer has moved from
app provides a communication and connection platform to send
passive acceptance to active engagement.
individual messages. Precima leverages the customer information through the unique technological capabilities we have today,
Survivors have aspirations too
encouraging customers to constantly move upwards.
Too many retailers like to stay at the bottom level – maybe because they’re just more familiar with the territory. But even
I think the magic happens when you leverage that information
if they’re comfortable there, their customers aren’t. Even very
to create alignment with the issues or opportunities that exist
price-conscious consumers aspire to live at a higher level, and feel
within your customer base. It means you can connect your
emotionally more involved with a retailer who more closely meets
communications, your value offer and even your reward
their needs and aspirations. Consciously or subconsciously, when
programme to things that are most important to individuals. You
someone’s being recognised or given reaffirmation statements, they
can inspire people, make yourself meaningful to them, and keep
feel better about the shopping they’re doing or the efforts they’re
them emotionally and transactionally close to you. The top of
making to stick with that one retailer over time.
Maslow’s triangle is a great place to do business. ■
recognition
relevance
12
INTERVIEW
of a
BrandLoyalty, IceMobile and Precima: working in unison to achieve more for our clients
The collaboration between BrandLoyalty, IceMobile and LoyaltyOne’s subsidiary Precima is already bearing fruit, as Robert van der Wallen explains.
See it for yourself
Unmissable opportunities
Geographically of course, with LoyaltyOne being mainly active in
One of the most exciting initiatives we’ve started is in the field of personalised promotions
When I’m asked what it’s like to be working with LoyaltyOne,
North America, and BrandLoyalty in Europe and Asia, our joint
– using a mobile app – whereby we make use of our three companies’ complementary
I can honestly say that this first year has more than justified our
global footprint has greatly enlarged our commercial sales reach.
strengths. To reduce the risk to retailers, part of our fee may depend on actual redemptions
decision to get together in the first place. Of course we knew there
As part of ADS, we can offer even greater financial stability than
rather than just clicks. Retailers may also use this app to cross-sell or up-sell, by making
would be tremendous opportunities, both for our clients and for
before. We’ve also increased our capabilities and knowledge due
customers relevant offers based on their current data or purchasing pattern. We’re looking to
ourselves, but the scale of these opportunities is becoming even
to the fact that our companies offer complementary best-in-class
share this at the RLC 2015, and I can’t wait to explore the opportunities it will open up.
more breathtaking with each day.
solutions. LoyaltyOne’s experience with long-term coalition loyalty
15
INTERVIEW
programmes such as AIR MILES is underpinned by Precima’s
choices, greater transparency and speed of information, and a
extensive data analytics capabilities, while BrandLoyalty’s
bewildering number of interconnections – just look at what’s
proven expertise in short-term loyalty programmes is
happening on social media. But despite all these distractions, food
reinforced by IceMobile’s unique digital solutions.
continues to consume a large part of most people’s family budget and a large part of their time (in shopping, preparing, and using
We are already using each other’s expertise to continually improve
food-related products). We see that everything that's been digitised
our own products and services. During this year alone, 50 cases
and brought to the consumer in an easy, transparent way gives them
of the nearly 3,000 loyalty programmes that BrandLoyalty has
more power to decide how they shop. That’s why it’s so important
run in the past will be reanalysed by Precima so that we can
to engage with consumers on this level.
prove the results much more robustly. Meanwhile, IceMobile is helping Precima enhance the user experience of its tools for
What we believe
category managers, and adding an extra digital dimension to
With the power balance shifting to the consumer, we as a
BrandLoyalty’s loyalty programmes via Bright Stamps. What’s
group of companies believe we need to know the consumer
more, our new working relationship has revealed immense
inside and out. Whatever we design, from a mobile app to a
synergies in what we see, what we believe and what we offer.
loyalty programme with pots and pans, we need to thoroughly understand the decision-making process, including the triggers,
What we see
at every stage. We believe that customer intimacy is crucial
Firstly – and very importantly – our three companies share
for retail growth, and we believe in creating a combination of
the same view of the challenges in food retail. Jeroen Pietryga
emotional and transactional loyalty to achieve this. And of course,
(CEO of IceMobile) and I have both been retailers – as have
we believe that data mastery is the key to success.
many of our colleagues at Precima – and we know how tough it
“Today’s customercentric dynamic is fast shifting to a customersteered dynamic. That’s why we need to be ahead of the game.”
is to succeed. It's only natural with the financial pressure of this
Good relationships depend on respect
modern age that retailers are focusing on scale and efficiency,
There’s more to data mastery though than simply having the ability
and it’s easy to lose sight of the fact that it's good old-fashioned
to crunch the figures. It’s also a matter of using the data intelligently
customer intimacy that brings you growth in the first place.
and upholding the ‘Give to Get’ principle in a way that consumers accept. The way we do that is by telling people upfront why we
From ‘either...or’ to ‘both...and’
need certain information and what they get in return. We use our
Retailers see efficiency and customer intimacy as contradictory
emotional intelligence and thorough understanding of retail to
propositions. They fully acknowledge how important it is to build a
gain insights from the data and to act on it in a way that benefits
relationship with customers – for example by putting extra staff on
everyone involved.
the shop floor to help people – but hesitate because it costs money. Our viewpoint is that efficiency and customer intimacy aren’t
What we offer
mutually exclusive, but that you can leverage the first to achieve the
BrandLoyalty, IceMobile and Precima can provide solutions
second. This seems like a paradox, but in fact it’s an everyday reality
separately or in combination, but our great strength is that we offer
for our clients.
an integrated approach to three core aspects: data insights, personal experience, and content (or motivators). As a group, we offer
Power to the consumer
actionable insights on individual or mass customer behaviour.
Another perspective that BrandLoyalty, IceMobile and Precima share is on how the retail landscape is evolving. Daily life is
Practical solutions
becoming ever more complex, with an increasing number of
Let’s say that a retailer wants to increase the spend of certain
16
INTERVIEW
customers who've been walking away en masse to a discounter.
feel engaged when they see their balance, they don't forget
BrandLoyalty may come up with a short-term programme like
to collect, and they feel even more rewarded when they get a
collecting for 5-star Zwilling knives, which is a great motivator – it
congratulatory message.
enables people to get high value with a huge discount. Then to create the right mechanism (how many stamps participants get for
Skin in the game
what amount of spend, how long they should collect, which type
There's one element to all this that makes us different, and
and number of knives to use, and so on), we use the insights from
that's that we actually put our own skins in the game. We
our research data. BrandLoyalty has run nearly 3,000 programmes
believe so much in the power of the consumer and the power
worldwide, so we’ve already got a broad base to work from, but
of our own data mastery that we are prepared to put our money
by using Precima’s additional data analytics capabilities, we can
where our mouth is. We willingly share the risks, along with
do a much better, more accurate proposal, with more effective
our clients. For example, BrandLoyalty will take away the risk
projection, resulting in better value for the retailer and the
of leftover stock in a loyalty programme by taking back unsold
consumer. Retailers who share their own data with us will get an
or unredeemed items. Risk-sharing has already been in our
even better programme with better results.
culture for a long time, but the same goes for Precima, which offers revenue-sharing or Pay for Performance for some data
Personal relevance
solutions. It proves how serious we are about what we offer,
Again, it’s a case of starting with the consumer, analysing the
and our willingness to offer innovative payment structures
decision-making process and using the data to come to a
creates a win-win situation for everyone.
And make a donation to support our primary school in Gulu, Uganda
better proposition. We design our products in a personal way, based on the needs and wishes of their users. For example,
All for one, and one for all
BrandLoyalty does concept testing, such as letting children
We see ourselves as 3 standalone companies that by sharing
play with Instant Loyalty Promotions while their parents
capabilities and expertise can make a better solo offering, or a better
watch from behind a glass mirror, while IceMobile invites
combined offer if our clients so wish. We´ve gone a long way in
consumers to its headquarters every week to test each new
the short period of time that we´ve been working together, and it
element of its retail apps. Our aim is to enhance the personal
actually feels very natural for us to collaborate on making the best
experience and relevance of everything we offer. And we see
use of our separate expertise. Whether driven by internal ideas or
through this that customer intimacy actually leads to a higher
external challenges, I do think that the opportunities to leverage
transactional loyalty. With Bright Stamps, for instance, people
each other´s capabilities will only increase. ■ For the past few years, BrandLoyalty has been working together with SOS Children’s Villages to support the newly opened primary school in Gulu, Uganda. Uganda is slowly recovering from a civil war and is relatively stable, so this is the perfect time for us to invest in Uganda’s children and help them take their future into their own hands. BrandLoyalty’s own charity organisation
Experience our approach to loyalty
(the Brand Charity Foundation) has taken up the challenge to help the school and hopefully
We collaborate from our home bases in Toronto, Amsterdam
create a bright future for Gulu’s schoolchildren. So follow your heart and support BrandCharity!
and Den Bosch, where Precima’s European office is located. At our Loyalty Experience Centre in BrandLoyalty’s Den Bosch headquarters, we invite visitors to experience what we have to offer in a more tangible way. Here you can see our data insight tools, personal experience enhancers and sales motivators in action.
Caring for children’s welfare worldwide
Deutsche Bank Nederland, Stichting Brand Charity Bestuur Plus Rekening, Account: 0575437979, IBAN: NL20 DEUT 0575 4379 79, BIC: DEUR NL2N
18
19
news in the market
news in the market
What’s happening to retail all over the world? Source: Planet Retail
Brazil: CARREFOUR bets on Brazilian convenience...again
Australia: Woolworths (AUS) opens first dark store
Rumours have circulated for months
The facility, in the Sydney suburb of
that Carrefour has been planning to
Mascot, is a test project that may lead
introduce a new format in Brazil, and
to the possible opening of several more
now those plans have materialised. The
similar outlets in other key markets to
retailer has introduced its international
lift efficiency amid an online push.
USA: NORDSTROM launches charitable private label In a first for the business, US department store and apparel retailer Nordstrom is developing a private label brand that will give 5% of revenue to non-profit organisations dedicated to empowering women and young girls.
Woolworths has opened a new store devoted entirely to its online business.
US: McDonald's hits supermarket shelves
convenience store banner Carrefour
UK: ALDI joins ‘healthy tills’ movement Discount store operator Aldi is to launch ‘healthy tills’ at all of its stores across the UK as of January 2015. This means
Express into São Paulo, the country’s largest metropolis.
Indonesia: Hypermart revamp for Matahari PP
McDonald's is to enter an already
that confectionery and chocolate will
crowded retail coffee market. The
be removed from the checkouts and
hamburger giant plans to market a
replaced with healthier options like
variety of coffee products under its
dried fruit, nuts, juices and water.
McCafé brand.
Indonesia grocer Matahari Putra Prima (MPP) will transform its Hypermart bigbox chain through a series of refurbishments in its latest bid to capture growing Indonesian consumer demand, the Jakarta Globe reports.
USA: WALMART ends Scan & Go scheme Walmart is to end Scan & Go selfscanning using shoppers’ smartphones.
US: Whole Foods Market integrates Apple Pay
UK: Morrisons opens first travel location store Morrisons has opened its first travel location store: at a Nottingham railway station.
Whole Foods Market is among the pioneering wave of US retailers to offer the new
Retail Week reports that the
Apple Pay mobile payment method that uses the iPhone to make purchases. With the
M Local convenience store
launch of the iPhone 6 and Apple Watch devices, the organic grocer is keen to be the
offers a Fresh to Go section
first on the block to offer the new technology. Whole Foods is looking to include Apple
tailored to commuters’
Pay across the board for all in-store purchases at coffee bars, tap rooms and juice bars.
tastes, with coffee, bacon sandwiches and pastries.
According to the Associated Press, the majority of customers could not understand how the Scan & Go app worked during tests in 200 stores.
The personal shopping assistant that
Bright Shopper is a digital eco-system that changes the way customers shop. It helps create a smart shopping list from products, promotions
over hearts and wallets
or ingredients from the recipes you offer. Bright Shopper will be an indispensable part of the customers daily shopping routine and therefore increase customer loyalty and drive more sales.
22
INTERVIEW
Why personal relationships are even more valuable in the
Mobile era The ability to create 1-to-1 relationships on a mass scale is already in your hands.
It’s not just business; it’s personal.
on presents to colleagues or friends. The bigger the emotional
Do personal relationships still matter in this day and age? You bet
connection, the greater the transactional value. The same is
they do. They’re like magnets that invisibly attract consumers to one
true with a commercial exchange: there’s always an emotional
store rather than another. Yet in the modern-day drive for scale and
and a transactional value. People will spend more if they feel
efficiency, decision-makers based far away in Head Office have lost
they have a good relationship with your store. That’s why it’s
IceMobile’s new CEO Jeroen Pietryga studied applied physics at the Delft University of
the ability to cultivate personal relationships. They’re just not close
so important to create a feeling of loyalty. Grow that emotional
Technology before going into marketing. After several years at P&G in Rotterdam, Brussels
enough to each store’s customers to know how to keep them loyal.
connection and you’ll grow the value of each transaction.
and Geneva, he came back to the Netherlands to work for food retail market leader Albert Heijn. His engineering training and marketing experience provide him with an unusually wide
Why’s emotional value important?
Get the right tools
perspective on the opportunities for customer engagement via retail apps, which have an
The emotional part of a relationship is a great driver for spend.
Many big food retail chains that have successfully focused on
unprecedented power to gain and retain customers, as he outlines here.
Let’s face it: you spend more money on gifts to your family than
efficiency are now struggling to grow their sales. They need
25
INTERVIEW
to use their size to invest in tool sets that help them to build a
now to focus on the 1-to-1 relationship they have with their best
one-to-one relationship with every customer. So they’ve adopted
customers. They need to commit now to driving top-line growth by
retail apps on a massive scale, although lots of these apps aren’t
offering the mobile solutions of the future. The natural tendency of
well designed and therefore aren’t well used. A good retail app
retail is to wait and just copy the competition, but retailers who do
should enable retailers to offer a better service to their primary
that will fall behind. They can’t hope to catch up with companies
customers. And we know from experience how these loyal
that are already building that personal relationship today.
shoppers are prepared to spend more after their app transforms an ordinary, anonymous supermarket into their own personal store.
Customers are ready. Are you? It’s amazing how quickly consumers will take to an app if
Personal shopping. Personal promotions.
you make it easy and satisfying to use. Older shoppers are no
At IceMobile, we believe that apps should make life easy. They
exception – in fact, we have seen many examples where they
should inspire you, help you shop and make you feel rewarded.
accept and adopt the right service first. Retailers need to be
Take our Bright Shopper app: it’s like having your own personal
prepared to invest in quality and work with partners who have
shopping assistant. It reminds you what to buy, suggests tasty
the proof, ability and experience to understand shopping trends
menus and remembers your preferences. Bright Stamps - our
and the fundamental needs that customers have.
promotional app - is easy and highly individualised too. Instead of collecting paper stamps, you just swipe your smartphone on
Value comes from a worthwhile exchange
the reader at the checkout and you’re done. Your stamps have
The 1-to-1 relationship is the most precious asset of your
been automatically uploaded, you can see immediately how many
company, so treat it properly. One design principle we use in
you’ve got and how many you still need to collect, and you even
developing our apps is ‘Give to Get’, and we communicate this
get an alert to remind you to collect the extra stamps you need
clearly. If we ask a customer for information, we make sure we
before the promotion ends. That’s real, personal service, especially
explain why we need it and what they get in return. For instance,
when you combine it with nice touches like a welcome message
we ask them to register so that we can inform them of the
for joining the promotion, or a congratulations push-message
number of stamps they’re entitled to, and we ask for permission
when you reach a certain number of points.
to use their data so that we can give them tailor-made offers and information. Now that BrandLoyalty, Precima and IceMobile
“Consumers are ready. Are you?”
Did you see it coming?
are part of the same company, we are working together to
Bill Gates says that with new technology, we consistently
analyse the data and deliver even better, completely personalised
overestimate what will happen in the next 2 years, but we always
offers and services. These then automatically drive brand
underestimate what will happen in the next 10 years. Smartphones
preference both in the short and the long term.
and tablets have become so much part of our everyday experience that it’s hard to think of life without them. But think back just 5
Creative, technical, or both?
years, and you realise that the shopping landscape looked very
There are many companies and agencies that can deliver an
different. 10 years ago, apps weren’t even around – there was no
app, but few that are able to operate on the intersection of
broadband internet, no colour screen, no Big Data and no cloud.
technology and creativity, which is what IceMobile does. We have
So it took vision for companies to develop mobile solutions, and
the creativity and futuristic vision to dream up something that
courage from retailers to invest in them.
shoppers will love, together with the technological skills to be able to make it work. This unique combination, with a focus on food
The future starts now.
retail, delivers personal relationships that will continue to grow in
That’s why it’s important for retailers to make the strategic choice
emotional and transactional value over the years to come. ■
26
27
barcelona special
barcelona CATALONIAN CAPITAL AND MEDITERRANEAN MAGNET
barcelona special
Barcelona, the capital of Catalonia, is one of the most dynamic, culturally vibrant, interesting and inviting cities in the world today. Pierre Chabot, who lives and works in Spain as BrandLoyalty’s Area Sales Director, takes us on a whirlwind tour.
Catalonia, Catalunya, Catalonha, Cataluña…
Why visit?
La Boqueria
Barcelona is the capital of Catalonia, a region in the north-west
Barcelona combines everything that is most charming about
No visit to Barcelona is complete without a visit to the Mercat de Sant Josep de la
Seasons in Barcelona
of Spain with a long and colourful history. Bordered by France
Mediterranean cities – a relaxed pace, months of endless sunshine,
Boqueria, often simply referred to as La Boqueria. This large public market in the
Winter can present you with azure
and Andorra to the north, the Mediterranean to the east, and the
unbeatable food – with a cultural and visual wealth that rival those
Ciutat Vella district is one of the city's foremost tourist landmarks, and with good
skies and improbably warm days,
Spanish regions of Aragon and Valencia to the west and south,
of any city in northern Europe. Its patchwork of architectural styles
reason. Bursting with everything from freshly caught fish to exotic spices and bright
while summer – though humid – is not
Catalonia has always played a strategically valuable role. It was
sets dark, Gothic façades next to the harlequin buildings of the
displays of fruit, and vibrant with the cries of the stallholders, La Boqueria is a feast
as blisteringly hot as in other Spanish
colonised by the Romans, and was an important maritime power
Modernistas and the skyline-piercing constructions of modernists
for the eyes, ears and nose. People eat, shop and gossip together, treating the market
cities. However, lots of locals desert
in medieval times. The region has three official languages: Spanish,
such as Jean Nouvel, Herzog & de Meuron. Sightseeing highlights
as the centre of the community in fine Spanish style.
the town in August, leaving the city
Catalan and the Occitan dialect of Aranese.
include the spectacular Gaudi church La Sagrada Famiglia, the
The market is the best showcase of fresh ingredients in the city, with just-netted
traffic-free but also empty of culture
Plaça Reial square, the Palau de la Música Catalana (Palace of
fish arriving at 7pm every evening. Poultry, legumes and cereals, offal, olives and
and eating opportunities, as many
Fruits of the vine
Catalan Music) and the eye-catching structures in Park Güell.
preserves, game, eggs, charcuterie, seafood, salted fish...you can buy food here that
restaurants are shut. Autumn attracts
Catalonia is blessed with diverse and fertile soils, plus a warm,
A day spent admiring these can be topped off with a sundowner
you can’t find anywhere else. Restauranteurs and private individuals rub shoulders as
late sun-seekers, although October
temperate climate. Together, these have proved perfect conditions
on one of the city’s seven beaches before dinner at any number of
they decide which of the best cuts of meat to take away with them.
and November tend to see sudden
for wine-making, with over 70,000 hectares devoted to wineries and
Michelin-starred gastronomic temples or humble, family-run tapas
Although the market itself dates from medieval times, it only gained a proper home
bursts of showers. Spring is pleasantly
vineyards today. The Catalonian area of Penedès is the birthplace
bars. Spectacular views over Barcelona can be gained from the
when construction of the original building was finished in 1853. A new fish market
warm and bright, while the busiest
of the sparkling Cava wine. The region’s white grapes include
Collserola mountain range behind the city. This is also a city with a
opened in 1911, and the metal roof that still exists today was constructed in 1914.
period is Easter, when prices of flights
Macabeo, Parellada and Zarello, and it also produces red wines
proud sense of identity, where local culture and traditional festivals
from Garnacha, Monastrell and Tempranillo vines.
are both celebrated and fiercely guarded.
and hotels are correspondingly high.
To discover more about La Boqueria, visit www.boqueria.info
30
31
barcelona special
barcelona special
A WHOLE VARIETY Of unique food retail concepts
Temptation nº4 Papa Bubble: the magic of authentic confectionery
Temptation nº2 Casa Gispert: top-quality coffee, nuts and southern fruits
Papa Bubble - Carrer Ample 28 Neighbourhood: El Born Metro: L3 (Drassanes)/ L4 (Jaume I)
Papa Bubble has given old-fashioned sweets a new lease of life. And how! Since this small sweetshop in Barcelona opened its doors in 2004, its sweets have become all the rage – and the infectiously popular Papa Bubble magic
Are you’re running out of time to taste all the delicious local
has spread all over the world. Authentic confectionery in bright colours
specialities? Would you like to take some of them home with you for
Casa Gispert - Sombrerers 23 - Neighbourhood: El Born - Metro: L4 (Jaume I)
your family and friends to enjoy? Perhaps you just deserve another
Take note if you love coffee, mixed nuts, southern fruits, honey, jam and teas: there’s
of Papa Bubble. These cheerful sweets
definitely one delicatessen in Barcelona that you shouldn’t just walk past! Casa
are made in the traditional manner in the
Gispert is a household name in Barcelona. That’s understandable, because it’s one of
shop itself, while you watch. Open the
the 10 best traditional food speciality shops in Europe. This delightful delicatessen
door and take a peek at how a mound
first opened its doors in 1851, and hasn’t looked back since.
of sugar, water and fruit essence is
Coffee beans and nuts are still roasted in the traditional manner in the original
transformed into original confectionery.
roasting oven from all those years ago. What’s more, the original store interior from
Whether you’re looking for tasty lollies or
the beginning of the 19th century is still intact. Take some freshly-roasted coffee or
individual fruit-based sweets, you’re sure
nuts with you for your loved ones back home. They’re sure to be grateful!
to find them at Papa Bubble.
treat? Whatever your excuse happens to be, it’s good enough to get you a knowing smile from the staff at the establishments below. Pop in to get a taste of Spain to take home...or to savour on the way back.
Temptation nº1 Bubó: the very best patisserie in all of Spain Bubó - Caputxes 10 - Neighbourhood: El Born - Metro: L4 (Jaume I) Bubó Bar - Caputxes 6 - Neighbourhood: El Born - Metro: L4 (Jaume I)
Just imagine being served by the best pastry chef in Spain. Step forward, Carles Mampel from patisserie Bubó in Barcelona. It’s a great honour, but he’s certainly
Temptation nº3 Vila Viniteca: wine-tasting in the heart of Barcelona Vila Viniteca - Carrer Agullers 7 - Neighbourhood: El Born - Metro: L4 (Jaume I)
earned it. He’s in charge of all Bubó desserts, and his creations are simply heavenly. The unusual sweet and savoury delicacies that emerge from his modern kitchen are
Villa Viniteca is a true jewel in the centre of
of excellent quality and and extremely tasty .
Barcelona. Here you can find the most extensive collection of the very best regional wines for an
Even if you don’t like desserts, it’s still worth paying a visit to this store just to admire
affordable price. In this specialist wine shop and
the wonderful 18th century building where the delicatessen is located.
delicatessen, founded by the Vila family in 1932, you’ll also get lots of excellent advice about
But if you are a true fan of patisserie, take the time to discover the Bubó bar just two
wines. The most delicious jamón iberico and
doors down, in front of the main entrance of the Iglesia de Santa Maria del Mar. Take
quesos from Spain are also on sale here. Why
a seat, and enjoy the noble art of the patissier at your leisure.
not take some home with you?
and the original shapes : that’s the secret
33
barcelona special
Temptation nº5 Demasié, Barcelona’s brown gold Demasié Princesa - Princesa 28 - Neighbourhood: El Born - Metro: L4 (Jaume I) Demasié Café - Roger de Lluría 8 - Neighbourhood: El Born- La Ribera Metro: L1 (Urquinaona)
The chocolate biscuits made by the Xocoa brothers Guillem and Marc Escursell are unbelievably delicious. Whether you prefer sweet or savoury biscuits, the talented siblings know how to tickle your tastebuds. All the possible colours, shapes and tastes that chocolate can offer are to be found here. This delicatessen is devoted to chocolate in the broadest sense of the word! If you are looking for a tasty present for your loved ones, this is certainly the place to be. And if you can’t resist chocolate yourself, there’s a simple solution, because Demasié also runs a café
Temptation nº6
in the centre of town. Highly recommended!
Jamón Experience nº6 JamÓn Experience Rambla de les Flors 88-94, Baques St. corner (in front of La Boqueria) Neighbourhood: Rambla - Metro: L3 Liceu, L1-L3 Placa Catalunya, L3 Drassanes
Keep learning. Keep developing. Keep growing. Mariël de Jongh, People Development Manager BrandLoyalty
Baluard - Carrer del Baluard 38 Neighbourhood: Barceloneta Metro: L4 (Barceloneta)
the texture, taste, colour and shape
Anyone who says that bread in
no two loaves are the same. Artificial
of the bread, while also ensuring that
Barcelona is tasteless hasn’t yet
colourings, aromas and flavourings
Everything you want to know about
discovered the Baluard bakery! Here,
form no part of the recipes. And the
jamón iberico is here under one roof!
they put a lot of love into every loaf
bakers really take the time to perfect
The Jamón Experience is a unique
– and you can taste it in every bite.
each and every handmade loaf.
space in the heart of Barcelona
In contrast to the many identical
Everything you buy here has been made
dedicated to this unique Spanish
factory-made loaves that pass over the
earlier in the day, in a natural process.
dry-cured ham. Here you can learn
counter every day in Spain, bread made
So if you’re looking for delicious, 100%
everything about jamón and enjoy
by Baluard is unique. The traditional
natural, high-quality bread with aroma,
tasting different varieties of this
manner in which the loaves in this
taste and long-lasting goodness, you
exquisite delicacy. Enjoy an engaging
pastry shop are prepared improves
know where to come!
interactive experience in a 2,000m2 state-of-the-art space that culminates with a tasting of six different kinds of jamones hand-cut by a master slicer and paired with a glass of cava, wine or beer. A unique experience you’ll treasure forever.
www.brandloyalty-int.com
Temptation nº7 Baluard: where each loaf of bread is unique
34
INTERVIEW
What
will tell you that traditional research won’t For insights that you can act on, you need facts, not just opinions. Brian Ross explains how actionable data is the key to retail success.
Understanding customers is a science whose time has come
longer have to be based on market surveys and the unreliable
When I finished my business degree in 1996, most companies
judgement, you could gain a robust understanding of what
either didn't have customer data, or didn’t know how to use it.
customers actually do, how they shop at your store, and what
Born and educated in Toronto, Brian Ross joined LoyaltyOne in 1996 and spent several years
The reason I joined the pioneers at LoyaltyOne was that we
really matters to them. Most of all, I was excited about this
working with AIR MILES, the largest coalition loyalty programme in Canada. He founded
all saw the potential of loyalty programmes to identify what
breakthrough capability to have strategy actually tied to
Precima – the customer analytics division of LoyaltyOne – in 2008, and as President is
were previously anonymous transactions. I knew this would
measurable results. And that’s exactly what today’s technology
responsible for its overall strategic and operational management.
revolutionise retailing, because strategic choices would no
allows us to offer.
insights they produced. Instead of depending on a consultant’s
37
interview
"Consumers are demanding greater relevance from every touchpoint."
Bridging the ‘Say / Do’ gap
…We have the key
If you go into survey of consumers and ask if they're healthy
At Precima, our starting point is to go and unlock the value of that
or health-conscious, 8 or 9 out of 10 people say yes. For some,
data. Somewhere inside it lies the answer to important questions
it could be true, but for others it’s just wishful thinking – or the
such as “Who are my most important customers?”, “What matters
result of peer pressure within the research group. What you need
to them?”, “What do they buy?” and “How can we better serve
to know is how they really shop and to what extent this desire for
their needs?” Our ability to interrogate the data is built on more
a healthy lifestyle actually influences their purchasing decisions. If
than 20 years of customer analytics and insights from working
shoppers are consistently buying products that are organic, or light,
with over 70 companies worldwide. We’ve developed extremely
or healthy, we know they're health-conscious. By analysing their
sophisticated methods of extracting and linking information to
customer data, you get a true understanding of the proportion of
discover what retailers need to know.
people for whom it's a very significant decision driver, compared to those with a more average consumption pattern - and what's more,
Measurable results
you know exactly which items they buy and how they shop. This
We know that retailers who understand their customers better
helps you make the correct decisions when stocking your store.
through data, and who can then use the results to improve their decisions, have a significant competitive advantage. Customer-
Improving on traditional methods
centricity can in fact deliver a sustainable 3% to 5% incremental
Another advantage of customer analytics is that they help you
increase in sales and profits. Of course, a lot of companies will
avoid making expensive mistakes. For example, the standard way
promise numbers like this, but if you build analytics into your
of rationalising your product range has always been to rank the
approach, you can set a target based on actual data rather than a
items top to bottom by sales or profit, and then delist the bottom
'best guess' scenario. And you can track it exactly. It’s an excellent
performers. Walmart has a published case study in which it delisted
way to mitigate risk, because you’re using very solid information.
these items using the traditional method but found that sales were
Let’s face it, nobody in retail today has a tolerance for spending
going down. Using extensive analytics, it researched the reasons
money without demonstrating measurable return.
and found that some of the items delisted had very high loyalty or were unique to certain very high-spending customers. And if you
From insight to action
start delisting items that customers care about, you can lose a visit
You can have the greatest insights in the world, but if you can't
or a series of visits. By analysing data from their loyalty programme,
translate them into a very specific decision or tactic, you get no
retailers can make much more accurate, fact-based decisions on
value from them. A lot of companies can create customer insights,
what to delist and what to keep.
and others have built specific tools around aspects like price optimisation, assortment or promotional effectiveness, but the
Retailers have the treasure chest…
connection between these different areas is often lacking. This
Every retailer has some kind of data, whether it’s transactional
essential, actionable connection is a unique feature of what we
data, customer data or the rich mixture of data you get from a
offer. Crucially, we also think like retailers – which isn’t surprising,
well-used loyalty programme. Some of it has been around for
considering many people on our team have spent years in retail. We
a very long time, yet it’s often barely used. If you consider that
design solutions for the realities of retail. We’re practitioners, not
a typical supermarket may carry 25,000 to 100,000 items, with
consultants or analysts. There’s simply no sense in causing analysis-
people shopping there 2 to 4 times a week, it obviously generates
paralysis or information overload.
a lot of information. But in most companies, the data is either not accessible, it's very disparate, or it's very complicated for the retailer
A guided approach
to look through all the data and actually find insights.
The average retailer within trading or merchandising is making
38
INTERVIEw
“Customer-centricity can deliver a 3% to 5% incremental increase in sales and profits. Sustainably.” million-dollar decisions every day, so we don’t just throw them a
ideal opportunity to offer this, but it’s vital to make yours stand out.
bunch of data and walk away. Instead, if someone’s looking to make
Consumers are bombarded with choice when it comes to loyalty
a pricing decision, we say “Here’s the data, here’s what it means,
cards, so they will only use yours if it offers compelling, truly
here's a recommended price and here's what the impact is going
differentiated value to them as an individual. And you can only do
to be.” It’s a practical, data-driven approach to an existing process.
that if you have that specific knowledge.
It's helping retailers do what they do already a bit better, a bit more easily, with the right tools. We also empower retailers by delivering
To win in the long run, become a leader now
insights into desktop tools that merchants can use themselves.
The ability to truly understand your best customers and to adapt
By enabling them to integrate such insights into their teams and
your value proposition to their needs can make a significant
processes, their own capabilities are often totally transformed.
difference to your bottom line, but it doesn’t happen overnight – you need to work at it. Also, it’s a daunting task to try to make sense
Your own private competitive advantage
of all the data yourself. But it’s an unavoidable fact that customer
Customer analytics isn’t a replacement for traditional methods like
analytics is becoming a core part of competing. Think about
market research, but it does complement them in an extraordinarily
Moore's Law, in which the productivity of technology doubles
effective way. You still need to understand market trends, market
every 12-18 months. This is a race, and it's incredibly important to
share, demographics and so on, but remember: each of your
get into it soon. So it’s crucial to pick an analytics partner flexible
competitors can get access to the exact same information. However,
enough to adjust their model to your business and to evolve with
if you can connect your own individual data set to other sources
you over time.
of knowledge, and use the information effectively, that gives you a unique advantage.
Join the quantum shift I believe that the way in which retailing is organised in the
Relevance is king
future will shift from being very product-centric to very
Consumers have less and less time – or money – to waste on
customer-centric. Instead of “Pile it high and watch it fly”, the
stores that don’t meet their needs closely enough. To retain
accepted wisdom will become “We have customers; let's find
and grow your appeal to higher-value customers in your area,
products”. And to take this further, the next logical step will be
relevance is the name of the game. If you've got a store with lots
to say “Let’s deliver the right product for the right customer at
of young families, carrying an assortment with healthy weekday
the right price in the right channel”.
meals for young children is very important, whereas for a store
The age of the consumer is already upon us. Consumers have
highly concentrated in the urban market, it's much more about
more power and choice than ever, and they are demanding
convenience for professionals on the go. But you need to go further
greater relevance from every brand touchpoint. The better we
than this segmented approach, and move towards much more
understand them, the better we can cater to their needs, in a
individualised relevance. A good loyalty programme gives you an
virtuous circle that benefits all of us. ■
40
41
Loyalty Insights
Loyalty Insights
Surprisingly few companies know what loyalty actually means to their business How can you measure what you can’t define?
99% of marketing managers agree that loyalty is a strategic priority 1
CEOs see customer loyalty as a more significant challenge to focus on than profit growth 2
Top 10 challenges faced by CEOs 1. Excellence in execution 2. Consistent strategic execution by top management 3. Sustained and steady top-line growth
4. Customer loyalty
only 25% of marketing
definitions:
3
managers confirmed they have a formal definition of loyalty Less than Less than
30% 50% measure both emotional & transactional loyalty
5. Speed, flexibility, adaptability to change
measure how customer loyalty affects performance outcomes
loyalty? One of the most widely accepted formal definitions is as follows: “A deeply held commitment to rebuy or re-patronise a preferred product/service consistently in the future, thereby causing repetitive same-brand or same brand-set purchasing, despite situational influences and marketing efforts having the potential to cause switching behaviour.”
emotional A perceived unique relationship which results in customers feeling affection for and a bond with a brand Net Promoter Score (NPS)
6. Corporate reputation for quality products/services
The overwhelming majority of firms view customer loyalty as a top
7. Stimulating innovation/creativity/enabling
strategic priority, yet only one in four has a formal definition of customer
transactional
loyalty. ‘Customer satisfaction’ and ‘Likelihood to recommend’ are the two
Actions taken by customers which defend
entrepreneurship 8. Profit growth
most tracked measures. Surprisingly, only a few firms have sophisticated
9. Improving productivity
analytical capabilities and only half examine how loyalty influences
10. Government regulation
financial business outcomes.
These insights are mainly based on data gathered through in-depth interviews with 92 senior-level marketing managers across a variety of industries, principally in the United States. Marketing managers were chosen in preference to top executives as they manage the customer experience within most organisations. However, the perspective of top CEOs is also included, as this has been captured in other studies mentioned within the wide-ranging research report quoted here.
and reinforce the relationship toward a brand, e.g. repeat purchase behaviour Purchase frequency, Share of wallet
1: Source: Akzoy L, Journal of Service Management Vol.24, No.4, 2013 2: Source: 2010 CEO Challenge Study, Adams, 2010. NB: Challenges in bold have moved up in the rankings since this report was first published 3: Source: Akzoy L, Journal of Service Management Vol.24, No.4, 2013 4: Source: Oliver, 1999
4
42
43
barcelona special
barcelona special
l'Eixample p38 Gràcia p33
el born p33
el raval p34
el gothic p33 poblenou p38
barceloneta p37 La Sagrada Família
arts hotel
Sarrià-Sant Gervasi
les corts
Montjuïc
Sants-Montjuïc
olympic city
airport
la rambla
Neighbourhoods in Barcelona
Barcelona is a city of many faces. Walk back into history when you enter the Gothic neighbourhood, eat tapas in the fishing neighbourhood of Barceloneta, enjoy the creativity of the young artists in Gracià or discover the mecca of the gay scene in Eixample. Like to get acquainted with citizens of the world in the immigrant neighbourhood of Ravel? Prefer to rub shoulders with the rich & famous in Sarrià? Why not do both? Join us on a trip through the different characterful neighbourhoods of this unique seaport.
45
barcelona special
El Gòtic: the vibrant heart of the city
acquainted with Barcelona’s artistic circle, this is the place to be.
Barri Gòtic, the Gothic neighbourhood, is the historical centre of
The residents’ limitless creativity and the local community spirit
Barcelona and is sometimes called “the Barcelona of days gone
combine to spark wonderful summer neighbourhood parties.
by”. In actual fact, the city of Barcelona as we know it today is a patchwork of joined-together villages. Barcelona itself originally
The village of Gràcia
extended no further than the Ciutat Vella (Old Town) district
After the Eixample neighbourhood had been assimilated into the
based around the Gothic neighbourhood. Everything else was
expanding city, it was the turn of the surrounding villages. Gràcia
either built or joined on later. That’s why El Gòtic has long been
was the first village to be added to Barcelona as the city continued
regarded as the heart of the city.
to grow. The street Passeig de Gràcia, which previously linked the village of Gràcia to the city of Barcelona, still bears witness to its
How Barcelona developed
past function, and the village feeling in this authentic old work-
In the Middle Ages, the ancient seaport was extended by building
ing-class area has never entirely disappeared.
upon sites of Roman remains. The Old Town and the Gothic neighbourhood at its core came into being, along with the El
Artistic talent
Raval, El Born and La Barceloneta neighbourhoods. The oldest
This hip part of town has always attracted artistic young people.
part of Barcelona’s port also dates from this era, together with
It’s a lively area of the city where new ideas are born all around
the areas running from La Rambla to Via Laietana and from the
you. You can see that from all the art galleries, novel boutiques,
port to the Ronda de Sant Pere.
arty clothing design stores, alternative shops, theatres and – of course – the alternative cinema Verdi Park, where you can enjoy
Tourist centre
the rare privilege of viewing films in the original version. This is
You can come across centuries-old alleys and buildings while
also a popular neighbourhood for expats and other foreigners,
wandering around the small, narrow streets of the Gothic
although you tend to find high-flyers and high-earners mainly in
neighbourhood. Walking through this district is literally like
the Vía Augusta on the other side of the neighbourhood..
taking a step back into history. Unsurprisingly, Barri Gòtic is packed with monuments and places of interest, making it and its adjoining neighbourhoods in the Ciutat Vella the tourist
Highlights: Cinemapark Verdí - Parc Guëll - Plaza del Sol - Plaza del Diamanto Neighbourhood: Gràcia Metro: L3 Fontana
centre of Barcelona. The whole district offers an extensive selection of shops, restaurants and nightlife, ranging from fun cafés to chic nightclubs.
El Born: trendy parties in the Old Town Fashionistas, hip young people and lovers of Catalan cuisine,
Highlights: Barcelona Cathedral - Catalan parliament and town hall at Plaza Sant Jaume I - Plaça Reial - Temple d´August - La Rambla - Els Quatre Gats Neighbourhood: El Gòtic Metro: L3 (Drassanes) or L4 (Jaume I)
Gràcia: a village atmosphere and full of arty types
don’t go to Barcelona without visiting El Born! Whether you’re after an exclusive item of clothing from an up-to-the-minute designer, want to sample the trendy nightlife in atmospheric cafés and luxurious cocktail bars, or simply want to taste the very best that Catalan gastronomy has to offer, you can find it
Once a village, always a village! Nowhere else in Barcelona is
all in El Born nowadays. But it wasn’t always so in this medieval
there such a lively village feeling as in the Gràcia neighbourhood,
neighbourhood.
where people exchange friendly greetings and the latest gossip on the streets. Carefree children still play together on the many
Medieval streets
squares just as they did in years gone by. If you want to get
El Born came into being in the 14th century, when it was
46
barcelona special
mainly a neighbourhood of sailors, merchants and crafts-
Catalan gastronomy
men. The area is part of Ciutat Vella, the oldest city district of
Food lovers will be delighted by the delicious culinary
Barcelona, and the names of its streets recall the trades that
delights served here. El Born is packed with contemporary
were practised locally: silversmiths, milliners and perfumers
restaurants, tapas bars, vegetarian restaurants and other
were numerous. Richer townsfolk lived in luxurious homes in
eateries serving everything from tasty dishes of the day to
Carrer de Montcada, just a short walk from the city guilds.
culinary masterpieces from the region. Sit back and allow yourself to be surprised by the choice, the creativity and
An unsavoury area
the love with which food in the Old Town is prepared. And if
Nowadays, El Born is the place to come for the latest fashion,
you’re already feeling full after a delicious meal, just stretch
cultural or culinary trends. You wouldn’t suspect that until the
out on the grass in the Parc de la Ciutadella.
end of the 1980s, it was a rough area of town that you would do better to avoid. Its decline had begun a century earlier, when Barcelona’s expansion resulted in the creation of the new neighbourhood l´Eixample. The richer townspeople deserted El Born to live in l´Eixample, while their less fortunate neigh-
Highlights: Santa Maria del Mar, the ‘Cathedral of the Sea’ - Picasso Museum Parc de la Ciutadella - Café el Convent Neighbourhood: El Born Metro: L4 (Jaume)
bours remained behind. Over the years, the neighbourhood
El Raval: multicultural from top to toe
slowly turned into a slum district of dark, neglected medieval
If you want to get to know people and cultures from all over the
alleys that had lost most of their original charm.
world, just come to El Raval. It’s home to people from dozens of different nationalities, who have each enriched it with their own
A hip neighbourhood
unique traditions, cultures and culinary specialities.
Things only changed when Barcelona started getting ready to host the 1992 Olympic Games. The entire neighbourhood
A neighbourhood of newcomers
was thoroughly renovated in order to rid it of its decadent
Pakistanis, Chinese, Hindoestanis, South Americans and
appearance. For instance, a trendy new market – el Mercat de
Moroccans are just a few of the townspeople you will find here.
Santa Caterina – was opened in the adjacent area of La Rib-
El Raval has a thoroughly foreign character, which it didn’t
era (which has now been amalgamated with El Born). The im-
just acquire over the last few years. When the medieval city of
provements were quickly spotted both by the locals and by a
Barcelona started its expansion in the 14th century, El Raval
fresh stream of tourists, thereby encouraging entrepreneurs
(‘the outskirts’) was the first district to be built after El Gòtic. The
to start their business here. Pretty fast, the slum district was
neighbourhood is located between the Ramblas and Parallel.
transformed into the hippest neighbourhood in Barcelona! Catalan farmers & Spanish migrants Exclusive designer boutiques
Around the time of the industrial revolution and of the
Take yourself for a fabulous stroll along the Paseo del Borne,
urbanisation accompanying it, large numbers of Catalan
past the Cathedral of the Sea. Or treat yourself to some window
farmers left the countryside and came to Barcelona in search
shopping in one of the exclusive designer boutiques situated in
of factory work. Lots of them set up home in the new neigh-
the small street that winds around the Picasso Museum. They’re
bourhood of El Raval. Centuries later, in the 1960s and 1970s,
simply packed with young fashion designers. Ask them to
when the Catalan economy had become the engine keeping
design a must-have leather bag or a pair of shoes as individual
the Spanish economy running, impoverished Spaniards from
as you are. Or select an original item of clothing from one of the
other parts of the country followed their example. The first
boutiques that’s caught your eye.
stream of immigrants was therefore mainly a national
49
barcelona special
Stretching over nearly 5km of sandy coastline, Barcelona's beaches attract sun-seekers from March to November.
phenomenon, and it’s still the case today that many people
in 1719, to make room for this construction project, a number
from other parts of Spain live in Barcelona.
of homes in La Ribera had to come down. Lots of residents suddenly found themselves on the street. Known as ´sin
Art & designer hotels
techos´(homeless), they were not offered any replacement
When the Museum of Modern Art (MACBA) was opened in
dwellings, but were left to their fate. This situation only slowly
1995, this marked a revival in the neighbourhood’s fortunes.
started to change in 1753, when construction actually began.
El Raval’s own Rambla was created, and the Catalan and Spanish townsfolk gradually returned to the area. Today, El
Former island
Raval contains an agreeable mixture of immigrants, locals
The fishing village of Barceloneta belongs to the old part of
and tourists. During the day, it’s delightful to sit on one of
Barcelona (Ciutat Vella) and owes the ground it stands on to
the benches in the Rambla del Raval and watch the world go
the reclamation of Maians Island, which used to lie just off
by. One of the top tourist attractions is El Gato (the cat), the
the coast of the old town. When John II, the King of Aragon,
bronze sculpture created by the artist Botello that tourists
wanted to connect the Roman harbour to the town in 1477,
can’t resist photographing. A visit to the MACBA shouldn’t
the basis of the fishing village was laid, although the island
be missed, before stretching out at one of the many café
itself remained until 1640.
terraces that El Raval offers. The luxurious designer hotel is a great place to stay while you explore the various artistic
What is now La Rambla used to be the wide river Besós, which
centres located in former monasteries or allow yourself to be
ran beween the sea, the old town and the island. In order to
tempted by a worldwide choice of cuisines.
expand the port area and protect it from fierce waves, the island was joined to the town at the point where the Estación
Highlights: Rambla del Raval - El Gato - MACBA Neighbourhood: El Raval Metro: L3 (Drassanes)
de Francía railway station now stands. Being right next to the port, this new part of town was an ideal place for sailors and port workers to live. And that was how the original fishing
Barceloneta: from fishing district to tourists’ beach paradise
district of Barceloneta came into being. Beach paradise for tourists
Fish and beach. Those were the characteristics of the former
Today, most of the fishermen have made way for hordes
island that was transformed into the fishing neighbourhood
of tourists who enjoy spending all day strolling down the
of Barceloneta in the 18th century. Nowadays, you can go
boulevard and La Rambla, sunning themselves on the beach
there to enjoy the sunshine, some delicious tapas, or an
or lounging around at leisure in one of the many chirinquitos
unselfconscious stroll over the long boulevard. The local
(beach restaurants). And yet not much has changed in essence:
fishermen have been replaced by tourists from every corner
sun, sea, beach, the salty sea air and the delicious fish dishes
of the earth, and yet Barceloneta still mainly revolves around
are still what Barceloneta is all about.
the sun, the sea, the beach and the fabulous fresh fish. Get to know it yourself by walking to the end of La Rambla, where Homeless
the statue of Columbus stands. It’s from this Catalan harbour that
The origins of the neighbourhood are less pleasant. At the start
he left to discover America. Then move on to visit the Maritime
of the 18th century, the residents of the former neighbourhood
Museum, where you can learn about Barcelona’s naval strength
La Ribera (now part of El Born) were turned out of their homes
in the past, the present, and the future. The extensive seafaring
when king Philip V decided to build the Ciutadella fortress. So
collection is located in Reial Drassanes, the former shipbuilding
50
barcelona special
yard for the royal fleet. If you’re curious about Catalan harbour
areas would do the social and physical health of the residents
architecture at the end of the 19th century, the fascinating
no good. He also envisioned a city neighbourhood in which
historical museum of Catalonia (Museu d'Història de Catalunya)
both the elite and the factory workers would feel at home.
is very much worth a visit The German artist Rebecca Horn gifted her sculpture Homenatge a la Barceloneta (Ode to Barceloneta)
Modernist open-air museum
to the City of Barcelona on the occasion of the 1992 Olympic
After Cerdá’s death in 1876, a variety of architects eagerly
Games. Consisting of a stack of rusty cubes, it has become a
got to work on the prestigious construction project. The rich
favourite place to meet.
decoration with round shapes, elegant façades and lavish floral patterns are characteristic of the Catalan modernism that developed at the end of the 19th century as a variant of
Highlights: Hommage a Barceloneta - Estación de Francía Museu d'Història de Catalunya - Colon monument - Museu Maritím Neighbourhood: Barceloneta Metro: L4 Barceloneta
the French art nouveau and German Jugendstil movements of the time. Even today, L´eixample is the place to enjoy Catalan modernism.
L´Eixample: the first extension of Barcelona The l´Eixample neighbourhood is sometimes jokingly called
L´Eixample is split into two residential areas, Eixample Esquerra
the New York of southern Europe because, just like the Big
(to the left) and Eixample Dreta (to the right), separated by
Apple, it is constructed from manzanas. These octagonal
Passeig de Gràcia, the most expensive shopping street in all of
residential blocks lend this spacious neighbourhood the
Spain. This fashionable shopping promenade with its modern-
characteristic appearance of a large metropolis. L´Eixample
ist street lamps is in itself a wonderful sight to behold. In the
(the extension) is indeed the most densely populated
middle of the neighbourhood you find the Sagrada Família, the
neighbourhood in Barcelona – and even in the whole of Spain.
masterpiece of the best-known modernist architect, Antoní Gaudí. Here you can also find other well-known modernist
Plan Cerdá
houses such as Casa Battló en Casa Milà. In fact, l’Eixample is
The central part of the town, with a surface area of 7.46 km , was 2
one huge modernist open-air museum.
designed by the Catalan architect and town planning specialist Ildefonso Cerdá. At the beginning of the 19th century, way ahead of his time, he came up with the idea of the neighbourhood of the future: a startlingly skilful way to expand Barcelona. Cerdá developed a concept involving conveniently arranged, broad, straight streets with octagonal residential blocks. It would be able to cope with future traffic loads, offer a healthy residential
Highlights: Passeig de Gràcia - Eixample Esquerra - La Ronda de Sant Antoní La Plaza Gaudi Eixample Dreta: La Sagrada Familia - La Casa Milà - La Casa Batllò - La Rambla de Cataluña - La Plaza de Cataluña - El Teatro Nacional de Cataluña - El Auditorio de Barcelona - La Casa de les Punxes - La Plaza de las Glorias Catalanas - La Plaza de Francesc Macià Passeig de Gracià: Metro: L1/L3 Passeig de Gracià
5 facts about the Sagrada Familia • Work on the Basilica of the Sagrada Familia (the Church of the Holy Family) commenced in 1884 and continues to this day
built within the residential areas, have enough space for local
Poblenou: from industrial site to high-tech innovation hotspot
covered markets, provide an even distribution of services for the
Where textile factories used to fill the air with smoke now
• There will eventually be eighteen towers. Eight have been constructed so far.
residents, and have a separate industrial area.
stand high-tech buildings full of staff developing, testing and
They represent Jesus Christ, the Virgin Mary, the 4 evangelists and the 12 apostles
implementing advanced information and communication
• Gaudi spent 40 years working on the Sagrada Familia. He died 3 days after a
and living environment, enable green gardens and parks to be
This was the concept of how the new Barcelona should look,
systems. The Catalan textile industry – which was formally
according to Cerdá. He was convinced that cities should
a booming business – seems to have passed its crown to the
primarily be built around the needs of their residents, and that
up-and-coming internet industry. The Poblenou neighbour-
building uninhabitable homes and large factories in residential
hood is at the heart of innovation in Barcelona!
• The Sagrada Familia is expected to be completed on the 10th of June, 2026, in honour of the 100-year anniversary of Gaudi’s death
tram accident, and is buried within the Basilica’s Crypt • Visited by 3 million people a year, it is Barcelona’s most popular tourist attraction
53
barcelona special
Industry. That’s what the Poblenou neighbourhood, in the
cal but abandoned factory buildings have also been renovated
north-west of the city, has always revolved around. The main
to create contemporary lofts, multimedia educational centres
industrial area is located in the city district of Sant Martí, the
and art workshops. Just take a peek into the luxury shopping
original name of the neighbourhood, and originated when a
centre of Diagonal, or into the modern, sustainably architectonic
large part of the existing industry, residents and agrarian com-
Cibernarium building where internet technology is taught, to
merce moved there from San Adrian de Besòs.
view the transformation. Pay a visit to Barcelona Activa, where new companies are created while you watch, or to the HUB, the
High-tech ´22@´
knowledge centre for design, where the textile museum and the
For many years, the previous industrial area lay deserted and
modern museum of decorative art are housed, for an impression
discarded, until Sant Martí was completely refurbished in 2006
of what this futuristic neighbourhood has to offer. ■
due to the innovative ‘project 22@’. In consultation with the local residents, the name Poblenou was chosen. Within the past few years, lots of new, high-tech companies have grown up along the Avinguda Diagonal boulevard. Classi-
getting around Metro Barcelona’s metro is fast, easy and straightforward and covers most of the city. Maps are available from tourist offices or any metro station. Buses The main hub for buses, and particularly night buses, is Plaça Catalunya. Pick up a bus map at the subterranean tourist office there. Trams Though expansion is planned, for now the trams are of limited use to visitors, apart from the line that runs from the Parc de Ciutadella to Diagonal-Mar via the Plaça de les Glòries.
Highlights: Disseny Hub (HUB) - Torre Agbar - Gloriès - Barcelona Activa Museu Can Framis- Cementeri de l’Est - Forum Neighbourhood: Poblenou Metro: L1 Gloriès of Llacuna
54
55
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
In 2004, Justin King was appointed CEO of the UK grocer Sainsbury’s, which was at the time described as “in danger of becoming a car crash of a business”. By the time he left 10 years later, he had increased shopper numbers from 14m to 24m and achieved ten years of consistent profits growth. How did he do it? We interviewed him to find out.
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
Making Sainsbury’s Great Again Justin King, who stepped down as CEO of Sainsbury’s in the summer, recalls ten years of positive change.
justin, why do you think Sainsbury’s chose you as CEO in 2004?
generally, the execution of change is the big challenge.
Sainsbury’s had been in long-term decline: it had been a family-
than 10 years by the time I arrived, so the problems were
run business till the mid-1990s and then it had had a succession
long-standing and deep-rooted. Sainsbury’s had tried to invest
of internal chief executives. Every company eventually reaches
its way through these challenges, but the problem with that
the point where they think that outside blood is what they really
kind of approach in the retail business is that if you for even
need, and Sainsbury’s was looking for someone with retail and
a minute put customers to one side, which heavy investment
manufacturing experience who would understand the quality side of
programmes of that nature tend to do, people will choose to
the business as well as how to compete on price. I seemed to fit the
shop elsewhere. So my job was firstly to make things clearly
description.
better for customers, and then to invite them back. We called
Sainsbury’s had actually been losing market share for more
the turnaround plan “Making Sainsbury's Great Again” because
Your predecessor, Sir Peter Davis, invested £3b in infrastructure – was that wise?
customers and colleagues all said the same thing: this was a
Particularly in retail businesses, but also in businesses
and they wanted it to be that way again.
once-great business that they loved working and shopping in,
56
57
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
Which key issues did you tackle?
they wanted to be able to do that again. I'm a great believer
Without availability, price and quality, you don't have a retail
that great communication follows great execution: you can't
business. If it's not on the shelf, you can't sell it. Sainsbury’s
run an advert saying you're better if you're not. So the key to
didn't have the right range or competitive pricing. Our
our success was that we'd covered the bases. We knew that by
strategy was to fix the basics, create universal appeal, and create
the time we started presenting ourselves to customers this way,
a customer-focused culture. Availability and quality were part-
we'd already materially changed for the better. We were pretty
and-parcel of fixing the basics: making sure the supply chain
confident that we could get them back in, and it worked.
worked, that the shops were well-stocked, that we had enough a lot to do with pricing: it was about enabling customers to do
How did you motivate your staff during this period?
all their shopping with us.
I'm a great believer in bonuses, and the bonus scheme we
people on the till at all times, and so on. Universal appeal had
introduced was universal: everyone in the company was in it,
How did you tell the public about the changes?
and the targets were the same for me as for everyone else. When
Actually, the whole turnaround started with asking a million
a full-time employee was around £300: 3 times more than the
customers what they thought we should do to make it a better
static £100 one-off payment at Christmas that the bonus scheme
business. We wrote to them, and amazingly, 250,000 of them wrote
replaced. Over my 10 years of tenure, the scheme paid out about
back. It's still, we believe, the greatest response that any company –
£700m. It was a highly successful way of aligning the interests of
certainly in the UK – has ever received to a customer mailing. They
our colleagues with those of the company. Of course, when you
told us what we needed to do, plus of course we'd involved them in
take away something that's certain with something that's attached
the turnaround of their store.
to performance, some people don't like it. But I think it’s fair, and it
That's why the first marketing campaign we did – which was
worked very well for Sainsbury's.
"I don't care what the numbers say: what do I tell the customer?"
we achieved the targets in that first year, the average payout to
actually 18 months into the turnaround – was entitled “Try cheek. That “something new” could be the item we featured,
How did you compete with the rise of Tesco and Asda? That's where universal appeal came in. We needed to sharpen
What influence have loyalty cards such as Nectar had at Sainsbury's?
The secret of Nectar's success has been the combination of loyalty
but it could equally be Sainsbury’s itself. It recalled the fact that Sainsbury's had become famous for offering interesting ingredients
our prices, and we did so by reducing them quite significantly
They've become more important. Nectar had been launched
about 5 years ago. It's very visible, very tangible, and it reflects their
and new experiences, and people also remembered the “Sainsbury’s:
in several tranches over 2004/5/6. We also needed to improve
shortly before I arrived and actually, it had had a very negative
shopping. So if they've just bought five different pieces of cheese,
everyone's favourite ingredient” advertising of the 1980s. And what
the quality of our in-store environment, so we started a huge
effect on the business at the time, because it replaced a previous
you can give the customer a voucher off a bottle of red wine,
we were effectively saying to customers who weren’t shopping with
programme to refurbish and extend the stores: Sainsbury's today
loyalty programme that was very popular back in the 1990s.
because the chances are that they're going to have a cheese board
us was “Give us another go”.
has the most modern, best-invested store network of any of the
But the deal with customers is very straightforward: they get
and invite some people round.
major supermarkets in the UK. We also reignited our product
something extra – loyalty points – which they value hugely and
What effect did the recovery programme have on your staff?
development function and started innovating in own label, with a
often save up to do their Christmas shopping with. They also
fantastic spokesman – Jamie Oliver – to sell that story.
understand you've acquired their data, their information. And
Why did you decide to go into convenience stores rather than hypermarkets?
I have an inability to use the 's' word; they're colleagues. The
The point about retail that you should always remember is
what customers tell you is that they don't mind you having their
When I was at Asda back in the 1990s, I brought the Walmart
main reason the slogan worked for colleagues and customers
that on the whole, all the money you need to drive your sales is
data if you do something useful with it for them. If you're just
Supercentre to the UK, so I knew the hypermarket format well
is that it described something they believed in. Colleagues
already in your shops. The problem is, it walks back out. The
going to sell that data to someone else who's going to market
and didn't think it was right for Sainsbury's, whose core business
believed that if we made Sainsbury’s great again, customers
main thing was that we needed to get people who were coming
things to them that they don't want, they get very upset about
is selling fresh food. We decided early on that we wouldn't open
would come back and shop, and customers said they'd love to
to us a lot to complete their shopping with us, and those who
that. But if you use that data to give them vouchers and extra
a shop where non-food takes up more space than food. We took
come back because they used to enjoy shopping with us and
were coming to us infrequently to come to us more often.
value on things that they do want, they love it.
the view that customers doing their weekly grocery shop wanted
something new today,” and it was quite deliberately tongue-in-
points with instant coupons at the till – which Sainsbury's launched
58
59
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
to be able to see their food, and not be forced to walk through the
All the growth in the next 5 or 6 years will be in discounters, online
non-food if they didn't want to buy it. I remember in my early
or convenience stores. That sounds dramatic, but it still means that
days, when I worked at Mars, I was responsible for Co-ops, and
by 2020, the market will be around £200b, and £140b of it will still
shoppers used to hate that forced flow. And it was clear to us that
be in supermarkets, just as it is today. On the one hand, you could
our customers wanted to shop for fresh food more frequently – by
say it's going to flatline, but it still means that supermarkets will
definition – so convenience stores were a logical response to that.
retain the substantial part – say 65% to 70% – of all the shopping we do for groceries. To paraphrase Mark Twain, the death of the
What’s your view of online shopping?
supermarket has been greatly exaggerated.
When I arrived, the online business had already started and it was only been as the technology has developed that it's become a better
Any advice for CEOs and budding CEOs, retail ones in particular?
experience for customers, with improved availability and more
My constant drumbeat at Sainsbury's was always the same, which
reliable and accurate deliveries, but online tends to get slightly
was that you need to put the customer and the colleague at the
overstated. Even today, when I ask people what proportion of food
centre of everything you do. Everyone you ask will say “I already
is sold online, lots of people think it's 20-30% of the market, but
do that”, but I'm always surprised that quite often you confront
it's actually under 5%. And very few people only shop online.
people about small things in the business, and you ask "Where's the
clear that it was already important to some customers. But really it's
customer in this?" and they look at you quite critically as if you'd
Why is Sainsbury’s starting a joint venture in the UK with Netto?
asked a trick question. To give you an example, quite often if we'd
Just as with online shopping, we decided to make a discount format
write to me and ask me why. And I'd say the same thing to the
available for a very simple reason: our customers wanted it. Netto
buyer every time: "Tell me what I should tell the customer." In the
brings in the expertise of running a discount format, which it
early days, the buyers would look at me oddly and would just say
does successfully in many countries, and Sainsbury’s knows and
"The numbers say we should be delisting it". And I'd say, "I don't
understands the UK consumer.
care what the numbers say – what do I tell the customer?" And if
delisted a product, customers who were loyal to that product would
you can write back to the customer and say "We have delisted that
Did you make any mistakes along the way?
product because it didn't sell very well, but we think this product
The culture we developed at Sainsbury's was of taking sensible risks
is much better and here's a voucher for it, we hope you'll try it and
when customers and colleagues told us it was the right thing to do;
we think you'll find it's better than the one you used to buy", that's
a risk worth taking. The challenge when you get something wrong
putting the customer at the heart of every decision you make. And if
is not whether you've made a mistake, but whether you're prepared
you do that, you won't go wrong. ■
Award-winning journalist and congress host Alex Thomson, who will be moderating the RLC 2015 in Barcelona, speaks his mind.
to admit to it, address it, put things right and not make the same
Alex Thomson has been the moderator of the Consumer Goods Forum since 2005. He is a
mistake twice. We encouraged our people to think that way and
familiar figure in British TV news, both as an award-winning correspondent and anchor on
as a consequence, I think the business moved faster. Big ideas like moving to 100% Fair Trade bananas, or deciding to sponsor the Paralympics, came out of that culture of people being prepared to take risks. There were plenty of mistakes along the way, but I think it's pointless to start talking about individual ones.
Justin King Justin was named Most Admired Business Leader by Management Today as well as Britain’s Most Impressive Businessman in the IPSOS-MORI Captains of Industry Report.
ITN's Channel 4 News. He combines reporting on major national and international stories, and war coverage, with his role in the TV studio as the presenter of in-depth news stories. Alex is a regular contributor to national newspapers and magazines, writing articles on media issues as well as news items arising out of his international roving reporter's brief. He also regularly fronts full-length current affairs documentaries for Channel 4's Dispatches strand. Outside ITN, Alex is in demand both as a speaker and facilitator for national and international business and
Where do you see most of the growth in food retail coming from?
Justin King will be speaking at the Retail Loyalty Congress 2015
policy conferences. His inquisitive mind and journalistic training encourage him to pose the questions that would otherwise remain unasked.
60
61
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
"I'm constantly struck by the sheer difficulty for retailers in expanding into some other markets"
diabetes, so I think that whole issue is absolutely fascinating, as is
food which, if you eat a lot of it, will do you harm. But it's very,
the seemingly humble issue of food waste. We're wasting beyond
very easy to go over the level of what is frankly good or safe for
a third of the food on the plate, and almost a half in terms of the
you. It's a huge thing, and it's not going to go away.
production and supply line – it's absolutely catastrophic.
Alex, how did you get involved with the food retail industry?
They´re thinking the unthinkable, which you can do when you're
I'm also constantly struck by the sheer difficulty for retailers in
a family concern and a global leader in your market and you have
expanding into some other markets. Just look at Tesco´s move into
So in the future, do you think certain foods will be sold like cigarette packets?
Completely by accident! About 9 years ago, I got a call from
no shareholders. Of course the counter-argument to that is: yes
the States with Fresh & Easy. The American market is very difficult,
It's possible! They could be behind the grille. And retailers do
my agent, who said `We've got a problem: the moderator we´ve
you can, but you don't have to. And they actually have.
and the German market's virtually impossible. It´s a mystery to
themselves know very well what to do and not to do. It's less of a
booked for CIES (the old name for the Consumer Goods
me. When you see a monolith, a global player like Tesco, which
problem now, but when they blatantly exploited pester power by
frankly fell flat on its face, it kind of makes you think "If they can't
putting all the sweets near the checkout, so that any child would
days' notice, I had to go to Paris and chair it for 3 days. So I
What triggers do you use to get the room going?
do it, then who can?" I wonder if it was a cultural issue – what did
say "Mummy! Mummy! Mummy!", I really don't think that was
said yes and next thing I know, I'm sitting on stage with 1,000
It all depends on the situation. If you're coming on with someone
they misread? As for Terry Leahy, the great man of Tesco, is history
acting in the customer's interest. And I think we could all grow up a
delegates, next to the bosses of Coca-Cola, Carrefour and
who happens to be my next-door-neighbour in my village – Jamie
actually rewriting that now? Was what he handed over to Phil
little bit about that sort of thing.
Proctor & Gamble. And they've asked me back ever since.
Oliver – and it's immediately after the coffee break, as happened
Clarke in fact a poisoned chalice? The comings-and-goings at CEO
I knew nothing at all about food retail then and have been getting
at the CGF in Paris, you know you're going to have a full room
level are quite instructive.
deeper into it ever since, into the whole soap opera. I quickly
and it's going to be buzzing and all over the place and somewhat
discovered that manufacturers, suppliers and retailers aren't
chaotic, because that's Jamie. Knowing who you're dealing with and
Is the food industry too inwardly focused?
necessarily the best of friends. Of course, I come to it as a complete
what's coming up injects a certain energy into the room.
Yes, and extraordinarily so. There's no bigger business than food:
Is there a big divide between certain consumer movements – such as for promoting a healthier lifestyle – and what the food industry is pushing for?
outsider – I'm basically a war correspondent – so I'm beholden to
Mark Price, for instance, at Waitrose, is someone I've worked with
big food is bigger than big oil. Now, big oil can actually get away
Well I hope so, because if not, you've got a real problem. The
no one, and one of the reasons I'm there is that I can ask questions
down the years, and he's always very good value in what he's got
with being quite insular, because oil comes out at remote places,
food industry – and I include ‘from farm to fork’ here – wants
of a CEO on stage that nobody in the audience could do, because
to say. Obviously, he's got a particular standpoint, but it's always
you don't really see it, and the only real problem they have in terms
at the end of the day to turn a decent profit, and it's got a legal
it would be considered beneath you if you're a rival, and if you're
going to be an interesting and energising kind of presentation from
of customer interfaces is when fluctuations in oil prices never seem
obligation to keep its shareholders happy. The consumer industry
inside the company, it would be a seriously bad career move. So I
someone like that. And quite often, these conferences seem to be
to get passed on to the benefit of the customer at the pumps. But
has an obligation to get food both as cheaply as possible and at
operate as an outsider within an insider space.
happening during a major football tournament – in Paris we were
look at the interface between food and the public: it's huge! The
the highest quality possible. So whatever the industry says, if it's
in the middle of the World Cup. If you're in Paris and France has
whole issues of food safety, packaging, own brands versus market
working right, those goals should not be in concert with each other,
just won a football match the previous night, you'd be an idiot to
brands...it affects everyone. Then there’s the whole way in which
and something's gone a bit wrong if they are. And there's no point
get up on stage and not say anything about football.
areas of food inevitably seem to be going towards the realms of
in trying to wrap that up and pretending the food industry has got
cigarette manufacture, in terms of the battle ground for things like
the same aims as consumers – of course it doesn´t! But out of that friction should come change and energy. ■
Forum) can´t make it – could you go instead?´ With only 2
Has moderating the CGF led to any intriguing discoveries? Certainly – one of the most interesting things has been working
Has anything you´ve found out about the food retail business been an eye-opener?
traffic lighting. And there’s a huge inbuilt conservatism in the food
Centre for Food & Nutrition. They're doing lots of work at the moment on issues like sustainability, obesity, food miles,
I was surprised at the degree to which sustainability is talked
bent over backwards to make life as complicated as possible for the
food safety and nutrition. In fact, I'm chairing their upcoming
about, and the quite central place that it occupies in retailers'
poor old consumer, deliberately so.
conference at the Bocconi University of Milan in December,
thinking. I'm very interested in the moment in this growing
Let’s face it: they fought tooth and nail against a simple traffic
where they're making this big push to get the Milan Protocol
friction between regulation on 'bad food' and whether the
light system – I suspect they hate that because it's something
accepted by world leaders at Expo 2015 in Milan.
market can look after itself; whether the industry can be its own
the consumer actually understands. What they want to do
It's really interesting stuff. Barilla – the biggest pasta
watchdog. How long do we go on saying "Food which is high in
is put tiny information in very, very small lettering that
manufacturers in the world – have basically decided that they
sugar or fat content should be eaten in moderation", when that
basically most people can't physically read, and than make it
need to sell less pasta, that making money is not the only game
food is too cheap? What approach should we take? In Scandinavia
as incomprehensible as possible, and then hide it round the
in town, and that you can perhaps measure your success as
they've been dabbling in taxing fat or sugar, and the issue certainly
back of the packet anyway, and that is their way of dealing – or
a company in other ways, that you need to redefine growth.
isn't going away. We have a huge problem with obesity and
rather of not dealing – with the issue of really, really cheap
with Guido Barilla for the past 2 or 3 years on the Barilla
industry: as I see it as a consumer, the food industry seems to have
Alex Thomson His journalism has won several BAFTA and EMMY awards; two New York Film and TV Awards and in 2011/12 he was named TV Journalist of the Year by the Royal Television Society.
Alex Thomson will be moderating the Retail Loyalty Congress 2015
62
63
DIGITAL LOYALTY PROGRAMMES
DIGITAL LOYALTY PROGRAMMES
KING OF STAMPS Ever thought it might be handy if customers could collect stamps digitally? It’s already
The concept of collecting stamps that can be exchanged for
counted. In fact, during the promotion, retailers can even use Bright
happening, thanks to Bright Stamps. Developed by IceMobile, this digital stamps
desirable products or discounts isn’t new – shoppers have been
Stamps to communicate 1-to-1 with each customer, for example
doing it for years. But retailers now have the chance to offer a smart
encouraging them to get the maximum number of points required.
app is proving to be one of the most innovative and effective tools that retailers can
new alternative to the traditional paper-based collection method.
use nowadays. It’s increasing turnover, providing additional insights into individual
With Bright Stamps, customers don’t have to worry about losing
Bright Stamps makes the entire process easier and more personal.
their paper stamps or being a bit too late to exchange their fully
Connected to the customer’s loyalty card, the app enables the user
purchasing patterns, and even enabling retailers to communicate with their customers
stamped card for the sparkling new pan they wanted. It also means
to instantly see how many stamps he or she has collected. It sends
that retailers don’t have to worry about not knowing precisely how
the customer notifications after each purchase and stimulates
on a 1-to-1 basis.
many customers are participating until all the full cards have been
them to reach the reward offered before the end of the promotion.
64
65
DIGITAL LOYALTY PROGRAMMES
26%
DIGITAL LOYALTY PROGRAMMES
extra turnover thanks to Bright Stamps
This 1-to-1 engagement ensures that people who collect Bright
number of stamps they have gained after making their first
HERE’S HOW IT WORKS
to optimise the use of the data collected. With BrandLoyalty,
Stamps are more engaged with the promotion – leading them to
purchase, and is congratulated on collecting their reward after
1) The customer has the retailer’s loyalty card
IceMobile and Precima working closely as one company, all three
spend more without even realising. The mobile experience thereby
successfully completing the programme. Also, participants
2) He or she downloads the Bright Stamps app and registers for the
aspects can be integrated seamlessly.
becomes an extension of the physical shopping experience: they
who do register but haven’t yet started collecting can be sent
reinforce one another.
a reminder about the rewards awaiting them. In other words,
3) The cashier passes the loyalty card through the checkout system
supermarket chains such as Azbuka Vkusa in Russia, Coop in
each message is connected to the participant’s individual,
4) Because the card is linked to the Bright Stamps app, stamps are
Denmark and RT Mart in Taiwan. In most cases, Bright Stamps led
promotion using their loyalty card
Bright Stamps has already been successfully implemented by
DIGITAL COLLECTORS SPEND UP TO A QUARTER MORE THAN PAPER COLLECTORS
current status.
Bright Stamps works by making collectors more aware of their
Bright Stamps also offers retailers opportunities to gain an
progress within the loyalty programme and by motivating them
insight into participants’ individual shopping behaviour on a
to get more involved. It heightens the perception of how many
daily basis. For example, business intelligence can reveal how
SMOOTH IMPLEMENTATION
use Bright Stamps. This exclusive retailer, with more than
stamps they still need to reach their goal – which is why they
many people are collecting, what they are buying and which
Let’s look at the logistics. Firstly, for digital stamps to be successful,
50 stores in large Russian cities, offered its customers the
rewards are popular. There’s also the possibility for retailers
it’s essential to ensure a great on-screen user experience so that
opportunity to take part in a loyalty programme by collecting
to offer certain products for extra stamps each week, and to
users feel it’s fun and easy to take part in the programme. Secondly,
digital rather than paper stamps. Over an 18-week period,
The app is a handy, versatile tool that stimulates collection via
immediately analyse the success. Data can therefore be used
the app needs to be perfectly integrated into the checkout system.
customers received one stamp for every 250 rubles they spent.
personal notifications. For instance, each person who registers
not just to personalise the Bright Stamps app, but also to
And thirdly, it’s of extra value to the retailer if the CRM and
They could use these to get discounts of up to 93% on high-
is welcomed into the programme, is sent a reminder of the
directly raise the retailer’s turnover.
other back-office systems can be connected to the app, in order
quality pans. Natalya Chubarova, head of the retailer’s loyalty
started collecting in the first place.
automatically added to the shopper’s account
to an extra 25% increase in turnover compared with paper stamps.
5) The customer can immediately view how many stamps they have by checking Bright Stamps
BUSINESS CASE: AZBUKA VKUSA In 2013, Russia’s largest food retailer became the first to
66
67
DIGITAL LOYALTY PROGRAMMES
DIGITAL LOYALTY PROGRAMMES
BRIGHT STAMPS HAS WON 2 GLOBAL AWARDS: The Mobile Innovation Award Best use of Mobile for Customer Loyalty
programmes and CRM analytics, commented, “This loyalty
retailer’s own house style. Furthermore, the retailer may adjust it
over. For instance, retailers could launch a recipe module or a particular promotion
STARBUCKS: STRIKING GOLD WITH
programme offered a new approach to the way we interact
to fit in with their own needs by adding existing or new options, or
that is then halted when the next loyalty programme starts. These modules are also
MOBILE SOLUTIONS
with our customers. It allowed them to choose to collect
even in their own existing app. And besides this, Bright Stamps is
specially fitted to each retailer.
Starbucks is a true pioneer in the field of
stamps digitally, and it proved very popular. Customers came
continually undergoing further development in line with feedback
to the store more often and spent more money.” In fact, even
from retailers and users. This not only makes the retailer’s life
FUTURE-PROOF
QR and SMS campaigns, the Square
customers who didn’t normally take part in Azbuka Vkusa’s
easier, but also the user’s life too. After a technical assessment in
Bright Stamps is being constantly enhanced to keep it at the cutting edge of social
Wallet mobile payment app and its own
promotions decided to join in when offered Bright Stamps.
which the retailer’s existing systems and the current status of these
and technological developments. One of the possibilities being trialled is beacon
Starbucks app. It also has its own loyalty
What’s more, the digital collectors spent 25% more than the
are examined, it takes around two to three months for Bright
technology, which enables devices to communicate with one another. This could
programme: My Starbucks Rewards, which
other collectors. Thanks to these results and other factors,
Stamps to be customised, fully integrated and rolled out in-store.
be extremely interesting: it could enable retailers to become even more relevant
gives customers points if they pay with a
and to communicate more personally with each customer, thereby also enabling
Starbucks card, via the Starbucks mobile
customers to benefit from a better service.
app or with star codes. Rewards include
Bright Stamps won 2 Global Awards: The Mobile Innovation Award and Best use of Mobile for Customer Loyalty.
RELEVANT ALL YEAR ROUND
mobile marketing, using methods including
Loyalty programmes do of course have a beginning and an
complimentary refills, free snacks, birthday
TAILORED SOLUTIONS
end: promotions stop a few weeks or months after they start.
Bright Stamps is likely to always exist alongside paper stamps as an attractive alternative
discounts, personalised offers and more.
Bright Stamps is a white-label product. It comprises a number of
However, many retailers find it important to remain relevant
collecting method. It gives retailers the chance to increase their turnover, to gain more
After launching this programme, Starbucks’
standard features and a set of requirements for retailers and their
to their customers even when there’s no promotion running.
insights into individual purchasing and shopping behaviour, and to communicate on a
profits rose by 26% in the second quarter
technical partner(s) to enable it to be integrated successfully. It
That’s why Bright Stamps has been developed with various
1-to-1 basis (on a mass scale) with their customers. It’s a digital innovation whose time
of 2013 and its total turnover increased by
goes without saying that Bright Stamps may be adapted to each
functionalities that can be put into place once a promotion is
has come. Why not add it to your own loyalty shopping basket? ■
11% to $3.6 billion.
1
1
1
Increase your customers’ 1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1
Bright Stamps is an innovative digital solution that makes it possible to collect stamps digitally. With Bright Stamps you can communicate 1 to 1 1
1
1
1 1
1
1
with your customers and gain real time customer insights. Moreover this
1
1
1
new way of engaging increases spend and customer loyalty.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1 1
1
1
70
71
Lifestyle
Lifestyle
Catalonia’s Finest!
The Barcelona Chair The Barcelona Chair was designed by Ludwig Mies van der Rohe for the 1929 World Fair in Barcelona. It’s partly thanks
A Great Food Water
to this iconic piece of furniture that Van der Rohe, who was born in Aachen in 1886, became recognised as one of the
Highly effervescent, Vichy Catalàn has a remarkable mineral content of
most pioneering designers of his time.
bicarbonates, sodium, chlorine, potassium, fluoride, calcium, magnesium and lithium, giving it a very distinctive flavour. And like the finest of
Van der Rohe’s design was inspired by the
champagnes, it offers all of this taste in an extremely elegant bubble. The
characteristics of a folding chair, as can be
king of sparkling, high-mineral-content waters, Vichy Catalàn provides the perfect accompaniment to fine dining – especially as its high bicarbonate level aids digestion.
seen from the crossed chrome legs. After the World Fair ended, the chair quickly found
Celler de can Roca
its way into other buildings, especially banks and luxury offices, where it may
(Gerona, about 100km from Barcelona)
often be admired. Labelled as futuristic and trailblazing at its launch in 1929, the
Awarded as best restaurant in the world in 2013, and ranked #2 in 2014. Traditional
Barcelona Chair has lost none of its power
cuisine with a modern twist, without being
80 years on, and the design of this timeless piece still makes it a must-have object.
as futuristic as El Bulli was.
Take a look at their inspirational website: www.cellercanroca.com
INEDIT Damm
Oto Cycles
Inedit was created in 2008 by Ferran Adrià and his team of sommeliers from elBulli who believed in the need for a beer to accompany and complement
Intended for day-to-day use, Oto Cycles add a
the varied flavours found in modern gastronomy. The result was Inedit: a truly
touch of exclusivity and fun to travelling on two
unique beer made with barley malt, wheat, hops, coriander, liquorice and
wheels. These unique electric bicycles are all
orange peel. It is best served in a white wine glass (no more than half full) to
born – in Barcelona – from a passion for classic
fully appreciate its intensity and aromatic complexity.
and retro design. Just one of the charms of their handmade beauty is that you will never find two
This delicious new drink pairs perfectly with a variety of culinary creations,
identical models. Extensive customisation options
including even the most complicated ones based on citrus fruits and bitter
are available in terms of of colours, tyres, saddles,
elements. Splendid when served with starters, salads and fatty fish, its versatility
motors, batteries and other components, ensuring
also allows it to accompany bittersweet flavours and spicy sensations.
the exclusivity of each Oto Cycle.
72
INTERVIEW
In the ‘era of the new thrift’,
shopping should be enjoyable, not just cheap Although searching for discounts has become a way of life, shoppers also expect something extra from their retail interaction. BrandLoyalty’s MD Philip Spanton explains why.
Shopping for discounts has become a way of life
Consumers pay less but want more
Since the economic crisis struck, we’ve seen that the discounters
a lower-quality experience. Quite the opposite: consumers are
have taken a large slice of traditional supermarkets' business. That’s
demanding even better value than before, in all sorts of ways. They
understandable, because lots of people’s monthly grocery budget is
want to make the most of their leisure time, so food retailers are
only exceeded by their mortgage or rent payment; it's a significant
responding by offering delivery services and pick-up points. That’s
part of their family's household expenditure. But that’s led to a
a good idea, but consumers also want more for less: they can sit on
permanent cultural change too, because it’s become a regular
the couch with the TV on, flicking through and comparing prices
habit for consumers from all socioeconomic groups to shop at
at the click of a switch, or use price-comparison apps before buying.
discounters too. Thrift has become the new norm: even though the
The internet is having an impact not just by taking away sales, but
Philip Spanton began his career working for Wallace International in London, before
economy is improving, people have concerns for the longer term
also by educating the consumer on where the best value is. And
transferring to Australia where he spent the next 10 years, during the course of which he
and they don't want to spend money unnecessarily. In the UK,
sometimes this means it can be cheaper to feed the family at Pizza
helped set up TCC. He met BrandLoyalty’s CEO Robert van der Wallen whilst working in Hong
discounters have gained an extra 2% market share over the past 2
Hut or McDonald's than at home, it involves no preparation or
Kong and, after a short period spent in Japan, decided to join forces with him in 2001. Philip
years, while the big 4 supermarkets have lost about 2.5%, and we're
clearing up, and it's also a treat. So your traditional grocery store or
currently oversees sales and marketing for BrandLoyalty worldwide.
seeing a similar effect in other parts of Europe.
supermarket needs to work out how to compete.
Yet the desire for lower prices isn’t matched by an acceptance of
74
INTERVIEW
Turning food shopping into an everyday pleasure
we need to give them value for money in the broadest sense. This
have a significant and lasting impact on consumers’ habits. The
includes soft factors such as location, lighting, parking, service
research we’re doing now shows customers not spending 5%
I think the answer is to feed the need for emotional satisfaction.
and in-store cleanliness, as well as a good product range. But
more, but 30% to 40% more as a result. We will present the
On the one hand, people are watching the pennies, but on the
it also involves creating an emotional connection with a store,
latest results at the RLC in February to share our insights with
other hand they want the extras, the treats, the feeling of pleasure
based on a pleasurable, meaningful and personal interaction. And
the retail industry.
that traditionally they would have had to pay extra for. That’s why
that’s where BrandLoyalty comes in.
Adding excitement with an ILP
you see more mainstream retailers offering things like free cups of coffee in-store, or delicious freshly-prepared meals that shoppers
Touch and feel your reward
The ILPs that we run complement these programmes
can just take away and pop into the oven. But the discounters are
Our programmes aim to restore that sense of engagement
perfectly. They create immediate interest and excitement,
trying to take the middle ground as well – for example by selling
by enabling the retailer to offer the consumer real value that
while also allowing retailers to capitalise on external events
lobster and other upmarket foods, and upgrading their services.
can significantly alter behaviour. We do this in two ways: with
such as the World Cup or a Disney movie. ILPs based on a
traditional product-based programmes, and through instant
back-to-school theme or the run-up to Christmas naturally
Loyalty deserves a bigger reward
loyalty promotions (ILPs). With the first kind, most of what we
focus on higher-spending target groups such as households
This means that mainstream food retailers are having to try even
do revolves around the world of food: it relates to the preparation,
with children. The supermarket becomes the centre of the
harder to achieve customer loyalty, yet in the constant consumer
cooking, serving, storing, eating and drinking of items that
community, engaging consumers while lifting traffic and sales.
search for extra value, loyalty cards have lost a lot of their power.
you buy in the supermarket. Interestingly, these are items
Most grocery cards only offer about 1% of your spend as a rebate,
that consumers don't normally spend money on, but they do
Building loyalty, one step at a time
so that's not going to lock you in when someone's offering better
understand their value. And we're able to structure programmes
Through the combination of these two types of loyalty
value online or down the road. This is again bad news for retailers,
in a way that enables us to offer up to ten times the value of what
programme, we can add value in the short to medium term,
who thereby lose the opportunity to make use of customer data
most loyalty cards will give back. Most retailers with a loyalty
in a stepped-up process. We create one step after another by
to track consumers and make more targeted offers. These days,
card tend to offer 0.5% to 1% back to the consumer. Spend €500
running sequences of programmes with retailers on a regular
people prefer to give wallet space to cards – such as AIR MILES
and you get a €2.50 or €5 voucher. But with the product-based
basis, bringing something new, unique, exciting and of real
– that offer substantial, tangible value in the form of an airline
programmes that we offer, the same spend allows consumers to
value to keep consumers coming back.
seat or some other desirable item. Another way to ensure a loyalty
get a free item – like a piece of cookware – that has a perceived
I believe that with all the challenges out there, this ‘building
card is used regularly is to link it to other types of promotional
value of upwards of €50. We can do this because we're not
block’ approach is the way forward. Each piece of added
programmes.
offering the reward to all consumers. With us, you need to hit
value that we offer serves to strengthen the retailer-consumer
certain expenditure thresholds. So we focus all the investment at
relationship. Loyalty cards will continue to play an important
Creating value for money
very specific target groups, depending on what a particular retailer
role in providing valuable customer data, but retailers need to
That’s why I feel that the way forward is not about discounting
is aiming to do. Shoppers can actually touch and feel the value
work on many other factors too.
any more – it's about creating better overall value for money. And
for money immediately because everything’s displayed in-store,
value for money isn't just about price; there are very few people
encouraging purchase in a very tangible way.
Emotions that never change Nowadays, the economy is changing too quickly and
who will shop just on price alone. Most people split their spend, going to discounters to buy certain goods and then returning to
Significant results
consumers are too fickle for any of us to rely on previous
mainstream to buy other items. To tempt them back more often,
Because these programmes tend to run for about 6 months, they
certainties. The changes in this dynamic food retail environment require fast and constant adaptation, with retailers needing to add value in a variety of different ways.
“The biggest challenge for mainstream food retail results from the global economic recession: consumers are demanding better value in all sorts of ways, and they are much more knowledgeable about how to get it.”
But the loyalty business has been around for about 100 years, and it’s based on human emotions that never change. The search for value, the opportunity to get something for nothing, the chance to get added value – these are all timeless desires. ■
77
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
THE SPANISH FOOD RETAIL LANDSCAPE Spain is famed throughout the world for its delicious food. The variety and quality of ‘la cocina española’ are clearly reflected by the different store formats and retail companies active in the food sector. Barcelona is also the European city with the greatest number of covered and open-air markets creating this unique food experience. Source: Planet Retail
Retail environment
the retail sector was heavily dominated by traditional retailers
The structure of the Spanish food retail sector is similar to
and there was no serious competition.
structures in other western European countries: the market is mature and sophisticated, with a relatively high level of
Up to 2008, household expenditure on food continued to grow
concentration. The five top players account for around
at a similar rate to other retail sales, as Spaniards became more
two-fifths of the grocery market and most of them are multi-
sophisticated in their food choices. In a country where food
format operators, with the exception of Mercadona (which
occupies an important role in people’s lives, consumers do
only operates supermarkets). The sector also has a stronger
not mind spending extra money on food and particularly on
foreign presence (mainly from France and Germany) than
fresh meat, fish and vegetables. However, the economic crisis
other Western European countries, due to the relatively small
is affecting grocery sales. In terms of retailers, the discounters
size of local companies which provide plenty of takeover
seem to be coping better with this situation, as more price-
opportunities, plus the fact that some internationals, including
conscious consumers favour this format compared to pricier
Carrefour and Auchan, set up business in Spain at a time when
formats such as supermarkets and convenience stores.
78
79
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
top 5 companies
Last but not least, discounter Dia operates the largest supermarket chain in Spain, with more than 4,000 outlets, around a quarter
The top 5 players capture over 40% of grocery sales, a percentage slightly
of them acquired from Schlecker in 2012.
lower than in most other western European countries.
It also recently bought Supermercados El Arbol, a regional chain with over 400 supermarkets. This retailer continues
The Spanish ‘top 5' zone is dominated by local retailers. The largest grocery retailer
to invest in Spain despite the gloomy
in Spain is Mercadona, which operates a network of around 1,500 supermarkets. Its
economic prospects, showing that is well
sales have almost doubled over the last five years, after the opening of around 100 new
positioned to withstand the crisis. Dia% is
supermarkets per year over the period 1999-2008, until the crisis forced the retailer to slow
one of the very few ever-growing retailers,
down expansion. Pricing is based on a competitive Every Day Low Price strategy which is
besides Mercadona.
positioned at around 3% below those of its competitors. Competitive prices are reinforced through its private label range, accounting for more than 40% of total sales in 2012 with products across a wide range of lines from grocery through to drugstore, health and beauty, and pet care. The total product range spans some 8,000 lines including food service counters for fresh fish and cheese. With relatively large stores of around 1,000-1,500 square metres, located in town centres, Mercadona has managed to effectively fill the gap between
El Corte Inglés ranks fourth in grocery retailing. This company is Spain's
hypermarkets and discounters for competitively priced, convenient grocery shopping.
second largest retailer, operating a wide range of formats from department stores to travel agencies and supermarkets. El Corte Inglés’s strategy is largely based on the department store and hypermarket sectors, although it is seeking to reduce its
French retailer Carrefour is trailing Mercadona for the leading position in the
dependence on these relatively mature markets, which account for 50% and 20% of
Spanish grocery sector, and ranks as the leading operator in the hypermarket
sales respectively. Since 2000, as part of this strategy and to circumvent increasingly
sector. Following its divesting of the Dia discount operation, Carrefour now trades
restrictive planning regulations, El Corte Inglés has sought to diversify its business
under three main grocery formats: Carrefour hypermarkets, Carrefour Market
with smaller food and non-food formats. In 2000 itself, it launched the Supercor
(supermarkets) and Carrefour Express (convenience stores). Recently, Carrefour re-
supermarket and Opencor convenience store formats, which the retailer is also using
entered the discount segment, with the Atacadão-inspired Supeco banner opening in
as part of its aim to be present in every city across the country.
southern Spain, with further openings taking place in 2014.
Eroski is the distribution group of the Mondragón Cooperative Corporation, the world's largest worker-owned co-operative. The Eroski umbrella covers a wide range of food, non-food, wholesaling and travel formats. Before the crisis, Eroski managed to grow at a good pace, aided by efficient logistics, cost reduction policies and the benefits of Alidis, the buying group that Eroski set up with French group Intermarché in 2003, and joined
Company
Number of outlets
Total Sales Area m2
Average Sales Area m2
Grocery Banner Sales Grocery Spending (EUR) Market Share
Mercadona
1,500
1,918,836
1,308
19,795,857,000
19.88
Carrefour
456
1,633,599
3,582
6,208,589,958
6.23
Eroski
1,804
1,551,540
860
5,173,062,082
5.14
Dia
4,151
1,460,271
352
4,648,375,960
4.67
El Corte Inglès
550
3,199,223
5,817
4,624,831,338
4.65
by Edeka in 2005. This alliance enabled Eroski to achieve economies of scale, helping the retailer to cut costs. Furthermore, in 2007 Eroski strengthened its position in the market further by acquiring a 75% stake in supermarket chain Caprabo. However, the crisis has taken its toll on the retailer, which posted negative sales since 2009 and has been forced to go ahead with a sell-and-lease store plan in order to reduce debt.
Source: Planet Retail 2014
80
81
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
Markets In Spain, marketplaces occupy still a relevant position in terms of food shopping options. Barcelona in particular is also referred to as the ‘City of Markets’
retail tours
due to the large number of different markets it offers.
During the Retail Loyalty Congress, you will be able to visit these
Nowhere is the character of a city more apparent
and other Spanish retail outlets as we are offering the opportunity
than in its food markets, and no European city has more covered and open-air markets than Barcelona,
at different moments to participate in the following retail tours:
with a total of 40. The most famous marketplace is La Boqueria (next to the Ramblas). The Boquería market, officially called the Mercat de Sant Josep after the Carmelite convent that once occupied this space, is the city's biggest and most beautiful product market and over 100 years old. Other markets in Barcelona include: Mercat Del Ninot - a Barcelona market that's for the locals and away from the tourist traps Mercant Del Encants - Barcelona's biggest flea market
Fresh Food Experience Tour
Spanish Food Retail landscape Tour
Innovative Retail Tour
You will visit the city’s biggest and most beautiful food product market, ‘La Boqueria’, which is over 100 years old. You will also visit other fresh food experience outlets, including El Corte Inglés, learn about the challenges that the markets and other stores face with fresh products, and find out how they use these to attract customers.
During this tour, you will visit different chain stores currently active in the Spanish / Catalan food retail market. During these visits, you will receive more detailed information on specific Spanish challenges food retailers face, and will be welcomed by professionals of each chain who will talk about each retailer’s individual strategic approach to strengthening their positioning.
Often, the best ideas are encountered when visiting more than just other food retailers alone. During this inspirational tour, you will experience lots of different concepts that a variety of retailers are using to attract and retain shoppers. Be inspired as well and sign up for this tour!
Private labels Although private-label products had a slow start in Spain due to customer loyalty to leading brands, attractive prices and appropriate marketing have made private-label ranges increasingly popular. In value they represented 41% of total sales, according to Nielsen. All major foreign and Spanish food retailers in the market offer private-label ranges, from premium-priced lines
The tours will take place
to standard and economy ranges.
on the following dates 4 February 2015: 09:00 – 13:00 4 February 2015: 14:00 – 18:00
From price to premium
To ensure you don’t miss out on the chance to take part in the tour(s) of most interest to you, please reserve your place at the RLC 2015 now via
www.retailloyaltycongress.com
82
83
gadgets
Gadgets
Scribble Pen
Gadgets
This Scribble Pen is the chameleon of all the pens in the world. It can take – and reproduce – any colour you want. Just hold the RGB colour sensor to any object you like and the pen will let you draw or write with that exact colour.
Smart gadgets? We can never get enough of them. Some of them are just fun, while others are more
Price: Available soon
functional. Take for instance a cup
Getscribblepen.com
My Vessyl
that automatically knows what you’re
Tracking your physique and eating habits is popular, but time-
drinking, a ceiling fan that knows when
drink you consume. Luckily for us, there’s My Vessyl. A cup that
consuming. Especially the part where you have to enter every
you enter the room or a pen that can
is not only capable of letting you know you’re drinking enough
write in 100,000 different colours.
Price: USD 100
during the day, but also knows what’s inside, automatically. myvessyl.com
Haiku Fan SenseME
Coolest Cooler At first, you might think this is the single most ridiculous gadget ever made: a rolling cooler with built-in blender and Bluetooth speakers. But take another look, because this is one of the most
The world is getting smarter and smarter. And we don’t mean people. We’ve written about a smart thermostat and a smart smoke detecter before, but now it’s time for the Haiku Fan SenseMe. This interior gadget has so many sensors, it will outsmart you in a comfortable way without you even noticing.
eCool Beer Cooler
Price: USD 1,000
You care about Mother Nature, but you
bigassfans.com
also want to have a cold beer every now and then, right? Well, check out the eCool Beer Cooler. This environmentally
demanded gadgets at the moment. With good music, good drinks and lots of thoughtful touches, it turns the average day trip into a totally cool experience. Price: USD 185 coolestkickstarter.com
Crock-Pot Smart Slow Cooker
friendly device lowers the temperature
How convenient would it be if you could access and operate
of your favourite drink naturally, beneath
your slow cooker while you’re not at home? Very convenient?
the ground. Because you’re not using
Than this Crock-Pot is the ideal gadget for you. Throw in the
any electricity, it will definitely cool your
ingredients and start cooking with your iPhone a couple of
conscience on a hot, sunny day too.
hours later. From now on, dinner is ready when you are.
Price: USD 370
Price: USD 130
eng.ecool.dk
crock-pot.com
CREATING MONSTERS FOR OUR LITTLE MONSTERS DARE TO JOIN US AT THE RETAIL LOYALTY CONGRESS 2015
87
Loyalty Insights
opening the discounters’ doors Instant Loyalty Promotions weren’t considered a worthwhile investment for discount formats – until millions of colourful children’s giveaways proved otherwise.
88
Loyalty Insights
Daring to be different
Meet the Stikeez
Until a few years ago, Instant Loyalty Promotions (ILPs) were
The characters that the success of Lidl’s ILP depended on
practically a no-go area for discount retailers. Because of their
were Stikeez: small, colourful, friendly stick-on, pull-off figures
heavy focus on prices, margins and assortment, discounters
that can be stuck onto almost any flat surface at any angle.
weren’t really concentrating on attracting specific target
Created by a company called ZING, they were hugely popular
groups via promotional activities. As for loyalty companies
in the US before crossing the Atlantic to appear at the 2010
themselves, the salespeople rarely thought about approaching
Brand Licensing Europe trade fair in the UK. BrandLoyalty’s
a discounter to propose a loyalty programme, because they
ILP team came across them there, snapped up a licence deal
were sure to be rebuffed. So it was quite a surprise when Lidl
and immediately started building a concept around them. As
agreed to run its first-ever ILP in Germany – especially when
ILP Business Development Manager Wido Duncker explains,
it turned out to be a great success.
“We're always looking for innovative new things to give away for free, and we knew that this toy with a high perceived value
Attracting families with children
would be very appealing to children. We pre-tested the Stikeez
Andreas Ehle, Executive Director of BrandLoyalty Germany,
concept on a children’s panel, together with some other
takes up the story. “When we first started talking to Lidl about
concepts, and Stikeez came out as having huge potential. After
loyalty programmes, they couldn’t see the logic of using them.
running successful initial promotions elsewhere in Europe, we
So we did an analysis of why a loyalty campaign could make
were ready to launch it on a huge scale for Lidl in Germany.”
sense for Lidl as well as for its customers, and found out that Lidl attracted significantly fewer families with young children
Who dares, wins
than the average German retailer. As it emerged that the focus
During the four weeks of that first Stikeez promotion in the
should be on these shoppers, it was more logical to think of an
spring of 2013, young families poured into Lidl’s stores to do
ILP (which can attract specific groups, such as young families)
what the campaign slogan suggested: “Collect them all!” Families
than a normal Loyalty Programme (which focuses more on the
with children aged 0-5 years were the most active collectors,
existing client base).
closely followed by those with children aged 6-14.
While trying to persuade Lidl to say yes, it probably helped
What’s more, there was a significant return on investment.
that I have 20 years' experience as a retailer, so for me it was
Lidl’s market share and customer spend both rose by around
like going back to my roots and thinking how to influence the
7%, while the number of new customers increased by nearly
total business. It was also an advantage that I could look at
2%. When the results became apparent, Lidl decided to run a
the details of the analysis and work out the effect that the ILP
follow-on promotion the following year: “Stikeez from space!”
should have. But even so, I know it was quite a big decision
This time, with awareness of Stikeez having grown outside
for Lidl to entrust us not only with its first-ever ILP in its
Lidl’s own customer base, the number of new customers
home country, but also to base it on a giveaway that was more
increased by over 6%, customer spend increased by over 3%,
expensive than the usual cards and stickers promotions.”
and market share grew by around 8%.
"There was a significant return on investment. Lidl’s market share and customer spend both rose by around 7%."
91
Loyalty Insights
Andreas admits, “It was an unusual combination: a hard discounter with quite an expensive free gift. But Germany is a very mature ILP market, so everyone's looking for a differentiator: something new or exclusive. We ran the promotion after the Easter holiday so that kids would be back at school, because kids spread the word in the school playground, swap their Stikeez and want to get more of them to complete their collection.”
Why stop growing? Lidl International is responsible for stores in 25 countries, in different states of development and with different market shares. When approached with the Lidl Germany success story,
INSTANT LOYALTY PROMOTIONS HOW THEY WORK (EXAMPLE):
1
A promotion is run for a 6-week period
there was some doubt as to whether it would be possible to replicate the results everywhere else. As Wido explains, “In most of the countries outside Germany, there's still huge growth. So to tell a retailer who has double-digit growth that they should still do something on top was our greatest challenge. They're already doing so many things right and growing so much, why should they run a loyalty campaign too? But by producing the figures, we managed to
2
Promotions that stick in the mind
the customer immediately receives 1 free gift
sell the Stikeez promotion in 16 out of those 25 countries. Every retailer understands the importance of attracting families with children, and this is an easy way to do it.”
For each €10 spent,
3
Kids start collecting,
4
Collectability and fun
He continues, “ILPs such as Stikeez now form an increasing share of BrandLoyalty's portfolio,
playing with and trading the gifts
and are run by a dedicated team of specialists. Currently, BrandLoyalty is running nearly a dozen Instant Loyalty Promotions simultaneously in Europe, including Stikeez campaigns. For example, there’s Disney Cooking, an exclusive co-creation between us and Disney. The characters are classics from Pixar (the animators of Toy Story) and Disney films, with very
are stimulated with collector’s albums/boxes
high appeal. The basic idea is to collect stickers and put them in your album. You can buy an album for a couple of euros, and the moment you have one, you want to complete it. We added a cooking theme to the album, with beautifully visualised cooking recipes from the characters and an emphasis on good nutritional value and healthy living. The family cookbook album serves to extend the value of the promotion.
“It was an unusual combination: a hard discounter with quite an expensive free gift.”
We’ve also got Disney Flizz: robust, high-quality plastic shooters that girls love putting together and collecting in their album, while boys love the shooting mechanism. And there are quite a few more concepts that we’ve got up our sleeve. To create a hype, we always need to stay on top of what's happening in children's lives: the films they watch, the toys they play with, the themes they’re interested in and so on. It’s a fun business: it’s all about making children smile. That’s why we’re grateful to Lidl for giving us – and our competitors, of course – more opportunities to reach families with children. Lidl has truly opened the doors to Instant Loyalty Promotions in the discount sector.” ■
KIDS PLAY, COLLECT & HAVE FUN!
✑✍❚❁❐❆✿❄❉■❇❂❁▼▲✿❁❂❃❄❅❆❇❈❉❊❋●❍■❏❐❑❒▲▼◆❖◗❘❙❚❀✑✒✓✔✕✖✗✘✙✐✍✝✻✽✼✛✌✎✏ ✡✢✣✤✥✦✧★✩✪✫✬✭✮✯✰✱✲✳✴✵✶✷✸✹✺❞✁✠✃✄☎✾✆☛✈✉✿☞❛❝❜✚✓✜✞✟■
marriot_light_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-=[]\;’,./ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? å∫ç∂´ƒ©˙ˆ∆˚¬µ˜øπœ®ß†¨√∑≈¥Ω`¡™£¢ §¶•ªº–≠“‘«…æ≤ ÷≠ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜Ø∏Œ‰Íˇ¨◊„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" €$€£¥₩฿руб ≠ marriot_light_italic_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-=[]\;’,./ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? å∫ç∂´ƒ©˙ˆ∆˚¬µ˜øπœ®ß†¨√∑≈¥Ω`¡™£¢ §¶•ªº–≠“‘«…æ≤ ÷≠ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜Ø∏Œ‰Íˇ¨◊„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" € $€£¥₩฿руб ≠ marriott_med_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-=[]\;’,./ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? å∫ç∂´ƒ©˙ˆ∆˚¬µ˜øπœ®ß†¨√∑≈¥Ω`¡™£¢ §¶•ªº–≠“‘«…æ≤ ÷≠ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜Ø∏Œ‰Íˇ¨◊„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" € $€£¥₩฿руб ≠ marriott_med_italic_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-=[]\;’,./ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? å∫ç∂´ƒ©˙ˆ∆˚¬µ˜øπœ®ß†¨√∑≈¥Ω`¡™£¢ §¶•ªº–≠“‘«…æ≤ ÷≠ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜Ø∏Œ‰Íˇ¨◊„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" € $€£¥₩฿руб ≠ marriott_bold_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-=[]\;’,./ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? åç´ƒ©˙ˆ˚¬µ˜øœ®ß†¨¥`¡™£¢§¶•ªº–“‘«…æ÷�ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜،‰Íˇ¨„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" €�$€£¥₩฿руб
93
marriott_bold_italic_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-=[]\;’,./ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? åç´ƒ©˙ˆ˚¬µ˜øœ®ß†¨¥`¡™£¢§¶•ªº–“‘«…æ÷�ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜،‰Íˇ¨„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" €�$€£¥₩฿руб
COLUMN
marriot_condensed_light_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-=[]\;’,./ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? å∫ç∂´ƒ©˙ˆ∆˚¬µ˜øπœ®ß†¨√∑≈¥Ω`¡™£¢ §¶•ªº–≠“‘«…æ≤ ÷≠ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜Ø∏Œ‰Íˇ¨◊„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" € $€£¥₩฿руб ≠ marriot_condensed_medium_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-=[]\;’,./ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? å∫ç∂´ƒ©˙ˆ∆˚¬µ˜øπœ®ß†¨√∑≈¥Ω`¡™£¢ §¶•ªº–≠“‘«…æ≤ ÷≠ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜Ø∏Œ‰Íˇ¨◊„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" € $€£¥₩฿руб
marriot_condensed_bold_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-=[]\;’,./ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? å∫ç∂´ƒ©˙ˆ∆˚¬µ˜øπœ®ß†¨√∑≈¥Ω`¡™£¢ §¶•ªº–≠“‘«…æ≤ ÷≠ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜Ø∏Œ‰Íˇ¨◊„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" € $€£¥₩฿руб ≠ AbadiMTStd-Light_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-= [] \;’,./≠ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? å∫ç∂´ƒ©˙ˆ∆˚¬µ˜øπœ®ß†¨√∑≈¥�`¡™£¢ §¶•ªº–≠“‘«…æ≤ ÷≠ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜Ø∏Œ‰Íˇ¨◊„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" € $‚Ǩ¬£¬•‚Ç©‡∏ø—Ä—É–±
AbadiMTStd-LightItalic_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-= [] \;’,./≠ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? å∫ç∂´ƒ©˙ˆ∆˚¬µ˜øπœ®ß†¨√∑≈¥�`¡™£¢ §¶•ªº–≠“‘«…æ≤ ÷≠ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜Ø∏Œ‰Íˇ¨◊„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" € $‚Ǩ¬£¬•‚Ç©‡∏ø—Ä—É–±
Let us take you on a tour of our extraordinary architecture.
In this edition of H&W, Shopper Marketing Expert Art Frickus shares his insights on interesting global retail developments.
AbadiMTStd_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-= [] \;’,./≠ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? å∫ç∂´ƒ©˙ˆ∆˚¬µ˜øπœ®ß†¨√∑≈¥Ω`¡™£¢ §¶•ªº–≠“‘«…æ≤ ÷≠ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜Ø∏Œ‰Íˇ¨◊„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" € $‚Ǩ¬£¬•‚Ç©‡∏ø—Ä—É–±
AbadiMTStd-Italic_abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz`1234567890-= [] \;’,./≠ ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ~!@#$%^&*()_+{}|:”<>? å∫ç∂´ƒ©˙ˆ∆˚¬µ˜øπœ®ß†¨√∑≈¥Ω`¡™£¢ §¶•ªº–≠“‘«…æ≤ ÷≠ÅıÇÎ´Ï˝ÓˆÔÒ˜Ø∏Œ‰Íˇ¨◊„˛Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿ Á¸`⁄‹›fifl‡°·‚—±”’»ÚƯ˘¿|áéíóúâêîôûàèìòùäëïöüÿãñõÁÉÍÓÚÀÈÌÒÙÄËÏÖÜŸÑÃÕÂÊÎÔÛ ”“’‘ '" € $‚Ǩ¬£¬•‚Ç©‡∏ø—Ä—É–±
Let us excite your taste buds with a Michelin-starred sensation. Let us offer you a luxurious haven on the beach, yet right in the city. Let us leave you with delightful memories that will last a lifetime.
Enjoy privileged views of the Barcelona seafront in exclusive suites, high above the city and the Mediterranean. The Hotel Arts Barcelona suites provide an oasis of peace and luxury to be discovered. For reservations, please call Hotel Arts Barcelona at + 34 93 551 30 00 or visit hotelartsbarcelona.com.
Hotel de la Villa Olímpica, S.A.
‘Lifestyle’ meets ‘Blurring’ The choice of a supermarket format
shopper with an individualistic mindset,
Corp in Seoul stands the flagship store
or leisure concept will in the future be
who is looking to utilise their time in the
of CJ FoodWorld; two floors of blurring,
increasingly dependent on the way we
best possible way while searching for the
where restaurant formats such as Tous les
live, our outlook on life and the measure
ideal interpretation of their wishes.
Jours, A TwoSomePlace, VIPS and Bibigo
in which a retailer is able to ‘visibly’ take
have taken up residence in the middle of
advantage of all this.
Divide and rule
a large supermarket. Because CJ Corp has
The ability to embrace ‘lifestyle’ as a
In an unending quest to serve every
all sorts of different food service formats
target group segmentation is, and will
consumer need, retailers are morphing
in-house, it can itself decide on the best
become, one of the decisive factors for
across as many channels as they can.
possible way to create the various locations,
success through which retailers and
Supermarkets are selling petrol and putting
from the drugstore to the fresh food
suppliers will manage to differentiate
convenience stores in their car parks. Mega-
market, and the coffee house to the ice
themselves. Today’s shopper will
store operators are creating smaller niche
salon – including maybe pairing them with
increasingly decide for herself when –
formats. Drugstore chains have aisles of
a cinema or a concert hall.
and on whom – she will spend her time
exclusive wines and sushi, and DIY stores
and money. This means that as a retailer,
are selling the best sandwiches. Channels
Taking an in-depth ‘lifestyle’ approach
you will have to reach shoppers’ hearts if
have never been as blurred as they are
and being willing to blur traditional
you want them to reach for their wallets.
today, giving shoppers a huge choice of
boundaries makes it possible to gain a fresh
where they can spend their money.
perspective of how to tempt and activate
In recent years, the spotlight has been
Many countries are just beginning to ‘blur’
individual shoppers. It gives retailers and
on Seoul, the capital of South Korea.
and are extremely busy experimenting to
manufacturers new opportunities to turn
‘Progressive’, ‘high quality’, ‘technology’
find the right mix. But in Korea, they’ve
each shopper into a loyal customer.
and ‘highly demanding customers’ were
already been through this phase. One
the terms that I already associated with
example of a completely hybrid retailer
the Korean retailer landscape, but there’s
is the Korean CJ Corporation. In fact,
more besides. The blending of added
‘retailer’ isn’t really the right description.
value and consumer experience on the one
The firm itself talks about being a ‘global
hand, counterpointed by efficiency and
lifestyle company’. It’s a worldwide
logistics on the other, have resulted in some
conglomerate and has branches in the
delightful concepts in which the boundaries
entertainment industry – with music and
between horeca and food retail are
film companies and cinemas – as well as in
becoming more and more blurred. In other
the pharmaceutical industry, logistics, the
words, companies are capitalising perfectly
food industry, food retail and the horeca
on the current wishes of the omni-channel
sector. Beneath the headquarters of CJ
94
barcelona special
from food to art Restaurants to remember TICKETS tapas bar Avinguda Paralelo 164 08015 Barcelona www.ticketsbar.es Opening hours From 13:00 to 15:30 (only on Saturday) and from 19.00 to 23:30. Closed on Sunday, Monday and during holidays.
Exploding olives that detonate on the tongue, tuna belly painted with cured ham fat, Galician crab cannelloni, fried duck egg with truffled fat and potato cream...the culinary surprises are endless. Desserts are equally inventive: just take The Living Forest, a fairytale concoction of meringue toadstools, pistachio moss, wild strawberries and coconut sorbet that resembles a dish of deadly
Ferran Adrià, founder of the world-famous El Bulli restaurant
toadstools on a grassy mound.
and considered one of the best chefs on earth, set up Tickets tapas bar with his brother Albert to serve innovative and
Tickets is one half of the Adrià brothers’ new venture within the
creative tapas in an unforgettable multi-themed atmosphere.
resurgent and creative neighbourhood of Poblesec, located adja-
The concept is ‘la vida tapa’: a fun way of eating that turns the
cent to its other half: cocktails-and-snacks bar 41°. It’s extremely
diner into a participant in the circus of life, interpreted through
difficult to get a reservation at either of them – you have to book
a variety of amusing and astonishing tapas.
through the website (try at midnight) months in advance!
41O
oyster, and pistachios wrapped in a delicate lattice of yogurt
Avinguda Paralelo 164 08015 Barcelona www.41grados.es Opening hours If you can find an available slot, just book it immediately.
and dusted with sweet white powder. Desserts are equally spectacular: meringues of dried raspberries with hazelnut, blackcurrent profiteroles and lime-flavoured marshmallow cubes give you some idea of the delights awaiting you.
Named after Barcelona’s parallel of latitude, 41º is described
Low-slung chairs and banquettes recline below glittering
as "a magnificent volcano of creativity, ideas and hopes."
bull skulls in this unique 16-seater gastronomic palace, yet
Offering both classic cocktails and more modern, contem-
admission is surprisingly simple and democratic: advance
porary ones, 41º serves amazingly inventive snacks by
reservations are required and can only be made through the
Albert and Ferran to accompany them, such as Parmesan ice
restaurant website. You just need luck and patience to find
cream sandwiches with lemon marmalade, Borscht with raw
the booking window…
Dos Palillos
CA L'ISIDRE Carrer de Les Flors, 12 - 08001 Barcelona t. (+34) 93 441 11 39 - www.calisidre.com Opening hours From 13:30 to 16:00 and from 20:30 to 23:00. Closed on Sunday and during holidays.
15:30 and from 19:30 to 23:30 Closed on Sunday, Monday, and during holidays.
Albert Raurich, the founder of this highly exclusive tapas bar, worked at the worldfamous El Bulli from 1997 till 2007, where he was head of kitchen for 6 years. Dos
Passadis del Pep
MOMENTS
Casa Leopoldo
and stuffed pigeon. Desserts are equally
your waiter’s suggestions. For example,
Moments at Mandarin Oriental, Barcelona Passeig de Gracia 38-40 - 08007 Barcelona +34 931 51 87 81 Mobcn-moments@mohg.com
inventive and delicous. The visionary chef
you could begin with slices of bread
has also designed an ‘anti-ageing’ menu,
rubbed with tomato and a plate of
in collaboration with Dr. Manuel Sanchez,
Iberian, acorn-fed cured ham, followed
Opening hours FROM 13:30 TO 15:00 AND FROM 20:30 TO 22:00 CLOSED ON SUNDAY AND MONDAY
specialist in anti-ageing treatments.
by portions of the best shellfish and
With 80 years of history behind it, this
crustaceans prepared simply but with a
classic family-run restaurant has been
distinct personality. You could continue
buzzing ever since señor Leopoldo
Pla de Palau 2 - 08003 Barcelona Tel. +0034 933101021
with a dish of the very best fresh grilled
Gil inaugurated it all those decades
fish, cooked to perfection with sautéed
ago. Situated at the heart of Raval,
Opening hours 13:15 - 15:45 20:30 - 23:30 Closed on Sunday
garlic and vegetables. Other specialities
it’s remained immune to the endless
you might like to try may include
changes in the local population and the
succulent chickpeas stewed with
neighbourhood itself, continuing to offer
This characterful family restaurant serves
Palillos serves a unique selection of fusion
a mixture of traditional Catalonian and
food, based around the cuisines of Asia
Located within the Mandarin Oriental
Mediterranean cuisine, with a modern
and Spain. The aim of this new concept
Hotel, this gastronomic tour de force
PASSADIS DEL PEP
Opening hours 13:00 – 16:00 21:00 - 24:00 (except Sunday) Closed on Monday and during holidays
twist. Special attention is paid to seasonal
is to blend the simple philosophy of
has already earned two Michelin stars.
products, with top-quality fresh ingredi-
Spanish tapas with the highlights of Asian
Managed by its world-acclaimed female
ents playing an important role.
gastronomy (Japan, Thailand, China and
chef Carme Ruscalleda and her son Raül
Vietnam), in a creative style.
Balam, the restaurant serves Catalan
Traditional Catalonian cuisine with an
ham and artichokes, accompanied by
high-quality Catalan dishes made from
cuisine with a unique twist, amid the
amazing quality of fish and seafood has
Basque peppers seasoned with oil and
fresh ingredients purchased daily from the nearby La Boquería market.
Classic Spanish dishes such as veal tripes and pig’s trotters may be found here at
‘Dos Palillos’ means ‘two sticks’, and
golden and amber hues of the superb
drawn diners to this unique restaurant
sprinkled with salt. Or some sensational
different times of the year, together with
the name refers to the fact that people
Moments dining room.
for more than 30 years. The entrance is
baby squid sautéed with garlic shavings
lobster gazpacho, spring mushrooms,
in Asia and Spain both use sticks to
quite underwhelming (tucked away at the
and white rice, or a delicate version of
Try the 'revuelto de ajos tiernos y gambas'
whitebait and seafood rice. Ca l'Isidre's
eat with: chopsticks for Asian food
Ruscadella and her culinary team search
end of a passage, beside a cash machine)
sea snail cooked in the Burgundy style
(eggs scrambled with young garlic and
combination of authenticy and surpris-
and cocktail sticks for tapas. 25 sorts
for the finest seasonal ingredients every
but the restaurant itself, decorated with
with butter.
shrimp) or the famous 'cap-i-pota' (stewed
ing contemporary touches makes it
of tapas and 5 desserts are available
day to create new menus. Their aim is
ancient stonework and adorned with
popular with celebrities.
in the informal bar area, with a more
to offer special, creative, healthy, tasty,
paintings by respected artists, offers
Don’t miss the opportunity to try this
red mullet, oxtail, small octopuses,
extensive gourmet menu on offer in the
well-prepared dishes based around neo-
a relaxed, friendly atmosphere. This is
cuisine, whose simplicity and good
sautéed seafood, delicious traditional
Asian bar. Depending on the season, you
traditional Catalan cuisine. Fish dishes
created to a large extent by the warm,
taste are based on fresh, top-quality
stews, paella...the cuisine is simple but
may choose from dishes such as fresh
include squid with mushrooms and
personalised treatment that the staff
products. No menu, no rush.
excellent. A home-from-home for artists
seaweed sunomono with cockles, large
pepper, lobster tortita with seafood pesto,
offer their customers.
grilled oysters with sake, Cantonese-
parrot fish and Galician wild turbot, while
style Iberian pork dewlap, or homemade
meat lovers may select between Pyrenean
There’s no menu at this restaurant, so
Japanese beef-and-ginger burgers.
suckling lamb, Iberian pork, ox steak
you just let yourself be tempted by
DOS PALILLOS Carrer d'Elisabets 9 - 08001 Barcelona 0034 93 304 05 13 - www.dospalillos.com dospalillos@dospalillos.com Opening hours Tuesday and Wednesday from 19:30 to 23:30 Thursday, Friday and Saturday from 13:30 to
pig’s head and trotter). Deep-fried baby
and intellectuals, Casa Leopoldo is
CASA LEOPOLDO Carrer de San Rafael 24 - 08001 Barcelona, Tel: 0034 93 441 30 14 - www.casaleopoldo.com
comfortable and unpretentious. The dining room, lined in blue-and-yellow tiles, has an appropriately Mediterranean feel. ■
98
99
Facts & Figures
Facts & Figures
Loyalty Trends That Will Define Your Business
What to do: Companies that become a go-to resource or forum for this emerging type of commerce can create profits for everyone. This way, your business can profitably participate in a P2P economy instead of being left out.
3 Soft benefits make a programme stand out. Loyalty currency is everywhere and is increasingly of nominal value to customers. To remain relevant, loyalty programmes will have to provide significant value beyond points and discounts. Rewarding consumers for non-transactional behaviour is what will help brands stand out from their competitors. What to do: Take a cue from some of the big-name brands. For instance, the Ikea Family loyalty programme is built in part on soft rewards such as sneak previews of new collections. FIFA Fan Rewards, for gamers who play the EA Sports FIFA video game, is
Trends in loyalty have never been more complex, more demanding, or
centered on content and experiences, not on points. And Global Hotel Alliance’s GHA Discovery programme features a reward
more important. Today’s marketers must understand issues ranging
component of authentic local experiences such as spending the day
from global competition and micro peer-to-peer economies to the rising
prepared for that evening’s dinner, or getting special access to
attraction of soft benefits and the value of a well-designed app. Here’s
with a fisherman off the coast of Portugal and having the catch exclusive department stores including Harrods in London, Illum in Copenhagen, or KaDeWe in Berlin.
what you need to know. 4 Make mobile work for your best customers. LoyaltyOne’s 2013 Social Word-of-Mouth study reported that the
1 Competition is now global.
average smartphone owner downloads 26 apps but uses only six of
First and foremost: there are no local businesses any more. Consumers price-shop on their phones, and big
them daily. Clearly, the real estate on a consumer’s main screen is a
online companies like Alibaba and Amazon have trained consumers to expect a wide product selection. Free
hot property.
next-day shipping, formerly considered a luxury service, is becoming more of an expectation. What to do: Savvy marketers build their apps around the What to do: All businesses need to have a competitive value proposition: one that holds up compared to
preferences and behaviours of their most highly engaged customers.
players from around the world, both in person and online.
It’s worth trying to become one of the six apps that your customers regularly use – apps can increase transaction volume and total
2 Competition is also micro.
earnings, and sustain those higher numbers over the long term.
The rise of online marketplaces like Kijiji and eBay have opened up peer-to-peer (P2P) economies.
And customers are increasingly turning to their mobile devices for
Consumers can find acutely relevant items on P2P networks, which will continue to nip away at companies
receiving and redeeming coupons at the cash register.
whose generic inventory isn’t tailored to customer preferences.
1
4
6
5 Customers expect an omni-channel shopping experience.
insights that can then be applied to broader audiences.
As more customers use mobile apps to research and shop, retailers
7 Customers are getting protective about
need to provide consistent shopping experiences across all channels.
their data.
Customers see little difference between making a purchase in
The big issue about loyalty data and customers is not that
Kevin Roberts is the world’s foremost speaker on brands, a
He has written several books, including “Lovemarks: the Future
person at a retail location, online from home, or by mobile app
someone’s information might be leaked (although companies need
provocateur and inspirer with 45 years of business experience with
Beyond Brands,” a ground-breaking business book published in 18
during their commute.
to protect against that). Rather, it’s that the average consumer
several of the world’s leading companies. Based in New York, he
languages, showing how emotion can inspire businesses and brands
doesn’t see an upside for disclosure. Could customers start
is CEO Worldwide of Saatchi & Saatchi, the world’s most famous
to deliver sustainable value. Lovemarks was named one of the ten
demanding payment in exchange for their data? That’s a real risk.
creative communications company, which works with 6 of the top
“Ideas of the Decade” by Advertising Age in 2009.
What to do: Create an effective omni-channel strategy that
Kevin Roberts, CEO Worldwide of Saatchi & Saatchi
10 and over half of the top 50 global advertisers.
maintains the customer’s individual experience preferences as they move from channel to channel. Facilitate meaningful interactions
What to do: Use data to noticeably improve the customer
to keep customers engaged, and ensure that each experience is
experience, such as to provide better customer service, easier buying
Born and educated in Lancaster in the north of England, Kevin
uncompromisingly positive, inspirational leadership style, and an
consistently outstanding.
processes, personalised communications, offers tailored to customer
Roberts started his career with iconic London fashion house
ability to generate ideas and emotional connections that accelerate
Kevin Roberts has an international reputation for an
purchases, preferential treatment, and access to exclusive offers
Mary Quant before becoming a senior marketing executive for
extraordinary value. He has made presentations to business
6 Market segments will continue to fragment.
and events. For example, UK-based Tesco is a leader in the use
Gillette and Procter & Gamble in Europe and the Middle East.
audiences in 60 countries.
of loyalty programme data to identify which products customers
Aged 32, he became CEO of Pepsi-Cola Middle East; and later
Businesses need to stop thinking about general consumer
are most interested in receiving discounts for. The goal here will
Pepsi’s CEO in Canada. In 1989, Roberts moved to Auckland,
categories, such as “mothers over the age of 30.” Instead, that one
be not just to sell to the customer, but to anticipate and meet the
New Zealand, to become Chief Operating Officer with Lion
category will become a collection of dozens, if not hundreds, of
customer’s goals.
Nathan. He took up his position as CEO Worldwide with
smaller micro-markets that shift with time, place, need, and fashion.
Saatchi & Saatchi in 1997. If there’s one word to summarise the driving force in today’s loyalty
kevin roberts "Kevin Roberts was arguably more entertaining and more informative than
What to do: Current technology makes it possible to achieve the
world, it’s relevance. Providing relevance as a value exchange is the
Kevin Roberts has honorary appointments at, and doctorates
any other speaker, speaking about any
kind of specificity in member segmentation that was unattainable
key concept for marketers. Shoppers will react favourably to highly
from, several universities, including the University of Auckland
other subject, anywhere."
just five years ago. Loyalty marketers should take the time to
relevant personalised offers delivered in a dynamic way that satisfies
Business School in New Zealand, Lancaster University in the UK,
- San Francisco technology reviewer
examine their databases to find behavioural indicators that offer
their specific needs. The real meaning of loyalty is a commitment to
and Victoria University in Canada. For a decade he was CEO in
new opportunities in previously undiscovered segments. Testing
the development of long-term customer engagement strategies that
Residence at the Judge Business School, University of Cambridge,
concepts and programmes with smaller groups can generate
foster sustainable, profitable growth. ■
and has lectured at Stanford, Wharton, Tuck, Oxford and Beijing.
will be speaking at the Retail Loyalty Congress 2015
50
1
Credits
1
5
We would like to thank the following people for their contributions to this edition of Hearts & Wallets:
Editor Chantal van Wijk
art Direction & design Lieke van Gorp
illustrations RenĂŠ Kouwenhoven
Photography Peter Hermeling Roel van Koppenhagen, Studio NoPoint
Editorial Cathy Scott, Olav van Dam, Stedenman,
About this Publication Heards & Wallets is a publication of BrandLoyalty International
Marco van Bilsen, Jeroen Pietryga, Koen van Dijck, Art Frickus, Karla Heeren,
Copyright Š2014 Brandloyalty International
Jeff Berry, Pierre Chabot
Nothing from this publication may be copied, transmitted and/or made public
Printing Gianotten printed media
by means of printing, photocopying, transmitting digitalised data files or in any other way whatsoever without prior written permission from the publisher. After specific permission from the publisher, articles from this issue may be republished and/or reproduced, provided that the source is mentioned. The publishers have done their utmost to identify all persons or organisations who own the rights to the visual images used. Should a person or organisation be able to prove that their permission was required for any images we have used, we hereby ask them to contact us as soon as possible. This publication has been developed with the greatest of care. However, the authors and publisher disclaim any responsibility in the case that any information it contains may have been reproduced incompletely or inaccurately. Should any such omissions or inaccuracies come to light, the authors and publisher will be pleased to receive suggestions for amendments.
We create digital solutions that help and reward people shopping and inspire them to enjoy food every day.
To discover the latest updates and information about the speakers and programme, visit
www.retailloyaltycongress.com