Safety and Liability

by Ned Einstein

Defending Contractors

Part 1: Lead Agencies and Brokers For decades, motorcoach providers have provided commuter-express service, under contract, to transit agencies (and, occasionally, to municipalities, counties or regions which do not have formal transit agencies). Particularly in the past 20 years, this role has expanded: Motorcoach providers are increasingly providing service on local and regional routes, often with regular buses –not even motorcoaches.

Similarly, many motorcoach companies also own school buses and provide school bus service, under contract, to school districts. For decades, roughly a third of all school bus service has been contracted out, and this percentage has remained surprisingly consistent. For the same reasons that contracted transit service has been expanding, I expect contracted school bus service to soon expand as well.

Other modes, like non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) or “ambulette” service operate solely under contract to funding agencies or their brokers. These contractors have far worse problems. Their “lead” or funding agencies are not even transportation bureaucracies (like transit agencies or departments of transportation), but usually healthcare agencies. In some cases, the lead agencies are not even healthcare agencies.. A few years ago, non-emergency services (NEMT, Medicaid and VA transportation) in New Jersey were “managed” by the state’s Department of the Treasury.

Paratransit services are also contracted out for the most part, where the lead agencies are mostly transit agencies. In small, rural communities, transit service to the general public is often demand-responsive; some of this is provided by public agencies while some services are contracted out.

Finally, a percentage of special needs school bus transportation is contracted out –often to those contractors which provide general education pupil transportation to the same school districts. This practice is less common because the students who use these services are far more vulnerable, and many school districts like to maintain tighter control over the quality of service. In contrast, transit and healthcare agencies responsible for paratransit and non-emergency services cannot wait to pawn off the responsibilities to deal with them to contractors, particularly as the contractors indemnify them, and “hold them harmless,” for all errors and omissions. When brokers are shoehorned in to relieve lead agencies from even the fumes of supervisorial responsibility, these agencies are insulated by two layers of indemnification.

Trends, Trials and Tribulation The significant amount of public transportation service contracted out reflects a number of factors including:

Contractors almost always provide the service for less money than public agencies.

•Contractors almost always provide the service for less money than public agencies –even accounting for the often bloated bureaucracies still ostensibly in charge of managing and monitoring service and the high costs of service, overall, as a result. While thoroughly indemnified, these lead agencies and brokers still control many of the most critical factors which affect safety. The most obvious of these factors are the design of routes, the selection of stops, the establishment of schedules and/or the assignment of trips.

•In the case of shared-ride demandresponsive services, they are usually contracted out because they are far more complex to design (when any semblance of design is even performed) and exponentially more complex to operate. Especially where design is non- or barely-existent, operations are even more complex. Transit agencies at least have transit bureaucrats in charge, and most agencies contain staff with varying degrees of skill in at least setting parameters for their scheduling software. The same is not true for school district bureaucrats. However, the complexity of demand-responsive school bus service (mostly for “special needs” students) is far less than paratransit or NEMT service. In special needs service, routes and schedules are largely the same from day to day, all year long (notwithstanding cancellations). Along with a greater concern for more vulnerable students, special needs school transportation is less often contracted out.

• Regarding fixed route general education school bus service, many or most school districts have a weak command of route design, stop selection and the array of things that can go wrong when they are not designed properly (see http://bit.ly/TAWhopiksstps; http://bit.ly/TAEvalStps; http://bit.ly/TADsmgBetwStps; http://bit.ly/TAStpPos; http://bit.ly/ TACrsOrient; http://bit.ly/TABsSpsLndMns). However, the same routes operate largely unchanged throughout the school year. Plus, for decades, routes, schedules and stops have been established by software (which simply optimizes the chaos from the lack of design). The principle issue related to contracting out service is cost.

•As noted, contractors are universally required to indemnity or “hold harmless” their lead agencies – effectively relieving themselves of any accountability for incidents. (Enlightened attorneys coupled with competent experts can usually pierce this accountability – even while the contractors pay for its monetary components.) In reality, lead agencies commit many errors and omissions which contribute to incidents, and/or which create an operating environment which makes it challenging and/or unprofitable for their contractors to avoid the risks.

•Unlike most public agencies, contractors’ drivers are typically not unionized. Even when they are (the larger contractors more commonly are), the lead agencies can screen out the onerous union provisions by disallowing them in the requests for proposals to which contractors are required to submit bids.

•Most elusive of these factors – and a central theme that will weave in and out of this series of installments – is that few plaintiffs’ attorneys bother to file against lead agencies or brokers who are often largely (and in some cases almost solely) responsible for the incidents. While excellent, honest hardworking plaintiffs’ attorneys exist, they hardly abound.

As a result of these and other factors, lead agencies effectively operate with near-complete impunity – again, often insulated by a second layer of brokers. With no accountability (or rare or marginal accountability at best), in a society lacking accountability in general,

As a result of these and other factors, lead agencies effectively operate with near-complete impunity.

contracting is a major force: With the cost savings, indemnification, elimination or minimization of union-related constraints and the avoidance of complexity, contracting is hard to resist. The problem is, of course, that contractors do not make many major decisions and are often victimized by hapless policymaking and planning decisions which lead to incidents for which they are most-often blamed – even where much or all of the errors and omissions are not their fault.

Immunity and Impunity

The degree to which impunity mirrors immunity varies considerably by mode. At one end of the spectrum, despite its many shortcomings (particularly its disinterest in systemdesignandefficiency),theschooltransportation community is vividly distinguishable from fellow modes in that officials, management and staff alike love and adore the passengers. At the other extreme – transit service and many paratransit services – officials, management and staff loathe the passengers.

This disposition is particularly true of disabled passengers and even more so for wheelchair users. Such passengers require more time (particularly wheelchair users –who must be loaded and unloaded via a lift or ramp even while their chairs are often not secured) and are clearly more trouble (and more confrontational since their wheelchairs are so often not secured – particularly on fixed route services). These passengers subject their transporters to greater “exposure” because of the body of regulations (mostly the Americans with Disabilities Act) designed to protect them. Particularly with the paucity of knowledge about, and disinterest in, designing paratransit services, costs for transporting these passengers by paratransit are dramatically higher than those for transporting them by fixed route services.

Motorcoach operations lie in between these extremes. Other than when contracted by transit agencies, their concern for passengers lies closer to that of school districts. Even where management and drivers may not care about passenger safety as a personal matter, the motorcoach operating environment revolves heavily around the notion of “customer service. ”

Motorcoach service is also peculiar in that it encompasses a mix of excellent safety features juxtaposed on a reckless disregard for other aspects of it. An example of this disregard is the common disinterest in fatiguerelated factors in the driver assignment process (see http://bit.ly/TADrFtg; http://bit.ly/TAHOSprobs.). Similar is the disregard for the likelihood of drivers possessing Obstructive Sleep Apnea (see http://bit.ly/TABusLag1; h t t p : / / b i t . l y / T A b u s L a g 2 ; h t t p : / / b i t . l y / T A B u s L a g 3 ; http://bit.ly/TABusLag4 and https:// bit.ly/3qA0sGp). At the other end of the spectrum, the concern for comfort often ropes in safety along with it. Plus many motorcoach practices and characteristics – such as the prohibition of standees, heavily-padded forwardfacing seats, pneumatic suspension systems and, since 2015, the requirement for the installation (not the usage) of three-point occupant restraints – provide significant safety advantages which transit service (provided with buses) does not.

Largely because of the factors cited above, more and more private transportation companies continue to operate under contract to public agencies and brokers. With the impunity these factors provide, lead agencies have increasingly asserted more and more control over key operating parameters. As they do – particularly when they sandwich in brokers to ostensibly oversee and direct operations – the decisions these agencies and brokers make are increasingly responsible for incidents in which their contractors are involved. In some cases, the operating environments created by these agencies and/or their brokers leave the contractors few reasonable opportunities to operate safely. As a consequence, compromises of passenger, pedestrian and motorist safety abound (see safetycompromises.com/ ).

Defending Contractors

Because of these factors and trends, defending contractors is gradually becoming easier – at least for those who understand the complex dynamics involved in both operations and the impacts which the evenmore-complex dynamics of the relationships among operating agencies, lead agencies and brokers create. This is not to say that contractors are never at fault; they are rarely solely at fault. In some cases – most commonly in the NEMT sector when contractors operate under the alleged “direction” of brokers – it is challenging to place much fault on contractors for even the worst incidents.

This reality is not easy for even a seasoned expert witness to learn. That is because so few attorneys are willing to file against lead agencies and, particularly brokers, particularly in certain sectors. (The reasons for this will be explored, in detail, in a future installment in this series.) The opportunities to review the relationships between contractors and brokers are usually limited, and most plaintiffs’ attorneys focus only on the smaller fish directly in front of them whose involvement can be understood or expressed in simple terms, and where the lawsuits require significantly less effort, less understanding and less cost.

Because the negligence is almost indefensible, I have always been reluctant to serve on the defendant’s side of a wheelchair tipover case. However, I recently departed from this pattern on a case where I agreed to help defend a nursing home whose staff members were blamed for a wheelchair tipover largely because the plaintiff’s attorney was too cheap and lazy to file against the broker which selected the contractor, governed its operations, poisoned its operating environment with reckless disregard and a degree of stupidity offensive to anyone with a modicum of knowledge about operations. Examining the evidence, I found the brokerage contract so onerous that it was almost impossible for a contractor to operate safely in the operating environment which the broker and its hapless lead agency had created. The unlucky contractor on whose vehicle the incident occurred was, in fact, scapegoated for the incident by the broker, and never assigned any further trips – effectively destroying the company. While I am not helping to defend that long-gone contractor, I learned along the way that it “never had a chance, ” and could only have regularly (if even occasionally) secured a wheelchair at great financial risk. The notion that the plaintiff’s nursing assistant – working for my carrier’s client – was responsible for it was preposterous.

In future installments in this series, I will explore the relationships between contractors and their lead agencies and brokers in great detail. Armed with such knowledge, and an expert who understands these dynamics intimately and has had experience dealing with them as a contractor, a contractor’s attorney (selected by its carrier) can learn about these relationships and defend his or her client. Of course, few or no attorneys read NATIONAL BUS TRADER (although many do review

The motorcoach operating environment revolves heavily around the notion of “customer service. ” Defending contractors is gradually becoming easier.

It is incumbent upon the readers of publications

like NATIONAL BUS TRADER to explain these relationships to their carriers’ counsel.

reprints of many of my articles in excellent attorney-oriented resources like the newsletter of experts.com). It is incumbent upon the readers of publications like NATIoNAl Bus TrAdEr to explain these relationships to their carriers’ counsel. These attorneys must, in turn, explain them to their carriers so that they permit their attorneys to make the effort needed to defend their clients when the facts provide grounds for doing so (or at least sharing the “damage pie”). Without connecting these dots, contractors’ carriers are simply going to permit their counsel to dance around a bit and try to lower the settlement value through the trio of lies, spoliation and shenanigans which comprise the defense in most cases where genuine fault exists at some level. Armed with this understanding, both carriers and their attorneys will have other and, usually, better choices.

The opinions expressed in this article are that of the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions of NATIONAL BUS TRADER, Inc. or its staff and management. q

Ned Einstein is the president of Transportation Alternatives (transalt.com [1]), a public transportation consulting/expert witness firm. Einstein (einstein@transalt.com) specializes in catastrophic motorcoach accidents.

Advertising works! National Bus Trader

(815) 946-2341

Absolutely the finest dump valve ever. •Air powered version since 1985. •All parts easily replaceable

DUPREE PRODUCTS Phone: (888) 668-4288 Fax: (905) 374-3796 www.dupreeproducts.com

Classified

Visit National Bus Trader’s Online Classified Ads at www.busmag.com

Classified ad rate is $30 per issue for first 25 words, 25 cents for each additional word. Rate includes Internet access. Name, address, zip and phone number are not included in word count. The total number of words in a classified ad can not exceed 70. Rates apply on each ad individually – the rate for multiple insertions is the total of each ad figured individually. Free classified ads are acceptable ONLY when submitted on or with your free classified ad certificate. Display advertising rates on request. 1 – BUSES WANTED

Seeking 102D3 converted by Custom Coach. Prefer motor home interior with side aisle or semi-side aisle. Please provide details by e-mail to safety@busmag.com or phone Larry at (815) 946-2341. 1940s White Model 788 or 798 wanted. 12 cylinder engine mounted under floor midship. Would like a complete original bus, but like to hear about parts buses. Contact Howard Lane, Hardwick MA 01037 at (413) 477-8790 or howard.lane@comcast.net. I

5C – MISCELLANEOUS BUSES

1982 BBC/GMC HR150G trolley bus. Brown-Bovari controls, running condition. Must dispose due to space limitation. Make offer. Contact Dale@trams.ca or phone (604) 325-9990 in Vancouver. I

6 – MOTOR HOMES FOR SALE

1956 Flxible coach –old conversion. Phone (802) 9482886 in VT for details. I

Next Deadline – April 15 for June issue 6 – MOTOR HOMES FOR SALE

2000 MCI DL3 Custom Coach conversion. Detroit Diesel engine and Allison trans. Sleeps 4-6, BA, shower, microwave, refrigerator, stove, generator, 4 aux. AC units, 2 flat-screen TVs, DVD, Bose speakers. No slides. Customize to suit. 185,208 original miles. Asking $72,500. All serious offers considered. Call (610) 868-6001, Ext 115. More pics and details at transbridgelines.com/busesfor-sale. I MCI MC5A ’67 (shell). 8V-71, 4-speed. For sale to highest bidder. Call (928) 358-6415 or (505) 713-9242 in AZ. I ’67 Flxible. Converted, 6V-92, 10-spd./OD, diesel generator. Recent $10,000 rebuilt –rebushed. Don’t see well; can’t drive and enjoy. Best offer over $17,500. Needs TLC. Phone Chet at (269) 445-0641 in MI. I

10 – PARTS AND EQUIPMENT

6V-92T Detroit Diesel engine. Fresh overhaul. In storage. Spent $4,700. Make offer. Phone (815) 262-0587 in IL. I

14 – NOTICES

Visit our 35+ vintage buses at Lakewood NJ Bus Terminal Saturdays. Join Friends NJ Transport Heritage Center. www.friendsnjthc.org. Annual dues $30. Call Tom at (732) 833-1213. I

Please mention National Bus Trader when answering advertisers

Advertiser’s Index

City of Fort Madison . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .27 Complete Coach Works . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .19 dupree . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .34 FMCa . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .15

irizar usa . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .2

Midwest Bus Corporation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .7 Morse Farm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .34

Motor Coach industries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .38

ronald reagan Presidential Foundation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .19 royal star . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .34 temsa Global . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .37

texan theatre Greenville . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .19

united Motor Coach association . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .35

ZF . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .11

15 – MISCELLANEOUS Wanted: Original upholstery for AC Transit 800-900 Series Fishbowl. Gold and blue striped pattern used on bucketstyle seats. Used seat covers acceptable. Contact Ed at enapiwoc@aol.com. I

Down The Road

Coming events of interest to readers of NatioNalBustrader. submissions for the department should be directed to the editor. unless otherwise indicated, events are not open to the general public.

July 7-10, 2021. FMCA's 103rd International Convention and RV Expo. Cam-Plex Multi-event Facilities, Gillette, Wyoming. August 25-29, 2021. Flxible Bus Rally. loudonville, ohio.

August 31-September 3, 2021. American Public Transportation Association (APTA) EXPO 2021. anaheim, California. For information visit www.aptaexpo.com. November 14-18, 2021. NTA Travel Exchange. Cleveland, ohio.

March 15-18, 2023. FMCA's 107th International Convention and RV Expo. Georgia National Fairgrounds and agricenter, Perry, Georgia.

Rolling ahead with reliable coaches, service, and support.

Reliability Driven™