FLAT TOP INNOVATION
The first of Britain’s much-heralded new aircraft carriers is moving towards sea trials this year, to be followed by flight trials in 2018 and operational service starting in 2020. The ships have demanded innovation in many fields, not least in the development of a completely new protective coating for their flight decks.
T
seat, single-engine, all-weather stealth multirole fighters, designed to perform ground attack and air defence missions. For carrier-based operations they will be using their Short Take-Off and Vertical Landing (STOVL) capability.
QUEEN AND PRINCE The HMS Queen Elizabeth and HMS Prince of Wales will be the Royal Navy’s biggest ships in history, each built with 40,000 tonnes of steel and requiring a total of 1.5 million square metres of paintwork, equivalent to slightly more than the size of Hyde Park. Their flight decks are the size of three football pitches (19,500m2). This is the business area, where Lockheed Martin F-35 Lightning II jets, operated in combination by the Royal Navy and the RAF, will take off and land. Also known as the Joint Strike Fighter (JSF), these are single-
ROCK AND ROLL Normally the flight decks of aircraft carriers are coated with an anti-slip paint to prevent aircraft from losing control as they take off and land, and also keeping the crew safe. Those coatings are adequate for the short take-offs of the Joint Strike Fighters, which nevertheless involve powerful downward jet efflux and high temperatures – much more than created by the old Harrier jump jet. But on the new carriers the aircraft landings will be vertical, and the aerothermal effects would far exceed the tolerances of normal flight deck coatings. The requirements demanded that a completely new coating solution be developed, and with it a completely new application system. To add to the difficulty, the coatings were to be applied outdoors at the naval yards in Fife, Scotland – where the weather conditions alone present a significant challenge.
he carriers will be host to a new generation of multi-role aircraft. The vertical landings these will perform on the carrier decks create blast furnace temperatures from their jet exhausts, and extreme jetwash. Besides surviving this heat and pressure, the landing areas have to maintain a non-slip surface to prevent the aircraft skidding as the ships pitch and yaw at sea. These two demands, seemingly in direct conflict, had to be solved with a new type of coating for the ships to operate as intended.
8 January-March 2017
UP FRONT
THERMAL METAL The new coating, developed specifically for the carriers by Monitor Coatings of North Shields, is an innovative thermal metal material. It can withstand the high temperature and pressure from aircraft exhausts, yet still provide sufficient friction for the aircraft undercarriage and safety for ground crews. It also protects the decks from the weather and contains the flight deck markings. The JSF’s jet exhaust gases reach temperatures of more than 920°C and generate immense thrust and efflux. Built around a combination of aluminium and titanium, the new thermal metal coating goes even further – it can withstand temperatures of up to 1,500°C (2,700°F). The coating is being applied to the designated landing spots using a specially developed robotic spray, which fires metal atomised from wire through a jet of plasma at temperatures of almost 10,000°C (18,000°F). The molten droplets then flatten and quickly solidify, creating a tough but rough coating 1.2mm thick that is bonded to the steel beneath. Monitor Coatings, a technology leader for
surface engineering in extreme environments, were invited to tender in a competitive bid along with many other coatings companies in the UK. The company is part of Castolin Eutectic and provides wear protection services for aerospace, oil & gas, steel and other industries from facilities in the UK, Singapore and China. Monitor say: “Our starting point in the coating design was to understand the parameters and operating conditions from a very broad brief offered by Thales. With our knowledge of Aerospace coatings we designed a system that could cope with strength, thermal shock, marine environments and the ability to be textured to provide the anti-skid characteristics required. “The initial design parameters were very broad: a replacement for conventional paint that could withstand the gas wash effect generated from the F32B MkII Lightning Strike while operating in a marine environment. The thickness of the coating and final surface texture elements were developed jointly with the Aircraft Carrier Alliance (ACA) and Monitor. “Once we established the base parameters, primarily from experience, we used a finite
January-March 2017 9
UP FRONT
THE THERMAL COATING IS APPLIED ON THREE OF THE CARRIER'S FIVE LANDING SPOTS TO PROVIDE OPERATIONAL CAPABILITIES FOR THE JSF. IT WAS DETERMINED THAT AT TAKEOFF SPEED USING THE CARRIER'S RAMP, THE REGULAR NON-SLIP COATINGS WON'T BE ADVERSELY AFFECTED. Checking the profile on a landing spot
element and finite volume analysis model to predict the results we needed. These were then added to the system and fine-tuned to compensate for off-site working. A digital approach meant that we could save time and money and avoid a vast number of iterations with multiple variables. “Work started back in mid-2009 with a break between summer 2010 and summer 2011. The development process was however gated. First we had to submit standard coatings for third party testing. The tender process was then won on the back of the test results. Following this we conducted the modelling phase, proofed on a pilot deck situated at Monitor. The first real transition to ship deck production was in August 2015.” ON THE DECK Working for the Aircraft Carrier Alliance, Flight Deck and Coating Manager David Thomson, and Monitor Coatings Project Manager Chris Castiglione had to make sure that the new coating could successfully be applied, and that it would work in operational conditions. They told PCE: “The thermal coating is applied on three of the carrier’s five landing spots to provide operational capabilities for the JSF. It was determined that at takeoff speed using the carrier’s ramp, the regular non-slip coatings won’t be adversely affected. The aero-thermal effects on the landing spots however would survive only a few aircraft evolutions. “The rest of the flight deck is covered with a non-slip coating similar to that used on any other warship. But for these carriers the JSF is configured as STVL – Short Takeoff Vertical Landing. It creates a combination of temperature, pressure and velocity that would dramatically reduce the longevity of a normal non-slip coating.”
10 January-March 2017
ROLLING DRUM After passing laboratory trials, the solution was tested to see that it would achieve the required coefficient of friction through rolling drum trials. It was also necessary to demonstrate that the coating could practically be applied to large areas of the flight deck. A trial area on the deck was used to prove the application technology. The tests included the tenting and containment needed to ensure that the environmental conditions were suitable for the application, which was undertaken during one of the wettest and stormiest winters on record. Application of the coating is via an Arc Spray system, similar in concept to an inkjet printer. The concept of Arc Spray is not new in the building of large vessels such as oil rigs, bridges and steel hull boats, but generally involves standard coatings such as aluminium or zinc which are often applied manually. Monitor say this new type of use is a first. Development work culminated in a two day demonstration of the process application, quality system and in-service repair program of the Thermal Metal Spray to the Aircraft Carrier Alliance and stakeholders, well received by senior naval officers and civilians from the marine engineering community. TEMPERATURE CONTROL Thompson and Castiglione continue: “Preps for the coating is by far the hardest part of the coating operation. Initially we had to prove that the coating could be successfully applied in a factory environment, then in 2015 we proved that it could successfully be applied on a noncritical area of the deck by laying a runwaysized area on a non-operational section.
UP FRONT
“The application requires a dry, clean temperature controlled area. Preparing the steel deck was the longest part of the operation. Specific blast criteria had to be achieved, and the blast profile was tested at the BAE testing facility in Warton, Lancashire. The blast profile details are proprietary knowledge but they include a cleanliness level of SA3 and profile characteristics with defined criteria for the distance between peaks, hook sharpness, and depth. “We blasted with aluminium oxide. Naturally the procedure creates a large volume of aluminium dust that has to be controlled and collected. Completing the coating in the Scottish weather at the navel yard in Rosyth was certainly demanding. We used 24m by 40m enclosures to create a working environment of around 22ºC and 40% humidity, with 10 air changes per hour. Monitor coatings were responsible for the application and the blast standard, with help from other companies contracted for the actual blasting. “All application has to be done within 24 hours of surface preparation. The coating application itself is performed by robot. The thermal metal coating is a three-coat system. The robot applicator operates like an inkjet printer but tapers the coating out towards the edges, which are then overlapped. At the edges of the thermal coating there is another taper where regular non-skid coating is applied over the top. The nominal thickness for the thermal coating is 1200 microns.” LONGEVITY With any new coating and application technique there will always be questions about how it will stand up in use. Thompson and Castiglione say: “Longevity remains to be tested as the coating is new, but the normal non-skid application is expected to last three years, and we are hoping that the new coating will have a lifetime of double that.
“Maintenance is feasible within limits. Airworthiness is the prime factor. There would normally be a daily visual inspection of the flight deck areas, and any foreign objects would be removed. If small areas of damage were discovered at sea, onboard maintenance might consist of cutting out damaged material and patching with regular non-skid coating.” After the success of the trial area the coating has been extended to approximately 2,000 square metres of the 19,000 square metre flight deck, with the work due to be completed prior to sea trials in early 2017. The remainder of the flight deck will have a conventional non-slip coating applied. Ian Booth, Managing Director of the Aircraft Carrier Alliance, said: “There is incredible momentum behind the programme to prepare HMS Queen Elizabeth for sea trials and integrate the F-35B Lightning II aircraft. Working with experts in the UK, we have developed a unique coating to provide the necessary protection to the flight deck of the aircraft carriers and this will ensure they can deliver the UK’s carrier strike capability for the next fifty years.” BIGGEST EVER The UK lost its carrier aircraft capability with the retirement of the Harrier jump jet fighters in 2010 and the scrapping of its HMS Invincibleclass carriers. The two new carriers will each have a displacement of 65000 tons, which is three times the current Invincible class. Their range will be 8 – 10,000 nautical miles, with propulsion coming through has two propellers outputting 80MW of power (enough to run 1,000 family cards or 50 high speed trains). The propellers themselves weigh 33 tonnes each. The height of the ships from keel to masthead will be 56 metres.
January-March 2017 13
UP FRONT
At a cost of more than £6 billion each, both carriers will accommodate up to 40 rotary and fixed wing aircraft. The JSF jets will be housed below decks but can be brought to the flight deck by lifts in 60 seconds. The first ship, HMS Queen Elizabeth, was named on 4 July 2014, with commissioning planned for later this year, and initial operating capability expected in 2020. The second, HMS Prince of Wales, is scheduled to be launched this summer and commissioned in 2020. They will be versatile enough to be used for operations ranging from supporting war efforts to providing humanitarian aid and disaster relief. Captain Simon Petitt, Senior Naval Officer of HMS Queen Elizabeth, commented: “The new flight deck coating is one of the many 21st Century engineering innovations being incorporated in the Queen Elizabeth Class programme. As the largest warships ever built for the Royal Navy, these powerful ambassadors
14 January-March 2017
will protect UK interests around the globe for the next 50 years.”
THE AMERICAN WAY Thermal Sprayed Non-Skid (TSN) coatings are also now being used on US Navy aircraft carriers, some of which will carry similar jets to the UK’s new carriers. The coatings being used there were developed by the US Navy. Johnny Sanchez, Flight Deck Non-Skid Specialist for California-based South Bay Sand Blasting & Tank Cleaning (SBSBTC) has been directly involved in supervising applications. He says: “We are using titanium & aluminum on the Landing Helicopter Dock (LHD) class of ships due to the new type of aircraft that put out higher heat signatures than the previous vertical Harrier jets. This sacrificial coating is only applied to the spots on the flight deck where the deck is impacted by high heat, where the deck would buckle and crack the
UP FRONT
Sanchez ensures all non-skid and coatings application meets NAVSEA standards, and trains and supervises coatings inspectors
traditional non-skid coatings system. With 21 years experience of non-skid and other multiple coatings application, Sanchez ensures all non-skid and coatings application meets NAVSEA standards, and trains and supervises coatings inspectors. He continues: “Coatings for aircraft carrier decks have come a long way from general epoxies with high solvent content. Due to environmental regulations, nonskid coatings have gone up in percent solids to 90% resin & binder. With new resins like polysiloxane, non-skids now have good heat resistance and colour retention. “The most commonly used non-skid chemical makeup is polyamide primers and polyamine, due to their high resistance to solvents, chemicals, hydro carbons - and of course they do not break down in a highly corrosive environment like salt water. “Here in the States, the most common surface prep requirement is meeting the cleanliness standard of SSPC-WJ-2L (Ultra High Pressure Water Jetting) with allowable light flash rust. If a profile needs to be implemented then the surface prep would be SSPC-SP-10 near white blast, but this is rare in flight deck preservation operations.” ARRESTING Nuclear-powered aircraft carriers, known as CVN carriers, use arresting gear cables to enable aircraft landings. Due to their design the non-skid in the landing area must be nonabrasive, and the aggregate must not be hard or
16 January-March 2017
as dense. It must be capable of breaking down or ‘giving’ to the arresting gear cables as aircraft tail hooks catch them and cause them to slap against the deck. Sanchez explains: “Non-skid for CVN use is broken into two composition types, Abrasive & Non-Abrasive. “Normally the aggregate used is aluminium, which is a softer alloy. It’s used in the nonabrasive areas and identified as Limited non-skid, versus the general non-skid which uses very hard and dense aluminium oxide aggregate.” APPLICATION TECHNIQUES Sanchez says the application is mostly by roller: “For non-skid application with a life expectancy of one or three years, we use a hard core phenolic roller with a smooth surface which peeks up the non-skid, giving it its anti-slip surface. “The main requirement is spread rate. The non-skid range is ¼inch (6mm) to 3/8inch (8mm) thick, but that’s not how we calculate thickness - we calculate by spread rate as square footage divided by gallons. So the minimum allowance is 18 sqft per gallon (approximately 0.44m2 per litre) to a maximum 30 sqft per gallon (0.74 m2 per litre).” “Not much maintenance can be accomplished when the ship is out to sea. Due to the vast square footage, you would need the equipment and product to accomplish the preservation, and experience in operating the equipment. The Navy can only accomplish spot repairs.
UP FRONT
© Johnny Sanchez “We can accomplish full removal and replacement on helicopter carriers during a drydocking. CVN Carriers have too many moving parts so we can usually accomplish anywhere from 50% to 70% of the flight deck while other work gets done on the catapults, elevators, and other equipment.”
LIGHT WEIGHT COATINGS Saving weight can be a priority on board commercial ships and naval vessels. The designers of cruise ships, ferries, offshore support vessels and tugs often face weight constraints, but for military vessels, weight minimisation is always an important objective. However, there has often been a compromise between lightweight coatings and cost. Now, two of the specially formulated lightweight coatings from AkzoNobel’s International range have gained US Navy approval. These coatings are designed to combine all of the best features for exterior and interior decks with dramatic weight savings. The coatings offer an innovative new option both for commercial ships and navies. Both products, which can be used during new construction or at maintenance and repair, exceed the requirements set out in US Navy Military Specification standards and have recently been granted approval for their respective applications. THE PRODUCTS Intershield 5150LWT is a low solar-absorbing,
NORMALLY THE AGGREGATE USED IS ALUMINIUM, WHICH IS A SOFTER ALLOY. IT'S USED IN THE NONABRASIVE AREAS AND IDENTIFIED AS LIMITED NON-SKID, VERSUS THE GENERAL NON-SKID WHICH USES VERY HARD AND DENSE ALUMINIUM OXIDE AGGREGATE. high durability, lightweight, epoxy non-skid deck coating resistant to fuel and chemical damage from aircraft and vehicles. Together with the appropriate primer, the system has excellent anti-corrosive performance. It is the first approved non-skid coating that can be used for both ‘General’ deck areas and ‘Landing’ deck areas on board aircraft carriers. Since Intershield 5150LWT systems can be applied as an anti-corrosive epoxy non-skid deck coating in general areas, landing and run-out area coating system, it has the benefits of easier
January-March 2017 17
UP FRONT
one coating type system maintenance and less complex sea stores management on-board. Intershield 5150LWT is a low absorption coating which results in less heat from the sun passing through decks to spaces below. This cuts the load on air-conditioning units and saves energy. It also creates improved working conditions for ships’ crews and a better operating environment for sensitive electronic equipment. The most important characteristic of Intershield 5150LWT, however, is its light weight. It offers a 25% saving in weight over existing non-skid coating Intershield 6GV and is 60% lighter than the requirement set out in the MILPRF-24667 standard. Intershield 5150LWT has a low volatile organic compound (VOC) rating and was granted US Navy approval to MILPRF-24667 Type I and Type II; Composition G and Composition L categories in November 2015. It is therefore approved as a standard- and high-durability rollable deck coating and can be applied as an abrasive deck system in all areas that receive a non-skid deck coating. Intershield 5150LWT is coloured dark grey (FS Colour 36076) and is packaged in a sixgallon kit. It has a spread rate of one US gallon per 20-30 square feet and a drying time of 12 hours at 73oF (23oC). SELF-LEVELLING EPOXY Intershield 7100LWT is an ultra-lightweight self-levelling epoxy underlayment, with zero VOC, which can be used with or without primers as a primary interior coating either at new construction or for levelling uneven decks during maintenance and repair. Principal applications for this coating include the underlayment for non-skid exterior decks, and internally for mess areas, berthing spaces, passageways, galleys and wet areas including showers and heads. Intershield 7100LWT can reduce weight by
almost 60%. It has received US Navy approval to the MIL-PRF-3135 Type III, Class 2, Grade B standard with a content weight less than one pound per square foot at a thickness of one quarter inch, or 0.5kg per 100 square centimetres at a thickness of 64 millimetres. The coating requires little secondary surface preparation and can be top-coated with a range of products including tiles and carpet. The shiny coating is applied with squeegees or notched trowels directly to metal surfaces and does not require a primer. In addition to its zero VOC content, benefits include longterm corrosion protection, resistance to fuel and chemicals, self-levelling properties for easy application, suitability for shipboard areas subject to water, and no over-coating requirement. BENEFITS Weight savings are important for ship designers over a range of commercial and naval vessels. Cruise vessels, Ro-Ro’s, fast ferries, offshore support vessels and tugs are amongst the merchant ships and workboats in which structural weight can be a design constraint. Less weight in a ship structure can facilitate the carriage of more cargo and/or reduce throughthe-water resistance, adding speed, saving fuel and reducing CO2 and other emissions, including particulate matter, or a combination of both. In a military context, lighter decks save structural weight, adding to speed, reducing fuel consumption and potentially enabling the carriage of more armament. The use of Intershield 5150LWT non-skid coating on the entire flight deck of an aircraft carrier, for example, would save 22 tons, equivalent to one additional aircraft or significant volumes of additional munitions. The fact that both of these products have successfully completed the rigorous US Navy approval process demonstrates that their formulation is both robust and fit-for-purpose.
January-March 2017 19