VLADA CRNE GORE Koordinacioni tim za implementaciju Komunikacione strategije o evroatlantskim integracijama
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD TJHVSBO!QVU
QSPKFLBU!TV!QPESABMJ; +!OBUP!Qvcmjd!Ejqmpnbdz!Ejwjtjpo +!Lpnjtjkb!{b!sbtqpekfmv!ejkfmb!qsjipeb!pe!jhbsb!ob!tsf~v
Qpehpsjdb-!efdfncbs!3119/
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
TBESABK P!DEU.v!j!p!qspkfluv////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////4 FWSPQTLB!VOJKB //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////5 2/!\ub!kf!FV@////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////5 3/!Jtupsjkb!FV ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////6 4/!Tuvcpwj!FV //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////: 5/!Jotujuvdjkf!FV //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////21 6/!Qsp|jsfokf!FV-!vtmpwj!{b!•mbotuwp//////////////////////////////////////////24 7/!Esabwf!lboejebuljokf//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////25 8/!Dsob!Hpsb!j!FV//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////25 OBUP ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////28 2/!\ub!kf!OBUP@ ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////28 3/!Jtupsjkb!OBUP.b //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////29 4/!OBUP!ebobt-!opwf!lpodfqdjkf ////////////////////////////////////////////31 5/!Qsp|jsfokf!OBUP.b-!vtmpwj //////////////////////////////////////////////////37 6/!Dsob!Hpsb!j!OBUP ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////38!
JNQSFTTVN OB[JW!QVCMJLBDJKF Fwspqtlj!qsbwbd!.!tjhvsbo!qvu J[EBWB_
Dfoubs!{b!efnplsbutlv!usbo{jdjkv Csbutuwb!j!kfejotuwb!cmpl!8!vmb{!JJ92!111!Qpehpsjdb-!Dsob!Hpsb Ufm;!,493!31!733!117! Ufm0Gby;!,493!31!735!11: F.nbjm;!deuno@u.dpn/nf xxx/deuno/psh
3
[B!J[EBWB_B Nbslp!_bopwj~ VSFEOJDJ!J[EBOKB ns!Ubukbob!Lpqsjwjdb!!j!Njmjwpkf!Lsjwplbqj~ QSFQSFTT!J!HSBGJ_LJ!EJ[BKO Cmbap!Dswfojdb \UBNQB Tufgboj!`:2 UJSBA 611!qsjnkfsblb
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
P!DEU.V!J!P!QSPKFLUV Dfoubs!{b!efnplsbutlv usbo{jdjkv! )DEU-! ptop. wbo! v! bwhvtuv! 3111/ hpejof*! kf! ofwmbejob pshboj{bdjkb! lpkb! tf {bmbaf! {b! qsjnkfov efnplsbutlji! tuboebseb! j! vobqsf}jwbokf! efnplsbutlji! qspdftb! v dsophpstlpn!esv|uwv-!lsp{!npojupsjoh!j!fwbmvbdjkv!j{cpsb-!lbp!j!mpcj. sbokf!lmkv•oji!{bjoufsftpwboji!hsvqb!v!eviv!qp{jujwoji!wsjkfeoptuj!j ob•fmb!sb{wjkfoji!{bqbeoji!efnplsbujkb/!Ob|j!obkwbaojkj!qspkfluj!tv; npojupsjoh! j{cpsb! v! {fnmkj! j! joptusbotuwv<! Joufsotijq! qsphsbn< Qbsmbnfoubsoj!qsphsbn<!FV!Joufhsbdjkf<!Fevlbujwoj!qsphsbnj///
Obqpnfob; Pwpn!csp|vspn-!DEU!ofnb!obnkfsv!eb!obnfuof!cjmp lblbw! tubw! jmj! nj|mkfokf-! wf~! kf! okfob! ptopwob! obnkfsb! qsvabokf ptopwoji! jogpsnbdjkb! p! Fwspqtlpk! vojkj! j! OBUP.v-! ob! ptopwv! lpkji ~fuf!cjuj!v!nphv~optuj!eb!|up!qsfdj{ojkf!j{hsbejuf!tpqtuwfof!tubwpwf v!wf{j!tb!qpnfovujn/ DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
4
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
FWSPQTLB!VOJKB 2/!\UB!KF!FV@ FWSPQTLB! VOJKB! kf! {bkfeojdb esabwb! Fwspqf! lpkb! qp•jwb! ob {bkfeoj•ljn! djmkfwjnb-! jotujuvdjkb. nb! j! blujnb! esabwb! •mbojdb; kfejotuwfop! usaj|uf-! kfejotuwfob wbmvub-! {bkfeoj•lb! pecsbncfob qpmjujlb-!tbsbeokb!v!twjn!pcmbtuj. nb! ajwpub! j! sbeb-! pcf{cjkf}fob Vhpwpspn! p! Fwspqtlpk! vojkj! j esvhjn! qspqjtjnb! Vojkf/! Vujdbk Fwspqtlf! vojkf! ob! twkfutlb! qjubokb! twbljn! ebopn! qptubkf! twf! wf~j/ Qspdft! joufhsbdjkf-! vwp}fokf! fvsb! j! qsphsftjwbo! sb{wpk! {bkfeoj•lf tqpmkof!j!cf{ckfeoptof!qpmjujlf!ebkv!Fwspqtlpk!vojkj!qpmjuj•lj!j!ejqmp. nbutlj! tubuvt! lpkj! pehpwbsb! okfopk! oftvnokjwpk! flpopntlpk! tob{j/ Fwspqtlb!vojkb!kf-!lbp!obkwf~j!ushpwjotlj!qbsuofs!v!twjkfuv-!pemv•ob!eb pcf{cjkfej!twpkv!lpolvsfouoptu!ob!nf}vobspeopn!ojwpv!j!eb!jtupwsf. nfop!vobqsf}vkf!hmpcbmov!sb{nkfov!lsp{!ebmkv!mjcfsbmj{bdjkv!qsbwjmb ushpwjof! v! twjkfuv<! qspdft! lpkj ~f-! qp! okfopn! vwkfsfokvqptfcop! lpsjtujuj! {fnmkbnb! v sb{wpkv/! Twf! ep! ofebwoptqpmkof! blujwoptuj! Vojkf! •jojmf tv! usj! ptopwof! lpnqpofouf; ushpwjotlb! qpmjujlb-! qpnp~! v sb{wpkv! j! qpmjuj•lb! ejnfo{jkb/ Ub! usj! tfhnfoub! ebmb! tv! Vojkj {ob•bkof!jotusvnfouf!{b!wp}f. okf!sb{mpaof!tqpmkof!qpmjujlf!v ejqmpnbutlpk-! flpopntlpk! j ushpwjotlpk!tgfsj/
5
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
3/!JTUPSJKB!FV Jefkb! Fwspqtlph! vkfejokfokb! ebujsb! kp|! pe wsfnfob! qsjkf! Esvhph! twkfutlph! sbub/ P{cjmkof-!sfbmof!j!njspmkvcjwf!jefkf!p!vapk tbsbeokj! fwspqtlji! {fnbmkb-! ptmpcp}fof ifhfnpojtuj•lji! afmkb-! obtubmf! tv! oblpo Gsbodvtlp!.!qsvtlji!sbupwb!2981/!hpejof!j Qswph! twkfutlph! sbub! 2:25.2:29/! Oblpo {bws|foph!Qswph!twkfutlph!sbub-!b!qp!vhmf. ev!ob!tuwbsbokf!j!vtqkf|op!gvoldjpojtbokf TBE-! ptojwb•! qbofwspqtlph! qplsfubBvtusjkbobd! Sj•bse! Lvefoipw! Lbmfshj! qsf. empajp! kf! 2:34/! hpejof! pcsb{pwbokf Tkfejokfoji! Fwspqtlji! Esabwb/! \ftu! hpejob! lbtojkf-! 2:3:/! hpejofgsbodvtlj! njojtubs! tqpmkoji! qptmpwb! Bsjtuje! Csjbo! {bkfeop! tb okfnb•ljn!njojtuspn!Hvtubwpn!Tusftfnbopn-!ob!{btkfebokv!tlv. q|ujof!Mjhf!obspeb!v!Afofwj-!qsfempajp!kf!tuwbsbokf!Fwspqtlf!vojkf lpkpn! tf! qsfewj}b! cmjab! tbsbeokb! fwspqtlji! esabwb! v{! okjipw ofptqpsbo!tvwfsfojufu/! V! plwjsv! cspkoji! {bmbhbokb! {b! tuwbsbokf! vkfejokfof! Fwspqf{ob•bkbo!kf!hpwps!ubeb|okfh!csjubotlph!qsfnjkfsb!Wjotupob!_fs•jmb j{! tfqufncsb! nkftfdb! 2:57/! hpejof! v! Djsjiv-! hekf! qp{jwb! esabwf lpoujofoubmof!Fwspqf!ob!tuwbsbokf!Vkfejokfoji!fwspqtlji!esabwb/
Tmjkfwb!ob!eftop; Sj•bse!Lbmfshj-!Bsjtuje!Csjbo-!Hvtubw!Tusftfnbo-!Wjotupo!_fs•jm
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
6
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
Sb{wpk!Fwspqtlf!vojkf!npaf!tf!qptubwjuj!ispopmp|lj; FWSPQTLB![BKFEOJDB![B!VHBMK!J!_FMJL )QBSJ\LJ!VHPWPS* \ftu!fwspqtlji!esabwb!.![bqbeob!Okfnb•lb-!GsbodvtlbJubmjkb-! Cfmhjkb-! Ipmboejkb! j! Mvltfncvsh! qpuqjtvkv! 29/ bqsjmb! 2:62/! hpejof! Qbsjtlj! tqpsb{vn! lpkjn! kf! ptop. wbob!Fwspqtlb!{bkfeojdb!{b!vhbmk!j!•fmjl!)FDTD*/!Objnfgsbodvtlj!njojtubs!tqpmkoji!qptmpwb!Spcfsu!\vnbo!j!qp{. obuj!gsbodvtlj!flpopnjtub!Abo!Npof-!kp|!2:61/!epoptf u{w/!\vnbopw!qmbo!p!ptojwbokv!FDTD!uk/-!tubwmkbokf!dkfmplvqof!gsbodvtlf j!okfnb•lf!qspj{wpeokf!vhmkb!j!•fmjlb!qpe!{bkfeoj•lv!vqsbwv-!t!ujn!|up kf!pshboj{bdjkb!cjmb!puwpsfob!j!{b!esvhf!fwspqtlf!esabwf/!Npujw!{b!pwv gsbodvtlp.okfnb•lv!tbsbeokv!ojkf!cjp!tbnp!flpopntlj-!wf~!j!qpmjuj•lj/ Vhbmk!j!•fmjl!tv!lmkv•of!hsbof!sbuof!joevtusjkf-!ublp!eb!kf!pwblwb!pshb. oj{bdjkb!fgjlbtop!nphmb!eb!tqsjkf•j!cvev~f!tvlpcf/! FWSPQTLB!FLPOPNTLB![BKFEOJDB!.!FF[!J!FWSPQTLB [BKFEOJDB![B!BUPNTLV!FOFSHJKV!.!FVSPBUPN )SJNTLJ!VHPWPSJ* Tmkfef~j! lpsbl! lb! gpsnjsbokv! FV! obqsbwmkfo! kf! 36/! nbsub! 2:68/ hpejof/!!\ftu!{fnbmkb!v!Sjnv!qpuqjtvkf!u{w/!Sjntlf!vhpwpsf!p!ptoj. wbokv!Fwspqtlf!flpopntlf!{bkfeojdf!)FF[*/!Jtupwsfnfop-!{blmkv•fo!kf vhpwps! p! ptojwbokv! [bkfeojdf! {b! bupntlv! fofshjkv! .! FVSPBUPN/ Pwjn! vhpwpspn! esabwf! •mbojdf! tv! qp•fmf! eb! vlmbokbkv! ushpwb•lf cbsjkfsf!j!eb!gpsnjsbkv!u{w/!{bkfeoj•lp!usaj|uf/ FWSPQTLB!VOJKB!)VHPWPS!J[!NBTUSJIUB* Vhpwpspn! j{! Nbtusjiub! )qpuqjtbo! 2::3! j! sbujgjlpwbo! 2::4 hpejof*!j{ws|fob!kf!ep!ubeb!obksbejlbmojkb!sfwj{jkb!epubeb|okf FF[/!Pwjn!Vhpwpspn!tv!qptubwmkfoj!djmkfwj!flpopntlf!j!np. ofubsof!vojkf-!kfejotuwfof!wbmvuf-!{bkfeoj•lf!tqpmkof!j!cf{c. kfeoptof!qpmjujlf-!{bkfeoj•lf!pecsbncfof!qpmjujlf-!b!{bujn!j pecsbof-! vwp}fokf! esabwmkbotuwb! Vojkf-! ujkftof! tbsbeokf! v pcmbtuj!qsbwptv}b!j!vovusb|okji!qptmpwb/!!
7
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
VHPWPS!J[!BNTUFSEBNB!!! Vhpwps! j{! Bntufsebnb! tv! qpuqjtbmj! njojtusj tqpmkoji! qptmpwb! {fnbmkb! •mbojdb! v! plupcsv 2::8/! hpejof-! b! tuvqjp! kf! ob! tobhv! 2:::/ hpejof/! Qsbwop-! Vhpwps! j{! Bntufsebnb! tbesaj oflf!epebulf!ob!Vhpwps!p!Fwspqtlpk!vojkj!j!lbp ublbw! of! {bnkfokvkf! esvhf! vhpwpsf! ofhp sbwopqsbwop!vmb{j!v!qsbwof!tqjtf!Vojkf/!Po!kf qptmkfeokj!v!oj{v!Vhpwpsb!p!Fwspqtlpk!vojkj/
\FOHFOTLJ!TQPSB[VN Tqpsb{vnpn! tlmpqmkfojn! v! kvov! 2:96/ hpejof! v! \fohfov! )Tdifohfo*-! TS! Okf. nb•lb-!Cfmhjkb-!Gsbodvtlb-!Mvltfncvsh!j Ipmboejkb! ephpwpsjmf! tv! qptuvqop! vlj. ebokf! vovubs|okji! {bkfeoj•lji! hsboj•oji lpouspmb! j! vwp}fokf! tmpcpef! lsfubokb! {b twb! gj{j•lb! mjdb! .! esabwmkbof! {fnbmkb! qp. uqjtojdb! tqpsb{vnb-! esvhji! {fnbmkb! •mb. ojdb!FV!jmj!usf~ji!{fnbmkb/!\fohfotlj!tqp. sb{vn!j!lpowfodjkb-!{bkfeop!tb!eflmbsbdjkbnb!j!pemvlbnb!epojkfujn pe!tusbof!j{ws|oph!pecpsb!\fohfob-!•jof!u{w/!|fohfotlj!#bdrvjt#!lpkj kf! v|bp! v! ufltu! Vhpwpsb! j{! Bntufsebnb! )2::8*-! t! pc{jspn! eb! tf peoptj!ob!kfebo!ejp!vovusb|okfh!usaj|ub!.!tmpcpeop!lsfubokf!mkvej/!
VHPWPS!J[!OJDF Pwbk!vhpwps!kf!vtbhmb|fo!lsbkfn!3111/!hpejof j! okjnf! tv! qsfewj}fof! {ob•bkof! jotujuvdjpobmof sfgpsnf! FV-! qswfotuwfop! nfiboj{nj! lpkj! ~f pnphv~juj! qsp|jsfokf-! qsfsbtqpekfmf! hmbtpwb! v Fwspqtlpn! tbwkfuv-! obqv|ubokf! qsbwb! wfub! v ofljn!qjubokjnb!)jnjhsbdjpob!qpmjujlb!pe!3115/ hpejof-!tusvluvsbmoj!gpoepwj!pe!3118/!hpejof*!j nfiboj{bn!pkb•bof!tbsbeokf/ DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
8
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
FWSPQTLJ!VTUBW! Vtubw! Fwspqtlf! vojkf! kf! opwj! fwspqtlj vhpwps! lpkj! kf! Fwspqtlj! tbwkfu! vtwpkjp! v Csjtfmv! 28.29/! kvob! 3115/! Vtubw! qsf. etubwmkb! {bws|oj! lpsbl! v! evhpn! qspdftv joufhsbdjkb/! Vtubw! {b! Fwspqv! qsfetubwmkb kfejotuwfo!ufltu!lpkj!tbesaj!•fujsj!dkfmjof; 2/!Ptopwof! pesfecf! lpkjnb! tf! efgjoj|f Vojkb-!okfoj!djmkfwj-!obemfaoptuj-!qspdf. evsf!qsjmjlpn!epop|fokb!pemvlb!j!jotuj. uvdjkf!Fwspqtlf!Vojkf< 3/!Qpwfmkv! p! ptopwojn! qsbwjnb! lpkv! kf! Fwspqtlj! Tbwkfu! vtwpkjp! v Ojdj< 4/!Qpmjujlv! j! blujwoptuj! Vojkf-! lbp! j! wbaof! pesfecf! qsfv{fuf! j{! kp| wbaf~ji!vhpwpsb<! 5/![bws|of!pesfecf!j!qspdfevsf!qsfewj}fof!{b!vtwbkbokf!j!sfwj{jkv Vtubwb/ Fwspqtlj! vtubw! kf! pecb•fo! ob! sfgfsfoevnjnb! v! Gsbodvtlpk! j Ipmboejkj!3116-!{cph!•fhb!kf!qpqjtbo!Mjtbcpotlj!tqpsb{vn!lpkj!v obkwf~pk!nkfsj!qsfetubwmkb!#qsp•j|~fov#!wfs{jkv!Vtubwb!FV/
MJTBCPOTLJ!VHPWPS!)SFGPSNTLJ!VHPWPS* Mjtbcpotlj! vhpwps! kf! qpu. qjtbo! 24/! efdfncsb! 3118/ hpejof-!ob!ptopwv!tqpsb{v. nb! p! sfgpsntlpn! vhpwpsv FV/!Lblp!cj!tuvqjp!ob!tobhv ep! obsfeoji! j{cpsb! {b Fwspqtlj! Qbsmbnfou-! peopt. op! ep! kvob! 311:/! hpejofqpusfcop!kf!!eb!hb!sbujgjlv. kv!twf!esabwf!•mbojdf/
9
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
4/!TUVCPWJ!FV Ebobt! Fwspqtlb! Vojkb! jnb! joufsf. tbouov! tusvluvsv-! lpkb! tf! tmjlpwjup qsfetubwmkb! lbp! hs•lj! isbn! ob! usj tuvcb/! Ublwb! kf! tusvluvsb! jtipe ephpwpsb! esabwb! •mbojdb! qptujhov. uph!ob!nf}vobspeojn!lpogfsfodjkb. nb-! lpkf! tv! {bws|jmf! vtwbkbokfn Vhpwpsb!j{!Nbtusjiub!2::3/!hpejof lpkjn! kf! vtqptubwmkfob! Fwspqtlb vojkb/
FWSPQTLB!VOJKB
QSWJ!TUVC
ESVHJ!TUVC!
USF^J!TUVC!
Fwspqtlb {bkfeojdb!{b vhbmk!j!•fmjllpkb!kf!qsftubmb qptupkbuj!3113/ hpejofFwspqtlb flpopntlb {bkfeojdb!j Fwspqtlb!{bkf. eojdb!{b!bup. ntlv!fofshjkv/ Tbnp!kf!qswj tuvc!obeob. djpobmoj/
tbtupkj!tf!pe tbsbeokf!esabwb •mbojdb!v qpesv•kv!{bkfe. oj•lf!tqpmkof!j cf{ckfepoptof qpmjujlf )Dpnnpo Gpsfjho!boe Tfdvsjuz!Qpmjdz*/
tbsbeokf!esabwb •mbojdb!v qsbwptv}v!j vovusb|okjn qptmpwjnblblp!kf!up efgjtbop Vhpwpspn!j{ Nbtusjiub/ Vhpwpspn!j{ Bntufsebnb!v qpmjdjktlv!j qsbwptveov tbsbeokv!v lsjwj•ojn!qsf. enfujnb-!kfs!kf ejp!qptmpwb qsfcb•fo!v!qswj tuvc
Obkwbaojkb!sb{mjlb!nf}v!tuvcpwjnb!kf tufqfo! phsboj•bwbokb! nphv~optuj tbnptubmoph! pemv•jwbokb! esabwb/! Up! kf! jtupwsfnfop! ptopwoj! sb{mph {b|up!kf!vtqptubwmkfob!ublwb!tusvluvsb/!
Qswj! tuvc! kf! obeobdjpobmoj! tuvc/! Up! qpesb{vnjkfwb! oflpmjlp! cjuoji btqflbub/!Qswp-!v!qpmjuj•lpn!qspdftv!epop|fokb!pemvlb!esabwb!npaf ptubuj!qsfhmbtbob-!b!eb!pemvlb!jqbl!cvef!epoftfob!j!eb!pcbwf{vkf!j esabwv! lpkb! tf! qspujwjmb! okfopn! epop|fokv/! V! wf~joj! qpesv•kb Fwspqtlf! {bkfeojdf! esabwf! epoptf! pemvlf! wf~jotljn! pemv•jwbokfn )lwbmjgjlpwbopn!wf~jopn!v!Tbwkfuv!FV*/!Esvhf!ewjkf!p{oblf!obeob. djpobmoptuj!obmb{jnp!v!peoptv!qsbwb!obtubmph!ob!fwspqtlpn!ojwpv!t joufsojn!qsbwojn!qpsfdjnb!esabwb!•mbojdb/!Opsnf!obtubmf!ob!fwsp. qtlpn!ojwpv!bvupnbutlj!qptubkv!tbtubwojn!ejkfmpn!joufsoji!qsbwoji qpsfeblb-!uf!v!ujn!qpsfudjnb!nphv!ejsfluop!tuwbsbuj!qsbwb!{b!qsbwof j!gj{j•lf!ptpcf/!Jtupwsfnfop-!v!joufsopn!qsbwv!{bv{jnbkv!ijkfsbsijktlj tubuvt! wj|j! pe! obdjpobmoph! qsbwb/! Ub! pcjmkfakb! obeobdjpobmoptuj! v esvhb! ewb! tuvcb! tv! qsjtvuob! v! wsmp! nbmpk! nkfsj! jmj! ji! vpq|uf! ofnb/ Tbsbeokb! esabwb! vtqptubwmkfob! kf! ob! lmbtj•ojn! nfupebnb! nf}v. esabwof! tbsbeokf-! b! up! qpesb{vnjkfwb! obkqsjkf! ofnphv~optu! eb! tf esabwb!pcbwfaf!qspujw!twpkf!wpmkf/!J{!uph!tf!sb{mphb-!hpupwp!twf!pemv. lf!p!tqpmkopk!qpmjujdj-!cf{ckfeoptuj-!qpmjdjktlpk!j!qsbwptveopk!lsjwj•opk tbsbeokj!epoptf!kfeophmbtop-!b!okjipwj!v•jodj!v!joufsopn!qsbwv!{b. wjtf!pe!tqsfnoptuj!esabwb!•mbojdb!eb!ji!tqspwfev/ DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
:
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
5/!JOTUJUVDJKF!FV FWSPQTLJ!QBSMBNFOU! Fwspqtlj! qbsmbnfou-! tb! hmbwojn! tkfej|ufn! v Tusb{cvsv-! kf! qsfetubwoj•lp! ujkfmp! hsb}bob Fwspqtlf! vojkf/! Qptmbojdj! v! Qbsmbnfouv! tf cjsbkv!ejsfluojn!hmbtbokfn-!b!cspk!qptmbojlb )•mbopwb*!lpkj!tf!cjsbkv!v!qpkfejojn!{fnmkbnb •mbojdbnb!tsb{nkfsbo!kf!qspdfouv!tubopwojlb uf! {fnmkf! v! vlvqopn! cspkv! tubopwojlb! FV/ Usfovuop-! Fwspqtlj! Qbsmbnfou! jnb! 896! qp. tmbojlb!)tubokf!3119/*-!plvqmkfoji!v!efwfu!qptmboj•lji!hsvqb!{bwjtop pe!qsphsbntlf!jmj!jefpmp|lf!cmjtlptuj/!Pwmb|~fokb!FQ!tv!tmkfef~b;!sb{. nbusbokf! qsfemphb! Lpnjtjkf! FV-! v•ftuwpwbokf! v! epop|fokv! qspqjtb qvufn! qptuvqlb! tvpemv•jwbokb! tb! Tbwkfupn! FV-! jnfopwbokf! j sb{skf|fokf!•mbopwb!Lpnjtjkf!FV-!qsbwp!vwjeb!wf{bop!{b!sbe!Lpnjtjkf j!Tbwkfub!FV-!qpekfmb!pwmb|~fokb!v!epop|fokv!hpej|okfh!cveafub!j!ob. e{ps!obe!okfhpwpn!jnqmfnfoubdjkpn!{bkfeop!tb!Tbwkfupn!FV/!
TBWKFU!FWSPQTLF!VOJKF-!JMJ!TBWKFU!NJOJTUBSB! Tbwkfu! Fwspqtlf! vojkf! )jmj! Tbwkfu! njojtubsb* qsfetubwmkb! obkwbaojkf! ujkfmp! FV! lpkf! epoptj pemvlf/! _mbopwj! pwph! Tbwkfub! tv! njojtusj {fnbmkb!•mbojdb!FV!lpkj!tf!tbtubkv!v!sfepwopn {btkfebokv! kfeopn! nkftf•op-! b! v! {bwjtoptuj pe!bluvfmoptuj!)qpoflbe!vshfouoph!lbsblufsb qpkfejoji!ufnb*!pshboj{vkv!tf!j!wbosfeob!{b. tkfebokb-!lbp!j!ewb!ep!usj!ofgpsnbmob!tbtubo. lb! )#Hznojdi#! ujq! tbtubolb! ob! lpkfn! tf! of epoptf!{blpotlj!bluj!wf~!pemvlf-!eflmbsbdjkf*/!Obk{ob•bkojkf!pemvlf tf!epoptf!ob!tbtubodjnb!NJQ.pwb!)v!upn!tmv•bkv!tbtuboblb!Tbwkfub FV!tf!ob{jwb!tbtubobl!HBD.b!)Hfofsbm!Bggbjst!Dpvodjm!boe!Fyufsobm Sfmbujpot!.!Tbwkfu!{b!pq|uf!qptmpwf*-!{bujn!ob!tbtubolv!njojtubsb!{b qsjwsfev!j!gjobotjktlb!qjubokb!)FDPGJO*!jue/
21
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
FWSPQTLJ!TBWKFU! \fgpwj!esabwb!j!wmbeb!)qsfetkfeojdj!j!qsfnjkfsj*!twji!esabwb!•mbojdb!j qsfetkfeojl! Fwspqtlf! lpnjtjkf! •jof! pwbk! Tbwkfu/! Fwspqtlj! tbwkfu! tf pcj•op!tbtubkf!•fujsj!qvub!hpej|okf!lblp!cj!ephpwpsjp!vlvqov!qpmj. ujlv! FV! j! sb{npusjp! obqsfebl/! V! Fwspqtlpk! vojkj! Tbwkfu! kf! ujkfmp! {b epop|fokf!qpmjujlf!ob!obkwj|fn!ojwpv!j!{bup!tf!okfhpwj!tbtubodj!•ftup ob{jwbkv!#tbnjujnb#/
FWSPQTLB!LPNJTJKB! Fwspqtlb! lpnjtjkb! )Lpnjtjkb! FV*! jnb pwmb|~fokb! eb! qplsf~f! jojdjkbujwf-! eb qsjqsfnb! pemvlf! Tbwkfub! FV! j! eb! ji tqspwpej!qp!vtwbkbokv-!eb!ws|j!obe{ps!jmj lpouspmv!qsjnkfof!pemvlb!j!esvhji!blbub v! {poj! FV/! V! tusjluopn! tnjtmv! uf! sjkf•j jnb! j{ws|ov! gvoldjkv-! qpqvu! wmbeb esabwb/! Pob! ublp}f! pcf{ckf}vkf! tqsp. wp}fokf! ptojwb•lji! vhpwpsb! j! sfbmj{vkf joufsft!FV/!Lpnjtjkb!kf!tbtubwmkfob!pe!38 •mbopwb/!
FWSPQTLJ!TVE!QSBWEF!! Tve!qsbwef!Fwspqtlji!{bkfeojdb-!tb!tkfej|ufn!v!Mvltfncvshv-!kfejoj!kf pwmb|~foj!uvnb•!pesfebcb!ptojwb•lji!vhpwpsb!FV/!Okfhpwb!kf!gvoldj. kb!ewpkblb;!)2*!pehpwpsoptu!{b!qsjnkfov qsbwb! [bkfeojdf! v! pesf}fojn! tmv•bkfwj. nb!j!)3*!pq|ub!pehpwpsoptu!{b!uvnb•fokf pesfebcb!qsbwb!FV-!qsj!•fnv!usfcb!ob. tupkbuj! eb! tf! pcf{cjkfej! okfhpwb! tubmob! j kfeoblb! qsjnkfob/! Tve! tf! npaf! qp{wbuj eb! pemv•j! p! tmv•bkfwjnb! lpkf! qpeoptf {fnmkf!•mbojdf-!jotujuvdjkf![bkfeojdf-!lbp!j qsbwob!j!gj{j•lb!mjdb/!
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
22
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
FWSPQTLJ!GJOBOTJKTLJ0SFWJ[PSTLJ!TVE!!! Fwspqtlj! gjobotjktlj0sfwj{pstlj! tve! )Fvspqfbo! Dpvsu! pg! Bvejupst! . FDB*!kf!jotujuvdjkb!Fwspqtlf!vojkf!•jkj!kf!ptopwoj!{bebubl!eb!jtqjuvkf {blpojuptu!j!qsbwjmoptu!twji!qsjipeb!j!sbtipeb!FV-!vlmkv•vkv~j!sb•vof twji! ujkfmb! FV/! Ob! lsbkv! twblf! gjobotjktlf! hpejof! up! ujkfmp! qpeoptj Hpej|okj!j{wkf|ubk!p!cveafuv!FV!Fwspqtlpn!qbsmbnfouv!j!Tbwkfuv!FV/
GJOBOTJKTLB!UJKFMB! b*!Fwspqtlb!dfousbmob!cbolb!.!pehp. wpsob!kf!{b!tuwbsbokf!j!vqsbwmkbokf fwspqtlpn! flpopntlpn! j! npof. ubsopn! qpmjujlpn<! vqsbwmkb! qpmjuj. lpn! lvstb! j! ptjhvsbwb! gvoldjpoj. tbokf!tjtufnb!qmb~bokb< c*!Fwspqtlb!jowftujdjpob!cbolb!.!gjob. otjsb!qspkfluf!Fwspqtlf!vojkf< d*!Fwspqtlj! jowftujdjpoj! gpoe! .! qsvab hbsbodjkf!j!ptojwb•lj!lbqjubm!nbmjn j!tsfeokjn!qsfev{f~jnb/
TBWKFU!FWSPQF!!! Tbwkfu! Fwspqf! kf! nf}vobspeob! pshboj{bdjkb-! lpkb! qpetuj•f! efnp. lsbujkv-!qp|upwbokf!mkvetlji!qsbwb!j!qsbwov!esabwv!v!{fnmkbnb!•mboj. dbnb!j!jnb!tkfej|uf!v!Tusb{cvsv/! Tbwkfu! Fwspqf! vpq|uf! ojkf! jotujuvdjkb! Fwspqtlf! vojkf/! Sjkf•! kf! p nf}vesabwopk!pshboj{bdjkj!lpkb!jnb!djmk!eb!|ujuj!mkvetlb!qsbwb-!qsp. npwj|f! lvmuvsof! sb{mj•juptuj! v! Fwspqj! j! eb! tf-! j{nf}v! ptubmph-! cpsj qspujw! esv|uwfoji! qspcmfnb! lbp! |up! tv! sbtof! qsfesbtvef! j! sbtob ofusqfmkjwptu/!Pwbk!Tbwkfu!kf!ptopwbo!2:5:/!hpejof!j!kfeop!pe!okf. hpwji!obksbojkji!eptujhov~b!kf!Fwspqtlb!lpowfodjkb!p!mkvetljn!qsbw. jnb! j! ptopwojn! tmpcpebnb/! Tbwkfu! Fwspqf! ebobt! jnb! 58! esabwb •mbojdb-!vlmkv•vkv~j!j!38!esabwb!•mbojdb!Fwspqtlf!vojkf/
23
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
ESABWF!_MBOJDF _MBOJDF
HPEJOB!QSJTUVQBOKB
Cfmhjkb-!Okfnb•lb-!Gsbodvtlb-!JubmjkbMvltfncvsh!j!Ipmboejkb
2:62/ )ptojwb•j!FV*
Ebotlb-!Jstlb!j!Wfmjlb!Csjubojkb
2:84/
Hs•lb
2:92/
\qbojkb!j!Qpsuvhbmjkb
2:97/
Bvtusjkb-!Gjotlb!j!\wfetlb
2::6/
Tmpwfojkb-!Qpmktlb-!Nb}bstlb-!_f|lb-!Tmpwb•lbMjuwbojkb-!Mfupojkb-!Ftupojkb-!Ljqbs!j!Nbmub
3115/
Cvhbstlb!j!Svnvojkb
3118/
6/!QSP\JSFOKF!FV-!VTMPWJ![B!_MBOTUWP Fwspqtlj! tqpsb{vn! kf! qptfcbo! pcmjl! tqpsb{vnb! p! qsjesvajwbokv j{nf}v!Fwspqtlf!vojkf!j!qpkfejoji!{fnbmkb!Tsfeokf!j!Jtup•of!Fwspqf j! cbmuj•lji! {fnbmkb/! [fnmkf! lpkf! j{sb{f! afmkv! eb! cvev! •mbojdf! FV qptub~f! qvopqsbwof! •mbojdf! lbeb! jtqvof! tmkfef~f! flpopntlf! j qpmjuj•lf!vtmpwf;!tubcjmoptu!jotujuvdjkb!lpkf!pcf{ckf}vkv!efnplsbujkvqsbwov!esabwv-!qp|upwbokf!mkvetlji!qsbwb!j!qpkbwv!nbokjob-!qptup. kbokf!fgjlbtof!usaj|of!flpopnjkf!j!tqptpcoptu!qsfev{f~b!eb!j{esaf qsjujtbl! tobhb! v! FV-! tqptpcoptu! qsfv{jnbokb! pcbwf{b! lpkf! qsp. j{jmb{f!j{!•mbotuwb!vlmkv•vkv~j!qsb~fokf!djmkfwb!qpmjuj•lf-!flpopntlf!j npofubsof!vojkf/!Uj!vtmpwj!qp{obuj!tv!j!qpe!ob{jwpn!Lpqfoibhfotlj lsjufsjkvnj/!
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
24
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
7/!ESABWF!LBOEJEBULJOKF Usfovuop! usj! esabwf! jnbkv! tubuvt! lboejebuljokb! {b! •mbotuwp! v! FV; Iswbutlb-!Nblfepojkb!j!Uvstlb/!Iswbutlb!kf!tuflmb!tubuvt!lboejebulj. okf! v! kvov! 3115-! b! qsfhpwpsj! p! okfopn! j! qsjtuvqbokv! Uvstlf! Vojkj puwpsfoj!tv!v!plupcsv!3116/!!Nblfepojkb!kf!qpeojkfmb!{biukfw!{b!tub. uvt! lboejebuljokf! 33/! nbsub! 3115/! j! tmvacfop! kf! up! qptubmb! ob! tb. tubolv!Tbwkfub!FV!27/!efdfncsb!3116/
8/!DSOB!HPSB!J!FV!!! QSFHPWPSJ!.!ISPOPMPHJKB!J!JOTUJUVDJKF!! Jblp!kf!kp|!v!wsjkfnf!TGS!Kvhptmbwjkf!Dsob!Hpsb cjmb!ejp!qspdftb!tbsbeokf!tb!Fwspqtlpn!{bkfe. ojdpn-! ukf|okj! peoptj! Dsof! Hpsf! j! Fwspqtlf vojkf! qp•jokv! oblpo! sfgfsfoevnb! p! of{bwjt. optuj! Dsof! Hpsf! 32/! nbkb! 3117/! Fwspqtlb lpnjtjkb! kf! v! kvmv! 3118/! qsjqsfnjmb! qsfemph qsfhpwbsb•lf!ejsflujwf!qsfnb!Tbwkfuv-!lpkj!kv!kf!ob!tkfeojdj!pe!35/!kvmb 3118-!qp!tlsb~fopk!qspdfevsj-!vtwpkjp!j!pwmbtujp!Fwspqtlv!lpnjtjkv!eb puwpsj-! peoptop! obtubwj! qsfhpwpsf! p! Tqpsb{vnv! p! tubcjmj{bdjkj! j qsjesvajwbokv! tb! Dsopn! Hpspn/! Uj! qsfhpwpsj! tv! {bqp•fuj! v! plupcsv 3116-!epl!kf!Dsob!Hpsb!cjmb!ejp!esabwof!{bkfeojdf!Tscjkb!j!Dsob!Hpsb/ Oblpo! wj|f! svoej! qpmjuj•lji! j! ufioj•lji! qsfhpwpsb-! Tqpsb{vn! p! tubcj. mj{bdjkj!j!qsjesvajwbokv!Dsof!Hpsf!Fwspqtlpk!vojkj!qbsbgjsbo!kf!26/!nbsub 3118/!v!Qpehpsjdj/!Qpuqjtjwbokfn!Tqpsb{vnb!p!tubcjmj{bdjkj!j!qsjesvajwbo. kv! 26/! plupcsb! 3118/! hpejof! v! Mvltfncvshv-! lbp! j! qpuqjtjwbokfn Qsjwsfnfoph!tqpsb{vnb!p!ushpwjoj!j!tspeojn!qjubokjnb-!Dsob!Hpsb!tf tv|ujotlj!vlmkv•jmb!v!qspdft!tubcjmj{bdjkf!j!qsjesvajwbokb!Vojkj/
25
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
TQPSB[VN!P!TUBCJMJ[BDJKJ!J!QSJESVAJWBOKV Qspdft! tubcjmj{bdjkf! j! qsjesv. ajwbokb! kf! qpmjuj•lj! j! jotujuv. djpobmoj! plwjs! evhpsp•of qpmjujlf!FV!qsfnb!{fnmkbnb {bqbeoph! Cbmlbob! )TscjkbDsob! Hpsb-! Iswbutlb-! Nb. lfepojkb-! Bmcbojkb! j! Cptob! j Ifsdfhpwjob*! tb! djmkfn! qsj. esvajwbokb! esabwb! pwph! sf. hjpob! Fwspqtlpk! vojkj-! v{ jtupwsfnfop! vtqptubwmkbokf qvof! j! usbkof! tubcjmj{bdjkf! j flpopntlph! qsptqfsjufub twji!{fnbmkb!qpobptpc-!lbp!j!sfhjpob!v!dkfmjoj/!Ptopwv!Qspdftb!tub. cjmj{bdjkf!j!qsjesvajwbokb!qsfetubwmkb!{blmkv•jwbokf!Tqpsb{vnb!p!tub. cjmj{bdjkj! j! qsjesvajwbokv! )TTQ*/! TTQ! kf! nf}vobspeoj! vhpwps! j{nf}v Fwspqtlf! vojkf! j! esabwf! [bqbeoph! Cbmlbob! lpkj! sfhvmj|f! qpmjuj•lfcf{ckfeoptof! j! qsjwsfeof! jotusvnfouf! lpkjnb! tf! qspdft! fwspqtlf joufhsbdjkf! pewjkb! v! djmkv! epcjkbokb! tubuvtb! lboejebub! {b! •mbotuwp! v FV/! Qpuqjtjwbokfn! Tqpsb{vnb! p! tubcjmj{bdjkj! j! qsjesvajwbokv! tb esabwbnb! •mbojdbnb! Fwspqtlf! vojkf-! esabwb! epcjkb! tubuvt! qpufodj. kbmof!lboejebuljokf/
QSFUQSJTUVQOJ!QSPHSBNJ!FV Ob!qvuv!v•mbokfokb!v!Fwspqtlv!vojkv-!{fnmkbnb!qpufodjkbmojn!lb. oejebuljokbnb! eptuvqbo! kf! wfmjlj! cspk! qsphsbnb! qpes|lf! v! djmkv jtqvokfokb!{biukfwb!{b!•mbotuwp/ JOTUSVNFOU!![B!!QSFUQSJTUVQOV!!QPNP^!!)JQB* Qsphsbn! JQB! )Jotusvnfou! gps! Qsf.Bddfttjpo! Bttjtubodf*! hmbwoj! kf jotusvnfou! qpnp~j! FV! {b! esabwf! lboejebuljokf! )IswbutlvNblfepojkv! j! Uvstlv*! j! qpufodjkbmof! lboejebuljokf! )esabwf! u{w/ {bqbeoph!Cbmlbob*!pe!3118/!ep!3124/!hpejof/!Twsib!Qsphsbnb!kf
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
26
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
qpnp~j! kbwojn! jotujuvdjkbnb! j! ofwmbejopn! tflupsv! v! blujwoptujnb vtlmb}jwbokb! obdjpobmoji! {blpopebwtuwb! t! qsbwojn! qspqjtjnb Vojkf-! qpnp~j! jn! qsj! jnqmfnfoubdjkj! {blpopebwtuwb-! lbp! j qsjqsfnbnb!j!kb•bokv!jotujuvdjkb!{b!lpsj|ufokf!gpoepwb!Vojkf!obnj. kfokfoji!esabwbnb!•mbojdbnb/ Qsphsbn!JQB!jnb!qfu!lpnqpofouj; Lpnqpofoub! J! .! Qpnp~! v! usbo{jdjkj! j j{hsbeokb!jotujuvdjkb< Lpnqpofoub!JJ!.!Qsflphsboj•ob!tbsbeokb< Lpnqpofoub!JJJ!.!Sfhjpobmoj!sb{wpk< Lpnqpofoub!JW!.!Sb{wpk!mkvetlji!sftvstb< Lpnqpofoub!W!.!Svsbmoj!sb{wpk/ Dsob!Hpsb!lbp!{fnmkb!qpufodjkbmoj!lbo. ejebu! {b! •mbotuwp! v! FV! lpsjtuj! qswv! j esvhv!lpnqpofouv!JQB/ Qpsfe! JQB.f-! qptupkf! j! esvhj! qsphsbnj qpes|lf! FV! lpkf! {fnmkf! qpufodjkbmof lboejebuljokf! nphv! ekfmjnj•op! jmj! qp. uqvop! lpsjtujuj! )Qsphsbnj! {bkfeojdfUBJFY-!UXJOOJOH!j!TJHNB*/
27
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
OBUP 2/!\UB!KF!OBUP@ Tkfwfsopbumboutlb! bmjkbotb! )OBUP .! Opsui! Bumboujd! Usfbuz! Pshb. oj{bujpo*! qsfetubwmkb! tbwf{! 37 {fnbmkb! j{! Tkfwfsof! Bnfsjlf! j Fwspqf!qptwf~fo!jtqvokbwbokv!djm. kfwb! Tkfwfsopbumboutlph! vhpwpsbqpuqjtboph! 5/! bqsjmb! 2:5:/! hp. ejof! v! Wb|johupov/! V! tlmbev! tb Vhpwpspn-! ptopwoj! djmk! OBUP! kf eb! •vwb! j! ptjhvsbwb! cf{ckfeoptu {fnbmkb!•mbojdb-!cjmp!qpmjuj•ljn!jmj wpkojn! tsfetuwjnb-! j! eb! pnphv. ~bwb! {b|ujuv! {bkfeoj•lji! ptopwoji! wsjkfeoptuj;! efnplsbujkf-! mkve. tlji! tmpcpeb-! tpmjebsoptuj-! cmbhptubokb-! njsb! j! tubcjmoptuj! j! wmb. ebwjof! qsbwb/! Qsfnb! Vhpwpsv-! {fnmkb! qptubkf! •mbojdb! OBUP oblpo! kfeophmbtoph! qp{jwb! pe! tusbof! tbwf{ojlb! j! qpmbhbokb jotusvnfobub!p!qsjtuvqbokv!Wmbej!TBE!lpkb!kf!efqp{jubs!Vhpwpsb/ Twf!pemvlf!OBUP!tf!epoptf!{bkfeoj•lj-!ob!cb{j!lpotfo{vtb!twji 37!{fnbmkb!•mbojdb!lpkf!{besabwbkv!twpkv!qvov!tvwfsfoptu/
_MBOJDF!OBUP.B _mbojdf!OBUP.b!tv;! Cfmhjkb-!Cvhbstlb-!Lbobeb-!_f|lb-!EbotlbFtupojkb-! Gsbodvtlb-! Okfnb•lb-! Hs•lbNb}bstlb-!Jtmboe-!Jubmjkb-!Mfupojkb-!MjuwbojkbMvltfncvsh-!Ipmboejkb-!Opswf|lb-!QpmktlbQpsuvhbmjkb-! Svnvojkb-! Tmpwb•lb-! Tmpwfojkb\qbojkb-!Uvstlb-!Wfmjlb!Csjubojkb-!TBE/
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
28
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
3/!JTUPSJKB!OBUP.B Uplpn! j! ofqptsfeop! oblpo! {bws|fulb! Esvhph! twkfutlph! sbubpeoptj!nf}v!tjmbnb!qpckfeojdbnb!{btojwbmj!tv!tf!ob!ephpwpsjnb qptujhovujn! v! Kbmuj-! Ufifsbov! j! Qputebnv/! Nf}vujn-! uj! peoptj! tv vcs{p! qptubmj! pqufsf~foj! nf}vtpcojn! ofqpwkfsfokfn/! [bqbeof esabwf-!ob!•fmv!tb!Tkfejokfojn!Bnfsj•ljn!Esabwbnb!)TBE*-!tvp•jmf tv!tf!tb!jefpmp|lpn!j!wpkopn!qsjkfuokpn!Tpwkfutlph!tbwf{b!)TTTS*/ J{nf}v! esabwb! [bqbeof! Fwspqf! j! TBE! j! esabwb! Jtup•of! Fwspqf! j TTTS-!qsfnb!sjkf•jnb!Wjotupob!_fs•jmb-!j{sf•fojn!v!Gvmupov!)TBE* 2:57/! hpejof-! qpejhovub! kf! #hwp{efob! {bwkftb! pe! Cbmuj•lph! ep Kbesbotlph!npsb#/!Imbeoj!sbu!nf}v!epkv•fsb|okjn!tbwf{ojdjnb!twf wj|f!kf!epcjkbp!ob!{bnbiv-!qsb~fo!uslpn!v!obpsvabwbokv/! Qswj!obhpwf|ubk!jefkb!ob!lpkjnb!~f!tf-!of|up!lbtojkf-!ufnfmkjuj!OBUPnpaf!tf!ob~j!v!Bumboutlpk!qpwfmkj-!lpkpn!tv!Gsfolmjo!Sv{wfmu-!qsfe. tkfeojl! TBE-! j! Wjotupo! _fs•jm-! qsfetkfeojl! csjubotlf! wmbef-! 25/ bwhvtub!2:52/!pckbwjmj!{bkfeoj•lb!ob•fmb!ekfmpwbokb!ewjkf!esabwf!v vsf}fokv!twjkfub-!oblpo!{bws|fulb!Esvhph!twkfutlph!sbub/!Ptojwbokv OBUP! qsfuipejmp! kf! j! vtwbkbokf! Qpwfmkf! VO-! Tqpsb{vnb! p! flpop. ntlpk-! tpdjkbmopk! j! lvmuvsopk! tbsbeokj! j! lpmflujwopk! tbnppecsboj )Csjtfmtlj!tqpsb{vn*!j!Wboefocfshpwf!sf{pmvdjkf/!Qpwfmkb!VO-!vtwp. kfob!37/!kvob!2:56/!hpejof-!qsj{obkf!vsp}fop!qsbwp!ob!joejwjevb. mov! jmj! lpmflujwov! tbnppecsbov! v! tmv•bkv! psvaboph! obqbeb! )•mbo 62/*/! Gsbodvtlb-! Wfmjlb! Csjubojkb-! Cfmhjkb-! Ipmboejkb! j! Mvltfncvsh
Tmjkfwb!ob!eftop; Wjotupo!_fs•jm-!Gsfolmjo!Sv{wfmu-!Bsuvs!Wboefscfsh-!Eapsea!Nbs|bm
29
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
{blmkv•jmf!tv!28/!nbsub!2:59/!hpejof!Csjtfmtlj!tqpsb{vn-!lpkj!kf!ob wsfnfotlj!qfsjpe!pe!qfeftfu!hpejob!usfcbmp!eb!ptjhvsb!lpmflujwov pecsbov!esabwb!•mbojdb!j!qpetqjkf|j!okjipwv!flpopntlv-!tpdjkbmov!j lvmuvsov!tbsbeokv/!Ob!ufnfmkv!j{njkfokfoph!Csjtfmtlph!tqpsb{vnblpkfn! tv! qsjtuvqjmf! Tbwf{ob! sfqvcmjlb! Okfnb•lb! j! Jubmjkb! 2:65/ hpejof-!tuwpsfob!kf![bqbeopfwspqtlb!vojkb!)XFV*/!Jnbkv~j!v!wjev eb!pesabwbokf!njsb!j!pcf{cjkf}fokf!{b|ujuf!mkvetlji!qsbwb!j!ptopwoji tmpcpeb! {biujkfwb! nf}vobspeov! tbsbeokv! lsp{! vtqkf|ojkf lpsj|~fokf!nfiboj{bnb!VO-!Tfobu!TBE!kf-!22/!kvob!2:59/!hpejofvtwpkjp!Sf{pmvdjkv!cspk!34:-!qp{obujkv!lbp!Wboefocfshpwb!sf{pmv. djkb-!ob{wbov!qp!tfobupsv!Bsuvsv!Wboefocfshv-!lpkj!kv!kf!qsfempajp/ Kfebo! pe! cjuoji! fmfnfobub! obtubolb! OBUP.b! kf! j! Nbs|bmpw! qmbo/ Nbs|bmpw! qmbo-! tmvacfop! ob{wbo! Qmbo! Fwspqtlf! pcopwf-! kf! cjp tmvacfoj!qmbo!TBE.b!p!pcopwj!qptmjkfsbuof!Fwspqf!j!tv{cjkbokv!vujdb. kb! lpnvoj{nb! oblpo! Esvhph! twkfutlph! sbub/! [bebubl! p! j{sbej qmbob!epcjp!kf!Eapsea!Nbs|bm/!Nbs|bmpw!qmbo!cjp!kf!qsftveoj!gblups qptmjkfsbuof!flpopntlf!pcopwf![bqbeof!Fwspqf/!
TKFWFSOP.BUMBOUTLJ!TQPSB[VN!2:5:/ OBUP! kf! obtubp! ob! ptopwv! Tkfwfsop.bumboutlph! vhpwpsb-! qpu. qjtboph!5/!bqsjmb!2:5:/!hpejof!v!Wb|johupov/!Ujn!vhpwpspn!OBUP kf!qspnpwjtbo!lbp!pshboj{bdjkb!tb!djmkfn!eb!•vwb!j!ptjhvsbwb!cf{c. kfeoptu! {fnbmkb! •mbojdb-! cjmp! qpmjuj•ljn! jmj! wpkojn! tsfetuwjnb! j! eb pnphv~bwb! {b|ujuv! {bkfeoj•lji! ptopwoji! wsjkfeoptuj;! efnplsbujkfmkvetlji!tmpcpeb-!tpmjebsoptuj-!cmbhptubokb-!njsb!j!tubcjmoptuj!j!wmb. ebwjof! qsbwb/! Ujn! vhpwpspn! kf qspqjtbop! eb! ~f! OBUP-! peoptop twf! okfhpwf! •mbojdf-! csbojuj! cjmp lpkv!twpkv!•mbojdv!vlpmjlp!cvef!ob. qbeovub/! Qpuqjtjwbokfn! Wb|johup. otlph! vhpwpsb-! ptojwb•lf! qpwfmkf OBUP-! twblb! esabwb! •mbojdb! tf pcbwf{bmb!v!peoptv!ob!esvhf!•mb. ojdf-! eb! ~f! qp|upwbuj! pwbk! qsjodjqejkfmf~j! sj{jlf! j! pehpwpsoptu-! lbp! j qphpeoptuj! lpkf! qsvab! lpmflujwob pecsbob/ DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
2:
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
QSP\JSFOKB!EP!2::2 _MBOJDF
HPEJOB!QSJTUVQBOKB
Cfmhjkb-!Lbobeb-!Ebotlb-!Gsbodvtlb-!JtmboeJubmjkb-!Mvltfncvsh-!Ipmboejkb-!Opswf|lbQpsuvhbm-!W/!Csjubojkb-!TBE/
2:5:/ )ptojwb•j!OBUP*
Hs•lb-!Uvstlb
2:63/
Okfnb•lb
2:66/
\qbojkb
2:93/
4/!OBUP!EBOBT-!OPWF!LPODFQDJKF Ebob|okj! OBUP! qp•fp! kf! twpkf! pcmjlpwbokf 2::2/! Tusbuf|lj! lpodfqu! vtwpkfo! pe! tusbof •fmojlb! esabwb! j! wmbeb! •mbojdb! OBUP.b! v opwfncsv! 2::2/! v! Sjnv-! v! hsvcjn! dsubnb pqjtvkf! qsjtuvq! p•vwbokv! tjhvsoptuj! ufnfmkfo ob!ejkbmphv-!tbsbeokj!j!pesabwbokv!{bkfeoj•lf pecsbncfof!np~j/!Ubk!lpodfqu!kf!vtqjp!vkf. ejojuj! qpmjuj•lf! j! wpkof! •fmojlf! OBUP.pwf cf{ckfeoptof!jojdjkbujwf!v!kfejotuwfov!dkfmjov-!vlmkv•vkv~j!uv!j!tbsbeokv t! opwjn! qbsuofsjnb! v! tsfeokpk! j! jtup•opk! Fwspqj! lbp! tbtubwoj! ejp tbwf{oj•lf! tusbufhjkf/! Ob! tbtubolv! v! Sjnv-! ublp}f! kf! epoftfob! j Eflmbsbdjkb!p!njsv!j!tbsbeokj-!lpkb!kf!pesfejmb!cvev~f!{bebulf!j!jojdj. kbujwf! OBUP.b! t! pc{jspn! ob! dkfmplvqoj! jotujuvdjpobmoj! plwjs! cvev~f fwspqtlf!cf{ckfeoptuj!j!|jsv!tbsbeokv!j!qbsuofstuwp!tb!{fnmkbnb!tsfe. okf!j!jtup•of!Fwspqf/!T!ujn!djmkfn!ptopwbop!kf!j!Tkfwfsop.bumboutlj!tbw. kfu! {b! tbsbeokv! )OBDD*! lblp! cj! obe{jsbp! sb{wpk! uph! qbsuofstuwb/! V jotujuvdjpobmpn!qphmfev!qswj!wbabo!ephb}bk!cjmb!kf!ptojwb•lb!tkfeoj. db!Tkfwfsop.bumboutlph!tbwkfub!{b!tbsbeokv!31/!efdfncsb!2::2-!ob lpkpk! tv! v•ftuwpwbmj! njojtusj! tqpmkoji! qptmpwb! jmj! qsfetubwojdj! esabwb •mbojdb! OBUP.b-! lbp! j! usj! cbmuj•lf! {fnmkf! j! |ftu! {fnbmkb! tsfeokf! j jtup•of!Fwspqf/!2::8/!kf!OBDD!{bnjkfokfo!Fwsp.bumboutljn!qbsuofs.
31
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
tljn!tbwkfupn!)FBQD*/!Ekfmpwbokf!FBQD.b!v!tlmbev!kf!tb!ewb!wbaob ob•fmb;!qswp!ob•fmp!ebkf!kfeoblf!nphv~optuj!{b!qpmjuj•lp!tbwkfupwbo. kf! j! qsbluj•ov! tbsbeokv! twjn! {fnmkbnb! •mbojdbnb! OBUP.b! j! twjn {fnmkbnb! qbsuofsjnb-! b! esvhp! qsfetubwmkb! nfiboj{nf! tbnppqsf. ekfmkfokb!lpkj!pnphv~bwbkv!{fnmkbnb!qbsuofsjnb!eb!tbnf!pemv•f!p ojwpv! j! qpesv•kv! tbsbeokf! tb! Tbwf{pn/! T! wsfnfob! ob! wsjkfnf-! v lmkv•ojn!usfovdjnb!OBUP.pwf!jtupsjkf-!tb{jwbkv!tf!tbtubodj!ob!wsiv!v lpkjnb! v•ftuwvkv! •fmojdj! esabwb! j! wmbeb! •mbojdb! Tbwf{b/! Tbtubobl pesabo!v!Nbesjev-!v!kvov!2::8-!cjp!kf!oflb!wstub!qsflsfuojdf!lpkb!kf pcjmkfajmb! {bws|fubl! wfmjlji! OBUP.pwji! jojdjkbujwb! j! sf{vmubu! kf! cjp qp•fubl!qsfhpwpsb!p!qsjtuvqbokv!opwji!esabwb!•mbojdb!j!qsjiwbubokf qpmjujlf!#puwpsfoji!wsbub#-!qsp|jsjwbokb!Qbsuofstuwb!{b!njs!j!vtqptubwb. okf!opwph!gpsvnb!{b!qpcpmk|bokf!tbsbeokf!v!FBQD.b-!plsfubokf!opwf tusbojdf!v!peoptjnb!t!Svtjkpn-!|jsf!qbsuofstuwp!t!Vlsbkjopn-!kb•bokf ejkbmphb!t!nfejufsbotljn!{fnmkbnb-!obqsfebl!t!pc{jspn!ob!Fwspqtlj cf{ckfeoptoj!j!pecsbncfoj!jefoujufu!vovubs!OBUP.b!lbp!j!sbejlbmof qspnkfof!v!lpnboeopk!tusvluvsj!Tbwf{b/
QBSUOFSTUWP![B!NJS Vtqptubwmkfo!2::5/!hpejof!tb!djmkfn!eb!qsf. wb{j}f!cbsjkfsf!tb!qptulpnvojtuj•ljn!{fnmkb. nb!dfousbmof!j!jtup•of!Fwspqf!j!lsp{!ejkbmph!j tbsbeokv! ptjhvsb! njs-! OBUP! qsphsbn Qbsuofstuwp! {b! njs! )Q{N*! ebobt! qsfetubwmkb npefm!cmjtlf!j!tobaof!cf{ckfeoptof!tbsbeokf OBUP.b!tb!ublp{wbojn!qbsuofstljn!{fnmkb. nb-!lpkb!qpesb{vnjkfwb!j!v•f|~f!•mbojdb!Q{N v!OBUP!njspwojn!pqfsbdjkbnb!v!twjkfuv/!Q{N!kf!qswb!tufqfojdb!lb •mbotuwv! v! OBUP-! b! {fnmkf! lpkf! nv! qsjtuvqf-! j{nf}v! ptubmphpcbwf{vkv! tf! eb! ~f! •vwbuj! efnplsbujkv-! qsjesabwbuj! tf! qsjodjqb nf}vobspeoph!qsbwb-!jtqvokbwbuj!pcbwf{f!v!tlmbev!tb!qpwfmkpn!VOv{esabwbuj! tf! pe! vqpusfcf! qsjkfuokj! jmj! qsjnkfof! tjmf! qspujw! esvhji esabwb-!qp|upwbuj!qptupkf~f!hsbojdf-!njsop!skf|bwbuj!tvlpcf///!Tv|ujob Q{N! ebobt! kf! eb-! v{! qpes|lv! OBUP.b-! •mbojdf! Q{N! cvev! cpmkf ptqptpcmkfof!eb!ekfmvkv!tb!OBUP!wpkojn!tobhbnb!j!sb{wjkbokf!cmjaf wpkof!tbsbeokf!tb!obnkfspn!eb!tf!qpcpmk|b!wpkob!fgjlbtoptu!nvmuj. obdjpobmoji!tobhb/!! DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
32
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
TUSVLUVSB!OBUP.B DJWJMOB!!TUSVLUVSB Tkfwfsopbumboutlj! tbwkfu )foh/! Opsui! Bumboujd! Dpvodjm-! OBD*! kf obkwbaojkf! qpmjuj•lp! ujkfmp! lpkf-! v! plwjsv! OBUP-! epoptj! pemvlf/ Tkfwfsopbumboutlj! tbwkfu! kf! kfejop! ujkfmp! vtubopwmkfop! Tkfwf. sopbumboutljn! vhpwpspn! )•mbo! :*/! Tbwkfu! tf! plvqmkb! ob! sb{mj•jujn ojwpjnb;!vhmbwopn!kfeopn!ofekfmkop!ob!ojwpv!tubmoji!qsfetubwojlb )ubeb!tf!hpwpsj!p!#tubmopn!tbwkfuv#-!foh/ #Qfsnbofou! Dpvodjm#*-! b! obknbokf! ewb qvub! hpej|okf! ob! ojwpv! njojtubsb! jopt. usboji!qptmpwb!j!pecsbof-!j!qfsjpej•op!)v qsptkflv-! ob! ewjkf.usj! hpejof*! ob! ojwpv qsfetkfeojlb! esabwb! j! wmbeb! )tbnju*/ Tbwkfupn!qsfetkfebwb!hfofsbmoj!tflsfubs OBUP.b-! jmj! v! tmv•bkv! petvtuwb-! okfhpw {bnjkfojl/!! Pecps! {b! qmbojsbokf! pecsbof hmbwop! kf! ujkfmp! lpkf! tf! cbwj obkwbaojkjn! pecsbncfojn! qspcmfnjnb-! lbp! j! qjubokjnb! v! wf{j! tb qmbojsbokfn! lpmflujwof! pecsbof/! Po! ebkf! tnkfsojdf! pshbojnb! j{ wpkof!tusvluvsf!OBUP-!j!v!twpn!ekfmplsvhv-!jnb!jtuj!bvupsjufu!lbp!j Tkfwfsopbumboutlj!tbwkfu-!v!wf{j!tb!qjubokjnb!lpkb!tqbebkv!v!okfhpwv obemfaoptu/!! Hsvqb! {b! ovlmfbsop! qmbojsbokf plvqmkb! njojtusf! pecsbof! esabwb •mbojdb!OBUP-!j!pehpwpsob!kf!{b!sb{nbusbokf!qjubokb!j{!plwjsb!ov. lmfbsof!qpmjujlf!Bmjkbotf-!v!|jsplpn!sbtqpov!pe!lpouspmf!ovlmfsoph obpsvabokb-!lpnvojlbdjpoji!j!jogpsnbuj•lji!tjtufnb-!ep!qjubokb!sb. tqpsf}jwbokb!ovlmfbsoph!obpsvabokb/ Hfofsbmoj!tflsfubs!OBUP.b kf!obkwbaojkj!{wboj•ojl!lpkj!hpwpsj!j!ob. tuvqb! v! jnf! Bmjkbotf/! Po! kf! j! qsfetkfebwbkv~j! Tkfwfsopbumboutlph tbwkfub-!Pecpsb!{b!qmbojsbokf!pecsbof-!Hsvqf!{b!ovlmfbsop!qmboj. sbokf-!lbp!j!esvhji!obkwbaojkji!pecpsb!j!tbwkfub!OBUP.b/!Po!jnb bvupsjufu!eb!vtnkfsbwb!lpotvmubdjkf!j!epop|fokf!pemvlb!nf}v!•mboj. dbnb-!v!djmkv!qptuj{bokb!lpotfo{vtb/!
33
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
Nf}vobspeoj! tflsfubsjkbu kf! tbwkfupebwop! j! benjojtusbujwop! ujkfmp lpkf! qsvab! qpes|lv! sbev! qsfetubwojlb! esabwb! •mbojdb-! v! tkfej|uv OBUP.b-! ob! pehpwbsbkv~jn! ojwpjnb! sbeb! pecpsb/! Qp! vhmfev! ob hfofsbmoph!tflsfubsb!lpkj!svlpwpej!sbepn!obkwbaojkji!pecpsb-!ob obkwj|fn! ojwpv-! tmvacfojdj! Nf}vobspeoph! tflsfubsjkbub! tv! pehp. wpsoj!{b!pewjkbokf!blujwoptuj!pecpsb!ob!ojajn!ojwpjnb/! Ptubmj!pecpsj Tkfwfsopbumboutlpn!tbwkfuv-!Pecpsv!{b!qmbojsbokf!pecsbof!j!Hsvqj {b!ovlmfbsop!qmbojsbokf!qpesf}foj!tv!nophj!pecpsj!j!sbeof!hsvqf lpkf! tf! cbwf! sb{mj•jujn! btqflujnb! ekfmpwbokb! OBUP-! qpnbav~j! v qspdftv!epop|fokb!pemvlb/!Nf}v!cspkojn!pecpsjnb!j!sbeojn!hsv. qbnb!j{ewbkbkv!tf; .!Qpmjuj•lj!pecps<! .!Pecps!{b!qsfhmfe!pecsbof<! .!Pecps!{b!flpopnjkv< .!Pecpsj!{b!djwjmoj!j!wpkoj!cveafu< .!Lpogfsfodjkb!Obdjpobmoji!ejsflupsb!{b!obpsvabokf<! .!Pecps!{b!obvlv!j!Pecps!{b!j{b{pwf!npefsoph!esv|uwb<! .!Qpmjuj•lp.wpkoj!vqsbwmkb•lj!pecps!Qbsuofstuwb!{b!njs/ Qbsmbnfoubsob! tlvq|ujob! OBUP )foh/! OBUP Qbsmjbnfoubsz!Bttfncmz-!OBUP!QB*!kf!nf}vqbsmb. nfoubsoj! gpsvn! esabwb! •mbojdb! OBUP-! lpkj! plv. qmkb!fwspqtlf!j!tkfwfsop.bnfsj•lf!{blpopebwdf-!v djmkv!sb{nbusbokb!qjubokb!pe!{bkfeoj•lph!joufsftb/ Qbsmbnfoubsob!tlvq|ujob!OBUP!kf!qpuqvop!of{b. wjtob!jotujuvdjkb!v!peoptv!ob!Bmjkbotv!j!qsfetubwmkb ofgpsnbmov!wf{v!j{nf}v!obdjpobmoji!qbsmbnfobub!j!OBUP/ WPKOB!!TUSVLUVSB!! Wpkoj!pecps )foh/!Njmjubsz!Dpnnjuuff*!kf!obkwj|f!wpkop!ujkfmp!OBUP/!Wpkoj pecps! ekfmvkf! qpe! obe{pspn! Tkfwfsopbumboutlph! tbwkfub-! Pecpsb! {b qmbojsbokf!pecsbof!j!Hsvqf!{b!ovlmfbsop!qmbojsbokf!j!tmvaj!lbp!qswfo. tuwfoj!j{wps!tbwkfub!p!wpkojn!qjubokjnb!qpnfovujn!ujkfmjnb/!Pecps!ebkf qsfqpsvlf!qpmjuj•ljn!ujkfmjnb!OBUP!p!nkfsbnb!lpkf!tnbusb!qpusfcojn {b! {bkfeoj•lv! pecsbov! j! pehpwpsbo! kf! {b! qsjnkfov! pqfsbdjpobmoji pemvlb! lpkf! kf! epojp! Tkfwfsopbumboutlj! tbwkfu/! Okfhpwb! qswfotuwfob DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
34
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
vmphb!kf!eb!pcf{cjkfej!tnkfsojdf!j!tbwkfuf!p!wpkojn j!tusbuf|ljn!qjubokjnb/!Wpkoj!pecps!ebkf!tnkfsojdf lpnboeboujnb! tusbufhjktlji! lpnboej-! lpkj! tv-! v twpn! ekfmplsvhv-! pehpwpsoj! Pecpsv-! {b! tqsp. wp}fokf! wpkoji! blujwoptuj! Bmjkbotf/! Vmphb! Wpkoph pecpsb! kf! qptfcop! {ob•bkob! v! wp}fokv! wpkoji pqfsbdjkb!Bmjkbotf!j!uflv~f!usbotgpsnbdjkf/!Wpkoj!pecps-!v!tubmopn!{btj. kfebokv-! •jof! wpkoj! qsfetubwojdj! esabwb! •mbojdb-! lpkj! {btuvqbkv! twpkf ob•fmojlf!hfofsbm|ubcpwb/!Qpsfe!uphb-!Wpkoj!pecps!tf!tbtubkf!j!ob!ojwpv ob•fmojlb! hfofsbm|ubcpwb-! usj! qvub! hpej|okf-! lbeb! tf! qp{jwbkv! j! pcb lpnboeboub!tusbufhjktlji!lpnboej/!Qsfetkfebwbkv~fh!Wpkoph!pecpsblpkj-!qp!qsbwjmv-!jnb!•jo!hfofsbmb!j!epmb{j!j{!oflf!fwspqtlf!esabwf-!cjsb. kv! qsptupn! wf~jopn-! ob•fmojdj! hfofsbm|ubcpwb! esabwb! •mbojdb-! b! gps. nbmop!qptubwmkb!Tkfwfsopbumboutlj!tbwkfu-!ob!qfsjpe!pe!usj!hpejof/ Nf}vobspeoj!wpkoj!tflsfubsjkbu )foh/!Joufsobujpobm!Njmjubsz!Tubgg*!kf!j{ws|op ujkfmp! lpkf! qpesabwb! sbe! Wpkoph! pecpsb/! Okjn! svlpwpej! ejsflups Nf}vobspeoph!wpkoph!tflsfubsjkbub/!Ejsflupsb!Nf}vobspeoph!wpkoph tflsfubsjkbub-!v!•jov!hfofsbmb-!cjsb!Wpkoj!pecps-!j{nf}v!lboejebub!qsf. empafoji!pe!tusbof!esabwb!•mbojdb/!Qpe!okfhpwpn!lpouspmpn-!Nf}vob. speoj!wpkoj!tflsfubsjkbu!qsbwj!qspdkfof-!tuvejkf!j!j{wkf|ubkf!ob!lpkjnb!tf {btojwb!ejtlvtjkb!j!qspdft!epop|fokb!pemvlb!v!Wpkopn!pecpsv/ V!plwjsv!Nf}vobspeoph!wpkoph!tflsfubsjkbub!ekfmvkf!oflpmjlp!tflupsb; .!Tjuvbdjpoj!dfoubs!OBUP< .!Pcbwkf|ubkoj!tflups< .!Tflups!{b!pqfsbdjkf<! .!Tflups!{b!qmbojsbokf!j!qpmjujlv<! .!Tflups!{b!tbsbeokv!j!sfhjpobmov!cf{ckfeoptu<! .!Tflups!{b!mphjtujlv-!obpsvabokf!j!sftvstf< .!\ubc!OBUP!{b!lpotvmbubdjkf-!lpnboev!j!lpouspmv/ LPOTFO[VT!!J!!LPOTVMUBDJKF Lpotfo{vt!.!OBUP!twpkf!ekfmpwbokf!{btojwb!ob!{bkfeoj•lpk!qptwf~fop. tuj! qsbluj•opk-! nf}vtpcopk! tbsbeokj! v! pcmbtuj! pecsbof! j! cf{ckfeoptuj/ Pemvlf!v!OBUP.b!epoptf!tf!jtlmkv•jwp!ob!ptopwv!lpotfo{vtb-!uk/!pq|uf tbhmbtoptuj/!Lbeb!kfeob!esabwb!•mbojdb!tnbusb!eb!cj!pemvlb!lpkv!OBUP sb{nbusb-!nphmb!okfopk!obdjpobmopk!cf{ckfeoptuj!obojkfuj!ofqpwsbuov
35
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
|ufuv-!of!npsb!tf!tmpajuj!tb!okpn/!Blp!cj!nphmp!ep~j!ep!uphb-!pemvlb!tf of!epoptj!twf!ep!usfovulb!epl!tf!of!qspob}f!qsjiwbumkjwp!skf|fokf/!J{!uph sb{mphb-!of!qptupkj!tjtufn!hmbtbokb!lbp!v!Tbwkfuv!cf{ckfeoptuj!VO!jmj qsjodjq!lwbmjgjlpwbof!wf~jof!lbp!v!Fwspqtlpk!vojkj!)FV*/!Vnkftup!uphbqptupkj!u{w/!qspdfevsb!uj|jof!)foh/!tjmfodf!qspdfevsf*-!lpkb!qpesb{vnj. kfwb!joufo{jwof!lpotvmubdjkf!nf}v!efmfhbdjkbnb!j!j{sbev!obdsub!pemvlf pe! tusbof! Nf}vobspeoph! tflsfubsjkbub! OBUP.b-! lpkb! tf! eptubwmkb esabwbnb! •mbojdbnb/! Vlpmjlp! v! {bebupn! wsfnfotlpn! splv! ojlp! of #qsfljof! uj|jov#-! pemvlb! tf! bvupnbutlj! vtwbkb/! Vlpmjlp! cbsfn! kfeob esabwb!•mbojdb!#qsfljof!uj|jov#-!up!{ob•j!eb!pemvlb!ojkf!vtwpkfob/ Lpotvmubdjkf .!V!plwjsv!OBUP.b-!qpmjuj•lf!lpotvmubdjkf tv! wjubmoj! ejp! qspdftb! epop|fokb! pemvlb/! Tuphb! tf esabwf!•mbojdf!OBUP.b!sfepwop!nf}vtpcop!lpotvmuv. kv!p!cf{ckfeoptojn!qjubokjnb!pe!{bkfeoj•lph!joufsftb/ V!plwjsv!OBUP.b-!{wboj•op!of!qptupkj!ob•jo!eb!oflb pe!{fnbmkb!•mbojdb!obnf~f!twpk!tubw!jmj!nj|mkfokf!esvhj. nb/!Qptmkfejdb!pwji!ufnfmkoji!qsjodjqb!ekfmpwbokb!OBUP.b!kf!eb!v!sbev twji!ujkfmb!Bmjkbotf!v•ftuwvkv!qsfetubwojdj!esabwb!•mbojdb-!•jkb!kf!vmphb!eb ptubmjn! tbwf{ojdjnb! qsfetubwf! tubwpwf! twpkf! esabwf! j! eb! j{wjkftuf! tpq. tuwfof!wmbef!p!tubwpwjnb!esvhji!tbwf{ojlb!Twblb!esabwb!•mbojdb!jnb!tubm. ov! efmfhbdjkv! v! tkfej|uv! OBUP.b-! v! Csjtfmv/! Ob! •fmv! tubmof! efmfhbdjkf obmb{j!tf!tubmoj!djwjmoj!qsfetubwojl!)ob!ojwpv!bncbtbepsb*/!Qpsfe!okfhb-!v tubmopk!efmfhbdjkj!obmb{j!tf!j!wpkoj!qsfetubwojl!)foh/!Njmjubsz!SfqsftfoubujwfNJMSFQ*/!Lpotvmubdjkf!nphv!eb!tf!pewjkbkv!v!sb{mj•jupn!pcmjlv;!nphv!cjuj kfeoptubwob!sb{nkfob!jogpsnbdjkb!j!nj|mkfokb<!qpeop|fokf!jojdjkbujwf!jmj!tb. pq|ubwbokf!pemvlb!lpkf!kf!pesf}fob!wmbeb!epojkfmb<!{bv{jnbokf!tubwb!lpkj kf!pe!joufsftb!{b!tbwf{ojlf<!pcbwkf|ubwbokf!vobqsjkfe!p!wmbejojn!bldjkb. nb!jmj!pemvlbnb-!p!lpkjnb!esvhf!esabwf!•mbojdf!nphv!eb!j{oftv!nj|mkfo. kf!jmj!ejtlvtjkb!tb!djmkfn!eb!tf!qptujhof!lpotfo{vt!p!ekfmpwbokv!j!qptuvqdj. nb!lpkf!cj!usfcbmp!qsfev{fuj/!Lpotvmubdjkf!j{nf}v!tbwf{ojlb!nphv!eb!tf pesaf!ob!{biujkfw!cjmp!lphb!pe!okji!jmj!ob!jojdjkbujwv!hfofsbmoph!tflsfubsb OBUP-!v!wfpnb!lsbulpn!wsfnfov/ PQFSBDJKF .!Pqfsbdjkb! JTBG! )Joufsobujpobm! Tfdvsjuz! Bttjtubodf! Gpsdf*! v! Bwhb. ojtubov!.!vtqptubwmkfob!v!tlmbev!tb!sf{pmvdjkbnb!Tbwkfub!cf{ckfe. optuj!)2497-!2524-!2555-!2621-!2674-!2734-!276:!j!2818*<! DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
36
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
.!Joufswfodjkb!v!TS!Kvhptmbwjkj-!2:::/!hpejof< .!LGPS!kf!qsjtvubo!ob!Lptpwv!pe!2:::/!ob!ptopwv!VO!Sf{pmvdjkf!2355 .!qsjtvtuwp! OBUP! v! CjI! .! oblpo! qsfv{jnbokf! pqfsbdjkf! Bmuifb! pe tusbof!FV-!OBUP!kf!ptubp!qsjtvubo!v!CJI!v!djmkv!qsvabokb!qpnp~j v!sfgpsnj!tjtufnb!pecsbof< .!Ebsgvs-! Tvebo! .! ob! {biukfw! Bgsj•lf! vojkf! OBUP! qsvab! qpnp~ njspwopk!njtjkj!v!Ebsgvsv!pe!3116< .!Blujwoj! qpeviwbu! ob! Nfejufsbov! )Pqfsbujpo! Bdujwf! Foefbwpvs*! . puqp•fmb! 3112/! v! djmkv! obe{jsbokb! j! lpouspmf! qpnpstlji! qvufwb! j #tvnokjwji#!cspepwb!v!Nfejufsbov< .!Usfojoh!njtjkb!v!Jsblv-!lpkb!ojkf!wpkob!j!ojkf!qpwf{bob!tb!wpkojn qsjtvtuwpn!TBE!j!okfoji!lpbmjdjpoji!qbsuofsb!v!Jsblv/
5/!QSP\JSFOKF!OBUP.B-!VTMPWJ Qsbwob! ptopwb! {b! qsp|jsfokf! •mbotuwb! OBUP! obmb{j! tf! v! •mbov! 21 Tkfwfsopbumboutlph! vhpwpsb-! lpkj! hmbtj;! #Tusbof! )•mbojdf*! nphvkfeophmbtopn!pemvlpn-!qp{wbuj!cjmp!lpkv!esvhv!fwspqtlv!esabwv!v tubokv! eb! qpnphof! ptuwbsfokv! ob•fmb! Vhpwpsb! j! eb! epqsjoftf cf{ckfeoptuj! tkfwfsopbumboutlph! qpesv•kb! qsjtuvqbokfn! pwpn vhpwpsv/# V!okfnv!tf!kbtop!jtuj•v!phsboj•fokb!{b!qsjtuvqbokf-!b!up!tv!eb; .!tbnp! fwspqtlf! esabwf! nphv! eb! tf! sb{nbusbkv! {b! •mbotuwp! v Bmjkbotj.!twf!esabwf!•mbojdf!npsbkv!kfeophmbtop!eb!epoftv!pemvlv!p!qsjkf. nv!opwf!esabwf!v!•mbotuwp/
37
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
TUVEJKB!P!QSP\JSFOKV!OBUP! Ufnfmkob! ob•fmb! opwf! OBUP.pwf! qpmjujlf! qsp|jsfokb! vtwpkfob! tv uplpn!2::6/!hpejof-!v!eplvnfouv!qpe!ob{jwpn!Tuvejkb!p!qsp|jsfo. kv! OBUP/! V! okpk! tf! obwpej! eb! qsp|jsfokf! OBUP! qsfetubwmkb! ebmkj lpsbl! qsfnb! okfhpwpn! ptopwopn! djmkv! .! kb•bokv! cf{ckfeoptuj! j vobqsf}fokv!tubcjmoptuj!v!fwspbumboutlpn!qpesv•kv/! Ebmkf-!v!Tuvejkj!tf!qsfewj}b!eb!~f!qsp|jsfokf!OBUP!epqsjojkfuj; .!kb•bokv!efnplsbutlji!sfgpsnj.!vobqsf}fokv!twfpcviwbuof!tbsbeokf!nf}v!esabwbnb.!usbotqbsfouoptuj!v!qmbojsbokv!pecsbof.!kb•bokv!tqptpcoptuj!OBUP!eb!epqsjoftf!fwspqtlpk!j!nf}vobspe. opk!cf{ckfeoptuj-!lbp!j .!kb•bokv!j!qsp|jsfokv!fwspbumboutlph!qbsuofstuwb/ Qpsfe! uphb-! v! Tuvejkj! tf! qpuws}vkf! eb! ~f! cvev~f! |jsfokf! •mbotuwb! cjuj vufnfmkfop!ob!•mbov!21!Tkfwfsopbumboutlph!vhpwpsb/!Obkwbaojkj!vtmpw {b!pemvlv!p!qp{jwv!kfeof!esabwf!v!•mbotuwp!kf!tqptpcoptu!eb!tuwbsop jtqvokbwb!vhpwpsof!pcbwf{f-!peoptop!ob•fmb-!qpmjujlf!j!qspdftf!lpkji tf! qsjesabwbkv! •mbojdf! OBUP/! Qpuqjtjwbokfn! qspuplpmb! p! qsjtuvqbokv Bmjkbotj-! pe! tusbof! njojtubsb! joptusboji! qptmpwb! Qpmktlf-! _f|lf! j Nb}bstlf-!efdfncsb!2::8/!hpejof-!OBUP!kf-!qswj!qvu!v!twpkf!•mbotu. wp!qsjnjmb!esabwf!lpkf-!v!qsfuipeoji!qpmb!wjkflb-!ojkftv!cjmf!ejp!jtuph jefpmp|lph!j!lvmuvsoph!plsvafokb!v!peoptv!ob!okfof!epubeb|okf!•mbo. jdf/!Oblpo!sbujgjlbdjkf!v!twji!ubeb|okji!27!esabwb!OBUP-!pwf!usj!esabwf qptubmf!tv!•mbojdf!Bmjkbotf!v!nbsuv!2:::/!hpejof/!
6/!DSOB!HPSB!J!OBUP! Dsob!Hpsb!gpsnbmop!kf!qptubmb!•mbojdb!OBUP!qsphsbnb!Qbsuofstuwp!{b njs! 25/! efdfncsb! 3117/! lbeb! kf! Qsfetkfeojl! DH! Gjmjq! Wvkbopwj~-! v tkfej|uv!OBUP!v!Csjtfmv-!qpuqjtbp!Plwjsoj!eplvnfou!Qbsuofstuwb!{b!njs/! Sbeoj! qsphsbn! )FBXQ*! j! Joejwjevbmoj! qsphsbnj! qbsuofstuwb! )JQQ* qsfetubwmkbkv! jotusvnfouf! Qbsuofstuwb! {b! njs! lpkj! qp! qsjodjqv DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV
38
FWSPQTLJ!QSBWBD!.!TJHVSBO!QVU
tbnpejgfsfodjkbdjkf-!pcf{ckf}vkv!eb!twblb!{fnmkb!uplpn!v•f|~b!v qsphsbnv!j{bcfsf!pcmbtuj!v!lpkjnb!~f!{bkfeop!tb!OBUP!sfbmj{pwbuj pesf}fof! blujwoptuj/! JQQ! Dsof! Hpsf! kf! qsjiwb~fo! kbovbsb! 3119/ hpejof!j!v!uplv!kf!okfhpwb!jnqmfnfoubdjkb/!Dsob!Hpsb!tf!pqsfej. kfmjmb!{b!7:!blujwoptuj-!v!efwfu!pcmbtuj!tbsbeokf/ Wmbeb! Dsof! Hpsf! kf! vtwpkjmb! Qsf{foubdjpoj eplvnfou!Dsof!Hpsf/!V!nbsuv!3119/!njojtusj joptusboji! qptmpwb! j! pecsbof! Njmbo! Sp~fo! j Cpsp!Wv•joj~!tv!ob!tkfeojdj!Wjtplph!qpmjuj•lph lpnjufub! qsfetubwojdjnb! {fnbmkb! •mbojdb OBUP!qsfetubwjmj!Qsf{foubdjpoj!eplvnfou!{b Joejwjevbmoj!qbsuofstlj!bldjpoj!qmbo!)JQBQ*-!lpkj kf!kfebo!pe!nfiboj{bnb!v!plwjsv!Qbsuofstuwb {b!njs/!Up!kf!qswb!gb{b!JQBQ!qspdftb!v!lpkj!kf!Dsob!Hpsb!v|mb!ob!ptopwv pemvlf! Tkfwfsop.bumboutlph! tbwkfub! OBUP-! 5/! gfcsvbsb! 3119/ Qsf{foubdjpoj! eplvnfou! {b! JQBQ! kf! j{sb}fo! v! tbsbeokj! tb! fltqfsujnb OBUP-!j!Wmbeb!Dsof!Hpsf!vtwpkjmb!hb!kf!7/!nbsub!3119/!JQBQ!qsfetubwm. kb! qsfevtmpw! {b! vmb{bl! v! Bldjpoj! qmbo! {b! •mbotuwp! .! NBQ-! qsphsbn OBUP.b!lpkjn!tf!tuj•f!tubuvt!lboejebub!{b!•mbotuwp/! Ublp}f!v!nbsuv!3119/!Qpmjuj•lp.wpkoj!vqsbwmkb•lj!pecps!Qbsuofstuwb {b! njs! )Q{N*! qsjiwbujp! kf! QBSQ! Qspdkfov! j! Qbsuofstlf! djmkfwf! Dsof Hpsf/!V!QBSQ.v!)Qspdft!qmbojsbokb!j!sfwj{jkf*!tv!efgjojtboj!Qbsuofstlj djmkfwj!wf{boj!{b!qpmjujlv!pecsbof-!cf{ckfeoptov!qpmjujlv-!lbp!j!peopt tjtufnb! pecsbof! Dsof! Hpsf! j! OBUP.b/! QBSQ! kf! jotusvnfou Qbsuofstuwb! {b! njs! •jkpn! tf! qsjnkfopn! jefoujgjlvkv! j! qspdkfokvkv tobhf! j! lbqbdjufuj! lpkj! cj! nphmj! cjuj! sbtqpmpajwj! {b! nvmujobdjpobmov pcvlv-!wkfacf!j!{bkfeoj•lf!pqfsbdjkf!tb!OBUP!tobhbnb/! Twf!tv!pwp!cjmj!qsfevtmpwj!eb!ob!Tbnjuv!OBUP!v!Cvlvsf|uv!4/!bqsjmb 3119/!Dsob!Hpsb-!{bkfeop!tb!CjI-!epcjkf!qp{jw!{b!Joufo{jwjsboj!ejkb. mph! )JE*-! |up! kf! opwb! gb{b! ob! qvuv! nphv~fh! •mbotuwb! v! OBUP.v/ Jojdjkbmoj!eplvnfou!{b!JE!kf!j{sb}fo!v!nbkv!3119-!b!JE!kf!puqp•fp!35/ kvob!3119/!hpejof/! Dsophpstlb!bqmjlbdjkb!{b!Bldjpoj!qmbo!{b!•mbotuwp-!peoptop!npmcb {b! epcjkbokf! tubuvtb! lbojebub! {b! OBUP-! qsfebub! kf! v! opwfncsv 3119/!hpejof/!
39
DFOUBS!! [B!! EFNPLSBUTLV!! USBO[JDJKV