THE CHICAGO ARCHITECTURAL CLUB presents:
FUTURE PRENTICE
2012 CHICAGO PRIZE COMPETITION 71 entries / 13 countries Competition partners:
FIRST PRIZE Title: The Buildings are sleeping, you should go and wake them up, she says. Team: Cyril Marsollier Wallo Villacorta
The buildings are sleeping, you should go and wake them up, she said.
1T558
Nurture Two exibition sequences spiral through the emptied core.
7\SLFDO ÁRRUSODQ ² WR
1T558
Addition Vs. Demolition Self-functioning laboratory research facility.
th Flr Floorplan
1T558
Through an appreciation of the validity in Northwestern University’s (NU) need for a new IXQFWLRQDO IDFLOLW\ DQG WKH SXEOLF¡V LQWHUHVW LQ SUHVHUYDWLRQ FRQĂ LFWLQJ LQWHUHVWV FDQ EH UHFRQFLOHG with thoughtful negotiation. As is, Prentice Women’s Hospital cannot accommodate NU’s intended use of it as a lab research facility. Maintaining the existing structure celebrates the possibilities of free space. Introducing a third entity achieves the functionality of the desired research facility. The new volume embraces half of the existing structure while the intersecting facade preserves the complete iconic image of Prentice Women’s Hospital. The black volume is transformed to include an auditorium and thus anchors the connection between all other entities through mutual use. %HFDXVH RI LWV JHQHURXV Ă RRU SODQ YHUVDWLOLW\ DQG EHLQJ HPEHGGHG LQ D FXOWXUDOO\ ULFK HQYLURQPHQW Prentice effortlessly becomes a museum. The building engages in an automatic dialogue about the value of preservation and its marriage to un-manifested concepts. “[The buildings] are sleeping, you should go and wake them up, she says.â€? ² 5REHUW 0RQWJRPHU\
1T558
SECOND PRIZE Title: Superimpositions: Prentice as Additive Icon Team: Noel Turgeon Natalya Egon
ADDITIONS
/FMTPO "ULJOT .VTFVN PG "SU
0SJHJOBM #VJMEJOH t 8JHIU 8JHIU t "EEJUJPO t 4UFWFO )PMM t
ARoS - Rainbow Panorama 0SJHJOBM #VJMEJOH t 4DINJEU )BNNFS -BTTFO t "EEJUJPO t 0MBGVS &MJBTTPO t
Caixa Forum
0SJHJOBM #VJMEJOH t 6OLOPXO t T "EEJUJPO t )FS[PH EF .FVSPO t
Louvre
Boston Public Library
%JEEFO 7JMMBHF
0SJHJOBM #VJMEJOH t 1BMBDF t UI $ UP UI $ "EEJUJPO t * . 1FJ t
0SJHJOBM #VJMEJOH t T t "EEJUJPO t .73%7 t
0SJHJOBM #VJMEJOH t .D,JN .FBE 8IJUF t "EEJUJPO t 1IJMJQ +PIOTPO t
1700
2050 1750
1800
1850
1900
1950
2000
Chicago Federal Chicago, 1905 - 1965
Pruitt Igoe
St. Louis, 1954 - 1975
Stock Exchange
Chicago, 1894 - 1971
Singer Building
Mahattan, 1908-1968
Larkin
Penn Station
Buffalo, 1906 - 1950
Manhattan, 1910 - 1963
DEMOLITIONS
16
DEMOLISHED ADDITIONS
"O FYQMPSBUJPO JO BMUFSOBUJWF GVUVSFT GPS BMSFBEZ EFNPMJTIFE CVJMEJOHT CZ SFQSFTFOUJOH UIF DPFYJTUFODF PG XIBU XBT UIFSF BOE XIBU GPMMPXFE
4VQFSJNQPTFE JDPOJD BEEJUJPO UP $IJDBHP 'FEFSBM #VJMEJOH EFNPMJTIFE .JFT WBO EFS 3PIF UPXFST QPTU PïDF $BMEFS
4VQFSJNQPTFE JDPOJD BEEJUJPO UP 1FOO 4UBUJPO EFNPMJTIFE .BEJTPO 4RVBSF (BSEFO
4VQFSJNQPTFE JDPOJD BEEJUJPO UP 4JOHFS #VJMEJOH EFNPMJTIFE -PXFS .BOIBUUBO &YQSFTTXBZ VOCVJMU CZ 1BVM 3VEPMQI
ICON AS ADDITION " TFMFDUJPO PG QPTTJCMF JDPOJD BEEJUJPOT CBTFE QVSFMZ PO GPSN UP EJìFSFOUJBUF QFSJPET PG UIF UJNFMJOF
16
SUPERIMPOSITIONS "EEJUJWF FMFWBUJPO PWFS UJNF *UFSBUJWF DPNQPTJUJPOT
100 years
80 years
60 years
40 years
20 years
16
SUPERIMPOSITIONS 6SCBO *DPO
structure as icon
icons as icon
innovation as icon
utility as icon
corncob as icon
QSPHSBN BT JDPO
GPSN BT JDPO
16
THIRD PRIZE Title: Bridging Prentice Team: James Wild, Lauren Haras, Katherine Lee, Andres Lemus, Tom Marquardt, Pedro Melis, Aman Moayer, Kerry Rutz, Katelyn Smith, Ashley Wendela
URBAN PLANNING Our strategy is to offer a new green space and public plaza at the center of the Northwestern Medical campus. These green amenities will offer respite to patients, faculty, staff and the surrounding community, thereby creating a world destination for the new, highly public and iconic campus center.
N
The circulation ‘bowl’ you ascend to the elevated bridge offers picnic areas, views to the plaza and a landscaped, above ground park. The plaza below boasts an urban relief gesture, honoring Prentice by allowing it to become a sculptural object at a civic scale. The new lab building is intentionally modest and both veils and frames Prentice to celebrate the co-existence of new and old, making this center a new civic icon for the City of Chicago.
6LX88
BRIDGING PRENTICE Innovation is built on a foundation of knowledge gathered by those before us. Bertrand Goldberg’s Prentice Hospital was an innovative engineering feat that changed the course of modern healthcare when it was built in 1975, and today, Northwestern University strives to push the envelope with new, groundbreaking medical discoveries. This proposal celebrates the past through reinterpretation for the future by celebrating a moment in Chicago architectural history by promoting progressive community programs and Northwestern’s forward-looking medical research.
6LX88
PRENTICE TOWER gallery and learning labs
NEW 500,000 SF LAB BUILDING research facilities, offices, conference
The floor plates have been strategically removed within the cloverleaf volumes and through the entire center to create a new, naturally lit space with an open atrium. The galleries provide rotating, interactive exhibits that integrate science and art to further reinforce the S.T.E.M and Vista programs.
The proposed new lab building will offer state-of-the-art laboratories with an open-air atrium that provides naturally lit offices that face the Prentice site. The bridge linking the two buildings provides a publicly accessible green space within the center of the community and the Northwestern Hospital Streeterville campus. The bridge activates and overlooks the plaza space while linking the existing Prentice building with the new lab building.
New atrium and skylight opens up the interior to vertical natural light. A monumental glass sculpture is based on biological fractal model.
A monumental archway frames
PRENTICE PLINTH circulation hub and public amenities
a view to Prentice.
GROUND FLOOR: PUBLIC The ground floor is the circulation center and contains an information kiosk, lounge areas and transparent, open views from the Prentice building to the lab building lobby. SECOND FLOOR: PRIVATE Administrative offices, community outreach support staff and conference rooms. THIRD FLOOR: PUBLIC Escalators ascend directly from the ground floor to the cafe where visitors may scale the ‘bowl’ ramp which allows direct access to the outdoors and green bridge. Also accessible from this floor are elevators up to the Prentice tower and an auditorium/multi-use area with reception space, which round out the public program.
An elliptical cut out allows natural light inside the bridge and to the plaza below.
FOURTH FLOOR/BRIDGE LEVEL:PUBLIC/ PRIVATE The top floor of the Prentice plinth extends over to the new lab building. This space also includes additional learning labs, seminar space, and meeting rooms.
Mechanical equipment is relocated to below Lansdscaped ‘mounds’ offer
to provide an open
subtle grade changes on the
pavilion at the roof top
otherwise flat green roof.
level. The bowl acts as a ramp as well as a sloped seating area for summer concerts and plays.
A three story lobby entrance directs one to the information center on the ground floor or up the escalator to the new public cafe, auditorium and rooftop park
The ground floor transforms into the circulation cetner of the Entire Northwestern Streeterville Campus.
The café area filters
S.T.E.M exhibit + learning labs
circultion from the
green bridge + bowl
ground floor to the
new labs + research
bowl for the green roof
staff offices + conference
access.
public information, kiosk + cafe auditorium, event + prefunction naturally-lit atrium space
6LX88 6LX88
6LX88
HONORABLE MENTION Title: Project X Team: Anja Buttolo Tilmann Lohse Priska Lohse Michael Pancost
B3 99952
B1 99952
B2 99952
ALL OTHER ENTRIES
Title: [Inside Out] In: Extending Future Prentice Team: Studio Link-Arc Yichen Lu Amy Shu Chang
Villa Rotunda
Guggenheim Museum
Museum fur Nordrhein-Westfalen
Scale Comparison of Atrium Spaces
PROGRAM
PROGRAM
1. PRENTICE RE-FOCUSED The design of the new Prentice extension intends to preserve the iconic reinforced con-
FUHWH VKHOO GHVLJQHG E\ %HUWUDQG *ROGEHUJ 5HFRJQL]LQJ WKDW WKH H[LVWLQJ IORRU DUHDV DQG KHLJKWV GR QRW VXVW RUWKZHVWHUQ 8QLYHUVLW\¶V need for medical research lab facilities, we propose to remove the existing programs within the concrete shell, and place the programs RI PHGLFDO UHVHDUFK ODE RQ WKH H[WHULRU RI WKH VKHOO *ROGEHUJ¶V LFRQLF IRUP EHFRPHV WKH new atrium for the medical research facility, visible from the urban context, yet preserved to serve as a public space for the campus.
[INSIDE OUT] IN : EXTENDING FUTURE PRENTICE
[1]
reg.# 0T098
Chicago City Grid
= New Volume
Prentice Floor Plan
Urban Fabric Extended
Cornell Campus Green
Yale Campus Green
Northwestern Downtown Campus Green
Scale Comparison of Campus Greens
2. URBAN CONNECTION Elements of the Chicago city and the Northwestern hospital campus are embodied in both the urban scheme and building scheme of the future Prentice extension. The rectilinear urban fabric of Streeterville is conceptually extended within the new volume, wrapping around the organically shape of the existing Prentice building and programmed with medical research facilities. We addressed the need for a campus heart in the Northwestern Downtown campus by reserving Site B for a new common green. The siting of the new campus green next to the Prentice building enriches the hospital campus by creating a focal point that gathers students, researchers and the general public. We provided future underground parking under the green, with easy access from North Fairbanks Court.
Circulation Diagram
[INSIDE OUT] IN : EXTENDING FUTURE PRENTICE
Northwestern University Downtown Campus
[2]
CAMPUS HEART
reg.# 0T098
1 4
4 7
2
7
6
2 7
6 6 3
3 7
6
7
6
Ground Floor Plan
0
20
40
Typical Floor Plan
6
0
20
40
Program Areas
Atrium Circulation Public Space Circulation
3. PROGRAM PROVISION 7KH QHZ YROXPH RI WKH 3UHQWLFH EXLOGLQJ H[WHQVLRQ ZLOO KRXVH 1RUWKZHVWHUQÂśV VWDWH RI WKH art medical research lab facilities. Double height open laboratories receive natural light on the north and are interconnected to lab support spaces. Offices surround the existing concrete clover form. Natural light shines through the existing oval windows into the offices from the new atrium void.
[INSIDE OUT] IN : EXTENDING FUTURE PRENTICE
[3]
Public Space
reg.# 0T098
4. SPATIAL CLARITY
The carved-out void RI *ROGEHUJ¶V FORYHU IRUP EHFRPHV D PL[LQJ FKDPEHU IRU YDULRXV XVHUV RI WKH PHGLcal facility. At various floor levels in the volume are spaces for exchange of ideas, knowledge, and culture. Circulation is devised around WKH VSDWLDO H[SHULHQFH RI *ROGEHUJ¶V FORYHU VKHOO E\ DOORZLQJ WKH SXEOLF WR DVFHQG ZLWKLQ LW DQG DURXQG LW (GXFDWLRQDO SURJUDPV SXEOLF spaces, and cultural events wrap around the exterior of the clover-shell, attracting the public from entrance plaza. In this new volume, the LGHDOL]HG JHRPHWU\ RI *ROGEHUJ¶V GHVLJQ LV IXVHG ZLWK WKH IOXLGLW\ RI VW &HQWXU\ DUFKLWHFWXUH Section
[INSIDE OUT] IN : EXTENDING FUTURE PRENTICE
[4]
0
10
20
40
reg.# 0T098
Title: The Prentice Y Team: HiWorks Architecture Brantley Hightower, AIA, LEED AP
The YMCA has been an international institution for nearly 170 years. While these facilities have always provided a variety of services and social opportunities to a range of different communities, in the US they were originally intended to provide a safe environment for young men as they transitioned from rural to urban living.
the
Prentice Y
In the second half of the twentieth century, the mission of the YMCA expanded to include women and families. Today, the Y is dedicated to the development of a healthy “body, mind and spirit.� While this mission is most often met with athletic programming, the Y continues to provide a range of services to a broad social and economic spectrum.
It is a curious artifact of history that both the Loop and the Near North Side of Chicago currently lack a Y that serves its general population. Given the number of residents who have moved into the area in the last few decades, there exists an acute need for a downtown neighborhood Y.
0KY73
The Prentice Y
Athletic Extension group exercise rooms racquetball courts
natatorium meeting rooms theater climbing wall running track gymnasium locker rooms
would provide for a variety of community needs just as the original Prentice Women’s Hospital consolidated multiple women’s health services in a single location. In addition to standard YMCA athletic amenities, the Prentice Y would also provide expanded facilities for childcare, job education and counseling. Furthermore, it would offer meeting space for community groups. In the proposed scenario, Goldberg’s original structure becomes the base for a vast programmatic expansion. Given the dimensional requirements of athletic facilities relative to the dimensions of the existing tower, the added functions of the Prentice Y would be stacked vertically creating a layered program organization. The design would actively take advantage of the unique spatial opportunities resulting from the engagement of its form with the specifics of its internal program and its outward relationship to its site.
exercise floor administrative offices mechanical spine Existing Tower playland science lab classrooms
The Athletic Extension is supported by concrete piers and is braced by the Existing Tower. Goldberg’s original structure was defined by curving planes of poured concrete while the Extension is made of interconnected concrete trusses.
bouncy castle pterodactyl indoor playground office space retail space
The vertical organization of an athletic facility is not without precedent. Manhattan’s Downtown Athletic Club was memorably conceptualized as a series of stacked fields, courts and pools. Rem Koolhaas of course made this diagrammatic approach famous in Delirious New York. As compelling as its diagram was, the building lacked any outward expression of its unusual organization and few opportunities for program interaction were exploited internally.
0KY73
The curtain wall skin of the building’s base is formally extended to become a frame whose rigid lines contrast with the softer curves of the existing hospital tower. Within fields of highly tinted glass, zones of clear glazing provide directed views south toward the Loop and east toward Lake Michigan.
The Existing Tower
is reimagined as a multi-level childcare facility that serves both the needs of Y users as well as other members of the community. This particular program also represents an ideal fit for the former hospital floors. While the limited floor heights would pose a challenge for other potential program types, here it represents an environment perfectly scaled for children. By eliminating the need for interior partitions, the design is able to express the purity of Goldberg’s design in a way that was not possible in the building’s original configuration. This sense of openness is heightened through the strategic cutting of holes in floors to provide space for special activities to occur while at the same time allowing visual connections to be made between multiple levels.
0KY73
The Athletic Extension
offers an opportunity to explore the spatial possibilities implied by the Downtown Athletic Club. In addition, this vertical stacking of spaces give certain activities privileged locations that are typically only available to only the most powerful executives and wealthiest property owners. At the Prentice Y it is not the most privileged who enjoy the best view. Rather it is anyone who shows up for the 6:00 free swim.
More than a place to exercise, the Prentice Y is intended to act as a true community center offering a range of cultural and entertainment opportunities for those working and living downtown. Because of its location in the heart of Northwestern University Medical Campus, it can also provide a needed respite for family and friends of patients.
0KY73
Title: Prentice Tower. Iconic Past - Beacon for the Future Team: Brinckerhoff and Associates LLC Peter Brinckerhoff AIA, LEED AP Visualizedconcepts inc. Thorsten Bosch, Associate AIA Nick Glazebrook Felipe Patino Michal Ciurej
Title: Future Prentice Team: Bozhidar Hinkov, Architect Stoian Andonov Martin Krastev
Title: Radical Preservation Team: Andrew Kovacs
RADICAL PRESERVATION
ARCHITECTURE AS COLLECTIBLE
REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1A207
When architecture becomes useless - or it can no longer fulfil its intended purpose of function it becomes a collectible. This project proposes a radical re-purposing of Goldberg’s masterpiece. Rather than awkwardly reprogram the structure, this proposal radically declares a new function for the Goldberg’s masterpiece as a collectible - or a form of architectural preservation through designed demolition. The only way to really save Goldberg’s structure is by making it into smaller pieces, effectively a set of collectibles. A 3-dimensional preservation/demolition plan is generated through Goldberg’s initial column grid. Cube chunks of the structure are systematically dismantled with love and care to generate a new function where useless architecture may have new life as a collectible.
RADICAL PRESERVATION: Chicago Prize 2012 Future Prentice
PRESERVATION THROUGH DESIGNED AND CURATED DEMOLITION...
REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1A207
RADICAL PRESERVATION: Chicago Prize 2012 Future Prentice
A SET OF COLLECTED PIECES...
REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1A207
RADICAL PRESERVATION: Chicago Prize 2012 Future Prentice
REGISTRATION NUMBER: 1A207
TO THE COLOSSAL.
PRESERVED THROUGH DEMOLITION FROM THE MINIATURE...
RADICAL PRESERVATION: Chicago Prize 2012 Future Prentice
Title: Out to Pasture Team: Matthew Messner Piotr Drezek Obed Lopez Belem Medina Jeisler Salunga Matthew Schneider
Out to Pasture
1FT94
FUTURE PRENTICE
There comes a time in every buildings existence when it has outlived its purpose. Those unlucky ones, slowly degrade into abandonment. Others leave us in a blaze of imploding glory. A select few, on the other hand, find a new place in the world where they can feel useful again. No one ever said life on a farm was easy, but if any building can handle it, Prentice Women’s Hospital is one of them. Never quite fitting in to its surroundings, imagine the epiphany Prentice would have among structures of similar formal language. Not only would it be more comfortable in the fresh air of the countryside, it would be the greatest of its peers, for once. Away from the pressures of the city life, and those that would see harm come to it, Prentice could exist with dignity and honor. And when asked by our children, “Where did Prentice go?” We can answer with a clear conscience, “It lives on a nice farm, where it can be free.”
Site Plan
1FT94
FLOOR TO FLOOR HEIGHTS
187’-0”
133’- 5”
CORN
13’-6”
THIRD FLOOR COW FARM
13’-6”
SECOND FLOOR COW FARM
13’-6”
FIRST FLOOR COW FARM
13’-6.5”
GROUND FLOOR COW FARM
FLOOR DEPTHS FOR TOWER APPROX. 15” FLOOR DEPTHS FOR PODIUM APPROX. 12”
1FT94
1FT94
Title: Hotel Bertrand Team: John H. Nelson Christian Dethloff Samuel Pavlovcik
Hotel Program •
• • • • • • • •
•
144 Rooms • 56 Double bed suites • 88 Single bed suites • 34 Short term Mini suites Bar & Lounge Restaurant Ballroom Street level Café Business center Conference Rooms Roof Terrace Green Space Workout Center • Lap Pool • Sauna Spa & Care Center
Rooftop Viewing Area
Open Atrium Tower Suites Mechanical Bar
Roof Terrace & Green Space
Restaurant
Two Story Grand Ballroom
Main Entry and Lobby Grand Stair Atrium
1GU60
Typical Hotel Rooms • Double Bed Suites • Single Bed Suites • “Capsule” Efficiency Suites Features • Built In cabinetry • Vintage Chic Style • En Suite Bathroom • Mini Lounges at each Quad • Guest Laundry Facilities on each level • Queen Sized Beds Minimum
Typical “Capsule” Suite Plan (Partial)
Typical Single Bed Suite
Typical Tower Plan
Typical “Capsule” Suite
1GU60
Exterior Improvements • New Curtain wall at base • Atrium Glass • New Energy Efficient Windows • Green Roof • New Hardscape & Planting at Ground Level • Remain Sensitive to Historic Facade
1GU60
Hotel Program CafĂŠ Restaurant Workout center Bar Guests Suites Ballroom Conference Areas
Ground Floor Plan
Level 1 Plan
Level 3 Plan
Level 2 Plan
Terrace Plan
1GU60
Title: Future Prentice Team: Edith Wong
Title: Biophilia Through Medical Spaces Team: Yanelys Rosua Silvia Baldoquin Candace Hoskins
biophilia through medical spaces design strategies:
landscape treatment of the entrance (green areas.) N
nature trails
MEDICAL LAB FACILITIES
500 ft
(rendering of structure, spatial connections)
connection
GREEN HOUSE BRIDGE
(rendering of bridge looking towards prentice women’s hospital) PERMANENCE AND HOMENAGE TO EXISTING CONDITIONS
west view towards michigan lake
Photo credit: Chicago Architectural A Club
PLANTS CONSERVATORY
(photoshop renderings, or landscape diagram of native plants and its location in site)
native plants
PLANT NURSERY
interior view from medical facility
1RJ72
Image courtesy of Landmarks Illinois
nursery/ conservatory spaces
programatical section a
programatical section b
(redbud, american linden, european beach, white fir, bur oak, pagoda dogwood, new england aster, blue flag iris, common ninebark)
interior view nursery/ green house bridge
1RJ72
Image courtesy of Landmarks Illinois
green house connector through medical spaces
circulation diagram
(retractable enclosed bridge serves as a warm transitional and programatical space between medical facailities)
(prentice medical facility > green house bridge > new medical facility > nursery > garage bridge )
green house connector through medical spaces
1RJ72
Image courtesy of Landmarks Illinois
Title: Lab Life -Chicago self sufficient research facilities Team: Grzegorz Owczarczyk Michal Kubrak
LAB LIFE-
CHICAGO SELF SUFFICENT RESEARCH FACILITIES
2TU00
LAB LIFE-
CHICAGO SELF SUFFICENT RESEARCH FACILITIES
“LAB LIFE” workday cycle includes all important aspects and needs of being a LAB worker or researcher. Proximity of housing and green spaces (roofs), work spaces and recreational + meeting spaces (Old Prentice Building) creates a whole new kind of environment. A life becomes a balanced circle. Housing units for lab workers and researchers, different unit combinations + sizes in towers on top
LAB space, research rooms, study space and other facilities + green roof (possible for plant growing etc.)
Bars, casinos - entertainment space serving the LAB and housing
Recreational facilities for lab workers Old building serving new functions to emphasize the form Hotel facilities for guest scientists and businesman having meetings and working with local professionals
Public space for both lab workers and other citizens. Lab campus connectconnect ed with Prentice underground
2IÀFH DQG PHHWLQJ VSDFH IRU FRQnecting business and science / research - maximum cooperation
2TU00
LAB LIFE-
CHICAGO SELF SUFFICENT RESEARCH FACILITIES
What is the real quality of the Old Prentice Building and why in fact do we want to preserve it? Why is this building so important for the architectural history and how can it re-gain its lost youth and be brought back to life? Trying to implement new laboratories there certainly won’t be a good idea - there is not enough space for that and it will not be cheap. It will also be expensive comparing to coming up with new spaces for laboratories. How can we then emphasize the structure and materiality of the Old Prentice Building treating it as a symbol of its age and rather as a monument instead as a really functional and feasible object? Idea of bringing attention to it can be realised by making it more of a public space containing different functions and forgeting about its previous life. Hotels, bars, conference rooms or sport facilities will bring new life for the object. Combining this with new lab facilities + housing units creates a whole life environment for researchers and workers while giving new importance for the 3UHQWLFH EXLOGLQJ 7KDW ZD\ PRVW RI WKH VFLHQWLVWV DQG UHVHDUFKHUV ZLOO KDYH VWURQJ FRQWDFW ZLWK LW ZKLOH DOVR EHLQJ DEOH WR ÀQG FRPIRUWDEOH ZRUN HQYLURQment in new laboratory facilities.
2TU00
Title: Hotel Bertrand and Med City Team: Studio Sym Design Mark P. Miszuk AIA, LEED AP Rene Steevensz AIA Mo Yala AIA
SUPERIOR STREET
ROOF DECK / RESTAURANT (5th Floor)
2nd Thru 4th
GROUND FLOOR
Program
Parking Spaces Hotel Rooms
SUPERIOR STREET
KITCHEN (6th Floor)
TYPICAL HOTEL FLOOR (8th thru 14th)
SECTION LOOKING EAST
103 112
HOTEL BERTRAND
HURON STREET
ID: 3B210
ID: 3B210
HOTEL BERTRAND
TYPICAL APARTMENT FLOOR
APARTMENT FLOOR
RESEARCH DEVELOPMENT FLOOR
ROOF TERRACE
APARTMENTS
MEDICAL MALL PARKING / MECHANICAL
E. HURON STREET
N. McCLURG CT
N. FAIRBANKS CT
APARTMENTS
APARTMENTS
RESEARCH DEVELOPMENT
E. ERIE STREET
Program
MED CITY
GROUND FLOOR Parking 1000 Spaces Apartment Area 900,000 SF Medical Mall Area 712,000 SF Research Development Area 480,000 SF
ID: 3B210
LOWER LEVEL LOADING / PARKING FLOOR
MED CITY ID: 3B210
Title: An Expansion to a Masterpiece Team: Kathleen Guede Heriberto Delgado
Title: Live Grow Learn Team: Dan Marta Nick Spoor Josh Myers Christian Torres
LIVE:
GROW:
RESIDENTS WILL BE ABLE TO USE NEW GREEN HOUSES SPACE TO GROW CROPS FOR USE IN THE COMMUNAL KITCHENS AND FOR SALE IN WEEKLY FARMERS MARKETS HELD ON NEW GREENSPACE BRIDGEING THE EXISTING ROAD. THE YEILD OF THE GREENHOUSES WILL BE BOL STERED, IN THE GROWING MONTHS, BY USE OF EXISTING VACANT LOT AS A NEW URBAN FARM CULTIVATED BY OCCUPANTS AND OTHERS IN NEED.
UTILIZE EXISTING WEDGE SHAPED PATIENT ROOMS AS SINGLE RESIDENCE OCCUPANCIES ALLOWING PEOPLE TO TRANSITION TO PERMANENT HOMES. EXISTING NURSING STATIONS WILL BE TRANSFORMED INTO COMUNAL KITCHENS ALLOWING RESIDENTS TO LIVE INDEPENDENT LIVES.
LEARN:
EXISTING PODIUM WILL BE UTILIZED AS A COMMUNITY CENTER. OCCUPANTS OF THE NEW FACILITY WILL BE ABLE TO TAKE ADVANTGE OF THE SPACE AND SOCIAL SERVICES TO LEARN NEW SKILLS MAKING THEM BETTER ABLE TO FIND WORK.
Registration #3FM08
Registration #3FM08
1
1
1
1
1 4
5
4
4
3
4
5
2 4
4
5
1
5 2
5
5
3
3
4
2
4
4
3
5 2
1
4
2
2
1
LIVE GROW FLOOR PLATE OPTIONS 1 2 3 4 5
Resident Rooms Double Height Green House Rain Water Irragation Communal Kitchens Dining Area
Registration #3FM08
Registration #3FM08
Title: Prentice Science Conference Hall Team: Johan B채ckman
3FS24
PRENTICE SCIENCE CONFERENCE HALL PROBLEM: - The qualities of the Old Prentice are being overshadowed by the dislike of its raw appeal and vacant feel - The land owners find the building unsuiting for their uses SOLUTION: - By making the building interact with the public the opinions could change
Function seperation of upper stories
- By giving it a new more dynamic function its role in the area could be lifted CONCEPT: - The building is split into a park and a conference center - The reason is to attract different users to make the building reach out to more people - The aim is to achieve a symbiosis between the two functions, so that the generation and distribution of information is as dynamic as possible
Remains of former slabs, used as an urban park
Ramp between the slabs
Conference hall and workshop pods 3FS24
changing rooms & toilets
yoga deck
green park
sun deck
Floor order diagram
conference hall cafeteria
administration terrace toilets
foayer
reception
Flow diagram 3FS24
services
restaurant & sky bar
workshop spaces
administration
workshop pod
interrior of the workshop pods
3FS24
Title: Save Prentice Team: Matthew Claus Bear Pope Dan Drecoll
Title: Future Prentice Team: Gabriella Moreno
Title: Embracing Prentice 2012 Team: BauerLatoza Studio Jaime Aubry Roberta Brucato John Cramer Sarah Olson Theresa Potter Tim Vacha
Title: Prentice Re-Framed Team: Martin Cerna Dan Penick
RE FRAMED The decision to destroy an architecturally significant work such as the Prentice Women’s Hospital is one that should not be made without considering all potential alternatives. Our main objectives to preserve the existing tower as an architectural monument are to utilize the land as a premier research laboratory and introduce a new program which frames the site as a centralized scientific hub. Acknowledging that the existing tower does not allow for an ideal research facility, we propose to elevate the research laboratories above the existing tower thereby freeing the plan for a more appropriate use. By allowing the tower to maintain its formal integrity of its open plan, we are able to house a program which is flexible by nature. To activate the new program and structurally support the lifted laboratories we introduced a new tower to north of the site. As a central hub we introduced a large scale science library that works together with both the research laboratories and the adjacent scientific community. Because of this, the purpose of the podium is defined by more publicly accessible programs that support both the library and the community’s academic goals. Meanwhile, the northern tower is used to house larger and more informal spaces such as reading rooms and computer labs so that the existing tower can leverage its flexibility for book stacks. With these programmatic moves we arrived to an architectural language which treats the elevations as a device to frame the existing tower as a three dimensional sculpture.
Entry Number: 04E07
Programmatic Shifting
1.
2.
Podium as Research Facility
3.
Free program from towerr
4.
Surround tower with Program
Activate site by injecting Library of Science
LEGEND 1. Main Lobby Below 2. Auditorium 3. Extended Classrooms 4. Circulation Core 5. Classroom Support 6. Gathering Space 7. Lobby Extension 8. Open Reading Area 9. Library Book Stacks 10. Offices 11. Conference Room 12. Rest rooms 13. Break room 14. Research Labs 15. Lab Support 16. Collaboration Space 17. Communal Space
1
2
8
1
5
10
10 11
2
1
1
3
15 9
4
5
9
3
9
15
4
4
15
8
5
3
2
3
1
12 12
3
13
2
3
3
1
1
15
14
5
14 17
15
9
6
5
15
6
6
16 3
3
3
3
16 7
A
B
Podium Level
C
D
E
7
A
B
Tower Level
C
D
E
7
A
B
C
D
E
Upper Research Level Entry Number: 04E07
Private Programs Library Programs
14
Educational / Support Main Circulation
14
Display Boxes
14
Display Case Mega Truss
5.
Architectural Tec tonics
LEGEND 1. Main Lobby Below 2. Auditorium 3. Extended Classrooms 4. Circulation Core 5. Classroom Support 6. Gathering Space 7. Lobby Extension 8. Open Reading Area 9. Library Book Stacks 10. Offices 11. Conference Room 12. Rest rooms 13. Break room 14. Research Labs 15. Lab Support 16. Collaboration Space 17. Communal Space 18. Vivarium
9
9
8
8
9 8
2
9
8
18 3 3
Entry Number: 04E07
Entryy Number: 04E07
Title: Turning Inside-Out Team: NJBA A+U Noel J Brady MRIAI MIDI
Chicago Architectural Club 2012
FUTURE PRENTICE
Proposed Ground Floor
Existing Ground Floor
Proposed Floor Level 5 (and above)
Existing Floor Level 5
4J862
Chicago Architectural Club 2012
FUTURE PRENTICE
Turning Inside Out
Typical Laboratory Floor
Proposed Side Elevation
4J862
Chicago Architectural Club 2012
FUTURE PRENTICE
Existing Superior Street View
Proposed New Screened Facade
4J862
FUTURE PRENTICE
Chicago Architectural Club 2012
4J862
Title: Northwestern University Central Plant and Facilities Headquarters Team: Burnham & Van Cleave Suzie Van Cleave, AIA David Burnham Bryan Abbott Allison Kenney Cooling Tower Depot, Inc.
Title: The Building Goes On Team: JAQ Corp, int’l John M. Gay Terron Wright Leeswann Bolden Nickolas Hill
Title: Chicago Vivarium Team: Thomas de Monchaux Rodrigo Zamora
5LU53
5LU53
Wh Th at if e po Chi the P t c Go entia ago renti l l d lat Viva ce to b of e r w s er eq kysc g’s a nt in ium r er c u cam ivale rapin rchite the f ealiz ould cle pus nt o g, th ctur oliate es th grow f e Th ar-sp for b 60 s at str . In t form e bot like a e a p Chi an la iome torie uctu he C s of anica flow r c er? a 5 ublic ago b floo dica s, cre e ext hicag Bertr l l re 0-s am Viv ati rud o tr an r s s d n a tor a e e m a y ra eni rium nd m arch g a v s up ditio Av ert ty a hy e , t i i he n n v c w a b i for h to est nd re ridiz anic ith al cal su rium sou pp . sea es t al m tern o is at rch his e con thwe rt lif an a res pro zzan ing sam tain st cy e, lik rtifici i g o e s urc ram nes. tre ple a vi linde a te al en e: w it v v e h fee s. W orga ariu r of G rrariu iron n m m t i o m i t , z e ho l su t a e d h n o tr d b e t b r thr trop 50- verst arou ium: erg’s aqu calib s the ough ical b tory ory c nd s a tub quat arium rated e a loo atriu elev elow atriu nop vera ular refoi . The a y alo kout m’s tors , trop m sta laye l sus rainf l plan o s by— ng th ; com outer and ical a cks m rs re pend rest s a e e b p w a c d p u res nd inn lem eri itc ove l t ip h in ge earc fruit er pe ent phery hbac . Pub le b g 20 io om he ful a k 0 l soc et rs, en riphe ry ra featu ram ic cir mes r c o m i c i r p e a r s a ula : oth l a s a uts oun y en ps es sig er la nd su long ide th ter b cour and mult long tion i Th natu ndma ppor this e lab etwe age mlandi ple i e n re e n n t s r n g o ha win k bu spa ner . In v —b ve s r ec sys vest essa dow ildin ce, a wall olute iome ment e r a nd dic tem d pa gs y d c al s. from heat ttern . Var evo comm k i Be a a e l p od ab t n i r G n o d o a ora hu vid ns o Am jam tor mi e d in G ldbe te rg’ dit he erica in Fra y a o y c r oo y is ligh ldb s 17 b ga n ho nklin lin g a sust ting. erg’s an 51. W rden, spita intro nd ain dr l ith at du “p ven abl po ten ainfo roo The hysi ced tila y f c Viv r P t t t tio e h o iall g e s e p a a n n cen rium y ph t atr pla nsy rde trad n i n l u v i a tur ” t t a e m i , i y C xten rmac for ngs nia or m ona hic ds eu the for Hos ed l ag o s this t tical stud local pital icina ,i l ky. rad pla e y itio nts of e colog n , x ni i T o e h s nto e C tic the hic and 21 ago st-
5LU53
Ch ica go
um
Viv ari
hL ab
arc
lR ese
ica
me d
Bio
s
5LU53
Title: The Trophy Team: Choi, Hyung Jin Kang, Mi Ju
Title: Research Apparatus Team: Alexandre Guilbeault, M. Arch David Giraldeau, M. Arch, B.A.
Title: Urban Village Team: Brian Bedford Kate Bedford
Chicago’s Land Policies Plan 2 acres / 1,000 residents Streeterville
17.7 acres / 11,533 residents 1.53 acres / 1,000 residents
Chicago’s open space is unevenly dispersed to its 2.7 million residents. While generous space has been given along sections of the water’s edge, much of the existing open space is isolated from the city fabric. (Northwestern University Future Growth)
THE HEART OF THE NEIGHBORHOOD This urban and architectural solution not only meets the needs of Northwestern University, but is envisioned to become the heart of the Streeterville neighborhood. The district, with a rapidly climbing residential population and home of a growing university and medical campus, currently lacks the open space required by the City of Chicago. This solution, largely about social integration, involves a deliberate crafting of open space around carefully considered University and public program. This space offers opportunities for public engagement - both a necessity in university education and supportive of community development. The result is a symbiotic relationship in which the health and welfare of employees, patients, businesses and the greater community are paramount. 6Y440
CONTEXT WITHIN THE STREETERVILLE NEIGHBORHOOD *cross-hatching indicates surface or garage parking
Northwestern University and Hospital 0
40’
120’
240’
Businesses
Residential and Restaurants
City Bus Route
Outdoor Living Room
WEAVING PUBLIC AND PRIVATE The Outdoor Living Room is activated by a density of “pedestrian edges” – effectively doubling the walkable perimeter of the standard block. Pedestrian access links the former Prentice building and the Northwestern campus to this open space and business hub, which will provide tenant opportunities for services and amenities that the neighborhood currently lacks. The weaving of public and private through mixed uses supports sustainable economic development where convenience, activity and a dense population coalesce. Below the Outdoor Living Room, a central connector links the research facility to a building for future campus growth. These structures are sited and shaped to minimize canyonization in the open space. 6Y440
VIEW SOUTH FROM PRENTICE Event Center
Restaurant URBAN VILLAGE In this solution, a tower addition connects to the existing Prentice structure, converting it into what could become one of Chicago’s most distinct and desirable hotels. As Northwestern continues its ownership of the building, the University’s hotel, conference, and event space needs will take priority; rooms and spaces will be made available to the others thereafter. A public circulation route connects through the structures, crossing over university program as it winds down to the street level. Bertrand Goldberg’s concept of making “villages” is given new life, through the intermingling of public and private programs within the building and adjacent site.
Social Spaces
Hotel Rooms
Hotel Rooms
u A t r i
m
Public Level
Cafe
Public Circu
lation
Services & Retail
NW University Administrative Offices NW University Bookstore
NW University Welcome Center
Connector
6Y440
HOTEL ATRIUM SPACE
HOTEL LEVEL FLOOR PLAN
to
be
10
30
60
low
o pe
n
0
A NEW LIFE FOR PRENTICE Prentice is valuable as a singularity. Within the modified building, a narrow atrium separates the original structure from the addition, pierced only to allow for necessary circulation between the two volumes. The atrium gives the visitor access to experience the uniqueness of Prentice, the building’s innovative and sculptural concrete shell. This relationship makes the original structure more approachable and relatable than its former life, highlighting its value through human interaction. By preserving Prentice, the richness of Chicago’s architectural fabric will be bolstered in the Streeterville neighborhood, giving current and future residents the opportunity to be deeply connected to this place. 6Y440
Title: Next Library Team: Sheehan Partners, LTD. Neil Sheehan Sylvia Billisics Jeremy Mickler Bryn Namivari Laura Bowe Jac Selinsky Tom Veed
: NEXT : L IB R A RY
6YF92
FUTURE: :PRENTICE
Innovation involves drawing from the past while looking to the future. Goldberg’s tower is reinvigorated as The Next Library. No longer simply a repository for knowledge, it is the physical manifestation of the digital power required to process as well as preserve new research. Inside the concrete cloverleaf, four dual rings of servers rise seventy feet, supported from the shell by a system of steel bracing that replaces the floors and creates a single volume that extends from the topmost server to the glass-enclosed base. Hot air is exhausted between the server rings and rises to the roof stack, drawing cool air from louvers below. In the summer, cool air is created from lake water, while in winter waste heat is reclaimed to preheat intake air. Grated catwalks provide technician and public access to the neural network of conduit, fiber, and computer.
SERVER CORES: data storage:petaflop processing
The reimagined podium hovers between the tower and public landscape below, embracing the tower base without infringing on it, and is the interface by which users access data above. Contained within is an evolving infrastructure for multiple modes of input and output. The underside of the building is a digital surface, lifted on its north side to express the auditorium slope. The streetscape extends beneath the building connecting Huron and Superior Streets via a forest of columns punctuated by the revelation of the tower’s base through the podium’s open court. Pedestrians can witness the servers rising above consistently processing and perpetually aiding the expansion of human knowledge.
TOWER: server housing:stack vent
PODIUM: input:infrastructure for interface
DIGITAL SURFACE: output:project projection NETWORK:campus extension librarys:museums:labs:hospitals:universities
OPEN SPACE:critical path parks:unprogrammed lots:public space:pedestrian paths
WATER:resource utilization lake:river:main:treatment:locks:breaks
6YF92 6YF92
6YF92
switchgear
substation
generator stack
backup generators
public space
outreach
performance
large format
lab
office
imaging
amenities
reference
winter:exhausted waste heat to preheat intake air
summer:lake source cooling
SERVER CORE:PASSIVE STACK
server catwalk
server lobby
tower lobby street interior court
tower lobby
LINES OF SIGHT:VIEWS
6YF92
Title: The Incubator Team: Lina Nilsson
THE INCUBATOR A NEW PROGRAM FOR A NEW TIME The Incubator is Prentice Tower as a creative space for start-up companies in the bio-medical field The Incubator is a business model that combines biomedical education & research with the goal to launch successful start-ups in biotech as well as showcasing Northwestern University to the public. With office spaces and Lab spaces for lease as well as audiotoriums, show rooms and conference rooms and even short stay hotel rooms for guest researchers all the functions a startup company can need are represeted. With its close proximity to the rest of the Campus / hospital neighbourhood there are many synergy effects for the whole area to be obtained. Finally the program in the building includes many recreational functions that are open to the public as well, such as a sky bar and a rooftop swiming pool /gym. The audiotoriums and exhibition areas can also be used for public events.
PODS All the functions are grouped together in clusters of circular slabs and stacked and entwined vertically like a DNA-string for a spatially interesting and flexible effect. This liberates the curvlinear space inside Prentice tower and releases its sculptural effects also from the inside.
PRESERVATION = REMOVAL OF THE OLD SLABS.. The existing floor slabs in the building are demolished and replaced by the pods. Since the slabs aren’t flexible enough neither in plan or section; and since the most important feature of the Prentice tower is its load-bearing, concrete shell-structure, this operation is done to liberate the curvilinear, beautiful space inside the Prentice tower. Before Prentice tower was seen as a sculptural building form the outside, but now this is true for the inside as well.
..BUT PRESERVATION OF THE SHELL The shell is keep intact, it’s the best feature of Prentice Tower. It get a new dramatic light effect from the refurbished teracce area. LABORATORIES FOR LEASE IN THE BASE The labs for lease are placed in the base of the building. This part get a new more translucent, double skin facade of glass and metal mesh.
NEW LAB On the plot across the street from the Prentice building a new state of the art medical lab is built and connected with the Prentice building with a foot bridge. PUBLIC SQUARE In connection with the new reserach lab a public space is c reated.
urban situation & concept
7C248
meeting & conferance rooms
sky bar / green house offices
show room / exhibition
pool / gym
bio-food court
audiotorium
researchers in recidency / short stay hotel rooms terrace
laboratories & lab support area
offices
lobby
exploded axonometry
7C248
cross section
perspective from the exhibition area
7C248
perspective from the sky bar
7C248
Title: The Glass Museum Team: Volodymyr Ilchyshyn
The Glass Museum Chicago has a reputation for being a melting pot of architecture with different typesof structures covering not only its downtown area but also its outskirts. The melting pot should be preserved and documented in a museum which is more than the Architectural Foundation’s model of downtown. Bertrand Goldberg’s Prentice Hospital is the facility which could house the museum. With a bit of restoration and an addition to encase the entire clover shaped structure and keep it away from the weather the former hospital becomes an historic architectural piece inside of its own casing. (continued, pg.2)
7C826
The lower part of the new museum could be used for large exhibition halls and traveling exhibitions. The clover structure would become the permanent location for the history of architecture. Each of the floors would be a different era in architecture. The exterior of the clover, which would be encased in the new glass box, would allow viewers to get closer to the clover shaped structure via stairs and balconies attached to the glass box. The roof level of the base structure would also be used for events and exhibition openings.
7C826
Architecture throughtout the years
Events/open area
New Exhibitions
7C826
Title: Re-Imagine: Re-Construct: Re-Instate Team: Phil Stott Jon Gately
Title: Preserving History Team: Lily Alvarez Lillian Campos Jose Garcia
PRESERVING HISTORY
Future Prentice 2012 Competition
Once an innovative structure in the Chicago skyline, today a dated building, but a building that holds significant meaning in both its design creation and in the lives of many of Chicago's citizens. When the building was designed it was an innovative structure because of its monolithic concrete shell which was completely cantilevered of the core. The elimination of columns for support allowed for a free plan, flexible to accommodate the multi-purpose program. It was necessary for our design to keep these points present in the preservation of the Prentice building. Our design is a monumental glass and steel skin that treats the Prentice building as a habitable sculpture. The existing structure is experienced by the user spatially in four different ways. The first way is the building being seen from a far in which it is seen as a precious sculpture protected from the elements. The second experience occurs in the entrance hall in which the building is seen form worms eye view. The third is the experience of the user from within the existing structure in which the program takes precedence of the experience, and the fourth is located on the tenth floor where the space exposes the user to an exterior interior relation with the existing structure and the skin.
Plan view Hierarchal Views and Axis Diagram
Elevation Structure Diagram Skin Design
Sectional Expansion and Contraction Slab Diagram
Natural Light Spatial Study
N
CHICAGO ARCHITECTURAL CLUB: FUTURE PRENTICE 2012 COMPETITION ID: 7SA68
Square Footage and Program Analysis Total Square Footage: 556, 922 sq. ft. Lecture Halls Large Lecture (120)- 1,200 sq. ft. Meeting Room (30)- 760 sq. ft. Computer Lab: 800 sq. ft. Rest Rooms: 800 sq. ft.
Tectonics and Materials: Exterior
White Concrete
Interior Double Insulated Glass
Landscape
White Concrete
Wood
White Concrete
Steel
Steel
White Tile
Grass
Prentice Concrete
Prentice Concrete
Clinics Waiting Area: 120 sq. ft. Reception: 60 sq. ft. Physician Office: 120 sq. ft. Exam Room: 110 sq. ft. Nurse Work Area: 80 sq. ft. Medical Records: 60 sq. ft. Medication Storage: 60 sq. ft. Supply Room: 150 sq. ft. Rest Rooms: 800 sq. ft. Reception/ Recreation Area Recreation Area: 20,400 sq. ft.
Research Labs Labs: 600 sq. ft. Research Office: 200 sq. ft. Medication Storage: 60 sq. ft. Supply Room: 150 sq. ft. Break Room: 400 sq. ft. Rest Rooms: 800 sq. ft. Library Check Out: 160 sq. ft. Reference Desk: 160 sq. ft. Audio Lab: 300 sq. ft. Visual Lab: 600 sq. ft. Librarians Office: 200 sq. ft. Work Room: 200 sq. ft. Storage Room: 300 sq. ft. Rest Rooms: 800 sq. ft. CHICAGO ARCHITECTURAL CLUB: FUTURE PRENTICE 2012 COMPETITION ID: 7SA68
CHICAGO ARCHITECTURAL CLUB: FUTURE PRENTICE 2012 COMPETITION ID: 7SA68
7XV08 Title: Saving Prentice - Goldberg Commons Team: Paul Benigno Gregory L. Klosowski Christina Bies Jill Macal
GOLDBERG COMMONS
The debate to save Prentice Women’s Hospital can be distilled down to the concepts of private property ownership set in contrast to an inherent responsibility to the larger city, as evidenced by the multifaceted public discourse between private corporate owners and the collective consciousness of a broad range of artists, architects and a design-fluent public.
A viable solution must offer more to the larger campus than square footage. This is an opportunity to spark the imagination and broaden the positive impacts, not just at this building, but throughout the campus, the neighborhood of Streeterville, and the larger city. Goldberg’s groundbreaking iconic four leafed plan was inspired by an idea of community where the center held common support programs for the patients at the outer edges. We realized the larger campus needed a heart, achievable through the transposition of the original parti to the larger scale of the neighborhood, campus, and proposed buildings, creating a university commons.
Labs Commons
Initial idea of unifying the site through a common ground plane
Labs
Site plan diagram
The proposed structures for research labs define the edges of this new piazza, creating overlapping public and semi-protected spaces. The notion of a hybrid zoning condition allows the institutions to achieve their practical goals while providing a vital place in the heart of Streeterville. Prentice, not only acting as a visual anchor for this new campus heart, has a functional redefinition as a university owner hotel and a global architectural tourist destination. The programmatic viability is supported the proximity to retail, a museum and the lakefront. This intentional interlacing of zoning and use enlivens and enriches the area on multiple scales, allowing the spaces to live on beyond typical business hours.
Michigan Avenue Retail District
Towers lacking pedestrian scale
Scaleless urban edge
Michigan Avenue / Retail District
Pedestrian connection to lake
Navy Pier entertainment center
View of the lakefront
Streeterville Boundry
Northwestern campus buildings
Navy Pier
7XV08
D
E
D A
D C
A C B
View of the commons and surrounding structures as seen from the south. The larger scale massing of the towers are situated to maximize solar exposure to the outdoor commons balanced against the need for a half million square feet of lab spaces.
DRAWING KEY A Laboratory Tower B Linear labs / Commercial base C Interior food court / commercial D Daylighting / Common space E Goldberg Hotel F Hotel rooms G Below grade parking
“....The city from a simple settlement became the place of assembled institutions. The measure of the greatness of a place to live must come from the character of its institutions sanctioned through how sensitive they are to renewed desire for new agreement... The street is a room by agreement. A community room the walls of which belong to the donors...the ceiling is the sky...� Example of traditional piazza
Example of traditional stoa building type
From a sketch on the Drawings for City
Louis Kahn
7XV08
Remainer of the hotel rooms above, 140 suites total
Typical hotel floor alternate plan
Typical hotel floor
Rooftop pool and lounge area
Curtain wall is removed and replaced with new metal screen wall system
View of the hotel rooftop with seatling, lounges and a pool
We realized the larger campus needed a heart, achievable through the transposition of the original parti to the larger scale of the neighborhood, campus, and proposed buildings, creating a university commons.
Floor 4 is removed to restore base to the original height
F Staggered floor plates to create areas with varying ceiling heights for hotel program
A
D
Floor 3: Meeting rooms Floor 2: Lounge and bar Floor 1: Lobby and Support Ground: Open
Existing structural frame
D
C
Courtyard paving continues into building base
G 7XV08
Above: As seen from the upper level, the commons is active on several levels with adjacent structures that respond to the original structre’s form
Above: The commons as seen from the ground floor at the repurposed Prentice building. Large rolling doors open up the interior to the outside when the weather permits.
This intentional interlacing of zoning and use enlivens and enriches the area on multiple scales, allowing the spaces to live on beyond typical business hours
Above: Looking southwest, the commons transforms at night, with active retail and visible lab circulation. Rooftop spaces, lit above a common datum, would accentuate the more daring engineering moves and cast a beautiful glow. . Below left: A view from the upper level circulation with the unifying sculptural canopy element. Below right: a view along the pathway that connects the southwest corner to the interior commons (on left) and exterior commons (beyond)
Below: Goldberg hotel on the left with the fifth floor roof deck and pool visible to the interior lounge below. The surrounding circulation and overlapping uses create multiple active vertical datums.
7XV08
Title: Future Prentice Team: Amira Ajlouni
FUTURE PRENTICE
CHICAGO ARCHITECTURAL CLUB: 2012 CHICAGO PRIZE COMPETITION
CONCEPT
FUTURE PRENTICE
CHICAGO ARCHITECTURAL CLUB: 2012 CHICAGO PRIZE COMPETITION
ID : 8LH86
FUTURE PRENTICE
CHICAGO ARCHITECTURAL CLUB: 2012 CHICAGO PRIZE COMPETITION
Bridge Connection
ID : 8LH86
Title: Future Prentice: A mixing box for engaged research Team: Damon Wilson Frank Nelson
Title: The Garden and the Void Team: Mircea Eni Nikita Troufanov Kyle Breelove Katy Manwaring
THE GARDEN AND THE VOID
09S44
VOID EXIST’G CAMPUS
GARDEN THE HUB PLAZA
FUTURE DEV’T
Old Prentice Hospital is reimagined as an inverted space. What was interior has worn out it’s function and is stripped away, opening up to the elements. The exterior in turn is cherished and enclosed, becoming interior space. The void of the old bed tower serves as a courtyard, a spatial sculpture and a water recycling system. The enclosed exterior serves as a winter garden. The new building takes on a new spirit and function as a connection node within the University Campus. It offers a public plaza, healing center and a winter garden for the patients, staff and visitors. It connects the campus buildings by plugging into the existing sky-bridge network on every side, acting as a HUB. Both a transitional space and a destination, the HUB provides health and recreation functions, designed around the principles of Evidence Based Design. The floors are connected through a series of walkable ramps, eventually emerging at the roof into a winter garden.
09S44
0 AS IS
1 REMOVE GROUND FLOOR
2 REMOVE FLOOR SLABS
3 CONNECT THE PEOPLE
This allows for an urban plaza that will act as crossroads of Northwestern’s campus. A refection pool marks where the tower touches the ground. The tower becomes the healing nucleus nucleus of the campus.
The tower’s sculptural beauty is enhanced and celebrated while ceilings are heightened in the podium.
A continuation of Northwestern’s existing sky bridge network connects patients, students, and staff through a hub of activity.
3 SPACES FOR RELAXATION
4 OUTDOORS, INDOORS
5 THE AXIS OF THE CAMPUS
5 ENCLOSED SANCTUARY
The Healing Center offers patients, visitors and staff a place to escape the confinement of the hospital. A cafe, spa, and chapel offer what they are looking for. Spaces appear to float amongst the crossing skybridges
A park then tops the podium and surrounds the stalk of the tower. The park is a retreat elevated from the city sculpted to be a place of repose, refreshment, and recovery.
Visitors can access from a stair or elevator in the core as well as the skybridges. The Garden and the Void is meant to be a hub of the communities healing and social health.
A screen covers the facade elements while a crystal glass structure encloses the park into a winter garden.
09S44
09S44
Title: Future Prentice Team: Mark Bruzan Architect AIA, LEED Green Associate
Lake Michigan
SUPERIOR STREET Hotel & Admin. Off.
SITE LOCATION PLAN
Park
Site B Ͳ Lab Building
Mc CLURG COURT
FAIRBANKS COURT
HURON STREET
ERIE STREET
N
Site B is developed with a mixedͲuse building which includes 500,000 S.F. of lab space.
The balance of the site is developed as a park featuring a large reflecting pool and green space.
Green roofs are incorporated on both the existing and new structures.
FUTURE PRENTICE 1 10.15.12
SITE PLAN
This
proposal envisions a mixedͲuse complex to satisfy Northwestern University’s desire for a state of the art medical research lab facility. The program includes the adaptive reͲ use of Goldberg’s iconic structure and utilizes the adjacent site for the new lab building.
9AW17
The design establishes a dialogue between the existing and new while expressing dynamic imagery of medical research through the use of innovative materials. The new facility shall strive to obtain LEED Platinum certification by employing environmentally sound and sustainable strategies.
Retail spaces ring the ground floor at the new lab building. The second through fourth floors are split between lab storage/archive spaces and a parking garage. The fifth floor contains mechanical space and additional archive rooms. The sixth through eight floors house the lab spaces. An egg shaped “embryo” form faces the park and houses staff offices. Clad in stainless steel, the embryo becomes a provocative counterpoint to the concrete clover of the Goldberg structure.
A
reinforced concrete framework references the existing Women’s Hospital. Exterior walls at the building are concrete up to the lab levels where zinc wall panel cladding is employed.
PROGRAM OF SPACES EXISTING PRENTICE HOSPITAL ADAPTIVE REͲUSE Ground Floor Floors 1Ͳ3 Floor 4 Floors 5Ͳ11
hotel lobby / café / shops NU administrative offices green roof terrace / restaurant/ meeting rooms / lounges 140 hotel guest rooms
NEW MEDICAL RESEARCH LAB / MIXEDͲUSE BUILDING Ground Floor Floors 2Ͳ4 Floor 5 Floors 6Ͳ8
lobby / retail spaces lab archive and storage spaces / parking garage mechanical research lab spaces
FUTURE PRENTICE 2 10.15.12
9AW17
The existing Women’s Hospital is reͲdefined to house administrative offices in the base portion of the building and a 140 room boutique hotel at the quatrefoil shaped tower. The hotel is envisioned to serve guests and visiting professors to the facility as well as the general public. A bridge walkway connects the offices to the new lab acros s Huron St.
Green roofs
are incorporated and new glazed enclos ures are added to the clover form at the fourth floor – serving as a restaurant, conference/meeting rooms and lounges for the hotel.
Images of organisms under a microscope – dictydium cancellatum Ͳ
are screen printed on the structural glass. Similar glazing utilized in the new building’s entrance locations serve as linkages between existing and new construction.
FUTURE PRENTICE 3 10.15.12
9AW17
The lab building entry faces
the park and is oriented on a north/south axis with the existing Prentice building. A four story height structural glass wall with a screen printed image Ͳ Defects in the Cholesteric Texture = punctuates the axis at the south façade at Erie St.
The new building will provide daylighting to 90% of it’s spaces, largely in part of a three story height atrium at the lab levels. A window wall at the east facade provides dramatic views to the embryo form.
A
variety of sun screens are employed to modulate solar radiation including operable light shelves that are programmed to adjust throughout the day and aluminum screens layered over the egg shaped offices. The parking garage is screened with perforated metal panels screened with an image of an Arabidopsis thaliana seedling.
FUTURE PRENTICE 4 10.15.12
9AW17
Title: Prentice Volume II Team: Michael Charters
VOL
PRENTICE 02 A New Center
Current trends show top medical research institutes moving towards programmatically diverse, campus-like master plans. Northwestern University’s current Chicago campus is a piecemeal collection of facilities without a cohesive identity. Through the refurbishment of Prentice and the development of the adjacent lot, Northwestern has a rare opportunity to create an iconic campus core which brings in revenue, enhances staff and patient experience, while establishing a recognizable identity for the Chicago campus.
01
Red envelope shows the University’s current plan to build a laboratory tower in place of the current Goldberg structure. In addition to an uncomfortable neighboring adjacency, a vertical massing isn’t best suited for a research facility.
02
A courtyard building better addresses the collaborative nature of a research facility.
03
A new central plaza is created, enhancing the current green corridor.
E SUPERIOR ST
K E L A
LA
M
KE
I C
SH
H
OR IV E
A N
DR
I G
E
E HURON ST
04
N FA I R B A N K S C T
E ERIE ST
An expanded pedway system, creating a central media/social hub in the Prentice Podium.
05
A diverse program ensures 24 hour activity.
9WB40
Hotel atrium, made possible by rearranging the mechanical penthouse
Prentice Hotel and Conference Center
Given the University has rejected the reuse of Goldberg’s iconic structure as housing, laboratory, and office space, I propose it be repurposed as a hotel. There are several working examples of medical university run hotel and conference centers, most notably on the Georgetown medical campus. The hotel would serve hospital patient families, prospective faculty and students, alumni, as well as general tourists. I propose shifting the mechanical penthouse order to allow for a central atrium, bringing light deep into the floor plate. Additionally, the podium will feature a native vegetation roof garden, restaurant, bar, conference center, children’s care, and a media hub as part of an expanded pedway system.
FIG 01
FIG 01
A void cut into the podium for vertical circulation pays homage to the original structure
03 02
01
Plan - Typical Hotel
Plan - Podium Roof 01 - RECREATION ROOM 02 - SUN DECK 03 - PLAYGROUND
01 05
01 04
Standard Room
Large Suite
Extended Stay Family Suite
02
TO LABS
05
02
04
03 03
Plan - Ground Level
Plan - Level 03
01 - BACK OF HOUSE 02 - LOBBY/CONCIERGE 03 - BAR 04 - RESTAURANT 05 - DROP OFF
01 - PRESENTATION ROOMS 02 - CONFERENCE ROOM 03 - OPEN CONVENTION AREA 04 - CHILDREN’S CARE 05 - MEDIA HUB
9WB40
Refurbished Prentice structure and new administrative campanili overlooking main plaza
Plan - Typical Tower
01
01 - OFFICE
TO HUB
03
02
01
Plan - Typical Laboratory 01 - OFFICES AND CONFERENCE 02 - LABORATORY 03 - BREAK OUT SPACE
New Research Laboratories
In contrast to Northwestern’s plans of constructing a laboratory tower, I am suggesting horizontal courtyard layout on the adjacent lot. New research facilities tend to rely heavily on lateral adjacencies for encouraged collaboration, a tower is counterproductive in its isolating, elevator dependent circulation. An administrative spire doubles as a campanili clock tower.
04
06 07 02
03
Plan - Ground Level 01 - OFFICES AND CONFERENCE 02 - PLAZA 03 - BREAK OUT SPACE 04 - BOOKSTORE 05 - CAFE 06 - GARDEN 07 - WINTER GARDEN
05
01
LEVEL 02
LEVEL 01
9WB40
Title: Here and Now Team: David Evancho Zach Hoffman Dan Jick John Lee
HERE AND NOW —FUTURE PRENTICE CHICAGO ARCHITECTURE 2012 COMPETITION HERE AND NOW AIMS AT REALIGNING NORTHWESTERN'S CAMPUS LIFE WITH THE EXIS ING PRENTICE HOSPITAL THROUGH AN ARCHITECTURE DRIVEN BY A CERTAIN LEARNING ENVIRONMENT— AN ENVIRONMENT NOT DEFINED BY STATIC CAMPUS LIFE, BUT ORIENTED TOWARD A DYNAMIC PEDAGOGICAL POSSIBILITY THROUGH THE USE OF FLEXIBILITY AND CIRCULATION.
12R09
The Future Prentice reinitiates Goldberg’s vision of flexible planning and proximity by replacing the core with open circulation that connects each of the floors. The spiral itself becomes a primer for a new pedagogy.
The new learning environment is situated in motion, where "classrooms" are no longer relevant spatial experiences.
12R09
Research as education is non linear. Future Prentice is about using flexible partition spaces to organize new educational ensembles for today’s campus. This spatial rethinking is meant to orient students toward communicating and learning based on their own needs.
This entrepreneurial model of spatial orientation then becomes a service for today's campus life. This new platform is easily adaptable to Goldberg's open floor plan.
12R09
3
1
1. CIRCULATION 2. INTERIOR PARTITIONS 3. FAÇADE TREATMENT
2 Diagrammatic Section
A dynamic nexus point VKRXOG UHpHFW WKH burgeoning Northwestern Campus. This new approach of free form planning, rooted in campus life, draws inspiration from Goldberg’s own geometry WR SURYLGH pH[LELOLW\ DQG new opportunities for the school and hospital, inside and out.
Plan 1/64"=1'0
Title: On and On Team: Matthew Messner Piotr Drezek Obed Lopez Belem Medina Jeisler Salunga Matthew Schneider
On and On
The value of Prentice Women’s Hospital can be measured in many ways. Efficiency, iconography, and spatial experience, to name a few, weigh heavy on its cantilevered shoulders. Perhaps it is time Prentice re-imagined a play known so well to its contemporaries. To make a building tall, very tall, is the surest way to cement its place in the collective consciousness and its place in the city. More square footage per footprint, a place in the sky line, and awe inspiring views. Future Prentice wouldn’t just be another tall building. A unique structure at its current height, one hundred stories taller it would stand out as one of the most unique highrises ever conceived. Every one of Goldberg’s innovations multiplied by ten. A building redefined, to redefine all other tall buildings.
23T16
10’-6”
TWENTY-FOURTH FLOOR
10’-6”
TWENTY-THIRD FLOOR
10’-6”
TWENTY-SECOND FLOOR
10’-6”
TWENTY-FIRST FLOOR
10’-6”
TWENTIETH FLOOR
10’-6”
NINETEENTH FLOOR
10’-6”
EIGHTEENTH FLOOR
10’-6”
SEVENTEENTH FLOOR
10’-6”
SIXTEENTH FLOOR
10’-6”
FIFTEENTH FLOOR
10’-6”
FOURTEENTH FLOOR
10’-6”
THIRTEEN FLOOR TWELFTH FLOOR
10’-6”
FLOOR DEPTHS FOR TOWER APPROX. 15” FLOOR DEPTHS FOR PODIUM APPROX. 12”
14’-8”
ELEVENTH FLOOR
10’-6”
TENTH FLOOR
10’-6”
NINTH FLOOR
10’-6”
EIGHTH FLOOR
10’-6”
SEVENTH FLOOR
10’-6”
SIXTH FLOOR
10’-6”
FIFTH FLOOR
22’-1.5”
FOURTH MECHANICAL
22’-10.5”
FOURTH MECHANICAL
10’-0”
790’-0”
FOURTH FLOOR (Existing steel frame addition not shown)
13’-6”
THIRD FLOOR
13’-6”
SECOND FLOOR
13’-6”
FIRST FLOOR
13’-6.5”
GROUND
SCHEMATIC SECTION
FUTURE PRENTICE: 2012 CHICAGO PRIZE COMPETITION_7
23T16
23T16
Title: Water Purification Tower Team: Sang Wook Park Chong Woo Shin Jin Soo Baek
CHICAGO ARCHITECTURAL CLUB
2012 CHICAGO PRIZE COMPETITION / FUTURE PRENTICE
Northwestern Memorial Hospital Inpatient beds 894 beds Waste water Black water
Located on the campus of Northwestern University, the current site is surrounded by medical facilities, research labs and university residences, all buildings that produce an abundant amount of grey water. Known to be a relatively benign form of waste water, grey water can be recycled and reused fairly easily after having gone through an appropriate filtration process. The main concept of our design is to bring together the grey water from the neighboring buildings and to create a facility that can serve not only as a water purification system but also as a means to knit the diverse community together. The building will provide a myriad of opportunities for education, including a library, a gallery and an observatory, as well as social and commercial opportunities. Its main purpose, however, will be to serve as the focal point for the recycling of the grey water produced in the area, and to store and transport it back into the city. With this newly instilled purpose to a building currently with no specific use, the former Prentice Women’s hospital will no doubt serve a pivotal role in water recycling for the community.
min. 44,342liter/day
Grey water
Black water vs. Grey water = 31% : 69% min. 98,697liter/day
Total Black water: 191,406 liter/day
Total water usage > 617,440 liter/day
Total Grey water: 426,033 liter/day
White water required per day > 620,000 liter/day
Library, Dormitory, School of Engineering and applied science, School of law Waste water Black water min. 28,644liter/day
Grey water min. 63,756liter/day
Feinberg school of Medicine Inpatient beds 2200 beds Waste water
Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago Inpatient beds
Black water
182 beds min. 109,120liter/day
Grey water
Waste water Black water min. 9,300liter/day
Grey water min. 242,880liter/day
min. 20,700liter/day
27H69
Alisma Reed
Iris
Water hyacinth
Phragmites japonica Lemnaceae
Typha orientalis
Ottelia alismoides
Hydrilla verticillata
Lotus
Bur reed
Hornwort
Hydrocharis asiatica
Scirpus trigueter
Hyacinth
Hydrocharis
Javan Waterdropwort Thunbergii
The grey water from the nearby buildings is collected in the lower levels of the structure, where it goes through the initial process of sedimentation. During this process, the suspended solids settle down in the water under the influence of gravity. The solids that collect in the bottom of the sedimentation tank are then separated from the water and are removed from the tank on a regular basis. Subsequently, the filtered water is then transported to the top level of the tower, triggering the second step of water purification. Starting from the top level, the water travels vertically through the floor slabs of the tower at a low velocity, going through various aquatic plants that each serves a distinct function in decontamination. As the water travels through more floors, the more filtered it becomes; once it reaches the lower levels, the water will then be stored and transported for immediate usage.
Typha orientalis Lotus
Hydrilla verticillata
Hydrocharis asiatica: neutralize polluted air with an absorption of carbon
Mentha arvensis Ottelia alismoides Hornwort
Lemnaceae: neutralize acid water with an absorption of N(nitrogen) and P(phosphorus).
Hydrocharis asiatica
Phragmites japonica
Water hyacinth: neutralize acid water with an absorption of N(nitrogen) and P(phosphorus).
Bur reed
Isoetes coreana
Reed: neutralize acid water with an absorption of HNO3(nitric acid), P(phosphorus), K(potassium), Ca(calcium) and Mg(magnesium).
Scirpus triqueter Potamogeton pectinatus
Fresh water Fresh water
Phragmites jasponica: neutralize acid water with an absorption of nitric acid(HNO3) and can use it as medication.
Pure water storage
2nd pur
ification
site B Sediment process
All these ‘Hydrophytes’plants have an ability to purify N(nitrogen), P(phosphorus), K(potassium), Ca(calcium), Mg(Magnesium) in polluted water.
process
in site B
Sediment
27H69
19.
1. Reed 2. Alisma 3. Iris 4. Hydrocharis 5. Hyacinth 6. Lemnaceae 7. Thunbergii 8. Thypha orientalis 9. Javan Waterdropwort 10. Lotus 11. Hydrilla verticilata 12. Mentha arvensis 13. Hornwort 14. Ottelia alismoides 15. Hydrocharis asiatica 16. Isoetes coreana 17. Bur reed 18. Phragmites japonica 19. Scirpus triqueter 20. Potamogeton pectinatus
1.
14.
1.
17.
21.
17.
18.
LURIE RESEARCH CENTER 17.
8.
8.
14.
1.
15.
1.
21. Outdoor Theater 22. Gym 23. Sediment process 24. Pool 25. Cafe 26. Restaurant 27. Library 28. Gallery 29. Conference room
19.
2.
1.
6.
5.
3.
25.
26.
4.
10F: Restaurant
11F: Observatory/Cafe
27.
9.
10.
7.
8.
11.
8.
12.
8F: Library
9F: Library 18.
27.
1.
22.
21.
14.
13.
18.
15.
28.
28.
17.
24.
5.
17.
8.
23.
16.
17.
6F: Gallery
7F: Gallery
17.
10.
2F: site A Table
1.
8.
29.
1.
1.
1.
free-floating hydrophytes
REHABILITATION INSTITUTE OF CHICAGO 1.
19.
6.
21.
submerged hydrophytes
20.
emergent hydrophytes 21.
5F: Conference room site B
Masterplan
27H69
00000 27H69
Title: A Building Inside Team: Cristina Chamero. Architect Juan Felipe GarcĂa. Technical Architect
Title: Chicago Skywalker Team: RubĂŠn Bodewig Belmonte Alejandro Soriano Herrera
WHERE CITY AND UNIVERSITY MEET AGAIN
SAVE PRENTICE
ID 32B31
ossible is n p m oth :I #3 in Y
!!
NU
BO
g
Northwestern University wants to demolish Old Prentice Women’s Hospital building to replace it and build in this place a 500.000 sqft new facilities. But... is it necessary?
1p
NO
H RT E NOHOR 0 68 E S K LA IVE DR
RE
DI
ST
RI
BU
TI
ON
OV E
trategy to mov »s ep «L
o
campus. the in
!! er
IE UR . L N’S H T RE L ER LD ITA OB CHI SP GO R & HO ICA N CH AN OF
The Northwestern University campus and Northwestern Memorial Hospital mobility patterns currently are too much dependent on parking lots for private vehicles.
STRA TE G
S
HO
Y
e peoplemov h T : er #1
We could learn from the Loop, and improve the interior mobility network to connect every building of the Campus and provide hubs to link with exterior networks based on sustainable transport. That would be a healthy change for a Medical Hub.
Northwestern University Chicago Campus Loop urban orbit
ID 32B31
T R
A
lon g
E IC NT ’S E N PR ME H) WO (NM AL PIT
trategy to mo ys ve t i rs
d link pl ac le an es op pe
E W GA
C &M N S O N S OL ILIO V PA
RD WAIAL R MO ING ME ILD BU
p. oo eL
H
e
The vacant lot in front of the former Prentice is an unique opportunity to create a green heart for the campus, turning this place into a medical and social hub for the community.
R .LU TH R BE L RO DICACH E M EAR S R RE TE N CE
ft
0
ON RT L MODICAH ME ARCG SE IN RE ILD U B
cyclists live
T AS ET 3 E RE 23 E ST I ER
N L ER ITA ST OSP E HW L H RT IA NO MOR ME
IE
LE AR AL SE DICRCH MESEA NG I RE ILD BU
us tr a k p n i l ns l aces bs nd por a hu i h e n t t i l n w e t k r wo p th eo
p
E FU X T R PA U E N R S S E E I R O V N E
m
N
E
E
215.000 s qft new
ca
LO T
R
5
8
=
R
prove everyw m I : he #2 r The
university campus, specially focused on medicine and health, should be surrounded by a healthy and green environment that could contribute to create a better atmosphere for patients, doctors, investigators, students...
STRA TE G
EP
G
K IC RM O C MCLL HA ER DT AY OL M Y EB I V W LL LE LL HA HA
tons/year
lev els
E 16 NT P 0x O 22 DIU 0f M t ( SU 35 R .10 FA 0 s CE qf t)
ted
en heart gre F OF BL ING U R ILD BU
1.3 CO2
Y
TH
G IN AT HE NT A PL
each bike saves
=5
E leva
ea
TT BO AB LL HA
20
RR
RT HW NE EST W E 50 PR RN 0.0 OJ UN 00 EC IVE sq T S RS ft UR IT =1 F Y 6x AC lev E els
R
n areas to gree cre at
ke t
rthwestern Un No ive
What if we could generate this new space saving the building and generating a new identity landmark in the campus? We propose to move the projected built surface of the new building to a new external volume over a new green heart of the Campus.
connect campus buildings
CU
ac
Ch ica g
STRA TE G
CE PA S S
200
Viewpoint deck
Cafe & Restaurant Garden
ft
100
University Facilities
0
Hall & Mezzanine
50
Boardrooms & Offices
Campus extension: lecture hall, labs, offices, research, classrooms.
Mixed use building: offices, labs, meeting rooms, library... Campus transport hub: connection with park lots, bike service, interior street, elevated plaza.
1 Prentice building .................. 327.000 sqft 2 Connection building ............. 186.000 sqft 3 Campus extension ................ 165.000 sqft Total
2
3
0
50
100
................................... 678.000 sqft + 215.000 sqft green heart!
1
200
ft
ID 32B31
BACK TO THE FUTURE Could a modern building come back to life and get updated according to other modern architecture concepts and references?
A MODERN TRIBUTE
The architectural history teaches us that there are some universal languages used by civilizations to build a memorial for paying tribute to an important figure of the past. Maybe if the city of Chicago does not recognize the importance of Bertrand Goldberg’s legacy, is because this building is not within the appropriate framework to understand its importance.
Bauhaus Dessau - Walter Gropius, 1926
So we’ll convert its environment in a temple to honor his memory with a universal language through three well known strategies: PODIUM: Locate the building on a raised platform that allows it to rise and be seen as a monument to the memory.
Continuous Monument - Superstudio, 1969
Statue of Liberty - Bartholdi + Eiffel , 1886 FOOTPRINT: Recognize a legacy of the past through the void of the trace left, as a scar on the ground.
Exodus - Rem Koolhaas, 1972
Berlin Wall Memorial - Kohlhoff & Kohlhoff, 1998
La Ville Spatiale - Yona Friedman, 1960
High Line NYC- Diller Scofidio + Renfro, 2003
GHOST: Preserve for the future the spirit of a memory beyond the material, the tangible and the visible things.
National S11 Memorial - Michael Arad, 2011
ID 32B31
Title: Frame the Future Team: Hui Xu
FRAME THE FUTURE The most critical issue on the site has to do with two things: what is a future space for medical research programs like? How to preserve and even exaggerate the evocative characteristics of existing structure? What we propose is an engaging framework that could bring people closer than ever before to the important medical world it carries out by revealing the medical researchers at work. The renovation offers visitors an insight into the full spectrum of the world of medical science. The existing structure as a beautiful object of being could serve as a container for the exchange of information and education. The central core of the existing floors is cut through a spiral ramp, connecting both the entrance at the ground level and the four petal-spaces arranged in split-level series. The pedal spaces contain both various exhibitions on research progress and open labs where public science activities take place. The existing structure is framed by a tower stands behind acting as the stage setting. It also holds the main medical program. Horizontally, the tower and the existing structure are connected by a new podium with a courtyard open to public. Both the scientists and the visitors to the museum will be gathering together in this space. This courtyard also provides a fantastic platform for people to have an overall view of the unique outline of the tower and the winding ramp. This proposal shows a maximum of respect for the current architectural legacy.
FRAME THE FUTURE 40X48
1
MEDICAL RESEARCH LABS PUBLIC PODIUM MEDICAL MUSEUM
SITE PLAN
SCHEMATIC SECTION
GROUND FLOOR PLAN
TYPICAL FLOOR PLAN
FRAME THE FUTURE 40X48
2
FRAME THE FUTURE 40X48
3
FRAME THE FUTURE 40X48
4
itle: Architecture, Aging-In-Place Team: Elizabeth George Jason Dobbin
RESIDENTIAL NORTHWESTERN MEMORIAL HOSPITAL CAMPUS SITE A: TO BE UTILIZED BY NORTHWESTERN SITE B: ONLY SITE UTILIZED IN THIS PROPOSAL
STREETERVILLE, GOLD COAST, AND RIVER NORTH BOOMER RESIDENCES CHICAGO, ILLINOIS
On January 1, 2011, the oldest members of the Baby Boom generation turned 65 years old. “On that day, today, and every day for the next 19 years, 10,000 baby boomers will reach age 65”. The needs for this American demographic (26% of the total U.S. population) will dramatically change the composition and subsequently the landscape of this country. As Boomers typically feel a decade younger than their actual age, they may stay socially active longer than those of previous generations. - Pew Research Center
T THHEECCHHICICAAGGOO ININT TEERRGGEENNEERRAAT TIOIONNAAL L CCOOMMMMUUNNITITYYCCEENNT TEERR 50R28
SUPERIOR STREET
1
2
3 6
4
7 9
5
6
9
8
8
10
14 ASSISTED LIVING
15
1 DROP-OFF 2 RESIDENT ENTRY 3 RESIDENT LOBBY 4 FRONT DESK/CONCIERGE 5 LEASING/ADMINISTRATION 6 CAFE’/KITCHEN 7 ELEVATORS 8 STAIRS 9 RESTROOMS 10 COMMUNITY CENTER 11 COMMUNITY MARKET 12 PUBLIC ENTRY 13 MARKET ENTRY 14 BUS DROP-OFF/LOADING 15 RAMP TO EXIST. PARKING (BELOW GRADE)
11
SKILLED NURSING WELLNESS: FITNESS/SPA/REJUVENATION GARDEN CAFETERIA/RESTAURANTS/ADMINISTRATION
13
12
COMMUNITY: ARTS/ACTIVITIES/DOMESTIC COMMERCE/ADMIN. MECHANICAL
HURON STREET
ENTRY LEVEL
TH E CH I CA GO I N TE R G E N E R A TI ON A L C OM M U N I TY C E N TE R 50R28
1 17 11
8
12
9
18
4
REJUVENATION GARDEN
18
9 13
7 2
14
7
3
8
8
10
19
8
8 18
18
6
19
16
6 15
5
5
COMMUNITY ARTS FLOOR FLOOR 2
REJUVENATION ROOF GARDEN FLOOR 5
1 GALLERY/FLEXIBLE SPACE 2 RELIGIOUS SPACE 3 THEATER 4 COMMERCIAL KITCHEN 5 ART ROOM/CLASSROOM 6 CLASSROOM 7 ELEVATORS 8 STAIRS 9 RESTROOMS 10 LOBBY/LOUNGE 11 EXTERIOR FITNESS SPACE 12 HAMMOCK FIELD 13 AMPITHEATER 14 FORMAL PATIO 15 POOL 16 GARDEN PLOTS 17 WALKING (WANDERING) PATHS 18 CHANGE ROOMS/SHOWERS 19 SUPPORT STORAGE
AGOO T THHEECCHHI CI CAG AL I NI NT TEERRGGEENNEERRATATI OI ONNAL CCOOMMMMUUNNI TI TYYCCEENNT TEERR 50R28
15 12 12
15
15
1
14
15
13
17 16
7 7
4
3
2
9
8
15
11
12
15 15
16
13
5
6
6
4
4
3
16 9
2
17 10
7
8
16 11
13 16
16 15
16
5
7
16
16
12
16
16
16
14
2
17
10
5
3
16
12
1
16
17
6
12
16
16
16
16
16 8
16
16 16
5
16
16
16
15
16
16
12 16
13 16
12
16
16
HOUSEHOLD I
TYPICAL ASSISTED LIVING FLOOR PLAN
16
16
16
FLOOR PLAN KEY 1 ENTRY/ELEVATOR 2 ACTIVITY KITCHEN/ NURSE STATION 3 DINING/ACTIVITY 4 PANTRY/KITCHEN/SERVERY 5 CONVENIENCE VENDING 6 MEDICINE ROOM 7 SPA/TUB 8 PUBLIC WASHROOMS 9 SOILED ROOM 10 CLEAN ROOM 11 COMMUNITY ROOM 12 WORK STATIONS 13 DEN/LIVING 14 LIBRARY/LIVING 15 ONE BEDROOM LIVING UNIT 16 STUDIO LIVING UNIT 17 STAIRS
HOUSEHOLD II
TYPICAL SKILLED NURSING FLOOR PLAN
FLOORS 11, 12, 13., 14
FLOORS 8, 9, 10
UNIT PLAN KEY E
D
D
E C
F
B A
UNIT INTERIOR
TYPICAL STUDIO UNIT PLAN
G
A ENTRY CLOSET B KITCHENETTE C DINING/ACTIVITY D LIVING E BATH F BEDROOM G WALK-IN CLOSET
A
TYPICAL 1 BR UNIT PLAN
T H E C H I C AG O I N T ER G EN ERAT I O N AL C O M M U N I T Y C EN T ER 50R28
Title: Healing Ecology. The New Center For Integrative Medicine At The Northwestern Memorial Medical Campus. Team: Paul Alt John Jewell Chris Wolf Robert Christo Colin Emch-Wei
Lake Michigan
Water Tower
Museum of Contemporary Art
Lake Shore Park
Views of Lake
Vertical Circulation
Beach
Mechanical Space e sh
Lak
Prentice Women’s Hospital
Yoga Tai Chi Aerobics
D ore
Lurie Children’s Hospital
rive
Existing Center for Integrative medicine
Health Education Center
Rehabilitaion Institute of Chicago
Michigan Avenue
Communal Event Space
Hotel Rooms
680 N. Huron D
Behavioral Therapy Rooms N
Existing Center for Integrative medicine
Accupunture Aroma Therapy Reiki
New Center for Integrative Medicine
Communal Assets
Site Connections
Northwestern Memorial Medical Campus
HEALING ECOLOGY
THE NEW CENTER FOR INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE AT THE NORTHWESTERN MEMORIAL MEDICAL CAMPUS
Art Gallery
Art Therapy Music Therapy/ Performance Space Retail Space
We propose to reprogram the building using evidence-based design to foster architecture as a tool for healing. This design program is intended to interface with traditional clinical programming to increase the efficacy of treatments for those trying to overcome disease, prevent chronic health conditions, and enhance their well-being. The use of complementary medicine treatments researched by the National Institute of Health like reiki, meditation, music therapy, and art therapy will be provided alongside traditional clinical programs for chemotherapy, diabetes, and other chronic diseases. In summation, we propose to house the Northwestern Memorial Hospital Integrative Health Department in the Ida B. Stone Pavilion. Currently, this department is temporarily located in an office building adjacent to a hotel. Our proposed Integrative Health Center will contain spaces that range from organic food stores, a pharmacy, communal healing event space, individual healing event space, hotel, and an education center. The proposed center will act as the gateway between the Northwestern Memorial Hospital, The Rehabilitation Institute, Children’s Hospital, and the surrounding community. Healing never occurs in isolation. By integrating adjacent community assets like Lakeshore Park, the Chicago Lakefront, the MCA, and the Looking Glass Theater, opportunities for activating additional communal healing events become available for the programming of the proposed center. Additionally, the surrounding medical buildings are packed with clinics, laboratories, and medical offices that focus services on individual care. Our proposal will create a comprehensive integrative medical facility that serves all patient needs including food, medication, health and lifestyle education, group and individual therapy…all the while employing strategies that unify the mind, body, and spirit.
Lounge Area
Universal Worship space Therapeutic Garden Office/Clinic Space
Lobby
Communal Healing Space Office/Clinic Space Hotel Rooms Individual Healing Space
N
Therapeutic Garden Space ENTRY ENTRY ID: ID: 53F06
OFFICE SPACE/ CLINICAL SPACE
The 3rd & 4th floors are dedicated to medical office space and clinics.
Base
ART THERAPY
The communal art therapy space links to an adjacent garden space, roof garden above, and allows northern light. In addition, the sunlight penetrates to the music therapy space below.
ART THERAPY
GALLERY SPACE
The gallery space wraps around the music therapy/performance space to create a sequence of healing programming.
MUSIC THERAPY/ PERFORMANCE SPACE This space can be used for large performances for visitors and patients as well as a healing environment for music therapy.
MUSIC THERAPY/PERFORMANCE SPACE
LOBBY The lobby is located between the north and south entrances with a reception pod between the elevators and the grand staircase.
RETAIL SPACE
Retail Space is located on the ground floor connecting to the lobby. Retail opportunities include a pharmacy, a cafe, and an organic market.
N LOBBY
ENTRY ID: ID: 53F06 ENTRY
Middle
BEHAVIORAL THERAPY SPACES The behavioral therapy space cantilevers off of the underside of the north facing section of the structure. The spaces provide an opportunity for meditation, journaling, and other behavioral therapies. BEHAVIORAL THERAPY SPACE
MECHANICAL TO TOP TREES TO ROOF
By moving the mechanical space from the middle to the top of the building, both access to the roof and the opportunity for a therapeutic roof garden is created.
UNIVERSAL WORSHIP SPACE The worship space facilitates communal spiritual healing services for all denominations. The lights floating within the atrium above are a metaphor for hope and future possibilities.
UNIVERSAL WORSHIP SPACE
THERAPEUTIC GARDENS The therapeutic garden is a forest of trees sitting on the roof of the base element of the building. It provides for passive and active participation within a garden and forest environment.
N
THERAPEUTIC GARDENS
ENTRY ENTRY ID: ID: 53F06
YOGA/TAI CHI/AEROBICS SPACE The double height space in the middle of the top two levels is designated for yoga, tai chi, and aerobics. Top
INDIVIDUAL THERAPY ROOMS The adjacent therapy rooms are designated to help participants with complementary therapies such as acupuncture, reiki, and aromatherapy. YOGA/TAI CHI/AEROBICS SPACE
LOUNGE SPACE CENTER MOVES OUT
By moving the circulation out of the center it has created the opportunity for a double height space for communal activities.
These are communal spaces where people can share stories or view adjacent healing activities.
HEALTH EDUCATION CENTER This is a resource center where participants can research and learn about complementary medicine.
HEALTH EDUCATION CENTER
HOTEL ROOMS
Hotel Rooms are provided for outof-town participants engaging in the complementary medicine therapies as well as the surrounding traditional clinics at Northwestern Memorial Campus.
HOSPITAL ROOMS TO HOTEL ROOMS
By subtracting from the existing hospital rooms, a more spacious hotel sized room is created with access to two bathrooms for families. N
COMMUNAL EVENT SPACE This is a flexible space for communal activities such as the celebration of healing through meals, dancing, and presentations HOTEL ROOM
ENTRY ID: ID: 53F06 ENTRY
Title: The Prentice & The Pauper - (Goldberg Storytelling Center) Team: C_UP T. Joseph Surjan Stephanie H. Fumanelli John F. Perrine
Storytelling is a form of talk therapy. FOUR storeys of matter : Existing Condition
Remove Podium
Staircase Plinth & Water Basin
Floating Garden & Auditoriums
SOLID = Static
LIQUID = Non-equilbrium
GAS = Equilbrium
PLASMA = Public
Storey
Storey
Prentice & Pauper - ( Goldberg Storytelling Center ) the
the
Storey
Storey
Chicago Architectural Club: 2012 Chicago Prize Competition - FUTURE PRENTICE registration number -
85X36
panel 1/4
In this new tale, the Prentice plays herself, and the role of the Pauper is performed by a civil servant known as Staircase. Staircase Plinth :
North Elevation
Prentice & Pauper - ( Goldberg Storytelling Center ) the
the
West Elevation
South Elevation
Chicago Architectural Club: 2012 Chicago Prize Competition - FUTURE PRENTICE registration number -
85X36
panel 2/4
Stories adapt & change over time as a direct link to the storyteller.
Precast Concrete Components :
Staircase
Tread & Riser as single unit.
Prentice & Pauper - ( Goldberg Storytelling Center ) the
the
Vault
Entry Vestibule @ Water Basin
Floating Garden
Filtered light for Interior & Exterior
Chicago Architectural Club: 2012 Chicago Prize Competition - FUTURE PRENTICE registration number -
85X36
panel 3/4
A city is a story, & every story is a city. CITY
FOUR scales :
Prentice & Pauper - ( Goldberg Storytelling Center ) the
the
DISTRICT
STREET
HOUSE
Chicago Architectural Club: 2012 Chicago Prize Competition - FUTURE PRENTICE registration number -
85X36
panel 4/4
Title: The Seed Of Culture / Newborn Prentice Team: Tipo Elena Bellini Marco Benvenuti Marco Bartoli Niccolo Bassilichi Annalaura Ciampi Sara Ramundo
Title: PWH Hotel Team: Chris Curley Josye Utick
PWH HOTEL
An Entrepreneurial Shift from Hospital to Hospitality Chicago Architectural Club’s 2012 Chicago Prize Competition ID Number 70J87
Ground Floor Plan
Level 1 Floor Plan
skybridge connections
Front Desk Area
Incubator Hub
Student Cafe/Coffee Shop
Guest Rooms
Front Office & Admin
Public Circulation
Restrooms
Meeting/Conference/ Classrooms
Bar Lounge/Coffee Shop/Restaurant
Fitness
Back of House/Service
Vertical Circulation
PWH HOTEL
An Entrepreneurial Shift from Hospital to Hospitality Chicago Architectural Club’s 2012 Chicago Prize Competition ID Number 70J87
Level 2 Floor Plan
Level 3 Floor Plan Front Desk Area
Incubator Hub
Student Cafe/Coffee Shop
Guest Rooms
Front Office & Admin
Public Circulation
Restrooms
Meeting/Conference/ Classrooms
Bar Lounge/Coffee Shop/Restaurant
Fitness
Back of House/Service
Vertical Circulation
PWH HOTEL
An Entrepreneurial Shift from Hospital to Hospitality Chicago Architectural Club’s 2012 Chicago Prize Competition ID Number 70J87
section
Guest Room Level Floor Plan
Option 1
Option 2
Option 3
no vertical expansion/168 guest rooms
2 story vertical expansion/216 guest rooms
Front Desk Area
Incubator Hub
Student Cafe/Coffee Shop
Guest Rooms
Front Office & Admin
Public Circulation
Restrooms
Meeting/Conference/ Classrooms
Bar Lounge/Coffee Shop/Restaurant
Fitness
Back of House/Service
Vertical Circulation
5 story vertical expansion/288 guest rooms
PWH HOTEL
An Entrepreneurial Shift from Hospital to Hospitality Chicago Architectural Club’s 2012 Chicago Prize Competition ID Number 70J87
Title: Water the Clover Team: Mohamad Dehnee
Title: reC/OVER LEAF Team: Supachai Chalermratananon Jeranun Lowatcharagul
reC/OVER LEAF "Chicagoland" is revolved from "the great Chicago fire". Shall "reLeaf" prentice women’s hospital be motivated from her relict... Prentice women's hospital by Bertrand Goldberg is one of the significant historic landmark at global city, the heart of four clover leaf architectural form emerges among the fog of ordinary boxy building since then. As one part of the Northwestern University expansion phase; "reC/over" the utilizable place for the future of medical research program is the design treatment that vertically grows to reach the recent Chicago skyline celebration. Such as new leaves springing, clover leaf floor plate forms from the art of the missing leaf, the variety of the floor openings create the common internal court between levels. From the original massive concrete converses to the new transparency material, through this dissolution facade merges into the sky that allows the light transmitting inside as well as the panoramic views to Lake Michigan and cityscape. For public access and Northwestern university campus network; by disappearing its podium that exposes the sculptural concrete stem with the radical linkages to the other buildings, at its base provides the common area for public activity domain, also an underground exhibition accessibility. reC/over is one that recovers the magnificent modern architecture’s master while metro-fitting the existing building to meet the new programmatic requirement. It is a concept that honor for the life and soul of “Chi-City”.
03895
MEDICAL RESEARCH
DATA RESEARCH
INTERCHANGE
03895
STRUCTURE
As remaining the existing core system state. Rather insert the rigid frame (shown as red) for reinforcing By minimized footprint, provides the transfer bracing to receive the extension load growth.
FACADE
Translucent concrete is based building envelope material with light-transmissive properties due to embedded light optical elements. This results into the certain light pattern on surface, depending on the fiber structure... creates the gradient transition to transparency glass at top of the tower.
03895
03895
Title: Future Prentice Team: Iori Architects Inc. Clelia Iori, BArch OAA Principal Yoonsun Chang, Arch.Sci.,Associate
Title: Ghost Team: Kyle May Shane Neufeld
33287
G
H
O
S
T
WE OFTEN TAKE FOR GRANTED THE THINGS CLOSEST TO US. IT IS ONLY AFTER WE HAVE LOST THEM THAT THEIR MEANING CAN TRULY BE UNDERSTOOD. AS IS THE CASE WITH ARCHITECTURE, WHERE A BUILDING’S DESTRUCTION MAY BE PAINFUL, OUR COMPREHENSION OF THIS LOSS CRYSTALLIZES ONLY AFTER THE WORK HAS DISAPPEARED FOREVER. CHICAGO’S PRENTICE HOSPITAL, SLATED FOR DEMOLITION, OFFERS US THE OPPORTUNITY TO RE-THINK THIS PERILOUS YET TRADITIONAL OUTCOME AND TO PROPOSE AN ENTIRELY DIFFERENT TYPE OF RESPONSE. WHAT IF THE DECISION WEREN’T TEARING IT DOWN OR LETTING IT STAND, BUT RATHER, TO ACCOMPLISH BOTH? IN ORDER TO DO JUST THAT, OUR PROPOSAL ENCAPSULATES PRENTICE IN A MULTI LAYERED GLASS CASE—LIKE AN ARTIFACT IN A MUSEUM—WHOSE QUALITIES BOTH ALLOW FOR ABSOLUTE TRANSPARENCY AS WELL AS OPTICAL DISTORTION. THE GLASS MAY FOG, GLITTER, REFLECT, OR COMPLETELY GO AWAY. THE IMAGE OF PRENTICE WILL NO LONGER REMAIN BRUTAL AND CONSTANT, BUT WILL INSTEAD BEHAVE AS AN APPARITION, TRANSFORMING FROM ONE DAY TO THE NEXT. LIKE A GHOST, PRENTICE WILL DISAPPEAR WHEN WE LEAST EXPECT IT, BUT RETURN TO HAUNT US JUST TO REMIND US HOW MUCH WE MISS IT.
33287
33287
Title: PWH: Old shape, New landmark Team: Pragmatopia Marc Kirschbaum Stefanie Weidel
1148ft John Hancock Center
725ft Olympia Center
843ft Park Tower
859ft Water Tower Place
871ft 900 N Michigan
608ft Chicago Place 525ft New Prentice
Chicago
Near North Side
Chicago Avenue
Fairbanks Court
Superior Street
Huron Street
Erie Street
N
FUTURE PRENTICE 12345 PWH: old shape, new landmark
64235
Concept - scheme
characteristic landmark
PROTECTING
revision Goldberg
keeping place identity
unique architecture
+
PRESERVING
MEDICIAL RESEARCH CENTER
old shape, new landmark
preserving the original facade
floor 23 floor 22 floor 21
+
floor 20
RISING OFFICE
worth keeping
energetic rehabilitation
reflate vacancy floor 15
VERTICAL GARDEN
floor 14 floor 13
historical and futurize
climatic facade
space expansion for Northwestern University
floor 12
LAB floor 11 floor 10
ROOF TERRACE GUEST HOUSE/ APARTEMENTS
USE BY UNIVERSITY ENTRY
floor 2 floor 1
64235
Floor plans & vertical gardens
view green area cafeteria region of nonoperation meeting point old facade usable space
climatic facade
lab / office stairs to upper/lower green areas
green area
part of bearing structure N
floor 12+13
floor 14+15
floor 16+17
floor 18+19
floor 20+21
floor 22+23
floor 24+25
64235
Section | Green area setting
lab / office
climatic facade exterior facade interior facade
opening windows
open or close space green area
technical area
N
N
64235
Title: Move IT, or LOSE it Team: Jeff Jeno
Title: “Sports Research Facility builds on Architect Goldberg’s rich Chicago vision for architecture!” Team: Cesar M. Ceballos, AIA Kerry Shahan, AIA Tony Rios Lelee Laosy Jesus Rangel
4QPSUT 3FTFBSDI 'BDJMJUZ CVJMET PO "SDIJUFDU (PMECFSH’T SJDI $IJDBHP WJTJPO GPS BSDIJUFDUVSF $IJDBHP JT XFMM LOPXO GPS TQPSUT BOE B QSPQPTFE SFTFBSDI SFUBJM BOE TQPSUT NFEJDBM GBDJMJUZ JT TFU UP CVJME B EZOBNJD NBSLFUQMBDF BDSPTT GSPN POF PG $IJDBHP’T BSDIJUFDUVSBM NBTUFSQJFDFT %FMJWFSJOH NVDI OFFEFE IPVTJOH QSPGFTTJPOBM PGGJDFT BMPOH XJUI B NBTUFSGVM QMB[B UIBU CBMBODFT UJNF BOE TQBDF CSJOHT B OFX FSB PG SFTFBSDI UP /PSUIXFTUFSO 6OJWFSTJUZ BMPOH XJUI QSPNJTF GPS GVSUIFS FDPOPNJD HSPXUI 1SFOUJDF #VJMEJOH 1SFTFSWBUJPO $IJDBHP’T SJDI NPEFSO BSDIJUFDUVSBM IJTUPSZ JT XPSUI PG QSFTFS± WBUJPO )PXFWFS CVJMEJOHT OFFE GVODUJPO BOE QVSQPTF BOE OFFE UP BEBQU UP UIF FWFS DIBOHJOH OFFET PG UIFJS PXOFST BOE UFOBOUT 5IF QSFOUJDF CVJMEJOH’T PVUXBSE BQQFBSBODF TIPVME OPU DIBOHF JO GPSN 3FQMBDJOH UIF BSDIJUFDU’T DVSUBJO XBMM TZTUFN XJUI BO VQEBUFE DMFBS HMBTT TZTUFN XJMM GVMGJMM (PMECFSH’T PSJHJOBM WJTJPO GPS BO PQFO HMBTT TZUFN "MUIPVHI XF EFDJEFE SFTFBSDI XPVME CF UIF CFTU VTF GPS UIF CVJMEJOH QSPWJEJOH QVCMJD BDDFTT UP UIF MPXFS SPPG BOE BDDFTT UP UIF UPQ MFWFM PG UIF CVJMEJOH XJUI BO BSDIJUFDUVSBM BSU NVTFBN BOE DPGGFF TIPQ XPVME CF CFOFGJDJBM UP UIF QSPKFDU 5IJT DPVME CF BDDPNQMJTIFE CZ QSPWJEJOH B TJOHMF HMBTT TUBJSXFMM TZTUFN .BJO± UBJOJOH B NJOJNBM BQQSPBDI UP BOZ BEEFE DPOTUSVDUJPO XPVME CF UIF PCKFDUJWF IFSF
75219
4JUF 1MBO
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
1SPHSBN .FEJDBM
.FEJDBM BOE %FOUBM 0GGJDFT 4QPSUT .FEJDJOF 4UFN $FMM 3FTFBSDI .FEJDBM 3PCPUJDT 5FDIOPMPHZ )FBMUI BOE 8FMMOFT
"NNFOJUJFT
*DF 4LBUJOH 3JOL $PNNFSDJBM 3FUBJM TUPSFT BOE 3FTUBVSBOUT 1VCMJD TQBDF 1VCMJD BSU JO IPOPS PG 8PNFO’T 1SFOUJDF 1BUJFOUT BOE .FEJDBM 4FSWJDF "SFB±-PBEJJOH BOE 6OMPBEJOH $FOUSBM 1MBOU .FDIBOJDBM &MFDUSJDBM 'BDJMJUZ 4FSWJDFT $POGFSFODF $FOUFS BOE -FDUVSF )BMMT "VEJUPSJVN .VTFVN -JCSBSZ
)PVTJOH
"QBSUNFOU 6OJUT GPS .FEJDBM 3FTJEFOUT BOE 4UBGG 4IPSU 5JNF 6OJUT GPS 1BUJFOUTÂ’ 3FMBUJWFT
75219
75219
4JUF 1MBO 0VS QSJNBSZ GPDVT JT CPUI UP FOSJDI UIF BSFB XJUI OFX FDPOPNJD HSPXUI UP UIF 6OJWFSTJUZ XIJMF FOIBODJOH UIF PSJHJOBM 1SFOUJDF #VJMEJOH UISPVHI UIF EFWFMPQNFOU PG B DFOUSBM 1MB[B 5IF TJUF QMBO JODMVEFT BNQMF PQQPSUVOJUZ GPS HSPXUI JO CPUI SFTFBSDI BOE EFWFMPQNFOU XIJMF BEESFTTJOH DPNNPO OFFET PG 6OJWFSTJUJFT JODMVEJOH IPVTJOH BOE SFUBJM HSPXUI #SJOHJOH DVTUPNFST UP UIF BSFB UP CPUI FOKPZ UIF FOSJDIFE IJTUPSZ PG $IJDBHP XIJMF FTUBCMJTIJOH B QSPNJOFOU SFTFBSDI BSFB XBT PVS PCKFDUJWF 5IJT EFWFMPQNFOU CVJME VQPO UIF IJTUPSJDBM SJDIOFTT PG UIF BSFB XIJMF BJNJOH UPXBSET UIF GVUVSF XJUI EFWFMPQJOH JOEVTUSJFT UIBU PGGFS IJHI HSPXUI
.PEFM PG 1MB[B /PSUI 1FSTQFDUJWF
)PVTJOH
)PVTJOH JT BMXBZT B DSJUJDBM OFFE GPS 6OJWFSTJUJFT BOE XIBU XF VOEFSTUBOE /PSUI± 5IF 1MB[B JT BU UIF IFBSU PG PVS EFTJHO UIBU JODMVEFT UIF IJTUPSJDBM 1SFOUJDF XFTUFSO JT OP EJGGFSFOU 8JUI HSPXJOH SFTFBSDI GBDJMJUJFT BT QSPQPTFE B MBSHF CVJMEJOH 4JODF UIF GPSNT PG UIF CVJEJOH BSF TUSPOH JO TIBQF BOE EFTJHO 0VS NVMUJ±TUPSZ IPVTJOH VOJU JT QMBDFE BMPOH &SJF 4USFFU 8IJMF JU JT UIF CBDLESPQ UP NPEFM BOE JEFB PG DSFBUJOH B SFUBJM QMB[B DBSSJFT B CBMBODF BDSPTT UIF TUSFFU UIF $PVSUZBSE JU XBT BMTP BO PQQPSUVOJUZ UP QSPWJEF B CPME FOFSHFUJD XFTU GBDJOH "MUIPVHI UIF QMB[B JT JOUFOEFE UP CF VTFE CZ UIF QVCMJD QSPWJEJOH B TLBUJOH TDSFFO *U JT PVS JOUFOUJPO UP DSFBUF BO FMFWBUFE IPVTJOH FMFNFOU BCPWF UIF EFWFM± SJOL JO UIF DFOUFS XBT B XBZ UP TIPX BO BDUJWF QIZTJDBM TQPSUJOH BDUJWJUZ PQNFOUT OFX QBSLJOH BOE DFOUFS BDDFTT SPBE BMPOH XJUI NBJOUBJOJOH B EJWJEJOH XIJMF CVJMEJOH BO BUUSBDUJPO UP UIF SFUBJM TIPQQJOH FYQFSJFODF 5IJT QMB[B JT MBOETDBQJOH FMFNFOU XIFSF UIF CVJMEJOHT DPMVNOT BOE TFDPOE TUPSZ BDDFTT XBZ TFU POF TUPSZ EPXO GSPN UIF OFX QFEFTUSJBO TUSFFU UIBU DPVME BMTP BDU BT B UIBU XPVME CF DPNQMJNFOUFE XJUI B SPX PG USFFT BOE VQQFS TUPSZ BDDFTT MJHIUXFMM UP UIF MPXFS MFWFMT PG UIF MBSHFS EFWFMPQNFOU 1SPWJEJOH PSHBOJ[FE WFIJDVMBS BDDFTT XIJMF FOIBODJOH VTFS FYQFSJFODF UISPVHI 0VS OFX EFWFMPQNFOU JT DSFBUFE BT UIF JOWFSTF PG UIF 1SFOUJDF CVJMEJOH MBOETDBQF JT TPNFUIJOH XF SFDPNNFOE &SJF TUSFFU DBO PGGFS CPUI BO FOIBODF XJUI B 8BSN (SBOJUF 4UPOF #BTF XJUI 4ZNNFUSJD (MBTT 4RVBSFT PO UPQ EPPSXBZ UP UIF OFX DFOUFS XIJMF QSPWJEJOH IPVTJOH PDDVQBOUT BO FOIBODFE MBOE± QSPWJEJOH CBMBODF CFUXFFO OFX BOE FYJTUJOH BSDIJUFDUVSBM FMFNFOUT TDBQF QFEFTUSJBO BDDFTT
$PODMVTJPO *UÂ’T BO JEFBT DPNQFUJUJPO BOE XF IPQF UIBU UISPVHI PVS HSBQIJDT QMBOT BOE XSJUUFO UFYU QSPWJEF B HMJNQTF JOUP UIF GVSUIFSFE WJTJPO GPS IPX UP BQQSPBDI UIF PQQPSUVOJUZ GPS EFWFMPQNFOU JO UIJT BSFB 5IF SFNPWBM PG IJTUPSJD BSDIJUFDUVSF JT OPU TPNFUIJOH UIBU TIPVME CF UBLFO MJHIUMZ BOE BMUIPVHI VTFT DIBOHF CVJMEJOHT DBO BEBQU UP GJOE OFX QVSQPTF " OFX WJTJPO PG DPNNFSDJBMJTN SFTFBSDI JO UIJT IJTUPSJD EFWFMPQNFOU XJMM BMMPX GPS OFX MJGF BOE TUSPOH WJUBMJUZ UP $IJDBHP T VSCBO DPSF
75219
Title: (great) Food, (teach) Architecture Team: Mark Davis Clarisse Labro Pavla Cervova
Future Prentice Chicago Architectural Club
95639
2012 Chicago Prize Competition
North
eS
e hor
ak NL
ve
Dri
N Mc Clug Ct.
Model, view from northwest FONTION CONNECTIONS
E. Erie Street
E. Huron Street
E. Superior Street
E. Chicago Ave.
NEW BUILDING
PRENTICE HOSPITAL
N Fairbanks Ct.
PLAZA
Site plan Future Prentice Chicago Architectural Club
SEMI PUBLIC SPACE 30 000 m2
OBESITY CENTRE 32 000 m2
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
School
Nutrition Activity Ctr.
LABS 48 000 m2
Indoor Public Space
Laboratories
Programmatic Section
95639
2012 Chicago Prize Competition
Playing courts on roof
Small vegetable market stalls
North, transparency view of Prentice
Upper Floor-plate, School typ. A Inserting large classrooms and workspaces around a free plan with central open stair. Adjacent rooms have enclosed entrance foyers.
Lower Floor-plate, Mixed-use typ. A (school and laboratories) Functional organization around a central atrium.
Cores
Large commercial open to street, with spill out into interior
Upper Floor-plate, School typ. B Smaller classrooms and technical rooms. Natural light enters circulation space at the crease.
Future Prentice Chicago Architectural Club
Lower Floor-plate, Mixed-use typ. B (all users, students, workers) Mixing all users in largest possible room, free plan cafeteria.
Ground Floor Level, Mixed-use slab Grandiose indoor public room, with bound on two sides by small market stalls and large commercial tenants.
South facing, ofďŹ ces, work rooms
Upper Floor Level, Mixed-use slab Longitudinal circulation along north transparent façade. Occupiable roof playing courts.
95639
2012 Chicago Prize Competition
Urban Farm,
Rooftop Greenhouse supplies kitchens, on-site market, school visits
Vertical Circulation, 1
Transparency on façade, longitudinal paths for program mixing expressed on exterior glass wall
Vertical Circulation, 2
Transparency between floor plates, around common space in school and laboratories
Big Room, 2
Program mixing on top floor of plinth Cafeteria serves produce grown on site
Big Room, 1
Program mixing inside the horizontal slab, indoor market and forum, low winter garden
Future Prentice Chicago Architectural Club
95639
2012 Chicago Prize Competition
Title: Thermae Chicagiensis Team: Bureau for Architecture and Design Felix Monasakanian Mohamed Sharif Efren Soriano Michael A. Durรกn (support)
The aging hospital is made-over as a vertical public bathhouse. a combination of Reductive surgery and circulatory catheterization formally and socially rejuvenates it into a vigorous center of health and wellness. ‘Future Prentice’ is ‘Thermae Chicagiensis’, Chicago’s new, water-fueled, gold-leafed, fun palace; where historic preservation is lavishly splashed with leisure and pleasure. A libidinously charged theater, it is home to lovers of watery indulgences, raw concrete and slow-paced hedonism. Within its fullfigure—arguablyexperienced as a tower for the very first time and revives Goldberg’s idea that he had designed it “from the inside out”—a luxurious atmosphere is all-pervasive,andacontemporary commingling of ‘promenade architecturale’ and ‘raum plan’ inducesasenseofviscousdelirium.
9
8
3
5
2
I OF IV
i ii
iii
iv v vi
vii
viii
xi
i. caldarium ii. sudatoria iii. towels iv. sudatoria v. tepidarium vi. frigidarium vii. towels viii. palaestrum ix. natatio x. open court xi. bridge to south campus
ix
x
9
8
3
5
2
II OF IV
ii
i
ii
i
i
viii
ii
vii viii
iii
iv
i
ii
iv
v
iii
v iii
iv v
iv
vi
ii
vi iii
v
vii
iv
ix i
ii
6
vi
vii
24
vi
iii
48
12
viii
v
vi
vii
CAMPUS i. OPEN COURT (NORTH CAMPUS ENTRANCE) ii. LiNE OF PODiUM ABOvE iii. BRiDGE TO SOUTH CAMPUS ABOvE iv. LOBBY v. UP vi. DOWN vii. FORECOURT (OPEN AiR yoga iNSTRUCTiON)
PALAESTRUM I i. LANDiNG AT BRiDGE TO PALAESTRUM II i. SPA ENTRANCE ii.. apodyteria SOUTH CAMPUS ii. ESCALATORS TO SPA/ iii.. OFFiCE OFF iv. RAMP UP TO PODiUM UM AND SPA v. FROM PODiUM ROOF iii. GYMNASiUM LOBBY MECHANiCAL vi. DOUBLE HEiGHT BRiDGEvii. iv. apodyteria v. GYMNASiUM vi. ExERCiSE OCULUS AT NATATiO (ABOvE) viii.. POOL SKY SKYSTEPS vii. DOUBLE HEiGHT BRiDGE TO SOUTH LiGHTS CAMPUS thermae chicagiensis
PODIUM ROOF i. NATATiO (FOR COOLiNG NG OFF iN N SUMMER AND iCE SKATiNG iN WiNTER) ii.. OCULUS iii. LOBBY iv. DiSROBiNG CUBiCLES v. HOT SPA vi. RAMP DOWN TO PALAESTRUM ii vii. RAMP UP TO THERMAE TOWER viii. SUMMER POOL AND SUNBATHiNG DECK ix. JUiCE BAR
COMPOSITE THERMAE PLAN i. CALDARiUM (TEPiDARiUM BELOW) ii. SUDATORiA iii. DRY POOL - TOWELS AND REFRESHMENTS
e or
sh
ke la dr
huron st
mcclurg ct
fairbanks ct
future campus addition
9 100 50
8
3
5
2
400 200
III OF IV
viEW TO SOUTHWEST CORNER OF THERMAE CHiCAGiENSiS
viEW SOUTHWARD FROM OPEN COURT TO ESCALATORS TO PALAESTRUM
viEW NORTHWARD FROM ESCALATOR TO PODiUM ROOF AND TOWER
bridge
50 100
200 400
viEW SOUTHWARD FROM PODiUM LOBBY TO SPA—THERMAE RAMP
future campus addition
9
viEW NORTHWARD FROM PODiUM ROOF TO NATATiO
8
3
5
2
IV OF IV
Title: 3 ACTS OF PRESERVATION Team: Norman Kelley Thomas Kelley
1
2
3
Acts
of Preservation
‘The age value of a monument reveals itself at first glance in the monument’s outmoded apperance.’ -Alois Riegl, The Modern Cult of Monuments: Its Essence and Its Development
Acts of preservation are always works of approximation. Unlike acts of forgery or plagiarism, they are not facsimiles. Too often, however, they are cast as lacking opportunity. This is the error of outmoded appearances. This project aims to widen the manners in which the whole, or part of a work may be approximated. The future of historic preservation now includes confronting its opposition - Modernism. This is an opportunity to revisit antiquated notions of preservation and embrace this new territory with ulterior acts.
6TM46
3
The Double Icon
Act 1
4
...if two lie down together, they will keep warm. But how can one keep warm alone? 12 Though one may be overpowered, two can defend themselves. -Ecclesiastes 4:9-12 6TM46
5
Cockeye Preservation
Act 2
6
The body is no body to be seen But is an eye that studies its black lid. -Wallace Stevens
6TM46
7
Approximate Commemoration
Act 3
8
MONUMENT, n. A structure intended to commemorate something which either needs no commemoration or cannot be commemorated. -Oxford American Dictionary
6TM46
Title: Rebirth of Prentice Team: Daniel Pitaluga
Title: Prentice Green Team: Mariela M. MartĂnez Correa
PRENTICE GARDEN HILL IS A PROPOSAL BASED ON TURNING THE FORMER PRENTICE WOMEN’S HOSPITAL INTO A LUXURY AND WELL CENTERED APARTMENT COMPLEX FOR THE NORTHWESTERN STUDENTS AND EVEN SOME OF ITS FACULTY. THE PROPOSAL FOCUSES ON CREATING DIVERSE GREEN
AREAS FOR THE WELL BEING OF ANY OF ITS RESIDENTS, WHILE AT THE SAME TIME, SATISFYING SOME OF THEIR OTHER NEEDS, SUCH AS CREATING SOME
COMMERCIAL AREAS.
THE PRENTICE AREA ALSO COMES EQUIPPED WITH SEVERAL GREEN BE ACCESSED EITHER THROUGH PRENTICE
GARDEN HILL’S GREEN ROOF OR THROUGH STREET
LEVEL, PROVIDING CIRCULATION AREA, AS WELL AS, RESTING COME TO RELAX. SOME
PLATFORMS THAT CAN
SPACES, WHERE PEOPLE WOULD
COMMERCIAL SPACES CAN BE LOCATED BETWEEN THE PLATFORMS.
3G653
student recreational area
EXISTING CONDITIONS
Usable Area = 15,50
restaurant space
study hall
3G653
3G653
student residence PRIVATE SPACE
RESIDENTIAL AREA
student garden area
PUBLIC SPACE
green/commercial space
PUBLIC PLAZA COMMERCIAL AREA STUDY AREA RECREATIONAL AREA
3G653
Title: Wellness Center and Research Facility Team: Danielle Bayrami
Title: Future Prentice Team: Charles Francis Pigott
Title: New Prentice Team: Jeremy Woolley
to appease those who view the Prentice is somewhat of an “eyesore,� yet also bringing a new purpose to this now obsolete facility, the first step of the repurpose is to bring new life to the exterior, while trying to maintain some of the core identity of the original architecture, and that of Chicago.
with green walls around three of the four sides, and a glass curtainwall system encasing the upper portion of the Prentice, the architecture is preserved, while providing an opportunity to incorporate the architecture into the surrounding chicago vernacular of rectangular, high rise buildings.
north
on the entry floor, and next three floors, the new focus on the space is to become a versatile public and performing arts space. with mobile partitions, small galleries and gatherings can take place, or the partitions could be removed (as seen in the plans above) to be an open space for a multitude of purposes.
on the first roof, removing the mechanical equipment once needed for medical air circulation, the patio can once again be open. bringing vegetation to the space also brings a new potential for various public gatherings, small performances, or even an equivalent to an atrium. the old patient rooms, in the upper seven floors, will be removed, creating vast open spaces for rotating and permanent art galleries. some of the pieces could come from local artists, or on loan from the nearby museum of contemporary art.
north
the site shows the transition of the women’s hospital, and the programming needs, moving to a new 500,000 square foot facility to the old VA hospital site. since the site affords the opportunity for a large open space, the initial thought is to create a planned open space, while creating vertical hospital on the western end of the site. in the planning of the site, creating a link between the new and the old, through site, form, and space will provide a story of the new and old Prentice, and the roles each now play.
Title: Future Prentice Team: Rosalyn L. Mitchell, AIA Mark L. Bruzan, AIA, LEED AP, Erica P. Garcia, Interior Designer
EXAMPLES OF BIOMIMETICS
GECKO FOOTPRINT
FUTURE PRENTICE
CELL BASED INFLATABLE FURNITURE.
1
8YB66
1-3 FLOOR PLAN
FUTURE PRENTICE
GROUND FLOOR PLAN
2
8YB66
FUTURE PRENTICE
KALIDESTOPE INSPIRATIONS
3
8YB66
FUTURE PRENTICE
RENDERING: BUILDING BATHED IN PINK LIGHT
4
8YB66
Title: Future Prentice Team: Chipman Design Architecture Inc. Diana Naydenova
curtain wall mesh screen
OPS49
inspiration : roy lichtenstein
OPS49
Title: The Urban Garden Team: John Delgado Yesenia Hernandez
Title: Growth Out of Unity Team: Mathieu Tronel