Windows 7 Adoption in India
A CIO survey report
Contents Executive Summary.................................................................
3
Introduction..............................................................................
4
Survey Responses and Trends..............................................
5
Appendix A...............................................................................
14
The CIO Association of India is a member-driven, national, non-profit organization serving CIOs and Heads of IT in India. CAI serves as the leading voice of the Indian CIO with industry, government and media, and others.
2
Executive Summary In the next 12 months, most Indian CIOs (almost 80%) plan to upgrade to Windows 7. The perception of the OS is exceedingly positive among CIOs, with an overwhelming majority rating Windows 7 as “excellent” or “satisfactory”. In terms of key constraints, application compatibility and hardware limitations are the areas that concern our CIOs the most, while budget does not seem to be an apprehension for most of the CIO community. Windows Vista users are looking at the speed and stability of Windows 7 as the key drivers for upgrade, while XP users are looking for better features, performance and security. Both sets of users are looking forward to the power management enhancements and the improved UI of Windows 7.
Key Findings l 97.7% of the CIOs rated Windows 7 as “excellent” or “satisfactory”. l 78.74% plan to deploy Windows 7 within the next 12 months. l Deployment of Windows 7 is already in progress in 36.21% of
the organizations surveyed l IT teams in 47.13% of the surveyed organizations have tested
the OS and an additional 31.03% have already commissioned a pilot or Proof-of Concept (PoC) for Windows 7 l Application Compatibility is the key constraint with an average
rating of 3.17 out of 5 (where 1 is “no constraint” and 5 is a “big constraint”) l 57.47% of CIOs are evaluating Desktop Virtualization solutions
3
Introduction Windows 7 was launched in India towards the end of 2009. It was well-received and quickly gathered interest amongst the CIO community. About six months after Windows 7 was announced, the CIO Association of India (CAI) and Microsoft collaborated on a survey that sought to understand the state of Windows 7 Adoption in India. Commissioned in August 2010, this survey seeks to get a sense from the CIO community on their organization’s plans to deploy Windows 7, as well as understand the consideration set for CIOs to decide on upgrading to Windows 7. CAI, India’s largest independent association of CIOs, has members from some of the most prominent organizations across the country. This survey was sent to the CAI member community and received 174 responses. Duration: The survey was launched on August 10, 2010 and responses were accepted till August 13, 2010. Reach: CIOs across India responded to the survey. A list of the respondent companies is presented in Appendix A. 174 CIOs across India responded with complete responses.
4
Survey responses and trends
Q 1. Based on what you have seen or heard of Windows 7, what is the overall rating you would give Windows 7?
The question presented the respondents with an option of rating Windows 7 as “excellent”, “satisfactory” or “poor”.
Overall rating for Windows 7 0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
Excellent
60%
54.60%
97.7% of CIOs rated Windows 7 as “excellent” or “satisfactory”.
Excellent Satisfactory
Poor
43.10%
Satisfactory Poor
2.30%
The perception of Windows 7 has been very favorable with 97.7% of the cios rating Windows7 as “excellent” or “satisfactory”. Of these, 54.6% of the CIOs indicated that Windows 7 is an “excellent” Operating System. Further, 43.10% of CIOs polled indicated that they thought Windows 7 is “satisfactory”, based on their perception of Windows 7. A small number of respondents – 2.3% – however had reservations about Windows 7, giving it a “poor” rating.
Q 2. When do you plan to deploy Windows 7?
Windows 7 seems to be making strong in-roads in organisations across India, with 36.21% of the CIOs telling us that the Windows 7 deployment was already in progress across their enterprises. A sizeable number of CIOs have already evaluated the benefits of the new OS and have plans to deploy the same within their organizations in the next one year. Of these, 18.97% plan to deploy Windows 7 in the next 6 months and another 23.56% are looking to plan their deployment in the 6-12 month window after the survey.
Further, almost 80% of the CIOs in the respondent group are planning to deploy Windows 7 in their organizations within the next 12 months.
5
When do you plan to deploy Windows 7? 0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
Deployment in progress
40%
36.21%
18.97%
In the next 6 months
Deployment in progress
23.56%
6 - 12 months
In the next 6 months
8.62%
12 - 24 months 24 months hence
35%
6 - 12 months 12 - 24 months
0.57%
24 months hence
12.07%
No plans at this time
No plans at this time
Among the remaining respondents, 8.62% of the CIOs have plans to deploy Windows 7 in 12-24 months A miniscule number of 0.57% of the CIOs who responded, indicated plans of adopting Windows 7 only after 2 years. The number of CIOs with “no plans” of migrating to Windows 7 at this point is 12.07%.
Among the organizations where deployment is already “in progress”, 71% of the CIOs have rated Windows 7 as “excellent”, while 27% have rated it as “satisfactory”.
Among the organizations where deployment is already in progress, 71% of CIOs have rated Windows 7 as “excellent”, while 27% have rated it “satisfactory”.
Overall rating for Windows 7 among CIOs with deployment in progress 2%
27%
Excellent 71%
Satisfactory Poor
Contrasting the above, against organizations that have no plans to deploy the OS at this time, 24% of the CIOs in such organizations have termed it “excellent” and 67% have given it a “satisfactory” rating.
Overall rating for Windows 7 among CIOs with no plans to deploy 5% 24%
Excellent Satisfactory
67%
6
Poor
Q 3. Has your organization evaluated Windows 7?
We asked the respondents about the extent of their evaluation of Windows 7. 31.03% of our CIOs have already commissioned an extensive evaluation of the system. They have either run a pilot or PoC to evaluate Windows 7. 47.3% of the CIOs have commissioned a basic testing of the OS, with their IT teams having reviewed the OS. The interest in Windows 7 is evident in the numbers, which indicate that out of the remaining CIOs, 14.97% have indicated plans to evaluate it soon. Only 6.9% of CIOs have indicated that they have no plans to test/evaluate Windows 7.
Has your organization evaluated Windows 7? Extensively. We have commisioned a Pilot
31.03%
or a PoC on the new OS Basic testing. The IT team has reviewed the OS
47.13%
Planning to evaluate Windows 7 soon
14.94%
No plans to evaluate Windows 7 in the near term
6.90%
31.03% of our CIOs have already commissioned an extensive evaluation of the system.
Among the organizations where deployment is in progress, 52.38% have tested the OS extensively, while 44.44% have undergone basic testing.
Evaluation of Windows 7 in organizations with deployment in progress Extensively. We have commissioned a Pilot or a PoC on the new OS
3%
52% 45%
Basic testing. The IT team has reviewed the OS Planning to evaluate Windows 7 soon
Among the organizations where deployment is expected in the next six months, 27.27% have evaluated the system extensively, whereas 48.48% have implemented basic testing.
Evaluation of Windows 7 in organizations with deployment in the next 6 months
Extensively. We have commissioned a Pilot or a PoC on the new OS
6% 18%
27%
49%
Basic testing. The IT team has reviewed the OS Planning to evaluate Windows 7 soon Not planning to deploy Windows 7 soon
7
Q 4. What, in your opinion, are the key constraints to upgrade to Windows 7?
(Please rate criteria on a scale of 1 to 5. 1 being – constraint and 5 – big constraint)
This question throws light on the challenges that CIOs face, while considering an upgrade to Windows 7. We asked CIOs to rate the severity of the following constraints – budget constraints, migration costs, application compatibility, testing requirements, hardware limitations, business case /ROI, and licensing concerns, in order to determine the ones with the most impact.
Key constraints to upgrade to Windows 7 Scale of 1 to 5. 1 - no constraint, 5 - big constraint
3.3
3.17
3.2 3.1 3
2.86
2.9
2.81
2.8 2.7
2.59
2.57
2.6
2.58
2.54
2.5 2.4
47.13% of our CIOs indicated that application compatibility is a big concern (Rating 4 or 5)
o
tc
ge
d Bu
ra
t ns
ts
M
n
tio
ra
ig
s co
i
at
lic
p Ap
on
t pa
ty
ili
ib
s
t in
ts
en
re ui
g
tin
s Te
q re
ns
I
tio
m
m
co
ita
e ar
w rd Ha
e/
lim
s
es
in
s Bu
s ca
RO
ns er
nc
g
in
ns
e Lic
co
Ranking of Key Constraints to upgrade to Windows 7:
1. Application Compatibility : Average rating of 3.178 out of 5. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Hardware Limitations : 2.862 Business Case/ROI : 2.81 Migration Costs : 2.592 Licensing Concerns : 2.58 Budget Constraints : 2.575
7. Testing Requirements : 2.54 On questioning the target group, we learnt that paramount among the CIOs’ concerns, was application compatibility, with 47.13% of our CIOs rating it as a big constraint (27.59% rated it at 4 and 19.54% gave it a rating of 5). There seems to be a lack of awareness about Windows 7’s XP Mode , which provides XP application compatibility – as one of the respondents put it, “Lack of out-of-box XP compatibility for applications is a huge, huge barrier.”
8
Key constraints to upgrade to Windows 7 Scale of 1 to 5. 1 - no constraint, 5 - big constraint 5 11% 4 18%
3 21% 2 17%
1 33%
Budget Constraints
5 6%
5 7%
5 20%
4 19%
4 17%
4 28%
3 27%
5 14% 4 21%
3 21%
1 17%
Migration Costs
4 22%
4 16%
3 25%
Application Compatibility
3 18% 2 20%
2 27%
2 17%
2 20%
1 25%
1 23%
1 22%
Testing Requirements
Hardware Limitations
Business Case/ ROI
2 16% 1 25%
5 14%
3 24% 3 25%
2 23%
5 11%
1 33%
Licensing Concerns
Interestingly, among the organizations that have tested Windows 7 extensively, only 12.96% have said that application compatibility is a big constraint, while 31.48% have said it was no constraint.
Application Compatibility as a constraint for CIOs who have tested extensively 13%
1 (no constraint) 32%
22%
2 3
11%
22%
4 5 (big constraint)
Looking at the CIOs with no plans to deploy Windows 7 at this point, more than 60% of them felt that application compatibility is a big constraint (Rating 4 – 24% and 5 – 38%). Hardware limitations is viewed as another big constraint among the CIOs with no plans to deploy at this time, with 48% of them rating it as a level 4 or 5 constraint.
Application Compatibility as a constraint for CIOs with no plans to deploy at this time 1 (no constraint)
14% 10% 38% 14% 24%
2 3 4 5 (big constraint)
9
32.76% of the respondents did not feel constrained by budgets while evaluating Windows 7.
Hardware Limitations as a constraint for CIOs with no plans to deploy at this time
24%
1 (no constraint)
24%
2 3 19%
24%
4 5 (big constraint)
9%
Encouragingly, even during these less-than-perfect economic conditions, most CIOs don’t feel that budgets are a big constraint for the move to Windows 7, with 32.76% of our respondents saying that it is no constraint.
Budget Constraints for all respondents
11%
1 (no constraint) 33%
18%
2 3 4
21%
17%
5 (big constraint)
Q 5. Other Constraints (Not mentioned above)
We gave the respondents the option to mention other constraints that are preventing the adoption of Windows 7. Here are some that were mentioned by the CIOs:
1. End-user comfort with existing Windows XP systems. 2. Training requirements for IT teams. 3. Device driver related issues, for devices like network printers. 4. Lack of high-quality documentation for Windows 7. 5. The Netmeeting tool seems to be missing.
10
Q 6. What according to you are the key factors/ reasons for upgrading to Windows 7?
Dissatisfaction with Windows Vista and the fact that Windows XP is nearing end of support seem to be two important drivers for the adoption of Windows 7.
“We had a performance issue on our Windows Vista preloaded OS. We understood from Microsoft that Windows 7 is reliable, fast and secure, and that they have eliminated all the drawbacks of Vista. As a part of our Microsoft Enterprise Agreement, we can have standardized Windows 7 as the base OS group-wide, irrespective of the OS loaded by the PC manufacturer (OEM).” - Subbarao Hegde, CTO,
GMR Group
“Overcome problems of Vista, better features.” - PL Rajani, DGM – IT,
NTPC
“Standardisation for replacing end-of-life XP.” - Sanjay Belsare, Executive Vice-President – IT,
Kotak Mahindra Bank
Many responses included CIOs who were appreciative of better features, performance, and security vis à vis the existing Windows XP systems.
“Enhanced productivity…enhanced end point security through Bit Locker, and Direct Access enables remote connect instead of VPN connect.”
- S. Francis Rajan, Head – ICT, Bangalore International Airport Ltd.
“Speed of response, additional functionality, manageability and security.” - Murali Krishna, Vice-President,
Infosys Technologies
“Reliable, secure and fast.”
- BLV Rao, Vice-President & Head – Global IT, Infotech Enterprises
Others using Windows Vista were positive about Windows 7’s stability and speed. Some other influencing factors included the need for an OS that enables quick start-up and an optimum utilization of system resources.
11
“Enterprise agreement, better tech features like, UAC, improved booting time, application locker.”
- Suhas Gajanan Jayawant, Head – Infrastructure, L&T Infotech
A significant number of CIOs were enthusiastic of the virtualization features of the OS. The fact that Windows 7 is IPV6-ready also seems to be an influencing factor. In addition, power management enhancements seemed to surface prominently amongst the top few reasons for considering Windows 7. Moving away from the technology benefits, the “visually appealing” interface seems to have been a strong influencer as well, with a significant number of CIOs commenting on the user-friendly graphics.
“Stability, features and user-friendliness.”
- RP Rath, Vice-President – Technology, Quatrro BPO Solutions Pvt. Ltd.
“The new features help the users, especially the graphical part and the search capabilities.”
- Alok Dashora, Vice-President – IT & IS, Tata Sky Ltd.
In a quest to move with the times and keep up with the future, our CIOs at large indicated that they saw the migration to Windows 7 as inevitable, even in those organizations where it is not immediately planned.
12
Q 7. Is your organization evaluating Desktop Virtualization solutions as part of your desktop strategy?
The landscape over the next few years could change substantially as an increasing number of CIOs are seeing value in, and actively evaluating the potential presented by, Desktop Virtualization (DV). This question seeks to understand the importance placed by CIOs on DV, which presents multiple advantages to organizations today – namely, opex costs, centralized management, faster adoption, the ability to overcome hardware limitations and so on. 52.47% of our respondents echoed this sentiment as they agreed that they are evaluating DV as part of their desktop strategy.
Desktop virtualization solutions as part of your desktop strategy? 0.00%
Yes
10.00% 20.00%
30.00%
40.00%
50.00% 60.00% 70.00%
Yes No
52.47% of the CIOs are evaluating Desktop Virtualization as part of their desktop strategy.
No
13
Appendix A (LIST OF RESPONDENT COMPANIES) 3i Infotech Limited Aditi Technologies AFL Pvt Ltd. Air Works India Engineering Amway India Apeejay Surrendra Group Apollo Hospitals Enterprise Ltd. Artificial Limbs Mfg. Corporation Of India Aurobindo Pharma Bangalore International Airport Ltd. Bayer Cropscience Ltd. BPCL Cadence Design Systems C-DAC Cerner Healthcare Solutions CESC Ltd. Cipla Columbia Asia Hospitals Delhi Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. Deloitte Consulting India Pvt. Ltd. Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Digital Group Dynamic Logistics ECIL Eveready Industries India Ltd. Glencore India GMR Group Godrej Properties Ltd. Grant Thornton Greenply Industries Ltd. Group Sanofi-Aventis
14
Groz Beckert HDFC Bank Ltd. Hero Honda Motors Ltd. Honda Motor India Pvt. Ltd. Hutchison 3 Global Services Pvt. Ltd. Hyundai Motor India Ltd. IDBI Bank Ltd. Indiabulls Indian Renewable Energy Development Agency Indira Gandhi National Open University Indo American Cancer Inst. & Reserach centre Indo-American Hybrid Seeds IndusInd Media & Communications Ltd. -A Hinduja TMT Company Infosys Technologies Infotech Enteprises Institute of Publc Enterprise Invensys ITTIAM Jaypee Business School JWT Kaya Ltd. Kodak India Pvt. Ltd. Kotak Mahindra Bank L&T Infotech L&T-Sargent and Lndy Ltd. LANCO Infratech Ltd. Loop Mobile Communications(India) Ltd. Lurgi India Company Maharashtra Pollution Control Board
Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Co Ltd. Mecklai Financial Services Ltd. Medley Pharmaceticals Ltd. Metso Minerals (India) Pvt. Ltd. Microchip Technology India Pvt Ltd. Microland Ltd. MindTree Ltd. MRVPL National Informatics Centre Ness Technologies India Pvt Ltd. NH Securities Ltd. NISE NPCIL,HQ NSDL NTPC Orbis Financial Corporation Ltd. Orchid Chemicals & Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Orient Paper Patni Computer Systems Ltd. Persistent Systems Ltd. Petron Engineering Corporation Ltd. Polaris Software Lab Ltd. Powergrid Quatrro BPO Solutions Pvt. Ltd Raymond Ltd. Rediff.com Resil Chemicals Private Ltd. Roots Industries India Ltd. S1 Services India Pvt Ltd.
Sakthi finance Ltd/ABT Industries Ltd. SAP India Seco Tools India Pvt Ltd. SEMCO Sequoia Capital Setco Automotive SIDBI Sierra Atlantic Sir Ganga Ram Hospital SJM Technologies Sona Koyo Szteering Systems Ltd. Sonata Software Ltd. SOS Kinderdorf International SPi Technologies India Private Limited Sterling Commerce Solutions India Pvt Ltd. Tata Sky Ltd. Tata Technologies Limited The Calcutta Medical Research Institute The Press Trust of India The Ruby Mills Ltd. TSI UNICEF Urban Development Department, GOK ValueSource Technologies VF Asia Ltd. Watson Pharma Wipro Xchanging Yahoo Yatra Online Pvt Ltd.
15
www.cioindia.org
c 2010 Microsoft. Windows is a registered trademark or trademark of Microsoft Corporation in the United States and/or other countries.