7+,6 5(3257 +$6 %((1 352'8&(' ,1 &2//$%25$7,21 :,7+
20$ $02
5(3257 ,17
7+( (1(5*< 5(3257 5(1(:$%/( (1(5*< %<
::)
! " # $ % &'' (
$ ) " $)
$ * )"
$ $ "
(
(&2)<6 $
&+,-
$ ) ) ) " ) $ ) " $ ) ( .
/ ) ) $
0
) ( "
" $ (
20$ .
1 0 2 3 41235 ) " $ " ) ( .
123
) *$ " 321( 123
$ " 321 $ )
$ $ " " )" )" )" " $ ( ::) ,QWHUQDWLRQDO 3 2 *6 &&+7 8 9 ( ( (FRI\V :(1( 6 ! ,-', ;#'; < = .
%
( ) ( 20$ >
6 &-+ ;';? 3@ .
%
( ( 7KLV UHSRUW ZDV PDGH SRVVLEOH E\ WKH JHQHURXV VXSSRUW RI (1(&2 96% +A,*?*+-'--;*?7*'
&2175,%87256 B 9 9 . C *: @ ) : : & 6 ) C . : & 1 8 $$ " > !" 2 > " 2 D " @ : $ < 3 " C 3 " 6 ) 6 " C 6 "
6 " < B " < ) B " < ) B E
" . @ " ) " 2 " D) " 2 $$ " 8 )" 6 8
" 8 " C 8 " 2 ) 8 " : > " C > " : > " > " F > " % $ " 3 < " 9 < " 3 ! ) < " D D " : D )" : 2 " F 2 " @ 2 D " DG H 2G I" $ 2 D " 2 2 $ " < 1 " 9 1 " 2 : " @ : " J $ " 8 " : $ " 9 " 9 9 " 8 9 " . ) " J " 3 J " > " 2 " " % ) F Stefan Henningson : ) 4: ?5 : F @ " 9 E B " 9 $ < : <
D " 6 " < 6 49
$ " ! +& : ?(5 .
123*321 $) : 8 3 D 6 . . 2 )" @ 3 J
B " 3 2 :
" . B
" @ = ) )
.
) : ;
.
) : -
Â&#x2039; )ULW] 3|ONLQJ ::)
&217(176 &'
&''M $ )
,
3$57 3 $ ) )
) &''M $ .
)
.
) ! .
N ) N 0 N / ) N D N D ) N N N .
)
&& &; &; ?; ? ?+ -; - #& #7 7' 77 A? A, ,-
3$57 .
) ) ,A ! ) +? &'; 3 &'A @ &&# 9 ) O $ ) 4 ! ( $ )5 &;+ 9 ) O 9 $ $ ) &#A &+? : ) ?&A B ??+ $33(1',&(6
?;&
5()(5(1&(6
?-?
*/266$5<
?#?
.
) : #
0DS $ QHZ SHUVSHFWLYH RQ WKH ZRUOG ORRNLQJ WRZDUGV *OREDO *,6 'DWDEDVH &RPSOHWH *ORED/ 6HW Â&#x2039; $02 .
) : 7
q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r -DPHV 3 /HDSH 'LUHFWRU *HQHUDO ::) ,QWHUQDWLRQDO
.
) : A
5(&200(1'$7,216 )25 $ 5(1(:$%/( (1(5*< )8785(
&/($1 (1(5*<
3URPRWH RQO\ WKH PRVW HIILFLHQW SURGXFWV 'HYHORS H[LVWLQJ DQG QHZ UHQHZDEOH HQHUJ\ VRXUFHV WR SURYLGH HQRXJK FOHDQ HQHUJ\ IRU DOO E\
*5,'6
6KDUH DQG H[FKDQJH FOHDQ HQHUJ\ WKURXJK JULGV DQG WUDGH PDNLQJ WKH EHVW XVH RI VXVWDLQDEOH HQHUJ\ UHVRXUFHV LQ GLIIHUHQW DUHDV
$&&(66
(QG HQHUJ\ SRYHUW\ SURYLGH FOHDQ HOHFWULFLW\ DQG SURPRWH VXVWDLQDEOH SUDFWLFHV VXFK DV HIILFLHQW FRRN VWRYHV WR HYHU\RQH LQ GHYHORSLQJ FRXQWULHV
021(<
,QYHVW LQ UHQHZDEOH FOHDQ HQHUJ\ DQG HQHUJ\ HIILFLHQW SURGXFWV DQG EXLOGLQJV
)22'
6WRS IRRG ZDVWH &KRRVH IRRG WKDW LV VRXUFHG LQ DQ HIILFLHQW DQG VXVWDLQDEOH ZD\ WR IUHH XS ODQG IRU QDWXUH VXVWDLQDEOH IRUHVWU\ DQG ELRIXHO SURGXFWLRQ (YHU\RQH KDV DQ HTXDO ULJKW WR KHDOWK\ OHYHOV RI SURWHLQ LQ WKHLU GLHW t IRU WKLV WR KDSSHQ ZHDOWKLHU SHRSOH QHHG WR HDW OHVV PHDW
.
) : ,
0$7(5,$/6 5HGXFH UH XVH UHF\FOH t WR PLQLPL]H ZDVWH DQG VDYH HQHUJ\ 'HYHORS GXUDEOH PDWHULDOV $QG DYRLG WKLQJV ZH GRQpW QHHG
75$163257
3URYLGH LQFHQWLYHV WR HQFRXUDJH JUHDWHU XVH RI SXEOLF WUDQVSRUW DQG WR UHGXFH WKH GLVWDQFHV SHRSOH DQG JRRGV WUDYHO 3URPRWH HOHFWULILFDWLRQ ZKHUHYHU SRVVLEOH DQG VXSSRUW UHVHDUFK LQWR K\GURJHQ DQG RWKHU DOWHUQDWLYH IXHOV IRU VKLSSLQJ DQG DYLDWLRQ
7(&+12/2*< 'HYHORS QDWLRQDO ELODWHUDO DQG PXOWLODWHUDO DFWLRQ SODQV WR SURPRWH UHVHDUFK DQG GHYHORSPHQW LQ HQHUJ\ HIILFLHQF\ DQG UHQHZDEOH HQHUJ\
6867$,1$%,/,7<
$*5((0(176
'HYHORS DQG HQIRUFH VWULFW VXVWDLQDELOLW\ FULWHULD WKDW HQVXUH UHQHZDEOH HQHUJ\ LV FRPSDWLEOH ZLWK HQYLURQPHQWDO DQG GHYHORSPHQW JRDOV
6XSSRUW DPELWLRXV FOLPDWH DQG HQHUJ\ DJUHHPHQWV WR SURYLGH JOREDO JXLGDQFH DQG SURPRWH JOREDO FRRSHUDWLRQ RQ UHQHZDEOH HQHUJ\ DQG HIILFLHQF\ HIIRUWV
.
) : +
Â&#x2039; 0DUWLQ +DUYH\ ::) &DQRQ
5(&200(1'$7,216 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
Â&#x2039; 1$6$
q::) +$6 $ 9,6,21 2) $ :25/' 7+$7 ,6 32:(5(' %< 3(5 &(17 5(1(:$%/( (1(5*< 6285&(6 %< 7+( 0,''/( 2) 7+,6 &(1785<r .
) : &'
,1752'8&7,21 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
)LJXUH (YROXWLRQ RI HQHUJ\ VXSSO\ LQ WKH (QHUJ\ 6FHQDULR VKRZLQJ WKH NH\ GHYHORSPHQWV 6RXUFH 7KH (FRI\V (QHUJ\ 6FHQDULR 'HFHPEHU
3(5 &(17 5(1(:$%/( (1(5*< %< $) &'' $ ) $)
)( = "
)
( 6 $ &'' $ ) )
$) ?'#'P
! ) ) ) / ( " ) $ $ * ) $ &'' $ )
! ( .
$ "
" " " : ? (
.
) $ 0 ( .
)
) " "
O
$ ( >
" )" " 0$ "
" Q $ ) R " " $ R R ) /
) ! P
.
) $ / $ ) " 0
( 3
*
)
O
"
(
.
) : &&
q %,//,21 3(23/( +$9( 12 $&&(66 72 5(/,$%/( (/(&75,&,7<r
.
) : &?
5(1(:$%/( (1(5*< )8785( 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
Â&#x2039; &DW +ROORZD\ ::) &DQRQ
$ 5(1(:$%/( (1(5*< )8785( :+< :( 1((' ,7 9 $
) E
$ ( ) ( .
)
) ) $ ( 1 O " O 0 "
(
)
$ "
z
)
6:
8 2 ! (
" 0 $)
$ ) 0 ) $ * )( 3 ) $ $ )
) ) )
(
(1(5*< )$&76 :( +$9( 72 )$&( &(- $ $
)&( ) $ " 0
$ ) O )
( 3 ) "
$ ! (
3
" ?(A $ $ ) 4 ) " 5
? ( . $ )"
Q " $ )
( . 0
$
> 1 4 >15 ?(# ) ) )
;( ) $ ) $ " / )
( )
!
( 6 $ )
/ )
$ ( &( 3" ) 1 4 15 ?'&'" : ?( 3" ) 1 4 15 ?'&'" : ( ;( ( ( : $ 2 6 6 --? --?'-''?-?+(
.
) : &;
q,) (9(5<21( &21680(' $6 08&+ (1(5*< $6 7+( $9(5$*( 6,1*$325($1 $1' 8 6 5(6,'(17 7+( :25/'p6 2,/ 5(6(59(6 :28/' %( '(3/(7(' ,1 <($56r
)LJXUH :RUOG RLO SURGXFWLRQ E\ W\SH KWWS ZZZ ZRUOGHQHUJ\RXWORRN RUJ GRFV ZHR NH\BJUDSKV SGI
2,/ $1' *$6 $5( 5811,1* 287 ) ) 0
" "
6: @
> "
B ( 6
O E 3
) 3 ) 4 35- " ( 2 )
$) -'*7' $) ?';'( F
O ) $ "
3 O " $ )
B " 6 ( )
)
"
9 " 9 =(9(
)
( ! "
0 " # $ &' ) ( ) $ " B "
( ) Q ( 9
" ) ( 0 )(
E $
! -' ) " {$ * * | (
.
) : &-
: /
" $ " $ )
) ( -( 3" ) 1 4 15" ?''+" : ( #( :
=(9( B $ ; )" 9 3 $ $ # 9 &' ( : $ ?'# $ ?'&' 46:" 9 " ?'&'5 }: &";-+ $ $ ( 1
=( 9( &,(,7 $ )( 7(+ $ (
2,/ $1' *$6 $5( 5811,1* 287 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
)266,/ )8(/ 6285&,1* 0DS 2LO &ODLPV LQ $IULFD 3 +HDUQ -U 7 +DUH HW DO *OREDO *,6 'DWDEDVH &RPSOHWH *OREDO 6HW Â&#x2039; $02
.
) : &#
&/,0$7( &+$1*( ,6 $/5($'< $ 5($/,7< 0 "
$
) ( > ) $) " " " Q !
O ) $ $)
( .
>1 ) &#'"''' ) 7( 8 $
$ ) " / ! A( .
"
) ,(.
$ $) ?';'"
)
?'' $ ) $ Q " $ $) +(. / "
$ $ &(#Â&#x20AC;B * ( . " $
! 0 ) "
$) ,' $ ) $) ?'#' 4 &++' 5 O
$ ) (
.
) : &7
.
$ )
)( $ * $
" )
( B
$ *
$
( $ $ )" $ )* "
$ )
( 7( ( ( $
!( A( ( ( E -?A 7+A' $ '?&?&( ,(
) "
.
) 6 ) 4. 65 . 6 B = ( 9 $ ?''+ +( 2 : )" % 3 " : 6 )" @ @ " 9 " B > " 9 < " $ % " @ 9 " . 0 " .
4?''+5 3
B 3 B B 3
=% BBB 1
" @ 8 B B " D (
&/,0$7( &+$1*( ,6 $/5($'< $ 5($/,7< .
) : &A
Â&#x2039; <LIHL =+$1* ::) &DQRQ
&+$1*,1* 5($/,7< 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
Â&#x2039; 'RQDOG 0LOOHU ::) &DQRQ
q18&/($5 ,6 $1 81(7+,&$/ $1' (;3(16,9( 237,21r
.
) : &,
<56 2) +$50)8/ :$67( 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
18&/($5 :$67( :,// %( '$1*(5286 )25 <($56 "
$
) ( * ) $ O
) ) ( 6
) 0 ) ! ) O
$ )( .
= 9 8 ) #'"''' &?"''' )" ) ) $
)( 3
=(9( : 3 )" $ &'"''' ) $ $
$ ) ( / ) $ "
)
) $ ( ) $ " $ ) ( % z ) )( / ) " ) "
( ) $ ) )
&(- $ ) &'" ) ( % ! )
! ( 6 $ "
) $ $
" $ ) ( &'( 3" ) 1 4 15" ?'&'" :
0DS 2SHUDWLRQDO QXFOHDU UHDFWRUV 3 +HDUQ -U 7 +DUH HW DO *OREDO *,6 'DWDEDVH &RPSOHWH *OREDO 6HW
1 %
.
) : &+
::)p6 3(563(&7,9( B
)
* )( : $ )
" $ ) ) $ $) ( 2 ) $ ! (
) O
" $ " $
3 O ) ( 2 )
) $ ( )
O
$
)
( D ) $
"
)
( 3
$ "
$
/ (
0 ) $
) ) ( 9
) " $ (
q:( 35(',&7 21 7+( %$6,6 2) 0,' 5$1*( &/,0$7( :$50,1* 6&(1$5,26 )25 7+$7 t 2) 63(&,(6 ,1 285 6$03/( 2) 5(*,216 $1' 7$;$ :,// %( o&200,77(' 72 (;7,1&7,21pr 7KRPDV & ' HW DO ([WLQFWLRQ ULVN IURP FOLPDWH FKDQJH 1DWXUH 9RO 1R
.
) : ?'
.
) : ?&
Â&#x2039; .HYLQ 6FKDIHU ::) &DQRQ
::) 3(563(&7,9( 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
)LJXUH :RUOG (QHUJ\ 6XSSO\ 6RXUFH 7KH (FRI\V (QHUJ\ 6FHQDULR 'HFHPEHU
0DS )RVVLO )XHO DQG 5HQHZDEOH (QHUJ\ 3RWHQWLDO 7KLV 20$ PDS LV DQ DUWLVWV¶ LPSUHVVLRQ VKRZLQJ WKH DEXQGDQFH RI 5HQHZDEOH (QHUJ\ SRWHQWLDOV ,W LV QRW LQWHQGHG WR FODLP H[DFW YDOXHV IRU UHQHZDEOH HQHUJ\ SRWHQWLDOV EXW UHSUHVHQWV D URXJK HVWLPDWH EDVHG RQ ODQGPDVV
.
) : ??
3266,%/( 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
3266,%/( 9 ) * $ ) ) $) ?'#' $ " $
* ( .
$ ) ( F
( )
"
"
"
)
) " Q ) ( )
) $ " ) 0 $ ( 6 " $ ) O 0 " ( 3
"
( ?''+" B ;A8 $ )" $ $ ) ??78 O /
) / )
8 6 &&
) 3 &?
=(9("
) ?''+ $ (
" ;'
$ ( 1 &7' { | $ " 0
( 9
$) A'
( ) $) A' " 4:J5 $) &+'
) 4?'', ?''+5( @
" $ $ =9 &'' $ ?''A =9 &#' $ ?''+&;( 6
( % * ) $ )
; ) ( > / $ ! " $ $
( 8 $ ) $
) ) 0 )"
*
(
"
) 8 ) 9 " $
$ { | / )
" ) E * " )* 0 ( 2 ) $
) $) ?'#' ) ( $ ( 6 $ ( . $ $ ) "
) ( )
$ $ ) $ " $ ) ) )
$) ?'#'( .
) "
"
$ ) ( ) $ ) )
?'#'
)
)
" +# ) $ ( .
) $) $ ,' * $ $ ) ( .
" " " E ( > "
) ) $ ( $ )
) " $
$ $ ( 3 0 $ / "
) $ " $ ? $ 8@:( .
)
E " * O
) ( .
$) )
) " $ (
" $ E 0 / O ) O
( . &'' $ $ ) )"
) R
(
) " ) $ ) $ ( ) ) $ "
O O ( &&( =< )
% 8 $
( ( ) @ @ @ &?( 3 @ ?''7
( ( ( ( &;( $ ?'&' 8 $ 9 " % ?&(
q:( &$1 5('8&( 285 5(/,$1&( 21 )266,/ )8(/6 %< %< r 6RXUFH 7KH (FRI\V (QHUJ\ 6FHQDULR 'HFHPEHU
.
) : ?;
7+( (&2)<6 6&(1$5,2 ,1 $ 1876+(//
?'#'" ) &# ?''#( 3 " " " $ )*
( ) )
)* 0 " $
)
"
0 ( 3 $ " )
/ ( " " $ )
)"
"
$ )( 6 )" { | )
$
) 0 )( 6 ) 4 / $ $ 5
$ )
)LJXUH :RUOG (QHUJ\ 6XSSO\ E\ 6RXUFH .
) ) 9 " @ $ ?'&'
.
) : ?-
$ O ) " " / ) (
" $ $ ) $ $ *
( B * $
$ )"
$ ( 6) ?'#'" ) - ) )
0 ) {$ * * | ( 6 $ !
0 O $
)* ) "
) " $
) 0 ) ! $ ( 1 $ ) ?'-'"
( "
$
"
)*
( &-( 3 $ ) ?;& ?;?
) (
q%< :( 6$9( 1($5/< b 75,//,21 3(5 <($5 7+528*+ (1(5*< ()),&,(1&< $1' 5('8&(' )8(/ &2676r
7+( (&2)<6 6&(1$5,2 ,1 $ 1876+(// 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
&#
0DS *OREDO 3RSXODWLRQ 'HQVLW\ *ULGGHG 3RSXODWLRQ RI WKH :RUOG YHUVLRQ *3:Y DQG WKH *OREDO 5XUDO 8UEDQ 0DSSLQJ 3URMHFW *5803 SURGXFHG E\ WKH &HQWHU IRU ,QWHUQDWLRQDO (DUWK 6FLHQFH ,QIRUPDWLRQ 1HWZRUN &,(6,1 RI WKH (DUWK ,QVWLWXWH DW &ROXPELD 8QLYHUVLW\
.
) : ?#
(1(5*< )25 $ 1(: )8785( .
) : ?7
Â&#x2039; &KULV 0DUWLQ %DKU ::) &DQRQ
.
) : ?A
Â&#x2039; &KULV 0DUWLQ %DKU ::) &DQRQ
&+$1*,1* 5($/,7< 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
7+( (1(5*< 0,;
8 $
)
3
" ,' $ ) 4 " 5( .
$
) " ) ) " $ " 0 ) $ )( =
) " " $ ) * $) ?'#'" $ ! $ ) ( .
) " " $ ) "
$ ) ( . $ " Q
) $
) "
0 ) $ ) * $ &'' $ $ (
(1(5*< 2) 7+( )8785(
.
) : ?,
8 $
7+( (1(5*< 0,; 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
q,1 25'(5 72 &87 */2%$/ *5((1+286( *$6 (0,66,216 %< $7 /($67 %< 7+( :25/' :,// 1((' 72 75$16,7,21 72 5(1(:$%/( (1(5*<r 8 $
8 $
)
)LJXUH :RUOG 5HQHZDEOH 3URGXFWLRQ 3RWHQWLDO 7KH (FRI\V (QHUJ\ 6FHQDULR 'HFHPEHU 39 6RODU SRZHU IURP SKRWRYROWDLFV &63 &RQFHQWUDWLQJ VRODU SRZHU &6+ &RQFHQWUDWLQJ VRODU KLJK WHPSHUDWXUH KHDW IRU LQGXVWU\ /RZ 7 /RZ WHPSHUDWXUH KHDW +LJKW 7 +LJK WHPSHUDWXUH KHDW .
) : ?+
0DS *OREDO 6RODU 3RWHQWLDO 1$6$ 0DS RI :RUOG 6RODU (QHUJ\ 3RWHQWLDO
.
) : ;'
9 ) .
) ) ) * )
( 3
" * ) ) $ ) '('? ) )" $ (
) " ) )" $
&#
$) ?'#'" /
) ) ) ( 9 ) "
)( : 4:J5 " )
)" $ 4 * $
&+A' 5 $ " ! ( B 4B9:5
)
$ O !
" $ ) $
( .
$ $ ( 9
$ $
( B $ " $
$ (
" )
" ) ( 9 ) " "
{ * |( 1 $ $
) ( : O ) )
O ) ) ( 6 ) B9: ) )
*
$ ) * &# "
( . $ ) $ $) $ )
$ ) (
q,) 2) 7+( 6$+$5$ '(6(57 :$6 $ &21&(175$7(' 62/$5 3/$17 ,7 :28/' 32:(5 $// 2) (8523(r %ULGJHWWH 0HLQKROG 'HVHUWHF )RXQGDWLRQ
.
) : ;&
Â&#x2039; -RKQ ( 1HZE\ ::) &DQRQ
62/$5 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257 (1(5*< 0,;
.
) : ;?
) ) ? $ ) " ) $
) ( @ " ) *0
)
) (
/
)
$) ?'#' O / &"'''"''' &''"''' $ ( ) $ " $ $ $ (
3 ) $
"
) )(
$ "
$ " ( = "
) ( 6 *
$ )
$ "
( $ "
$ $
" $ (
q$1 $'',7,21$/ 216+25( $1' 2))6+25( :,1' 785%,1(6 :28/' 0((7 $ 48$57(5 2) 7+( :25/'p6 (/(&75,&,7< 1(('6 %< r 6RXUFH 7KH (FRI\V (QHUJ\ 6FHQDULR 'HFHPEHU
.
) : ;;
Â&#x2039; 1DWLRQDO *HRJUDSKLF 6WRFN 6DUDK /HHQ ::)
:,1' (1(5*< 0,; 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
8
) .
$
$ " $ ) ) ) $ ( =
) " $
$) ?'#'( . )
$
&#(
"
) $
)
"
*
( = " )
"
) )
)( ) / )
{$ |(
: "
0 )&7( 8
) # ) R
) ) $ )
$ $ -
) ?'#'( 8
#
( !
$ )
( 8
) ! " $ { | )
( ) "
) ( " $
) "
) ) )
) &A( &#(@
$
"
*
)
)( &7( ( * )( 8 3Â&#x201E; Â&#x201E; 2 Â&#x201E; Â&#x201E; Â&#x201E;2 )Â&#x201E;?'&'( &A( 9
8
: E % :
: .
B
2 ( 3 8
: E " 2( @ " :%1B ) @ B
.
) : ;-
*(27+(50$/ (1(5*< 0,; 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
Â&#x2039; 0LFKHO 7HUUHWWD] ::) &DQRQ
q%< 025( 7+$1 $ 7+,5' 2) %8,/',1* +($7 &28/' &20( )520 *(27+(50$/ r 6285&(6 (FRI\V (QHUJ\ 6FHQDULR
.
) : ;#
q,) :( &28/' +$51(66 2) 7+( (1(5*< ,1 7+( 2&($1 :( &28/' 6833257 7+( (1(5*< 1(('6 2) %,//,21 3(23/(r
.
) : ;7
1 .
" $ " ) $ ) O $
0 * )( 9 E ) ) * $ ) " $ ) )( * "
) *
) & $ ) ) $) ?'#'( > " ) 0 ) ) $ " 3 : 0 %
6 ( *
" * " * 0 ( * ) * (
0 0 %HUQLWVDV HW DO 9RUWH[ ,QGXFHG 9LEUDWLRQ $TXDWLF &OHDQ (QHUJ\ $ 1HZ &RQFHSW LQ *HQHUDWLRQ RI &OHDQ DQG 5HQHZDEOH (QHUJ\ IURP )OXLG )ORZ´ 20$( ¶
.
) : ;A
Â&#x2039; :LOG :RQGHUV RI (XURSH ,QDNL 5HODQ]RQ ::)
2&($1 (1(5*< 0,; 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
>) >) )
$ " ) *0 ) ( D * ) $
"
Q ) ( >) ) $ "
$ $ :J( > " )
( 6) Q " )
0
" " ( .
) $ * 0 ( B Q -'*,' $
)
&,( .
) Q
)
) ( >) &? ) ?'#' &# )( %
)
$ ) " ) Q $ ( &,( ( ( )* * * * * * *$ *
.
) : ;,
q1(: +<'5232:(5 6&+(0(6 :28/' 1((' 72 0((7 675,1*(17 (19,5210(17$/ 6867$,1$%,/,7< $1' +80$1 5,*+76 &5,7(5,$r
.
) : ;+
Â&#x2039; +DUWPXW -XQJLXV ::) &DQRQ
+<'52 (1(5*< 0,; 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
Â&#x2039; QDWXUHSO FRP 7LP /DPDQ ::)
6 ) ) $ O ) " O )
) ( 6 ) ) ) ) ( )
( 2 )" $ $
( " $ $ O $
( 8
"
$ $
$ ! " ( 6 ) $ " ) 3 " 3 D 3 ( > " $ ) $ (
) 0 $ )
( 3
)
$
$ "
$ ) )
) $ ( 3 " * / / ) )R
) " ) " $ 0 $) ) ( 9 "
" / )
) " $
0 ( 6) ?'#'" 7'
$ ( &; $
$ $ $
) ! 4 $ &; 5" $
$ ) ( 0
$ )
)
( .
R ) R R .
) : -'
( =
$
$ 0 " )"
0 ( " ;'
$ ( 9 ) " ! R
)
( .
E $ ( 3
) "
-(# $ $ ) $) ?'#' " { ) | O
$
! $ ) )
)( . $ $ $ " ) $ $ )( "
$ )
" ) $ $) $ ) )" $ 0 $ ) ( 3
"
$ ) $ (
" "
" $ (
6 ) $ / O
$
"
" ( .
)
?#'
$ ) O / $ * ! $ O
E ( .
.
$ )
)
/ (
7'*7&(
! ? $
$) ?'#'" $
$ )( .
) ( ) ) " $ )
"
)
( 3 $ * * ) ( 3 $ $ ( D * $ ) (
) " $ $ ) ?';'" ) $) ?'#'(
%,2(1(5*< 0,; 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
0DS :RUOG ELRPDVV SRWHQWLDO $UWLVW¶V LPSUHVVLRQ 20$
.
) : -&
.
) : -?
7+( &+$//(1*(6 $+($' .
) )
)
)
$ $) ?'#'( 6 0 O E ( .
" "
/ ) ( 1
" )
$
)
$ 4 5
$) )
0 )
)R 4 5 $ )
) ) $) $ "
!
)
" ) ( 3 $ ) $
/ $ ( )
) " ( B ) )( 2 $ 0 ) ( / ( D "
$ )
/ $ ) (
$ $
$
)* )* " $ $
( .
(
.
) : -;
Â&#x2039; 6LPRQ GH 75(< :+,7( ::) 8.
&+$//(1*(6 $+($' 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
(1(5*< &216(59$7,21 > )P =
) " $ ) ?'#' &# ?''#( . {$ * * | E " ) $ ( . $ ) ) O " ) " " ) ( "
) 0 ) $ ( )
/ $) $ ( $ $
! $ $ ) )(
) ( ) " ) !
)
( .
$
$ $ ( " ) ) ) ( ! " ) ) $) * ( 9 ) "
"
" ) ) $ (
) "
"
) ( : $ ) ( 2 4 5 " ! " $
)*
( @ ) )"
0 ) )* ) (
.
) : --
" &7'
$ ( 9 ) * 0 ) $) ( .
" $ "
$ 0 (
0 " )
( @ $ ) "
* 0 ) ( .
)
! $ /
)
" "
( .
)
$
$) ?';'( 3
"
)
)
0 ) ! $ (
$) 7' $) " Q " )
( D
)
0
( $
) 0 ) $) ?'#'"
0 ?*; Q ) ) ( . $ " $ $ O 8 ) ) 0 (
.
) ( . *
0 "
)( 0 0
" $ 0 ( 9 )" $ "
"
" 0 ) ( 6
0 R $ " $ " " $) " * Q
*
(
"
" $)
$ E )
O $) $ " )" ( .
) "
$ ) $ (
) ) (
q7+( */2%$/ &267 2) /,*+7,1* ,6 %,//,21 3(5 <($5 02'(51,=,1* :$67()8/ 7(&+12/2*< &28/' 6$9( r 0LOOV ( ³7KH ELOOLRQ *OREDO /LJKWLQJ (QHUJ\ %LOO ³ ,QWHUQDWLRQDO $VVRFLDWLRQ IRU (QHUJ\ (I¿FLHQW /LJKWLQJ 6WRFNKROP
'2 025( :,7+ /(66 .
) : -#
Â&#x2039; 0LFKHO *XQWKHU ::) &DQRQ
(1(5*< &216(59$7,21 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
Â&#x2039; 1DWLRQDO *HRJUDSKLF 6WRFN -LP 5LFKDUGVRQ ::)
q(1(5*< ()),&,(1&< $1' 5(1(:$%/( (1(5*< &$1 5('8&( 285 '(3(1'(1&( 21 )266,/ )8(/6 %< %< r 7KH (FRI\V (QHUJ\ 6FHQDULR 'HFHPEHU
.
) : -7
(1(5*< &216(59$7,21 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
:+$7 12:" Â&#x2021;
) $ 0 ) )" $ "
C {. |
@ / ( 8 " !
$ 6 *3 $ *. ) 463.5 $ " $
)(
Â&#x2021; ) $ $
) (
$ )* 0 "
)* $ ) $ ( 3 "
) $ ( { | )"
$ )
( Â&#x2021;
)* 0 ) $ " * ) " / {: > | ( 0 / )
) 0 ) ! $ ( 8 $ (
Â&#x2021; ) ! " ) ( . ! "
) ) ( 9 ! )
0 ( Â&#x2021; @ *
0 $ " $ " * $ ( $) 0 " $
( Â&#x2021; 9 $
$ $ )* 0 ( )
*
" $) ) $ "
$ " ! $ $) ( 9 $ $ " ) *$ " $
* * $ 0 (
Â&#x2021; " $ "
$
)
) " ) )
$ ( @ ) )" $ ) )*
0
"
" ) E ) $ (
.
) : -A
&$6( 678'<
.
) : -,
::: 7237(1 INFO 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257 Â&#x2039; 1DWLRQDO *HRJUDSKLF 6WRFN 7\URQH 7XUQHU ::)
q::) +(/3(' '(9(/23 7237(1 $1 21/,1( 6($5&+ 722/ 7+$7 ,'(17,),(6 7+( 0267 (1(5*< ()),&,(17 $33/,$1&(6 21 7+( 0$5.(7r . . (info
Figure XX.XX
B $ ) 0
$ ) (
. 4 ( ( 5" 0
)* 0
( @ $ )
)* 0 ) $ " "
" 0
/ " "
( . &A ) $
=93 B (
.
) : -+
Â&#x2039; 1LJHO 'LFNLQVRQ ::) &DQRQ
.
) : #'
(/(&75,),&$7,21 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
(/(&75,),&$7,21 $ ) " $
P .
) $ ) " $
$ ( B )" ) *0 0 ) R $) ?'#'"
) " ( B " ! " $ ) 0 "
) 4
$ 5 $ ( = $ ) ( " "
( . ) )
$
O "
(
) * $ " " :J "
$ " ! (
! ) ) (
0 ) $ "
$ O
$ $ ( 0
$ $ $ ( "
! "
% 9 3
)
2 % 3 (
) ) " $)
)
) ( 1 ! )
$ " )* ( 8
/ ) ) "
)
( . )"
" $ ) "
) ) 4 {$ |5( .
) $
*
$ ) "
) ( .
) ) $ ?'*;' ) $
( 3
" 7' $) ?'#' ) ( .
-' ) " $ "
) B9: (
E ) Q O ! " $)
O (
) $ ) ( 3
"
$ )
O ) ( $) !
! "
) " *
) " * $ ( :
&(- $ $ )&+ $ ) #'*&'' ) / $ ?# $ ) $
?';'?' " '('# $ 8@:(
::) VXJJHVWV ZKLWH ERUGHUV DQG EDFNJURXQG
.
$ 4{ |5 { |
)( : ) )" "
( : )" $
)
$
( >
" 0
)
( = )
.
)
?' )( .
$
?& ( &+( 3" ) 1 4 15" ?'&'" : ( ?'( 3" ) 1 4 15" ?''+" :
.
) : #&
Â&#x2039; $GDP 2VZHOO ::) &DQRQ
:+$7 12:" Â&#x2021;
) ! ) ) $ ( D * $
$ $ " $ $ ) $ $ (
* " )
) (
Â&#x2021;
) 0 )
) $ ( .
) $ )
0 )" $ $
) (
Â&#x2021; B
! ) $ 0 ) $ (
$) $ $ 4 :J 5" $) 4
" B9:" ) " $ 5(
Â&#x2021; 2
0 ) )" $ " )
(
0
)
" (
.
) : #?
Â&#x2021; 6) ?'#'" " $ ) )(
" ( $ ) )"
0 " " $ ) " $ ( . * " $
(
*/2%$/ (1(5*< 1(7:25.6 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
0DS $UWLVWLF LPSUHVVLRQ RI D IXWXUH :RUOG (QHUJ\ *ULG *,6 '\PD[LRQ 3URMHFWLRQ $02 *OREDO (QHUJ\ *ULG $QD\OVLV
.
) : #;
&$6( 678'<
.
) : #-
0,&52 +<'52(/(&75,&,7< 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
Â&#x2039; 6LPRQ GH 75(< :+,7( ::) 8.
2 * ) ) %
B % " * ) ) )
( "
Q $
" ( 2 &''
! ) " " "
(
"
) (
q::) ,167$//(' $ 0,&52 +<'52(/(&75,&,7< 6<67(0 $6 7+( '(0$1' )25 :22' )25 &22.,1* $1' +($7,1* :$6 /($',1* 72 '()25(67$7,21 ,1 7+( $5($r
.
) : ##
(48,7< )
)( 9 P > )"
) $
) $ ( $
" "
E ) $ ) ( "
( 3 / )" " ) $)
( 3 $ ) $ "
/ ) $ 0
) ( .
( 3 &(- $ O 0
O $ )?&( 3
)( / ?(A $
$ -; $ " ? $ ) $
?'&' ?';'" '(''# $ 8@:??(
$
)" ) $
)
( 3 "
$ " $ ) " $ " / ) $ Q ( 6 E
$ ( 0 )
?; O $ ) ) ( . ) $ " ) " $ $ ( 6 $ ( 0 " *
.
) : #7
) 0 )
$ "
$ {$ |
( : *
)
) O % 8 : $ ( .
" " )
( 3 "
"
$
)( D * "
$ ( $
) )( E )
$ ) E
O ) "
! ) ,# $ ) ( 3
" $ 0 ) " $ " *
) " $ $) ( 3 $ )
( ( ( )( ) ) ) 0
"
( B $
" )
$)
( > )" " $
)
$ " $ $ ) $ $ ( 6 O $
) ( 8 $ ) )"
) $ E $ ( " "
) ) " ) ( $
$
)
"
( $ ) )
( ) )
) (
@
$ ) )( B $ ) )
! ( .
)
$ (
%81 ) )
) $ ( 8 " E
( !
)
"
E ( 2 0
0
$ ( .
$ *
$ $ (
$ 0 ) "
)
) ( .
" 0 " $ *$ / ( .
) $ " *
( .
$ $ 0
$ )(
$ "
)" * " " " " $ )"
) (
$ ) ( 6 $
) " $ ) ( :
0 $ ) ( 2 * $
$ ) E ( $ ) $
$ )
( ?&( 3" ) 1 4 15" ?'&' ??( 3" ) 1 4 15" ?'&' ?;( 8 $ 3 B B " =% " ( ( $ * * * * *
( " ?& @ $ ?'&'
.
) : #A
Â&#x2039; %UHQW 6WLUWRQ *HWW\ ,PDJHV ::) 8.
:+$7 12:"
(48,7<
3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
Â&#x2039; &DUROLQH 6LPPRQGV ::)
&$6( 678'<
.
) : #,
62/$5 39 $1' :,1' 32:(5 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
q::) +(/3(' ,167$// 62/$5 39 $1' :,1' 32:(5 :+,&+ +$6 ,03529(' 7+( /,9(/,+22'6 $1' +($/7+ 2) /2&$/ 3(23/(r 62/$5 39 $1' :,1' 32:(5 .
< " < ) "
( ?''+"
:J "
( 6 0
0 " )
(
.
) : #+
/$1' $1' 6($ 86( 1 )
/ (
P 9 $ )
) ) ) " E
$ )
(
$ " 0$ " $ " ( 2 )"
O E $
$
(
) ) ) " " " "
" Q " ( .
) ) $ )
(
1
"
! $ ) " $
( 9 " ! " " $
) ( 8
0 "
)
" ( 3 $ "
) ) )" )
(
)
* " * $
) ( .
"
"
$ )?-( .
) * * $
$ )(
$ " $ " $ ! $ (
Â&#x2039; (GZDUG 3DUNHU ::) &DQRQ
.
) : 7'
/$1' $1' 6($ 86( 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257 .
) ) ) $ $ )( 3
"
$ $) )
)(
) )"
( .
* $ )" " $ )( 1 $ "
) $ $ $ $ )( )
?#'
" / $ * !
$ )" -(# $ $ $ ) $ ( 6 $ "
) " ( ) )
" $
(
" "
) "
"
) ) "
( "
)" ) $ )( .
$ )
)
( . / $ )"
"
?#
) ( 3 / ) O
0 )
0 ( . )" ) $ 4 ! 3 5
"
(
3
$ "
0 ) ) $ $ ( ) $ ) $) & ) ( .
&(#
=% 3 1 R "
( ! $ )( 2 )
) ) " ! $ ( .
) $) * " $ " / )( 9 ) $ ) $ " $
( 3 ) $ $ " (
" $ "
(
6
$ ) " $
/
) " (
" *
( 6 ) ) $
) $ (
" $ * "
$ " $ $ ) )( 24. For more information on WWFâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s position on bioenergy, see www.panda.org/renewables
q7+( :$< :( 86( 285 /$1' $1' 6($ ,6 .(< 72 6(&85,1* $ 5(1(:$%/( (1(5*< )8785( $1' 3(5+$36 7+( +$5'(67 &+$//(1*( :( )$&(r .
) : 7&
:+$7 12:" Â&#x2021; 3 * ) ) " * " ( .
)
O
!
O
$ ( .
8 9 $ E $ ! (
) "
>) 3 9 $ ) 8 ( Â&#x2021; . $ " ) "
$ $ "( {D * $$ | O
$ ) " ) 3 " $ O $ ( "
) ) " ) $) )" $ $ )" " ( Â&#x2021; ) "
) 4 $
) $ 5
) $ $ ) $
$ )( 9 3 "
3
(
$ B 3 " )
! $ $ )" $ (
) $ ) )
> B J ( Â&#x2021;
$
$) $ ( 9
@@ 4 @ @ 5"
$ " ) (
)
$ ) (
.
) : 7?
Â&#x2021; 6 ) $ $ $ ) O $
O ( J ) 0
"
9 B "
$ 9 $ 6
6 9 " )( 6 $ ) $ "
)
)( Â&#x2021; 3 "
$
"
"
) Q $ ( : $ )
(
Â&#x2021;
/ O $ ) "
)
O
$
$ ) $ )( .
0 ) ( .
/ "
$ E ) "
! $) ) ) ( )
) ) $ )
) (
q$// /$5*( 6&$/( (1(5*< ,1)5$6758&785( '(9(/230(176 0867 6$7,6)< ,1'(3(1'(17 ,1 '(37+ 62&,$/ $1' (19,5210(17$/ ,03$&7 $66(660(176r
.
) : 7;
Â&#x2039; 1DWLRQDO *HRJUDSKLF 6WRFN -DVRQ (GZDUGV ::)
:+$7 12:" 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
q7+( 68*$5&$1( ,6 86(' 72 352'8&( %,2(7+$12/ &$1( 5(6,'8(6 $5( )(' 72 7+( &2:6 0$.,1* 83 )25 7+( /266 2) 3$6785(r
%,2(7+$12/
6 $ Â&#x2026; : "
) ( .
$ ( B
" *
( 3
)
" " ! (
.
) : 7-
%,2(7+$12/
3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
Â&#x2039; (GZDUG 3DUNHU ::) &DQRQ
&$6( 678'<
.
) : 7#
/,)(67</(
&5,7,&$/ /,)( 67</( &+2,&(6
>
) P 2 $
)
0 / ) ( .
) ) )
$ $) ?'#' "
) ) (
" / ) )
$ ) ) )( " "
$
)
)( D ) $ )
( 9
$ ) ) "
)
" )
$ ) * &'' $ $ (
.
) : 77
. $ "
$
$ " )
( 3 "
) ( $ / $ )" $) ?'#' 1 B@ " $) /
( "
$ $ $ " ( )
* ( 3 . 9 ?#" $
0 Â&#x2020; {
/
4 $
! 5R
0 ) " "
) " ! ) / ( Â&#x2020; :
$ "
|(
$ ( .
) $ $
{$ * * | E
$) ?'#' O $ 1 B@ 0
( * $)
E "
$) , " ?&
( : $ ) $) ?'#'( : E
$) 1 B@ " $
( )
0 O ) " $ "
Q) ( ) Q ! $ * $ ) E $ "
( .
* $ )( 3
"
0 $ ) " $
( : ) ! " "
)
( )
$
" $ ) $ )( 3 $) ) E
$)
&+
( J
$ ( : ) )"
) ( 2 ) ( B 0 $ ( .
)( 6 )
$
)
$ 0
) ) "
( 3 $
) $
) ( 25. Waste - Uncovering the Global Food Scandal. Tristram Stuart, 2009
.
) : 7A
Â&#x2039; &KULV 0DUWLQ %DKU ::) &DQRQ
&+$1*(6 ,1 /,)(67</( 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
Â&#x2039; -HIIUH\ $ 6D\HU ::) &DQRQ
6RXUFH SODFHKROGHU
.
) : 7,
:+$7 12:" 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
:+$7 12:" Â&#x2021; ) $ )"
"
) E ) )( 3
$
) "
) $ ( : $ )
( Â&#x2021; )
"
)" $ ( 8 " %81 "
$
)
" ) ( Q
( Â&#x2021; $)
$
"
$ #' ?7( B
$) ) $ )
)
"
)
) $ ( 3 $
* !
) $ $ )
) "
(
Â&#x2021; 6
$ ) " )
$ ) "
( D * " *
$) ) $
$ (
Â&#x2021;
!
)
8>8
* ) (
(
/ ) ) *
( ) " $
R )
* ( $ (
Â&#x2021; % ) $ )" $
4 ) 0 5 ( : 0 $ " ( ( 3 " =.Â&#x2021; B 0 " 1 * . " ) "
$
( .
$ 0
"
$ 0 " / )
* ( ?7( D / " C(" B( @( 2 ( 9 * B $ D
B ( 9 : ) 6 ( 9 " ?'',(
.
) : 7+
.
) : A'
&877,1* $,5 75$9(/ 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
Â&#x2039; 1DWLRQDO *HRJUDSKLF 6WRFN 7\URQH 7XUQHU ::)
&$6( 678'< &877,1* $,5 75$9(/ B $
$ ( = *=< 1 B " $ ?'
$ Q 0 ) ( 3
)
"
9 ( 3 " $ * *
( 0 " 6." $
0 ) )
(
.
) : A&
),1$1&( $ *
) * " $
P .
0 " )
( 8 * $ 0 ( 6 ( ( >
$ )
(
)LJXUH 3D\ EDFN WLPHOLQH RI UHVHDUFK DQG GHYHORSPHQW LQ EXVLQHVV /0 0XUSK\ DQG 3 , (GZDUGV %ULGJLQJ WKH 9DOOH\ RI 'HDWK 7UDQVLWLRQLQJ IURP 3XEOLF WR 3ULYDWH 6HFWRU )LQDQFLQJ 1DWLRQDO 5HQHZDEOH (QHUJ\ /DERUDWRU\ 0D\
/21* 7(50 23325781,7,(6
.
) : A?
$ $ ! & ) ( 6
0 O O ) * $ ) ) ) $) ?'#'( .
)* )
( 6) ?'#'" $ ) - ) ) "
) ) {$ * * | ( 3 )
0
! O ) O (
O *0 $ 8@:"
),1$1&(
3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
9 ?AO )
$) $ ) )( %
E $ "
$ 0 O $ / ) *$ ( 6
0 $
( D $
* $ )* ) * " ) " $
) 0 )
! $ ( 8 $ ! *
! ?# ) ;(# ) " $ $ ? $ 8@:( 3
" ) ! * ( .
$
$) ?'-'( = )" 0 ) *
( ! ) ( % $ )
$ )(
0 " $ * " * $ ) 0 )( D * $
" ! " ) E / $$ $
) (
* ) $ * $ )( = *
" )
" $ * "
) $ " :J ( 6)
"
* $ ) $
)"
$
* ) $ ( .
) #' " $ ?# =(9( B ?,( 8 $
) "
$
$ )" ( 3 1 B@
$ $* $USA'' $ ) ?+" * ( .
$ $ ) "
) $ R "
) $ $ )
)* 0 ) (
$ 5 &'*) ) *
&# E $ ( 8 * ) ) ) $ ;''"''' ;'
$ ) ( ) 0 ) " ) )"
* ( .
*
) $ ) * ) (
*
$ 0 "
$ ( .
* *
* 0
* ( ?A( http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk /+/http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/ stern_review_report.htm ?,( $ ?'&'" 9 R % ?&" : ?'&' ?+( ( ) ( 8?'Â&#x201E;9 $ )Â&#x201E;C Â&#x201E; ( ;'( ( $ * (
) $ " * $ )
" ) {
| E $ ( B ) # ) 4 #,'
.
) : A;
(1(5*< 1(7:25.
0DS *OREDO (QHUJ\ &RQFHSWXDO *ULG 'LDJUDP 20$
.
) : A-
:+$7 12:" 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
:+$7 12:" Â&#x2021; )
) 0 $ $
)( 1 " $ " O Q
* $ 0 (
* $
! "
$
(
$
" $ )
( Â&#x2021; $ ) $ )
" ( = )" ! ) ! ) ( . " " { | $ $ ) * )
= ( ) " ) ( Â&#x2021;
$ * * " ) )" " * 0 )* ( 9 $
$ ) ) 0 )" (
Â&#x2021; 8 $
0 )
$
) $
) )
0 )( Â&#x2021; : )
) * )* 0 )
) O
" $ O
( 8 "
)
( Â&#x2021; : )* 0 $ )
0 $ )( Â&#x2021;
) 0 " $ ) $ ) 0 )* ( 3 )
$ $) $ " $ (
Â&#x2021; :
) $ ) ) 0 )" $ 0 ( :
$ ) ( .
"
$
) / "
) $ )*
0 ) ( Â&#x2021; 2
)
0 ) O J3.
)* 0 " ) !
0 )(
.
) : A#
q*(27+(50$/ (1(5*< &$1 3529,'( 83 72 7(1 7,0(6 &855(17 */2%$/ (1(5*< q 352'8&7,21 8
8
{ |
"
: " 2 ) : % 8
$ )( .
)
$) ?'?'"
&,* -' $ ( )
-#'"'''
! E $ $) ?'&#" +''"''' $) ?'?'(
}9 :BB" 8 " {2 B B |" ?''A
.
) : A7
*5((1 *(27+(50$/ ,19(670(17 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
Â&#x2039; -DPHV : 7KRUVHOO ::) &DQRQ
&$6( 678'<
.
) : AA
,1129$7,21 $
) )P
5 ' ,19(670(17
.
) : A,
.
) * $) )
$ O $ 0 ) ! )( 1 ) ) $
( .
$ 0
)
" $
( .
)
) O
$ ) +# &'' $) ?'#'"
$
( 6
"
$ ) * 4 @5 $ ) ) 0 )( 3
" 7# $ ) $ ) @
" $
! +'' $ @ ;&(
$
! ( =
) " @
! &A' $ ?'-'( = ?'?#"
) O
/ ( . Q)
0 "
)" ) (
.
) O ) $ O $ ) ( 3
" ) $ $ ) )" $ @( 9 ) ) ( ) $) ( 9 ) ( 9 $
( $ Q)
"
)
O ) $ ) ( B "
$
&+ )"
$ ) "
) ( ) $ $ " $ ) ) $ ( ) $
) ( = $ ) " "
)
$ O $ )
(
"
0 $ " 0
)
( 3
) $
$ ) O
)
( 3 " "
) / ( >) E ) )" " ) ) ?'#'
) ( >)
$
"
) ( )
$ " ) ) " $ $) $
) ) ( > " E ( @ ) E
) $ ( .
6 ) 2 )
9 D E $
( 3
) "
$ ?'#' 4 #
) )5( . $
"
" 0
"
)
(
*
( . ) ( C #' )
6
0 Q " E ) D C $ ( . 6 *D
0 $ &++&"
$ $
$ $ $ ( 8
"
) &'' $ ) ) $) ?'#'( ;&( $ @ ?''+ =9 &"&-' $ O
($ ( ?''+ @ 0 (
.
) : A+
:LOG :RQGHUV RI (XURSH 'LHJR /RSH] ::)
,1129$7,21
3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
q&855(17/< 5(1(:$%/( 6285&(6 $&&2817 )25 21/< 2) 7+( :25/'p6 (1(5*< 3529,6,21r
:+$7 12:"
) "
$
&'' $ ) )( .
)* 0 " " " $ ) " (
3
"
$
) )" ) / ! (
! " $ ( 1
)LJXUH &ROODJH LPDJH LQWR ZKDW WKH IXWXUH FRXOG EH PDGH RI (YHU\WKLQJ FKDQJHV EXW QRWKLQJ FKDQJHV ,QYLVLEOH UHYROXWLRQ ,3&& :RUNLQJ *URXS ,,, 0LWLJDWLRQ RI &OLPDWH &KDQJH .
) : ,'
:+$7 12:" 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
) $ 4BB95" ! " $ 4
5" $ ( 8 $ $
) ) * ! ( 8
" $ ) 0 (
"
"
* " " $ ) (
$
) ( @
$
) ( 3
$ 0 $ ( 6
$ " O ) O $ )(
Â&#x2039; 20$
.
) : ,&
Â&#x2039; 0LFKHO *XQWKHU ::) &DQRQ
&$6( 678'<
.
) : ,?
%$&. 72 7+( )8785( 3$57 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
q7+( 86( 2) 02'(51 )8(/ &(//6 ,1 7+( 6+,33,1* ,1'8675< &$1 5('8&( 75$163257 *+* (0,66,21 %< t r ,3&& :RUNLQJ *URXS ,,, 0LWLJDWLRQ RI &OLPDWH &KDQJH
%$&. 72 7+( )8785( 9 " $
( 9 )
O
( >)$
" $) %
* $ 9 $ " $ $ *
( 8 ) 6 9 )9 *3 ) ) $) " $) &'*;# (;? ;?( ( ) ( * $ * ) * *
.
) : ,;
8 $ : 8 : E
.
) : ,-
7+( )8785( ,6 ,1 <285 +$1'6 .
) $ ) $ ( .
$ ) )
) ) $ ( 3
)
)( 1 "
) B1?
! )
$ ( O " " $ " " O
)" $ )( > *
(
) $ ) ) $)
$ ( $ ( .
) " " ) (
0 " ( 3
" ) 0 / ( 6 ( ) $ (
(
( 6 "
O ) ( 9 )(
Final Energy (EJ/a)
8 $ ) 9 ) ?'#'
)LJXUH :RUOG 5HQHZDEOH )RVVLO )XHO 8VH 3URMHFWLRQ
.
) : ,#
Â&#x2039; ::) &DQRQ )HUQDQGR =DUXU
7+( )8785( ,6 ,1 <285 +$1'6 3DUW , 7+( (1(5*< 5(3257
.
) : ,7
Â&#x2039; :LOG :RQGHUV RI (XURSH ,QDNL 5HODQ]RQ ::)
3$57
7+( (&2)<6 (1(5*< 6&(1$5,2 .
) : ,A
:LOG :RQGHUV RI (XURSH ,QDNL 5HODQ]RQ ::)
(FRI\V 1HWKHUODQGV %9 !" ! # $ % &'()*&
*( (&*('+,-./
0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 0 5-6 7() 68/ ) 9 0 ::: () 68/ ) 9
*( ) 68/ -('<8 )(-,'5
80 ; --( (-< &5=- '-(+5//(- (>,/&5,- %+,?/
@ ) 68/ 4
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
,+
3UHIDFH
*( -('<8 )(-,'5 *,/ >((- )'(,&(. >8 ) 68/ , +(,.5-< ) -/?+&,-)8 5- (-('<8 (665)5(-)8 '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 ,-. )+59,&( )*,-<( & >(<,- ,/ ,- 5-&('-,+ '(/(,')* A' =()& 5- 4 ! ,-. /?>/(B?(-&+8 >(),9( , ) ++,> ',&5;( ;(-&?'( :5&* :* :('( ,+/ C((- & 5-;(/&5<,&( , A //5>+( ' ,. & :,'./ D '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 >8 4 $
*( 9,5- ) -&'5>?& '/ ,'( +5/&(. >(+ : >?& &*( ,?&* '/ ,'( 5-.(>&(. & 9,-8 &*(' ,.;5/ '/ - & - &*5/ +5/& :* *,;( ) -&'5>?&(. /5-)( &*( >(<5--5-< 6 &*( A' =()& (,. ,?&* '/0 ' ; --( (-< 2 ' =()& +(,.('3 &5=- '-(+5//( (>,/&5,- %+,?/ -&'5>?&5-< ,?&* '/ E '(;5(:('/0 ' 6 ' % '-(+5/ + C 2 ' =()& .5'()& '3 %((/ ;,- .(' (?- 2 ' =()& .5'()& '3 ' 6 ' '-/& ''(++
* 9,/ ('9,-/ ' ,,'&(- ((+5/ ' -5B?( <:5=C 5)*F+( % A(' ' ,'& (//(+5-C '5C, .( 5//(' ,;5. .( G,<(' 5++(9 (&&5-<, ,/C5, ,<(. 'G,/A(' 5/
.;5/5-< ( A('&/0 ,'& (*?( ' *'5/ (-.'5C/ ' *'5/&5,- ,>( ' >('& ,'9/( ' ,'+ ,9(+5-)C ' 5C+,/ H*-( 5-, ',?/
>('& 5-C(+ ' '-/& ;,- I?5=+( ' >('& ;,- .(- (.
5 : ? * .
) ) 9
+&
6XPPDU\
*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5/ , A //5>+( A,&*:,8 & , <+ >,+ /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 /8/&(9 & &,C(/ , * +5/&5) ,AA' ,)* & ,++ ,/A()&/ 6 (-('<8 ?/( ,)' // &*( (-&5'( : '+. ,-. (,)* A //5>+( 9(,-/ 6 /?AA+85-< &*5/ (-('<8 6' 9 &*( /?/&,5-,>+( / ?')(/ :( *,;( ,;,5+,>+( & ?/ & . (/ / 6' 9 &*( A('/A()&5;( 6 ,)&?,+ A*8/5),+ ,)&5;5&5(/ &*,& ?/( (-('<80 ?' 5-.?/&'5,+ A' )(//(/ ?' ),'/ ?' >?5+.5-</ ' (,)* 6 &*(/( ?/(/ 5& ,/C/ &*( B?(/&5 -0 x *,& 5/ &*( PLQLPXP ,9 ?-& 6 (-('<8 '(B?5'(. & .(+5;(' &*(/( 6?-)&5 -/J x
: ),- :( /?AA+8 &*5/ (-('<8 5- , VXVWDLQDEOH :,8J
*( C(8 ,/A()&/ 6 &*5/ -(: <+ >,+ -('<8 )(-,'5 ,'(0 x & &,C(/ ,- ,9>5&5 ?/ >?& 6(,/5>+( A,&*:,8 5- ,++ /()& '/K :( ),- >?5+. ,- (-('<8 /8/&(9 >8 4 $ :*5)* / ?')(/ RI LWV HQHUJ\ IURP VXVWDLQDEOH VRXUFHV x
*5/ (-('<8 /8/&(9 :5++ ?/( -+8 , 6',)&5 - 6 9 /& 6 &*( /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 / ?')(/ 9,C5-< &*5/ , ' >?/& /)(-,'5 x ( ),- 9 ;( & :,'./ , : '+. &*,& ),- .(;(+ A ,-. /?/&,5- ) 96 '&,>+( OLIHVW\OHV ,+&* ?<* ?' +5;(/ :5++ + C .566('(-& x -('<8 HIILFLHQF\ 5/ &*( C(8 '(B?5/5&( & 9((&5-< ?' 6?&?'( (-('<8 -((./ 6' 9 /?/&,5-,>+( / ?')(/ x +()&'5)5&8 5/ &*( (-('<8 ),''5(' 9 /& '(,.5+8 ,;,5+,>+( 6' 9 /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 / ?')(/ ,-. &*('(6 '( HOHFWULILFDWLRQ 5/ C(8 x ++ ELRHQHUJ\ '(B?5'(. A'59,'5+8 6 ' '(/5.?,+ 6?(+ ,-. *(,& .(9,-./ ),- >( / ?')(. VXVWDLQDEO\ A' ;5.(. &*( ,AA' A'5,&( 9,-,<(9(-& A',)&5)(/ ,-. A +5)5(/ ,'( 5- A+,)( x
*( )(-,'5 L/ (-('<8 /8/&(9 :5++ *,;( +,'<( FRVW DGYDQWDJHV ;(' , >?/5-(//# ,/#?/?,+ /8/&(9 ,/ 5-5&5,+ 5-;(/&9(-&/ :5++ >( 9 '( &*,- 66/(& >8 /,;5-</ - (-('<8 ) /&/ 5- &*( +,&(' 8(,'/
*( ;(',++ ) 9A /5&5 - 6 <+ >,+ (-('<8 /?AA+8 5- &*( )(-,'5 5/ /* :- >(+ : ?)+(,' ,+ ,&?',+ <,/ 5+ 5 0 +<,( 5 0 ' A/ 5 0 9A (++5-</M 5 0 ',.5&5 -,+ 5 0 (/5. N ,/&( 8.' A :(' ( 0 (,& ( 0 +()&'5)5&8 +,' &*('9,+ -) / +,'0 (,& -) / +,'0 :(' * & ; +&,5) / +,' ,;( N 5.,+ 5-.0 66#/* '( 5-.0 -#/* '(
" $
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
4$ 4 $ $ 4
4
55 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) +?
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
7DEOH RI FRQWHQWV
,QWURGXFWLRQ
$SSURDFK
4
5 (-('<8 ,AA' ,)* 4 'HPDQG
$ ;(',++ '(/?+&/ 4$
4
-.?/&'8 4
4$ ?5+.5-</ $
"
',-/A '& "
6XSSO\ ± 5HQHZDEOH HQHUJ\ H[FO ELRHQHUJ\
"
;(',++ '(/?+&/ "
" 4
"4 &(-&5,+/ 6 ' '(-(:,>+( A :(' ,-. *(,& 2( )+ >5 (-('<83 $4
"
"
(/?+&/ O +()&'5)5&8 $
" "
$
(/?+&/ O (,& ,-. ?(+/ 6 ' -.?/&'8
" $
$4
(/?+&/ O (,& 6 ' ?5+.5-</ 4
"
$
(/?+&/ O ?(+/ 6 ' ',-/A '&
" P
$ 95//5 -/
6XSSO\ ± 6XVWDLQDEOH ELRHQHUJ\
$
?99,'80 ((&5-< .(9,-. :5&* /?/&,5-,>+( >5 (-('<8 P $P
$ 4
?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 >5 (-('<80 AA' ,)* & (-/?'( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 P
$
?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 >5 (-('<80 ,-. ?/( ,-. 6 . /()?'5&8 P" "
$ "
?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 >5 (-('<80 <'5)?+&?',+ ,-. A' )(//5-< 5-A?&/ !P PP
$ $
?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 >5 (-('<80 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ ! P
$
?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 >5 (-('<80 /( 6 '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( !
$ P
?/&,5-,>+( ,+<,( !
$ !
9A,'5/ - :5&* &*(' /&?.5(/ !
$
?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 >5 (-('<80 '((-* ?/( <,/ (95//5 - /,;5-</
,QYHVWPHQWV DQG 6DYLQJV
555 : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
+;
4 -&' .?)&5 - 44
4
4 (-(',+ 44
! -.?/&'8 !!
"
4 ?5+.5-</
$
',-/A '& 4
:(' PP 4 P
P
+()&'5)5&8 '5./ 4
!
(-(:,>+( *(,& ,-. 6?(+/ 4 4
(/(,')* N (;(+ A9(-& 444 4 4
(-/5&5;5&8 ,-,+8/5/ - (-('<8 A'5)(/ 4 4
-)+?.5-< '(9,'C/ 4$$ 4 $
3ROLF\ FRQVLGHUDWLRQV
P
4 P
*( -((. 6 ' A +5)8 4PP
P 4
+5)8 >=()&5;(/ 4PP 4 P
P
44P
() 99(-.,&5 -/ PP
&RQFOXVLRQV
$SSHQGL[ $
.H\ ILJXUHV
$SSHQGL[ %
'HPDQG DVVXPSWLRQV
-.?/&'5,+ ,)&5;5&8 (; +?&5 - " 4
4
?5+.5-</ ,)&5;5&8 (; +?&5 - """ 4 "
$SSHQGL[ &
%LRHQHUJ\ DVVXPSWLRQV
4 $
() ;(',>+( 6',)&5 -/ "$$
4
5(+. 6 (-('<8 )' A/ "PP 4 P
665)5(-)5(/ 6 ) -;('/5 - &()*- + <5(/ "PP 4 P
$SSHQGL[ '
6HQVLWLYLW\ DQDO\VHV RQ ELRHQHUJ\
$SSHQGL[ (
)RUHVWU\ RYHUYLHZ
$SSHQGL[ )
5HVLGXHV DQG ZDVWH FDWHJRULVDWLRQ RYHUYLHZ
$SSHQGL[ *
5HIHUHQFHV
5; 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) +-
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
4"4
(6('(-)(/ O -&' .?)&5 - E AA' ,)* $44
4
4"4
(6('(-)(/ O (9,-. $44
4"
(6('(-)(/ O ?AA+8 2( )+ >5 (-('<83 $
"
4"$
(6('(-)(/ O 5 (-('<80 (-(',+ $$$
$
(6('(-)(/ O 5 (-('<80 (/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( $PP 4"P
(6('(-)(/ O -;(/&9(-&/ N ,;5-</ 4$
$SSHQGL[ +
*ORVVDU\
; : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
+#
/LVW RI )LJXUHV
5<?'( #
+ >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ 6 ;,'5 ?/ '(-(:,>+( (-('<8
5<?'( 4 #
/ ?')(/ " "
*( '5,/ -('<(&5), 5/ , + <5),+ ) -)(A& & 5-6 '9 ?' ?/( 6
5<?'( 4 # 4 5<?'( 4 #
(-('<8 P P -)(A&?,+ ,AA' ,)* & 6 '(),/&5-< 6?&?'( (-('<8 .(9,-. ! ! -('<8 ?/( 5/ ( ,95-(. 5- &*( &*'(( .566('(-& ),''5(' &8A(/0
5<?'( 4 # "
(+()&'5)5&8 *(,& ,-. 6?(+ ! ! ;(',++ ,AA' ,)* ?/(. & ),+)?+,&( (-('<8 .(9,-. ,-. /?AA+8
5<?'( 4 # $
6' 9 4 & 4 $ ',9(: 'C ,AA+5(. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 & (-/?'( &*(
5<?'( 4 #
/?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 &*( )(-,'5 Q/ >5 (-('<8 /?AA+8 2 *( /5R( 6 &*( /*,A(/ 5- &*( 59,<( 5/ - & 5-.5),&5;( 6 &*( /5R( 6 &*( ),&(< '5(/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 3 4 5 (-('<8 ,AA' ,)* /* :5-< &*( ;,'5 ?/ >5 9,// 5-A?& &8A(/
5<?'( # 5<?'( # 4
5<?'( # 5<?'( # "
5<?'( # $ 5<?'( # 5<?'( # P 5<?'( # ! 5<?'( # 5<?'( # 5<?'( # 5<?'( # 4 5<?'( # 5<?'( # " 5<?'( # $ 5<?'( #
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
;5 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) +7
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
5<?'( # P 5<?'( " # 5<?'( " # 4
+ >,+ ;(',++ (-('<8 ?/( 5- &*( ',-/A '& /()& ' >8 (-('<8 ),''5(' &8A( " (' " + >,+ (-('<8 .(9,-. 5- ,++ /()& '/ /A+5& >8 (-('<8 ),''5('
+ >,+ (-('<8 /?AA+8 5- &*( )(-,'5 /A+5& >8 / ?')(
5<?'( " #
2M 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ 5-)+?.( &*( /?/&,5-,>+( /*,'( 6 " &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// ?/( 3 $ - 6 + >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ 6 :5-. A :(' 2 (6&0 ; +?&5 - 6
5<?'( " # "
.(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ;(' &59( '5<*&0 , 59?9 6(,/5>+( "4 A &(-&5,+3 $4 (6&0 + >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ 6 *8.' ,-. )(,- A :(' 2 (6&0
5<?'( " # $
9?9 ; +?&5 - 6 .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ;(' &59( '5<*&0 , 59?9 " 6(,/5>+( A &(-&5,+3 $ + + >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ 6 / +,' A :(' ,-. *(,& 2( )+
5<?'( " #
&(-&5,+ >?5+.5-< / +,' &*('9,+3 2 (6&0 ; +?&5 - 6 .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ;(' &59( '5<*&0 , 59?9 6(,/5>+( A &(-&5,+3 $" "" + >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ 6 <( &*('9,+ (-('<8 2 (6&0
5<?'( " # P 5<?'( " # !
9?9 ; +?&5 - 6 .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ;(' &59( '5<*&0 , 59?9 "$ 6(,/5>+( A &(-&5,+3 $$ + >,+ A :(' /?AA+8 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 $ " -/&',5-& A+,)(. - ,-. :5-. A :(' .?( & <'5. +595&/
5<?'( " #
,-<( '(A'(/(-&/ .566('(-)(/ ,)' // '(<5 -/ $ " + >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ;/ ,)&?,+ ?/,<( 6 /?AA+8#.'5;(-
5<?'( " #
A :(' $ + >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ;/ ,)&?,+ ?/,<( 6 .(9,-.#.'5;(- .'5;(- $ 2- -#>5 3 A :(' A+5& 6 /?AA+8 A&5 -/ 5- &*( <+ >,+ -.?/&'8 /()& ' 2( )+?.5-< ?.5-<
5<?'( " # 4
(+()&'5)5&83 $ A+5& 6 /?AA+8 A&5 -/ 5- &*( <+ >,+ ?5+.5-</ /()& ' 2( )+?.5-< ?.5-<
5<?'( " #
(+()&'5)5&83 4 $4 A+5& 6 /?AA+8 A&5 -/ 5- &*( <+ >,+ ',-/A '& /()& ' 2( )+?.5-< +?.5-<
5<?'( " #
5<?'( " # " 5<?'( $ #
(+()&'5)5&83 $ + >,+ 4#(B (95//5 -/ 6' 9 &*( (-('<8 /8/&(9 5- &*( &*( $" )(-,'5 " ;(';5(: 6 &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 Q/ /?/&,5-,>+( >5 (-('<8 ?/( ;('/?/ /?/&,5-,>+( A &(-&5,+ ,-. /?/&,5-,>+( >5 (-('<8 <'((-* ?/( <,/ 2 3 (95//5 -/ ;('/?/ 6 //5+ '(6('(-)(/ 6 ' $P 4 $ P
5<?'( $ # 4
;(';5(: 6 /*,'(/ 6 '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 )(-,'5 ,-. &*(' /&?.5(/ *( ,>/ +?&( -?9>('/ ),- - & >( ) 9A,'(. 9A,'(. >(&:((- &*( &: <',A*/ - &*( +(6& ,-. &*( &: - &*( '5<*& ,/ '5<*& ,/ $! &*(8 ,'( 5- 65-,+ ,-. A'59,'8 (-('<8 ?/( '(/A()&5;(+8 !
5<?'( $ #
+ >,+ ?/( 6 >5 (-('<8 ;('/?/ &*(' '(-(:,>+( ,-. - -#
5<?'( $ # "
$ '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 / ?')(/ -)(A&?,+ ,AA' ,)* & >5 (-('<8 /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 5- &*( -('<8 -('<8 )(-,'5 P
;55 : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
+A
5<?'( $ # $
(/?+&/ 6 &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ,//(//9(-& 6 +,-. A &(-&5,+ 6 ' 6 '
5<?'( $ #
',5-#6(. )?+&5;,&5 - 6 (-('<8 )' A/ P$ $ ,-. ?/( 6 &*( <+ >,+ +,-. 9,// ( )+?.5-< -&,')&5), 2& &,+0
5<?'( $ # P
4 *,3 5- &*( )?''(-& /5&?,&5 - ,-. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 -,'5 5- 4 $ *( >5 (-('<8 )' A+,-. ;,+?( 6 4$ *, 5/ &*( 9, 59?9 +,-. ?/( 6 ' >5 (-('<8 )' A/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 PP P '(#( )+?.(. +,-. ?/(/ 5- &*( /&?.8 &*(' +,-.
5<?'( $ # !
,&(' ?-/?5&,>+( 6 ' ,<'5)?+&?'( 5-)+?.(/ >,''(- +,-. ,-. 5-+,-. :,&(' > .5(/ P! ! ' ,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 >,/(. - )?''(-& +,-. ?/( 6 '
5<?'( $ #
,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. ' ,/ ?-A' &()&(. 6 '(/&(. +,-. P #6(. ,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 >,/(. - /?5&,>5+5&8 6 ' ',5-#6(.
5<?'( $ #
,<'5)?+&?'( ! P ,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 >,/(. - >5 .5;('/5&8
5<?'( $ #
A' &()&5 - ! P (-& ,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 >,/(. - *?9,- .(;(+ A9(-&
5<?'( $ # 4
! P ,+)?+,&5 - 6 +,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 >,/(. - <+ >,+ ,+
5<?'( $ # 5<?'( $ # "
6 . /()?'5&8 ! P ,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 >,/(. - 6 . /()?'5&8 !P PP -# ,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 6 ' &*( ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ ),&(< '8
5<?'( $ # $
>,/(. - /?/&,5-,>+( *,';(/&5-< 6 ,..5&5 -,+ 6 '(/& <' :&* ,-. ,-. /?/&,5-,>+( ?/( 6 &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// 4 !4 ?/&,5-,>+( '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( A &(-&5,+ 6 ?-. 5- &*( -('<8 <8
5<?'( $ # P
)(-,'5 6 ' 4 $ 5- 65;( ),&(< '5(/ ! ..5&5 -,+ ,-,+8/5/ 6 ' '(-(:,>+( 9?-5)5A,+ / +5. :,/&( A &(-&5,+ $ !$
() ;(',>+( 6',)&5 - 6 /&',: 6' 9 )('(,+/ 5- ) ?-&'5(/ /
5<?'( $ # ! 5<?'( $ #
-+8 $D 6 &*( /&',: 5/ ,;,5+,>+( 6 ' (-('<8 A?'A /(/ .?( & & ) 9A(&5-< ?/( ,/ / 5+ 6('&5+5/(' ,-59,+ 6((. ' ,-59,+ >(..5-< -< ,-. >(),?/( 6 ) ++()&5 - >,''5('/ $ !$ )*(9,&5) '(A'(/(-&,&5 - 6 ,+<,( )?+&5;,&5 - )8)+( ! !! 9A,'5/ - 6 <+ >,+ +,-. ?/( 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 :5&*
5<?'( $ # 4
>5 (-('<8 ,'(, A &(-&5,+/ 6' 9 +5&(',&?'( -&5-<(-)8 5-.5),&(/ ,&(/ &*( ,?&* ' <,;( &*( A &(-&5,+ ,/ , ',-<( ',&*(' &*,- , .(65-5&5;( 5&5;( -?9>(' ! 9A,'5/ - 6 <+ >,+ A'59,'8 (-('<8 ?/( 6' 9 (-('<8 )' A/ 5- / 5-
5<?'( $ #
5<?'( $ # 4 5<?'( #
&*( -('<8 )(-,'5 :5&* A'59,'8 >5 (-('<8 A &(-&5,+/ 6' 9 +5&(',&?'( -&5-<(-)8 5-.5),&(/ &*( ,?&* ' <,;( &*( A &(-&5,+ &5,+ ,/ , ',-<( ( < .?( & ?-)('&,5-&8 5- 6?&?'( 85(+./ / T 4 U ,-. T '->?'< 4 !U <5;( &*( /,9( -?9>('/ ,-. A,'&5,++8 *,;( &*( /,9( ,?&* '/ &*(8 ,'( <' ?A(. & <(&*(' -('<8 )(-,'5 >5 (-('<8 <'((-* ?/( <,/ 2 3 (95//5 -/ ;('/?/ 6 //5+ '(6('(-)(/ 6 ' 4 $ (-('5) ,AA' ,)* 6 ' ) /& ),+)?+,&5 -/ " "
;555 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) +,
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
5<?'( # 4
-.( (. .(;(+ A9(-& 6 (-('<8 A'5)(/ 2:(5<*&(.3 ,;(',<(
5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'(
# # # # # #
" $ P !
2: , 3 5/ /* :- 6 ' &*( >5 9,// 5-.( :*5)* ),''5(/ , +,'<( $ ?-)('&,5-&8 $
&,+ <+ >,+ ,--?,+ ) /& '(/?+&/ 6 ' -('<8 )(-,'5 (& ) /& '(/?+&/ A(' /()& ' P P 9A,'5/ - 6 ) /& '(/?+&/ :5&* <+ >,+ P P AA' ,)* 6 ' 5-.?/&'8 ! !
(/?+&/ 6 ' 5-.?/&'8 2,++ /()& '/3 4 4 AA' ,)* 6 ' >?5+.5-</
5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( 5<?'( !
# # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # # #
4 " $ P ! 4 4 44 4 4" 4$
5<?'( ! # 4
-5& ) /&/ .(;(+ A9(-& 6 ' >?5+.5-</ 4 4 4 4 4
(/?+&/ 6 ' >?5+.5-</ 4 AA' ,)* 6 ' & &,+ &',-/A '& 4 AA' ,)* 6 ' &',-/A '& # 5-6',/&'?)&?'( " 4 " AA' ,)* 6 ' &',-/A '& # ;(*5)+( &()*- + <8 " 4 "
(/?+&/ 6 ' &',-/A '& # 5-6',/&'?)&?'( $ 4 $
(/?+&/ 6 ' &',-/A '& # ;(*5)+( &()*- + <8 4 AA' ,)* 6 ' A :(' P 4 P
(/?+&/ 6 ' A :(' ! 4 ! AA' ,)* 6 ' (+()&'5)5&8 <'5./ 4
(/?+&/ 6 ' (+()&'5)5&8 <'5./ 4 4 4 AA' ,)* 6 ' >5 (-('<8 4 4
(/?+&/ 6 ' '(-(:,>+( *(,& N 6?(+/ 4 4 AA' ,)* 6 ' N 4 4
(/?+&/ 6 ' '(/(,')* N .(;(+ A9(-& 4 -('<8 A'5)( ',-<(/ ?/(. 6 ' &*( /(-/5&5;5&8 ,-,+8/5/ 4" 4 " (& '(/?+&/ 6 ' .566('(-& (-('<8 A'5)( /)(-,'5 / 4$ 4 $ ; +?&5 - 6 (-('<8 /?AA+8 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 /* :5-< &*( &*( 44 C(8 .(;(+ A9(-&/ ; +?&5 - 6 A(' ),A5&, '(-(:,>+( ,-. - -#'(-(:,>+( (-('<8 8
5<?'( #
4 .(9,-. " 4 &8+5/(. 5-&(-/5&8 6 ?/( )?';(/ 26' 9 T ('-,'.5-5 U3 " &8+5/(. '(+,&5 -/*5A >(&:((- 6+ ' ,'(, ,-. A(' ),A5&, 4 " T 4 "U "" )*(9,&5) & /* : ;(';5(: 6 6+ : 6 6 '(/& A' .?)&/ 5-&
5<?'( #
.566('(-& >5 (-('<8 ),&(< '5(/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 2 S'() ;(',>+( ,>+( 6',)&5 -3 $ 4" )*(9,&5) & /* : ;(';5(: 6 '(/5.?( ,-. :,/&( 6+ :/ 5- &*( *(
5<?'( # 5<?'( # 4
)(-,'5 .566('(-&5,&5-< >(&:((- A'59,'8 /() -.,'8 ,-. &('&5,'8 '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( $ 4"
5 : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
++
/LVW RI 7DEOHV
4 4
,>+(
,>+(
,>+(
,>+(
,>+( "
# # # # #
4 "
,>+( $ #
,>+( $ # 4
,>+( #
,>+( # 4
,>+( #
! -.?/&'8 /()& ' .(65-5&5 -/ 4 ?5+.5-< /()& ' .(65-5&5 -/ $ 4$
',-/A '& /()& ' .(65-5&5 -/ " 665)5(-)8 ,-. 6?(+ /*56& ,//?9A&5 -/ 6 ' ,++ &',-/A '& 9 .(/ "$ $ +,//565),&5 - 6 A :(' 5-& /?AA+8#.'5;(- ,-. .(9,-.# .'5;(- 2>,+,-)5-<3 A&5 -/ $! "! ?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5, ?/(. 6 ' >5 (-('<8 P4 4 ..5&5 -,+ -((. 6 ' )' A+,-. 6 ' 6 .0 66()& 6 .566('(-& ,//?9A&5 -/ 6 ' 6 . /?AA+8 ,-. .(9,-. ,-. &*(5' >,+,-)( ! P 56(&59( 8(,'/ ,-. A' <'(// ',&5 / ?/(. >8 /()& ' $ $ ,8>,)C 8(,'/ A(' 5-.?/&'8 /?>#/()& ' 25- -;(/&9(-&/ ,-. A' <'(// ',&5 / A(' 9(,/?'(/ ,-. /()& ' 25-
,>+( # "
,>+( P #
,>+( P # 4
E94 6+ ' ,'(,3 4 ,A,)5&8 ) /&/ 6 (+()&'5)5&8 2 / E 3 P4 P ;(';5(: 6 )'5&5),+ A?>+5) A +5)8 -((./ 4!4 ! A '& ;(';5(: 6 )'5&5),+ A'5;,&( /()& ' (66 '&/ ,-. '(B?5'(. /?AA '& A +5)5(/ 4 4
,>+( P #
(9,-.#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( ?5+.5-</ /()& '0
,>+( P # "
'(&' 65& 44 (9,-.#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( ?5+.5-</ /()& '0 -(: -(: >?5+. 44
,>+( P # $
(9,-.#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( ?5+.5-</ /()& '0
,>+( P #
,AA+5,-)(/ (&) 44 (9,-.#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( ',-/A '& /()& '0 9 .,+ 9 .,+ /*56& 44
,>+( P # P
(9,-.#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( ',-/A '& /()& '0
,>+( P # !
(+()&'565),&5 - 4444 (9,-.#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( -.?/&'8 /()& ' 4444
,>+( P #
,>+( P #
,>+( P #
?AA+8#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/0 '(-(:,>+( *(,& ,-. A :(' 44 ?AA+8#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/0 A :(' <'5./ 44 ?AA+8#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/0 (-('<8 &',-/5&5 - 6 ' &*( '?',+ ?',+ A ' 44
,>+( P # 4
,>+( P #
5 (-('<8 A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ ,-. ( ,9A+(/0 +,-. ?/( $44$ 5 (-('<8 A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ ,-. ( ,9A+(/0 ,<'5)?+&?',+ ,-. A' )(//5-< 5-A?&/ $44$
,>+( P # "
5 (-('<8 A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ ,-. ( ,9A+(/0 (/5.?(/ ,-.
,>+( P # $
,>+( #
,>+( # 4
:,/&( 44 5 (-('<8 A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ ,-. ( ,9A+(/0 9A+(9(-&,'8 ,'8 6(++5-</ P44P + >,+ (-('<8 A' ;5.(. >8 / ?')( ,-. 8(,' 2 GE,3 " 4 + >,+ (-('<8 A' ;5.(. >8 / ?')( ,-. 8(,' 2 GE,3 # (')(-&,<(/ "44 4
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &''
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
,>+( #
() ;(',>+( 6',)&5 -/ 6 '(/5.?(/ ?/(. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5
,>+( # 4
,>+( #
,>+( #
4 " 5(+./ 6 (-('<8 )' A/ ?/(. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 "P 4 P -;('/5 - (665)5(-)5(/ 6 >5 (-('<8 &()*- + <5(/ "! 4 ! ,/5) /(-/5&5;5&8 ,-,+8/5/ - >5 (-('<8 6' 9 )' A/ " 4
/LVW RI %R[HV
4 # # # 4 #
" " " $ $
# # # # # # #
-&5-<(-)80 ()*- + <8 )* 5)(/ - >5 (-('<8 ) -;('/5 - 4 ,/( /&?.80 &,&(# 6#&*(#,'& A+,-&/ /,;( (-('<8 5- &*( )(9(-& )(9(-& 4 5-.?/&'8 4 & '80 (&' 65& ',&(/ 5- ?5+.5-</ ,/( /&?.80 ?5+.5-< ) +5-< .(9,-. 5- 9(.5&('',-(,- ) ?-&'5(/ " " & '80 ,&('5,+ -((./ 6 ' >,&&('5(/ ""
" $ 4 4
-&5-<(-)80 ,&('5,+/ 6' 9 >5 9,// P ,/( /&?.80 ?/&,5-,>+( +,-. ?/( >8 /?<,' ),-( ,-. ),&&+(
$ # $ # " $ # $
5-&(<',&5 - P P & '80 ,-. ?/( 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 PP & '80 *( ' +( 6 +5;(/& )C 6((.5-< 5- <+ >,+ +,-. ?/( !" P" -&5-<(-)80 .(++5-< &*( 6?&?'( .(9,-. 6 ' ,-. /?AA+8 6
$ #
P$ 6 . !$ P! & '80 ,&(' ?/( 6 ' >5 (-('<8 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 !!
$ # P $ # !
& '80 '(/&/ 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ! !! ,/( /&?.80 5)' ,+<,( ,/ ,- (-('<8 / ?')( !
-&5-<(-)80 '(5<*& &',-/A '& "P P " & '80 *( ' +( 6 *8.' <(- 6?(+ 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 $ & '80 *( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 $ " "P & '80 ?AA+8# ;('/?/ .(9,-.#.'5;(- (+()&'5)5&8 / ?')(/ $P
$SSHQGLFHV
AA(-.5 AA(-.5 AA(-.5 AA(-.5 AA(-.5 AA(-.5 AA(-.5 AA(-.5
%(8 65<?'(/ " 4 4 (9,-. ,//?9A&5 -/ " 5 (-('<8 ,//?9A&5 -/ "$ 4 $ 4 (-/5&5;5&8 ,-,+8/(/ - >5 (-('<8 " '(/&'8 ;(';5(: $ 4" 4"
(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( ),&(< '5/,&5 - ;(';5(: $
(6('(-)(/ $4 4"4 4$4 + //,'8 4
5 : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&'&
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &'?
,QWURGXFWLRQ
*( +,/& 4 8(,'/ *,;( :5&-(//(. ,- 5-)'(.5>+( 5-)'(,/( 5- (-('<8 ?/( >8 *?9,- / )5(&5(/ : '+.:5.( - '()(-& .(),.(/ 5& *,/ >() 9( )+(,' &*,& &*( :,8 &*5/ (-('<8 5/ /?AA+5(. 5/ ?-/?/&,5-,>+( ,-. > &* /* '&# ,-. + -<#&('9 (-('<8 /()?'5&8 ,'( - : ,& &*( & A 6 &*( A +5&5),+ ,-. / )5(&,+ ,<(-.,
*( )?''(-& A?>+5) .(>,&( - &*( (; +?&5 - 6 ?' (-('<8 /8/&(9 ),- >( )*,',)&('5/(. ,/ +595&(.K 5& 5/ ) -/&',5-(. >8 ?' &'?/& 5- ( 5/&5-< /8/&(9/ ,-. ?' 95/&'?/& 6 ,+&('-,&5;(/
*( 9,5-/&'(,9 ) -/(-/?/ ,AA(,'/ & >( &*,& &*( >(/& :( ),- * A( 6 ' ,'( 5-)'(9(-&,+ )*,-<(/ & &*( ( 5/&5-< /&'?)&?'( 6 ?' (-('<8 /8/&(9 8A5),++8 /)(-,'5 /&?.5(/ /* : /?)* 5-)'(9(-&,+ )*,-<(/ ,<,5-/& , V>?/5-(//#,/#?/?,+L '(6('(-)(
*5/ ;5(: 6 &*( 6?&?'( /&,-./ 5- /&,'C ) -&',/& & &*( >(+5(6 :5&*5- &*( '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 : '+. &*,& V,-8&*5-< 5/ A //5>+(L & 5/ &'?( &*,& &*( A?'( &()*-5),+ A &(-&5,+ 6 9,-8 '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 / ?')(/ 6,' /?'A,//(/ ?' )?''(-& .(9,-. ,-. /&,&(9(-&/ /?)* ,/ &*( 6 ++ :5-< ,'( 6&(- 5//?(.0 ³7KH VXQ SURYLGHV PRUH HQHUJ\ WR WKH HDUWK LQ RQH KRXU WKDQ WKH HQWLUH ZRUOG QHHGV LQ RQH \HDU´ ;(- :*(- :( ,//(// '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 A &(-&5,+/ 9 '( '(,+5/&5),++8 5 ( ,++ :5-< 6 ' 6(,/5>+( .(A+ 89(-& ',&(/ ,-. &,C5-< '(<5 -,+ .566('(-&5,&5 - 5-& ,)) ?-& (;5.(-)( /?<<(/&/ &*,& :( /* ?+. >( ,>+( & 9((& ?' (-('<8 .(9,-. 6' 9 '(-(:,>+( / ?')(/ <5;(- &*(5' ,>?-.,-)( 2/(( 5<?'( # 3 40 '+.:5.( (-('<8 ?/( 5- 65-,+ (-('<8 &('9/ 2,6&(' ) -;('/5 - 6' 9 A'59,'8 6?(+/3 :,/ W G 5- 4 P 2W$ G 5- A'59,'8 (-('<8 &('9/3 T 4 U *(- :( &'8 & '() -)5+( &*(/( 65<?'(/ W GE, 6 : '+.:5.( 65-,+ (-('<8 .(9,-. ,-. / & / 6 GE, 6 '(,+5/,>+( '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 A &(-&5,+/ :( >(<5- & ?-.('/&,-. &*,& , 9 '( .(&,5+(. ;5(: 5/ -((.(. ;5(: :*5)* ) -/5.('/ (-('<8 - &
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
)+?.5-< - -#(-('<8 ?/(
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&';
=?/& 5- &*( '5<*& ,9 ?-& ,-. 5- &*( '5<*& A+,)( >?& 5- &*( '5<*& ),''5(' 6 '9 2( < (+()&'5)5&8 ' 6?(+3 ,-. 6 ' &*( '5<*& A?'A /(/ 2*(,& 5- >?5+.5-</ ;/ *(,& 5- 5-.?/&'83
5 0 +<,( 5 0 ' A/
!
5 0 9A (++5-</
'59,'8 (-('<8 2 GE,3
P $
5 0 ',.5&5 -,+ 5 0 (/5. N ,/&(
&XUUHQW ZRUOGZLGH ILQDO HQHUJ\ GHPDQG
( 0 : (,& ( 0 5<* (,& 8.' A :('
"
( 0 +()&'5)5&8
-) / +,'0 :(' -) / +,'0 (,&
4
* & ; +&,5) / +,' ,;( N 5.,+
4 5<?'( #
5-.0 66#/* '( 5-.0 -#/* '( 4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ 6 ;,'5 ?/ '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 / ?')(/
* +5/&5) ;5(: - &*( (-('<8 /8/&(9 5/ '(B?5'(. ,-. &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 A'(/(-&(. 5- &*5/ /&?.8 A' ;5.(/ ( ,)&+8 &*,&0 , * +5/&5) ;5(: - &*( (-('<8 /8/&(9 ,)) ?-&5-< 6 ' ,++ /()& '/ ,++ '(<5 -/ ,++ ),''5(' 6 '9/
*( C(8 B?(/&5 - :( A /( 5/ &*5/0
³,V D IXOO\ VXVWDLQDEOH JOREDO HQHUJ\ V\VWHP SRVVLEOH E\ "´ ( *,;( 6 ?-. &*,& ,- 2,+9 /&3 6?++8 /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 /?AA+8 5/ &()*-5),++8 ,-. () - 95),++8 6(,/5>+( <5;(- ,9>5&5 ?/ >?& '(,+5/&5) <' :&* ',&(/ 6 /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 / ?')(/ :(;(' &*( A,&* & &*5/ 6?&?'( : '+. :5++ .(;5,&( /5<-565),-&+8 6' 9 V>?/5-(// ,/ ?/?,+L ,-. , 6(: 2.5665)?+&3 )* 5)(/ :5++ -((. & >( 9,.( - &*( :,8K )* 5)(/ :*5)* :( :5++ .5/)?// 5- &*5/ '(A '&
*5/ '(A '& 5/ /&'?)&?'(. ,/ 6 ++ :/0 - ()&5 - 4 2$SSURDFK3 :( :5++ A'(/(-& &*( FRQFHSWXDO IUDPHZRUN :( )'(,&(. & '(A'(/(-& &*( : '+.L/ (-('<8 /8/&(9 *( 6',9(: 'C 5/ /59A+( (- ?<* & >( ?-.('/& . (,/5+8 >8 ,- 5-&('(/&(. +,89,- >?& /?665)5(-&+8 .(&,5+(. & .(A5)& &*( 5-&(<',+ 5-&'5),)5(/ 6 &*( (-('<8 /8/&(9 >(5-< 5-;(/&5<,&(.
" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &'-
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
- ,)) '.,-)( :5&* &*( A'(/(-&(. ,AA' ,)* :( 65'/& .5/)?// ?' ,//?9A&5 -/ ,-. /?>/(B?(-& 65-.5-</ 6 ' &*( GHPDQG 6 (-('<8 5- ()&5 - 2'HPDQG3 ( &*(- 9 ;( - & &*( VXSSO\ 6 (-('<8 :*5)* :( *,;( /A+5& 5-& &: /()&5 -/ .?( & &*( +(;(+ 6 ,&&(-&5 - :( *,;( .(; &(. & &*( /?AA+8 6' 9 >5 9,//0 ()&5 - " 26XSSO\ ± 5HQHZDEOH HQHUJ\ H[FO ELRHQHUJ\ 3 .5/)?//(/ ,++ /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 A&5 -/ &*(' &*,- >5 9,//K :( A'5 '5&5/( &*( ?/( 6 &*(/( / ?')(/ ()&5 - $ 26XSSO\ ± 6XVWDLQDEOH ELRHQHUJ\3 &*(- .(/)'5>(/ &*( ?/( 6 >5 9,// 5- &*( )(-,'5 5-,++8 :( ,+/ ,..'(// &*( () - 95) 59A+5),&5 -/ 6 ?' )(-,'5 5- ()&5 - 2,QYHVWPHQWV DQG 6DYLQJV3 >(6 '( A'(/(-&5-< , >'5(6 .5/)?//5 - - A +5)8 (+(9(-&/ '(B?5'(. & >'5-< &*5/ )(-,'5 & 6'?5&5 - 5- ()&5 - P 23ROLF\ FRQVLGHUDWLRQV ( (-. :5&* ()&5 - ! 2&RQFOXVLRQV3
$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&'#
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &'7
$SSURDFK
*( -('<8 )(-,'5 6 '(),/&/ 6?&?'( <+ >,+ .(9,-. ,-. /?AA+8 >8 5-*('(-&+8 6 ++ :5-< &*( A,',.5<9 6 '5,/ -('<(&5), 60 (.?)5-< (-('<8 .(9,-. & &*( 95-59?9 '(B?5'(. & A' ;5.( (-('<8 /(';5)(/ 4 ' ;5.5-< (-('<8 >8 '(-(:,>+( :*('( A //5>+( + ),+ / ?')(/ 65'/& ' ;5.5-< '(9,5-5-< (-('<8 6' 9 V&',.5&5 -,+L (-('<8 / ?')(/ ,/ )+(,-+8 ,/ A //5>+(
5<?'( 4 #
*( '5,/ -('<(&5), 5/ , + <5),+ ) -)(A& & 5-6 '9 ?' ?/( 6 (-('<8
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
P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&'A
5<?'( 4 # 4
-)(A&?,+ ,AA' ,)* & 6 '(),/&5-< 6?&?'( (-('<8 .(9,-.
/ .(/)'5>(. 5- ()&5 - 5& 5/ 59A(',&5;( & ) 9A,'( .(9,-. ,-. /?AA+8 5- / 9( .(&,5+ & ,''5;( ,& 9(,-5-<6?+ ) -)+?/5 -/ -('<8 6+ :/ *,;( >((- )*,',)&('5/(. >8 ),''5(' &8A( 5 ( .566('(-&5,&(. 5-& (+()&'5)5&8 ,-. 6?(+/K 5- ,..5&5 - *(,& .(9,-. 5/ ) -/5.('(. /(A,',&(+8 ( &*?/ ,''5;( ,& &*( &*'(( 9,5- ),''5('/ '(A '&(. 5- &*( (-('<8 >,+,-)(/ & :*5)* &*5/ : 'C 5/ ),+5>',&(. T >,+,-)(/ 4 !U
5<?'( 4 #
-('<8 ?/( 5/ ( ,95-(. 5- &*( &*'(( .566('(-& ),''5(' &8A(/0 (+()&'5)5&8 *(,& ,-. 6?(+
,C5-< &*5/ ,AA' ,)* 6?'&*(' :( ( ,95-(. (-('<8 .(9,-. 5- &*( ;,'5 ?/ /()& '/ 6 &*( (-('<8 /8/&(9 2/(( 5<?'( 4 # "3 -('<8 .(9,-. ),- >( .566('(-&5,&(. 5-& &*( 6 ++ :5-< /()& '/0 -.?/&'8 ',-/A '& ?5+.5-</ N (';5)(/ &*('" ' (,)* 6 &*(/( /()& '/ (-('<8 .(9,-. -((./ & >( )*,',)&('5/(. 5- .(&,5+ +(,.5-< & ,- 5-)'(,/5-< .566('(-&5,&5 - 6 &*( (-('<8 ),''5('/
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
*(-(;(' :( '(6(' & &*( A &(-&5,+ 6 ,- (-('<8 / ?')( 5- &*5/ '(A '& :( '(6(' & &*5/ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ *( .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ 5/ &*( ,9 ?-& 6 (-('<8 , /A()565) / ?')( ) ?+. /?AA+8 ,& , <5;(- 9 9(-& 5- &59( <5;(- ,- ,9>5&5 ?/ 8(& 6(,/5>+( .(A+ 89(-& A,&* 6' 9 5&/ )?''(-& .(A+ 89(-& /&,&( &( &*,& :*5+( &*( ,//?9A&5 -/
! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &',
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&*,& &*('( 5/ ,+:,8/ , )* 5)( & >( 9,.( 6 :*5)* &()*- + <5(/ & 5-)+?.( .(A(-.5-< - &*(5' /&,<( 6 .(;(+ A9(-& - &*5/ /&?.8 :( *,;( &'5(. & '(+8 / +(+8 - ( 5/&5-< &()*- + <5(/ ' &()*- + <5(/ 6 ' :*5)* -+8 5-)'(9(-&,+ &()*- + <5),+ .(;(+ A9(-& 5/ '(B?5'(. *('( :( *,;( .(;5,&(. 6' 9 &*5/ ,//?9A&5 - &*5/ 5/ )+(,'+8 /&,&(. ,-. ( A+,5-(.
-('<8 6+ :
.(+ + <5) 5<?'( 4 # "
;(',++ ,AA' ,)* ?/(. & ),+)?+,&( (-('<8 .(9,-. ,-. /?AA+8 6' 9 4 & 4 $
5'/& - -#>5 (-('<8 /?AA+8 A&5 -/ /?)* ,/ :5-. / +,' ,-. <( &*('9,+ ,'( ( *,?/&(. /& 6 &*(/( ,'( /5-<+(#(-('<8#),''5(' A&5 -/ ( < / +,' ' :5-. -+8 /?AA+8 (+()&'5)5&8 + ),+ / +,' &*('9,+ A' ;5.(/ -+8 + ),+ >?5+.5-< *(,& () -.+8 &*( >5 #(-('<8 A&5 -/ ,'( .(A+ 8(.
*( 6?++ ,AA' ,)* .(/)'5>(. ,> ;( 5/ /* :- 5- 5<?'( 4 # " -( 59A '&,-& >/(';,&5 & 9,C( *('( 5/ &*( -?9>(' 6 .566('(-& '(-(:,>+( / ?')(/ ,;,5+,>+( 6 ' (+()&'5)5&8 .(9,-. ,-. &*( /A,'/( -?9>(' 6 A&5 -/ 6 ' *(,& ,-. 6?(+ ),''5('/
- .(A+ 89(-& ',&(/ ,'( ) -/5.('(. &()*-5),++8 ,-. () - 95),++8 6(,/5>+( &*(8 . - & -()(//,'5+8 '(/?+& 5- , +(,/&#) /& /)(-,'5 2/(( ,+/ ()&5 - 3 ,-. ?/?,++8 '(B?5'( ,- ,+&('-,&5;( A +5)8 (-;5' -9(-& & V>?/5-(// ,/ ?/?,+L 2/(( ()&5 - P3
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&'+
+&* ?<* &*( )(-,'5 5/ A'59,'5+8 <+ >,+ 5& 5/ 6?-.,9(-&,++8 >,/(. - ),+)?+,&5 -/ ,& '(<5 -,+ +(;(+ :5&*5- &*(/( : '+. '(<5 -/ :*5)* .566(' <'(,&+8 5- &*(5' (-('<8 ?/( ,-. A &(-&5,+ ,-. &*(5' /&,<(/ ,-. /A((. 6 .(;(+ A9(-&0 x ?' A( x '&* 9('5), x ,&5- 9('5), x
?//5, ,-. &*(' ?',/5, x 5..+( ,/& x ,)565) x x x x
*5-, -.5,
(/& 6 /5, 6'5),
%LRHQHUJ\ DSSURDFK
5 (-('<8 6' 9 >5 9,// '(B?5'(/ , 9 '( (+,> ',&( ,AA' ,)* &*,- 9 /& &*(' '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 A&5 -/ 6 ' &*( 6 ++ :5-< '(,/ -/0 x 5 (-('<8 '(B?5'(/ , 9 '( &* ' ?<* ,-,+8&5),+ 6',9(: 'C & ,-,+8/( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 ,/ )?+&5;,&5 - ,-. A' )(//5-< 6 >5 9,// ,-. ?/( 6 >5 (-('<8 *,;( , +,'<( ',-<( 6 ,// )5,&(. /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 5//?(/ x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
4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &&'
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
5<?'( 4 # $
',9(: 'C ,AA+5(. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 & (-/?'( &*( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 &*( )(-,'5 Q/ >5 (-('<8 /?AA+8 2 *( /5R( 6 &*( /*,A(/ 5- &*( 59,<( 5/ - & 5-.5),&5;( 6 &*( /5R( 6 &*( ),&(< '5(/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 3
- '.(' & C((A &*( A' =()&5 - ' >?/& &*( C(8 A'5-)5A+( 5- /(+()&5-< &*( /?AA+8 ,-. &()*- + <8 A&5 -/ :,/ & -+8 ?/( A&5 -/ &*,& ,'( )?''(-&+8 ,;,5+,>+( ' 6 ' :*5)* -+8 5-)'(9(-&,+ &()*- + <5),+ .(;(+ A9(-& 5/ -((.(.
: ( )(A&5 -/ :*('( &()*- + <5),+ )*,-<( 6 , 9 '( ',.5),+ )*,',)&(' 5/ -((.(. ,'( &*( 5-)+?/5 - 6 5+ 6' 9 ,+<,( ,/ , /?AA+8 A&5 - ,-. 6('9(-&,&5 - 6 +5<- )(++?+ /( & (&*,- + 6?(+ ,/ , &()*- + <8 A&5 - &* ,'( - & 9,&?'( A&5 -/ 5- &*( )?''(-& 9,'C(& ,+&* ?<* > &* ,'( ,AA' ,)*5-< ) 99(')5,+ ;5,>5+5&8 ,++ : 6 ' .(;(+ A9(-& /&5++ -((.(. 5- ,+<,( <' :5-< ,-. *,';(/&5-< :( 5-)+?.(. &*( ?/( 6 /5<-565),-& ,9 ?-&/ 6 ,+<,( 5+ 6' 9 4 -:,'./ -+8 - &*(' 59A '&,-& ,//?9A&5 - 5/ 9,.( - &*( &',.5&5 -,+ ?/( 6 >5 9,// ?''(-&+8 ,> ?& $ G 6 A'59,'8 >5 9,// 5/ ?/(. 5- &',.5&5 -,+ ,AA+5),&5 -/ *5/ ) -/5/&/ A'59,'5+8 6 : .8 >5 9,// ,-. ,<'5)?+&?',+ '(/5.?(/ *,';(/&(. 6 ' * 9( *(,&5-< ,-. ) C5-< 5- .(;(+ A5-< ) ?-&'5(/ :,'. 4 $ &*( )(-,'5 :5++ /?AA+8 (-('<8 6 ' &*(/( .(9,-./ &*' ?<* , ' ?&( ,+&('-,&5;( & &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// ?/( *( &',.5&5 -,+ ?/( 6 >5 9,// 5/ &*('(6 '( A*,/(. ?& ;(' &59( A' A '&5 - 6 &*5/ A*,/(. ?& >5 9,// 5/ ?/(. :5&*5- &*( )(-,'5 5- , /?/&,5-,>+( 9,--(' /(( ,+/ ()&5 - $ 5&*5- &*( )(-,'5 &*( .566('(-& >5 (-('<8 ' ?&(/ .5/A+,8(. 5- 5<?'( 4 # ,'( A'5 '5&5/(. ,/ 6 ++ :/0
',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,//0 / &*5/ >5 9,// 5/ )?''(-&+8 5- ?/( 5& 5/ ?/(. 65'/& 5- &*( )(-,'5 ;(' &59( &*( ) -&'5>?&5 - 6 &*5/ ),&(< '8 >() 9(/ +(// ,/ 5& 5/ A*,/(. ?&
4 : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&&&
?/&,5-,>+( '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&(0 ?/&,5-,>+( '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( '5<5-,&5-< 6' 9 ,<'5)?+&?'( 6 '(/&'8 ,-. &*( 6 . A' )(//5-< 5-.?/&'8 6 ' ( ,9A+( ,'( ?/(. & 9((& ,/ 9?)* .(9,-. ,/ A //5>+( ?/&,5-,>+( ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</0 *5/ ),&(< '8 ) -/5/&/ 6 : .8 >5 9,// <,5-(. 6' 9 /?/&,5-,>+( *,';(/&5-< 6 ,..5&5 -,+ 6 '(/& <' :&* ,-. 6 &*( /?/&,5-,>+( /*,'( 6 &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// ?/( & 5/ ?/(. & 65++ '(9,5-5-< .(9,-. 5- +5<- )(++?+ /5) ' ?&(/ ,/ 9?)* ,/ A //5>+( ?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 )' A/0 -('<8 )' A/ ,'( ?/(. & 65++ ,/ 9?)* 6 &*( '(9,5-5-< (-('<8 .(9,-. ,/ A //5>+( :*5+( /&,85-< :5&*5- &*(5' /?/&,5-,>+( A &(-&5,+P -('<8 )' A/ 5-)+?.( 5+ )' A/ /&,')* ,-. /?<,' )' A/ ,-. 2+5<- 3)(++?+ /5) )' A/ ?/&,5-,>+( ,+<,(0 +<,( ,'( ?/(. & 85(+. 5+ & 65++ &*( '(9,5-5-< .(9,-. 5- &*( 5+ ' ?&(/ +<,( ,'( ?/(. +,/& >(),?/( &*(5' <' :5-< ,-. *,';(/&5-< 5/ )?''(-&+8 - & , A' ;(- &()*- + <8 - , ) 99(')5,+ /),+(
*( ,//?9(. ) -;('/5 - (665)5(-)5(/ 6 &*( ' ?&(/ A'(/(-&(. 5- 5<?'( 4 # ,'( <5;(- 5- AA(-.5
5<?'( 4 #
5 (-('<8 ,AA' ,)* /* :5-< &*( ;,'5 ?/ >5 9,// 5-A?& &8A(/ ,-. ) -;('/5 - ' ?&(/ :*5)* '(/?+& 5- ;,'5 ?/ (-('<8 ),''5(' &8A(/ &*,& 9((& .(9,-. !
9A(&5-< ?/(/ ,'( /,6(<?,'.(. ( < >8 C((A5-< , /?5&,>+( 6',)&5 - 6 ,<'5)?+&?',+ ' 6 '(/& '(/5.?(/ - &*( 65(+. ' 5- &*( 6 '(/& '(/A()&5;(+8 P (( ()&5 - $ 6 ' &*( .5/)?//5 - - /?/&,5-,>+( >5 9,// !
X '5. ?A<',.(Y '(6('/ & >5 <,/ >(5-< )+(,-(. ,-. ) 9A'(//(. & ,++ : 5& & >( 5-=()&(. 5-& <,/ <'5./
*( /5R( 6 &*( /*,A(/ 5- &*( 59,<( 5/ - & 5-.5),&5;( 6 &*( /5R( 6 &*( ),&(< '5(/ 5- &*( )(-,'5
44 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &&?
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
4 #
-&5-<(-)80 ()*- + <8 )* 5)(/ - >5 (-('<8 ) -;('/5 -
&217,1*(1&<
7(&+12/2*< &+2,&(6 21 %,2(1(5*< &219(56,21
()&5 - 4 .(/)'5>(/ &*( ' >?/& )(-,'5 ',&5 -,+( 6 ' /(+()&5-< &()*- + <8 A&5 -/ & 5-)+?.( 5- &*( >5 (-('<8 ) -;('/5 - ' ?&(/ *(/( )* 5)(/ 6 ) ?'/( '(/ -,&( 5- &*( 65-,+ (-('<8 /?AA+8 '(/?+&/ ,-. &*(5' ) -&5-<(-)5(/
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
4 : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&&;
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &&-
'HPDQG
2YHUDOO UHVXOWV
- ?-.('/&,-.5-< 6 ?' (-('<8 /8/&(9 >(<5-/ :5&* , .(&,5+(. + C ,& &*( .(9,-. 6 (-('<8 2/(( ()&5 - 430 x x x x
*('( 5/ (-('<8 ?/(.J - :*,& 6 '9 ,-. :5&* :*5)* (665)5(-)8J *5)* 6?-)&5 -/ . (/ &*5/ (-('<8 .(+5;('J ,- &*5/ 6?-)&5 - >( .(+5;('(. .566('(-&+8J
&8A5),+ ( ,9A+( & 5++?/&',&( &*5/ ,AA' ,)* 5/ ?' (-('<8 ?/( 5- >?5+.5-</ +,'<( 6',)&5 - 6 ?' & &,+ (-('<8 .(9,-. (/A()5,++8 5- ) +(' )+59,&(/ ) 9(/ 6' 9 &*( '(/5.(-&5,+ >?5+& (-;5' -9(-& *( (-('<8 5/ ?/(. 5- &*( 6 '9 6 *(,& ,-. 6&(- :5&* ;('8 A ' ) -;('/5 - (665)5(-)5(/ ,-. +,'<( + //(/
*( .(/5'(. 6?-)&5 - 5/ , :,'9 * 9( >?& . (/ 5& -((. & >( .(+5;('(. 5- &*( )?''(-& 6 '9J - 6,)& &*5/ 6?-)&5 - ),- >( .(+5;('(. :5&* 9?)* +(// (-('<8 5-A?& 56 &*( >?5+.5-< 5/ 5-/?+,&(. ,-. *(,& + // 5/ '(.?)(. " $ &*('
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
4$
-.?/&'8
4 ?5+.5-</
$
',-/A '&
$ 4 5<?'( #
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ (-('<8 .(9,-. ,)' // ,++ /()& '/ 6' 9 4 & 4 $
/C5-< &*(/( B?(/&5 -/ 5- ,++ &*'(( .(9,-. /()& '/ -.?/&'8 ?5+.5-</ ,-.
',-/A '& +(,./ & &*( )(-,'5 6 ' 6?&?'( (-('<8 .(9,-. ,/ /* : 5- 5<?'( #
*('( ,'( 9,-8 .566('(-& :,8/ 6 + C5-< ,& (-('<8 .(9,-. *( /()& '/ :( *,;( )* /(- -.?/&'8 ?5+.5-</ ,-. ',-/A '& ,'( ) -<'?(-& :5&* &*( /()& '/ 6 ' :*5)* &*( -&('-,&5 -,+ -('<8 <(-)8 2 3 '(A '&/ (-('<8 /&,&5/&5)/ :*5)* 6 '9 &*( >,/5/
4$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&&#
*( ;(',++ '(/?+& 6 &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5/ &*,& (-('<8 .(9,-. ),- >( '(.?)(. ;(' &*( -( & 6 ?' .(),.(/ :*5+( A' ;5.5-< 9 '( (-('<8 /(';5)(/ & 9 '( A( A+( *( )(-,'5 ,)*5(;(/ &*5/ A'59,'5+8 &*' ?<* &*( ,<<'(//5;( ' ++# ?& 6 &*( 9 /& (665)5(-& &()*- + <5(/ 6 &*5/ A,&* 5/ 6 ++ :(. (-('<8 .(9,-. ),- >( /&,>5+5/(. ,-. &*(- GHFUHDVHG 5- ) 9A,'5/ - & )?''(-& (-('<8 ?/( : '+.:5.(
*5/ )(-,'5 6 ' 6?&?'( (-('<8 .(9,-. /&,-./ 5- /&,'C ) -&',/& & &*( X>?/5-(//#,/# ?/?,+Y 2 3 ' '(6('(-)( /)(-,'5 / :*5)* ) 99 -+8 ,//?9( , GRXEOLQJ 6 (-('<8 .(9,-. (;(- 5- &*( 9 /& A&595/&5) ),/(/ 2/(( 5<?'( # 43 ;(- ,9 -</& &*(' ,9>5&5 ?/ /)(-,'5 / &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5/ ?-5B?( 5- 5&/ ,//?9A&5 - 6 .()'(,/5-< (-('<8 .(9,-. >8 4 $ K 9 /& /)(-,'5 / 6 '(/(( ,& >(/& , VWDELOLVDWLRQ 6 .(9,-. T +59,&( +?&5 -/K 4 K '((-A(,)( 4 K *(++ 4 !K ;,- ??'(- 4 PK 4 U
&,+ (-('<8 265-,+ ' A'59,'83 T GE,U
4
(6 (6
*(++ +?(A'5-&/ !
,- ??'(- (6
,- ??'(- " +59,&( +?&5 -/
"
Q "$ 4
.; T'U(; +?&5 2Q 3 -('<8 (A '&
4 5<?'( # 4
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
9A,'5/ - 6 <+ >,+ (-('<8 .(9,-. (; +?&5 - 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 :5&* &*(' (-('<8 /)(-,'5 / A &*'(( +5-(/ ,'( 5- A'59,'8 + :(' /5
+5-(/ 5- 65-,+ (-('<8
& 5/ 59A(',&5;( & ?-.('/&,-. &*,& &*( '(.?)&5 - 6 & &,+ (-('<8 .(9,-. 5- &*5/ )(-,'5 5/ - & .('5;(. 6' 9 , '(.?)&5 - 5- ,)&5;5&8 & .(A(-./ A'59,'5+8 - &*( '(.?)&5 - 6 (-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 ',&*(' &*,- , '(.?)&5 - 6 ,)&5;5&8 +(;(+/ A(' ),A5&, 2/(( 5<?'( 4 # 43
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
4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &&7
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&*( )(-,'5 L/ ?-.('+85-< ,//?9A&5 -/ 6 A A?+,&5 - <' :&* ,-. <' :&* :*5)* ,'( ?/(. & A' =()& ,)&5;5&8 5-& &*( 6?&?'( T 4 PK 4 "U 4 "
!
A?+,&5 -
2&'5++5 - 4 $3
"
4 !
!
"
" 4
4
4
5<?'( #
2&'5++5 - 4 $3
A?+,&5 - 2>5++5 -/3
4
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ A A?+,&5 - ,-. ?/(. ,/ &*( >,/5/ 6 ' &*( )(-,'5
5++?/&',&( &*5/ 6?'&*(' 5<?'( # /* :/ , /?99,'8 6 /(+()&(. ,)&5;5&8 ,//?9A&5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 *( ,)&5;5&5(/ /* :- *('( ,'( &* /( ,)&5;5&5(/ :*5)* ,'( 9 /& ) 99 -+8 ,// )5,&(. :5&* V+5;5-< /&,-.,'./L ' V) 96 '& +(;(+/L0 x
*( ,9 ?-& 6 '(/5.(-&5,+ +5;5-< /A,)( x
*( ,9 ?-& 6 5-.?/&'5,+ A' .?)&5 - ,/ ,- 5-.5),& ' 6 ) -/?9A&5 x
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
*5/ 5/ .5/)?//(. 5- 9 '( .(&,5+ 5- &*( 6 ++ :5-< /()& '#/A()565) /()&5 -/
V L /()& '/ /* :- -+8 *('( O /(( ()&5 - 4 6 ' .(&,5+/
4P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&&A
4 D
D
4 4
4
4 "
4 D
D
D 4
)&5;5&8 25-.( (. - 4 $3
D
4
4 4
4
4 "
'+. 4 D
D
D 4
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
,QGH[HG DEVROXWH DFWLYLW\ OHYHOV
-# 4 D
D
D 4
4 $
,QGH[HG SHU FDSLWD DFWLYLW\ OHYHOV
D
4
D
4 D
5<?'( # "
-#
4 $
-#
D 4
,QGH[HG DEVROXWH DFWLYLW\ OHYHOV
D
,QGH[HG SHU FDSLWD DFWLYLW\ OHYHOV
D
)&5;5&8 25-.( (. - 4 $3
4
)&5;5&8 25-.( (. - 4 $3
)&5;5&8 25-.( (. - 4 $3
-#
D 4
)&5;5&8 25-.( (. - 4 $3
)&5;5&8 25-.( (. - 4 $3
,QGH[HG SHU FDSLWD DFWLYLW\ OHYHOV
D
D
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
,QGH[HG DEVROXWH DFWLYLW\ OHYHOV
'+. 4 D
D
D 4
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
)&5;5&8 +(;(+/ 5-.( (. - 4 $ 5- ,>/ +?&( &('9/ 2'5<*&3 ,-. A(' ),A5&, &('9/ 2+(6&3 * :- 5-.?/&'5,+ A' .?)&5 - ; +?9(/ 5- &*( Q Q /()& '/ 2 -.?/&'83 '(/5.(-&5,+ 6+ ' /A,)( 2 ?5+.5-</3 ,-. A,//(-<(' C5+ 9(&('/ 2 ',-/A '&3
4! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &&,
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
,QGXVWU\
,QGXVWU\ ± 'HILQLWLRQV
*( 5-.?/&'8 /()& ' ?/(/ (-('<8 6 ,++ &*'(( ),''5(' &8A(/ 5- &*( .(65-5&5 - ?/(. *('(0 (+()&'5)5&8 6?(+ ,-. *(,& -.?/&'8 ) 9A'5/(/ &*( 6 ++ :5-< /()& '/ 25 ( 5& ( )+?.(/ &*( A :(' /()& ' :*5)* 5/ &'(,&(. - &*( /?AA+8 /5.( 6 &*( )(-,'5 O /(( ()&5 - "30
,>+( #
-.?/&'8 /()& ' .(65-5&5 -/
6FHQDULR
,QGXVWU\ VHFWRU
,QGXVWU\ VHFWRU
&DWHJRU\
,($ GHILQLWLRQ
6FHQDULR PDUNHU VHFWRU
X Y
' - N /&((+
&((+
-#6('' ?/ 9(&,+/
+?95-5?9
-#9(&,++5) 95-(',+/
(9(-&
,A(' A?+A ,-. A'5-&
,A('
*(95),+ N A(&' )*(95),+
*(95),+/
. N & >,))
.
T ++ &*('/U
&*('
X Y
*( )(-,'5 ?/(/ 9,'C(' /()& '/ & 6 '(),/& (; +?&5 - 6 ,)&5;5&8 ,-. ,//(// A &(-&5,+ 6 ' (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-&/ *5/ 9(,-/ 6 ' ( ,9A+( &*,& :( ,//?9( (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-&/ ),- >( 9,.( 5- &*( (-&5'( - -#6('' ?/ 9(&,+/ /()& ' :*5)* ,'( ,-,+ < ?/ & &*( 59A' ;(9(-&/ :( ,//?9( 6 ' &*( A' .?)&5 - 6 ,+?95-5?9 (&) ' /59A+5)5&8 :( :5++ '(6(' & 5-.?/&'8 /()& '/ >8 &*(5' )(-,'5 -,9(/ 6 ' &*( '(9,5-.(' 6 &*5/ '(A '& ,QGXVWU\ ± )XWXUH DFWLYLW\ )&5;5&8 +(;(+/ 6 ' &*( 65'/& 6 ?' /()& '/ 2&*( V L /()& '/3 ,'( ,//(//(. 5- &('9/ 6 & --(/ A' .?)(. ,-. +5-C(. & A A?+,&5 - <' :&* )&5;5&8 +(;(+/ 6 ' &*( +,/& &*'(( /()& '/ 2V L /()& '/3 ,'( ,//(//(. >8 <' :&* ³$´ VHFWRUV ' &*(/( /()& '/ ,- ,//?9A&5 - 5/ 9,.( - &*( 6?&?'( (; +?&5 - 6 & --(/ A' .?)(. A(' ),A5&, >,/(. - &*( + <5) 6 X5-&(-/5&8 6 ?/(Y )?';(/ 2/(( AA(-.5 3 *5/ ,//?9A&5 - 5/ &*(- 9?+&5A+5(. >8 &*( 6?&?'( A A?+,&5 - & (/&59,&( & &,+ 6?&?'( A' .?)&5 - +(;(+/
4 : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&&+
5<?'( # $ /* :/ &*( '(/?+&5-< ,)&5;5&8 +(;(+/ 6 ' &*( 6 ?' 5-.?/&'5,+ /()& '/ /&((+ )(9(-& ,+?95-5?9 A,A('
P ,A('
' .?)&5 - E , 2>- & --(/3
$
+?95-5?9 "
(9(-&
4 &((+
4 5<?'( # $
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ A' .?)&5 - +(;(+/ 6 &*( Q Q 5-.?/&'8 /()& '/
µ%¶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
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &?'
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
-+8 & 66/(& + //(/ .?( & .5//5A,&5;( ?/( 2( < *8<5(-5) A,A('/ 6('&5+5/('3 B?,+5&8 + // 2( < A,A(' 65>'( A+,/&5)/3 ' &*(' + //(/ ,QGH[HG DEVROXWH DFWLYLW\ OHYHOV
)&5;5&8 25-.( (. - 4 $3
" D
D
-.?/&'8 2 3
-.?/&'8 2 3 - -#
-.?/&'8 2 3
4 D
D
D 4 5<?'( #
-.?/&'8 2 3 - -#
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
-.( (. (; +?&5 - 6 ,)&5;5&8 5- &*( -.?/&'8 /()& '
,QGXVWU\ ± )XWXUH HQHUJ\ LQWHQVLW\ -)( &*( & &,+ A' .?)&5 - +(;(+ *,/ >((- .(&('95-(. 6 ' (,)* /()& ' 6?&?'( (-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 5/ (/&59,&(. >,/(. - C(8 9,'C(' A' )(//(/ *( ;(',++ '(/?+& 5/ , .()'(,/( 5- (-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 9(,/?'(. 5- (-('<8 A(' & --( A' .?)(. 6 ' V L /()& '/ ,-. 5- (-('<8 A(' () - 95) ;,+?( 6 ' V L /()& '/
*( (-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 (; +?&5 - :,/ ( ,95-(. 5- .(&,5+ 6 ' &*( 6 ?' V L /()& '/ ,-. &*( '(/?+&/ ,'( /* :- 5- 5<?'( # P +&* ?<* &*( 5-.5;5.?,+ &()*- + <5(/ ;,'8 >8 /()& ' ,++ /()& '/ 6 ++ : &*(/( ) 99 - ,//?9A&5 -/0 x -)'(,/(. ?/( 6 '() ;('(. 5-A?& 9,&('5,+/ ' ,+&('-,&5;( ' ?&(/ R 5 ( '()8)+5-< 6 /&((+ A,A(' ,-. ,+?95-5?9 ,-. ,+&('-,&5;( 5-A?& 9,&('5,+/ 5-& &*( )+5-C(' A' )(// 5- )(9(-& A' .?)&5 x 9>5&5 ?/ '(6?'>5/*9(-& 6 ( 5/&5-< A+,-&/ & 9((& A('6 '9,-)( >(-)*9,'C/ ,-. /&'5-<(-& '(B?5'(9(-&/ 6 ' ?/5-< >(/& ,;,5+,>+( &()*- + <8 2 3 5- ,++ -(: A+,-&/ 4 x
-&5-?5-< 59A' ;(9(-&/ 6 ;(' &59(
' &*( V L /()& '/ ,- ,--?,+ (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-& 6 4D :,/ ,//?9(. :*5)* 9,8 >( >&,5-(. &*' ?<* 59A' ;(. A' )(// A&595/,&5 - 9 '( (665)5(-& (-('<8 /?AA+8 4 ( A+5)5& ,//?9A&5 -/ ,'( 9,.( - &*( (,'+8 '(&5'(9(-& 6 5-.?/&'5,+ A+,-&/ >?& &*( ',A5. 9 ;( & :5++ +5C(+8 '(B?5'( ,9>5&5 ?/ '(&' 65&&5-< ' '(A+,)(9(-& 6 &*( +(,/& (665)5(-& A+,-&/
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&?&
59A' ;(. (665)5(-)8 5- 9 & ' .'5;(- /8/&(9/ ,-. +5<*&5-< ,/ :(++ ,/ /()& '#/A()565) 9(,/?'(/
-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 2 G E & --(/3
4 D &((+
D ! D
(9(-&
D +?95-5?9 " D 4 D
,A('
D 4 5<?'( # P
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
; +?&5 - 6 (-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 6 ' &*( 6 ?' Q Q 5-.?/&'8 /()& '/ 5-)+?.5-< ?/( 6 '()8)+5-<E,+&('-,&5;( ' ?&(/
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
*( '()8)+(. /&((+ ' ?&( 5/ 9?)* 9 '( (-('<8 (665)5(-& >?& ',&(/ 6 '()8)+(. 9,&('5,+ 5-A?&/ ,'( ,+'(,.8 *5<* *( )(-,'5 -(;('&*(+(// ,//?9(/ , /9,++ 5-)'(,/( 5- &*( ?/( 6 '()8)+(. 9,&('5,+/ & WP D 5- ,-. W"$D 5- - -# '(<5 -/ >8 4 $
*( '()8)+(. A' )(// 5/ ,+/ ,//?9(. & 5-)'(,/( 5&/ (-('<8 (665)5(-)8 6' 9 ,' ?-. $O G 6?(+ ,-. O! C * A(' & --( & $ G 6?(+ ,-. $ C * A(' & --( 5- &*( (+()&'5) ,') 6?'-,)( A' )(// T ,'&5- 4 U &HPHQW - &*( )(9(-& /()& ' :*5)* 5/ ?/(. ,/ , 9,'C(' 6 ' &*( - -#9(&,++5) 95-(',+/ /()& ' (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-&/ &*,& ,'( )?''(-&+8 &,C5-< A+,)( /* ?+. >'5-< &*( ,;(',<(
4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &??
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
(-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 . :- 6' 9 $O G 6?(+ A(' & --( & G 6?(+ A(' & --(. Also, a ~30% reduction on the electricity demand (to ~80 kWh per tonne) was assumed. (),?/( 6 &*( *5<* &(9A(',&?'(/ '(B?5'(. -+8 *,+6 6 &*( 6?(+ -((./ ),- >( A' ;5.(. >8 >5 9,// >?& :*('( >5 9,// 5/ ?/(. ,-8 ) 9>?/&5>+( >5 9,// 5/ /?5&,>+( *( )(-,'5 ,+/ ,//?9(/ , '(.?)&5 - 5- (-('<8# ,-. ),'> -#5-&(-/5;( )+5-C(' A' .?)&5 - +5-C(' 5/ '(A+,)(. >8 5-.?/&'5,+ >8#A' .?)&/ /?)* ,/ >+,/& 6?'-,)( /+,</ 6+8 ,/* ' -,&?',+ A RR +,-(/ 5- ?A & " D 6 )(9(-& A' .?)&5 - >8 4 $ *5/ : ?+. '(/?+& 5- )(9(-& &*,& : ?+. /(& 9 '( /+ :+8 >?& ,+/ >( 6 *5<*(' /&'(-<&* T%59 4 4U #
&$6( 678'<
,/( /&?.80 &,&(# 6#&*(#,'& A+,-&/ /,;( (-('<8 5- &*( )(9(-& 5-.?/&'8
67$7( 2) 7+( $57 3/$176 6$9( (1(5*< ,1 7+( &(0(17 ,1'8675<
*( )(9(-& 5-.?/&'8 5/ , +,'<( (-('<8 ?/(' ,-. ,+/ ,- 59A '&,-& <+ >,+ ) -&'5>?& ' & <'((-* ?/( <,/ (95//5 -/ *( 5/ &*( &*5'. +,'<(/& )(9(-& A' .?)(' 5- &*( : '+. ,+& 5;(' ,&('5,+/ ' ?A A(',&(/ , )(9(-& A+,-& 5- +,'C/.,+( '5R -, *( A+,-& :,/ >?5+& 5- &*( $ L/ ,-. ;(' &59( '()(5;(. ;,'5 ?/ ?A<',.(/ & 5-)'(,/( C5+- ),A,)5&8 ,-. &*(' A(',&5-< /8/&(9/ - &*( ) 9A,-8 5-/&,++(. , /(& 6 -(: (B?5A9(-& &*,& /?>/&,-&5,++8 59A' ;(. (-('<8 A('6 '9,-)( *( A+,-& ?A<',.(/ 5-)+?.(.0 x
;('&5),+ ' ++(' 95++ 6 ' ',: 9,&('5,+/ 6?(+/ ,-. 65-5/*(. )(9(-&
x
-(: $#/&,<( + : A'(*(,&('E),+)5-(' C5+- :5&* /&,&(# 6#&*(#,'& )+5-C(' ) +('
x
9 .('- C5+- >?'-('
*( -(: (B?5A9(-& 59A' ;(. (-('<8 A('6 '9,-)( /?>/&,-&5,++8 ,)' // &*( 9,= ' (-('<8 5-&(-/5;( A' )(//(/ 5- &*( A+,-& '(.?)5-< (+()&'5)5&8 ) -/?9A&5 - >8 $ D ,-. 6?(+ ) -/?9A&5 - >8 PD *( ?A<',.( 9,.( &*( +,'C/.,+( A+,-& -( 6 &*( 9 /& (665)5(-& )(9(-& A+,-&/ 5- '&*# 9('5), & '()(5;(. '() <-5&5 - 6 ' &*5/ ,)*5(;(9(-& 6' 9 &*( A' <',9 6 &*( -;5' -9(-&,+ ' &()&5 - <(-)8
$OXPLQLXP +?95-5?9 :*5)* 5/ ?/(. ,/ , 9,'C(' 6 ' &*( - -#6('' ?/ 9(&,+/ /()& ' :5++ 5-)+?.( ;,/&+8 5-)'(,/5-< /*,'(/ 6 /() -.,'8 '()8)+(. ,+?95-5?9 5- &*( A' .?)&5 - A' )(//
()8)+5-< 6 ,+?95-5?9 ?/(/ 6?(+/ :*5)* ,'( - & (,/5+8 '(A+,)(. >8 >5 6?(+/ >?& ,& "O $ G A(' & --( 5& 5/ , 9?)* 9 '( (665)5(-& A' )(// &*,- &*( A' .?)&5 - 6 A'59,'8 ,+?95-5?9 :*5)* 5- ,..5&5 - & O4 G A(' & --( 6 ' A'(#>,C5-< 6 &*( ,- .(/ ?/(/ $O * 2- & C *3 6 (+()&'5)5&8 A(' & --( 6 ,+?95-5?9 A' .?)(. (B?5;,+(-& & $$ G A(' & --( 5 ( 5& 5/ ,- '.(' 6 9,<-5&?.( 9 '( (-('<8 5-&(-/5;( &*,- '()8)+5-<
*( )(-,'5 ,//?9(/ &*,& &*5/ ),- >( '(.?)(. & ,' ?-. 4 * A(' & --( 5- &*( 6?&?'( >?& A'5 '5&5/(/ &*( '()8)+5-< 6 ,+?95-5?9 :*('( A //5>+( *,'(/ 6 '()8)+(.
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&?;
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±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
5-,+ (-('<8 2 G E ,3
?(+/ 2 /()& '/3
!
5<* (,& 2 /()& '/3
"
+()&'5)5&8
4 4 5<?'( # !
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ ;(',++ (-('<8 ?/( 5- &*( -.?/&'8 /()& ' >8 (-('<8 ),''5(' &8A(
" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &?-
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
%XLOGLQJV
*( >?5+.5-< /()& ' A' ;5.(/ <'(,& A &(-&5,+ 6 ' (-('<8 /,;5-</ ,-. (+()&'565),&5 - *( /()& ' 5/ ,+/ 9,'C(. >8 + -<(;5&80 .()5/5 -/ - >?5+.5-< .(/5<- & .,8 5-6+?(-)( >?5+.5-< (-('<8 ?/( 6 ' 9,-8 .(),.(/ 6&(- ?A & , )(-&?'8 <5;(- &*( +56(&59(/ 6 ?' >?5+.5-< /& )C %XLOGLQJV ± 'HILQLWLRQV
*( >?5+& (-;5' -9(-& /()& ' :*5)* :( :5++ '(6(' & /59A+8 ,/ &*( V ?5+.5-</L /()& ' 5- &*5/ . )?9(-& ) ;('/ (-('<8 ?/( 5- &*( '(/5.(-&5,+ ,-. /(';5)(/ /()& ' ,)) '.5-< & &*( .(65-5&5 -/ 5- &*( -('<8 >,+,-)(/ 2/(( ,>+( # 43
,>+( # 4
?5+.5-< /()& ' .(65-5&5 -/
%XLOGLQJ VHFWRU
%XLOGLQJ VHFWRU
,($ GHILQLWLRQ
6FHQDULR GHILQLWLRQ
(/5.(-&5,+
(/5.(-&5,+
99(')5,+ ,-. A?>+5) /(';5)(/
99(')5,+
%XLOGLQJV ± )XWXUH DFWLYLW\
*( 6 ++ :5-< /&(A/ ,'( 6 ++ :(. 5- &*5/ -('<8 )(-,'5 & (/&,>+5/* &*( 6?&?'( ,)&5;5&8 +(;(+/ 5- &*( ?5+.5-< /()& '0 &,+ 6?&?'( 6+ ' ,'(, :*5)* 5/ &*( ,)&5;5&8 9,'C(' 5- &*( ?5+.5-< /()& ' 5/ A' =()&(. >,/(. - A A?+,&5 - <' :&* ,-. 5-)'(,/(. +5;5-< /A,)( A(' ),A5&, 595+,'+8 & &*( 5-.?/&'8 /()& ' &*( 6?&?'( '(/5.(-&5,+ 6+ ' /A,)( A(' ),A5&, 5/ 5-6 '9(. >8 , '(+,&5 -/*5A >(&:((- +5;5-< /A,)( ,-. A(' ),A5&, 2/(( AA(-.5 43
//?9A&5 -/ - &8A5),+ *5/& '5),+ .(9 +5&5 - ',&(/ ,'( &*(- ?/(. & /A+5& 5-& 6+ ' ,'(, &*,& ( 5/&/ & .,8 2A'(#4 $ /& )C3 ,-. 6+ ' ,'(, 8(& & >( >?5+& 2-(: /& )C3
*( '(/?+&/ 6 ' &*( '(/5.(-&5,+ >?5+.5-</ /()& ' ,'( /* :- 5- 5<?'( #
*5/ 5-)'(,/( 5/ - & -()(//,'5+8 &*( /,9( 5- ,++ '(<5 -/ ,/ /&,'&5-< A 5-&/ ;,'8
$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&?#
(/5.(-&5,+ 6+ ' ,'(, 2>- /B93
" $ (: /& )C
4$ 4 $
?''(-& /& )C
$ 4
5<?'( #
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ '(/5.(-&5,+ 6+ ' ,'(, (; +?&5 - 5- &*( ?5+.5-</ /()& '
' ) 99(')5,+ 6+ ' /A,)( , /595+,' ,AA' ,)* 5/ 6 ++ :(. >?& ',&*(' &*,- ?/5-< A A?+,&5 - <' :&* ,/ , 9,'C(' &*5/ (; +?&5 - 5/ A(<<(. & <' :&* :5&* , .() ?A+5-< 6,)& '
*( ;(',++ (; +?&5 - 6 '(/5.(-&5,+ ,-. ) 99(')5,+ 6+ ' /A,)( 5/ /* :- 5- 5<?'( # ,QGH[HG DEVROXWH DFWLYLW\ OHYHOV
)&5;5&8 25-.( (. - 4 $3
" D
D
?5+.5-</ 2 3
?5+.5-</ 2 3 - -#
?5+.5-</ 2 3
4 D
D
D 4 5<?'( #
?5+.5-</ 2 3 - -#
4
4 4
4
4 "
-.( (. (; +?&5 - 6 6+ ' /A,)( 2 S (/5.(-&5,+ S 99(')5,+3
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &?7
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
4 $
%XLOGLQJV ± )XWXUH HQHUJ\ LQWHQVLW\
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
' , <5;(- '(&' 65& 5& 5/ ,//?9(. &*,& - ,;(',<( D 6 &*( *(,&5-< -((./
) ?+. >( ,>,&(. >8 LQVXODWLQJ ZDOOV URRIV DQG JURXQG IORRUV '(A+,)5-< +. :5-. :/ :5&* KLJKO\ HQHUJ\ HIILFLHQW ZLQGRZV ,-. >8 5-/&,++5-< YHQWLODWLRQ V\VWHPV ZLWK KHDW UHFRYHU\ 9()*,-5/9/ B?,'&(' 6 &*( '(9,5-5-< *(,&5-< ,-. * & :,&(' -((. : ?+. >( 9(& >8 ORFDO VRODU WKHUPDO V\VWHPV &*( '(/& >8 KHDW SXPSV " &RROLQJ :5++ >( A' ;5.(. >8 ORFDO UHQHZDEOH / +?&5 -/ :*('( A //5>+( 2/(( # 3
-)'(,/(. HOHFWULFLW\ -((./ A(' 6+ ' ,'(, .?( & 5-)'(,/(. ) +5-< .(9,-. 5-)'(,/(. ,AA+5,-)(/ ?/( 2A(' ,'(,3 ,-. *(,& A?9A A :('5-< *,;( ,+/ >((- (/&59,&(.
1HZ VWRFN *( )(-,'5 ,//?9(/ &*,& -(: >?5+.5-</ :5++ 5-)'(,/5-<+8 >( >?5+& & , QHDU ]HUR HQHUJ\ XVH /&,-.,'. $ '(,)*5-< , A(-(&',&5 - 6 D 6 -(: >?5+.5-</ >8
4 *(/( ,'( *5<*+8 (-('<8 (665)5(-& >?5+.5-</ .?( & ;('8 + : + //(/ &*' ?<* &*( >?5+.5-< (-;(+ A( 25-/?+,&5 - ,-. 59A' ;(. :5-. :/3 ,-. ,+9 /& - + //(/ 6' 9 ,5' ( )*,-<( 2?/( 6 *(,& '() ;('8 /8/&(9/3
*( '(/5.?,+ *(,& .(9,-. 5/ ) ;('(. >8 SDVVLYH VRODU 25'',.5,&5 - &*' ?<* :5-. :/3 ,-. 5-&('-,+ 2A( A+( ,AA+5,-)(/3 JDLQV '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 /8/&(9/ 5- &*( 6 '9 6 VRODU WKHUPDO 5-/&,++,&5 -/ ,-. KHDW SXPSV - ) 9A,'5/ - & , -(: >?5+.5-< 6 & .,8 &*5/ >?5+.5-< &8A( '(B?5'(/ - 6?(+ /?AA+8 6 ,-8 C5-. 5 ( 5& 5/ ,- DOO HOHFWULF >?5+.5-<
*( -(,' R(' #(-('<8 ) -)(A& :5++ ,+/ >( ,AA+5(. & :,'9E* & )+59,&(/ 6&(- '(;5;5-< &',.5&5 -,+ >?5+.5-< ,AA' ,)*(/ *(/( 5-)+?.( H[WHUQDO VKDGLQJ GHYLFHV
" &*(' &()*- + <5(/ /?)* ,/ : . A(++(& ;(-/ 9,8 *,;( , ' +( & A+,8 5- -5)*( 9,'C(&/ ' ,/ , >'5.<5-< &()*- + <8 >?& *,;( - & >((- 5-)+?.(. 5- &*5/ )(-,'5 :*5)* (9A*,/5/(/ &*( ?/( 6 *(,& A?9A/ '?- - '(-(:,>+( (+()&'5)5&8 $
8 V-(,'#R(' (-('<8 ?/(L :( 9(,- >?5+.5-</ :*5)* *,;( ,- (-('<8 ?/( ,& +(;(+/ ) 9A,',>+( & &*( A,//5;( * ?/( /&,-.,'. .(;(+ A(. 5- ('9,-8
P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&?A
,-. ,- A&59,+ YHQWLODWLRQ VWUDWHJ\ 2*5<* ( )*,-<( ',&(/ ,& -5<*& +(// .?'5-< &*( .,83 O /(( ,+/ #
-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 A(' 6+ ' ,'(, 2'(+,&5;( & 4 $3
*('( :5++ >( '(9,5-5-< ) +5-< .(9,-. 5- &*(/( '(<5 -/ (/A()5,++8 5- - -# '(/5.(-&5,+ >?5+.5-</ :5&* *5<* 5-&('-,+ + ,./ 6' 9 ) 9A?&('/ 2 665)(/3 ' +5<*&5-< 2'(&,5+3 ,QFUHDVHG HOHFWULFLW\ QHHGV 6' 9 5-)'(,/(. ) +5-< ,-. ,AA+5,-)(/ ,/ :(++ ,/ &*( ?/( 6 *(,& A?9A/ *,/ >((- (/&59,&(. ,-. 5-)+?.(. 5- &*5/ )(-,'5 2/(( ,> ;(3
D
(/5.(-&5,+ # +()&'5)5&8
" D 4 D
(/5.(-&5,+ # (,&
D ! D
99(')5,+ # +()&'5)5&8
D " D
99(')5,+ # (,&
4 D D 4
5<?'( #
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
; +?&5 - 6 (-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 5- &*( ?5+.5-</ /()& '
*( '(/?+&5-< ;(',++ (; +?&5 - 5- (-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 5/ /* :- 5- 5<?'( # *( .',/&5),++8 '(.?)(. *(,& .(9,-. ),- >( >/(';(. ,/ :(++ ,/ , W$ D 5-)'(,/( 5- (+()&'5)5&8 .(9,-. A(' ?-5& 6+ ' ,'(, - ,;(',<( *5/ 5/ .?( & 5-)'(,/(. (+()&'5)5&8 .(9,-. 6' 9 *(,& A?9A A(',&5 - ,/ :(++ ,/ ,- ,//?9A&5 - - 5-)'(,/(. ?/( 6 ,AA+5,-)(/ +5<*&5-< ,-. ) +5-< :*5)* ),- -+8 >( A,'&5,++8 66/(& >8 (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-&/
&(0 (,& /* :- 5- &*5/ <',A* 5/ ,++ *(,& &*,& 5/ - & /?AA+5(. >8 *(,& A?9A/ ' / +,' &*('9,+ A&5 -/ +()&'5)5&8 .(9,-. 6 ' *(,& A?9A/ 5/ 5-)+?.(. 5- &*( (+()&'5)5&8 +5-( 2,/ :(++ ,/ (+()&'5)5&8 6 ' +5<*&5-< ,-. ,AA+5,-)(/3
! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &?,
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
# 4
& '80 (&' 65& ',&(/ 5- ?5+.5-</
6725<
%8,/',1* 5(752),7 5$7(6
*5/ )(-,'5 ,//?9(/ &*,& '(&' 65& ',&(/ :5++ '5/( 6' 9 &*(5' )?''(-& +(;(+/ & '(,)* 4O D >8 W4 4 & ,++ : 6?++ '(&' 65& 6 ,++ ( 5/&5-< >?5+.5-< /& )C >8 ' >(6 '( 4 $
*5/ 9,8 /((9 +5C( , )*,++(-<5-< ,9>5&5 - <5;(- )?''(-& '(&' 65& +(;(+/ 5- 9,-8 A,'&/ 6 &*( : '+. :(;(' &*5/ : ?+. - & &*( 65'/& &59( /?)* *5<* '(&' 65& +(;(+/ *,;( >((- ,)*5(;(. )) '.5-< & &*( ('9,- 4 >?5+.5-</ '(A '& T ; 4 U &*( '(6?'>5/*9(-& ',&( 5- ('9,-8 5- 4 :,/ ,AA' 59,&(+8 4 4D ,-. ,)) '.5-< & &*( -,&5 -,+ (-('<8 (665)5(-)8 ,)&5 - A+,- T ; 4 PU &*( ('9,- < ;('-9(-& /(& , '(6?'>5/*9(-& ',&( &,'<(& 6 4 D 6 ' 4 5- ,)) '.,-)( :5&* &*( )?''(-& A +5)8 .5'()&5 - ,& ?' A(,- +(;(+
%XLOGLQJV ± )XWXUH HQHUJ\ GHPDQG (/A5&( &*( /&' -< 5-)'(,/( 5- ,)&5;5&8 5 ( 6+ ' /A,)( &*( (-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 '(.?)&5 -/ .(&,5+(. ,> ;( +(,. & , .',/&5),++8 '(.?)(. -((. 6 ' >?5+.5-< *(,& 5- &*( 6 '9 6 6?(+/ ' *(,& .(+5;('(. .5'()&+8 & >?5+.5-</ & &*( /,9( &59( ,- 5-)'(,/( 5- (+()&'5)5&8 ?/( 5/ ( A()&(. *(/( '(/?+&/ ,'( /* :- 5- 5<?'( # 4 "
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
4 (,& # :
! "
+()&'5)5&8
4 4 5<?'( # 4
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ ;(',++ (-('<8 ?/( 5- &*( ?5+.5-</ /()& ' >8 (-('<8 ),''5(' &8A(
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&?+
#
&$6( 678'<
,/( /&?.80 ?5+.5-< ) +5-< .(9,-. 5- 9(.5&('',-(,- ) ?-&'5(/
%8,/',1* &22/,1* '(0$1' ,1 0(',7(55$1($1 &28175,(6
# A' =()& 4 PE ! X -('<8 665)5(-)8 5- &*( -/&'?)&5 - ()& ' 5- &*( (.5&('',-(,-Y 2::: 9(.#(-() ) 93
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
*( +,'<(/& A &(-&5,+ 6 ' 59A' ;(9(-& ( 5/&/ 5- ?'>,- ,'(,/ ,-. &*( '(.?)&5 - 6 &*( ) +5-< .(9,-. '(B?5'(/ , * +5/&5) ,AA' ,)* & 5-&(<',&( .(9,-. /5.( 9,-,<(9(-& ,-. (-('<8 (665)5(-)8 5- &*( A+,--5-< A' )(// 6 >?5+.5-</
*( # A' =()& 6 ++ :/ , /?/&,5-,>+( >?/5-(// ,AA' ,)* :*5)* 5-) 'A ',&(/ .(9 -/&',&5 - A' =()&/ ,-. ),A,)5&8 >?5+.5-< 5-& -( 5-&(<',&(. (66 '& *( A' =()& 6 )?/(/ - /&'(-<&*(-5-< >?/5-(// /(';5)(/ ,-. /?AA '&5-< 9,'C(&/ 59A' ;5-< 5-/&5&?&5 -,+ ),A,)5&5(/ ,-. (/&,>+5/*5-< 6,; ?',>+( 5-/&5&?&5 -,+ /&'?)&?'(/ ,/ :(++ ,/ 65/),+ ,-. () - 95) 5-/&'?9(-&/
*( A' =()& 5-)+?.(/ A5+ & >?5+.5-< A' =()&/ 5- &(- ) ?-&'5(/0 *(/( :('( '(,+5/(. ?-.(' + ),+ ) -.5&5 -/ :5&* + ),+ (-&'(A'(-(?'/ ,-. ,)*5(;(. ?&/&,-.5-< '(/?+&/0 x
*'(( -,&5 -,+ -('<8 + >( :,'./
x
++ :#?A ,)&5;5&5(/ 5- &*( ) ?-&'5(/
x
;(',++ /,;5-</ 6 &E, ' "$ & ;(' +56(&59(
x
5<* A &(-&5,+ 6 ' +,'<( /),+( 59A+(9(-&,&5 -
" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &;'
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
7UDQVSRUW
7UDQVSRUW ± 'HILQLWLRQV )&5;5&8 5- &*( &',-/A '& /()& ' 5/ ) 99 -+8 <5;(- 5- A('/ -#C9 2AC93 6 ' A,//(-<(' &',-/A '& ,-. & --(#C9 2&C93 6 ' 6'(5<*& &',-/A '&
*( &',-/A '& /()& ' 5/ &*?/ .566('(-&5,&(. 5-& A,//(-<(' ,-. 6'(5<*& 9 .(/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 *( .(&,5+(. .(65-5&5 -/ ,'( <5;(- 5- ,>+( #
,>+( #
',-/A '& /()& ' .(65-5&5 -/
7UDQVSRUW PRGH
7UDQVSRUW PRGH
,($ GHILQLWLRQ
6FHQDULR GHILQLWLRQ
,.
# / P
,.
# ,' 5&8
,.
# ,' - -# 5&8
,.
# ?/1 ,)*
,5+
# ,5+
;5,&5 -
# +,-(
,.
# '?)C
,5+
# ,5+
;5,&5 -
# +,-(
9(/&5) -,;5<,&5 - 1 '+. ,'5-( ?-C('/
# *5A
7UDQVSRUW ± )XWXUH DFWLYLW\
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
" : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&;&
*( )(-,'5 &*('(6 '( ,//?9(/ /?>/&,-&5,+ 9 .,+ /*56&/ ,:,8 6' 9 5-(665)5(-& 5-.5;5.?,+ ' ,. ,-. ,;5,&5 - 9 .(/ ,-. & :,'./ &*( 9 '( (665)5(-& ',5+ ,-. /*,'(. ' ,. 9 .(/ ,QGH[HG DEVROXWH DFWLYLW\ OHYHOV
)&5;5&8 25-.( (. - 4 $3
D
',-/A '& - -# 4 D
',-/A '&
D
D 4 5<?'( #
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
-.( (. (; +?&5 - 6 ,)&5;5&8 5- &*( ',-/A '& /()& '
*( '(/?+&5-< 9?)* .()'(,/(. <' :&* 6 : '+.:5.( ),' &',665) 2'(/?+&5-< 6' 9 ,- 5-)'(,/( 5- - -# '(<5 -/ ,-. , /&,>5+5/,&5 - ' .()'(,/( 5- '(<5 -/3 5/ ) ?A+(. :5&* , +,'<( 5-)'(,/( 5- /*,'(. &',;(+ 9 .(/ (/A()5,++8 ',5+ &',;(+
*( 9 .,+ /*56& (;(- '(/?+&/ 5- , 9 .(/& ;(',++ '(.?)&5 - 5- ( &('-,++8 A :('(. A,//(-<(' &',;(+ ; +?9(/ 6 '(),/& 6 ' 4 $ A'59,'5+8 &*' ?<*0 x , /*56& 6' 9 ),' &',;(+ & *?9,-#A :('(. &',;(+ /?)* ,/ :,+C5-< ,-. )8)+5-< ! ,-. x
, /*56& 6' 9 2>?/5-(//3 ,;5,&5 - &',;(+ & ,+&('-,&5;(/ /?)* ,/ ;5.( ) -6('(-)5-<
& /* ?+. >( - &(. &*,& &*5/ )*,-<( 6 &',;(+ A,&&('- ,:,8 6' 9 5-.5;5.?,+ ),' &',-/A '& ,-. & :,'./ 9 '( (665)5(-& 9 .(/ '(B?5'(/ ,- ,AA' ,)* & +,-. ?/( A+,--5-< :*5)* 9,C(/ *5<*#) ;(',<( 9,//#&',-/5& /8/&(9/ A //5>+( ,-. () + <5),++8 ,-. () - 95),++8 /?/&,5-,>+( +&* ?<* &*( 9 .,+ /*56& ,//?9A&5 -/ 9,8 >( ) -/5.('(. ,9>5&5 ?/ &*(8 ) ?+. 5- &*( '8 >( A?/*(. (;(- 6?'&*('
!
&( &*,& &*( .5/&,-)(/ 5-; +;(. 5- &*( 9 .,+ /*56& & :,+C5-< ,-. )8)+5-< ,'( /* '& / &*( ;(',++ A('/ -#C9 ; +?9( /*56&(. 5/ /9,++
5.( ) -6('(-)5-< :5++ 9,5-+8 .5/A+,)( , /*,'( 6 >?/5-(// &',;(+ :*5)* '(A'(/(-&/ &*( 95- '5&8 6 A,//(-<(' ,5' &',;(+ T 4 U
"4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &;?
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
"$ "
$
',-/A '& 2&- AC9 ' &C93
',-/A '& 2&- AC9 ' &C93
$ QRQ 2(&'
$ 4$ 4 $ $
2(&'
4$ 4 $ $
4
5<?'( # "
4 $
4 $ )(-,'5
4
4 $
4 $ )(-,'5
.,+ /*56& 6 ' A,//(-<(' &',-/A '&
' 6'(5<*& ; +?9( :,/ /*56&(. 6' 9 ,;5,&5 - ,-. &'?)C 9 .(/ & :,'./ ',5+4 +&* ?<* , '(.?)&5 - 6 ;(',++ 6'(5<*& ; +?9(/ 9,8 >( .(/5',>+( 5- , 9 '( + ),+5/(. () - 98 9 .(+ &*5/ A&5 - :,/ - & ) -/5.('(. *('( 6 ' +,)C 6 , B?,-&5&,&5;( >,/5/ 6 ' /?)* ,//?9A&5 -/ &( &*,& &*( 5-)'(,/( 5- ',5+ ),A,)5&8 -((.(. & /?/&,5- &*( 5-)'(,/( 5- > &* A,//(-<(' &',;(+ ,-. 6'(5<*& &',665) 5/ ;('8 +,'<( & ),- >( ,'<?(. &*,& 5- &*( , /595+,' 5-)'(,/( 5- ' ,. &',665) : ?+. *,;( >((- '(B?5'(. >?& &*( )*,++(-<( 6 ,//?'5-< , *5<*#),A,)5&8 ,-. :(++#9,-,<(. ',5+ -(&: 'C /* ?+. - & >( ?-.('(/&59,&(.
4$
4
',-/A '& 2&- AC9 ' &C93
',-/A '& 2&- AC9 ' &C93
QRQ 2(&'
4 $ $
2(&'
" 4 ! " 4
4
5<?'( # $
!
4 $
4 $ )(-,'5
4
4 $
4 $ )(-,'5
.,+ /*56& 6 ' 6'(5<*& &',-/A '&
4 &( &*,& .?( & .,&, ,;,5+,>5+5&8 + -<#&('9 (-('<8 ?/( 6 ' 6'(5<*& >8 /*5A :,/ - & 9 .(++(. >,/(. - ,)&5;5&8 >?& >,/(. - 6 '(),/&/ ,C5- & &*( V L ,-. V L /()& ' ,AA' ,)* 5- -.?/&'8
" : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&;;
7UDQVSRUW ± )XWXUH HQHUJ\ LQWHQVLW\
*( /&(A/ >(+ : ,'( 6 ++ :(. & (-/?'( &*,& &*( )(-,'5 (9A+ 8/ &*( 9 /& (665)5(-& &',-/A '& 9 .(/ :5&* &*( *5<*(/& +5C(+5* . 6 , '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 /?AA+80 ;5-< & (665)5(-& &()*- + <5(/ ,-. 9 .(/ 6 (9A+ 89(-& ( < &'?)C/ :5&* '(.?)(. .',< 59A' ;(. ,5' &',665) 9,-,<(9(-& ' '(.?)(. 6?(+ -((./ 5- *8>'5. >?/(/ +()&'5685-< &*( 9 .( ,/ 6,' ,/ A //5>+( ( < (+()&'5) ),'/ 5- ?'>,- (-;5' -9(-&/ ,-. (+()&'5) ',5+ /8/&(9/ / , +,/& /&(A A' ;5.5-< &*( 6?(+ 6' 9 /?/&,5-,>+( >5 9,// :*('( A //5>+( 2/(( ()&5 - $3
,>+( # " /?99,'5/(/ &*( 6?(+ /*56& ,//?9A&5 -/ &*,& ),+)?+,&5 -/ :5&*5- &*( )(-,'5 ,'( >,/(. ?A - *( 9 /& - &(: '&*8 ,//?9A&5 -/ ,'(0 x x
x
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
# "
& '80 ,&('5,+ -((./ 6 ' >,&&('5(/
6725<
0$7(5,$/ 1(('6 )25 %$77(5,(6
*( (+()&'565),&5 - 6 &*( &',-/A '& /()& ' 6 '(/((/ , :* +(/,+( /*56& & (+()&'5) ;(*5)+(/ ,-. A+?<#5- *8>'5./ 6 ' ,++ ),'/ >?/(/ ,-. W D 6 &'?)C/E.(+5;('8 ;(*5)+(/ *5/ +,'<( ; +?9( 6 (+()&'5),++8 (-,>+(. ;(*5)+(/ :5++ '(B?5'( , ) -) 95&,-& A' .?)&5 - 6 >,&&('5(/K , &8A5),+ (+()&'5),+ ;(*5)+( :5&* , $ C9 ',-<( : ?+. '(B?5'( , >,&&('8 :(5<*5-< ?A & , B?,'&(' & --(
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
"" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &;-
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
,>+( # "
665)5(-)8 ,-. 6?(+ /*56& ,//?9A&5 -/ 6 ' ,++ &',-/A '& 9 .(/
0RGH
(IILFLHQF\ JDLQV YV
# /
$ D
# ,' 5&8
P$D
# ,'
24 0 !O +E C9
- -# 5&8
4 $ 0 4O +E C93
# ?/1 ,)* # ,5+
$ D O $D D
(OHFWUL
&RPPHQWV
ILFDWLRQ
" D O D44 D P D $ D O P D
( < /) &('/ D 5 ( 9 /& &',-/A '& . -( >8 (+()&'5) ;(*5)+(/ ' - (+()&'5) A '&5 - 6 A+?<#5- *8>'5. ;(*5)+(/ 8>'5./ E (+()&'5) (/A()5,++8 5- )5&5(/
$D O
*56& & 6?++8 (+()&'565(. ',5+ '(/5/&,-)(
D
'(.?)&5 - /A,)( A&595/,&5 9A' ;(9(-&/ 5- ,5'6',9( ,-. (-<5-(
# +,-(
W$ D
-E,
.(/5<- <,5-/ 6' 9 ,5' &',665) 9,-,<(9(-& A&595/,&5 - T 4 U
# '?)C
$D
# ,5+
D
# +,-(
W$ D
D $D O D -E,
V+,/&#95+(L .(+5;('8 ;,-/ (+()&'5) *56& & 6?++8 (+()&'565(. ',5+ T/(( A,//(-<(' A+,-( &',;(+ ,> ;(U ' A(++(' ,-. *?++ 9,5-&(-,-)( ,-.
-( # *5A
W$ D
?A<',.(/ '(&' 65&/ 5-)+?.5-< & :5-<
T>?& W$D
C5&( A(',&5 -,+ 59A' ;(9(-&/
2 43 6' 9
5-)+?.5-< /A((. '(.?)&5 -K /9,++
(+()&'5)5&8U
/*,'( 6 *8.' <(- 6?(+ 5- /*5A/ T 4 U
*( '(/?+&5-< ;(',++ (; +?&5 - 6 (-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 5- &*( &',-/A '& /()& ' .566('(-&5,&(. >8 6?(+ ,-. (+()&'5)5&8 ?/( 5/ /* :- 5- 5<?'( # &( &*,& &*( /*,'( 6 (+()&'5)5&8 + C/ '(+,&5;(+8 /9,++ 5- ) 9A,'5/ - & &*( 6?(+/ >(),?/( &*(/( /&5++ -((. & ?-.('< ) -;('/5 - ,& , ) 9A,',&5;(+8 + :(' (665)5(-)8 & <(-(',&( 9()*,-5),+ (-('<8 6 ' &*( :*((+/
4 *('( , /*56& &,C(/ A+,)( 6' 9 6?(+ & (+()&'5)5&8 5& 5/ ,//?9(. &*,& &*( (+()&'5),++8 A :('(. ;(*5)+( :5++ -((. $O4 $ &59(/ +(// 65-,+ (-('<8 - ,;(',<( /5-)( &*( (-('<8 5/ .(+5;('(. & &*( ;(*5)+( 5- ,- ,+'(,.8 ) -;('&(. 6 '9 44 :(' (-. 6 ',-<( ?/(. 6 ' '(<5 -/ :*('( 9 & ')8)+(/ ,'( &*( - '9 *5<*(' (-. 6 ',-<( 6 ' - -# :*('( ,'( ,//?9(. & 5-)+?.( , 9?)* *5<*(' 6',)&5 - 6 (+()&'5) /) &('/
"$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&;#
,//<' # ?(+
" 4
,//<' # +()
!
'(5<*& # ?(+
" 4
4 5<?'( #
4
4 4
4
4 "
,//<'
'(5<*&
,//<'
'(5<*&
,//<'
'(5<*&
,//<'
'(5<*&
,//<'
'(5<*&
,//<'
'(5<*&
-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 2 G E AC9 ' G E &C93
!
'(5<*& # +()
4 $
; +?&5 - 6 (-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 5- &*( ',-/A '& /()& '
7UDQVSRUW ± )XWXUH HQHUJ\ GHPDQG
*( ,//?9A&5 -/ - ,)&5;5&8 (; +?&5 - :5&* 9 .,+ /*56& ,-. - (-('<8 5-&(-/5&8 (; +?&5 - :5&* 6?(+ /*56& +(,. & &*( ;(',++ (-('<8 .(9,-. (; +?&5 - 5- &*( &',-/A '& /()& ' /* :- 5- 5<?'( # P 4 ?(+ # ;5,&5 -
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
! ?(+ # *5AA5-<
"
?(+ # ,.E ,5+
4 +()&'5)5&8 4 5<?'( # P
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ ;(',++ (-('<8 ?/( 5- &*( ',-/A '& /()& ' >8 (-('<8 ),''5(' &8A(
*( ,9>5&5 ?/ ,//?9A&5 -/ - (-('<8 (665)5(-)8 ,-. (+()&'565),&5 - +(,. & , ) -&',)&5 - 6 (-('<8 .(9,-. 5- &*( &',-/A '& /()& ' .(/A5&( , /&' -< 5-)'(,/( 5- ?-.('+85-< ,)&5;5&8 *(- 5-&('A'(&5-< 5<?'( # P 5& 5/ 59A '&,-& & '(9(9>(' &*,&
" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &;7
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
,/ .(9,-. 5/ /* :- 5- 65-,+ (-('<8 DV GHILQHG LQ WKH ,($ HQHUJ\ EDODQFHV &*( /*,'( 6 (+()&'5)5&8 5- &',-/A '& + C/ /9,++ (;(- &* ?<* 6 ' 9,-8 9 .(/ 5& .(+5;('/ &*( ;,/& 9,= '5&8 6 9()*,-5),+ (-('<8 & &*( :*((+/ *5/ 5/ >(),?/( &*( 6?(+/ /&5++ ?-.('< ) -;('/5 - 5- &*( ;(*5)+(L/ ) 9>?/&5 - (-<5-( ,-. &*('(6 '( '(A'(/(-& , *5<*(' (-('<8 ) -&(-& 2/(( ,+/ 6 &- &( 43 &( &*,& , /9,++ /*,'( 6 &*( /*5AA5-< 6?(+ .(9,-. /* :- 5- 5<?'( # P *,/ >((- ,//?9(. & >( A' ;5.(. >8 *8.' <(- 6?(+ /(( ,+/ " # # $
-&5-<(-)80 '(5<*& &',-/A '&
&217,1*(1&<
)5(,*+7 75$163257
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x
;( & , 9 '( + ),+5/(. () - 98
A' A '&5 - 6 & .,8Q/ 6'(5<*& &',-/A '& 5/ ?/(. & 9 ;( < ./ >(&:((- + ),&5 -/ :*5)* ) ?+. >( > &* A' .?)('/ ,-. ) -/?9('/ 6 &*,& A' .?)& '(-.('5-< &*( 6'(5<*& B?(/&5 -,>+( 6' 9 ,- (-('<8 A 5-& 6 ;5(: - ( ,9A+( 6 &*5/ 5/ &*( /*5AA5-< 6 ,<'5)?+&?',+ ) 99 .5&5(/ 6' 9 -( '(<5 - 6 &*( : '+. & ,- &*(' :*5)* ) ?+. A' .?)( &*( /,9( ) 99 .5&8 + ),++8 q?,-&5685-< &*5/ (66()& 5/ ?& 6 /) A( 6 &*5/ /&?.8 >?& 5& /* ?+. >( - &(. &*,& '(.?)&5 - 6 &*(/( 6'(5<*& ; +?9(/ '(A'(/(-&/ , ) -&5-<(-)8 AA '&?-5&8 6 ' '(.?)5-< (-('<8 .(9,-. 6 ' ' ,. ,5' ,-. /(, 6'(5<*& x
/( 6 *8.' <(- 5- + -<#.5/&,-)( &'?)C5-<
/ ( A+,5-(. 5- " # *8.' <(- 6?(+ :,/ ,//?9(. & >( ?-,;,5+,>+( 6 ' + -<#.5/&,-)( &'?)C5-< :5&*5- &*( &59( 6',9( 6 &*5/ /&?.8 :(;(' ,- &*(' A,&*:,8 ) ?+. >( ) -)(5;(. & , /?/&,5-,>+( &',-/A '& /()& ' :*('( /A()5,+ ,&&(-&5 - : ?+. >( <5;(- & &*( (/&,>+5/*9(-& 6 , /?5&,>+( *8.' <(- 6?(+ )*,'<5-< -(&: 'C &*,& : ?+. ,++ : 5&/ ?/( 5- + -<#.5/&,-)( 6'(5<*& - /?)* , /)(-,'5 6?(+ .(9,-. 6' 9 6 //5+ 6?(+/ ' >5 6?(+/ 6 ' ' ,. 6'(5<*& ) ?+. &*( '(&5),++8 >( /5<-565),-&+8 '(.?)(.
"P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&;A
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &;,
6XSSO\ ± 5HQHZDEOH HQHUJ\ H[FO ELRHQHUJ\
2YHUDOO UHVXOWV
*( ,//?9A&5 -/ .(&,5+(. 5- ()&5 - 6 ' &*( .(9,-. /5.( +(,. & 0 x x
9?)* '(.?)(. .(9,-. ;(',++ ) 9A,'(. & V>?/5-(//#,/#?/?,+L 2 3 *5<*(' (+()&'565),&5 - ',&(
*( '(/?+&5-< ;(',++ .(9,-. /A+5& 5/ A'(/(-&(. 5- 5<?'( " # &( 5- A,'&5)?+,' &*,& &*( .(9,-. 6 ' A :(' '5/(/ /&(,.5+8 6' 9 =?/& >(+ : GE, & ;(' 4 GE, - ) -&',/& *(,& ,-. 6?(+ .(9,-. <' : ,& 65'/& >(6 '( '(.?)5-< .',/&5),++8 5- +,&(' 8(,'/4 - &*( -( & /&(A &*5/ .(9,-. 9?/& >( 9,&)*(. :5&* (-('<8 /?AA+8 - ,)) '.,-)( :5&* &*( ,AA' ,)* 2/(( ()&5 - 43 &*5/ 5/ . -( 5- &*( 6 ++ :5-< '.('0
*('( ,;,5+,>+( - -#>5 (-('<8 '(-(:,>+( A&5 -/ ,'( ?/(. 65'/& 6 .(9,-. ),-- & >( 6?++8 /,&5/65(. >5 (-('<8 5/ ?/(. ?A & &*( /?/&,5-,>+8 ,;,5+,>+( A &(-&5,+ 5- &*,& 8(,' 2/(( ()&5 - $3
++ '(/5.?,+ .(9,-. 5/ /?AA+5(. >8 ) -;(-&5 -,+ / ?')( /?)* ,/ 6 //5+ ,-. -?)+(,' (-('<8 "
?(+ # - (A+,) //
$
?(+ # -.?/&'8
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
?(+ # ;5,&5 4$ ?(+ # *5AA5-< 4 ?(+ # ,.E ,5+ $ (,& # :
(,& # 5<*
$ +()&'5)5&8 4
5<?'( " #
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ (-('<8 .(9,-. 5- ,++ /()& '/ /A+5& >8 (-('<8 ),''5('
4 &( &*,& &*( /*,'( 6 (+()&'5)5&8 + C/ /9,++ 5- ) 9A,'5/ - & ( < &',-/A '& 6?(+/ /5-)( &*(/( /&5++ *,;( & ?-.('< ) -;('/5 - ,& , ) 9A,',&5;(+8 + :(' (665)5(-)8 & <(-(',&( 9()*,-5),+ (-('<8 6 ' &*( :*((+/
" : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&;+
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
" $
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
4$ 4 $ $ 4 5<?'( " # 4
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ (-('<8 /?AA+8 5- &*( )(-,'5 /A+5& >8 / ?')( 2M 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ 5-)+?.( &*( /?/&,5-,>+( /*,'( 6 &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// ?/( 4$3
- &*( 6 ++ :5-< /()&5 -/ &*(/( '(/?+&/ :5++ >( .5/)?//(. 5- <'(,&(' .(&,5+ 6 ' (,)* 6 &*( .(9,-. /()& '/ A'()(.(. >8 , A'(/(-&,&5 - 6 &*( .(&,5+(. ,//?9(. '(-(:,>+( A &(-&5,+/ A()5,+ ,&&(-&5 - :5++ >( <5;(- & &*( ) 9A+( /?>=()& 6 >5 (-('<8 5- ()&5 - $
4"
*( '(,.(' 5/ '(95-.(. &*,& >(),?/( &*5/ <',A* A'(/(-&/ 65-,+ (-('<8 &*( /*,'( 6 6?(+/ ( < 6' 9 6 //5+ ' >5 (-('<8 + C/ +,'<( 5- ) 9A,'5/ - & &*( (+()&'5)5&8 ,-. *(,& A&5 -/ 4$ '5<5-,+ / ?')(/ ,'( - & ( A+5)5& - &*( ) 9A /5&5 - 6 &*( &',.5&5 -,+ ?/( 6 >5 9,// & *,/ >((- <' ?A(. :5&* ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ *('( ,/ :( ( A()& , +,'<( /*,'( 6 5& & >( 6 '(/&#/ ?')(. (/A()5,++8 5- +,&(' 8(,'/
$ 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &-'
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
" #
6725<
& '80 *( ' +( 6 *8.' <(- 6?(+ 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5
7+( 52/( 2) +<'52*(1 )8(/ ,1 7+( (1(5*< 6&(1$5,2
8.' <(- 6?(+ A'(/(-&/ , -?9>(' 6 EHQHILWV :*5)* ,++ : 5& & A+,8 , >'5.<5-< ' +( 5- &*5/ )(-,'5 0 x
& 5/ , 6?(+ ,-. ) ?+. &*('(6 '( +5<*&(- &*( .(9,-. 6 ' '(-(:,>+( 6?(+/ ,-.E ' *5<* &(9A(',&?'( *(,& 6 ' :*5)* -+8 ;('8 6(: /?/&,5-,>+( A&5 -/ ( 5/&
x
& ),- >( 6?++8 /?/&,5-,>+( ( < 56 <(-(',&(. ;5, (+()&' +8/5/ 6' 9 '(-(:,>+( A :(' / ?')(/
x
6 <(-(',&(. 6' 9 '(-(:,>+( / ?')(/ 5- &*5/ :,8 5& ),- ,+/ 6?-)&5 - ,/ , /& ',<( 9(.5?9 6 ' '(-(:,>+( A :(' 5 ( /& '5-< (+()&'5)5&8 <(-(',&(. >8 &*( /?AA+8#.'5;(- A :(' / ?')(/ 5- &59(/ 6 ;('A' .?)&5 -
- ,..5&5 - & &*(/( >(-(65&/ * :(;(' , 6(: FKDOOHQJHV . ( 5/&0 x
*('( 5/ - ( 5/&5-< &',-/A '& -(&: 'C 6 ' *8.' <(- 6?(+ *5/ : ?+. 9(,- &*,& :* +(/,+( 5-/&,++,&5 - 6 , -(: &8A( 6 )*,'<5-< 5-6',/&'?)&?'( : ?+. >( '(B?5'(. & 9,C( *8.' <(- 6?(+ ,;,5+,>+( & .5/&'5>?&(. &',-/A '& ?/('/ /?)* ,/ A,//(-<(' ),'/
x
8.' <(- *,/ , + :(' (-('<8 .(-/5&8 &*,- ) -;(-&5 -,+ 6?(+/ ,-. , + :(' 9,// .(-/5&8 (;(- ,& *5<* A'(//?'(/ 9,C5-< 5& >?+C8 & /& '( ,-. &',-/A '&
x
-;('&5-< (+()&'5)5&8 & *8.' <(- ,-. &*(- >,)C & (+()&'5)5&8 5/ ) -/5.(',>+8 +(// (665)5(-& &*,- ?/5-< &*( '5<5-,+ (+()&'5)5&8 .5'()&+8
' &*( '(,/ -/ ,> ;( &*( )(-,'5 ?/(/ *8.' <(- A'59,'5+8 5- ,AA+5),&5 -/ :*('(0 x
G ?'-(8/ ,'( >(&:((- + ,. )(-&'(/ ' ?/( 5/ .5'()&+8 -(,' A' .?)&5 - /5&(/ / &*,& &*( .(9,-. ) ?+. (,/5+8 >( 5-&(<',&(. :5&* , -(: '(-(:,>+( A :(' -(&: 'C 25 ( - & ?/(. 5- A,//(-<(' &',-/A '& >?& /?5&,>+( 6 ' )(-&',+ 5-.?/&'5,+ 5-/&,++,&5 -/3
x
*( &59( E .5/&,-)( >(&:((- )*,'<5-< /&,&5 -/ 5/ /9,++ 2( < -+8 ?/(. 5- , 6',)&5 - 6 /* '& .5/&,-)( /*5AA5-< ,-. - & ,//?9(. & >( /?5&,>+( 6 ' ' ,. &',-/A '&3
- ,..5&5 - & .5/A+,)5-< 6?(+ ,-. *(,& .(9,-. / 9( *8.' <(- 5/ '(B?5'(. 5- &*( A' .?)&5 - 6 6('&5+5/(' & >&,5- /?/&,5-,>+( -?&'5(-&/ 6 ' &*( A' .?)&5 - 6 >5 9,// 6 ' /?/&,5-,>+( >5 (-('<8 - & &,+ G 6 ,..5&5 -,+ (+()&'5)5&8 .(9,-. 5/ ?/(. 5- 4 $ & x
5/A+,)( W$ G 6 LQGXVWULDO IXHOV DQG KHDW A'59,'5+8 5- )*(95),+ ,+?95-5?9 ,-. )(9(-& A' .?)&5 -
x
5/A+,)( W $ G 6 VKLSSLQJ IXHO
x
?AA+8 $ G 6 (+()&'5)5&8 & A' .?)( IHUWLOLVHU &*' ?<* *8.' <(-
$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&-&
3RWHQWLDOV IRU UHQHZDEOH SRZHU DQG KHDW H[FO ELRHQHUJ\
*( GHSOR\PHQW SRWHQWLDO /* :- 5- &*( <',A*/ 5- &*5/ /()&5 - 5/ &*( A &(-&5,+ - :*5)* &*5/ /&?.8 5/ >,/(. & 5/ &*( A &(-&5,+ :*5)* ),- >( '(,+5/(. ,& ,-8 <5;(- A 5-& 5- &59( <5;(- &()*-5),+ >,''5('/ ,-. ,9>5&5 ?/ 8(& 6(,/5>+( 9,'C(& <' :&* .(;(+ A9(-&/
*( .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ . (/ - & -()(//,'5+8 '(A'(/(-& &*( 9 /& ) /&#(66()&5;( .(;(+ A9(-& 5 ( 5& . (/ - & ,)) ?-& 6 ' 9,'C(& >,''5('/ ' ) 9A(&5&5 - :5&* &*(' / ?')(/ *( UHDOLVDEOH SRWHQWLDO 5/ &*( 6?++8 '(,+5/,>+( A &(-&5,+ 6 &*( '(/ ?')( :5&* , + -<#&('9 .(;(+ A9(-& * '5R - :LQG
*( )(-,'5 5-)+?.(/ A :(' <(-(',&5 - 6' 9 > &* -#/* '( ,-. 66#/* '( :5-. *( <' :&* 6 -#/* '( :5-. A :(' *,/ >((- '(9,'C,>+( 5- &*( +,/& .(),.( :5&* ,--?,+ <' :&* ',&(/ ( )((.5-< 4$D 5- 9 /& 8(,'/ 5;(- &*( /),')5&8 6 +,-. 5- / 9( '(<5 -/ 6 &*( : '+. 5-)'(,/5-< ,&&(-&5 - 5/ <5;(- & 66#/* '( :5-. <(-(',&5 - (;(',+ 66# /* '( :5-. A,'C/ ,'( ,+'(,.8 5- A(',&5 - : '+.:5.( ,-. 9,-8 9 '( ,'( )?''(-&+8 5- A(',&5 - ,-. A+,--5-< A*,/(/ T 4 PK <:5=C 4 !K (?&R 4 K 4 4 K 4 !U
*( )(-,'5 5/ >,/(. - &*( ,//?9A&5 - &*,& &*('( 5/ A &(-&5,+ 6 ' , ) -&5-?5-< /&(,.8 <' :&* 5- :5-. A :(' ;(' &*( -( & &: .(),.(/ :5&* <' :&* +(;(+/ /+ :5-< /5<-565),-&+8 &*('(,6&(' ' 66#/* '( :5-. A &(-&5,+ ,--?,+ <' :&* ',&(/ 6 W D 6 ' -#/* '( :5-. ',&(/ -(,'(' 4 D ,'( ?/(.
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
4$ 5-.0 66/* '(
4 $
5-.0 -/* '(
$ 4
5<?'( " #
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
(,+5/,>+( &(-&5,+
+ >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ 6 :5-. A :(' 2 (6&0 ; +?&5 - 6 .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ;(' &59( '5<*&0 , 59?9 6(,/5>+( A &(-&5,+3
$4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &-?
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
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
*( A &(-&5,+ 6 ' > &* *8.' ,-. :,;(E&5.,+ A :(' / ?')(/ 5/ .(A5)&(. 5- 5<?'( " # " 4$
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
4
8.'
$
,;( N
5.,+
$
4
5<?'( " # "
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
(,+5/,>+( &(-&5,+
+ >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ 6 *8.' ,-. )(,- A :(' 2 (6&0 ; +?&5 - 6 .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ;(' &59( '5<*&0 , 59?9 6(,/5>+( A &(-&5,+3
$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&-;
6XQ
*( +,'<(/& &()*-5),+ A &(-&5,+ ,-. UHDOLVDEOH &()*-5),+ A &(-&5,+ 6 ' /?/&,5-,>+( A :(' ,-. *(,& <(-(',&5 - 5/ 6' 9 .5'()& / +,' (-('<8 A,'&5)?+,'+8 5- '(<5 -/ :5&* , +,'<( ,9 ?-& 6 .5'()& 5'',.5,&5 -
*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5-)+?.(/ 6 ?' .566('(-& / ?')(/ 6 / +,' (-('<80 x +,' A :(' 6' 9 A* & ; +&,5)/ 2 3 x -)(-&',&5-< / +,' A :(' 2 3 x -)(-&',&5-< / +,' *5<*#&(9A(',&?'( *(,& 6 ' 5-.?/&'8 2 3 x T +,' &*('9,+ + :#&(9A(',&?'( *(,& 6 ' >?5+.5-</4 U
*( A &(-&5,+ ,. A&(. 6 ' &*( 65'/& &*'(( / ?')(/ 5/ /* :- 5- 5<?'( " # $ 5/ , :(++#(/&,>+5/*(. / ?')( 6 (+()&'5) (-('<8K ,' ?-. 4 6 ),A,)5&8 5-/&,++(. : '+.:5.( ,& &*( (-. 6 4 T 4 4 U *( )(-,'5 ) -&,5-/ , A &(-&5,+ 6 ' >,/(. - ) -&5-?5-< ,--?,+ <' :&* ',&(/ 6 4$# D 5-)+?.5-< ?&A?&/ 6' 9 > &* >?5+.5-<#5-&(<',&(. ,-. +,'<( ,'(, 5-/&,++,&5 -/ 6 ' &*( -( & &: .(),.(/ T 4 K <:5=C 4 !U 4 !
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
" 4
! "
4 4
5<?'( " # $
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
(,+5/,>+( &(-&5,+
+ >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ 6 / +,' A :(' ,-. *(,& 2( )+ >?5+.5-< / +,' &*('9,+3 2 (6&0 ; +?&5 - 6 .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ;(' &59( '5<*&0 , 59?9 6(,/5>+( A &(-&5,+3
4 +,' &*('9,+ *(,&5-< 6 ' >?5+.5-</ 5/ , :(++#(/&,>+5/*(. &()*- + <8 ,+'(,.8 5- :5.(/A'(,. ?/( - &*5/ )(-,'5 * :(;(' 5& 5/ &'(,&(. - &*( .(9,-. /5.( :5&* , A &(-&5,+ (B?,+ & ,' ?-. D 6 )?''(-& *(,& .(9,-. 5- >?5+.5-</ - 5-.(A(-.(-& A &(-&5,+ <',A* 5/ &*('(6 '( - & '(A' .?)(. *('(
$" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &--
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
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
*( A &(-&5,+ 6 ' <( &*('9,+ (-('<8 5- &*( )(-,'5 5/ /* :- 5- 5<?'( " # ( 0 :
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
$ "
( 0 5<*
4
( 0 +()&'5)5&8
4
5<?'( " #
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
(,+5/,>+( &(-&5,+
+ >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ 6 <( &*('9,+ (-('<8 2 (6&0 ; +?&5 - 6 .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ;(' &59( '5<*&0 , 59?9 6(,/5>+( A &(-&5,+3
4P
*5/ 5/ , ) -/(';,&5;( ,//?9A&5 - ?'&*(' /&?.8 - &*( .5/&'5>?&5 - 6 &*( 5-.?/&'5,+ *(,& .(9,-. ,-. &*( ,;,5+,>5+5&8 6 -(,'#>8 / ?')(/ 5/ '() 99(-.(.
$$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&-#
" # 4
6725<
& '80 *( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 '(-(:,>+( (-('<8
7+( 6867$,1$%,/,7< 2) 5(1(:$%/( (1(5*<
*( -('<8 )(-,'5 )+,//565(/ (-('<8 6' 9 &*( /?- :5-. :,&(' ,-. (,'&* ,/ '(-(:,>+( 5-)+?.5-< >5 9,// & ,59/ & ?/( &*(/( (-('<8 / ?')(/ & .5/A+,)( (-('<8 6' 9 ) -;(-&5 -,+ / ?')(/ /?)* ,/ ) ,+ 5+ <,/ ,-. -?)+(,' A :(' ,/ &*(/( ,'( '(+5,-& - 6?(+/ :*5)* ,'( '(A+(-5/*(. - , ;,/&+8 .566('(-& &59(/),+( &*,- &*,& 6 &*(5' ?/( :(;(' (;(- '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 / ?')(/ 9?/& >( ),'(6?++8 ,//(//(. '(<,'.5-< /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 ,-. 59A,)& - &*( + ),+ (-;5' -9(-& ()&5 - $ 5/ (-&5'(+8 .(.5),&(. & &*( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 >5 (-('<8 >?& &*(' A&5 -/ ,+/ ',5/( ) -)('-/ &*,& -((. & >( ,..'(//(. *( C(8 >=()&5;( 5/ /?/&,5-,>+( +,-./),A( ,-. 5-6',/&'?)&?'( .(;(+ A9(-& A+,--5-< 6 ),'(6?++8 A+,--(. :5&*5- &*( + ),+ ) -&( & '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 ),- >( >(-(65)5,+ :5&* ?& ?-,))(A&,>+( Q/5.( (66()&/Q
5HVXOWV ± (OHFWULFLW\
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
?)+(,' 5+
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
4
,&?',+ <,/ ,+
5 0 ' A/ 5 0 9A (++5-</
!
5 0 (/5.?(/ ( (+()&'5)5&8
8.' A :(' -) / +,'0 :('
"
* & ; +&,5) / +,' ,;( N 5.,+
4
5-.0 66#/* '( 4 5<?'( " # P
5-.0 -#/* '( 4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ A :(' /?AA+8 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5
$ 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &-7
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
5<?'( " # P /* :/ * : 9?)* 6 &*( ,;,5+,>+( '(-(:,>+( A :(' 5/ ,)&?,++8 ?/(. 5- &*( )(-,'5 <5;(- &*( (; +?&5 - 6 A :(' .(9,-. " #
& '80 ?AA+8# ;('/?/ .(9,-.#.'5;(- (+()&'5)5&8 / ?')(/
6725<
6833/< 9(5686 '(0$1' '5,9(1 (/(&75,&,7< 6285&(6
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
- ,..5&5 - & &*( ),'(6?+ >,+,-)5-< 6 .(9,-. ,-. /?AA+8 &*('( 5/ , 6?'&*(' ) -/&',5-& - &*( A :(' /8/&(9 5- &*5/ )(-,'5 0 *( ,9 ?-& 6 /?AA+8#.'5;(-4! A :(' / ?')(/ 5/ ) -/&',5-(. & , )(5+5-< <5;(- 5- , A(')(-&,<( 6 & &,+ (+()&'5)5&8 .(9,-. & '(6+()& &*( 6,)& &*,& , )('&,5- ,9 ?-& 6 >,+,-)5-< ' .(9,-.#.'5;(- / ?')(/ ,'( '(B?5'(. & (-/?'( ) -&5-? ?/ /?AA+8 (( ,>+( " # 6 ' &*( )+,//565),&5 - 6 / ?')(/
?AA+8#.'5;(- A :(' A&5 -/ ,'( &* /( / ?')(/ :* /( <(-(',&5 - ,& ,-8 <5;(- * ?'
4!
.(A(-./ - &*( ,;,5+,>5+5&8 6 &*( (-('<8 / ?')( ( < :5-. A :(' A* & ; +&,5) A :(' ' )(,- A :(' (9,-.#.'5;(- A :(' A&5 -/ ,'( &* /( A&5 -/ :*5)* ),- >( 9 '( (,/5+8 &,5+ '(. & .(9,-. /?)* ,/ <( &*('9,+ (+()&'5)5&8 *8.' A :(' :5&* /& ',<( ,-. (+()&'5)5&8 6' 9 >5 9,//
$P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&-A
(B?5+5>',&( + ,. A,&&('-/ ,-. &*('(6 '( ,++ : ,- 5-)'(,/5-< /*,'( 6 /?AA+8#.'5;(- A :(' 5-& &*( <'5. (+()&'5)5&8 <'5./ /* ?+. >( :(++#) --()&(. :5&*5- , '(<5 - 5;(- &*( )?''(-& /&,&( 6 (+()&'5)5&8 <'5./ 5- 9 /& A,'&/ 6 &*( : '+. &*5/ 9(,-/ , +,'<( 5-;(/&9(-& 5-& &*( ) -/&'?)&5 - ' ( A,-/5 - 6 '(<5 -,+ <'5. ),A,)5&8 &&+(-()C/ 9?/& >( '(9 ;(. & ,++ : ?-*5-.('(. &',-/95//5 - 6 (+()&'5)5&8 >8 x 5-)'(,/5-< ),A,)5&8 ,-. x 5-)'(,/5-< &*( ',-<( 6 &',-/95//5 - +5-(/ (8 -. 4 4 &*('( 9,8 ,+/ >( ,- ,..5&5 -,+ .(9,-. 6 ' &()*- + <5(/ &*,& ),A' ;5.( <'(,&(' <'5. /&,>5+5&8 *( )(-,'5 : 'C/ - &*( A'(95/( &*,& N ( A(-.5&?'( :5++ >( 6 )?//(. - .(;(+ A5-< /?)* &()*- + <5(/ 2/(( ,+/ ()&5 - 3
,>+( " #
+,//565),&5 - 6 A :(' 5-& /?AA+8#.'5;(- ,-. .(9,-.#.'5;(- 2>,+,-)5-<3 A&5 -/
6RXUFH
7\SH
5-. -/* '(
?AA+8#.'5;(-
5-. 66/* '(
?AA+8#.'5;(-
5.,+ N ,;(
?AA+8#.'5;(-
?AA+8#.'5;(-
(9,-.#.'5;(-
(
(9,-.#.'5;(-
8.'
(9,-.#.'5;(-4
5 (+()&'5)5&8
(9,-.#.'5;(-
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
4 8.' A :(' 5/ )+,//(. ,/ .(9,-.#.'5;(- *('( :(;(' < . (-;5' -9(-&,+ A',)&5)(/ /* ?+. 5-)+?.( ,&&(-&5 - & 95-59?9 :,&(' 6+ :/
&( &*,& - ( A+5)5& ,//?9A&5 -/ ,'( 9,.( - (,'+8 '(&5'(9(-& 6 ( 5/&5-< ) ,+#65'(. A :(' A+,-&/ ,& &*( <+ >,+ /),+( :(;(' 6 ' 9 /& '(<5 -/ &*( ,..5&5 -,+ ) -/&'?)&5 - 6 ) ,+#65'(. A :(' A+,-&/ 5/ )+(,'+8 - & ) 9A,&5>+( :5&* &*( .(;(+ A9(-& A,&*:,8 /(& ?& 5- &*5/ )(-,'5
$! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &-,
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
, 59?9 /*,'( 6 A :(' 6' 9 /?AA+8#.'5;(- / ?')(/ 5<?'( " # !
D D ! D P D D $ D " D D 4 D D D 4
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
-/&',5-& A+,)(. - ,-. :5-. A :(' .?( & <'5. +595&/ ,-<( '(A'(/(-&/ .566('(-)(/ ,)' // '(<5 -/
' <'(,&(' A(-(&',&5 -/ 6 '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 -+8 +595&(. ,-,+8/5/ 5/ ,;,5+,>+( ,/(. - , -?9>(' 6 /&?.5(/ T + C !"K v'(-/(- 4 "K ,.9,A 4 U :( ( A()& &*,& &*( +595&5-< /*,'( ) ?+. '5/( & D >8 4 $ 6 ' ,++ '(<5 -/ A' ;5.(. &*,& (+()&'5)5&8 /8/&(9/ ,'( '(#.(/5<-(. & 66(' 9?)* 9 '( 6+( 5>5+5&8 &*,- &*(8 . & .,8
*5/ '(B?5'(/ &*,& 6?++ ?/( 5/ >(5-< 9,.( 6 DOO &*( 6 ++ :5-< +(;('/0 x '5. ),A,)5&8 59A' ;(9(-&/ & '(9 ;( > &&+(-()C/ ,-. 5-)'(,/( &',-/95//5 - ),A,)5&5(/ x (9,-. /5.( 9,-,<(9(-& A,'&5)?+,'+8 6 ' :* +(/,+( )?/& 9('/ >?& ,+/ ,& 5-.5;5.?,+ ) -/?9(' +(;(+ x & ',<( 5- &*( 6 '9 6 A?9A(. *8.' )(-&',+5/(. *8.' <(- /& ',<( ,-. *(,& /& ',<( x (9,5-5-< ( )(//(/ 6 '(-(:,>+( (+()&'5)5&8 ),- >( ) -;('&(. & *8.' <(- 6 ' ?/( ,/ , 6?(+ 5- /A()565) ,AA+5),&5 -/ 2/(( " # 3 & 9?/& >( - &(. *('( &*,& &*( )(-,'5 9('(+8 A+,)(/ &*( +595&/ 9(-&5 -(. ,> ;( - &*( (-('<8 /8/&(9 5- (//(-)( A /&?+,&5-< &*,& A :(' /8/&(9/ :5++ >( ,>+( & (; +;( 5- /?)* , :,8 ,/ & ,++ : &*(/( ,//?9A&5 -/ & >( ;,+5. ,//(// ( ,)&+8 * : &*5/ ) ?+.
-('<8 9,8 >( /& '(. 5- *8.' A :(' '(/('; 5'/ (5&*(' &*' ?<* >,+,-)5-< 6 -,&?',+ 5-6+ :/ :5&* <(-(',&5 -#.(&('95-(. ?&6+ :/ ' &*' ?<* A?9A/ &*,& ?/( (+()&'5)5&8 5- 66#A(,C * ?'/ & '(65++ &*( '(/('; 5' ++ *8.' A :(' 5-6',/&'?)&?'( *,/ A &(-&5,++8 /5<-565),-& (-;5' -9(-&,+ ,-. / )5,+ 59A,)&/ &&(-&5 - 9?/& >( A,5. & . :-/&'(,9 6+ :/ ,/ A(,C5-< A(',&5 -/ ),- 59A,)& - -,&?',+ *,>5&,&/ ,-. *?9,- ?/( 6 '5;('/
*' ?<* /9,'& )* 5)(/ 6 ' + ),&5 -/ .(/5<-/ ,-. A(',&5-< '(<59(/ /?)* 59A,)&/ ),- >( ,; 5.(. 95-595/(. 95&5<,&(. ' ) 9A(-/,&(. 5- ,)) '.,-)( :5&* ( 5/&5-< 5-&('-,&5 -,++8 ,<'((. /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5,
$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&-+
>( ,)*5(;(. ,-. :*5)* ' +( /& ',<( ,-. /9,'& <'5. /8/&(9/ : ?+. A+,8 :,/ >(8 -. &*( /) A( 6 &*5/ /&?.8
*( <'5. ) -/&',5-& ( A+,5-/ :*8 '(-(:,>+( A :(' A&5 -/ ,'( - & 6?++8 ?&5+5/(. (;(- &* ?<* &*( .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ?&/&'5A/ .(9,-. 5<?'( " # /* :/ &*,& +,'<( ) -&5-<(-)5(/ 5- &*( /?AA+8#.'5;(- A :(' /?AA+8 / ?')(/ ,AA(,' ,/ (,'+8 ,/ 4 *( '(,/ - &*(/( A &(-&5,+/ ,'( - & 6?++8 ?&5+5/(. 5/ &*( <'5. ) -/&',5-& 4 5 ( &*( 6,)& &*,& ?' <'5./ :5++ -((. &59( & A'(A,'( 6 ' &*( +,'<( /*,'( 6 /?AA+8#.'5;(- (+()&'5)5&8 / ?')(/
"
'59,'8 (-('<8 2 GE,3
$ 4$
,;( N 5.,+
4 $ 5-.0 66#/* '(
$
5-.0 -#/* '(
&(-&5,+
/(.
4 5<?'( " #
&(-&5,+
/(.
4 "
&(-&5,+
/(.
4 $
+ >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ;/ ,)&?,+ ?/,<( 6 /?AA+8#.'5;(- A :('
;(- 6 ' .(9,-.#.'5;(- A :(' /?AA+8 A&5 -/ &*( 6?++ A &(-&5,+ 5/ - & ?&5+5/(. *5/ 9,8 >( /?'A'5/5-< /5-)( &*('( '(9,5-/ , <,A 5- .(9,-. :*5)* 5/ 65++(. >8 >5 (-('<8
*( '(,/ - 6 ' &*5/ 5/ '(<5 -,+ .566('(-&5,&5 - 5<?'( " # 6 ' ( ,9A+( /* :/ , +,'<( A &(-&5,+ 6 ' 5- +,&(' 8(,'/ :(;(' ,/ 9 /& 6 &*5/ A &(-&5,+ +5(/ 5- '(<5 -/ :5&* , + : (+()&'5)5&8 .(9,-. 5& ),-- & >( 6?++8 ?&5+5/(. 4
&(0 *( -('<8 )(-,'5 ,++ :/ /*,'5-< 6 (+()&'5)5&8 :5&*5- (,)* 6 &*( : '+.L/ &(- '(<5 -/ *,'5-< >(&:((- '(<5 -/ *,/ - & >((- &,C(- 5-& ,)) ?-&K 5- '(,+5&8 &*5/ /* ?+. >( ?/(. & 6?'&*(' A&595/( : '+. A :(' /?AA+8
4
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &#'
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
4 ! 8.'
'59,'8 (-('<8 2 GE,3
" 4
( 0 +()&'5)5&8
! " 4
-) +,'0 :('
&(-&5,+
/(.
4 5<?'( " #
&(-&5,+
/(.
&(-&5,+
4 "
/(.
4 $
+ >,+ .(A+ 89(-& A &(-&5,+ ;/ ,)&?,+ ?/,<( 6 .(9,-.#.'5;(- 2- -#>5 3 A :('
5HVXOWV ± +HDW DQG )XHOV IRU ,QGXVWU\
5;(- &*( '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 A &(-&5,+/ 5- ()&5 - " 4 2,-. >5 (-('<8 O /(( ()&5 - $3 &*( 6 ++ :5-< /?AA+8 A5)&?'( (9('<(/ 6 ' *(,& ,-. 6?(+ .(9,-. 5- &*( -.?/&'8 /()& ' 2/(( 5<?'( # !3
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
!
// 0 & '(A+,)(,>+(
P
// 0
(A+,)(,>+( // 0 5<* 2Q Q /()& '/3
$ "
5 0 ?(+/ 2Q Q /()& '/3
5 0 5<* 2Q Q /()& '/3
4
( 0 5<*
(,&
4 5<?'( " #
0 5<*
(,& 4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
A+5& 6 /?AA+8 A&5 -/ 5- &*( <+ >,+ -.?/&'8 /()& ' 2( )+?.5-< (+()&'5)5&83
?AA+8 6' 9 6 //5+ 6?(+/ . 95-,&(/ 5- &*( (,'+8 8(,'/ / /?/&,5-,>+( >5 (-('<8 >() 9(/ ,;,5+,>+( 5& >(<5-/ & .5/A+,)( &*(/( 6?(+/ &*('(>8 ( A,-.5-< >(8 -. 5&/ V&',.5&5 -,+L . 9,5- 6 &*( A,A(' /()& ' 8 4 $ >5 (-('<8 /?AA+5(/ ,+9 /& &: &*5'./
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&#&
6 5-.?/&'5,+ 6?(+ ,-. *(,& .(9,-. ,6&(' ,9>5&5 ?/ (665)5(-)8 9(,/?'(/ *,;( >((- &,C(- 5'()& 5-.?/&'5,+ A' )(// *(,& 5/ A,'&5,++8 /?AA+5(. >8 <( &*('9,+ *(,& ,-. ,6&(' 4 >8 .5'()& ) -)(-&',&5-< / +,' *(,& '(/5.?,+ 6 //5+ 6?(+ .(9,-. '(9,5-/ 6 ' 5-.?/&'5,+ A' )(//(/ :*5)* '(+8 - & -+8 - &*( (-('<8 ,-. ),'> - ) -&(-& >?& ,+/ 9()*,-5),+ A' A('&5(/ 6 )?''(-& 6 //5+ 6?(+/ 6 ' ( ,9A+(
5HVXOWV ± +HDW IRU %XLOGLQJV
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
*( )?''(-& ?/( 6 &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// :5++ >( A*,/(. ?& ,-. -+8 , /9,++ /*,'( .((9(. /?/&,5-,>+( ?A & D 6 &*( )?''(-& ,9 ?-& :5++ >( ?/(. 5- +,&&(' .(),.(/ - &*( 65-,+ 8(,'/ 6 &*( )(-,'5 (;(- &*5/ /9,++ ,9 ?-& 6 >5 9,// /* ?+. - + -<(' >( '(B?5'(. .?( & &*(' '(-(:,>+( A&5 -/ ,-. , .595-5/*5-< .(9,-.
//5+
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
! P
5 0 &*('
$
5 0 ',.5&5 -,+
"
(
4 +,' *('9,+
4 5<?'( " # 4
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
A+5& 6 /?AA+8 A&5 -/ 5- &*( <+ >,+ ?5+.5-</ /()& ' 2( )+?.5-< (+()&'5)5&83
&( &*,& &*('( 9,8 >( , /*,'( 6 &*( W G 6 /?/&,5-,>+( &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// &*,& ) ?+. >( ?/(. & /?AA+8 &*(' >5 (-('<8 -((./ 5- &*( 65-,+ 8(,'/ & 4 $ :(;(' ,/ &*( ) 9A /5&5 - 6 &*5/ &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// ?/( 5/ - & ( ,)&+8 C- :- :( *,;( )* /(- *('( - & & .5;('& 5& 5-& &*(' >5 (-('<8 /&'(,9/
4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &#?
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
5HVXOWV ± )XHOV IRU 7UDQVSRUW
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
//5+0 (*5)+(
5-,+ (-('<8 2 GE,3
//5+0 *5AA5-<
! //5+0 ;5,&5 5 0 (*5)+( " 5 0 *5AA5-< 4 5 0 ;5,&5 - 4
5<?'( " #
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
A+5& 6 /?AA+8 A&5 -/ 5- &*( <+ >,+ ',-/A '& /()& ' 2( )+?.5-< (+()&'5)5&83
*+* (PLVVLRQV
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
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&#;
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
4 (95//5 -/ 2>- & --(/E,3
4$ 4 //5+ N ?)+(,'
4 $
4
(-(:,>+(/
$ 4
5<?'( " # "
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ 4#(B (95//5 -/ 6' 9 &*( (-('<8 /8/&(9 5- &*( )(-,'5
;(',++ &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 : ?+. +(,. & , W! D .()'(,/( 5- (-('<8#'(+,&(. 4# (B?5;,+(-& (95//5 -/ ;('/?/ +(;(+/ >8 4 $ $
*( (95//5 -/ /* :- *('( ,'( 4#(B?5;,+(-& (95//5 -/ :(;(' /5-)( &*5/ ) -)('-/ (95//5 -/ 6' 9 &*( (-('<8 /8/&(9 -+8 &*( ;,/& 9,= '5&8 6 (95//5 -/ ,'( 4 ;('8 /9,++ 6',)&5 - 6 &*( (95//5 -/ ) 9( 6' 9 ,-. " :*5)* *,;( >((- ) -;('&(. & 4#(B?5;,+(-&/ 6 ' ,<<'(<,&( ?/( *('( $
*(/( ,'( V',:L (95//5 -/ *(- ) ''()&5-< 6 ' &*( 6,)& &*,& , +,'<(' /*,'( 6 &*( "
'(9,5-5-< (95//5 -/ ,'( (95&&(. >8 ,;5,&5 - &*5/ '(.?)(/ & WP D .?( & &*( 59A,)& 6 ,;5,&5 - ,& *5<*(' ,+&5&?.(/
95//5 - '(.?)&5 -/ 9,8 >( (;(- +,'<(' 56 &*( (95//5 -/ 6' 9 *8.' A :(' ) ?+. >( '(.?)(. *( (95//5 - 6,)& ' 6 ' *8.' A :(' :,/ )* /(- ,)) '.5-< & *5/& '5),++8 >/(';(. ',&(/ *('( * :(;(' /9,++(' *8.' A :(' A&5 -/ ( < '?-# 6#&*(#'5;(' 5-/&,++,&5 -/ : ?+. >( ( A()&(. & *,;( + :(' (95//5 -/
" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &#-
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&DUERQ FDSWXUH DQG VWRUDJH
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x A&5 -/ & '(.?)( ' '(A+,)( &*( $D 6 //5+ (-('<8 ?/( &*,& '(9,5-/ ?-&5+ ,-. ,6&(' 4 $ x x x x
A&5 -/ & '(.?)( &*( 4 (95//5 -/ 6' 9 &*( ) 9>?/&5 - 6 >5 9,// A&5 -/ & '(.?)( &*( 4 (95//5 -/ 6' 9 &*( 5-.?/&'5,+ ?/( 6 >5 9,// A&5 -/ & '(.?)( &*( +56()8)+( 4 (95//5 -/ 6' 9 &*( A' .?)&5 - 6 >5 6?(+/ /8/&(9/ &*,& /&,'& - 6 //5+ 6?(+/ >?& &*,& ,'( /?5&,>+( 6 ' +,&(' ) -;('/5 5-& 2 5 (-('<8 :5&* 3
$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&##
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &#7
6XSSO\ ± 6XVWDLQDEOH ELRHQHUJ\
6XPPDU\ 0HHWLQJ GHPDQG ZLWK VXVWDLQDEOH ELRHQHUJ\
*( )(-,'5 5-) 'A ',&(/ , /5<-565),-& /*,'( 6 /?/&,5-,>+( >5 (-('<8 /?AA+8 & 9((& &*( '(9,5-5-< .(9,-. ,6&(' ?/5-< &*(' '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 A&5 -/ *( )(-,'5 -+8 5-)+?.(/ >5 (-('<8 /?AA+8 &*,& 5/ /?/&,5-,>+( ,-. +(,./ & *5<* <'((-* ?/( <,/ (95//5 - /,;5-</ :*(- ) 9A,'(. & 6 //5+ '(6('(-)(/ P 5<?'( $ # /* :/ &*,& &*( )(-,'5 5/ ),A,>+( 6 9((&5-< .(9,-. :5&* >5 (-('<8
"
$
!
P
4$
P$#!$D /,;5-</
4 $
$ "
4
$
5 0 +<,( 5 0 ' A/ 5 0 9A (++5-</ 5 0 (/5. N ,/&( (95//5 -/
&(-&5,+
5<?'( $ #
(95//5 -/ 2< 4(BE G 65-,+ (-('<8 ?/(3
:5&*5- &*( /?/&,5-,>+( A &(-&5,+ ,-. /59?+&,-( ?/+8 ,)) 9A+5/*5-< *5<* <'((-* ?/( <,/ (95//5 - /,;5-</
'59,'8 >5 (-('<8 2 GE,3
/(.
6 //5+ '(6('(-)(/
)(-,'5 >5 (-('<8
;(';5(: 6 &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 Q/ /?/&,5-,>+( >5 (-('<8 ?/( ;('/?/ /?/&,5-,>+( A &(-&5,+ ,-. /?/&,5-,>+( >5 (-('<8 <'((-* ?/( <,/ 2 3 (95//5 -/ ;('/?/ 6 //5+ '(6('(-)(/ 6 ' 4 $
& 5/ 59A '&,-& & ?-.('/&,-. &*,& ) 9A,'(. & &*(' /&?.5(/ T '((-A(,)( 4 K *(++ 4 !K E 4 U &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ?/(/ , '(+,&5;(+8 +,'<( ,9 ?-& 6 >5 (-('<8 /* :- 5- 5<?'( $ # 4
P
*( )(-,'5 L/ ,AA' ,)* & >5 (-('<8 /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 5/ .(/)'5>(. 5- ()&5 - $ 4 ,-. .(&,5+(. 6?'&*(' 5- ()&5 -/ $ &*' ?<* $ P *( '(/?+&5-< <'((-* ?/( <,/ (95//5 - /,;5-</ ,'( A'(/(-&(. 5- ()&5 - $ P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&#A
'59,'8 (-('<8 ?/( 2 GE,3
"
"
4 4
$
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
$GY >5@(YROXWLRQ
4
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
4 "
4 $
:(2 5HIHUHQFH
!
"
"
4 4
6KHOO %OXHSULQWV
!
'59,'8 (-('<8 ?/( 2 GE,3
5-,+ (-('<8 ?/( 2 GE,3
5-,+ (-('<8 ?/( 2 GE,3
(QHUJ\ 5HSRUW
$
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
4
4
4 4
4
-# &*(' +,' ,-. 5-. -/A()565(. ++ 5-)+?.5-< +,' ,-. 5-. 5 9,//
5<?'( $ # 4
;(';5(: 6 /*,'(/ 6 '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ,-. &*(' /&?.5(/ *( ,>/ +?&( -?9>('/ ),- - & >( ) 9A,'(. >(&:((- &*( &: <',A*/ - &*( +(6& ,-. &*( &: - &*( '5<*& ,/ &*(8 ,'( 5- 65-,+ ,-. A'59,'8 (-('<8 ?/( '(/A()&5;(+8
*( A'(. 95-,-& '(,/ - 6 ' &*5/ +,'<( >5 (-('<8 /*,'( 5/ &*,& &*( )(-,'5 *,/ , /5<-565),-&+8 *5<*(' & &,+ '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 /*,'( 5- 5&/ (-('<8 /?AA+8 &*,- &*( &*(' /&?.5(/ '(,)*5-< $D 5- 4 $ *(- &'85-< & ,)*5(;( /?)* *5<* '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 /*,'(/ 65-.5-< , '(-(:,>+( 6?(+ ,-. *(,& /?AA+8 5/ &*( >5<<(/& )*,++(-<(
*( )(-,'5 L/ >5 (-('<8 5/ &*('(6 '( 9 /&+8 ?/(. 9,5-+8 & A' ;5.( &',-/A '& 6?(+ ,-. 5-.?/&'5,+ 6?(+ ,-. *(,& 5 ( & 9((& (-('<8 .(9,-./ &*,& ),- - & >( 9(& &*' ?<* '(-(:,>+( (+()&'5)5&8 ' &*(' '(-(:,>+( *(,& ,AA+5),&5 -/ -+8 ;('8 /9,++ ,9 ?-&/ 6 >5 (-('<8 ,'( ?/(. 6 ' (+()&'5)5&8 A' .?)&5 - :*('( - & (- ?<* .(9,-.#.'5;(),A,)5&8 ( 5/&/ 6' 9 &*(' / ?')(/ 2/(( 5<?'( $ # 3 / ;(',++ .(9,-. /&,>5+5/(/ .?'5-< &*( +,/& &(- 8(,'/ 6 &*( &59( * '5R - >5 (-('<8 ?/( :5++ ,+/ /&,>5+5/(
! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &#,
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
"
//5+ N ?)+(,'
5-,+ (-('<8 ?/( 2 GE,3
$ 5 0 ',-/A '& 6?(+/
4$
5 0 -.?/&'8 *(,& N 6?(+/
4
5 0 ?5+.5-< *(,&
$
5 0 +()&'5)5&8
$ 4
5<?'( $ #
&*(' '(-(:,>+(/ 4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
+ >,+ ?/( 6 >5 (-('<8 ;('/?/ &*(' '(-(:,>+( ,-. - -#'(-(:,>+( (-('<8 / ?')(/
*( 9,5- (-('<8 .(9,-. &8A(/ ) ;('(. >8 >5 (-('<8 5-)+?.(0 x 7UDQVSRUW IXHOV ZKHUH HQHUJ\ VWRUDJH GHQVLW\ LV RIWHQ D FUXFLDO IDFWRU HVSHFLDOO\0 R -< .5/&,-)( ' ,. &',-/A '& R ;5,&5 R *5AA5-< x
,QGXVWULDO IXHOV ZKHUH HOHFWULF RU VRODU KHDWLQJ LV LQVXIILFLHQW HVSHFLDOO\0 R AA+5),&5 -/ &*,& '(B?5'( ;('8 *5<* &(9A(',&?'( R AA+5),&5 -/ &*,& '(B?5'( , /A()565) (-('<8 ),''5(' ( < , <,/( ?/ 6?(+ ' / +5. 6?(+ -( ( ,9A+( : ?+. >( &*( /&((+ 5-.?/&'8 :*('( &*( /&'?)&?',+ /&'(-<&* 6 , / +5. 6?(+ 5/ '(B?5'(.
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
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&#+
$ #
-&5-<(-)80 ,&('5,+/ 6' 9 >5 9,//
&217,1*(1&<
0$7(5,$/6 )520 %,20$66
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
P 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &7'
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
6XVWDLQDELOLW\ RI ELRHQHUJ\ $SSURDFK WR HQVXUH VXVWDLQDELOLW\
*( >5 (-('<8 /?AA+8 9?/& >( / ?')(. /?/&,5-,>+8 ,-. )'(,&( *5<* <'((-* ?/( <,/ (95//5 - /,;5-</ 5- '.(' 6 ' &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 & >( /?/&,5-,>+( *( )(-,'5 (-/?'(/ &*5/ >8 5&/ ) 9A'(*(-/5;( ) -)(A&?,+ ,AA' ,)* & >5 (-('<8 /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 /* :- 5- 5<?'( $ # " 9 '( .(&,5+(. .(/)'5A&5 - 5/ A' ;5.(. 5- ()&5 -/ $ &*' ?<* $
5<?'( $ # "
-)(A&?,+ ,AA' ,)* & >5 (-('<8 /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5
' 9 &*( ) -)(A&?,+ ;5(: 5- 5<?'( $ # " :( *,;( .('5;(. , /(& 6 /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5, & ,//(// &*( /?/&,5-,>+( >5 (-('<8 A &(-&5,+/ 6' 9 '(/5.?(/ :,/&(/ ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ ,-. (-('<8 )' A/ ,-. ,+<,( *(/( )'5&('5, ,'( A'(/(-&(. 5 ,>+( $ #
P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&7&
,>+( $ #
?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5, ?/(. 6 ' >5 (-('<8
7RSLF
6XEWRSLF
&ULWHULD DSSOLHG WR HQVXUH VXVWDLQDELOLW\ WRSLF LV DGGUHVVHG
,-. ?/( ,-.
?''(-& +,-. ?/(
x )+?/5 - 6 ) -;('/5 - 6 )?''(-& 6 '(/&(.
6 . /()?'5&8
A' &()&(. ,-. ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. <'5)?+&?',+ :,&(' ?/(
x )+?/5 - 6 ,'(,/ - & /?5&,>+( 6 ' ',5-#6(. ,<'5)?+&?'(
5 .5;('/5&8
x ,'&5,++8 ) -&,5-(. 5- )?''(-& +,-. ?/( )'5&('5 -
A' &()&5 -
x ..5&5 -,+
( )+?/5 -
6
+,-.
:5&*
*5<*
>5 .5;('/5&8 ;,+?( ?9,-
x ,'&5,++8 ) -&,5-(. 5- )?''(-& +,-. ?/( )'5&('5 -
.(;(+ A9(-&
x ..5&5 -,+ ( )+?/5 - 6 +,-. 6 ' *?9,- .(;(+ A9(-&
. /()?'5&8
x ,'&5,++8 ) -&,5-(. 5- )?''(-& +,-. ?/( )'5&('5 x ..5&5 -,+ ( )+?/5 - 6 +,-. 6 ' 9((&5-< 6 . .(9,-.
<'5)?+&?',+ ,-. ' )(//5-< :,&(' A' )(//5-<
?/(
5-A?&/
<'5)?+&?',+
x + /(. + A 6 ' A' )(//5-< :,&(' 5- >5 6?(+ A' .?)&5 x 6('&5+5/(' A' .?)&5 - 6' 9 /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8
-?&'5(-& ?/(
,-. 6((./& )C x ,-. % 6('&5+5/(' ?/(0 )+ /(. + A ,AA' ,)*
9A+(9(-&,'8 ?/&,5-,>+( ?/( 6 6(++5-</
,..5&5 -,+ 6 '(/& <' :&*
x )+?/5 -
6
A' &()&(.
5-,))(//5>+(
,-.
?-.5/&?'>(. 6 '(/& ,'(,/ x )+?/5 - 6 - -#) 99(')5,+ /A()5(/ x )+?/5 - 6 : . -((.(. 6 ' 5-.?/&'5,+ A?'A /(/
/( 6 /?/&,5-,>+( /*,'(
6
x )+?/5 - 6 P D 6 &*( )?''(-& &',.5&5 -,++8 ?/(. >5 9,//
&',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,//
(/5.?(/ ,-.
;,5+,>5+5&8 6
:,/&(
'(/5.?(/
x )+?/5 - 6 '(/5.?(/ &*,& ,'( - & ,;,5+,>+(
?/&,5-,>+( :,/&(
x ..5&5 -,+ '()8)+5-<
?/(
x )+?/5 - 6 :,/&( 6' 9 - -#'(-(:,>+( / ?')(/
P4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &7?
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
$ # 4
&$6( 678'<
,/( /&?.80 ?/&,5-,>+( +,-. ?/( >8 /?<,' ),-( ,-. ),&&+( 5-&(<',&5 -
6867$,1$%/( /$1' 86( %< 68*$5 &$1( $1' &$77/( ,17(*5$7,21
( -((. +,-. 6 ' .566('(-& ?/(/0 6 ' A' ;5.5-< 6 . 65>'( * ?/5-< ,-. (-('<8 ,-. 6 ' ) -/(';5-< -,&?'( ,-. 5&/ >5 .5;('/5&8 / &*( ,;,5+,>+( ,9 ?-& 6 +,-. 5/ +595&(. 5& 5/ 59A '&,-& & ,)) 99 .,&( &*(/( <' :5-< .(9,-./ 5- , /?/&,5-,>+( :,8 -( :,8 & /?/&,5-,>+8 5-)'(,/( &*( A' .?)&5;5&8 6 +,-. 5/ &*( 5-&' .?)&5 - 6 95 (. )' A#+5;(/& )C ,<'5)?+&?',+ /8/&(9/ - ( ,9A+( 6 /?)* , /8/&(9 5/ &*( 5-&(<',&5 - 6 /?<,' ),-( ,-. ),&&+( T A,' ;(C 4 PU *5/ ) -)(A& 5/ ?/(. 5- &*( ',R5+5,- '(<5 - 5>(5'z '(& ,-. &*,& :,/ A'(;5 ?/+8 -+8 ?/(. 6 ' ( &(-/5;( ),&&+( 6,'95-< 5/ - : ,+/ A,'&5,++8 ?/(. 6 ' <' :5-< 6 /?<,'),-( *5/ /?<,'),-( 5/ A' )(//(. 5-& (&*,- + 6?(+ *( '(/5.?(/ '5<5-,&5-< 6' 9 &*5/ A' )(//5-< ,'( ?/(. ,/ /?AA+(9(-&,'8 6((. 6 ' &*( ),&&+( (),?/( &*('( 5/ - : , / ?')( 6 ),&&+( 6((. +(// A,/&?'( +,-. 5/ '(B?5'(. & 6((. &*( /,9( /& )C 6 ),&&+( 6'((5-< ?A &*( +,-. 6 ' &*( /?<,'),-( )?+&5;,&5 -
(/?+&/ /* : &*,& ?/5-< &*5/ 9(&* . &*( /,9( +,-. &*,& -)( /?AA '&(. , )('&,5- -?9>(' 6 ),&&+( - : /?AA '&/ &*( /,9( -?9>(' 6 ),&&+( :*5+( ,+/ A' .?)5-< (&*,- + 6' 9 /?<,'),-( - ,..5&5 - &*( 5-) 9( 6 + ),+ 6,'9('/ 5/ 59A' ;(. -59,+ :(+6,'( 5/ - & =( A,'.5/(. >(),?/( &*( ),&&+( 5-&(-/5&8 5/ /&5++ ;('8 + :
<(&*(' &*(8 ) ;(' &*( 6 ++ :5-< /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 & A5)/ '(6+()&5-< &* /( 6 ?-. - &*( +(6& *,-. /5.( 6 5<?'( $ # "0 x
/DQG XVH DQG IRRG VHFXULW\ 6HFWLRQ 0 :( *,;( ( )+?.(. +,-. & (-/?'(
x
&*,& >5 .5;('/5&8 A' &()&5 - 6 '(/& ),'> - /& )C A' &()&5 - *?9,- .(;(+ A9(-& ,-. 6 . .(9,-. ,'( - & 59A,5'(. >8 >5 (-('<8 )' AA5-< - ,..5&5 - :( *,;( 5-)+?.(. -+8 +,-. /?5&,>+( 6 ' ',5-#6(. ,<'5)?+&?'( 5- ?' >5 (-('<8 )' A +,-. A &(-&5,+ $JULFXOWXUDO DQG SURFHVVLQJ LQSXWV 6HFWLRQ 0 :( *,;( ,+'(,.8 '(/&'5)&(.
x
>5 (-('<8 )' AA5-< & +,-. /?5&,>+( 6 ' ',5-#6(. ,<'5)?+&?'( *5/ 5/ , /5<-565),-& ,<'5)?+&?',+ 5-A?& /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5 - ,/ :,&(' 5/ -( 6 &*( 9,5- ,<'5)?+&?',+ 5-A?&/ - ,..5&5 - :( ?/( , )+ /(. :,&(' + A ,AA' ,)* 6 ' &*( A' )(//5-< 6 >5 9,// 5- >5 6?(+ A+,-&/ & (-/?'( /?/&,5-,>+( A' )(//5-< :,&(' ?/( <'5)?+&?',+ -?&'5(-& 5-A?&/ ,'( ,+/ '(B?5'(. & >( ,/ + : ,/ A //5>+( &*' ?<* ?/5-< A'()5/5 - 6,'95-< ,-. , )+ /(. + A ,AA' ,)* :*('( A //5>+( 5-,++8 ,++ -5&' <(- 6('&5+5/(' 5/ A' .?)(. 6' 9 /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 ,-. 6((./& )C/ &RPSOHPHQWDU\ IHOOLQJV 6HFWLRQ 0 :( *,;( 5-)+?.(. -+8 ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ '5<5-,&5-< 6' 9 /?/&,5-,>+( *,';(/&5-< 6 : . *( 65'/& / ?')( 5/ ,..5&5 -,+ 6 '(/& <' :&* (-/?'( &*5/ *,';(/&5-< 5/ /?/&,5-,>+( -+8 ) 99(')5,+
P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&7;
x
/A()5(/ 5- 6 '(/&/ &*,& ,'( ,))(//5>+( ?-A' &()&(. ,-. ,+'(,.8 .5/&?'>(. ,'( 5-)+?.(. *( /() -. / ?')( 5/ , /*,'( 6 &*( )?''(-& &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// ?/( (-/?'( 5&/ /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 &*( 9,= '5&8 6 &*5/ &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// 5/ A*,/(. ?& ,-. 5/ - & ?/(. 5- &*( )(-,'5 5HVLGXHV DQG ZDVWH 6HFWLRQ 0 :( *,;( 5-)+?.(. -+8 '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&(/ &*,& '5<5-,&( 6' 9 , '(-(:,>+( / ?')( -8 '(/5.?(/ &*,& ,'( - & ,;,5+,>+( .?( & ) 9A(&5-< ?/(/ 6 ' ( ,9A+( ,'( ,+/ - & &,C(- 5-& ) -/5.(',&5 -
++ &*(/( )'5&('5, ,-. &*(5' ,AA+5),&5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 ,'( .5/)?//(. 5- 6?'&*(' .(&,5+ 5- ()&5 -/ $ &*' ?<* $ ()&5 - $ .5/)?//(/ * : &*5/ ,66()&/ &*( <'((-* ?/( <,/ (95//5 - /,;5-</ ,)*5(;(. >8 ?/5-< >5 (-('<8 5- &*( )(-,'5
6XVWDLQDELOLW\ RI ELRHQHUJ\ /DQG XVH DQG IRRG VHFXULW\
*( )(-,'5 ( A+5)5&+8 A'5 '5&5/(/ , -?9>(' 6 +,-. ?/(/ ;(' +,-. ?/( 6 ' >5 (-('<8 )' AA5-< - ,..5&5 - &*( )(-,'5 '(/&'5)&/ >5 (-('<8 )' AA5-< & +,-. /?5&,>+( 6 ' ',5-#6(. )?+&5;,&5 - 6 (-('<8 )' A/ 5- '.(' - & & '(B?5'( 5''5<,&5 - ! ,/ ,- ,<'5)?+&?',+ 5-A?&
*('(6 '( &*( 6 ++ :5-< +,-. 5/ - & ?/(. 6 ' >5 (-('<8 )' AA5-< 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 0 x ,-. ?/(. 6 ' /?AA+85-< 6 . 6((. ,-. 65>'(K &,C5-< 5-& ,)) ?-& 6?&?'( A A?+,&5 - <' :&* ,-. , .5(& )*,-<( /)(-,'5 x ,-. ?/(. 6 ' A' &()&5 - 6 >5 .5;('/5&8 ,-. *5<* ),'> - /& )C 6 '(/& () /8/&(9/ x ,-. ?/(. 6 ' *?9,- .(;(+ A9(-& >8 ( A,-.5-< &*( >?5+& (-;5' -9(-& x ,-. - & ' 9,'<5-,++8 /?5&,>+( 6 ' ',5-#6(. )?+&5;,&5 - 6 (-('<8 )' A/ ( A('6 '9(. ,- ,//(//9(-& 6 +,-. A &(-&5,+ 6 ' ',5-#6(. )?+&5;,&5 - 6 (-('<8 )' A/ >,/(. - &*5/ +,-. ?/( A'5 '5&5/,&5 - 5<?'( $ # $ /* :/ &*( '(/?+&/ 6 &*5/ ,//(//9(-& ( ,)C- :+(.<( &*,& /?>/&,-&5,+ +,-. ?/( A+,--5-< 2A +5)83 5/ '(B?5'(. & .5'()& +,-. ?/( 5- &*( ) ''()& 9,--(' *5/ 5/ .5/)?//(. 6?'&*(' 5- ()&5 - P 4
*( ,//(//9(-& :,/ >,/(. - .,&, 6' 9 , '()(-& /&?.8 T 5/)*(' 4 U ()&5 - 4 P 5- &*,& &*,& '(A '& A' ;5.(/ ,- ,//(//9(-& 6 A' .?)&5 - A &(-&5,+ 6 ' .566('(-& >5 (-('<8 )' A/ ( ?/(. &*( / ?')( .,&, 6 &*5/ /&?.8 ,-. ,..5&5 -,+ ) 68/ ! ( '() <-5/( &*,& ,<'5)?+&?',+ :,&(' ?/( 5/ , ) 9A+( 5//?( - &*( -( *,-. 5-&(-/5;( ?/( 6 5''5<,&5 - ),- +(,. & 2+ ),+ ,-. '(<5 -,+3 6'(/* :,&(' /* '&,<( - &*( &*(' *,-. 5''5<,&5 - 5/ , 9(,-/ & '(,)* &*( 6?++ A' .?)&5 - A &(-&5,+ 6 &*( +,-. &*('(>8 '(.?)5-< &*( -((. 6 ' ,..5&5 -,+ ,<'5)?+&?',+ +,-. *('(6 '( :( *,;( )* /(- & A+,- (-('<8 )' AA5-< - +,-. /?5&,>+( 6 ' ',5-#6(. ,<'5)?+&?'( *5/ +(,./ & , /,&5/6,)& '8 85(+. :5&* ?& '(B?5'5-< ,..5&5 -,+ :,&(' ?/( (+,&(. A',)&5)(/ &*,& 5-)'(,/( A' .?)&5 - /?)* ,/ &(9A ','5+8 /& '5-< ',5- :,&(' & ,AA+8 5& & &*( +,-. +,&(' ),- >( ?/(. 5- ),/(/ :*('( &*(8 . - & +(,. & .(&'59(-&,+ (66()&/ - &*( 2+ ),+ ,-. '(<5 -,+3 () /8/&(9 ,-. :,&(' /?AA+8 P" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &7-
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
,-,+8/(/ & A('6 '9 &*( ,//(//9(-& 6 ' &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ?/5-< &*( /&(A:5/( ,AA' ,)* '(6+()&(. 5- 5<?'( $ # $ ,-. .(/)'5>(. 5- .(&,5+ 5- &*( ,)) 9A,-85-< &( &
++ ;,+?(/ 5- *, $ "4 $
4
4 !
P PPP
4 $ $ , &,+
> ) & &,+ ) -/5.('(.
, > ) . ( 6 < * 5 = R
5<?'( $ # $
!
44
P
4$
4
. ( 6 < * 5 = R ?''(-& '(/& -/?5&,>+( ,5-#6(. ..5&5 -,+ )(-,'5 )(-,'5 ?''(-& )' A+,-. +,-. A &(-&5,+( )+?/5 -/ ',5-#6(. ',5-#6(. +5;(/& )C A &(-&5,+ ?/(
&,+ <+ >,+ +,-. 9,// 2( )+?.5-< -&,')&5),3 )+?.(.0 A' &()&(. +,-. >,''(- +,-. ?'>,- ,'(,/ :,&(' > .5(/
&,+ +,-. ) -/5.('(. 5- &*( /&?.8 )+?.(.0 )?''(-& ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. )+?.(.0 ?-A' &()&(. 6 '(/&(. +,-. )+?.(.0 - & /?5&,>+( 6 ' ',5-#6(. ,<'5)?+&?'( &(-&5,+ 6 ' ',5-#6(. ,<'5)?+&?'( )+?.(.0 ,..5&5 -,+ +,-. 6 ' >5 .5;('/5&8 A' &()&5 - *?9,- .(;(+ A9(-& 6 . .(9,-. -('<8 )(-,'5 A &(-&5,+ 6 ' (-('<8 )' A/ -('<8 )(-,'5 0 +,-. ?/( 6 ' (-('<8 )' A/ ?''(-& +,-. ?/(. & /?AA '& +5;(/& )C 26 ' '(6('(-)( -+8K ;('+,A/ :5&* &*(' ),&(< '5(/3
(/?+&/ 6 &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ,//(//9(-& 6 +,-. A &(-&5,+ 6 ' ',5-#6(. )?+&5;,&5 - 6 (-('<8 )' A/
&,'&5-< A 5-&0 &*( & &,+ <+ >,+ +,-. 9,// ( )(A& -&,')&5), 6 4 *, )+?/5 - 6 ,++ )?''(-& A' &()&(. +,-. >,''(- +,-. ?'>,- +,-. ,-. 5-+,-. :,&(' > .5(/ ,/ &*(8 ),-- & >( ?/(. 6 ' ,<'5)?+&?'( )) '.5-< & &*( .,&, &*5/ & &,+/ $ "4 *, )+?/5 - 6 )?''(-& ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. & /,6(<?,'. )?''(-& 6 . A' .?)&5 - )) '.5-< & &*( .,&, &*5/ & &,+/ $ *, (( ,+/ 5<?'( $ # !
)+?/5 - 6 ) -;('/5 - 6 ,++ )?''(-& ?-A' &()&(. 6 '(/&(. +,-. & A' &()& 6 '(/& >5 .5;('/5&8 ,-. 6 '(/& ),'> - /& )C/ )) '.5-< & &*( .,&, &*5/ & &,+/ 4 ! *, (( ,+/ 5<?'( $ # !
)+?/5 - 6 ,++ +,-. &*,& 5/ - & ' 9,'<5-,++8 /?5&,>+( 6 ' ',5-#6(. ,<'5)?+&?'( & (-/?'( -+8 ',5-#6(. >5 (-('<8 )' AA5-< )) '.5-< & &*( .,&, &*5/ & &,+/ 4 $ $ *, (( ,+/ 5<?'( $ #
)+?/5 - 6 ,..5&5 -,+ +,-. 6 ' 6?&?'( '(B?5'(9(-&/ 6 ' >5 .5;('/5&8 A' &()&5 - *?9,- .(;(+ A9(-& ,-. 6 . .(9,-. *5/ :,/ . -( >,/(. - ) 68/ +5&(',&?'( ,-,+8/(/ .5/)?//(. 5- 9 '( .(&,5+ 5- 5<?'( $ # &*' ?<* 5<?'( $ # *5/ & &,+/ 44 *, P$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&7#
,/(. - &*5/ ,//(//9(-& :( ),+)?+,&(. , & &,+ /?/&,5-,>+( +,-. A &(-&5,+ 6 P *, 6 ' &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 L/ ',5-#6(. )?+&5;,&5 - 6 (-('<8 )' A/ *( .(&,5+/ 6 &*5/ ,//(//9(-& ,'( ( A+,5-(. 6?'&*(' 5- ()&5 -/ $ &*' ?<* $ $
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
?9>(' 5/ <5;(- 6 ' ) 9A,'5/ - -+8 P 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &77
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
$ #
& '80 ,-. ?/( 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5
6725<
/$1' 86( ,1 7+( (1(5*< 6&(1$5,2
?++ +,-. 9,// : '+.:5.( ( )+?.5-< -&,')&5), (-) 9A,//(/ ,> ?& 4 *, 2 4 95++5 - C943 *( /&,&?/ ' 6?-)&5 - 6 &*5/ +,-. 5/ ) 99 -+8 '(6(''(. & ,/ &*( X+,-. ?/(Y *('( ,'( 9,-8 &8A(/ 6 +,-. ?/( 9( 6 &*(9 .(/)'5>( ,)&5;( +,-. ?/( >8 *?9,-/ /?)* ,/ +,-. ?/(. 6 ' ,<'5)?+&?'( ,-. +,-. ?/(. 6 ' *?9,- .(;(+ A9(-& /?)* ,/ ?'>,- ,'(,/ ,-. &',-/A '& 5-6',/&'?)&?'( &*(' +,-. ?/(/ '(6+()& &*( -,&?',+ /&,&( 6 &*( +,-. /?)* ,/ 6 '(/&(. ,'(, ' <',//# ,-. : .+,-.
*( )(-,'5 5-) 'A ',&(/ , +,-. ?/( ,-,+8/5/ >,/(. - /(;(- .566('(-& +,-. ?/(/ - &*5/ ,-,+8/5/ A'(/(-&(. 5- &*5/ ()&5 - $ ,-. 5&/ /?>/()&5 -/ :( ),+)?+,&( &*( (66()&/ 6 A A?+,&5 - <' :&* .5(& )*,-<(/ >5 (-('<8 ?/( ,-. >5 .5;('/5&8 A' &()&5 - - <+ >,+ +,-. ?/( ,9 -< &*('/ 5<?'( $ # /* :/ &*( +,-. ?/( 5- &*( )?''(-& /5&?,&5 - ,-. &*( )(-,'5 5- 4 $
"
-A' &()&(. <',//# ,-. : .+,-.
,-. ?/( 2 *,3
4
-A' &()&(. 6 '(/&(. ,'(,/
' &()&(. ,'(,/ ! 5 (-('<8 )' A+,-. <'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. " '(,/ 6 ' *?9,.(;(+ A9(-&
4 ?''(-& 5<?'( $ #
)(-,'5
&*(' +,-. ?-/?5&,>+( 6 ' ,<'5)?+&?'(
,-. ?/( 6 &*( <+ >,+ +,-. 9,// ( )+?.5-< -&,')&5), 2& &,+0 4 *,3 5- &*( )?''(-& /5&?,&5 - ,-. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5- 4 $ *( >5 (-('<8 )' A+,-. ;,+?( 6 4$ *, 5/ &*( 9, 59?9 +,-. ?/( 6 ' >5 (-('<8 )' A/ 5- &*( )(-,'5
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
PP : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&7A
&XUUHQW ODQG XVHV ( ( )+?.(. +,-. 6' 9 &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 &*,& )?''(-&+8 *,/ , +,-. ?/( 9,C5-< ,<'5)?+&?'( 6 (-('<8 )' A/ - & A //5>+( ' - & ,))(A&,>+( *(/( :('( &*( 6 ++ :5-< +,-. ?/(/0 1RW SRVVLEOH
,''(- +,-. '>,- ,'(,/ -+,-. :,&(' > .5(/
1RW DFFHSWDEOH
' &()&(. +,-. '(/&(. +,-. <'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-.
*( 65'/& 6 ?' +,-. ?/(/ 5- &*( ,> ;( +5/& :('( A'(#( )+?.(. 5- &*( / ?')( /&?.8 '(.?)5-< &*( ,//(//(. +,-. ,/ /* :- 5- 5<?'( $ # P
++ ;,+?(/ 5- *,
&*(' +,-. ?-/?5&,>+( 6 ' ,<'5)?+&?'(
'>,- ,'(,/ 4 " ' &()&(. +,-.
P PPP !"!
&,+ +,-. ) -/5.('(. 5- &*( /&?.8
5<?'( $ # P
'(#( )+?.(. +,-. ?/(/ 5- &*( /&?.8 &*(' +,-. ?-/?5&,>+( 6 ' ,<'5)?+&?'( 5-)+?.(/ >,''(- +,-. ,-. 5-+,-. :,&(' > .5(/
( &*(- 6?'&*(' ( )+?.(. &*( ) -;('/5 - 6 )?''(-& 6 '(/&(. +,-. ,-. ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. & /,6(<?,'. )?''(-& 6 '(/& >5 .5;('/5&8 ,-. ),'> - /& )C/ ,-. )?''(-& 6 . A' .?)&5 -" 5<?'( $ # ! /* :/ &*( '(/?+&/ 6 &*(/( ( )+?/5 -/
..5&5 -,+ >5 .5;('/5&8 ,-. 6 . /()?'5&8 /,6(<?,'.5-< :('( . -( 5- , +,&(' /&(A /(( ()&5 -/ $ ,-. $ $ "
P! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &7,
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
++ ;,+?(/ 5- *, $ ?''(-& ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-.
" ! -A' &()&(. 6 '(/&(. +,-.
4 !
5<?'( $ # !
&,+ +,-. ) -/5.('(. 5 )(-,'5 ,//(/9(-&
,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 >,/(. - )?''(-& +,-. ?/( 6 ' ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. ' ,/ ?-A' &()&(. 6 '(/&(. +,-.
- & &,+ " ! *, 6 &*( 5-5&5,+ 4 *, '(9,5-(. ,6&(' &*(/( ( )+?/5 -/ 6 )?''(-& +,-. ?/(/ 6XLWDELOLW\ RI ODQG IRU UDLQ IHG DJULFXOWXUH ( ,+/ (-/?'(. &*,& - ?-/?/&,5-,>+( :,&(' 5-A?& : ?+. >( -()(//,'8 6 ' (-('<8 )' A )?+&5;,&5 - *('(6 '( :( ( )+?.(. ,++ +,-. &*,& :,/ 6 ?-. & >( (5&*(' - & /?5&,>+( ' -+8 9,'<5-,++8 /?5&,>+( 6 ' ',5-#6(. ,<'5)?+&?'( 5- &*( /&?.8 5<?'( $ # /* :/ &*( '(/?+&/ 6 &*5/ /&(A - & &,+ ! *, 6 &*( 5-5&5,+ " ! *, '(9,5-(. ,6&(' &*(/( ( )+?/5 -/ %LRGLYHUVLW\ SURWHFWLRQ
*( ('9,- .;5/ '8 ?-)5+ - + >,+ *,-<( 2 3 A('6 '9(. , /&?.8 - &*( ) -/(';,&5 - 6 &*( >5 /A*('( T U -( 6 &*( ) -)+?/5 -/ 6 &*5/ : 'C :,/ &*,& >(&:((- O4 D 6 &*( : '+. +,-. 9,// /* ?+. >( A' &()&(. & A'(/(';( &*( .566('(-& 6?-)&5 -/ 6 &*( >5 /A*('( /?)* ,/ )+59,&( '(<?+,&5 - ,-. 5&/ >5 .5;('/5&8
*( 9 /& '()(-& /&,&5/&5)/ A' ;5.(. >8 &*( '+. ,&,>,/( - ' &()&(. '(,/ /&,&( &*,& "D 6 &*( +,-. 9,// 5/ )?''(-&+8 A' &()&(. T 4 U
P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&7+
++ ;,+?(/ 5- *, "P" ('8 /?5&,>+( ' /?5&,>+( " .(',&(+8 /?5&,>+(
& ' 9,'<5-,++8 /?5&,>+(
4 $ $
5<?'( $ #
,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 >,/(. - /?5&,>5+5&8 6 ' ',5-#6(. ,<'5)?+&?'(
*('(6 '( & >( ,& &*( ?AA(' +595& 6 &*( ',-<( A?& 6 ':,'. >8 &*( ,- ,..5&5 -,+ D 6 &*( <+ >,+ +,-. 9,// /* ?+. >( A' &()&(. +&* ?<* 5& 5/ - & C- :- :*('( &*5/ D 5/ + ),&(. :( ,//?9( 5- ?' ),+)?+,&5 -/ &*,& 9((&5-< &*5/ '(B?5'(9(-& :5++ ,+/ '(.?)( &*( +,-. A &(-&5,+ 6 ' ',5-#6(. )?+&5;,&5 - 6 (-('<8 )' A/ >8 D *5/ '(.?)&5 - 5/ ,..5&5 -,+ & &*( ( )+?/5 - 6 A' &()&(. +,-. >,/(. - .,&, ,/ A'(/(-&(. 5- ()&5 - $ *( '(.?)&5 - & &,+/ $" *, ,-. 5/ /* :- 5- 5<?'( $ #
""
++ ;,+?(/ 5- *,
('8 /?5&,>+( ' /?5&,>+(
$"
"
)+?.(. 6 ' >5 .5;('/5&8 A' &()&5 -
.(',&(+8 /?5&,>+(
4 $ $
5<?'( $ #
& ' 9,'<5-,++8 /?5&,>+(
,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 >,/(. - >5 .5;('/5&8 A' &()&5 -
! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &A'
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
+XPDQ GHYHORSPHQW <:5=C A('6 '9(. , /&?.8 - A &(-&5,+/ 6 '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 / ?')(/ 5-)+?.5-< ,- ,//(//9(-& 6 &*( 5-)'(,/( 5- +,-. ?/( 6 ' &*( >?5+& (-;5' -9(-& T <:5=C 4 "U ?''(-& +,-. ?/( 6 ' &*( >?5+& (-;5' -9(-& :,/ (/&59,&(. & >( 4D 6 &*( & &,+ <+ >,+ +,-. 9,// ( )+?.5-< -&,')&5), -5&(. ,&5 -/ A' =()&5 -/ (/&59,&( &*5/ +,-. ?/( & >( "D 5- 4 T 4 4U ( &*('(6 '( ,//?9( &*,& +,-. ?/( 6 ' &*( >?5+& (-;5' -9(-& :5++ 5-)'(,/( 6' 9 &*( )?''(-& 4D & "D 5- 4 ( ( &',A +,&(. &*5/ 65<?'( ?/5-< &*( A A?+,&5 - <' :&* -?9>('/ ?/(. &*' ?<* ?& &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 & , $D +,-. ?/( 5- 4 $ *( <' :&* 6' 9 )?''(-& & 4 $ +,-. ?/( 6 ' &*( >?5+& (-;5' -9(-& &*('(6 '( '(B?5'(/ ( )+?.5-< D 6 <+ >,+ +,-. 9,// ( )+?.5-< -&,')&5), 6 ' &*5/ A?'A /( ( & :( *,;( ,//?9(. &*,& ,++ 6 &*5/ ( A,-/5 - :5++ &,C( A+,)( - ?-A' &()&(. <',//# ,-. : .+,-. >(),?/( ( A,-/5 - 5-& &*(' +,-. &8A(/ 5/ (5&*(' - & A //5>+( - & ,))(A&,>+( ' 9?)* +(// +5C(+8 D 6 &*( <+ >,+ +,-. 9,// ( )+?.5-< -&,')&5), ,9 ?-&/ & 4D 6 &*( ?-A' &()&(. <',// ,-. : .+,-. ( *,;( &*('(6 '( '(.?)(. &*( +,-. A &(-&5,+ 6 ' ',5-#6(. )?+&5;,&5 - 6 (-('<8 )' A/ >8 4D 6 ' *?9,.(;(+ A9(-&
*5/ '(.?)&5 - 5/ ,..5&5 -,+ & &*( ( )+?/5 - 6 ?'>,- ,'(,/ >,/(. - .,&, A'(/(-&(. 5- ()&5 - $ *( '(.?)&5 - & &,+/ " *, /* :- 5- 5<?'( $ #
++ ;,+?(/ 5- *,
('8 /?5&,>+( ' /?5&,>+(
$" "
"$
)+?.(. 6 ' >5 .5;('/5&8 A' &()&5 )+?.(. 6 ' *?9,.(;(+ A9(-& .(',&(+8 /?5&,>+(
4 $ $
5<?'( $ #
& ' 9,'<5-,++8 /?5&,>+(
,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 >,/(. - *?9,- .(;(+ A9(-&
)RRG GHPDQG
*( -((. 6 ' ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. & 9((& 6?&?'( 6 . .(9,-. 5/ , *5<*+8 .(>,&(. 5//?( ( & C , A',<9,&5) ,AA' ,)* & ,//(// :*(&*(' ' - & &*( )?''(-& ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. 5/ ,>+( & /?/&,5- 6?&?'( 6 . .(9,-. <' :&* *( A'(95/( 6 ?' ,AA' ,)*
! : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&A&
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
*5/ 9(,-/ &*,& :( . - & 9,C( ,//?9A&5 -/ - )*,-<(/ 6 6 . .5/&'5>?&5 - A,&&('-/ :*(- 6 '(),/&5-< 6?&?'( .(9,-. ,-. /?AA+8 & . (/ - & 9(,- &*,& )?''(-& 6 . .5/&'5>?&5 - A,&&('-/ /* ?+. >( 9,5-&,5-(. *('( )+(,'+8 5/ ,- 59>,+,-)( 5- 6 . .5/&'5>?&5 - <+ >,++8 )?''(-&+8 >?& &*5/ & A5) :,/ - & A,'& 6 &*5/ /&?.8 "4
6 :*5)* W4 2- -# 3 ,-. W"! 2 3 ),+ '5(/ ,'( 9(,& A' .?)&/ ,-. &*( '(/& ,'( .,5'8 (<</ 65/* (&)
"
' 9(,& &*5/ 6,)& ' :,/ .('5;(. 6' 9 +5&(',&?'( ;,+?(/ 6 ' 6((. (665)5(-)5(/ A(' ,-59,+ &8A( T 9((&/ 4 !U ,-. )?''(-& .5/&'5>?&5 - 6 ) -/?9A&5 - 6 9(,& A(' ,-59,+ &8A( T 4 U :*5)* 5/ , 95 (. .5(& 6 > ;5-( ;5-( A5< ,-. A ?+&'8 A' .?)&/ ' (<</ +5&(',&?'( ;,+?(/ 6' 9 T + -C 4 !U :('( ?/(. ' .,5'8 +5&(',&?'( ;,+?(/ 6' 9 T 9((&/ 4 !K 59(-&(+ 4 K 5-- 4 U :('( ?/(. *( 6((. 5/ ,//?9(. & *,;( ,- (-('<8 ) -&(-& 6 GEC< 6 .'8 9,&&(' T 9((&/ 4 !U ""
*5/ ),- >( ,)*5(;(. 5- &*( 6 ++ :5-< .5(& /)(-,'5 :*5)* /* ?+. -+8 >( ) -/5.('(. ,/ ,- ( ,9A+(0 x
*( .5(& *,/ &*( /,9( 9(,& 2,-. (<<3 5-&(-/5&8 5- > &* ,-. - -# ) ?-&'5(/ >8 4 $ x
*5/ .5(& 9(,-/ , W$ D '(.?)&5 - 5- 9(,& ) -/?9A&5 - 2) -/&,-& 5- (<< ) -/?9A&5 -3 5- 4 $ ) 9A,'(. & 4 $ 5- ) ?-&'5(/ ,-. ,- W4$D <' :&* 5- 9(,& ) -/?9A&5 - 2 D 5- (<< ) -/?9A&5 -3 5- - -# ) ?-&'5(/ x ,5'8 A' .?)& ) -/?9A&5 - 5/ *(+. ) -/&,-& 5- '(<5 -/ ,-. 9 '( &*,- . ?>+(. 5- - -# '(<5 -/ & '(,)* W$ D 6 &*( A('#),A5&, 5-&(-/5&8 5- 4 $ x
*( ;(',++ .,5+8 A(' ),A5&, 6 . 5-&,C( 5- &*5/ 9(,&#) -/&',5-(. .5(& 5/ ,> ?& 4 ! C5+ ),+ '5(/ A(' ),A5&, A(' .,8 5- - -# '(<5 -/ ,-. 5- !4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &A?
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
( &*(- 9?+&5A+5(. &*( ) -/&',5-(. A(' ),A5&, .5(&/ :5&* )(-,'5 A A?+,&5 - <' :&* -?9>('/ & <(& , & &,+ <' :&* 5- 6 . .(9,-. 5- )' A (B?5;,+(-&/ *5/ :,/ 5-.( (. ,<,5-/& 4 $ ,-. 5/ A'(/(-&(. 5- &*( 8(++ : +5-( 5- &*( <',A* 5 5<?'( $ # 4
( ( &',A +,&(. &*( <' :&* 5- IRRG VXSSOLHG E\ WKH FXUUHQW DJULFXOWXUDO FURSODQG >8 ?/5-< , 85(+. 5-)'(,/( 6 D A(' 8(,' *5/ ;,+?( 5/ ,- 5-&('9(.5,&( ;,+?( 5- , ',-<( 6 85(+. 5-)'(,/( A' =()&5 -/ 6 " & $D 6 ?-. 5- +5&(',&?'( T 4 K 4 K 4 K 4 K '> 4 U *( 59A,)& 6 )+59,&( )*,-<( - 85(+. A' =()&5 -/ :,/ - & ( A+5)5&+8 ) -/5.('(. 5- &*5/ ,-,+8/5/ :(;(' >8 )* /5-< &*( 5-&('9(.5,&( ;,+?( 6 85(+. 5-)'(,/( A' =()&5 -/ :( *,;( &'5(. & >( 9 .(',&( 5- ?' ,//?9A&5 -/
*5/ 85(+. 5-)'(,/( :,/ ,AA+5(. & &*( 5-.( (. ;,+?( 5- 4 $ 6 D ,-. 5/ '(A'(/(-&(. >8 &*( >+?( +5-( 6 &*( <',A* 5- 5<?'( $ # 4 ' '(6('(-)( 5<?'( $ # 4 ,+/ ) -&,5-/ &*( 5-.( (. 85(+. .(;(+ A9(-& 6 ) ,'/( <',5-/ ;(' &*( +,/& $ 8(,'/ :*5)* *,/ >((- *5<*(' &*,- &*( D ,//?9(. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5
! D
,+?( 25-.( (. - 4 $3
D
5(+.
" D 4 D D ! D
*, ,..5&5 -,+ -((.(. 5- 4 $
(9,-.
D " D 5(+. 6 ) ,'/( <',5-/ 2( ,9A+(3
4 D D P ! 4 4 4 4 4 4 " 4 $ 5<?'( $ # 4
,+)?+,&5 - 6 +,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 >,/(. - <+ >,+ 6 . /()?'5&8
' 9 &*( <',A* 5- 5<?'( $ # 4 5& ),- >( >/(';(. &*,& ?-.(' ?' )(-,'5 L/ ,//?9A&5 -/ &*( )?''(-& ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. 5/ A' =()&(. & >( ,>+( & /?AA+8 &*( (-&5'( 6 . .(9,-. 6 ' 4 $ :(;(' 5- 5-&('9(.5,&( 8(,'/ &*5/ 5/ - & ,+:,8/ &*( ),/( ( *,;( ),+)?+,&(. &*,& &*( 9, 59?9 /* '&,<( 6 6 . 6' 9 )?''(-& ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. ))?'/ 5- 4 $ ,-. ,9 ?-&/ & ,> ?& "D 6 )?''(-& ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-.
*5/ & &,+/ *,
'(<5 -/ *5/ 9(,-/ ,- W D .()'(,/( 5- 4 $ ) 9A,'(. & 4 $ 5- ) ?-&'5(/ ,-. , W D <' :&* 5- - -# ) ?-&'5(/ ! : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&A;
$ # "
6725<
& '80 *( ' +( 6 +5;(/& )C 6((.5-< 5- <+ >,+ +,-. ?/(
7+( 52/( 2) /,9(672&. )((',1* ,1 */2%$/ /$1' 86(
,-. ?/( 6 ' &*( 6((.5-< 6 +5;(/& )C 5/ , +,'<( ) -&'5>?& ' & & &,+ <+ >,+ +,-. ?/( (),?/( ( ,)& -?9>('/ ,'( .5665)?+& & >&,5- :( *,;( 9,.( ,- (/&59,&5 - ?/5-< +5&(',&?'( .,&, -0
<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. ?/(. 6 ' <' :5-< ,-59,+ 6((. )' A/ T 4 U (/&59,&(/ &*,& D 6 &*( )?''(-& $ *, 6 ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. ,'( ?/(. 6 ' <' :5-< ,-59,+ 6((. )' A/ *5/ (B?,&(/ & $4 *,
,-. ?/(. ,/ A('9,-(-& 9(,. : ' A,/&?'( )) '.5-< & T 4 ,U .,&, &*5/ +,-. ?/( :,/ ,' ?-. " *, 5- '()(-& 8(,'/
*5/ 9(,-/ &*,& ,> ?& 4 *, 6 &*( 4 *, ' D 6 &*( <+ >,+ +,-. 9,// ( )+?.5-< -&,')&5), 5/ ?/(. 6 ' /?AA '&5-< +5;(/& )C
*5/ /* :/ &*,& &*('( 5/ , +,'<( A &(-&5,+ 6 ' ,..5&5 -,+ +,-. ,;,5+,>5+5&8 6 ' &*(' A?'A /(/ :*(- &*( )+,59 6 +5;(/& )C 6((.5-< - +,-. ?/( 5/ '(.?)(. *( )(-,'5 5-)+?.(/ &: ' ?&(/ 6 ' '(.?)5-< &*5/ )+,590
5HGXFLQJ WKH GHPDQG IRU OLYHVWRFN SURGXFWV PRVW LPSRUWDQWO\ PHDW *5/ 5/ . -( >8 ) -/&',5-5-< 9(,& ) -/?9A&5 - )'(,&5-< , 9 '( /?/&,5-,>+( .5(& *5/ ) ?+. >( ,)*5(;(. &*' ?<* , W$ D '(.?)&5 - 5- A('#),A5&, 9(,& ) -/?9A&5 - 5- 4 $ ) 9A,'(. & 4 $ 5- ) ?-&'5(/ &5A?+,&5-< , .5(& :5&* &*( /,9( 9(,& 5-&(-/5&8 6 ' - -# ) ?-&'5(/ &*5/ 59A+5(/ , W4$D <' :&* 5- 9(,& ) -/?9A&5 - 5- 4 $ ) 9A,'(. & 4 $ 5- - -# ) ?-&'5(/ '( .(&,5+/ - &*(/( .5(& ,//?9A&5 - ),- >( 6 ?-. 5- ()&5 - $ $
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
8 ?/5-< &*(/( &: +(;('/ &*( )(-,'5 *,/ , /?/&,5-,>+( ;5(: - A' .?)&5 - ,-. ) -/?9A&5 - 6 +5;(/& )C A' .?)&/ +(,.5-< & , /?/&,5-,>+( +,-. ?/( A'(/(-&(. 5- $ #
!" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &A-
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
$ # $
-&5-<(-)80 .(++5-< &*( 6?&?'( .(9,-. 6 ' ,-. /?AA+8 6 6 .
&217,1*(1&<
02'(//,1* 7+( )8785( '(0$1' )25 $1' 6833/< 2) )22'
. 5/ &*( 9 /& 59A '&,-& ,<'5)?+&?',+ A' .?)& 5- &*( : '+. *5/ 5/ '(6+()&(. >8 &*( 6,)& &*,& A',)&5),++8 ,++ ,<'5)?+&?',+ A' .?)&5 - 5/ .5'()&(. ,& 6((.5-< &*( : '+.L/ A A?+,&5 - .5'()&+8 ' 5-.5'()&+8 >8 6((.5-< +5;(/& )C &*,& /?AA+5(/ ,-59,+ A' .?)&/ &*(' ,<'5)?+&?',+ A' .?)&/ /?)* ,/ 65>'(/ 6 ' )+ &*5-< >5 9,// 6 ' (-('<8 <(-(',&5 - ,-. & >,)) A' .?)&5 - 9,C( ?A , ;('8 /9,++ /*,'( 6 &*( & &,+ )?''(-& ,<'5)?+&?',+ A' .?)&5 -
*5/ 9(,-/ &*,& 9 .(++5-< &*( 6 . .(9,-. ,-. /?AA+8 ,-. &*( >,+,-)( >(&:((- &*(9 5/ 59A '&,-& 6 ' ,++ ,<'5)?+&?',+ ,-. +,-. ?/( ,-,+8/(/ 5-)+?.5-< &*( )(-,'5 L/ >5 (-('<8 A &(-&5,+ ,-,+8/5/ *5/ 5/ , ) 9A+( &,/C 6 ' &*( 6 ++ :5-< '(,/ -/0 x
(9,-.0 6?&?'( 6 . .(9,-. .(A(-./ - &*( /5R( 6 &*( : '+.L/ A A?+,&5 - ,-. &*( ) 9A /5&5 - 6 5&/ .5(& *5/ .5(& 5- &?'- .(A(-./ - A,',9(&('/ /?)* ,/ :(,+&* ,-. )?+&?',+ )* 5)( ,'&5)?+,'+8 59A '&,-& 5/ &*( 5-&(-/5&8 6 ,-59,+ A' .?)&/ 5- &*,& .5(& ,/ &*(/( '(B?5'( , +,'<( ,9 ?-& 6 ,-59,+ 6((.
x
?AA+80 6?&?'( 6 . /?AA+8 .(A(-./ - &*( ,'(, ,;,5+,>+( 6 ' 6 . )?+&5;,&5 - ,-. &*( 6 . 85(+. A(' ,'(, ?-5& *( .(;(+ A9(-& 6 &*5/ 85(+. 5/ *,'. & A'(.5)& ;(' + -<(' &59(/),+(/ >(),?/( 5& .(A(-./ - -?9(' ?/ 6,)& '/ /?)* ,/ N '(/?+&/ &()*- + <8 ,. A&5 - (.?),&5 - ,-. /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 '(B?5'(9(-&/
x
,+,-)( 6 .(9,-. ,-. /?AA+80 &*( >,+,-)( >(&:((- 6 . /?AA+8 ,-. .(9,-. 5/ A '+8 ?-.('/& . & 5/ 6&(- ,'<?(. &*,& &*( )?''(-& 6 . /?AA+8 5/ ,.(B?,&( 6 ' &*( (-&5'( <+ >,+ .(9,-. >?& &*,& .5/&'5>?&5 - A' >+(9/ +(,. & 6 . /* '&,<(/ 5- A,'&/ 6 &*( : '+."$
*( +,-. ,;,5+,>+( 6 ' >5 (-('<8 )' AA5-< 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5/ /&' -<+8 .(A(-.(-& - &*( ,//?9A&5 -/ 9,.( 5- &*( 6 . ,-,+8/5/ *('( A //5>+( :( *,;( ?/(. ) -/(';,&5;( ,//?9A&5 -/ :5&* -( - &,>+( ( )(A&5 - &*,& :( *,;( 5-)+?.(. , ) -/&',5-& - &*( ) -/?9A&5 - 6 9(,& )'(,&5-< , 9 '( /?/&,5-,>+( .5(& /(( ()&5 - $ $
"$
*( -('<8 (A '& . (/ - & 9,C( ( A+5)5& ,//?9A&5 -/ - )*,-<(/ 5- &*( 6 . .5/&'5>?&5 - /8/&(9 *5/ 9(,-/ &*,& 5- &('9/ 6 &*( ),+)?+,&5 -/ *('( :( ,//?9( &*,& 6 . /?AA+8 ,-. .(9,-. ,'( 5- >,+,-)( - : ,-. :5++ '(9,5- 5- >,+,-)( 5- &*( 6?&?'( ,+,-)( 9(,-/ &*,& &*('( 5/ - /* '&,<( 6 6 . A' .?)&5 - ,& &*( <+ >,+ +(;(+ 6 ' :*5)* :( : ?+. -((. & V/(& ,/5.(L ,..5&5 -,+ +,-. ,-. &*,& &*('( 5/ - ;('?/( 6 )' A+,-. ,& &*( <+ >,+ +(;(+ :*5)* ) ?+. >( &,C(- ?& 6 6 . A' .?)&5 - :5&* ?& ,66()&5-< /?AA+8 *5/ . (/ - & 9(,- &*,& + ),+ /* '&,<(/ ' ;('/?AA+5(/ . - & ( 5/& >?& 9('(+8 &*,& &*( )(-,'5 9,C(/ - ,//?9A&5 - - &*(/( A,&&('-/ )*,-<5-< 5- -( :,8 ' ,- &*(' 5- &*( 6?&?'( (.?)5-< :,/&( 5- &*( 6 . ,-. ,<'5)?+&?',+ /()& ' 9,8 59A' ;( &*( /5&?,&5 -K &*5/ :,/ - & 5- &*( /) A( 6 &*5/ /&?.8 >?& ,..5&5 -,+ '(/(,')* 5-& &*5/ 5//?( : ?+. >( ;,+?,>+( !$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&A#
&217,1*(1&<
02'(//,1* 7+( )8785( '(0$1' )25 $1' 6833/< 2) )22'
,>+( $ # 4 /* :/ &*,& ,-8 )*,-<(/ 5- &*(/( 6,)& '/ ),- *,;( +,'<( (66()&/ - &*( -((. 6 ' ,..5&5 -,+ )' A+,-. 6 ' 6 . *( ( ,9A+(/ 5- &*( &,>+( /* : * : &*( )*,-<(/ ),- '(/?+& 5- , /+5<*& ' /*,'A 5-)'(,/( ' , /*,'A .()'(,/( 6 &*( )?''(-& ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. 595+,'+8 &*( (66()& 6 .(9,-. - &*( ,)&?,+ +,-. XVHG 5- &*( )(-,'5 2',&*(' &*,- &*( +,-. A &(-&5,+ /* :- *('(3 ),- >( ,66()&(. >8 )*,-<(/ - &*( .(9,-. /5.( *5/ 5/ >'5(6+8 .5/)?//(. 5- AA(-.5
,>+( $ # 4
..5&5 -,+ -((. 6 ' )' A+,-. 6 ' 6 .0 66()& 6 .566('(-& ,//?9A&5 -/ 6 ' 6 . /?AA+8 ,-. .(9,-. ,-. &*(5' >,+,-)(
3DUDPHWHU
([DPSOH FKDQJH FRPSDUHG WR YDOXH
&URSODQG IRU ELRHQHUJ\ $YDLODEOH
8VHG
O !
#
$ O 4P
#
$ O!
#
XVHG LQ WKH (QHUJ\ 6FHQDULR 6FHQDULR UHVXOWV
?AA+80 --?,+
"O $D 5-/&(,. 6
85(+. 5-)'(,/(
D"
(9,-.0 (,&
4$OP$D 5-/&(,. 6
) -/?9A&5 -
W$ D '(.?)&5 - 5- "P
9(,& ) -/?9A&5 ,+,-)( 6 .(9,-.
?AA+8 5/ O D 6
,-. /?AA+8
.(9,-. 5- 4 $ 5-/&(,. 6 >(5-< (B?,+
+&* ?<* &*( 5.(-&565(. *, 5/ &*( +,'<(/& ,9 ?-& 6 ,..5&5 -,+ +,-. -((.(. 6 ' 9((&5-< 6 . .(9,-. 5- ,-8 <5;(- 8(,' & 4 $ :( )* /( & ( )+?.( 5& 6' 9 &*( A &(-&5,+ ;(' &*( (-&5'( A('5 . 5- &*( )(-,'5 *5/ '(.?)&5 - 5/ ,..5&5 -,+ & &*( ( )+?/5 - 6 )?''(-& ,<'5)?+&?',+ )' A+,-. >,/(. - .,&, ,/ A'(/(-&(. 5- ()&5 $ *( '(.?)&5 - 5/ ;5/?,+5/(. 5- 5<?'( $ #
" (( ()&5 - $ $ 6 ' 9 '( 5-6 '9,&5 - - )(-,'5 ,//?9A&5 -/ - &*5/ & A5) "P (( ()&5 - $ $ ,-. $ # " 6 ' 9 '( 5-6 '9,&5 - - )(-,'5 ,//?9A&5 -/ - &*5/ & A5) ! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &A7
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
++ ;,+?(/ 5- *,
$P
$"
('8 /?5&,>+( ' /?5&,>+(
"
)+?.(. 6 ' >5 .5;('/5&8 A' &()&5 -
)+?.(. 6 ' *?9,.(;(+ A9(-& )+?.(. 6 ' 6 . /()?'5&8 .(',&(+8 /?5&,>+(
4 $ $ & ' 9,'<5-,++8 /?5&,>+(
5<?'( $ #
,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 >,/(. - 6 . /()?'5&8
6XVWDLQDELOLW\ RI ELRHQHUJ\ $JULFXOWXUDO DQG SURFHVVLQJ LQSXWV
<?,',-&(( /?/&,5-,>+( ,<'5)?+&?'( ,-. A' )(//5-< 6 (-('<8 )' A/ :( 5-)+?.(. , /?/&,5-,>+( 6',9(: 'C 6 ' &*( 5-A?&/ '(B?5'(. 6 ' &*(9 3URFHVVLQJ ZDWHU XVH ( ,//(//(. 6' 9 +5&(',&?'( ( A('& A5-5 -/ ,-. ?' A'(;5 ?/ ( A('5(-)( &*,& , )+ /(. + A ,AA' ,)* 6 ' >5 6?(+ A' )(//5-< :,&(' 5/ )?''(-&+8 ) 99(')5,++8 ,;,5+,>+(
*5/ 9(,-/ &*,& >5 6?(+ A+,-&/ ),- .5/)*,'<( ,/ 9?)* )+(,- :,&(' ,/ &*(5' & &,+ :,&(' 5-&,C( ,-. &*('(6 '( . - & -((. & >( .(&'59(-&,+ & &*( - '9,+ :,&(' /?AA+8
()*- + <8 /?AA+5(' (.5-5 T (.5-5 4 !U )+,59/ &*,& &*( A+,-&/ &*,& 5& >?5+./ 5-&,C( - -#A &,>+( '5;(' :,&(' ,-. .5/)*,'<( A &,>+( :,&(' 6 &*5/ 5/ ) -65'9(. &*(/( A+,-&/ ) ?+. /(';( ,/ :,&(' A?'565),&5 - A+,-&/ $JULFXOWXUDO ZDWHU XVH
*( 85(+. A' =()&5 -/ 6 ' (-('<8 )' A/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 ,'( >,/(. - ',5-#6(. ,<'5)?+&?',+ /8/&(9/ :*('( -?&'5(-&/ ,'( ,..(. & &*( +,-.
(<,'.5-< ,<'5)?+&?',+ :,&(' ?/( &*5/ 9(,-/ &*,& - 5''5<,&5 - ! 5/ ?/(. 6 ' &*( )(-,'5 L/ (-('<8 )' A/ -('<8 )' A 85(+./ ,'( /),+(. 5- ,)) '.,-)( :5&* &*( +,-.L/ /?5&,>5+5&8 6 ' ',5-#6(. ,<'5)?+&?'( 2/(( ,+/ AA(-.5 43 & '(6+()& &*5/ *5/ 9(,-/ &*,& 9 /& 6 &*( )(-,'5 L/ 85(+./ ,'( ,& ,' ?-. $ OP D 6 &*( 9, 59?9 85(+. )?''(-&+8 >&,5-(. 5- *5<* 5-A?& ,<'5)?+&?',+ /8/&(9/ *(/( 85(+. -?9>('/ ,'( A'(/(-&(. 5- AA(-.5 4
!P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&AA
$ #
6725<
& '80 ,&(' ?/( 6 ' >5 (-('<8 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5
:$7(5 86( )25 %,2(1(5*< ,1 7+( (1(5*< 6&(1$5,2
,&(' A,'&5)?+,'+8 6'(/*:,&(' 5/ ,- 59A '&,-& '(/ ?')( 6 ' &*( *?9,- A A?+,&5 - ( ?/( 5& 6 ' -?&'5&5 -,+ A?'A /(/ ,/ .'5-C5-< :,&(' ,/ ,- ,<'5)?+&?',+ '(/ ?')( ,-. 6 ' &*(' A?'A /(/ /?)* ,/ )+(,-5-< '()'(,&5 - ,-. &',-/A '& ,&(' 5/ ,+/ ,- (//(-&5,+ 6,)& ' 5- &*( A'(/(';,&5 - 6 -,&?'( ,-. 5&/ >5 .5;('/5&8 ,&(' /* ?+. &*('(6 '( >( ?/(. /?/&,5-,>+8 &*' ?<* ?& &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 *( )(-,'5 ,)) 9A+5/*(/ &*5/ /?/&,5-,>+( :,&(' ?/( >8 5-) 'A ',&5-<0 x
&ORVHG ORRSV LQ SURFHVVLQJ ZDWHU IRU ELRHQHUJ\0 >5 (-('<8 A' )(//5-< A+,-&/ .5/)*,'<( :,&(' ,& &*( /,9( ' , *5<*(' A?'5&8 +(;(+ ,/ &*(8 &,C( 5& 5- (( ()&5 - $ " 6 ' 9 '( 5-6 '9,&5 -
x
5DLQ IHG FXOWLYDWLRQ RI ELRHQHUJ\ FURSV0 >5 (-('<8 )' A/ ,'( - & 5''5<,&(. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 *(8 &,C( &*( -()(//,'8 :,&(' 6' 9 -,&?',+ ',5-6,++ (( ()&5 - $ " 6 ' 9 '( 5-6 '9,&5 -
x
6HDZDWHU RU EUDFNLVK ZDWHU FXOWLYDWLRQ RI DOJDH0 ,+<,( 5+ ?/(. 6 ' A' .?)5-< >5 6?(+/ 6 ' &',-/A '& 5/ >&,5-(. 6' 9 ,+<,( )?+&5;,&(. 5- /(,:,&(' ' >',)C5/* :,&(' 5-/&(,. 6 6'(/*:,&(' (( ()&5 - $ P 6 ' 9 '( 5-6 '9,&5 -
$JULFXOWXUDO QXWULHQW XVH
(<,'.5-< ,<'5)?+&?',+ -?&'5(-& ?/( &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5-)+?.(/ , 6',9(: 'C 6 ' &*( 9 /& ) 99 -+8 ?/(. -?&'5(-&/ >,/(. - -5&' <(- A* /A* '?/ ,-. A &,//5?9 *5/ 6',9(: 'C ,59/ & 95-595/( &*( -((. 6 ' &*( ,..5&5 - 6 -?&'5(-&/ ,-. A' .?)(/ -5&' <(- >,/(. -?&'5(-&/ 6' 9 /?/&,5-,>+( / ?')(/ x
x
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
!! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &A,
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
*('(6 '( & (-/?'( &*( 9 /& /?/&,5-,>+( -?&'5(-& ?/( A //5>+( :( 5-)+?.(. 5- &*( .(9,-. /5.( 6 &*( )(-,'5 9 .(+0 x ++ *(,& (-('<8 5-A?& '(B?5'(. & A' .?)( 6('&5+5/(' 6 ' >5 (-('<8 )' AA5-< x ++ (+()&'5)5&8 '(B?5'(. & A' .?)( *8.' <(- 6 ' 6('&5+5/(' 6 ' >5 (-('<8 )' AA5-<
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
*5/ ),- 5-)+?.( -?&'5(-& '() ;('8 6' 9 '(&?'-5-< .5<(/&,&( 6' 9 :(& :,/&( 2( < 9,-?'(3 .5<(/&5 - & &*( +,-. ,/ , 6('&5+5/(' ,/ &*( -?&'5(-&/ ,'( A'(/(';(. .?'5-< &*( .5<(/&5-< /&(A /(( ()&5 - $ - &*(' ( ,9A+( : ?+. >( -?&'5(-& '() ;('8 6' 9 *?9,- /(:,<( /&'(,9/ ( ,)C- :+(.<( &*,& &*( -()(//,'8 &()*- + <5(/ ,-. A',)&5)(/ 6 ' /?)* , )+ /(. ,AA' ,)* -((. & >( 6?'&*(' '(65-(. ,-. 9 '( :5.(+8 ,. A&(. >(6 '( 5& ),- >( A&595/(.
6XVWDLQDELOLW\ RI ELRHQHUJ\ &RPSOHPHQWDU\ IHOOLQJV
. 6' 9 6 '(/&/ 5/ *,';(/&(. 6 ' .566('(-& A?'A /(/ /?)* ,/ ) -/&'?)&5 - A,A(' A' .?)&5 - ' (-('<8 A' .?)&5 - ( *,;( ,-,+8/(. &*( /?/&,5-,>+( A &(-&5,+ 6 ' &*( *,';(/&5-< 6 : .8 >5 9,// 6' 9 6 '(/&/ 6 ' (-('<8 A?'A /(/ 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 &,C5-< 5-& ) -/5.(',&5 - &*( .(9,-. 6 ' : . 6 ' &*(' A?'A /(/ *(/( /?/&,5-,>+( ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ ) -/5/& 6 &: ) 9A -(-&/ :*5)* ,'( .5/)?//(. *('(
"! - )?''(-& 6('&5+5/(' A' .?)&5 - -,&?',+ <,/ '(,)&/ <,/ :5&* ,5' ,& *5<* &(9A(',&?'(/ ,-. A'(//?'(/ & A' .?)( ,99 -5, :*5)* 5/ 6?'&*(' A' )(//(. 5-& 6('&5+5R(' / &*( -,&?',+ <,/ 5/ > &* , / ?')( 6 ' *(,& ,/ 6 ' *8.' <(- :( *,;( '(A+,)(. &*5/ :5&* /?/&,5-,>+( *(,& ,-. *8.' <(- 5- ?' )(-,'5 ! : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&A+
$ # P
& '80 '(/&/ 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5
6725<
)25(676 ,1 7+( (1(5*< 6&(1$5,2
'(/&/ ,'( 59A '&,-& 5- , /?/&,5-,>+( <+ >,+ () /8/&(9 *(8 &,C( ?A 4 ,-. /& '( 5& 5- &*( 6 '9 6 >5 9,// ,-. '(+(,/( 8<(- - ,..5&5 - 6 '(/&/ * /& ,- 5-&(<',+ A,'& 6 &*( : '+.L/ >5 .5;('/5&8 *('(6 '( :( . - & ,++ : ,-8 ( A,-/5 - 6 )' A+,-. 5-& )?''(-&+8 6 '(/&(. ,'(, 5- &*( )(-,'5 6 ' -(5&*(' 6 . - ' >5 (-('<8 - 6,)& :( 5-)'(,/( &*( : '+.L/ A' &()&(. +,-. ,'(,/ >8 ,> ?& $ D ' 9 '( .(&,5+/ A+(,/( '(6(' & $ # (<(&,&5 - 5- &*( 6 '(/&/ <' :/ >8 &,C5-< ?A 4 ,-. &*( (-('<8 6' 9 /?-+5<*& /*,'( 6 &*5/ <' :&* ),- >( *,';(/&(. & A' ;5.( : .8 >5 9,// 6 ' A?'A /(/ /?)* ,/ ) -/&'?)&5 - ,-. (-('<8 *5/ /* ?+. >( 59A+(9(-&(. 5- , /?/&,5-,>+( :,8 *( >5 9,// A &(-&5,+ 6' 9 6 '(/&'8 &*,& 5/ 5-)+?.(. 5- &*( )(-,'5 ) 9(/ 6' 9 /?/&,5-,>+( / ?')(/ -,9(+80 x
?/&,5-,>+( ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ ) -/5/&5-< 6 &: /?>),&(< '5(/0 R
9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ 6' 9 ,'(,/ :*('( &*('( 5/ '(9,5-5-< /?/&,5-,>+( 6 '(/&'8 A &(-&5,+ ,6&(' /,&5/685-< &*(' .(9,-. 6 ' 5-.?/&'5,+ ' ?-.: . 6 ' ) -/&'?)&5 - ,-. &*( A' .?)&5 - 6 A,A(' 6 ' ( ,9A+(
R
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
x
?/&,5-,>+( : . A' )(//5-< ,-. + <<5-< '(/5.?(/ ,-. : . :,/&(0 '(/5.?(/ 6' 9 /?/&,5-,>+( 6 '(/&'8 ,-. : . A' )(//5-< 6 ' - -#>5 (-('<8 ,AA+5),&5 -/ ( < /,:.?/& 6' 9 &59>(' 95++/ ,-. :,/&( : . 9,&('5,+
()&5 -/ $ $ ,-. $ A' ;5.( 6?'&*(' .(&,5+ - /?/&,5-,>+( ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ ,-. - : . '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( '(/A()&5;(+8 /)*(9,&5) ;(';5(: 5/ A' ;5.(. 5- AA(-.5
" ( '() <-5/( &*,& &*( /5R( 6 &*5/ /*,'( 5/ ,- (/&59,&5 - ,-. &*,& 5& 9,8 ;,'8 .?( & + ),+ ) -.5&5 -/ *('(6 '( &*( /?/&,5-,>+( ?/( 6 >5 9,// A'(;5 ?/+8 ?/(. ,/ &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// /* ?+. >( ,.,A&(. & &*( + ),+ /5&?,&5 - - ,..5&5 - +(,/& /?/&,5-,>+( ?/(/ /* ?+. >( A*,/(. ?& 65'/& 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &,'
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
$GGLWLRQDO IRUHVW JURZWK ?/&,5-,>+( ,..5&5 -,+ 6 '(/& <' :&* 5/ .(65-(. *('( ,/ <' :&* &*,& 5/ )?''(-&+8 - & *,';(/&(. ,-. &*,&0 x 5/ - & -((.(. 6 ' 6?&?'( <' :&* 5- .(9,-. 6 ' 5-.?/&'5,+ ' ?-.: . 2( < 6 ' ) -/&'?)&5 - ' A,A(' A' .?)&5 -3 x ),- >( *,';(/&(. 5- ,- () + <5),++8 / ?-. :,8
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
*( 9,5- .566('(-)(/ :('( ),?/(. >8 &*( ?A.,&(. /&,&5/&5)/ - .5/&?'>(. 6 '(/& ,;,5+,>+( 6 ' : . /?AA+8 *( ,..5&5 -,+ A &(-&5,+ 6 ' &*( /5 ) ?-&'5(/ :,/ 5-)+?.(. 5&*( () + <5),+ A &(-&5,+ >8 9((&/ '(/?+&5-< 5- , & &,+ <+ >,+ A &(-&5,+ 6 ' /?/&,5-,>+( ,..5&5 -,+ 6 '(/& <' :&* 6 W4P G
,6(<?,'.5-< ,+/ &* /( ,'(,/ ?/(. 6 ' ) -/(';,&5 - 6 / 5+ /+ A(/ ,-. :,&('/*(. $
*( A &(-&5,+ 5/ .(&('95-(. >8 &*( <' // ,--?,+ 5-)'(9(-& 25 ( 6 '(/& <' :&* 5- , 8(,' A(' ,'(,3 &*( 6 '(/& ,'(, ) -/5.('(. ,-. &*( .(9,-. 6 ' : . A' .?)&/ 5-)( &*( ;,+?( 6 ' &*( <' // ,--?,+ 5-)'(9(-& 6 ' ) 99(')5,+ /A()5(/ 5/ >,/(. - &*( ) ?-&'8 ,;(',<( :*('(,/ 5- &*( 6 '(/& ,'(,/ ?-.(' ) -/5.(',&5 - &*( /*,'( 6 ) 99(')5,+ /A()5(/ :5++ >( '(+,&5;(+8 *5<* &*( A &(-&5,+ 5/ +5C(+8 & >( ?-.('(/&59,&(. *('( A' ;5.5-< , V>?66('L 6 ' /,6(<?,'.5-< /?/&,5-,>+( *,';(/&5-< A',)&5)(/ $
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&,&
(;(',+ 6,)& '/ *,;( ) -&'5>?&(. & &*5/ '(+,&5;(+8 +,'<( ,..5&5 -,+ A &(-&5,+0
*( 9 /& /5<-565),-& 6 &*(/( 6,)& '/ ,'( 0 x &*( ?A.,&(. /&,&5/&5)/ - &*( ?/( 6 6 '(/&/ ) 9A,'(. & .,&, 6' 9 A('5 . ! O $ 2,+/ :5&* 5-)'(,/(. '(+5,>5+5&83 x &*( '(+,&5;(+8 +,'<( )*,-<(/ 5- 6 '(/& /()& '/ 5- ) ?-&'5(/ +5C( ?//5, ,-. ',R5+ 2.(;(+ A9(-& 6 6 '(/&'8 /()& '/ >(&&(' ;(';5(: 6 6?-)&5 -/ 6 6 '(/& ,'(,/ ,-. 59A' ;(. ,))(//5>5+5&83 x &*( 9 '( .(&,5+(. /(& 6 ),&(< '5(/ ,-. .(65-5&5 -/ 5- &*( /&,&5/&5)/ ,/ )?''(-&+8 5-.5),&(. >8
++ ;,+?(/ 5- G ?/&,5-,>+( *,';(/&5-< 6 ,..5&5 -,+ 6 '(/& <' :&* A &(-&5,+ 4$ 4P ?/&,5-,>+( &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// A &(-&5,+K 5-)+?.(. 5- )(-,'5
-/?/&,5-,>+( &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// A &(-&5,+K ( )+?.(. 6' 9 )(-,'5 5<?'( $ # "
-# ,-. ( )+?/5 -/ 6 ' &*( ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ ),&(< '8 >,/(. - /?/&,5-,>+( *,';(/&5-< 6 ,..5&5 -,+ 6 '(/& <' :&* ,-. /?/&,5-,>+( ?/( 6 &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,//
?/&,5-,>+( /*,'( 6 &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// ?/( ' ?A(. 5- &*( ),&(< '8 6 V 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ 25-)+ &',.5&5 -,+ ?/(3L &*( /?/&,5-,>+( /*,'( 6 )?''(-& ?/( 6 >5 9,// 6 ' &',.5&5 -,+ ?/(/ ,+/ ,AA(,'/ A'59,'5+8 6 ' . 9(/&5) *(,& A' .?)&5 - ( : 'C ?A - &*( ,//?9A&5 - &*,& &*( 9,= '5&8 6 &*5/ ?/( 5/ : .8 >5 9,//$4 &* ?<* &*(' / ?')(/ )+(,'+8 ) -&'5>?&(
*( -('<8 )(-,'5 : 'C/ - &*( ,//?9A&5 - &*,& ,-8 &',.5&5 -,+ ?/( 6 >5 9,// &*,& 5/ ) -/5.('(. ?-/?/&,5-,>+( & .,8 :5++ >( <',.?,++8 A*,/(. ?& ,-. '(A+,)(. :5&* 9 '( /?/&,5-,>+( ,AA' ,)*(/ /?)* ,/ / +,' &*('9,+ A&5 -/
$4
.(&,5+(. .,&, - &*( ) 9A /5&5 - 6 &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,// ?/( :,/ ,;,5+,>+( ( *,;( &*('(6 '( A&(. - & & ,++ : 5& & 6((. 5-& ,-8 &*(' /?AA+8 ' ?&(/ &*,- *(,& ?/( 5- &*( '(/5.(-&5,+ >?5+.5-< /()& ' :(;(' 5- '(,+5&8 , /*,'( 6 5& 9,8 >( /?5&,>+( 6 ' +5<- )(++?+ /5) ) -;('/5 - ' ?&(/ 4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &,?
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
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
6XVWDLQDELOLW\ RI ELRHQHUJ\ 8VH RI UHVLGXHV DQG ZDVWH
( A('6 '9(. , +5&(',&?'( /&?.8 - '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( 6 ' &*( ),&(< '5(/$ /* :- 5 5<?'( $ # $ *( 6?++ +5/& 6 / ?')(/ ?/(. ),- >( 6 ?-. 5- AA(-.5 $
++ ;,+?(/ 5- G
4$
5+ ,-. 6,& '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( '(/&'8 '(/5.?(/ ,-. : . :,/&( <'5)?+&?',+ '(/5.?(/
!
(& :,/&( ,-. '(/5.?(/
4$
'8 :,/&(
&,+0 G 5<?'( $ # $
?/&,5-,>+( '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( A &(-&5,+ 6 ?-. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 6 ' 4 $ 5- 65;( ),&(< '5(/ $"
6&(' >&,5-5-< &*( +5&(',&?'( ;,+?(/ 6 ' &*( A &(-&5,+ 6 (,)* '(/5.?( ,-. :,/&( )+,// :( A('6 '9(. &*'(( ,..5&5 -,+ ,-,+8/(/ & ,''5;( ,& &*( 65-,+ '(/5.?( ,-. :,/&( A &(-&5,+ 65<?'(/0
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
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&,;
( ,.,A&(. +5&(',&?'( A' =()&5 -/ 6 ' 4 $ 6 ' 9,-?'( ,-. :,/&( ,-59,+ 6,& A &(-&5,+ & '(6+()& &*( 9(,& ) -/?9A&5 - +(;(+ 5- &*( )(-,'5 5- ()&5 - $ $
( ,+&('(. &*( .'8 :,/&( A &(-&5,+ 6' 9 9?-5)5A,+ / +5. :,/&( 2 3 & '(6+()& &*( 6,)& &*,& - & ,++ 5/ '(-(:,>+( ,-. &*,& / 9( 5/ :(& ,-. / 9( 5/ .'8 /(( 5<?'( $ # 0
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
. A' )(//5-< '(/5.?(/ ,-. : . :,/&( :('( >,/(. .5'()&+8 - T 9((&/ 4 !U :*5)* ,+'(,.8 ) -/5.('/ &*( ) 9A(&5-< ?/(/ 6 ' &*(/( '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&(/ 6' 9 &*(' 5-.?/&'5(/ 26 ' ( ,9A+( A,A(' N A,-(+ > ,'. 5-.?/&'5(/3 *( /&?.8 5-5&5,++8 ),+)?+,&(/ &*( () + <5),++8 / ?-. A &(-&5,+ 6 &*(/( '(/5.?(/ ,-. &*(- /?>&',)&/ ,++ .(9,-. 5-)+?.5-< &*( ) 9A(&5-< ?/(/ :5&*5- , &',.(#>,/(. 9 .(+$
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
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
++ ;,+?(/ 5- G 4
4
"P $
" ,
> )(-,'5 '()8)+5-<
, > ) . ( 6 5<?'( $ #
) -#'()8)+(.
5<?'( $ # P
( )(-,'5 :(& :,/&(
6 )(-,'5 .'8 :,/&(
+ >,+ 95 (. ,6&(' A'(#/ '&5-< '()8)+5-< A&5 -/ )+?.(.0 ,..5&5 -,+ '()8)+5-< 5- )(-,'5 -#'()8)+(. 95 (. )+?.(.0 - -#'(-(:,>+( :,/&( -('<8 )(-,'5 :(& :,/&( 6' 9 95 (. -('<8 )(-,'5 .'8 :,/&( 6' 9 95 (.
..5&5 -,+ ,-,+8/5/ 6 ' '(-(:,>+( 9?-5)5A,+ / +5. :,/&( A &(-&5,+
$D
$D
. -# '(-(:,>+(
;,5+,>+( /&',: 6' 9 )('(,+/
-#,;,5+,>+( /&',: 6' 9 )('(,+/
() ;(',>+( 6',)&5 - 6 /&',: 6' 9 )('(,+/ 5- ) ?-&'5(/ -+8 $D 6 &*( /&',: 5/ ,;,5+,>+( 6 ' (-('<8 A?'A /(/ .?( & ) 9A(&5-< ?/( ,/ / 5+ 6('&5+5/(' ,-59,+ 6((. ' ,-59,+ >(..5-< ,-. >(),?/( 6 ) ++()&5 - >,''5('/
$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&,#
*( '(/?+&5-< '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( ),&(< '5(/ ,'( +5/&(. >(+ : *(5' '5<5-$P 5- &*( >5 9,// )*,5- 5/ .(- &(. :5&* , +(&&(' >(&:((- >',)C(&/0 A'59,'8 2 3 /() -.,'8 2 3 ,-.E ' &('&5,'8 2 30 x 5+/ ,-. 6,&/ O G 2 30 R -59,+ 6,& R /(. ) C5-< 5+ x '(/&'8 '(/5.?(/ ,-. : . :,/&( O 4$ G 2 30 R <<5-< '(/5.?(/ O W$ G R . A' )(//5-< '(/5.?(/ W G x
x
x
R . :,/&( O W G <'5)?+&?',+ '(/5.?(/ O 4$ G 2 30 R ('(,+/ R ,A(/((. R 66(( R 8 (& :,/&( ,-. '(/5.?(/ O ! G 2 30 R ?<,' >((& A' )(//5-< '(/5.?(/ R &,& A' )(//5-< '(/5.?(/ R ,-?'( R 5+ A,+9 (9A&8 6'?5& >?-)*(/ R ,+9 5+ 95++ (66+?(-& R ?<,' ),-( R ,//,;, R (& 9?-5)5A,+ / +5. :,/&( '8 :,/&( O G 2 30 R '8 9?-5)5A,+ / +5. :,/&(
6XVWDLQDEOH DOJDH
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
/ - & ,++ +,-. 5.(-&565(. 5- &*( /?/&,5-,>+( >5 (-('<8 )' A+,-. A &(-&5,+ 5/ /?5&,>+( 6 ' <' :5-< 5+ )' A/ ,+<,( ,'( -((.(. (;(- &* ?<* &*( )' A+,-. A &(-&5,+ 5/ - & 6?++8 ?/(. 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &,7
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
5/ ,AA' 59,&(+8 G *( 9 /& ) -/(';,&5;( /)(-,'5 -+8 ) -&,5-/ ,+<,( 5+ 6' 9 95)' ,+<,( <' :- 5- A(- A -./ - - -#,',>+( +,-. 65++(. :5&* /,+& :,&(' *( & &,+ A &(-&5,+ 6 ' ,+<,( 5+ 6' 9 &*5/ &()*- + <8 :,/ (/&59,&(. ,& G 6 5+
*( )?+&5;,&5 - 6 ,+<,( 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 &,C(/ A+,)( 5- , 6',9(: 'C &*,& A&595/(/ &*( >(-(65)5,+ A' A('&5(/ 6 95)' ,+<,( :*5+( '(9,5-5-< :5&*5- &*( > ?-.,'5(/ /(& >8 &*( +,-.#>,/(. ,+<,( )?+&5;,&5 - /)(-,'5 6' 9 &*( /&?.8 - &*5/ 6',9(: 'C &*( >5 (-('<8 /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5, /(& 6 ':,'. >8 &*( )(-,'5 ,'( '(/A()&(. *( 6',9(: 'C ) -/5/&/ 6 &*( 6 ++ :5-< (+(9(-&/0 x
x x x
x
x
x
5)' ,+<,( ,'( )?+&5;,&(. - - -#,',>+( +,-. &*,& . (/ - & ,)) 99 .,&( /5<-565),-& ),'> - /& )C/ R <'5)?+&?',+ 6('&5+5/,&5 - ) -/5/&/ A'59,'5+8 6 -5&' <(- ,-. 4 6('&5+5/(' R *( )?+&5;,&5 - &,C(/ A+,)( 5- /,+& :,&(' 5+ 5/ ( &',)&(. 6' 9 &*( ,+<,( ,-. 6(. & , >5 6?(+ A' )(//5-< A+,-& ?+&5;,&5 - (-('<8 5-A?&/ ) -/5/& 6 (+()&'5)5&8 6 ' A?9A5-< ,-. 5+ ( &',)&5 - (&){ A&5 -,+0 *( '(9,5-5-< ,+<,( >5 9,// ),- >( '(65-(. & ) ++()& *5<* ;,+?( ) 9A -(-&/ ( < A' &(5-/ & 9,8 >( A //5>+( & A' .?)( ,-59,+ 6((. A' .?)&/ 6' 9 &*( A' &(5- 6',)&?'( A &(-&5,++8 '(.?)5-< &*( -((. 6 ' <' :5-< ,-59,+ 6((. )' A/
*( >5 9,// '(/5.?(/ 6 5+ ( &',)&5 - ),- >( .5<(/&(. (5&*(' .5'()&+8 ' ,6&(' &*( A&5 -,+ '(65-5-< /&(A *( A' .?)(. >5 <,/ 5/ ) 9>?/&(. & A' .?)( (+()&'5)5&8 ,-. *(,& *( (+()&'5)5&8 A' .?)&5 - ) ;('/ &*( )?+&5;,&5 - (-('<8 5-A?&/
*( .5<(/&,&( 6 &*( .5<(/&5 - /&(A ,-. &*( 4 >&,5-(. 6' 9 &*( >5 <,/ ) 9>?/&5 - ,'( 6(. >,)C & ,+<,( & )+ /( &*( -?&'5(-& )8)+( ' -5&' <(- -?&'5(-&/ :( ,59 & )+ /( P$D 6 &*( )8)+(
*( )8)+( 6 ,+<,( )?+&5;,&5 - '() 99(-)(/
*5/ )8)+( 5/ /* :- /)*(9,&5),++8 5- 5<?'( $ # !
*( 9, 59?9 ,9 ?-& 6 ,+<,( 5+ ?/(. 5- &*( )(-,'5 5/ 4 G 6 5+ 5- 4 $ ,/(. - &*( 85(+./ ),+)?+,&(. 5- &*( ) 68/ /&?.8 &*5/ ,9 ?-&/ & ,AA' 59,&(+8 *, ?/( 6 - -#,',>+( +,-. *( 4 G 5+ ?/( 5/ ,> ?& 4$D 6 &*( G ,+<,( 5+ A &(-&5,+ 5.(-&565(. 5- &*( 9 /& ) -/(';,&5;( /)(-,'5 ) -&,5-5-< -+8 ,+<,( 5+ 6' 9 95)' ,+<,( <' :- 5- A(- A -./ - - -#,',>+( +,-. 65++(. :5&* /,+& :,&(' *('(6 '( &*( ,+<,( 5+ ?/( 5- &*( )(-,'5 65&/ ) 96 '&,>+8 :5&*5- &*( A &(-&5,+ 5.(-&565(. 5- &*( ) 68/ /&?.8 (/A()5,++8 ,/ 6?'&*(' A &(-&5,+ 6' 9 ,+<,( )?+&5;,&5 - 5- A(- :,&(' 9,8 >( &,AA(. .?( & 6?&?'( &()*- + <5),+ A' <'(//
P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&,A
5<?'( $ # !
)*(9,&5) '(A'(/(-&,&5 - 6 ,+<,( )?+&5;,&5 - )8)+(
$ # !
,/( /&?.80 5)' ,+<,( ,/ ,- (-('<8 / ?')(
&$6( 678'<
0,&52$/*$( $6 $1 (1(5*< 6285&(
5)' ,+<,( ,'( /9,++ '<,-5/9/ &8A5),++8 :5&* , /5R( 5- &*( 95)' 9(&(' ',-<( &*,& +5;( 5- ,B?( ?/ (-;5' -9(-&/ 5C( A+,-&/ &*(8 ),A&?'( 4 ,-. /?-+5<*& &*' ?<* A* & /8-&*(/5/
*5/ 9,C(/ &*(9 ,- 59A '&,-& 6 . / ?')( 6 ' &*(' ,B?,&5) /A()5(/ 5)' ,+<,( ,'( A,'& 6 &*( +,'<( 6,95+8 6 ,+<,( :*5)* ,+/ 5-)+?.( 9,)' ,+<,( /?)* ,/ /(,:((./ 5)' ,+<,( <' : B?5)C+8 ,-. ),- /8-&*(/5/( ;,+?,>+( ) 9A -(-&/ /?)* ,/ A' &(5-/ 6,&/ ,-. 5+/ ,-. ,-&5 5.,-&/ *('(6 '( ,+<,( ,'( ) 99(')5,++8 )?+&5;,&(. 6 ' *5<* ,..(. ;,+?( -?&'5&5 -,+ ,..5&5;(/ /?)* ,/ 9(<,# 6,&&8 ,)5./ -( ( ,9A+( 5/ &*( ) 9A,-8 ,'&*'5/( &*,& *,/ <' :- 95)' ,+<,( 5- A -. /8/&(9/ 5- &*( -5&(. &,&(/ 6 ' &*( -,&?',+ 6 ./ 9,'C(& /5-)( !4
*( 5+ A' .?)(. >8 ,+<,( ),- ,+/ >( ?/(. 6 ' (-('<8 A?'A /(/ ,'<( /),+( )?+&5;,&5 - 6 95)' ,+<,( 6 ' &*(/( A?'A /(/ 5/ )?''(-&+8 ?-.(' .(;(+ A9(-& : '+.:5.( ,9A+(/ 6 A+,8('/ 5-)+?.( ,AA*5'( ,-. (&' +<,( 5- &*( (++,-, 5- ,:,55 ,-. (,9>5 &5) 5- /',(+ ,= ' (-('<8 ) 9A,-5(/ /?)* ,/ *(++ , A,'&-(' 5- (++,-, ,-.
- >5+ T
*,;( ,+/ /&,'&(. 5-;(/&5-< 5- ,+<,( &()*- + <8 6 ' (-('<8 A?'A /(/
! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &,,
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
- >5+ 4 U
&RPSDULVRQ ZLWK RWKHU VWXGLHV
( ) 9A,'(. &*( +,-. ?/(. 6 ' (-('<8 )' A/ ,-. &*( A'59,'8 >5 (-('<8 ?/( 6 >5 (-('<8 )' A/ ,-. ,+<,( 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 :5&* +5&(',&?'( ;,+?(/ - A &(-&5,+/ T 9((&/ 4 !K 4 K '->?'< 4 !K 4 K <:5=C 4 "K '> 4 K ,- ??'(- 4 K 4 !K ,9A>(++ 4 !K 5(+. 4 !U - ?' ) 9A,'5/ - :( .566('(-&5,&(. >(&:((- /&?.5(/ &*,& ,AA+5(. - ' 6(: /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5, ,-. &* /( &*,& ,AA+5(. , /(& 6 /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5, 5- &*( /,9( ',-<( ,/ &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 $ ++ ;,+?(/ 5- *, 9((&/ 4 !
P4
<:5=C 4 "
4 !$ "
,9A>(++ 4 !
!$
,- ??'(- 4
" $
" ?++ /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5,
!P
?++ /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5, # ) -&5-<(-)8 ' / 9( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5,
!
5(+. 4 ! -('<8 (A '&
-('<8 (A '& # +,-. ?/( 6 ' (-('<8 )' A/
4$
5<?'( $ #
' / 9( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5, # ) -&5-<(-)8
$
$
4
4 $
$
"
9A,'5/ - 6 <+ >,+ +,-. ?/( 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 :5&* >5 (-('<8 ,'(, A &(-&5,+/ 6' 9 +5&(',&?'( -&5-<(-)8 5-.5),&(/ &*( ,?&* ' <,;( &*( A &(-&5,+ ,/ , ',-<( ',&*(' &*,- , .(65-5&5;( -?9>('
5<?'( $ # /* :/ &*,& &*( +,-. ?/(. 6 ' >5 (-('<8 )' AA5-< 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5/ ,& &*( + :(' (-. 6 &*( ',-<( 6 A &(-&5,+/ 6 ?-. 5- +5&(',&?'( & 5/ 59A '&,-& & - &(
$ &?.5(/ +,>(++(. | ' / 9( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5,| <(-(',++8 &,C( 5-& ,)) ?-& 6 . /()?'5&8 ,-. >5 .5;('/5&8 )'5&('5, &?.5(/ +,>(++(. | ?++ /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5,| <(-(',++8 ,..(. )'5&('5, - :,&(' ?/( / 5+ A' &()&5 - .(<',.,&5 - 6 +,-. ,-. .(6 '(/&,&5 - ,-. 6 '(/& ),'> - /& )C/ *5/ +(,./ & , /595+,' ',-<( 6 )'5&('5, &8A(/ ,/ &*,& 6 &*( -('<8 (A '& :(;(' &*( 9(&* . ,-. .(<'(( 6 ,AA+85-< &*(/( )'5&('5, ,-. &*( ,//?9A&5 -/ 9,.( .?'5-< &*( ,-,+8/5/ ;,'8 /&' -<+8 :*5)* +(,./ & &*( .566('(-)( 5- '(/?+&/ >(&:((- &*( /&?.5(/ - ( ,9A+( 6 &*( (66()& 6 .566('(-& ,//?9A&5 -/ - 6 . /()?'5&8 5- &*( )(-,'5 - &*( ?&) 9( 6 &*( ,-,+8/5/ 5/ <5;(- 5- $ # $
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&,+
&*,& &*( <5;(- +,-. ?/( 6 ' (-('<8 )' A/ 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5/ &*( 9, 59?9 ,9 ?-& ?/(. .?'5-< &*( 4 $O4 $ &59(6',9( ++ ;,+?(/ 5- G 4 $
9((&/ 4 !
$P
"
<:5=C 4 " 4 E '->?'< 4 !
"!!
4
,- ??'(- 4
4
$ !
4
?++ /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5,
! 4$
'> 4 4 ! -('<8 (A '& " 4 4 ,9A>(++ 4 ! 4P 5(+. 4 ! 5<?'( $ # 4
?++ /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5, # ) -&5-<(-)8 ' / 9( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5, ' / 9( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )'5&('5, # ) -&5-<(-)8 -('<8 (A '& # A'59,'8 (-('<8 ?/( (-('<8 )' A/ -('<8 (A '& # A'59,'8 (-('<8 ?/( ,+<,(
4
"
!
4
"
9A,'5/ - 6 <+ >,+ A'59,'8 (-('<8 ?/( 6' 9 (-('<8 )' A/ 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 :5&* A'59,'8 >5 (-('<8 A &(-&5,+/ 6' 9 +5&(',&?'( -&5-<(-)8 5-.5),&(/ &*( ,?&* ' <,;( &*( A &(-&5,+ ,/ , ',-<( ( < .?( & ?-)('&,5-&8 5- 6?&?'( 85(+./ / T 4 U ,-. T '->?'< 4 !U <5;( &*( /,9( -?9>('/ ,-. A,'&5,++8 *,;( &*( /,9( ,?&* '/ &*(8 ,'( <' ?A(. & <(&*('
5<?'( $ # 4 .(9 -/&',&(/ &*,& &*( A'59,'8 >5 (-('<8 ?/( 6' 9 (-('<8 )' A/ 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5/ ,& &*( + :(' (-. 6 &*( ',-<( 6 A &(-&5,+/ 6 ?-. 5- +5&(',&?'( & 5/ 59A '&,-& & - &( &*,& &*( A'59,'8 >5 (-('<8 ?/( 6' 9 (-('<8 )' A/ 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5- 5<?'( $ # 4 5/ &*( 9, 59?9 ,9 ?-& ?/(. .?'5-< &*( 4 $O4 $ &59(6',9( *5/ 9, 59?9 ?/( ))?'/ 5- 4 $ ,-. ?/( 5/ + :(' 5- ,++ &*(' 8(,'/
6XVWDLQDELOLW\ RI ELRHQHUJ\ *UHHQKRXVH JDV HPLVVLRQ VDYLQJV
*( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6',9(: 'C 6 ' >5 (-('<8 A'(/(-&(. 5- ()&5 - $ 4 5-) 'A ',&(/ &*( 6,)& &*,& >5 (-('<8 ?/( /* ?+. ,)*5(;( *5<* <'((-* ?/( <,/ 2 3 (95//5 - /,;5-</ ) 9A,'(. & 6 //5+ ,+&('-,&5;(/ *('(6 '( :( *,;( A('6 '9(. , +56( )8)+( ,-,+8/5/ 6 &*( (95//5 -/ ,// )5,&(. :5&* >5 (-('<8 ?/( 5- &*( )(-,'5 ( *,;( 5-)+?.(. (95//5 -/ 6' 9 /5 .566('(-& ) -&'5>?& '/ 5- &*( >5 (-('<8 +56( )8)+(0 x 95//5 -/ 6' 9 +,-. ?/( )*,-<( :*(- +,-. 5/ ) -;('&(. & >5 (-('<8 )' A+,-. 95//5 - 6,)& '/ 6 ' &*(/( ) -;('/5 -/ :('( >&,5-(. 6' 9 T 4 U x 95//5 -/ 6' 9 &*( A' .?)&5 - ,-. ,AA+5),&5 - 6 -5&' <(- 6('&5+5/(' 6 ' >5 (-('<8 )' A/ ,-. ,+<,( T 4 K 4 K ) 68/ 4 !U x 95//5 -/ 6' 9 ,<'5)?+&?',+ 6?(+ 5-A?&/ 6 ' )?+&5;,&5 - 6 >5 (-('<8 )' A/ 6 '(/&'8 ,-. ) ++()&5 - 6 ,<'5)?+&?',+ '(/5.?(/ TG 4 !U 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &+'
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
x x x
95//5 -/ 6' 9 &',-/A '& 6 >5 9,// & &*( A' )(//5-< /5&( TG 4 PU 95//5 -/ 6' 9 (-('<8 5-A?&/ .?'5-< >5 (-('<8 ) -;('/5 - T ) 68/ 4 !>U 95//5 -/ 6' 9 &',-/A '& 6 &*( >5 (-('<8 ),''5(' & &*( (-. ?/( + ),&5 - TG 4 PU
/& 6 &*(/( ) -&'5>?& '/ 5-)+?.( (95//5 -/ ,// )5,&(. :5&* (-('<8 ?/( / &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 .',/&5),++8 5-)'(,/(/ &*( /*,'( 6 '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 &()*- + <5(/ &*,& *,;( + : ' - (95//5 -/ :( *,;( 9,.( &: /(A,',&( ),+)?+,&5 -/0 5- -( &*( (95//5 - 6,)& '/ 6 ' &*( (-('<8 5-A?&/ :('( ( &',)&(. 6' 9 &*( 6 //5+ 6?(+ '(6('(-)(/ T 4 >U ,-. 5- &*( &*(' &*(8 :('( &,C(- 6' 9 -('<8 )(-,'5 .,&, *('(6 '( :( A'(/(-& '(/?+&/ ,/ , ',-<(
(95//5 -/ 2< 4(B E G 65-,+ (-('<8 ?/(3
! P
P$±!$D /,;5-</
$ " 4
6 //5+ '(6('(-)(/
5<?'( $ # 4
)(-,'5 >5 (-('<8
-('<8 )(-,'5 >5 (-('<8 <'((-* ?/( <,/ 2 3 (95//5 -/ ;('/?/ 6 //5+ '(6('(-)(/ 6 ' 4 $
5<?'( $ # 4 /* :/ &*( '(/?+&/ 6 &*( +56( )8)+( ,-,+8/5/ ' 4 $ :( *,;( ),+)?+,&(. &*,& &*( (95//5 -/ ,// )5,&(. :5&* >5 (-('<8 ,'( 4O ! < 4(BE G 65-,+ (-('<8 ?/( *( ;,+?(/ 6 ' &*( ) ''(/A -.5-< 6 //5+ '(6('(-)(/ ,'( P O! < 4(BE G *5/ 9(,-/ &*,& (;(- 6 ' &*( 9 /& ) -/(';,&5;( ),+)?+,&5 - 2:5&* 6 //5+ '(6('(-)( 6 ' (-('<8 5-A?&/3 ,;(',<( (95//5 - /,;5-</ ,'( WP$D *(- &*( ) ''(/A -.5-< -('<8 )(-,'5 ;,+?(/ ,'( ?/(. ,;(',<( (95//5 - /,;5-</ ,'( W!$D
' ) -/5/&(-)8 6 //5+ '(6('(-)(/ ,'( >,/(. - )?''(-& .5'()& (95//5 - ;,+?(/ ?/(. &*' ?<* ?& &*( )(-,'5 *5/ 9(,-/ &*,& &*(8 . - & 5-)+?.( +56( )8)+( (95//5 -/ ,// )5,&(. :5&* 6 //5+ 6?(+ A' .?)&5 - /?)* ,/ .'5++5-< ,-. &',-/A '& (95//5 -/ - ,..5&5 - &*(8 ,'( - & ) ''()&(. 6 ' &*( +5C(+8 6?&?'( .(;(+ A9(-& 6 5-)'(,/(. 6 //5+ (95//5 - 6,)& '/ .?( & 5-)'(,/5-< .5665)?+&8 6 6 //5+ 6?(+ A' .?)&5 - 6' 9 ( < &,' /,-./ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&+&
,QYHVWPHQWV DQG 6DYLQJV
,QWURGXFWLRQ
*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ( ,95-(/ &*( 6(,/5>5+5&8 6 , 6?++8 '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 6?&?'( >8 &,C5-< , > && 9#?A A*8/5),+ ,AA' ,)* & &*( (-('<8 /8/&(9 & . (/ - & -()(//,'5+8 A'(/(-& &*( 9 /& ) /&#(665)5(-& :,8 6 ,)*5(;5-< &*5/ < ,+ & 5/ * :(;(' 5-/5<*&6?+ & (/&59,&( &*( ,// )5,&(. 5-;(/&9(-& ,-. /,;5-</ 6 &*5/ (-('<8 /8/&(9 5- ) 9A,'5/ - & , (-('<8 /8/&(9
*( 6 ++ :5-< /()&5 -/ :5++ x x
.(/)'5>( ,AA' ,)*(/ ,-. ,//?9A&5 -/ ?/(. & .('5;( 5-;(/&9(-&/ ,-. /,;5-</ '(/?+&5-< 6' 9 &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5-.5),&( &*( 6?-)&5 -,+5&8 ,-. +595&,&5 -/ 6 &*( ?-.('+85-< ),+)?+,&5 -/
*( <(-('5) ,AA' ,)* 6 ' ,++ /()& '/ ,/ :(++ ,/ >,/5) .,&, ,-. A,',9(&('/ ?/(. 5- ,++ ' 9 /& 6 &*( /()& '/ 5/ A'(/(-&(. 5- ()&5 - 4 ++ :5-< ()&5 - 4 /A()565) 9(&* ./ ,//?9A&5 -/ ,-. '(/?+&/ ,'( A'(/(-&(. 5- /(A,',&( /()&5 -/ 6 ' (,)* 6 &*( /()& '/0 x 5-.?/&'8 x >?5+.5-</ x &',-/A '&#5-6',/&'?)&?'( x &',-/A '&O;(*5)+( &()*- + <8 x A :(' x (+()&'5)5&8 <'5./ x '(-(:,>+( *(,& ,-. 6?(+/ x '(/(,')* ,-. .(;(+ A9(-& 2 N 3 -/5.(',&5 -/ 6 ' &*( ?-)('&,5-&8 6 C(8 A,',9(&('/ ,-. &*( .5/&'5>?&5 - 6 5-;(/&9(-&/ ,-. '(;(-?(/ 6 '9 &*( ) -)+?/5 -
*HQHUDO
*( &: NH\ TXHVWLRQV &*,& &*( ) /& 9 .(+ 6 ' &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ,&&(9A&/ & ,-/:(' ,'(0 x *,& :5++ >( &*( -(& ) /&/ 6 &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 J x *,& :5++ >( &*( ?A6' -& 5-;(/&9(-&/J
,-/:(' &*(/( &: B?(/&5 -/ &*( ) /& ),+)?+,&5 -/ A(' /()& ' .566('(-&5,&( >(&:((- ),A5&,+ ( A(-.5&?'(/ 2&DS([3 ,-. A(',&5 -,+ ( A(-.5&?'(/ 22S([3 :*5)* 5-)+?.( /,;5-</ .?( & + :(' ' - 6?(+ ) /&/
4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &+?
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
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
*5/ 9(,-/ &*,& & &,+ 5-;(/&9(-&/ : ?+. ?/?,++8 >( 9?)* *5<*(' &*,- ,A >?& &*( 9,= ' /*,'( 6 5-;(/&9(-&/ : ?+. *,;( & >( 9,.( 5- &*( '(6('(-)( /)(-,'5 ,-8:,8 8 6 )?/5-< - &*( () - 95) .566('(-)(/ >(&:((- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ,-. >?/5-(// ,/ ?/?,+ &*( '(/?+&/ 6 ' 5-;(/&9(-& ,-. /,;5-</ *5<*+5<*& &*( -(& 65-,-)5,+ 59A,)& 6 &*( )(-,'5 ++ ) /& ;,+?(/ ,'( <5;(- 5- 4 $
*( -('<8 -6 '9,&5 - .95-5/&',&5 - .(65-(/ +(;(+5/(. ) /&/ ,/ '(A'(/(-&5-< ³WKH SUHVHQW YDOXH RI WKH WRWDO FRVW RI EXLOGLQJ DQG RSHUDWLQJ D JHQHUDWLQJ SODQW RYHU LWV ILQDQFLDO OLIH FRQYHUWHG WR HTXDO DQQXDO SD\PHQWV DQG DPRUWL]HG RYHU H[SHFWHG DQQXDO JHQHUDWLRQ IURP DQ DVVXPHG GXW\ F\FOH ´ (),?/( 6 &*( )(-,'5 L/ ),/*# 6+ : ,AA' ,)* &*( & &,+ ?A#6' -& 5-;(/&9(-&/ 2 ,A 3 ,'( -+8 ) 9A,'(. :5&* &*,& /,9( 8(,'L/ 6?(+ ) /& /,;5-</ 2 A 3 +(;(+5/(. ) /& ,AA' ,)* :*5)* 5/ 9 '( ) 99 - 6 ' A'5;,&( 5-;(/&9(-&/ : ?+. /A'(,. &*( ,A ;(' &*( & &,+ +56(&59( ,-. 5-)+?.( ,+/ /,;5-</ ,6&(' 4 $ +(,.5-< & , *5<*(' A' 65&,>5+5&8 6 5-;(/&9(-&/ 5- '(-(:,>+( (-('<5(/ &*,- ) -;(-&5 -,+ A :(' A+,-&/ 4
T &('- 4 U ?99,'8 6 -)+?/5 -/ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&+;
5<?'( #
(-('5) ,AA' ,)* 6 ' ) /& ),+)?+,&5 -/
- JHQHUDO &*( DSSURDFK 6 ' (,)* /()& ' ?/(/ &*( /,9( /(& 6 /()& '#/A()565) ,)&5;5&8 .,&, ,/ &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 & ),+)?+,&(0 x ,..5&5 -,+ ),A,)5&8 '(B?5'(9(-&/ A(' A('5 . 2( < A' .?)&5 - ),A,)5&8 5- & --(E, ' <(-(',&5 - ),A,)5&8 5- 3 6 ' &*( ,A ),+)?+,&5 -/ ,-. x 9 '( (665)5(-& ' '(-(:,>+8 6?(++(. ,)&5;5&8 A(' A('5 . 2( < A' .?)(. & --(/ ' <(-(',&(. *3 6 ' A ),+)?+,&5 -/
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
*( '(/?+&/ 6 ' / 9( C(8 (-('<8 A'5)(/ 5-)+?.5-< ,;(',<( >5 9,// A'5)(/ ,'( /* :- 5- 5<?'( # 4 /(-/5&5;5&8 ,-,+8/5/ - &*( (-('<8 A'5)(/ 5/ A'(/(-&(. 5- ()&5 -
" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &+-
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
! P
+()&'5)5&8
-.( 4 $ S
,+
,/
$
5+ 5 9,// 2: , 3
" 4 4 $
5<?'( # 4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
-.( (. .(;(+ A9(-& 6 (-('<8 A'5)(/ 2:(5<*&(.3 ,;(',<( 2: , 3 5/ /* :- 6 ' &*( >5 9,// 5-.( :*5)* ),''5(/ , +,'<( ?-)('&,5-&8
()& ' ,-. &()*- + <8 /A()565) OLIHWLPH \HDUV DQG SURJUHVV UDWLRV :('( ?/(. 6 ' /(;(',+ /()& '/
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
,>+( #
56(&59( 8(,'/ ,-. A' <'(// ',&5 / ?/(. >8 /()& '
6HFWRU
/LIHWLPH
3URJUHVV
\HDUV XVHG"
UDWLRV XVHG"
-.?/&'8
}
9A+5)5&
?5+.5-</
}
}
',-/A '&# -6',/&'?)&?'(
}
#
',-/A '&O (*5)+( ()*- + <8
}
}
:('
}
}
'5./
}
#
(-(:,>+( *(,& ,-. 6?(+/
}
}
N
#
#
$ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&+#
.H\ ILQGLQJV
*( ;(',++ '(/?+&/ - 5-;(/&9(-& ,-. /,;5-</ 6 ' &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 /* :- 5- 5<?'( # A'(/(-& &: 65-.5-</ &*,& :5++ >( ()* (. 5- /()& '#/A()565) '(/?+&/0
--?,+ ,A ) /&/ ,'( A /5&5;( 2S 5-;(/&9(-&/3 ,-. ,& ,' ?-. &'5++5 - A(' 8(,' 5-5&5,++8 *5<*(' &*,- -(<,&5;( A ) /&/ 2S /,;5-</3 ,A <' : ?-&5+ 4 $ & ,+9 /& $ &'5++5 - A(' 8(,' >?& &*( <' :&* 6 A /,;5-</ 5/ 9?)* *5<*(' (& '(/?+&/ &?'- 6' 9 ) /&/ & /,;5-</ >8 4 " & &*(5' 9, 59?9 -(& ) /&/ ,'( >(+ : 4 &'5++5 - A(' 8(,' >?& &?'- & -(& /,;5-</ 6 ,+9 /& " &'5++5 - A(' 8(,' 5- 4 $ :5&* A /,;5-</ '(,)*5-< 9 '( &*,- $ &'5++5 - A(' 8(,' "
'5++5 - E,
4
&,+ ,--?,+ (& (/?+&/
#4
&,+ ,--?,+ A #"
&,+ ,--?,+ ,A
#
#! 5<?'( #
4
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
4 "
4 "$
4 $
&,+ <+ >,+ ,--?,+ ) /& '(/?+&/ 6 ' -('<8 )(-,'5
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
',-/A '& 5/ .5;5.(. 5-& X -6',/&'?)&?'(Y ,-. X (*5)+( ()*- + <8Y *( 5-6',/&'?)&?'( A,'& 5-)+?.(/ ,++ 5-;(/&9(-&/ ,-. /,;5-</ .?( & )*,-<(/ 5- &*( 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &+7
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
4
'5++5 - E,
# #4 # #" #$
5<?'( # "
-.?/&'8
?5+.5-</
',-/A '&# -6',/&'?)&?'(
',-/A '&# (*5)+( ()*- + <8
:('
'5.
N
(-(:,>+( (,& ,-. ?(+/
4
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
4 "
4 "$
4 $
(& ) /& '(/?+&/ A(' /()& '
) 9A,'5/ - >(&:((- ,-. ,A A ,-. -(& ) /&/ 6 ' &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5/ /* :- 5- 5<?'( # $ 5;(- &*( A' =()&(. <' :&* 6 <+ >,+ -(& ) /&/ :5++ A(,C 5- 4 4$ 5- '(+,&5;( &('9/ /&,85-< >(+ : 4D 6 A /,;5-</ :5++ ) -&5-? ?/+8 '5/( ,-. '(,)* $D 6 <+ >,+ 5- 4 $ +(,.5-< & -(& /,;5-</ 6 ,> ?& 4D 4
4 D *,'( ,A
$
$D
*,'( A
'5++5 - E,
*,'( (& /&
D
$
$D
D
#$
#$D 4
5<?'( # $
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
9A,'5/ - 6 ) /& '(/?+&/ :5&* <+ >,+
&',-/A '& ,)&5;5&8 29 .,+ /*56&3 ..5&5 -,+ ) /&/ 6 ' 9 '( &',5-/ >?/(/ ',5+' ,./ ,-. ',5+' ,. A :(' ,'( ;(') 9A(-/,&(. >8 + :(' ) /&/ 6 ' /,;(. ),'/ &'?)C/ ' ,. ) -/&'?)&5 - ,-. 9,5-&(-,-)( ,/ :(++ ,/ &*( ,// )5,&(. /,;5-< - &',-/A '& 6?(+/ '( .(&,5+ 5/ <5;(- 5- ()&5 - $ P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&+A
,QGXVWU\
*( 5-.?/&'8 /()& ' 5/ .5;5.(. 5-& &*( 6 ++ :5-< /(;(- /?>/()& '/ 2/(( ,+/ ,>+( # 30 x x x x x x x
' - ,-. /&((+ (9(-& +?95-5?9 ,A(' *(95),+/ . &*('/
' &*( 65'/& 6 ?' /()& '/ 2V L /()& '/3 &*( ,A ) /&/ ,'( .('5;(. 6' 9 /?>#/()& ' /A()565) A,8>,)C 8(,'/ 6 ' &*( '(B?5'(. (-('<8 (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-&/ .(&('95-(. 5- &*( )(-,'5 *(/( (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-&/ ,'( ,//?9(. & >( '(<?+,'+8 ,AA+5(. 59A' ;(9(-& 9(,/?'(/ " :5&* .(65-5&( ,-. 65 (. A,8>,)C 8(,'/ /* :- 5- ,>+( # 4 ,//?95-< &()*- + <5),+ ,.;,-)(9(-&/ ,-. '5/5-< 9,'<5-,+ 59A' ;(9(-& ) /&/ >,+,-)( ?& - ,;(',<( 6 ' ,++ '(<5 -/ ,-. &*( & &,+ &59(/),+(
5<?'( #
AA' ,)* 6 ' 5-.?/&'8
*(/( 2*5<*('3 (-('<8 (665)5(-)8 9(,/?'(/ *,;( - & >((- ),''5(. ?& / 6,' *5/ 9,8 >( .?( & 0 x ) 9A,-5(/ .(9,-.5-< /* '&(' A,8>,)C &59(/ x , +,)C 6 5-6 '9,&5 - - &*(/( 9(,/?'(/ ,-. &*(5' >(-(65&/ x &*(' '(,/ -/ &*,& *5-.(' &*( 59A+(9(-&,&5 - 6 ) /&#(665)5(-& (-('<8#/,;5-</ 9(,/?'(/
"
& 5-)+?.5-<
! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) &+,
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
*( A,8>,)C 8(,'/ 6 ' &*( 9(,/?'(/ '(B?5'(. & ,)*5(;( &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 L/ ,..5&5 -,+ (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-& ,'( (/&59,&(. :5&* ,++ 59A+5),&5 -/ 6 &*( )(-,'5 5- 95-. *5/ 9(,-/ &*,& &*( /,9( 9(,/?'(/ 9,8 *,;( + -<(' A,8>,)C A('5 ./ 5- &*( >,/(+5-( ,/ &*( )(-,'5 ) -&,5-/ /&' -<(' .(;(+ A9(-&/ 5- (-('<8 (665)5(-)8 &()*- + <5(/ ,)' // ,++ /()& '/ ,-. '(<5 -/ &*,- &*( >,/(+5-( (),?/( 6 () - 95(/ 6 /) A( ,-. /),+( &*( ) /&/ 6 ' (-('<8 (665)5(-)8 9(,/?'(/ 5- &*( 5-.?/&'8 /()& ' ,'( + :(' 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 &*,- 5- &*( >,/(+5-( ,'&/ 6 &*( ) /&/ ,'( XA,5. >,)CY >8 *5<*(' .(9,-. 2,-. A'5)(/3 6 ' 9 '( (-('<8 (665)5(-& A' .?)&/ ,-. A' .?)&5 - A' )(//(/
,>+( # 4
,8>,)C 8(,'/ A(' 5-.?/&'8 /?>#/()& '
6HFWRU &((+ (9(-& +?95-5?9 ,A('
3D\EDFN \HDUV " $ " $ $
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
*( '(/?+&/ 6 ' &*( 6 ?' V L /()& '/ :('( &*(- ( &',A +,&(. & &*( (-&5'( 5-.?/&'8 /()& ' ?/5-< &*(5' '(+,&5;( /5R( 5- (-('<8 &('9/
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
&++
" 4
>- E,
#4 #" ,A
#
(& /&/
#!
A
# # 4 # " # # !
5<?'( # P
4
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
4 "
4 "$
4 $
(/?+&/ 6 ' 5-.?/&'8 2,++ /()& '/3
.H\ ILQGLQJV
*( 5-;(/&9(-& 5- &*( 5-.?/&'8 /()& ' :5++ A(,C ,& 4 >5++5 - ,--?,++8 5- 4 $ /* :- 5- 5<?'( # P *5/ 5/ , + :(' A(,C 5-;(/&9(-& ) 9A,'(. & &*(' /()& '/ / A,8>,)C ',&(/ ,'( (/&59,&(. & >( >(+ : 65;( 8(,'/ 6?(+ /,;5-</ ( )((. 5-;(/&9(-&/ ,6&(' &*( 65'/& A('5 . --?,+ ,A :5++ <' : /+ :+8 ,-. /&(,.5+8 ?-&5+ 4 $ -&5-? ?/ (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-&/ ,<<'(<,&( 6?(+ /,;5-</ ;(' &59( * :(;('
*('(6 '( &*( '(/A()&5;( /,;5-</ ) -&5-?( & 5-)'(,/( ?-&5+ 4 $ :*(- -(& /,;5-</ 5-)'(,/( & " >- ,--?,++8
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?''
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
%XLOGLQJV
5<?'( # !
AA' ,)* 6 ' >?5+.5-</
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
,>+( #
-;(/&9(-&/ ,-. A' <'(// ',&5 / A(' 9(,/?'(/ ,-. /()& ' 25- E94 6+ ' ,'(,3
6HFWRU
3URFHVV
7HFKQRORJ\
3URJUHVV UDWLR
(/5.(-&5,+
(&' 65&
+,' &*('9,+
!
(,& A?9A
P$
-/?+,&5 -
(-&5+,&5 - :E *(,& '() ;('8
,//5;(
!
+,' &*('9,+
!
4
+,' &*('9,+
!
(,& A?9A
P$
P
-/?+,&5 -
!
(-&5+,&5 - :E *(,& '() ;('8
"
,//5;(
!
P
+,' &*('9,+
!
(: 99(')5,+
(&' 65&
(:
,QYHVW LQ 4
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
?'&
,/(. - &*( (; +?&5 - 6 '(&' 65&&(. ,-. -(:+8 >?5+& 6+ ' ,'(, 5- &*( )(-,'5 ,A ) /&/ ,'( ),+)?+,&(. A(' A('5 . 5-)+?.5-< &*( ) /&/ 6 ' (-.# 6#+56(&59( '(A+,)(9(-&/ 6 -(: >?5+. ' '(&' 65&&(. (-('<8 (665)5(-& >?5+.5-</ 56(&59(/ 6 ' -(: ,/ :(++ ,/ '(&' 65&&(. >?5+.5-< 9(,/?'(/ ,'( (/&59,&(. & >( 4$ 8(,'/ A ) /&/ ,'( ),+)?+,&(. ?/5-< &*( (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-&/ ,-. '(+,&(. (-('<8 /,;5-</ A(' /B?,'( 9(&(' 6' 9 &*( )(-,'5 ,-. (-('<8 A'5)(/ 6 ' (-.#?/( (+()&'5)5&8 ,-. *(,& $
(/5.(-&5,+ (&' 65& 99(')5,+ (&' 65&
(/5.(-&5,+ (: 99(')5,+ (:
E/B9
4$ 4 $ $ 4
5<?'( #
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
4 "
4 "$
4 "
4 "$
4 $
-5& ) /&/ .(;(+ A9(-& 6 ' >?5+.5-</
$
>- E,
$ #$ ,A #
(& /&/ A
# $ #4
5<?'( #
4
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
(/?+&/ 6 ' >?5+.5-</
4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?'?
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
4 $
.H\ ILQGLQJV / /* :- 5- 5<?'( # ,--?,+ ,A ) /&/ 5- &*( >?5+& (-;5' -9(-& A(,C ,& ,+9 /& 4 >5++5 - ,--?,++8 : '+.:5.( 5- 4 (& ) /&/ A(,C 5- 4 4$ ,& W!$ >5++5 - ,--?,++8 ,/ 5-)'(,/5-<+8 (-('<8 /,;5-</ ,'( *5<*(' &*,- 5-;(/&9(-&/ ,+/ .?( & .()'(,/5-< ?-5& ) /&/ *( &'(-. 6 5-)'(,/5-< ,--?,+ /,;5-</ ,-. /+5<*&+8 .()'(,/5-< 5-;(/&9(-& ) -&5-?(/ ,-. +(,./ & -(& ,--?,+ /,;5-</ 5- 4 "$ ,-. , 9, 59?9 6 ;(' "$ >5++5 - /,;(. 5- 4 $
7UDQVSRUW
5<?'( #
AA' ,)* 6 ' & &,+ &',-/A '&
',-/A '& ) /&/ ,'( ),+)?+,&(. >8 .566('(-&5,&5-< >(&:((- &: ,/A()&/ 6 /*56&/ 5- &*( &',-/A '& /8/&(90 x -;(/&9(-& ,-. /,;5-</ '(+,&(. & , /*56& 6 A,//(-<(' ,-. &',-/A '& ; +?9(/ >(&:((- &',-/A '& 9 .(/ 2WUDQVSRUW LQIUDVWUXFWXUH3 ,-. x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
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
?';
5<?'( # 4
AA' ,)* 6 ' &',-/A '& # 5-6',/&'?)&?'(
A ) /&/ 6 ' 5-6',/&'?)&?'( ) -/5/& 6 6?(+ /,;5-</ .?( & &*( )* 5)(/ 6 9 '( (665)5(-& &',-/A '& 9 .(/ *(/( 6?(+ /,;5-</ ,'( ),+)?+,&(. ?/5-< ,)&5;5&8 .,&, A(' &',-/A '& 9 .( 6 ' &*( >,/(+5-( ,/ :(++ ,/ &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 :*5)* ,'( &*(- 9?+&5A+5(. >8 '(/A()&5;( 6?(+ (665)5(-)5(/ 6 ' (,)* &',-/A '& 9 .( ,-. 6?(+ A'5)(
5<?'( #
AA' ,)* 6 ' &',-/A '& # ;(*5)+( &()*- + <8
*( ,A 5-;(/&9(-& 6 ' YHKLFOH WHFKQRORJ\ 5/ ),+)?+,&(. >,/(. - ,..5&5 -,+ ),A,)5&5(/ 6 ' 9 '( (665)5(-& ,-. ,+&('-,&5;(+8 6?(++(. ;(*5)+(/ 2( < A+?<#5- *8>'5. ),'/ ,-. >?//(/3 *( '(/A()&5;( ),A,)5&5(/ ,'( .('5;(. 6' 9 &*( X9 .,+#/*56&(.Y ,)&5;5&8 " 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?'-
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
.,&, 6 &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 & ,; 5. . ?>+(#) ?-&5-< *( ),A,)5&8 -?9>('/ ,'( 9?+&5A+5(. >8 ,..5&5 -,+ ;(*5)+( ) /&/ *(/( ,'( .('5;(. >8 ?/5-< )?''(-& ( &', ) /&/ 2( < *8>'5. ;/ /&,-.,'. ),'3 ,-. A' <'(// ',&5 / & ,++ : 6 ' , '(.?)&5 - 6 &*(/( ,..5&5 -,+ ) /&/ *( '(/?+&/ <5;( &*( ,..5&5 -,+ ,--?,+ ,A A(' &',-/A '& 9 .( A ) /&/ 6 ' ;(*5)+( &()*- + <8 ,'( >,/(. - &*( ,--?,+ (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-& ,/ :(++ ,/ ,--?,+ ,)&5;5&8 .,&, A(' &',-/A '& 9 .( *( (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-&/ 5-)+?.( , '(A+,)(9(-& 6 6 //5+ 6?(+/ >8 (+()&'5)5&8 +&* ?<* (+()&'5)5&8 5/ <(-(',++8 9 '( ( A(-/5;( &*,- 6 //5+ 6?(+/ $ &*( (665)5(-)8 59A' ;(9(-&/ +(,. & -(& A /,;5-</
4
>- E,
# #4 ,A #
(& /&/ A
#" #$
5<?'( # "
4
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
4 "
4 "$
4 $
(/?+&/ 6 ' &',-/A '& # 5-6',/&'?)&?'(
.H\ ILQGLQJV
(/?+&/ 6 ' &',-/A '&O5-6',/&'?)&?'( /* :- 5- 5<?'( # " A'(/(-& <' :5-< ,A &*,& A(,C ,& W! >5++5 - ,--?,++8 5- 4 $ 59?+&,-( ?/+8 6?(+ /,;5-</ 5-)'(,/( &*' ?<* ?& &*( A('5 . ,-. A(,C ,& ,' ?-. " >5++5 - 5- 4 $ +(,.5-< & -(& /,;5-</ 6 ,+9 /& >5++5 - &*,& 8(,' ?( & &*( ) 9>5-,&5 - 6 &*( ,A A(,C 5- 4 $ ,-. ) -/&,-&+8 5-)'(,/5-< /,;5-</ -(& ) /&/ A(,C ,& W4 >5++5 - ,--?,++8 5- 4 4$
$
*5/ '(<,'./ &*( '(,+ ) /&/ 6 A' .?)&5 - -.#?/(' A'5)(/ 9,8 .566(' .?( & /?>/5.5(/ ' &, (/ 6 ' <(-(',&5 - 5-6',/&'?)&?'( ,-. ) -/?9A&5 - $ : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
?'#
$
>- E,
#$ ,A
#
(& /&/ A
# $ #4
5<?'( # $
4
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
4 "
4 "$
4 $
(/?+&/ 6 ' &',-/A '& # ;(*5)+( &()*- + <8
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
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?'7
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
3RZHU
5<?'( #
AA' ,)* 6 ' A :('
*( ,A ) /&/ 6 ' A :(' ,'( ),+)?+,&(. 6' 9 ,..5&5 -,+ ),A,)5&8 ,-. ?-5& ) /&/ ..5&5 -,+ ),A,)5&8 25- 3 A(' / ?')( 5/ ),+)?+,&(. >,/(. - ,)&5;5&8 .,&, A(' '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 / ?')( ,A,)5&8 ?-5& ) /&/ 6 ' &*( .566('(-& / ?')(/ ,'( &,C(- 6' 9 +5&(',&?'( / ?')(/ 9 /&+8 T ) 68/ 4 ,U ,/ :(++ ,/ ( A('& C- :+(.<( -+8 ,A 5-;(/&9(-&/ 6 ' .(9,-.#.'5;(- A :(' / ?')(/ *,;( >((- 66/(& ,<,5-/& ,A 5-;(/&9(-&/ 6 ' ) -;(-&5 -,+ A+,-&/ &*,& : ?+. *,;( >((- >?5+& ' '(A+,)(. 5- &*( '(6('(-)( /)(-,'5 ++ /?AA+8#.'5;(- A :(' / ?')( 5-;(/&9(-&/ *,;( >((- &'(,&(. ,/ 6?++8 ,..5&5 -,+ ( < :5-. ,-. *(8 &*('(6 '( '(A'(/(-& , *5<* (/&59,&(
*( ),+)?+,&(. ,A ) /&/ A(' / ?')( ,'( /* :- 5- ,>+( # "
,>+( # "
6RXUFH
,A,)5&8 ) /&/ 6 (+()&'5)5&8 2 / E 3
/RDG
3URJUHVV
+UV
UDWLR
5-. -/* '(
4
!$
4
5-. 66/* '(
$
4
!
P
$
,;(
4$
4 !
4 $
4
!
4
"
P
"
" "
!
4
4 $
( &*('9,+
P
!
$
4 P
4
4
8.'
$
4 $
4 $
4 $
4 $
4 $
!
!
P
*( ),A,)5&8 ?-5& ) /&/ ?-&5+ 4 $ ,'( .('5;(. >8 ?/5-< )?''(-& 5-;(/&9(-& A(' ,/ , >,/5/ ,-. ,AA+85-< A' <'(// ',&5 / 6 ' 6?&?'( A('5 ./
P : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
?'A
A ) /&/ ,'( ),+)?+,&(. ?/5-< <(-(',&(. A :(' 25- *3 6' 9 '(-(:,>+( / ?')(/ ,-. 6 //5+ 6?(+ ) /&/ 6 ' &*( )?''(-& A :(' 95 A(',&5 -,+ ) /&/ 6 ' A :(' ,'( ,//?9(. & >,+,-)( ?& :5&* /,;(. A(',&5 -,+ ) /&/ 6 ' ) -;(-&5 -,+ A :('
*('(6 '( A ) /&/ ,'( 6?(+ ) /&/ /,;5-</
,A
!
(& /&/
A
>- E,
" 4 #4 #" # #! #
5<?'( # P
4
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
4 "
4 "$
4 $
(/?+&/ 6 ' A :('
.H\ ILQGLQJV ,A ) /&/ 6 ++ : &*( <' :&* 6 '(-(:,>+( A :(' 5- &*( )(-,'5 ,-. A(,C ,& WP >5++5 - 5- 4 "$ -+8 >8 4 $ . 6?(+ /,;5-</ 2 A 3 >(<5- & ?&:(5<* &*( 5-;(/&9(-& ) /&/ ,-. -(& ) /&/ >() 9( /,;5-</ 6 W >5++5 - 2/(( 5<?'( # P3 & 9?/& >( /&'(//(. ,<,5- &*,& :( A'(/(-& V),/*#6+ :L ),+)?+,&5 -/ *('( +(,.5-< & -(& /,;5-</ -+8 5- &*( 65-,+ 8(,'/ 6 &*( &59( 6',9( - , +(;(+5/(. ) /& >,/5/ '(-(:,>+( (+()&'5)5&8 / ?')(/ >() 9( )*(,A(' &*,- ) -;(-&5 -,+ / ?')(/ 9?)* / -(' &*,- 4 $
! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?',
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
(OHFWULFLW\ *ULGV
5<?'( # !
AA' ,)* 6 ' (+()&'5)5&8 <'5./
- <(-(',+ 5& /* ?+. >( - &(. &*,& ;('8 6(: /&?.5(/ - 5-;(/&9(-&/ ,-. /,;5-</ 6 ' +,'<(#/),+( A :(' /8/&(9/ :5&* /*,'(/ ,> ;( D ( 5/& T 4 ! '((- (& #4P 4 $ 4 U *5/ 9,C(/ 5& .5665)?+& & A' ;5.( < . (/&59,&(/ 6 &*( ,// )5,&(. ) /&/ ,-. /,;5-</ - &*( 6 ++ :5-< :( ,&&(9A& & B?,-&568 &*( A &(-&5,+ () - 95) 59A,)&/ 6 &*( A :(' /8/&(9 ?A<',.(/ ,//?9(. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5
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
: ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
?'+
,A
"
(& /&/ A
>- E,
4 ! " 4
5<?'( #
4
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
4 "
4 "$
4 $
(/?+&/ 6 ' (+()&'5)5&8 <'5./
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
5HQHZDEOH KHDW DQG IXHOV
*( -(& ) /&/ 6 ' '(-(:,>+( *(,& ,-. 6?(+/ ,'( ),+)?+,&(. 6' 90 x &*( ) /&/ 6 ' <( &*('9,+ ) -)(-&',&(. / +,' *(,& ,-. &*( ) /&/ 6 ' >5 9,// ) -;('&(. & 6?(+/ x &*( /,;5-</ 6' 9 /,;(. ) -;(-&5 -,+ 2*(,&5-<3 6?(+/
4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?&'
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
5<?'( # 4
AA' ,)* 6 ' >5 (-('<8
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
" A(-.5&?'(/
>- E,
4
(& /&/ ,;5-</
# #4 #
5<?'( # 4
4
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
4 "
4 "$
4 $
(/?+&/ 6 ' '(-(:,>+( *(,& N 6?(+/
4 : ? * .
) ) 9
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
?&&
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
5HVHDUFK 'HYHORSPHQW
/&/ 6 ' '(/(,')* ,-. .(;(+ A9(-& 2 N 3 5-)+?.( ,A ) /&/ -+8 *(8 ,'( ),+)?+,&(. 6' 9 ,A 5-;(/&9(-& A(' /()& ' ,-. /()& '#/A()565) N 5-&(-/5&5(/ N 5-;(/&9(-& 6 ' , <5;(- $#8(,'#A('5 . 5/ >,/(. - &*( ,A 5-;(/&9(-& 6 ' &*,& /()& ' 6 ' &*( 6 ++ :5-< A('5 .
*( /A()565) N 5-&(-/5&5(/ >8 /()& ' ,'( ,//?9(. & >( ,' ?-. PD - ,;(',<( .(A(-.5-< - &*( /()& ' - ,)) '.,-)( :5&* -()(//,'8 &()*- + <5),+ .(;(+ A9(-& 6 ' &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 :( ,//?9( *5<*(' /*,'(/ 6 ' x 5-.?/&'8 x &',-/A '& 2 ',-/A '& O ;(*5)+( &()*- + <83 ,-. x (+()&'5)5&8 <'5./ /()& '/ ,-. + :(' 5-&(-/5&5(/ 6 ' x >?5+.5-</ x 5-6',/&'?)&?'( 2 ',-/A '& O 5-6',/&'?)&?'(3 x A :(' x '(-(:,>+( *(,& ,-. 6?(+/
44 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?&?
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
5<?'( # 44
AA' ,)* 6 ' N
.H\ ILQGLQJV 5<?'( # 44 /* :/ &*,& N 5-;(/&9(-&/ '5/( & W P >5++5 - 5- 4 " ,-. .()'(,/( /+5<*&+8 ,6&(':,'./ *(8 '(,)* $$ >- 5- 4 $ -&5+ 4 4$ N /A(-.5-< 5/ +,'<(+8 .5'()&(. & (-('<8 .(9,-. /()& '/ (/A()5,++8 &*( &',-/A '& /()& ' +&* ?<* &*5/ /()& ' ) -&5-?(/ & >( &*( & A '()5A5(-& N /A(-.5-< 5/ A,'&5,++8 /*56&(. & (-('<8 /?AA+8 /()& '/ ,6&(' 4 A,'&5)?+,'+8 &*( A :(' ,-. '(-(:,>+( 6?(+/
4 !
,A (& /&/ A
>- E,
" 4 ! " 4
5<?'( # 4
4
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
4 "
4 "$
4 $
(/?+&/ 6 ' '(/(,')* N .(;(+ A9(-&
6HQVLWLYLW\ DQDO\VLV RQ HQHUJ\ SULFHV /& 6 &*( /()& ' ,AA' ,)*(/ .(/)'5>(. ,> ;( ),+)?+,&( A ) /&/ >,/(. - 6 //5+ 6?(+ A'5)(/ - 9,-8 ),/(/ A ) /&/ ) -/5/& 6 /,;(. 6 //5+ 6?(+ ( A(-.5&?'(/ -+8 4 : ? * .
) ) 9
?&;
*('(6 '( &*( /(& 6 6 //5+ 6?(+ A'5)(/ 6 ' 4 #4 $ 5/ 6 /5<-565),-& 59A '&,-)( 6 ' &*( ;(',++ '(/?+&/ '5)( 6 '(),/&/ ,//?9(. *('( :('( ( ,95-(. ,<,5-/& &*(' /&?.5(/ ,-. 6 ?-. & >( ) 9A,',>+( /(-/5&5;5&8 ,-,+8/5/ :,/ ,+/ A('6 '9(. - &*( ,//?9(. A'5)( 5-)'(,/(/
*( <' :&* ',&(/ 6 ' &*( ;,'5 ?/ 6?(+/ ,-. /()& '/ :('( ;,'5(. >8 1$ D ,-. #$ D 6 ' &*5/ /(-/5&5;5&8 ,-,+8/5/ *( '(/?+&5-< A'5)(/ ),- >( /((- 5- 5<?'( # 4"
*( '(/?+&/ 6 &*( /(-/5&5;5&8 ,-,+8/5/ - ;(',++ )(-,'5 ) /&/ ,'( /* :- 5- 5<?'( # 4$ - 5-)'(,/( 5- 6 //5+ 6?(+ A'5)(/ <' :&* 6' 9 &*( ,;(',<( ,--?,+ 4D 5- &*( '(6('(-)( ),/( & W D +(,./ -+8 & /9,++ )*,-<(/ ?-&5+ 4 4$ >?& ,+9 /& &'5A+(/ /,;5-</ >8 4 $ - ) -&',/& , .()'(,/( 6 &*( ,--?,+ <' :&* ',&( & ,- ,;(',<( 6 W D )'(,&(/ , /)(-,'5 :*('( 5-;(/&9(-&/ ?&:(5<* /,;5-</ ?-&5+ 4 $ ! P
:('# ,/ # (6('(-)(
',-/A # ,. # (6('(-)(
4 $ A(' G
:('# ,/ # -)'(,/(. $
',-/A # ,. # -)'(,/(. :('# ,/ # ()'(,/(.
"
',-/A # ,. # ()'(,/(.
4 4
5<?'( # 4"
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
4 "
4 "$
4 $
-('<8 A'5)( ',-<(/ ?/(. 6 ' &*( /(-/5&5;5&8 ,-,+8/5/
*( '(. ) +?9-/ 6 &*( '(6('(-)( A'5)(/#),/( 5- 5<?'( # 4$ ,'( 5.(-&5),+ :5&* &*( 8(++ : ) +?9-/ 6 & &,+ ,--?,+ -(& '(/?+&/ 5- 5<?'( # 4" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?&-
$ 6 867$,1$%/( ( 1(5*< 6 833/< )25 (9( 5< 21(
" 4
>- E,
#4 #"
(6('(-)( A'5)(/
#
-)'(,/(. <' :&* ',&(/
#!
()'(,/(. <' :&* ',&(/
# # 4 # "
5<?'( # 4$
4
4 $
4 4
4 4$
4
4 $
4 "
4 "$
4 $
(& '(/?+&/ 6 ' .566('(-& (-('<8 A'5)( /)(-,'5 /
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
4$ : ? * .
) ) 9
?&#
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
4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?&7
3ROLF\ FRQVLGHUDWLRQV
7KH QHHG IRU SROLF\
*( -('<8 )(-,'5 A'(/(-&/ , ',.5),+ .(A,'&?'( 6' 9 ?' )?''(-& /8/&(9 6 (-('<8 ?/( & A /&?+,&(/ &*( 6,/&(/& A //5>+( .(A+ 89(-& 6 (-('<8 (665)5(-)8 ,-. /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 A&5 -/ & 5/ )+(,' &*,& &*( )?''(-& A +5)8 ) -&( & : ?+. - & >( ,>+( & .(+5;(' - &*5/ )(-,'5 -/&(,. ,- ,.,A&(. A +5&5),+ ,-. () - 95) (-;5' -9(-& 9?/& >( (/&,>+5/*(. & ,++ : &*(/( .(;(+ A9(-&/ & *,AA(- 5- &*( () - 95) 9,'C(&A+,)(
*5/ :5++ '(B?5'( .(&,5+(. ,-,+8/5/ 6 A //5>+( 5-/&'?9(-&/ ,-. )?''(-& >(/& A',)&5)(/ ,& '(<5 -,+ +(;(+ - &*5/ /()&5 - :( A' ;5.( , >'5(6 ;(';5(: ,-. 5-5&5,+ &* ?<*&/ >?& &*5/ ),-- & '(A+,)( , ) 9A'(*(-/5;( ,-,+8/5/ 6 A +5)5(/ '(B?5'(. & .(+5;(' &*( -('<8 )(-,'5
3ROLF\ REMHFWLYHV
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
(-('<8 (665)5(-)8 *,--(++5-< 5-;(/&9(-&/ 5-& &*( 9 /& (665)5(-& ,-. '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 A&5 -/
+&* ?<* , .(&,5+(. A +5)8 .5/)?//5 - 5/ >(8 -. &*( /) A( 6 &*5/ '(A '& :( A'(/(-& 5- &*( 6 ++ :5-< &*( 95-59?9 '(B?5'(9(-&/ &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ,/C/ 6 &*( A +5)8 (-;5' -9(-& 5- '.(' 6 ' 5& & >() 9( '(,+5&8 ' (,)* C(8 /()& ' ' /?>#/()& ' &*( A'59,'8 A +5)8 >=()&5;( 5/ A'(/(-&(. :*5)* ,59/ & <(-(',&( &*( A'(#) -.5&5 -/ &*,& 6 '9(. &*( A'(95/( 6 ' &*( )'(,&5 - 6 &*5/ -('<8 )(-,'5 ' (,)* >=()&5;( / 9( A //5>+( A +5)8 .(/5<- ( ,9A+(/ ,-. A &(-&5,+ >/&,)+(/ ,'( - &(.
4P : ? * .
) ) 9
?&A
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?&,
>?5+.5-< '(&' 65&/
x -;(/&9(-& /?AA '& 6 ' 5-6',/&'?)&?'(
&',-/A '& ( < 2(+()&'5)3 ',5+
x ()8)+5-< 5-6',/&'?)&?'(
A' )(//(/
x N 5-& -(: A' .?)&5 -
9,&('5,+/
'(-(:,>+( + -<#+5;(.
A' .?)&/ >,/(. -
x (/(,')* 5-& ,-.
5-.?/&'8 N
x -)(-&5;(/ & /&59?+,&(
x A&59,+ '()8)+5-< ',&(/
( 5/&5-< A+,-&/
/&,>5+5&8 ,-. /9,'& <'5./
x N 5-& .8-,95) <'5.
5-6',/&'?)&?'( 5-;(/&9(-&/
x -)(-&5;(/ & /&59?+,&( <'5.
A' )(//(/
x A&595/,&5 - 6 A+,--5-<
<'5. A(',& '/
x --()&5 - >+5<,&5 -/ 6 '
&()*- + <5(/
'(-(:,>+( (-('<8
6 ' ,++
R - #4 8(,'/ !
5-)(-&5;5/( .(A+ 89(-& 6
6+( 5>+( /?AA '& /)*(9(/ &
x 9A'(*(-/5;( '(+5,>+( ,-.
6XSSO\
R : 6 ' ,++ -(: A+,-&/
A('6 '9,-)( +(;(+/ 6 P
x -)(-&5;(/ & ,)*5(;(
.(A+ 89(-& 6 -(:
x ,QYHVWPHQWV 5-& A?>+5)
(/A()5,++8 6 ' 6'(5<*&
x -)(-&5;(/ & /*56& & ',5+
9 .(/
6?(+ (665)5(-)8 6 ' ,++ &',-/A '&
x 3HUIRUPDQFH VWDQGDUGV -
,QGXVWU\
4!
P 2>(/& ,;,5+,>+( &()*- + <83 5- &*( ) -&( & 6 >?5+.5-</ 5/ ?-.('/& . & 9(,- -(,' R(' #(-('<8 ?/( >?5+.5-</ ,C5- & &*( A,//5;( * ?/( /&,-.,'. .(;(+ A(. 5- ('9,-8 ! &( &*,& ,++ &59( /),+(/ 5- &*5/ &,>+( '(6(' & &*( <+ >,+ ) -&( & 9( '(<5 -/ - &,>+8 5-.?/&'5,+5/(. '(<5 -/ :5++ >( ( A()&(. & 9 ;( 9?)* 9 '( B?5)C+8
PHQWV
LQYHVW
?>+5)
'HPDQG 7UDQVSRUW
6 ' ,++ (-('<8#) -/?95-<
(-('<8 (665)5(-)8 /&,-.,'./
x 8-,95),++8 5-)'(,/5-<
( 5/&5-< /& )C 2'(&' 65&3
ZRUNV
/& )C
R - 4 # 8(,'/ ! 6 ' ,++
6 ' ,++ -(:
IUDPH
'(<?+,& '8
R - $# 8(,'/
,9>5&5 ?/
!
P
SHUIRUPDQFH OHYHOV 6
x -)(-&5;(/ & ,)*5(;(
%XLOGLQJV
;(';5(: 6 )'5&5),+ A?>+5) A +5)8 -((./
,-.
) -/5/&(-&
(&&5-<
,>+( P #
: ? * .
) ) 9
?&+
>?5+.5-< A' =()&/
,QGXVWU\
E 3
DQG HOHFWULF YHKLFOHV
WRZDUGV SOXJ LQ K\EULG
SULYDWH VHFWRU LQYHVWPHQWV
65-,-)5,+ 5-)(-&5;(/ & VWHHU
x , 5-)(-&5;(/ ' &*('
9 .(/
SHUIRUPDQFH &',-/A '&
.(A+ 89(-& 6 KLJKHVW
WHUP YLVLRQ
( 5/&5-< A+,-&/ :5&* ORQJ
x 9A' ;5-< A('6 '9,-)( 6
-(: A+,-&/
SHUIRUPDQFH +(;(+/ 5-& ,++
x ?/*5-< &*( .(;(+ A9(-& ,-. x -) 'A ',&5-< KLJKHVW
7UDQVSRUW
'(-(:,>+( A :(' / ?')(/
DQG GHSOR\PHQW 6
x ?/*5-< &*( GHYHORSPHQW
6XSSO\
x 5'()&5-< A'5;,&( 5-;(/&9(-&/ & /?/&,5-,>+( / +?&5 -/ >8 66('5-< ORZ LQWHUHVW ORDQV IURP JRYHUQPHQW IXQGV WR EDQNV
6+ :/
4
/&,<(/ &*' ?<* JRYHUQPHQW EDFNHG PDWFK IXQGLQJ &*,& '(.?)(/ '5/C ,;('/5 - & X)+(,-&()*Y - &*( ),A5&,+ 9,'C(&
x ,5/5-< 6 ),A5&,+ 6 ' VHHG LQYHVWPHQW 5- +(,- -('<8 ()*- + <8 ;(-&?'(/ -)'(,/5-< 6?-.5-< 6+ :/ & X)+(,-&()*Y 5- (,'+8
x 9A*,/5/ - ?>+5) '5;,&( ,'&-('/*5A/ & .(9 -/&',&( .(A+ 8 ,-. .()'(,/( ) /&/ 6 ' /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 / +?&5 -/
Â&#x20AC; (9 -/&',&5 - Â&#x20AC; (A+ 89(-&
PHQW
LQYHVW
'LUHFWLQJ x ?>+5) A +5)5(/ .(/5<-(. & )'(,&( OHYHUDJH RI SULYDWH LQYHVWPHQWV &*' ?<* &*( 5-- ;,&5 - ;,+?( )*,5- 6 (/(,')* Â&#x20AC; (;(+ A9(-&
VKLS
SHUIRUPDQFH OHYHOV 5-& ,++
OHDGHU
x -) 'A ',&5-< KLJKHVW
%XLOGLQJV
'HPDQG
;(';5(: 6 )'5&5),+ A'5;,&( /()& ' (66 '&/ ,-. '(B?5'(. /?AA '& A +5)5(/
A'5;,&(
-,>+5-<
,>+( P # 4
'HPDQG ',-<( 6 .(9,-. A +5)5(/ : ?+. >( '(B?5'(. & (-/?'( ,9>5&5 ?/ (-('<8 (665)5(-)8 ,. A&5 - ,-. 5-)'(,/(. (+()&'565),&5 - 6(: A +5)8 >=()&5;(/ ,-. A &(-&5,+ 9(,/?'(/ ,'( .(&,5+(. >(+ : - &*( %XLOGLQJV /()& ' A +5)8 >=()&5;(/ 5-)+?.( 5-)'(,/5-< &*( &*('9,+ (665)5(-)8 6 &*( >?5+.5-< 5&/(+6 ,/ :(++ ,/ '(.?)5-< (-('<8 .(9,-. 6' 9 ,AA+5,-)(/ ,-. +5<*&5-<
,>+( P #
(9,-.#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( ?5+.5-</ /()& '0 '(&' 65&
%8,/',1*6
7+(50$/ ()),&,(1&< ± 5(752),7
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
(&' 65&&5-< 6 (-&5'( ( 5/&5-< * ?/5-< /& )C >8 ' >(6 '( 4 $ 5 ( '(&' 65& ',&(/ '(,)*5-< 4O D A(' 8(,'
x
(&' 65& :*5)* '(/?+&/ 5- , '(.?)&5 - 6 *(,& ) -/?9A&5 - >8 ! D ' 9 '( - ,;(',<( ,-. /?AA+5(/ &*( '(9,5-5-< .(9,-. 9 /&+8 ;5, / +,' &*('9,+ ,-. *(,& A?9A /8/&(9/
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
?>+5) 65-,-)5-< /?AA '& 5-5&5,&5;(/
x
x
,'&-('/*5A/ :5&* (-('<8 ) 9A,-5(/ &
) -/5.('5-< + -< A,8>,)C &59(/ ,-. +,'<(
65-,-)( 9(,/?'(/ ;5, , 6(( - '(.?)(.
?A6' -& ) /& x
(-('<8 >5++/
A6' -& 5-;(/&9(-& /?AA '& 5/ '(B?5'(.
'5-)5A,+ ,<(-& A' >+(9
&( &*,& '(&' 65& +(;(+/ ,'( )?''(-&+8 $O D 5- 9 /& '(<5 -/ ,-. &*('(6 '( &*( +(;(+/ '(B?5'(. 5- &*( )(-,'5 A'(/(-& , ) -/5.(',>+( 5-)'(,/(
,>+( P # "
(9,-.#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( ?5+.5-</ /()& '0 -(: >?5+.
%8,/',1*6
7+(50$/ ()),&,(1&< ± 1(: %8,/'
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
' <'(//5;(+8 9 ;5-< & , -(,'#R(' (-('<8 ?/( -(: >?5+.5-< /&,-.,'. >8 4
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
9>5&5 ?/ >?5+.5-< ) .(/ 6 ' -(:
x
A6' -& 5-;(/&9(-&
>?5+.5-</
x
'5-)5A,+ ,<(-& A' >+(9
V ,+C5-< &*( &,+CL0 . A&5-< &*( /&,-.,'.
x
',5-5-< '(B?5'(9(-&/
x
6 ' ,++ A?>+5)+8 A' )?'(. >?5+.5-</
*( A'5-)5A,+ ,<(-& A' >+(9 ' V+,-.+ '.#&(-,-&#A' >+(9L '(6('/ & &*( /5&?,&5 - :*('( &*( A'5-)5A,+ .()5/5 -#9,C(' 6 ' ,- 5-;(/&9(-& 5/ - & &*( A('/ - :*5)* : ?+. >(-(65& 6' 9 &*( 5-;(/&9(-& *5/ ),- +(,. & >,''5('/ & ) /&#(66()&5;( 5-;(/&9(-&/ >(5-< 9,.( )+,//5) ( ,9A+( ,'( (-('<8#(665)5(-)8 9(,/?'(/ 5- >?5+.5-</ :*5)* ,'( - & :-(. >8 &*(5' ))?A5('/0 &*( 5-;(/&9(-& *,/ & >( 9,.( >8 &*( :-(' >?& &*( '(.?)(. (-('<8 >5++/ ,'( >(-(65)5,+ & &*( &(-,-& 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ??'
,>+( P # $
(9,-.#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( ?5+.5-</ /()& '0 ,AA+5,-)(/ (&)
%8,/',1*6
$33/,$1&(6 $1' /,*+7,1*
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
<<'(//5;(+8 9 ;5-< & &*( 9 /& (665)5(-& &()*- + <5(/
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
8-,95),++8 5-)'(,/5-< (-('<8 (665)5(-)8
x
?-.(. ',&5 -,+5&8P
/&,-.,'./ >,/(. - 6 ' ,++ (-('<8#
x
(> ?-. (66()&/ 5- ,AA+5,-)(/L (+()&'5)5&8
) -/?95-< A' .?)&/ 5-)+?.5-< +5<*&5-<
?/(
- &*( ',-/A '& /()& ' &*('( ,'( 6 ?' 5-6+?(-&5,+ 6,)& '/ &*,& ,AA+8 & > &* A,//(-<(' ,-. 6'(5<*& &',-/A '& ,-. &*,& -((. & >( ,..'(//(. >8 A +5)5(/ 5- &*5/ /()& '0 x )&5;5&8 x &'?)&?'( 29 .,+ /*56&3 x -&(-/5&8 x ?(+
,>+( P #
(9,-.#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( ',-/A '& /()& '0 9 .,+ /*56&
75$163257
$&7,9,7< $1' 6758&785( ,1&/ 02'$/ 6+,)7
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
;5-< +,'<( ; +?9(/ 6 )?''(-& ,-. 6?&?'( A,//(-<(' &',;(+ 6' 9 5-.5;5.?,+ ,5' ,-. ' ,. 9 .(/ & &*( 9 /& (665)5(-& 9 .(/ /?)* ,/ *?9,-#A :('(. ',5+ ' /*,'(. ' ,. 9 .(/
x
;5-< & ,+&('-,&5;(/ & A' ;5.( /(';5)(/ /?)* ,/ ;5.( #) -6('(-)5-< 6 ' >?/5-(// &',;(+ ,-. '(.?)(. ) 99?&(' &',;(+ &*' ?<* '(<5 -,+ A+,--5-<
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
x
+5)5(/ .(+5;('5-< *5<*#B?,+5&8 A?>+5) &',-/A '& ,& ) 9A(&5&5;( A'5)(/
x x
?A<',.( A?>+5) &',-/A '&
5/#5-)(-&5;5/5-< ),' ?/( ,-. 5-)(-&5;5/5-< &*(' 9 .(/ ( < ) -<(/&5 - )*,'<5-< A?>+5) )8)+( *5'( /)*(9(/
,'<( 5-;(/&9(-&/ & /8/&(9/
x
?>+5) A(')(A&5 -
?/&,5-,>+( ?'>,- E +,-.#?/( A+,--5-< & /?/&,5- + ),+ ,-. E ' + :#(-('<8 &',-/A '& /8/&(9/
x
5<* /A((. ',5+:,8 /8/&(9/ >(&:((- +,'<( )5&8 )(-&'(/ & )*,++(-<( /* '&# ,-. 9(.5?9 .5/&,-)( ,5' &',;(+
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
) ) 9
??&
,>+( P # P
(9,-.#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( ',-/A '& /()& '0 (+()&'565),&5 -
75$163257
,17(16,7< $1' )8(/ ,1&/ (/(&75,),&$7,21
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
D 6 ;(*5)+(/ & >( (+()&'5) ' A+?<#5- *8>'5./ >(6 '( 4 $
x
D 6 V+,/&#95+(L &'?)C/ & >( (+()&'5) >(6 '( 4 $
x
D 6 ',5+ &',-/A '& & >( (+()&'5) >8 4 $
x
*,/5-< 5- /?/&,5-,>+8 / ?')(. >5 6?(+/ 2/(( ,+/ >(+ :3
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
x
,&,+8/5-< (/&,>+5/*9(-& 6 ;(*5)+( )*,'<5-< -(&: 'C/
x
,'<( 5-;(/&9(-&/ & (+()&'568 ',5+ /8/&(9/ .5665)?+& 5- + :#.(-/5&8 '(<5 -/
('6 '9,-)( /&,-.,'./ 6 ' ;(*5)+(/
x
-;(/&9(-&/ 5- (+()&'5) )*,'<5-< -(&: 'C/
- &*( ,QGXVWU\ /()& ' 9,-8 .566('(-& A +5)5(/ ),- >( ;5/?,+5/(. &*,& ,59 ,& 5-)'(,/5-< > &* (-('<8 ,-. 9,&('5,+ (665)5(-)8
,>+( P # !
(9,-.#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( -.?/&'8 /()& '
,1'8675<
(1(5*< $1' 0$7(5,$/ ()),&,(1&<
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
5-595/( ?/( 6 (-('<8 ,-. 9,&('5,+/ 6 ' ,++ 5-.?/&'5,+ A' .?)&5 -
x
(#?/( ,& &*( ) -/?9(' (-.
x
A&59,+ '()8)+5-< ',&(/
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
x
&'5-<(-& A('6 '9,-)( /&,-.,'./ 6 ' )?''(-& ,-. -(: 5-/&,++,&5 -/
x x
(#?/( /)*(9(/ ( < 6 ' <+,// > &&+(/
x
5-/&,++,&5 -/ x
&,&(# 6#&*(#,'& '()8)+5-< 5-6',/&'?)&?'(/ ,-. 9,-,<(9(-& (: 9,&('5,+/
-;(/&9(-&/ '(B?5'(. & ?A<',.( ( 5/&5-< -;(/&9(-&/ '(B?5'(. & 5-)'(,/( '()8)+5-<
x
N '(B?5'(. & 59A' ;( 9,&('5,+ (665)5(-)8
6XSSO\ VLGH H[FO ELRHQHUJ\
66 '&/ ,'( ,+'(,.8 ?-.(':,8 5- ;,'5 ?/ A,'&/ 6 &*( : '+. & /A?' &*( <' :&* 6 '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 ,-. &*( ',)( 5/ - & >?5+. &()*-5),+ ( A('&5/( ,-. ),A5&,+5/( - &*( () - 95) ,-. / )5,+ >(-(65&/
4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ???
,>+( P #
?AA+8#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/0 '(-(:,>+( *(,& ,-. A :('
32:(5
5(1(:$%/( +($7 $1' 32:(5
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
-&5-?(. ',A5. .(A+ 89(-& 6 '(-(:,>+( / ?')(/ 6 ' A :(' ,-. &*('9,+ ?/(
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
x
((.#5- &,'566 /8/&(9/ & <5;( + -<#&('9
'5. 5-&(<',&5 -
A'5)( /5<-,+/ x
&'(,9+5-5-< 6 A+,--5-< A' )(//(/
x
N /?AA '&
/ 9(-&5 -(. ,> ;( &*( C(8 '(B?5'(9(-& 6 ' &*( A :(' /()& ' 5- &*5/ -('<8 )(-,'5 5/ &*( '(,.5-(// 6 A :(' <'5./ 6 ' , -(: (', 6 , .5;('/565(. A :(' / ?')( 95
,>+( P #
?AA+8#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/0 A :(' <'5./
32:(5
32:(5 6<67(0 5($',1(66
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
-/?'( A :(' /8/&(9/ ,'( ,>+( & 9,-,<( *5<* /*,'(/ 6 /?AA+8#.'5;(- A :(' / ?')(/
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
-)'(,/5-< &',-/95//5 - ),A,)5&5(/
x
x
' ;5/5 - 6 /& ',<(
x
N 5-& /9,'& A :(' /8/&(9
(#&*5-C5-< 6 A :(' /8/&(9 9,-,<(9(-& '(B?5'(.
x
9,-,<(9(-&
,'<( 5-;(/&9(-&/ '(B?5'(. 5-& <'5. 5-6',/&'?)&?'(
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
,>+( P #
?AA+8#/5.( A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/0 (-('<8 &',-/5&5 - 6 ' &*( '?',+ A '
32:(5
(1(5*< 75$16,7,21 )25 7+( 585$/ 3225
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
'(,&( &*( '5<*& 9,'C(& (-;5' -9(-& 6 ' , &',-/5&5 - & )+(,- '(+5,>+( ,-. ,66 '.,>+( (-('<8 & &*( '?',+ A ' 5- .(;(+ A5-< ) ?-&'5(/
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
5'()& ?/( 6 / +,' *(,&
x
-;(/&9(-& '(B?5'(9(-&/
x
665)5(-& ?/( 6 >5 9,// '(/ ?')(/
x
/&,>+5/*(. 6 //5+ 6?(+ /?>/5.5(/
: ? * .
) ) 9
??;
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x x x x
,-. ?/( ,-. 6 . /()?'5&8 <'5)?+&?',+ ,-. A' )(//5-< 5-A?&/
(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</
/DQG XVH DQG IRRG VHFXULW\ & 5/ ;5&,+ & A' ;5.( *?9,- /(';5)(/ /?)* ,/ 6 . ,-59,+ 6((. 65>'( +5;5-< /A,)( ,-. (-('<8 5- , /?/&,5-,>+( :,8 (-/?'5-< &*,& -,&?',+ () /8/&(9 6?-)&5 -/ ,'( A'(/(';(.
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
" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ??-
,>+( P # 4
5 (-('<8 A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ ,-. ( ,9A+(/0 +,-. ?/(
%,2(1(5*<
/$1' 86( $1' )22' 6(&85,7<
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
,-,<5-< ,++ -(: +,-. ?/( / &*,& - .5/A+,)(9(-& 6 59A '&,-& +,-. 6?-)&5 -/ ))?'/0 >5 .5;('/5&8 ,-. () /8/&(9 A' &()&5 - ),'> - /& ',<( 5- ),'> - /& )C *?9,- .(;(+ A9(-& A' ;5/5 - 6 6((. 6 . ,-. 65>'(
x
(;(+ A /?)* , 6',9(: 'C ,-. ,)) 9A,-85-< )('&565),&5 - /)*(9(/ 6 ' >5 9,// ,-. >5 (-('<8 ,/ , A5 -((' /()& '
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
x
-&('-,&5 -,+ ,<'((9(-& - +,-. ?/( 9,-,<(9(-&
x
),- /+ : 5-&('-,&5 -,+ ,<'((9(-&
-&('-,&5 -,+ N A' <',99( 6 '
x
/?/&,5-,>+( ,<'5)?+&?'( x
566('(-& -,&5 -,+ 2() - 95)3 5-&('(/&/ ((. 6 ' ) 9A'(*(-/5;( &',)5-< /8/&(9 6 ' >5 (-('<8 )*,5-/
5 9,// ,-. >5 (-('<8 /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 )('&565),&5 - /)*(9(/ ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 & A +5)8 .(;(+ A9(-&
x
' &*( ( ,9A+( 6 /?<,' ),-( ,-. ),&&+( 5-&(<',&5 - /(( $ # 4
<'5)?+&?',+ ,-. A' )(//5-< 5-A?&/ +5)8 /* ?+. >( .(;(+ A(. &*,& A' ;5.(/ 5-)(-&5;(/ 6 ' 95-595/5-< ,<'5)?+&?',+ 5-A?&/ ,-. 9, 595/5-< '() ;('8 6 &*(/( 5-A?&/ ,>+( P # ) -&,5-/ 6?'&*(' /?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' ,-. ( ,9A+(/ 6 /?)* A +5)8 - ,..5&5 - A +5)8 &*,& 5-)(-&5;5/(/ &*( .(A+ 89(-& 6 '(-(:,>+( (-('<8 &()*- + <5(/ /* ?+. (-,>+( &*( -5&' <(- 6('&5+5/(' 5-.?/&'8 & /:5&)* & /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 ,-. 6((./& )C / ?')(/ ,/ .(/)'5>(. 5- ()&5 - $ "
,>+( P #
5 (-('<8 A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ ,-. ( ,9A+(/0 ,<'5)?+&?',+ ,-. A' )(//5-< 5-A?&/
%,2(1(5*<
$*5,&8/785$/ $1' 352&(66,1* ,13876
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
+ /5-< ,<'5)?+&?',+ -?&'5(-& )8)+(/
x
+ /5-< :,&(' + A/ 5- A' )(//5-< A+,-&/
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
x
-)(-&5;(/ 6 ' 95-595/5-< ,<'5)?+&?',+ 5-A?&/ >8 A'()5/5 - 6,'95-<
x
+5)8 6',9(: 'C 6 ' -?&'5(-& ) ++()&5 - 6' 9 '(/5.?( ,-. :,/&( /&'(,9/
) - 95) ?-,&&',)&5;(-(// ,& + : A'5)(/ 6 ,<'5)?+&?',+ 6('&5+5/('/
x
+ : .5//(95-,&5 - 6 ,<'5)?+&?',+ C- :+(.<( -((.(. 6 ' A'()5/5 - 6,'95-<
5HVLGXHV DQG ZDVWH / '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( ,'( , >8#A' .?)& 6 &*(' A' )(//(/ &*(5' 9, 59?9 /?/&,5-,>+( ?/( 6 ' (-('<8 A?'A /(/ 5/ ,- 59A '&,-& >=()&5;( -8 A +5)8 (66 '& /* ?+. &,C( 5-& ) -/5.(',&5 - :*5)* >8#A' .?)&/ ,+'(,.8 *,;( ,- &*(' ?/( (-/?'5-< &*,& &*(
$ : ? * .
) ) 9
??#
?/( 6 '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( 6 ' (-('<8 A?'A /(/ . (/ - & ),?/( ?-.(/5',>+( .5/A+,)(9(-& (66()&/ - &*(' 59A '&,-& ,/A()& 5/ & 59A' ;( &*( 5-6',/&'?)&?'( 6 ' ) ++()&5 - 6 '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( / &*,& ,++ '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( &*,& ,'( <(-(',&(. ),- >( ?/(. 5- ,- (665)5(-& ,-. ) /& (66()&5;( :,8 *5/ 5/ /?99,'5/(. 5- ,>+( P # "
,>+( P # "
5 (-('<8 A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ ,-. ( ,9A+(/0 (/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&(
%,2(1(5*<
5(6,'8(6 $1' :$67(
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
,C5-< /?/&,5-,>+( A &(-&5,+ 6 '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( ,;,5+,>+( 6 ' &*( (-('<8 /()& ' & (-/?'( 6?++ ?/( 6 &*( /?/&,5-,>+( A &(-&5,+
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
x
)*(9(/ 5-)(-&5;5/5-< &*( ?/( 6 '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( 6 ' >5 (-('<8
5665)?+&8 & .(&('95-( .(65-5&5 - &*,& 5.(-&565(/ -+8 '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( 9,&('5,+/ &*,& *,;( - ,+&('-,&5;( ?/(
x
) - 95) ?-,&&',)&5;(-(// 6 '(/5.?( ,-. :,/&( ) ++()&5 - .?( & +,)C 6 5-6',/&'?)&?'(
&RPSOHPHQWDU\ IHOOLQJV (: >5 9,// 5/ >(5-< )'(,&(. ) -&5-? ?/+8 5- 6 '(/&/ /*,'( 6 &*5/ <' :&* ),- >( *,';(/&(. /?/&,5-,>+8 ,-. ?/(. 6 ' (-('<8 A?'A /(/
*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5-)+?.(/ : .8 >5 9,// 6' 9 /?/&,5-,>+( *,';(/&5-< 6 ,..5&5 -,+ 6 '(/& <' :&* ,-. , /*,'( 6 >5 9,// &*,& :,/ A'(;5 ?/+8 ?/(. ,/ &',.5&5 -,+ >5 9,//
*5/ A &(-&5,+ ( )+?.(/ : . 6' 9 ?-.5/&?'>(. 6 '(/&/ ,-. - -#) 99(')5,+ /A()5(/ & /,6(<?,'. 6 '(/& ,-. >5 .5;('/5&8 ) -/(';,&5 - +5)8 ) -)('-5-< ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ /* ?+. &*('(6 '( >( ,59(. ,& 5.(-&5685-< + ),&5 -/ ,-. ,9 ?-&/ 6 6 '(/& <' :&* &*,& ),- >( *,';(/&(. /?/&,5-,>+8 ,-. ,& (-/?'5-< &*,& &*( '(9,5-.(' 6 6 '(/& 5/ +(6& 5-&,)& *5/ A +5)8 ,AA' ,)* ),- >( ) 9A+(9(-&(. >8 )('&565),&5 - /)*(9(/ 6 ' A' A('+8 9,-,<(. 6 '(/& '(/ ?')(/ *5/ 5/ /?99,'5/(. 5- ,>+( P # $
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ??7
,>+( P # $
5 (-('<8 A +5)8 /?<<(/&5 -/ ,-. ( ,9A+(/0 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</
%,2(1(5*<
&203/(0(17$5< )(//,1*6
32/,&< 2%-(&7,9( x
.(-&5685-< + ),&5 -/ ,-. ,9 ?-&/ 6 6 '(/& <' :&* &*,& ),- >( *,';(/&(. /?/&,5-,>+8 ,-. 9,C5-< /?'( &*,& &*(' 6 '(/& 5/ +(6& 5-&,)&
(;$03/(6
%$55,(56 7+5($76
x
x
x
+5)8 6',9(: 'C 6 ' /?/&,5-,>+(
5665)?+&8 & . 6 '(/& ,//(//9(-&/ ,-.
9,-,<(9(-& 6 6 '(/& '(/ ?')(/
) -&' ++(. *,';(/&5-< (/A()5,++8 5-
('&565),&5 - /)*(9(/ 6 ' A' A('+8
'(9 &( + ),&5 -/
9,-,<(. 6 '(/& '(/ ?')(/
5HFRPPHQGDWLRQV
+&* ?<* A +5)5(/ ,'( -()(//,'8 & ,..'(// ,++ /()& '/ 6 &*( (-('<8 /8/&(9 / 9( A +5)8 -((./ ,'( 9 '( A'(//5-< &*,- &*('/ >(),?/( &*(8 '(A'(/(-& HQDEOLQJ IDFWRUV0 6,5+5-< & ,..'(// &*(9 :5++ *,;( '(A(')?//5 -/ 6 ' &*( +5C(+5* . 6 /?))(// 5- -( ' /(;(',+ &*(' /()& '/
*( &: NH\ HQDEOLQJ IDFWRUV 5- &*5/ -('<8 )(-,'5 ,'(0 x &' -< (-('<8 (665)5(-)8 9(,/?'(/ ) ?A+(. :5&* (+()&'565),&5 - 6 ' '(9,5-5-< .(9,-. x
*( A'(A,',&5 - 6 ?' (-('<8 <'5./ & ) A( :5&* &*( 5-)'(,/5-< .(9,-. 6 ' '(-(:,>+( 6&(- /?AA+8#.'5;(- (+()&'5)5&8 - ,..5&5 - , /(& 6 A +5)8 ,-. 9,'C(& '?+(/ -((./ & >( (-6 ')(. :*5)* (-/?'(/ &*,& &*( /?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 >5 9,// ?/( 6 ' (-('<8 5/ /,6(<?,'.(.
*( '(9,5-5-< A +5)8 '(B?5'(9(-&/ ),-- & (,/5+8 >( A'5 '5&5/(.0 &*(8 ,++ -((. & >( ,..'(//(. & ,++ : &*5/ )(-,'5 & >() 9( , '(,+5&8 ,-. &*( ',-C5-< 6 >=()&5;(/ :5++ .(A(-. /&' -<+8 - &*( + ),+ ) -&( &
*('( ,'( * :(;(' / 9( A +5)5(/ :*5)* (5&*('0 x *,;( , + -< +,< &59( & 6?++ 59A+(9(-&,&5 x *,;( (66()&/ 6 ' 9,-8 .(),.(/ & ) 9( x '(+8 - 9,&?'( &()*- + <5(/ -+8 ' x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
P : ? * .
) ) 9
??A
- & ( 5/& P4 - A',)&5)( , A +5)8 95 5/ ,+:,8/ '(B?5'(. & (66()&5;(+8 5-)(-&5;5/( &*( .5;('/5&8 6 /()& '/ ,-. &()*- + <5(/ & 5/ )+(,' &*,& -(: 9(&* ./ 6 ' 5-&(<',&5-< &*( '5/C ,-. &*( &'?( ) /& 6 ?' (-('<8 '(/ ?')(/ -((. & >( 6 ?-. & (-/?'( '(#.5'()&5 - & :,'./ /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 / +?&5 -/
*( >(-(65& 6 &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5/ &*,& 5& ) ?+. 6 '9 &*( >,/5/ 6 ' , /(& 6 )+(,' 5-.5),& '/ 6 &*( 59A,)& 6 A +5)5(/ 5- (,)* /()& ' ( < x *,& 5/ &*( ,;(',<( ,9 ?-& 6 (-('<8 ?/(. 5- &*( () - 98 & A' .?)( , & --( 6 /&((+J x : 6,' *,;( :( ) 9( 5- ,. A&5-< D A+?<#5- *8>'5. ' (+()&'5) ),' ) -)(A&J x *,& 5/ &*( /*,'( 6 A,//(-<(' &',;(+ (66()&(. ;5, ?' ',5+/ ',&*(' &*,- ?' ' ,./J x : 9,-8 6 ?' * ?/(/ *,;( >((- '(&' 65&&(. & 95-59?9 (-('<8 /&,-.,'. ,-. ,'( :( /&5++ ,++ :5-< - -#A,//5;( * ?/(/ & >( >?5+&J x *,& 5/ &*( /*,'( 6 '(-(:,>+( A :(' 5- ?' + ),+ () - 98J x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
(95//5 -/ *5+( 9,-8 A +5)5(/ ,59(. ,& '(.?)5-< (95//5 -/ 9,8 ,+/ *,;( ,- (66()& - &*( (-('<8 /8/&(9 &*(8 6&(- . - & ,-. : ?+. &*?/ 95// &*( < ,+ :5&* '(/A()& & &*5/ )(-,'5 P4
' ( ,9A+( 6 ' /()& '/ :5&* + : A'5)( (+,/&5)5&8 , ),'> - A'5)( : ?+. - & -()(//,'5+8 >( &*( 9 /& (66()&5;( 5-/&'?9(-& .(A(-.5-< - &*( /()& ' ,-. + ),+ )5')?9/&,-)(/ ! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ??,
&RQFOXVLRQV
6?++8 '(-(:,>+( <+ >,+ (-('<8 /8/&(9 5/ A //5>+( : '+.:5.(0 :( ),- '(,)* , $D /?/&,5-,>+8 / ?')(. (-('<8 /?AA+8 >8 4 $
*('( ,'( ?A6' -& 5-;(/&9(-&/ '(B?5'(. & 9,C( &*5/ &',-/5&5 - 5- &*( ) 95-< .(),.(/ 2 O4D 6 <+ >,+ 3 >?& &*(8 :5++ &?'- 5-& , A /5&5;( ),/* 6+ : ,6&(' 4 $ +(,.5-< & , A /5&5;( ,--?,+ '(/?+& 6 4D 6 5- 4 $ P %DVHOLQH a (- D
(-(:,>+( :('
$
(-(:,>+( (,& N ?(+/
5-,+ -('<8 2 GE,3
<<'(//5;( (-.# ?/( (-('<8 /,;5-</ ,-. (+()&'565),&5 -
//5+ N ?)+(,'
"
4
?>/&5&?&5 - 6 &',.5&5 -,+ >8 '(-(:,>+( / ?')(/
4 5<?'( ! #
(9,5-5-< 6 //5+ 6?(+/
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
; +?&5 - 6 (-('<8 /?AA+8 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 /* :5-< &*( C(8 .(;(+ A9(-&/
*( C(8 )*,++(-<(/ & ,)*5(;5-< &*5/ &',-/5&5 - +5( 5- &*( 6 ++ :5-< 6,)& '/0 x x x x
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
(.?)&5 -/ 5- 4#(95//5 -/ .?'5-< &*( A('5 . 4 #4 $ ,-. &*('(,6&(' '(A'(/(-& ,- ,..5&5 -,+ +,'<( () - 95) ;,+?(
P
: ? * .
) ) 9
??+
(' A('/ - 65-,+ (-('<8 ?/( 2 GE,E),A5&,3
$ "$ "
-#'(-(:,>+(/
$ 4$ 4 $
(-(:,>+(/
$ 4
5<?'( ! # 4
4
4 4
4
4 "
4 $
; +?&5 - 6 A(' ),A5&, '(-(:,>+( ,-. - -#'(-(:,>+( (-('<8 .(9,-.
" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?;'
$SSHQGL[ $
,>+( #
.H\ ILJXUHV
+ >,+ (-('<8 A' ;5.(. >8 / ?')( ,-. 8(,' 2 GE,3
6RXUFH
7RWDO HOHFWULFLW\ (- D
5-. A :('0 -#/* '(
4
"
P
"
44
4$
5-. A :('0 66#/* '(
$
"
P
,;( N 5.,+
* & ; +&,5) / +,'
P
$
P
-)(-&',&(. / +,'0 :('
P
4
8.' A :('
P
"
" "
" !
"
( &*('9,+
P
P
"
"
5 9,//
P
4
,+
! 4
4 $
" !
$ "
,/
!
"
4$
4!
4
5+
" 4
4 $
"
$
?)+(,'
$
! 4
$
!
4
-)(-&',&(. / +,'0 (,&
"
4
! !
( &*('9,+
4
4
5 9,//
" P
" !
//5+ 6?(+/
4 P
P4
$
"4 4
!
4 $
%XLOGLQJ IXHOV KHDW (- D
+,' &*('9,+
P
4
( &*('9,+
4
$
$
"
$
! "
5 9,//
"
4
4 4
" 4
4
//5+ 6?(+/
""
$
$ $
P
7UDQVSRUW IXHOV (- D
P
" !
4
4 P
"$ P
$ !
!$ $
P !
! !
P
,QGXVWU\ IXHOV KHDW (- D
5 9,// //5+ 6?(+/ *UDQG WRWDO (- D
" : ? * .
) ) 9
?;&
,>+( # 4
+ >,+ (-('<8 A' ;5.(. >8 / ?')( ,-. 8(,' 2 GE,3 # (')(-&,<(/
6RXUFH
7RWDO HOHFWULFLW\ (- D
5-. A :('0 -#/* '(
D
4D
D
PD
4 D
4 D
5-. A :('0 66#/* '(
D
D
D
D
D
$D
,;( N 5.,+
D
D
D
D
D
D
* & ; +&,5) / +,'
D
D
D
!D
D
4 D
-)(-&',&(. / +,'0 :('
D
D
D
$D
D
PD
8.' A :('
PD
D
D
PD
"D
4D
( &*('9,+
D
D
D
4D
D
"D
5 9,//
D
D
D
D
4D
D
,+
" D
D
4 D
4D
$D
D
,/
D
4 D
D
D
D
D
5+
D
$D
D
4D
D
D
?)+(,'
"D
"D
D
"D
D
D
,QGXVWU\ IXHOV KHDW (- D
-)(-&',&(. / +,'0 (,&
D
D
D
D
"D
$D
( &*('9,+
D
D
D
D
D
$D
5 9,//
D
!D
4 D
"4D
$D
$ D
//5+ 6?(+/
!D
4D
P D
$PD
4 D
4 D
%XLOGLQJ IXHOV KHDW (- D
+,' &*('9,+
D
D
"D
PD
"D
$4D
( &*('9,+
D
D
4D
D
44D
$D
5 9,//
" D
D
D
4 D
44D
D
//5+ 6?(+/
$PD
D
D
$ D
44D
D
7UDQVSRUW IXHOV (- D
D
$D
4D
4D
P D
D
D
$D
!!D
!D
4PD
D
5 9,// //5+ 6?(+/ *UDQG WRWDO (- D
"4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?;?
$SSHQGL[ %
%
'HPDQG DVVXPSWLRQV
,QGXVWULDO DFWLYLW\ HYROXWLRQ
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x
5/5-< 5-&(-/5&8 6 ?/( & , 9, 59?9 6 ++ :(. >8 , .()'(,/( -)( ,- () - 98 *,/ .(;(+ A(. 25 ( , + & 6 9,&('5,+/ ,'( ?/(. & >?5+. &*( >,/5) 5-6',/&'?)&?'( 6 , .(;(+ A5-< () - 983 x ;(',++ + :(' 9,&('5,+ 5-&(-/5&8 &*( +,&(' ,- () - 98 .(;(+ A/ 25 ( 5& &,C(/ +(// 9,&('5,+ - : & .(;(+ A ,- () - 98 &*,- 5& .5. 8(,'/ ,< 3 : &*(/( &: (+(9(-&/ &',-/+,&( 5-& A(' ),A5&, ) -/?9A&5 - 5/ - & /&',5<*&6 ':,'. - ,)) '.,-)( :5&* T ((+5/ 4 U :( ,//?9( /,&?',&5 - 6 &*( A(' ),A5&, ) -/?9A&5 - 5- &*( + -< &('9
5<?'( #
&8+5/(. 5-&(-/5&8 6 ?/( )?';(/ 26' 9 T ('-,'.5-5 U3
P"
&( &*,& :( ,'( ) -)('-(. :5&* A' .?)&5 - 5- &*5/ )(-,'5 ,/ 5& 5/ '(+,&(. & (-('<8 ?/( :*('(,/ )?';(/ ?/?,++8 ) -)('- ) -/?9A&5 - 5-)( :( + C ,& &*( <+ >,+ +(;(+ &*( .566('(-)( >(&:((- &*(/( 5/ -(<+5<5>+( " : ? * .
) ) 9
?;;
+&* ?<* 5& 9?/& >( - &(. &*,& 5//?(/ 6 &',.( 9,&('5,+ /?>/&5&?&5 - ,-. 9,-8 (+(9(-&/ 6 / )5(&,+ )*,-<( 9(,- &*,& &*(/( '(+,&5 -/*5A/ ,'( .5665)?+& & >/(';( (9A5'5),++8 :( *,;( -(;('&*(+(// ?/(. &*(9 & 9,C( 9 '( '(65-(. ,//?9A&5 -/ - 6?&?'( 5-.?/&'5,+ A' .?)&5 - +(;(+/ >(8 -. /59A+( ( &',A +,&5 - 6 *5/& '5),+ &'(-./
%
%XLOGLQJV DFWLYLW\ HYROXWLRQ
(/5.(-&5,+ /A,)( A(' ),A5&,
*( 6?&?'( (; +?&5 - 6 '(/5.(-&5,+ 6+ ' /A,)( 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 5/ (/&59,&(. >8 9?+&5A+85-< 6?&?'( A A?+,&5 - -?9>('/ :5&* ,- (/&59,&5 - - 6?&?'( 6+ ' ,'(, A(' ),A5&, *( (; +?&5 - 6 6+ ' ,'(, A(' ),A5&, 5/ &* ?<*& & >( )+ /(+8 +5-C(. & A(' ),A5&,
A(' ),A5&,
5<?'( # 4
&8+5/(. '(+,&5 -/*5A >(&:((- 6+ ' ,'(, ,-. A(' ),A5&, T 4 "U
+&* ?<* '(+5,>+( -?9>('/ 6 ' ,>/ +?&( 6+ ' /A,)( ,'( - & ,;,5+,>+( 6 ' ,++ : '+. '(<5 -/ &*( '(/A()&5;( ,AA' 59,&( <' :&* ',&(/ 6 6+ ' /A,)( A(' ),A5&, ),- >( +5-C(. & /?)* , '(+,&5 -/*5A *5/ 9(,-/ &*,& 6 ' .(;(+ A5-< '(<5 -/ :*5)* ,'( /5&?,&(. & &*( +(6& 6 &*( )?';( , +,'<(' <' :&* ',&( 6 '(/5.(-&5,+ /A,)( A(' ),A5&, 5/ (/&59,&(. >?& 6 ' .(;(+ A(. '(<5 -/ '(/5.(-&5,+ /A,)( A(' ),A5&, -+8 <' :/ ;('8 /+ :+8 56 ,& ,++
"" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?;-
$SSHQGL[ &
%LRHQHUJ\ DVVXPSWLRQV
*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ?/(/ &*( 6 ++ :5-< A'59,'8 5-A?&/ & A('6 '9 &*( >5 (-('<8 9 .(++5-<0 x
*( /?/&,5-,>+( '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( A &(-&5,+ .(/)'5>(. 5- ()&5 - $ ' &*(
x x x
'(/5.?( A &(-&5,+ (/&59,&5 -/ - &*( '() ;(',>+( 6',)&5 - 6 '(/5.?(/ :('( ?/(.
*(/( ,'( /A()565(. 5- AA(-.5
*( /?/&,5-,>+( (-('<8 )' A *()&,'( A &(-&5,+ ,/ .(/)'5>(. 5- ()&5 - $
*( /?/&,5-,>+( ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ A &(-&5,+ ,/ .(/)'5>(. 5- ()&5 - $ $
*( /?/&,5-,>+( ,+<,( A &(-&5,+ ,/ .(/)'5>(. 5- ()&5 - $ P
),+)?+,&( &*( .(9,-. &*,& ),- >( /?AA+5(. >8 &*( ,> ;( &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ?/(/ &: ,..5&5 -,+ .,&, / ?')(/0 x
*( 85(+./ 6 &*( (-('<8 )' A/ ?-.(' &*( ( A()&(. )5')?9/&,-)(/ - ;(';5(: 6 &*(/( 85(+./ 5/ <5;(- 5- AA(-.5 4
x
*( (665)5(-)5(/ 6 ) -;('/5 - &()*- + <5(/ ?/(. 5- 9((&5-< &*( .(9,-. ;(';5(: 6 &*(/( (665)5(-)5(/ 5/ A' ;5.(. 5- AA(-.5
&
5HFRYHUDEOH IUDFWLRQV
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x ) - 95) 6(,/5>5+5&80 ,/ 2,<'5)?+&?',+3 5-6',/&'?)&?'( 59A' ;(/ ,-. &*( ;,+?( 6 '(/5.?(/ 6 ' (-('<8 A?'A /(/ 5-)'(,/(/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 &59(6',9( () - 95) >,''5('/ & '(/5.?( ) ++()&5 - .595-5/* x
()8)+5-< 6 -?&'5(-&/0 A'59,'8 ,<'5)?+&?',+ '(/5.?(/ ,'( 5- 9,-8 ),/(/ +(6& - &*( +,-. & '()8)+( &*( -?&'5(-&/ ) -&,5-(. 5- &*(9 *5/ A',)&5)( ),- >( ,.,A&(. ,)) '.5-< & &*( )(-,'5 L/ 6',9(: 'C 6 ' '()8)+5-< -?&'5(-&/ ,6&(' (-('<8 *,/ >((- ( &',)&(. 6' 9 &*( '(/5.?(/ >8 '(&?'-5-< .5<(/&,&( 6' 9 .5<(/&5 - 6 '(/5.?(/ & &*( +,-. 6 ' ( ,9A+( *5/ 9(,-/ &*,& &*(/( '(/5.?(/ ),- >( ?/(. & /?AA+8 (-('<8 ,/ :(++ ,/ '()8)+( -?&'5(-&/
,>+( # A' ;5.(/ ,- ;(';5(: 6 &*( - -#,.,A&(. ,-. &*( ,.,A&(. 5-)+?.5-< '(,/ -5-< ,-. / ?')(/ 6 ' &*( ;,+?(/
"$ : ? * .
) ) 9
?;#
,>+( #
() ;(',>+( 6',)&5 -/ 6 '(/5.?(/ ?/(. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5
&URS
5HJLRQ
2UL 5HDVRQLQJ JLQDO
&HUHDOV
2(&'
)LVFKHU SORXJKHG EDFN IRU (ULFVVRQ VXVWDLQDELOLW\ UHDVRQV XVH IRU DQLPDO EHGGLQJ HVWLPDWHG ORVVHV HFRQRPLFDOO\ IHDVLEOH RWKHU XVHV
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\
1RQ 2(&'
SORXJKHG EDFN IRU VXVWDLQDELOLW\ UHDVRQV XVH IRU DQLPDO EHGGLQJ HVWLPDWHG ORVVHV HFRQRPLFDOO\ IHDVLEOH RWKHU XVHV PDLQO\ UXUDO HOHFWULILFDWLRQ
)LVFKHU /HZDQGRZVNL (ULFVVRQ
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\
&KLQD
SDSHU IRUDJH UXUDO HQHUJ\ UHF\FOLQJ FROOHFWLRQ
=HQJ
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\
5LFH DV D $OO VXE FDWHJRU\ RI FHUHDOV
%DVHG RQ FHUHDOV LQ &KLQD SDSHU IRUDJH UXUDO HQHUJ\ UHF\FOLQJ FROOHFWLRQ
=HQJ
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\
5DSH VHHG
2(&'
(TXDO WR FHUHDOV
)LVFKHU (ULFVVRQ
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\
1RQ 2(&'
(TXDO WR FHUHDOV
)LVFKHU /HZDQGRZVNL (ULFVVRQ
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\
6R\ EHDQV
5HIHUHQFH
8VHG 5HDVRQLQJ IRU FKDQJH KHUH
&KLQD
(TXDO WR FHUHDOV
=HQJ
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\
2(&'
(TXDO WR FHUHDOV
)LVFKHU (ULFVVRQ
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\
1RQ 2(&'
(TXDO WR FHUHDOV
)LVFKHU /HZDQGRZVNL (ULFVVRQ
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\
=HQJ
&KLQD
(TXDO WR FHUHDOV
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\
&DVVDYD
$OO
6LPLODU WR FHUHDOV EXW LQVWHDG RI )LVFKHU XVH IRU DQLPDO EHGGLQJ WKHUH LV (FRI\V XVH DV DQLPDO IHHG DQG IHUWLOLVHU H[SHUWLVH
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\ UHF\FOLQJ RI QXWULHQWV
6XJDU EHHW
2(&'
(TXDO WR FDVVDYD
)LVFKHU (FRI\V H[SHUWLVH
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\ GXH WR LPSURYHG FROOHFWLRQ WHFKQRORJ\ IRU H[DPSOH UHF\FOLQJ RI QXWULHQWV
1RQ 2(&'
(TXDO WR FDVVDYD
)LVFKHU (FRI\V H[SHUWLVH
,PSURYHG HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\ GXH WR LPSURYHG FROOHFWLRQ WHFKQRORJ\ IRU H[DPSOH UHF\FOLQJ RI QXWULHQWV
&RIIHH ± RXWHU VNLQV
$OO
(VWLPDWH
+LJK SRWHQWLDO HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\ EHFDXVH LW LV D VHFRQGDU\ UHVLGXH DQG EHFDXVH RI LQIUDVWUXFWXUH LPSURYHPHQWV OLPLWHG DPRXQW RI FRPSHWLQJ XVHV
3DOP RLO HPSW\ IUXLW EXQFKHV
$OO
(VWLPDWH LQFOXGHV UHWXUQ WR ILHOG 'HKXH DQG LQFLQHUDWLRQ ZLWKRXW HQHUJ\ UHFRYHU\
+LJK SRWHQWLDO HFRQRPLF IHDVLELOLW\ EHFDXVH LW LV D VHFRQGDU\ UHVLGXH 'HKXH LQGLFDWHV WKDW XVH DV HQHUJ\ LV HFRQRPLFDOO\ PRUH DWWUDFWLYH WKDQ RWKHU XVHV
3DOP RLO ± $OO 3DOP RLO PLOO HIIOXHQW 320(
6XJDU FDQH %DJDVVH
3RWDWRHV
(VWLPDWH EDVHG RQ IDFW WKDW WKLV LV D ZDVWH ZKLFK LV FROOHFWHG LQ SURFHVV ZDWHU LQVWDOODWLRQV
(VWLPDWH EDVHG RQ IDFW WKDW WKLV LV D ZDVWH ZKLFK LV FROOHFWHG LQ SURFHVV ZDWHU LQVWDOODWLRQV
2(&'
0RVWO\ XVHG IRU SURFHVVLQJ SODQW 0DFHLGR HQHUJ\ GHPDQG EXW OHVV WKDQ LQ 'DPHQ QRQ 2(&' UHJLRQV
6FHQDULR DVVXPHV PD[LPXP XVH IRU SURFHVVLQJ SODQW HQHUJ\ GHPDQG
1RQ 2(&'
0D[LPXP XVH IRU SURFHVVLQJ SODQW HQHUJ\ GHPDQG
6FHQDULR DVVXPHV PD[LPXP XVH IRU SURFHVVLQJ SODQW HQHUJ\ GHPDQG
2(&'
(VWLPDWH VHFRQGDU\ UHVLGXH EXW ODUJH DPRXQW XVHG LQ DQLPDO IHHG
6HFRQGDU\ UHVLGXH VR KLJK DYDLODELOLW\ :H DVVXPHG XVH LQ DQLPDO IHHG LV DQG ORVVHV DUH 2WKHU LV DYDLODEOH
1RQ 2(&'
(VWLPDWH VHFRQGDU\ UHVLGXH EXW ODUJH DPRXQW XVHG LQ DQLPDO IHHG
6HFRQGDU\ UHVLGXH VR KLJK DYDLODELOLW\ :H DVVXPHG XVH LQ DQLPDO IHHG LV DQG ORVVHV GXH WR ODFN RI LQIUDVWUXFWXUH IRU H[DPSOH DUH 2WKHU LV DYDLODEOH
(VWLPDWH EDVHG RQ (XURSHDQ GDWD RQ FRPSHWLQJ XVHV
$QLPDO IDW $OO
" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?;7
0DFHLGR 'DPHQ
&DSDUHOOD
&
<LHOG RI HQHUJ\ FURSV
,>+( # 4
5(+./ 6 (-('<8 )' A/ ?/(. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5
&URS W\SH
5DQJH RI \LHOGV &RPPHQWV DFURVV
WKH
UHJLRQV *- KD
5+/ 1 6,&/
4$O $ 2W $O
x B?,&(/ & W44# GE*, 6 &',-/A '& 6?(+ & --(
5+E*,3
x ?9>('
5-)+?.(/
A'59,'8
5+
85(+./K
,<'5)?+&?',+ ,-. 6?(+ A' )(//5-< '(/5.?(/ ,'( 5-)+?.(. (+/(:*('( x ,'C(' )' A/0 ',A(/((. / 8>(,-/ ,-. 5+ A,+9
?<,' 1 /&,')*
4 O 4
x B?,&(/ & W" # $ GE*, 6 &',-/A '& 6?(+
2W"OP & --( 6
x ?9>(' 5-)+?.(/ A'59,'8 /&,')*E/?<,' 85(+./K
/&,')*
'
/?<,'E*,3
,<'5)?+&?',+ ,-. 6?(+ A' )(//5-< '(/5.?(/ ,'( 5-)+?.(. (+/(:*('( x ,'C(' )' A/0 /?<,' ),-( ,-. 9,5R( x 5<*(/& 85(+./ 5- ?&* 9('5), .?( & /?5&,>5+5&8 6 ' /?<,' ),-(
2 5<- 3)(++?+ /5)
O 4
x B?,&(/ & W #!! GE*, 6 &',-/A '& 6?(+
)' A/
2W!O 4 & --( 6
x ?9>(' 5-)+?.(/ A'59,'8 >5 9,// 85(+./K 6?(+
.'8 9,&&('E*,3
A' )(//5-< '(/5.?(/ ,'( 5-)+?.(. (+/(:*('(
++ 85(+./ 5- ,>+( # 4 ,'(0 x
.,A&(. 6 'P$0 R R
x
&
?5&,>5+5&8 6 &*( /?/&,5-,>+( +,-. A &(-&5,+ 6 ' <' :5-< &*,& )' A &8A(
,5-#6(. )?+&5;,&5 - 2- 5''5<,&5 - !3 5;(- 5- A'59,'8 85(+. 6 &*( 9,5- A' .?)& &*(' >5 9,// '5<5-,&5-< 6' 9 &*( /,9( *()&,'( 2( < &*( >,<,//( 6 /?<,' ),-( &*( (9A&8 6'?5& >?-)*(/ 6 5+ A,+93 ,'( 5-)+?.(. 5- &*( '(/5.?(/ >&,5-(. .?'5-< >5 9,// A' )(//5-< *(/( ,'( B?,-&565(. 5- &*( ) -;('/5 - (665)5(-)5(/ &,>+( 5- ,>+( # (IILFLHQFLHV RI FRQYHUVLRQ WHFKQRORJLHV
*( (665)5(-)5(/ 6 >5 (-('<8 ) -;('/5 - &()*- + <5(/ ?/(. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ,'( >,/(. - )?''(-& >(/& A',)&5)(/ ,>+( # A' ;5.(/ &*( ?/(. ;,+?(/ ,-. 56 -()(//,'8 ,..5&5 -,+ ) 99(-&/ - &*( '5<5- ,-. ,AA+5),&5 - 6 &*(/( (665)5(-)8 ;,+?(/ ++ (665)5(-)5(/ 5- ,>+( # ,'( 6' 9 A'59,'8 >5 9,// &8A( & .(9,-. ),''5(' -8 ,<'5)?+&?',+ ' A' )(//5-< 5-A?&/ '(B?5'(. 5- ,..5&5 - & &*( A'59,'8 >5 9,// &8A( ,'( 5-)+?.(. 5- &*( ) 99(-&/ 2( < A' )(//5-< *(,& ,-. (+()&'5)5&8 *(,& ?/(. 6 ' 6('&5+5/(' A' .?)&5 -3 -8 A' )(//5-< '(/5.?(/ '(/?+&5-< 6' 9 &*( ) -;('/5 - ,'( ,+/ 5-)+?.(. 5- &*( ) 99(-&/ 2( < '(/5.?(/ /?)* ,/ &*( >,<,//( 6 /?<,' ),-( &*( (9A&8 6'?5& P$ ()&5 - $ " .(/)'5>(/ &*( 9(&* . + <8 6 ' ,.,A&5-< 85(+./ & +,-. /?5&,>5+5&8 6 ' ',5-6(. ,<'5)?+&?'( "P : ? * .
) ) 9
?;A
>?-)*(/ 6 5+ A,+93 *5/ /* ?+. >( - &(. :*(- 5-&('A'(&5-< &*( .,&, 6 ' ( ,9A+( ) -;('/5 - (665)5(-)8 6 2+5<- 3)(++?+ /( &*' ?<* 6('9(-&,&5 - /((9/ + : >?& &*( 65<?'( ,+'(,.8 5-)+?.(/ ,++ A' )(//5-< *(,& ,-. (+()&'5)5&8 5-A?&/
,>+( # 7HFKQRO RJ\ 5+E6,& & 6?(+
('9(-& ,&5 -
9# >?/&5 - P
-;('/5 - (665)5(-)5(/ 6 >5 (-('<8 &()*- + <5(/ %LRPDVV W\SH 5+ 6' 9 5+ )' A/
&RQYHUVLRQ HIILFLHQF\ !!D
&RPPHQWV
5+ 6' 9 ,+<,(
! D
&,')* ' /?<,'
! D
x 665)5(-)8 5/ 6?(+ ?&A?& ) 9A,'(. & 5+ 5-A?& ,-. 5-)+?.(/ A' )(//5-< *(,& ,-. (+()&'5)5&8 5-A?&/ x (/5.?(/ 6' 9 ,+<,( ,'( '()8)+(. 5- )?+&5;,&5 - /&(A x 665)5(-)8 5/ 6?(+ ?&A?& ) 9A,'(. & /?<,'E/&,')* 5-A?& x ..5&5 -,+ 5-A?&/ A(' G 6?(+0 4$ G 6 *(,& G (+()&'5)5&8 x ..5&5 -,+ ?&A?&/ A(' G 6?(+0 W " G 6 '(/5.?(/ A(' G 6?(+
2 5<- 3)(++ ?+ /(
D
-.?/&'5,+ .5'()& 6?(+
D
'8 :,/&( 6' 9 9?-5)5A,+ / +5. :,/&(
P!D 2 : *(,&3 P D 2 5<* *(,&3 D 2 +()&'5)5&83 $D 2 :
*(,&3 D 2 5<* *(,&3 " D 2 +()&'5)5&83 $4D
x : (665)5(-)5(/ ,//?9(. >(),?/( 6 /?> A&59,+ 6?(+ /?> A&59,+ ) 9>?/&5 - A' )(// ,-. -()(//,'8 6+?( <,/ )+(,-5-<
D 2 : *(,&3 $PD 2 5<* *(,&3 4 D 2 +()&'5)5&83 " D
x ,/(. - PD .5<(/&5 - (665)5(-)8 x 9>?/&5 - (665)5(-)8 & (-. ),''5(' (B?,+ & ) 9>?/&5 - 6 X &*(' ) 9>?/&5>+( >5 9,//Y )(A&5 -0 "$D (+()&'5) (665)5(-)8 >(),?/( <,/ (-<5-( ),- >( ?/(.
&*(' ) 9>?/&5>+ ( >5 9,//
5<(/&5 - 1 ?A<',.5< & <,/ <'5. B?,+5&8 5<(/&5 - 1 ) 9>?/&5 -
++ :(& :,/&(/
*,') ,+ A' .?)&5 -
++ : .8 >5 9,//
++ :(& :,/&(/
x 665)5(-)8 5/ 6?(+ ?&A?& ) 9A,'(. & 5+ 5-A?& x ..5&5 -,+ 5-A?&/ A(' G 6?(+0 " G 6 *(,& G (+()&'5)5&8 x ..5&5 -,+ ?&A?&/ A(' G 6?(+0 W $ G 6 '(/5.?(/ A(' G 6?(+
x 665)5(-)8 5/ 6?(+ ?&A?& ) 9A,'(. & 2+5<- 3)(++?+ /( 5-A?& ,-. 5-)+?.(/ A' )(//5-< *(,& ,-. (+()&'5)5&8 5-A?&/ x ..5&5 -,+ ?&A?&/ A(' G 6?(+0 W G 6 '(/5.?(/ A(' G 6?(+ x *( ) -;('/5 - (665)5(-)5(/ ,'( (66()&5;(+8 5-)+?.(. 5- &*( 5-.?/&'5,+ .(9,-. -?9>('/ x ,+5. 6 ' : . 6?(+ 6 ' A,A(' ,-. )(9(-& C5+- 6?(+
x ,/(. - )?''(-& >(/& A',)&5)(/
x ,/(. - PD .5<(/&5 - (665)5(-)8 x (.?)(. >8 + //(/ >(),?/( 6 <,/ )+(,-5-< ,-. ) 9A'(//5 x -. ),''5(' 5/ )+(,- >5 <,/ :*5)* 5/ (B?,+ & -,&?',+ <,/
x ,/(. - )?''(-& >(/& A',)&5)(/
P 9>?/&5 - ,/ ?/(. *('( ),- >( (665)5(-& .5'()& ) 9>?/&5 - >?& ),- ,+/ 5-)+?.( <,/565),&5 -#>,/(. A' )(//(/ .(A(-.5-< - &*( /5&?,&5 "! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?;,
$SSHQGL[ '
6HQVLWLYLW\ DQDO\VHV RQ ELRHQHUJ\
*( -('<8 )(-,'5 ?/(/ 4$ *, 6 +,-. & <' : >5 (-('<8 )' A/ /*,'( 6 &*(/( )' A/ 5/ .(/&5-(. 6 ' 6?(+ &',-/A '& & 5/ &*('(6 '( 5-/5<*&6?+ & ?-.('/&,-. &*( '(+,&5 -/*5A >(&:((- &',-/A '& .(9,-. ,//?9A&5 -/ ,-. '(B?5'(. +,-. 6 ' >5 (-('<8 )' AA5-< +&* ?<* , 6?++ 9?+&5A+( /)(-,'5 ,-,+8/5/ :,/ >(8 -. &*( /) A( 6 &*5/ : 'C / 9( >,/5) ),+)?+,&5 -/ *,;( >((- 9,.( >,/(. - &*( '(+,&5;( /*,'( 6 ;,'5 ?/ .(9,-. /()& '/ 5- &*( & &,+ >5 )' A ; +?9(
*(/( ,'( A'(/(-&(. & <(&*(' :5&* &*( ,-,+8/5/ - 6 . .(9,-. ,-. 85(+. (; +?&5 - 5- ,>+( #
,>+( #
0HWULF
,/5) /(-/5&5;5&8 ,-,+8/5/ - >5 (-('<8 6' 9 )' A/
([DPSOH FKDQJH
&URSODQG IRU ELRHQHUJ\ DYDLODEOH
-('<8 )(-,'5 24 $ 3
P *,
?AA+80
"DO $D 25-/&(,. O !
--?,+ 85(+.
6 D3
5HGXFWLRQ
(TXLY DUHD
XVHG
LQ GHPDQG
LI VXSSOLHG IURP
4$ *,
(- D
ELRFURSV
-E,
*,
5-)'(,/( (9,-.0
4$DOP$D 5-/&(,. 6 $ O 4P
-59,+
$ D 9(,&
A' .?)&5 -
) -/?9A&5 - 5-
) -/?9A&5 -
,+,-)( 6
?AA+8 5/ DO
6 . .(9,-. D 6 .(9,-. 5- ,-. /?AA+8
-E,
*,
$ O!
-E,
*,
4 $ 5-/&(,. 6 >(5-< (B?,+
&,+ 6'(5<*&
D '(.?)&5 -
-E,
Â&#x201A; *,M
WP *,
&',-/A '&
D '(.?)&5 -
-E,
Â&#x201A; *,M
"
W4 *,
-E,
Â&#x201A; *,M
"
W4 *,
,//(-<(' ,5' D '(.?)&5 -
-E,
# " *,
"
W *,
&',;(+
-E,
# *,
" 4
W *,
+()&'565),&5 - $ D 5-/&(,. 6 D 6 6'(5<*&
(+()&'565),&5 D '(.?)&5 -
M >8 4 $ ,++ ' ,. 6?(+ 5- &*( )(-,'5 5/ /?AA+5(. 6' 9 >5 (-('<8 /&'(,9/ &*(' &*,- )' A/
" : ? * .
) ) 9
?;+
$SSHQGL[ (
)RUHVWU\ RYHUYLHZ
*( .5,<',9 5- 5<?'( # 5/ ,- ;(';5(: 6 &*( 6+ : 6 6 '(/& A' .?)&/ &*' ?<* &*( <+ >,+ /8/&(9 ..5&5 -,++8 5& 5-.5),&(/ :*5)* A &(-&5,+/ 6 /?/&,5-,>+( '(/5.?(/ :,/&( ,-. ) 9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</ :('( 5-)+?.(. 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 >5 9,// /?AA+8 ,-. ?-.(' :*5)* ) -.5&5 -/ - & &,+ 6 ?' ),&(< '5(/ ,'( 5-)+?.(.0 x
9A+(9(-&,'8 6(++5-</0 >5 9,// &*,& ),- >( /?/&,5-,>+8 *,';(/&(. 6' 9 ,..5&5 -,+ 6 '(/& <' :&* ' 6' 9 >5 9,// A'(;5 ?/+8 ?/(. 6 ' &',.5&5 -,+ ?/(/ (( ,+/ ()&5 - $ $
x
,';(/&5-< '(/5.?(/0 '(/5.?(/ &*,& >() 9( ,;,5+,>+( ,& &*( *,';(/&5-< 6 6?(+: . ,-. 5-.?/&'5,+ : . 4$D 6 &*(/( '(/5.?(/ 5/ .((9(. '() ;(',>+( (( ,+/ ()&5 - $
x
' )(//5-< '(/5.?(/0 '(/5.?(/ &*,& >() 9( ,;,5+,>+( ,& &*( A' )(//5-< 6 5-.?/&'5,+ : . ( < /,:.?/& P$D 6 &*(/( '(/5.?(/ 5/ .((9(. '() ;(',>+( (( ,+/ ()&5 - $
x
. :,/&(0 : . :,/&( >() 95-< ,;,5+,>+( ,6&(' ?/( ( < : . :,/&( 6' 9 >?5+.5-< .(9 +5&5 - (( ,+/ ()&5 - $
' &*( +,&&(' &*'(( ),&(< '5(/ ) 9A(&5-< .(9,-. 6' 9 &*(' /()& '/ /?)* ,/ &*( A,-(+ > ,'. 5-.?/&'8 *,/ >((- &,C(- 5-& ) -/5.(',&5 -
5<?'( #
)*(9,&5) & /* : ;(';5(: 6 6+ : 6 6 '(/& A' .?)&/ 5-& .566('(-& >5 (-('<8 ),&(< '5(/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 2 S'() ;(',>+( 6',)&5 -3
$ 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?-'
$SSHQGL[ )
5HVLGXHV DQG ZDVWH FDWHJRULVDWLRQ RYHUYLHZ
5<?'( # 5/ , /?99,'8 6 '(/5.?( ,-. :,/&( 6+ :/ 5- &*( -('<8 )(-,'5 & 5++?/&',&(/ &*( .566('(-&5,&5 - >(&:((- A'59,'8 /() -.,'8 ,-. &('&5,'8 '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&( 9,.( 5- ()&5 - $
5<?'( #
)*(9,&5) & /* : ;(';5(: 6 '(/5.?( ,-. :,/&( 6+ :/ 5- &*( )(-,'5 .566('(-&5,&5-< >(&:((- A'59,'8 /() -.,'8 ,-. &('&5,'8 '(/5.?(/ ,-. :,/&(
$ : ? * .
) ) 9
?-&
$SSHQGL[ *
*
5HIHUHQFHV
5HIHUHQFHV ± ,QWURGXFWLRQ $SSURDFK
5HSRUWV DQG SXEOLFDWLRQV T +59,&( +?&5 -/U T 4 U T '((-A(,)( 4 U T *(++ 4 !U T;,- ??'(- 4 PU
T 4 U *
X +59,&( +?&5 -/Y '(A '& +59,&( 5/C 6 ' :5&* C5-. A('95//5 - >8
()*-5),+ ?AA '& -5& # (95//5 - /)(-,'5 / ; ,9>'5.<( -5;('/5&8 '(// '((-A(,)( ,-. (-('<8 T'U(; +?&5 - ;('/5 - 4 X *(++ /)(-,'5 / & 4 $ Y *(++ -&('-,&5 -,+ >; 24 !3 -('<8 /)(-,'5 /0 )',9>+( ,-. +?(A'5-&/ ,- ??'(- (& ,+ 24 P3 +59,&5) *,-<( 4 AA # $ X &,>5+5R5-< <'((-* ?/( <,/ ) -)(-&',&5 -/ ,& + : +(;(+/0 ,- ,//(//9(-& 6 '(.?)&5 - /&',&(<5(/ ,-. ) /&/Y -&('-,&5 -,+ -('<8 <(-)8 24 3 '+. -('<8 ?&+ C
5HIHUHQFHV ± 'HPDQG
'DWD VRXUFHV T 4 !U
-&('-,&5 -,+ -('<8 <(-)8 '+. -('<8 ,+,-)(/ ,-. - - .,&,>,/(/ 4 ! .5&5 -
5HSRUWV DQG SXEOLFDWLRQV T ('-,'.5-5 U
T 4 U
T ; 4 U
T ; 4 PU
('-,'.5-5 ,-. ,++5 2 3 X (9,&('5,+5R,&5 -0 + -<# &('9 &'(-./ 5- &*( 5-&(-/5&8 6 ?/( 6 9,&('5,+/ ,-. (-('<8Y ?&?'(/ % 995&&(( - +59,&( *,-<( 24 3 X ((&5-< &*( % ,;5,&5 - &,'<(& O A&5 -/ 6 ' '(.?)5-< (95//5 -/ & 4 $ Y ('9,- 4 >?5+.5-</ '(A '& >8 &*( (.(',+ 5-5/&'8 6
',-/A '& ?5+.5-< ,-. '>,- (;(+ A9(-& X 4 (> ?.('(A '&Y ::: >9;>/ .( ,&5 -,+ -('<8 665)5(-)8 +,- >8 &*( ('9,- (.(',+ 5-5/&'8 6 ) - 98 ,-. ()*- + <8PP
T ' (-(->('< 4 4U
' (-(->('< * &*(/5/ 24 43 X (;(+ A9(-& ,-. -;('<(-)(Y &'()*& -5;('/5&8
T 4 "U
-&('-,&5 -,+ -('<8 <(-)8 24 "3 X 8(,'/ 6 (-('<8 ?/( O 5+ '5/(/ N +59,&( *,++(-<(/Y 5< $#$
*&&A0EE::: >9:5 .(E 5E (.,C&5 -E E ?>+5C,&5 -(-E-,&5 -,+('# (-('5((665R5(-RA+,- A' A('&8SA.6 >('(5)*S>9:5 /A',)*(S.( ':>S&'?( A.6
PP
$4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?-?
T 4 PU T 4 P>U T 4 U
T%59 4 4U T ((+5/ 4 U
T ,'&5- 4 U
T )*(-C 4 U
T 4 "U
T ''(++ 4 !U
T 4 PU
*
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
5HIHUHQFHV ± 6XSSO\ H[FO ELRHQHUJ\
'DWD VRXUFHV T 4 !U
-&('-,&5 -,+ -('<8 <(-)8 '+. -('<8 ,+,-)(/ ,-. - - .,&,>,/(/ 4 ! .5&5 -
5HSRUWV DQG SXEOLFDWLRQV T ('&,-5 4 $U ('&,-5 ( &*('95)/ 24 $3 A $ T ('&,-5 4 PU ('&,-5 4 P# ,8# G?-( -&('*,)*5-< ('9,-8 T + C !"U % + C (-(:,>+( -('<8 8/&(9 6 ' &*( (&*('+,-./ ' ) $&* -&('-,&5 -,+ +,' '?9 --(-(-('<5( ('+,</ Â&#x201E;-)*(- !"
$ : ? * .
) ) 9
?-;
T 4 $U
T 4 U
T ) 68/ 4 U
T 4 U T 4 !U T 4 U T '/( 4 !U T ,<- - PU T 4 PU T 69,- 4 4U
T <:5=C 4 !U
T 4 U
T (?&R 4 U
T ?-. 4 $U T # 4 U T 4 4 U T v'(-/(- 4 "U T 4 U
$" 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?--
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
(-(:,>+(/ 4 + >,+ &,&?/ (A '& 4 2 (-(:,>+( -('<8 (&: 'C 6 ' &*( 4 /& (-&?'83 v'(-/(-0 (-(:,>+( -('<8 ),.(95) '(// 4 " +59,&( +?&5 -/ 24 3
T 4 !U
*
*5-, 5-. :(' (A '& 0 P!#!4# ! #4 # *5-, *5-(/( (-(:,>+( -('<8 -.?/&'5(/ // )5,&5 - 4 !
5HIHUHQFHV ± %LRHQHUJ\ *HQHUDO
'DWD VRXUFHV T !U
! + >,+ 5>'( ?AA+8 .(+ 9(
T 4 ,U
&,&5/&5)/ - A('9,-(-& A,/&?'(/ ,-. 9(,. :/ 4 *&&A0EE6, /&,& 6, '< &,&5/&5)/ - A'59,'8 )' A/ ,-. +5;(/& )C (B?5;,+(-& 4 *&&A0EE6, /&,& 6, '< '+. ,&,>,/( - ' &()&(. '(,/ &,&5/&5)/ G,-?,'8 4 *&&A0EE::: ?-(A#
T 4 >U T 4 U
:)9) '<E:.A,E9.</E /&,&/ G,- . :-+ ,. +/ 6FLHQWLILF SDSHUV T ,9A>(++ 4 !U
T '> 4 U
T 5(+. 4 !U T 59(-&(+ 4 U
T A,' ;(C 4 PU
T ,- ??'(- 4 U
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
5HSRUWV T + -C 4 !U
T (.5-5 4 !U
+ -C (& ,+ 5+5(?(66()&(- ;,- (.('+,-./( ) -/?9A&5( ;,- (5:5&'5=C( A' .?)&(- 25- ?&)*K -<+5/* (B?5;,+(-&0 -;5' -9(-&,+ (66()&/ 6 ?&)* ) -/?9A&5 - 6 A' &(5-#'5)* A' .?)&/3 4 ! (.5-5 (.5-5 +,?-)*(/ (&*,- + 95++ &*,& A' .?)(/ :,&(' 2 '(//
(+(,/(3 4 ! ,;,5+,>+( ,& *&&A0EE?C '(?&('/ ) 9E,'&5)+(E5. % 4 " "4 ! P 4
$$ : ? * .
) ) 9
?-#
T '->?'< 4 !U
T ) 68/ 4 !U T ) 68/ 4 !>U T 4 U T
- >5+ 4 U
T 4 U
T 4 U T 4 U T 5/)*(' 4 U T '((-A(,)( 4 U T <:5=C 4 "U T 4 U T 4 U T 4 U T 4 U
T 4 >U
TG 4 PU TG 4 !U T 5-- 4 U
T E 4 U T 4 U
'->?'< (& ,+ //(//9(-& 6 <+ >,+ >5 9,// A &(-&5,+/ ,-. &*(5' +5-C/ & 6 . :,&(' >5 .5;('/5&8 (-('<8 .(9,-. ,-. () - 98 ,5- (A '& 4 ! ) 68/ '+.:5.( A &(-&5,+ 6 ,B?,&5) >5 9,// 4 ! ) 68/ ()*-5),+ /A()565),&5 -0 <'((-* ?/( <,/ ),+)?+,& ' 6 ' >5 6?(+/ ; $ 4 ! : 9?)* >5 (-('<8 ),- ?' A( A' .?)( :5&* ?& *,'95-< &*( (-;5' -9(-&J 4 - >5+ - >5+ +<,( 5 6?(+/ (/(,')* ,-. (;(+ A9(-& ' <',9 2 ' )*?'(3 *&&A0EE::: ( -9 >5+ ) 9E) 'A ',&(E65+(/E-(:/Â&#x2026;A?>Â&#x2026;,+<,( Â&#x2026;6,)&/*((& A.6 '+. ,<'5)?+&?'(0 & :,'./ 4 E4 $ # ' /A()&/ 6 ' 6 . -?&'5&5 - ,<'5)?+&?'( ,-. 9,= ' ) 99 .5&8 <' ?A/ + >,+ ('/A()&5;( &?.5(/ -5& . ,-. <'5)?+&?'( '<,-5R,&5 - 6 &*( -5&(. ,&5 -/
9( G?-( 4 <'5)?+&?',+ ?&+ C 4 O 4 ! 4 + >,+ '(/& (/ ?')(/ //(//9(-& 4 ?-&'8
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Â&#x2026; ((. 665)5(-)8 A.6 E (6('(-)( /)(-,'5 6' 9 '+. -('<8 ?&+ C 4 4 ' :5-< :5&*5- 595&/ 4
$ 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?-7
T *(++ 4 !U
*(++ *(++ +?(A'5-&/ /)(-,'5 6' 9 *(++ (-('<8 /)(-,'5 / & 4 $ 4 ! 9((&/ //5>5+5&5(/ ,-. +595&,&5 -/ 6 ' /?/&,5-,>+( >5 (-('<8 A' .?)&5 - /8/&(9/ 4 ! + >,+ -;5' -9(-&,+ ?&+ C 4 4 -;('/,&5 - ,-. /?/&,5-,>+( ?/( 6 &*( >5 /A*('( '+. 5- ',-/5&5 - # ?&?'( 5 (-('<8 ,-. /?/&,5-,>+( +,-. ?/( 4 !
T 9((&/ 4 !U T 4 4U T U T 4 !U
*
5HIHUHQFHV ± %LRHQHUJ\ 5HVLGXHV DQG ZDVWH
2LOV DQG IDWV x x x
?-/& -( ,': . G 5=C/&', G 4 P *( 5A5. ,-.> C :5&* # ' 9 ,8+ ' N ',-)5/ ' ?A '(// 4 '(/ ?')( /&?.8 - '() ;('(. ;(<(&,>+( 5+ ,-. ,-59,+ 6,&/ +(,'A :(' &. - >(*,+6 6 ?/&,5-,>+( -('<8 '(+,-. '(+,-. ,A,'(++, ?' A(,- (-.('('/ *,A( *(5' ?&?'( (-.(' ,<,R5-( ?<?/& 4
)RUHVWU\ UHVLGXHV DQG ZRRG ZDVWH x
x
*&&A0EE6, /&,& 6, '<E . ,-. <'5)?+&?'( '<,-5R,&5 - 6 -5&(. ,&5 -/ 9((&/ 24 !3 V //5>5+5&5(/ ,-. +595&,&5 -/ 6 ' /?/&,5-,>+( >5 (-('<8 A' .?)&5 - /8/&(9/L &'()*& *( (&*('+,-./
4 $
&,&5/&5)/
- )' A
,-.
6 '(/&'8
A' .?)&5 -
,;,5+,>+(
,&
$JULFXOWXUDO UHVLGXHV x
x x
x x x
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
$P : ? * .
) ) 9
?-A
x
x
x x
x
x
x
x x
x x
x
x
x
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
N 2 3 ?' A(,- ,// )5,&5 - 6 ' (-;5' -9(-& *(,+&* ,-. /,6(&8 5- 5+ '(65-5-< ,-. .5/&'5>?&5 - 2 3 &*( -/&5&?&( 6 ' -;5' -9(-& ,-. ?/&,5-,>5+5&8 6 &*( 995//5 -Q/ G 5-& (/(,')* (-&'( 2G E 3 G?-9(-< ,5 -<* ? 5? *?-=5,- (-< (-(:,>+( ,-. ?/&,5-,>+( -('<8
(;5(:/ 4 24 !3 PO4 " %59 ,+( 4 " V + >,+ A &(-&5,+ >5 (&*,- + A' .?)&5 - 6' 9 :,/&(. )' A/ ,-. )' A '(/5.?(/L (A,'&9(-& 6 *(95),+ -<5-(('5-< N ,&('5,+/ )5(-)( 9 4$4P -<5-(('5-< ?5+.5-< 5)*5<,- &,&( -5;('/5&8 ,/& ,-/5-< "!!4"# 44 5 9,// ,-. 5 (-('<8 4 24 "3 O P$ (:,-. :/C5 4 $ V *( A &(-&5,+ >5 9,// 6 ' (-('<8 A' .?)&5 - 5- &*( R()*
(A?>+5)L 5 9,// ,-. 5 (-('<8 24 3 " $O"4 ,)(. (,+ ,-. G , 5+;, 24 "3 V //(//9(-& 6 <'((-* ?/( <,/ (95//5 -/ 5- &*( A' .?)&5 - ,-. ?/( 6 6?(+ (&*,- + 5- ',R5+L ()'(&,'5,& 6 &*( -;5' -9(-& 6 &*( &,&( 6 z ,?+ ',R5+ A 4
,+ 4 " V '+. )' A '(/5.?(/ A' .?)&5 - ,-. 59A+5),&5 -/ 6 5&/ ?/( ,/ , >5 6?(+L ,'> - ,-,<(9(-& ,-. (B?(/&',&5 - (-&(' *( *5 &,&( -5;('/5&8 +?9>?/ " 4 -5&(. &,&(/ -;5' -9(-& -&('-,&5 -,+ 24 $3 $P$O $!" C*,-/,-= ,-5 &?9> '< ,9/ - ,-. G (-& - 4 V ' .?)&5 - ,-. .5/&'5>?&5 - 6 )('(,+ /&',: - &*( ,-,.5,- A',5'5(/L ,-,.5,- 5 /8/&(9/ -<5-(('5-<E ( <Â&#x2020;-5( .(/ >5 /8/&F9(/ ,? ,-,., "!0 # " &(?-A?-& ; ' .??'R,9( +,-.> ?: 4 V L 5/5 ,')Â&#x2021;, 5.,. '5C ,&*5=/ ',-C (;(-/ 5'C (*(?+ (+<5Â&#x2C6;
$! 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?-,
x x x
x
'C/* A0 | ('(,+/ /&',: ,-. ,<'5)?+&?',+ '(/5.?(/ 6 ' >5 (-('<8 5- (: (9>(' &,&(/ ,-. ,-.5.,&( ?-&'5(/| ;5 ,. ('>5, 4# )& >(' 4 P 4 $ V (:,/'(/&(- ,6; ('(-0 & A5( 6 A&5(L ',C&5=C -.('R (C +,-& (- 9<(;5-< ,<(-5-<(-
}5,-8,-< I(-< 5&,5 ,Â&#x2026; 5' -< , 4 P V &5+5R,&5 - 6 /&',: 5- >5 9,// (-('<8 5- *5-,L *('9,+ -('<8 (/(,')* -/&5&?&( 5,-=5- -5;('/5&8 5,-=5- P4 ( A+(L/ (A?>+5) 6 *5-, (-(:,>+( ,-. ?/&,5-,>+( -('<8 (;5(:/ 24 P3 P O !P ?/ 66 4 " V (-(:,>+( (-('<8 6' 9 A,+9 5+ # 5-- ;,&5 - - (66()&5;( ?&5+5R,&5 - 6 :,/&(L (A,'&9(-& 6 5;5+ ,-. -;5' -9(-&,+ -<5-(('5-< -5;('/5&8 6 ,+,8, ,+,8/5,
:HW ZDVWH DQG UHVLGXHV x x x
x
x x
x
x
x
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
(;5(:/ 4 24 !3 PO4 " %59 ,+( 4 " V + >,+ A &(-&5,+ >5 (&*,- + A' .?)&5 - 6' 9 :,/&(. )' A/ ,-. )' A '(/5.?(/L (A,'&9(-& 6 *(95),+ -<5-(('5-< N ,&('5,+/ )5(-)( 9 4$4P -<5-(('5-< ?5+.5-< 5)*5<,- &,&( -5;('/5&8 ,/& ,-/5-< "!!4"# 44 5 9,// ,-. 5 (-('<8 4 24 "3 O P$ &(?-A?-& ; ' .??'R,9( +,-.> ?: 4 V L 5/5 ,')Â&#x2021;, 5.,. '5C ,&*5=/ ',-C (;(-/ 5'C (*(?+ (+<5Â&#x2C6; ,- ,,-.(+ ;,- 5(' 4 V 5-,//( &'(,&9(-& 6 ' (-('<8 A' .?)&5 - ,-. (-;5' -9(-&,+ A' &()&5 - ,& ,+) * + .5/&5++('8 A+,-&/L ' ) 6 4 -& -6 - ' .?)&5 - ,-. /(/ 6 &*,- + G?-( #4 4 ,;,-, ?>, -;5&(. %(8 &( 4 $ V (:,/'(/&(- ,6; ('(-0 & A5( 6 A&5(L ',C&5=C -.('R (C +,-& (- 9<(;5-< ,<(-5-<(-
'U\ ZDVWH x x
665)( 6 +5. ,/&( ?-5)5A,+ +5. ,/&( 5- &*( -5&(. &,&(/ O 4 P ,)&/ N 5<?'(/ -;5' -9(-&,+ ,&, 9A(-.5?9 4 #4 !
$ : ? * .
) ) 9
?-+
x x
*
(-&(' ;(9 5&; ('5-< 6;,+>(*((' (.('+,-./ 6;,+ 5- 5=6('/ 4 #4 &,&+5-( /&,&5/&5),+ .,&, - &*( (&*('+,-./ 6 ' 4 #4 $
5HIHUHQFHV ± ,QYHVWPHQWV 6DYLQJV
T 5'>?/ 4 !U T P P '< 4 U
5'>?/ ,5')',6& ,-<( 6 4 ! +5/& A'5)(/ 4 !
*( (5-< P P ()*-5),+ /5&( .;,-)(. >+(-.(. :5-<+(&/ +,/& ;5/5&(. - 4 # #4! T 4 "U (?&/)*( ,*- -/('( )*5(-(-6,*'R(?<( 59 ('-;('C(*' 4 " T )*(-C(' 4 U )*(-C(' Â&#x201E;&(':,<(- .(' ,*- ,&,+ <?( 6 ',5+' ,. 6'(5<*& ),'/ 6 ('9,- ',5+' ,. ) 9A,-8 (?&/)*( ,*- +,/& ;5/5&(. - 4 # #4! T 4 !U (A,'&9(-& 6 99?-5),&5 -/ -('<8 ,-. ,&?',+ (/ ?')(/ ++ /+,-. '5. &?.8 4 ! T 4 U (A,'&9(-& 6 99?-5),&5 -/ -('<8 ,-. ,&?',+ (/ ?')(/ ++ /+,-. (-(:,>+( '5. &?.8 O A.,&(. & 5-)+?.( .(9,-. /5.( 9,-,<(9(-& 4 T 4 U (?&/)*(/ I(-&'?9 6Â&#x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Â&#x201E;'5)* 4 U IÂ&#x201E;'5)* -/&5&?& 6Â&#x201E;' ,?9# ?-. ,-./)*,6&/(-&:5)C+?-< ' 6(//?' 6Â&#x201E;' ,?9(-&:5)C+?-< '+(/?-< ,?9# ?-. -6',/&'?C&?'(-&:5)C+?-< 4 . :-+ ,.(. - 4 # # 4 T ,-/, '(?*,-. 4 U ,-/, '(?*,-. C8 + ?. ! 95',&(/ ,+(/ 5-6 '9,&5 - 6 ' )+ /(. ),A5&,+ 6?-. 4 T 4 U -&('-,&5 -,+ -('<8 <(-)8 A('5(-)( ?';(/ 6 ' -('<8
()*- + <8 +5)8 4
3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?#'
T 4 $U T 4 PU T 4 U T ?6&*,-/, 4 !U T 4 U
-&('-,&5 -,+ -('<8 <(-)8 ' =()&(. /&/ 6 (-(',&5-< +()&'5)5&8 # 4 $ A.,&( 4 $ -&('-,&5 -,+ -('<8 <(-)8 -('<8 ()*- + <8 //(-&5,+/ # 5 9,// 6 ' :(' (-(',&5 - ,-. 4 P -&('-,&5 -,+ ,'5&59( '<,-5/,&5 - -&('-,&5 -,+ *5AA5-< ,-. '+. ',.( # ,)&/ ,-. 65<?'(/ 4 ?6&*,-/, --?,+ '(A '& 4 ! O ?' /&'(-<&*/ 5- .(&,5+ 4 '+. ,-C G 5-& (A '& -,+8/5/ 6 &*( ) A( 6 -('<8 ?>/5.5(/ ,-. ?<<(/&5 -/ 6 ' &*( #4
-5&5,&5;( '(A,'(. 6 ' /?>95//5 - & &*( #4 ?995& ((&5-<
' -& 2 ,-,.,3 G?-( 4 K *&&A0EE::: (). '<E.,&, ().E$$E$E"$$P$ A.6 T ,5+:,8 ()*-5),+ 4 U
,5+:,8 ()*-5),+ (> ,<(/ ,5+:,8 5-,-)( +,/& ;5/5&(. - 4 # #4! T &('- 4 U &('- &('- (;5(: - *( ) - 95)/ 6 +59,&( *,-<( 2A'(#A?>+5),&5 - (.5&5 -3 ?99,'8 6 -)+?/5 -/ 4
: ? * .
) ) 9
?#&
$SSHQGL[ +
*ORVVDU\
>(/& ,;,5+,>+( &()*- + <8
>?/5-(// ,/ ?/?,+
,A
),A5&,+ ( A(-.5&?'(/
),'> - ,A&?'( ,-. & ',<(
)+(,-&()*
) ++()&5;( &('9 ?/(. & .(/)'5>( &*( (-/(9>+( 6 V)+(,-L ' + :# ),'> - E + :#(-('<8 &()*- + <5(/
<' // ,--?,+ 5-)'(9(-& S (B?5;,+(-& & -,&?',+ &'(( <' :&* 5- , 8(,' 5- &*( 6 '(/&
<' // . 9(/&5) A' .?)&
<'((-* ?/( <,/
G
<5<, = ?+(/
-&('-,&5 -,+ -('<8 <(-)8
-&(-/5&8 6 /(
C *
C5+ :,&& * ?'
G
= ?+(/ ?-5& & ( A'(// B?,-&5&5(/ 6 (-('<8
*,
9(<, *()&,'( 2 C943
*
9(<, :,&& * ?'
G
9(<, = ?+(/
A
A(',&5 -,+ ( A(-.5&?'(/
A(' ),A5&,
A(' A('/ -
A('5 .
A('5 . 5- &*( ) -&( & 6 &*5/ /&?.8 ?/?,++8 9(,-/ $#8(,' A('5 .
AC9
A('/ -#C9 2?-5& 6 ,)&5;5&8 5- A,//(-<(' &',-/A '&3
('/ -,+ &: # ,-. &*'((# :*((+('/
+?<#5- 8>'5. +()&'5) (*5)+(
,&&('8# +()&'5) (*5)+(
'(<5 -
*('(0 '(<5 - 5/ , <( <',A*5) ,'(, ) 9A'5/5-< -( ' /(;(',+ ) ?-&'5(/ *( : '+. ) -&,5-/ '(<5 -/
(-(:,>+( -('<8 ?')(/
(/5.?(
5- &*5/ /&?.80 +(6& ;(' >5 9,// 6 A' .?)&5 - ' A' )(//5-< 6 ',: 9,&('5,+/ ' ?/( 6 A' .?)&/ 99 -+8 /A+5& 5-& A'59,'8 '(/5.?(/ 6 >5 9,// A' .?)&5 - 2( < /&',:3 /() -.,'8 '(/5.?(/ 6 >5 9,// A' )(//5-< 2( < /,:.?/&3 ,-. &('&5,'8 '(/5.?(/ ,6&(' A' .?)& ?/( 2( < 9,-?'(3 ('&5,'8 '(/5.?(/ (/A()5,++8 :*(- &*(8 - + -<(' *,;( ,- () - 95) ;,+?( ,'( 6&(- ),++(. :,/&(
4 3 9 $ ) 9 ) ) ?#?
'() ;(',>+( 6',)&5 - ',)&5 - 6 &*( & &,++8 <(-(',&(. '(/5.?( &*,& ),- >( '() ;('(. 6 ' (-('<8 A' .?)&5 -
/B9
/B?,'( 9(&'(/ ?-5& ?/(. & ( A'(// &*( ,9 ?-& 6 >?5+.5-< ,'(, 5- &*( >?5+.5-< /()& '
&C9
& --(#C9 2?-5& 6 ,)&5;5&8 5- 6'(5<*& &',-/A '&3
,/&(
&('9 ?/(. & '(6(' & &('&5,'8 '(/5.?(/ 2/(( V (/5.?(L3 (/A()5,++8 :*(- &*(8 - + -<(' *,;( ,- () - 95) ;,+?(
*
,&&#* ?'/ ,+&('-,&5;( ?-5& & 9(,/?'( &*( (-('<8 A' ;5.(. >8 (+()&'5)5&8 / ?')(/
: ? * .
) ) 9
?#;
::) :25/':,'( 1(7:25. ::) 2I¿FHV 3 3 $ E 3 3 6 6
6 6 6 6 B $ B B B J
B 3 $ B
B B $ B @( ( B @ E
8 $ 8 $ 8 8 ) 8 8
8 8 ) >
> < > ) ) C < ) D 2 2 ) 2 2 ! 2 2 $ /
% $ % %
% % % ) : : : % 8 : ) : : : 9 9
9 9 3 9 9
9
9 . . . . ) = = 3 $ = < = 9 3 J $ $ $
::) $VVRFLDWHV H J 9 43 5 H % 4 5 : @ $ 4D 5 % B 4% 5 2WKHUV 9 ) 4=3 5 3 1 $ ?'&' 3XEOLFDWLRQ GHWDLOV : $
C ) ?'&& $) O % 4 ) 5" 8 " 9 ( 3 ) $
$ *
$
) ( . ! ?'&& 3 .
)
! )
) )" )" "
$ (
7+( (1(5*< 5(3257 UHQHZDEOH HQHUJ\ E\ 5(3257
$ 6&(1$5,2 ([WHQVLYH HOHFWULILFDWLRQ RI WUDQVSRUW HQKDQFHG HQHUJ\ FRQVHUYDWLRQ VPDUW JULGV VXVWDLQDEOH HQHUJ\ IRU DOO
&+$//(1*(6 &RQVHUYLQJ HQHUJ\ UHGXFLQJ GHPDQG HOHFWULILFDWLRQ HTXLW\ ODQG ZDWHU VHD XVH LPSOLFDWLRQV OLIHVW\OH FKRLFHV EHKDYLRXU FKDQJHV SXEOLF DWWLWXGHV LQYHVWPHQW LQQRYDWLRQ DQG 5 ' JRYHUQDQFH
%(1(),76
$ ZRUOG SRZHUHG E\ UHQHZDEOH VXVWDLQDEOH HQHUJ\ E\ PLG FHQWXU\
:K\ ZH DUH KHUH 7R VWRS WKH GHJUDGDWLRQ RI WKH SODQHW¶V QDWXUDO HQYLURQPHQW DQG WR EXLOG D IXWXUH LQ ZKLFK KXPDQV OLYH LQ KDUPRQ\ ZLWK QDWXUH ZZZ SDQGD RUJ
3DQGD 6\PERO ::) :RUOG :LGH )XQG IRU 1DWXUH )RUPHUO\ :RUOG :LOGOLIH )XQG
³::)´ LV D ::) 5HJLVWHUHG 7UDGHPDUN ::) ,QWHUQDWLRQDO $YHQXH GX 0RQW %ODQF *ODQG 6ZLW]HUODQG ² 7HO )D[ )RU FRQWDFW GHWDLOV DQG IXUWKHU LQIRUPDWLRQ SOHDVH YLVLW RXU LQWHUQDWLRQDO ZHEVLWH DW ZZZ SDQGD RUJ
62/87,216 ,Q DOO RI RXU KDQGV SROLF\ PDNHUV FRUSRUDWH OHDGHUV LQYHVWRUV FRPPXQLWLHV DQG LQGLYLGXDOV
:LOG :RQGHUV RI (XURSH ,QDNL 5HODQ]RQ ::)
6WRS IRVVLO IXHO SROOXWLRQ VDYH PRQH\ DGGUHVV FOLPDWH FKDQJH LPSURYH KHDOWK QR QXFOHDU ULVNV QHZ MREV LQQRYDWLRQ SURWHFW QDWXUH
$ 9,6,21