CAPACITY BUILDING Identifying needs, specificities and imbalances Summaryof the deliverable 5.2.1 (WP5-Task 5.2)
March 2012 Author: MIUR – CNR (Italy)
!
& '
() ! "#$ %&' ' &# #!! (!%")"%"*"! # "' + , #%! ! ! - .*/& ((!,,!**& 0 1 & #& 0 !,"2! +,! 3 4 0 !(& *&# 5 !#*")6"#$ #!! (!%")"%"*"! # "' + , #%! "# /.' # % ( %"*6 +.", "#$5 !%. "*6
! "!
#
$
%
#* & .%*"&# 4
)"# #%! .# ! */!
0 !2!#*/
' !8 &
0"
&& "# *!
%*"&# %&0
&$ ' ' ! 9 ::;047<
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
!"
7
"!) .' '
6 &)*/! !(& *
/" !(& * " &#! &) */! *!( %/"!2! *& ).,)", */! &+?!%*"2! &) ! "#$ 6#! $"! "# +!*8 !!# # *"&# , !$"&# , # . &(! # ( &$ ' -).# "#$ %/!' ! 8 "*/ !2" !#%! *& "#*! # "#* 0 !$"&# , "' + , #%! "# */! ' "#! !%*& * " */! ! .,* &) */! ( &%! &) +.", "#$0.( * + ! *& %&,,!%* # /"$/,"$/* . !)., "#)& ' *"&# # +!#!)"* ) &' */! (!!%/! # %&#* "+.*! *& */! 8 & /&( /!, "# &' ! &# %*&+! :44 ( &?!%* ' ",! *&#! # &2! 2"!8 &)*/! "# !))& * "# */! ) ' !8 &
*"&# , ! ! %/ &$ ' ' ! # "# ).# "#$ %/!' ! "#%,. "#$ . 2!6 &) &) ( &?!%* " ",,. * *! ! (!%*"2!,6 "# & ' . # & ' /
/! &+?!%*"2! &) / (*! 4 " *& " !#*")6 " % !( #%"! !(& *"#$ */! ' "# )"# "#$ &) / (*! 4 "))! !#* 0 ! )&.# 4 &.#* "! 8 "*/ ' 1 1 $ &( 9! $ &.#* "! 8 "*/ $ &( ' 1 & *.$ ,< 7 &.#* "! 8 "*/&.* ' ) .#"2! "*6-"# *"*.*"&# ,,!2!,9! $ ! ' #6
' &#$ # *"&# "# ! "#$ */! */!' ! &) "!),6 (( & %/! *& */! " .! &) "# */! ' "#! !%*& !, # < 1) ' &8 6 #
2'
9! $
1 $ &( +! " ! ( "#<
!!%! * ,6 #
!$.,
%*"2"*"!
*
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
& !&2!
!
)&%. &#
;
&+","*6 %/!' !
! #$%&
' ( )
#
'.
#$* +
.# .
,-. /0
% 7: ;F > 7; 44 4 : 7G : F 3 3
&$ ' ' ! " "#%,. !
1 2 .' 3'4 534*4
4
-
=
& ' 3 ( ! !#* . 2!6 &) */! %/!' ! % "! &.* * !$"&# ,,!2!,9"! + "# ,!2!,< *& (!%")"%"*"! # " !#*")6 (& "+,! "' + , #%! ' &#$ "))! !#*$!&$ (/"% , ! ( *, #*"% !
,%
'
2
!$"&# ,
4
•
&$ ' ' ! )&%. ! &# "#*! !$"&# ,%&/! "&# # * # # *"&# ,%&0&(! *"&# # #!*8 & "#$ • &?!%* +&.* # ! * # "#$ */! %! # ,"' *! / #$! # */! "#! #2" &#' !#* #! $6 • &$ ' ' ! )&%. ! &# ?&"#*&(! *"&# # #!"$/+&. /&& %&&(! *"&# 9 (!%")"% ' !#*"&# *& ?&"#* #&8 ,! $!< • &?!%* +&.* ,"' *! / #$! # */! "#! #2" &#' !#* )! # . * "# +,! . ! &)' "#! # %& * , ( %! &,"%6 .((& * • &$ ' ' ! )&%. ! &# * # 0# *"&# , #!"$/+&. /&& # % & 0+& ! %&&(! *"&# 9 (!%")"% ' !#*"&# *& ' &+","*6<1 #!*8 & 8 "*/ #&#0 &.*/! # ! "*! #! # %&.#* "! • &?!%* +&.* ,"' *! / #$! # */! "#! #2" &#' !#* )! # . * "# +,! . ! &)' "#! # %& * , ( %! "*"' ! # (& * &,"%6 .((& *
!
! "*! !
1
!
#! #
& ' ( &2" ! %&,,!%*"&# &) "$#")"% #* %*"2"*"! */ * "#*! # *"&# , $ #"A *"&# !$., ,6 % 6 &.*"# */! ' "#! !%*& /! !@(! "!#%! &) # ' &#$ &*/! ! ",,. * *! /" / (*! &))! # &2! 2"!8 #&*&#,6 &) "#"*" *"2! +.* , & &) */! ' !*/& &,&$6 +!/"# */! & $ #"A *"&# &) */& ! "#"*" *"2! 8 !,, !%*& &)"#*! ! * /! * +,! +!,&8 /&8 6#*/! " &)*/! +&2! ' !#*"&#! "#*! # *"&# , $ #"A *"&# C %*"&# %%& "#$ *& ' "# %"!#*")"% */!' ! "# 8 /"%/ */!6 ! "' (,!' !#*! # */! ' !*/& &,&$6 . ! +6 ! %/ &) */! $ #"A *"&# "
5
%
"& "
& & ) 8'
)
# ! * # "#$ */! %! #1 ,"' *! %/ #$! # */! "#! #2" &#' !#*1 &,"%6 .((& *
0 &
1
(" %9 1
1
1 (
# ! * # "#$ */! %! #1 )! # . * "# +,! . ! &) ' "#! # %& * , ( %! 1 "*"' ! # (& *1 &,"%6 .((& * # ! * # "#$ */! %! #1 ,"' *! %/ #$! # */! "#! #2" &#' !#*1 &,"%6 .((& *I " !' "# *"&# # ! * # "#$ */! %! #1 ,"' *! %/ #$! # */! "#! #2" &#' !#*
67 &#$ *! ' (! (!%*"2!1 !' (&8 ! "#$ #!*8 & &) " !%*& 8 "*/ ,! ! /"( ",, 1 .((& *"#$ #!*8 & &) %"!#*" * 8 "*/ ( &(& ,08 "*"#$ ",, 1 +.", "#$ %"!#*")"% *! ' *& %&,, +& *! &# ).# ! ( &?!%* 1 * "#"#$ "# !%" "&# .((& * 6 *!' H . ,"*6 . #%! "# */! 2" & 6 ( &%! 1 )&%. &# /"$/0( &)",! %"!#*" * # "# * .%*&
( *&) */! */!' *"% ( &$ '
#*!$ *"&# +!*8 !!# # *. , # &%"&0!%&#&' "% , %"!#%! 1 ,"# "#$ +!*8 !!# (/6 "% , # +"&,&$"% , %"!#%!1 )&%. &# ! ,6 % !! %"!#*" * #*! " %"(,"# 6 %&' (!*!#%6 * "#"#$ # % ( %"*6 +.", "#$
"#"#$ %&. !
"#"#$ %&. !
&+","*6 !,,&8 /"( &$ ' ' !
"# ,,6 & ' ( ! !#* *$,&+ , # !$"&# ,,!2!, */! # ,6 " &) */! "#)& ' *"&# %&,,!%*! */ &.$/ */! D.! *"&## " ! !2!,&(! .# ! ! 0! /"$/,"$/*"#$ ( "& "*"! # #!! )& "))! !#* !%*& */!' ! $ #"A *"&# ) &' 0 "))! !#* %&.#* "! 9"#%,. "#$ &' ! #&#0 %&.#* "! < )",,! */! D.! *"&## " ! # . : $ &( 0 8 ! ! )"# ,,6 %&,,!%*! /! ! .,* ! ( ! !#*! * $,&+ , ,!2!, * + "# ,!2!, # ) &' */! (! (!%*"2! &) */! ( "2 *! !%*& 9"# !! 4 ( "2 *! $ #"A *"&# # 8 ! ! */! D.! *"&## " !< & .' ' •
"A! */! D.! *"&## " !C ' !*/& &,&$6 # )
•
)
4 $ &(
'
) •
4
)';
;
'
2
+.", "#$ ; ; # ) ; )&%. "#$ &# " %"(,"#! ," ! 0 ;' & *,6 * # */ &.$/ %*"&# 1
;
1
1 # 4 •
! .,*
1 +.", "#$ # ;)&%. "#$ &# " %"(,"#! ," ! 0 1
=
0
' <
; "# */! !%*& &)
; ;
;
; "# */! !%*& &) ;1 # 4 ;' & *,6 */ &.$/
%*"&# 1
& !, *! %&' ' .#"*"! 1
•
$ &( 0 > &3 ? ? J &&& "# *"&# &)K &&,, +& *"&# &# K & ! *"&# &)9%&' ' &# * "#"#$ ( &$ ' ).# "#$ %/!' ! (&,"%"! < I #*! " %"(,"# 6 (( & %/ I #*! # *"&# , !%&$#"*"&# &) * "#"#$ I &+","*6 9!' (/ " &#<1
•
$ &( 4 0 '
) ;
8 1
4
'
+ 1 1) 0 ''
; + 4
' 0
1 $ &( ')4
0
1 ;
) /
8/
G
"$/,"$/*"#$ !!
(!%")"%"*"!
#
' + , #%!
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
;
( &?!%* "#%,. ! )& "))! !#* # */! "#! #2" &#' !#*1 %! # * , ( %! 1 "*"' ! # (& *1 &,"%6 #
! ! %/! 8 /&
! #&*( *#! &)
9!2!# ") */! !#* . 2!6<1
"*/ !)! !#%! *& */! "! . "! %*"&# ' & *&)*/! ).# ! ( &?!%* ! !2&*! *& 5 # ! * # "#$ */! %! #B */!' ! /" " "' (& * #*+!% . ! */! ! ( &?!%* ! ' &+","*6 "# * .' !#* */ * # 8 ! *& ( !%" ! #!! ) &' +&**&' 0.( (! (!%*"2! 7< * !$"&# , ,!2!, 8 /",! */! #!"$/+&. /&& %&&(! *"&# " ' & ! !' (/ "A! "# */! , % ! "*! #! # ! */! "#*! !$"&# , %&/! "&# (!%* " ' & ! "' (& * #* )& */! *, #*"% ! %&#%! # " !@(,"%"*,6 ' !#*"&#! ( *&)*/! , % # ! "*! #! # ! ( &$ ' ' !
# */! "# /!
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
0 ! 1 4 )
&' ! (!%.," )! *. ! '
H .! *"&## " ! ! .,* /&8 */ * "# */! ' "#! )"!, ' ' 1 8 /",!1 9+ "%< # 1 ; 0 ; ' ! ' 0
;
# )
!
'
! '
1
((! 8 /!# %&# " ! "#$ */! ( "2 *! !%*& ," ! )& !@ ' (,! */! " !#*")"% *"&# &) ' 1
& !&2! */! */ !! "))! !#* "# /&8 ,"$/*,6 "))! !#* (( & %/ *& &' ! (!%* 8 "*/ */! *, #*"% ! "#$ )& # "#% ! "#$ **!#*"&# *& */! !$., *"&# # ' # $!' !#* !%*& 1 */! , % ! %&# " ! "#$ */! ! .% *"&# /"$/,6 !,!2 #* # */! ! "*! #! # ! %%& "#$ &# # /"$/ ( "& "*6 *& */! *!%/#&,&$" * ( &)",!
;
/" !(& * " ( !,"' "# 6 !))& * *& &2! 2"!8 %/!' ! * ( #0 . &(! # ,!2!, "# & ! *& 6#! $"! +!*8 !!# # *"&# , . &(! # # !$"&# ,( &$ ' ' !
!
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
1
)
! "#$
0
* *!$6 *( #0 . &(! # ,!2!,
'
)
;'
A)
/
B
/ /
>
##!@ # !@ )
/////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// :
. $)
& '
()
$)
& '
()
4
;
%
! 9 D)
&?!%* ! ,"#$ 8 "*/
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// C ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ..
( %"*6 .", "#$
44
4 4 /! . 2!6 4
44
@ ' (,! &) ; 4
&+","*6 %/!' !
#
"! . "! %*"&#
#
'. 3
%*"&# "# */! . 2!6!
.# .
!
%&0).# ! ( &?!%*
( %"*6 .", "#$
4G 4F
#* LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL 4F
&$ ' ' !
2! E
4
& '
()
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 3
7 4 *, #*"% !$"&#LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL
7
77
7=
7
7 4 4 *, #*"% !$"&#
&$ ' ' !LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL 7
74
&?!%*
*, #*"% !$"&#
,%
7
!
!$"&#
7
4 ,%
!
!$"&#
&$ ' ' !
=
7
,%
!
!$"&#
&?!%*
=
! "*!
=
#! # !
!$"&#
774
! "*!
#! # !
!$"&#
&$ ' ' !
77
! "*!
#! # !
!$"&#
&?!%*
"#
8'
(!%")"*"! $)
G
# "' + , #%! "# !$"&# ,( &$ ' ' ! -( &?!%* & '
()
" &; & ;(
;
) ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// C
= 4 #*! $&2! #' !#* , %! #"% &' ' " "&# =
>
#*! # *"&# , &.#%",)& */! @(,& *"&# &)*/! ! 9
=7 == . &
)& */! "#!
,*"% ! $ #" *"&#
%"!#%! M !*8 &
<
&) .# "#$ $!#%"!
7: 74 7
F
$) 4
& '
()
F)
/////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// 3
&%! . ! # D.! *"&# /!
7=
*+ !
7G
7 ! .,* # ,6 " $,&+ ,,!2!,LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL 74
"& "*"!
# #!!
7
"& "*"!
# #!!
77
"& "*"!
# ( &+,!'
=: =:
!%"("!#* ) &' */! ( "2 *! !%*&
= =7
= ! .,* # ,6 " !$"&# ,,!2!, = 4 *, #*"% !
=G
=
=;
,%
=7
! LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL
! "*!
= = !! &
)
#! # ! LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL => (!%")"%"*"!
# "' + , #%!
* !$"&# ,,!2!,
=F
GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG/ H
%% I J " 0 0 %% I J $ &( F ) %% I (4
=G
J '
F)
1D!K
9 1)
' E '
, @! E
;
&)
;
&
-GGG
GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG/KH
GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG//K
GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG K:
4:
44