ABOUT THE WORD DESIGN VilĂŠm Flusser
single page layout final.indd 1
11/02/2013 23:51
single page layout final.indd 2
11/02/2013 23:51
ABOUT THE WORD DESIGN
single page layout final.indd 3
11/02/2013 23:51
‘About the Word Design’, from ‘The Shape of Things’ written by Vilém Flusser Published 2013 Camberwell College of Arts, Peckham Road, Camberwell SE5 8UF
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Digitally printed Edited by Colleen Burns, Amy Haigh Documentation by Myrddin Wooding Print Management Kellie Marsh Illustration by Jalil Poplazi, Dorian James Exhibition Curation and Photography by Hollie Smith The Shape of Things
single page layout final.indd 4
11/02/2013 23:51
1 DESIGN
6-11
2 TEKTON
12-15
3 MECHOS
16-19
4 AGILITY
20-25
5 CULTURE
26-29
6 ORBIT
30-35
7 PENS
36-39
8 ARTEFACTS
40-43
9 CONFESSION
44-49
GLOSSARY
50
INDEX
51-52
single page layout final.indd 5
CONTENTS
5
11/02/2013 23:51
single page layout final.indd 6
11/02/2013 23:51
1 DESIGN
single page layout final.indd 7
11/02/2013 23:51
8 THE WORD DESIGN
DESIGN
In English, the word design is both a noun and a verb (which tells one a lot about the nature of the English language). As a noun, it means – among other things – ‘intention’, ‘plan’, ‘intent’, ‘aim’, ‘scheme’, ‘plot’, ‘motif’, ‘basic structure’, all these (and other meanings) being connected with ‘cunning’ and ‘deception’. As a verb (‘to design’), meanings include ‘to concoct something’, ‘to simulate’, ‘to draft’, ‘to sketch’, ‘to fashion’, ‘to have designs on something’. The word is derived from the Latin signum, meaning ‘sign’, and shares the same ancient root. Thus, etymologically, design means ‘de-sign’. This raises the question: How has the word design come to achieve its present-day significance throughout the world?
single page layout final.indd 8
11/02/2013 23:51
DESIGN
9
_
+
This question is not a historical one, in the sense of sending one off to examine texts for evidence of when and where the word came to be established in its present-day meaning.
single page layout final.indd 9
11/02/2013 23:51
DESIGN
10
single page layout final.indd 10
11/02/2013 23:51
11
11 SEMANTIC
single page layout final.indd 11
DESIGN
TITLE
It is a semantic question, in the sense of causing one to consider precisely why this word has such significance attached to it in contemporary discourse about culture.
11/02/2013 23:51
single page layout final.indd 12
11/02/2013 23:51
2 MECHOS
single page layout final.indd 13
11/02/2013 23:51
MECHOS
14
1
2
4
single page layout final.indd 14
11/02/2013 23:51
15 The word occurs in contexts associated with cunning and deceit. A designer is a cunning plotter laying his traps. Falling into the same category are other very significant words: in particular, mechanics and machine. The Greek mechos means a device designed to deceive – i.e. a trap – and the Trojan Horse is one example of this.
MECHOS
THE CRAFTY ONE
Ulysses is called polymechanikos, which schoolchildren translate as ‘the crafty one’. The word mechos itself derives from the ancient MAGH, which we recognize in the German Macht and mögen, the English ‘might’ and ‘may’. Consequently, a machine is a device designed to deceive; a lever, for example, cheats gravity, and ‘mechanics’ is the trick of fooling heavy bodies.
single page layout final.indd 15
11/02/2013 23:51
single page layout final.indd 16
11/02/2013 23:51
3 TEKTON
single page layout final.indd 17
11/02/2013 23:51
18
TEKTON
TECH·NE - art TEK·TON - carpenter HYLE - wood
MATERIAL WORLD Another word used in the same context is ‘technology’. The Greek techne means ‘art’ and is related to tekton, a ‘carpenter’. The basic idea here is that wood (hyle in Greek) is a shapeless material to which the artist, the technician, gives form, thereby causing the form to appear in the first place. Plato’s basic objection to art and technology was that they betray and distort theoretically intelligible forms (‘ideas’) when they transfer these into the material world. For him, artists and technicians were traitors to Ideas and tricksters because they cunningly seduced people into perceiving distorted ideas.
single page layout final.indd 18
11/02/2013 23:51
TEKTON
19
single page layout final.indd 19
11/02/2013 23:51
single page layout final.indd 20
11/02/2013 23:51
4 AGILITY
single page layout final.indd 21
11/02/2013 23:51
22
AGILITY
The Latin equivalent of the Greek techne is ars, which in fact suggests a metaphor similar to the English rogue’s ‘sleight of hand’.
single page layout final.indd 22
11/02/2013 23:51
23 ARTICULUM
AGILITY
The diminutive of ars is articulum – i.e. little art – and indicates that something is turned around the hand (as in the French tour de main). Hence ars means something ‘agility’ or the ‘ability to turn something to one’s advantage’, and artifex – i.e. ‘artist’ – means a ‘trickster’ above all. That the original artist was a conjurer can be seen from words such as ‘artifice’, ‘artificial’ and even ‘artillery’. In German, an artist is of course one who is ‘able to do something’, the German word art, Kunst, being the noun from können, ‘to be able’ or ‘can’, but there again the word for ‘artificial’, gekünstelt, comes from the same root (as does the English ‘cunning’). ars - Latin equivalent of the Greek techne, similar to the English rouge’s ‘sleight of hand’ tour de main - indicates something is turned round by hand artifex - ‘artist’ means trickster above all Kunst - German word for art, derives from the noun konnen konnen - German word for ‘to be able to’ or ‘can’
single page layout final.indd 23
11/02/2013 23:51
AGILITY
24
2
single page layout final.indd 24
11/02/2013 23:51
AGILITY
25
1
single page layout final.indd 25
11/02/2013 23:51
single page layout final.indd 26
11/02/2013 23:51
5 CULTURE
single page layout final.indd 27
11/02/2013 23:51
28
CULTURE
INTERNAL CONNECTIONS Such considerations in themselves constitute a sufficient explanation of why the word design occupies the position it does in contemporary discourse.
single page layout final.indd 28
11/02/2013 23:51
The words design, machine, technology, ars and art are closely related to one another, one term being unthinkable without the others, and they all derive from the same existential view of the world. However, this internal connection has been denied for centuries (at least since the Renaissance). Modern bourgeois culture made a sharp division between the world of the arts and that of technology and machines; hence culture was split into two mutually exclusive branches: one scientific, quantifiable and ‘hard’, the other aesthetic, evaluative and ‘soft’.
CULTURE
29
This unfortunate split started to become irreversible towards the end of the nineteenth century. In the gap the word design formed a bridge between the two. It could do this since it is an expression of the internal connection between art and technology. Hence in contemporary life, design more or less indicates the site where art and technology (along with their respective evaluative and scientific ways of thinking) come together as equals, making a new form of culture possible.
single page layout final.indd 29
11/02/2013 23:51
single page layout final.indd 30
11/02/2013 23:51
6 ORBIT
single page layout final.indd 31
11/02/2013 23:51
32
ORBIT
CONNOTATIONS Although this is good explanation, it is not satisfactory on its own. After all, what links the terms mentioned above is that they all have connotations of (among other things) deception and trickery. The new form of culture which Design was to make possible would be a culture that was aware of the fact that it was deceptive.
TRICK·ER·Y - trickery GRAV·IT·Y - gravity NA·TURE - nature
So the question is: Who and what are we deceiving when we become involved with culture (with art, with technology – in short, with Design)? To take one example: The lever is a simple machine. Its design copies the human arm; it is an artificial arm. Its technology is probably as old as the species homo sapiens, perhaps even older. And this machine, this design, this art, this technology is intended to cheat gravity, to fool the laws of nature and, by means of deception, to escape our natural circumstances through the strategic exploitation of a law of nature.
single page layout final.indd 32
11/02/2013 23:52
33 By means of the lever – despite our body weight – we ought to be able to raise ourselves up to touch the stars if we have to, and – thanks to the lever – if we are given the leverage, we might be able to lever the world out of its orbit. This is the design that is the basis of all culture: to deceive nature by means of technology, to replace what is natural with what is artificial and build a machine out of which there comes a god who is ourselves. In short: The design behind a, culture has to be deceptive (artful?) enough to turn mere mammals conditioned by nature into free artists.
single page layout final.indd 33
ORBIT
ARTFUL
11/02/2013 23:52
ORBIT
34
single page layout final.indd 34
11/02/2013 23:52
ORBIT
35
single page layout final.indd 35
11/02/2013 23:52
1 7
single page layout final.indd 36
11/02/2013 23:52
7 PENS
single page layout final.indd 37
11/02/2013 23:52
PENS
38
UNCERTAIN GROUND This is a great explanation, is it not? The word design has come to occupy the position it has in contemporary discourse through our awareness that being a human being is a design against nature. Unfortunately, this explanation will not satisfy us. If in fact design increasingly becomes the centre of attention, with the question of Design replacing that of the Idea, we will find ourselves on uncertain ground.
single page layout final.indd 38
KEY WORDS human, design, idea, nature, value
11/02/2013 23:52
39
The only thing that gives plastic pens any value is their design, which is the reason that they write. This design represents a coming together of great ideas, which – being derived from art and science – have cross-fertilized and creatively complemented one another. Yet this is a design we don’t notice, so such pens tend to be given away free – as advertising, for example. The great ideas behind them are treated with the same contempt as the material and work behind them.
PENS
To take one example: Plastic pens are getting cheaper and cheaper and tend to be given away for nothing. The material they are made of has practically no value, and work (according to Marx, the source of all value) is accomplished thanks to smart technology by fully automatic machines. TECH·NOL·O·GY noun. [tek-nol-o-gee] The application of scientific knowledge for practical purposes. technics engineering - technique I·DE·A noun. [eye-dear] A thought or suggestion as to a possible course of action. notion - thought - conception concept - opinion - view VAL·UE noun. [val-yoo] Relative worth, merit or importance. worth - price - cost - merit - rate MA·CHINE noun. [ma-sh-een] An apparatus using or applying mechanical power to perform a particular task. engine - machinery - device mechanism - motor
single page layout final.indd 39
11/02/2013 23:52
5
8 6
7
single page layout final.indd 40
11/02/2013 23:52
8 ARTEFACTS
single page layout final.indd 41
11/02/2013 23:52
42
ARTEFACTS
TRICKERY How can we explain this devaluation of all values? By the fact that the word design makes us aware that all culture is trickery, that we are tricksters tricked, and that any involvement with culture is the same thing as self-deception. True, once the barrier between art and technology had been broken down, a new perspective opened up within which one could create more and more perfect designs, escape one’s circumstances more and more, live more and more artistically (beautifully).
single page layout final.indd 42
11/02/2013 23:52
43 DEATH-BED
ARTEFACTS
But the price we pay for this is the loss of truth and authenticity. In fact, the lever is about to lever all that is true and authentic out of out orbit and replace it mechanically with perfectly designed artefacts. And so all the artefacts become as valuable as plastic pens, become disposable gadgets. This becomes clear when we die, if not before. Because despite all the technological and artistic arrangements we make (despite hospital architecture and death-bed design), we do die, just as other mammals die. The word design has managed to retain its key position in everyday discourse because we are starting (perhaps rightly) to lose faith in art and technology as sources of value. Because we are starting to wise up to the design behind them. GADG-ET noun. [gad-et] Small tool such as a machine that has a particular function, but is often thought of as a novelty. Gadgets are sometimes referred to as gizmos MAM-MAL noun. [mam-mal] Mammals (class Mammalia) are a clade of warm-blooded amniotes
single page layout final.indd 43
11/02/2013 23:52
single page layout final.indd 44
11/02/2013 23:52
9 CONFESSION
single page layout final.indd 45
11/02/2013 23:52
CONFESSION
46
single page layout final.indd 46
9
11/02/2013 23:52
CONFESSION
47
REALISATION This is a sobering explanation. But it is also an unavoidable one. A confession is called for here. This essay has had a specific design in mind: It set out to expose the cunning and deceptive aspects of the word design. This it did because they are normally concealed. If it had pursued another design, it might, for example, have insisted on the fact that ‘design’ is related to ‘sign’: a sign if the times, a sign of things to come, a sign of membership. In that case, it would have given a different, but equally plausible, explanation of the word’s contemporary situation.
KEY WORDS cunning, deceptive, concealed, sign
single page layout final.indd 47
11/02/2013 23:52
CONFESSION
48
single page layout final.indd 48
11/02/2013 23:52
THAT’S THE
CONFESSION
49
ANSWER THEN: EVERYTHING DEPENDS ON DESIGN.
single page layout final.indd 49
11/02/2013 23:52
GLOSSARY
50
Art The quality, production, expression, or realm, according to aesthetic principles, of what is beautiful, appealing, or of more than ordinary significance. Bridge A connecting, transitional, or intermediate route or phase between two adjacent elements, activities, conditions. Confession Acknowledgment or disclosure of sin or sinfulness, especially to a priest to obtain absolution. Design To plan and fashion artistically or skillfully. Everything Every, thing or particular of an aggregate or total; all. Fooling To act like a fool; joke; play. Gravity The force of attraction by which terrestrial bodies tend to fall toward the center of the earth.
single page layout final.indd 50
Human Consisting of people: the human race.
elliptical, described by a planet, satellite, etc., around a celestial body, as the sun.
Intent Something that is intended; purpose; design; intention.
Pen any of various instruments for writing or drawing with ink or a similar substance.
Key Something that affords a means of access.
Root An essential part or element; the basic core.
Lever A rigid bar that pivots about one point and that is used to move an object at a second point by a force applied at a third.
Sign Any object, action, event, pattern, etc., that conveys a meaning.
Machine An apparatus consisting of interrelated parts with separate functions, used in the performance of some kind of work.
Trojan Horse A hollow wooden horse concealing soldiers, left by the Greeks upon their pretended abandonment of the siege of Troy.
Nature The material world, especially as surrounding humankind and existing independently of human activities.
Ulysses From Ulixes, the Latin name for Odysseus, a character in ancient Greek literature.
Orbit The curved path, usually
Value Relative worth, merit, or importance.
11/02/2013 23:52
51
G
art
18, 22
authenticity
42
B
gravity
O 32
H
orbit
P
homosapiens 32
Plato
18
human
plastic
39,43
pens
39,43
32,38
bourgeois
28
bridge
29
I
branches
29
intent
8
R
barrier
42
idea
18,38
root
8,23
Renaissance 29
K
C
33,43
cunning
9
Kunst
23
S
cheats
15
key
39
sign
8
crafty
15
schoolchidren
15
confession
47
science
39
D
L lever
15,32
law
32
T
deception
8
deceit
15
M
all
machine
15,29
material
18,39
U
mammals
33,43
Ulysses
design
E existenal
28
everything
49
F fooling
single page layout final.indd 51
INDEX
A
N
Trojan Horse
15
technology
42,43
15
V
noun
8,23
verb
8
nature
8,32
value
39,42
15
11/02/2013 23:52
single page layout final.indd 52
11/02/2013 23:52