February 1-29, 2024 The “Real State” of the Real Estate Market www.danielgale.com NEW TO MARKET Address Town Listing Price Style Bedrooms Bath Waterfront Features MLS # 155 Broad Avenue Aquebogue $649,000 Ranch 3 1.5 3534503 55 Beach Road Aquebogue $649,500 Ranch 3 2.0 Bay,Beach,Beach Rights,Water Access,Water View 3528946 19 Fox Trail Court Aquebogue $1,299,000 2 Story 4 3.5 3531483 11 Surfway S. Baiting Hollow $139,990 Cottage 3 1.0 3533087 10 Eastway Path Baiting Hollow $155,000 Cottage 2 1.0 3534634 6 Woodcliff Trail Baiting Hollow $174,990 Cottage 2 1.0 Sound,Water View 3531017 1532 Middle Road Baiting Hollow $649,900 Cape 3 2.0 3532383 119 May Drive Baiting Hollow $889,000 Colonial 4 2.5 3529292
10100 New Suffolk Avenue Cutchogue $1,200,000 Ranch 3 1.0 Bay,Beach,Beach Rights,Water Access,Water Other,Waterfront 3531443 8095 Alvahs Lane Cutchogue $2,175,000 2 Story 4 3.5 3531028 3655 Stillwater Avenue Cutchogue $2,250,000 2 Story 3 1.6 Bay,Beach Rights,Bulkhead,Dock/ Mooring,Motor Boats Allowed,Water Access,Water View,Waterfront 3531421 15105 Oregon Road Cutchogue $5,990,000 Modern 6 8.5 Sound,Water View 3533040 2820 Shipyard Lane East Marion $725,000 Other 1 1.0 Bay,Beach,Beach Rights,Water Access,Water View,Waterfront 3532660 240 Stratmors Road East Marion $1,199,000 Ranch 3 2.0 3533288 1 Sloane Lane East Marion $1,450,000 Farmhouse 3 2.6 3534192 1655 Old Orchard Road East Marion $1,495,000 2 Story 4 3.5 Bay,Beach,Beach Rights,Dock/Mooring,Water Access 3534612 29 Temple Avenue Flanders $425,000 Cottage 3 1.0 Beach Rights 3532736 72 Bay Avenue Flanders $749,000 Cape 3 1.0 Waterfront 3529676 555 Bridge Street Greenport $965,000 Antique/Hist 2 1.5 3530657 508 4th Street Greenport $1,350,000 Duplex 4 2.0 3532483
190 Pheasant Place Greenport $1,390,000 Colonial 4 2.5 Beach Rights 3531299 70 Tuthills Lane Jamesport $695,000 Farmhouse 3 2.0 3529385 33 Lagoon Court Jamesport $799,000 Water Access 3530596 33 Circle Drive Jamesport $899,000 Cape 4 3.0 3532291 1146 Main Road Jamesport $1,200,000 3529388 1192 Main Road Jamesport $1,999,999 3529390 105 Lockitt Drive Jamesport $2,800,000 Other 3 3.0 Bay,Beach,Dock/ Mooring,Motor Boats Allowed,Water Access,Water Other,Water View,Waterfront 3534012 2800 Main Road Laurel $785,000 Ranch 4 2.0 3531110 2300 N Oakwood Road Laurel $1,200,000 2 Story 2 2.0 Water Access,Water View,Waterfront 3530143 2300/2400 N Oakwood Road Laurel $2,200,000 Other 3 3.0 Beach,Beach Rights,Creek,Water Access,Water View,Waterfront 3530141 2755 Westphalia Road Mattituck $739,000 Exp Ranch 3 2.0 3532110 355 Woodcliff Drive Mattituck $795,000 Ranch 3 2.0 3534109 600 Point Pleasant Road Mattituck $950,000 Water Other 3534644
19500 Main Road Mattituck $975,000 3530050 1420 Gabriella Court Mattituck $1,150,000 Post Modern 4 2.5 3529008 2980 Ole Jule Lane Mattituck $1,595,000 Colonial 3 2.0 Beach Rights,Canal,Creek,Dock/ Mooring 3534620 385 New Suffolk Avenue Mattituck $2,075,000 Land 3530560 385 New Suffolk Avenue Mattituck $2,075,000 3530701 245 Love Lane Nw Mattituck $2,575,000 Water Access 3532051 250 Naugles Drive Mattituck $3,200,000 2 Story 4 4.5 Sound,Water View 3533122 1855 Greenway E Orient $495,000 3534631 420 Old Farm Road Orient $810,000 3533103 290 Windward Road Orient $3,499,999 Modern 5 4.0 Water View 3533473 35650 County Road 48 Peconic $3,850 3529751 427 (C) Lincoln Street Riverhead $2,480 3534402 427 (D) Lincoln Street Riverhead $2,480 3534407
427 (C&D) Lincoln Street Riverhead $4,940 3534411 37-14 Hubbard Avenue Riverhead $40,000 Mobile Home 2 1.0 3533397 525/A5 Riverleigh Riverhead $70,000 Mobile Home 1 1.0 3529683 525/50 Riverleigh Avenue Riverhead $99,999 Mobile Home 3 1.5 Lake/Pond/Stream 3530017 37-28 Hubbard Avenue Riverhead $114,900 Mobile Home 2 2.0 Beach Rights 3529639 1800 Osborn Avenue Riverhead $219,000 Mobile Home 2 2.0 3533373 1661-384 Old Country Road Riverhead $324,999 Ranch 3 2.0 3530230 1661-269 Old Country Road Riverhead $325,000 Ranch 2 2.0 3528918 3301 Carnoustie Court Riverhead $480,000 Townhouse 2 2.0 3529589 2104 Cedar Path Riverhead $599,990 Townhouse 2 2.5 Beach Rights,Lake/Pond/ Stream 3531278 1018 Roanoke Avenue Riverhead $695,000 3532570 1025 Roanoke Avenue Riverhead $725,000 Colonial 3 2.5 3529613 852 Pond View Road Riverhead $749,000 Contemporary 4 3.0 Pond 3531766
33 Woodhull Avenue Riverhead $779,996 Colonial 4 3.5 3534155 52 W Linda Lane Riverhead $825,000 Cape 4 2.5 Beach Rights 3531114 15 Kingfish Court Riverhead $839,000 Post Modern 4 2.5 Beach Rights,Sound,Water Access 3531981 226 Riverleigh Avenue Riverhead $849,000 3530218 406 Osborn Avenue Riverhead $4,600,000 3531193 169 N Ferry Rd Shelter Island $675,000 3532589 73 N Cartwright Road Shelter Island $1,445,000 Colonial 4 3.5 3530179 5 Country Club Drive Shelter Island $1,675,000 Ranch 3 2.5 3532284 220 Glenn Road Southold $889,000 Exp Ranch 3 2.0 Creek,Water View,Waterfront 3534276 2845 Hobart Road Southold $890,000 Ranch 3 2.0 Water View 3534762 1345 Long Creek Drive Southold $898,500 Ranch 4 2.0 Creek,Water View,Waterfront 3530471 555 Mill Creek Drive Southold $899,000 Cottage 2 1.0 Creek,Inlet,Motor Boats Allowed,Water Access,Water View,Waterfront 3529857 355 Cedar Drive Southold $955,000 2 Story 3 2.0 3529596
400 Meadow Court Southold $1,050,000 Townhouse 3 2.5 Beach Rights,Bulkhead,Dock/ Mooring,Water Access 3533651 280 Pond Avenue Southold $1,349,000 Exp Ranch 5 4.0 3531156 55975 Route 25 Southold $1,600,000 3530714 55975 Route 25 Southold $1,600,000 Comm/Ind 3530579 25 Lighthouse Road Southold $2,050,000 Nantucket 4 2.5 3531072 3995 Wells Avenue Southold $2,169,000 2 Story 4 4.0 Bulkhead,Canal,Dock/ Mooring,Water Access,Water View,Waterfront 3531580 0 Atlantic Ocean Walk Water Island $2,900,000 Mid Century Modern 4 4.0 3529892
UNDER CONTRACT Address Town Listing Price Style Bedrooms Bath Waterfront Features MLS # 1700 S Smith Drive Southold $499,000 3513191 265 Arshamomaque Avenue Southold $500,000 Beach Rights 3517263 415 Kaplan Avenue Greenport $350,000 Land 3522316 Tuthills Lane Jamesport $350,000 3529386 62 Tuthills Lane Jamesport $375,000 3529387 3085 Laurel Avenue Southold $475,000 Water View,Waterfront 3530497 300 Johnson Court Greenport $599,000 2 Story 2 1 3510535 615 Deep Hole Drive Mattituck $699,000 Ranch 3 1 Water View 3513112 1500 Grand Avenue Mattituck $619,999 Cottage 2 1 Water View 3519855 455 Middle Road Riverhead $399,990 Colonial 3 1 3521571 57 Nash Avenue Flanders $595,000 Ranch 2 1 Bay,Water View 3524542
3985 Pequash Avenue Cutchogue $745,000 Cottage 2 1 Beach Rights 3526018 1000 9th Street Greenport $280,000 Garden Apartment 1 1 3527049 805 Wiggins Street Greenport $540,000 Bungalow 2 1 3527810 50 Kirby Lane Riverhead $849,000 Ranch 2 1 Beach Rights 3529906 508 Willow Pond Drive Riverhead $399,000 Garden Apartment 1 1.5 Beach Rights,Sound,Water Access 3523797 48 Peconic Trail Flanders $635,000 Cottage 1 1.5 Bay,Water View,Waterfront 3529531 2000 Pequash Avenue Cutchogue $705,000 Ranch 3 1.5 Beach Rights 3529862 15705 County Road 48 Cutchogue $675,000 Cape 3 2 3506822 19 Dolphin Way Riverhead $679,999 Exp Cape 4 2 3507450 355 Azalea Road Mattituck $895,000 Exp Ranch 3 2 3508177 10 Brown Street Riverhead $560,000 2 Story 4 2 3509921 525-147 Riverleigh Avenue Riverhead $179,999 Mobile Home 2 2 3510328 820 Marratooka Road Mattituck $895,000 2 Story 3 2 Water View 3513710 875 Sigsbee Road Mattituck $619,000 Bungalow 3 2 Bay,Beach,Beach Rights,Water Access,Water Other 3515761 944 Ostrander Avenue Riverhead $599,990 Ranch 3 2 3518019
477 Hartmanns Farm Road Riverhead $849,000 Ranch 3 2 Pond 3522899 525 Riverleigh Avenue Riverhead $99,000 Mobile Home 2 2 3523355 764 Flanders Road Riverhead $469,000 Ranch 3 2 3526361 166 Baywood Drive Baiting Hollow $599,000 Ranch 3 2 3527696 1235 Wells Road Peconic $2,195,000 Contemporary 3 2.5 Creek,Water View,Waterfront 3494446 40 Kerry Court Riverhead $849,000 Colonial 5 2.5 3511955 430 Pine Tree Road Cutchogue $1,499,000 Colonial 4 2.5 Bay,Beach,Beach Rights,Dock/ Mooring,Water Access,Water Other 3520932 16 Tyler Riverhead $899,990 Colonial 4 2.5 3527564 42 Harper Road Baiting Hollow $649,999 Colonial 3 2.5 Beach,Beach Rights,Sound 3527864 405 Willow Pond Drive Riverhead $499,999 Townhouse 2 2.5 Beach,Beach Rights,Sound,Water Access 3533500 523/193 Riverleigh Avenue Riverhead $135,000 Mobile Home 2 2.55 3531617 213 Knapp Place Greenport $999,999 2 Story 4 3 Beach Rights 3499694 6 Mastro Court Baiting Hollow $999,000 Post Modern 4 3 3513496 1250 White Eagle Drive Laurel $1,495,000 2 Story 4 3 3517170
CLOSED 370 Fishermans Beach Road Cutchogue $2,400,000 Nantucket 5 3 Bay,Beach,Beach Rights,Creek,Dock/ Mooring,Water Access,Water View,Waterfront 3525608 150 Ellen Street Riverhead $599,900 Ranch 2 3 3525819 400 Windjammer Drive Southold $2,895,000 Contemporary 4 4 Bay,Beach,Beach Rights,Dock/ Mooring,Inlet,Water Access,Water View,Waterfront 3510741 Address Town Listing Price Sold Price Style Bedrooms Bath Waterfront Features MLS # 15325 County Road 48 Cutchogue $2,900,000 $2,900,000 3360407 2820 Stanley Road Mattituck $689,000 $639,000 3511424 955 Lilac Lane Cutchogue $349,000 $395,000 Beach Rights 3453178 248 5th Avenue Greenport $679,000 $565,000 Other 1 1.0 3469147 1228 Roanoke Avenue Riverhead $499,000 $450,000 2 Story 1 1.5 3500811 55075 Route Southold $279,000 $284,950 Garden Apartment 1 1.0 3512575 525-P2 Riverleigh Avenue Riverhead $54,999 $43,000 Mobile Home 1 1.0 3517274
4106 Fox Hill Drive Baiting Hollow $525,000 $510,000 Townhouse 2 2.0 3516050 329 2nd Street Greenport $595,000 $575,000 Cottage 2 1.0 3516734 105 Scenic Lake Drive Riverhead $529,000 $505,000 Townhouse 2 2.0 3513324 1049 West Street Riverhead $250,000 $280,000 Ranch 2 1.0 3514368 1661-168A Old Country Road Riverhead $149,900 $100,000 Ranch 2 2.0 3514661 555 Bridge Street Greenport $865,000 $965,000 Antique/Hist 2 1.5 3515140 1661-261 Old Country Road Road Riverhead $239,999 $235,000 Mobile Home 2 2.0 3508050 24 Anchor Path Baiting Hollow $135,000 $135,000 Cottage 2 1.0 3525016 1661-423 Old Country Road Riverhead $159,000 $159,000 Ranch 2 2.0 Pond 3528057 550 Depot Lane Cutchogue $649,000 $620,000 2 Story 3 3.0 3511626 35 Hillcrest Drive Baiting Hollow $119,990 $105,000 Cottage 3 1.0 3512144 11 Pebble Way Riverhead $545,000 $555,000 Colonial 3 1.5 3485238 1645 Bayview Avenue Mattituck $849,000 $835,000 Colonial 3 2.5 3490332 65 Cottage Road Baiting Hollow $105,000 $105,000 2 Story 3 1.0 3490877 17525 County Road 48 Cutchogue $999,999 $909,000 Farmhouse 3 2.0 3491434 1118 W Main Street Riverhead $499,009 $515,000 Colonial 3 2.0 3513652
630 Northville Turnpike Riverhead $525,000 $530,000 Colonial 3 2.0 3518229 10725 Old Sound Avenue Mattituck $649,000 $645,000 Ranch 3 2.0 3510846 525/93A Riverleigh Avenue Riverhead $169,999 $165,000 Mobile Home 3 2.0 3515779 730 Bayview Drive East Marion $1,585,000 $1,500,000 Colonial 3 2.0 Bay,Beach,Beach Rights,Creek,Lake Association,Motor Boats Allowed,Water Access,Water Other,Water View,Waterfront 3517085 1270 Trumans Path East Marion $1,295,000 $1,250,000 Cape 3 2.0 Beach Rights,Lake,Lake Rights,Lake Views,Lakefront,Water Access,Water View,Waterfront 3511618 33 Big Pond Lane Jamesport $869,000 $860,000 Townhouse 3 2.5 Beach,Beach Rights,Lake/Pond/ Stream,Pond,Sound,Wa terfront 3513736 295 Maiden Lane Mattituck $1,495,000 $1,400,000 Colonial 3 3.0 Creek,Dock/ Mooring,Harbor,Inlet,Wa ter Access,Water View,Waterfront 3508809 60 Koke Drive Southold $749,000 $780,000 Ranch 3 2.0 Water View 3521422 327 Hamilton Avenue Riverhead $549,000 $570,000 2 Story 4 2.5 3514049 570 Country Club Drive Cutchogue $1,495,000 $1,542,210 Colonial 4 3.0 3515195 500 Banks Street Cutchogue $2,100,000 $1,950,000 Farmhouse 4 2.5 3492490 3010 Stanley Road Mattituck $1,985,000 $1,945,000 Colonial 4 3.5 3463123
Cutchogue Office Ma.tuck Office (Love Lane) Ma.tuck Office Greenport Office Shelter Island Office 631.734.5439 631.298.4130 631.298.0300 631.477.0013 631.749.1155 cutchogue@danielgale.com ma.tucklove@danielgale.com ma.tuck@danielgale.com greenport@danielgale.com shelterisland@danielgale.com *Code of Ethics: If you are working with a local agent….this is for informa<onal purposes only* Visit us on Facebook: Daniel Gale North Fork 2085 Bayview Avenue Greenport $1,289,000 $1,175,000 Mid Century Modern 4 1.5 Pond,Waterfront 3513156 334 Maple Avenue Riverhead $569,000 $550,000 Colonial 5 2.0 3436199 1200 Indian Neck Lane Peconic $2,850,000 $2,850,000 Antique/Hist 5 3.6 3499631 212 5th Avenue Greenport $1,090,000 $1,070,000 2 Story 5 3.0 3483423