Forskningsbakgrund Decision Dynamics JTIโ ข
Professor Rickard Larsson Fรถretagsekonomiska institutionen Ekonomihรถgskolan vid Lunds Universitet Decision Dynamics AB Ideon Science Park SE-223 70 Lund, Sweden www.decisiondynamics.se
Decision Dynamics LLC 2131 La Granada Drive Thousand Oaks CA 91362, USA info@decdynamics.com
!"#$%& '$%(()*+ ,%)-.(()%+ '/*&( /*"0.%("1.1 > 53?? @<=;4 ABC6?6;3 234567348 9:8;7<= DEF F FFQ HTUVQN FYMJDEF EIZQTXMYSQ N GH IJKLM L GN OP Q IQLPN N H XQ KHJXLM L G LTU Y INXQP W a [ELXQFEF\]HJXLMF LGNFHXY ^JKQPEFHLR \ HLRSQXLR E F F bcdb IjEF_`PHIY G GQHILS ULFLR G ZYPFS EKKHILS e fYPMFOPYg e k_IQPUY E PHKP GM N G Q Q YZ hN G R S iPQ SH M O P GYP LTU FIYFRQFNFGHHXNMF jYXIN FaFSQR EFI [MQZ HaEYMMZYPMFNGY YII SQI SLTX RYPXY G UQIQP RQMM Y HLRINM M HM l a E DEF F SQI IQPYSQ HQKYPYINRJTXQI L e LMNXY G XLRNF_YMMH HZNHRFXMYNP LTU GLRGPYIIEFHQSMOHNGGYLTU SH LQ NGUQI EMIYINYZQ SQPYH FSQ iPQ HLRPQHQII MPQH HJFHOII e [LXQF LTU mE aFGY RQFYP YII SQFFFY EFLQFNGUQI FHKNPYINFLFHXOMMYF INMMFYIIF DEF ZYP N G HXPQZ F F EF F FYSQP IZQTXM Y SQ IJKLM L GN gP SIY XQ NIJKLM L GN OP YII SQI _N H _ SYRQ IYM Y HXNM M e a YII [ [ F FF F F F F F RQM M Y RO N H XLP HLR UYP QIJSQM H Q N Q PYS HYRRY UY G QIIY N Q OP YII ZN H e n [ E E F F F HOGY OP_`P INMM YIIYF EKKGN IZQTXM_IQPY LHHZNMXYN QHYXQP ZNHH ZNPNXOPI N[QGFl OGLTUFYYIIYIISQIIY MOROPXQ GGQP INMM LTU Fa Y a_`PIUFEQHIORSY PYRYP PZNIYP LHH M O GGY al HYRI a ZNMXQI HOII ZN NFGaP N MNPQMIYYINKLlFZQP PY QHHY N _YMMH_EFZNFSYRQ XMYPINFMIYMM YIIY HXNM HIOMMMFFYSQP NFl G INMNFFM HYXQP K K a [ [ F F Q OP LTXH YII SQI _N H ZN H HY QIQQFSQF e n a F E F F F F HLR _YMM Q P LHH RQP YI PMN G I Q_IQPHLR SQ XY HQH HLR_`PM O G N GYP YZ Z PY FSQFHIJPXLPe ]a HYRRY HOII _NFFH SQI ZNHHY [FQIQQFSQFEHLR ZN EKKMQZQP[ HLR GPHZEFaPYPQ SMOGGY RQSe YII UY IQPYl LTU HLR XPOZQP RJTXQI XPY_I LTU Q QPGN YII IZQTXMY LTU YP QIY FFFOP HaMQSQH YII ZNaPQFaI _YXINHXI _`SH RQS LMNXY QF GPEFYIISMOZNGGYMNXFFSQYPIYQFFXQSQMF YZNIJKLM L GN nHIJPXLPo RO FIYNHXLPZN R`IQPRQMK MYZF LHH PZOGHjOMQ_IQPHLR SQPYH HIJPXLP FYPZaPYl LTU YII ZNFFEKKMEFQZQPSQRYPXY F F MNXHIJPXLP HXNM M YSQP Z Y LTU Y SPY ZYPH OP RJTXQI Y LPM SY _PaF ZaPYe F FF F EF FFFIYMIYFXQ[ OP YIIa SQ LMNXY HIJPXLPFY OP MFNXZOPSNGYl RQF NFIQ MNjXY [PYF INMM YMMOPk I[NYFPYGeKYpaaYII_GPYSYRQ ROKa SQNHXLP`ZQPGPNKY OP PY FKSQYIIKPNMFOTNKQP GGY ROPXQ INHYRRY MM XL XPQIY SPYG LTUOGGQSQIYMSQMYQPP eqOP MNSPY F F F HQ Y LTU UY GQI XY e r a a E FF F ZOPSQ_ M Y LTU RQSZQPXYPINM M YII IZ RO N H XLP HLR OPZYPY SPYH RLIHYIHQP K SQIIY aSQ XYlF XLRKMQIIQPY ZYPYFSPY ZOM N QII HYRYP[QIQl RQF XYFHXQ LTXHa N ZNHH GPYS LRP NPPNIQPY ZYPYFSPYe DEFGHFIJKLMLGNF OP [YPY FQF MNIQF SQM YZ SQFF QFLPRY ROFGS RYIQPNYM HLR jUYF KPLS[ ETQPYSQFl LTU SYHIQM QI RJTXQI SQM YZ RQS Q RJTXQI LR_YIIY SQ[LXQ KHJXLM LE[GNMHNTXIQLPN YKKYPYI h OMNFZHKNPQPYSQ YP QIYSQ UY e F F N[FLXQ IQ QHKQTN SQ Q_IQP SQI YII K QPYSQH OPQRLI eYPQn RQS SQFe ^JKLMLGNF [ F QF PYS ROFFFNHFXLP HLRILG F IQLPN IN M M HN G LTU YP QIYSQ ZN S OP SOP_`PIPLMNGQ SQ SQM YZ DEFGH YP[QIQ HLR UYP _aII HI`PHI XLFXPQI YFZOFSFNFGe st5=3=; :uF @<=;4 5BCF6?6;3 F E DEFGH IJKLM mr^vw mxmJQPHyEFrPNGGHbc}~ XO SY N HIP RQ IQI _`P YII ROIY L GN OP ^JKQy nvFQISNTRQHI z{ [ E F F YILP HLR IZQTXM Y SQH YZ |YIUYPN Q PN G GH Y S vHY QM PN G GH JQPH SQP IYM SQGQI eqaPSFSPYd~~dz NFHIPERQFI OPI Q hNFGQPy LLRNr Hl gPQJy UQQMPNrGUI LTU |NQPHQJ x NFGHIYS l e ¢ ¡ ¡
D^v£ xDEFGNYFa^JKQ vEFSQ z Ebcc~ HYPS NLF NnJFFGHIYS YRNTHLTU^ULP IZQTXMyIYMYSQH YZ SQYIIFLPHXY KHJXLM LSQP GQPFT¦YY n¤QTN [[ j EF YM M Z ¥SQG PS N HM IQI YZ Q I Q_IQP UY L YI a SQF FLPHXY FF E m F F E F F E QIIRYPXSQTQ N R RQS ^vw QI JY N HIP RQ IQI N IPLS TQPYSQH K r e n a FYSQF d~~b LTU K SQF SYFHXY RYPXFYSQF d~~§e aP YZ ¨©a _PaGLP SOP RYF ZOMjQP RQMMYF IZa YMIQPaFYINZ P`PYFSQ YRNTSNRQ H D^vF£HNL[FQHINZYP nQFQTNYZHNLDEFF nGHJF_JPY jQ _P bd~ jQ SNRQFHNLFF[QUYFSMYH N b} _P GLP GY YP eª e a a F E NQ_IQPUY GHIYSFSLTU ¥SQG PS HIYPIYSQ RQS _P GLPHLR HQSY UYP HIYIN H IN H XI PQS TQPYIH FH ¨©Fe nQIIY HIYINFHINEFHXY YP[QIQ GQFLR_`PSQH YZ [M Y KHJXLMLGQF IN M M SYGQ a F KPL_QHHLP hI MQ kN YPHQ ZNS rQPGQ H NZQPHNIQIe D^vF£DEFPQHEMIFQPYP [MNP SQMF HaQF YZ b© QHZYPYFSQ YZ[NFnYINQTNLHFNQPLFHLR T H r[LXHIYZHXLR nJFYRN F mr^vwHLR Y GQP SQ GN Y HXY IJKQ K HYRRY HOII HLR ] D F F F F E IPQHKQXIN Q kpiZQLTU vh^ FlHSQMOPHx~QIIyb}zKPQ_QPQFjOR_`PQM HIYM _`PZYPSQPY SNUREPQ HNQTNLHNLHLR YFYRN GQPTUH DPIJSMN G F F KPQ_QPQ H Q RQMM Y J ^v LTU e kQII YFIYM HXNMMFYSQPe nQTNHNnLF nJFYRNn TH D^v¦ a mr^vwOP XLFHIPEQPYSQ ZN H YP K aGLPe UYP_OPPQ _P FZOFSQPaUQMY RQFNFGYP_`P HYRIMNGY _PaGLPINMM HXNMMFYS _PaF ZNHHY XLFIPLZQPHNQM Y YLPSKYPH_P GLPRNe FSPQ Q IPQRI _LPREMQPYSQ _`P YII G`PY SQR RQP YFZOFSYPZOFMNGY OPLTURQSZQIQI FSQe RNFSPQ KPLZLTQPY aGLP aMMHy LTU FJYFHPNXI _LPREMQPYSQ Ha YII E F F UYP_JPY _P N HM IQI HLR OP HKQTN Q M I N QU SQROIQP GQPHNQFFF U`GPQ HIYIN HINHHQX LTU KPQTNNFHINLEFNIeNLF HLR QF PQF EKKMQZQMHQy F QH_`P NRRQM «EKKROPXHYRUQISNRQ FHNLF _`P YII EFSZNXY KPL[MQRYINHX HYRRYF[MYFSFNFG RQS F E F XPQYIN Z N I QI LTU N I N I N L e EMQPNFGYP _`P^YFXQy|OFHMY SNRQFHNLFQF ZNMXQI GQP QF [ F UYP RQP YM Y HQPYSQ _LPR [OIIPQ FGe F F _`PSQMFNSNPQXI F [QHZYPYH XYXLRKM v IQPFNFGQIYZHLRPQHRNEMIFYIHXYP _QMXOMMLPFY jOR_`PI RQS RQP NTQPYS RYFEQMMZN[YQPOX e t443F;: E8u:F?355 [ ¬®F 3436=F ¬F B=:¯3®4 @A°±4 ²67F 48=3=;4¯ [ F _a P N GHROHHN G Y XZYM N I QIQ ROIH M Y RQS N HIP RQ IQIH PQMN Y NM N I QI ³ YII RY nINMQM_`PM_LPHX E F F NNIMMNNIGQIQY ROIPQH MIYI ³GQLTUFLRZYMHNSXNIQI\IQHIyPQIQHI ³ YII RY \ _YXIN HHXIYIIROIQP SQIFQPRY[QHZYPYP YZHQP YII ROIYe [ F F QMN Y XY ROIYH S Z KQPHL a GaFGQP RQS QF ZNHH INSHKQPNLlS QRQMMYFe nQFFY INMM_`PMNIMNGUQI OP_EM I EMOFPQI IZ´~µ _PINMaM_GQ_LPR FH NHYRIMN FHNLFFQP NzSQF FFLPHXY Y SQKQPHLx FQP UYSQ HYRRY KPQ_QPQ GYZY SN}}RQKQPHL aGLI U`GPQ ©© F }© µ F F E F HIOFESNPQSHHIOMM Q YZ LTU N SQ SY HXY HI SN Q QP LTU mr^vwl HLR ZNHYH N^Y[QMM be º¾¹ ·¸ºº¾º¾¿»¼¹¿ À¿¹Á¿Âù¿¹Á¿À ÄÅà ƹǾÁ¾ÈÉ ÆÊɷ˾ÇÁ Ì ¶Í ¾ÎÏËÄÅùºÁ¹ ˹РÑÒ¶ÍÓ ½¶·¸¹ î áåÚ×âÝÜãÕÚØ×äÚåæÙÚÕÜåæÕ Ô Ô ßà ßà ÕÖ× Ø × Ù Ú Ö Ø Þ ÛÚÜÝ× ç ç ìíòó ñ âèåïð×Õ ×ñéÙæêÕ âèå×Õòò× ÔñÜÚÝÜæë àÚêÜ ôÚ õöõ ññ õïï ññ õò÷ññ ßøù ßæÛæÕÜ öð ññ ðð ññ úññ û ð ßÕØâüæÕâÕØâ ×ÚâÕæøÜãã ö ý ÷ øÕÖëÙæþ éÿöò öéÿýööúó øÕÖëÙæþ ö ÜÚøÕÖèÜãëÙæ äããÜ ìíßà ì • • • • • • •
$
$ !! "# !! "
% & ! !! (
'%
! ! )
' *
+
% % ! !, '
% '% ) , !!
% *
'% % '% ! ! ! !! !!
% '%
'
* !!!
--.
'
/ 0
* 1/23
'
'% % %
! !!
456788 9: ;78<56<8<=7= >=7? =@A7=7? => BCAA785 =<CD?BC7EE<F<7D =7A G7F<?<CD GHD5I<F? J 4K L
Ô×ÝÕÚØ×ÙÚ çßô éûà ßÕØâüæÕâÕØâ ×ÚâÞÕæøÜãã N N N NP
ÙææÕãÜâ×ÙÚØëÙÕ ×Ö×ÕÚâ × éÙæêÕ ÙææÕãÜâÔ×ÙÜÚÝÜ ÚØëÙÕæë ×Ö×ÕÚâ × ððþþ÷÷ò ððþþ õó ððþ÷þ÷óï ððþ÷þ òú ö ý ÷ øÕÖëÙæþ éÿöò ö ý úó øÕÖëÙæþ éÿöö
MM
MM
O
O O O
X YZ V[\XV '%
& % QRSTUVW ]T^_RT^ `STZ]Z^_T^V % a 3 ' '% '% !! ! !!
U_bR_\\ZcV[]d]^_^ " * $ % a 3 ' " ! e!$ '% % * 1/23 a 3 ' / f * '% f '
,, 456788 g: ;78<56<8<=7= h <D =7AD BCD?<? =7D? h 67iA7jj? k58<l<=7= EmA G7F<?<CD GHD5I<F? J 4K L
Ô×ÝôÕÚØ×à ÙÚ çß éû áÚâÜã Þ ÕæØÙÚÕæ N N N NP
r
n
æÙÚ ÜÖ ØðþÜãó Ü × éÙæêÕ þ÷ö ðððþ÷÷ ÷þ÷ú o
pq
rp
O
O
n
æÙÚ ÜÖ Ø Üãðþ÷öÜ × ÔÜÚÝÜæë ðððþ÷þ÷þ÷õõ óó o
pq
rp
s
O
s
t cV[]d] ^_^_T % &
% * 1/2 uv/2w 1
* '
%
'
x '
t % / y '% " ! ! % $ % zz ! !, z
456788 {: |CAA785 =<CD?BC7EE<F<7D =7A I7885D G7F<?<CD GHD5I<F? J 4K L CF} ~ 4K k58<l<=7=?I == EmA I =D<Di 5k J Di? =Hj 7A :
Ó
? CI
¡ ¢£ ¤ ¥¦§§ ¨£ ¤ ¦§§ £© ¤ ª«§§ ¤ ¡§§ £¬ § ®¯ ¤ ¤°£ ±¯ §§ ®¯ ¤ ¤¡£ ±¯ ²³´ µ¶·¸¹º ¶ µ¶º» ¼·½³¾¾ ¿ ·´´ À·¸´ ¾Á¹· µÂ¶· à Á¸³»ÀÁÄ»³ ¶ Ŷ À´· ¶Æ´ ÆÄ ¶¶³¾³ ¶·Ã³ Ǹ³¾¾·» ÈÉÊË ÄÌÍ ÈÉ¿Î Àĸ ·¾¾· Ŷ À´·´ÁÀ´ÁÀÆ´ ÀÁ¹»ÁµÁÆ·»´· Ϻ ¸Á»À´ ÈÉÈÐ »ÁÒº»ÓÔ ²³´ Ŷ Á»´¶³ÀÀ·»´ Ñ ·´´ »Ä´³ ¶· ·´´ ó» ¸Á»À´ ÆÄ ¶¶³¾³ ¶·Ã³ ÃÁ¸³»ÀÁÄ»³» Ŷ Õ¼·»Æ³ÑÖÅ»À¾·ÕÉ Àĸ ÄÌ ÆÀº Ŷ ó» à Á¸³»ÀÁÄ» ÃŶ ×Á»¹À´·Ã ÄÌÍ Øó¹º ¶Ã ¸³ÃÒ³´³´ Í· ¶ µÙ¶ÀÙÆ´ ·´´ µÙ¶½Å´´¶· ¸Å´ »Á»¹³» ¹³»Ä¸ ·´´ ¹Ù¶· ó» ¸³ ¶ ½·¾·»À³¶·Ã Ú Å ¸µÙ¶´ ¸³Ã ó» ÙÒ³ ¶Ò ÁÆ´ µÙ¶ ¼·»Æ³ Àĸ ÛܼÝÞ Í· ¶Ô ßàááàâãàääâåâæ ²³Ì ÁÀÁÄ» ²Â »·¸ÁÌÀ ç¼Ýè Ŷ ³´´ »Â´´ ÄÌÍ Ï¶· Æ´ÁÀÆ´ Á»À´¶é¸³»´ Àĸ ¸Å´³ ¶ ç 黹À ´Â ϳ ¶ ¸³Ã ÍÙ¹ µÄ ¶ÀÆ»Á»¹À ¸ÅÀÀÁ¹ ÆÒ·¾Á´³´ »Å¶ ó´ ¹Å ¾¾³ ¶ ½ºÃ³ ¶³¾Á·½Á¾Á´³´ ÄÌÍ Ò·¾ÁÃÁ´³´ Ô
êëãëìë âíëì îïðñòóôõð öð÷ø ù úðøóöû ó ÇËÈÈ¿Ó ü»Ã³ ¶ÀÙ¹³¾À³ ÃÄ Æ鸳»´³ ¶· ¶ Ϻ¾Áó¾Á¹Í³Ã ·µ ÷»ÀÆ ç¼Ý Ô Ö٠ϳ»Í·¸»É ²·»¸· ¶Æý þ³»´³ ¶ µÄ ¶ ÿ³Ã³¾À³É ²³Ì³¸½³ ¶É ÀÁà Ô
µÄ ¶Ã ÀÂÌ;ŠÁÌ·¾ ¶³ÀÀ ÿÁ¸Á´³Ã
ÇËÈÈÐÓ
ú ò µÄ ¶ÃÉ »¹¾·»Ã Ô
×Á»¹À´·ÃÉ Ô Ô Ã³¹º ¶ÃÉ ¼ Ô ÇËÈÈËÓ úû ð ø ó ð øð ò ø óû ð øû ô ô ô Ô Ü³ ¶¹³»É Ä ¶¹³ ý Ï´Á¸·ÀÔ
ð óôø