2 minute read
Discussion and Outlook
The reference project demonstrates a significant GHG avoidance potential with load shifting. When dispatch sequences are well-configured and designed to respond to changing grid conditions, even a battery bank with a small capacity can avoid substantial GHG emissions. When not designed well, however, the GHG avoidance from onsite renewable resources can diminish in the future as the grid gets cleaner. Accordingly, any design and system sizing decisions based on present grid emission profiles can seriously limit the future emissions avoidance potential. The reference project is based in California within the context of an electric grid with high solar contribution already, and a projection that solar photovoltaic penetration will increase significantly over the next few years. While the exact results of a similar study will differ for other projects based on their demand profiles and grid-regions, the findings are applicable for any region with a reasonable Renewable Portfolio Standard. With renewable penetration increasing in grids across the board, periods of curtailment for intermittent renewable energy sources may differ but the magnitude of difference in GHG emission factors between mid-day and lateafternoon hours will be similar.
Finally, it is important to note that this paper focuses on only one of several mechanisms for load shifting - electrical storage and dispatch with the help of batteries. Similar arguments apply to load shifting through thermal storage and building demand management controls. Such microgrids - thermal or electric - that offer an optimal combination of building controls, distributed energy resources, and storage will play an increasingly important role towards decarbonization of the built environment, especially with the increasing penetration of intermittent renewables in the grid as time-of-use considerations becomes paramount to avoid future grid emissions.
Shreshth Nagpal
Principal - Design Analytics | snagpal@elementaengineering.com
Rushil Desai
Building Performance Analyst | rdesai@elementaengineering.com
Endnotes 1 Desai R, Shah S, Nagpal S, Investigating the impact of cost-based and carbon-based renewable energy generation and storage sizing strategies on carbon emissions for all-electric buildings; 2018 BPACS 2 https://www.integralgroup.com/news/climate-mobilization-act/ 3 https://www.cityofberkeley.info/climate/ 4 Siler-Evans K, Azevedo IL, Morgan MG. Marginal emissions factors for the US electricity system.
Environmental science & technology. 2012 May 1;46(9):4742-8.
In 2014, Elementa Engineering DPC joined Integral Group LLC as part of an interactive global network of mechanical, electrical, plumbing and energy engineers, and firms collaborating under a single deep green engineering umbrella. We specialize in the design of simple, elegant, costeffective systems for a wide variety of project types. Elementa Engineering DPC is a New York based professional services consulting engineering firm focused on positively impacting the built environment. Through a relationship with Integral Group LLC, we are creating a new realm of possibilities by combining our diversified leadership and common visionary approach to green buildings. Collectively championing the use of the most innovative and sustainable systems, we give life to high performance buildings and communities that both respect and enrich the Earth, and provides our clients with global expertise in step with a local presence.
New York Design Studio
54 West 40th Street New York, NY 10018
