Portfolio 2019 by Dhanya Pravin

PORT F OL I O URBANPL ANNI NG|ARCHI T E CT URE|I NT E RI ORDE S I GN

DHANY APRAVI NPODUVAL

DHANY APRAVI NPODUVAL M. Pl a n, S c hool ofPl a nni ng&Ar c hi t e c t ur e-De l hi B. Ar c h, Mumba i Uni v e r s i t y poduv a l . dha n y a @y a hoo. c om Apa r t me nt8, Vi l l a7, Qui r e e nS t , Al Na h y a n, AbuDha bi Ci t y . + 9710547202583 www. l i nk e di n. c om/ i n/ dha ny a pr a v i n2b01859b

Naona l i t y : I ndi a n Vi s aS t a t us : Vi s i tVi s a P a s s por tNumbe r : 489y DOB: 5De c e mbe r1993

Obj ecv e Y oung , dy na mi cAr c hi t e c t -Pl a nne re a g e rt ot a k eupc ha l l e ng e sa ndde v e l op, whi l el e a r ni ngi nt heg l oba l e nv i r ons l e a di ngt or e a pg oode x pos ur ea nde x pe r i e nc ei nt heﬁe l dsofAr c hi t e c t ur ea ndPl a nni ngDha ny ade mons t r a t e sa hi s t or yofe duc aon&wor ka tmulc ul t ur a l hi g he re duc aoni nst ut e sa ndur ba nde v e l opme nti ndus t r y . Dha n y ai sa de pti nDe s i g n, Ma ppi ng , a ndAna l y s i s . S hei sat hor oug hpr of e s s i ona l wi t haMa s t e rofPl a nni ng ( M. Pl a nni ng )wi t hma j or si nHous i ng&Re a l E s t a t ef r omS P A, Ne wDe l hi a ndB. Ar c hf r omMumba i Uni v e r s i t y .

Ac a demi cPr og r es s Ma s t e r si nPl a nni ng ( Hous i ng ) CGP A: 8. 50 20172019 Ac hi e v e me nt s&Re c og nion

Ba c he l or sofAr c hi t e c t ur e

CGP A: 7. 2 20112016

Ac hi e v e me nt s&Re c og nion

S c hool ofPl a nni nga ndAr c hi t ec t ur e, Del hi T he s i spr oj e c t , ‘ Appr oa c he st oRe de v e l opme ntofUr ba nVi l l a g e s -Mumba i ’ l ook e d a tama t r i x&i t e r aonf orr e de v e l opme ntofv a r i ousv i l l a g e si nt hec i t yofMumba i . S t udi oe x e r c i s eonMa r k e tRe s e a r c h, Pl a nni ng&P r oj e c tF or mul aonf orapr oj e c t i nHy de r a ba d, Ana l y s i ngHous i ngOp ons& r e c omme ndi ngS t r a t e g i e sf ort hec i t y ofCoi mba t or e&Out l i neDe v e l opme ntPl a nf ort hec i t yi nAndhr aP r a de s h. T op4i nac l a s sof24wi t hc ons i s t e ntpe r f or ma nc et hr oug houtt hede g r e e .

Pi l l a i Col l eg eofAr c hi t ec t ur e, Na v i Mumba i

T he s i spr oj e c t‘ Upg r di ngT ha k k a rBa ppaCol ony: ACa s eofL i v e+Wor k+S e l l ’ , upg r a di nga ni nf or ma l s el e me nti nMumba i wi t hmi x e dus ena t ur e . S t udi opr oj e c t sofv a r i ouss c a l ewi t hc our s e si nCons t r uconT e c hnol og y , Bui l di ng S e r v i c e s&E smaon&Cosng .

Cha r l e sc or r e aGol dMe da l : Unde r g r a dua t et he s i ss e l e c t e da mongt heﬁna l 8 e nt r i e s , c onduc t e dbyt heUDRI .

Ac hi e v e me nt s&Re c og nion

H. S . C

20092011 Ac hi e v e me nt s&Re c og nion

S . S . C

20112016

NI AS AAwa r df orE x c e l l e nc ei nAr c hi t e c t ur a l T he s i s : Unde r g r a dua t et he s i s s e l e c t e da mongt hefina l 10e nt r i e sa tt hez ona l l e v e l , c onduc t e dbyt heCOA. Mi na l P a nc ha l Awa r d: Unde r g r a dua t et he s i snomi na t e da tc ol l e g el e v e l f ort he a wa r d, c onduc t e dbyt heMi na l P a nc ha l T r us t . I NS DAGCompe on: P a rc i pa nte nt r ya tt hec ompe onfloa t e dbyI NS DAGf or i nnov av ede s i g ni ns t e e l . WI S ECompe on: P a rc i pa nte nt r ya tt hec ompe onfloa t e dbyCAAa i mi nga t i nc l us i v es pa c e sf ort hee l de r l y F e a t ur eCov e rPhot og r a ph( Rur a l S t r e e t s c a pe )-T e c k t on: T e c k t oni sas c hol a r l y j our na l f orAr c hi t e c t ur e , Ur ba nDe s i g n&Pl a nni ng . Cor r e s ponde nt , Conc e pt ua l i z e r , E di t or i a l Boa r d, VOX, Pi CAg r a m: Re s e a r c he d, c e a t e d, s c r e e ne da nds or t e dc ont e ntf ort hea bov eme n one dAnnua l a nd Bi -Annua l Col l e g eP ubl i c aons .

S . I . W. S , Mumba i

T hec our s ei nc l ude dt heba s i c sofE l e c t r oni nc s&Comput e rT e c hnol og ya l ongwi t h t hes ubj e c t sofPhy s i c s , Che mi s t r y&Ma t he mac s . E di t or i a l Boa r d, T heWe l f a r e r : Re s e a r c he d, c e a t e d, s c r e e ne da nds or t e dc ont e ntf or t heAnnua l Col l e g eP ubl i c aon.

S t . Ant honyGi r l s ’ Hi g hS c hool , Mumba i

T hec our s ef r omst hef oundi ngs t onea l s oi nc l udi nge x t r ac ur r i c ul a ra cv ie s .

Or g a ni z a ona l Pr og r es s Pl a nni ngI nt e r n

Y out hf orUni t y&Vol unt a r yAcon, Na v i Mumba i

2018 P r oj e c t sWor k e dOn

Wor k e dwi t hHa bi t a tt e a monpr oj e c t si nv ol v i ngCommuni t yP a rc i paon. P a rc i pa t or yPl a nni ngi nI nf or ma l s el e me nt sofI ndor e . DPRonP ol i c yAna l y s i sf orHous i ngi nI ndor e .

Re s pons i bi l ie sI nc l ude d

As s i sngi nv a r i ouspa rc i pa t or ypl a nni ngwor k s hops Ma ppi ngonAr c GI S S ur v e yAna l y s i s P ol i c ye v a l uaon Gr a phi cde s i g n

S T a NDDes i g n, Mumba i

Ar c hi t e c t

Re s i de na l &Hos pi t a l i t yi nt e r i orde s i g npr oj e c t sa l ongwi t hv i s ua l br a ndi ngpr oj e c t a ndUr ba nDe s i g npr oj e c t s . De s i g n&P r ot ot y pi ngf orP a t hwa y st oS DG-6, UNUME RI T . J a dha vRe s i de nc e Vi s ua l Br a ndi ngf orVi r g oL a mi na t e s Comme r c i a l I nt e r i orf orBa oHa uz RE Wor k i ngDhobi Gha t -Compe onE nt r yf orDe nc i t y2017.

20162017 P r oj e c t sWor k e dOn

Re s pons i bi l ie sI nc l ude d

De s i g nde v e l opme nt F ur ni t ur e&P r oduc tDe s i g n P r e pa r i ngS i t e&P r e s e nt aonDr a wi ng s S i t e&Ve ndorCoor di naon Quot e sa ndCosng BOQ Mode l Ma k i ng

Ac hi e v e me nt s&Re c og nion

P a ne l i s ta tt hec onf e r e nc e‘ P a t hwa y st oS DG-6’ byt heUN. T het e a mf r omS T a ND pr e s e nt e dt oi l e tmode l pr ot ot y pe sont hel i neofE c oS a nf orr ur a l I ndi af or UNU-ME RI T . T hede s i g nwa swe l l a c c e pt e da ndpr og r e s s e df orpr ot oy pi ng .

T r a i ne eAr c hi t e c t

VS DPAr c hi t ec t s , Ba ng a l or e

20152016

As s i s t e di nHi g he ndRe s i de na l , i nst u ona l &Hous i ngP r oj e c t s .

P r oj e c t sWor k e dOn

Re s i de nc ef orRe ddy s Ca f eCof e eDa yF a c t or yUni t Pi t c he sf orL ux ur yRe s i de nc e s .

Re s pons i bi l ie sI nc l ude d

Ge ne r aonofpr e s e nt aon&s i t edr a wi ng s v e ndorc oor di naon Mode l Ma k i ng

S k i l l s

Re f er enc es

Aut oCAD RE VI T AdobeS ui t e S k e t c hUp VRa y L a ng ua g eS k i l l sEngl i s h, Hi ndi , Ma r a t hi ,

Dr . P . S . NRa o, Di r e c t or , S c hool ofPl a nni ng& Ar c hi t e c t ur e , De l hi

Ma l a y a l a m&T a mi l

P r of . S mi t aDa l v i , F oundi ngF a c ul t y , Pi CA, Na v i Mumba i

Ar . Ni k i t aD’ S i l v a , P r i nc i pa l Ar c hi t e c t S T a ND, Mumba i

“ Cie sha v et hec a pa bi l i t yofpr ov i di ngs ome t hi ngf ore v e r y body , onl ybe c a us e , a ndonl y whe n, t he ya r ec r e a t e dbye v e r y body . ” -J a neJ a c obs

GRADUA T E-ACADE MI C

CONT E NT S Re de v e l opme ntS t r a t e g i e sf or Ur ba nVi l l a g e s , Mumba i . Ur ba nPl a nni ng , 2019

Av l onGr e e ns , Ma s t e r Pl a n

Ma s t e rPl a nni ng , F e a s i bi l i t yS t udi e s , 2018

P ol i c yAdv oc a c y , I ndor e

PROF E S S I ONALWORK

P a rc i pa t or yPl a nni ng , Ur ba nPl a nni ng , 2018

Vi r g ol a mi na t e sE x hi bionDe s i ng

Vi s ua l br a ndi ng , 2017

P a t hwa y st oS DG: Mi c r ot oMa c r oP e r s pe cv e s

Ur ba nDe s i g n, 2016

Hous ef orJ a dha v

I nt e r i orDe s i g n, Re s i de na l , 2016

L a nds c a pi ngf orK e wa l r a ma ni

F ur ni t ur eDe s i g n, Re s i de na l , 2016

L ux ur yVi l l af orI ndus t r i a l i s t

UNDE RGRADUA T E-ACADE MI C

Ar c hi t e c t ur e , Re s i de na l , 2015

Upg r a di ngT KB-ACa s eofL i v e+Wor k+S e l l Ur ba nDe s i g n, Ar c hi t e c t ur e , 2016

S pi r i t ua l Ce nt e r‘ Onei nWhol e ’ Re l i g i ous , Ar c hi t e c t ur e , 2014

I nc l us i v eS pa c e sf orE l de r l y

Ar c hi t e c t ur e , Ba r r i e rF r e eDe s i g n, 2013

Re de v e l opme nt S t r a t e g i e sf or Ur ba nVi l l a g e s Ur ba nPl a nni ng|Mumba i , I ndi a .

T h eUr b a nVi l l a g e si nt h ec i t yo f Mu mb a i n a me l yt h et h r e e f a b r i c s ; t h eGa o t h a n , t h eK o l i wa d aa n dt h eAd i v a s i p a d ad a t e b a c kt ot h ef o r mao no f t h ec i t y , b r i n g i n gr i c hc u l t u r a l h e r i t a g e&h u g et r a n s f o r mao n so v e rt h ey e a r s . On c eas t r o n g a g r a r i a n , fi s h i n ga n da n i ma l h e r d i n gc o mmu n i t y , t h ev i l l a g e s h a v eb e e ne n g u l f e db yt h ec i t yt o d a y . T h i sb r i n g sas h ii nt h e e c o n o mi ca cv ie sa n de t h n i ch o mo g e n e i t yt h r o u g ht h e p e r i o do f me . Hi g h l yu n a ffo r d a b l eh o u s i n gs t o c ki nt h ec i t y ma k e st h eh o u s i n gs e c t o rt ot u r nt ot h e s eu r b a nv i l l a g e sf o r wa n to f a ffo r d a b l eh o u s i n g . T h ei n a d e q u a c i e si nt h er e g u l a o n s&s c h e me sb i n d i n gt h ev i l l a g e sh a v ec a u s e dd i l a p i d ao n i nt h e s es el e me n t s& f o r me di n f o r ma l d e v e l o p me n tp r a cc e si nt h ed u ec o u r s e . We a kl a n dt l e sa n dh i g hc o e r c i o no ni n f r a s t r u c t u r ea d d st ot h el o we r i n go f ma r k e tp r i c e si nt h e s e . p r i mel a n d so ft h ec i t y T h eb l a n k e ta p p r o a c ho f p r o v i s i o n sf o rr e d e v e l o p me n t&r e s t r u c t u r i n gt h ev i l l a g e sb r i n g si nat h r e a to f l o s so f l i v e l i h o o d , g e n t r i fi c ao n&d i l a p i d ao no f s t r u c t u r e s . T h eq u e so ni s , h o wt op r o t e c t t h ed y i n gl i v e l i h o o d sa n db r i n gi nh o l i scd e v e l o p me n tb e n e fin gb o t ht h ed y i n gv i l l a g e&t h ee v e ri n c r e a s . i n gc i t y

Or i g i nofUr ba nVi l l a g e si nMumba i

Vi l l a g e si n1900

Vi l l a g e si n2015

T hema j or i t yi ft hev i l l a g e sc a mea bouti nt hes hor eoft hei s l a ndsofBomba y , S a l s e e&T r omba y . T heAdi v a s i whol a t e rs el e di nt hef or e s toft hec i t ya l ongwi t ha . f e wot he rv i l l a g e sc a mea r oundt obeno ďŹ e da ss l umsbyt hey e a r2015

Conc e ptofUr ba nVi l l a g e si nMumba i Ga ot ha n “ Ga ot ha n"or"v i l l a g es i t e " me a nst hel a ndi nc l ude dwi t hi n t hes i t eofav i l l a g e, t ownorc i t y a sde t e r mi ne dbys e con122of t heMa ha r a s ht r aL a ndRe v e nue Code1966. Nol a ndr e v e nuet o bel e v i e di nonl a ndswi t hi ns i t e s ofv i l l a g e . T he ya r ec ompa c ts e t t l e me nt se i t he ri nha bi t e dby pe opl ewhoowns ma l l pi e c e sof l a ndora r el owe rc a s t el a ndl e s s l a bor e ri nv ol v e di npr i ma r ya cv i t y .

Kol i wa da K ol i wa dame a nst heha bi t a tof t heK ol i s . T heK ol i sa r er e f e r r e dt o a st heor i g i na l i nha bi t a nt sof Mumba i wi t hapr i ma r yoc c upa onofF i s hi ng .S pe c i a l Ga ot ha n l a wsa r ee v ok e dt oa dmi ni s t e r t he i rl a ndus epa e r ns . Ma nyof t heK ol i wa da sa r e as l uml i k e ne i g hbor hoodsduet ohi g hc ong e son, de ﬁc i e nti nf r a s t r uc t ur e a ndde a r t hofpl a nni ng .

Ma g ni t udeofUr ba nVi l l a g e si nMumba i

Ar e adi s t r i bu onofUr ba nVi l l a g e si nMumba i

Adi v a s i pa da Adi v a s i pa daa r et hev i l l a g es el e me nt swhi c ha r epr e domi na nt l y t heT r i ba l Adi v a s i ha ml e t s . T he s e ha ml e t sha v es e e nat r a ns f or ma oni nt e r msofbui l di ngc ons t r uc on, f r omk uc c hat os e mi puc c a t opuc c ahous e s .Ma nyoft he ha ml e tha v ebe e nl os ti nt hec i t y a ss l umsduet ode ﬁc i e nti nf r a s t r uc t ur ea ndhi g hc ong e son.

S el e me ntL e v e l Cl a s s i ďŹ c aon

Pl otL e v e l Cl a s s i ямБc aon

Compa r av eAna l y s i s -Re g ul aons

S pe c i a l Ga ot ha nl a wsa r ee v ok e dt oa dmi ni s t e rt he i rl a ndus epa e r ns .E a s yc onv e r s i onofhe r i t a g epr e c i nc ta s nos t r i c tr e g ul aon. He r i t a g eGr a de3s t r uc t ur e se a s yr e de v e l opme nt&l os sofhe r i t a g e . Ve r yL e s sc ov e r a g ef or Adi v a s i pa daa ndt henumbe r sofs uc hpa da sv e r yl e s s

Compa r av eAna l y s i s -Ca s eS t udy

K e yF i ndi ng s

I s s ue s

Conc e pt ua l Re c omme ndaon

Re c omme ndaon&S t r a t e g y

Av l onGr e e ns Ma s t e rPl a nni ng Ma s t e r pl a nni ng , F e a s i bi l i t yS t udy |Hy de r a ba d, I ndi a .

P r o j e c twh i c hi n v o l v e sMa s t e rP l a n n i n go f 2 5a c r e si nt h ec i t y o f h y d e r a b a df o rr e s i d e na l a n dmi x e du s ea l o n gt h et r a n s i t d e v e l o p me n ta r e ao f Ga c h i b o wl i . T h ep r o j e c ti sp l a n n e di n t h el i n e so f as u s t a i n a b l et o wn h i pwi t hd i ﬀe r e n th o u s i n go p o n df o rd i ﬀe r e n tc o mmu n i t yg r o u p s

Br i e fJ usямБc aon

Ci r c ul aonDr a wi ng

Ma s t e r pl a n

Uni t -E c onomi c a l l yWe a k e rS e con

Uni t -Mi ddl e&L owe rI nc omeGr oup

Uni t -L ux ur yApa r t me nt s

Uni t -T ownhous eVi l l a

P ol i c yAdv oc a c y -I ndor e P a rc a pa t or yPl a nni ng , Ur ba nPl a nni ng |I ndor e , I ndi a .

T h i si sap r o j e c tt a k e nu pb yt h eY UV Ai nc o l l a b o r ao nwi t h I n d i a nI n st u t eo f Hu ma nS el e me n t s . I ta n a l y s e st h ep o l i c i e s f o ru r b a nd e v e l o p me n ti ni n f o r ma l a r e a si nt h ec i t yo f I n d o r e a n dc r ic a l l yi n v e sg a t e st h eo n g o i n gp o l i c i e so f P MA Yi nt h e c i t y . T h ep r o j e c t g o e sa h e a da n di n v o l v e sc o mmu n i t yp a rc i p a o na n da d v o c a c yo f t h ep o l i c i e sa n di t sa n a l y s i s

P ol i c yT r a j e c t or y

I ndor ei sami ds i z e dc i t yl oc a t e di nc e nt r a l I ndi a . Ac c or di ng t ot heCe ns us2011, i t spopul aoni sa r ound20l a k hof whi c h27. 14%i sl i v i ngi ns l ums . t hec i t yha sahi s t or yof f or ma l pl a nni ngt ha tc a nbet r a c e dba c kt ot he16t hc e nt ur y i nt e r wov e nwi t has t e a dymi g r aoni nt ot hec i t y . Cr ic i s e da sbot hpr og r e s s i v ea ndr e g r e s s i v enoneoft he s ol u onss uc c e e de di ne r a s i ngt het hr e a t&v ul ne r a bl i t y a s s oc i a t e dwi t hs l ums . T hepr a cc eofde mol ion&e x c c e s i v es uppl yofi na de qua t ehous i nghowe v e rsl l pe r s i s ta nd s odoe st hesg ma . Atac r i t a c a l j unconi n mewi t ht hec ur r e ntde v e l opme ntpl a ne ndi ngi n2021, t hec i t yi si nmuc h ne e df orane wdi r e cont oma k ei t sc l a i msf or ur ba ni nc l us i onar e a l i t y .

Re l oc aonT r a i l s

T hepa t hl i nedi a g r a mst ot he r e l oc a t e da r e a sf r omt hepr e s e ntba sl oc aons .

Ca s e&S t r a t e g y

Ca s eAdv oc a c y

Vi r g oL a mi na t e s E x hi bionDe s i g n Vi s ua l Br a ndi ng|Ne wDe l hi , I ndi a .

T h eb r i e f f o rv i s u a l b r a n d i n gf o rt h i sb u i l d i n gma t e r i a l c o mp a n yl o o k sa taf r e s hp e r s p e cv eo nt h ec o mp a n ywi t had y n a mi cl o o k oi t . T h eb r i e f s p e c i ﬁ c a l l yl o o k si t sf r o mt h ec a s eo f a n e x h i b io nd e s i g nf o rt h ec o mp a n y . K e e p i n gi nmi n dt h ep r i n c i p l eo f ‘ Vi r g o ’ a sa ne c o f r i e n d l ye s t a b l i s h me n t , u p c y c l i n go f b u i l d i n gma t e r i a l ss e r v e sag r e a t e rp u r p o s e . He n c et h ed e s i g n ﬂ o o we dt h es a mel i n eo f t h o u g h t

T r a ns l aonofBr a ndI de nt y K e e pi ngi nmi ndt hepr i nc i pl eofâ&#x20AC;&#x2DC; Vi r g oâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; a sa ne c of r i e ndl ye s t a bl i s hme nt , upc y c l i ngof bui l di ngma t e r i a l ss e r v e sag r e a t e rpur pos e Bymov i nga wa yf r omadi s pl a ybe i ng me r e l yadi s pl a ya ndg i v i ngi tf uncon, t hede s i g ns t r i v e st og i v el i f et ot hel a mi na t e s . Byi nt r oduc i nga ni nt e r a cv ee l e me nt i nt ot hes pa c e , t heus e ri se ng a g e dnot onl ywi t hs pa c ebuta l s owi t ht hepr oduc t .

Cr e angaMoodboa r d

T r a c kl i g h nga nd ope ng r i dCe i l i ng Al l bl a c ks t a l l

Me t a l f r a me

L a mi na t es wa t c he s

T e r r a c oa

T e r r a c o ac ur i os t obr i nga bouta s e ns eoft r a dion t oac ont e mpoPl a nt e r s r a r ys e ng

Me t a l f r a mef ur ni t ur ewi t h Vi r g ol a mi na t es e a t

Vi s ua l i z i ngt heVi s ua l

Asunde r s t oodt hr oug ht hepr e v i ouss t a l l de s i g ns , f a c et o f a c edi s c us s i onsa r ea ni nt e g r a l pa r tofv e ndor buy e rc ommuni c aon

T hepr opos e dde s i g ni nt e g r a t e st he f unconsofa ne x hi bions t a l l t of or m ac ohe s i v edi s pl a yi ns t a l l aon, bi ndi ng t hes t a l l t hr oug hs y s t e ma ndor de r

I NT E RACT I VEWAL L

DI S PL A YI NS T AL L A T I ON

DI S CUS S I ON T ABL E

E NQUI RYDE S K

Us e ri nt e g r a t e d de s i g ni ns t a l l aont ha tc r e a t e sa n i nt e r f a c ebe t we e nbuy e ra ndpr oduc t

Ani c oni cde s kwi t hbol dbr a ndi ngon i t sf r onta r a c t spot e na l buy e r s

Vi s ua l i z i ngt heVi s ua l

I NT E RACT I VEWAL L

DI S PL A YI NS T AL L A T I ON

DI S CUS S I ON T ABL E

E NQUI RYDE S K

T hedr a wi ngi ndi c a t e showt hedi s pl a yi ns t a l l aoni smulf uncona l a ndi nt e g r a t e sv a r i ouspr og r a msi nas i ng l e s t r ok e -s e ang , di s c us s i ont a bl e s , s t or a g ea ndmos ti mpor t a nt l y , l a mi na t edi s pl a y

Vi s ua l i z i ngt heVi s ua l

DI S PL A YI NS T AL L A T I ON

I nt e r a cv eWa l l E l e v aon

Vi s ua l i z i ngt heVi s ua l T hedi s pl a yi sde s i g ne dt os howc a s et he v a r i e dl a mi na t e sVi r g oha st ooï¬&#x20AC;e rby i nc or por angt he mi nau l i t yc e nt r i c i ns t a l l aon

DI S PL A YI NS T AL L A T I ON

P a t hwa y st oS DG: Ma c r ot oMi c r o P e r s pe cv e s Ur ba nDe s i g n|Ne wDe l hi , I ndi a .

Ont h eo c c a s s i o no f Wo r l dT o i l e tDa y , 1 9No v e mb e r2 0 1 6 , t h e UNUn i v e r s i t y, UNUME R I Ti nMa a s t r i c h t , t h eS wa c hB h a r a t h o rC l e a nI n d i aMi s s i o nt a r g e t si t sa cv ie sa t3l e v e l s . F i r s t , i t a i mst oi mp r o v es u p p l ys i d e , S e c o d . i ts e e k st op r o mo t ec r e a v ec o o p e r av ec o n s o ru msi n v o l v i n gp r i v a t ea n dp u b l i c ; T h i r d , i tt r i e st on u d g et h en e c e s s a r yb e h a v i o u r a l c h a n g eo n . t h ep a r to f c iz e n st oma k eI n d i ac l e a n T h i sp r o p o s a l a i mst op r o j e c tas a n i t ao nmo d e l o nt h i ss p e c t r u m

S us t a i na bl eDe v e l opme ntGoa l s

S i t eCondions

E l e me nt si nS a ni t aon

Compa r av eAna l y s i s

De s i g nI nnov aon

P r oc e s sS k e t c he s

De s i g nP r opos a l

S ubs t r uc t ur e

S upe r s t r uc t ur e

Hous ef orJ a dha v I nt e r i or , F ur ni t ur eDe s i g n|Mumba i , I ndi a .

T h i sp r o j e c ti n v o l v i n gt h ei n t e r i o rd e s i n go f t h eh o u s eo f a P o l i c eOffic e ra n dh i sf a mi l yo f fi v el o o k e da td i ffe r e n ts e g me n ss u in gt ot h ed i ffe r e n tt a s t e so f t h ef a mi l y .T h eb l e n d o f t r a d io n a l d e s i n g sa n dc o l o u r s c h e me sv e r yI n d i a nwi t ha c o n t e mp o r a r yt a s t eb e c o me st h ed a t u mo f t h ed i ffe r e n ts e g me n t s

Conc e ptDe s i g n

Dr a wi ng s

Wa l l P a ne l Dr a wi ng s

Ba t hr oomCons t r uconDr a wi ng s

F ur ni t ur eDr a wi ng s

L a nds c a pi ngf or K e wa l r a ma ni L a nds c a pi ng , F ur ni t ur eDe s i g n|Mumba i , I ndi a .

T h et e r r a c el a n d s c a p i n gf o rt h er e s i d e n c ef o l l o wst h ea e s t h e t i cs e n s eo f t h eh o mea n df o l l o wsa sa n e x t e n s i o no f t h es a me . T h ep r o j e c ti n c l u d e sl a n s c p a i n gd e s i n ga swe l l a sf u r n i t u r e . d e s i g nf o rt h ep r o j e c t

Cr e angaMoodboa r d

Conc e pt ua l F l oorPl a n GI Rus tﬁni s hBa r

Cl i mbe r s Col ourP a l l a t e Me t a l Ba rs t ool s

F l oor i ng&S e angF i ni s he s `

Pi neWood S a nds t one Upc y c l e dT y r e P ouﬀe

He r r i ng bone

S i t eDr a wi ng s

L ux ur yVi l l af or I ndus t r i a l i s t Re s i de na l Ar c hi t e c t ur e |Ba ng a l or e , I ndi a .

T o wn h o u s ev i l l af o raf a mi l yo f f o u r , t a k i n i n gi n t or e g a r dt h e c u l t u r a l a n dc o mp t e mp o r a r yt a s t eo f t h ef a mi l ya n de mp h a s i s e do nt h ei n d o o ra n do u td o o rg r e e n s . Ama j o re l e me n to f t h ed e s i n gi st h es c i e n c eo f V a s t ua n di t sc o mp l i a n c et ot oi t

Gr oundF l oorPl a n

Ve rc a l S pi ne

Re pr e s e nt aon

Upg r a di ng T ha k k a rBa ppa Col ony -Ac a s eof L i v e+Wor k+S e l l Mi x e dUs e |Mumba i , I ndi a

T h ep r o j e c t a i msa t a l l e v i an gl i v i n ga n dwo r k i n gc o n d io n si na ni n f o r ma l h o u s i n gc l u s t e ri nc e n t r a l Mu mb a i , at h r i v i n gf o o t we a rma n u f a c t u r i n gh u bwh i c hi n c l u d e sp r o p o s i n gs t a t e g i e so f i n t e r v e no n f r o mp l a n n i n gt od e s i g n . T h ep r o j e c ti n v o l v e sp h y s i c a l ma p p i n go f t h ec o l o n y , s u r v e y i n gi t se x i sn gf a b r i c , c o n d io n , a n di n f r a s t r u c t u r e . Anu n d e r s t a n d i n go f l i v i n ga n dt h ewo r k i n gp ae r n so f v a r i o u s t y p e so f i n h a b i t a n t swh oa r ep a rc i p a n t si nt h i si n f o r ma l ma n u f a c t u r ei n d u s t r ywa sb o u g h to u t . T h i sa l s oh i g h l i g h t sac o mp l e xn e t wo r ko f t r a n s a co n swi t h i nt h ec o l o n ya n do u t s i d ei t , wh i c hi n c l u d e sv a r i o u sp a r t so f t h ec i t y , t h ec o u n t r ya n dt h ewo r l d . T h es t r a t e g yo f u p g r a d i n gt h ep h y s i c a l c o n d io n si nah i g hd e n s i t ya r e a h i n g e du p o nr e c o g n i s i n gt h ee c o n o mi cp o t e na l o f t h e s ee x i sn g n e t wo r k sa n ds t r e n g t h e n i n gt h e ms u c ht h a ta ni n s e r to f a ni mp r o v e dwo r ka n de c o n o mi cmo d e l , t h ec o mmu n i t yc a nr e g e n e r a t e ah e a l t h yL i v e+Wo r ke n v i r o n me n t wi t hi mp r o v e ds e r v i c e sa n ds a n i t ao n . I ta e mp t st op r o p o s eas o l uo nr i g h tf r o ms i t ep l a n n i n g t od e t a i l e di n d i v i d u a l u n i t s , i n c l u d i n gc o n s t r u co nd e t a i l sf o rt h e s a me .

I de nf y i ngt heS el e me nt T ha k k a rBa ppaCol onyc ha r a c t e r i z e dbyi t sl oc aon, c onne c t st hema j ora r e a sofc i t y a nds a t e l l i t ec i t y . t hec ol onye v ol v e df r ome i ngar e f ug e ea r e af ort hemi g r a nt s , pos ti nde pe nde nc ea ndg r a dua l l ys el e dt hema r wa di c ha ma rmi g r a nt swhoc on nue dt opr oc e e dt he i rpr of e s s i onoff oot we a rma k i ngi nt hea r e a . S el e me nt T ha k k a rBa ppaCol ony T y pol og y Al ongma j ort r a ns i tnode Na t ur e Mi x e dUs e . T OD. F oot we a rI ndus t r y Obj e c tL e v e l S e mi P uc c a . L a a di by l a ne . F i ni s he dr oa ds , S el e me ntL e v e l F or ma l K a r k ha na . I nf or ma l I ndus t r y x i sngI ndus t r ywor k i nga tdi ﬀe r e ntl e v e l s Ne i g hbour hoodL e v e lE T a bl es howi ngt hec ha r a c t e roft hes el e me nt

T hema ppi ngoft hes el e me ntput sa c r os si t sc ha r a c t e r i sc s ofc i r c ul aona ndf uncona l ne t wor k s . I tma psz one sofv e hi c ul a rc ha osa ndt hena t ur eoft heby l a ne sa l ongwi t ht he s t udyoft hef uncona l c ha r a c t e roft hes el e me ntwi t hr e s pe c tt of oot we a rma k i ngs howi ngt heov e r l a ppe df uncons a ndi t sc ompl e x na t ur e . T heg r a phi ca l ongs i dee nl a r g e st he pe de s t r i a na ndv e hi c ul a rr e l aons hi pwi t ht hebui l ta tdi ﬀe r e ntc or e soft hes el e me ntwhi c hi nc l us e st hef or kj uncon a nda tt heby l a ne -ma i nr oa d, j uncona tt hepr i ma r yr oa ds e c onda r yr oa da l ong wi t ht he‘ c howk s ’ whi c hpr ov et obe t hel ungoft hes el e mt e nt .

T heT ool Hous e&i t sNe t wor k s T het ool hous edoubl e supa sa ma nuf a t ur i nga nds a l euni ta pa r t f r omi t sba s ef unconofahome . T het ool hous ema na g e si t ss a ni t a onf a c i l ie sbypr oj e cngt he uppe rﬂoor . T hec omme r c i a l uni ti sg e ne r a l l yon t heg r oundpl a newi t ha c c e s st ot he homea bov ea dj a c e ntt oi t . T he s hopuni ti se i t he rs ha r e dbe t we e n t heowne rort het e na ntorowne d s ol e l y . T heAs s e mbl yK a r k ha nai nf or ma l l y di v i de si t sf unconswi t ht hehe l p oft hec i r c ul a t or ypa t h. T hel a c kof e noug hs t or a g es pa c e sr e s ul t si n t hedumpi ngofma t e r i a l s . L a c kof t oi l e t sf ort hewor k e r sa ddst ot he i nc onv i ni e nc eoft heus e r .

De ﬁni ngt heT ool Hous e

T hene t wor kc l e a r l yi ndi c a t e si t sc ompl e xna t ur ewi t hme c ul ous l y wor k e doutf uncona l ne t wor k s . T hene t wor kdoe snotonl ywor kf unc ona l l ybuta l s os pi l l outt ot hes oc i a l i nt e r a consa nda ﬀe c t st hes oc i a l s t r a t aoft hes el e me nt .

T heT ool Hous e&i t sNe t wor k s

I de nf y i ngt heS t a k ehol de r sa ndne t wor k si nt heS el e me nt

As ur v e yc a r r i e doutwi t h50r e s ponde nt sr e i nf or c e st hehe r i di t a r yna t ur eoft hei ndus t r ypu ngl i g htont he i mpor t a nc eofc ul t ur et hec ommuni t yc a r r i e swhi c ha l s oj usďŹ e st heowne r s hi ps t a t usoft hes el e me nt .

I s s ue s , As pi r aons&S t r a t e g i e s T heg r a phi cpoi nt souti s s ue sf r omdi ffe r e nts c a l e s , r a ng i ngf r om pe r s ona l t oc ommuni t yt ot her e a l aonofc ommuni t ywi t ht he c i t y . I tt r i e st ohi ntt hes t r a t e g i e sa ndt hes c a l eoft hei nt e r v e non. T hes ur v e yc a r r i e doutby50r e s ponde nt ss howt hedi r ene c e s s i t yofpe de s t r i a na ndv e hi c ul a rc i r c ul aona l ongwi t hpa r k i ng , wi t ht hes e g r e g aonoft hebuffingpr oc e s swi t houta ffe c t i ngt hee c onomy .

S ha r i ngRe s our c e s= Re l e a s i ngS pa c e sf orAme nie s

S t r a t e g yf orl a ndS uppl y

T heF r a me wor k s

Pha s i ngoft hepr oj e c t

He i r a r c h yofRoa ds

T heGr oundPl a nea ndPha s i ng

Gr oundF l oorPl a n

I ma g eof t hee c onomy , t he s hoema l l br i ng sv a r i ousdoma s ofpe opl ei n me nt

Boosngt hequa l i t yoft he e c onomy , t hede v e l opme nt c e nt r ehous e sde s i g nt e sng a ndl e a r ni ngc e l l a pa r tf r oma r e nt a l hous i ngc ompone nti n t hepl a nea bov ef ort hemi g r a ntl a bour e r s .

T hef oc usoft hes e t - Cons ol i da t e d t l e m e n t , t h e c o o p e r i nc l us t e r sof het ool pl ug , T hes a l epl ug ,T av eoffic ea ndt he f o u r , t h e p o w e r h o u s e whol e s a l e i da n; nt owup- r e x e nebuffoft hee c ono- ma ma j orf uc g r a d e d w i t h ‘ k a a s ’ , i n g p c e l l e s , r e t a i nsr e onsa sat ool my s i c a l l yl i nkt he2 a r er e l oc a t e d l i g i ouss t r uc - phy pl ugi nt he m a j o r c h o w k s o f a wa yf r om ur e s . floor sa bov e . t t hel e a v e s , r e l i nk i ng t hes el t he m. me nt

F i r s tF l oor -AnAl t e r na t eGr oundF l oor

F i r s tF l oorPl a n

T hefir s tfloora e mpt st of uncona sa na l t e r na t eg r oundfloort ot hefloor sa bov ewi t hc i r c ul aona ndl i nk shor i z ona t a l l ya ndv e rc a l l y . T hi st a k e sc a r et hepr i ma r ya nds e c onda r yr oa dsa r enothi nde r e dont hel e v e l be l ow. T hene t wor k sa r es t a g g e r e dondi ffe r e ntl e v e l sma k i ngi tv i s ua l l yi nt e r a cv e , we l l l i ts pa c e . T hel i nk sc onne c tt he t ool hous e st ot hec ommuni t ywor k s hopsa a ndt hepubl i ct oi l e t sa l ongwi t hbuffe ra ndr e c r e aona l s pa c eont he l e v e l .

AS el me nti nt hema k i ng T hes el e me ntnowi sr e wor k e dwi t hc l us t e r sL i v e+Wor k+S e l l , L i v e+Wor ka ndWor ka l ongwi t har e t a i l s t or e a ndr e s e v e l opme ntc e nt r ea sapl ugi nt oi t . T hema i da na ndt hec howk sa r er e i nf or c e da st hel ung soft hes el e me nta nda r ewor k e dwi t ht hema j ora x e si nt e r l i nk i ngt he m. T hema i da na c t sa st hes t a g ef ort hes el e me nt wi t ht hec oope r av ehous e d. Ci r c ul aoni st a k e ni nt oc ons i de r aonwi t ht hehi e r a r c hyofr oa dsi npl a c ea l ong wi t hac onc i ousa e mptt or e t a i nt hev i s ua l i ma g e soft hes t r e e twhi c hc onne c t st heus e r . T hei ns e ronofas e r v i c er oa dt ofil t e rt hev e hi c ul a rt r a fficwi t hr e s pe c tt ot hef uncna l l owsf orade di c a t e dl oa di ngunl oa di ng s pa c e . T hec i r c ul aona l s opl ug si npa r k i ngs pa c e sa tr e g ul a ri nt e r v a l sa l ongwi t hdr opoffa r e af ort hes c hool bus e sa nda ut or i k s ha ws .

Amodul eoff ours a l e , t hr e el i v e a ndones ha r e dwor k s hopwor k e d outt obeus e da saﬂe x i bl l eone . T hec l us t e ri spunc t ur e dwi t h pa r k i ngs pa c e s&s t or e swi t h r e l i g i ouss pa c e sont heg r ounda nd c ommuni t ywor k s hopsont heﬂoor s a bov e .

Gr oundF l oorPl a n-Comme r c i a l Pl ug

AS el me nti nt hema k i ng T heL i v e+Wor k+S e l l e me r g e df r omt hee x i sngs c e na r i ooft hei nt e r t wi ne dl i v i ng . I t ha sf uncona l de pe nde nc eoft hes a l ec ompone ntont heot he r s . T hes a l ea r e a sa r ec ha r e c t e r i z e dbyc ol ona de swhi c hs uppor tt hel e v e l sa bov e . T heL i v e+Wor ke me r g e doutoft hene c e s s i t yofhomef unconi nga st het ool hous e whi c hha v eama j ors ha r ema k i ngt hes el e me ntaf oot we a rma nuf a c t ur i nghub. T hus t hepos ioni nga ndt hea c c e s soft hec ompone nti st owa r dt hema j ora c c e s s . T hek a r k ha nae me r g e df r omt hee x i sngs c e na r i oofpr oduconwi t ht hede a r t hof s pa c ea ndr e s our c e s . T hef ourwor kuni t sr unni ngonac oope r av eba s i sbys ha r i ngof s pa c ea ndt hema c hi ne r yi sa ppr oa c he df r omt hema j ors e r v i c er oa da st hea c c e s s .

Uni tL e v e l : L i v e+Wor k+S e l l

Uni tL e v e l : L i v e+Wor k

S pi r i t ua l Ce nt r e ‘ Onei nWhol e ’ Re l i g i ous|Da ma n, I ndi a .

T h eb r i e f e x p l a i n st h er e l e v a n c eo f as p i r i t u a l c e n t r e . T h eu r b a nc o n t e x ti nS i l v a s s awa ss e l e c t e d , k e e p i n gi nmi n dt h es t r o n gc o n n e cv i t y , ﬂ o u r i s h i n gt o u r i s mwi t hr o o t e dc u l t u r a l b a c k g r o u n d . Onf u r t h e r s t u d i e si nC h r i sa ni c o n o g r a p h y , t h et r i n i t ye me r g e da st h ep h i l o s o p h ye x p l a i n i n g‘ o n ei swh o l e ’ a n d‘ wh o l ei so n e ’ . I n t e r p r en gt h e p h i l o s o p h yo f t h et r i n i t y , t h eu n i s o nt r a n s f o r me di n t os p a c eo f p u r i t y , a wea n du n i t y , t h u sb e c o mi n gt h ee s s e n c eo f t h ec e n t r e wh e r et h er o s a r yme d i t ao nt a k e sp l a c e .

Onei nWhol e I nt e r pr e ngt hephy i l os oph yoft het r i ni t y , t heuni s i ont r a ns f or me di nt os pa c e ofpur i t y , a wea nduni t y , t husbe c omi ng t hee s s e nc eoft hec e nt e rwhe r t et he r os a r yme di t aont a k e spl a c e . t hea dmi ni s t r aont ookov e rt hepl a c eoft he mi ndwhi c hc ont r ol st hee nr es y s t e m oft hec e nt r e , t hema r r i a g eha l sz one d i nt hepl a c eofbodya ndt hec hur c h a ndt hee nc l os e dme di t angs pa c e f or mi ngt hes oul oft hec e nt r e .

Hi e r a r c h yi nt heVol ume s

De s i g nE v ol u on

Gr oundF l oorPl a n

T heur ba nc ont e x ti nS i l v a s s awa ss e l e c t e d, k e e pi ngi nmi ndt hes t r ongc onne cv i t y , ﬂour i s hi ngt our i s mwi t h r oot e dc ul t ur a l ba c k g r ound. Onf ur t he rs t udi e si nChr i sa ni t ya ndi t si c onog a phy , t het r i ni t ye me r g e da st he phi l os oph ye x pl a i ngt he‘ onei nwhol e ’

T het hr e ez one s s e g r e g a t e dwi t h r e s pe c tt ot hef uncon, i sa c c e s s e df r omt he r oa da bu ngi tma k i ng t hes i t eac or ne rone . T hev ol ume sa ndt he ph y s i c a l z oni ngoft he c e nt r ebr i ng sav i s ua l pe r s pe cv et ot he v i e we r . T hi st r i e st o op mi z e t hec or ne rv i e woft he pl ot . T hepa r k i ngwor k sout i nt heba s e me ntwi t ha uni -di r e cona l flowof v e hi c ul a rt r a ffic . L a nds c a pee l e me nt s fil t e rt het r a fficf r om t het wowhe e l e r pa r k i ngont hes i t e .

De t a i l e dDr a wi ng s

De t a i l e dPl a n: S pi r i t ua l Cor e

De a t a i l a tCa s t e l l a t e dS t e e l Be a m

S c r e e nde t a i l a tt heE nt r a nc eL obby

De t a i l e dDr a wi ng s

T hes pi r i t ua l bl oc ki spr ov i de dwi t ht wo a c c e s swhe r eonei sape de s t r i a npa t ha ppr oa c he df r omt hec r uc i ďŹ x , whe r ea st hes e r v i c ea c c e s si sa ppr oa c he df r omt hee nt r a c e f oy e r . T hef oy e ri si nc l os epr ox i mi t ywi t ht he c ommuni t yk i t c he n. T hes a c l eoft hes t r uc t ur ea r ouc e st hs e ns eofa wei nt heus e r s . c ons i ous l ybol dt or e g i s t e rt hes t a t e me nt . Duea e n oni spa i dt oc r e angv i s ua l c onne c t or sa ndr e f e r e nc e st of a c i l i t a t e st he publ i cna t ur eofde s i g n. T hec hur c hi ss uppor tbyane t wor kofs t e e l c a s t e l l a t e dbe a ms a st heme mbr a nea ndpr e f a br i c a t e dc oonc r e t epa ne l a st hes k i nc r e angar t h y mt o t hev i e w. De t a i l Pl a n: Cul t ua l Cor e

I nc l us i v eS pa c e s f orE l de r l y Ar c hi t e c t ur e , Ba r r i e rF r e eDe s i g n|Mumba i , I ndi a .

T h ef a mi l yo f t e nwi t hmu lg e n e r ao n s , n av et oAn d h r a P r a d e s hmi g r a t e dt ot h es u b u r b so f Mu mb a i f o ral i v e l i h o o d . I nt h ed u ec o u r s et h ef a mi l yc a r r i e da l o n ga l l t h ec u l t u r a l s i l t f r o mt h en av eb l e n d i n gwi t ht h ec o n t e x t . T h ea cv es p a c e s we r ema j o r l yt h el i v i n g , d i n i n ga n dt h ek i t c h e ns p a c e s . T h e p r o p o s e dd e s i g na l s ot o o kc a r eo f a na cv el i v i n gs p a c ewi t h . wa sf o c u so f t h eg e o me t r y

I nc l us i v e, S e c ur ea ndE ng a g i ngE nv i r ons T hema s s i ngr e ďŹ&#x201A;e c t st he s e g r e g aonofv ol ume swi t h r e s pe c tt of uncona nd a cv ie si nt hes pa c e .

Ph y s i c a l br e a k upoft he ma s s e st obr i ngi nl a nds c a pe . I nt r oduconoft he c i r c ul aone l e ma e nta sa c onne c t or

I nt r oduconoft hec our t y a r di nc l os epr ox i mi t yt o t hea cv es pa c e s . T hi s i mpr ov e sv e rc a l c i r c ul aon v i s ua l l y .

De s i g nP r oc e s sDi a g r a ms

T hemull e v e l r ooďŹ ng s y s t e mwi t h t e r a c oa l e st a k e si nt oa c c ount t hel oa dbe a r i ngna t ur ea ndt he mi c r oc l i ma t e .

T hel e v e l hous e ss e c onda r yl i v i ng s pa c e si nc l udi ngt hey og aa ndt he be ds pa c e sov e r l ook i ngt he c our t y a r d.

T hes e g r e g a t e ds pa c e sa r e c onne c t e dbye nc l os e dpa t hwa y s . Ana r r a yofc ol ona de sde ďŹ net he c onne c t or s . T hes t r a t e g ye me r g e df r oma na t t e mptt or e mov et hes e ns eof l one l i ne s sa ndi ns e c ur i t ypr e v a l e nti nt hee l de r l ybyc r e ang s pa c e swhi c hc oul de ng a g et he m wi t hpe opl eorwi t hs ma l l c hor e s orf ol l owt he i rhe a r t . I noutg a r de nswe r ec ha l k e doutf ort he s a mec ons i de r i ngt hei nt e r e s tof t heme mbe r soft hef a mi l ywi t houtl e ngt hes e c ur i t yoft he s pa c ef a deout . He nc et hepor os i t yi nt hede s i g n. T hes pa c e swe r e pl a nne dk e e pi ngt hea c c e s sa nd t hev i e wi nmi nd .

E x pl ode dI s ome t r i cs howi ngt hef ucona ndc ons t r ucon

T hef oot pr i ntoft hede s i g nf ol l owsa nor g a ni cpa t hwi t ht hee nt r a nc ev e r a nda ha cnga st hepoi ntofj unc t ur e . T hes e g r e g aonofs pa c e sbr i ng si napor ousna t ur ei ni tt husbr i ng i ngt hee x t e r i orl a nds c a pea sapa r toft he de s i g n. I ts e ns iv e l yl ook sa tt hei ns e c ur ie soft hea g e da nda e mpt st oa l l e v i a t ei t . T heus e ror i e nt e dde s i g n br i ng ss e ns iv ec ha r a c t e r i sc soft heus e r . T hede s i g nr e s pondst ot hemi c r oc l i ma t eoft hes ur r oundi nga r e a a l ongwi t hl oa dbe a r i ngbui l di ngt e c hnol og ywhi c hi nt r oduc e ss t onema s ona r ywa l l swi t ha ppr opr i a t es pa ns wor k e dout . T he mbe rr ooff r a mi ngf ort het e r a c oa l er e s pondst ot hehumi di t y .

Gr oundF l oorPl a n

Vi e wf r omt hea dj a c e ntHe bba l L a k e T hel oa di nt he s t r uc t ur ei st r a ns f e r r e df r omt hea r c he si nt hea r c a de st ot hepi l l a r s . T i mbe rg i r de r sa ndbi nde r ss uppor t s t hefir s tfloorl e v e l wi t hboa r di ngma t e r i a l . T her oofi ss uppor t e dbya ebe a mi nc a s e sofhi ppe dr oof . T hemul-l e v e l l e a nt or oof sa r es uppor t e dont hel oa dbe a r i ngwa l l s . T hes i t ede fine dbyr a i nt r e e sa l ongwi t hflowe r i ngs hr ubsa l ongt he k e r bs t one s . T heha r ds c a pepa t hwa y sme a nde ra l ongv e r ymi ni ma l l e v e l s . T hes os c a pei spunc hur dwi t hs e angs pa c e sa t i nt e r v a l s .

S e conf r omt heL a t e r a l S pi ne