One Short At-Bat
By Andy Purvis Special to the Island Moon This is an eyewitness account of the story of Eddie Gaedel as told by Detroit Tigers pitcher, Virgil “Fire” Trucks.
Island Moon
SPORTS
on him. Eddie reaped the benefits of his 15 minutes of fame by appearing on several TV shows in the following weeks. In fact, he earned over $17,000, a large sum of money in those days. His playing contract with Veeck had only been for $100. It’s a funny story with a sad ending.
“I was sitting in the Detroit dugout when a midget popped up off the St. Louis Browns bench and walked up to home plate to pinch hit for Tigers outfielder Frank Saucier, at Sportsman’s Park in St. Louis, Missouri. Twenty-six year Eddie Gaedel spent the next ten years boasting old Eddie Gaedel was swinging four miniature he had been a Major League bats in the on-deck baseball player. He was circle, the kind constantly in and out of scraps they give away and drank to excess on most on bat day at the occasions. Eddie Gaedel ballpark for kids,” died in his room of a heart said Trucks. Eddie attack on June 18, 1961, at was 3 feet 7 inches the age of 36, after suffering tall and he had from a terrible beating by instructions from an unknown assailant. The St. Louis owner mugger robbed Eddie of his Bill Veeck to hold life and the $11 he had in his the bat on his pocket. The fisticuffs left shoulder. “Do not Eddie Gaedel I’m gonna murder it! him bruised up with whelps swing,” instructed on his face, chest, and knees. He had suffered Veeck. earlier in his life from high blood pressure and The date was August 19, 1951, and Eddie was an enlarged heart. It was classified as a murder, the first batter for the St Louis Browns against but the case was never solved. the Detroit Tigers in the second game of a Only one guy from Major League baseball doubleheader. He was wearing a jersey with the number 1/8 written on the back. “Nobody attended Eddie’s funeral. Detroit Tigers pitcher, thought he was really going to get in the batter Bob Cain, drove 300 miles to be there. Cain box. When he did step into the batter’s box, was shocked that no one else from baseball our manager “Red” Rolfe called timeout and attended. went out to the home plate umpire and said, To add insult to injury, Eddie’s mother was ‘They can’t put that guy in to hit,’” said Trucks. down and out and broke. She claimed she “That’s when Zack Taylor, the Browns manager had been swindled out of Eddie’s bats and his ran up and handed the umpire a contract signed St. Louis Browns uniform by a man claiming by Will Harridge, the President of the American to be representing the Baseball Hall-of-Fame League,” explained Trucks. Museum. The only items that the Hall of Fame Sure enough, Eddie Gaedel had been signed to a Major League contract by the Browns. So Gaedel stepped back in the box and Detroit pitcher Bob Cain got ready to throw.
“That’s when Eddie yelled at Cain, ‘Just get the ball over; I’m gonna murder it.’ Detroit catcher Bob Swift called timeout and went to the mound and said to Cain, ‘His strike zone is only an inch and a half; keep it low.’ Cain started laughing so hard he almost fell off the mound. After Cain collected himself, he threw four straight pitches that would have been called strikes on anybody else, but were called balls on Gaedel, because they were too high. So Gaedel went to first base where he was replaced by a pinch runner, Jim Delsing. That was the end of his professional baseball career; his one and only at-bat,” laughed Trucks. Cain later admitted that he had feared for Gaedel’s life if he had hit him, so he took it easy
How I Tee It
now has are the pictures of Eddie Gaedel at bat during that game.
Andy Purvis is a local author. His books “In the Company of Greatness” and “Remembered Greatness” are on the shelves at the local Barnes and Noble, at Beamer’s Sports Grill 5922 S Staples, and online at many different sites including Amazon, bn.com, booksamillion, Google Books, etc. They are also available in e-reader format. Contact him at www. purvisbooks.com, or andy.purvis@grandecom. net. Special thanks to ESPN Corpus for creating Uncle Andy’s Sports Blog. You can go to www.espncorpus.com and click on BLOGS. New story each week. Also access via “Dennis and Andy’s Q&A” when that comes up on site. Click on it and then go to Blog. You may also go to www.purvisbooks.com and please leave comments!
Play Golf Amongst Oak Trees instead of Palm Trees
Tapatio Springs Golf Resort just a 3 hour drive By Mary Craft I play golf with a group of guys every Sunday rotating courses each week. We play Oso, Padre Isles, Lozano, Gulf Winds at the base and Newport Dunes. River Hills in Calallen and Northshore were in the mix until they recently became private clubs. Twice a year we travel to a golf resort outside the area and our most recent trip took us to Tapatio Springs Resort in Boerne.
Use Instant-Replay Umpires to End Baseball’s Epic Officiating Screw-ups
By Dotson Lewis, Special to the Island Moon dlewis1@stx.rr.com How would you like a erroneously ruling that then-Yankee Nick job as a major league Swisher left third base too soon in the 2009 baseball instant-replay umpire? Sounds like a American League Championship Series, umpire great job…do you think you could handle the Tim McClelland said: “In my heart I thought he pressure? left too soon... after looking at replays, I’m not The Oakland Athletics’ overruled home run sure I believe the replay.” this week shows again that subjective on-field rulings are numerous.
Inaccuracy is inevitable in a game with as many intricacies as unreliable, often unfair ways to officiate MLB games. Balls will be called strikes, checked swings will be debated, and the infield fly rule will confound fans forever. But one of the goals of Major League Baseball is to ensure the game is officiated as correctly as possible and offer an effective in-game remedy for the human mistakes of umpires. Last week’s debacle at Cleveland’s Progressive Field showed once again that the MLB is failing at that goal. With two outs in the ninth inning between the Athletics and the Indians, Oakland infielder Adam Rosales hit a game-tying home run that was incorrectly ruled a double on the field. The ruling was upheld even after four umpires, including crew chief Angel Hernandez, reviewed the replay.
Catastrophe in Cleveland That’s the short version of the “Catastrophe in Cleveland.” The larger takeaway is that baseball’s instant-replay system, introduced in 2008 to prevent the type of missed call that occurred on Wednesday, is not working. Baseball needs a replay umpire, or more games will be decided by human error. It’s still unclear how exactly Hernandez and his crew missed what everyone in the stadium— including both teams, both sets of announcers, and everyone in the press box—clearly saw. Rosales’s hit bounced off the railing about nine inches above the yellow home-run line at the top of the padded wall in left field and ricocheted back onto the outfield grass. That couldn’t have happened had the hit not been a home run, because the ball would have hit the soft padding below the line. After the game, Hernandez told a reporter that the crew did not believe there was “100 percent certainty” to overrule the call on the field, which sounds ludicrous to anyone who’s watched even one replay of the “double.” Joe Torre, the league’s executive vice president of baseball operations, released a statement Thursday afternoon that unwittingly identified the basic problem with baseball’s current replay system: “In the opinion of Angel Hernandez, who was last night’s crew chief, there was not clear and convincing evidence to overturn the decision on the field. It was a judgment call, and as such, it stands as final.” Torre’s statement, like the MLB’s current rule book, conflates an objective fact with a subjective review. Whether a ball crossed the home-run line is an objective question, and a review system that allows subjectivity to so easily override objectivity is fatally flawed.
Imperfect game This isn’t the first time in recent years that a game has been marred by inept umpiring that could not be properly reviewed. Armando Galarraga’s perfect game on June 2, 2010, was ruined when first-base umpire Jim Joyce called the last out of the game safe. And after
Tapatio came into existence when Clyde Smith of Smitty’s Grocery Store chain fame developed the course in 1981. He still lives in a cliffside glass-walled home overlooking the course. It is a very secluded resort that you must drive through four miles of winding forested hilly roads to get to. Along the way you see many animals including lots of deer.
The MLB instituted its current instant-replay system precisely to avoid the unreliable subjectivity that has tainted so many games over the years. But even given the opportunity to rely on that failsafe Wednesday night, Hernandez and his crew doubled down on the wrong call instead.
A replay umpire could solve many of the problems that plague the current system. Right now, field umpires must head into the clubhouse to watch the replay, often on a tiny monitor, facing intense pressure to complete the review as quickly as possible to keep the game moving. And replays are only used when there’s reason to believe an umpire made the wrong call the first time, which sometimes causes umps to stubbornly stick to the original call in the face of opposing evidence—as Hernandez did on Wednesday.
But put a replay umpire in a room with a large monitor that gets the feeds of both teams’ television broadcasts and the ability to quickly communicate with the umps on the field— similar to the system currently in use in college football—and those problems will go away.
Skin in the game
A replay ump would have no skin in the game, access to more replay angles, and the impartiality of being at least one step removed from the action. That way, all disputed calls that should be based on objective results—fair/foul balls, disputed home runs, safe/out tag plays on the bases—could be funneled through a single observer with a mandate of impartiality and access to replay technology befitting of the 21st century.
Detractors may argue that adding another umpire would only complicate an already thorny process, but it would actually make things simpler. Despite what the umpires’ union might say, a replay ump could keep the men in blue from making destructively bad calls they have to live with forever—just ask Joyce how that feels. It would benefit teams and players, who could trust that a bad rapport with an ump or a fuzzy picture on a replay screen would not cost them any more games. It would certainly benefit the fans, who don’t want to see their team miss the playoffs in October because of a horrendous call in early May. And it would benefit the game by removing a layer of potential inaccuracy.
It’s worth noting that Rosales’s hit would have only tied the game, and Cleveland could have prevailed in the bottom of the ninth or in extra innings. Ultimately, though, that’s not the point. We have the technology to almost completely eradicate objective errors from baseball. Until the MLB installs a replay umpire or makes some other tweak to its obviously compromised review system, the stain of games like last night will linger over the sport.
Do you remember the “pine tar” incident? Tim was the rookie umpire behind the plate when this happened.
Tim McClelland Interested in applying to be an instant replay umpire? Contact Dotson: dlewis1@stx.rr.com to get started.
Beamer’s introduces
“Meat Lovers Mondays”
The clubhouse is very posh with rich woodwork and marble. The large outside patio has lattice roofing for shade and a huge fireplace that keeps it comfortable on the cool evenings.
Just
Why just 18 when you can play 27?
Tapatio by morning........
There are three nine hole courses that each offer a unique golfing experience. The toughest is “The Ridge” which is definitely not walkable. Some of the cart paths are so steep you wonder if the cart will make it up. The fairways are bordered by walls of rock and if you are lucky your ball will bounce off and back into the fairway if you should hit there. This nine tends to eat the most balls because there are also rock gorges in the center of the fairway on some holes. Our group decided to keep track of lost balls after 18 holes with the one losing the most buying a round. The winner, or should I say loser, lost 12 balls.
During the years the resort hit some hard times as did many golf resorts due to the economy. The upkeep started to slip and it was not the pristine course it once was until 2011 when George Strait bought it and brought it back to its former glory. It is a popular destination for golf outings for groups that come from all over Texas. There
6
99
each
This offer is good for Dine-In or Carry Out
992-1291
2012 Sports Bar
5922 S. Staples between Holly & Saratoga *$1.69 for each additional toppings
2011 Sports Bar
was a large group from Houston that were spending four days while we were there. Their club was called GTYP which stands for Golf Till You Puke and three of the days they played 36 holes. The tournament winner was the one with the lowest score at the end. Their matching polo shirts for the event had “T.I.T.S.” above the pocket that stood for Tournament in Tapatio Springs. Obviously a fun group that does not take the game too seriously. There was one 6’6” player who was particularly fun but that’s another story.It is great to have a golf resort with such a different landscape than ours that is just three hours from the Island. Close enough for even just a one nighter and heck you can still play another 18 before you head back. If you go, tell them you heard about them from the Moon. Maybe that will get me a free round. It can’t hurt.
$
Every Monday order a large pizza with your favorite meat topping for just $6.99 each*. Choose from Pepperoni, Beef, Sausage or Ham.
The Lakes nine has the most water both to get across and bordering fairways. It played much easier for us than usual because of the drought. A 2 handicap hole was made easy because the large pond in front of the green was dry. The Valley is the easiest and has many beautiful homes along the fairways. We saved this one to play our last nine and were charged only $16 each to play the extra nine. Double occupancy room, golf with cart for 18 holes and breakfast brunch was $140/person on a Saturday. The restaurant had pretty good food but the brunch was awful. You are better off ordering breakfast from the menu. All the rooms were large and modern with a balcony.
A 13
CALSP000003
May 16, 2013