July 2014
Interview with Lothar Maier CEO of Linear Technology
Ultralow-Power Embedded Applications Safe Power Supply in Medical Apps Worldwide
Linear Technology's Products
Drive Industry
All the forces in the world are not as powerful as an idea whose time has come. —Victor Hugo, 1800
Power Developer contains new ideas that come every month. —Power Developer Editors, 2013
POWERDEVELOPER
Read Power Developer, the monthly newsletter for Engineers:
h t t p : / / w w w. e m b e d d e d d e v e l o p e r. c o m / n e w s _ l e t t e r /
Power Developer
y, ficienc -off um on her lt in hig t due conten itch ster sw .” sitions
ard
8614 bo is the LT r. be d trace ic cham floor; re anecho e noise ce is th rement in an tra ue 2. Bl measu ed at Figure di R25 ra at CISP
upply
Medical Staff
rters in plications
TECH ARTICLE Reduce Interference & Improve Efficiency with Silent Switcher Designs
ce (ch.
le tra 14; purp e LT86 2) is th 2.2A load. ce (ch. Blue tra n, 3.3V out at 3. re Figu 13.5Vi ; both LT8610
1) is the
TECH ARTICLE
ago, doctors had to rely on simple microscopes and stethoscopes to make
l procedures always posed a huge risk mewhat rudimentary. The life and wellprimarily depended on the skills and Today, hospitals are full of high-tech ed devices that allow for much more s, as well as keyhole surgeries. These mize the risk to patients and ensure progress made in the field of medicine, nges, not the least of which
Safe Power Supply for Patients and Medical Staff DC/DC Converters in Medical Applications
“We are always making decisions to develop products that customers are going to buy and find valuable five years in the future—this is tough to do, but we do it.”
Linear Technology is known to have the highest operating margin in the industry. How did the company get to this point?
There is no single factor that leads to the margins that we see here at Linear. However, the most important element, from a product standpoint, is that we make new, unique products. We do not try to copy anything from our competitors or second-source another competitor’s products. We come up with products that are not only technically interesting, but also compelling in terms of bringing value to the customer. This may sound easy, but is a rather tall order because it typically takes two to three years for us to develop a product. Then it takes another few years for the customer to take our product and design it into their product. We are always making decisions to develop products that customers are going to buy and find valuable five years in the future—this is tough to do, but we do it.
Austria
d switche e ks are r, all cloc cillato mode, peed os e low-s th l g al in ud from ed ov rem the wer is ip with the ch s used ces on source d those re triggere n tion of he ce w ur so t up almos s wakeA t. en is rnal ev wn in th n exte ered do is pow least ything ds the ic ode yiel at st m is th bo de, th ion as ption nsumpt consum wer co d. power ic ce m du d dyna been re nts have mpone
Which markets do you feel are the most important to target?
The best markets, historically speaking, have changed. Fifteen years ago, Linear was very concentrated in the communications market and then came the “dot-com bubble” which made that market less important. We used to have a very strong presence in consumer products with high-end analog components that were sold into digital cameras and high-functioning cellular phones. This was a significant part of our business. Around 2007, it became obvious that this consumer business, which we thought was high-performance analog, had deteriorated to just plain consumer grade. That is when we made the decision to move away from those markets and find new ones. At that time, we refocused the company on the automotive, communications, and industrial markets. That brings us to where we are today. Seven years ago, it would have seemed unwise to become so involved in the automotive and industrial markets, but these markets today have become some of the fastest-growing segments of the analog market. We believe we are in the right markets, at the right time.
COVER INTERVIEW Linear Technology’s Products Drive Indiustry Interview with Lothar Maier, CEO of Linear Technology
Fi
e er activ
power
TECH COLUMN
Designing Embedded Applications for Ultralow-Power, Part 2
Controll
Syste
20nA 300nA
active Display ller Contro sleep
System
System
10s 1ms wn
1nA
down
current
Another key factor that contributes to our high operating margin is product pricing. We price each product based on the value it brings to the customers, not the transistor count. Also, we recognize that we not only have to develop superior products, but we have to actually deliver them. Linear has a great industry reputation for providing products on time and with short lead times. The combination of all of these aspects results in Linear having optimal operating margins.
r do m powe
em. the syst ock to the main cl on for pt ke utes wer is contrib mainly the mode rough th n io pt all onsum n from umptio er cons e chip. s on th
CONTENTS
Time
n in ent draw
Curr gure 1.
various
4 12 20 26
. states
rtant s impo
“It’ wakermine e which to dete termin e out of t to de m an co rt wakeble to h e, la ic pl It’s impo ai h av am w r ex ces are t ode. Fo up sour rces are wer m interrup e, any up sou ular po p mod a partic e; it may le to t of slee b e mod ou a at il e a m rn v t a to co In hibe interrup the job. ut of o s-match e es th may do dr or m ad co is w the I2C vice. It ular the de be just e ic up ar rt s e a ce ak ur ap nw e up ch reso that ca ode.” ch wak ing whi m hi r w nd e d ta w an it is po unders mode ample, in each For ex a e. as bl t la working avai terrup ces are rator in le to resour a compa to be ab ests, to have system me sugg useful top ce in a does e system the na ur d th as e so an e, ak od herals e ake-up t to w w th rip pu er In Stop m pe in st l d. al U regi analog reshol s down and CP ure 1, use an a set th power n in fig in RAM ceeds 4, only en reta te PSoC ion show hen it ex pu lik at w in s ic not ev e ce pl vi rpos ake the ap ts. In de ed ined. W neral-pu case of conten be need are reta start. using ge t would ’ states chip re ake-up TC up to w R rr s a e te ad th IO pins PIO) in do as ode le (G m ld is ut ou d tw outp from th yway, an rd rese n for en a ha time an umptio e its ev ns th in or l co ta to re eck power nning al ch g ed ru in to ne t t yz be an anal will es no import When er ller do ion, It is all pow contro at e ss ic th pl ro e. an ap ption ac us stat consum previo power used. modes
3
Power Developer
Reduce InteRfeRence &
ImpRove effIcIency
with Silent Switcher Designs By Christian Kueck, Strategic Marketing Manager Power Management Products Linear Technology Corporation
4
TECH ARTICLE
S
witching regulators replace linear regulators in areas where low heat dissipation and efficiency are valued. The switching regulator is typically the first active component on the input-power bus line, and therefore has a significant impact on the electromagnetic interference (EMI) performance of the complete converter circuit.
5
Power Developer Modern input filter components in surface mount technology have better performance than through-hole parts. However, this improvement is outpaced by the increase in operating switching frequencies of switching regulators. Higher efficiency, low minimum onoff times result in higher harmonic content due to the faster switch transitions. For every doubling in switching frequency, the EMI becomes 6dB worse when all other parameters, such as switch capacity and transition times, remain constant. The wideband EMI behaves like a first-order high pass with 20dB higher emissions if the switching frequency increases by 10x. Savvy printed circuit board (PCB) designers will make the hot loops small and use shielding ground (GND) layers as close to the active layer as possible; nevertheless pinout, package construction, thermal design requirements, and package sizes needed for adequate energy storage in decoupling components dictates a
certain minimum hot-loop size. To make layout even more challenging, on a typical planar printed circuit board the magnetic or transformer-style coupling between traces above 30MHz will diminish all filter efforts since the higher the harmonic frequencies are, the more effective unwanted magnetic coupling becomes. The tried and true solution is to use a shielding box for the complete circuit. Of course, this adds costs, increases required board space, makes thermal management and testing more difficult, and introduces additional assembly costs. Another frequently used method is to slow down the switching edges. This has the undesired effect of reducing the efficiency, increasing minimum on-off times as well as the required dead times, and compromising the potential current-control loop speed. With Linear’s new LT8614 Silent Switcher™ regulator, you have the effect of a shielded box without using a shield and also eliminate the above-mentioned drawbacks (figure 1).
Figure 1. The LT8614 Silent Switcher minimizes EMI/EMC emissions while delivering high efficiency at frequencies up to 3MHz.
6
TECH ARTICLE
“Higher efficiency, low minimum on-off times result in higher
Figure 2. Blue trace is the noise floor; red trace is the LT8614 board at CISPR25 radiated measurement in an anechoic chamber.
harmonic content due to the faster switch transitions.�
Figure 3. Blue trace (ch. 2) is the LT8614; purple trace (ch. 1) is the LT8610; both 13.5Vin, 3.3V out at 2.2A load.
7
Power Developer
The LT8614 has a world-class low quiescent current (IQ) of the LT861x series of only 2.5µA operating current. This is the total supply current consumed by the device, in regulation, with no load. It features the same ultralow dropout of this family, which is only limited by the internal top switch. Unlike alternative solutions, the LT8614’s resistance between drain and source on (RDS(on)) is not limited by maximum duty cycle and minimum off times. The part skips its switchoff cycles in dropout and performs only the minimum required off cycles to keep the internal top switch boost-stage voltage sustained, as shown in figure 6. At the same time, the minimum operating input voltage is 2.9V typical (3.4V max.) and the device can supply a 3.3V rail with the part in dropout. The LT8614 is higher efficiency than the LT8610/11 at high currents since its total switch resistance is lower. It can also be synchronised to an external frequency operating from 200kHz to 3MHz. The AC switch losses are low, so it can be operated at high switching frequencies without much efficiency loss. In EMI-sensitive applications such as automotive environment, a good balance can be attained, and the LT8614 can run either below the AM band for even lower EMI, or above the AM band. In a setup with 700KHz operating switching frequency, the standard LT8614 demo board does not exceed the noise floor in a CISPR25 measurement. The figure 2 measurements were taken in an anechoic chamber 12V in 3.3V out at 2A with a
8
“With Linear’s new LT8614 Silent Switcher™ regulator, you have the effect of a shielded box without using a shield.”
TECH ARTICLE
fixed switching frequency of 700KHz.To compare the LT8614 Silent Switcher technology against a current state-of-the-art switching regulator, the part was measured against an LT8610. The test was performed in a gigahertz transverse electromagnetic (GTEM) cell using the same load, input voltage, and inductor on the standard demo boards for both parts.
Figure 4. Ch 1: LT8610, ch 2: LT8614 switch node rising edge both at 8.4V in, 3.3Vout at 2.2A.
One can see that up to a 20dB improvement is made using the LT8614 Silent Switcher technology compared to the already very good EMI performance of the LT8610, especially in the more-difficult-to-manage higher frequency area. This enables simpler and more compact designs where the LT8614 switching power supply needs less filtering and distance compared to other sensitive systems in the overall design. In the time domain, the LT8614 shows very benign behavior on the switch node edges, as shown in figure 4. Even at 4ns/div, the LT8614 Silent Switcher regulator shows very low ringing (ch. 2 in figure 3). The LT8610 has a good damped ringing (ch. 1, figure 3) but one can see the higher energy stored in the hot loop compared to the LT8614 (ch. 2). Figure 5 shows the switch node at 13.2V in. One can see the extremely low deviation from the ideal square wave of the LT8614 (ch. 2). All-time domain measurements in figures 3 to 5 are done with 500MHz Tektronix P6139A probes with close probe-tip shield connection to the PCB GND plane, both on the standard demo boards.
Figure 5. Ch 1: LT8610, ch 2: LT8614, both at 13.2V in, 3.3V 2.2A out.
9
Power Developer Besides their 42V absolute maximum input voltage rating in automotive environments, the dropout behavior is also very important. Often critical 3.3V logic supplies need to be supported through cold-crank situations. The LT8614 Silent Switcher regulator maintains the close to ideal behavior of the LT861x family in this case. Instead of higher undervoltage lockout voltages and maximum-duty cycle clamps of alternative parts, the LT8610/11/14 devices operate down to 3.4V and start skipping off cycles as soon as necessary, as shown in figure 6. This results in the ideal dropout behavior, as shown in figure 7. The LT8614’s low minimum on-time of 30ns enables large step-down ratios even at high switching frequencies. As a result, it can supply logic-core voltages with a single stepdown from inputs up to 42V. In conclusion, the LT8614 Silent Switcher regulator reduces EMI from current state-ofthe-art switching regulators by more than 20dB, while increasing conversion efficiencies with no drawbacks. A 10x improvement of EMI in the frequency range above 30MHz is attained without compromising minimum on-off times or efficiency in the same board area. This is accomplished with no special components or shielding, representing a significant breakthrough in switching regulator design. This level of performance in a single integrated circuit (IC) has not been possible until now. This is just the sort of breakthrough product that allows endsystem designers to take their products to the next level.
10
Figure 6. Ch 1: LT8610, ch 2: LT8614 switch node dropout behavior.
Figure 7. LT8614 dropout behavior.
P WERING INFRASTRUCTURE The increased amount of data and video
The ISL85003/3A are the industry’s most
being transmitted via the cloud has placed
efficient 3A synchronous buck regulators.
huge bandwidth and power demands on the infrastructure market. Designers a need a power partner with the expertise to improve system efficiency and simplify the design process.
Intersil’s new technology delivers the industry’s lowest RDS(ON) performance. • Integrated high-side, low-side FETs • Input voltage range 4.5V to 18V • Output voltage adjustable from 0.8V, ±1% • Efficiency up to 95%
See Intersil’s leadership power technologies at intersil.com/infrastructure Power Modules Digital Power Integrated FET Regulators Switching Regulators FPGA Power Hot Plug Voltage Monitors Power Sequencers
Go to Intersil.com/power-management Download Datasheet Read App Note Order Demo Board Watch Video
intersil.com
Power Developer
Safe Power Supply
for Patients and Medical Staff DC/DC Converters in Medical Applications
O
nly about 100 years ago, doctors had to rely on simple equipment such as microscopes and stethoscopes to make a diagnosis. Surgical procedures always posed a huge risk since the equipment was somewhat rudimentary. The life and wellbeing of patients therefore primarily depended on the skills and experience of the surgeon. Today, hospitals are full of high-tech equipment and computerised devices that allow for much more detailed and early diagnoses, as well as keyhole surgeries. These new technologies help minimize the risk to patients and ensure fast recovery. The technical progress made in the field of medicine, however, poses great challenges, not the least of which is the power supply.
By Thomas Rechlin Senior FAE for Europe RECOM Engineering, Gmunden, Austria
12
TECH ARTICLE
13
Power Developer INSULATION IS KEY
INSULATION LEVEL
Insulation is one of the key issues. This might not be very obvious since the relevant standard prescribes an insulation value of 3kVDC/1s. But what exactly does that mean? To fully appreciate the complexity of the issue, let’s have a closer look at what insulation actually means. The two main factors are the clearance and the creepage distance. The parameters define the distance that must be kept between the primary and the secondary circuit in a power supply. While the permissible values vary from application to application, they must always conform to binding standards.
Closely related to the clearance and the creepage distance is the insulation level, which determines the insulation voltage. The insulation level determines the voltage that a DC/DC converter or power supply can safely withstand over a defined period of time. However, the relevant specifications are not always referring Figure 1. Online tool to the same thing since they differ with for calculating the the actual voltage kVDC or kVAC and correct insulation. obviously with the specified time period (per second, minute, or permanent). In addition, one needs to take into account that the test voltage is often only applied for one second in the course of a hipot test. The values for longer periods of time are normally extrapolated and labelled in data sheets with “rated.”
Clearance and Creepage Distance The air clearance is defined as the shortest distance through the air between two conductive elements (lower left diagram). The clearance must be sufficient to prevent arc-over. The creepage distance is the shortest distance on the surface of an insulating material between two conductive elements (lower right diagram). It is crucial that creepage currents are kept to a minimum. Please note that the air clearance and creepage distances in resin-encapsulated converters are typically measured between the pins, since the resin material is generally acting as an insulator. However, data sheets of DC/DC converters should still contain reliable information regarding the internal air clearance and creepage distances both inside the transformer and the PCB.
14
For medical technical equipment, the main standards prescribe an insulation of a minimum of 3kVDC/1s. As this value is not always disclosed in the data sheets of the various manufacturers, it can be difficult to compare devices. That is why RECOM has devised an online isolation calculator (figure 1) that can be accessed at www.Recom-international.com.
“Functional insulation is the most straightforward and reliable type of insulation between the input and output ends of a device.”
TECH ARTICLE INSULATION TYPE There are three insulation types. Functional insulation is the most straightforward and reliable type of insulation between the input and output ends of a device. It normally consists of a varnish applied to the winding wires of the transformer. With this type of insulation, the wires are wound in layers around a shared core. With this method, it is possible to achieve reliable insulation of up to 4kVDC/1s. Much more effective and safe is double or basic insulation. With these methods, the primary and secondary windings are separated by an additional insulation barrier. In ring-core transformers, this is achieved by placing a bridge at the centre of the ring core to physically separate the windings (figure 2). With this insulation, it is, however, not possible to wind the wires one over the other, so that the electromagnetic properties might be impaired, leading to a lower rate of efficiency.
Effective insulation can also be achieved with what is known as a “potted core.� With this method of construction, the core and primary winding are placed in a plastic pot which is filled with epoxy. The secondary winding is then wound around the pot (figure 2). While this solution is more expensive, it is the insulation type of choice where high efficiency is required. Basic insulation caters to insulation values of up to 6.4kVDC/1s. The best insulation type, however, is reinforced insulation. Here, the primary and the secondary windings are separated by a minimum of two separate insulation barriers. This is normally done by using special winding technology and by placing special foils between the windings (figure 3). In addition, certain specifications as regards the air clearance and creepage distances within the transformer as well as on the PCB must be met. Reinforced insulation provides effective insulation of up to 10kVDC/1s.
Figure 2. Pot core transformer (left) and transformer with bridge at the center acting as an insulation barrier (right).
15
Power Developer “Based on a risk index matrix, all risks that might potentially arise from the power supply must be analyzed and weighted.� CERTIFICATION FOR MEDICAL APPLICATIONS In June of 2012, EN 60601-1 (3rd edition) for medical technical equipment and systems, came into force in EU member nations. It would, however, be wrong to assume that the equivalent international standards based on the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) standard were introduced on the same day. In the U.S., for instance, the UL 606011 standard (3rd edition) came into force in July 2013 and the Canadian equivalent (CSA C22.2 no. 601.1) in April 2013. In many other countries, including Japan
Figure 4. Introduction dates and rules of IEC 60601-1, 3rd edition.
16
and Australia, the new standards are still being drawn up, and other nations such as China have not even started the ratification process. Another obstacle for manufacturers is the fact that the requirements regarding certification laid down in the existing standards vary greatly from country to country. In Europe, all devices, new and existing, must be certified according to the 3rd edition. In the U.S. and Canada, the new requirements only apply to new designs. For an overview of the new rules, see figure 4.
TECH ARTICLE The main difference between the 2nd and the 3rd editions is the new distinction between patient and operator protection. The safety requirements for means of operator protection (MOOP) are significantly lower than those for means of patient protection (MOPP) and generally correspond to those laid down in EN 60950-1. The requirements for MOPP are much more stringent than before, especially with regard to insulation. Table 1 lists the insulation requirements for the two categories. It is important to note that all requirements for both means of protection must be met. This ensures that the patient or operator are still fully
protected even in the event of failure of a safety device or construction. Another important change is the increase of the maximum permissible earth leakage current by factor 10. This is a consequence of the new MOOP and MOPP concept. The total patient leakage current is classified based on patient’s environment—the type of the device, with which the patient is in contact. The closer the contact between the device and the patient, the lower the permissible leakage current. Table 2 shows the applicable limits for normal conditions (NC) and single fault conditions (SFC).
Table 1. Insulation requirements for class up to 250VAC and class up to 43VDC or 30VAC (grey boxes).
Table 2: Leakage current limit by device type.
“When choosing a converter, it is advisable to obtain the respective risk-management reports from the manufacturer.”
17
Power Developer Apart from technical changes, the new standard now demands a formal risk analysis according to ISO 14971, which might pose a challenge to certain power supply manufacturers. Based on a risk index matrix, all risks that might potentially arise from the power supply must be analysed and weighted. The matrix takes into account the occurrence, probability (unlikely to frequent), and impact (insignificant to catastrophic) of the potential risk, based on a rating system from 1 to 5 in each category. If the risk index is ≤6 (probability x impact), the risk is deemed acceptably low. Risks with a higher index must be completely eliminated. These requirements are difficult to assess, especially for DC/DC converter manufactures, since the end device, which obviously has a major influence on the risk level, is often not known. When choosing a converter, it is advisable to obtain the respective risk-management reports from the manufacturer. Only if these documents are in place, is it possible to deal with the power supply as a “black box,” which speeds up the certification process for the actual medical technical device.
Classification of Patient Environment Type B (Body): No physical contact with patient. Type BF (Body Float): No physical contact with patient, or no risk to patient from device failure. Type CF (Cardiac Float): Direct contact to patient’s heart and risk of injury or death in the event of device failure.
18
CONVERTERS FOR MEDICAL TECHNICAL EQUIPMENT In order to meet the above requirements, and in particular the limits for insulation and leakage current, a combination of high-quality AC/DC for medical application and DC/ DC converters is often the most efficient solution. This approach makes it easier to meet the stringent requirements of double patient protection. RECOM offers a wide range of medicalgrade DC/DC converters from 0.25W to 15W. These converters are equipped with basic or reinforced insulation for ratings from 3kV to 10kVDC/1s. They are certified according to EN/UL 60601-1 3rd edition, and EN/UL 60950-1, and do not contain any hazardous substances according to the RoHS2 and REACH directives. As usual for RECOM devices, these products come with a three-year warranty.
AUTHOR
Thomas Rechlin Senior FAE for Europe RECOM Engineering Gmunden, Austria t.rechlin@ recom-power.com +43(0)7612/9003-3102
TECH ARTICLE
Your Circuit Starts Here. Sign up to design, share, and collaborate on your next project—big or small.
Click Here to Sign Up
19
Power Developer
Linear Technology’s Products
Drive Industry
20
COVER INTERVIEW
L
inear Technology Corporation designs, manufactures, and markets a broad line of high-performance analog integrated circuits. The company’s products provide an essential bridge between the analog world and digital electronics in communications, networking, industrial, automotive, computer, medical, instrumentation, consumer, military, and aerospace systems. Linear Technology has managed to negotiate the vagary of these tech industry markets while staying committed to high-quality products.
Lothar Maier CEO of Linear Technology
EEWeb spoke with Lothar Maier, CEO of Linear Technology, about the company’s impressive operating margin and about the evolution of automobile electronics. Maier also discussed the popularity of LTspice®.
21
Power Developer “We are always making decisions to develop products that customers are going to buy and find valuable five years in the future—this is tough to do, but we do it.”
22
COVER INTERVIEW Linear Technology is known to have the highest operating margin in the industry. How did the company get to this point? There is no single factor that leads to the margins that we see here at Linear. However, the most important element, from a product standpoint, is that we make new, unique products. We do not try to copy anything from our competitors or second-source another competitor’s products. We come up with products that are not only technically interesting, but also compelling in terms of bringing value to the customer. This may sound easy, but is a rather tall order because it typically takes two to three years for us to develop a product. Then it takes another few years for the customer to take our product and design it into their product. We are always making decisions to develop products that customers are going to buy and find valuable five years in the future—this is tough to do, but we do it. Another key factor that contributes to our high operating margin is product pricing. We price each product based on the value it brings to the customers, not the transistor count. Also, we recognize that we not only have to develop superior products, but we have to actually deliver them. Linear has a great industry reputation for providing products on time and with short lead times. The combination of all of these aspects results in Linear having optimal operating margins.
Which markets do you feel are the most important to target? The best markets, historically speaking, have changed. Fifteen years ago, Linear was very concentrated in the communications market and then came the “dot-com bubble” which made that market less important. We used to have a very strong presence in consumer products with high-end analog components that were sold into digital cameras and high-functioning cellular phones. This was a significant part of our business. Around 2007, it became obvious that this consumer business, which we thought was high-performance analog, had deteriorated to just plain consumer grade. That is when we made the decision to move away from those markets and find new ones. At that time, we refocused the company on the automotive, communications, and industrial markets. That brings us to where we are today. Seven years ago, it would have seemed unwise to become so involved in the automotive and industrial markets, but these markets today have become some of the fastest-growing segments of the analog market. We believe we are in the right markets, at the right time.
23
Power Developer What are the differences in engaging with the automotive and industrial markets as opposed to the consumer market? The design-in and “Seven years ago, it design-out cycles would have seemed are much different. In consumer markets, unwise to become you can get designed in relatively quickly, so so involved in the you need a treadmill of automotive and new products ready to industrial markets, but go at any time. A few years ago, we were doing these markets today well at keeping up with high demand of have become some of the consumer products. We had great margins, and the fastest-growing we were being designed segments of the into first-generation and second-generation analog market.”
devices, but it became obvious with the third-generation products that oftentimes, cost became more important than performance. We could make products that would extend the battery life of a consumer product from 10 hours to 20 hours, but nobody was willing to pay more for that—those types of advancements were not highly valued. With the automotive market, it takes much longer to develop a product that gets designed into an automobile. We are creating designs in vehicles right now that will not show up until model-year 2018. But once the product is designed in, it’s there for a long time.
24
In the industrial market, a product can be designed into an application for 10 to 20 years. The engineering invested into those products can be leveraged over many years, whereas in the consumer space, the product sales rise and decline quickly, and then there are no legacy sales to pay for that research and development investment.
What do you see as being the path forward for Linear, aside from automotive and industrial? The plan for Linear over the next five years is to stay the course. We are in all the right markets, we have a huge head start, and the amount of electronics in automobiles cannot be stopped. Everything that is mechanical in a car is at some point going to become electric because this saves weight, which will ultimately improve fuel economy. Everything in a car engine that is attached to the belts will eventually become electrical. When that happens, it will become a whole new game in terms of applications because these modifications will put more demand on the internal system in the car. The command center in a car is not going to be adequate as is, so there will be more electrical components to do all of the housekeeping. The challenge with designing for this market is that the sale of products in the automotive industry revolves around providing a part that solves a specific problem. However, as the car becomes more electrical, this becomes a suboptimal way of addressing problems. Automobile electronics are becoming
COVER INTERVIEW more of a system, not just a collection of mechanical components bolted together. Also, in the past, we have dealt with the suppliers to the automotive companies, and now we are dealing more closely with the car companies themselves.
Switching gears a little bit, could you talk about the philosophy behind LTspice®—why do you give it away for free, and why do you feel it is the best simulation program with integrated-circuit emphasis (SPICE) tool on the market? The application goes back 15 years. Over the years, the original developer of our CAD tool developed the first version of LTspice®. Obviously, it is tailored to run Linear’s products, but we also designed it to run some competitors’ products as well. As I said before, it is one thing to provide good products, but you have to provide good service as well. LTspice® is just one of those products that hits both those marks. From an ease-of-use standpoint, it is an intuitive system, and we get much praise from our customers on the overall product.
“It is one thing to provide good products, but you have to provide good service as well. LTspice® is just one of those products that hits both those marks.”
25
Power Developer
Designing Embedded Applications for ULTRALOW-
POWER Part 2
Designing Embedded Applications for ULTRALOW-
C
onsidering the importance of conservation, the portability of embedded systems is a key design consideration.
Portable systems are generally battery-powered with battery life dependent upon the systems’ power consumption. These days, as part of “Go Green” initiatives, power consumption is a selection criterion even for wall-powered applications.
POWER Part 1
By Sachin Gupta, Kannan Sadasivam, Cypress
To read the previous article in this series, click on the image above.
26
By Sachin Gupta, Kannan Sadasivam Cypress Semiconductor
TECH COLUMN
G
enerally, a system on a chip (SoC) supports more low-power modes compared to a traditional microcontroller unit (MCU). The reason for this is that due to the high level of integration, they have more on-chip components, and multiple power profiles are needed to support different operating needs. The number of power modes and the resources available during each mode vary from device to device. For example, in a particular low-power mode, one device may power down everything and just retain register and RAM content while another may just power-down the central processing unit (CPU) while keeping other resources up and running. Different manufacturers may name these modes differently as well. For this article, we’ll cite the example of PSoC 4 devices from Cypress Semiconductor to explore power modes in detail.
27
Power Developer The following power modes are supported by most other devices from other manufacturers too: •
Active Mode
•
Sleep Mode
•
Deep-Sleep Mode
•
Hibernate Mode
•
Stop Mode
Let us see generally what these power modes offer. 1.
Active In this power mode, the CPU, as well as all other resources on the chip, are up and running. This mode contributes towards the major portion of a system’s overall power consumption. Various peripherals available on the chip can be powered down individually in this mode when they are not in use.
2. Sleep This is another common power mode for controllers. This power mode primarily relates to the CPU. When
28
the CPU goes to sleep, its clock is removed. The only contribution by the CPU towards the total power consumption is static power consumption, as there is no switching due to the clock and hence no dynamic power consumption. Other peripherals like analog-to-digital conversions (ADCs) and comparators are available in this mode. 3. Deep Sleep In this power mode, even the system clock is disabled. Therefore, none of the high-frequency resources are available in this mode. However, the current state of these resources remains intact (i.e., CPU registers, SRAM). As the high-frequency clock is disabled, power that would have been consumed due to switching is saved. Generally, deep-sleep modes have an option to keep a low-frequency clock running which can be used to drive low-frequency resources such as a timer. Also, this mode allows developers to use communication protocol blocks, such as a I2C slave, which do not need a clock to be generated by the device itself. This can be achieved given that a primary way to enter this mode is to
5. Stop Stop mode, as the name suggests, powers down all peripherals and does not even retain RAM and CPU register contents. In devices like PSoC 4, only IO pins’ states are retained. Wake from this mode leads to chip restart. When analyzing power consumption for an application, It is important to check power consumption across all power modes used.
Display active Controller sleep
20nA 300nA
System power down
1nA
Controller active
4. Hibernate In this mode, all clocks are switched off, including the low-speed oscillator, and power is removed from all resources on the chip with the exception of those resources used as a wake-up source when triggered by an external event. As almost everything is powered down in this mode, this mode yields the least power consumption as both static and dynamic power consumption components have been reduced.
10s 1ms System power down
disable the main clock to the system. However, power is kept on for the blocks. This mode mainly contributes to power consumption through the static power consumption from all the blocks on the chip.
System current
TECH COLUMN
Time
Figure 1. Current drawn in various states.
It’s important to determine which wakeup sources are available to come out of a particular power mode. For example, to come out of sleep mode, any interrupt may do the job. In hibernate mode; it may be just the I2C address-match interrupt that can wake up the device. It is worth understanding which resources are working in each mode and which wake up resources are available. For example, it is useful to have a comparator interrupt as a wake-up source in a system to be able to use an analog input to wake the system when it exceeds a set threshold. In the case of the application shown in figure 1, a wake-up using general-purpose inputoutput (GPIO) interrupt would be needed or even a hard reset would do as the RTC will be running all the time anyway, and the controller does not need to retain its previous state.
“It’s important to determine which wakeup sources are available to come out of a particular power mode.”
29
Power Developer Hibernate and stop mode can bring down the power consumption to as low as 100 nA. For the real-time clock (RTC) itself, you can easily find very low power RTCs that consume in the range of 100–200 nA. Assuming that the controller is directly driving the LCD, we can consider the liquid-crystal display (LCD) off-state power consumption to be zero. This puts our average power for the system shown in figure 1 in the range of 300 nA. If we assume that the design uses a CR2032 as the power source, then we are looking at around 225 mAh of capacity. With a 300 nA of current, this battery would support operation for approximately 70–80 years but only if the device was in power-down mode the entire time. Every time a button is pressed, the controller wakes up. This can pump up the controller’s power consumption into the 500 uA-1mA range. Assume a 1 mA range where the controller is fetching data from the RTC and displaying it on the LCD. While the controller can
perform this activity in a very small amount of time, the display needs to be kept active for longer (10 seconds for the user to read the time). Since this is a directly driven LCD, this means the controller has to remain active for longer, thus consuming more charge. For such instances, devices like Cypress’s PSoC4 have low-power modes where the device shuts down all peripherals and only runs those blocks that are necessary to drive an LCD. In these devices, the LCD drive is run in a specific low-power mode called digital correlation mode. The result is significantly reduced current consumption. Every key press would go through a current profile as shown in figure 1. The area under the curve is the typical power consumption during a single key press. The charge consumed can be calculated as:
Q = (1mA*1ms) + (20uA*10s) Based on the above number, we can calculate how many key presses can be supported with a give power source.
“A faster MCU can finish tasks quickly and spend more time in low-power modes, yielding a system that consumes less power.”
30
TECH COLUMN Time spent in the active mode is critical since that draws the maximum power. One option is that the MCU can stay in active mode running at a slow CPU clock with reduced active power. However, this might result in a higher, average power consumption because the time spent in the active mode depends on the clock frequency. Here, power consumption will be determined by the time taken by the MCU to process data since the MCU must stay in active mode. A faster MCU can finish tasks quickly and spend more time in low-power modes, yielding a system that consumes less power. Depending on the system requirements, it is up to the system designer to determine the most optimal configuration.
In the next part of this series, we will examine a larger system as an example and explore how to reduce average power consumption. Some system-level techniques will also be discussed that can help to reduce average power consumption.
Sachin Gupta has several years of experience in embedded solution development. He holds a bachelor’s degree in electronics and communications from Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University, Delhi. He can be reached at sachin@embeddedroots.com.
Kannan Sadasivam is a Staff Applications Engineer with Cypress Semiconductor Corp. He has spent a considerable amount of his past career designing and integrating satellite subsystems. He loves working on different types of analog circuits and applications. He can be reached at qvs@cypress.com.
31
M o v i n g To w a r d s a
David Elien VP of Marketing & Business Development, Cree, Inc.
Clean Energy
Let There Be
LIGHT
FUTURE
How Cree reinvented the light bulb
— Hugo van Nispen, COO of DNV KEMA
Cutting Edge
SPICE
Modeling
MCU Wars 32-bit MCU Comparison
+
Cutting Edge Flatscreen Technologies
+
New LED Filament Tower
View more EEWeb magazines— Click Here
Power Developer O ct o b er
201 3
From Concept to
Reality
Sierra Circuits:
Designing for
Durability
A Complete PCB Resource
Wolfgang Heinz-Fischer Head of Marketing & PR, TQ-Group
TQ-Group’s Comprehensive Design Process
Freescale and TI Embedded Modules
+
Ken Bahl CEO of Sierra Circuits
PLUS: The “ Ground ” Myth in Printed Circuits
+
+
PCB Resin Reactor
ARM Cortex Programming
Low-Power Design Techniques