Editorial/Opinion ....................Pages 12,13 Education

Student debt forgiveness, is it enough for Black borrowers?

By ARIAMA C. LONG

Amsterdam News Staff, Report for America Corps Member

President Joe Biden announced he’d forgive up to $20,000 for qualifying student loan borrowers for ones who earn less than $125,000 a year. It’s projected that up to 43 million borrowers could receive debt relief, and has sparked a nationwide debate about fairness and adequate compensation.

During the presidential campaign, Biden promised to implement student debt relief. For a long time, the continued deferments of payments seemed to be as close as he’d get to keeping his promise following the COVID-19 pandemic. Many have rejoiced that the President has finally delivered, while others are irritated about not qualifying or that they have already paid off their loans.

The student loan forgiveness program promises up to $20,000 in forgiveness for Pell Grant recipients and up to $10,000 for other borrowers. People earning less than $125,000 a year are eligible. They are proposing a cap on monthly payments for undergraduate loans at 5% of their income. Additionally, borrowers who are employed by nonprofits, the military, or government may be eligible for relief through the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program for a limited time. The deferment of student loans is extended one last time through December 31, 2022 while the forgiveness program gets up and running.

“A post-high school education should be a ticket to the middle-class, but over the years, we have witnessed the cost of college skyrocket to exorbitant amounts preventing far too many borrowers from being able to purchase a home, start a business, or save for retirement,” said US Rep. Adriano Espaillat in a statement.

Chair of the Biden Administration’s Board of Advisors on Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCU) and President of Delaware State University Dr. Tony Allen, said that many of his students come from lower resourced communities, they’re first generation college students, and they have higher debt than the average student. The Associated Press (AP) reported that Blacks with student loans have an average of $40,000 in debt compared to white counterparts.

Allen calculates that for the last decade of HBCU graduates about 1.1 million alum will get some sort of forgiveness money, adding up to about $15 billion in aid. He said the historic program, despite any challenges that may arise, is critical because it’s a “significant beginning.” He expects that administrators that lead colleges or universities and lenders will have to “take a hard look” at the affordability of tuition in the future.

Allen’s excited for his current students and incoming freshmen with loans who are eligible. The program states that loans must have started prior to July 1, 2022. “What the President has done is not just give immediate relief, he’s put some action behind what’s been a lot of words from a lot of people for a long time,” said Allen.

However, central questions of ‘why not more’ or ‘why should they get their loans forgiven’ have circulated since the announcement. The White House said Biden is focused on “growing our economy from the bottom up and the middle out’’ and that “some students in that situation were able to pay off their debt is a testament to them, but it is no reason to deny relief to others.”

Allen said that the “equitable” program crosses race, gender, ethnicity, partisan, and class lines. He said at the end of the day, regardless of what people look like, millions will benefit from the program.

“The President believes strongly in imposing accountability on college raising costs without delivering additional value to students,” said the White House. The administration said that the relaunching of regular student loan payments with the debt relief program will “offset the cost” in the short term. But, they won’t have an estimate of the real cost until the program starts.

Many in impacted communities aren’t satisfied with the amount, though.

“While we acknowledge and welcome the sorely-needed relief that many need, we know that the Biden administration can go further by canceling student debt entirely. So many people need and deserve that relief,” said Dr. Amara Enyia, policy and research coordinator for the Movement for Black Lives in a statement.

Enyia said that Black students are often forced to borrow at higher rates and hold disproportionate debt which reinforces the racial wealth gap. The organization is advocating for plain canceling all student debt to boost the economy.

National Action Network (NAN) Senior Vice President of Policy & Strategic Partnerships Ebonie Riley said that the decision to forgive some student debt is “historic” but there’s still more work to do. Riley suggested canceling $50,000 of student loans and closing the income gap since Black households carry more student debt regardless of their incomes after graduation. “Approximately one in four Black Americans have negative net worth — meaning their total debt exceeds their total assets,” said Riley. “The $125,000 income cap will leave a large amount of the population behind, especially in an era of high inflation. A Black doctor or attorney who earns above the cap could very well have six-figure student debt.”

Meanwhile, Senate Deputy Leader Michael Gianaris is pushing a new law that would exempt student loan forgiveness from state income taxes. Right now, student loan forgiveness is taxed in 13 states, including New York. Student loans can’t be federally taxed as income because of the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA), but this bill would bring that protection to the state level.

“Relieving student debt is critical for so many across New York. It should not turn into a cash grab by the state,” said Gianaris in a statement. “This is an important step in making it easier to access the higher education and career training New Yorkers need and deserve.”

An application will be available in early October. Once completed, people can expect relief within 4-6 weeks if eligible. Individuals can apply until October 31 for the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) waiver and up until November 15 for the student loan forgiveness program.

Go to studentaid.gov to sign up to be notified automatically when student loan forgiveness information is available.

A matriculating student celebrates during remarks at the Borough of Manhattan Community College's (BMCC) 57th commencement ceremony at the Barclays Center in Brooklyn on Thursday, June 9, 2022. (Michael Appleton/Mayoral Photography Office photo)

Ariama C. Long is a Report for America corps member and writes about culture and politics in New York City for The Amsterdam News. Your donation to match our RFA grant helps keep her writing stories like this one; please consider making a tax-deductible gift of any amount today by clicking here: bit.ly/amnews1

captured someone with a dog next to the mural, but it is reportedly difficult to decipher what the person is doing. Locals told the AmNews that he is known to the community and it was not him, but another man seen on camera at around 2.30 a.m. on Friday night.

Christopher Wallace, contradictions notwithstanding, is an icon to a certain demographic. Vincent Ballentine is the wellknown artist who took two days to create the mural in 2019 on the corner wall of Beauty World salon on Fulton Street and St. James Place. “Oh…the disrespect is real. Damn shame. Why did they do that?” wrote Ballentine on Instagram. In an interview with CBS, he stated, “I woke up to this… I think the neighborhood really saw it as he was one of ours, and he made it out and made something of himself. That’s the story that people hold on to.”

“It’s a terrible thing. I really don’t know why they did it, because they spray painted on it ‘East Coast’--and we’re in the East Coast. Like, if they vandalized it and they put ‘West Coast’ then it is understandable. But putting ‘East Coast’ and spilling blood on it like the red paint makes no sense. It’s definitely done by somebody not from out here. It had to be someone that has something against the East Coast to make it look like it is somebody from the West Coast,” local Keyfood supermarket co-owner Subi Wuddi told the Amsterdam News on Tuesday evening. By then, artist Ballentine had repainted the mural, the damage gone.

Wuddi added that it was not the guy with a dog as reported, he is known to the neighborhood and denied being involved. It was another individual who “spraypainted it, then threw a can of paint. He came prepared.”

Biggie became known for his poignant lyrics about dealing drugs on the Fulton Street block as a youth, set to beats by Puff Daddy––the ’90s saw his star rise. A protracted, possibly manufactured beef between the East and West Coast rap world saw violence and disruption in the world of rap.

Residents say that what was scrawled on the picture in the East Coast City of New York, close to Biggie’s Brooklyn homestead makes no sense to folks trying to figure out who the culprit is.

“Hip hop raised me, along with so many other Brooklynites, and Brooklyn raised Biggie,” Public Advocate Jummane Williams, told the Amsterdam News, “Vandalizing this mural just blocks from this icon’s home is disrespectful to the artist, his family, the broader Brooklyn community and identity, and the world he impacted. The Brooklyn way is to spread love, not destruction.”

The NYPD public information told Amsterdam News, “There are no arrests and the investigation remains ongoing.”

Retired NYPD captain, and current mayor of New York City Eric Adams told the paper, “Biggie is a hero to our community, and that’s darn sure not how you spread love the Brooklyn way, as Biggie would say.” The city’s chief executive officer who held an event at City Hall to mark what would have been Biggie’s 50th birthday continued, “We’re going to look into that and make sure that mural is cleaned up and repaired because this has a place there and it remains there, and we want to find the person responsible.”

Any time of the day in the New York City borough––in particular folk walking, on bikes, in cars, or through open apartment windows––can be heard blasting Biggie hits: “Big Poppa,” “Mo Money, Mo Problems,” “Juicy,” Life After Death” etc. Passersby usually join in at whichever verse is pouring out of the speakers. Biggie––contradictions notwithstanding––is a “hood hero” because he really did go from “ashy to classy,” to quote his famous line. His come-up is well documented, his murder is still a topic.

Biggie used to bag groceries at the Keyfood supermarket which is directly opposite the mural. It has been owned and operated by the Wuddi family for decades, and proudly displays a tribute to their famous onetime employee. Subi Wuddi continued, “Yes, I knew him personally. I was in the ‘Juicey’ video. He was a good guy.

“He used to bag groceries here, and his mother, Violetta Wallace, is a sweetheart. He comes from a good, educated background. He was a good person, and until this day his name and legacy carries. Last Saturday [at Crispus Attucks Park], they had the Biggie basketball tournament for the kids. His mother funds that every year for the kids. Plus she takes the kids on three charter buses to the water parks: to Wolf Creek, Great Adventures, Hershey Park. She gives back to the community, she gives back to the churches in the neighborhood. So, yes, she gives back.”

While Ballentine has been able to fix the damage, the energy in the proud neighborhood of the Biggie-stronghold is both vexation and disappointment.

Amsterdam News nightlife columnist David Goodson said,“Not Surprisingly, it’s a whodunnit regarding who would do such an act. Instead we’ve been hearing disparaging remarks from a new wave of artists regarding the accomplishments and skill level of BIG. Unfortunately their expression is often rooted in disrespect.”

own category code. Instead they are categorized generically as a “sporting goods store,” making it impossible to identify suspicious spending patterns that could be flagged for law enforcement.

By creating a distinct MCC for firearm dealers, financial institutions could effectively track sales at stand-alone gun and ammunition stores separate from other merchants without limiting gun sales or creating new regulations.

Looking to purchase your first home?

There are many firsts in a person’s life. And buying a home can mean lots of questions and uncertainty. When you’re ready to be a homeowner, count on us to provide you with the guidance and financing options for your unique needs. • Down payments as low as 3% • Flexible qualification guidelines • Competitive rates

One day you’ll reach further. One day starts here.

Visit eastwestbank.com/homebuyer or call 888.726.8885.