TODAY ESTIMATING AMERICAN SOCIETY OF PROFESSIONAL ESTIMATORS J anuary /F ebruary 2023 How to Estimate The Cost of General Conditions and General Requirements Who Exactly is Someone Else? 2023 Awards Chapter Meetings
ASPE
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
2022 - 2023
President
M. Chris Morton, FCPE cmortonfcpe@outlook.com
First Vice President
Mike A. Alsgaard, CPE maalsgaard@fishbeck.com
Second Vice President
A. Keith Parker, CPE keithparker@circlebco.com
Immediate Past President
Mel D. Cowen, CPE mel@cowen-est.com
Treasurer
CONTENTS
Governor Larry Lucero, CPE
Central Plains Governor Matthew Burress, CPE mburress@performanceservices.com Southeast Governor Danny Chadwick, CPE estimatordan@gmail.com Northeast Governor Dexter Murphy, CPE dextercmurphy@comcast.net INDUSTRY DIRECTORS Barbara J. Jackson, PhD, DBIA Barbara Jackon LLC Jean Arnold, Esq Arnold & Arnold, LLP 215 Donelson Pike #140710 Nashville, Tennessee 37214 615.316.9200 • ASPEnational.org CONTACT THE ASPE BUSINESS OFFICE ASPE National President 3 New Members, CPEs + AEPs 4 ASPE Executive Director 5 Who Exactly is Someone Else? 6 9 How to Estimating the Cost of General Conditions and General Requirments 12 How to start, organize, and maintain an ASPE "Joy of Bocce" Tournament 20 Critical Calendar 22 Chapter Meetings 24 Joanne Warren JWarren@ASPEnational.org Executive Director Tina Cooke Tina@ASPEnational.org Standards Committee • Website • Accounting • Membership Natasha Crumbliss Natasha@ASPEnational.org Education Committee • Estimating Academy Classes • Summit Cinder McDonald Cinder@ASPEnational.org Certification Committee & Program
(Appointed) Paul Croke pcroke@hinrest.com Northwest Governor Steve Watkins steve.watkins@bnbuilders.com Southwest
llucero@redlineinsulation.com
Aswe welcome 2023, I recommend that you consider doing something to improve your estimating skills. Enrolling in an Estimating Academy course or joining one of our certification programs would be a great way to ring in the new year!
We are currently offering ten Estimating Academy courses, and we will be developing more in the future. These are online, self-paced courses that can sharpen your estimating capabilities. We also offer on-demand webinars to assist you in your educational endeavors.
Our certification program offers the Associate Estimating Professional (AEP) credential, designed for estimators with less than five years of experience, and the Certified Professional Estimator (CPE) credential, designed for estimators with five or more years of experience. Both certification programs provide you with the credentials to prove to your clients and your employer that you have met the rigorous requirements of the certification process while demonstrating your commitment to estimating proficiency.
Membership renewals for 2023 were due by December 31, 2022. If you have not yet renewed your membership, please take a moment and do it now!
Finally, as always, please feel free to contact me or any board member if you have questions or suggestions on how we can improve our Society.
Thank you for your continued support of ASPE, and here’s to another great year!
Estimating Today • January/February 2023 3
Connect at: cmortonfcpe@outlook.com Chapter 5 – Denver M. Chris Morton, FCPE ASPE National President 2021-2023
ASPE Message from the President
Welcome to Our New Members (October + November)
Matthew Espinoza
Joseph Tran
John Paul Villegas
Gary Stevens
Rebecca Hingst
Tom Dennis
David Shank
Colin Moss
Kevin Guth
Jason Sommeso
Stratos Giannikos
Igor Kim
Joel Beasley
Richard Whitmer
Daniel Ream
Nachiket Khake
Zidong Guo
Pete Forakis
David Galain
Rod Collins
Andrew Jonsson
Conor Clarke
Daniel Clark
Aaron Wood
David Nevins
Randy Sheppard
Wyatt Blome
Driver SPG
WithumSmith+Brown
Partners Adjusting Firm LLC
Nitti Builders, LLC
FCL Builders
Shank Glazing Solutions, LLC
Alston Construction
Paragon Construction Services
Haugland Group
Bayside Refrigeration, Inc.
G&G Landscape Solution
MKA International, Inc.
Ravenvolt
Kaizen Estimating Services
Titan Industrial Services, Inc.
Baldwin Shell Construction
DCW Cost Management
OCMI, Inc.
Shaw Electric Inc.
The Weitz Company, LLC
David Nevins
M.Davis & Sons, Inc.
Meridian Experts
Kewal Agarwalla, AEP
Jeremy Drislane, CPE
Roy Huemer, CPE
Sai Tarun Mattaparthi, CPE
Donald Crean, CPE
Rich Trotter, CPE
Jim Buccilli, CPE
Brandon Galley, AEP
Bryan Baldwin, AEP
Matthew Houts, CPE
Brian Forrest, CPE
John Guzak, CPE
Richard Comaduran, CPE
Guillermo Saura, AEP
Robb Ross, AEP
Michael Swanson, AEP
Cumming Management Group Traylor Bros. Inc.
Huemer Consulting LLC
Hixson Architecture
Crawford Consulting Services
Crawford Consulting Services
Crawford Consulting Services
Crawford Consulting Services
DCW
4 American Society of Professional Estimators • ASPEnational.org
CHAPTER Membership Classification Count (as of 12/1/2022) Affiliate AEP Corporate CPE Estimator Fellow Honorary Member Member Emeritus ME (CPE) Student Total 71 61 9 486 728 23 5 19 33 38 1,473 215 Donelson Pike #140710 Nashville, TN 37214 615.316.9200
NAME COMPANY
Los Angeles Orange County San Diego Denver Arizona Arizona Arizona Chicago New Orleans New York New York New York Atlanta Atlanta Atlanta Houston St. Louis Metro Baltimore Greater D.C. Arkansas Puget Sound Puget Sound Quad City Des Moines Area Delaware Delaware Central Plains MAL 1 3 4 5 6 6 6 7 9 10 10 10 14 14 14 18 19 21 23 33 45 45 71 73 75 75 92
International
Cost Management MKA
Inc.
Crawford Consulting Services
Crawford Consulting Services Naples Custom Home Cost Golden Gate Great D.C. Garden State Southwestern Ohio Three Rivers Three Rivers Three Rivers Three Rivers Puget Sound Orlando Philadelphia Philadelphia 2 23 26 38 44 44 44 44 45 50 61 61
to New
COMPANY CHAPTER
Crawford Consulting Services HFS Company Scorpio Corporation
Congratulations
CPEs + AEPs (October + November) NAME
ASPE Message from the Executive Director
Thestart of a new year is a great time to take stock of the past and look forward to new opportunities. At ASPE, we are excited about the continued expansion of the educational offerings provided by the Estimating Academy, our accredited certification program, the upcoming Summit (September 22 and 23 in Chandler, AZ—save the dates!), and a variety of regional and local chapter events.
ASPE has a lot to be proud of and a primary focus for 2023 is to spread the word far and wide about all our organization has to offer. During my first few months as executive director, I heard it repeated that ASPE is “one of the best-kept secrets” in the industry. Well, we intend to change that. The 2023 marketing program will include an updated and rebranded website, refreshed promotional assets, and a consistent and visible online and social media presence. In addition, we will investigate partnership opportunities with vendors and other industry organizations to increase our visibility. These efforts are designed to raise awareness nationally and to increase membership and engagement at the chapter level.
Another opportunity to increase engagement is by submitting one or more nominations for a 2023 member or industry award. The award criteria and nominating schedule are included in this edition of Estimating Today. We hope you will consider nominating a deserving member, chapter, and/or project for recognition at the 2023 Summit.
Please feel free to reach out anytime with your ideas and input— I’d love to hear from you.
Estimating Today • January/February 2023 5 Connect at: JWarren@ASPEnational.org 910.541.1480 - Direct Line
Joanne Warren
Who Exactly is Someone Else?
The odds are good that you may have stumbled across the obituary for “Someone Else” while cruising around the Internet. This tongue-in-cheek posting, written by an unknown author, pokes fun at members of organizations that always say “let someone else” do that. However, this got me thinking about why it is we all often default to letting someone else do it.
So, who exactly is someone else? Someone else is that person who, despite being terribly busy, always finds time to participate and, in most cases, carries more than their fair share of the load. Someone else is just like you and me! He or she does not have superhuman powers nor do they have an abundant amount of spare time in their life to participate. However, they do have something that not all people do, which is a commitment to their actions.
ASPE is not immune from the “let someone else” do it mentality. Each year most, if not all, of our national elections for officers and/or governors are uncontested, and we often have difficulty finding members that are willing to commit to being a leader of our society. And the same is true at the chapter level, where many positions go unfilled at election time. National and chapter elections are once again upon us. Will you step up to participate as an officer, board member, or committee member or will you defer to “Someone Else?”
So, what if “Someone Else” is dead as the obituaries on the Internet proclaim? How will ASPE survive? That is up to all of us that are members. We can choose to step up and be a leader or we can sit back and hope that “Someone Else” really is not dead. Who exactly is “Someone Else?”
Chris Morton, FCPE, LEED® AP Denver - 5
CMortonfcpe@outlook.com
American Society of Professional Estimators • ASPEnational.org
Introducing ASPE’s Continuing Education Certificate in Construction Estimating
ASPE's very own Certificate in Construction Estimating is comprised of six required courses focused on the core competencies and fundamentals necessary for a beginning estimator to master. This program is a comprehensive introduction to the foundational principles in plan reading, estimating math, bidding practices, materials and processes, preparing an estimate, and more. Whether you're new to estimating, need a refresh, or are looking for a training program for your staff, ASPE's Certificate in Construction Estimating is the up-to-date solution to accessible online estimating education.
Join us in 2023 for the following class dates:
Certificate in Construction Estimating Classes:
• Basic Estimating Math
• Plan Reading for Estimating
• Introduction to Construction Estimating I
• Introduction to Construction Estimating II
• Construction Materials and Processes I
• Estimating and Bidding
Other Estimating Academy Online Classes:
• Advanced Estimating Math
• Construction Materials and Processes II
• Construction Procurement Methods with Estimating Focus
• Fundamentals of Heavy Civil Estimating: Heavy Highway https://www.aspenational.org/page/EA
Estimating Today • January/February 2023 7
January 23
March 17, April 17 - June 9, July 10 - September 8, October 9
December 8
-
-
WE’RE FOCUSED WE’RE INNOVATIVE WE ENGAGE FOR IMPACT
Anser Advisory is a national capital project and advisory consulting firm offering tailored, creative solutions to an exciting range of public and private sector clients. Our services cover the entire lifecycle of capital development, starting with early-stage project readiness and continuing through to marketing successful execution.
Our diverse and talented team of 800+ professionals includes architects, engineers, project managers, inspectors, ESTIMATORS , certified professional accountants, financial analysts, and more.
$15B+
Portfolio of Project Estimating
“Our business exists as a combination of the individual and diverse backgrounds and talents of each of our employees. One of our founding core values is to foster diversity, equity, and inclusion in our organization…We embrace what makes us unique and foster creativity, agility, and innovation to Deliver Excellent Results for our Clients and Community.
- Bryan Carruthers, Chief Executive Officer
”
GREATER ORLANDO AVIATION AUTHORITY
PORT OF LONG BEACH
WWW.ANSERADVISORY.COM
2023 AWARDS
Honoring Members + Chapters for their contributions to ASPE and the construction industry Honoring Member Estimators for their project successes
EST IMATOR OF THE YEAR
For excellence in advancing the art of construction estimating through Standards, Ethics and Practice, while leading and training others, and promoting ASPE throughout one’s career
CHAPTER PRESIDENT OF THE YEAR
For excellence in leading, promoting and supporting the goals and growth of the Chapter
FELLOW AWARD
For having attained national recognition for achievements in the art of construction estimating and for having made exceptional contributions to the Society
LEGACY - HOWARD S. PROUT FOUNDER OF CERTIFICATION AWARD
For excellence in promoting and utilization of Standards of Ethics and Practice
LEGACY - FRANK E. YOUNG EXCELLENCE IN EDUCATION AWARD
For excellence in pioneering and promotion of Educational Opportunities and Advancements
LEGACY - MERLE W. HECKENLIVELY FOUNDER OF STANDARDS AWARD
For excellence in promoting and utilization of Standards of Ethics and Practice
INDUSTRY AWARDS
Celebrating projects displaying overall estimate efficiency and accuracy, unique and innovative design, technology solutions or community involvement
CHAPTER CHAMPION
For dedicated effort and contributions made to the advancement and growth of the Chapter
CHAPTER ACHIEVEMENT
For excellence in promoting ASPE and supporting its Members at the Chapter level
TECHNOLOGY AWARD
For promoting Technology innovation in advancement of the estimating profession
Intent to Submit Forms – Due March 15, 2023
Candidate Nominations + Chapter Applications - Due by April 3, 2023
Begin planning by nominating an ASPE Member who exemplifies the qualities needed and who deserves acknowledgement for their contributions
ASPEnational.org / Resources / Awards Requirements + Scoresheets
Estimating Today • January/February 2023 9
10 American Society of Professional Estimators • ASPEnational.org Thank You to our Partners! Corporate Members Corporate Partners Bluebook * ConsensusDocs * DCD Magazine Anser Advisory - Gold STACK Construction Technologies - Silver Delta Innovative Services, Inc. - Bronze Frank R. Walker - Bronze Den-Mark Specialty Construction - Basic Flynn BEC LP - Basic ML Group - Basic Unified Building Group - Basic Shaw Electric Inc. - Basic
ASPE Industry Awards
Best Estimate
The ASPE Industry Best Estimate Award honors those entries that display the best overall estimate of a proposed project across any sector. Benchmarks can include, but are not limited to, the following:
- Estimate Efficiency
- Estimate Accuracy
- Budget Control
- Material Efficiency
- Revisions
- Client Satisfaction
- Tools and Technology Used
- Solutions for Unexpected Challenges
Most Innovative Project
The ASPE Industry Most Innovative Project Award honors those entries that display the most unique and innovative benchmarks across the entire scope and process of the project submitted. Benchmarks can include, but are not limited to, the following:
- Innovative Design Build
- Creative Design Build
- Technology Elements of Project
- Technology Solutions
- Use of Advanced Techniques/Software
- Green Innovation
- Community Involvement
- Addressing Environmental or Coding Concerns
All Entries Must Include a Project Narrative
Your narrative must not exceed a maximum of 750 words. The narrative should focus on why the project should be considered the best in its category. The descriptions of each of the required elements are meant to be used as guidelines. You should interpret all criteria based on your own unique project submission and respond accordingly. This information will also be used during award presentation.
Visual Presentation
While points are not awarded for the visual presentation, the photos may impact your entry in that they help to tell your story. Support your narrative with photos that display the scope and process of the project and any challenges described in the narrative. You may include up to 3 photos in your project submittal.
Begin Planning Today for 2023 Awards! www.ASPEnational.org Award Applications are Due April 3, 2023
ASPE reserves the right to honor multiple award entries based on submittals received.
12 American Society of Professional Estimators • ASPEnational.org How to Estimate the Cost of General Conditions and General Requirments Aaron Vice, CPE Arkansas - 33 avice@cdicon.com TABLE OF CONTENTS Section 1: Introduction Section 2: Types and Methods of Measurements Section 3: Project Specific Factors Section 4: Overview of Costs & Mark-ups Section 5: Special Risk Consideration Section 6: Ratios and Analysis Section 7: Miscellaneous Pertinent Information Section 8: Project Drawing / Plan Sheet Section 9: Sample Take-Off and Pricing Section 10: Glossaty / Terminology Section 11: References
SECTION 1: INTRODUCTION
This technical paper is intended to provide the reader with a guide for estimating general conditions and general requirement (GC/GR) costs for a given project. The two terms are often used interchangeably, but this is not the case. In simple terms, general conditions include costs associated with managing a project while general requirements are any non-management indirect costs required to complete a project.
While the majority of a project’s value is based on a set of detailed bid documents, much of the cost associated with Division 01 is left to the contractors’ discretion. To produce a complete but competitive estimate for general conditions and general requirements, we must gain an understanding of the project’s size, complexity, schedule, and location.
Brief Description of Subject Matter
Many variables must be considered when developing the general conditions and general requirements estimate for any project. The subjective nature of this scope of work means that we cannot simply rely on the bid documents for what needs to be estimated. Instead, we must develop a strategy and design our scope of work to be included. This process begins by first understanding the total scope and complexity of the work to be completed. Next, a construction duration must be established. While bid documents often stipulate a project’s duration, producing a schedule in-house is always advised. An ambitious owner with a desire for an accelerated schedule could require additional personnel to meet the stipulated time for construction. Conversely, if a project allows twelve months for construction and it is determined during the pre-bid phase that work could be completed in 10 months, we may be able to reduce our general condition and general requirement costs significantly. With a good understanding of the project scope and how long the project should take to complete, we can begin building an estimate for general conditions and general requirements.
SECTION 2: TYPES & METHODS OF MEASUREMENT
Several units of measurement will be required when estimating general conditions or general requirements for a project. Labor and equipment costs can be calculated either hourly, daily, weekly, or monthly. Temporary offices, utilities, and rental equipment such as dumpsters or portable restroom facilities are often calculated monthly. Expendables such as office or safety supplies, printing costs, job site signage, etc. are calculated as lump sums or per/ each cost. General requirement items such as temporary dust partitions, traffic control measures, the stone base for site access, or fall protection could require material take-offs as well as a labor and equipment estimate to erect and dismantle these temporary requirements.
SE CTION 3: PROJECT SPECIFIC FACTORS
Small vs. Large Quantities
Quantity, as it relates to the general condition and general requirement costs, is most often associated with a project’s size and duration. The size and complexity of a project will dictate the number of personnel required and the resources that will be needed to execute the work. The vast majority of costs associated with general conditions and general requirements are billed based on time, therefore the duration of the project can have a significant impact on this scope of work.
Estimating Today • January/February 2023 13 HTETCO General Conditions and General Requirements... Continued
MAIN CSI MASTERFORMAT™ DIVISION 00 00 01 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS 01 30 00 ADMINISTRATIVE REQUIREMENTS 01 40 00 QUALITY REQUIREMENTS 01 50 00 TEMPORARY FACILITIES AND CONTROLS
Geographic Location
Many projects require that a bidder visits a job site before submitting a bid. The use of online aerial maps and viewing tools like Google Earth or Street View has certainly helped estimators in recent years to gain an understanding of a project and its surroundings. However, these tools cannot replace a site visit for real-time data gathering on the condition of a project site.
Site access and availability are important factors to consider. While a large area for material storage and a job site compound may be desirable, it may not be feasible if the site is occupied or inaccessible.
Surrounding buildings or specific occupancy types such as residential neighborhoods, school zones, or hospitals could restrict work hours and extend construction time or require additional indirect costs such as flagging or site fencing in order to maintain a safe environment for workers as well as neighbors.
Seasonal Effect on Work
Weather can have a significant impact on the progress of a project. Because one of the two major factors in calculating general conditions or general requirements is time, climate factors must be considered when developing your estimate. For instance, a project scheduled to break ground during the wettest month of the year for a given area may delay progress or require additional temporary measures to proceed. It is the estimator’s responsibility to gain a general understanding of the climate conditions for a specific project by analyzing the schedule against historical weather patterns for the region.
SECTION 4: OVERVIEW OF COSTS & MARK-UPS
Staffing is the largest cost associated with general conditions. Labor costs for managing a project are typically calculated on a weekly basis. Labor values should reflect an employee’s billable rate. This includes their pay rate plus any additional overhead, insurance, or expenses as required. In addition to an employee’s billable rate, estimators should consider any equipment necessary for that individual to perform their responsibilities. Personal equipment such as a company vehicle, computer, cell phone, or travel expenses such as fuel, overnight stays, and per diem should always be considered.
Once labor rates are established, a project staffing plan should be developed that ensures the project can meet
all expectations. Providing operations with a clear understanding of the scope and complexity of the project can help in determining the appropriate staff requirements. Be sure to consider how much time each team member will be needed on a particular project. For example, a project engineer may be needed only one day a week to complete repetitive tasks while a field engineer will be needed daily, but only for the first few months of a project.
Equipment rental, as it pertains to general conditions or general requirements, will vary drastically from project to project but will often include mobile office space, temporary restrooms, temporary barricades, and fencing, as well as dumpsters for job site waste. In general, a similar approach as described above for staffing can be applied to equipment. First, coordinate specific project needs with operations. Next, solicit pricing for equipment rentals from vendors and determine the amount of time the equipment will be used. Be sure to consider fuel charges as well as expendable items such as bits or blades.
Material costs, much like equipment, will vary depending on the demands of the project. A site logistics plan or project strategy meeting can help identify these costs. First, consider the staff and equipment that you have included for your project. What materials will these people need to perform their jobs? Ice and cups, bits and blades, along with office furniture and supplies would all fall in this category. Many projects will require temporary barriers or the need for temporary handrails while construction is ongoing. If specific requirements for these items are not provided, consult with the operations team on how they should be constructed. Once lumber quantities are developed, a list of materials can be sent to your local supplier for pricing.
Another important part of any project’s general condition or general requirement costs is indirect costs such as permits, insurance, and bonding. Once the specific requirements of the project are identified, reach out to third-party vendors responsible for each and request pricing.
While general conditions and general requirements do not typically include mark-ups, the accuracy of this scope of work can have an enormous impact on a project’s profitability as a whole. If we underestimate the time or resources needed to complete a project, the results could be detrimental to the project, the bottom line, or the company as a whole. A comprehensive estimate and presentation to management will allow them to make an informed decision regarding mark-ups.
14 American Society of Professional Estimators • ASPEnational.org
HTETCO General Conditions and General Requirements... Continued
SECTION 5: SPECIAL RISK CONSIDERATION
The biggest risk factor associated with estimating general conditions and general requirements is a miscalculation of the time it will take to complete the project. The importance of a realistic, meaningful project schedule cannot be stressed enough. Projects are not built in a controlled environment. Weather delays and other extenuating circumstances can have a significant impact on your ability to meet the project schedule.
Delays caused by subcontractors are another risk to a project’s overall schedule. Open dialogue regarding a subcontractor’s ability to staff a project with the right number of qualified employees is important. Equally as important is ensuring that the general conditions are built around a staff of personnel who can motivate others to complete the project in a timely fashion.
Material availability has become a major issue in recent years. Commodities that were once readily available may now require much more time to acquire. While this generally falls outside of the general conditions or general requirements scope of work, these delays can impact a project’s overall schedule or require additional resources and planning to avoid penalties. Communication with the market before turning in a bid is important in determining whether the materials will be available on-site when needed.
SECTION 6: RATIOS AND ANALYSIS
Each project will come with its own unique set of needs, whether large or small, single or multi-phased, ground up or renovation. One way to ensure that the estimate is as accurate as possible is to look back at previously completed projects. Unlike many scopes of work that rely on outside sources such as subcontractors or suppliers to provide current market values, general condition costs are controlled in-house. This means that the estimator can analyze past projects and determine whether the estimated cost for general conditions was sufficient to cover the costs incurred.
A common metric for tracking and checking general conditions and general requirements against similar past projects is to look at the total cost for these items on a per-month basis. For instance, a recently completed $10 million, 14-month project with total general condi-
tions and general requirements cost of $980,000 had a monthly operating cost of $70,000. Due to the subjective nature of this scope of work, tracking this ratio over time can help check a project’s general conditions and general requirements estimate against historical data.
SECTION 7: MICELLANEOUS PERTIENT INFORMATION
Always review the Division 01 specifications and site plans for any special requirements. You may learn that a project requires safety measures above and beyond what OSHA or your company would typically require. A small site may require off-site parking or not allow the use of a mobile office. School zones or zoning ordinances may restrict work hours or street closures and therefore hinder progress if not accounted for. Review the requirements for costs such as builders’ risk insurance, permit fees, and testing fees. These costs are sometimes carried by the project owner. If so, they should not be carried as a part of your general requirements bid.
Estimating Today • January/February 2023 15 HTETCO General Conditions and General Requirements... Continued
SECTION 8: SKETCHES, SAMPLES, SECTIONS AND DETAILS
(Figure “A”)
For this paper, we will assume that this project is a new standalone 3,452-square-foot single-story bank branch. The project is being competitively bid and the documents indicate that the project must be completed in 330 calendar days. Begin by reviewing the bid documents to gain a general understanding of the project scope. Next, communicate with operations so that an appropriate staff and project duration can be developed. Concurrent with the review being performed by the operations team, quantitative analysis and unit price costs can be gathered for miscellaneous items that we know will be required.
Bid documents indicate that a full‐time superintendent is required on‐site for the duration of the project.
SECTION 9: SAMPLE TAKE-OFF AND PRICING
Specifications also say that progress meetings will be held monthly. Operations have had a chance to look at the project and feel that in addition to the superintendent, a project engineer should be included full‐time with a project manager included at one‐fourth capacity (1/4 time). Additionally, we will include a field engineer for the first 3 months of construction to assist the superintendent and a full‐time general laborer for miscellaneous tasks. For estimating purposes, all quantities should be rounded up to the nearest whole week or month.
Bid documents indicate that a full-time superintendent is required on-site for the duration of the project. Specifications also say that progress meetings will be held monthly. Operations have had a chance to look at the project and feel that in addition to the superintendent, a project engineer should be included full-time with a project manager included at one-fourth capacity (1/4 time). Additionally, we will include a field engineer for the first 3 months of construction to assist the superintendent and a full-time general laborer for miscellaneous tasks. For estimating purposes, all quantities should be rounded up to the nearest whole week or month.
The accounting department can provide us with an updated list of labor and personal equipment rates
The accounting department can provide us with an updated list of labor and personal equipment rates
(Figure B):
(Figure B):
16 American Society of Professional Estimators • ASPEnational.org HTETCO General Conditions and General Requirements... Continued
Section 9 ‐ Take‐Off and Pricing Sheets required
Company Labor Rates (includes burden) Hourly Weekly Project Manager $110.00 $4,400 Superintendent $110.00 $4,400 Assistant Superintendent $75.00 $3,000 Project Engineer $60.00 $2,400 Job Accountant $35.00 $1,400 Field Engineer $60.00 $2,400 Scheduler $90.00 $3,600 Estimator $85.00 $3,400 General Laborer $35.00 $1,400 Personal Equipment Monthly Charge Rates Monthly Vehicle Allowance $1,300 Fuel Allowance $350 Computer $200 Cell Phone $75 Total Station $500
HTETCO General Conditions and General Requirements... Continued
The owner has stipulated that the project must be completed in less than 330 calendar days. After a discussion with the superintendent and scheduler, it has been decided that the project can be completed in 10 months or approximately 300 calendar days. With this information, we can compile our estimate for general conditions (Figure C):
The owner has stipulated that the project must be completed in less than 330 calendar days. After a discussion with the superintendent and scheduler, it has been decided that the project can be completed in 10 months or approximately 300 calendar days. With this information, we can compile our estimate for general conditions (Figure C):
Labor Quantity Unit Unit Price Unit Subtotal Superintendent Salary (Includes burden) 42 WK $ 4,400 WK $ 184,800 Vehicle Allowance 10 MO $ 1,300 MO $ 13,000 Fuel Allowance 10 MO $ 350 MO $ 3,500 Computer 10 MO $ 200 MO $ 2,000 Phone 10 MO $ 75 MO $ 750 Field Engineer Salary (Includes burden) 12 WK $ 2,400 WK $ 28,800 Vehicle 3 MO $ 1,300 MO $ 3,900 Fuel Allowance 3 MO $ 350 MO $ 1,050 Computer 3 MO $ 200 MO $ 600 Phone 3 MO $ 75 MO $ 225 Total Station 3 MO $ 500 MO $ 1,500 Project Manager (1/4 Time) Salary (Includes burden) 11 WK $ 4,400 WK $ 48,400 Computer 3 MO $ 200 MO $ 600 Phone 3 MO $ 75 MO $ 225 Project Engineer Salary (Includes burden) 42 WK $ 2,400 WK $ 100,800 Computer 10 MO $ 200 MO $ 2,000 Phone 10 MO $ 75 MO $ 750 General Laborer Salary (Includes burden) 42 WK $ 1,400 WK $ 58,800 Labor Total $ 451,700.00
site. An agreement is in place to park on a neighboring property as long as the lot is restored at the completion of the project. Once take‐offs are completed, we can confirm unit pricing with local suppliers or subcontractors and compile our estimate for general requirements (Figure D): 15
Estimating Today • January/February 2023 17
Next, we will focus our attention on the general requirements for the project. Section 015000 indicates that a job trailer with a conference room will be required. All temporary power and water should also be included in our proposal. Testing and permits will be paid for by the owner. Finally, the contractor is responsible for fencing the entire site due to a nearby elementary school. After reviewing the site logistics plan (Figure A) it was further determined that offsite parking will be required to maintain access to the site. An agreement is in place to park on a neighboring property as long as the lot is restored at the completion of the project. Once take-offs are completed, we can confirm unit pricing with local suppliers or subcontractors and compile our estimate for general requirements (Figure D): Materials Quantity Unit Unit Price Unit Subtotal Temporary Fencing 774 LF $ 8 LF $ 6,192.00 20’ Gate @ Construction Entrance 1 EA $ 750 EA $ 750.00 Fence Delivery, Setup, and Removal 1 LS $ 1,500 LS $ 1,500.00 Temporary Stone Base (#57 Stone, 35% Compaction) Construction entrance – 12” (In‐Place) 71 CY $ 28 CY $ 1,988.00 Employee parking lot – 6” (In‐Place) 78 CY $ 28 CY $ 2,184.00 Sod at the temporary parking lot 3094 SF $ 1.00 SF $ 3,094.00 Material Lay‐down area – 6” (In‐Place) 90 CY $ 18 CY $ 1,620.00 Jobsite Signage 1 LS $ 1,200 LS $ 1,200.00 Office Trailer 10 MO $ 650 MO $ 6,500.00 Office Supplies 10 MO $ 125 MO $ 1,250.00 Portable Toilets 10 MO $ 85 MO $ 850.00 Ice & Cups 10 MO $ 75 MO $ 750.00 Extended Boom Forklift 10 MO $ 1,250 MO $ 12,500.00 Fuel Allowance 10 MO $ 250 MO $ 2,500.00 40 CY Dumpster 16 EA $ 550 EA $ 8,800.00 Storage Trailer 10 MO $ 150 MO $ 1,500.00 Temporary Power 10 MO $ 250 MO $ 2,500.00 Temporary Water 10 MO $ 50 MO $ 500.00 Material Subtotal $ 56,178 Taxes @ 8% $ 4,494 Material Total $ 60,672
Next, we will focus our attention on the general requirements for the project. Section 015000 indicates that a job trailer with a conference room will be required. All temporary power and water should also be included in our proposal. Testing and permits will be paid for by the owner. Finally, the contractor is responsible for fencing the entire site due to a nearby elementary school. After reviewing the site logistics plan (Figure A) it was further determined that offsite parking will be required to maintain access to the site. An agreement is in place to park on a neighboring property as long as the lot is restored at the
HTETCO General Conditions and General Requirements...
Now that we have completed our estimate for both general conditions and general requirements, we can compare our total to previous projects on a cost-per-month basis:
Now that we have completed our estimate for both general conditions and general requirements, we can compare our total to previous projects on a cost‐per‐month basis:
The total project budget has been estimated at $2 million. GC/GR costs on past projects of a similar size and complexity typically run between $48,000 and $55,000 per month, indicating that the total value estimated is likely sufficient for the current project.
The total project budget has been estimated at $2 million. GC/GR costs on past projects of a similar size and complexity typically run between $48,000 and $55,000 per month, indicating that the total value estimated is likely sufficient for the current project.
SECTION 10: GLOSSARY / TERMINOLOGY
General Conditions – Costs associated with managing a project
General Requirements – Non-management indirect costs associated with executing a project
Operations – Company personnel generally responsible for managing a project under contract, including, but not limited to, Superintendents, Project Managers, Schedulers, Foreman, etc.
SECTION 11: REFERENCES
S. Hulston & D. Zastrow. Digitek Solutions. Retrieved from General Conditions vs. General Requirements: https://digiteksolutions.com/general-conditions-vs-general-requirements/
18 American Society of Professional Estimators • ASPEnational.org
Continued
Labor Total $ 451,700 Material Total $ 60,672 Total GC/GR Cost $ 512,372 $512,372 / 10 months = $51,237.20 / Month
Unified Building Group (UBG) is a nationally licensed construction company with offices located in Broomfield, CO, West Palm and Pompano Beach, FL. UBG specializes in the telecommunications, corporate real estate, educational, power, energy, health care, restaurants, residential and commercial industries. UBG’s core capabilities range from real estate, site acquisition, investment, pre-construction, construction management, design build, to complete building lifecycle facilities management and maintenance. Our team has a combination of over 300 years of construction industry experience. UBG was formed to change the way the industry builds, collaborates and executes on projects. With branches in Arizona, California, Colorado and Florida, we are here to serve you!
Multiple Scholarships Available
Up to 25,000 to be Awarded
Application Due Date - April 28, 2023
Estimating Today • January/February 2023 19
2023 Scholarship Program
For more information, visit ASPEnational.org
Education Tab - Scholarship
How to start, organize, and maintain an ASPE “Joy of Bocce” Tournament
An ASPE Chapter can start a “Joy of Bocce” Tournament for fundraising every year and clear a minimum of $10,000 after expenses with entry fees of $750 for teams and $250 for sponsors. The steps to take to start, organize, and maintain an event are as follows:
First. Get the ASPE Chapter Board to discuss the best time of year, location, and method of advertising the event. Form a committee to create the program.
Second. Update your master list of names, email addresses, and cell phone numbers of every general contractor, subcontractor, and supplier in your region. I recommend two separate master lists; one for general contractors and one for the subcontractors and suppliers. These master lists can be used for membership drives, newsletters, and ASPE monthly events. I recommend that consultants call general contractors and that general contractors call subcontractors and suppliers.
Third. Post the “Joy of Bocce” event on your website continuously throughout each year. Take photos of the 1st Annual event with the winning team holding the coveted Bocce Cup and company logos of all the teams and sponsors that year. This form of advertising saves time explaining the event to new people interested in participating. Use the master list to call and find out who all the estimators are in each firm. Tell the decision maker to go online to your website and sign up as a team or sponsor. The website should have a link to Eventbrite and an entry form for those that prefer to send a check.
Fourth. There should be four bocce courts available for four hours to accommodate 75 people. Pizza and water should be included. Make sure it is a no-host bar unless you can make money. It is preferable to put a deposit down early to make sure the four courts are available.
Fifth. You most likely come across people throughout the year. Tell them how fun it is to participate in a fundraising event where networking and fellowship are welcome. Tell them everyone has a good time. It should only take two minutes to tell them to go to your website and find out all about it. It is an easy pitch in the course of your workday throughout the year.
Sixth. The Bocce committee should be organized to have the chapter treasurer deposit the proceeds and write the checks. This is a straightforward approach that should be effortless. Imagine a company in your chapter willing to match the $10,000 in donations.
Seventh. After the first year, the Bocce committee should have the excel templates in place to keep track of the teams and sponsors including those who paid, who submitted their logo, and team instructions prior to the event. It gets easier to run the yearly event as time goes by.
There is an excel template available online that I call “Team Brackets”. There are 16 teams listed on the scoreboard with start and finish times. The first four games are counted up. The four teams that have the most points cumulatively at that point move on to the semifinal rounds. The winners go to the final round. The loser brackets are used to play bocce while the semifinals and final are played to determine third, fourth, and fifth positions.
20 American Society of Professional Estimators • ASPEnational.org
The coveted “Joy of Bocce” Cup is passed on each year to the current winning team and returned to ASPE at the next annual tournament. The winning team engraves the names of the four players on the “Joy of Bocce” Cup. The Bocce committee may decide to expand the award ceremony to gift certificates to the winning players, second-place winners, etc. Our chapter gives out $25 Home Depot cards to the winning players and $10 Starbucks cards to the second-place winners.
In doing 12 of these “Joy of Bocce” Tournaments over the years there are a few experiences I wish to share.
1. Some firms wait until the last minute to sign up. They get upset when they are told that there are no more openings. Some firms have two teams signed up early to hopefully win first place. There is usually one firm that has signed up and does not show up. This creates an opportunity for another backup team to sign up.
2. We start our tournament at 5:00 pm and try to pace the timing of the food distribution. There are people who have not eaten all day and are hungry. Do not set all the pizzas out at once. Set times so that everyone can enjoy the tournament food.
3. Usually after the first four games many teams go home or retire at the bar and order something to eat, waiting it out until the end.
4. The key ingredient to the success of the event is hospitality! I highly recommend requiring the teams to submit the names, email addresses, and cell phone numbers via email one day before the event so preprinted name tags can be ready when they all come. It can be difficult and overwhelming when 64 people come at once in a 15-minute period. Expect some teams with different players. Expect people who do not have business cards to put in the “Joy of Bocce” Cup. It is important that everyone feels welcome and identified.
5. Tell people that Bocce is a game you can learn in five minutes. One can develop a skill and strategy quickly. There are many players ready to give advice. Remember Bocce can be played by anyone who can throw a ball.
6. Remember that proper planning removes anxiety and allows for the event to become successful. The Bocce Committee should have a follow-up meeting sometime after the event to improve on the process. I can say it becomes easier to host this event as the years go by.
Here is a list of items that would help the Bocce Committee plan a tournament:
1. The master lists are discussed above. Assign each ASPE Board member a call list that they are responsible for.
2. Create a flyer and post it on your website along with photos and logos of teams and sponsors.
3. Have a written contract with the facility. Create a written menu with specific serving times.
4. Have the ASPE W9 form on file to email to any company that requests it.
5. Create an excel template to keep track of the teams and sponsors that have signed up to date and email status periodically to the ASPE Chapter Board members.
6. Create an excel template showing the 16 teams and the players to print name tags.
7. Create a Team Brackets Board.
8. Create a logo poster for the teams and another poster for the sponsors to display at the event. There usually is a blueprint company that donates these posters.
9. Create an “Instructions to Teams” email notice describing where, when, parking instructions., etc.
10. Create a “Thank you for your support” email to all team players and sponsors to send after the event with the results of who won the tournament.
Samples of these items may be obtained if you wish to email me at KFinc@ix.netcom.com
ASPE Silicon Valley Chapter 55 has used this fundraiser for scholarships and educational events. Every ASPE Chapter can use this fundraiser to offset chapter expenses as well.
Kevin Fennimore, FCPE Silicon Valley - 55 KFinc@ix.netcom.com
Estimating Today • January/February 2023 21
2023 ASPE Critical Calendar
January 1 New Fiscal Year Begins!
3 AEP/CPE Status: Expiring /AEP’s/CPE’s revoked for non-renewal (Renewal due 12/31/2022)
31 ASPE Membership: Membership suspended for non-renewal (Renewal due 12/31/2022)
31 Deadline: Member Profile Updates for inclusion in 2023 Membership Directory
February 23 Chapter Reports due to Regional Governors
March
3 2023 Summit - Registration Opens for Chapter Representatives 15 Deadline to submit “Intent to Submit” form for Award Submittals
April 1-30 Chapters hold annual elections
3 All Award Nominations / Applications due to SBO
10 Deadline for Chapters to identify their 2023 Summit Chapter Representative
24 Award Winners to be announced (to Winners only)
28 Scholarship applications due to SBO
May 12 Deadline for Chapters to submit Chapter elections result form to SBO
26 Scholarship Winner(s) to be announced (to Winners only) 29 SBO Closed for Memorial Day
June 1 Chapter Reports due to Regional Governors
American Society of Professional Estimators • ASPEnational.org
Cons en sus Do cs® Keeping You Ahead of the Curve Stay ahead of the curve with updated standard contracts. The revised contracts address insurance changes, legal developments, and refine terminology. ConsensusDocs are the only contracts written by 40 leading design and construction industry organizations. Subscribe now… ConsensusDocs helps YOU build a better foundation for project success! ConsensusDocs.org ASPE Members Save 20%
ASPE CHAPTER MEETINGS
ARIZONA
Arizona #6
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Jerry Chandler j.chandler@cox.net
ARKANSAS
Arkansas #33
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Jack Guess jguess@baldwinshell.com
NW Arkansas #79
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Danny Chadwick, CPE estimatordan@gmail.com
CALIFORNIA
Los Angeles #1
Where: Virtual Website: laestimator.org
Meeting Contact: Bruce Danielson la1ofaspe@outlook.com
Golden Gate #2
Where: Virtual Website: aspe2.org
Meeting Contact: Robert Muir, CPE robmuir72@hotmail.com
Orange County #3
Where: Virtual Website: aspe-oc3.org
Meeting Contact:
Troy Thomas constructionpro1984@yahoo.com
CALIFORNIA (CONTINUED)
San Diego #4
Where: Virtual Website: aspesd4.org
Meeting Contact: Paul Chang pchang@balfourbeattyus.com
Sacramento #11
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Bryan Hall bryan.hall@vanir.com
Silicon Valley #55
Where: Virtual Website: aspe55.org
Meeting Contact: Shawna Alvarado shawna@odonnellplastering.com
COLORADO
Denver #5
Where: Virtual Website: aspedenver.org
Meeting Contact: Jennifer Farmer, AEP jennifer@livingdesignstudios.com
CONNECTICUT
Nutmeg #60
Where: Back Nine Tavern Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Lee Sullivan lee@lionsheadcc.com
Yankee #15
Where: n/a
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Bill Jacabacci jacabacci@gmail.com
DELAWARE
Delware #75
Where: Virtual Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Brett Mucklow bmucklow@bpgsconstruction.com
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
Greater D.C. #23
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Carlos Rosales cbrc74@hotmail.com
FLORIDA
Tampa Bay #48
Where: The Pub Resturant Website: aspetampabay.com
Meeting Contact: Ray Velez reymvelez@gmail.com
Gold Coast #49
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Danny Chadwick, CPE estimatordan@gmail.com
Orlando #50
Where: Anser Advisory Website: https://aspeorlando50.com
Meeting Contact: Andrew Kleimola akleimola@anseradvisory.com
GEORGIA
Atlanta #14
Where: Virtual Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Clinton Aldridge ca45@gatech.edu
24 American Society of Professional Estimators • ASPEnational.org
ASPE CHAPTER MEETINGS (CONTINUED)
ILLINOIS
Chicago #7
Where: Virtual Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Bryan Mixer, CPE bmixer_rvc@msn.com
INDIANA
Central Indiana #59
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Jeremy Adkins, CPE jadkins@wccci.com
Old Fort #65
Where: Virtual Website: aspechapter65.org
Meeting Contact:
Thad Berkes tberkes@designcollaborative.com
IOWA
Quad Cities #71
Where: Varies
Website: aspequadcities.org
Meeting Contact: Scott Robinson, CPE scottr@jlbradyco.com
Greater Des Moines #73
Where: Varies
Website: iowaaspe73.org
Meeting Contact: Dominic Filippelli dominic.filippelli@storycon.com
LOUISIANA
New Orleans #9
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Danny Chadwick, CPE estimatordan@gmail.com
MAINE
Maine #37
Where: Varies
Website: aspemaine.com
Meeting Contact: John Brockington, CPE jbrockington@woodwardcurran.com
MARYLAND
Baltimore #21
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Steve Dooley, CPE sdooley@phoenix-eng.com
MASSACHUSETTS
Boston #25
Where: Virtual Website: aspe17.org
Meeting Contact: Eric Rennell eric@rennellcapitalgroup.com
MICHIGAN
Detroit #17
Where: Virtual Website: aspe17.org
Meeting Contact: Matt Burress, CPE mburress@performanceservices.com
MISSOURI
St. Louis Metro #19
Where: AGC Training School Website: aspe19stlouis.org
Meeting Contact: John Smith, CPE jpsmith@tarltoncorp.com
Heartland #32
Where: Varies
Website:aspe32.org
Meeting Contact: Eric Soriano esoriano @hermeslandscaping.com
NEVADA
Las Vegas #72
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Chuck James, CPE wcjames2@cox.net
NEW JERSEY
Garden State #26
Where: Virtual Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Robert Sibilia, CPE sibiliaconstructionservicesllc @gmail.com
NEW MEXICO
Roadrunner #47
Where: Fiestas Restaurant
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Joshuah Crooker-Flint, CPE joshc@auiinc.net
NEW YORK
New York #10
Where: Virtual Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Rose Jesse rosejesse.aspe@gmail.com
Empire State #42
Where: Athos Resturant Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Alvaro Garza, CPE Alvaro.garza@nationalgrid.com
Estimating Today • January/February 2023 25
ASPE CHAPTER MEETINGS (CONTINUED)
OHIO
Southwestern Ohio #38
Where: Varies
Website: aspe-cincinnati.org
Meeting Contact: Dan Frondorf, CPE dan@dgfrondorf.com
OKLAHOMA
Landrun-OK City #80
Where: Varies
Website: aspeok.org
Meeting Contact: Mike Phillips, CPE michaelp@miller-tippens.com
OREGON
Columbia-Pacific #54
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Steve Watkins steve.watkins@bnbuilders.com
PENNSYLVANIA
Greater Lehigh Valley #41
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Dexter Murphy, CPE dextercmurphy@comcast.net
Three Rivers #44
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Dexter Murphy, CPE dextercmurphy@comcast.net
Philadelphia #61
Where: Varies
Website: na
Meeting Contact: Stephen Biddle SBiddle@oliverfps.com
PENNSYLVANIA (CONTINUED)
Central Pennsylvania #76
Where: Loxley's Resturant
Meeting Contact: Shawn Buckwalter, CPE sbuckwalter@egsconstruction.com
TENNESSEE
Middle Tennessee #34
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Ricky Sanford rsanford7159@gmail.com
TEXAS
Houston #18
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Larry Lucero, CPE llucero@redlineinsulation.com
Rio Grande #40
Where: Varies
Website: n/a
Meeting Contact: Rodolfo Barba, CPE rodolfobarba1@gmail.com
Dallas/ Ft.Worth #43
Where: Virtual Website: sites/google.com/view/aspe-dfw
Meeting Contact: Rick Wyly, CPE rick.wyly@wylycost.com
UTAH
Great Salt Lake #51
Where: Virtual
Website: na
Meeting Contact: M. John Shampton, CPE mjohnshampton@gmail.com
VIRGINIA
Richmond #82
Where: Varies
Website: aspe-richmond.org
Meeting Contact: Sid Bass, CPE sbass@reynolds.edu
WASHINGTON
Puget Sound #45
Where: Virtual
Website: na
Meeting Contact: Eric Benton Eric.benton@pmsvs.com
WISCONSIN
Brew City #78
Where: Varies
Website: na
Meeting Contact: Matt Washkoviak, CPE mattwashkoviak@camosy.com
Please Note: Information is subject to change. Report changes in your Chapter’s information with an email to Tina@ASPEnational.org
26 American Society of Professional Estimators • ASPEnational.org
Estimating Today • January/February 2023 27 The industry standard for search! Exclusively for commercial construction professionals, like you! TheBlueBook.com/ASPE (844) 617-2478 BUILDING RELATIONSHIPS SINCE 1913 BUILDING RELATIONSHIPS SINCE 1913 • Quick & easy access to the nation’s largest database of qualified commercial construction professionals • Find exactly who you need, where and when you need them • Always available, always up-to-date
ASPE CORE VALUES
EDUCATION:
ASPE educates and mentors professional estimators for the sustainability of the construction industry.
PROFESSIONALISM:
ASPE promotes the lifelong pursuit of excellence and credibility in professional estimating.
ASPE CORE PURPOSE
ASPE is the construction industry’s leader and recognized authority in professional estimating through excellence in education, certification and standardization.
FELLOWSHIP:
ASPE develops a fellowship of professional estimators that connects and leads the construction industry.
215 Donelson Pike, #140710 • Nashville, Tennessee 37214 • 615.316.9200 • ASPEnational.org