IN/2011/CL/35
Foreword India’s unique cultural heritage lies in its cities, towns and settlements, which form a complex and highly developed fabric of human habitation. The country’s flourishing urban culture is continuously undergoing a process of change, interacting with new elements and assimilating new ideas as well as the aspirations and creativity of its people. Cities thus renew themselves while maintaining their unique and diverse heritage, both cultural and natural. Rapid urbanization, along with the influence of globalization, has in recent times accelerated the pace of change in all aspects of Indian life, and particularly in urban settlements. India’s cities and towns find themselves under pressure to accommodate rapidly growing populations, with all the demands on technology and public services and utilities this entails. This can lead to a chaotic urban scenario disturbing the delicate balance of the city’s physical, social, cultural and ecological environment. If Indian cities and towns are not strengthened to cope with these abrupt changes and transformations, the uniqueness and diversity of the cultures that exist in them will soon be lost forever, and they risk becoming homogeneous and monotonous. The preservation of the culture and heritage of cities and towns is a major challenge for local authorities and citizens alike. The present Concept paper on Heritage Walk in the historic cities of Jaipur, authored by Dr. Shikha Jain accordingly seeks to identify the core heritage resources of the city and its enduring characters thereby proposing a possible itinerary of a heritage walk in the old city of Jaipur. Designing of such a heritage walk, far from being a mere tourism attraction, should serve as a small-scale model case to guide our reflection on how an urban renewal may take place in harmony with heritage preservation. The publication is a collaborative effort between the Government of Rajasthan and UNESCO under the Indian Heritage Cities Network. Launched by UNESCO in 2006 with the endorsement of the Union Ministry of Urban Development, this Network provides a platform of exchange for the municipalities and town planners on the use of heritage resources for sustainable urban development. As of December 2010, it comprises of twenty-four Indian member cities, of which Jaipur is one, seven non-Indian cities and regional partners, as well as several universities, NGOs and other institutional members. Developing a heritage walk itineraries constitutes one of the four key actions that a member city is expected to undertake. Remembering that the Indian Heritage Cities Network began during an international conference that took place in the very city of Jaipur, it is our immense pleasure that the city serves, once again, as the first example of a Concept paper on Heritage Walk developed under the Network. We hope that this publication would serve as a source of inspiration to other member cities, leading to the development of a series of similar attempts across India.
Shri Armoogum Parsuramen UNESCO Director and Representative to Bhutan, India, Sri Lanka and Maldives
Shri Shanti Dhariwal Minister for Urban Development, Housing, Local Self Government, Home, Law, Parliamentary Affairs, Government of Rajasthan
UNESCO Survey Team Members • • • • • •
Dr. Shikha Jain Ms. Parul Munjal Ms. Vanicka Arora Ms. Somya Johri Ms. Neha Saxena Ms. Parul Bhatti
Acknowledgements • • • • • •
Ms. Minja Yang, Former Director and UNESCO Representative for Bhutan, India, Sri Lanka and Maldives Ms. Moe Chiba, Programme Specialist for Culture, UNESCO New Delhi Ms Faith Singh, Trustee, Jaipur Virasat Foundation Mr. Vinod Joshi, Jaipur Virasat Foundation CEO, Jaipur Municipal Corporation Dr. Aylin Orbasli, Oxford Brookes University
4
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
Table of Contents Indian Heritage Cities Network .......................................................................... 7 - Introduction and approach...................................................................... 7 - Why develop a heritage walk?................................................................ 8 Jaipur - history of a city . ........................................................................................ 9 City and its evolution .............................................................................................13 Urban form and architectural identity ..........................................................19 - Streets and chowks...................................................................................20 - Bazaars...........................................................................................................21 - Typology of façades..................................................................................22 - Construction materials.............................................................................23 - Gates and city walls...................................................................................24 - Forts and palaces.......................................................................................26 - Temples.........................................................................................................29 - Havelis and cluster houses.....................................................................32 - Water structures.........................................................................................35 - Public open space and gardens............................................................38 - Public buildings and memorials...........................................................40 Intangible heritage .................................................................................................42 - The city as a centre for arts and business . ......................................43 - Arts and crafts.............................................................................................44 - Building arts and crafts............................................................................45 - Music and dance........................................................................................48 - Festivals.........................................................................................................49
Entrance of Samrat Haveli, Jaipur
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
5
Proposal for heritage walk ..........................................................................................................................................................50 - Proposed itinerary ............................................................................................................................................................51 - Mapping socio-cultural activities.................................................................................................................................55 - Listing built heritage . . ....................................................................................................................................................57 Challenges to heritage-based urban development . ......................................................................................................61 - Lack of awareness towards heritage...........................................................................................................................62 - Poor implementation of regulatory and legislative framework ......................................................................63 - Sustaining intangible heritage......................................................................................................................................65 - Solid waste management...............................................................................................................................................66 - Water infrastructure..........................................................................................................................................................67 - Electricity wiring and services.......................................................................................................................................69 - Fire safety..............................................................................................................................................................................70 - Vehicular traffic and parking..........................................................................................................................................71 - Management of stray animals.......................................................................................................................................73 - Insufficient tourist facilities...........................................................................................................................................74 Vision for planned growth ..........................................................................................................................................................75 Recommendations for action ....................................................................................................................................................83 - Heritage awareness programme..................................................................................................................................84 - Interpretation of the heritage resources of the city..............................................................................................85 - Legislative and regulatory framework for heritage conservation....................................................................86 - Incentive mechanisms for heritage management ...............................................................................................87 - Adaptive reuse ...................................................................................................................................................................88 - Mainstreaming local crafts into the modern market............................................................................................91 - Infrastructure improvement through community participation and public private partnerships......92 - Improved physical access to the heritage resources ...........................................................................................93 Sources and credits . .......................................................................................................................................................................94
6
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
INDIAN HERITAGE CITIES NETWORK Introduction and approach •
Founded in 2006 as a programme of UNESCO New Delhi office and with the endorsement of the Ministry of Urban Development, Government of India, the Indian Heritage Cities Network (IHCN) supports Indian cities in their endeavour to safeguard and use the heritage resources for sustainable development through policy advice, capacity building, good practice exchange, awareness raising, technical assistance and the facilitation of partnerships.
•
By becoming a member of the Network, the cities are expected to take the following actions: (i) incorporate heritage cell within the municipality; (ii) formulate heritage regulations and guidelines; (iii) organize heritage festivals; and (iv) develop heritage walk itineraries within the historic city, highlighting its heritage aspects - cultural, natural and intangible.
•
The present document accordingly provides an analysis of the urban heritage of Jaipur, both tangible and intangible along with a proposal for a Heritage Walk through Chowkri Modi Khana, a historical segment of Jaipur City. Challenges for heritage conservation and recommendations for action are also provided, in a hope to serve as a food for thought for the municipal and the State authorities towards a more heritage-centric urban development. A typical house entrance in Jaipur
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
7
INDIAN HERITAGE CITIES NETWORK Why develop a heritage walk?
8
•
A heritage walk through a selected segment of a city aims at showcasing one of the most authentic representation of a city’s historic, cultural and architectural heritage. It gives a holistic experience to the international and domestic tourists and rejuvenates a sense of pride amongst the residents, including school students and youth.
•
A heritage walk is also an important tool for urban renewal of the city. By developing a tourist itinerary through a most representative historical fabric of a city, it is intended to incite a number of ancillary projects that support economic regeneration of the area and encourage the municipal authorities to address long term sustainability issues. These could include: improved conditions for the local craftsmen, local restaurants and accomodation facilities for the tourists, developing a community area or even infrastructure projects for improved drainage, solid waste management or rain water harvesting with participation of the residents along the walk.
•
Thus a heritage walk can be a micro project that addresses wider heritage conservation issues related to the city and, serves as a role model for heritage conservation of the entire city.
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
Jaipur – History of a City
Rajasthan – JaipurRajasthan – Indian Heritage – JaipurCities – Indian Network Heritage Cities Network
9
JAIPUR – HISTORY OF A CITY
The eastern Rajasthan, lying to the east and south east of the Aravalli divide includes the modern administrative districts of – Udaipur, Chittorgarh, Rajsamand, Banswara, Dungarpur, Kota, Bundi, Baran, Jhalawar, Bhilwara, Ajmer, Jaipur, Tonk, Dausa, Dholpur, Karauli, Bharatpur and Alwar.
10
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
•
The current district of Jaipur lies in Eastern Rajasthan, in the Banas River basin and forms a part of Eastern Plain of Rajasthan. The region is drained by a number of seasonal rivers of which Banganga, Dhundh and Bandi are prominent.
•
From the 10th century onwards, the district referred to as Dhoondhar, formed one of the four distinguishable politico-cultural regions of Eastern Rajasthan, in addition to Mewat, Hadauti and Mewar. Dhoondhar region was roughly comprised of current districts of Jaipur, Dausa and Tonk, with Jaipur and Amber further constituting Dhoondhar subzone within the larger tract of Dhoondhar region.
•
In Aryan epics, Dhoondhar region (called Matsya Desh/ Mina Wati) was the shortest trade route between north India and rich port cities of Gujarat and Malabar. The region was held by Badgujars, Rajputs and Minas till the 11th century.
•
From the 11th century onwards, however, the Dhoondhar region was increasingly under the power of Kachchwaha dynasty of Rajputs.
The three main capitals of the Dhoondhar Region under the Kachchwahas – Dausa, Amber and Jaipur.
•
The Kachchwaha Rajputs trace their descent through the solar dynasty to Kush, one of the two sons of Lord Rama, the famous king of Ayodhya and the hero of the epic Ramayana. According to local tradition and popular bardic chronicles, Dulha/Dhola Rai (whose reign is accepted as being from 1006-1036 AD by most historians) one of the rulers of this clan, laid the foundation of Dhoondhar kingdom in 967 AD and made Dausa his capital.
•
Kakil Dev (1036-1038) who succeeded his father Dulha Rai in 1036 AD, seized Amber from Meenas, laid the foundations of the Amber Fort and built the temple of Ambikeshwar Mahadev – one of Amber’s earliest extant monuments. The capital of Dhoondar was shifted from Dausa to Amber between 1179 and 1216 AD.
•
By the 17th century, the Kachchwaha Rajput clan became known for political clout and importance in the Mughal administration. Raja Man Singh (1590-1614) and Mirza Raja Jai Singh (1622-1667) contributed to the financial and cultural wealth of Dhoondhar through political alliance with Mughals.
•
Sawai Jai Singh II (1700 – 1743) who outlived five Mughal emperors and tried to prop up the Mughal Empire from 1707 – (Aurangzeb’s death) to sack of Delhi by Nadir Shah (1739) established the city of Jaipur and strengthened the boundaries of Dhoondhar.
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
11
Political map of Rajasthan in 1595 with Jaipur under Mughal subah of Ajmer
•
Part of the Golden Tourism Triangle – Agra, Jaipur, Delhi of northern India, Jaipur has emerged as one of the most sought after destinations on the tourist map of the world. The tourist season for Jaipur is from October to March. The city attracts domestic and foreign tourists in large numbers averaging to about 3000 tourists per day, who stay for 3-4 days in the city.
12
Important tourist destinations within the state of Rajasthan
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
Political map of Rajasthan in 1931 as Rajputana agency under the British Rule. The current Jaipur Dausa and Tonk Districts roughly form the Dhoondhar Cultural Region.
In the past decade, the arrival of both domestic as well as foreign tourists to the city has nearly doubled, though the state of Rajasthan had seen a decline in number of foreign visitors.
CITY AND ITS EVOLUTION Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
CITY AND ITS EVOLUTION •
The foundation of the city of Jaipur was established by Sawai Jai Singh II (1700-1743) in 1727. The city was designed by Sawai Jai Singh II himself and further developed and monitored by his renowned counsellor Vidyadhar.
•
The city planned in the gridiron pattern was built with extraordinary foresight and futuristic planning and is probably the only 18th century walled city in India that can still cater to the present day pressures of vehicular traffic on roads.
•
It included innovative concepts in traditional planning guidelines along with an appropriate adaptation of the terrain itself. The direct application of the mandala in the plan of Jaipur seems improbable, though parallels can be found between the Jaipur planning principles and traditional texts on spatial organization such as Rajvallabha, the regional 15th century text written by the sutradhar Mandan.
•
Two significant facts responsible for the origin of the city and its subsequent layout were: a) The need of a new capital for 18th century Dhoondhar as the earlier one of Amber built on a hill was getting congested; b) Sawai Raja Jai Singh’s vision of the new capital as a strong political statement at par with Mughal cities and as a thriving trade and commerce hub for the region.
Interpretation of the 18th century map from Kapad-dwara collection, Jaipur, with the gridiron pattern evident in the layout
14
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
A – Religious centre or temple B – Political centre or for C – Gates and walls D – Havelis and houses
The generic plan of a medieval Rajasthani hill town- as in Dausa and Amber
The hill town of Dausa with an organic layout guided by the topography
•
The medieval towns of Rajasthan were of military, agrarian, mercantile or religious nature. The presence of a deity marked the reference point for the ruler’s abode and the rest of the city. The name of the town was usually associated with the political or religious centre (with the Ambikeshwar temple in the case of Amber and with Sawai Jai Singh in the case of Jaipur).
•
Unlike Dausa and Amber, the two previous capital cities of the Dhoondhar region established on hill-top, whose planning was guided by topographical structure of the areas, Jaipur city was revolutionary both in terms of its grid-iron pattern planning and its location at the base of the hills.
•
There was also a significant economic shift from an agricultural base in Dausa and Amber to trading in the capital of Jaipur.
Amber Town with the Fort on top of the hill and the walled town down the slopes
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
15
•
The site selected for establishing the new capital of Jaipur was a valley located south of Amber and the plains beyond, a terrain that was the bed of a dried lake. There used to be dense forest cover to the north and the east of the city.
•
The physical constraints that informed the building of Jaipur city included the hills on the north that housed the fort of Jaigarh and the Amber palace beyond, and the hills on the east, which contained the sacred spot of Galtaji.
•
To facilitate water supply to the new city, the Darbhavati river in the north was dammed to create the Jai Sagar and Man Sagar (that later housed the Jal Mahal) lakes. Later the Jhotwara river in the north-west was diverted through the Amani Shah Nallah and a number of canals were channelized through Brahmapuri and Jai Niwas to supply water to the city.
The site with the natural east west ridge and the surrounding forts as defense feature
•
18th century dimensional norms
16
The east-west axis of the town was divided by three perpendicular roads into eight portions with the central ones of equal size and the outer ones as per the remaining dimensions till the Chand Pol in the west and Suraj Pol in the east. A sawaya (a quarter extra) system of measurement was used in the planning and details of Jaipur, with use of dimensions that are a quarter more than a whole number.
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
The intersection of the axes to define the Badi chaupar (city square)
Division into eight portions, ends of the roads marked by gates in the city wall
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
17
•
Later in the 18th and 19th centuries, there were additions in the built fabric of the city and the palace such as the Hawa Mahal and a number of temples added by Sawai Pratap Singh under whom the Jaipur architectural vocabulary reached its peak in terms of stylization.
•
Two major contributors to the city development and establishment of modern infrastructure were Sawai Ram Singh II (1835 – 1879) and Sawai Man Singh II (1922 – 1969).
•
In the 19th century, with the accession of Sawai Ram Singh II, the city extended beyond the old city walls, adapted newer modes of transport such as the railways with a railway station located on the western outskirts, started using gaslights on the streets and adopted modernized drainage and piped water supply system.
•
There were interesting additions in the urban fabric within the walled city with new buildings constructed in the Indo Saracenic vocabulary such as the Mubarak Mahal within the Palace Complex, the Naya Mahal or Vidhan Sabha and the Maharaja’s College in 1873 (now Rajasthan School of Arts); and the Ramniwas Bagh that was later enhanced with the visual focus of the monumental Albert Hall Museum to the south of the walled city.
•
The 20th century observed further modernization and urban renovations within the walled city, including the restoration work of the city walls and gates and, converting the inner temporary houses in the sectors into more permanent structures; pioneered by the famous Mirza Ismail who was appointed as the Prime Minister of Jaipur in the early 20th century. A number of new colonies such as the Bani Park came outside the walled city.
•
In 1947, the four largest Rajput states, Jodhpur, Jaisalmer, Bikaner and Jaipur opted to join secular India. Jaipur then became the capital of Rajasthan leading to further attraction of administrative and economic activities. These factors led to increased development of residential areas to cater to the growing population.
18
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
I9th and 20th century additions
URBAN FORM AND ARCHITECTURAL IDENTITY Streets and chowks Bazaars Typology of façades Construction materials Gates and city walls Forts and palaces Temples Havelis and cluster houses Water structures Public open space and gardens Public buildings and memorials Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
URBAN FORM AND ARCHITECTURAL IDENTITY Streets and chowks
View of a main bazaar street - the width of the main roads was kept 39 1/4 gaz - 108 feet, secondary roads are half this size - 54 feet, the tertiary roads are 27 feet and the inner mohalla streets are 13 feet wide
•
The main markets, havelis and temples on the main streets in Jaipur were constructed by the state in the 18th century, thus ensuring a uniform street façade is maintained. The widths of roads were predetermined.
•
According to a popular belief, the city was painted pink to celebrate the visit of the Prince of Wales in 1876, during the reign of Maharaja Sawai Ram Singh II, lending the city the name of ‘Pink City’.
•
Junctions of the main axial streets formed the two square public open spaces called chaupars (Badi chaupar and Chhoti chaupar). The width of the square chaupars was three times that of the main street.
•
Historically, the chaupars were outlets for intense social use with water structures connected by underground aqueducts, supplying numerous sources of drinking water at street level. Presently, the centre of each chaupar has square enclosures with ornamental fountains.
•
The streets and chowks (central open squares in a town) of the internal chowkries (sectors) with numerous clusters or mohallas were not predetermined; hence show a mix of grid iron and organic pattern, with the basic unit of built form being the rectangular haveli.
View of a chaupar today
20
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
URBAN FORM AND ARCHITECTURAL IDENTITY Bazaars •
Original markets in the city include Kishanpole bazaar, Gangauri bazaar, Johari bazaar, Sireh Deorhi bazaar, along the main north-south and east-west axes that intersect at Chhoti and Badi Chaupars.
•
Typical architectural features of the bazaar streets are use of chhajjas (sunshades) resulting in strong horizontal lines, projecting vertical blocks on brackets, a modular system of arches filled with delicate latticed screens to cut direct sun and glare of reflected sun in the street.
Bazaar streets have temples above shops with wide staircase starting from pavement to the temple level. Space above shops at first floor level originally functioned as galleries for watching royal processions, religious festivals and public celebrations
Uniform planned shop fronts on bazaar streets with upper floors in interesting juxtaposition
Defined street façade at a chaupar with sunshades and latticed colonnades at upper floors and shop fronts on the ground floor
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
21
URBAN FORM AND ARCHITECTURAL IDENTITY Typology of façades •
Façades of Jaipur and surroundings typically have gokhdas (sitting spaces) on either side of the entrance.
•
The openings are often characterized by the use of cusped, trefoil or pointed arches with rectangular or chhatri (vaulted dome) type framing, flanked with lotus columns. An increased ornamentation is seen in later post Jaipur Marwari patterned havelis as compared to the Dhoondhari ones from the 18th century.
•
Stylistically, the bangaldar (curvilinear) roof became prevalent in stone chhatris and chhajjas (sunshades) and was later used in other areas of Rajasthan too.
An elaborate entranceway with a gokhda and cusped and pointed arch as important elements in the streetscape, Goyal Bhawan, Chowkri Modikhana
22
Entrance with chhatri type framing, the bangaldar chhatri was used extensively in the Dhoondhar region
Entrances in Dhoondhar region, use of arches with rectangular framing
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
The bangaldar chhatri with the sunshade following the profile forms the focus of the Chandra Mahal façade, in the City Palace complex, that dates from the period of the foundation of the city
URBAN FORM AND ARCHITECTURAL IDENTITY Construction materials •
Stone for construction is available in abundance in the region. The earlier structures are of masonry in random rubble or dressed form in grey metamorphosed stone, schist from Ramgarh or stone from Ghat Ki Guni area. Later in the 19th century, Bansi Paharpur stone was used in Jaipur.
•
Stone walls are on an average 1 feet 6 inches thick and plastered with lime. Columns are either assembled with laterite stone or are monolithic with timber type joints. Use of stone in beams, lintels, door and window frames is common.
•
Makrana marble is used for decorative components such as carved columns and black marble from Kotputli for inlay-work.
•
Roofing is usually of stone slabs except in a few cases where bricks are arranged in a concentric manner called the ladao roof. For thermal insulation, a layer of inverted clay pots used between multiple roofing layers amounting to a total roof thickness of about 1 feet 6 inches.
•
Typical finishes of this region include araish (slaked lime smooth finish) on floors and walls. The havelis, palaces and temples show excellence in stone work of jharokhas (projected balconies), jaalis (latticed screens) and parapets. Stuccowork in lime plaster is also found. Decorative finishes include mirror work, stained glass, mother of pearl inlay and silver inlay work frescoes, pannimeena and dakmeena work.
A typical wall section in Dhoondhar
A Haveli in Amber with random rubble masonry, finished with lime plaster.
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
23
URBAN FORM AND ARCHITECTURAL IDENTITY Gates and city walls •
The walled city of Jaipur shows a 6 meter high and 3 meter thick crenellated masonry wall surrounding the city that is pierced by nine gates – seven original and two were added later. The city gates were earlier closed at night as a rule. The practice discontinued in 1942 due to inconvenience to the travellers from the railway station who reached the city late in the night.
•
Remains of fortifications of earlier capital of Amber in the north and Ambagarh in the Ghat ki Guni area in the east present an interesting landscape.
The fortifications at Jaipur
24
The fortifications at Amber
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
Typology of Gates in Jaipur
•
The walled central square (Chowkri Sarhad) several high walled courtyards sequentiall laid out with a system of gateways.
•
Similar gateways can be seen in the other palaces in and around Jaipur – such as the Amber fort and palace. Sireh Deodhi Gate – royal ceremonial gate as entry to the palace complex from the northsouth axis or the Sireh Deodhi Bazaar
Chand Pol – The Suraj Pol and Chand Pol mark the eastern and the western ends of the east- west axis.
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
25
URBAN FORM AND ARCHITECTURAL IDENTITY Forts and palaces •
The true hill forts of Jaipur lie beyond its walled boundaries, perched on strategic locations in the hills on the north, east and west, namely the forts of Amber, Jaigarh, Ambagarh and Nahargarh. All these forts have palatial royal residences within the complex.
Amber – Built over several centuries since it was established as the seat of the Kachchwahas in the 11th century. The palace fortress was in use till the shift of the capital to Jaipur in 1728 Nahargarh - Built in 1734 has many ruins but also houses structures with architectural merit like Hawa Mandir and Madhavendra Bhawan
Jaigarh – Built by Maharaja Jai Singh II in 1726, ‘The Pride of Jaigarh’ the Jai Ban canon is supposed to be the largest canon of its type. The Fort has palaces, well maintained gardens, granary and a tall watchtower within.
26
City Palace Jaipur with Nahargarh in the backdrop – The first Chowkri to be developed in the city of Jaipur was Chowkri Sarhad that contains the entire city palace with Chandra Mahal dominating the skyline
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
•
These include constructions by the rulers of Dhoondhar such as –Amber Fort and Palace, Jaipur City Palace, Nahargarh, Raghunathgarh, Jaigarh, Ambagarh; as well as by the thakurs (estate owners) within the region in their thikanas (land/estates) such as Samode Chomu,Manoharpura, Achrol, Bishangarh. The most exemplary in ornamentation are the Amber Palace, the Jaipur City Palace and the Samode Palace for its mirror- work.
The Amber Fort with Palace structures
Plan of the Bishangarh Fort, a thikana fort
The City Palace Complex, Jaipur
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
27
•
The palace structures within the city palace complex of Jaipur comprise of the Badal Mahal, the seven storied Chandra Mahal with highly ornamented interiors and the Sarvato Bhadra constructed during Sawai Jai Singh’s reign (1700-1743). Later additions include the Pritam Niwas by Sawai Pratap Singh (1778-1803), Diwan-i-Am, constructed in the 18th century under Sawai Madho Singh I (1751-1768) or Sawai Pratap Singh (1778 – 1803) and Mubarak Mahal by Sawai Madho Singh II (1880-1922) in 1896 for use by royal guests.
•
The pleasure palaces outside the city palace complex are the Jal Mahal – within the Mansagar Lake and Ram Bagh Palace and Raj Mahal that have been converted to heritage hotels.
Jal Mahal is a pleasure resort, built in the centre of an artificial lake outside the city to the north-east by the road to Amber. There is debate as to its period of construction – either along with the foundation of the city in 1734 or as late as 1799. The palace has airy domes, pavilions and terraces around an old fruit orchard. It was used by the Maharaja and his guests for shooting migrating geese, grouse and duck
28
Chandra Mahal –seven storeyed structure with symmetry and unity of massing and synthesis of Mewar and Jaipur styles of palace architecture
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
URBAN FORM AND ARCHITECTURAL IDENTITY Temples
This partial map is based on an earlier map of Jaipur that has been dated in the reign of Pratap Singh (1778–1803) by Gole, (Indian Maps and Plans, page 195). The original map is not to scale and was made just to show the construction of a canal till Sanganer and was thus purely representational in nature. However the underlying factors to be noted are the city wall that also includes Brahmapuri as part of the town, number of gates and locations of temples with shikhara – on the main chaupars and in the Sireh Deodhi Bazzar.
•
Jaipur and Amber, the earlier of capital of Dhoondhar capital are renowned for their numerous historic temples. While Amber has excellent stone carved temples with shikharas (spires) built from 11th century onwards, Jaipur became the precursor in building haveli temples of the 18th century. The Jain and Hindu temples form a significant part of the built fabric.
•
The planning of Jaipur is rooted in the centric Indian philosophy with the temple of Govind Dev defining the centre that led to the genesis of the city plan. The Govind Dev Temple, established in a pavilion called Suraj Mahal, standing in between the Badal Mahal and Chandra Mahal in the Jai Niwas Garden, continues to be the most active temple even today.
•
Although there is no definite data, locals state that around 400 temples were built in Jaipur during its planning. There are more than 1000 temples of various sizes in Jaipur with 606 within the walled city as registered temples with the Devasthan department in 1973. All the important temple sites, specifically on the main commercial streets had been marked in the Jaipur plan during the reign of Sawai Jai Singh.
•
Even today, the important temples with shikharas can be observed at four most important locations in the city along the cardinal axes i.e. the Laxmi Narayan Temple at Badi Chaupar, the Rama temple at Chhoti Chaupar, the Murli Manohar temple at Ramganj Chaupar and the Kalka temple opposite to the main Sireh Deodhi entrance to the Palace. It is interesting that in all these temples the idol is facing towards Govind Dev, the main deity of Jaipur.
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
29
Typology of Temples in Jaipur
Entrance to a haveli style temple, Jaipur
30
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
Typology of Temples in Jaipur
•
Each mohalla (cluster of houses) has its own temple presided over by the deity most appropriate for their prosperity and protection. A relationship between temples and wells (both constituting ritual spaces) can be observed inside the chowkries in the layout of the sectors.
•
Most of the remaining temples inside the city were built in the haveli temple style without shikhara. Sawai Pratap Singh got numerous temples constructed within the city, reflecting the stylized articulation of the period.
Map of Jaipur marking important temple locations within the walled city and inside each chowkri area
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
31
URBAN FORM AND ARCHITECTURAL IDENTITY Havelis and cluster houses •
The havelis (medieval north Indian mansions belonging to nobles) of Jaipur range from a single courtyard house form to an assemblage of multiple courts, depending on the status of the owner and number of family members. Majority of the havelis have one or two courtyards.
•
The haveli forms the basic urban fabric of the towns in the Jaipur region. Palaces can be visualized as an extension of the havelis. The haveli plots in Dhoondhar region conform to a rectangular or square shape, sometimes with offsets.
Shah Haveli at Samode
32
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
The court as the centre of the haveli - reflected in the concentric articulation
Typology of Havelis in Jaipur
Bhatt Haveli with three courtyards
Natani Haveli with multiple courts, Jaipur
The Tatterkhana House, Jaipur, reflects a single family cluster consisting of a single family and its zenana (wing occupied by ladies of the house) and infrastructure of servants
The Shivdin Haveli, Jaipur with typical two court planning
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
33
Johari Haveli, Ghat Ki Guni – representing the unique subtype of a garden haveli with rectilinear layout and stepped terraces overlooking the Purana Ghat valley street on the eastern outskirts of present Jaipur
Chaumoo House- a later mansion in bungalow style
•
The Jaipur havelis not only provide a wide range and scale of this archetype but also present two unique typological variations of the haveli i.e. the haveli temple type found as courtyard temples (with no shikhara) on the main commercial streets as well as inner residential streets of Jaipur and secondly, the garden haveli type found on the Ghat Ki Guni valley stretch located on the Jaipur Agra highway.
•
The association of a particular haveli with the temple or well in the cluster also emphasized the status of the owner. Group of havelis formed mohallas – number of mohallas formed a chowkri (sector) well defined as a geographical entity in the city. A chowkri in Jaipur may comprise of up to 400 mohallas.
34
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
URBAN FORM AND ARCHITECTURAL IDENTITY Water Structures •
Water being scarce in the region, indigenous methods for effective water collection have been evolved and practiced across Rajasthan. A vast number of reservoirs, artificial lakes, tanks, kunds (stepped ponds), step-wells or baories, wells, ponds etc, have been built and renovated over the centuries.
Panna Mian Kund in Amber
Water body at Galtaji
Well in community open space
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
35
Typology of Water Bodies in Jaipur •
The surface water bodies – Talkatora, Jai Sagar, Man Sagar (Jal Mahal Lake) and the Ramgarh Lake were important features in the city plan. The artificial lakes were created in response to the natural topography.
Important historic water bodies located within the walled city. The two middle squares in blue were originally public water tanks that were closed in 19th century when piped water supply came into the city. These two locations called Badi Chaupar on right and Choti Chaupar on left serve as public squares with fountains today.
36
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
Typology of Water Bodies in Jaipur •
The water structures such as step wells or baories were important elements in the urban fabric that reflected the importance of water in the water scarce environment.
•
A unique water system of underground canals was specially devised for the water supply in the city and the square central tanks were located in the Badi Chaupar and Chhoti Chaupar. In the center of each chaupar, square enclosures with ornamental fountains were outlets for intense social use. Fountains were connected by underground aqueducts – supplying numerous sources of drinking water at street level. In the mohallas, the community wells were used as water sources.
•
For both the mohalla and haveli, the well was an important part of the social set up of the community.
•
The water bodies, water structures and wells all suffered due to the introduction of piped water supply that replaced the indigenous systems and to the rapid urbanization that encroached upon the catchment areas.
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
37
URBAN FORM AND ARCHITECTURAL IDENTITY Public open space and gardens •
Public open space and gardens constitute another typical element of Jaipur city planning. Just as the Govind Dev temple on which the planning of the city was centred, the Jai Niwas garden and the Chaugan were envisaged as a significant open space for the city, meant for performances and sports witnessed by the general public and attended by the royalty.
•
Chaugan is the public entertainment ground of Jaipur in the west of the walled city where polo, elephant fights and other sports were held between 1724 and 1921. Square in plan, enclosed by high walls, the Chaugan was venue for Teej and Gangaur fairs in earlier times and now houses the Zonal Sports Stadium.
•
Jai Niwas Garden, the first garden to be established in the city by Sawai Jai Singh II, is a symmetrical formal garden on double char bagh pattern with fountains and water falls in Mughal theme using natural slope of the terrain.
•
With British influence, later gardens such as the Ram Niwas Bagh established in 1868 by Sawai Ram Singh II deviated from the earlier Mughal planning of Jai Niwas and Ghat Ki Guni gardens.
•
The Albert Hall was later added in the centre of this English pattern Ram Niwas garden. Even today, it is significant as the second largest open space for the city. Located outside the walled city, it sprawls across an area of 4 acres and was designed by surgeon Major De- Faback. It is a well-laid out garden comprising a zoo, a bird park, play ground, exhibition ground and a gymnasium.
38
The recently restored Raj Niwas Bagh, Ghat ki Guni, is planned on the Rajput -Mughal garden concept (Source: Ajay Khare)
Street façade of Raj Niwas Bagh, Ghat ki Guni, lined with chhatris
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
•
Ghat ki Guni was a recreational area established by Sawai Jai Singh II in 1739 on the outskirts of Jaipur, beyond Ghat Lake, where water was available, a concept of which seems to have developed with the Mughal influence at the time of Akbar. It has three main gardens that demonstrate the palace-garden —Sisodia Rani Ka Bagh, Vidyadhar ka Bagh and Raj Niwas Bagh—and haveli-garden typologies.
Sisodia Rani Ka Bagh Ghat ki Guni, comprises of terrace gardens equipped with fountains, cascades and water channels sprouting from natural springs.
Kanak Vrindavan – a temple-garden complex, the temples and gardens have recently renovated. Set within the scenic backdrop of the Jal Mahal and the surrounding hilly area, the complex has become a favourite excursion and picnic spot of tourists and locals.
Kesar Kyari, Amber is a stepped formal royal garden attached to the Palace
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
39
URBAN FORM AND ARCHITECTURAL IDENTITY Public buildings and memorials •
Monumental structures such as the Jantar Mantar Observatory, the Hawa Mahal, Old Vidhan Sabha Building and parts of the City Palace Complex are important public buildings in the city centre today.
•
Public buildings such as railway station, schools, hospitals, theatres, museums, colleges were constructed in the 19th century, starting with the reign of Sawai Ram Singh II (1835 – 1879). These were built in the Indo Saracenic style with the Naya Mahal or Old Vidhan Sabha exhibiting an architectural style that is a fusion of local Rajput elements with colonial pediments and arches.
Jantar Mantar - astronomical observatory by Sawai Jai Singh between 1724 and 1734. The yantras (instruments) were constructed in stone and lime. The Jantar Mantar, Jaipur is inscribed as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 2010.
Hawa Mahal reflecting stylization at its peak under Sawai Pratap Singh
40
Gaitor Cenotaphs - The prominent of the cenotaphs is that of Maharaja Jai Singh, built in white marble, comprising of 21 ornately carved pillars depicting scenes and figures from Hindu mythology
• The memorials include the royal cenotaphs at Gaitor with significant ones being the Chhatris of Sawai Jai Singh II and Sawai Madho Singh; and the cenotaphs of royal ladies and the victory tower - Isar Lat.
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
Old Vidhan Sabha - variation in the Indo Saracenic style with use of European features such as the round arch
Jaleb Chowk -huge square court earlier had single stories structures on all four sides. Sawai Ram Singh II (1835 – 80) extended verandahs and constructed a floor above
Albert Hall reflecting the Indo- Saracenic style adopted by the PWD in the 19th century
The New Vidhan Sabha building
Jawahar Kala Kendra - Designed by Charles Correa, the Jawahar Kala Kendra (1986)
•
The new Vidhan Sabha building reflects the continuity from the 19th century colonial framework by the Public Works Department by replication of architectural details from the ‘Jeypore Portfolio’.
•
Jawahar Kala Kendra, a cultural centre designed by Charles Correa in 1986 and the urban design for Vidyadhar Nagar, a residential area in New Jaipur, designed by the architect B V Doshi and established in 1984-1986 are an attempt to reflect the symbolism of the Vastu Purusha Mandala (concept in ancient Indian treatise emphasising on establishing harmony between natural and human environment), which is said to have formed the basis of the planning of the city of Jaipur, according to several historians.
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
41
INTANGIBLE HERITAGE The city as a centre for arts and business Arts and crafts Building arts and crafts Music and dance Festivals
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
INTANGIBLE HERITAGE The city as a centre for arts and business •
The important part of Sawai Jai Singh’s planning included the promotion of commercial activities of the city. As a result, merchants were invited in 1729 through dispatched letters and given special incentives and prime location to settle in the city. They were given free land and given remissions and concessions on taxes.
•
Located on important trade routes, Jaipur thus became an important and vibrant center for trade and commerce that fuelled its growth further, housing large numbers of artisans, craftsmen and merchants from distant parts of India. There were potters, utensil makers, stone carvers, building craftsmen and builders, leather workers and tanners, jewelers and precious stone cutters, ivory carvers, brass ware manufacturers, enamellers; weavers, dyers and embroiderers, settled in mohallas or group of mohallas occupied by families pursuing similar trade or craft. The same guild system continues till date, as in the proposed heritage walk area of Chowkri Modikhana.
•
The royal patronage to literary works, music, miniature painting and the performing arts also resulted in huge collections in the pothikhana (royal library) and has led to the evolution of the Jaipur style of painting, music and dance and the encouragement of the Dhoondhari language.
•
Chhattis Karkhane (36 departments) set up on Mughal or Persian standards with Hindi names, gave state protection to learned men, poets, writers, painters, musicians, dancers, artists and sculptors to train them further, thereby enriching the arts and crafts traditions. Jaipur became a hub for artists after the 1857 War of Independence, when many of them who fled from Delhi found refuge in Jaipur.
The tradition of stone carving of the idols for the temples continues till date in Jaipur
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
43
INTANGIBLE HERITAGE Arts and crafts •
During the period of Maharaja Sawai Pratap Singh (1778-1803), the Jaipur School of painting flourished with influences from the Devgarh and Kishan garh painting styles. Sawai Jagat Singh (1803 – 1848) was the last patron for paintings – after whom the traditional style deteriorated due to influences from western art. Miniature painting continues however as an art today, drawing from the Jaipur School tradition.
•
The Pachranga (five coloured) flag designed by Raja Man Singh remained to be the identity of the Dhoondhar region and the five coloured pagri (turban) was worn by the rulers of Dhoondhar. The colours are an important aspect of the Dhoondhari cultural heritage, with various dyeing techniques and block printing of Sanganer having evolved in the region.
•
The tie and dye (leheriya) textile printing, textile block printing of Sanganer, natural dyes, metal crafts, enamelling (minakari), crafting silver jewelry and artifacts, stone crafts, handmade paper and blue pottery are the most famous handicrafts today.
Clay pottery displayed by a craftsman
44
Puppet making – a craft that finds market in the tourists in the present context.
Sawaya Pachranga flag of Sanganer has long been a centre for Sawai Jaipur on Chandra block printed textiles since centuries. Mahal, City Palace complex The picture shows the process of drying of the dyed cloth that is to be printed
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
INTANGIBLE HERITAGE Building arts and crafts •
The Dhoondhar rulers are known to be the patrons of arts and crafts from the period of Raja Man Singh (1590 – 1614). Besides the buildings crafts of stone carving, mirror works and inlays; an indigenous fresco technique done on araish evolved, examples of which can be seen in Bairat caravan serai, Bharmal Ki Chhatri from the period of Man Singh (influence from the Mughal Court of Akbar), and in Ganesh Pol (1639), Amber, from the period of Mirza Raja Jai Singh with Mughal influences later absorbed to develop integrated style.
Intricate glass inlay work inside Amber Palace
Building crafts – stone carved columns and screens
A floral motif fresco from the Amber Palace
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
45
The Ganesh Pol demonstrates the indigenous fresco technique with evident Mughal influence in the decorative patterns around the subject – Lord Ganesha and fine stone carved lattice screens, Amber Palace
46
Frescoes in ceiling of Sita Ramji Temples at Galtaji
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
The continuity of stone crafts till date with use of the traditional knowledge systems
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
47
INTANGIBLE HERITAGE Music and dance •
The city has well developed folk music and dance forms, such as ‘Dhudhadi’, that is the Jaipur style of Galibazi (verbal art form traditionally used as medium for social awareness and reform) and ‘Tamasha’, a style of musical folk play introduced to the city during the reign of Sawai Ram Singh II (1855 – 1880).
Traditional attire adorned by girls to perform a form of folk dance
A dance form being presented as a part of the current initiatives to showcase the cultural heritage of the region
48
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
INTANGIBLE HERITAGE Festivals •
•
Fairs and festivals are an important part of the entire region. The integration of the festivals with royal traditions followed since the establishment of the city, making the festive celebrations of Makar Sankranti, Teej, Gangaur, Holi and Dusshehra special for the city of Jaipur, as processions and performances take place with the involvement of the royal family. The game of polo is a modern version of Chaugan (means a hockey like stick in Persian that was used in the Mughal period to play a sport of the same name with a wooden ball, on horse back) that brought international recognition to Jaipur during the period of Maharaja Man Singh II. The annual Jaipur Heritage International Festival, started in 2002 by the Jaipur Virasat Foundation is a week long event, presently called the Rajasthan Day celebrations – Jaipur Festival in partnership with the Government of Rajasthan and endorsed by UNESCO New Delhi. The celebrations provide an international cultural platform to the living traditions of Rajasthan, now an integral part of the social fabric of the city.
Celebrations during the annual Jaipur Heritage Festival
A painting in Pundrik Haveli depicting festive celebrations in Chogan area
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
49
PROPOSAL FOR HERITAGE WALK: Chowkri Modikhana
Proposed itinerary Mapping socio-cultural activities Listing built heritage
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
PROPOSAL FOR A HERITAGE WALK: Chowkri Modikhana Proposed itinerary •
A proposed itinerary lies within the Chowkri Modikhana, starting from the Rajasthan School of Arts, Kishanpol Bazaar and ending at Chaura Rasta.
•
As one of the historic Chowkries designed of the 18th century planned city of Jaipur, Chowkri Modikhana is a unique representative of the living heritage of Jaipur. It derives its name from the Modis (trader) as the area was traditionally housing Jain and Hindu traders. It was also a residential area of the officials.
•
With interesting havelis, temples, public buildings, museums and craft productions, the Chowkri Modikhana provides to the visitors an encounter with Jaipur’s traditional communities, lifestyle, crafts, stories of each street and entry into historic buildings.
•
The proposed itinerary is based on the survey works of the local NGOs, Jaipur Virasat Foundation and DRONAH, who undertook the mapping of the social activities and the inventory of the historical buildings of the area, along with the listing of infrastructure development needs.
•
The same proposal has been presented to the local community of Chowkri Modikhana for their feedback during an exhibition held in March 2007 at the time of Rajasthan Festival in Jaipur.
The walk within the Chowkri Modi Khana with the different streets defining different socio- cultural entities
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
51
The Heritage Walk starting from the Albert Hall
Street condition noted in a survey
52
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
Initiatives by Jaipur Virasat Foundation to revitalize the walk area include street plays and performances in public spaces such as the Film Colony chowk
Exhibition in Mahavir Park at Chowkri Modikhana held for participatory design development
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
53
Proposals exhibited in Mahavir Park at Chowkri Modikhana for community feedback. Residents from the neighbouring chowkries visited this exhibition and appreciated the suggestions too. Thus the exhibition at Chowkri Modikhana had a wider impact leading to increasing heritage awareness in the walled city of Jaipur
54
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
PROPOSAL FOR A HERITAGE WALK: Chowkri Modikhana Mapping socio-cultural activities •
Though a decline in the population of the walled city has been noted in the 2001 census, a primary social survey has shown that the Chowkri Modikhana has a growing population and the residents have still kept strong socio-cultural bond with the area.
•
The area is a vibrant hub of intangible heritage in terms of traditional knowledge systems and craft activities. Crafts such as manufacturing of lac bangles and making brass metal utensils is continued by the local artisans settled in the houses in Chowkri Modikhana area since centuries.
•
The social fabric is defined by the names of the streets, such as the Thatheron ka Rasta that groups together low income group artisans (brass workers or thatheras). These historic definitions continue till date, with existing examples of the same occupational patterns being followed from generation to generation, passing on the traditional knowledge systems.
Cultural Map of the walk area
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
55
Local small scale food stalls
•
People maintain strong sense of attachment with religious structures, as well as with streets and havelis, as they are linked with important personalities associated with the royal court.
•
The personal collections of manuscripts, such as showcased in the Sanjay Sharma Museum within the walk area have significant cultural value. The Museum itself draws visitors and acts as a means of dissemination of significance of the area.
•
There is scope for revitalization of local informal entrepreneurial set ups through the heritage walk as in the case of small scale food stalls and craft retail existing in the area.
Manufacturing of lac bangles
Thatheras at work in Thatheron ka Rasta and Nanga Thatheron Ki Gali, continuity of traditional craft over generations
56
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
PROPOSAL FOR A HERITAGE WALK: Chowkri Modikhana Listing built heritage •
The area covered under the itinerary of the proposed Heritage Walk comprises of 106 structures, of essentially residential and commercial nature.
•
Bajjo Ki Haveli and Natwar Lal Shastri Haveli as well as houses dominate the fabric, with courtyard temples such as Shri Digambar Jain Mandir Sanghji, Baij Ji Ka Mandir and Shri Anant Deviji Ka Mandir as landmarks. Most of the structures are ground plus two floors, any further floors are later additions.
•
The structures are separated by thin lanes called gandi galis that were supposed to function as shafts for cooling.
•
The Rajasthan School of Arts is a significant structure conforming to the pink colour code and urban façade of the Kishanpol Bazaar street. Unlike the main bazaar streets such as Kishan Pol Bazaar and Chaura Rasta, the internal streets covered under the itinerary of Hertage Walk were not meant for commerce and the workshop of the artisans are accommodated in the house. The façades of the buildings are usually introverted, with projected balconies on the first floor.
Natwarlal Shastri Haveli
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
57
Baij Ji Ka Mandir
Kishan Pol Bazaar
58
Sangakon Ka Rasta
Ceiling detail– Bajjo Ki Haveli
Decorative stucco and painting – Bajjo Ki Haveli
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
•
The chowks such as Digamber Jain Mandir Chowk earlier formed community spaces attached to temples or held common facilities such as the well area i.e. Sanghi ji ka Kuan. The Mahavir Park is the only large open space in the area.
Digamber Jain Mandir Chowk used currently for parking
Proposal for Mahavir Park to be used as a community space prepared by students of Oxford Brookes University during a study programme in Jaipur
South Elevation, Sangakon Ka Rasta
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
59
Elaborate gateway with ornamentation borrowing Rajasthani, Mughal and Colonial elements - Goyal Bhawan
Mughal style entrance gateway of haveli in Thatheron Ka Rasta
North Elevation, Sangakon Ka Rasta
60
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
Internal space from courtyard – Khinduka Haveli
CHALLENGES TO HERITAGE-BASED URBAN DEVELOPMENT
Lack of awareness towards heritage Poor implementation of regulatory and legislative framework Sustaining intangible heritage Solid waste management Water infrastructure Electricity wiring and services Fire safety Vehicular traffic and parking Management of stray animals Insufficiency of tourist facilities
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
CHALLENGES TO HERITAGE-BASED DEVELOPMENT Lack of awareness towards heritage •
Lack of interest and awareness of the people towards heritage conservation has led to deteriorating condition of the heritage buildings. A number of monuments are poorly maintained. Violation of rules and regulations for the conservation of heritage buildings and their surroundings is a common phenomenon.
Insensitive repairs in Chowkri Modi Khana
62
Later interventions – shop fronts and adding new windows with evident use of cement – Nataniyon Ka Rasta
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
CHALLENGES TO HERITAGE-BASED DEVELOPMENT Poor implementation of regulatory and legislative framework •
The Government of Rajasthan has put into place a numbers of regulations and byelaws which aimed at protecting heritage monuments and structures. These include the Rajasthan Monuments, Archaeological Sites and Antiquities Act 1961 that applies on any state protected monument under the jurisdiction of the Department of Art and Archaeology and Heritage Byelaws for properties within Walled City as outlined in the Master plan of Jaipur 2011.
•
The implementation of the byelaws is however poor, with the local population clearly flouting them giving in to pressures of commercialization, need for modern conveniences and growing population. 35% of high-class houses were demolished in 1971-81 and replaced by their owners.
•
Encroachments onto the street– Nataniyon Ka Rasta
New structures replacing old ones; services added on to façades – Maniharon Ka Rasta
There are multiple reasons for poor implementation of the byelaws, such as insufficient data base on heritage buildings, with different sources quote different number of heritage structures; lack of specific legislative and regulatory measures according to each street or typology that requires detailed studies and analysis of the existing fabric of the city; and lack of clarity of division of responsibilities in the implementing agencies.
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
63
•
Guidelines for signage in the historic areas need to be formulated and implemented as excessive display of advertisements due to commercialization impacts the urban ambience on the main streets and chowks as well as the inner lanes.
An inner street with evident visual clutter due to excessive commercial advertisements, electrical wires and cables and encroachment by parked two wheelers
64
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
CHALLENGES TO HERITAGE-BASED DEVELOPMENT Sustaining intangible heritage •
Traditional craftsmanship which has given life to the streets of Jaipur is under the threat of disappearance due to the poor living conditions of the artisans and to the pressures of growing family needs. A solution needs to be found to sustain these small-scale industries.
•
The fairs and festivals have been an important part of the city’s cultural heritage and with the diminishing role of the royal family, there is a need for revitalization of the same not only for tourists but also for the local community.
The Thathera community of brass craftsmen works in difficult situation within their tiny home spaces in the walled city area
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
65
CHALLENGES TO HERITAGE-BASED DEVELOPMENT Solid waste management •
•
Solid waste management has emerged as one of the most pressing urban environment issues for the city as the majority of the city does not have a primary waste collection system. The problem is particularly serious in the walled city area such as Chowkri Modikhana, where the solid waste is left on to the street, spread by stray cattle and dogs and accumulating over months in the open drains and narrow lanes (gandi galis) that divide the various property lines. Gandi Galis are cleaned only once a year. This is a major cause of water logging and unhygienic living conditions. The accumulated waste is a threat to the historic structures in many instincts.
The narrow space dividing two structures – gandi gali with accumulated solid waste
Waste management is absent in slums and kacchi basti areas where waste is dumped into nallahs. Even in the areas where there is a solid waste collection system in place, there is no system of segregation of biodegradable waste from the non biodegradable, and the city does not have a proper designated sanitary landfill site.
66
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
CHALLENGES TO HERITAGE-BASED DEVELOPMENT Water infrastructure Sources of water •
With piped water supply introduced in the mid 19th century, the traditional water systems like baories and Jhalaras suffered gross neglect. At present, most of the baories in Jaipur are defunct.
•
The embankments of the lakes have been encroached by the built form accommodating the growing cities, and the natural drainage channels carry the sullage and waste water into the lakes polluting and stagnating them.
•
During the period of Sawai Ram Singh II, the Jai Sagar Lake was made a garbage land fill area on which urban growth sprawled; the Ramgarh Lake, which used to be the main source of supply more than 30 years back, produces insignificant quantity of water now.
•
The Man Sagar Lake is heavily polluted at present with the city sewage flowing into it through two nallahs, Brahmapuri and Nagtalai. The Talkatora which once recharged ground water of the city is now dry. Old Check dams, which used to recharge ground water in the city, have been broken down over the years and as a result water levels in the city have decreased alarmingly.
•
Ground water is the only source of water for parts of the city that do not get piped water supply.
•
Piped water is also not entirely safe due to contamination with sewerage. Due to loss of systems of recharging ground water, there is drastic depletion of ground water and Jaipur faced a water crisis in 2009-2010. It is hoped that with the heavy monsoon in 2010 and recent government initiatives of mandatory rain water harvesting for property owners may improve stituation in next few years.
•
Ground water in the city has been found to be contaminated due to several reasons like over extraction and seepage of wastewater, from soak pits used in the septic tank system, into the ground water. All these factors have resulted in an increase in the concentration of nitrates and fluorides in ground water.
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
67
Sewerage and drainage •
Sewerage system was laid inside the walled city in 1930s.
•
At present, nearly 80% of the population is covered by a sewerage network.
•
The issue lies in the disposal of the sewerage as there is no sewage treatment plant and the sewage flows through the natural drains into the Mansagar Lake polluting it.
•
The drainage situation in the city ranges from average to poor with water logging being a very common phenomenon in Jaipur. Even with less amount of rain, roads and open areas get waterlogged. Water logging could be attributed to choking of drains with solid waste or later interventions and inadequate design of drains – irregular slope and form.
Garbage and sewage in Sangakon ka rasta
68
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
CHALLENGES TO HERITAGE-BASED DEVELOPMENT Electrical wiring and services •
The overhead wires and cables for electrical supply, telephone wiring and television cables in the walled city area not only cause an aesthetic issue for the built heritage as they are loose and unorganized obscuring the building façades, but are possible sources of electric and fire hazard. Another threat is main transformers situated in dense areas without sufficient setback from the street – creating a fire and safety hazard.
Film Colony, Chowkri Modi Khana – transformer at inappropriate location
•
Mathuresh Bhawan, Chowkri Modi Khana – loose hanging cables and wires are a visual and physical threat
Electrical poles at irregular frequency blocking heritage façades; street lights, high tension cables, transformers and distribution boxes and air conditioning and desert cooler ducting affixed to the exterior walls of the heritage structures are insensitive interventions that create visual clutter and are a threat to the built fabric at times.
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
69
CHALLENGES TO HERITAGE-BASED DEVELOPMENT Fire safety •
Jaipur’s vulnerability to fire hazard is likely to increase with growing population density and as the urban fabric becomes denser. At present, around 1200 fire accidents occur annually resulting in a loss of Rs.10-15 Crore.
•
The infrastructure and manpower of the Fire Department is grossly insufficient and the internal areas of the walled city are at further threat, being inaccessible to fire trucks due to road widths. Major uplift of the infrastructure for fire fighting and devising of indigenous solutions for the walled city areas are urgently required.
The inner lanes with unorganised electrical cables wires and fittings and narrow width make them high risk with regards to fire safety
70
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
CHALLENGES TO HERITAGE-BASED DEVELOPMENT Vehicular traffic and parking •
The longer east- west axis of the city that is marked by Suraj Pol and Chand Pol is about three kilometres in length. Hence, the entire walled city was meant to be accessible to the common man on foot. The main roads were used by elephants, carriages, horses and camels and footpaths by pedestrians; and the internal chowkries were a composition of self sustaining clusters, with narrow road widths.
•
This equation has changed now with cars and two wheelers parked on both sides of the main streets and in open spaces and squares in front of heritage structures, encroaching upon the movement and spill over spaces. The narrow internal streets are also encroached upon by parked two wheelers on both sides and cars in open spaces that were meant for community use.
•
The situation is worsened due to commercial activity, as 60% of the total wholesale units of the city lie in the walled city. The presence of wholesale units is closely interlinked with goods handling in terms of loading, unloading, storage etc. Since adequate space is not available within the walled city for all these activities, it spills onto the roads increasing congestion. The encroachment by hawkers also claims the space for vehicular and pedestrian movement. These factors are a detriment to the urban environment in the walled city – in areas around tourist attractions, the main commercial streets and in the inner lanes of the chowkries.
Traffic situation at the chaupar – segregation of pedestrian and vehicular traffic required along with heritage walkways
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
71
•
The lack of a good public transport system, traffic planning (such as one way streets, sufficient designated parking space and environmentally friendly transport options), traffic norms and regulations in the city enhances the problem with no specific pedestrian areas (such as heritage walkways) demarcated; affecting both the tourist and the local community negatively.
Chowk in front of Bajjo Ki Haveli encroached upon by car parking
Parking in thin inner lanes of Chowkri Modi Khana
Commercial activity with two wheelers parked on either side of the street creates chaotic situation during peak market hours
72
Congested Roads due to parking of 3 wheelers and four wheelers
Open spaces meant for recreational use have been encroached upon as parking lots, as seen in the heritage walk route, in open space in front of the Digamber Jain Temple Sanghiji in Chowkri Modi Khana
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
CHALLENGES TO HERITAGE-BASED DEVELOPMENT Management of stray animals •
Stray cattle, dogs etc. cause regular nuisance and traffic obstruction in addition to soiling street surfaces.
Stray cattle adding to the congested street situation
Open spaces meant for recreational use encroached upon by stray cattle as seen in the heritage walk route, in open space in front of the Digamber Jain Temple Sanghiji in Chowkri Modi Khana
Stray cattle along with encroachment by informal commercial activity on to the streets
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
73
CHALLENGES TO HERITAGE-BASED DEVELOPMENT Insufficient tourist facilities •
The influx of tourists has brought pressures on the urban fabric and infrastructure. There is a need to carry out studies to assess the carrying capacity of popular tourist destinations with a view to regulate tourist traffic. The conversion of a number of historic palaces and havelis into heritage hotels is a positive accomplishment. However, there is still an acute shortage of budget hotels during the tourist season.
•
Quality of tourism facilities is much to be desired. The issues include poor heritage interpretation, encroachment around the heritage buildings by cars and informal shops, absence of planned pedestrian walkways and inadequate/insufficient basic infrastructures, in addition to noise and pollution.
A dilapidated building in Chowkri Modikhana. The owner of the building is keen to convert it into a Bed and Bath facility and a proposed view of the building after restoration is shown.
74
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
VISION FOR PLANNED GROWTH
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
VISION FOR PLANNED GROWTH •
This section simulates the original form, studies transformations in built form over time and demonstrates possibilities of enhancing the built heritage through planned intervention and architectural guidance.
The bazaar street as it was originally planned
76
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
Later additions include incongruous multi storeyed structure in the background of the street façade, that take away from the ambience
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
77
New structures replacing the historic fabric
Addition of incongruous new floors on top of historic structures and shop fronts with roller shutters
78
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
Changing built form of the inner streets
Due to the lack of awareness and implementation of regulatory and legislative frameworks, loss of architectural character is a common feature with new structures replacing old ones
Bajjo ki Haveli in Chowkdi Modi Khana as it must have been originally, without addittions and alterations
The current condition of the Bajjo ki Haveli in Chowkdi Modi Khana with lack of maintenance and addition of two incongruous floors
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
79
The Bajjo ki Haveli in Chowkdi Modi Khana, a visualisation of how the addition of the two floor could have been made without loss of character with planned intervention and architectural guidance
80
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
Later subdivisions visible in the façade treatment
Proposed planned development to respect façade elements of heritage value and reflect the undivided original form in the façade
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
81
Proposed view of Ghat ki Guni, Jaipur
Proposed view of Mirza Ismail Road, Jaipur
82
Existing condition and proposed view of Shr Radha Damodar temple, Chaura Raasta
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ACTION Heritage awareness programme Interpretation of heritage resources of the city Legislative and regulatory framework for heritage conservation Incentive mechanisms for heritage management Adaptive reuse Mainstreaming local crafts into the modern market Infrastructure improvement through community participation and public private partnership Improved physical access to the heritage resources Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ACTION Heritage awareness programme •
Heritage awareness programmes, such as those initiated by NGO’s like Jaipur Virasat Foundation and INTACH – that give an opportunity to the local community to be a part of the heritage movement and get a feeling of pride for their heritage, need to be encouraged.
•
More publications and the audio visual and print media to be brought out in innovative ways for the awareness - raising of the city resident, heritage property user and owner.
•
Heritage education to be made part of the school curriculum to inculcate awareness towards heritage in the up coming generations.
An existing and proposed view of a street passage and gate in Chowkeri Modikhana area
84
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ACTION Interpretation of heritage resources of the city •
Interpretation of the heritage resources through heritage walks with different themes – such as historical phases, water systems, religious association, association with specific personalities, crafts, architectural styles, catering to various age groups and visitor types need to be developed to address the multiple facets of the city.
•
Interpretation of the natural heritage, with adventure and nature trails around the city.
•
Educational value of complexes such as the Jantar Mantar should be interpreted targeting school children and other educational institutes.
•
Interpretation centres at various access points into the city including city gates, railway station, airport, bus terminals, and the major tourist destinations, need to be set up.
•
Proper signage and interpretation plaques are required for identification of heritage structures and cultural associations.
•
Re-planning of museums such as the Albert Hall and City Palace Museum with more communication and interpretation can turn them in to heritage resource centres.
Proposed street signage designs and better interpretation of the streets to guide the visitor and inculcate a sense of pride in the residents
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
85
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ACTION Legislative and regulatory framework for heritage conservation •
On the basis of the surveys and analysis of the entire historic core of the city, byelaws and regulations to be developed that specifically cover aspects such as planning and architectural typologies, street façades and land use (to prevent over commercialization).
•
Detailed database to be developed, preferably with use of Geographical Information Systems (GIS) that documents the current built fabric.
•
Strict implementation of the byelaws and regulations with the use of the GIS and capacity building and sorting out of responsibilities in the administrative framework, with heavy fines for flouting the same.
•
Street furniture, hoardings, signage to be controlled by design guidelines and regulations.
•
Areas outside the walled city that are proposed to be tapped as heritage resources to undergo detailed surveys (built and social) and impact assessment studies, to develop byelaws for controlled development in a planned and sustainable manner.
86
Façade surveys of Chaura Raasta, Jaipur showing layers of historic fabric from 18th, 19th and 20th centuries
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ACTION Incentive mechanisms for heritage management •
Easy availability of loans for restoration of historic structures to enable the middle and low income groups to invest on the maintenance of the historic fabric.
•
Tax deductions for expenditure on heritage properties to target the service class and high income groups.
Dilapidating fabric of Thatheron Ka Rasta housing low and middle income artisans reflects need for developing financial mechanisms for enabling the proper maintenance of such structures
Haveli in Chomu lying vacant – interest of owners needs to be developed in the restoration and the re-use of such structures through incentives
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
87
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ACTION Adaptive reuse •
Use of the heritage structures such as the city gates as information kiosks, and others as interpretation centres or accommodation of basic amenities for visitors (such as rest rooms) in the heritage destinations (including temples where pilgrims are the target group) in a planned manner.
•
The adaptive reuse of the houses and havelis should encourage only concepts such as the bed and bath, bed and breakfast and personalised displays to ensure that the residents continue to reside in the walled city and the walled city does not become a gentrified commercial asset losing its social fabric.
•
Underused public structures such as the Naya Mahal (in Jaleb Chowk) present opportunities for reuse for tourist infrastructure and interpretation, conference and exhibition purposes.
•
Adaptive reuse of thikana forts such as Bishangarh can generate good tourism revenue as heritage hotels, resulting in enhanced tourism revenue for the surrounding villages.
Proposed reuse for Roop Niwas Bagh as a cultural and recreational space, Ghat ki Guni, Jaipur
88
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
•
The potential of community participation in revitalization of the area as studied in the Chowkri Modi Khana Heritage Walk area needs to be replicated for the rest of the walled city as well.
Possible tourist facilities that can be incorporated in the existing fabric through involvement of the local community, enabling the revitalization of the area – as demonstrated for the walk area, Chowkri Modi Khana
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
89
Sri Anant Deviji ka Mandir, 1480 Nataniyon ka Rasta PROPOSED USAGE: House open for tourist visit
Terrace, Kirodilal Gupta
Sri Anant Devi Ji Ka Mandir on the current heritage walk route is an example of a mohalla level haveli temple. Opening the stucture for tourist visit can create incentive for its maintenance and revitalization
Proposed roof top cafe Proposed roof top terrace in the walk area – involving participation of the owner to add tourism infrastucture and in turn help revitalize the area
90
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ACTION Mainstreaming local crafts into the modern market •
The crafts such as that of metal beaters (thatheras) need to be integrated into the mainstream with exhibitions, and workshops that interpret the crafts better and create a dialogue between the craftsmen and other sectors such as industrial designers to revalidate the crafts in the present day context.
•
Stone crafts and other building crafts to be organized as a resource to ensure the access of the craftsmen, their crafts and traditional knowledge systems to on going restoration works.
•
Strengthening of the concept of craft villages/ destinations such as Sanganer to encourage the maintenance of the traditional knowledge systems with tourism encouraging their economies.
Use of recycled glass and metal by craftsmen at Chandpol Bazaar, to be identified as living cultural resources
Stone crafts to be organized as a resource
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
91
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ACTION Infrastructure improvement through community participation and public private partnerships •
The recharging of the ground water through revitalization of the traditional water systems of rainwater harvesting, wells, baories, the water systems at the chaupars, and lakes such as Ramgarh, Mansagar, Talkatora may be undertaken with community involvement and Public Private Partnerships.
•
Community participation to be used for proper solid waste management at community level. The role of the informal sector – Kabadis and rag pickers also needs to be addressed as they are existing means of recycling of waste.
•
Public Private Partnerships to be tapped as funding resources for the major investments in the infrastructure reorganization such as underground cables and wiring, sewages network and treatment plants, drainage and water supply, and city level management of solid waste.
•
Fire safety measures require community participation as well as PPPs with indigenous systems to be devised to suit the inner historic fabric of the walled city.
A sample exhibition panel used for Vikas and Virasat Exhibition in Jaipur to promote public participation
92
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ACTION Improved physical access to the heritage resources •
Traffic and transport needs to be reworked with parking pools and pedestrainised pockets. Judicious use of public areas such as the Jaleb Chowk might partially help in resolving the parking problem of the walled city area.
•
Other sustainable modes of transport for the walled city such as solar rickshaws should also be considered.
•
Better public transport systems to be developed with organized movement that helps the parking situation in and outside the walled city.
Parking of two wheelers in clusters in the internal streets with shop fronts
More than half of the width of the street is used for parking cycles/scooters, leaving only the other half for pedestrian Possible parking solutions to save on space
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network
93
SOURCES AND CREDITS All photographs and drawings are credited to DRONAH (Development and Research Organization for Nature, Arts and Heritage) and JVF (Jaipur Virasat Foundation) except for the ones mentioned below: •
P. 17 – Jaipur map sourced from Survey of India
•
P. 24 – Map of Jaipur, Satellite image. Sourced from Google Earth
•
P. 26 – Map of Bishangarh Fort, Sourced from royal family of Shahpura
•
P. 28 - Map sourced from Princely Terrain: Amber, Jaipur and Shekhawati. Edited by Shikha Jain (Shubi Publications, 2006)
•
P. 31-33- Drawings sourced from Havelis: A Living Tradition of Rajasthan by Shikha Jain (Shubhi Publications, 2004)
•
P. 58 - Proposed Plan of Mahavir Park sourced from Dr. Aylin Orbasali, Oxford Brookes University, UK
94
Rajasthan – Jaipur – Indian Heritage Cities Network