فهم الفهم مدخل إلى الهرمنيوطيقا نظرية التأويل من أفلاطون إلى جادامر لـ د عادل مصطفى0001

Page 1

I

3i ~

b

P,

JX;>L~-.LS~ j ~ ~ ~ +WI>'J~U '

'

3i p;;~f

!

Y I &I

I

&

ilJL ji

2 3 .

" ~ eJS ;' & i&p j l UjE

4 aLL, 3i "Context "jL,'Text

"X+

163

;lL%ll 3" JX;

'ILL

"p' $33. L

"

W I2~y ~ +Jyi*z A3.&+i +23 .?YI y jc, (k3L)+JU &y*llL&A;'J.4&bn cp .&I,

el3

~ j ~ k ; . ~ i Y ~ ~ z % ~ + ~ u ; j & ~ + - +

+-h j3 9 1 r

b

~ a n&d~J . +MI

&

IL

GJI

.

0

jyJjcJl ,

&,

>

d j

&-

4~

jS&

.c4;

& L52 j I Ubj !&I,-+ :L5&lUb

jij&GJ 6-.i;jr;4 b3 3 I& .i*

~JI

0

.

.- ,

,i

2jtbj +2

0

ipL+ j .hSj y JG LL.

U ~ L ; ~ I ,-+.(J?. u)

, ,

+ T * I

&;.U j k jSj hi ,

I

biPcfPG&fSL3LO

pj Y!

.&I& +cJ . &i

tlJSy

~ b d ; JS;~

j p ; 9 a ~ l l

& ;y j l fu &IJHY - u

~ ~ ~ i + ~ j i ~ i ~ r j

-

Y

2 - ,

w&&.LC2>+&G.t*?l+j.Cbiy . .

j

,yJ531

21

J!+I . .& . jin A- N uL-~+&I~ +~~j El WEIJ & & . > r e 2 2 1 l+l & . 'Lg;-~iF.dJll 2-41 ji * i - i

,w ++I

J2 LYkSJ . ~2j~ L+L JS

~i YJJAl b+j

zlQl+ & LA.&+I

$+ Y . & > I;e;lY (JY AI ji)

. ~6

9 Y

Signification '3YA11'JK;j .U

. &LC L+

Y L i 2+

>

4-t . p .

*+U.

Jd"dl

ji &-Jg '&I

di;! . >-JJ

&I2 +UU

ijA P,'L

3

'&* UA Iw ~ + j.3

&It

ji

gi ;;;I >z;IL4

jjg ~ ~ Y A I

+I

6

+

24 Y :> . jUI +;

~l;>j

1'

3!4b

Metaphor"\-'Ji' "Jadl Al+Y

l " j Narrative

.i

i>l.

~

i, f

~

j

+:+I j p

A L+L

i+I

+21i+4 t l jp ~ +~i

j.;-1;21j&I :L(: I

.

11 J~~

A b Jj 'JU:

"~41"~ Image I1i

*

~ p p ) l l l j

$s+Jj)& .*+MI-jr*311 . &!j Polysemy .. ..

Y LA, +LA hi+ , ' 9 A& ji 4 '&I 9

llc+,.

,

.

j

c -

6 J u ~ ~ I p a

5

c~~~

$31 . I'

31 C

ll+*djV

99

L: .i+'o

o

.

h

-

ji ..

9

h12 &31g

JI.-.;ll p j! 'transitive ' u " &dl .L " p k 9 " +IJ .L intentionali- "+@I" o h . "I.Q . , &*~ I l r> &dl ~5" I

.&I t H a

cj,4

j d t y

j+*.;ijplli.&s2&l

b

j.j

';>I

*+

3

j

'L . j

- -

I '*II

+

C hp j

>31 : i

i ~ ' h - +i

. b>s!23 &bpp4"J!

>i.j JI& .

d

l

Oh.

93).&L&A

dJLUI\S3 .i r I i l & 331j !+J

;&IpSignification ..

"DYAl'W Jl+ *i hill1

fore-

:Jl 'L ji 3-

b + I,ia . ql, 4

$

9b Y! dP-jl--

i~nderstnnd "

v-2' l1

. y L I .SY+d j& ji 'undei-st:lnd .Y cJL : "L+b+&l i212"+ dfl

PP r

9

>u! J u

Y l d!;- 2 ~ 3 1

awl1

e: I .p .s+

3 LJ ~

j .y

>!

."*%I

ci p

~

s ~.&WI .U I

c-

C

.IA $.\+- Ii!+JI ji A;& --2 c

* Q L4 i c 1 ~ :1

JS

~tc ,

ripUl aL,kll SCh; 3plU , L l J 'Rational "i&" +I

&A

7>lA3

l>l> r13

dp cJll*

L a . &b C

.&I

L,~+ ,

ae~,

A .A>*LI U?J.

dl.2 #-I

4

G* -3

UWL'L ~ ~

d i ji L~ y~Horizon 'l+&iU io: c

;j3-

pJ-C;IU. , l + u & l ~ ~ i 2 ~ ~ L & b j j 4-. i5,L-L

-191

L J h

+++,Jl

awl JsJI Genre

'&>YI

>IN

+MI &L->

JLs '+i

Valdes &-db J+- Uj L i A l Ig;L%j LsjYA ++ ,I &I

jp

~ " u i YLIJ>j l ;Afiq-pll

4-Id1&+Ulj. i * l + l li

d 3 .e,Ldlj

L&.bq5;9&lM

j

.'pal: p a+- Jig

ji J+>

iglY I A '+- +L:,

J Y L i.4 &&&5

+ju ~

v~

l&&> v . a ~ 'id&! a i i u y l ,,+-*&Ij . / - ~ j> 'I

- /%j

J!'L-~ &>;J;

.'. jqJI . y . -ji +b

U+-II ~

J

~OL &I+ ~ Je- l

jS

-491

-L

d

I> "A' i;".~

;z> Hermeneia ,+Y

."+-"

4 i J l igliJ~~ Herrnesp , H '

I.+>

lll++pll iJs

J1Jl

Hermeneuein

>t

j .

2 $LJI &-j K -9

'431y12 j .ipkj

31

ji L+J~JI>

oI&

j .$

33!

C

j K -Li3 &;

. +I

&->

i! 9 3 $+I

igl31&-

d+ & &Ul

I

L

u'

I

I

II

u #

+I

.IJ3 I ;.p-'Gi

I

' 9

& J3& .IFr

& . $ . 'i+lLI

& *

c.' & ~s3 i

>&I

J~y

s21L>L ""i

"IL

y

I

~ ~; u $ l

,

i! :j i

+

y Y ~i+ j ji - p - q3>

jiH .&+I /+I &"k g ;

lntertexu- "/+I

,

c .I y 2 - 9 &L

_CLF I&

Aji-

JI

9u

l ' 'v jL!

&L3bl

>I ~ Q Y J~I ~ Lu J I> L ;A

&L'&-

+

3 J-I+ji JJ.LII

>!:L"P!

./+I

JLLi

,

++UI

IL.

:~!*t+i 9 j*JI

L+

j ! ally

JL2 - j L j $5 J5 b!'' .3-$1

p

j y k a~~ u * ~:~;i i ,iy 2 *u-ikJ3L ~ S L I

..

2 &+IL;

'41 Lji 3*p-42 ."+

;P

+ y ~ $ W > A - j i " 3 & ~ % ~ l ~ L u

2 jb +.ill3 GjjJ Hermeneu- W s+a+ISU ji 'l_h,f LA3

C

.'I*~j&& +YI

b u interpretation'

i r F. 2 oL&

L ~ L U I

$A

L Y i 1 3 h & &+-

.yYl Li+

& j f l l &I+ & tics' 3-

&+

I

kf fl*

&> &dl3

6%

3 ~ 3> 1 ! >>fl$l ~ j ! ~

2 +,I3 j$%I>j LA

$ d l Q U ) u "&I

&dl1'

,

L+&I ~ j Y l

3 Law.- jI sJI

j- jldl - c+$l

ji /i-;

lip

& $b

I L .+&I

&dl

4J3+>

9 3+a +I!p+ &UI + d l 3 ctP&Ir b y l

elJJ L+

w siCategories)

G) 'bill c

.(@,+,&I

,*

244>+;JLA )&I& +

& "31 $91 p f i jl, 4 k + L U ;LG;jul&

9

L-dl&&I

ji &I

JjWl,yr'&.+ rll+IH -.

L " ~ J I " 6";+l"

j+;JL.;l **p

i&I

c

jji

d ~ C+ i $1

~,WI

+$I

9

3X-;? L 2 c l l , + I J"2L1

o h i;\S li! .+d+JI l

b f i ~i

+cl,!

S+

jp

L+JI "jlrn

~2 W~L, 2 j4; ji '"+U + fp! &,t;6iSUl al,+il

Y .$all'-i

i l Y l l l UInterpretation

dh +MI

Her- LU AIL ISx;Lj -.L&

6

+&+;J

.I1+

1+ J Jj & ~

.-yy_i!--Y

2 * U I ~'r"'13 L G L +d u 4 3 r MIal~k-~.'~; >+I 2 r ~j 6l -LL.*>

.3b3b ;lzj

+

a;iUikSyp+La :&al

4

<

L&LUi&LZy>&4iJj&iSIA~ Jij L l l + d d p , .Ul a

9

+

k p 3 >LA'

4 4u'k j~ t b b i f i :&L*+~

;

d

j ,j1+ 3-3

L!&Y p

QL

& i ~ b~

I

W L &b=*+'&~i

'I+\

Amoral

31 Walter Otto

'y

p

j .

'ei

Z

: p p j f i 2~ 6 ii- L

. 'ti%-! & ~ ubc ' rcOp

ysf

Ij3

d

+t j + l J Jl

&-+4jg ~ j + l

'OUL 2 .ipG

J!JI~9

dF- p p

3;P

s3

3 @ ej& il]Ji3 $1' ~2 G2Ul p U L :J3bl & JUI LUX

.?i+ $, &*

&dl" jL3" I@l

,i

+ d J ~ ~J3$ ji + L6'+ 5

,P

' b y b 2 9 3 '*y Jp J3$

.*

5 r P

-41 A-J.J $1 21 r

25 ji

+

I

I

&YI di3 '+I3

& L+ &I$ 9&y

jr b L U 3 l'fLgr)ll"

j - &L'Scl&$I

&> "I;tb+,l

L&+

cp U U

. U I

Lb

il;hU j L & l

& +dl

OL

a

$ ikJ!ob

4 1 9mlL;i; idl r b ) l ! 1-b.--J

&LY\

Hermeneue- U aLn!&YI

OL. ~ C L I rI-Y I

.I1&-"

Z W I a b G Y I 4 i\+l

jHermeneia M 3 i n . i;WI 2 "f& &&";yJ-JI -& l

3i "J4;;4;;11 &i ~akls j JLc I

.&I41 4 ,

(

*9

*

y-- !

d9c> JL- 4 u ! c+- - Y

Li+y~ JAI & .U ;I 2Lu 3

+i.*!*i 5

TO

4~

& *

;UJ;Z

awl ~ U.jaI

% ji 2 'Interpret jij-&jb~

LL$L~~Tz%J~+-~~&L+WIijWI :~i&yI ji +I

J

j

ji

2 .&I ~

J!

2LJl

J

L

Y I 2 ,+I

j .L - ~ J I ~ 'J+I

ci;l~j ~ & J I " ji L%jl

. I sWI , GY UI 2 WU 'LA! +& P+$Isic~~si441J!+ki j w 6

9

.

11&

'-j

' " f * i L i j":'Lf-jL+L 9

-LYI

: +a J > ~ " 4

+&+-*ol+i~ ps 3-x)-L a P

.'&-I1

3l LIIJ+-''siL1'di'l J L1l,--''

I JI>

'ler"''

>'<+ill

Z W I ~ L U Y J3i I

LOg

./A

I 1 + % ~ I ' '

2 J$l& "J$I1' 2 +I Lg,i? 21 -91JL+JI d. LAL&-1 j ..j4& 4 _in "L.'&Y~" J! r I i " ; j"'J.+!<,I% .GI;

J g l p dlLl

J!4 L - C C "&Ji-"u&-dl 9 11-i.

u+ G;?J I

ad;,I

&I

Jf LL+Y 1+.sJJi _i;L $kJ .J g l J l C i j.'%2J?;il

I-ig, .b ++ J..

~ L i t l~l W ' j l

+Herrneneia .JUl*

JS44&1

u W l J>$I

~ r p

di

"&JL' LLS c;U

4 4 is% cL&Jl i3WI31 4 a ; b Ion ~ 'j3i"iJJL J Sj .j.cg-3 ~ p&p

-%dl3

'a;L $ 3 2 +J cUj, j3iJ .L&

&J .!hJk r U l

A

LG

&IJI

gf d,+ LC$1

#I L+IJ!

rL-tll&&

&3s

? ;

&i2 .++I

oddlL..L - L +

~ k l -i j j . + i l l o h L.2 $1

+3 +J>L jk-

++lJ$1 JL>+

, i

jkZj

2 .;

;* . ~ + l , A l

L +

U JUI

ji

u

a i yawl ?JSC+ u>yl LLG J+Zddlo h

e>

e l& ;

CSW

6 GF Y

+>I

#\& djJi JlLa$

U l

& ~ \ ~ & - u - J u I ~ 32Y . I- ~ ~ 4 ;;ul ji j Ui L& ji 9 M ,I J b Y I 4WI 419 Jj ks ~ iidji3 i ',+kg Y? ju 2 h 1 '1 . i j k l lm;Ul;p

uJ dUl +I-. i! &lp+&I

j!

j'L) &i+dl

rs21

&UI

JS

'hill

Ju 31 &I C S L WL-.L ++I

- 6.k _

c! 5 +*(-

L+.L

.-r)

.

y-i +UI

. + & - I i+l$I

&.IJ;'*I+!+&

5

+L -. djlr 61

, u ' k u

9 3 >qlG j L 9

I1'+L1'

j7s 5

$3 .&Jl

24 1; +&+I jl '6 , 9 A3L +fl1'+'' ~ l ; p+ U +Jl Jd-I >-

/

UL~

+iJC! .i Y

JrjiJ71:

a

~

~rb U 1 ~ :i+ La *c9

h&$j

.*'$

9 Y! &Y\

YJL i + ~ A l I j & Y j

jwl CqJ1

L - - 3 + Y It+i 33 ,*

,

J>$I j! .+@I hill i r ljjr ed; =&I

&I

JID.Jl ;p 6iei;U +

. . iiip ~ 2 Ui

jI

C

ddsJl - @ b j

:pj2l JljJ13 .JgI+

+,J L ;&I3

>+y

' G 632 ji

j.3

.?, J~+I L.+ i,, +b3 LLV d k /&I 9

&-j i d ,

'

c d i

"+A1 *ill1' ji d i ."L&dI F.+

4 '441 d

l

ji cil-: Y

rrJi

i ~ b;Ibpl' !

.&--

ji

4

~ + ~ d ~ ~ & ~ d i p b ' ~ ~ d ~ j i ;+I>

21 &J

'ck;JrllirGS + 'i

+irljJ! 0

I

jA ..@-3;J

t 2i . ;I 04 ~ JcFz L- d- ~ - ~ ~ L I ~ * ~ E ~ ~ + Y ( I

Palmer,R.E. Hesmeneutics.Northwestern University Press, (;;) 1969.pp.18,19

Ad .(! $JtA&& J L > l i;KJ) JJYl 4 1pJ)'eci;',i 'el+-' 3iL

+

&J 1;.)43L11 c

jC

~"15 '

2 AK ki 2 '(4 ;+I+ +Y13 J ~ L + ~ U ~ ~ ~ T , - L ~ - + + ~ - L

I d d SJI L >+

+A)i.u yj SJiJJ Li.3 'ZJ1

.FIJI2

1-i.

= .,dl c;K

&J

2 L'GJ p IS. ~ L ~ .(&U I

uJ.'&a> 3iJ

d! i;rc

e+3

Ji I$; ;

~?&I I

4 ja \i! .&;dl

$L~ ai

I+

-

& IS. ,&I

I L jJ ~ ~ Z /YL LI

jl +I

-

ail .+-TTF$

Lgkon ,&

b

2 TTF+

L &* 5

L"&'

'I J+I'

b3'U&c

&K-

J3i

J*

ogA+-

.4Lkg

dg Peri herrneneias

I L~ $ 2 A Enunciation

'&&II 2" dLJj

. " j-1''

"Jl>!''dL &&I

2 '(A3iJ s ) 4 Jgfll P g YJ! ~ -41 +>I ~ A .'b L~i UoI g I+ ~+$41 j && 2 1 y-i! >A\ &! 15-g! ukJl 31 &I

jf

k,kJI 9 ,&I

1%

&I!;

.?&

L G>

j+

'AJ *UJ ~ .b +> 2 b ~ 'G b k9- i j 9 3i + zJ+ 3b& Ji &iJ& +I3 + b J IJ+ 'Li>Al+j45;!~9&~-~1~cS4;U3X;;ja

*3 Enunciation

(&J!Al)

al>wli;>L j .& j k l G

+

+-L G

GI:dl>+~++=

9 ,

+j

~.il&l>!

",l>YI' $

,! "j%YINJ

j k l L kl;;u yj @-

4 ~ % Y ILi $ &I .L+I PGYI j, JY LY I

:J!2S;JJ + L Y

I

awl +>I

YP 2 A3r

- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ; r i k u j l j~ + i, i ~

ih;L.&L;;I&

.i. p 3

suer 'k 3~

&I;ilis~I+U&ii~ j 4L ~>L..+i! -*LI L& s3 && 14.1 ji hi'% j i &' -I

f!

.+Y13

MI

vI&I j .$3

91 j .&l

& L Y I f i & J d ~#lils j i

is&iuull o L W

d&

~p-~~ilisll!$ci!&.~Jt.;l~i?jJ-~ JLJ-I dJiS !

f *i

2 &&I

9

3 6 - i,Cp i.LLJI

j . $ J ~ ~ J i . ~ ~ - - 4 % j i d r Y ~ & U i -. ; I .~ J--" t j J

2 ++

1&3L

,+I

&,a!'&-i

~14411 .'LA

-

L

u 3I

&

'ad&- 'Id3Id h i,j& &i ,

*

.jjJ_Lj; *i j+- 3 u

I

d p b LL & 'I

L-

4gjL

I@

.L+Y

U

j

i

b

:hl:J+

L Y-i*LI .i+

ji &I3

Object .

kk; JA

"i+dI1+ Y Object

:Wji j+- lib

L,04!

~ g*hli ! rlj C

0S3Lhr-i +;T 9 .&Ii+j 4 i i

' c

J.5 I., ,> j - 7 6~2 g*ll *dl3 I.

-j i t + p

.ljsul

~ 4L 3 +~i; i ',aY\ -2 - ; $ 1

t + q L 1 3Mcrhod &I

rJI

I

I

I

9+L;% $ + -I

y3

Jpfll

;P i * j l

p:

P

O+

31&-*lj

L+!( Dierrneneusen

~7);

J5

ji *5&ji '~;r,-iPJI

~rr4; &gFu

I

./I

;p

Ppro Nobis "L&!

JS ji 4 ' :'uN 9. i + L l +

41 "*

&J3i

j .c&-

+*PL4+-

++

ji j .4+ x +I &I J>$Ij~ .(! ~i p 'a S ~ p.i41 Iy ~bi L Y

+bi p

~ Y I A2I

8 Y

OL

_;-I1

.+L

bi J>+

bi

:u&~ l i V M

2 & bi 4

$I

--

b+-

~ i i y++I

Hermeneutical Circle ''i=L3iril ;jl-clll'

.&;I

PJI'pLli;:

&$I 2 6 - 27 '

391L,QI

~ I ~ ULY-. I . LA&

.;PI+J

~

j

4-

- b~ s ~ i i A - J J

C

d

2 ;+-._sY I ,L+

~ 4 . 4 & jfsbarlL

~ I ~ L L

. d 1 ( - L h g I 5 h i

U

2: J +>$I i

b& ;+I> . &&I

43?

4 +I>VIp ;Ss ~i!,&I

U

& &I d-k ji ;*,4i 4 +&

-L

+jiu&Ul

-3

+LC

+-

i>kO; t l l @I3 i+WII L j Ckip 31 .&I

.-g;$1

>! .-+j f r-u

@I t

b L 3

'~3*~cr4A ALdlp 1 I L - &L

"";ill

&L9U W l

$;it

/&l+I

.The Hermeneutical problem I1+b+&1

; , Y /dl

%

U 1 8 '8

l +bj *I3

LoS Pychologism "L-J&1

kc;JI"

>! al~;,Y

1

kc91Lc,+d L+ &-&dl j y i Ajf+ p s kJW1 k c 4>Ls;?LISydg) +$&I

,+ Jj

61jajL

9i @I

>A 9

p

3 6 - j\jlr&YI

@>+

k, i r ; i l ~ s~93.1 J G 1 % ! d lL >,,.+

p U +MI JGldJ l i l p kS "i;-ldIu L. k. Y l

& J3b3. ipUl J 3 4 + b &dl441 a\ - 21 - b3+\, C, UT, 2 & ji 4 & 2 b L * i

>+-J& +O I , ~ Y I

b~

JS qJI ' 4 1 3 jJWl Jaw! ~ ; ,LL) a j .IkL GP~ tip ) &@

R.Bultman jL&d 3 g J &\ll j p w l JgL- &I v

~ j I" JJ+Y~

- -

elldl

~

j

i

j

;

3 es+ j

'

&Is.

iltll ji

J&yI dLJ j I Jj j U 3Demythologizing . &dl

bJ@ "JJ+~I euI t>" 2 'ay. $-Y J, GLC!$-*i yt; ' b ;A ~

'ap%!l&

a,\, ~

s

g

~

+

-

~

~

i

~

%

+

~

lbid., p.28 (.*)

:

+

~

2

11-+~11

I+& ji

GI*

a3

u > ~;kLi ~

A

idp- ji 2 ,+-+ji &i .ll$dll 2 GI+ p k $1 2 d& 9,$3 Up9 b ~UI'JLYI 14ji + . - $ L""'

L~&A

G

G$

M

++YI 1-

;r.:I>>

IAji

Nr+'

j ~ 9 u1 > ~ k i

I*+ ji Y

L

~

I

2~

'

G

+

LA+I,~

ji 2 AU 4 y3 5 b+ii3 b,l+

3i ~ +a&+ b

ji

ij. . f f l ~ l ji3L L ~ F I ~ ~

i3j;j.

J

'IJU+jJ'kd .&&-dl

u 4&ll

pWi I

Lgr

9~

+

'

. IWorld ~ View ~

-'L~

2+

j.9&~J3

Lgr d+- Yi3 d l L-i.b L b 3 ;+I &->UI d l

.

L+i L a

&.+ j .

Ibid., 29-30 (s)

Ibid., 30. (*)

+- JMI

JS - (iAj~lj>j~l)) J.L )L: p j!

&!

+b

Z

&u

'I&-$!"

+-j

A-ah) +I

27%

3 3 &-jul&&I

jJb JS 4 3 iaj j I+I

U U .(Lapx3 + l -+-,o j 3'I>2 j jULJ&j L & b pYb i " U y !qlpfl!'' 2 wb 21c&13 &! i (#+

k+i WI -\r;

++!

Laj+

&+r'+&

d!3>

+j jJ

&idyl ~

-

~

+d&-j

3+

3

3 ( G - j L +j

l

~

l

x

&

A

#

JpIp ".Lj&~l &.+

~ 3 $' I' 3 \;I3

p2

i&.iy13e$l

2 bib + ~J-cyl - J.~"JL- jU

l

0 j - d

4IJ3! 3i

b

&

ZUI >L+

*G+

9~~

441 $Y dl Jly Lei !

J

b

+,

L9+3

Y 1 4 &be&\

rlii p i?_b+&

L U3 lalL+l

jY

?

ig-$13LLL

--,UI

J,,

VU @I

J b YI

,yHermeneutics " L & L p & l " jK l i p .uLG-l,

dgPfJ d

I' '3p '>I *I l1&+4 jK l i b .& 2 1&&.!I r-l

L iid;s .i,c;jl

+

L3 JI2i

5 ili>l i j ilikUl 4t j N I b l g l rL+ ++ +

>! +&I i i i Lss --&I "+Iu

1 . L+

--#I

..

'JS *G,'+I'

,i

Lii ' d mL, a p N I J&

. b ~ r-'/+Ii

&&Exegesis

l lj.

w L ; a

.3LAl

&I

1 b . &I J

2 s..zG &-#I

J..+L, ~

Y J+J I

lj.

+ kj

L1 31 , r i J I k l y

d ; J l .

.9

2 2 1 L-K

.+A1

cJLdl

3LL- jf>! d d l

$2 Y&+)'I J% 3

ji3k c J U l

u; ; d l 3L- j L L+->

.ll+)'l

~ 3~2 i c " 3 4 J 1 SL-"

>+ +>;

391sg 3 d

wJ+,jI& U l +b2-

$ L+

a&@%i+&iYYl$

1

1 . L &>

9

&& ,jL)'l

b y t p lJkrjl

' > ~ ~ I + j i ~ ! + ~j ~i t ~ b \ a'

M l

&-& d . L h &' I!

JbJl

&lJd

~ ~ j +

t -

+H;YI bi 2 &>we +GI41 B , j~>I cY 9e i $&&Jb hut &I> G J l p J!j>+J b j t 2 JaJlp~ AJ+ 31

'W

4 &J'J

;J>>

ji L13 4 ' 1 + d l ~ l & -hOi JI

i;U jjJ Demythologizing

2 +,+d' l

grb

'+JJlr'Y~

&jb +&+I .lp+Is

+ !;I

,v>:j"

j$l j U >/N, Y

Cj+ I OL

++I +I

*ki .I&Q

2)" 4 1 &j e +&I

j K LLs L+

J&

,d

".,+ e

+sj&icP #i

&

ji +I

a&- Jdy -- .. >&I

J&d

4+1

e l is+-4

I

&i

. - -I.C Y . I a&I3,J

Lj291U+ JAI~ W~ IL y

'i+.&-i

*hIA !:;-l' $ jj

&J;G

21LLJd+j

O

1

L&b*p"

+;t_+

I

IJ2!3

aLir;jl

pjl +I

I

I &I>+I,

~

~

d~

C.

u219

&dl uL-SJI

L,c & W I k;UI P UWI2 +I plj1. j ;I&, 'pa";Y d.Pf l ? '&-9, &Lll+

+a

J! i > q l 4 llL++&ll'

4 '&Ju

j! Jjdl

~

U

+ ;5 ~-dl JLs

GPt,

*

LCUI . + ' L

i+

I

- &,Ul j+&,

+UI 4

j

J

&L -i

& i.i

F

CX-

r " 4 +buj

Cg3 .+W

jj,Al

'L+*&IH

;+,cd+l

&I

J!L-~x J& *i TJ&

4 J -

t+Id

"&dl UWI

Ll '&&I

p.d'.-$ L r l y

u! w2W+i3)1

41 ~JLG J+

4iWI L I ~ G4! I ~+4-;"igl1

#I)

j ,&I,

p i p s &d"MI l 'LC (Li+l .*rlgi

. ji

cij i

I

67 ' -2 'LA

+

&L;)'I iL+J

.+-&+&+-

+iJ35&JO

CPr +2 3 .+-jUI +I 4 . e+ b ~ ; i j i i . & l p l W # l J e W l + l JC

d L+WI r+lj >i LI,*ll

-

9&-jUI

. j i > ~ l

~JJI h

*I

> +3 LI,*lI

'Mi 9+&I / L A Y 1 >I +-31+I +Wl

r L

e lj . eJ kIl

&*--(UF

i;i-+ j

t+p

t+y .&+I

f+~

2 - L&U> - &i

+;r.

y%+lktll rj.ul tgJc Lj -.

2 jJUl bi . j>j Y I

&- L ~ J 0% >i ~3&I

: d+

LdU>

Explanation " 4 1 ", Understanding

+p.LJI+-

d y -L ;,1-

aLI,*ll

lp+y

P; 1-

.is1a!&

r+I

;r."Ip+p "dfj"Ig;! Causal : "+I1'

Li .j L . ' $ I

'@I'

+WI 3

&,

.c

~

&Ui ~

&-.. ~

.&AL&

&13>l J%

p l l $1

~ p

;r.

&Ull>#

"dY-'l

i u l diCi j l dJJI-

~

. ; iJ! G L Y I

b+9 A--( L'I~IAI

(.) +Llkl:.Ji.f-L..ij &K)

ji+

''41" -

~ l

>

~

jl

;r.'

:"Jrl*ll

i

i

ak LLI ;r. .)

~

~

. .

~

5-e'y, &Js;lp&l

'al -J+vl &I

U

b QUI2

J!Martin Heidegger

(1889- 1976)

LJ+& .. LIp l,.,r*iJ ~E.Husser1J+

',jLYl3r r ~ l N<M

Lyr!

& L+WI2 jLy

C

&ib~~I#.

r*d~

-9

;dlh+dl Being and Time

&, I ,

oiljy

0$

+#I

(1927) k ~ d 1 3

,5 , .

Hans-Georg l'pl~b ~ J >bl' MJp.i3Al L+UI"fl+"

+

~Gadamer(1900-?)

2 +Is-.) t i r ~ &bj+Jl I & b e & \ 2+ ' Jar 3!(i;uXII JLes\ll

j>I " jL.213 -.-JIM

j .&,ad&"L++3/gll

&->L

-3

+LS

>+-I1

J3i~ill+ LL

-

+-

p +I+

'Z+3

J! + ~ > x i

&a

r b p y i c ~ -A-J i '&--+L 2 $1

p" ~

9 "&I3

LZ&-lu

lui d 3 ld p MI & 9 3 .>Ju!

Ikb&/gll

r*~YI&&IL;,L+~-;"_~~U

j.I.j&-3~JUa~

4.l;

abed j I & .JLJI I L 2 flG L C ! , i b b e 4 E Ja? ~

J1-> i z*p Jj B G Y 4 Jlp b & - 3 U ~

Effective Historical con- "$1 &I

J% JJpll ~ l j l l

J! L C ~ YJl!+f.isdl~

k+ Jrk

;+k;~kbypAt+

~ 43 1 &"410 3 + L

j .a f l 4 b +Wl&l+b*&L

L_9JJl+ d l

&$\"r#

+-JUl

.&

+I

2

Sciousness

3%->IF

2 &A>

plaG

eb

s j l

! "UI 94

IS& j i J!/l~l>Y LUl #-3

. W I JX;

&&I

>-De L'interpretation (1965) bC;S 2 l&b+&J kP Paul Ricoer J4-J J2 &irjpll

>! .I"Y-

G h WeZglL 3i

;*.L -

+ ..

>

j4-jJ_kr!

P; L;&

&i

.Li &&I jp-21 ULWI

pk +3i19 &I

>! j

.

2, j l

~ ~ S Y4 I ho&j

&$I

~

o ,b

+u

~

ji &.u' .A2 3 ~ ..,)cr; ; 9

'A$ L;&

UiQ2 L&b*JI

3i j.M~ &I

> j pUl &I

j_S?* .lhi'+-&I

.L+

uA13@I

.&jyJ3

PJI

'JkJ.1

JS

J&&

$A135

& 2 1 i jr>l

bf .&I

'J?JIUIpEci j l l J S I ~ ~ I

WI

+I

2j .L&beZglI j .yljp

e

4& 291

4ks4! Exegesis

cSJ&l +I

ILL .&I

3i p U l d4;XI~

$ 1&I;'

t+y

,+~i jh-*i3L+

U ~ i i -&I

& > b y 1 : > d l jy>l

j 9 y 1 lai Equivocal &I

2 jy>I

+

3

-IJ>

k-;UI jy>I3

2)

L k l j

VOC;II

3b%

&

@*+Jell Jk ifir GUI lai9 ? 4 ~ > 1

2U.l dl;

2 Lg-5 '(;iJY>) GJl> Y &-e

;LLAI

:&I

wi 3 3

2,jy .;>dl

i%

I

-

9:

c

+ >.;I

+I+&

J~E

&- /+I oh 3;0 LA+ &J '+LYI

i&j <J

2 L&+&13

iSjJl&I

+.1I

&Lj. ji @+&I

.+i 2.bL

i2 LUI +I

d&l

;clV> 4

LIYAl

u Y j > J r S G Y l ' >- & +- j u + l & s j i ~

$ - u Q J Y l .i - Litll rYYl $ r&- j U l $ ' u L ~ " L& si 42 $ .pllil~ Ji&.&I ?\$I LSU j +d ;Lc ~j w&IJ ~u'J 2141 L+ CLG

J. ;

jl r " ~ J + l ' > k S b U i j j i +.J- i LQJl

.&Lib rLDJi L++-

Iconoclasm . 'jtiii'l

j - p +-dl1

JjGJ: .GLDAJ k b k 1jci

p ji! ++J&I L&+&l

I

j2L;JYI

l& ; I ! He]-niencutics of Suspicion " u L ; j Y I

Hermeneutics, pp. 33-45. L J W l &ad\

(o)

Literal Meaning >+I Allegorical (metaphorical ( J J L j Y I ) d i > l

&I

-

&I

-

Meaning) Anagogic (Spiritual Mean- (&>>I) &UI &I

-

ing) Tropological (Moral) &I

&I

-

9>W13 I

6

'Literal 4 1Ge

LdJl

2 II

A+\

rl$Yl

9

j~k M W ~('I

di Spiritual (+3jl dYIJI p d U I S ,j&yb rl lif i . (+..A!L I > l S DL &L+ &..sji j % Y I d p L 1 3 r 24-1&I : 2 ZWI 3L&.l 6

9iAnagogical &GI &;L-Jl+ ++>I i l Y *I1 + I ~ & $ ~ + I & J ~ ~ ~ I ' ~ J L ~ L ! ~ P ~ ~ irW\r, s,ib

r+-

klkijl

4 -3>\

. +?J\J Y l l l 9L,&i3+L ,& Y

J;Z Gig Chladenius (17 10-1759) "&+-3W1' j

U

.

&

;

~

l

~

&

~

-

&

4 9 1 .& 41 *pk. ji j ,a31UL i 3b lip . uq 3i jJlLIl Aji &I icl J 2 ik i j j j i 9j J j I L j&& d i ~ i + ~ & C ~ ~ -& ~ - ~13;1~iip:p

& 'J

+I

+ *

AJ3i &I.+ Y iFi PiUu3' 6

~

3

a L LL13

c

'tkjjsj W

G3+

-

& d l JJI*-JI jL$+ J j

liUg431*;3

' ; I I I k4@4 i.3Jsi31oh 2 ,.L-.+A .Q ~~+J++WI~LL~~~~~~Z.JIJI~LI+~ + +L JN trd3. JL: L 2 Conversational Standards . & * Jt\ 2 1 C

'+J

1

1

'o+Jll1

~

: +..dl

9 2Jpll 6

L,+

>

~

~

&L 'ICi@I

+j;! .

lU Js$ Gy

r&

jbu jCilj

I

ji /+i j;Y

LO

Lr

P I ~ .U

9

.& L

;;O,L,dl I*

+&I - - U I

eLII $3 C$3

c

+U & d+-

d i >4 di! 2. (3j

)

I1

cf -'!+I -'L%,+I"

:

&I1

2

4

Gy

44

- G>L2 -

&i

b 21

;+- .. Y di

31 Z>lxll ,&b

Earle,W.J.,Introduction to Philosophy ,McGraw- (* )

wordlsentence

~i-Alk&~.-&+~/-L&!lyisa(~)

:meaning vs. speaker's meaning

Ibid., p.168. (el

&" W'

The Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy, Cambridge Univer- (*) sity Press, 1996,p.716.

39': >b>

3 3

i*

<

CI

3 &&I

. 4 k & , 6 ~ $- v . d- $ $6 j 1 +J3 d

CI

-y9

hi*

L&Jly

'+ e$ , '+& 3 9

.+A . , L&

l b ji ki*

b,;

J%-

&&

+8 .+l$yl

v .+a>

~ u j

LO-&

L

1

C

~

p

a U I & L J I LU .&b A~i

2 8'ib3G-A

b

JWI b

*I

t

j .&gir31

.+ b y &LA iib!&LG p L:+

4k9f.I +LA%

dg

i-~ &td ; i 4 e = ) 1 J-S;C & .&I >I

+ill

il,Ll>!

j,+l

J+J

&.&)

~ji;s.."$I." * _ b & d le 3 &\ +I &dl

i+l Li .(a+ I+ &.!&IJ ij

iL+1

$41 L@+

l Hermeneutical ~ circle

6 - b

~ j . l w

Jl;s;j CU e2

ji +I~bd91 J\ 2 I&!;

I;F +IJ

6.>I

~g.

+&I2 I; Jj

,&-

: &!& &

L $3 +-ZI]I +l+llbLrl qLr +jill

"&LJ'L;II ."+lJJIu f+

# .&JiAl

I

& ... J.6 &&I . b 2 d 3 +I &-I2 " 41i e l U l p

I

+ A \ ;I>YL

i;ldl&G

ji~ '+';b 2 3 JLll

3!q L - b U l L -J >.U \Z W l L3.;>+I I&& J.6 p l sU13 OL L$& +dill +I w Gi G U I Ji$YI ;p AJi cJ.- &L+ &I Y I;; Ji b L L.L+

bJg+U I g L i & JU ~ I b i 2

2+

(=&a

!

cI

& L + - ~ I I ~ - - ~ . ~ ~ ~ J I ~ ~ Y I L +j& >2

&-

$31 241J r U l I j P JX;j. b L 3 &,I 3 '4j l r i& ji! +I . e l j i g OL )Y I L+L JL &J L);Ys;j 5 "i jlJJI" o h Y! &+ Y 1J5

r+\j

"&gUl i i l ~l& "

,

''&iL;Ili213"(=>-A

3" I

'

: (iiJJl'6

ji ?I31

j! Paradox

3

'ii,L" 3i)&LA

. ~ $ ~ i ~ , j i j l ~d y l r i r l 3 Y l ~ & I $ 3 I ~ , j I

i g ; L ~ ~ l ~ ~ l ~ ~ . Y J lj!UL!> ~ o L z . ~ r ~

lib ! .13i

L-

*h

I

i

Y

>!&I

.+$31j.l ;1

++dl

iP,

ji

Y Li & j - Y l

,$

LY i dJU ?Yl jlS

I

#%+,.aJ

#g? gG

;kId.+.L.>i j~LLj ‘~>-+~F zl +12 213 - L L 1'i;r(i5~' L J b ji # pY I +, L! .@I

p d L .*L

~ I ~ $31 Y pghi I ~ihh;LI 2 L13& ' ;kl

jnJ

igr

.PIA++

++

&4J3 tl-; oL,uI 2 3 . ( ' ) i i ~ !

2 ;&I

learning Paradox

"

CL;l

yi9++I Jkjd!;ouy JH yL+

Zii,l1

Y

dlfib U

$ i J .A j i L & & ~ j s l b y l & l t t ; & Y !I*;+&+

LSli!LiIji3

t~biiiC3_111Le

jY&-L&+Y

c;;K Meno

"a*"

a J 3 L jAnarnnesis %I jlS

d 3 L 2 l + l L l dj ZG-YL)

z,u,

"I$..kl' +I!.

j.(&I

C

+.

l

.

*i iJ3Lxll oh P

o~

P

lj3

+dl J&c

c

bl+~$k~.i-;ir;i+Likj&p&++&2Y I

+s

+l+l

jo

-31

LYl-4;

e+e

- 3

i+l

>/b

J3L-

p d!;

> JL.2

J+

+

Earle,W.J., Introduction to Philosophy, p.55.

(.;)

J.JUl~lS+;"11

"pi

+b*%

+4141

_ii j(~; di

>+

p i@I &I$

.UI &

j .u

Funk, Robert W., eds., History and Hermeneutic., Journal of ( e ) Theology and the Church* series,Vol. IV., New York: Harper, 1967., pp. 107-21.

2 +$&I

LjJI? + U I LLL '. +j JlGJe

Jq @+4&l> 4 A b j j p

++ il .+-J~

LL ig;i ~ r lL++~AI , 3!

I

'+Ul 'l+L>%ll

$3

> J&

&--

iJ'jrW13iUCY~3iirp%I~-~-

J l r j i3.j

.j%yCrl, &_CJ J+ dl

1 I!;

41)

3i3Ql 3 -. &

- +I

Adl

jj

ll+L**ll

i ~ + U j , p > ~ l + ~ J + A ~ ~ L + + & l

+&us3'&I

j&d3 iQl&

joy L2!%+

L++J-glli+

di

9

..

> Dialogical '+Jlr"

u *

dl

:

I1

.LWI L++igll

&

ck&-i

Richard E. Palrner,Hermeneutics,pp.91-94. (it)

*

JUlI L JdiJ

$1 d

~+I > L~

291&-J ~ k j p lj YI+\'~ Ci-Ui +Js-! ''d+J.l & l j > M I ip,L++Al ieg. ji d'L,*i .&LJ @I @&&! ; , j .'&->MI @I 2 >+ j .>IpYI l i a 9

wL

&jUI j j U J+

jc +I

jI +JI jGl;b

&

dl oGYIji Y! 5 GbjY &I+ +ji & &>UI L b ! $5 L&be&l j++I U ip,@I + 3 j a-9dl+ 2 dr3 .J2'Ul ++ j i& tJllj 2 +LA% "7, dl +I & l j j\j ~ p LL+>L- Lglj2 dFV& wj &.!I & +L 41' +i J! W L siq &.!b3 'pg.ill41Z+jU! IF(C5 ,+9I

LS+ Asbl "12

JS

jDre-Understanding '',+A\

o&L 2 ,el3 '+b&

i+

++!dl .@I

,Li L, .j%>! + ,I

us*

I-ia

LJ,3t;"

y l+l2 I" $1

l

: LMl

>

ibjJJl

9

"jJrJi 'r&Y\l1

J+

& Imperium in Imperio (

4;)

2x1 &yL,o Kk

U l &I>

(Ij*

&*\>rw~'+yj ..'+I('

y "@I'

yj

P

~ - l xul - 4 ~ l l g , l l

y

11&~~J.il

eUI A&!

i~ 9 +,I

+

2 9 1 +lji

43 W.Dilthey (1833-1911 ) ' d U r

Geistes\vissens- -9>I J.5 ;j;W

L , 9!, &

r+L+Y

r&lll

I r&lJ

V u i >i d ! #

&p9

&;~l

2

yJ LLi ++&l

i & . , + 'i.LIjJI I

Z;

i U l dl+

*I1

2

>I &I

Chaften

t3Y

+0 ~1 4 OL 1 LU +Iy

I a-

&+

.qd3i+ ! i ~ i > i k > - ~ . k y l j

Jy

+.ui

&L\>3

I+

I w J l

3

K

.j L , u g

& ZU;: 9 r"l

. kppr

C;!

v-+-ill <LYI

j+ll&

tlH

r. L+IJIJI

41Ji ' l i j l,&+bJI Lgi%.I

b ~ *3 3 M I Ji+UI

j&

ll*

ji! >L3,JI

i

3

,&Uj

d-3

- ,,

+L ~ cgdg J _c+ GI i+L. . 3Ls)'l _;c h i y ;

;r" L - 4"3

>+

+ +;GI

,jid , d I ?

j " 3

Glpr1 j+ ji

-dUI

kc&l -S;1+L+

I+

-@ ii

2 &ibJIIJI

>+;.; a & c

P

d l ;

j$l

hiJl

2 1-

V ~ P J J& I jU

+L j 3 gA> L+~&.JI~

Ij3gG3,c;Ui 4 +kj,JWI L J d l 3 ;"Ie J W -@ IL;i $IS .&3i-JI 4 ,rbX?Li u +.!@I ;i.$

-

J~

! : $ 2 ~ - ~ j ? & & j ? J ~ c ~ ! d ~ , 4

qkll

tw-;ii

L+

s&YI

3 J3b JA . sj i

+;p iGl ikljJl

P W Iikk; d3k c;G +-JISj~

.($8)jL;)II

t l j d @I

&$\3

&I

,+I31 GUY\

r+ L3-j LLI Jy ++ &-+

2 -->L+

L &oj bL&

I

iP $1 ;ILI

-

'j U r ' ykiA

L . b L y l p jp ipb p&y$

u

-

ids k9-j

ie l f'%-CS UId iKA4

bJL'Lst

'

0

b

ah-

LA=

ck;p

U

- :>

I .+LyI

-91;o -.

6

Introspection " j L Y l " 3% j4 &"&C=l> 3 9 j~ p6k; ji LJ & o * z 3 JSC; j .

eJUI

. l l u i

L J s j "+LJLM+ &$I LUi b L l ;clL-t.p ;&I

3 k j .+dl %@I

jLjyl ~

g )

~ Y j d . 1 2L& &dl3

j 4 i & i ~ j ~ U i L $ & + l + Y l ~.Y. $ l > Y

?~+~c il_~.b ~ ;$I-+ ,s i+ J j4 w $ LII&I~(

I

'

I

L& e-

& &Ij .

w$ijbjl+! l++i

6

ijii;ll

Y $1 L > ~ Yo I L ++

. j. ~ 4+1+&'>u

u W ~ J I $ ~ ~ J & U I

j Y! ~ g ~,+ g .Ys 'iphj .'L2L Y ]

&p&d i'>flA1"

'alJ13 &I

@

JY

+Y &dl ; d l

j

"p&> l" 'Yp

p Lsbsn ;+I

JS I;3 .&I3

p y l

j e i ~ ~ L a l l . ~ Y *ir4L-J>~Li ~ I h ~ i

Causality- +I . .

&iP I JLSC;S!

-+I

6-

&J

P

&+

l o b Naturalistic +MI - eL-

ji J!&LJ> u i .j L W j+~j

&I

4J

2

z+ >J

$1-

+

i j r ~ . ~ (a+2, j l

+$

,

*LI

;ic/J13

Oriented

& g l iC_LI ~ g r

;+Ij

2 jLjp +IJI j;l Y Jpi a

ab~+ h J

'irlJy13

a Y + +& ji &IJJ .>?I &I -I J J 11&&13;iJI &" 2 9aLjy1 ~ g Sr r 1" pU- 2 ;>+I . ~ Y + i l l 2 ~+jlrjlp Y ~

-a>?

#

'+LjY

t;L;+

irY+

Igr! .iL;LI 2 i .Igr-li ;*I

h

#

?

&.qI-I,>

"+-3JI

r&l'

PU

+&

7 I

.CLi +dl c+l*-

L

J3a "-4" CL;qJ CFi--. b 3 -i N&~u

aY+

3y+ eJL;II aLIJ*lI

j&- j!

I

lib

&=ji +W>

-i-S%

ji Gcistes~vissenscli~iften

3ciieJl o h .+1-;yl

pl&l

& L L a&- jig 'Lg;l; LiWI ;+I & Wlj 'Power 'i+Il1 3 9-4 Meaning

tpx L J U d,

4U>j K ~3 .aL+&Jl .wl C&J13

L&iYl

+LC;! Lii;t

&I

il,,

L+l j

d

L&ll+

a h !

ili*ll

U 4

3 L.+Lk" . - jkJ2UI

"A

Contingent (ZL)ZJLb ijaLLiS ++I

.

pW -.

Jy G.Vico

j lj

l

3

ep4+ I ' I1+-J-I

3 &-3 ~ + L i z 1 l+LlI

L+~/Li&~~p;jiLgl+Y

JJJlYl +LS j.+

9 A j L

'&A! &jldI3 4 4 1 & &I / C W I ciII ;i;Li~l+hU+I

'pl.;rl'+LI;+j++bp32 A+

&AI

+b '+IAl

J3

Cd;+Wl&&+jYl

+Gyl J3yl

. J U L X+I

+ ;I

2 3

+b &! ."A-~L-

a&+?J13

j L y l +Wl IL J! iWl>

Ihl;; , Y '&!dl

iJUI

,J! Introspection ' S U Y I ' @ #1- J2bl lJ% ; .bjp>&, ~ l J M lJb3

;+IjJ& I;!

&ql

a!&

4Y +dl

c;*W13L&iyI aLIJAIl& ji! 241 aLI,JJl ;ilL jalc+$I 2 & & jiJ3fPj+ j241 4ti! 5 dlJ>yl2 &k& A j31 q L y 1 I

f,

Facts

*bi .A;AI

++I

Cg,

'fLi31"3i abpJ1

> A 2 C j$3 "0

I$L.

.@!

3f +Id1

p j L W &&!I

aLIJAIljiJ3fPj4

i i&I

;+I

+

jwI jGLyI

jkYl

b&* $1 +jb 9 3 5 aGW1 l +I

3i

-LyI

I*

;&I

31 ;ilLyI

C&I

2 +Ul

i&ll

+!dl

3

+++I

4 LrJ.1 ,i

W14lj 4 ~

L+A.

sLI,AI> ++

;+tl

,gLdr J+- . q L Y I

;,j,A& r**i

4 4& 1j

LZ

Y &LA)!\

.j d d l

j

3 j,C1

,sL)CJI 2 & g;li

jJj

;I&\

2fl,

* Ij

ji L-...~$IJjk;li .+LAY

JL-~

Jb.I+.&

&I)

"2 j$l j! dJi

I

,.& Categories ' s Y + "

i-

ihr3'&Lpbr 9 d;*i ~id J i gi c(+L ;GIjc + k+ b /hJ&09

&d& b -.. ,jY+

&UI

&-+

+WI 2-+=pbr

&L+!I

Y .I,

+I*lI

i+I

$1

e3i~jL;p

ZAL 9&U13 jLy &MI

dJi+~'-l+,+gr-jI~lrJAy)=I

cvj r JALL ji ~;L;YI d ~ lj r Y! s

t&

~ L I ~ *y)=I U & LZ+&

J +MI~J..U ~Y illi~Qi 9~

~ Y! L+/pll2li3l I++ Y 6 i ~ l ~ ) ' I ~ 153: A 4 >!+Y!g ,~&WI j - , I JsL; il&I , & ;y L .&+I

u b+Lr;YI aLIJJJI 2 + - U l

b&W> bIA j Ul

u \ 3

i e Understanding . " p g k l l ' hLU

3!@I d\S

&-dlj p cr+I b'@l"

a L I J d l L+ d p -1

+L9Explanation "+I' W&13

&-\dly& b;jl! p!$dkl

Explain

'4' a! r&d

4

r2 . i U l al* ?I

~i 'kl2

Understand

& ;+-k-.,2

JY312i "JLUI"ffLl && ,AZ w L

4 1

5

L2 ,&W .

-1

; I L I , ~As .Lg;l.13!2

>+

I . ] 1, >

+-\dl i+l>

+2+l

kr$AI

21

, ,

& &-

j3k @

+ji ,@I

~-2 T y p e . "UI" 31

l*..&lr+>ipUillpgi~~ @

j l- U L.

Y! Individual "3-~+111'

JL 2

kh4, j+Il

'em bid +Lyl

&L.Jl

&I

1-

dkip j .4Li iilp J3G ji ' j U , -63U i+L;yl ,,

Reductionist Objectivity .i&LyI +I

.%I

$>I ++dl '"&LI" .%I

J;I

Hermeneutics, pp. 103-106. (1'

(*)(ZUI i pl Erlebnis ( 2

+Ui ilidl j U > yl;s

+"eLgl*jjl*ij.>>C~+Lj;r.Cd-&-+ 4 5

9+~t+ib3Lp,~"j-U.J~J..*l;l13+poil &+

9

j - -

A

dJiu: j U r J k 4 j k

++&I

.I&& jCS 2Z b 3

&-

Erlebnis i,lS3i cri; eljI AIJL)!\ ; r i~j r i . Lit) y%I ;&I"

+j f JSCE &dliL;L&+&!.I

J U Y I &i $ .";,"*&!.I

GWI

& Ausdruck

'p-'

ilid

~JS+

& & *gi"L5kl>" bi

.+J"IJpi.iG j3!&.-)p-:Y3$~3j+-Y 3fi1tJ*l& & .ui u 41 9 & &I3 jI 4 -. ;;Z 5 ";+I jc

I+.+ ci& '

31

Fl-

A+$ $1 dj ~ 5 7 - GJ >.4LU ;-

2~>p & ji! , d-.l

~

d

b$L ! 'bjL

.j L W +-Id!

o ' ul

Ibid., pp.107-111. (a)

d! ,1?

L

"

~

-

"

.*

ji

u

&i LrJj

I Objectif'ication "Gyl'

'ZAl)> L Y I P

+ ,'g I

,+

31 Y A L ~ S ~ S L UI CL~ - j kfd+

&ji;ll

dY d l bi .(i31j)'l

L*l LiLrlI i+

C L " ~ + ~ '

Intro- j % Y L

.j&Yl

&=,5> ji @

JS j ,+ LbL-yl

-G5 .GL;)'l aLIJ-III/Lk L.;zgj;zgj ji I

I

/b ( Y )

dj bj d+

2 +I

;+I

;+I

jc e* djlJ

&I

ZF j j Y zybL 2

+

I

~ L i J J - l.L&..iyl U

I

EX- "iL,LIdl+''

d j h

Y Spection

&'UIji &I3

Jv( 7 ) j!Lob9 c J b - 1JSli Y

&-+j J j ~u+dYl

oLlJdI>

.*Id1

jLyl2-

Yj

+j f iJs&& &-~

L

y

I

i]o L I J J I pressions of Lif Js ; .CJ;~&i Js s3 . \ + , j+-ji- a L I J >8 ;&A1 GY

jlr I I t

I

Ikl F

O$

j f L&.~yl a L I J f f l

: Ggilbj i;L;yI

a L I J J I JL?, il'h j

?&I jib; j f+ '@I ku ri3

J+

j L y I

oL+Jl

tl; t*s. - ~

cjJ+iidpr

i.LIJJI

n

.(*)&I: i+I idp j #I

.. -

L

4

L ~ J J

QI'

hj! ."+jJI u+Y

41~

,Zl.11i*u"&~&jJ&l~l

f+ &'L C L ' Y Il k &

L y l a L I J d l ZLLi j K l i i

r.,r~d~w~k-.Y~~dillJull

&IJJ\o+l

gi

;LJJJ U

l

pul&U>A-

.'L>L

lJ- d . - - - - 'L - 4 &Ld> u; G I ) d ij ,& L Y I i+C. +LLlI i j l +IJ3

~$31 (A

,ji _L'U

+Y,. ?Y

b+~J3

"++

+&I

3bi

(9 15fll~4~3

Jp'

j+

.+fgh!& i l l jLo;llg

d-ildj

+JJ

'L+c

+ill

.ylG~ e L~; 3 i l &i idea\ (JLGYl ( \ ) : &+

Jr XL.4 &2

ALP

jUI3

-1 p g Actions JUYI ( Y ) J L Y - I dw3 G d l ? + ~ i S ; l g ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ A b 3 - J $ j j Y ' & 3 U 1 . , i & d l ,l$l j aji j"&lSJl +d L.Q .ilyrs c.

*pc

*

qa J U

+'&

;+

b y u 1. ' p l

~Gyl,&'+~I&+&+iS;13 (Y)

.L,ig L-

bi a

Expressions of 'L2UI ;+I ;&&I

3 L&iLdl a l & l 2 3

gjil

y ~31; ~b

J!

'&@I ' L~

#

!

A L a3 ,LLi d g Lived Experience . i ) ale-'' ~

J! +&yIJ &w'S&ul

3$

u\

\L

-

jc

''el' a

kGv.

a";

'h-

9 1

& .-WI*ll

JhJ+vJ3!+--ii

--'$J

&W1 iip

i+l'

'"+l-+l

&4

J b Y I

> biz.

+bJ a t J.L ~ g ; ! . j i & ~ ~ p l ~ + & j l l i k ~ l ~ US1 5 ~ j+ 1

5

~ l ~ - & L p ) ~ ~ % y l & w &..-I2 Explain 4 L!" .iGIpA iw!+Gal 9

&..-I2 ' G I

Cgk, LajL;;;L-+fS;9 L.-a o +-

understand

$k!> +J

>

+dl + J l y a

L5AJ.l dJ&s

: ;&I

r ; ' ~'Understanding

&I

> iS;ell o

bkA!I

h jc

.'+djL&@idLjYlLaj

+I

~k;? &-ill JUJI 41.+I .&I

&-d+d,l

."d\pvl + .*dl

4 3j"'

.9

+ L ~ I A I ~ I g!l-

egiU- L.

8 s ..9$ 2 - ~ t - c%l

.Lg;li

LJ p-4 1 LJ JUl

'Erlebnis ZUI ;+I

j'L

a Histori-

l l & d ~ > ~ l l

T L l I 1b . 2 "&-JL-"

e

.

-

bL)!\ L&

21

IJlydU3

liL $23

cal Being .

~ & - ~ i j . ~ ' ~ f ( l i j . ~ t ; ~ & L . . b : . u l ~ l

kJb

$"eJI r,L-i'+..A

d

~

2

e+

.&Wl LL3Ul+,kJl& '"i-JUlll

iilA' i+ ,Lb! j &*C +I

"&!J'

cs&

d>

+ c- $UI Hermeneutical Circle '-->'L-Jl d Y 1 i;4llJU~ll 31 O J L ~ ~jj .+ L > % I ~ Y ui j $ l 2 "cl*'Jl" 3 '"*l*Yl" Y! -1 ias b +J32J.l M I 3 .'J5' d!i l L Y 4 #

c

l

,.L, $+I

.J(

- &-dUl d J i 9&Lj

e

.+13'J13

Y c . u CU ++I -1

rlirY13

' I"'

Meaning : "&I1'

JUI & JJGI dpyl-1JrWl iL, ap 'Jj j .L+l

u

3

JUI jl!JJGI3-1

F & u c 1 2 ~ ~ ~ j . + : + l ~j > + l

541~ L C L UjI @WI LG 0~3-4+- JUI&

.GJl 3 u++3

+2&I contextual. 'jh'>iji! d l A +\I iJ+ +ji L U ~;P . +Yr3 L;;?I J j Y *I1

di

.L;

+ y LU

e Jj j~+.

2 " '

LL,

d

J3

-

-

+j

~ ~JWI

3 +I ~

~L 5 A

i

&2.Ll/3bu -.

>T3

'9 *,i +I I

.!iU

,A ;&JI

+&I 4

i;g L i b ji kl;LC?

$9 ! '1 A-

j+X4ig

+

+=

3

I JJI

# -LJ

a J W I (+

I

d .ily

d + l 3

,+ j +

&lJ3

j+%i3 b g j+%y

&>UIj g l j+%ig

&$I

2I b .-I' i & sfi&I 21 .LA31 gi i+ GF &I> &pUill

>+3C)JX, Pre-S~ppositiunless +>>> XI1

J L z i l &iUj

+I

p

@J

+Y

++.+ '

j y l iljzY1 .

+ > I & ~ + I J ~ ~ ~ ~ : & $ ~ > & >

J ~ ihjJIt1 ! >i ULI $>.L id, j u ' L u l i+l1 & L&.yl IIJ

kg,

r+l)

''&+$"d-4ji ++I &-> eLj Jj &3cUlIb&a OY&

C

.

Y I it_: +

-

duJd\

&-Y d-ill +IJ

L+J!c;;YJI ! L U l i+_L4

Geisteswissens- +-,>I

i;LjY

ijz

+.y iI

aLIJ*U

& +W. CL chaften) .

GUI ;+I e-2t

j I &; 5 +..t

*-

~b.,ii>j

&

.+l+U .L ipUijl L-e

.LA L&b*Al

U+J

OH

>$&&.a

*hl

&I JUI hey&-% jl h33 e-+ LJU ++AI3 *I L+I j .&I > rl.;" rE j .

c+J!rJl

i

& iLt dl i Z ; , ' J I

d j Li! . b j 3 kj T c4;

clb j T +I

Lg-4; 2 c;U

kJ3.>!dI

-2u

I

#

'il&IU Jk,j t .-jilp.L@ J--u Objective Spirit

f,

et d

3 L 3

.&&A

+

$ L ~ & I +

IOUL&b

c+

j&

ji y$I' J

U ll i . ] u dgltqg &W3 3 1 j 4 1

qL

L ,3

&Is l&b*/eJI

~ J ~ J a d I d j - S ~ W a & i & ~ ~

+

b &i L a l d l04

+ b GJUI aliU L. d L. >%YI

jp b c;pj . e L L i J l a

+ ";pLbl1 ! & aldl a

d!+-dUI o h 2 Phenomenon

3~

+k

+4 LLI

~ $1

&I

~

i

l

~

j

+iJl&-

L

~

-

j

JL?~ 3!

dlJ.! 3 a $

.+I4!

-A

Y3

i +jqtdy .

~

~

Lc41-j;JjAI

Ljjj

3 +I

3

r

j

J$

& Jh?-j & 4 y I

e

'b3 &difJj .jUI*+l>~/ d

2-3

bJp9eL&->j GkLl+Al

*-I3

aulJ3yl o

rr"+ j+J'& I ,j ~ p

J g l kQj-7

#.

j

.db+JI

i b ~ ~ i p ir' L b

h

L L . 4

~ b + JLI~J

2 i+ ijr;S Y I

A ;+

l

j+r: +J=-Ij p 3 2 3 J.*- JS &-I3 j+JJ k C5L

y3iiilyraL~+-,r;..

&rl,

r'

&-;CU

"

b l .u*-I3 1-b@ 3 L -

p-

";pLbU L K

&-I>

Jj C;Li;;l !;I

kuL

9,

0

h

d3 .. ~ ..

Ji hI2

.;+A1&pllillawl

A +

*-

4 j &A

daJl~+lprj~+ti+iC&llL+j dlJ>yJ~ 3 L d~l & l + J !U j Y l > : &Yl &A+!

&i i3f" L&s 35j .4JL>1&$I

cSJ&l&+I

-9

~

I

I C

. ; ~ * . ~ j j . ~ - ~ ~ L jai >~ 'bH + &~l t l i

2 Lb '&-!IJ 2 d w cd-A! \h A J f~ 3 3 ji ~ A++Il i.LkJI dj i kg+ j ..$!'iis j

2iL-I

+'L

p-~ I J &$I I

LLIJ

@+y-

.

\+b ' k J1 % ' i . ~ r I' j&%G

+Ij,4b L! . i - ~ z l ~

'+~Ad.1":@j.'+-$-++is-i~~+p ?? + I j & J lOL j ,j+ J5 'I1..&- ji ~ - $ l &!I1

21..

.I1?

&&-

~ * U ~I;&1 I

j ,(& ~ l bj& j

!

; j.4*(GLu) I

Z W l 'y o

h

cp u Z w l l l "a-

-

& /llLl

Ih \

;JIj i ~ dJWYI I

JL% pl+ &dlA

•

o h J%

&*rJ'&I

j * o l l J > : ~ l a l L , U ~ ~ k ~ ; ~ J

21...jG)'l' J b Y I '&I i&\J I ~ Y'A I +-+I +I ~~ipuil~~~ cq- \ \ +>I jfi ( . . r W l j

8 3

~>prlljc+J1)

ib J a s d$ c%bi

;*II~

.IS>

+ 'I

~I+I

+-ipOilli+l+$Y 3 @I3

ji OLLI

lj J i l l

'4ibd,! efiJ1 d.k .3IJ,)'I

>

j;l

'L

+J &J

L~

21 :Jplli+j j ,V*JI j w !

&b dqj L&!l

-\7

31

Ad%

dL JL- JX; ?A+ pj .d$LA b

JlvVl

L+

L-J++l

&ji

>L 3iA+'$:

j4

f

r;j .& &

G

I

2 1

dl i k l

& 2 L+ ji 2

~

j" +L & j+ 4 3ir +

isclA

$24

,i ~ A,i i],*dl I kbU~ A@ ji s; ji bJe+tpil & ji F I J I jrj .LA

&I

+ .P

G

-9

i!

L.4

j

+>I

6-41;L .$jl

5

P

Gy&i j l syi! L.3-4 *3

3-4 *3

&dlILjF-++l

+j >I-

++Jd!

b

--4?ikr$is+lA+37&

JGfj-.&$

3UJ1

J+

3-4

'4j+-

j$L3

a .+9b& LrLr~tp~LrL '4>+ L is,&I S>~-JI L& ' W I q Q A

$&p>sir+-JIo+-$kJy++l

.+w $3

uI+I .

>l+L

+Wlj

012b

J!vej+jiLgjc~&iill;3re;i!~i& AIJ+ +Id! + d l &+i LL+ >f) $-iZU ~ed; 0-2 (&dl OL .&I & ! I3 i31J)!i3 +I3

c-

2JL(;?> e 3 .&UI cc*Ll Cogi- " ~ L I l& ' 'w3 I&&o> t!& d l ' ;lLP&'YI

j J+L J JLd'n 6 '-LJI (j& Jq;ill I..(C

Jjl iiLi.Yb GG

+(9 L;yI) to

b\ jT3 Cogitatum Qua Ccogitatum

. "+

J".'i.'.A ji @Ij-j L

5' d CUl Y lbkJl

> ~ J I

.L+i 41 2 Science of 'dJl

l+&

+'I

c & U I

o

h

-

o h c i l 5 !;I

aLc+J.l

+>I

cL-J+++I

$L ji b - i &I

L a dJ\L-i;j f

\7

@

& ~Consciousnes~ ."CUS9 &" 231

~ -..; i J ; * : d ~ ~ i i > ~ i + y ~ ~ ~ ~ >\ vl i j ; l ~ Phenomena l'pl+ll'' & '&

Opjects i.Lc&AIJ

' L + ~ ' Lii J+ iiWl jbll LLQ .LMJ &-&I & L " L + ~ " L&YJkJl L);ri? Subject b - 1 p i y U ; JS

-

f 4 l I - k p~ + J j j .db+$

. (*)object

I&

*u-,ji! &I

4991 f

.L+F

3 4 I I - k

& Gaydl ~ + y d

" J

- M S J b & j~i +;r.pl+ll~id--r p% : ++dl db+J.I p 'db+Al

;I!

d-'lr+JA

Y W Jkz& &U A A b-J b+ &JI

++

a-

... 4 db+A p& 4; I..+

0t

&Lh;

d - l >SubjectN -

>Objectu "L9l .G&I

"

J,YI

jr +9

.&I j .j t

&, I

"L+,"

Y! .zlJ

.PI$

&

Uj f >,Ul J+l(*)

'rp.byn Uji, '$dl j Predicate " 4 1 '

43i; j, &%Ql j Subject

" i t l J I M&Lh; dl

I-&

e-

+I3

a+

J% G J & l & k p $ l ; i 2l'aLGpAl .L

d-il*

~i

b

h

dFmj

.+e3 c,Ll

Y3

L-L &L+

+Ij

.U*JJI

Objects " s L p Y "

LL~.S~L& .. L + ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ & ~ ! I L C - \ ;A & -

kS 831iJ,+i'*'y LaJ*rpll:

+j.isb "++$I"

.&-i

d 3 ) & M I -I j

U

j L c j l.+jiL;

$p L,oU-IdLG4d.l j l , \ f +J13

( e l 3 bGJl

'41;

&Lc+pa

;fcps

: i t s likq fld l ~ j . 3i+-Cl

+ I s d l i&l i 9 l 'b-1 -3) ;&I

s3WI

i+-Cl 3 Immanent (i;bUI)

++$I

,

d k Transcendent.

"B,UI" ;&I ,

-,&I

~ l + ~ - d I 3 j& ~d ~ dl l L J J l ~ p L j . $ W I

ji &i JL,231wy & d l&Z3 231 G J L IiJa 3g+ y j+ J! &A j91& rji

b WJj f

.sUyJSL JG & .

II*

bi+Y!6JL

L+Jl

--

o h

-.

*'I

c

j+i>,jf

41 bt .a3i iJcyl ;il+aYY.b! .*2(p3iu>2

>rs 5

,>

i y lo h &In

b A,~;ai L ~ ~ . L Z L ~

LJJ-

ytl): LJUI

Jx;j .6kj e4ir+

j i a l J q k a d ~ 3 i ~ o )d &

j + , %

~~Ja'cj-

.OGY I 2 9...

+31 L #

*& Natural Attitude &I ji -I. $ a& 'LgJl . a l , y - 31 e lk.iid L;p;

L+> 4

&+I3

& ii+

f

$ s;lS

,fi-3

f

9

~~Ja.tl

*xt.

'

i

~ $

j . )

f~

i

.?!+.'>I

G S l 2 L'i - 7 7

+&.if

'&,&

.

;li)

'W%

b3 2 d*i j.; Lliy L t l l 5JAL2LJ3.d d l C&9U.f13*11 f$

-

cJL&

d

.J$

&JwY\

C

(&j - 1

F

q I2&

~ S+h

I$1Kif L

~ A -

j h + L b d I, I 4 1i.+

@

+441 2 di Jr;

JI?~

pi3

bitJQN

J! ~ d . 1": ~ $1b

LJIJryl

lg;&

,l+l

JI

OL

L & J l c-.h i $ l

i?J-IJi

jJkupb~*i,~~l&~li .'+' p b y r; ; ,*L;-J iL$k3 $9L J &313! ji! + - YV

.&>

jj+

+>+i

j~

L+

rY~ i, ~ O ~ C I

J I ? L ~ ' L ~ " & ~ L - J J & ~ L Y ! L ~ > ~ ~ ~- ~Y A

.&!A\ J.'U ilku 2 LnS bli + M I +p&l&LA

J L , L l d L L d I j . i ) J t 5 ; > ~ + \ ~ ~ j- YLq

&b j Ui3 ' 4 1 jrg)gt~+I s"L y l J & l && J! &i ddl (dl; Y J$L lJlda& + &dlJ) , L >! &+ ji k J 3 q 3 . ( " A * ~t;! $'5 ki" iJ$UJ .-.d

-Q

Phenomenological reduc- >$+&I J k j lJ ii+ ZLkik tUiJ 6 ~ ~ G - r , IL 3 a~lS1-3d!&+ j K L JS J G l

9

>>I1'

tion

'+I+

.&I

J e l i ; ;.- P

I &.I

9&g)+&l

>>I

2

~ ~ - y ~ J S j . t l ; * ~ ~ $ j r ~ ~ :

b >G

.b*UCC

J&!J QJrLAl f%g)!

& 5 =lA L+

LJ$d (~L~JI$LQ @+$I I ,JUI)

+lr&J1

j L +

ji,wbdflb&dlirJ

Jk$L.~&l&$l$ .+dIL;bl,i

JkJ

l L ~ i V J ~ l J $ ~ b l d i - ~ l F ~ ~ -

y ,r

3'"'

34-53 4

k g - ?

Lr

+

-"

-ki

L7.

y '4-533 .XiS,Al

~&p~~-*l+i- Y Y~ + 2 LLi b

L&dl +.I

l *i L, kj .-$&

i,+

2\31j L j 'ilkc. ; ;W &.+.,A!

;Lr ,i

+L+v13

J + , c ~ ~ ~ j ~ i ~ ~

;.h-;.*--s,i+.+iLo .LAp

u -

'y JJ;!

Jp~

l

~

Q u &-liL ,YY I lib a\ + &I b e%$I p&I, +' Y a! J+ .+lJ UI+I Y ++31 GJ-I . F~jS +I 6, '& > $ j j + j'h*I JI> b i& &S ksjrj oL+j +MI

A

LS'&+$+Wl

lib ju2

'*J&

9L i A-+iJb

2s."w &FL;jk 3;;

'+

o h

&$I aI;+

.I1++

pig>

P I2h I * i l &

o L s ~ I I

69

.o,! , ,

bLi $

jn pl+l Lk '+WI ptg y ji 4; .& &4 1 ;

+&cj-~L,rJlaL+~kj~ . d L S b J

dpwl &+I

'.&29

j'~ .&+>I

+p

W pl+l

.+MI

;FI - Y l & to:t L n l & P I & a?G8I&.La, .. Lj, & +&-k; $dl Jt+

l

jr d#)&$++&( ) j l >

t+ s? JkZ I(-JL;LI

e e Y I

j .

'L$y yj I @I

* L

L6jF ~ ++Jl

h+cgb.Lg+.l-

+'&I

dY9I&$

0.b

J!&I

o

jf A

h

tGL-4

jA ~ Y I I >I LS$I

+-dYJ.

Correlates ~ b j - I&L .. 'bJ+L

('24 5 3 V p L)plAl JSiJ+ JjUIji;?

;. yv-

O&liJlJ L . + l O g d I

+t+, ~i.'P"l

jrl

'y Igs%L.dl& k;i,-+Jl

L ~ I ZIL+I ~ I j+!+?I

o L &

: sJ&&l

.*I

j i ~ ' ~ - d j~ > ~- T A

.r-+l+Jl

+k! lj

d\A

2 1'LLG

GYI +I

-41

.*I a-I

>! o i z , . b

j&+i2&+3.j9~iiz~b&+ j!j ''L-1 *LA j6; JJ 'k- 4 U - I

+

--

!

l p ju

U

j .

~

& J I JlgJI

b$e+I

r ~ - & ' ~ ~ ~ . + p ~ k + ~ & - e b J5. &&dl/&I 5

9

j .Ld;,c31 ciJJi LL &$I>

Y l r@\ .k.i L;( &LLj LeT d S Y I

i! Jj

.+J

.&dclt&

& p b J l ;p r i - ~ i L = ++ r t . L X . j ""J' L*a'J' 4 1 " U I J 1-'

b 1%

+J

L+

.Lp j.-;J.$!..+I L;( '(&+I. . & +L a priori

'r@I

r&d Jb

.&-+I

I++.

C@K .l+YIJ

8 '+dl

r@l

.I''&I

++I

I&

S I

is& ( Z+

&W W I W U I

1-()

2191jsAssertion +& JidP;Ji2 WL

d3 i d U l +ISJ j b 1 L +u t ...+ l. r@I bI . i ~ ~ J $&IJ .l L'S

Jt W

-Yq

+WI +I

219~: r+

Lyl pr> &i BWl PGJL

LJJ; j .+I .++I

&

3% 2 9

yjji g, i g l j l l i r H k ; i l & - 3 ; .t*

&+I

jgk!L p i '&-dl

&3*+&p

&&3

jCS

JiJld +I

jp

j )

~.&'1-b*e3u

w - i J p 3 ,MpLJk)j!e-illt.J'yfi. & d l 'y

&lb

y ~ Yo l

j&*

h

I

$ jYl

3 4

j .WJ* U Y I L I J r j .Y+

&I

L q I ydi k A * + l I

d&

++

LS r L L W I j!

69 j .d

j .

Y

I

J

'CUi (PJ

u

'

jb$lj.

ib

bK

d3 .ebS

r

OLS;

L (4+bJ

j?;)

Finite Calculus

I

,+

& d /L! y 4 k t , p, 242 J W I d.2

631

l -lhj

Berkeley )JSJb Gg

2LLI $ d l

&I3

j j l t k j l hi

,yt y I I I h ji

a\+* & b 4 d 3 'jXbY1 I

+.Ltll + e l ,&I

-fY

5 5 3 .&Id1

4.l

I

in- p L Y J I uL-' b

LE .s,p+a 'l * L..

jI 2

Ui' k $ e & l +

+~dy~L"OYd)5~3b)& 5 +-dy

L g $5 $dl &&ILL ,&LS h

'++I

i .%b1 9

3s -$

$ Edmund Husserl 3

(1859- 1938) Jp -rY,!hJ

5

I

'2

K

I

J

~4 g 4 $ 0Li.y fl,.

J

*4j

.&JL-ill L!+leyf

jo I , ~ L S I I I & +J ~ l p u l E& -4 p ] j . ; ~ ~ ~ y , u L ~ i ~ h ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 9 . \A" \ r(P 0L;rkl)l

J)

rlPjl~ .(\4\V-\AY'A)

+U2j;lplL&&al+Lu

&+EJxljLCjeJ-C1&Cli

\4Y4rLrjz \4\7

.b p .

+*

UI+-~~&..~+~A~I+~I+I~;K

,ji! Jp LS i k l h l l .*%I2

h W

&F-J I

ji

'%& I

Presup- "-

Ji&+I

+:

YJ &% ,

&

j i d 5ci ‘+I+!\

4~ j% 'ds"..rJA , +j& ji U,

JYhl #

tlr t,~pIds L'Llkj,'ds' 414 14b ;i(

J-S AL+

Positionless Science

.

I+

-

JSLC;; +Ul & d l +l Js $ jl+I 4 y ~ 3 $ - ' i J 3.~g.'+i>~ p'j~~ +p3 ! 'Lgl

4 Y 4, >&I & I; ;

.LJ;. . & j+TL"' i

,,

Infinite Re- ' J b Y 4&'1 j >UI

i3+

g

5 ,

t-h4,&d-l&$3& l d&? r.

LALAI

i k l 6 i~ -

JLrI J3\ JI J+

Psychologism "L-.!&I

jK L$ll'

2

..&LA1 jjW13J13JJlJl3IJK &%I

% 4

~

t k l dJi j +.!@I

j

.d5>13;a\ 3 a>&>

&i &3 I J l

~

-L

#

<+ '$1 d

>&,

LJ?% -.

& LgU

&-&I

by

LA3 " d &.L >..I U'&#I

t

gress

,

#

d

;f

. *-!&I 1 k.+JpW'J-k3

c>-,;L

alJ+l

tiY i CL: li! hflj

k ~ . 01 - i $LA\ .Lk3 5

9,9

JF

Y 3 CIA

.

d

~

d

L%+

.~ . ~.

4

~

,

L

j j J I G.Frege (1 824- 1925)

k

b

J

+-)>k

# 3 J > ~&I I L jr &:w ~ 3 i.B+i3w31j ;f * l l j J!

L$J j

~

k ckj lj ij u~ - c* ) %?&*$I

l

.

s

b

GLy1 t&l

L4ji. -$*&I -

-$&I

Li..Ldl,&

j+ iS~i ~2 I+, .

&&I

&,I

j y l

j

Ism ''tj;" J! Lb;* pl, J JGj!+-,UIJ

J!

.QY+

J 2 j j bjl!+

C>

6

hr' j- PJ' pl, 3!c_; jS b3.z 2 'L+L+I i+-

JS & L+

;.

2

J d j jf L+ J

b3e$&"

$

c)

@

&I

;t.

I

! &I

! j L Y I - 4-k;&sUl +dl)

,

JS jJri;. ~ P + Y

~-)U & I jjz j+->l-JI3

PSY- (&$&I

IJ,

;&!I

@ 4 +'&Yl

I 1 k $ & - J Ib $ l " 4J j k l l Jd ji Chologism

I;Jjf

Z+hd! LWI jo k,hj rt,'J +UI ;~lisUljkg

j .i,+

ahis t,

.% j$l

+,I

De- >&Y & +A i i+k>l

6~ I JY LY

3i-1

G b4 1~;IUI try^ >! 3 J-I

dl& Y

I" 2> ji k J & I

i&

jo

b$I di

gU-I ductive Inference

+_bl13+i,.L13LJtl&iJ&-+ .L&

i-11~Wl

.&!LA$,+-SbiJIllLji*

t=~+r ..Ig!$$.

3lkXll mli J 3 4 ! 3 qb

41

Necessary (Apodic-

*i 5 'hiibA

JVLK

-

A+Y

+I

jil

bAF-

9 Contingent

ll&,j+ll

I JY LY

I% ' ~;i;f

"Gp" li! tic) .

~ii>l.,ojLLI L+sc;L; j" : $WIJ

LI L j

WIoh, + hi Jl+A\ &

jl+Y j l l L L ~ ~ ~ * ~ & i j ' J & ~ ~ ~

k c$ 2"

&I : flu! k&A h hi dl 2 .di & --+-A dl d2 j i &I+,

65J3 "4

L /&

J

@> PI 9 3 ) 431 ~ $ 1 ,+I &4 1 1 :kLj @>J+ Pi pJ JY-u-.YI &J (bls 3 JULY

fp!&&I

$+

~&SL>1--JaUks13

jK' li! LS+I

JYLYI

&

2 6 - * i .Y ci

f l ~ y ~ p y . ? I h d l + ~ ( d i jU L-S,$J)~UI

Y JYLY I dl+ .JYLY I dlH +I! 4l.c, ~ i j ~ t ~ . - ~ &

CSJl s ~ ~ i

Y Jkll j;L j i Naturalism 1sb$I $3 Pres~rip-"~,l+' j k l U ! j%byl& fL J t i & ADescriptive . '+ J ' Y tive

n

>+I Naturalistic &b

1

:Vicious circle

'")'I

i , L d ++I

A-

II

&+

35 ,-JP &+i +2 ,pl2 k,J&

,

d3L

I

e"J" .‘~uI

.+dl

jU r@

i i

I

j'j

@ &

L

cC-!~G J & I

JYLW

*I

;.'J

"Iy & *

C j j j i &~I-.+~I ~ W

A gl I.J L .A L. '&I+!\

2 &I3>! jl .J+g

*cl$I

*rl$!

j14i& p ji +.+I! ~ $ +A& &I> &+ I A l

2 ta~La12L +s

4 &I ,

*A (L

*c~>

$dl

ji d i

L '~YYLYI

I - L 49-'L-,J&J'

3

1

jbL; . '

blqiJI &K I+ b@

&,jlc>T

db

>*I

gi+T

,JIG

J1 Causal "L' -.. gl & f d d W l g ab&AI+-.Jkil . ,e.. U j- g .j U . 6 L: Conceptual , XJ+'

l

l

1

6

is$

vJs,

I

J+

pi,

"+

Pre- ""&+.A dGl+I1'

& r+- pWL . ~ a j * z &-j

,+MI

+Y kL;4 +eldl L+,ysuppositions &L

y + 3 j . J)WI r-

qji d + - + & L L I 'Jji

;AJ 3i .d+

j%l

i.hZ j&-ji

++ill

'~~&~ia.i:~jik*kli+~~.+lrll~%+

Intentionality " A I U l &I

" j L A~

L~L-Z -I ~

1 4js""J+" LJ.!e& w i-~; ,&YI jsisG GIJJ+ +a-

J *hsi

LL

> G,&.,*u

jK .&

Con- (,Al) "d3l"+L ji The Mental

4

j f ~ ; a9 i b JS ;C >+..dl ' P - Sciousness ~ ~ .

J -

J+ JS +&Intentionality

21

c;~brckiyjt > i ~ j

eJj ~ b

+-J

- ~4~ fxi

w r "

$ l j2 )

431a

.&p A ~ + y~

$391

. I1+&l'l 9

J ~ ) ~ J-S~ . L .'*&IJ+

Int Tentional Object .'&,+I$J

"~;aAl"

I

Y L pj

4 J (fll. .$AJ

834 $ 4 1 Q-4' Ls! ~ I &IJ .b *& 9 431 dl j d%l Y a Y LLI J IL + . A-e+y fxi QPk l 8 4~ 1 3 e9d.b .~JJISJ + J . L+$ .GI ~ $ 9 r .@ J& JS $ *>I 2 4 2 1& ~ V-&IJ I . 431 -

p+ $ $3

;I,UI

1 b . jlS IiBj! LJaJ1 drP! +3

++y

++

2 (J' p k iJSY e+$l .m .iJSy J3k& 21 JLYI &-~ g- ;. u Lk 3b rbllg16 &.+44 di s'i J i b "h-" & +@I

JL&l

.>sy

"--I1

5

s L P p j&k+i

9 LKJC*;

0+ b L a .>fly

Intention- 1 1 c 5>fljY1l ~

j&

ji

; 4 U IJ W ~ I

. ( ' $ 9 ~ 1Inexistence

Ji- Y

;UJl JUG% ji U I .

U ' I,

,

J ~ &$I j i LL,! b ji

&-L+fi J : ,\ ru3iQ,+I

.02x

Immanent

&-

>5

2 3 1 2

I 1 + L 1 '

r

'fd lb4,

;.b+Al

Y .i+ +=cpil

JI 912

-

L

t+,

yi +&I

PI

ip-

95 "JG". 5 u 1Q-4

I1+kl'

,&isijl~d~j.&I&3

.i;p-ill&~U

+L 6 3 % '$ S3s;r-p t 3 2 3 4 Id13

9)

(&A;

~ I ~ + - + + ~ + ~ ~ J ;JL ; ~.PI~ ~ L . Jjre-,5

'p ;.. Y

- -

j"filjI"L+.dS>$&":~&

,4913

j-JI

&*-i t+u

LC,

#

+Lo 2 Z + d l j I 9L ~ & I

2

4,

T&

my;;

+! 3 5 3 rlk-,y

jl;JI 3 L W I i b C T J I 2 +LA&iJ - 2. L-

t+Jlp c-4;

\+ j!, L,A+YI

291jfi-

6

i;pdl

.I'&lit+911 9

>

-3

& 4ltl1.&p3 r 9 Jr-: JS I J L j I & JJdl&-Lh;lIp r& J&13 .2+4 I

M

%MI f$

L

-

3

4

1 L+JI

h3bl+i

William J. Earle, Introduction to Philosophy, pp. 130-131. (*)

p

.dJ+

k3LL >A1

a,&>;+J

i;Ul

l

+ i + ~ y ;c J+ "

k4: *i*bApfl o J.k L. ,9

+4-1

Cogito ( g ~ ~ ; r 4 UZS;JI ()

p b bJ!

C S p db3 4;i L U S

1~ Y *l o k g Cositatum (+ 9 1 ) 9

,DL&\

b

4

9

~

3

.u

,&-

b A* & - 3 +,AI i+ o ,, i2 ~ J+i 2 J+I ;b~p cbfki +&I ijj27 .ip+ ~ 4;LE49ps

JA! J&

29

d i

..

&I

.+

~t;. jY

~ U L ~ IY9p ;;?Y 'GCA%&I

, , a

J!3)' py L4. 9

2) Associationist . +I

3 L&JI *+'I3

j+J&

dl4

fl .b~) ~ L k3 U &b+y3 +UI

2 4 &1j)! jd3 t>1)YI3

cke;j f

.sb

.2+Ul

4 (/

31 i -..

JWYI &% 3 1 -

Reasons "&WIillJ&lug ill,gprll

JWC>U&J?l

= \,OVt

L S

- -

It$>&\

35

Causal

&I3)! 3 3 b

J ~ L L s A1 I ~ L"~ Jl+-U~

J~IJ-Z)IO~I~U"JI+J~ C1' J fT, Y , ? A t ? , Y ? ?

Causal

"+I1

al&

4 'Evidence

35 abL-! Y & . - " C zJ1_LJI&L

'ild"31 Reasons

''G J?

J ~ G ~ ~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ , A b j t w . & 3 i ~ '&&~&~~d&iJ~&at;+Y #

+k;s

+

k&

,j+

+dl

+2

U k i ai I&

U d e r!+'Jl j13

JS

dp ~ J I @y

' 3 -

f

Jj Reference ( i J L l ) 'ilb!" ldlr *UI

;-isi ,t a& hi ~ $ 1 ~ s - ; 7 .*dl ~ > U23 l& l,+

&I

&

aL&I

j.3 .+&I

0

4

1

p&+ .+ 31

t+j.LI

~99

C&

JI. kJ*p.dl -

L J U I *I

J l j w bp

j?u 6-

J*

j . 4

>I

&iC

S

~

+bJ+4 ~

C

J iJ-a

$5-

4 "8Jab--r" 1 Gj kL 5 L -.+l i+J i,31

-

&%LL ub+j.LI

'-4~1

~

Y I.; >UI

4

l, d lyS3 t-y

i

L j ~ ~: 2 t d4 ~1

4 ;.IL+$1I

p &I! . . = I d 1

~

~ '&I $

1

P

.zfb& G4! gel kS &IJ>

;j

ZjJ j k ;?yLi iiS;4 &= +$++I

+-S

L d j j f I& L G L jtd .;.~Ls+$lr*gl a"

2 3 2 Q j3+3

& ;.~bg$I

L p U I rX14 jL;; i23

LY jJI rX1l d L d i ji

j3>

..sL+Jl

2 PI+

L23Jl

&.

+& M I

,$ j

&&

L4 -

QG

2 - -

&u 4 'v"k 2 jGJ1

.&

t=&N;+*JI

c%I &3

LS, W

j! 'dl@I

+dl!-.&

LpS a;llP+JI

61

L..h

a-&3

i+-~

'IIL_t.L"c3L.L:

04 jU; bl, k r h , jI k.Q Y j%yl

j !o L G A I

L

+ Y jJliLJdl j ! . r L = . i Y ~ ~ u l d J i * ~ W +

& W +ji \4 j K j !

Lge4*

$& L 2 t=I+Yl

.''&La"

I

;

j .n+d4r__0Q''

Logos U3

*3

?+

LII+"

,pL'WI .sLr+JI

j+

$

CGYI

uw-

Phainomenon i + L d 1

&3

2 fb1Jall.J.L

Lo 9 LS-ifl CLli LSj! ll~pLbll ;i.9J.S +3

k43+4f3

.&

29

9 '

153

d

'j+

.+

'+

2 3j

j4 tBj j.3 ‘&

.JJ?31 G

J 359 ~ 9

z 9j

J W l ~ l C & J l c

+i.LL & j-'L +all

b

CJMIL2.J&-I

z+ L2 Ld

&d$32 _a> $?IJl+b Transcendent ." k jj 0

L

t&&;i I ; jhJkllUi3 4 (JWl J! 3 4 1 &-I

L

"

.pl+l

'y zLA.4

jc ;rkll 3PJ+!Pl 'y *

.!

Trans-Phenomenal p l @ I

~'+2l +& 3 L jjL+ +'+YI 3 &GI+\

31 "

J+

~ I - > "i b J+I , ,

y

ikib t

;$I

c+-

3

L-

' L ~ Y tness 4 L Y l ~Ubll I+& tp; CJ> .JjL

djLi~E&

.t>L kJ+>ldl

pJ

&lj3

CJ3 JYLW

3?LTJI

jls

3

(J 'kg?+ +I>

I&-

,

L+

(JWI

LLii$ll' yI

2 +I"

Presuppositionless- "Ul ,L.j+ll

21Y Y I

-.

j .Ldi;CJ aL+&>lj@I

(J3 ! a&l

w4!

.PI&

Natural Attitude . "+I

L!

+I

2 ji

,+9 I&.&

+ - . L

dZjb

j L Y L

~j'%$+&k-da

JdIJ,-,..

.&Id!

l>

W

&d b

jlUl Q L 1

.

8@43&Jaf -Yl

jo la+>

;>LL&~JI

+

2 2 3 1 L-

+

ckid p3 'iS,114>pl1 Pheno- '&J*tpll rJl' qLr &-'J? tLCbl #I

'#I

& +Jl'

(J"J"+l) &'J'IJI

>ime no logical Reduction

I 2 d3 Epoche ( n-41yI"

U

>! 6 Bracketing

C

Suspension +*yI3

"as; &-" L;; j l l Epoche i+l;g?l

.( ,.&&I

$7 ~ J *"ILl

3

>i 3 L Y I &' UI I L 2

e

.&qJj+dl

&I

4p

'831a b p y J y 3 p31 > di

L~?S

y 3

&--

w 9 +u~ ++3

>I+

j&+-3

.>$I

pl&>j

&

&'I$

kS

21)3L3-$loh! J!+ji - Y jJ! ~ @ >e3 j jY (LLU

La, f

. k b j

uyjj & p L j s p ~ Y ! p 1 4 h J l j O L j l " z Y t ~ &.L

.pl4hJkll

jr

bli9 ciCi jI a+

& hJ yI+

&+I

jr

9L :+~JI ~ 3 ;G. 21 O~UIJ! >>';+I

o h

& : j

Y! pl+l

L+..&

.&kjlH131

. j i r>- I; -

~g;j+

j+-

I

plqkll ~ f 4;9 Eidetic Reduction (dJgpll jf) " d p U I j! o

&I

IJ~ U l &i

dl +I

LdAlI ,yEidetic U--J 9

.ply1jg O+

9

Jl+ &J i''JkjN ji

. -

'iJtpl1

#J

Jl

b%l

(jg~

Eidos +&I

- 2 - 1"ZSS%~I Jgpllll ~ $ ~ L ' ~ L~L+VIA s gjj t u +-L;;I . ' l a & ~ b2 ''

&+$~~~&-ZU;t~pji\-l,jp.----i

lsJl i* 8413L-

ji

&I

Jl=*a

i+ bUl ely

'&L;;J '+Wl

JI+

Jl&I

j j A

John Shand, Husserl, In : Philosophy and Philosophers, Pen- (*) guin Books, 1993, pp.238-239.

Eidetic

'kl'Science of Essences

JI+'

abU Science

j .TpiZ j&-ji

lL &J

JS ;r tu4+5'i 4

c

p ~ L ~iiy U Iji

t+p$1 +W .~*JI I&.!

GiL jWI 4 ~+;+'I.J.Y"

,I .+

+.L &&dJ +t+y, . ~ I J >i I

Z

&i &I

1ntu;ed

>t?-31~ iir 3l L i

p 4 +4; .;;K

'LT-LiL4*:A;

I

!;I

34 ZIYJJI o h Meaning

I

4 d jcLY

aL+UI o h 3

Jtr L-3 .i$Ul i l k ) l

y-?>a~-i14 I* '

Jp

51 .t+31 ~

9 9 .

ir"

.

+J>&

did c k ~ ~ ,,

$-

. "+" >f Significance "ZIY>"d

~~~stJ&r@&

+

jb

(FY,"+J! j U !;I kc

i91-2 J!

J-L ~IJ~--L;II

(J J j rLL

,bN

+

&I

.&I

!-La +b $.a+

jLr&'+Te~Jb&li+ig:-rj$Ab

9

3

4

j b 3 t 1' %a

1

dg

Referent

- jls !;I L13

d & ~

+

+d;jr *u3 .aF9

1 -. 4>+I

I

L!di35r & J l & J ! + j i L

A

jlyi

"rLLIF' .Y

~ ilkli-j,L

'"&+dl il

J~-L b;Y >i ,I~I>

f ' :% ' dl!; j ..by1tjdJl 7.9

"Y -

0'

3

' \ + \.ipjll.&Sgjlj "3i

(4?1A4Jl*&ldi)-ypp+l+jMJ~

~jJj Lls bj d+! ji &-G+ !;I &Y j l r ~ # + p juJ3 .w&J!rI~1

I

eM>&I

cebj4

'AJMI 2 jlU 'LLP LP1 Ibid., p.240. (u)

ji

CS @-I3

dl 3 g d I

J,+ I&

IS+P J ,

d

2

.r&Yl

-L'J;c '+A

& ;G

j .J

~k;, 'Free

Variation ' + I

d I '9+Lpj Lk+

jh3i+UL

Jj >+

i>

Eidetic Intuition . &MU -b;jJ & ji L Q .

*I

jL&

3i '&MU&

( ~ L G I )d3d~ JS j .

.4 PI+laJ+b ~ u l ; ++I ~

~ji>~gbl~

& ' J w ~04 ~ I LpUill ;.'b+J.I

JLii &

+i

#

@'

U

I

Y j%yl&

+ 3 3 'kJ*d'.+I piyJI &dl i,r'W4

J ~ u d 3 &i jtl jU ,.& i

OLj3q i! . a ~ pCrLYl b +I &I

.j%yI & LJ ilY> &f

lJ+

jY

'a priori

JS 3,

3-3

~ 4&I ;

I&

k

JS

djji

a l + U l j CJYY J13j l r l l

+-

L~

bJe&l dw3.tJJIp ib5J1 pl@*kll

Y @+

9

+-

j f J+

.+> 2~~&i

L&

4

+LU 3 4 - $ a l + U \

+LrJeJtpll

L L& L Y l

$lk

0.b

j l ? J .+

lJ+

ik;-Jl p'UI &u+ l-J*rpl+

dl;.t

j .2j

'&'I

;i >L!

-

~;*lk. & - ~ l i ~ + + ~ ~ + ~ ~ .$Lj

31 jlk. 31

>?

jJL

31

>d & 'Categorical d JL JUI JL diJ$

++&)I

& LCJ,$ &..

0.b

Lj uY i+I - ~ t l \ JUI

.W & j Y 37 ;$I, 4

9

i, i l Y 2 &i2 i&, LL;i +

~ I + IjiI 3

L ;;C;

j'l! j % ~ ~ & + ~ i ~ & > & i ~j Li5 J U L~ - ~ .

a&J,eS d31

-LYI

&Lr+A

21"412 k J + t p l a Y Y * I I CLS, 2 oI*

UQ

&2+r~+ - &-~ ! i s

i+JLZIUk+ - <'5,

c j Y Y dlg j L L l

9

+L3 .+I3 i j l + j l +Yl

'&I+

dlb .hJI*II aLL?l+iY13

iLLi

Jl&l

&YY*II

+ldI a&&l> +dl

GU W IJ

. h e2 CJWI WJ CLj\, iiJChi3L~A+ CJW' i s i

t(*~o~)q P r ~ ;I j ~ -I;J

.G3yl

& jTLJ&

J+

ik-Lj

'W ,19i j , p-&*+I lib JLp 3 b Y &-JI csG1;jYlg 4 CJUI

41j! L& 1 &,&I

.,r ~ b ; ~ + ~ .+WI ~ ~ ' ~ i ' kl; >+ 29 JU fi. ~ Jgi I LVI J& ,I li91 p y?,,+ L ji 2 .I+ L I E~~ I O * hi,p4391LYI OL.LW UL. . 'isp~" pL dl .LA 91 3 4 1 +L &L ai &I ,191 &p y

pdi- ~

-

p k+

OL

Li

2 JUI p Ug

$ d+UI

Y I L ~ ~ + ~ ) U ~ ~ + U ~ + + b i s i > P i il.4 b e - 4; +~.n'olI' l+A t -.+ l . L ~4I &dl CJWlBracketing "p9'1 d'g

2

-1I.

+>

."plWI EJL'' &-j l l Transcendental Ego &lb*l;l$l

tGY)&+I3 c2.LU ;i?t;iUjkJ++ - - J+l .(+dl

, I &Idbi

e

I L U 21-

LP, ;Lfilgll Ig;LcGY

&-39) +I JWL '(Noema LJj) i l Y l l l p, k J t ; i ~ + I Lv13 .kJt;i~i;ll Lv& k4U-I

Noesis)

&I

LiL.bLP*

'(+dl)

9b*r(&$I 2 2141ji JFW i I d U I ) LJUl QG cJ*iji L+ $7 J_rd Y LJLLI~JI J43*3 'h L ~ I

i,hlr.

t+,

3i;4+

cL_i ~ u - 4+ 4 ~ -?AL,

aY+

.g3J j +

ji

j L 5 !;I 4i

+gll~lgll

+

U'&Y;,'+L~~~I~Y*~I&-~L~+J Z

6~~- 1-

jil +MI 3i

j&-t

d 5 Is lib Idealism. "&ILL"

.La3

t

~

LYI

+ k U l L y l js

L a y 7 3 j;r 9 +b 9 g 3J i l Y 2 j~"! +b

JS

LYI cLi

+Wl ji &i ++I t&lUG+Jl

&I :ti6

LYI

3 3 .+Jb~;$l

j&

Y

l a b '+JI

ll&lll

ilY~

62y-3

2 +LcL$l

L ~ I

$1 js 6 2 s i*i, ~ 2 8 3 W b-J i j l U l & l U I J-1 p $2Ji " J y l ' iJa rdy #

jl

* y 3

(&U oLa

r$

Js l J ,2

*

(aliJI

4 alU13i) ~

t23-3

4

~aldl $+ l &ill . i

b

+j&)>I * I , - ' i j L Y L &- $3 6

d

.

.re31

3 iLi;-.Lg! +y Z+GY p a k U l 31 a Y Y J I

9423Js+-~it.ibL6;b+23LS13~3 dl

3 1"i

ilY*ll a Y +

qLlltll 0g;~

UJp I r l J i c l *i3 ~ .&,

flLU #I

jc Jj+

2-41

3+ d l

~

Bryan Magee, The History of Philosophy, DK Publishing, INC (*) 1998, p.211.

+J

l h i J ~ . r i l ~ & L r ~ ~ ~ ~ $ p 3 J i ) d _ 9 r l I U ) U ; t 8 Zi+ ( 4 1 ; j +>I

J!) 3-41

Jk a&

&d

l

L

y

4

PL;'YI 3 4 (+gj ;r=i LJA

t;)+-Jl

b J y d !

I S

&3 Phenomena . " p l + l " J .y%)ll & &I& ,$I pYL

i U lpl+l

iiK y & $ + p l l

$3"leJWbbaCsy.~i15i&JLfi&+-

.i+I

,)+ YJ

LJSp l + l

Y $ d l d l ; jax$

+b jc c k t U l

jk d e p l l

& &$Ij d b x dlJ>! ~ ~~ > L J -91

jJ+

j3uc+3

&!I

b

+k 'LALLJI

J+- . b L 4-d

~pl+l&

k

>J J L j l

*bckPJ3 J

2p l J d l a . b &!

~3

,J$3

dg+&I

4

ji jj>Cogitaturn

21 j.3

1 j ) : '&ij'&*II

d%Ldll' bk5

2

L

" 9 4ilj*LIN

dalJ>yJ;.;-jj

. IpLb p k l l 1lC

2)

+&d 2 1 3 Potential

"i+&'

4

tL1F-plqkll bLi 2 k $ jp ..LA+I\ kg.13

J+'+

. & j L d ~ j Lk031j

\J

G&pb

j)Jp;

kI,j+&l

ji $1 LJ:

Y !LASJPositivism "++Jlu 2 U+

~g;i L3 JjY

GL~&.LI Jl UI A4

&Yl jl $;LU

1 J+

.Chhr -Ll+ilv31 'y 'Jl* pl &crj*&l dJbJ + !"tl+,+ 41; Lj&I jp +j.3 d5 A ~ JJ+I

*j

;s LL, u+L-yYI1l i;K U d r?Ui .Z

JkJl rbi 3 9 Y i;Uj J& jfll '&ILL! 2 t,j J+ kg++& L+ d+ Y j &Ul j d l 3 L r J G I 3! ."al+Ul ji "a+Ul 1- - kjpI.1 ' U U I i p W l dy

I+

/

L&$

+La"

9 9

~

l

l

-

'

.ii+;i~~t.+js'ci+I~

414 i!9~ &Y

i

J+jI$l3

i , l ! Z h L + j i ~ l ~ ~ ~ >

~ J ~ l ~ & j i * , LY; ; ~ ~ & J I + ~ A L . - ~

Jl.b-i y ~ + j dl ~"LYI"

&

+-.A

eliJ

1 1 + ~ ~ 1 1

LS 2 -3

+

jg>

&+ >i&-dI ' I ~ @ l ' j'b

+$ d~ LUX d 4 Substantial I

",Lj j.3

-41

' ~ 3

6b13

> Li' ;

'4+1 ,jl'G id+ l g l U I 3 "++I

31&@

b

dy

b

.- .

p-+ill

aIJI"JL+>!

.au! p\_pkjl

2 1~ L J s I $LYl l

L&

&I &I

Jl&a &

+ .>i

Y 41

U

>&I

AcdJi

>! WL? &.)I Jb

a&! ply! ">*.)Iu 9 .I1 +h;j - 2 -

JJYI

.'*)srJJ*&l

&A

253

qLLGl+!l

l

>*l;,Y

~ - $&O@~@~ b.)eG

,jL QbLcl'J+"

Li&+aJI

&i 9(&l,

Univocal . d Y d I

Y @I JL%L.J+I

+i

,.

Res '+L;~I'

Fyl j f Z@Ig

1&3

j

-,, /

L;1,Sum I

C;~O+i 1'+-3j1'

C

a>&-> 'kg .&Aj+&l

U)

03%

I "+pgr Li"

dj e(CJLJI+&I ;r.

Lgik dl i J U I ipWl;_?

$1

i-)k

>+

rUJUy'I 1 j b d U L " SL+LJ>I

JI

jk

LA t.@

&**I I

yell j I t&VlJ1'

+J

L j J L

d j +WI, ~

JLi J+ J3 3

&MI

2d

&-J

k J U I994 Jd

.flu!

43 1~J&A;r.i ! a * 3 1 3 U l

Y YA-YY Y

bJ&!

LcLi,? e J (9) Jp '\ 4 17 '+$I, +t;u 4 4 1>IAI'&K >19

.&\i

2 LL+&i ~ L = + A I+65'ai hkk '141i

J - - J ~ L J ~ ~ ~ + ~ J I

012.J,o% ji

4 ebjij .aI*II

+L&

&LA

.++Wl;p

b L ! 3ia W l 2

J! *&UI m

~ji~i~'ji! ji . - a\> di j

ji p l - 9 1 9 ~ ~ 4 &qL 1 .&Id1 >!

. It..:&

L L m

&i j 3 3 ' 2Lb 41

*je-t;31

+J1

j.

bAttl\i

j~~~tLkP~+-b~+~!~Jt)+~*j+.

-

46 + L L j J I &Ljbl g ol+l

'pJJ &I

ryL

Bracketing '&+-" &'UIj &.,dl

rJCpll 2 W I j &>WI

i&JT+:I

LL-;IJ3

>*lI+l

-4kSpJl*&&~qll&l;p

+Lj

&-4 -. %Y 3 J-? U3

l L U ~j i &+&I

d

&U4 "*+" o c u l & d l LaJ*&\

3-JI"

'G3idl~ 4.i +J

Her-

Z

Jj

r

+9gi 5 + pli3 J+ . - ji

L*; J3

jL, 4 dlJ+(

& I" Jl. +;I

I .

d.kJl > L l *i l-J*fpll

&I3

.LA& pl, .l+A 6

&Yl

b

o h

' U I ~I&

J+

u-13

&dl

jJ tli&

,e3 41 9 . .

-

'&JL&I & i t +w.++"

*

#

'&I;

&s-J*@l

LLb

l i ~ l

Jj i J E y I 2 & i l l 1

oiLI

, ,

.d-a 2 9

. - jt jcu $

"l&b+y' LIS

5

4 3,

'~LP *-L

dL!

&&Ijrl,

a i3 6 Jp jr #I

' ~ c t r * .:+5

&IJF-

, ,

++

-i

.+$++I

L i l F ~ i l

:+ ;+I

jb$IJ

jJ ;ji 9 3 'meneutic Pl~enomenology a ,

Jj

-i;i A

tbi & jlk,

J ~ + I 1 ' -I,

%

jJ

r&4

&J*@l

0-

$ j b - h j+ll

o h

ihl

J

lh J+

A G '&-

> b yj ~&'jL$13 >*dl" 2 ' r r ~ ' l,j Jd,;~3pq .rL-i&J*+ Y;'

a ''(+?I)

&IjI*O &3C,L-1i

LIU

j

+

JL;;I jJ. (*)~errneneuticof Dasein

e o s ~L , ,~''Ah ~ ~ $ " >* =z% jC-L 3-3 9 3 '&I

'.

p " jL$13 ~ ~ $ 1 'j ' ~

1

"+ ~ j~i"'-

-

-

Daein

3541 jc

*IjIAI ( e )

Is-+'

'.sYYJJ& r;;+ & j ) "l&b*p" +&+I (;.'9N13 k;UI 4 jL+lI lg1Lc-I 31.+ L d l 'y

LaJ3+

JLs &-&-illj +I

&I

'y

& &s ' L d - l

L;7b*&I"

e

L . i 7

-

j-dI31

.J+

j

is ~ 4 ii4ikll~ A N~ +4 c ~ ej ~ g l

N~~

Antiscientism(&l.Lc;lI/G&I)

&.dl&

ji lklbU J+ JS 31ii2

C

>I,\

.jlrll +pNI Ul3 JjSU +&>I

bi

B&ill>

3!

.&kj- "tJkt~.' jfi

'h jie jl;l Y i I f l

2 >xJ4

b

~ ~ & . & l l j ; ? l d & ~ .&p

Reduc-'i>I' J'pp;"

;i?L

+.I!

jm

jlt &I!. Z+.O"

+Id!

.gjliUl jWJll jlh jL.-k - jWJ 2 1y3$l & c " ~ + " ~J+ ji

,&c?;ij$l

& M I kc>

9

3+

&

>

2

~Apodicticknowledge 'LA3+

j&bJ >J '4 JU ,iJl tion

Li Eidetic Reduction . 'ILSpUI >>I' L

ji tJj,JPl "4 $i $44M j4 C

+

JS 2

JS; >EJ~ -itu'h3 a+-

'L-i; ; I + ! .&$

ji

.") +-,Lj

: $1"

C-k

rYJ1

3!&IrP

"

Facticity

~

.

L

+-

j

J

elj

3 4&1

jL$lJ >t.Jl"

~

~

j

j "&$+4__elI-

. &i cLlib' JL+ JLU jl, Iil3 .''W*p" d 3 +jdl& +TLI* 9 b jp 'P k.!+&I 2 ."?' A!; r&- lib' : L=!LLI LI,J +Yl 1

'

3

~

"

'I&\

-

JS

>+ 31 JlglIL Jjk hl J2 .kJ&&J

L-3I--ad-! Phainomenon j !J+ i&

pha

+G

"+=A1'

ib!

>i)

J! "Me1' a ~ ~ : ~Logos ' P h a i n o m e n o n : W

ab ~"d..&tl 'yW1

.

3 41

gJj+l

+ .:

+ i l lA!il'+-

dl & . & & PI ~ O id& S Phenomena "I++" .fiiF pr j l '+hi b e&.l & ' L Ljj L,WI++ *.dp +ji! 9u &.L . bLsL aiLJl+ 4 1 A!, 'e+I + 4 dUI A!,

rJeLzll r c g p l l

cAlt

."Is U1' +d > l I.&! 3 uLcY.!I

1.b>'i d L S Y 1 I . b j'i 2

LLLL. 'iJEYI 2 cS+~9&41 jt

Yi

"p

Richard E. Palmer, Hermeneutics, pp. 124-127. (3)

& :+ L - c ; c l 3 j J I 0 ~ Y I ~ ~ I j b O L g Y I .".iPUl

~ U ~ ~ I &- G & ~ I & L jGj + &- > +~ I Anr- j.jLyl Lyll~ C> j Jdl& c&> Uj.L6ii; . ,+dl +b ji +ji k J W L & 'GILJI ($1inism I L.;4 ~ . ji JLS +&I ;+JL;./~-Y I& - M.I a

,&

+@Yl +

>!I1

i ~ h b~ J + L J+ el!A&+

JsCr 3 pIshJ4$JL~;;IXI

jL5 b W. L.

h3 2k

.I1l$;li

.hi j~bJk;,l+J!--h

+

'Gj ' & ; i d ! +&u a Y @ l 3 > L y I &$I

&ill2131 'Ll+i &j

LL>L$I

>

&.s -1

&/

*dl *&I

* i

&I

lib

Y li;&

j!'-y++

GLyl

dUl

& Ljls '++'

&*

r b lj?2 . b C q

GIU ;L& p-ji &I IL j q & 5 I$-> aeLd ;I.& j!& JA s U&LL+dJ &l! & U I euJ -*I LbJA>J 5 -2 $&,o*.Ls >*$I ilk >+I 9 SN~I isdl ji i! 'U 'LP~" Fj l J u l y 3 :~l3 t 3 y+ 3 bL-1 J2.4

-9

5

~+;.~~l%y jdld&dI> Li

"aFJM

U I j ;

I

.L+,

G J !

:@~jpk+~+

,

"j++" LS Verstehen

2 c;*! q U 1 J

L

Y 1 j'Understanding ' ++yI

W C I .&>

3, "Jlhll

J

LS L-2

9

$ 4 1

cjl L

'

'+I" ~ +1L

-3 iCJIAI &J

iuibLd4 5 3 "Understanding'

++yl

Hirmeneutics, pp.128-129. (*)

k;-, +I ji LS 6 d ~ i

v

GY

>Yl

'&-I>

ip, ji rz,~ L Y Iji A

2 Y & ,+A!+b

ji 2 .+J!s9 ipAI3L;LLY1 cktS 2 & rJI

3~

J3,>

IL & l ' JLj s~ .+WI lj ' rJl f+ .Existentialityl (Existenrialitat). '

Js d , I

,6

$'

3-12

; I -

++I

j i L b; l 6"3*p1 ., i Ld 5

L ~ Yy dIJ$l

/&I

2

'ej 3-12 L l r

a L W I y L-

oUgBewandtnisganzheit) . ) "2%

I%&

9

+&

&- LOLL3 &*+Lc

' j U l -13

ji LSMJJ+d .'3+' k34h)L ~ ~ $ i 1 ~ 3 9, eL ~ L ~ S W I 2 jb J!i J ~ !bi Hermeneutic "&Ljk iil3' &cll~&b 1 34 1I!;. I"$ Wlji -3 ik, 2+ d lCd& Circle " ~ w-9 + ' 31 9 .+13'Y1 OL y I&.!; 'Jkll' J! 9&.I

k 1 3

j\

d

iyJJ1ll %3 5

.gG!d3*3

.&C

$+ & ; ~ 3

;*$Ij3L+ &2L++# #

+3*41

3 ,- ,. a . +,I

j +

. - J eul YI $d&

L

I

I

d

J S J I ' & J I ?+

I+

?+ 'si f > I

I >' I

jdl P

&I 9 LWI 3 L ?i3 . ( & ! . . . p ~ Y l

Jwl&I

.&I ..i3>1

>L3 a 1

'+

i;jY

'+

('%A

.LLL++

4.-

J3 ii U 1

2~

IJLILS) +JWI ;l;ll

la3

CLLS

Y +i 2 ' ~ ~ ' p341 + > j ' s -WI GI+[ 3&I & 'LWIi l i ' j p r i \ U lh L + >!

PI

~i -y

.FjJI

4

e+ill " U

& i l l ilLYI pLb

I IJWI'

3 &% > ~ I A 2I - d b I

(&I$

&I

&I

31 tJ+2 G ?IJ)

31 ;L;Y

I

ri;d i

i r A I aLXJl j !

LUYI'~~

.d&

*iLXJIJ .rlri;w &U

3i) j U I +&

r1-Y

l

I L

&WI'+$ I L & +$ L6;! J: ' L U I + L-y i &ill

.&lyll&!;I1 j U I 31 + J l +

k3&JI+Ll

4 ~ l e L k l l ~ ~ ~ ~ & ( I ~ W l ~

bI I& . A> -

Ep ilLY1 >+p il<Il2&

+ C 03 &-ill

Y j;-, .J +is ill,>^^ L+ a+I j J I 2U-Ijrj dl ;ilU\PL+2 Y j "+I1J3L.a j 2x_pll'' J! i ; ~ h d i i ~ ~ . ~ ~ ~ 31 & JLbj J ir13dl& i259 @! 5 &-I& Lb 2 &

+

+

>>L+I- 2 ; l ~ l l3! j d ~ - 6 -s 3j-1 2 I jl, - a91: d iJL) i.+~93 ei&=3 &jl ,

.>- -

$

c & q \ >! bn J j & IL3.(ZJ$I ilLi'l d '+ &ill >$I ,j\di i L,p 42 >i GYI 0.42 .")b+YI i>lJ! p jCpi 99 OL! +I 34 j , r_r;JI ;&I j i >!hi-L+i '"4 3 ""'i'~;~> +*&:&j l l JkJl ipuj ,ipUill c '$+ dill *IJWI1ppj2 1 j ' l l L*g; LeS + il>Yl Jbj Y

b

..

9

ijhJl aLkJI Jb ab3Lll

+ &Lp;

&-ill JL+l d;!

aL@I OL

L+

-

i;bj

+i J+rLiisill J

/

ljj

julj

c~Ulj

r+dL3

~ '61 . 4~ -isrJ r;+"r J!3531W JF&y-Y-Yq,I)

/L%l

aUlj

J&Lt

.~uXJI~~~J-.!# "+A"

j P6(3 L

ikJl j~WIi$iksJl

+ L 4

$1

"12-lp1' L;x;

Meaningfulness (Bedeutsamkeit)

9 4- L A L. a l i W I 3 &I

dY>d-&ll

2 i 2 ;I;"

&b JhL

( A 4& d l

,

9IJUI I_L .+ : Ld+l J2 +\,>)!I

J L J l p j .L@

v/-i?

Jj ' ! L & ~ ' ~ I

5,

;P #i

&d j&&

2 1ihit;ll j j .iilll+?,r+

IL @ r j W l s.l+i"ll

~ & Y I jGY1 +ill / L Y l

r d J U

rL+dJ43

L+

I

I

j i 3 b " f l * p '+-A

2>jeri:9

;-I1

~Jpdu3iiillJLc&Lr$&pjli~!.iiil&Ll

PI9di->MI

~J;~~L i+ U I & ' . 2 ~ \

&j 3 1 + + L > ! + - ~ U ~ jp&figi&lP &I

.+LY PjWI Y J I j bi

+3!

w ~ r & ~ ~ t + ~ ~ 9W'w& + ji!

j ~ y ~>IL! l

&~+YI

JSC~2 CIP*;U ~ J ~ A I . U I 3 OM

J!+

J ~ j ~ l l i m j C ~ + & + l ~ A U .% I &>I>

Jw!' i b k 'di . I J~WI

+I

jY ~jlr~+~-j~!'Jt&

++@+lib

P

2 +I+YI~~+I+

I

I

'41

>LI . b h

FI

5'

, 1 1 * , 1 1

+WI ;&eAl

&I1

.c+,

pj, JLLcui 'y

'y A h - iJb

P

I

(JL!

G+L)

+-p ik, +jJJS. J> 3

s ''GIJ3L j' 9U" .M % ' L idjU, ' U S *

d! d i 5 ask i

*

j j z 3 . + i ij j~ C p t b ~ j

39-4&A WI L~ .31i>I+ & ! IIL

$

dlu

>

#

*%(s

"

4

1

+lil Prepredicative l

~j.5>9L~tjj, U ~ 41;+ 9

9

yLU

'Lfl +I

9

dJk3 d 4 h- 3 &JG b ~ j

* * 91 j . t141 ij

~

6

1

'--

3

WI'

'

a

",Li ka L.++u

2 3 . JI ~ 3 I

I

'

I

J.-hl

dL

++

'

+u$ : &$

"

P

&I:

, I a&-

U , I

$1

WSL;.

+I

>lJt

+ ,&

4

1

b

JGC~

&

JUI &&

~ : & Y I

li..'a&>

8 Ui',$I

b 1 & - 2 q !

GLio 4

31 +l+Y\ fir Lib?)s r U I j

3: &iSUI &I

I:

+3 .rr$I3

I$*>

3

3

j !

is;?

,+11

P

'fie' JA

UlJ

4 Z-/b" >i5jk;g

J ,! +I

LL.c&Yl

&dl

*$> ",A+"

Lil .a$-u]>\jliJJJ

+

JJ

he Language is .The House of Being

+ pre-structure

'I+-

+I'

J ? ~ $ ~ - C . ~ . ~ ! I ~

pdl ,jj &+ I& &.-'k J ;iy>w'p

Hermeneutics, p. 135. (*)

IT-

* ;l,@-~uatl-&l

-1

2 3

&+

n.;r>; Ud+i

~~3-

al,w ' 3 ~ 1 JJL 1 3

+*+dl

+L

&-'L&b+p

Statement (A~ssage)'~'o,WI" .LA &.dJ

J&$2 Pre- '+.JI

JLrlL3 LWI

CL'*w4 l'iS*pllLA5

'+

& "ls

-.

jX U &Li +i J?J'UJ

@I1'

jfi- $ al,kIl j k awl

0 . L

j

(j&) ZJaLl1':

The Ham- I'LL&

J+

C

J

9L

'

C

Understanding .

-2- Igl y&+

'Ifl+s1'

2 4il Jp3 Lmer is heavy

LYy ;tj_Sj id Lg-2

& ; ~ ~ ! $ ~ . w l - + y l & & - + h - L 9

' & ! + & . L J J * , ~ ~~ 3~ ' ~ 3 1 ~ ~ ~ ! & &

F & ZJaLl &+L JAdk 9

Ji:$41

+%

Lil . i > ' i

+

2 I+ 4 'iJL+!l ~k . ( o h W L 2 $I!) &L&Predi- ~ J & L! J 'Copulative &IJ J 'Subject Jslj

@ & GJI

iJy J d b GJaLI

& j2_ 41& 'Object e+4" yp- ? +Wl i &JLJ -LYI o w ljt 2

.pcL&&I,$>

U

*i Kate adjective

ti+

j&

;G

JYld

yw j j 4 ~ 1-l 2 a#! d !

113+B1

.++ alJk3

~Wli

& ,$ ~Z+ rJl upLa-

+S !A

JLCI 9

~p .iJ+ * & dJ A ~ L L . &A1% I

'*;-I ("

j

a

&YI

'w &+

e

I-& 9" JS" j j

l l f l ~ l l

9 1C ! ~ b ."& 3 .&b Z b l 3 Z+ #

<--

I-&*

Jfh! @ r9

JS k

p ZJ>&J!

ullal j >+xicgL1 J d9L 4p 2

')s fJ+9l k$-

-*

jv

.&j M ;. I 41 b+i i d N l 3'1 4L;S;Y I 2 1-

21

l

l

i

Z

~

f

l

ji Jj

. . 3!GL',F-1;

41 j .GJu-5 ~ ; : >fiCorrespotidence " ~ l h4 ;''I& U - l f#ji e6 . d. Y Ji&Lz% &L+d\ bJ9- & & Y!

.&I

;+(yJ U t fP & d l

43Jl ,p+&I

+I

p&i 'PI fbi JS +,J c+~'..f I2~91 jli+il o k , 2 '+.I3+i-++ LL i l l 1 +L,A 'LA\ -. &->+ , p a d +j JS e 3 .J(SjY~Q A jJ ,(SjYl ++ r+~ A JJ u i+ipt;:> ~ U Y I 2', , .-. p?, .(wi) "--YH > i U w3 z+& 91 ~ L A ~ I &-&i+ L 1.41 j j ~ 3-44 . ,(SjF>u +I

JjUlp#I

'

B

1

~

~

N

.&

~ . I ~ & J ~, - + % ? ~ & C - ~ ? & ' ~ ~ , + A J I

.i,ki - ~ 9 i\lJ21 i- L-I i+

Y

o

J

~

~j

~

,.-dJj 2-Jl3 5 ) .Lp .Y

-

;r.j L> .ipy>

ji

4+ I1

2

iSj i\IJ2!

Js

+-

&

3-41!

+';whip

2

FJ

& J y J I

04>t+vlJI

%&%?lg&h.L91"

pi3 .I

L9Truth 'Jr*!jll

3 iJ+LQ

i+l

o

h JS

&!a;lr;?L j3 '&A

Hermeneutics, pp. 142-143. (*)

'"dl

2

2 "1'

dl 'iiY jY

Fr~iitioi&) yyl J-JJ .i+J;LI

&I

ZJpivg

q&%Y

>y1

I 0 - L LS]!

c;i;U.l

~ y dd JJF

J -

J&&+

s

+I

.LAg+LJl L J ~ W

a

;ml3 ~ L AcI J' ~ ~lafl3 ji

~ 2 3

I h g Dei) .

+ ,I

9,

dl4 i,,A-l

+IJ

,?+ sp-{1*1

l +I

&.L 3 y - dl4 I&IS

,$lp

l'r%JI" ckog. . i>L i h3 2 LS]! j .

J+

dljL l d l

d+U

-2

%95L,

-

~

:OF

&-J

&-

+jC;I\ j+-I ~

,,s

jJI

iGJ >-ci

CJL j ~3

AI+II~

hCi

&- &J+i -

'9LS kpul 4i

;

zz

jL&

$ L . -

& +3

"+-"

jc

,

A i;G>+I =>I -i 9

q i 1 4 ib,.

'LJ

- 4

.

+MI tP3 >LO I&k

1 aJb3 <&L)!l ~ l d& ! 72-

3

oh &

& ij.5-

Modern Subjectism) 'j * C I d i l l

&.&+-Y +UI 3

+--I ~

& &li

a l U lL ,J

;&k

- p - +U 2jL)II +I

+I

5

.+WI

$9

2

#

&jill /&I

.

dls ;>la

.

p +dl

*

35 L

.+k

;&-I

G L ~d 9! d !

jc "sly-"

U k b -34

,

- g

& & jL;)II

+3 Jx;V >I lib A,+

Objecti- "L,i9." 2-92 a Gk.)l3 I!. .$+.

-

+ W l j . jL;)II

L L ~ A

UL-

4~ '#&I

0-L

"i;lUIM

&dl $531 &i L&~?U * LA& . Yl

jI .;I L&r .;rj 1 9 >

.w&l

-

dG+Wl j l +-&v 'Subjectivity

b3

+i

QL' ,+I ilul .(Subjektitat

Subjectism "aldl-La' 9

3 filb; r9'i AJLI

i ~

Jbb*&

.j L Y I &.!I

$bi J;>

113+u

i

</UI 63f13J object tpdrl'

&

4IJli . I I J I uGL.:$4i

+>

>>$I

.

Y a~dl

p-

Jbyl9-C;i I& 'igldl Fications

F-

4'LAY1 b L ; J l > e Yfr .&I j .+$

Jsj bgrgll 3i) &I &A!

Zlg, 2 4j; r& &I

3

i . g l ' 1 1 ~ ~L"&I 3

ib3+SI

"LAI - -

>LA)'! b ++I

3 .j L ) ' l & 6

M

LS>+)~

Gq;o

Ibli-.!

Yg ~ W I I L

jlg,WIU.ikor dUl .9

r

e

~ U ~L L Y I'Lsr j f r L+WIjr

Fruitio Dei "&L ibjJI1' jc ?dl

L ~ f .is&! r

L"L,+'

b&

ji Y!

# A Y jLbYl IL J;. j Ji

jfijiY!i

.j

k Y 1 4 L9 j b i Y l > GI;~ U Iji YI, 1- ' Lii

+ j.3

L " ~ J + "

k ~ _ ~ r

jU I J

I-i

i.01

L & Col.respondence

C+

J+- U '&$I

Y

''L+lk;I1

1-L

J+~

r d !~

l i r>L

+ d l Objectification " L G J l '

+->L$l

GL9l-i

@ 2 J?

u 1

f u I kbbl3 +&dl " Jlgb!''

0

PL jbL ;p . Z L L l &X3L.!l

>j+I

' LsjY 9u ~ I J ++II

j*

Xr U 1 3 .fW13 ++I

&W

A ji

~ J I

i 1 2

;?-. i+I

&-fi - ;&. +I FUJI

91."+l"

;p LJILJl o +I

+3

-Lj

-I

v+

1-b 2 bJ*-

;plkL i+ Lh $ ji dd 'Ir+"

J v - 3 - #I3

j" +&-il&+A Text '3pJI1' 6~ j+%i-i;O ~LL+l;ll 1 b . &$

;p

g +ji ;p

- p ' .. ~ b u 3I & Y! .+!+yl

L@

;p + d l

j + ~ f l l

L ILJ.+I

2 ' 4 dl .orlJJ ~j+&A

iZdI

L+13

T*i

&

kOl-;Vg I& /l%I 34 dij 41

Ibid., pp.142-148. (*)

j

jHCl ?+I

y ji&d.k.&

A- : Jjyl ct3j:2- >.1;41# j i j l + 3 iI e lhll A Yj

~

~

jipgrj+l 9

kJ +WI

'Objects ' s l s + p l

+j

jJl;.~ljr~Ij.+2pLs&Ly?

r ~ Y l

J+

.G: ji j L Y I

~Ij.Ig,&~IJ~i+ILo&-E!gi~l~

$3

.@I

J!

&I

e,

,I

'&pl

~

U

913!&!!!f& 9 3

c.d

l bJlp $

" 3 Lj 1 &L"9 & ~4s;I1Li+q_;" Zp X "j a-

+I r*JI ..*$I

jLU .- l

Jj 'I?.+'

,jLiyI

*&M ;;I

d!; 9 jL;yC.

rdCrk;Ijr*.JI

"&%" Li!

,

.JH.J1

jp &I

t

4 iGJrr31

rJX5- i! j L Y I J I.rX-lJI (+I

"-

r G +

+.)

ll-+aN L -j ~&I- +dlJI r j L(&%, V 3 k i1 4 .ill &I jl JLC .- . . - ,I u u w :w ~ k21 : +k\11 j .#I ~ l d 1&hki 3 +>L:

&

,is

'2'+ p3 .+u~I 43J! isrk~ 41 +ji A-JLII91 .i1. ji 9 i LIW &LLI &4 j4,L IL & I 2;t:&I

&,LL;a

J$dI ,I+I

-

Q

+J I

j b I; pj .il$

i ~ l sJ l ! J-4 C

4

-CAji

LSyltll

I

'4ji --JI

JS 'GI>

jr kj

+I

I&Y~ .d s a l J I

P &.L~I sy

loJl C. jSI Jl+l

ji 21'&i

j~;>id! +LS

113+11

r~ .L;-P! 3 L;;WI -I 4

&

~ - .- U 2ILj jh-ji

>$ &iYy! .>rrJl;.&

J L ij .

&-hN p ';$I

-f

L& JY ++p

iuI

G 'bp;-~h:- "LL2L&l Jj

+-'>) 9-15%-I JjUI

LJSL*

j .

5

.+%I

-CP

iJjUI

~ ~ 3 1

J ~ U I.wg j~ A ai JS LJI

&-

1 h & L l I >!b j g b - Yg tfl>s$.l J b Y j L i

&9gI

3j L 2Li L!'

'rr+'

hlj-ll

3 x 3 &+-A

i d l j J j L pEj i + & g

J& .L+ gI &L

3i

I+$

fi .+ & JS "lrh JlglJL 3" &* ax31

au ;

+b ;r.I ,,L T+ ~-3

d &9 p l w l - j - d L ; y I

r;k

J l g l 2 tj

~>:J-L-

JIvj .- jltlll

,J+-ujI

YLdI +;I!

jc3 2

"ir+l'

u

_i d ~ ~ r P r i 4 , r9 i 4 ,iM3.+' +

J&I

C.,

fi-

>g

pH dl

3-3

4 .JjU d l.+ ;

C.S h

~ +I 3 ,

. k J ~ &-. - b 9

& il>L;iliiWl+'s

"*Wl

&LA

>x31Jl JIG[.I.+

JibU "U

Selfhood : q d I g &LLdIg

j .

j U y l wlj.,j

j

2~ ,

.'I?

jLiV + ,

~ r y; jJ~~ e. l .x j l

-

ji

t

+

4L a b 3 ~

~

.d 2 y - 6 . 1

''LLflC;II

3j &A"'

$ ilLJ1 _;1 a.J.t1 99 +Jl

A @I

>J

>

a

j U l

j!

J+'s "L+liLyI LjJl

"*+u

~rt.31;-

OAJY ~ I J A

J X j &! J+

G+

ji

I

3 zky? JUl &J+

-9

p >&I

>fl$lg

.j L y l /h;! &+

l S -9 >+I

J;t'4 lc;!j l I +,JALkll o

IL.UI

.(+dl

L

i;;i + eJUIi l tbi .+ Jill jjWI d l LbPj *i j K "&>MI 3 1 Jr*.' jM r r ~ ' :+~>b wji > ~ L L $ ~ Ii >I .. +..iyl >x$\

k i++

&!TI+&

ji

s L U _;1

I+fl' "

+ I d j L Y+ I L. -L I ,&c

Geschick ( i)ihl w9 U

jY

i dl

yWlj+I > d l

ckpj G j K j

./Yl+

$

w%3 L)-F-+ ;LpLL,+ j k

31 &-LU 3 j L & 'jj> d b

-3

b jW

. A h - >>$I

l+L 3!

~

plJ

j .''irlpl

a +A&

Ai

I

k~f

JjL-il

G J J ~ 3;' ~ +i; > L ~ Y Y!I ~2+-

>*JI

.di~*.J

,,&Ld

'j+'l

!J$ I J 9 t h ; p - J jL-;yl j jL

4'e

A;& L a~i ~c,~WJ +dJCcll

Pj

Lbp* j ' U U 1

L+J

.p4-1;Ul

j j j iiWl Ul- j L ) U blt; 2 YJ 9 yJ d l j &Jl IL" j I $b $Cu i >YKi ~ j.~ r

d

l

.C

- .. 2 j L y I i e

to/B*J %+,jj

'

2 . + d kj L y l ~ y J i ; .~. l

b9f W I +j

-

i c W ljU1-

. a w ld$

3;i

&

'y

L! "*+"J+-

+Ul

jk llJp?-' ji&-i d

li;ul

-.

..+b,4 IjL!

j f (Dassagen) . "J4;JIN

P;#

lliF-ll

=!

. ' U I2

j ~ b . i ; ~ l ~ ~ $ ~ + . L A J&Jl

.a 3f 9 J+

.j L y I 3

l 9&I

i

1 j!g

5 J*JJ

"J+"

Al h & & - I 3J j.&A Gl_gS&A-

y

. J ~ J I +,dl 29-

-liljJI J&$I

JS

~~-1j&

s~r&

+& LJ+ 35

,j!

*y 9

p k g

l+lJ Lt&i &I

2& J ~ J I

yJ L ~

*u:

.GI j'3+'

JJ

>*J(j jLyl

+/kl &+I

@I p y Y l +b $JflJLi

p: >J)

* J b

L

~

jLyl

I

L . . + Lkb L+i

$ &LJU 'I

l i b L'(

p i i l i l +b

.pidl

Fbi L U ~?.&

J,+J+ I'

jflg

ki@; JjL & +I

h i pi

j L y 1 d3 4

;1 J+l

+dl +I3

++ .

2

++

y-+&I J&I 2 2

>,& b r 6iSrzj Jly

L ~ l

d+ by& 21 -42 yp~&;-.LL3 jH3+J~++pliilt j! .w3 3 +-j &.d jc 4 1>*- 4 J? i-.j

43kl32 2

3

t~5'pJiLgo=cepglap~>*+p~~I JJ.? W 'pLtll a'Y .,jLylg

iphJI +I

$91 & b JyJI 9'"+!

~ L T Ie ~l J l

3

5

~

+L

$ CkJ4 p

Wrul

p

"x+"ZC pl JS-

$ -13

'+I

Lgi & & b e & l

y

I+

~ $ 1

2L^. J?/

A46 p L &J+ :& UI

/aldl

+Is

i s U I &.A

b y &

./+I

bt$JI $Loj-.

W J l j??g G..JAls

.Ihb+&l&

A:,

llx+ll

A; IS

"rJ1'4 =+p

/LYI

J--g

>

+La1'

u"3u

~

+I S s . Jg&4~;4&1 C S I,

j9 - 3 a h -

4i,O3

&I

*

jn &J

*'I

*L

5

d~ *hl .

"R+l'

ji3J3

2

+

kLs 3 i ~ ~ & be - y r;y '~6-J IZ 2

+J!&-+J

$ dJk

! l i b &iL3 9

y 3 3

'L

9

~J,~UI&L-/.;.W

j j&

j 4 1 1 . L +

.z$&i JU3!p (7+

+' +"

21Jrh14 J L s p

l'lL*+l

"~y+f"

j

j 9 "j L y l

-F

4 i>+f"

& &+U

kS jL;)'I 3 JjYl2-P)'I+,I

4 ~ o d d

: "x+n J++ .i@l

u

3L

+

jjt-e-

&rLg;.iLyp~j'&~/LJ$~ .L&%&jlj>

d!; ';@

wi@l Jjzh-)

dy J>Y! L J I

>GI &I

fi&

Lp & Gnl

. ~ ~ pL UG~ - ~ 1;~ilyl

2-

&I

C

&I+ ,

&LUI

>j -

LLis dy i;UI L J I

2Lh~LlJ G'Antistrophes ~

~J>J,>

,

.bw-& j -.j

Strophes &+I

j31

i#l

$32 ISy .'C;i; ,j? Jjlx;;itlltJI &$.I 4j & @Y I LQt--.l. *LijjL;)'I 4 6 - L+ 'i+I

.Gr;" 'Formalist

JI+I

*Wl

L-6 Y ' + + "

I?X;*&+

y Yj

"&$211" &A

0 - L

U U I I@

ji ?I31

y &-Y

eb OF\-!

-I

j .

jfi

A\C j o j

w-d

l~

~

$ i+

$ L1 U ~ I 4 yp ~ i @ l &

Y djrl

jk a;

~GJI

A d -

:+I

.++I

/9&4ill~~_iii&,i+~'iu;

+i+I

p*''j 45 I W Y I

J+ &dlG A L."G>

+&ill &I

dl;C6%15

LF-%

" d a d - ! " 1-b..&dl &I b - 1 3--3

iLpLll

~i;Wl

LJl

jjq

&f

C

&I.

&A

jo

&+

-t ej+ +ill

~ 4 1 3 1

2 di .b+I?i - 2 -1'lwl'l

&.s& &dl11~5-1'1 ';+dl

2 la3 .J+- ji +d ,l

2

.o%i3

erXi&lp &-ill

,

";+,dl

+ji u12-+u

yJ"

,$ 'I

>I j L 9

&.+ CrJl IL ++

>! Strophe 4 4 i+2 @-j f 2 ~ 21 UI G r h - J;J ';&I JS

Antistrophe L

6

.+dl

4

1

3 3

J a L 3 ;@I

$ +iii*JPZJI $p 2 &% ji JJL ti9klI LJl2 J U Y I h3 ig.r

+ji3'&+I

igr j .+IL

+I

;Z h C 6 1 1 *LI

3.1'pCU 4 1 + y 1

JUJl

-.. ..

r)ci-4

4 L" &3Ul ji 2 .(&WI i G J l

2 &-Y L &ji

--

Ji

j45;- pYl i+

. . &I J,~UL.O+I

LUYI

,-.dl

A 3

J~:

.(dji 333 JG L)di VJ

*&J

.- ji 4! d

2

+&I

-

l CJ 2

:ji dli

; I - $P&

41 o+ai A : ~ ' +~ -

c""-*JI+I CS

L'y

."oA~&

C b -Y* I j .. Y

#I

jgk

&-L4p5 jjiLJbl ikJl

j!

h 4 d - i 1 1 1 C ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ 1 > ~ L & ~ $ r ? ; + t . u .'"'pu;ll Y &UI '(%&I

Georg Trakl 'yljWs'

4to

'--I1

JS hi dn i ;.+&I 9

JU Y

;+J

~ U y,sLtll l

&-ill Ort " jKLI" jJa

+L L ~ 09+

LL:";@" &I>

2J&l 8 / k J l

& +&I

l &I

4 slj)L ! J ~

Ys +Isz 0 9

Yd

j!

4

J3L 'Is+"

3 3

2 J L+$&

Y3

&+JI jKLl L Y I ~

r& yC:

;t.

$ 9 1 Jl&I

l i ! -J

.?

YJ 1.41

Palmer, Hermeneutics, pp. 157-158.

(9

9.4L A 3 .CAI & b.lSLL 1

J3L-

j p New Criticism

l@i

L J3

I

I I

-.

Y Y i+.&Ll

d.3

Subject mattes

-sgil'

l&cu

"441d l "

%+3'

jlJ3

i1__5 &

"~+JIlJI'

.a+dl I (Z+s+Y

A l l 1y '*+'jks.

j '++I

s)

+jg ~ i + a i . 'IU LZT$+Cbll

+--+GLIid1jf jLb& Presuppositions

1''

G U Y I +u-J .Z&a!l gab! >s+I"

jJI 1"-

i@1

J-Y

pji/-"5 4-

J! >&I

4

1 ji j + d I

"&&I

i*r;.JIN

*:pi

I+*

LLlU

.Lqr

~!~-+a$~Llj "++" S F \ 4 ~ e9LC iz &\4 ~ I + L "LFi/IJ - e - J2I J.oYlN

The Origin uf the

& I d a "lei

s U L g e o L u \ 4 0 *C L s ~ + - p l W ~ s k ~ f A s t

oh 2 Holzwege . (+L;312 d J L )

;,l+WI

gi3 1J jui 1-

- d . L ~ ~ , C r ; lh l &WI

4

+L

"sLaL1'

J! J& i.I,.GLJI

a

;ic +",++'JI

L

ji yvI

+&-

'++dl

.u+i3

>>

d>I

i.l,*phl

~ s I jjL+rI i i l l ~ yj World' hb' l i ! d l 5 &-i j p j r F - +&I ,* Js 1 . L ,-+a. + jb J*'".WI;

L

~

~

J

I

~

f&-

I+"

j

G

LurWI1l

~d Gc

e.

+99 Jujl!".LA~ J 2l b3 .. - 1LA& h F U U .'J&l$ '&Y cbkpJ! cL~+& Y-

99

dl.-j

,+!I

J! u&- d 4 j (L' I

J!jpdl p 3 3 '3+'3

Form.

"&-dl"

4

"JX;' 2 J$I& /

J.0'

+-

&I

'y "I

41 .(&IJ

d 1 4 "&+" ) bIA3+I

G L S ~ ~A Y ~ ji I~ j l l j L & I -6

> ~ j & S ~ L ; i ; J l & ~ ~ + ' p' j

h.3

LG&'U j-l

&LYI

LMI

b ~ J + j ~ p

J!1.&pb j L + A J L & & I d ' >+I& J L b S Y l "+I +,W 'l. 1I'

-

& . t 3

i.l>*$I

I L f'ch!

<">JYI'

>l&&-j

."ucl;L, >pj431 *t-j .'+cll

Lgr,>,Yl+ipllJ*'"'

+ k jj.'ks +WI

j k L Y lj U I

.&I

i+JSIj

.uc pa

U

jY

I >+

&-I> LJ+l

a '4 ~ &I 2 *I3

.,&I

.i) k;ku+ j b

-

;u-&I wl &;~j & J!ZkLu!j

+jUl 3iiULu

hL;l&! Correctness) . ;irilpPII l+u3 1-

U3 .b12hi +JI

.l.&b*Al

++" 9d

'&.A

$

+b

bj , +&I ~p . , ~ g b y ~41 ~ 2

l l 2rJ.1+L;rill 4i &!>I

A-&!-&I

L " ~ + u "

+bJ

j - -

r33 6 - b - . 11>J9~11 'hi3 &+ '+r +'&I ++I

3-

-9 jk J+1

L2 " f l ~ " b

iJS-,& -

' 1 Q 3 + 4 p '

q 3 Y l ik?j$3

bL

I A 3

2 Wep

3 b 1 Lil

.&;dl

2 kl~

Hermeneutics, pp.159-161. (.u)

& &I

NL+db

Lf*? Mens Auctoris i ;*..i---c~l

.

"d$l

$1,

.WI

+~t:~;+~';+J$kcs@>+luj~

Hans-Georg Gadamer, Truth and Method,Continuum New (*) York, Introduction to second* edition,l999, p.xxx.

&I

i i+"

'> c i i * l ~ +c+~

L+ Lii A ,JCI

2 kL,41 -I

.&IJ

:-l+

L ijl! ~ .L L- +UI JPAI I

sF 'l lj'

&

*

&Ul& 4j 9

J

>

: *l;

P--41

~

+I

~

I

*21

'LUI

9 t+r~ &L

*

~ jt+ p~ 1 2l 3 h~ i~

d p - &-ill $ I;

LA

-

L-~I~#I

1-

~

P

&-J Sache 't+41" iP Mt+41/aI-illU Eig ijjat $IJ .t+41p

* 61&~1t

:

+'&I

lj, J, J, .&i +LG

LL G aY1 al-ilb 6 jk j Y! 'w Y L.& LA* &-JL;;II -'41 +

&

bi .-wI>

>+I

+ .~ g &y c

I

.G.i

L

C Lj ~!k

+i &Y p ~ j l k ' L LIWI q~ &I j

+;> -

l m l

d-il~

;?,c+-

/OIAI~>?-

-L2

d~~&LYI

.&WI ~

I

~

-41 J!

~

A

~

~

I

~

~

I

41 ' ~ d>\-ill ; ,Jxg jj 'J.4 + d l j p j l U l gJ1j l $1 'yJ'g3J *I .- >+I +z Y y ~ + ai 2

i5;l-ill

Y y1.4 i&l

-J&Yl

1-

I+U *I

*I'

&,,b.&Id1 j l++b - jyl j'aHJ1

j

Jj Geist " y>I'

j l U I p J 1 j YfLS

j - J- W ~ J5 (JWI j - j- l

j y l ~y-3J

~

~

+3$&

?l>k

a;

&\%;

l r l ,&!, ; l s~

$JI P'

'u ;L-3

Negativity

;ya+

&i

*3

+

ieXl3 iltJj

G.+

++&I

ifL&

UI3

Y3

J-

+Z

&

jl! 2L.i 4r

'IJLIII

I;L~ V+ dJ; 2 V+ -11134 ~s~~+UI 6 4j ~

Ju&-dl l

ji &

2 s*P J& G U I +&I

b JILI . ;N -.J z"I+

>

ib3J&I ik 4 - d-

j3) j LbUl +\-dl 2 $kY

.(pYl

dj 5

'

.Jj U l

+vJ"-III>kn$&I

&'A

J G I .(i+UI

LC

+$I

ikr-+q1JS

>f13

Y

J

LUX

j+Wi

f a j+%i . u u ~ ~ $ J& 1

6

21 ."jb$13 2-91"

2 3.+Lp*i

U @ -I

i;)l

- -

Hermeneutics, pp. 165-166. (*)

! ZWI

'Apai $1

1 9

irkel~;db+$~~d~t;y +L914Y +>$I

iJ-S; L&i YJ : @ & b$lJ

213

c.9 & &.-p 4'4193 ';+dl

u-'

Aesthetic '+Y

..

;#

3 +J j_r9;0 9 ' i + & l 2 dJ'L'-*r C-

i&1

kb

I &I"

/

o Y

E&

J!yI+

04

C~n~ciousness

9l l + h L Y I

*I'

-

L9 1Jls Subjectivizing 'k;lUI r U!" 31 WI el&% $bi3. 2 1 d 1&I 9

8 3 8'

>UI

->

2

J@

- -

236

ll'+yl

& +I

21$1

J-L

~ t+y l 'hi-5

a,&-> .9

2 1hill *i,

b "I&'&+ > aKI,>! iAll~*+-

L&L~

41 Form . "$.All' J

1 4 &JL d

I&

&JJ

Y j i i 5 j y l1 -

h.$ conten;

l

I;* "

j d l "

9

2

&L&

*-@

,JI

b3

214 +L &+

9b j

4 1 L+; L h j J+I IL&'& ;is4 i lLb U C.l&I ;i! PI is JI 3,-GIU b J&YI j ~eh ; i

Y+i+

' b J.AU L A : 'k~+i 2 4 -di + Y d i A>

~ic + ~ p ~ j ..dl..S ,\ll

+4~~c3~~&~'i+t+ & JP; L! ! " d.. . l 3 1A+'

'&;r~i;~

d ! ' :~&I

.. 2 ..iJw 2 2141 .+

..'J;LILUI

JU A

+ M I L & J & ~ Y L-ILb'+..+&~t"sn &jE3 +fb

-3

+"+ dill ijlill @I3

3133+I

2p

i+I

+Li d

'$2"ic'!jydJl3 .L&> #

5 J k iil rjt j .j t - Y &!I &S3+.d p: 'j.43 .>RJ1 ?j&Y > I ' ~ ~ . ~ ~ ~ I ; ~ L U I A

*

LL*, -* .. . 3 J% &cu~~ j.~ j i tsi !c3I td-d~;p~~J J)c; 2 Y3

'JJI ~r?, 4d-il~ JIGI J!

JK; j.3 i>y--~ .&I

J+ Yl L+ +-3 *L ILb U f-~+ $1 &I J-JI Y ~t 2 .eu~k~ 3 1,I ubL , 31+WI IL 2 1?Id1 @I 2 LA j L % L\l Y!-+@l+Wl IL

2;

+

99

Li

9lia3 .U UL.

..

#I

9 9

.t+

j K &dI ci;G&\

Ju;13wu .

p

>-ill

l

9 c,gr

el

I Z b

- .

* *

LIPk

JeJI

& ~' i-

i, L ~ WJI ~

d3 dJ "J.dll'' Das

&$I

b+

$

I+ :&YI

J+ 1

pug

~;ia;~:,

Lgl yi *kl .Jlj;lJIJI

--I

9+:-6&u

&pi

;>I

ji & b J d l

~

'LW L

&dl

yL!

i I+"

J

t

I L &>$ ,dl

9,

;c--~Jk" >iiJy &I! '*$L 'zL

. *&i-

i:,G)U

&'i 5 :,*$I zlb :,p (*)~leibendeWahre

5

9

c u3131 ~

iJs4 J! JW-

+ 9$,jK &-ill >:u +J 2 &-&-ill *>I

: *2>-9

9

- c j-I; ,ji,j91L&k

9

rb

I

9

y% w

.i.1

I

:-

&i ' , j >KJI ~ *>I

iP

LI ;ISU

.. 'Z&&I' 4 +l

*

l &>

':,*dl J! ji GI++

J+ 9

j l l Z i + & l Truth I

iS-il~';;)~J

u! 1. -

& p;! i i;LCYI> ~ ~

L IL;f J l i l ,j!L..-. . & K ~ W I ~ 9

..$iiYb~++,j9~w~dl*J

+y1

3-Y

J-I

21 +$k

9- - L L - ~ ~ L I

G A I :,LC! 9

;+,jL.idr;Uw Y l & &

i j $ l Mediation

.u+ h,, 8 4.Lp&I

J-JI

I

J+IJ

'L>''

a*"'-

Ibid., p. 169. (*)

.rs3 A

.if'& p~+ *

iJ J--I>+WI

j .09 3

*>-' '

&&-&'I"

~ uc

C

~ ~ $ 1~ "

C43

j c y 1 +I

>Ci

+.Liki' &-Lj .&I

f&

&dl

I

+j;3ij+12+3rr;ll~Y+

JUI

cA+

61ir131>J jlX. Y >+r*yl 2-1 ji . . .''J.--' I .i& ' >i 6 4 uip;jil- Y ci i > ~ 4 Y u+4yl 9> *yl& > I d 1 ap # G I +> +J

>i +?I

-

c;*U

.&I

2 J aLk.

pb)

+;;rp>hlsLkll> *I

‘&llJ*kfp-Y

E r.;L d $ *

C

U )"

2-1

3eJ4 L>

> d l+&!I1' +t

+J & yl>k dl>J 3 > % : 4>

L*yl U3 &KAY I Gki I&03 d j1 3 Y;rll ifWI .;L t& , i L-I 41'~931 /&IUI' LA1

Aesthetic

"71

2i.l&lM

2Lsll

9 tl&1+

' .i &L . ~ 2 I&>

.-+a

rL+Differentiation

Aesthetic non-Differentiation . "+yl ~yl)>+i?WI~+$~J_tzll~~I

LE Ls;L~~>+I +jl~~~ 9A 9Y> j d l .buI&b&>> & J *b 2 r& >iJy I 2

LI

h - p2J *yl 5

Y!

&I

&I

illc 2 +>I'$

a L d3y u !

;p

&-I-&

ULPf 31

2 .;is&\ 2- '%+I GIUI d3 41L i L pI.- 5 27 2 '4>F 9&I ji .>Tk3 ,&.!

s

-+3

3+

;I,UI

l j&-lib Ji; b u 4i;

dd

& &-L,+j

b'

Q+$3

Gj LL

.PSI

.rb$ILUG dUil

.+%I

&-2ji

JK;

3 3

'99

?*; 41

'+jN ~g;!.LA

!G ~ ~ J I

+%I

rJ U Y I U J ~ ~ J L J ~ ~ ~ + - ~ J J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I + & i > W l $ UWYI oh >p-Y - y d l . 9

kc+

wij y W I +*+ & 2J.J 'ir-:p-

+GLJl jI &I3 5.9

oJ';

.pg4Y3

"&LY1

3 J" U.

L. J U l p L $3

+

ULI' blj-

Y +&I

2

' J -

L&-+

.iJri &Lb &-3 j+ J; T &I

dig3 JLI

& LU T JJiguIU +-3 l'eI)I ?I&,Ls $a kfpl>k 62 T jl;K. -

w 3 + 4 + & u : ~ & + b > S j i ~ j . b ~ j! JP;

5. 9

>ie3

Jri 3 Played" /Js +& 2 "3;.F-"+&I

.J-

9

a

b 'MA Play

.&

i j g cp

H

Il+II

ll;i;3-11

Clrh; G & q

+ -

1

> 2gg +I& 541

& L o s s i d l j ++I

4;l-i

9'

3)C j l a J j . w & l obiJ J b W j 41 y,j .Ai y,i* 2; +.,-k ;c3%1

4&k:b W j 5

c

. b I ju

Y

I

Y! b

.'bP &2 Y

-41 %; ji 9 b & Y -41 ji di 5 -YI

2& 2 +Jlj

&,dl

8 3

Mediation .

;yr

L> i l i 9+-A &I &Li

.kJn-lI&i;yr&h+5U~&f

j,&t.fr&-L;r+

jL

.&I&'+

j ~ 6 ~ 1 ' kd - $'1

Jp!

J!L L S b;i;Cu

L . + ~ I ~

&*

a..+ ..-'

I

'41Y j :y a k

jp&s5Uld9jY b a m L g l

ji I+i,-L;J

+I

y a G 3 w J!e-v&I

.L623J!

& @ J? @ b f

& .+"~Ju'~;I~d!++ i j ~ 9 3

-1

2131lhjJk, +$1

l

-"wL~ $+I

LUi j!

. ' ~ W r& LP'1&.441 WUI b*3.

b

II

Llj

a-'

ji +I

$p 4 &

+i 4 4

i+

ex11 1j ,>&I

ji & ji! +!I

&5

2lJl LUi r& "ap+dI" C PI 14 +IJJI

;P >&I

pJU $ yaY4 jl +&I '+I

L &

e1JIM b .&

J!

IrJ! &->

L ~ dlLa+l

'&+

L A )

iliz 2 "

ji

>A\

21

p2p

3~

J.1) &I

Z

ilL'4il !&I

IJ.eJCI Die SacheSselbst 9

G2~

_

PYI

I+ Y Ll .bl-s

. 'l>F,ll

4i! i iLjll

+.

P

jf

J--"

g

J

'y ++I Lo

:

.iJw l J w! .*h; l j '4) 2 &dbi, bi ~2

~

k613, -@I

9L &> . ( k J J J

IL

GC;~I~

~'b>p ZL)- ~3 r&Yl

+&-'

*+

a;'Up U l & d l

- . k j. c l l l k - &dl&&I

+I

'y

L

+s ILLs .&&A?! d J 1 J L ; J)C;~

bl+ t+bk

L+YI

JS bI.2

/&I

+ .- b p Ji.91 Ys ~;-+dlj J L A l y Jlfclk i.+j ~ j s b b JL;I;!.~+~A=,~I :

&&!Ss'?"! GWYIlJYI

: ;&I

2

L J W l

j i .C ~ ;L p

4 L G

J% ;r.~ JL.dl

+j L A U .$A&

6-9 ;&,dl

4

.Ly! J&

$ J 5 +IJ

&I

j l i J%&

;.,

Ly&

;ijJ j JdI & J U I & &C5\- 1 - J1 ci p S d l & i L - I

~ I J A Y 'y I .+.dl

+LJAU d i y +->

'.s"' Y LP ~ ~ c -~ . ; t & & I J d I J ! / k ' d . i l g l l d3 ~qlUl& ;;5&1 +yl ;+I j3l&> 6 jjL

2

Glkll 4 1J!JEt

+'c$$\

/u!YI''

.

I;kj;#

;ibd!- d*;.YIj & k l L .2 h- 4;i b pl+

IgJ&

. b l j L >

&ill

-2

?

+ -&

J

C

& > ~ i ~ ~@KLI:L+ i -

01;

bLj .

'u Al;+ U d-

ip-!I" ji

kjj i+\

4 1;,+

218 +&L

ji LJ L+

&b

ig

/$I1'

9

.&IL & x . a

2 1I*

pgr '"'&I J",

G%l

I1&Yl P

~

xu13

y

i+I

j j .+Id\ L L ~ + \

dL. y% L - ~ Y Y Y

LpiIJ-eJI

I

; r JPJl ILji ihfjLS, r+- Lpil % ipl~ PI : J ~ i+l - .L ,~ &+"

$1

rX$elli

+-dp a+ w9

J

6

S/,J

subject '1alAl'3 ! h d l J-eJI- %+a ji '%is ~

~

Js $ 1 A-jC+

i&

&dl 9 0

J1J &&I

,

!~ J P J I ~ & C ~ A J I ~ ~ ~ ~ + I ~ ; ; ~ J C - . J >x3

& e u li &+&b

&-+3

u3&3 i 'y Wl &&I l&+L

A dIL FI>kjb

J i i i 2~ .-Y ci$

Y I! &dl - $JJI

*L+i

r+

.ip&I~

&IJ - 4 1 + e3.,

j

y *&-I

J, +IUI

- j k&&JaYlj l

q y 5 - Y l j~>+l

bb

+b

.+I

-44$1 & ~ jA j

+YI

&A&JJl

IL &i

eudl

Sj

J-eJl

. I 3 5 3 ak1;> i . U Y I 3 Truth and Method, pp. 101-110.

A

ji j p -Y i ?New Criticism "+&I

&I"

'pdIJi 9UII-.'"

' 3

j Y \ +-> ~ih,lli;UR+J&~j;l,d,l>,c~~

.. ,L;y1>3J

ad>LLI~

3

+&,dl

; ; J U >

'4-11 wlU:G3 &>I'J *~jxrl & pA +j?r Li s+ upd Pre-Structure .u&i-?J~~

::

J,

aIJ+INJk.Li3

1;>Ppre-Conceptions .

L&c;jibL.+#b.CUic;j~

-.jrt.+4&1J+&~.. .

ai LGb3.&-JUl&J

J+l

L J ~>i &L;?A b & : J+

*va,j &

J'

A L L 13 1~

lh &

+ a -

~ L J ILrllli %+

i l L y>i I liJGyIj ~ & +, U

j+&ll

+J\!~,(JLF.

&I@I

+dl ' L

-Al3

j4

1-b21

dl jl1i+1

+I

- 3 L&-,L-

Jj+ . MiL+ll'jd+91

2

&l+l1

w-i 3 1 4 1 A :JI-1%

L+i +LL~

+

&L 9

+JI

L & ~.P>I

&.I0 : L&y

& sr"4->9 &U>*3 &-,UI

.sldl

p j - &C-J-\J -

& *

;ilS 1L-j;

F

:

bI Y l

L i U l dlJd

+21 Lq! e l + J JObjectification "krby" Lii +&dl r3"l pis &la &I L >+> .+"ip+9' ~ L I , A Ij-++iiF @ 3 &I cigLi k

j

~

r

C

*

.

ji & +LdUI itLI>AI ji J!+i3 L+~LJI I

"U'

ylak & !,

1

I

.

L

+

l

1

+ d L LA Geisteswissenschaften . (hsJ)

L,AI + a31;

"-+&I'

. d l ,y'41 &la t+lI ali 1

&L jiJ

;+ .

b+,

JL jkJP + L J ~ji

c rd ~l i J A l p~'+LdUI

llw iiAl I1 &t -+'&Il

$ +,.A4" +& J+

J*

2.I\&,'

+JI

l FUI

r l ~ Y .(L.)>IIl

llk+p

%I

0 1 ~

>&' 9

i

i;fl+Y

9

++A & A ILUI

39JAnonymous

((cY

$91'

' 2 . l, Ij . ) )leb b I &&I

'

9

ruth and method, pp. 218-242.

(t%)

I L ,Lbj 2 Lifeworld 3 eWI jt.erJI ) ,

.

.(?> &-,Wl/J.J

ir... WWI +LAI+II

Oi;

jLjy

*~r

G I ~a+ I

,J+

r]bl I L

. 'il;LI *I

JL&I

+WI'

~

gLUIl

I1"l

r]Lcl1

,.+ $'1 +>

ji

Ibid., pp. 242-245. (a)

@-+

9 '

~ p 4 - c,+I . ~

u-\r!& d l )

+JI

'12+3.1

'Aji

c+g

GJI

rg3

,

,

+WI" ' G I )&L u 244;lAI

+Wl r~j;,-j

jL+I

6

wI'

-,(+WJ

;',,

'2Y j I &J

cS*

I"-.

ikiS

6-1

+LC j .

&ot.

jLj$ljL~'L+.i'~- ; I& cF-

+

I'

I

j%l

+

U

I

U

b,--

.L+y

i

L;-* aL++ *&Yli+ JS $ &i JSc;j . c c g k L jlu 2 y ++ j + l 3 ! & b ~ i z i . $ 3 i.C + ~ ~ ~ e & : ~ ~ +Wl j !.ILL 9

'w'

3

C

c;tj JSL; k P k J iJlyYl

L> .(*+

+$

/U-I

ell- j l

-+I db 2 G+

393

WIj &J

UGI :JI y-JS

-

i b ji i L d . 1

j

L &I) &I

293LS

e U 1 3 ++$I

yj IL i u I

+L j$3

jl+r +b &I2 +!+ 9'>+$I +U1' j l 3 .GIJ\ J 3 1 +Wl 3 1&+ 31 ~9 &!4 & .r'-91 !F -3 2.h-j&~L+I&wI'& 31 ++ j ;4 ~ Y

+*

9 3

&LcT;cl3+34~

.cJ>

?+ ?*P

#

&b~tl"p Hermeneutics of Facticity ( ' b - 7 $1

+w 4,

$1

G L y ! d ! d \ 4.

4 .'+\'

+$I

.

JS Y 1$ 2 1

I L a(+.

@ I L

.(+li$I

bGLy1d!u

ijer JSy uUL; I L A+

.+L*l

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i k * J ~ i g l f * i t L I L C ~ ? @ ~ 9 P, k4! 4%234 +LLi b! "-'iP3 % 'e & +I : +Y I L3i ) LflY

+

+

,,

f+-

.(&A:!: j p a ≪yl .>*JI+&+ ,+i

>*3J &~

4I L

G@J

+2 *!+ 'u I+, ~ ~ $g e ! $dl 1

+-2 >U+

I Ly

lh .j

L y \J

fl*r

+- Thrown Project - 'rW! ~ 9 &I "

pl Potentialities

'&'9

+JA &.,.dl +-3 i d .LUI *ifiJ *.: +s .

I'LL&9 '

0 L

lj, 3-41 $ p d +&+Is '>L -3

r l O h j : rzui JA

9(aljlJl)

& Y >UI

+

LLI 4.

>u\

: ji j

ijb$ X W l + .I

i-;JL.

'eJU

i " :

21 ~ L Y I >+I+

v~+~+l;ligi.c&ll~

+&IJ >UI

*iJ

2 I+

~ J+Gs I

L L h +Wl j3 pLj.!l j Thrown

jt'&i+?4~0

&I

j kl,

. 'di+-.$dl3

G L I i C i ~ > ~ ~ j L' ~i +b - j

&jJ 2 '&kJJU qu!

+u\ bi &-I&

.w13

' d @ l L ~ & * ; r ~ ~ ~ & - ~ + . - = d & l i ~ ~j- ~ l

& &-.@.AIJ +U-L! L I+WI ~ ij-' '+J

d% -I

pee; Y g U I @I i;bj.!~ 1-

d i

+-yL1'

Ig_sLc

&-J A l l 3

+&I

3

>UI

The Histosicality Of Undesstanding

el3

du!&1 dllj, GUI @I

,GY I

p.lb

y &la1>UI

Wel- "+WI +jJ' -I&W, G L I j K .>Ul

31

~A...o

++

&I

+ S I

33-b

':'

.

2

're;"

&ad4 I3 +I

J5L GU-I Tanschauunp (world view)

c U Y I j&JP;dl +,WI

2 ?+i

Ibid., pp. 254-264. (el

,+dI>pl~Gj~+

;J\I+~

3 j V 1d j j i b j

a I J y - c +

U52I

;-3+i;llj

ji

&I

c,u kgr

. & p l %I+;

31 --L $ +I41

P I

&L4

.*GI

~4

-i

21j

Y Li

J-eS +i

jij i P U I

I-'

idli ;P 4

j .+!!

j .

J>LL;j i

Y >Ul

2 01jji

&I; 3 g b

.L-s&

1

Li! A U 1

L ~ ++ Ij3-

$1

+-il;i\

+ ~ ' ~ > l L ~ l j i ~ ; & @ \ + ~ ~ l i ~

j '@I

+El'

+S

U i

jll

l+.+ ,

,G! +I+ LP) GJLkll +I,JJI

I U

-

jp ,WLj

k;tll

.&LLI

#

i >Upg, J5. 2 ,+Ui: h e - ' j - l l pE+IN3i-l

92

4

jp 4

+ d L dli juI i L .+GI

* 9 , ,-9

3 I;J! &,\

+S

11 4

.GJu! ZY &I

5,9

J g l2 GJ3

9

~ Ib J! I'J fGiJP

+I2

2

#

4 +.A\

. j J.G

+-,U

GAL , q s ~ -&! ?Judgement LGi j? L$ j! & (*)~ightenment & & d l j~'' : &,b\ 2 GILL! b I

EL- "y&l"

Lgl +I

..&I

r G y l ji J$l

kJ*i/Li LP) Li!

4

f l

i+l~ f~~~

."0~~- h m J U I

i+

.~iii; jI;6 .j%YI

s

>i '&- +$

&=&"I

.

,+

Ibid., pp. 271-277. (st)

JSL>&-~Y+AI 2 s4d -

>L;LI-

+I; .

J.jCUlL J I +3-, I I++I ~

2 1i -L .4 ; i l

G Lj .w

++UI

'&Ill

: #I

4/ U l SY L

YI

L g ; ~ ~ ~ I ~ j ~ I @ l ~ J S & j ~ ~ +Ir

3 b 3 4 - ji & Y j .LU.GG .kJL jl pLJI &I>

%

L+

>j>

C ~ l ~ 3 j & ~ C j l - f j .

y?&l$I

ig

&dl''@I ' 0 U W l & ' A,

9YObject

"

b

6>Y p+Al &&MI AS&

+"I

I L .+ Lhhi &dl&l$I j .

3, !;;*lr,++ L A ~ & &'J3 ~ .C' ~ e j + pL ~p 'Lu i J e -41

C>

+I

+.JII;bg>JS&=+Y

JrLbtllj.

&. I

+J+

j.

r,y

-

Li>.~$l3.")-Y

&L.G @I j T #k j'I

hj( d b ,i &I)4jldl +I

did!

P

l

i t~ -. ~It:

Ci!j i C_LI C;JI

J! .&!;)I

&

3

J~wl

J I ~ \@Li . e l 3 b d I jl r;kl Yt 'SI;)13 eJUIyj lhL>lj++J&rj! !+&I

Temporal Distance -M>l%Uli)~ (T)&

9P U l j +LLl

j;! (jLillj$I

+-Y

,i,eI 6-. ' . C

di

;E:?~'

k ! b I j;!j (&JJ&

Lj

*+$I)

p

.''++a&

j4 ~ - 3" : y l > k J+ .i+

LL++JI

9L ;E: +% d Y I j +lrJl 9

ji J!~ I J 04 L ~

*&-JL.

l& yl % "&UI" \ \.La .*

>&I$

, Hail we41 #

ju d~~ ++JI

*%

+ji ~ ;Yi :di*jilj

<I,L #

.+I

~ + j iLglb j

2 4 1 u-i +>

/2f

;+I1

4 - Y LLL~ " d l OL-L

j !

2 - ? y t . J.d;J LiJ 31

&I;

.r +Iy

4;sp

.4

&,eS

'

r b K i +p Y 3

.>+j

+>

&A\LA tds4!j!.>; +i"S 3i . d k-;IL . . t d G p l l j , G++.h+ ; j l j L 3 y b Y I 3b$- bi + Y r dt+i ~ +A1 #&I p~ b i b;! &I+L ++&I

d3&

/

$ I,

'9

jii+12

b ' ~ 3

+Li 2 ..U i .J L .i l Y , j i

J

b V J S P ~ u ~ V I ~ K ~ . J L . J~ l lI l l+j >~ b p $3'

& ' p G $ lLd&. .&

kbhl&

& +$I

iiu\

3

#I&@gp3?29L&d,t$l@ i i u ji &+ I A .+., Y +$I GUL~ :L -1iLl -. . L,IT -C

St ;'$I$ * ; . I I

L g ; U -4 j!+$I

~934 ++- 4 3bii ~ e-

' J + ~ ji ~ ~ ~ -P C I

2~~+I

@I

J!15,321 >3P)~d+'b-j i t J: .'*)"I"JI

j!Lg:

+ii9I.b &! .b,W3 >$I J U Y I J;W GIj b +La ji +d l Aesthetic Distance 11+~1

r&

iiUI1'

i ~ d l $ ,p.JI j .+k i L & A U 3~ 6! &I

I&

!

& G W IkJlk Yg +I&I+L AUI Fji 1053

> 4ii >jll

9.

k i j i&LJIL!l

: i

+dl

>$I J U Y I

lbid., pp. 291-300. (s)

:~ l d j ,( Y4 ) ~

*-

L+&&l d /LYI J X ; ~ G I * L ~ Oj&I -~j i + ~ p i p 3 L ~ j l l p j @I 2 &I Js LJAI JX; jlj +>I G U l c+ 1bj .&-JUl & &~.ii Z% A b ~ 5Y' L+ p 4 &I

p 3

"

+ A

LLPd &dl +*LI

I&.

~9~ 3 X J UA

~

b j5'

J ~ d , b ; p c + ~ Y r , . l I ~ I G + i S Ltr' 1 o L L _ j 3 ~ f ; I J

~*;-~lrj,r;!i~UIdLj+&p-"rj..C.

yli iQ & ,+dlJ .I+L

b

I ~ L

jL-i d &.A!&

& &dl I 1 ~ * Lj i Ll.& . r, a\ L l e 4~. -l 1r'' i d-l ye j 4 u 1c- i~ 2 L&I+I Jb i s J u,+dl .+I! AI+II #

5 ' x3

~

y13k4

@I 4.

+li Y j uiljll;cili

8 +Jl -

e

..JIJUI

W I Li!j '+I

jlj"

J+\

&Ja

+$I

I L .+Ulg

2 + +I

iJj+

W I &a rcsJwl

2 kl 'I'L. . c6;@-JU\ A!

Reconstruction Of The Past &\flF@hlf!(t) +&ip~kdLIL,+dl+dUIL+lL~-

..

Application &dl"+l(O) #

'!

+. EL('&I&I, Y k;;I 'f-*. ULb J A b+ i

&i

21e

~plicatinn1~+i9 l' 2Yi

2&;I. #lJI

&I lib

,9

y

+ .+&I u~ % ' IJ

A3Ql

&+

l .L&lJL

+&j

we41

i kJj11~ -->uI

41 +kJ+i ~ I+ i JUI &.-

;rkp: t

L

ji A-Y &c;lul US'jd A!; .>ylhl13

iJwl0-

++ u+j

@ ji 3 ~iY iclj ~ i l r

2% kl&I o L jJ,9CL+ ;I~ .&\>I L!UJ U

:

'Understanding

&I

3 CI*;iY

I3 'Explication 4 1

Ii!:,

11 : -I9 9

LU "pL" 2%

1

L 4j++

/jwlj

oL,Q Application .

'6

If@

a\'

,

J!WP I

i

09- j &= .. Praxis ) " 4 I A 1 '

.,++.03

&J'Zll> e

iJ\*. -341

pi 9 &+dl J4 L i U JY j i

l ;ikr j , @EL&YI IL .(Jd

k;rwl~+d

&: p ~J-~ k

Truth and method, pp. 307-3 1 1. (a )

>>'jl-l

?lib

#.

+ k,_i. 2, - Phronrsis

&cS; Ig.i 9 in+Ji iSiJ,kkJI

.&

du2 Ju+

ill;LIN ',rWl

J&

2 ''&LJI

L.s&I"

(

s

-

)

A L j!

G&l

& *ul-kleJl i

,

.'ILfPUl

2 4 1 > & JS f l ~ b .&I J

~

& &-4-

j "jl;!

i d i l l '

' ~ ~ p l >i l ' '

J"

SJl"gi "bUl

ILj e j

& ijal&

a! +,~ k *Ig. ; . ~ $1 iidl jn +ldI dJJ+ Y ~Is;l; +L & 5 oL;;+I Jjbij,Jl G&l I++

jn

*a 9Zdl ,elk1

2G p e Y j p-

.+J

J J ~ J I I L ~ ~ * ~ - J I ~ + ~ + + I & ~ + .A\; i j i j '&I

.LJai_tr -,

&,i.d~j .?IS&iJS;d kj)lL;LI c j W l jn ;&Ig 2-

-2

"gt

j

keg0

Y jrJS=;rl,

Jl~t-Jl

~2 J!

plb T,J$

o

j&ul

ir-Li WJJ

.JUI &iJlj d l ;E! +Wl j$l j b 1 3 G U I

+ )Ci iliry: +I J4LAldlc

J2i.dl

,i

+J

L

J+

I ~_tr! Lhi$I bCS GI+

j&l++Lc+&+-Yi&3~

& cLUX .bl>l U

l

j&I

+L J.LJ

James Phillips: Key Concepts: Hermeneutics, In Philosophy,

I;r (*

Psychology & Psychiatry, 301 (1996) p. 67.

p'ti1' ~ 3 + 24LA& Ti-3 3 . / d l

i-+*-

-+ Demythologizing

u 1

i,

"d,+gl

P

Ih Li J U I & 2 jL& l + + q + p +iLI ;%:?.f /UI 2 &-+ill &I ir + U l j+l L h

*-IIL 21 +&I

"mI+-

2

. p i *LL. 9

9

jj

j!

4+3

y yj C

d!

L Y Ij+

i$

Ji +z+ >p-Y p q l I" 1 . . - 4" _t;;; j f LS .&I I

Y

.

3 jsii+Y1

;

- .* *,fl

9

I

+

.'-

byYJ

~

!

&

~

*-

JI&

A &'id #&dl ~

U

& y.Ul "WI

.o+

'!

& d l I ""

11

uL-XII $33

,Ul 41:

'

;141Lk,Y Object ''Q..&~" I'.

L++

L

dgL

~ w Ya3L9~~+tk,jC i~J Y\pr3 t> I L L ~

L;L ,.b

91.G

-

ji

.+UI -1

bi 'UI23

~

I

~

&I! + ,&

(jLAiriijlhiJ) .a L J jb

+bLJCTfj

L

J'L L*r $31#l>

LUJ

i+ &&j;s

L + k di)l L .iJ+YI 41r GI+ f I, LA,~,+VI

3 3 L&

Z'k

ji &&J

4 ~yx;

$39l@.~~k+l4$&&-+6~

I+

0bJ 'w & LA,

Q JiiN 1I#,.

*li

Lt-J,y+,II

WL,

k

ddl&

~JL. LjlP)4 t

'~YXI .ULL+Q

C

;

~*kr!&juuf#~

(@!/$$I/&wI)

&-jul /A1 '&UI 4

_c41 3 iCpi L

.*I'

3, b _ c j lIL 3, ;A . f l J l l l 3, *%~i

&4

$1

1-

~

o --

JgLl

ji

1 5 ~ ~

Jgi' I IJ ~ W +-,uI

TI

z w L G ~2%- 3 #I.+ , 4 I& > kr

~ 1 1 1

j;&0 "i;i-Li"

& $U41

mbpl>k

C,

+-,~;II

-

llLi.

d ld A L-

.p

C,

.yklI

h -

G% h9I++ Lk Y i -

T ~ O U)

u;.r $ Jaw' &3"' &31 p-j;1 (fi :+

.J+

't+y'-3 LY .. \ &t- LL! uip3 6% -Y

jlki >I> Object #

.tu;il

bJ 0:1,

L 9O . L ~ J

G&

LJWI h i l l

&!p I r k A .jcyPi L,L;p J ~ Y Ikill ++

'~i-l;iM kj-

+I

~

YjJ ILGJIi> jlki >I>

+I ~ L L0 I. i ~ j .%;L .

j i

& I d 4 +*,*Ul

a -

I

C

I.iA LLb I.l i p . d l p i Y I &&.I! U>Y

j'll

9*

I Lj . L W I a Y p l l j j J 3 a & p r l l

j a*

"G&'

>*u

+i~>i~g +>I

I

-Y

41 3) LYI

.&+Lli

9

JS

JLb! j +?I,+

e-

J3W\ y -1

G U I 3 ) Eiy,Jl

yk_l-c.. l ' 2 d + A l 1

Lpy"'$1

..

3

P

2 2 'rul'l 9,

-iip-Jii j ji;,YJ 019 & -p'lt3

.+

d 4

~ y - - ~ j ~ k ~ . ; i j k , i J i ~

& L&+

.4-,"j

Z/LC

+cS=j AljJl I& --I&I;

~5112 3 +-I

p

L.G*

&I;

u4+ .L ~ ~ ;~ r '1 ?+*w' 2 ~LUI491

r+~ j*L+i ;UUI~1- ' 'y k.l*d" $j l l clrY &I

+ I L Li f b Y I

3~ .b3 .

P ~ ~ ~ $ ! l & & ~ ~ - j l & Y

+c p ! t.~i ij~;. di & YJ 'it;Lul .(&-

&jb

+-+I3

% ' L

&3)

9.2

+%I

&3j

1

1

~

~

Z

1

II-~

bf -

11

z s P &'Ul U

@ill jL,-jWI *&$I

@I

&JI 3 UIIL

.OU

t..

p As0*-3

.

L~>!L+~I

~

G+T

yY

2132 - d3 - 5 LYI I

I

d+'u d3&s '3

j b J ~ ~-Q Z - ~y~~ p ll+Y1 ++Ill dy- j L , . W I

.

'ZJLJI L Y l & b b . @ G Y I

JIvl

.

4

U c l r k d l jlbl

.JiYl U l & -

L&AI~ .W i

+ I"

dl.!>LkJ,kJ,iil +A1

LYI ~ gj>jl~ : +YIA Y! +;Y '++$I

dfi-*&j

&$

l l-ia .'&Is;L;I

d

K +

I

1

9

9 : :

&jul

2CLll U I dJ

i+ly

. I1-ih1h3LYI &'k% ~ Ya I $9+

& jSj

i+I

. 9

&Ll!

>UI~+L~

JS 3 +I

- +%I

JL9 2 1By L+AI

2

~ k

- -

Hermeneutics, pp. 191-193. (*)

k+y $Lg

b>$

--

.d&A& ~ J J j i ; c ~ * l ~ L ~.+~g + ~ g j j W l +I

xF blk

.'I

o+-

b&

(i*)

~

2

:**

dl;bps J++

/GI*GI> yCM

gi~

1

j +

LY 2

-@4> Neg- "+I"

i ,/

> ' l +

:j :'A' + i+ +j ,9

"

U Y l Jj &I

si

1'"

p ; j b : ativity

JS J2 .,

2 63 +$I .4$LS LOS 'AU y%L r;& ~ * JGil I + Cdj +$I3 '&- '& ++

p,&J.d

I

*+

I

j .,+i'

.?UI

GldI G J I

2 JXP ..

&I

/

jf

i+l

.bjJ@ 2 16&1 ;c>3

+4 .&JI

ICj L

~ L !

G4.t.Y L

&I

I J (

9

2 .aj '.&b

,

yI>k

~+JI

ir;j 3 3c 4 . U

J--: &+ ji 0j

+-d&

&31

ji J!

d & * . L ~2 (PJI

t U I j ?$I

k-i .-

4b b y I j

J +j" .jl;y

342JI+

2j i

i j l +b

2-

fiiLJI

:,

-Is i !;Ib29' ;S;p ."+--jib - ~ - =

Jy Jjj

A'

LiLld!,=I+ +-27 ,jil

+>>I

& La +I

?

2p-" + uUI

Pathei Mathos . ''+

+A Gj '241

J+- ji b++i

Z

9

'd 2L;)'I

ryZ-J1 >j*2rJl dF- i 6 U l J-

jld!

. ' p ~ & i +-2 ;+U" : cpkJjL)!l + ,eJ I+ J, d ji rJ4 e+I +I LmL+ i&l S 2J-b de &dl 9;&I j L y ! ->$I Ji OLji 2 .a+ 9 ++I U I 35 j f L~L;I j s p Y I J! j % Y ,I +I J! o p * ; Y GrJcll &

J ;

3

j

k

J

I

Jd

.;+&I

2 1 id! i j l "

ji LQ~ L L NOL l *+

;+I

2

4 L?+I .kJw JI ujL + ~ c j d~ > k4 & '+- 4 9d $ LWa3,$U ~ I + I y L 5 1

& ji .pll

I+

--

aJ,$l

T~OU

m k F 4

. tl-ill JI

' ... ti! . r J l k ~ e+y 9Y '4 ii:jl LA 1A';. 2 jls- dlJ jJ4l zd2 2 L,02 :: 4

5

@-A \ i l dp

*- -& LA

6%

1

j

jl & @

9 .

&J

9

3 4i '2.J JL ~i)-.;sLA+L

:i, ei; )MI '&\+I3

c)kJ\

)G

"

I

. 9 .-

4dl )@I

%

'GJ!

. 2

di 3

"Nonobjectifiable" . d9 $Y c5d1

''-1'

& ;+/ I J ~~ 5 3 ;p &i & 41 Y i +Thou ji

L,+Li &dl&I

JS-

2 iL+I

JS + ,

L+'+

&I

ji *G-1 &. Y3 .&L&U l

"~ a i ' ~L

./ .

;J%bi & LA 5)LJI Jgp;Jj

,&

b

;+I1ji &.I; .&I J+l&l

$Lj

Y

.$1

~@L:JI

~2~~ *&JI

Z%

$"

J!41-3 -JI+"

.") +lS-

9

i ; .J*+ ,Ji ~J

JI+ +-J

*&

- a

i+lg

- cGJLjM Jlqr

+ J! "iii-tin + A/

tzg

0

31 -3

y~ j! .(>I) rjJLhll 'Lb L + a. ;+ . 'ad1 - . - . AJIY ''

+;dl

~ g k + g

&YI c uIL ~ . L~ py ?21~ ' ~ i - c i ' 3~- u

LSL

t

.k'+

~ ~ C h G% l l +& &

&..+ W L kli chs2 & pe ji '&&-

LLShi-

'ui*

&+ ~

'IC;;~''

j&$WI+>4YLAZ&I

ji&--j~+ -3

pJJ ji 2.L .JkJ~J--

4 -

9LA JI&I

j! &u

Yf

i)L .Lo13

'+JK1 Jlfy d

9

Ibid., pp. 194-198. (*)

,+A

Fusion of Horizons

%+I

j

i p J J &l~.&l Z+.1

J j L * JS j ;r~4-;r$l

' + i+

Negativity '+LlIU

JS"j&J j i l l *

+' : JIG1... dI);;

J+-

j! y 1 2 k

>I,+

J! .J

>+

cub

-*

&j

jUl& & *

UIJd2 kli & i&l ji I;!J G . J ."? 1 s C~ IS p > ~ ~ A& J j U I jJ U l 4 . S c LL.+L,> L;cbk3l;j2>JLxl IL.jF Y&i21ji+

ji 'UI~ 9'+I

JLB;*~L

Docta Ignoratia bl+

jLS L 9

.JjL JS 3 .;!& i l l #I uI&I

jfl ''rIlJI 2 9'jl S ,>Jl

j

IJ t+

LI:,

&J

$*,l i j J,:I

h GI

l LI:, -3

+?4 1'JAI

+'I

J*G ji

.+

-2

fb;r.~

r' CLI

Truth and Method, p. 363. (el

Lo fi4 Assertion . A+-

J? &I .&I

..# 9&I ji 9

& ji b J a &-ill JIG1Y- J l p ;p>lx & The Subject '&I ~ 9 ~&dl ' Jl+l ' 5

.P

J I G 1 c+

J, &I

:>I

pbii- j l ~ 3

+JI

. & j

!

+LYI

~ L I ~ JJLy J I 23-~'-i3kb ,,, ,

J?:pJI j ~ i ~ ~ l 3 p L C + ~ ~ ~ ~ j ~ J+-

.o+Ji J.ill

J I G 1 jii &-I>

F~ ji ;--

&I

!La '&R.G.Collinpwood > 3 v j p . c ,

JLy ji+ll

v-

-

~i 4 jp L*L>L - - k ~+&I $ : &,UI &jLl~ L I ~ u 4 ~ L V ~i AK JIG\ & ' .- +

- 2 - '>

i p l > k &jJ

j .

b+

Jl+Jl+

+ d l &I

I~JL . I

.,+h4Jr L J& & jl '&I &illJI+I

$

I

J

.-

j$ W I

J

aJW1 j-J 'u\$-~J .k i ~ ~,& s ! O

,

h

,

& ~ , ~ ! i & i h l j * + ~ ~ ~ l ~ & , ~

$ ip12b 294 .j%y!

& $ 0 u

& d l

.JU

>I &I

..++'

&I2

d.!zb>e &dl grll&&(i j9 3!'&.WI j j Y l P I 2 'y ->L "" &W .l

L+

I I

- . L& J ' 0 . 1 ~ ~

L.-

i i y~.!/I dl! &-JUI ul&l9 J\+1

&i9 9 - Y di j l .PI Ji4 4 /&I

L .- b F *U

~ Y -+L

+u aLh. 2&$$\

>wl

Je9 c4 1j A&-

y L i l l "p l L .L& t J$illJ &I

c+~b

agJ4(1 J

.I

~Jl .'J&% l.l ~ + l A h -

Fusion of Horizons " ~ b( r~ U Il/Jl+&l) I IL

+&ill w .312b

;P

?IJ

2 ry*tll

jk l i l j ~ ~_i 3 1

+WYI

pJl

31 % 4.4.~ +A4_ & U I j i Y l +_ci:LFYl 4~.S'3+i j i ; l i ~ 'a ,.*ir:WL ! -WI 4

JIJI +I

3I,4 3 4iNegativity - " l U I 13 ' h :+$ :JI

a~ u

+YI

ai-

k>

9

'

+ I.i)*l i

dF- Y L *Lg~bbi +JI

Hermeneutics, pp. 198-201. (+a)

&

t

La>

L+-

+

C +

t

a 1 j?? L # 1Z W I &> a+

Y>

#I

W

+-dJi .L% A+

-L*

I

63

.P&'YI JliJD$l o k l U I ?h aklU e l ;p>

++

pl~k

;-I1

;\>I Ldal >&-

&U &->&A

'&>

9

T&I

&all

j 'dp-JSJI' i;W

j iSWl++

gb;. eJWlj J r e ; l l I L

+*>

: pl>kJ&. j L d l

The Noeric +I 6k-w

JAG

LlUl j p

Jy'Y~

9

9

jLk; J+I

C!"

cL+i f j i

L ~ ~ & IjLh+ I '

a d l

Jjdl j &dl

j

LlUl j2 ' & ~ 1

e3

BWI J>Ly J;Ij d .l "v~&Y&&

9 1ik-j j! Incarnation : " bu j ~ 9 ~&Lid\ l ) i + b J *-TsJI "&I JgIj u~~ UU'I I ji i+ (b *&+ je I&+ & L 2 ~ 4 L K l 1 ~ . " J &S ~ j . j~ &Y

GI; I+&

4 Lg& JJ"? ji f ~ +fi + k! 5 2;b ~ f ;

a U I

I

+2 a+..+JyY~i+i

4 ..1&p .- &I ~'UI Ji

I

.c-k;&'U

&&Y

1 &LJl&.4

.OWj b alJJ&MI

$Ji'&+I

&'u 21>i *UI &> ji

*@~~*iji ! ! + I ~ & J I ~ L & + I ~ 9

&JI 'UI&:I$

a

p

4

j 9~ WI j +!+I

L ~ I U

U9

Ibid., pp. 201-205.b)

JL 9j t - > l & ,ji~ ji j

$+

u

-+,ILL -+ . ,3 iJIl-.

-

d .

,

-,

4

-

G

U l

7 4 1G W Ij! +-3

L

A+I

'UI&-

+\

J~~

L" . a l l

2 +jL>I P

L w sjsj U I Js U I s L i i : db 3 j L y l

++~~~i;u~,Ujid /g%)l~ ;;, &hb& i ; u l Object .

Y

jL)'l+-

i

"pSyl' j j JKJI

+0-3

J+12

u3 jC;)lI Jlj-(+WI

. + W I 3 t i i l l l jg&jIiJLL3i ijy&

L.&&lli+

,yAbsolute "$LO" 3 r]W& L A l iAl$4 $ 2 1 ~~ 3 . ; ~ 4 2 -p Y!

;+%,Ia+ll.i

JAI

"4 tGp j.L3 .awl ji u3.UI 2i ' k 1 2

-1

.'+W& ,jL;)!l ;+I

w

&j& d l $91

~ f l , !i ; U I JX;p

r3ai >+I & i l U .%La

l h ,jCL

'&+ ;ij!yLzjl

* *-

;>s j j .+I a h &I3 L . 2 . A i & d l +LJl ;+ & j&k3 .ja13 jL>! && & . % ! Ii/Lc k;U!

5

-

Ibid., p. 207.

(.B)

+

uI

i

u + ~ Yb~(@ slxj-,ji ~ I;I.

&I

) +WL

I >yJ

cji.

.&-3iA\ i+

d&+ hi J l y -

Y +I hi 1-

L%ji J 3 k Y 3 rJ

JJi

+JI> ,j&,ji

'id&'

e-

&

pJI

J& L eL&4 1J L 6 3 3 4 1 j;l iiwb -Y+ b3.+!+-3 9

~LYI

Zugehorigkeit" )W& 5 9 . i j+i3

&+

4 2

Ld13u U Y 1 3

j I J! fl+

&I

++a&

.(.h;;YI

~ i j l s ~ i U : w l J G , r J l ~ * j ~ i ~ ~ ~ W ~ ~

J~IL

PJI

@L

L&+

b j a

.@

&

zJ3E

2 '+I' J G

*,' L U l J*

I L .3j@si $JilllJWl

?'

J!

Ml$,, ' lk

iw i;l~ . . wi

~PLLI

&

d l 3 d l L&

jl13d '+YIJ&YI

b L 3

&&I

' pu +&Y1 y cLiUl Li.5

.&Yl&s&Is;jLg;.lo;j j +.LCUl ;&I p2 1-4gklir1 ++I tUj;i;UI & +I

L LP) ' 4 + 3

f~

I L . i i L , iJ*

y b &J+I

L.5i+

#

I

'

Ibid., pp. 207-209. (*)

--

,jL-;yl p&

h - . * i 3 ~ ~ l j . + - J ~ + L " & i i ~

LU

L-,+

J ~ WjrI/i 3j .

,>A& &I

'I

st+

2 ~ 5J '1 + 2 3~ 'i+IN

A k j 2 &-& w jd A ~ J& JGy12k J& $9 & j

d

l

,jib

3 s-~I

2

Ll

2

& .

,

: ,?-La

'&A-ji f

>-jij

LL...L>~L~&~L~

..,

L i r ' L+ ~ =L=~ *-3 21

cjv~

c&i&$ YI i ~ : L s c ' ~ w ~ 6

'JLlfb J+IY

9-

Wb. j y j & i i u l y 4 i !

& I*,

+:J@l'+~ ..JLJI

& 'The i System &I

5-5

J.6r13&I

&J*+l -

a ~)Fi3

i - 3 ~

&dl

3G b 3

+-A

~

M

..,jL-.iyl

41 SG! I+i

'

ji d G y l y s

L&l ++$I

ji

tj.

#

j! J$

j L $ l Y ;~ J .l & U I

Lg,+ ;I

J

' + A I J b ~

I

-

~

,i ~ 3 9 +~i +L &'&13

-L

y

L

-31...

'~Yj.&p3>

P

J

MI

-:I

$3

dk JG&! : -1

jh,eW $

ciM;

. & d l ipj

u;;

6 2

~

Y

Phronesis "WIaAl

d L .3 ' 4 -1 JL ' 2 w

+I-

3 t+ ;',j&%j3 bl+ j ? L - ~ ~ + s ~ ~ ~ + , .&>q!

46 L&oj '+I)

3 j+%i A s.L J J U I jd!ij.y+

J!i2

jL>\ PI *i3 .(f +I

+>I LIP,

4.+,..i

3 &I

~ $ 3. c J b 4 . -

>I

' ~ $ 1 +I

J3L

gP I ...jL!

" + b j r i j ~j

K ; ~ ~ n

+&#L! 9 3 ) GAL & - I i l g L j! o

G

j

2 j+%i3 i-bl+Lly b L y I & +%-fll 3 4 1 #L\ji e j ij b Hexis) .) +L; A+3 +L 2) CAI3 + * * & d l +I! ji &- J*rl Ethics" ' U l bj3 .(+I Ethos) .. fl$yl &-3 LJl-Ll &+h:Jj yfll >bi3Ad3ii14p (d.+d\

2 Lps

L-I

bj . i b b &2

+.+ &

~

&-

al,JA13 aLU;ryI qj jhC

CLS; 4 l&f

&+d3 Ub J%

d I

'y + L y l iJL,&l

L+l

~

.

~

~

i

b

3

9b ~

LjLyI

~

J #

4 I

J

L

L

&

Gadarner, Hans-Georg. Truth and Method, p. 312. ($1

.*I

J+>;,;&l~pz;by-?lUji&lj.

kj41 j?i +J +:, 'r? j k , '9 ~(Episteme) %+I -%YI

41 jp %+I3

,yJ

(Phronesis)

Truth and Method, p. 3 13 (a)

Ibid., pp. 314-315. (.*)

.;i j i j &I

Y .J--"

p 1y- '

'&$I

Li LLJa 9 L - b

&>I

+

&g -4

9

'L+AI

+-3

9

L p d+&I

+5

LF-

1.bA\-221

GSVI ~ I , I > I i+ &JI &' -I '41 Ai Y > ~ V I ~ - d. $ ~ + d ~ ) X Z b ' ~ + + - ~ i + ' k l , p ,S

9

3 &I

Ju3~ ~ I p d Ll Mp i dFu i i > ~ , ~ b ! j _ z ~ J Lp p L J , 4i . 2>1 -->I +$I ++ .L4-b +jj Ai C & + I ~ %--$ JSL '

+&

d l jLiyl+.

i,i +SUI

+ji31 -

JS

G+I

JZ

j;!

-ii;Y

G+I

~r,

~ I G ~ + , l p j .! C W l G p t I j c d ~ Y l lhjc=

U j'i c@

&-(Phronesis)

-AiJ+

L.J~ !2: 'bL~&-u i : b i d 'L ;>@I

v-.

- - > a&\ & blj31j ;+I+JI

~1

AM

1 I;.

d

bjF-

2 6 - V I i U ?' 2 L 3 l dl U I Z&l (:; ) q . 0c5;9" 3i +9 i+Ji +kS .>Ul I,

+p

2

>>I

-+fWI -i.l+llj 04 , ,

+-

; + I ~ I -. bi bij'+I ~i \ i ~

++-

o

h

.$MI/*uI

w-L l g * .&

c5UI +&I

.+&Id; &&2 ip

o + - J 3 p j

a

Jy31J ~ Y I

'y L 4p

;isPLjll

*O .

2 J+ ~3~i& J

J ! ~ )-~ + I

L!,kd~&+~~4~jidi+-j1j~~p +ljk L i ; i pyI

+$I +,I

+Jl

-3

.&+ 'Lip ;cgi jjUI

p g +I

'I&-"

ckir

+

j I & Y L ~ > ~ ~ / ~ & ~ ~ + I L J Sj ,j

i

j

$&i j pJ .ul+l

Li

eE*&

n~&-~

u i .-'& &

+ i + LY

$I*: +itjli~-~,4j.+-Y~jlkl1 $9

;c+Ji2~3.

&d

Epieikeia (Equity) : ill&

9 js;G $ j i +,,i

~3

j4 , 7 + b g di - 9 3 z

.'a~;liJIp8 iflcktli" 2

3i- r ; f , j . ' . r z J l ~ l r ~ y j L : i i d ~ ; J g + ~ JL@I

2141LlPl

& u $ ,y,

j+WI

Truth and Method, pp. 3 17-3IS.

'J.4

(9)

&I

$ G W l L&b+=Jl

L+&

(

1

.

jI

.

3

-

2 13 3

.+L+

C;L+3 .C. .&L3 '&L! 3dlJ\$L5&Ji b3 ,j>u\22\91~y &li -4Jl % y L ~ U21I i L

i

i 2

K

J

/

2

bk&i

pkil +WL 2,UL

5,

P

*LLJ

&-&All

iJ3+4

yp

i l . iy'+

4p

.ag;m W I .bg;uJ

Z+l '-/y Y .&dls & M I & LJ+I

&-

A 3 :'

3

9j L Y I

>Ts+

+%Yl

u\ Z A I &sk;

OGl>

.>

x3 kg%+

d 3 I b & iJj P L

&I

I

j&-ku3lgekjaiqr+~$jpb+a+!9;

+- +%Yl -.& - I ;h3 #I i*i %3,j LA + U I J 1-

!&' -I

Z?

%&I

4 ji kQ

bi .&++dl &A!

*,I

j .'iildl d 3 ! b j .@+4

jp ji 'U& Y @%YI

4

.a& - - 2%

+dl ;r 3W13 '%$I:JI dF- jt

i+yL.J -I

~

Z+l

$MI j

td~> .Y .i~. 3

jk

i - ~

Y di3:ILL

~ ! ~ k j . ~ ~ ~ L +j&h - i ijb i ~ ~ (Phrone- kkJl&jcoJJ &,i b 1h3.$5

LLWI~+I +

+%&I

$1 +LilL. LL-I .. '/i +,+ I

r L j!

+2 iijb '2sis)

j i b k i &-3

+3

21

G&+

yS "SS-

q!+~r

;+I

ji

&LjZ,d ' ~ + ~ w

Y Jyi

LLJI

_U ,(*)+JJ

,ji'bi ; -I&

Y u ~ jU ! &L~I ~ &%I l l J?

S%Yl J? +Ul.+%Yl a k L a ! 3- . I&'j ) ~ ; i ; ~ ; r q_d; l 9t.41 J, ? Y

>'+I

.j

-

.i+*.@ LL&Ss 4 w j ) C 1 Y l

yl&l

2 1 *-& k6+ -- + ;u1 241 2 by .&I

&jJ 4 &;

y i

a~ LJA

hi

-?>

/3)

. ~ % ' b ' lk

a 1ai ++.A!

+jJ+

a@

a.

,$>3

&LA ip)(-

;jJ

&j>lo h

I Cj3j+L;jl J)C1 ;Y) +

,,-LA

+& -,

t~+

L d jhi 6J3+~

'*

&jJ

tj C

291ZJI 2-

L~'&dl + L+

'+

&dl&I

C

j p l l

(+L 9

ll+ldl~ $ 1 ' ~ ~ - 3' I

!

2

b~

l l & j ' l

& k~L.!ll$JLLhi9

I

j.".3&ijo+fw4& . ..

jiltjc+-3W&9

iJJ +

~

L

>

~

2 JUI LU~S.bG-+ai L+L ~

gJpj.+-=-4jJ&~~~~ ~L+-L - p $1 i j X ; Y l L$l (Nous) . Z&~S &L tj t I

2 j C S ~ ~ + & ' ~ p i i ~ g i r + l + ~ Ibid., p. 321.

(9)

-,.

.Ud

L

.i+I

2

I: I

LL o+lg

ji

b

% , d l ?l';

i+ .&'u

, -

>y "

k i Y l

8

6-L

< . Ly-YI a I + l p ,3 e

+/=% jS5'1

2 1dud1J

a 1

% j C )

(<+ )3u

Lsl-i

L $ 1

& Lijli 3 +SLY( - &_Lki I

,Jb! d I + l

,+w\,

y 2WL

Id3 . L L l l 4 9 1 J ; l l

w

4

p3;.

GIJI ii+3 S 3 CU d i ji Lgi9 .&I;

& Phronesis) . ) L i d .4& 4 +.>I elN &- '&-&I &UIi l ; j '&!-dl i i ~ 1 + .4-611

Sympathetic Understanding ( &"I-

+I

J24 b b .( \ \ r ' l

d 3U-I o &MI

b

+I

pj

'&2U/

I+\

'+La41

3 c e s Y I iiAI &.&I && " ~ ji & --+-.he ji +w.JGYI

uibL;L~+U + I'

s 4

PIJs

IL+L~ J U Ia -. . ;UI

~ $ 1

Li

' i b k L_;*!

-+- L +

. ~ , ~ ~ ; ! ~ & U I & & I S J I $ ~ ~ ~ ~

+ - j . ~ ~ ~ " z p l ~ j r L ~ + ~ l p ~ ~jij! * - l ~

+-%? J&l

,AIL+

JL

el 4

di 4'.+i GAI

u2

8

++dl +I

LJ&

Y $5

j !.Z&l o h

9 L. ~ &l+l3

,

&I Li+ $ OL,IJI,

Ibid., p. 322. (*)

I

I

I

&UIjl 2 j T ; i ; c ; J 9

Insight I-d

FJ

~

2 rk* LLs

b

~

L-43

~

j

~.. -J

A

A

k

li.

&-g

i&j k J d ij%-Yl ~

~

~

~

~

-'+

Jh b: ~ s

8-b

4 koul,al C+~3

541 8

4

+>-dl

+

4

94 1 .!I2Lcd&-'L&

2

~

+,*I

+%

ji 'b-i

qk-J +i+ig

2 f l )v%l ~ w3 +%91

ys*;ll 4;j Deinos . (+I)

''&*-LII"

p g

c~+%-YI

Ibid., p. 323. (s)

-

b

.&-EL3 c L/

~ &i L

~

diLd

I

-

G+ +~1j 1.LW

C

-

3

silks J5 +A J i l l

kr&I

+,%'ill

+; i

>iJzi ji _ ~ i,*?il r

i>

-

2 J& ji ;cj-Lell&&i2 ;

. i J- i &iJs J ~ br;&l i-j' 2 J-? .&I,, ji klb JPp n;!

J--i 3i l J l g . b ALn

+A

s3 .Li3.1 3.5

IL

( P h ~ - o n e s i s ) ~ ~ &I ~ + L ! &I

p

+-

;,&

&

& uTerrible.'Lii;*!<LI

d l

C

I

~

+ Ii

lin &A

&dl

uqi

Y

Yj

pi

: 4 1 a k J+- .$I

i p W +,I

'-%Yl

;i J+I

-3

&-

&-3*Ul L+

+ ;3

Z ~ l & & k3PI;Li3

L+%-~I

+

2'b&ip 1L;) C-lj ; i di .q3

LSU

ji 31\ ~ n*ii ' I - ijz;i

,;,I _i

YU ils -

&>I

g ~ .'& l Y

-

&ljiU;*!Y

p

J

3

*er Y *GY

+ 'I

$3 e + * L

ipll;j .

2 +I

iI

3

Y ' I i ~ g .+I+! j

Y

L~L.

j4

;kr.

2 . j 2ckip + h 3+*

l~@~.ed;,&&&

V3i 41 +-&it>-

. Q ~ & I

ji J 3 h - k+ l. .' b

$

.A

J

&-

$ Y A YJ 3 $ L . + & ~ _ i d i + b - - f A X

;I $3

'&I

- (WI &I

+;I1 I L

+ji

4

13 1

. L J Y J ~ pJL+ ~ I b3 1 41 J+-bpg4-

Ibid., p. 324.

(*Y)

-.+ k;-L; -i

L4

'

G. LI; '7

.(4);

Lib 0 Lo.-3

ji

jJ >! d K ,

&gal>

4 ;

i $ . C g > p ~ , . ~ p a 9 b L L l I

/, p~.bC+i21 + , 4 J~ ~W ~ \r"i"W

J u r y n Ha- _+bjb

-L

j~ $1

b i-C;j

d,-4 + d l &-9ul

;-J%

4.Wl JAI - &

p13k

R e ~ - ~ n a(1929\ )

L G ~dJ$G> !

;P J LL5ji13 ~ ,5

*-gli;eep

C

.-I>

~,pi 3 '

+

JL,2 &i3

igk.1 +-ti;*4;s

Demythologizing h J + k ! ~

;;i-'~'~+-

Y

's3 3i

~b >>I

~9.UI'+L

; > L

b'j3:jgli ~ L Yj* It J + ~ l p~~

2%

9 li! ! + d l +j>I >I& u+Yl _C, +>Wl ixkJlLL,!

&&- JLx,

~ L Y I

pgsll ti;r;lcry $ 5

3 s )

,4u\

@j

,MI +;

LL'

++

LaLC -l2-

<Ju"bl\ 2 1, M I ,k --dl ip U l >e JL l(&pNI

J-2

W

v+ aL&

9

9'

'

ICI_( i-G '-.+ ;IL;YI 4UI -1%

$1;

'

6

dK; 2

+& ! 42 ; \ > I & " & J + ~ I ~ 23 ".--dl @ 1d J Lj w3 43j A jLgYl F2 44 u1 3 Demythologirinyl&,gk~~ ti;'%; >. j A+) +I

2

,G32j

1 +I

34

#

y

$1

r

+

?3i b.5 De~nystification "uL$I c ji LUi . (J6-J w3 &j+i!l p>b 31 Y " L ~ + ' ~ I I >>I g3jL . l l d d ~ lA l u ~ L L dJ+Y~ ?>I +,$"

5,9

j Y I& j V jj3

hi! I

&I

OL

I J-S-~L;~

a

ji ,

. e l 3

;I*-! LFJ!

'iJ+9l ~3~~ ji ~

4b jL;L

L

a t 2 L jL;4 ji j~

#I

I jJ l I

j13 .++I

~

9

JIUI e

l $ J&

,

d a*. bL

& > ~ Jj l Ij J \

&I

-

.I > 3 jL_;)'l +I3 cfJ3 - j .;;;U &Word ";bU1' Ldi 2 ~LJII~ C-

~

t 4 9I 1-

Jy

x*p+>I

L ' ,+i ilb3(Y)

3U 4 S h -"&I d.5/J&?l1' #

(>*dl) (il +;I!

. j ~ p 3-

0 .

+-Kerygma

'5

"L&lI

,&a I p i s l I

$ b L 3*.ill + d l d J i 3 ! 3 U;*.&dl .Ir, L I* ~ , L+I &

-3

-J L

y L YI l U

o3 i+ I*.

+3

=-

3Pk

&*.

a*.

b-

I

L;U+-vv

.+ 31 Fi

-

P P :/P

jL&CIi;,,

ji E

' * &js j ~ l 0 3 * U

- z Y I I U j . . t ~ + ~ j~ +

~-g,>,.G~

2 p+I "JI+JI1 J b a&- dj c+- ji dl+

jj+j

+ .-

i

.&I

+I

d &+I

I

Pre- " j l l lel'+

j i iy

sl++

Lg"P2 'jL;l13>*Al"

3+*

'+I

2 p A i&.Jl

A LU;

e+

& ' z-J

LL .

h

3

+

+4

brJ*lL

. ~J,~~u U 'I 6,41

p . 131 ~

2 3 9 3 . 4 tJjll(j;i-

r~oh;-I

-Ju!

1-

.W j~ j .

L+J

J& .@l;Li oegj3 yH-jI&J&p Loj a

.+UI

J

*-+y

j& 4

--

9 2 >>p;jlL & &

JGY

+

A*"

e J u I &I> c-h; &,$Id& 4 J L;-J

AIJS-YI

~

++JIj ' J ~ ~ jk& c . s > v ~>WI ~ C&I ji A

b LI+ *i j&-+jg

&-Y &,WU

jl

; 1 LC

+JO ,

L w &-

&I

l y **P

j

G31j 'GI>+&j$l

3iLjfJ

JJi o

p;

Y A3L j. Lhr 3 3 LC) J)~H Understanding 9 3

IL~ ~

~

~kpd $ 1

L

L

G

Y 1 &*L4

+ ."aJMI ji r-u

~

Collingwood,R.G. The Idea of History. Oxford: Clarendon

Press, 1936, p.2 18.

~ I ' i J L . oj .;ryb IU J! , \ 4 1 Y

r"&\j

Emi- 2 &A!c j L - y I 5 ; j W I &$Ig

3-x)-j+,o

jlp I"

+."&L;yI

LUX,)

+

Ck.5 lio Betti (1890- 1968)

L++AI1' uMI

&+I

~ $ 3 .(+3!.

.@+&sJI

c+tj. Y3i

LSi e*ij ys &I

c l j 4

L++p

5,9,

q3++A '+?-L;E &is ~k;L;)'l

L,;'+I

LJ+kJ\ L

&oy

)LuY

J3bG *&lJIJl

9

~

ij2

~

~

b,L;c& & + d l

'+u ,A!

' ! j

+I

>L2%

I

,I)

~

~

I

+

I

j &+dl

:

oLI,U

yJ1 cj! +GY Jy-

s & j U l OG$A .LA

>

,*pi

L U I J @I

c J d J rWI &I

21 2 - 2 - + ' 1 p 1 *

eb 4

~

+

- ' 9

~

LWI 5&2y1

eWI +I

LUi

-bs)l

+dl i k j6

2P

o L I ~ J J+ Ip

I 6-

dsis LLUI

;f.+

LJ+I

L

3

+&

.. 2

r h Y I

4e02 (dl-Jy

2 1Lc;=b++,l Jbi- 9r U l

d l 0L;;L . .O ) L l

LLL j d~

&

+!!

I

5 &L;'$l

'

b$I

~

s

~

Richard E. Palmer, Hermeneutics, p.55.

(.;)

Y3 .(y-+) 2r)l

L+!

cdmii p

&L

& Y3

i ( p l 2 q

&I W ,L;rLc 2&-1 & .WSL 'dj" Jy Gr r ~ l j l si+-j3 3%)

JL>

J+yl

.

bs

W 3 L3ca

+: lJGpYI+$

l &y&\

1-

G;;Lrs JGj &LA)'\ ;;~LJjdl

F ~ ~j4ULF I

+LYl

z+\ L lib .d;Lc3.23A3jlr;y\ JLiIg,4 2 1 1 4cs25)1 &.I +jJ ~3 421; + L ~+y+%& ji J g l k& ALL='AJ P_dj eJl iliL - U. L. t+Jl k;i+-13 jkL3 . ilk Js.+ L 4.531 W l ah I1&+glI" 4 1L + 3 Si"J!& l " ,d L a ; r

',+ -

:,I'&&I 3 ;L;IUI M

I

4

1 I+ &l;~kryl:,

j S JL46 2 +* Y

MgT t J'3% 41 2 .&L! b3b JS 2 bJ3p 3 &-t+gll GC, &:,'UI2 l ; U Lti d .. j..~ UjJ*lI

GI-

G b &i~i3 4 4 * d

rUl

I

A:, i A k + ! Object

t-t;lY

"w$".'wr j!

& d J $ ~ i + ~ h ~ y k - i ~ ~ i t b l ; ~ i i ; b i .i v. .p lib ' I L N I ;p4 b t+gll + # .

r-'3 elipYl I i U ..LA;*._d;: 3

p]

.&+A1

~ t+gll& -

p]

!P t b Y I

(c'

&.& &

i 4 U I >I

~ u yb il & + . ~ d l b2 l J++

& b 3JiSinngebung ( "@I' i>ll+ 4;

j .J,'LJ

-

L,L l h I&

' q c y l p+

cWI

(Q.,iAl

&.&

&+J

rc" hs L+-a",.+Jll'

+U

&..&

/- L C 9 \ -,> 21 2 J L % ( \ q-,Y) L Y1 . S i ~ ~ ~ i p e h u In p .iuslrgi~tig J3'U11'.&

id\ Q, 2

-3

4 &

i+LLy\ & L I J d l

.b+, LI, +&I

IL JL+ ~i,

ek 4 %I

b-iA +; J L L ~

k;b

&+ j21JJW3 n

u

jL

jr .+Irk

.++A1 3 LCLQ 'gGeieist) j L y l cjJ Objectification

-W &s

L + k J L 9+I

G ~ U$I i,+I> 2 &-ji &Yl j .

AJ&I+GI~ JS

>*-

>-,kll

; I+

t+;il

2 i!9 9

' >- ' 11

iJ3+~TP

C

j! j .'i>UI

j !

'y &%a

t+f I

'

jij

.p @iJX; 3 , 5 , ,

l u & 'd$l

JS

A-@I

9

&dl

i

Ibid., p.58 (*)

+&

Wirkungsgeschichte

'I&

WI c2UI''

".

>%y&- + &JV-

a

~

~

-

3!

$

fL t l l ; i ~ k &

'>*Jl

J3i

L.SLj-LlLJ

2

2J>

49 $ Validity of Interpretation

pk.

'+j*

6

C

.L ' C.!' &LJ ;>Yl

rb+ +

;i;JJL L W I ++jgJl>

G1' jl* L+>YI

+ I'\

\q7V

aL;.lyiYI j .

, &AL

.

.

+I

, 5

.2+~p~+-Jlpl+ &~YI,+I

dl3

-j

$ ~ - d $ l ~ a f ~ ~ J j r r~P +l 4~ , &

jk-> c+ $1) "4" Ji++ &~1- &ill>-I ah~2 a~j;c.:-3~~ p ' IL .(;* ~ @I ~ &I 9 te '&I +d+I OL >I+ +al5LYL3 c + + ~ + dJ Grj &L:iLPF y4 & 9+ &I I L a h -> d , 9

9

I

I

cf W . ' r J z j I ~ + l & . ~ ~ d & + l c s > ~ .+I

I.'.+LS 'i*

J+I &A

->L

E3 j $1

&

L-6;P'I

i -f ..> l ~ p

'ilYdll'

j

",+I

.'+plp+9 .+UI &dl

+Lp

j~ &&I

JLJ+

2;

9) d l 6+dl

Gdl 'ilY dl'>(+All *P@ dj! lJ? .Luj b j U G LLA+&I

&I"

+j f +&4

p j p LpLg-

id4~g.U v ~ ~ ~ - + > ~ ' L ( U + ~ & I )

ti3 li JJl

i.l.k

*-pYg

' 2+j

li.

ji 3 j

+AJ

j j .i+&I l&b+/gII

L+ LBe(lent~in~ "&I"

b+l Yjs Bedentsamkeit ';JYAI'' jc

Jx "

ji

*-

P

, S <

+GJlor FI- & J+l

&EL)'&

+~ i i /LI* ~

ij L 'E

>+

+e g p

yi9&I

- g i i l l l Gi

I Liiik ~ P

jGl, U l

.L+$l "dY3"

&

ee/g"

+ *i

,e,Au

e4! &I

&flflpll A ,1 diu;

z J A J @I

3PdLdlLg, & jJI

&I

ju ,&I3 +bb 51 j* ~

~

*

iJzell

j

$5 !;I

~

!

~

.#+t"

: ltslk. *G14-,I

+ & +& I ,

,

l

- 4 d &b C

44

J+

b c dl;"+t;~,ilb 3

&+F

6 ~ .2 3 * u

*i 9 ,I y L L . 4&Y, , t, I*- *i di jc *5L& r"j

j

2 9 J$-

b L jL-; & yj-=!l U &..A&i+l

.d &&I Jslpll

j!

~

~

l

*,,l!J931

;)L+ j 2 9 A 3 b u I+ (@I &I &i) P

+Jl~$W.F+&Lpiy:i+dI&jlS

+ju

&I

~

;&+~JI

! a y l ih - .j.'WJf-'&. $"& .. -.

+IUIII

& ‘d$l

~

Hirsch, E. D.,JR. Validity of Interpretation. New Haven: Yale (*I University Press, 1967.V 11 46.

e ~~i4.i~ a

-

,b+-

w

4i -

Y

2 1

~

~

u ~jiiji't..+i'L+~~ +-

L++AI

JLit!& )4;u.

L

3

~

-

1

I;

j! validity

. "d+l / U l '

~

~

;

~

j

~

'2jL Ui _i 4i2 ' 9 3 .j i

r>

2,-,

91 I~UI&I~ a c U+-L++&I 2 - d3Q~ J~J-I'&L y3 & 3 bi d i b ~ .. ' ~~ j & b Y iJ?L3bl >!

.+-dl

'ilYl1I &I

c&C-' j' -

@+d &I;l JjWl f;II

LI

w-21~ I ? YI 3i31 r3 r~~ LJ 9 4PJI

$ + - k ~ > j y f jik&'&dY>liJd\ & &I> pV3 &YI d l J+ ;u &-+ +YI ILji ds!454 bl+ ++/sJU

&Jl*'ill

-GI

.&j~.ii iLlh;y-?rji+

jlh;

p"'

2

L$l.L &dl&I

9lL .LJ;!,i' Y3

J+

.l+b+J~+

iS,>+$I

"JLU

+I

>j

&LYI'

+- &&

; d l 3 pkJ.1& k d l >

j&

j.9l.e-l #I &I +M)a Y b Y I , L , a" Lapfl j Jk41Y! ( L L L l a l h l +JSjl.l 'C;ib+dl

jlh;

&I

IL

ca

6

3

'&i fJ3

.'a

w3&i4 L W I tCj>Ul LL~ Jhi Lg;p d

~

~

'y>+I

, & d l &I

Ih

.>s-"y4

J-4

.k+iI+.& tp,ji L-r3++,.&

sp 4,

>,+

+ 32,

>3>

Js

1115 i j~ 3~ ~p3> ~ 1 ~ 2

,i b b + ~ Y ~

a+ .,I

&

skc

cS-i113f l & L LAP1' +I

.

3 J+

,

4 ~ J 2w ih;r ~ jb-L A-IJI .. i+ P;9JLLI $ OL2 i+Al

i+Atll

bi J>

9

'&&$I

W+lj

d+

j p l l $+ j

4 s+

L > L lij Li

d

2

~j @=+&I

Jru

l+ ,I

?+I

l i . JS

GL+

i ~J s i> -3

;+L&+&I

1 rJi4 j .ir*

4

XL

i

'JAJI &ILS, J-JI

:+

fa^ ,i

~ jji;3)L ; > ~ '-J& Y + I,

i+*r

.

w

Y

J

#

j f j+Ul

&j

dl &$+I

d l &jA,&

. .

ja+l j 9 I dlJ& LA &$- ji j g > L&O&ji kJ+YI . ji k J + & I j ji GUI LLJi F

T+

4& &+&-ill I;

jej .+,-L=gll kJ+Y

I

9 .

ji "#I

MI''2 dL& ji bIy $5 !;I y l ~ k 2 1iL&j .j + b Lycidas" " A "+UI ,?keUI d l ' ' L

W

i-IL . . Lycidas" 42; ji "

'A+ t l ~ - j

r

. ... L ji ,& L

J-JI

J ',J>

jl' +L

XL

2 'diP r~~

L~WI j G

\ ' i ;1IL

elf"@I

-is+

Y&I;

Awl j f

2

o h

>. $3 9

I j

dk-4

$ (-s"

i

A

~L'WIJP*~I bi

J '&>I>' &Jk%!f3

-

ilYd13 &I

\I

.&+i

i;>b)U&E

1-b J.!$1;113

. j pu j !

1 &U

)

it-: i~v, . - Y i+*c i .

S

&lij -+dl G&)>l>b "& ,j>" &. 4 --1d9 9 .J I + J I & l i

~ p > & js 9

Validity ! ' l ~ l ~js l lI++LLk l $+ &JL u

Lgd+-

5' il+

21 411 ;;,/klb

+@I

,ji'F

!

4 ~

>yU3

Validity of Interpretation. p.207

. (*)

* x3 *LC; ~. a&9 L+-

"4

ji

.@I

**c;L,,&I ii 2 1-

&I

U i;J& &L

+ 2j 'LLN

.

L&

.

:

i+iji d l > 9 .+ .+A\

.J jL Y3

4 2& _i-:i djLr*il o h b $3

&>

+,i Y

i&

.@I

cI

+,*1+

*-p

I L

kS

o&

A-* 1%

JS

& 4"3 b*J+ C-5- 4 L+

a!

r

'/LYI

&3

.a -1 C

sJ9

~ 1j 6

-i

;>L~'L

k L ; I j2+b~JlLKAIrs,&~jkcS

+-! L5xI. lb+ 2U

dl 04 A&

++dl

2 +i'JL~J A;*

&1;j +I! j .&I

~

~

&&+A1 JAY &*.; IiW . U I 2 MJLs +b ji j;z 2 T

&&!I

~

~y 3iI.

L+~" j j Ebeling

l 'A& JI. @+A!

,

jr Jl+l

d&

i-kj . U*I

j!

l

+Q+&

3 e-+-

2

UI r

&A

+

l

& d l &I

JI.

;p32131

++JI

I. d l Li.A ~

3 5 'A&

e

l

c~YLrr,

+

&I

F3

% ' u p N I JLr,j ~3 Ck - be- Agll LKA & ~ ! d @ 3 P ; X l l & & l & I d ~ ~ ~ L g i $

d2y - . ~ l JAG &I&b 'I++ GI; 'w 9% j\ J

;p JFU c4ic+- JIJ.JIji

d3&&!I

jK

J4 .

:% '

uI

I

&I'%

Z2flY

T U

l PL Jg

L &j

I

oh & j\bjlij3 F 4 J3 ohLLK I$ L >+ ji k+/Li Gi

.kr;C;ip+&I Caj+

'y L y e &a ++yJ

u"&

441d

Jj klJ2i LA- ~3Ljjbg

ji -4;; LjX11 &Is

*ul+ :

d d

d;.*

ddl

A k &dl U

*li & .&+&I

J! a3).j, ;t?UI-IJ --I

&3

+I

L*l

1 4 '-$A!

*w.

I d!iL

j~*.,.

J+

;ip&l L U I

; i&+&I

'U

1 &+/glj

*I

A

-

3 &A1 & I& 2 ,J+I-LLI

++dl Q+JI

2 - 1++A&

&u --jWI

. d ~ g d j 31~ &&I

F lib ri

A b

Lg;t & Ss+&l

awJe&I

ALA +'JI

& a3-LS43 ~-r3J*+ (*4, G 4 ' &31 > .~$ jJJro' & JUbJ i'&*L!" ."&$A1 u1JcJl'j

i,+ JFL.f!X: L n

JJX; &.LJ'Lll&,I

s J u ! i p d l (jP

f JS

31) JJ+

l-Lj12 .&lJ>l

Jb

&

j b k

& b +->I

3

+WIJ

21 J-L,.-4I

ufiJ @ i y f l JLU-L +,I-4 .

Igl>4~_ $3

~ > F JJP

.

&b2b k J y . j U Y l t&Yl

.

' 0 4 1 JJ3j JIP~&+*dl

+bJd#l

Y

.JJ>

k+ b+ L&be& >Jurgen Habermas (1929 )

:SJ~!!!! JGiJ5 &A

LA!) +?I

.LL&U

d k y l &iJ

p &blp&I

+I

+++I

>j

b

d k y !

, L. A . c +I3

LL LLWI 3 +bi 21Ji b&%i

ijl>;

/,5

j$jL

j ,&*JI

(%+I

b~

&

;i b3+* & l p & l

3 +I-

.($ )

" W J I "

& jgjh && "iJ&I3 $ d l " eL.5 4 " J+I3 u. L Y I"0. - L +& U l L+

jI

Positivism

bb

- \ V q A)

ti! %jlyt P ;UI

C E V u 1 3

c;$

d 3 ib+k=

i h l i b j A i iL 6 c J U 1 3 i L ; j +LJIirSj&$ji;Udl

- \ A \ A) &jL

b 3

k

3 9 1 jl+j

t&3y~ +j K " .u "41 3i '+J ' ~ s

@ dJ313

@

J+

3

i.li14 L;jj +=

EJ$l+

c;u

3

.-F

@Jr.+713

.+A1

'I

L Y I "j! .-C

&>I d

p

a

9,

j lh L . & o ~ J&& j ' -JIUIJ L (\AoV (\AY\-\vv*)

4 jL

&I; O U Y I~3

C

3bjLA13

; P ' ~ ~ ~ . c r ~ & ~ - J ; & u c + W ( \ A A Y

jw jL LLJX L ijj & ! G I iJl+Y

I aLLUl

L$13+Jl

' b - . lgMr

-41

@illy

~ l i l' lk C+6

~i.-I

+I

&$I3

Y ~k

i*bl 3

Scientism &+I

i,WI

aid n$3I ~ J % + Y I

a\--

31~+ijZ/cw~b;i~!k& L& r L - 3 -I LYI JS y ' ~ $ 3:yi ~4 ,LLcl3! &I & + . d l L$I ~ i .a%aI 3 $3

.s3~2>-4-+2>

&L &dl

oJL;r13

i

CA+

P I

P 9

J& WIji LAL

i

kpW~ij+

9&I

4 ~ 'u

ir13d3& ~ &~!hUl+Lib $t ~ iJ3> 4 i k$&i & &I i

G p U &I

I 'L+j

31 3e f4 1 .GJ+ls

+

&

6ulj - -

+W1j*C1

(

'~JI'' (+

3i '

cl*j""l

Ulj.+ > U Y I b .L 4

i)&

~

5

G) W~ ,& ~

j!jl?;ll

U j k i ) !

j,dI

.o&JJ 3 +I>

~

G U !

&C3&1

>yu3

PI &J

b ~ ; Y \' j3 Y > G dj15$l

1 9 1pa -- p s 4 -;" +-.+I d y WI r g ' +&";WI ;#I Gg p l a y I & J l p-iljlp &I J

bj !.j L Y l o ' b& ~

I 491 Si&dl

J L C I d k3jJ 9&&I

+L)l? +dl3

U l2

2 +' aL&l

l b

& "jlhj1l

4 1 4+I ~

r"U +$I

&

Z

bkll

J-q9

~

~

J

J

L

~

*

+GG! + 2 -l3 +Ij+ j l i

9

&I'.

~

&

~

' 0LJ.d .G 35 99

+~IJ*;-

&2

kls ' LLJI c+

&L u 1 ~

OL~.

3

,#LglS ++I

I

c d : "& L

b ~lki .&I3

p - 3

9

~ @i + \ $ , l "U\" pLozjb

l

&~b

.

M a & L "

I

;I j

ELL,^!^

+Ul ij-I 4

+I3

L

&L2b ~

L

?

,

I

W

J;x!I& &

~

L

A

jJSJLJi+~~Ir.i~L2b3.+~lIL (YpY l + K k S

bk3' L A ! &2 q w &J&l

elbl\

+,++t-t;&

-

l"&+Ll

Ex- "/I"

d+-jijFyl. &-?I

>I)\

jlsli!, , .p > , .

i r & - ~ ~ + yL l + 1-

J!&*j

,

j l j l

d3 ++I

a l ~ l ~ y>MI l 2 >LA J% 9 j j C

Understanding . "+I'

Plaining

-

>*%L- ~ >y<- . I

9

,191 L& r+ 21 ++I k.134Y1

I

j j +

i i u l :\+I

+I!

+:

J1$-l

.*r, ji

d , cUg.;++

ji Lhr

d+

,:iy

d.L+

.+I

+dl G U Y I y . 3 9 7 JL&;3

+ji k - l 3 4 Y l jLLk .bl

&i Horizon ( "jj!lll'

Ck-1Le.lg+yl

? ;

4

World "+WI ihl @I o Y +

+3

J ' i l j3 i p ' i k C; =L.+

3

jLLL

L

swView

ji 2 : (b+lJgd j ji ljlY ,iil

UI&L~&/U~&I~~I*>~*+;~ 1

i

U +JJ+I iliYIp3 c 2 +L+ J+l s 3 +.l3+!ll

JIF

*-& e'&

d .

oYI 6

j;

6 ,

J~*JJ 'LL

*

+I LJUji 2 yl+

j ;/bAb uGlJI kJ ji C+b+dl

.w3

U I

L

J~I.I,%I

+J$L2a! zJA\ .;.'A &LAb&-3

i , l r ji 9 .L;Ul kJ L,k

o+Lilib i ++I3

d l 3 ; & . J l L1'k

kJJl EJLGiij i j o I g l + % b & - 3 ~ l > ! - L-S Lii, ,L ji 3 J3@+ Y .d+.Pr JALS az+ &ji +- 3,b 2 &jL ,

6 '

I

$

j

6

Theory of Communicative Action &!~d13rhfl&t,j

>%dl 3rJIqag communicative action ≶i@(Y)

~

Ur

I

~

"+?MI a l w Y l

4'

J

t h ~ l L & ~ ~ l t ~ h ~ y & ~ YJ I ~ ~Y LL I 2 k;u! L I ~ >+ 'y 1 L 2 '~.uio &,&) +I'

Phonetics 'al-Yl

(a"'

&L?

+" Phonology J

/wkJ~) ~ w Yl dY, +s -

Semantics ( j U l

4 4 1 a b W I ZXC zJ+

" U I 3 pLL1 ~ I J l ' '

Extralinyuiscic Reality . 49%

J.Jll;

2 1Pragmaticc ( L & k l & I >

l++w 4 4 1 sLKLJI

U I 4. j L ' r ( l 23 6

j 'I - p - J, +

p-5L14

+j

jg

$I ilrb;tPJl

kJjlUI,

y-iJ

L+

JLiS&

. j L Y I 2 & &a

,

J" is;] Jp;ji C;ibkIJ\ Ig.d b JUI jlk;>i;Ul&wJ j&lLg;u .- j!&YYl

+

4 4 1a

U U I 3&

3

j'b

.;JYIII

+s

, I+dl

y g31& a * 4 )~" iJ& f-

'I$

i

I

2 d $11

P-IPJ ab+J~, JUI id! 4-;G &b2b &J

.

2 1(q3!Jd)Q k l & 0 . 7

,7

IJ,j.r+Lg.j+-+i~~'~~~~L+'s!~L~i~ 5,

.*

IL >p Jd9 -jl,;Jl

+J

j+ll jl)jUl d

L+$I

e p 46

2

I+'&

'Ul" ;E! L - - d l

Q ~ I A jIi

&A\ ~JUI

L&>>'-~ U

l jY! U

l

31&I 'bJ

l p k l J' ( 1 9 \ Y ' - \ A ~ v )

rJUl & Lailgue "Zilil" Li Parole

sr. JLI Paroie .

. "rhUI'2 Langue +y 41 &&I +I , I

&L Q,,ltL. p y + ;~k? &~JIJLY I tui .&

&i l l r ~ ~ n

L

a 1+s J2 +I c- . I ..Q j3- 3 , -

2

L

+ysI II\

2 1+dl (aE&l) +UIiau~ 8 ;UI L+ Y

a * c

.&I

d +'.ysI

Id p s A k UI I +s c>i 2j k;'Parole "yWI1 i l , a ii,arG 2 1p b b 3 ,"wI'~ &i +I +I '-lJJ &,~-YIL>Y~ a21 .1i,~ ii,&L3La 4 ' 1fi dli vJJ Langue . (qjIdl)~

~

9 -

b&klAl U

Y U by ~

&L2b 31 &IJ u Y Lit;l blA jLS jJl 3 jYf-JI&, , Parole l ' r W l "

-!

2 by juA ib+ k.&J ~ + - S Z ~ J L I ..zi~~4 pki3 W414 pki dj,' + d l ;+I aL;+ 2jrJL 'q l j rrWl 'LCV ' r W I ' &k Jw ib . I + b k I & I jC%I L*zi >I -I

.LUI

P~IUL . . J?UI

L+L+I~I"

6

. , ~ L. i,& k" i i l l l U

lip Universal Pragmatics . (+Wl

/&UI /++I)

i

9

tj-

L U I +I+i > b l p>$ LUI L & k l & l L

-

& t3+I IU f 9 L j .JUI &l+l & ".

4 1 +\

iI

(JSUI)

s";j-

-1_,

-JycJl k;lL;l13, ~ + + Y \ L@ SWI~ 4 3 2 1 1 JJV\ i,,l

.;.,;UYl

~i

+b: \ + W I : ~ ' ~ I + I ~ ~ I ~ C ( \ ~ ~ L - \

rp'u +I

6

&Id1 3!&13

J&3~+b : Y+Wl 6 I&!.+

&+YI

.J I ~ + I

+WI . . + p J l

$ 9 d b 2~ 1i1di 21-i3

s Cm . k k+I> +JI

%I

+lc :

&&I

IL&L+

-I

i sA b jC,LWI

-.

OL & p s

31 +Id! o h 2sp b3(L $1 aUI &i J,YI+,YI IL&L,~s U - -- -P3

++

LS Speech Acts 'r)IUI J L i '

2 3 i;UI

-LYI

OW by+3~ittgenstein (1889-195 1) &.+&bi+ 4'.C

4 J.Austin (191 1-1960) . h 3 1

&&y1

&-4'

" a W k J l j Y l pi, L CWIJ L i Y '&&J

How to Do Things with 5

:

Yqh4LJ L 4 . l agi3 i ' L 9 ; ~ p

95

J--n

5

e3Words

2%

@ JgsSll pj+I 0 2

9

,

&! &.owl 4.\

LL J$I ,i P

l i ' ~>i~3:4&'& ~ .Locu .Tionary Act.

2~>UI Jdd~ 2. Y

ji ~+-AI i

j e y \ 'WJI j 2 +5i "4:

j

'

)1

jg,(!;!

&I; J+lI

' l Z j L i L

c

i

iJWI

,

' 4d /Jij 2 2 _i~L,'-i l;il' :JUI &+, & i uwi si "i Y " ~ j iLi L &i Y rili! ++

cI ; j

I I & U ~ J J J I ; ~ ~ . ~ L - ~ ~ ~ C

''2

7 Y Lb ''*&jtJ? l . c j $ L ' ! j -

S+.A

L

;i>l

, d j $ l p j ~ i Y j

+&pl$OIL!ji

&jgj

+rW1JLjI3 @\I &dl Illocutionary Act

1;i"

0%

A+-

ji &-!>I

lin -.J

.+jeJ

&d jgj &li9iJ&Jl

9

(2C;YI jg)' I /g;YI ' +-I

G j k Y I+ ' $I

2S I ~ L

#I

ji ~

3 t 1 ~i 1S 2 .~Y p ,

jr .iui,

.$!..+IJrjI ,I +j, L i i ;eJ' tli!:

I

'in-3

(') .Perlocutionary Ac

s,+J JjkL+j jL -. ;

j +

J--U

6

rJL13

++hi >! &LAb d

6

r&I

I

rKUl JLd

+-j. L W I + k l r J I

>! d-cg; $1'

&KUI P

*\dl

i

jt + J a J k J L >

;cl4S;U L W I JLcI+II+

+i5i 33.1J k r j W

L j N I bjiJl

Austin, John. How to do Things With Words. Oxford Univer-

(p)

sity Press, 1975, pp. 5-6.

~

LWI & b k 1 4 1 ji

di .+W slJb3iaLi+

3

~ ~ " 3 ' ~ ~ 1 3 k . , s L J 5 ; ; - l l ~ l ~ +

" 3 ~ 9 q rl*jiul

I*;

Jd3 !

p3. --'+I

&\J;

jll ?KUlJWi y JWC-JlSL~~I;,: u-2i1locutiona1-y . lillocu- "3L;)'I /gj&)'l / ~ l d l& "d l jp ~ ~ L p3+

7

.d39l&>A4 &bi.l. p-+dl 9Tionary Act tiWl JLji&+ ji AJi & L A b li-Y

v,

JLjij!AJ++r;!uj.C&~iJ+j.oli&Ji

%, h i Validity 'l~l+Il' J 6I Propositional Truth ( &+I 6+l:ki 3 4 >;L & jL +i ~;*el -lj.

L-l

j * &2 ~

&. 'I

i;;Z tiWl

jul"

JP

~~3 &I +&I$!

2

+!I

dAL+

ji (3>>.+=3+L13

J!iJG)uL

(JkAl) J3Yl23 )!b Ul+I

.

k j j ai

2J l L\i.

+YI U

lU

&,+ Y Jj iC(

6> L AJ&d >W

C

*>

&&d

.5'-Id0j?+Yl A W I 3!iJL.iXI L d l Y U L i 9 L ; L I A bK ;i li! : &LAb J . 4 .Legik +> (jI&J?( 3 *, Y 33 9 JUL tlb3 i W l +lrJl& JS >j

c

>& 3

L

31 iJLfiyljL

d

tpX33 ~ i l c;lUI & j h-

Propositional

&Jl"i&L ~$+ -

Expressive 6

jw! j'+

Iillocutionvry Jut/ ;!j

&- &d $ >i>vp ~ Wa LI& I b h ji J> & 2 a 9 k - b~~ 3 j b Iillocutionary >L! /&j@l I

ipWIj ~ j f l &"b l

r"l dUl j&l+-.L%>

,'I Avowal ( $+!,

tconstative

+-

.aJI&uJ

: J! ; t j u Y I

Regulative . l&i3 'Representative) +$i

tJWl

:Constative Speech Act &$dl u ' ~ l & l

lJWl

J!

4 4 1 j + J l 9+i

'Propositional

p

+ L 3 )fLJl

3 Cornitive

' (&&I)

f+s

. d U I ' &*+I

+$I

J;YIG*~.JI

.

& -k;u-j (>$ .LJCPI9;1\

Repreaenta- &LA f, A\.on a1 ( ~ ~ l & i Y l & % l , J d ~

J! 9

+$I

- 3c

4 4 1jfll

:(ti~e

o>p?

u4! ~ 9 - 2(21-ill&IJJI)

& d l +L $ jExpressive ++I

L

dU-I & -3

L 4 - 1 d.S3

.&I$!

11- Gj@yl b f l l o > ~ -: Regulativ @i&wlJdl &MI

-t

. &

,+Ib,J!3-j ~Loctionary

'e3 dlhj

4 +Lid\

;ilLLI

I /21i+o

/&L.;-~Y

h - j c

L3+ + h i I

.&lgJI 9 *P

4 9 5 j3 j13fi j> i j L

++I

~ W I

ZWI ~ 22 + i p 3

j j 4 l

GklrJl;

OL

p a

&-Validity

W

I

~ .L ~> Y- I

>jb 2

UI

LUI

>.;~~LLI~'G.+>I~

~;JI

2

2 b3>\

p.J + b Y l9u~9L+ r;p

J?lj 21 dj : dLAk *s L W I +WI JWYI ~.USYI i~a;. 2% >Aj l ' "kL;-y3&;jjpi&gjZ2, JL+~ p ' L 'JF9 L ... ul&I'

C+

I I

i

I

9/&I

t+l9

>& Constative

%+I +WI JWYL

U loJWl j Lo i+1LJ& & i l l 9-b

Truth ( " & d l " .(&J&l

9L g i a ,bAvowal

LJ&Yl

Truthfulness or Sinceri- ";LlllGUJ &Iv

>& Regulative &&dl &%I1

29 JLdfllJ -

+Wl

iibfll~ / S Y

JWfllsty.

1'' -

Appropriateness or Rightness . "AL.JIsf L c S I "

'&-ji L*,i W I l+&l$l

ji JglkJ

Habermas, Jurgen. The Theory of Communicative Action. (a) Vo1.2 Translated by Thomas McCarthy, Bacon Press, Boston, 1889, p. 62.

&LS !;I L+

JdL

LL-7Regulative

&.+&dlJLdVl &Z3

J,d

3 r l o ~. ~ ~ ~ l p ~ & J \ j ' k 4 W l

1 ; + $ b 1 $ 1 3 , 3 ; & , J . I ~ \lh + JLji wLL.L!

2

%LYI

db2b

&.& &,

+3 i W I L & b b l $ l

--+ di, y.e ,I ,- ~ g _ k :

0

0

a3 ;---~-w $;I

!",I

3, &,%-I

J-l--Jl-lJUIJd+U ~h-, &-I+!

k

+J&il

*,

Yli

o h i;,

l L : LWI

U

P+J~+YI

~2p~

+pYl

+9)*+Yl

~ 4 1 d u +2 , - 4 +-

LWI

1

JWYI ,i +,+I

9

3UWI

+LA

& yt u b , b j l l S;r(ir%lIJ M%-yIs jU)&Wi & &?aPI - ,, & ai ilw i

i

. J ~ I A& I ~ l i i 'PI j j ig: ~ 4; ~J?++I &dl ,&i L lip 3 *;-I3 &i - 2 - &j*yI 4 & y y ,A\A a&- z u ! alJ&YI b & k l J l Jj* .+A%L-! !*I%flk &!+ai &L2b +I, 2 LUI G~)~+YI 9

,

-

0".

u

,&

dl &.b+&l 2 L i A .a1 2 &.A j l l &-dl &I &!5 &'+dl &k & L A b Ig;-i.Ltll JyG j l l UL;,Y l L++p

. P I 9 3 'U'j . "

+-iLZlJrG+A

j!

..+&A1

L

~1

j-ig4 $1 i

-

j - &qj 23 i i

$1 i

;p $-IJ

$7

i

+-

jgi ji A Y && j - +&I Cogito Ergo Sum 2 5 , $1 Lb $f Li

,I.

Lf

Paul Ricoeur, Freud &Philosophy,translated by Dcnis Sav- (o) ageJew Haven and London,Yale University Press, 1970, p. 32.

b l j dE 2 k - 1

J. *

u

,& a&-;

/$I>!

A+\ U ,& rl;"Yl

+I

"

i G .V+LYI . - l5 , l j ~ L IL

D W l iY;j

L+$

-jA+

Y

,,

I >!kJ lil

H2 jl' 1 2 3 di

L&ZJ. j J L < A l U I LL

.&I

u

&J&J

LJL2 L

,& L@+>L-+=!

k+ L i i . U L I

JJdl~sJ+l ji .d *J&dl

i & Y l jigk

S

u

c g Y \

L

ji

Ae

d j ~... l ~ & ~ & ji>& $- YI& i Y ! ~ + b j + b

Lj .&I

I

h &dlj &I 5-

U

l +j 5 LLJ-

' f - iIL. ?i -4j $9 G~ &,L .dA&Jl>Ul>Li+

2 g JJw~ ~Z%I 9+ Y p p 0

P

L ~ L L &>La G

2% +1L

r ~ * pJpLA r

&5

& $ l j A b &$I

.

s@Yl>

Y i I+ji

++

2

Skepticism . " U l QL'

~ L g 1 0! LJ&

Yi

&&I;

+I L g9

3>'LGU'U 9 jL$13rR-I' > ki L~LiO+i L ; ki &YI j9&-%w~ j& JA

A

.A+ eL

uy>q~N JLGI L L I ~ Y

LOA-J

I'

&+

YG+J

+&Y, 2 & &

A

dc~ @ d l $ pgSt; & +YP

P

+I

J+

+ iw+p'+~ >LS

+

.l&9+u71

j L 92

I;,

J&L . .

~&dl+

+9

~ j.T++Jp

.&

Ibid. p. 33. (.;)

Ricoeur, Freud,p. 34. (.s)

--

p~

Ibid. pp. 34-35

(9)

,+

Ijui L

I

'p&I'

~

ji + kGUc;j -

C;r)

W I4

1

eJUl ;SF

jib1 3

2 - 2 - 1&-jWI J+l

dL

2~J$'-

r"-U *-lj.l

&LYl

,9 1 ',' >+I

' g "sldl"g

(I

+j g +

&-bes

j .L-l

W&+\

+

I

3

e ~ i-si>UI & L Y I

L

&Ul

j2

JG

++ +Ig ++

41

21 " u ! ~ Y I "&id +-3

Gi L.j\i~ d~ 3

ljP

9 L3y

a>L)

d3ir +L S &I;

~

& ~ ~ d l ~ & l . ~ ~ ~ + & + T * * I

Ii

~ J / = : i - i i ~ . . & ~ b i ~ / ~ &lid -~ j L y I j!:.jli

u Y ~ Ch + ~wir^.ij~ 3 .(so)

2 ~ ; L S j13 +>L

>K41j.rc.;Il&~e;fa&b -. ..Actually) &a!&) 2\312 &j L

3 j>

6 h J 1

di I

JaWl b h I s

L

Y I ;I! +~ i + U l ~

Potentially) . i$L)

& W J I 2 Ck A& >b!2 -

eMI

jlSLP-Sc+5Jb

~ +I

-

&I;

‘& +-. -( I J.4

p3

j i;L)HII

L;r +Ls p, kr

LL -;

&$I

+L~>I

3

ii& p;!@dl

.G%i3 'ki3 '

I

~

e bi : ?

%&r&-

;+

~ Y I & 2L+

+j

bl

. U l j ebis L i U I jebi"TJ&GY~ j

aLisL

~

L~'l& &+I SL

bi

I&*

kA +jd K &'u3 L b - & bi3 L a4h ~ &~L ~ I

,

&

*-

8?Iu3

& ji +ju l i p .+UI +&I L.5 Iiis L p l j +ebil+9+ k$y +2 ;L;iL e-h;j ,ji3 :b~aL>*J. J*c ji & 'L @ LcXJ~ +J b l l k l l y;≤)l

PJiL;. -

U i& l j J LbJw $&?-YJ&&>~al;3p L p Y. 1 3 JLLl !,A F

'!

j"s'l

J*nL +l;iyL

.GI>

j -!+I3

,

+L& ++YI

LbpL jLJlri3

3i &&I

vsii*. .-ji + Y '41 2 3i &I

2

+;.

&L-

&>I

v1 F"i 2 r"& d

I

~i+ .-

i

JS3~&$>b ~

L ~i+i3 S -5

>+I

b

.

1-

n&--

c+-

++$I

$.Jil

S

~

l

& ; &

~

s3'jk-..ILI

~

~

J+

L

0-b

p- 9 3 Perspectival

4j &

"/I

a l l& Y J! 'Post-Objective

iJUYi & I; 2 3 'aUWl ;p GlZ

2 JYYl

Cbj j&

Y3 Power Interest . U I $b r+ $UI r L 3 1 Y! &,L $ +IJs y*;;dl $ U l a L jr rltlil i b L j

$1 ~(l-L&l)

lplpi

iL'l.~i+@-&~bJ.G (GB)

Lbp'2

&.ii;F @+

+I3 .&I

3 3 cJUIJ)

s t 3iglk. +-&y

~

.I1

$ ji Jwji 3% % ' h i 4&&I1 ji 21- l.. -. +A

-

l

1. !

b

V

y

~

_~si

&ji 2 &I

~p LL

L

QL Id11

$b&3

j

J* ~

.-I

+- Y $1

I

L ;+&I JG'3~ 2

j .

~

j -

; P Li J +, ib

L1

.

Y 3 ji3'++ Y +lGi

j+L+

b~*L i$ I 5 .;

3 JbkJ

,411pJ

.

j+-

.

:

fL+ +-i

k&

4 ;

bJ1&

+~1

%

~

l

j

d&cJl

,i

>! J--*.--43>) /IPJl

J q U K x;*i3 k . 4

"2lJ ++l I " 22 JjK 4,-

&

k;1

A;Lf4).(/I

+A! &I; && "

u+jk~i6 &I

'")(~,-im:l F x i e ' 3 i Y l Lb$"

21>JG-dJp&\ l L +& +I ,JUlj l

~ I

~

1

'

'

wl pL';Lgi

L- - L ~ & ~ -I&?' I

& +J ~ I A I ~1 JWL p; 3 3 'CkgY~J ~ 1 4 4 4 L+ lldddJill t3+ 2 kJ< "*#" Akb & .(>uj) JdJj j tEJb + ul yntu , 'p iiliJ.Y &-(;;$ e4;@ &l .'**) 3 r!3db &K

1-

-:

l

&I

&Wl

FJl~ 3 +

J% 3jd3 d l

alU JX; 3Lp j I JW

&d*.

j &

l

~

d

oIUI j !

Correlation ''&-L-" G% 2 2

>Gg

4

aIUO .p+JI

J;oj- i_l+ -

& Y3 .tr"2 - "&I -

k; .23 .f 3 GLL alTIfl3 uJg+& &b$3d;jrp.!r~d'J2b33&~

ji j ~ tli + F-

J+

Popper,K.R.,and Eccles,J.C., Remarks on The Term 'Real' , in,The Self and Its Brain, corrected* second printing, Springer International, 1985, pp. 9-10 .

~

o i r

i3+1

9

_CL; , -

Let .>l+rJ

9-i.

.3

d j y '?

+

rllill\

L - . 2- L L I

is & i , , ~ g+ ;i 4;i; j .~ I , L ; C ~ I

y

w

s J 2 U- -

I ,+I .

3'U &-%I

!;

.

+I-

-

L5jj

i

ji j .t'>&3

lgl ~

~

p.2 & Lr,,Co

.,L>UI

elb

cLGl

3 dj. j L X J I j rKUl JL-3

Js-

' 2j]JI-L";p >lpYl1

',GIk-;;i

~*;IL - . . L+

a i i

.+J!

a;P &-Ja3*L;1b ji

jJI;! ji

JJAI

LGLPJI

j~U I fJ +dl l OY l ~ j Jj

IbkJl l+j3 F-Y LU; jp ' " & d - l &JLl i&'&> ds3;"j j ;! big JJh +L-JIJJI IL j& 'LaY 6 L J L

l1oL,&+l k $7

Z + b j& jl

+ Y +JLl a&\

.(&dl &LA1L5ji JP-h-JJJ3) a b l y +J1

*-il

&I

I;iG Yg

pul j'WI JIJ pui

JJAI j!' : i;ii9&G

ybyl &I3

pul&I

3~

&IJ>! Yg

4 1 3

JLlb

A b d3 + 'I

' ~ 4sJ+ 4 P-; : Jkc Jli &A j b >j& j3+

ogl

ogl>+

4 1

oJ1-

r;l~~+

Y &Ig

bj*L-~L

-

j

l

&

." & l J d I q U . 1dsA J S

. rr-r \ B

?GJY\ L J - ~

ip c"-;

F~~(B)

b!

QL,

d b ~3+ j

~li; qlAl

ji J! Paul Ricoeur (19 13 '/>

iiJL 31 ~ d pV ~ ;& .$!..~I+I p L 3

6 - b u ' g

~3>91

3.&13 @r'WI hi3

&i

&I

2

*i3.(+)+w

"1&dI;43

G C .

'i+b'(kj)JG

2 ) J&J

&pJ" el;s

J3 a&Symbolism of Evil I"\;

b> cds3 Y ,tll

Y

Lib ' j S l b Y ~3,

'i-'j 3 J :'%~ ~

j

G ~ j iJ !

~

~ l k j

&J

ALi j j J+-3 .+& i;;l~Jl'l~ ;p a 1

4 3j l i i 1 6 r L Y 1 J!$1

42,

4

ubl+

Encyclopedia of Phenomenology, Eds. Lester Embrec et al., (a) Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1 9 9 7 , ~61 . 1.

kJ41.S~ U ,;I

U; jr;p

u

9 &i;l>.'+~"~

,ji >AJ J+ k$*+ - - /LYl & ; t l ; ;L, Ji k j L a LIUI - . L

&Lscbl kJ+ d d

>A> i.&,u .J+ +I;

_ii. L L i _5i

'

$41 L

>

~

~

2 JliJlj

Lj &I

4I ~

l

C

si. L J & 2 d 3 L &i,sr! &!.19;i;li 3;iliCU 1 . A U I j j U l ~ r J 1JLr &I3

9

+j f

Y +IJ

p pti y,

$Jt-

@+

&-iIr]l GJ+p+d!

+gs

9

tjl+*dI & jy p

j .

0,

+$I

6p

3 Y1

.ad$,

&I,

.&G

I..;0!d+ Jb dl k]Ul ja I&-rk; Jk; iL+ &i$3

o&

j$

&Li 4 5 J+

.lyJgtp& 'kJgtpy-Jl

p b J ~ ' ~ ,2 b '*@I

wl)JbyG A dm!&b

($1

"391, f,

.+-

3 L3i 612$*&I

j!

Intentionali " L W l '9 3 # L ~ L&L I J, ,$L2 @iJ . -4 wL g p .&I 3j+I

JI&

k J

&I

4to -.A

p- gJl;--ji @i :ty

WL

5 L o p Ih .-+

5 ,

d y

&-$.+&I >lijUI j !:t+ . k g - + p ja t> @i jr JI.+ $21 9i kb*d e + I jl d i & -3.>x-l lh +3 &L;~I

r U 1p C I j ~r iJk I &LgLdl .ly$+.+ -LYI &MI& &ij .

t"~+lg;lPjfl"

J! La

~'~+liJliLu.dl"

J&3JAG &+A1 - &I &I "41 i J L j Y I U h-.M 2 LS+JI d l 2-41 - +I-3 &g"

(L% al+) "2&1g jb;)ll' g Metaphore Vive (1975)

J&3

AgTemps et Recit (1983,1984,1985) .

+&d\#I -.

ji .lUi .&

3 2 1J

++&

. ( d u a ) C;;L+I '+I

21

J ~ Y I-

;O,LYI'

++

U l

_r &2&PA~ j1 ~ ; i ; Y 2 I- >.+I &I Y - G bi 2 -

. ~ I

p~ ,

$ Reference

f,; y 7 j +-

~ A I

L

i,L;y\

Ju- +Jdk9

. i J L Y I igki ,jdI

a-j . ~ i , ~ j +

2 +; , L W

++I3

L+l+yl

+A!

.&-

-+I b i 3+-

d3

+

Jp .hhi - pllill++ I L ji 2 i +,LyI \-$;b&j3 +Wl uipiji Up- i++ Zi3L2! $A cslZY& I&;! ~

'

L

~

K

+

W

J$++ kb pi ++I d+! (JW!IL.

+4

A 3

'e J+

~

UI

~

&%I!

bi ;

+i hi &+I

3

jL$!"

,

~

~

-4"

'aU>hil

y k $3

Z G 2 -3 #

~

L~L+A~

b*

+b y 7.4"

-

$ 2 +J

9

59

J L Y ,~+!j .

hck_s Ui'

' u ~ Y I ' b l L L I ' ~ I ~ :+Cj Y I

#

I

>

9

.&lj..aci.$l

~

S ~ I

-,

~

(

z u !+ I ~ Y &i I + 2 3 l

fi3 6 - 3 &-L ~ I ; J I~ t!jj I++

pb

~

r]b dt!! 3 4 1 j W l +W& clj u b (I- k b + Y~u I p-

.i;LII

+ ~$13 '">&I3

+

.&I

441' p l +Lu -3

.jbi3+I3 L

~

2JIG~

G vJ - 3

a-3r! J&.~

L+

~ P l2j 9 3 jbj" 3 i l U l ++I Lli

&JL 2 & d&iiJl & Y 3 I J I "

3-

&g

+J

p

cJ+j

i A j L - J I >UI

>j

&=?J

~3

jb$l &L=!a!

CI;K & irLjW 2 - j

& kjWI flJ+s

jL$l Z>

Je>u

Z+ .&->UI

5

jb>

.UI

L & JF lA;tjjlr3rlg - i &I

jb$l &J

2$lWeJ.&l ~2 &I>>

%L$l a&l3JI j'lgJ d L i r c L hL+J.dI

irYglxll

;A . 9- u bl j d ~is;i 2' - -

"*rJ

Encyclopedia of Phenomenology, p. 613.

(9)

Antony Thisleton, New Horizons i n Her- Antony Thisleton, meneutics. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1992, p.26.

(.t)

2y > ! ; w l

& 21iJ&

Lg;u u $ L - S wgsJ,.+ . U ~ _ - I L LLI #i

F I j i I J , c-iUIJ, iUl

U

& & & - I &I

&i

g *J,

&+dl

.ir'

bi pJ, +9u~

;~;LI y

l jj -. 4 ; "Lw ,.++AiJ,tLikllg

Jlji l*G . ' -.d l j S C ' a L - i

'"'irJ, +*, ,,

*I

9

'L* -

U dl;>J, >$IJ dJ,3

J ~ liJ,'hsj~ 1 , >! -ki _ill G ~ ~i YkI ~f l ~

~~y;L~'ic5k~1~~lj;~,i;i L ~ & Y I J i ~ ~ + - ' * " 5 f ~ l

~>J;dLi,&f&!

u~~~Y,' I L+ 2 iul -1% cGI& ."d!-ui' 2 4 1i+> ;P I+ jhk i U~Q j Y I & >PIJ 'GulJ,1" 2 d&d . ; i ~u& $L ji .fid & + Hermeneutics of suspicion . "uL;~Y I JL4; Ij45;- + ZWI &LiJUI r Y 9 ji Jh-J bL1

ji J+

9

GJI

&JGJ

L&+p1I

j3& J

L f

;P

byJk L+

Skepticism " d l -L1' u

-

Y '+A

"++ C

t ;P

&Yl -

a+,>j 2+ s j ~ a'&\>I JmYl 'ilbij i + ~ &i r j .~ Y I

di . ( ~ & l& M Y \ 3

+ jy+- _roCJl

k

r".

F

--l1

#

David Stewart, The Hermeneutics of Suspicion, Journal o Liter-($) ature and Theology 3 (1989): 301.

i*lA1'

o

~L

Jf! J$-1

AJA@ Lg;lzrlg!

31

L&

dl3 Second Naivete " k ; E

Paul Ricoeur, Freud and Philosophy, p. 33. (*)

i,L% 4+i I ,

p -

,&8

$ ji Is Like "$A'+

Lj,~Itlrxt~i~L'd~ i~lu"~'dl .+,Y I rib &dl! .h3i>$41& Metaphor J;c

P

-3

9

rsQ

+p-i , L Y

I

+. I S Not ~ ; k e "&5 A '-9

>! J a l

& 2 9 1 J-+ L+

6 i , L Y I J+$

r-&dI

@-Y ij L O Y l j Referent "CrJl" 9

j+l

$UI

' J! , U l l ' ji

hbl'Ldi d L 'y$~~' IL.++I LUY\2 LUI ~ e f e r i n 't41, U I ' p d l ' p l W I " I L i "&I CLi b Ig;,Eb i , L Y I +ji ,+L8 dk3 .i+% &&I

bQ' J&J

De~rlythol iJ_.jryl

*(is

like.

&"&

d l

J

1%

Naivrt G ~ j ~ iJ e'Gizing l ~

"wl'+& +s;

) Iconoclasm ''

4 -

d&dl j

G + I

Js

- - t&-&J '"JAd idj j?:j+I ! h . E i L

&

'L+

&"

Jckl\

&> j3bj Metaphor-Faith ~ J L I

j3&-Second

rb'll'$& o;i

rjUl+MI c

iLi

&I

J

''&dl' i&!J &'&y!

(7) ~+l;iilll&13(\):z%aYhj*~'1'JAd GI$\ i

3 :>&I

k

&JaYd3Ulo MI $ &!+I

h

&. (Y) U I o

dj+l

h

a*Jt- &. Jl

+Zs

Jb" J i++ jL

.i++

9

&-

9

Limit Expressions ":;-+ZLlal+l"

>sS;,

3 h - J

jiJLLjN&IAl >+I + L ) L J ~ JProverbs > ~ I JJ b V l Js; ''i+dl al&I1'

o h ."JP

$J

Escatological Sayings ( L U I jc $ L Ji i>'ll

Jyi j

4;431

akKAl3

++pJ+-J

+J

Parables

Erin White, Between Suspicion and Hope: Paul Ricoeur's Vital (*) Hermeneutics, Journal of Literature and Theology 5 (1991):

.F'+

kb-

. - ++>I L ~ U I i J b YI +s h -,The ~ Model) cipJl) GISL*U %J&I +I ".A' 1'r +: 2 1"j.9'Jj i&u +

lI&&Il

A''

;J -I

L CJ

I

J

+I ii.3

FJ+ The Qualifier

I

u

2

! "pWI''

I

j

. L j b Y I kkJl "Lu ;?rl J 4 ' 2 4 1 J.cd! +i

*i "dl\I"

'G-+ ji*-~& ~

'

~

~

~

~

~

&$I/CJ-)WI

c+-j

.-)wI -lJ

i

614.-U

9

4 1~j

-L

. ~g;iJs 3X-; . L-)"

*+ii->

]3!9

p l b~ L '-%J

- + J

6

I

(&ill?

~ K A ~ ~ U

LpJl +&dl-)&2 '(;% Qualifier 'GI ;NJI -. .&&+l-_p &.LA= 2

t;u &,I

~

Parable

JG&Li-)YI +L3h y

-3

C

2

JS

j-s

. i - ) b Y \ &=

ki""413 ' i J l r j Y I

Ln :i$

-)&2

/LAI

J

~

+ ;I

G$L

&$111+-

;3

u-bF ~ U I

J--i;+?>I

c k - l LQ

i J L i Y I -13.~4

& /I

~ r *~r, .j i I, j91,

2

ji

b3 +-

>Igl

&b

j~

-)&--)

+" 29 3 @- I

Revelationu~~J1

93i

.'+ 2 u +;I .1" . .12jl 1". ..I$" 4 ++ 2 +I-) +-ji ' L 4

&A3 '&a

J

+&&I

&I3

."LA%

-

I+ LUX . i J L W ,bTJ2 ;,UYL 'b-i+;+&I; J& &_P &p j l I" &d i 1I 4 ,&-J J&

;+

+G 5 L A ;t:ji

j l+UI>

&+4

$

*U LM~del/Qualifier

LGUI

/c,G..dll'

"-&I

. & , h Y I q4sJ1 Lp

3 hrL-.Yl

J&-,

i2+ &+-I

1 5 Ailljb

G ~ ~ &'d UjiI& J&-J

& ji ,i@I+ 'y & ' k 4 J jJSS;! il'-% %? 2&33 5

Lk3 'L9

>>Y+

Ian) &;olJ

jJ

Z~ualifier "&lll' ~

k-> >I-! 9 3 ~ 3 >1;b 2 P~>WI C

s ~ Lj

&Ill -9

23

&I3

j&

&)$I

i

>

& # &

j& i;p &5 +i+ k;d'i i A I ;~lli%.I2 3

& /&J" d J L Y I +> js; 3-3 JF >AJ3 1

'y

+?

'qu

( * ) 1 1 ~ $ ~

4"

U3 ",+&Y

k&JI

.

1

L & ~ > +I G I 3 iJL%

>Ip! Lg13i .JjC;I13 U+

5

c

2r yj I &3

ul+loL

jp

JS-JL)~

l

&I2 '

1

>&->

0L f & d l Ramsay

4-i~; j 31; ; ; lae

"Jd ,D

$3j l + U lj>A

-

~

3

~

~

d

~

T

,+ @>

+

+

Thisleton, New Horizons, p. 69 . (a)

~

~

~

Jell DL*, 4 Jd.2ij ullLpl3j LJ2 y Y 3X;I c y Y l .dl431&-&.+ u z - + m +&& itJ-p y 1 /+J(ykU LLK !;I $j I

I

,

,

jiLLiJw

pli-ji

C

I cp -

*-Y3p+

~jiISJWljL-;r.~Ul

d b ji A;21 &i jr;l

-

'u

&JJ L+~JJL;" 3 p d I& Y! jiGJWIb. l *. j & ji 2, 1 bd rij i r g J ~.A,~ JL;\ +I /+I ;?. ~ r l j& l i ~ ~ 41 i fLi I++ +-3 A-j21&I +>h& &$>h& .&$I ji Y! . . :j g J+ LLIi 23 .~ ~ , L kLl.l .L I e+.

0i.a

"

(uy 441 \ow W I ) &lJ+YI

db% ;*LL? LY;

I J3Gj l l .sL,Jdl *b $+-

rt+LJ

."A&&I 2 d L J 1 3 s,

- 2 - jh-jLG

e+

+t;,Y

jI A,J; Y3 '++i &Lgi-; j l d &G I

6

& 'W +Lg. Y

J!Y &>yU-~FL'

-

6

3i d $ 1

l &.bey j! 2 3

+

>I+-ie'

It

4

L2

s

&!$I

o w -

4 >I&.

&dl

.o&ji3 03 1 '

&IILJJ" J! tob3dLpJ3

iJe dLA 41 2 IdLd1' I

& Sikg, ,a Explanation

@I1'

.J

+

9&$I &I ji 21jl,;L,;Y!

2 1aLi?U-I

2 bLJ

,Le;f -; L+ ~ p l + l

213J&L:L.03 ?LZ I

Z

&$

241

Explanation "+I1'

@

&I

'

IL L+

Zi-1 jU .l+L-;54 L&l JjL$IJ

&$I

0

U~iderstandin~

d ;

,ji

rUI 2 4 1

+s

2+-

"+I1'

c u&I

$ ~ Y > Q &,i JY

jf

21 . Z $ I

J&-J

Y

-31

A3i+ J+Ji

&I

#I

J! ! p 1 3 ' 4 4 1 ~4 &L A3k3 > L y I &dl3 > r t l l J dl&%'* & 2 C

L3$

iJ3J

.L&Ay\ 2 4 1 j

"pbi~~ll A

'+I"

j #bAb &-AS

l+eJI

& * U l j 'll+&ll'l 3

&g14

~

IL2 pl>Lt &L j &dl3)

l'AAw 2 >\lul l

(-+I

&

J"+R1

b > e 3 ly l l k "c5i;lN bi - (*)

:.?s$z+.%* Langue 'i;UI" ,pJS ~jJS 3j-3 99 t:i;UI j" Parole) Jghcll U

L .p,,

LA? lJParole ' 1 C W l ' 3

Paul Ricoeur, Ethics and Culture: Habermas and Gadamer in (.s) Dialogue, Philosophy Today 17 (1973): 152-165.

4 4 dl Langue)

.

.

& ji . .. di -A

jgs,ll

c++

...MI -a3 ,*_sCu r"q !/+I 2 *zg UI r w;r~14 >=L+-.+> J --y /+I LS e 4 14 1 , +k &- 'Z&' I.W'$> " . CI

&I~-~~'GI>+...Y2iU-3i&&

s+ 6v ~1 - -

(+) l1iJk

'd bi 2 pl+

zbh ji i&

3 :&I &IUUY Y pl>k J r h ,j!" C j f Y&

&+ ji

eJA

z

Jrb i L +.+I

J

df.

.J&-J

#L,p fs

b

f&Jl tikj j I$*

e

l

da$+Yl

.;i;lJlj b+

4 4 ' +4 (c.h &I & M &,b Jrh J&J &-k 3 .@I J! ULVJ4 &+3 &bpj "*

Ul

flu U )s;l$-I

&p< " & l l ; ; ~ .j L lGJw" wb -9

&I

"+

'y

+2 JA,b

4 J&-J

d 3 L

l " U & b-. l j L l e G 4 J ! ~ - j ~ & p d&- ,ji+Y ~ L J I ji d I'>~I

2 96b-l I+.LJbjjj.i/ .&I

U

~d iisdl 2 3 JI;

J3L

Gadamer, The Hermeneutics of Suspicion, in Hermeneutics: (a) Questions and Prospects. eds. G. Shapiro and A. Sica (Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press. 1984), p. 63.

Paul Ricoeur, Explanation and Understanding: On Some Re- (*) markable Connections Among The Theory of the Text, Theory of Action, and Theory of History. In The Philosophy of Paul Ricoeur: An Anthology of His Work, eds. C. Reagen and

D. Stewart (Boston: Beacon Press, 1978): pp. 149-166.

ci

-,

p IlSJUlIl &>2 &-Id\ a,ul C P 3 L-?; SJI

tJ

Jc i i 34~ ;igl &lJl;!

OL

+Id1 4 &+ ~ j&+L+ L Y jiJy~\ki~

l!=J/ ji &I3 ! L - J A I I

-4 4

J ~ ~ ~ d91A ~ 3 d$ljd ;ro i JuI1l I'+!

"+!JUl'g d

."-

jp Y!g

l+

>j &lJ"

U l &l&I

Referent

'&IJ&+

&%Xg

+IJ

9

"y+l'

.+A ji Jg$l .. . <L(afl) -

+~ijCrkJl~pY14-rgp4CUi ,y4 1dl+ .OI+I~

Jj

L

a

*+I

o'Lig a91 &I &YI

&I

jLtl~g

OL

k4-k c$lOl

& ' L.Lil

+.&

&-id1 . . - ji j&-J~ 1 ~j ~ 4 2 &- 9% ?I3 2 dl 9 ~ ' + I "

+

-41 2 Y &&I

Y;.

& ~ g O i + + ~ ~J/I

,y p y p g djA LkLbJl C L O.YL +kg

d i g

dGl+

ji~k.)Ll~~.#Y~_rlJ&2ji~l$li--ki d 0

3 Jgjll

jy Li ~ J d l ?

. ( l + d I )

"+" iIJ cl&l

c

~j L jh-j l

JK; j zi ~ Ul+ll

*\

.a!$! d/I3

& i$;-Jl

+I

~-aldl~

-1

; t _ - ~ ~ pad lY $ l g h. -

J+lp

J-- d!&j 4 1, =Yl

a

3

+p+p

&-$I

2131J4,aAl

LJ 4 r&Yl ji A,+ +iOGA ++- Y3 Reality Principle " ~ I g l l

-'b

4-

*-

L 4 - b

pb

+*I,

.%

l

;

p J&3b a L , ~ij-91~ L+A13

oY+l x

*h *%-3

~ Y2I+'UI

t

--$I

@

9

I L ryi.

J

j4y13

e3 LSYI

~ &;I L L ~~ I &~ &A 41

&I

& (41)

.&&jI 9

2 3+

di

1412 1-3Jr-+i 'JJc

6 p W l

l j &

\+'I

2 Jj -. 3

uI+ +-g13+Y~

!;I bI .&+I!i+ . J.. &I L l r

~

~

j

i

*

+Y +i! r

~

j

l

~

c l l ji

F~

~

~

~

J,~ld.blg j _ e j ~ +\jl$iJ4J+-+ Y

o L ~ gL i LL i~ ;wg ~k-1~ &+ 21 Y pi p g i j &I

jz; &+

'+* 3 6 3 +'I

AWI

.$% 2

rL-g

.,:+i&,+

&!:+I

a d l~i&l ~

b

QLy

$ '&I;LCIPII

.;+ig

ari +aa+413 + 'I 9tO&I j! J,

U b y LL~. &+&I

Paean d

@ + -

ds-. $dl

l ;a+\

&L+

2

5

j%y1&*~:&~e1~yi~r1~& - -

.A &+-LS 41 iglihFL

.. L&!

.jg.'

I

I

. L ~ I U L L - ~ + Y 4 ~r--dJl ji3+-ij-+l 3 3 W ! J? ~ j L ) ' l j,t i4&&I A M 1 4% 9 i-.y!p L CI+I ji3!&Ip pg;+I

2 LU 6 j\&I A~Ji +dl @

J

4 di jiku9d\F a@Yl*&i

9 I& >i .IJlP ~

~

rI+l i , i

jU 231

Y 'a-I

\ +I+\

Y

F'* ..I .bI+

L :

: j3\

L&

& LiJ & &US .+qijlSji w jqcri l ~L! I j& LILi

L Z ~ J

d

P . I 4 1 ~9L ~ S ,U ,I; I

9

:Up,

~

.el9 , ,,<

d~ +*

F J l i

. -.

d

*cl;i3

l

jy,2 eJ L i C L&lJAl ~ J5. : jxi

2L-,Ml+lj

+Ij

ji

~

IY .;

W

>eji

di !ilj

'dJk 'hi 4 J ~ :LI+j i 7 k&l

-

jjj

4 j~c?Lr;.i 1 Ar

& 21 ~

*sr,iij j

~b

*I

+

&I

.+PI

2

>JI

LI-~~UI

& '@I3 'Ab

2 &UI h 3h~ ~3 b

+

j + -

p W l Li3 'A31 o U I

ji! A

Y

U j i pI *rCtl~ji dP-i ::b~p-

~3~ A

gJ Li

I '&

sAi LU f3G

.iGUl 9&3 &L o $'7

k;

L

JS .OUI @A

d3i

+u-$

, ~ I J I'3~)3

Z

'ZJi"

$1

$Ji b L 9 l j 2 1o U I ++Js

2 $33

2 JL

2 2

'&I

26 & d l

Jk3+ &+'+ +, - &j p E .+I j.3.~9.5+ i Y 'JA&-ill +>I '4 L+ p L 'aJl+T&'+I+I &I 'd391OUI o h

+&+

I

--

i l w 1 &J &%L* 3 A 3 '&32"i 2 1" '+up29b~3 j,l& ; ii .FH L~ &I 1

&-'jp d

OLIS+*~~

JJ*

bu3

0 9

1 9

&Ig

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.