في الخلاص النهائي مقال في وعود الإسلاميين والعلمانيين والليبراليين لـ د فهمي جدعان by hamza

ISBN 9957 - 00 - 288-0 ( L J ~)

,Zll rights reserved. No Part of this book may be I-cproduccd, 01- ~rnnsniit~ed i n any or hy any Incans. elccll-onic or ~neclionical.including photocopying. ~rcco~ding 01. by any intbr~nalionslorage relrieval sysleln. wirlioul thc priol- pcr!iiissior~ i r l writ~npol' [lie publisl~er. 1'cll.m

r ~ .jjL 4-d-i j $ I c-lL '&>LYl :&$/ +G y G Ld%.l

3 SpJl

rA*r ?& \

4. - .

r d j j 6

&Ij

JLJ

.L. ~- 4 - Ir G P 9 \

~ +GU i 3 F-"&(.I"

J,~I &I,

r&j

z2Yl

Jl -"

Jyv~21,+

&-Jl@d\

+\I

W L J 6 \ 2 1 4 b*u&&

a >2~ ,;

k;;pu~ UI .SL

"&>",

~ c.

.c9 LO&\ u

UL+

.dj+ &dj 0% "*I+

k j '"&@*I~'

+.g

a+\ y

jg,"&A22l

'LA,>

LJGdi

'&by

> ja t

?&-

21J L ~ U

$ &I y ,

L+p

2 9 '

i! C . ~ ~G>&I I ,

d l G \ ..>dl

rh$ y2, .&14\ PLL, .&UI

a 9 1;r. ;&I

;>A14''

+ &Is

~ d' L y

$ ih";'&L*

.&)+ a; L,

CagAJ\

3 ""'I U

.+'IF

&-dl Lo, ('syY4y

04,

%-dJ Y j b &[ 3

1' 9 &91 I jw\,

'y ;L+

L L G

++A

."+I"

dj2.2 L o p

0 4- 4

L &-dl ..

? d ~ ~ & !0l 4

)

& d..

+I&\

Jl+l

p "

ubu

i) t+L!LC.

2 LC, hjlJ@I

d,&. ILL 2 y - .4

LJI~+I 9ilK 2 6S+y9~ 41 d\j xi J\ja\ 2\41j

@(i -391fci>~

&;.">@I ~

+ ?+di &I ...

) WI

, LJS

~ d&@J '

'kg\J~j'\

- ..

t- &I

.+I

+pi\

+,A\

&, ?L JG

)

L W.1 J

%+I

+...s'/,uI~ L LA&

oh Ji L - 1

+I,& L.AI? i.,+~i, ,.,&IAI;,~ cyj\ * CROISAT, Maurice, Le fedkralisine dans les dP111ocraties conteinporaines, 1992. : Jj

:&>&dlj +@\

Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy

&Yj

+ J ~ + ~ JL-I jC C++I

JsJ

&QlJ

L--,. d l k j J JjLejj3i 3 S . JLL -J+!.~

a 3 w U

JL~ j ~ ?WI - d *. 4d$~

ts Jpii 3

LL-

a-iiJdi1l . ..

I ' ~ L I $ - ~ I

*UIJ

+,s13&)'l

@ U \

)-I

)%&C

. A ~ Y ji I ibJJI $I+YI+

" ) l ' i b + ~

J>L\'I a 1 4

&\+I

ej'

6<y91

p>y AJ L i l i 3 y-36

i2J

AJ. " d ~ erJ~" Q~

di i Y

dij

LbiJIAI 3

'>UI

U j

LJ-L J JL

j .L&

'>I-+

JL+&

& > d l :Lx&&A

+->

:$ (M~;lticuih~rajis~r~, Pluralism).

) I

+&,yl

L~ \

b-i +@\+--IU -LLI L

Colnmunitarian

JELL\ )bj!G L ~ Y & , +l+r-dK : L A

d-t

JL~

Deliberative Democracy. ;i?gldl u l A d l j Democracy. Participatory Democracy G J u lG \ # - d lJ

& ~G-910 - b & di *, . Cosmopolitan

Democracy 4 L J l

d l _CC 1-il . j j U

'LA pj dL+&lj

J'j

3 ajjL+-JJI I

IV, ;

LLL

~d.&G' 1

Lit

lJ+i

d \ i4~J1

'+ p 1O J j * j

iW &L=JI

+L=Jl

jL .

GEL.

L+--

-LJl

iu&I

...

~5 .&>+I

l i l L U I j +dl

+..M-.y\

> j L

ZL >dl

+J,4

e&Ij

&'G Jj b&oL

I-

*V'

LT j ,.,.

3 +=

+l?Vl

4 d 1G ~ + I&

4 L + ~ .&-/VI

qpV&

3 J+>

3 ~&LAI,y

F-

WI 3 b j i d J j d l

+J3Jdj

&,.U~ljcL-L&+

) + + 4

4 1

j .p-$e=L.j

L i b '

y i di

iJI>Y U

&-yVl

&lpl'

;+a! &

( ~ 3ji)(s

O~YJI

~ > G_PC: I +i

ZJ'UI oh 2

) a

&+\h i

++I'& &+

&L b-

JS L+ L&"yi.j~;&I

+dl

>LbYlj

+-j

GL&j

(

;

+41.1

A+,.OLLI~L J Q U I ~ ~ j U al l j -L=Jl

+lj&

llGL&lll

a+\

>j~

* slr\i-Yl

I &*ij aK>l

Lmc6jSli .<L@-+dj +"-dl a G U I + d l

+>l4-\&\hi 3 b J j L J.2 ll&b>~'l a G k

*Yj ' a d j +J&alp&

o j w j p-L .&yVi

J j 2001

r u l

L ~ ~ 2L: I.jJbj "f I )UI"

GG)

.(+l$-Jl

....

* +& I ~ I &~ L #

j j k i j d

LC. @I+Jl

b~ u L a$\ &I-

> p J5

ts*

JQ &I -" ?'

+IJ

+Li

Y~C~L'I

J! 24. d

L'l~pF

+\+...dl

?I q F 1

+iJI

GG" ~ ~

a+ajjJ9 $

,.iy~&I

a, &4 1

"hJ2-"

J! J-A\ -. 2

4 "w" 2 LC.+ I + c - J i

&iL " + ~ ~ . / Lgi-i ";icz +J" LL.+

c U I j +$I

LKI :ly

.+LiJI

M - I

+~+.JI

Hsb"

j ~ ~ j +.= )

~ ~. 9 -1 '.YLI~

d j-

PI ~ 3 ~+JG( 47)

LC. I

I h J .&\JI * "cIy L d-+

&LI+cjI

1 b& ."-"

& JL-

"dkAJ-bl' ?>-I I , & --

3 LC. & b \ p . J I

& j "iL&"

c(y3>>K

A\ U 9I

Jj+d ~

d K i

~ j $ %+I 1

,?-.-dl

dm1 cjpilj

wp ,i

Lg?!

2, - pul

p-af

d l a 2

,L-y -h ..a

j-jU

"+i"

5 L p U i J /JJj

+31

&Ch:

LC. &i"L$'

L"&cdlt

$ Ig^u ;F "

j+lj

"i+'hLlt' pkJl

$lj

o-is

" G ~ I " &LA\j , k

IjL

t r b

a& +I

L=4UI

&ill &=-dlj

I+:& l z i j

E&I

&&Ij

4sUIJ

-'7

&-I

)Uyl

@+il

Y J! 331 4 r y i 6pAl

A, . '

OL c-

fCIJIJ

~ 1 - 5 3 b>?-

&-A\,

.*UIj

1c.4+bj

$ Qi

L C ~'GC

o L 3 ?I.L $J

ru!jr l y J - y l j

3.. 6: - '+JI

df 2

&li

y$1 ~L>llj +%91j + L Y l J d\ j

d\ : d W l

31 rF>& J,ji i+ 3 d j b '"-;cL h l & &Ld >+ d& '+\ o d "~&!l"

.J-dlj ~jul +,

+\$.dl

I-i.

fl41

~ $ 1

$(d'&t

11GJJ3f1 p LC. 'LJ9l$-Al

6j>l "&IJI'~

+vl

clrf

:J,~LI

&>di + - J ~ . L ~ 2 - J,\,A^UI ... c j + ~ j

&I +.+&j~ ji

uji

+IOJ y w y l j + L ~~I y b 4s$i y ~ ji : + W I

tjpil

615.*yl

dl5

LOLL

kJ+-lt

$2 &I L,JI -. + & . L ~ I +I

A+

t G W \

31 j

~ t i

+JJL) "4

15*gll"(pL j 3 Z 4 ; j

,)dl

4',i "41" ,"+I &I",

hc,p -b- d*il J d d ~ ~ F L;li

*i /%-I

&, c.,&+,& i dii 'LL%"e, .&jl

( c w l ) ?*

w\j clj

(+jL

,jJI

*J bj*i

JU&j>\ 0 - b

d-ill

d k A l j .Jj$I

~ U I ,

,jAI & 2 uU~ UIJl

3pdl

>>I>

Mashiah)

$3 d

>u JJ..s--

ki (?JJ> >JIj>]) d$j,c*Li+r , L >% jj ULJI

s&l

Gdl+j

&> Jj9l :

L#&

9: '>,I>

%+I

J -

(dL.'yl

)i,

4 4

I',$$

l ; .4;!

&91 clkp.& Jj&

& Qb LsLt

3L:

+J-ql

-&-dl

d>&l

V J J

3191 r-4

4 1L!

.,,++,

d>,J

.@G!&

i! L J ~ s - ,& p(C;

.(King

+ JW,L&l

d3l Li . i > L jr X +

+ j i 2 "ULU w " 1-b ( j L j y \ > I )

j L j I & L i 3 L,+L!

JAl,

d l

J! rb -9 @ (Psalms 8:5,80: 18) :?d 4 l 1j L.

L$ 4 12 - j

The Messiah Ul & l / g )

(4') l-b ei &

/A< &I)- ,

,. ~ L ; Y$21 I

r,si ) b j g U J kjC) '"h.by~" j) 1

- -

ELIADE, Mircea (Editor in Chiei), The Encyclopedia of Religion. art. Mcssianism, Vo1.9, pp. 470-477.

G A I )j-

" jk" ijY

;LG

U-igi i l ' d ~ &I+I"& G '(SSSJ'

&--dm.&l+lg

A 41 41 @ *i r>lg

.(')!41l~i

&+I,-

~ I

1 OJ+LI

r*.

2*il

&LA\ IL& (LJI >i) .&$I +Jl

4) -4 9

k. b W l j t@YI I

?*c" &>&A JWl

jiFl"

f, ",&A

lgki

+ isk

&I e L d l j &$&I

d+J\ ji

bi)

( ~ A +I b

i )

A& b > \ Li .$Y$ U / ;\+Ij

d h Y I clL

+j,A~

i j 9 12

ilL 3 i f k 9 \ & Y

c+y1j

"sl$yl

'I>~i '"d~ 3k 6-4 b (cs9~ d W \

'Gfi L p '$

C%YIj

&dl

OL & +uii

& 2>$1"j " p l " -+

3 9 3 G & j .c Lj .cikJIj J$I

ilk &&I

&5fi L

j_. ,?+;G

&k 5 ;{ ~ L= C\! $le(;-lylj

++- a-9di 2 L a dSI-Ll L 3 J ~G3 I &L &bi &I $j>l a L & L@Z-&\ & j > b j J l p Y b

.''i&i&I1

:"MI

/2'

-"L

p \ A l ~ b Y )Lr 1

W &Uj J (Le desenchantement du rnonde) ")-1

. d

-'pjj.j

.~-dhg,

K , .jui l L&i

A -d

.~4;

+,,

+"i,

P;+L&~ rsdi

i.iiikkii

&Jrl JLAI

J, 'i+d-i

d,d1

j lgG

~ +-dljI

i.KF

L.;.J>,

'J LhL. iT;/

~ - d db'\>\

j .b

';GI j .; i o ~ I

-3J-

& ' ".A

byj

j l J l 3 4bJI

' K JMI sL,d~j k d / J l

ite' *j

J.2Y Q y L 'lL+Jj&l'

s) .-

c;d I>! &I

.&lhll

-Ij

UI1-

11&2.4u111 &&*\ ad,&\o h p l

&& 8 LC. a/\

& &$I o h

Jlill +A&

~ 4%~" I

-&JLJl

-L+&-Vl

'p?LJ\

d,JI b - 1 . 2

2 iwj4+

) cJkd1 4 1j[ 4 1

3 +s-+

-I&\

b+bj

4 1J j > j

Q L y l aliLiili r G j jwj j LL; c 41 +WI 3 ;L.L ;LA\ 'j J 4 L j 'LAl>\ L&Al ~ V &IIs3 U Ip i jb Ci!j

Llil;

;+I&!.&. " JW\ pLdl

dj(j

cl_s

isj

.%yl cp

&I, k y \ " ii~j . ,/ & 'lwiril d ~ +

Jp.- 6

&Lyl *i;tl

JL$! jlk;

J&i , U I a!"

'uilL L*,

ikj

>jLl

.(. .) +I p jj .

Vbj&FLc

UI 2.

J U I Gl$L.Alj

3+ j +I

+ylN l L

%J d ~ 3 1-i

."p,~x. >%I &

&\ - YJ ( + A ) & L ' i z i i l

3 L

J-2

a p l ^ ~lglwJ ~ '2144d i.,e++ hi

di j !& j J Ul

4J-A..l

+jb,-Jl Ck.3 +I

窶連-

G I d l

LLL d j ; , ,+GI '1 JJ*2

L+

r(G5Ckil Gl&I) kcp

039,

dj" :Lpi!

j$&

I+ ,k:I3 &a&

diii J@I

p / % - IJ

d,>

+%.A!

a[ & &I,

l-4 * j-

I ,

'lli>&ll;+&I

di,,+LJI

0 - b

,Lki$l,

,i &I,i ,+YI

./%-I

LJL!

(yl i j k y I " , '2&+-

+jL+

JG!&i j ~2 A-

dy%yl

'I'dkyl 'f%yl

->,

*\I1

lil+bj'l

P-U

+ljs-$\ 0

9-ib

& \ $ 'r&l

u UT

O w l , aK&,

91 U

G@I

&idO+JI

OK7

aLL.4, +IF!,

d,Jl

' I ,

.(ibLlli)

'cxj >@I,

31,

a,L-,

. L a

,+ j,UA, 'G3,&- &I l'pI1l i&Lt > L p &L+A JG, L L ; --,+ ~ && +-+ L dl ed; C:L;,+I-! J -i3-di C ~ C jj,

& d J b r-1 ,P

&>Ij

$4,

&Jc!

L++

&j>\EiLi j .,&b~ \hA+

i4-b

q,j:Y,!

.+LY\

Yu,

b!, ' ~ K ' / I OL J &I

>&-

dl j 414@ILi;ll J + ~ E i41),> I L+ r%y\ ),J, i,

<>i*sYIj is>@\

S k !

.ii

,bL3

eig

S-lj

L32$~

d l >,,,

JL+!r

A-

]

b-9L4L.J 'LG, LK +,Lhr $ 4

3 A,,*

& &Sj

+!2 tJUl, >UI&

r$i

3 ~ 1 > 1

'WJ

3 LJ?)

+-, UIj dT,Ai +I

2 '@'j\

&,ok

p dli

'LJ#Ij

~ S 3 -~ l

i2p;LI GIUI +$I

a'j 3

J ~ G$I jt

LC.

L ' -6 2 UI. I +! jL

~51-91y J L i l I

.'l'I,Bp~j41 p J$ ~

as+1 2Ld.

a! c . s b l

LQYI

cjL 3 ?L Jib+ 'lgXe, 4,~i-ij~5-91

r;I

3 +I

LC.

p91

&Ul

0.ia

(I?

.@Ij

s~r-ri + i,gj I*.

is"

*>I

'1-7

J+' "

lit L & W j

-2

ir-rlj d 5 + l j

a k u o~ *. J

$I)-\

I +)I ~

+~ > u l

I,B,+j

(&s&-)

('-99

y p j-ui I,ij2j c i ~dj p J-I

>-\I1

3- J&>I&I -

J! li!j+$I b

JI~'"+L!

d ' -1

Jki3 ~22,.kg~,ii, ~ k ibJ&i , j /&lj '&$I

d j k 2 "

.&,L*II

GU " J U l

3Czd.tI

~ 5 j hY .-Ir

r%Yl

41 1~:

J.L+.A

'b+%Yl

eL L

+$I

'y "+bJ'ji"

akkj

i;cp

jLJ1 3

A-) 441-3

'by

~ , ~ , 9 l 11qy9111 ?YdYl,

& djj .2001 r W \ 2

?%Yl

GI+I

I*.

'&"?91

& >WI

?%>I

+L?I

ji j e &lYj ~

'y 2-

( 2 b )

L+

a! +

62kL&l

q&21>\

o*.

t b i i

b-44 j

';hi,

(lj,

4,i)

J u i3,

AL-AZM. S.J.: Islamic Funda~nentalismReconsidered. 1993. :3+i alJiu)Gr LLki 4 1 ;LJ : d6$) UY J, Lh>+ .(2002 Lag

(2)

& &I,+ j.r%Y'

lie

j.3

~ 9 1& LA $1

"L' s J q G+

-3

;aj ~i~

I !"d>lspj

d. .

J j ~3

, &

LiL

+%y\ I +4is+

C & J ~ &dl 3 k Y \

d%YI

3 iijl &G a + V \

y+\

;pj

* .

3 ~111&lLlI

JG ,

d d3

$ &G -L .. -

+A\ !3 .2+LV\ J+\

>,u;pL\ i w i jij .+.J!

p Lii &i, a+ ".iu 3.

+$I

d y

a~~~

*-JI PI > '

4j12

-GI'

OL >I

G'UI

did. L- . J ~?%!i;+\j

+I+\ a+J S L -(L ~L ~& Iry) j i j c 4 i a ~ 34 3. 1.1 J \ 3 ~ ' 1 ur b ai di & --+3 ..&I lie 3 - ~ 9 \ aKJ9\ L! p-

3 2

~ boJJ/2J& ! '&

-* &A\

;A+%! Q3

\P E L J

dj>

{\dl j r j djdl 2 2 LJjdI aC1>Wl 3 'lppll"\LA 1 - i ~ & LAL Yj " & L A " Ji )a1 L j ‘dpVl K LLK \ii &i '+I \L & /VI jK .4lj&\ cj+\ 0

0 i L j )

&3L,p1I

L&bj

dJ> LaGIc

+-3

.&pi c. 3

J! \r64;i >+LA\ bil

is,>

&j3

eIijl

&+!\

L".

+LA

;

3~ 9 1 PIj p L " ;J-E* 3

pu is> L 9 +'A\ u j Js lia,

'"+&Ijlli ...

3 i;i

,+ j.&! .+LC

k L c ~I + I " P L Y !

~ I - L c ~ \6 ~

hiJ

cfli9

.(l)llAj~~

Jdi .+J &.LJL /Ui &?,!

LS?

blj

~2P

i i iJ L l l

,;,c

u &yi 2 ..

'J*JI a>i

k g .$A

Iijg i3l3.iJ > I >

>I$

j i >,UI,

AS+

dl La c~~

Jdl GyJ

.)-i9

by ;A:9

>,Mi

' U L &UI rQ3 JdIJ 91 LC*!a>-,

J! JLjJ

, ' b

~ $ l g .b\*L>

(2)"*"ul LLL

'J!

J jjk JIj L

2 - A'I

,+OLLl &>+J!\

eC;I

3 &,,A

jdi

-ij

3 d J L i J d>i3 Jdi 2,b & / J L ~

jp" : dy

'L, _C ,i $1

J;;ij

cSt-+ +b

jli

d , ~ a i & 1ij9. > , L I ~

'&I

s i j j

d > f dl3 +-JI .p

ji, "

91 j i 4e4;L1 _is LC.-\

& 'l*u\"j+, ij ' d h 3 c3:I& J!J &LUlLLL -a 2 3 L& &L 2j-PljJ?jl) L-J~J &IJ

+ A

&i - WlJ J*Ji 6i+l &I L,

-42

j +&I\

.(+UI)

k i s jJ

bL..&b

j +,.L

&MI

++&I L A

y 4

&i&

bi& & d l l l 'dj L .e

3 L ~ A9 I

d ~ > G ~ -dl& l '

jSi G&T3

IL+-,,\

i 4.a & *_

-'2-3

p--j

df I,. ll~JFj

c ' ~ L9~J d I

C+

. ( U I ) +Lc

GI .

L >&I

6u;

a +>I1 i

p &-,

G *U :'JUI

&-&dl J d l

2 b Y 1 9 &f -'I,

J ~ W J\ d

j & - I ij~ L l j d.d

4%~"

hll ji +UI +-& L &&2

opjf kis isr9i

j w i

9 b

,&.I1'+

a&lJlj

4~ & is!*i '

& +!*h!i

-9e-i j b ,

"dk;rYl"

d i

+IF

+dl

&=+ 5

Lip dJ.( &ij i d >

,-~'JI 2 dj >j u\ ij$\ j ~j J j i l j u i ,

:&GjI d

J1j-J

i l

iJ+-J\

ljlj b J

*hi .&.,A&\

&+dl

U Y I j

i.&>~j

>,+jJ\ 3 L . &

p T

+ (

L,+- d L J ?%)'I 2

&.+Jj

~ L Y+.yj

y ~. ~ ~ ~ e ;j JLII *il 3 % &i

ji;

~sj I ai 9 $1

' J ~ L ~JL~ j 9j +I

d L j &K i!.(&+I & j ) 9 c r L ' $ I

~ L~ 1

jla;

a\ Q

;.Asj

d i

&I .

ji Y!

uei-

'%/I

JI,J\ . -

&jJ j & - \

?%)'I

+>Lyi

-41

t"\-iAj

.pii+ L5i

91 2

Y ' j g UI iAj

GL Justice as Fairness

dJjb

( 3 b i

+XYI~

+& y=-- ' A h

L., ...

ijJ dy- t l i l 5

LC, dl&\)

+&I &ii&i

ji h CIL

I -L +~ I

,S Theory of Justice +&

>bif L 1971

~ - ~2 I

i) c i l p

3: 'L-+/

L~ ' d ~ ''+EL:!'' d ~ A ?z

JWI J

ji 2 ipb

J-J

& & j.(did1

y y L+

. F T LC.

-U& a+\

~i; LL'! .. LKJI

21, ,y

&-p j &L +I! $&)

C2 &I

- (Jdl)

T+

$/ il 5

a. i1

J! j W l j

d*ii

*ki13

' ' '..L J L ~ \ OL " 2 J,JI

fLJj LgL

JLJ+

p;~ L gJkC ~ X Y I 4 j J J ~ iJ ji p

j;z

(+-$I)

i+ ~i,$I

2 ukJL;Y ;i

.?"yI

.J\j-iY\ % j'u-.

j +.&,I

s~;-L.d 1 - i "

'dl,ik

2\d.l

,~VI

L ;(U ;~) 3 J+ di 3) 3 J i & iJj&k A> ~5d j k >wA I ji~ J&\ IL -1 J . (w-d~) . oJB c-JJ . Q ~ JU l j j 1 l I3 ji l ' y d - ~a ~ l ' d w ' / ~ G j ,+.s p U 1 3 9 1Jj +A\4 >+ tr4\L+ L I U I 11-

.'be[ L&/ 4 4 9

-$ & j I

r e 1;

j&"

aepj

&,*;

j i 2 ,dl

JcL Jlri ~i

dY1'

JSC,

fwJ2k!j

SLj

,L L'.Kd j.+-I

",di

b\ d

pk!\ 341 d f L

d l - & j > 9-

Q k Y l

Jk 2 b M j

iJi>Y\-L?-

J!- "

21 q J U l

rfwl

oJB q

izjJ

I 2

J 'yyJl j

sJ*-\l

L MIj

k.,j ip-".--u '&+I

> + ~ r&-JL

GI> jdl iiu

LL 2 '( v u l ) r

dYit>I1 & + >L+-

.,A\ 341 ij.,,As$\

dl jjJI cL2 - +\

4 Y! & Y

l ' k / ~ & ~Ol ' I , U I

j i j ' q i+ ~ ul J! QI,>I aldJi 1"

; t ~ ib~ i

i .

'(Le dksenchantement du munde)

ad1 k j , $ .(La sortie de la religion) "ydlj.cJAi" &J

SC, d

d * U >&I

,,&A1

New

+LjJ 19,' i d 1 i.&Y+l

4-d-1&I)

''qY91"

+dl +lFvlJ

pp" rP3

9 Jl

&/i

k j J j [ i ) (Age

ek'$~-l i15.%'$I ) WI i )

i ) &'$I

.G,dI d,jLJl 3 &-dl- s'$l Peter ) ~3 .tL+.JI $>

.J 3 > tlJ#l a dI PIi!& JX- 4i$l

. . t l c L - j Y l jiu

ui 3 p~'(L.Berger

;C &LL!

y '?dl) Wl"

:WC. i'$.LI

&i - j. & d l s ~ $ i J ~ ! / ~ ~ i ) , + ~ j . ~ &+

dkil $ 3 1 L+~t

IJ& di

uj dl

JGi

. " d ~ ~ 9 1bj

dl h

alj&i /

&.ddlg

d l

d L A i i J l di (Roger Finke &-b

)

3 (Rodny Strak

(I'

NORKIS, Pipa and INGLEHART, Ronald, Sacred and SecularReligion and Politics Worldwide, PP. 3 -4.

i LALP

F L.

~jill

S,@\ (y+dk J5L.J

3iJl

EL91 OKJ+

)&L

.11d4 Li,

3 L+

SIJI

j!4 p ,

&>I

d S

c~~ D+J

i+ ;li 4&%yl c b y ~ &jI 4+-dl JEL91 if d d l

"LA -- .9

y j i 49 c-&b

?WI 'y bLjj ~ i t l3i y K -

JG ,

Posten +u

-Wi

&+>

dt.' 4% p-ii

L.$;kd\ rr>I

+~z;;r~dl" ,i l l % W i

9 ) b

4 1 , ~L-JJ-I

Y L ~F-ji

FIJI

a>kij Jyllands

41 +

-,"

r%yI JyJ "I+YI

. . ,-&-I

"d*;L~"+lb &A\ &I

+-JI el-92, '2006

MLI

J - p-+ ~ L sY G l1wJb

Jp.

a'*., . " j... ~ S ~ j,"

;_.

6J&\

i>k!t , A I

ep*

, ,LL

'(2005)

i%yI y3L.j 9

j p i i CL-L+-Y

(..I >+I,

~.s=J

wli

'&-GJ3i-L

L,'llwJ~ --,

$" 1 ~ 1 ,@,

&I$

3 &Ij

if "i, 'LL is*.&

c.4, $'1

4 lJ+ ;jL 3..

3 i p i l j! Jkl~

4~3*py

-, jipi~

)

-jAi;54-

C) UI 'y L-

lJ+

;-,

,i "+LL"+-41"

--J+~

h;c % W I +IJ

JS J&

.&91

' , A

L.,

9 M-d,

X LUj; ."Q'&l -iibJ1,i

14-ii

Henri 3jWl

G ~ lj J g p &>LC. f+t, . & ~ C9dd_ll k , *)d 3 1 k

j .

I+

"+;kWll' :j$ I'

&-dl 3 j W I jlgCI, +A\

U'LL&II

'[ Laos

--%&I

Jl+- &I

+L$

p f-r2 6

+L&

I$/ 'JLLII 2 4 1 IL+,

?LI

& A 1 3! %b

~c-4

Pena-Ruiz

& d, .&LJ\ LSJI .aj JLLI IL& ?+-l 36 (h_;U) Laicite

@Lj

$ Q$ YI;.

rllli, ;@9i;LI & - I , ."dj-dJ *+I

"~l." &*-l~"

y'+ JJ l iqkL $ j .Sphere publique ?WI JGl 4LZ/

(I'

$ 3 ?WI cWlci.U*,

Maurice BARBIER, La laicit&,p. 69

127

~ b+ k

-9

~ ~ /, + b ~1 i

PENA-RUIZ, Henri, Qu'est -- ce que la laicite, PP. 7 1-72. .128/.

.. 1')

'08'd 13 ' S L - t L 'dd '?3'd0

,,,

'HLZInX-VN3d

.83 4 "'COQ, Guy, Lai'citC et republique, p . 21

L-

-. 0 1

dU-1" J> 3 & L L J

.(dUl) o h

C3> & 3 b J & 9

i3iiwk

& Jj>*

3 qU1

&\,A

Ju \A+h,

a[ J,I

(A:) Patrie ;&9 3 ?I871 Cui 4 ,; 1873 r i j l j&+

G W l Ja h, >

.J+L

pJU\

d3dl

+gi

p3 - dkJ\& j i 3

rWl jb!

'&$I

0-b

+kJ\

tp8w1sy

j & I j l d+++

L+&L?

&A\> $+I j i y i + &t

4 1% /

a3 .-LLI

i+, 2

2 && +-G + ~ I

Idj

I-

&ip'$&I

a ~ l ,&" j -,+!I

-\>I

LL. 'JUI >Lf- '>LA-\

d,dl

aJSi> -Jl -41

+UI JLCCji

I+ ~ ( j ii s i i& . i I ' .

jki

GJZ! .d&>91

dc& 1905 rlJl j j L &

&-,

&-A\ e3 - J391

a$ - +%yI

tl&13

>91 >-m& 02 -kJ+l &>I

cLMiI

33 . Anti-clerical

l h >3*_1

<U\ a7 &y-

:&\,A LJ%&,A

&>I

Laicite

c J! ,&

Secularism

2 351

j+dl ~ $ 1 ;;LC J U I >L+

' e l

h j'ij

.+A\3 d,dI 3 J&~ &>+ U l d C U lj'I-41 3

(7+dJ

- LA

+UI

GipUI a

+LA\\,

; , > +UI

L J ~ L > ~ ~ d &d l A3 J.A Gi '(wI) i+

COSTA-LASCOUX, Jacqueline, Les trois Ages de la lai'cite, PP. 7 -8; REMOND, Rene, La laicit&et ses contrintes,1995.

133

(''

GAUCHET, Marcel, La religion dans la democratie, P .4 1 ; et M.GAUCHET, le dksenchantement du monde- Une histoire politique de la religion, 1985.

"' GAUCHET,M,, La religion dans la dkmocratie, P.38 '2'

VINCENT, Jean-Marie, Max Weber ou la dernocratie inachevCe,p. 171

135

?&I

ILt 49 d+

j+L

I;(-&/

& 3 4 4 ~2% j A+& &+ Y A~~.(>~LAI) 9 A\" : J+ iLeJJj

a,+\ +

&" 3,

+U fJLrJI ?+&

J -

~L *

e;.3 I+UI + +J&L. & 'JJI .~-r> i h j2j .ItL5>j J L

ecs" Y " :JG j! taL iy 'A1 d,JLYI ~r &UI j

d&L K

d-6

+-'&

.1906 (LJI 3 (&dl)

LT.

JLf;-.'(&Ljy)

I &lJ ~ L < ~'~\J,AJI,

+; $1

". K

j !

L Y! i

~ i ~! $ 1

&-+cl>l -

J&-,.>Y '0-

~J,AI,

I &I,~

)

.(neutralite)

"J+il1

di,

&. Jyp

i r i , Y dii isllj

q u &I,

+---

&-Jj9\

LT,-UI+

">b" p k +LA&

GAUCHET, M., 0p.cit. PP. 83-84

136

fb"

:;%JY

jL;: a L J 1 j '(reparation

> (gjj&\ ;p

b'j!~~+zh;l' >h>IF.

+-i

r ~ 1 d , +!'&i;ii&

,i p ~ &. 15:

'+A91

LL ~ k i

~ma& JUl, ( 41o h & %J4

(I'

>A\

$,ipg_Jui 41 ,

jj d p

-4i

&! dFL% Y d b w \ &!P & l J A, j p-&bjy & b

raycite

jU I y!

&-IJ

antireligieux

"' DEBKAY, Regis,

&>lu

anticlerical

La IaYcitC: une exception frangaise. p. 200.

137

'A,':4 ' L" u ++I

L%i+'j

'rwlj

+ j l j

'dLY1

+m(&j $Ij

2 + i5jj J&! d+

&kil

U- p

+$I

,b91 J! eY>4A h j ( y &)

GUI

'I'

s~io!"

JL\jjij

.+-A\

J! ~2 J5 jj A*g! J_ij d~

."+I

;%j +kWi ;_I

'+l+jl

p-pj - L Laos p gdl 6 Lai'citC @z.A di;&

a\ dj 3 E L Y \ j

c3>lj (. .) d dy-+:

Jfij

& +$I

8-b

4'2+.&A+dL~ P ' kiljL+l+"dlj

l (4d

+ U l " j . L lj

d &l - l' i -y --fLiL";. '

+Y ~

U 31 J+ I

&-LI$.Akil

d\ i j\

uI+-Ai dPX,- d-i

BARBIER,M., La lai'citk, PP. 75-77

139

cj>i

A\ j

4 .(1912)

,+A,

p k.yWi :il;U &L\,

k. ~ W IL"+",

.f'3d~ 2 iljd\

I+

.-u\ $ i d \ 2 &L k-, aij

a! >*u ck -C"

Y, +&I

jJz-+

a[ a,ffl ck

FdiJ

o>yj

JGI Jj ?LJI JGI i+I

& ?+J,VI

+I'

">'f.-'I

J-YI~

yJ.+& 'La ;jjL*

",;UI:

;GI+jlu-& LL

</LC\

3k&[

p Y d~~ J ~ I~. + 3 ~a! J \ ~.+LYII ~ .a,ffl ?LJI JGI cJd "i k i ju. i i j J flJ /6

. > b y 1 cLaii\j& /

,dU

C b Ji iJj,.d& /

A&+,

&->

*&I

2Y y- A,!

&LC\ ~

uU I ~

iljdlHp-G!

J$I+

&,L

J+-,

4u;i

&, iljdi

raI>WI L J k j

$dl >L,'cl'>Gl" &c

.--- 3 Q

> L l

iJJ> 623 d\j -LC\

LLJI

G! &.Y j ~ U & ;I# y

.&dl t+JI

J!j >g Y

J+ j

i$L*

&& ai +- a\ U dl

.@I

~4.91 uu> u a&" a! ~ UyI

&I+

p li!,~

4gkj d a&- a!

kjJ * r 2 21

J+

241

4j \Laj

?+J-

.>Ah J A i ~ I

~ ~ J ILittrt (9-1)

A+

"'Barbier, Op.cit, PP. 85-86.

14 1

L qLlcj ' 6 4 >?A-

Exception ) yJJl

"' "'

"-41 i > \ p l l

& jL

I.L j ."ojyJ1'

J! +U& p+

q U I o&i

" b l l

JI u2pj: .dJj

+kwI

:+--Y&

& ?ll;+(fragaise

$ rLS! w-j.?LJI

bii &I?

-6

Buisson, F., LaYciti-, art. In Dictionnaire de Pedagogic et d'instruction publique (Cite dans HAYAT,Pierre, La laicit6 et les pouvoirs, PP 125- 126). Barbier, Op. Cit, P. 97.

"' Guy COQ, Lai'citC et rkpublique, P. 29. .21

.&/

L.&

"' "'

HAYAT, Pierre, La lai'citt' et les pouvoirs-Pour une critique de la raison lai'que, 1988. Op.Cit., p.6. PENA- RUIZ, Qu'est-ce que la lai'citC, PP. 127-132.

L+

. (secularism)

GLAI, (secularization)

&$ $\dLL\ j Bryan Wilson

1-y)

(

(secularization

LP laZ$ & 2ji I*.

/Ll

(+UI)

L U Y I;,A& &,AF @ ~L$ @\ I,

Efh 0%

$5 L

d t Mircea Eliade

7L4L.d.*>G-I%&& d l

+-UI~i+iJ jj

& I d \ j

& +ij),i

duU\

L p

Secularism

bJ3&j

r9+d

-1)

Encyclopedia of Religion

&-,+4 $ G

3 p. L.+

G+-

31h

-&.L~I

&I*s,M _kij

-k,Wi

j ~91,

+*I\

h ; U I bi . ~ & l

& ~ % W J ~i Y J y L AI* ! '+y

d L $ \c '

~la9-, i

;>b f, +>

'I'

&qJ ' ~ J -$I J

5L J f l + , ji

Gj bQJ! brj &I

3,- ;tj.,*I\

i.Lp3

j Air,

)

"kyy"

WILSON, Bryan,, Secularization , art. In Encj .:lopedia of Religion, vol. 13, P 159.

>*i!

,i "L-" JJI ai JS. ?WI &I,ap

GL.LcpIJ g _ i 4

@i '(&+I I JG

aL+J3+y\

d&I1 p L

'I&

+ p? " i l k c y l " ? ~ ej pi ~

L ~ Y I

2 &Ij

,i 41 ji a & ~ ji\ ~ % V I dl ji

&iji i p ~ -

a L u J+

& j >-dl a>fl

$=-A\) a*

?/ $1

L-

DL&=

9 k.L-/

~ji

*c 'It=

k*I

u, +"*I\ ~

+ l

..-I ly & ..

*--

JWI ej"

,!j+

- ,h -4 AL ;,D?/l cs

+ &Ij

") Wl 3 &+I h 9%bi ~1 aj*l\ &I

3 ?t

w: Jyi 3u i~ C I P

3k.y

j~J i $w\j-kf pj .-LJI

LUI" -

&-'11aj*14-u+

G+L

Y ii

'd+>

2 II&LLI'I

ai d& +-j .l'+jy!

+Jr+!ll &!

"I-

G ''

d l 37 L -.

J U. + $1

&&-+ I+

z+Jd\ pl+l

Secularization U J > ~ +I

>j J,!&*il L,UI

abGylj .(')uI

jpil

& a( &"$

dl b[ -

uyv>,

U i

L j +.J1

1"J

1 U \ ' l

$dj*14

-91 G

~w L

j-9\

/+\

WILSON, Bryan, Secularization, art. in Encylopedia of Sociology, vo1.4.

j y > l j a L $ l L+

dl Peter

@" :J+

jjLUl4-

w lil

bl+ jf Li,&

i 1 2 L

&-AUji ; ~ - d i

$2'4 pl? &I

'LL l i l j .+-dl

Jg+,j

l 3 ab&G

Berger p) A

2 a&

a L $ \ j+I

L L 'b,,&

GUIje

l 3 alsiki

'jA

jy>lj

A ,j

i db '&&I

& dUl3 d K

$ 1

& L $ l

p,;lJl

alsU 3 1-

j t 'iljd\ & j 41 & &4kll\ 3

>q .MI u& w% 3 ~

'U&

ikJl

Jl;Li

J>dxj

LU\

$ U ~ d \ d i ~ ~ - d ! + j L i ~ 1 L -&m\ j ~ > j

+U\i*l &I

'''

fjLi!

3 &-dl i l y J l

.&9=;1-

i g h l *

cCks-& I+..& _r ,+i

d&I31s ..J-u

y l

BERGER,Peter L.The Sacred Canopy: Elements of a Sociological Theory oi' Religion, 1967 and 1969(La religion dans la conscience moderne. PP. 174- 175).

3 b

3;W

&J+$1

pltr.

td j! iibji L+- ' +y i d

-4

p l d i L ~UJ~ll

'I+\''

' C ~ J3-94 &+k\'' JL-9 L 1 ' i U \ fl F-j\

3-94 -3

,! 6 Secular

i GAGJ!, "4

r&1 r ~ - ~ )

J& ( + b y \

$dl

,i ,&+*i~ >,91

'd*ii

J! ' e g ~ ~ b y i

-9 (5-9jl) p dJj

.(&I)

d'jk 2

9 dj-9.*--dl d L 1 ~ v a&@& 1 ~

.(&A) +A 1" AS

k k

* b

-9!

r+j

(&$*i\) &-b$1 , ~ ~ j 1 0\ j - rd l

j! 1-

1 -

~I,L+SI

L-i rW F .(+-+JI) j z >;LJ~ I a .?-<& -3 > ~b 9

.(2)r~i-~!J

LLc &Yd\ -7 &'&

d E k ; J > ~ "

J+.AI

3-93 &>Ul J+

-9 9 v ~i

31~

~h l Secular

& '1648

L ( + ~ I )Secularism e

& ( 1906

rWI 3

f '"~J3*i\ ~ L z !

l e. -\ SF

a J L \ IJS3 3 L Y I -I:

c%)

A+

p j .+j\ >ij

"' Wilson, Op.cit.

4 4 Zly

rcJluh

U L - 9 + C' ;i.j

18 17, John Holyooke

+ELb

au-y~

"' Art. Secular, in Dictionary of the Social Sciences.

~2~ dU 3&.Y\I1

+-UAI

d, J+4 +-" "ilylli k" ii b && &-&I ILdi 4 .(l)tfd+ js

btf &Ib i ~ z& j ul-

JIIl

2 ?$I Jj

djpT

~ $ 1 i J G 1 &,

sjL+

'~d-1

Luvl

!Id

."-A1 +pF

4 J*; LJ

&>$

L+

>>I2 u

jJ1'bJ-1

. Weltanschauung

JLk

G$\

rd &dl a1 d,

di GL

'UI

' ~ < ~ iy l d *(2)+A\

2 " & ~ I I + I "r _ j ~ ,ZIJAI

3 ;G &iJ . Z l A l & c il.91 MI =LI

'2'

GUIj

iJG\,

p, 'Secularization U+>'$I

$ .+I

3i L+

;$& >AS ai L+ a&I di

& +$\ Jl d,-l

F(U SLU

4 14 pUi >L+l

&I, 'tlLJ,dl

3,&

r*irlK C I A 6 qk;jl pI#l y

LS- c & > p i l j L&d\ i J L ; U I ,

Jlf, .*

hL ..

L 'mi +

($,ql

+ b $ l

CIA!-I6~1i1di

&>$

j~ii

L"&+>

a b ~ s j l "

J~S; $3

L Y J 1 3 Original Christian Version dl;

&.A,dl,

.12/ '&I c2 i&u\ Encyclopedia of Sociology, P. 2487

:&I

&4>Lkjl

>y, ~

~~~6

d+bJl l A+ (I'

J,W, A+.+,

'+U jipLII ~gj

hij.

+,A J

J I d5J1 i&'L!

>\>I 41 2 >d, .MLj it-,

;,-I

if;"

v~~ &-

- J+1, U ,I

."J@I 4%1~11 4 i-bp L j

dbi91

31 J p i l j . '-,

u-&d

L +&I

>,Lua k ~ ,

ai 3

u-Jl

3 b 2j

8 '3YY>j I

qkwi

4;b>k

y+'y

*Lbrj I

'&A\I"

4jr a+\ k, '+

J&! j

q31a142 3- '&&I -

+>?I

d 3L.

3 +I+& Lb ii%

&&j-+u

3 jl

Yu -JIaLJLI\:>LSYI

ji d "6 . 41 -

+ ~i ji -

"~ I lij. i j i g ~ ~ ~~L C J~

'i"I I" Ji u;;:L p : >J+i ;w p- ' u, ) UI IG eb Jkw/II

i s

+*i\ AWL ~ L-C Y I,b\F~,Y

iGy j++.dl

+j . " # ~ i

d y ~

-'I3

&5 1 5 sL @ tW. &--j

+?,

&''$+IJ

I+by-j .ItbJYij G*ii

&jJlt

d -+Jl

' Secularism

bi j\ ."dd~" "JL j-

"Lk

*c jlk!

13aL. ,

bi & j .( Secular)

3 i 4G

J+ abj+i

& a i i $1

'"+

+bJI

c+%*il"

;r-. .-UI

i"j+,-s

I 9 y j +&I

J>b3 W

&b Y

r&\ j2i1-

alJ+Ij

.+dlj

J! 4

u a ~ b j YYL ~

.aijij a

w&& a

aI+>vI

L~JI

,i 4jyk

iSpg~~ I ~ C ; S Y3 I +3 p i .(I)&>Ul& y & a9 3 .&?VI ;GI

JLQ"? jl ; k i l l

& k j

j+I

ryuI 4C*j

oLlJ%Ll

j . LLi? '$&I

4 JL 3 Larry Shiner >L 6 j Y G L U

+ pLbjii

l t-...~ + l &+I

L j b+,

px-3 -3

+b\Il

r3-'1I

Dictionary of Modem Sociology

. .--

. ;4 YJ-' *&I

'531 g &>U\ ; $3 .+dl

d L bJ&i+

p i

~ k wjii

a I i

i h

-2

-3

'.+'J! (

+ a&

15J?l~ 6iJ 4 '

&$I

r X L i

\ I 1

;$G&,

& 3kWI +I

, JY ~ id,l ; ~ ~;(TC 3

L-2 "

J" ' d

.&I

-1

qlgi~ -I+& -f

" 'q-5-

-4 -5

JK-!

-6

OLi . ,

d F J ~

- ~ i-YS + q I 1

i'J 2

37 , 3 c u l

.(2)&>Ul

?--c"J! 4 - k

SJ1' iddl r3 $1

;li ~9

(..)

+iJ

b..i"i.L;s

. .

3 9 +& ,A .

A* 31 LG-

~ i i3_

21ikrjl~

6-.L J L 9 ~ ~7 J; c - ~ i yi d 5 ~ 1 ;II_LL\ 5 J d j ~ I

f+ J

i..

lik 2 J

+L Gi uj & --2j - ( > \ + - I );>\>

1 ;-,.LA\ci

- d l j ilJ-U

" \+I" j> & 3 +I ~-b-'d.@ \& I1>,b'!

+A! &-. d C h2- 6i . l .& c & &A!LLJI .+LLlr+" 0 *-xs & "+" .djAl

L C

+A-$,

.J d l )

uik. Y

,&I

z&\

&L;

.+UI a d ?>I

~ P GL J d ' >p b -Id 41 o,i I

,+&I

k - 3J

j .&>A\

2 I+! * i a

i,,Ul

Secularization keW6 _pG

&L i d p . &kLL.\l

1-b . " ~ S ~ Lg .?,s & k. d l 4" &-d J d - ) "~;ls= \ +" Wl J

~ i c L 3'' i &l5L

;i_p aIL& iJhi il&

3 Y 9 - 2 3 &2 - J. +,+-

Lii.{) '-++y~y\j

&L.+

& 9 I j +Lidj

secularism

*$)

."'";..*r -+$I ;-rJ ~ k wj! \"J9pIb +kLLU

~JJ p I 4~Jd

~ J ; U J G.9 I

+ L&JI c+,

& irk."

2y J/i; $1

ipWi

L+L'LJ\~ .. .. " g J L d I

&I"

"&I

rj-,+ & J L ? ~ &&\I I~

p&Y1

L-4

.(l)L%dl

"1 L..b J l i! d l b+ 2j 'iJ\GI djd\ UL J

L Y p ' Q j'k3,. L&&AI c..i iJl 3..

'>+I

ll&-dlll

'+by1

Li+

4 L2

1 2 9

1 ".

3 ciJ&i

& -LG

+ +i

jljjl

a~,d

b y \

&Kj

;,&A\

+U!La-

d*.dlj '

*ij .+dl & l j i I

3 4p~)4 4 1LlJ&y

) b &\

,L +.&I

-,j C

c W ~~2~ ",'ki)~ i;i

co>~+v -91 j -LUI

ljj . ( 2 1 1 1 k ;'~ LAI ~

SMJl tj" ( j!

G'r'-)'l

+ b ) 1 1 &gj

alJ+

bjLj ~

'd'L5,

+m;lij -

+I"

&\JI

+ a+\

0bIF[l

3 "Ji & L d l j3iJU~

d ,l

J+

'%$I

3 +UI aL$\

J$I

Leh. XJAJIvJ&lj+,MI b k

j_r -. A+

djdI

dLj

...

$ &jy 1

u\&

4 1 ~u" \

3&Ckil 3 d

Js JiF&

&LO GIj y U l j

'"&I ~ 3 .+

a1-L-

;

, d l

LL.$%I

1 1 3 ~PIy ~JG~" i+ J! L-: 1- '

I I

isljbYI j .

~uuj

A ~ U

JUJI

..&L.b b; b

,'+di

A~ &i2 "c-~pll3 ~uy u~1'

~ ~ - ,i9-LJI1

L.:

&dl I'+\

) Is, d v u \ J dj$&LL)\J.i913

isb'yJ'lj

4+-&

:i ~p I/\

s i p 'uj

g djdl 11

:;-L\

b *,:i

L L ~ I &j

&dl%;

J.jYl

A. Y

++- P;%

d,>

+Ulj

.&A!& d l

v, J.2 v

((y*WIj

J U I ,

r p - $1

,~JYC;LI _pu

LE jL-59,

pl? +I,

'kt;L&lc

&dl & G%Il

;yj

'+,+

d,dl

&dl

,i i - ~ i +&'I

.bL fGJl

, C

J &.A\ ~

.('U

> ?+"

dl)l+l

u J W I

;is>yj

~ L ,=-I +,+~ I

h- &I.

i - ~'+py : :i

WJL k i ~ c

p-\.bj LJL+U, L i b

3 ZYJI

+=-:>I

.4>\2

di) &AI &$ &2L?;iYlg

&,l>?j'lj

p i

L+-+,

j&-d!

ji"

a i :2j 26 J

9jI)

''I-

+'~,*-j +I

d 3 p

JJ u

&+qi

J+jijJ

LL.+

"c;&I ~ U I L 2

+p$-aiJ

dlj

p-(i blJ

6 J$

ipvl

a l g x ; i l d P ; ~ Y j p j d J * l 1 +bJ

')%I" &j

+-LJl&

Js L!,

d i e

@ i t

,&&

rWI GW ~ W GWYl I p. - di

+ ,

G > L +jJ 2 k.+kWI & d l - J

JL L$

Js 4ijJ.i i49\ .(2)11d%7 JGM d L y l X J y L I &-Is LAY G I + &

Wl 3pj @,+A\ L,p

lG-

jL;y

@Jb 3

a\ d p 'jYv\ o h > L\&-

i> J &

+ d &

&CII 41

b~+ ai LZli

6dlj C d L)

rJF

jjj~*lii~i++tLiexljJ~~jil'&~

~9 L) 4-J

,UlJ/LC1

ji 6 , &15~i-. ~ @i

'p;LJl

+Ul d l J l

+d3 pb J > b j i g 2 ~&-J'(i w LW & - > ~ i

J#.&

wl3;r kp by p b J>LF bJLi

&iJj

+-W j .*;uy

+ & L! '&AC,q + I

j%!J l

kY-*U l

g" LC. CL+"*ll

J . A L

Gi (+-$I ? d l lib

dyi

+ +UI

9 4+

r+ y &J\

,yI, i J y

. + A id,L&\

&+I

^ C

pg\ J

+' "Jiyill 2 ?!! jay J dwiJi LU &>L$3)

J c&.

ed;

.">I

4 1I

G+

rL.2 Y

J6ki@ L 31 ,i '"+>LA"

T,=

.fl$3+'$~

&91

@iY

).+ J!

$-">LA

' Io*' -l

2 QUI

' l k L ~

L--&

11..

> k j j ) Lr\J!

i J& ;

& " 4}3.&\11

j +I

&..A j

l h

dJ 6-

.L>uL >\ '

LL \ ~

.0j2-j

du.yl

3c;. 'iJj+& '$2 Y hp 9;

4k-i. ' Q U I

3 ! d l ;! '31; J[ >d\ I

a i G ~ h

UL-J ?jb YI, dY

2Y d J .dU\

A. JGi

'&>La

+3v4! 7 l1++l

~IGL;;

(+A\ &$IJ

?;. SiCA5 y @ 'L,b 1-$; 4! J*j"dL&>l>l

&*" q'jk GJJ.J\

2-1

~ U I &

kjpiil' ~gw j LL i+

.WJ

a;d, . b s y i J

ri,i

~k Ji '"&LLjJ"

4 ui L!Ji

?J\,

I+\

&C-j +&I

+ U l

ys3 ) i i 2

2 M l l i 3 i.*-i

_I!

b>*r

'oJJp '33- ~ U ji > I b y \3

Gb! &Lk

i~ ,,

k ; U I

14 '41111 ak4 JUI

3Yl

I 1 q U i>&ll

l1;&l1

,j&*

I+:LJ-U{-U\

/'A\JGl

Jj "&JI'' >> -1 e j L

k !\~L~>[JJj~Lb! 3 9 13\-,

-41

9 ' ~ ~ '3PI 6

p ji

.isF[

khij ~

dlj

a&.

~ r i~ l 9 2jki\ 9

,,+i u 49 3 6 - 113, ' ~ i , d j d 4kL +i2, "91"? d e l l .pis & +' ,>

& JjJl

&LL~

A-1

~]j,d\ ,y y-

.d jJ1 3

r 4 9 1 PCP &-\>I

$LC;" jc

+>iji

'3k-l .

J -SLY\ --

b ji 6 Acte de foi "34

f91 ih-

ji t.h i &i- "$1 -k+

p k. *Lj

LLXJI~

di.l1

inlj -+

L 3 Lk+L +LXJIj

31 J$& d iL & &I

3 &-j / \ j C

Uj 4 9 y j

PCP J>h +

w\ +

,&i

;+ -

/Vl

? * \

03.3s

I1+"di1' *>k,

;GJ+

&& " 2 ~iibL+

&>u -k

dp ->-dl

j\ &J9~ &\

.&>?I

arQl

p j ~ Cdi i". J! LI~

.&I

G ~ I 6" i

~ L a l il b & .

jh& d l &I

ji; y~ MI39

Y &i

?j l j&A\

J>ls"i.I&"

a\J\eiA

'* Lt

6Ji

-%$I\

+ (A .&

&,&I

'&b

&&&-

G,A

L'l'&l

i+'l&\

+ 3 k~~'(i.\j)

d~ ~i

l"i,rll'

&Y' I ji ,4 '&I?

& + y ..A\ I1&,A\ G'

j s 9 13-1

l'a~al"

+.''>1,>~1~~ l'L-h>l~ll

Gw\l' JY 3' 'iy q ',

%$I

3 J,G -

3 y-af

db r

+ ii!,

r"\ & - jib\ L

&!iAjjl? &+/

&%!!

4\,d1.h

2 t+: a

YJ&.&

&-.Y,IJ",

+\+I,

&yi d

iflij!\

a l J & .G ~ &L \ \

'IdLh ~-ili.-=Ul1' ji Liberal Democracy ''iil=\li ~ l + . . d i 1 ' Neoliberalism

2'9

";-.dl

qli_jll",!

Ultra-Liberalism

(Libertarianisrni~ibertaris~n~:)

+,~&\i''

$ (Emile Faguet,Liberalisme, 1303) +L &A!---.(

p.J\dj

1."(i

& &I & $2GI a&-

&LA L~%?I

.l10dJj

@ -

Y d i j (h9

dLj

G G Y~j ')m G j J

'&+L-Yj

b9 )

JjGy

+di

(-ij2

(gl,d\ i> 4 " :(1927

\ilj

lk.ilk-Y

-3 1927

Ludwig Von Mises, Liberalism, ) ~ i , Uld

?-d>

LiL

L i

i^-iJgij

.L-.9lil

u & j J d $ .Li?ihrY, k$ +&

jri jiif J p d i ~ ! ~ JiPv; L~& A

d - ~j 9

b l L l grhii jr LLAI

. s w ji ~3129

sLWI

2 i&l 9j"&

;&is o

GL. i

J23- LL i (..)*\+I

4 aij ,+ . di bi,

+UI

@$ Js

G&Jj[

&J-

c ~ - - ~

3 dij L L,+G

, h L&

a,--

+uji

uut

213!

$1 .~*JI

,& i J 3 L A l

A+ -I

eJ&, +&\'I

L ) ~ u

+..&&dl # U I jylhil /+-Icso 3

,& +jpA(pL&l

-L

dj '

;.L)il

v & .,

+L J! &-;

L'i! . 2 y s ) l l ?Li & $+

L++2q+)

&-4.4% &$I

+ai h

y+\

ij :)

."+-LYI

q l J d l j!": 1929 ?Ljl

U I j~ ++I U / e(~iilU l \A ,)& &I

djdl

a,$&

d L jr

uL@L--

*~I~:\!I~.,J&~

ai><-:

'91 .&gi ... & 'ij.

..."'

p,o

.I&

&I u! '*jc!

JL;i~" 3 i'y

b$ $1

d I 2 k ) J l 3; *Ldl

2 i>ijC

4 ~ 9d 1 '$dl

S!" : A-b d y

jp y

L -

L i i :>ti

+ ;J

oyy

'i,+F91

W I

LLs'l~yl

J+l

''is+

prj L G \ ,& ~,

&I +I

'+ J d

2 j2.L

;*I

p &f-

+--&I

Lkl

+st\

-,0bL.AJS+\

.(Friedricl-1 Von Hayek, La constitutio~lde la libertk 1960) (&

-ul

~.. u "

:yr $' S

F &Gs.i-"il

id\'WI

c i g ~ :Lp ,Y $,I

I ;iJj&I

.(Rayond Polin, Le libt-ralisme, oui, 1984)

d e - 2

~~d-1 yJ,L$'I I

GI,& 2+~i'1 :dY3 dg-,, J-> ,:

UI-$A!

i +Y&I ,

4 1 6M

(

GAl

)

"is-vi

j2 d.. ii\&\\" - ,j! j+ &tiJ& yJw ,u _CU,-jLoy\ \ 14 'q)*il 2A1d a

CJAI+I

4 2

,&>L&Y\

,\$I

& AJ+JI A $1 /-.A\ Mario J Y ~-2

bit. 'a& +Iil

J5'

- i > u I&ji l l d ~u\>" l Jy

d L Ye l j d j d l

d&i

) ."&Ldl + L ' $., l :,...,L!l ++I

c!&

(d+)

iJfi,aw

(;\.F9\j J \ ~ $ ' iI j > \ d , ~L+I

)ly (&d pr3)

i&\>JpJ\ l h z...L+

&$,

L@j'&~

"dy\,jbl'21

.(Vargas Llosa , ides enjcux de la libcrtk. 1994

&,A& d 4 . y

b\& ( L d L L )

Si)

a G+ + 26 &,y~ JWkJ '+I r J > ~;Ck ?Ij '&I j k I j ++l3 AY L+\

di,

.(Allan Bloom, Commentaires, %--'y i > j d l djd\

;&iG

dj>

d i+

& @Gjj

djJi dy-J

J+Mi 9

UlkL

p J,LI cz+\

. (Norterto Bobbio, LibCralisme et dkmocratie,

"u M(,'

YL @j

~dp jd2 I ~ J+)Jj ' uLY

.ily

kji Y

oh +-di J-

+UIj 'djchll z!J>

L dl" -/ L &d L)L

~+.JI~

iGi

1985) '&&I

&di*w & d l &J&l &I

ihl .. +I

ohJ >+I

OL+I

:+J

i l l

199 1 )

"j > L '

Jsd-) (/, QIIJJ~-;!

1- '

.(Raymond Aron, Qu'est-ce que le libCralisme? 1960)

9 'ZGLA ,i

t + ~,I LLJI

'>$I"

Raymond Polin, Le ) "Q-ll,L=Ul -LJI d ~ - + ":j+-)!

-69dyJ+ J,d-j

yW1 d

1-b2 3 J>jj -63, .(liberalisme, oui,

( > Norterto Bobbio, Libkralisme et ) ;i-I\g J

LJG

yvl +u 3

~Y)j

$ .(dCrnocratie,

199 1

.'1,114+,4kx i p Q\,J\" ." :Ij$

"' LAURENT, Alain, La Philosophie, +;: bLJ~&

0j.0 c-L;.;.'

liberale - Histoire et actualite d'une tradition intellectuelle,2002.

i! 'hJ+l d.L..&d1I

1 j~ -. J

~k&

'j &+ a\i& &fi .. \ \

3J-b

Jp>LCY ihL i-L.J\ - L-LJ b>k

Cap d

' 2it i6+

J+$1

."i. LC-\ c L b -

jf c

~i. & 3~J i~ y 9 ~

-u>&

i>-6

'+>+I

& +&' &I\ 1-

LC>"

LJJJ &.,LLr>i

LL -k +jJ '.g~

L @A 9 djJ' d Y > L L \

+J&~

l 4 12 dJyJLL\

F-d i q d ~

d,\s

4 y j . ~ + * i i ) Wi js &

JWI

d ~ L l \yj-j j Igs

+JWI

g J i J "-A\

iui j&\JI

,?LI

~i -91

4 1. . 9 + 1-. G*

La,$\

Laisser faire j i 2

JGi

3 >-'+9

C?ll! :

JJ.LU j~A\ p k 9 1AK ~ ~ b j & l k ? , L j V>i'J\G\ r d - lj.&> t L 9 $ (Benjamin Constant) "

41 & L ~ Idi L+UI fi .. \I + +C + Lp -)&I d i j (Individualism) GI>$ JL .A:: 4 'r+ :his,@+J!Z > k & ';I+\ p

(>,dl)

3t 2;:

k4d&

L.JI .is"..

&>pi\ d

/91

J,!

$ ,>

i,L)

J,! c$

j f jjij\

LJ,-.JI

J+

scks\ +,LU \ +*.

"+>>" 4 rk '1.;

j!j L+>$i

& +i3

JI,d~ a\J+\J

Liberalism , art. by Jereiny WALDRON, in Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy, PP. 600-604.

' Dictioilnaire dlEthique et de Philosophie morale,P. 880. 210

Le liberalisme, textes choisis et present& par Mikael Garandeau, P. 13-14.

~ Libkralisme 4 1 ?I,:&\

& 1 2i,i~6(I ~;,LLI ~LLI

Encyclopkd~ePhilosoplique Univcrsellc, 11. Les Notions Philosophiques, t.1, PP. 1467-136:;

:LL-;-'l

?\--I

+J.J

il)

2 ,p$, ~.YW\II ,k;,i 5< 2

"illt*ll

;>L*JI

dl-

a%!) 4 L)

dial

>A&

isJj LJIGI

'&51U1

r&+

ti.+-

;C.Pkj t d L y l

3jA

d,,L

L"A!

,>k!,

d ~ y~ i

&dl+ f2

y*dl

,dl

Lib $ L Y l

jyw ;is' + d l oh,

.> j

F-t ~ & k j+l u I>,&- +-3, ' L j G

a-W\

'LGiij. p'(&-+LI & d l &I &&*-:

+ t-

+\~LI~

iJ& -4 '(Happiness

LW\ &U dp

J&I

tLpl

dl .--+I

J-CC.di J j JL

j JU,

3111 pLJJ j j , .GI

dp L &,,.L+-+LJI&+,

The Pursuit of ) J-YI

3% ~

L I )

> L \ I

3 WLi . d j d l

4 J+ 4 j i

41 4 1

;,,*&

&i- d

p LC.,+dl

JL, iJJ> J$

df Lk

d,> ,i ' ; ~ > b 'L+LA

) $$I

+ - d l

L+I~

>L~U

&-Y UjdIj - (3-6

+ LLLE

il,>IC!,

91~

;y&)

234

'~I~;JI

.( h F g>dl>)) (Nomocratie) d j L

AkiUI4 2

Li;"dl,+

.~8\1.

"LUI

,L& jK--Ll,

A+

'"++I &/I"

r>~,.L+i

J9 I

jK--91dC, I'>*)

.LL-JI,

cf d *i 9,

:dL;YI b L z i l d i + b LLK aLsG 3

+L p

+ ,

>GYI, J-I

j F j

+-.A 4 a d 1 p 'J"

rL!a

OF-

& . ~ ~ I I J U l p L ~ V J ~ 4 6 j i W ~ . i ~ l k ,

A\,>!

'L.4 41 fi WI3 c l i j ~ k'd.il J-q-

y . s ~aji.i ~

ji 3

41 . + - jju

abwl dl L L q L - J i

dl$l cf

611 j !gpy

+lgU 'pi, 4

by\

&>,dl&+I

341 r~

;;e" +>'

.~5\'1 &J\,+=J ll

a,&-

&$\

~LLLII & j 4 1 J],

d y , /+. jLrlI,

dj$ . W I & 2

J: 2 j % Y I 4&

,-3

isdl

+~~+y~!,;i&i~,J~ai

GliJJi i)id

.;.UI$- -

.GI4

Jjvl

GI&

t&lC~ j j

?JTj

'-$!

&-PJ -4 Lb)

AY j

J@lt G U ~ qlg! I

p i .(I.Kristol)

.di i ;r' *ki

* j '

U. . . dy->b

'l+dlll 3 L4

AU-I+I

d L 4 4 d&

JAG

& LA-> &dlJC. -

414

&dl& - dJ; #

'&-,PI

4111 k.Gi

G 4L->lJ qlfi _)

( Z J ~ L ' S I &$I )

.)L.+YI

: +$I

dJj (W.Ropke) LOU

3Ui

J l ~ Y I ;i;3~l+Jl j

2 % ((Robert Nozick) &-jy

a - 2JJ

p (Milton Friedman)

1-b c)! &4j.i;(F.A.Von Hayek) &b

i)p &-J4ri ;r' ) A

a\& &pF iJw 3 1 9 - dl4\ & d u \ d l b j +& J! 91; "?L-~\jl q1iJJu ."IIliJJl i i- l > diit yIG! kceii J

$3%i, d

&Ib j

i&!

3412 dj>

0-b

Y! d L Y / d bjle. i ; :

&jJ

J!~ zy ai d j d & -

y &GI L=!lp&I +-J

Y @ '(+I)

(+&

>$I

djdl

& &!

'(:)EL y\ J ~ -1 :

.Us3plI J

o p e b

.(Etat minimal)

(yya: 9 9

~&>I>I

S L 4 I &$I

'&L& 'eJ : Z Y

Uj &Lj .b$la

'L+iJiL

&2 . > 3 & ~&i J! Q l 9 1+i>+h+

ug q&>ljlQI$I

L/ .

LiG\ Ul+Ij - 6

.>pl\ djJj

(Communitarianism)

QIS;>iJI

"h L'l&LL\

4 1 4L 1-*i

Q l > d l1-

lib

J,! &GI Q\J=.ul/;

.&A\

& J31i j L j y \ 31 6; ~4.pQ&->I>I

Q I ~ L! I

. . d l

..u."'jPi)( I'&G\lt[,

d\4\l1& - - ... z J a \-,,

&J&-J\

"?IS\" 31,

<w\,? b y \ 3

\J& w-";L-~I"

~~L.J=.ujil

&&\I1

& i w - k.,

& &>LdiI,

t ( 3 4 1 j

+C,

t;c$l+-JJljc&$l)

L+, )LA\, > L C

b, " f L s ~iiti ~"

012 '

' b ~ ++I , y

l d ~ 1

?&'I

2 LkL

;S>b

j 째

d>U

+!! LL, ' D g j

'ye

2 G,J=.uI -

.&I

"a&->\>\

+?-CiS +\I

"",",,UI

,i - 11Q&-31>\ QIJllf'

iiy -i,+&I

6;-

&-+

3LAy1

o h dl

..Iy

.I+

>I?-\I

b b il&

.iilJd\, ;lJIL,Il, +-I (1917)

Wl .-

>&I

(1918-1914)

ZJ$,

&, &I

'+-, bJJ,i

w iL!3 i

-?=-dlH

1970, 1920&

1-1

&JkJLjJ\ eJU~ dG '@{,

+-a/+&I '++I, d

u k l ~

\ aL-)'+I1-0

John ) 1946- 1883 fi 3Jbd~ +-d 6

Ld,

bjL,

Q I ~JGil\ I

~ * kj!i

+d\ b, & , L;A&J\ Z+&\ &+I

J,LI

~ , A3 I i>L-MI

jY.ij

"L-~WY

.(Playnard Keynes

'&bjI>

, 1-

+Jj

i>bFY

'All+ .

"3e j Q

: il,*n)

+p\

j,Vl

O > j

;j+

d+\) GhYI

ilJ*i1 ;+ i+

QIJI +&I ~

3 - b3

Y,\

;>>I

j j J ''i_~l.J-\'' j! h

i i + b . (Etatisation

(Mises) 33 be-9(LJUI irrJdI)G &

iibY31 3

r ~ -i F

sC1;JI

$lk.

'dJj

(&IJ)

>hi 3

(dLG3)

JLI

u 3

'1938

(Walter

Jy&L a>b!&\ GyJl

ful

Lippmann) dQ

a-I

ILL=

.(&-jj),

QGI)lii) 4+,p-, \+d U

2 LeJ4 i i u &I 9,; &/!I\ ~>b;iYl

& ,( de-2 i *

"~jd1)

di L U PJ ~

;,A) ' ~ I 2+ +&I I A\+\ 1-b iC&

i.J~) dL+ j

.(Libertarianism: ~~LJ4 (;+-&I1 ) (~LJ

' ; d l

y (&,V&\

*&L!

+ 3, ' y p i jd+bd y ,

-,( 9 6

&i- ''>A\ &>L~~YI"

Q\+\

3 3*5 4

(Monetarists) " ~ * h l-A\ l + b i "

(>jqjj)

f&\

qI+I a c L .(. , q k J U l j 'iJj-d\ ;Jy$u~&~~s~\JL$~$& -

;+&I

c3J-l &

Aj3j+) &

.gl&\l 2

,IjL

+A\ d j u

kib

f I L&LLIj & > A \ & f -I &I+ i C .&3Ldlqks&l -

+ d l

t-% ;I i J . Lt L k 61

~ J / r c ? ~$t c

'(1974 > G y \2 J J ~ )&b d p '(Socikte du Mont- Pdlerin dl& @Ij

b . ;

&>u1947 r~~

+I)

d J iS J & j2 A dy +e)

" & > A 1 iJ>LJ.I JLi"3 &I

Ig-J

pk;?

4rj

kj'd>&YI

.j A l & - j

b i - L i

& La&

L. J r k i r i

? j:J .il

dpll

J,!;>A\ \+Ji~3ki>-dl 13; LIJSG>GYI '-\ki4j zjIJ4

LUI

GU.1

; a

a+\

,ij,

++I

U S A > ~$32

'>JJlj

+i J!, ,'LVI

SJIdl &id ;+J\ &J\

>uYI"

i J * r L+Y

IA ,i+i

a&J

k-;i '

LL,Z

;.L&LJ

i ,dl

i d \

Jlj ' b L J . 1

$>LPL'YI

;1L+-31

3*1, d

a4~313

di3

~l-91

~ $ 1 ,&dl

rLb

3j3 '~--d\

+=-

>+I

~ ~ I p l l

+ J ~ l c G~ .ti" + b y i n &&GI OLCL J) ;>yd($6 wlk. 11 &&, ) a p I $i

ij .& > ' 4 ) ' 1 aL,UI 3 3

ilc >LAY\

+ I,

~~i ;\*t + d l I .

>&I

$9";>4't

54 i>Y LU U

.;iL &,L\ /+I

;

o h ~.-y

d i "

l l + J J .~ -,

3i"-&I

27, +..A\ L ~ * L+ I U!

c LJ) .

(Lemieux yJ)

$ i.i

+ij "@I

:Jbi, pip! J b 3*

>+I" & " h ~ p l >+I"l 4

(Lepage

,tig.j

>+I

J,!

J@\3 j .(Beneton, 1983) d J i

(formalisme)

>+I

i+blt\

ebb pj

.LP&\

cYLYIo&&iJ >+I -

- L ~ I-Ul

4Jj19 '"JilJI 4 iiJU1

>u\ d J 'p\ 3 $-K) & ~ @ v \

&J,i JC CIA(i+*l;I Ql-,&c ,jp ,UI

$&I

j U Y 1

. (Aftalion d d ~ i j )(Rosa 1 jj,)

G Y S ~ Jg J U 1 &JI I-+/ r$l

JC.!~ kjIji 3 &i

, y V \ $9

&dl

&)-I

(,.A\ $ &U

Art. Ndo-Libkralisme, in Eilcycolpedie Philosophique universele, 11. Les Notions, t. I. PP. 1468-1469.

"'MONTESQUIEU, De Itesprit des lois, t.1. Livre XI, ch. 111.

$) De L'esprit de la conquete et de l'usurpation +S (1830-1766) d b i ; ,i,

I& k&I

"' "'

+ &VI

$ .I'&&I

& y I 1

+-('c*JIj & j" G ~ & ! ~

L,J

+,I iJyl1

3 -.

CONSTANT B, De L'esprit de la conquCte et de l'usurpation, P. 164-168. CONSTANT, B., De la libertk chez les Moden~es:Ecrits Politiques, 1980.

- 1836)

JQI

Thon~asHill Green

+LAY/

& GSVI jj/.+.&I

jl_> &L4;

+WI

LUI

"' BERL..IN,I Two Concepts of Liberty, , 1958. 224

~SF-

*--

G~~ (1882

3 ij J5~ L L Y

"' "'

MikaCl Garandaeu,Le liberalisine,P. 181; T.H. Green, Lecture on the Principles of Political Obligation, in. Philosophical Works, Vol. II., I' 449-452. Dictionuaire dlEthiyue et de Philosophie mc>l.ale,P. 88 1

'" CRANSTON,M., Freedom: A New Analysis, P. 48. "'

M W L S , John, A Theory of Justice, P. 2 3 9 , 3 0 ? .

226

"' RAWLSJ.,

, LibCralisme politique, PP 6-8

229

"' FKIBDMAN, Milton, Capitalisme ct liberte, 1971; L.a liberte du choix, 1980.

"$+IeJl"

~&(L1illusionconstructiviste) I*

dfi 41>1&-&dl ?+I lh,

Gfi'

' ( / k s - y ~ A\),

s>b

'%p ,i

" d ~ YC&l~ &>IJ!

pi>

~ ~ 9 1

L+Al

.d@l

a J l < 3

L +i

LJ+

i2b!

_-bj

& iJ>b Uf &->I- - U .I +Wl o h -SJ .j-I 3 ;>I, P-ji y! u &-y L114ks-y~"1J > b+hi-+

k*r

3 &,+,!=a

'L J! L-3

&Id Y1 L &

Jd ~>,-cc

tj+ d! f .(Totalisme scientiste) d+l'l y iij d k s - y ~?W& > \ J j j +w 9i Z+L 3 GJ>b d A >+& $4 & klk ~ 1 j ~v i>b!"

'I&+\

L+)

. ,

,kA2s%u

:I$L

LL\,+XQ

11+.3

&jJJd &+.

" LLI~" ,,+A , lh dg .

@ks-YIrlkli

&by1

?iJJj,

'tG.1

\. .9

,&& r+- 4.L" LA ji L.& ?+y L " 2 ~ yA&'' j ,i 'I-qd' L "&" -. df (&b) dd

l l ~ L ii>! \ ~ ' l

9 dLY1 j_! d j b

'*bJ 'U=& a4 .+..A

4.s

ui)0a9

f-41p. lil,

'Ax+,

b i

J! ; - k i l l

Robert Nozick & j j

t 2 +

"' HAYEK, F. Von., Law, Legistation and Liberty, 1: Rules and Order; I1 : The Mirage of Social Justice; 111 : Political Order of a Free People, 1973, 1979, 1979. Dictionnaine des Oeuvres Politiques, PP. 437-441. :(&i,!=:

p (Minimal ~ t a t e ) " ~ >d-I i l l dj>" ji +i,G~ . d j d l

"' NOZICK,R., Anarchy, State, and Utopia, 1974 23 8

+*;

'&&

.gigzy1j j p . 5 3 $ "&'j -

+k ji

Absence of ) iGl;il AJ

+$I iij*llj

A, \ d-i

+"p

L g j h j ">Ij

&-I.

&I>

r l b l slj*ll

2IjLl

&,L&\I

ej~i,.

uL 3 ( Interference !

ji &+ I & dj*l\

AfW4-9

i-+

&-j.d%l

j T

.j?pvl

LLjkjjl

AL jSu Gij.

A-

.'IJ>L\

J! dJ+-

kijrJL~~j

ib & i & . J l j ~

l , 2 %U

Y j k

2 "+A\ p"!+;+ +i G ' " + ~ y id l & \ ' ' ~2 .21(Collectivist) "+U\" i91 d y 3 , j > I ~ LJI ~ P

&j.+

ai aj$ di

C,I+

ji ~ I L42 J J!

&IJI

3 $ hJj+ 8 "3>L~JAI dj> 3-

& .L ,l

Jj*l\3

2 J

j. ~d X j d \ J l

I j+\

&'>I

i ,

3 kk 'U;&

.+&I

.L;N,~L$~ j=!

g J ( , ! b l

-,+

i:+

;ii; &:-

+'1-

> JWY\$

M-

UJ ,I

&$/.

+,LJ&JJ,

2 -I) -

iI&i

djLkjl

blPIZ

4__;ji~

LJ d k ( Absolute Self

L.> -

d-4-d1 L

~id i

ownership )

"&I ...

19A~11: LO

p - &I"

ii,kll &p+l

&+I

+ ~ i

& &>UIo

*L=>

"+dl" j !36.3 LB,

j $

,L-J=Jl&

P+&l

‘ " i + l > ~ e l l 1 ,

&JIp$.ul

o j , d

i.1

.-J

:+Lj

9, . ( & j j )

31 3

Q-G

6JI & L ~9I

*i 3i k." : (Self

'j*5'1 -

~&LQ\ ~ I

Ownership) & >-+dlj

& - L,&\

- 37-% d U l >+I

4 & ~i~i! Y! ' > ~ Y I oGL,& +LZ

2 ? ~ iai L@I

Gi; 'S>I,)J

+tb

lip

J " L .. JL

, " ~ > I , L+.+I+\

k b b hi ai & $F/:i

Lii-j+J

"' GELINAS,J., La globalization du monde, PP. 143- 173 %J, &L~I - ,-I\

C ~ :J3 ) +,.!I

+L\I&!I?

&$I

ijkd;

.(95-53= ,

:jk &i +I: i;iL;;ii d l , l y >

WOLLF, Jonathan, Liberterianism, art. 111 Rovtledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy, P. 619.

.a\J+3

& U I j(+&I)

qdl

&y{LA '@I

444 4iml

& L 3, L i C Li+ 3 L JJ& 2 ' 3b

+Lyl

&$I

T +LLlj

r,+

+ 4 $6 j~~ N 5 "+41 Y~ JG-I ~

11 dl f4 L

AlJ>y

d.3

*J\ 37 '4 .G,>$ -+%Y\ d

+-7 \I

4 ~ J v \

L&LI

+ rul

LA\ -. &'A13 +I ;&A\

d M di ~ 3.ajiiii~. .-

4 1 ..

~,JI

1 2 8 - 127 3 <,128 _s

'I)

'l'

9~ & J I

$b3+J+?I

' ++

+bvIj LA3

.I1.

U! ' #Ij + U l

.+->K$ j

&&dlj

Lei U j w K

. c ~*gj '

O*I$

+ U I

dk!19

dl+\

I+ * 6 - 9-

>F j > pa,& d\~+l

'$lJG? j

~ . . +*

' &>&-

,q &.--eLJl 3

kLLd.1

4 4 14 &b

+ +J+kiy~

4-1

+WI

cJJ-5

G W ~j

. &&dlj

& - d U l j &>L&vlj w ! & v l J

G I

&,A\ &)-I

++Ij

- n'+*&j &:

Z , I

yj +J+9\

L*\

--J\..>I~

LI. w K

&)-I

2 ~ 3SY +J+9l

+Id\ L+

;> & - du\ .

6 4 1

' qp ' L+

: d&&l j . ib Lg22 +)-Ij

Jj91

jG.ldp

- &I

&JLx!! +++?I

+MI

&>&.&-*& $

+)-I

iJY

"Ij

.&&I

&-i

d&)-K

&>L&YIj

o h j

+&dl (=LhsYl J+

jJ91&+I Lei L! & , &J

J$Ij

&&I

dW\6+1

JYLA

>$Ipj>

&)-I

&+I

eLb

s~I ~ "I di +A\j .

3 +)-I +j

"GI

&\j

&I 4 s k C 1 +

l+iJ

&>1s;jv13 I

.MI

i1d\ 3 ~\-LV\

-sJE1

3 u 9

&I&\

3 . pu'~yL1 32c+-U\ J unL L '

Liberte ou Liberation ? : d l 4 1

_CS d

i - ~ jd \d~l L ". A\ d I

L-/&'

â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;

l dKJ (

Y >/

iI L

%.,-!)

+ 211 cJ

E G

LUi

-C,

L! . ( J+J~

personnalisme i ; U I

J jJ

E.Mounier

91 &*-f

$ 1

Lpbjj

;+I>

) : 3 \ 4 1

J I

J ~ L&$I -;

GlJl G U )I qur-k;

Le personnalisme )1 $

) dl

Jj &

>+I

&+-+JUI ( Esprit)

Li3

~ * i l

9 bk\Lj

"'3 '

?-d(

Jl,$-l

$-J

h J b J

&'I

gjMl

. LL GJ+ ~ L U?-jii I >L & LA

>,+&I

4 b-FJ b>&e3 aldl

( &I

AliJ

alj

;'[A+-jlJi

2 kJ . .

ud u a

UT r,. Ui )

J &

. u i

J ( PI

~) ~ J

,+I 1-b

j(&

~->@l i-J

k/I

+%)'I

3 & ,$

+ &$

Ui Y!

,~L>U

Jl ~

> 31-5+,\

&> 4>J+2-J1

4 >#I

&g+ F"

G b J l , d L > l l j iJJ&I-5

Ui.i

1521&"21 &

iFJ'

2-b

~1~

a b j oIi

&jj i

L+i-

~ $ 1

4-1

+d-L bAG

)

1.d$4&Aj

j1 Jj \-b3! 4

y 'hi i

~ j -~I

(musulman, 1967

. (1969

41 L+..LLI

i& -a

jbjl:

A J--L

14 -,a.

+&I

<;A

:,el,!!

143 ,=

166- 165

L$;, L

(I!

"' ''I

Y&+I

J+~ \ A j

hF &iL ~ U_is Y U j 4

' ki)+>CCI L g & 3 j r ~ ~ Y d i ~ _ & & ~ . c' l ~ c p w ~ dl>& gb I& (LMY &a1 &m1 3&+1 c J 4 a&+ JL- . " " LA J);i ' y & A ( ~i"

'&-/dl lglb aid1 Y W

21J+\ u2

bbu

+&'

.(')'I

, j>6

3i ~I.

J+\

3 LjSj i d~ 9

55-, ! J+' 3p $a

Y\d\d b i

cJb~),&l &&

. 3L-il

> b+. e -A

diiv~

Jwl&sL3--i&j&JA~ j+4L(ij'>~

s3J+ rj&~ 1-b.

a&+\

4 d u \ &-j -

Lgi IJ+

2-1

'2'" b1-

- a

L$Y

;LJI -

cL\-. r

L&5Ls

j j!

J$& L&J-I a4#

-- y ~

- +\I

JXe ?-pj +L . lJ+ , LU& ui, .u

+( Leon :juI

( IIegel)

Brunschvicg ) L"

F-

9 ' s i k j l j.

p-+ JJ L

; ~ -

3I-iYl

J-! %+I ~ G j iji!

Y ~ I

31 J J4 9 idj

LL&

-63L-..' &>I 11

&+I 6

J':

,Ii

dl$\

UI,

df ia

L,-iJ5p zJy

p " yL= ,bL ti +Wl

a, j - . d l 3 +!d 4~ p ?K-.YI lai> &I 4 9 1

",A\

(1)ll

-',yI$I A-9

*-I, 6

+*, &.ill

dk d L i

3 &+\

d L ( t y AJj, .

GI>\+

j+bil

dl,

. & kjp

u&i +Cc

b u (. .) ji+ih

d&"

di j p >C.

>dl

A) L-i &-I\

+ L Y l

- &+I

$LL

,161 - 149 "-=, (

;:,&I

L .

;L:. 6&J\ - - , LC

14 - 2

: 6 1 !

;

.52 ,*s 4 2 - 1 c 6

~:,--!i

.28 L.o

ti^ J>IL L -. A 5'2

250

' 3<

\IJ

1972

: . ~ L A rY-+>i ~ I ~

:-A

-ix,'.i

.--

I:,

jL-,'$l&

+S?l+b.

3 &+I

o h j

;>w'j,$&*'I

4iilYj

3 Lip -&!

L&pj

%iJ ~ G3I

U9 & S bK-!>ijU3. &I#&i+ Y +I'

I ~ I A+ ! j. , -I

&t,&+.G3pUjj.

")'I

4 LA)'\

.'2'$

.rj

L-J7 q>

3KJi

s-i

Lj>

&L&

d p ! LIj[ ~ LLK

L&$! aL2 &I +I

3 ~JK+! 0 , i e c;Lu A j . fl g ( O lJL.&, UI

.L~;JL

(

$ +>+I j

>lj

+LjaK7 2 & A +$I ;+I\

;GSLJI

3 C.J5j

& u ~I+..AI~ /UI 1-3

L Y '

>+Iu +%-'$I

->+I

-91

J&l

p &&-+&-ij i is*

iJ;J

rJ/

) .

)j .iJ3Uci

d ~i+i&+I

L-yi i K A,91

2 @ ' &+

-LL+

k~,' h 4 1 T,

;bgJ1 +-,A& SGI

L-JI

8J.L

%&I

i 4i

. L.+.JI

J &$I

e &A!

003

4if

' "&$I &UI

&bj! -&-

u' p d$\>

L l j L+A

fl ii.L kiK &I

%, l J

'+-A\ +,4\'G+I

3 3 - L i L k a j 4;li 3 d L J ' l 4 +

)i,,+dl

.d i

iJJpbI1

3%!

$1 '*I

)

a & >-L-t9 -

-\I

+91 ca L 3 LLLI,

A,. (

d,U\

) >+I

&k+hYIJ

;+di

+, . .

&$I

p ~i. ( l ) + J l a i y%,.A\ ~ +iA>L~JI+

,A\

s+-

Y di, . .

.J!

2 dk$lo.b

Lp L

eai &

L.F

d i J: +-.

kbJ

aLU\ 3 &lA\

l l a .&

tu-,~,

+Ii ~ \ $j-\

46 z d \

di p-

~ l L + l l

~,,UI +L>j-b I 2 +h.

j+\ J. iki y-ji

u\ $7'&-&A\ &)-I &pi

a,+\

1 + , 4 U .+I3 L ; y J

+ +Y J!,

:>I4

\LL\

ai J! J ~- idjW\ -

3, . . &-~i 4 1

LL-?

+r'll

Jb) d>@\ j

did " c;G rjG k; skxlj,I> i > L s l J! k& &- +b\ Jdij 4 b y \ P I l+.db>dlJJ dj ~~1 ' hil-,-Ll + f l 2 &I ~ ~ $91 F" I &.AL+ LJ J db)ll

i""1

$ r%C

+" ji OJC~-SI

+LJI

3\91#

iJ& 3 b\f.\dlj

$$I

&f .

&I +I,

rWIj

+ b y \

3L9

+" &I

jljL-LyIJ & > d l Ji-irjJl

+$Ij

kG,.

4 ; y

"& f

-kJII"Ul

-GI

jlC-vlj

& &I ;.~*I.I kJji j jb j $1

5y z.L& ' UWI 3

bJji

LJl&ll

ija l

JAI L+

.i\

~-,~91

k.+

. ( Nkoliberalisme J~

d*-j

Lpj

*-2'' .

& -.Jj " L & & l

-& 3, - d+,L&-

LLS UIJr

GJ$l>

$/Ji

3J q 3 L , h L.., ,.-~ J I 3 L%\

@L,&

iJ$Ij &Ij

Jj*"

L-

ija

J+l

iL6-31121 J! + k j l 4 1j+

&L.& $,I>

.( 1 )

rL j

-L

)

" ..

u_J

ik-*Ll

‘ & b @lj ~ i>\Jyl&F d c h .& d \ J b \

. + ~ Y I +l^jl

ija

fii

k, Lq

;,Ail1

, p , '(Liberalisme

)

o w M &I a

~ ( r l l

solidariste) "+Ld

@ @ >l , L ~i ;~ ~YI +-i. d,dl,

h-2 dl d l 9 & f ) J

L j & JJ&

LO&-

di,dJl"

. J l

" h J ~ ~ \

3 /d ,b yJdb

,i ;+&I 4 1 43;L 1 O&

&-+

'414

?-JI&

ir.&-Lg, i i s

j j , JL.43: d:b

:i 41-y 41121~~

11-

' ~ Ua I%&.d>,A1 l, (yY2'1 a-

2 k. '4141 & 1115p+~j ''u*pCllll bLU +

, ~ i y ~.,i \ 2191 6

'41L a,+

j%j

dy.,Al lb

--;!

rl-;j~ 2

pLc

c~~

L1 l l + b l l

'll&+~

~ I ~ U I

LC+I.

+ ?-LYI

3 9 1OL

4 U-I,

ai ;uj P.;y

*.-J

y & +,,i"il y, 2 j+-

~i,p-41dp?i

"'oy?J.!

ai 4:

(Liberalism/Conservatism) jy

3gjl (Encyclopedia of Sociology ::by1

&-syo,-~J

3'':Jl+l

I-i.

3JAA\

' G ~ I 414'1 & a! ; , &&15d1 LfeOLl 39

1LgrPj $1

0 1

jp Y

.Y--

. ~ +

byy)

JljJl

.LB, ALB

' i > b J ~ i u a+ ~+

I+-

O-M

j -Li

>J&J

;.i, ,&-,i &$I FAl

y h

uj'i,.,oLJ.IJ Q*L\-41 j$l A1 C3,&UIj $2'

$L &I

L.k

4144 G

.$ $"

4 &-

:+I

- 4L!

a! 1-i.

,LC

(Fobert Boguslaw)

9JT PJIA

j, & t , u

(a%)

~16k c i i*;

+-i;i + . + d l j(a%)

j; d l r;l&Y$I j .?I T+

L;kd2

o&Y$I

,*c ai

?>T +I&

'+I

g& 4 Y;+& ~

>,b YJ I+.,-, .k&h

(''

I*! 3cj :IjjJ

?! ykjJjI i j L

, b

l,i!i i

?i Y j l j J dF ... 3 - b ,

L&dJ > y $ I

Ti-LLl

4 U-6J L i l J

?I= LL....,JI " - +I$\

T&>L,&Yl +\$I

Jp& oQI$I y,

t3LdI

T New Deal Ld-I

? ( l ) l l i / ~ l ;&I

LLiYJ

~l(;L4,

:>>dl

4\41YG - . GIJ

A-jj, A - b J

> , b ,i i

. . .(y-.-Jj

p @ ly$\i-4. . .3-j&

BOGUSLAW, Robert, art. Liberalism/Consen-~.tism, in. Encyclopedia of Sociology, Vol. 3. P. 1596.

h '& k

J>9~ ... \,

~ ;tk~ i

"dp-dl

,1"

iicd\"j "+SLY\

a&'J>l 3 b-3

JLS;i & j;L

,+, j i ,

'Yj c i W I

,b" j ' l ; ~ y \ r

&-d l j L

& ;~~'+\j

+i,

GUI

J L ~ &lJ I

LdJ;--'\j

4611~

+JI -\j

+-!-.LI

r"'$~"

" & - . j ~

$ p $1 e&i!, &Jdl

% , y'

&jJ>j

&jJ" & @ &i L+>L-~I,

1;-\__11

2 >>A& dj $ . & y y j

GlF91

&Ul

'&-I

"-,pi

cU~

AJ-k

ji d9*l\ v-d~d~ +-I

JLj 2

;%'$I

LL I + G I

q,iriJlO+l;,

;

"i.~r;l;-'Yl" .+J

\+&

@ 119

+.kj" & s ~ I " +%y! 114

d, 3

"t""A&

yi -~%LJI, ~I+JI, +I)

JAc.wl +I-.

- >b\ I ' d y

.+iA-

& .'lLd-d~", "+-d!"

slp ir. "j?-i-Jl"

r9dji;L? L c l

3 cb + ,

&-"~JL) ~

qJul

P;" j J+ j

"Jj

ir. 4i- ltdir;l'j

w-. & d l

*'I

'(. " .(J,+alj j

'IJG L a1j Lda\ j d I j 2pql y fl , " ; i t&p9l J ' & ;CLJ\I1 $2 J p J l \ - L a J> .W

bFJ1

6U J '(JLLI) 1-bT+

641

j+b L j > b & LS L

Jl i>Fj

lajLb; j6j-k ali +&WI "&jAl" oSS3 4 -

a\ 3" A. &!\ .. &kWI I + .& +-.J$ 36 I&j/ ~g?;; > . is &p, ,c

vLt

J -

&&Aj

&!I "19'>

3~ L +

c,?L,,m

G r L u

- & d l

PGLt ij-3

4 ' i g c b j k~Li 6 j jt

Jbl

u j y

&.LL:

L + ~ J I ~

L z i +a1 o h I+.~l l i W i OGI" ,j I+F-

f L 2 L l i j j . G a l &-j

~ L jiF

+I+JI ~>J,CJI

e.&pJJ-I

r-S:&~

G I 4 + dldl

&',&"dlfWc;. ~ g r l b I j

31 I 1 & j > \ l 1

2 I '

& d l CLbhiiP +p+I l g J W j i;-bI+-dI

++ lyJLC- j~+i&jrLil\$ $91 &>JLU jjt p.3

--AGUI

iikr djdi

ohAL-(-?iJ ~L - I+ L

& liLd-hLIj ~ L i &I j j

" ~ 9 iIJI 1

"IJ)"

ji 0 ~ ~ 4 4 ~j,$ LC. l J +

2b'jI p L l l >JL

3Tj

a j ';>IIYI

GEL I-.

ire

LP LC.

,p,i

+ c-i

01 a& ~ W

L,J

llzgr:>~

+I1'

~ L L ir19dJ I L+

JU 2

&-yLi L+$g

& $ y >I

r j p 41 -i ~ I ~ >L>g>T V & PI&" 8 ~ udi 6\1 j\

.l;yju i jy 2' a & L

)is

-I

+iP i

~erorne Bruner ji

'b-ik!, '+

L+L

L,;ljo

2% y ~j:, b-1~.

."'y'>i

+y '

'j 1

u i g

"Gi>" +-fi

0 \' \ ;;L_L.yLs

,-J

d*i Y!

Totalitarisme )

t,& Jki i13-S +&I q@l

i;c ;>b" -,p Lc U

Q &+

'LJL

he3

(3) 3 ~f ai (JUI) I& 3- &+A 'y r u '&$I -. 91 3 "~141 w \l a "p &I "+,u\" i-12j .&jF 9 ! d / j ,Jl,-JJl 91 a J 9 l &I " ~ j 9 1 tbi " dc

,i 2 9 6 a~L5-1 f, a

~ L 'y 4

>JI

'y AIi f,

I h

3 Z&I @{

-L:

4,d' ,+

LC.

'h-hi,

;L-5 g+\

I i$&J\

.\+bIy

L U i Jd

c,,+ mj 3

L+C

r d+ ~ -

l h i h ir.1

3. A .

‘&$I

2 i 9 .(JUI)

f ' A b 3 b '+JJ.I

'';,Ak+bA\''

4 9 1 +I

LL'PC

&jIyJ$

J! - ~ ;LK j $JL a! /PI

GIJ

+dl,

> L.&

&>+

id$\

3 & \ G I L c+-+ &A\

J& A ( J w ) ~h 3 J$I&+

&,+ u A / l h

bJci &! +JI a;.~jl-;il

i ~ j 9o 1h 3 &\

‘yp j l JS

'eLb

15---s

21& ( j i +-

'iu\

ji,

A $1

'>~)b"

+&a1;\yJi

-+Ltl

?i ~

& ;Csbj rjJ4

&; i -. l j/ pi

gi! S'Ji &

.AI/-\ l h '&L.Ml

(=G 3& 'j

+ JS- GA\ $JI

\h \ is!

GLJl

?IjL ji +L&,

&\&il

k!; iJs-1,

d l

CK L

li,

ii+

.ih~LJ\A

BOURDIEU, Pierre, La philosophie sociale du NCo-LibCralisme. art. in. L,'HuinanitC, 4 Nov., 2003.

,Lk j $UI k i i ; l

" b k i _;r 1 " ;*i-,AI&i'\+;I

~ L 6 &!1 &$I ~a ;, -J, >$lj

j .

41 _-.+

"PI Lp pf-il"

BOURDIEU, Pierre, L'essence du libkralisine, art. in. le. h,londe diploinatique, Mars, 1995.

d C ; s ) '(' ( \ y c c i c 7

E / z / ~ ~ o6-6z1' )

c d L

q r l ; ;"

\p--+\*

C v

\n;j'\@. Cci -qT

C Y ~ vI

q? l,~+C~,l~

,+"

If-

' ~ q %(

J C ~ ~ ! ~ Tq5-?

-+fr ~- 7

ci (&,

C-

)t7r +c? l,~d@ll 9 2 i - f ~A

JC 1

lITPTT-

j p - " ' i e CIT~~-61' c-+l~61'

c-+\<

& -?

f 9mFI

mii.

e-e d P-rcfi qd q f A C T ~ , , ~ ~ w I$m ~ ,AC, - 9- ~

,,@r1:

7~ "i'?s JT

j+-@\q%.

i'!C

\fAi lp-f IF.d l C +

CCI?

6 if"

C y , ?

,FC,fI97 ,

\c \<%. qy,:J%

q-fim

P1 f i 0

-q3-

CJ?

,y v

fif

3 7 m

14 s qCI.rr q+

C\,K,--,".

I(:

fir \AqJ ,f-f-*-.

c v

(\<i,0

4' 1 % ~I<$

.i.,c,

:I,K,T"

-&]C

CtJ-7

~8 i q 6 1 '(i \ m r

\ , K , q c y CJ?

IFf'3if' +nc?\d I<'

-+C?;7 - ~ -~ \n, K , T

qy-9 I p - 9

I-.)

i\).

(,<i,c

+CC -+c.

14 * q -df -7 I$I'T

-@j<,c

61-

\m+

I$---,-

-*-9-

IF';?'

\p-C,?

I-

lp-c,? \+I@

%-cl~

" " 0

\fc?

, T I?-.-

-TCc61' C ~ P TjC

I+\?

\.fie

pT0

Ip-C,? ,K,

0 I n , ? l~?cr"'

France

J+

/\>)

Jiy

L"JU& I+.-

t3;14 ~

di u

4 1&+

+LA1

d J t

9-y

4.i!

(Soir

;+J

JL-~K pij j i l '

I ~3 L .a!,

.ii I~

~ I

a+)

3 L A - &G

iCk-L

rbti l

'Ipg.

LA> L

hF +$

21 (>,-L)

JJ3 &J\U

+\$I

2 g g di QJ

A4p

CUJL&di

."Gf>l

'rLL-Gt'

C-kiV~J.&

A4A( ) Wi jp j

A* ai L ++ 3.''4 9

i >,>J

j&F

&I+">

a\ a h J i j J ..",UI +.& + Ali; 3s ,Jj s y

,aJ

.el 3

21 aj i A+

,,+PI

'bi, jb; i

" 4 ~ i / ~r 'l ty

+b-

cZj

4(L+.il p)~

&dlj

j\jLJ'IL -

"i.\+/~\

y -

kjJ 3

+Glj

L ~ J LdJ J \ 3k51~1'

.ig J

HS.'C

-lC

..\I

Lw~

'>$I

JJL)+c/i W;. " Indiffkrence t 1 2 5 S l JkJ'lJ

Y &&I

i(2006/ 2i2 :+-kiyl) "JL~ &d - ..

EY 3 ' J J ~ ~

c " W W \ "' ( ~ ~ u 4 ) j j_.

2 '+..+A

(cr*hll) JL

++ Y C YUI"

J p ~(200612/8:

k-' :

.;dj .4ik.y3 U +,A\I 1

r". L U\ &,b-

&k e y ,

&Ir

2 L. Ly4

CL Karl Schrnitt

J j u $1,.

"' CKISTI, Kknato, Le liberalisme conservateur, P. 20-23 381

~ L L ~LL Y I ,

uw-, b i

d b ~ o2 . jjl~

Vz&l+~

:JJ

$ . . .&lp-Jic ~ + i i J ~ 3

c,,;iif

+\ G-2

"+,

:J+i

+LI Uly a +I+-.~I JdlL p I J GLj! iiG 2, @ kLiejl - - i ~ l ~ Y l c>b ; S I I l ~9

& LC. 'c,,;ii,4\,~ w lq,L ) ' l

L%$

(&6

.iri

LC.+/ '+Coil

~\$l,

; l i ly 'GL~!GLI +lpj hJ,-

2 d+- d.d\ dL .&p+l L i l G [, +L\ IL ~i ,I "+, +I+->" ,I "qu+I+->" ,i "$I&+-I," 2

L LJALG L' +L

+u'; + 2*,

+\+-*U

+JJj$Jl

L,A"

a)*-.

>,+I

iJ91+.>

Cc! ' C iLG

."J+I

+I++ j l~ J+LI J

2 3

.3,+

+\,&.dl > L i .c*l,

.w&$&ihi

@Iy

?i ;U! ?i'?%?/I L@ /+I

j .J L

& ,'

CSt p-y ~ &I\

;GJU\

~ p ..U;i\ i j a 3 K i : l y

-915

d i

L -'d

?&J\

.*I

?( ~-\LP\>I

&-&.a. .- y, b u y ;rLd\@ ; 3 >l*jyi s'49J M _L3dI $, k;L! _. .>i*xil, ;GLil\) fi 2.1 ,& &t, LA ,u

i>Q

i l l j

2 2 y 2ki,&-d\

"u-" di d< d i l l jL C "

&i3

LA&

, rjaJ\ 0 . ; ~ +

3.!Ld

La&7\

c,,;iiji

( a .3

)

;iL ~'3 L c

i + A i L

L2-,5jL ,+-:-al,+'

A1-Azm, Sadik J., Islamic Fundamentalism Reconsidered: A Critical Outline oj'froblenls, Ideas and Approaches, art. In South Asia Bulletin, Volume XIII, Nos. 1 and 2, 1993. Barbier, Maurice , La laicite , L'Harinattan , Paris 1995 .

Berlin , 1. , Two Concepts of Liberty , Oxford University Press , 1958. Boguslaw , Robert , art :Liberulirnl i Con,ser-vatism, in . Encyclopedia of Sociology , Vol. 3 , 2 d Ed . Bourdieu , Pierre , 1.'essence dzr lihiralisnze , art . in. Le Monde diplo~natique, Mars , 1995 .

La philosophie sociale du Nio - Liberalisnze, art, in. L'Humanite , 4 Nov - 1999 . Colnblin , Jose, Le neoliherali,rnze -pensfie unique , L'Harinattan , Paris , 2003 . Constant, Benjainin,De /'esprit de la conqu2te et de 1'~~szrrpation , GF - Flarninarion Paris , 1986 . De la libertk ches les modernes , Ecrits philosophiques , ed . M . Gauchet , GF Flaininarion , Paris , 1980 .

Coq , Guy , Lai'citi et vipublique , Editions du Felin, Paris , 1995 . Costa - Lascoux , Jac'queline , Les tvois dges de la lai'cite , Hachette , Paris , 1996 . Cranston , M ., Freedom : A New Analysis , London, Longman , 3 d ., 1967 . Croisat , Maurice , Le fkdivalisme duns les dkmocvaties contempovaines, Montchrestein , E. J.A, Paris , 1992 . Debray , Rkgis , La lai'citi - une exception ji.ancaise, in . Genese et Enjeux de la lai'cite , Labor et Fides , Geneve , 1990 . Friedman , Milton, Capitalisme et 1i:;evtk Ed. Robert Lafon , Paris , 197 1 . La liberte du choix , E d . Befond, paris , 1980 . Garandeau , Mikael , Le libkvalis~?ze , Textes choisis, GF -. Flammation paris , 1998 . Gauchet , Marcel , La religion duns la dkmocrutie , Galliinard , paris , 1998 . Le dksenchanternent du monde , Editions Galliinard, Paris 1985 .

Un monde dksenchantk ? Les Editions L'Atelier / Editions ouvriitres , Paris , 2004 .

Gelinas , Jacques B . , La glolalisation du monde , les Editions Ecosociete , Montreal , 2000 . Green , T . H ., Lecture on the Principles of Political Obligation , in . Philosophical Wtlrks , vol . I1 , London , 1911 . Hayat , Pierre , La lai'citk et les pouvoirs :pour Line critique de la raison laique , Editions K1ME , Paris , 1988 . Hayek , F.V. , Law , 1egislatio.a and !iberty , I : Rules and Orders , II : The Mirage of Social J~isticr, III : Political Order of a Free People , London and Henley , Routeledge - Kegan Paul, 1973 , 1976 , 1979 . Laurent , Alain , La philosopie libkt ~ l -e Histoire et ac,tualitk d'une tradition intellectuelle , les Belles Letters , Paris , 2002 . Locke , John , Traite du gou~lerrnentcivile , GF Flaininarion , Paris , 1992 .

Lovejoy , Arthur S. , The great chccir: oj'fleing : A ~ t u d of i the Hi.story of. arr Idea , Mcridian , New York , 1960 .

Mills , C. , Wright , The Sociological Imagination , Oxford University Press , 1959 . Montesquieu , De l'esprit Flainmarion , Paris , 1979 .

des lois , GF

Norris Pippa and Inglehart Ronald , Sacred and Secular - Religion and Politics Worldwide , Cambridge University Press , 2004 . Nozick , Robert , Anarchy , Stale and Utopia , Oxford ,Blackwell , 1974 . Pena - Ruiz , Henri, Qu 'est - ce gzle la lai'cite?, Gallimard , Paris ,2003 . Rawls , John , A Theoty of' .Ju.stii:e , Oxford University Press , 197 1 . Liberalisme politique , P.U.F, paris , I 995 .

Remond , Rene , La lai'citi et seas4contraintes Pouvoir , Paris , 1995 .

Salin , Pascal , Libiralisme , Editions Edile Jacob , Paris , 2000 . Tillyard , E.M.W. , The Elizab~thanWorld Picture Vintage , New York , 1959 .

Wilson , Bryan , Religion i;? Si:clllal- S o c i e ~, Penguin , London , 1966. Wollf , Jonathan , Libertarinnism , I . in Routeledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy , vol . 5 .

A Dictionnary of Social Seiences , Edited by Julius Goulod , Wiliam L . Kolb , United Educational Scientific and Cultural Organization , 1964 .

Dictionnaive Encyclopkdique Qrliilet , Editions Librairie Aristide Quillet , Paris , 1997 . Dictionnaire d 'Ethique et de Phi1o;ophie morale , sous la direction de Monica 'Cantos - Spei-ber , P.U.F , 3e edition, 1996 . Dictionnaire de la Philosophie, sous la direction de Philippe Raynai~det Stephane Rials P.U.F. , Paris . Dictionnaire des oeuvres politiques , 3e ed.ition , P.U.F , 1995 . EncyclopPtl' of'sociology , 2d Ed . : Vol 3-4 Edgar F. ~orgacfTt. Editor in chief, Rollda J.V. Montgomery, Macmillan Reference USA, New York, 2000 . Encyclopkdie philosophique uni~~e,~,~.elle II . Les Notions philosophiq~les, P.U.F , Paris , 1990 . Routeledge Encylopedia of Philosophy , R.outeledge, London, 1998. The Er~cyclopediaof'lieligion ,Mirce~bEliadc, Editor in Chief; vol . 13, Macmillan Publishing Company, Collier Macmillan Publisher:,,.London, 198? . The New Encyclopaedia Britanicn , vol . 10, 15"' Edition , the University of Chicago , U.S.A , 1991 .