الموضوعية في العلوم الإنسانية لـ صلاح قنصوه

E-mail: kansopress @ hotmail.com kansopress @ yahoo.com

?&Jl

G W l f&J13 f&J13

Z?iJI

6

dl

?&JI3 I

O

L

Jbf 2,

f&JI,

'Cultural .moral

'029,

'y e

i;J+

t$

jr

j.. 'b ' 3 L Y l i

' G L Y I ?&JI +J

l lh jb*i, . & b l ~ & & L + 3 & - 3 f & Y

JAG

dl &+L,L.,Yl +&dl +lWI Y L9 ,+JWI a L I J d I 3 olhLill, ~1291 & dY*U Humanities a

.f&J&b*L&3f

&-

A: + .cJl93

rL&I

+I

+a

Lj

sl.9 l.&bj~f,lf Lj

L +YI

js>,

*UI

aLIJd! J A ,

+I,

sf

&dl

J$

Jirp l. 4 4 4 +I

+ jlrS

L , + ,

.GLYI

.&I *J&ll

+Lor

t+kJl

&LA

1

&,f

21 sf+

jW U I

4

i& L() dpY!,

&..I 1 LLS ;# &I9

,

u U \ 6.J u I A \

J

@- dill ti;;LjYI r+I~

JC

li, .4rbt;h l+& 3

p +5 @In Jl,Al

I

i

*LAY\* ;VI-

j,

j .U > L + I

2s f,

'l&

p 1 Y J y-i Y 31

,&

&I

>L

sf

.JYj.

+

ipk, ,iJ,dl

@,JI

. i s O I ~ J +I

cllli ~;i

cS*Yl awl

pi L l i i &JA19Jel

is+

.i91 UL! +-. +I

JC JJI

Ll+

$1

LL& j-

+-df p .+l+YI -

tjdl

j?l

k'j si;? .Q . ~ L Y Ii.91 J ~ f ,

3 + $ + $41 'JjLrlf c3+J 'Wx.,l C: 9 4 ,;& I Lc, -j 0

~

9

-

Y a l p

2Lll

Y &

$$

uiL.kY, .dlrJ r+, 'uT,r .I, ci+21 l&4u ++I,&

j 41-

'-by &A

.li.&> +I d2.G

is1[,Kit

jLYI ~ A I

,

I

.j&ls d l

p

31 '.-.";

j {lJl, ;

'c>L,

'.?,

,I

u

kF-

-6, j .-k

6lS c4L,o

JL L s j *Ir

$ ,& i$k Jy j .{MI jJ++ +I ijU ' u L ~ Y Y b ily;

iu

;?'

4 J& .+ J.2 3

dl! 3 4 . d L Y 4 & , +lt. j &..!I

JL

IL

pI +&, *I

.+%I

,L> j f,

b > ~ ,

Jl &I L Jlj j k l atktSz

+I

'o&

2,-

'dLsN

';-.!,.!I

+

;>l+ +I jU I i j ? '+I 9 9 '04 ir;lo

>lLL, '+ +L L. +A 'dL)'I 3 t++~ dl $-IU-I LOG ,I .*.9 : osljl dL)'l .dLYI ijcb j .L . + &k,

>

I 'jlu +I G l z ,.&bj .*&+ di Ll. Ft lip lbbt '41% W ,JIi I .[+I, d y dS;. 3, '+I

LL~ +

I L

& &S

L

W

Mass ( * ) c u l t

L

2-

JLY!,

;+I

&

jAb a ,1 ;

,+I

Jr

.tyl+Yl~ 9 l+'+ L &b j , 3slr; 21+I J+YI

' U l ~ l J l dj l,&IS3 ' l p l h l

l alj+ ' )l'J aL.+

Jj + d l &!L!>l

aL+J !

219 $

t j . # 21 Society j&21 LWI, C ~$4 y 01jj. ~ i+ .I,YI cy, ,-rill?!,

9 1j .

'+A

L+ ,l l

j >,dl

+I

&JI

+YI

&

R ~ ~ O+J W J

&I

j3,dl p, & i l Y d

Momuse j A j L a2y 6,

I

&

+Y

+,JY-+Y

*

,

J;;31,

I aKF

,

I

* *

(*)

Uj,

.f&l

(* *)

q W l

j -. LUI 03b& 3 b L d-iJI

. \ f'If &v13q~JIJ &a,& B. R w U . L e t The Pwple Think, P.43.

&

.f&l & d l cJ& &g

@I

*> 4,

(1)

:JjYl LU

42F $1

L&+>

jr i;Lyl

~;UI~,,LJI, &J+l

4 1y

,iiJ01

aY+I

+I

+-

~lj i :;++

C & . D ~ ~ ~ J iJb

i,~f

jr GUl L A . ! '&I&

( ~ 2 -1 ~ 1 $

J . Bronowski, The Common !huw of Scknce, p. 16. J . Bemal, The Social Fuactlon of Sdence, P.4.

L&

LWI &iP. J2-L;

Jl ~J,I!

C . P. Snow. The Two Cukurcs and The Scientific Rcvdotbn.

(*)

\A

-

Davidson (editor) The Search for MePnlng in Life P. 1 2.

\Q

(t)

R. 9. Peny, Thc G e m 4 Theory of Vdue, PP. I I u l>I2 :

&I

.2

*2

12'

YFl bh .\to

-\tt

(O)

3

6c>d

c>fl(T)

JO ' \ f T l - '+I

+ c.24

& d l +I rci j Y l Jl

3 $J

&

+

Q l 349-

b\CL

,~,.U\I eJL-

;4;L-;)ll

a

d+

'4.G

I

&lb

i& di;?

d' j jj .

“&.!I

dl J!

?>f

{

l f,.UI

,+

&I; dl+

j +LC. dl>

$+ 2 \ - ) ~ ~

+%I

G L Y I I~,.UIWII eJL j

dl5 J .&lb

iibliab,

. f w l l&&3dIL&L9b,b

I$

;r 3Ln;iI i l L I

+I

'dL$l JX; iU i.&

Jc j

JjYl eUJI

& ilk Y

dy ' ~ i h ~ l e

&WI)

+ a&)

L l i b .+&I +o+

~ j

-9, J+-

,I Instantaneous j Y I eUJl

& '+jk !i J.p+I

missing Factor a2,dl

ii&l

+I

&PI+

j .+I

L 9 b dl J

GJLC.9

W

.(')G+u

+A &lL" li;ll +A! +-@ill+I j i,.& b"+l$ ,J+ df & &+,, 'sJ d 9 (rls. -k%$ &y-94 JI +A s l ~ Yy -ky.

& -91

J, .+L

6

L

6

Y ;4;L! Gy.4 id 'J, .(A)&JL Az 6 9 ,'3 81 $Ul, .l.+~a-fj ≪ &I d,+l &!I j 2 &I tplb

Quted in

G . Sarton, A Guide to the History of Scitnce, p. 1 1 .

b i d , P. 15.

("1 (A)

B. Farrington, Greek Science Vol. 2 p. 173.

K. Popper, The poverty of Historleisin, P. 1

p-FAI +Li .&'\+!I GE 9 7 &I 1i1 : 91 Y; I p; JLGI. +.1;- 41 p;, .;>&, l i j i&, 6% & ,' J G l & &lS d l sL;Yl LiG, .+I j a+ 2 &I .GYI & i@l & .+ ;C &I L ~ $ 1 vl dr d$l+!l >,& I+!, ..&I 3 && b & ;@I Y, .(")& & ibrJ6, '&b JGJb J+-

L.L-$,,

;.

@G

b>

r,

+,

Gk

LilkaJk

'dLYI,

4fj

121, &+ +$I I L &, . d b y l

L

dI

I

;E-! ii;rsll

rbG$4

bL.+ b I$ &I) i

A

a6141 ;C

:$I

&~ I . ( ;

J

U

dl

'hji~ Ll+, "',;L,.Jl '@I,

'"I

+&.!I

U

I +I)

'kL1

d l .GlklYl a U l

jp;

q141 U+I . ",;q

3 Logos

;C

L,)

;k

rJ**3JI,

L+l

GYl

' d l ,

'i;UI

&&,

-\ij

J s U

&

dlS

3 &ljA i & J l .L ,-. L+ ;'

j ;>I> &lS d l a * U I

G j U I JYYl

+ GL~

l i+YI

J.UA

. blhlI

d,& l

p3 ilJL3

jLYI

'by,

3;

& $\+!I

+I

&

S+

j LJ.i"4

4

1 ap%I j ,

g

.djUI,

'&I,

'$4 Jy*)r!, j_wil,JI & b,J1+\ 4; ; !{ 4 11" & jl+!! d L y l Gy J>b dl jqLr L+ &.ill &+I &,dl, 'k1j1 / L Y ~ .GP dl b, JL; ,y d U ,Jy 3 +UI ;MI & u k , + { 'ZL~JI, iJ+Yl9 41 dl+ j 29 . a U l , 2b$1 L A & ,S41J'u;c~ + yy 2 ~j+jLs +AI c]"-,lJ b ' ,+ Y b-u -' b-u 51 k& F,l 2, '+Ilk. .&I

.by.& M.Walker, The Nature of Scientific Thought, P. 143.

Y0

31 l&2

(''1

dL)ll 2 +lc>&.*

&IJ# Jlj?

OLU ,

& fl b)lj

I L j +jL i t -1, uL.01&JJ &ldI pk &JJ

3 JQI

. d U I

L1

GLYI

&i @,I

sly

>d ,,l

& kb, 6 j l l JIG1 34, ~ L L ,UIAYI, ~L..L.JI, d4>Y1 j d i 'k +I, &I,

I

dLY1

1

(yJ

'iSUI

iljk &S

&I/YI

jc

$A dic%yI,

L U I

c1' U I &I

3yAl

.Common Sense

E. Nagel, The Structure of Science, P. 447.

YV

Bernal, Science in Hlstory, P. 713.

+Ul

3

U-9,. Y l / &L)>jj h L l w f . J i':J &+I iL;P

&~+,ll)

("7 ,,AL(\f) JUI

d w l &dl j ?+L, .&I L& Eidos & ! I .qLJyI r,LJl j GUY1 djlJ ~ A &tI j (+Ul

&

J1

4

.@I,

a9399

& p er;, JI i$l-jl $ G I W ;Jk3;, Jj

It

JQ & d)b,

3 U ,,I

u;+ $91 fUi;,t ty), a';-dl-il,JJLl

I

t

.+.&+

.lJi

& &I

y

6

j$I

>*,

LUX,

JLS,J

dpll

j,LJ! -+&& ; r i ,dW

L'L,

u 4/

&,

'j &IUI ?J, .( j v ) g J ~ l

;Li! L $ GF ~ I + I jls

& $1

rljl

akJ> j id\~ ~ & I ~ Y I . "7'gJul \I dls

+

GLf aL_& JS

a l i iLE,

&,dl

3 j /GI

>*I

Jj

J $Jl .i d$l

uJj

&.& JS

jL

+

'j

eLL

'j 4CiIJI

LIS.l++Yl , & d l 3 i $ b

at

OL

)3

d L Y l LIJ>

( L u l l ?I-S j

0JlA5L

-u-

&.+JI

&+

& j-UI

cGJI

i+f )+-+i. j % f -)f &jfiL+ .b+ 3bk* dl LUL . d l

I

3 A+

t

,GJI

> 3 &&+ .fA

y

J, PI, !b3

-fV/

'+I

&u\ +)f

s;?UFjl I (\o)

B a a l , Op. Cit, P. 713.

(\I)

W.D. Ross, A&otk, P. 236.

( \V)

LOC.

Cit.

(\A)

L J + ~ +I

j+,b

ibi, ac; d , b +IS ,+i I*&YI i, ac; L c ~ %t,+, b JL, &ill d i 91 L+& &. ,l 41 .L

LPG

+IS

i;t

L +IS ZL,

A,

.GI;;?!

dk 4 o

L

b w

4,

hLY1 L!)a

G u l h-

~9 liJ .af+!

r b 1 1

j JL 3 L&JI

4

a U l

-+st CL; Y j rbLUI ,& jJ ~ Y I ~ U &$ I, - 4&. ,a dd h -&-ill La Linguistique U I

,& + @I +I PWYl

ob,

f+I

(y ;I,ul

I;L V b t

u ~9+ SU~I,

3

MetMa,

f-Li 'js ,JJWI

$4;.sj

-F,

&,& & d l +dl jLUl + , .(yt)&,d13

+ J+ L. +, &L.i - -

&.lJJJ c4sJ1,

j

t

-CZ

~IJI

. . . .P161fll

I&,

.

(")

JIJI Ih

No. 4; \(1966) p. 201. .?I -oV /

bL%

.:, J

C&J & c r 4 l

. \ra

- \rt /

a b l

cGlJUI(Y0)

,&UI &I

(Y)I

I

.&UI to

-t*

CIp ,'JJI

'tdl (YY)

;+b4. ( Y t )

c Ljlp &

f+JI

& & U I sr&l

JiJI. &&I

vlti

by 4

>w

l

~

by

& j +&!I

b&$I

.A+ jL-+ $

j

df 3

f&~n

kLpl31 is dlp! j I,,LI -\i GLYI I i d l I 3 I 1 1 3 I I U, f .L *I 2

&-43

&$

2

2 I .G Yr, i

, J

a

$

'31jYI

+2

Y I G L y II-.;

&UL

+A

&.+

&I

I+

21Jdl JJiJl; L , J

~ A 4 I

,

' 'JiJI

flSrY~, &I & ~J ,.++

j .&Lf

1#-131 ~LL ,.

.?a1 F J ~ C r+J ,.+Y,k j+-$I

.+G)II

P

I SF

New Route ti+&I

j

'+dl

J ~

&I

+

~I+Y $ I . JU+

i>+ ilji

a Y L

++I j ( \ O W -\tq7)

31 d&-

U f, 6~32b U ,I +!I ~ LU &$ LI,~ bGYI d i df ;j,. L U I b L j3+ 4 1 iliJl 2l,dI ;'yill(\ V \ t +) 33 ALG b -1 +I 4k 2 - U I ilbl;l

'4 hi b

'w && tllfl~ 315 &I3 .>spa.^ j&Jl +I4 rWJ i+&l ,KiVl 41 JJ iJlr'&hb , ci; 9 jls, d3 . \7hh yb

4,i;f

Browwski and Mazlish, The Western Intellectual Tradition P. 549.

z3wI

P O )

t*

Bernal. Op. Cit.. P: 722.

(Y')

Zeitlin, I. Ideology and the Development of Sdociological Theory PP. 1 1 - 12.

(YV)

.t.v-ter L9 zeitli op. ct., P. IS.

-1'

@bJ&c31 $dl

,yu~+(r~) (rf

Zcitlin Op. Clt., P. 13.

.t\t - t \ v /

&>#A1 c>lk Y b

J+

(1') .3(tY)

& , &dl

JF

.+L')I1

i+AI

c&b$ *y>j

4; JLf

+I

41 +I

L j U

d&l

241 +I

Ji*- dl yjj JjL Q

Jl$ & d l

;;.? p1.

.3L?'l

bj L s + + - d u b

p,3

j d,

j&b

c.&I

Jr &kJ ;UL. p.~ JlJ+

&lL

QYYLYII

p l y 1 ilj3

JL 4; W I oi.,-,

C ~ W J

dL L E I

.({MI

.Ill;jp, dl b * r ~

k Jby~& ~ J I ill^ -3

.( " ' U ~& J , i;LY 4 4 +y+.

C.U~Construct

.\ *T- ff Zeitlin, Op. Cit.. P. 58. Ibid, P. 59.

c+IUIJ

,,.hJI

jaL13 '39&J( t t ) (to)

Bcmd. Op. Cit.. P. 721.

-

Ibid, PP. 723 4.

tV

p

I

&. 1 i 9 I, &Jl 14' l+f psy

&J9

V,

J

d

o h

(

d

8

J, .;rY,UI

'GL*II J l , + df l+-

. $4 0

& ' .J13

9 rkll

I

I

'j..

,

9

&$I

j.iY+

'ULYI

r,.U :~

Whitehead, A., Adventures of Ideas, PP. 111.

)I

'j..

; ; k.,

U dji LGLAYI ' ~ I L SL,+u pJd,l '.&q

2 dl5

@ L

GI

&I ~ $ 1 jii 3rj J ;l?> & *aY3uI

Jl & d l f, awl b U b j c l ~&+ lit!

O

L

ci;pi bf

)VI

L+

? -k

c.~

L I ~ ~ tI, JV,I J+ i ~ p j L * l y ! , y b ~ ~ U l ~ L b f >

&#%cdl*+-

.d LIJdl

L

c+,a

&I,

:+..i .cii

t, 'LlJdl c+,a 'j ;j+ 0L. 2 '3e l ,bLi)f! LI9 b4 Jgl2

& + , j . ! , y ~ Y I r ; r $ b ~ ~ ~ I ~ u l , y u b

a

j.

L>L,

&&!j f 'j b y l f l

tuI

&-dill &I

d cb

.dUl +b'j 4 ,SdI i& cLJ*L+ ~,;)I & , Y +.,dl I

A 2 &$bf

&a\~bY &b+

4141 h >A 3f k! JWd

'pWIikJjj0~3j&Isr3Lyj&ptJcY~ti~J~ d 21o ~ Y ! , &Naturalism &&lI ruYI *!, G b & 2 kY 3fi- bf j+ Y JjVl oGYb Anti - Nahualism c i d I WI r$l j&*i j L Y l r$1 Z K L f, i,ii j. i/=y 4@I, b L Y I 'j +I '& $I O j I L l 4 &ill &V,l

&+

$' d+Ul

d l +I

4

a U I L

ibu\ bj+.!I

dj;L;! 'G+ 6

L L +.

J

&dl

3~ J&

LIJdI

Y;

A,-.

Ib, relevance c')(ks?U &l;YI,

G

3

++I

'+a 9 - b j ' w l k & dl u w '$1. > - , '+I_)! @I &-+I

j

d&YI

'$I ik+l

#

p-L

a'+

u 1 ,>

relevant

+-d l

Factors &I> f,

> yl$l

@ (")Relevant

LtLUJl j & &i dl*

icE j d b J$d\ q j .&A( J1 e y Jd 02qj &+ & .rJLLI + +lLl : d

JL bs~lsLUL

t+A&

l A &IJ& I, LUf d~ r3b1irli U l, I r i l Y ~ JI,l

J+

Y ~ L J I r J I J& L+ d; h u 3t &&, ++Y& ,&"\I df L+, 4 .o> 3 ijfi. 1j4fIYskd( i)l l' c 9 1df & & t2A~ relevare +. LEU +%I &Vl

&+I b

J*(*)

c')(ksy + j b u l LA + L ( O @ ) 4 ~ C Y Yl ~l J.Li ) s k*YI( ) ' c

ALL

J1

+I Variables

U

I

j

3

b '+VI

&I

J1

r

pi dV

* i t ,+( i i jL-

.w

E. Naglel, The Structure of Sdmce,p. 451. \

or

dfU J.+ Y 4 j +lI J b U l i . &

r l j ~u l Lt; dl U

.("I&

4, 'i-

l di &a\&!

,k WI

$b cb .Iy

-

-3

6%

+,1" '

ai5

&

&U 6

i,.

.

,(S

4 i&LYl

j

jl+Y

;uU

&

dt 'IL

' * b y 1 +Yl && k!$l;rc &dl

MI &&I Js l;

Oedipus effect C ~ ~ , Y Ij

e-

+-df -9

j . 9 1 d~

+L~I

L9&I d

Jll&J2

o13ijl,h.lI .?u; l;+, b?l;r

dI alJI &U l p j 4 dl ijUl

,-

+ Iiji

& l;+l

ilk j jl,h.ll

ldJa bJ&"

Y l J\ 6 , I &a&I

$b

ty.4

J,KJ

&dl 4

1

-3

&

ii/.Il

.(")ejJ dJ> JJL ~9,& >kll I L &L Suicidat t d $UIJ +I JtYl 9 3 j L J : , i & JjYb Self - F ~ l f f i n g a d &IJ jAl 3kJb

3

LLP,:

b;; @LL 4;r%dl,& 'bUl &dl4 1'j ,& d& # ~ & f '?jii .4Wl + &aI& &fi'j ;3 dl xi ~.,4;11JLYI J ilk d 3 a k i Y I J+YI aui~ ,LI JLVl Jhj;: +I ,MI I L & :LjJ . \ f 1~ yb 3

&

'w 4

1

319

3 a&

.("')b . k. l l a$>!

Js

'j &ladl &I .t*A/

jLpi

+IJ

Y dl9 3 jib 3-UI &I U

t3U

'2 '&I

-

MI ~ a +

K. Poppor, The Poverty d H&toridnn, P. 13.

$,3;

;j+f

&

by 4

8

s

1

ilk

8.h

3 jiY- # f> JjK

( Oy)

bf 6 ;

3 c ~ ; , ~ J - c s ~ ~ I+-+ t6pJI

.&\&I j ,dl>\ is$ & &+I E. Nagel. Op. Cit.. P. 469. .

dj( 0 7 )

8.h

L JS

c~Y,;

L;;!

2 Jl

? ,,

(Of)

Ibid, PP. 468 - 9.

(ao)

Werkmcister allbmy construction and the problem of

(07)

objectivity in Gross L.,(d.)Symposuim on SoddogicPl Themy, PP. 490 - 2.

Bronowski and Mazlish, Op. Cit., P. 141.

(OV)

Werkmeister, asocial Sciences and the Problem of

(Oh)

-

Value in Scientism and Values edited by schoeck PP. 16 17.

o w

&

a& &I1 + b Y I

'&.+) d+i.i rkJf JS Q+

**

'.-I, pl,hll

.& i&l;t

3

',;LAY!

+L'

03&

.@I &I

~3f

jlb;

j ~ !a l i W I

i>YJI JkC

,++ $1

&I+ d% && &A. &y G L Y l

3

5,

i+*

&&I 4

~

+$I

e

Gjli +.Li , . ~ f Jl&l

jr Snell

t+

rdgl

d.2 dj,& 'r,L Li, 3 @ 3 ++YI i;UI j*,t 'ys@(y j , Y l ~ ~ L . y & I l ~ ~ l j r r l = (of)+i

Nagel, Op.Cit., PP. 459 - 460.

ov

a-, @I

9

Q.Gibson, The Logic of Sod.l Enquiry, P. 73.

('-1

Jefreys. *scientific method and philampby Sdcnrc News, P. 61.

.Y Y

/

L

(LWJ L l

('Y) L

PIS (7Y)

Urban. Beyond Ratism and IdePlLom p. 167.

('1)

Sullivan G . GPLUo P. 38.

('0)

j d+UI

&dY G L Y I pl&l -

bliGjCfll.iSPS;riTJl+l&

Ub,

*I

&3

I,

r&

l,-

aL&

-:

#&I

d-3

Uj

Jy

a L 8

b

.( ' * ) i > ~,I

91 L$ LI, ,.& Y

bJ+

'$1

t"y1

value

d!

b

fbJ1

~>\&'-t'"

4

Xi . i s U l

JAG

bI+I

&L

A 6-

LIJ-L'4

G.Myrdal, Value in Social theory, P. 51. G . Myrdal, Objectivity in Social Research, P. 9. Nagel. Op. Vit., P 485.

,y

b

Jh J1

>a1

dG ,

d

j4

u

,I

j ,

'pz, 4 4 ilY>

,+& i b L l+Y

& d,

s3

LlL Giilitll

,y *;I+'

4 %+-

dl J

~

fbJl Jy bl&l G L Y I pI&l &I d l

s3

$9 +wl

bl+

j ~+UI

+I;"

b&+lI

& u.. i Id, . G L y l f + J l CGdl GLYI +I ,y 29 jI ,I j a 1f&! $k &IJy .l+l+, pb41

awl,

'$1

Jl

@ &I ~ y ; l & l ~o&LJI

.h,

+ill

e+;saL++.~

bvbLS;,

.rbdl

'$1

I 6

b+d9

b $ b " ' t-G w ' b3+ L

,I #LL

.##&

oljJ Lb l3 ,y,

Sw4

1brelevant

I

&?Yl!

* l p l (IIJ>l d&4

L + A ,

p

G J , d

&I

3

, I

& &

(j.

;t. a+.+.

*li'YI

I

a

I

+

+ &L3'p & * i a,;

bL;li'Yl.j.,&

&$ iLK k u l &p

3 y ,& ,+& 6

J! '&+I agad A , b l j l +l! dl.& (W&

rWI

,

0

L+ &d

-

'

4 .'

(jp &i+

itfJ3+Y!

ls.GJ ' & k t

.@ CJS& d l

l. LiA&

0 f b b

L iCQI

- 3Jl

@I

Continuum

pld\3 -- GlJYl

&!I

a3k,y +I

~ 1 ~ 3 1

&by!,

&

&JU\ & J l

K. Popper, Op. Cit., P. 16. K.Mannhcim, Ideology and Utopia, P. 50

j j ~ U I*$ l

- 4s ,!rf, - *,,Y, Jjr &-Y 6Ul G L Y I r,l.Jl' d k f r l 'y @I A- %, +

+,JY-+)u

JL+ $b ~ f i*r r J,

dt

& d, CJJJ

a ~~ 4

"GJ

+,J3+Y~

& I 4 d L i $ +,I

3

p l W tjI

klb abjJ3+frlp i L LJ ; ; !L

+ '+

riG,

Ja ah, +I

.&I,

1s- +jJY.+frl

. b&YI

GI

I*i$ &jE Y 4i

ukfrl

;?Ajc

'y

/LsJ

'y

l+p- (&$Y$J J,

+JLfrl+ 'yj

,Sociolgy of Knowledge ii&l

J>

+-L

u

bi&II

+Ja

dp->JS I$.L&

-

, j L Y Il

@I

eLJI +I

--

.(Vy)~L+I,d 'y ;?j $ A, +,Jyfi

j121 &

.ipWl ii4 pJU ?&I +I

*y

' L d

6

4 j

++J

,&L &I g j f i 3, ~ g j U ~ ~ U I

. (vr)"'=l+Yl 3

l

u bLiJSociologism +jJydI

J2

I

~G>;Jhf

@

'y

31

c a l j U l iL13

& L d l Llj+*Ul

LJz.5 ?l+L JJKJ

&I

L jfUI

c G U ~ , aGJI JSj 6 JL6-JIJ alkLJl

+I

f,

J,

&I

-1'

'aliI)-I,

+,J$&frl,

'y

j >+,I! 2 rJY $1 dlJ& Y sU1 dl, "4

'y +. Jl. JF i -

iGlj_( c c d b l d l +bk J%

ic$l

+li .+A!\

L+

+J Glj.>+*,I 'p dl aI&I tlil a y l JI 'irl &-Y &&I l&.dl dl 1s

'y

ul$J!,

;ylJl,

1

+

,+ILlJ,w S l jJi -

Jl

3

aLJI

1-b~, ~$1,

dI J

~&dl(@l

prj 'iSI

kd3&vl ,/

b 6dyJk

djUI

+$& :4

(vy)

.v o Nagel. Op. Cit., P. 498.

Pf)

LI,JI

t+y v

4

J~ p-&k*-i"

J, (b

1

4

I, .++JI +.+

ar

i , y +UI

&I

I L

eb

i;jL;yI

i+i

riiir

+

dr j.

4~ 4

b U ~ b+j

.I*jjkdl-Jc

+c.

&+I

hA, .i;iLyl j h~ -:,I

j.

&l

IL. J, y.J f,LJl 'j Jc d&

GJ+fl

,+~JI

L;p 4: cj;.l. lib .++JI LU;: e*-P,2 ar JI 4~31 ,I ~ U Ij .L,+ ~1 ~ ; r J,+J j. r p2 JI 4: &ep ,+@ C: dl d+4Jl js, J

A

@ >,

&J+

i f d l

- > J+ hl#

Jjb J, +lJI

-41

4

+

1-b &

p a l&j

91 2u

Y

.+jlJlj

kI &

+Wl

'('&) $jb

.I*# t j s ) j ' d l &ly J5J YJ+~&I Y ,I LL; +I f I L W s6,Ul ,dul 'y p- l. , d ~ )

Q. Gibson. Op. Cit.,

P. 77.

(Vt) :&dl

fAo

LJU\-1

Jl d& &dl +cJL AJi j d;L, Js a+,+ . f l d d l ,y & G j ++Jl

,yb3&&I

6-1

(~JUI

,.+I4

... & z+!L

rIj.dl) Y * V JP c

t

\h4

&,-b

G#+y

t,,j&I

.r.~ Y, 6 V ~ Y I

dJb (*)

-\

J+

ad1 by*) eJUl

&u raL;LJ)II) & & ~ I J . ! !d p + eJUl +G9 tikrlihll -I &j - Y

w l r&JI

L +b

Js rJL! pWli . . .?Id1 4 p 1S r&YI . . .?Id1 4. xl~+yL1J-d 2~

iipl +Id1 ;,&I cL..'I

1S 16EL ] 39,

.#

L, 313

sGYI

W,

@l &-dl w

&$dl r

~

>

J rlj J

I

cry' -.

+I

1

3

a

,

+i&l

l i&Jl

+

.bJ,J +d, > 4 i&\&!Jb

+>-~+AI 4 1 4 1

L

C;I

+ 1,

I

GlJl l+(p + 9 I1 1 a L j a l h*d l

alhJ.1,

4 J 4 w-4 &+ W I ~ c l i l &4 p+ &i+ 30~1 LBL, w y J &.Ls JI i&~ G ~ I+% .L-J,2 L+ +I GIJI j3 ,L[ .bflb, 3 cl-dl (41(~41 b b $ 4 3

9~

J

L)-JI

. 9

dl l&b U l J4;l &dl

L

2, 2 && L &ILs?,

LL=L = j[, Trend

Jl + \64; 9

9'Wl elhIl i&l

GlJl

k ~&l &dl &I!.,

b

js,

k GlJl jJb+

.&I

gldl

I

b ~ ~ ,

b b ,y

+ @I

._Llii bbJ$ J a>l+ L 14

Convention C91iJI

+

LljJl

idslb

,l

&

sjJ1

jUYl

al,>YlJ l L

J1

I

& ,

&I QLitll

wY> ifit

3 G S U I,yId13 * M I Jy &L&lj ;ILL&I -3 t

691tUl

al+l

j - &I e ..t.vyb

>L., l $1

&I

L

L,>

aIjrP;llJ

&P

alclfl?l rljllYl

3

& 31;

Jlr";' '+'LYl

j ++>I

r&Il

&+JIB p,f .I& Substantive i&JI LzkJl

t&,J,J=Yl

ab+y

V

Sf

LIj>a d . . )

'+,$

at

*J

&+!I

&!x 39j-& ! I

- -

&& &-&A\ (&J3>dl &+I) I. :Jlj-ll jr +4?& JY ,I &+JI r&- M .&I V ~ J - GjS :JI@I jc +4'?4$1 641 &IJ>

C & ; ; L j

&,LF>

j ;jd & i l l

dlk;

Subjectivism GldI &$Ij

&, r p j A+,

i;IAl

i , d

@,Jl

d> LT $1

$41 w, .

4 9 LT

(

g,

LC

jf

l,Jl

ijyl

L&a

GLyI

)

&) d,+lJJl

JlzkJl

4$i +>$I

JLYI

++J&-d L I'

& i Jl

+ +

i i b u l iS,CL!,

jdJ;4

JL~!3 $IdI

La&

b+bYI9

y-

,+&Ja

; d q 'j

Y bl,, i>lJL,@j

d W Y L i .La>, ipUl

tli,

w3

I"C

$1

f,

&dl

>fl, G L q

plli 9 I.&

Y d$lAl,

j dU+ 41 4 ~ 9 1 , f 3 4

d*,J,?rJ' jc

p,JI

i k . 4

Sti

&+I)

Objectivism i&+Jl

. b U l Jb pb

dib+JU

l2+*i

,+i adpI,J=Y1

e*

241

:

k

cefl

.&I>>

9lli A+

2 eG,Jl +lkI. Jl(k.

pL j b + .&-d W I 9 59 & .+l+Yl, GLYI ("Ventehen &I

To1~;rlfI-i' e 1-

ms!pnp!n!pul

~ f '. . II&

.w

c

4' C?- +r; q q - I&*

,fl I? -T If'

I<* ITS^? ~

P H .

' If'

!d

1&ri7~,,). sn;' * I F C I ~ 'fl- y v 8 lL-5 ruf + .+ I+ c~IL* .+ IF I*

ws!pupou pj!8010poq~w -4 t i n e 1-r

I&C? f l

ws!p!iuassa pj!8olopoq1aw,

1,

."\ -4 ~ n hIf' In? 11-61? \me(-

j!mpomoN q&Cf'

-+4'

OA)

UXJB

jl

I&S\T C\mheI

CT

'T'CIQ.I'

~ C ?

-9 df LJs, ' W I JjL j L- U - 1 J ,J, L Jj X.L r> d$ 69. '@I, d L Y l Jl+ j - &I.

++A! 1 + "p j.L;Si p ,l '&IJ + A \ +j. 'Substantive d L j l 6wI d d l - LZr-,~A13 . &J&Yl F ' 6JJw';;,Wl b , +L (&I AIJ 4jJA

jG J I

6jJl -1

-91 +..PI

*

+

a l J k j2,alJhj

df

hf

&

JAG

'pW1

L

GjL

df d3a

a b ,+

& +&I,

>,.e J~

&UJF

J L ,

+i;A j,+JS JAG &Yl J p l I I L i r U >L' .;;1;LYI r,JJI j a4r;JIJ dUI Jy jlil? 3&

Bernal, Science in History P. 1 1.

t,

+ L Y I f,LJI

fk b q + -

3 $4

a[ j .L&

2+

a ~ !

++AI d !,

i.b3 itiL &

+wl

J-?, 'eU1 sLJL i.&,MI i.k,Jl e L b! & .+I a .+;, i+ & f+-J&

+ 3j

f,LJl

I+$

J.LJ

$=Ji+iJ

.&I,

UI

p &.dl

e9j- .I+

irJ.l..a

'kJL 31 L,fJ1

i+i

Jr

Jjk& 2

&I2

4 1

(VA)

;)?dl+Ul

+Jill

JI +A . d1

Ljn 'iyjlj, GU JLII, I L -UI,

9 i j .L+JI,

&I

J J k Jf-

&I

++$I

-

(*I

dl 4x2 j .IL,

itiL

JHY6 ,MI

j .dlJjdl (jc

j .

Y

A

~1 ULYI

++JJ

i+i & WI

lj,;,

6jlS;;ldf

-

U

.&MI

*yJ?) I 'j

a~+,-JJuL-I

f,.ld i&JI

c)'zll

+Jc

lJIU

.+L+Yl,

LJJ + j

9 >.l;r!

>L;ll

b J 3

a

L &,

kJ+ & 4 i & L Y l aIc+,dJ

.*I

@I

LA?,

G&?, Operationism i;\-Y

6

'L+I

~f 9 ,I > d l

i>J? LSJ

l+

y $1

I* '

@I,

r l j 3 J d y iyy 3

ci3+d.l bJY3 i 3 d I l+b@++JI

Physicalism

-

GLYI

is a b g l

Empirio - Criticism t4l -.+dlS

I i.,ll@l+

'i&d,I

+J!,

4

JjL' ~ 54 , +WIp , J I

j l IL

i & JJ l l+s;~L

+

*t sIsrk

JS 9,I o bK, ,UI

2

L6 . (

~ilclill~ &LVl

i y )

Y, '(\).&Ab l

, JS I

3I

d

+Y, .@I a

GVI, ~

'iJ+

JJAI

l

$91

JS

+by!

fliJ1

rG\

'+L

b?L Notion L+ &

4 1 , '-+I3

JL!.i d l +dlJ

~ -I+

'J.lJI 3d ; ; ' dl dl Li, j yS3 ' 6 2 a+

~ 3 l dj+ J! +UI ++I

wk 91 9 -I+

E.Lhrkheim,,LesReglea de la MCthode Sodologique, sixPme edition. 1912, p.x. b i d . , P. XI

(\ )

(v

,& &! ar $1 '-41& ktf;

&Id1 &L

abLk;l

likl;;=

&La+,

lpw*

9 ~2j . awl

*Iy

+I,

,GI

j!

il;LI

JIj Y l -3

rj JC

I+! v ,&>AI i Conscience LJ+ ,I l+,

.+&,

g, 3 ij,dl,

Jl

a!,+

J J

L b ,

G,;I

zAb3

lh, .i+

J ) Wl fLJl

j .(Menteaux I

+L+YI

@

ab*

!

yj; ,& .Lt;lJC J+

@+,A

rCJ&I

~

Y &;ji Y d l k j Y l

GI,

JC LLI+,f

b

kl

Jl $1

* ,i

@

JgI?KJ9>

YJ

~re~r6sentations(&..dl)

$1 'w +I>

LIJ>

.'&I

awl

,I +>j i ; .->k .&I I+I&&I +L+Yl eliJI J,L ef13iulill e&li ai ?lSJJ> dy, yfl $ a s k ,I +-> dl l,+ ;. +I& && Y *&I I+I& ilUl j c6; a! t b Y l ,lb JC J.d 4 'aUlal b-c, +I L-J&I, .WI, . 4 4 1 b &I &4 ..?j .&I C)L+ j+ &,l j ~ t~i J i> $ a++JI ;1+.;4 & &+YI ,lWI Jj &( t L + Y I ,lb 6(t)@+y

Y

e-

I

I

.)4('+, Loc. Cit. Ibid., P. XI Ibid., P. XIII.

+A

l ii

j

,'

.; + !

a> & c;&y ;+u I+

d&-

J A I

a,! 6u+

~

+

~ J I 'y L-~JJIOL

!I& ;.; dul a jc A

4 &, &kgd l L J u l L jJerjkj

&>&I

6

d l

di

.&

3j

.(')&I

&I

J j l l &$

r; &

*I

+I

l L

db

j

b

d

Y -Jk 3 I+

3 LXc I -

ponyme

, I+

-'

bccJ+i A,

&itIbid., PP. XIII - XIV. Ibid., P. XIV.

&&I

@I

~lpll, iJL

L

I

3: Y,

.lag3

'+I

dl

-JUI

Lp.&

>

&J

d l irI,+l

.cJ&~ 'y 'y

JJy

/

;$dl

lpy

LaJ3>

&-J\ Symboles

LC- &..dl dl&

+4

JI

A~ , r '4

- cFU-6 >, .@ +% .ipLlill + jc (+

L I

&,

dtJ ,

' C l i j @I

- j9>1

.clans jCJ6

+u

l

l+;rd l +'Ill

d.L, .(")&k.AI j

I &j , dI ~

&l&l

dr

&&

j

jc

~r+ dl S i l -k & .k! L *

i

t

J,.dI

signs QLWI yiu! 'y

k1 VJ,

& WICLk!

&..dl Prknotion &I

a L J U I jc

+

L i i j ~ b ;

JI! rji 31 ,L&2 r, MI I& ,L~I

j . L, ~ &+ bx. i4*i>dp 4 I , I h

I

J+

bJ+

o

J+

P

1%

/b $4 &@ &I

p '

d,JI

fg$I,,

&@

jc FY &I

L

/b

c?t;li, +Yl,

dad!,

+ .+"I

'(yl

@

,I @I

+ Jbi+ ,d

thy1 .L

+,>

*J

+Wl, %

C ~ Y IJ, I dt G ,

.A~.&J +vJ+ + & h r & d+ Y ,&J 319 ed1 4

&I

4

/

& C 4

cjJl i+lI d l +J&I

d% 3

i J u4-L

Q~G LUIJJ=-~ ;-! ~ I + L J+I

&2 2, .l++

JlyYl_( aLWI

rjI ~i. L lib ;&I

b i d . , P. XII.

(A)

b i d . , P. XM.

0) (\ *)

b i d . . P. 5.

by ,it;Ul +bU

J,YI

tqkll J

J

LJAI

&

u. ~ 411 -9

L;-I

Jj

+WI

dl C S G I ~ Y& I

j ~f !&$(*I flipKJJ~

.+ks j.

~ + b Y lG l $ ' w l >+!I J,

lbJL >P;

J;I +i;lYI

igCi

$CiJt

31

-bl$l,

&\$IS)

y j

- j - - &I

-

.

3f LA

hu1p,. p & I

yfl di $3,

b& '&

pi i

- 2 -,

d l U l , &$I

j .j.ls

JS Jl *i;g

Loc. cit. Ibid.. P. 9.

~ J I J, &I,

& G I OK+

j.>j &, jr

b*

+Y

l lil b& . (")&,

Ibid., P. 6.

&(&dl

'+&Y,Js

&+

bk;o ;L, $3, 'LA U

4Y

& I.Yj J, >s(tki irli,

I l c s courants \s1>1;1~

Y a l c U I &la

li,

j .

yb, ALI( .

$,

;/l, Coercion j 4 1G"0 l+l1 +-

&YI

+UI

pEJ,>

>FJl

LL. JbfjC J I > ~ j I.

c2&I

J u

sJ&l

j

A,

.Is

L-, G-

GIG k j i j l f f l j ~ J! U Y I t j f Y &%I t j t ptJJ . r U l , c+ffl j .&I p.4'Lj-r us, j.*I &I j .j y '+.

&

Y

tjl,JI

+ J '

t j t L;>J

;lil

+ ,'jiy

jWX. i&

.&L, &L J b

L+

& Y, CIJdl

&

+&

~JI;! b-I

43

alLlsl

j. + b Y I

+ aJJLjL.5

LILY U, i-Ltll j . L3Lakj+ \r~i

b

$' ,$I

Jl

6

JMI J+

OL+iJlJ-" j .&I &G

+ J' ,Yl

j t I-. , .&&I C'I $1,

iL4 ,'+,

&

;r

b

f, ,HYI

.-IJ

c

JI izi* t,

'tjI&lb

' j b& ~ +i ~

+ b 1 f l i j p,

6

aIJ(;JI

GYG j JKS &I bJ+9 3 +LI UIAl 0 Y - h j .&L! & &, J cbyl ."O)JbYl,

Ibid., PP. 12 - 13. Ibid.. P. 13. Ibid., P. 19.

ul;li& GljJl

.ab+y j . Ibid., P. 21. Ibid., P. 29.

dJ> ~ G Y J+ I

%

L(*) ('"1 ('A)

b i d . , P. 31 b i d . , PP. 32 - 3.

8, ..&k $LY: j t

r+

LA Ir!

Lp &$IJ

.&fS

+.5

,+I J&I

Y,

b,&

*;I

.+ +dl

+JI

datum c,krll,

3

e4; pp! L. '&?YL

;ki; + a &

b+! $6 h i

LJi .

d l

'p

C4.b

+&Yl

(cbll 2 J 'd,L & Y ,a\ '&I 1.b ,A & d l A d i C . ~ > W Y aI U W I

+ ,.'

'$1

&\,A1

,A J I

,

;+

,A

&

&I

&Yl

+I

'y Jl5

,i

.JG y;J. J+k

Ibid., P. 34.

(Y')

i;kt a ~ ,JJI l~ +-A

ps k

'jG

jb 3 L l ,

. &>&YI

LU1 J]

,I

pI$l

@

$1

,

i

L

I

@

~ Y Ip~JJklli.(")&I,AI

(IL!

. t k Y I

.+ '$1

&&I+

+L, .&%I

pl$l

air, ?IJI

+2

a,,+,

L JJI ~

J

'a j I + I ,

JI+Y

I

f,

L

~

t J j 1 ~ J= ~

31 J aLCLLf, B

~ji(*) + JJ

.&/;I*t

Ibid., PP. 36 - 7. Ibid.. PP. 37 - 8.

' k-F2 + b Y I j .35 .6 1; IjJ& di

A,

@

$1

jj k k

p- "$1

a+

/LYI

G b Y l FbJl L l r

jcdl

;"$1

by

,t

ih;h*U JLJl

&li

$1

+ $1

UY,

. &+I &I

el"l,

'a+'

31

d' ~

&-"$1

&

jP

dI;!

jxL. irL;;. d y

0 4 -

r,

Y bfi I

jr Ljgl

dl5 K dil ~

ceGiD q&

'ibWI

~

&!,dl,

I &I

ji;~ dr +

9 bLYl & d .l

D, F+

-1

c&'

iuWl d&li

dbdl

4 1

L+

j .tjl!di *, L

eLJl

el+Yl

a-I

22~1Lb!

.(yt)+ldl,

qL;. dl5

+-$1

iL% 6-d b i G l

'+ d,l p-d'

eY9

db ' L k Y l ,

+-d i l l Le sens 41,

dl

+A+

> ;I,!

$A

+ I-

d i l l $1

& 9,.&,Jy4I

$L +-d 3 9

' fbJl

LJJYI,

c&+~

pbll

Jd d+l;i

j &+-

ebJl L I J b

+-Y I+

a4;$ OL ,J !,

Jli j 3 d I Y3 . I + J y G 35 jr & sdLI#, '+ b yJ U Ulj i ~ l i lel L + & /Li d",!

Lbl

j .I

,

9

I

a

, .&

I

@a

.kL&

&

f>l U

l

0

L

.LA 4 11 I L dCY, l &G

tPu +d 2 , I jo J&I b i d . , P. 2. b i d . . P. 40.

jr

&I

d

U I&

'*A1

j9, ' @&yJl

L I L dl & ,

jJg ; ,

3 ad&,

+ ' .I,

$JL; jo

t-UI

,+-

J.) .'yO'L,.+LI

ib1

'@I cJLi d&

9 , '4dl a b d l

~

b i d . , P. 41. b i d . , PP. 42. Ibid., P. 43.

,>* A+ 'y

1

& .

L%& & , i , dl

ii'U

.rls?'I

,& 'y % d d

2 k>Libk

+ l k , *+'"J4

& bbp &I if#

kl+c

'y +j

j L jyl&,('\)~'"J1 .

?p?lj> ++A &$I LUYI 'y >&

& *LLi

&u

>J @I

&J

& &I,: i'Li J l j Y l '& +Lu &u JS & c i f + I ~ 4?,

,&P/ L' + L , S ~ ~ - ~ I I L

b i d . , P. 44.

Vf)

b i d . , P. 45.

(ye

b i d . , loc. cit.

(Y\)

Ibid., P. 53. Ibid.. P. 55.

r*li,JI

dl

p w ~j.

-f+s ->> iu > j .L

dl

.++A!

'$C3

b,..i9

,A+

&

IiA

&A

b+

+&YI

.l&&A

'$1

++I

i,d t ,J, ~ u+y G s, L J+ L+9 'yL-p d,& ,I) i+kJ +U i% >F, ++r JS L+ 6 v ~ j.1 9L $ rlc4 d b h c4/ r, Identique ( U l a Jr +Y, ;+i U I ;+JI a L W I LK !;I Gf . ~ l j ,, + +f f, -k+ i+ vUI J& 3. .JG

C.I>

-+,

Jr,

lh

,&I> 3 jz L

l&>Iy jc LAY

yJ4

2

+

d

@ k Y1

01~42

i~

LT

elij.LAd&-'i;?f> k~j, ;>s

Jr

;>F~

@

r

kb

Jy

>,dl

Ibid., PP. 55 - 6 .

QV

,&d

dl

;GI ,& '$1

Llr%l

+I

4-2

q$\

bl&l

vUI

+ . d k + Y I 2lJ1 JJ4 j f &+

UilLL-jfd,>&jfi)CLdI

~ > W? I -

6-L

*j

Y

bb-

L&

& JL Jc &-df

3

b@&

Lf J W I

3

J

6-X.

2lJl df

Jr

L ljl i,cL+YI

jc I;*

& @b

bc-L%I

-.

, ' p ,

iLJ.b>,

S ;li $' 1

.i+

kb& d-4

JW~I

Jld, ;bLL, G j l i d d Y b p i > j&

+ ;X11cljk bl>ktaltalon iJbJ lrGy 6

.i & L J l 4jLX.,

6

i j l U I 6lrLh;I

Ibid.. P. 57. Lac. cit.

t

> r I

& ,'PI

I

@%I 'y +l;zYI LgL

J,L jed; $1

,I I

LjlJl&

.( \ A ~ V JL;;Yl )

&~~

&+

cjc &IJ>

0 Y h &%I

I

$ '+A

&,

Lzl

A,

*J;5

p '

&I,

j u b 9 I.b,

y

'b&

.L g L ,

JL 3 iklr;c ablhi jj U Y I a Y h L I j >

j JJJl ')3 $At+ id-O ~ U I ; ,,UYI

I

& J,k

+ ckl&

JL j *XI

+ kJJJI

+ 'y

j

: , A,

j L Y I

J;LiLI

ul&l

,+ j j .blir r, ij+ ,I (i+, &J%

.+-+I

jh

YQ

&Jyr-Jl

r-\5jJ>

ah:, j6'UI jJJl Jj iPI;L), & + Y l +LJl J1 j U Y l w 2 egoistic $91 .&i, 3L;tIl

i j 4 obUI j ilPb 4Jr2 >y2 'LUI &G &. j U Y l 0 Y h p j l j 4+ b + & +l&-YI kl,>l T i h e f f , N.,Sociological Theory. Its Nature and Growth. PP. 108 - 9.

If

(Y")

J U l jc r$Ul

jUYI

,y

iL'Ul sl&l

& altruistic i 6 4 1j U Y l

4

&

LYJ-U

3 ++YJ

dl

Lip.

Jl~2 Y eISJJ2& 4 Jli s ' rirXt;ll o 3 @ & ~2

Jr i l

&dl

$A

2\41j ." 9 2 j?+

jc LIJ*UPEJ,2

m & ,

$

&!j3

$YdI

o

e

h

3

L,L

bEIiL

G ' 3 5 , &I

LbL a%

&'^L1 *d

1"

",+

j .

J! j C

i ; ,

lgJj~1d l di j L+L -L%I

&.&lz;llj

~r A

dill & k Y I j.Lkrll

++L .,l

&A

~ U,I

di,

indices $YdI j .i2Liyl

4

?& 2 ,

J5

Glul UISr!,

i j J l Lljdl

l

&.$I +-&I

~ t l , . d lJ&

cJ I

~ / hr b d l ,lit

41 ~I,JI st:

.#

0-L b)i

e

$141

& &(

0 2 ~ 3

$ Lfccg Ld

J+I

+lkl13

jrd,- d l

(~4-1

+&I

b

*&&I

.&-dl I;+

C&&Y!

2 1 3 3

+G,

.&,$I +j i;C;;JJl +Li;rYI 2L.Jl &I anomie *lrll

.juYI a Y h J

concomitant variations &I

L p ~ b& ~f j

->&I

Ibid., P. 1 1 1 .

E. Tiryakian, Sociologism and Existentialism, P. 19.

sWWI

&-91

j rjX;II slj;I!, . +bjI13

4-lb

; ,

+

>F!

dl *, $1 j . (&J', J @ ' L l A I +L J >j ( j ~ IA&ii>+

e,h,

aGpd-AbJS3

+' p~p -b

.&ql

I

J

y

JA

'

d

~

+

~

~

.

p

j(C;Jb

k & @ J , j J , .k& Sj i i 1 4 -:JI~-JI j GI ilss J iibla, .+YI :&+IiJk,I T;7.+J13 '+L&JI d&l :&I &La '

.(:')Yb+ &\ alJl 'y j&-J4

*$I

-

&I

-iJ+ A& ,

dL J ~ Y3 I W rlSJ3>

b b +.!I

& +.!I

dfi

&L.a

~ $ 1

old1

39;,3 c-z 'cj JS+-

&I

jjj;

LUS, ' i . 1 ~ 1

9 1Jl +.!I

.'$I

t>

Durkheim, Sociology and Philosophy, P. 96.

lL

~li, + 4 &I J+?( 12141flS;zI> ic,kll flS;zt,

ci

dill

31 JjYI 1J.JLi

~ 2 jY+Y?) ,

(i*) aYLiJ.1 3 ic+

9b &

Jljc;

6,in JI;LLI>

l&;til;LI i&j \ q \ \ fbA, ;

I-LJ 'jI+,JI

tJ,

& ,

\ f o r fb L&YI Value judgments and judgments of Reality. Ibid., PP. 80 - 2.

(f

\)

~

& ljSIJ .+

'iiLiyl

a w l Jl+I :I &MI : IL ?lSJJ3

abl&I

*l+

m i

LA i+Ul

6 -t ' c ~ ~ Y Ij .kj. icSj +I

9

,

L+ L&I

&G,JI,

$>

ib dt'

UJI

jLi!,

+I

$1

0 1 3

,

jF

6;IC

ij

'++I

36-

jf

+iA

, u ~ 64 I 6 LA

6k Z i' ;JUI

j Y '+jL LW 2% JL! 3 3 3 ~j . by; ('')aLe foyer d'une vie morale, i& il& f, jSJLl + ., 6 4; &,dl f , JPJI Jja; Y LA& 3+ , Zi% jJrl; il&I 3 4" c+ 431 I L jr k+ +Y19 *1I,JI jlr >MI @I !, "I +j . '4&'I !MI IL d l , & -41 j .$51 @I

& , A

.S+l

j

.L

+MI

Jrl j .ci; 3 4 1 & &C" ,I

.41i pL; & ,f

j .GiiJ, S,L

6-

I .pi J, +34l il&l jr &I

'jjIpI1 jr JkLl

6 124 JUI

9 @,I .j 3 Y 1 Y, . d J i C & '$I $L,JI d

df J,

!, a14j

f++Lj3

&lI

'CI, JL

4, .

$1

iL;LI

jr

/YI,

ej r4li jj

d! @ ci; @I 63 '$I 'I~YIJjMYI

&IJ3 3

' 6 3 y i I l !MI jr

'&-A ?

&A

b + j-

2 $ 'ijdl, ijl+I,

& j 3 3 a+-

i g l bj+

i3jL

i+i

cSJ I bf 6! c + 6) 4 '&I J L U ~dLckll&I dfll 6 2 &&, d J d df I&x&) 64 Li; 351 jk! @ UI jG a 2141 j&YI $I 9jL3 .j+YI '

C

~

4.3

j .'3J,Vl

dt''$1 abf, .&

$I

fl &>I, '$1

;JLJI 3yl J, &lr

j Ibid.. P. 91 .

JU ,I

Y b

y

+%I,l

391,

J! js, J,

.4 j L 4 & Jl+ '$1

pi J,

a~G .,

'LA 4 ; I I 4~ ,'+>I

'&I

-2$1 4; J! +i dbf

( f y )

u,m I

s

+I+,A ?ls,r dy,- J,I o b l j Lbjc j - k . 7 + b l as&\-1_(1 f, fb, L + .;

&,

IL

'&&!I

'J3

>

!La,* $1 LGIJJI O h , 'pl,h!I j . b> & &jJl 4 1& a ' $ , J y , . " J l &I &l,.i, Zk

*u

Y

'(")i;Li

JS

jr

L 'J3YI

+ill

ijJl j ?K>,>

j '++A

&+

Ibid., P. 90 - 3.

( f r )

Ibid.. P. 94.

(f f )

Ibid., P. 97.

(fa)

Durkheim. Les Regles de la MCthode sociologique. P. 172.

(f7)

Ibid., P. 175.

(tV)

Ibid., PP. 176 - 7.

(th)

@ &JlGJl

iLLl

Js 'y

&&+I

&A.

' G J I +J2Al

by$ 'ju,

L;II ali ?ISJ,J

-Jy&I

Ci-JI agelicism aLl&l J1

dYlu l&+I

bjAb

a&&

&

"*).Substantive

. (")~ociologism

&I.JI ')dl

Y &ill

cjJl - A 1

3--

& p f

&,

LIJJJI

iLjLJl aL.lJJJl

&

f,

ISB

.& &li%lI 2,

It.+I

'j itall

o h ~

'Jb4 &dl

al*13yI

$4-

CU:, > j . & hz CJI!'J '"&YI +jX,

iZ;ltJI +@I (*)

Ib

&

3 bf j .

j f Ji (ousia)

c+9

eJJ ( G Ijf)

iJUI

$

$4

f,

J41LC

c+* p-+ill iJ_JI a&)?illj. &-ill

++JL

u + I,!

+I.JI alp,

iJh@ f,

d+l

,qYl+.

f,

+I

a1;u

,I

,'

&Jl

'b, LIJJJI ++L4b L Jl iJ12y

3

;L.;-L3 t+J& &+ L GW4 WJ, u l J! +%,

+J 4

+lJI

4

substance 9 9 1

.

~

&ill 1

$.h.e

Jl

D. Mitchel (editor) A Dictionary of Sociology, art. Agelicism.

(if)

r i a l i a n , op. cit., P. 14.

(O')

Durkheirn. Les Regles, P. VIII.

(O')

Ibid.. P. 156. Ibid., PP. 55 - 56.

&-L.iyl+YI

tLi41

j .

dG]

GLjl (&

JI @ Y

d j j

4f

& ky &

IL J;

y

df

&ja

JL &dl

+lAl +I &I j p &I , .d+, @I +A dill) Calculation uLJ-1, JYLYI

+L;rYI,

31 $3

,(&dl,

U. G%

Y

3 bl,

& j&- Y JU4, d& Y 21,L-. a21+I .(*)& & &IJ> d L 1 &,

21~I,AJIJL

p~~JL

+\,%I

,(Ot)L.+

+ $1

+

O~F-

91 $1-;14 w

&&I Adl&J

Quoted in: Ti~yakian.Sociologism and Existentialism P. 18.

j . +$I

$ i&lJ

4;AJ

j S Y I

j

;c

+JI. ~

edl

dl,%Jl,

&%Jl

(Ot) i s JL J j ~ $~ ..sI dJwl 03, liJ

. \ AAV djdl

&LW Cj;;,

4

1 +.l

j &Uf

4

,J&~ &L I \Ir & Y (*) @I +L ;c JlAl I L

Quoted in: Syllivan, Limitdons of Seience, P. 125.

(0째)

b b realism + l j I

I.;p3I*'

Cb+

&;;I1 ,I&/

Jr &I

j .dK pEJJ>dl 9, Y,

+ I*'

&I

41 holism -1 k$I y l +IS +j ++. 41 wholes al$X! 91 i&I ci+

Y

v-CjJl agelicism

L w jK

y 94

jt

bu! i6L >&

>y-$4

&jSJ

'>ljYI

i,Ll,

La1 d>,dl A&I

J,dl

& d y ! iJkJ

*i &

.i&l

is ++

+,$.I

a k U I Jj >>I, is>

. kUI A,LJ

Objectivist

L Lj2r

fbJI

d$-

L W

j!

*

>I,!

LJ+

scientific *I

aLj:

OGYI IL+ ~r

&+L1

aLr4

J!

'4 ~

&dl,

Neopositivism L ' d l -dl

'q,L.Jl,

'g13Yl,

'*I

(&+I

+>

J d Al Empiricism

L@f i s -l.L, ,I)

wAI,

'#&+I

.~;ij,-,;k ~rs g ~ j~ 91 bk b~ ~Y d ,

i l (LlJ2) u Jlidill ( \ ( \ t +) Mach *ill, -4 u-o;* L' J yi;

(*)(tb

*ij

b -~- j jj l

~

i,si

a ~ r l k ; ~ ~JGI 6%

GI

> - JI C

+YI

+dpll

!WL

L

+

'i;i1il4

.-41

by&

.+I

4 .j',

c+

al,+l

2

fLi,

oLc&LYI

OGL

41 J .;I Y >AC Y

J&

&WI,

U

o

h

Jr

&b

31 Constructs

4 jp? U

> I; 3, +,

J ~ L Y I ,oYYI;.YI

4 si; 0Lb.I

w!,

b4-

J,

Bi0m.V

& d l d&Yi

jJ41&4

4 >LpZ'Y!, t b Y 1 3

j . '4 1

.,by,

Li3j) blbYfti

'aL+lj

~ L bI b + lJJI* ~

MI,~+-I,

d & k j ! &-bl

'ablk;YI

j j w ~cp, . c ~ ) + I

JS J.+ JL J I + ~ &I

. \ v a - \ 3 q fl

&

~r

$1

y i$Ul

4lJl juli I&\ j j 4 k - +I

3kJI h l $ l

b,a~ ,lb

41 - 2 -

2 4 1 oblk;YI

i&Jl

&YI

p, j&,

+I

. p l w l LG,p U I Jj Ll,j I

0

jyA u

a b l k ; ~@ ~ k;j4

GI

d&k>l

.I--! L &I

b &

i*

(03)

(\fV\) /b 9 (a)

k-341

31)bt

Jb,) blbGJXI by,

3.h

K. Pearson, The Grmuner of Science, P. 6.

(OV)

Ibid., P. 75.

(Oh)

~ $ 4yLi' L Ji +I J5 . 51 JI - a-L;K, (+by!

+I

h.

ib, j~+!I

Cyl

d, C = r . ( " ) b ~'jy..~ ; b u l 4

j IA-1

&!I +I

pl, L ~ YIJ,I

Y &I

2

1

>J

&I

4 4 )

a

J &J1

;;Z &,bbb&d! Y

IJ, PI$

.+I >J

h

ej

- 2 -, W

+I

b& i dl

4 A,

&!I i ~ l z L L k s l 4&>

Xij G L Y I +I

bjkll

j I

Y tL;rYI,

3

+

+JI

k,

&-a ,d

+ ill

j.

;>

62 jqi ,I j q ~ a#Li~

L;; . *4&1

51

4

L ; j I&, &I pl, Ji bY 6 t b Y I j &I SQCilql

L i ; W I iy;31 'j.. b&Jl

*, .'I+l+

. ('y)Fl+

'j..

$1

b&.

j dIy&

Ibid., P. W.

(Of)

Ibid., P. 110.

(7.1

in. Dictionary of Philosophy. edited by D. Runes, art. Physicalism.

(I\)

H. Feigl. philosophy of Science in philosophy,

Cy)

edited by R. Chisholm et a1 PP. 528 - 9.

i i d (paradigm &I) +ls

&ddl

PA

.+I

;;rJb J+- p -ic$I

&-+ d l 3- I d 1

9

3 2\46 - &>L;LI I

d +a

3

+GJI

f,

I e-k; >tdl

\

& &dl

ci.dl

I+\

b6gYI 1-b u d p l I a+ ALI,

&J

+ b Y I

~

dt &!>I 3 iF - P X S O ~ ~ S L C d I i+Jl G U p I I j L Y l ii*

&

' I* .,

>&I

I

,

dlS

+&

d,

';nonego) >J+

''t)/I;L(

&3,-71> >j

: J "WI

&+I1

&>L &39(7r)

. V l &- cbs; hL&

T. parsons, The Structure of Social Action, P. 6 1.

+;

(>t)

l

$

t

f,

$

>I

-&%I

rl

d&JI

t&

'u&*LI

G-41d\s13)11

r?, &-b,

Y

,+

'k

LiJI

4 p Y,+dh (aldjr)1l ,!)

Lj.

J1 G;3

t ( T T ) ~ q l jar L ~L ~ 4 l+ ~

1 9 J1.l -Lj

.bKa a I J k I

4-.&

L J & J J I ,y iLL

.('v)d\b!z~l

#

jlflYI

ab,+d\ GJ

2 a W U l JSI,AIB

(3kJA]

,y il-U L A y

&

@WI

-

:g u

&A,

ihs

.;lls+Jl

J+- \CS

USKJID d&

&y 41 .L&

& d l operationism JljrYl8 lJiL

1

b. L - ucil;lj +P b

-

\ q YV Cb r d k ~ 2 ,

U & , $d s , df

Y,

+A c w l p gI.5 &&- b + J l - 4 d &, d d l ~ j t .$ Si ld JA '@&A3 wIL aL; d-l Jc dfi d i l l &GJl J 1" pu . a 1 r, +I ( ~ 3 e\~ 0 2 41 tbk @ p fG3 & &d/ y >, . ' \ ~ v l&, & ' ;? a!bl31 3 L ~& J -+I L X L l j JLLl .;YJ & 9 IL, . ( \ q f A ) ovyl IL Jl-b b b

,;~OIJ

0

h

C. Wright, <The Origin of Modem Science in the iStructure.of Scientific Thought, ( 7 0 ) edited by Madden, P. 16. P. Frank, *Einstein. Mach and Logical Positivism in Madder (edit), op. cit., P. 90. ( 7 7 )

.Y t A

/

6

&ul Fjl

P. W. Bridgman, The Logic dModern physics, P. 5 .

(TA) (71)

. V T 1 / '&UIr j I

(Y*)

-

'&-$ F j l

(V\)

. V V I - VVY ,y '&UI F j l

(VY)

.A

\fV /

IJ, 4

ZJAI

jl,hlU

.Dodd

@

4j & l L

alS;c +i a&

I L j L&-

&fJf

&

+ J, .i--J.IJl +,.!I ,I alL&l +-&dlA, &Y

+I3

ayCM L+l &I)+

rj;l &I,

i+ +s

i+ jli I

jr

JWI j

L,

&I

3

b Y I

&dl +I

(vL)J,kdI

>> b #+In

u+Yl

3 U l

~

@L:&L

L)+

&I - @ - - &-dl)

tk; J] Jull

j I I $LI JLJ~ G~4 , GI y ~ Y ILI

I

G+I awl r,

jJ U Y I f+ y 3,Lw' dl . F Y I ab*Jl $

&eL

i l y &

cAd* r ~ . d w I

LL& J, JL

.&I 2

-.

r+WI Phlogiston ad+s.-&n

Jy ijlJl ;.Cjll

r+W1 4 L

3

.(vr)ilJ*U -&I p l , h l l &L+, e l j J I J a41*llJ /LA!, i ~ l j y $lA a-

(i&lj

3

Y]

U

j

b

,1$

'iU-

jf

&I

4-G j LJkLll al.lj;y

f +b @ li]

. LLS

J&

&dl j41;;. jL

&-ill &,Yl

j13Y1

&dlA,

a++r

p d J essential L y U l

institution rWl, GWI,

4,

&* ~ W 4 I

,LdL

&jJI

L&.! @I a&&\ Jp +3,

(W] L,

& ~ - \16 r

&I

9 L + J, t b Y I

Lundberg cAJ.zl

393,

GUY1

JYLYI,

,f)

-4 LJ LLI j l j ; Y I

;1III

y b@

.A+

j ~

O+

&>

jc

e-

.g l j n

y Y I

J! &

$

.LLl

+ ;r-41* F Y I jr t*; a~.~,~~ AL LL-y + +$1 I.GYI, .L .k

I;\+d l

N. Timasheff. Sociological The-ory,P. 195.

("f)

Ibid., P. 194.

("t)

j1-' 2 +

$ls Becher

$, ..>,z-,

4s)491

b > q' U ~ +I

>l,5l

o*ii

jr

ddl 4

1

JpYI tIk;l

di 9 td-&dl)

4

j Y jf

trUI

3

j,iI

> ,Stah1 JIL:+

1

a&,

&Ul

. G I t,

*I

iy&

alSJ k A&,+

L~I~L ~ II+ J L ~ . a Y U l i

'&

a\&, t+I

+j)

2-3

- -

l j~ +I

'AJI Jk j Jj

J

C L%

LL ,I

(y k l " ~ l

2 d l &*I3 &@.I1

JJ;: '&%I I ; ;-

.+i

rI*ijb3

Y ;+Yl

al&Al

o

*

h

j !&Ul

a,% (Wl

+

3

iG2 ij.4 $ ! +&iix-6 41

9 4 1 >+

&I

z,*

+

d>3

j&l

+ ' LA

' a ! & jt,,

t ija

.(h >L~YI'

CL: Y,

dl

JALU

Y j$ +S3 1-' +jl+JI, &MI ~ J ~ I Jj . dl 4 .,+Yl jJb yli. J i j U l l ~jl+Jl &A jlk;? Jk Y 41 ~ I J I J'?jl;il

j b.jkl

rUiJL ct i -

t~s

'93

+

+ 3 i+s + &I

j/

3

.+I

/ %&I z*t >, e& '&I rk-u -> 46 42J L>JIGLP~YI ~+YI, .ui&~++at +I

'

I

8

b

,

.JW Gij !ki

+ a3

j

at +.+) 0 1 4 1 L;a & L a ! (y ,si t, a+ &% 3 .J L Y I &I; i*/ > (+UI, &ll Jj 2 + A b>\ (Wl a Y & j +jl+dI rI/l a p 3 A- dt.J .' " 7 r ; b s t , &+YI j?, 4 1 mu4

y b

j mk

p l y 1 JG .*bj & J l &+I (motion V l ,i) ijUl j a Y $

Jk j, 3 a&-

A,

6

dfll

L&&

3

@ Yf

&

'*I

'+cilb (WI 4: I&

j .

is,$, . j4JI

J%

&$I

,TTJ

tuj j .

+,O J

JI

.YY

;?tuI

j

2;

+ $1

field of force ,idJ

'>Ul r J l

(AY)

c k J+>~ .SFd L - LIjdI &.+ - GF &!I 21$1 jo v,s, $1 &'! dl (WI~ 9 GI)2 a K & l d ~ . l+ b~y 1 f,LJl j LIJdl &-dl 8 LJL

t+,A

df ;r -. Ja@I

,f

JGwl cs&2

interdependant

LUIA&\

+j

$1

.L

-

.

rJG~In

d J a,

-. >)

irL&I

Jr j- L Y I

. J b % $L+ jy>l 3 L * f l l i j l J i;i: WI, association l + l + l I 0 J b Y J d&Lfll i

+kYl CGL)'!

,

I

a! f,LJl & -.

r&J!,

'lbjl+ll blL."

.(rA)ijJI a

r&

k & jUl,

3 .j i 31 ~4

uiWI

LCLLI

3 ir,lij' d&J1 L C I A I @I

*-

&I

'@ Experimental designs

d3&&K

J1 & I & $1

,t

d>

b p 'C.dlJ>

'&l+YI

I*

t

&

a!

Timasheff, op. cit., PP. 192 - 3.

JI j,aLS;

j,+

IIL.,..,~ csL+..d&,

.GIy

>

J

. + b y 1 csLIJdl j iJAl r b L

$

+

{WI bK

1 @ .&!I

d.2 Y,

jf

.Yjr

I

A d

&% bf &I

(+

i, .+Wl d,$I + d *-4Jl +I Jr &+Yl 0 Y L - jo , s t f, &lL L%-

js T21L&+Yl

4JS

cdil&l

\To

@

+d l JJL+ &I,

6%

,

jo

+

{WI

j +dl

+,I bt

jI

I

&

@y js VY,i L>,JI sL&I 3 1

aKY,

'Chapin U & ~ R

I

d m ! ,

kL'k

& , + ?

L d I &.I!

substantive GlyJI ,I I*

rJAJ

+I

8

p, J! iCI;. iS/ 31 dl& V, 'dissociation jo c3d Gy bf '41 IL Jr, .U

6 ; E U

J *

j. air

dYd1 2 1-

&

b+&YI b L I j d 1

(At)

Ibid., P. 207. -fof

4

iL.b

'dc *>

~

~ +I 3

c>+

1 4 dj

.>(he)

.f \ *

&L! & &I> @ d(5 & d l ii-JdU .;iS+l Q U I J% 2 QU.

YU &Jl ks; $J.-

Jl&

Ed +Lp4 ,~ I h C lI l ,GI--~ J1 L& j.

r;U. Y lh,

'Gb

fYJ2

4

tj-n

df J-L,

l i dfi-

-d4

(t?l bf fLJYl

G.1J

2 L

:L

- '""i,bL.~ QY I>

h

dY

4 A .

&I

$I--Yl Q U I

iS*l

L

b

91 -41

&b

2

d-l

d d l i .*I

ab&I

&w @ Y

i&i

>>Lir ~ I i d y d I d JF-Li

&-JJ L ~ l j-i j - L Correlatior b@;YI

6

$1'

GI>YI --$ j

L&+>I

J r j - df 4

, JI& ~

3

'y i=-l;; GI,

'bIY

Ih

jI--YI L

Y l

+ J Y I & 2 I p Y I +.+

Y.9

f& JI (fq1,I)

0K.L

aYLLI tj & a Y G l+Y Coefficients

& d k L & eLb ~ lflj,i Jf u d p & r *dl ,I 1 3 udkn :+ ;JC j JlribYl >rl~. +!I ~ 2 . j,+I &-JI uYU.1 dfii, W LG &>I >* Y JI LLJ; +I&, J1 b>A yi dl +

bU1

+

j ,I)

k~JLLI

>

'dKl1,

&-.dl t ljJ1 I+ df

&I

b

;Y,

.A,.LJ

& G I a\,>[

J

Ljlj 'j&

dbjl j

v3&d,$

d U l i .b>,

ryJl,

~l,J-l,

& kp Qi@l

~ , ~ l j j Yi;4 I r(GL;yl f&Il flj, j. L.2 .k dl Jl +&>I , I +Jdl ildl &

lx

k< kk

*I

w & aI A i l

1-b 2 AJdl rEJ31'

*j&I 'j.4Lk.JI f,

(dl+YI

&L;II

92 index &>IS JJ& f, l d i l d l l pEJ3> J

L 9. &%I

.("')+Is JL

L(

I

j &I

G,LJI

+I

&I,

x,

j \q\Y

&YI

. a h d i l l +I *UA

ak

yYI [J,

jc i,l;uI

A,

+j d+b

c,&YI

~ I > * u++IS u A dill &I

j L Y l d&!I

3+

3,L.J

.J&I

Psychololgyas The Be- aJ&I

dl&l

Q U I Gill;

+i$k Li,i

L O \,

fir

d,

~r&L: i+ic~~~ IL jb . a 9 1 IL

'j.41I .&,&

.&I

dh

L@>Iij%

ULI

j- J-,LJI

+I

3

,

+I+ j G L ,JI

j f, w ;iI

. (")>+I

'

&J

I .y one to one correlation &I2

Q Y U ~ $ & L Y IQ W I ,slb13Yl

u

sign ~LWIIC& Merton ad,i*,

JI

$*i+~+YI

*kll &I 34,

LjIJl d,&

f d l &>.ki &I &I

.

G J I ~bl&% ++I3

~ L ;!& A,

d > ,

L&

. tyc!plu. $ >+I

~dl iG*LIr, GWI

o.+ ,

j I

+(S

+I

U,lj d l internal i$ll'l L% f,

i d 6 ->IS

~ *i3I . ( A A ) L w b!

i & l IL,

+ Jr

$5

$3

Jr

' d L % I 'j.4 b,.+

$

:I'+!\

f,+lLi,

'cr*I,iu,fiQdl&Wci;pi~

jc*dl&Y,

d&

Jb)

*i,

&4

9

d+UI

d l

I+&.+

+lp

gs ~U+YI

i;

4;b j &I

dill ~

J

+D

441 J L

4-b dL5

haviorist views it

o w l

,l

QI&AI bJwr U!, &&dl..

&I

012 L+

+J@l

j&,dl Q L

+Is J 4'1

d$ d i l l

,l +bi

E. Durkheim, The Mvision of Labor traans by G . Simpson, P. 64.

(Ah]

Merton, Social Theory and Structure, P. 115.

(Af)

E. Nagel. The Structure of W n c e , PP. 476 - 7.

(fa]

A

.( \ ' ')WL; +)WI

~b r j

d [,

&

dl

2P;'

Ideationally

A l j ~ l pAl>)'li .a b (j &d ':&$,I

p

&*

b

r& .

iJ+

b+

JA I &*&,I

-

JJ; +-LAC( . ( \ ' y ) Q

pi &

....o*

+A

b~t.i d

2 Jyp Jj+ p g+JIPklli)

&$

b$l

bdl;.kl

is&I

;*

1

bpL~i2UI

4 +)

d,&b

++JA

je+ ~r ++&I

,y +.A

jrJL f - + ~&- d u l d.b +&I ~j-&...& &+o-kr ;r >,.I1 jbl&g f$ dl dub -. ii%

Y,

@

b>&

r -j%)'l b b p F

& U iLo Y + 3 & .-)&I

.+YI j

d l ii% ,?6 &Jb+Jl ;rr?

bl,.II

i~b%!I

f$

&

&dl LGUJl &i b +)L; J!.iII!t+Jl GJ1i;l .&I .&I J o ) OM &dl&dl J &I t+Y) ! Q$ i &

.b&I ;pU

J ~~3.1

.WI,

&J . . . . @

1%

6 9 1

I+ .&Y U- t t p l GI> dli

$4 $ 3

(Transcendence iiJlill,I) ,.MI

if.(

.('")a&I

LaJ

t+JI,

,y

;J

L+J&

&&jJyp &-) I L

JL ,

& (tPfJJ wl,.Il

ii;iCI ,y rl+1

+d )+I IL & 91 + J ~+JI dy , IO;L~

& 49 -&il &.Mu. ". "l+b+r, ?

,L+J,l

b

*+I

@

J~~

b2

7 2 s

Lldl ;rr? &MI jJ@ 9

L S ~b & J ! d l jtjp~.b )I+ ,

iy-

~ j 41 :

d

Y

b

0

h

4

4 4 1 ;r -. ;rWl .

+*-ill

JrJ

4'1

oa-4

6 3 1

dl

0 2 ~ 3

,I +MI as24

&-

Husserl, Idens, PP. 1 19 - 120.

211

4'1

(\*\I

Ibid., PP. 241 - 2.

(ley)

.y? - yo

&>$dl

a*

6J-

.y?

/

. J

4

b & u l

(1 * y ) (\ * t )

9' 4, dills, ~

Y +f,

ow

4

bL+

&1,

-,I

i>UI I f,

2%

~~, .alU 4 L Y l i;JI

+lit

J d I 84,

k k f JJ-~. b.

I~&&&I

.('' ")Sensile i

Noesis --$IJ

&&;,,-dl

9, &JYI

,,-dl 5 dl; Passivity iJLcri;YI

31 ,+

3

l aL&1

4

@3

6 6 L Iil; .&I

&$I

3 . i2U1 +&I &# dL& VJ activity +Wl b + ~+-, iJ> iw +zUl ++ &&I

J! ,+ eUJl d!

L+,A ~Noemak.&l 9 ~tp, J1 A , 4 A,IJI, 9 4 jc. &I s1,>yli . Z M l +&I +LP r+I) +All3(LuS 9 4 $Air 2-U LuisJ (dJU j ; ; ;d! LLJ 4Y, . b> j , iJJI j 4; Jh, . (Luis +n +I LI,.yI +J j(i+~c) d& L r; & 3kL p ' j .?I ...+ I,~+I,T +lif

@ c.+ b('")91 04.2

4dI ~SI&4; &E jl &iy

&&

Jl

i&

L @ ~,G*I+I

b d w

'p j, I & d,

&.i&!I

, Ji

p

G W l UJLAb,

$' ipj, zk

&.A LIL d l Luis,

l,-

>yl b

+ a Y L j, o h

&.!I

A j+ L , k , ~ d & GJul 2141 -b% 'uck!l i&

81J>Yl a

--A13

b54~y&!1

81J3y.i .dL+

ciJl d l , &-I &+i .&I

3\41&I

AI,>yl

34

+A aE6

&, .*I,

I

&G

&\8!>>?1 d&2 3

L[

9% % Jyp r ~ 2

+

+&I

'8~d1 4; .(@I411 #+Jl

dLYI

*

,

3 1 3 (QYU-I) &,$.I1

d&!Wl

3 ,

3

b*

u-

(&&2

3

+ j Y bLslj!

~

j J U l )Wl dp b 6 - + r J I

L L d l i;.+Yl

JLr .>I41

&&I

)LJl

;J1. di

iLUl

2,

J, L

klk

b G +

9, b

, l . ! .JJJ ,U&L

lip

Transcendent Disconnecting

j

j

( , + ,

GXJJ Jjl,Jl

Alj>Yl h GXJl

J.

b

.kt\

* I

J, 'b b1?)J.!.13 AlJ>yl & ++Jl G%

J-2".

0>F2

~ i e t i c--dl u J l + l J Nexus +l$l &I,

&l Lj,! $i b

&

b&19-(

,-f

1 . ' ( . IA b l i b j q l

J!

LijJI

AIJ>yl

>&I

dl J, b r l p . J I

+ ~ l n jUI+-yih; L ~ U I

+ J, #k,J+ji ;I+\

AIJ>yI .(\'")&+.I JL&$I

+g 3 dl4! j+I

Huserl, Ideas, PP. 258 - 9.

(\ *V)

Welch, The philosophy of Edmund Husserl, P. 139.

( \ *A)

A

Jy- Y &I&\

GJI

-41

d

G%

JMI d i l i l l I L

I&II

A

Y &I

&-I,+

*-

\ d l :&WI

Y

-kIl

di

a 4 1 ij%

~ + A I j ALYI, I

.&+A1

9 u J & JJI +\$I OL d3+i

'

2

.L\OIC+AI

dl JI;CI

d\ d,~ ''k

. p 2 l &Wl+-

-

& J++

+, .~ILYI, d 4 I & f+JJI J+I J+ &+ 9 a 4 1 &L kY. ; ; lY J d , +* ~

~

~

.(\.')&

~

3 1 ~ 4r~ L ~ 1a 4 AYI ~ ji;? 41 IL J., .I^ c, ' l & a d d 'lcy LC ;;3 +Uli .akU &I

, c,, r iJ3PL

b

41 o b 9

2 ~ 3 . 1J F , ,

'a&!UI 3 4l; Ideal QlL

+>&5 ,y CjlrfL, '+lJl +\ J! +I41 j u Y LIL

54

' k t

aL +Jl

I L

4r 3 "L ;,

&, .is2 ,I

&IS ,1-

~j

wlJ2b+UI

-CrJk<

'++

+>

J S ,

.i.dI,

Clear $ d l 31JryI a+

L,JpdI

CP a k U l

+

+UI

+>

2IAI '&L

.L J!

dS;- JJI +Ul f& fbJ1 1 .i9 d3ChI3 &bJI f+l LfrUl r+I jj dl

GeJ

JF,

+Uli .~,s-AI &ia, , a l U &= @ AlJ2l &5 ,y

.+

.L

.f-+A1

5.~1

I,,+

.9j

& Y, .

(\\')

r'bJI

C+ & Jr*pb+dIUI

aYGli . >I41 &L &-k $LC1 dlJ>i?Y p&&.. +# ~ f+lk OL r~ Y Fictions (\ \ ~

w-.I^ &

) ' ~ f

' W I i+, &I

. ++ &Ljl, ~ U,a&, I

J ,l;l

cL+JI,

.+Ul +j Posits p GlJI 4j - .( +>A1GIJI ++I >u - YA,+ &

.( b k l +I

@>'$#

-\

p &-I

&$>)

'+pl.d%&d,&bt$>p&-t

:dJContingent Essentiality L J LdJ 'L

' ( G u l &) 'lb~zr~l

j&

4JG

-0

3y 9 l . a$;,

Correlative --bContingency

l .2 c p J 1 1

,I

iJJP y

+>A1dl.+,l,

:$9

@I

Being

. cit;$-IfbJ11 & hi ti-I Nornerically &lr +&.dl & ,

.%$-I a.l+,Il ! J &.i

4 3U.I - 1 fWJI & y L J & ~$.Z1 +Uli - V .Nonidentical i+UI $.Z -A Quality (iJJyd&) Y Yku.1 +$ -

e-

.("y)w d l +-J,LYI

Inner Experience ci,Lildl +&!,

+kU

Status

'+

-

&GI

("y)

.(\fro)

P. 13.

0

&b &

Welch. Op. Cit., P. 185.

Husscrl. Id-,

-\

+&YI

L$J J r p t-Lk. j.

("r)

'+I o

4dl

G u,

Y,

dl -->

h

+J,L,AIl

dL,Yl

o

,+Lwr;. 4 1 lh

&A-

i+b

vjaj

.WIJI

'$1

L

' U l ++$I

, JS +

GyJ

a ,1

djJI

~

dL?&

bLO2

G1J.I

&J1

.&L, &k y i

-

O

I$

&,

+, +'J1

&j

h

'&l.*Il

,A,

GIUI ++I)

I$ &.dl dJ-I 3 d k 3 ;-IilLl b j ~ ILC

- -

diJl

r, Lls

(/UI

.tJ%+

I&,

.kli j 2

rllJ>?l

e

~J+L

gu~ JS i+,

+--&I

h

jb3

~,;~J+,AII~LL$I d$-

Ll+,

df ,&- Y J+-

JLP;-YI

'bli j LYl J.1 l+

dl,

&I

&J+,AII

+-ill'+>,&I

ozj-.

#A1

.(\\')bli Soul &I

~ Uju-. ,I

:& t o

& ,is,

dJj.jl

&I

-..L j , JFp

X.L

d' 9 , +I>K LYl

&

,A

i+,,

+,

>yW

l

Y .;WI ?Y;, ,Uci>-, u dr &ii id+ , J% 2 (+!I) U U - I dL +df ',lLJ\ >y-* &-t d L Y 0 * 3 +MI o L , I J 3 I '@J+,AII >>I wlJl

j6 ;

+ jl+f

3 , .rCJUJYp

p 21G~ j Ibid., PP. 13 - 14.

GUI

d J 1

LG,.~ ictj1Jl I+ LG iJL JS d k Y ;L;lUl GUI f, Solipsism

29

JUI

'+

&

GJkl a G l 3 ; t Y & LA I

3 I+ ((+bJ Lflb,, + \ p Y L &.I

C+

LJ&>I>I

+d+2 WI

b >J+

i&.LdI '>jj.jl

4;Jk4)

2 $1 +-+ (''1)

+

&

41

pL9

O>F*

ai-+*

J i kJ&;JI

+ ~i-+-+ 0 r -

$

to)

+&I

&,Yl

>*u , '#-I "pu ++,I.l 4 -b J! i&LlLi;JI LJ+rJI, -. &a 3, GJUl i.xAl & uI_SI >+ 4 2, /&I CL/& h d 4 i 2, ./&I CLI & &ill s - f . LCJ ."y +s d J J 4 t - -d I iJL9.l jc j;k; 2 - , J- k L j +iJl &.G,.l 61"

b

q

u

b&

-

~JH

+

+ill

j

,lWJ @I

&lJl

a cL-1 2

~ { W IIL

&I,

. &dJI

j

o+-

& LZrJ+rJl

++I

L.WI

2 kt a

6cc;Lkll

{WI

>IJI

Y

. i -: ;~ PC

cL-yI

+, .

at jl.&

J.

2y

>,9--

O

& Cui j t +

L

d

ibid., PP. 18 - 120

&+Yl

i

&

4 />

+J1

@

+I

+I

;C1 +Ji +Ja

b L at&

/&I

4 1( ;Y

ii-ill & d l

yl I+

U l J.-+ Y

+ &a.,

i i ; ! d l ,.Q ' 4 1I"

& i l l >&I

U &I 2 bb-9 ~ L K Sb I

$9

b

L

kr.

&, .U~G;JI - ck .la2 4 i . 0 ~

r&- LA& L ~ l ~ +# d l 4

Disclosure &I

I*

-Li

&I

~ I j bii i +L

. ~k12;;Jli & . l J &.,A

jl

.L;li dp-

$ J;?

Guk &-dtJ

{Wl

<d+rJl

b >4 ~ 1-

c+

tL;.

s

b

4

b\ l++,.b, 012 bl

~ ~ 9 1 ,L&Lf

I

GldI

i+JI

jl LC {WI - CC~IJI -

;SkL;Jl

YYq

iJ,&

bd,+131&A

VJ J,Ul

LW

aI+L

r jk; l$' LZrJ+rJ1 1 1 .9r &-

3Xb;YI &

60"

+

L

iJ4lS31 .LA

qk12;AI

+ 31 >Ji. ' i J b ~ $ l

++I &;J~JI;;JI

+ - -&.dl -

'j ,\;W '&I

5,d

L[ ' J k L $ l

4 ~ 9d 31. d l '& 31 $9 ;lc

JLr;&J$l

!Wl

JLI

l&k

L-,,&YI

dJ\

'y

bul Jk

j &--,A b u l - &I- Fellow - Subjects @I 6% j Co - Transcendental i S J L &!EL$ .("')'+ ,jYl 'j clr;; 'y 6 &.dl ((LA91 i;li

p~ ' i J k ~ l>+&a&

?Jb

GJLI

:&

'\;[I

J, ~ivennesso# _.

a&,

crcJLL y; & i;\U $3, &dl &I

$l~u;;Jb;'

j6, d l 'Intersubjectivity 6-

&

'y

a&lpYl

d& JS

L

y;

&I

w

jCk;

ji & d + , ~ l

ilk

&dl , d l 4

3 &; ' J h b y

#

J; &!kJI;$\ i;li

UUI,

&*

sljb .("')&IJ .iu j;i, i+,LYI J..G &I

\'I (\\"I

Ibid.. PP. 21 - 2.

(\

Ibid.. P. 30.

:$ 3 1 =ince interiore ho&

&-I31

b b ~s~I&AII OSLJI habital Veritas*

$3 ,y +UI i&JI

(\ \A)

4

+ pbs'

I& eLJ1

~J>,J~I-E ,!;I 6

jL')'l

Y+

2

4

j .2 - k ) W l

& j Y l f&l

++,A&IJJ d f i &I

bj.

b

u

JI~!,d L y l b .;i

,& jS;- J, 4,i + a++,

2

.&lS

O

jc

b

Y e--1 l h

+

'&p

+ ++I

L: hL Lb sl&Yl &U;j

+ j+dl hypothese

&ill e

b 1-b

Js

4,

de Travail

(\W0lj+l\

l

2

,& j b

&I

LL+

A ,@

&. yU PX,.

6&j#

d+-

ir

j .lib, .ZLs a&

)b

Y,

dgjl j .jJL -c" & + ,

.bi jL! .(&)

6

1

.&

J!

Jl

&-&dl s L y I j

CLJ

eaL+I

pLS

t&YI

'csli+lI

o

h

;c!

241 & Js, a&J\ oh Js

& .

.,ill. ,i i*, +Y & pal, b p +I rlc dY d L Y I L I > J L p l i ,i ?j% ali% ~yrllLi Y +1J, +I PI& k ; Y ' + 2 d 1 +;,I .*YI jL $ 9 IL, bLi 2 e Y , d l 3 - 1 3 L,&, iLSL Jh3 '&+I l;+I. J ; ; 3 >+I! hi

+,

.&+ d.21j+.YI

M Ii! b $1

>

&>2

2 d+

dI +I

u b l

&&\

~

.&A

M

6J c,j;Jl

& k

CuI

+

dJG

kI

*

b&

i

I

&

diW13 '+I

2 @ .~AW.LI

9 J]I

-

?&+

c.J

.&.A

Libdl & Y l &

Gi&i

A,

CjJl aLJ,ALi d l M j f l l

21 31 &J$! .bt. kJr @ 9 & bz@l &JJkl J;:

2-

.+p.'241>iwr;U +A + b e - T +A J.L + d l

+

&G

C I * 2 j Y I I L dl & ,

j

JsLk;

0 b 3

&;?!j.dL>*-lj,

49

[,

;f'.p k 3 > & f l L

d3 I-b

clj!

j !kL->L di,

+ b ii c-*j Y

, & ! ~ ' I y V ' ~ y2 L2 jyj +-d

3i

o-b

+3J41 C +3 S I dlJ&

j

JS JL,

b$

4

&I\ : A & ?+di

+YI

br4Y! &

t~31

Li2 &I j

+L &&

d3&I i ;

&

&Y

jr A&+ b_i3 4 ; did +I

I

6i3 .+I,+

o

cIj!

+-CSJJI

b > ,bbr, ?L.+YI OL dl5, c

&

&2b &Z

3, dl5 J

I i b 2I$I

li!

'J29L

&*L l i b . &I3

~ $ 1 3 +I

&

.+&- j

& a., $&Y, Cc. JS d L p G +i

IL 3,yfrl

luSCfapzJl

jr J*-

&+

klj CfS;S

CjJl ali%lj

s~+I

d '49 e M Aka

l

ib

, .Lp+2

1 -

31 J I

b f liij~ .+ ~ ~

?I. L JUYI

++

L+

+A++I

)Lu

iJUYl + l,l

jr

9 4 +J

i;j

4 2 .J U Y I ,G3 l+-~. JUYI\&\L 31 4 1)b jj?J TJ.4 j .& jbk ;;? ) 31 &I I+ +Y.~i 31, ,641 *lib j .uL[ & Y fliJ1 d\ ~ b Y 4 I I J . U y I j dl i.YLri;YI OLLIJ. Jc OL 3'

+ ld e+> J U Y I

.>lyYl b

i

d

&I$,

&

o

\

6

214 (LJ.UI)

jL;yI

&

&!&

kl,

.&I41

LWI

+p$IJ

~ J U Y Id+-

y b!;

91

LIL 3'

oI&l

Y

LC;;J

&

@ Y ij.@b

Jlc;

U Y I i.&L be.

j .0

Y j bib L

pldl AIJ+

j . ~ p y J -$L;?'I I

J1

91 --

bfbJ1

J&

&I&!

i;YI

4

,

,.+ (\

*Liill,

Y W I d i

9 Jp& +4 ! 1[4

U;3Y is bJ,+d4

L$IJ &JI

5, bfbJIJ

j,L

J&

41 + j+WI

d+uI & y 'Y

i > .rr~

l& j .J U Y I

.i.L,+dI

i b L y d+Ul

jr

4 s i+$ La+

$ L y l .f14 &I

6q3Yl1

fliz &&I

OL

iL'lkll2 31 .UJ .&.kJl

UbJ

wu* La,

&I

8 I.+.sku1 3\ ,IjyI ;lY, i+~ a k u ~A+, L J U Y I +L Jl ~ r) L j, .+j fliJ1

9131 d

*, p,

3dL-

dp.+ .&I

+d 5

d3+l

jr

h

~r

> J!,

Jtli~4

e-+!I

+J h l fliJ1

j .

y+l L+?J+,.d +4 %LAY! ?NiJ G U l 31 * y d I j . 4 Y, cGJu\a-

+J,d d w y ,

. & I ~ ~ L ~ & )b I

*&

+

fg1 Ju! p q -& &,O* J! L;k, b I4 414 ihi EL ' j x b y l Jr J,I fL, iJ Lab! $2 jJI i4JI FLJI a L y I 4+ csgi + 3 , '{U d L Y I ay+dl blsyr $ 2

& Y ii'I

dl*

+,I ?*-{

b #I

b L

tjY

.)at Q .,'

'{WI,

Y,

jl 5~ .jb,+dI ykW dl k& + '&I (J, dLYI J! LL Si. '{MI jj L Y l C ~ + J j t 'iC4;

9b

J*,

+!!I,

J';;G;" (&,JI ,I)

& {MI y , n

31 o@Yb Ciui a&,

-499

% JUYI

&)-G

3:

+J+YI

.J+JI 3

,1$

44-43

at *U

('")~+j

ipG 6 3

cL-L 4IJ2l J! &4

,A jJL dJ $1

a+ln

'(~1,

29 js Jl &$

Y, 'dl; &ILL>

+Ul

&IL-\;;Il

L??&I,

,A,

3jI~

31 adJ+&l

+JUYI

{MI y , n

)&I

fl&b

&

a+J

'+>dl aYldYI

i,k. lsdS Jldy /&I

LS

oC;*!

& d l 2 ->L 3-J*, 9 +dl JUI bli! j L 2 j L y l 4 w$i&\i .* bul

aa i, .LA\ ji 9 QLYI 2141 j t 2, ihdl WIJI LLL $ 9 - udb>lJ >*41~ j3+b J& , p-Dasein d L Y I 2141 4 ~ l a)&ni dl ILa db b U - I ~kK.1c+b

+-

>flJl '

I*

1 2

3

aY

+I

Lui

I*,

.+

.(\yy)uo2**il

9

+!

0 2 ~j 9s

'Gyk

'GI;

+ $,

f

I,& j L Y I 4 1 ,

5

4dl i;b a.4 Jr a+& 'dLY1 2ly LJk

dl,

.(\")ab&-n

.+* @!

2ldb

@

2x3

6%

-

2*Jl

9 I 5i! LLi . L\

L

,+&2 x 3

o'J*,

6

jLYI

9

. +l, . \r fl '+J+p>1+ .A

+ &UlFJl

+j. ~ A J I >J~,II

(\ YY)

'J~L ( \ ~ t )

& ,

.dl+,

+-L 9 j K

,.j,JWYI j . 'GL~ -

-

'ci;jc

+Y,

VJ+

LJ,>

j L y l jc

GL~I

i,&

&.Ul &$'I

+-

>&I jc JWYI &J++lI ~;r JWYIJ L + J, 'J L Y I +L

b U I J L I&, &= ~1%

+. dl

'+ L G

a6 L ;l.

I

j$'

d6- Y zdJ+ dl& 3 '5i Zl+ JWYI & dl rf 'aQbL12 *b

at L'J U4 9, .JWYI &= 3

2y1J+,

Lie41 d3 .(lw){WI+; a.%.&.

41 9 L JLZYI dY

bUl& L , .>+ JWYI

A

-9

L ,

+a

3 6 - j i l l j L y l 2IJl9 JLYI

jc J U X I LZrJ++lI

L+

9 jWI

'b &I

+d,

iJ*ill QL 6 4 $5

L :JWYI jc gLYI

.'.'A)L33> J! j LC i.i;L]MI,

d l , .i.i;L!21,s L lij

2

*

JL

b L 'y

~2&= .\ o l

+L

>&I

j f &-++lI #

a 3 5

+ JYdIJ +'T

.Yo0 ~g b i f l U I J + d l U

2lJl

JWYI J5 .

3 + LA

\t

Lg " +I

j aL19

. Y l ~g ' a Y U Y l

I

#

a 3 5

lib >>L

L

JYdI 9

( y j l (\TO)

c d ~& 2 .>(\TI)

j +l;; ( J > L ( \ T V )

- & u l c$(\ TA)

45;!

j.

Y 4 '&.dl

L

+ j. ipW +bJS +y *.

st,

$I

j. L+

4 1 {LJ L2lj j I~LI Cri; ~9 I

91 i d yJ,

is-1,

&j

+.

a k l i +YI

JJI

.+I

I L

d,

&In

JC

+

.i,

~ I J II L J

GUl

3

(4 3jg c y+Al jJa

@4

~_)rj) lhodologique

abyL,$.l

+ dl 4

st

db L

JS,

l+b, +I

@I

&&-dl

I

L

3

2 5 9

>+

j b ] l JL

'L+~l,i

yJ I

4 4 1 di jWI.1 &I s

+-+S

,

I

j

:ab+$.l

J.

:+a4

'ijYl JC

Airy

J,l;j

{WI hk: +iG _Li

JJI

j,+b

~

3

Lj vj &

.LkG, d,-.Jl

&pY.

.Lp jlG JS

c t J L 1

.3+J4 rJlh; 3 L ; G j LaJ+& JLJI 1291 hJ&4 &y

2

C

jA

t~

rJ, ,j,k

j a12$1, ~JUI a- C1,

{WI 4 L

4Y, e3

3f

~ l j >c-i; @- jI jJL Jjk

L4LJ LliJ {b - Urnwelt I; > d l &-dl 1-b & d &i $ ~ i+

j, db, b tk, ;dl

I tliJl

U

.("')ipUj

&k, - ULi!, 'dl; f,

u

. &Jl+

dl5 l i b

&J+&I

$LJI

..ilY>

I L JL,

{b dY dii '

&I

JC JGXI

' d l 4-

31,

2lJl

,+ _Li

'ilJ*ll

,Lu $c +I

&.,li

4.&

EL

fl

' 3- L Y b1

i9Ul J% 3

'

lcri

k,

ULY j

3-4;

A ,5

'&G

91;

C+

1-bjJL

{b {Wl IL,

++ Rkflkhie

j & {LU ~ &S

JL, l+li oL;~GYI JJI

'{Wl +>$I

Yff

3

.A+! .A+?,

+

J% 3

31

j- ~- 33 i JUYI 3 L

&I

>A1 ({WL ~ 4 1 is!) - k ~ ~d, , k_rby

3 9 Lb

sul dq"! &&

2,

cj

+I

i

a

a&-&!

kL, ~$L* L+-

&isr

Y,

J$\

j

4

4

e3.l

41 i>+&Y

+GI I

\A*

a\ 4 .+&I

+ 3 t+JIJ

tP3.1 Jr

;IJ,

L++

dkbb b,lW & b i ; $ .r

J U Y I A+l

b

b

&&

+ & CWI AI,,~ d% 3 >A\ dj~)-)-

j, yi

j

3

at && G2

J +

2-G

j+Jl

9$ )W4 cG%

4. GY & L ,

c

Y r;Y * f ~ ,

Jj 3 - 1 b~i .-I

J+J%

&I

d+f

i&

+

&-J L y l

2-4 L\ LJA

JG ,+t~

($3

Y

2 411 p i 6 &+,J!;

A

j;s jnt

if.

b & L

Ub ,l+G j is,& JljVl, a;J+I!, aK+l UX;,iJlJ.CL'J;I>p-Ild~yjti~sisi~ Y c m 41 -k @dld@l Gk #, . m LJ I .+ MI 0 L & Jk! SL; Y iYt a! 0-b , & L dbp rllJ4 & 6 ~ 64 ~ , &4 Y &dlj$I 1-b YJ.GGyI &.-j e,.~Il Jli, Y ~1 d c;JI j i++ :&I 4 1&G i-d- 3 OL +t dt +t Y ~t 91 $ ;.I t I .+WI j y ~ >+I j+ ,I e, 4 &~I=.S &@"+ I d . ;&I CAI o h ;$I rl+ Jsj.

>3

,

p I+ j . i>-

.iJJiiLi bLGt &I1 iiPll iJl rl@I jiiJ LI4-1 -31 p u t 2

bI

b

,

@+I

L 4 X ; k

3 >jLC

eJ+

JIty-d + 4 , aYGY!

. . .I&,

d+K

JUYI

t p ++-Y b>>,t &I! a 9 1 & dl

&

>s p

b

31 &I&,cj_w

+ aw c l l y l J L i Y l .(\'t'+S\S

, , at

+ b ' ~ l i+i , Jp!Jl >fly*y

i,-c

+I

J1 &> 'hkt

bilb$j X A l

kL LALA ybdl J. ji'Ipj.i, j

,&I

,d$l,

b,.-l;i

iL,$ i;-r yl-4 ~SJ brl@l bkt LkYl o h cj" rlJ&&! o ab*

b(\tr)Jl&Y~

-,.

sji

.i,?

$ ii?

3k.J .L&IZ;, OLJX; 3 d+, LZ-' a-w - l dt ++

:I41 QLi;YI

j.

o h

i,WI

9, :y J J E>,$l

. O Y - 0 . cg . O V - O Y cg

,,

F1;; J;, eul$5

dt

'&WI FJI ( \ t T ) '&MI FJl ( \ t t )

.*

j eJu J , + &I i: *r JIG + k , i ?-.is&~~o,+~++!Lr

{MI

,+I

+ ,

j

sljl >+JJ

9, '!MI

'jf (lJ ,

'

d

>+l,

.J+

&

j.

t&.'!MI

&I j JUYI 4

jM

- dJJ

4

A91

li)+l

JL) $&I

3,

>&I

lL

&

J +

+ br.,

J) >&\

++ 4LcL ;rc > d l*p .>+I

'+A

+-

81

'p'hrJ-L

II Ci;

syYl

~GI&&U%

!WI I L JXi

dl dl 6>+d!, +&I

p t.r 3 I .A+! JLil 6-

*-il

p L +JL

iill

'+JJ

**

JUYI

2

>,A\

JLjY &JI (&Lill ,I)

' s - I1.b j , talUb icUl r . b

j

I&,

o&$

++

6J.k

s+-

Ci-Ul91

+ &J1

y , t+,ll

I h :&5

Jlej,Lj- *vt-I 4 6l,J 9 JGYI d& p .(+ d3+ t + ~j ir' OYGYI 9 s ; .ac JUYJ dr ~YI, .+I+ Y L . . . . . .L>_)I ,I *L$ ,l * k b i c 402 !MI +

+-

GP

+-

GY-G s&YI+ >&I

31

{L jr

>+I3

{b

YfV

4

+idfi

'{L 4 , '?I

.-

JUYI !Lr jr ~ 3 1

. k g u &I> J) +& i -diJl

&ul

Li&

1 WjJI

+A>

3gj OL !MI_) (d_)rjL\ JGYI j

p L I )Wl i+

&

~+II

:a+

+>

-6-

IL I

j, '@GIJ+ JLYI

p

dl

6.j"

+ j +I

GJP

$

I

I

JI ej

JLSUJ

.j+

@GYl

&MI

!W d+

9

+J

b13

& Iks*

J L Y I j+

JUl

,Jj , .'&..dl &L

+j .J L Y I

.&k &b

iJ+ c443 J+I I

91 3

q+

JJ+ dI c 3 r J + ~ I

.I ~ W j Y 'k!MI +I 3 ~ ; .L

I ;ab

~1

JJ+ LL ,

+_ drd! ) J3L

~

G

~

@GYl

IiJ+ J L Y I J+I

+

L 1 :c+Jl 9 +As &gI dl j .,,SJ3 ."iv'y-CYI & U I j+- @ G Y I J+l I L j ..\+I, I&&

c L l iI jJL &IJ -riiJ b13 ZIJ1 .j" 31 9 , . dLJ j +-dl ,I kl, 4 3 41 + 3 & j. j- q ' l 2lJl Jr + J+ L JI JLYL~ .21. . . . . .i+ ,I isJ& ,I '+ .!W+ 3 L Y l elJl YW c+ 9 l i 1 +As J+ L, 3 J,b

dill

i*o J s br 9 ++ ,I

Jr ,ykjI

J~

~

hj IIWI $

&I-: &li J G Y I

JlJli.;YIJ .

3, jk! dill J G Y I j+L ,; bUIj Progressive & d l &UI .1;?+ It:

ej

&I

$1

&&,J+&I

&GI r&!1

,& kj

&I

&& dill

0-

2-3-11

&ULi

jf

.(*)Regressive -lJI

31 dl yc, ;1-

r&> .t-12 k .Wl 4 4

k,J+rJl j .JGYI

cbPJ

I+

jjYl

SJJI j .$+

J+I;

6

iL%

&4 'p - &,.J+rJI

&I Jt. ~ f iS C l j d l l I Lpi .&G r+j id&\

.

L+

r

Jj! & I-

02+

J L Y I P,lJl

! ,

u~ ~ - + G J & J L I C "JI+-J+,~JUX~ J j . 4 . Y A JbI-p, 't, 35;1 &Yl J3-1 4L2-c+L '4;L.b J! b+ 1 .i41 4+-& r*+4 I+ ~ L . L . j 9', + '.~J.L G ' G~'UUI L-,J++I ~t &I ,& 4-j $ L Y I @I iiW LJJ+ iULIJ.J" O

r

k 9

dl

+

PlJl

&-J L Y I Pyl

dt $ df L+&

t;-?

-

d i jI -

,&I

I

.

JI

i,Lc jlk; . ; ; 10

dl

j iJj& ah

j+ cJ-I -

uc - YJ- L & “p (&j- &) +.I

OL

dill

j.2

3 dp

&Jl

.L,+ ~ Y G Y I

j,~

. ( ' t A ) ~ ~ J#

d! J@ L k 9r i+U j,ii J G Y I df Js

.~

b 1 j .J L Y I 2

;+Y\

j+d,l

&J\ ,y

i+lr

t, 4;t;k ,jLJ)rl

y&..ill

& &dl

&dl

o

h

dl

( \ f ~ *tJ&l )

J> +

&JI

+-2 j.Ll > &I$ .+I+

Jl

&% dl p

&.

i JZB

(a)

4

I& '

o$

a&lr

&

Sarter, The problem of Method, P. 153, Passim.

.Vo

- Tf

/ GoYUYI

+$

cjjL(\fA)

W

+, eJ&I

->AL L ~ Y I u i

&-+I l

'j +JJU

+

iy

JLI~

~

\~tr

a % ,

?C.IJ

Ikr sinnhafte Aufbou der sozialen c & b Y I

. \ f?.

i

+, 'L&

rWI

p

*I

\fry iy Jf,

& 41 welt

J44,

.&

&b

y

OgYI I L +Lh4I

rW l

o@Yl

&+

&A &

ij,+

b

Forgotten Man a d w l j,j+

G+,l

3 +I3 ,lLr

r'

.;I

dill > b Y I

j.

&I

5

j '&dl I L j J

o$

k.9

$+

b-+J $'3, &L,JI

.Lo&!

&$I_) rb

G+l

**

&I

Gbrp3.1

4 - j GJ J1 L q l 4 &+&j L& dlJ &dl ~ L Y I I4; dLh4i

&$I

i$s+Jl

+ +I4

,l L+y

$A

j

,lWI

+-j , 2 a i I,

ad13 '&I3

JI,.

J

a31211 l a d 4 1 $UI

. J P ~-9

4 qldl

,+&

dj+

*,+4

e

c . 9 J,&!

>W1

jt

Jrp

; . Jp, J-i j. + ' ,J,+&l dY+

J-Jl

j.

ilib

j$

e@JL

d,+L+Yl

L ' +13

>+Ij

j+

LYI & PI& SUE ikil JI

ci~: A J ~~ I + I Y Ijt a&_, & +$ W +t dr& 4; y . @ j .l&Jjl&L &+YI a l + Y l dl+ &&I qldl U Y l , aL;LWI J j ty>l 9, +$ lAJic j L W l Conrelate IjLi&b, IL

LI*

&,+

& !!.

&I

J:

'

'

I

'+ +I4

,lWl IL ,lWI I L &I>

. >L;rYI

I b

'

+&U

+I4

,I) L+ 1;1 G ~L +i - ~r {UI

IL

.

a

+,'21- s-d l f-r &dl b&, 3 1;1 &.& j f

-3

."">l+Yl

j +l+Yl

& ,..@I+,I-

qj! b

u!j9>1f-r

&, 2 , 1 6 2 I

dl

I+.+

.{WI I L

&+

p,

dI 'sWI

k1

i , r ~&

(L+j

'FliJl

d

p,

0-L

it+r j I~I~IJL j-; Jl I L JS

LUI

r,M

,lu i.LLdl - - &!,d,l

A. Schiitz *The social world and the theory of social Action* in

~ L Y .&>UI I (\tf)

Llirll

j r ~4L-AI J

+.d! &YI

&,I

f+!

$1

A,

& '@ & J W ~.>I;> + f1-4G*ll & & t>> lCLJ I IJA +I ~ I > L Y l a Y h LA^ '>dl, &I Curves at+^ LIJ> & ~ Y pl, I

+ ,*,

j,~ J,&~I

iUI

j

dl hi1 I-&-$ .qI..dl -+.!I,

i.~w~,byr ~ s+; @LYl

&I

~ Y I+I

> q ' I LL dl d > ,

U I JS I 4 4 13 LLL ~,L.>,L,

$

)MI

al,Cl

"&YI

+lJI

"+Yl

a d b Y I 3 i.'L,Lcc @A i . * )MI ,fL,

. YIJI . &>>

Y,

l

,+P

~

I

&

6 J I &I

a m

+?

2 jf

+*I

(&I

.&by!

A -

. & b y 1 ?I,Jl 'y ; d l JS j $53 ALa, .&I

& ~ I - & ~, I I&,.dl

+

$1

b .-rs%+

t

#

,kJ), i j b &L;! Y & b Y I & d l Social Life Y\ .k

)LI,

a

2, Idealization and Formalization

0 &Jl

I L - ~

3 , ~dlk;j $a+

i

;GI

l L~ IJ> ~

JS;. JGUI *&ill 241 lJA

;LLf dl

liA

p

Jj

a,& + b y 1 j LL; :'3f A &ill

j t L>-

d

L U ~~ W I ,

+L+YI 0bUI

dl d,~ dJi+,, c >> j li lib >;I,

G4

'iglJl a b U l

:JUI J l g l

dip,

0Ja

d+l+

,l

3

jLLlI &I

Y

L~xll, i,@I

6

& > ;

dl

world

JM1 4 4 1 , ,y >J+ Jl+Yl

iJL\ j>ldj> yaJ 4rJ Jl tr;~

&&

+I

&Jl

*j

&-L. -4 1 i,+I 3 &L;rYI dl L3>Is, ji .bGL?'I a&WI y kI9 @I

ii;

c.12

Braybrooke (editor) phtlosophidpr~blemsof the social sciences, PP. P

i

&l

&l.+YI

J\ t 5 j l

dl

)MI dl

I;C

4~

COS~OS

YOY

I

4

i>l>

&I

Ih, @I

,,,dl

;I&o/h ,

dkl

o p L ,

J\ +k

&.dl

ej, + > G I d>tpl!, Genesis

' ( L N L

A+by!

JI U

41 ,,

L Ih,

O G -

;Wl

&l -IJ+

.+ IS,

r&I

&I

.bil~13

&I&%I +-J

Y 47

d$-

;WL

,yi3 LIJ+

&dl &I

+df j$d y ~

&J

&I

41

;14

J-JI JWI

U l

c;I

jli?(

d~

(/+,I) LLB

Jji.b fl$Yl

LI~JIL iy&?,: 8+y f, $1; tWI I h i). -4 $91 & jf)&k+YI iy >L;;YI & scheme jlk; j Ibid., P. 57.

a&

+Id1 JaJI s z k , ;1! c;I,

Purity of method ($1

e,

c)a3

,iiL i;rb iJyt yI$

jalhll;ll

JI * L l

;c! a*cl j,li

&I

.&k+YI

i + J b +k+Yl

,.a, '++Jl,

I CUS

Ih

r;;;G, ( L W &&I) hlill ir;J4, # p ' p J I 69 +$I oUlL11+-

.('O.)ll_lr

t,

JUl -+&I

&du)u

dill +Wl

0-

lh &

~ ~ &l b~~tpl!, JUI ++I

CUS

6 9 ,

b Y l ;WI

.+ J ++I

k +;

J .J;U

J&

&& . p- ISL

' Y L N L ~ l d L[ l J

p a l Jrlill +4

L W

N+I&u

4ee4;; dI J,L +-, .oyL

Ih

q3f

1491 hf &

&I.

&

2 4 1 , &I

ci

& ~ Y I

;WI i). t W

A

(section

CLY

I !WI &J3ayJ

2

dl U 1

A+

jr

&Jl

L

I

dl

b

b

aw

j @&I' df dl> df Cljc

b 6 p r

41~JUI

&&IJ+

dl

01 $,I

4 4 , -y

+.+,

jL-1Js

d a k

~t &1& dt

&b

JUL,

dl a b d I j ~Lh,dlSubscripts ,aYJ.b

LpL

by1

2, &p91y

!+ ;$I bh;LI I& Jl& k b b&-aLi

fi dl &-%

ddl MI

tLl & Y, ..+W, ;&I3 UI >I :& p d,A fj,

1 U

J$,

4

.&WI

f, dlj* y

.(\a\).+

&+YI

!MI J! tflj4 df L! # dl ;+.I!

. &+YI

iyJ

L H L I kL*r9,.!b2kL

;r u,a! Y,

b+

drp~3 *JI

&

b&-$

kY. ~I;-JY~

9 +IJI +I +Jl

a

kl&

L,'&jl&I&L+YI pe @dl& b y 1 !WI

wy, LJ J& 41 ~s .Q , i+ b~~ -9 y-@dl+ @&I J a L A G ' , ; I 3 dl J&

CIP,

b+JI

Is3 ~J-&J!b k - ddl

j pr dl &

Y

!W!

4

j .dli,

b(*)#~jf

;r

J y '&a3 r&dl

; . d l WLL, ~ Y Y J+ &is,

9& b Y I

sf

!WI

.&Jldl&(Jy,y+&&4!,

I L dl

b~b,+

4f

O+

b$d\&d

+ ~ W ILI,

4 OJJ_~pkj !LrS t141 j ; .3 +jWIj al+13 +I3 &$I J% j . 3 . Ibid., P. 57.

&,a;4, (\"I)

Jb .&,

)MI I L 3 A-41, +&I

i+

+c

b'g-

*- + 2

SF-,\

@

Seb j. F i d3 - - Situation >ir i J h~ & d l +I JG -;&- +L-

d &iJ +I& k f dl -& ~ G G Y I 3-1 2 izh i b t 9b

& Y, +AIL

21l h

c~b+$

+*

O

b+-

. (ley) ~ -L ; -r bb; ~ h j ; LJ;I

+J

& ,lWI

I*

J

++2

'+!I 2

h

$4

+Ll,

JC.S

L

-Ub, 6 'di~t

& + p-

+Jb 3 - J

l

e +-

'&?y

,I +I k b

y d

,+$" , iyb I L

J. ,lWl I L (.GI ,I) ab+*

+I

+G

1

& ! & I G1J.L

J. iJ>b ;?iii

> - j-I

iAt JL~I >>,J ,I abF-

6 2y

d'l"

j $1

4 1

4

b;; ~ " " 3JJ+ pl,J+. - ,'JI 2 I-!,'y J! 'h 3Jls I.. L l * a b % j *JI &dl &+YI i+ 3 dr & ,I { L J ~j,., +A I + L-91, ~

,

M.. PP. 58 - 9.

&+

.L'J J-U &I

J W I 4 ' 3 ,lWI

+

3

&Si[

p , . 1 l C t j dl + 4-r i

Jl +l+YI

fli,

ri dl ,A $1

bWI

J: 'l& &.ill &YI

d p I4 Y I Tml il>I ,+I Y LL .l+$1 l. iiy

i3> ,I L%

d > ,

'&I;;

I;.J

.('")cG+!

e 1 A ,H .

'y

d+ JJI - d ., ~,;L?I # &;p i.! j,:

&I -

&,

p+Ij

+ & $+ & dl 4 l.+ &

.J-' 2

p+C,

2 l J +I

'#$I

L'

'y

&

-

-:

9 1

A, p U l Jl ww P I db1I.,+' IL

i&lAl

adY, e"4 ""; p + l

V

JY ,L

'&uJ

Intended act > a ,% !

JJ~

&A 'y e,lja

Jl,+

3;r;l

41 &B

Nj

&B

+3

in - Order - to Motive

.Terminus ad Quem

Terminus ad Quo a&

k .,+I ~

~ L Y I

..&I,>

ddl

2 c+l;f

l . I4

4

+!I

d&- @ &-Ij .&.ill ddC, d+>

-

&I

j;L3

212,

'$.ill

'y

LUGCyf ,I '+I

d l dLdl -LOLL

.Because motive dyl

8

A&\

Institntion

91 ,+ JI

JJI

'4

+l ,l

31 'bl~a4

Ju,

y4 'GL;I bWI JIL.;) 21JJI JIj- L Y I

+!Ia

4 1

d U I ,A

&dl

,A

212,

'$1

P I

;EU> '+I

; ; Ie 1 a d& JJI dl Complexes yFy d2, 'y L L 5 L, i J,YI d& ; ,&d .dY 21' d& d l

r?*L- jc &dl

wc

i !;I~

df

b~+ r,

t J ~ O Iji.;?

&JJ

.C

J

& J i-1L . . +IS

(bt;c~301LjG Y

dy

fiA .&> GI; jL! j

a$,

'J-"dt;, .I&,

'LY4

;GI

U j LLI jltll

(MI ~

ik;

i&lZ

jL kl;;U $1;

&IJp

d

J;I

+ d J:

c6;

'di

jLI

IL

JI

&> ,A,

3

'@$I rdIJ9+,l 'NextTirnea~UI;Jl~kb;J~~I ci,,

Ibid., PP. 59 - 60.

0-L:

ipU~ tjY,

@I

A,

d i p .&+YI

.,I -iil$l

J;J

iifi

.@ i n w . 3 LYI q ,, +&

e,

j

j4

91 & Y ~ + 9 1JWI

~,,lisaL-,>

L l l l dl uJY, .JLYI

haii+

,q

.&kdl

& JSUI

J .uilt> 3 j>I; ; I df

d l 3 > >L;I

YdI &UYI dL;l dS,

+WI

ib+

+-

IL

Jl 2 3 1 &

$L,Jl,

d/l dl tjXlI 3

a&l,

u?J

h dp! dl dJ3& 4 & I b ( j b A .GJ,4 bEl ,I & p. J4j JWII , dl '4Lj J I+.i +I 4,~JP,

4

JWl

s u

L

I

WI dr

'j..

L '

~ $ 1 i?;, &J ,41i i;io Typical i;k;ll 4 1 . ,

Jl LpHJ

+

i b ~chl;c :

O ,t>t

YL;YI JWYl ~j dl d S

t;4 Y,

.jlUl

; +~JI ci41

j idJ&.\, dl&\

J"&+djf~&'i~,fjlflij~yu..JS 1; 31 @I eb., JWI jj?w;rlkiLll+ . & G y > s j l ; & .dbj, ~ L L JS-4 t~j~, +JI, >>I, 'j.. ,I> &I1 cP & b Y I +1'I j 42Ja dl &-2 , $L2 . - 0

j bjjul &J Yc,.d;l U Y I Jl >]I c.&i Iil

sl$Yl~ dI .+L;YI Ibid., P. 60.

L

?Wl

s l j

91 ,+$d!

+I+l5

I?,

Y +kYl

$

. ' \ O O ' c ~ L S I dY,

91 ,A

Y, L+Y,I,

&

d b Y l i;L;YI

ikL;YI

/L!I jlh; j bl ti Y,i.

J L

2l,>

j ;ji;s 1i1 + i &LI & ($1

+p

r;i-Y,

JS

I+

&lie-

dl

1, 1dY1 21,~

.Typical Sameness c i J d l &YI

i i U l j +ill Prototype

p,

.dI.$l,

d U I 6J2l & d l FYI LYb

U

>J

.&

dfi-

l ,A +&I

2%

dr &I '&

J!

*PG

e+l

JU &YI LfJ

'++A &L;43Jull > 'U>> ldYl

&y

J ~ J I~1 r j

'991. SUI IU PUI

9% &

l&i+L;rYI Y G W ,

2l,> ,lz

+by\

$,!'

y?

iil

.

dl ?+I@I & Jl i$ , U ! , .&I!I$, 2 l >b,

'4I. lip

.2l,'d

- d l

$1;

2 ~ + CIJI IL dl,

LLLl

I$, el,> -.

"07 J ;4 '

di

$1

Sti

'+!I, I

JW 3 2pq4

&j

+ bl i &dl

&I$

4. + + i + ~ 2 ~ t + d y ~ ~ 4 , A dJ.5@ 4L &-& Lf &,

?L!I,

i-J4 J..+ +$I JLil dl >+l 'di 3 jLhi, .2+3J +,..A& 2 9 Y l ,JLilel Jk y A & Fd L+ 293 u ,>* i~ $91 w I , .g++I J

a.+

,

LA di ~ j .L , i % j S ~JW~, J W ~ JU A+

kri

J! ' G U l ~ l = k y l , dK+ 3I

$

Ibid., PP. 61 Ibid., P. 63.

- 2.

I

,

l

+I>& I

,'93J . +Ij,

pU4l A 4 4 pbl+dS,

+ fly

$1

6-41

ldYl (yl,+,

Jc

I L

&I

d++-

' + ~ L o * t j s ~ ~ d , + ~ ~ ~ ~ u .+GI ~ > L o , ' b6 A$I

pN

6 b - U

.p

'& & ,l

jlbyl &I>

fJl I

I &.d d&-

~ J &I I

-

4 1 1.b 31 & 291 " > ~ k&I$., . J 9 4 +J di;? 6 3 4 1

r&il

ryZ /L j.

3L; ';ELkll

iJdl w l & &LA PGIJI pI+l 0.b $l p+Jl &I

*

OGI ,y &I

&%I

+ JrJ

;E: dLjS &J

b 2

>+ dl JL ,+ 9 4

4 $, JjUI $ + k Y I

I& '+

o b .

di,

d . l, . GL;,

&ldJ

+,

4

dl J,L~

MI

b Y I )WI j J Co - Actors jlSJLtll

(rdUI d4 ,I

*G,

4

# 'ji

'++I

. # b y 1 )ul

'ili~~~ ++YI ~ U W IjI +

JC.l~j LI,L~,Y,

'41JLiI >J,

j?+

'41

2ljJ J>+I ,L;i*

js JLiY

Jjl &I

&L-&w,+i. A 4 '$51, aLJ crJ.J-L;Il, &+I ,AS a& Lo $ , .J L j f - . + Jc &-r L i t > : # b Y I {WI '&la ,+ lil '02 y 3%xl S1.L

.$YI

ry+ Y

' p L ; r Y I )W

J+)+&,

2;

'+I

J i ; ! , 4

3.iA

rx id 8 y ' " I

@

;;L, & S; )W &Vl

+IJ

44 ;ti?

&LS

6JI

JrJ !h;i

t+ d,l +Jl

&I &%I

"pL;rYI

Jr

+A!

)WI

'>+i&bd~jS

&%k /&I &I Jr, .&IS Aloofness pL,& dl Jr .*I 2l,>

+-dlJ

'@

~ ! d " ! " - . ' y ~ ~ ~ ~ & - y & \ J ~ j ) l ~ , & y

j J LUl

t W l jU;

J dr I, . ~ W IL I

twq

+Ul

dlJL,;jY

,+wI GI+

&LA')'!

kH

I

U ;I

JJ~JI

;C

JJI

'+g.JI

/L

& b Y l +I

C""J

41 +[1q

d J p j bki- , I

.&by1

- j;

--L;

"A91 4;

&JJ L ~ " A Y I

+I

b*,

@

Y L+

'y

&t

1

Liil +. + .,.LA

a d & L N G &I

a b l ,

&&YI

+JJI

.

9,

0%

Jy pkj' Conceptual

& J&

ji-J .++$I

.+.J&* a;,

r;" 'y 02j?-! L L J I

Y Y G G&J

91 GL+

31-

dJA4

2 @= #

J ~kH~ $1 ! I+ Y rua @ c_

'&.dl ./k -3

J 3 U \

.+ I,& (1h-Liy 91 d"l

iJfi i& LJs .

@ ,

l

dl J 2 Capacity +fll

r h l l OL jtt .+YI

,lWI

W

I L

o

h

3

-9,

.tL3 w w dl bLSz;/ iJkf, ' L A 9 & Puppets d~ +IF 6 51 A+ .('OY),,+liLI Vls LlLI t L l J, UAYII L 4 @ L+ J, & b y 1 t W l &I> +A A> ,! +I &JL% (; .&>\+I hi 'j '&LYl - 6 L W iJ+ '+Is elt>&, " ; " J ~ j y l0 L & Co - Ordinate ii,UI Jj + J, i ~ c t o r$2

.&A

i , @I

&b

3-J

(+

d&

&,b-

r:

.+I,

Ibid., PP. 63 - 5 .

JJI

$6

Ly

u

&

,I)

,I)

J.b

&ld

Y

*

+ +dI

>*- + a$),

3

Model ci$ 6o l p

3

JLjYl

sldfl)

54 A, .&, +, ~ l hi s #

>,s &,

+J~jl

&%I

j .d ~ = W Al JUI U

Lib, @-I

+JI

.&.dl + U l

a w l ,

Id

(

+

J

I i6rJ

+I

&JI SJI +b JS +.&

I

,

b&

+Ul &d d& li &!I bLi,JJI, e l J d l +I*," i-&A d

d3J qu

t,li"

J d I

- +Ul

+lS

U

+@

& J.d

bL;LI

j .

d&YI !!.& ,I-

&;$I

JU1 U I J, J& &li L J,, ./I

4

i A .+ \ J l

Jrpj. tl+I

JL,.!I . &,.!I

+

&-.dl r1.Y bdloT;yYI

.&& d L I ,

iti ~ + J I I L *2

%ddt J, +dl

G,.Ll.&

'p

.&I

JS &+

LU

kJe.t

4 i d r l j ;>IS! ,I &>u &J$ j .Jul

&>U+i b U l + I d 1 j .dd;,

e-

(IWI j

dL+Yl

&I aI>lj.

(,&>

LGYI o h j .+I

ZfiI

,I Gj J l&+I. ,.MI3

&Yl

GL-

l I L J,

- -

(IWl j Jil,Jl

+W

+IJl

JUI ke;U Specious

4 . &JI - J,dI &;> d l &I .rjl k, . ' & d l J.dl & ,r ol+ >& J $\-i!?, G*J\ +WI dp b w GLI -9 G>; G-i" d l >&YI (IWI j +UI J, lL J, U l dt

$21

pWIJ #

~

I

&.!I

dr L b

Y dp&YI i+G

&>UI J@lJ b

+JFrWLi

~ y ~p I

Gl+IkJJ-,

Ji:

U

&

"~~bnr

.

j .I

jlJ A'.+

4."""

- 6.

LC b

t,

d

-+i

j.upSJ+I.df+

.(\o~)J,YI

Ibid.. PP. 65

&&.i&k 9 1dl&,

I

+ bjr;

b i * p y

ibl;s~ l++ .il&I

~LSJ. > ~irj is 3t

(\Oh)

i

o

k d Ljgl bJJlj

h

L.%*

&-+

s&~Ul

j >LI AdJ /WI j GXilll 3 3 JLj U I I b l i Y l

t(*)&+YI

:8 ~IJJLP. eJI

c'J

kJ&s;;I

+I

&dl &-dl

b

:LbLYl i J a b - \ 3 llslll d l L Y b k @ kp dbY\ .ibMI iJUI bUYl kp 4lb; j

bw

&

I

iul /lr jlb; j &$I

j- L i Y6 l

;,I

4+

++

Y .&dl ;r'.&Jl

p

dl)& & d,

j

.Adequacy iiwl G a b

C~J. dl

3uJI JL

&dl+I

J,

ci; JCWI 6.1

&I

&li&I3

63)

i,.+, Jjiu

.;@I j 4LJ

&!'A1bUYl j j rljrll +*,

dj $dl

-Y

j i ; !

>

6 y J

jLYI i j a b

-r

'43'4

31

y y dl - A

+I

@- dl a G l y i Y l J, +A

.

by j L

&L*

4

+.!I

iul /lr 9 ,>IJl

c.rli Gli-l JAG

Ljgl diL;JI

u

t J I

-f

I

J,

+ .ltJ,

j i ; ;

&ljaLPLI

&+YI

b- -2 4 ~/bb

,I $141 i J a b UII k 5 ' 1 j jGfi

(Compatibility & I 1

a

h

jL:

+i

/WI y + b Y I

&u\ 4 &, .

b&

rJJI

b-dl

3 L Y,

b+ -

P. Bandyopadhyay, *One sociology or Many* in socioogical Review, P. 28. Rationality in the Social :3 1 9

d

Economics

j \ 1f t y L

4

( \ 01)

d $ (*)

World Ibid.. P. 67.

(I7')

241 2

9

j Jyp . a .a,I

+

, + d l JLdYI 2

;f. protenstion

~ j ra l w l h l " 'aYl"i;YI ~

.

+&

'k&I

+$b

Jyp

Retention 'l+YIJ

: J L+b

'bL$b &Id1

j +)p.j,L

qj;+I+

,,dl

3 >a,.&

bL$\ Tension

L-3+,5) dL

vJtij-

ISJ

-.

LJ,

IIII;; 31 bJ>

I Sd

s. JJ

-1

d

Y,

dl

.i+ LI+ 4 ;bll,

I

&+

Y 2 I Z l j l A,,

I;E

Znanieki a &L>I

&Jyu,J1

I

6dJI

Reliving

+%I

+I

j "&VI

y l J,L

eyu

j,W,,.

.&,

ps

d+L)

@A

.4;&b 14

cSyfll

I L &I+

FJJ

($1,

t

61 '1 tLs;Yl, I J u Vicarious Experience LLYL ;&I 2 .srlr%YI

L$

j.

#

csl&d

I;i Humanistic coefficient

A&+

+L)l\ j l

a

jr &I

el&

&A+

4 1

jAi+a\~~.jj++,,y~~,

* t+

&I

uj @ '&,

<L\+

cj6. I;>&b lil

I

&

'GLJ.I

.+L'$ i9UiJ1 + A ,

l

,

,r 41 IL

+ d j i - b j #,+dl) Reproduction - Nachbilder ' U\ leben, L

j

.4;&&L

Y,

dl J$ df

j.

6 a y b 1

b A,J

41 I L

31;

WJLIA~ c'j

Nacher- 31+13

& &I

w - kl>,

&

&U&B + *

a&.L)rl

elzJ\ i>L~lai & ~ 3 Maciver L 3 1 & Sorokin $ - reconstruction

Imaginative (+GI

+.+ b ?l&l

( \ " ) ~ o ~ i c -o Meaningful Method ,&L

motional Syllogism ->UI $lh;

b &

adL&YI

wl 2 ILL~I;i - a+-

& ~ L IJ ~ l $ l d+LJl

p 2 6.3 b &I j9 al&I & ~ ;)p 1<A!i ;),a 4 1\h& I&LCF dl&\

L3 & i l l

JilIIl

T. Abel. Op. Cit., P. 678. Ibid.. P. 84.

&&

J 4 l &I

eLdl IL Jj i W I Jj

j lj

+-

dK b

lip

p U l

bGJY&

O

h

& &I>

LA--

p U l ,pi JI4 1j+dl & LA,

af 'jA

>c$*

" i l l

"iJY"'

'

L,j da L 14

I+

+ d l lib,

1 A&l

_-

& J$

s2

+Ii&

& & +L

eJ

'$1

++I

. ~ L +A I

jJI a w l

4 J.3

&I

'*I

,ll+l

I

& L>'& +

.(\7r)ai+x

+!>I

U

& .GL;~LJL+-;,I+ Y+d,'iJ+l,

Maxims .&>I+,I >L, Abel

+

.+lJl,

JA

..

LLhi ++ t&L, ! 'JUI L lib .&I&& IJ u,+,

LIF

SjK

'jA

jb,j&c W i l , $ Q Y l + p J . 3 ~ l & i i y y

p-31 C;1Z p .$

aIc+AI

a1 b,,L

j . t+y

Ibid., PP. 684 - 7.

Ci+

L I J d +%YI

4 4$3,

Ibid., P. 680.

'jA

> ' ,$I

L -4)i dl ~ &IJl

p, j

J&

'\"'k'is[,

Y J.41 L

j al,+YI

ar & .

* *

-

M. Farber toward Naturalistic philosoply of experience in Diogcnea, 1%7. 60. p. 118.

(\I0)

(\'I)

Ibid., P. 115.

. >Ul+' !I Hussarl, Ideas, P. 225.

'y +I

,&I:

d,< ( \ TV) ( \ 'A]

YVY

l&&a > J . ~+;.pyJll q&YI

A,

,-L;il

9 JY ,I

structuralism 1 i . 1 )

jw1, J1

',I$

-4 6J.I 4 1 , ++I A

.

-+$

Jr 6Ul ~ $w 4 t iY,L-f

-JA..dIJ, .~;.JY

Eid!, Sociometry

e, yj L.

Lpb+

&

r_1-+Y!,

Gj.~y)

df

b h . 9 dL71 L&L.

&,

ipUl CU;

il,,d

&& df d > ,

(&,l+)

ci; l'..JLil

aLi%

+,p &-+J j2

+

L

j > Y l *L+II &

r$

&+ I,

Lli LG

J

+ dl

3 4 14 3 1kt! ++PY A,($-J+Yl d 4 ) t L ; r Y I

-141

o

&SJYI 4 1 ,.,.ALrf f;! ,.&L;YI aI,,Lr;Y U dl5 b ,,J+ dlLi .-UI LK, $4

&L;YI,

&

urt;( &,I+

+,,Y

+

~ dYbf

j &L.A,!

fi

~ ; 4&i ,s,, .(\)&YI,

e*

4.

j, #-ul ~ l .(')i_leWI b ~ iJI+YI l ~

b

+f bLPoU\ GUY1 -ill

&L,I y&I,

#

,,ldl, +4I jr 4+ bt+l j U I J j;WI +.d! &L

&&YI

*I

dl

b

&I

j& U i .J&l 9, 6 o & U

J-&b

df

b4wl,

1 . j

ill -41

.&,,I

&dl

*--

df LiilJl O Y

wb

c- (CC $

d j b

'y o h -

& 4 1> u l & b W

&el$13

& &kk!l &W I , i;?&\ 2j df 4 1 , bGY1, w l ,

J&

&@I3

&,N?r &$llj l ? l bl& p i p U l R&I>D& &>

Lu'?,

&.&l .&&dl, +I jW t l l '+,,kJl

i;L;Yl

++Jl

W .hb,

4 , '

djlj,

*-A,

'js

&dl &$I

+I

aI,,,ls

i&ill

iddl

aA-4 ,1-

&I$ i$&4

&

,A, , , *

+ iLo & .\dy.bL, P,,Uf

CLGYI B

a,& .+ .

plfll,

'y

0%

Field

b

&-31

+iJ+I

JU1a&&d&

'y

j K A,

df d , ~G ~ I dJ

J. Piaget, k Structuralisme, P. 93.

l (')

b

J. Moreno, The Sociometry Reader, edited by j. Moreno et al, P. Xn.

(v

2 '3JS

'$2 FYI j GI$

+b U I 3 + J&L ,I j U d J q I (Y)

4, . j y j~ \ j j Y I JXi j .~4 /&I +I, Jib! ,t)

2% dill Frame or reference (iJkyI

I&)Jj

&dill' g;-xI

jc

pl@I

Lij

4yLI

Jlb')'&~G

tpjI

+A&I,

.&I

I

&%I

&&dl , $

. t+Jl 'j &%I ,I j13! Jl LWI j L Y l

+A

j L y l 2 dl &1,iJIj 'd2Ulj /l$-I d+ ( t ) I, aliW1, '<@I I . , . & /&I lpj jc +JI &+ fLG *+I +1?~ .+ &G iJLj ,As 3 +SY $ 9 j-11, .& &I 391

*,

9 J 'WI dj

;js di-Yc,

1

3 (s$1

b

+- ill t+I

9 ++I

Jh- & 'al;'lUI A,+

$31 A J S 3%

-

'j ,1$

'aIbJ1

+

.&I

&\dl j . G ~ J I Icik j .&i$

&15=211 blG ,

dj?l &Lid\

5 4 1

&+YI

'LJUI,

JI L+

piYJ &&I1 & iiWl &jL D I J1+ b( &>

a1-+J1 LrJF

Y al;'lUl

&I2

o L&

+_I, $5

iiLbl

; L &

aLWI

G J u \ && bI $dl iiAl & iiWl j GI;,

-

'JS

d,.dI

2 bK (*) tcj&IJ

;r &;ti

DL ~ L ; ~ Y I~fldl,

2% dill &I -

aLWI

4G4.J

J-?j

+

hb j91 'JS /F 4, . ~ ~ j j42 J+ 1 )

.&J>-+YI

-+ ~ ~ J241 l j & Djl$I ;2L! +JI 21~1 + ~ U I , J >/lrl~>91 + u LLJI FJ~S &jL jL I d, . &j'AI, @I iYA 3 @+$I >*j.Il +I G$ 31

cU> JI,

+,.J++YII 9,

& ZjIjAl iiWl L l j J &I j.

&.

-j .

dl> L C

Jk

,I

'j

+ L 4 JI

641 j .

3

blS &jL

441

iiWl LJSL A,

),

bl &I

3 b & j I dl & k @I,

*I

.\At1 tGUYl

0~41, 241

JSS

.+b

d J 1&L

$,

&JUI Jk

4

&I

$1

441

&-Y

p4u

j , l ,

[&by( S ~ ! D dl +!I h &$ I, IL .d h, *rt; 41 Models +.dL J yj;ll

U I

JlLLJ y+

& b Y l

3,

&dl &L

oUXJli

U

l

Ab, & a ,

A5 2lJL

&d

oliXJI, & b Y l

s

~

l

P ,J

-&dl l rUI l . , l>

Jr .

LGrJ

d& 41 ciLdl l+ pd

dl

&+Yl

aUXJl

LI*, LA f r Y @..dFYL 4 . & 'j J,I*

J+

+ Jl d l j ~ ,Il

.qLi k Y l

$2 $S

i;. j.J

.;CU

y j

oLIJdl 'j &PI dJJdI A

'y

Y &dl

eiJ

tj

. ("r+I

& 'y *LL

Jr 'y

b>

C. Levi - strouss, structural Anthropology, penguin University Books, 1972, P. 279.(1)

YA

&+>.-

eiul

3

jlJkll

I

&

+Ja

++ .

& d&-

&i--', % & -I cil&lI

. &- d l

@-

-

i b

h

3

# d l I

j[r J j

,JAB

&

.

@ L .,A

4;lyLI

b>-41b&

2141 r X U I

i>b3JUI

b

+ a!

h

ibIJI +WI ~5&Lh4I dJLj

GGL' rIbl

JG

+I Jld+

SL

LJ> &+I, .*I pJI

k J 1 3

l+

L% .--+I

3 &9

e*bJ 1

d l dcls)'l

3 L+

b

h

Jy 'iy; 3

k>>, ,jd+YI

6,u.d

i;i; >, I-

& +lJI

h

+,+I

&J

I d tj& aL

b

&dl +I

r b +-

L h E>> r+- dy .i+@ , I 3JLs Jl &I =IL_14 U I aL.ltiUI jr

ci u l 2jb.d Jl&.&, l j K Ulb L j Y

ciLill

Lk,

=kp.2 &I 2~~~ ~~I~ & +Wl 'IE! cil&lI o

&@

d

& 6 4 1 Al f,

6-

dlJ&

' J & J l * A 2 J-j

+UI J+

&I +l;r;,YI i&5

d

;: Y,

&dl

. ("'&+YI y

Jj

$

+I cc

jI

s13YI & Y, .dY>, k9 6 + p f l # b! JA

@ &I

a%&

-LY) Neumann rjIrS; j3r

3Jk d&

. . .a -~JI

'y

e q I

a l i Constructs i+)

214

.+

&-:b+b &%I

games ( d J U l

+'y

df

y, L (4 ,7i&l

L+

-

9 3

f

b?,

ei+

dt

:WE, bLw

l LIP1pll $ij

U

3 ;-s!

+; ("'a*

6 - b

$

I

e-d l Transformations ay&I

ic*

(j.

@

e+;/ l& ll.;

--,

L+

Ibid., PP. 279 - 280.

(V)

J . Von Neumannand Morgenstern, Theory of

(A)

Games and Economic Behavior, Quated in: Ibid., P. 316.

df

> &I.;/ JI

E ;+ ,

4

+

+

-LYI

i=;qI aLI,JJl

'y

o

i&Ub

pf

~

f

J

OL

JS

dc; I

+

4, '(3flJl 4'1 WI O + t UJ j L$ df f-Z irLJJlj4

b

l&.u

j $5

+,+

JIP2 & i& L I Li U I f fk Li cI

L4,

df

kJ LUVcp ,bb,

dfi

df

& dill I. JS

6

s

l i b dl; df

I

dl

.&+I yl+ll+

ci$ &f b+

c+,

'y

jf

d l-.& .

&J$Yl -I;

>% ,I ,!

JJYI 4 1bp

f q l 25 df

>lJl

~

+

J 'yI ; I . 1

I

i

3

+y,

L3a d&

i~

+ J I

(1.)

'y

1 &

f -J

J.43

'+

Ji&I

lh & > I, ~~;?IJ&JI&.L&JI

- -

f

'y

.*e b&

elk14 jUl &I

Boas &I2 ; & G ~ I L j. j~ k d 5 b d

&J ,l

+L. $ L S ,

, ,a

.(')~l+Il

'True a & l . d I ~

c?;i 2

-44 i&UI

% L

I .JJfJ

6-c

91 b ' +,

JbYl

s3.-J+l

ii%A b df 9& l

I.9 EiI;II '+I lh d&-

@

2 l&

&= j~

'y

'k &

.j 9 1 ! 'y tj ~ q b ) @% 4 JS &, d+) p 4 @%

YJ,

.(;y

J5

I h

o

J$

D

+-Ul

e ~d , &%I j* Y I.,A dq + ,+ G~

W

a s k

a

&,dl,

&%

I

I

o

I.- J ? ;,

df A & ,

&L 3 d l L y LPf,

.&I,

cUl d r l & , , fliJl 'y

h

ajjJI

42c

.(\\)&#-,I b&

kl,

Ly+i Ji4i

bid.. P. 280. bid.. P. 281.

F. Boas. (ed) Handbook of M c a n Indian languages

YAY

>+

A L, . 4 j~ S Y I IL j5 j t a3, LI,Y,I LI, di;? '& + pl$l j. ki r+- Y i t g +.A J j j-

iL

dt

I+-.*

j. +I

i~l. d+

I&

)

%J

GJL

$3

rlj

j,+dl j .tj ** 41 '+yl ciL;II dY dl4

dt

$'1

L

i+ c i E

r1;?1 I L L&

-q

- &p

'norm WL.)

sg\& k d \ qh .u & PI$! "LI, &> 2y1+I d~ p i t d, i+

4

&Jl

1

.GI41 ,y > j

'$ 4+

-4

G\J\iflb.!!

- dJl&JJ

>+

EikJ!

- $Jz3$Y1

$3 dill i t

c)TJJ,$Yl

d l

&

dl GLJI @lit dl +'

+LW

+

&

bfl Jk ..?I

+ di;?

-b

ty.l2,

dill g

,k-k

+ I ~ J

Li$ + dt

A:)

b b p y l ,y g , '&dl g ciil4l j .~ $ 1 IL, 'GUI

j l ~ J& l 4 iiWl b;ii

S k y 1

d l

+

cJYl

j .

41 JUl I. .y.Lt

9% ciiJl,

41 cikJI y ').k p '*j.f&I

,y dl

$dl

eJ3.&+I + ,y pIJall &

& 'b31+ r& cikJI o L c.+ 31 ' J i2 y.31s avw~j .ii4b at eyli . +LJI ~s ILL y~~j+.I& k &A.sLk l J jIJJ EiU ctb Li ti$\+!\, cikJ! L I J 3 3 dl b q \ r, & .bJ23$Y~ I

3

*-

@X* ciLr)l

k.J

o

. ~ p u d !*&

+

h

i;- JiG .Home - Made c&l

4 J-YI

Theoreticians ~r,&

P. 67. quated in: Ibid, PP. 280 -

YAY'

1.

&

fS

i i l ~ 'J-SJ

MI,

$YI

&

3~ 'y\ 2

AI

&Ul,

C

+*ij4

U

jy+ .QI

L

I d

JI~VI

l

J

jvl J&JI

. ("I(\

cQi

M LJJ+

+I

3 eUI

+I

+-i+lp9 1 &f

set theory k r S 1

rJL- @ iI>gl

LJa

&+ I,

dl

' P ~ Y I .QI $ii

s&jl

/ljJJ

c;rl>Ja

jqql

+I

+>lc

+IJ>

> k Y I j . I;*d

p

J YL

J!

cy-

a L l > d l i .&&dl,

dIal+L,Jl~

Li' '&&dl

lLCk&;jJ4

[bid., PP. 281

- 2.

Loc. cit.

>+I

j &dl ;lL.+LJ! -1 +I+, JL ji&Cll L>LJ1 &I C)j a Y C f j '$dl 6 b,J2,.hJkllJ 'Groups L A 1 & &,

.('"&I

[bid., P. 283.

$L$ >*I

>-lbl~

f *) GUI

+-l+YI

~easure

j &GI

Invariant ;+%!I

ilP 41 >-

+ ++I

j .pi

~,~I.Y;, I

+, G L J I

3

31

@

rJu

. +-L;IYI

&+ I,

pi

&I

dd

y L+&

Kroeber

u iJUI

jG

I

&I aYl;J.l, 9)

'& U L &+ I,

I

&ti+&

J.+

i.J- rjY '$1 JI J&YI

&Qd

&Ja3brJl&AI-J (\y) (\y)

cjl-~ i j W l Jj &+ I,

kj

9 d- l & - i+Yl

LG

( 2f

I

i , i Lc;l '$dl

'C~,.AI Scale (jlk; ,f)

& ,

C

Gti .L&& +& jlkZ +I+!

'y

d,& &-

Js

'd-3 &+-

t,

'$dl

'y

,J;u

pI+l

Js

&iJl &,dl,

> & oypb d$ \;;IS b

aflb

J,ab d,>l

.sJUl I d

& .L><>, i

+ . q i Cjli

,I +19

C'I )" d dL ,c

-

..L, ;'+I

ciJ.14

,+%I

&,>l

kL.i'y d,k 2

+,

ab+L.II ,IAL,

G W I @I >~

Fi,.dl

ki,i,

2

4 +>

dl

J_; p b GW(+

'4+Ll>

oypb d,c

& L'+

ej+ll I L J . L u d I @I ' d L j 4 l l+J! LjWI, iJ,YI

+b . a l > s 3 di J! b,

L&I

h

. a j b y l ci,.Al~ aL+tl

g df & +\+I1

@

o

&*

.Mechanical

pL2 Cili & I 9 1 &-'y

4

Gf

ii&I

Y

+

a i U I (wi +bYI

Fluidity

/ ),!ril

df l A

w y

A+gpIl

++,.A\ dL cjl-~ dK kj, .("')&bl Eiy+ L df .I~ ' i j J d l a&>\ +Adi ci,i lA d l a w l J J&l p ~ b 2 i f ++9r +3 . LUI &JJ j ~ bE ! i , i -2 - Ji + jb! JT GlA CiU r,& .

jy

Js

+,

6

6

.& &+YI

d>- df

I

Ibid., P. 384.

YhO

+yJki,

Ju, 91 L&, L j p l l &I+& 'CiE +YI dt 9 & 2 Structuralist & d l b U l Lgt, .L y p L

+ ! I aLIJ> Js jlh? b d! d i 5

2 &

Js

t

'l,+ I- p-

'y b*,

d

a

' U ~ U e(3l J ~

L

J

Lac. Cit.

OLc . & L i ! , j &51 t~~

i&lj;YI

I L+i91,hll

G

h

'JUI dl+

;GI ,A,

-d@l

.&

'&I

E-Lzll

j

.'""F lbtll

LEY 'J+

$41 p?JJ

Ibid.

(\"I

Ibid,, P. 285.

(\A)

Loc.Cit.

-

WI

'

Lk. +L?l

(\f)

abL+lJ

&I,

&*I

&

&,I+

J3

Q13$Yl

z,f

(*),.

j .& &y

t b Y I

+, YJk;S,I,!

&-k 'qi ciu .c;l J! Y,I q+ 3 cik Jl t b y l ,& (t , ;*rull+4

(J+

.j,& diWI

%

1

,I) ~jdf

& 1

& FYI,

' 4 1

y &LI&, . M I

rll;L

2 ciLdl

& 2

&+I

I

I

~,YI $s

&%I

+y

-:

&,

Ij,s

3

+

L y) &jUI

&jk

&lJ!

'$6,

MI

j+

++I

:GJ

d

dp

J!

' q b j r+I

&jYI

dill c j ~ d b!k c ; b

Eil-U &Jjl, G b Y I & GI'DL >jJL;II ab3j $1'

I

,

I

I

'iy

,

& i;;L;I rJs

:JUl +I

eik, +) &X. : &jUI k J * ~ j i Y l 'qi ciu, G) &x. : Q I ~ , S Y I 'L.LI ciu L l S IiU LJJi U .(")&Ji eiLi3 &jiL% :b & Y l rJAS I I L I '+L+YI r+I & Ji-UUIIL L j rli;j k+S!jj;YLi . ~ L $3 I & &j - exYI j;j . &I j > dLj 41 'Reversible + - i , * , t ~ ~ l J b 41 ~ ~ J K I ~ ~ L jG UI ~+3 * ~ Y-$L qUI i+dI ~ Y + I y JJG dL by j l S I,IY , ' $.!.I\ ,& 6 iJk-j

: t&YI

J

0

-

#

o j L

L

&

&jUI

LM il41

b!

> .&b3

41-1J+L

e Y !

31 A+

Jl e2YI

dm,, .++

WI y Q

~-

L

2125' l+13,3Yl dl& r J k s k,l,3Yl LI . d I C L + l & ' L O I ~ I j *-I, ~ + I ~ & Y I 1 6 jji ~ (;. L Lji b,l$Y~ LO1 I , + U l + b Y I b,lz,pYb G A L , +YI h l 4 l j~ i $ .W u liJwk J $ Y I ,y, .r;,Ul

Cf. Ibid., PP. 2 - 3. Ib~d.,PP. 285 - 6 .

(Y.1

+

& Firth A>

w,

Zpdl

&

'$L$I

rt) j J& IJ ;r

&>"I

df tjt

3

(SJI -

~

)

?ji lA

+?

.i;Ixl

&JJI

ky

JLJJ

tel&lr

LL~+\JIB

j .Ei ~ +

+i +f +I

+-dl

j .

LE ~

o-i*

L>AI

J% 3

~ $ 'j4 1 df & Y,

+>3.;+ j (kj'4IpLJI J;JJ yi c i ~2 ~3 j W Typology L dl &u $15>J+ &.& &,La

'5JyrJIJ

>Lj:

,

,4WI df

tj~h

bqI

L u r;l

J%J6 +J&l

4 1 4 >#I Y

jLjll

reenters &Li_Lj

h

&dl

a>r/Lj-

~ - k &b .

il;;~ .White

r 4

&>L;

o

#

+.tf

-I

LLL;r,l & iLiul

O

h J+

lzY i

'j4

& & L U blif j

/X;s& ILL

L ;'

i;l-, y W

ii,

y-+

dl

5 3

l+

-

0

U G & &,

i;Lik p b Genes '(?Loll cili a&

.(*)LA i;LLolj runs

'4%

j tk; & dlS lii tc-Ixn ;t.,b

r-Hj. J h ! i r b Y Y;. k, J,

dr

+ ,I+

&.&I

'491

1 &p -rIr L 'J,Ml J +I ~ + ~~ l l ~&t &I j.d ( LI, ~ y b y l ci:JW~ J1+1 & !,&I, +l

gi cili rl*ijl

$ 5

, u p ; lp*i;!

+

cijLil&

L bZPb j&

Jk, Combinations k h l j 2

. '"'dL$!'

&

4j

&A1

>rh,- & a

41LI~JI

J+

+p $ L 14 ~4 $WI 5 4 4

$

,,

i ~ l

ill.& *Uu

2 &A 3& J3 k-dl & YJ Li, jL$I shin n+,c dl d b Y ~ ~ W I o

t

,y L , iyi

31 c

1 4 1$-!I

h

~

~

n

&+ I,

d,.+&!l =&!I

.b+

>JUJ

.k p>w

l l ;s,Y, , i k j u J l dl; ' 4 - s J& GY\ j; jls; G21 j; Vecto- +y &b J b I j .& % '&\>I I L jb L lil; t & Q

&,'

.

J+.!I

91 &+ +YI

f

$

& 49.3,

k,JY.,,t;YI

dl+

JY ,l

i

4 rial Factor

--