Total financial liability: Hoboken Fire and Police Departments by Perry Klaussen

As of 12/30/08

Total Liability of comp, comp vacation and terminal leave: HFD & HPD

$15,950,714 15 950 714

Official 2008/09 Budget lists total accrued vacation liability as $9.3MM $9 3MM and total terminal leave liability as $7.4MM $7 4MM for a total of $16.7MM. $16 7MM $16.7 $16 7 - $15.9 $15 9 = $744K. $744K Some documents doc ments list the number n mbe of uniform nifo m firefighters fi efighte s as 92 yet et the detailed document doc ment with ith firefighter, fi efighte date of hi hire, e acc accrued ed vacation acation and terminal te minal pa pay onl only listed 86 fi firefighters. efighte s I attribute the $744K to this lack of reconciliation between official documents acquired via the OPRA process. This is a 4.5% discrepancy. These incomes do NOT include overtime. overtime

Rank Actiing Fire Chief B tt li Battalion Chi Chieff Battalion Chief Battalion Chief B tt li Battalion Chi Chieff Battalion Chief Battalion Chief B tt li Battalion Chi Chieff Battalion Chief Battalion Chief Fi M Fire Marshall h ll Captain Captain C pt i Captain Captain Captain C pt i Captain Captain Captain C pt i Captain Captain Captain C pt i Captain Captain Captain C pt i Captain Captain Captain C pt i Captain Captain Captain C pt i Captain Captain Captain C pt i Captain Captain Captain

31 30 27 29 23 20 27 27 23 20 23 29 23 20 23 23 23 20 20 12 23 23 23 23 20 20 20 23 23 20 12 23 23 20 12 12 12

Accrued Termin Promotion P omotion to Yrs Y s at Vacatio C Current ent $ al Pay Pa Current Rank Rank n Value Days Terminal Pay value Salary 10/28/1992 16 185,000 185 000 243 166 500 166,500 155 106 204 106,204 11/25/1998 10 154 781 154,781 199 114 079 114,079 150 85,989 85 989 11/25/1998 10 154,781 243 139,303 135 77,391 12/19/2002 6 154 781 154,781 218 124 971 124,971 145 83 123 83,123 12/19/2002 6 152 157 152,157 152 85,659 85 659 115 64 808 64,808 4/5/2005 3 146,910 99 53,867 100 54,411 2/20/2008 10 mos. mos 137 695 137,695 229 116 786 116,786 135 68 848 68,848 2/20/2008 10 mos. 137 695 137,695 139 70 887 70,887 135 68 848 68,848 2/20/2008 10 mos. 134,194 134 66,600 115 57,157 2/20/2008 10 mos. mos 130 694 130,694 256 123 917 123,917 100 48 405 48,405 9/12/1995 13 139,662 139,662 221 114,316 114,316 115 59,486 59,486 1/6/1989 19 127,954 242 114,685 145 68,716 5/22/1997 11 125 786 125,786 55 25 623 25,623 115 53 576 53,576 5/22/1997 11 121,448 121,448 176 79,166 79,166 100 44,981 44,981 12/19/2002 6 123,617 84 38,459 115 52,652 Union Rep 12/19/2002 6 123 617 123,617 10 4 578 4,578 115 52 652 52,652 12/19/2002 6 123,617 123,617 208 95,231 95,231 115 52,652 52,652 12/19/2002 6 121,448 245 110,203 100 44,981 12/19/2002 6 121 448 121,448 17 7 647 7,647 100 44 981 44,981 12/19/2002 6 117,111 117,111 101 43,808 43,808 60 26,025 26,025 6/11/2003 5.6 121,448 23 10,346 115 51,728 6/11/2003 56 5.6 125 786 125,786 133 61 961 61,961 115 53 576 53,576 6/11/2003 / / 56 5.6 125,786 125,786 75 34,941 34,941 115 53,576 53,576 6/11/2003 5.6 123,617 240 109,882 115 52,652 6/11/2003 56 5.6 121 448 121,448 178 80 066 80,066 100 44 981 44,981 6/11/2003 / / 56 5.6 121,448 121,448 110 49,479 49,479 100 44,981 44,981 6/11/2003 5.6 121,448 40 17,992 100 44,981 4/5/2005 38 3.8 123 617 123,617 160 73 255 73,255 115 52 652 52,652 4/5/2005 / / 38 3.8 123,617 123,617 42 19,229 19,229 115 52,652 52,652 4/5/2005 3.8 121,448 100 44,981 100 44,981 4/5/2005 38 3.8 117 111 117,111 16 6 940 6,940 60 26 025 26,025 7/11/2007 / / 15 1.5 123,973 123,973 143 65,660 65,660 115 52,803 52,803 7/11/2007 1.5 121,835 189 85,285 115 51,893 7/11/2007 15 1.5 119 698 119,698 48 21 280 21,280 100 44 333 44,333 7/11/2002 / / 15 1.5 115,423 115,423 238 101,743 101,743 60 25,650 25,650 7/11/2002 1.5 115,423 44 18,810 60 25,650 7/11/2002 15 1.5 115 423 115,423 28 11 970 11,970 60 25 650 25,650

Full Name of OfficersDate of Hire Years Blohm, Richard Blohm 5/1/1977 O'B i O'Brien, JJohn h 9/1/1978 LaBruno, Joseph 6/1/1981 Setkiewicz Henry Setkiewicz, 6/1/1979 T Turner, Mik Mike 1/1/1995 Palmisano, Frank 3/1/1998 Manzetti Steven Sr. Manzetti, Sr 6/1/1981 M t lf Ken Metcalfe, K 6/1/1981 Cunning, Dan 11/1/1985 Greene Brian Greene, 3/1/1988 F l ,R Falco, Robert b t 11/1/1985 Daliani, Frank 1/1/1979 Cappiello Pat Cappiello, 1/1/1985 N d ll , JJames Nardello, 3/1/1988 Peskens, Anton 11/1/1985 Sansevere Mike Sansevere, 11/1/1985 St ki i , F Stankiewicz, Fred d 11/1/1985 Andreula, Mauro 3/1/1988 Cunning John Cunning, 3/1/1988 K l y, P Kasley, Paull 2/1/1996 Molta, Thomas 1/1/1985 Bufis James Bufis, 1/1/1985 L Lombardi, b di, Ri Richard h d 1/1/1985 / / Guzman, Frank 11/1/1985 Estrella Frank Estrella, 3/1/1988 Pi i i h, Phil Picinich, 3/1/1988 / / Schisani, Joseph 3/1/1988 Doneman Harry Doneman, 11/1/1985 Ly Lyons, , Ch Chris i 11/1/1985 / / Wallington, James 3/1/1988 Amaro Angel Amaro, 2/1/1996 M Munoz, , JJesus 1/1/1985 / / Tartaglia, AL 11/1/1985 Mendez Mickey Mendez, 3/1/1988 D lVi i , L DelViscio, Leonardo d 2/1/1996 / / Goldsack, Nicholas 2/1/1996 Turner Joseph Turner, 2/1/1996

11. co m

Fi D Fire Dept. t

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37

12/30/2008

D t Date

7/11/2002 7/11/2002 7/11/2007 / / 7/11/2007 7/11/2007 7/11/2007 / / 4/16/2008 4/16/2008 4/16/2008 / /

1.5 15 1.5 15 1.5 1.5 15 1.5 15 1.5 8 mos 8 mos 8 mos

113,285 113 285 113,285 113,285 113,285 113,285 111 148 111,148 111,148 111,148 85,498 85 498 85,498 85,498 85,498 95,364 95 364 95,364 95,364 95,364 95,364 94 542 94,542 92,075 92,075 92,075 92 075 92,075 92,075 92,075 92,075 92 075 92,075 92,075 92,075 92,075 92 075 92,075 92,075 92,075 90,431 88 787 88,787 88,787 88,787 87,143 87 143 87,143 8 , 3 87,143 87,143 87 143 87,143 8 , 87,143 96,320 96 320 96,320 96,320 , 96,320 87 964 87,964 85,498 , 85,498 85 498 85,498 83,854 , 84,676 84 676 84,676 84,676 8 ,6 6 84,676 84 676 84,676 84,676 8 ,6 6 84,676 84 676 84,676 84,676 84,676 84 676 84,676 83,854

52 38 62 240 244 187 74 20 51 67 75 31 19 215 0 253 125 0 88 208 216 40 48 60 70 19 4 28 51 36 20 180 8 84 24 10 232 36 8 52 35 59 23 76 16 90 57 28 75 5 64 32 92 85 61 37

11. co m

Captain Captain C pt i Captain Captain Captain C pt i Captain Captain Captain C pt i Captain Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fi Fi Fire Fighter ght Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fi Fi Fire Fighter ght Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fi Fi Fire Fighter ght Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fi Fi Fire Fighter gh Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fi Fi Fire Fighter gh Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fi Fi Fire Fighter gh Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fire Fighter gh Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fire Fighter gh Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fire Fighter gh Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fire Fighter gh Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fire Fighter g Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fire Fighter g Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fire e Fighter g te Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fire Fighter Fire Fighter

11 11 11 11 9 7 7 7 7 24 24 24 24 23 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 21 13 13 12 12 12 2 12 12 12 9 9 9 9 12 8 8 8 8 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6

5/1/1997 5/1/1997 5/1/1997 / / 5/1/1997 8/1/1999 4/1/2001 / / 4/1/2001 4/1/2001 4/1/2001 / / 1/3/1985 1/3/1985 1/3/1985 / / 1/3/1985 11/14/1985 3/21/1988 / / 3/21/1988 3/21/1988 3/21/1988 / / 3/21/1988 3/21/1988 3/21/1988 / / 3/21/1988 3/21/1988 3/21/1988 / / 3/21/1988 2/28/1996 2/28/1996 / / 5/22/1997 5/22/1997 5/22/1997 //22// 99 5/22/1997 5/22/1997 5/22/1997 / / 8/11/1999 8/11/1999 8/11/1999 / / 8/11/1999 8/1/1996 4/25/2001 / / 4/25/2001 4/25/2001 4/25/2001 / / 12/19/2002 12/19/2002 12/19/2002 / 9/ 00 12/19/2002 12/19/2002 12/19/2002 / 9/ 00 12/19/2002 12/19/2002 12/19/2002 12/19/2002 12/19/2002 6/12/2003

Buoncuore, David Fini Mauro Fini, Milt Miltner, ,R Ronald ld Moyeno, Luis Rozmester William Rozmester, C Cassesa, , JJason Stefano, Michael Turso Louis Turso, Z Zampella, p ll , L Louis i Buoncuore, William DePalma Ronald DePalma, Ipp lit , JJohn Ippolito, h Mendoza, Dan Sheridan Robert Sheridan, C Cruz, , anthony th y DeJesus, Carmelo Kolmer Lawrence Kolmer, K Koschig, hig, A August g t Maccaquano, Robert Mattessich John Mattessich, Mi li i, Tino Micalizzi, Ti Mion, Robert Murphy Dan Murphy, R Roman, ,R Rafael f l Cutillo, Thomas Badamo Alex Badamo, R bi , C Rubino, Carmine i Ballester, Baron DePinto Vincent DePinto, Mendoza, d , David d Metcalfe, Ian Soto Daniel Soto, Tarabocchia, b h , Dom Aligo, Thomas Martinez Rey Martinez, Montanex,, Phil hl Pierro, Albert DiVincent Steven DiVincent, Alfano, lf , Arnold ld Bucco, john Grilletti Bernard Grilletti, Classen,, Tyrone y Carter, Audra Casazza Michael Casazza, Chaneski, a , Robert ob Diaz, Maria England Daniel England, Hayes, ayes, Michael c ae Montoto, Dan Perez Alfredo Perez, Tamborra, Antonio Torres, Samuel Volaric Joseph Volaric, O'Connor, O Connor, Robert

38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 6 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 8 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91

21,818 15 944 15,944 26,014 26,014 100,698 100 445 100,445 76,980 76,980 23,433 6 333 6,333 16,150 16,150 23,664 26 490 26,490 10,949 10,949 6,711 75 283 75,283 86,278 42 627 42,627 30,010 70 932 70,932 73,660 73,660 13,641 16 369 16,369 20,461 20,461 23,445 6 248 6,248 1,315 1,315 9,037 16 460 16,460 11,619 ,6 9 6,455 58 095 58,095 27,111 , 8,562 3 567 3,567 82,764 , 12,843 2 606 2,606 16,466 , 11,083 18 683 18,683 7,143 , 23,835 5 018 5,018 28,225 8, 5 17,876 8 781 8,781 23,521 3,5 20,071 10 036 10,036 28,853 26,657 19 131 19,131 11,491

55 55 55 55 45 35 35 35 35 120 120 120 120 116 104 104 104 104 104 104 104 104 104 104 104 64 64 58 58 58 8 58 58 58 8 47 47 47 47 62 38 38 38 38 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30 28

23,077 23 077 23,077 23,077 23,077 23,077 18 525 18,525 14,408 14,408 11,083 11 083 11,083 11,083 11,083 42,394 42 394 42,394 42,394 42,394 42,394 40 517 40,517 35,452 35,452 35,452 35 452 35,452 35,452 35,452 35,452 35 452 35,452 35,452 35,452 35,452 35 452 35,452 35,452 35,452 34,819 21 122 21,122 21,122 21,122 18,746 18 746 Union Rep 18,746 18,746 8, 6 18,746 18 746 18,746 18,746 8, 16,757 16 757 16,757 16,757 , 16,757 20 235 20,235 12,172 , 12,172 12 172 12,172 11,938 , 9,464 9 464 9,464 9,464 9, 6 9,464 9 464 9,464 9,464 9, 6 9,464 9 464 9,464 9,464 9,464 9 464 9,464 8,628

Fighter Fighter Fi Fighter ght Fighter Fighter Fi Fighter ght Fighter Fighter Fi Fighter ght Fighter Fighter Fi Fighter ght Fighter Fighter Fi Fighter ght Fighter Fighter Fi Fighter ght Fighter Fighter Fi Fighter gh Fighter Fighter Fi Fighter gh Fighter Fighter Fi Fighter gh Fighter Fighter Fighter gh Fighter Fighter Fighter gh Fighter Fighter Fighter gh Fighter Fighter Fighter gh Fighter Fighter

Total accrued liability for Fire Department

83,854 83 854 83,854 83,854 83,854 70,237 68 499 68,499 68,499 68,499 68,499 54 175 54,175 54,175 54,175 54,175 54 175 54,175 54,175 54,175 54,175 54 175 54,175 54,175 54,175 54,175 54 175 54,175 54,175 54,175 54,175 43 770 43,770 43,770 43,770 43,770 39 728 39,728 39,728 39,728 39,728 39 728 39,728 39,728 39,728 39,728 39 728 39,728 39, 28 39,728 39,728 38 708 38,708 38,708 8, 8 38,708 38 708 38,708 38,708 , 38,708 38 708 38,708 38,708 , 38,708 38 708 38,708

30 0 124 116 61 8 60 47 79 51 31 34 43 82 95 71 71 28 51 16 4 0 0 8 0 12 4 16 0 20 0 28 12 0 8 20 28 0 24 20 0

11. co m

Fire Fire Fi Fire Fire Fire Fi Fire Fire Fire Fi Fire Fire Fire Fi Fire Fire Fire Fi Fire Fire Fire Fi Fire Fire Fire Fi Fire Fire Fire Fi Fire Fire Fire Fi Fire Fire Fire Fire Fire Fire Fire Fire Fire Fire Fire Fire Fire Fire Fire

6 6 5 4 4 4 4 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

12/1/2002 6/12/2003 7/10/2003 / / 8/18/2004 10/21/2004 10/21/2004 / / 10/21/2004 6/8/2006 6/8/2006 / / 6/8/2006 6/8/2006 6/8/2006 / / 6/8/2006 6/8/2006 6/8/2006 / / 6/8/2006 6/8/2006 6/8/2006 / / 6/8/2006 7/17/2007 7/17/2007 / / 7/17/2007 2/20/2008 2/20/2008 / / 2/20/2008 2/20/2008 2/20/2008 / / 2/20/2008 2/20/2008 2/20/2008 / / 2/20/2008 4/16/2008 4/16/2008 / / 8 4/16/2008 4/16/2008 4/16/2008 / / 4/16/2008 4/16/2008 4/16/2008 / / 4/16/2008 4/16/2008

Frey, Andrew Volaric Keith Volaric, F Ferrante, t ,G Gregory g y Padilla, Jose Crimmins Brian Crimmins, E Eusebio, bi , R Ralph lph Santiago, Charles Daliani Frank Jr Daliani, Di , A Diaz, Anthony th y England, Richard Forcum Michael Forcum, K pp, R Knapp, Ryan y Lehbrink, Walter Markey Andrew Jr. Markey, Jr M k y, M Markey, Matthew tth Piccininni, Joseph Richards Ronald Richards, T Turner, ,d david id Vasquez, Anibal Aponte Nestor Aponte, Pi i Piniero, , JJashua h Spina, Joseph Bracero Ricardo Bracero, C Caro, ,B Brian i Cologna, Fabio Maroney Andrew Maroney, M i Martinez, ,A Anthony h y Robinson, Kevin Sanchez Antonio Sanchez, Sh l, Eyal Shaul, y l Twyford, James Cruz Marco Cruz, Curko, k , Chris h Grossi, Joseph Manzetti Steven jr Manzetti, Marsh, h, Richard h d Matos, Nestor McGlinchym Chris McGlinchym, Scrivani,, Stephen ph Taglieri, John Walker Keeon Walker,

92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 119 120 121 2 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 131 132

11,794,706

9,317 38,511 38,511 30,176 15 476 15,476 2,030 2,030 15,222 9 430 9,430 15,851 15,851 10,233 6 220 6,220 6,822 6,822 8,628 16 453 16,453 19,062 19,062 14,246 14 246 14,246 5,618 5,618 10,233 2 594 2,594 648 1,177 1,177 1 766 1,766 589 2,354 2,9 3 2,943 4 014 4,014 1,720 , 1 147 1,147 2,867 , 4,014 3,441 , 2,867 -

4,221,905 TOTAL FD

30 28 27 22 21 21 21 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 7 7 7 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 -

9,449 8 628 8,628 8,509 8,509 5,684 5 321 5,321 5,321 5,321 5,321 2 573 2,573 2,573 2,573 2,573 2 573 2,573 2,573 2,573 2,573 2 573 2,573 2,573 2,573 2,573 2 573 2,573 2,573 2,573 2,573 1 181 1,181 1,181 1,181 1,181 633 633 633 633 633 633 633 633 633 507 507 507 507 507 507 507 507 507 507 3,219,143 7 441 048 7,441,048

1/1/2009

4/15/2008 4/26/2001 / / 1/5/1995 12/26/2002 3/10/2005 / / 1/13/2005 5/25/2006 4/1/2005 / / 4/1/2005 6/18/2007 6/8/2000 / / 8/18/2004 3/1/2008 3/1/2008 / / 6/7/2000 12/26/2002 6/8/2000 / / 9/2/2007 6/19/2007 8/18/2004 / / 6/9/2000 5/25/2006 5/25/2006 //2 //2006 5/25/2006 5/25/2006 5/25/2006 / / 3/1/2008 5/25/2006 5/2/2006 / / 5/24/2006 5/25/2006 5/25/2006 / / 6/6/2000 5/25/2006 6/10/2000 / / 4/1/2005 1/23/2008 5/25/2006 5/ 5/ 006

Accrued Vacatio Current $ n V l Value

S l y Salary

Acting Police Chie C pt i Captain Captain Captain C pt i Captain Captain Lieutenant Li t Lieutenant t Lieutenant Lieutenant Li t Lieutenant t Lieutenant Lieutenant Li Lieutenant Lieutenant Lieutenant Li Lieutenant Lieutenant Lieutenant Li Lieutenant Lieutenant Lieutenant Lieutenant Lieutenant Sergeants Sergeants g Sergeants Sergeants Sergeants g Sergeants Sergeants Sergeants g Sergeants Sergeants Sergeants g Sergeants Sergeants Sergeants g a

30 37 35.2 30 8 30.8 29 6 29.6 29.6 24 20 24 16 20 20 20 16 20 23 20 16 12 20 24 23 20 35 9 10 9 9 14 12 11 16 23 12 23 14 15 9

R k Rank

Years at R k Rank

216,414 216 414 164,161 164,161 157,621 166 341 166,341 166,341 166,341 157,621 125 240 125,240 123,479 123,479 129,068 116 946 116,946 123,553 123,553 121,313 109 501 109,501 119,450 119,450 121,313 126 805 126,805 122,432 122,432 120,246 118 060 118,060 121,313 121,313 127,812 125 645 125,645 122,432 22, 32 125,452 99 807 99,807 104,931 , 87,044 99 807 99,807 104,931 , 103,431 88 104 88,104 158,362 , 114,570 103 851 103,851 111,092 , 103,431 89 145 89,145 99,807 99,80

169 188 180 188 166 184 186 165 94 118 71 87 125 86 130 161 105 155 148 155 62 121 127 2 153 82 108 8 41 39 66 119 82 78 154 68 109 135 41 80

11. co m

Promotion to C Current t Rank R k

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38

Full F ll Name N off Offi OfficersDate D t off Hi Hire Years Y Police Lisa Robert Lisa, 4/6/1978 F l ,A Falco, Anthony th y 12/2/1971 / / Garcia, Edelmiro 10/1/1973 Simone Daniel Simone, 4/6/1978 R Romano, ,A Anthony th y 6/28/1979 / / Fitzsimmons, James 5/30/1979 Andriani Angelo Andriani, 8/2/1984 B tl y, T Bartley, Tony y 8/11/1988 / / Cahill, Thomas 9/12/1984 Campbell Charles Campbell, 7/1/1993 C Competello, p t ll , M Mark k 8/11/1988 / / Cruz, Kevin 8/11/1988 Drasheff Steven Drasheff, 8/11/1988 F Ferrante, ,k kenneth h 7/1/1993 / / LoBue, Daniel 8/11/1988 Manente Nicholas Manente, 8/12/1985 M C McCourt, , Ti Timothy hy 8/11/1988 / / Miskulin, John 7/1/1993 Pasculli Tory Pasculli, 11/19/1996 R f , JJames Roofe, 8/11/1988 / / Rutkowski, John 8/2/1984 Schell Edward Schell, 8/12/1985 Tavares,, Martin 8// / 988 8/11/1988 Wehrharhn, Walter 4/1/1974 Allegretta Corrado Allegretta, 11/15/1999 Brereton,, Brian 10/29/1998 / / 8 Cabrera, Danilo 11/15/1999 Costello III, III Michael 11/15/1999 Cruz,, Edgardo dg d 1/5/1995 / / De Trizio, Michael 8/1/1996 Drishti Edmond Drishti, 10/2/1997 Falco, l , Anthony h yP 7/1/1993 / / Figueroa, Dennis 8/12/1985 Gigante Melissa Gigante, 11/19/1996 Gnassi,, Enrico 8/12/1985 / / Gonzalez, Ranaldo 1/5/1995 Haack Roy Haack, 2/1/1994 Hochstdater, o da , Scott o 11/15/1999 / 5/ 999

135,459 135 459 114,305 114,305 105,081 115 823 115,823 102,269 102,269 107,416 86 276 86,276 75,459 75,459 44,935 51 110 51,110 32,490 32,490 39,090 50 695 50,695 38,047 38,047 58,410 75 613 75,613 47,612 47,612 69,030 64 714 64,714 69,643 69,643 29,349 56 308 56,308 57,588 , 88 71,089 30 312 30,312 41,972 , 13,218 14 417 14,417 25,650 , 45,586 26 758 26,758 45,749 , 65,347 26 155 26,155 44,848 , 51,716 13 537 13,537 29,572 9,5

Termin al Pay D y Days T Terminal i l Pay P y value l 150 120 230 120,230 185 112,481 112,481 176 102,746 154 94,876 94 876 148 91,180 91,180 148 86,400 122 56 666 56,666 102 46,660 46,660 122 58,130 78 33 600 33,600 102 46,688 46,688 102 45,842 102 41 378 41,378 78 34,320 34,320 102 45,842 117 54 962 54,962 102 46,265 46,265 78 34,549 61 26 511 26,511 102 45,842 45,842 122 57,830 117 54 459 Union Rep 54,459 102 02 46,265 6,26 174 80,796 46 16 888 16,888 51 19,788 , 88 46 14,728 46 16 888 16,888 70 27,204 , 62 23,803 56 18 367 18,367 78 45,500 , 117 49,659 61 23 320 23,320 117 48,151 , 70 26,815 75 24 640 24,640 46 6 16,888 6,888

10/29/1998 6/12/2003 6/12/2003 / / 3/1/2008 5/25/2006 6/7/2000 / / 1/23/2008 6/12/2003 5/25/2006 / / 5/25/2006 6/12/2003 5/25/2006 / / 5/25/2006 8/18/2004 1/23/2008 / / 10/1/1997 5/25/2006 12/26/2002 / / 8/12/1985 7/27/2006 8/2/1984 / / 6/18/2007 7/28/2005 11/15/1999 / / 9/7/1995 12/26/2002 8/12/1985 / / 7/27/2006 11/15/1999 7/27/2006 //2 //2006 6/1/1979 8/12/1985 1/23/2008 / / 8 1/23/2008 11/15/1999 12/26/2002 / / 1/23/2008 12/26/2002 8/11/1988 / / 11/15/1999 8/12/1985 9/7/1995 / / 10/29/1998 6/12/2003 8/12/1985 8/ / 985 1/23/2008 7/10/2003

112,049 111 092 111,092 103,431 103,431 92,447 99 807 99,807 107,261 107,261 87,044 105 346 105,346 103,574 103,574 105,457 107 751 107,751 101,927 101,927 103,851 107 261 107,261 87,044 87,044 107,261 102 987 102,987 85,731 85,731 93,429 46 147 46,147 93,429 93,429 40,298 54 228 54,228 86,526 86,526 86,985 82 611 82,611 96,909 96,909 46,147 86 526 86,526 49,147 9, 96,228 96 909 96,909 35,619 , 35,619 84 924 84,924 82,611 , 35,619 82 611 82,611 90,207 , 84,924 93 429 93,429 89,145 , 88,104 66 160 66,160 93,429 93, 9 35,619 66 160 66,160

69 66 78 106 38 160 55 76 91 92 85 44 77 135 39 83 70 75 58 24 152 28 40 88 46 28 135 29 36 41 148 117 18 8 18 25 36 21 41 36 26 99 35 84 31 127 23 21

11. co m

Sergeants Sergeants S g Sergeants t Sergeants Sergeants S g Sergeants t Sergeants Sergeants S g Sergeants t Sergeants Sergeants S g Sergeants t Sergeants Sergeants S g Sergeants t Sergeants Sergeants Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Off Officer Detective Officer Officer ff Officer Officer Officer ff Officer Officer Officer ff Officer Officer Officer Officer Officer Officer O Officer Officer

24 23 12 20 9 19 11 16 16 20 12 100 13 20 11 20 10 6 23 2 24 2 3 9 13 6 23 2 9 2 30 23 1 1 9 6 1 6 20 9 23 13 10 6 23 3 1 5

8/2/1984 8/12/1985 8/1/1996 / / 8/11/1988 11/15/1999 8/3/1989 / / 10/2/1997 7/1/1993 7/1/1993 / / 1/19/1989 8/1/1996 6/11/1909 / / 9/7/1995 1/19/1989 10/2/1997 / / 8/11/1988 3/15/1999 12/26/2002 / / 8/12/1985 7/27/2006 8/2/1984 / / 6/18/2007 7/28/2005 11/15/1999 / / 9/7/1995 12/26/2002 8/12/1985 / / 7/27/2006 11/15/1999 7/27/2006 //2 //2006 6/1/1979 8/12/1985 1/23/2008 / / 8 1/23/2008 11/15/1999 12/26/2002 / / 1/23/2008 12/26/2002 8/11/1988 / / 11/15/1999 8/12/1985 9/7/1995 / / 10/29/1998 6/12/2003 8/12/1985 8/ / 985 1/23/2008 7/10/2003

Houghton, Kevin Iapicca Patrick Iapicca, J Jacobelli, b lli, Gi Gino Kennedy, Thomas LaBruno Christopher LaBruno, L b d ,L Labradror, Lourdes d Leonard, Joseph Marnell James Marnell, O i , JJohn Orrico, h Pantoja, Edwin Pasculli Anthony Pasculli, P k, JJames Peck, Petrosino, John Rodriquez John Rodriquez, R Rosso, ,D Donald ld Williams, Sam Zanin Peter Zanin, Ag i , St Aguiar, Steven Alvarez, John Archilla Dylan Archilla, A ig Aurigemma, ,M Mark k Aviles, Michael Barbro James Barbro, Bi Binetti, i, S Saverio i Burke, Nicholas Butler Jonathan Butler, C hill, Joseph Cahill, J ph Calderon, Ramon Caraballo Armando Caraballo, C Caruso, , Anthony h y Castellano Chirichella Frank Chirichella, Chirino, h , Daniell Chohan, Madhu Cirillo John Cirillo, Collins, ll , Wiliam l Colon, Adam Colon Elias Colon, Cooney, y, Kevin Costello, Jill Craven Joseph Craven, DePalma,, Michael DePasquale, Justin De Trizio, Trizio Nicholas Della a Fave, a , Bernard a d DiMartino, David DiMartino Joseph DiMartino,

39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85

28,635 27 156 27,156 29,880 29,880 36,294 14 047 14,047 63,562 63,562 17,731 29 653 29,653 34,908 34,908 35,933 33 922 33,922 16,610 16,610 29,617 53 631 53,631 12,573 12,573 32,973 26 700 26,700 23,814 23,814 20,070 4 102 4,102 52,597 52,597 4,179 8 034 8,034 28,201 28,201 14,820 8 567 8,567 48,455 48,455 4,957 11 537 11,537 7,463 , 63 52,747 41 994 41,994 2,375 , 2,375 7 863 7,863 11,015 , 2,770 12 545 12,545 12,028 , 8,178 34 257 34,257 11,556 , 27,410 7 596 7,596 43,946 3,9 6 3,034 5 146 5,146

122 117 62 102 46 97 56 78 78 100 62 498 67 100 56 102 49 30 117 12 122 8 17 46 67 30 117 12 46 12 2 148 117 5 5 46 30 5 30 102 46 117 67 51 28 117 5 27

50,698 48 151 48,151 23,803 23,803 34,934 16 888 16,888 38,589 38,589 18,146 30 268 30,268 29,758 29,758 38,989 24 797 24,797 188,050 188,050 25,633 39 656 39,656 18,146 18,146 40,532 18 706 18,706 9,560 9,560 40,495 2 081 2,081 42,273 42,273 1,151 3 447 3,447 14,640 14,640 21,470 9 213 9,213 42,004 42,004 2,081 14 640 14,640 2,2 2,217 52,762 42 004 42,004 622 622 14 369 14,369 9,213 , 622 9 213 9,213 34,087 , 14,369 40 495 40,495 22,004 , 16,615 6 814 6,814 40,495 0, 95 622 6 720 6,720

7/10/2003 8/12/1985 9/30/1997 / / 12/26/2002 12/26/2002 5/12/1985 / / 1/23/2008 9/21/1984 1/23/2008 / / 11/19/1996 12/26/2002 1/23/2008 / / 8/11/1988 1/23/2008 12/26/2002 / / 7/28/2005 12/26/2002 12/26/2002 / / 8/1/1996 1/19/1989 11/19/1996 / / 7/27/2006 8/23/1994 12/26/2002 / / 8/23/1994 7/1/1993 10/1/1997 / / 7/10/2003 8/23/1994 1/23/2008 //23/2008 / 11/19/1996 7/1/1993 1/23/2008 / / 8 12/26/2002 11/15/1999 11/15/1999 / / 8/11/1988 10/1/1997 1/5/1995 / / 11/15/1999 11/15/1999 7/10/2003 / / 8/2/1984 1/5/1995 4/9/2008 /9/ 008 7/28/2005 11/15/1999 1/23/2008 / 3/ 008 1/19/1989 8/1/1996 8/12/1985 1/23/2008 8/12/1985

66,160 93 429 93,429 88,104 88,104 82,611 82 611 82,611 93,429 93,429 35,619 93 429 93,429 35,619 35,619 86,985 82 611 82,611 35,619 35,619 90,207 35 619 35,619 82,611 82,611 56,268 82 611 82,611 82,611 82,611 86,526 92 447 92,447 91,305 91,305 50,130 86 985 86,985 82,611 82,611 86,985 91 818 91,818 84,924 84,924 66,160 86 985 86,985 3 ,6 9 35,619 90,225 91 896 91,896 35,619 , 82,611 84 924 84,924 86,526 , 90,207 84 924 84,924 86,985 , 84,924 84 924 84,924 66,160 , 93,429 90 225 90,225 35,619 35,6 9 54,228 84 924 84,924 35,619 35,6 9 90,207 86 985 86,985 95,749 35,619 93 429 93,429

24 56 14 23 25 44 23 53 16 33 27 22 93 23 23 27 28 29 23 124 73 28 50 27 90 53 50 43 41 2 21 109 43 22 48 45 34 143 31 47 51 86 31 135 44 21 19 46 21 65 66 126 21 86

11. co m

Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Off Officer Officer Officer Officer ff Officer Officer Officer ff Officer Officer Officer ff Officer Officer Officer Officer Officer Officer O Officer Officer Officer O ce Officer Officer Officer Officer Officer

5 23 11 6 6 24 1 24 1 12 6 1 20 1 6 3 6 6 12 20 12 2 14 6 14 16 11 5 14 1 12 16 1 6 9 9 20 11 14 9 9 5 24 14 1 3 9 1 20 12 23 1 23

Dimone, Ryan Donofrio Emil Donofrio, D i hti, Arbend Drishti, A b d Falco, Jason Fesken Anthony Fesken, F Fonseca, ,G George g Francolino, Frank Fulton Robert Fulton, G ll , R Gallo, Ralph lph Garcia, Glorybi Gigante Vito Gigante, Gl bk , B Globke, Brett Gohde, Robert Gomez Wilfredo Gomez, G Gonzalez, l , Al Alejandro j d Gonzalez, Arturo Grossman Marco Grossman, H tfi ld, Christopher Hatfield, Ch i t ph Hermann, John James William James, K Kranz, ,S Steven Kucz, Charles Lehbrink Jeffrey Lehbrink, L p , Ed Lepre, Edward d Lombardi, Vincent Lucatorto Victor Lucatorto, L ig Lucignano, , JJoseph ph Lulaj, Nikola Madera Juan Madera, Markey, k y, Ch Christopher ph Marsi, Marc McNamara Patrick McNamara, Mecka, k , Jonathan h Mezzina, Joseph Miller James Miller, Miranda, d , Michael h l Moctezuma, Orlando Montanez David Montanez, Montanez,, William ll Mullins, Mark Munoz Bernardo Munoz, Novo,, Mario O'Connor, O Connor, Thomas Olavarria Cesar Olavarria, Olivera, O a, Anthony o y Olivera, David Oquendo William Oquendo, Perez, e e , Andrew d e Perez, James Rivera Ferdinand Rivera, Rivera, Jose Rosa, Francisco Rotondi Benedict Rotondi,

86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108 109 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 8 119 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127 128 129 130 30 131 132 133 33 134 135 136 137 138

5,881 19,378 19 378 4,568 4,568 7,037 7 649 7,649 15,225 15,225 3,034 18 340 18,340 2,111 2,111 10,632 8 261 8,261 2,902 2,902 31,071 3 034 3,034 7,037 7,037 5,627 8 567 8,567 8,873 8,873 7,371 42 457 42,457 24,686 24,686 5,199 16 108 16,108 8,261 8,261 28,995 18 024 18,024 15,727 15,727 10,537 13 209 13,209 2, 0 2,770 36,424 14 635 14,635 2,902 , 14,686 14 154 14,154 10,896 , 47,776 9 751 9,751 15,142 , 16,041 27 050 27,050 7,596 , 46,715 14 703 14,703 2,770 , 0 3,816 14 469 14,469 2,770 , 0 21,717 21 263 21,263 44,683 2,770 29 759 29,759

27 117 56 30 30 118 5 121 5 61 30 5 102 5 30 17 30 30 62 100 61 12 72 30 72 78 56 27 72 5 61 78 5 30 46 46 102 56 70 46 46 27 122 70 4 17 46 5 100 62 117 5 117

6,720 40,495 40 495 18,376 18,376 9,213 9 213 9,213 40,931 40,931 622 42 036 42,036 622 19,533 9 213 9,213 622 34,087 622 9,213 9,213 3,577 9 213 9,213 9,213 9,213 19,913 34 179 34,179 20,503 20,503 2,261 23 147 23,147 9,213 9,213 23,147 Union Rep 26 381 26,381 17,709 17,709 6,720 23 147 23,147 622 20,261 26 403 26,403 622 9,213 14 369 14,369 14,640 , 34,087 17 709 17,709 22,552 , 14,369 14 369 14,369 6,720 , 42,273 23 392 23,392 483 83 3,447 14 369 14,369 622 6 33,351 20 018 20,018 41,501 622 40 495 40,495

8/12/1985 11/15/1999 6/18/2007 / / 7/10/2003 7/28/2005 7/27/2006 / / 12/26/2002 8/11/1988 7/28/2005 / / 1/19/1989 8/11/1988 7/1/1993 / / 11/19/1996 8/3/1989 1/23/2008 / / 7/1/1993 7/27/2006 10/1/1997 / /

23 9 2 5 3 2 6 20 3 20 20 16 12 19 1 16 2 11

Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer Officer Officer Offi Officer

Police Accrued Liability

84,924 84 924 84,924 40,298 40,298 66,160 54 228 54,228 46,147 46,147 82,611 90 207 90,207 54,228 54,228 90,207 92 447 92,447 90,796 90,796 90,207 90 207 90,207 35,619 35,619 88,596 48 147 48,147 84,924 84,924

45 89 26 24 34 19 23 39 26 72 96 78 36 85 20 125 28 46

11. co m

Rotondi, Keith Russo Anthony Russo, S ti g , T Santiago, Teddy ddy Schelmety, Libon Sellick Edward Sellick, Si Simone III III,, D Daniel i l Simone, Jennifer Soto Frank Soto, T Torres, , Ri Richard h d Truppner, Robert Truppner William Truppner, T Turner, , Th Thomas Uva, Damian Velez Angel Velez, V l , JJosue Velez, Vera, William Volaric Christine Volaric, W h h h ,K Wehrhahn, Kris i

14,154 27 993 27,993 3,881 3,881 5,881 6 829 6,829 3,247 3,247 7,037 13 030 13,030 5,222 5,222 24,055 32 870 32,870 26,230 26,230 12,028 28 399 28,399 2,638 2,638 41,017 4 993 4,993 14,469 14,469

117 46 8 27 17 12 30 102 17 100 102 78 61 97 5 78 12 56

36,809 14 369 14,369 1,151 1,151 6,720 3 447 3,447 2,081 2,081 9,213 34 087 34,087 3,447 3,447 33,351 34 934 34,934 26,087 26,087 20,257 32 453 32,453 622 25,455 2 172 2,172 17,709 17,709

4 279 134 4,279,134 TOTAL PD

Total Accrued Liability - HFD + HPD

Total Liability of comp, comp vaca and terminal leave GRAND TOTAL

4,230,532 4 230 532 8,509,666 , , HFD HPD

7,449,675 7 449 675 8,501,039

15 950 714 15,950,714

Official Offi i l 2008/09 Budget B dg t lists li t total t t l accrued d vacation ti liability li bility as $9.3MM $9 3MM and d total t t l tterminal i l lleave li liability bility as $7 $7.4MM 4MM ffor a ttotal t l off $16.7MM. $16 7MM $16.7 $16 7 - $15.9 $15 9 = $744K. $744K Some documents list the number of uniform firefighters as 92 yet the detailed document with firefighter, date of hire, accrued vacation and terminal pay only listed 86 firefighters I attribute the $744K to this lack of reconciliation between official documents aquired via the OPRA process. process This is a 4.5% 4 5% discrepancy. discrepancy Th These i incomes do d NOT include i l d overtime. ti

139 140 141 142 143 144 145 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 153 154 155 156