An impact analysis for the National Guide for Wildland-Urban Interface Fires

Page 38

Firefighter response planning and resources. Fire service also adds to the cost of fire protection and planning. The National Fire Protection Association (Zhuang et al. 2017) estimates that in 2014, the United States spent about $135 billion on fire services, or about $1,000 per household per year, about half of which was directly spent on professional firefighters, and the other half representing the value of volunteer firefighters. Canada employs about 145,000 career and volunteer firefighters (25,000 and 120,000, respectively). Career firefighters earn approximately $90,000 per year (Living in Canada ND), and the average fire chief earns $126,000 per year (Neuvoo 2021b). Public education. As described elsewhere in this chapter, a growing body of literature intended for the public explains the nature of the wildland-urban interface, its fire risk, and the nature of fireresistant construction. However, public education also involves efforts to make the public aware of that literature and perhaps to better understand what to expect in an emergency. After the Waldo Canyon Fire near Colorado Springs, Colorado, the Colorado Springs Fire Department began a stewardship program with its 112 homeowner associations. They prepared and distributed “packets with information on tax benefits, tree service providers, evacuation planning, emergency planning, and outdoor burning. Everything a homeowner would have a question about is in that packet.” They “raffle off an evacuation kit to get them thinking about what [homeowners] should put into their kits” (Markley 2017). Emergency communication resources. Canadian emergency managers can use the National Public Alerting System (Public Safety Canada 2020), Wireless Public Alerting Service (Government of Canada 2016), social media platforms such as Twitter and Facebook, and perhaps other communication systems. People also rely on each other for information, as was evident in the Camp Fire (Sabalow et al. 2018), Waldo Canyon Fire (Markley 2017), and others, where people were contacted by neighbours, friends, and family. 2.13 Cultural and other intangible non-monetary issues The present analysis focuses on quantifying tangible benefits at the house, community, and national levels, especially monetary costs, casualties, and, to a limited extent, environmental impacts. But disasters affect different populations differently, partly because infrastructure improvements differ by economic and other demographic status, partly because people’s ability to withstand a disaster differs under the same stress from infrastructure impacts, and partly because cultural factors matter regardless of infrastructure and vulnerability status. While the present study does not address these issues in serious depth, it seems worthwhile to at least mention some of the literature that shows how they might matter and to a limited extent how they can be treated. Davis et al. (2012) recommends treating the issue by combining medical and functional methods. Under such a paired approach, one identifies high-risk, high-vulnerability populations, accounts for how overlapping population characteristics may increase or decrease the vulnerability of an individual in a disaster, considers the effects of stakeholder involvement, and identifies systemic levels where medical intervention can reduce vulnerability.

22


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook

Articles inside

B.6 Knowledge gaps and limitations of these conclusions

3min
page 133

B.4 Penticton Indian Band

1min
page 131

B.3 Sagkeeng Anicinabe First Nation community

1min
page 130

Table 44: Summary of limitations and opportunities for future work

28min
pages 109-124

Table 43: Community costs to satisfy recommendations of the National WUI Guide

9min
pages 105-108

Table 42: Allocation of costs and benefits among stakeholder groups

5min
pages 102-104

Table 41: Long-term national benefits and costs of the National WUI Guide

1min
page 101

Table 39: Total household costs for community-level compliance

1min
page 99

Table 37: New design benefits, costs, and benefit-cost ratios for satisfying the National WUI Guide

12min
pages 91-95

Table 38: Municipal and utility costs for a sample community

8min
pages 96-98

Table 30: Vulnerability (i.e., the response function) by equation 5

2min
page 86

Table 20: Cost options to evaluate for each archetype

1min
page 75

Table 19: Unit costs to satisfy recommendations of the National WUI Guide

2min
page 74

Table 17: Vinyl cladding fire spread ratings for some leading manufacturers and common products

13min
pages 68-72

Table 18: Initial clearing and maintenance costs for priority zones

2min
page 73

2.12 Community costs for planning and resources

5min
pages 36-37

3.6 Community costs for WUI guide Chapters 4 and 5

11min
pages 48-52

Table 2: Sample house data fields

6min
pages 43-45

2.13 Cultural and other intangible non-monetary issues

2min
page 38

3.2 Select archetypes

1min
page 42

2.8 Additional living expenses and business interruption losses

3min
page 33

2.6 WUI fire vulnerability models

2min
page 31

1.3 Organization of the report

1min
page 19

2.1.4 Relevant Evidence from the 2011 Flat Top Complex Wildfire

3min
pages 21-22

2.7 Deaths, non-fatal injuries, and post-traumatic stress disorder

2min
page 32

2.1.6 Relevant Evidence from Recent California WUI Fires

7min
pages 24-26

2.3 Retrofit and new design costs, benefits, and benefit-cost analysis

2min
page 28

Summary of key findings

2min
page 17

2.2 WUI guides, standards, and model codes

2min
page 27
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.