Test Your Skills

Applications of Proportional Valves

There are many applications for proportional solenoids in the control of hydraulic pressure and flow in both mobile and industrial applications.

The terms pressure differential and pressure drop indicate the same entity – a difference in pressure – and are often used interchangeably. In this discussion on proportional valves, we'll use the term pressure differential. Proportional valves are typically catalog rated for a nominal flow at a 5 bar (72.5 psi) pressure differential per flow path for a total 10 bar (145 psid), and a total loop differential across the valve equal to system pressure minus load and return line pressure or ΔpV = pS - pL - pT. In reality, however, very few systems have such an exact pressure differential. Therefore, it is necessary to determine the size of valve, based on the requirements of the system that it will be controlling. To maximize the performance characteristics of a proportional valve, a more thorough examination must be conducted of not only the required actuator flow but also of the available pressure to drive flow through the valve.

In most applications using industrial type proportional valves, flow is simultaneously metered in and out of the actuator (much like a pair of interconnected flow controls with sharp-edged orifices) in some proportion to the magnitude of the electric input signal, to provide precise control. And for a sharp-edged orifice of a given size, a mathematical relationship exists between the flow rate through and the pressure differential across the orifice such that:

Flow is proportional to the square root of the pressure differential and is expressed as: Q :: Δp

Meaning, that if the pressure differential is increased by a factor of 4, the flow will double. For example, with a given size valve: If QRATED = 10 lpm at ΔpRATED = 10 bar, what is QACTUAL if ΔpACTUAL = 40 bar?

Q

ACTUAL

Δp

ACTUAL ΔpRATED • Qrated

40 10 •10 = 20 lpm

Where:

ΔpACTUAL is the actual (or required) pressure differential across the valve

ΔpRATED is the catalog rated pressure differential across the valve

QACTUAL is the actual (or required) flow passing through the valve

QRATED is the catalog rated flow through the valve at a given pressure differential

Conversely, pressure differential is proportional to the square of the flow and is expressed as: Δp::Q2

Meaning that, if the flow is reduced by half, the pressure differential is reduced to 1/4.

For example, with a given size valve: If ΔpACTUAL = 40 bar and QACTUAL = 20 lpm, what must ΔpRATED be if QRATED = 10 lpm?

ΔpRATED Q

⎛ ⎜ RATED ⎝ ⎜QACTUAL

⎞2 ⎟ ⎟ ⎠

• ΔpACTUAL

10 20

⎞2 ⎟ ⎟ ⎠ 40 = 10 bar

Initially, increasing the pressure differential will increase the power available to the actuator and the higher flow will outweigh the power lost by the increased differential across the valve. Beyond a certain point, however, the power lost due to the increasing pressure differential becomes larger than the power gained by higher flow to the actuator, as shown in figure 1.

Figure 1: Pressure drop across valve (ΔPV ).

Experience has shown that this point occurs at approximately 1/3 of the maximum available system pressure and can be calculated as:

Where: ΔpV = Total valve pressure differential pS = Available system pressure. Δpv

1 3 • ps

For example, if applying this to a system with a maximum system pressure of 150 bar (2,175 psi), if the sum of the pressures acting on the load (including acceleration, friction, and pressure losses across other connected components and plumbing) and return line back-pressures add up to 100 bar (1,450 psi), 50 bar (725 psi) remains and is the differential that will drive flow across the valve. Assume that the system has a 200 lpm (53 gpm) flow requirement.

The graph in figure 2 is for a valve that at 100% command, passes 220 lpm (58 gpm) at a 10 bar (145 psi) differential (flow curve 1). On the surface, this seems like a reasonable, energy-efficient choice because the valve can pass the required flow at a low-pressure differential. The reality is, however, the system has up to 50 bar (725 psi) available to drive flow and at 95% command, this valve can pass over 400 lpm (105 gpm) (flow curve 4), far in excess of the 200 lpm (53 gpm) required. To limit the flow this proportional valve can pass at a 50 bar (725 psi) differential, the spool command would have to be set to about 63% of its full stroke – effectively a 37% reduction in its available control range.

The graph in figure 3 is for a valve that at 100% command produces approximately 100 lpm (26 gpm) at a 10 bar (145 psi) differential (flow curve 1) which compared to the 220 lpm (58 gpm) valve is, on the surface, too small.

Figure 2: Nominal flow with a 10 bar differential (flow curve 1).

Figure 3: 100 lpm at a 10 bar differential (flow curve 1).

What if the valve was sized to take advantage of the full spool stroke at the available pressure differential of 50 bar (725 psi) to pass the required flow of 200 lpm (53 gpm)? Plugging in the known quantities into the equation for QACTUAL:

Q

ACTUAL

Δp

ACTUAL ΔpRATED • Qrated

50 10 •100 = 223 lpm

At 50 bar (725 psi) pressure differential, and a 95% commanded spool stroke, this valve passes about 200 lpm (53 gpm) (flow curve 4), equal to the system's 200 lpm (53 gpm) requirement while providing some additional flow capacity.

The purpose of using electrohydraulic proportional valves is to provide control. A valve that is sized to provide the metering of flow across the full spool travel offers the best resolution and performance. It is well understood that a flow moving from a higher to a lower pressure zone without doing useful work is energy lost in the form of heat and the pressure losses incurred using a properly sized proportional valve is no exception. Simply increasing the size of the valve will not provide for a more energy efficient system because the valve must still be throttled to the equivalent cross sectional area to regulate flow, resulting in the same magnitude of pressure loss and heat generation. One way to make the system more energy efficient is to dramatically reduce the maximum supply pressure and substantially oversize the valve to pass the required flow at the lower available differential. However, larger proportional valves have bigger spools with more mass and are not as quick to respond to an input signal change as a smaller valve flowing at a higher pressure differential. Using the higher available pressure differential to drive the required flow through a smaller valve (while respecting the power limits mentioned earlier) certainly is less energy efficient, sometimes significantly so, but it is the price to be paid for greater control.

Proper sizing of industrial type, electrohydraulic proportional valves can be a rather involved, multistep process but is critical in performance-dependent systems. •

TEST YOUR SKILLS

1. When the inlet pressure to a proportional valve is doubled with no change to the outlet pressure, the resultant flow is:

a. reduced by 50%. b. the same. c. doubled. d. increased by 141%. e. increased by 400%.

2. Increasing the Δp through a valve beyond 1/3 of the available system pressure:

a. increases the power available to the actuator. b. decreases the power available to the actuator. c. causes the actuator to reverse. d. has no effect on the system. e. reduces the heat load in the system.

ONSITE

TRAINING

AND CERTIFICATION FOR: Hydraulic Techs & Engineers Electrical Techs & Engineers Pneumatic Techs & Engineers Multicraft Techs & Engineers

UPSKILL YOUR WORKFORCE!

CFC provides direct, Industry and/or Machine-specific training to companies the world over. Our Hands-On Training Equipment is mobilized directly to your facility with Certified Instructors traveling on-site. This turnkey approach includes all books, materials, equipment, and travel arrangements. We have the capability to upskill your entire workforce NOW!

CFCINDUSTRIALTRAINING.com 7042 Fairfield Business Drive Fairfield, Ohio 45014 +1 513.874.3225 info@cfcindustrialtraining.com

PRODUCT SPOTLIGHT

Go ahead. Push me. Ordinary heavy duty not heavy enough?

Heavy-Duty Mill Cylinders for:

 • Induction-Hardened,

Chrome-Plated Rods  • Heavy Wall Tubing  • Replaceable Glands & Retainer Rings  • High-Load Piston Design

Think indestructible and call Yates. www.yatesind.com

Yates Industries (HQ) 586.778.7680

Yates Cylinders Alabama 256.351.8081

Yates Cylinders Georgia 678.355.2240

Yates Cylinders Ohio 513.217.6777

Genuine Donaldson Internormen-Eaton Velcon-Parker

We're hydraulic filter experts. We've been doing it for over 30 years. We're very competitive and happy to serve your needs. If you need hydraulic filter application help, we know the right questions, and we can give you the right answers.

J/T Hydraulics & Service Co. Inc. 1601 W. 25th Street • Houston, TX 77008 Local: 713.984.9727 • Toll Free: 800.591.8280 Fax: 713.861.2250 • www.jthydraulics.com Introducing—9S Series Investment Cast Swivels

The "9S" Series swivels represent one of the most complete range of sizes and configurations available to industry. This series has been redesigned to incorporate a one-piece barrel arrangement, thus eliminating the need for braze joints. These swivels are pressure balanced with operating pressures up to 5,000 psi. All configurations are designed with a 4:1 Safety Factor and include RoHS compliant zinc plating.

P.O. Box 6479 • Fort Worth, TX 76115 V. 817/923-1965 • www.hydraulicsinc.com

Coxreels Extreme Duty Series

Born from the coalescing fires of the highest strength springs, stainless steel rollers, dual sintered bronze bearings, multiple axle supports, and welded box frames, the XTM Extreme Duty Reel combines the ultimate features into the world’s most robust reel solution. Special features such as swivel retainers which prevent unwanted vibratory loosening of threaded components and easily accessible ratcheting mechanisms set the XTM series on its own pedestal. High temperature, steel core arbors transfer the extra powerful heavy duty spring motor torque to the multiple supported axle ensuring reliable rewind in odd positions or dirty situations. Available in pressure ranges up to 5000 PSI, and dedicated hose solutions such as Suction hose, DEF hose, Gasoline or Fuel hose, the XTM is the solution for your high demand applications where you simply need the best of the best.

www.coxreels.com

Call you local Hitachi Muswellbrook representative or the branch on 02 6541 6300 for more information.  • No tools required  • No expensive hardware needed  • No more rags stuffed into hoses  • No more messy plastic caps  • The ultimate contamination control tool  • One hand installation  • Eliminate hydraulic oil spills & clean up  • Quick installation & ease of usage Stop The Mess! SAVE TIME SAVE MONEY SAVE LABOR SAVE OIL  • Safe for personnel & environment  • Industry acclaimed

For more information, call (203) 861-9400 or email sales@flangelock.com. www.flangelock.com

TERA-GLIDE Isobaric hydraulic hoses

Texcel’s line of constant pressure TERA-GLIDE Isobaric hydraulic hoses exceed industry demand for higher performance for hydraulic systems and components. Trust the color coordinated laylines for ease of hose pressure identification. The TERA-GLIDE high abrasion hydraulic hose covers are the solution for even the most challenging applications. Contact us to learn more.

www.TexcelHydraulics.com sales@texcelrubber.com 800-231-7116

Metaris Brand Low Speed High Torque Orbital Motors

Genuine Metaris Orbital Motors are your best low speed high torque motor option in an economical and compact design. Utilizing proven Roller-Star technology, these motors allow for high efficiency, smooth operation and a long operational life. The motors come equipped with a high pressure shaft seal and also come in a wide range of displacements. The Genuine Metaris Orbital Motor is a functional replacement for common motors in the market today such as Eaton®/ Char-Lynn®, Danfoss®, Parker® and White® .

Hydraulex For more information, call us at 1-800-323-8416 or visit www.hydraulex.com Plastic Bodied Solenoid Valves

Spartan’s line of composite plastic bodied solenoid valves are used all over the world due to consistent reliability, cost-effectiveness, quick availability, and application versatility. Learn more at www.spartanscientific.com.

customerservice@spartanscientific.com 8510 Foxwood Ct, Youngstown Ohio 44514

Contact us to showcase your products and services in the Product Spotlight. This special section is a high-profile area offering product-specific advertising. Visit www.fluidpowerjournal.com for more information or to view our media guide.