Competency Training and Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Certificate in
Power System Modeling and Analysis Training Course in
Load Flow Analysis
U. P. NATIONAL ENGINEERING CENTER NATIONAL ELECTRIFICATION ADMINISTRATION
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
2
Course Outline 1. The Load Flow Problem 2. Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis 3. Gauss-Seidel Load Flow 4. Newton-Raphson Load Flow 5. Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow 6. Principles of Load Flow Control 7. Uses of Load Flow Studies U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
3
The Load Flow Problem
Basic Electrical Engineering Solution
Load Flow of Distribution System
Load Flow of Transmission and Subtransmission System
Load Flow of a Contemplated System
Load Flow of a Single Line
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
4
The Load Flow Problem Basic Electrical Engineering Solution How do you determine the voltage, current, power, and power factor at various points in a power system? Sending End
Line
1.1034 + j2.0856 ohms/phase
Receiving End
Solve for: VS = ?
ISR = ?
VR = 13.2 kVLL
VOLTAGE DROP = VS - VR
Load 2 MVA, 3Ph 85%PF
1) ISR = (SR/VR )* 2) VD = ISRZL 3) VS = VR + VD 4) SS = VSx(ISR)*
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
5
The Load Flow Problem Sending End
VS = ?
Line
1.1034 + j2.0856 ohms/phase ISR = ?
Receiving End
1) ISR = (SR/VR )*
VR = 13.2 kVLL
S1φ = ( 2,000,000 / 3 )∠ cos −1 ( 0.85 ) = 666 ,666.67 ∠31.79 VA
Solve for:
Load 2 MVA, 3Ph 85%PF
2) VD = ISRZL 3) VS = VR + VD 4) SS = VSx(ISR)*
VR = ( 13,200 / 3 )∠0 = 7621.02∠0 V ∗
⎛ 666 ,666.67 ∠31.79 ⎞ I SR = ⎜ ⎟ = 87.48 ∠ − 31.79 A 7621.02∠0 ⎝ ⎠ VD = ( 87.48 ∠ − 31.79 )( 1.1034 + j2.0856 ) = 178.15 + j104.23 V VS = (7621.02 + j0 ) + ( 178.15 + j104.23 ) = 7,799.87 ∠0.77 V VS = 7,799.87 ∠0.77 /1000* 3 = 13.51 k V U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
6
The Load Flow Problem Load Flow From the Real World Sending End
Line
1.1034 + j2.0856 ohms/phase
VS = 13.2 kVLL
Receiving End
ISR = ?
How do you solve for:
VR = ? Load 2 MVA, 3Ph 85%PF
1) ISR = ? 2) VD = ? 3) VR = ? 4) SS = ? U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
7
The Load Flow Problem Load Flow of Distribution System Bus2 Bus1 I12 , Loss12 = ?
Utility Grid
V1 = 67 kV P1 , Q1 = ?
I23 , Loss23 = ?
Bus3 V3 = ? P3 , Q3 = ?
I24 , Loss24 = ? V4 = ? P4 , Q4 = ? Bus4 V2 = ? Lumped Load A P2 , Q2 = ? 2 MVA 85%PF Lumped Load B 1 MVA 85%PF
How do you solve for the Voltages, Currents, Power and Losses?
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
8
The Load Flow Problem Load Flow of Transmission and Subtransmission System G
G
Line 1
2
1 How do you solve for the Voltages, Currents and Power of a LOOP power system?
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Line 2
Line 3 3
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
9
The Load Flow Problem Load Flow of a Contemplated System How about if there are contemplated changes in the System? How will you determine in advance the effects of: • Growth or addition of new loads • Addition of generating plants • Upgrading of Substation • Expansion of distribution lines before the proposed changes are implemented?
Answer: LOAD FLOW ANALYSIS U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
10
The Load Flow Problem Load
Flow
Analysis
simulates (i.e., mathematically determine) the performance of an electric power system under a given set of conditions. Load Flow (also called Power Flow) is a snapshot picture of the power system at a given point.
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
11
The Load Flow Problem Load Flow of a Single Line Sending End
Line
1.1034 + j2.0856 ohms/phase
VS = 13.2 kVLL
Receiving End
ISR = ?
VR = ?
Injected Power at Receiving End SR = VR x (ISR)*
Solving for the Current ISR = (SR / VR)* U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Load 2 MVA, 3Ph 85%PF
Voltage at Sending End VS = VR + Z x ISR
Voltage at Receiving End VR = VS - Z x SR*/VR* Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
12
The Load Flow Problem Load Flow of a Single Line Sending End
Line
1.1034 + j2.0856 ohms/phase
VS = 13.2 kVLL
Receiving End
ISR = ?
VR = ?
Load 2 MVA, 3Ph 85%PF
Converting Quantities in Per Unit Base Power = 1 MVA
VS(pu) = 13.2 /13.2 = 1/0
Base Voltage = 13.2 kV
SR(pu) = 2/cos-1(0.85) / 1
Base Impedance = [13.2]2/1
Zpu = (1.1034 + j2.0856)/174.24
= 174.24 ohms U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
= 0.00633 + j0.01197 Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
13
The Load Flow Problem Load Flow of a Single Line Sending End
Line
1.1034 + j2.0856 ohms/phase
VS = 13.2 kVLL
Receiving End
ISR = ?
VR = ?
Load 2 MVA, 3Ph 85%PF
VR(k) = VS - Z x [SR]* / [VR(k-1) ]* Let
VR(0) = 1/0
For k = 1
For k = 2
VR(1) = __________
VR(2) = __________
ΔV(1) = __________
ΔV(2) = __________
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
14
The Load Flow Problem Load Flow of a Single Line Sending End
Line
1.1034 + j2.0856 ohms/phase
VS = 13.2 kVLL
Receiving End
ISR = ?
VR = ?
Load 2 MVA, 3Ph 85%PF
VR(k) = VS - Z x [SR]* / [VR(k-1) ]* VR(2) = __________ For k = 3
For k = 4
VR(3) = __________
VR(4) = __________
ΔV(3) = __________
ΔV(4) = __________
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
15
The Load Flow Problem Load Flow of a Single Line Sending End
Line
1.1034 + j2.0856 ohms/phase
VS = 13.2 kVLL
Receiving End
ISR = ?
VR = ?
Load 2 MVA, 3Ph 85%PF
VS = __________
ISR = __________
VR = __________
SR = __________
VD = VS – VR
SS = VS x [ISR]*
VD = __________
SS = __________
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
16
Power System Models for Load flow Analysis
Bus Admittance Matrix, Ybus
Network Models
Generator Models
Bus Types for Load Flow Analysis
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
17
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis The power system components are interconnected through the buses. The buses must therefore be identified in the load flow model. Generators and loads are connected from bus to neutral. Transmission lines and transformers are connected from one bus to another bus.
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
18
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis Network Models The static components (transformers and lines) are represented by the bus admittance matrix, Ybus
[YBUS] =
⎡ Y 11 ⎢ ⎢ Y 21 ⎢ ⎢ Y 31 ⎢ ⎢ M ⎢ ⎢Y n 1 ⎣
Y 12 Y 22 Y 32 M Yn2
Y 13 L Y 1 n ⎤ ⎥ Y 23 L Y 2 n ⎥ ⎥ Y 33 L Y 3 n ⎥ ⎥ M M ⎥ ⎥ Y n 3 L Y nn ⎥ ⎦
The number of buses (excluding the neutral bus) determines the dimension of the bus admittance, Ybus. U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
19
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis Network Models Line No. Bus Code Impedance Z pq (p.u.) 1 2 3
1 -2 1 -3 2 -3
0.08 + j0.24 0.02 + j0.06 0.06 + j0.18
Line 1 2
1 Line 2
Line 3
Set-up the Ybus
3 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
20
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis Network Models Compute the branch admittances to set up Ybus: 1 1 ______________ y12 = ____ = 1.25 - j3.75 = z12 0.08 + j0.24 1 1 ______________ y13 = ____ = 5 - j15 = z13 0.02 + j0.06 1 1 ______________ = 1.667 - j5 y23 = ____ = z23 0.06 + j0.18 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
21
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis Set-up the bus admittance matrix: Y11 = y12 + y13 = (1.25 - j3.75) + (5 - j15) = 6.25 - j18.75 = 19.7642 ∠ -71.5651° Y12 = -y12 = -1.25 + j3.75 = 3.9528 ∠ 108.4349° Y13 = -y13 = -5 + j15 = 15.8114 ∠ 108.4349° Y21 = Y12 = -y12 = -1.25 + j3.75 = 3.9528 ∠ 108.4349° U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
22
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis Y22 = y12 + y23 = (1.25 - j3.75) + (1.6667 - j5) = 2.9167 - j8.75 = 9.2233 ∠ -71.5649° Y23 = -y23 = -1.6667 + j5 = 5.2705 ∠ 108.4349° Y31 = Y13 = -y13 = -5 + j15 = 15.8114 ∠ 108.4349° Y32 = Y23 = -y23 = -1.6667 + j5 = 5.2705 ∠ 108.4349° Y33 = y13 + y23 = (5 - j15) + (1.6667 - j5) = 6.6667 - j20 = 21.0819 ∠ -71.5650° U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
23
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis Generator Models Voltage-controlled generating units to supply a scheduled active power (P) at a specified voltage (V). The generating units are equipped with voltage regulator to adjust the field excitation so that the units will operate at particular reactive power (Q) in order to maintain the voltage. Swing generating units to maintain the frequency at 60Hz in addition to maintaining the specified voltage. The generating unit is equipped with frequency-following controller (very fast speed governor) and is assigned as Swing generator U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
24
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis Bus Types for Load Flow Generators and loads are connected from bus to neutral.
Four quantities must be specified to completely describe a bus. These are:
Bus Bus Bus Bus
voltage magnitude, Vp voltage phase angle, δp injected active power, Pp injected reactive power, Qp
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
25
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis Swing Bus or Slack Bus The difference between the total load demand plus losses (both P and Q) and the scheduled generations is supplied by the swing bus. The voltage magnitude and phase angle are specified for the swing bus. P,Q + Type 1: G V∠ δ Swing Bus U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Specify: V, δ Unknown: P, Q
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
26
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis Generator Bus (Voltage-Controlled) Bus or PV Bus The total real power Pp injected into the system through the bus is specified together with the magnitude of the voltage Vp at the bus. The bus voltage magnitude is maintained through reactive P,Q power injection. + Type 2: G V∠ δ Generator Bus U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Specify: P, V Unknown: Q, δ
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
27
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis Load Bus or PQ Bus The total injected power Pp and the reactive power Qp at Bus P are specified and are assumed constant, independent of the small variations in bus voltage. P,Q Type 3: Load Bus
+
V∠δ -
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Specify: P, Q Unknown: V, δ Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
28
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis SUMMARY OF BUS TYPES Bus Type
Know n Q u a n t it ie s
Unknow n Q u a n t it ie s
Type1: S w in g
V p, δ p
P p, Q p
Type 2: G e n e ra to r
P p, V p
Q p, δ p
Type 3: Load
P p, Q p
V p, δ p
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
29
Power System Models for Load Flow Analysis G
G
Line 1
2
1
Bus Types
Line 2
Line 3 3
Bus No. 1 2 3
Voltage Generation V (p.u.) δ P Q 1.0 0.0 * * 1.0 * 0.20 * * * 0 0 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Load P Q 0 0 0 0 0.60 0.25
Remarks Swing Bus Gen Bus Load Bus
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
30
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow
Linear Formulation of Load Flow Equations
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Solution
Numerical Example
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
31
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Linear Formulation of Load Flow Equations The real and reactive power into any bus P is: Pp + jQp = Vp Ip*
or
(1)
Pp - jQp = Vp* Ip where
Pp = real power injected into bus P Qp = reactive power injected into bus P Vp = phasor voltage of bus P Ip = current injected into bus P
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
32
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Equation (1) may be rewritten as: Pp - jQp _________ Ip = Vp*
(2)
From the Bus Admittance Matrix equation, the current injected into the bus are: Ip = Yp1V1 + Yp2V2 + … + YppVp + … + YpnVn
(3)
I1 = Y11V1 + Y12V2 + Y13V3 I2 = Y21V1 + Y22V2 + Y23V3 I3 = Y31V1 + Y32V2 + Y33V3 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
33
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Substituting (3) into (2) Pp - jQp _________ = Yp1V1 + Yp2V2 + … + YppVp + … + YpnVn Vp* P1 – jQ1 _________ = Y11V1 + Y12V2 + Y13V3 V1*
(4)
P2 – jQ2 _________ = Y21V1 + Y22V2 + Y23V3 V2* P3 – jQ3 _________ = Y31V1 + Y32V2 + Y33V3 V3* U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
34
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Solving for Vp in (4) Y11V1 =
P 1 – jQ1 _______ V1*
1 V1 = Y11 Y22V2 =
⎡ P1 − jQ1 ⎤ − Y12V2 − Y13V3 ⎥ ⎢ V* ⎣ ⎦ 1
P 2 – jQ2 _______
1 V2 = Y22
- (___ + Y12V2 + Y13V3)
V2*
- (Y12V2 + ___ + Y13V3)
⎡ P2 − jQ2 ⎤ − Y21V1 − Y13V3 ⎥ ⎢ V* ⎣ ⎦ 2
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
35
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Y33V3 =
P3 – jQ3 _______ V3*
- (Y13V1 + Y23V2 + ___)
⎤ 1 ⎡ P3 − jQ3 V3 = − Y31V1 − Y32V2 ⎥ ⎢ * Y33 ⎣ V3 ⎦ n P jQ 1 p p Vp = ___ _______ - Σ YpqVq Ypp Vp* q=1
(5)
q≠p
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
36
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Solution Generalizing the Gauss-Seidel Load Flow, the estimate for the voltage Vp at bus p at the kth iteration is: n P jQ 1 p p ___ _______ - Σ YpqVqα k+1 Vp = Ypp (Vpk)* q=1
(6)
q≠p
where, α = k α=k+1 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
if p < q if p > q Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
37
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow
Gauss-Seidel Voltage Equations of the form shown in (6) are written for all buses except for the swing bus. The solution proceeds iteratively from an estimate of all bus voltages
For a Load Bus (Type 3) whose real power and reactive power are specified, the G-S voltage equation is used directly to compute the next estimate of the bus voltage.
For a Generator Bus (Type 2) where the voltage magnitude is specified, an estimate of Qp must be determined first. This estimate is then compared with the reactive power limits of the generator. If it falls within the limits, the specified voltage is maintained and the computed Qp is inputted, in the Gauss-Seidel equation. Otherwise, the reactive power is set to an appropriate limit (Qmin or Qmax) and the bus is treated as a load bus in the current iteration. U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
38
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Numerical Example Shown in the figure is a 3-bus power system. The line and bus data pertinent to the system are also given. The reactive limits of generator 2 are zero and 50 MVARS, respectively. Base power used is 100 MVA. Solve the load flow problem using Gauss-Seidel iterative method assuming a 0.005 convergence index.
G
G
Line 1
2
1 Line 2
Line 3 3
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
39
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Branch Data Line No. Bus Code Impedance Z pq (p.u.) 1 2 3
1 -2 1 -3 2 -3
0.08 + j0.24 0.02 + j0.06 0.06 + j0.18
Bus Data Bus Voltage Generation No. V (p.u.) δ P Q 1 1.0 0.0 * * 2 1.0 * 0.20 * 3 * * 0 0 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Load P Q 0 0 0 0 0.60 0.25
Remarks Swing Bus Gen Bus Load Bus
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
40
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Specified Variables: V1 = 1.0 δ1 = 0.0 V2 = 1.0
P2 = 0.2
P3 = -0.6
Q3 = -0.25
Note the negative sign of P and Q of the Load at Bus 3
Initial Estimates of Unknown Variables: δ20 = 0.0 V30 = 1.0 δ30 = 0.0 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
41
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow The Bus Admittance Matrix elements are: Y11 = 6.25 - j18.75 = 19.7642 ∠ -71.5651° Y12 = -1.25 + j3.75 = 3.9528 ∠ 108.4349° Y13 = -5 + j15 = 15.8114 ∠ 108.4349° Y21 = -1.25 + j3.75 = 3.9528 ∠ 108.4349° Y22 = 2.9167 - j8.75 = 9.2233 ∠ -71.5649° Y23 = -1.6667 + j5 = 5.2705 ∠ 108.4349° Y31 = -5 + j15 = 15.8114 ∠ 108.4349° Y32 = -1.6667 + j5 = 5.2705 ∠ 108.4349° Y33 = 6.6667 - j20 = 21.0819 ∠ -71.5650° U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
42
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Gauss-Seidel Equations Bus 1: Swing Bus V1
(k + 1 )
= 1∠ 0
for all iterations
Bus 2: Generator Bus Q2 must first be determined from: P2 - jQ2(k+1) = (V2(k))* [Y21V1(k+1) + Y22V2(k) + Y23V3(k)] then substitute it to: V2
(k + 1 )
(k + 1 ) ⎤ 1 ⎡ P2 − jQ 2 (k + 1 ) (k ) ⎢ = − Y 21 V 1 − Y 23 V 3 ⎥ * (k ) Y 22 ⎢ ⎥⎦ V ⎣ 2
(
)
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
43
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Bus 3: Load Bus
V3
(k + 1 )
⎤ 1 ⎡ P3 − jQ 3 (k + 1 ) (k + 1 ) ⎥ ⎢ = − Y 31 V 1 − Y 32 V 2 * Y 33 ⎢ V (k ) ⎥⎦ 3 ⎣
(
)
Iteration 1 (k = 0): V1 (1) = 1.0∠0° P2 - jQ2(1) = (1.0∠0°) [(-1.25 + j3.75)(1.0∠0°) + (2.9167 - j8.75)(1.0∠0°) + (-1.6667 + j5)(1.0∠0°) = 0.0 + j0.0 Q2(1) = 0.0 [This value is within the limits.] U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
44
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow V2
(k + 1 )
V2
(1)
(k + 1 ) ⎡ ⎤ 1 P2 − jQ 2 (k + 1 ) (k ) ⎢ = − Y 21V 1 − Y 23 V 3 ⎥ * (k ) Y 22 ⎢ ⎥⎦ V 2 ⎣
(
)
1 0.2 - j0.0 ___________________ ___________ = 9.2233∠-71.5650 1.0∠0°
Y22
(k +1 )
V1 Y21 - (-1.25 +j3.75) (1.0∠0°) (k ) Y23 V3 - (-1.6667 + j5) (1.0∠0°)
P2 − jQ2
( k +1 )
(V ) (k )
*
2
= 1.0071∠1.1705° U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
45
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow V3
(k + 1 )
⎤ 1 ⎡ P3 − jQ 3 (k + 1 ) (k + 1 ) ⎢ ⎥ = − Y 31V 1 − Y 32 V 2 * Y 33 ⎢ V (k ) ⎥⎦ 3 ⎣ P3 − jQ3
(
)
1 _____________________ V3 = 21.0819∠-71.5650 Y33 (k +1 ) Y31 V1 - (-5 +j15) (1.0∠0°) 1
-0.6 + j0.25 ____________ 1.0∠0°
(V )
k *
3
( k +1 ) Y32 V2 - (5.2705∠108.4349°)(1.0071∠1.1705°)
= 0.9816 ∠-1.0570° U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
46
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow ΔV2 = V2(1) - V2(0) = 1.0071∠1.1705° - 1.0∠0° ⏐ΔV2⏐ = 0.0217
ΔV3 = V3(1) - V3(0) = 0.9816∠-1.0570° - 1.0∠0° ⏐ΔV3⏐ = 0.0259 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
47
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Iteration 2 (k = 1): V1(2) = 1.0∠0° Let, V2(1) = 1.0∠1.1705° P2 - jQ2(2) = (1.0∠-1.1705°)[(-1.25 + j3.75)(1.0∠0°) + (9.2233∠-71.5649°)(1.0∠1.1705°) + (5.2705∠108.4349° )(0.9816∠-1.0570°) = 0.2995 - j0.0073 Q2 (2) = 0.0073
[This value is within the limits.]
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
48
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow V2
(k + 1 )
V2
(2)
(k + 1 ) ⎡ ⎤ 1 P2 − jQ 2 (k + 1 ) (k ) ⎢ = − Y 21 V 1 − Y 23 V 3 ⎥ * ( ) k Y 22 ⎢ ⎥⎦ V2 ⎣
(
)
1 ___________________ = 9.2233 ∠ -71.5650
0.2 - j0.0073 ______________ 1.0 ∠ -1.1705°
- (-1.25 +j3.75) (1.0 ∠ 0°) - (5.2705 ∠ 108.4349° ) (0.9816 ∠ -1.0570°) = 0.9966 ∠ 0.5819° U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
49
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow V3
(k + 1 )
⎤ 1 ⎡ P3 − jQ 3 (k + 1 ) (k + 1 ) ⎢ ⎥ = − Y 31 V 1 − Y 32 V 2 * ( ) k Y 33 ⎢ V ⎥⎦ 3 ⎣
(
)
-0.6 + j0.25 ___________________
1 _____________________ (2) V3 = 21.0819 ∠ -71.5650
0.9816 ∠ 1.0570°
- (-5 +j15) (1.0 ∠ 0°) - (5.2705 ∠ 108.4349°) (0.9966 ∠ 0.5819° ) = 0.9783 ∠ -1.2166° U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
50
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow ΔV2 = V2(2) - V2(1) = 0.9966 ∠ 0.5819° - 1.0071 ∠ 1.1705° ⏐ΔV2⏐ = 0.0125
ΔV3 = V3(2) - V3(1) = 0.9783 ∠ -1.2166° - 0.9816 ∠ -1.0570° ⏐ΔV3⏐ = 0.004 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
51
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Iteration 3 (k = 2): V1(2) = 1.0∠0° Let, V22 = 1.0 ∠ 0.5819° P2 - jQ22 = (1.0 ∠-0.5819°) [(-1.25 + j3.75)(1.0 ∠ 0°) + (9.2233 ∠ -71.5649° ) (1.0 ∠ 0.5819°) + (5.2705 ∠ 108.4349° ) (0.9783 ∠ -1.2166° ) = 0.2287 - j0.0472 Q22 = 0.0472
[This value is within the limits.]
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
52
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow V2
(k + 1 )
V2
3
(k + 1 ) ⎡ ⎤ 1 P2 − jQ 2 (k + 1 ) (k ) ⎢ = − Y 21 V 1 − Y 23 V 3 ⎥ * ( ) k Y 22 ⎢ ⎥⎦ V2 ⎣
(
)
1 ___________________ = 9.2233 ∠ -71.5650
0.2 - j0.0472 ______________ 1.0 ∠ -0.5819°
- (-1.25 +j3.75) (1.0 ∠ 0°) - (5.2705 ∠ 108.4349° ) (0.9783 ∠ -1.2166° ) = 0.9990 ∠ 0.4129° U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
53
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow V3
(k + 1 )
⎤ 1 ⎡ P3 − jQ 3 (k + 1 ) (k + 1 ) ⎢ ⎥ = − Y 31 V 1 − Y 32 V 2 * ( ) k Y 33 ⎢ V ⎥⎦ 3 ⎣
(
)
1 _____________________ 3 V3 = 21.0819 ∠-71.5650
-0.6 + j0.25 ___________________ 0.9783 ∠ 1.2166°
- (-5 +j15)(1.0∠0°) - (5.2705∠108.4349°)(0.9990∠0.4129°) = 0.9788∠-1.2560° U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
54
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow ΔV2 = V2(3) - V2(2) = 0.9990∠0.4129° - 1.0∠0.5819° ⏐ΔV2⏐ = 0.003 < 0.005
ΔV3 = V3(3) - V3(2) = 0.9788∠-1.2560° - 0.9783∠-1.2166° ⏐ΔV3⏐ = 0.0008 < 0.005
The solution has converged. U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
55
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow The bus voltages are: V1 = 1.0∠0° V2 = 0.9990∠0.4129° V3 = 0.9788∠-1.2560° The power injected into the buses are: P1 - jQ1 = V1* [Y11V1 + Y12V2 + Y13V3 ] P1 - jQ1 = (1.0∠0) [(19.7642∠-71.5651°)(1.0∠0°) + (3.9528∠108.4349°)(0.9990∠0.4129°) + (15.8114∠108.4349°) (0.9788∠-1.25560°) = 0.4033 - j0.2272 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
56
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow P2 - jQ2 = V2* [Y21V1 + Y22V2 + Y23V3 ] P2 - jQ2 = (0.999∠-0.4129°)[(3.9528∠108.4349°)(1.0∠0°) + (9.2233∠-71.5649°)(0.9990∠0.4129°) + (5.2705∠108.4349°)(0.9788∠-1.25560°) = 0.2025 - j0.04286 P3 - jQ3 = V3* [Y31V1 + Y32V2 + Y33V3 ] P3 - jQ3 = (0.9788∠1.256°) [(15.8114∠108.4349°)(1.0∠0°) + (5.2705∠108.4349°)(0.9990∠0.4129°) + (21.0819 ∠ -71.5650°)(0.9788∠-1.25560° ) = -0.600 + j0.2498 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
57
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow The branch currents are:
I pq = I line = y pq ( V p − Vq )
I qp = − I line = y pq ( Vq − V p )
I12 = y12 [V1 - V2]
I21 = y12 [V2 – V1]
I13 = y13 [V1 – V3]
I31 = y13 [V3 – V1]
I23 = y23 [V2 – V3]
I32 = y23 [V3 – V2]
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
58
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Line Currents Ipq
Vp p
Iline
ypq
ypo
Vq
yqo
Iqp
q
The line current Ipq, measured at bus p is given by
I pq = I line + I po = y pq ( V p − Vq ) + y poV p Similarly, the line current Iqp, measured at bus q is I qp = − I line + I qo = y pq ( Vq − V p ) + yqoVq U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
59
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow The branch power flows are:
P12 – jQ12 = V1* I12
P21 – jQ21 = V2* I21
P13 – jQ13 = V1* I13
P31 – jQ31 = V3* I31
P23 – jQ23 = V2* I23
P32 – jQ32 = V3* I32
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
60
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Power FLOWS The power flow (Spq) from bus p to q is
S pq = Ppq − jQ pq = V p* I pq The power flow (Sqp) from bus q to p is
S qp = Pqp − jQqp = Vq* I qp
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
61
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow The line losses are:
P12(Loss) – jQ12(Loss) = (P12 – jQ12) + (P21 – jQ21 )
P13(Loss) – jQ13(Loss) = (P13 – jQ13) + (P31 – jQ31 )
P23(Loss) – jQ23(Loss) = (P23 – jQ23) + (P32 – jQ32 )
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
62
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow Line Losses The power loss in line pq is the algebraic sum of the power flows Spq and Sqp
S loss = Ploss + jQloss = S pq + S qp
= VpI
* pq
â&#x2C6;&#x2019; VqI
= (V p + V q )I
* pq
* pq
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
63
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow SUMMARY OF BASIC INFORMATION Voltage Profile Injected Power (Pp and Qp) Line Currents (Ipq and Ipq) Power Flows (Ppq and Qpq) Line Losses (I2R and I2X)
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
64
Gauss-Seidel Load Flow OTHER INFORMATION Overvoltage and Undervoltage Buses Critical and Overloaded Transformers and Lines Total System Losses
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
65
Newton-Raphson Load Flow
Non-Linear Formulation of Load Flow Equations
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Solution
Numerical Example
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
66
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Non-Linear Formulation of Load Flow Equations The complex power injected into Bus p is
Pp − jQp = E*p I p
(1)
and the current equation may be written as Ip =
n
∑Y
pq
(2)
Eq
q =1
Substituting (2) into (1)
P p − jQ
p
= E
* p
•
n
∑Y E q =1
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
pq
(3) q
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
67
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Let E = V ∠ δ p p
E q = Vq ∠ δ q
p
Ypq = Ypq∠θ pq Substituting into equation (3),
Pp − jQ p =
n
∑VVY p
q
pq
∠ ( θ pq +δ q − δ p )
(4)
q =1
Separating the real and imaginary components
Pp =
n
∑VVY p
q
pq
co s( θ pq +δ q − δ p )
q =1
(5)
n
Q p = − ∑ V pV q Y pq sin( θ pq +δ q − δ p )
(6)
q =1
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
68
Newton-Raphson Load Flow The formulation results in a set of non-linear equations, two for each Bus of the system. Equations Pp are written for all Buses except the Swing Bus. Equations Qp are written for Load Buses only The system of equations may be written for
i number of buses minus the swing bus (n-1) j number of load buses
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
69
Newton-Raphson Load Flow The system of equations may be written as
P1 = P1 ( δ 1 ,δ 2 ,...,δ i ,v1 ,v 2 ....,v j ) P2 = P2 ( δ 1 ,δ 2 ,...,δ i ,v1 ,v 2 ....,v j ) M M Pi = Pi ( δ 1 ,δ 2 ,...,δ i ,v 1 ,v 2 ....,v j )
(7)
Q1 = Q1 ( δ 1 ,δ 2 ,...,δ i ,v1 ,v2 ....,v j ) Q2 = Q2 ( δ 1 ,δ 2 ,...,δ i ,v1 ,v2 ....,v j ) M
M
Q j = Q j ( δ 1 ,δ 2 ,...,δ i ,v1 ,v2 ....,v j ) U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
70
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Equation (7) may be linearized using a First-Order Taylor-Series Expansion P1spec
= P1calc
+
∂P1 Δδ 1 ∂δ 1
+
∂P1 Δδ 2 ∂δ 2
+... +
∂P1 Δδ i ∂δ i
+
∂P1 ΔV1 ∂V1
+
∂P1 ΔV2 ∂V2
+... +
∂P1 ΔV j ∂V j
P2 spec
= P2calc
+
∂P2 Δδ 1 ∂δ 1
+
∂P2 Δδ 2 ∂δ 2
+... +
∂P2 Δδ i ∂δ i
+
∂P2 ΔV1 ∂V1
+
∂P2 ΔV2 ∂V2
+... +
∂P2 ΔV j ∂V j
+... +
∂Pi ΔV j ∂V j
M M M
M∂P
= Pi calc
+
Q1spec
= Q1calc
+
∂Q1 Δδ 1 ∂δ 1
Q2spec
= Q2calc
+
∂Q2 Δδ 1 ∂δ 1
M M M
Q
spec j
= Q
calc j
+
i
∂δ 1
M∂Q
j
∂δ 1
M
M
M
Δδ 2
+... +
+
∂Q1 Δδ 2 ∂δ 2
+... +
∂Q1 Δδ i ∂δ i
+
∂Q1 ΔV1 ∂V1
+
∂Q1 ΔV2 ∂V2
+... +
+
∂Q2 Δδ 2 ∂δ 2
+... +
∂Q2 Δδ i ∂δ i
+
∂Q2 ΔV1 ∂V1
+
∂Q2 ΔV2 ∂V2
+... +
i
∂δ 2
M ∂Q
Δδ1 +
j
∂δ 2
Δδ 2
M
+... +
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
∂Q j ∂δ i
M
Δδ i
∂Pi + ΔV1 ∂V1
+
∂Q j ∂V1
M
∂Pi + ΔV2 ∂V2
M
∂Pi Δδ i ∂δ 2
Δδ 1 +
Pi spec
M ∂P
ΔV1 +
∂Q j ∂V2
M
ΔV2
+... +
∂Q1 ΔV j ∂V j ∂Q2 ΔV j ∂V j ∂Q j ∂V j
ΔV j
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis ⎡ P1 ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ spec ⎢ P2 ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ Pi s p e c ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ spec ⎢Q1 ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ Q spec ⎢ 2 ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ spec ⎣⎢ Q j spec
− P1
c a lc
− P2c a lc
M − Pi c a l c − Q 1c a l c − Q
ca lc 2
M − Q
ca lc j
⎡ ∂ P1 ⎤ ⎢ ∂δ 1 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ∂ P2 ⎥ ⎢ ∂δ 1 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ M ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ∂ Pi ⎥ ⎢ ∂δ 1 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ = ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ∂Q1 ⎥ ⎢ ∂δ 1 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ∂Q2 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ∂δ 1 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ M ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ∂Q j ⎥ ⎢ ⎦⎥ ⎣⎢ ∂ δ 1
71
∂ P1 ∂δ 2
L
∂ P1 ∂δ i
∂ P1 ∂V1
∂ P1 ∂V2
L
∂ P2 ∂δ 2
L
∂ P2 ∂δ i
∂ P2 ∂V1
∂ P2 ∂V2
L
M
M
M
M ∂ Pi ∂δ 2
L
∂ Pi ∂δ 2
∂ Pi ∂V1
∂ Pi ∂V2
L
∂Q1 ∂δ 2
L
∂Q1 ∂δ i
∂Q1 ∂V1
∂Q1 ∂V2
L
∂Q 2 ∂δ 2
L
∂Q2 ∂δ i
∂Q 2 ∂V1
∂Q2 ∂V2
L
M
M
M
M
M
∂Q
j
∂δ 2
L
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
∂Q ∂δ i
j
∂Q
j
∂V1
∂Q
j
∂V2
L
∂ P1 ⎤ ⎡Δδ1 ∂V j ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎥⎢ ∂ P2 ⎥ ⎢ Δδ2 ∂V j ⎥ ⎢ ⎥⎢ ⎥⎢ M ⎥⎢ M ⎥⎢ ⎥⎢ ∂ Pi ⎥ ⎢ ⎢Δδi ∂V j ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎥⎢ ∂Q1 ⎥ ⎢ ΔV1 ∂V j ⎥ ⎢ ⎥⎢ ∂Q2 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ΔV2 ∂V j ⎥ ⎢ ⎥⎢ ⎢ M ⎥⎥ ⎢ M ⎥⎢ ⎢ ∂Q j ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ΔV j ∂ V j ⎥⎦ ⎣
⎤ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎦
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
72
Newton-Raphson Load Flow or simply
⎡ ∂P ⎡ ΔP ⎤ ⎢ ∂δ ⎢ΔQ ⎥ = ⎢ ∂Q ⎣ ⎦ ⎢ ⎣ ∂δ
∂P ⎤ ∂V ⎥ ⎡ Δδ ⎤ ∂Q ⎥ ⎢⎣ΔV ⎥⎦ ⎥ ∂V ⎦
∂P ⎤ ⎡ ∂P ⎡ ΔP ⎤ ⎢ ∂δ V ∂V ⎥ ⎡ Δδ ⎤ ⎥ ⎢ΔV ⎥ ⎢ΔQ ⎥ = ⎢ ∂Q ∂ Q ⎣ ⎦ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢⎣ V ⎥⎦ V ∂V ⎦ ⎣ ∂δ U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
73
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Newton-Raphson Load Flow Solution ⎡ΔP ⎤ ⎡ J1 ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎢ ⎥= ⎢ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎣ ΔQ ⎦ ⎣ J 3
J2 ⎤ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ J4 ⎦
⎡ Δδ ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ΔV ⎢⎣ V
⎤ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥⎦
n ⎧ ∂ Pp = ∑ V p V q Y p q s in ( θ p q + δ q − δ ⎪ q = 1 ,q ≠ p ⎪ ∂δ p J1 ⎨ ⎪ ∂ P p = − V V Y s in ( θ + δ − δ ) p q pq pq q p ⎪ ∂δ q ⎩ U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
p
)
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
74
Newton-Raphson Load Flow
J2
J3
∂ Pp ⎧ 2 V = P + V ⎪ p p p Y pp c o s θ pp ∂V p ⎪ ⎨ ⎪V ∂ Pp = V V Y c o s ( θ p q pq pq + δ q − δ p ) ⎪ q ∂V q ⎩ n ⎧ ∂Q p = ∑ V pV q Y pq c o s ( θ pq + δ q − δ ⎪ q = 1 ,q ≠ p ⎪ ∂δ p ⎨ ⎪ ∂ Q p = −V V Y c o s( θ p q pq pq + δ q − δ p ) ⎪ ∂δ q ⎩ U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
p
)
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
75
Newton-Raphson Load Flow ⎧ ⎪V p ⎪ J4 ⎨ ⎪V ⎪ q ⎩
∂Q p ∂V p ∂Q p ∂Vq
= Q p − V p2 Y p p s in θ p q = − V p V q Y p q s in ( θ p q + δ q − δ
p
)
The solution of the load flow equations proceeds iteratively from the set of initial estimates. These estimates are updated after evaluating the Jacobian matrix.
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
76
Newton-Raphson Load Flow At the kth iteration,
δ p( k +1 ) = δ p( k ) + Δδ p( k ) V p( k +1 ) = V p( k ) + ΔV p( k ) The process is terminated once convergence is achieved whrein
MAX Δ P ( k ) ≤ ε p
and
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
MAX ΔQ( k ) ≤ ε q
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
77
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Numerical Example Shown in the figure is a 3-bus power system. The line and bus data pertinent to the system are also given. The reactive limits of generator 2 are zero and 50 MVARS, respectively. Base power used is 100 MVA. Solve the load flow problem using Gauss-Seidel iterative method assuming a 0.005 convergence index.
G
G
Line 1
2
1 Line 2
Line 3 3
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
78
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Branch Data Line No. Bus Code Impedance Z pq (p.u.) 1 2 3
1 -2 1 -3 2 -3
0.08 + j0.24 0.02 + j0.06 0.06 + j0.18
Bus Data Bus Voltage Generation No. V (p.u.) δ P Q 1 1.0 0.0 * * 2 1.0 * 0.20 * 3 * * 0 0 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Load P Q 0 0 0 0 0.60 0.25
Remarks Swing Bus Gen Bus Load Bus
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
79
Newton-Raphson Load Flow The elements of the Bus Admittance Matrix are:
Y11 = 6.25 − j18.75 = 19.7642 ∠ − 71.5651 Y12 = − 1,25 + j 3.75 = 3.9528 ∠ 108.4349 Y13 = − 5 + j15 = 15.8114 ∠ 108.4349 Y21 = − 1.25 + j .375 = 3.9528 ∠ 108.4349 Y22 = 2.9167 − j 8.75 = 9.2233 ∠ − 71.5649 Y23 = − 1.6667 + j 5 = 5.2705 ∠ 108.4349 Y31 = − 5 + j15 = 15.811 4 ∠ 108.4349 Y32 = − 1.6667 + j 5 = 5.2705 ∠ 108.4349 Y33 = 6.6667 − j 20 = 21.0819 ∠ − 71.5650 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
80
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Bus 1: Swing Bus (Not included) Bus 2: Generator Bus (Compute for P2) Bus 3: Load Bus (Compute for P2 and Q2)
⎡ ∂P2 ⎡ ΔP2 ⎤ ⎢ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ∂δ2 ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ∂P3 ⎢ ΔP3 ⎥ = ⎢ ∂δ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ 2 ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎢⎣ΔQ3 ⎥⎦ ⎢ ∂Q3 ⎢⎣ ∂δ2
∂P2 ∂δ3 ∂P3 ∂δ3 ∂Q3 ∂δ3
⎤ ∂P2 ⎤ ⎡ V3 ⎥ ⎢ Δδ2 ⎥ ∂V3 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎥⎢ ⎥ ∂P3 ⎥ ⎢ V3 Δδ3 ⎥ ⎥ ∂V3 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥⎢ ⎥ ∂Q3 ⎥ ⎢ ΔV3 ⎥ ⎥⎢ ⎥ V3 ∂V3 ⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ V3 ⎥⎦
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
81
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Specified Variables: V1 = 1.0 δ1 = 0.0 V2 = 1.0
P2 = 0.2
P3 = -0.6
Q3 = -0.25
Initial Estimates of Unknown Variables:
δ20 = 0.0 V30 = 1.0 δ30 = 0.0 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
82
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Compute Initial Power Estimates
P20 = V2V1Y21 cos( θ 21 + δ 1 − δ 2 ) + V2V2Y22 cos θ 22 + V2V3Y23 cos( θ 23 + δ 3 − δ 2 ) = ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 3.9528 )cos( 108.4349 + 0.0 + 0.0 ) + ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 9.2233 )cos( − 71.5649 ) + ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 5.2705 )cos( 108.4349 ) = 0.0
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
83
Newton-Raphson Load Flow P30 = V3V1Y31 cos( θ 31 + δ 1 − δ 3 ) + V3V2Y32 cos( θ 22 + δ 2 − δ 3 ) + V3V3Y33 cos θ 33 = ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 15.8114 )cos( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.0 ) + ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 5.2705 )cos( 108.4349 + 0.0 + 0.0 ) + ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 21.0819 )cos( −71.5650 ) = 0.0
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
84
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Q 30 = V 3V1Y31 sin( θ 31 + δ 1 − δ 3 ) + V 3V 2Y32 sin( θ 32 + δ 2 − δ 3 ) + V 3V 3Y33 sin θ 33 = ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 15.8114 ) sin( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.0 ) + ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 5.2705 ) sin( 108.4349 + 0.0 + 0.0 ) + ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 21.0819 ) sin( − 71.5650 ) = 0.0
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
85
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Compute Power Mismatch
Δ P20 = 0 . 2 − 0 .0 = 0 . 2 Δ P30 = − 0 .6 − 0 .0 = − 0 .6 Δ Q 30 = − 0 .2 5 − 0 .0 = − 0 .2 5 Evaluate elements of Jacobian Matrix ⎡ ∂P ⎢ ∂δ J = ⎢ ⎢ ⎢ ∂Q ⎢⎣ ∂ δ
∂P ⎤ ∂δ ⎥ ⎥ ⎥ ∂Q ⎥ V ∂ V ⎥⎦ V
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
86
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Elements of J1:
∂P2 = V2V1Y21 sin( θ 21 + δ 1 − δ 2 ) ∂δ 2 + V2V3Y23 sin( θ 23 + δ 3 − δ 2 ) = ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 3.9528 )sin( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.0 ) + ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 5.2705 )sin( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.0 ) = 8.75
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
87
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Elements of J1:
∂P2 = −V2V3Y23 sin( θ 23 + δ 3 − δ 2 ) ∂δ 3 = −( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 5.2705 ) sin( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.0 ) = −5
∂P3 = −V3V2 Y32 sin( θ 32 + δ 2 − δ 3 ) ∂δ 2 = −( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 5.2705 ) sin( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.0 ) = −5 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
88
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Elements of J1:
∂P3 = V3V1Y31 sin( θ 31 + δ 1 − δ 3 ) ∂δ 3 + V3V2Y23 sin( θ 32 + δ 2 − δ 3 ) = ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 15.8114 )sin( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.0 ) + ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 5.2705 )sin( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.0 ) = 20
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
89
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Elements of J2:
∂P2 V3 = V2V3Y23 cos(θ 23 + δ 3 + δ 2 ) ∂V3
= (1.0 )(1.0 )(5.2705) cos(108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.0 ) = −1.6667
∂P3 V3 = P3 + V32Y33 cos θ 33 ∂ V3 = 0.0 + ( 1.0 )2 ( 8.2233 )cos( − 71.5649 ) = 2.9167 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
90
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Elements of J3:
∂Q3 = −V3V2 Y32 cos( θ 32 + δ 2 − δ 3 ) ∂δ 2 = −( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 5.2705 )cos( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.0 ) = 1.6667
∂ Q3 = V3V1Y31 cos( θ 31 + δ 1 − δ 3 ) ∂δ 3 + V3Y2Y32 cos( θ 32 + δ 2 − δ 3 ) = ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 15.8114 )cos( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.0 ) + ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 5.2705 )cos( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.0 ) = − 6.6667 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
91
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Elements of J4:
∂Q3 V3 = Q3 − V32Y33 sin θ 33 ∂V3 2 = 0.0 − (1.0) (21.0819 )sin (− 71.5649 ) = 20 In Matrix Form,
⎡ 8.75 ⎢ −5 ⎢ ⎢⎣1.6667
−5
−1.6667 ⎤ 20 2.9167 ⎥⎥ −6.6667 20 ⎥⎦
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
92
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Solving for Gradients,
−5 −1.6667⎤ ⎡ Δδ2 ⎤ ⎡ 0.2 ⎤ ⎡ 8.75 ⎢ −0.6 ⎥ = ⎢ −5 ⎥ ⎢ Δδ ⎥ 20 2.9167 3 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥⎢ ⎢⎣−0.25⎥⎦ ⎢⎣1.6667 −6.6667 20 ⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ΔV3 / V3 ⎥⎦
Δδ = 0.003984rad . = 0.2283 deg 0 2
Δδ = −0.02587rad. = −1.4822deg ΔV30 0 = −0.02145 ΔV3 = −0.02145 0 3
V3
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
93
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Update Initial Estimates
δ 21 = δ 20 + Δδ 20 δ 21 = 0.0 + 0.2283 = 0.2283 δ 31 = δ 30 + Δδ 30 δ 31 = 0.0 − 1.4822 = −1.4822 V = V + ΔV 1 3
0 3
0 3
V31 = 1.0 − 0.02145 = 0.97855
Specified Variables
V11 = 1.0
δ 11 = 0.0 V21 = 1.0
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
94
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Update Estimates of Injected Power
P21 = V2V1Y21 cos(θ 31 + δ1 − δ 3 ) + V2V2Y22 cos(θ 22 ) + V2V3Y23 cos(θ 23 + δ 3 − δ 2 ) = (1.0)(1.0)(3.9528) cos(108.4349 + 0.0 + 1.4822) + (1.0)(1.0)(9.2233) cos(− 71.5649) + (1.0)(0.97855)(5.2705) cos(108.4349 − 1.4822 − 0.2283) = 0.1975
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
95
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Update Estimates of Injected Power
P31 = V3V1Y31 cos( θ31 + δ1 − δ 3 ) + V3V2Y32 cos( θ32 + δ 2 − δ 3 ) + V3V3Y33 cos( θ 33 ) = ( 0.97855 )( 1.0 )( 15.8114 )cos( 108.4349 + 0.0 + 1.4822 ) + ( 0.97855 )( 1.0 )( 5.2705 )cos(108.4349 + 0.2283 + 1.4822 ) + ( 0.97855 )( 0.97855 )( 21.0819 )cos( −71.5650 ) = −0.66633
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
96
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Update Estimates of Injected Power
Q31 = −[V3V1Y31 sin( θ31 + δ1 − δ3 ) + V3V2Y32 sin( θ32 + δ2 − δ3 ) +V3V3Y33 sin( θ 33 )]
= - [(0.97855 )(1.0 )(15.8114 )sin(108.4349 + 0.0 + 1.4822 ) + (0.97855 )(1.0 )( 5.2705 )sin(108.4349 + 0.2283 + 1.4822 ) +(0.97855 )(0.97855 )( 21.0819 )sin( −71.5650 )] = −0.2375
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
97
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Compute Power Mismatch Δ P2 = P2 ,s p − P2 ,c a lc = 0 .2 − 0 .1 9 7 5 = 0 .0 0 2 5
Δ P3 = P3 ,s p − P3 ,c a lc = − 0 .6 + 0 .6 6 3 3 = 0 .0 6 3 3
Δ Q 3 = Q 3 ,s p − Q 3 ,c a lc = − .0 .2 5 + 0 .2 3 7 5 = 0 .0 1 2 5 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Proceed to Iteration 2 Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
98
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Evaluate Elements of Jacobian Matrix Elements of J1:
∂P2 = VVY 2 1 21 sin( θ21 + δ1 − δ2 ) ∂δ2 +VV 2 3Y23 sin(θ23 + δ3 − δ2 ) = (1.0)(1.0)(3.9528)sin(108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.2283) + (1.0)(0.97855)(5.2705)sin(108.4349 − 1.4822 − 0.2283) = 8.6942
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
99
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Elements of J1:
∂P2 = −V2V3Y23 sin(θ23 + δ3 − δ2 ) ∂δ3 = −(1.0 )(0.97855)(5.2705)sin(108.4349 − 1.4822 − 0.2283) = −4.9393 ∂P3 = −VV 3 2Y32 sin( θ32 + δ2 − δ3 ) ∂δ2 = −(0.97855)(1.0)(5.2705)sin(108.4349 + 0.2283 + 1.4822) = −4.8419
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
100
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Elements of J1:
∂P3 = V3V1Y31 sin( θ31 + δ1 − δ3 ) ∂δ3 + V3V2Y23 sin( θ32 + δ2 − δ3 ) = (0.97855 )(1.0 )(15.8114 )sin(108.4349 + 0.0 + 1.4822 ) + (0.97855 )(1.0 )( 5.2705 )sin(108.4349 + 0.2283 + 1.4822 ) = 19.3887
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
101
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Elements of J2:
∂P2 = V2V3Y23 cos(θ 23 + δ 3 + δ 2 ) V3 ∂V3
= (1.0 )(0.097855)(5.2705) cos(108.4349 + 1.4822 − 0.2283)
= −1.4842
∂P3 V3 = P3 + V32Y33 cos θ 33 ∂V3 = −0.6633 + ( 0.97855 )2 ( 21.0819 )cos( −71.5650 ) = 5.7205 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
102
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Elements of J3:
∂Q3 = −VV 3 2Y32 cos( θ32 + δ2 − δ3 ) ∂δ2 = −(0.97855)(1.0 )(5.2705)cos(108.4349 + 0.2283 + 1.4822) = 1.7762
∂Q3 = V3V1Y31 cos( θ31 + δ1 − δ 3 ) ∂δ 3 + V3Y2Y32 cos( θ32 + δ 2 − δ 3 ) = ( 0.97855 )( 1.0 )( 15.8114 )cos( 108.4349 + 0.0 + 1.4822 ) + ( 0.97855 )( 1.0 )( 5.2705 )cos( 108.4349 + 0.2283 + 1.4822 ) = −7.0470 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
103
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Elements of J4:
∂P3 V3 = Q3 − V32Y33 sinθ 33 ∂δ 3 = −0.2375 − ( 0.97855 )2 ( 21.0819 )sin( −71.565 ) = 18.9137 In Matrix Form,
⎡ 8.6942 −4.9393 −1.4842⎤ ⎢−4.8419 19.3887 5.7205 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢⎣ 1.7762 −7.0470 18.9137 ⎥⎦ U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
104
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Solving for Gradients,
⎡ 0.0025 ⎤ ⎡ 8.6942 −4.9393 −1.4842⎤ ⎡ Δδ 2 ⎤ ⎢ 0.0633 ⎥ = ⎢−4.8419 19.3887 5.7205 ⎥ ⎢ Δδ ⎥ 3 ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥⎢ ⎥ ⎢⎣−0.0125⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ 1.7762 −7.0470 18.9137 ⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ΔV3 / V3 ⎥⎦
Δδ 21 = 0.0025 rad x 180 0 / πrad = 0.1458 0
Δδ 31 = 0.0038 rad x 180 0 / πrad = 0.2150 0
ΔV30 V3
= 0.0005
Δ V 31 = (0 .0005 )(0 .97855 ) = 0 .0005
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
105
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Update Previous Estimates
δ 22 = δ 21 + Δδ 21 = 0.2283 + 0.1458 = 0.37410
δ 32 = δ 31 + Δδ 31 = − 1.4822 + 0.2150 = − 1.2672 0 V = V + ΔV 2 3
1 3
1 3
= 0.97855 + 0.0005 = 0.9791
Specified Variables
V11 = 1.0
δ 11 = 0.0 V21 = 1.0 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
106
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Update Previous Estimates of Injected Power
P22 = V2V1Y21 cos( θ21 + δ1 − δ 2 ) + V2V2Y22 cos( θ22 ) + V2V3Y23 cos( θ23 + δ 3 − δ 2 ) = (1.0 )( 1.0 )( 3.9528 )cos( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 0.3741) + ( 1.0 )( 1.0 )( 9.2233 )cos( −71.5649 ) + ( 1.0 )( 0.9791)( 5.2705 )cos(108.4349 − 1.2672 − 0.3741) = 0.2018
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
107
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Update Previous Estimates of Injected Power
P32 = V3V1Y31 cos( θ 31 + δ 1 − δ 3 ) + V3V2Y32 cos( θ 22 + δ 2 − δ 3 ) + V3V3Y33 cos θ 33 = ( 0.9791 )( 1.0 )( 15.8114 )cos( 108.4349 + 0.0 − 1.2672 ) + ( 0.9791 )( 1.0 )( 5.2705 )cos( 108.4349 + 0.3741 + 1.2672 ) + ( 0.9791 )( 0.9791 )( 21.0819 )cos( −71.5650 ) = −0.5995
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
108
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Update Previous Estimates of Injected Power
Q32 = −[V3V1Y31 sin( θ31 + δ1 − δ3 )
+V3V2Y32 sin( θ32 + δ2 − δ3 ) + V3V3Y33 sinθ33 ]
= −[(0.9791)(1.0 )(15.8114 )sin(108.4349 + 0.0 − 1.2672 ) + (0.9791)(1.0 )( 5.2705 )sin(108.4349 + 0.37411 + 1.2672 ) +(0.9791)(0.9791)( 21.0819 )sin( −71.5650 )] = −0.2487
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
109
Newton-Raphson Load Flow Compute Power Mismatch Δ P2 = P2 ,s p − P2 ,c a lc = 0 .2 − 0 .2 0 1 8 = 0 .0 0 1 8
Δ P3 = P3 ,s p − P3 ,c a lc = − 0 .6 + 0 .5 9 9 5 = 0 .0 0 0 5
Δ Q 3 = Q 3 ,s p − Q 3 ,c a lc = − .0 .2 5 + 0 .2 4 8 7 = 0 .0 0 1 3 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
The solution has converged Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
110
Newton-Raphson Load Flow The solution of the Load Flow Problem is
V1 = 1.0∠0 0 V2 = 1.0∠0.37410 V3 = 0.9791∠ − 1.26720
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
111
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow
Load Flow for Radial Distribution System
Procedure: Iterative Solution
Initialization
Solving for Injected Currents through the nodes
Backward Sweep
Forward Sweep
Solving for Injected Power
Solving for Voltage Mismatch
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
112
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Bus2 Bus1 I12 , Loss12 = ?
Utility Grid
I23 , Loss23 = ? 0.635 + j1.970 立
Bus3 V3 = ? P3 , Q3 = ?
I24 , Loss24 = ? V4 = ? P4 , Q4 = ? 0.4223 + j0.7980 立 Bus4 V2 = ? Lumped Load A P2 , Q2 = ? 2 MVA 85%PF Lumped Load B 1 MVA 85%PF
0.131 + j1.595 立
V1 = 67 kV
P1 , Q1 = ?
Load Flow for Radial Distribution System
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
113
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Equivalent Circuit Bus2 V1 = 67 kV
Utility Grid
0.0364 +j 0.1131 pu
Bus1 0.0075+j 0.0915 pu
V1
~
0.0242+j0.0458pu
1 + j0 pu
V2
Base Values
Bus3 V3
Bus4 V4
0.085 + j0.05267 pu
0.17 + j0.10536 pu
Sbase = 10 MVA Vbase1 = 67 kV
Base Z =13.22/10 =17.424立
Vbase2 = 13.2 kV U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
114
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Iterative Solution 1. Solve Injected Currents by Loads 2. Solve Line Currents (Backward Sweep) 3. Update Voltages (Forward Sweep) 4. Solve for Injected Power 5. Solve for Power Mismatch Continue iteration by Backward-Forward Sweep until convergence is achieved After convergence, solve Iinj, Pinj, Qinj, PF, PLoss, QLoss U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
115
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Initialization Bus2 V1 = 67 kV
Utility Grid
Bus1
0.0364 +j 0.1131 pu
0.0075+j 0.0915 pu
V1
~
0.0242+j0.0458 pu
1 + j0 pu
Initialize,
V2
V1(0) = 1/0
Bus3 V3
Bus4 V4
0.085 + j0.05267 pu
0.17 + j0.10536 pu
V2(0) = 1/0 V3(0) = 1/0 V4(0) = 1/0 U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
116
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Solving for Injected Currents Bus2 V1 = 67 kV
Utility Grid
0.0364 +j 0.1131 pu
Bus1 0.0075+j 0.0915 pu
V1
~
0.0242+j0.0458 pu
1 + j0 pu
Solve Injected Currents by Loads
V2
Bus3 V3
Bus4 V4
0.17 + j0.10536 pu
0.085 + j0.05267 pu
I1(0) = 0 I2(0) = 0 I3(0) = S3* /[V3(0)]* = __________ I4(0) = S4* /[V4(0)]* = __________
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
117
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Backward Sweep Bus2 V1 = 67 kV
Utility Grid
0.0364 +j 0.1131 pu
Bus1 0.0075+j 0.0915 pu
V1
~
0.0242+j0.0458 pu
1 + j0 pu
Solve Line Currents (Backward Sweep)
V2
Bus3 V3
Bus4 V4
0.17 + j0.10536 pu
0.085 + j0.05267 pu
I24(0) = I4(0) = _______ I23(0) = I3(0) = _______ I12(0) = 0 + I23(0) + I24(0) = _______
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
118
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Forward Sweep Bus2 V1 = 67 kV
Bus1
Utility Grid
0.0364 +j 0.1131 pu
0.0075+j 0.0915 pu
V1
~
0.0242+j0.0458 pu
1 + j0 pu
V2
Bus3 V3
Bus4 V4
0.085 + j0.05267 pu
0.17 + j0.10536 pu
Update Voltages
V1(1) = 1/0
(Forward Sweep)
V3(1) = V2(1) – [I23(0)][Z23] = ________
V2(1) = V1(0) – [I12(0)][Z12] = ________ V4(1) = V2(1) – [I24(0)][Z24] = ________
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
119
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Solving for Injected Power Bus2 V1 = 67 kV
Utility Grid
Bus1
0.0364 +j 0.1131 pu
0.0075+j 0.0915 pu
V1
~
0.0242+j0.0458 pu
1 + j0 pu
Solve Injected Power
V2
Bus3 V3
Bus4 V4
0.085+ j0.05267 pu
0.17 + j0.10536 pu
S1(1) = [V1(1)][I1(0)]* = ___________ S2(1) = [V2(1)][I2(0)]* = ___________ S3(1) = [V3(1)][I3(0)]* = ___________ S4(1) = [V4(1)][I4(0)]* = ___________
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
120
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Solving for Power Mismatch Bus2 V1 = 67 kV
Utility Grid
Bus1
0.0364 +j 0.1131 pu
0.0075+j 0.0915 pu
V1
~
0.0242+j0.0458 pu
1 + j0 pu
V2
Bus3 V3
Bus4 V4
0.085 + j0.05267 pu
0.17 + j0.10536 pu
Solve ΔS1(1) = S1(sp) - S1(calc) = ____________ Power Mismatch ΔS2(1) = S2(sp) – S2(calc) = ____________ ΔS3(1) = S3(sp) – S3(calc) = ____________ ΔS4(1) = S4(sp) – S4(calc) = ____________ U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
121
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Iterative Solution Iteration 2: Solve Injected Currents by Loads
I1(1) = 0 I2(1) = 0 I3(1) = S3* /[V3(1)]* = __________ I4(1) = S4* /[V4(1)]* = __________
Solve Line Currents (Backward Sweep)
I24(1) = I4(1) = _______ I23(1) = I3(1) = _______ I12(1) = 0 + I23(1) + I24(1) = _______
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
122
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Iterative Solution Update Voltages
V1(2) = 1/0
(Forward Sweep)
V3(2) = V2(1) – [I23(1)][Z23] = ________
V2(2) = V1(1) – [I12(1)][Z12] = ________ V4(2) = V2(1) – [I24(1)][Z24] = ________
Solve Injected Power
S1(2) = [V1(2)][I1(1)]* = ___________ S2(2) = [V2(2)][I2(1)]* = ___________ S3(2) = [V3(2)][I3(1)]* = ___________ S4(2) = [V4(2)][I4(1)]* = ___________
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
123
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Iterative Solution Solve Power Mismatch
ΔS1(2) = S1(sp) - S1(calc) = ____________ ΔS2(2) = S2(sp) – S2(calc) = ____________ ΔS3(2) = S3(sp) – S3(calc) = ____________ ΔS4(2) = S4(sp) – S4(calc) = ____________
If Mismatch is higher than set convergence index, repeat the procedure (Backward-Forward Sweep) [Iteration 3]
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
124
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Iterative Solution Iteration 3: Solve Injected Currents by Loads
I1(2) = 0 I2(2) = 0 I3(2) = S3* /[V3(2)]* = __________ I4(2) = S4* /[V4(2)]* = __________
Solve Line Currents (Backward Sweep)
I24(2) = I4(2) = _______ I23(2) = I3(2) = _______ I12(2) = 0 + I23(2) + I24(2) = _______
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
125
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Iterative Solution Update Voltages
V1(3) = 1/0
(Forward Sweep)
V3(3) = V2(2) – [I23(2)][Z23] = ________
V2(3) = V1(2) – [I12(2)][Z12] = ________ V4(3) = V2(2) – [I24(2)][Z24] = ________
Solve Injected Power
S1(3) = [V1(3)][I1(2)]* = ___________ S2(3) = [V2(3)][I2(2)]* = ___________ S3(3) = [V3(3)][I3(2)]* = ___________ S4(3) = [V4(3)][I4(2)]* = ___________
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
126
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Iterative Solution Solve Power Mismatch
ΔS1(3) = S1(3) - S1(2) ΔS2(3) = S2(3) – S2(2) = ____________ ΔS3(3) = S3(3) – S3(2) = ____________ ΔS4(3) = S4(3) – S4(2) = ____________
If Mismatch is lower than set convergence index, compute power flows
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
127
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Bus2 0.0364 +j 0.1131 pu
Bus1
Utility Grid
Bus3
0.0242+j0.0458 0.0075+j 0.0915 pu
Bus4 Lumped Load A 2 MVA 85%PF
VOLTAGE PROFILE Lumped Load B 1 MVA 85%PF
V1 = ________ V2 = ________
INJECTED POWER
V3 = ________
P1 + jQ1 = ________ + j ________
V4 = ________
P2 + jQ2 = ________ + j ________ P3 + jQ3 = ________ + j ________ P4 + jQ4 = ________ + j ________
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
128
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Bus2 0.0364 +j 0.1131 pu
Bus1
Utility Grid
Bus3
0.0242+j0.0458 pu 0.0075+j 0.0915 pu
POWER FLOW (P-Q)
Bus4 Lumped Load A 2 MVA 85%PF
P12 + jQ12 = ________ + j ________ P23 + jQ23 = ________ + j ________
Lumped Load B 1 MVA 85%PF
P24 + jQ24 = ________ + j ________ POWER FLOW (Q-P) P21 + jQ21 = ________ + j ________ P32 + jQ32 = ________ + j ________ P42 + jQ42 = ________ + j ________ U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
129
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Bus2 0.0364 +j 0.1131 pu
Bus1
Utility Grid
0.0075+j 0.0915 pu
0.0242+j0.0458 pu
Bus4
Branch Currents
Lumped Load A 2 MVA 85%PF
I12 = ________
Lumped Load B 1 MVA 85%PF
I23 = ________ I24 = ________
Bus3
POWER LOSSES I2R12 + jI2X12 = ________ + j ________ I2R23 + jI2X24 = ________ + j ________ I2R24 + jI2X24 = ________ + j ________
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
130
Backward/Forward Sweep Load Flow Line sections in the radial network are ordered by layers away from the root node (substation bus). 1 2 4 7 13
8
8 14
21
22 27
Layer 1
3 5
9 15
23
Layer 2
6
10 11 17 16
12 18
32
20
19
24 28
Layer 3 Layer 4 26
25
29
30 33
34 35
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
31
Layer 5 Layer 6 Layer 7 Layer 8
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
131
Three-Phase Forward/ Backward Sweep Method The iterative algorithm for solving the radial system consists of three steps. At iteration k: Step 1: Nodal current calculation
⎡ I ia ⎤ ⎢I ⎥ ⎢ ib ⎥ ⎢⎣ I ic ⎥⎦
(k)
Where,
( ( (
⎡ S / V ( k −1 ) ⎢ ia ia( k −1 ) = ⎢ Sib / Vib ⎢ S / V ( k −1 ) ⎢⎣ ic ic
I ia , I ib , I ic
) ) )
⎤ ⎡Y * ia ⎥ ∗ ⎢ * Yib ⎥−⎢ ∗⎥ ⎢ ⎥⎦ ⎣ ∗
⎤ ⎡Via ⎤ ⎥⎢ ⎥ ⎥ ⎢Vib ⎥ *⎥ Yic ⎦ ⎢⎣Vic ⎥⎦
( k −1 )
Current injections at node i
S ia , S ib , S ic Scheduled power injections at node i V ia ,V ib ,V ic Voltages at node i Y ia ,Y ib ,Y ic
Admittances of all shunt elements at node i
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
132
Three-Phase Forward/ Backward Sweep Method Step 2: Backward Sweep to sum up line section current Starting from the line section in the last layer and moving towards the root node. The current in the line section l is:
⎡ J la ⎤ ⎢J ⎥ ⎢ lb ⎥ ⎢⎣ J lc ⎥⎦ Where,
(k)
⎡ I ja ⎤ ⎢ ⎥ = − ⎢ I jb ⎥ ⎢ I jc ⎥ ⎣ ⎦
(k)
⎡ J ma ⎤ ⎥ ⎢ + ∑ ⎢ J mb ⎥ m∈M ⎢⎣ J mc ⎥⎦
(k )
J la , J lb , J jc
are the current flows on line section l
l and M
Is the set of line sections connected to node j
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
133
Three-Phase Forward/ Backward Sweep Method Step 3: Forward Sweep to update nodal voltage Starting from the first layer and moving towards the last layer, the voltage at node j is:
⎡V ja ⎤ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢V jb ⎥ ⎢V jc ⎥ ⎣ ⎦
(k )
⎡Via ⎤ ⎥ ⎢ = ⎢Vib ⎥ ⎢⎣Vic ⎥⎦
(k)
⎡ zaa ,l ⎢ − ⎢ zab ,l ⎢⎣ zac ,l
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
zab ,l zbb ,l zbc ,l
zac ,l ⎤ ⎡ J la ⎤ ⎥⎢ ⎥ zbc ,l ⎥ ⎢ J lb ⎥ zcc ,l ⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ J lc ⎥⎦
(k )
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
134
Three-Phase Forward/ Backward Sweep Method After the three steps are executed in one iteration, the power mismatches at each node for all phases are calculated:
ΔS
(k ) ia
=V
(k ) ia
ΔS
(k ) ib
=V
(k ) ib
ΔS
(k ) ic
=V
(k ) ic
(I ) (I ) (I )
(k ) ∗ ia
* ia
− Y Via
2
− S ia
(k ) ∗ ib
* ia
− Y Vib
2
− S ib
(k ) ∗ ic
− Y Vic
2
− S ic
* ic
If the real and imaginary part (real and reactive power) of any of these power mismatches is greater than a convergence criterion, steps 1, 2 & 3 are repeated until convergence is achieved. U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
135
Principles of Load Flow Control
Prime mover and excitation control of generators
Reactive Var Compensation (e.g., Capacitors)
Control of tap-changing and voltage regulating transformers
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
136
Principles of Load Flow Control Generator Voltage & Power Control jX Ei∠δ
~
I
The complex power delivered to the bus (Generator Terminal) is
Vt∠0
⎡ E ∠δ − Vt ∠0 ⎤ Pt + jQt = [Vt ∠0]I * = [Vt ∠0]⎢ i ⎥ jX ⎦ ⎣
⎡ EiVt ⎤ Pt = ⎢ sinδ ⎥ ⎣ X ⎦ U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
⎡ EiVt Vt 2 ⎤ Qt = ⎢ cosδ − ⎥ X⎦ ⎣ X Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
137
Principles of Load Flow Control Generator Voltage & Power Control
⎡ EiVt ⎤ Pt = ⎢ sinδ ⎥ ⎣ X ⎦
⎡ EiVt Vt 2 ⎤ Qt = ⎢ cosδ − ⎥ X⎦ ⎣ X
Observations: 1. Real Power is injected into the bus (Generator Operation), δ must be positive (Ei leads Vt) 2. Real Power is drawn from the bus (Motor Operation), δ must be negative (Ei lags Vt) 3. In actual operation, the numeric value of δ is small & since the slope of Sine function is maximum for small values, a minute change in δ can cause a substantial change in Pt U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
138
Principles of Load Flow Control Generator Voltage & Power Control
⎤ ⎡ EiVt Pt = ⎢ sinδ ⎥ ⎣ X ⎦
⎡ EiVt Vt 2 ⎤ Qt = ⎢ cosδ − ⎥ X⎦ ⎣ X
Observations: 4. Reactive Power flow depends on relative values of EiCosδ and Vt 5. Since the slope of Cosine function is minimum for small values of angle, Reactive Power is controlled by varying Ei • Over-excitation (increasing Ei) will deliver Reactive Power into the Bus • Under-excitation (decreasing Ei) will absorb Reactive Power from the Bus U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
139
Principles of Load Flow Control Capacitor Compensation ~ p
Ipq
The voltage of bus q can be expressed as
q + jQc PL - jQL
Eq = Vp â&#x2C6;&#x2019;
X pqQq Vp
â&#x2C6;&#x2019;j
X pq Pq Vp
Observations: 1. The Reactive Power Qq causes a voltage drop and thus largely affects the magnitude of Eq 2. A capacitor bank connected to bus q will reduce Qq that will consequently reduce voltage drop U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
140
Principles of Load Flow Control Tap-Changing Transformer a:1 q s
r
The π equivalent circuit of transformer with the per unit transformation ratio:
1 y pq a
p
Observation: The voltage drop in the transformer is affected by the transformation ratio “a”
1− a y pq 2 a
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
a −1 y pq a
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
141
Uses of Load Flow Study
Sensitivity Analysis with Load Flow Study
Analysis of Existing Conditions
Analysis for Correcting PQ Problems
Expansion Planning
Contingency Analysis
System Loss Analysis
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
142
Uses of Load Flow Studies Sensitivity Analysis with Load Flow Study 1) Take any line, transformer or generator out of service. 2) Add, reduce or remove load to any or all buses. 3) Add, remove or shift generation to any bus. 4) Add new transmission or distribution lines. 5) Increase conductor size on T&D lines. 6) Change bus voltages. 7) Change transformer taps. 8) Increase or decrease transformer size. 9) Add or remove rotating or static var supply to buses. U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
143
Uses of Load Flow Studies 1) ANALYSIS OF EXISTING CONDITIONS • Check for voltage violations PGC: 0.95 – 1.05 p.u. (For Transmission) PDC: 0.90 – 1.10 p.u (For Distribution)* *Recommended 0.95 – 1.05 p.u.
• Check for branch power flow violations Transformer Overloads Line Overloads • Check for system losses Caps on Segregated DSL
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
144
Uses of Load Flow Studies 2) ANALYSIS FOR CORRECTING PQ PROBLEMS â&#x20AC;˘ Voltage adjustment by utility at delivery point Request TransCo to improve voltage at connection point TransCo as System Operator will determine feasibility based on Economic Dispatch and other adjustments such as transformer tap changing and reactive power compensation
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
145
Uses of Load Flow Studies 2) ANALYSIS FOR CORRECTING PQ PROBLEMS â&#x20AC;˘ Transformer tap changing Available Taps At Primary Side At Secondary Side Both Sides
Typical Taps
Tap 1: +5% Tap 2: +2.5% Tap 3: 0% (Rated Voltage) Tap 4: -2.5% Tap 5: -5%
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
146
Uses of Load Flow Studies 2) ANALYSIS FOR CORRECTING PQ PROBLEMS •Capacitor compensation • Compensate for Peak Loading • Check overvoltages during Off-Peak • Optimize Capacitor Plan • System configuration improvement
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
147
Uses of Load Flow Studies 3) EXPANSION PLANNING • • • • • • •
New substation construction Substation capacity expansion New feeder segment construction / extension Addition of parallel feeder segment Reconducting of existing feeder segment/ circuit Circuit conversion to higher voltage Generator addition
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
148
Uses of Load Flow Studies 4) CONTINGENCY ANALYSIS Reliability analysis of the Transmission (Grid) and Subtransmission System 5) SYSTEM LOSS ANALYSIS Segregation of System Losses
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering
Training Course in Load Flow Analysis
U. P. National Engineering Center National Electrification Administration
149
Competency Training & Certification Program in Electric Power Distribution System Engineering