35 Years of Conflict: Sir Stuart Atha, Ukraine and ‘Huge Gambles’

6 IMPACT 35 Years of Conflict: Sir Stuart Atha, Ukraine and ‘Huge Gambles’

Stuart Atha led Britain in some of the most high-profile military engagements in British history, including Iraq and Afghanistan. Now retired, Impact’s Head of News Lauren McGaun spoke to the Honorary Professor about his extraordinary career and some of his insights for the future.

Although never particularly interested in the military, Stuart decided on his path during his third year at Glasgow University. After seeing a poster for the University Air Squadron, Stuart decided to give it a try. Upon graduating, Stuart became a pilot officer, working his way up the ranks to senior commander.

“We have only seen some of the capabilities that Putin has in Ukraine, he has got many more”

Whilst Stuart oversaw many operational decisions, most of his career was spent supporting the development of other officers. “What you don’t see is that 99% of your time is actually spent on training and education,” he said.

Stuart explained how following orders has been a consistent theme in the Royal Air Force. “The young men and women that I led would actually be as keen to do what they’re asked to do as any generation that’s gone before.”

Stuart also recognised that there were setbacks that came with this immense responsibility. Speaking on the psychological impact of war, Stuart said: “I think we recognise [the issue of mental health], but I think just like in society, we’ve probably still got some way to go.”

Whilst Stuart has been involved in a broad range of conflicts, he is most noted for the Iraq War. Asked about the war, Stuart remarked: “I have lots of regrets when it comes to the Iraq War and the failure of planning.” Stuart also found the scale of destruction particularly hard to process. “My greatest sadness is perhaps the loss of life, both Iraqi and our own, that there was during that warfighting phase,” he said. However, he felt the military were left with no choice: “There is no risk-free option in conflict.”

Recognising Stuart’s exceptional commitment to the military, he received honours (CB and KBE) from the Queen in 2015 and 2019. “To be able to say that you have met the Queen, it’s just one of those special experiences that adds to a number of very special experiences within the military.” Reflecting on Ukraine, Stuart said that Putin’s invasion has faced tactical flaws from the outset. “I can’t believe what Putin set out to do: a four axis attack into Ukraine, which was something that I think was a huge gamble. I think it’s a gamble that’s failed.” He continued: “They haven’t had the training and they are up against a more determined foe in Ukraine.”

Does the Russian threat therefore mean that we are set for another world war? Stuart thinks it is unlikely but warns not to rule out the possibility. “We have only seen some of the capabilities that Putin has in Ukraine, he has got many more.” He added: “Part of my job previously was to look at a very dark place, which was very unlikely. But if it could happen, and it might change the world, then it becomes a priority.”

To round off the discussion, Stuart provided some words of wisdom for students aspiring to pursue a military path: “I have not met one person who said they regretted joining the military. It may not be for everyone, but I think that it offers you a really rewarding and satisfying career.”

By Lauren McGaun

Photography by Stuart Atha Page design by Gemma Cockrell