Revista de Estudios de Juventud. Nº 82. Jóvenes y gestión del riesgo by Instituto de la Juventud de España

≥ Septiembre 08

Jóvenes y gestión del riesgo

§ HZei^ZbWgZ %- q C°

G:K>HI6 9: :HIJ9>DH 9: ?JK:CIJ9

? kZcZh n \Zhi^ c YZa g^Zh\d 8ddgY^cVYdgVh :aZcV GdYg \jZo HVc ?ja^{c HjhVcV B cYZo <V\d

G:K>HI6 9: :HIJ9>DH 9: ?JK:CIJ9

2W`SQb]` 5OP`WSZ /ZQ]\QVSZ ;]`OZSa 1]]`RW\OQW \ RSZ \ [S`] 3ZS\O @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ AcaO\O ;{\RSh 5OU] 2WaS ] 5`t¿Q]

7ZcabÒQW]\Sa ;O` O 1OZhORWZZO 5O`Q O 1ObtZ]U] US\SÒZ RS ^cPZWQOQW]\Sa ]¿QWOZSa Vbb^( eee $ Sa 3RWQW \ 7\abWbcb] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR @SROQQW \ =PaS`dOb]`W] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR S\ 3aÔ O AS`dWQW] RS 2]Qc[S\bOQW \ g 3abcRW]a BSZ ' !$! %& ' 4Of ' !$! %& 3 [OWZ( SabcRW]a W\XcdS.[WUcOZROR Sa 0WPZW]bSQO RS 8cdS\bcR 1 ;O`_c{a RSZ @WaQOZ $ BSZ ' !"% %% 3 [OWZ( PWPZW]bSQO W\XcdS.[WUcOZROR Sa

7AA<( "!$" <7>=( & ' $ ' 2S^ :SUOZ( ; " &# '& 7[^`SaW \( :3@9= >@7<B A / :Oa ]^W\W]\Sa ^cPZWQOROa S\ {abS \ [S`] Q]``Sa^]\RS\ O aca Ocb]`Sa 3Z 7\abWbcb] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR \] Q][^O`bS \SQSaO`WO[S\bS SZ Q]\bS\WR] RS ZOa [Wa[Oa

ÞC9>8:

§ HZei^ZbWgZ %- q C°

? kZcZh n \Zhi^ c YZa g^Zh\d

-' :A I:B6 q e{\# *

7\b`]RcQQW \ q e{\# ,

@WSaU] g a]QWSROR @SdWaO\R] ZOa O^`]fW[OQW]\Sa OZ `WSaU] QcO\R] VOPZO[]a RS XcdS\bcR q e{\# &( 3ZS\O @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\

:Oa ^S`dS`aW]\Sa RS µZO O[S\OhO RSZ `WSaU]¶ q e{\# (& AcaO\O ;{\RSh 5OU]

! 3Z Q]\QS^b] RS µ\]`[OZWROR¶ S\ SZ Q]\bSfb] RS Z]a `WSaU]a Oa]QWOR]a O Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa g ZO USabW \ RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa q e{\# ), 7U\OQW] ;SU Oa ?cW` a

" 3Z `WSaU] g ZO USabW \ RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa RSaRS ZO ^S`a^SQbWdO RS U{\S`] q e{\# +, ;O` ;]`]ZZ \ >O`R]

# @WSaU] XcdS\bcR g Sf^S`WS\QWOa RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ q e{\# -( 8cO\ 1O`Z]a 0OZZSabS`]a

$ ¥8 dS\Sa S\ ^SZWU`] ] ^SZWU`]a]a- /ZO`[Oa g bSQ\]Z]U Oa a]QWOZSa RSZ µRSaO``]ZZ]¶ g U]PWS`\] RWUWbOZ q e{\# &%( È\USZ 8 5]`R] : ^Sh

% 8 dS\Sa S[^`S\RSR]`Sa S\ PcaQO RS ZO ]^]`bc\WROR q e{\# &&, ;S`QSRSa 5O`Q O @cWh

& @WSaU] 2SaO``]ZZ] g 1]]^SÒQW \ 7\bS`\OQW]\OZ 1]\bÒabO\R] dWaW]\Sa RSaRS Z]a R]a ZOR]a RS ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ q e{\# &)& /ZSXO\RÒ 0]\W /`WabWhtPOZ g 3dO /RO[ >WQOh]

' 3Z `WSaU] S\ SZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] /QS`QO RS aca ZSQbc`Oa RWOU\ abWQ]a g ^`]bSQQW]\Sa q e{\# &*, 8Oc[S 1O`P]\SZZ ASPO``]XO

8cdS\bcR g `WSaU]a C\O [W`ORO VOQWO SZ Tcbc`] q e{\# &,( 8Saย a 5O`Q O DS`RcU]

B6I:G>6A:H q e{\# &-. 8DA67DG68>รขC q e{\# '&,

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

:A I:B6

? kZcZh n \Zhi^ c YZa g^Zh\d

:A I:B6

2cÒ\bS ZOa ZbW[Oa R{QOROa VS[]a RSTW\WR] SZ `WSaU] OQ]bOR] aca RW[S\aW]\Sa QObSU]`WhOR] aca Q][^]\S\bSa SabO\RO`WhOR] aca \WdSZSa RSbS`[W\OR] Z]a ^S`TWZSa g Z]a t[PWb]a RS `WSaU] RWaS OR] O^ZWQOR] g SdOZcOR] ^`]UÒ[Oa ÔÒ ^`SdS\W`Z] 3\ RSTW\WbWdO VS[]a bS\WR] ³g bS\S[]a³ c\ ZOÙ] VWab]`WOZ RS Q][^`][Wa] g RSRWQOQW \ S\ SZ bÒPOX] SfVOcabWd] ÔÒ ZO Q`SOQW \ RS VS`Ò[WS\bOa _cS \]a RSTWS\RO\ RSZ `WSaU] 6]g SfWabS S\ SZ aS\bW` Q]ZSQbWd] c\O aS\aWPWZWhOQW \ VOQWO SZ b{`[W\] `WSaU] g c\O [SX]` ^`SRWa^]aWQW \ VOQWO b]R] O_cSZZ] _cS Z] [W\W[WQS ] Z] SZW[W\S 3a ^]` Sa] _cWht _cS gO \] \SQSaWbO[]a OTS`Ò`\]a bO\ TcS`bS[S\bS OZ b{`[W\] S\ aca RWabW\bOa RW[S\aW]\Sa g ^]RS[]a aOZW`\]a RS ZO a][PÒ RS ac ^`SaW \ ÔÒ S[^ShO` O ]PaS`dO`Z] RSaRS TcSÒ 7\QZca] ÔÒ ^]\S` S\ QcSabW \ OZUc\Oa RS ZOa ac^cSabOa µQS`bShOa¶ Q]\aS\acOROa 3abS []\]U`tTWQ] bWS\S ZO TW\OZWROR RS O^`]fW[OàS OZ `WSaU] Q]\ ]bÒ ^bWQO W\Q]`^]Ò\R] bO[PW{\ ac aW\ \W[] ZO ]^]`bc\WROR g RSaRS ac ]bÒ Tc\QW \ ZO ^]aWbWdO >OÒ SZZ] S\ SabS R]Qc[S\b] aS `SdWaOÒ\ ^]aWQW]\Sa bS `WQOa g aS QcSabW]\O`t\ OfW][Oa O[^ZWO[S\bS OQS^bOR]a Q]\ ]PXSb] RS []dWZWhO` VOQWO c\O \cSdO O^`]fW[OQW \ OZ ^]ZWa{[WQ] Q]\QS^b] RSZ `WSaU]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

3Z RW\O[Wa[] RS ZOa a]QWSRORSa g Z]a Q]\bW\c]a OdO\QSa QWS\b TWQ]a g bSQ\]Z UWQ]a dO\ `SRSTW\WS\R] Z]a SaQS\O`W]a dWbOZSa RS ZO QWcRORO\ O C\O `SOZWROR _cS []dWZWhO O ZOa ^Sà]\Oa O ^]\S` S\ [O`QVO \cSd]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a ] O []RWTWQO`Z]a ÔÒ USabW]\O` O_cSZZOa \cSdOa dO`WOPZSa _cS dO\ acÙWS\R] S\ SZ S\b]`\] 6OQS RWSh O ]a ZO Q][c\WQOQW \ ^]` ;SaaS\US` A;A ] [OWZ \] Q]\bOPO\ Q]\ SZ \ [S`] RS cacO`W]a _cS V]g S\ R O bWS\S\ g bO[^]Q] Z]a cacO`W]a RS S\b]\QSa Z] VOQ O\ Q]\ ZO W\bS\aWROR \W Q]\ ZO T`SQcS\QWO Q]\ _cS Z] VOQS\ Z]a OQbcOZSa :O OÔ`WQW \ RS \cSd]a `SQcà]a bSQ\]Z UWQ]a Xc\b] Q]\ ZO Q]\abObOQW \ RS ZO cbWZWROR RS Z]a [Wa[]a VO O[^ZWOR] SZ OQS`d] W\RWdWRcOZ RS Q][c\WQOQW \ Q][] Z] VO VSQV] S\ ]b`]a t[PWb]a a]QWOZSa AW\ S[POÙ] S\ SaO O[^ZWOQW \ RS `SQcà]a g OQbWdWRORSa ZOa ^Sà]\Oa RSPS\ aWbcOàS S\ c\O \cSdO ^Sà^SQbWdO _cS Sa ZO RS Oac[W` Z]a `WSaU]a RS Sa]a \cSd]a SaQS\O`W]a AWbcOQW]\Sa RS dcZ\SÒPWZWROR _cS acÙS\ PWS\ RS Z]a \cSd]a `SQcà]a RSZ ca] RS Z]a [Wa[]a ] RS ZOa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa _cS Z]a S\dcSZdS\ <] ]PabO\bS Sab]a ^`]QSa]a RW\t[WQ]a \] a]\ [ta _cS [O\WTSabOQW]\Sa RS c\O Sd]ZcQW \ a]QWOZ S\ Q]\abO\bS ^`]U`Sa] _cS Q][] bOZ Q][] QcOZ_cWS` ^`]QSa] RS QO[PW] S\bÒ O `WSaU]a 2cÒ\bS ZOa ZbW[Oa R{QOROa VS[]a RSTW\WR] SZ `WSaU] OQ]bOR] aca RW[S\aW]\Sa QObSU]`WhOR] aca Q][^]\S\bSa SabO\RO`WhOR] aca \WdSZSa RSbS`[W\OR] Z]a ^S`TWZSa g Z]a t[PWb]a RS `WSaU] RWaS OR] O^ZWQOR] g SdOZcOR] ^`]UÒ[Oa ÔÒ ^`SdS\W`Z] 3\ RSTW\WbWdO VS[]a bS\WR] ³g bS\S[]a³ c\ ZOÙ] VWab]`WOZ RS Q][^`][Wa] g RSRWQOQW \ S\ SZ bÒPOX] SfVOcabWd] ÔÒ ZO Q`SOQW \ RS VS`Ò[WS\bOa _cS \]a RSTWS\RO\ RSZ `WSaU] / Z] ZOÙ] RS SabS ^`]QSa] RS TO[WZWO`WhOQW \ ^`]U`SaWdO Q]\ SZ bS`[W\] µ`WSaU]¶ g Q]\ aca RWabW\bOa O^ZWQOQW]\Sa ^`]TSaW]\OZSa RS RWTS`S\bSa RWaQW^ZW\Oa g t`SOa RS bÒPOX] Z] VO\ W\bS`W]`WhOR] S W\bSUÒR] S\ Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa _cS SXSQcbO\ AS VO bS`[W\OR] SaO SbOÔ RS S\]`[S SaTcS`h] ÔÒ ZO Q]\QWS\QWOQW \ a]P`S ZO SfWabS\QWO RSZ [Wa[] S\ ZO _cS ÔÒ RSa^S`bO` O ZO a]QWSROR O\bSa VOP O _cS VOQS`Z] Q]\ _cWS\Sa bÒPOXO\ S\ Z]a RWabW\b]a aSQb]`Sa 3\ ZO OQbcOZWROR aS VO\ W\Q]`^]ÒR] O Z]a ^`]QSRW[WS\b]a RS OQbcOQW \ bO\b] SZ acXSb] Q][] SZ ]PXSb] RS `WSaU] Q][] _cWS\Sa bÒPOXO\ S\ SZ t[PWb] ^`SdS\bWd] 6]g SfWabS S\ SZ aS\bW` Q]ZSQbWd] c\O aS\aWPWZWhOQW \ VOQWO SZ b{`[W\] `WSaU] g c\O [SX]` ^`SRWa^]aWQW \ VOQWO b]R] O_cSZZ] _cS Z] [W\W[WQS ] Z] SZW[W\S 3a ^]` Sa] _cWht _cS gO \] \SQSaWbO[]a OTS`Ò`\]a bO\ TcS`bS[S\bS OZ b{`[W\] S\ aca RWabW\bOa RW[S\aW]\Sa g ^]RS[]a aOZW`\]a RS ZO a][PÒ RS ac ^`SaW \ ÔÒ S[^ShO` O ]PaS`dO`Z] RSaRS TcSÒ 7\QZca] ÔÒ ^]\S` S\ QcSabW \ OZUc\Oa RS ZOa ac^cSabOa µQS`bShOa¶ Q]\aS\acOROa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

3\ ZO OQbcOZWROR ZO USabW \ RSZ `WSaU] Sa c\ b{`[W\] [cg cbWZWhOR] S\ SZ t[PWb] RS ZO SQ]\][ O ZO aOZcR ZO SRcQOQW \ SbQ 3a c\ Q]\QS^b] _cS aS bWS\S S\ QcS\bO O ZO V]Ò RS OP`W` Z \SOa RS [S`QOR] VOQS` ^ZO\Sa SabÒb{UWQ]a SabO\RO`WhO` \WdSZSa RS aOZcR ] ^`SRSQW` Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RWa`c^bWd]a ?cWht S\ Z]a ZbW[]a bWS[^]a SabS b{`[W\] aS VO [OU\WTWQOR] O\bS ZO Q`SQWS\bS dSZ]QWROR RS Z]a QO[PW]a g T`cb] RSZ d{`bWU] W\RWdWRcOZ g Q]ZSQbWd] _cS {ab]a ^`]d]QO\ aS VO WR] RO\R] OZ µ`WSaU]¶ c\ Q`SQWS\bS ^`]bOU]\Wa[] AW\ S[POÙ] [ta OZZt RSZ ^]aWPZS a]P`SRW[S\aW]\O[WS\b] RSZ b{`[W\] `WSaU] {abS Sa Q]\\ObcÒZ O ZO dWRO g T]`[O Ô`bS RS ZO [Wa[O 3Z aS` Vc[O\] O^`S\RS O USabW]\O` SZ `WSaU] RSaRS ac \OQW[WS\b] SZ O^`S\RWhOXS dWQO`W] SZ S\aOg] g S``]` _cS dO\ O^]`bO\R] ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO _cS ^S`[WbW`t O\bWQWÔ` ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa QOZQcZO` []dW[WS\b]a g Oac[W` ] \] Z]a `WSaU]a _cS ac^]\S OT`]\bO` QORO \cSd] SaQS\O`W] _cS ZO dWRO ]T`SQS 1O[W\O[]a W\[Sà]a S\ ZO USabW \ RS \cSab`]a `WSaU]a Oac[WS\R] _cS {abS T]`[O Ô`bS RS ZO SfWabS\QWO g RS \cSabÒa OQQW]\Sa <]a aW`dS Q][] Ô`t[Sb`] _cS \]a RO ZO [SRWRO RS VOabO R \RS ^]RS[]a ZZSUO` S\ QORO c\O RS \cSabÒa RSQWaW]\Sa g OQQW]\Sa g bO[PW{\ Q][] `STZSfW \ RS ZOa OQQW]\Sa _cS VO\ bS\WR] c\ `SacZbOR] S`` \S] :O ÔZOPÒ `WSaU] O ^SaO` RS _cS S\ [cQVOa ]QOaW]\Sa aS ^S`QWPO RSaRS c\O Q]\\]bOQW \ \SUObWdO bWS\S c\ QO`tQbS` ^]aWbWd] g Sa Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS bWZ S\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa 3Z `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] RSZ `WSaU] g ac RSZW[WbOQW \ aW`dS ÔÒ [SRW` ZOa OQQW]\Sa g Q]\ SZZ] [WbWUO` Z]a ^]aWPZSa S``]`Sa 3Z `WSaU] Sa c\ Q]\QS^b] RW\t[WQ] _cS Sabt Oa]QWOR] W\SZcRWPZS[S\bS O c\O OQQW \ ] O c\ Q]\Xc\b] RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a ZO USabW \ 3a ZO dS`bWS\bS RS c\O []dWZWhOQW \ _cS bÒaQWS\RS O ZO SdWbOQW \ g _cS Sabt [ta QS\bÒRO S\ ZO ]^]`bc\WROR /ZUc\Oa RS ZOa SbOÔa RSZ QWQZ] dWbOZ S\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] Sd]ZcbWd] RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa a]\ [ta acaQS^bWPZSa RS dcZ\SÒPWZWROR _cS ]bÒa Oc\_cS S\ QORO c\O RS SZZOa aS RO\ ] OÔ`SQS\ dO`WOPZSa Sa^SQ TWQOa _cS ^cSRS\ VOQS` [ta ] [S\]a T`tUWZ O QORO QcOZ 1cOZ_cWS` ^`]QSa] [ORcÒbWd] ^]R` O dSàS OZbSÒR] S\ QcOZ_cWSÒ RS aca TOaSa ^S`] ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR Sa [Og]` O SRORSa [ta bS[^Ò\Oa ^cSab] _cS ZO ^Sà]\OZWROR b]ROd O \] Sabt RSZ b]R] Q]\T]`[ORO 6OabO OV]Ò aS VO\ Q]\aWRSÒR] SbOÔa RS Sa^SQWOZ dcZ\SÒPWZWROR ZO W\TO\QWO g ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO aW\ S[POÙ] RSPWR] OZ Oc[S\b] RS ZO Z]\USdWROR g O ZO Q]\aWUcWS\bS O[^ZWOQW \ RS ZOa SbOÔa RSZ QWQZ] dWbOZ ZO XcdS\bcR S\ b]RO ac OQbcOZ SfbS\aW \ Sa c\ ^S`W]R] S\ SZ _cS aS S[^`S\RS ZO USabW \ OQbWdO g Ocb \][O RS Z]a `WSaU]a _cS SZ VSQV] RS dWdW` bWS\S 3abS R]Qc[S\b] bWS\S ZO TW\OZWROR RS O^`]fW[OàS OZ `WSaU] Q]\ ]bÒ ^bWQO W\Q]`^]Ò\R] bO[PW{\ ]bÒ dS`bWS\bS ZO ]^]`bc\WROR g RSaRS ac ]bÒ Tc\QW \ ZO ^]aWbWdO >OÒ SZZ] S\ SabS R]Qc[S\b] aS `SdWaO`t\ ^]aWQW]\Sa bS `WQOa g aS QcSabW]\O\ OfW][Oa O[^ZWO[S\bS OQS^bOR]a Q]\ ]PXSb] RS []dWZWhO` VOQWO c\O \cSdO O^`]fW[OQW \ OZ ^]ZWa{[WQ] Q]\QS^b] RSZ `WSaU] AS O\OZWhO ZO O^ZWQOQW \ RSZ [Wa[] S\ RWabW\b]a t[PWb]a g ÔÒ RWabW\b]a bW^]a RS ^`]bOU]\WabOa g aS Q]\abObO ZO RW[S\aW \ bO\ ^ZcÒZ _cS bWS\S SZ `WSaU] Q][] `S^`SaS\bOQW \ a]QWOZ acPXSbWdO( c\O T]`[O O []R] RS Q`WabOZ ^]ZW{R`WQ] _cS OZ [WÒ` c\O QOÒ RSaRWPcXO OZ `Sab] 3a ^cSa c\ R]Qc[S\b] dWd] Ob`SdWR] Qcg] ]PXSbWd] TW\OZ Sa SZ RS ^`][]dS` `SdWaW]\Sa bS `WQOa RSa^S`bO` ZO Ocb]Q` bWQO ÔÒ aSUcW` OdO\hO\R] g OP`W` Oa \cSdOa Z \SOa RS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

bÒPOX] _cS Oc[S\bS\ SZ Q]\]QW[WS\b] a]P`S ZOa QOÔQWRORSa g Z]a ^]bS\QWOZSa RSZ aS` Vc[O\] 3Z []\]U`tTWQ] aS Q][^]\S RS RWSh O`b QcZ]a _cS ^]R` O[]a OU`cÔ` S\ QcOb`] UÒ\RSa PZ]_cSa 3\ SZ ^`W[S`] Q][^cSab] ^]` Z]a O`b QcZ]a g aS `SdWaO ZO Q]\QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] g aS QcSabW]\O\ OZUc\]a Oa^SQb]a RS ac Q]\ab`cQQW \ 3\ SZ aSUc\R] T]`[OR] ^]` Z]a O`b QcZ]a ! " g # aS RSTW\S ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ RSZ Q]\QS^b] XcdS\bcR g ac Oa]QWOQW \ OZ Q]\QS^b] RS `WSaU] ac Oa]QWOQW \ Q]\ ZO WRS\bWROR RS U{\S`] g ac ^`SaS\QWO S\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ 3\ SZ bS`QS` PZ]_cS Q]\ Z]a O`b QcZ]a $ % & g ' \]a ORS\bÒ[]a S\ t[PWb]a R]\RS SZ Q]\QS^b] µ`WSaU]¶ bWS\S aW\UcZO`WROR ^`]^WO Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS RSaRS ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO RS OR]ZSaQS\bSa g X dS\Sa QcO\R] aS [cSdS\ RS\b`] SZZ]a 3Z ZbW[] g QcO`b] PZ]_cS Z] Q]\abWbcgS SZ QO^ bcZ] S\ SZ _cS aS ^`]^]\S c\O [WÒRO [ta UZ]POZWhORO VOQWO SZ Tcbc`] 3\ SZ ^`W[S` PZ]_cS Q]\ Z]a R]a ^`W[S`]a O`b QcZ]a aS ^`]^WQWO SZ O`Ò\_cS RSZ RSPObS a]P`S SZ `WSaU] >OÒ SZZ] S\ SZ ^`W[S` O`b QcZ] 3ZS\O @]R` UcSh \]a ]T`SQS c\O `SdWaW \ bS `WQO RS ZOa RWabW\bOa Q]\QS^QW]\Sa RSZ `WSaU] Oa Q][] RS ZOa RWabW\bOa O^`]fW[OQW]\Sa _cS VO\ ^S`[WbWR] Q]\TWUcÒ` g OQ]bO` OZUc\]a RS Z]a Z [WbSa g Q]\RWQW]\O\bSa ÔÒ c\O ORSQcORO Q][^`S\aW \ RSZ Q]\QS^b] RS µ`WSaU]¶ g RS ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS ^]aWQW]\OàS T`S\bS O {Z AW SabS ^`W[S` O`b QcZ] Sa c\O `STZSfW \ a]P`S b]R] Z] O\ROR] S\ SZ aSUc\R] AcaO\O ;{\RSh aS O^`]fW[O OZ Q]\QS^b] RS `WSaU] Q][] c\ ^`]RcQb] RS ZO a]QWSROR RS Q]\ac[] 3\ SZ _cS ZO [S`QOR]bSQ\WO Sa ^`]bOU]\WabO g `Sa^]\aOPZS RS ZO TcS`bS RS[O\RO a]QWOZ RS PWS\SabO` g RS aSUc`WROR Oa Q][] RS b]R]a O_cSZZ]a ^`]RcQb]a _cS ^`SdS\UO\ RSZ `WSaU] _cS ^cRWSÒ RO O` SaS PWS\SabO` OZQO\hOR] 2SaUÒ\O ZOa ^S`dSàW]\Sa RSZ [S`QOR] RSZ PWS\SabO` RSaQ`WPS ZO ]bÒ QOÒ RSZ [Wa[] SZ RSPWZWbO[WS\b] RS ZOa QOÔQWRORSa g RS VOPWZWRORSa W\VS`S\bSa OZ aS` Vc[O\] QOcaOR] ^]` SZ ^`]bSQQW]\Wa[] RS ZO aSUc`WROR 3Z aSUc\R] PZ]_cS Sabt QS\bÒR] S\ SZ Q]ZSQbWd] ^`]bOU]\WabO RSZ []\]U`tTWQ] Z]a X dS\Sa g ac []R] RS ^S`QWPW` g USabW]\O` SZ `WSaU] G ÔÒ Q]\aSUcW`Z] 7U\OQW] ;SU Oa ;O` ;]`]ZZ \ g 8cO\ 1O`Z]a 0OZZSabS`]a ^`]^]\S\ S\ aca O`b QcZ]a ! " g # c\O W\[SàW \ S\ ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ a]QWOZ RSZ Q]\QS^b] RS XcdS\bcR g ac Ô`bWQcZO` Oa]QWOQW \ b`WO\UcZO` Q]\ SZ `WSaU] g ZO \]`[OZWROR 3dWRS\QWO\ bO[PW{\ ZOa ÔbS\bSa RWTS`S\QWOa RS U{\S`]) S\ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] ac USabW \ g S\ ac ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] Q][] ]^]`bc\WROR 3abS PZ]_cS aS QWS`Ò Q]\ c\O ^`]Tc\RO `STZSfW \ a]P`S ZO a]QWOZWhOQW \ S\ ZOa SbOÔa X dS\Sa S\ ZO _cS aS ^]\S RS [O\WTWSab] ZO OÔ`WQW \ RS ZO RS\][W\ORO µa]QWOZWhOQW \ S\ SZ `WSaU]¶ Qcg] ÒaU] [ta aWU\WTWQObWd] Sa SZ O\aWO RS Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ Oa Q][] _cS ÔÒ Q][^`S\RS`ZO Sa \SQSaO`W] bÒaQS\RS` OZ []RSZ] bÒRWQW]\OZ RS ZO Q]\QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] 3Z bS`QS` PZ]_cS Sa c\ SaÔQW] RSRWQOR] O Z]a SaQS\O`W]a S\ Z]a _cS VOPWbO\ Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa) ZcUO`Sa g OQbWdWRORSa R]\RS bO\b] SZ `WSaU] Q][] ac USabW \ bWS\S\ c\O Q]\QS^QW \ Sa^SQ TWQO OZ WUcOZ _cS ZO bWS\S ZO OQbWbcR Q]\ `Sa^SQb] OZ [Wa[] bO[PW{\ :]a O`b QcZ]a $ % & g ' SZOP]ÒR]a ^]` È\USZ 8 5]`R] ;S`QSRSa 5O`Q O SZ S_cW^] Q][^cSab] ^]` /ZSXO\RÒ 0]\W

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

/`WabWhtPOZ g 3dO /RO[ >WQOh] g 8Oc[S 1O`P]\SZZ \]a ORS\bÒ\ S\ b`Sa Q]\bSfb]a [cg ^`SaS\bSa S\ ZO dWRO RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa Xย dS\Sa( ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa SZ S[^`S\RW[WS\b] ZO Q]]^SÒQWย \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ g SZ Q]\bSfb] SRcQObWd] ร \USZ 5]`R] O\OZWhO ZO RS[]\WhOQWย \ RS ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa S\ `SZOQWย \ Q]\ ZO W\TO\QWO g ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO `SdWaO\R] ZOa ^`]gSQQW]\Sa _cS SZ [c\R] ORcZb] ^`]gSQbO a]P`S SZ X]dS\ T`cb] RS ac ^`]^W] [WSR] O\bS SabS \cSd] c\WdSà] ;S`QSRSa 5O`Q O ^]` ac Ô`bS QS\bÒ ac O`b QcZ] S\ c\ t[PWb] g S\ c\ ^S`TWZ RS Xย dS\Sa Q]\Q`Sb] S\ SZ _cS SZ b{`[W\] `WSaU] Sa c\O \SQSaWROR c\ ^`SdW] W[^`SaQW\RWPZS S\ ZO Q]\ab`cQQWย \ RS ZO ]^]`bc\WROR /\OZWhO SZ RW\O[Wa[] a]QWOZ S\ SZ _cS dWdW[]a Q][] c\ Q]\bSfb] RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa ÔÒ ZO XcdS\bcR g Q][] SabS Q]\bSfb] g ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa _cS ]b]ÙO Sabt ZWUOR] O Q]\QS^b]a Q][] S[^`S\RS` S[^`S\RWhOXS XcdS\bcR S[^`S\RSR]Ò g S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa 3\ SZ bS`QS` O`b QcZ] RS SabS PZ]_cS /ZSXO\RÒ 0]\W /`WabWhtPOZ g 3dO /RO[ >WQOh] `SdWaO\ ZOa RWabW\bOa ^Sà^SQbWdOa _cS ZO ^S`QS^QWย \ RSZ `WSaU] bWS\S S\ SZ t[PWb] RS ZO Q]]^SÒQWย \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] ^]\WS\R] c\ {\TOaWa Sa^SQWOZ S\ Z]a Q]\QS^b]a RS `WSaU] _cS aS [O\SXO\ S\ SabS t[PWb] Oa Q][] S\ SZ Q]\bÒabS S\ ZOa WRSOa RS `WSaU] S\b`S _cWS\Sa bÒPOXO\ g dWdS\ ZO Q]]^SÒQWย \ RSaRS Z]a R]a ZOR]a RS ZO [Wa[O G ^]` ย ZbW[] RSaRS SZ Q]\bSfb] RS ZO SRcQOQWย \ 8Oc[S 1O`P]\SZZ \]a ^`]^]\S Q]\ ac bÒPOX] c\ OQS`QO[WS\b] OZ `WSaU] SRcQObWd] g O c\O RS aca [O\WTSabOQW]\Sa [ta OQZO[OROa( SZ TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` 2SaRS c\O O^`]fW[OQWย \ Q` bWQO S\ ZO _cS bÒaQWS\RS OZ OZc[\OR] _cS ยต]TWQWOZ[S\bS TÒQOaOยถ g O ZO [WÒRO c\WZObSÒZ VOQWO SZZ]a g SZZOa 3f^Z]Ò g `SQ]``S SZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] dWUS\bS Oa Q][] Z]a QO[PW]a _cS aS VO\ WR] ^`]RcQWS\R] RS\b`] RSZ [Wa[] g _cS VO\ US\SÒR] [ta ]^]`bc\WRORSa _cS ZW[WbOQW]\Sa ] `WSaU]a 4W\OZ[S\bS S\ SZ ย ZbW[] PZ]_cS O bÒd{a RSZ O`b QcZ] RS 8Saย a 5O`Q O DS`RcU] aS ^ZO\bSO\ OZUc\Oa ÔcbOa RS Tcbc`] S\ ZOa _cS SZ `WSaU] Sa c\O Ô`bS g gO \] c\ b]R] g aS ^`]^]\S SZ OPO\R]\] RS ZO a][PÒ RSZ ^`]bSQQW]\Wa[] O\bS SZ `WSaU] ÔÒ RO` Ôa] O ZO ^`][]QWย \ RS ZO Ocb]\][ O ^Sà]\OZ O bÒd{a RS ZO USabWย \ RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa AcaO\O ;{\RSh 5OU] 4c\ROQWย \ 53A]QWOZ 3ZS\O @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ A]QW]Zย UWQO B`Sa

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

9D8JB:CIDH

3ZS\O @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ A]QW]Z UWQO B`Sa

G^Zh\d n hdX^ZYVY# GZk^hVcYd aVh Vegdm^bVX^dcZh Va g^Zh\d XjVcYd ]VWaVbdh YZ _jkZcijY

/QS`QOàS OZ `WSaU] Sa c\O bO`SO _cS `S_cWS`S OP`W` [ ZbW^ZSa dS\bO\Oa W\bS`^`SbObWdOa <]a ORS\bÒ[]a S\ c\ Q]\QS^b] Q][^ZSX] g ^]ZWa{[WQ] O\bS SZ _cS \] Sa ^]aWPZS aWbcOàS Q]\ ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a aW[^ZSa ] aW[^ZWTWQOR]`Sa 3Z O`b QcZ] bÒbO RS VOQS` c\O O^`]fW[OQW \ O Z]a RWabW\b]a ^]abcZOR]a bS `WQ]a RSaRS Z]a _cS aS VO OP]`ROR] SabS Q]\QS^b] ÔaSO\R] ^]` Z]a RWabW\b]a SZS[S\b]a _cS RWTS`S\bSa Ocb]`Sa g Ocb]Òa VO\ WR] O^]`bO\R] ÔÒ SabOPZSQS` c\ QWS`b] [O`Q] OPO`QObWd] RS ac Q][^ZSXWROR 2SaRS ZOa RSTW\WQW]\Sa \SQSaO`WOa ÔÒ SabOPZSQS` c\ Q]\bSfb] RS b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa ^S`] bO[PW{\ RSaRS ZO `SdWaW \ RS Z]a OÙc[S\b]a _cS RSaRS SZ O\tZWaWa RS ZO bSQ\]Z]U O ZO âWQ]Z]U O ZO O\b`]^]Z]U O ] ZO a]QW]Z]U O aS ^ZO\bSO\ Q][] \SQSaO`W]a ÔÒ ZO Q][^`S\aW \ RS Z]a ^`]QSa]a W\RWdWRcOZSa g Q]ZSQbWd]a _cS Q]\RWQW]\O\ ZO SdOZcOQW \ g SZ ^]aWQW]\O[WS\b] O\bS SZ `WSaU] ] Z]a `WSaU]a S\ ZOa a]QWSRORSa OQbcOZSa >OZOPÒa QZOdS( @WSaU] W\QS`bWRc[P`S ]^]`bc\WROR ^SZWU`] ^S`QS^QW \ a]QWOZ ^]RS` dOZ]`Sa WRS\bWROR X dS\Sa

:O \SQSaWROR RS `SdWaO` ZO \]QW \ RS µ`WSaU]¶ ;cQVOa ^]Z bWQOa a]QWOZSa g S\ Q]\Q`Sb] ZOa RS XcdS\bcR cbWZWhO\ SZ Q]\QS^b] RS `WSaU] PWS\ S\ ac XcabWTWQOQW \ PWS\ S\ ac RSTW\WQW \ ] S\b`S aca ]PXSbWd]a O ZO dSh _cS [cQVOa ^]Z bWQOa a]QWOZSa g ^`]UÒ[Oa ^]Z bWQ]a W\Q]`^]Ò\ S\b`S aca Oa^WÒQW]\Sa g ^`]^cSabOa ZO WRSO RS aSUc`WROR /[POa WRSOa Sabt\ ^`SaS\bSa QORO dSh Q]\ [ta T`SQcS\QWO aSO RS T]`[O Sf^Z QWbO ] W[^Z QWbO S\ Z]a RWaQcà]a W\abWbcQW]\OZSa ^S`] bO[PW{\ S\ Z]a S[^`SaO`WOZSa G S\ SaOa ^]Z bWQOa Z]a ^]RS`Sa ^ PZWQ]a g OUS\bSa ] S\bWRORSa a]QWOZSa QS\bÒ\ ac ObS\QW \ S\ bÒPOXO` a]P`S O_cSZZ]a Oa^SQb]a _cS ^cSRO\ SdWbO` ZO ^`]POPWZWROR RS ]Qc``S\QWO RS RO ]a ] ^SZWU`]a ÔÒ RWTS`S\bSa U`c^]a RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ ] RSZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ aSO RSaRS SZ ^c\b] RS dWabO RS ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS ZO ^`]bSQQW \ RS ZO aSUc`WROR S W\QZca] RS ZO USabW \ T`S\bS O Z]a `WSaU]a ASO QcOZ aSO SZ U`c^] TW\OZ OZ _cS aS RW`WXO ZO ObS\QW \ b]ROa ZOa ^Sà^SQbWdOa _cS aS ]`WS\bO\ OZ Tcbc`] aS OQS`QO\ RS c\ []R] c ]b`] OZ SaQS\O`W] RS bÒPOX] Q]\ OR]ZSaQS\bSa g X dS\Sa( Z]a `WSaU]a RSZ ^`SaS\bS aS S\bWS\RS\ Q][] ^]aWPZSa ^`]PZS[Oa ÔÒ SZ Tcbc`] g S\ SZ Tcbc`] Sabt\ a]P`S b]R] ZOa US\SÒQW]\Sa [ta X dS\Sa ;cQVOa RS ZOa ^]Z bWQOa a]QWOZSa _cS aS RW`WUS\ O ZO XcdS\bcR bWS\S\ Q][] ]PXSbWd] OgcRO` O Q]\ab`cW` SZ Tcbc`] bÒbO\R] RS Q`SO` ZOa [SX]`Sa Q]\RWQW]\Sa ^]aWPZSa ÔÒ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] S\ SZ bÒ\aQcà] RSZ bWS[^] ] ZcQVO\R] ÔÒ SdWbO` _cS Q]\RWQW]\Sa W\RSaSOPZSa RSZ ^`SaS\bS aS Q]\abWbcgO\ Q][] PO``SÒa ÔÒ ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ RS SaS Tcbc`]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

B]R]a Sab]a ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a RS W\bS`dS\QWย \ bWS\S\ Q][] bÒaT]\R] SZ `WSaU] G aW\ S[POÙ] VOPZO` RS `WSaU]a ] W\bS`dS\W` a]P`S SZZ]a ^]\S RS [O\WTWSab] c\ RSPObS OZbO[S\bS Q]\bÒRWQb]`W] _cS O [S\cR] acaQWbO aS\bW[WS\b]a S\Q]\bÒR]a 1]\bÒRWQQW]\Sa _cS T`SQcS\bS[S\bS bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ ZO RWTWQcZbOR RS OQ]^ZO` bS]` Oa ] ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a UZ]POZSa g US\{`WQ]a O QcSabW]\Sa Q]\Q`SbOa O t[PWb]a [cg RWTS`S\bSa Q]\ Q]\\]bOQW]\Sa [cg RWdSàOa g RS [cg RWTS`S\bS QOZOR] g bÒaQS\RS\QWO 3\ SabS O`b QcZ] `SdWaO`S[]a OZUc\Oa RS ZOa O^]`bOQW]\Sa bSย `WQOa [ta `SZSdO\bSa _cS aS VO\ Q]\ab`cWR] a]P`S SZ `WSaU] S\ ZOa ย ZbW[Oa R{QOROa <]a QS\bÒ`S[]a bO[PW{\ S\ ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO RSaRS ZO QcOZ ^]RO[]a ^S`QWPW` ZOa RWTWQcZbORSa ÔÒ SabOPZSQS` ^]aWQW]\Sa QZOÒa g RSTW\WbWdOa O\bS SZ `WSaU] G Sa Oa ^]`_cS Q][] W`S[]a ^ZO\bSO\R] ZOa ^]aWQW]\Sa O\bS SZ `WSaU] RS^S\RS\ RS bOZ QO\bWROR RS Oa^SQb]a a]QWOZSa WRSOa RSZ [c\R] RS ZO Sd]ZcQWย \ RS ZO aSUc`WROR RSZ ^]RS` RS Z] Q]ZSQbWd] g Z] W\RWdWRcOZยฌ ยณb]R]a SZZ]a ORS[ta OZbO[S\bS QOÙOR]a RS Q][^]\S\bSa WRS]Zย UWQ]aยณ _cS `SacZbO W[^]aWPZS ORS[ta RS W\RSaSOPZS _cS SZ RSPObS ^cSRO aS` ^ZO\bSOR] RSaRS c\O Zย UWQO c\WRW[S\aW]\OZ g [cQV] [S\]a R]U[tbWQO Q]\ ^`SbS\aW]\Sa RS QWS``S Q]\QZcaWd] 3\ `SZOQWย \ Q]\ ZO dO`WOPWZWROR RS Oa^SQb]a W[^ZWQOR]a S\ c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO US\SÒZ a]P`S SZ `WSaU] ^]\UO[]a Q][] SXS[^Z]a aWbcOQW]\Sa bOZSa Q][] ZOa ^]aWQW]\Sa T`S\bS O Z]a `WSaU]a O[PWS\bOZSa SZ RSPObS a]P`S SZ RSaO``]ZZ] QWS\b TWQ] g bSQ\]Zย UWQ] Z]a `WSaU]a SQ]\ย [WQ]a RS _cWS\Sa ]^SÒ\ S\ P]ZaO Z]a `WSaU]a RS`WdOR]a RS ZO Q]\RcQQWย \ bS[SÒ`WO Z]a `WSaU]a OZW[S\bO`W]a S\ Z]a Ô aSa S\ d O RS RSaO``]ZZ] ] Z]a `WSaU]a RSPWR]a O ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa OR]ZSaQS\bSa >O`SQS SdWRS\bS b][O\R] Q][] `STS`S\QWO ^]` SXS[^Z] SabO PObS` O RS Oac\b]a _cS SZ \WdSZ bSย `WQ] RSZ RSPObS \] ^cSRS aS` c\WTWQOR] RSaRS c\O a]ZO Q]``WS\bS RS ^S\aO[WS\b] OZ [S\]a aW bS\S[]a S\ QcS\bO ZO bÒaQS\RS\QWO RWTS`S\QWOZ RS QORO c\] RS SZZ]a ] ZO RWdSàWROR RS Z]a ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a ^`SdW]a ÔÒ ac OP]`ROXS 2WUO[]a _cS \] Sa Z] [Wa[] ^S\aO` S\ `WSaU]a Qcg] ]`WUS\ Sa Q]\]QWR] g ^]bS\QWOZ[S\bS Q]\b`]ZOPZS _cS S\ `WSaU]a _cS \W aW_cWSÒ aS ^cSRS\ ^`SdS`) _cS \] Sa Z] [Wa[] aWbcOàS O\bS `WSaU]a QcgOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa a]\ ^`SdWaWPZSa _cS O\bS `WSaU]a RS Q]\aSQcS\QWOa W[^`SdWaWPZSa) _cS \] Sa Z] [Wa[] VOPZO` RS `WSaU]a _cS W[^ZWQO\ RSQWaW]\Sa W\RWdWRcOZSa ] RS `WSaU]a _cS `S_cWS`S\ b][Oa RS RSQWaWย \ Q]ZSQbWdO G ^]` ac^cSab] _cS \] Sa Z] [Wa[] ^]aWQW]\OàS T`S\bS O `WSaU]a Ô`bWQcZO`Sa W\RWdWRcOZSa g bÒ\aWb]`W]a _cS T`S\bS O `WSaU]a _cS ^cSRS\ Q][^`][SbS` RSbS`[W\OR]a ^WZO`Sa S\ Z]a _cS aS OaWS\bO ZO dWRO Q]ZSQbWdO ] SZ [c\R] Q]\]QWR] G Z] QWS`b] Sa _cS S\ QORO c\O RS ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa ^]aWPZSa RS `WSaU] bS\R`S[]a bS\RS\QWO O Q]Z]QO`\]a RS c\O RSbS`[W\ORO [O\SÒ Oc\_cS SZ `SacZbOR] TW\OZ aSO Q]\bÒRWQb]`W] S\b`S c\Oa g ]bÒa ^]aWQW]\Sa G Q]\ [cQVO T`SQcS\QWO RSaRS ^]abcZOR]a _cS [ta OZZt RS Z] bSย `WQ] T]`[OZ ] RS ZO ac^cSabO ]PXSbWdWROR RS ZOa Q]``WS\bSa QWS\b TWQ] O\OZ bWQOa ÔaO\ ^]` ^]aWQW]\Sa WRS]Zย UWQOa RS RWTS`S\bS aWU\] >]`_cS SZ O\tZWaWa RSZ `WSaU] Q][] SZ RS QcOZ_cWS` Oac\b] RS bÒaQS\RS\QWO a]QWOZ ÔaO ^]` SZ bO[Wh RS ZOa Q]``WS\bSa RS ^S\aO[WS\b] _cS a]\ ^`]^WOa RS QORO [][S\b] VWabย `WQ] _cS Z] Sa S\ Z] a]QWOZ S\ Z] ^]Z bWQ] g S\ Z] WRS]Zย UWQ] >S`] ORS[ta ZO WRSO RS `WSaU] S\ a [Wa[O `SacZbO _cS Sa c\ Q]\QS^b] ^`]^W] RS c\ [][S\b] VWabย `WQ] _cS bWS\S aS\bWR] S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] VWabย `WQ] g ZZSdO Oa]QWORO ac ^`]^WO O[PWUย SROR S\ ac SaS\QWO ]`WUW\OZ _cS Sa ZO RS ZO a]QWSROR _cS ZO VOQS ^]aWPZS 1][] RWQS @O[ย \ @O[]a ZO WRSO

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

RS `WSaU] Q][] Q]\QS^b] Oa]QWOR] O ZO []RS`\WROR µO`ÒabÒ Q]\aWU] b]R]a Z]a acS ]a S[O\QWÔb]`W]a RS ZO []RS`\WROR ^S`] bO[PW{\ ac O[PWdOZS\QWO RS T]\R]¶ @O[]a @ AWUcWS\R] O SabS Ocb]` S\ SZ O\tZWaWa RS Z]a ^]abcZOR]a RS 0SQY aW ZO []RS`\WROR Sa ZO dWdS\QWO RSZ `WSaU] Sa \SQSaO`W] Q]\bS[^ZO` SZ `WSaU] RSaRS aca R]a QOÒa C\O ^`W[SÒ _cS W[^ZWQO c\ dOZ]` ^]aWbWd] RSaRS ZO _cS µSZ [c\R] _cS \] aS O``WSaUO Sa c\ [c\R] _cWSb] bÒRWQW]\OZ OP]QOR] O ZO SaQOaSh¶ g O ZO `S^SbWQW \) c\O dSàW \ RSaRS ZO _cS µSZ `WSaU] Sa aW\ \W[] RSZ RW\O[Wa[] RS ZO OQS^bOQW \ RS ZO O^S`bcÒ RSZ [c\R] g dO RS ZO [O\] RS ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO RS ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa Q`SQWS\bSa g RS ZO SfÔ\aW \ RSZ QtZQcZ] ÒQW]\OZ ÔÒ Sf^Z]bO` SaOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa¶ 3abO ^`W[SÒ µQOÒ¶ O ZO _cS SZ Ocb]` WRS\bWTWQO Q]\ ac Oa^SQb] µa]ZO`¶ RS Zc[W\]aWROR Sa ZO _cS VOQS RSaSOPZS ³S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ RSbS`[W\OR]³ SZ OT`]\bO[WS\b] RSZ `WSaU] g Z] _cS Sa [ta VOQS RSaSOPZS ZO SfWabS\QWO RSZ `WSaU] Q][] []b]` RS QO[PW] ^Sà]\OZ g a]QWOZ >S`] ZO aSUc\RO QOÒ ZO _cS SZ Ocb]` WRS\bWTWQO Q][] ZO µZc\O`¶ ZO ]aQcÒ ] ZO \SUObWdO Sa ZO _cS µW\dWbO O a]`bSO`Z]a ] SdWbO`Z]a¶ Z]a `WSaU]a 3a ZO dSàW \ RSZ `WSaU] _cS W[^ZWQO OZ [S\]a R]a Sf^S`WS\QWOa ^]bS\QWOZ[S\bS W\RSaSOPZSa( ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RSZ RO ] O Ô`bW` RS ZO Sf^]aWQW \ O _cS \]a a][SbS[]a Q]\ \cSabÒa RSQWaW]\Sa g ZO QcZÔPWZWhOQW \ ] SZ O``S^S\bW[WS\b] RS`WdOR]a QcO\R] ^S`RS[]a Z] _cS VS[]a O``WSaUOR] ] QcO\R] SZ `SacZbOR] \] VO aWR] SZ W\WQWOZ[S\bS ^`SdWab] >]` ]bÒ Ô`bS g aSO Q][] aSO Z] _cS a bWS\S\ S\ Q][ \ b]ROa ZOa ]^QW]\Sa ^]aWPZSa T`S\bS OZ `WSaU] Sa _cS `Sa^]\RS\ O ZO \SQSaWROR RS b][O` Ô`bWR] RS SabOPZSQS` c\ [O`Q] Q]\QS^bcOZ RSaRS SZ _cS aSO ^]aWPZS OR]^bO` c\O ^]aWQW \ RSbS`[W\ORO G RS OZUc\O [O\SÒ Z] _cS ZOa RWTS`S\bSa Q]``WS\bSa bS `WQOa bÒbO\ RS O^]`bO` Sa c\ []RSZ] RSaRS SZ _cS aS O^cSabO ^]` ZO \SQSaWROR RS _cS SaO b][O RS Ô`bWR] aSO `SOZ g STSQbWdO aW\ ]PdWO` SZ O\tZWaWa RS Z]a Z [WbSa RS ZO a]QWSROR OQbcOZ ÔÒ ^]aWQW]\OàS T`S\bS OZ Q]\QS^b] RS `WSaU] 2WUO[]a _cS SZ RSPObS aS ^ZO\bSO S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR ^]`_cS SfWabS ZO Q]\dWQQW \ RS _cS Z]a `WSaU]a O Z]a _cS \]a Sf^]\S[]a bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ \cSabÒ QOÔQWROR RS OQQW \ g _cS ^]` bO\b] \]a ]PZWUO\ O b][O` RSQWaW]\Sa 3abO Q]\dWQQW \ _cS Sa c\O RWTS`S\QWO VWab `WQO ^]`_cS Q]\bÒabO ZO a]QWSROR OQbcOZ Q]\ ZO RS ]b`]a [][S\b]a Sa ZO _cS Tc\RO[S\bO ZO ^`]^WO WRSO RS `WSaU] T`S\bS O ZO RS ^SZWU`] \ObcÒZ RWdW\] ] RS ]bÒ \ObcÒZShO ^`]^WOa RS ]b`]a bW^]a RS []RSZ]a a]QWOZSa ( aW SZ `WSaU] Sa c\O ^`]POPWZWROR OZU] _cS aWb O O\bS bSaWbcÒa S\ ZOa _cS aS ^cSRS g RSPS RSQWRW` ZO WRSO RS `WSaU] W[^ZWQO µRSQWaW]\Sa []RWTWQOPZSa S W[^cbOPZSa []ÒZ ^]Z bWQO g Xc` RWQO[S\bS¶ :cXt\ 8 : ) 3QVSdS`` O 8 SRa " 1][] aS OZO @O[]a ]^ QWb ZO Q]\QWS\QWO RSZ `WSaU] RSTW\WRO S\ Sab]a b{`[W\]a µdO RS ZO [O\] RS ZO SdWRS\QWO RS ZO O^S`bcÒ RSZ Tcbc`] RS ZO Q]\abObOQW \ RS ZO Q]\bW\US\QWO g ZO TÒUWZWROR RS ZO S[SÙS\QWO RS Z] W[^`SdWaWPZS RS ZO \SUOQW \ RS b]R] \WQV] S\ SZ _cS RSaQO\aO` aSUc`]¶ ^`]d]QO\R] c\O \SQSaO`WO ^cSabO S\ dOZ]` RS Z]a SaÔQW]a RS b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS RS Z]a Q]ZSQbWd]a RS ZO µ^]Z bWQO g aca Q]\aSQcS\QWOa¶ c\O ^cSabO S\ dOZ]` RS µZO \SUOQW \ RS _cS SZ [c\R] ^cSRO O`bWQcZOàS ObS\W{\R]aS a Z] bO\ a Z] O Z] _cS Z]a [S`QOR]a RWQbO\ g ^]\WS\R] S\b`S Ô`{\bSaWa ZO OQQW \ RSZ 3abOR]¶ <] Ô`SQS\ OTW`[OQW]\Sa [cg RSaQOPSZZOROa S\ SZ Q]\bSfb] OQbcOZ RS Q`WaWa RSZ []RSZ] SQ]\ [WQ] g TW\O\QWS`] S\ SZ aS\] RS Z]a Ô aSa RSaO``]ZZOR]a

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

3Z RSPObS a]P`S SZ OT`]\bO[WS\b] RSZ `WSaU] 7\QS`bWRc[P`S [WSR] g bSQ\]Z]U O C\] RS Z]a Oa^SQb]a QZOdS S\ ZO [O\SÒ RS Q]\QS^bcOZWhO` OZUc\]a bW^]a RS `WSaU]a g S\ ZO [O\SÒ RS RSTW\W` OZUc\Oa RS ZOa ^]aWQW]\Sa Sa^SQ TWQOa O\bS SZ `WSaU] S\ ZOa a]QWSRORSa OQbcOZSa bWS\S _cS dS` Q]\ SZ O\tZWaWa RS ZO bS\RS\QWO b`WdWOZWhOR]Ò RS RSbS`[W\OROa WRSOa RS PWS\SabO` POaOROa S\ ZO Q`SS\QWO RS ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS SfÔ\aW \ aW\ Z [WbSa RSZ Q`SQW[WS\b] WZW[WbOR] g RS Z]a []RSZ]a RS µRSaO``]ZZ]¶ Oa]QWOR]a O SabO Sa^SQ TWQO WRSO RSZ µPWS\SabO`¶ 3aO bS\RS\QWO b`WdWOZWhOR]Ò Sa ZO _cS O [S\cR] bÒbO RS ]QcZbO` ZO bÒaQS\RS\QWO \SUObWdO RS RWTS`S\bSa TS\ [S\]a ] `SOZWRORSa O ZOa _cS \]a dO[]a OQ]^ZO\R] g OQ]abc[PÒ\R] Q]\ \ObcÒZWROR aW\ _cS `S^S`QcbO\ S\ c\ `S^ZO\bSO[WS\b] RS ZO TO\bOa O RS ^`]a^S`WROR g TSZWQWROR WZW[WbORO 7\QZca] O ^SaO` RS _cS SfWabO ZO QS`bShO RS _cS S\ SZ [c\R] []RS`\] QcOZ_cWS` Q]aO ^]` QObOab` TWQO _cS aSO ^cSRS acQSRS` ^S`] Sa] a RSaRS ZO Q]\dWQQW \ RS _cS aS`S[]a QOÔQSa RS Q]\bÒ``SabO` Z]a STSQb]a ] Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RS QcOZ_cWS` bW^] RS µQObtab`]TS¶ 3abO ^Sà^SQbWdO RS ZO bS\RS\QWO O b`WdWOZWhO` ] O PO\OZWhO` Q]\bÒabO Q]\ c\]a ^`Sac^cSab]a a]P`S ZOa WRSOa RS RSaO``]ZZ] ] µWRSOa RSZ [c\R]¶ _cS @O[]a `Sac[S S\ b`Sa ^`W\QW^W]a( S\ ^`W\QW^W] ZO WRSO RS W\aSUc`WROR aSU \ ZO QcOZ b]RO aWbcOQW \ Sa µ^`SQO`WO g bÒ\aWQW]\OZ¶ \ORO Sa OaSUcÒPZS g [S\]a ZO WRSO RSZ PWS\SabO` Vc[O\] 3\ aSUc\R] ZcUO` ZO WRSO RS _cS ZO VWab]`WO Sa c\ ^c`] QO[PW] _cS \] Sabt µdS`bSPÒR] ^]` \W\U \ aS\bWR] RS ZO XcabWQWO¶ g _cS \] aS RW`WUS O \W\U \ µ`STcUW] aSUc`] RS ZWPS`bOR ] dS`ROR¶ G S\ bS`QS` g ZbW[] ZcUO` ZO Q]\dWQQW \ RS _cS Z]a aS`Sa Vc[O\]a a]\ W\QOÔQSa RS R][W\O` SZ RSabW\] aW\] _cS bWS\RS\ O µZO RSa[SacÒ ZO a]PS`PWO g SZ SfQSa] g Z] VOQS\ RS bOZ [O\SÒ _cS OQOPO\ RSaS_cWZWPÒ\R] SZ [c\R] g ^`]d]QO\R] [OZSa g RSaUÒQWOa _cS aS OPObS\ a]P`S SZZ]a [Wa[]a¶ @O[]a @ ]^ QWb >]` ac Ô`bS 0SQY ''' ^]\S SZ OQS\b] S\ ZO W\QOÔQWROR Q`SQWS\bS ÔÒ QOZQcZO` Z]a `WSaU]a g ÔÒ RSZW[WbO` SaÔQW] bS[^]ÒZ[S\bS Z]a RO ]a _cS ^cSRS\ ZZSdO` OÔ`SXOR]a RS bOZ [O\SÒ _cS SZ Q]\QS^b] RS `WSaU] Sa QORO dSh [ta QS`QO\] OZ RS W\QS`bWRc[P`S C\O W\QS`bWRc[P`S _cS S\ PcS\O Ô`bS W[^ZWQO g aS `STWS`S O c\O RS ZOa VS`Ò[WS\bOa [ta ^]bS\bSa RSZ RWaQcà] []RS`\] g RSZ RSaO``]ZZ]( ZO QOÔQWROR QWS\b TWQO g bSQ\]Z UWQO ÔÒ bÒ\aT]`[O` SZ [c\R] g SZ Tcbc`] 2SaRS SabS ^c\b] RS dWabO ZO µQS`bShO¶ bSQ\]Z UWQO O ZO dSh _cS Sa SZ []b]` g SZ ^WZO` RSZ OdO\QS g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] aS Q]\dWS`bS S\ ^]bS\QWOZ TcS\bS RS RSab`cQQW $ ZO bSQ\] QWS\QWO RSXO RS aS` Q]\TWOPZS G ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S ^`]d]QO [WSR] S W\aSUc`WROR C\O RS Z]a t[PWb]a S\ Z]a _cS [ta aS VO RSaO``]ZZOR] SZ O\tZWaWa RSZ `WSaU] S\ SabO ^Sà^SQbWdO bSQ\]Z UWQO Sa ZO _cS bWS\S _cS dS` Q]\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] Oa]QWOR] O ZO Q`WaWa SQ]Z UWQO 3\ ac O`b QcZ] µ/Z VWZ] RS ZO ^`SQOcQW \¬¶ @O[ \ @O[]a O\OZWhO ZOa ^]aWQW]\Sa RS 8]\Oa g :cV[O\\ RSaRS ZO Q]\bÒ^]aWQW \ RS R]a ^c\b]a RS dWabO OÔ`S\bS[S\bS Q]\bÒRWQb]`W]a RS O\OZWhO` ZO Q`WaWa SQ]Z UWQO @O[]a @ ! C\O Ô`bS RSZ W\bS`{a RS Sab]a ^c\b]a RS dWabO ÒRWQO S\ ZO QOÔQWROR ÔÒ bÒaQS\RS` SZ t[PWb] Q]\Q`Sb] RS O\tZWaWa VOQWO c\O Q]\ab`cQQW \ bS `WQO RS QO`tQbS` US\SÒZ g a]P`S b]R] ZO ^]abcZOQW \ RS R]a ^Sà^SQbWdOa RWdSÙS\bSa a]P`S ZO \SQSaWROR RS OT`]\bO` Z]a `WSaU]a O Ô`bW` RS R]a []RSZ]a RS ^]aWQW]\O[WS\b] Sf^Z QWb]a g Q]\Q`Sb]a SfbÒ^]ZOPZSa O ]b`]a t[PWb]a RWdSà]a ^S`] a]P`S b]R] S\QO[W\OR]a O ZO OQQW \ 3Z ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] RS 8]\Oa RSaRS ZO T]`[cZOQW \ RSZ >`W\QW^W] RS >`SQOcQW $ SZ RS :cV[O\\ RSaRS SZ O\tZWaWa aWab{[WQ]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

3Z >`W\QW^W] RS >`SQOcQW \ RS 8]\Oa Ô`bS RSZ ^`Sac^cSab] RS _cS ZO Q`WaWa SQ]Z UWQO aS RSPS OZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS c\O bSQ\]Z]U O S\ ZO _cS RSPS[]a RSaQ]\TWO` g O\bS ZO _cS RSPS[]a [O\bS\S`\]a OZS`bO ÔÒ ZW[WbO` Z]a `WSaU]a RS ac O^ZWQOQW \ ^S\aO\R] S\ µSZ ^S]` RS Z]a SaQS\O`W]a ^]aWPZSa¶ Sa RSQW` S\ Q]\aSQcS\QWOa µOZbO[S\bS RO W\Oa S W``SdSàWPZSa¶ 3Z ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] RS 8]\Oa aWUcWS\R] O @O[]a ]^ QWb aS RSaO``]ZZO O bÒd{a RS aSWa QOÒQbS` abWQOa Tc\RO[S\bOZSa( bS[]` g aS\bW[WS\b] RS O[S\OhO O\bS ZO SdS\bcOZWROR RS RO ]a S\ ac QOa] [SRW]O[PWS\bOZSa ] RS aOZcR ) W\QS`bWRc[P`S QWS\b TWQO S\ Q]\bÒ RS ZO ^`SbS\RWRO aSUc`WROR RS ZO SdOZcOQW \ RS `WSaU]a) WR]\SWROR RS ZO OQQW \ ^`SdS\bWdO RS ^`]bSQQW \ g QcWROR] RS Z]a PWS\Sa Sf^cSab]a O ZO SdS\bcOZWROR RS RO ]a) O^cSabO ^]` ZO ]^QW \ RSbS`[W\O\bS RS _cS aSO\ Z]a ^`][]b]`Sa RS ZOa \cSdOa ^`tQbWQOa bSQ\]Z UWQOa _cWS\Sa O^]`bS\ ZOa ^`cSPOa _cS RS[cSab`S\ ZO W\]QcWROR RS ac O^ZWQOQW \) O^cSabO ^]` ZO RS[]QÒbWhOQW \ RS ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa T`S\bS O Z]a `WSaU]a g ZOa [SRWROa RS ^`SQOcQW \ S\ Q]\bÒ RS ZO ^`W[OQ O RS Z]a Sf^S`b]a g ^]` ZbW[] ZO \SQSaWROR RS _cS aS UOÒ\bWQS c\O W\a^SQQW \ QcWROR]aO RS ZOa OZbS`\ObWdOa O\bS QcOZ_cWS` \cSd] ^`]RcQb] ] bSQ\]Z]U O 3abS ^c\b] RS dWabO W[^ZWQO c\O O^cSabO RS \R]ZS {bWQ] []ÒZ O^SZO\R] O ZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR Q]ZSQbWdO S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] RS W\QS`bWRc[P`S g [WSR] AS bÒbO S\ aca ^`]^W]a b{`[W\]a RS c\O µ{bWQO RS ZO Q]\aS`dOQW \ RS ZO ^`SaS`dOQW \ RSZ W[^SRW[S\b] g \] c\O {bWQO RSZ ^`]U`Sa] g SZ ^S`TSQQW]\O[WS\b]¶ 8]\Oa ''# S\ ZO _cS SZ [WSR] µSZ [WSR] ÒQW]\OZ ] Òh]\OPZS¶ aS Q]\dWS`bS S\ µO\bWQWÔQW \ RS ZO O[S\OhO¶ 3Z [WSR] ac^]\S c\ OQb] RS `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR VOQWO SZ Tcbc`] VOQWO Z] _cS ^cSRO dS\W` aWS\R] QWS`bO ZO QOÔQWROR Vc[O\O ÔÒ OQbcO` g b][O` RSQWaW]\Sa) Sa] a S\bS\RWS\R] ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa aWS[^`S RSaRS ZO O^cSabO ^]` ZO ]^QW \ RS µ`WSaU] QS`]¶ _cS `Sa^]\RO O c\ ^`W\QW^W] {bWQ] SZS[S\bOZ( \] Q][^`][SbS` SZ Tcbc`] 4`S\bS O Z]a ^]abcZOR]a RS 8]\Oa ZO Q` bWQO RS :cV[O\\ aS ^ZO\bSO RSaRS ZO WRSO RS _cS ZO O^cSabO RSZ >`W\QW^W] RS @Sa^]\aOPWZWROR ] >`SQOcQW \ a Z] O^SZO O µZO W\OQQW \ ZO []Òb]`WO ZO OPabS\QW \ Q`SgS\R] Oa ^`SdS\W` c\ Tcbc`] RS RSaOab`S¶ @O[]a @ ]^ QWb aW\ _cS aSO ^]aWPZS RSZW[WbO` SZ `WSaU] RS`WdOR] ^`SQWaO[S\bS RS ZO \] OQbcOQW \ 2S OZUc\O [O\SÒ Z] _cS :cV[O\\ `S^`]QVO Sa SZ bÒaT]\R] RS W[^]bS\QWO _cS SZ [WSR] ^]\S RS [O\WTWSab] ac^]\WS\R] _cS SZ [c\R] Sa aSUc`] RS ^]` a g _cS SdWbO\R] ZO OQQW \ Vc[O\O aS SdWbO`t SZ ^SZWU`] 1cO\R] QWS`bO[S\bS ZO `SOZWROR a]QWOZ OQbcOZ aS QOÒQbS`WhO ^]` c\O [ShQZO RS W\QS`bWRc[P`S `WSaU] WU\]Ò\QWO S W\RSbS`[W\OQW \ Qcg] OT`]\bO[WS\b] ^]\S RS [O\WTWSab] bO[PW{\ ZO USabW \ RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa :cV[O\\ O^cSabO ^]` ZO WRSO RS Q][^`][Wa] T`S\bS O ZO RS Z]a dOZ]`Sa []ÒZSa O^]abO\R] ^]`_cS aSO\ Z]a Q][^`][Wa]a Z]a _cS ]PZWUcS\ O Z]a aS`Sa Vc[O\]a O S\bS\RSàS g PcaQO` OQcS`R]a 4`S\bS O ZO µ`Sb `WQO RSZ [WSR]¶ ZO ]^QW \ aS` O ZO RS ZO µ`Sb `WQO RSZ S\bS\RW[WS\b]¶ S\ c\O `SOZWROR aWab{[WQO RS W\bSÒQQW \ g Q][c\WQOQW \ S\b`S Z]a OUS\bSa RS ZO Sa^SQWS Vc[O\O g SZ S\b]`\] [SRW] \ObcÒZ BOZ Q][] RSTW\S @O[]a µ:cV[O\\ ^`]^]\S _cS ZO \WQO [O\SÒ RS OR[W\WabÒ` ZO Q`WaWa SQ]Z UWQO ¬ Sa ^]` [SRW] RS Z]a S\bS\RW[WS\b]a ^c\bcOZSa g S\ ^S`^SbcO `S\SU]QWOQW \ ¬ S\ b{`[W\]a RS SaÔQW]a ^ PZWQ]a RS ^SàcOaW \ S\ Z]a _cS c\]a g ]b`]a \]a Q][c\WQO[]a [WSR] S WU\]Ò\QWO g O ZO dSh SZ RSaS] RS W` O^`S\RWS\R] ObS\W{\R]\]a O ZO RW\t[WQO W[^`SRSQWPZS RS ZOa Q]aOa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

RSQWRWS\R] g `S RSQWRWS\R] Z] RSQWRWR] S\ SZ [O`Q] RS c\O []`OZ g c\O QWS\QWO ^`]dWaW]\OZSa _cS \]a ^S`[WbS\ ORO^bO`\]a O c\ [c\R] R]\RS `WUS\ Q]\bW\US\QWO S W\QS`bWRc[P`S g SdS\bcOZ[S\bS Z]a S\`SR]a RS c\ US\W] [OZWU\]¶ @O[]a @ !

/ZUc\]a `STS`S\bSa bS `WQ]a RSZ `WSaU] RSaRS Z] a]QWOZ 1][] gO VS[]a O^c\bOR] Ô`SQS QZO`] _cS SZ Q]\QS^b] RS `WSaU] Sa OZbO[S\bS ^]ZWa{[WQ] g Q][^ZSX] g Q][] aS ^cSRS ^S`QWPW` \] Sa ^]aWPZS OQS`QOàS O {Z RSaRS ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a aW[^ZWabOa 3abS Sa c\] RS Z]a [ta QZO`]a Q]\aS\a]a RS _cWS\Sa VO\ bÒPOXOR] a]P`S ZO bS]` O RSZ `WSaU] RSaRS QcOZ_cWSÒ RS ZOa ^Sà^SQbWdOa ^]aWPZSa 3a^SQWOZ[S\bS RSaRS ZOa QWS\QWOa a]QWOZSa aS VO ^cSab] RS [O\WTWSab] SZ S\bÒ[OR] RS Q][^ZSXWROR _cS W[^ZWQO SZ O\tZWaWa RSZ `WSaU] S\ SZ _cS Sa \SQSaO`W] ^]\S` S\ XcSU] c\O PcS\O Ô`bS RS Z]a OÙc[S\b]a ^`]^W]a RS SabOa RWaQW^ZW\Oa bÒaQS\RWS\R] ZOa `STS`S\QWOa Sab`WQbOa RS ZO SQ]\][ O ZO bSQ\]Z]U O SbQ ÔÒ ^]\S`ZOa S\ `SZOQW \ Q]\ ZOa RW\t[WQOa a]QWOZSa _cS ZOa acabS\bO\ 7\RS^S\RWS\bS[S\bS RS _cS SZ ]`WUS\ RSZ SabcRW] RSZ `WSaU] ^`]dS\UO RS ZOa O^`]fW[OQW]\Sa RSZ O\tZWaWa SQ]\ [WQ] TW\O\QWS`] g S\ US\SÒZ RSaRS RWaQW^ZW\Oa _cS VO\ PcaQOR] ZO T]`[cZOQW \ QcO\bWbObWdO RSZ Q]\QS^b] ÔÒ ZO ]PbS\QW \ [ObS[tbWQO RS RSbS`[W\OR]a `SacZbOR]a( []RSZWhOQW \ QtZQcZ] g ^`SRWQQW \ ^`SdWaW \¬ C\O ^`W[SÒ Ô`bS RS ZO Q][^ZSXWROR aS POaO S\ _cS S\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` Sa \SQSaO`W] `SaOZbO` ZO O[PWU SROR ] R]PZS aS\bWR] RSZ ^`]^W] b{`[W\] RS µ`WSaU]¶ QcO\R] aS WRS\bWTWQO ^]` c\O Ô`bS Q]\ µZO ^`]POPWZWROR ] Q]\bW\US\QWO RS RO ]a¶ g ^]` ]bÒ µQ]\ SZ ]`WUS\ ] TcS\bS RSZ RO ] ] Q]\ Z]a OUS\bSa QOÔQSa RS ^`]d]QO`Z]¶ >cg @]R` UcSh / ''" 2SaRS ZOa ^]abcZOQW]\Sa [ta QcO\bWbObWdWabOa [ta SQ]\][WQWabOa SZ O\tZWaWa RSZ `WSaU] aS POaO` O S\ ZO RSbS`[W\OQW \ RS Tc\QW]\Sa ] []RSZ]a ÔÒ ZO SdOZcOQW \ RSZ `WSaU] RSaRS R]a ^]aWQW]\Sa RWTS`S\QWOZSa C\Oa _cS VO\ O^]abOR] ^]` `SZOQW]\O` ZO SfWabS\QWO RS TcS\bSa RS `WSaU] Q]\ ZOa [SRWROa RS aSUc`WROR RWa^]\WPZSa S\ c\ Q]QWS\bS S\ SZ QcOZ ZO [SRWRO RSZ `WSaU] RS^S\RS RSZ Oc[S\b] ] RWa[W\cQW \ Q]``SZObWd]a RS O[P]a b{`[W\]a( TcS\bSa g [SRWROa RS aSUc`WROR =bÒa _cS W\QZcgS\ S\ ac T]`[cZOQW \ ZO Q][PW\OQW \ [cZbW^ZWQObWdO RS ZO ^`]POPWZWROR ] W\QS`bWRc[P`S `Sa^SQb] O Z]a RO ]a g ZO [OU\WbcR ^`SdWabO RS RWQV]a RO ]a / RWTS`S\QWO RS SabOa ]`WS\bOQW]\Sa S\ ZOa _cS aS ^`Sac^]\S c\O RSTW\WQW \ µ]PXSbWdO¶ RS Z]a b{`[W\]a Q]\aWRSÒR]a S\ Z]a RWabW\b]a []RSZ]a aS VO\ ^]abcZOR] bO[PW{\ O^`]fW[OQW]\Sa RS \R]ZS [ta Q]\ab`cQbWdWabO RSaRS ZOa QcOZSa SfWabS c\ Tc\RO[S\b] PtaWQ] S\ ZO SdOZcOQW \ RS Z]a aWU\WTWQOR]a Oa]QWOR]a O Z]a RO ]a ^`SdWab]a 2SaRS SabO ^Sà^SQbWdO aS S\bWS\RS SZ `WSaU] Q][] Q]\ab`cQb] a]QWOZ [cZbWRW[S\aW]\OZ S\ SZ _cS VOg _cS W\Q]`^]Ò` S\b`S ]b`]a SZS[S\b]a _cS W`S[]a ^`SaS\bO\R] ZOa WRSOa RS d]Zc\bO`WSROR RS RS[]Ò RS Z]a STSQb]a g RS Q`SRWPWZWROR S\ _cWS\ USabW]\O Z]a RWTS`S\bSa `WSaU]a ] ZOa OZbS`\ObWdOa 3\ US\SÒZ SZ ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] RSaRS ZOa QWS\QWOa a]QWOZSa bOZ Q][] VS[]a dWab] ^ZOa[OR] S\ SZ RSPObS O^c\bOR] S\ SZ OÔ`bOR] O\bS`W]` aS VO QS\bÒR] S\ SZ O\tZWaWa RS ZO Q]\bÒRWQQW \ ] RWaQ`SÔ\QWO S\b`S ZOa dOZ]ÒQW]\Sa RS Sf^S`b]a g ZSU]a( S\b`S ZOa `SQ][S\ROQW]\Sa RS _cWS\Sa bWS\S\ ZO PObcbO bSQ\]Z UWQO RSZ ^]RS` _cS ]b]ÙO SZ Q]\]QW[WS\b]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

QWS\b TWQ] ]PXSbWd] g ZOa SdOZcOQW]\Sa TW\OZSa RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ US\SÒZ ] QWS`b]a Q]\Xc\b]a `S^`SaS\bObWd]a RS SZZO _cS S\ ]QOaW]\Sa \] ^]Q] T`SQcS\bSa OR]^bO ^]aWQW]\Sa _cS dO\ S\ Q]\bÒ RS ZO ]^W\W \ µQcOZWTWQORO¶ RS Z]a S\bS\RWR]a S\ ZOa [ObS`WOa Q]``Sa^]\RWS\bSa 3\ Q]\Q`Sb] SZ RSaO``]ZZ] bSQ\]Z UWQ] S\ aca RWabW\bOa dO`WO\bSa S\SÙ{bWQOa Q][c\WQObWdOa SbQ VO aWR] c\] RS Z]a t[PWb]a S\ Z]a _cS SZ RSPObS a]P`S SZ OT`]\bO[WS\b] RSZ `WSaU] [ta aS VO RSaO``]ZZOR] bOZ Q][] VS[]a dWab] :O ^cSabO S\ SaQS\O RSZ RSPObS VO aWR] SZ QcSabW]\O[WS\b] RS ^]` _c{ ZOa ^Sà]\Oa \] Sf^S`bOa SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO QWcRORO\ O ] U`c^]a _cS `S^`SaS\bO\ O SabO ]^W\W \ \] Sa^SQWOZWhORO aS ]^]\S\ O Z]a Q`WbS`W]a RS Z]a Sa^SQWOZWabOa QcO\R] Sab]a ^`SaS\bO\ ZOa dS\bOXOa RS ZO ac^cSabO ÒQW]\OZWROR b{Q\WQO S\ O^]g] RS ZO Oac\QW \ ] `SQVOh] RS RSbS`[W\OR]a `WSaU]a Q]\Q`Sb]a 2SaRS SabO ^Sà^SQbWdO RS ]^]aWQW \ S\b`S ]^W\W \ QcOZWTWQORO g ]^W\W \ RSa QcOZWTWQORO Sa \SQSaO`W] dOZ]Ò` aW Sa ^]aWPZS _cS _cWS\Sa Oac[S\ SZ `]Z RS ^`]TSaW]\OZSa ] µSa^SQWOZWabOa¶ S[^`S\RO\ OQQW]\Sa W\T]`[ObWdOa ^`SdS\bWdOa ] [SÒ[S\bS bS `WQOa S\ Q]\bÒ RS ZO ]^W\W \ RSZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO ^]PZOQW \) ] Q][] [ \W[] _cS \] bS\UO\ S\ QcS\bO SZ W[OUW\O`W] Q]ZSQbWd] OZ `Sa^SQb] S\ ]QOaW]\Sa ^`]Tc\RO[S\bS W\abOZOR] a]P`S Q]\dWQQW]\Sa ] Sf^SQbObWdOa _cS \] Q]W\QWRS\ Q]\ Z]a ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a RS SaOa ]^W\W]\Sa µQcOZWTWQOROa¶ :O QcSabW \ `SacZbO Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS `SZSdO\bS S\ [cQV]a RS Z]a Oa^SQb]a O Z]a _cS \]a `STS`W[]a VOPWbcOZ[S\bS QcO\R] ^S\aO[]a S\ Z]a µ`WSaU]a RS ZO XcdS\bcR¶ Q][] Sa SZ QOa] 3\b]\QSa `SacZbO \SQSaO`W] Oac[W` _cS aS `SOZWhO SaO [WÒRO Sf^S`bO Sa PtaWQO[S\bS c\O [WÒRO µORcZbO¶ a]P`S QcSabW]\Sa _cS bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ SZ c\WdSà] RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ [ta X]dS\ Oc\_cS SaS c\WdSà] Q][Ô`bO g S\QcS\b`S ac ]`WUS\ S\ dOZ]`Sa g RW\t[WQOa a]QWOZSa Q][c\Sa Q]\ ZOa P`SQVOa W\bS`^`SbObWdOa _cS SZZ] ac^]\S 3ab] ^]` ac^cSab] \] W\dOZWRO bOZ [WÒRO ¦TOZbO` O [ta ^S`] ]PZWUO O aS` Q]\aQWS\bS RS Z]a [ObWQSa `SZObWd]a O ZOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa _cS S\Q]\bÒ`S[]a S\ SZ QO[W\] g O Z]a SZS[S\b]a _cS Q][^]\S\ SZ c\WdSà] RS µZ] X]dS\¶ T`S\bS OZ RS µZ] ORcZb]¶ 3\ SabO SaQS\WTWQOQW \ Z] _cS ZOa QWS\QWOa a]QWOZSa VO\ bÒbOR] RS ^]\S` RS [O\WTWSab] Sa SZ VSQV] RS _cS ZOa `SOQQW]\Sa c ]^QW]\Sa RS ZO a]QWSROR \] Sf^S`bO _cS Sa S\ US\SÒZ a]P`S ZO _cS aS S\bWS\RS _cS aS ^`]gSQbO SZ `WSaU] \] aS Tc\RO[S\bO S\ ZO W`ÒQW]\OZWROR S W\QZca] S\ ZO [SÒ W\Q]\aQWS\QWO QcO\R] aS ]^]\S O ZOa `SQ][S\ROQW]\Sa ] RWQbOR]a RSZ SabO[S\b] RS Sa^SQWOZWabOa 4`S\bS O S\T]_cSa bS\RS\bSa O VOQS` VW\QO^W{ S\ µÔb]Z]U Oa ^S`QS^bWdOa¶ ] RSTW\WQW]\Sa µSab`SQVOa¶ RS ZO ÒQW]\OZWROR aS T]`[cZO ZO VW^ bSaWa RS _cS ZOa POaSa RS ZO µÒQW]\OZWROR a]QWOZ¶ QcS\bO\ Q]\ ]b`]a SZS[S\b]a O Z]a _cS aS ^cSRS g aS RSPS Q]\aWRSÒ` Q][] µ]bÒ ÒQW]\OZWROR¶ OZbS`\ObWdO 3\ RSTW\WbWdO O Z] _cS aS O^c\bO Sa OZ [O`Q] a]QWOZ ^]Z bWQ] g QcZbcÒZ S\ _cS bWS\S\ ZcUO` Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS ^S`QS^QW \ g Q][c\WQOQW \ RS Z]a `WSaU]a¶ 2]cUZOa ; '&$) >cg @]R` UcSh / ''" ³ 2S Z]a S\T]_cSa [ta QS\bÒR]a S\ SZ t[PWb] RS ZOa RSQWaW]\Sa a]QWOZSa ^]RS[]a `SaOZbO` ZOa aWUcWS\bSa bÒRWQW]\Sa >cg @]R` UcSh / ''" (

C\O ^`W[SÒ O^`]fW[OQW \ RS QO`tQbS` [ta âWQ]Z]UWQWabO g QS\bÒRO S\ Z] W\RWdWRcOZ Sa O_cSZZO Qcg] ^c\b] RS Ô`bWRO Sa ZO SdOZcOQW \ RS ZOa RSQWaW]\Sa O\bS SZ `WSaU] RSaRS SZ ^c\b] RS dWabO RS ZO ^]aWPZS ]Qc``S\QWO RS aSaU]a ] S``]`Sa RS bW^] Q]U\WbWd] AS bÒbO RSZ S\T]_cS

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

Q]U\WbWdWabO S\ ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa S\ Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS W\QS`bWRc[P`S

2SaRS SabO O^`]fW[OQW \ ZOa VS`Ò[WS\bOa W\bS`^`SbObWdOa RS ZOa RSQWaW]\Sa O\bS SZ `WSaU] aS QS\bÒ\ S\ SZ O\tZWaWa RS Oa^SQb]a bOZSa Q][] ZO RWa^]\WPWZWROR ] OQQSaWPWZWROR RSZ `WSaU] SZ aSaU] RS Ocb]Q]\TWO\hO S\ _cWS\Sa bWS\S\ S\ aca [O\]a ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa g S\ US\SÒZ S\ ÒaU]a RSbS`[W\OR]a RS ZO ^Sà]\OZWROR RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa 3\b`S Sab]a ÒaU]a bS\R` O\ W\bS`{a ZO ^`SRWa^]aWQW \ W\QZW\OQW \ ] OdSàW \ O\bS SZ `WSaU] ] RSbS`[W\OR]a µ[]RSZ]a [S\bOZSa¶ [SRWO\bS Z]a QcOZSa ZOa ^Sà]\Oa bS\RS` O\ O T]QOZWhO` ZO Q][c\WQOQW \ S\ Q`SS\QWOa µO[PWUcOa RWab]àW]\OROa ] OcaS\bSa¶

3abS S\T]_cS OZ _cS aS VO WR] W\Q]`^]Ò\R] SZ O\tZWaWa RS Sab [cZ]a RS \R]ZS a]QWOZ ] RS RSbS`[W\OROa QOÒQbS` abWQOa QcOZWbObWdOa RSZ ]`RS\ a]QWOZ Sa SZ _cS VO RSaO``]ZZOR] S\ [Og]` [SRWRO SZ S\T]_cS RS O\tZWaWa âWQ][{b`WQ] RSZ `WSaU]

>]` ac Ô`bS c\O aSUc\RO ^Sà^SQbWdO ZO âWQ]a]QWOZ aS VO QS\bÒR] S\ SZ O\tZWaWa RS Z]a []RSZ]a OQbWbcRW\OZSa O\bS SZ `WSaU] W\Q]`^]Ò\R] ZO \]QW \ RS _cS ZO OQS^bOQW \ ] `SQVOh] RSZ `WSaU] \] `Sa^]\RS O bS\RS\QWOa µW`ÒQW]\OZSa¶ ] O aSaU]a Q]U\WbWd]a aW\] _cS aS OaWS\bO S\ QObSU]` Oa Q]ZSQbWdOa QS`QO\Oa O Z]a dOZ]`Sa g ZOa Q`SS\QWOa Q][Ô`bWR]a a]QWOZ[S\bS S\ \bW[O `SZOQW \ Q]\ Oa^SQb]a OTSQbWd]a g ] S[]QW]\OZSa RS Z]a W\RWdWRc]a

3abO ^Sà^SQbWdO ^]abcZO ZO `SZOQW \ S\b`S ZO ^S`QS^QW \ a]QWOZ RSZ `WSaU] Q]\ ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa a]QW]RS[]U`tTWQOa S\bS\RWS\R] _cS a]\ SabOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa ZOa _cS ^S`[WbS\ Sf^ZWQO` dOZ]ÒQW]\Sa RWTS`S\bSa ÔÒ aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] aW[WZO`Sa S\b`S U`c^]a ^]PZOQW]\Sa RWdSà]a

³ 4W\OZ[S\bS c\O bS`QSÒ ^Sà^SQbWdO Q]\ab`cWRO RSaRS SZ O\tZWaWa [ta a]QW]Z UWQ] g a]QW]QcZbcÒZ ^ZO\bSO ZO SfWabS\QWO RS QcSabW]\Sa PtaWQOa S\ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ g OT`]\bO[WS\b] RSZ `WSaU] bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO _cS Sa SZ µ[]RSZ] a]QWOZ¶ g QcZbcÒZ ^]` bO\b] SZ _cS RSbS`[W\O ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS _cS SZ `WSaU] aS Q]\abWbcgO S\ c\O QObSU]` O `SZSdO\bS S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ RSbS`[W\OR]) Oa Q][] RSbS`[W\O bO[PW{\ SZ [O`Q] S\ SZ _cS aS RSTW\S Z] _cS aS S\bWS\RS Q][] `WSaU] g Z] _cS \] A]\ ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa g ] Z]a U`c^]a a]QWOZSa Z]a _cS bWS\S\ QOÔQWROR ÔÒ O[^ZWTWQO` ZOa RWTS`S\bSa \]QW]\Sa RS `WSaU] O Ô`bW` RS ZOa RW\t[WQOa Sa^SQ TWQOa RS c\ Q]ZSQbWd]

3\ SZ [O`Q] RS Sab]a ^`]QSa]a a]QWOZSa Sa R]\RS aS RO\ ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa ÔÒ _cS aS ^`]RchQO ZO aSZSQQW \ a]P`S Z] _cS aS Q]\aWRSÒ ] \] `WSaU] g a]P`S b]R] a]P`S ZO OQS^bOPWZWROR ] \] RS QORO c\] RS Z]a ^]aWPZSa `WSaU]a aWS[^`S S\ Tc\QW \ RS Z]a dOZ]`Sa Q`SS\QWOa g OQbWbcRSa _cS RSTW\S\ ZO Q]ZSQbWdWROR A]\ SaOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa RSZ bW^] _cS aSO\ ZOa _cS RSZW[WbO\ _c{ `WSaU]a a]\ Z]a _cS ^]\S\ S\ ^SZWU`] SZ ]`RS\ a]QWOZ ] Z] _cS Sa Z] [Wa[] QctZSa a]\ ZOa µ[O\SÒa RS dWdW`¶ OQS^bOPZSa g µZ]a bW^]a RS `SZOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa¶ Q]\ _cS QORO a]QWSROR RSQWRS Q]\abWbcWàS

2SaRS Sab]a S\T]_cSa [ta QS`QO\]a OZ ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] a]QW]Z UWQ] g S\ Q]\Q`Sb] RSaRS ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO RS ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ a]QWOZ SZ `WSaU] RSPS aS` Q]\aWRSÒR] Q][] ^`]POPWZWROR RS _cS ]Qc`Ò c\ RO ] ] Q][]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

^`]POPWZWROR RS _cS ]Qc`Ò ]bÒ OZbS`\ObWdO RWTS`S\bS bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO _cS O[POa ^]aWPWZWRORSa ac^]\S\ ^{`RWROa ] UO\O\QWOa >S`] bO[PW{\ bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO ZO SfWabS\QWO `SOZ RS c\O O[S\OhO _cS SfWabS g RS _cS Sa ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS SaO O[S\OhO ZO _cS ^S`[WbS ZO SdOZcOQW \ g ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa bO\b] RSaRS SZ ^c\b] RS dWabO TWaW]Z UWQ] Q][] Q]U\WbWd] ] OQbWbcRW\OZ ³Q]\RcQbcOZ >S`] Z] _cS Sa Tc\RO[S\bOZ S\ ZO WRSO RS ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ a]QWOZ RSZ `WSaU] Sa SZ VSQV] RS _cS ZO Sf^SQbObWdO RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b] O\bS SZ `WSaU] Sabt RSbS`[W\ORO ^]` ZO Sf^SQbObWdO Q][Ô`bWRO ^]` Z]a U`c^]a RS `STS`S\QWO `SZSdO\bSa ] ^]` Z]a Ô`t[Sb`]a RSTW\WR]a ^]` ZO a]QWOZWhOQW \ G SaS Q][^]`bO[WS\b] Q][] Sa TtQWZ[S\bS S\bS\RWPZS g O^ZWQOPZS RS T]`[O Sa^SQ TWQO O RWabW\b]a t[PWb]a `STS`WR]a O ZO `SOZWROR X]dS\ ^cSRS `Sa^]\RS` O ZO Sf^SQbObWdO ] S\T`S\bOàS O SZZO :Oa OZbS`\ObWdOa S\ ZO b][O RS RSQWaW \ T`S\bS OZ `WSaU] bS\R` O\ _cS dS` OZ [S\]a Q]\ ZO SdOZcOQW \ RS ZOa ^{`RWROa ^]aWPZSa SZ aWU\WTWQOR] RS RWQVOa ^{`RWROa g SZ aS\bWR] Sa^SQ TWQ] RS ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S 3\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` ^]`_cS ZO RSbS`[W\OQW \ RS ZOa ^]aWPZSa ^{`RWROa Oa]QWOROa O ZO OQS^bOQW \ ] \] RSZ `WSaU] aS SdOZ O\ S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZO `SZObWdWROR T`S\bS O ]bÒa `STS`S\QWOa ] S\ Q][ÔÒQW \ Q]\ SZZOa) S\ aSUc\R] ZcUO` ^]`_cS ZO SfWabS\QWO RS c\ [Og]` \ [S`] RS Q][^]\S\bSa \SUObWd]a aWU\WTWQObWd]a S\ ZO SdOZcOQW \ RSZ `WSaU] VOQS Q`SQS` ZO WRSO RS `WSaU] g SaO SdOZcOQW \ Sabt `SZOQW]\ORO Q]\ Z]a dOZ]`Sa _cS a]\ ZOa ÔcbOa RS RSZW[WbOQW \ ÔÒ ZO OQS^bOPWZWROR RS ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa SdOZcOROa 3Z `WSaU] W[^Z QWb] ] ZO UÒdSROR S\ ZO SdOZcOQW \ Sabt a][SbWR] OZ TWZb`] RS ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa S\ _cS aS SdOZ O g a]P`S b]R] RS ac aWU\WTWQOR] RS^S\RWS\R] RS ZOa Q]\dWQQW]\Sa {bWQ] []ÒZSa 2]cUZOa ; '&$ >]` bO\b] ZO dOZ]ÒQW \ RSZ `WSaU] aS`t [cg ^`]POPZS[S\bS RWTS`S\bS S\b`S U`c^]a _cS W\RS^S\RWS\bS[S\bS RS _cS Sab{\ WUcOZ[S\bS a][SbWR]a O Z]a ^`]POPZSa RO ]a QcS\bS\ Q]\ RWTS`S\bSa `STS`S\QWOa ÔÒ ZO RSbS`[W\OQW \ RS ZO aWU\WTWQObWdWROR S\ Sa]a RO ]a ^`]POPZSa 3ab] ^S\aO\R] S\ `WSaU]a VOPWbcOZ[S\bS Ob`WPcWR]a O Z] X]dS\ aS ^cSRS dS` Q]\ QZO`WROR ^]` SXS[^Z] S\ ZOa RWabW\bOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa RSZ `WSaU] S\b`S _cWS\Sa Q]\ac[S\ R`]UOa g _cWS\Sa \] Z] VOQS\) ^S`] bO[PW{\ S\b`S _cWS\Sa Q]\ac[S\ c\ bW^] RS acabO\QWOa T`S\bS O _cWS\Sa Q]\ac[S\ ]bÒa RWTS`S\bSa) ] S\b`S _cWS\Sa VO\ bS\WR] `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa T`S\bS O _cWS\Sa \] VO\ Sf^S`W[S\bOR] O \ Q]\ ZO aSfcOZWROR :O WRSO RS W\QS`bWRc[P`S Q][] VS[]a dWab] O\bS`W]`[S\bS Sa bO[PW{\ QZOdS ÔÒ Q]\TWUcÒ` ZOa OZbS`\ObWdOa RS RSQWaW \ 3a c\ Q][^]\S\bS ^`W[]`RWOZ S\ ZO SdOZcOQW \ RSZ `WSaU] RSaRS RWTS`S\bSa ^Sà^SQbWdOa 3\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` RSaRS ZO Q]\bÒ^]aWQW \ S\b`S W\QS`bWRc[P`S g aSUc`WROR ^cSab] _cS aW \] SfWabS c\ SaQS\O`W] RS W\QS`bWRc[P`S bO[^]Q] bWS\S aS\bWR] ZO WRSO RS `WSaU] >S`] bO[PW{\ RSaRS Z]a bW^]a RWabW\b]a RS W\QS`bWRc[P`Sa W[^ZWQOROa S\ SZ `WSaU]( a]P`S ZO ^`]POPWZWROR ] ^]bS\QWOZWROR RS _cS SfWabO\ ] \] Z]a RO ]a ^`SdWab]a ¥]Qc``W`t\ ] \]- ) a]P`S SZ UÒR] RS bÒaQS\RS\QWO RS ZOa ^{`RWROa ¥aS`t\ UÒ\RSa ] ^S_cS Oa- ) g bO[PW{\ a]P`S Z]a t[PWb]a ^]bS\QWOZ[S\bS OTSQbOR]a ¥S\ _c{ Oa^SQb]a aS [O\WTSabO`t\ ] RS _c{ bW^] aS`t\ Z]a RO ]a g ] ZOa ^{`RWROa- :cV[O\\ < ''&

:cV[O\\ O^]`bO ZO WRSO RSZ µc[P`OZ RS QObtab`]TS¶ Q][] SZ Z [WbS [ta OZZt RSZ QcOZ \] aS SabO` O RWa^cSab] O O``WSaUO` >S`] bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

_cS SaS c[PÒZ aS TWXO RS T]`[O RWTS`S\bS aSU \ ZO ^]aWQW \ ] SZ `]Z RS _cWS\ Z] SabOPZSQS aSO Q][] ^]`bOR]` RS RSQWaW]\Sa Q][] O\OZWabO ] Q][] ^]bS\QWOZ OTSQbOR] 3\ ZO RSbS`[W\OQW \ RSZ Z [WbS ] c[PÒZ ] S\ ZO ^`]^WO Q]\aWRSÒQW \ RSZ `WSaU] Sa W[^]`bO\bS RSbS`[W\O` _cW{\ RSQWRS _cS c\ `WSaU] RSPS bS\SàS S\ QcS\bO RSQWaW \ S\ ZO _cS ]^SÒ\ Tc\RO[S\bOZ[S\bS TOQb]`Sa RS aSZSQQW \ UcWOR]a ^]` TOQb]`Sa a]QWOZSa RS RWabW\b]a bW^]a @Sa^SQb] O ZO WRSO RS W\QS`bWRc[P`S SabS [Wa[] Ocb]` aS OZO Q][] ZO WRSO RS `WSaU] _cS W[^ZWQO c\O RSQWaW \ µ_cS bOZ Q][] aS ^cSRS ^`SdS` aS ZO[S\bO`t aW ]Qc``S c\ RO ] _cS aS Sa^SÒPO ^]RS` SdWbO`¶ Sabt `STS`WRO g O`ÒWUORO S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] RS RSaQ]\]QW[WS\b] a]P`S ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RSZ Tcbc`] W\QZcWR] SZ ^`]RcQWR] ^]` ZOa ^`]^WOa RSQWaW]\Sa 3\ SabS Q]\bSfb] Sa WUcOZ[S\bS Tc\RO[S\bOZ SZ QtZQcZ] bS[^]ÒZ S\ SZ _cS ]^SÒ\ c\O UÒ\ dO`WSROR RS TOQb]`Sa bO[PW{\ RSaQ]\]QWR]a O ^`W]`W 3\ ZO Z \SO RS Z] gO O^c\bOR] Q]\ O\bS`W]`WROR ZO WRSO RS aSUc`WROR Q][] ]^]aWQW \ O ZO RS `WSaU] `SacZbO` O c\O TOZOQWO RSaRS SabO ^Sà^SQbWdO( ZO aSUc`WROR Sa c\ RSaS] W[^]aWPZS g SZ `WSaU] W[^ZWQO RS VSQV] c\O ^]bS\QWOZ ^]aWPWZWROR RS OdO\QS O ^SaO` RS ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S = Z] _cS Sa Z] [Wa[]( \SUO` c\ `WSaU] ac^]\S W[^Z QWbO[S\bS OQS^bO` ]b`] DWab] Oa SZ Q]\QS^b] RS `WSaU] RSPS aS` RWTS`S\QWOR] RSZ RS µ^SZWU`]¶ S\bS\RWS\R] SZ `WSaU] Q][] RSQWaW \ RS ORS\bÒàS ] \] d]Zc\bO`WO ] W\d]Zc\bO`WO[S\bS S\ aWbcOQW]\Sa _cS ^cSRO\ RS`WdO` S\ ^SZWU`] RSQWaW \ RSTW\WRO ^]` ZO QOÔQWROR ^S`QWPWRO RS µQ]\b`]Z¶ G aWS\R] S\bS\RWR] SZ µ^SZWU`]¶ Q][] SZ µ`WSaU] Sfb`S[]¶ 3\ ZO W\b`]RcQQW \ O ZO ]PÒ RS ;O`g 2]cUZOa 2]cUZOa ; '&$ 8]O\ 0SabO`R ^ZO\bSO _cS aS ^cSRS ]^]\S` SZ ZS\UcOXS ^`]^W] RS ZOa Q]\QS^QW]\Sa []ÒZSa RS bOP ^SQOR]¬ ^`]^W] RSZ ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] bÒRWQW]\OZ a]P`S Z] _cS aS RSPS ] \] VOQS` Q]\ SZ ZS\UcOXS RSZ `WSaU] RS QO`tQbS` [ta W\RWdWRcOZWhOR] ^`]POPWZ abWQ] QS\bÒR] S\ ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO RS Z]a `SacZbOR]a RS ZOa OQQW]\Sa W\RWdWRcOZSa >S`] aW\ _cS SaS QO[PW] RS T]Q] ac^]\UO [O\bS\S` S\ ZO ]ÔQWROR ZO RW[S\aW \ a]QWOZ RS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ _cS Sa a]QWOZ RSZ `WSaU]( ZOa QObSU]` Oa S\ ZOa _cS aS RSTW\S ZO ^S`QS^QW \ a]\ T`cb] RS ZO W\bSÒQQW \ a]QWOZ 3Z ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] _cS ^`]^]\S :cV[O\\ Q][] ]^QW \ µ[]RS`\O¶ RSZ `WSaU] W[^ZWQO ZO Q]\aWRSÒQW \ RSZ `WSaU] RS ZO ]^QW \ ^]` SZ `WSaU] Q][] ]^]`bc\WROR RS OdO\QS ] Q][] ^bW[O cbWZWhOQW \ RS ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa 7[^ZWQO\R] RS VSQV] ]ZdWRO` Z]a ^SZWU`]a aW Sa \SQSaO`W] 0OX] SZ ^`Wa[O RS R]a ^`W\QW^W]a( \] SfWabS Q]\RcQbO ZWP`S RS `WSaU] T`S\bS O ZO ^`SbS\aW \ RS aSUc`WROR g SZ `WSaU] Sa Q]\acabO\QWOZ Q]\ ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa T`S\bS O ZOa WRSOa RS ^SZWU`] SdWbOPZS

3\ ]^]aWQW \ O ZO ]^QW \ b`ORWQW]\OZ RSaRS ZO QcOZ SZ `WSaU] aS Oa]QWO O Z]a bOP Sa g ZO `STS`S\QWO QcZbc`OZ RS Z] ^`]VWPWR] ] SZ ^SQOR] ! 0SQY C

3\ c\ aS\bWR] Ô`SQWR] 0SQY ! ^ZO\bSO Q][] SZ `WSaU] Sa c\O QObSU]` O QS\bÒZ RS ZOa WRSOa RS W\aSUc`WROR S\ ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO Q]bWRWO\O Q]\bS[^]`t\SO 3Z `WSaU] Q][] ^`W\QW^W] µW\TW\WbO[S\bS `S^`]RcQWPZS¶ S\ SZ _cS ZO SZSQQW \ ^`]POPWZ abWQO W\RWdWRcOZ bWS\S c\ OaWS\b] S\ Z]a ^`W\QW^W]a _cS RSbS`[W\O\ ZO OQS^bOQW \ RSaRS SZ ^c\b] RS dWabO Q]ZSQbWd] RSZW[WbO\R] ZO WRSO RS ZO SfWabS\QWO RS c\ aSaU] QcZbcÒZ S\ ZO W\bS`^`SbOQW \ bO\b] RSZ `WSaU] Q][] RSZ ^SZWU`] :] _cS \]a Q]\SQbO RS \cSd] RW`SQbO[S\bS Q]\ ZO Z \SO RS ZOa O^cSabOa [ta QcZbcÒZWabOa RSaRS ZOa QcOZSa µdOZ]`Sa Q][c\Sa Q]\RcQS\ O [WSR]a Q][c\Sa¶ 0SabO`R ]^ QWb RS bOZ [O\SÒ _cS Z]a W\RWdWRc]a Sabt\

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

RWa^cSab]a O OQS^bO` Z]a `WSaU]a S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZO ORVSaW \ O c\O RSbS`[W\ORO T]`[O RS a]QWSROR

3Z Tc\RO[S\b] a]QWOZ g QcZbcÒZ RS ZO RSTW\WQW \ Q]\QS^bcOZWhOQW \ SdOZcOQW \ g OQbcOQW \ RSZ µ`WSaU]¶ 1cO\R] \]a ORS\bÒ[]a S\ ZOa `STS`S\QWOa OZ `WSaU] RSaRS SZ Q]\bSfb] RS Z]a O\tZWaWa g ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RS XcdS\bcR aS \]a VOQS OPa]ZcbO[S\bS `SZSdO\bS ^]\S` SZ {\TOaWa RSZ S\T]_cS S\ SZ ^`]QSa] RS Q]\ab`cQQW \ a]QWOZ RS QObSU]` Oa bOZSa Q][] µ`WSaU]¶ :O ^`SUc\bO aS` O ¥^]` _c{ a]\ `WSaU]a Z]a `WSaU]a _cS aS OZO[]a- >]` c\O Ô`bS `SacZbO aWU\WTWQObWd] ]PaS`dO` Q][] VOPWbcOZ[S\bS Z]a `WSaU]a bWS\RS\ O aS` RSTW\WR]a S\ SZ S\b]`\] RS RWTS`S\bSa bW^]a RS ^`]PZS[Oa RS aOZcR ORWQQW]\Sa O RSbS`[W\OROa acabO\QWOa S\TS`[SRORSa RS bÒ\a[WaW \ aSfcOZ ZSaW]\Sa ^]` OU`SaW]\Sa ] OQQWRS\bSa RS b`tTWQ] SbQ AW\ S[POÙ] acSZS ]PdWOàS Q]\ TOQWZWROR c\ Q][^]\S\bS Tc\RO[S\bOZ _cS Sabt S\ ZO POaS RS Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a Oa]QWOR]a O Sab]a t[PWb]a _cS Sa SZ Q]\SQbO ZOa OQbWbcRSa g ZOa Q]\RcQbOa Q]\ ZOa RW\t[WQOa RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ S WRS\bWROR XcdS\WZ /a [WS\bÒa Z]a ^`W[S`]a OQS`QO[WS\b]a OZ RSaO``]ZZ] g Q]\]QW[WS\b] RS ZO ^`]^WO aSfcOZWROR ^cSRS\ ac^]\S` Ôa]a SaS\QWOZSa ÔÒ SZ OaS\bO[WS\b] WRS\bWbO`W] RS Z]a X dS\Sa g RS ac QO[W\] VOQWO ZO dWRO ORcZbO ] ZO Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ Q]\ RSbS`[W\OROa acabO\QWOa ^cSRS RSbS`[W\O` SZ ^`W\QW^W] RS c\O `SZOQW \ [ta [ORcÒ g Q]\aQWS\bS Q]\ RSbS`[W\OR]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] ^]` ^]\S` R]a SXS[^Z]a acSZS aS` VOPWbcOZ OT`]\bO` O[P]a QOa]a RSaRS ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a _cS SfQZcaWdO[S\bS ^`]PZS[ObWhO\ RSaRS ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa S\ ZO aOZcR ^]` SXS[^Z] SZS[S\b]a RS bO\bO W[^]`bO\QWO 3dWRS\bS[S\bS Sab]a bS[Oa ^`SaS\bO\ W[^]`bO\bSa SZS[S\b]a RS `WSaU] _cS Sa \SQSaO`W] OP]`RO` S\ ZOa ^]Z bWQOa ^`SdS\bWdOa UZ]POZSa >S`] ]PaS`dO`Z]a POX] c\O [WÒRO _cS SfQZcaWdO[S\bS TWXS ac ObS\QW \ S\ ZO QOÙO µ\SUObWdO¶ \] ^`]QcÒ`t ZO [SX]` g [ta Q][^ZSbO dWaW \ RS TS\ [S\]a RS [Og]` QOZOR] SaS\QWOZSa ÔÒ S\bS\RS` [SX]` ZO `SOZWROR XcdS\WZ >]` ]b`] ZOR] ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa a]P`S Z]a `WSaU]a bWS\S\ c\ SdWRS\bS Q][^]\S\bS RS Q]\ab`cQQW \ a]QWOZ Tc\RO[S\bOZ[S\bS S\ Z] _cS bWS\S _cS dS` Q]\ ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS aS dOZ]Ò\ ] XSÒ`_cWhO\ Z]a [Wa[]a ¥>]` _c{ acSZS SfWabW` [Og]` OZO`[O a]QWOZ `Sa^SQb] OZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa WZSUOZSa _cS `Sa^SQb] OZ Q]\ac[] RS bOPOQ] QcO\R] Sa SdWRS\bS _cS SZ bOPOQ] QOcaO [cQVOa [ta [cS`bSa OZ O ] _cS ]bÒa acabO\QWOa- 3abS SXS[^Z] \]a ^cSRS RO` c\O WRSO OQS`QO RS S\ _c{ [SRWRO ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa a]P`S Z]a `WSaU]a Sabt\ Tc\RO[S\bOROa a]P`S µ^`]PZS[Oa `SOZSa¶ \] _cS`S[]a RSQW` _cS RSbS`[W\OR]a Q]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa \] Z] aSO\ ^]` ac^cSab] ] a]P`S ZOa ^`S]QcÔQW]\Sa _cS ^cSPZO\ SZ W[OUW\O`W] Q]ZSQbWd] Tc\RO[S\bOZ[S\bS S\ b]`\] O bS[Oa [ta RSaQ]\]QWR]a a]QWOZ[S\bS [S\]a OQS^bOR]a ] µ\ObcÒZWhOR]a¶ g _cS SaQOÔ\ [ta O ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS Q]\b`]Z 3\ RSTW\WbWdO ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa a]P`S Z]a `WSaU]a S\bÒ` O\ S\ SZ bS``S\] RS ZOa `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa _cS a]\ ZOa _cS Q][^]\S\ ZO POaS RS ZO ]^W\W \ ^ PZWQO g OZW[S\bO\ Z]a RWaQcà]a g Z]a OÙc[S\b]a `Sa^SQb] O bOZ Oac\b] /QcRW[]a O ZO W\dSabWUOQW \ DOZ]`Sa a]QWOZSa g R`]UOa ÔÒ ]T`SQS` c\O RSTW\WQW \ RSZ b{`[W\] µ`S^`SaS\bOQW \ a]QWOZ¶ _cS QZO`WTW_cS SZ ^ZO\bSO[WS\b](

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

µ>`]^]\S[]a RSTW\W` {abOa IZOa `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSaK Q][] SZ Q]\Xc\b] aWabS[tbWQ] RS dOZ]`Sa \]QW]\Sa g Q`SS\QWOa _cS ^S`[WbS\ O Z]a acXSb]a Q][c\WQOàS g OQbcO` g Oa ]`WS\bOàS S\ SZ Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ R]\RS dWdS\ ÒQW]\OZWhO` aca OQQW]\Sa " Sf^ZWQO` SdS\b]a `SZSdO\bSa g RSTS\RS` ac WRS\bWROR) S\ RSTW\WbWdO RSTW\W` ZO `SOZWROR S\ ZO _cS dWdS\ ZO acgO W\aSÔÒPZS ^]` ]b`] ZOR] RS ZO RSZ U`c^] S\ SZ aS\] RSZ QcOZ dWdS\ C\O QOÒQbS` abWQO W[^]`bO\bS RS ZOa `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa Sa _cS `S^`SaS\bO\ c\ Q]\]QW[WS\b] Q][Ô`bWR] RS b]R] SZ U`c^] OQS`QO RS OZU] POX] ZO T]`[O RS c\O ·bS]` O RS aS\bWR] Q][ \¸ g S\ SabS aS\bWR] SabO` O\ S\ ZO POaS RS ZO ]^W\W \ ^ PZWQO >]` Z] bO\b] O RS[ta RS c\]a dOZ]`Sa \]QW]\Sa g Q`SS\QWOa W[^ZWQO\ c\Oa OQbWbcRSa) g b]R] SZZ] aS `SZOQW]\O Q]\ c\]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a¶ # 2S ZO [Wa[O T]`[O Z] _cS aS Q]\aWRSÒ µX]dS\¶ ] Z]a SZS[S\b]a aW[P ZWQ]a O Ô`bW` RS Z]a QcOZSa aS W\bS`^`SbO µZO XcdS\bcR¶ aS`t\ Q]\ab`cQQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa Oa Q][] ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS aS O\OZWhO\ ac `SZOQW \ Q]\ ZOa Q]\RcQbOa g VtPWb]a RS `WSaU] >]` SZZ] `SacZbO W[^`SaQW\RWPZS O\OZWhO` SZ bS[O S\ ac Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ VOQWS\R] VW\QO^W{ S\ Z]a Oa^SQb]a `SZObWd]a O Z]a dOZ]`Sa g ZO SRcQOQW \ _cS OgcRO\ O W\bS`^`SbO` [SX]` Z]a VtPWb]a g Q]\RcQbOa Q]\Q`SbOa /RS[ta RS Z]a Q]\QS^b]a gO [S\QW]\OR]a RSaRS ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO a]QWOZ g QcZbcÒZ RSZ `WSaU] aS O^c\bO\ OZUc\Oa ]bÒa WRSOa [cg `SZSdO\bSa ÔÒ SZ O\tZWaWa RSZ OT`]\bO[WS\b] RSZ `WSaU] S\ \cSab`] Q]\bSfb] ³ 3\ ^`W[S` b{`[W\] VOg _cS RWabW\UcW` S\b`S Z]a b{`[W\]a RS `WSaU] ]PXSbWd] g `WSaU] acPXSbWd] 2SaRS ZOa QWS\QWOa a]QWOZSa aS RWabW\UcS S\b`S Z] _cS aSO SZ `WSaU] ]PXSbWd] ¥`SOZ- ] ^]aWbWdWabO g SZ `WSaU] RSaRS c\ ^c\b] RS dWabO acPXSbWd] ^S`QWPWR] ] Q]\ab`cWR] RSaRS SZ `SZObWdWa[] QcZbcÒZ AS bÒbO RS Q]\aWRSÒ` _cS SZ `WSaU] \] Sa c\O QcOZWROR ^`]^WO W\b` \aSQO RSZ [c\R] T aWQ] aW\] _cS aS `S^`SaS\bO O Ô`bW` RS ZO W\bSÒQQW \ S\b`S ZOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa T aWQOa g ZOa âWQ]a]QWOZSa Sab] Sa ZOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa ZOa \]`[Oa []bWdOQW]\Sa dOZ]`Sa ¬

" @OQW]\OZWhO` aWU\WTWQO O_c XcabWTWQO` OQbcO` Q][] c\ `STS`S\bS _cS RO c\ QWS`b] aS\bWR] O aca OQQW]\Sa Z] _cS \] bWS\S ^]` _c{ W[^ZWQO` ^`SQWaO[S\bS c\ SXS`QWQW] RS `STZSfW \ Q` bWQO _cS ZZSdS O ZO Q]\QWS\QWO R]\RS µaS aWb O\¶ SfOQbO[S\bS ZOa ^`tQbWQOa S\ ZOa _cS Sabt\ W\d]ZcQÒR]a RWQV]a acXSb]a ;cQVOa dSQSa SabOa ]^SÒQW]\Sa RS ÒQW]\OZWhOQW \ ^cSRS\ SabO` aWU\WTWQObWdO[S\bS Q]\\]bOROa RS OTSQbWdWROR # ;SU Oa 3 RW` DOZ]`Sa a]QWOZSa g R`]UOa) 4/2 ;OR`WR ^

7\RS^S\RWS\bS[S\bS RS _cS aS ^cSRO\ ^ZO\bSO` RSTW\WQW]\Sa [ta ] [S\]a `SOZWabOa c ]PXSbWdOa Z]a `WSaU]a aS RSTW\S\ RS T]`[O acPXSbWdO O Ô`bW` RS ZO QcZbcÒ g Z]a dOZ]`Sa 2S VSQV] _cWS\Sa SXS`QS\ SZ `]Z µSf^S`b]¶ a]\ acXSb]a a]QWOZSa g aca O\tZWaWa g dOZ]ÒQW]\Sa \] Sabt\ SfS\bOa RS ac Q]\RWQW \ a]QWOZ Ô`bWQcZO` 3\ `SZOQW \ O ZOa R`]UOa SabO RcOZWROR RS ZOa OUS\QWOa Sa^SQWOZWabOa S\b`S SZ `]Z ^`]TSaW]\OZ g SZ `]Z RS QWcRORO\ O a]QWOZ Sabt ^S`[O\S\bS[S\bS RS [O\WTWSab] :]a RSPObSa a]P`S ZO \ObcÒZShO RS Z]a µ^`]PZS[Oa RS R`]UOa¶ acSZS\ SabO` W[^`SU\OR]a RS SabO R]PZS [WÒRO \SQSaO`WO S W\SdWbOPZS RSaRS ZO _cS aS ^`SbS\RS SabOPZSQS` ZOa T]`[cZOQW]\Sa [ta µ]PXSbWdOa¶ VOPWbcOZ[S\bS QS\bÒROa S\ µROb]a¶ :O ^]aWQW \ RS _cWS\Sa \] SXS`QS\ ZO ^]aWQW \ Sf^S`bO bWS\RS O ]PdWO` Z]a ROb]a Oc\_cS Z]a Q]\]hQO ÔÒ ^]\S` S\ XcSU] S\ ZO SdOZcOQW \ RSZ `WSaU] ]b`] bW^] RS RW[S\aW]\Sa

³ >S`] ORS[ta RS ZO WRSO RS acPXSbWdWROR T`S\bS O ZO RS ]PXSbWdWROR VOg _cS ^ZO\bSO` ZO RWQ]b][ O S\b`S SZ `WSaU] OQS^bOPZS g SZ W\b]ZSÒPZS AS bÒbO RS SabOPZSQS` Z]a Q`WbS`W]a ÔÒ RSTW\W` SaS µc[PÒZ¶ RS `WSaU] ] RS QObtab`]TS OZ _cS \]a VS[]a `STS`WR] Q]\ O\bS`W]`WROR 3\ ^`W\QW^W] SZ \WdSZ OQS^bOPZS aS` O O_cSZ S\ _cS aS ^cRWSÒ SabOPZSQS`

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

SZ S_cWZWP`W] ] POZO\QS ^bW[] S\b`S [O\bS\W[WS\b] RS ZO aSUc`WROR g SZ O^`]dSQVO[WS\b] RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa AWS[^`S bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO _cS SaS S_cWZWP`W] ^cSRS dO`WO` ÔÒ QORO ^Sà]\O g SabO`t Q]\RWQW]\OR] ^]` ZOa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa RS ^S`bS\S\QWO ORaQ`W^QW \ ] WRS\bWROR U`cÔZ S W\RWdWRcOZ RS QORO QcOZ

@SOZ[S\bS SaS POZO\QS aS SabOPZSQS S\b`S ]^QW]\Sa g \] S\b`S `WSaU]a \] aWS\R] [cg QZOÒ ZO SfWabS\QWO RS c\ ^`]QSa] ÒQW]\OZ Sf^Z QWb] S\ ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa [SRWO\bS SZ QcOZ aS ^`SbS\RO `SRcQW` SZ `WSaU] ÔÒ O[^ZWTWQO` Z]a PS\STWQW]a ^]bS\QWOZSa

4`S\bS O SabOa ]^QW]\Sa _cS ^]` ]bÒ Ô`bS \] bWS\S\ ^]` _c{ aS` ]^cSabOa S\ QcO\b] O ZO QOÙO RS `WSaU] _cS S\bÒ S\ aS ^`]RcQS\ RWaQ`SÔ\QWOa `Sa^SQb] O ZO OQS^bOPWZWROR bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO ZO dOZ]ÒQW \ RS ZOa RWTS`S\bSa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa g ZO dOZ]ÒQW \ _cS RWQVOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa acaQWbS 3\ US\SÒZ SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS `S^S`QcaW]\Sa _cS Q]ZSQbWdO[S\bS aS Q]\aWRS`S _cS aS RSPS\ bS\S` S\ QcS\bO ÔÒ ZO SdOZcOQW \ 2SaRS SabO ^Sà^SQbWdO aS Q]\aWRSÒ`t µ`WSaU] b]ZSÒPZS¶ \] \SQSaO`WO[S\bS µOQS^bOPZS¶ O ZO ^`SRWa^]aWQW \ O Q]\dWdW` Q]\ c\ `WSaU] ÔÒ OaSUcÒ` QWS`b]a PS\STWQW]a RSaRS ZO Q`SS\QWO g RSaRS ZO Q]\TWO\hO RS _cS aS ^cSRS Q]\b`]ZO` ORSQcORO[S\bS Ac^]\S ^]` bO\b] ZO TWXOQW \ RS c\ Z [WbS g RS c\O SfWUS\QWO RS Q]\b`]Z

/RS[ta SZ Q]\QS^b] RS OQS^bOPWZWROR Sabt Oa]QWOR] OZ Q]\QS^b] RS ^S`QS^QW \ acPXSbWdO _cS OP]`RO[]a O Q]\bW\cOQW \ Oa Q][] O ZO \SQSaWROR RS QZO`WTWQOQW \ RS ZOa RW[S\aW]\Sa RS ZOa TcS\bSa RSZ `WSaU] ZO RSbS`[W\OQW \ RS ZO ^`]POPWZWROR RS Sf^]aWQW \ g O ZO dS`WTWQOQW \ RS ZO d]Zc\bO`WSROR ] \] RS ZO Sf^]aWQW \ C\O Sf^]aWQW \ \] d]Zc\bO`WO bS\R`t Q][] `SacZbOR] c\ \WdSZ W\TS`W]` RS OQS^bOPWZWROR

³ 3a^SQWOZ[S\bS `SZSdO\bS Sa SZ O\tZWaWa RS ZOa WRSOa g ]^QW]\Sa O\bS SZ `WSaU] RSaRS ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO RS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ a]QWOZ ASU \ ZO RSTW\WQW \ RS >WRUS]\ Sb OZ '' SZ SabcRW] RS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ a]QWOZ RSZ `WSaU] Sa SZ RS µZOa Q`SS\QWOa OQbWbcRSa XcWQW]a g aS\bW[WS\b]a Oa Q][] RS Z]a dOZ]`Sa g RWa^]aWQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa g QcZbcÒZSa [ta O[^ZW]a _cS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa OR]^bO\ T`S\bS O ZOa TcS\bSa RS ^SZWU`] g Z]a PS\STWQW]a _cS SabOa Q]\ZZSdO\¶ 3abS O\tZWaWa Sa \SQSaO`WO[S\bS bOZ Q][] aS ^ZO\bSO RS QO`tQbS` [cZbWRW[S\aW]\OZ 3\ US\SÒZ aS ^cSRS Q]\aWRSÒ` ZO ^S`QS^QW \ a]QWOZ Q][] ZO ]ÙO\WhOQW \ RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ S\ RSbS`[W\OROa QObSU]` Oa Q][ÔbWPZSa Q]\ ZOa Sab`cQbcÒa a]QWOZSa SfWabS\bSa RS bOZ [O\SÒ _cS SaO W\T]`[OQW \ aSO acaQS^bWPZS RS aS` OaW[WZORO :O ^S`QS^QW \ Sabt Q]\SQbORO Q]\ Z]a dOZ]`Sa g Q]\ ZO QcZbcÒ 3abS bW^] RS ]ÙO\WhOQW \ Ô`bWQcZO` Sa SZ ]`WUS\ RS ZOa OÔ`S\bSa Q]\bÒRWQQW]\Sa S\b`S ZO ^S`QS^QW \ SfOQS`PORO RS RSbS`[W\OROa TcS\bSa RS `WSaU] T`S\bS O ZO _cS aS ^`]RcQS O\bS ]bÒa TcS\bSa Q]\ ^]bS\QWOZ RO W\] ]PXSbWdO[S\bS ac^S`W]` :O RcRO Tc\RO[S\bOZ _cS aS ^ZO\bSO O SabS `Sa^SQb] Sa aW ZO ^S`QS^QW \ SabO` O OPWS`bO OZ QO[PW] W\RcQWR] RSaRS OÙc[S\b]a ^`SbS\RWRO[S\bS ÒQW]\OZSa g SabO QcSabW \ Sa c\O RS ZOa Oa^WÒQW]\Sa O[^ZWO[S\bS RWTc\RWRO S\ ZOa OQbcOQW]\Sa Q]\ X dS\Sa ^]` SXS[^Z] S\ bS[Oa RS R`]UOa O bÒd{a RS ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RS ^`SdS\QW \ S W\T]`[OQW \

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

3Z Q]\bS\WR] RS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ \] `STZSXO a Z] Z]a SZS[S\b]a SfbS`\]a dWaWPZSa RSZ `WSaU] aW\] _cS W[^ZWQO b]R] c\ Q]\Xc\b] RS [SQO\Wa[]a g ^`]QSa]a W\bS`\]a Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ ZO [S[]`WO g ZO Q]\RcQbO Sf^`SaWdO 2S SabO [O\SÒ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ T]`[OZ OP]`RORO RSaRS ZO âWQ][Sb` O a Z] bS\R` O S\ QcS\bO c\O Ô`bS c\O RS ZOa RW[S\aW]\Sa RS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS S\b`S ZOa [ ZbW^ZSa _cS aS ^]\S\ S\ XcSU] S\ ZO SdOZcOQW \ RS Z]a `WSaU]a AOPS[]a _cS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ a]QWOZ bWS\S OaQS\RS\bS a]P`S ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa O ^SaO` RS ZO RWTWQcZbOR ÔÒ Oa]QWO` ^S`QS^QW \ OQbWbcR g Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a G ^]` bO\b] bS\S[]a _cS `SQ]\]QS` ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RS Z]a RSbS`[W\O\bSa a]QWOZSa dOZ]`Sa \]`[Oa S\ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ a]QWOZ S\ÒWhORO S\ ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO acPXSbWdO 2SaRS SZ ^c\b] RS dWabO RSZ `WSaU] bS\S[]a _cS OTW`[O` _cS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] Sa bO[PW{\ a]QWOZ bO\b] S\ SZ Q]\bS\WR] Q][] S\ SZ ^`]QSa] Oc\_cS ZO [O\WTSabOQW \ RS ZOa ]^QW]\Sa O\bS SZ `WSaU] aS bÒRchQO S\ RSQWaW]\Sa ac^cSabO[S\bS Ocb \][Oa d]Zc\bO`WOa S W\RWdWRcOZSa G bO\b] S\ SZ Q]\bS\WR] SZS[S\b]a _cS Q]\ab`cgS\ ZO WRSO RS `WSaU] Q][] S\ SZ ^`]QSa] [SRWO\bS SZ QcOZ aS W\Q]`^]Ò\ Z]a dOZ]`Sa g ZOa \]`[Oa S\ ZO RSQWaW \ ] ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ RSZ `WSaU] SZ Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ S\ _cS aS ^`]RcQS ZO SdOZcOQW \ SZ _cS [O`QO ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS SdOZcOQW \ RS aca RWTS`S\bSa Ô`t[Sb`]a Sa RSbS`[W\O\bS S\ ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa 3a SZ Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ Q]\Q`Sb] SZ _cS ]`WS\bO c\O RSbS`[W\ORO ]`WS\bOQW \ S\ ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa S\ ZO [SRWRO S\ _cS Sa SZ _cS O^]`bO Z]a SZS[S\b]a PtaWQ]a ÔÒ Z]a XcWQW]a RS dOZ]` g ZOa `STS`S\QWOa RS a]abS\WPWZWROR S\ ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa 3abS ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] Sa OZbO[S\bS Q]VS`S\bS Q]\ Z]a RWaQcà]a a]P`S SZ `WSaU] _cS VS[]a O\OZWhOR] S\ \c[S`]aOa ]QOaW]\Sa S\ SZ Q]ZSQbWd] RS OR]ZSaQS\bSa g X dS\Sa G aWUcWS\R] ZOa Q]\QZcaW]\Sa RS /\O >cg ''" ^]RS[]a O^c\bO` OZUc\Oa `STS`S\QWOa QZOdS _cS a]\ Q]VS`S\bSa Q]\ SZ O\tZWaWa [cQV]a RS Z]a bW^]a RS `WSaU]a _cS OTSQbO\ O ZO XcdS\bcR RSaRS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ ³ >`W[S`] _cS SZ `WSaU] a]QWOZ ^S`QWPWR] Sa bO[PW{\ \SbO[S\bS [cZbWRW[S\aW]\OZ ³ ASUc\R] _cS bOZ Q][] aS Sf^`SaO bO[PW{\ S\ SZ SabcRW] QWbOR] >cg @]R` UcSh / ''" g SXS[^ZWTWQOR] S\ ZO SdOZcOQW \ RS Z]a `WSaU]a RS R`]UOa ³Q][] c\] RS Z]a SXS[^Z]a ÔÒRWU[tbWQ]a RS ZO RcOZWROR S\b`S ZO ^S`QS^QW \ ]PXSbWdO g ZO acPXSbWdO W\QZca] RSaRS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS c\ [Wa[] acXSb]³ SfWabS c\O ÒRWQOZ RWTS`S\QWOQW \ S\b`S SZ \WdSZ RS `WSaU] ^S`QWPWR] ÔÒ ZO a]QWSROR S\ US\SÒZ g SZ _cS aS Q]\bS[^ZO Q][] `WSaU] `SOZ OZ _cS aS Sabt ^Sà]\OZ[S\bS Sf^cSab] ASU \ SabO Ocb]Ò SabO` O[]a O\bS c\ ac^cSab] RS µ]^bW[Wa[] \] `SOZWabO¶ _cS Q][] dS`S[]a aS Tc\RO[S\bO S\ b]R] SaS Q]\Xc\b] RS SZS[S\b]a a]QWOZSa S\ Z]a _cS aS SabOPZSQS SaO R]PZS dOZ]ÒQW \ RS c\ [Wa[] `WSaU] OÔ`S\bS( SZ `WSaU] OZ _cS c\O ^Sà]\O aS Q]\aWRSÒ a][SbWRO T`S\bS OZ `WSaU] OZ _cS SaO [Wa[O ^Sà]\O Q]\aWRSÒ _cS Sabt\ a][SbWROa SZ `Sab] RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa 3\ SZ QOa] RS ZOa R`]UOa Sa Q]\]QWRO SaO RcOZWROR S\ SZ aS\bWR] RS Q`SS` aWS[^`S _cS SZ `WSaU] ^Sà]\OZ Sa W\TS`W]` OZ RS ZOa RS[ta ^Sà]\Oa ^S`] S\ ]b`]a Oac\b]a ZO RW\t[WQO ^cSRS ^ZO\bSOàS S\ aS\bWR] W\dSà]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

³ BS`QS`] _cS aS ^cSRS SabOPZSQS` c\O R]PZS QObSU]` O RS `WSaU]a bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO ZO ^S`QS^QW \ a]P`S ZO ^`]POPWZWROR RS Sf^]aWQW \ ZO [OU\WbcR RS ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa g ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ Q]\b`]Z ^S`a]\OZ ] ZO d]Zc\bO`WSROR S\ ZO Sf^]aWQW \

2SaRS Sab]a W\RWQOR]`Sa bS\R` O[]a _cS Q]\aWRSÒ` ZO SfWabS\QWO RS `WSaU]a RS µPOXO ^`]POPWZWROR ^S`QWPWRO RS ]Qc``S\QWO POX] Q]\b`]Z ^S`QWPWR] g ^S`QS^QW \ RS UÒ\RSa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa¶ T`S\bS O `WSaU]a O\bS Z]a QcOZSa aS ^S`QWPS µOZb] Q]\b`]Z ^Sà]\OZ OZbO ^`]POPWZWROR RS ]Qc``S\QWO g POXOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa¶ 3ab]a ZbW[]a aS` O\ Z]a `WSaU]a ^S`QWPWR]a Q][] [ta Q]bWRWO\]a O Z]a _cS aS Q]\aWRSÒ ^Sà]\OZ[S\bS _cS aS Sabt [cg Sf^cSab] ^S`] _cS acaQWbO\ POX]a \WdSZSa RS ^`S]QcÔQW \ gO _cS ZO OZbO ^`]POPWZWROR RS ]Qc``S\QWO aS Q][^S\aO` O ^]` ZO aS\aOQW \ RS Q]\b`]Z RS Z] Q]\]QWR] g RS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS _cS ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa bO[PW{\ Q]\]QWROa a]\ [S\]a bÒaQS\RS\bSa

³ 1cO`b] _cS S\ SZ ^`]QSa] RS ^S`QS^QW \ a]\ OZbO[S\bS `SZSdO\bSa ZOa RW[S\aW]\Sa âWQ]a]QWOZSa QcZbcÒZSa g \]`[ObWdOa ³ ?cW\b] _cS S\ ZO SdOZcOQW \ RS Z]a `WSaU]a acPgOQS\ ZOa WRSOa a]P`S SZ bS[]` g ^]bS\QWO ^S`QWPWRO RSZ `WSaU] RSZ \WdSZ acPXSbWd] RS Q]\]QW[WS\b] g Q]``SZObWdO[S\bS SZ UÒR] RS \]dSROR 2S bOZ [O\SÒ _cS O_cSZZOa QcSabW]\Sa _cS aS Q]\aWRSÒ\ [S\]a Q]\]QWROa ZOa [ta \cSdOa ] \]dSR]aOa a]\ ZOa _cS US\SÒ` O\ [Og]` \WdSZ RS `Sa^Sb] [WSR] ] RWabO\QWO S\ SZ ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] RS ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa

/a ^]` SXS[^Z] VOPS` ^`]POR] RSbS`[W\ORO acabO\QWO ] VOPS` bS\WR] ZO ^`W[SÒ Sf^S`WS\QWO aSfcOZ ^cSRS RWZcW` ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] US\SÒZ O _cS aS Sabt Sf^cSab] ] Sf^cSabO S\ POaS O ZO aS\aOQW \ RS VOPS` ac^SÒR] aW\ ^`]PZS[Oa ] `SZObWdWhOR] Z]a `WSaU]a W\[SRWOb]a ] RS Q]`b] ^ZOh] _cS a]\ Z]a _cS [ta Ô`SQS\ ^`S]QcÔ` `WSaU]a Oa]QWOR]a O Z]a STSQb]a Q]\Q`Sb]a S W\[SRWOb]a RS QORO acabO\QWO Q]\aSQcS\QWOa W\RSaSOPZSa RS ZO Sf^SQbObWdO RS ZOa ^`W[SÒa `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa¬ ;WS\bÒa bO\b] g VOPW{\R]aS ac^SÒR] SZ µ`Sa^Sb]¶ ^]` Z]a `WSaU]a W\[SRWOb]a ZO Sf^SQbObWdO RS `WSaU] O ZOÙ] ^ZOh] bWS\RS O Q]\abWbcWàS Q][] c\O S\bSZS_cWO _cS \ORWS Ô`SQS Oac[W` Q][] ^`]^WO µO [ \] [S ÔaO`t¶

³ 3\ aSfb] g ZbW[] ZcUO` ZO SdWRS\QWO RS _cS SfWabS c\ OZb aW[] UÒR] RS acPXSbWdWROR S\ Z]a XcWQW]a RS dOZ]` a]P`S SZ `WSaU] Xc\b] O ZO Q]\abObOQW \ RS ZO b`S[S\RO Q][^ZSXWROR _cS Sabt W[^ZWQORO S\ SZ O\tZWaWa =PdWO[S\bS ZO acPXSbWdWROR RS Z]a XcWQW]a RS dOZ]` _cS `SRc\RO S\ ZO Q][^ZSXWROR RS ZO Q][^`S\aW \ RS Z]a ^`]QSa]a W[^ZWQOR]a S\ ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa O\bS SZ `WSaU] Sabt Q]\SQbORO Q]\ ZO acPXSbWdWROR WRS\bWbO`WO S\ ZO W\bS`^`SbOQW \ g OaW[WZOQW \ RS Z]a dOZ]`Sa a]QWOZSa Q]ZSQbWd]a 3\ PcS\O Ô`bS ZO acPXSbWdWROR \] RSPS` O aS` W\bS`^`SbORO Q][] acPXSbWdWROR W\RWdWRcOZ aW\] Q][] O_cSZZO _cS bWS\S _cS dS` Q]\ ZOa Sf^SQbObWdOa RS dOZ]`Sa RWTS`S\QWOZSa S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZO ^]aWQW \ a]QWOZ RS RSbS`[W\OR]a U`c^]a g Q]ZSQbWd]a a]QWOZSa G SabOa acPXSbWdWRORSa bWS\S\ [cQV] _cS dS` S\ SZ QOa] RS OR]ZSaQS\bSa g X dS\Sa Q]\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS Q]\ab`cQQW \ WRS\bWbO`WO S\ Z]a _cS ZO OR]^QW \ RS dOZ]`Sa aS `SQ`SO RS c\O [O\SÒ Ô`bWQcZO` 3\ OZUc\]a RS Z]a O`b QcZ]a aWUcWS\bSa aS bÒPOXO RW`SQbO[S\bS a]P`S SabOa QcSabW]\Sa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

@343@3<17/A 070:7=5@È471/A /UcW\OUO /\R`{c 1OQV \ 1][Oa : ^Sh <OdO``SbS # 7\T]`[S " 8cdS\bcR S\ 3aÔ O) 7<8CD3 ;OR`WR 0SQY C ''' :O A]QWSROR RSZ @WSaU] 5Z]POZ AWUZ] FF7 RS 3aÔ O 3RWb]`Sa ;OR`WR 1O^ZO\ > SR @WaY @SdWaWbSR >Zcb] >`Saa 1][Oa 2 Q]]`R ! 8 dS\Sa g SabWZ]a RS dWRO DOZ]`Sa g `WSaU]a S\ Z]a X dS\Sa c`PO\]a) 4/2 7<8CD3 ;OR`WR 2WSh @W^]ZZ{a 8 : ! 2S ZO a]QWSROR RSZ `WSaU] O ZO aSUc`WROR QWcRORO\O S\ @SdWabO RS QWS\QWO ^S\OZ g Q`W[W\]Z]U O 2]cUZOa ; '&$ :O OQS^bOPWZWROR RSZ `WSaU] aSU \ ZOa QWS\QWOa a]QWOZSa >OWR a 0O`QSZ]\O ''$ 5cWRRS\a / ''! 3Z `WSaU] S\ c\O a]QWSROR ^]ab bÒRWQW]\OZ @SdWabO RS =QQWRS\bS # $ ' 8]V\a]\ 0 0 ) 1]dSZZ] D B SRa '&% BVS A]QWOZ O\R 1cZbcÒZ Q]\ab`cQbW]\ ]T `WaY( SaaOga ]\ `WaY aSZSQbW]\ O\R ^S`QS^bW]\ 2 @SWRSZ >cPZWaVW\U 1][Ô\g 6]ZZO\R 8]\Oa 6 ''# µ:S ^`W\QW^S RS `Sa^]\aOPWZWb{ C\S {bVW_cS ^]c` ZO QWdWZWaObW]\ bSQV\]Z]UW_cS¶ >O`Wa 3R Rc 1S`T '%' bÒR 0O`QSZ]\O 6S`RS` ''# :OSaÔRO ;b) >OZZO`{a 8 ¥?c{ VOQS\- S\ @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a µRS 8cdS\bcR¶ \ #") 7<8CD3 ;OR`WR :SS B @ '& BVS >cPZWQ¸a >S`QS^bW]\ ]T @WaY O\R bVS _cSabW]\ ]T 7`ÒQW]\OZWbg >`]Q @ A]QQ :]\R / !%$ # $ :SS B @ '&! BVS ^S`QS^bW]\ ]T `WaY S\ BVS @]gOZ A]QWSbg @WaY /aaSaa[S\b / AbcRg 5`]c^ @S^]`b :]\R`Sa BVS @]gOZ A]QWSbg :cV[O\\ < ''& A]QW]Z]U O RSZ @WSaU] C\WdSàWROR 7PS`]O[S`WQO\O B`WO\O SR ;{fWQ] :cXt\ 8 : ) 3QVSdS`` O 8 SRa " µ5]PS`\O` Z]a `WSaU]a 1WS\QWO g dOZ]`Sa S\ ZO a]QWSROR RSZ `WSaU]¶ =ÙO\WhOQW \ RS 3abOR]a 7PS`]O[S`WQO\]a ÔÒ ZO 3RcQOQW \ ZO 1WS\QWO g ZO 1cZbcÒ =37 0WPZW]bSQO <cSdO ;O`bW\Sh >O`WQW] 8 7 ASUc`WROR S 7\aSUc`WROR S\ ZO =^W\W \ > PZWQO 3c`]^SO =PaS`dOb]`W] RS ASUc`WROR RS ;OR`WR 1]ZSQQW \ RS 3abcRW]a RSZ È`SO RS ASUc`WROR g ;]dWZWROR /gc\bO[WS\b] RS ;OR`WR ;SUWOa DOZS\hcSZO 3 RW` % /R]ZSaQS\bSa O\bS SZ OZQ]V]Z :O [WÒRO RS ÔR`Sa g [OR`Sa 1]ZSQQW \ 3abcRW]a A]QWOZSa \ 4c\ROQW \ :O 1OWfO 0O`QSZ]\O ;SU Oa 3 RW` # :O ^S`QS^QW \ a]QWOZ RS Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa RS R`]UOa S\ 3aÔ O " 4/2 # ;SU Oa 3 Q]]`R 6WX]a g ÔR`Sa( Q][c\WQOQW \ g Q]\TZWQb] ;OR`WR( 4/2 ;SU Oa 3 RW` DOZ]`Sa a]QWOZSa g R`]UOa) 4/2 ;OR`WR ;SU Oa 3 ) @]R` UcSh 3 ;SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQW \ a]QWOZ g `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa a]P`S R`]UOa 3\ DD// 2`]UOa g 2`]UORWQQW \( c\ S\T]_cS a]QWOZ g ^`SdS\bWd] AS`dWQW] RS >cPZWQOQW]\Sa RS ZO C\WdSàWROR RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO ;SU Oa 7 & :Oa R`]UOa WZSUOZSa S\b`S Z]a X dS\Sa RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO( RWaQcà]a RSaRS Z]a Q]\ac[]a RS QO\\OPWa g Q]QO \O =PaS`dOb]`W] RS 2`]U]RS^S\RS\QWOa RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO 47A1/; 3\ ^`S\aO ;SU Oa 7 ) @]R` UcSh 3 ) ;{\RSh A g >OZZO`{a 8 # 8 dS\Sa g aSf] 3Z SabS`S]bW^] _cS ]PZWUO g SZ `Wb] _cS WRS\bWTWQO ;OR`WR( 7<8CD3 4/2 ;SU Oa 3 ) 3Zh] 8 Q]]`R $ 8 dS\Sa dOZ]`Sa g 2`]UOa ;OR`WR( ;A1 4/2 1OXO ;OR`WR ;SU Oa 7 ) @]R` UcSh 3 ) ;{\RSh A ) >OZZO`{a 8 # 8 dS\Sa g aSf] 3Z SabS`S]bW^] _cS ]PZWUO g SZ `Wb] _cS WRS\bWTWQO) 4/2 7<8CD3 ;OR`WR( # ;W\WabS`W] RS AO\WROR g 1]\ac[] " :]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa SaÔ ]ZSa g ac aOZcR @Sac[S\ RSZ SabcRW] 6SOZbV 0SVOdW]c` W\ AQV]]Z /USR 1VWZR`S\ 60A1 ;OR`WR >OZZO`{a 8 ) 1S[PÒ\]a 4 :O [O`QVO( ZO ^cU\O ^]` SZ SaÔQW] 3\ @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a µRS 8cdS\bcR¶ \ #") 7<8CD3 ;OR`WR >OZZO`{a 8 ) 4SWfO 1 3aÔQW]a S WbW\SÒ`W]a ÔÒ SZ ]QW] XcdS\WZ \]Qbc`\] 3\ @SdWabO RS 3abcRW]a RS 8cdS\bcR < # 7<8CD3 ;OR`WR >WRUS]\ < '' BVS >agQV]Z]Ug ]T @WaY 3\ 2 7 0Z]QYSg SR 3\UW\SS`W\U AOTSbg ;OWRS\VSOR ;Q 5Òe 6WZZ >WRUS]\ < ) 6]]R 1 ) 8]\Sa 2 ) Bc`\S` 0 ) 5WPa]\ @ '' @WaY >S`QS^bW]\ 3\ BVS @]gOZ A]QWSbg 3Ra @WaY( /\OZgaWa >S`QS^bW]\ O\R ;O\OUS[S\b @S^]`b ]T O @]gOZ A]QWSbg AbcRg 5`]c^ :]\R`Sa BVS @]gOZ A]QWSbg

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

>ZO\ <OQW]\OZ a]P`S 2`]UOa % 2Ob]a RS 3ABC23A 3\QcSabO 3abObOZ RS ca] RS R`]UOa S\ SaQ]ZO`Sa $ 2Ob]a ^cPZWQOR]a S\ T]`[Ob] `Sac[S\ S\ ZO eSP RSZ =PaS`dOb]`W] SaÔ ]Z a]P`S 2`]UOa >cg @]R` UcSh / ''" >S`QS^QW \ a]QWOZ RSZ `WSaU] 2W[S\aW]\Sa RS SdOZcOQW \ g ^`SRWQQW \ BSaWa 2]Qb]ÒZ 2SÔ`bO[S\b] RS >aWQ]Z]U O A]QWOZ 4OQcZbOR RS >aWQ]Z]U O C\WdSàWROR 1][^ZcbS\aS RS ;OR`WR ;OR`WR @O[]a B]``S @ µ3Z `Sb]`\] RS 1OaO\RÒ( []RS`\WhOQW \ SQ]Z UWQO ^`SQOcQW \ S W\QS`bWRc[P`S¶ S\ 8 ; 5O`Q O 0ZO\Q] g > <OdO``] AcaOSbO µ¥;ta OZZt RS ZO []RS`\WROR- :Oa RW[S\aW]\Sa RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ ZO Q][c\WQOQW \ g ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa¶ ;OR`WR 17A " ! "## ! µ/Z VWZ] RS ZO ^`SQOcQW \( 8]\Oa g :cV[O\\ a]P`S ZO Q`WaWa SQ]Z UWQO¶ >]Z bWQO g A]QWSROR ! D]Z " <c[ !( ! # @]R` UcSh 3 ) ;SU Oa 7 ) 3ab`cQbcÒ g Tc\QW]\OZWROR RS ZOa T]`[Oa RS RWdSàW \ \]Qbc`\O( Z [WbSa g Q]\TZWQb]a) S\ ZO @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a µRS 8cdS\bcR¶ \ #") 7<8CD3 ;OR`WR @]R` UcSh 3 ) ;SU Oa 7 # :O P`SQVO US\SÒQW]\OZ S\ ZO SRcQOQW \ RS Z]a VWX]a ;OR`WR( 4/2 @]R` UcSh 3 ) ;SU Oa 7 ) g At\QVSh 3 8 dS\Sa g `SZOQW]\Sa U`cÔZSa 2W\t[WQO `SZOQW]\OZ ÔÒ Z]a bWS[^]a RS bÒPOX] g RS ]QW] ;OR`WR( 7<8CD3 4/2 @]R` UcSh 3 ) ;SU Oa 7 ) g <OdO``] 8 # ) 8 dS\Sa bWS[^] ZWP`S g Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa ;]RSZ]a dWdS\QWOa g Sf^SQbObWdOa S\b`S Z]a X dS\Sa RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO =PaS`dOb]`W] RS 2`]U]RS^S\RS\QWOa RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO B]ZSR] @]R` UcSh 3 ! ASf] g `WSaU] :O RWOZ{QbWQO S\b`S SZ ^ZOQS` g ZO Òh \ @SdWabO RS 3abcRW]a RS 8cdS\bcR 7<8CD3 ;OR`WR @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ 3 ) ;SU Oa ?cW` a 7 % 8 dS\Sa S\ Z]a [SRW]a :O W[OUS\ [SRWtbWQO RS ZO XcdS\bcR RSaRS ac ^`]^WO [WÒRO 7<8CD3 4/2 ;OR`WR DD// :O \]QVS C\ Q]\TZWQb] RS ^]RS` @SdWabO RS 3abcRW]a RS 8cdS\bcR \ #" 7<8CD3 ;OR`WR

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

9D8JB:CIDH

AcaO\O ;{\RSh 5OU] >aWQ Z]UO 1Z \WQO 2W`SQb]`O B{Q\WQO RS ZO 4c\ROQW \ 53 A]QWOZ

AVh eZgkZgh^dcZh YZ ÆaV VbZcVoV YZa g^Zh\dÇ

3abS O`b QcZ] Sa c\O `STZSfW \ Q` bWQO a]P`S ZO W\TZcS\QWO _cS ZO [S`QOR]bSQ\WO RS ZO a]QWSROR RS Q]\ac[] bWS\S S\ ZO ]ÙO\WhOQW \ a]QWOZ g S\ ZO Q]\T]`[OQW \ RS SabWZ]a RS dWRO C\ Q]\bSfb] S\ SZ _cS S[SÙS c\ \cSd] ^S`TWZ RS QWcRORO\] Q]\ QOÒQbS` abWQOa aW\UcZO`Sa Q]\ S\]`[Sa ^]aWPWZWRORSa ^S`] Q]\ ZW[WbOQW]\Sa [cg W\QOÔQWbO\bSa QcgO QOcaO bÒaQWS\RS OZ ^`]^W] W\RWdWRc] >OÒ Sf^ZWQO`Z] aS ^`]^]\S `SOZWhO` c\ `SQ]``WR] a]P`S ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ RSZ µPWS\SabO`¶ g RS ZO µaSUc`WROR¶ Q][] ]PXSb]a RS Q]\ac[] O\OZWhO\R] ZOa Òh]\Sa RS ac {fWb] Q][] [S`QO\Q Oa g Z]a STSQb]a _cS bWS\S\ a]P`S ZO ^]PZOQW \ g Z]a acXSb]a

>OZOP`Oa QZOdS( 6W^S`Q]\ac[] W\RWdWRcOZWa[] PWS\SabO` aSUc`WROR g `WSaU]

>c\b] RS Ô`bWRO :O a]QWSROR RS Q]\ac[] aS VO W\abOZOR] Q]\ {fWb] O \WdSZ ^ZO\SbO`W] 3\ [S\]a RS c\ aWUZ] QOaW b]R]a Z]a Ô aSa VO\ WR] S\bÒ\R] ^`]U`SaWdO[S\bS S\ SabS aWabS[O 6]g VOabO Z]a `SU [S\Sa VWab `WQO[S\bS [ta Q]\bÒ`W]a Q][] @caWO ] 1VW\O dWdS\ ScT `WQ]a ZOa [WSZSa RSZ Q]\ac[] :O Òh \ ^]` ZO _cS SabS aWabS[O aSRcQS Sa ^]`_cS cbWZWhO Z]a [SQO\Wa[]a [ta PtaWQ]a RSZ Tc\QW]\O[WS\b] RS Z]a aS`Sa dWd]a 6OPWbcOZ[S\bS O ZO ÔZOPÒ Q]\ac[] ZS RO[]a c\O Q]\\]bOQW \ SQ]\ [WQO g a]QWOZ RSXO\R] RS ZOR] SZ aWU\WTWQOR] ^`]dS\WS\bS RS ZO PW]Z]U O O ^SaO` RS _cS {abS Sf^ZWQO dS`RORSÒ[S\bS ZO QOcaO ^]` ZO _cS Z]a W\RWdWRc]a \]a VS[]a ac[OR] OZ Q]\ac[Wa[] aW\ O^S\Oa `SaWabS\QWO 2SaRS Z]a ]` US\Sa RS ZO dWRO c\O RS ZOa Tc\QW]\Sa W\b` \aSQOa O b]R]a Z]a aS`Sa dWd]a Sa ZO RS QO^bO` S\SÙ O g Q]\ac[W`ZO ÔÒ acPaWabW` 3Z VSQV] RS SabO` dWd]a Q]\ZZSdO c\ UOab] S\SÙ{bWQ] _cS `S_cWS`S c\O P a_cSRO g c\O QO^bOQW \ Q]\abO\bS RS \cb`WS\bSa 1ORO aS` dWd] Z] VOQS RS OQcS`R] O ZOa aW\UcZO`WRORSa RS ac Sa^SQWS g Z]a Vc[O\]a ORS[ta RS \SQSaWbO` \cb`WS\bSa OZW[S\bWQW]a bO[PW{\ \SQSaWbO[]a \cb`W`\]a RS OTSQb]a RS WRSOa RS VOPWZWRORSa SbQ 4c\QW \ _cS RSPS[]a `SOZWhO` RSaRS _cS \OQS[]a VOabO _cS []`W[]a g ÔÒ Z]UÒ`Z] ZO OQQW \ RS Q]\ac[W` aS VOQS SaS\QWOZ g T]`[O Ô`bS RS \cSabÒ WRW]aW\QÒaWO =bÒ RS ZOa QZOdSa _cS Sf^ZWQO\ _cS SZ Q]\ac[] aSO c\O RS ZOa TcS\bSa RS aSRcQQW \ Q]ZSQbWdO O \WdSZ ^ZO\SbO`W] S\ ZO VWab]`WO RS ZOa QWdWZWhOQW]\Sa ÒRWQO S\ _cS bOZ g Q][] Z] VS[]a W\abOZOR] S\ \cSab`] aWabS[O RS dWRO SabW[cZO W[^]`bO\bSa t`SOa RS \cSabÒ Sab`cQbcÒ â _cWQO 4`ScR ZOa RSTW\S Q][] SZ µ^`W\QW^W] RSZ ^ZOQS`¶ ^`W\QW^W] ] W[^cZa] _cS \]a ZZSdO O PcaQO` SZ ^ZOQS` ] O RSaQOÙO` ZO bS\aW \ _cS \]a ^`]d]QO SZ RWa^ZOQS` g SZ µ^`W\QW^W] RS `SOZWROR¶ [SQO\Wa[] _cS ^S`[WbS SZ OXcabS g ZO ORO^bOQW \ RSZ O\bS`W]`

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

W[^cZa] <cSab`] âW_cWa[] \SQSaWbO RS ZO ^`SaS\QWO RS O[P]a ^`W\QW^W]a g RS ZO Q]SfWabS\QWO S_cWZWPÒRO S\b`S SZZ]a ÔÒ c\ Tc\QW]\O[WS\b] âWQ]a]QWOZ WR \S] AW SZ Q]\ac[] Sa c\O \SQSaWROR g SZ Q]\ac[Wa[] Sa c\ ÒaU] _cS \]a QOÒQbS`WhO S\ SZ aWUZ] FF7 aS RSPS O _cS SabS aWabS[O a]P`S SabW[cZO SZ µ^`W\QW^W] RS ^ZOQS`¶ <]a W\dWbO O U]hO` Q]\ g ^]` b]R] O Q`SS` _cS \] VOg Z [WbSa ÔÒ SZ ^ZOQS` RSaRWPcXO\R] ZOa Tc\QW]\Sa `SUcZOR]Òa RSZ µ^`W\QW^W] RS `SOZWROR¶ :W^]dSbaYg % SabcRWO g RSaUÒ\O SfVOcabWdO[S\bS ZO Sd]ZcQW \ RS ZO a]QWSROR RS Q]\ac[] g RSTW\S SZ ^`SaS\bS Q][] SZ ^S`W]R] RSZ µVW^S`Q]\ac[]¶ 3bOÔ _cS aS OZhO Q]\ `Sa^SQb] O ZOa O\bS`W]`Sa Q]\ c\O aW\UcZO`WROR ^`]^WO S\ ZO _cS SZ ^`]bOU]\Wa[] gO \] Z] bWS\S ZO [S`QO\Q O aW\] SZ W\RWdWRc] Qcg] []b]` ^`W\QWÔZ ÔÒ SZ Q]\ac[] Sa SZ RS OZQO\hO` SZ PWS\SabO` SZ ^ZOQS` g ZO TSZWQWROR S\ c\ SXS`QWQW] ^`]Tc\RO[S\bS W\RWdWRcOZ :O [S`QOR]bSQ\WO RSZ Q]\ac[] VO []dWZWhOR] SZ RSaS] SfOQS`PO\R] SZ µ^`W\QW^W] RSZ ^ZOQS`¶ g RSPWZWbO\R] SZ µ^`W\QW^W] RS `SOZWROR¶ S\ Z]a acXSb]a 6O VSQV] RWO\O S\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a W\Q]\aQWS\bSa [ta ^`]Tc\R]a RSZ W\RWdWRc] S\ SZ t`SO [ta ^`W[O`WO g [ta W[^cZaWdO RS {abS :O UÒ\ TtP`WQO RSZ Q]\ac[] VO WR] Sd]ZcQW]\O\R] O bÒd{a RS Z]a O ]a 6O QO[PWOR] aca aWabS[Oa RS ^`]RcQQW \ RWab`WPcQW \ g RWTcaW \ AS VO ^S`TSQQW]\OR] S\ SZ SXS`QWQW] RS []ZRSO` ZO ]TS`bO g ZO RS[O\RO 6O ÔaOR] RS ORO^bO` ac ]TS`bO O ZOa RS[O\ROa RSZ ^ PZWQ] O SabcRWO` OZ W\RWdWRc] g aca ^]bS\QWOZSa \SQSaWRORSa BÒaQWS\RS RS ZO P a_cSRO RS \SQSaWRORSa O ZO O\bWQWÔQW \ RS ZOa [Wa[Oa 3Z OQbcOZ SaQS\O`W] a]QWOZ Sabt dS`bSPÒR] ^]` ZOa ZSgSa RS ZO SQ]\][ O RS ZWP`S [S`QOR] 3abO[]a W\abOZOR]a S\ c\ aWabS[O RS dWRO g Q]\ c\]a dOZ]`Sa _cS aS \cb`S\ S W[^`SU\O\ RS Z]a Q]\QS^b]a [ta PtaWQ]a RS ZO SQ]\][ O VOabO SZ ^c\b] RS _cS VO\ Q]\TWUcÒR] c\ \cSd] [OÔ a]QWOZ g `SZOQW]\OZ RS g S\b`S Z]a W\RWdWRc]a

:O `S]ÙO\WhOQW \ a]QWOZ O bÒd{a RSZ Q]\ac[] AOPS[]a _cS ZO ]ÙO\WhOQW \ a]QWOZ S\ U`c^]a S\ ZO Sa^SQWS O\W[OZ bWS\S c\O Tc\QW \ RS ^`]bSQQW \ ÔÒ ZO ac^S`dWdS\QWO 3abO` g T]`[O` Ô`bS RS SZZ]a UOÒ\bWhO ZO OZW[S\bOQW \ ZO aSUc`WROR T aWQO g ZO S[]QW]\OZ /aW[Wa[] SZ U`c^] bO[PW{\ Sa c\O TcS\bS RS O^`S\RWhOXS ÔÒ SZ W\RWdWRc] R]\RS SZ acXSb] OR_cWS`S VOPWZWRORSa RSab`ShOa S W\bS`QO[PWO Sf^S`WS\QWOa C\O QOÒQbS` abWQO RS QcOZ_cWS` U`c^] Vc[O\] Sa _cS aca [WS[P`]a Q][Ô`bS\ c\ aS\bW[WS\b] RS ^S`bS\S\QWO g c\ Q RWU] Q][ \) dOZ]`Sa OQbWbcRSa SabWZ]a RS dWRO g RS Q][c\WQOQW \ B]R]a Sab]a SZS[S\b]a Q]\b`WPcgS\ O _cS SZ U`c^] aSO ÔÒ SZ acXSb] c\ Q]\bW\S\bS \SQSaO`W] ÔÒ ac RSaO``]ZZ] BO[PW{\ RSaRS Z]a Q RWU]a RS c\ U`c^] aS [O`QO\ c\]a VtPWb]a g c\Oa QOÒQbS` abWQOa RS Q]\ac[] :]a ^`]RcQb]a g ZOa [O`QOa a]\ Ob`WPcb]a RS c\O WRS\bWROR U`cÔZ /ZUc\]a Ocb]`Sa aS OZO\ _cS c\] RS Z]a ÒaU]a QOÒQbS` abWQ]a RS SabO {^]QO Sa ZO RWa]ZcQW \ RS ZOa QZOaSa a]QWOZSa g RSZ []R] RS OU`cÔàS 3\ SaS ^`]QSa] RS RSaQ][^]aWQW \ RS c\O [O\SÒ RS SabO` a]QWOZ aS dO ObWaPO\R] c\ \cSd] [OÔ c\O \cSdO `S]ÙO\WhOQW \ POaORO S\ SZ Q]\ac[] g S\ ZOa [O`QOa 6]g Sa [cg Q][ \ _cS Q]\TZcgO\ acXSb]a RS ]`WUS\ a]QWOZ

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

RWaÔ` S\ ZO ^`STS`S\QWO ^]` c\ [Wa[] ]PXSb] RS Q]\ac[] <] \SQSaWbO\ S\bS\RSàS \W Q][Ô`bW` ]b`]a Q RWU]a _cS \] aSO\ aW\] Z]a ^`]^W]a RSZ Q]\ac[] g Z]a Oa]QWOR]a O ZO [O`QO SZSUWRO 3Z QO[PW] \] ÒRWQO S\ ZO RSaOÔ`WQW \ RS OU`cÔQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa Z] _cS Sabt QO[PWO\R] Sa ZO bÒRWQW]\OZ T]`[O RS WRS\bWTWQOQW \ a]QWOZ _cS aS VO RSaRWPcXOR] S\ RWabW\b]a Oa^SQb]a C\] RS SZZ]a Sa ZO RSaOÔ`WQW \ RSZ aS\bW[WS\b] RS QZOaS) ]b`] ZO RWdSàWTWQOQW \ RS Z]a U`c^]a RS ^S`bS\S\QWO) ]b`] Sa ZO d]ZObWZWROR g TÒUWZWROR RS Z]a d \QcZ]a U`cÔZSa 3\ SabS ^`]QSa] RS `S]ÙO\WhOQW \ ZOa OU`cÔQW]\Sa RS OQcS`R] O Q RWU]a RS Q]\ac[] a]\ [ta RW\t[WQOa g ST [SÒa ^]`_cS c\O dSh aObWaTSQV] SZ W\bS`{a ] ZO \SQSaWROR gO \] bWS\S\ Òh \ RS aS` 6OQS` c\O T]b] TWXO RS SabS \cSd] [OÔ a]QWOZ Sa [cQV] [ta Q][^ZSX] _cS VOQS c\ aWUZ] gO _cS OV]Ò Sa [ta OQSZSÒR] [ta TZcWR] ] µZ _cWR]¶ Q][] aS OZO 0Oc[O\ :Oa `SRSa Vc[O\Oa S\ U`c^]a VO\ RSXOR] RS aS` a ZWROa g SabOPZSa ÔÒ aS` [ta RW\t[WQOa g T`tUWZSa <] Sa _cS Z]a U`c^]a RSaOÔ`ShQO\ aW\] _cS ZO Tc\QW \ Q]VSaW]\OR]Ò RSZ U`c^] Sabt ÔaO\R] O c\ aSUc\R] ^ZO\] ^cSab] _cS ÔÒ SZ W\RWdWRc] Sa [ta W[^]`bO\bS aObWaTOQS` aca \SQSaWRORSa O bÒd{a RSZ Q]\ac[] :O Q]W\QWRS\QWO Q]\ Z]a RS[ta aS POaO S\ ZO aObWaTOQQW \ Q][Ô`bWRO ^]` c\ bW^] RS Q]\ac[] [ta _cS ^]` c\O ^`]bSQQW \ PtaWQO =bÒ RS ZOa Òh]\Sa ^]` ZOa _cS SZ U`c^] Sabt ^S`RWS\R] dOZ]` ÔÒ SZ W\RWdWRc] aS RSPS O _cS ZOa `Sa^cSabOa RS OgcRO O\bS ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RS RWTWQcZbOR _cS bÒRWQW]\OZ[S\bS aS ^`]RcQ O\ S\ SZ [O`Q] RS ZOa `SRSa a]QWOZSa \ObcÒZSa S\ Sab]a [][S\b]a S\ ZOa a]QWSRORSa ]^cZS\bOa aS dS\ ÔZWOROa S\ UÒ\ [SRWRO RSaRS Z]a aS`dWQW]a _cS aS ]T`SQS\ S\ ZOa OR[W\WabÒQW]\Sa ^ PZWQOa g ^`WdOROa 3abOa Sab`cQbcÒa `Sa^]\RS\ O ZOa \SQSaWRORSa [ta cÙS\bSa RSZ W\RWdWRc] ZS OgcRO\ O\bS Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa Z] _cS VOQS _cS ZO Tc\QW \ ^`W[WUS\WO RS ^`]bSQQW \ RS QcOZ_cWS` `SR a]QWOZ ^WS`RO dWdShO :O Q`SOQW \ RS aS`dWQW]a g ^`]UÒ[Oa RS O^]g] O Z]a QWcRORO\]a ORS[ta RS Q]\b`WPcW` O ZO [SX]Ò RS ZO QOZWROR RS dWRO bO[PW{\ VO W\TZcWR] S\ ZO bÒ\aT]`[OQW \ RS Z]a []R]a RS `SZOQW \ a]QWOZ

:O Ocb]``SOZWhOQW \ g SZ µW\RWdWRc] W\RWdWRcOZWabO¶ :O bS]` O RS ;OaZ]e '"! a]P`S ZOa \SQSaWRORSa Vc[O\Oa Sf^ZWQO [cg PWS\ _cS Z]a QWcRORO\]a RS ZOa a]QWSRORSa ]^cZS\bOa VO\ aObWaTSQV] QcOb`] RS ZOa QW\Q] QObSU]` Oa _cS SabS W\dSabWUOR]` ^`]^ca] :]a W\RWdWRc]a bWS\S\ `SacSZbOa aca \SQSaWRORSa TWaW]Z UWQOa PtaWQOa RS aSUc`WROR RS ^S`bS\S\QWO RS dOZ]ÒQW \ g aS S\QcS\bÒ\ S\ ZO Q]\aSQcQW \ RS ZO _cW\bO ZO Ocb]``SOZWhOQW \ ^Sà]\OZ :O Ocb]``SOZWhOQW \ bWS\S _cS dS` Q]\ ZO SXSQcQW \ RS OQQW]\Sa ÔÒ ZO aObWaTOQQW \ RS c\] [Wa[] GO Sabt\ QcPWS`bOa ZOa QcSabW]\Sa RS ^`W[SÒ \SQSaWROR g Z] _cS W[^]`bO OV]Ò Sa aObWaTOQSàS O c\] [Wa[] 3\ SabS SaQOZ \ RS ZO ^W`t[WRS RS ;OaZ]e ZO W\RWdWRcOZWROR S[SÙS Q]\ W\bS\aWROR g Z]a Q RWU]a g [O\ROb]a U`cÔZSa ÔaO\ O c\ aSUc\R] ^ZO\] AS OZhO Q][] ]PXSbWd] ^`W]`WbO`W] ZO P a_cSRO RS ZO aObWaTOQQW \ ^Sà]\OZ AcÙS ZO W[^S`W]aO \SQSaWROR RS ZO RWTS`S\QWOQW \ T`S\bS O Z]a RS[ta O bÒd{a RS ZO Ocb]``SOZWhOQW \ g ZO cÙS\QWO RS dWdW` Z]a OQ]\bSQW[WS\b]a RSaRS SZ ^`]bOU]\Wa[] W\RWdWRcOZ g RSaRS ZO Ocb]acTWQWS\QWO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

>]` ]b`] ZOR] ZO Ocb]``SOZWhOQW \ SZ ^ZOQS` g ZO aObWaTOQQW \ ^Sà]\OZ Sa c\O RS ZOa UÒ\RSa ]TS`bOa RS ZO a]QWSROR RSZ µVW^S`Q]\ac[]¶ Oa _cS ZO RS[O\RO RSZ acXSb] g ZO ]TS`bO SfWabS\bS aS S\QcS\bÒ\ ^S`TSQbO[S\bS OZW\SOROa 3abOa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa TOd]`SQS\ O \ [ta SZ W\RWdWRcOZWa[] T][S\bO\ S\ Z]a acXSb]a ac ^`]^W] `SQ]``WR] S\ ZO P a_cSRO RSZ PWS\SabO` S\ SZ _cS aW µZ]a ]b`]a¶ SZ U`c^] Q]\RWQW]\O\ SZ dcSZ] RS SaS acXSb] Sa TtQWZ _cS {abS aS OZSXS RS SZZ]a 3ab] \] _cWS`S RSQW` _cS SZ W\RWdWRc] _cWSÒ g ^cSRO dWdW` aW\ W\bSÒQbcO` Q]\ Z]a RS[ta RS VSQV] OV]Ò Z] VOQS [ta _cS S\ \W\Uc\O ]bÒ {^]QO UÒQWOa O ZOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa _cS VO\ [cZbW^ZWQOR] ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS `SZOQW \ g VO\ OPWS`b] \cSd]a []R]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ ^S`] O ^SaO` RS ZO O[^ZWOQW \ RS ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS Q]\bOQb]a SZ W\RWdWRc] Sabt RSXO\R] RS []dSàS S\ U`c^] ÔÒ aS` c\ dWOXS`] a]ZWbO`W] _cS aS `SZOQW]\O Q]\ c\]a c ]b`]a S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZOa \SQSaWRORSa \bW[Oa RS QORO W\abO\bS 3\ SabS Q]\bSfb] S[SÙS c\ \cSd] QWcRORO\] _cS RS\][W\O`S[]a SZ µW\RWdWRc] W\RWdWRcOZWabO¶ >Sà]\O Q]\ OZ [S\]a c\O T]`[OQW \ PtaWQO _cS ^cSRS OQ]USàS O Z]a aWabS[Oa RS ^`]bSQQW \ RSZ Ô a S\ SZ _cS `SaWRS _cS Sa ZWP`S g Ocb \][O ÔÒ RSQWRW` Q [] _cWS`S dWdW` 1]\]QSR]Ò RS aca RS`SQV]a g PcaQOR]Ò RS ac PWS\SabO` ^Sà]\OZ 3a VSR]\WabO Z RWQO g \O`QWaWabO 3\QcS\bÒ S\ SZ Q]\ac[] ZO Sf^`SaW \ RS ac [tfW[O ZWPS`bOR g O Ô`bW` RSZ QcOZ Q]\ab`cgS g `SQ]\ab`cgS ac WRS\bWROR ac SabWZ] RS dWRO 3Z µW\RWdWRc] W\RWdWRcOZWabO¶ \] ^S`bS\SQS O \W\Uc\O QZOaS a]QWOZ ^]`_cS aWS\bS ^]` S\QW[O RS b]R] µO a [Wa[]¶ ZWP`S g Ocb]acTWQWS\bS Q][] ÔÒ Q]\ab`S WàS O ZOa `SUZOa g O Q RWU]a RS c\ U`c^] Q]\Q`Sb] 3\ RSTW\WbWdO Q][] aS OZO /bbOZW % SZ W\RWdWRc] RSZ aWUZ] FF7 Sa c\ µ\ [ORO¶ S\ PcaQO RS Sf^S`WS\QWOa 3\ SabS dWOXS W\RWdWRcOZ Z]a Q RWU]a a]QWOZSa _cS bÒhO\ SZ QO[W\] aS RSaRWPcXO\ g SZ µW\RWdWRc] W\RWdWRcOZWhOR]¶ VOQS gO ac `SQ]``WR] a]Z] RSaRS ZO ZWPS`bOR RS bÒhO` ac ^`]^WO RW`SQQW \ 3ab] _cS S\ ^`W\QW^W] aS dWdS Q][] c\ Z]U`] Q][] SZ Sf^]\S\bS [tfW[] RS ZWPS`bOR _cS Z]a acXSb]a \] VOP O\ bS\WR] \c\QO bWS\S bO[PW{\ ac Q]\bÒÔ`bWRO SZ QV]_cS Q]\ ZO RWTWQcZbOR ÔÒ VOQS`Z] ;cQVOa dSQSa ZOa ^Sà]\Oa aS S\QcS\bÒ\ RSa^`]dWabOa RS ZOa O^bWbcRSa g VOPWZWRORSa ÔÒ SaS dWOXS µO a]ZOa¶ Q]\ QO`S\QWOa [cg PtaWQOa ÔÒ a]`bSO` Z]a W[^`SdWab]a ^S`] Q]\ ZO Q`SS\QWO RS _cWS\ \] ZOa bWS\S AS ^`]RcQS S\b]\QSa SZ S\QcS\b`] Q]\ SZ ^`]^W] dOQ ] ZO Q]ZWaW \ S\b`S µSZ aS` g SZ bS\S`¶ OÔ`SQWS\R] c\ SabOR] RS W\aObWaTOQQW \ g RS [OZSabO` RWTca] _cS `SacZbO ÔÒR XWQ] O\bS Z]a Z]U`]a RS Ocb]\][ O g ZWPS`bOR OZQO\hOR]a 3\T`S\bO`\]a O \cSabÒ a]ZSROR Sa SZ UÒ\ OQ]\bSQW[WS\b] RS ZO a]QWSROR RSZ aWUZ] FF7 3Z VSQV] RS VOPS` Z]UÒR] RSaS\Q]àSbO`\]a RS Z]a Oa^SQb]a [ta ` UWR]a g ]^`SaWd]a RS ZO QcZbcÒ g RS ZO ^S`bS\S\QWO O c\O QZOaS a]QWOZ \]a Q]Z]QO T`S\bS O \]a]b`]a [Wa[]a :Oa WRS]Z]U Oa \] WZcaW]\O\ Q][] bO[^]Q] gO ZOa `SZWUW]\Sa O`ÒabÒ\ Oa _cS SZ d{`bWU] RS S\T`S\bO` ZO a]ZSROR SfWabS\QWOZ OÔ`SQS Q]\ TcS`hO S\ SZ µW\RWdWRc] W\RWdWRcOZWabO¶ <] Sa RS SfbÒ O` _cS S\ SabOa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa S[S`XO\ a \b][Oa Q][] ZO O\aWSROR ZO O\UcabWO g ZO RS^`SaW \ <] VS[]a aWR] SRcQOR]a ÔÒ ZO a]ZSROR _cS W[^ZWQO ZO ZWPS`bOR \] SabO[]a S\b`S\OR]a ÔÒ [O\SXO` SZ aS\bW[WS\b] RS dOQ ] g QcO\R] {abS OÔ`SQS \]a RSaQ]\QS`bO[]a [tfW[S aW SZ Q]\bSfb] S\ SZ _cS dWdW[]a g ZO a]QWSROR RSZ µVW^S`Q]\ac[]¶ aS S[^S O\ S\ ]QcZbO`Z]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

AS ac^]\S _cS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa \]a Q`SQS[]a QcO\R] \]a S\T`S\bO[]a a]Z]a O ZOa Q]aOa ^S`] Sab] ]Qc``S aWS[^`S g QcO\R] \] bS\UO[]a \W\Uc\O `S\RWXO ^]` ZO _cS SaQOÔ` O SaS SXS`QWQW] g S\ \cSab`] QOa] SZ Q]\ac[] ^cSRS aS` ZO TWacÒ ^]` ZO _cS \]a OZSXS[]a RS SaO bO`SO pabS aS Q]\dWS`bS S\ Sa^SXWa[] _cS \]a W\dWbO O Q`SS` Z] Q]\bÒ`W] O ^S\aO` _cS ^]` SZ VSQV] RS SaQ]US` S\b`S ZO ^ZcÒZWROR RS ZO ]TS`bO SabO[]a Q]\ab`cgS\R] \cSabÒ WRS\bWROR g \cSab`] ^`]^W] QO[W\] 3\ SabO \cSdO `SOZWROR RS µa]Z]a¶ ZOa `SOQQW]\Sa Vc[O\Oa ^cSRS\ aS` [cg dO`WOROa g ZO [ta Q][ \ O\bS ZO O\UcabWO RS S\T`S\bO`\]a O \]a]b`]a [Wa[]a Sa ZO RS ZO µVc RO VOQWO RSZO\bS¶ ZO RS SaQOÔ` RS \]a]b`]a g Q]PWXO`\]a Q]\ [ta S[^S ] S\ SZ ÔÒ a] RSZ Q]\ac[]

3Z dOZ]` RSZ PWS\SabO` 2SaRS VOQS R{QOROa aS VOPZO RS c\O ^{`RWRO RS dOZ]`Sa a]QWOZSa g S\ US\SÒZ QcO\R] aS bÒbO SabS bS[O aS VOQS RSaRS ZO ^`S]QcÔQW \ RS \] aOPS` VOQWO R \RS dO[]a S\ SZ [][S\b] S\ SZ _cS Z]a dOZ]`Sa bÒRWQW]\OZSa gO \] a]\ Z]a _cS `WUS\ \cSabÒa dWROa 3a S_c d]Q] ^S\aO` _cS \]a SabO[]a _cSRO\R] aW\ SZZ]a Sabt\ S[SÙWS\R] ]b`]a \cSd]a g ZO RWTS`S\QWO Q]\ `Sa^SQb] O Z]a O\bS`W]`Sa ÒRWQO S\ SZ ZcUO` R]\RS Sabt\ aWS\R] TÒUcOR]a DWdW[]a S\ c\O QcZbcÒ dS`bSPÒRO ^]` ZOa ZSgSa RS ZO SQ]\][ O RSZ ZWP`S [S`QOR] 3\ SZZO aS W[^cZaO\ dOZ]`Sa Q][] ZO ZWPS`bOR ZO O[PWQW \ ZO Q][^SbWbWdWROR SZ `WSaU] SZ Q]\ac[] SbQ _cS VO\ []RSZOR] c\O a]QWSROR PtaWQO[S\bS [S`QO\bWZWabO ^`]d]QO\R] ^]` Q]\aWUcWS\bS c\O [S`QO\bWZWhOQW \ RS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa 6OabO OV]Ò Z]a ZcUO`Sa R]\RS aS VO\ Q]\TWUcÒR] Z]a dOZ]`Sa a]QWOZSa VO\ aWR] ZO `SZWUW \ ZO WRS]Z]U O g ZO TO[WZWO 3\ ZO OQbcOZWROR ZO [S`QOR]bSQ\WO RSZ Q]\ac[] Sa ZO ^`W\QWÔZ ^`]RcQb]Ò RS dOZ]`Sa a]QWOZSa RS Q`SS\QWOa RS SabWZ]a RS dWRO g RSaRS SZZO aS W[^`SU\O\ Z]a t[PWb]a bÒRWQW]\OZ[S\bS US\SÒR]`Sa RS dOZ]`Sa :Oa [O`QOa a]\ QOÔQSa RS Q`SO` WRS\bWRORSa QcZbcÒZSa Q][] \] aS VO ROR] S\ \W\U \ ]b`] [][S\b] RS ZO VWab]`WO RS ZO Vc[O\WROR <W\Uc\O `SZWUW \ \W WRS]Z]U O VO\ V][]US\SWhOR] SabWZ]a RS dWRO O \WdSZ ^ZO\SbO`W] S\ W\bS`dOZ]a RS bWS[^] bO\ Q]`b]a Q][] VO\ ZZSUOR] O VOQS`Z] ZOa [O`QOa 2SaRS SaO ^Sà^SQbWdO c\ X]dS\ XO^]\{a Q][Ô`bS SabWZ]a RS Q]\ac[] g RS W[OUS\ Q]\ c\ X]dS\ Ocab`WOQ] ] TW\ZO\R{a :Oa RWTS`S\QWOa g ZOa aW\UcZO`WRORSa RS ZO a]QWSROR RS c\ Ô a T`S\bS O ]b`] _cSRO\ RSaRWPcXOROa ^]` ZO ^`W[OQ O RSZ Q]\ac[] 2SaRS SZ Q][WS\h] RSZ aWabS[O RS ^`]RcQQW \ S\ QORS\O g RS Z]a ^`W[S`]a Ôa]a VOQWO ZO a]QWSROR RS Q]\ac[] acÙW c\ RWaQcà] RS UÒ\ QOZOR] a]QWOZ 3Z Òh]\O[WS\b] g ZO XcabWTWQOQW \ `SOZ RS _cS SabS aWabS[O RS ^`]RcQQW \ WPO O ^S`[WbW` SZ OQQSa] O c\ PWS\SabO` g O c\O QOZWROR RS dWRO VOabO S\b]\QSa RSaQ]\]QWRO aSRcX] O W\RWdWRc]a U`c^]a a]QWOZSa g U]PWS`\]a AS RSTW\S SZ µPWS\SabO`¶ S\ SZ 2WQQW]\O`W] RS ZO @SOZ /QORS[WO Q][] µSZ Q]\Xc\b] RS Q]aOa \SQSaO`WOa ÔÒ dWdW` PWS\¶ 3\ ac aSUc\RO OQS^QW \ Q][] µdWRO V]ZUORO ] OPOabSQWRO RS QcO\b] Q]\RcQS O ÔaO`Z] PWS\ g Q]\ bÒ\_cWZWROR¶ g S\ ac bS`QSÒ RSabOQO µSabOR] RS ZO ^Sà]\O Vc[O\O S\ SZ

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

_cS aS VOQS aS\aWPZS OZ PcS\ Tc\QW]\O[WS\b] RS ac OQbWdWROR a][tbWQO g â _cWQO¶ 2SaRS SZ Q][WS\h] RS ZO QcZbcÒ RS [OaOa VS[]a OQc OR] ZO ÔZOPÒ µPWS\SabO`¶ 4cS g aWUcS aWS\R] c\ WRSOZ c\ dOZ]` g bO[PW{\ c\O OQbWbcR _cS VO W[^`SU\OR] b]R]a Z]a t[PWb]a RS ZO dWRO RS c\ acXSb] :O VS[]a W\bS`W]`WhOR] bO\ ^`]Tc\RO[S\bS _cS aS VO ^`]^cZaOR] Q][] ]PXSbWd] S\ b]ROa ZOa RWaQW^ZW\Oa RS Q]\]QW[WS\b] 2S VSQV] QWS`b]a Oa^SQb]a RS ZO Q]\QS^bcOZWhOQW \ RSZ 3abOR] RS 0WS\SabO` aS VO\ `SUWR] RSaRS SaS ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] C\] RSa aca ^`W\QW^W]a Sa _cS SZ U]PWS`\] RSPS Oac[W` ZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR ^`W[O`WO RSZ PWS\SabO` RS aca QWcRORO\]a /a _cS ÔÒ Z]a U]PWS`\]a ÔÒ ZOa S[^`SaOa Q][] ÔÒ Z]a µW\RWdWRc]a W\RWdWRcOZWabOa¶ SZ PWS\SabO` Sa SZ µZSWb[]bWd¶ RS ac Tc\QW]\O[WS\b] BO\b] Sa Oa _cS a]QWOZ[S\bS S\bS\RS[]a ^]` RSTW\WQW \ _cS SZ PWS\SabO` Sa c\O \SQSaWROR dWbOZ _cS XcabWTWQO W\\c[SÒPZSa Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a ] OQQW]\Sa ÔÒ Q]\_cWabO`Z] S W\bS\bO` Q]\dS`bW`Z] S\ c\O Sa^SQWS ^]aSaW \ aSUcÒ :O =ÙO\WhOQW \ ;c\RWOZ RS ZO AOZcR =;A S\bWS\RS ^]` aOZcR ZO QOÔQWROR RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ÔÒ PcaQO` g OZQO\hO` SZ PWS\SabO` T aWQ] âWQ]Z UWQ] g a]QWOZ 3abS [O`Q] ÔÒ ZO P a_cSRO RS PWS\SabO` S\ ^`W\QW^W] W\WUcOZOPZS Q]\ `Sa^SQb] O ]bÒa {^]QOa RS ZO VWab]`WO QcS\bO Q]\ c\]a W\RWQOR]`Sa _cS aW`dS\ ÔÒ PO`S[O` aca \WdSZSa RS Q]\aSQcQW \ g S\ SaS aS\bWR] SZ Q]\ac[] RS c\O ^]PZOQW \ Sa c\] RS Z]a W\RWQOR]`Sa cbWZWhOR]a ÔÒ [SRW` SZ PWS\SabO` a]QWOZ RS c\ SabOR] /aW[Wa[] RSaRS ZO [S`QOR]bSQ\WO RSZ Q]\ac[] SZ PWS\SabO` Sa c\ ^`]RcQb] Sab`SZZO ÔÒ ZO dS\bO C\Oa dSQSa aS ^`SaS\bO Q][] [S`QO\Q O S\ a [Wa[O ]bÒa Q][] OÙc[S\b] ÔÒ ZO ^`][]QW \ RS ]b`]a ^`]RcQb]a 3Z PWS\SabO` aS dS\RS bO[PW{\ Oa]QWOR] O ]b`]a SabOR]a S[]QW]\OZSa [cg RSaSOR]a g Q]\ UÒ\ RS[O\RO Q][] ZO TSZWQWROR SZ ^ZOQS` ZO Sab{bWQO g SZ QcWROR] RS ZO W[OUS\ 3\ ZO UÒ\ TtP`WQO RSZ Q]\ac[] aS \]a ]T`SQS SZ ÔÒ a] RSZ PWS\SabO` RS ZO TSZWQWROR g RS ZO aOZcR AW aS bWS\S ZO QOÔQWROR RS Q]\ac[W` QWS`b]a ^`]RcQb]a aS SabO`t S\ [SX]`Sa Q]\RWQW]\Sa T aWQOa Q]\ [SX]` SabOR] RS t\W[] g aSUcÒ[S\bS Q]\ [SX]`Sa `SZOQW]\Sa ^Sà]\OZSa AW aS ZZSdO\ QWS`b]a SabWZ]a RS dWRO \]`[OZ[S\bS Oa]QWOR]a O RSbS`[W\OR]a Q]\ac[]a aS Z]UÒ`t SZ PWS\SabO` 6]g SZ PWS\SabO` Sa [ta _cS c\ RS`SQV] aS VO Q]\dS`bWR] S\ c\O ]PZWUOQW \ _cS Z]a µW\RWdWRc]a W\RWdWRcOZWabOa¶ RSPS\ ^SàSUcW` aW\ RWZOQW \ >S`] ¥_c{ bW^] RS PWS\SabO`- ¥RS TSZWQWROR- ¥RS ^ZOQS`:O UÒ\ TtP`WQO RSZ Q]\ac[] \]a W\dWbO ^S`[O\S\bS[S\bS O PcaQO`Z] S\ Z]a ^`]RcQb]a _cS \]a ]T`SQS <]a acUWS`S ac[SÙW`\]a S\ Z]a ^ZOQS`Sa RSZ VSR]\Wa[] g aS` Oa [ta TSZWQSa >`]RcQS W\\c[SÒPZSa ]PXSb]a Sf^S`WS\QWOa S W\QZca] []QW]\Sa S\ dS\bO ÔÒ OR_cW`W` SZ RSaSOR] PWS\SabO` AW\ S[POÙ] O ^SaO` RS ]T`SQS` c\ O[^Z aW[] QObtZ]U] b]RO ZO ]TS`bO SfWabS\bS S\ [ObS`WO RS PWS\SabO` bWS\S OZU] S\ Q][ \ c\O Sa^SQWS RS [O`QO RS TtP`WQO _cS Q]\aWabS S\ ZO ][WaW \ g ZO \SUOQW \ RSZ RWa^ZOQS`

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

>`SaS\bO SZ ^ZOQS` Q][] ZO \WQO dS`ROR g SZ RWa^ZOQS` Sabt SfQZcWR] S\ QcOZ_cWSÒ RS aca ^`]^cSabOa Sa [ta aW OZUc\O ^`]d]QOÒ OZU \ RO ] aS` O Q]\ SZ ]PXSbWd] ZbW[] RS ]T`SQS` c\ ^ZOQS` O \ b]ROd O [Og]` 3a Q][] aW RSaRS SZ RWQQW]\O`W] RS ZO [S`QOR]bSQ\WO RSZ Q]\ac[] aS VcPWSÒ\ SZW[W\OR] c\O aS`WS RS ÔZOPÒa g ^]` bO\b] RS ]^QW]\Sa RS ^S\aO[WS\b] 3\b`S ZOa _cS VO\ _cSROR] SfQZcWROa ^]R` O[]a RSabOQO` OZUc\Oa Q][]) R]Z]` OPc``W[WS\b] TS] `STZSfW \ dOQ ] T`cabÒQW \ dcZ\SÒPWZWROR Sa^SÒ SbQ 1ORO c\O RS SabOa ÔZOPÒa aS Q]``Sa^]\RS Q]\ S[]QW]\Sa Q]\ aS\bW[WS\b]a g Q]\ Sab`cQbcÒa [S\bOZSa _cS Q]\TWUcÒ\ SZ [OÔ S[]QW]\OZ RS Z]a acXSb]a g _cS a]\ SaS\QWOZSa ÔÒ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] [ORcÒbWd] RS Z]a [Wa[]a AOPS[]a _cS S\ QcOZ_cWS` ^`]QSa] RS O^`S\RWhOXS g RS RSaO``]ZZ] Vc[O\] ZO Q`WaWa SZ R]Z]` RS ZO Q]\TcaW \ ZO T`cabÒQW \ \]a VOQS [ta TcS`bSa g [ta [ORc`]a aW\ S[POÙ] Ô`SQS aS` _cS SaS SXS`QWQW] W\bS`W]` \] Sa Q][ÔbWPZS Q]\ ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO µTSZWQWROR¶ g RSZ µ^ZOQS`¶ 2SaRS SabO ^Sà^SQbWdO ZO ^`]^cSabO RS µPWS\SabO`¶ _cS ZO a]QWSROR RS Q]\ac[] \]a ^`]^]\S aS Sabt T]`[cZO\R] RSaRS µZO VcWRO VOQWO RSZO\bS¶ Sa RSQW` aS O`bWQcZO RSaRS ZO SdWbOQW \ RSZ R]Z]` RSaRS ZO SdWbOQW \ RSZ OPc``W[WS\b] ] RS QcOZ_cWS` ]b`] SabOR] S[]QW]\OZ _cS ac^]\UO SZ d{`bWU] _cS ^cSRS ^`]d]QO` SZ S\QcS\b`] O a]ZOa Q]\ c\] [Wa[] 3a bO[PW{\ c\O ^`]^cSabO S\ ZO _cS SZ acXSb] Q]\aWUcS ac SabOR] RS PWS\SabO` O bÒd{a RSZ Q]\ac[] AS Q`SS _cS ^]` SZ VSQV] RS Q][^Ò` Z]a ^`]RcQb]a Oa]QWOR]a OZ [Wa[] RS bÒS`Z] RS TcSÒ RS c\] [Wa[] dO O P`]bO` Ocb][tbWQO[S\bS S\ SZ W\bS`W]` RS ZO ^Sà]\O g Sab] \] Sa Oa >OÒ S[^ShO` bO\b] SZ PWS\SabO` Q][] ZO TSZWQWROR \] a]\ SabOR]a _cS aS OR_cWSÒ\ ÔaWdO[S\bS O[P]a a]\ SabOR]a S[]QW]\OZSa T`cb] RS ^`]QSa]a ^Sà]\OZSa R]\RS ZO Ô`bWQWÔQW \ OQbWdO Sa SaS\QWOZ BO[^]Q] a]\ ^S`[O\S\bSa ] SabtbWQ]a S\ SZ bWS[^] TZcQb O\ S\ c\O Sa^SQWS RS bS`[ [Sb`] a]P`S SZ _cS dO\ dO`WO\R] S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZOa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa RSZ W\RWdWRc] 3ab] _cS Sa RS aS\bWR] Q][ \ RS µ^`W\QW^W] RS `SOZWROR¶ S\ ZO a]QWSROR RSZ VW^S`Q]\ac[] aS W\dWbO O Q`SS` _cS SZ PWS\SabO` Sa SZ ZcUO` OZ _cS aS ZZSUO g S\ SZ _cS aS ^S`[O\SQS ^]` RS`SQV] :]a dOZ]`Sa bWS\S\ c\O TcS`bS QOÙO S[]QW]\OZ g ac^]\S\ ZOa Uc Oa a]P`S ZOa _cS bÒhO[]a \cSab`] []R] RS SabO` g RS dWdW` S\ a]QWSROR /^`S\RS[]a dOZ]`Sa RSaRS _cS \OQS[]a O bÒd{a RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa QS`QO\Oa g [WS\bÒa a][]a X dS\Sa \]a S\Q]\bÒ[]a [cg R QbWZSa ÔÒ OPa]`PS` g []ZRSO` []RSZ]a RS dWRO) aW\ S[POÙ] O [SRWRO _cS dO[]a VOQW{\R]\]a ORcZb]a Z]a dOZ]`Sa aS Q`WabOZWhO\ g []RWTWQO`Z]a aS VOQS [ta Q][^ZSX] C\] RS Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa RSZ µPWS\SabO`¶ Q][] dOZ]` S\ ZO a]QWSROR OQbcOZ Sa _cS Q][] VS[]a aS OZOR] O\bSa aS ^`SaS\bO Q][] c\ PWS\SabO` cb ^WQ] S W[^]aWPZS Sa RSQW` Q][] c\ SabOR] W\OZQO\hOPZS _cS Sabt Q]\ab`cWR] RSaRS ZO TO\bOa O RS ZO ][\W^]bS\QWO RSaRS SZ µ^`W\QW^W] RSZ ^ZOQS`¶ g aW\ Q]\bO` Q]\ SZ µ^`W\QW^W] RS `SOZWROR¶ 2S VSQV] S\ RWabW\b]a SabO[S\b]a aS VO Q]\abObOR] ZOa ZW[WbOQW]\Sa ÔÒ RO` `Sa^cSabO QcO\R] aS b][O Q][] ^c\b] RS `STS`S\QWO ZO WRSOZWhOQW \ RSZ PWS\SabO` :O Q`WaWa RSZ 3abOR] RS 0WS\SabO` Z] SdWRS\QWO Z]a U]PWS`\]a bWS\S\ c\O ZW[WbOQW \ `SOZ ÔÒ RO` c\O `Sa^cSabO UZ]POZ Q][^ZSbO g O b]R]a Z]a QWcRORO\]a _cS \SQSaWbO\ aObWaTOQS` ac PWS\SabO`

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

:O cb]^ O RS SaS µPWS\SabO`¶ ^`]QcÒ bO[PW{\ UÒ\RSa RSQS^QW]\Sa W\RWdWRcOZSa g Q]ZSQbWdOa Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS QcO\R] SabO WRSOZWhOQW \ aS VO Q]\dS`bWR] S\ SZ SXS a]P`S SZ _cS ^Wd]bO \cSabÒ SfWabS\QWO AW ZO dWRO \]a S\T`S\bO O Q]\abObO` ZO `SOZWROR RSZ dOZ]` RSZ PWS\SabO` _cS ZO a]QWSROR RSZ VW^S`Q]\ac[] ]T`SQS Z] _cS Q`S O[]a Q][] dS`ROR ^]aWPZS SabOZZO Q][] c\ UZ]P] G ZO [OU\WbcR RSZ dOÒÔZ] Sa b]ROd O [ta UÒ\RS ÔÒ Z]a µW\RWdWRc]a W\RWdWRcOZWabOa¶ ^]`_cS \] bWS\S\ `STS`S\QWOa Q]ZSQbWdOa U`cÔZSa ] RS QZOaS O ZOa _cS OaWàS g bO[^]Q] S\QcS\bÒ\ SZ Q]\acSZ] RSaSOR] S\ ZOa WRS]Z]U Oa ] S\ ZOa `SZWUW]\Sa :O UÒ\ RSQS^QW \ RS ZO [S\bWÒ UZ]POZ RSZ PWS\SabO` g RSZ ^ZOQS` Sa RWT QWZ RS Oac[W` [tfW[S aW SaO cb]^ O dWS\S Q`SORO RSaRS SZ SfbS`W]` OZ W\RWdWRc] g \] Q][] c\O W\dS\QW \ RSZ acXSb] /\bS SaO R]Z]`]aO QO RO O dSQSa SZ W\RWdWRc] \] ^cSRS Q][^`S\RS` _cS SaO cb]^ O Sa SZ bSZ \ RS c\ SaQS\O`W] W\dS\bOR] g aWUcS ^SàWUcW{\R]ZO O ^SaO` RSZ U]Z^S W\QOÔh RS `SOZWhO` c\ O\tZWaWa Q` bWQ] g ^`]Tc\R] RS aW Sa] _cS ^SàSUc O SÒ c\O `SOZWROR ^]aWPZS ] c\O _cW[SÒ >]` Sa] bÒa SabO Sf^S`WS\QWO S\ [cQV]a QOa]a ZO `SOQQW \ \] Sa ZO `STZSfW \ aW\] ZO RS ZO P a_cSRO O \ [ta S\Q]\ORO aW QOPS RS SaS PWS\SabO` 3\ SabS SabOR] RS RSaQ]\QWS`b] SZ W\RWdWRc] ^cSRS S\Q]\bÒàS ^]` ^`W[SÒ dSh Q]\ OZUc\Oa RS ZOa ÔZOPÒa g RS ZOa S[]QW]\Sa _cS VOP O\ aWR] SfQZcWROa RSZ RWQQW]\O`W] RS ZO [S`QOR]bSQ\WO( R]Z]` T`cabÒQW \ dcZ\SÒPWZWROR 3\ Sa]a [][S\b]a aS S\QcS\bÒ RSa^`]dWab] O ac dSh RS c\ SXS`QWQW] _cS S\ ZO a]QWSROR RS VW^S`Q]\ac[] \] aS T][S\bO( ZO `STZSfW \ W\b`]a^SQbWdO G Q]\ ZO RWTWQcZbOR RS \] aOPS` USabW]\O` ZO T`cabÒQW \ g Z]a ^`]QSa]a _cS {abO Q]\ZZSdO 3\ SaOa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa aS SdWRS\QWO ZO TOZbO RS ^`SÔÒQW \ `SOZ RSZ µW\RWdWRc] W\RWdWRcOZWabO¶ AS ^]\S\ RS [O\WTWSab] ZOa QO`S\QWOa VOabO OV]Ò bOÔROa ^]` SaS Sa^SXWa[] RS ZO ][\W^]bS\QWO T][S\bOR] ^]` ZO [S`QOR]bSQ\WO RSZ Q]\ac[] /\bS SaS RSaQ]\QWS`b] T`S\bS O c\] [Wa[] g T`S\bS OZ Q]\bSfb] c\O `SOQQW \ [cg Q][ \ g US\SÒZWhORO Sa ZO RS O`bWQcZO` RS \cSd] c\O µVcWRO VOQWO RSZO\bS¶ ÔÒ W\bS\bO` [O\bS\S` ZO cb]^ O g Oa aSUcW` PcaQO\R] ZO a]ZcQW \ S\ SaS SaQS\O`W] WRSOZ 2S SabO [O\SÒ SZ acXSb] \] aS QcSabW]\O`t O a [Wa[] \W OZ S\b]`\] _cS ZS `]RSO <] aS OQS^bO SZ RS``c[PO[WS\b] RS ZO b]``S RS \OW^Sa \W ZO W\SfWabS\QWO RS SaS ÔÒ a] bO\ PWS\ O`[OR] R]\RS aS OR_cWS`S aS Q][^Ò g aS QO[PWO b]R] Z] _cS S\ {Z aS ]T`SQS AW \] VOg VOPWZWRORSa ÔÒ RSa[]\bO` SaS RSQ]ÒR] \W bO[^]Q] ÔÒ USabW]\O` ZO T`cabÒQW \ _cS {abS ^`]d]QO aS ^`]^WQWO\ ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa ÔÒ _cS OZUc\]a acXSb]a aS RSaZWQS\ VOQWO SabOR]a Q][^cZaWd]a RS Q]\ac[] aSO QcOZ aSO SZ ]PXSb] RS Q]\ac[] aSf] R`]UOa Q][^Òa XcSU]a SbQ ^cRW{\R]aS _cSRO` ObÒÔR]a S\ ZOa a][PÒa RS Z] _cS c\ R O ZSa TcS ]T`SQWR] Q][] SZ ÔÒ a] :O ORWQQW \ S\ QcOZ_cWSÒ RS aca bW^]a Sa c\] RS Z]a S[SÙS\bSa RSZ [OZSabO` S\ ZO QcZbcÒ RSZ VW^S`Q]\ac[] Sa SZ a \b][O RS ZO RWaTc\QW]\OZWROR RSZ ÔÒ a] RSZ PWS\SabO` >]\S RS [O\WTWSab] _cS ZO [O_cW\O`WO RSZ Q]\ac[Wa[] Sa [ta ^]bS\bS _cS aca W\dS\b]`Sa Z]a aS`Sa Vc[O\]a 7\dWbO OZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] RSZ Q]\ac[] Q][^cZaWd] O ZO UcZO OZ Q][^Ò` ^]` Q][^Ò` OZ Q]\ac[W` ^]` Q]\ac[W` G Z] VOQS [O`QO\R] SZ `Wb[] O bÒd{a RS ZOa []ROa g ZOa bS[^]ÒROa RS ZO QORcQWROR RS Z]a ^`]RcQb]a g RS ac `S\]dOQW \ Q]\abO\bS :]a ^SZWU`]a RS ZOa ORWQQW]\Sa a]Z] aS VOQS\ SdWRS\bSa QcO\R] SaS Q][^]`bO[WS\b] Q][^cZaWd] RO O Z]a

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

W\bS`SaSa Q]ZSQbWd]a `SZOQW]\Sa b`OPOX] aSUc`WROR PWS\Sa aOZcR ^ PZWQO Q][c\WROR SbQ QcO\R] Sab] ]Qc``S ac`US c\O \cSdO RS[O\RO b]ROd O [ta ^]bS\bS _cS ZO RSZ µPWS\SabO`¶

:O aSUc`WROR g ZO SdWbOQW \ RS Z]a `WSaU]a :O UÒ\ TOQb]` O RSZ Q]\ac[] S\ ac ZOÙO Sf^S`WS\QWO VO WR] ^S`TSQQW]\O\R] ZO RSbSQQW \ RS \SQSaWRORSa VOabO ZZSUO` W\QZca] O []ZRSO`ZOa /a _cS Q]\ SZ [Wa[] W\US\W] Q]\ SZ _cS aS Q]\ab`cg ZO ]TS`bO RSZ µPWS\SabO`¶ bO[PW{\ aS VO VSQV] Q]\ ZO RS ZO µaSUc`WROR¶ @SQ]`RS[]a _cS Q]\ SZ RSaQcP`W[WS\b] RS ZO OU`WQcZbcÒ acÙW SZ aS\bW[WS\b] Q]ZSQbWd] RS ZO ^`]^WSROR g Q]\ {abS SZ bS[]` O ^S`RS`ZO 2SaRS O_cSZ S\b]\QSa g Q]\ ZO ZZSUORO RS ZO `Sd]ZcQW \ W\Rcab`WOZ Q][S\h SZ QO[W\] RS ZO ^`]bSQQW \ VOabO ZZSUO` O aWabS[Oa RS [tfW[O a]TWabWQOQW \ 1cO\b] [ta bS\S[]a [ta _cS`S[]a g a]P`S b]R] [ta [WSR] bS\S[]a O _cS \]a Z] _cWbS\ Oa _cS ZO aSUc`WROR Sa ]b`] RS Z]a ]PXSbWd]a RS ZOa a]QWSRORSa ]^cZS\bOa g Q]\ SZZO ZO Q`SOQW \ RS aWabS[Oa _cS ^`SdS\UO\ Z]a `WSaU]a RS ^{`RWROa G S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR Z]a `WSaU]a RS ZO ^{`RWRO \] a]Z] a]\ Z]a [ObS`WOZSa aW\] bO[PW{\ Z]a T aWQ]a Q][] ZO aOZcR Z]a OTSQbWd]a S W\QZca] Z]a ^`]^WO[S\bS Oa]QWOR]a OZ Q]\ac[] :O [S`QOR]bSQ\WO RS ZO µaSUc`WROR¶ bWS\S c\ SZS[S\b] RS S\UO\QVS ÔÒ QWcRORO\ O SfbÒ]`RW\O`W] SZ [WSR] ;WSR] O ZO RSaUÒQWO O Z] RSaQ]\]QWR] O ZOa QObtab`]TSa O µS\UO\QVOàS¶ ] O ^S`RS` Z]a Z]U`]a OZQO\hOR]a AOPS[]a bO[PW{\ _cS SZ [WSR] Sa c\ [SQO\Wa[] RS RSTS\aO Tc\QW]\OZ aWS[^`S g QcO\R] \] aSO SfOQS`POR] ^]`_cS aW \] \]a ÔÒZWhO W[^WRW{\R]\]a S\T`S\bO` ORSQcORO[S\bS O ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa _cS Z] ^`]d]QO\ DWdW` Q]\ [WSR] \]a VOQS dcZ\SÒPZSa ^]Q] O``WSaUOR]a g [cg `SQS^bWd]a O QcOZ_cWS` ^`]^cSabO _cS Oc[S\bS \cSabÒ µaSUc`WROR¶ <] Sa RS SfbÒ O` _cS ZOa S[^`SaOa RS aSUc`]a aSO\ OQbcOZ[S\bS c\] RS Z]a \SU]QW]a [ta ^` a^S`]a /aSUcÒ[]a b]R]) ZO QOaO SZ Q]QVS ZO TO[WZWO ZO aOZcR Z]a dWOXSa SZ ^]bS\QWOZ `]P] VOabO ZZSUO[]a O OaSUcÒ` ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS \cSabÒ ^`]^WO [cS`bS <] Q]\bS\b]a Q]\ SZZ] g VOQW{\R]\]a SQ] RSZ RWQV] µ[ta dOZS ^`SdS\W` _cS QcÒ`¶ VO\ S\bÒR] Q]\ [cQVO TcS`hO S\ ZO SaQS\O RSZ VW^S`Q]\ac[] Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa ÔÒ ZO SdWbOQW \ RS `WSaU]a 3\ c\O a]QWSROR _cS dWdS aSRcQWRO ^]` SZ SabS`S]bW^] RS ZO TSZWQWROR RSZ ^ZOQS` g RSZ PWS\SabO` Sa [cg ^`]QZWdS O aS` Q]\dS\QWR] RS ZO W[^]`bO\QWO _cS bWS\S ^`SdS\W` Z]a `WSaU]a _cS ZS ^cRWSÒ\ ZZSdO` O ^S`RS` SaO µTSZWQWROR¶ µ^ZOQS`¶ g µPWS\SabO`¶ bO\ RSaSOR]a ;tfW[S aW S\ SaO a]QWSROR Z]a µW\RWdWRc]a W\RWdWRcOZWabOa¶ Sabt\ RSPWZWbOR]a S\ QOÔQWRORSa g RSab`ShOa ^Sà]\OZSa ÔÒ [O\SXO` ZO T`cabÒQW \ RSZ RWa^ZOQS` g aW\ `STS`S\QWOa Q]ZSQbWdOa _cS ZSa [O`_cS ZO Z \SO O aSUcW` 2SaRS SabS ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] Sa TtQWZ S\bS\RS` Q][] µZ]a ^`]UÒ[Oa RS ^`SdS\QW \ RS `WSaU]a¶ aS VO\ Q]\dS`bWR] QOaW S\ ]PXSb]a RS ^`W[SÒ \SQSaWROR BS\S[]a ^cSa R]a UÒ\RSa T]`[Oa RS QZOaWTWQO` ZO ]TS`bO >]` c\ ZOR] O_cSZZ]a ^`]RcQb]a _cS \]a dO\ O ^`]d]QO` PWS\SabO` ^ZOQS` TSZWQWROR g ^]` ]b`] O_cSZZ]a _cS \]a dO\ O ^`]QcÒ` aSUc`WROR g _cS dO\ O aS`dW` ÔÒ SdWbO` _cS ^S`RO[]a SaS PWS\SabO` ^ZOQS` ] TSZWQWROR ac^cSabO[S\bS OZQO\hOR]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

AW Z] `STZSfW]\O[]a [ta O T]\R] a]\ R]a Z \SOa RS [S`QOR] OPa]ZcbO[S\bS Q][^ZS[S\bO`WOa C\O aS` O ZO RS ZO TSZWQWROR O bÒd{a RS ZO Q]\_cWabO RSZ PWS\SabO` g ZO ]bÒ SZ [O\cOZ RS W\ab`cQQW]\Sa ÔÒ \] ^S`RS` SaO TSZWQWROR C\ {fWb] RS dS\bOa aSUc`] ^]`_cS QcO\R] \] aS Q][^Ò S\ c\O Z \SO aS Q][^Ò`t aWS[^`S S\ ZO ]bÒ :] ^S`dSà] RS SabO aWbcOQW \ Sa _cS ZO WRSO RS µPWS\SabO`¶ _cS aS Sabt ]T`SQWS\R] O ZO Q]ZSQbWdWROR Sa c\ acS ] _cS \] aS Q]``Sa^]\RS Q]\ ZO `SOZWROR ^]` Sa] S\ ZO ]bÒ Z \SO RS \SU]QW] ZO µaSUc`WROR¶ O bÒd{a RS ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS `WSaU]a RSTW\S g RSaUÒ\O c\]a `WSaU]a _cS O dSQSa bWS\S\ c\ Tc\RO[S\b] Q]\Tca] S W\QZca] W``SOZ 3dWRS\bS[S\bS ZO a]QWSROR Q]\bS[^]`t\SO bWS\S `WSaU]a `SOZSa 0SQY Z]a RSaQ`WPS [cg PWS\ S\ ac ZWP`] µ:O a]QWSROR RSZ @WSaU]¶ ''& g \] Sa [W W\bS`{a ÔaO`Z]a ^]` OZb] ] PO\OZWhO` ac SfWabS\QWO AW\ S[POÙ] S\ SabO a]QWSROR S\ ZO _cS dWdW[]a [cQV]a RS Z]a `WSaU]a _cS VOg _cS ^`SdS\W` dWS\S\ RSbS`[W\OR]a RSaRS ZO ][\W^]bS\QWO RSZ Sa^SXWa[] RSZ PWS\SabO` g RSZ bS[]` O ^S`RS`ZO [ta _cS RS Z]a `WSaU]a `SOZSa S\ a [Wa[]a :O ÔZOPÒ ^`SdS\QW \ SdWbO` _cS OZU] acQSRO Sa c\ b{`[W\] _cS aS O^ZWQO O QcOZ_cWS` t`SO RS ZO dWRO >`SdS\QW \ RS OQQWRS\bSa ^`SdS\QW \ RS R`]UOa ^`SdS\QW \ RS S\TS`[SRORSa SbQ 3dWRS\bS[S\bS SdWbO` _cS OZU] [OZ] acQSRO O bÒd{a RS ZO ^`SdS\QW \ Sa c\ UÒ\ OdO\QS _cS ^cSRS aS`dW` ÔÒ [SX]Ò` ZO QOZWROR RS dWRO `SRcQW` Q]abSa W\\SQSaO`W]a g ^`][]dS` VOPWZWRORSa S\ ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ÔÒ S\T`S\bO` Sa] _cS S\bS\RS[]a Q][] ^SZWU`]a] :O ^`SdS\QW \ RS `WSaU]a Sa c\O SabÒbSUWO WR \SO aWS[^`S g QcO\R] Sab{ Q]\ab`cWRO RSaRS SZ µ^`W\QW^W] RS `SOZWROR¶ g RS aS\bWR] Q][ \ g RSaRS c\ ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] S\ SZ _cS \] aS ][WbO\ ZOa QOÔQWRORSa \W aS W\]QcZS\ ^`]QSa]a RS O^`S\RWhOXS W\b` \aSQ]a OZ aS` Vc[O\] >]` SXS[^Z] SZ O^`S\RWhOXS O bÒd{a RSZ S\aOg] g S``]` VO aWR] SaS\QWOZ ÔÒ _cS \cSabÒ Sa^SQWS ZZSUcS OZ aWUZ] FF7 g S\ SaS []RSZ] RS O^`S\RWhOXS SZ dOZ]` RS ZO S_cWd]QOQW \ VO aWR] g aWUcS aWS\R] c\O QZOdS ÔÒ ZO [ORcÒQW \ RS Z]a acXSb]a :O S_cWd]QOQW \ O^]`bO W\T]`[OQW \ g Sf^S`WS\QWO O Ô`bW` RS ZO QcOZ Q]\TWUcÒ[]a \cSab`] [OÔ RS Q]\]QW[WS\b]a ^S`] aW QObSU]`WhO[]a µZO OQbcOQW \ S`` \SO¶ Q][] `WSaU] g ^`][]QW]\O[]a µZO OQbcOQW \ Q]``SQbO Q][] SZ {fWb]¶ SabO[]a SZW[W\O\R] RSZ ^`]QSa] RS O^`S\RWhOXS c\] RS Z]a Ôa]a SaS\QWOZSa ÔÒ _cS dS`RORSÒ[S\bS aSO T`cQb TS`] ZO S_cWd]QOQW \ 3Z ^`]PZS[O ÒRWQO S\ _cS S_cWd]QOàS W[^ZWQO aS\bWàS T`cabÒR] g aS\bW` SZ R]Z]` RS Q]\abObO` _cS \] a][]a ][\W^]bS\bSa g aW ZO [S`QOR]bSQ\WO RSZ µPWS\SabO`¶ ][WbS aS\bW[WS\b]a Q][] SZ R]Z]` ] ZO T`cabÒQW \ ZO [S`QOR]bSQ\WO RS ZO µaSUc`WROR¶ `STcS`hO bO[PW{\ SaO \SUOQW \ >]` SabS []bWd] VOg bO\b] S[^S ] S\ W\ab`cW`\]a ÔÒ _cS \] \]a S_cWd]_cS[]a g \] aW\bO[]a ZO aS\aOQW \ _cS ^`]d]QO SZ R]Z]` g ZO Q][^`]POQW \ RS _cS \] a][]a ][\W^]bS\bSa 3Z R]Z]` Sa c\ [SQO\Wa[] RS RSTS\aO SaS\QWOZ _cS \]a OdWaO _cS OZU] \] dO PWS\ RS\b`] RS \cSab`] ]ÙO\Wa[] _cS VOg OZU] _cS \]a VOQS RO ] BO[PW{\ QcO\R] aS [O\WTWSabO \]a W\RWQO _cS \] ^]RS[]a Q]\bW\cO` g \]a VOQS ÔÒ` ÔÒ `SdWaO` Z] _cS \]a ÔaO AS` W\aS\aWPZSa OZ R]Z]` T aWQ] ] OZ S[]QW]\OZ \]a W\QOÔQWbO ÔÒ ZO W\b`]a^SQQW \ ÔÒ ZO QOÔQWROR Q` bWQO ÔÒ ZO P a_cSRO OQbWdO RS a]ZcQW]\Sa SbQ 3\ RSTW\WbWdO ac \SUOQW \ \]a RWTWQcZbO ZO ac^S`dWdS\QWO ^]`_cS ac OcaS\QWO \]a W[^WRS bÒ\aT]`[O` SZ R]Z]` S\ ]^]`bc\WROR RS O^`S\RWhOXS g RS Q`SQW[WS\b]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

3\ SabS S[^S ] ^]` T]`[O` O Z]a acXSb]a ÔÒ SZ {fWb] O bÒd{a RS ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS `WSaU]a aS ZSa \WSUO ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS O^`S\RS` RS Z]a PS\STWQW]a _cS ^`]QcÒ ZO b][O RS Q]\QWS\QWO RSZ TÒQOa] g RSZ `SOXcabS â _cWQ] g S[]QW]\OZ bO\ ^]aWbWd] _cS ^`]d]QO SZ aOPSàS Q]\ ZW[WbOQW]\Sa :O SdWbOQW \ OPa]ZcbO RS QcOZ_cWS` UÒR] RS R]Z]` T aWQ] ] â _cWQ] \]a QWSUO ÔÒ `SQ]\]QS` Z] _cS `SOZ[S\bS \]a RO O \]a W[^WRS S\T`S\bO`\]a Q]\ ZO QOcaO ]PXSbWdO g RW[S\aW]\O` Z]a `WSaU]a `SOZSa S\ \cSabÒ `SZOQW \ Q]\ SabO 3ab] \]a RSXO RSPWZWbOR]a g RSa^`]dWab]a RS c\ [SQO\Wa[] RS ^`]bSQQW \ \ObcÒZ :O \SUOQW \ RSZ R]Z]` \] W[^WRS _cS SabS aS ^`]RchQO RS VSQV] aS [O\WTWSabO WUcOZ[S\bS :] _cS QO[PWO Sa ac [O\SÒ RS [O\WTSabOàS RS W\bS`^`SbOàS g RS b]ZSÒàS 3\ SabOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa aS Q]\dWS`bS TtQWZ[S\bS S\ c\ TO\bOa[O W[OUW\O`W] RSZ _cS µZO a]QWSROR OaSUcÒRO¶ RSPS RSTS\RSàS O`[t\R]aS RS \cSd] Q]\ [ta ^`]bSQQW]\Sa ÔÒ SZW[W\O`Z] /a _cS S\ SaS ^`]QSa] Q]ZSQbWd] RS Q]\ac[] RSZ µPWS\SabO`¶ g RS ZO µaSUc`WROR¶ O ZO Ô` _cS PcaQO[]a cb]^ Oa dO[]a OR_cW`WS\R] c\O Sa^SQWS RS a \R`][S RS W\[c\]RSTWQWS\QWO âWQ]a]QWOZ c\ ^`]U`SaWd] RSPWZWbO[WS\b] RS \cSabÒa ^`]^WOa QOÔQWRORSa ÔÒ OT`]\bO` Z]a `Sb]a RS ZO dWRO 3ab] Sf^ZWQO _cS X dS\Sa S W\QZca] ^Sà]\Oa ORcZbOa aS [O\WTWSabS\ [ta W\[ORcÒa S W\TO\bWZWhOROa 2Wa^cSabOa O RWaT`cbO` RS Z] _cS ZSa Q]``Sa^]\RS ^S`] Q]\ S\]`[Sa RWTWQcZbORSa ÔÒ Oac[W` ZOa `Sa^]\aOPWZWRORSa g ZOa T`cabÒQW]\Sa Q][c\Sa O ZO dWRO G QcO\R] \]a Q]Z]QO[]a T`S\bS O SabOa ^Sà]\Oa S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] SRcQObWd] ] ZOP]ÒZ \]a a]`^`S\RS SaO TÒUWZWROR g SaO ^`]Tc\RO RSacPWQOQW \ _cS S\ OZUc\]a QOa]a ZSa ZZSUO O W\QOÔQWbO` ÔÒ c\O W\Q]`^]ÒQW \ a]QWOZ ORSQcORO AW \SUO[]a g SdWbO[]a SZ R]Z]` g SZ RWa^ZOQS` \]a VOQS[]a W\b]ZSÒ\bSa O ZO T`cabÒQW \ AW dWdW[]a S\ c\O a]QWSROR RS Z] W\[SRWOb] \] Q]\QSPW[]a ZO RS[]Ò Q][] c\O TcS\bS SaS\QWOZ ÔÒ SZ O^`S\RWhOXS AW dWdW[]a ÔÒ SZ SfbS`W]` \] T][S\bO[]a ZO W\b`]a^SQQW \ g SZ Ocb] Q]\]QW[WS\b] AW \]a RSTS\RS[]a RS Z]a PS\STWQW]a RS ZO S_cWd]QOQW \ ^S`RS[]a ZO ^`W\QWÔZ d O RSZ O^`S\RWhOXS AW SdWbO[]a Z]a `WSaU]a \]a W\QOÔQWbO[]a S\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RSZ Q]ÒXS >]aWQW]\O[WS\b]a b]R]a SZZ]a _cS Q]\b`WPcgS\ O c\ ^`]U`SaWd] RSPWZWbO[WS\b] RS \cSabÒa RSTS\aOa \ObcÒZSa Q]\T]`[OROa O Z] ZOÙ] RS [WZSa RS O ]a C\O TÒUWZWROR _cS aS W\Q`S[S\bO S\ SZ µW\RWdWRc] W\RWdWRcOZWabO¶ g _cS bWS\S Q][] Q]\aSQcS\QWO SZ RSaZWhO[WS\b] VOQWO c\O ^]aWQW \ ^`]U`SaWdO[S\bS RS^S\RWS\bS [ta W\TO\bWZ 3abO OQbWbcR Sa [cg ZZO[ObWdO ^]`_cS aS ac^]\S _cS S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR aS QcS\bO Q]\ [ta W\T]`[OQW \ g [Og]` OQQSaWPWZWROR O ZO [Wa[O 1cSabW \ _cS bS\R` O _cS T]`bOZSQS` g RO` [ta `SQcà]a ^S`] _cS ÔÒR XWQO[S\bS ÔÒ OZUc\Oa ^Sà]\Oa [ta _cS Oc[S\bO` aca RSab`ShOa Z] _cS ^`][cSdS Sa c\O OQbWbcR ÔaWdO g RS[O\RO\bS 1WSU]a O ac `SOZWROR g ^`]^S\a]a O ZOa a]ZcQW]\Sa [tUWQOa _cS ZSa [O\bS\UO S\ SZ ÔÒ a] Q][] c\ RS`SQV] <] Sa RS SfbÒ O` _cS SZ aWUZ] FF7 aSO SZ aWUZ] RS ZOa ORWQQW]\Sa ZO Ô\RS[WO RS ZOa a]QWSRORSa ]^cZS\bOa /RWQQW \ O ZOa R`]UOa OZ XcSU] OZ aSf] OZ bÒPOX] O 7\bS`\Sb OZ bSZ{T]\] [ dWZ O ZOa Q][^Òa /c\_cS ZOa ORWQQW]\Sa a]\ [cg RWdSàOa S\ US\SÒZ ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ORWQbOa bWS\S\ QOÒQbS` abWQOa [cg Q][c\Sa A]\ W\RWdWRc]a Q]\ c\O ^Sà]\OZWROR

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

RS^S\RWS\bS Q]\ ÒaU]a W\[ORc`]a S W\TO\bWZSa _cS VO\ VSQV] c\ ^`]QSa] âWQ]Z UWQ] RS W\RWdWRcOQW \ W\Q][^ZSb] ^]` Z] _cS bWS\S\ RWTWQcZbORSa ÔÒ dWdW` Q]\ Ocb]\][ O S W\RS^S\RS\QWO AcSZS\ aS` W[^cZaWd]a Q]\ W\b]ZSÒ\QWO O ZO T`cabÒQW \ RWab [WQ]a g ^`]QZWdSa O ZO O\aWSROR :Oa QOÒQbS` abWQOa RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa Q]\ c\ ^`]PZS[O RS ORWQQW \ a]\ SZ [tfW[] Sf^]\S\bS RS c\ []R] RS SabO` g RS Q`SQS` S\ ZO a]QWSROR RSZ VW^S`Q]\ac[] @S^`SaS\bO\ ZO Q`ch RS c\O []\SRO QcgO QOÒ Sa ZO RS Z]a ^ZOQS`Sa RSZ Q]\ac[] A]\ SZ Sa^SX] RS ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR _cS Z]a aS`Sa Vc[O\]a bS\S[]a Q]\ `Sa^SQb] O ZO [O_cW\O`WO RSZ Q]\ac[] ZO [cSabÒ RS Q][] {abO VO OZbSÒR] Z]a aWabS[Oa RS `SUcZOQW \ [ta PtaWQ]a RS \cSab`] ^`]^W] W[^cZa] PW]Z UWQ] RS Q]\ac[]

:]a `WSaU]a RS ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RSZ `WSaU] :O [S`QOR]bSQ\WO RSZ Q]\ac[] aS OZhO O\bS \]a]b`]a Q][] c\ UÒ\ PS\STOQb]` _cS \]a dO O ^`]QcÒ` PWS\SabO` ^ZOQS` TSZWQWROR g ÔÒ SZZ] Z] dO O VOQS` Rt\R]\]a b]R] bW^] RS TOQWZWRORSa Q`{RWb] ÔU] O^ZOhOR] SbQ ÔÒ W\QWbO`\]a O OZQO\hO` ZOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa ] [S`QO\Q Oa _cS RSaSO[]a ]PbS\S` 3a c\ dWOXS RS P a_cSRO RS aObWaTOQQW \ ^Sà]\OZ S\ SZ _cS \cSab`] UÒ\ SXS`QWQW] Sa SZ RS SZSUW` S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] RS a]P`S]TS`bO bS\S[]a O \cSabÒ RWa^]aWQW \ QcOZ_cWS` OZbS`\ObWdO W[OUW\OPZS dWdW[]a S\ c\ [O`Q] S\ SZ _cS Sa [cg aS\QWZZ] Q]\TWUcÒ` \cSab`] SabWZ] RS dWRO OQ]`RS Q]\ Z] _cS SZ [S`QOR] \]a ]T`SQS :O \WQO µ^`]OQbWdWROR¶ W\RWdWRcOZ _cS aS \SQSaWbO Sa ZO RS RSaSO` OZU] RS Z] _cS aS \]a ]T`SQS AS \]a ^`]^]\S c\O Q]\ab`cQQW \ W\bS`\O RSaRS SZ SfbS`W]` g \] RSaRS SZ W\bS`W]` RSaRS Z] ac^S`TWQWOZ g \] RSaRS Z] ^`]Tc\R] 3a c\ Q]\bSfb] _cS \] \]a VOQS [ORcÒ` [ta PWS\ ^]bS\QWO Z] Q]\bÒ`W] \]a W\dWbO O Q][^]`bO`\]a Q][] \W ]a ] Q][] OR]ZSaQS\bSa _cS S\aOgO\ ac W[OUS\ O aS` [ta \O`QWa]a _cS \c\QO g ^]` bO\b] O RSPWZWbO` \cSabÒa T]`bOZShOa g \cSabÒa QOÔQWRORSa 3Z SabcRW] RS ZOa ORWQQW]\Sa aS VO Q]\dS`bWR] S\ c\ ]PXSbWd] W\bS`\OQW]\OZ W\RWa^S\aOPZS ÔÒ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ^]Z bWQOa RS OQbcOQW \ g ÔÒ SZ RWaS ] RS ^ZO\Sa ^`]gSQb]a g ^`]UÒ[Oa RS bÒbO[WS\b] g RS ^`SdS\QW \ AS VO W\dSabWUOR] RcÒ\bS R{QOROa g aS VO ZZSUOR] OZ Q]\aS\a] S\ ZOa ^]Z bWQOa W\bS`\OQW]\OZSa a]P`S SZ OP]`ROXS RS SaO ^`]PZS[tbWQO S\ b]R]a aca t[PWb]a 3\ ZO OQbcOZWROR aS QcS\bO Q]\ c\O O[^ZWO PObS` O RS ^`]UÒ[Oa POaOR]a S\ ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] g S\ ZO ^`][]QW \ RS TOQb]`Sa RS ^`]bSQQW \ _cS aS W[^ZO\bO\ RSaRS SRORSa bS[^Ò\Oa S\ SZ t[PWb] SaQ]ZO` TO[WZWO` g Q][c\WbO`W] 3\ \] ^]QOa ]QOaW]\Sa aS VO VOPZOR] RS _cS Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] g RS ^`]bSQQW \ a]\ ZOa R]a QOÒa RS c\O [Wa[O []\SRO <] a]\ Q]\QS^b]a \W SabtbWQ]a \W SabO\Q]a Sabt\ W\Sf]ÒPZS[S\bS dW\QcZOR]a :Oa dO`WOPZSa OU`cÔROa ÔÒ QORO c\] RS Z]a TOQb]`Sa O dSQSa ^cSRS\ aS` ZOa [Wa[Oa RS^S\RWS\R] RS ZOa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa ] Z]a acXSb]a >]` Sa] S\ ]QOaW]\Sa c\ TOQb]` Q]\aWRSÒR] RS `WSaU] ^cSRS OQbcO` Q][] ^`]bSQb]` ÔÒ c\ acXSb] RSbS`[W\OR] S\ c\O QW`Qc\abO\QWO Q]\Q`SbO ] dWQSdSàO c\ TOQb]` SbW_cSbOR] Q][] RS ^`]bSQQW \ ^cSRS aS` RS `WSaU] ÔÒ c\ acXSb] Q]\Q`Sb] S\ c\O QW`Qc\abO\QWO RSbS`[W\ORO 2S OV _cS bO\b] Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] Q][] RS ^`]bSQQW \ aSO c\O `SR RS dO`WOPZSa _cS W\bSÒQb O\ S\b`S a RS c\O [O\SÒ RW\t[WQO Q]\ c\ `SacZbOR] O dSQSa W[^`SRSQWPZS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

3abO T`]\bSÒ RWTcaO S\b`S TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] g RS ^`]bSQQW \ ^]\S RS [O\WTWSab] OZU] _cS dO [ta OZZt RS c\O TOZbO RS a]ZdS\QWO S\ ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ bS `WQO ?cWht Z] _cS VOP` O _cS ^`SUc\bOàS Sa aW Sa ORSQcOR] ] \] OaWU\O` SZ Ob`WPcb] RS `WSaU] ] ^`]bSQQW \ O Sab`cQbcÒa [S\bOZSa O OQbWbcRSa O VOPWZWRORSa g RSab`ShOa RS Z]a acXSb]a ;tfW[S QcO\R] aS Q]\abObO Q]\bW\cO[S\bS _cS b]ROa SabOa dO`WOPZSa ^cSRS\ aS` bO\b] Tc\QW]\OZSa Q][] RWaTc\QW]\OZSa RS OQcS`R] O c\Oa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa S\ c\ SaÔQW] bWS[^] Q]\Q`Sb] / ZOa dO`WOPZSa aSZSQQW]\OROa Q][] RS `WSaU] ZSa ]Qc``S Q][] O Z]a ]PXSb]a RS Q]\ac[] \] a]\ \W [OZOa \W PcS\Oa S\ a [Wa[Oa ^S`] S\ W\bSÒQQW \ Q]\ ZOa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa g Q]\ c\ SaÔQW] bWS[^] Q]\Q`Sb] ^cSRS\ S\Q]\bÒàS RSaOXcabOROa Oc[S\bO\R] SZ [OÙS\ RS S``]` S\ ZOa OQbcOQW]\Sa RS c\ acXSb] <] ]ZdWRS[]a _cS SZ `WSaU] Sa ZO ^]aWPWZWROR ] Q]\bW\US\QWO RS _cS OZU] \]a RO S g RSaRS _cS \OQS[]a VOabO _cS []`W[]a SaO ^]aWPWZWROR SfWabS 3\ ZO OQbcOZWROR SabS Q]\QS^b] bÒaQWS\RS O Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a ] O aWbcOQW]\Sa RS ^SZWU`] BO[PW{\ aS VOPZO RS `WSaU] ÔÒ bW^WTWQO` O Q]ZSQbWd]a O U`c^]a g O ^Sà]\Oa Q]\Q`SbOa AS RSTW\S Q][] Q]ZSQbWd] RS `WSaU] O_cSZ _cS ^]` aca QOÒQbS` abWQOa Sa [ta dcZ\SÒPZS O aWbcOQW]\Sa RS SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ 2SaRS SabO ^Sà^SQbWdO QcOZ_cWS` ^Sà]\O RS QcOZ_cWS` SROR g Q]\RWQW \ ^cSRS S\Q]\bÒàS S\ c\ [][S\b] ROR] S\ c\O aWbcOQW \ RS `WSaU] S\ RSTW\WbWdO b]R]a a][]a ^]bS\QWOZSa acXSb]a RS `WSaU] 3ab] O[^Z O b]ROd O [ta ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RSZ [S`QOR] RS ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS `WSaU]a AS VO RWdSàWTWQOR] ZO ]TS`bO VOabO ZZSUO` O aSU[S\bO` [cg SfVOcabWdO[S\bS ZO ^]PZOQW \ RSabW\ObO`WO ÔÒ ]T`SQS`ZSa ^`]^cSabOa ^`SdS\bWdOa RS OQcS`R] O aca \SQSaWRORSa Sa^SQ TWQOa >OÒ c\O a]QWSROR W\TO\bWZWhORO Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa g [O\cOZSa a]P`S ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RSZ `WSaU] aS Q]\dWS`bS\ S\ c\ ^`]RcQb] RS Q]\ac[] [ta /gcRO\ O Q][PObW` SZ [WSR] O ZO \] aSUc`WROR g O ZO S_cWd]QOQW \ W\dWbO\R] O Q`SS` _cS aWUcWS\R] aca ÔcbOa aS ^cSRS UOÒ\bWhO` c\ QO[W\] RS {fWb] g RS PWS\SabO` aW\ acT`W[WS\b] ;OZ _cS \]a ^SaS O _cWS\Sa \]a RSRWQO[]a O ZO ^`SdS\QW \ \] bS\S[]a ZO QS`bShO RS _cS Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa RS ^`SdS\QW \ c\WdSàOZ Sab{\ W\QWRWS\R] RW`SQbO[S\bS ^]` a a]Z]a S\ Z]a VtPWb]a RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ O ZO _cS dO\ RW`WUWR]a 3abS \] Sa c\ RWaQcà] RS RSaQOZWTWQOQW \ RS Z]a ^ZO\Sa \W RS Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa RS ^`SdS\QW \ Sa S\ b]R] [][S\b] c\O `STZSfW \ a]P`S SZ ^c\b] RS Ô`bWRO S\ SZ _cS aS OaWS\bO\ a]P`S SZ Q]\bSfb] QcZbcÒZ S\ SZ _cS VO\ WR] b][O\R] T]`[O g RS ZO W\TZcS\QWO _cS {abS bWS\S bO\b] S\ SZ RWaS ] Q][] S\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS Z]a [Wa[]a 3Z `WSaU] Q][] ZO Tc\QW \ PW]Z UWQO RSZ Q]\ac[] VO SfWabWR] RSaRS SZ ^`W\QW^W] RS Z]a bWS[^]a :O RWTS`S\QWO S\b`S Z]a R]a Sa _cS SZ Q]\ac[] Sa c\O Tc\QW \ \SQSaO`WO ÔÒ Z]a aS`Sa dWd]a g SZ `WSaU] Sa c\O Q]\RWQW \ \ObcÒZ OZ VSQV] RS dWdW`

:O \Obc`OZ USabW \ RSZ `WSaU] 2Sa^c{a RS SabS `SQ]``WR] ^]` ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ RSZ PWS\SabO` ZO aSUc`WROR g SZ `WSaU] g RS ZO RSZW[WbOQW \ RS OZUc\Oa RS ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa _cS

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

QOÒQbS`WhO\ O ZO a]QWSROR RSZ VW^S`Q]\ac[] \] RSPS[]a ]ZdWRO` _cS aSUcW[]a S\ c\O [O_cW\O`WO _cS \]a dO O aSUcW` W\dWbO\R] O Q]\ac[W` \cSd]a ^`]RcQb]a OQ]`RSa Q]\ ZOa ^]bS\QWOZSa \SQSaWRORSa RS QORO [][S\b] :O UÒ\ TtP`WQO RSZ Q]\ac[] g ac [S`QOR]bSQ\WO Sa W[ÔÒPZS g bWS\S c\O ^]bS\QWO [Og]` _cS ZO RS _cWS\Sa ZO Q`SO`]\ 3\b]\QSa ¥Q [] aOZW` RS ZOa ^S`dSàW]\Sa _cS W[^ZWQO- :O OZbS`\ObWdO POaORO S\ `][^S` SaS aWabS[O VOQW{\R]ZS c\O =>/ V]abWZ Sa W\dWOPZS g O R O RS V]g c\O cb]^ O 3Z ^SaW[Wa[] ^cSRS W\c\RO`\]a OZ b][O` Q]\QWS\QWO RS _cS VS[]a Q`SOR] c\ aWabS[O _cS \]a aSRcQS \]a S\dcSZdS ^S`] _cS bO[PW{\ \]a O^`SaO 6S[]a Q`SOR] c\ Q]\bSfb] RS Sa^SXWa[]a _cS \]a RWab]àW]\O\ ¥1 [] bS\S` [SRWRO S\ ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO RSa[SacÒ- ¥1 [] VOQSàS TcS`bS S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] RS ^`]bSQQW \- ¥1 [] `][^S` ZO TO\bOa O RS SabS Ô`_cS bS[tbWQ] R]\RS b]R] aS []\bO ÔÒ \cSab`] PWS\SabO`:O ZbW[O ^SZ QcZO RSZ RW`SQb]` QO\ORWS\aS 2S\ga /`QO\R µ:O SROR RS ZO WU\]Ò\QWO¶ % RSaQ`WPS [cg PWS\ SabS []RSZ] RS dWRO RS OÔ`S\bS PWS\SabO` g aSUc`WROR 3Z ^`]bOU]\WabO ÔÒ RSTS\RSàS RSZ [OZSabO` RWTca] _cS ac SabWZ] RS dWRO ZS ^`]RcQS Q]\ab`cgS S\ ac TO\bOa O c\O dWRO OZbS`\ObWdO VOabO _cS aS `][^S ^]` ZO TcS`hO RS Z]a OQ]\bSQW[WS\b]a :O aOZWRO _cS SZ QW\SOabO ^`]^]\S Sa ZO RSZ `SU`Sa] O Z]a `Wb[]a PW]Z UWQ]a _cS [O`QO ZO \ObcÒZShO S\ b]R]a g QORO c\] RS Z]a Oa^SQb]a RS ZO dWRO Q]bWRWO\O <] SabO[]a RSa^`]dWab]a RS QOÔQWRORSa b]R] Z] Q]\bÒ`W] SabO[]a ZZS\]a RS ^]aWPWZWRORSa 3a c\O QOÒQbS` abWQO RS \cSabÒ ^`]^WO \ObcÒZShO 1]\bO[]a Q]\ c\O [O_cW\O`WO W\bS`\O SfbÒ]`RW\O`WO _cS \]a O^]`bO aOPWRc` O aW aOPS[]a SaQcQVO`ZO S W\bS`^`SbO`ZO :O Òh \ ^]` ZO _cS bS\S[]a RWTWQcZbORSa ÔÒ VOQS`Z] Sa ^]`_cS SZ µ`cWR]¶ RS ZO a]P`S SabW[cZOQW \ SfbS`\O \]a Z] W[^WRS 1cO\R] ]PaS`dO[]a O c\ \W ] _cS S[^WShO O\RO` \] \]a a]`^`S\RS dS`ZS ZSdO\bOàS Q]\ b]`^ShO [O\bS\S` SZ S_cWZWP`W] QOS` g d]ZdS` O W\bS\bO`Z] 5S\SÒZ[S\bS \]a ^`]RcQS [cQVO bS`\cÒ O ZO dSh _cS \]a OR[WÒ SZ S[^S ] _cS ^]\S ÔÒ acXSbOàS S\ ^WS g SZ SaTcS`h] _cS VOQS OZ RO` Sa]a bWbcPSO\bSa ^`W[S`]a Ôa]a :O \ObcÒZShO RS SaS \W ] ZS RO ZO S\SÙ O acTWQWS\bS ÔÒ OdO\hO` O ^SaO` RS Z]a bÒa^W{a ZOa QO ROa g OZU \ U]Z^S _cS ]b`] / [SRWRO _cS dO UO\O\R] aSUc`WROR S\ a [Wa[] g RSab`ShO S\ aca []dW[WS\b]a W\bS\bO`t Q]\_cWabO` \cSdOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa Q][] Q]``S` aOZbO` POWZO` SbQ 3a c\ O^`S\RWhOXS _cS Oc\_cS QcS\bS Q]\ ac^S`dWaW \ Z] VOQS a]Z] 3\ aca US\Sa Sabt SaO QOÔQWROR ÔÒ SQVOàS O O\RO` g ÔÒ ZO USabW \ RSZ `WSaU] _cS Sab] Q]\ZZSdO DO a]`bSO\R] RS [O\SÒ W\abW\bWdO ZOa RWTWQcZbORSa _cS aS S\QcS\bÒ O^`S\RS O QOZQcZO` Z]a `WSaU]a _cS QORO []dW[WS\b] bWS\S Z]a USabW]\O g Sa] ZS VOQS W` UO\O\R] VOPWZWROR 1ORO Ôa] _cS RO[]a QORO RSQWaW \ _cS b][O[]a QORO SZSQQW \ _cS VOQS[]a Q]\ZZSdO c\O ^]aWPWZWROR RS S``]` c\ [OÙS\ RS W\QS`bWRc[P`S _cS bS\S[]a _cS Oac[W` /ZUc\Oa dSQSa ^]RS[]a QOZQcZO` ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS OQWS`b] ^S`] S\ ]bÒa \] bS\S[]a [ta ]^QW \ _cS Oac[W` SZ `WSaU] RS b][O` c\O RSQWaW \ aW\ ^]RS` Q]\abObO` aW \]a VS[]a S_cWd]QOR] VOabO VOPS`ZO ZZSdOR] O QOP] :O USabW \ RSZ `WSaU] Sa c\O QOÔQWROR W\b` \aSQO O ZO ^Sà]\O g RSPS[]a ^]bS\QWO` _cS aWUO aW{\R]Z] >OÒ SZZ] RSPS[]a `][^S` Q]\ SabS ^`]QSa]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

RS RSPWZWbO[WS\b] Q]ZSQbWd] RS W\TO\bWZWhOQW \ g RSXO` _cS \cSabÒ ^`]^WO \ObcÒZShO \]a RSdcSZdO ZO T]`bOZShO 2SPS[]a Q]\aSUcW` _cS \cSab`] aWabS[O W\[c\]Z UWQ] âWQ]a]QWOZ dcSZdO O Tc\QW]\O` ^]` a [Wa[] @343@3<17/A 070:7=5@È471/A /bbOZW 8 % µ2WQQW]\O`W] RSZ aWUZ] FF7¶ 0O`QSZ]\O >O R]a 0SQY C ''& µ:O a]QWSROR RSZ `WSaU]¶ 0O`QSZ]\O >O R]a 0Oc[O\ H ! µ3Z O[]` Z _cWR] /QS`QO RS ZO TÒUWZWROR RS Z]a d \QcZ]a Vc[O\]a¶ 0cS\]a /W`Sa 4]\R] RS 1cZbcÒ 3Q]\ [WQO 0Oc[O\ H % µBWS[^]a Z _cWR]a DWdW` S\ ZO {^]QO RS ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S¶ 0O`QSZ]\O Bca_cSba 0Oc[O\ H % µ:WPS`bOR¶ 0O`QSZ]\O 3R :=A/2/ 0c`YS 8 g =`\abSW\ @ ''# µ2SZ VOQVO OZ QVW^ 1 [] ZO bSQ\]Z]U O QO[PWO \cSabÒa [S\bSa¶ 0O`QSZ]\O >ZO\SbO 2WdcZUOQW \ 2OeYW\a @ µ3Z US\ SU] abO :Oa POaSa PW]Z UWQOa RS \cSabÒ Q]\RcQbO¶ 0O`QSZ]\O AOZdOb 2SP]`R 5 ''' µ1][S\bO`W]a a]P`S ZO a]QWSROR RSZ Sa^SQbtQcZ]¶ 0O`QSZ]\O /\OUÒ[ 4`][[ 3 '' µ2SZ bS\S` OZ aS`¶ 0O`QSZ]\O >OWR]a :W^]dSbaYg 5 '&$ µ:O SÒ RSZ dOQ ] 3\aOg] a]P`S SZ W\RWdWRcOZWa[] Q]\bS[^]`t\S]¶ 0O`QSZ]\O /\OUÒ[O :W^]dSbaYg 5 % µ:O TSZWQWROR ÔÒR XWQO 3\aOg] a]P`S ZO a]QWSROR RS VW^S`Q]\ac[]¶ 0O`QSZ]\O /\OUÒ[O = AVOcUV\Saag 8 '&' µ>]` _c{ Q][^Ò ZO US\bS¶ ;OR`WR 3R 2 Oh RS AO\b]a @SghtPOZ ; D ''' µ>`]ÔUO\RO g [O\W^cZOQW \¶ ;OR`WR /QS\b] 3RWb]`WOZ @SghtPOZ ; D µ2WRtQbWQO RS Z]a RWaQcà]a ^SàcOaWd]a( ZO ^cPZWQWROR g ZO ^`]ÔUO\RO¶ ;OR`WR 3RWb]`WOZ ZO ;cÒZZO @]R` UcSh 2 g /`\]ZR ; % µA]QWSROR g bS]` O RS AWabS[Oa¶ AO\bWOU] RS 1VWZS 3RWb]`WOZ C\WdSàWbO`WO AS\b{ @ µ:Oa Q]``]aW \ RSZ QO`tQbS` :Oa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RSZ bÒPOX] S\ SZ \cSd] QO^WbOZWa[]¶ 0O`QSZ]\O /\OUÒ[O AQVeO`bh 0 # µ>]` _c{ [ta Sa [S\]a :O bWÒ\ O RS ZO OPc\RO\QWO¶ ;OR`WR BOc`ca AbSW\S` 5 % µ2WSh ^]aWPZSa Òh]\Sa ÔÒ ZO b`WabShO RS ^S\aO[WS\b]¶ ;OR`WR AW`cSZO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

9D8JB:CIDH

(

7U\OQW] ;SU Oa ?cW` a A]QW]Z UWQO B`Sa

:a XdcXZeid YZ ÆcdgbVa^YVYÇ Zc Za XdciZmid YZ adh g^Zh\dh VhdX^VYdh V adh n aVh _ kZcZh n aV \Zhi^ c YZ dedgijc^YVYZh

3Z Q]\QS^b] µXcdS\bcR¶ Sa c\O Q]\ab`cQQW \ a]QWOZ _cS RSbS`[W\O ZOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa RSZ c\WdSà] aW[P ZWQ] _cS ZS `]RSO g ac W\bSÒQQW \ S W\aS`QW \ S\ SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO a]QWSROR 3\ SaS ^`]QSa] OR_cWS`S\ aS\bWR] ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa a]P`S Z]a `WSaU]a [SRWObWhOROa ^]` SZ bW^] RS Q]aOa _cS SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO a]QWSROR W\bS`^`SbO Q][] ^`]^WOa RS {^]QOa XcdS\WZSa g RSZ µRSPS` aS`¶ RS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa 3a S\b]\QSa QcO\R] ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa a]P`S Z] _cS Sa ] \] Sa µ\]`[OZ¶ g ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS aS R]bO RS aS\bWR] O SabS Q]\QS^b] aS aWb O\ S\ c\ ^`W[S` ^ZO\] RS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa S\b`S Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa g RS ZOa QcSabW]\Sa _cS RSbS`[W\O\ _cS Z]a `WSaU]a S W\QZca] SZ ^`]^W] Q]\QS^b] RS XcdS\bcR aS O\OZWQS\ RS c\O c ]bÒ [O\SÒ

>OZOP`Oa QZOdS( @WSaU] µ<]`[OZ¶ 5cab] 1]\ac[] 8 dS\Sa =QW] 5`c^] 7RS\bWROR

3Z `WSaU] S\ SZ Q]\bSfb] RS Z]a SaÔQW]a RS WRS\bWROR /\OZWhO` SZ S\T]_cS OR]^bOR] O ZO V]Ò RS SabOPZSQS` Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa a]P`S Z]a `WSaU]a `SacZbO SaS\QWOZ ÔÒ aOPS` RSaRS R \RS SabO[]a OP]`RO\R] SZ bS[O g S\ _c{ [SRWRO SabO[]a bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO b]R]a Z]a SZS[S\b]a _cS Q][^]\S\ QORO c\] RS Z]a TS\ [S\]a SabcRWOR]a AW\ [W\cadOZ]Ò` ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RS RSbS`[W\OR]a VtPWb]a ] Q]\RcQbOa \W RSXO` RS `SQZO[O` c\O ^]Z bWQO ^`SdS\bWdO Q]\abO\bS g ObS\bO bO[^]Q] ^]RS[]a ]PdWO` _cS S\ ZO QOÒ ]^cSabO ^S`] Q][^ZS[S\bO`WO RS Z] _cS ac^]\S\ `WSaU]a ÔÒ OR]ZSaQS\bSa g X dS\Sa SfWabS c\ Q][^]\S\bS RS O^`S\RWhOXS g a]QWOZWhOQW \ _cS ^cSRS Q]\dS`bW` RSbS`[W\OROa OQQW]\Sa S\ Sf^S`WS\QWOa dWbOZSa ^]aWbWdOa 7\bS\bO` \SUO` ZO SdWRS\QWO RS RSbS`[W\OR]a Ôa]a RS Z]a g ZOa [ta X dS\Sa aW[^ZS[S\bS ObS\RWS\R] O ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa [ta RS[]\WhOR]Òa RS bOZSa Q]\RcQbOa \]a OZSXO`t RS ZO `SOZWROR RS ZOa Q]\RcQbOa g aca []bWdOQW]\Sa g ^]` bO\b] RS ZO [SX]` [O\SÒ RS OP]`RO` g ^`SdS\W` Z]a ^]aWPZSa `WSaU]a 3Z ]QW] ÔÒ Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa \] RSXO RS aS` Z] _cS ac^]\S ZO dWRO a]QWOZ ^ PZWQO ÔÒ Z]a ORcZb]a Oc\_cS S\ Tc\QW \ RS c\ []RSZ] _cS SabOPZSQS ZOa RWTS`S\QWOa S\ ZO bS\RS\QWO O ZO RcOZWhOQW \ ] RWa]QWOQW \ bS[^]ÒZ S\b`S aS[O\O g TW\ RS aS[O\O g _cS QW`Qc\aQ`WPS ac QO[^] RS OQbcOQW \ O ZOa \]QVSa RS Z]a TW\Sa RS aS[O\O S\ PcS\O [SRWRO S\ b]`\] O RSbS`[W\OR]a a [P]Z]a _cS [O`QO\ RS T]`[O SaS\QWOZ c\ bS``Wb]`W] RSZ _cS aS O^`]^WO\( \]QVS PO`Sa g Ô`_cSa [ aWQO S\ [cQV]a QOa]a OZQ]V]Z g ]bÒa acabO\QWOa SbQ :] W\bS`SaO\bS Sa ]PaS`dO` SZ ^`]QSa] ^]` SZ QcOZ RWQV] SaÔQW] S\ SZ _cS bWS\S ZcUO` ZO dWRO a]QWOZ ^ PZWQO RS Z]a g ZOa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

X dS\Sa aS ]PaS`dO Q][] SZ Q]\bSfb] ^S`dSà] S\ SZ _cS bWS\S\ ZcUO` b]ROa ZOa O[S\OhOa g `WSaU]a _cS ZSa OQSQVO\ G SabO ^c\bcOZWhOQW \ \] W[^ZWQO \SUO` ZO ^`SaS\QWO RS bOZSa `WSaU]a aW\] QS\bÒ` SZ W\bS`{a S\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a a]QWOZSa _cS VO\ ^`]d]QOR] _cS _cSRS\ Z]QOZWhOR]a RS [O\SÒ bO\ Q]\Q`SbO Z]a [S\QW]\OR]a `WSaU]a Q][] TS\ [S\] \]dSR]a] OZ`SRSR]` RS ZOa ZbW[Oa US\SÒQW]\Sa RS X dS\Sa BO[^]Q] ^]RS[]a ]ZdWRO` g Sab] Sa OZU] _cS Q]\dWS\S RSabOQO` _cS \] b]R]a Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa aSQc\RO\ Sab]a []RSZ]a RS ]QW] []bWd] ^]` SZ QcOZ \] RSPS` O[]a Ob`WPcW` OZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ XcdS\WZ c\O aS`WS RS `WSaU]a _cS `Sa^]\RS\ O c\O T]`[O [cg Q]\Q`SbO RS S\bS\RS` g S[^ZSO` SZ bWS[^] ZWP`S 3\ QcOZ_cWS` QOa] a Sa QWS`b] _cS RWQV] []RSZ] `Sa^]\RS O Z] _cS SZ W[OUW\O`W] Q]ZSQbWd] X dS\Sa W\QZcWR]a Ob`WPcgS O ZO XcdS\bcR :O OcaS\QWO RS `STS`S\bSa Q`SO W\QS`bWRc[P`Sa S\ c\O a]QWSROR _cS RS^]aWbO S\ aca X dS\Sa ZO Sa^SÒ\hO RSZ Tcbc`] OZU] _cS aW\ RcRO ]QOaW]\O OZUc\Oa Q]\bÒRWQQW]\Sa [cg aW\b][tbWQOa >]` SXS[^Z] SfWUW` O Z]a g ZOa [ta X dS\Sa [Og]` Ocb]\][ O S W\RS^S\RS\QWO g Z]QOZWhO` S\ SZ ]QW] O Ô`bW` RS RW\t[WQOa QcZbcÒZSa RS Z]a dOZ]`Sa ^`SR][W\O\bSa g RSZ [S`QOR] Z]a SZS[S\b]a _cS aW[P]ZWhO\ bOZ Ocb]\][ O OZ bWS[^] _cS aS `S^`W[S ZO [Wa[O O bÒd{a RS b]R] c\ RSa^ZWSUcS RS OÙc[S\b]a _cS aS OZO\ O Sa]a SaÔQW]a RS ]QW] Q][] OUZcbW\O\bSa RS Z]a [Og]`Sa `WSaU]a _cS OQSQVO\ O Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa 1][] aS aS OZO S\ SZ µ7\T]`[S " 8cdS\bcR S\ 3aÔ O¶ ( µAS bÒbO RS c\O OÔ`S\bS Q]\bÒRWQQW \ ^]`_cS SZ ^`]gSQb] RS ZO Ocb]\][ O ^Sà]\OZ g ZO WRS\bWROR RSZ g] Sa OQbcOZ[S\bS SZ UÒ\ ^`]gSQb] RS \cSabÒa a]QWSRORSa / Z]a X dS\Sa aS ZSa SfWUS _cS aSO\ Ocb \][]a g aS ZSa ]T`SQS ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS Sf^S`W[S\bO` SaO Ocb]\][ O S\ Z]a bWS[^]a Z]a SaÔQW]a g ZOa ^`tQbWQOa RS ]QW] :O dS`RORSÒ ÔÒR]XO aS `STWS`S O ZO SfWUS\QWO RS SaO Ocb]\][ O /aW[Wa[] g S\ c\O \cSdO ÔÒR]XO Z]a ORcZb]a g S\ Ô`bWQcZO` ZOa TO[WZWOa bÒbO\ RS `SbÒaO` ] RS RWa[W\cW` Q]\ SZ OÙc[S\b] RS _cS ZOa ^`tQbWQOa RS ]QW] dO\ c\WROa O Z]a `WSaU]a SZ ^`]gSQb] RS Ocb]\][ O ^Sà]\OZ O bÒd{a RSZ ]QW] :O ^cU\O _cS aS SabOPZSQS S\b`S ZO TO[WZWO g SZ OR]ZSaQS\bS W\bS`W]`WhO ZO Oa]QWOQW \ S\b`S ]QW] g Ocb]\][ O g `STcS`hO SZ RSaS] RS OZQO\hO` RWQV] bW^] RS Ocb]\][ O OZ bWS[^] _cS ^S`[WbS Q]\bS[^ZO` SZ ]PXSbWd] RS ZO S[O\QWÔQW \ O [ta ZOÙ] ^ZOh] ¶

1]\dWS\S aS OZO` _cS UÒ\ Ô`bS RS Z]a SabcRW]a a]QW]Z UWQ]a `SOZWhOR]a a]P`S dOZ]`Sa aS OZO\ _cS S\ Q]\Xc\b] ZO a]QWSROR ^`SaS\bO c\O [O\SÒ RS ]`RS\O` g ^`W]`WhO` Z]a dOZ]`Sa [cg aW[WZO` 3a RSQW` _cS X dS\Sa g ORcZb]a Q][Ô`bS\ c\O Sab`cQbcÒ RS XcWQW] QOaW WR{\bWQO Z] _cS VOQS [ta W\bS`SaO\bS SZ OQS`QO[WS\b] O Z]a ^`]QSa]a ^]` Z]a QcOZSa aS ]`WUW\O\ ZOa RWTS`S\QWOQW]\Sa aW[P ZWQOa ^]` SXS[^Z] S\ b]`\] OZ bS[O RS Z]a `WSaU]a _cS \]a ]QcÔ G Q][] bÒaT]\R] RS b]R] SZZ] Sabt ZO dWaW \ RS Z]a ORcZb]a RS Z]a dOZ]`Sa Ô`bWQcZO`Sa RS aca X dS\Sa Oc\_cS ZOa dOZ]ÒQW]\Sa _cS Sab]a VOUO\ aSO\ Q][] gO VS[]a RWQV] [cg aW[WZO`Sa ( µ3\ SabS aWabS[O RS dOZ]`Sa QcgO Sab`cQbcÒ OR]^bO\ Z]a ORcZb]a Q][] ^`]^WO {ab]a aS aWb O\ S\ IZO RW[S\aW \K 7<8CD3 # µ7\T]`[S " 8cdS\bcR S\ 3aÔ O¶) 7<8CD3) ^ "$&

SQ]\ [WQ] ZOP]`OZ OZ [Wa[] bWS[^] _cS `SQ]\]QS\ O Z]a X dS\Sa S\ ZO IRW[S\aW \K ^`SaS\bWabO VSR]\WabO 3Z VSQV] RS \] aWbcO`Z]a S\ ZO [Wa[O RW[S\aW \ _cS aS aWb O\ SZZ]a Sf^ZWQO

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

OZUc\Oa RS ZOa Sf^SQbObWdOa _cS Z]a ORcZb]a bWS\S\ a]P`S Z]a X dS\Sa( Sab]a bS\R`t\ c\O ^]aWQW \ ]^cSabO O ZO acgO `Sa^SQb] O Z]a dOZ]`Sa W\ab`c[S\bOZSa [O\WTSabORO S\ ZO `SPSZR O g ZO W[^`cRS\QWO dOZS\b O ORS[ta RS S\ ZO SaQOaO Q]\aWRS`OQW \ RS ZO TWRSZWROR 7\RS^S\RWS\bS[S\bS RS QctZ aSO SZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] Q]\Q`Sb] RS QORO X]dS\ RSaRS ZO ^S`a^SQbWdO ORcZbO aS ]PaS`dO`t Q][] OZU] \]`[OZ OZU] ^`]^W] RS ZO SROR g S\ OZUc\]a QOa] VOabO \SQSaO`W] SZ _cS {ab]a aS Q][^]`bS\ RS bOZ []R] S\ Tc\QW \ RS aca dOZ]`Sa W\ab`c[S\bOZSa ¶

>O`SQS ^cSa _cS ZOa Q]\aWRS`OQW]\Sa a]P`S Z]a dOZ]`Sa Ob`WPcWR]a O Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa `SPSZRSa W[^`cRS\bSa S\QOXO\ ^S`TSQbO[S\bS Q]\ ZO dWaW \ RS ac OZb] U`OR] RS Sf^]aWQW \ O `WSaU]a W\RS^S\RWS\bS[S\bS RS aca Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a W\RWdWRcOZSa

1]\ac[]a Ucab]a g VtPWb]a QcZbc`OZSa S\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS `SQ`SOQW \ WRS\bWbO`WO( SZ Q]\QS^b] RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ g aca [t`US\Sa ] SZ µ`WSaU]¶

;SU Oa 3 RW` ) ) µDOZ]`Sa a]QWOZSa g R`]UOa¶) 4/2) ^ ' ! ;SU Oa 7) @]R` UcSh 3 ) µ:O WRS\bWROR XcdS\WZ RSaRS ZOa OTW\WRORSa [caWQOZSa¶) 7<8CD3 1WbO `SQ]UWRO S\ c\ U`c^] RS RWaQcaW \ `SOZWhOR] S\ 0O`QSZ]\O Q]\ V][P`S g [cXS`Sa RS S\b`S # g ' O ]a " =QV] U`c^]a RS RWaQcaW \ `SOZWhOR]a S\ ;OR`WR 0O`QSZ]\O g 0WZPO] Q]\ X dS\Sa RS SRORSa Q][^`S\RWROa S\b`S Z]a # g Z]a ' O ]a RWdWRWR]a S\ bÒ[]a SbO`W]a " $ % ' " # ' g bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO OZUc\O RWTS`S\QWOQW \ ^]` U{\S`] g QZOaS a]QWOZ 3dWRS\bS[S\bS ZO [cSabÒ `S^`SaS\bOPO ^`W\QWÔZ[S\bS SZ U`cSa] RS ZOa QZOaSa [SRWOa c`PO\Oa g ac ^`SbS\aW \ \] RSXOPO RS aS` SaO

3\ c\O {^]QO dWbOZ US\SÒZ[S\bS QOÒQbS`WhORO ^]` ZO W\RSTW\WQW \ [cQV]a RS Z]a ^`W\QWÔZSa `STS`S\bSa RS ZO WRS\bWROR XcdS\WZ ÔaO\ ^]` Z]a Ucab]a Z]a VtPWb]a QcZbcÒZSa g Z]a Q]\ac[]a _cS aWb O\ O QORO QcOZ S\ c\ ZcUO` `SQ]\]QWPZS 3ZZ] W\RS^S\RWS\bS[S\bS RS _cS bOZSa `SQ`SOQW]\Sa WRS\bWbO`WOa aSO\ bS[^]ÒZSa g TZSfWPZSa Sa RSQW` _cS aS `SQ`SO\ a [P]Z]a _cS bS aWb O\ S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] ^S`] \] aS Oac[S\ ^`W\QW^W]a g dOZ]`Sa Oa]QWOR]a O bOZSa a [P]Z]a 3ab]a Q]\ac[]a Ucab]a g VtPWb]a QcZbcÒZSa RSTW\W`t\ SabWZ]a RS dWRO QORO c\] RS Z]a QcOZSa bS\R`t c\O `SZOQW \ Q]\Q`SbO Q]\ Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU] 3abWZ]a RS dWRO _cS SZ [S`QOR] bWS\RS O O^`]^WOàS Q`SO\R] OZU] Oa Q][] c\ [S`QOR] RS WRS\bWRORSa S\ b]`\] O Z] _cS acSZS Q]\]QSàS Q][] µb`WPca c`PO\Oa¶ ÔÒ S\bS\RS`\]a _cS ^SàWUcS SZ Q]\b`]Z a]QWOZ RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a g VtPWb]a _cS RS ]bÒ [O\SÒ aS` O RWT QWZ Q]\b`]ZO` 1]\b`]Z O bÒd{a RS ZO W\bSUÒQW \ Q][S`QWOZ []ROa SabWZ]a bS\RS\QWOa g RSZ ^`]^W] VSQV] RS R]bO` RS dWaWPWZWROR O _cWS\Sa W\bS\bO\ RSaO``]ZZOàS S\ Z]a [tÙS\Sa RSZ aWabS[O >]` ac^cSab] _cS SZ Q]\b`]Z g dWaWPWZWROR RS Sab]a SabWZ]a RS dWRO ac^]\R`t bO[PW{\ ZO QZOaWTWQOQW \ g SabO\RO`WhOQW \ RSZ bW^] RS `WSaU]a Oa]QWOR]a O QORO QcOZ

³ µ/ [ [S UcabO ZO [ aWQO [cg \]`[OZ g g] a]g [cg \]`[OZ

³ G] [S RSQO\b] ^]` ZO [ aWQO _cS Sa [cg ZO _cS ZS UcabO [ta O ZO US\bS _cS ZS UcabO O ZO [Og]` O RS ZO US\bS Q]aOa Oa ¥aOPSa-

³ G bO[^]Q] a]g \] bS\U] [cQVOa [O\ Oa ¶ !

:O QWbO O^c\bO c\O bS\RS\QWO Q]\bÒabORO O Z] ZOÙ] RS [cg RWdSà]a bÒPOX]a `SOZWhOR]a RS T]`[O [ta ] [S\]a RW`SQbO S\ b]`\] OZ c\WdSà] RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa 3\ O_cSZ [][S\b] O ] S\ SZ _cS aS ^`SbS\R O ZZSdO` O QOP] c\ OQS`QO[WS\b] O Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS Q`SOQW \ g `SQ`SOQW \ RS WRS\bWRORSa XcdS\WZSa O bÒd{a RS ZO [ aWQO g RS ZO [O\WTSabOQW \ RSZ Ucab] ^]` SZZO ^cRW[]a Q][^`]PO` Q [] SZ ^]aWQW]\O[WS\b] [Og]`WbO`W] g US\SÒZWhOR] RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa _cS Q][^caWS`]\ Z]a U`c^]a RS RWaQcaW \ `SOZWhOR]a " RSaQO\aOPO S\ c\ OÙc[S\b] bO\ QZO`] Q][] Q]\bc\RS\bS( ZO [O\WTSabOQW \ RSZ Ucab] g RSZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] µ\]`[OZ¶ Q][] [cSabÒ RS c\O W\bSUÒQW \ g a]QWOZWhOQW \ ORSQcORO g Q][] [O\SÒ RS aWbcOàS S\

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

c\ SaÔQW] \Scb`] S W\RWTS`S\QWOR] _cS TOQWZWbO ZO ^`]gSQQW \ RS SabS`S]bW^]a a]QWOZ[S\bS Tc\QW]\OZSa OZ bWS[^] _cS RWTWQcZbO _cS ]b`]a ^cSRO\ aWbcO`bS S\ ZOa ^]aWQW]\Sa _cS ]QcÔ\ Sa]a [Wa[]a SabS`S]bW^]a <] SÒ SZ O\tZWaWa RS bOZ Q]\QS^b] RS µ\]`[OZWROR¶ c\] RS Z]a ^`Sac^cSab]a RS Ô`bWRO RS bOZ W\dSabWUOQW \ RS ZO [Wa[O [O\SÒ _cS bO[^]Q] SabOPO S\ ZOa VW^ bSaWa W\WQWOZSa RSZ `Sab] RS SabcRW]a ^`]^W]a _cS ^cSRO QWbO` # AW\ S[POÙ] ZO Q]\abObOQW \ RS Z] S[SÙS\bS RS c\ RWaQcà] _cS aS O\b]XO RS V]\R] QOZOR] a]QWOZ gO aSO W[^Z QWbO ] Sf^Z QWbO[S\bS W[^cZa c\O ^`W[SÒ ZSQbcÒ bÒ\adSàOZ RS ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS bOZ Q]\QS^QW \ RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ OÔ`SQ O S\ ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ RS ZOa WRS\bWRORSa XcdS\WZSa g S\ ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS aS ^]\S\ S\ XcSU] g aS `SZOQW]\O\ Z]a RWTS`S\bSa OUS\bSa a]QWOZSa g Z]a `Sa^SQbWd]a c\WdSà]a aW[P ZWQ]a Oa]QWOR]a /a SabO[]a S\ RWa^]aWQW \ RS OQS`QO`\]a O ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS ZO [O\WTSabOQW \ RS Z]a Ucab]a S\ [ aWQO S\ dWRS]XcSU]a S\ ^cPZWQWROR aWb O O _cWS\ Z] VOQS S\ c\ SaÔQW] [ta ] [S\]a RWTS`S\QWOR] ] W\RWTS`S\QWOR]) O ZO T]`[O S\ _cS Z]a Q]\ac[]a S\ R`]UOa S\ ]QW] S\ [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQW \ Q]\b`WPcgS\ O Q]\T]`[O` Z]a c\WdSà]a aW[P ZWQ]a _cS ^]aWQW]\O\ O QORO QcOZ S\ QObSU]` Oa a]QWOZSa `SQ]\]QWPZSa ^]` SZ `Sab]) OZ aS\bWR] S\ _cS Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a g OQbWbcRSa `Sa^SQb] O Z]a dOZ]`Sa `Sa^SQb] O ZOa T]`[Oa RS `SZOQW]\OàS S W\bSÒQbcO` S\ aSU \ _c{ Q]\bSfb]a aS W\bS`^`SbO\ POX] SZ ^`Wa[O RS Z] a]QWOZ[S\bS OQS^bOR] g ORSQcOR]) g S\ RSTW\WbWdO O ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS b]R] SZZ] Q]\b`WPcgS O Q`SO` ZOa QObSU]` Oa _cS SZ W[OUW\O`W] a]QWOZ OQS^bO`t Q][] µ\]`[OZSa¶ S\ ZO Q]\T]`[OQW \ RS Z]a c\WdSà]a aW[P ZWQ]a _cS `WUS\ ZO dWRO S\ a]QWSROR µ<]`[OZWROR¶ _cS ORS[ta aS Q][^]`bO Q][] c\O QObSU]` O RS dOZ]` _cS RSTW\W`t Z] SaS\QWOZ[S\bS µPcS\]¶ T`S\bS O Z] _cS \] Z] Sa bO\b] ] Sa µÒ`]¶ ] Sa RW`SQbO[S\bS µ[OZ]¶

# 3\b`S ]b`]a ^]RS[]a aS OZO` µ:O WRS\bWROR XcdS\WZ RSaRS ZOa OTW\WRORSa [caWQOZSa¶ 7\XcdS µ8 dS\Sa g `SZOQW]\Sa U`c^OZSa¶ 4/2 7\XcdS µ8 dS\Sa g ^cPZWQWROR¶ 4/2 7\XcdS " µ8 dS\Sa g aSf]¶ 4/2 7\XcdS # µ8 dS\Sa g ^]Z bWQO¶ 4/2 7\XcdS #

3\ Tc\QW \ RS SabS ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] ^]RS[]a ^S`QWPW` c\O TcS`bS g SdWRS\bS bS\RS\QWO O ZO V][]US\SWhOQW \ ] W\RWTS`S\QWOQW \ S\ Z] _cS aS `STWS`S O ZO [O\WTSabOQW \ RS Ucab]a ] OÙc[S\b]a _cS RSaZWUcS\ OZ W\RWdWRc] RS Z] US\SÒZ[S\bS OQS^bOR] Q][] µ\]`[OZ¶ :O aWU\WTWQOQW \ S\ c\ aS\bWR] _cS ^]aWPWZWbS O ]b`]a SbW_cSbO`bS ] `SQ]\]QS` S\ bW c\ SabS`S]bW^] _cS b `SQ]\]QS`ta S\ µZ]a ]b`]a¶ aS`t [OaWdO[S\bS `SQVOhORO S\ ^]a RS aWbcOàS S\ c\ SaÔQW] \Scb`] S\ QcOZ_cWS` QOa] W\bSUÒR] S\ Z]a Z [WbSa _cS RSbS`[W\O\ ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ 3abO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ aS`t ZO _cS `WXO g RSbS`[W\S SZ bS``S\] RS XcSU] S\ SZ QcOZ aS [O\WTWSabO\ Z]a Ucab]a g bWS\S\ ZcUO` Z]a XcWQW]a RS dOZ]` RSbS`[W\O\R] Z] OQS^bOPZS g Z] W\OQS^bOPZS /a TcSÒ RS RWQV] bS``S\] RS XcSU] aS aWbcO`t\ ZOa [W\]` Oa a]P`S ZOa _cS aS ^`]gSQbO\ Z]a SabS`S]bW^]a RWTS`S\QWOR]`Sa _cS ^S`[WbS\ _cS RWQV]a SabS`S]bW^]a aS [O\bS\UO\ a]QWOZ[S\bS dWd]a aW\ \SQSaWROR RS _cS QOaW \W\U \ X]dS\ Z]a `SQ]\]hQO ÔÒ a [Wa[]( a]g µ\]`[OZ¶ Z] _cS aS [O\WTWSabO S\ _cS [S Q][^]`b] RS T]`[O µ\]`[OZ¶ bS\U] Ucab]a µ\]`[OZSa¶ g Q]\ac[] RS ZO [O\SÒ _cS aS Sa^SÒ RS [ g [S Q]``Sa^]\RS 3aS RSPS` aS` Sa SZ Q]``Sa^]\RWS\bS O Z]a Qt\]\Sa RS W\bSUÒQW \ g \]`[OZWROR ]^cSab] OZ µaS` Ò`]¶ 3abO bS\RS\QWO RWaQcàWdO ^ZO\bSO c\O T]`[O RS OP]`RO` g `SQ`SO` RSbS`[W\OR]a dOZ]`Sa bS `WQO[S\bS ^`SR][W\O\bSa S\ ZO a]QWSROR _cS aWUcS ZO Z \SO RS Z] O^c\bOR] DOZ]`Sa PWS\^S\aO\bSa Q]\ c\ OZb] Q][^]\S\bS ^ÒU[tbWQ] g RS `SZObWdWa[] []ÒZ) [cg QS\bÒR]a S\ SZ µRSPS` aS`¶ Q][] RSPS` O\ aS` ZOa Q]aOa T`S\bS O Z] _cS S\ ZO ^`tQbWQO µSa¶ ORS[ta RS S\ ZO Oac\QW \ g QZOÒ RWTS`S\QWOQW \ RS Z] _cS S\ ZbW[O W\abO\QWO Sa µdS`RORSÒ[S\bS W[^]`bO\bS¶( ZO O[WabOR ZO TO[WZWO aSU \

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

W\RWQO\ b]ROa ZOa W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa a]P`S dOZ]`Sa g ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS Z]a ^`W]`WhO ZO a]QWSROR / Ô`bW` RS OV QcOZ_cWS` Q]\aWRSÒQW \ `SZObWdO O ZO []ÒZ ^`WdORO _cS \] OZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] ^cSa {abS bS\R`t W\TZcS\QWO a]P`S ]b`]a _cSRO`t QW`Qc\aQ`WbO OZ bS``S\] RS ZO d]Zc\bOR ^Sà]\OZ 3a RSQW` RSXO\R] QZO`] QctZSa a]\ ZOa Q]aOa dS`RORSÒ[S\bS W[^]`bO\bSa _cS QORO QcOZ VOUO Z] _cS _cWSÒ [WS\bÒa \] [S OTSQbS B]R] Z] aS OZOR] `SacZbO `SZSdO\bS ÔÒ SZ bS[O _cS QS\bÒ SabS []\]U`tTWQ] ^cSa ^`SQWaO[S\bS Sa]a Z [WbSa RS\b`] RS Z]a QcOZSa aS RSbS`[W\O Z] a]QWOZ[S\bS OQS^bOPZS aS`t\ Z]a _cS [O`_cS\ RS T]`[O SaS\QWOZ ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa a]P`S Z]a `WSaU]a /a VOP`t RSbS`[W\OR]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU] S\b`S ]b`]a Z]a `SZObWd]a O Q]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa ZSUOZSa ] WZSUOZSa g O `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa _cS aS`t\ Oac[WR]a Q][] Ô`bS µ\]`[OZ¶ RS SbOÔa OR]ZSaQS\bSa RS Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ g O^`S\RWhOXS >S`] bOZSa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa VOP`t\ RS aS` ^cSabOa S\ `SZOQW \ RW`SQbO Q]\ ZO SROR ^cSa Z]a Z [WbSa RS SaO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ dO`WO`t\ O [SRWRO _cS SZ X]dS\ Q`SQS g aS OQS`QO O Z]a bS``S\]a S\ b]`\] O Z]a QcOZSa aS RSbS`[W\O a]QWOZ[S\bS ZO [ORc`Sh gO Ôa{ ZO TOaS RS Sf^S`W[S\bO` g ^`]PO` RS VOQS` ZOa Q]aOa aW\ ^S\aO` RS \] aS` Q]\aQWS\bS RS Z]a `WSaU]a 2S WUcOZ T]`[O RS\b`] RS Z]a ^`]^W]a X dS\Sa ZOa ^`]gSQQW]\Sa RS SabS`S]bW^]a a]\ ]b`]a Z]a _cS Sabt\ S\ Z]a [tÙS\Sa RS Z] µ\]`[OZ¶ RS Z] b]ZSÒPZS g [O\bWS\S\ c\O `SZOQW \ W\b]ZSÒPZS S W\Q]\aQWS\bS Q]\ Z]a `WSaU]a SabO`t\ RW`SQbO[S\bS Oa]QWOROa Q]\ SZ bW^] RS `WSaU]a Oa]QWOR]a O SZZ]a g SZZOa _cS aS Oac[S\ Q][] OZU] Q]\acabO\QWOZ O ZO d]ZcPZS \ObcÒZShO XcdS\WZ ^S`] aS `SQVOhO\ Q][] OZU] ^`]^W]( g] µQ]\b`]Z]¶ :O ^`]^WO Sf^S`WS\QWO S\ W\dSabWUOQW \ TcS ZO _cS S\QS\RW SZ W\bS`{a ^]` RWQV] bS[O ^S`] OZUc\Oa ZSQbcÒa g VOZZOhU]a OV]\RO`]\ g ^]bS\QWO`]\ SZ [Wa[] 3\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` ZO Q]\abObOQW \ RS _cS SZ bÒPOX] RS OZUc\]a a]QW Z]U]a O``]XOPO RSbS`[W\OR]a `SacZbOR]a _cS S\QOXOPO\ ^S`TSQbO[S\bS Q]\ ZO Z \SO O\OZ bWQO W\WQWORO /a S\ µ8 dS\Sa g SabWZ]a RS dWRO¶ 1][Oa ³Q]]`R ) 4/2 7\XcdS) ! aS [cSabÒ Q [] SZ $ RS Z]a X dS\Sa \] aS ^]aWQW]\O S\ \W\U \ SabWZ] RS dWRO S\ Ô`bWQcZO` g a Z] Q]\aWUcS VOQS`Z] QcO\R] SZ [Wa[] Sabt QZOÒ[S\bS QS WR] O OQbWdWRORSa Q]bWRWO\Oa _cS [O`QO\ SZ RSdS\W` RS ac bÒ\aQc``W` Q][] X dS\Sa S\ b`t\aWb] VOQWO c\O dWRO ORcZbO SabcRWO` Q]\ac[W` ]QW] bÒPOXO` 3\ aSUc\R] ZcUO` [ta OZZt RS W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa S[^ `WQOa ^`]^WO[S\bS RWQVOa QWS`bOa `STZSfW]\Sa W\QWRS\ S\ ZO WRSO RS c\O bS\RS\QWO S[SÙS\bS DWQS\bS DS`R Z] Sf^`SaO RS [O\SÒ QS`bSÒ S\ c\ O`b QcZ] OÔ`SQWR] S\ SZ RWO`W] 3Z >O a POX] SZ b bcZ] RS µ:] \]`[OZ¶ $ RS OP`WZ RS ( µ>OÒ aS` \]`[OZ VOg _cS ^`WdOàS RS SaP]hO` b]RO d]Zc\bOR RS SZSQQW \ 3ZSUW` Sa Q]\RS\OàS O ZO RWTS`S\QWOQW \ g ZO []RO gO Sa ZO W\RWTS`S\QWOQW \ ZO ^`]bSabO Q]\bÒ ZO W\RWdWRcOQW \ SZ OPO\R]\] RS aS` RWabW\b] c\ \WQ] g] 1cO\R] b]RO ZO a]QWSROR RS [OaOa VcgS RS aS` b][ORO Q][] [OaO Z]a aWU\]a dOZW]a]a a]\ O_cSZZ]a _cS \]a VOQS\ [cZbWbcR BÒbO` RS aS` [cQVSRc[P`S QcO\R] VOabO SZ [ta dcZUO` VcgS RS SZZO Sa []RO AS` dcZUO` QcO\R] SZ [ta WU\]Ò\bS bÒbO RS aS` aW\UcZO` Sa Sf_cWaWb] :] QcàW Sa ^`SbS\RS` aS` \WQ] 2Sa^]XOàS RS ^Sà]\OZWROR Ogc\O` RSZ g] VOQSàS bO\ W\dWaWPZS Q][] Z] [ta \]`[OZ Sa ZO ]^QW \ ac^S`W]` RS \cSab`]a R Oa ¶ GO O\bSa 4Ò\Q] @]aWbW aS OZOPO _cS µZO [cZbW^ZWQWROR RS ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS dWRO g RS ZOa Q]``Sa^]\RWS\bSa bS\RS\QWOa QcZbcÒZSa g ^]Z bWQOa _cS ^cSRS\ aS` ]PaS`dOROa S\ ZO QZOaS RS SROR XcdS\WZ Q][] ^]` ac^cSab] S\ QcOZ_cWS` ]bÒ QZOaS RS SROR \] VO W[^SRWR] S\ ZO VWab]`WO RS ZOa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

a]QWSRORSa QO^WbOZWabOa g VOabO \cSab`]a R Oa ZO Q`SOQW \ RS bS\RS\QWOa O ZO V][]US\SWhOQW \ `SOZ RS ZOa QcZbcÒa XcdS\WZSa¶ $ 6][]US\SWhOQW \ S\ ZO [O\WTSabOQW \ RS Ucab]a g ^]aWQW]\O[WS\b]a XcdS\WZSa ^`SQWaO[S\bS O`bWQcZORO S\ b]`\] OZ VSQV] RS _cS Z]a [Wa[]a a]\ Q]\aWRSÒR]a a]QWOZ[S\bS Q][] µ\]`[OZSa¶ B]R]a Sab]a O^c\bSa W[^cZaO\ SZ W\bS`SaOR] OQS`QO[WS\b] O ZO T]`[O S\ _cS aS RSaS\dcSZdS SZ Q]\QS^b] RS µZ] \]`[OZ¶ S\ \cSab`] S\bÒ[OR] a]QWOZ Q]\b`WPcgS\R] O _cS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa _cS aS SabOPZSQS\ S\ {Z aSO\ g aS SabOPZShQO\ RS ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS Z] VOQS\ ^]\WS\R] S\ XcSU] Z]a c\WdSà]a aW[P ZWQ]a g ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa RS ^]RS` _cS bO\b]a SabcRW]a a]QW]Z UWQ]a OP]`RO\ RS T]`[O [ta ] [S\]a aSQb]`WOZ 3\ SabS QOa] SZ W\bS`{a RSZ OQS`QO[WS\b] aS QS\bÒ S\ ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS bOZ Q]\QS^QW \ RS µZO \]`[OZWROR¶ Q]\b`WPcgS O Q`SO` g Q]\ab`cW` ZO QObSU]` O a]QWOZ RS µZ] X]dS\¶ g a]P`S b]R] RSbS`[W\O RS T]`[O SaS\QWOZ ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa _cS a]P`S Z]a `WSaU]a 3dWRS\bS[S\bS SZ SXS`QWQW] \] VOP`t RS b][OàS [ta _cS Q][] c\ ^`W[S` OQS`QO[WS\b] O bO\ dOab] bS``Wb]`W] RS O\tZWaWa RWaQcà] S\ Q]\ab`cQQW \ dWd] OPWS`b]

/ZUc\Oa W[^ZWQOQW]\Sa RSZ b{`[W\] µ\]`[OZ¶ AW ^`SbS\RS[]a OQS`QO`\]a O ZO T]`[O S\ _cS SZ Q]\QS^b] RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ aS W\aS`bO S\ SZ W[OUW\O`W] Q]ZSQbWd] RS ZO a]QWSROR Q]\bS[^]`t\SO Ô`SQS ORSQcOR] O^`]fW[OàS O OZUc\Oa RS ZOa RWTS`S\bSa [O\SÒa S\ _cS VWab `WQO[S\bS aS VO W\bS`^`SbOR] g O\OZWhOR] SZ [Wa[] 2SaRS SZ ^c\b] RS dWabO SabOR abWQ] ZO RWab`WPcQW \ <]`[OZ `S^`SaS\bORO ^]` c\O U`tTWQO Q]\ T]`[O RS QO[Ô\O OR_cWS`S W[^]`bO\QWO RSPWR] O _cS SfWabS\ [cQVOa dO`WOPZSa Oa]QWOROa O TS\ [S\]a \ObcÒZSa g a]QWOZSa _cS aWUcS\ ac []RSZ] 3\ POaS O SZZ] aS RSaO``]ZZO ac Tc\QW]\OZWROR []RSZWhOR]Ò g ^`SRWQbWdO _cS Sa ZO POaS RS b]R] SZ [cSab`S] g RS ZOa UOÒ\b Oa RS `S^`SaS\bObWdWROR RS Z]a SabcRW]a SabOR abWQ]a O^ZWQOR]a O ZO a]QW]Z]U O Ac SfbS\RWRO cbWZWhOQW \ Sabt XcabWTWQORO ^]` ZO T`SQcS\QWO ] \]`[OZWROR Q]\ ZO _cS QWS`b]a TS\ [S\]a bWS\RS\ O Ô`SQSàS S\ aca Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a O SabO RWab`WPcQW \ g \] a Z] S\ POaS O Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a _cS aS OQc[cZO\ S\ ZOa ^]aWQW]\Sa QS\bÒZSa RS ZO QO[Ô\O O_cSZZ]a _cS a]\ [ta T`SQcS\bSa aW\] bO[PW{\ ^]`_cS ^S`[WbS RSbS`[W\O` ZO T`SQcS\QWO ÔÒ b]R]a Z]a TS\ [S\]a _cS `Sa^]\RS\ O ZO RWab`WPcQW \ W\QZcWR]a SZ ^]`QS\bOXS RS QOa]a _cS aS OZSXO\ RS SaO [SRWO 4S\ [S\]a Q][] Z]a QOÒQbS`Sa []`T]Z UWQ]a RS W\RWdWRc]a RS c\O Sa^SQWS QOÒQbS`Sa TWaW]Z UWQ]a a]QW]Z UWQ]a âWQ]Z UWQ]a dOZ]`Sa SabOR abWQ]a [cSabÒZSa S``]`Sa Q][SbWR]a OZ [SRW` RSbS`[W\OROa [OU\WbcRSa SbQ 3a RSQW` S\ US\SÒZ QcOZ_cWS` QOÒQbS` abWQO _cS aS ]PbS\UO Q][] ac[O RS [cQV]a TOQb]`Sa /a ^]RS[]a VOPZO` RS TS\ [S\]a µ\]`[OZSa¶ Q][] O_c{ZZ]a _cS SabOR abWQO[S\bS aWUcS\ ZO RWab`WPcQW \ <]`[OZ

$ @]aWbW 4 '& ) µ6Wab]`WO g bS]` O RS ZO 1cZbc`O RS ;OaOa¶ 3R 5cabOd] 5WZW) ^ '$

/ Ô`bW` RS SabS Q]\QS^b] SabOR abWQ] aS`t 2c`YVSW[ _cWS\ VOPZO`t RS Z] \]`[OZ S\ b{`[W\]a RS T`SQcS\QWO Q]\aWRSÒ\R] _cS Sa SaO T`SQcS\QWO ZO _cS STSQbWdO[S\bS ]b]ÙO dOZ]` OZ TS\ [S\] a]QWOZ _cS Oa aS Q][^]`bO :O ^`W\QWÔZ Tc\QW \ RS SabO RWab`WPcQW \ ac QOÒQbS` abWQO Sa _cS `S^`SaS\bO []RSZ]a S\ Z]a _cS Z]a QOa]a aS OQc[cZO\ S\ b]`\] O c\ dOZ]` ZO [SRWO ^]` Z] _cS SZ Q]\QS^b] RS T`SQcS\QWO `SacZbO W\b` \aSQ] O SabS []RSZ]( SfWabS\ ^]aWQW]\Sa S\ ZOa _cS aS aWb O\ ZO [Og]` Ô`bS RS Z]a QOa]a

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

[tfW[O T`SQcS\QWO g O [SRWRO _cS bS OZSXOa RS SaOa ^]aWQW]\Sa ZO T`SQcS\QWO SZ \ [S`] RS QOa]a dO aWS\R] ^`]U`SaWdO[S\bS [S\]` Q]\ c\ ^c\b] RS W\TZSfW \ QZO`] S\ ZO QO RO >]` bO\b] aS`t\ Z]a TS\ [S\]a ^]PZOQW]\OZSa T`SQcS\bSa Z]a _cS aS`t\ Q]\aWRSÒR]a Q][] µ\]`[OZSa¶ O Ô`bW` RS Z]a QcOZSa ^]RS` RSbS`[W\O` ZOa `Sa^SQbWdOa [SRWOa g RSadWOQW]\Sa b ^WQOa 3abS OQS`QO[WS\b] SabOR abWQ] ^S`[WbS `SW\bS`^`SbO` RSbS`[W\OROa QWbOa bSfbcOZSa `SQ]UWROa S\ Z]a U`c^]a RS RWaQcaW \ _cS OZS\bO`]\ SZ W\bS`{a ^]` SZ bS[O RS W\dSabWUOQW \ ^ZO\bSOR] 3\ SZ OTt\ ^]` Sf^ZWQO` ZO T]`[O S\ ZO _cS W\bS`^`SbO` ZO [O\WTSabOQW \ RSZ Ucab] W\RWTS`S\QWOR] g US\SÒZWhOR] S\ O_cSZ QOa] `STS`WR] O [ aWQO Q][] [cSabÒ RS µ\]`[OZWROR¶ [cQV]a Ô`bWQWÔ\bSa XcabWTWQOPO\ RWQV] ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] S\ POaS O []bWd]a `SZObWd]a O ZO T`SQcS\QWO g ^]aWPWZWROR RS SaQcQVO VOPWbcOZ TtQWZ g Q]\abO\bS 3\ RSTW\WbWdO Ucab] µ\]`[OZ¶ Q][] O_c{Z _cS `S^]\RS O TS\ [S\]a Q]bWRWO\]a T`SQcS\bSa g _cS \] `S_cWS`S\ RS \W\U \ SaTcS`h] g ^`SRWa^]aWQW \ Sa^SQWOZ ÔÒ ZZSdO`Z]a O QOP] AOZWàS RS RWQVO RWab`WPcQW \ <]`[OZ aWbcOàS S\ Z]a Sfb`S[]a RS ZO QO[Ô\O bS OZSXO`t\ ^]` bO\b] RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ 3\ ZO Z \SO RS Z] O^c\bOR] ^]` 2c`YVSW[ ZO T`SQcS\QWO RSZ TS\ [S\] ZS ]b]ÙO ac dOZ]` µ>OÒ [ SZ Q]\QS^b] \]`[OZ Sa SZ Q]\QS^b] RS Z] Q]bWRWO\] _cS Sabta S\ QcOZ_cWS` Ô`bS ¥>]` _c{ Z] ZZO[Oa \]`[OZ- >]`_cS Sa Q]bWRWO\] ^]`_cS S\ QcOZ_cWS` Ô`bS _cS dOgOa Z] ^cSRSa ZZSUO` O ] ` AW b dOa O RSaOgc\O` OZ PO` Z] ]gSa) bS [SbSa S\ SZ Q]QVS ^]\Sa ZO ÒRW] g ZO ]WU]) [S d]g O [W QOaO ^]\U] ZO bSZS g XcabO[S\bS aOZS S\ c\ O\c\QW]) Sa] T]`[O Ô`bS RS bc dWRO Q]bWRWO\O gO B \] VOa VSQV] \ORO SfQS^QW]\OZ ÔÒ S\Q]\bÒ`bS Q]\ Sa] 1cO\R] RWU] \]`[OZ \] Sa _cS Q`SO _cS ZO bcgO Sa [OZO \] g] Z] _cS RWU] \]`[OZ Sa _cS d]g O ^]\S` ZO bSZS g O\bSa SabO`t [W QO\QW \ _cS ZO bcgO¶ %

3\ZOhO\R] Q]\ Z]a OÙc[S\b]a SabOR abWQ]a ^S`] RSaRS c\O OaW[WZOQW \ RS Z]a [Wa[]a [ta ]ÙO\WQWabO 1][bS Ob`WPcgS ZO QOÒQbS` abWQO RS µ\]`[OZ¶ O Z] _cS Sa µ\ObcÒZ¶ µTWaW]Z UWQ]¶ SabOPZSQWS\R] c\O RWTS`S\QWO ^`tQbWQO[S\bS QcO\bWbObWdO S\b`S Z]a TS\ [S\]a _cS `Sa^]\RS\ O SaO µ\ObcÒZWROR¶ g O_c{ZZ]a _cS a]\ µÔb]Z UWQ]a¶ >S`] aS`t 5S]ÙSa 1O\UcWZVSW[ _cWS\ \]a TOQWZWbS OZUc\Oa RS ZOa QZOdSa S\ SaO [Wa[O RWTS`S\QWOQW \ S\b`S bOZSa Q]\QS^QW]\Sa RS Z] µ\]`[OZ¶ g Z] µÔb]Z UWQ]¶ 3\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` ^]`_cS aS OZO Z] W[^`SaQW\RWPZS RS ZO ^]ZO`WROR RS c\ TS\ [S\] ÔÒ _cS aS S\bWS\RO\ g bS\UO\ aS\bWR] O[POa QOÒa RS ZO []\SRO RSZ [Wa[]( Z] µ\]`[OZ¶ `S_cWS`S RS Z] µ\] \]`[OZ¶ ] µÔb]Z UWQ]¶ g dWQSdSàO

% µ:O WRS\bWROR XcdS\WZ RSaRS ZOa OTW\WRORSa [caWQOZSa¶ =^ QWb ^tU $% 0O`QSZ]\O U`c^] [Wfb] # ' O ]a

3\ aSUc\R] ZcUO` ^]`_cS SabS ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] RS ZO ^]ZO`WROR RSaQO\aO a]P`S c\O R]PZS Q]\QS^QW \ RS Z] µ\]`[OZ¶ _cS Sa ^`SQWaO[S\bS ZO _cS O^]`bO SZ [ObWh \]dSR]a] S W\bS`SaO\bS( Z] µ\]`[OZ¶ Q][] bW^] _cS `Sa^]\RS O ZO [SRWO SabOR abWQO RS c\ TS\ [S\] RSbS`[W\OR] S\ ZO Z \SO RS ZOa W\bS`^`SbOQW]\Sa [S\QW]\OROa VOabO SZ [][S\b] ^S`] bO[PW{\ Q][] dOZ]` _cS `Sa^]\RS O RSbS`[W\OROa SfWUS\QWOa ] [SbOa Q]ZSQbWdOa O OZQO\hO` >]` bO\b] ZO SfWabS\QWO RS Z] RSaSOPZS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ `S_cWS`S RS ZO ^`SSfWabS\QWO RS Z] W\RSaSOR] _cS VOP`t RS aS` RSXOR] Ob`ta OPO\R]\OR] `SQVOhOR] S\ Tc\QW \ RS c\O RWabW\QW \ Sab{bWQO g []ÒZ _cS dO [ta OZZt RS ZOa RWTS`S\QWOa QcO\bWbObWdOa _cS aS SabOPZSQS\ RSaRS c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO SabOR abWQO S\b`S Z] \]`[OZ g Z] Ôb]Z UWQ] 1]\ SZZ] OR_cWS`S

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

[ObWQSa QcOZWbObWd]a _cS RSXO\ bÒ\aZcQW` `SZOQW]\Sa S W\bSÒQQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa RWU\Oa RS aS` O\OZWhOROa g bS\WROa S\ QcS\bO O ZO V]Ò RS RSaS\bÒ O` Z]a RWaQcà]a OZ `Sa^SQb] &

& 1O\UcWZVS[ 5 '% ) µ:] \]`[OZ g Z] Ôb]Z UWQ]¶) AWUZ] FF7 ' 3Z ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] S\QOXO O ZO ^S`TSQQW \ Q]\ Z]a OÙc[S\b]a RS Z]a X dS\Sa `Sa^SQb] O Z]a QO[PW]a S\ aca Ucab]a S\ [ aWQO ^]` ^]\S` c\ SXS[^Z] RS Z]a SabcRWOR]a _cS Sd]ZcQW]\O\ RSaRS ^]aWQW]\Sa [ta RWTS`S\QWOR]Òa VOQWO ^]aWQW]\Sa [ta W\RWTS`S\QWOROa S W\aS`bOROa S\ ^]abcÒa [OaWdO[S\bS OQS^bOROa( b]R]a Ô`SQS\ VOPS` ÔaOR] ^]` SaOa ^]aWQW]\Sa RWTS`S\QWOR]Òa µ\]`[OZSa¶ S\ [][S\b]a dWbOZSa Q]\Q`Sb]a ^S`] OZ [Wa[] bWS[^] b]R]a OQS^bO\ _cS bOZSa ^]aWQW]\Sa aS RSXO`t\ Ob`ta QcO\R] SZ [][S\b] dWbOZ aSO ]b`] g ^]` bO\b] Z] _cS aS Q]\aWRSÒ Q][] µ\]`[OZ¶ OR_cWSÒ [ObWQSa RWabW\b]a 3\ ZO ^`SSfWabS\QWO RS Sa]a Ucab]a µ\] \]`[OZSa¶ ÔÒ ZOa {^]QOa dWbOZSa VWab `WQOa S\ ZOa _cS aS `SOZWhO\ Z]a XcWQW]a RS dOZ]` S\QcS\bÒ ZO \]`[OZWROR ac Òh \ RS aS` S\ SZ ^`SaS\bS ^]` bO\b]

3\ b{`[W\]a ^`tQbWQ]a SabO[]a S\ Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS Q]\bÒabO` SZ ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] RS 1O\UcWZVS[ S\ [cQV]a RS Z]a SabcRW]a a]P`S VtPWb]a g Ucab]a QcZbcÒZSa g RS ]QW] _cS bWS\S\ O Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa Q][] QS\b`] RS ObS\QW \ 3a Oa ^]`_cS ^]RS[]a Q]\abObO` Q [] SfWabS\ RSbS`[W\OR]a Ucab]a S\ [ aWQO S\ dWRS]XcSU]a S\ ]QW] g RSbS`[W\OR]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RcÒ\bS Z]a TW\Sa RS aS[O\O RcÒ\bS ZO aS[O\O ZOP]ÒZ Q]\ Z]a Ô`Sa _cS aS W\bS`^`SbO`t\ Q][] µ\]`[OZSa¶ O RSbS`[W\OROa SRORSa Q]\ W\RS^S\RS\QWO RS _cS Sab{\ [ta ] [S\]a Q]\\]bOR]a RS T]`[O \SUObWdO ^`SQWaO[S\bS ^]`_cS T]`[O\ Ô`bS RS ZO ^`]^WO Q]\T]`[OQW \ RSZ c\WdSà] aW[P ZWQ] RS Z] _cS aS W\bS`^`SbO Q][] µaS` X]dS\¶ >S`] SZ [Wa[] RWaQcà] ^ZO\bSO Q][] c\O dSh _cS QORO QcOZ dO ac^SÒ\R] ZOa SbOÔa dWbOZSa S\ _cS Sa]a Ucab]a aS W\bS`^`SbO\ Q][] µ\]`[OZSa¶ ZO [O\WTSabOQW \ RS Z]a [Wa[]a VOP`t RS aS` ]bÒ aW aS ^`SbS\RS ÔaO` O T]`[O` Ô`bS RS Z] a]QWOZ[S\bS OQS^bOR] Q][] ^`]QSa] ORSQcOR] RS [ORc`Sh g Q`SQW[WS\b] 3a RSQW` aS Q]\]QS ^S`TSQbO[S\bS ZO ^`SSfWabS\QWO RS Z] _cS \] Sa µ\]`[OZ¶ ÔÒ QORO SROR ^`SQWaO[S\bS ^]`_cS aS VO ÔaOR] ^]` OV O ZO SROR S\ _cS a SÒ µ\]`[OZ¶ Z] QcOZ ^]aWPWZWbO aWbcOàS S\ ZOa ^]aWQW]\Sa _cS a aS Q]\aWRSÒ\ ORSQcOROa ÔÒ ZO SROR ^`SaS\bS G Sa] aW\ ^S`XcWQW] RS _cS S\ SZ Tcbc`] [ta ] [S\]a W\[SRWOb] aS OQS^bS _cS ZOa ^]aWQW]\Sa RSZ ^`SaS\bS ZZSUcS\ O aS` Q]\aWRSÒROa Q][] µ\] \]`[OZSa¶ ÔÒ SZ [][S\b] dWbOZ RSaRS SZ QcOZ aS `SOZWQS\ ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa ' 2SaRS c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO âW_cWtb`WQO S\Q]\bÒ[]a c\ OQS`QO[WS\b] O µZ] \]`[OZ¶ _cS S\ZOhO ^S`TSQbO[S\bS Q]\ ZOa WRSOa O^c\bOROa ^]` 1O\UcWZVS[ /a 4S`\O\R] ÈZdO`Sh C` O VOPZO RS Q [] bOZ RWaQW^ZW\O [{RWQO OZ RWTS`S\QWO` S\b`S Z] \]`[OZ g Z] Ôb]Z UWQ] Z] _cS VOQS Sa ^]\S` S\ SdWRS\QWO SZ ÔaOR] Sf^ZWQO` SZ ^`SaS\bS g ^`]gSQbO` SZ Tcbc`] 3XS`QWQW] ^]` bO\b] RS ]`RS\O[WS\b] RS ^]RS` _cS OaW[WZO Z] µ\]`[OZ¶ O Z] \]`[ObWd] O ZO µ\]`[O¶ S\ ZO Z \SO RS Z]a ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a RS 4]cQOcZb <]`[Oa dWbOZSa g RWaQW^ZW\O`Sa S\ SZ QOa] RS Z]a W\RWdWRc]a g \]`[Oa a]QWOZSa S\ SZ QOa] RS ZOa ^]PZOQW]\Sa 4W\OZ[S\bS g QOaW RS [O\SÒ O\SQR bWQO Oc\_cS \] [S\]a aWU\WTWQObWdO OQcRW` OZ 2WQQW]\O`W] RS ZO @SOZ /QORS[WO 3aÔ ]ZO \]a ^`]^]`QW]\O`t c\O RSTW\WQW \ RS ZO ÔZOPÒ µ\]`[OZ¶ _cS aW`dS Q][] ^S`TSQb] Q][^S\RW] RS UÒ\ Ô`bS RS ZOa WRSOa O^c\bOROa O Ô`bW` RS Z]a ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a RS Z]a Ocb]`Sa QWbOR]a /a a]\ b`Sa ZOa OQS^QW]\Sa RSZ b{`[W\] QORO c\O RS ZOa QcOZSa S\QOXO Q]\ [cQV]a RS Z]a OÙc[S\b]a O^]`bOR]a( µ2 QSaS RS Z] _cS aS VOZZO S\ ac \ObcÒZ SabOR]¶ S\ ZO Z \SO RS 1][bS ) µ?cS aW`dS RS \]`[O ] `SUZO¶ Oc\O\R] Z]a ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a RS 4]cQOcZb Q]\ c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO [ta QS`QO\O O ZO SabOR abWQO Q][] ^cSRS aS` ZO RS 2c`YVSW[ ) ! µ2 QSaS RS Z] _cS ^]` ac \ObcÒZShO T]`[O ] [OU\WbcR aS OXcabO O QWS`bOa \]`[Oa TWXOROa RS O\bS[O\]¶ `SaQObO\R] ZOa ÔZOPÒa RS 1O\UcWZVS[ ] SZ ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] âW_cWtb`WQ] RS ÈZdO`Sh C` O a]P`S ZO ^`SSfWabS\QWO RS Z] _cS \] Sa \]`[OZ

ÈZdO`Sh C` O 4 '&! ) µ;WaS`OPZSa g Z]Q]a¶) Bca_cSba) ^ %

3\ Tc\QW \ RS b]ROa SabOa ^Sà^SQbWdOa RS Z] _cS aWU\WTWQO SZ b{`[W\] µ\]`[OZ¶ _cS \] RSXO\ RS aS` c\O ^S_cS O [cSabÒ RS Z]a [cg RWdSà]a ^c\b]a RS dWabO ^]aWPZSa SabO[]a S\ RWa^]aWQW \ RS VOQS`\]a c\O WRSO RS Q [] ZOa [Wa[Oa bO\b] S\ ZO ^`]^WO RSTW\WQW \ g O\tZWaWa RSZ b{`[W\] Q][]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

S\ ac Q]\bÒ^]aWQW \ Q]\ Z] _cS \] Sa Z] µ\] \]`[OZ¶ Z] µÔb]Z UWQ]¶ SaQ]\RS\ [O\SÒa RS ]`RS\O` g ]ÙO\WhO` ZOa W\bSÒQQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa T]`[Oa [ta ] [S\]a Sf^Z QWbOa RS ^]RS` Oa Q][] \c[S`]a]a SZS[S\b]a _cS Q]\b`WPcgS\ O Q`SO` g `SQ`SO` Z]a RWdSà]a c\WdSà]a aW[P ZWQ]a _cS Q][^]\S\ SZ W[OUW\O`W] Q]ZSQbWd] S\b`S ]bÒa Q]aOa S\ b]`\] O Z]a `WSaU]a

:] µ\]`[OZ¶ S\ ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ RS µZ] X]dS\¶ 1S\bÒ`S[]a \cSab`] W\bS`{a S\ ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS ZO Q]\QS^QW \ RS Z] µ\]`[OZ¶ Q]\b`WPcgS O Q]\T]`[O` Z] _cS a]QWOZ[S\bS aS W\bS`^`SbO Q][] ¶X]dS\¶ >OÒ SZZ] \]a OQS`QO`S[]a O RWQV] ^`]QSa] O bÒd{a RS ZO T]`[O S\ _cS SaS c\WdSà] aW[P ZWQ] aS RWTS`S\QWO RSZ c\WdSà] RS µZ] ORcZb]¶ O ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS acÙS\ ZOa RWTS`S\QWOa RS\b`] RSZ ^`]^W] Q]ZSQbWd] XcdS\WZ g O Q [] b]R] SZZ] aS W\aS`bO g OR_cWS`S aS\bWR] S\ SZ S\bÒ[OR] a]QWOZ

/ 4`S\bS O µZ] ORcZb]¶ 3\ µ:O ^S`QS^QW \ a]QWOZ RS ZOa R`]UOa S\ 3aÔ O "¶ 4/2 " Z]a Ocb]`Sa a]abWS\S\ ZO SfWabS\QWO RS Z] _cS RS\][W\O\ µZSUWbW[WROR dS`bWQOZ¶ `Sa^SQb] O Z]a Q]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa _cS aWb O O Z]a Q]\ac[WR]`Sa S\ ^]aWQW]\Sa RS [Og]` ] [S\]` Q`SRWPWZWROR O ZO V]Ò RS VOPZO` a]P`S RSbS`[W\OROa R`]UOa S\ Tc\QW \ RSZ c\WdSà] aW[P ZWQ] RSaRS SZ _cS `SOZWhO\ ] \] RWQV]a Q]\ac[]a Z]a QcOZSa `Sb`]OZW[S\bO\ ZO ^`]^WO RSTW\WQW \ RS bOZSa c\WdSà]a 3a RSQW` UÒ\ Ô`bS RS Z]a Q]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS Z]a `SZObWd]a OZ QO\\OPWa aS`t\ W\bS`^`SbOR]a Q][] µQ]aO RS X dS\Sa¶ OZU] _cS ZSa aWb O S\ SZ W[OUW\O`W] Q]ZSQbWd] S\ c\O ^]aWQW \ RS ZSUWbW[WROR ÔÒ VOPZO` RS bOZSa Q]\ac[]a Q]\ W\RS^S\RS\QWO RS ZO `SOZWROR QcOZWbObWdO g QcO\bWbObWdO RS Sa]a Q]\ac[]a 4`S\bS O SaO µZSUWbW[WROR dS`bWQOZ¶ bO[PW{\ aS VOPZO RS c\O µZSUWbW[WROR V]`Wh]\bOZ¶ _cS ^`]^WQWO ZOa RWTS`S\QWOQW]\Sa RS\b`] RSZ [Wa[] c\WdSà] aW[P ZWQ]( X dS\Sa Q]\ [Og]` ZSUWbW[WROR ÔÒ VOPZO` RS RSbS`[W\OR]a Q]\ac[]a ^`SQWaO[S\bS ^]` aS` aca ^`]bOU]\WabOa T`S\bS O ]b`]a _cS \] Z] a]\

1][] VS[]a O^c\bOR] gO S\ c\O {^]QO dWbOZ S\ ZO _cS Z]a X dS\Sa \] Ô`SQS\ S\Q]\bÒ` [ta `STS`S\bSa WRS\bWbO`W]a _cS O_c{ZZ]a _cS ZSa aWb O\ S\ SZ QO[W\] _cS ZSa Q]\RcQS VOQWO ZO dWRO ORcZbO Z] _cS ZSa WRS\bWTWQO Q][] X dS\Sa bWS\RS O aWbcOàS [ta S\ SZ bW^] RS Ucab]a g Q]\ac[]a _cS [cSabÒ\ _cS S\ ZO Ocb{\bWQO Oac\QW \ RS c\O aS`WS RS dOZ]`Sa ] ^`W\QW^W]a _cS Uc S\ aca Q]\RcQbOa /Z SabO` TcSÒ RS Z]a dS`RORS`]a t[PWb]a RSQWa]`W]a QO`SQS` RS SaÔQW]a ^`]^W]a g S\Q]\bÒ` UÒ\RSa ^`]PZS[Oa ÔÒ SZOP]Ò` c\ ^`]gSQb] dWbOZ Oac[WPZS g Q`S PZS ^`]PZS[O RS OQQSa] O ZO dWdWS\RO OZOÙO[WS\b] RSZ ^S`W]R] RS T]`[OQW \ OQOR{[WQO ^`SQO`WSROR ZOP]ÒZ a]P`S^`]bSQQW \ RS^S\RS\QWO SQ]\ [WQO a Z] SZ QO`tQbS` Sa^SQ TWQ] RS Z]a Q]\ac[]a Ô`SQS ^`]^WQWO` SZ bW^] RS c\WdSà]a aW[P ZWQ]a _cS aWb O O Z]a X dS\Sa Q][] bOZSa /a SfWabW`t\ Ucab]a g Q]\ac[]a S\ ]QW] S\ `]Ô S\ [ aWQO S\ R`]UOa SbQ SbQ µRS X dS\Sa¶ Q][] ]b`]a aS`t\ µRS ORcZb]a¶ g SZ Ôa] RS c\]a O ]b`]a [O`QO`t g RSTW\W`t RS T]`[O SaS\QWOZ bO\b] Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS Q`SQW[WS\b] g [ORc`Sh Q][] SZ ZcUO` Q]\Q`Sb] _cS QORO QcOZ ]QcÔ S\ RWQV] ^`]QSa]

;SU Oa 3 RW` ) µDOZ]`Sa a]QWOZSa g R`]UOa¶) 4/2

/ Ô`bW` RS c\ aWabS[O RS dOZ]`Sa _cS ^ZO\bSO c\O Q]\Q]`RO\QWO US\SÒZ S\b`S Z]a dOZ]`Sa RS Z]a ORcZb]a g Z]a RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa a SfWabW`t\ [ObWQSa g Ob`WPcQW]\Sa _cS Q]\b`WPcgS\ O Q]\T]`[O` RS T]`[O RWTS`S\QWORO Z]a c\WdSà]a aW[P ZWQ]a _cS RSbS`[W\O\ ZOa RWTS`S\QWOa S\b`S X dS\Sa g ORcZb]a /a RSbS`[W\OR]a dOZ]`Sa a]\ O\OZWhOR]a ^]` SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO a]QWSROR Q][] b ^WQO[S\bS µXcdS\WZSa¶ ^]` c\ ZOR] ^]`_cS aS Q]\abWbcgS\ S\ Ocb{\bWQOa Oa^WÒQW]\Sa RS Z] _cS RSPS` O aS` c\ ] c\O X]dS\ g ^]` ]b`] ZOR] g OZ [Wa[] bWS[^] ^]`_cS S\ a [Wa[]a Q]\ab`cgS\ ZO QObSU]` O µX]dS\¶ DOZ]`Sa Q][] ZO `SPSZR O SZ VSR]\Wa[] ZO a]ZWRO`WROR ZO b]ZSÒ\QWO ZO RWdSàW \ SbQ _cS Q]\ W\RS^S\RS\QWO RS ac dS`RORSÒ Oac\QW \ Z]a ^`]^W]a X dS\Sa bWS\RS\ O `SQVOhO` ZO dOZWRSh RS Z]a [Wa[]a Q][] aS O RS WRS\bWROR US\SÒQW]\OZ Oc\_cS \] \WSUO\ _cS T]`[S\ Ô`bS RS Z]a `STS`S\bSa aW[P ZWQ]a _cS ZSa aWb O\ a]QWOZ[S\bS Q]\b`WPcgS\ O [O\bS\S` S\ S_cWZWP`W] c\ aWabS[O _cS aS Ocb]XcabWTWQO g Ocb]acabS\bO 3a RSQW` aW SfWabS OQcS`R] `Sa^SQb] O ZO WRSO RS _cS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa a]\ VSR]\WabOa `SPSZRSa S W``Sa^]\aOPZSa OZ bWS[^] _cS aS Oac[S _cS S\ ZbW[O W\abO\QWO SZ aWabS[O RS dOZ]`Sa W[^SÒ\bS Sabt [O`QOR] ^]` SZ `c[P] _cS [O`QO\ Z]a ORcZb]a aS W\bS`^`SbO`t Q][] µ\]`[OZ¶ _cS Sa]a [Wa[]a X dS\Sa aS Q][^]`bS\ RS ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS Z] VOQS\ RcÒ\bS ZOa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

\]QVSa RS Z]a TW\Sa RS aS[O\O ^]` SXS[^Z] ^cSa Q]``Sa^]\RS`t O ac Q]\RWQW \ µXcdS\WZ¶) ORS[ta Ô`SQS\ SabO` OP]QOR]a O SZZ] S\ Tc\QW \ RS c\ aWabS[O _cS aWb O bOZSa Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a Q][] \ObcÒZSa []RSZ]a Oa^WÒQW]\OZSa 3dWRS\bS[S\bS Sab] W\TZcgS RS T]`[O SaS\QWOZ S\ ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa a]P`S Z]a `WSaU]a _cS \] a Z] aS`t\ ]PaS`dOR]a RSaRS ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO _cS ^cRW{Ò[]a ZZO[O` [ta µaO\WbO`WO¶ ] `SZOQW]\ORO Q]\ ZO aOZcR Tc\RO[S\bOZ[S\bS RSaRS Z]a ORcZb]a ^cSa ÔaO`t O T]`[O` Ô`bS RS Z] _cS aS S\bWS\RS Q][] W\SdWbOPZS g \SQSaO`W] \] a Z] ÔÒ ^`]QcÒ` c\O ORSQcORO W\bSUÒQW \ aW \] ÔÒ Q][^]\S` S\ a [Wa[] SZ Q]\QS^b] RS µZ] X]dS\¶ /a aWUcWS\R] Q]\ SZ SXS[^Z] SZ X]dS\ _cS \] aOZUO _cS \] bÒa\]QVS _cS \] VOUO µP]bSZZ \¶ ^cSRS ZZSUO` O aS` Q]\aWRSÒR] Q][] µÒ`]¶ ^cSa ac Q][^]`bO[WS\b] \] aS`t µ\]`[OZ¶ S\ Tc\QW \ RS Z] _cS aS Sa^SÒ RS c\ X]dS\ RS Z] _cS aS W\bS`^`SbO _cS Sa µaS` X]dS\¶ 3\b]\QSa SZ aWabS[O aS [O\bWS\S S\ c\ S_cWZWP`W] ^S`TSQb] _cS ORS[ta Sf^S`W[S\bO c\ ^`]QSa] RS W\dSàW \ [cg W\bS`SaO\bS( aS W\bS`^`SbO Q][] µ\]`[OZ¶ _cS c\ X]dS\ aS Q][^]`bS RS T]`[O W``Sa^]\aOPZS ^]`_cS O ZO Q]\RWQW \ XcdS\WZ aS Ob`WPcgS c\O \ObcÒZ OcaS\QWO RS `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR OZ bWS[^] _cS Z]a ORcZb]a bWS\RS\ O Ocb]QcZÔPWZWhOàS ^]` aS` `Sa^]\aOPZSa RS c\ aWabS[O RS dOZ]`Sa S\ SZ _cS ^`W[O SZ W\RWdWRcOZWa[] g SZ Q]\ac[Wa[] >]` ]bÒ Ô`bS SZ VSQV] RS _cS b]R]a aSÔ\ QctZSa a]\ Z]a dOZ]`Sa µQ]``SQb]a¶ a]ZWRO`WROR b]ZSÒ\QWO Q]\ W\RS^S\RS\QWO RS ac Ocb{\bWQO Oac\QW \ ObS[^SÒ QcOZ_cWS` ^]aWPWZWROR RS _cWSPÒ b]bOZ µ³ 3Z ^`]PZS[O Sa _cS QcO\R] b S`Sa [Og]` b a aOPSa RWabW\UcW` Z] _cS Sabt PWS\ g Z] _cS \] Sabt PWS\ ^S`] QcO\R] S`Sa X]dS\ ] OR]ZSaQS\bS g] Q`S] _cS \] ³ :]a _cS aS SfQSRS\ a]\ Z]a \W ]a ^S`] ZOa QcZÔPZSa a][]a \]a]bÒa¶ !

! ;OR`WR U`c^] [Wfb] " ## O ]a 1WbO `SQ]UWRO Q][] ZO aWUcWS\bS S\ SZ aS\] RS c\O W\dSabWUOQW \ QcOZWbObWdO a]P`S SZ bS[O RSZ µP]bSZZ \¶ g Z]a Q]\TZWQb]a _cS ]QOaW]\O\ Z]a []RSZ]a RS RWdSàW \ \]Qbc`\O RS [cQV]a X dS\Sa @]R` UcSh 3) g ;SU Oa 7 ) ¶3ab`cQbcÒ g Tc\QW]\OZWROR RS ZOa T]`[Oa RS RWdSàW \ \]Qbc`\O( : [WbSa g Q]\TZWQb]a¶) S\ :O \]QVS( c\ Q]\TZWQb] RS ^]RS`) @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a 2S 8cdS\bcR \ #") 7<8CD3) >

3dWRS\bS[S\bS `SacZbO b`S[S\RO[S\bS Q []R] dSàS W\abOZOR] S\ c\O ^]aWQW \ RS OPa]ZcbO RSa`Sa^]\aOPWZWhOQW \ ^]` ZO _cS SZ W[OUW\O`W] Q]ZSQbWd] Oac[S Q][] µ\]`[OZ¶ µ\ObcÒZ¶ _cS ^]` aS` X]dS\ bS Q][^]`bSa RS ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS Z] VOQSa 1cO\R] aSOa [Og]` Q`ShQOa [ORc`Sa bc c\WdSà] aW[P ZWQ] aS`t ]b`] g ÔaO`ta O Q][^]`bO`bS RS ]bÒ [O\SÒ 6OabO S\b]\QSa b]R]a Ô`SQS\ OQS^bO` _cS bS Q][^]`bSa RS ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS Z] VOQSa 3a ZO ]bÒ QOÒ RS ZO bÒRWQW]\OZ Sf^`SaW \ µQcO\R] aSOa [Og]` Q][S`ta VcSd]a¶( QcO\R] aSOa [Og]` bS\R`ta QOÔQWROR RS SZSUW` Ocb]\][ O `Sa^]\aOPWZWRORSa [WS\bÒa bO\b] RWaT`cbO ORSQcORO[S\bS RS bc µW``Sa^]\aOPWZWROR¶ µ³ >cSa a Sa QWS`b] a][]a c\]a UcO``]a ³ 1ZO`] Oa SfWabS SZ bÒPOX] RS PO``S\RS`] ¥\]³ ASUc`] _cS SZZ]a \] ^WS\aO\ WUcOZ ³ >S`] dO[]a ¥_cW{\ Sa SZ PO``S\RS`] O_c - ¥SZZ]a ] g]- ^cSa QcO\R] g] aSO PO``S\RS`] gO [S _cSXO`{ ¶ "

" ;OR`WR U`c^] [Wfb] $ & O ]a =^ QWb ) ^ #

3\ Tc\QW \ RS SabS `SÔ`b] a]QWOZ RS `]ZSa SZ S\bÒ[OR] aW[P ZWQ] _cSRO ^S`TSQbO[S\bS S_cWZWPÒR] g b]R]a Ô`SQS\ aOPS` R \RS g Q [] aWbcOàS ÔÒ _cS ac Q][^]`bO[WS\b] S\QOXS Q]\ Z] _cS aS Sa^SÒ RS ac Q]\RWQW \ RS X]dS\ ] RS ORcZb] ;WS\bÒa ZO RWTS`S\QWOQW \ W\RWdWRcOZ ^S`bS\ShQO OZ t[PWb] RS Z] ^`WdOR] b]R]a a][]a RWTS`S\bSa ^S`] ZO [O\WTSabOQW \ ^ PZWQO bWS\RO O ZO W\RWTS`S\QWOQW \ g ZO V][]US\SWhOQW \ b]R]a a][]a WUcOZSa SZ ^c\b] \Scb`] aS`t SZ _cS RSbS`[W\S Z] a]QWOZ[S\bS OQS^bOPZS G

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

QcO\R] SZ S_cWZWP`W] S\b`S Z]a c\WdSà]a aW[P ZWQ]a _cS Q][^]\S\ µZ] X]dS\¶ g µZ] ORcZb]¶ OZW[S\bO bOZ bS\RS\QWO g RSTW\S Z]a Z [WbSa a]QWOZ[S\bS OQS^bOPZSa RS Z]a [Wa[]a ZO \WQO ^`S]QcÔQW \ RS QORO QcOZ VOP`t RS aS` Q][^]`bOàS RS [O\SÒ µ\]`[OZ¶) Sa RSQW` aW\ aOZWàS RS Z] _cS aS ^`Sac^]\S RS bc Q]\RWQW \ g aW\ aWbcOàS S\ ^]aWQW]\Sa _cS ^]aWPWZWbS\ WRS\bWTWQOQW]\Sa SfQSaWdO[S\bS TcS`bSa ÔÒ bW ] ÔÒ Z]a bcg]a

0 4`S\bS O Z]a ^`]^W]a X dS\Sa /Z Oac[W` g OZW\SOàS S\ SZ []RSZ] RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ RS ZO V][]US\SWhOQW \ _cS OQS^bO ZO µ\]`[O¶ W[^SÒ\bS Q][] [cSabÒ RS Z] a]QWOZ[S\bS RSaSOPZS S\ ZO Z \SO RS Z]a ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a RS 1O\UcWZVS[ Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa _cS Oa Z] VOQS\ ^`]gSQbO\ Z]a SabS`S]bW^]a _cS `S^`SaS\bO\ b]ROa ZOa Q]aOa _cS O \ ^S`bS\SQWS\R] OZ c\WdSà] RS µZ] X]dS\¶ S\ SZ W[OUW\O`W] Q]ZSQbWd] aW[P]ZWhO\ b]R] O_cSZZ] \SUObWdO[S\bS Q]\\]bOR] QcO\R] [S\]a S\ Tc\QW \ RS RSbS`[W\OR] ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] RS Z] _cS RSPS aS` c\ ^`]QSa] RS Sd]ZcQW \ g [ORcÒQW \ ^Sà]\OZ µ\]`[OZ¶ 3a RSQW` `STZSXO\ Z]a []RSZ]a RS Z] _cS aS W\bS`^`SbO Q][] \] RSaSOR] T`S\bS O ZO RSaSORO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ ÔÒ RSbS`[W\OROa SRORSa ^]` `S^`SaS\bO` ZOh]a WRS\bWTWQObWd]a bO\ TcS`bSa g QZO`]a _cS OZSXO\ O _cWS\ S\ SZZ]a aS `SQ]\]QS RS ZO RSaSORO W\RWTS`S\QWOQW \ S\ SZ aS\] RS ZO UÒ\ [OaO b]R]a a][]a WUcOZSa >]` bO\b] a]\ ]b`]a _cWS\Sa aS aWb O\ OZ [OÙS\ RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ g RSZ []RSZ] \] a Z] RSaSOR] aW\] ORSQcOR] :O aW[^ZS Q]\abObOQW \ RS _cS c\] [Wa[] \] T]`[O Ô`bS RS Sa]a Q]ZSQbWd]a aWbcOR]a OZ [OÙS\ RS Z] OQS^bOPZS Q][] µ\]`[OZ¶ bS aWbcO`t S\ SZ aS\] RS SaO [Wa[O µ\]`[OZWROR¶ /a ^`]gSQbO\R] Z]a SabS`S]bW^]a aW\ Oac[W`Z]a Q][] ^`]^W]a a]\ µ]b`]a¶ Q]\TW`[O\ ac dOZWRSh g ]^SÒbWdWROR a]QWOZ 3Z RWaQcà] ^ZO\bSO R]a aWbcOQW]\Sa _cS Tc\QW]\O\ Q][] QOÒa ]^cSabOa RS ZO [Wa[O []\SRO bO\ Q][^ZS[S\bO`WOa _cS aS VOQS\ W[^`SaQW\RWPZSa ÔÒ OR_cW`W` aS\bWR] RS \cSd] OaWabW[]a O ZO [S\QW]\ORO ^]ZO`WROR S\b`S Z] µ\]`[OZ¶ g Z] µÔb]Z UWQ]¶ ] µ\] \]`[OZ¶ >]` c\ ZOR] _cWS\Sa aS W\aS`bO\ S\ SZ ^ZO\] W\RWTS`S\QWOR] RS ZO UÒ\ [OaO a]QWOZ S\QcS\bÒ\ S\ Z]a [tÙS\Sa RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ S\ ZO _cS aS aWb O\ O_cSZZ]a SZS[S\b]a O Ô`bW` RS Z]a QcOZSa XcabWTWQO\ ac ORaQ`W^QW \ a]g µ\]`[OZ¶ ^]`_cS \] a]g µÒ`]¶ >]` ]b`] ZOR] ZOa ^Sà]\Oa _cS RS T]`[O Q]\aQWS\bS g d]Zc\bO`WO aS aWb O\ S\ Sa]a [Wa[]a [tÙS\Sa RS Z] a]QWOZ[S\bS OQS^bOPZS S\QcS\bÒ\ S\ ac ^]aWQW \ [W\]`WbO`WO g RWTS`S\QWOR]Ò SZ OaWRS`] WRS\bWTWQObWd] [ta TcS`bS g _cS S\ [Og]` [SRWRO Q][^]\S ac WRS\bWROR Q][] W\RWdWRc]a ] U`c^]a 2cÒ\bS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g ^`W[SÒ XcdS\bcR ZOa WRS\bWRORSa aS Q]\ab`cgS\ [ta ^]` `SQ`SOQW \ _cS ^]` dS`RORSÒ Oac\QW \ RS Z]a dOZ]`Sa ] ^`W\QW^W]a _cS Q][^]\S\ SZ U`c^] RS Ô`Sa OUZcbW\OR]a S\ b]`\] O RSbS`[W\OROa OTW\WRORSa SZSQbWdOa _cS RO\ ZcUO` O c\O a]ZWRO`WROR [SQt\WQO _cS \] ]Ùt\WQO 3a RSQW` S\ SZ U`c^] aS PcaQO `STcUW] S\ [][S\b]a dWbOZSa RS W\RSTW\WQW \ >`SQWaO[S\bS ^]` SZZ] ^]` ZO Oac\QW \ US\SÒZ RS _cS ZO XcdS\bcR Sa c\ SabOR] ZW[W\OZ RS b`t\aWb] aS OQS^bO Q][] µ\]`[OZ¶ ZO bÒdSa O ^Sà]\OZ _cS ac^]\S SZ dWOXS S\b`S RWdSàOa WRS\bWRORSa _cS O \ `SacZbO\R] W[^]`bO\bSa S\ QORO [][S\b] dWbOZ Q]\Q`Sb] aS dO\ RSXO\R] Ob`ta S\ Tc\QW \ RS c\ ^`]QSa] RS [ORc`Sh _cS aS W\bS`^`SbO W\SdWbOPZS /a SaOa WRS\bWRORSa ]`WUW\OROa ^]` ZOa OTW\WRORSa SZSQbWdOa( S\ [ aWQO S\ `]Ô S\

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

]QW] S\ VtPWb]a SbQ aS OPO\R]\O\ Q]\ ZO [Wa[O TOQWZWROR Q]\ ZO _cS aS OR_cW`WS`]\ ^`SQWaO[S\bS ^]`_cS Z] µ\]`[OZ¶ aS`t OPO\R]\O`ZOa QcO\R] RSXS\ RS aS` Tc\QW]\OZSa ÔaO\R] O `S^`SaS\bO` SabOR]a RS W\[ORc`Sh ] µ\] \]`[OZWROR¶ _cS \] S\QOXO\ Q]\ Z] _cS Q]``Sa^]\RS OZ [][S\b] dWbOZ Q]\Q`Sb] 3Z QO[W\] ORS[ta RS aS` ^S`TSQbO[S\bS Oac[WPZS S\ Z] _cS ^cSRS ZZSUO` O bS\S` RS QO]a S W\RSTW\WQW \ ^Sà]\OZ aS W\bS`^`SbO Q][] W\SdWbOPZS( OZ TW\OZ RSZ [Wa[] aS S\QcS\bÒ ZO RSaSORO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ SZ `STcUW] RSTW\WbWd] S\ SZ [ta UÒ\RS RS Z]a U`c^]a µG] Sa _cS VS VSQV] QO[PW]a RS Z] [ta ÒRWQOZ 2S W`[S RS Z] [ta UcO``] RS Z] UcO``] O W`[S O Z] [ta ^WX] RS Z] ^WX] :cSU] OZ QOP] RSZ bWS[^] Z] ^WS\aOa g RWQSa dOgO QO[PW] _cS VS [SbWR] G OV]Ò ^cSa OV]Ò [S ORO^b] O b]R] c\ ^]Q] BS\U] _cS W`[S O_c ^cSa [WÒ [S UcabO`t [ta ] [S\]a ^S`] [S d]g ¶ #

1 g S\ ^Sà^SQbWdO /Z ^ZO\bSO` c\ RWaQcà] Q][] SZ _cS \]a ]QcÔ _cS O Ô`bW` RS Z]a SabcRW]a a]QW]Z UWQ]a g QcZbcÒZSa RS Z]a ZbW[]a O ]a Ô`SQS XcabWTWQOPZS QcO\R] [S\]a S\ Z] _cS aS `STWS`S O ZO Q]\abObOQW \ RS c\O bS\RS\QWO S[SÙS\bS S\ SZ W[OUW\O`W] Q]ZSQbWd] QOPS ^`SUc\bOàS ^]` ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS VO Sd]ZcQW]\OR] RWQV] RWaQcà] S\ SZ aS\] RS ZOa ZbW[Oa US\SÒQW]\Sa RS X dS\Sa ¥3\ _c{ [][S\b] Q][S\h O S[SÙS` RWQV] RWaQcà] `SZObWd] O ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶- ¥>]` _c{- ¥1 [] VO dO`WOR] ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS SZ [Wa[] OZW[S\bO ZO T]`[O S\ _cS aS W\bS`^`SbO RSTW\S g `SQ`SO SZ c\WdSà] RS µZ] X]dS\¶- ¥3abO[]a S\T]QO\R] SZ ]PXSbWd] ORSQcOR]- AW\ RSXO` RS bS\S` ^`SaS\bSa SabOa ^`SUc\bOa Ô`SQS SdWRS\bS _cS ac `Sa^cSabO `S_cWS`S RS W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa [ta O[PWQW]aOa g ÔcaOROa _cS SZ OQS`QO[WS\b] _cS ac^]\S SabS SaQ`Wb] S\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` aS` O \SQSaO`W] OQ][SbS` c\ O\tZWaWa RSZ S\bÒ[OR] a]QW]SQ]\ [WQ] _cS QOÒQbS`WhO Z]a QO[PW]a a]QWOZSa RS ZOa ZbW[Oa R{QOROa ^]` SXS[^Z] 3\ QcOZ_cWS` QOa] ^]RS[]a RSXO` OZUc\Oa ^W\QSZOROa O []R] RS VW^ bSaWa ^WabOa O aSUcW`

# 0O`QSZ]\O U`c^] [Wfb] " O ]a µ:O WRS\bWROR XcdS\WZ ¶) =^ QWb ) ^ "

>O`SQS SdWRS\bS _cS VS[]a OaWabWR] O c\ ^`]QSa] S\ _cS ZOa RWTS`S\bSa US\SÒQW]\Sa RS X dS\Sa VO\ Sf^S`W[S\bOR] QO[PW]a aWU\WTWQObWd]a S\ Z] _cS `Sa^SQbO O aca ÔcbOa ORaQ`W^bWdOa S WRS\bWbO`WOa / Z]a WZcaW]\O\bSa O ]a aSaS\bO [][S\b] S\ _cS acÙWS`]\ RWdSà]a []dW[WS\b]a Q]\bÒQcZbcÒZSa _cS ^`SbS\R O\ acPdS`bW` [cQV]a `RS\Sa W[^SÒ\bSa aWUcWS`]\ c\]a O ]a RS RSaS\QO\b] g POXORO O ZO `SOZWROR RcÒ\bS ZO R{QORO RS Z]a aSbS\bO _cS RSaS[P]QO`]\ S\ Z] _cS aS RW] O Q]\]QS` Q][] OQbWbcRSa µÔa]bOa¶ RS Z]a X dS\Sa RS Z]a ]QVS\bO ;ta OZZt RS _cS aSO\ ] \] QWS`bOa ZOa bS]` Oa a]QW]Z UWQOa _cS RSTWS\RS\ _cS VWab `WQO[S\bS SfWabS c\O bS\RS\QWO Q`]\]Z UWQO O ZO OZbS`\O\QWO S\b`S OQbWbcRSa RS `SPSZR O g RS W\bSUÒQW \ ] Q]\aS`dORc`Wa[] Sa [ta _cS ^`]POPZS _cS S\ bOZSa OQbWbcRSa RSTW\WROa Q][] µÔa]bOa¶ aS S\QcS\b`S SZ US`[S\ RS ZOa ^`]gSQQW]\Sa _cS RS`WdO\ S\ ZO W[OUS\ _cS aS bWS\S RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa V]g S\ R O 7[OUS\ [cg OZSXORO RSZ Sa^ `Wbc `SPSZRS g Q]\bSabObO`W] Q]\ SZ _cS aS WRS\bWTWQO O Z]a O ]a aSaS\bO g ^]` SZZ] Z UWQO[S\bS OaS\bOR] S\ SZ Sa^ `Wbc RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ g ZO W\RWTS`S\QWOQW \ _cS QS\bÒ \cSab`] W\bS`{a <] Ô`SQS SfbÒ ] ^cSa aWUcWS\R] SabS VWZ] OÙc[S\bOZ _cS Z]a SabcRW]a a]QW]Z UWQ]a g Z]a OQS`QO[WS\b]a W\abWbcQW]\OZSa g OQOR{[WQ]a O ZO `SOZWROR

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

XcdS\WZ dS\UO\ QS\bÒ\R] ac W\bS`{a S\ Z]a ZbW[]a O ]a S\ b]R]a O_cSZZ]a bS[Oa _cS ^`SbS\RS\ RSaS\bÒ O` SaOa ^]aWQW]\Sa aWbcOROa O Z]a [tÙS\Sa RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ ^`SQWaO[S\bS ÔÒ ^`]QcÒ` _cS Z]a X dS\Sa SabcRWOR]a SdWbS\ SaOa [Wa[Oa ^]aWQW]\Sa( R`]UOa b`WPca c`PO\Oa [OÙW\OQW \ S[POÒh]a \] RSaSOR]a SbQ SbQ 1][] _cSR RWQV] O\bS`W]`[S\bS SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO a]QWSROR Ô`SQS aOPS` QctZSa a]\ Z]a dOZ]`Sa _cS RSPS\ Q]``Sa^]\RS` OZ Sa^ `Wbc X]dS\ `SPSZR O Q`SObWdWROR W[OUW\OQW \ S\ ZO Z \SO RS Z]a aSaS\bO ^S`] OZ [Wa[] bWS[^] Oac[S aW\ _cSXO QctZSa a]\ Z]a dOZ]`Sa _cS `SacZbO\ ]^SÒbWd]a S\ SZ Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ _cS bWS\S\ _cS dWdW` OQbcOZ[S\bS Q][^SbWbWdWROR W\RWdWRcOZWa[] SbQ 1][^`S\RS` SZ ^`]QSa] ^]` SZ QctZ aS ^`]RcQS ZO Sd]ZcQW \ S\ SZ aWabS[O RS dOZ]`Sa bS\R`t [cQV] _cS dS` Q]\ ^S`QWPW` ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS ZO bS]` O RS ZO \]`[OZWROR aS W\aS`bO S\ SZ [Wa[] S\ SabS QOa] QS\bÒ\R] ZO ObS\QW \ S\ SZ aSQb]` ^]PZOQW]\OZ [ta X]dS\

$ :]hO\] 8 '' ) µ¥2S _c{ VOPZO[]a QcO\R] VOPZO[]a RS Z]a X dS\Sa-¶) S\ eee TSa^W\OZ Q][ ^ &

C\O RS ZOa ^`W\QWÔZSa Òh]\Sa RS ZOa RWTS`S\QWOa SfWabS\bSa S\b`S ZO Q]\QS^QW \ RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa S\ {^]QOa Q][] Z]a O ]a aSaS\bO `Sa^SQb] O ZO OQbcOZWROR ^`]POPZS[S\bS RSaQO\aS S\ SZ VSQV] RS _cS S\b]\QSa SÒ c\ Q]ZSQbWd] _cS O\aWOPO Ocb]OTW`[OàS S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ Q]\bÒRWQb]`W] [WS\bÒa S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR OaWabW[]a O c\O aWbcOQW \ S\ ZO _cS Q]\ W\RS^S\RS\QWO RS ZOa Z UWQOa bS\aW]\Sa _cS ^cSRS\ US\SÒ` c\WdSà]a aW[P ZWQ]a RWTS`S\bSa µZ] X]dS\¶ T`S\bS O µZ] ORcZb]¶ b]R]a Z]a OUS\bSa a]QWOZSa Ô`SQS\ RSaS[^S O` ac Ô^SZ RS bOZ [O\SÒ _cS SZ aWabS[O aS [O\bWS\S S\ S_cWZWP`W] 3fWabS\ Q]\TZWQb]a ^S`] aS Oac[S\ Q][] µ\]`[OZSa¶ S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ W\RWdWRcOZWabO Q]\ac[WabO ^ÒU[tbWQ] g RS `SZObWdWa[] []ÒZ 1][] aS OZO 8]aS^ ; :]hO\] µV]g Z]a X dS\Sa [ta _cS dWdW` c\O aWbcOQW \ RS Q`WaWa ] RS RSaSab`cQbcÒQW \ Ô`SQS\ O Sab`cQbcÒR]a AW\ WRS\bWRORSa \W `STS`S\QWOa QZOÒa g RWabW\bOa g Q]\ ZO bÒ\_cWZO OQS^bOQW \ RS _cWS\ \] Z] dWdS Q][] c\O ^{`RWRO aW\] Q][] ac \]`[OZWROR dWbOZ¶ $ 2S Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa aS Sa^SÒ _cS aS Q][^]`bS\ Q][] Z] VOQS\ RS ZO [Wa[O [O\SÒ _cS aS Sa^SÒ _cS RSXS\ RS VOQS`Z] QcO\R] µ[ORc`S\¶ g RS Z]a ORcZb]a aS Sa^SÒ OQbWbcR Q` bWQO Ocb]`Sa^]\aOPWZWhOQW \ g S\ ZbW[O W\abO\QWO `SaWU\OQW \ 3\ Q]\Xc\b] bOZ S_cWZWP`W] Tc\QW]\O O []R] RS ^`]TSQ O Ocb]Qc[^ZWRO G \] Sa _cS Z]a X dS\Sa RS V]g S\ R O \] \SQSaWbS\ Ocb]OTW`[OàS Q][] aca ÔR`Sa S\ ac R O ^S`] Z] QWS`b] Sa _cS SZ dOZ]` RS ZO acPdSàW \ ZO `SPSZR O g ZO RWTS`S\QWOQW \ `SacZbO`t RWT QWZ[S\bS RSTW\WPZS W\QZca] WRS\bWTWQOPZS QcO\R] Z]a Z [WbSa a]\ bO\ RWTca]a _cS Ô`SQS\ T]`[O` Ô`bS RSZ ^`]^W] aWabS[O S\ S_cWZWP`W]( ^S_cS Oa R]aWa RS XcdS\WZ S W\]TS\aWdO `SPSZR O Oac[WPZSa ^]` QcO\b] Sabt\ Q][^ZSbO[S\bS OZSXOROa RS Z]a dS`RORS`]a t[PWb]a RS RSQWaW \ \] ac^]\S\ [ta _cS bS[^]ÒZSa g ST [SÒa Q]\_cWabOa g ^]` b]R] SZZ] [O\bWS\S\ SZ S_cWZWP`W] ORSQcOR] _cS Q][^]\S SZ S\bÒ[OR] a]QWOZ µ\]`[OZWhOR]¶ %

% >OÒ SXS[^ZWTWQO` SabO aWbcOQW \ ^]RS[]a OQcRW` O µ:O \]QVS( c\ Q]\TZWQb] RS ^]RS`¶ \ #" RS ZO @SdWabO RS 3abcRW]a 2S 8cdS\bcR 7<8CD3 R]\RS Z]a Ocb]`Sa Sf^ZWQO\ O ^`]^ aWb] RS ZO ^]Z{[WQO acÙWRO S\ b]`\] O Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa ]QOaW]\OR]a ^]` SZ µP]bSZZ \¶ Q][] Z]a ORcZb]a Oac[S\ ZO Q]\_cWabO SaÔQWOZ g bS[^]ÒZ _cS ac^]\S SZ [Wa[] X dS\Sa _cS aS µO^`]^WO\¶ RS RSbS`[W\OROa ^ZOhOa g QOZZSa RcÒ\bS ZOa \]QVSa RS Z]a TW\Sa RS aS[O\O ^`SQWaO[S\bS ^]` ac QO`tQbS` ST [S`]( b]RO dSh _cS ZO Q]\_cWabO b]QO O ac TW\ S\ ZO [O O\O RSZ R][W\U] SZ aWabS[O `Sb]`\O O ac S_cWZWP`W] ]`WUW\O`W] g Z]a bS``Wb]`W]a dcSZdS\ O [O\]a RS aca µRcS ]a¶ Z]a ORcZb]a g O aca Tc\QW]\Sa \ObcÒZSa bÒPOX] g dWdWS\RO VOabO SZ dWS`\Sa aWUcWS\bS

2S WUcOZ [O\SÒ SaS QZO`] g S_cWZWPÒR] `SÔ`b] RS `]ZSa ^`]^WQWO c\ OQ][]RO[WS\b] S W\[]dWZWa[] bOZ _cS QcSabW]\Sa _cS S\ ]bÒa {^]QOa ^]R` O\ aS` Q]\aWRSÒROa Q][] SZS[S\b]a _cS S\U`]aO\ SZ RSPS RS ZO Q]\RWQW \ XcdS\WZ aS Ob`WPcgS\ O ZOa ^`]^WOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa RS ZO a]QWSROR S\ Q]\Xc\b] OZ aWabS[O RS dOZ]`Sa W[^SÒ\bS ] W\QZca] O QcSabW]\Sa RS ]`RS\ Sab`cQbcÒZ RS [O\SÒ _cS SZ ^]aWPZS aS\bW[WS\b] RS QcZÔ aS RWZcgS <]a `STS`W[]a ^]` SXS[^Z] O ZO Q]ZSQbWdO g QOaW ^S`S\\S Oac\QW \ RS OaWabW` O c\O US\SÒQW \ RS X dS\Sa ÔaWd]a RSaQ][^`][SbWR]a W\Q]\abO\bSa g SaQOaO[S\bS Ô`bWQWÔbWd]a <] _cS`S[]a RSQW` _cS bOZ

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

dWaW \ Q]``Sa^]\RO O ZO `SOZWROR RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa RS \cSab`] Ô a ^S`] a _cS SZ VSQV] RS _cS SZ W[OUW\O`W] Q]ZSQbWd] OZW[S\bS ZO W\SdWbOPWZWROR g QOaW ZO \SQSaWROR S\ POaS O Z] _cS aS` O\ Z]a dOZ]`Sa `SOZ[S\bS µ]^SÒbWd]a¶ S\ c\O a]QWSROR Sfb`S[ORO[S\bS Q][^SbWbWdO S W\RWdWRcOZWabO RS bOZ aWbcOQW \ Q]\b`WPcgS O S\U`]aO` ZOa TWZOa RS _cWS\Sa Oa aS Q][^]`bO\ _cS S\Q]\bÒ`t\ `STcUW] S\b`S ZO Q][^`S\aW \ US\SÒZ( µ¦g Q [] dO\ O aS` aW Z]a VS[]a VSQV] Oa ¶ >]` ]b`] ZOR] OQS^bO` aS` Ô`bS W\bSUÒ\bS g OQbWdO RS c\O a]QWSROR Q]\ac[WabO g Q][^SbWbWdO Q]\RcQS O _cS Q][] gO aS OZO[]a UÒ\ Ô`bS RS Z]a [SQO\Wa[]a RS Ocb]OTW`[OQW \ g ORaQ`W^QW \ aS ZZSdS\ O QOP] O Ô`bW` RSZ Q]\ac[] W\QZcgS\R] Z]a Q]\ac[]a _cS ^]R` O[]a Q]\aWRSÒ` µRS `WSaU]¶ Q][] ZOa R`]UOa AS Q]\ac[S\ ^`]RcQb]a []RSZ]a aWU\]a _cS a]\ [ta _cS Sa]) a]\ Ocb{\bWQ]a `STS`S\bSa ORaQ`W^bWd]a S WRS\bWbO`W]a _cS bS aWb O\ g bS VOQS\ ^S`bS\SQS` O c\ µ\]a]b`]a¶ RS ZO [Wa[O [O\SÒ _cS aS OZO O µZ]a ]b`]a¶ 3Z OÙc[S\b] S\QOXO O ZO ^S`TSQQW \ Q]\ ZO [SbtT]Ò RS ZO P` XcZO g SZ ÒRO` cbWZWhORO ÔÒ aWU\WTWQO` OZUc\O RS ZOa ^`W\QWÔZSa RWTS`S\QWOa O^`SQWOPZSa S\b`S SZ Sa^ `Wbc XcdS\WZ RS Z]a O ]a aSaS\bO g SZ OQbcOZ( [WS\bÒa O\bSa UcWOPO\ ac QO[W\] VOQWO ZO dWRO ORcZbO OgcRt\R]aS RS c\O P` XcZO O Ô`bW` RS ZO QcOZ WPO\ `SQbWTWQO\R] g Q]``WUWS\R] ZOa Q]]`RS\OROa _cS RSTW\ O\ ac ^`]^WO ^]aWQW \ S\ RWQV] QO[W\] OQbcOZ[S\bS Z] VOQS\ Q]\ c\ ÒRO` _cS RSbS`[W\O ZO ^]aWQW \ _cS ]QcÔ\ S\ `SZOQW \ O _cWS\Sa ZSa `]RSO\) S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZO ^]aWQW \ RS Z]a RS[ta QORO QcOZ W`t Q]``WUWS\R] ZO ^`]^WO ;WS\bÒa OQbcOZ[S\bS Z]a aWU\]a g a [P]Z]a _cS ^`]^]`QW]\O\ Z]a Q]\ac[]a Z]a Ucab]a g Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RSTW\W`t\ bc ^]aWQW \ `Sa^SQb] OZ `Sab] RS ÒRO`Sa [O\SXOàS Q]\ P` XcZO \] `S_cWS`S Q]\]QS` ZO ^]aWQW \ RS Z]a RS[ta aW\] Q]\]QS` QctZ Sa SZ <]`bS g QctZ Sa SZ QO[W\] _cS aS _cWS`S bÒhO` S\ Tc\QW \ RS SaS <]`bS /a @]abW aWUcWS\R] O /ZOW\ B]cÒW\S aS OZO _cS Z]a X dS\Sa RS Z]a O ]a aSaS\bO aS QOÒQbS`WhO`]\ µ^]` c\O P a_cSRO RS WRS\bWROR [cg ^]Q] S\ QO[PW] ^]` c\O RSTW\WQW \ RSZ ORdSàO`W] g \ORO S\ OPa]Zcb] ^]` c\O RW`SQQW \ SabÒb{UWQO RSabW\ORO O W\RWdWRcO` Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS VSUS[]\ O a]QWOZ g RS `SOZWhOQW \ Q]ZSQbWdO¶ & 3a RSQW` ZO P` XcZO T`S\bS OZ ÒRO`

& @]aWbW 4 '& ) µ6Wab]`WO g bS]` O RS ZO 1cZbc`O RS ;OaOa¶ 3R 5cabOd] 5WZW) ^

3abS bS `WQ] S_cWZWP`W] a]QWOZ S\ SZ _cS b]R]a Ô`SQS\ Q][Ô`bW` c\ [Wa[] g OQS^bOR] aWabS[O RS dOZ]`Sa ^cSRS Sf^ZWQO` ]b`] RS Z]a []bWd]a _cS acabS\bS\ ZO bS\RS\QWO O ZO W\RWTS`S\QWOQW \ RS ZOa X dS\Sa US\SÒQW]\Sa Q][] `STZSX] RSZ Sa^ `Wbc a]QWOZ W[^SÒ\bS 3a Oa ^]`_cS Ô`SQS ^`]RcQWàS c\O W\dSàW \ aW[P ZWQO S\b`S ZO OaW[WZOQW \ RS RWQV] aWabS[O RS dOZ]`Sa ^ZOUOR] RS ^`W\QW^W]a W\bS`^`SbOR]a bO\ W\SdWbOPZSa Q][] ^S`\WQW]a]a W\RWdWRcOZWa[] Q]\ac[Wa[] SU] a[] Q][^SbWbWdWROR g c\O OQbWbcR ^Sà]\OZ _cS bÒbO RS OZSXOàS RS ^]aWQW]\O[WS\b]a _cS ^cRWSÒ\ S\QOaWZZO`bS S\ ^]abcÒa OZSXOROa RS Z]a dOZ]`Sa PWS\^S\aO\bSa g ^]Z bWQO[S\bS Q]``SQb]a _cS ]QcÔ\ c\ ZcUO` ^`WdWZSUWOR] S\ ZOa Oa^WÒQW]\Sa RSZ W[OUW\O`W] Q]ZSQbWd] ZO b]ZSÒ\QWO g ZO a]ZWRO`WROR ^`W\QWÔZ[S\bS 3a RSQW` aW b]R]a aOPS[]a _cS SZ Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ Sa W\RWdWRcOZWabO _cS \W\Uc\] RS [Wa Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a Ucab]a ] [O\WTSabOQW]\Sa RSZObS _cS g] ^cSRO OZW\SO`[S S\ Tc\QW \ RS bOZSa dOZ]`Sa G S\ bOZ OTt\ ^]` RSaZWUOàS RS ^]aWQW]\Sa µW\RSaSOPZSa¶ OZSXOROa RS ZO µ\]`[O¶ a]QWOZ ZO bS\RS\QWO [Og]`WbO`WO Òab`SO SZ ^]Z] ]^cSab]( aW ZO a]QWSROR Sa W\RWdWRcOZWabO OQS^bS[]a OQbWbcRSa OZbO[S\bS U`cÔZWabOa 3\ SZ aS\] RS ZO UÒ\ [OaO b]R]a a][]a WUcOZSa µ\]`[OZSa¶

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

:O W[^]`bO\QWO RSZ U`c^]( W\bSUÒQW \ SfQZcaW \ g `WSaU] 4`S\bS O ZO TO[WZWO g ZO SaQcSZO SfWabS c\ W[^]`bO\bS bS``S\] RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ W\T]`[OZ S\ SZ _cS Z]a X dS\Sa aS S\QcS\bÒ\ Q]\ Z]a Ô`Sa g Q][WS\hO\ O Sf^S`W[S\bO` W\RWdWRcOZ g U`cÔZ[S\bS Q]\ ZOa Q]aOa S\ b]`\] O ZOa QcOZSa O^c\bOZO`t\ ac WRS\bWROR g aS aWbcO`t\ S\ SZ QO[W\] RS ac [ORc`Sh G RcÒ\bS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g ^`W[SÒ XcdS\bcR SaO a]QWOZWhOQW \ W\T]`[OZ bWS\S ZcUO` S\ SZ bWS[^] RS ]QW] g S\ b]`\] O Z]a Ô`Sa BWS[^] _cS VOQS\ ^`]^W] g dSRO\ O W\XS`S\QWOa SfbS`\Oa RS Z]a ORcZb]a _cS `S^`SaS\bO\ TWUcÒa RS Ocb]`WROR OÔ`S\bS[S\bS OZSXOROa RS ZOa W\_cWSbcRSa g ^`S]QcÔQW]\Sa RS Z]a X dS\Sa g _cS OR_cWS`S c\O W[^]`bO\QWO QZOdS Q][] Sa^SX] `STS`S\bS g PO\Q] RS ^`cSPOa RS ZO dWRO S\ a]QWSROR BS``S\] ^]` bO\b] S\ SZ _cS ^]\S\ S\ ^`tQbWQO ZO POaS RS Z]a dOZ]`Sa g ^`W\QW^W]a `SQWPWRO S\ TO[WZWO g SaQcSZO g S\ SZ _cS S\bÒ\ S\ Q]\bOQb] Q]\ b]ROa O_cSZZOa Q]aOa RS ZO µdWRO `SOZ¶ _cS aS SaQOÔ\ RS ZO Xc`WaRWQQW \ g SZ Q]\b`]Z RS Z]a OUS\bSa T]`[OZSa BS``S\] _cS ^]` bO\b] Sa W\acabWbcWPZS g _cS aS Q]\abWbcgS S\ SZ QS\b`] RS W\bS`{a g ObS\QW \ RcÒ\bS Z]a O ]a S\ Z]a _cS Z]a X dS\Sa \] bWS\S\ [cQV]a [ta OaWRS`]a RS WRS\bWTWQOQW \ / [SRWRO _cS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa Q`SQS\ g S\QcS\bÒ\ ]bÒa W\_cWSbcRSa g ]b`]a `STS`S\bSa RS WRS\bWTWQOQW \ Q][^ZSbO` Z]a SabcRW]a bÒPOXO` S[Ô`SXOàS SabOPZSQS` RSbS`[W\OR]a ^`]gSQb]a dWbOZSa bOZ ]QW] QcO\R] [S\]a Oa S\bS\RWR] W`t ^S`RWS\R] ac QS\bÒZWROR Q][] [SRW] RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ g O^`S\RWhOXS ;WS\bÒa Z]a ORcZb]a `S^`SaS\bO\ c\O bÒ\a[WaW \ RS dOZ]`Sa g ^`W\QW^W]a dS`bWQOZ g OZSXORO RSZ c\WdSà] aW[P ZWQ] RS Z]a X dS\Sa µ_c{ [S dO O S\aS O` RS R`]UOa RS aSf] RS [ aWQO SbQ aW Sa [Og]` g \] aOPS Q [] S\bS\RS[]a g \]a `SZOQW]\O[]a Q]\ bOZSa SZS[S\b]a ¶ SZ U`c^] RS Ô`Sa `S^`SaS\bO c\O bÒ\a[WaW \ V]`Wh]\bOZ RS WUcOZ O WUcOZ _cS Ô`bS RS aW[WZO`Sa RcROa g aS\aOQW]\Sa g _cS ^]` b]R] SZZ] aS S\bWS\RS QS`QO\O /a \] `SacZbO SfbÒ ] SaQcQVO` Q [] Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa bWS\RS\ O aS OZO` O aca O[WU]a g Q]\]QWR]a Q][] ^`W\QWÔZ TcS\bS RS W\T]`[OQW \ g Q]\aSX] `Sa^SQb] O bS[Oa Q][] Z]a _cS ^cSRS\ aS` Q]\aWRSÒR]a `WSaU]a 3\ bS[Oa Q][] SZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa ] ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa ZO O^`]POQW \ g SZ SXS[^Z] RSZ U`c^] `SacZbO\ Oa^SQb]a SaS\QWOZSa _cS RSbS`[W\O\ S\ PcS\O [SRWRO [cQVOa RS ZOa T]`[Oa S\ _cS c\ OR]ZSaQS\bS ^cSRS S\bÒ` S\ Q]\bOQb] Q]\ RSbS`[W\OROa acabO\QWOa ] VtPWb]a >]` SXS[^Z] `Sa^SQb] O ZO SROR RS W\WQWO` ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa g RS _c{ [O\SÒ ] Q [] O\OZWhO` ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa S\b`S U{\S`]a ] dOZ]`Sa Q][] ZO TWRSZWROR ] `Sa^SQb] OZ bW^] RS acabO\QWOa _cS aS ^cSRS\ g RSPS\ ^`]PO` g Z]a Z [WbSa RS Z] b]ZSÒPZS g RSZ Q]\b`]Z :O W[^]`bO\QWO dWS\S RORO a]P`S b]R] ^]` Z] `SZSdO\bS _cS `SacZbO ZO W\bSUÒQW \ S\ SZ U`c^] Q][] ^ZObOT]`[O PtaWQO RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ O RSbS`[W\OROa SRORSa >]`_cS RS ZO [Wa[O [O\SÒ _cS ^cSRS `S^`SaS\bO` c\] RS Z]a [ta W[^]`bO\bSa O^]g]a g `STcS`h]a S\ O ]a Q]\dcZa]a SZ U`c^] bO[PW{\ ^cSRS Q]\abWbcWàS S\ c\] RS Z]a OUS\bSa RS QS\acÒ g [OÙW\OQW \ [ta W[^]`bO\bSa 6OQS` Z] _cS b]R]a g b]ROa VOQS\ b][O` Z] _cS b]R]a g b]ROa b][O\ bS\S` Z]a Ucab]a _cS b]R]a g b]ROa bWS\S\ S\ SZ U`c^] ^cSRS ZZSUO` O Q]\abWbcWàS S\ c\] RS Z]a [ta W[^]`bO\bSa _cSPÒRS`]a RS QOPShO ÔÒ SdWbO` aS\bWàS OÔ`bOR] ] OÔ`bORO [OÙW\OR] ] [OÙW\ORO µÒ`]¶ ] µÒÒ¶ >O`SQS SdWRS\bS ZO W[^]`bO\QWO _cS Sab] OR_cWS`S O ZO V]Ò RS S\T`S\bOàS O Q]\RcQbOa RS [Og]` ] [S\]` `WSaU] ] O^`S\RWhOXS g a]\ QZtaWQ]a Z]a

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

OÙc[S\b]a RS OR]ZSaQS\bSa _cS S[^ShO`]\ O PSPS` ] Tc[O` µ^]`_cS b]R] SZ [c\R] Z] VOQ O¶ ^]` ^]\S` c\ SXS[^Z] >`SQWaO[S\bS Z]a [Wa[]a RWaQcà]a bWS\RS\ O aS OZO` Q][] c\O RS ZOa [ta W[^]`bO\bSa ^`cSPOa RS [ORc`Sh SZ VSQV] RS RSaZWUOàS RSZ ^]RS` g ZO W\TZcS\QWO RSZ U`c^] g OR]^bO` RSQWaW]\Sa _cS W\QZca] Q]\bÒRWQS\ ZO bS\RS\QWO [Og]`WbO`WO RS Z]a Ô`Sa 7\RS^S\RWS\bS[S\bS RS _cS ZO UÒ\ [Og]` O RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa bS\UO\ ZO SROR _cS bS\UO\ Oac[O\ _cS ^]aSS\ SaO QOÔQWROR RS b][O` RSQWaW]\Sa OZ [OÙS\ RSZ U`c^] Z] QWS`b] Sa _cS Sa Q][ \ aS OZO` Q [] O\bS`W]`[S\bS S\ {^]QOa ÔaOROa \]bO`]\ RS T]`[O QZOÒ ZO ^`SaW \ RS ORO^bOàS g aSUcW` SZ Ôa] _cS [O`QO SZ U`c^] 3a S\b]\QSa QcO\R] OÔ`SQS Z] _cS ^]RS[]a S\bS\RS` Q][] SZ `WSaU] RS µaS` Ò`]¶ ] µaS` ÒÒ¶ _cS S\QOXO S\ Z]a [SQO\Wa[]a ^]` Z]a _cS Oac[W` `WSaU]a T]`[O Ô`bS RS ZO SZSQQW \ a]P`S RSaQO`bO` ]b`]a `WSaU]a S\ SabS QOa] SZ RS ZO SfQZcaW \ RSZ U`c^] RS Ô`Sa 2cÒ\bS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g ^`W[SÒ XcdS\bcR a]P`S b]R] Z]a O[WU]a g O[WUOa acSZS\ aWbcOàS ^]` S\QW[O RS ZO TO[WZWO Q][] TWUcÒa RS `STS`S\QWO g O^]g] S\ POaS O Z]a SZS[S\b]a gO [S\QW]\OR]a 3\ QcOZ_cWS` QOa] bOZ O[WabOR \] VO RS SabO` \SQSaO`WO[S\bS S\QcORÒRO S\ SZ U`c^] RS `STS`S\QWO aSU \ Q]\bSfb]a ^]`_cS SfWabS\ RWTS`S\bSa \WdSZSa RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ /a SZ U`c^] Q]\ SZ _cS aS aOZS Z]a TW\Sa RS aS[O\O ^cSRS SabO` [Og]`WbO`WO[S\bS Q][^cSab] ^]` Q]\]QWR]a ] µQ]ZSUOa¶ Q][] Z]a RS\][W\O\ Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa ^Sà]\Oa Q]\ ZOa _cS aS ÔaO c\ bWS[^] RS ]QW] g RWdSàW \ ^S`] _cWhta Q]\ ZOa _cS \] aS QcS\bO ÔÒ bS[Oa [ta µaS`W]a¶ 3abO RWTS`S\QWOQW \ \]a ^S`[WbS dWaZc[PÒ` ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS aS SabOPZSQS\ [][S\b]a ÔÒ VOPZO` RS ZOa Q]aOa µW[^]`bO\bSa¶ g [][S\b]a ÔÒ RWdS`bWàS [O`QOR]a ^]` c\O O[PWS\bS g c\O OQbWbcR [ta RSaS\TORORO g ^]` [][S\b]a [S\]a `Sa^]\aOPZS g µaS`WO¶ ;][S\b]a S\ Z]a _cS Ô`SQS\ _cSRO` S\ aca^S\a] ZOa ^`S]QcÔQW]\Sa g ^`]PZS[Oa g S\ Z]a _cS SZ bW^] RS `SZOQW]\Sa Ô`SQS\ aS` [ta µac^S`TWQWOZSa¶ g TZSfWPZSa Sa VOPWbcOZ aOZW` Q]\ c\ U`c^] g OZbS`\O`Z] O Z] ZOÙ] RS c\O [Wa[O \]QVS( a{ Q]\ _cW{\ aOZU] ^S`] \] Q]\ _cWS\ `SU`Sa] ' ;][S\b]a S\ Z]a _cS bWS\S\ ZcUO` ZOa Q]\RcQbOa VOPWbcOZ[S\bS Q]\aWRSÒROa Q][] RS `WSaU] 3\ QcOZ_cWS` QOa] SZ VSQV] RS aS OZO` _cS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa _cS aS SabOPZSQS\ S\ SZ bWS[^] RS ]QW] bWS\RS\ O aS` S\QcORÒROa S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] RS TWSabO g OcaS\QWO RS µaS`WSROR¶ \] VO RS `SabO` W[^]`bO\QWO O ZOa RW\t[WQOa RS `SZOQW \ U`cÔZ _cS bWS\S\ ZcUO` S\ SZ ]QW] Q][] SZS[S\b] PtaWQ] RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa a]P`S b]R] RS [S\]` SROR O [SRWRO _cS Q`SQS\ dO\ S\Q]\bÒ\R] RWTS`S\bSa Q]\bSfb]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ g SZ ]QW] ^WS`RS Ô`bS RS ac W[^]`bO\QWO QS\bÒZ 3a Oa ^]`_cS µaOZW`¶ aS Q]\abWbcgS S\ c\ Ocb{\bWQ] OQb] a]QWOZ _cS bWS\S [ta aS\bWR] Q][] SfQcaO ÔÒ SabO` Q]\ O[WU]a g Q]\]QWR]a g ÔÒ Q]\]QS` US\bS _cS Q][] Q]\bSfb] _cS ^SàWUcS SZ Q]\ac[] RS OZQ]V]Z c ]bÒa acabO\QWOa ^]` ^]\S` c\ SXS[^Z] 3dWRS\bS[S\bS Sab]a SZS[S\b]a bO[PW{\ [O`QO\ RS T]`[O SaS\QWOZ SZ RSdS\W` RS ZOa \]QVSa g ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS aS SabOPZSQS\ ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa ^S`] aWS[^`S Q][] Oa^SQb]a aOb{ZWbSa OZ \ QZS] QS\bÒZ RS ZOa [Wa[Oa( SZ Q]\bOQb] S\b`S WUcOZSa

' @]R` UcSh 3) ;SU Oa 7) At\QVSh 3 ) µ8 dS\Sa g `SZOQW]\Sa U`c^OZSa¶ 4/2 7<8CD3

/ Ô`bW` RS SaS Q]\bOQb] S\ c\ SaÔQW] ^`]^W] ] O^`]^WOR] aS O^`S\RS`t\ ZOa ^`W[SÒa ZSQQW]\Sa RS ZO dWRO S\ a]QWSROR g RS Z]a [SQO\Wa[]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ RS [O\SÒ Ocb \][O S W\RS^S\RWS\bS Oc\_cS bOZ Ocb]\][ O S W\RS^S\RS\QWO aSO T`tUWZ g bS[^]ÒZ 3a RSQW` _cS \]a S\Q]\bÒ[]a O\bS ZO ^`W[SÒ dSh S\ ZO dWRO RS Sab]a g SabOa X dS\Sa S\ _cS OQb O\ aW\ ZO ac^S`dWaW \ g SZ Q]\b`]Z RS aca ORcZb]a g

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

^`]POPZS[S\bS ZO ^`W[S`O dSh S\ _cS ^]` SZZ] aWS\bO\ ZZSdO` ZOa `WS\ROa RS aca OQb]a 2S OV ac `SZSdO\QWO O ^SaO` ] _cWhta RSPWR] O SZZ] RS _cS S\ bOZSa Q]\bSfb]a bO[PW{\ aS S\QcS\b`S\ RSbS`[W\OR]a `WSaU]a Q]\ Z]a _cS VO\ RS O^`S\RS` O ZWRWO` aW\ [ta O`[Oa _cS ZO SRcQOQW \ T]`[OQW \ S W\T]`[OQW \ OR_cW`WRO ^`SdWO[S\bS

/ []R] RS Q]\QZcaW \ B]R]a Z]a Oa^SQb]a OP]`ROR]a VOabO SZ [][S\b] \]a ^`]^]`QW]\O\ c\O WRSO RS Q [] SZ Q]\QS^b] RS Z] µ\]`[OZ¶ Q]\b`WPcgS O RSbS`[W\O` c\ bS``S\] RS XcSU] _cS RS c\] c ]b`] []R] [O`QO Z]a Z [WbSa g ZOa `SUZOa RS ZOa W\bSÒQQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa BS``S\] RS XcSU] S\ SZ _cS bS\R`t\ QOPWRO Z]a XcWQW]a RS dOZ]` ZO [O\WTSabOQW \ RS Z]a Ucab]a ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa a]P`S Z]a `WSaU]a g SZ aS\bWR] S\ _cS aS W\bS`^`SbO\ G ^]` ac^cSab] bS``S\] RS XcSU] Q]\ c\Oa [SRWROa RSbS`[W\OROa _cS \] Q]\dWS\S `SPOaO` aW \] _cWS`Sa aWbcO`bS S\ SZ ^ZO\] RS ZO RWaS\aW \ _cS ac^]\S ac^SÒ` Z]a Z [WbSa RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ 2S Z]a Z [WbSa ÔÒ TcSÒ QcOZ_cWS` ^]aWQW \ ]QcÔRO SabO`t ZSX]a RS ZOa \]`[Oa W[^Z QWbO[S\bS SabOPZSQWROa g aS Q]\abWbcW`t S\ WRS\bWRORSa TtQWZ[S\bS SabS`S]bWÔPZSa g a]QWOZ[S\bS QS\acÒPZSa :] W\bS`SaO\bS Sa ]PaS`dO` Q [] RWQV] bS``S\] RS XcSU] [O`QO RS T]`[O Tc\RO[S\bOZ SZ aS\bWR] RS [cQV]a dOZ]`Sa _cS RSbS`[W\O\ ZO dWRO S\ a]QWSROR 3a^SQWOZ[S\bS aWU\WTWQObWd] Sa SZ QOa] RSZ dOZ]` b]ZSÒ\QWO _cS OR_cWS`S c\ aWU\WTWQOR] POabO\bS Q]\Q`Sb] B]ZSÒ\QWO _cS OPO`QO`t VOabO SZ Z [WbS RS Z] ^`]^W] _cS \] Sa ]b`] _cS SZ Z [WbS _cS [O`QO SZ QO[^] RS Z] µ\]`[OZ¶ RS Z] OQS^bOPZS >]` bO\b] RS WUcOZ [O\SÒ _cS \] aS`t \SQSaO`W] b]ZSÒ` O_cSZZ] _cS aS aWb S [ta OZZt RS Z]a Z [WbSa RS RWQV] bS``S\] RS XcSU] a]QWOZ a aS b]ZSÒ`t Z] _cS aS S\QcS\b`S RS\b`] RS SaS bS``S\] RS XcSU] ^cSa aS`t µ\]`[OZ¶ G SabO Q]\aWRSÒQW \ `SacZbO SaS\QWOZ ÔÒ S\bS\RS` SZ aS\bWR] S\ SZ _cS OZUc\]a `WSaU]a ^cSRS\ aS` W\bS`^`SbOR]a ^]` Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa( aS`t\ µ\]`[OZ¶ Oac[W` OZUc\]a Q][] `Sa^cSabO O c\O {^]QO dWbOZ W\Q]\aQWS\bS S W\[ORcÒ g RSXO`t RS aS`Z] QcO\R] aS S\bÒ S\ SZ [c\R] RS µZ] ORcZb]¶ RS ZO [ORc`Sh 3\ RSTW\WbWdO aS b]ZSÒ Z] gO OQS^bOR] RS O\bS[O\] Q][] Oac[WPZS ^]` [cQV] _cS Z]a Z [WbSa aSO\ Z] acTWQWS\bS[S\bS O[^ZW]a Q][] ÔÒ OPO`QO` ^]aWQW]\O[WS\b]a POabO\bS VSbS`]U{\S]a( aW Sabta S\ Z]a [tÙS\Sa RS Z] a]QWOZ[S\bS Oac[WPZS aW Sabta OZ [OÙS\ RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ bS S\Q]\bÒ`ta TcSÒ RS Z]a Z [WbSa RS Z] US\SÒZ[S\bS b]ZSÒPZS g Q]``Sa SZ µ`WSaU]¶ RS _cSRO` SfQZcWR] /ZU] aW[WZO` ]Qc``S Q]\ ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS aS W\bS`^`SbO\ Z]a dOZ]`Sa _cS bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ ZO µ[ORc`Sh¶ bO\ W[^]`bO\bS O ZO V]Ò RS XcabWTWQO` Q [] Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa dO\ OPO\R]\O\R] RSbS`[W\OROa ^]aWQW]\Sa ÔÒ W\aS`bOàS S\ ZO RSaSORO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ 3a Oa ^]`_cS ZO [ORc`Sh aS W\bS`^`SbO Q][] c\ QO[W\] RS RW`SQQW \ \WQO _cS ^cSRS Ô`SQS` ÔÒR XWQ] Q]\aWabS S\ OPO\R]\O` ZOh]a WRS\bWTWQObWd]a RWTS`S\QWOR]`Sa ÔÒ OPÒhO` ZO W\RWTS`S\QWOQW \ ZO V][]US\SWhOQW \ Q][] SbOÔ TW\OZ RSZ ^`]QSa] RS RSaO``]ZZ] g Q`SQW[WS\b] ^Sà]\OZ 3a RSQW` [ORc`Sh Q][] QO[W\] ^]` SZ _cS aS OPO\R]\O\ ZOa ^]aWQW]\Sa [ta ^Sà]\OZSa S W\RWdWRcOZWabOa ÔÒ ZZSUO` O bS\S` Ucab]a ]^W\W]\Sa XcWQW]a RS dOZ]` Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a _cS a]\ Z]a RS b]R]a Z]a RS ZO UÒ\ [OaO W\RWTS`S\QWORO 3Z ^`]QSa] Oa RSaQ`Wb] ^]R` O aS` bOQVOR] RS aW[^ZWTWQOR]` ^S`] aS [cSabÒ Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS Q`cR] g aWU\WTWQObWd] QcO\R] O RSbS`[W\OROa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

SRORSa Z]a X dS\Sa [ta [Og]`Sa ] Z]a ORcZb]a [cSabÒ\ OPWS`bO[S\bS ^]aWQW]\Sa d]Zc\bO`WO[S\bS RWTS`S\QWOR]Òa _cS a]QWOZ[S\bS \] Q]``Sa^]\RS\ Q]\ Z] _cS aS Sa^SÒ g ^`Sac^]\S RS ac SROR g RS ac ^`]QSa] RS [ORc`Sh 3\b]\QSa bOZSa ^Sà]\Oa ]QcÔ`t\ Z]a [tÙS\Sa [ta TtQWZ[S\bS SbW_cSbOPZSa g SabWU[ObWhOPZSa ^]` SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO a]QWSROR µ\]`[OZ¶ 3Z ^`]PZS[O dWS\S QcO\R] SabOa aWbcOQW]\Sa _cS `Sa^]\RS\ O RW\t[WQOa a]QWOZSa [ta ] [S\]a OaW[WZOPZSa RS`WdO\ S\ ^`]QSa]a ^]` Z]a QcOZSa bWS\RS\ O W\abWbcQW]\OZWhOàS ZOa W\bS`^`SbOQW]\Sa [ta W\bS`SaOROa S WRS]Z]UWhOROa RS ZOa [Wa[Oa O []R] RS ^S\aO[WS\b] \WQ] 3a S\b]\QSa QcO\R] ZO O^`]^WOQW \ RS Z] a]QWOZ[S\bS OQS^bOPZS aS VOQS [ta ÔbS\bS g ^`S]QcÔ\bS ^]` Ô`bS RSZ ^]RS` ^]Z bWQ] SQ]\ [WQ] QcZbcÒZ SbQ _cS bÒbO RS ^S`^SbcOàS S\ ac aWbcOQW \ dS\bOX]aO O POaS RS VOQSàS Q]\ ZO ÔbS\bS RS Z] _cS Sa µ\]`[OZ¶ g OQS^bOPZS RS Z] _cS Sabt PWS\ Z] _cS Sabt [OZ g Z] _cS \] aS ^cSRS ^S`[WbW` AcSZS aS` c\ ZcUO` Q][ \ OTW`[O` _cS SZ ^]RS` Sa Q]\aS`dOR]` ^]` \ObcÒZShO g S\ ZO QOÔQWROR RS RSTW\W` g O^`]^WOàS RS Z]a Z [WbSa RSZ bS``S\] RS XcSU] S\Q]\bÒ`t ac [SX]` O`[O 3dWRS\bS[S\bS QORO aWbcOQW \ US]^]Z bWQO Q]\Q`SbO g QORO [][S\b] VWab `WQ] RSbS`[W\O`t ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS aca TcS`hOa RS ^]RS` bÒbO\ RS O^`]^WOàS RSZ aS\bWR] RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ _cS [ta Q]\dWS\S O aca W\bS`SaSa g [SX]` S\QOXO\ Q]\ ac WRS]Z]U O _cS bO[^]Q] OZQO\hO`t SZ [Wa[] UÒR] RS W\bS\aWROR \W aS`t WUcOZ[S\bS ^`S]QcÔ\bS S\ b]R]a Z]a ZcUO`Sa RSZ ^ZO\SbO [cQV]a TOQb]`Sa S\bÒ\ S\ XcSU]( aWabS[O ^]Z bWQ] SQ]\][ O `SZOQW]\Sa W\bS`\OQW]\OZSa SbQ 3\ QcOZ_cWS` QOa] a Ô`SQS QZO`] _cS ZOa Q]``WS\bSa UZ]POZWhOR]Òa Ô`SQS\ SabO` a][SbWROa O c\O TcS`bS ^`SaW \ RS ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa RS ^]RS` _cS bÒbO\ RS UZ]POZWhO` ^`SQWaO[S\bS SaO acS`bS RS ^S\aO[WS\b] \WQ] _cS ZOa a]abWS\S S\ ac ^]aWQW \ RS ^`WdWZSUW] :O Q]\abObOQW \ RS bOZ Sfb`S[] aS S\QcS\bÒ S\ ZO POaS RS OQbcOQW \ RS Z]a Q`SQWS\bSa []dW[WS\b]a QWcRORO\]a O\bWUZ]POZWhOQW \ QZO`] Sf^]\S\bS RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa _cS d]Zc\bO`WO[S\bS aS aWb O\ OZ [OÙS\ RS Z]a Z [WbSa RS ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ W\abWbcQW]\OZWhORO DOZUO c\ SXS[^Z] RS Q [] SZ Q]\QS^b] RS Z] µ\]`[OZ¶ aS W\aS`bO S\ \cSabÒ dWRO ^]Z bWQO g Q]bWRWO\O QOÙt\R]aS RS c\ Q]\bS\WR] WRS]Z UWQ] [cg Q]\Q`Sb] Q]\ ]PXSbWd]a [cg RSbS`[W\OR]a 3Z " RS OP`WZ RS ! SZ Sf ^`SaWRS\bS RSZ U]PWS`\] 8]a{ ;O` O /h\O` ^`]\c\QWOPO c\O Q]\TS`S\QWO S\ ZO Tc\ROQW \ 4/3A POX] SZ b bcZ] µ3Z Tcbc`] RS 3aÔ O S\ SZ FFD O\WdSàO`W] RS ZO 1]\abWbcQW \¶ _cS Q][S\hOPO Q]\ ZOa aWUcWS\bSa ÔZOPÒa( µ:O 1]\abWbcQW \ g SZ SaTcS`h] RS b]R]a RcÒ\bS Sab]a O ]a \]a VO ^S`[WbWR] OZQO\hO` SfOQbO[S\bS O_cSZZ] _cS TcS W[^]aWPZS RcÒ\bS b]ROa ZOa R{QOROa ^`SQSRS\bSa ;S `STWS`] O ZO \]`[OZWROR :O RSaSORO Q]\RWQW \ RS aS` c\ Ô a \]`[OZ C\ Ô a _cS \] bWS\S _cS QO[W\O` QORO R O ^]` SZ TWZ] RS ZO \OdOXO ^S`] _cS bO[PW{\ RSPS aS` Q]\aQWS\bS RS _cS ac SabObca RS \]`[OZWROR ZS S\T`S\bO O \cSdOa `SOZWRORSa g ZS US\SÒ \cSd]a ^`]PZS[Oa O Z]a _cS RSPS RO` `Sa^cSabO 6]g _cWS`] `SWdW\RWQO` SaO \]`[OZWROR RS 3aÔ O g dW\QcZO`ZO Sf^`SaO[S\bS OZ {fWb] Q]\abWbcQW]\OZ g OZ SaTcS`h] RS R]a ] b`Sa US\SÒQW]\Sa RS SaÔ ]ZSa G OZ [Wa[] bWS[^] _cWS`] aS OZO` _cS SZ VSQV] RS aS` c\O RS[]QÒQWO \]`[OZ ^ZO\bSO c\O ^S`[O\S\bS SfWUS\QWO RS Q]\bW\cWROR S\ ZO bO`SO OZ bWS[^] _cS ZO d]Zc\bOR TW`[S g aS`S\O RS VOQS` T`S\bS O `Sb]a _cS VOabO OV]Ò \]a Ô`SQ O\ ZSXO\]a ] OXS\]a ¶

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

/ Q]\bW\cOQW \ SZ RWaQcà] RSaUÒ\OPO QW\Q] ^c\b]a O Ô`bW` RS Z]a QcOZSa VOQS` T`S\bS O ZO µbO`SO¶ RS OaS\bO` ZO O\aWORO µ\]`[OZWROR¶) O aOPS`( OTWO\hO` ZO SabOPWZWROR RSZ aWabS[O W\abWbcQW]\OZ T]`bOZSQS` ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa ORSQcO` ZO [O\SÒ RS SabO` S\ SZ SaQS\O`W] W\bS`\OQW]\OZ ^`]Tc\RWhO` S\ SZ RW\O[Wa[] SQ]\ [WQ] g OQS`bO` S\ ZOa `Sa^cSabOa O ZOa \cSdOa \SQSaWRORSa g `SOZWRORSa a]QWOZSa >O`SQS SdWRS\bS _cS bOZSa ^c\b]a \] `SacZbO\ QOacOZSa ^]` `Sa^]\RS` O QcSabW]\Sa RS ^`]Tc\R] QOZOR] ^]Z bWQ] S WRS]Z UWQ] _cS SabOPO\ RS ^ZS\O OQbcOZWROR S\ SZ [][S\b] g S\ SZ Q]\bSfb] S\ SZ _cS aS ^`]\c\QWOPO\ SabOa ÔZOPÒa( S\ ZO [O\SÒ RS RO` Ocb{\bWQ] Q]\bS\WR] ^]Z bWQ] O Z]a [Wa[]a Sa RSQW` OZ bW^] RS Q]aOa a]P`S ZOa _cS OaS\bO` ZO µ\]`[OZWROR¶ RS ZO \OQW \ SaÔ ]ZO S\Q]\bÒ`S[]a ZOa QZOdSa RS ZO O^`]^WOQW \ RSZ Q]\QS^b] _cS b]R]a ^SàWUcS\ 3abO[]a ^]` bO\b] O\bS c\ SXS[^Z] RS Q [] SaS Q]\QS^b] RS µZ] \]`[OZ¶ SaQ]\RS UÒ\RSa Q][^]\S\bSa WRS]Z UWQ]a _cS bÒbO\ RS ]`RS\O` ZO dWRO S\ a]QWSROR \]`[ObWdWhO` ZOa Q]\RcQbOa g RSa\WdSZO` S\ c\] c ]b`] aS\bWR] ZO POZO\hO RSZ ^]RS` 2S QcOZ_cWS` []R] Z] _cS SabO[]a S\ Q]\RWQW \ RS ^ZO\bSO` Q][] QO[^] RS SabcRW] O Ô`bW` RS Z] RSaQ`Wb] S\ SabOa ^tUW\Oa Sa SZ W\bS`SaO\bS g SaS\QWOZ ^`]QSa] ÔÒ S\bS\RS` \cSabÒ dWRO S\ Q][ \ ^]` SZ QcOZ SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO a]QWSROR ^`]gSQbO c\O aS`WS RS SabS`S]bW^]a a]P`S µZ] \]`[OZ¶ S\ µZ] X]dS\¶ Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa Oac[S\ g Q]\TW`[O\ Sa]a [Wa[]a SabS`S]bW^]a O Ô`bW` RS QWS`bOa RW\t[WQOa RS V][]US\SWhOQW \ S W\RWTS`S\QWOQW \ QcZbcÒZ g Z]a UÒ\RSa [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQW \ W\T]`[OQW \ g ^]RS` `SQ]US\ `STcS`hO\ S W\abWbcQW]\OZWhO\ bOZSa SabS`S]bW^]a >]` ac^cSab] ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa a]P`S Z]a `WSaU]a \] SaQOÔ\ O bOZSa ^`]QSa]a @343@3<17/A 070:7=5@È471/A :WP`]a ÈZdO`Sh C` O 4 '&! µ;WaSÒPZSa g Z]Q]a¶) Bca_cSba 1O\UcWZVS[ 5 '% µ:] \]`[OZ g Z] Ôb]Z UWQ]¶) AWUZ] FF7 /ÙS\bW\O SRWb]`Sa 1][Oa 2 Q]]`R " µ8 dS\Sa g SabWZ]a RS dWRO¶) 7<8CD3 4/2 2WQQW]\O`W] RS ZO @SOZ /QORS[WO RS ZO ZS\UcO 3aÔ ]ZO ;SU Oa 3 RW` µDOZ]`Sa a]QWOZSa g R`]UOa¶) 4/2 ;SU Oa 7 g @]R` UcSh 3 µ:O WRS\bWROR XcdS\WZ RSaRS ZOa OTW\WRORSa [caWQOZSa¶) 7<8CD3 ;SU Oa 7 g @]R` UcSh 3 ! µ8 dS\Sa S\b`S a]\WR]a¶) 7<8CD3 4/2 @]R` UcSh 3 g ;SU Oa 7 ¶3ab`cQbcÒ g Tc\QW]\OZWROR RS ZOa T]`[Oa RS RWdSàW \ \]Qbc`\O( : [WbSa g Q]\TZWQb]a¶) S\ :O \]QVS( c\ Q]\TZWQb] RS ^]RS`) @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a 2S 8cdS\bcR \ #") 7<8CD3 @]R` UcSh 3 ) ;SU Oa 7 ) g At\QVSh 3 µ8 dS\Sa g `SZOQW]\Sa U`cÔZSa¶) 7<8CD3 4/2 @]R` UcSh 3 Q]]`R µ8 dS\Sa g dWRS]XcSU]a¶) 7<8CD3 4/2 @]aWbW 4 '& µ6Wab]`WO g bS]` O RS ZO 1cZbcÒ RS ;OaOa¶) 3RWb]`WOZ 5cabOd] 5WZ At\QVSh : ) ;SU Oa 7 ) g @]R` UcSh 3 " µ8 dS\Sa g ^cPZWQWROR¶) 7<8CD3 4/2 B]cÒW\S / '% µ:O a]QWSROR ^]ab W\Rcab`WOZ¶) /`WOZ /`b QcZ]a g ^tUW\Oa RS 7\bS`\Sb /h\O` 8 ; O " " " µ3Z Tcbc`] RS 3aÔ O S\ SZ FFD O\WdSàO`W] RS ZO 1]\abWbcQW \¶) Q]\TS`S\QWO ^`]\c\QWORO S\ ZO 4c\ROQW \ 4/3A) ;OR`WR 1O^]\W A µ:] \]`[OZ Q][] QObSU]` O a]QW]Z UWQO¶) S\ eee Pc SRc eQ^ >O^Sà A]QW A]QW1OÂ Vb[ :]hO\] 8 ; ) µ¥2S _c{ VOPZO[]a QcO\R] VOPZO[]a RS Z]a X dS\Sa-¶) S\ eee TSa^W\OZ Q][ >S\Rta 0 & ! " ) µ5S\bS \]`[OZ¶) O`b QcZ] OÔ`SQWR] S\ ZO SRWQW \ RS ;OR`WR RSZ RWO`W] /01 DS`R D $ " ) µ:] \]`[OZ¶) O`b QcZ] OÔ`SQWR] S\ ZO SRWQW \ RS ;OR`WR RSZ RWO`W] 3Z >O a

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

9D8JB:CIDH

)

;O` ;]`]ZZ \ 3RcQOR]Ò a]QWOZ 3a^SQWOZWabO S\ Ô`bWQWÔQW \ W\QZcaW \ a]QWOZ g U{\S`]

:a g^Zh\d n aV \Zhi^ c YZ dedgijc^YVYZh YZhYZ aV eZgheZXi^kV YZ \ cZgd

:]a Q]\QS^b]a RS U{\S`] X dS\Sa ] `WSaU] a]\ Q]\ab`cQQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa g QcZbcÒZSa _cS QO[PWO\ g Sd]ZcQW]\O\ O Z] ZOÙ] RSZ bWS[^] g RS ZO VWab]`WO S\ Tc\QW \ RS [ ZbW^ZSa TOQb]`Sa 2S^S\RWS\R] RS SabO Sd]ZcQW \ aS O`bWQcZO\ RWaQcà]a W[OUW\O`W]a a]QWOZSa ^]Z bWQOa SbQ _cS W\QWRS\ a]P`S ZO `SOZWROR g O ac dSh {abO a]P`S ZO Sd]ZcQW \ RSZ RWaQcà] S\ QWS`b]a Oa^SQb]a g ac aWU\WTWQOR] <] Sa Z] [Wa[] \OQS` V][P`S _cS [cXS` S\ 3aÔ O _cS S\ 4W\ZO\RWO ] S\ ]b`] Q]\bW\S\bS WUcOZ _cS \] Sa Z] [Wa[] aS` X]dS\ O_c _cS S\ ]b`]a ZcUO`Sa ] ZO Q]\QS^QW \ g ZO ^S`QS^QW \ a]QWOZ RS `WSaU] S\ \cSabÒ a]QWSROR _cS S\ ]bÒa VOQS " O ]a O_c _cS OV]Ò /Z WUcOZ _cS ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ WRS\bWbO`WO RSZ U{\S`] ] Z] _cS aWU\WTWQO aS` X]dS\ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] g ZOa [O\SÒa b]ZSÒPZSa ] \] RS USabW]\O`Z] a]\ Q]\ab`cQQW]\Sa QcZbcÒZSa g a]QWOZSa _cS O^`S\RS[]a S W\bS`W]`WhO[]a S\ \cSab`] ^`]QSa] RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ g S\ Tc\QW \ RS SZ Q]\bSfb] g ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa S\ _cS aS RSaO``]ZZS ^cSRS aS` [ta ] [S\]a ` UWR] [ta ] [S\]a OPWS`b] [ta ] [S\]a aO\] SbQ 3\ ZO POaS RS b]R]a Sab]a Oa^SQb]a g S\ ac Q]\ab`cQQW \ Sabt\ Z]a Oa^SQb]a acPXSbWd]a _cS RSbS`[W\O\ _cWS\Sa a][]a g Q [] a][]a 3\ SabS O`b QcZ] aS `SZOQW]\O\ Z]a TOQb]`Sa acPXSbWd]a _cS Q]\TWUcÒ\ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] Q]\ ZO Q]\TWUcÒQW \ RS Z]a Oa^SQb]a WRS\bWbO`W]a RS U{\S`] G Q [] ZO WRS\bWROR acPXSbWdO RS U{\S`] W\QWRS S\ SZ `SacZbOR] RWTS`S\QWOR] S\ QcO\b] O ZO USabW \ g ZO dWdS\QWO g Z]a `SacZbOR]a RS OP]`RO` aWbcOQW]\Sa ] US\SÒ` OQQW]\Sa _cS W[^ZWQO\ c\ `SacZbOR] RS OZbO ^`]POPWZWROR RS ^SZWU`] RO ] ] ^{`RWRO = PWS\ VOQS`Z] RSaRS c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO US\SÒR]Ò RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa Sf^S`WS\QWO O^`S\RWhOXS g RSaO``]ZZ] >OZOPÒa QZOdS( @WSaU]a ]^]`bc\WRORSa X dS\Sa U{\S`]

1]\QS^b]a g ^Sà^SQbWdOa @WSaU]a g X dS\Sa 3Z `WSaU] Sa ZO ^`]POPWZWROR ] ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS _cS ^`]RchQO c\ ^SZWU`] c\ RO ] ] c\O ^{`RWRO AW\ S[POÙ] S\ QOabSZZO\] ZO ÔZOPÒ `WSaU] b][O dO`WOa OQS^QW]\Sa AS caO bO[PW{\ ÔÒ WRS\bWTWQO` SZ ^SZWU`] ] RO ] [Wa[] _cS aS ^]R` O ^`]RcQW` /a VOPZO[]a RS µ`WSaU]a ZOP]ÒZSa¶ ÔÒ S\c[SÒ` ] RSaQ`WPW` Z]a ^SZWU`]a RO ]a ] OQQWRS\bSa _cS ^]RS[]a acT`W` S\ SZ bÒPOX] ] VOPZO[]a RS µQ][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU]¶ ÔÒ `STS`W`\]a O Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a _cS Q][^]`bO\ c\ ^SZWU`] :O Q]\aWRSÒQW \ a]QWOZ RSZ `WSaU] VO WR] Oc[S\bO\R] g S\Q]\bÒ\R] Sa^SQWTWRORSa S\ RWTS`S\bSa t[PWb]a g SZ S\T]_cS VO aWR] SZ RS ^`SdS\QW \ ^`]bSQQW \ g ^`SaS`dOQW \ AS VO\ ]PaS`dOR] Z]a TS\ [S\]a g Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a ÔÒ O bÒd{a RS ac O\tZWaWa SdWbO` Z]a RO ]a g ZOa ^{`RWROa ] PWS\ W\bS\bO` [W\W[WhO`ZOa 3abO Q]\QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] Sa `SQWS\bS S\ \cSabÒ VWab]`WO Q][] Vc[O\WROR g ^`]^WO RS ZOa a]QWSRORSa [ta RSaO``]ZZOROa SQ]\ [WQO[S\bS S\ ZO _cS ZO SdOZcOQW \ RS `WSaU]a aS `SOZWhO RS QOÒ O ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS RO ]a ]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

^{`RWROa gO _cS {ab]a bO[PW{\ aS QcO\bWTWQO\ S\ b{`[W\]a SQ]\ย [WQ]a :O W\dSàWย \ g Z]a SaTcS`h]a _cS aS `SOZWhO S\ ZO ^`SdS\QWย \ RS `WSaU]a ZOP]ÒZSa ] SZ bOPO_cWa[] ^]` SXS[^Z] aS bÒbO RS c\O W\dSàWย \ RW`WUWRO O SdWbO` ROย ]a O ZOa ^Sà]\Oa SdWRS\bS[S\bS ^S`] c\] RS Z]a OÙc[S\b]a ^`W\QWÔZSa _cS [cSdS\ ZOa d]Zc\bORSa ^]Z bWQOa Sa SZ RW\S`] _cS QcSabO OZ SabOR] Oac[W` ZO ObS\QWย \ O ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S\ SZ aWabS[O aO\WbO`W] ZOa ^S\aW]\Sa SbQ >`S]QcÔQW]\Sa ^`]^WOa RS Z]a Ô aSa RSaO``]ZZOR]a SQ]\ย [WQO[S\bS S\ Z]a _cS VOg c\ QWS`b] UÒR] RS PWS\SabO` g ZO QWcRORO\ O U]hO RS c\O aS`WS RS RS`SQV]a 6OPZO[]a RS `WSaU]a S\ QOa] RS QObtab`]TSa \ObcÒZSa ^]` SXS[^Z] g b]R]a g b]ROa aOPS[]a _cS ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RS c\ VcÒQt\ ] c\ bS``S[]b] S\ QcO\b] O ROย ]a g ^{`RWRO RS dWROa \] a]\ ZOa [Wa[Oa S\ 1O\ORt _cS S\ 1S\b`]O[{`WQO 3\ US\SÒZ Z] _cS \]a RWQS SabO QcZbcÒ RS ^`SdS\QWย \ RS `WSaU]a Sa ^]` c\ ZOR] ZO \SQSaWROR RS ^`SaS`dO` SZ PWS\SabO` g ZO QOZWROR RS dWRO RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa g ^]` ]b`] ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RS `SRcQW` Z]a Q]abSa `SRcQWS\R] ZO \SQSaWROR RS ObS\RS` ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RS c\O S[SÙS\QWO c\ OQQWRS\bS c ]bÒa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa \]QWdOa 3Z RSaO``]ZZ] RSZ O\tZWaWa g ZO USabWย \ RSZ `WSaU] RSaRS SabO [WÒRO aS O`bWQcZO O Ô`bW` RS SZS[S\b]a ]PXSbWdOPZSa _cS O bÒd{a RS ac ]PaS`dOQWย \ g QcO\bWTWQOQWย \ OQbย O\ Q][] W\RWQOR]`Sa RS ^`]POPWZWROR RS _cS c\O RSbS`[W\ORO QW`Qc\abO\QWO ^SZWU`]aO ] \]QWdO ^cSRO ^`]RcQWàS A]\ Z] _cS aS RS\][W\O TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] :O WRS\bWTWQOQWย \ RS Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] \]a ^S`[WbS O`bWQcZO` TOQb]`Sa ^`]bSQb]`Sa _cS SZW[W\S\ SZ `WSaU] ] [W\W[WQS\ Z]a ROย ]a ^]aWPZSa BO[PW{\ aS b][O\ S\ QcS\bO Z] aS RS\][W\O\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU]a AW\ S[POÙ] ZO WRS\bWTWQOQWย \ RS ZOa ^`]POPWZWRORSa ZO S\c[SÒQWย \ RS Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a ] SZ \RWQS RS ^`]POPWZWROR RS _cS aS ^`]RchQO ] \] c\O RSbS`[W\ORO QW`Qc\abO\QWO \] W\QZcgS ZO QS`bShO RS _cS STSQbWdO[S\bS aS ^`]RchQO Q]\ ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa _cS ^`SdS[]a C\ S\T]_cS a]QWOZ RSZ `WSaU] ]PaS`dO g O\OZWhO RS ZOa OQQW]\Sa ] RS ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa _cS {abOa bWS\S\ RS `S^`SaS\bO` c\O S[SÙS\QWO S\TS`[SRORSa bÒab]`\]a ] ROย ]a) ÔÒ Z]a QcOZSa RSPS\ `SQ]\]QSàS Z]a TOQb]`Sa ^`]bSQb]`Sa O^]g] TO[WZWO` dOQc\OQW]\Sa ^S`[O\S\QWO S\ SZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] bÒPOX] aSUc`] OQQSa] O aS`dWQW] RS aOZcR ) ZOa Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] Q]\RcQQWย \ RS Ocb][ย dWZ O OZbO dSZ]QWROR Q]\RcQbOa W[^cZaWdOa ) g Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] RSaS[^ZS] OUcOa SabO\QOROa 2]\RS SZ ]PXSbWd] ย ZbW[] RS SabO ]PaS`dOQWย \ g O\tZWaWa Sa ZZSUO` O ac `SRcQQWย \ ] SZW[W\OQWย \ ASUย \ SabS [Wa[] S\T]_cS ZOa OQQW]\Sa VOQWO ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ÔÒ Q]\aSUcW` SabS ]PXSbWd] RSPS\ ]ÙO\WhOàS S\ Tc\QWย \ RS ZO SbOÔ RSZ QWQZ] dWbOZ U{\S`] Q]\bSfb] QcZbcÒZ g ]b`]a 2]\Oa ''"

1WbOR] S\ 9@/CA9=>4 27</ :Oa Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] S\ ZO TOaS XcdS\WZ ;Og] RS & 1]\acZbORO ^]` 7\bS`\Sb( Vbb^( QW\bS`T]` ]`U cg ^cPZWQ a^O\WaV `SUW]\ O[^`] QW\bS`T]` bS[Oa g]cbV R]Q \]b ZWP`]!% ZWP`]!% ^RT

2SaRS c\O [WÒRO a]QWOZ g Q]\ab`cQbWdWabO SZ `WSaU] bWS\S c\ QO`tQbS` [cZbWRW[S\aW]\OZ Oย ORWS\R] O ZOa ^`]POPWZWRORSa \c[{`WQOa ROย ]a ROb]a ]PXSbWdOPZSa g ^{`RWROa QcO\bWTWQOPZSa Oa^SQb]a QcOZWbObWd]a _cS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ^]\S[]a S\ [O`QVO O ZO V]Ò RS XchUO` ] dOZ]Ò` c\ `WSaU] S\ RWTS`S\bSa Oa^SQb]a( ^S`QS^QWย \ ] \] RS ^SZWU`] Q]\]QW[WS\b] RS Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] d]Zc\bO`WSROR S\ ZO Sf^]aWQWย \ OZ [Wa[] W\[SRWObSh ] RS[]Ò RS Z]a STSQb]a /a SZ `WSaU] Sa bO[PW{\ c\ Q]\ab`cQb] a]QWOZ \] c\ Q]\QS^b] ]PXSbWd] g c\WRW[S\aW]\OZ C\ [Wa[] `WSaU] ] ^SZWU`] aWU\WTWQO Q]aOa RWabW\bOa aSUย \ RWTS`S\bSa ^Sà]\Oa ] Q]\bSfb]a g S\ RWTS`S\bSa [][S\b]a

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

ASU \ ZOa `STS`S\QWOa bS `WQOa RS SabO ^Sà^SQbWdO Q]\ab`cQbWdWabO SZ `WSaU] Q]\ZZSdO b`Sa Q][^]\S\bSa PtaWQ]a( ZOa ^{`RWROa ZO aWU\WTWQOQW \ RS SaOa ^{`RWROa g ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S Oa]QWORO Q]\ ZOa [Wa[Oa B]R]a SZZ]a SZS[S\b]a acPXSbWd]a :O acPXSbWdWROR RS Z]a b`Sa Q]\QS^b]a dWS\S RSTW\WRO ^]` Z] `SZObWd] RS SabOPZSQS` ZO Q]\aSQcS\QWO RS c\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] ] c\O RSbS`[W\ORO aWbcOQW \ Q][] c\O ^{`RWRO ] PWS\ Q][] c\O UO\O\QWO S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZOa `STS`S\QWOa RS ZO ^Sà]\O ] SZ U`c^]( Sf^SQbObWdOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa OQbcOZSa g ÔaOROa dOZ]`Sa SbQ 3abOa `STS`S\QWOa QO[PWO\ S\ Tc\QW \ RS [cZbWbcR RS TOQb]`Sa( ZO QZOaS a]QWOZ SZ \WdSZ SQ]\ [WQ] ] ZO QcZbcÒ GO VS[]a dWab] _cS Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] \]a OgcRO\ O µ]PXSbWdO`¶ SZ `WSaU] _cS Q]``S\ ] ZO ^`]POPWZWROR RS ^SZWU`] O ZO _cS c\ RSbS`[W\OR] U`c^] ] c\O a]ZO ^Sà]\O aS S\T`S\bO 3Z O\tZWaWa g dOZ]ÒQW]\Sa RSZ `WSaU] POaOROa S\ ROb]a SabOR abWQ]a g QtZQcZ]a [ObS[tbWQ]a a]\ Z]a _cS OgcRO\ O WRS\bWTWQO` Z] _cS aS RS\][W\O `WSaU]a ]PXSbWd]a >S`] VOg ]b`]a [{b]R]a RS O\tZWaWa RSZ `WSaU] `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ Z]a O\tZWaWa g dOZ]ÒQW]\Sa W\bcWbWdOa _cS ]PaS`dO\ Z]a Oa^SQb]a acPXSbWd]a S WRS\bWTWQO\ Z] _cS aS ZZO[O\ `WSaU]a acPXSbWd]a 3ab]a W\RWQOR]`Sa RS ]PaS`dOQW \ g dOZ]ÒQW \ ÔÒ ZO RSbS`[W\OQW \ RS `WSaU]a bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ ZOa Sab`cQbcÒa ^Sà]\OZSa Q]U\]aQWbWdOa S[]QW]\OZSa RS []bWdOQW \ Q]\ Z]a Oa^SQb]a a]QWOZSa QcZbcÒZSa g ^]Z bWQ]a :] _cS S\ c\ RSbS`[W\OR] Q]\bSfb] Q]\abWbcgS c\ `WSaU] S\ ]b`]a ^cSRS \] aS`Z] S\ OPa]Zcb] 3ab] Sf^ZWQO` O ^]` _c{ T`S\bS O c\O [Wa[O aWbcOQW \ ÔÒ c\]a W\RWdWRc]a `S^`SaS\bO c\ `WSaU] ] bWS\S\ SabO ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] ÔÒ ]b`]a \] Z] Sa S\ OPa]Zcb] 3ab] Sa Oa ^]`_cS ZO SdOZcOQW \ RS SabO aWbcOQW \ Sabt ObÒdSaORO ^]` W\TW\WROR RS Oa^SQb]a acPXSbWd]a W\RWdWRcOZSa g Q]ZSQbWd]a G b]RO acPXSbWdWROR aS Q]\ab`cgS \] S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ ] Z]a TOQb]`Sa ]PXSbWdOPZSa RS Z]a _cS RWa^]\S[]a ³OZ [S\]a \] a]Z] \W ^`W\QWÔZ[S\bS³ aW\] O bÒd{a RS Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS O^`S\RWhOXS RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ g a]QW] OTSQbWd]a _cS Q]\TWUcÒ\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS \cSabÒ WRS\bWROR W\RWdWRcOZ g Q][] U`c^] / ac dSh b]R]a Sab]a Oa^SQb]a RSbS`[W\O\ \cSabÒ ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] ] ZO aS\aOQW \ RS ^SZWU`] S W\aSUc`WROR Oa^SQb] W[^]`bO\bS _cS ]`WS\bO \cSabÒ dOZ]ÒQW \ g USabW \ RS `WSaU]a g ^]` bO\b] \cSab`]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a AW \] \]a aS\bW[]a S\ ^SZWU`] \] ^]\R`S[]a S\ Tc\QW]\O[WS\b] [SQO\Wa[]a ] TOQb]`Sa RS ^`]bSQQW \ ]PXSbWd]a \W W\bcWbWd]a ] acPXSbWd]a g ^]` Z] bO\b] ]`WS\bO\ \cSabÒ Sf^]aWQW \ O Z]a ^SZWU`]a ] O[S\OhOa >]\UO[]a Q][] SXS[^Z] c\ S[POÒh] RS c\O X]dS\ RS O ]a AW SabO X]dS\ Sa SaÔ ]ZO ^S`bS\SQS O c\O TO[WZWO [SRWO g Sabt SabcRWO\R] S\ ZO c\WdSàWROR dWdW`t Q]\ aca ÔR`Sa c\ S[POÒh] \] RSaSOR] Q]\abWbcgS c\O dS`RORSÒ O[S\OhO ÔÒ ac ^`SaS\bS g ^]\S S\ ^SZWU`] ac ^`]gSQb] RS dWRO gO _cS aSUcÒ[S\bS \] S\bÒ S\ aca ^ZO\Sa RSRWQO` ac bWS[^] O Q`WO` g QcWRO` c\O Q`WObcÒ 3\ Q]\aSQcS\QWO Z] [ta ^`]POPZS Sa _cS SabO X]dS\ Pca_cS Z]a `SQcà]a \SQSaO`W]a ÔÒ OP]`bO` g \] ZZSdO` O QOP] SZ S[POÒh] 7[OUW\S[]a OV]Ò _cS SabO X]dS\ S[POÒhORO Sa c\O X]dS\ W\[WUÒ\bS _cS VO ZZSUOR] VOQS ^]Q] ÔÒ bÒPOXO` S\ 3aÔ O g _cS \] bWS\S Ô^SZSa AS VO _cSROR] S[POÒhORO g Z]a TOQb]`Sa _cS SZZO SdOZ O ÔÒ Q]\bW\cO` Q]\ SZ S[POÒh] ] \] a]\ ]b`]a bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO _cS aW ZO Q`WObcÒ \OQS

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

S\ bS``Wb]`W] SaÔย ]Z ^]R`t bS\S` \OQW]\OZWROR SaÔย ]ZO g Sab] TOQWZWbO S\ QWS`bO [SRWRO Z]a Q][^ZWQOR]a g ZOÙ]a bÒ[WbSa ÔÒ Z]a ^S`[Wa]a RS `SaWRS\QWO RS ZO [OR`S aW\ Q]\bO` Q]\ ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS _cS SZ ÔR`S bS\UO \OQW]\OZWROR SaÔย ]ZO Q]\ ZOa RS`WdOQW]\Sa _cS Sab] ^]R` O bS\S` BS\S` c\ VWX] ] c\O VWXO SaÔย ]ZO O SabO X]dS\ W\[WUÒ\bS aSUcÒ[S\bS ZS Q][^]`bO ]b`] bW^] RS ^`]PZS[Oa ^S`] ^]` ]b`] ZOR] ZS ^cSRS RO` c\O aSUc`WROR _cS SZZO dOZ]Ò Q][] ^`W]`WbO`WO >OÒ SZZO _cSROàS S[POÒhORO ZSX]a RS aWU\WTWQO` c\ `WSaU] Q][^]`bO c\O ]^]`bc\WROR BO[PW{\ ^]RS[]a bÒbO` RS W[OUW\O` _c{ `S^`SaS\bO` O Sab]a S[POÒh]a ÔÒ ZOa Ô`SXOa RS ZOa `Sa^SQbWdOa QVWQOa >S\aS[]a S\ SZ \WdSZ RS W[^ZWQOQWย \ ] \] Q]\ SZ S[POÒh] RS aca Q][Ôย SÒa( {abS ^cSRS aS` dO`WOPZS S\ Tc\QWย \ RS [cZbWbcR RS TOQb]`Sa 1OPS ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS c\O W[^ZWQOQWย \ b]bOZ g Oac[W` RS [O\SÒ Q][Ô`bWRO ZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR ] PWS\ RSaOÔ`SQS` =^QWย \ {abO ย ZbW[O W[^]aWPZS ÔÒ SZZOa A]ZO[S\bS SabS VSQV] W\QWRS S\ Qย [] S\T`S\bO\ c\] g ]bÒ ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS ^`SdS\W` ] \] Z]a S[POÒh]a =bÒ ^Sà^SQbWdO W\bS`SaO\bS S\ ZO RSTW\WQWย \ RS `WSaU] Sa W\QZcW` ]b`]a Q]\QS^b]a Q][] a]\ ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S g SZ [WSR] C\ `WSaU] W[^ZWQO` O c\O QWS`bO W\QS`bWRc[P`S Oa]QWORO O c\ SdS\b] Tcbc`] ] c\ SdS\b] ac^cSab] VSQV] _cS \]a ^cSRS acUS`W` c\O QWS`bO W\aSUc`WROR ] W\QZca] [WSR] 3ZS[S\b]a OPa]ZcbO[S\bS acPXSbWd]a ^]` ZO QOÙO S[]QW]\OZ _cS Q][^]`bO\ ยฅ1ย [] aS [WRS SZ [WSR]- <] Z] ^]RS[]a [SRW` \W ]PXSbWdO` aW\ S[POÙ] ]`WS\bO \cSabÒ OQQWย \ g Q][] [SQO\Wa[] âWQ]Zย UWQ] bWS\S aS\bWR] g OQbย O Q][] TOQb]` RS ^`]bSQQWย \ 3Z [WSR] \]a ^cSRS OgcRO` \] O RSXO` RS OQbcO` aW \] O OQbcO` RS [O\SÒ [ta ^`cRS\bS ] Q]\ ZO acTWQWS\bS aSUc`WROR 3ab] \]a OP`S ]bÒa ^Sà^SQbWdOa `Sa^SQb] O ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS _cS SZ `WSaU] \] aSO aย Z] OZU] O SdWbO` ] O ^`SdS\W` AW [WÒ[]a SZ `WSaU] Q][] c\O W\QS`bWRc[P`S g Z] O\OZWhO[]a RS c\O [O\SÒ W\bcWbWdO Q]\aWRSÒ\R] Z]a Oa^SQb]a _cS bS[S[]a _cWht Q]``S` `WSaU]a \] aย Z] ^cSRS Q]\abWbcW` ZO ^]aWPWZWROR ZO ^`]POPWZWROR ] ZO O[S\OhO RS acT`W` OZUย \ ROย ] ] OZUc\O ^{`RWRO aW\] ZO Q]\RWQWย \ \SQSaO`WO ÔÒ OQQSRS` O \cSdOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa g Sf^S`WS\QWOa g ^]` bO\b] c\O RSQWaWย \ _cS b][O`S[]a RS [O\SÒ `Sa^]\aOPZS VOQW{\R]\]a QOÙ] RS SZZO g Z] _cS ^cSRO ^`]RcQW` AW \]a QS\bÒ[]a S\ ZO SbOÔ OR]ZSaQS\bS g ac W[^]`bO\QWO S\ ZO Q]\abWbcQWย \ g OTW`[OQWย \ RS ZO WRS\bWROR SZ Qย [] aS RSaO``]ZZO g aS Q]\TWUcÒ ac acPXSbWdWROR bWS\S [cQV] _cS dS` Q]\ ZOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa ^Sà]\OZSa g ZO Sf^Z]ÒQWย \ RS \cSdOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RSaRS ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO RS c\ Q][^`][Wa] Tcbc`] ^Sà]\OZ g ZO RS ac S\b]`\] 1cO\R] ZOa POaSa RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZO WRS\bWROR \] a]\ Z] acTWQWS\bS[S\bS aSUcÒa g Sab`cQbcÒ\bSa ZO \SQSaWROR RS OTW`[OQWย \ OR]ZSaQS\bS g aca OQQW]\Sa aS `SOZWhO\ aW\ c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO RS Q][^`][Wa] VOQWO aW [Wa[]a ] VOQWO Z]a RS[ta g aS W\Q`S[S\bO\ ZOa Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] _cS PcaQO\ ZO aObWaTOQQWย \ W\[SRWObO ZOa S[]QW]\Sa TcS`bSa ] ZO Ocb]OTW`[OQWย \ O bÒd{a RS Sf^S`WS\QWOa _cS PcaQO\ aS\aOQW]\Sa RS Z]U`] ] `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] W\[SRWOb] 3abOa R]a ]^QW]\Sa `Sa^SQb] OZ Q][^`][Wa] RSZ OR]ZSaQS\bS g SZ X]dS\ `Sa^SQb] Q]\aWU] [Wa[] ] Q]\aWU] [Wa[O g `Sa^SQb] OZ S\b]`\] ]`WS\bO\ g RSaO``]ZZO\ ] \] aca QOÔQWRORSa RS VOQSàS QOÙ] RS ZOa OQQW]\Sa _cS `SOZWhO\ g ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RS ZOa [Wa[Oa 8Saa]` '' =^Q 1WbO

ASUย \ SabS ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] ^]RS[]a SabOPZSQS` RWTS`S\QWOa S\b`S Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] _cS ^]\S\ S\ ^SZWU`] SZ RSaO``]ZZ] O \WdSZ ^aWQ]a]QWOZ

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa ZO ^`]^WO dWRO ] ZO RS ]b`]a g _cS PcaQO\ SZ ^SZWU`] S\ aW [Wa[]) g ZOa Q]\RcQbOa W\d]ZcQÒ\ QWS`b]a `WSaU]a Sa RSQW` O_cSZZOa _cS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa `SOZWhO\ Q]\aQWS\bS[S\bS Oac[WS\R] SZ Q][^`][Wa] g ÔÒ Z]a _cS ^]\SàS S\ ^SZWU`] ] bS\S` S[]QW]\Sa TcS`bSa ] PcaQO` SZ `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] \] Sa SZ ^`W\QWÔZ ]PXSbWd] aW\] [ta PWS\ Q][] c\O \SQSaWROR RS Sf^Z]Ò` W\bS\bO` g OQQSRS` O \cSdOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa _cS \]a ^S`[WbS\ RSaO``]ZZO`\]a Q`SQS` ] OdO\hO` S\ OZUc\] RS \cSab`]a ]PXSbWd]a /c\_cS ÔÒ SZZ] VOgO _cS Q]``S` OZUc\]a `WSaU]a

AcPXSbWdWROR 7RS\bWROR U{\S`] 3\ SZ ^`]QSa] RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ \SQSaO`W] ÔÒ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS \cSabÒ WRS\bWROR g RS \cSabÒ ^Sà]\OZWROR SZ _cW{\Sa a][]a Q [] aS\bW[]a Z] _cS Q]\ [ta ^`]POPWZWROR VOUO[]a S\ ZO dWRO SbQ dWS\S RSbS`[W\OR] ^]` dO`W]a TOQb]`Sa _cS Q]\TWUcÒ\ \cSabÒ acPXSbWdWROR g \cSabÒ T]`[O aS` g SabO` S\ SZ [c\R]( ZO SROR SZ aSf] ZO Sb\WO ZO QZOaS a]QWOZ O ZO _cS ^S`bS\SQS[]a SZ \WdSZ SQ]\ [WQ] ] \cSab`] ZcUO` RS ^`]QSRS\QWO 3\ Tc\QW \ RS b]R]a g QORO c\] RS Sab]a TOQb]`Sa g ]b`]a \cSab`] Q]\bSfb] TO[WZWO` a]QWOZ g QcZbcÒZ \]a RWQbO ZOa µ\]`[Oa¶ RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b] b]ZSÒPZSa ] \] Z]a RSaSOPZSa g ZO USabW \ RSZ Q]\TZWQb] ZO bÒaU`SaW \ g Z] _cS \cSab`] Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ `S_cWS`S ] \] `S_cWS`S RS \]a]b`]a g \]a]bÒa ÔÒ aS` OQS^bOR]a g OQS^bOROa ^]` \cSab`] S\b]`\] 3ab]a Oa^SQb]a W\QZcgS\ Z]a SZS[S\b]a acPXSbWd]a _cS Q]\TWUcÒ\ \cSabÒ ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] /^`S\RS[]a O aS` Q][] a][]a S\ Tc\QW \ RS Z] aS Sa^SÒ RS \]a]b`]a g \]a]bÒa S\ QORO [][S\b] bO[PW{\ aSU \ ZO SROR _cS bS\S[]a ] RSZ aSf] /c\_cS QWS`b]a Ôb`]\Sa Sab{\ QO[PWO\R] \] aS SRcQO WUcOZ O c\O \W O _cS O c\ \W ] :O bÒ\a[WaW \ RS Z] _cS aS Sa^SÒ RS c\ X]dS\ g RS c\O X]dS\ O \WdSZ a]QWOZ ] O \WdSZ TO[WZWO` \] Sa WUcOZ g ^]` bO\b] bO[^]Q] Sa WUcOZ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] _cS aS Q]\ab`cgS S\ c\ QVWQ] _cS S\ c\O QVWQO :]a dOZ]`Sa Z]a [S\aOXSa g ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ [c\R] ÔaO ^]` Q [] VS[]a O^`S\RWR] O [WÒ`Z] O XchUO`Z] g a]P`Sb]R] O Z] _cS aS Sa^SÒ RS \]a]b`]a g \]a]bÒa ÔÒ aS` OQS^bOR]a g OQS^bOROa ^]` \cSab`] U`c^] a]QWOZ g Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS S\ Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa g OR]ZSaQS\bSa Q]\ aca U`c^]a RS WUcOZSa 1]bWRWO\O[S\bS aOPS[]a g `S^SbW[]a _cS Z]a QVWQ]a g ZOa QVWQOa \] a]\ WUcOZSa( µZOa QVWQOa a]\ [ta bÒ\_cWZOa Z]a QVWQ]a a]\ [ta OQbWd]a ZOa QVWQOa aS VOQS\ O\bSa [Og]`Sa acSZS\ aS` [ta `Sa^]\aOPZSa) Z]a QVWQ]a a]\ c\ ^]Q] [ta O``WSaUOR]a Z]Q]a ¶ G Sa _cS O POaS RS `S^SbW`Z] Z]a QVWQ]a g ZOa QVWQOa a]\ Sa] _cS RSQW[]a _cS a]\ ^]` _cS Z] _cS SaQcQVO\ Z] _cS ZSa ^S`[WbW[]a ] ZSa `S^`W[W[]a S\ Tc\QW \ RS aW a]\ QVWQ]a ] QVWQOa Z] _cS `S^`SaS\bO\ ZOa ^SZ QcZOa Z]a dWRS]XcSU]a Z] _cS RWQS\ aca WUcOZSa _cS a]\ _cS O ac dSh `S^`]RcQS\ RS Z] _cS dS\ 3Z U{\S`] Sa c\O Q]\ab`cQQW \ a]QWOZ Sa c\O [O\SÒ RS S\bS\RS` QcZbcÒZ g a]QWOZ[S\bS Z] _cS Sa c\ QVWQ] g c\O QVWQO S\ Tc\QW \ RS ac aSf] PW]Z UWQ] g ^]` SZ VSQV] RS _cS OZU \ R O aS`t\ V][P`Sa g [cXS`Sa ORcZbOa :O SbOÔ RS OR]ZSaQS\QWO Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS Sa c\O SbOÔ RS Q]\TWUcÒQW \ RS ZO ^`]^WO WRS\bWROR RS OTW`[OQW \ RS ZO [Wa[O :]a QVWQ]a g ZOa QVWQOa O^`S\RS\ _cS a]\ RWTS`S\bSa ^S`] \] a]ZO[S\bS Q][] Z] a]\ R]a W\RWdWRc]a RWTS`S\QWOR]a ^]` SZ VSQV] RS aS` ^Sà]\Oa RWTS`S\bSa aW \] Q][] R]a ^Sà]\Oa _cS a]QWOZ[S\bS aS ZSa Ob`WPcgS c\Oa QOÒQbS` abWQOa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

^]` aS` dO` \ g ]bÒa ^]` SZ VSQV] RS aS` VS[PÒ O ZOa QcOZSa ORS[ta aS ZSa RO a]QWOZ[S\bS c\ dOZ]` g c\O QObSU]` O XSÒ`_cWhORO ^]` ZO _cS ZOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa [OaQcZW\Oa Sabt\ a]P`SdOZ]ÒROa g ZOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa RS\][W\OROa TS[S\W\Oa Sabt\ W\TÒdOZ]ÒROa a]QWOZ[S\bS 1VWQ]a g QVWQOa O^`S\RS\ O ^S`bS\SQS` O QObSU]` Oa a]QWOZSa _cS SabOPZSQS\ aca `SZOQW]\Sa POaOROa S\ UÒ\ Ô`bS S\ SZ ^]RS` :]a RSaS_cWZWP`W]a S\ ZO [Og]` O RS ZOa a]QWSRORSa S\b`S ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS dWRO RS V][P`Sa g [cXS`Sa SZ `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] a]QWOZ Z]a VtPWb]a g ZOa `Sa^]\aOPWZWRORSa RS ZO dWRO ^`WdORO R][{abWQO g Q]bWRWO\O a]\ W\RWQOR]`Sa RS _cS Z]a bÒaÔa]a US\SÒQW]\OZSa Q]\bW\ O\ ^`]RcQW{\R]aS g _cS Z]a QO[PW]a a]\ ZS\b]a B]ROd O V]g SZ O^`S\RWhOXS RSZ aSfWa[] aS [O\bWS\S ^]` Z]a dOZ]`Sa ]PaS`dOR]a ^]` Z]a g ZOa OR]ZSaQS\bSa caO\ S\ ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ RS ac WRS\bWROR :]a ÒaU]a [OQVWabOa g aSfWabOa _cS Oc\ Q]\aS`dO[]a S\ \cSabÒ a]QWSROR a]\ `S^`]RcQWR]a ^]` Z]a QVWQ]a g ZOa QVWQOa g {ab]a bWS\S\ W\TZcS\QWO S\ ZO dWdS\QWO RS Z]a `WSaU]a _cS Q]``S\ g S\ Q [] Z]a O\OZWhO\ dOZ]Ò\ g USabW]\O\ RS [O\SÒ RWTS`S\QWORO aW a]\ QVWQOa ] aW a]\ QVWQ]a AS\QWZZO[S\bS ^]` _cS S\ ZOa TO[WZWOa g ]b`]a Q]\bSfb]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ Oa Z] VOQS[]a Oa aS Z] S\aS O[]a g Oa Sa^SÒ[]a g SfWUW[]a _cS Z] VOUO\ 3Z U{\S`] bO[PW{\ RSPS aS` S\bS\RWR] Q][] c\ O\tZWaWa RS Z]a aWabS[Oa RS `SZOQW]\Sa RS ^]RS` S\b`S V][P`Sa g [cXS`Sa g c\ O\tZWaWa RS Z]a aWabS[Oa ^`tQbWQOa g Q`SS\QWOa _cS ^S`^Sb O\ SaOa `SZOQW]\Sa RS ^]RS` ] RSaWUcOZROR

:]a `WSaU]a bWS\S\ aSf] 3\ ZO [Og]` O RS ZOa QcZbcÒa g ZOa a]QWSRORSa SZ dOZ]` g SZ O``]X] Sa OZU] dOZ]ÒR] ^]aWbWdO[S\bS bO\b] ÔÒ V][P`Sa Q][] ÔÒ [cXS`Sa ^S`] \] Z]a [Wa[]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a [S`SQS\ SabO dOZ]ÒQW \ ^]aWbWdO ÔÒ O[P]a aSf]a /Z WUcOZ _cS ZOa OQbWbcRSa QOZWTWQOROa Q][] Q]PO`RSa S\ SZ QOa] RS Z]a QVWQ]a aS Q]\dWS`bS\ S\ [cQV]a QOa]a S\ ^`cRS\QWO \SQSaO`WO ÔÒ ZOa QVWQOa /ZUc\]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a µ[ta [OaQcZW\]a¶ bWS\S\ STSQb]a UÒdSa STSQb]a a]P`S ZO dWRO ^`]^WO g OXS\O :Oa QVWQOa µVO\ RS¶ ^`SaS`dO` ZO dWRO ÔÒ Z]a QVWQ]a \] bWS\S SZ [Wa[] dOZ]` >cSRS aS` ^]` Sab] _cS Z]a QVWQ]a X dS\Sa [cS`S\ [ta _cS ZOa QVWQOa ^]` Òh]\Sa \] PW]Z UWQOa >]` SXS[^Z] ZOa OQbWdWRORSa dW]ZS\bOa ÔÒ [cQV]a X dS\Sa Sabt\ ^`]Tc\RO[S\bS ZWUOROa OZ S\bS\RW[WS\b] RS Z] _cS aWU\WTWQO aS` V][P`S G O Z]a `Wb]a W\WQWtbWQ]a VOQWO ZO dWRO ORcZbO :O OQbWdWROR RS Q]``S` `WSaU]a ] Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU] bO[PW{\ RSPS aS` Q]Z]QORO S\ SZ Q]\bSfb] RS ZO O^`]POQW \ RS Z]a Q][Ô S`]a g ZO OQS^bOQW \ RSZ U`c^] ÔÒ Z]a X dS\Sa g ZOa X dS\Sa ;cQV]a RS Z]a Oa^SQb]a S\ _cS ZO XcdS\bcR OTSQbO ZO bÒ\_cWZWROR a]QWOZ Sabt\ Oa]QWOR]a O Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU] :]a g ZOa OR]ZSaQS\bSa ZZO[O\ [ta ZO ObS\QW \ QcO\R] a]\ SfbS`\OZWhOR]`Sa RS ^`]PZS[Oa _cS QcO\R] acT`S\ RS^`SaW \ OWaZO[WS\b] OPca] aSfcOZ SbQ Z] _cS ZZO[O ^]RS`]aO[S\bS ZO ObS\QW \ RS RWdSà]a aSQb]`Sa a]QWOZSa Q][] Z]a Q][c\WQOR]`Sa [OSab`]a SbQ g ZO XcdS\bcR Sa WRS\bWTWQORO Q][] c\ U`c^] RS ^]PZOQW \ ^`]PZS[tbWQ] _cS O [S\cR] OZQO\hO c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO SabWU[ObWhORO 3\ ZOa QVWQOa ZOa Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] a]\ Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS Q]\RS\OROa g QOabWUOROa a]QWOZ[S\bS ] PWS\ dWQbW[WhOROa S\ SfQSa] aWS\R] acXSb] RS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

[SRWROa a]QWOZSa _cS ZOa OTSQbO\ g `Sa^]\aOPWZWhO\ RS aWbcOQW]\Sa Q][Ô`bWROa 3ab] bÒS Q]\aSQcS\QWOa O``WSaUOROa 3\ US\SÒZ SZ `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] ^Sg]ÒbWd] RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa _cS ObÒdWSaO\ SZ ^S` ]R] OR]ZSaQS\bS TOQWZWbO ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ RS ZO WRS\bWROR \SUObWdO 3`WYa]\ '%" gO _cS ZO dOZ]ÒQW \ a]QWOZ Q]\b`WPcgS O ZO SZOP]ÒQW \ RS ZO WRS\bWROR ! :]a g ZOa OR]ZSaQS\bSa \SQSaWbO\ aS` `SQ]\]QWR]a g `SQ]\]QWROa Q][] µOZUcWS\¶ :]a QVWQ]a ^`]POPZS[S\bS ^`STWS`S\ aS` `SQ]\]QWR]a Q][] OZUcWS\ dW]ZS\b] ] bS[WR] _cS Q][] \ORWS G ZOa QVWQOa WUcOZ[S\bS ^S`] SZZOa a]\ [ta `SQ]\]QWROa Q][] d QbW[Oa g ac[WaOa S\ ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa ^Sà]\OZSa g QOÔQSa g `Sa^]\aOPZSa S\ ]b`]a Oa^SQb]a Q][] Z]a SabcRW]a ^]` SXS[^Z] :]a OUS\bSa a]QWOZWhOR]`Sa g Z]a `Sa^]\aOPZSa RS W[^cZaO` ^]Z bWQOa ^`SdS\bWdOa S\ aOZcR ^]` SXS[^Z] US\SÒ\ dO`WOROa `Sa^cSabOa ObÒdSaOROa ^]` c\O aS`WS RS TOQb]`Sa ]PXSbWdOPZSa TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] ^S`] bO[PW{\ ^]` c\O aS`WS RS aSaU]a acPXSbWd]a _cS bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ Z]a dOZ]`Sa aSfWabOa RS \cSabÒ a]QWSROR g _cS ZO\hO\ [S\aOXSa g `SOTW`[O\ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] ] \] S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa OaW[{b`WQOa RS U{\S`] >]\UO[]a Q][] SXS[^Z] ZO [SRWRO b][ORO ^]` OZUc\Oa Q][c\WRORSa Ocb \][Oa RSZ 3abOR] 3aÔ ]Z RS dOQc\O` O b]ROa ZOa \W Oa S\b`S g " O ]a _cS \] VOgO\ [O\bS\WR] `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa ÔÒ ^`SdS\W` SZ DW`ca RSZ >O^WZ][O 6c[O\] D>6 S\ ZOa QVWQOa g SZ Q]\aWUcWS\bS `WSaU] RS acT`W` c\ Qt\QS` RS QcSZZ] cbS`W\] S\ SZ [SRW] ] ZOÙ] ^ZOh] AS bÒbO S\ c\O QO[Ô O RS ^`SdS\QW \ RS c\O W\TSQQW \ _cS aS RO bO\b] QVWQ]a Q][] QVWQOa S\ SZ _cS Z]a `WSaU]a RS W\TSQbOàS S\ c\]a g S\ ]bÒa Sa SZ [Wa[] g _cS SabO W\TSQQW \ ^cSRS QOcaO` g RS`WdO` S\ ]bÒa S\TS`[SRORSa [ta ] [S\]a UÒdSa bO\b] S\ c\]a Q][] S\ ]b`]a 3a \SQSaO`WO ZO ^`SaS\QWO RS ]b`]a TOQb]`Sa Oa]QWOR]a ÔÒ QOcaO` ZO S\TS`[SROR S\ SZ QOa] RSZ D>6 ]b`]a TOQb]`Sa a]\( Q]\RcQbO aSfcOZ [OZO \cb`WQW \ bOPO_cWa[] SbQ BO[PW{\ aS aOPS _cS ZO [Og]` O RS ZOa W\TSQQW]\Sa aS RO\ aW\ ZSaW]\Sa OÔ`S\bSa g RSaOÔ`SQS\ Sa^]\bt\SO[S\bS aW\ RSXO` Òab`] RS ZO ZSaW \ >]` Z] US\SÒZ ZO W\TSQQW \ RS D>6 RS OZb] `WSaU] \] QOcaO ^`]PZS[Oa RS aOZcR O \ORWS >S`] S\ ]QOaW]\Sa ZO W\TSQQW \ ^]` SabS bW^] RS dW`ca ^cSRS ^`]d]QO` QO[PW]a QSZcZO`Sa 1]\ SZ bWS[^] Sab]a QO[PW]a QSZcZO`Sa ^cSRS\ Q]\RcQW` OZ Qt\QS` aW \] a]\ bÒbOR]a A Z] ZO W\TSQQW \ ^SàWabS\bS RS D>6 RS OZb] `WSaU] O_cSZZO _cS \] RSaOÔ`SQS RcÒ\bS O ]a Oc[S\bO SZ `WSaU] RS Qt\QS` S\ ZOa ^Sà]\Oa AS VO ]PaS`dOR] g SabcRWOR] RS [O\SÒ Sa^SQWOZ ZO W\QWRS\QWO RSZ DW`ca RSZ >O^WZ][O 6c[O\] S\ SZ Qt\QS` RS QcSZZ] cbS`W\] g aS VO RSaO``]ZZOR] c\O dOQc\O _cS ^`SdWS\S ZO W\TSQQW \ RS OZUc\] RS Z]a dW`ca RS [ta OZb] `WSaU] ÔÒ SabS bW^] RS Qt\QS` S\ ZOa [cXS`Sa

! =^Q 1WbO

7\RS^S\RWS\bS[S\bS RS ZO ^S`bW\S\QWO ] \] RS ^]\S` ZO dOQc\O ROR]a Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU]a ]PXSbWdOPZSa g RSaRS c\ ^c\b] RS dWabO S^WRS[W]Z UWQ] SabS SXS[^Z] \]a ^cSRS acUS`W` dO`WOa `STZSfW]\Sa( ¥^]` _c{ aS b][O Q][] [SRWRO ^`SdS\bWdO ZO O^ZWQOQW \ RS ZO dOQc\O a]Z] O QVWQOa QcO\R] QVWQ]a g QVWQOa ^cSRS\ W\TSQbOàS g ^cSRS\ bÒ\a[WbW` ZO W\TSQQW \- AW ZO dOQc\O OQb O W\RWabW\bO[S\bS RSZ aSf] ¥^]` _c{ \] aS ^WS\aO S\ S`ÒRWQO` SZ `WSaU] bO\b] RSaRS SZ ^c\b] RS dWabO RS ZO W\TSQQW \ Q][] RSaRS SZ ^c\b] RS dWabO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

RS ZO bÒ\a[WaW \ g ^]` Z] bO\b] RO` ZO ]^QW \ RS dOQc\O` O c\]a g ]bÒa W\RWabW\bO[S\bS g RS [O\SÒ d]Zc\bO`WOAW Z] _cS aS ^`SbS\RS ^`SdS\W` a]\ ZOa W\TSQQW]\Sa RSZ dW`ca RSZ Ô^WZ][O Vc[O\] g {abOa Sabt\ Oa]QWOROa O ]b`]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] _cS bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ SZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] O bÒd{a RS ZOa ^`tQbWQOa aSfcOZSa RS `WSaU] ¥^]` _c{ Z]a [S\aOXSa W\T]`[ObWd]a g RS aS\aWPWZWhOQW \ \] W\QZcgS\ W\RWabW\bO[S\bS O QVWQ]a g O QVWQOa S\ `STS`S\QWO O SabS dW`ca3\ SabS QOa] Q][] S\ SZ RS Z]a S[POÒh]a S\ OR]ZSaQS\bSa ^]` SXS[^Z] SZ `WSaU] g ZO `Sa^cSabO a]QWOZ S W\abWbcQW]\OZ RS ^`SdS\QW \ RSZ `WSaU] bWS\S [S\aOXSa S W[^ZWQOQW]\Sa `SOZSa RWTS`S\QWOROa g OaW[{b`WQOa ÔÒ Z]a QVWQ]a g ÔÒ ZOa QVWQOa( AW aS dOQc\O a]Z] O ZOa QVWQOa Sa c\ ^`]PZS[O RS ZOa QVWQOa \ORWS RWQS _cS OTSQbS O Z]a QVWQ]a >O`SQS QZO`] _cS Q]\ SabO [O\SÒ RS S\T]QO` ZOa Q]aOa Z]a QVWQ]a \] bWS\S\ ^]` _c{ bS\S` \W\Uc\O ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] `Sa^SQb] O ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS ÔRSQS` c\O W\TSQQW \ ^`]d]QORO ^]` SZ D>6 g ZOa ^]aWPZSa OTSQQW]\Sa RS`WdOROa BO[^]Q] bWS\S\ ^]` _c{ bS\S` \W\Uc\O ^S`QS^QW \ RS `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR a]P`S ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS bÒ\a[WbW` SZ dW`ca O bÒd{a RS `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa aW\ ZO cbWZWhOQW \ RS ^`SaS`dObWd]a c ]bÒa [SRWROa ORSQcOROa ÔÒ SdWbO` ZO bÒ\a[WaW \ RS QcOZ_cWS` S\TS`[SROR RS bÒ\a[WaW \ aSfcOZ Q][] ^cSRS aS` {abO AW\ S[POÙ] ÔÒ ZOa QVWQOa ZO Q]aO QO[PWO 3Z [S\aOXS ÔÒ SZZOa g aca TO[WZWOa _cS dWUWZO`t\ _cS Qc[^ZO ZOa \]`[Oa ÔÒ ^`]bSUS`ZO RS ^]aWPZSa ^SZWU`]a Sa _cS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa ÔÒ SZZOa g acPÒg] 3::/A W[^ZWQO\ c\ `WSaU] ] Z] _cS aS W\bS`^`SbO Q][] c\ ^SZWU`] _cS aS ^cSRS SdWbO` dOQc\t\R]aS G gO _cS bWS\S\ _cS S[^ZSO` ac bWS[^] S\ W` OZ UW\SQ Z]U] g dOQc\OàS ÔÒ SdWbO` `WSaU]a ZSa W\T]`[O`t\ RS _cS Sa Q]\dS\WS\bS b][O` ]bÒa [SRWROa ÔÒ SdWbO` ZO bÒ\a[WaW \ RS S\TS`[SRORSa aSfcOZSa ] S[POÒh]a \] RSaSOR]a 3ZZOa `SQWPW`t SabS µ^Zca RS ObS\QW \¶ bO\b] S\ aca TO[WZWOa Q][] S\ ZO SaQcSZO Q][] S\ SZ aWabS[O aO\WbO`W] `Sa^SQb] O aca Q][Ô S`]a Z] QcOZ Q]\b`WPcgS O _cS SZZOa a ^cSRO\ bS\S` c\ [Og]` Q]\]QW[WS\b] aS ZSa VOgO bÒ\a[WbWR] ZO R]aWa acTWQWS\bS RS [WSR] O Q]\bÒS` c\O S\TS`[SROR g ^]` bO\b] c\O [Og]` ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] /RS[ta W[^Z QWbO[S\bS aS Q]Z]QO \WQO g SfQZcaWdO[S\bS a]P`S SZZOa ZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR RS \] ÔRSQS` g \] bÒ\a[WbW` SZ dW`ca >]` Z] bO\b] SZZOa RSPS\ Oac[W` g Oac[S\ RS VSQV] b]R] SZ ^Sa] RS ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RSZ `WSaU] ] ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RS \] VOQS`Z] ASU \ ZOa Q]\QZcaW]\Sa RSZ SabcRW] µ8 dS\Sa g aSf] 3Z SabS`S]bW^] _cS ]PZWUO g SZ `Wb] _cS WRS\bWTWQO¶ `SOZWhORO ^]` ZO 4c\ROQW \ RS /gcRO Q]\bÒ ZO 2`]UORWQQW \ 4/2 SZ 7\abWbcb] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR 7<8CD3 g ZO =PÒ A]QWOZ RS 1OXO ;OR`WR ! Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a aSfcOZSa \] a]\ dWdWR]a Q]\ ^`S]QcÔQW \ ^]` Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa SaÔ ]ZSa g ^SàWabS c\ SabS`S]bW^] _cS US\SÒ c\ OPWa[] RS RWabO\QWO S\b`S V][P`Sa g [cXS`Sa S\b`S QVWQ]a g QVWQOa O ZO V]Ò RS S\T`S\bO` ZOa QcSabW]\Sa `SZObWdOa OZ aSf] 3Z ^`]PZS[O \] Ô`SQS SabO` S\ _cS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa \] Q]\]hQO\ Z]a `WSaU]a RS RSbS`[W\OROa T]`[Oa RS `SZOQW \ :O QcSabW \ Sa _cS SaO RW[S\aW \ RS `WSaU] \] Sa dWdWRO Q]\ ^`S]QcÔQW \ ^]` Z]a g ZOa OR]ZSaQS\bSa 2WQV] RS ]bÒ [O\SÒ ÔÒ ZO [Og]` O RS Z]a X dS\Sa Z]a `WSaU]a µSabt\ OV ¶ ^S`] µ\] a]\ ÔÒ bO\b]¶ g RS QcOZ_cWS` []R] aS acabS\bO RS [O\SÒ RWTS`S\bSa ^]` SZZ]a _cS ^]` SZZOa AS bÒbO RS c\ SabS`S]bW^] Q][Ô`bWR] g [O\bS\WR] ^]` O[P]a aSf]a _cS aS Sab`cQbcÒ

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

a]P`S R]a OTW`[OQW]\Sa Oac[WROa ^]` c\]a g ]bÒa( µ:]a QVWQ]a a]\ g RSPS\ aS` ·aSfcOZSa¸ g ZOa QVWQOa a]\ ZOa _cS RSPS\ Q]\b`]ZO`¶ 3ab] bWS\S _cS dS` Q]\ ZO Q]\TWUcÒQW \ RS ZO WRS\bWROR [OaQcZW\O g TS[S\W\O RSaRS c\O `SZOQW \ RSaS_cWZWPÒRO RS ^]RS` BWS\S _cS dS` Q]\ Z]a ^`WdWZSUW]a g SZ OQQSa] O Z]a `SQcà]a _cS aS bÒRcQS\ S\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a _cS aS ^S`[WbS\ g aS b]ZSÒ\ S\ Z]a QVWQ]a g Z]a _cS aS \WSUO\ O ZOa QVWQOa /Z [Wa[] bWS[^] _cS b]ZSÒ[]a W\QZca] OZS\bO[]a aW\ \W\U \ SaQt\ROZ] Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a aSfcOZ[S\bS OQbWd]a RS Z]a QVWQ]a Q][] Ô`bS RS ac ^`]QSa] RS [ORcÒQW \ g OQQSa] O ZO dWRO ORcZbO ^`WdWZSUW] ) QOabWUO[]a Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS ZOa QVWQOa aSfcOZ[S\bS OQbWdOa \SUOQW \ RS OQQSa] OZ `SQcà] O ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO :]a QVWQ]a bWS\S\ SZ ^`WdWZSUW] RS ^ÒQbWQO` aSf] Q]\aS\bWR] aW\ `Sab`WQQW]\Sa [WS\bÒa _cS ZOa QVWQOa Sabt\ a][SbWROa O c\ W[^]`bO\bS Q]\b`]Z gO _cS SZ ^Sa] RS ZO dWdS\QWO RS ZO aSfcOZWROR Q][] c\O Sf^S`WS\QWO µ^]bS\QWOZ[S\bS ^SZWU`]aO¶ S\ bO\b] _cS W[^ZWQO `WSaU]a ÔÒ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] âWQ]a]QWOZ RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa `SQOS ^`W\QWÔZ[S\bS S\ ZOa X dS\Sa AW b][O[]a SZ SXS[^Z] RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO ] ZO OU`SaWdWROR S\ Z]a QVWQ]a Sa ^S`[WbWRO Q][] Ô`bS RS aca XcSU]a Sf^S`WS\QWOZSa RS O^`S\RWhOXS RS `SZOQW \ AW\ S[POÙ] S\ ZOa QVWQOa \] Sabt ^S`[WbWR] Sa W\QZca] µO\bWSab{bWQ]¶ dS` ^SZSOàS O ^c SbOh]a O R]a QVWQOa ] Q][Ô`bW` XcSU]a [ta OU`SaWd]a T aWQO[S\bS :] _cS S\ c\]a aS b]ZSÒ g aS T][S\bO S\ ZOa ]bÒa aS \WSUO g¬ dWQSdSàO( \] aS b]ZSÒ TtQWZ[S\bS S\ c\ QVWQ] `]ZSa OQbWbcRSa ] dOZ]`Sa QObOZ]UOR]a Q][] TS[S\W\]a :]a QVWQ]a Sabt\ ]PZWUOR]a O [O\bS\S` QWS`b]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a _cS ZSa Q]\TWUcÒ\ T`S\bS O Z]a RS[ta Q][] µ[OaQcZW\]a¶

" 2 Oh /UcOR] 8OZ \ ; O 8]a{) ;O`b \Sh /`WOa @]aO`W]) ;O`b \ AS]O\S 5S[O " µ>`SdS\QW \ RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO g ZcQVO Q]\b`O ZO SfQZcaW \ RSaRS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO¶ 7\abWbcb] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR RSZ ;W\WabS`W] RS B`OPOX] g /ac\b]a A]QWOZSa ;OR`WR

:O dW]ZS\QWO aS \]`[OZWhO ^S`] bO[PW{\ Sa ]PXSb] RS ]PaS`dOQW \ g O\tZWaWa RSaRS ^Sà^SQbWdOa _cS ^S`[WbS\ QObSU]`WhO` ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] g O`bWQcZO` [SRWROa ^`SdS\bWdOa ASU \ RWdSà]a SabcRW]a SZ PcZZgW\U OQ]a] SaQ]ZO` S\b`S WUcOZSa OTSQbO S\b`S c\ " g c\ " RS OZc[\]a g OZc[\Oa ASU \ c\O S\QcSabO RSZ 7<8CD3 SZ OQ]a] S\b`S WUcOZSa ZZSUO O OTSQbO` O c\ ! 3\ SabO [Wa[O S\QcSabO aS `SQ]US _cS SZ !% RS Z]a X dS\Sa S\QcSabOR]a Q]\aWRSÒ _cS µaW \] RSdcSZdS Z]a U]Z^Sa Sa c\ Q]PO`RS¶ g SZ !' Q`SS _cS µaW c\ O[WU] acg] O``S[SbS O ]b`] RSPS ^]\SàS RS ac Ô`bS¶ /RS[ta SZ $ RS Z]a SabcRWO\bSa `SQ]\]QS _cS VO Ô`bWQWÔR] S\ SfQZcaW]\Sa RS Q][Ô S`]a ] S\ OU`SaW]\Sa âWQ]Z UWQOa :O W\[S\aO [Og]` O RS Z]a OU`Sa]`Sa a]\ QVWQ]a G aW PWS\ SZZ]a g SZZOa a]\ ]PXSb] RS dW]ZS\QWO bO[PW{\ Sa RWTS`S\bS ÔÒ c\]a g ÔÒ ]bÒa( ZOa QVWQOa `SQWPS\ [ta OU`SaW]\Sa dS`POZSa g a]QWOZSa _cS Z]a QVWQ]a _cWS\Sa ^]` ac Ô`bS `SQWPS\ [ta OU`SaW]\Sa T aWQOa " 1cO\R] aS RSaQ`WPS O Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa ZO dW]ZS\QWO [OQVWabO ^]` SXS[^Z] ZO `SQ]\]QS\ aW\ S[POÙ] QcO\R] SZZ]a g SZZOa VOPZO\ a]P`S SZZO ^WS\aO\ [Og]`WbO`WO[S\bS _cS Sa c\ ^`]PZS[O _cS OTSQbO O [cXS`Sa QOaOROa g [Og]`Sa /[P]a aSf]a Q`SS\ _cS Z]a V][P`Sa _cS [OZbÒbO\ bWS\S\ UÒ\RSa RWTWQcZbORSa ÔÒ Q]\b`]ZO` ac OU`SaWdWROR aWS\R] c\O QcSabW \ V]`[]\OZ #

# ;S`Oa :ZWSP`S /\O ! µ>`SdS\QW \ RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO RS U{\S`] S\ OR]ZSaQS\bSa¶ S\ @Sd 3abcRW]a RS 8cdS\bcR \ $ ! 7<8CD3 ;OR`WR ^^ "! #

@]aO 5 [Sh S\ ac SabcRW] µ:O []`bOZWROR RS ZO 3aÔ O OQbcOZ¶ ''% aS OZO SZ U{\S`] Q][] c\ TOQb]` RS []`bOZWROR RWTS`S\QWOZ g Q [] µQWS`b]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a bÒRWQW]\OZ[S\bS [OaQcZW\]a OZ RSaQS\RS` ZO []`bOZWROR ^]` ]bÒa QOcaOa SZ µ^`WdWZSUW]¶ RS Z]a V][P`Sa bWS\S c\O Q]\bÒÔ`bWRO QZOÒ S\ ZO aOZcR g S\ ZO []`bOZWROR [OaQcZW\O¶ ASU \ ZO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

[Wa[O Ocb]Ò SfWabS\ ROb]a acTWQWS\bSa a]P`S ZO [Og]` ^`SRWa^]aWQW \ RS ZOa [cXS`Sa O ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS ZO S\TS`[SROR g Sab] ^]R` O O^c\bO` O _cS Z]a RWTS`S\bSa dOZ]`Sa S\ _cS aS SRcQO g aS bÒ\a[WbS O \cSab`]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa g X dS\Sa S\ Tc\QW \ RS ac aSf] ]`WUW\O\ g ]`WS\bO\ Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS SZZ]a g SZZOa RS RWabW\b] []R] O\bS Z]a `WSaU]a g ZO S\TS`[SROR 2S SabO [O\SÒ RWTS`S\bSa Q]\ab`cQQW]\Sa RS ZO aOZcR ZO dWRO g ZO [cS`bS Sf^ZWQO\ c\]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a ]`WS\bOR]a RWTS`S\QWOZ[S\bS T`S\bS OZ `WSaU] g ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS V][P`Sa g [cXS`Sa $ 3abO QcSabW \ Q]\TWUcÒ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] RS c\]a g ]bÒa ^]` bO\b] ZOa O[S\OhOa g ^SZWU`]a _cS STSQbWdO[S\bS acT`S\ c\]a g ]bÒa g Z]a [SQO\Wa[]a acPXSbWd]a _cS aS ^]\S\ S\ [O`QVO S\ ZO dOZ]ÒQW \ RS `WSaU]a 3\ Q]\aSQcS\QWO bO[PW{\ ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa S\ _cS OQQSRS\ ] US\SÒ\ \cSdOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa g Sf^S`WS\QWOa Tc\RO[S\bOZSa S\ ZO SbOÔ OR]ZSaQS\bS g X]dS\ S\ ZO Q]\TWUcÒQW \ RS ac WRS\bWROR g RS ZO Q]\TWUcÒQW \ g b`t\aWb] O ZO dWRO ORcZbO :O ZSQbcÒ RS Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] aSU`SUOR]a ^]` aSf] g ZO ]PaS`dOQW \ RS ZO Q]\TWUcÒQW \ RS ZO WRS\bWROR g ^]` bO\b] Z]a Oa^SQb]a acPXSbWd]a S\ QVWQ]a g QVWQOa ^cSRS RSaS\QORS\O` g ObÒdSaO` ³g RS VSQV] S\ OZUc\]a Oa^SQb]a Oa Sa³ b]RO c\O aS`WS RS Q]\aSQcS\QWOa ^]Z bWQOa g a]QWOZSa S\ SZ OP]`ROXS RS Z]a `WSaU]a

:]a `WSaU]a g ]^]`bc\WRORSa ÔÒ SZZ]a g ÔÒ SZZOa A]\ dO`W]a Z]a W\T]`[Sa _cS VO\ SabcRWOR] ZO []`bOZWROR RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ SaÔ ]ZO g RS Z]a X dS\Sa S\ Ô`bWQcZO` :]a V][P`Sa bWS\S\ c\O Sa^SÒ\hO RS dWRO [S\]` _cS ZOa [cXS`Sa 3a^SQWOZ[S\bS Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU] RS Z]a X dS\Sa dO`]\Sa g ac [cS`bS W\QWRS\ a]P`S ZOa QWTÒa RS Sa^SÒ\hO RS dWRO RS Z]a dO`]\Sa

$ 5 [Sh @SR]\R] @]aO 2^b] RS A]QW]Z]U O 77 C<32 µ:O []`bOZWROR RS ZO 3aÔ O OQbcOZ¶ @SdWabO >]Z bWQO g A]QWSROR $ ''% ;OR`WR ^^ " $ % @cWh @O[]a ;WUcSZ 0ZO\Sa :Z]`S\a /[O\R g DWQWO\O 4S`\t\RSh 4Ò\QWaQ] :O []`bOZWROR S\ X dS\Sa g ac W[ÔQb] a]P`S ZO Sd]ZcQW \ RS ZO Sa^SÒ\hO RS dWRO /\ROZcQ O '& '' @Sd 3a^ AOZcR > PZWQO ''% d]Z % \] ^^ !' "&

ASU \ SZ SabcRW] µ:O []`bOZWROR S\ X dS\Sa g ac W[ÔQb] a]P`S ZO Sd]ZcQW \ RS ZO Sa^SÒ\hO RS dWRO /\ROZcQ O '& '' ¶ aS ^`]RcX] c\ Oc[S\b] `SZObWd] RS ZO []`bOZWROR S\ Z]a X dS\Sa O\ROZcQSa S\b`S Z]a b`WS\W]a '& '& g '' '' :Oa QOcaOa _cS Q]\b`WPcgS`]\ O SabS Oc[S\b] S\ Z]a dO`]\Sa S\b]\QSa TcS SZ A72/ Z]a OQQWRS\bSa RS b`tTWQ] Z]a acWQWRW]a g ZOa a]P`SR]aWa RS R`]UOa 3abOa [Wa[Oa QOcaOa RS [cS`bS ^`]d]QO`]\ c\Oa ^S`RWROa b]bOZSa RS "$ O ]a S\ ZOa UO\O\QWOa RS O ]a RS dWRO 3\ ZOa [cXS`Sa ^]` Q]\bÒ SabOa QOcaOa RS [cS`bS aS [O\bcdWS`]\ `SZObWdO[S\bS SabOPWZWhOROa aca bOaOa Q]\ c\ STSQb] QOaW W\O^`SQWOPZS a]P`S ZO Sa^SÒ\hO RS dWRO OZ \OQS` 3Z Oc[S\b] RS ZO []`bOZWROR S\ SZ U`c^] RS SROR RS # O " O ]a ^]` ZOa QOcaOa [S\QW]\OROa O\bS`W]`[S\bS aS WRS\bWTWQ Q][] c\ TS\ [S\] QOaW SfQZcaWd] RS Z]a X dS\Sa dO`]\Sa O\ROZcQSa _cS ^`]RcX] c\O ÒZS\bWhOQW \ S\ ZOa UO\O\QWOa RS O ]a RS dWRO S\ ZO R{QORO RS Z]a ]QVS\bO %

& 2Ob]a Sfb`O R]a RS ZO eSP RSZ 7\abWbcb] RS ZO ;cXS` Vb^( eee [WUcOZROR Sa [cXS` [cXS`Sa QWT`Oa W\RSf Vb[

>]RS[]a S\Q]\bÒ` OZUc\]a ROb]a a]P`S ZO ^`SdOZS\QWO RS Z]a QVWQ]a S\ QcO\b] O Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU]a g aca Q]\aSQcS\QWOa ÔÒ SZZ]a g SZZOa 3\ US\SÒZ g RSXO\R] RS ZOR] _cS ZOa QOcaOa RS [cQVOa RS ZOa S\TS`[SRORSa bWS\S\ Q][] TOQb]` RS `WSaU] Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU] bOPO_cWa[] Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa ^`tQbWQOa aSfcOZSa RS `WSaU] SbQ aW ]PaS`dO[]a Z]a ^]`QS\bOXSa RS [cS`bSa ^]` QOcaOa SfbS`\Oa S\ 3aÔ O RcÒ\bS SZ % VO\ `S^`SaS\bOR] c\ ! #& RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ TS[S\W\O 3\ SZ ^]`QS\bOXS RS [cXS`Sa [cS`bOa ^]` `SOQQW \ OUcRO bÒa SZ Q]\ac[] RS acabO\QWOa âWQ]OQbWdOa TcS RS c\ % &

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

:]a QVWQ]a bWS\S\ c\O bOaO RS []`bOZWROR ^]` OQQWRS\bSa RS b`tTWQ] QcOb`] dSQSa ac^S`W]` O ZO RS ZOa QVWQOa ASU \ SZ W\T]`[S RS ZO 1][WaW \ @/11 ÔÒ SZ 3abcRW] RS ZO >`]PZS[tbWQO RS Z]a X dS\Sa g ZO aSUc`WROR dWOZ S\ # !&% X dS\Sa RS S\b`S # g ' O ]a [c`WS`]\ S\ OQQWRS\bSa RS b`tTWQ] S\ 3aÔ O g [ta RS & `SacZbO`]\ VS`WR]a UÒdSa :O [OU\WbcR RS SabOa QWTÒa Q][^]`bO _cS Z]a OQQWRS\bSa RS b`tTWQ] aS VOgO\ Q]\dS`bWR] S\ ZO ^`W[SÒ QOcaO RS [cS`bS RS Z]a X dS\Sa SaÔ ]ZSa ^]` RSZO\bS RSZ aWRO ] ZOa R`]UOa S\ c\O a]QWSROR R]\RS Z]a X dS\Sa `S^`SaS\bO\ O^`]fW[ORO[S\bS SZ RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ SZ ! RS Z]a [cS`b]a S\ ZO QO``SbSÒ g SZ " RS Z]a VS`WR]a UÒdSa 3abO SZSdORO aW\WSabÒZWROR RS Z]a X dS\Sa aS Q]\QS\bÒ RS T]`[O ^`S^]\RSÒ\bS S\ Z]a dO`]\Sa 3abS `WSaU] O Ô`bS RS ZO WRS\bWTWQOQW \ RS ZO ^{`RWRO RS dWROa g RS Q]\aSQcS\QWOa UÒdSa ÔÒ ZO aOZcR a]QWOZ[S\bS bO[PW{\ Sa SdOZcOR] S\ b{`[W\]a SQ]\ [WQ]a ASU \ SZ [Wa[] W\T]`[S SZ `SacZbOR] TW\OZ W\RWQO _cS Z]a OQQWRS\bSa RS b`tTWQ] RS Z]a X dS\Sa ac^]\S\ c\ Q]abS OU`SUOR] RS QS`QO RS " [WZZ]\Sa RS Sc`]a OZ O ] 3Z Q]abS RS c\ X]dS\ _cS _cSRO ÔÒ^Z{XWQ] aS aWb O S\b]`\] O [WZZ]\Sa RS Sc`]a [WS\bÒa _cS SZ Q]abS RS c\O d QbW[O _cS _cSRO Q]\ W\dOZWRSh OPa]ZcbO aS SabW[O S\ [WZZ]\Sa RS Sc`]a ' ASU \ ROb]a RS =<CA72/ Q`SQS SZ \ [S`] RS [cXS`Sa W\TSQbOROa ^]` SZ D76 O \WdSZ [c\RWOZ g O^c\bO Q][] ^`W\QWÔZ QOcaO RS W\TSQQW \ ZO `SZOQW \ Q]\ aca Ô`SXOa [OaQcZW\Oa _cS O ac dSh aS VO\ W\TSQbOR] ^]` SZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa W\gSQbOPZSa ] [O\bS\WS\R] `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa aW\ ^`]bSQQW \ ÔUO\R] ] Q]\ ]b`]a V][P`Sa AW `Sb][O[]a SZ SXS[^Z] RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO RS U{\S`] ] dW]ZS\QWO [OQVWabO :O ]ÙO\WhOQW \ ;c\RWOZ RS ZO AOZcR VO OZS`bOR] RS _cS ZO dW]ZS\QWO RS U{\S`] Sa ZO ^`W[SÒ QOcaO RS ^{`RWRO RS O ]a RS dWRO S\b`S ZOa [cXS`Sa RS # O "" O ]a ^]` S\QW[O RS ZOa UcS`Òa Z]a OQQWRS\bSa RS b`tTWQ] ] Z]a RWabW\b]a bW^]a RS Qt\QS` / ] 3Z \ [S`] RS [cXS`Sa X dS\Sa [cS`bOa O [O\]a RS aca Ô`SXOa ] Sf Ô`SXOa S\ SZ O ] % Sa RS X dS\Sa S\b`S $ g ! O ]a a]P`S c\ b]bOZ RS % AW W\QZcW[]a ZOa [cXS`Sa S\b`S ! g " O ]a \ [S`] OaQWS\RS O !$ G aW \]a `S[WbW[]a O Z]a ROb]a ^]` RS\c\QWOa RS [OZ]a bÒb]a O [cXS`Sa ^]` Ô`bS RS ac Ô`SXO ] SfÔ`SXO c\ " % Q]``Sa^]\RS\ O X dS\Sa S\b`S $ g ! O ]a 3a RSQW` aS [O\bWS\S c\ Sa_cS[O RS `SZOQW \ RSaWUcOZ g dW]ZS\bO S\b`S Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa W\abOcÒR] S\ ZOa Ò QSa RS \cSabÒ a]QWSROR g POaOR] S\ ZO Sab`cQbcÒ RS ^]RS` g ac^`S[OQ O S\ ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa RSZ V][P`S a]P`S ZO [cXS`

C</72A /72A 3^WRS[WQ c^RObS 2SQS[PS` % 7A0< '%& ' %!$ & S\ ZO eSP

/ ZO dWabO RS ZOa `STS`S\QWOa O\bS`W]`Sa Ô`SQS QZO`] _cS Z]a TOQb]`Sa acPXSbWd]a S WRS\bWbO`W]a RS U{\S`] Q]\TWUcÒ\ ZO SdOZcOQW \ ZO Q]\aWRSÒQW \ g Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU] STSQbWd]a RS QVWQ]a g QVWQOa :O Q]\aSQcS\QWO Sa _cS Z]a QVWQ]a \] SdOZ O\ Z]a `WSaU]a bO\b] RSaRS SZ Q][^`][Wa] g ZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR VOQWO ac ^`]^WO dWRO ] ac ^`]^W] RSaO``]ZZ] g SZ RS Z]a g ZOa RS[ta aW\] S\ Tc\QW \ RS Z]a dOZ]`Sa RS ^`WdWZSUW] g ac^`S[OQ O RS Z] [OaQcZW\] a]P`S Z] TS[S\W\] 3abO QcSabW \ ZSa ZZSdO O [O\bS\S` ³S\ ^]`QS\bOXSa [ta SZSdOR]a _cS ZOa QVWQOa³ Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] _cS ^]\S\ S\ ^SZWU`] ac ^`]^WO dWRO g ZO RS Z]a g ZOa RS[ta 3a RSQW` RSaRS c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO RS U{\S`] aS` QVWQ] Q][^]`bO` O c\O OQbWbcR OQbWdO RS QOÒ O ^]\SàS S\ ^SZWU`] g ^]\S` S\ ^SZWU`] O ]b`]a Oa G aS` QVWQO RSaRS SabO [WÒRO W[^ZWQO` O aS` acXSb] ÔaWd] ] d QbW[O RS Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU] RS Z]a QVWQ]a S\ Tc\QW \ RSZ SabOPZSQW[WS\b] RS `SZOQW]\Sa OaW[{b`WQOa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

' @SdWabO RSZ @/11 [Og] &

:O SdOZcOQW \ RS `WSaU]a g ZO QOÔQWROR ^`SdS\bWdO RS ^SZWU`]a g ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO RS U{\S`] S\ US\SÒZ g `Sa^SQb] O Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa S\ Ô`bWQcZO` aS W\QZcgS QORO dSh [ta S\ SZ O\tZWaWa RS ZOa a]QWSRORSa [ta RSaO``]ZZOROa SQ]\ [WQO[S\bS Oa Q][] S\ ZO ]PaS`dOQW \ g ZO W\bS`dS\QW \ O bÒd{a RS ^]Z bWQOa [SRWROa a]QWOZSa _cS ^`SbS\RS\ W\QWRW` a]P`S Z]a QO[PW]a \SQSaO`W]a ÔÒ _cS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa Q]`Ò\ [S\]a ^SZWU`]a aS ^`]RchQO\ [S\]a aWbcOQW]\Sa g `SZOQW]\Sa RS W\S_cWROR g ZOa W\dSàW]\Sa g Z]a Q]ab]a SQ]\ [WQ]a `SacZbS\ [ta `S\bOPZSa 3abO ^Sà^SQbWdO \]a RO ]bÒ [WÒRO g ]b`]a SXS[^Z]a RS Q [] ZO [WÒRO g ZO µSdOZcOQW \ TS[W\WhORO RSZ `WSaU]¶ ^cSRS ac^]\S` _cS ZO SdOZcOQW \ RS Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a g ZOa OQQW]\Sa RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa W\QZcgO\ ZO Q]\aWRSÒQW \ bO\b] RS ZO ^`]POPWZWROR RS ^{`RWRO ^SZWU`] ] RO ] Q][] ZO RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa g PS\STWQW]a 3a RSQW` _cS aS W\QZcgO ZO QOÔQWROR RS OQbcO` S\ c\ aS\bWR] c ]b`] S\ Tc\QW \ RS c\O dOZ]ÒQW \ \] a]ZO[S\bS ]PXSbWdO aW\] bO[PW{\ W\bcWbWdO g POaORO S\ Z]a dOZ]`Sa TS[W\WhOR]a RS `Sa^Sb] g ^`SaS`dOQW \ RS ZO dWRO ZO Q]\aWRSÒQW \ acPXSbWdO RSZ [WSR] Q][] c\ TOQb]` RS ^`]bSQQW \ ] ZO QOÔQWROR RS Q]\dWdW` Q]\ ZO W\QS`bShO S\b`S ]b`]a GO VS[]a [S\QW]\OR] ZO ^`SdOZS\QWO RS Z]a QVWQ]a `Sa^SQb] O Z]a OQQWRS\bSa RS b`tTWQ] >cSa SabO QcSabW \ `S^S`QcbS S\ ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RS ^`SQW]a RS Z]a aSUc`]a RS Q]QVS g []b] :Oa OaSUcÒR]Òa ^`S[WO\ ZO ^`cRS\QWO RS ZOa QVWQOa X dS\Sa >OÒ ZOa Q][Ô Oa RS aSUc`]a ZOa [cXS`Sa S\ US\SÒZ g ZOa X dS\Sa S\ Ô`bWQcZO` a]\ [SX]`Sa Q]\RcQb]Òa _cS Z]a V][P`Sa g [S\]a OU`SaWdOa OZ d]ZO\bS BWS\S\ [S\]a OQQWRS\bSa g OZ bS\S` [S\]a OQQWRS\bSa US\SÒ\ [S\]a UOab]a ^]` Z] _cS ZOa [Wa[Oa ^ ZWhOa RS aSUc`] RS Q]QVS ] []b] bWS\S\ [S\]a Q]ab]a ÔÒ V][P`Sa _cS ÔÒ [cXS`Sa 3abO RWTS`S\QWO Sa [ta QZOÒ S\b`S QVWQOa g QVWQ]a C\ X]dS\ _cS bS\UO S\b`S ' g # O ]a ^cSRS ZZSUO` O ÔUO` VOabO "%% Sc`]a [ta _cS c\O X]dS\ RS ZO [Wa[O SROR ^]` c\ aSUc`] / [SRWRO _cS ZO SROR OdO\hO SZ ^`SQW] RSZ aSUc`] RWa[W\cgS g ZOa RWTS`S\QWOa RS ^`SQW] ^]` aSf] bWS\RS\ O RSaOÔ`SQS` 3\ SZ [c\R] RS Z]a \SU]QW]a g Z]a ZWRSÒhU]a S[^`SaO`WOZSa QORO dSh aS dOZ]Ò\ [ta QOÔQWRORSa TS[W\WhOROa Q][] ZO Q`SObWdWROR ZO TZSfWPWZWROR g ]bÒa Q][] ZO QOÔQWROR RS Oac[W` `WSaU]a RS `SOQQW]\O` g ORO^bOàS `t^WRO[S\bS O Z]a QO[PW]a 3\bS\RWS\R] ^]` Oac[W` `WSU]a ZO QOÔQWROR RS b][O` RSQWaW]\Sa RS OQbcO` RS c\O [O\SÒ Q]\b`]ZORO `Sa^SQb] O Z]a ^SZWU`]a RO ]a ] ^{`RWROa _cS S\T`S\bO Q]\ ac OQbcOQW \ 3a Z] _cS aS RS\][W\O `WSaU] Q]\b`]ZOR] :Oa X dS\Sa O``WSaUO\ RS c\O [O\SÒ [ta Q]\b`]ZORO g []bWdOROa ^]` dOZ]`Sa [ta Q][^`][SbWR]a Q]\aWU] [Wa[Oa g Q]\ SZ `Sab] RS ^Sà]\Oa 2SaRS c\O dWaW \ SQ]\ [WQO `SacZbO _cS W\dS`bW` S\ ZOa [cXS`Sa g S\ ZOa X dS\Sa Sa c\ PcS\ \SU]QW] g Q][^]`bO [S\]a `WSaU]a g [ta PS\STWQW]a Q][] gO VS[]a dWab] S\ SZ SXS[^Z] RS Z]a aSUc`]a RS Q]QVS ] []b] 2SaRS ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS Ô aSa S[^]P`SQWR]a S\Q]\bÒ[]a ]b`]a TS\ [S\]a _cS bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ ZO QOÔQWROR RS ZOa [cXS`Sa RS b][O` `WSaU]a S\ PcaQO RS \cSdOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa g _cS {abOa `SdWS`bO\ RS c\O [O\SÒ [ta PS\STWQW]aO ÔÒ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] g ZO ZcQVO Q]\bÒ ZO ^]P`ShO RS ZOa TO[WZWOa g Q][c\WRORSa O \WdSZ Z]QOZ

=^ QWbO #

DO`WOa ]ÙO\WhOQW]\Sa W\bS`\OQW]\OZSa VO\ OZS`bOR] RS ZO TS[W\WhOQW \ RS ZO ^]P`ShO 1][] Q]\aSQcS\QWO RS SZZ] ZOa OUS\QWOa g ]ÙO\WhOQW]\Sa RS Q]]^SÒQW \ OZ RSaO``]ZZ] Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS RcÒ\bS ZO R{QORO RS Z]a ' g

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

VOabO V]g S\ R O Q][S\hO`]\ O ^ZO\bSOàS ZO \SQSaWROR RS ZO W\Q]`^]ÒQW \ RS ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO RS U{\S`] S\ ZO W\dSàW \ _cS aS `SOZWhO Q][] OgcRO OZ RSaO``]ZZ] S\ Ô aSa B]ROd O V]g 3Z 4]\R] RS 2SaO``]ZZ] RS ZOa <OQW]\Sa C\WROa ÔÒ ZO ;cXS` C<743; g ZO 1][WaW \ 3c`]^SO 13 Q]\bW\ O\ VOQWS\R] ZZO[O[WS\b]a O `SR]PZO` ZOa OQQW]\Sa ÔÒ OP]`RO` ZOa RSaWUcOZRORSa RS U{\S`] S\ SZ SaTcS`h] ^]` ^]\S` TW\ O ZO ^]P`ShO [c\RWOZ 4]`[OZ[S\bS aS `SQ]\]QS _cS SZ `]Z RS ZOa [cXS`Sa Sa [cg W[^]`bO\bS ÔÒ ZO a]QWSROR ZO aOZcR ZO \cb`WQW \ g ZO SRcQOQW \ RS \W Oa g \W ]a ÔÒ SZ Q`SQW[WS\b] SQ]\ [WQ] g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS c\ Ô a AS OZO\ ZO ^]QO STWQOQWO RS ZO OgcRO OZ RSaO``]ZZ] aW \] aS bWS\S S\ QcS\bO ZO S_cWROR RS U{\S`] g \] aS W\Q]`^]Ò SabO ^Sà^SQbWdO S\ ZO ^ZO\WTWQOQW \ ZO SZOP]ÒQW \ RS ^`Sac^cSab]a g S\ SZ RWaS ] RS ^]Z bWQOa ÔÒ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] :Oa [cXS`Sa Q`SO\ [ta `W_cShO g a]\ [ta TWOPZSa _cS Z]a V][P`Sa ;cVO[[OR Gc\ca RSQWRW S\ '%$ _cS SZ '# RS ZOa PS\STWQWO`WOa RS Z]a Q`{RWb]a RS ac PO\Q] ÔÒ ^]P`Sa TcSÒ\ [cXS`Sa ^]`_cS ZOa [cXS`Sa µa]\ [SX]`Sa ZcQVOR]Òa Q]\bÒ ZO ^]P`ShO¶ 3abS ^`W\QW^W] `WUS ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RS OgcRO OZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ]ÙO\Wa[]a Q][] ZO =<C ] SZ 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ g ZO WRSO ZS VO dOZWR] SZ >`S[W] <]PSZ RS ZO >Oh S\ $ g ^]RS` OaSUcÒ` _cS VO aOQOR] RS ZO ^]P`ShO Sfb`S[O O [WZZ]\Sa RS ^Sà]\Oa 1cO\R] Gc\ca ^ca] S\ [O`QVO S\ '%$ Q]\ a]Z] % R ZO`Sa ac WRSO RSZ PO\Q] ÔÒ ^]P`Sa ]PaS`d _cS Z] ^`W[S`] _cS VOQ O\ ZOa [cXS`Sa RS 0O\UZORSaV QcO\R] bS\ O\ W\U`Sa]a SÒ `SQc^SÒ` O aca VWX]a RS ZOa QOaOa RS Z]a `WQ]a R]\RS Z]a VOP O\ RSXOR] bÒPOXO\R] O QO[PW] RS Q][WRO :] aSUc\R] S\dWO`Z]a OZ Q]ZSUW] 1cO\R] SZ ^`{abO[] S\bÒ S\ ZO TO[WZWO O bÒd{a RS c\O [cXS` Z]a PS\STWQW]a dO\ RW`SQbO[S\bS OZ PWS\SabO` RS b]RO ZO TO[WZWO( Z]a \W ]a dO\ OZ Q]ZSUW] Q][S\ [SX]` SZ bSXOR] Sabt O``SUZOR]¬ 1cO\R] aS bÒbO RS c\ V][P`S VOg RS[OaWOROa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS _cS OQOPS S\ ZWQ]` aSU \ @]aOV\SV HOTO` RWaQ ^cZO RS Gc\ca g ^`SaWRS\bO RS ZO 4c\ROQW \ 4OaVT [WZOU`] RS 0O\UZORSaV Q]\ $ PS\STWQWOROa RS [WQ`]Q`{RWb]a( µAW c\O [cXS` UO\O c\ R ZO` UOabO SZ % S\ ZO TO[WZWO C\ V][P`S ZS RSRWQO SZ ! ¶ !

> ESP C<743; 3\ Vbb^( eee c\WTS[ ]`U \SeaM SdS\ba ab]`gMRSbOWZ ^V^-Ab]`g72+%

AS O`bWQcZO\ ^`]gSQb]a ÔÒ OgcRO` O [cXS`Sa O ZOa _cS ZO S[WUÒQW \ RS Z]a ÔR`Sa RS aca VWX]a S VWXOa VO RSXOR] a]ZOa g Sa^SÒ\R] c\Oa `S[SaOa _cS \] aWS[^`S ZZSUO\ :O S[WUÒQW \ [OaQcZW\O Q][WS\hO S\dWO\R] `S[SaOa g RW\S`] O ac TO[WZWO RS ]`WUS\ ^S`] Q]\ SZ bWS[^] Q][WS\hO\ O SaÔQWOàS g SaQOaSO` ;cQVOa dSQSa Z]a V][P`Sa T]`[O\ c\O aSUc\RO TO[WZWO S\ SZ Ô a RS S[WUÒQW \ g OPO\R]\O\ O ac TO[WZWO S\ SZ Ô a RS ]`WUS\ 3abO QcSabW \ \] ÔaO OZ Q]\bÒ`W] 1cO\R] c\O [cXS` S[WUÒ ZOa `S[SaOa _cS {abO S\d O O ac TO[WZWO S\ ac ZcUO` RS ]`WUS\ DO`WOa Z]QOZWRORSa RS b]R] SZ [c\R] S[Wa]Òa RS S[WUÒ\bSa VO\ `SOZWhOR] c\ W[^]`bS ^`]QSa] RS bÒ\aT]`[OQW \ UÒQWOa O ZO `SW\dSàW \ RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ S[WUÒ\bS g S\ SabS aS\bWR] SZ Ô^SZ RS ZOa [cXS`Sa S\ SabS aS\bWR] VO aWR] Q`cQWOZ \] a]Z] ^]` SZ S\d ] RS `S[SaOa aW\] bO[PW{\ ^]` ac QOÔQWROR RS RSQWaW \ g ZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR Q]\ _cS Oac[S\ ZO W\dSàW \ RS ZOa [Wa[Oa

! 3Z >O a RS 8c\W] &

1cO\R] VOPZO[]a S\ b{`[W\]a RS RSaO``]ZZ] ] S[WUÒQW \ VOPZO[]a RS ^]PZOQW \ X]dS\ Oc\_cS Z]a Ô`t[Sb`]a a]QW]SQ]\ [WQ]a g QcZbcÒZSa \] aSO\ Q][ÔÒPZSa S\b`S Z]a U`c^]a RS SROR RS 3aÔ O g Z]a RS c\ Ô a S[^]P`SQWR] S\ RSaO``]ZZ] Q][] bO[^]Q] Z] a]\ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU]a ] SZ ^`]^W] Q]\QS^b] RS XcdS\bcR AW\ S[POÙ] a ^]RS[]a O^`SQWO` _cS ZO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

Q]\ab`cQQW \ WRS\bWbO`WO RS U{\S`] bWS\S W\TZcS\QWO g Q]\ab`cgS ³Q]\ RWTS`S\bSa Sf^`SaW]\Sa³ POaSa Q][c\Sa S\ Z] _cS aS `STWS`S O ZO SdOZcOQW \ RSZ `WSaU] ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS ^SZWU`] g ZO QOÔQWROR RS S[^`S\RS` g Oac[W` OQQW]\Sa POX] c\ `WSaU] Q]\b`]ZOR] ÔÒ US\SÒ` \cSdOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa ] Sf^S`WS\QWOa RS RSaO``]ZZ] g Q`SQW[WS\b] @343@3<17/A 070:7=5@È471/A 2 Oh /UcOR] 8OZ \ ; O 8]a{) ;O`b \Sh /`WOa @]aO`W]) ;O`b \ AS]O\S 5S[O " µ>`SdS\QW \ RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO g ZcQVO Q]\bÒ ZO SfQZcaW \ RSaRS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO¶ 7\abWbcb] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR RSZ ;W\WabS`W] RS BÒPOX] g /ac\b]a A]QWOZSa ;OR`WR 5 [Sh @SR]\R] @]aO ''% 2^b] RS A]QW]Z]U O 77 C<32 µ:O []`bOZWROR RS ZO 3aÔ O OQbcOZ¶ @SdWabO >]Z bWQO g A]QWSROR $ ;OR`WR ^^ " $ 9ÒcaY]^T 2W\O & µ:Oa Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] S\ ZO TOaS XcdS\WZ¶ 1]\acZbOR] ^]` W\bS`\Sb( Vbb^( QW\bS`T]` ]Ù cg ^cPZWQ aÔ\WaV `SUW]\ O[^`] QW\bS`T]` bS[Oa g]cbV R]Q \]b ZWP`]!% ZWP`]!% ^RT ;SU Oa 7 @]R` UcSh 3 ;{\RSh A g >OZZO`{a 8 # 8 dS\Sa g aSf] 3Z SabS`S]bW^] _cS ]PZWUO g SZ `Wb] _cS WRS\bWTWQO ;OR`WR( 7<8CD3 4/2 ;SÒa :ZWSP`S /\O ! µ>`SdS\QW \ RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO RS U{\S`] S\ OR]ZSaQS\bSa¶ S\ @Sd 3abcRW]a RS 8cdS\bcR \ $ ! 7<8CD3 ;OR`WR ^^ "! # @SdWabO RSZ @/11 [Og] & @cWh @O[]a ;WUcSZ 0ZO\Sa :Z]`S\a /[O\R g DWQWO\O 4S`\O\RSh 4Ò\QWaQ] ''% µ:O []`bOZWROR S\ X dS\Sa g ac W[ÔQb] a]P`S ZO Sd]ZcQW \ RS ZO Sa^SÒ\hO RS dWRO /\ROZcQ O '& '' ¶ @Sd 3a^ AOZcR >cPZWQO d]Z % \] ^^ !' "& C</72A /72A 3^WRS[WQ c^RObS 2SQS[PS` % S\ ZO eSP ESP RS C<743; 3\ Vbb^( eee c\WTS[ ]Ù ESP RS C</72A( eee c\OWRa ]Ù ESP RSZ 7\abWbcb] RS ZO ;cXS`( Vbb^( eee [WUcOZROR Sa [cXS`

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

9D8JB:CIDH

8cO\ 1O`Z]a 0OZZSabS`]a A]QW]Z UWQO B`Sa

G^Zh\d! _jkZcijY n ZmeZg^ZcX^Vh YZ hdX^Va^oVX^ c

3Z `WSaU] Sabt ^`SaS\bS S\ ZO [Og]` O RS OQQW]\Sa g Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS ZO XcdS\bcR S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR ^]\WS\R] RS [O\WTWSab] ZO OÔ`WQW \ RS c\O RS\][W\ORO µa]QWOZWhOQW \ S\ SZ `WSaU]¶ _cS ^`Sac^]\S c\O aWU\WTWQObWdO O\aWO RS Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ RS[O\RORO ^]` Z]a W\RWdWRc]a X dS\Sa Q][] Ô`bS W\RWa^S\aOPZS RS c\ O^`S\RWhOXS dWbOZ :O Q][^`S\aW \ RS SabS TS\ [S\] RSPS ÔaO` S\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` ^]` Q]\aSUcW` W\bS`^`SbO` RS [O\SÒ STSQbWdO Z]a Ô`t[Sb`]a g Z]a SZS[S\b]a ^]` Z]a QcOZSa ZO XcdS\bcR ^`SaS\bO c\]a RSbS`[W\OR]a ^S`TWZSa RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b] a]P`S SZ `WSaU] _cS ac^S`S\ SZ []RSZ] Q][^`S\aWd] POaOR] S\ ZO Q]\QS^QW \ RS SabS `WSaU] Q][] aW[^ZS ^SZWU`]

>OZOP`Oa QZOdS( A]QWOZWhOQW \ S\ SZ `WSaU] Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ XcdS\bcR `WSaU]a

3f^S`WS\QWOa a]QWOZWhOQW \ g `WSaU] DO\RS` HO\RS\ '%% RSTW\S O ZO a]QWOZWhOQW \ Q][] µc\ ^`]QSa] S\ SZ QcOZ Z]a W\RWdWRc]a S\ ac W\bSÒQQW \ Q]\ ]b`]a RSaO``]ZZO\ [O\SÒa RS ^S\aO` aS\bW` g OQbcO` _cS a]\ SaS\QWOZSa ÔÒ ac Ô`bWQWÔQW \ STWQOh S\ ZO a]QWSROR¶ ?cS SabO a]QWOZWhOQW \ `SacZbO c\ SZS[S\b] OPa]ZcbO[S\bS QS\bÒZ S\ ZO T]`[OQW \ RSZ W\RWdWRc] VO _cSROR] `S^SbWRO[S\bS Sf^cSab] S\ \c[S`]a]a S\aOg]a g T]`[O Ô`bS ^`W\QWÔZ RSZ Q]`^ca RS Q]\]QW[WS\b] a]P`S Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS Q`SQW[WS\b] g RSaO``]ZZ] Vc[O\]a

DO\RS` HO\RS\ 8O[Sa E '%% µA]QWOZ >agQV]Z]Ug¶ @O\R][ 6]caS <cSdO 1]`Y 1WbOR] ^]` ÈZdO`Sh g RSZ @ ] '' S\ µ3RcQOQW \ g RSaO``]ZZ]( ZO bS]` O RS DgU]baYg g ZO h]\O RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] ^` fW[]¶ ]^ QWb ^ '"

>S`] ZO bS]`{bWQO RSaO``]ZZORO a]P`S ZO a]QWOZWhOQW \ VO OdO\hOR] c\ Ôa] [ta) DgU]baYg '&' SabOPZSQW ORSQcORO[S\bS _cS SZ aWU\WTWQOR] RS ZO a]QWOZWhOQW \ bÒaQWS\RS ZOa T`]\bSÒa RS c\O aW[^ZS ORSQcOQW \ ] ^]bS\QWOQW \ RS ZOa Sab`cQbcÒa Q]U\WbWdOa RSZ W\RWdWRc] S\ POaS O ac W\QO`RW\OQW \ S\ Z] a]QWOZ aW\] _cS Sa QOÔh RS Q]\abWbcWàS Q][] ZO `STS`S\QWO RS POaS _cS QOÔQWbO OZ W\RWdWRc] ÔÒ RSaO``]ZZO` g ^]bS\QWO` aca ^`]QSa]a Q]U\WbWd]a ^`]^W]a ZZSUO\R] O [O\WTSabO` SZ Ocb]` _cS µSZ O^`S\RWhOXS Vc[O\] ^`Sac^]\S c\O \ObcÒZShO a]QWOZ Sa^SQ TWQO g c\ ^`]QSa] [SRWO\bS SZ QcOZ Z]a \W ]a OQQSRS\ O ZO dWRO W\bSZSQbcOZ RS O_cSZZ]a _cS ZSa `]RSO\ ¶ BOZ Sa ZO ^]bS\QWO _cS aS Q]\QSRS O Z]a ^`]QSa]a W\bS`\]a _cS ZO a]QWOZWhOQW \ Sa QOÔh RS US\SÒ` S\ SZ W\RWdWRc] _cS RS VSQV] DgU]baYg ZZSUO O OTW`[O` ZO ^`W[OQ O RS ZO [Wa[O S\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] Q]U\]aQWbWd] RSZ W\RWdWRc]( µ3\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] QcZbcÒZ RSZ \W ] b]RO Tc\QW \ OÔ`SQS R]a dSQSa( ^`W[S`] O \WdSZ a]QWOZ g [ta bO`RS O \WdSZ W\RWdWRcOZ) >`W[S`] S\b`S ^Sà]\Oa W\bS` âWQ]Z UWQO g RSa^c{a S\ SZ W\bS`W]` RSZ ^`]^W] \W ] W\bÒâWQ]Z UWQO B]ROa ZOa Tc\QW]\Sa ac^S`W]`Sa aS ]`WUW\O\ Q][] `SZOQW]\Sa S\b`S aS`Sa Vc[O\]a ¶ DgU]baYW '&' ] '! !" ^ '"

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

3a c\ VSQV] S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR Q]\aWRSÒ` _cS S\ PcS\O [SRWRO Z]a OQbcOZSa ^`]QSa]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ VO\ acT`WR] c\O aS`WS RS bÒ\aT]`[OQW]\Sa S\ Z] _cS aS `STWS`S OZ Ô^SZ RSaS[^S OR] ^]` aca OQb]`Sa) aW PWS\ Z]a SZS[S\b]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ bÒRWQW]\OZSa ZO TO[WZWO g ZO SaQcSZO aWUcS\ Q]\T]`[O\R] RS [O\SÒ SaS\QWOZ Z]a ^c\b]a RS `STS`S\QWO RS RSaO``]ZZ] S\ ZOa TOaSa RS OR]ZSaQS\QWO g XcdS\bcR ac Ô^SZ VO QO[PWOR]) ^]` c\O Ô`bS ZO SaQcSZO VO ÔaOR] O Q]\abWbcWàS QcOaW SfQZcaWdO[S\bS Q][] c\ SZS[S\b] T]`[ObWd] Q]\]QW[WS\b] ^S`RWS\R] Ô`bS RS ac aS\bWR] QZtaWQ] SRcQObWd] Q][] SXS bÒ\a[Wa]` RS \]`[Oa Q]\RcQbOa g dOZ]`Sa ! >]` ]b`] ZOR] ZO TO[WZWO bO[PW{\ VO RSPWZWbOR] ac Ô^SZ SRcQObWd] T`cb] RS ZO RSXORSh ] ZO W[^]aWPWZWROR RS Z]a ^`]US\Wb]`Sa RS RSRWQO` bWS[^] g SaTcS`h]a O ZO SRcQOQW \ RS Z]a W\RWdWRc]a 2S SabO [O\SÒ SZ bS`QS` ^WZO` RS ZO a]QWOZWhOQW \ SZ U`c^] RS Ô`Sa VO Q]PÒR] Sa^SQWOZ W[^]`bO\QWO Q][] O^]g] Q]\ SZ _cS Z]a X dS\Sa ^`SbS\RS\ ac^ZW` ZOa QO`S\QWOa S[]QW]\OZSa OTSQbWdOa S W\QZca] SRcQObWdOa RS Z]a RS[ta ^WZO`Sa RS ZO a]QWOZWhOQW \) RS VSQV] S\b`S {ab]a ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa Q]\ SZ U`c^] RS O[WU]a aS Q]\aWRSÒ\ SaS\QWOZSa S W\acabWbcWPZSa Q]\T]`[O\R] c\ aWabS[O RS O^]g] dWbOZ RS ^`W[S` ]`RS\ /a ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa Q]\ SZ U`c^] RS Ô`Sa VO\ ÔaOR] RS aS` c\ SZS[S\b] [ta S\ SZ ^`]QSa] RS O^`S\RWhOXS dWbOZ O Q]\abWbcWàS Q][] c\O RS ZOa ^`W\QWÔZSa d Oa RS OaW[WZOQW \ RS dWdS\QWOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa g Q]\]QW[WS\b]a AS\bOROa ZOa POaSa Oc\ RS [O\SÒ SaQcSbO a]P`S ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RS Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ SZ ]PXSb] RS SabOa Z \SOa Sa SZ bÒbO` RS ^`SaS\bO` {abO RSaRS c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO US\SÒZ g `SZOQW]\ORO Q]\ ZO Sab`cQbcÒ g RW\t[WQO RS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa RS ZO XcdS\bcR Q]\ ZOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa RS `WSaU] :O bSaWa US\SÒZ _cS Sab`cQbcÒ`t SabS O`b QcZ] Sa _cS SZ `WSaU] ZSX]a RS Q]\abWbcWàS Q][] c\ Q][^]\S\bS SfbÒ ] g OXS\] O ZO a]QWOZWhOQW \ RSZ OR]ZSaQS\bS g X]dS\ T]`[O Ô`bS W\SZcRWPZS RSZ [Wa[] S\ SZ OQbcOZ aWabS[O a]QWOZ g SQ]\ [WQ] :Oa µSf^S`WS\QWOa¶ dWdWROa Q]\ SZ U`c^] RS Ô`Sa Q][^ZS[S\bO\ QcO\R] \] acabWbcgS\ b]bOZ[S\bS S\ QOa]a Sfb`S[]a O ZOa ÔcbOa g `STS`S\QWOa SRcQObWdOa T]`[OZSa ] W\T]`[OZSa `SQWPWROa RSaRS ]b`]a t[PWb]a G S\ SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS SabOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa Q]PÒ\ Sa^SQWOZ W[^]`bO\QWO ZOa Oa]QWOROa OZ `WSaU] S\bS\RWR] {abS \] a]Z] RSaRS ac dS`bWS\bS RS ^SZWU`] aW\] RS ]^]`bc\WROR ! :O ^{`RWRO RSZ Ô^SZ SRcQObWd] RS ZO SaQcSZO aS S\QcS\bÒ O[^ZWO[S\bS RSaO``]ZZORO S\ ;SUWOa Sb OZW & µ2]QS\bSa ] [OSab`]a) ^S`QS^QW]\Sa RS ZO SRcQOQW \ RSaRS RS\b`]¶ 4/2 " 0S`WO\ Q][^ % µ:Oa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa ^S`dSàOa RS ZO []RS`\WROR¶ 0O`QSZ]\O /\b`V]^]a # 5WRRS\a /\bV]\g g 6cbb]\ EWZZ SRWb]`Sa µ3\ SZ Z [WbS) ZO dWRO S\ SZ QO^WbOZWa[] UZ]POZ¶ ]^ QWb ^ ' 0O`QSZ]\O Bca_cSba SRWb]`Sa

6OQS bWS[^] _cS ZOa QWS\QWOa a]QWOZSa VO\ RSaQcPWS`b] SZ ^`]PZS[O RSZ `WSaU] W\bS\bO\R] O^]`bO` c\ O\tZWaWa RSZ [Wa[] _cS W\QZcgO ac S\QOXS g ac RS^S\RS\QWO RS Z]a ^`]QSa]a a]QWOZSa S W\QZca] U`cÔZSa) RS SabO [O\SÒ ZOa bS\RS\QWOa O\OZ bWQOa OQbcOZSa ^`SaS\bO\ OZ `WSaU] Q][] c\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] RSTW\WR] S W\QZca] QOÒQbS` abWQ] RS QWS`b]a U`c^]a _cS `Sa^]\RS\ O ^`]QSa]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ Sa^SQ TWQ]a " /a Q]\dS\W[]a Q]\ 5WRRS\a S\ _cS b]ROa ZOa T`]\bSÒa SQ]\ [WQOa ^]Z bWQOa g a]QWOZSa aS VO\ RWTc[W\OR] g ^]` bO\b] \]a S\Q]\bÒ[]a S\ ZO \SQSaWROR RS `SdWaO` ZOa dWSXOa QObSU]` Oa O\OZ bWQOa 3\ Z] _cS \]a b]QO ^]RS[]a RSQW` _cS SfWabS RS VSQV] c\O \cSdO Q]\QS^QW \ RSZ bWS[^] SZ `WSaU] g ZO ]^]`bc\WROR # 3abO \cSdO Q]\QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] RSPS Oac[W` _cS SZ [Wa[] OZ [S\]a S\ UÒ\ Ô`bS Sa T`cb] RS c\ \cSd] ÔÒRWU[O ^`]RcQbWd] g QcZbcÒZ 0SQY $ `Sac[S ZO QcSabW \ RS [O\SÒ ^`SQWaO( µ3\ ZO []RS`\WROR OdO\hORO ZO ^`]RcQQW \ a]QWOZ RS `W_cShO dO OQ][Ô ORO aWabS[tbWQO[S\bS ^]` ZO ^`]RcQQW \ a]QWOZ RS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

`WSaU]a >]` Z] bO\b] Z] ^`]PZS[Oa g Q]\TZWQb]a RS `SÔ`b] RS ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO QO`S\QWO a]\ acabWbcWR]a ^]` Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa g Q]\TZWQb]a _cS acÙS\ RS ZO ^`]RcQQW \ RSTW\WQW \ g `SÔ`b] RS Z]a `WSaU]a ^`]RcQWR]a RS [O\SÒ QWS\b TWQ] b{Q\WQO $

0SQY ^]\S a]P`S ZO [SaO ZO UÒ\ ÔÒR]XO RS ZO Q]\T]`[OQW \ a]QWOZ OQbcOZ) ZO a]QWSROR RS ^`]RcQQW \ S\ ZO _cS SabO[]a W\[Sà]a Sa bO\ ^`]RcQb]Ò RS PWS\Sa g aS`dWQW]a Q][] RS `WSaU]a AW OQS^bO[]a SabO ^`]^cSabO S\b]\QSa \] ^]R`S[]a Q]\aWRSÒ` OZ `WSaU] Q][] c\ `SacZbOR] OXS\] S W\Q]\dS\WS\bS OZ OQbcOZ aWabS[O a]QWOZ Q][] aW TcSÒ c\O SfQ`SQS\QWO T`cb] RS c\ RSaO``SUZ] ^cÒ[S\bS Q]gc\bcÒZ g SfbÒ aWab{[WQ]) ^]` SZ Q]\bÒ`W] aW _cS`S[]a O\OZWhO` g S\bS\RS` SZ `WSaU] S\ ZO [O\SÒ S\ _cS ZO XcdS\bcR Z]a Oac[S RSaRS c\O O[^ZWO ^Sà^SQbWdO VOP`S[]a RS S\T`S\bO` ZO \SQSaWROR RS ^]\RSÒ`Z] S\ Tc\QW \ RS ac ^`SaS\QWO W\aSÔÒPZS O ZO Q]\RWQW \ Vc[O\O RS Sab]a bWS[^]a) ÔÒ SZZ] Sa \SQSaO`W] OR[WbW` g Q][^`S\RS` SZ VSQV] RS _cS SZ `WSaU] T]`[O Ô`bS W\SZcRWPZS RS \cSabÒ SfWabS\QWO aWS[^`S _cS Q]\bW\ S SZ ÔÒRWU[O RS RSaO``]ZZ] W\Rcab`WOZ QWS\bWTWQ] bSQ\]Z UWQ] S W\QZca] RS Q]\ac[] OQbcOZ _cS S\ OZUc\]a QOa]a Sfb`S[]a SabO ^]\WS\R] S\ XcSU] ZO [Wa[O QOÔQWROR RS ac^S`dWdS\QWO Vc[O\O >]` bO\b] S\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ []RS`\]a SZ `WSaU] Sa c\ SZS[S\b] [ta S\ OZUc\]a QOa]a RS ]`RS\ ^`W[]`RWOZ S\b`S SZ U`c^] X]dS\ S\bS\RWS\R] _cS {ab]a aS Sf^]\S\ O Z]a [Wa[]a S\ [cQV]a QOa]a XcabWTWQt\R]aS ^]` ZO \SQSaWROR RS SRcQOàS S\ Z]a [Wa[]a RS Sf^]\SàS O Z]a Z [WbSa g Sf^S`W[S\bO` Q]\ aca QOÔQWRORSa 3\ ac[O Ô`SQS` O _cS aS VO RSaO``]ZZOR] c\O µa]QWOZWhOQW \ S\ SZ `WSaU]¶ _cS ^`SÔÒ`t O Z]a W\RWdWRc]a [ta X dS\Sa ÔÒ S\T`S\bOàS O Z]a ^SZWU`]a _cS aS S\Q]\bÒ`t\ S\ ac bÒgSQb]`WO dWbOZ AS`t SaS\QWOZ ^]` bO\b] Q][^`S\RS` SZ `WSaU] \] a Z] RSaRS ac ZOR] QS`QO\] O ZO S[]QW \ W\QZca] ^ZOQS\bSÒ Q]\ ZO _cS OZUc\]a OP]`RO\ RSbS`[W\OROa Sf^S`WS\QWOa aW\] Q][] ZO Sf^`SaW \ RS c\O Q]\RWQW \ Q]\Q`SbO Q][] c\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] µaS` O``WSaUOR]¶ _cS SabO XcabWTWQOR] RSaRS c\O [O\SÒ RS aS` ^S\aO` OQbcO` g aS\bW` SaS\QWOZ[S\bS ^S`bS\SQWS\bS OZ Q]\QS^b] RS µaS` X]dS\ ^S`] _cS S\ RSTW\WbWdO aS ^`SaS\bO Q][] ZO [SX]` ORSQcOQW \ ^]aWPZS ÔÒ Z]a bWS[^]a _cS dWdW[]a

% 6SW[S` 1 ''& µA]QWOZ Sab`cQbc`S ^agQV]Z]Ug O\R bVS SabW[ObW]\ ]T bVS `WaY¶ /\\cOZ `SdWSe ]T A]QW]Z]Ug " "' # '

3a [ta 6SW[S` ''& % W\b`]RcQS c\ SZS[S\b] Q` bWQ] S\ ZO bS]`WhOQW \ a]P`S SZ `WSaU] 3Z `WSaU] PcaQOR] _cS SfQSRS ZO aW[^ZShO RS ZO `SZOQW \ SdS\b] \]QWd]³^`]POPWZWROR RS aS` OTSQbOR] A]abWS\S _cS SZ `WSaU] \] Sa a Z] c\O `SOQQW \ [SRWORO ^]` ZO ^`]POPWZWROR O\bS aWbcOQW]\Sa SdWRS\bS[S\bS ^SZWU`]aOa aW\] _cS OTW`[O ZO SfWabS\QWO RSZ `WSaU] Oac[WR] ^]` ^ZOQS` Q]\ SZ RSQWRWR] g Q]\dS\QWR] ^`]^ aWb] RS Q]\aSUcW` c\ `STcS`h] Q][] Ô`SQS aS` QOa] S\ SZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa OZQ]V]Z bOPOQ] `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa aW\ ^`]bSQQW \ SbQ :O bS\RS\QWO ] ^`SRWa^]aWQW \ OZ `WSaU] ac^]\S S\ Z]a X dS\Sa ZO Oac\QW \ RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a bS[SÒ`W]a Q][] c\O T]`[O RS SfVWPWQW]\Wa[] g Q][^SbWbWdWROR S\b`S SZ `Sab] RS Q][Ô S`]a g S\ ZO [Og]` O RS Z]a QOa]a dO O Oa]QWOR] O ZO aS\aOQW \ OUÒROPZS _cS ac^]\S ÔÒ SZ acXSb] Oac[W` bOZSa `WSaU]a :O bS\RS\QWO OZ `WSaU] Q]\T]`[O c\ Q]\Xc\b] RS OQbWbcRSa bS[SÒ`WOa ^S`] ¥QctZSa a]\ ZOa ^`W\QWÔZSa Òh]\Sa ^]` ZOa _cS aS ^`]RcQS\ SabS bW^] RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU] :O `Sa^cSabO Sa Q][^ZSXO gO _cS W\bS`dWS\S\ \c[S`]aOa dO`WOPZSa S\ SabS aS\bWR] 2SaRS dO`WOPZSa ^Sà]\OZSa Q]U\WbWdOa OQbWbcRW\OZSa g S[]QW]\OZSa Q][] dO`WOPZSa aWbcOQW]\OZSa a]P`S b]R] ^]` ZO W\TZcS\QWO RSZ U`c^] RS WUcOZSa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

$ 0SQY CZ`WQV $ µ:O a]QWSROR RSZ `WSaU]) VOQWO c\O \cSdO []RS`\WROR¶ 0O`QSZ]\O ]^ QWb ^ '

>]` ]bÒ Ô`bS RSPS[]a Oac[W` _cS ÔÒ [cQV]a W\RWdWRc]a ZO Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ Q]\ aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] ]^SÒ Q][] TcS\bS RS WRS\bWROR g RS Ocb]OTW`[OQW \) ZO TÒaS Q][ \ RS µSa \]`[OZ _cS Z]a X dS\Sa aS O``WSaUcS\ [Oa¶ \] a]Z] O[ÔÒ S\ ac Q]\bS\WR] SZ RSaS] RS OQ][SbS` bOZSa Sf^S`WS\QWOa aW\] _cS Z]a OU`cÔ POX] c\O aS O RS WRS\bWROR QZOÒ g ^`SQWaO g ^`SaS\bO OZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ ZO SdWRS\QWO RS ^S`bS\S\QWO OZ U`c^] X]dS\ >OÒTÒaSO\R] O ;O`f ^]RS[]a ZZSUO` O OTW`[O` _cS SZ `WSaU] S\b`S Z]a X dS\Sa bWS\S c\ dOZ]` RS ca] g c\ dOZ]` RS QO[PW]) ac ca] aS QS\bÒ S\ ZO UÒbWTWQOQW \ RS ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO g ac dOZ]` RS QO[PW] Sa ZO Sf^`SaW \ O\bS SZ [c\R] RS c\O WRS\bWROR _cS O \ aWS\R] bÒ\aWb]`WO g ST [SÒ Sa ^]RS`]aO 2S QcOZ_cWS` [O\SÒ ZO RSTW\WQW \ RS µ`WSaU]¶ b][ORO RSaRS c\ ^c\b] RS dWabO SfQZcaWdO[S\bS \SUObWd] Sa W\acTWQWS\bS ÔÒ RO` QcS\bO RS ZO `SOZWROR Q][^ZSXO RSaRS ZO _cS Sab]a X dS\Sa OP]`RO\ aca ^`]^WOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa ^]` QcO\b] µ`WSaU]¶ VO RS aS` S\bS\RWR] bO[PW{\ Q][] Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ g Oa Z] S\bWS\RS\ Z]a X dS\Sa GO 2][W\U] 1][Oa O^]abOPO S\ SZ W\T]`[S RS 8cdS\bcR " & ZO \SQSaWROR RS S\bS\RS` SZ `WSaU] RSaRS c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO [ ZbW^ZS W\bS\bOR] ac^SÒ` c\O dWaW \ RSZ Q]\QS^b] `WSaU] O\QZOR] SfQZcaWdO[S\bS S\ Z] \SUObWd] O c\] _cS aS aWb S [ta QS`QO RSZ Q]\QS^b] µSf^S`W[S\bOQW \¶ RO\R] Oa ZO ]^]`bc\WROR RS c\O [Og]` Q][^`S\aW \ RS Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RSZ U`c^] X]dS\ 2S {abOa W[tUS\Sa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa g OQbWbcRSa RO`S[]a QcS\bO S\ ZOa ^tUW\Oa aWUcWS\bSa `SZOQW]\t\R]ZOa Q]\ aWbcOQW]\Sa Q]\Q`SbOa g `SOZSa Q][] SZ aSf] ZOa R`]UOa ZO Q]\RcQQW \ SbQ

> Sà^SQbWdOa RS W\bSUÒQW \ g Ô`bWQWÔQW \( SZ PS\STWQW] [ta OZZt RSZ `WSaU]

& 1][Oa /`\Oc 2][W\U] " µ7\T]`[S 8cdS\bcR S\ 3a^O O "¶ ;OR`WR 7<8CD3

AW\ RcRO S\ SZ ^c\b] O\bS`W]` VO _cSROR] QZO`] ZO SaS\QWOZ \SQSaWROR RSZ aS` Vc[O\] RS Sf^S`W[S\bO` Z]a ORSQcOR]a ^`]QSa]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS S\ aca SbOÔa RS W\TO\QWO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g XcdS\bcR gO _cS Sab]a ^`]QSa]a aS`t\ QOÔQSa RS US\SÒ` bO\b] SZ ]^]`bc\] RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZOa QOÔQWRORSa Q]U\WbWdOa Q][] SZ RS ^]bS\QWO` ZOa TOQcZbORSa a]QWOZSa g `SZOQW]\OZSa RSZ [Wa[]

3dWRS\bS[S\bS ZO TWXOQW \ RS WRS\bWRORSa ^]` \OQW[WS\b] ] QZOaS b]ROd O [O`QO\ Q]\ TcS`hO SZ RSdS\W` dWbOZ RSZ W\RWdWRc] Oc\_cS SZ [Og]` QO[^] RS OQQW \ W\RWdWRcOZ ^S`[WbS Sd]ZcQW]\Sa W\a]a^SQVOROa VOQS OZUc\Oa R{QOROa gO aSO RS T]`[O d]Zc\bO`WO ] T]`hORO

/V]Ò PWS\ OV]Ò ^]aWPZS[S\bS [ta _cS \c\QO S\ ZO VWab]`WO a]QWOZ RS ZO Vc[O\WROR ZOa \SQSaWRORSa RS ^S`bS\S\QWO g RS `STS`S\QWOa U`cÔZSa RS Q]\ab`cQQW \ RS c\O WRS\bWROR VO\ aWR] [ta \SQSaO`WOa g ^cSabOa S\ dOZ]` ^]` Z]a W\RWdWRc]a RSaRS c\ Q`WbS`W] RS ^cÒ \SQSaWROR RS ac^S`dWdS\QWO W\RWdWRcOZ) aW S\ SZ ÔaOR] ZO ^S`bS\S\QWO O c\ U`c^] dS\ O [O`QORO ^]` ZOa QZtaWQOa QObSU]` Oa RS \OQW[WS\b] g QZOaS Sa RSQW` SZ \OQW[WS\b] ^`]d]QOPO Ocb][tbWQO[S\bS c\ O`ÒWU] ' g S\ b]R] QOa] SZ W\RWdWRc] bS\ O RS \SQSaWbO`Z] _cS RSaO`ÒWUOàS Z] QWS`b] Sa _cS ZO []RS`\WROR VO ^`]QcÒR] OZ W\RWdWRc] c\ VSQV] ^c\bcOZ RS \OQW[WS\b] ^S`] OPa]ZcbO[S\bS bÒaQS\RS\bOZ) SZ RSaO`ÒWU] Q][] ^`W\QW^W] Tc\RO[S\bOZ Sa RSQW` ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RSZ SXS`QWQW] RS ZO ZWPS`bOR RS SZSQQW \ VOabO aca [tfW[Oa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa ^`]QcÒ c\O O[^ZWbcR RS OQQW \ aW\ ^`SQSRS\bSa) 2S VSQV] Sa SZ ^`]^W] W\RWdWRc] SZ _cS RSPS RW`WUW` aca SaTcS`h]a O Q]\aSUcW` c\ O`ÒWU] _cS O\bSa dS\ O RW`SQbO[S\bS W[^Z QWb] RSaRS aca ]` US\Sa [SRWO\bS ZO SZSQQW \ RS c\ U`c^] RS `STS`S\QWO _cS aSO QOÔh RS bÒ\a[WbW`ZS ZO WRS\bWROR \SQSaO`WO

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

' :Oa `STS`S\QWOa O ZO bS]` O RSZ O`ÒWU] RSaO`ÒWU] aS S\QcS\bÒ\ Sf^cSabOa S\ 0Oc[O\\ HgU[c\b µ;]RS`\WROR Z _cWRO¶ 0cS\]a /W`Sa 4]\R] RS 1cZbcÒ 3Q]\ [WQO

3\ ZO OQbcOZWROR ZOa QObSU]` Oa RS `STS`S\QWO bÒRWQW]\OZSa O\QZOXSa aSUc`]a g acXSb]a S\ ^`W\QW^W] O ZOa ZSgSa RS c\O QWS`bO W\[cbOPWZWROR S\ SZ RSdS\W` RS Z]a bWS[^]a Ô`SQS\ SabO` S\ TÒ\QO `SU`SaWÂ&#x201E;\ ] QcO\R] [S\]a [O\WTSabO` c\O ^]bS\QWO [S\]` ÔÒ ]T`SQS` OZ W\RWdWRc] c\ ÂµSaÔQW] aSUc`]Â¶ _cS ]T`ShQO OZ W\RWdWRc] c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO [ \W[O[S\bS bÒ\_cWZWhOR]Ò OQS`QO RS ac Tcbc`] 0Oc[O\\ S\ ac S\aOg] a]P`S ZO Âµ;]RS`\WROR Z _cWROÂ¶ OQWS`bO OZ RSaQ`WPW` QWS`b] SabOR] RS O\UcabWO _cS S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR aS QWS`\S a]P`S Z]a W\RWdWRc]a S\ ac QO[W\] VOQWO c\O WRS\bWROR g `STS`S\QWO _cS QORO dSh Ô`SQS [ta RWT QWZ RS Q]\aSUcW`( ÂµAW\ S[POÙ] Sa]a QÂ&#x201E;RWU]a g Q]\RcQbOa _cS c\] ^]R O SZSUW` Q][] ^c\b]a RS ]`WS\bOQWÂ&#x201E;\ SabOPZSa g ^]` Z]a QcOZSa SÒ ^]aWPZS UcWOàS SaQOaSO\ QORO dSh [ta S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR >S`] a W[^ZWQO _cS S\ SabS [][S\b] aOZW[]a RS ZO {^]QO RS Z]a ÂµU`c^]a RS `STS`S\QWOÂ¶ ^`SOaWU\OR]a ÔÒ RSa^ZOhO`\]a VOQWO c\O SÒ RS ÂµQ][ÔÒQWÂ&#x201E;\ c\WdSàOZÂ¶ S\ ZO _cS SZ RSabW\] RS ZO ZOP]` RS Q]\ab`cQQWÂ&#x201E;\ Sabt S\R{[WQO[S\bS S W``S[SRWOPZS[S\bS W\RSTW\WR] \] ROR] RS O\bS[O\] g bWS\RS O ÔaO` ^]` \c[S`]a]a g ^`]Tc\R]a QO[PW]a O\bSa RS OZQO\hO` ac Â&#x2030;\WQ] TW\OZ dS`RORS`]( SZ TW\OZ RS ZO dWRO RSZ W\RWdWRc]Â¶ 0Oc[O\\ =^ QWb ^ !

3a ^]aWPZS ^S\aO` ^]` bO\b] _cS ZO \SQSaWROR RS O\QZOXSa dWbOZSa RS SaÔQW]a aSUc`]a g `SQ]\]QWPZSa aSO c\ VSQV] Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS `SZSdO\bS S\b`S SZ U`c^] X]dS\ AW ZO \SQSaWROR RS S\Q]\bÒ` c\ ÂµZcUO` S\ SZ [c\R]Â¶ Sa c\O QW`Qc\abO\QWO \SQSaO`WO ÔÒ QcOZ_cWS` W\RWdWRc] SabO \SQSaWROR aS`t RS ]`RS\ ac^S`W]` S\ ZOa SbOÔa RS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g XcdS\bcR R]\RS ZOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa RS RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZO ^Sà]\OZWROR Sabt\ S\ TÒ\QO Q]\ab`cQQWÂ&#x201E;\ g ^]` Z] bO\b] ZO \SQSaWROR RS O\QZOXSa `STS`S\QWOZSa Sa [Og]` 3Z U`c^] RS Ô`Sa Q][] gO VS[]a Q][S\bOR] O\bS`W]`[S\bS Ô`SQS SZ Â&#x2030;\WQ] aSUc`] `STcUW] O\bS ZO [Og]` RSPWZWROR RS ]bÒa W\abWbcQW]\Sa a]QWOZWhOR]`Sa g ^`]dSSR]Òa RS WRS\bWROR TO[WZWO g SaQcSZO 3a S\ SabS U`c^] RS `STS`S\QWO R]\RS Z]a XÂ&#x201E;dS\Sa dO\ O RSaO``]ZZO` OZUc\]a RS Z]a SZS[S\b]a [ta W[^]`bO\bSa RS ac Q]\ab`cQQWÂ&#x201E;\ W\RWdWRcOZ) Sa c\ bS``S\] RS a]QWOZWhOQWÂ&#x201E;\ W\T]`[OZ S\ SZ _cS Z]a XÂ&#x201E;dS\Sa aS S\QcS\bÒ\ Q]\ Z]a Ô`Sa g Q][WS\hO\ O Sf^S`W[S\bO` W\RWdWRcOZ g U`cÔZ[S\bS Q]\ ZOa Q]aOa S\ b]`\] O ZOa QcOZSa O^c\bOZO`t\ ac WRS\bWROR g aS aWbcO`t\ S\ SZ QO[W\] RS ac [ORc`Sh 3abO a]QWOZWhOQWÂ&#x201E;\ [O`QO`t RS VSQV] c\O Ô`bS W[^]`bO\bS RS aca OQbWbcRSa g Q`SS\QWOa S\ ZO SbOÔ X]dS\ RS bOZ [O\SÒ _cS SabO Sa W\acabWbcWPZS g ac OcaS\QWO RS dWdS Q][] c\O Ocb{\bWQO aS\aOQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS ^{`RWRO G SZ `WSaU] SdWRS\bS[S\bS Sa c\ SZS[S\b] ^`SaS\bS ^]` RSTW\WQWÂ&#x201E;\ S\ ZOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa U`cÔZSa S W\RWdWRcOZSa RS Z]a XÂ&#x201E;dS\Sa \] bO\b] ^]` aca QOÒQbS` abWQOa RS ^SZWU`] aW\] Q][] VS[]a O\]bOR] S\ SZ ^c\b] O\bS`W]` ^]` ac QOÔQWROR RS ^`]dSS` RS Sf^S`WS\QWOa _cS aS ^S`QWPS\ Q][] W\RWa^S\aOPZSa ÔÒ S\T`S\bOàS O ZO dWRO g ^]` SZ Q][^]\S\bS RS ^ZOQS` g S[]QWÂ&#x201E;\ RS ZOa _cS OZUc\Oa a]\ QOÔQSa RS ^`]dSS` OZ X]dS\ :O W\bSUÒQWÂ&#x201E;\ ^]` bO\b] Sa OPa]ZcbO[S\bS dWbOZ bO\b] _cS SZ PS\STWQW] O Q]\aSUcW` RS ZO [Wa[O Sa [cg ac^S`W]` S\ OZUc\]a QOa]a O Z]a ^]bS\QWOZSa `WSaU]a S\T`S\bOR]a RSaRS ZO dWaWÂ&#x201E;\ XcdS\WZ :O ^S`QS^QWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ `WSaU] ^]` Z] bO\b] VO POaQcZOR] S\b`S ZO XcdS\bcR) aS W\bS`^`SbO S\ PcS\O [SRWRO _cS SZ Ocb{\bWQ] `WSaU] c\ `WSaU] [Og]` _cS SZ RS QWS`bOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa O OT`]\bO` ^cSRS aS` aWUcWS\R] ZO Z \SO

8Â&#x201E;dS\Sa g USabWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ `WSaU]

OÙc[S\bObWdO RS ;OZcT At\QVSh >S`cUOhW g 1SPOZZ]a SZ \] Z]UÒ` ZO OQS^bOQW \ W\bS`^Sà]\OZ S W\bS`Ô`Sa :O ac^SÒQW \ RS SabS `WSaU] aS dW\QcZO S\ [cQV]a QOa]a O ZO `SOZWhOQW \ RS ^`tQbWQOa W\RWdWRcOZSa ] U`cÔZSa _cS ZW\RO\ Q]\ aWbcOQW]\Sa Sfb`S[Oa RS OR]^bO` QWS`b]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a g OQbWbcRSa _cS Oc\_cS \] aSO\ RS ac OUÒR] ] \] aS Sab{ b]bOZ[S\bS Q]\dS\QWR] RS aca Q]\aSQcS\QWOa `SOZSa aS OQS^bO`t\ S\ Tc\QW \ RS RSaO``]ZZO` c\ aS\bWR] RS ^S`bS\S\QWO O c\ U`c^] S\ ZO \SQSaWROR RS R]bO` RS aS\bWR] O aca OQQW]\Sa g Z]UÒ` `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] S\ ac [c\R] a]QWOZ 2S VSQV] \c[S`]aOa W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa g ROb]a VO\ RSbSQbOR] _cS ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS ZO SfQZcaW \ RSZ U`c^] Sa ^S`QWPWRO Q][] c\ `WSaU] UÒdS _cS ObOQO OZ aS\bWR] RS ^S`bS\S\QWO RSZ U`c^] g O ZO Q]\T]`[OQW \ RS ZO WRS\bWROR g _cS ^`SaS\bO Z]a [Wa[]a ^SZWU`]a Oc\_cS RS ]b`] ]`RS\ _cS ]b`]a `WSaU]a [ta SdWRS\bSa O ^`W]`W Q][] Z]a Q]\ac[]a RS acabO\QWOa Q]\RcQW` POX] Z]a STSQb]a RSZ OZQ]V]Z ] [O\bS\S` `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa aW\ ^`]bSQQW \ :O \SQSaWROR RS Q][^SbW` RS Ô`bWQWÔ` ] RS ^S`bS\SQS` OZ U`c^] RS `STS`S\QWO Sa RS bOZ QOZOR] _cS Sa ^]aWPZS Q]\aWRSÒ` _cS S\ QWS`bOa ]QOaW]\Sa Z]a []dW[WS\b]a g ZOa RSQWaW]\Sa RS OQQW \ dWS\S\ ] dS\R`t\ ]`WS\bOROa ^]` ZO \SQSaWROR RS aS` g RS Q]\abWbcWàS Q]\ aca Ô`Sa 3Z `WSaU] RS \] W\QZcaW \ S\ SabS aS\bWR] Sa dWab] ^]` Z]a W\RWdWRc]a X dS\Sa bO\b] RSaRS ac ZOR] RS O[S\OhO S\bS\RWRO SabO Q][] SZ S[^]P`SQW[WS\b] RS ac dWRO Q][] RSaRS SZ PS\STWQW] ^`SdWab] S\ ZO W\bSUÒQW \ Q]\ ac U`c^]) gO aSO RWdS`bWàS Sf^S`W[S\bO` ] Q]\dS`bWàS RS VSQV] S\ [WS[P`]a ]^SÒbWd]a g aWU\WTWQObWd]a RS\b`] RSZ U`c^] :O W\bSUÒQW \ Q]\ Z]a Ô`Sa ORS[ta bWS\RS O acPXSbWdO` RS [O\SÒ W[^]`bO\bS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU]a [SRWO\bS ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ RS ZOh]a OTSQbWd]a g RS a]ZWRO`WROR _cS aS Q]\TWUcÒ\ Q][] Ocb{\bWQOa µ`SRSa RS aSUc`WROR¶ [SRWO\bS ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ RS ZOh]a RS Q][Ô S`Wa[] g TWRSZWROR _cS ^S`[WbS\ Q][Ô`bW` µZ] PcS\] g Z] [OZ]¶ RS ZOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa dWbOZSa µAW\ [W\cadOZ]Ò` ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RS RSbS`[W\OR]a VtPWb]a ] Q]\RcQbOa \W RSXO` RS `SQZO[O` c\O ^]Z bWQO ^`SdS\bWdO Q]\abO\bS g ObS\bO bO[^]Q] ^]RS[]a ]PdWO` _cS S\ ZO QOÒ ]^cSabO ^S`] Q][^ZS[S\bO`WO RS Z] _cS ac^]\S\ `WSaU]a ÔÒ OR]ZSaQS\bSa g X dS\Sa SfWabS c\ Q][^]\S\bS RS O^`S\RWhOXS g a]QWOZWhOQW \ _cS ^cSRS Q]\dS`bW` RSbS`[W\OROa OQQW]\Sa S\ Sf^S`WS\QWOa dWbOZSa ^]aWbWdOa 7\bS\bO` \SUO` ZO SdWRS\QWO RS RSbS`[W\OR]a Ôa]a RS Z]a [ta X dS\Sa [W VWX] O \] PSPS ] \] aS S[P]`ÒQVO O \ \] bWS\S `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa \] bWS\S Q]\bOQb] Q]\ ZOa R`]UOa aW[^ZS[S\bS ObS\RWS\R] O ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa [ta RS[]\WhOR]Òa RS bOZSa Q]\RcQbOa \]a OZSXO`t RS ZO `SOZWROR RS ZOa Q]\RcQbOa g aca []bWdOQW]\Sa g ^]` bO\b] RS ZO [SX]` [O\SÒ RS OP]`RO` g ^`SdS\W` Z]a ^]aWPZSa `WSaU]a ¶

@]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ Sb OZW % µ3Z `WSaU] S\ Z]a Q]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa) c\O O^`]fW[OQW \ RSaRS Z]a SZS[S\b]a _cS ]`WS\bO\ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ acPXSbWdO S\ ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa¶ ]^ QWb ^ !% 4/2

3a [ta ZO W\QZcaW \ S\ Z]a Ô`t[Sb`]a RS µOQbcOQW \ X]dS\¶ Sa RSaSOPZS ^]`_cS W\abOcÒ c\O µ\]`[OZWROR¶ RSaSOPZS bO\b] ^]` Z]a X dS\Sa Q][] ^]` Z]a ÔR`Sa _cS bWS\RS\ O Oac[W` ZO W\SdWbOPWZWROR dWdWRO Q]\ ^`S]QcÔQW \ aW\ RcRO RS QWS`b]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU] S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZO bO\ RSaSORO \]`[OZWROR) S\ µ/R]ZSaQS\bSa O\bS SZ OZQ]V]Z¶ ;SU Oa % aS ^`SaS\bO RS T]`[O O Z]a ^`]US\Wb]`Sa g bO[^]Q] O Z]a VWX]a \] ZSa W\bS`SaO ZO ^Sà]\OZWROR \W ZO Sa^SQWOZ WRW]aW\QÒaWO Q][] W\RWdWRc] _cS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

^]aSS\ QORO c\] RS SZZ]a Z]a X dS\Sa ) Z] _cS W[^]`bO Sa _cS Qc[^ZO\ c\O aS`WS RS `Wb]a ] `SUZOa _cS PcaQO\ O\bS b]R] SZ S\QOXS ORSQcOR] S\ SZ QcS`^] a]QWOZ ZO \]`[OZWROR AS` \]`[OZ \] RSabOQO` \] RO` ^`]PZS[Oa Sa ZO \WQO dOÒ RS [SRW` _cS Z]a ÔR`Sa b][O\ S\ Q]\aWRSÒQW \

2S SabO [O\SÒ ZO W\bSUÒQW \ S\ U`c^] \] a]Z] Z]UÒ Q`SO` S\ SZ W\RWdWRc] c\O aS\aOQW \ RS ^S`bS\S\QWO RS µ\]`[OZWROR¶ aW\] _cS Q][] dS`S[]a S\ SZ ^c\b] aWUcWS\bS Sa QOÔh RS RWZcW` ZOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa RS `WSaU]

! @WSaU]a S\ SZ ]QW]( `WSaU]a acPXSbWd]a GO VS[]a W\RWQOR] RS [O\SÒ a][SÒ S W\WQWOZ _cS ZOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa RS `WSaU] Sabt\ RSQWRWRO[S\bS a][SbWROa O ZO dOÒ RS [SRW` RS c\ ^S`QS^QW \ acPXSbWdO RSZ [Wa[] ^S`QS^QW \ _cS RSdWS\S RS c\ Q]\ab`cQb] a]QWOZ U`cÔZ g S\ Sa^SQWOZ RS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ [ta ] [S\]a aSaUORO S\ QcO\b] O ZOa g Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RS ZOa OQQW]\Sa _cS S\bÒ O\ `WSaU]a 3\ ]bÒa ÔZOPÒa g aWUcWS\R] O 1SPOZZ]a ZO SZSQQW \ ] OQS^bOQW \ RS RSbS`[W\OR] bW^] RS `WSaU]a VOPZO [ta RSZ bW^] RS a]QWSROR S\ ZO _cS dWdS g RSaSO dWdW` c\ W\RWdWRc] _cS RS aca SabW[OQW]\Sa ^`]POPWZWabOa ! AW OQS^bO[]a SabS Òh]\O[WS\b] VOP`S[]a RS SabO` RS OQcS`R] Q]\ 2]cUZOa g EWZROeaYg '' QcO\R] `STWS`S\ _cS ZO \]QW \ RS `WSaU] ^]` bO\b] \] aS POaO S\ SdWRS\QWO S[^ `WQO \W S\ Òh]\Sa ^`tQbWQOa aW\] _cS Sabt Q]\ab`cWRO QcZbcÒZ[S\bS RS []R] _cS S\ QORO Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ aS RSabOQO\ c\]a `WSaU]a g aS WU\]Ò\ ] `SRcQS\ ]b`]a 3fWabS Oa c\O µQcZbcÒ RSZ `WSaU]¶ RSbS`[W\ORO Ô`bWQcZO` S W\bÒ\aTS`WPZS Oa]QWORO O ZO ^]aWQW \ a]QWOZ RS Z]a OQb]`Sa VOQWS\R] _cS Z]a ^SZWU`]a aSO\ aWS[^`S WRS\bWTWQOR]a Q][] bOZSa Q][c\WQOR]a g USabW]\OR]a O bÒd{a RS c\ TWZb`] QcZbcÒZ _cS Sa Ô`bWQcZO` /a c\ ^SZWU`] Q][] aWU\] OPa]Zcb] RS c\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] \] Sa c\ ROb] \WQ] g SfQZcaWd] _cS aW`dO ÔÒ SZOP]Ò` c\O aSZSQQW \ ÒQW]\OZ RS Z]a `WSaU]a( SfWabS c\O aSZSQQW \ g c\O Q]\ab`cQQW \ a]QWOZ RS Z]a `WSaU]a O bÒd{a RS Z]a QcOZSa {ab]a a]\ TWZbÒR]a g dOZ]ÒR]a >OWQVSZS` ''$

;SU Oa 3caSPW] Q]]`RW\OR]` % µ/R]ZSaQS\bSa O\bS SZ OZQ]V]Z) ZO [W`ORO RS ^OR`Sa g [OR`Sa¶ ]^ QWb ^ !" 4/2 :O 1OWfO

>]` Z] bO\b] ^cSRS SfWabW` RS VSQV] SfWabS c\O RWa]\O\QWO S\b`S SabW[OQW]\Sa b{Q\WQOa ] µQWS\b TWQOa¶ RSZ `WSaU] g ZO ^S`QS^QW \ ^ PZWQO ] W\RWdWRcOZ RSZ [Wa[] _cS \]a VO Q]\RcQWR] O ZO \]QW \ RS µ`WSaU] ^S`QWPWR]¶ ] µ`WSaU] acPXSbWd]¶ 3abO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] [SRWObWhORO ^]` TOQb]`Sa RS ]`RS\ QcZbcÒZ Q]\bSfbcOZ g ^Sà]\OZ aS ^`SaS\bO RS []R] O[^ZWTWQOR] S\ Sa^SQWOZ S\ c\O RSbS`[W\ORO Q]\TWUcÒQW \ SaÔQWOZ g bS[^]ÒZ R]\RS SZ U`c^] X]dS\ RSaO``]ZZO c\O RS aca OQbWdWRORSa [ta QOÒQbS` abWQOa g RSTW\Wb]`WOa SZ ]QW] 3\ SabS QOa] aW QOPS O \ [ta _cS S\ ]b`]a Z]a XcWQW]a W\bcWbWd]a a]P`S SZ `WSaU] Sabt\ `SZOQW]\OR]a bO\b] Q]\ Sab`cQbcÒa ^Sà]\OZSa Q]U\]aQWbWdOa S[]QW]\OZSa g RS []bWdOQW \ Q][] Q]\ Z]a O[PWS\bSa a]QWOZSa QcZbcÒZSa S W\QZca] ^]Z bWQ]a

! 2 Oh 1SPOZZ]a /\O ;O` O µ:O ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] a]P`S Z]a \WdSZSa RS OQS^bOPWZWROR RSZ [Wa[]¶ ;OR`WR

3Z ^`W[S`] RS Z]a SZS[S\b]a _cS O^c\bO\ O ZO RWa[W\cQW \ RS ZO ^SZWU`]aWROR S\ SZ bWS[^] RS ]QW] RSZ U`c^] X]dS\ Sa RSQW` RSQ`S[S\b] RS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] Sabt `SZOQW]\OR] Q]\ SZ Q]\QS^b] RS dcZ\SÒPWZWROR) aW RSTW\W[]a O ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR Q][] ZO µTÒQQW \ Sab`cQbcÒZ RSZ `WSaU] QcgO `SRcQQW \ a]Z] ^cSRS aS` Z]UÒRO ^]` SZ aWabS[O¶ 1tQS`Sa ''' Oac[W`S[]a _cS S\ SZ bWS[^] RS ]QW] ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS ^SZWU`] S\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a g Q]\ac[]a aS dS aSdSÒ[S\bS `SPOXORO ^]` ZO ^`SaS\QWO g OaWabS\QWO RSZ U`c^] RS `STS`S\QWO _cS S\ SabS QOa] ]^SÒ Q][] aWabS[O) O[WU]a g Q]ZSUOa OQb O\

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

Sab`cQbcÒZ[S\bS Q][] c\O `SR RS `STS`S\QWO g OcfWZW] S\ ZO _cS SZ W\RWdWRc] aS ^`]bSUS g S\ SZ ^S]` RS Z]a QOa]a aS `STcUWO O\bS Q]\aSQcS\QWOa W\RSaSOROa RS aca Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a ] Q]\ac[]a) ZO TÒaS µZ]a Q]ZSUOa [S QcWRO\¶ `Sac[S RS [O\SÒ STSQbWdO c\O ^]aWQW \ Oac[WRO ^]` c\O [Og]` O RS X dS\Sa ^]`_cS RS VSQV] ZOa OQbcOQW]\Sa Q]ZSQbWdOa g Z]a Q]\ac[]a RS acabO\QWOa S\ U`c^] ^S`[WbS\ Oc[S\bO` \]b]`WO[S\bS OZ X]dS\ SZ c[PÒZ RS ^SZWU`] OZ _cS SabO RWa^cSab] O Sf^]\SàS g ^]` bO\b] SZ \WdSZ g ZO dO`WSROR RS `WSaU]a O Z]a _cS Sabt\ RWa^cSab]a O ]^bO` 3Z bS[]` Q][^]\S\bS Tc\RO[S\bOZ S\ ZO SQcOQW \ `WSaU]a PS\STWQW]a _cSRO Oa aSdSÒ[S\bS ObS[^SÒR] 3Z aWUcWS\bS Oa^SQb] O SdOZcO` S\ SZ SabcRW] RS ZO acPXSbWdWROR RSZ `WSaU] S\ SZ bWS[^] RS ]QW] S\b`S ZO XcdS\bcR bWS\S _cS dS` Q]\ c\O QWS`bO W\QOÔQWROR RS O\tZWaWa ]PXSbWd] RS aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] _cS VO aWR] acabWbcWR] aWUcWS\R] O :cV[O\ " ^]` c\O ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ [Wa[] ac^cSabO[S\bS ]PXSbWdO ^S`] S\UO ]aO µ:O W\QS`bWRc[P`S [Wa[O Q][^]\S\bS O\SfOR] O ZO TOZbO RS QS`bShO g bO[PW{\ O ORW` O[]a \]a]b`]a RS W\T]`[OQW \ a]P`S c\ OQ]\bSQW[WS\b] ZS RO c\ QO`tQbS` acPXSbWd] OZ ZZO[OR] µ`WSaU] ]PXSbWd]¶ ZO ^`]POPWZWROR acPXSbWdO RSZ µ`WSaU] ]PXSbWd]¶ ^`]^WQWO c\O ^S`QS^QW \ W\ORSQcORO RSZ `WSaU]¶ >]` SXS[^Z] b][S[]a S\ Q]\aWRSÒQW \ ZO OZbO ^`]POPWZWROR RS ]Qc``S\QWO RS c\ OQQWRS\bS RS b`tTWQ] aW aS VO\ Q]\ac[WR] OZQ]V]Z c ]bÒa acabO\QWOa 3Z X]dS\ _cS Q]\RchQO S\ SabS SabOR] ] aSO OQ][Ô O\bS RS c\ Q]\RcQb]` S[P`WOUOR] ^S\aO`t RSaRS ZcSU] Z] ^WS\aO\ Z]a X dS\Sa g \] bO\ X dS\Sa OZ d]ZO\bS µSa] \] [S dO O ÔaO` O [ ¶ gO aSO ^]`_cS bWS\S S\ OZbO SabW[O aca R]bSa Q][] Q]\RcQb]` RSZ ]`RS\ RS c\O ^S`QS^QW \ acPXSbWdO bÒ\aT]`[ORO S\ `SOZWROR ]PXSbWdO µg] a{ Q]\RcQW`¶ ] ^]`_cS RSaQ]\]QS RS T]`[O ]PXSbWdO Z]a STSQb]a _cS a]P`S Z]a `STZSX]a g ZO QOÔQWROR RS Q]\b`]Z RSZ dSV QcZ] bWS\S SZ OZQ]V]Z ^S`QS^QW \ S\UO ]aO ^S`] _cS `SRcQS ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S 7\QZca] SfWabS c\O ^]`QW \ RS Q]\RcQb]`Sa X dS\Sa _cS Sabt\ RS OQcS`R] Q]\ ZO OTW`[OQW \ RS _cS µQ]\ OZQ]V]Z aS Q]\RcQS [SX]`¶ # Z] _cS [O\WTWSabO O[^ZWO[S\bS ZO W\bS` acPXSbWdWROR O ZO _cS SabO Sf^cSabO SabS Q]\ac[]

" :cV[O\ <WYZOa '' µA]QW]Z]U O RSZ `WSaU]¶ ;{fWQ] C\WdS`aWROR 7PS`]O[S`WQO\O

3\ ]bÒa ]QOaW]\Sa a SfWabS ZO QS`bShO RS `WSaU]a `SOZSa Q]\Q`Sb]a g RSTW\WR]a ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] aS acPXSbWdWhO`t ^]` SZ RSa^ZOhO[WS\b] RS ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa \SUObWdOa O c\ ac^cSab] Tcbc`] S\ SZ _cS Q][] \] aS Q][^]\R`t\ Z]a Z [WbSa RS Z] OQS^bOPZS g \] OQS^bOPZS) 3abS RSa^ZOhO[WS\b] Sa [ta SdWRS\bS aW QOPS aW b][O[]a Q][] `STS`S\QWO SZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa g ]bÒa acabO\QWOa S\ SZ bWS[^] RS ]QW]) aW Q][] VO aWR] [O\WTWSabO[S\bS RS[]abÒR] S\ QWTÒa Z]a W\RWdWRc]a X dS\Sa aS SfbÒZW[WbO\ S\ Z]a Q]\ac[]a RS OZQ]V]Z RS [O\SÒ aWabS[tbWQO S\ ac bWS[^] RS ]QW] ^S`] O \ Oa a]\ [O\WTWSabO[S\bS Q]\aQWS\bS RS aca STSQb]a RO W\]a POabO`t Q]\ `Sa]ZdS` SabO RWa]\O\QWO Q]U\WbWdO [SRWO\bS SZ RSa^ZOhO[WS\b] RS ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa \SUObWdOa RSZ [Wa[] O c\ Tcbc`] ZSXO\] S\ SZ _cS aS b][O`t\ ZOa [SRWROa ^S`bW\S\bSa ÔÒ _cS Z]a STSQb]a \]QWd]a \] aS [O\WTWSabS\) µQcO\R] aSO [Og]` \] [S S[P]`ÒQVO`{¶

# G $ @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ Sb OZW % µ3Z `WSaU] S\ Z]a Q]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa) c\O O^`]fW[OQW \ RSaRS Z]a SZS[S\b]a _cS ]`WS\bO\ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ acPXSbWdO S\ ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa¶ ]^ QWb ^ !% 4/2

=b`] RS Z]a [ObWQSa W[^]`bO\bSa O ZO V]`O RS O\OZWhO` ZO acPXSbWdWROR RSZ O\tZWaWa RS Z]a `WSaU]a S\b`S ZO XcdS\bcR Sa ZO RWTS`S\QWO S\b`S Z]a Q]\QS^b]a RS Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ g VtPWb] aWUcWS\R] ZO Z \SO O`Uc[S\bObWdO ^`SaS\bORO ^]` @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ % Sa QWS`b] _cS S\ ZOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa RS `WSaU] SZ \WdSZ RS W\QS`bWRc[P`S g bS[]` Q`SORO ^]` c\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] ] Q]\ac[] aS []RWTWQO aW aS W\b`]RcQS ZO dO`WOPZS `S^SbWQW \ ^]` c\ [ta _cS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

Oac[WR] Q]\QS^b] SZS[S\bOZ a]P`S ZO ^`]POPWZWROR _cS SdWRS\QWO _cS ZO ]Qc``S\QWO RS c\ acQSa] S\ SabS QOa] RS Q]\aSQcS\QWOa \SUObWdOa RS c\ Q]\ac[] ] Q][^]`bO[WS\b] bWS\RS O Oc[S\bO` S\ Tc\QW \ RSZ \ [S`] RS `S^SbWQW]\Sa _cS aS VOUO RSZ [Wa[] 2S SabS []R] ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] S\ Z] _cS aS `STWS`S O Q]\ac[]a g Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a Sabt PtaWQO[S\bS ZWUORO OZ Q]\QS^b] RS VtPWb]) <] ]Qc``W`t \ORO [OZ] OZ [S\]a aS ^S`QWPS Q][] RS [cg RWT QWZ ]Qc``S\QWO aW SZ W\RWdWRc] aS ZW[WbO O ^`]PO` ] Sf^S`W[S\bO` Q]\ Q]\ac[]a ] Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a c\ \ [S`] `SRcQWR] RS dSQSa ^cSab] _cS SZ `WSaU] ^]` SfQSZS\QWO aS RO S\ ZO RS^S\RS\QWO Sa RSQW` S\ ZO `S^SbWQW \ `SWbSÒRO g Q]\bW\cO 3a Oa Q][] RS VSQV] SabO ^`Sac\QW \ RS POX] `WSaU] ^S`QWPWR] O\W[O g T]`bOZSQS ZO Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ S\b`S Z]a X dS\Sa gO aSO S\ aca Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS `WSaU] \] ÔaO \ORO ^]` Q]\RcQW` OZUc\O dSh Q]\ OZQ]V]Z ] S\ aca Q]\ac[]a RS acabO\QWOa ! @SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa( SZ `WSaU] RS R]PZS TWZ] :O ^Sà^SQbWdO RS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa S\ ZOa TOaSa RS OR]ZSaQS\QWO g XcdS\bcR bWS\S c\ Q][^]\S\bS QS\bÒZ S\ ZO dWRO RS Z]a W\RWdWRc]a gO _cS T]`[O\ Ô`bS SaS\QWOZ RSZ Q]\Xc\b] RS Sf^S`WS\QWOa ^`]^WOa RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZOa SRORSa XcdS\WZSa 3Z aSf] OZ [S\]a bO\b] Q][] ]b`]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a g [cQVOa dSQSa O \ [ta _cS SZZ]a ^cSRS [O\WTSabOàS RS c\O T]`[O Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS ^]RS`]aO RORO ZO SROR g Z]a RSaS]a RS Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ _cS SZZ] Q]\ZZSdO O[{\ RS SabO` W[^ZWQOR]a S\ ZO OQbWdWROR aSfcOZ \] a]Z] ZO P a_cSRO RSZ ^ZOQS` [Wa[] aW\] bO[PW{\ RS [O\SÒ [ta ] [S\]a RW`SQbO SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS Z]a OTSQb]a g aS\bW[WS\b]a GO S\ $ SZ W\T]`[S a]P`S X dS\Sa dOZ]`Sa g R`]UOa ;SU Oa g 3Zh] $ $ aS OTW`[OPO _cS Z]a X dS\Sa RS S\b`S # g " O ]a ]b]ÙOPO\ c\O \]bO RS & a]P`S c\ [tfW[] RS O ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RS bS\S` c\O dWRO aSfcOZ ^ZS\O g aObWaTOQb]`WO :O SROR [SRWO RSZ W\RWQW] RS `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa Sa RS $ # O ]a aSU \ ROb]a RSZ [W\WabS`W] RS aO\WROR g Q]\ac[] RSZ O ] $ 3\ SZ ZOR] \SUObWd] c\Oa " [S\]`Sa OP]`bO`]\ S\ SZ [Wa[] O ] aSU \ Z]a ROb]a RSZ ;W\WabS`W] RS AO\WROR aWS\R] SabO bOaO c\O RS ZOa [ta OZbOa S\b`S Z]a Ô aSa RS ZO C\W \ 3c`]^SO

$ ;SU Oa 3caSPW] g 3Zh] 8OdWS` µ8 dS\Sa dOZ]`Sa g R`]UOa¶ ;OR`WR % % O 3\QcSabO AQVS`W\U RS aSfcOZWROR g O\bWQ]\QS^QW \ S\ ZO XcdS\bcR Sa^O ]ZO $

>]` ]b`] ZOR] c\ " RS Z]a X dS\Sa SaÔ ]ZSa S\b`S # g " O ]a `SQ]\]QS OR]^bO` Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] S\ aca `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa aSU \ `SQ]US\ Z]a ROb]a RS ZO µASUc\RO S\QcSabO AQVS`W\U a]P`S aSfcOZWROR g O\bWQ]\QS^QW \ S\ ZO XcdS\bcR SaÔ ]ZO¶ `SOZWhORO ^]` SZ S_cW^] 2O^V\S % 3Z SabcRW] `SdSZO Oa [Wa[] _cS [ta RS !&' [cXS`Sa X dS\Sa aS S\QcS\bÒ\ S\ aWbcOQW \ RS `WSaU] RS acT`W` c\ S[POÒh] \] RSaSOR]

& 3\ µ:O aSfcOZWROR RS Z]a X dS\Sa dWabO RSaRS Z]a ÔR`Sa¶ 1]\RS 4S`\O\R] # aS S\QcS\bÒ c\O RSbOZZORO dWaW \ RS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ ÔbS`\O a]P`S ZOa OQbWdWRORSa aSfcOZSa RS aca VWX]a

B]R]a Sab]a ROb]a \]a W\RWQO\ RS T]`[O QZOÒ _cS SZ aSf] S\ QWS`b]a QOa]a Sa RSaRS c\O [WÒRO SfbS`\O c\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] RS `WSaU] S\b`S ZO XcdS\bcR SaÔ ]ZO ^]` ZOa [ta _cS SdWRS\bSa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa W\RSaSOROa _cS ZOa ^`tQbWQOa aSfcOZSa aW\ ^`]bSQQW \ QOcaO\ 3dWRS\bS[S\bS SZ RSaS] RS Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ g RSaQcP`W[WS\b] RS ac aSfcOZWROR T]`[O Ô`bS RS Z] Sa^SÒPZS S\b`S ZO XcdS\bcR g bO[PW{\ S\b`S Z]a ^`]US\Wb]`Sa aOPSR]`Sa _cS SZ aSf] SabO TÒ\QO[S\bS c\WR] O ZO SbOÔ RS Sd]ZcQW \ g [ORcÒQW \ Oa Q][] _cS RSaRS ac ^c\b] RS dWabO ZOa Q]aOa Q]\ `Sa^SQb] O ZO SRcQOQW \ aSfcOZ aS VO\ dWab] bS WROa RS [Og]` ZWPSÒZWROR g ^]` Q]\aWUcWS\bS RS [S\]` `S^`SaW \ &

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

3Z VSQV] RS ZO W\WQWOQW \ aSfcOZ ^cSRS W\bS`^`SbOàS Q][] c\] RS Z]a [ta W[^]`bO\bSa `Wb]a RS Ôa] O ZO dWRO ORcZbO 2S [O\SÒ [Og]`WbO`WO Z]a W\RWdWRc]a X dS\Sa ^`Sac^]\S\ _cS SZ aSf] Sa c\ Q][^]\S\bS SaS\QWOZ S\ aca `SZOQW]\Sa bO\b] Sa^]`tRWQOa Q][] [ta ] [S\]a SabOPZSa ^]`_cS [ta OZZt RSZ ^ZOQS` PcaQOR] S\ SZ ^`]^W] OQb] SabS Q]\aWUcS OQbWdO` OZ [S\]a S\ Ô`bS c\ \WdSZ Q][c\WQObWd] RS ]`RS\ ac^S`W]` ORS[ta RS Sf^S`W[S\bO` g RSaQcP`W` SZ ^`]^W] QcS`^] g SZ OXS\] /a _cS SZ aSf] Sa PcaQOR] \] a]Z] Q][] ]PXSb] RS UÒbWTWQOQW \ T aWQO aW\] ^]`_cS ac^]\S SZ SabOPZSQW[WS\b] RS ZOh]a [ta \bW[]a g ^Sà]\OZSa ] ZO ^`]Tc\RWhOQW \ RS Z]a [Wa[]a ' 3\ \c[S`]aOa ]QOaW]\Sa VO aWR] RS[]abÒR] _cS OZ [S\]a S\ Z] RSQZOÒbWd] Z]a W\RWdWRc]a X dS\Sa a]\ Q]\aQWS\bSa RS Z]a `WSaU]a ]PXSbWd]a RS ZOa ^`tQbWQOa aSfcOZSa `SOZWhOROa aW\ ^`]bSQQW \) aW\ S[POÙ] ÔÒ Z]a [Wa[]a Z]a [Og]`Sa `WSaU]a ^`]dWS\S\ RS ]b`]a SZS[S\b]a Oa]QWOR]a O bOZSa ^`tQbWQOa) S\ SaS\QWO aW PWS\ Sa QWS`b] _cS SfWabS c\O ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU]a ]PXSbWd]a S[POÒh]a \] RSaSOR]a S\TS`[SRORSa RS bÒ\a[WaW \ aSfcOZ Sab]a \] Ô`SQS\ aS` ZO ^`W]`WROR RS bOZ [O\SÒ _cS ÔÒ Z]a V][P`Sa SZ `WSaU] S\ ZO OQbWdWROR aSfcOZ aS QS\bÒ S\ ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS ^S`RS` ]^]`bc\WRORSa ] [ta ^`S]QcÔ\bS ÔÒ SZZ]a RS \] `Sa^]\RS` O ZO Sf^SQbObWdO Qc[^ZW` g ÔÒ ZOa QVWQOa S\ ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS SQVO` O ^S`RS` `SZOQW]\Sa OTSQbWdOa _cS W\bS`SaO\ ORS[ta RSZ `WSaU] _cS aS ^S`QWPS RS [O\SÒ [ta OUcRO SZ RS µ\] UcabO`¶ \] aS` RSaSORO ] \] Ô`SQS` µObÒQbWdO¶ 3abO QZO`] _cS VOg _cS O\]bO` O_c ZOa aS\aWPZSa RWTS`S\QWOa S\ SZ RWaQcà] a]P`S aSf] g `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa _cS ^`SaS\bO\ V][P`Sa g [cXS`Sa g ^]` bO\b] RS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RWTS`S\QWOZ _cS a]P`S SZ `WSaU] [O\WTWSabO\ O[P]a U{\S`]a :]a SabS`S]b ^]a RSQZOÒR]a Q]\dS\WS\bS[S\bS SabcRWOR]a O^c\bO\ O ZOa RWabW\bOa ^`W]`WRORSa a]P`S SZ aSf] S\ Tc\QW \ RSZ U{\S`]) [WS\bÒa Z]a QVWQ]a ^`W]`WhO\ Z]a Oa^SQb]a ^cÒ[S\bS T aWQ]a g ^ZOQS\bS`]a RS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa Z] QcOZ ^`]^WQWO _cS \] _cWSÒ\ µ^S`RS` ZO ]^]`bc\WROR¶ RS ^ÒQbWQO` aSf] ZOa QVWQOa RSQZOÒ\ O\bS^]\S` Z]a Oa^SQb]a [ta OTSQbWd]a g `SZOQW]\OZSa 3abO QOÙO OTSQbWdO _cS RSQZOÒ\ RSa^ZSUO` ZOa [cXS`Sa S\ [Og]` [SRWRO _cS Z]a V][P`Sa ZOa Sf^]\S O c\ R]PZS `WSaU] gO aSO S\ `SZOQW]\Sa Sa^]`tRWQOa ] Q]\ Ô`SXO SabOPZS <] a]ZO[S\bS aS`t\ ZOa [ta OTSQbOROa S\ QcO\b] ^]` SXS[^Z] O Z]a S[POÒh]a \] RSaSOR]a aW\] _cS RSaRS SZ ^c\b] RS dWabO OTSQbWd] a]\ ZOa _cS [ta RWQS\ acT`W` S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZO QOÙO OTSQbWdO _cS RSa^ZWSUO\ S\ c\O `SZOQW \ aW VO\ ^`SbS\RWR] \Sf]a S[]QW]\OZSa Q]\ aca Ô`SXOa [WS\bÒa _cS SZ V][P`S a]Z] VO PcaQOR] aSf] S\ ZO [Wa[O 3fWabS ^]` bO\b] c\ [WSR] OZ `SQVOh] \] UcabO` \] aSRcQW` \] `SbS\S` _cWhta ac^S`W]` OZ `WSaU] ^S`QWPWR] S\ ZO `SZOQW \ aSfcOZ

' ;SU Oa ?cW` a Sb OZW µ8 dS\Sa g aSf]( 3Z SabS`S]bW^] _cS ]PZWUO g SZ `Wb] _cS WRS\bWTWQO¶ 4/2 7<8CD3 #

G aW \] VO SfWabWR] SaO `SZOQW \ OTSQbWdO ^`]Tc\RO QOÔh RS VOQS` _cS ZO Ô`SXO OT`]\bS ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa W\RSaSOROa RS c\ S\QcS\b`] aSfcOZ c\ S[POÒh] ZOa [cXS`Sa aS S\T`S\bO\ a]ZOa O SabOa Z] QcOZ S\ a [Wa[] Sa dWdWR] ^]` SZZOa Q][] c\ `WSaU] [ta ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS _cSROàS a]ZOa S\ c\O aWbcOQW \ OZbO[S\bS ^`]PZS[tbWQO

@]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ 3ZS\O ! µASf] g `WSaU]) ZO RWOZ{QbWQO S\b`S SZ ^ZOQS` g ZO `Oh \¶ @SdWabO 3abcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR \ [ $!

3\ QcO\b] OZ `WSaU] S\b`S Z]a V][P`Sa Sa ^S`QWPWR] RS [O\SÒ RWTS`S\bS OZ RS ZOa [cXS`Sa O \ Q][Ô`bWS\R] SZS[S\b]a S\ Q][ \) QWS`b] Sa _cS Z]a V][P`Sa RSQZOÒ\ PcaQO` S\ Z]a S\QcS\b`]a aSfcOZSa S\ UÒ\ Ô`bS ZO UÒbWTWQOQW \ T aWQO g ^ZOQS\bSÒ _cS dWS\S ^`SQSRWRO ^]` SZ XcSU] RS ZO aSRcQQW \ S\ Z]a S\QcS\b`]a Sa^]`tRWQ]a) aSU \ SZZ]a [Wa[]a T`S\bS O ZO [cXS` _cS ^]\S S\ OQQW \ SZS[S\b]a [ta ^S`bS\SQWS\bSa OZ ]`RS\

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

S[]QW]\OZ SZ V][P`S Ô`SQS RSaSO` Z]a PS\STWQW]a RS ZO Ô`bWQWÔQW \ S\ c\ S\QcS\b`] _cS aS RSTW\S [ta _cS \ORO ^]` Z] S` bWQ] g S\ SZ _cS b]ROd O aS ^]\S\ RS [O\WTWSab] QWS`bOa `SZOQW]\Sa RS R][W\OQW \ ] acP]`RW\OQW \ RS ZO [cXS` OZ V][P`S 3\ bS]` O Z]a RSaS]a RS ZO [cXS` SabO`t\ acP]`RW\OR]a OZ V][P`S ^]` QcO\b] {abS ^]R`t PcaQOàS c\O \cSdO Ô`SXO aSfcOZ gO _cS RSQZOÒ S\ [cQV]a QOa]a \] SabO` Q][^`][SbWR] S[]QW]\OZ[S\bS OZ [Wa[] \WdSZ _cS ZO [cXS` Q]\ Z] QcOZ {abO Ô`SQS _cS RSPS`t OQS^bO` Q]\RWQW]\O\bSa O ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa \] caO` ^`SaS`dObWd] ^]`_cS O {Z \] ZS UcabO SbQ aW ac Sf^SQbObWdO Sa Q`SO` ] [O\bS\S` c\O `SZOQW \ >]` Z] bO\b] SZ V][P`S Ô`SQS Q]``S` [S\]a `WSaU]a _cS ZO [cXS` S\ SZ aSf]) OÔ`S\bS[S\bS \] ^]\S S\ XcSU] ac OTSQbWdWROR \W S[]QW]\OZWROR ] RS VSQV] Z] VOQS S\ [cQVO [S\]` [SRWRO g ORS[ta ^cSRS SdWbO` ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa W\RSaSOROa Q][] Z]a S[POÒh]a aW TW\OZ[S\bS ]^bO ^]` \] Oac[W` aca `Sa^]\aOPWZWRORSa Xc\b] O ac Ô`SXO AW SZ V][P`S VOPZO a]P`S ]b`]a `WSaU]a ^]` SXS[^Z] ZOa S\TS`[SRORSa RS bÒ\a[WaW \ aSfcOZ Z] ^]\S\ a]P`S ZO [SaO \WQO[S\bS Q][] ^`]POPWZWROR ZSXO\O _cS \] Sabt W\bS`W]`WhORO aOZd] S\ Z] RSQZOÒbWd] ] S\ b]R] QOa] QcO\R] {ab]a RcRO\ RS ZO µTWOPWZWROR¶ RS ac Q][Ô SÒ aSfcOZ 3Z V][P`S ^]` bO\b] \] OÔ`SQS OZ [S\]a S\ ac ]^W\W \ bO\ Sf^cSab] O Z]a `WSaU]a ]PXSbWd]a Q][] aca Q]ZSUOa TS[S\W\Oa \W RWa^cSab]a O W\bS`W]`WhO`Z]a S\ RS[Oa O 3\ b]R] QOa] SZ aSf] g aca `WSaU]a Ô`SQS\ bS``Wb]`W]a ^`]^WQW]a ÔÒ ZO Sf^`SaW \ RSQWRWRO RS c\O W``Sa^]\aOPWZWROR Q]\aQWS\bS a]P`S SZ bS[O S\b`S ZO ZO XcdS\bcR 1cO\R] VOPZO\ a]P`S SZ aSf] [O\WTWSabO\ SZ UÒ\ ^`]PZS[O RS Q]\b`]Z a]P`S aca RSaS]a g ^cZaW]\Sa aSfcOZSa g ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa W\RSaSOROa Ô`SQS\ OQVOQOàS [ta O ZO [OZO acS`bS _cS O c\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] W[^`cRS\bS G Sa _cS Sa S\ SZ bS``Wb]`W] RS ZO \]QVS g RSZ TW\ RS aS[O\O QcO\R] c\]a g ]b`]a RSa^ZWSUO\ aca O`[Oa ÔÒ W\bS\bO` Q]\aSUcW` c\ µTW\ RS TWSabO¶ Q][^ZSbO[S\bS Oa^WÒQW]\OZ) c\ S\QcS\b`] aSfcOZ 3\ ZOa aOZWROa RS ]QW] S\ ZO \]QVS aS US\SÒ c\ QZW[O _cS TOd]`SQS c\O Q]\bO[W\OQW \ S[]QW]\OZ g SZ a [P]Z] aSf] acT`S ^]R` O[]a RSQW` c\ QO[PW] RS QcOZWROR( ZOa \]`[Oa g Z]a dOZ]`Sa RS ZO QcZbcÒ ^`SR][W\O\bS aS RWZcgS\ g SZ W[^cZa] aSfcOZ [ta PtaWQ] b][O TcS`hO g aS VOQS R][W\O\bS 3Z aS\bW[WS\b] RSZ dWdW` µO_c g OV]Ò¶ ZO ScT]`WO Q]ZSQbWdO RS ZO RWdSàW \ g SZ ^`]bOU]\Wa[] RS aS` c\] g SabO` S\ U`c^] aS Q]\dWS`bS\ S\ SaS Q]\bW\S\bS S\ SZ _cS ZO W\bSÒQQW \ RS RWdSà]a SZS[S\b]a ^`]RcQS Q][PW\OQW]\Sa ^SZWU`]aOa ! 1]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa

;SU Oa ?cW` a Sb OZW # µ8 dS\Sa g aSf]( 3Z SabS`S]bW^] _cS ]PZWUO g SZ `Wb] _cS WRS\bWTWQO¶ 4/2 7<8CD3

3\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ [SRWObWhORO ^]` Sf^S`WS\QWOa RS ZO _cS dS\W[]a VOPZO\R] O Z] ZOÙ] RS SabS O`b QcZ] S\QOXO RS [O\SÒ Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS `SZSdO\bS SZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa gO aSO\ {abOa RS ZOa RSQZOÒROa Q][] µZSUOZSa¶ ] WZSUOZSa / ] bÒa O ] ZOa QWTÒa a]P`S Q]\ac[]a RS acabO\QWOa _cS Z]a RWabW\b]a ]PaS`dOb]`W]a _cS SabcRWO\ SZ TS\ [S\] ]T`SQS\ a]P`S SZ Q]\ac[] RS ZOa [Wa[Oa ]T`SQS c\ Ô\]Ò[O `SdSZOR]`) / UÒ\RSa ÒaU]a c\O PcS\O Ô`bS RS ZO XcdS\bcR Q]\ac[S gO aSO RS [O\SÒ VOPWbcOZ ] Sa^]`tRWQO[S\bS OZU \ bW^] RS acabO\QWOa \] aWS\R] SfbÒ ] S\Q]\bÒ` aW\ ZO \SQSaWROR RS SaQO`PO` RS[OaWOR] ^S`TWZSa RS ^]ZWQ]\ac[]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

AWUcWS\R] SZ SXS RS Òh]\O[WS\b] RS SabS O`b QcZ] dO[]a O S\bÒ` O_c O bÒbO` ZOa Òh]\Sa RS ac Q]\ac[] RS c\O T]`[O OZU] [ta Q][^cSabO _cS OQVOQO\R] SZ [Wa[] bO\ a]Z] O c\]a ^c`]a STSQb]a T aWQ]a g O\ [WQ]a _cS ^]` Z] RS[ta gO S\ bWS[^]a ZSXO\]a SÒ\ RSaQ`Wb]a Q]\ PSZZShO W\WUcOZOPZS Q]\ `Sa^SQb] O c\O acabO\QWO gO S\ RSaca] SZ ]^W]) a]P`S SabO 2WRS`]b S\ ac 3\QWQZ]^SRWO Q][S\bOPO O ZO V]Ò RS RSaQ`WPW` aca STSQb]a _cS µ aS RWQS _cS ^`]RcQS c\O OZSU` O a]`^`S\RS\bS S\ SZ t\W[] RS _cWS\ Z] W\UWS`S g _cS Obc`RS ZO [S\bS Q]\ WRSOa g ^ZOQS`Sa _cS VSQVWhO\¶ ;ta OZZt RS _cS STSQbWdO[S\bS c\O Òh \ ^]bS\bS ÔÒ Z]a Q]\ac[]a ^S`bS\ShQO\ OZ ]`RS\ QcOaW ]\ `WQ] RSaQ`Wb] ^]` 2WRS`]b Z] _cS W\bS`SaO Q]\]QS` Q]\ RSbS\W[WS\b] a]\ ZOa []bWdOQW]\Sa O ac Q]\ac[] _cS S[^cXO\ O c\ \ [S`] Q]\aWRSÒPZS RS W\RWdWRc]a X dS\Sa O Q]\ac[W`ZOa ^SaS O Z]a `WSaU]a Q]\]QWR]a g Oac[WR]a RS ZOa [Wa[Oa 3a RSQW` PcaQO[]a SZ `SacZbO\bS RS ZO SQcOQW \ S\b`S `WSaU]a g PS\STWQW]a RS ac Q]\ac[] _cS c\O ^Sà]\O X]dS\ `SOZWhO QcO\R] Q]\ac[S R`]UOa =PXSbWdO[S\bS Z]a RWaQcà]a ^ PZWQ]a S W\abWbcQW]\OZSa a]P`S Z]a ^SZWU`]a RSZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa ZZSdO\ O ]a `Sa]\O\R] S\b`S ZO XcdS\bcR g \] Sa RS SfbÒ O` ^]` bO\b] _cS c\ Òab`] RS Z]a [Wa[]a VOgO Q`SOR] ^]a] S\ ZO ]^W\tbWQO RS Z]a W[^ZWQOR]a OZ VOPZO` a]P`S SabS Oac\b] 3abcRW] bÒa SabcRW] ZOa RSQZOÒQW]\Sa RS c\O [Og]` O RS W\RWdWRc]a Sabt\ ]`WS\bOROa [Og]`WbO`WO[S\bS O RSabOQO` Z]a SZSdOR]a `WSaU]a Oa]QWOR]a OZ Q]\ac[] RS acabO\QWOa SdWRS\bS[S\bS RWTS`S\QWO\R] Z]a [Wa[]a S\ Tc\QW \ RSZ bW^] RS R`]UO /V]Ò PWS\ SabO RSQZOÒQW \ SabO µ^S`QS^QW \ RS ^SZWU`]¶ OT`]\bO c\ aS`W] `WSaU] RS `SacZbO` QWS`bO[S\bS S\UO ]aO S\ OZUc\O [SRWRO) aW PWS\ QcO\R] ZO XcdS\bcR VOPZO a]P`S R`]UOa Z] VOQS ^]\WS\R] a]P`S ZO [SaO SZS[S\b]a ÒQW]\OZSa g ]PXSbWd]a SfbÒ R]a RS ZO SRcQOQW \ T]`[OZ ] W\T]`[OZ `SQWPWRO a]P`S ZOa [Wa[Oa SabOa ]^W\W]\Sa Ô`SQS\ SabO` dW\QcZOROa RS T]`[O [cQV] [ta ^]bS\bS OZ ]PXSb] ZO R`]UO ZO acabO\QWO _cS O ac Q]\ac[] ] OZ S[^ZS] RS ZOa [Wa[Oa 3\ SaS\QWO Ô`SQS` O _cS Sa ZO acabO\QWO ZO _cS aS O^`]^WO ^]` aW [Wa[O RS Z]a `WSaU]a aWS\R] Sab]a ObS[^SÒR]a S\ [Og]` ] [S\]` [SRWRO ^]` dO`W]a SZS[S\b]a ^`]dS\WS\bSa RS ZO OQbWbcR ^Sà]\OZ _cS ^`SaS\bO[]a O_c RS [O\SÒ a][SÒ

2WRS`]b 2S\Wa :¸3\QgQZ]^{RWS ]c 2WQbW]\\OW`S ÒWa]\\{ RSa aQWS\QSa RSa O`ba Sb RSa [{bWSà %% QWbOR] S\ µ3Z bSfb] R`]UOR]¶ 1Oab]ZRW /ZPS`b] ''% ]^ QWb ^ ' ! pabS ZWbSÒZ g Z]a _cS OÔ`SQS\ O Q]\bW\cOQW \ aS VO\ SfbÒ R] RS µ3Z `WSaU] S\ Z]a Q]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa) c\O O^`]fW[OQW \ RSaRS Z]a SZS[S\b]a _cS ]`WS\bO\ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ acPXSbWdO g ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa¶ @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ ;SU Oa ?cW` a g 0OZZSabS`]a 5cS`Ò¶ % ;OR`WR 4/2

:O ^`W[SÒ RS ZOa [ObWhOQW]\Sa _cS []RWTWQO ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] RS ZOa acabO\QWOa Sa ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS Ocb]Q]\b`]Z _cS a]P`S ac Q]\ac[] RSa^ZWSUO SZ ^`]^W] W\RWdWRc]) Sa \]`[OZ S\ ZOa W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa QcOZWbObWdOa a]P`S SZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa S\Q]\bÒ` ^]aWQW]\Sa _cS aW PWS\ \] `SabO\ W[^]`bO\QWO O Z]a ^SZWU`]a ]PXSbWd]a RS ZOa [Wa[Oa aW aWb O\ O ac Q]\ac[WR]` Q][] OUS\bS Q]\aQWS\bS _cS ^]\S S\ XcSU] SZ [SQO\Wa[] RS ZO d]Zc\bOR ÔÒ SdWbO` µ[OZSa [Og]`Sa¶ S\ SabS QOa] SZ ^SZWU`] `SQOS S\ ZO RS^S\RS\QWO RS ZO acabO\QWO VSQV] _cS aW Sa Q]\aWRSÒR] Q][] UÒdS T`S\bS O c\O ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] Q]\b`]ZOR] aW SZ Q]\ac[] OÔ`SQS Q][] c\ SZS[S\b] acXSb] ^cÒ[S\bS O ZO RWaQ`SQW]\OZWROR RSZ W\RWdWRc] @S^`]RcQW[]a O_c OZUc\]a ZWbSÒZSa RS ZO W\dSabWUOQW \ QcOZWbObWdO a]P`S `WSaU]a Oa]QWOR]a O R`]UOa S\b`S W\RWdWRc]a X dS\Sa ZZSdORO O QOP] S\ % ! _cS WZcabÒ\ Q]\dS\WS\bS[S\bS SabO ^]aWQW \ µ/ dS` g] Q`S] _cS Z] RS ZOa R`]UOa Z] [SX]` Sa Z] [SX]` RS ZOa R`]UOa Sa aOPS` b Z [WbS R \RS Sabt ^]`_cS Sa WUcOZ bO\b]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

aW PSPSa Q][] aW bS R`]UOa ^cSa aOPS` R \RS Sabt SZ Z [WbS ÔÒ \] ÔaO`bS¶ ;OR`WR " O ]a

3dWRS\bS[S\bS aS ^]\S RS [O\WTWSab] _cS ZO QOÔQWROR RS Q]\b`]Z W\RWdWRcOZ RSQZOÒRO bWS\S c\ STSQb] Sfb`S[ORO[S\bS W\TZcgS\bS a]P`S ZO acabO\QWO RSaQOÙt\R]ZO RS ac QOÔQWROR RS ^`]d]QO` RO ]a g aWbct\R]ZO Q][] c\O O^cSabO ^]` c\O µSf^S`W[S\bOQW \ RS POX] `WSaU]¶ _cS Ô`SQS OP`W` c\ QO[W\] [ta aSUc`] ÔÒ ac ^`cSPO :O aSUc\RO RS ZOa [ObWhOQW]\Sa Sa c\ QWS`b] RSaQ]\]QW[WS\b] `SOZ RS Z]a STSQb]a RS ZOa [Wa[Oa) aW ^]` SXS[^Z] aOZS O ZO ÔZSabÒ SZ `WSaU] RS [cS`bS ] RS STSQb]a T aWQ]a Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS RO W\]a ÔÒ SZ Q]\ac[WR]` SZ RWaQcà] ^cSRS UWÒ` VOQWO R]a ^]aWQW]\Sa) ] PWS\ aS Oac[S _cS Sa SZ SfQSa] SZ _cS Q]\ZZSdO SZ `WSaU] c\ STSQb] RS`WdOR] RS ZO bS]` O RSZ Q]\b`]Z _cS RSa^ZWSUO\ S\ aca RWaQcà]a

³ µ6Og [cQVO US\bS _cS Q]\ c\O ^OabWZZO ] Q]\ c\ ^O` RS

³ ¥C\O- AS VOP`t b][OR] aWSbS c ]QV] Q][] [ \W[] _cS

^OabWZZOa S\ c\O \]QVS aS VO\ _cSROR] S\ SZ aWbW] RWUO\ c\O dOZS ^S`] ASdWZZO " O ]a

] PWS\ _cS ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa [ta ^S`XcRWQWOZSa ]^SÒ\ O ZOÙ] ^ZOh] Q]\ Z] QcOZ S\ ^`W\QW^W] POabO` O RS VSQV] Q]\ SZW[W\O` ac Q]\ac[] ZZSUOR] O c\ ^c\b] Q]\Q`Sb] RS ZO bÒgSQb]`WO dWbOZ ÔÒ SdWbO` Q]\aSQcS\QWOa W\RSaSOROa

³ µG] [S W[OUW\] _cS Z]a TW\Sa RS aS[O\O ZZSUO`t c\ ^c\b] S\ _cS Z] RSXOa ^]`_cS \ORWS aOZS RS TWSabO Q]\ QWS\ O ]a ] aSO \] Z] Q]\]hQ] S\b]\QSa ZZSUO`t c\ ^c\b] S\ _cS Z] RSXOa g SZ V UOR] aS bS [SX]`O`t¶ ;OR`WR " O ]a

>S`] [ta OZZt RS Z]a OÙc[S\b]a _cS bWS\RS\ O W\b`]RcQW` SZS[S\b]a RS ]`RS\ W\RWdWRcOZ S\ QcO\b] O ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa Q]\ ZO ^`]^WO acabO\QWO SfWabS\ ]b`]a `STS`WR]a OZ Q]\bSfb] S\ SZ _cS Sab]a Q]\ac[]a aS `SOZWhO\) a]\ RS VSQV] O^`SQWOQW]\Sa _cS acPXSbWdO\ SZ `WSaU] S\ Tc\QW \ RS TOQb]`Sa g Q]\RWQW]\O\bSa SfbS`\]a 3Z ^`W[S`] RS Sab]a Òh]\O[WS\b]a Oc\_cS \] SZ ^`W\QWÔZ UWÒ S\ b]`\] O ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS ZO dWdS\QWO RS \c[S`]aOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] S\ ZO bÒgSQb]`WO dWbOZ ^Sà]\OZ) ZO Q]\dWdS\QWO Q]\ {abOa VSQV] _cS QOÒQbS`WhO PcS\O Ô`bS RSZ RWaQcà] XcdS\WZ a]P`S SZ `WSaU] O^SZO RS VSQV] O ZO \SQSaWROR RS Oac[W` c\O Q]\RWQW \ SfWabS\QWOZ POaORO S\ ZO Q]\dWdS\QWO Q]\ c\ PcS\ \ [S`] RS ^SZWU`]a S\ ]QOaW]\Sa S\ Oa^SQb]a bO\ PtaWQ]a Q][] ZO OZW[S\bOQW \ ZO ^`]^WO aSUc`WROR T aWQO SbQ 3\ ac[O SfWabS c\O ^S`QS^QW \ RS _cS VOg [cQV]a TOQb]`Sa g SZS[S\b]a S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR _cS OQSQVO\ O ZO ac^S`dWdS\QWO dWbOZ ^cSabO Q]\abO\bS[S\bS S\ `WSaU]

³ >S`] \] aS O dS` SZ bOPOQ] Sa [cg [OZ] ^S`] WUcOZ RS [OZ] \] a{ VOg [cQVOa Q]aOa [cg [OZOa WUcOZ RS [OZ] _cS b][O` b]R]a Z]a R Oa QV]Q]ZObS <] a{ O dS` Z] dS] [OZ]

³ 3a] RS^S\RS b]R] SZ [c\R] Q]\]QS OZ b ] ^S^S _cS aS

³ >cSa gO Sabt

[c`W Q]\ '! O ]a Tc[O\R]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

³ G O c\ b ] ac^S`aO\] RS # ZS ^cSRS Ob`]^SZZO` c\ Q]QVS Sa _cS a]\ QOa]a [cg ASdWZZO " O ]a

>S`] SZ OÙc[S\bObWd] _cS [ta \]a W\bS`SaO RSaRS SZ ^c\b] RS dWabO RSZ Q]\bSfb] US\SÒZ RS SabS O`b QcZ] Sa Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS SZ `WSaU] g Z]a Q]\ac[]a ] OQbWbcRSa O``WSaUOROa b][OROa Q][] Ôb` \ RS c\O QWS`bO µ\]`[OZWROR Q]\RcQbcOZ¶) aW PWS\ Sa QWS`b] _cS SZ RWaQcà] a]P`S SZ `WSaU] OPO`QO c\ O[^ZW] Ò\U] RS dO`WOPWZWROR RSaRS ^]aWQW]\Sa QOcbOa g ^`SdS\bWdOa VOabO OQbWbcRSa [ta ^`]OQbWdOa VOQWO SZ [Wa[] bWS\RS O ^S`QWPWàS Q][] c\ SZS[S\b] QcOaW Q]\\ObcÒZ O ZO dWRO RSZ X]dS\ OZ [S\]a aW_cWSÒ S\ QWS`bO [SRWRO G SZZ] Sa Oa ^]`_cS aS ^`Sac^]\S RS [O\SÒ Ocb][tbWQO ZO `SZOQW \ S\b`S XcdS\bcR g Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ SabO\R] SabS ZbW[] Q]\bS\WR] RS \c[S`]a]a aWU\WTWQOR]a S\b`S Z]a QcOZSa SdWRS\bS[S\bS SZ `WSaU] Sa dSQb]` SaS\QWOZ 3f^S`W[S\bO` aWU\WTWQO Oac[W` OZ [S\]a S\ RSbS`[W\OR] UÒR] QWS`b]a `WSaU]a OZ b][O` Q]\bOQb] Q]\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a ] Q]\ac[]a RS Z]a _cS aS RSaQ]\]QS RS ^`W[SÒ [O\] SZ OZQO\QS RS aca Q]\aSQcS\QWOa AW PWS\ SZ O^`S\RWhOXS SfbS`\] g T]`[OZ ] SZ dWQO`W] ^`SbS\RS W\b`]RcQW` OZ [S\]a QWS`b]a SZS[S\b]a RS ^`S Q]\]QW[WS\b] Z] QWS`b] Sa _cS RSaRS µZ] X]dS\¶ ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO ^Sà]\OZ RS ^`W[SÒ [O\] `SacZbO SaS\QWOZ S W\bÒ\aTS`WPZS /^`S\RS` S\bÒ` SZ [c\R] ORcZb] g [ORc`] Ô`SQS `S_cS`W` \SQSaO`WO[S\bS ZO Sf^]aWQW \ O ^`cSPOa [SRWO\bS ZOa QcOZSa SZ W\RWdWRc] Sf^Z]Ò aca Z [WbSa g []ZRSO ac Q]\RcQbO O^`]^Wt\R]aS RS Q]\]QW[WS\b]a _cS RSPS\ aS`dW` ÔÒ c\ RSaS[^S ] Q]``SQb] S\ ZO dWRO ORcZbO G bO\ ^]bS\bS Sa ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS ZO Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ Q][] `Wb] W\SfQcaOPZS RS b`t\aWb] VOQWO ZO dWRO ORcZbO _cS bO[PW{\ Sabt Q]\bS\WRO S\ Z]a Ôb`]\Sa RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b] _cS Z]a ^`]US\Wb]`Sa Sa^SÒ\ RS aca VWX]a SdWRS\bS[S\bS dWab]a RSaRS ZO ^`S]QcÔQW \ g SZ RSaS] RS SdWbO`ZSa RO ]a 1][] SXS[^Z] SZ Q]\ac[] RS OZQ]V]Z b][OR] Q][] Q]\RcQbO RS `WSaU] Sa W\bS`^`SbOR] ^]` Z]a ÔR`Sa Q][] c\ OQ]\bSQW[WS\b] _cS [ta ^`]\b] ] bO`RS bS\R`t ZcUO` gO _cS ^S`bS\SQS O ZO SaTSÒ RS Z] _cS VOQS b]RO ZO XcdS\bcR AWUcWS\R] ZOa OÙc[S\bOQW]\Sa Sf^cSabOa S\ µ/R]ZSaQS\bSa O\bS SZ OZQ]V]Z) ZO [WÒRO RS ÔR`Sa g [OR`Sa¶ " µ:]a ^`]US\Wb]`Sa \] a Z] S\bWS\RS\ Q][] ^`tQbWQO[S\bS W\SdWbOPZS _cS aca VWX]a Q]\ac[O\ OZQ]V]Z aW\] _cS ZZSUO\ O ^S\aO` _cS SaS Q]\ac[] T]`[O Ô`bS RSZ ^`]QSa] RS Q`SQW[WS\b] RSZ ^`]QSa] RS O^`S\RWhOXS dWbOZ g _cS ^]` bO\b] \] RSXO RS bS\S` c\O QWS`bO Tc\QW \ ^]aWbWdO¶ aWQ

" ;SU Oa 3caSPW] RW`SQb]` % :O 1OWfO ]^ QWb ^ $

G ÔÒ bS`[W\O` SabS Q]\QS^b] RS µ\]`[OZWROR Q]\RcQbcOZ¶ _cS dS\W[]a RSTW\WS\R] Q]\bWS\S c\O RS`WdORO RS aWU\WTWQOR]) c\O \]`[OZWROR Q]\RcQbcOZ bO[PW{\ Sa S\bS\RWRO Q][] ZO Oac\QW \ ^]` Ô`bS RS Z]a W\RWdWRc]a X dS\Sa RS Z]a Ôb`]\Sa RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a \]`[OZWhOR]a g Sa^SÒPZSa RS ac U`c^] RS `STS`S\QWO) gO Q][S\btPO[]a S\ ^c\b]a O\bS`W]`Sa RS SabS O`b QcZ] _cS a]P`S ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] S\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a ] Q]\ac[]a acPgOQS c\] RS ]`RS\ ac^S`W]` ^]` QcO\b] RS bÒaQS\RS\bS bWS\S ÔÒ ZO dWRO RSZ W\RWdWRc] X]dS\) ZO \SQSaWROR RS \] dSàS SfQZcWR] RS Oac[W` c\ RSbS`[W\OR] \WdSZ RS `WSaU] S\ Q]\ac[]a RS acabO\QWOa ÔÒ SdWbO` SZ `WSaU] [Og]` SZ RS dSàS SfQZcWR] RSZ U`c^]a Ô\]Ò[O _cS ^cSRS `SacZbO` TÒ\QO[S\bS ObS`ÒR]` ^]` ZO SfQZcaW \ RS ZOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa dWdS\QWOZSa RSZ U`c^]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

! ! 8 dS\Sa g Q]\RcQQW \ / ] bÒa O ] ZOa QWTÒa RS OQQWRS\bSa RS QW`QcZOQW \ S\ Z]a _cS Z]a ^`]bOU]\WabOa a]\ X dS\Sa \cb`S\ ZO SabOR abWQO a]P`S []`bOZWROR S\ ZOa QO``SbSÒa \OQW]\OZSa :Oa QWTÒa VOPZO\ RS _cS QORO O ] OZ`SRSR]` RS " ^Sà]\Oa X dS\Sa [cS`S\ S\ OQQWRS\bSa RS b`tTWQ] S\ 3aÔ O aWS\R] Sab]a OQQWRS\bSa ZO ^`W[SÒ QOcaO RS [cS`bS S\b`S ZOa ^Sà]\Oa RS S\b`S # g ' O ]a 1ORO R O O^`]fW[ORO[S\bS [cS`S\ S\ ZOa QO``SbSÒa QcOb`] ^Sà]\Oa RS SaO TÒ\XO RS SROR ^`SaS\bO\R] Z]a V][P`Sa c\O bOaO RS []`bOZWROR # ' QcOb`] dSQSa ac^S`W]` O ZO RS ZOa [cXS`Sa $ & :O [Og]` O RS Sab]a OQQWRS\bSa bWS\S\ ZcUO` S\ SZ TW\ RS aS[O\O # :Oa SZSdOROa QWTÒa RS []`bOZWROR S\b`S ZO XcdS\bcR S\ OQQWRS\bSa RS QO``SbSÒ Sabt\ \] a]ZO[S\bS dW\QcZOROa O ac [Og]` W\Sf^S`WS\QWO OZ d]ZO\bS aW\] bO[PW{\ S\ c\]a ^]`QS\bOXSa SZSdOR]a RSPWR] O ZO Q]\RcQQW \ POX] Z]a STSQb]a RSZ OZQ]V]Z g ]bÒa acabO\QWOa ] SZ OQ][Ô O[WS\b] O Q]\RcQb]`Sa _cS RSPWR] O ZO W\USabO RS acabO\QWOa \] Sabt\ ^ZS\O[S\bS S\ ^]aSaW \ RS ZOa TOQcZbORSa [ \W[Oa ÔÒ c\O Q]\RcQQW \ `Sa^]\aOPZS g aSUcÒ 3dWRS\bS[S\bS QcO\R] aS VOPZO ] aS ]^W\O a]P`S ZO O[^ZWO dO`WSROR RS Z]a `WSaU]a _cS ZO XcdS\bcR S\T`S\bO ZO Q]\RcQQW \ g Z]a OQQWRS\bSa Sa c\] RS Z]a _cS [ta `S^S`QcbS\ S\ SZ W[OUW\O`W] Q]ZSQbWd] ^]` aca bS``WPZSa STSQb]a g ^]` ZO Sfb`S[O dWaWPWZWROR O _cS SabO a][SbWR] \] a Z] ^]`_cS ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RS Z]a [Wa[]a a]\ RS UÒ\ \]b]`WSROR g dWaWPWZWROR S W[ÔQbO\ TtQWZ[S\bS S\ SZ RWaQcà] ^ PZWQ] ]^SÒ\R] Q][] bÒUSRWO RS ]`RS\ a]QWOZ aW\] bO[PW{\ ^]`_cS Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS RSaRS VOQS OZUc\]a O ]a ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RSabW\OROa O Q][PObW` ZO OZbO aW\WSabÒZWROR S\ QO``SbSÒ VO\ aWR] ]PXSb] RS Sa^SQWOZ ObS\QW \ S\ Tc\QW \ RS Z]a `SQcà]a g SabÒbSUWOa RSabW\OROa O bOZ TW\ / \ O ^SaO` RS ZOa QWTÒa S\ US\SÒZ ZO XcdS\bcR [O\bWS\S Q]\ `Sa^SQb] O SabS bS[O c\O OQbWbcR _cS SabO POaORO OZ [S\]a S\ Z] RSQZOÒbWd] S\ c\O OQcS`R] QOaW US\SÒZWhOR] S\ _cS ZOa OQbWbcRSa W[^`cRS\bSa OZ d]ZO\bS `SdWabS\ UÒdSa ^SZWU`]a g Q]\aSQcS\QWOa Tc\SabOa ÔÒ SZZ]a Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS aW Q][] Sa TÒ\QO[S\bS VOPWbcOZ aSU \ ZOa QWTÒa ZO Q]\RcQQW \ dO OQ][Ô ORO RSZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa gO aSO\ SabO OZQ]V]Z c ]bÒa acabO\QWOa

# @/11 /\cO`W] a]P`S aSUc`WROR dWOZ %

>S`] aOPS[]a _cS S\ ZO Q]\RcQQW \ Sa R]\RS S\QcS\bÒ\ Z]a W\RWdWRc]a X dS\Sa c\] RS Z]a bS``Wb]`W]a [ta ^`]QZWdSa O ZO dWdS\QWO RS OQbWbcRSa RS `WSaU] ^]` QcO\b] S\bÒ\ S\ XcSU] SZS[S\b]a Q][] ZO S[]QW \ RS ZO dSZ]QWROR ZO Q][^SbS\QWO SZ SfVWPWQW]\Wa[] ZO Q]\RcQQW \ Sa ^]` RS`SQV] ^`]^W] SZ bS``S\] [ta OP]\OR] ÔÒ ZO Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ RS µaS\aOQW]\Sa TcS`bSa¶ g RS Sf^S`WS\QWOa µOZ Z [WbS¶ ^S`] bO[PW{\ Sa SZ t[PWb] R]\RS ZO XcdS\bcR ^cSRS aS\bWàS [ta ^`]QZWdSa O ]QcZbO` aca dS`RORS`]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a :Oa QO[Ô Oa RS SRcQOQW \ g aS\aWPWZWhOQW \ ZO O^cSabO ZSUOZ ^]` W\Q`S[S\bO` SZ \WdSZ RS ZOa aO\QW]\Sa O Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a bS[SÒ`W]a g ac Q`W[W\OZWhOQW \ S\ OZUc\]a QOa]a aO\QW]\Sa RS Qt`QSZ VO\ Q]\T]`[OR] c\ RWaQcà] ^ PZWQ] a]P`S SZ bS[O S\ QcSabW \ OZ _cS Sa RWT QWZ _cS Z]a W\RWdWRc]a aS acabÒWUO\ g _cS \] `S^`]RchQO\ S\ aca RWaQcà]a >OÒ W\bS\bO` SXS[^ZWTWQO` SabO QcSabW \ RS RWaÔ`WROR S\b`S OQbWbcRSa g Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a b][S[]a Q][] SXS[^Z] ZO ]^W\W \ RSZ U`c^] X]dS\ O\bS c\ VSQV] Q][] SZ RS ZO Q]\RcQQW \ POX] Z]a STSQb]a RSZ OZQ]V]Z c ]bÒa acabO\QWOa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

3\ c\] RS Z]a SabcRW]a [ta `SQWS\bSa a]P`S ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS Z]a `WSaU]a da PS\STWQW]a S\b`S X dS\Sa $ aS ^`SUc\b O Z]a S\b`SdWabOR]a a]P`S SZ \WdSZ RS RO ] _cS ^S`QWP O\ S\ RWdSàOa aWbcOQW]\Sa _cS SZ QcSabW]\O`W] ZSa ^`SaS\bOPO dOZ]`t\R]ZOa S\ Tc\QW \ RS ac QOÔQWROR ^S`QWPWRO RS ^`]d]QO` RO ]a S\ c\O SaQOZO RS O R]\RS SZ SÒ µ\W\U \ RO ]¶ g SZ µ2O ]a UÒdSa ] [cg UÒdSa¶ :O ^`SUc\bO aS T]`[cZ S\ Z]a aWUcWS\bS b{`[W\]a µ>S\aO\R] S\ Z]a X dS\Sa Q][] b ¥1 [] ^c\bcO` Oa ZO UÒdSROR RS Z]a RO ]a _cS ZSa ^cSRS\ ]QOaW]\O` `SOZWhO` QORO c\] RS Z]a aWUcWS\bSa Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a- >c\b O SabO UÒdSROR S\ c\O SaQOZO RSZ aW\ RO ]a O RO ]a Sfb`S[ORO[S\bS UÒdSa ¶ :O bOPZO $ [cSabÒ Z]a `SacZbOR]a

BOPZO $ > S`QS^QW \ RSZ UÒR] RS RO ]a Q]\ `Sa^SQb] O Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a g Q]\ac[]a 3aQOZO OU`cÔRO <W\U \ RO ] 2O ]a UÒdSa ] Sfb`S[ORO[S\bS UÒdSa 2Ob]a S\ [SRWOa g ^]`QS\bOXSa 5ÒR] RS RO ]a Q]\ ZO SaQOZO 2O ]a [cg UÒdSa ] Sfb`S[ORO[S\bS UÒdSa &

<W\U \ RO ] !

2O ]a `SUcZO`Sa " %

1]\ac[W` Q]QO \O \]`[OZ[S\bS

& &

& '

1]\RcQW` dSV QcZ]a QcO\R] aS VO\ Q]\ac[WR] R`]UOa ] OZQ]V]Z

&" %

& '

1]\ac[W` ^OabWZZOa VOPWbcOZ[S\bS

" &

& &

<] caO` ^`SaS`dObWd]

& !

$$ $

% '

BS\S` ^SZSOa

$! $

% '

1]\ac[W` QO\\OPWa VOPWbcOZ[S\bS

$! &

% %

1]\ac[W` OZQ]V]Z VOPWbcOZ[S\bS

!& !

#$ #

% #

1]\ac[W` bOPOQ] VOPWbcOZ[S\bS

% %

!' $

# $

% !

# '

>OaO` [cQVOa V]`Oa O\bS SZ ]`RS\OR]` QVObSO\R] XcUO\R]

& %

;SRWO

$ ;SU Oa Sb OZW & µ:O ZSQbc`O XcdS\WZ RS Z]a `WSaU]a RS ZOa R`]UOa 2SZ SabS`S]bW^] O ZO Q][^ZSXWROR¶ 4/2

3fWabS\ R]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a _cS ]PbWS\S\ ZO [Wa[O QOZWTWQOQW \ RS [SRWO ^]` Ô`bS RS Z]a S\b`SdWabOR]a) µ1]\ac[W` Q]QO \O VOPWbcOZ[S\bS¶ µ1]\RcQW` dSV QcZ]a QcO\R] aS VO\ Q]\ac[WR] R`]UOa ] OZQ]V]Z¶ O[POa Q]\ c\O ^c\bcOQW \ RS & ' RS c\ [tfW[] RS ^c\b]a ^]aWPZSa 3a RSQW` c\O O^ZOabO\bS [Og]` O RS Z]a S\b`SdWabOR]a Q]\TWS`S\ OZ [Wa[] \WdSZ RS RO ]a OZ Q]\ac[] RS c\O acabO\QWO ^S`QWPWRO Q][] SfbÒ]`RW\O`WO[S\bS RO W\O Q][] ZO Q]QO \O _cS O ZO Q]\RcQQW \ POX] STSQb]a RS OZQ]V]Z c ]bÒa R`]UOa G Sa [ta SabS RO ] Sa ac^S`W]` OZ _cS aS Q]\aWRSÒ O\Sf] OZ Q]\ac[] RS acabO\QWOa Q][] ÔabWZZOa ] Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a Q][] SZ \] ca] RS ^`SaS`dObWd] ] ZO Ô`bWQWÔQW \ S\ ^SZSOa

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

/V]Ò PWS\ Ô`SQS QZO`] _cS SfWabS ^cSa c\O QWS`bO Q]\bÒRWQQW \ S\b`S ZOa RSQZOÒQW]\Sa a]P`S Z]a `WSaU]a RS ZO Q]\RcQQW \ OZbSÒRO ^]` [SRW] RSZ Q]\ac[] RS acabO\QWOa g ZOa ^`cSPOa _cS \]a O^]`bO\ Z]a ROb]a RS aW\WSabÒZWROR) SZZ] \] a Z] Sa RSPWR] O _cS ^SaS O ZOa OZbOa QWTÒa RS [cS`b]a a Z] c\O [W\]` O RSaO``]ZZS Sab]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a) Sa _cS aW\ RcRO ZO `SOZWROR RS ZO OQQW \ Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS S\ SZ SaÔQW] RS ZO \]QVS g SZ ]QW] g ZO [ShQZO Q]\ RSbS`[W\OROa acabO\QWOa Q][] SZ OZQ]V]Z bÒab]QO Z]a c[PÒZSa ^S`QS^bWd]a RS ZO `SOZWROR g ^]` SZZ] RS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] 3\ POaS O Sab] ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] S\ ZO Q]\RcQQW \ S\b`S SZ U`c^] X]dS\ VO aWR] ]PXSb] RS c\ W[^]`bO\bS \ [S`] RS []RSZ]a bS `WQ]a OZ `Sa^SQb] bOZSa Q][] SZ []RSZ] RS <wwbw\S\ g Ac[[OZO '&# ^]` QWbO` OZUc\] 3\ QcOZ_cWS` QOa] ZOa O^]`bOQW]\Sa [ta W[^]`bO\bSa RS RWQV]a []RSZ]a ÒRWQO\ S\ _cS ^]\S\ RS [O\WTWSab] ZO W[^]`bO\QWO _cS OR_cWS`S\ ZOa dO`WOPZSa OQbWbcRW\OZSa []bWdOQW]\OZSa g ] Q]U\WbWdOa S\ SZ ^`]QSa] RS ZO Q]\RcQQW \ Q]\ SZ ]PXSbWd] RS ZZSUO` O Q][^`S\RS` g ^`SRSQW` SZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] RSZ Q]\RcQb]` 3abS []RSZ] RS `WSaU] QS`] RS <wwbw\S\ g Ac[[OZO '&# ^]abcZO _cS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] RS OQQWRS\bS Sa WUcOZ O QS`] ZO [Og]` Ô`bS RSZ bWS[^] `WSaU] acPXSbWd] \cZ] :O RWTS`S\QWO S\b`S SZ `WSaU] ]PXSbWd] `SOZ g SZ acPXSbWd] Sa SZ []bWd] RS _cS ]Qc`Ò\ Z]a OQQWRS\bSa AW\ S[POÙ] aW OP]`RO[]a ]bÒ RW[S\aW \ RS ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] S\ ZO Q]\RcQQW \ POX] Z]a STSQb]a RS OZQ]V]Z g R`]UOa S\Q]\bÒ[]a `SacZbOR]a _cS \]a ^`SaS\bO\ OZUc\]a SZS[S\b]a [ta ÔÒ ZO `STZSfW \) S\ SZ [Wa[] SabcRW] aS ^`SUc\b O Z]a S\b`SdWabOR]a a]P`S ZO QOÔQWROR RS Q]\b`]Z RS Sa]a [Wa[]a RO ]a [SRWO\bS ZO aWUcWS\bS ^`SUc\bO µG b ^Sà]\OZ[S\bS S\ _c{ [SRWRO bS aWS\bSa QOÔh RS Q]\b`]ZO` ] SdWbO` Z]a RO ]a _cS VOa RWQV] _cS ^cSRS\ ]QOaW]\O` Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a _cS VS[]a ZS R] O\bSa S\ SZ QOa] RS _cS Z]a `SOZWhOÒa QZO`] Sa b]bOZ[S\bS W\QOÔh RS Q]\b`]ZO` g b]bOZ[S\bS QOÔh RS Q]\b`]ZO` Z]a RO ]a¶ :]a `SacZbOR]a aS ^`SaS\bO\ S\ ZO bOPZO $

BOPZO $ 5 ÒR] RS Q]\b`]Z SdWbOQW \ `Sa^SQb] O Q]\ac[]a SaQOZO >]QO QOÔQWROR RS Q]\b`]Z B]bOZ QOÔQWROR RS Q]\b`]Z 3aQOZO OU`cÔRO 5ÒR] RS Q]\b`]Z S\ ZO SaQOZO >]QO QOÔQWROR !

B]bOZ QO^OQWROR RS Q]\b`]Z &

;SRWO

1]\ac[W` ^OabWZZOa VOPWbcOZ[S\bS

#" '

$ $

1]\ac[W` Q]QO \O \]`[OZ[S\bS

& $

#" "

$ $

1]\RcQW` dSV QcZ]a QcO\R] aS VO\ Q]\ac[WR] R`]UOa ] OZQ]V]Z

' %

$ #

1]\ac[W` QO\\OPWa VOPWbcOZ[S\bS

# "

"& "

$ #

!" $

" #

$ !

BS\S` ^SZSOa

& $

& &

# $

<] caO` ^`SaS`dObWd]

$ '

1]\ac[W` OZQ]V]Z VOPWbcOZ[S\bS

! $

"% !

$ '

>OaO` [cQVOa V]`Oa O\bS SZ ]`RS\OR]` QVObSO\R] XcUO\R]

" %

"% #

1]\ac[W` bOPOQ] VOPWbcOZ[S\bS

1O^OQWROR [SRWO " %

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

=PaS`dO\R] Z]a `SacZbOR]a S\ SZ bS[ _cS \]a W\bS`SaO µ1]\RcQW` dSV QcZ]a QcO\R] aS VO\ Q]\ac[WR] R`]UOa ] OZQ]V]Z¶ \]a `SdSZO c\ ROb] SaS\QWOZ) [ta # RS S\b`SdWabOR]a [O\WTWSabO\ bS\S` VOQWO ZO Q]\RcQQW \ POX] STSQb]a RS OZQ]V]Z ] R`]UOa c\O b]bOZ QOÔQWROR RS Q]\b`]Z SdWbOQW \ Z] _cS W\RcQS O ^S\aO` _cS ] PWS\ aS SdWbO SabS Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a RS [O\SÒ [Og]`WbO`WO ] _cS SfWabS c\O OUcRO ^S`QS^QW \ RS Q]\b`]Z a]P`S Z]a ^SZWU`]a g `WSaU]a ^]bS\QWOZSa RSZ [Wa[] QOa] RS `SOZWhO`Z] ?cWhta c\ PcS\ \ [S`] RS S\b`SdWabOR]a Sabt RS VSQV] a]P`SdOZ]Ò\R] S\ SfQSa] aca ^`]^WOa QOÔQWRORSa S\ QcO\b] O ZO SdWbOQW \ RS OQQWRS\bSa Z] QcOZ `SacZbO Q]VS`S\bS Q]\ ZOa RSQZOÒQW]\Sa SaQcQVOROa S\ \c[S`]aOa W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa µg] a{ Q]\RcQW`¶ = PWS\ Q][^ZS[S\bO`WO[S\bS SfWabS\ S\b`SdWabOR]a _cS O ^SaO` RSZ `WSaU] ]PXSbWd] SdWRS\bS RS bOZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] aS aWS\bS\ OZSXOR]a RS ^]aWPZSa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa \SUObWdOa ^]` c\O ^S`QS^QW \ acPXSbWdORO RSZ `WSaU] µSa] \] [S dO O ÔaO` O [ ¶ >]` ZbW[] O Z]a S\b`SdWabOR]a RSZ SabcRW] aS ZSa ^`SUc\b S\ _cS [SRWRO ZSa Q][^S\aOPO SZ `SOZWhO` RSbS`[W\OROa OQQW]\Sa ] Q]\ac[]a S\ Tc\QW \ RSZ PS\STWQW] _cS TW\OZ _cS {ab]a ZSa ^]R O\ O^]`bO` bOPZO $ !

BOPZO $ ! 5 ÒR] RS Q][^S\aOQW \ RS Q]\ac[]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a SaQOZO <] Q][^S\aO \ORO 1][^S\aO b]bOZ[S\bS 3aQOZO OU`cÔRO 5ÒR] RS Q][^S\aOQW \ S\ ZO SaQOZO <] Q][^S\aO \ORO !

1][^S\aO OZU] 1][^S\aO " % b]bOZ[S\bS &

;SRWO

1]\ac[W` ^OabWZZOa VOPWbcOZ[S\bS

& $

1]\RcQW` dSV QcZ]a QcO\R] aS VO\ Q]\ac[WR] R`]UOa ] OZQ]V]Z

&% !

1]\ac[W` Q]QO \O \]`[OZ[S\bS

BS\S` ^SZSOa

& #

$ #

1]\ac[W` QO\\OPWa VOPWbcOZ[S\bS

% '

$ #

<] caO` ^`SaS`dObWd]

$ "

# &

! "

1]\ac[W` bOPOQ] VOPWbcOZ[S\bS

#% "

!# #

! "

1]\ac[W` OZQ]V]Z VOPWbcOZ[S\bS

!% #

# $

! !

>OaO` [cQVOa V]`Oa O\bS SZ ]`RS\OR]` QVObSO\R] XcUO\R]

"! "

"! $

6OQS[]a \]bO` _cS aW PWS\ c\O [Og]`WbO`WO ^O`bS RS Z]a S\b`SdWabOR]a aS ^]aWQW]\O\ S\ Z]a ^c\b]a RS ZO SaQOZO RS O ! dOZ]`Sa _cS Q]``Sa^]\RS\ O µ\] Q][^S\aO \ORO S\ OPa]Zcb]¶ c\ &% SfWabS QOaW c\ ! RS S\b`SdWabOR]a _cS ]b]`UO\ c\O \]bO S\b`S " g O SabS Q][^]`bO[WS\b] S\ ZO SaQOZO RS Q][^S\aOQW \ dOZ]`Sa _cS Q]``Sa^]\RS\ O µQ][^S\aO OZU]¶ ] µQ][^S\aO b]bOZ[S\bS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

/a _cS S\ ^`W\QW^W] g O ZO dWabO RS Z]a ROb]a \]a S\Q]\bÒ[]a ^`]POPZS[S\bS O\bS c\O `SOZWROR acXSbO O c\O TcS`bS O[PWU SROR) ^]` c\ ZOR] Z]a S\b`SdWabOR]a \]a W\T]`[O\ RS ZO OZbO ^S`QS^QW \ RS `WSaU] _cS ÔÒ SZZ]a bWS\S ZO Q]\RcQQW \ POX] Z]a STSQb]a RSZ OZQ]V]Z g ]bÒa acabO\QWOa ^S`] ^]` ]b`] ZOR] c\ PcS\ \ [S`] RS SZZ]a aS aWS\bS ZSX]a RS ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa \SUObWdOa 2S \cSd] ^]R` O[]a ^S\aO` _cS S\ [cQV]a QOa]a ZOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa a]P`S SZ `WSaU] Sabt\ aS`WO[S\bS dW\QcZOROa O W[^`SaW]\Sa acPXSbWdOa _cS []RWTWQO\ SZ c[PÒZ RS `WSaU] b]ZSÒPZS g OR[WaWPZS @343@3<17/A 070:7=5@È471/A ÈZdO`Sh g RSZ @ ] '' µ3RcQOQW \ g RSaO``]ZZ]( ZO bS]` O RS DgU]baYg g ZO h]\O RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] ^` fW[]¶ 0SQY CZ`WQV $ µ:O a]QWSROR RSZ `WSaU]) VOQWO c\O \cSdO []RS`\WROR¶ 0O`QSZ]\O 0S`WO\ Q][^ % µ:Oa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa ^S`dSàOa RS ZO []RS`\WROR¶ 0O`QSZ]\O /\b`V]^]a 1Oab]ZRW /ZPS`b] ''% µ3Z bSfb] R`]UOR]¶ 0O`QSZ]\O 2WRS`]b 2S\Wa %% µ:¸3\QgQZ]^{RWS ]c 2WQbW]\\OW`S ÒWa]\\{ RSa aQWS\QSa RSa O`ba Sb RSa [SbWSà¶ 5WRRS\a /\bV]\g g 6cbb]\ EWZZ SRWb]`Sa µ3\ SZ Z [WbS) ZO dWRO S\ SZ QO^WbOZWa[] UZ]POZ¶ 0O`QSZ]\O Bca_cSba SRWb]`Sa 6SW[S` 1 ''& µA]QWOZ Sab`cQbc`S âgQV]Z]Ug O\R bVS SabW[ObW]\ ]T bVS `WaY¶ /\\cOZ `SdWSe ]T A]QW]Z]Ug " :cV[O\ <WYZOa '' µA]QW]Z]U O RSZ `WSaU]¶ ;{fWQ] C\WdSàWROR 7PS`]O[S`WQO\O ;SU Oa % µ/R]ZSaQS\bSa O\bS SZ OZQ]V]Z) ZO [WÒRO RS ÔR`Sa g [OR`Sa¶ ;OR`WR 4/2 :O 1OWfO ;SU Oa ?cW` a Sb OZ # µ8 dS\Sa g aSf]( 3Z SabS`S]bW^] _cS ]PZWUO g SZ `Wb] _cS WRS\bWTWQO¶ 4/2 7<8CD3 ;SU Oa ?cW` a Sb OZ & µ2]QS\bSa ] [OSab`]a) ^S`QS^QW]\Sa RS ZO SRcQOQW \ RSaRS RS\b`]¶ ;OR`WR 4/2 ;SU Oa 3caSPW] Q]`R & µ3Z `WSaU] S\ Z]a Q]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa¶ ;OR`WR 4/2 @/11 /\cO`W] a]P`S aSUc`WROR dWOZ % @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ ;SU Oa ?cW` a g 0OZZSabS`]a 5cS`Ò & µ3Z `WSaU] S\ Z]a Q]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa) c\O O^`]fW[OQW \ RSaRS Z]a SZS[S\b]a _cS ]`WS\bO\ ZO ^S`QS^QW \ acPXSbWdO g ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa¶ ;OR`WR 4/2 @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ 3ZS\O ! µASf] g `WSaU]) ZO RWOZ{QbWQO S\b`S SZ ^ZOQS` g ZO Òh \¶ @SdWabO 3abcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR \ [ $! DO\RS` HO\RS\ 8O[Sa E '%% µA]QWOZ >agQV]Z]Ug¶ @O\R][ 6]caS <cSdO G]`Y

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

9D8JB:CIDH

È\USZ 8 5]`R] : ^Sh >`]TSa]` 2^b] A]QW]Z]U O C\WdS`aWROR 1][^ZcbS\aS RS ;OR`WR

´? kZcZh Zc eZa^\gd d eZa^\gdhdh4# 6aVgbVh n iZXcdad\ Vh hdX^VaZh YZa ÆYZhVggdaadÇ n \dW^Zgcd Y^\^iVa

:Oa Q]\ab`cQQW]\Sa S\ b]`\] O ZO W\TO\QWO g XcdS\bcR ZOa `Sb `WQOa g ^`tQbWQOa bSQ\]Z UWQOa Oa]QWOROa O ZOa [Wa[Oa a]\ \SQSaO`WO[S\bS ^]Z bWQOa 3abS O`b QcZ] [cSabÒ SZ []R] S\ _cS ^]abcÒa RS O\bO ] _cS W\bS\bO`]\ W[^]\S` `SZOQW]\Sa RS Ocb]`WROR ^]` [SRW] RS SRcQOQW]\Sa POaOROa S\ SZ `Sa^Sb] RS ZO Ocb]`WROR g ZOa []ÒZWRORSa OZ ca] aS S\b`S[ShQZO\ g OP`S\ Ôa] V]g S\ R O ^]` [SRW] RS \cSdOa ^`tQbWQOa g RWaQcà]a bSQ\]Z UWQ]a ORS[ta RSZ POQY b] POaWQ g ZO SRcQOQW \ ^]` Q][^SbS\QWOa 3\ SabS Ô\]Ò[O ZOa \]QW]\Sa RS `WSaU] g ^SZWU`]aWROR Ob`WPcWROa O ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa S\b`S OR]ZSaQS\bSa X dS\Sa g ZOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ g SZ ]QW] bSQ\]Z]U Oa a]QWOZSa T][S\bO\ c\ R]PZS XcSU] >]` c\O Ô`bS ^S`[WbS\ _cS QWS`b]a _cS aS Ob`WPcgS\ O Z]a [ta X dS\Sa RS Z]a [ dWZSa SZ ;SaaS\US` 4OQSP]]Y 67# g ]bÒa bSQ\]Z]U Oa g `SRSa a]QWOZSa OZW[S\bS\ ZO OZO`[O a]QWOZ OQS`QO ZO dW]ZS\QWO S\ Z]a [ta X dS\Sa g Z]a `WSaU]a O Z]a _cS Sabt\ Sf^cSab]a >]` ]bÒ Ô`bS W\QWbO\ g OZZO\O\ SZ QO[W\] ÔÒ US\SÒ` g RWTc\RW` ^`tQbWQOa g bSQ\]Z]U Oa [ta TOQbWPZSa RS Q]\b`]Z g `SUcZOQW \ 3abS ^`]QSa] aS RWaQcbS S\ SZ Q]\bSfb] RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] RWaÔ` RS ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ S\ 3aÔ O aca OaWU\ObcÒa ^S\RWS\bSa g V]`Wh]\bSa >OZOPÒa 1ZOdS( /R]ZSaQS\QWO OZO`[O a]QWOZ RSaO``]ZZ] WRS\bWROR RWUWbOZ U]PWS`\] RWUWbOZ XcdS\bcR bSQ\]Z]U Oa a]QWOZSa `SRSa a]QWOZSa dW]ZS\QWO :O ^`S\aO g Z]a Sa^SQWOZWabOa \] RSXO\ RS VOPZO` RS d]a]b`]a Oa( P]`ÒQVSÒa T`SQcS\bSa g ]PSaWRORSa RS^`SaW]\Sa O\aWSRORSa S VW^SÒQbWdWRORSa S\ Oc[S\b] >]Q] W[^]`bO _cS ZO [Og]` O RS dcSabÒa _cSXOa g [OZSabO` \] bS\UO\ POaS ]Ùt\WQO :] [Wa[] RO _cS RO Z] [Wa[]) ÔabWZZO dO ÔabWZZO dWS\S Sa] a Q]\ SZ Q]\aS\bW[WS\b] RS ÔR`Sa g [OR`Sa OcaS\bSa BO[PW{\ XcUtWa O acWQWRO`]a QORO dSh [ta g [ta bS[^Ò\] /\bSa RS aS` \W ]a Oa g RS O^`S\RS` O VOPZO` ] SaQ`WPW` gO a]Wa QZWS\bSa( bS\{Wa _cS ZZSdO` QWS`bOa [O`QOa ] QSZSPÒ` Z]a Qc[^ZSO ]a S\ ZcUO`Sa ac\bc]a]a ÔÒ \] RSaS\b]\O` S\ ZO Ô\RWZZO AW aOZ a ^]` OV dSbS b O aOPS` Q]\ _cW{\ W`{Wa _c{ b][O`{Wa) g aW \] aOZ a ^cSa Sa] _cS \] aOP{Wa `SZOQW]\O`]a _cS ÔatWa RS[OaWOR] bWS[^] Q]\ ZO >ZOg Z]a dWRS]XcSU]a g S\ SZ µ[SaS\Uc{`¶ 5]]UZS ]a VOQS [ta dOU]a [ta b]\b]a S W\QOÔQSa RS ZSS` Q]\ RSbS\W[WS\b] AW O ]a Ob`ta ^caWabSWa RS []RO Z]a A;A OV]Ò Q]\ SaO T`WOZROR \SQSaO`WO ÔÒ UÒPO` g RWTc\RW` OU`SaW]\Sa O dcSab`]a WUcOZSa _cW{\ aOPS Z] _cS aS`{Wa QOÔQSa RS VOQS` S\ µZO W\bS`\Sb¶ :O SaQcSZO RS V]g \] dOZS Ô \t) \SQSaWbtWa _cS ]a [SbO\ S\ QW\bcÒ _cS Z]a [OSab`]a RSXS\ bO\bO [S[Sh RS SRcQOQW \ UWZW ^`]U`S /ZUc\]a RS dcSab`]a [OSab`]a OTW`[O\ _cS QcOZ_cWS` bWS[^] ÔaOR] TcS [SX]` BS\{Wa [ta RWTWQcZbORSa ÔÒ O^`S\RS` ObS\RS` g SabO`]a _cWSb]a Oc\_cS bO[PW{\ [Og]` QOÔQWROR RS bÒPOX] S\ S_cW^] g SabtWa [cg ^cSab]a S\ ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa >S`] aW ]a ]ÙO\WhtWa O bÒd{a RS Z]a

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

[ dWZSa g ZO `SR ÔÒ S\Q]\bÒ` h]\Oa g T]`[Oa RS ]QW] OZbS`\ObWdOa aS ]a bOQVO RS PO\RO QOZZSXSÒ ] b`WPc c`PO\O O \ [ta aW ^`]QSR{Wa RS Z]a SfbÒ`ÒRW]a g RS TO[WZWOa W\[WUÒ\bSa <] Oa^W`tWa O \W\Uc\O ^`]TSaW \ ] d]QOQW \ ^]`_cS \W Z] RSaStWa \W Q`S{Wa _cS aSO ^]aWPZS 6OP{Wa RSXOR] RS ^`SUc\bO`]a _c{ _cS`{Wa aS` RS [Og]`Sa A Z] ]a ^`S]QcÔ aOPS` _c{ Qc``]a ^WZZO`SWa _c{ ]^]`bc\WRORSa aS ^`SaS\bO`t\ G [cQV]a a]\ Z]a Sa^SQWOZWabOa S\ ZO [ObS`WO g ]ÙO\Wa[]a _cS dWdS\ RS dcSabÒ ac^cSabO W\TO[WO g ^SZWU`]aWROR ¥6OQWO R \RS O^c\bO\ bO\ RS[]\WhOQW \ [SRWQOZWhOQW \ g aS\aOQW]\OZWa[]3abOa `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa µS\ \SUObWd]¶ RS OR]ZSaQS\QWO g XcdS\bcR `SS\d O\ O ]b`]a [WSR]a g ^t\WQ]a []ÒZSa ^`]^W]a RS {^]QOa ÔaOROa >]` SXS[^Z] ZO W\RWU\OQW \ OQS`QO RS ZO Q]\bÒbOQW \ RS [O\] RS ]PÒ W\TO\bWZ S\ ZO @Sd]ZcQW \ 7\Rcab`WOZ bcd] [S\]a _cS dS` Q]\ ZO Sf^Z]bOQW \ _cS Q]\ SZ bS[]` O _c{ VcPWSaS\ VSQV] Z]a µ^S_cS ]a Pt`PO`]a¶ RS VOPS` RWaT`cbOR] RS W\RS^S\RS\QWO SQ]\ [WQO ^]` \] RSQW` Q][] aS OZO 0c`[O\ & SZ [WSR] O _cS Z]a aOZO`W]a RS ZO [cXS`Sa g RS Z]a \W ]a c\ PW\][W] _cS acSZS W` Oa]QWOR] ^cRWSÒ Q][^SbW` Q]\ Z]a aOZO`W]a RS Z]a V][P`Sa 1cO\R] ZO 3c`]Ô RS ZO @Sd]ZcQW \ 7\Rcab`WOZ ^cSRS ^`SaQW\RW` RS ZO [O\] RS ]PÒ W\TO\bWZ S\ ZOa TtP`WQOa :Sg RS ZO >`]VWPWQW \ RSZ BÒPOX] 7\TO\bWZ RS &%" S[^WShO O acÙW` c\ [WSR] VOQWO Z]a V][P`Sa X dS\Sa [S`]RSO\R] S\ ZOa QOZZSa RS ZOa QWcRORSa 3Z Ô^SZ RS ZO SaQcSZO O TW\OZSa RSZ aWUZ] FD777 g ^`W\QW^W]a RSZ F7F `SRcX] S\ Ô`bS SZ ^t\WQ] []ÒZ Oa]QWOR] O ZO Q`W[W\OZWROR S µW`ÒQW]\OZWROR¶ RS Z]a µ^S_cS ]a []\ab`c]a¶ OV]Ò `SQZcWR]a S\ ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa SRcQObWdOa :O SaQcSZO bO[PW{\ W[^ca] c\ []RSZ] RS W\TO\QWO [ta ^` fW[] O ZOa QZOaSa ^`WdWZSUWOROa S\bS\RWR] Q][] c\ ^S`W]R] RS RS^S\RS\QWO \SQSaWROR g QcWROR] g ^]` bO\b] RS `S^`]RcQQW \ RS bÒRWQW]\Sa RS Ocb]`WROR 3\ TW\ c\ RW_cS RS Q]\bS\QW \ _cS RS Ôa] Q]\bÒ``SabOPO ZOa bS[WROa W\ac``SQQW]\Sa RS Z]a X dS\Sa ^`]QSRS\bSa RS QZOaSa ]P`SÒa 6S\R`WQY '' / [SRWOR]a RSZ aWUZ] F7F ZOa \]QW]\Sa RS W\TO\QWO g OR]ZSaQS\QWO S\ Ô`bS OR[W\WabÒROa O bÒd{a RS ZO SaQcSZO S[^WShO\ O W[^`SU\OàS RS dOZ]`Sa RS ]`RS\ `Sa^Sb] g O[]` ^`]^W]a RS ZO TO[WZWO dWQb]`WO\O RO\R] Ôa] O ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa g Q]``Sa^]\RS\QWOa S\b`S ZO TO[WZWO SZ 3abOR] g ZOa ^]Z bWQOa a]QWOZSa _cS QOÒQbS`WhO\ O ZOa RS[]QÒQWOa ZWPSÒZSa ]QQWRS\bOZSa RSZ aWUZ] FF ÈZdO`Sh C` O %) 5W[S\] AOQ`Wabt\ & :Oa \]QW]\Sa RS W\TO\QWO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g XcdS\bcR VO\ SfWabWR] g SfWabS\ S\ `SZOQW \ O []R]a RS RSTW\W` g S\bS\RS` O Z]a ORcZb]a ZOa TO[WZWOa g SZ 3abOR] 3a] Sa a]\ \]QW]\Sa [cbcO[S\bS RS^S\RWS\bSa C\O WRSO _cS ^]R` O Ô`SQS` ]PdWO Oc\_cS Q]\ W[^ZWQOQW]\Sa ^`tQbWQOa _cS ac^]\S OQS^bO` _cS QcO\R] VOPZO[]a RS ZO W\TO\QWO ] ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO ac \ObcÒZShO ] SRcQOQW \ O bÒd{a RS \cSabÒa ]^W\W]\Sa VOPZO\ []RSZ]a g bS\RS\QWOa RS ]ÙO\WhOQW \ ^]Z bWQO 0c`[O\ & :]a [ta X dS\Sa V]g S\ R O aWUcS\ aWS\R] []bWd] RS \c[S`]aOa `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa W\bS`SaOROa RSaRS ZOa QO[Ô Oa RS `SQ]UWROa RS T]\R]a ÔÒ OgcRO O ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] ZO XcabWTWQOQW \ RS W\bS`dS\QW]\Sa P{ZWQOa ZOa QO[Ô Oa ^]Z bWQOa Q][] ZO µ\W O¶ RSZ QO\RWROb] ^`SaWRS\QWOZ RSZ >O`bWR] >]^cZO` S\ ZO QO[Ô O SZSQb]ÒZ RS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

& S\ 3a^O O 3abO bS\RS\QWO VO OR]^bOR] \cSdOa T]`[Oa OZ O[^O`] RS ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \

8 dS\Sa g bSQ\]Z]U Oa a]QWOZSa ( [Wb]a [WSR]a g ^`]gSQQW]\Sa /ZUc\Oa ^Sà]\Oa Sabt\ ^`S]QcÔROa ^]` ZOa V]Òa _cS ÔaO\ Z]a Oa \W ]a Oa g OR]ZSaQS\bSa S\ SZ ;SaaS\US` S\ 4OQSP]]Y g S\ BcS\bW 67#¬ g Z] _cS ^cSRS aWU\WTWQO` _cS SabOPZShQO\ aca `SZOQW]\Sa OTSQbWdOa RS [O\SÒ dW`bcOZ) ]bÒa RO\ ^]` VSQV] _cS Z]a [ta X dS\Sa bWS\S\ VOPWZWRORSa µW\\ObOa¶ ÔÒ SZ ca] RS ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa g _cS ac ca] Sa Ô`bS Q]\acabO\QWOZ ÔÒ RSaS\d]ZdSàS g Q][^SbW` S\ ZO a]QWSROR OQbcOZ ] a]QWSROR `SR ¥?c{ VOQS` T`S\bS O Z]a W\bS`SaSa _cS acabS\bO\ Sab]a [Wb]a g Z]a STSQb]a _cS Q]\ZZSdO\3\ ZO ZWbSÒbcÒ Sa^SQWOZWhORO _cS acÙS RSaRS [SRWOR]a RSZ aWUZ] FF OÔ`SQS\ R]a S\T]_cSa PWS\ RWTS`S\QWOR]a 0cQYW\UVO[ 3Z ^`W[S`] `S^`SaS\bO O Z]a X dS\Sa Q]\ c\O ^`SRWa^]aWQW \ µ\ObcÒZ¶ VOQWO RSbS`[W\OR]a [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQW \ OcRW]dWacOZSa bSZSdWaW \ [cZbW[SRWO O RWTS`S\QWO RS Z]a [SRW]a S\ T]`[Ob] W[^`Sa] 3abOa Sf^ZWQOQW]\Sa Q][] O^c\bO[]a S\ c\ SabcRW] ^`SdW] 5]`R] : ^Sh g ;SU Oa $ Ob`WPcgS\ O Z]a [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQW \ c\ ^]RS` aW\UcZO` ÔÒ Sf^Z]bO` ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR RSa[O\bSZO` ZO W\RWdWRcOZWROR g RSab`cW` ZO W\]QS\QWO RS Z]a [ta X dS\Sa 2STWS\RS\ ZO WRSO RS _cS SZ [SRW] SaQ`Wb] T][S\bO ZO OPabÒQQW \ g SZ ^S\aO[WS\b] Z UWQ] >]` SZ Q]\bÒ`W] ZO bSZSdWaW \ g ^]` SfbS\aW \ UÒ\ Ô`bS RS Z]a OcRW]dWacOZSa g [cZbW[SRWO ^]abS`W]`Sa \] `S_cWS`S\ VOPWZWRORSa Sa^SQWOZSa ÔÒ W\bS`^`SbO`Z]a Z] _cS ac^]\S O ac dSh c\O ^{`RWRO RSZ Q]\b`]Z RS Z]a ORcZb]a a]P`S SZ O[PWS\bS aW[P ZWQ] RSZ X]dS\ Oa Q][] c\O RSadWOQW \ S\ SZ b`t\aWb] O ZO SROR ORcZbO

:Oa O^ZWQOQW]\Sa _cS ^`]^WQWO\ Q][c\WQOQW]\Sa g ca]a [ta ^Sà]\OZSa [ta W\T]`[OZSa Q][] ZO [S\aOXS` O W\abO\bt\SO ZO bSZST]\ O ^]` 7\bS`\Sb g ZO Q`SOQW \ RS PZ]Ua aS Q]\]QS\ OQbcOZ[S\bS Q][] bSQ\]Z]U Oa a]QWOZSa a]TbeO`S a]QWOZ ] ESP 3abO Z \SO RS bÒPOX] RSTW\S µbSQ\]U{\SaWa¶ Q][] µSZ ^`]QSa] [SRWO\bS SZ QcOZ Z]a Vc[O\]a Q]\ab`cgS\ [O\W^cZO\ S W\bSÒQb O\ Q]\ ZOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ RO\R] ZcUO` O c\ ^`]QSa] RS RSaO``]ZZ] W\bSÒQbWd] _cS RS [O\SÒ Q]\bW\cORO Q]\RWQW]\O \cSabÒa `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa g Sf^S`WS\QWOa RSZ [c\R]¶ AVO`[O\ "( % &

2SaRS Q][WS\h]a RS Z]a O ]a \]dS\bO ]bÒa dWaW]\Sa [ta ]^bW[WabOa ] W\bSUÒROa¶ [O\bWS\S\ _cS ZO W\bSÒQQW \ RS Z]a [ta X dS\Sa Q]\ ZOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ Q]\RcQS O ZO OR_cWaWQW \ RS \cSdOa Tc\QW]\Sa g Sab`cQbcÒa [S\bOZSa ] µbSQ\]U{\SaWa¶ g S\ Z]a _cS \]a RSbS\R`S[]a S\ aca [O\WTSabOQW]\Sa [ta OQbcOZSa [ta bO`RS S\ SabS O`b QcZ] BO\b] c\]a Q][] ]b`]a `SQ`SO\ c\ RSbS`[W\Wa[] bSQ\]Z UWQ]( ZO bSQ\]Z]U O Sa ZO QOcaO\bS RS b]ROa ZOa ^{`RWROa RSTc\QW \ RS ZO W\TO\QWO g PS\STWQW]a ZWPSÒQW \ RS ZO US\SÒQW \ SZSQb` \WQO W\RS^S\RWS\bS[S\bS RS Z]a S\b]`\]a a]QW]SQ]\ [WQ]a g ZOa RWTS`S\QWOa RS QZOaS g SRcQOQW \ 3\ STSQb] Z]a X dS\Sa aS `S^`SaS\bO\ S\ ^]aSaW \ RS c\ bOZS\b] \ObcÒZ RS c\O Q`SObWdWROR Sa^]\bt\SO _cS Sa S\ QWS`bO T]`[O `SdSZORO O bÒd{a RS ZOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa 0WS\ aSO O bÒd{a RSZ bSZSdWa]` ] RSZ ]`RS\OR]` ZO bSQ\]Z]U O aS ^`SaS\bO Q][] OUS\bS bÒ\aT]`[OR]` RS ZOa Sab`cQbcÒa [S\bOZSa g Z]a ÒaU]a âWQ]Z UWQ]a RS Z]a [ta X dS\Sa RS aca SabWZ]a RS Q]\]QW[WS\b] g O^`S\RWhOXS BO[PW{\ Q][Ô`bS\ c\ S\T]_cS QS\bÒR] S\ Z]a Oa \W ]a Oa 3\ SabS SaQS\O`W] Q][] aS OZtPO[]a S\ Z]a P`SdSa O^c\bSa VWab `WQ]a aS OP`S\ Ôa] SabÒbSUWOa RS ^`]bSQQW \ g RSTS\aO POaOROa Tc\RO[S\bOZ[S\bS S\ SZ `SU`Sa] RS \]QW]\Sa RS TO[WZWO µW\bSUÒRO¶ g \cSdOa []ÒZWRORSa g Q]\ac[]a [ta OV]Ò W\QWbOROa O ac dSh ^]` \cSdOa OZO`[Oa g [WSR]a a]QWOZSa S\ b]`\] O ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa S\b`S Z]a Oa X dS\Sa g ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa 3\ [cQV]a QOa]a SabOa dWaW]\Sa Q][ÔUW\O\ Z]a W\bS`SaSa a]QWOZSa S\ b]`\]a O Z]a [ta X dS\Sa g Z]a RSZ Z]PPg RWUWbOZ _cS

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

W\QZcgS [cZbW\OQW]\OZSa OR[W\WabÒQW]\Sa OUS\QWOa RS [O`YSbW\U S W\dSabWUOQW \ ]ÙO\Wa[]a W\bS`\OQW]\OZSa g aca t`SOa ^`W]`WbO`WOa RS W\dSabWUOQW \ ³ ^]` SXS[^Z] ZO aSUc`WROR RS Z]a \W ]a Oa S\ ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ g aca `SRSa / ^SaO` RS OQ]US` bS\RS\QWOa S\ c\ ^`W\QW^W] ]^cSabOa SabS W\b`WQOR] Q][] ÔaO`S[]a O RSbOZZO` RSXO S\b`SdS` c\ [Wa[] ^`W\QW^W] Z UWQ] Q]\ STSQb]a W[^]`bO\bSa a]P`S ZO W\QWbOQW \ Q]\ab`cQQW \ g U]PWS`\] RS ZO WRS\bWROR RWUWbOZ aWS\R] SabO ZO OaWU\ObcÒ ^S\RWS\bS ÔÒ SZ bO\ O\aWOR] µRSaO``]ZZ] T]`[OZ¶ PO\QO SZSQb` \WQO Q][S`QW] SZSQb` \WQ] OR[W\WabÒQW \ g U]PS`\O\hO SZSQb` \WQO RS ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \

BSQ\]Z]U Oa RS W\bSUÒQW \ TO[WZWO`( ZO 5S\SÒQW \ 3W\abSW\ 3Z ZWP`] RS 8S`]S\ 0]aQV[O & bWbcZOR] 5S\SÒQW \ 3W\abSW\ ;ta ZWab]a [ta `t^WR] g [ta a]QWOPZSa 1][c\WQO` Q]\ Z]a X dS\Sa RSZ aWUZ] FF7 ^`SaS\bO c\O QOÒQbS`WhOQW \ ^]aWbWdO QOaW SfcZbO\bS RS Z]a [Wa[]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa g X dS\Sa \]`[OZ[S\bS RS[]\WhOR]a g ] [SRWQOZWhOR]a 3Z bSfb] SabOPZSQS` c\O aW\SÙWO S\b`S ZOa dWaW]\Sa ]^bW[WabOa ] W\bSUÒROa _cS acÙWS`]\ O ^`W\QW^W]a RS Z]a \]dS\bO g Z]a dOZ]`Sa RS TO[WZWO g []ÒZWROR RSTS\RWR]a ^]` ZOa ^]abcÒa µO^]QOZ ^bWQOa¶ 3Z bSfb] Sa T`cb] RS ZOa W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa `SOZWhOROa ^]` SZ UOPW\SbS RS SabcRW]a RS [O`YSbW\U V]ZO\R{a 9SSaWS 7\bS`\OQW]\OZ Sa^SQWOZWhOR] S\ bS[tbWQOa RS XcdS\bcR / Ô`bW` bO[PW{\ RS c\ S\T]_cS QS\bÒR] S\ Z]a \W ]a Oa g X dS\Sa g S\ ^]aWbWd] ÔÒ ZO 5S\SÒQW \ 3W\abSW\ 7\bS`\Sb Sa Ô`bS RS ZO `SOZWROR RWO`WO S\ ZO SaQcSZO g S\ QOaO Sa S\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` µc\ QS\b`] RS S\QcS\b`] aW\ V]Ò`W] RS QWS``S C\ [cZbWQS\b`] R]\RS SZ Q]\bOQb] \] acabWbcgS SZ bÒb] ^Sà]\OZ RS ZO dWRO `SOZ Q][] aS bS[ O VOQS OZUc\]a O ]a aW\] _cS OgcRO O W\bS\aWTWQO` SZ d \QcZ] Q]\ O[WU]a g Q]\]QWR]a¶

1cOR`] 5S\S`OQW \ RSZ 0OPgP]][

5S\S`OQW \ F

'"# '##

'$ '&#

'&& VOabO OV]`O

1]\bSabObO`W]a

<SUObWd]a

>]aWbWd]a

>]aUcS``O g `SQ]\ab`cQQW \

2S^`SaW \ SQ]\ [WQO

1`SQW[WS\b] RSaO``]ZZ] g PWS\SabO`

@SP]aO\bSa RS WRSOZSa

DOQ ] WRS]Z UWQ]

7RSOZSa b`ORWQW]\OZSa

<] VOP O [O`QOa

<OQS\ ZOa [O`QOa

;O`QOa ^]` R]_cWS`

/^OaW]\OR]a

@SZObWdWhO\

AS`W]a

=b`] Tcbc`]

<] VOg Tcbc`]

0cS\ Tcbc`]

/ ZO P a_cSRO RS ZO ^S`a]\OZWROR

:O ^S`a]\OZWROR aS Q]\ab`cgS

:O ^S`a]\OZWROR Sa Ocb{\bWQO

7RS\bWROR OZSXORO RS ^OR`Sa g Ocb]`WROR

7RS\bWROR S\bS\RWRO Q][] [W[SbWa[]

7RS\bWROR Sa aS` aW\QS`] Q]\ c\] [Wa[]

B][OR] RS 0]aQV[O &(!'

5S\S`OQW \ 3W\abSW\

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

2S Z]a [cQV]a ÒaU]a Q]\ Z]a _cS aS RWPcXO SabO ac^cSabO \cSdO US\SÒQW \ `Sac[WR]a S\ QcOR`] RSabOQO SZ Ô^SZ QS\bÒZ _cS XcSUO ZO TO[WZWO ÔÒ SabS bW^] µWRSOZ¶ RS X dS\Sa 0]aQV[O ^ZO\bSO _cS bÒa dO`W]a RSQS\W]a S\ Z]a _cS ZO TO[WZWO Ô`SQ O `SZSUORO O c\ aSUc\R] ^ZO\] dcSZdS\ Z]a WRSOZSa TO[WZWO`Sa( µ3\ ZcUO` RSZ XcSU] RS ZO ]QO XcUO[]a Q]\ EWW I¬K 3Z `SU`Sa] RS ZO TO[WZWO VO aWR] bO\ aWU\WTWQObWd] _cS SZ Q]\QS^b] RS [O`YSbW\U RS TO[WZWO aS VO W\b`]RcQWR] RS T]`[O Sf^SRWbWdO ¦?c{ P]\Wb] ]bÒ dSh O VOQS` Q]aOa Xc\b]a bO\ S\ ZO W\bW[WROR g bO\ O UcabWb] ¶ 0]aQV[O &( %$ >]Q] RSa^c{a RS _cS ZO dSàW \ V]ZO\RSaO RS 5S\SÒQW \ 3W\abSW\ dWSaS ZO Zch S\ $ 3Z >O a AS[O\OZ ^cPZWQ c\ `S^]`bOXS OQS`QO RSZ \cSd] `Sb] RS ;WQ`]a]Tb ÔÒ ZWRSÒ` ZO `Sd]ZcQW \ RS Z]a V]UO`Sa g SZ S\b`SbS\W[WS\b] 1][] OTW`[O S\ SZ `S^]`bOXS 8 /ZZO`R c\] RS Z]a RWaQ ^cZ]a [ta ^`][SbSR]`Sa RS 0WZZ 5ObS( µ;WQ`]a]Tb ZZSdO ! O ]a QS\bÒRO S\ ZOa OQbWdWRORSa _cS aS `SOZWhO\ S\b`S ZOa ' g ZOa % <]a]b`]a OV]Ò dO[]a O ^]` SZ ^S`W]R] RS S\b`S ZOa % g ZOa ¶ 4S`\t\RSh RS :Wa $( !$ 3Z [S\aOXS RS ;WQ`]a]Tb Sa RS c\O QZO`WROR [S`WRWO\O / \ Oa `SacZbO W\bS`SaO\bS `SÔÒ S\ ZOa ^`SaQ`W^QW]\Sa a]QWOZSa _cS OQ][Ô O\ ZO QOaO TcbcÒ W\bSÒQbWdO RS ;WQ`]a]Tb Q][] aS O^`SQWO S\ ZO aWUcWS\bS RSaQ`W^QW \ _cS ^`]^]`QW]\O O ZO ^S`W]RWabO RSZ 3>A >O[ 6SObV `Sa^]\aOPZS RS ZO RWdWaW \ RS ZO QOaO RWUWbOZ( <ORO [ta S\bÒ` ^]` SXS[^Z] c\O Ô\bOZZO btQbWZ aWbcORO S\ ZO Ô`SR W\T]`[O RS R \RS Sabt\ Z]a \W ]a RSa^c{a RS Z]QOZWhO`Z]a Q]\ c\ 5>A Z]QOZWhOR]` ^]` aOb{ZWbS 6SObV QcS\bO _cS Z]a ÔR`Sa aW\ S[POÙ] VO\ RSQWRWR] RSaOQbWdO` SaO ]^QW \ S\ SZ OR]ZSaQS\bS GO Q]\T O\ S\ {Z Z] acTWQWS\bS Q][] ÔÒ \] aSUcW`ZS Z]a Ôa]a µA][]a Q]\aQWS\bSa RS ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RS ^`]bSUS` ZO W\bW[WROR¶ RWQS I K 3Z ZcUO` [ta W[^]`bO\bS RS ZO QOaO Z] ]QcÔ Q][] S\ QOaW b]ROa ZO bSZSdWaW \ Q]\dS`bWRO S\ c\ Ocb{\bWQ] QS\b`] RS S\b`SbS\W[WS\b] RWUWbOZ AS ^cSRS\ dS` ^SZ QcZOa POX] RS[O\RO RSaQOÙOROa RS 7\bS`\Sb SaQcQVO` [ aWQO `SQ][S\RORO ^]` O[WU]a Q]\SQbOR]a OZ ;SaaS\US` _cS bO[PW{\ Sa RS ;WQ`]a]Tb XcUO` Q]\ [WZSa RS ^Sà]\Oa O c\ dWRS]XcSU] VOPZO` Q]\ ZO OPcSZO ^]` dWRS]Q]\TS`S\QWO B]R] SZZ] UÒQWOa O ZO Q]\a]ZO FP]f !$ _cS Q][] c\O UWUO\bS ^WÒ O VO RSd]ÒR] OZ `Sab] RS Z]a VOPWbO\bSa RSZ aOZ \ SZ 2D2 SZ S_cW^] RS [ aWQO SZ aWabS[O RS QWS\ S\ QOaO SZ bSZ{T]\]

>OÒ aWbcOàS S\ µSZ [Wa[] QS\b`] RS ZO dWRO c`PO\O S\ SZ Tcbc`] RWUWbOZ¶ Oa ^cSa ;WQ`]a]Tb bO[PW{\ RWdWaO Q][] Q]\RWQW \ W\RWa^S\aOPZS `SQc``W` O dOZ]`Sa bÒRWQW]\OZSa RS TO[WZWO S\ b]`\] OZ S\b`SbS\W[WS\b] g ]QW] Q][Ô`bWR] <] ]PabO\bS SabO W[OUS\ RS TO[WZWO TcbcÒ `SQc``S O \]QW]\Sa bÒRWQW]\OZSa RS OR]ZSaQS\bSa QcWROR]aO[S\bS ]PaS`dOR]a ] [S`SQSR]`Sa RS Q]\TWO\hO RS^S\RWS\R] RS aW W\Tc\RS\ ] \] Q]\TWO\hO O Z]a ORcZb]a S\ Q]\b`]Z RS ac SRcQOQW \ S\ ZO QOaO RWUWbOZ aW\ ^]` SZZ] RSa^`S\RSàS RS Z]a PcS\]a ca]a g VtPWb]a Oa]QWOR]a O dOZ]`Sa bÒRWQW]\OZSa RS TO[WZWO `SZOQW]\Sa g SRcQOQW \ ] OZ [S\]a `SRSTW\W`Z]a O Ô`bW` RS ^`]QSa]a g b{Q\WQOa _cS ^S`[WbS\ µW\dWaWPWZWhO`¶ ] USabW]\O` ac [Og]` ] [S\]` ^`SaS\QWO 3abOa `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa RS ZO QOaO RWUWbOZ RS ;WQ`]a]Tb g SZ bW^] RS SaQS\O`W] TO[WZWO` _cS ^S`TWZO S\QcS\bÒ\ aW[WZWbcRSa Q]\ ZO aWUcWS\bS

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

QOÒQbS`WhOQW \ RS ZO TO[WZWO RS ZO 5S\SÒQW \ 3W\abSW\ O QOÙ] RS 0]aQV[O &( %% %& ( 1cO\R] c\O TO[WZWO RS V]g RSQWRS XcUO` Q]\ ZO EWW ] O ]b`] XcSU] c\ R][W\U] ^]` ZO bO`RS Z] VOQS\ ^]` c\O Òh \ PWS\ RWabW\bO _cS S\ Z]a O ]a QW\QcS\bO( ^]`_cS bWS\S\ UO\Oa :WP`S g Sa^]\bt\SO[S\bS aS ^]\S\ O XcUO` Q]\ c\O <W\bS\R] 5O[S1cPS g c\O >ZOgAbObW]\ S\ ZO VOPWbOQW \ R]\RS Sabt ZO bSZSdWaW \ R]\RS Sabt\ Z]a 2D2 RS 2Wa\Sg SZ ]`RS\OR]` Q]\ Q]\SfW \ O 7\bS`\Sb g SZ ;A< g R]\RS Q]\bW\cO[S\bS acS\O\ Z]a [ dWZSa C\O VOPWbOQW \ QOZS\bWbO g OQ]USR]Ò R]\RS Sa [cg UÒb] Xc\bOàS b]RO ZO TO[WZWO O XcUO` <ORWS Sabt ]PZWUOR] O \ORO <] 3ZSUW[]a SabO Xc\b]a ZWP`S[S\bS g ^]` ^`]^WO d]Zc\bOR

<] VS[]a RS ]ZdWRO` _cS SabO \]QW \ RS TO[WZWO W\bSUÒRO ac^]\S c\ \cSd] \WQV] RS Q]\ac[] Q]ZSQbWd] Q][] gO ^]RS[]a O^`SQWO` Q]\ S\ ZO RWa^]\WPWZWROR OQbcOZ RS dWRS]Q]\a]ZOa V][S QW\S[O ZO EWW¬ _cS O ZO dSh ^S`[WbS [O\bS\S` ZOa gO SabOPZSQWROa c\WRORSa RS Q]\ac[] W\RWdWRcOZSa Q][] SZ [ dWZ SZ 2D2 SZ [^! >/2 /[P]a T]`[Oa RS Q]\ac[] [O`QO\ ZOa bS\RS\QWOa RS ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ S\ 3aÔ O RcÒ\bS Z]a ZbW[]a O ]a Xc\b] Q]\ ZO ^Sà]\OZWhOQW \ RS Z]a Q]\bS\WR]a g ZcUO`Sa RS OQQSa] 5]`R] g ;SU Oa $ AS[SXO\bS `S^`SaS\bOQW \ RS ZO TO[WZWO bO[PW{\ W\QWbO c\ OQS`QO[WS\b] S\b`S SZ aOZ \ TO[WZWO` aca ÔR`Sa g bSQ\]Z]U Oa g µZO VOPWbOQW \ ^`]^WO RS Z]a X dS\Sa¶ c\ ZcUO` RS\b`] RSZ V]UO` TO[WZWO` S\ SZ _cS 7\bS`\Sb P`W\RO O Z]a ^S_cSa ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS `SZOQW]\OàS Q]\ ]bÒa ^Sà]\Oa aW\ aOZW` RS ac [WQ`]Q]a[]a ]ÙO\WhOR] O ac [O\SÒ g aW\ SfQSaWdOa W\XS`S\QWOa RS Z]a ÔR`Sa 4SWfO # C\O TO[WZWO [ta W\bSUÒRO S W\bSUÒR]Ò aW QOPS aW Q]\aWRSÒ[]a _cS SZ `SU`Sa] RS ZO TO[WZWO OQ]US ZO TO[WZWO \cQZSO` bÒRWQW]\OZ ORS[ta RS ZOa TO[WZWOa []\]Ô`S\bOZSa ZOa Ô`SXOa V][]aSfcOZ Q]\ VWX]a ÔR`Sa g [OR`Sa RWd]`QWOR]a Q]\ ] aW\ VWX]a _cS T]`[O\ c\O \cSdO Ô`SXO¬ >]`_cS Q][] OTW`[O 0]aQV[O &(& [ta QS`QO\] OZ RSaWÒbc[ _cS O ZO `SOZWROR a]QWOZ( µ5ÒQWOa O b]R]a Sab]a O ]a RS µRSa `RS\Sa¶ S\ SZ bS``S\] RS ZO TO[WZWO \cQZSO` VS[]a ZZSUOR] TW\OZ[S\bS O ZO Q]\QZcaW \ RS _cS Z]a \W ]a \SQSaWbO\ a]P`S b]R] aSUc`WROR g Sab`cQbcÒa QZOÒa bS\S` S\ QOaO c\ ^cS`b] aSUc`] RSaRS SZ _cS Ô`bW` ÔÒ RSaQcP`W` SZ [c\R]¶

1cOR`] 5S\S`OQW \ RSZ 0OPgP]][

5S\S`OQW \ F

3aQO^O`aS RS ZO TO[WZWO

2SaO``OWU] TO[WZWO`

2SaSO\ ZO TO[WZWO

5`O\ TO[WZWO Q]\ ^OR`Sa \WQ]a

4O[WZWOa [ta ^S_cS Oa

2WdSàOa T]`[Oa RS TO[WZWO []\]Ô`S\bOZ RS dO`W]a ÔR`Sa

/^S\Oa RWd]`QW]a

>`W[S`]a RWd]`QW]a

2Wd]`QW]a a]\ [ta ZO `SUZO _cS ZO SfQS^QW \

6WX]a ^]` ac^cSab]

6WX]a \] RSaSOR]a

6WX]a RSaSOR]a \OQWR]a RSZ O[]`

3RcQOQW \ Sab`WQbO g Ocb]`WbO`WO @WS\ROa QORO dSh [ta acSZbOa 0]aQV[O &( &%

5S\S`OQW \ 3W\abSW\

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

2SZWPS`OQW \ g ^OQb]

:O ZZSUORO RS SabS bW^] RS `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa ^]\S a]P`S SZ V]`Wh]\bS RSZ [O`YSbW\U g SabcRW]a RS ZO XcdS\bcR ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS µOQS`QO`¶ SaO µVOPWbOQW \ RS Z]a VWX]a¶ bO\ W\Q][^`S\aWPZS ÔÒ [cQV]a ORcZb]a BO[PW{\ ^S`[WbS OVcgS\bO` Sa]a [WSR]a RS OWaZO[WS\b] Sfb`S[]a RS Z]a [ta X dS\Sa Q][] ZOa a]\OROa TWUcÒa RSZ OcbWa[] RS X dS\Sa _cS acÙW RSaRS TW\OZSa RS Z]a \]dS\bO S\ ZO a]QWSROR 8O^]\SaO S\QS`ÒR]a S\ aca VOPWbOQW]\Sa g Q]\ b]R] bW^] RS bSQ\]Z]U O g Q]\SQbWdWRORSa BO[PW{\ ^S`[WbS RWaWÔ` S\ Ô`bS Z]a [WSR]a Oa]QWOR]a O ZO `SR TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` ^]`\]UÒT O W\TO\bWZ ^SRSÒabWO¬ ^]` \] RSQW` ZO ^{`RWRO RS dOZ]`Sa []ÒZSa g RS Ocb]`WROR a]P`S Z]a [ta X dS\Sa :O ZZSUORO RS ZO TO[WZWO W\bSUÒRO ZO RS ZO 5S\SÒQW \ 3W\abSW\ g ZO _cS dWdW`t S\ ZOa QOaO RWUWbOZ RS ;WQ`]a]Tb ^S`[WbW` O WUcOZ[S\bS OQ]`bO` ZOa P`SQVOa US\SÒQW]\OZSa OQbcOZSa ^]` [SRW] RS W[tUS\Sa WR ZWQOa Oa]QWOROa O SaS SaÔQW] Q][ \ O SaS aOZ \ O SaOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa g \cSd]a Ôb`]\Sa RS ]QW] Q][Ô`bWR]a QcOR`] BO[PW{\ ^S`[WbW` O [O_cWZZO` ZO aWbcOQW \ S\ SaOa QOaOa Q][Ô`bWROa RcÒ\bS [ta bWS[^] Z]a X dS\Sa Sabt\ Q]\RS\OR]a O dWdW` [ta bWS[^] Q]\ aca ÔR`Sa _cS Q]\ aca TcbcÒa TO[WZWOa [ta O \ S\ SZ QOa] SaÔ ]Z _cS ZWRSÒ ZOa bOaOa RS Ô`] XcdS\WZ S\ 3c`]Ô ORS[ta RS bS\S` Z]a [S\]`Sa \WdSZSa RS Q]\QWZWOQW \ ZOP]ÒZ g ^]` bO\b] c\] RS Z]a Ô aSa Q]\ ÔR`Sa g [OR`Sa [ta OcaS\bSa S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ R]\RS W[^SÒ ZO O\][WO RSZ Q]\ac[] /Z]\a] & ASU \ ZO T]b]UÒT O ^`SaS\bORO ^]` ZO 5S\SÒQW \ 3W\abSW\ QcOR`] Z]a X dS\Sa gO \] Sabt\ RSaS]a]a RS OPO\R]\O` SZ \WQV] TO[WZWO` S\b`S ]bÒa Q]aOa ^]`_cS \] aS Z] ^cSRS\ ^S`[WbW` >cSRS _cS RS SabS []R] bO[^]Q] Q]`Ò\ Z]a ^SZWU`]a ] `SacZbS\ ^SZWU`]a]a Oa]QWOR]a Z]a SaÔQW]a RS Ocb]\][ O _cS Z]a [ta X dS\Sa PcaQO\ S\ ZO QcZbcÒ RS ZO \]QVS 7\bS`\Sb¬ ] ZO VOPWbOQW \ ^`]^WO AW ZO [Og]` O RS Z]a W\T]`[Sa Sf^S`b] Q]W\QWRS\ O ZO V]Ò RS SabWU[ObWhO` g RS[]\WhO` O Z]a [ta X dS\Sa ¥O _c{ Sa RSPWR] _cS Sa]a [Wa[]a \W ]a g X dS\Sa aSO\ O ac dSh Q]\aWRSÒR]a Z]a ^`W\QWÔZSa W[^cZa]`Sa RS ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ g OV]Ò O ac dSh POZcO`bSa RS Z]a \cSd]a dOZ]`Sa RS ZOa \cSdOa TO[WZWOa `SQ]\abWbcWROa OZ O[Ô`] RS ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa- ¥/ _c{ Sa RSPWR] _cS SabOa [Wa[Oa ^`][SaOa g ^`]gSQQW]\Sa RS^]aWbOROa S\ Z]a [ta X dS\Sa g aca `SZOQW]\Sa Q]\ ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ g SZ ]QW] Q][Ô`bO\ QO`bSZ OQbcOZ[S\bS Q]\ Z]a [WSR]a g ZOa dWUWZO\QWOa _cS W\QWbO\ O ac dSh SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS [SRWROa g ^`]UÒ[Oa Sc`]^S]a QS\bÒR]a S\ ZO QWPSàSUc`WROR g SZ Q]\b`]Z-

/ZO`[Oa g dWUWZO\QWOa bSQ\]a]QWOZSa :Oa dWaW]\Sa ^]aWbWdOa g Q]\QWZWOR]Òa ^`][cZUOROa ^]` ZOa OUS\QWOa RS [O`YSbW\U Sa^SQWOZWhOROa Q][] ZO OUS\QWO 9SSaWS Q]SfWabS\ S\ SZ W[OUW\O`W] a]QWOZ Q]\ `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa _cS Oa]QWO\ ZO dW]ZS\QWO O ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa S\b`S Z]a X dS\Sa g ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa /a Z] O^`SQWO[]a S\ SZ `S^]`bOXS bWbcZOR] µ3Z QWPSÒQ]aOR]` OQb O S\ T` ]¶ ASU \ Z]a Ocb]`Sa RSZ [Wa[] /c\W \ g >{`Sh % Z]a Sa^SQWOZWabOa VO\ RSbSQbOR] \cSdOa []ROZWRORSa RS OQ]a] S\b`S Z]a X dS\Sa S\ ZOa _cS aS [ShQZO\ T]`[Oa RS dW]ZS\QWO bÒRWQW]\OZ g \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa 3Z µQWPSÒQ]a]¶ Q]\aWabS S\ µS\dWO` W\acZb]a ] O[S\OhOa S\ [S\aOXSa RS [ dWZ RS QVOb ] RS [S\aOXS` O Ocb][tbWQO¶ S\ OZUc\]a QOa]a OQ][Ô OR] RS ZO UÒPOQW \ g RWTcaW \ S\ [ dWZSa S 7\bS`\Sb RS ZO OU`SaW \

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

/c\_cS Sab]a QOa]a a]\ [cg ^]Q]a OZ`SRSR]` RSZ O Z]a Sa^SQWOZWabOa S\ ac [Og]` O âWQ Z]U]a Oa RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] ZSa ^`S]QcÔ W\bS`dS\W` Z] O\bSa ^]aWPZS O\bSa RS _cS SZ TS\ [S\]a aS SfbWS\RO >OÒ SZZ] `SacZbO W[^`SaQW\RWPZS `SbÒbO` ^S`TWZSa âWQ]Z UWQ]a ^]` SXS[^Z] RSZ QWPSÒQ]aOR]` RSZ _cS aS RSabOQO µZO T`WOZROR RS Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa ÔÒ ZZSdO` O QOP] b]R] SZ ^`]QSa] gO _cS \] aS bÒbO a Z] RS ZO QZtaWQO dW]ZS\QWO Q]\ SZ OQOZ]Ò[WS\b] RSZ [][S\b] RS ^]` [SRW] aW\] _cS VOg _cS b][OàS ZO []ZSabWO ^]` SXS[^Z] RS UÒPO`Z] RS ZZSUO` ZcSU] O QOaO ÔÒ Q]ZUO`Z] S\ 7\bS`\Sb¶ :Oa dWaW]\Sa µSabWU[ObWhOR]Òa¶ RS X dS\Sa W\TO[Sa S\ [O\]a RS ZO âWQ]Z]U O Q][] RS Q]abc[P`S RO\ Ôa] O ]bÒa µW\bS`dS\QW]\Sa¶ RS Ocb]`WRORSa XcRWQWOZSa g ^]ZWQWOZSa Q][] O^`SQWO[]a S\ RWQV] `S^]`bOXS :]a [WSR]a g OZO`[Oa a]QWOZSa _cS SabS bW^] RS dWaW]\Sa aS\aOQW]\OZSa OZW[S\bO\ T]`[O\ Ô`bS RS c\ [O`Q] [ta O[^ZW] RS W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa ^`]UÒ[Oa g ^]Z bWQOa a]QWOZSa 1]W\QWRWS\R] Q]\ SZ W\WQW] RSZ >ZO\ /dO\hO 3c`]^S] aS Q]\abObO c\ Q`SQWS\bS W\bS`{a ^]` T][S\bO` g acTÒUO` W\dSabWUOQW \ OQS`QO RS Z]a \W ]a Oa S\ SZ ca] RSZ [ dWZ S 7\bS`\Sb 3\b`S ZOa W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa _cS aS Sabt\ ZZSdO\R] O QOP] S\ SabO RW`SQQW \ RSabOQO SZ ^`]gSQb] Sc`]^S] 3C 972A =<:7<3 $ ' RSaO``]ZZOR] RS\b`] RSZ ^`]UÒ[O Sc`]^S] A/43@ 7<B3@<3B >:CA >@=5@/;;3 RW`WUWR] ^]` ZO ^`]TSa]Ò A]\WO :WdW\Uab]\S ^`SaWRS\bO RS ZO 7\bS`\ObW]\OZ 1][[c\WQObW]\ /aa]QWObW]\ S\ Q]ZOP]ÒQW \ Q]\ RWabW\b]a S_cW^]a RS W\dSabWUOQW \ Sc`]^S]a S\b`S Z]a _cS aS W\QZcgS c\ U`c^] RS W\dSabWUOQW \ RS ZO C\WdSàWROR RSZ >O a DOaQ] 3abOa ^]Z bWQOa RS W\dSabWUOQW \ aS `S[]\bO\ O Z] _cS SZ 1]\aSX] RS 3c`]Ô OQ]`R ZO 3abÒbSUWO RS :WaP]O ÔÒ Q]\aSUcW` _cS ZO SQ]\][ O Sc`]^SO aS POaOÒ S\ SZ Q]\]QW[WS\b] ÔÒ RS SabS []R] ZZSUO` O aS` [ta RW\t[WQO g Q][^SbWbWdO :O ORO^bOQW \ RS Sab]a ]PXSbWd]a O \cSab`] Ô a _cSR] ^ZOa[ORO S\ SZ µ>ZO\ $ ÔÒ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZO A]QWSROR RS ZO 7\T]`[OQW \ g RS 1]\dSÙS\QWO Q]\ 3c`]Ô g S\b`S 1][c\WRORSa /cb \][Oa g 1WcRORSa /cb \][Oa¶ Q]\]QWR] bO[PW{\ Q][] >ZO\ /dO\hO S3aÔ O %( ! & :Oa QcOb`] t`SOa RS OQbcOQW \ _cS W\QZcgS SabS >ZO\ a]\( µQWcRORO\ O RWUWbOZ¶ µaS`dWQW]a ^ PZWQ]a RWUWbOZSa¶ µSQ]\][ O RWUWbOZ¶ g µ\cSd] Q]\bSfb] RWUWbOZ¶ QcOR`] ! 3abO ZbW[O t`SO Q]\QSRS c\O W[^]`bO\QWO g ^`Sac^cSab] Q]\aWRSÒPZS O ZO ac^S`dWaW \ RS Q]\bS\WR]a g ZO QWPSàSUc`WROR Q][] Ô`SQS aS` Q]\RWQW \ W\RWa^S\aOPZS ÔÒ _cS SZ QWcRORO\] RS O ^WS aS TWS g O\W[S O VOQS` c\ [Og]` g [SX]` ca] RS ZO OR[W\WabÒQW \ ZO PO\QO g SZ Q][S`QW] SZSQb` \WQ] ÔÒ Oa ZZSUO` O W\Q`S[S\bO` Z]a W\RWQOR]`Sa RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZO RW[S\aW \ T]`[OZ RS ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ S\ 3aÔ O <] Sa RS SfbÒ O` _cS SZ [O`YSbW\U RS ZO TO[WZWO W\bSUÒRO S\ b]`\] ] OZ`SRSR]` RS ZO EWW ] SZ 6][S 1W\S[O ] Z]a RWaQcà]a QS\bÒR]a S\ Z]a \W ]a O aS bÒRchQO\ S\ SabÒbSUWOa POaOROa S\ ZO a]P`S^`]bSQQW \ g QORO dSh [ta SZ Sa^W]\OXS RS Z]a \W ]a g \W Oa ^]` Ô`bS RS Z]a ÔR`Sa g [OR`Sa SRcQOR]`Sa S W\QZca] U]PWS`\]a 3\ ZcUO` RS ^`WdO` O Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa RS ZO OZTOPSbWhOQW \ g a]QWOZWhOQW \ RWUWbOZ Q][] ^`]^]\S ZOa ^]abcÒa µW\bSUÒROa¶ aS ZSa `SUcZO g ac^S`dWaO ^]` [SRW] RS \cSdOa b{Q\WQOa ^`]^]`QW]\OROa ^]` ZO UÒ\ [cZbW\OQW]\OZ Z]a ]ÙO\Wa[]a Sa^SQWOZWhOR]a g ZOa OR[W\WabÒQW]\Sa ac^Ò \OQW]\OZSa Z] _cS O ac dSh ^S`[WbS `SabOPZSQS` ZO XSÒ`_c O S\b`S ORcZb]a g X dS\Sa ^`][cZUORO ^]` Z]a Sf^S`b]a µO^]QOZ ^bWQ]a¶ RS R{QOROa ÔaOROa

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

1cOR`] ! :Oa 1cOb`] È`SOa RS /QbcOQW \ RSZ >ZO\ /dO\hO $ 1WcRORO\ O 2WUWbOZ ³ 1]\d]QOb]`WOa WUcOZROR RS U{\S`] [Og]`Sa g RWaQOÔQWbOR]a ;# ³ >cSabO S\ [O`QVO RS Z]a >`{abO[]a 1WcRORO\ O g 8 dS\Sa C\WdSàWbO`W]a %# ;# ³ 1]\d]QOb]`WO RS RW\O[WhOQW \ A;# ³ >`]gSQb] A]`WO B2B ;# ³ 4W`[O Q]\dS\W] Q]\ W[^cZaO B2B ' ;# 3Q]\][ O 2WUWbOZ ³ >cSabO S\ [O`QVO RS Z]a >`{abO[]a B71 S 7<B@= " # ;# ³ 1]\d]QOb]`WO RSZ >`]UÒ[O /`bS>g[S # # ;# ³ 4W`[O RS Q]\dS\W] >G;3A 3=7 ;# ³ 3ZOP]ÒQW \ RS SabcRW]a >G;3A $ ;# ³ 1]\d]QOb]`WOa 4=@7<B3: %;# ³ 1]\d]QOb]`WOa >@=47B ;# ³ >cSabO S\ [O`QVO RS OQQW]\Sa ÔÒ ^`]bSUS` ZO ^`]^WSROR W\bSZSQbcOZ # ;# ³ 7[^cZa] O ZO Q`SOQW \ RS 4OQb]` Oa RS A]TbeO`S ;#

AS`dWQW]a > PZWQ]a 2WUWbOZSa ³ :O\hO[WS\b] RSZ >`]UÒ[O 1WcRORSa AW\UcZO`Sa /gc\bO[WS\b]a 2WUWbOZSa %% ^`]gSQb]a S\ [O`QVO " ;# ³ 1]\bW\cOQW \ RSZ >`]UÒ[O 1WcRORSa 2WUWbOZSa " [c\WQW^W]a ! ;# ³ >ZObOT]`[O RS /R[W\WabÒQW \ 3ZSQb` \WQO $ ;# ³ 3\aS O Sa $ ;# ³ =bÒa // >> <cSd] 1]\bSfb] 2WUWbOZ ³ @ScbWZWhOQW \ RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ RSZ aSQb]` ^ PZWQ] ;# ³ A c^S`dWaW \ RS Q]\bS\WR]a $ ;# ³ 2 SaO``]ZZ] RSZ >`]UÒ[O RS 3fbS\aW \ RS 0O\RO /\QVO ! % [c\WQW^W]a ;# ³ >`]gSQb] A3BA7 =<C ;# ³ ; SX]Òa S\ ZO eSP RSZ >ZO\ /dO\hO ! ;# ³ :O\hO[WS\b] RSZ 1S\b`] BSQ\]Z UWQ] RSZ >ZO\ /dO\hO ;# ³ 3ZOP]ÒQW \ SabcRW] 1WPSàSUc`WROR ! ;# ³ /QbcOQW]\Sa RS ASUc`WROR 7<B31= % ;#

4cS\bS( ;7BG1 %

3abS bW^] RS RWaQcà]a `SacS\O S\ ]b`]a bSfb]a Q][] SZ ZWP`] RS ;]\a]`Wc % bWbcZOR] 1 [] Q]\b`]ZO` Z] _cS VOQS\ bca VWX]a Q]\ SZ ]`RS\OR]`( b{Q\WQOa RS VOQYS` ÔÒ ÔR`Sa 3Z bSfb] ^ZO\bSO _cS ZO \WQO OZbS`\ObWdO _cS ZSa _cSRO O Z]a ÔR`Sa QcO\R] ZO Q][c\WQOQW \ Q]\ aca VWX]a TOZZO Sa µQ]\dS`bWàS S\ c\ dS`RORS`] Sa^ O W\T]`[tbWQ] /Z WUcOZ _cS Z]a VOQYSà PcS\]a SZ ]PXSbWd] RS Z]a ÔR`Sa bWS\S _cS aS` RSbSQbO` ZOa dcZ\SÒPWZWRORSa RS aca VWX]a g ^`]bSUS`Z]a [WS\bÒa ZSa OgcRO\ g S\aS O\ O VOQS` c\ PcS\ ca] RS 7\bS`\Sb g ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa¶ 3Z ZWP`] ]T`SQS c\O aS`WS RS `SQcà]a S\b`S Z]a _cS aS W\QZcgS\ µ I¬K Q]\b`]ZO` ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa \cSdOa _cS Z]a \W ]a g X dS\Sa SabOPZSQS\ ^]` ZO @SR dWUWZO` b]R] Z] _cS SaQ`WPS\ S\ SZ ;SaaS\US` g ]b`]a QVOba Q]``S]a SZSQb` \WQ]a T]`]a ] PZ]Ua Q][] c\O T]`[O RS ^`]bSUS`ZSa dS` Z] _cS Sabt\ VOQWS\R] Z]a VWX]a S\ ac ]`RS\OR]` RSaRS QcOZ_cWS` ]b`] ]`RS\OR]` OQQSa] `S[]b] g S\ RSTW\WbWdO ^]RS` Q]\b`]ZO` b]R] Z] _cS Z]a \W ]a g OR]ZSaQS\bSa VOQS\ Q]\ c\ ]`RS\OR]` ] Q]\ c\ bSZ{T]\] [ dWZ¶ ;]\a]`Wc % S\ Q]\bÒQcPWS`bO

1]\QZcaW]\Sa g µ2SaO``]ZZ]a¶ :]a RWaQcà]a QS\bÒR]a S\ SZ \W ] O ] OR]ZSaQS\bSa bÒS\ Q]\aWU] dWaW]\Sa _cS OZSXO\ O Sa]a [Wa[]a SabcRW]a RS ZOa Sab`cQbcÒa g `SZOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa _cS Z]a VOQS\ ^]aWPZS 3ab]a S\T]_cSa ZZSdO\ W\aQ`Wb]a O ac dSh SabÒbSUWOa RS W\RWdWRcOQW \ _cS OZ bWS[^] _cS QSZSPÒ\ Ôb`]\Sa RS RSaO``]ZZ] Q][ÔbWPZSa Q]\ SZ µ^`]U`Sa]¶ RS ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ bSQ\]U{\SaWa g `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa RS TO[WZWOa bSQ\]Z UWQO[S\bS Q]\QWZWOROa TO[WZWO W\bSUÒRO `SabOcÒ\ dOZ]`Sa []ÒZSa g OZO`[Oa a]QWOZSa Q]\ \cSdOa W[^ZWQOQW]\Sa ÔÒ W\bS`dS\QW]\Sa a]QWOZSa g bSQ\]Z UWQOa AW ZOa QO[Ô Oa Q]\bÒ Z]a QS\b`]a a]QWOZSa Z]a P]bSZZ]\Sa g ZOa b`WPca c`PO\Oa Sabt\ Q]\aSUcWR] RSbS`W]Ò` Z]a []dW[WS\b]a g bSXWR]a XcdS\WZSa g a]QWOZSa S\ [cQVOa RS \cSabÒ QWcRORSa 2SZUOR] & ZO RS[]\WhOQW \

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

g âWQ]Z]UWhOQWย \ RS ZOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa a]QWOZSa Sabt ^S`[WbWS\R] ORO^bO` S W[^ZS[S\bO` RSbS`[W\OROa `SZOQW]\Sa S\b`S SZ ^`W\QWÔZ aSQb]` RS cacO`W]a RS W\bS`\Sb Xย dS\Sa RS QZOaSa [SRWOa g Z]a \cSd]a ย `RS\Sa RS U]PWS`\] RWUWbOZ C\ W[OUW\O`W] RS ZO W\TO[WO g SZ `WSaU] _cS ^S`[WbS _cS ZO UÒ\ S[^`SaO g aca W\bS`SaSa ^S\Sb`S\ QORO dSh [ta S\ ZO SaTSÒ Q]bWRWO\O /RS[ta RS W\abOcÒ\ [SQO\Wa[] RS `SUcZOQWย \ g U]PWS`\] _cS W\QWbO\ b{Q\WQOa ^]ZWQWOZSa W\QZca] VOQYSà d{OaS SZ ZWP`] RS ;]\a]`Wc % aS RO ^WS O c\O \cSdO ^Sà^SQbWdO QOÔh RS OP`W` ZOa QOXOa \SUÒa RS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g bS[^Ò\O XcdS\bcR 2S ZO [O\] RS ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa RS ZOa \cSdOa `SRSa a]QWOZSa OÔ`SQS c\O \SQSaWROR W[^S`W]aO ^]` `SQ]\ab`cW` ZO WRS\bWROR RWUWbOZ ^]` RSaO``]ZZO` [SQO\Wa[]a R]\RS aS Q]\Tc\RS\ ]QW] `SZOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa g U]PWS`\] RWUWbOZ C\]a [SQO\Wa[]a _cS S\ c\ ^`W\QW^W] O bÒd{a RS bSQ\]Z]U Oa Q][] Z]a QVOba SZ ;SaaS\US` g OV]Ò S\ ^ZObOT]`[Oa [ta O[^ZWOa g ยตbÒ\aÔ`S\bSaยถ Q][] ZOa `SRSa a]QWOZSa ]T`SQS\ ^S_cSย ]a ZOP]Òb]`W]a a]QWOZSa ÔÒ S\aOgO` \]QW]\Sa g `SZOQW]\Sa RS QWcRORO\ O RWUWbOZ VOQWS\R] Oa dS`ROR Z]a ]PXSbWd]a RS OZUc\Oa UÒ\RSa S[^`SaOa g U]PWS`\]a _cS ^]` ]bÒ Ô`bS ZZSdO\ Oย ]a O^`SQWO\R] Z]a POX]a \RWQSa ] \RWQSa RSaWUcOZSa S\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZO W\T]`[OQWย \ 3\ SabS `Sa^SQb] ZO a]QWSROR SaÔย ]ZO g ac RSaO``]ZZ] RSaWUcOZ RS ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO W\T]`[OQWย \ Sa c\ QOa] RS [tfW[] W\bS`{a 1][] [cSabÒ ZO U`tTWQO 3aÔย O ]QcÔ c\] RS Z]a ^`W[S`]a ZcUO`Sa S\ SZ Ò\YW\U [c\RWOZ S\ SZ ca] RS SabOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa a]QWOZSa ESP aWS\R] QZOÒ[S\bS Z RS` S\ SZ S\b]`\] Sc`]^S]

5`tTWQO Ca] RS O^ZWQOQW]\Sa eSP S\ 3c`]^O 4`O\QWO

7bOZWO

@SW\] C\WR]

/ZS[O\WO

BSZST]\ O 7\bS`\Sb

>]RQOabW\U

% '

# !

# "

" ' !

;S\aOXS` O 7\abO\bt\SO

" !

& !

% &

!& %

"& !$ !

"! #

#& $

#' &

3a^Oย O

1`SOQWย \ RS 0Z]Ua

4cS\bS( <]dOb`Wa <Sb=PaS`dS` 3c`]^S $ S3a^Oย O %( %'

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

/ ^SaO` RS ZO OZbO ^S\SbÒQW \ RS ZOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa a]QWOZSa ZOa ^c\bcOQW]\Sa S\ Z]a \RWQSa US\SÒZSa RS RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ RcÒ\bS Z]a ZbW[]a O ]a W\RWQO\ c\ SabO\QO[WS\b] W\QZca] c\ ZSdS `Sb`]QSa] 3aÔ O ]QcÔ c\O ^]aWQW \ RSabOQORO O \WdSZ [c\RWOZ S\ Z]a ca]a a]QWOZSa RS 7\bS`\Sb S\ Sa^SQWOZ ZO [S\aOXS` O W\abO\bt\SO aW\ S[POÙ] ]PbWS\S ^c\bcOQW]\Sa [SRWOa S\ ZO OR[W\WabÒQW \ RWUWbOZ g ^c\bcOQW]\Sa [cg POXOa S\ ZO Q][^Ò g ZO PO\QO SZSQb` \WQO O ^SaO` RS Q]\bO` Q]\ c\] RS Z]a aWabS[Oa PO\QO`W]a [ta STWQWS\bSa RSZ [c\R] ! 3abO RWaÔ`WROR S\ Z]a W\RWQOR]`Sa RS RSaO``]ZZ] W\dWbO O W\ROUO` S\ SZ Ô^SZ _cS XcSUO\ OQbcOZ[S\bS Z]a X dS\Sa S\ `SZOQW \ O ZOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa a]QWOZSa ZO OZO`[O a]QWOZ S\ b]`\] O ZOa [Wa[Oa Qc`W]aO[S\bS S\ c\ [][S\b] Q][] VS[]a W\RWQOR] S\ SZ QcOZ S[^WShO\ O TÒUcOàS \]QW]\Sa RS TO[WZWO W\bSUÒRO g S\ SZ _cS Q][] `SQcS`RO SZ W\T]`[S S3aÔ O %( & Z]a ^`W\QWÔZSa RSaO``]ZZ]a RS ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ µ\] acÙSI\K RS ZO OQbWdWROR ^`S[SRWbORO RS Z]a W\US\WS`]a aW\] Q][] ^`]^WSROR S[SÙS\bS RS ZO ^`]^WO `SR RS `SRSa G Z] VOQSI\K ÔÒ `STZSXO` _cS ´bOZ Q][] aS dWS\S OTW`[O\R] S\ \c[S`]a]a T]`]a RSaRS ^`W\QW^W]a RS aWUZ]´ ZO dS`RORSÒ YWZZS` O^^ IO^ZWQOQW \ [ta SfWb]aOK RS 7\bS`\Sb a]\ a][]a ZOa ^Sà]\Oa¶ " ! ASU \ Z]a \RWQSa RS RSaO``]ZZ] ^cPZWQOR]a ^]` SZ W\T]`[S 7A7 " 3aÔ O ]QcÔPO ZO ^]aWQW \ O\bS^S\ ZbW[O S\ ZO 3c`]Ô RS Z]a # 3C # g ZO RSQW[]bS`QSÒ S\ ZO C3 # ]PbS\WS\R] ZO [SX]` ^]aWQW \ S\ ZO RW[S\aW \ a]QWOZ 7\T]`[Sa [ta `SQWS\bSa aS OZO\ _cS RcÒ\bS SZ ZbW[] O ] aS VO ÔaOR] RSZ R{QW[] bS`QS` ^cSab] OZ dWU{aW[] S\ ZO C3 % S3aÔ O % " AW aS Q]\aWRSÒ ZO RWab`WPcQW \ ^]PZOQW]\OZ ^]` U`c^]a RS SROR Z]a ROb]a ^ZO\bSO\ _cS [ta RSZ & RS Z]a cacO`W]a aS S\QcS\bÒ\ S\b`S ZOa SRORSa RS " O "" O ]a 3Z U`c^] Q][^`S\RWR] S\b`S ZOa SRORSa RS " O !" O ]a [ta QS`QO\Oa O \]QW]\Sa OQbcOZSa RS XcdS\bcR ac^SÒ SZ $! RS Z]a cacO`W]a RS 7\bS`\Sb 5]`R] g ;SU Oa $ 3Z ^`]U`SaWd] `SXcdS\SQW[WS\b] RS Z]a W\bS`\OcbOa SaÔ ]ZSa _cSRO `ST`S\ROR] ^]` Z]a ROb]a [ta `SQWS\bSa( S\ SZ ^S` ]R] RS " OZ aSUc\R] aS[Sab`S RS $ ZO ^]PZOQW \ W\TO\bWZ Q][^`S\RWRO S\b`S Z]a " O ]a _cS VO cbWZWhOR] 7\bS`\Sb S\ Z]a ZbW[]a ! [SaSa VO ÔaOR] RS c\ $ OZ % 7<3 %

/ SabOa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa QOP` O O ORW` _cS S\ UÒ\ [SRWRO SZ OcUS OQbcOZ RS ZOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa a]QWOZSa RSZ {\TOaWa _cS aS ^]\S S\ Z]a ^`]^W]a cacO`W]a g Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS S\ Z]a X dS\Sa Z]a [tfW[]a ^]PZOR]`Sa RS ZO `SR Sa SZ `SacZbOR] RSZ RSPOQZS RS ZOa µS[^`SaOa ^c\b] Q][¶ S\ SZ O ] 1][] W\RWQO\ /``WOhc Sb OZ &( µO_cSZZ]a _cS S\ Z]a O ]a \]dS\bO bÒbO`]\ RS TWXO` SZ Tc\QW]\O[WS\b] RS ZO `SR S\ b]`\] O ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa RS \SU]QW] _cS SaS bS``Wb]`W] O \ dWÙS\ OZPSÙOPO ÔÒ ac Q]Z]\WhOQW \ S[^`SaO`WOZ SabOPO\ S_cWd]QOR]a 3Z QS\b`] RS W\bS`\Sb \] SÒ\ ZOa S[^`SaOa _cS RSO[PcZO`]\ QcSabO OPOX] g aW\ T`S\]a ^]` ZOa Ocb]^WabOa RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ b]R] Z] Q]\bÒ`W] SZ \cSd] µOab`] `Sg¶ SÒ SZ cacO`W] ³SZ W\bS`\OcbO¶ AW\ S[POÙ] Q][] bO[PW{\ \]a `SQcS`RO\ Sab]a Ocb]`Sa RSa^ZOhO` OZ cacO`W] O OZ QS\b`] RSZ RWaQcà] g RS ZOa ^`tQbWQOa \] aWU\WTWQO RS^]aWbO` S\ {Z SZZO ZOa QOÔQWRORSa RS Q]\b`]Z >S`] ¥_c{ aWU\WTWQO `SOZ[S\bS- 3\ \cSabÒ ]^W\W \ aWU\WTWQO T][S\bO` SabÒbSUWOa RS Ocb]^`]RcQQW \ g Ocb]``SUcZOQW \ Q][] c\ \cSd] `SdcZaWd] ÔÒ O[]`bWUcO` Z]a Q]\bÒabSa SfWabS\bSa S\b`S Z]a ca]a a]QWOZSa g T]`[OZSa RS ZO `SR Oa Q][] c\ OQbWd] W[^]`bO\bS ÔÒ _cS ZO OR[W\WabÒQW \ g ZOa [cZbW\OQW]\OZSa T][S\bS\ SZ µRSaO``]ZZ]¶ RS WRS\bWRORSa RWUWbOZSa TWOPZSa g ]PaS`dOPZSa S\ `SR @343@3<17/A 070:7=5@È471/A /Z]\a] : 3 & µ2S ZO \]`[O RS Q]\ac[] OZ Q]\ac[] aW\ \]`[O( ^`SQO`WSROR ZOP]ÒZ Sa^SQcZOQW \ W\[]PWZWO`WO g \cSdOa T]`[Oa RS Q]\ac[] S\ 3aÔ O¶ ^]\S\QWO S\ F 4]`] a]P`S BS\RS\QWOa A]QWOZSa 8cdS\bcR g 3fQZcaW \ C<32 ;OR`WR [O`h] ÈZdO`Sh C` O 4 1][^ b` % 9O`Z ;O`f ;Of ESPS` g 3[WZS 2c`YVSW[( a]QW]Z]U O g SRcQOQW \ ;OR`WR ;]ÒbO /``WOhc @ 0ZO\Q] @ 1O`] 5 3abOZSZZO / g 5 [Sh 1`ch 3 & µ¥7\abOZOR]a S\ ZO Q`SabO RS ZO eSP - 1W\Q] Ocb]`Sa S\ PcaQO RS ZO µPWU be] R]b hS`]¶ S\ 7 AtROPO g / 5]`R] Q]]`Ra 1cZbcÒ RWUWbOZ g []dW[WS\b]a a]QWOZSa :O 1ObOÒbO ;OR`WR '& /c\W \ 8 / g >{`Sh 4 8 % µ3Z QWPSÒQ]aOR]` OQb O S\ T` ]¶ 3Z >O a $ RS \]dWS[P`S 0]aQV[O 8 & 5S\SÒQW \ 3W\abSW\ ;ta ZWab]a [ta `t^WR]a g [ta a]QWOPZSa >ZO\SbO 0O`QSZ]\O

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

0cQYW\UVO[ 2 /TbS` bVS 2SObV ]T 1VWZRV]]R >]ZWbg >`Saa 1O[P`WRUS 0c`[O\ 3 & 2SQ]\ab`cQbW\U 2SdSZ]^[S\bOZ >agQV]Z]Ug O SRWQW \ @]cbZSRUS :]\R`Sa 2SZUOR] ; & :O QWcROR [S\bW`]aO 4ÒcRS g [WaS`WO RSZ µ[]RSZ] 0O`QSZ]\¶ :O 1ObOÒ ;OR`WR S3aÔ O % 7\T]`[S O\cOZ a]P`S SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ S\ 3aÔ O ;OR`WR( 4c\ROQW \ =Ò\US 4SWfO 1 # µ:O VOPWbOQW \ RS Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa¶ S\ >O^SZSa RSZ 1371 $ C\WdSàWROR RSZ >O a DOaQ]( 1371 1S\b`] RS 3abcRW]a a]P`S ZO 7RS\bWROR 1]ZSQbWdO Vbb^( eee SVc Sa 1371 Ô^SZSa $ ^RT 4S`\t\RSh RS :Wa > $ µDWOXS OZ QS\b`] RS ;WQ`]a]Tb¶ S\ 3Z >O a AS[O\OZ 2WO`W] 3Z >O a & RS S\S`] 5W[S\] AOQ`Wabt\ 8 Q][^ & 3RcQO` ^]` Q][^SbS\QWOa ¥_c{ VOg RS \cSd]- ;]ÒbO ;OR`WR 5]`R] / g ;SU Oa 7 $ 8 dS\Sa g QcZbcÒ ;SaaS\US` BSQ\]Z]U Oa RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ g ZO Q][c\WQOQW \ S\ ZO a]QWSROR W\bSÒQbWdO 7<8CD3 4/2 ;OR`WR 6S\R`WQY 6 '' µ1]\ab`cQbW]\a O\R `SQ]\ab`cQbW]\a ]T 0`WbWaV QVWZRV]]R( /\ W\bS`^`SbWdS ac`dSg & b] bVS ^`SaS\b ROg¶ S\ / 8O[Sa g / >`]cb 3Ra 1]\ab`cQbW\U O\R `SQ]\ab`cQbW\U QVWZRV]]R( 1]\bS[^]Ò`g WaacSa W\ bVS a]QW]Z]UWQOZ abcRg ]T QVWZRV]]R 0OaW\Uab]YS 4OZ[S` !# #' 7<3 % 3\QcSabO a]P`S 3_cWÔ[WS\b] g Ca] RS BSQ\]Z]U Oa RS ZO 7\T]`[OQW \ g 1][c\WQOQW \ S\ Z]a V]UO`Sa % ASUc\R] aS[Sab`S $ 7\abWbcb] <OQW]\OZ RS 3abOR abWQOa ;OR`WR ;]\a]`Wc ; % 1 [] Q]\b`]ZO` Z] _cS VOQS\ bca VWX]a Q]\ SZ ]`RS\OR]` B{Q\WQOa RS VOQYS` ÔÒ ÔR`Sa 1`SOQW]\Sa 1]^g`WUVb ;OR`WR AVO`[O 2 " µ1cZbcÒZ ÔbVeOga bV`]cUV bVS W\T]`[ObW]\ OUS¶ S\ <Se 2W`SQbW]\a T]` QVWZR O\R OR]ZSaQS\b RSdSZ]^[S\b # ! "

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

9D8JB:CIDH

;S`QSRSa 5O`Q O @cWh 1]\aSX] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR RS /abc`WOa

? kZcZh ZbegZcYZYdgZh! Zc WjhXV YZ aV dedgijc^YVY

<cSabÒ a]QWSROR dWdS c\ Q]\bW\c] ^`]QSa] RS QO[PW] S\ SZ _cS OÔ`SQS\ \cSd]a Q]\bSfb]a _cS a]\ bO[PW{\ ]^]`bc\WRORSa ÔÒ ZO XcdS\bcR g _cS Sabt\ ZWUOR]a O Q]\QS^b]a Q][] S[^`S\RS` S[^`S\RWhOXS XcdS\bcR S[^`S\RSR]Ò g S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa 3abOa T]`[Oa RS OP]`RO` g OT`]\bO` SZ [c\R] ZZSdO\ Q]\aWU] c\O aS`WS RS QOÒQbS` abWQOa RWTS`S\QWOZSa g QcOZWRORSa gO aS bÒbS RS c\O ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò O \WdSZ S[^`SaO`WOZ Q][] a]QWOZ >`]Tc\RWhO`S[]a S\ Z]a Oa^SQb]a _cS bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ SZ PWS\SabO` a]QWOZ Q][] c\ \cSd] Q]\bSfb] RS bÒPOX] g Q]\ ZO TWUcÒ RS S[^`S\RSR]` g S[^`S\RSR]Ò a]QWOZ g Z]a Oa^SQb]a `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ SabO \cSdO TWUcÒ AS ^ZO\bSO ORS[ta SZ t[PWb] RS W\bS`dS\QW \ [ta dW\QcZOR] OZ aSQb]` a]QWOZ ] bO[PW{\ RS\][W\OR] bS`QS` aSQb]` Q][] ]^]`bc\WROR ÔÒ ZO XcdS\bcR S\ ac RSaO``]ZZ] ^Sà]\OZ g bO[PW{\ ^`]TSaW]\OZ AS `SQ]US\ OZUc\Oa Sf^S`WS\QWOa RSaRS SZ t[PWb] SRcQObWd] _cS T][S\bO\ SabO QcZbcÒ S[^`S\RSR]Ò RSaRS ZO W\TO\QWO g S\ ZO XcdS\bcR RSaRS RWTS`S\bSa SaÔQW]a >OZOPÒa QZOdS( XcdS\bcR S[^`S\RSR]Ò S[^`S\RSR]` a]QWOZ S[^`S\RWhOXS

<cSd]a Q]\bSfb]a RS bÒPOX] ]^]`bc\WROR g `WSaU] AS ^ZO\bSO\ \cSd]a Q]\bSfb]a RS bÒPOX] _cS aS `STWS`S\ OZ t[PWb] S[^`SaO`WOZ g ac aWbcOQW \ OQbcOZ aSU \ SZ 7\T]`[S 53; % g ^]` ]bÒ Ô`bS Oa^SQb]a `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ ZO TWUcÒ RS S[^`S\RSR]` ] S[^`S\RSR]Ò a]QWOZ Q][] c\ \cSd] QO[^] RS ]^]`bc\WROR RS bÒPOX] ÔÒ ZO XcdS\bcR ASU \ SZ >`]gSQb] 53; S\ ac ZbW[] W\T]`[S % SZ Q]\bSfb] ^cÒ[S\bS S[^`SaO`WOZ RS ZO OQbWdWROR S[^`S\RSR]Ò Q]\abWbcgS RSaRS TW\OZSa RS Z]a O ]a ' c\ SZS[S\b] W[^`SaQW\RWPZS ÔÒ S\bS\RS` SZ RSaO``]ZZ] SQ]\ [WQ] RS QcOZ_cWS` bS``Wb]`W] g OgcRO O ZO ^`SdWaW \ g OXcabS RS ^]Z bWQOa ^ PZWQOa OZZ R]\RS aS \SQSaWbO SZ W[^cZa] RS \cSd]a ^`]gSQb]a g ZO US\SÒQW \ RS S[^ZS] 3Z ^`]gSQb] 53; 5Z]POZ 3\b`S^`S\ScàVW^ ;]\Wb]` \OQW S\ SZ O ] ''% Q][] c\O W\WQWObWdO RS ZO :]\R]\ 0caW\Saa AQV]]Z g RSZ 0OPa]\ 1]ZZSUS ÔÒ Q`SO` c\O `SR W\bS`\OQW]\OZ RS W\dSabWUOQW \ S\ SZ S\b]`\] RS ZO 1`SOQW \ RS 3[^`SaOa

7\T]`[S 53; 3a^O O % 5Z]POZ 3\b`S^`S\Sc`aVW^ ;]\Wb]`

3[^`S\RS` Sa ^]` RSTW\WQW \ OQ][SbS` OZU] _cS S\bÒ O RWTWQcZbOR g `WSaU] 3\ SZ aS\bWR] SQ]\ [WQ] QZtaWQ] S[^`S\RS` Sa ^]\S` S\ [O`QVO c\ \cSd] ^`]gSQb] S[^`SaO`WOZ Oac[WS\R] SZ `WSaU] _cS {abS Q]\ZZSdO O QO[PW] RS c\ PS\STWQW] S[^`SaO`WOZ _cS aS RSTW\S Q][ \[S\bS Q][] ZO `S[c\SÒQW \ RS SaS `WSaU] _cS aS Oac[S OZ S[^`S\RS` BS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO _cS c\O W\WQWObWdO S[^`S\RSR]Ò Sa b]R] O_c{Z \SU]QW] ] OQbWdWROR S[^`SaO`WOZ W\QZcgS\R] SZ Ocb]S[^ZS] _cS aS ^]\S S\

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

[O`QVO S\ QcOZ_cWS` aSQb]` g _cS \] a]P`SÔaO Z]a " [SaSa RS dWRO ZO bOaO RS OQbWdWROR S[^`S\RSR]Ò `SUWabÒRO ^]` 53; S\ ZO ^]PZOQW \ SaÔ ]ZO RS & O $" O ]a RS SROR Sa RSZ % $ S\ SZ % /ZUc\]a Oa^SQb]a RWTS`S\bSa `Sa^SQb] O O ]a O\bS`W]`Sa aS OZO\ _cS aS ORdWS`bS c\ STSQb] W\[SRWOb] S\ SZ RSaQS\a] RS ZO W\bS`dS\QW \ TS[S\W\O S\ ZO OQbWdWROR S[^`S\RSR]Ò AW\ S[POÙ] \cSabÒ bOaO aWUcS Oc[S\bO\R] Q]\ ZO Q]\b`WPcQW \ RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa SfbÒ\XSÒa gO aSO\ RS `{UW[S\ US\SÒZ ] Q][c\WbO`W]a g _cS ZO [cXS` W\[WUÒ\bS RSZ ^`W[S` bW^] Sa ^`]^]`QW]\OZ[S\bS [cQV] [ta S[^`S\RSR]Ò _cS ZO SaÔ ]ZO 3\ QO[PW] ZO SROR [SRWO aS VO [O\bS\WR] SabOPZS ^]` Z] _cS ^cSRS RSQWàS _cS ZO W\Q]`^]ÒQW \ RS X dS\Sa OZ ^`]QSa] S[^`S\RSR]` \] aS VO RSbS\WR] OZ [S\]a SabS O ] 3\ QcO\b] OZ bW^] RS W\WQWObWdOa aS Q]\bS[^ZO c\O [Og]` RWdSàWTWQOQW \ S\ SZ bW^] RS \SU]QW] Q`SOR] Z] QcOZ aS Ob`WPcgS O c\ [Og]` W\bS`{a ^]` ZO W\\]dOQW \ S\ ^`]RcQb] S\ bSQ\]Z]U Oa g S\ ZO SfÔ\aW \ :O Q`SOQW \ RS S[^ZS] g ZO RW[S\aW \ RS ZOa W\WQWObWdOa S[^`S\RSR]Òa S\ US\SÒZ aWUcS aWS\R] b ^WQO[S\bS µ[WQ`]¶ ^S`] \] Sa RSaRS OPZS SZ ^]`QS\bOXS RS ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa _cS bWS\S S\ ac t\W[] ZO W\bS\QW \ RS Q`SQS` g RS Q`SO` S[^ZS] 3\ QcO\b] O ZO TW\O\QWOQW \ RS ZOa W\WQWObWdOa aS ORdWS`bS\ R]a Q]aOa( S\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` c\O W\dSàW \ [SRWO [Og]` g c\O [Og]` W\bS`dS\QW \ RS TcS\bSa TW\O\QWSÒa OXS\Oa O ZO ^`]^WO ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò >]` Q]\aWUcWS\bS ZO ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò RSZ % aS ^]R` O dS` Q][] [ta ^`SÔÒRO ÔÒ Oac[W` `WSaU]a g Q]\ c\O [S\bOZWROR [ta OQ]`RS Q]\ ZOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa Ob`WPcWPZSa O SabO TWUcÒ :O /R[W\WabÒQW \ ^ PZWQO VO ZZSdOR] O QOP] [ ZbW^ZSa OQQW]\Sa ÔÒ [SX]Ò` SabS S\b]`\] S[^`S\RSR]` RSaRS aca Q]\RWQW]\Sa ZOP]ÒZSa O ZO SfWUS\QWO RS [Og]` `WUc`]aWROR S\ SZ ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] RS ^`]gSQb]a acaQS^bWPZSa RS PS\STWQWOàS Q]\ acPdS\QW]\Sa OZ O^]g] O ZO [cXS` S[^`S\RSR]Ò g O ZOa ^Sà]\Oa W\[WUÒ\bSa O ZO Q]\TSQQW \ RS ^ZO\Sa RS T][S\b] S[^`SaO`WOZ bO\b] O \WdSZ SabObOZ Q][] `SUW]\OZ ] Z]QOZ g bO[PW{\ S\ QcO\b] O ZO [SX]Ò RS ZO bÒ[WbOQW \ Pc`]Q`tbWQO g ]b`]a T`S\bSa /aW[Wa[] SZ \ [S`] RS W\abWbcQW]\Sa OQOR{[WQOa bO\b] ^`WdOROa Q][] ^ PZWQOa _cS Sabt\ W\Q]`^]Ò\R] OaWU\ObcÒa Qcà]a g X]`\OROa `SZOQW]\OROa Q]\ ZO OQbWdWROR S[^`S\RSR]Ò Q`SQS R O O R O g Oc\_cS ac W[ÔQb] b]ROd O \] Sa acTWQWS\bS aS dO [SX]Ò\R] ^`]U`SaWdO[S\bS 4W\OZ[S\bS Z]a [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQW \ g ]b`]a [cQV]a OUS\bSa bOZSa Q][] ZOa 1t[OÒa RS 1][S`QW] /a]QWOQW]\Sa RS 3[^`SaO`W]a 2SaO``]ZZ] :]QOZ 0O\QO g 1OXOa RS /V]``]a aS VO\ d]ZQOR] S\ ZO ^`][]QW \ RS ZO TWUcÒ RSZ S[^`S\RSR]` >OÒ O\OZWhO` SZ SabOR] RS ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS S\b]`\] ] TOQb]`Sa _cS aS Q]\aWRSÒ\ Q][] [ta W\TZcgS\bSa S\ SZ OdO\QS ] SZ `Sb`]QSa] RS ZO OQbWdWROR S[^`S\RSR]Ò SZ ]PaS`dOb]`W] 53; `SOZWhO O\cOZ[S\bS c\O S\QcSabO A]P`S OZUc\]a TOQb]`Sa SaS\QWOZSa( SZ O^]g] TW\O\QWS`] ZOa ^]Z bWQOa UcPS`\O[S\bOZSa Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa UcPS`\O[S\bOZSa ZO SRcQOQW \ g T]`[OQW \ ZO bÒ\aTS`S\QWO RS 7 2 SZ OQQSa] O W\TÒSab`cQbcÒ Q][S`QWOZ g ^`]TSaW]\OZ ZO O^S`bcÒ RSZ [S`QOR] W\bS`\] SZ OQQSa] O W\TÒSab`cQbcÒ T aWQO g ZOa \]`[Oa a]QWOZSa g QcZbcÒZSa /RS[ta( SZ O^]g] O ZO [cXS` S[^`S\RSR]Ò SZ `Sa^Sb] OZ RS`SQV] W\bSZSQbcOZ SZ O^]g] OZ Q`SQW[WS\b] S[^`SaO`WOZ g SZ W\bS`{a ^]` ZO W\\]dOQW \

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

3Z OQQSa] O W\TÒSab`cQbcÒ T aWQO ZOa [SRWROa RS O^]g] O ZO [cXS` S[^`S\RSR]Ò SZ OQQSa] O W\TÒSab`cQbcÒ Q][S`QWOZ g RS aS`dWQW]a SZ W\bS`{a ^]` ZO W\\]dOQW \ Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa UcPS`\O[S\bOZSa g SZ O^]g] OZ Q`SQW[WS\b] RS ZOa S[^`SaOa g \SU]QW]a a]\ Z]a TOQb]`Sa _cS Sabt\ S\ c\ SabOR] OZU] [ta _cS OQS^bOPZS S\ \cSab`] Ô a S\ SZ % 2SZ b]bOZ RS ZO OQbWdWROR S[^`S\RSR]Ò SaÔ ]ZO ZO UÒ\ [Og]` O aS Q`SO ^`W\QWÔZ[S\bS ^]` O^`]dSQVO[WS\b] RS c\O ]^]`bc\WROR :O ]^]`bc\WROR Sa SZ []bWd] ^`W\QWÔZ

%$ "

:O \SQSaWROR Sa SZ []bWd] ^`W\QW^OZ

" '

=b`]a a]\ Z]a []bWd]a ^`W\QW^OZSa

& %

1cO\R] c\O ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò ^]bS\QWOZ RSbSQbO c\O ]^]`bc\WROR g b][O ZO RSQWaW \ RS ZZSdO`ZO O ZO ^`tQbWQO SfWabS\ ORS[ta []bWd]a ^Sà]\OZSa `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ ac RSaO``]ZZ] ^Sà]\OZ g ^`]TSaW]\OZ ;Og]` W\RS^S\RS\QWO

# %

/c[S\bO` W\U`Sa]a

;O\bS\S` W\U`Sa]a

=b`] QOa] ] \] aOPS 3[^`SaO TO[WZWO`

" " %

AS `SQ]US ORS[ta SZ ^S`TWZ a]QW]SQ]\ [WQ] RSZ S[^`S\RSR]` `SaWRS\bS S\ 3aÔ O aSU \ SZ bWS[^] RSaRS SZ W\WQW] RS ZO OQbWdWROR( ³ >S`TWZ RSZ S[^`S\RSR]` \OQWS\bS VOabO ! [SaSa RS OQbWdWROR ( dO` \ RS SROR [SRWO S\ b]`\] O Z]a !& O ]a Q]\ SabcRW]a ac^S`W]`Sa \WdSZ RS `S\bO SZSdOR] S\ OQbWd] _cS aS RSRWQO O bWS[^] Q][^ZSb] O ac W\WQWObWdO _cS \] VOP O S[^`S\RWR] ]b`] \SU]QW] Q]\ O\bS`W]`WROR g _cS bWS\S \OQW]\OZWROR SaÔ ]ZO ³ >S`TWZ RSZ S[^`S\RSR]` \cSd] S\b`S ! g " [SaSa RS OQbWdWROR ( DO` \ RS SROR [SRWO S\ b]`\] O Z]a !% % O ]a Q]\ SabcRW]a ac^S`W]`Sa \WdSZ RS `S\bO SZSdOR] S\ OQbWd] _cS aS RSRWQO O bWS[^] Q][^ZSb] O ac W\WQWObWdO _cS \] VOP O S[^`S\RWR] ]b`] \SU]QW] Q]\ O\bS`W]`WROR g _cS bWS\S \OQW]\OZWROR SaÔ ]ZO ³ >S`TWZ RSZ S[^`S\RSR]` Q]\a]ZWROR] [ta RS " [SaSa RS OQbWdWROR ( DO` \ RS SROR [SRWO S\ b]`\] O Z]a "! O ]a Q]\ SabcRW]a ]PZWUOb]`W]a \WdSZ RS `S\bO SZSdOR] S\ OQbWd] _cS aS RSRWQO O bWS[^] Q][^ZSb] O ac W\WQWObWdO _cS bWS\S POabO\bSa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS VOPS` S[^`S\RWR] ]b`] \SU]QW] Q]\ O\bS`W]`WROR g _cS bWS\S \OQW]\OZWROR SaÔ ]ZO ³ >S`TWZ RSZ S[^`S\RSR]` _cS VO OPO\R]\OR] c\O OQbWdWROR ;cXS` SaÔ ]ZO RS QS`QO RS " O ]a RS SROR Q]\ SabcRW]a ac^S`W]`Sa ] S\aS O\hO ]PZWUOb]`WO Q]\ c\ \WdSZ RS `S\bO ^Sà]\OZ POX] _cS OQbcOZ[S\bS bÒPOXO g _cS ^]aWPZS[S\bS VOP O bS\WR] OZUc\O ]bÒ Sf^S`WS\QWO RS bW^] S[^`S\RSR]` O\bSa RS OPO\R]\O` ZO OQbcOZ 3Z W\T]`[S 53; Q]\bS[^ZO RWdSàOa []bWdOQW]\Sa ÔÒ SZ OPO\R]\] RS

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

OQbWdWRORSa S[^`S\RSR]Òa ^]` Z] _cS bÒa SabS ^S`TWZ aS Q][S\bO\ OZUc\Oa ^SQcZWO`WRORSa ]PaS`dOROa S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZO []bWdOQW \ ÔÒ SZ QWS``S ] OPO\R]\] RS c\O W\WQWObWdO( C\O ]^]`bc\WROR RS dS\RS` TOZbO RS `S\bOPWZWROR RSZ \SU]QW] ^`]PZS[Oa ÔÒ Q]\aSUcW` TW\O\QWOQW \ acÙW[WS\b] RS ]bÒ ]^]`bc\WROR RS bÒPOX] OPO\R]\] ^ZO\WTWQOR] Q]\ O\bS`W]`WROR []bWd]a ^Sà]\OZSa ³ >S`TWZ RSZ S[^`S\RSR]` ^]bS\QWOZ( AS Q]\aWRSÒ _cS c\O ^Sà]\O Sa c\ S[^`S\RSR]` ^]bS\QWOZ aW VO `Sa^]\RWR] OTW`[ObWdO[S\bS O ZO ^`SUc\bO RS bS\S` W\bS\QW \ RS S[^`S\RS` S\ Z]a ^` fW[]a b`Sa O ]a bÒa ZO S\QcSabO 53; 3Z ^S`TWZ [SRW] RS SabS Q]ZSQbWd] Sa( dO` \ RS SROR [SRWO QS`QO\O O Z]a !# O ]a Q]\ SabcRW]a ac^S`W]`Sa \WdSZ RS `S\bO SZSdOR] S\ OQbWd] g SaÔ ]Z ³ >S`TWZ RSZ S[^`S\RSR]` SaÔ ]Z % S\ US\SÒZ( dO` \ RS !% ' O ]a RS SROR [SRWO Q]\ SabcRW]a ac^S`W]`Sa \WdSZ RS `S\bO SZSdOR] _cS bÒPOXO VOPWbcOZ[S\bS O bWS[^] Q][^ZSb] S\ ZO W\WQWObWdO _cS Sabt RSaO``]ZZO\R] _cS \] VOP O aWR] S[^`S\RSR]` Q]\ O\bS`W]`WROR S\ c\O OQbWdWROR RWabW\bO RS ZO OQbcOZ g _cS Sa RS ]`WUS\ SaÔ ]Z 3\ Z] _cS aS `STWS`S O Z]a \cSd]a Q]\bSfb]a RS bÒPOX] `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ SZ t[PWb] a]QWOZ acÙS\ RS ZO \SQSaWROR RS Q]ZOP]ÒQW \ RS RWTS`S\bSa OUS\bSa( SabOR] [S`QOR] Q][c\WROR g a]QWSROR QWdWZ AS bWS\RS O \cSdO RWdWaW \ [WfbO RS ZO ^`]RcQQW \ RS PWS\SabO` S\T]QOR] RSaRS c\ `SÔ`b] RS Ô^SZSa S\b`S Sab]a OUS\bSa S\ R]\RS SZ 3abOR] aWUcS aWS\R] SZ UOÒ\bS RS Z]a RS`SQV]a a]QWOZSa g RS ZOa ^`SabOQW]\Sa PtaWQOa SZ [S`QOR] ^cSRS TOd]`SQS` c\O [SX]` SZSQQW \ W\RWdWRcOZ g ZO a]QWSROR QWdWZ ^S`[WbS TOd]`SQS` SZ SXS`QWQW] RS ZO RS[]QÒQWO a]QWOZ S W\bSUÒQW \ a]QWOZ

0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O

3abS SaÔQW] O[^ZWOR] RS ^`]RcQQW \ RS PWS\SabO` Sa c\ SaÔQW] ^`]^WQW] ÔÒ SZ S[^`S\RWhOXS a]QWOZ g ac^]\S c\ \cSd] Q]\bSfb] RS bÒPOX] g ]^]`bc\WROR ÔÒ ZO XcdS\bcR 3\ SZ Q]\bSfb] S[^`SaO`WOZ SZ S[^`S\RWhOXS Sabt b][O\R] QcS`^] /RS[ta RS ^]bS\QWO` ]ÙO\WhOQW]\Sa W\\]dOR]Òa ]ÙO\WhOQW]\Sa _cS O^`S\RS\ aS PcaQO\ ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa QOÔQSa RS ZcQVO` ^]` W[^ZS[S\bO` c\O WRSO _cS `Sa^]\RO O ZO W\WQWObWdO g Q`SObWdWROR ^Sà]\OZ 4c\ROQW]\Sa g S[^`SaOa ^`WdOROa Sabt\ ^]bS\QWO\R] SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS SabO t`SO RSaRS SZ Q]\dS\QW[WS\b] RS _cS SZ S[^`S\RWhOXS Sa ]bÒ TcS\bS STSQbWdO RS RSaO``]ZZ] SQ]\ [WQ] g a]QWOZ RS c\O Q][c\WROR RSbS`[W\ORO 3\ SZ Q]\bSfb] ^ PZWQ] bO[PW{\ aS VOPZO RS S[^`S\RWhOXS g aS SabOPZSQS c\O SabÒbSUWO ÔÒ SZ T][S\b] RSZ O^`S\RWhOXS g S[^`S\RWhOXS S\ Z]a t[PWb]a SRcQObWd]a OQOR{[WQ]a TO[WZWO`Sa g S[^`SaO`WOZSa

8 dS\Sa S[^`S\RSR]`Sa @OaU]a RWTS`S\QWOZSa

! ;Q 1ZSZZO\R 2 1 '&% µ1VO`SabS`WabWQa ]T AcQQSaaTcZ 3\b`S^`S\Sc`a¶ 8]c`\OZ ]T 1`SObWdS 03VOdW]S S\ 0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O !$#

ASU \ SZ Sf^S`b] S\ USabW \ g RW`SQQW \ >SbS` 4 2`cQYS` ! SZ b{`[W\] S[^`S\RSR]` RSZ TÒ\Q{a S\b`S|\Sc` µOZUcWS\ _cS VOQS acg] OZU]¶ TcS W\b`]RcQWR] VOQS R]a aWUZ]a ^]` SZ SQ]\][WabO TÒ\Q{a 8SO\ 0O^bWabS AOg ÔÒ `STS`WàS O c\ OUS\bS SQ]\ [WQ] Sa^SQWOZ \] OZUcWS\ _cS aW[^ZS[S\bS OP`S c\ \SU]QW] aW\] OZUcWS\ _cS bÒ\aTWS`S `SQcà]a SQ]\ [WQ]a RS c\ bS``Wb]`W] RS POXO ^`]RcQbWdWROR O ]b`] RS [Og]` ^`]RcQbWdWROR g `S\RW[WS\b]¶ 3Z SQ]\][WabO RSZ Q`SQW[WS\b] SQ]\ [WQ] RSZ aWUZ] FF 8]aS^V / AQVc[^SbS` RSaQ`WPW SZ S[^`S\RSR]` Q][] ZO \SQSaO`WO TcS\bS RS µRSab`cQQW \ Q`SObWdO¶ ÔÒ OdO\QSa SQ]\ [WQ]a W[^]`bO\bSa

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

/Ô`SQS\ \cSd]a Q]\QS^b]a `SZOQW]\OR]a Q][] a]\ RS S[^`S\RWhOXS a]QWOZ g SZ S[^`S\RW[WS\b] a]QWOZ 3Z S[^`S\RWhOXS aS Q]\aWRSÒ QZOÒ[S\bS c\O [O\SÒ STSQbWdO RS T][S\bO` SZ RSaO``]ZZ] SQ]\ [WQ] a]QWOZ RS c\O Q][c\WROR W<<]DO<2WA " S\ SZ W\bS\b] RS RSTW\W` SZ Q]\QS^b] g ROR] _cS S[^`S\RW[WS\b] ] S[^`S\RWhOXS a]\ d]QOPZ]a QcgO RSTW\WQW \ b]ROd O \] Sabt `SQ]UWRO S\ SZ 2WQQW]\O`W] RS ZO @SOZ /QORS[WO RS ZO :S\UcO 3aÔ ]ZO 2@/:3 ^ZO\bSO Q]\QS^b]a _cS Sabt\ Sab`SQVO[S\bS `SZOQW]\OR]a /a \]a S\Q]\bÒ[]a Q]\ S[^`S\RS`( OQ][SbS` g Q][S\hO` c\O ]PÒ c\ \SU]QW] c\ S[^S ] Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS aW S\QWS`Ò\ RWTWQcZbOR ] ^SZWU`] G bO[PW{\ Q]\ ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò( _cS S[^`S\RS Q]\ `Sa]ZcQW \ OQQW]\Sa RWTWQcZb]aOa ] OhO`]aOa /^`S\RWhOXS( OQQW \ g STSQb] RS O^`S\RS` OZU \ O`bS ]TWQW] c ]bÒ Q]aO 2@/:3 2S b]R] SZZ] ^]RS[]a RSRcQW` _cS S[^`S\RWhOXS bWS\S _cS dS` Q]\ SZ O^`S\RWhOXS RS ZO ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò #

" E30 7<<]DO<2WA C\WdSàWROR RS 23CAB= Vbb^( W\\]dO\RWa eSbÔW\b Q][ # ;Q 1ZSZZO\R 2 1 '&% µ1VO`SabS`WabWQa ]T AcQQSaaTcZ 3\b`S^`S\Scà¶ 8]c`\OZ ]T 1`SObWdS 03VOdW]S S\ 0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O !$# $ 0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O &# % 0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O !& & E30 7<<]DO<2WA C\WdSàWROR RS 23CAB= Vbb^( W\\]dO\RWa eSbÔW\b Q][ ' 0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O

7aWR`] RS >OPZ] 2W`SQb]` RSZ 17/23 ³C/; $ RSTW\S SZ S[^`S\RWhOXS a]QWOZ Q][] SZ Q][^`][Wa] ÔÒ Q`SO` \cSd]a []RSZ]a RS OQbWdWROR ÔÒ RSaO``]ZZO` ^`]RcQb]a g aS`dWQW]a _cS aObWaTOQS\ ZOa \SQSaWRORSa PtaWQOa RS Q]ZSQbWd]a RSaObS\RWR]a ^]` ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa g SQ]\ [WQOa Q]\dS\QW]\OZSa DOZ]`Sa Q][] W\WQWObWdO Q][^`][Wa] Ocb]\][ O `WSaU] WZcaW \ Q]\TWO\hO g RSbS`[W\OQW \ dOZ]`Sa ^`]^W]a RS ZO ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò a]\ dOZ]`Sa Tc\RO[S\bOZSa S\ ZO W\WQWObWdO a]QWOZ ASU \ /aV]YO % ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa a]QWOZSa ^]aSS\ R]a Ob`WPcb]a a]P`SaOZWS\bSa( c\O WRSO W\\]dOR]Ò _cS ^`]RchQO c\ QO[PW] a]QWOZ aWU\WTWQObWd] g c\O dWaW \ S[^`S\RSR]Ò O ZO V]Ò RS `SOZWhO` aca ^`]gSQb]a >]aSS\ ZO dWaW \ ZO Q`SObWdWROR g ZO RSbS`[W\OQW \ bÒRWQW]\OZ[S\bS Oa]QWORO O Z]a g ZOa S[^`S\RSR]Òa RS \SU]QW]a ^S`] ac []bWdOQW \ Sa ZO RS US\SÒ` c\ QO[PW] a]QWOZ ^`]Tc\R] g RcÒRS`] g \] SZ PS\STWQW] SQ]\ [WQ] 3\ W<<]DO<2WA & RSTW\S\ O ZO TWUcÒ RS S[^`S\RSR]` a]QWOZ Q][] O_cSZZO ^Sà]\O _cS aS W\a^WÒ S\ ]PbS\S` dOZ]` O bÒd{a RS c\O bÒ\aT]`[OQW \ _cS PS\STWQWO O Q][c\WRORSa S\ RSadS\bOXO g ^]` S\RS O ZO a]QWSROR) T`S\bS O ZO ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò µO aSQOa¶ _cS PcaQO Q`SO` dOZ]` O bÒd{a RS c\ \cSd] [S`QOR] ] ^`]RcQb] >]RS[]a Q]\QZcW` ^]` bO\b] _cS SZ S[^`S\RSR]` g S[^`S\RSR]Ò a]QWOZ Sa c\ bW^] RS S[^`S\RSR]` S\ bO\b] _cS ac ]PXSbWd] ^`W\QWÔZ Sa W[^cZaO` QO[PW]a a]QWOZSa <cSabÒ QcZbcÒ T][S\bO S\ SaQOaO [SRWRO SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` :O WRSO RS S[^`S\RS` g SZ ^S`TWZ RS S[^`S\RSR]Ò ] S[^`S\RSR]` Sabt\ [O`QOR]a ^]` [ ZbW^ZSa SabS`S]bW^]a ' _cS aS Q]\dWS`bS\ O [S\cR] S\ PO``SÒa S\ ZO bÒgSQb]`WO S\b`S SZ acS ] RS S[^`S\RS` g ZO `SOZWhOQW \ RS SabS acS ] >OÒ ZO [Og]` O RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa W\QZca] O\cZO\ QcOZ_cWS` ^]aWPWZWROR RS bS\S` SaS acS ] 3Z UÒR] RS []bWdOQW \ RS QOÔQWbOQW \ g ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa ^Sà]\OZSa a]\ Oa^SQb]a _cS O [S\cR] `STcS`hO\ RWQVOa PO``SÒa _cS aS [O\WTWSabO\ S\ RWabW\bO T]`[O S W\bS\aWROR aSU \ \cSabÒa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS U{\S`] SROR S\b]`\] a]QW]SQ]\ [WQ] US]U`tTWQ] ] QcZbcÒZ SbQ 5Ò\ Ô`bS RS Z] _cS aS \SQSaWbO ÔÒ S[^`S\RS` ^cSRS `ST]`hOàS ] OR_cW`WàS 3[^`S\RS` aWS[^`S Sa VOQS` Q]aOa \cSdOa `S\]dOàS S W\\]dO` 3[^`S\RS` c\ \SU]QW] bO[PW{\ Sa VOQS` OZU] \cSd] 3a Ob`SdSàS O ^S\aO`

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

RS c\O T]`[O RWabW\bO 3\ SZ [][S\b] OQbcOZ SabO[]a dWS\R] _cS ]bÒ T]`[O RS S[^`S\RS` Sa ^]aWPZS GO a]\ [cQVOa ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa _cS Z] Sabt\ RS[]abÒ\R] bÒa VOPS` bÒRcQWR] O ZO `SOZWROR S[^`SaO`WOZ c\O WRSO ] c\O T]`[O 3a [cg W[^]`bO\bS _cS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa aSO\ ^`]bOU]\WabOa gO _cS \] a]ZO[S\bS a]\ [cQV]a S\ QO\bWROR aW\] _cS a]\ Z]a _cS RSaSO\ `SOZWhO` c\O dS`RORSÒ Q]\b`WPcQW \ >]aSS\ QOaW \ObcÒZ[S\bS ZOa VS`Ò[WS\bOa RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa W\\]dOR]Òa ZOa _cS aS `S_cWS`S\ ÔÒ aS` dS`RORS`]a ^`]bOU]\WabOa RS c\ ^`]QSa] W\\]dOR]`( S[Ôb O bÒPOX] S\ S_cW^] g ZWRSÒhU] :O XcdS\bcR [ta _cS ]b`]a Q]ZSQbWd]a Sabt RSaS]aO RS Ô`bWQWÔ` B]R] QO[PW] Q][WS\hO Q]\ c\O dWaW \ g c\O RSQWaW \ RS S[^`S\RS` ZO OQQW \ 3\ '%& SZ SabOR]c\WRS\aS 6WZZ 2Ògb]\ OR[W\WabÒR]` ORXc\b] RS ZO /US\QWO RS >`]bSQQW \ RS ;SRW] /[PWS\bS RS 3abOR]a C\WR]a RSQWRW Tc\RO` c\O ]ÙO\WhOQW \ _cS O^]gOÒ O Z]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa RS b]R] SZ [c\R] Ac WRSO SÒ PcaQO` ^Sà]\Oa Q]\ WRSOa \cSdOa RS QO[PW] a]QWOZ _cS Q][PW\OÒ\ ZO QOÔQWROR S[^`S\RSR]Ò g c\ [O`QOR] QO`tQbS` {bWQ] 4c\R ZO ]ÙO\WhOQW \ /aV]YO( 7\\]dOR]`Sa RS Z] ^ PZWQ] _cS ]^SÒ S\ QcO`S\bO g aSWa Ô aSa RS /aWO ÈT`WQO /[{`WQO g 3c`]Ô 1S\bÒZ g VO OgcROR] O " ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Òa a]QWOZSa ^`]^]`QW]\t\R]ZSa QOaW " [WZZ]\Sa RS R ZO`Sa RS TW\O\QWOQW \ RW`SQbO O\OZWhO\R] aca SabÒbSUWOa ]T`SQW{\R]ZSa aS`dWQW]a ^`]TSaW]\OZSa g P`W\RO\R] Q`SRWPWZWROR O ac USabW \ µ>OÒ Z]UÒ` c\O bÒ\aT]`[OQW \ a]QWOZ ^]aWbWdO VOg _cS Q]\TWO` g O^]gO` O ZO XcdS\bcR SZZ]a RSaSO\ c\ QO[PW] ^`]Tc\R] g bWS\S\ WRSOa W\\]dOR]Òa¶ RWX] 6WZZ 2Ògb]\ ÔÒ _cWS\ Z]a g ZOa S[^`S\RSR]Òa a]QWOZSa a]\ ^Sà]\Oa W\a^WÒROa _cS ZZS\O\ SZ SaÔQW] _cS _cSRO dOQ ] S\b`S Z]a \SU]QW]a g ZO a]QWSROR ^`]^]\S\ \cSd]a SaQS\O`W]a g `SUZOa a]\ SXS[^Z]a RS bS\OQWROR g RS ^`]Tc\R]a dOZ]`Sa []ÒZSa 3ab] bWS\S _cS dS` Q]\ P`W\RO`ZSa O ZO XcdS\bcR ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS VOQS` ac Q]\b`WPcQW \ RS `SaÔZRO`Z]a g ^S`[WbW`ZSa Q`SO` ÔÒ _cS QcO\R] aS dcSZdO\ ^Sà]\Oa ORcZbOa ^cSRO\ aOPS` _cS bWS\S\ SZ ^]RS` BWS\S\ ZOa dWaW]\Sa W\\]dOR]Òa \SQSaO`WOa ÔÒ TOQWZWbO` SZ QO[PW] RS ÔÒRWU[O

0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O !!

/aV]YO bÒPOXO Q][] c\O S[^`SaO RS QO^WbOZ RS `WSaU] 0caQO OZb] `S\RW[WS\b] S\ W\dSàW]\Sa []RSabOa g PWS\ ]`WS\bOROa 3Z `S\RW[WS\b] PcaQOR] Sa S\ [SX]Òa S\ SRcQOQW \ ^`]bSQQW \ RSZ [SRW] O[PWS\bS SZ RSaO``]ZZ] `cÒZ ZO [WbWUOQW \ RS ZO ^]P`ShO Z]a RS`SQV]a Vc[O\]a ZO aO\WROR ZO ObS\QW \ O ZOa ^Sà]\Oa RWaQOÔQWbOROa ZO ObS\QW \ O \W ]a S\ aWbcOQW \ RS `WSaU] g ]b`]a QO[^]a 3a c\O `SR [c\RWOZ T]`[ORO ^]` ^Sà]\Oa _cS ^cSRO\ ^`]RcQW` QO[PW]a aWab{[WQ]a ^]aWbWd]a W[^]`bO\bSa _cS O ac dSh aS Q]\dS`bW`t\ S\ µ`STS`S\QWO S\ aca `Sa^SQbWd]a QO[^]a¶ µ_cS SabOPZSQS`t\ ] []RWTWQO`t\ ÔcbOa RS OQQW \¶ S\ SZ ^ZO\] \OQW]\OZ S W\bS`\OQW]\OZ /aV]YO VO ^`][]dWR] ZO WRSO RS _cS Z]a g ZOa S[^`S\RSR]Òa a]QWOZSa ³^Sà]\Oa Q`SObWdOa g bS\OQSa Q]\ c\O []bWdOQW \ W\_cSPÒ\bOPZS³ a]\ \SQSaO`W]a ÔÒ W[^cZaO` ZO W\\]dOQW \ _cS `S_cWS`S ZO a]QWSROR ÔÒ bÒbO` RS `Sa]ZdS` aca [OZSa [ta UÒdSa¶

0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O

ASU \ 0]`\abSW\ c\ QO[PW] a]QWOZ W[^]`bO\bS Q][WS\hO Q]\ T`SQcS\QWO Q]\ c\ \WQ] Ocb]` S[^`S\RSR]`( c\ W\RWdWRc] ]PaSaWd] _cS RSbSQbO c\ ^`]PZS[O S W[OUW\O c\O \cSdO a]ZcQW \ _cS b][O ZO W\WQWObWdO ÔÒ OQbcO` RS OQcS`R] Q]\ SaO WRSO _cS `S \S `SQcà]a g Q]\ab`cgS ]ÙO\WhOQW]\Sa ÔÒ ^`]bSUS` g Q][S`QWOZWhO` ZO WRSO _cS ac`bS RS S\SÙ O g RO c\ S\T]_cS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

a]abS\WR] ÔÒ ac^SÒ` ZOa W\ac^SÒPZSa `SaWabS\QWOa g _cS R{QORO bÒa R{QORO Q]\bW\ O [SX]Ò\R] T]`bOZSQWS\R] g S\U`]aO\R] SaO WRSO VOabO _cS Z] _cS S\ ]b`] [][S\b] SÒ c\O WRSO [OÙW\OZ aS VO Q]\dS`bWR] S\ c\O \]`[O \cSdO 0]`\abSW\ # `STWS`S _cS 2OdWR 1 ;Q1ZSZZO\R âWQ Z]U] S\ ac ZWP`] :O a]QWSROR O[PWQW]aO O\OZWhO Z]a Oa^SQb]a RS ZO []bWdOQW \ RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa 2STW\ O b`Sa []bWdOQW]\Sa Vc[O\Oa R][W\O\bSa( \SQSaWROR RS ^]RS` \SQSaWROR RS OTWZWOQW \ g \SQSaWROR RS Z]U`] :O _cS [ta ZS W\bS`SaOPO SÒ ZO \SQSaWROR RS Z]U`] _cS {Z Q]\aWRSÒPO _cS SabOPO `SZOQW]\ORO Q]\ ZO QOÔQWROR S[^`S\RSR]Ò >ZO\bSO _cS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa Q]\ \SQSaWRORSa RS Z]U`] OZbOa bS\R O\ O RSXOàS W\TZcW` [S\]a _cS Z]a RS[ta ^]` ZOa acUS`S\QWOa RS ]b`]a `Sa^SQb] O _c{ VOQS` ^S\aO` ] Q`SS` 3abOPO\ µ]`WS\bOR]a ORSZO\bS S\ SZ bWS[^] VOQWO ]PXSbWd]a RS OZQO\QS [ta ZOÙ] Oc\ QcO\R] Sa] aWU\WTWQOÒ `S\c\QWO` O ^ZOQS`Sa W\[SRWOb]a 3Ò\ [S\]a Q]\T]`[WabOa g ZSa W[^]`bOPO [S\]a SZ `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] ^ PZWQ] :] _cS ZSa W\TZc O O ZO V]Ò RS OP]`RO` ^`]PZS[Oa SÒ\ Z]a VSQV]a >`STS` O\ SZ Q]\aSX] RS Z]a Sf^S`b]a O Z]a O[WU]a /c\_cS ]b`]a Q]\aWRSÒPO\ _cS Oac[ O\ `WSaU]a ;Q1ZSZZO\R aS OZOPO _cS \] aS dS O\ O a [Wa[]a RS SaS []R] 6OPWbcOZ[S\bS OQS^bOPO\ RSaOT ]a a]Z] QcO\R] dS O\ _cS VOP O OZUc\O ]^]`bc\WROR RS {fWb] OQS^bOPZS g QcO\R] SZ RSbS`[W\O\bS ^`W\QWÔZ RS ac {fWb] SÒ ac RSab`ShO 3abOPO\ []bWdOR]a [ta ^]` SZ Sa^ `Wbc RS Z]U`] [ta _cS ^]` SZ RS RW\S`] >OÒ SZ S[^`S\RSR]` ] S[^`S\RSR]Ò ZO dS`RORSÒ aObWaTOQQW \ ^`]QSR O RS VOQS` _cS SZ [c\R] aS Q]\T]`[OÒ RS c\ []R] RWabW\b] :O RWTS`S\QWO S\ SZ bÒbO[WS\b] RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa RS \SU]QW]a g S[^`S\RSR]Òa a]QWOZSa Ô`SQS `STZSXO` OQbWbcRSa RWTS`S\bSa a]P`S SZ Ô^SZ RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S\ SZ t`SO Q][S`QWOZ g a]QWOZ 3\ SZ aSQb]` S[^`SaO`WOZ VOQS [cQV] _cS aS `SQ]\]QS O ZOa ^Sà]\Oa Q][] []b]`Sa RS QO[PW]

;Q 1ZSZZO\R 2 1 '&% µ1VO`SabS`WabWQa ]T AcQQSaaTcZ 3\b`S^`S\Sc`a¶ 8]c`\OZ ]T 1`SObWdS 03VOdW]S S\ 0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O !$# ! 0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O !&

ASU \ 0]`\abSW\ ZOa bS]` Oa RS QO[PW] a]QWOZ aS VO\ QS\bÒR] [ta S\ Q][] ZOa WRSOa []dWZWhO\ ^Sà]\Oa _cS S\ Q [] ZOa ^Sà]\Oa []dWZWhO\ WRSOa :O a]QW]Z]U O WRS\bWTWQO [cQVOa TcS`hOa S\ SZ QO[PW] a]QWOZ ³ RS[]UÒT O bSQ\]Z]U O SQ]\][ O []dW[WS\b]a a]QWOZSa ^`]QSa]a ^]Z bWQ]a³ ^S`] RSRWQO\ ^]Q] bWS[^] O O\OZWhO` SZ RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa AW ZOa WRSOa RSPS\ SQVO` Ò QSa g SfbS\RSàS \SQSaWbO\ ^]` bO\b] Z RS`Sa) US\bS ]PaSaWdO _cS bS\UO ZO RSab`ShO []bWdOQW \ S\SÙ O g ]PabW\OQW \ ÔÒ VOQS` b]R] Z] _cS aSO \SQSaO`W] ÔÒ ZZSdO`ZOa ORSZO\bS( ^SàcORW` W\a^WÒ` aSRcQW` S\UObcaO` WZc[W\O` ZZSUO` O Z]a Q]Òh]\Sa OZWdWO` bS[]`Sa bÒ\aT]`[O` ^S`QS^QW]\Sa O`bWQcZO` aWU\WTWQOR]a g [O\W^cZO`Z]a W\US\W]aO[S\bS O bÒd{a RS RWTS`S\bSa aWabS[Oa ! :]a SZS[S\b]a aWU\WTWQObWd]a " RS QOÒ O Sf^ZWQO` SZ VSQV] RS aS` c\O ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò a]\( ZO Q]\QS^QW \ ÔaW \ RSbS`[W\OQW \ g {bWQO RS ZO ^Sà]\O >OÒ SdOZcO` Sab]a Oa^SQb]a 2Ògb]\ RS /aV]YO RWaS ] c\ aWabS[O _cS aS RSaQ][^]\ O S\ QcOb`] QObSU]` Oa( Q`SObWdWROR QOZWROR S[^`S\RSR]Ò ! W[ÔQb] a]QWOZ RS ZO WRSO g " TWPÒ {bWQO

" 0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O % &

3Z ^`W[S` Q`WbS`W] Sa ZO Q`SObWdWROR _cS bWS\S R]a SZS[S\b]a( ZO Q`SObWdWROR ÔÒ SabOPZSQS` ]PXSbWd]a ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO dWaW]\O`WO a]P`S SZ V]`Wh]\bS RS c\ []RSZ] RWabW\b] ÔÒ SZ QO[^] RS OQQW \ g ZO Q`SObWdWROR S\ ZO `Sa]ZcQW \ RS ^`]PZS[Oa gO _cS ÔÒ ZZSUO` O SabS \cSd] ZcUO` VOg QWS\b]a RS ]PabtQcZ]a g [WZSa RS OXcabSa _cS SabOa ^Sà]\Oa bWS\S\ _cS VOQS` g ÔÒ Z] _cS bWS\S\ _cS aS` Q`SObWd]a

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

:O QOZWROR S[^`S\RSR]Ò Sa ZO [ta RWT QWZ RS Q][^`S\RS` :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa bWS\S\ S\ ac [S\bS ZO W[OUS\ RS Z] RWTS`S\bS _cS aS`t ZO a]QWSROR QcO\R] ZO WRSO Tc\QW]\S g \] ^cSRS\ RSbS\SàS VOabO _cS ZO WRSO \] a Z] Tc\QW]\O S\ c\ ZcUO` aW\] _cS Tc\QW]\O S\ b]RO ZO a]QWSROR 3Z W[ÔQb] a]QWOZ RS ZO WRSO \] aS QS\bÒ S\ ZO ^Sà]\O aS QS\bÒ S\ ZO WRSO _cS `Sa^]\RS O ZOa ^`SUc\bOa RS aW c\O WRSO Sa acTWQWS\bS[S\bS PcS\O S\ a [Wa[O ÔÒ SfbS\RSàS c\O dSh _cS aS VO RS[]abÒR] ZO STWQOQWO g QcO\bO US\bS aS dS`t OTSQbORO g Q]\ QcO\bO `SZSdO\QWO :O TWPÒ {bWQO aS `STWS`S O ZO Q]\TWO\hO _cS US\SÒ ZO ^Sà]\O :O V]\ÒRSh RSZ S[^`S\RSR]` a]QWOZ ac W\bSU`WROR Sa c\] RS Z]a OQbWd]a [ta W[^]`bO\bSa @Sa^SQb] OZ µQWQZ] RS dWRO¶ RSZ S[^`S\RSR]` 2Ògb]\ Z] RWdWRW S\ QcOb`] SbOÔa( /^`S\RWhOXS c\ ZOÙ] ^S`W]R] S\ SZ _cS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa OR_cWS`S\ ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO ZOa VOPWZWRORSa g ZOa Q`SRS\QWOZSa _cS \SQSaWbO\ Ô` ^`]RcQW` c\ QO[PW] W[^]`bO\bS :O\hO[WS\b] SZ Q][WS\h] RS ZO SbOÔ RcÒ\bS ZO _cS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa S[^WShO\ O ^]\S` O ^`cSPO g dOZWRO` aca WRSOa ! 2Sa^SUcS c\O SbOÔ O[^ZWO S\ ZO _cS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa Q]\a]ZWRO\ ]ÙO\WhOQW]\Sa g ^`]aWUcS\ ^cZWS\R] g SfbS\RWS\R] aca WRSOa VOabO _cS {abOa aS OR]^bO\ O[^ZWO[S\bS " ;ORc`Sh SZ [][S\b] S\ SZ QcOZ ZOa WRSOa RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa VO\ bS\WR] c\ W[ÔQb] RS[]abÒPZS S\ ac QO[^] 0]`\abSW\ # RSa^c{a RS c\ SfbS\a] `SQ]``WR] `SZObO\R] RWTS`S\bSa Sf^S`WS\QWOa RS S[^`S\RSR]`Sa g S[^`S\RSR]Òa a]QWOZSa RS b]R] SZ [c\R] ^ZO\bSO c\O aS`WS RS QcOZWRORSa RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa a]QWOZSa Q]\ {fWb]

# 0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O ! " !!"

µ>]` `SUZO US\SÒZ aS OR[WbS _cS Z]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa Q]\ [cQV] {fWb] a]\ ^Sà]\Oa [ta aSUcÒa g ^SàWabS\bSa _cS ZO [Og]` O RS Z]a RS[ta W\QZcgS\R] Z]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa Q]\ [S\]a {fWb] 3ab] ^cSRS \] aS` QWS`b] :Oa RWTS`S\QWOa W[^]`bO\bSa bS\ O\ _cS dS` Q]\ ZO []bWdOQW \ :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa Q]\ [ta {fWb] SÒ\ Z]a [ta RSQWRWR]a O OZQO\hO` c\ ]PXSbWd] O ZOÙ] ^ZOh] _cS bcdWSÒ c\ aWU\WTWQOR] ^`]Tc\R] ÔÒ SZZ]a 1]\aSQcS\bS[S\bS a]Z O\ aS` [ta aWabS[tbWQ]a S\ SZ []R] S\ _cS PcaQOPO\ ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa aS ORSZO\bOPO\ O ]PabtQcZ]a Q]\b`]ZOPO\ Z]a `SacZbOR]a ] ^ZO\WTWQOPO\ Q]\ O\bSZOQW \ 3abOPO\ [ta ^`S]QcÔR]a ^]` ZO QOZWROR g ZO STWQWS\QWO g [ta Q][^`][SbWR]a Q]\ ZOa ^Sà]\Oa O ZOa _cS VOP O\ S[^ZSOR] ] W\d]ZcQÒR] S\ SZ ^`]gSQb] ] Q][] a]QW]a

$ 4S`Ò\ HcPWZZOUO / % 3Z S[^`S\RWhOXS a]QWOZ \cSd]a `Sb]a \cSdOa `Sa^cSabOa >`]^cSabO ÔÒ W\Q]`^]Ò` SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` S\ ZO T]`[OQW \ RS Z]a Oa bÒPOXOR]`Sa Oa a]QWOZSa S\ O `ST]`[O RS ZO T]`[OQW \ g ZO bWbcZOQW \ S\ SZ [O`Q] RSZ 333A

3Z S[^`S\RWhOXS Sa c\ ^`]QSa] _cS Q]\b`WPcgS O Q]\ab`cW` ZO Ocb]\][ O RS _cWS\ Z] OQ][SbS 3TSQbWdO[S\bS _cWS\ S[^`S\RS( aS aWb O S\ c\O ^]aWQW \ RS ^`]bOU]\WabO RS ac ^`]^WO dWRO g S\ SZ QS\b`] RSZ VSQV] RS bÒPOXO` ÔÒ a ( ]^bO ^]` ObS\RS` ^Sà]\OZ[S\bS O aca \SQSaWRORSa SQ]\ [WQOa RS S[^ZS] RS RSaO``]ZZ] ^`]TSaW]\OZ) SabW[cZO ac QOÔQWROR RS W\WQWObWdO RS b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa RS RW`SQQW \ g ZWRSÒhU]) SabW[cZO ac QOÔQWROR

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

=b`]a Q]\QS^b]a _cS Sabt\ `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ ZO WRSO RS S[^`S\RS` a]\ Z]a RS S[^`S\RWhOXS S[^]RS`O[WS\b] Ocb]\][ O g []bWdOQW \ $

Q`SOR]Ò g ]ÙO\WhObWdO) Q`SO Q]\RWQW]\Sa ÔÒ US\SÒ` aca ^`]^W]a `SQcà]a) RWdSàWTWQO g O[^Z O ac OR_cWaWQW \ RS Sf^S`WS\QWO ^`tQbWQO g acPXSbWdO) Q`SO Q]\RWQW]\Sa ÔÒ OR_cW`W` ^]RS`Sa dWbOZSa W\RWdWRcOZSa( Ocb]SabW[O Ocb]Q]\TWO\hO aSUc`WROR RSQWaW \ dOZS\b O TW`[ShO T]`bOZShO ^]aWbWdWROR OaS`bWdWROR Q]\]QW[WS\b]a QOÔQWRORSa g VOPWZWRORSa ]b`]a O^`S\RWhOXSa) ^cSRS ^ZO\bSO` ac ^`]gSQb] S[^`S\RSR]` Q][] Sf^`SaW \ RS ]bÒ T]`[O RS ^S\aO` g RS Q`SO` `W_cShO S\ ZO a]QWSROR g bO[PW{\ Q][] SabÒbSUWO RS QO[PW] a]QWOZ 3Z S[^]RSÒ[WS\b] ^`]QSa] ^]` SZ QcOZ ZOa ^Sà]\Oa \]a ZWPÒ[]a RS RWabW\b]a bW^]a RS ]^`SaW \ O bÒd{a RS ZO OR_cWaWQW \ RS ^]RS`Sa dWbOZSa W\bS`W]`WhO\R] \cSabÒ Sf^S`WS\QWO g \cSab`]a O^`S\RWhOXSa Sa c\O ^]RS`]aO VS`Ò[WS\bO ÔÒ SZ S[^`S\RWhOXS 7\dSàO[S\bS S[^`S\RS` ^cSRS aS` c\O d O ÔÒ SZ S[^]RSÒ[WS\b] S\ ZO [SRWRO S\ _cS \]a aWb O O\bS ^`]QSa]a RS OR_cWaWQW \ RS ^]RS`Sa dWbOZSa >]` Q]\aWUcWS\bS S[^`S\RS` Q]\b`WPcgS bO[PW{\ O ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ W\RWdWRcOZ U`cÔZ g a]QWOZ RSZ ^]RS` ] :O Ocb]\][ O Sa c\ SabOR] RS ZO ^Sà]\O RS Z]a U`c^]a RS ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa RS Z]a []dW[WS\b]a _cS RSbS`[W\O ZO QOÔQWROR RS {ab]a RS RSaO``]ZZO` ^`]QSa]a ÔÒ RSXO` RS aS` ]PXSb] RSZ R][W\W] RS ]bÒ ^Sà]\O ]b`] U`c^] ]bÒ W\abWbcQW \ SbQ g aS` acXSb]a QORO QcOZ RS ac ^`]^WO dWRO Oa Q][] acXSb]a a]QWOZSa ^]Z bWQ]a SQ]\ [WQ]a QcZbcÒZSa g Xc` RWQ]a 3a c\ SabOR] S\ ^`]QSa] RS QO[PW] ^S`[O\S\bS O [SRWRO _cS Sd]ZcQW]\O\ ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RS acP]`RW\OQW \ RS^S\RS\QWO dWbOZ g RWaQ`W[W\OQW \ :O Ocb]\][ O Sa O ZO dSh c\ ^`]QSa] acPXSbWd] RS ZO ^Sà]\O g c\ ÔQb] a]QWOZ _cS \]a ^S`[WbS O ZOa ^Sà]\Oa dWdW` Q][] acXSb]a ^ZS\]a aWS\R] ^`]bOU]\WabOa Q]\ `SQcà]a Q]\ RWaQcà] Q]\ Q]\QS^QW]\Sa W\bS`^`SbOQW]\Sa OÙc[S\b]a g XcWQW]a ^`]^W]a) Oac[W{\R]aS Q][] ^Sà]\Oa Ocb \][]a g aW{\R]Z]) OQbcO\R] g SZWUWS\R] Qct\R] Q [] g Qct\b] bWS[^] OQbcO`) SZWUWS\R] O _c{ RSabW\O` ZOa OQbWdWRORSa dWbOZSa /\bS ZO TOZbO RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa `SOZSa g ] aObWaTOQb]`WOa S[^`S\RS` aS ^S`TWZO QORO dSh [ta Q][] c\O OZbS`\ObWdO ^`]TSaW]\OZ aS`WO ÔÒ [cQVOa ^Sà]\Oa 1][] aS VO ^cSab] RS [O\WTWSab] S\ SZ SabcRW] µ¥?c{ Sa ÔÒ bW S[^`S\RS`-¶ % `SOZWhOR] S\ SZ [O`Q] RSZ ^`]gSQb] 3?C/: 3[^Z{ObS SZ S[^`S\RWhOXS Sa S\bS\RWR] Q][] µc\O T]`[O RWabW\bO RS ^S\aO`¶ AS ^ZO\bSO\ #f ;]bWd]a ÔÒ S[^`S\RS` `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ SabS Q]\QS^b]( ³ ³ ³ ³ ³

3[^`S\RS` ÔÒ RSaO^`S\RS` g O^`S\RS` 3[^`S\RS` ÔÒ Q`SQS` g RSaO``]ZZOàS 3[^`S\RS` ÔÒ Q]\ab`cW` Ocb]\][ O g ^]RS` ] 3[^`S\RS` ÔÒ Q][^`][SbSàS g Oac[W` `Sa^]\aOPWZWRORSa 3[^`S\RS` ÔÒ Q][Ô`bW` g `SÔ`bW`

2SaO^`S\RS` Q]\aWabS S\ RSaO``]ZZO` c\O dWaW \ Q` bWQO _cS ^S`[WbO WRS\bWTWQO` O\OZWhO` g QcSabW]\O` SaOa WRSOa g ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a OR_cW`WR]a ³_cS bOZ dSh aSO\ S`` \S]a Sab{\ aSaUOR]a ] RS\ c\O dWaW \ W\Q][^ZSbO RS ZO `SOZWROR ] _cS aS\QWZZO[S\bS \] ^S`[WbO\ OZQO\hO` O_cSZZ] Q]\ Z] _cS aS acS O³ Q]\ SZ TW\ RS ^]RS` Q]\ab`cW` c\O dWaW \ \cSdO RS ZOa Q]aOa 3\ SaS ^`]QSa] Sa Tc\RO[S\bOZ ZO RWa^]aWQW \ O OQ][SbS` SaO aSUc\RO TOaS Q]\ab`cQbWdO RS \cSd]a O^`S\RWhOXSa % ?c{ Sa ÔÒ bW S[^`S\RS`-¶( 5]PWS`\] RS <OdO`Ò eee S[^ZSObS\OdO`Ò Q][

AS ^cSRS ^ZO\bSO` SZ RSaO^`S\RS` O ZO dSh Q][] c\O Q]\RWQW \ ÔÒ SZ S[^`S\RWhOXS S\ SZ aS\bWR] RS _cS aS \SQSaWbO\ SZW[W\O` OZUc\Oa RS ZOa ^`]^WOa PO``SÒa [S\bOZSa g Q][] c\O ]^]`bc\WROR G Sa _cS ^S\aO` S\

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

S[^`S\RS` ]T`SQS c\O SfQSZS\bS ]QOaW \ ÔÒ ^`]^]\S`\]a SabO `SdWaW \ Q` bWQO RS \cSabÒ dWaW \ RSZ [c\R] g RS ZO ^]aWQW \ g aWbcOQW \ S\ {Z :]a O^`S\RWhOXSa _cS VOQS[]a RSaRS SZ [][S\b] S\ _cS W\WQWO[]a SZ ^`]QSa] RS S[^`S\RS` W\QZcWR]a Z]a S``]`Sa Q]\b`WPcgS\ OZ Q`SQW[WS\b] g RSaO``]ZZ] Q][] ^Sà]\Oa bO\b] S\ Z] W\RWdWRcOZ Q][] S\ Z] ^`]TSaW]\OZ g S\ Z] a]QWOZ 1ORO ^Sà]\O bWS\S S\ c\ [][S\b] ROR] c\O RSbS`[W\ORO QOÔQWbOQW \ Q]\ `Sa^SQb] OZ S[^`S\RW[WS\b] _cS ^]R`t `ST]`hO` g Q][^ZSbO` S\ ac S[^`S\RWhOXS :Oa Q][^SbS\QWOa RS S[^`S\RSR]`Sa Sabt\ `SZOQW]\OROa ^]` Z] bO\b] Q]\ RWTS`S\bSa QOÔQWRORSa QcOZWRORSa g VOPWZWRORSa( 1][^SbS\QWOa g QOÔQWRORSa ^Sà]\OZSa ³ ³ ³ ³ ³ ³ ³

/cb]SabW[O /cb]\][ O 3[^]RSÒ[WS\b] 7\bSZWUS\QWO S[]QW]\OZ g VOPWZWRORSa a]QWOZSa 6OPWZWRORSa RS Q][c\WQOQW \ 1OÔQWROR RS O^`S\RWhOXS 1OÔQWROR RS bÒPOX]

1][^SbS\QWOa S[^`S\RSR]Òa ³ 2SaO``]ZZ] RSZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` W\WQWObWdO Qc`W]aWROR O^S`bcÒ [S\bOZ QOÔQWROR RS Oac[W` `WSaU]a Q`SObWdWROR¬ ³ 2SaO``]ZZ] RS ZO OQbWbcR S[^`S\RSR]Ò `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR WRS\bWTWQOQW \ g a]ZcQW \ RS ^`]PZS[Oa bS\OQWROR `SaWabS\QWO O ZO T`cabÒQW \ ³ 2SaO``]ZZ] RS ZOa VOPWZWRORSa ÔÒ ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa ZWRSÒhU] bÒPOX] S\ S_cW^] \SU]QWOQW \ 1][^SbS\QWOa S[^`SaO`WOZSa ³ 1]\]QW[WS\b]a bS `WQ]a ] b{Q\WQ]a `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ SZ aSQb]` ]TWQW] c ]QcÔQW \ ZOP]ÒZ ³ 3f^S`WS\QWO ZOP]ÒZ ³ ;O\SX] RS B71 1][^SbS\QWOa ] QOÔQWRORSa b{Q\WQOa ³ ³ ³ ³

1cZbcÒ S[^`SaO`WOZ 3f^S`WS\QWO S\ USabW \ RS ^`]gSQb]a 4W\O\hOa USabW \ OR[W\WabÒbWdO g Q]\bOPZS ;O\SX] RS B71 ÔÒ ZO USabW \ S[^`SaO`WOZ

:O []bWdOQW \ ^cSRS S\bS\RSàS Q][] c\ ^`]QSa] âWQ]Z UWQ] _cS bWS\S `SZOQW \ Q]\ ZO T]`[O S\ _cS ZO Q]\RcQbO aS W\WQWO Sa OQbWdORO [O\bS\WRO RW`WUWRO S W\bS``c[^WRO :O TcS`hO []bWdOQW]\OZ RS c\O ^Sà]\O ]`WS\bORO O S[^`S\RS` Sabt RSbS`[W\ORO ^]` aca \SQSaWRORSa g RSaS]a W\aObWaTSQV]a SZ dOZ]` _cS ZSa ]b]ÙO g ZOa RWTWQcZbORSa g PO``SÒa _cS ^S`QWPS ÔÒ S[^`S\RS` 3fWabS\ RWTS`S\bSa bW^]a RS []bWdOQW]\Sa( ³ ;]bWdOQW]\Sa RS Z]U`] g Ocb]``SOZWhOQW \ /cb]\][ O aObWaTOQQW \ ^Sà]\OZ Ocb]SabW[O S[^]RSÒ[WS\b] 2SaO``]ZZ] ^Sà]\OZ Q`SQW[WS\b] OR_cWaWQW \ RS Sf^S`WS\QWOa g RS Q]\]QW[WS\b]a

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

A]ZWRO`WROR Q]\ ZO TO[WZWO g U`c^] RS ^S`bS\S\QWO ³ ;]bWdOQW]\Sa W\ab`c[S\bOZSa ZOP]ÒZSa g SQ]\ [WQOa 5S\SÒQW \ RS c\ ^cSab] RS bÒPOX] ^]aWPWZWROR ZOP]ÒZ ;SX]Ò RS W\U`Sa]a SQ]\ [WQ]a [ta UO\O\QWOa ³ ;]bWdOQW]\Sa ZWUOROa OZ S\b]`\] /\bSQSRS\bSa TO[WZWO`Sa S[^`S\RSR]`Sa 7\QS\bWd]a acPdS\QW]\Sa RS ^]Z bWQOa ^ PZWQOa >O`bS RS ZO RSQWaW \ RS ^]\S` S\ [O`QVO c\O W\WQWObWdO S[^`S\RSR]Ò RS^S\RS RS ZO []bWdOQW \ _cS bS\UO\ ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ÔÒ VOQS` T`S\bS O SaS `WSaU] _cS Sa ORS[ta c\O WZcaW \ c\ ^`]gSQb] RS Tcbc`] g c\O T]`[O RS RSaO``]ZZ] ^`]TSaW]\OZ g ^Sà]\OZ 3\ 3aÔ O OZ WUcOZ _cS S\ [cQV]a ]b`]a Ô aSa aS VO dS\WR] Q][^`]PO\R] _cS SabS bW^] RS dWRO \] Sa SZ _cS SaQ]US` O ZO [Og]` O RS Z]a _cS Sabt\ S\ SROR RS VOQS`Z] RSQO\bt\R]aS [ta aca Sf^SQbObWdOa ^`]TSaW]\OZSa O bÒPOXO` ^]` QcS\bO OXS\O gO aSO S\ SZ t[PWb] ^`WdOR] ] S\ SZ ^ PZWQ] AW\ S[POÙ] O [SRWRO _cS Oc[S\bO ZO Sa^SÒ\hO RS dWRO g aS QcP`S\ Sa]a ^cSab]a ^`]TSaW]\OZSa g aS OZOÙO ZO SabO\QWO [SRWO S\ SZZ]a aS Q]\abObO ZO \SQSaWROR RSZ T][S\b] RS ZO OQbWdWROR S[^`S\RSR]Ò ^cSa ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa a]\ ZOa _cS ^cSRS\ US\SÒ` c\O PcS\O Ô`bS RSZ S[^ZS] _cS aS dO O \SQSaWbO` O [SRW] ^ZOh] >]` Q]\aWUcWS\bS bÒPOXO` S\ ZO [SX]Ò RS ZO []bWdOQW \ ÔÒ S[^`S\RS` Sa c\] RS Z]a `Sb]a _cS Sabt\ OT`]\bO\R] ZO [Og]` O RS Z]a Ô aSa RSaO``]ZZOR]a g [SX]Ò` ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS Z]a _cS S[^`S\RS\ S\ Ô aSa S\ d Oa RS RSaO``]ZZ] Sa bO[PW{\ c\ `Sb] OZ _cS aS S\T`S\bO\ Z]a U]PWS`\]a RS Sa]a Ô aSa S\ _cS Z] W[^]`bO\bS Sa OTWO\hO` g RSaO``]ZZO` c\ bSXWR] S[^`SaO`WOZ _cS bWS\S [cQVO Q][^]\S\bS RS acPaWabS\QWO :O []bWdOQW \ ÔÒ S[^`S\RS` Sa c\ OÔ`bOR] Q][^ZSX] _cS RS^S\RS RS [cg RWdSà]a TOQb]`Sa S\b`S Z]a _cS RSabOQO\( ³ :O ^`]^WO ^Sà]\OZWROR g Z]a dOZ]`Sa _cS aS ZS ac^]\S\ O ZO ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò( d]QOQW \ W[OUW\OQW \ QOÔQWROR RS Q`SO` S W\\]dO` QOÔQWROR RS aOQ`WTWQW] R]bSa ÔÒ ZO ]ÙO\WhOQW \ g ZWRSÒhU] RW\O[Wa[] QOÔQWROR RS Q][c\WQOQW \ g ]bÒa ³ :O SRcQOQW \ g ^`SÔÒQW \ `SQWPWROa _cS VOgO\ T][S\bOR] SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` g _cS VOgO\ ^`]^]`QW]\OR] ZOa VS`Ò[WS\bOa \SQSaO`WOa ÔÒ OQ][SbS` c\ ^`]gSQb] S[^`SaO`WOZ Q]\ UOÒ\b Oa RS {fWb] g Q`SQW[WS\b] ³ :O SfWabS\QWO RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa g ZO QOÔQWROR ÔÒ ^S`QWPW`ZOa S\ SZ S\b]`\] ³ 3Z O^]g] a]QWOZ g [SRWtbWQ] O ZO TWUcÒ RS ZO ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò _cS aSO QOÔh RS `SQ]\]QS` `Sa^SbO` g T][S\bO` ac ^`]ZWTSÒQW \ ³ :O SfWabS\QWO RS [SRWROa g ^`]UÒ[Oa UcPS`\O[S\bOZSa _cS ZS ^S`[WbO\ bS\S` ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS RSaO``]ZZO` Z]a ^`]gSQb]a dWOPZSa g US\SÒR]`Sa RS S[^ZS] g `W_cShO ³ :O SRcQOQW \ g ^`SÔÒQW \ `SQWPWROa _cS VOgO\ T][S\bOR] SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` g _cS VOgO\ ^`]^]`QW]\OR] ZOa VS`Ò[WS\bOa \SQSaO`WOa ÔÒ OQ][SbS` c\ ^`]gSQb] S[^`SaO`WOZ Q]\ UOÒ\b Oa RS {fWb] g Q`SQW[WS\b]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

³ :O SfWabS\QWO RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa g ZO QOÔQWROR ÔÒ ^S`QWPW`ZOa S\ SZ S\b]`\] ³ 3Z O^]g] a]QWOZ g [SRWtbWQ] O ZO TWUcÒ RS ZO ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò _cS aSO QOÔh RS `SQ]\]QS` `Sa^SbO` g T][S\bO` ac ^`]ZWTSÒQW \ ³ :O SfWabS\QWO RS [SRWROa g ^`]UÒ[Oa UcPS`\O[S\bOZSa _cS ZS ^S`[WbO\ bS\S` ZO ^]aWPWZWROR RS RSaO``]ZZO` Z]a ^`]gSQb]a dWOPZSa g US\SÒR]`Sa RS S[^ZS] g `W_cShO

! :O P a_cSRO RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa :O P a_cSRO RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa S\ `SZOQW \ Q]\ ZO WRSO RS S[^`S\RS` g ZO TWUcÒ RS S[^`S\RSR]` a]QWOZ Sabt RW`SQbO[S\bS `SZOQW]\ORO Q]\ ZOa OQbWbcRSa O\bSa ^ZO\bSOROa _cS ac^]\S\ c\O P a_cSRO OQbWdO W[OUW\ObWdO g Q]\ c\O PcS\O USabW \ RS Z]a `WSaU]a _cS S\ b]R] SZ ^`]QSa] OÔ`SQS`t\ 3abt P a_cSRO RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa ZZSdO Q]\aWU] c\ ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] QS\bÒR] S\ ZO OQQW \ g c\Oa OQbWbcRSa _cS ^cSRS\ aS` O^]gOROa RSaO``]ZZOROa RSaRS ZO SRcQOQW \ O\bSa RS Z]a [][S\b]a RS OQQSa] OZ S[^ZS] 2WTS`S\bSa U]PWS`\]a g S\bWRORSa RWdSàOa Sabt\ ^ZO\bSO\R] ^`]UÒ[Oa g OQQW]\Sa ÔÒ T][S\bO` SaS Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` ^`]^]`QW]\O` O^]g]a T]`[OQW \ g VS`Ò[WS\bOa ÔÒ _cS ^cSRO Q]\Q`SbOàS S\ ^`]gSQb]a Q]\Q`Sb]a bO\b] O \WdSZ a]QWOZ Q][] S[^`SaO`WOZ / Q]\bW\cOQW \ ^ZO\bSO`S[]a OZUc\]a SXS[^Z]a S\ SabS aS\bWR] _cS \]a ^S`[WbS\ ]PaS`dO` O_cSZZ]a Oa^SQb]a QZOdSa _cS VS[]a RS bS\S` S\ QcS\bO S\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS P a_cSRO RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa AS ^`]RcQS S\ Z]a ZbW[]a bWS[^]a SZ Oc[S\b] RS SabS bW^] RS `SQcà]a g ^`]UÒ[Oa S\ ZOa RWTS`S\bSa 1][c\WRORSa /cb \][Oa 3Z 5]PWS`\] RS <OdO`Ò Xc\b] Q]\ $ S\bWRORSa RSZ bS``Wb]`W] T]ÒZ ^ca] S\ [O`QVO S\ SZ O ] # SZ ^`]gSQb] 3[^Z{ObS W\WQWObWdO _cS ^SàWUcS T][S\bO` SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` g ZO Q`SOQW \ RS S[^`SaOa S\ O_cSZZOa ^Sà]\Oa _cS S\QcS\bÒ\ [ta RWTWQcZbORSa ÔÒ Q]\abWbcW` g ^]\S` S\ [O`QVO aca WRSOa S[^`SaO`WOZSa X dS\Sa [S\]`Sa RS b`SW\bO O ]a [cXS`Sa W\[WUÒ\bSa ^Sà]\Oa UWbO\Oa g ^Sà]\Oa Q]\ RWaQOÔQWROR ] RWdSàWROR T aWQO Tc\QW]\OZ ^`]^]`QW]\t\R]ZSa ZO OgcRO \SQSaO`WO ÔÒ VOQS`ZOa `SOZWROR C\] RS Z]a Oa^SQb]a Tc\RO[S\bOZSa S\ SZ ^`]QSa] RS S[^`S\RS` Sa bS\S` []bWdOQW \ ÔÒ _cS`S` RO` SaS Ôa] >OÒ SZZ] Sa W[^]`bO\bS bS\S` S\ QcS\bO _cS \] b]ROa ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RS\ RS ZO [Wa[O [O\SÒ \W ^]` Z]a [Wa[]a []bWd]a \W RSaRS ZO [Wa[O aWbcOQW \ RS Ô`bWRO BO[PW{\ Sa ^`SQWa] _cS Q]\]QS` Q]\ _c{ PO``SÒa aS S\QcS\bÒ\ Z]a U`c^]a _cS \]`[OZ[S\bS \] S[^`S\RS\ _c{ SabS`S]bW^]a g [Wb]a ^]aSS\ a]P`S SZ VSQV] RS S[^`S\RS` ] Q [] aWS\bS\ _cS S\ QOa] RS S[^`S\RS` ZO a]QWSROR dOZ]Ò` O aca WRSOa eee S[^ZSObS\OdO`Ò Q][ 3Z Q]\QS^b] RS S[^`S\RS` Sa dSàtbWZ g Q][^ZSX] gO _cS Q]\Qc``S\ S\ {Z c\O UÒ\ RWdSàWROR RS QcSabW]\Sa >OÒ O\OZWhO` ZO dWaW \ g ^S`QS^QW \ a]P`S ZO ^cSabO S\ [O`QVO RS c\ \SU]QW] _cS bWS\S\ O_cSZZ]a _cS ^]aSS\ [ta RWTWQcZbORSa ÔÒ S[^`S\RS` ] _cS \c\QO aS VO\ ^ZO\bSOR] []\bO` c\ \SU]QW] aS VO\ SabcRWOR] Q [] W\bSÒQb O\ S\ SabS ^`]QSa] QcOb`] RW[S\aW]\Sa(

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

:Oa `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa SabS`S]bW^]a g ^`SXcWQW]a( QÂ&#x201E;[] W\TZcgS S\ SZ VSQV] RS S[^`S\RS` ZO a]QWOZWhOQWÂ&#x201E;\ RWTS`S\QWOZ RS U{\S`] ZO ^`]QSRS\QWO ZO RWdSàWROR QcZbcÒZ g ZO SROR :O QOÔQWbOQWÂ&#x201E;\ ^Sà]\OZ aSUÂ&#x2030;\ ZOa RWTS`S\bSa Q][^SbS\QWOa( Â³ 1][^SbS\QWOa g QOÔQWRORSa ^Sà]\OZSa( /cb]SabW[O g Ocb]\][ O S[^]RSÒ[WS\b] W\bSZWUS\QWO S[]QW]\OZ g VOPWZWRORSa a]QWOZSa VOPWZWRORSa RS Q][c\WQOQWÂ&#x201E;\ g QOÔQWROR ÔÒ O^`S\RS` Â³ 1][^SbS\QWOa S[^`S\RSR]Òa 1][^SbS\QWOa RW`WUWROa OZ RSaO``]ZZ] RSZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` W\WQWObWdO Qc`W]aWROR O^S`bcÒ [S\bOZ QOÔQWROR RS Oac[W` `WSaU]a Q`SObWdWROR SbQ Q][^SbS\QWOa RW`WUWROa OZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZO OQbWbcR S[^`S\RSR]Ò `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR WRS\bWTWQOQWÂ&#x201E;\ g a]ZcQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS ^`]PZS[Oa bS\OQWROR `SaWabS\QWO O ZO T`cabÒQWÂ&#x201E;\ SbQ g Q][^SbS\QWOa `SZOQW]\OROa Q]\ ZOa VOPWZWRORSa ÔÒ ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa ZWRSÒhU] bÒPOX] S\ S_cW^] \SU]QWOQWÂ&#x201E;\ SbQ Â³ 1][^SbS\QWOa ] QOÔQWRORSa b{Q\WQOa 1]\]QW[WS\b]a bSÂ&#x201E;`WQ]a g ] b{Q\WQ]a `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ SZ aSQb]` ]TWQW] c ]QcÔQWÂ&#x201E;\ ZOP]ÒZ g ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO ZOP]ÒZ Â³ 1][^SbS\QWOa S[^`SaO`WOZSa :O SfWabS\QWO RS QcZbcÒ S[^`SaO`WOZ ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO S\ USabWÂ&#x201E;\ RS ^`]gSQb]a g S\ ZO dWOPWZWROR RSZ ^`]gSQb] TW\O\hOa g USabWÂ&#x201E;\ OR[W\WabÒbWdO SbQ /a^SQb]a _cS W\TZcgS\ S\ SZ VSQV] RS S[^`S\RS` ! :O []bWdOQWÂ&#x201E;\ @STS`WRO O Z]a []bWd]a W\bS`\]a _cS W[^cZaO\ g []dWZWhO\ O ZOa ^Sà]\Oa O ZO OQQWÂ&#x201E;\( :O ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RS ÔÒ SZZO [Wa[O ] ÔÒ ]bÒa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RS ^]` \SQSaWROR SQ]\Â&#x201E;[WQO g ZOP]ÒZ ] ^]` ]^]`bc\WROR g aObWaTOQQWÂ&#x201E;\ ^Sà]\OZ g aW SfWabS\ O\bSQSRS\bSa TO[WZWO`Sa S[^`S\RSR]`Sa " >]aWPWZWRORSa ^Sà]\OZSa Oa^SQb]a SfbS`\]a g ]PXSbWd]a 3abO RW[S\aWÂ&#x201E;\ Sabt `SZOQW]\ORO Q]\ SZ Q]\bSfb] _cS `]RSO O ZO ^Sà]\O g OP]`RO Oa^SQb]a Q][]( :SUOZWROR 7RW][O aWbcOQWÂ&#x201E;\ ^Sà]\OZ RS S[^ZS] [SX]Ò RS S[^ZS] RSaS[^ZS] OQQSa] O `SQcà]a SQ]\Â&#x201E;[WQ]a T]`[OZSa ] W\T]`[OZSa ^]aWPWZWROR RS OQQSa] O `SQcà]a ^Â&#x2030;PZWQ]a ] W\abWbcQW]\OZSa OQQSa] O ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa g ] O ZO Q]\SfWÂ&#x201E;\ Z]QOZ RS `SRSa []dWZWROR ^]aWPWZWROR RS [S`QOR] aW VOg ] \] aObcÒQWÂ&#x201E;\ `SQcà]a ÔÒ ZO Q]\QWZWOQWÂ&#x201E;\ S\b`S ZO dWRO ZOP]ÒZ TO[WZWO` ^Sà]\OZ g a]QWOZ g ]b`]a 3abOa QcOb`] RW[S\aW]\Sa aS W\bS``SZOQW]\O\ Q][] c\ aWabS[O OPWS`b] g RW\t[WQ] RS []R] _cS POabO W\QWRW` S\ c\O RS SZZOa ÔÒ ZZSUO` O []RWTWQO` ] O ^`]RcQW` QO[PW]a S\ ZOa ]bÒa b`Sa 2S QOÒ O ZO PÂ&#x2030;a_cSRO RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa g `SRcQW` Z]a `WSaU]a aS ^ZO\bSO SZ Q][] SabW[cZO` Z]a TOQb]`Sa []bWdOQW]\OZSa( Â³ 1]\ SZ RSa[]\bOXS g RSQ]\ab`cQQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS ZOa PO``SÒa _cS SfWabS\ S\ SZ W[OUW\O`W] RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa( `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa ^`SXcWQW]a g SabS`S]bW^]a aS ^`SbS\RS RWa[W\cW` SZ bS[]` O Oac[W` `WSaU]a g SZ W\Q`S[S\b] RS Z]a \WdSZSa RS Ocb]\][ O W\WQWObWdO g Ocb]SabW[O S\b`S ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ^`W\QWÔZ[S\bS S\b`S ZOa [cXS`Sa Â³ BÒPOXO` a]P`S ZOa Q][^SbS\QWOa S[]QW]\OZSa g Z]a SabOR]a RS t\W[] :Oa ^Sà]\Oa O\QZOROa S\ S[]QW]\Sa \SUObWdOa [WSR] `SaWU\OQWÂ&#x201E;\ [SZO\Q]Z O \] Sabt\ S\ RWa^]aWQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS S[^`S\RS` Q]\ {fWb]

8Â&#x201E;dS\Sa g USabWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ `WSaU]

³ 1]\ab`cW` [SRWO\bS SZ ZS\UcOXS ZO Q`SOQW \ RS \cSdOa `SOZWRORSa C\O cbWZWhOQW \ aO\O STWQOh g Q]\ab`cQbWdO RSZ ZS\UcOXS RS ZO Q]\dSàOQW \ RS ZO \O`ÒQW \ ÔÒ ^`]RcQW` OQQW \ g bÒ\aT]`[OQW \ aS Q]\dWS`bS S\ VS`Ò[WS\bO Tc\RO[S\bOZ ÔÒ Q]\ab`cW` ^`]gSQb]a ³ 3\b`S\O[WS\b] S\ ^`]QSa]a RS b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa RS ZWRSÒhU] RS Q][c\WQOQW \ Q]\ab`cQbWdO RS \SU]QWOQW \ RS `Sa]ZcQW \ RS Q]\TZWQb]a g RS [SX]Ò RS ZOa VOPWZWRORSa ÔÒ ZO `Sa]ZcQW \ Q`SObWdO RS ^`]PZS[Oa ³ /^]`bO` VS`Ò[WS\bOa ÔÒ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS Q][^SbS\QWOa g QOÔQWRORSa _cS SZW[W\S\ OZUc\Oa RS ZOa RWTWQcZbORSa _cS aS ^ZO\bSO\ ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa ³ 7\bS`dS\W` RS T]`[O W\bSUÒZ Q]\ b]ROa ZOa Ô`bSa W[^ZWQOROa S\ SZ ^`]QSa] RS Q`SOQW \ RS c\O S[^`SaO ZOa ^Sà]\Oa _cS TW\O\QWO\ ZOa _cS ^`]dSS\ RS `SQcà]a ZOa _cS Q][^Ò`t\ SZ ^`]RcQb] ] aS`dWQW] SbQ ³ >`][]QW]\O` `SRSa Vc[O\Oa ÔÒ Q`SO` ^`]gSQb]a ÔÒ VOQS` S_cW^]a _cS ^cSRO\ ac[O` TcS`hOa g ]PXSbWd]a 5S\SÒ` `SZOQW]\Sa WRS\bWRORSa g SabWZ]a _cS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa UcabS\ VOPWbO` g Q][Ô`bW` ³ 5S\SÒ` []RSZ]a `STS`S\bSa W[tUS\Sa ^`]^]\WS\R] SXS[^Z]a g Q]\]QWS\R] \SU]QW]a ] S[^`SaOa aW[WZO`Sa S\ ]b`]a ZcUO`Sa RS T]`[O _cS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa aS aWS\bO\ WRS\bWTWQOROa g dOgO\ SZW[W\O\R] ^`SXcWQW]a ] SabS`S]bW^]a ³ BÒPOXO` a]P`S ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RSZ TÒQOa] 3\ \cSabÒ QcZbcÒ \] Sabt PWS\ dWab] TÒQOaO` ^]` Z] _cS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa \] `SQWPS\ c\O aSUc\RO ]^]`bc\WROR g aS RSQS^QW]\O\ >OÒ SabW[cZO` SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` VOP` O _cS S[^ShO` ^]` Q]\ab`cW` c\O QcZbcÒ R]\RS \] bcdWSÒ QOPWRO bO\bO QcZÔPWZWhOQW \ \W ^S\OZWhOQW \ OZ TÒQOa] g aS RWSÒ dOZ]` O Z]a ^`]QSa]a g OZ O^`S\RWhOXS ]PbS\WR] RcÒ\bS Z]a [Wa[]a ³ =b`] Oa^SQb] W[^]`bO\bS bO\b] ÔÒ ZO P a_cSRO RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa Q][] ÔÒ dOZ]Ò` ^]aWPZSa `WSaU]a Sa `SOZWhO` c\ RWOU\ abWQ] RS Ocb]S[^ZSOPWZWROR RS QORO ^Sà]\O _cS Q]\aWabS S\ SZ `SacZbOR] RS dOZ]Ò` SZ ^]aWQW]\O[WS\b] RS c\O ^Sà]\O S\ ZOa RWdSàOa RW[S\aW]\Sa _cS W\QWRS\ RW`SQbO[S\bS S\ ac ^]bS\QWOZ S[^`S\RSR]`( ZOa []bWdOQW]\Sa ZOa Q][^SbS\QWOa g ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa ^Sà]\OZSa aW\ ]ZdWRO` SZ ^`]gSQb] S[^`S\RSR]` g ac dWOPWZWROR C\ PcS\ RWOU\ abWQ] RSbS`[W\O ZO RS`WdOQW \ O Z]a `SQcà]a ORSQcOR]a) ZO ^`]^cSabO RS WbW\SÒ`W]a g OQQW]\Sa S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa g \SQSaWRORSa RSbSQbOROa) ZOa ^]bS\QWOZWRORSa g QOÔQWRORSa) ZOa Sf^SQbObWdOa g ZOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa >OÒ _cS SabS ^`]QSa] bS\UO [Og]`Sa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS {fWb] aS VO RS SZOP]Ò` WbW\SÒ`W]a RS W\aS`QW \ Q]\ g RSaRS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa _cS ac^]\S\ c\ Q]\Xc\b] RS OQbWdWRORSa aSQcS\QWOROa _cS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa RSPS\ `SQ]``S` Q]\ SZ TW\ RS TOQWZWbO`ZSa `SQcà]a ÔÒ _cS USabW]\S\ Q]\ Ocb]\][ O ac ^`]^W] ^`]QSa] RS W\aS`QW \ a]QW]ZOP]ÒZ & & 1S\WQS`]a 3ab{dSh 8 1 ) 3 =bS] /\bc ] ! =`WS\bOQW \ A]QW]ZOP]ÒZ POaORO S\ 7bW\SÒ`W]a C\O ^`]^cSabO [Sb]R]Z UWQO ÔÒ ZO W\bS`dS\QW \ Q]\ ^Sà]\Oa S\ `WSaU] RS SfQZcaW \ 4c\ROQW \ B][WZZ] ;OR`WR ^ &$

:]a WbW\SÒ`W]a RSTW\S\ SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS OQQW]\Sa T]`[OQW \ b{Q\WQO S\ VOPWZWRORSa S\ QOÔQWRORSa S[^`S\RSR]Òa W\T]`[OQW \ a]P`S b`t[WbSa ]`WS\bOQW \ OaSa]Ò[WS\b] S[^`SaO`WOZ SbQ \SQSaO`WOa ÔÒ [SX]Ò` ZO Ocb]S[^ZSOPWZWROR RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa :]a WbW\SÒ`W]a bWS\S\ _cS aS` ^Sà]\OZWhOR]a g T]`[O\ Ô`bS RS c\ ^`]QSa] _cS OPO`QO [ta Oa^SQb]a _cS Z]a Sab`WQbO[S\bS ZOP]ÒZSa BWS\S\ c\ QO`tQbS` ^SROU UWQ] ] T]`[ObWd] g aS Tc\RO[S\bO\ S\ ZO Q]\aSQcQW \ RS c\O bÒ\aT]`[OQW \ ]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

QO[PW] A]\ OPWS`b]a TZSfWPZSa g RW\t[WQ]a( Q]\ QOÔQWROR RS ORO^bOQW \ O ZOa \SQSaWRORSa Z]U`]a g Sf^SQbObWdOa RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa _cS Z]a `SQ]``S\ BWS\S\ c\ S\T]_cS W\bSUÒR]` >SàWUcS\ Z]UÒ` c\ ^]aWQW]\O[WS\b] RS S_cWROR `Sa^SQb] OZ `Sab] RS ZO QWcRORO\ O 4][S\bO\ ZO Ocb]\][ O ZO Ocb]SabW[O ZO W\WQWObWdO g ZO Q]``Sa^]\aOPWZWROR S\ SZ ^`]QSa]

" 4][S\b] RS ZO QcZbcÒ S[^`S\RSR]Ò AS \SQSaWbO\ [ta ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa g [ta S[^`SaOa RSaS]aOa RS S[PO`QOàS S\ OQbWdWRORSa Q`SObWdOa S W\\]dOR]Òa :O SRcQOQW \ ^cSRS Q]\b`WPcW` S\]`[S[S\bS O ZO Q`SOQW \ RS c\O QcZbcÒ [ta S[^`S\RSR]Ò S[^ShO\R] RSaRS ZOa SRORSa [ta bS[^Ò\Oa 7[^cZaO\R] ZOa OQbWbcRSa g QOÔQWRORSa S[^`S\RSR]Òa aS PS\STWQWO O ZO a]QWSROR W\QZca] [ta OZZt RS ZO O^ZWQOQW \ RS {abOa O \cSdOa W\WQWObWdOa 3\ c\ aS\bWR] O[^ZW] SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` Sa c\O OQbWbcR US\SÒZ _cS ^cSRS `SacZbO` bWZ S\ b]ROa ZOa OQbWdWRORSa ZOP]ÒZSa a]QWOZSa g S\ ZO dWRO Q]bWRWO\O AS bÒbO ^]` bO\b] RS c\O Q][^SbS\QWO PtaWQO g c\] RS Z]a ]PXSbWd]a RSZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] RSPS` O aS` SZ RS T][S\bO` S\ Z]a X dS\Sa ZOa QcOZWRORSa ^Sà]\OZSa _cS Q]\abWbcgS\ ZO POaS RSZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]`( ZO Q`SObWdWROR ZO W\WQWObWdO ZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR ZO QOÔQWROR RS OT`]\bO` `WSaU]a g ZO W\RS^S\RS\QWO A][SbWRO O Q]\abO\bSa QO[PW]a ZO a]QWSROR []RS`\O aS ORO^bO g Sd]ZcQW]\O g RcÒ\bS SabS ^`]QSa] RS[O\RO W\QSaO\bS[S\bS \cSd]a ^S`TWZSa ^`]TSaW]\OZSa 6]g S\ R O bO\b] ÔÒ bÒPOXO` ^]` QcS\bO ^`]^WO Q][] ^]` QcS\bO OXS\O VOg _cS RSaO``]ZZO` QOÔQWRORSa Q][]( Q`SObWdWROR b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa Oac\QW \ RS `WSaU]a []bWdOQW \ `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR Q][c\WQOQW \ Q]\abO\QWO bÒPOX] S\ S_cW^] ^ZO\WTWQOQW \¬ Q]\Xc\b] RS Q][^SbS\QWOa QZOdS _cS W\bSUÒ\ ZO QcZbcÒ S[^`S\RSR]Ò 3\ SabS OÔ`bOR] aS Sf^]\S\ OZUc\Oa Sf^S`WS\QWOa _cS `SZOQW]\O\ ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RS SRcQO` ÔÒ S[^`S\RS` gO aSO O \WdSZ a]QWOZ Q][] S[^`SaO`WOZ 3Z aS`dWQW] ÔÒ ZO ^`][]QW \ RS \cSdOa S[^`SaOa RS ZO 1][c\WROR RS ;OR`WR bWS\S Q][] ]PXSbWd] O^]gO` SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZOa \cSdOa S[^`SaOa ]b]Ùt\R]ZSa ZOa VS`Ò[WS\bOa \SQSaO`WOa ÔÒ _cS aSO\ Q][^SbWbWdOa g ^cSRO\ Q]\a]ZWROàS S\ Z]a [S`QOR]a S\ _cS RSaO``]ZZO\ ac OQbWdWROR :Oa RWabW\bOa OQQW]\Sa RSZ aS`dWQW] aS POaO\ S\ W\bSUÒ` ZO W\\]dOQW \ O ZOa \cSdOa >G;3A 3\bS\RWS\R] ZO W\\]dOQW \ S\ SZ aS\bWR] [ta O[^ZW]( RS ^`]RcQb]a g aS`dWQW]a RS OQQSa] g USabW \ RS Z]a [S`QOR]a ZO ^`][]QW \ g SZ RWaS ] RS ^`]QSa]a g [{b]R]a RS ^`]RcQQW \ OPOabSQW[WS\b]a g RWab`WPcQW \ RS ]ÙO\WhOQW \ g USabW \ RS ZO S[^`SaO :O 1][c\WROR RS ;OR`WR O bÒd{a RS ZO 1]\aSXS` O RS 3[^ZS] g ;cXS` ZO 1]\aSXS` O RS 3Q]\][ O g 1]\ac[] g ZO 1]\aSXS` O RS 3RcQOQW \ RSaO``]ZZO RWabW\b]a ^`]UÒ[Oa ÔÒ OgcRO` O Z]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa g S[^`S\RSR]Òa RS ZO 1][c\WROR O ^]\S` S\ [O`QVO ac S[^`SaO( C\ []RSZ] RS ^ZO\ RS S[^`SaO ]\ ZW\S) VS`Ò[WS\bOa W\bSÒQbWdOa ÔÒ WRS\bWTWQO` Z]a `WSaU]a RS QORO ^`]gSQb] ] aca \SQSaWRORSa bSQ\]Z UWQOa) OQQW]\Sa RS T]`[OQW \ S\QO[W\OROa O ZO RSTW\WQW \ RSZ ^ZO\ RS S[^`SaO)

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

OaSa]Ò[WS\b] ^Sà]\OZWhOR] O Z] ZOÙ] RSZ ^`]QSa] g aS`dWQW]a ÔÒ \cSdOa ^Sà]\Oa S[^`SaO`WOa >`]UÒ[O µ3[^`S\RS` S\ ZO 3aQcSZO¶ RS ZO 1][c\WROR RS ;OR`WR S\ SZ _cS Q]ZOP]Ò\ ZO 1]\aSXS` O RS 3RcQOQW \ g ZO 1]\aSXS` O RS 3[^ZS] g ;cXS` ^`SbS\RS `Sa^]\RS` O ZO \SQSaWROR RS ^`][]dS` ZO QcZbcÒ S[^`S\RSR]Ò S\b`S ac QWcRORO\ O 3\ SabS ^`]UÒ[O aS RSaO``]ZZO\ RWTS`S\bSa SabÒbSUWOa Q][] T]`[OQW \ RSZ ^`]TSa]ÒR] g Q]\Qcà]a Q]\ ]PXSb] RS RSaVOQS` Z]a SabS`S]bW^]a g ac^SÒ` Z]a ^`SXcWQW]a _cS b]ROd O ^SaO\ a]P`S SZ S[^`S\RW[WS\b] S W\QS\bWdO` ZO []bWdOQW \ RS Z]a g ZOa SaQ]ZO`Sa VOQWO ZO QcZbcÒ S[^`S\RSR]Ò S\ SRcQOQW \ ^`W[O`WO g aSQc\RO`WO 1]\ SZ TW\ RS ^`][]dS` ZO aS\aWPWZWhOQW \ RS ZO Q][c\WROR SRcQObWdO ^`]^]`QW]\O` W\T]`[OQW \ g `SQcà]a ÔÒ SZ ^`]TSa]ÒR] g RWTc\RW` PcS\Oa ^`tQbWQOa _cS aW`dO\ RS SXS[^Z] g `STS`S\bS S\ c\ QO[^] bO\ \]dSR]a] ZO 8c\bO RS /\ROZcQ O `SQ]US W\bS`SaO\bSa ^`]gSQb]a RS bÒPOX] S\ ac eSP eee Xc\bORSO\ROZcQ O Sa OdS``]Sa QcZbcÒMS[^`S\RSR]Ò 3Z >`]gSQb] 1OÒPSZOa RSabW\OR] O T][S\bO` S\ SZ OZc[\OR] RS 3RcQOQW \ >`W[O`WO SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` \SQSaO`W] ÔÒ bÒ\aT]`[O` ZOa WRSOa S\ OQb]a Oa Q][] ÔÒ aOPS` W\bS`^`SbO` ZO `SOZWROR S\ ZO _cS dWdS\ g RO` `Sa^cSabO O Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa g \SQSaWRORSa RS ac S\b]`\] AS bÒbO RS c\ Q][^ZS[S\b] T]`[ObWd] RSZ Qc``WQcZc[ ]PZWUOb]`W] RSabW\OR] O US\SÒ` W\WQWObWdOa QOÔQSa RS TOd]`SQS` SZ RSaO``]ZZ] ^Sà]\OZ g a]QWOZ / bÒd{a RS c\]a ObÒQbWd]a [ObS`WOZSa RWRtQbWQ]a RS QO`tQbS` Z RWQ] g Ô`bWQWÔbWd] aS T][S\bO\ ZOa VOPWZWRORSa g QOÔQWRORSa S[^`S\RSR]Òa Q][] a]\( ]PaS`dOQW \ g Sf^Z]ÒQW \ Q`SObWdWROR b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa []bWdOQW \ g ZWRSÒhU] Q][c\WQOQW \ ^ZO\WTWQOQW \ g bÒPOX] S\ S_cW^] eee ^`]gSQb]QOÒPSZOa Sa 8 dS\Sa 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa A]ZWRO`W]a Sa c\ ^`]UÒ[O RS T][S\b] RS ZO QcZbcÒ S[^`S\RSR]Ò g RS ZO a]ZWRO`WROR S\b`S SZ OZc[\OR] RS SRcQOQW \ ^`W[O`WO SRcQOQW \ aSQc\RO`WO T]`[OQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ POQVWZZSÒb] g ^`]UÒ[Oa RS QcOZWTWQOQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ W\WQWOZ / Z] ZOÙ] RSZ Qcà] SZ OZc[\OR] Q`SO g USabW]\O c\O Oa]QWOQW \ ÔÒ `SOZWhO` c\O Q]\QWS\QWOQW \ S\ ac S\b]`\] g ]PbS\S` T]\R]a ÔÒ TW\O\QWO` OZU \ ^`]gSQb] RS W\bS`{a a]QWOZ RSaO``]ZZOR] ^]` OZUc\O RS ZOa =<5 a Ô`bWQWÔ\bSa CbWZWhO\R] Q][] VWZ] Q]\RcQb]` ZO Q`SOQW \ g USabW \ RS ZO Oa]QWOQW \ SZ OZc[\OR] OR_cWS`S QcOZWRORSa g OQbWbcRSa S[^`S\RSR]Òa Q][] ZO ]PaS`dOQW \ RSZ S\b]`\] ZO ^ZO\WTWQOQW \ bÒPOX] S\ S_cW^] W\WQWObWdO Q`SObWdWROR Ocb]SabW[O VOPWZWRORSa RS Q][c\WQOQW \ `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR S W\RS^S\RS\QWO 3abS ^`]UÒ[O SRcQObWd] bWS\S Q][] ]PXSbWd] Q`SO` c\ SaÔQW] _cS aW`dO RS Sab [cZ] g RS O^]g] OZ OZc[\OR] QOÔh RS US\SÒ` WRSOa _cS RS\ `Sa^cSabO O ^`]PZS[Oa a]QWOZSa eee Xc\bORSO\ROZcQWO Sa OdS``]Sa QcZbcÒMS[^`S\RSR]Ò 3[^`SaO 8]dS\ 3c`]^SO 2SaO``]ZZOR] S\ Q]ZOP]ÒQW \ Q]\ ZO 1]\aSXS` O RS 7\\]dOQW \ 1WS\QWO g 3[^`SaO 3Z ^ZO\ S[^`S\RSR]`Sa W\QZcgS OQQW]\Sa []bWdOR]Òa RS ZWRSÒhU] g bÒPOX] S\ S_cW^] S\ SRcQOQW \ aSQc\RO`WO POQVWZZSÒb] g T]`[OQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ 2cÒ\bS SZ Qcà] SZ OZc[\OR] USabW]\O c\O Q]]^SÒbWdO RS Q][S`QW] S\ ZO _cS W\bS`QO[PWO\ ^`]RcQb]a Q]\ Q]]^SÒbWdOa RS OZc[\OR] RS ]b`]a Ô aSa ] `SUW]\Sa) ZcSU] dS\RS\ S\ SZ [S`QOR] Z]QOZ Z]a ^`]RcQb]a _cS VO\ OR_cW`WR] :Oa Q]]^SÒbWdOa `SÔ`bS\ Z]a PS\STWQW]a ]PbS\WR]a WUcOZ _cS QcOZ_cWS` S[^`SaO AS ^ZO\bSO\

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

Q][] ]PXSbWd] SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS QOÔQWRORSa S[^`S\RSR]Òa Q][] a]\( ZO Ocb]SabW[O Q`SObWdWROR ]PaS`dOQW \ g Sf^Z]ÒQW \ RSZ S\b]`\] b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa g bÒPOX] S\ S_cW^] /RS[ta RS T][S\bO` SZ ca] RS ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ g RS ZO Q][c\WQOQW \ g Q]\b`WPcW` OZ ca] RS ZO ZS\UcO SfbÒ\XSÒ Q][] W\ab`c[S\b] RS Q][c\WQOQW \ eee OUS\QWOWRSO Sa Vbb^( SXS dOZ\OZ]\SRcQO Q][ >`]UÒ[O RS AW[cZOQW \ RS 3[^`SaOa Q]\ 4W\Sa 3RcQObWd]a >`]UÒ[O RS T]`[OQW \ RW`WUWR] OZ OZc[\OR] RS ZOa TO[WZWOa ^`]TSaW]\OZSa RS /R[W\WabÒQW \ 1][S`QW] g ;O`YSbW\U g 6]abSZS` O g Bc`Wa[] _cS bWS\S Q][] ]PXSbWd] ^`W]`WbO`W] ZO T]`[OQW \ RSZ OZc[\OR] S\ SZ QO[^] RS ZO USabW \ g ZO OR[W\WabÒQW \ RS ZOa S[^`SaOa cbWZWhO\R] Q][] [Sb]R]Z]U O ZO `S^`]RcQQW \ RS aWbcOQW]\Sa `SOZSa [SRWO\bS ZO aW[cZOQW \ 1ORO c\] RS Z]a QS\b`]a _cS Ô`bWQWÔ\ S\ SZ ^`]UÒ[O A3432 aS Q]\abWbcgS Q][] c\O S[^`SaO Q]\ c\O aS`WS RS RSÔ`bO[S\b]a _cS OZ [Wa[] bWS[^] Sabt\ RWdWRWR]a S\ ^cSab]a RS bÒPOX] _cS SZ OZc[\OR] W`t ]QcÔ\R] RS T]`[O `]bObWdO /QbcOZ[S\bS VOg Tc\QW]\O\R] S[^`SaOa S\ ZO `SR \OQW]\OZ g c\Oa # S\ ZO `SR W\bS`\OQW]\OZ 6Og S[^`SaOa RSZ aSQb]` RS ZO OZW[S\bOQW \ bSfbWZ RS bÒ\a^]`bS bc` abWQOa RS ZW[^WShO RS S[POZOXS RS aSUc`]a Vbb^( eSPa aSTSR Sa 3[^`S\RSX]dS\ Sa c\ ^`]gSQb] RW`WUWR] O OZc[\OR] RS Z]a QWQZ]a T]`[ObWd]a RS T]`[OQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ RS /\ROZcQ O AS RSaO``]ZZO S\ Q]ZOP]ÒQW \ Q]\ ZO 1]\aSXS` O RS 7\\]dOQW \ 1WS\QWO g 3[^`SaO O bÒd{a RS ZO /US\QWO RS 7\\]dOQW \ g 2SaO``]ZZ] 3a c\ ^`]UÒ[O W\bSUÒZ _cS Q]\abO RS dO`WOa TOaSa eee S[^`S\RSX]dS\ Q][ 5S\bS 3[^`S\RSR]Ò A]ZWRO`WO 3a c\ ^`]UÒ[O RS T][S\b] RS ZO QcZbcÒ S[^`S\RSR]Ò g RS ZO a]ZWRO`WROR S\b`S SZ OZc[\OR] RS QS\b`]a SRcQObWd]a _cS W[Ô`bS\ S\aS O\hOa ÔÒ ORcZb]a 3Z OZc[\OR] Q`SO g USabW]\O c\O Oa]QWOQW \ Q]\ ZO TW\OZWROR RS `SOZWhO` OQbWdWRORSa RS Q]\QWS\QWOQW \ g aS\aWPWZWhOQW \ Oa Q][] RS ]PbS\QW \ RS `SQcà]a ÔÒ TW\O\QWO` OZU \ ^`]gSQb] RS W\bS`{a a]QWOZ RSaO``]ZZOR] ^]` ZOa =<5 A Ô`bWQWÔ\bSa 1]\ ZO Q`SOQW \ g USabW \ RS ZO Oa]QWOQW \ SZ OZc[\OR] OR_cWS`S QcOZWRORSa g OQbWbcRSa S[^`S\RSR]Òa Q][] ZO ]PaS`dOQW \ RSZ S\b]`\] ZO ^ZO\WTWQOQW \ bÒPOX] S\ S_cW^] W\WQWObWdO Q`SObWdWROR Ocb]SabW[O VOPWZWRORSa RS Q][c\WQOQW \ `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR S W\RS^S\RS\QWO AS ^`SbS\RS T][S\bO` S\ SZ OZc[\OR] c\O Q]\QWS\QWO a]ZWRO`WO `Sa^]\aOPZS g Q][^`][SbWRO eee Xc\bORSO\ROZcQWO Sa OdS``]Sa QcZbcÒMS[^`S\RSR]Ò 3[^`S\RS` S\ 3c`]Ô 3a c\ Qcà] RS T][S\b] RSZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`SaO`WOZ _cS aS W[Ô`bS O bÒd{a RS W\bS`\Sb Q]\ c\O R]PZS TW\OZWROR( ^]` c\O Ô`bS SabW[cZO` ZOa OQbWbcRSa g VOPWZWRORSa S[^`S\RSR]Òa S\ SZ OZc[\OR] g ^]` ]bÒ ^`]^]`QW]\O` Q]\]QW[WS\b]a \SQSaO`W]a ÔÒ ZO SZOP]ÒQW \ RS c\ ^ZO\ RS S[^`SaO g \]QW]\Sa PtaWQOa a]P`S ZOa RWTS`S\bSa t`SOa RS c\O S[^`SaO 6Og R]a \WdSZSa( 0taWQ] g OdO\hOR] AS OP]`RO\ Z]a bS[Oa( ^S`TWZ RSZ S[^`S\RSR]` [O`YSbW\U Oa^SQb]a TW\O\QWS`]a g ZSUOZSa ]ÙO\WhOQW \ g ^`]TSaW]\OZWa[] 1`SO\R] S[^`SaO / Z] ZOÙ] RSZ Qcà] SZ OZc[\OR] Q`SO g USabW]\O c\O S[^`SaO Q]\ ZO TW\OZWROR RS RSaO``]ZZO` RS c\O [O\SÒ QOaW `SOZ b]ROa ZOa ]^SÒQW]\Sa Z]U] SabObcb]a TOP`WQOQW \ Q][S`QWOZWhOQW \ b`t[WbSa OR[W\WabÒbWd]a _cS aS `SOZWhO\ S\ QcOZ_cWS` S[^`SaO c ]ÙO\WhOQW \ CbWZWhO\R] Q][] VWZ] Q]\RcQb]` ZO Q`SOQW \ g USabW \ RS ZO S[^`SaO SZ OZc[\OR] OR_cWS`S QcOZWRORSa g OQbWbcRSa S[^`S\RSR]Òa Q][] ZO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

]PaS`dOQWย \ RSZ S\b]`\] ZO ^ZO\WTWQOQWย \ bÒPOX] S\ S_cW^] W\WQWObWdO Q`SObWdWROR Ocb]SabW[O VOPWZWRORSa RS Q][c\WQOQWย \ `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR S W\RS^S\RS\QWO 1]\Qcà] RS ^`]gSQb]a RS S[^`SaOa dW`bcOZSa BWS\S Q][] ^`W\QWÔZSa ]PXSbWd]a SZ T][S\bO` ZO OQbWbcR S[^`S\RSR]Ò ÔÒ _cS ac`XO\ PcS\Oa WRSOa RS \SU]QW] _cS Q`SS\ `W_cShO g S[^ZS] ÔÒ ZO Q][c\WROR S W\bSUÒ` ZOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa RS ZO W\T]`[OQWย \ g ZOa Q][c\WQOQW]\Sa S\ ZO OQbWdWROR S[^`SaO`WOZ :]a ^`]gSQb]a bWS\S\ Q][] TW\OZWROR SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS c\O WRSO ÔÒ ZO Q`SOQWย \ RS c\O S[^`SaO dW`bcOZ Q]\ OÙc[S\bOQWย \ a]P`S ac dWOPWZWROR :O 1tbSRÒ <SP`WXO ยณ 00D/ S\ 4]`[OQWย \ RS 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa ^`][cSdS g Q]]`RW\O ZOa OQbWdWRORSa RS ZO C\WdSàWROR /\b]\W] RS <SP`WXO `SZOQW]\OROa Q]\ ZO Q`SOQWย \ RS S[^`SaOa g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RSZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` Oa Q][] ZO W\dSabWUOQWย \ g RWTcaWย \ RS Q]\]QW[WS\b] a]P`S ZO OQQWย \ S[^`S\RSR]Ò g ZO T]`[OQWย \ c\WdSàWbO`WO S\ S[^`S\RSR]`Sa 3abO QtbSRÒ \OQS Q]\ SZ ^`]^ย aWb] RS Q]ZOP]Ò` Q]\ Z]a RWdSà]a OUS\bSa RS ZO a]QWSROR g RSZ S\b]`\] SQ]\ย [WQ] [ta ^`ย fW[] ÔÒ T][S\bO` Z]a dOZ]`Sa RS ZO QcZbcÒ RSZ S[^`S\RWhOXS g T][S\bO` SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS \SU]QW]a W\QZcWR] SZ Ocb]S[^ZS] RSZ OZc[\OR] c\WdSàWbO`W] ÔÒ ac W\bSUÒQWย \ S\ SZ [S`QOR] RS bÒPOX] Vbb^( eee \SP`WXO Q][ \SP`WXO PPdO S[^`S\RSR]`Sa W\RSf Vb[Z 3Z >`]UÒ[O 3[^`S\RSR]` FF7 \OQS ÔÒ W[^cZaO` g O^]gO` SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` g ZO Q`SOQWย \ RS S[^`SaOa W\\]dOR]Òa S\ 3aÔย O BWS\S Q][] ]PXSbWd]a( T][S\bO` ZO QcZbcÒ S[^`S\RSR]Ò ^`]^]`QW]\O\R] W\T]`[OQWย \ RS W\bS`{a) OQS`QO` ZO Q`SOQWย \ RS S[^`SaOa OZ [c\R] c\WdSàWbO`W] g O^]gO` RW`SQbO[S\bS O Z]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa W\\]dOR]`Sa [SRWO\bS RWTS`S\bSa VS`Ò[WS\bOa RS TW\O\QWOQWย \ Oa Q][] OaSa]Ò[WS\b] g OQ][Ôย O[WS\b] S\ ZOa ^`W[SÒa SbOÔa RS Q`SOQWย \ RS ZO S[^`SaO AS RW`WUS( O W\abWbcQW]\Sa g ]ÙO\Wa[]a W\bS`SaOR]a S\ T][S\bO` ZO Q`SOQWย \ RS S[^`SaOa g SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` O OUS\bSa W[^ZWQOR]a S\ ZO Q`SOQWย \ g ] USabWย \ RS S[^`SaOa W\\]dOR]Òa O W\dSà]`Sa _cS TW\O\QWS\ ^`]gSQb]a S[^`SaO`WOZSa W\\]dOR]`Sa O ^Sà]\Oa S[^`S\RSR]Òa _cS _cWSÒ\ RSaO``]ZZO` c\ ^`]gSQb] S[^`SaO`WOZ W\\]dOR]` Vbb^( Q]PÒ\RSR S[^`S\RSR]`ffW Sa Vb[Z UcWO Vb[ : \SO 71= S[^`S\RSR]`Sa 1]\ ZO : \SO 71= 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa & SZ 7\abWbcb] RS 1`{RWb] =TWQWOZ TW\O\QWO S\ Q]\RWQW]\Sa ^`STS`S\bSa O Z]a Ocbย \][]a g S[^`S\RSR]`Sa _cS ^]\UO\ S\ [O`QVO \cSdOa S[^`SaOa ] \cSdOa OQbWdWRORSa ^`]TSaW]\OZSa Vbb^( eee WQ] Sa eSP Q]\bS\WR]a % W\RSf-\+ >`]UÒ[O RS 4]`[OQWย \ 0O\QOXO ÔÒ 8ย dS\Sa 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa 0O\QOXO O bÒd{a RS ac =PÒ A]QWOZ RSaO``]ZZO Qcà]a RS T]`[OQWย \ ÔÒ XcdS\bcR S[^`S\RSR]Ò 0O\QOXO Q]\ SZ ]PXSb] RS Q]\b`WPcW` OZ RSaO``]ZZ] a]QW]SQ]\ย [WQ] RS ac h]\O RS OQbcOQWย \ ^]bS\QWO` SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` W\QS\bWdO` ZO W\\]dOQWย \ g RWdSàWTWQOQWย \ g O^]gO` ZOa W\WQWObWdOa S[^`SaO`WOZSa RS Z]a Xย dS\Sa Q]\d]QO Z]a >`S[W]a 0O\QOXO 8ย dS\Sa 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa 1]\abWbcgS SZ ]PXSb] RS SabS Q]\Qcà] SZ RSaO``]ZZ] g ^cSabO S\ [O`QVO RS ^`]gSQb]a S[^`SaO`WOZSa _cS RSPS`t\ cPWQOàS S\ Z]QOZWRORSa RSZ bS``Wb]`W] \OQW]\OZ `SOZWhOR]a ^]` Xย dS\Sa RS VOabO !# Oย ]a W\QZcaWdS PWS\ RS T]`[O W\RWdWRcOZ ] Q]ZSQbWdO eee PO\QOXO Sa

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

4c\ROQW \ @SR /\ROZcQ O 3[^`S\RS :]a ]PXSbWd]a US\SÒZSa RS ^`][]QW \ RS ZO QcZbcÒ g ZO OQbWdWROR S[^`S\RSR]Ò g O^]g] O ZO Q`SOQW \ g RSaO``]ZZ] a]\ ]PXSbWd]a Sa^SQ TWQ]a _cS Q]\b`WPcgS\ O ZO Q]\aSQcQW \ RS Z]a TW\Sa RS ZO 4c\ROQW \ @SR /\ROZcQ O 3[^`S\RS ÔÒ [SX]Ò` g dOZ]Ò` ZO W[OUS\ a]QWOZ RS ZO ^Sà]\O S[^`S\RSR]Ò ZO Ocb]acTWQWS\QWO SQ]\ [WQO g SZ O^`]dSQVO[WS\b] RS Z]a `SQcà]a S\R US\]a g Q]\b`WPcW` OZ W[^cZa] RS ZO T]`[OQW \ S[^`SaO`WOZ S[^`S\RSR]Ò S W\\]dOR]Ò S\ Z]a aWabS[Oa SRcQObWd]a `SUZOR]a RS ZO S\aS O\hO ^`W[O`WO aSQc\RO`WO g ZO T]`[OQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ Vbb^( eee O S[^`S\RS \Sb :]a >`S[W]a 8 dS\Sa 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa A]QWOZSa :O 4c\ROQW \ 5S\SÒZ C\WdSàWROR 3c`]^SO RS ;OR`WR S\ Q]ZOP]ÒQW \ Q]\ ZO 7\bS`\ObW]\OZ G]cbV 4]c\RObW]\ VO ^cSab] S\ [O`QVO SabO Q]\d]QOb]`WO ÔÒ ^`S[WO` W\WQWObWdOa S[^`S\RSR]Òa ^`]bOU]\WhOROa ^]` X dS\Sa Vbb^( eee g]cbVOQbW]\\Sb ]Ù W\RSf ^V^-TcaS+W\abWbcbSa aQ]^S+\ObW]\OZ \O[S+AÔW\ >ZO\ RS /QQW \ ÔÒ SZ 3a^ `Wbc 3[^`S\RSR]` 3\b`S^`S\ScàVW^ (ZO 1][WaW \ 3c`]^SO VO ^cPZWQOR] c\ ^ZO\ RS OQQW \ POaOR] S\ ZO `Sb`]OZW[S\bOQW \ `SQWPWRO O Ô`bW` RSZ ZWP`] dS`RS RS 3\b`S^`S\ScàVW^ 3Z >ZO\ RS /QQW \ SabOPZSQS c\ [O`Q] RS # t`SOa ^`W]`WbO`WOa SabÒb{UWQOa Sf^cSabOa S\ ZO OUS\RO Sc`]^SO Vbb^( Sc`]Ô Sc W\b Q][[ S\bS`^`WaS S\b`S^`S\ScàVW^ OQbW]\M^ZO\ Vb[ 2W`SQQW \ 5S\SÒZ RS >]Z bWQO RS ZO >G;3 ;W\WabS`W] RS 7\Rcab`WO Bc`Wa[] g 1][S`QW] /QQW]\Sa O RSaO``]ZZO` ÔÒ ZO SXSQcQW \ RS ZO ^]Z bWQO RSZ 5]PWS`\] S\ [ObS`WO RS ZO ^S_cS O g [SRWO\O S[^`SaO ^]` RWTS`S\bSa C\WRORSa Vbb^( eee W^g[S ]Ù 7>G;3 Sa 3A :/25>G;3 12B7( 1S\b`] ÔÒ SZ 2SaO``]ZZ] BSQ\]Z UWQ] 7\Rcab`WO 12B7 ;W\WabS`W] RS 7\Rcab`WO Bc`Wa[] g 1][S`QW] 3a c\O 3\bWROR > PZWQO 3[^`SaO`WOZ RS^S\RWS\bS RSZ ;W\WabS`W] RS 7\Rcab`WO Bc`Wa[] g 1][S`QW] _cS ^`][cSdS ZO W\\]dOQW \ g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] bSQ\]Z UWQ] RS ZOa S[^`SaOa SaÔ ]ZOa Ac ]PXSbWd] Sa Q]\b`WPcW` O ZO [SX]Ò RSZ \WdSZ bSQ\]Z UWQ] RS ZOa S[^`SaOa SaÔ ]ZOa Vbb^( eee QRbW Sa eSP12B7 Sa^ W\RSf Vb[Z 1=4723A 1][Ô O 3aÔ ]ZO RS 4W\O\QWOQW \ OZ 2SaO``]ZZ] 3a c\O a]QWSROR O\ \W[O RS QO^WbOZ [Wfb] ^ PZWQ] g ^`WdOR] Q`SORO S\ '&& Qcg] ]PXSb] Sa SZ T][S\b] RS ZOa W\dSàW]\Sa ^`]RcQbWdOa RS S[^`SaOa SaÔ ]ZOa S\ Ô aSa S\ RSaO``]ZZ] ÔÒ Q]\b`WPcW` Q]\ Q`WbS`W]a RS `S\bOPWZWROR bO\b] OZ RSaO``]ZZ] SQ]\ [WQ] RS Sa]a Ô aSa Q][] O ZO W\bS`\OQW]\OZWhOQW \ RS ZO SQ]\][ O SaÔ ]ZO Vbb^( eee Q]TWRSa Sa /<13A( /a]QWOQW \ <OQW]\OZ RS 1S\b`]a 3c`]^S]a RS 3[^`SaOa S 7\\]dOQW \ 3aÔ ]ZSa 3a ZO Oa]QWOQW \ <OQW]\OZ RS Z]a 1S\b`]a 3c`]^S]a RS 3[^`SaOa S 7\\]dOQW \ 3aÔ ]ZSa Qcg] TW\ Sa Q]ZOP]Ò` O^]`bO\R] ac Sf^S`WS\QWO a]P`S ZO Q`SOQW \ RS \cSdOa >G;3 g ] OQbWdWRORSa \cSdOa S\ ZOa >G;3 SfWabS\bSa POaOROa S\ SZS[S\b]a W\\]dOR]`Sa Q]\ ^]bS\QWOZ RSaO``]ZZ] Vbb^( eee O\QSa Q][ eSP W\RSf& Vb[ 53; BVS 5Z]POZ 3\b`S^`S\ScàVW^ ;]\Wb]` 3aÔ O 3Z ^`]gSQb] 53; \OQW S\ SZ O ] ''% Q][] c\O W\WQWObWdO RS ZO :]\R]\ 0caW\Saa AQV]]Z g RSZ 0OPa]\ 1]ZZSUS ÔÒ Q`SO` c\O `SR W\bS`\OQW]\OZ RS W\dSabWUOQW \ S\ SZ S\b]`\] RS ZO 1`SOQW \ RS 3[^`SaOa 3aÔ O O bÒd{a RSZ 7\abWbcb] RS 3[^`SaO aS W\Q]`^]` OZ >`]gSQb] 53; S\ ac aSUc\RO SRWQW \ :O W\WQWObWdO \] bWS\S ^`SQSRS\bSa g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] OQbcOZ RSZ >`]gSQb] ZS

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

Q]\RcQS O aS` c\ `STS`S\bS S\ ZO W\dSabWUOQW \ RSZ TS\ [S\] S[^`S\RSR]` S\ b]R] SZ [c\R] Vbb^( eee WS SRc US[ `SacZbOR]a Vb[Z 7\abWbcb] ;OR`WZS ] RS 2SaO``]ZZ] 3[^`SaO`WOZ 3Z 7;/23 Sa c\O S\bWROR RS RS`SQV] ^ PZWQ] g ORaQ`WbO O ZO 1]\aSXS` O RS 3Q]\][ O S 7\\]dOQW \ BSQ\]Z UWQO Ac ^`W\QWÔZ ]PXSbWd] Sa ^`][]dS` SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZO `SUW \ [SRWO\bS OQbcOQW]\Sa _cS TOd]`ShQO\ SZ Q`SQW[WS\b] SQ]\ [WQ] g ZO Q`SOQW \ RS S[^ZS] 3[^`S\RSR]` aWUZ] FF7 >tUW\O RS :O 1OWfO Q]\ W\T]`[OQW \ RS W\bS`{a ÔÒ ZO Q`SOQW \ RS S[^`SaOa g S[^`S\RSR]`Sa Vbb^( eee S[^`S\RSR]`ffW Q][ 1S\b`] RS 7\WQWObWdOa 3[^`S\RSR]Òa ³17/23³ RS ZO C\WdSàWROR /cb \][O RS ;OR`WR BWS\S ZO [WaW \ RS Q]ZOP]Ò` Q]\ Z]a RWdSà]a OUS\bSa RS ZO A]QWSROR 3aÔ ]ZO S\ US\SÒZ g RS ZO 1][c\WROR /cb \][O RS ;OR`WR S\ Ô`bWQcZO` ÔÒ T][S\bO` Z]a dOZ]`Sa VOQWO ZO Q`SOQW \ RS S[^`SaOa g SZ Ocb]S[^ZS] RSZ OZc[\OR] c\WdSàWbO`W] ÔÒ ac W\bSUÒQW \ S\ SZ [S`QOR] RS bÒPOX] g ÔÒ RSaO``]ZZO` SZ Ô^SZ W[^cZa]` _cS ^cSRS RSaO``]ZZO` ZO C\WdSàWROR Q][] Ô`bWQW^S S\ Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa RS W\aS`QW \ g O^]g] O Q]ZSQbWd]a RSaTOd]`SQWR]a ^]` ZO d O RSZ Ocb]S[^ZS] g ZO Q`SOQW \ RS S[^`SaOa Vbb^( eee QWORS ]Ù >]`bOZ RS S[^`S\RSR]`Sa 1][c\WROR RS ;OR`WR :O 1][c\WROR RS ;OR`WR O bÒd{a RS ZO 1]\aSXS` O RS 3[^ZS] g ;cXS` ZO 1]\aSXS` O RS 3Q]\][ O S 7\\]dOQW \ BSQ\]Z UWQO g ZO 1]\aSXS` O RS 3RcQOQW \ RSaO``]ZZO RWabW\b]a ^`]UÒ[Oa ÔÒ OgcRO` O Z]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa g S[^`S\RSR]Òa RS ZO 1][c\WROR O ^]\S` S\ [O`QVO ac S[^`SaO Vbb^( eee S[^`S\RSZ] Sa 1723; 5S\SÒZWbOb RS 1ObOZc O 3Z 1S\b`] RS 7\\]dOQW \ g 2SaO``]ZZ] 3[^`SaO`WOZ 1723; Sa c\ ]ÙO\Wa[] RSZ 2SÔ`bO[S\b] RS BÒPOX] S 7\Rcab`WO RS ZO 5S\SÒZWbOb RS 1ObOZc O Ac [WaW \ Sa W[^cZaO` SZ bSXWR] S[^`SaO`WOZ QObOZt\ g ^]bS\QWO` ac Q][^SbWbWdWROR O\bS Z]a `Sb]a _cS RSPO OT`]\bO` Vbb^( eee QWRS[ Q][ QWRS[ Sa SZQWRS[ W\T] W\RSf Xa^ 1/23 8c\bO RS /\ROZcQ O 1S\b`] /\ROZch RS 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa 8c\bO RS /\ROZcQ O 1/23 Sa c\ ]ÙO\Wa[] _cS bWS\S SZ ]PXSb] RS RSaO``]ZZO` SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` RS /\ROZcQ O Vbb^( eee Xc\bORSO\ROZcQWO Sa W\\]dOQW]\QWS\QWOgS[^`SaO QORS >`]^ 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa 2S ZO 1t[OÒ RS 1][S`QW] RS /ZWQO\bS g 5S\SÒZWbOb RS DOZS\QWO =T`SQS c\ O^]g] W\bSUÒZ OZ S[^`S\RSR]` S\ ZO Q`SOQW \ RS ac S[^`SaO Q]\ c\Oa [ \W[Oa Sf^SQbObWdOa RS dWOPWZWROR g Q]\a]ZWROQW \ O [SRW] ^ZOh] g SZ aSUcW[WS\b] g OaSa]Ò[WS\b] S[^`SaO`WOZ S\ aca ^`W[S`]a O ]a RS dWRO Vbb^( eee QO[OÒZWQO\bS Q][ >@=> 3Z 7\abWbcb] RS ZO ;SRWO\O g >S_cS O 7\Rcab`WO DOZS\QWO\O 7;>7D/ Sa c\ ]ÙO\Wa[] RS ZO 5S\SÒZWbOb DOZS\QWO\O S\QOÙOR] RS RSaO``]ZZO` ZO ^]Z bWQO RS ^`][]QW \ W\Rcab`WOZ S\ SZ t[PWb] RS ZOa ^S_cS Oa g [SRWO\Oa S[^`SaOa Vbb^( eee W[^WdO Sa :O 3[^`SaO <OQW]\OZ RS 7\\]dOQW \ A / Sa c\ ]ÙO\Wa[] RS QO^WbOZ ^ PZWQ] ORaQ`WbO OZ ;W\WabS`W] RS 3Q]\][ O Ac OQbWdWROR PtaWQO Q]\aWabS S\ PcaQO` \cSd]a W\ab`c[S\b]a TW\O\QWS`]a RS O^]g] O ZO >G;3 3\ Q]\Q`Sb] ]T`SQS Q][] T `[cZO RS TW\O\QWOQW \ SZ ^`{abO[] Ô`bWQWÔbWd] Vbb^( eee S\WaO Sa

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

7D/8 1`SOQW \ RS S[^`SaOa >tUW\O Q]\ W\T]`[OQW \ RS ZOa OgcROa _cS ]T`SQS SZ 7\abWbcb] DOZS\QWO\] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR ÔÒ ZO Q`SOQW \ RS S[^`SaOa ZWRSÒROa ^]` X dS\Sa 2Wa^]\S RS c\ ^`]UÒ[O Q]\ OaSa]Ò[WS\b] aSUcW[WS\b] T]`[OQW \ g OgcROa SQ]\ [WQOa Vbb^( eee WdOX Sa :O /US\QWO 3aÔ ]ZO RS 1]]^SÒQW \ 7\bS`\OQW]\OZ /317 ]T`SQS RWdSàOa OgcROa g acPdS\QW]\Sa ÔÒ O_cSZZOa S[^`SaOa _cS bÒPOXS\ S\ ^`]gSQb]a RS Q]]^SÒQW \ g RSaO``]ZZ] S\ ]b`]a Ô aSa Vbb^( eee OSQW Sa @343@3<17/A 070:7=5@È471/A 0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O 1S\WQS`]a 8 1 3ab{dSh) 3 =bS] /\bO ] ! =`WS\bOQW \ A]QW]ZOP]ÒZ POaORO S\ 7bW\SÒ`W]a C\O ^`]^cSabO [Sb]R]Z UWQO ÔÒ ZO W\bS`dS\QW \ Q]\ ^Sà]\Oa S\ `WSaU] RS SfQZcaW \ 4c\ROQW \ B][WZZ] ;OR`WR ^ &$ 4S`Ò\ HcPWZZOUO / % 3Z S[^`S\RWhOXS a]QWOZ \cSd]a `Sb]a \cSdOa `Sa^cSabOa >`]^cSabO ÔÒ W\Q]`^]Ò` SZ Sa^ `Wbc S[^`S\RSR]` S\ ZO T]`[OQW \ RS Z]a Oa bÒPOXOR]`Sa Oa a]QWOZSa S\ O `ST]`[O RS ZO T]`[OQW \ g ZO bWbcZOQW \ S\ SZ [O`Q] RSZ 333A( 1]\TS`S\QWO RS 2W`SQb]`Sa Oa RS 1S\b`]a g 2SÔ`bO[S\b]a RS BÒPOX] A]QWOZ g 8c\bO RS 5]PWS`\] RSZ 1]\aSX] 5S\SÒZ RS 1]ZSUW]a RS 2W^Z][OR]a S\ BÒPOX] A]QWOZ g /aWabS\bSa A]QWOZSa % 5]\htZSh A ) 1O[û F ) 3aQ]PO` @ '' =ÙO\WhO` S\bWRORSa RS W\WQWObWdO a]QWOZ( WRSOa ÔÒ S[^`S\RSR]`Sa /;0 /aa]QWOQW 0O`QSZ]\O 5]\htZSh A ) 1O[û F ) 3aQ]PO` @ =ÙO\WhO` S\bWRORSa RS W\WQWObWdO a]QWOZ( WRSOa ÔÒ S[^`S\RSR]`Sa /;0 /aa]QWOQW 0O`QSZ]\O '' 5Z]POZ 3\b`S^`S\ScàVW^ ;]\Wb]` 7\T]`[S 3XSQcbWd] 53; 3aÔ O % eee WS SRc 53; 5c O ÔÒ ZO ^cSabO S\ [O`QVO RSZ ^`]UÒ[O 8 dS\Sa 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa A]ZWRO`W]a 83A 8 dS\Sa S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]ZWRO`W]a 1]\aSXS` O RS 3RcQOQW \Â 2 5 RS 4]`[OQW \ >`]TSaW]\OZ g 3RcQOQW \ >S`[O\S\bS 8c\bO RS /\ROZcQ O eee Xc\bORSO\ROZcQWO Sa OdS``]Sa QcZbcÒMS[^`S\RSR]Ò 5c O ÔÒ ^`]TSaW]\OZSa _cS bÒPOXS\ ZO []bWdOQW \ O S[^`S\RS` >`]gSQb] 3[^Z{ObS $ Vbb^( eee SQ]SabÒbSUWO Q][ O`bWQcZ]a VS[S`]bSQO \]PSZa ^RT ?c{ Sa ÔÒ b S[^`S\RS`( 5]PWS`\] RS <OdO`Ò eee S[^ZSObS\OdO`Ò Q][ ;Q 1ZSZZO\R 2 1 '&% µ1VO`SabS`WabWQa ]T AcQQSaaTcZ 3\b`S^`S\Scà¶ 8]c`\OZ ]T 1`SObWdS 03VOdW]S S\ 0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O !$# >SbS` 4 2`cQYS` ''! µ7\\]dObW]\ O\R 3\b`S^`S\ScàVW^¶ 6O`^S` 0caaW\Saa <cSdO 1]`Y S\ 0]`\abSW\ 2 # µ1 [] QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] :]a S[^`S\RSR]`Sa a]QWOZSa g SZ ^]RS` RS ZOa \cSdOa WRSOa¶ 2SPObS 0O`QSZ]\O >`]gSQb] 3[^Z{ObS 7\WQWObWdO 1][c\WbO`WO 3_cOZ # AS`dWQW] <OdO``] RS 3[^ZS] 5]PWS`\] RS <OdO`Ò g 4]\R] A]QWOZ 3c`]^S]

E30

Vbb^( Sa^O\]Z OaV]YO ]`U

Vbb^( eee Tc\ROQW]\fOdWS`RSaOZOa Q][

7<<]DO<2WA C\WdS`aWROR RS 23CAB= Vbb^( W\\]dO\RWa eSb^OW\b Q][

4c\ROQW \ 5OhbSZO\ eee UOhbSZO\ ]Ù 5c Oa ÔÒ S[^`S\RS`

3(JX]dS\Sa S[^`S\RSR]`SaJ5cWO 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa [Vb

3(JX]dS\Sa S[^`S\RSR]`SaJ3[^`S\RSR]` FF7M 3Z >]`bOZ RSZ S[^`S\RSR]` W\\]dOR]` [Vb

3(JX]dS\Sa S[^`S\RSR]`SaJ8]dS\Sa 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa 3\ 0Z]UOZOfWO [Vb

3(JX]dS\Sa S[^`S\RSR]`SaJ=P`O A]QWOZ 0O\QOXO 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa >`]U`O[O RS T]`[OQW \ 0O\QOXO [Vb

3(JX]dS\Sa S[^`S\RSR]`SaJ7 >`S[W] 8 dS\Sa 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa A]QWOZSa [Vb

3(JX]dS\Sa S[^`S\RSR]`SaJ>]`bOZ RS 3[^`S\RSR]`Sa RS ZO 1][c\WROR RS ;OR`WR [Vb

eee S[^ZSObS\OdO``O Q][

eee Xc\bORSO\ROZcQ O Sa OdS``]Sa QcZbc`OMS[^`S\RSR]`O

eee ^`]gSQb]QO`OPSZOa Sa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

eee OUS\QWOWRSO Sa

Vbb^( SXS dOZ\OZ]\SRcQO Q][

Vbb^( eSPa aSTSR Sa

eee S[^`S\RSX]dS\ Q][

Vbb^( eee \SP`WXO Q][ \SP`WXO PPdO S[^`S\RSR]`Sa W\RSf Vb[Z

Vbb^( Q]P`O\RSR S[^`S\RSR]`ffW Sa Vb[Z UcWO Vb[

Vbb^( eee [cXS`OQbWdO \Sb

Vbb^( eee WQ] Sa eSP Q]\bS\WR]a % W\RSf-\+

eee PO\QOXO Sa

Vbb^( eee O S[^`S\RS \Sb

Vbb^( eee g]cbVOQbW]\\Sb ]`U W\RSf ^V^-TcaS+W\abWbcbSa aQ]^S+\ObW]\OZ \O[S+A^OW\

Vbb^( Sc`]^O Sc W\b Q][[ S\bS`^`WaS S\b`S^`S\Sc`aVW^ OQbW]\M^ZO\ Vb[

Vbb^( eee W^g[S ]`U 7>G;3 Sa 3A :/25>G;3

Vbb^( eee QRbW Sa eSP12B7 Sa^ W\RSf Vb[Z

Vbb^( eee Q]TWRSa Sa

Vbb^( eee O\QSa Q][ eSP W\RSf& Vb[

Vbb^( eee WS SRc US[ `SacZbOR]a Vb[Z

Vbb^( eee S[^`S\RSR]`ffW Q][

Vbb^( eee QWORS ]`U

Vbb^( eee S[^`S\RSZ] Sa

Vbb^( eee QWRS[ Q][ QWRS[ Sa SZQWRS[ W\T] W\RSf Xa^

Vbb^( eee Xc\bORSO\ROZcQWO Sa W\\]dOQW]\QWS\QWOgS[^`SaO QORS

Vbb^( eee QO[O`OZWQO\bS Q][ >@=>

Vbb^( eee W[^WdO Sa

Vbb^( eee S\WaO Sa

Vbb^( eee WdOX Sa

Vbb^( eee OSQW Sa

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

9D8JB:CIDH

/ZSXO\RÒ 0]\W /`WabWhtPOZ 5`c^] RS 3abcRW]a S\ 2SaO``]ZZ] 1]]^SÒQW \ 7\bS`\OQW]\OZ g pbWQO /^ZWQORO 2SÔ`bO[S\b] RS >`]gSQb]a RS 7\US\WS` O 3BA77 C\WdSàWROR >]ZWb{Q\WQO RS DOZS\QWO

3dO /RO[ >WQOh] 5`c^] RS 7\dSabWUOQW \ 27//: 2W[S\aW \ 7\bS`QcZbcÒZ g /^`S\RWhOXS /QbWd] RS ZO :S\UcO 2SÔ`bO[S\b] RS :W\U abWQO /^ZWQORO 3BA711> C\WdSàWROR >]ZWb{Q\WQO RS dOZS\QWO

G^Zh\d! YZhVggdaad n XddeZgVX^ c ^ciZgcVX^dcVa# 8dcigVhiVcYd k^h^dcZh YZhYZ adh Ydh aVYdh YZ aV XddeZgVX^ c &

3\ SabS O`b QcZ] dO[]a O OP]`RO` ZOa RWabW\bOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa _cS aS bWS\S\ RSZ `WSaU] S\ SZ QO[^] RS ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] DS`S[]a b`Sa O^`]fW[OQW]\Sa RWTS`S\bSa( S\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` ZO Q]\QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] [ta SfbS\RWRO S\ ZOa [Sb]R]Z]U Oa _cS ]`WS\bO\ ZOa W\bS`dS\QW]\Sa S\ ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ Q][] a]\ SZ S\T]_cS RSZ [O`Q] Z UWQ] ] ZO USabW \ POaORO S\ `SacZbOR]a 3\ aSUc\R] ZcUO` O\OZWhO`S[]a Q [] aS ^S`QWPS SZ `WSaU] ^]` Z]a ^`]bOU]\WabOa RSZ RSaO``]ZZ]( Z]a g ZOa QWcRORO\]a g QWcRORO\Oa ^]P`Sa RS Z]a Ô aSa RSZ Ac` <]a RSbS\R`S[]a S\ RWdSà]a SabcRW]a g Ô`bWQcZO`[S\bS S\ ZOa Q]\QZcaW]\Sa RS :O d]h RS Z]a ^]P`Sa c\ bÒPOX] Oca^WQWOR] ^]` SZ 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ ASUcWRO[S\bS dS`S[]a Z] _cS ]^W\O\ RSZ `WSaU] aSWa X dS\Sa Q]]^SÒ\bSa SaÔ ]ZSa g bS`[W\O`S[]a Q]\bÒabO\R] aca dWaW]\Sa Q]\ ZOa ]bÒa dWaW]\Sa RSZ `WSaU] O\bS`W]`[S\bS [S\QW]\OROa :Oa Ocb]Òa _cWS`S\ OUÒRSQS` OZ 7<8CD3 g O ZOa Q]]`RW\OR]Òa RS SabS \ [S`] ac W\dWbOQW \ ÔÒ SaQ`WPW` SabS O`b QcZ] g O ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S\b`SdWabOROa ac O[OPZS Q]ZOP]ÒQW \ W[^`SaQW\RWPZS ÔÒ ZO `SOZWhOQW \ RS SabS bÒPOX]

>OZOPÒa QZOdS( @WSaU] X dS\Sa Q]]^SÒQW \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ RSaO``]ZZ] dcZ\SÒPWZWROR aSUc`WROR

2 SaO``]ZZ] g Q]]^S`OQW \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ C\O RWabW\QW \ \SQSaO`WO

<]a Ô`SQS `SZSdO\bS SabO RWabW\QW \ gO _cS Q][] VS[]a OÙc[S\bOR] S\ ]b`]a SaÔQW]a 0]\W Sb OZ &) >S`Wa Sb OZ & RS [O\SÒ US\SÒZ S\ SZ RSPObS a]P`S ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] S\ 3aÔ O g S\ Ô`bWQcZO` S\ Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa RS ^]aUÒR] _cS T]`[O\ O Z]a Sa^SQWOZWabOa SaÔ ]ZSa \] aS SabcRWO\ Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] ] RSZ acPRSaO``]ZZ] aW\] c\O RS ZOa ac^cSabOa a]ZcQW]\Sa S W\ab`c[S\b]a ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ <]a Ô`SQS c\O dWaW \ b`S[S\RO[S\bS `SRcQQW]\WabO _cS ^cSRS ^`]d]QO` _cS S\ \cSab`] Ô a \] SfWabO c\O aS`WO ^`]PZS[ObWhOQW \ RSZ [c\R] RS ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ ^cSab] _cS S\ ZO OQORS[WO SaS [c\R] Sa OZU] µROR]¶

>OÒ W\b`]RcQW` ZO `STZSfW \ _cS a]P`S SZ `WSaU] aS VOQS S\ SZ t[PWb] RS ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] Q`SS[]a Q]\dS\WS\bS `SOZWhO` c\O ^`W[SÒ RWTS`S\QWOQW \ S\b`S Z] _cS aS S\bWS\RS ^]` Q]]^SÒQW \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ g Z] _cS aS Q]\]QS Q][] RSaO``]ZZ] :O ^`W[SÒ aS Q`SO S\ Z]a O ]a # ÔÒ VOQS` T`S\bS O ZOa RSaWUcOZRORSa S\b`S Ô aSa Q]\aWRSÒR]a RSaO``]ZZOR]a PtaWQO[S\bS Z]a Ô aSa [ta W\Rcab`WOZWhOR]a Q]\ [Og]` RSaO``]ZZ] SQ]\ [WQ] g [cQV]a RS SZZ]a ^]bS\QWOa Q]Z]\WOZSa RS ZO aSUc\RO ]ZSORO Q]Z]\WhOR]Ò Sc`]^SO g Z]a RS[ta Q]\aWRSÒR]a acPRSaO``]ZZOR]a ] S\ d Oa RS RSaO``]ZZ] 5 [Sh g AO\OVcXO '''( % ZO RSTW\S\ Q][] c\ Q]\Xc\b] RS OQbcOQW]\Sa `SOZWhOROa ^]` OQb]`Sa ^ PZWQ]a g ^`WdOR]a S\b`S Ô aSa RS RWTS`S\bS \WdSZ RS `S\bO Q]\ SZ ^`]^ aWb] RS ^`][]dS` SZ ^`]U`Sa] SQ]\ [WQ] g a]QWOZ RS Z]a Ô aSa RSZ Ac` RS []R] _cS aSO [ta S_cWZWPÒR] S\ `SZOQW \ Q]\ SZ <]`bS g `SacZbS a]abS\WPZS 2S\b`] RS ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ VOg c\O cZbS`W]` RWTS`S\QWOQW \ _cS Sa ZO RS /gcRO =TWQWOZ OZ 2SaO``]ZZ] /=2 ASU \ ZO RSTW\WQW \ _cS SabOPZSQS SZ 1][Wb{ RS /gcRO OZ 2SaO``]ZZ] RS ZO =ÙO\WhOQW \ ÔÒ ZO 1]]^SÒQW \ g SZ 2SaO``]ZZ] 3Q]\ [WQ] ZO /=2 ZO Q]\abWbcgS\ Z]a TZcX]a _cS ZOa OUS\QWOa ]TWQWOZSa W\QZcWR]a Z]a U]PWS`\]a SabObOZSa g Z]QOZSa ] aca OUS\QWOa SXSQcbWdOa RSabW\O\ O Z]a Ô aSa S\ RSaO``]ZZ] g O ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa [cZbWZObSÒZSa g _cS S\ QORO ]^SÒQW \ aObWaTOQS\ ZOa aWUcWS\bSa Q]\RWQW]\Sa( O bWS\S\ Q][] ^`W\QWÔZ ]PXSbWd] ZO ^`][]QW \ RSZ RSaO``]ZZ]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

SQ]\ [WQ] g SZ PWS\SabO` RS Z]a Ô aSa S\ RSaO``]ZZ] g P a]\ RS QO`tQbS` Q]\QSaW]\OZ g Q]\bWS\S\ c\ SZS[S\b] RS R]\OQW \ RS OZ [S\]a SZ # :O /=2 aS QO\OZWhO O bÒd{a RS RWabW\b]a W\ab`c[S\b]a Q][] a]\ ZO OgcRO TW\O\QWSÒ ZO OgcRO b{Q\WQO ZO OgcRO OZW[S\bO`WO ] ZO OgcRO Vc[O\WbO`WO 3Z aSUc\R] Q]\QS^b] Sa SZ RS RSaO``]ZZ] 3abO[]a RS OQcS`R] Q]\ 2cP]Wa _cS a]abWS\S _cS aS bÒbO RS c\ Q]\QS^b] _cS \] ^cSRS aS` RSTW\WR] RS [O\SÒ ObS[^]ÒZ aW\] _cS aS ZZS\O RS Q]\bS\WR] VWab `WQO[S\bS 1ORO a]QWSROR g QORO {^]QO bWS\S\ ac ^`]^WO T]`[cZOQW \ RS _c{ Sa SZ RSaO``]ZZ] _cS `Sa^]\RS O ZOa Q]\dWQQW]\Sa Sf^SQbObWdOa g ^]aWPWZWRORSa _cS ^`SR][W\O\ S\ SZZOa 3\ RSTW\WbWdO SZ Q]\QS^b] RS RSaO``]ZZ] aS `SZOQW]\O Q]\ ZO WRSO RS Tcbc`] _cS aS ^`SaS\bO Q][] [SbO ÔÒ SZ Q]ZSQbWd] Vc[O\] 2cP]Wa ( %$ BÒRWQW]\OZ[S\bS SZ RSaO``]ZZ] VO aWR] OP]`ROR] RSaRS ZO RWaQW^ZW\O SQ]\ [WQO Oc\_cS Q]\ ZO W``c^QW \ RS Q]\QS^b]a Q][] SZ RSaO``]ZZ] Vc[O\] ] SZ RSaO``]ZZ] a]abS\WPZS S\ Z]a O ]a ' ] ZO Q]\b`WPcQW \ RS ]bÒa RWaQW^ZW\Oa Q][] ZO O\b`]^]Z]U O ZO QWS\QWO ^]Z bWQO ] ZO Sb\]UÒT O S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR aS `SQ]\]QS _cS SZ RSaO``]ZZ] ÔÒ aS` RSTW\WR] Q][] bOZ VO RS aS` Vc[O\] g {abS VO RS W\QZcW` ZOa aWUcWS\bSa aSWa RW[S\aW]\Sa 5]cZSb ( ' ( c\ Q][^]\S\bS SQ]\ [WQ] Q`SOQW \ RS `W_cShO g [SX]`Sa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS dWRO RWab`WPcWROa Q]\ S_cWROR c\ W\U`SRWS\bS a]QWOZ [SRWR] S\ b{`[W\]a RS PWS\SabO` S\ [ObS`WOZ RS aOZcR dWdWS\RO g S[^ZS] c\O RW[S\aW \ ^]Z bWQO _cS OPO`_cS dOZ]`Sa bOZSa Q][] Z]a RS`SQV]a Vc[O\]a ZO ZWPS`bOR ^]Z bWQO SbQ c\ SZS[S\b] QcZbcÒZ _cS `SQ]\]hQO SZ VSQV] RS _cS ZOa QcZbcÒa Q]\TWSÒ\ WRS\bWROR g Ocb]SabW[O O ZOa ^Sà]\Oa c\ [SRW] O[PWS\bS aO\] g c\O dWRO ^ZS\O aWabS[Oa g Q`SS\QWOa aW[P ZWQOa S\ QcO\b] OZ aWU\WTWQOR] ZbW[] RS ZO dWRO

! :O USabW \ POaORO S\ `SacZbOR]a OÔ`SQS Q][] c\] RS Z]a ^WZO`Sa RS ZO 2SQZOÒQW \ RS >O` a RS # R]Qc[S\b] ^`]UÒ[tbWQ] _cS `SQ]US SZ Q][^`][Wa] RS Ô aSa R]\O\bSa g `SQS^b]`Sa ÔÒ ZO [SX]Ò RS ZO STWQOQWO RS ZO OgcRO 2Wa^]\WPZS S\ Vbb^( eee e]`ZRPO\Y ]Ù VO`[]\WhObW]\ >O`Wa >O`Wa2SQZOÒbW]\AÔ\WaV ^RT ITSQVO RS Q]\acZbO & RS ]QbcP`S RS &K

/ Z]a STSQb]a RS ZO RWaQcaW \ a]P`S Z] _cS aS S\bWS\RS ^]` `WSaU] ZO RWTS`S\QWO S\b`S Q]]^SÒQW \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ g RSaO``]ZZ] \] Sa S\ OPa]Zcb] POZOR ^cSab] _cS aW O\OZWhO[]a Q][] aS OP]`RO SZ `WSaU] S\ SZ QO[^] RS Z]a W\ab`c[S\b]a RS ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ S\Q]\bÒ`S[]a c\O dWaW \ RSZ `WSaU] [cQV] [ta bSQ\]Q`tbWQO [ta US`S\QWOZWabO QS\bÒRO PtaWQO[S\bS S\ ZOa ^]aWPWZWROR RS µO[W\]ÒQW \¶ RSZ [Wa[] S\ ZO USabW \ RS ZOa W\bS`dS\QW]\Sa RS RSaO``]ZZ] >]` SXS[^Z] aW ]PaS`dO[]a Q [] Q]\bS[^ZO SZ `WSaU] SZ S\T]_cS RSZ [O`Q] Z UWQ] ZO [Sb]R]Z]U O [ta SfbS\RWRO ÔÒ ZO `SOZWhOQW \ RS Z]a ^`]gSQb]a g ^`]UÒ[Oa RS RSaO``]ZZ] S\ b]R] SZ [c\R] S\Q]\bÒ[]a _cS Z]a `WSaU]a aS RSTW\S\ Q][] TOQb]`Sa QZOdS _cS SaQOÔ\ RSZ Q]\b`]Z RS ZO US`S\QWO RSZ ^`]gSQb] g _cS bWS\S\ SZ ^]bS\QWOZ RS W[ÔQbO` RS [O\SÒ \SUObWdO S\ SZ ^`]gSQb] 3c`]ÔWR "( ! >]` SZZ] aS acUWS`S `SOZWhO` c\ ORSQcOR] O\tZWaWa g USabW \ RS Z]a `WSaU]a ÔÒ _cS ZO W\bS`dS\QW \ aSO aObWaTOQb]`WO =b`] SXS[^Z] Z] bS\S[]a S\ ZO [Sb]R]Z]U O _cS aS `SQ][WS\RO S\ ZO `ST]`[O RSZ aWabS[O RS OgcRO OZ RSaO``]ZZ]( ZO USabW \ POaORO S\ `SacZbOR]a ! 3\ c\O `SQWS\bS ^cPZWQOQW \ _cS `SQ]US PcS\Oa ^`tQbWQOa _cS aWUcS\ SabO b{Q\WQO =123 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ $ aS W\dWbO O :]a US`S\bSa RS ZOa W\bS`dS\QW]\Sa ÔÒ _cS caS\ SabÒbSUWOa RS SdOZcOQW \ RS `WSaU]a g RS USabW \ RS `WSaU]a ÔÒ OaSUcÒàS RS _cS b]R]a Z]a W\bS`SaOR]a RW`SQb]a Q][^`S\RO\ Z]a `WSaU]a _cS ^`]POPZS[S\bS OTSQbS\ SZ Z]U`] RS Z]a `SacZbOR]a g ÔÒ OgcRO`ZSa O _cS bÒPOXS\ Xc\b]a ÔÒ S\QOÒ` Sab]a `WSaU]a ^ I¬K OaW[Wa[] aS acPÒgO _cS ZO SdOZcOQW \ RS `WSaU]a RcÒ\bS SZ ^`]QSa] RS W[^ZS[S\bOQW \ OaSUcÒ _cS aS b][S\ S\ QcS\bO Z]a TOQb]`Sa _cS ^cSRS\ OTSQbO` SZ Z]U`] RS `SacZbOR]a g S\ Q]\aSQcS\QWO _cS aS OXcabS\ Z]a W\ac[]a ^

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

RSTW\WR] Sf O\bS g SabcRWOR] Q][] a]ZcQW \ OZU] _cS VOg _cS O^`S\RS` O VOQS` aW\ _cS aS ÔaS ^]` c\ SaQ`cbW\W] aS`W] g ^ZcÒZWabO RS ZO \ObcÒZShO RS Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa Qcg] S\T`S\bO[WS\b] []bWd ZO W\dS\QW \ RSZ ^`]^W] aWabS[O RS Q]]^SÒQW \

3\ SZ QO[^] RS ZO OgcRO Vc[O\WbO`WO aS ]PaS`dO c\O Q]\QS^QW \ RSZ `WSaU] [ta O[^ZWO _cS ZO _cS ^]RS[]a O^`SQWO` S\ ZOa W\bS`dS\QW]\Sa RS RSaO``]ZZ] AW\ RcRO SZ QO`tQbS` RWabW\bWd] RS ZO OgcRO Vc[O\WbO`WO QOÒQbS`WhORO ^]` ZOa W\bS`dS\QW]\Sa S\ QOa]a RS RSaOab`Sa RSaS\QORS\OR]a PWS\ ^]` QObtab`]TSa \ObcÒZSa ] PWS\ ^]` Q]\TZWQb]a O`[OR]a R]\RS SZ `WSaU] g ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR Sabt\ [cg ^`SaS\bSa VOQS _cS Sab]a b{`[W\]a VOgO\ `SQWPWR] c\O ObS\QW \ Sa^SQWOZ /a aS VOPZO RS `WSaU] RS RSaOab`Sa Q][] ^`]RcQb] RS ZOa O[S\OhOa g ZOa dcZ\SÒPWZWRORSa :Oa O[S\OhOa aS RSTW\S\ Q][] SZ TS\ [S\] \ObcÒZ ] Vc[O\] _cS S\ QOa] RS ^`]RcQWàS OTSQbO \SUObWdO[S\bS O ZOa ^Sà]\Oa g ac [SRW] I[WS\bÒa _cSK ZOa dcZ\SÒPWZWRORSa RSaQ`WPS\ SZ UÒR] S\ _cS c\ aWabS[O a]QW]SQ]\ [WQ] ZOa ^Sà]\Oa g ZOa TO[WZWOa a]\ acaQS^bWPZSa OZ W[ÔQb] RS ^]aWPZSa O[S\OhOa @Sg g CÙ]WbW #( ! <]a OQS`QO[]a O Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa RSZ `WSaU] [S\]a bSQ\]Q`tbWQOa Oc\_cS RSPWR] O _cS O ZO V]Ò RS ^ZO\WTWQO` ZOa OQQW]\Sa RS OgcRO Vc[O\WbO`WO aS aWUcS cbWZWhO\R] c\O [Sb]R]Z]U O ^`tQbWQO[S\bS aW[WZO` OZ S\T]_cS RSZ [O`Q] Z UWQ] d]ZdS[]a O S\Q]\bÒ`\]a Q]\ c\O RW[S\aW \ RSZ `WSaU] ^`]^WO RSZ S\T]_cS ]`b]R]f] RS Z]a ^`]gSQb]a 4S``S`] & ( `WSaU]a O Z]a _cS SZ ^`]gSQb] RSPS S\T`S\bOàS g _cS S\ QOa] RS ^`]RcQWàS ^cSRS\ RO` OZ bÒabS Q]\ SZ [Wa[] @Sg g CÙ]WbW #( #& I ¬ K ZO SdOZcOQW \ RSPS`t SabcRWO` Q [] aS VO VSQV] SZ aSUcW[WS\b] g ZO USabW \ RS `WSaU]a ^]` Ô`bS RS Z]a `Sa^]\aOPZSa RS ZO SXSQcQW \ RSZ ^`]gSQb] @Sg g CÙ]WbW #( ! AW\ S[POÙ] ZO USabW \ RS ZO OgcRO Vc[O\WbO`WO W\Q]`^]Ò ]bÒ RW[S\aW \ RSZ `WSaU] _cS \] OÔ`SQS S\ ]b`]a W\ab`c[S\b]a RS ZO Q]]^SÒQW \( ZO WRSO RSZ `WSaU] OZ _cS aS S\T`S\bO SZ ^Sà]\OZ Vc[O\WbO`W] S\ ac bÒPOX] 3a SabO c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO RWTS`S\bS RSZ `WSaU] _cS bO[^]Q] OÔ`SQS`t S\ ZOa RWaQcaW]\Sa a]P`S SZ `WSaU] [ta ^`]^WOa RS Z]a SabcRW]a RS RSaO``]ZZ] g _cS `Sb][O`S[]a ^]abS`W]`[S\bS QcO\R] O\OZWQS[]a ZOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa RSZ `WSaU] RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa S\b`SdWabOR]a Oa

@ WSaU] W\QS`bWRc[P`S dcZ\S`OPWZWROR S W\aSUc`WROR C\O SQcOQW \ _cS QO`OQbS`WhO O ZO ^]P`ShO

" >cSRS\ dSàS RWTS`S\bSa W\ab`c[S\b]a RS Z]a R]\O\bSa Q][] ZOa 3abÒbSUWOa RS @SRcQQW \ RS ZO >]P`ShO >]dS`bg @SRcQbW]\ AbÒbSUg >O^Sà S\ ac bS`[W\]Z]U O W\UZSaO RWa^]\WPZSa S\ ZO eSP RSZ 4]\R] ;]\SbO`W] 7\bS`\OQW]\OZ Vbb^( eee W[T ]Ù SfbS`\OZ <> ^à^ ^à^ Oa^ TSQVO RS Q]\acZbO $ RS ]QbcP`S RS &K g _cS `STZSXO\ ] OZ [S\]a RSPS` O\ bO\b] ZOa SabÒbSUWOa RS RSaO``]ZZ] RS Z]a Ô aSa RSZ Ac` Q][] ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RS Q]]^SÒQW \ RS Z]a R]\O\bSa ]TWQWOZSa PWZObSÒZSa g [cZbWZObSÒZSa

:O /US\RO 7\bS`\OQW]\OZ RSZ 2SaO``]ZZ] ZS ]b]ÙO OQbcOZ[S\bS c\O W[^]`bO\QWO acabO\QWOZ O ZO `SRcQQW \ RS ZO ^]P`ShO 2SaRS _cS S\ SZ O ] Z]a Ô aSa _cS Sabt\ `S^`SaS\bOR]a S\ ZO /aO[PZSO 5S\SÒZ RS <OQW]\Sa C\WROa acaQ`WPWSÒ\ ZO 2SQZOÒQW \ RSZ ;WZS\W] _cS Q]\bWS\S Z]a =PXSbWd]a RS 2SaO``]ZZ] RSZ ;WZS\W] S\ b]ROa ZOa Qc[P`Sa W\bS`\OQW]\OZSa 1]\TS`S\QWO RS ;]\bS``Sg RS 1c[P`S ;c\RWOZ a]P`S RSaO``]ZZ] a]abS\WPZS RS 8]VO\\SaPcÙ] RS 2SQZOÒQW \ RS >O` a RS # >`]UÒ[O RS /QQW \ RS /QQÒ RS & SbQ g S\ ZOa ^ZO\WTWQOQW]\Sa RS Z]a OQb]`Sa ^ PZWQ]a g ^`WdOR]a RSZ <]`bS g RSZ Ac` " ZO ZcQVO Q]\bÒ ZO ^]P`ShO ]QcÔ c\ ZcUO` ^`SS[W\S\bS 3\ ZO RSTW\WQW \ RS ZO ^]P`ShO Z]a `WSaU]a ZOa W\QS`bWRc[P`Sa ZO W\aSUc`WROR g ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR a]\ Q]\QS^b]a QS\bÒZSa 2c\QO\ &) E]]R !) 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ 3ab] ac^]\S VcW` RS ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a aW[^ZWabOa _cS [WRS\ ZO ^]P`ShO RS c\O [O\SÒ Sab`SQVO g SabtbWQO Q][] SZ QZtaWQ] c[PÒZ RS ^]P`ShO _cS aS RSbS`[W\O S\ Tc\QW \ RSZ W\U`Sa] ] `S\bO \SQSaO`W] ÔÒ _cS c\O ^Sà]\O ^cSRO a]P`SdWdW` g c\O dSh TWXOR] aS Q]\dWS`bS S\ ZO `STS`S\QWO ÔÒ RSbS`[W\O` _cW{\Sa a]\ ^]P`Sa 2cP]Wa ( "! C\O RSTW\WQW \ S\]`[S[S\bS acUS`S\bS O \cSab`] XcWQW] \]a ZO O^]`bO 5S]TT E]]R ! QcO\R] S\ZOhO ZO ^]P`ShO Q]\ ZOa W\QS`bWRc[P`Sa Q` \WQOa ZO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

W\QOÔQWROR ÔÒ VOQS` T`S\bS O SZZOa g SZ `WSaU] AS` ^]P`S aWU\WTWQO S\T`S\bOàS O c\O W\aSUc`WROR Q` \WQO \] O c\O W\aSUc`WROR dO`WOPZS ^cSab] _cS aS` ^]P`S W[^ZWQO ZO W\QOÔQWROR RS Q]\b`]ZO` Z]a SdS\b]a Tcbc`]a ^]`_c{ ]b`]a bWS\S\ [ta Q]\b`]Z a]P`S SZZ]a /aW[Wa[] a]abWS\S _cS ZO Q]\RWQW \ RSbS`[W\O\bS ÔÒ ZO US\bS ^]P`S S\ b]R] SZ [c\R] Sa ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S 3abOa W\QS`bWRc[P`Sa RS`WdO\ RS c\O W\SabOPWZWROR g d]ZObWZWROR US\SÒZ S\ S\b]`\]a ^]Z bWQ]a SQ]\ [WQ]a a]QWOZSa g []ÒZSa ^]` SZZ] µdWdW` S\ SabOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa W[^ZWQO `WSaU] g SZ `WSaU] aS Q][^]\S RS ZOa W\QS`bWRc[P`Sa OQS`QO RSZ Tcbc`] I¬K Z]a ^]P`Sa OZ [S\]a ^]` RSTW\WQW \ aS S\T`S\bO\ O [Og]`Sa W\QS`bWRc[P`Sa _cS ]b`]a BWS\S\ [S\]a Q]\b`]Z a]P`S ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa g Z]a SdS\b]a OZ`SRSR]` RS SZZ]a 3abt\ ]PZWUOR]a O dWdW` [ta S\ SZ ^`SaS\bS g RS [O\SÒ RWaQ]\bW\cO S\ SZ Tcbc`] 3Z dOZ]` _cS ZS RO\ OZ ^`SaS\bS SfQSRS SZ dOZ]` _cS bWS\S SZ RSZ Tcbc`] W\QWS`b] 3\ ]bÒa ÔZOPÒa ac ^`STS`S\QWO RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b] S\ SZ bWS[^] Sa S\ SZ ^`SaS\bS Z] _cS ZSa VOQS [ta dcZ\SÒPZSa ÔÒ SZ Tcbc`]¶ ^ "$& =bÒ ^Sà^SQbWdO W\bS`SaO\bS Sa ZO _cS O^]`bO 2c\QO\ 5`SS\ & _cS OÙc[S\bO _cS SZ `WSaU] OZ _cS aS S\T`S\bO c\ W\RWdWRc] ] c\O c\WROR TO[WZWO` ^]P`S aS ^cSRS S\bS\RS` Q][] c\O T `[cZO aW[^ZS @WSaU]+^SZWU`] f dcZ\SÒPWZWROR ^ !$ R]\RS dcZ\SÒPWZWROR RSaQ`WPS ZO QOÔQWROR `SRcQWRO RS OZUc\Oa Q][c\WRORSa ] c\WRORSa TO[WZWO`Sa ÔÒ ac^SÒ` Z]a SdS\b]a ] bS\aW]\Sa O Z]a _cS aS dS\ Sf^cSab]a ÔU !$ 3abO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR \] a Z] Sabt W\TZcWRO ^]` ZO ^`SaS\QWO RS W[ÔQb]a `S^S\bW\]a µSfbS`\]a¶ Z] _cS aS` O ZO QObtab`]TS a]P`SdS\WRO aW\] _cS bWS\S _cS dS` Q]\ TOQb]`Sa W\RWdWRcOZSa g a]QWOZSa Q][] SZ U{\S`] ZO SROR ZO RWaQOÔQWROR ZO Sb\WO ZO QOabO g Q]\ SZ ^]RS` `SZObWd] RS c\ W\RWdWRc] ] RS c\O Q][c\WROR ÔÒ RSTS\RS` aca W\bS`SaSa >]` bO\b] ZO dWRO RS ZO [Og]` O RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ^]P`Sa aS Q]\ab`cgS OZ`SRSR]` RS ZO WRSO RS OT`]\bO` SZ `WSaU] g Q]\ RS[OaWORO T`SQcS\QWO RWQV]a `WSaU]a ÔaO\ O aS` QObtab`]TSa ^Sà]\OZSa ] ÔÒ ZO a]QWSROR ^ !! :O [Og]` O RS RWQVOa QObtab`]TSa aS ^]R` O\ SdWbO` O bÒd{a RS c\O Q][PW\OQW \ RS ^`]bSQQW \ RSZ SabOR] ] RS ZO Q][c\WROR W\bS`\OQW]\OZ g RSZ T]`bOZSQW[WS\b] RS Z]a W\RWdWRc]a W[^ZWQOR]a c\O Q][PW\OQW \ Q]\]QWRO Q][] aSUc`WROR Vc[O\O ^ !! :]a ]ÙO\Wa[]a W\bS`\OQW]\OZSa Sa^SQWOZWhOR]a S\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] Q][] SZ 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ ] SZ >`]UÒ[O RS <OQW]\Sa C\WROa ÔÒ SZ 2SaO``]ZZ] ><C2 bO[PW{\ aS VO\ ]QcÔR] RS Q [] ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR g SZ `WSaU] OTSQbO\ O ZO W\aSUc`WROR Vc[O\O 2SabOQO[]a S\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` ZOa O^]`bOQW]\Sa RSZ ><C2 ÔÒ bS`[W\O` Q]\ ZOa _cS `SOZWhO SZ 0; 3Z 7\T]`[S a]P`S 2SaO``]ZZ] 6c[O\] RSZ ><C2 RS ''" OP]`RO ZO QcSabW \ RS ZO aSUc`WROR Vc[O\O RSTW\W{\R]ZO Q][] aSUc`WROR Q]\bÒ O[S\OhOa Q` \WQOa Q][] SZ VO[P`S ZO S\TS`[SROR g ZO `S^`SaW \ g ^`]bSQQW \ Q]\bÒ OZbSÒQW]\Sa a PWbOa g R]Z]`]aOa RS ZO dWRO Q]bWRWO\O gO aSO S\ SZ V]UO` S\ SZ S[^ZS] ] S\ ZO Q][c\WROR ^ $ :O aSUc`WROR Vc[O\O aS Q][^]\S RS RWTS`S\bSa RW[S\aW]\Sa _cS ^cSRS\ OU`cÔàS S\ aWSbS QObSU]` Oa ^`W\QWÔZSa( aSUc`WROR SQ]\ [WQO OZW[S\bO`WO S\ [ObS`WO RS aOZcR O[PWS\bOZ ^Sà]\OZ RS ZO Q][c\WROR g ^]Z bWQO <] SfWabS\ Sa^SQWOZSa `STS`S\QWOa OZ `WSaU] O ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR ] O ZO OcaS\QWO RS ^]RS` RS Z]a ^]P`Sa ÔÒ ^]RS` VOQS` T`S\bS O ZOa W\aSUc`WRORSa ^S`] S\ SZ RSPObS a]P`S SZ RSaO``]ZZ] SabS 7\T]`[S ac^ca] c\O O^]`bOQW \ `SZSdO\bS O ZO Q]\QS^bcOZWhOQW \ RS ZO aSUc`WROR S\T]_cS O[^ZW] RS ZO aSUc`WROR OZSXORO RS Z]a ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a [ta RSTS\aWd]a [WZWbO`WabOa _cS WRS\bWTWQO ZO aSUc`WROR Q]\ ZO ^`]bSQQW \ O\bS ZO dW]ZS\QWO T aWQO S\ Q]\bSfb]a RS Q]\TZWQb] >{`Sh RS /`[W ] %( $

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

3\ ac Â&#x2030;ZbW[] 7\T]`[S a]P`S 2SaO``]ZZ] 6c[O\] RSRWQOR] OZ QO[PW] QZW[tbWQ] SZ ><C2 W\QZcgS `STS`S\QWOa OZ `WSaU] g ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR ZWUt\R]Z]a OZ \WdSZ RS RSaO``]ZZ] Vc[O\] RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ^]P`Sa( SZ `WSaU] bWS\S `SZOQWÂ&#x201E;\ Q]\ ZO Sf^]aWQWÂ&#x201E;\ O ^SZWU`]a Sfb`S[]a a]P`S Z]a QcOZSa ZOa ^Sà]\Oa bWS\S\ SaQOa] Q]\b`]Z ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR Sa c\O [SRWRO RS ZO QOÔQWROR RS [O\SXO` RWQV]a ^SZWU`]a aW\ acT`W` c\O ^{`RWRO RS PWS\SabO` ^]bS\QWOZ[S\bS W``SdSàWPZS S\ SZ ZOÙ] ^ZOh] I K :]a ^`]QSa]a [SRWO\bS Z]a QcOZSa SZ `WSaU] aS bÒ\aT]`[O S\ dcZ\SÒPWZWROR S\ c\ Ô a aS USabO\ Q]\T]`[S OZ SabOR] acPgOQS\bS RS RSaO``]ZZ] Vc[O\] Q][] ZOa RSaWUcOZRORSa S\ SZ W\U`Sa] S\ ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa g S\ SZ ^]RS` ^]Z bWQ] _cS [OÙW\O\ O Z]a ^]P`Sa %( %' 3abO[]a O\bS c\O Q]\QS^QWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ `WSaU] ÂµSfb`S[OÂ¶ _cWhta []bWdORO ^]` SZ bS[O QS\bÒZ RSZ 7\T]`[S ^S`] W\RcROPZS[S\bS ZSXO\O RS SaO ÂµW\aSUc`WROR Q`Â&#x201E;\WQOÂ¶ RS ZO _cS VOPZOPO E]]R g O ZO _cS \]a `STS` O[]a OZ W\WQW] RS SabS OÔ`bOR] 3\ SZ SZ 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ RSRWQÂ&#x201E; ac 7\T]`[S /\cOZ O ZO :cQVO Q]\bÒ ZO >]P`ShO g S\ {Z aS Oa]QWO W\S_c d]QO[S\bS W\aSUc`WROR Q]\ Sf^]aWQWÂ&#x201E;\ O Z]a `WSaU]a pab]a aS RSTW\S\ Q][] SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS OQ]\bSQW[WS\b]a W\QWS`b]a _cS ^cSRS\ `SRc\RO` S\ RSb`W[S\b] RSZ PWS\SabO` ^ !' Sa RSQW` ^cSRS\ W\Q`S[S\bO` ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa 3abO[]a O\bS c\O Q]\QS^QWÂ&#x201E;\ ÂµSfbS`\OÂ¶ RSZ `WSaU]( OQ]\bSQW[WS\b]a a]P`SdS\WR]a Q`WaWa Q][] ZOa RS\][W\O SZ 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ _cS ^cSRS\ OTSQbO` O c\O ^Sà]\O a]ZO Q][] ZO S\TS`[SROR ] ZO [cS`bS O c\O Q][c\WROR O c\O `SUWÂ&#x201E;\ S W\QZca] O c\O \OQWÂ&#x201E;\ RSaOab`S \ObcÒZ Q`WaWa [OQ`]SQ]\Â&#x201E;[WQO ;ta OQS`bORO \]a Ô`SQS ZO aSUc\RO Q]\b`WPcQWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ RSRWQORO O `SQ]US` ZOa d]QSa RS Z]a ^]P`Sa <OÒgO\ Sb OZ AS bÒbO RS c\O RS ZOa [Og]`Sa W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa RS bW^] QcOZWbObWd] `SOZWhORO S\ SZ t[PWb] RS Z]a SabcRW]a a]P`S RSaO``]ZZ] gO _cS aS `SOZWhO`]\ S\b`SdWabOa O $" ^Sà]\Oa ^]P`Sa S\ " Ô aSa C\] RS Z]a bS[Oa `SQc``S\bSa RS SabOa S\b`SdWabOa TcS ZO RSTW\WQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS aSUc`WROR ZO RWTS`S\QWOQWÂ&#x201E;\ S\b`S aSUc`WROR S W\aSUc`WROR S\ Z]a V]UO`Sa Z]a TOQb]`Sa _cS VOQS\ _cS Z]a V]UO`Sa aSO\ [ta W\aSUc`]a SbQ :]a ^]P`Sa S\TObWhO`]\ ZO O\aWSROR g SZ [SRW] _cS Sf^S`W[S\bO\ ^]`_cS aS aWS\bS\ W\aSUc`]a g dcZ\SÒPZSa ;cQV]a RS SZZ]a a]abcdWS`]\ _cS aS aWS\bS\ [ta W\aSUc`]a g [ta dcZ\SÒPZSa _cS S\ {^]QOa ÔaOROa RSaQ`WPWS\R] ZO aSUc`WROR Q][] SabOPWZWROR Q]\bW\cWROR S\ aca [SRW]a RS dWRO ^`SdWaWPWZWROR S\ aca `SZOQW]\Sa aS\bW[WS\b] RS aSUc`WROR g ZO ^S`bS\S\QWO O c\ U`c^] a]QWOZ ^ # /aW[Wa[] aS ^ca] RS [O\WTWSab] ZO RWTS`S\QWO S\b`S Z]a UÒR]a RS aSUc`WROR S W\aSUc`WROR S\ Tc\QWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ aSf] g RS ZO `SUWÂ&#x201E;\ :Oa [cXS`Sa a]\ [ta dcZ\SÒPZSa ÔÒ acT`W` OPca]a g dW]ZS\QWO S\ SZ V]UO` QcO\R] S\dWcRO\ g S\ SZ ZcUO` RS bÒPOX] :]a V][P`Sa Ô`bWQcZO`[S\bS Z]a [ta XÂ&#x201E;dS\Sa a]\ [ta acaQS^bWPZSa RS aS` O``SabOR]a ^]` ZO ^]ZWQ O @S^`]RcQW[]a O Q]\bW\cOQWÂ&#x201E;\ Z]a SZS[S\b]a _cS RSTW\S\ ZO aS\aOQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS W\aSUc`WROR RS Z]a g ZOa ^]P`Sa Sa^SQWTWQO\R] OZUc\Oa RS ZOa WRSOa _cS aS ^caWS`]\ RS [O\WTWSab] RcÒ\bS ZOa S\b`SdWabOa( Â³ 7\aSUc`WRORSa S\ SZ bÒPOX] g S\ Z]a [SRW]a RS dWRO bWS`Ò dWdWS\RO W\U`Sa]a SbQ Â³ 2SaOab`Sa \ObcÒZSa g QOcaOR]a ^]` SZ U{\S`] Vc[O\] VcÒQO\Sa QO[PW]a S\ SZ QZW[O SbQ Â³ 1`W[S\ g dW]ZS\QWO RSaQ]\TWO\hO S\ ZO ^]ZWQ O dW]ZS\QWO S\ SZ V]UO` SbQ Â³ >SàSQcQWÂ&#x201E;\ ^]` ZO ^]ZWQ O g OcaS\QWO RS XcabWQWO dW]ZOQW]\Sa Vc[WZZOQW]\Sa QOcaOROa ^]` ZO ^]ZWQ O Q` [S\Sa _cS \] aS ^SàWUcS\ SbQ

8Â&#x201E;dS\Sa g USabWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ `WSaU]

³ 1]\TZWQb]a QWdWZSa g UcS`Òa ^{`RWRO RS b]R] Z] _cS bWS\S dOZ]` ^`]PZS[Oa S\ Z]a QO[^]a RS `STcUWOR]a SbQ ³ 1V]_cSa g Sab`SaSa QOcaOR]a ^]` Z]a QO[PW]a [OQ`] ^]Z bWQ]a ^{`RWRO RS dOZ]` RS ZO []\SRO TZcQbcOQW]\Sa RS ^`SQW]a RS ZOa [ObS`WOa ^`W[Oa SbQ ³ DcZ\SÒPWZWROR a]QWOZ Q][WRO `]Ô RWU\O bÒPOX]a RSQS\bSa SbQ ³ AOZcR S\TS`[SROR g [cS`bS \] ^]RS` RWa^]\S` RS PcS\O ObS\QW \ aO\WbO`WO aW\ RW\S`] D]ZdS`S[]a a]P`S SabOa OQS^QW]\Sa RSZ `WSaU] ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR g ZO W\aSUc`WROR [ta ORSZO\bS OZ Q][ÔÒ` ZOa `Sa^cSabOa RS Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa S\b`SdWabOR]a ÔÒ ZO `SOZWhOQW \ RS SabS bÒPOX] Q]\ Z] _cS O_c aS VO Sf^cSab]

! / ZUc\Oa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa RSZ `WSaU] RS Z]a X dS\Sa Q]]^SÒ\bSa SaÔ ]ZSa >OÒ ZO `SOZWhOQW \ RS SabS bÒPOX] aS S\b`SdWabO`]\ O aSWa X dS\Sa SaÔ ]ZSa QcgO OQbWdWROR OQbcOZ aS RSaO``]ZZO S\ SZ aSQb]` RS ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ :]a ^S`TWZSa RS Z]a aSWa S\b`SdWabOR]a g S\b`SdWabOROa a]\ Z]a aWUcWS\bSa( D # ( 7\US\WS`] 7\Rcab`WOZ # O ]a g \OQWR] S\ DOZS\QWO 2S ÔR`S ^`]TSa]` RS C\WdSàWROR g [OR`S ^`]TSa]Ò RS 7\abWbcb] 3abt TW\OZWhO\R] aca SabcRW]a RS ;OabS` S\ >]Z bWQOa g >`]QSa]a S\ RSaO``]ZZ] Q]\ c\O ^`tQbWQO W\bS`\OQW]\OZ S\ c\O =<5 OT`WQO\O RSRWQORO OZ RSaO``]ZZ] `cÒZ 3abt QcàO\R] SabcRW]a RS R]Qb]ÒR] g OQbcOZ[S\bS Sa PSQO`W] S\ c\ RSÔ`bO[S\b] c\WdSàWbO`W] RSRWQOR] O bS[Oa RS Q]]^SÒQW \ g RSaO``]ZZ] S\ 3aÔ O D % ( 7\US\WS`] 7\Rcab`WOZ % O ]a g \OQWR] S\ DOZS\QWO 2S ÔR`S ^`]TSa]` RS aSQc\RO`WO g O`bWabO ^ZtabWQ] g [OR`S ^`]TSa]Ò RS aSQc\RO`WO g âWQ Z]UO 1]\ RWdSàO T]`[OQW \ RS ^]aUÒR] S\ 1]]^SÒQW \ 7\bS`\OQW]\OZ g 2SaO``]ZZ] /QbcOZ[S\bS bÒPOXO\R] S\ c\O ]TWQW\O b{Q\WQO RS Q]]^SÒQW \ c\WdSàWbO`WO S\ 3aÔ O ; % !( A]QW Z]UO % O ]a g \OQWRO S\ 1]QS\bOW\O /ZWQO\bS 2S ÔR`S S[^ZSOR] RS PO\QO g [OR`S ^`]TSa]Ò RS ^`W[O`WO O[P]a XcPWZOR]a ;OabS` S\ 5{\S`] g 2SaO``]ZZ] g OQbcOZ[S\bS bÒPOXO\R] S\ c\O =ÙO\WhOQW \ <] 5cPS`\O[S\bOZ 7\bS`\OQW]\OZ RSRWQORO O ZO T]`[OQW \ g SRcQOQW \ RS ORcZb]a S\ SZ Q]\bW\S\bS OT`WQO\] R]\RS `SaWRS D & "( 7\US\WS`] RS =PÒa > PZWQOa g /`_cWbSQb] & O ]a 2S ÔR`S W\US\WS`] W\Rcab`WOZ g [OR`S âWQ Z]UO BS`[W\O\R] ac T]`[OQW \ RS ;OabS` S\ >]Z bWQOa g >`]QSa]a RS 2SaO``]ZZ] g RS\b`] RS SZZO O ^c\b] RS Q][S\hO` aca ^`tQbWQOa W\bS`\OQW]\OZSa S\ c\ ]ÙO\Wa[] [cZbWZObSÒZ S\ /[{`WQO :ObW\O ; ' #( 7\US\WSÒ /U` \][O ' O ]a 2S ÔR`S ac^S`dWa]` S\ S[^`SaO aWRS` ÙWQO g [OR`S OcfWZWO` RS S\TS`[S` O /QbcOZ[S\bS bÒPOXO\R] S\ c\O ]ÙO\WhOQW \ UcPS`\O[S\bOZ RS RSaO``]ZZ] S\ 3aÔ O ; # $( 7\US\WSÒ B{Q\WQO /U` Q]ZO # O ]a 2S ÔR`S 7\T]`[tbWQ] g [OR`S O[O RS QOaO :WQS\QWORO S\ 1WS\QWO g BSQ\]Z]U O RS /ZW[S\b]a g OQbcOZ[S\bS bS`[W\O\R] ac T]`[OQW \ Q]\ c\ ;OabS` S\ >]Z bWQOa g >`]QSa]a RS 2SaO``]ZZ] S\ c\ ]ÙO\Wa[] [cZbWZObSÒZ S\ 5cObS[OZO

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

2cÒ\bS ZO `SOZWhOQW \ RS ZOa S\b`SdWabOa aS OP]`RO`]\ R]a QcSabW]\Sa ^`W\QWÔZSa >]` c\ ZOR] aS ZSa ^`SUc\b ^]` ac []bWdOQW \ ÔÒ RSRWQOàS OZ QO[^] RS ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO ÔÒ SZZ] ac PW]UÒT O ^Sà]\OZ ^]aWPZS W\TZcS\QWO ] O\bSQSRS\bS TO[WZWO` Q`WaWa ^Sà]\OZ d]QOQW \ SbQ¬ <]a W\bS`SaO[]a bO[PW{\ ^]` SZ UÒR] RS O^]g] TO[WZWO` _cS VOP O\ `SQWPWR] S\ SabO SZSQQW \ :O aSUc\RO Ô`bS RS ZOa S\b`SdWabOa aS RSRWQ O Sf^Z]Ò` SZ bS[O QS\bÒZ _cS \]a ]QcÔ Sa RSQW` Q [] Z]a g ZOa X dS\Sa Q]]^SÒ\bSa S\bWS\RS\ g ^S`QWPS\ SZ `WSaU]( _c{ ac^]\S ÔÒ SZZ]a g ZOa ^]aWPZSa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RS`WdOROa RSZ [Wa[] >OaO[]a O Q]\bW\cOQW \ O O\OZWhO` SZ Q]\bS\WR] RS ZOa S\b`SdWabOa aWUcWS\R] SabO [Wa[O Sab`cQbcÒ ! > ]`_c{ RSQWRS\ bÒPOXO` S\ SabS QO[^] g QctZ Sa SZ O^]g] TO[WZWO` _cS `SQWPS\ 3[^SQS[]a Q]\ D # [cg ^`S]QcÔR] RSaRS ZO W\TO\QWO ^]` ZO ZcQVO Q]\bÒ ZO W\XcabWQWO 2S ac TO[WZWO ZS dWS\S c\O SRcQOQW \ Q`WabWO\O Q]\ aS\aWPWZWROR S W\bS`{a ^]` Sab]a bS[Oa 2S ac VS`[O\] ZS dWS\S SZ Sab [cZ] RS Z]a aQ]cba 2S OV aca ^`W[SÒa Sf^S`WS\QWOa RS d]Zc\bO`WOR] VOQWS\R] O^]g]a S\ [ObS[tbWQOa S\ ZO Ô``]_cWO RS ac PO``W] 3ab] ZS ZZSdO ^]abS`W]`[S\bS O c\O =ÙO\WhOQW \ <] 5cPS`\O[S\bOZ RS 2SaO``]ZZ] =<52 ObÒ R] ^]` ZO OQQW \ ^]Z bWQO ZZSdORO O QOP] ^]` SZ ]ÙO\Wa[] >]` ZbW[] aS OZO` _cS ZO T]`[OQW \ c\WdSàWbO`WO `SQWPWRO S\ bS[Oa RS Q]]^SÒQW \ g ac W\bS`{a ^]` ^]RS` bÒPOXO` ^]abS`W]`[S\bS S\ ZO [Wa[O c\WdSàWROR bO[PW{\ VO\ ac^cSab] c\O TcS\bS RS []bWdOQW \ W[^]`bO\bS 3\ `SZOQW \ Q]\ SZ O^]g] TO[WZWO` D # aS aWS\bS [cg O^]gOR] Oc\_cS a _cS aca ÔR`Sa [O\WTWSabO\ QWS`bO ^`S]QcÔQW \ ^]` Z]a dWOXSa( [W TO[WZWO [S VO QcSabW]\OR] S\ OZUc\O ]QOaW \ aW Sa c\O PcS\O ]^QW \ ^Sà]\OZ g Z] RS Z]a dWOXSa \] ZSa VOQS \W\Uc\O UÒQWO Oc\_cS bO[PW{\ RS^S\RS RS Qct\b] bWS[^] dWdO TcSÒ 3abS Sa c\] RS Z]a []bWd]a _cS ZZSdO\ O D # O ^`STS`W` SabOPZSQSàS S\ c\ t[PWb] c\WdSàWbO`W] SaÔ ]Z S\ ZcUO` RS bÒPOXO` S\ SZ bS``S\] S\ c\O =<52 ] S\ c\ ]ÙO\Wa[] W\bS`\OQW]\OZ ; # $ `SQ]\]QS ac d]QOQW \ ^]` Z] a]QWOZ RSaRS [cg ^S_cS O ³a{ _cS VOg OZU] [OZ RWab`WPcWR] S\ SabS [c\R] [S UcabO` O aOPS` _c{ ^cSR] VOQS` g] BO[PW{\ ]^W\O _cS ac SRcQOQW \ S\ c\ Q]ZSUW] RS []\XOa VO ^]RWR] W\TZcW` S\ ac RSaO``]ZZ] ^Sà]\OZ a]P`S b]R] RcÒ\bS ZO µQ`WaWa¶ _cS Sf^S`W[S\b S\ ac [][S\b] OZ ^ZO\bSOàS \] bO\b] Z] _cS g] ^cSR] RO` OZ [c\R] aW\] _c{ Q][^`][Wa] bS\U] g] Q]\ {Z ^]` c\O QcSabW \ RS XcabWQWO ] RS S_cWROR @]RSORO RS TO[WZWOa Q]\aS`dOR]Òa ac S\b]`\] VOPWbcOZ RSZ Q]ZSUW] ZS T]`XO c\ aS\bWR] RS ZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR ^]` VOQS` ZOa Q]aOa PWS\ `SacZbOR] RS ac SRcQOQW \ ` UWRO g Sab`WQbO >]` ]bÒ Ô`bS SZ RSaS] RS aOZW` RS Z]a Q `QcZ]a RS US\bS _cS \] ZS []bWdOPO\ S\ SaS [][S\b] \W ^]` ZOa Q]\dSàOQW]\Sa \W ^]` Z]a RWaQcà]a \W ^]` \ORO c\WR] O ZO WRSO RS _cS ZO dWRO _cS SabOPO dWdWS\R] \] SÒ ZO _cS `SOZ[S\bS RSaSOPO ZS ZZSdO O QS\bÒàS S\ Q]\]QS` Q `QcZ]a RS ^Sà]\Oa Q]\ c\O [O\SÒ RS ^S\aO` RWTS`S\bS RS ZO _cS aS VOP O S\Q]\bÒR] VOabO SaS [][S\b] / Ô`bW` RS OV S[^WShO O T]`[OàS Rt\R]aS QcS\bO RS _cS c\O dSh _cS S[^WShOa gO \] ^cSRSa aOZW` @Sa^SQb] OZ O^]g] TO[WZWO` SZ VSQV] RS aS` VWXO \WQO \] ZS VO TOQWZWbOR] ZOa Q]aOa O ; # $ VOabO SZ ^c\b] RS _cS b]ROd O V]g aWUcS\ aW\ S\bS\RS`ZO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

RSZ b]R] ^]` RSXOàS W\TZcS\QWO` _cWht ^]` ZO dWaWย \ _cS bWS\S ZO US\bS a]P`S SabOa QcSabW]\Sa( ยฆ/g _c{ PWS\ a]ZWRO`WO _c{ PcS\O ^Sà]\O 3abt [cg PWS\ _cS _cWSÒ QO[PWO` SZ [c\R] Oc\_cS b]ROd O Sa [cg X]dS\ g \] aOPS O _c{ aS bWS\S _cS S\T`S\bO` B]ROd O bWS\S [cQV]a WRSOZSa S\ ZO QOPShO gO ZZSUO`t SZ [][S\b] SZ _cS bS\UO _cS aS\bO` ZO QOPShO ZZSUO`t c\ ^c\b] S\ SZ _cS bS\R`t _cS \]`[OZWhO` ac aWbcOQWย \ T]`[O` c\O TO[WZWO SbQ 1]\ `Sa^SQb] O ZOa O[WabORSa QORO dSh OQS^bO [ta ZO SbW_cSbO _cS ZS ^]\S ac S\b]`\] aW\ bÒbO` RS RSTS\RSàS Q][] Z] VOQ O OZ ^`W\QW^W]( \] \] Sa _cS g] aSO PcS\O \W a]ZWRO`WO Sa c\O aW[^ZS QcSabWย \ RS XcabWQWO g b]R]a RSPS` O[]a VOQS` Sab] 1cO\R] Q][^`S\RSa g OQS^bOa _cS ZO `SOZWROR Sa ]bÒ aWUcSa aW\bWS\R] [cQV] QO`Wย ] ^]` SZZ]a Q][^`S\RSa g Q][^`S\RS\ _cS aW[^ZS[S\bS VO\ ]^bOR] ^]` c\Oa dWROa b]bOZ[S\bS RWTS`S\bSa O ZO [ O Oc\_cS WUcOZ[S\bS `Sa^SbOPZSa /gcRO` O Z]a RS[ta ac Ô`bWQWÔQWย \ S\ =<52a S\ Q]ZSQbWd]a c\WdSàWbO`W]a Q]\ W\bS`SaSa a]QWOZSa c\WR] O ac T]`[OQWย \ c\WdSàWbO`WO S\ QcSabW]\Sa OTW\Sa VO\ aWR] S\ SZ QOa] RS D % QZOdSa S\ ac []abÒR] W\bS`{a ^]` RSRWQOàS OZ QO[^] RS ZO Q]]^SÒQWย \ Ac S\b]`\] TO[WZWO` VO aWR] b]bOZ[S\bS TOd]ÒPZS g RSaRS [cg ^`]\b] `SQWPWย b]R] SZ O^]g] ÔÒ Ô`bWQWÔ` S\ =<52 g dWOXO`( aWS[^`S VO\ `Sa^SbOR] [W ]^QWย \ VOabO SZ ^c\b] _cS OV]Ò a]\ [Wa ÔR`Sa Z]a _cS aS VO\ S\UO\QVOR] OZ QO[^] RS ZOa =<52a ASUย \ ; % ! SZ bS[O RS ZO RSaWUcOZROR <]`bS Ac` VO ac^cSab] RSaRS ac W\TO\QWO SZ TOQb]` RSbS`[W\O\bS ÔÒ _cS`SàS RSRWQO` ^`]TSaW]\OZ[S\bS O ZcQVO` Q]\bÒ SabS TS\ย [S\] Oc\_cS aW\ RcRO ac bÒPOX] RS d]Zc\bO`WO ]ÙO\WhOQW]\Sa \] UcPS`\O[S\bOZSa g S\ Q]ZSQbWd]a QcZbcÒZSa bO[PW{\ >]` ]bÒ Ô`bS ac S\b]`\] TO[WZWO` VO Q]\b`WPcWR] RS OZUc\O [O\SÒ( RS [W b O \OQWย ZO ^`]^cSabO RS VOQS` d]Zc\bO`WOR] S\ ย g ! ย RS 0C> >OÒ D & " \] VO VOPWR] \W\Uย \ OQ]\bSQW[WS\b] WZc[W\OR]` aW\] c\O aS\aWPWZWROR c\O W\_cWSbcR _cS VO WR] P`]bO\R] RSaRS ZO \Wย Sh a]P`S c\ bS[O _cS \] Sa bO\ T`SQcS\bS g _cS ZcSU] dOa QO\OZWhO\R] 1WS`b] Sa _cS Q]\ SZ bWS[^] TcS OR_cW`WS\R] [ta W\T]`[OQWย \ VOQWS\R] Qcà]a g ^ÒQbWQO\R] S\ OZUc\Oa =<52a Ac S\b]`\] TO[WZWO` VO aWR] RSQWaWd] gO _cS bO\b] ac [OR`S âWQย Z]UO Q][] ac VS`[O\] âW_cWObÒ VO\ RSRWQOR] g RSRWQO\ ac dWRO O ZO OgcRO Vc[O\WbO`WO RSaRS aca ^`]^WOa ^`]TSaW]\Sa g OQbWbcRSa VOQWO Z]a RS[ta GO aca ÔR`Sa S\ Z]a Oย ]a % T]`[O`]\ Ô`bS RS SaS Q]ZSQbWd] VW^^WS ^]` Z] _cS _cWht ÔÒ {Z SZ bS[O RS ZO a]ZWRO`WROR RS Z]a []dW[WS\b]a a]QWOZSa \] ZS `SacZbS\ SfbÒย ]a 3\ ac QOa] SZ O^]g] []ÒZ g SQ]\ย [WQ] Oa Q][] SZ `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] RS ac TO[WZWO g O[WabORSa VO aWR] aWS[^`S W\Q]\RWQW]\OZ bOZ g Q][] aS [cSabÒ S\ SabO OTW`[OQWย \( AW bS Ô`SQS PWS\ O bW VOhZ] >]` ย ZbW[] ; ' # Q`SS _cS ZO d]QOQWย \ ^]` bÒPOXO` S\ SZ QO[^] RS ZO Q]]^SÒQWย \ ^cSRS aS` VS`SRORO RS ac [OR`S c\O [cXS` _cS S\ {^]QO RS ^]abUcS`Ò SabOPO [SbWRO S\ `]ZZ]a RS ZO WUZSaWO OgcRO\R] O b]R] SZ [c\R] Oc\_cS ÔÒRย XWQO[S\bS OV]Ò aSO _cWS\ [S\]a ZO S\bWS\RO <] ]PabO\bS g ^SaS O ZO ^]aWPZS W\TZcS\QWO RS ZO [OR`S ] ac Q]ZOP]ÒQWย \ S\ =<52a ] ^`]gSQb]a S\ SZ [Wa[] aS\] c\WdSàWbO`W] Sabt Q]\dS\QWRO RS _cS S\ ac QOa] Sa ^cÒ[S\bS d]QOQW]\OZ RS b]RO ZO dWRO aWS[^`S VS aWR] [cg aS\aWPZS O Sab]a bS[Oa g bO[PW{\ VS dWOXOR] [cQV] aWS[^`S W\QZca] RSaRS X]dS\QWbO O Z]a # Oย ]a g] gO [S WPO ^]` SXS[^Z] O VOQS` QO[^]a RS bÒPOX] IยฌK ^S`] PcS\] \] bS Z] b][Oa \ORO S\ aS`W] OZ ^`W\QW^W] \W bS Z] ^cSRSa ^ZO\bSO` Q][] ^`]TSaWย \ ^]`_cS Z] dSa ac^S` Q][^ZWQOR] Z] _cS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

ÔaO Sa _cS aWS[^`S Sabta OV S\ SZ bS[O VOabO _cS ^]Q] O ^]Q] aS VO WR] [ObS`WOZWhO\R] ^]`_cS aW\ _cS`S` b dOa SZWUWS\R] SaS QO[W\] \] Q]\aQWS\bS[S\bS ^S`] g] aWS[^`S VS bWÒR] ^]` OV g QZO`] aS Sabt [ObS`WOZWhO\R] g aS Q]\dWS`bS S\ ^`]TSaW \ 1]\ `SZOQW \ OZ O^]g] TO[WZWO` ; ' # Sf^`SaO _cS O dSQSa [W [OR`S \W [S VOPZO Q][S\bO ¥]bÒ dSh bS dOa- C\O [OR`S _cS Q][] RSQ O[]a O\bS`W]`[S\bS dSZOPO ^]` SZ PWS\SabO` RS ZO US\bS bÒa ZO UcS`Ò c\O [OR`S _cS S\ ac {^]QO aS WPO RS dWOXS aW\ RSQ àSZ] O aca ÔR`Sa g aW\ S[POÙ] Sa OV]Ò ZO _cS [ta Z] `SQVOhO ^]aWPZS[S\bS ^]` SZ bS[]` RS ^S`RS`[S RS _cS [S _cSRS TcSÒ RS _cS \] `SU`SaS AW\ S[POÙ] g Q][] aS `S^WbS S\ QOaW b]R]a Z]a S\b`SdWabOR]a ZO TWUcÒ RSZ ÔR`S Sa SZ _cS bÒbO RS S\bS\RS` ZO aWbcOQW \( W\bS\bO Q][^`S\RS`[S aWS[^`S g [S O^]gO [cQV aW[] g aW\ S[POÙ] ^`]POPZS[S\bS acT`S W\QZca] [ta _cS [W [OR`S G] Q`S] aW[^ZS[S\bS _cS aW ZS Ucab [W [OR`S aWS\R] Oa ³Q]]^SÒ\bS³ g g] bO[PW{\ a]g Oa ^cSa Z] dOZ]Ò g Z] OQS^bO ^]` O[]` :O dWaWbO RS aca ÔR`Sa O >S` R]\RS ; ' # bÒPOXOPO OgcR aW\ RcRO O c\ `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] g c\ QO[PW] ÒRWQOZ ^]` Ô`bS RS ZO [OR`S VOQWO ZOa OQQW]\Sa Vc[O\WbO`WOa ³S\ SabS QOa] Q]\ \W ]a³ ZZSdOROa O QOP] ^]` ac VWXO S\ SaS [][S\b] Oc\_cS aS ZS dcSZdO O ]ZdWRO` Q]\ SZ bWS[^] Aca O[WU]a g VS`[O\] aW\ S[POÙ] VO\ bS\WR] aWS[^`S [cg QZOÒ ac d]QOQW \ ^]` Z] _cS \] aS ZO W[OUW\O\ RS ]bÒ [O\SÒ Z] bWS\S\ Oac[WR] g ZO O^]gO\ ! ¥ ?c{ Sa SZ `WSaU] g _c{ ^S`QS^QW \ bWS\S\ SZZ]a RSZ [Wa[]- ¥?c{ ac^]\S ÔÒ SZZ]a dWdW` S\ Q]\bSfb]a RS `WSaU]:OP]ÒZ[S\bS Q]\TWSaO D # Sa c\ QO[^] Q]\ [S\]` aSUc`WROR _cS ]b`]a g aW \] aOZS PWS\ ^cSRSa bS\S` ^`]PZS[Oa ÔÒ QO[PWO`bS RS aSQb]` 3\ SZ ^ZO\] TO[WZWO` RS^S\RS RS Qct\b] bWS[^] dWdOa TcSÒ g ^]` ac^cSab] S\ [ta RS c\O ]QOaW \ ZS VO\ VSQV] QcSabW]\OàS aW ac RSQWaW \ Sa c\O PcS\O ]^QW \ ^Sà]\OZ a]P`S b]R] ^]` Z]a dWOXSa `SWbSÒR]a =b`] `WSaU] ÔÒ {Z Sa SZ VSQV] RS \] UcO`RO`bS SaÔQW]a RS aSÔÒQW \ S\b`S ZO dWRO ^Sà]\OZ g ZO TO[WZWO` g bc bÒPOX] BO[PW{\ Q]\bS[^ZO `WSaU]a T aWQ]a OZ dWdW` TcSÒ( VOg [Og]`Sa ^`]POPWZWRORSa bc dWRO dOZS [S\]a :]a Q]\bSfb]a a]\ [ta O``WSaUOR]a AW\ S[POÙ] g O ^SaO` RS b]R] ac Sa^SQWOZ Q]\TWO\hO S\ ZO P]\ROR RSZ U{\S`] Vc[O\] g S\ SZ aS\bWR] Q][ \ c\WR] O ZO aSUc`WROR _cS aWS\bS S\ ac QOÔQWROR RS ORO^bOQW \ ZS ZZSdO\ O RSQW` _cS( aW ]b`]a dWdS\ OZZ g] bO[PW{\ ^cSR] VOQS`Z] D % \] aS VO ^ZO\bSOR] RS[OaWOR] SZ `WSaU] aW[^ZS[S\bS VO RSaQO`bOR] QWS`b]a RSabW\]a ^]` bÒbOàS S\ ac ]^W\W \ RS Ô aSa RS[OaWOR] dW]ZS\b]a ] S\ Q]\TZWQb] Oc\_cS ^]` ]bÒ Ô`bS Q]\TWSaO _cS SabS SabS`S]bW^] aS ZS VO QO R] Q]\ 1]Z][PWO ^]` SXS[^Z] AW\ S[POÙ] a _cS aS ^ZO\bSO SZ `WSaU] RS ^S`RS` ZO ZWPS`bOR RS \] ^]RS` ÔaSO` RS \]QVS Oc\_cS Q]\aWRSÒ _cS VOg [cQV]a b ^WQ]a Q]\ Sa] [cQVO SfOUSÒQW \ ASU \ {Z( Q]\ Q]\]QW[WS\b] g ÒQW]\OZWROR aS ^cSRS [W\W[WhO` ZO ^SZWU`]aWROR g `SZObWdWhO`ZO QcO\R] aS bÒbO RS Oa]QWO`ZO O RSbS`[W\OR]a Ô aSa 3Z `WSaU] S\ QcO\b] O ZO aOZcR a ZS ^`S]QcÔ( <] ^]RS` bS\S` \W [SRW]a \W ^Sà]\OZ aO\WbO`W]a ORSQcOR]a g QcOZWTWQOR]a ÔÒ ObS\RS` S\TS`[SRORSa 3Z VOPS` SabOR] T`S\bS O SabS `WSaU] dS` []`W` O c\O ^Sà]\O S\ 3QcOR]` ^]` SabO Òh \ a _cS [S VO VSQV] `SÔÒ` S\ SZZ] 3Z `WSaU] RS Q]\bÒS`

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

S\TS`[SRORSa Q][^ZWQOROa bÒ\a[WbWROa ^]` W\aSQb]a bO[PW{\ ac^]\S c\ bS[O RS ^`S]QcÔQW \ ÔÒ ZO [Og]` O RS Z]a Q]]^SÒ\bSa Z] _cS ZS ZZSdO O ^S\aO` _cS S\ `SOZWROR SZ `WSaU] Sabt [ta dW\QcZOR] OZ Ô a R]\RS aS bÒPOXO 1cO\R] ZS ^`SUc\bO[]a O ; % ! QctZ SÒ ac ^S`QS^QW \ a]P`S SZ `WSaU] ZO aOZcR ]Qc^ SZ ^`W[S` ZcUO` 3fWabS\ RWQS RWTS`S\bSa SaQS\O`W]a SZ \] bS\S` O[PcZO\QWOa S\ 0c`c\RW ^]` SXS[^Z] SZ \] RWa^]\S` RS V]a^WbOZSa QS`QO\]a Q][] S\ /h]`Sa R]\RS VOP O _cS W` O ZO WaZO ^`W\QWÔZ 3\TS`[SRORSa _cS ^cSRSa ÔRSQS` Q][] ZO [OZO`WO ^`]PZS[Oa Q]\ ZO Q][WRO [OZ]a aS`dWQW]a [{RWQ]a SbQ \] bS µ^S`[WbS\¶ QOS` S\TS`[O / \WdSZ ^Sà]\OZ Z]a ObÒQ]a S\ AcRtT`WQO ] ZO bS\aW \ _cS ac^]\S SZ _cS S\b`S\ S\ bc QOaO ] _cS bS `]PS\ S\ Z]a Q]QVSa a]\ c\O `SOZWROR W\RWaQcbWPZS 3\ 0c`c\RW ^]` SXS[^Z] VOP O [ta O`[Oa ^S`] SabOPOa [ta `SaÔZRORO ^]` SZ ^Sà]\OZ RS ZO ]ÙO\WhOQW \ aW\ S[POÙ] S\ AcRtT`WQO \] bWS\Sa bO\bO Q]PS`bcÒ Sa c\ `WSaU] [ta ^Sà]\OZWhOR] Oc\_cS g] \] b][] `WSaU]a W\\SQSaO`W]a [S Q]\aWRS`] c\O ^Sà]\O Q]\aS`dOR]Ò 3Z VSQV] RS \] bS\S` Q]QVS O_c bO[PW{\ W\TZcgS 3\ 0c`c\RW µÔaSO` QO[W\O` Sa W[^S\aOPZS aS ] O\ POZOh]a ^]` ZO \]QVS ZO US\bS aS []` O S\ ZOa t`SOa `cÒZSa g g] SÒ ZO \WQO PZO\QO S\ [cQV]a aWbW]a RS VSQV] ac [Og]` [WSR] SÒ [ta ^]` ZO ÒhO _cS ^]` SZ Q`W[S\( aS` PZO\QO ^cSRS ZZSUO` O aS` c\ ]PXSbWd] g Z UWQO[S\bS aS` RWTS`S\bS S\ /\U]ZO g 0c`c\RW SÒ [cg SdWRS\bS 3\ AcRtT`WQO SZ Q`W[S\ Sa [ta SQ]\ [WQ] [WS\bÒa _cS S\ 0c`c\RW Sa [ta ^]Z bWQ] 3\ /\U]ZO ^]` SXS[^Z] [S `]PO`]\ c\O Qt[OÒ BO[PW{\ SfWabS SZ `WSaU] RS OQQWRS\bSa RS b`tTWQ] :Oa QO``SbSÒa a]\ [OZOa \] VOg ^`]bSQQW \ 3\ 0c`c\RW aWUcS RWQWS\R] aS ^`]RcQS\ [cQV]a OQQWRS\bSa S\ QO``SbSÒ g] [Wa[O [S QO ^]` c\ bS`Ò^Z{\ 3\ 3aÔ O SfWabS [ta `SaÔZR] ZO dWRO RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa \] dOZS bO\b] Q][] acQSRS S\ 3c`]Ô BO[PW{\ SfWabS SZ `WSaU] RS ^S`RS` `SZOQW]\Sa 3\ ac QOa] ^]` SXS[^Z] ac ÔaW \ ^]` bÒPOXO` TcSÒ TcS [ta TcS`bS _cS aSUcW` Q]\ ac Ô`SXO :Oa ^`]POPWZWRORSa ^cSa RS bS\S` Ô`SXO a]\ [S\]`Sa >S`RS` O[WabORSa Sa ]bÒ `SOZWROR ^S`] bO[PW{\ UO\Oa W\TZcS\QWO a]P`S ZO TO[WZWO g a]P`S ]bÒa O[WabORSa _cS aS VO\ WR] W\bS`SaO\R] ^]` Sa]a bS[Oa Oc\_cS SZ `WSaU] RS W\Q][^`S\aW \ ^]` Ô`bS RS ZO TO[WZWO acQSRO( :Sa QcSabO S\bS\RS` QcSabO Sf^ZWQO` Z] _cS Sa SZ acPRSaO``]ZZ] a]\ dWaW]\Sa [cg RWabW\bOa RS OV _cS ZO dcSZbO O QOaO aSO bO\ RWT QWZ g SZ aS\bWR] RS ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S aS dSO QORO dSh [ta RSaO``]ZZOR]( bS OQ]abc[PÒa O ^S\aO` O Q]`b] ^ZOh] ^S`] O ac dSh bO[PW{\ RS\b`] RS c\ ^`]gSQb] [ta O ZOÙ] ^ZOh] _cS W\QZcgS SZ VOQS` g O^`S\RS` Q]aOa \cSdOa 3\ `SZOQW \ Q]\ ZO TO[WZWO ; % ! Sa ZO \WQO RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa S\b`SdWabOROa _cS [O\WTWSabO Q][] `WSaU] ZO aS\aOQW \ RS OPO\R]\] _cS ZO TO[WZWO ^cSRS ^S`QWPW` RS bW g dWQSdSàO 3f^`SaW]\Sa Q][] µb \] Sabta O_c ¶ aS VO\ ac[OR] O ZO aWbcOQW \ RS OU]PW] ^`]d]QORO ^]` ZO S\TS`[SROR RS ZO [OR`S RcÒ\bS ac OcaS\QWO 1]\ Z]a O[WU]a ]Qc``S OZU] aW[WZO` ^S`RS` O[WabORSa Sa c\ `WSaU] _cS Q]``Sa ^S`[O\S\bS[S\bS Oc\_cS bO[PW{\ Sa QWS`b] _cS ^WS`RSa O[WabORSa ^S`] bO[PW{\ UO\Oa W\TZcS\QWO a]P`S ZO TO[WZWO g a]P`S ]bÒa O[WabORSa _cS aS VO\ WR] W\bS`SaO\R] ^]` Sab]a bS[Oa =b`] `WSaU] g _cWht SZ [ta ZWUOR] O ZO ^Sà]\OZWROR RS ZO S\b`SdWabORO Sa ZO ^S`QS^QW \ _cS bWS\S RS ac ^]aWPZS QO[PW] RS QO`tQbS` SZ VOQSàS [ta

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

RcÒ S W\aS\aWPZS OZ aS\bWàS W\Q][^`S\RWRO g ^]aWPZS[S\bS a]ZO S\ [][S\b]a S\ Z]a _cS VO \SQSaWbOR] VOPZO` g Q][S\bO` aca ^`]PZS[Oa S\ SZ QO[^] S\ SZ _cS bÒPOXO( ZOa O[WabORSa bS b][O\ Q][] c\O ^Sà]\O ÒÒ Sf bWQO \] S\bWS\RS\ bca QZOdSa >]` ]bÒ Ô`bS dWdW` a]ZO PcaQO`bS ZO dWRO a]ZO Sa [ta RWT QWZ dWOXO` OQ][Ô ORO Sa [cQV] [ta TtQWZ ^S`] QcO\R] QO[PWOa RS Ô a RS QOaO g RS O[WabORSa bO\ T`SQcS\bS[S\bS Sa Z UWQ] _cS Sa] ]Qc`Ò >]` ]bÒ Ô`bS O ORS Sa RWT QWZ S\ RSbS`[W\OR]a Q]\bSfb]a W\bSUÒ`bS Q]\ ZO US\bS Z]QOZ A]\ `SZOQW]\Sa dS`bWQOZSa _cS \] ^cSRS\ aS` bÒ\aT]`[OROa S\ V]`Wh]\bOZSa 3ab] SÒ Oa S\ 0c`c\RW 3\ /\U]ZO \] bO\b] Oc\_cS O dSQSa aW bS OQS`QOPOa O ZO US\bS Z]QOZ ^]R O S\bS\RSàS Q][] aW _cWaWSÒa bS\S` `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa ] _cS \] SabOPOa Q]\bS\bO Q]\ SZ bÒPOX] RS OZUc\O ^Sà]\O) bO[PW{\ SÒ RWT QWZ ÔaSO` Q]\ ZOa ^Sà]\Oa RS /\U]ZO ^]`_cS S`Sa PZO\QO S`Sa RWTS`S\bS 1cO\R] bS `SZOQW]\Oa Q]\ ^Sà]\Oa RS ]b`]a Ô aSa \] aOPSa VOabO _cS ^c\b] ZSa UcabOa Q][] ^Sà]\O g VOabO _c{ ^c\b] S`Sa c\O W[OUS\ c\ a [P]Z] =b`] ^c\b] OP]`ROR] ^]` ZO S\b`SdWabORO Sa SZ RSZ `WSaU] ZOP]ÒZ OZ \] VOPS` Q]bWhOR] OZ \] VOPS` ÔUOR] aSUc`WROR a]QWOZ >cSRSa W\QZca] \] S\Q]\bÒ` bÒPOX] a]P`S b]R] aW VOa ]^bOR] ^]` c\ QO[^] ^`]TSaW]\OZ [cg Sa^SQWOZWhOR] Q][] Sa SZ _cS`S` bÒPOXO` S\ W\dSabWUOQW \ g RSaO``]ZZ] S\ c\ ]ÙO\Wa[] W\bS`\OQW]\OZ ] S\ c\WdSàWRORSa A Z] aS Q]``S c\ `WSaU] aW bWS\Sa OZU] _cS ^S`RS` OTW`[O D & " SZ `WSaU] bWS\S ^cSa [cQV] _cS dS` Q]\ Z] _cS c\] ^WS`RS SfQS^bcO\R] ZO aOZcR ¦QZO`] 3Z `WSaU] S\ Q]\bÒ RS ZO aSUc`WROR Sa aW\ RcRO c\ S\T]_cS [cg W\bS`SaO\bS _cS SZ S\b`SdWabOR] Sf^ZWQO RS ZO aWUcWS\bS [O\SÒ( SZ `WSaU] S\ Q]\bÒ RS ZO aSUc`WROR Sa SZ UÒ\ [O\bÒ RS \cSabÒ {^]QO `STW`W{\R]aS \] a Z] O ZO aSUc`WROR T aWQO \W ZOP]ÒZ aW\] bO[PW{\ O ZO aS\bW[S\bOZ g ORS[ta O ZOÙ] ^ZOh] 1]\dS\QWR] ORS[ta RS _cS SZ bS[O RS ZO aSUc`WROR Sabt [ta O`ÒWUOR] OV]Ò S\b`S ZOa ^Sà]\Oa g Z]a X dS\Sa OQbcOZSa _cS S\b`S Z]a OPcSZ]a RSZ QO[^] QcO\R] S\ `SOZWROR aW c\] VcÙO S\ SaO WRSO bO\ b`]\ORO RS ZO aSUc`WROR Sabt POabO\bS dOQ O ASUc`WROR aSUc`WROR QcO\R] OZ TW\OZ RS Z] \WQ] _cS SabO[]a aSUc`]a Sa RS _cS a Z] SabO[]a ^S\aO\R] S\ SabO` aSUc`]a \] ^S\aO[]a gO S\ ]bÒ Q]aO 3\b]\QSa T`S\bS O Sa] SZ `WSaU] Ô`SQS _cS aS Q]\dWS`bS S\ c\O T]`[O RS Q]\bSabOQW \ QOaW RWdS`bWRO /RS[ta S\ SabO US\SÒQW \ \cSabÒ ] S\ [W QOa] ZO RS [W ^S`TWZ ZO US\SÒQW \ Sfb`S[ORO[S\bS [W[ORO R]\RS aS \]a VO _cWbOR] SZ RS`SQV] O ZO `SPSZR O [S `STWS`] OZ >ZO\ ;O[t R]\RS aS \]a ^S`[WbS b]R] ¦SZ Q]``S` `WSaU]a aS Q]\dWS`bS S\ c\O T]`[O RS `SPSZR O QOaW OR]ZSaQS\bS /Z ^`SUc\bO`ZS ^]` Z]a `WSaU]a S\ SZ bS``S\] aS\bW[S\bOZ Ô`SQS _cS ZO `Sa^cSabO \] aS VOQS Sa^SÒ`( a a VS Oac[WR] `WSaU]a S\ SabS bS``S\] g [S VS ^WZZOR] Z]a RSR]a BS VOQS ^S\aO` QcSabW]\Sa RS T]\R]( AW Sab]g ^`W]`WhO\R] ³SZ d]Zc\bO`WOR] TcSÒ³ OZU] O Z] _cS \] d]g O `S\c\QWO` S\b`S ]bÒa Q]aOa ^]`_cS bO[^]Q] ZO ]bÒ ^Sà]\O _cWS`S _cS `S\c\QWS O SZZ] Sa Q][] aW \] SabcdWSaS Q][Ô`bWS\R] c\O WRSO RS ZOa Q]aOa Q]\ ZO ]bÒ ^Sà]\O g Sa] Sa c\ `WSaU] STSQbWdO[S\bS C\ `WSaU] _cS bO[PW{\ Oa]QWO g `SQcS`RO Q]\ aca O ]a RS 3Òa[ca g Q]\ ZOa PSQOa RS Q]]^SÒQW \ c\WdSàWbO`WO `SQWPWROa S\ SZ QO[^] RS ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ @WSaU]a _cS VO\ ac^cSab] S\ ac QOa] dS`RORS`]a RWZS[Oa []ÒZSa( ÔÒ aS\bW`[S g] PWS\ OgcRO\R] O Z]a RS[ta ^S`XcRWQ] O ]bÒ ^Sà]\O c\O

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

WRSO _cS ZS ZZSdO O ^S\aO` _cS _cWht S\ c\ Tcbc`] RSXS RS dWOXO` ^]`_cS S\bWS\RS _cS RSaRS O_c bO[PW{\ ^cSRS W\bS`dS\W` Q]\ ac OgcRO >OÒ ; ' # SZ `WSaU] aS `Sac[S S\ c\O a]ZO WRSO S\ ac QOa]( ZO ^`]^WO b][O RS RSQWaWย \ SZ [][S\b] S\ SZ _cS RSQWRSa ]^bO` ^]` SaS SabWZ] RS dWRO RSXO\R] b]R] Z] _cS bWS\Sa O_c ÔÒ [O`QVO`bS TcSÒ aW\ RSaQO`bO` ^]` SZZ] SZ `WSaU] T aWQ] QZO`] Sabt OZ dS`bS Sf^cSabO O ^]aWPZSa Q]\bOUW]a S\TS`[SRORSa OU`SaW]\Sa c ]b`]a Vt\RWQOâ ^`]^W]a RS QORO ZcUO` dWaWbOR] >S`] O ^SaO` RS b]R] SZZO bWS\S QZO`] _cS ZO OQbWbcR _cS b][Oa T`S\bS O ZOa Q]aOa Sa Z] `SOZ[S\bS W[^]`bO\bS >]` ac^cSab] g OZ WUcOZ _cS SZ S\b`SdWabOR] O\bS`W]` Oac[Sa `WSaU]a S[]QW]\OZSa ZZt[S\aS aS\bW[S\bOZSa c ]b`]a ^S`] ZO WRSO RS [O`QVOàS g RSRWQO`bS O Z] _cS `SOZ[S\bS bS VOQS aS\bW` PWS\ Sa ac^S`W]` O b]R] Z] RS[ta 1][] QOaW b]ROa ZOa [OR`Sa RS Z]a S\b`SdWabOR]a SZ `WSaU] Sa c\O WRSO `SQc``S\bS _cS ZSa ^`S]QcÔ ^]` [cQV]a []bWd]a <]`[OZ[S\bS [ta dW\QcZORO O ZO S\TS`[SROR g O ZO W\aSUc`WROR T aWQO ^]` SZ [WSR] RS ^S`RS` O c\ VWX] ÔÒ aWS[^`S _cS O ZO Q]]^SÒQWย \ S\ a ^cSa RS SZZ] aS aWS\bS\ POabO\bS ]ÙcZZ]aOa AW\ S[POÙ] ; # $ \SQSaWbย Sf^S`W[S\bO` ^]` a [Wa[O ÔÒ aS` ^ZS\O[S\bS Q]\aQWS\bS RS Z]a `WSaU]a O Z]a _cS ac [OR`S aS `STS` O( S\TS`[SRORSa Q]``c^QWย \ g c\ aW\T \ RS aWbcOQW]\Sa _cS STSQbWdO[S\bS aS RO\ S\ c\ S\b]`\] [ta W\aSUc`] S\ QWS`b]a Oa^SQb]a Oc\_cS Q]\ Oย ]a \] bS ROa QcS\bO RS Sa] PSPSa OUcO RSZ ^]h] aOPWS\R] _cS bS Sf^]\Sa O c\O RWO``SO Z] _cS \] aOPSa Sa _cS Oa ^cSRSa Q]\bÒS` c\O VSÔbWbWa :] QWS`b] Sa _cS \W bS Z] ^ZO\bSOa ^]` SabO` bO\ OZSXOR] RS bc S\b]`\] ^`ย fW[] RS O_c RS 3aÔย O g ORS[ta ^]`_cS ^WS\aOa _cS aW O ZO US\bS RS OZZ \] ZS ÔaO \ORO O bW bO[^]Q] AW\ S[POÙ] Q]\ SZ bWS[^] Q][^`S\RSa _cS Q]\ ^`SQOcQWย \ g ^`SdS\QWย \ Z]a `WSaU]a RWa[W\cgS\ BO[PW{\ Sa QWS`b] aWUcS Sf^ZWQO\R] _cS QcO\b] [ta aS Q]\]QS ZO `SOZWROR RSZ ZcUO` R]\RS bS S\QcS\bÒa [ta [WSR]a ^cSRSa aS\bW` 3abS Sa SZ QOa] RS ZO Sf^]`bOQWย \ RS Z]a [SX]`Sa [{RWQ]a ZObW\]O[S`WQO\]a O QO[PW] RS ^Sb`ย ZS] S\ DS\ShcSZO ] SZ PZ]_cS] RS [SRWQO[S\b]a ^]` Ô`bS RS 3abOR]a C\WR]a >]` ]bÒ Ô`bS g S\ ac QOa] SZ `WSaU] OR_cWS`S ]bÒ RW[S\aWย \ OZ ^ZO\bSOàS RWZS[Oa []ÒZSa RSZ bW^]( AW g] d]g ÔÒ dWdW` Q]\ SZZ]a bS\U] _cS aS` Z] [ta Q]VS`S\bS ^]aWPZS g dWdW` Q][] SZZ]a \] ^cSR] OQS^bO` `SQWPW` c\ bÒb] RS TOd]` `SQWPWS\R] Z]a bÒbO[WS\b]a aO\WbO`W]a OQcRWS\R] O [W S[POXORO g RWa^]\WS\R] RS c\ VSZWQย ^bS`] aW TcSÒ \SQSaO`W] ÔÒ `SU`SaO` O QOaO O QcÒ`[S [WS\bÒa Z]a QcPO\]a aS _cSRO\ OZZ S\TS`[]a g aW\ `SQWPW` OgcRO aO\WbO`WO Oc\_cS bO[PW{\ S\bWS\R] _cS ^]` [cg Q]]^SÒ\bS _cS aSOa \] _cWS`S RSQW` _cS bS\UOa _cS POaO` bc RSQWaWย \ S\ c\ ย \WQ] ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] {bWQ] []ÒZ ] RS XcabWQWOยฌ

" 1 ]\bÒabO\R] dWaW]\Sa RSZ `WSaU] S\ SZ Ac` g S\ SZ <]`bS 4W\OZWhO[]a SabS O`b QcZ] Q]\ SZ Q]\bÒabS S\b`S ZOa dWaW]\Sa RSZ `WSaU] Oa]QWOROa O ZO Q]]^SÒQWย \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ g ZO ^]P`ShO _cS ^`SaS\btPO[]a S\ Z]a ^`W[S`]a R]a OÔ`bOR]a RS SabS bÒPOX] g ZOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa RS \cSab`]a g \cSabÒa S\b`SdWabOROa <] Sa \cSab`] t\W[] US\SÒZWhO` SabOa Q]\QZcaW]\Sa ^cSa a][]a Q]\aQWS\bSa RS ZOa ZW[WbOQW]\Sa RS SabS O`b QcZ] AS bÒbO [ta PWS\ RS c\Oa ^`W[SÒa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa RS QO`tQbS` Sf^Z]Òb]`W] ^S\aOROa [ta ÔÒ S\TObWhO` Qct\ RWabW\bO Sa ZO ^S`QS^QWย \ RSZ

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

`WSaU] S\ Tc\QW \ RSZ Q]\bSfb] RSZ _cS aS ^`]dWS\S g RS ZO QOÔQWROR RS Q]\b`]Z a]P`S ZOa dWROa _cS aS bWS\S >OÒTÒaSO\R] O /[O`bgO AS\ QcO\bOa [Og]`Sa a]\ ZOa QOÔQWRORSa RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa Sa RSQW` ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa `SOZSa RS ZOa _cS RWa^]\S\ ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ÔÒ ZZSdO` ORSZO\bS SZ ^`]^W] ^ZO\ RS dWRO [Og]` aSUc`WROR [Og]` Q]\TWO\hO S\ ZO ^`]^WO dWRO g [S\]` aS\bWR] RSZ `WSaU] aS bWS\S 3\ SZ OÔ`bOR] \]a `STS` O[]a O ZOa W\QS`bWRc[P`Sa Q` \WQOa RS ZO ^]P`ShO g ZO W\QOÔQWROR ÔÒ VOQS` T`S\bS O Z]a `WSaU]a AS` ^]P`S RWQS E]]R ! aWU\WTWQO \] aS` QOÔh RS Q]\b`]ZO` Z]a SdS\b]a ^`SaS\bSa g Tcbc`]a ^]`_cS ]b`]a bWS\S\ [ta Q]\b`]Z a]P`S SZZ]a AW Q][ÔÒ[]a SabO WRSO RS ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S Q]\ OTW`[OQW]\Sa RS \cSab`]a X dS\Sa Q][] aW ]b`]a dWdS\ OZZ g] bO[PW{\ ^cSR] VOQS`Z] Q]\ Q]\]QW[WS\b] g ÒQW]\OZWROR aS ^cSRS [W\W[WhO` ZO ^SZWU`]aWROR ] SZ `WSaU] aS `Sac[S S\ SZ [][S\b] S\ SZ _cS b][Oa ZOa RSQWaW \ RS RSRWQO`bS O SabS QO[^] ^]RS[]a O^`SQWO` ZO Q]\TWO\hO _cS bÒ\a[WbS\ \cSab`]a X dS\Sa S\ aca QOÔQWRORSa ÔÒ S\T`S\bOàS OZ `WSaU] 3ab] Q]\bÒabO Q]\ ZO dWaW \ [ta RSa]ZOR]Ò RS ZO W\aSUc`WROR _cS ^S`QWPS\ ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ^]P`Sa( W\aSUc`WROR S\ SZ bÒPOX] S\ Z]a [SRW]a RS dWRO Q`W[S\ g dW]ZS\QWO TOZbO RS XcabWQWO SbQ <OÒgO\ Sb OZ g Q]\ ZO OcaS\QWO RS ^]RS` ÔÒ ^]RS` ac^SÒ` SabOa W\aSUc`WRORSa 5`SS\ & 6Og R]a S\b`SdWabOa _cS O^]`bO\ ]b`]a SZS[S\b]a O SabS O\tZWaWa _cS Q`SS[]a Q]\dS\WS\bS `SaOZbO` C\O Sa ZO RS ; % ! _cS RSaQ`WPS c\O Ô\]`t[WQO RSZ `WSaU] [cQV] [ta O[^ZWO _cS ZO RS ZOa ]bÒa ^Sà]\Oa S\b`SdWabOROa 3ZZO aS `STWS`S O `WSaU]a S\ ZO aOZcR t[PWb] S\ SZ QcOZ Q]W\QWRS\ QOaW b]ROa ZOa S\b`SdWabOa ^S`] bO[PW{\ O `WSaU]a RS`WdOR]a RS ZO RSZW\QcS\QWO RS ZOa UcS`Òa `WSaU] S\ Z]a OQQWRS\bSa RS b`tTWQ] `WSaU] ^]` aS` RWTS`S\bS O Z]a RS[ta SbQ ?cWhta ZO PW]UÒT O RS SabO S\b`SdWabORO _cS VO dWdWR] Z]a ZbW[]a b`Sa O ]a S\ ÈT`WQO ZO VOQS [ta Q]\aQWS\bS RS Z] O``WSaUORO _cS ^cSRS aS` ZO dWRO S\ RSbS`[W\OROa Ô`bSa RSZ [c\R] :O Sf^]aWQW \ `SOZ OZ `WSaU] g ÈT`WQO Sabt ^]PZORO RS aWbcOQW]\Sa [cg RWT QWZSa S\ b{`[W\]a RS aSUc`WROR Oc[S\bO ZO ^S`QS^QW \ RSZ [Wa[] 3a SabO c\O ^S`QS^QW \ Q][Ô`bWRO ^]` ]b`]a S\b`SdWabOR]a Q][] D % _cS OTW`[O S\ SabS aS\bWR]( SZ dS` []`W` S\ 3QcOR]` O c\O ^Sà]\O I^]` \] `SQWPW` ORSQcORO ObS\QW \ [{RWQOK [S VO VSQV] `SÔÒ` S\ SZZ] AWUcWS\R] Q]\ ZO S\b`SdWabO O ; % ! SZZO bO[PW{\ `SÔÒ S\ Z]a `WSaU]a S[]QW]\OZSa RS ac ^`]TSaW \( dWdW` OZSXORO RS ZO TO[WZWO RS ZOa O[WabORSa RWTWQcZbOR S\ [O\bS\S` ZOa Ô`SXOa 3\ SZ `Sab] RS ZOa S\b`SdWabOa VOg bO[PW{\ OZcaW]\Sa O ZO RWTWQcZbOR RS [O\bS\S` c\ S\b]`\] [ta aSUc`] S[]QW]\OZ[S\bS O_c :O TO[WZWO aW\ RcRO ]QcÔ c\ ZcUO` QS\bÒZ 2S OZUc\O c ]bÒ [O\SÒ SZ RSRWQOàS O SabS QO[^] VOQS _cS aca TO[WZWOa dWdO\ Q]\ ^`S]QcÔQW \ SZ bWS[^] _cS ÔaO\ TcSÒ / ^SaO` RS SZZ] OZ bÒbOàS RS RSQWaW]\Sa [cg d]QOQW]\OZSa ^SaO [ta ac W\bS`{a g UO\Oa RS RSRWQOàS O SabS aSQb]` _cS ZOa Q]\aWRSÒQW]\Sa TO[WZWO`Sa S W\QZca] SZ `WSaU] RS \] ^]RS` [O\bS\S` `SZOQW]\Sa SabOPZSa RS Ô`SXO :ZO[O ZO ObS\QW \ Q][] VOg R]a QcSabW]\Sa _cS ^`S]QcÔ\ [cg ^]Q] ] \ORO O \cSab`]a S\b`SdWabOR]a g S\b`SdWabOROa( ZO W\SabOPWZWROR SQ]\ [WQO g ZO dWdWS\RO :O ^`W[SÒ aS [S\QW]\O S\ R]a S\b`SdWabOa aW\ ]QcÔ` c\ ZcUO` QS\bÒZ g ZO aSUc\RO \] OÔ`SQS S\ OPa]Zcb] Z] _cS Q]\bÒabO Q]\ ZOa SabOR abWQOa US\SÒZSa a]P`S ZO XcdS\bcR S\ 3aÔ O =PaS`dOb]`W] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR S\ 3aÔ O $

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

:O ]bÒ S\b`SdWabO _cS ]T`SQS SZS[S\b]a W\bS`SaO\bSa RS O\tZWaWa Sa ZO RS D & " _cS OTW`[O _cS SZ `WSaU] S\ Q]\bÒ RS ZO aSUc`WROR Sa SZ UÒ\ [O\bÒ RS \cSabÒ {^]QO 3Z b][O` RSQWaW]\Sa O``WSaUOROa Sa c\ OQb] RS `SPSZR O XcdS\WZ ?c{ ZSX]a Sabt SabO dWaW \ RS ZOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa RSZ `WSaU] RS Z]a ^]P`Sa _cS OÔ`SQS\ S\ ZOa S\b`SdWabOa `SOZWhOROa ^]` SZ 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ 3a QWS`b] _cS SabOa dWaW]\Sa \] Q]``Sa^]\RS\ S\ Ô`bWQcZO` OZ aSU[S\b] XcdS\WZ ^S`] ZO O\aWSROR g SZ [WSR] _cS Sf^S`W[S\bO\ SabOa ^Sà]\Oa O QOcaO RS ac W\aSUc`WROR Sa c\O Q]\abO\bS S\ aca dWROa >]`_cS aS aWS\bS\ W\aSUc`]a g dcZ\SÒPZSa RS[O\RO\ [Og]` aSUc`WROR [Og]` ^`]bSQQW \ g [Og]` Q]\b`]Z C\O dSh [ta aS ^]\S RS [O\WTWSab] _cS ZOa RWTS`S\QWOa RS Q]\bSfb]a RS VWab]`WOa dWbOZSa a]\ aW\ RcRO QZOdSa ÔÒ S\bS\RS` SZ `WSaU] >OÒ TW\OZWhO` SabO RWaQcaW \ _cS`S[]a ZZO[O` ZO ObS\QW \ a]P`S ZO dWaW \ bO\ `Sab`WQbWdO _cS RSZ `WSaU] aS bWS\S S\ SZ QO[^] RS ZO USabW \ RS Z]a ^`]gSQb]a RS ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ) Q][] acPÒgtPO[]a S\ SZ OÔ`bOR] ^`W[S`] SZ {\TOaWa Sabt ^cSab] S\ SZ Q]\b`]Z RSZ `WSaU] ÔÒ _cS \] OTSQbS RS [O\SÒ \SUObWdO O ZOa W\bS`dS\QW]\Sa RS RSaO``]ZZ] 3\ QO[PW] S\ Z]a SabcRW]a _cS aS `STWS`S\ O ZO ^]P`ShO SZ `WSaU] OÔ`SQS Q][] c\ SZS[S\b] Q]\acabO\QWOZ _cS RSTW\S Z]a Q]\bSfb]a S\ Z]a QcOZSa Z]a g ZOa ^]P`Sa dWdS\ ¥1 [] aS ^cSRS ^`SbS\RS` Q]\b`]ZO` c\ SZS[S\b] _cS Sabt bO\ ^`SaS\bS S\ Z]a S\b]`\]a S\ Z]a QcOZSa aS RSaO``]ZZO\ Z]a ^`]gSQb]a- /T]`bc\ORO[S\bS \cSab`]a X dS\Sa \] Q][Ô`bS\ SaO dWaW \ RS Q]\b`]Z aW[^ZS[S\bS Z] WU\]Ò\ \] Z] bWS\S\ [cg ^`SaS\bS Z] Q]\aWRSÒ\ [O\SXOPZS ] Z] OQS^bO\ Q][] Ô`bS W\VS`S\bS RS Q [] g R \RS VO\ SaQ]UWR] bÒPOXO` ^S`] \] Q]\aWRSÒ\ _cS ^cSRO RSaOÔ`SQS` <]a Ô`SQS SabS c\ aWU\] ^]aWbWd] _cS RWQS [cQV] RS Q [] \cSab`]a S\b`SdWabOR]a g S\b`SdWabOROa aS OQS`QO\ O SabS aSQb]` ^`]TSaW]\OZ bO\ ^]PZOR] RS ^ZO\bSO[WS\b]a bSQ\]Q`tbWQ]a g US`S\QWOZWabOa _cS W\dS\bO\ [Sb]R]Z]U Oa g ^`]QSRW[WS\b]a ÔÒ S\Q]\bÒ` QS`bWRc[P`Sa S\ Q]\bSfb]a _cS aS QOÒQbS`WhO\ ^]` b]R] Z] Q]\bÒ`W] @343@3<17/A 070:7=5@È471/A 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ 7\T]`[S a]P`S 2SaO``]ZZ] ;c\RWOZ :cQVO Q]\bÒ ZO ^]P`ShO ;c\RW >`S\aO ;OR`WR 0]\W / 5 [Sh B]``Sa ; :: ;Q5SS @ g >S`Wa 8 & µ¥?c{ Q]\]QW[WS\b] ÔÒ _c{ RSaO``]ZZ]- @STZSfW]\Sa RSaRS ZO W\dSabWUOQW \ c\WdSàWbO`WO¶ 1][c\WQOQW \ ^`SaS\bORO S\ SZ 7D 1]\U`Sa] C\WdSàWROR g 1]]^SÒQW \ OZ 2SaO``]ZZ] " \]dWS[P`S 0SZZObS`Ò 0O`QSZ]\O 2cP]Wa / µ2SaO``]ZZ]¶ S\ >{`Sh RS /`[W ] 9 RW` 2WQQW]\O`W] RS /QQW \ 6c[O\WbO`WO g RS 1]]^SÒQW \ OZ 2SaO``]ZZ] 7QO`WO 635=/ 0O`QSZ]\O 0WZPO] ^^ %# %& 3c`]ÔWR " /WR 2SZWdS`g ;SbV]Ra D]Z >`]XSQb 1gQZS ;O\OUS[S\b 5cWRSZW\Sa 3c`]^S/WR 1]]^SÒbW]\ =TTWQS 0`caSZOa 4S``S`] 5 & /^]gO\R] Z]a >`]QSa]a RS 2SaO``]ZZ] 3\T]_cSa g [{b]R]a ÔÒ c\O OgcRO W\QZcaWdO 2]Qc[S\b]a RS BÒPOX] 4c\ROQW \ 1O`]ZW\O ;OR`WR 5 [Sh ; g AO\OVcXO 8 / ''' 3Z AWabS[O 7\bS`\OQW]\OZ RS 1]]^SÒQW \ OZ 2SaO``]ZZ] 1723/: ;OR`WR 5]cZSb 2 µ2SaO``]ZZ] Vc[O\]¶ S\ 1]\WZZ 8 Q]]`R 5Z]aO`W] ÔÒ c\O A]QWSROR 7\bS`QcZbcÒZ 0O\QOXO DOZS\QWO ÔU " " 5`SS\ 2 & 2S ZO ^]P`ShO OZ ^]RS` 7\bS`[ \ =fTO[ 0O`QSZ]\O <OÒgO\ 2 1VO[PSà @ AVOV ; 9 g >SbSaQV > 1`g ]cb T]` QVO\US =fT]`R C\WdSàWbg ^`Saa <Se G]`Y =PaS`dOb]`W] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR S\ 3aÔ O $ 7\T]`[S /\cOZ 8 dS\Sa $ 7\XcdS ;OR`WR =123 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ $ 0cS\Oa ^`tQbWQOa `SQWS\bS[S\bS WRS\bWTWQOROa RS USabW \ ÔÒ `SacZbOR]a RS RSaO``]ZZ] =123 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ >O` a 2Wa^]\WPZS S\ Vbb^( eee ]SQR ]Ù RObO]SQR !# ## !$&#!$! ^RT ITSQVO RS Q]\acZbO $ RS ]QbcP`S RS &K >{`Sh RS /`[W ] 9 % µ3Z Q]\QS^b] g SZ ca] RS ZO aSUc`WROR Vc[O\O( O\tZWaWa Q` bWQ] RS aca ^]bS\QWOZWRORSa g `WSaU]a¶ @SdWabO 172=0 R¸/TSà 7\bS`\OQW]\OZa %$

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

>S`Wa 8 0]\W / g 4]\aSQO ; & Âµ;tabS` S\ >]Z bWQOa g >`]QSa]a RS 2SaO``]ZZ] S\ ZO C>D @STZSfW]\Sa a]P`S c\ S\T]_cS Ô`bWQWÔbWd] bO\b] S\ Z]a Q]\bS\WR]a Q][] S\ ZO USabWÂ&#x201E;\Â¶ 1][c\WQOQWÂ&#x201E;\ ^`SaS\bORO S\ SZ 7D 1]\U`Sa] C\WdSàWROR g 1]]^SÒQWÂ&#x201E;\ OZ 2SaO``]ZZ] " \]dWS[P`S 0SZZObS`Ò 0O`QSZ]\O >`]UÒ[O RS <OQW]\Sa C\WROa ÔÒ SZ 2SaO``]ZZ] ><C2 ''" 7\T]`[S 2SaO``]ZZ] 6c[O\] ''" 4]\R] RS 1cZbcÒ 3Q]\Â&#x201E;[WQO ;{fWQ] >`]UÒ[O RS <OQW]\Sa C\WROa ÔÒ SZ 2SaO``]ZZ] ><C2 % 7\T]`[S 2SaO``]ZZ] 6c[O\] % & :O ZcQVO Q]\bÒ SZ QO[PW] QZW[tbWQ] A]ZWRO`WROR T`S\bS O c\ [c\R] RWdWRWR] ;c\RW >`S\aO ;OR`WR @Sg 4 g CÙ]WbW / # ;O\cOZ RS USabWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ QWQZ] RSZ ^`]gSQb] S\ ZO OQQWÂ&#x201E;\ Vc[O\WbO`WO =PÒ A]QWOZ RS ZO 4c\ROQWÂ&#x201E;\ :O 1OWfO 0O`QSZ]\O 2Wa^]\WPZS S\ Vbb^( eee WSQOV ]Ù ITSQVO RS Q]\acZbO $ RS ]QbcP`S RS &K AtSh > ''# 3Z Ac` S\ SZ /cZO AS[W\O`W] RS 7\dSabWUOQW]\Sa ÔÒ ZO Ôh 1S\b`] >WU\ObSZZW HOÒU]hO AS\ / 2SaO``]ZZ] g ZWPS`bOR >ZO\SbO 0O`QSZ]\O E]]R 5 ! ÂµAbOgW\U aSQc`S abOgW\U ^]`( bVS Âµ4OcabWO\ 0OÙOW\Â¶ E]`ZR 2SdSZ]^[S\b ! ! ^^ "## "%

8Â&#x201E;dS\Sa g USabWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ `WSaU]

9D8JB:CIDH

8Oc[S 1O`P]\SZZ ASPO``]XO 2W`SQb]` RS µ1cORS`\]a RS >SROU]U O¶

:a g^Zh\d Zc Za h^hiZbV ZYjXVi^kd# 6XZgXV YZ hjh aZXijgVh! Y^V\c hi^Xdh n egdiZXX^dcZh

6Og c\ bW^] RS `WSaU] _cS ac^]\S Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ S W\\]dOQW \ Oc\_cS O_c \]a ]QcÔ[]a RSZ `WSaU] SRcQObWd] _cS ^]` aca STSQb]a RSPS Q]\b`]ZOàS g SdWbOàS C\O RS aca [O\WTSabOQW]\Sa [ta S[PZS[tbWQOa Sa SZ TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` Q]\QS^b] ÔÒUcOa POX] SZ _cS aS Q]PWXO\ RWdSàOa W\bS`^`SbOQW]\Sa g aWbcOQW]\Sa C\ TS\ [S\] _cS aS Sf^ZWQO O Ô`bW` RS ZOa SabOR abWQOa g RS Z]a Q]\RWQW]\O\bSa a]QWOZSa g Sab`cQbcÒZSa ^S`] bO[PW{\ O Ô`bW` RS Z] _cS acQSRS S\ SZ W\bS`W]` RS ZOa OcZOa g RS ZOa VWab]`WOa RS dWRO RS QVWQ]a g QVWQOa Q]\Q`SbOa <] b]R] _cSRO S\ SZ RWOU\ abWQ] /Z TW\OZ aS O^c\bO\ OZUc\Oa ]`WS\bOQW]\Sa ÔÒ bÒbO` RS ^`SdS\W` g USabW]\O` [ta ORSQcORO[S\bS Z]a `WSaU]a SRcQObWd]a 6OPZO[]a W\RWabW\bO[S\bS RS OR]ZSaQS\QWO g XcdS\bcR ÔÒ `STS`W`\]a O c\ ^S` ]R] _cS aS S[^WShO O^`]fW[ORO[S\bS O Z]a " O ]a ³^]` O_cSZZ] RS ZO Q`SQWS\bS ^`SQ]QWROR XcdS\WZ³ g bS`[W\O VOQWO Z]a O ]a 2S OV ZO W[^]`bO\QWO _cS ]b]ÙO O ZO 3A= 3\aS O\hO ASQc\RO`WO =PZWUOb]`WO >OZOPÒa QZOdS( @WSaU] 7\\]dOQW \ 4ÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` /PO\R]\] SaQ]ZO` =^]`bc\WROR :WPS`bOR 3Z `WSaU] Q][] SZ Q]\TZWQb] a]\ W\VS`S\bSa O ZO Q]\RWQW \ Vc[O\O g Sabt\ ^`SaS\bSa S\ Z]a RWabW\b]a t[PWb]a RS ZO dWRO a]QWOZ >S`] S\ c\ [c\R] QORO dSh [ta OQSZSÒR] Q]\ QO[PW]a _cS aS dO\ acQSRWS\R] aW\ b`SUcO) [ta Q][^ZWQOR] S\ SZ _cS \] aW`dS\ ZOa `Sa^cSabOa aW[^ZSa O Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa Q][^ZSX]a g R]\RS VOg _cS `SQc``W` O Sf^ZWQOQW]\Sa [cZbWQOcaOZSa g O \O`ÒbWdOa W\bS`RWaQW^ZW\O`Sa) g [ta W[^`SdWaWPZS RSPWR] O ZOa R]a QW`Qc\abO\QWOa O\bS`W]`Sa SZ Q]\QS^b] RS `WSaU] OR_cWS`S c\ QO`tQbS` ^]ZWa{[WQ] g S\ OZUc\]a QOa]a ZOa T`]\bSÒa S\b`S SZ `WSaU] Q][] Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ g OdS\bcÒ ^]` c\ ZOR] g SZ `WSaU] Q][] TÒQOa] [OZSabO` RSaS\QOXS g RSaQ]\b`]Z ^]` ]bÒ OR_cWS`S\ OaW[Wa[] RSZW[WbOQW]\Sa [ta Q][^ZSXOa g acbWZSa ;ta O \ QcO\R] Z]a `Wb]a RS bÒ\aWQW \ RS ZO XcdS\bcR aS O\bWQWÔ\ ³VOg _cWS\ VOPZO RS OR]ZSaQS\QWO ^]`_cS b]R] aS VOQS g aS ^`cSPO O\bSa³ g aS `SbÒaO\ OZ ^`]^W] bWS[^] ³^]`_cS Z]a SabcRW]a aS OZOÙO\ SZ OQQSa] O c\ ^cSab] RS bÒPOX] TWX] Sa [ta bO`R ] g ZO W\RS^S\RS\QWO RSZ V]UO` TO[WZWO` aS RS[]Ò G QcO\R] ZOa ]TS`bOa RS ]QW] g Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ aS [cZbW^ZWQO\ bO\b] S\ Z]a V]UO`Sa Q][] S\ Z]a \cSd]a bS[^Z]a RSZ VW^S`Q]\ac[] QO^WbOZWabO /Z bWS[^] _cS Q`SQS\ Z]a [WSR]a ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa W\Q]\b`]ZOPZSa g ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS USabW]\O` g S\QOchO` ORSQcORO[S\bS Z]a `WSaU]a B]R] SZZ] OTSQbO bO[PW{\ O ZO SRcQOQW \ [SRWO\bS c\O SaQ]ZO`WhOQW \ _cS aS ^`]Z]\UO g SfbWS\RS O b]RO ZO ^]PZOQW \ Q]\ \cSdOa SfWUS\QWOa g ]^]`bc\WRORSa T]`[ObWdOa 6OQS bO\ a Z] c\Oa R{QOROa O^S\Oa aS VOPZOPO RS TÒQOa] g RSaS`QW \ SaQ]ZO` ^]`_cS SZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] O Ô`bW` RS ZO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

SRcQOQW \ aSQc\RO`WO SabOPO `SaS`dOR] O c\Oa {ZWbSa [WS\bÒa ZO [Og]` O RS X dS\Sa W\U`SaOPO OZ b{`[W\] RS ZO SaQcSZO ^`W[O`WO OZ [S`QOR] RS bÒPOX] 3aO SÒ ZO \]`[OZWROR 1][] Z] SÒ _cS S\ [cQV]a ^cSPZ]a \] VOP O W\abWbcb]a RS 3\aS O\hO ;SRWO g S\ ZOa QWcRORSa aS ^]R O\ Q]\bO` Q]\ Z]a RSR]a RS c\O [O\] 6]g SZ ÔWaOXS aS VO bÒ\aT]`[OR] ÒRWQOZ[S\bS

3Z `WSaU]( c\O ]^]`bc\WROR Q`SObWdO S W\\]dOR]Ò >]` ]bÒ Ô`bS \] VOg _cS ]ZdWRO` _cS bOZ Q][] VO\ bS]`WhOR] Ocb]`Sa Q][] 5WRRS\a g 0SQY OQS`QO RS ZO a]QWSROR RSZ `WSaU] {abS \] RSXO RS aS` c\O Q]\ab`cQQW \ a]QWOZ _cS ]PSRSQS O Q`WbS`W]a QcZbcÒZSa []ÒZSa g ^]Z bWQ]a O Ô`bW` RS Z]a QctZSa aS OQ]bO c\ Q`WbS`W] [ta `Sab`WQbWd] ] OPWS`b] RSZ [Wa[] OZ WUcOZ _cS ac aWS[^`S ^]Z{[WQ] SbW_cSbOXS RS \]`[OZWROR g O\]`[OZWROR RS Q]\RcQbO OQS^bOPZS ] W\OQS^bOPZS RS {fWb] g RS TÒQOa] 3Z aS\bWR] RSZ `WSaU] Q][] aW\ \W[] RS ]^]`bc\WROR g Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ Sa \SQSaO`W] ÔÒ _cS ZO XcdS\bcR bÒ\aWbS Q]\ ZWPS`bOR Ocb]\][ O g Q`SObWdWROR VOQWO ZO ORcZbSh aW\ SfQSaWd]a bcbSZOXSa g ^`]bSQQW]\Wa[]a :O a]QWSROR _cS aSQcSabÒ `S^`W[S ] RWZcgS Sab]a Ob`WPcb]a Sabt ^S`RWS\R] QO^WbOZ W\\]dOR]`) g ZO SaQcSZO _cS \] Z]a SabW[cZO [O\bWS\S ZO [WÒRO [ta TWXORO S\ SZ ÔaOR] _cS S\ SZ Tcbc`] 3abOa bS\aW]\Sa W\bSÙS\SÒQW]\OZSa S\b`S ZWPS`bOR g Q]\b`]Z VO\ aWR] O[^ZWO[S\bS SabcRWOROa RS RWabW\b]a ^c\b]a RS dWabO 8Oc[S 4c\Sa c\] RS Z]a O\OZWabOa [ta ^`]ZWX]a S\ SZ bS[O _cS \]a ]QcÔ Z] Q]\QS^bcOZWhO RS SabS []R]( µ3\ RWdSà]a SaQ`Wb]a a]P`S OR]ZSaQS\QWO VS OTW`[OR] _cS c\O RS ZOa [SX]`Sa RSTW\WQW]\Sa RS OR]ZSaQS\QWO _cS VOP O S\Q]\bÒR] S\ [W dWRO ^`]TSaW]\OZ SÒ ZO RS O_cSZ OR]ZSaQS\bS _cS aS RSTW\ O Q][] µc\ Sf^Z]ÒR]` `S^`W[WR]¶ C\O RSTW\WQW \ _cS `STZSXO U`tTWQO[S\bS ZO Q]\bÒRWQQW \ ^S`[O\S\bS S\b`S SZ OR]ZSaQS\bS _cS _cWS`S Sf^S`W[S\bO` g RSaQcP`W` \cSd]a [c\R]a g ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ORcZbOa _cS \] RSaSO` O\ \W\Uc\O Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ _cS ^`STS`W` O\ _cS SZ OR]ZSaQS\bS aS aWUcWSÒ []dWS\R] S\ c\ S\b]`\] ^` fW[] g Q]\]QWR] POX] ac ac^S`dWaW \ ¶ :Oa bÒgSQb]`WOa RS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g RS ZO XcdS\bcR POaQcZO\ S\b`S SZ aS\bWR] RSZ `WSaU] g ZO \SQSaO`WO aSUc`WROR 8]O\ RSZ /ZQthO` ^Z]PZS[ObWhO SabO RWagc\bWdO( µ3\ ^`W\QW^W] SZ `WSaU] Sa \SUObWd] aW Z] S\bS\RS[]a Q][] ^SZWU`]) ZO aSUc`WROR Sa ^]aWbWdO aW \]a bÒ\a[WbS QS`bShO QOZ[O g bÒ\_cWZWROR C\O aSUc\RO ZSQbcÒ S\ QO[PW] ^cSRS QO[PWO` SabO ^`W[SÒ dWaW \ gO _cS SZ `WSaU] Sa ZO dWRO [WS\bÒa _cS ZO aSUc`WROR ^cSRS aS` ^]` SXS[^Z] ZO Ôh RS Z]a QS[S\bS`W]a ¶ C\O RWabW\QW \ bO\ ^`SQWaO Q][] \SQSaO`WO >]`_cS S\ ZO SRcQOQW \ ³OZ [S\]a O_cSZZO _cS O^cSabO ^]` ZO W\\]dOQW \ SZ QO[PW] g ZO bÒ\aT]`[OQW \ RS ZO SaQcSZO³ SZ `WSaU] Sa aW\ \W[] RS OdS\bcÒ RS Qc`W]aWROR RS ÔaW \ ^]` SZ Q]\]QW[WS\b] RS dWbOZWROR RS ZWPS`bOR RS O^`S\RWhOXS O Ô`bW` RSZ S\aOg] g S``]` RS RcRO g RS W\bS``]UOQW \ RS O^S`bcÒ RS Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ RS aOQcRWRO RS ^`]d]QOQW \ g RS cb]^ O >]` SZ Q]\bÒ`W] ZO aSUc`WROR aS Oa]QWO O ZO `cbW\O O ZO W\S`QWO O ZO []\]b]\ O OZ Q]\T]`[Wa[] O ZO Ô`tZWaWa OZ QWS``S OZ [WSR]( O ZOa QcZbcÒa Q]\aS`dOR]Òa g SaS\QWOZWabOa _cS XcabWTWQO\ SZ [O\bS\W[WS\b] W\OZbSÒPZS RSZ RWaQcà] WRS]Z UWQ] RSZ ^]RS` ^]Z bWQ] g RSZ ]`RS\ a]QWOZ :Oa ^`tQbWQOa SaQ]ZO`Sa [ta W\\]dOR]Òa g SfWb]aOa _cS ObWS\RS\ [ta OZ ^`]QSa] SRcQObWd] UZ]POZ g RS Tcbc`] _cS O Z]a `SacZbOR]a OQOR{[WQ]a

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

Ô`QWOZSa g RS c\ ^`SaS\bS ST [S`] Ô`bS\ RS SabO TWZ]a]T O RSZ `WSaU] A]\ ZOa _cS O^cSabO\ ^]` c\ RWtZ]U] ^S`[O\S\bS S\b`S SZ ^`]TSa]ÒR] g SZ OZc[\OR] S\ ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ `SQ]\ab`cQQW \ g bÒ\a[WaW \ RSZ Q]\]QW[WS\b]) O Q]abO ]PdWO[S\bS RS `S\c\QWO` O ZO Sab`WQbO aSUc`WROR _cS ^`]^]`QW]\O SZ \] aOZWàS RSZ ^`]UÒ[O g RSZ ZWP`] RS bSfb] ³b]R] Q]\b`]ZOR] g ^`SdWaWPZS³ g RS RSXOàS a]`^`S\RS` ^]` ZOa aS\ROa RSZ RWtZ]U] g ZO W[^`]dWaOQW \ b`cTOROa RS W\aSUc`WRORSa RS W\QS`bWRc[P`Sa g RS a]`^`SaOa W[^`SdWaWPZSa 3abS Sa SZ RSaOT ]( ^S`RS` SZ [WSR] O d]ZO` C\O OdS\bcÒ _cS aS T]`XO O Ô`bW` RSZ [cbc] `Sa^Sb] S\b`S Z]a RWabW\b]a OUS\bSa SRcQObWd]a) RS aW\SÙWOa g Q][^ZWQWRORSa _cS aS S\`W_cSQS\ Q]\ ZO Q]ZOP]ÒQW \ >S`] Sa SdWRS\bS _cS \] Sa Q]\dS\WS\bS \W aOZcROPZS W\abOZOàS S\ SZ `WSaU] ^S`[O\S\bS ZO\hOàS Sa^]\bt\SO[S\bS OZ dOQ ] OZ OdS\bc`Wa[] Sab{`WZ g bÒ[^]a] _cS \] Q]\RcQS O \W\Uc\O Ô`bS >OÒ O^`S\RS` O dWdW` Q]\ SZ `WSaU] g ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S aS `S_cWS`S\ `STS`S\bSa {bWQ]a g []ÒZSa Oa Q][] c\O a ZWRO SRcQOQW \ ÔÒ ZO QWcRORO\ O QSZ]aO Q]\ SZ Qc[^ZW[WS\b] RS Z]a 2S`SQV]a 6c[O\]a g RS ZO 7\TO\QWO g Q]\ ZO ^S`bW\S\bS QO`bO RS RSPS`Sa g ]PZWUOQW]\Sa _cS Q]\ZZSdO ZO Q]\dWdS\QWO RS[]Q`tbWQO :O T]`[OQW \ RS c\ Q`WbS`W] []ÒZ Ocb \][] Sa ZO [SX]` UOÒ\b O ÔÒ []dSàS g Tc\QW]\O` ORSQcORO[S\bS S\ ZO a]QWSROR g S\ ZO SaQcSZO RSZ `WSaU] 3abS bSfb] \] ]PabO\bS aS QS\bÒ S\ Z]a TOQb]`Sa ^S`dSà]a RSZ `WSaU] Oa]QWOR]a OZ [OZSabO` OZ TÒQOa] ZO T`cabÒQW \ SZ OPO\R]\] SZ RSad \QcZ] Vc[O\] SZ RSaS\QOXS a]QWOZ g O ]bÒa [O\WTSabOQW]\Sa _cS bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ ZO ^`WdOQW \ ZO ^{`RWRO ] ZO RSTWQWS\bS USabW \ RS ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa SRcQObWdOa AWbcOQW]\Sa _cS ^`SQWaO\ RS c\O W\bS`dS\QW \ SRcQObWdO RS QO`tQbS` ^`SdS\bWd] g ÔZWObWd] Q]\ SZ ^`]^ aWb] RS aOZW` RSZ ^]h] ] Z]UÒ` OZU \ bW^] RS `SQc^SÒQW \ [SX]Ò g {fWb] S\ ZOa bÒgSQb]`WOa ^Sà]\OZSa g OQOR{[WQOa RSZ OZc[\OR] C\O RS ZOa bSaWa _cS O_c aS a]abWS\S Sa _cS SZ `WSaU] ³aSU \ Q][] aS [W`S³ Sa OZ [Wa[] bWS[^] Ô`bS RSZ ^`]PZS[O g RS ZO a]ZcQW \ /\bSa RS Q][S\bO` Z]a STSQb]a ^S`dSà]a RSZ `WSaU] Q]\dWS\S RSaVOQS` OZUc\]a b ^WQ]a OQS`QO RS ZO W[OUS\ a]QWOZ _cS aS Q]\ab`cgS [SRWtbWQO g a]QWOZ[S\bS RS ZO XcdS\bcR /ZU] _cS S\ \ORO Q]\b`WPcgS O TOQWZWbO` c\O ORSQcORO USabW \ RS ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa SRcQObWdOa( SZW[W\O\R] `WSaU]a \SUObWd]a g `SQ]\]QWS\R] Z]a `WSaU]a PS\STWQW]a]a

1]\bÒ b ^WQ]a g SabS`S]bW^]a( SZ \WdSZ T]`[ObWd] Q`SQS 2SaUO\OR]a >`]PZS[tbWQ]a 7``Sa^]\aOPZSa 2Sa[]bWdOR]a 1]\TZWQbWd]a 2SZW\QcS\bSa S\ ^]bS\QWO 1O`S\bSa RS dOZ]`Sa 6SR]\WabOa =PaSaW]\OR]a ^]` SZ ^`SaS\bS g RSa^`S]QcÔR]a ^]` ac Tcbc`] 6S O_c OZUc\]a SabS`S]bW^]a _cS ^`]gSQbO\ Q]\ SfQSaWdO T`SQcS\QWO Z]a [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQW \ >]`_cS ZO ^`]gSQQW \ RS SabOa W[tUS\Sa S\ ZO [SRWRO _cS aS aW[^ZWTWQO\ aS a]P`SRW[S\aW]\O\ g aS US\SÒZWhO\ Z]UÒ\ c\ [Og]` W[ÔQb] S[]bWd] S\ ZO OcRWS\QWO g dS\RS\ [ta >]`_cS S\ SZ ^S`W]RWa[] Q]\bW\ O Tc\QW]\O\R] SZ dWSX] OfW][O RS _cS ZOa [SX]`Sa \]bWQWOa a]\ [OZOa \]bWQWOa >]` ]b`] ZOR] Sab]a [S\aOXSa QOZO\ S\ ZO a]QWSROR g S\ QWS`bO [SRWRO aW`dS\ RS Q]O`bORO ÔÒ S\[OaQOÒ` ZOa ^`]^WOa QO`S\QWOa g [WaS`WOa ORcZbOa g ÔÒ WRSOZWhO` ZOa P]\RORSa RS c\ ÔaOR] _cS aWS[^`S aS Q]\aWRSÒ [SX]` VOQWS\R] OPabÒQQW \ RS ZOa \cSdOa RW\t[WQOa g Q]\bSfb]a a]QWOZSa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

2WdSà]a SabcRW]a `SQWS\bSa 4c\ROQW \ 4/2 0`cZZSb 5 [Sh 5Ò\SZZ 3Zh] `SQ]US\ d]QSa RS X dS\Sa g OR]ZSaQS\bSa g SZ `SacZbOR] \]a [cSabÒ c\ RWOU\ abWQ] [S\]a c\WT]`[S \SUObWd] g RSaSa^SÒ\hOR]` C\O T]b]UÒT O [cZbWQ]Z]` C\O `SOZWROR VSbS`]U{\SO g ZZS\O RS [ObWQSa 0OabO ROàS c\O dcSZbO ^]` Z]a W\abWbcb]a QS\b`]a RS T]`[OQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ g RS SRcQOQW \ RS ^Sà]\Oa ORcZbOa g c\WdSàWRORSa ÔÒ ^S`QWPW` ZO VSbS`]US\SWROR RS OQbWbcRSa dWdS\QWOa Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a g QcZbcÒa AW\ S\bÒ` O T]\R] S\ SZ O\tZWaWa Q][ÔÒbWd] Q]\ ]bÒa {^]QOa aW OZ [S\]a ^]RS[]a OTW`[O` _cS V]g Sab]a Q]ZSQbWd]a a]\ [ta RWdSà]a S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZO O[^ZWOQW \ RS ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa RS b]R] bW^]) _cS ac O^SU] OZ [c\R] RWUWbOZ W\b`]RcQS ]b`]a ZS\UcOXSa Q][c\WQObWd]a g ]b`]a ^`]QSa]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \) g _cS Z]a `STS`S\bSa S WQ]\]a a]\ [ta ST [S`]a g QO[PWO\bSa :O W\bS`dS\QW \ SRcQObWdO a]P`S ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g ZO XcdS\bcR XcdS\WZ SfWUS c\ QO[PW] RS [WÒRO ÔÒ RSaVOQS` TOZa]a SabS`S]bW^]a g Q][^`S\RS` _cS \] Sa Z] [Wa[] aW ZO dS[]a a Z] Q][] c\ Q [cZ] RS ^`]PZS[Oa _cS aW ZO ^S`QWPW[]a Q][] c\ OPO\WQ] RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa ÔÒ USabW]\O` STWQOh[S\bS SZ `WSaU] ^]aWbWd] g \SUObWd]) g ÔÒ S\bS\RS` _cS \] ^cSRS VOPZOàS RS ZO XcdS\bcR S\ aW\UcZO` aW\] S\ ^ZcÒZ ÔÒ bÒbO` ORSQcORO[S\bS ZO Q`SQWS\bS RWdSàWROR 2S SZZ] \]a ]QcÔ`S[]a [ta RSbS\WRO[S\bS S\ SZ QO^ bcZ] TW\OZ RS OZbS`\ObWdOa 6OabO O_c c\O P`SdS O^`]fW[OQW \ O Z]a Oa^SQb]a [ta Sab`WQbO[S\bS SRcQObWd]a 3\ SZ QO^ bcZ] [ta \SbO[S\bS W\ab`cQbWd] OQOR{[WQ] c\O TOZaO RWdWaW \ O ZO _cS `SQc``W[]a a Z] O STSQb]a T]`[OZSa RSZ RWaQcà] Q]\dWS\S `SPObW` SZ b ^WQ] bO\ TOZa] Q][] SfbS\RWR] RS _cS SZ OZc[\OR] Sa QORO dSh ^S]` g _cS aOPS [S\]a Q]aOa _cS ZOa US\SÒQW]\Sa O\bS`W]`Sa <] Sa dS`ROR ^]` dO`WOa Òh]\Sa Oc\_cS SZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] [cSab`S RSTWQWS\bSa UÒdSa g ZbW[O[S\bS aS VOgO\ S\QS\RWR] OZUc\Oa OZO`[Oa RS RWdSà] QOZOR] <] Sa dS`ROR S\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` ^]`_cS ZO SfbS\aW \ RS ZO SaQ]ZO`WROR ]PZWUOb]`WO VOabO Z]a $ O ]a ³O ^SaO` RS aca RWaTc\QW]\Sa g RWTWQcZbORSa S\ ac O^ZWQOQW \³ ^`]^]`QW]\O c\ \WdSZ T]`[ObWd] ac^S`W]` g c\ QOcROZ RS Q]\]QW[WS\b]a _cS \c\QO OZQO\hO`]\ ZOa US\SÒQW]\Sa O\bS`W]`Sa 3a QWS`b] _cS [cQV]a OZc[\]a g OZc[\Oa aS RSaQcSZUO\ g TÒQOaO\) g _cS SZ \WdSZ OQOR{[WQ] [SRW] RSZ OZc[\OR] RS ZO 3A= g RSZ 0OQVWZZSÒb] Sa W\TS`W]` OZ RS VOQS OZUc\Oa R{QOROa( ^S`] aS bÒbO RS c\O Q][ÔÒQW \ S\UO ]aO ^]`_cS O\bSa Sab]a SabcRW]a bS\ O\ c\ TcS`bS aSaU] SZWbWabO g aSZSQbWd] ³a Z] OQQSR O c\O [W\]` O³ [WS\bÒa _cS OV]Ò bÒa ZO O^`]POQW \ RS ZO :=5A3 SZ QWS\ ^]` QWS\ RSZ OZc[\OR] Q]\ b]R]a aca ^`]PZS[Oa g RWdSàWRORSa ³OQ`SQS\bOROa Q]\ ZO ZZSUORO RSZ OZc[\OR] W\[WUÒ\bS³ U]hO RS SabO SaQ]ZO`WROR ^`]Z]\UORO :O RS[]QÒbWhOQW \ RS ZO S\aS O\hO Q]\ZZSdO UÒ\RSa PS\STWQW]a ^S`] bO[PW{\ OZUc\]a RSaOXcabSa _cS Q]\dWS\S W` Q]``WUWS\R] Q]\ SZ bWS[^] :O \WQO Q][ÔÒQW \ `WUc`]aO Sa ZO _cS ^]R` O SabOPZSQSàS S\b`S SZ POX] ^]`QS\bOXS RS SabcRWO\bSa RS S\b]\QSa Q]\ c\ ^]`QS\bOXS aW[WZO` RS SabcRWO\bSa S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR( aW\ RcRO SZ `SacZbOR] S\ QcO\b] OZ \WdSZ T]`[ObWd] aS` O OZbO[S\bS TOd]ÒPZS O Sab]a ZbW[]a 3\ aSUc\R] ZcUO` ^]`_cS ZO TOQWZWROR Q]\ _cS aS OQQSRS O ZO W\US\bS W\T]`[OQW \ O bÒd{a RS ZOa B71 BSQ\]Z]U Oa RS ZO 7\T]`[OQW \ g ZO 1][c\WQOQW \ TcSÒ RSZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] Oa Q][] ZOa \c[S`]aOa ]TS`bOa SfbÒSaQ]ZO`Sa g QcZbcÒZSa ³R \RS VOg [cQV] R \RS SZSUW`³ ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS dWOXO` OZ SfbÒ\XS`] g RS O^`S\RS` WRW][Oa SbQ W\QWRS\ RW`SQbO ] W\RW`SQbO[S\bS a]P`S SZ \WdSZ T]`[ObWd] /c\_cS Q][] dS`S[]a [ta ORSZO\bS ZO XcdS\bcR OQQSRS RS T]`[O RSaWUcOZ OZ RWaT`cbS RS Sab]a

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

PWS\Sa g ]^]`bc\WRORSa QW`Qc\abO\QWO _cS OQ`SQWS\bO ZO RSaWUcOZROR g c\ [Og]` `WSaU] RS TÒQOa] ] SfQZcaW \ SaQ]ZO` g a]QWOZ G S\ bS`QS` ZcUO` ^]`_cS RWdSàOa SdOZcOQW]\Sa \OQW]\OZSa S W\bS`\OQW]\OZSa [cSabÒ\ SZ ^`]U`Sa] Sf^S`W[S\bOR] /ZUc\]a SXS[^Z]a( SZ W\T]`[S µ>O\]Ò[O RS ZO 3RcQOQW \ &¶ aS OZO _cS 3aÔ O VO [SX]ÒR] !% ^c\b]a S\ SZ \WdSZ T]`[ObWd] RS Z]a X dS\Sa T`S\bS O Z]a ! ^c\b]a _cS VO\ Q`SQWR] Q][] [SRWO SZ `Sab] RS Z]a Ô aSa RS ZO =123 3abS SabcRW] `SOZWhOR] a]P`S ROb]a Q]``Sa^]\RWS\bSa OZ Qcà] # $ aS QS\bÒ S\ Z]a RWabW\b]a bÒ[]a RS ZO S\aS O\hO ^]ab]PZWUOb]`WO g ^]\S RS `SZWSdS ZO ^`]U`SaW \ Sf^S`W[S\bORO S\ Z]a b`SW\bO ZbW[]a O ]a VOabO Q]\dS`bWàS S\ SZ [ta S_cWbObWd] RS ZO =123 Oc\_cS aWUcS bS\WS\R] ZO bOaO [ta POXO RS bWbcZOR]a POQVWZZS`Sa 3Z Q{ZSP`S 7\T]`[S >7A/ Q]\bÒ`WO[S\bS O Z] _cS aS OZO\ [cQV]a O\tZWaWa O^`SacÒR]a g bWbcZO`Sa RS ^`S\aO aS\aOQW]\OZWabOa [cSabÒ _cS 3aÔ O aS S\QcS\bÒ S\ SZ ^SZ]b \ RS ZO [Og]` O RS Ô aSa RSZ S\b]`\] Sc`]^S] ³aSÔÒR]a ^]` RWTS`S\QWOa SabOR abWQO[S\bS W\aWU\WTWQO\bSa³ g _cS a Z] c\]a ^]Q]a Q][] 4W\ZO\RWO 1]`SO ] 8O^ \ ZSa OdS\bOXO\ acabO\QWOZ[S\bS 1OÒPO O 3Z ROb] SabOR abWQO[S\bS [ta aWU\WTWQObWd] Sa SZ POX] ^]`QS\bOXS RS OZc[\OR] SfQSZS\bS) g SZ ^`]PZS[O US\SÒZ _cS `SdWabS WR{\bWQO UÒdSROR Sa SZ RWd]`QW] RSZ Q]\]QW[WS\b] SaQ]ZO` RS ZO `SOZWROR Oa Q][] ac SaQOaO `SZSdO\QWO ÔÒ Q][^`S\RS`ZO g OT`]\bO` ^`]PZS[Oa RS ZO dWRO Q]bWRWO\O 3\b`S SZZ]a ZO Q][^`S\aW \ ZSQb]Ò >]` Sa] \] SfWabS c\O Q]``Sa^]\RS\QWO ZW\SOZ S\b`S TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` TÒQOa] a]QWOZ) Q][] \] ZO VOg S\b`S SZ {fWb] OQOR{[WQ] g {fWb] SaQ]ZO` g a]QWOZ S\bS\RWR] {abS \] S\ ac dSàW \ SQ]\ [WQO g [S`QO\bWZWabO aW\] S\ ac QOÔQWROR RS USabW]\O` ORSQcORO[S\bS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa g Z]a `SQcà]a RS ZO Q][c\WROR 3\ Q]\QZcaW \( bS\S[]a c\ \WdSZ T]`[ObWd] RS ZO XcdS\bcR _cS \] Sa ÔÒ ZO\hO` ZOa QO[Ô\Oa OZ dcSZ] g _cS _cWhta \] aS OXcabO O Z]a ^`]\ abWQ]a [ta ]^bW[WabOa RS 0]aQV[O Ocb]` RS µ5S\SÒQW \ 3W\abSW\( [ta ZWab]a [ta `t^WR]a [ta a]QWOPZSa¶ ^S`] bO[^]Q] aS OXcabO O ZOa dWaW]\Sa O^]QOZ ^bWQOa g QObOab`]TWabOa _cS ^`SaS\bO\ ZO XcdS\bcR OQbcOZ Q][] c\O US\SÒQW \ QcZbcÒZ[S\bS dS\WRO O [S\]a S W\QZca] O\OZTOPSbO

@]ab`]a [O\WTSabOQW]\Sa g \ [S`]a RSZ TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` :Oa RWabW\bOa a]QWSRORSa aWabS[Oa SRcQObWd]a g OQb]`Sa a]QWOZSa Q]\ab`cgS\ c\ Q]\QS^b] RWabW\b] RS TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` S\TObWhO\R] c\]a c ]b`]a TOQb]`Sa RS^S\RWS\R] RS ZOa Tc\QW]\Sa g `]ZSa _cS SXS`QS\ RS aca W\bS`SaSa g RS aca Sf^SQbObWdOa <] Sa Z] [Wa[] ÔÒ _cWS\ RW`WUS ZO ]`_cSabO ÔÒ OZ _cS b]QO aSU \ _cS W\ab`c[S\b] g ÔÒ SZ _cS OaWabS Q][] ^ PZWQ] >]` Sa] SabS TS\ [S\] aS Sf^`SaO RS []R] ^]ZWa{[WQ] Q][^ZSX] S W\QZca] Q]\bÒRWQb]`W] 3\ [W ZbW[] ZWP`]( µC\O SRcQOQW \ ÔÒ [O O\O¶ RWPcX] c\O O[^ZWO QO`b]UÒT O RSZ OZc[\OR] TÒQOaOR] _cS OV]Ò Q][^ZS[S\b]( SZ _cS aca^S\RS c\O ] dO`WOa OaWU\ObcÒa ] c\ QWQZ] OQOR{[WQ]) SZ _cS `S^WbS c\O ] dO`WOa dSQSa) SZ _cS \] ]PbWS\S SZ UÒRcOR] RS 3A=) SZ _cS \] O^`cSPO ZO aSZSQbWdWROR g \] ^cSRS S\bÒ` S\ ZO c\WdSàWROR) SZ _cS aS dS ]PZWUOR] O aSUcW` c\O QO``SÒ c\WdSàWbO`WO _cS \] QcS\bO S\b`S aca ]^QW]\Sa ^`STS`WROa) SZ _cS OQQSRS O ZO 4]`[OQW \ >`]TSaW]\OZ Q]\aWRSÒRO Q][] c\O QO``SÒ RS aSUc\R] ]`RS\ g c\ `STcUW] RS aS[WTÒQOaOR]a) SZ _cS O^`cSPO g aS ^`][]QW]\O O ^SaO` RS \] VOPS` OR_cW`WR] Z]a Q]\]QW[WS\b]a

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

g Q][^SbS\QWOa [ \W[Oa TWXOROa ^]` ZO :=3 :Sg =Ùt\WQO RS ZO 3RcQOQW \ ) SZ _cS aS S\QcS\bÒ S\ SZ ZbW[] Qcà] RS ac QO``SÒ c\WdSàWbO`WO g VO ]ZdWROR] PcS\O Ô`bS RS Z] _cS O^`S\RW S\ ZO 3A=) SZ _cS Z]UÒ c\ ^cSab] RS bÒPOX] S\ ac ^`]TSaW \ g aS dS ]PZWUOR] O `SQWQZOàS S\ QOaW b]R]) SZ OPaS\bWabO Ô`QWOZ ] b]bOZ) SZ _cS OPO\R]\O SZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd]) SZ _cS aS OPc``S g [cSabÒ c\O ^`]U`SaWdO RSaOTSQQW \ VOQWO ZO S\aS O\hO g SZ O^`S\RWhOXS) SZ _cS [O\WTWSabO ac [OZSabO` g `SQVOh] RS T]`[O OP ZWQO ] dW]ZS\bO) SZ _cS ]PbWS\S PcS\Oa \]bOa ^S`] \] aS ORO^bO O ZO W\abWbcQW \) SZ _cS O^`cSPO g ÔaO SZ Qcà] aW\ VOQS` ^`tQbWQO[S\bS \ORO) SZ _cS [cSabÒ RWTWQcZbORSa SaQ]ZO`Sa ZZO[ObWdOa ] OZbOa QOÔQWRORSa g aS ZSa S\aS O SfOQbO[S\bS Z] [Wa[]) SZ _cS \] ZS S\QcS\bÒ \W\U \ aS\bWR] O Z] _cS Sabt SabcRWO\R]) SZ _cS dS ZO W\abWbcQW \ SaQ]ZO` Q][] OZU] [cg SfbÒ ] g OZSXOR] RS ac `SOZWROR Q]bWRWO\O) SZ _cS QOaW \c\QO ObWS\RS \W aS Q]\QS\bÒ) SZ _cS W\Qc[^ZS aWabS[tbWQO[S\bS ZOa \]`[Oa g TOZbO SZ `Sa^Sb] OZ ^`]TSa]ÒR] g O aca ^`]^W]a Q][Ô S`]a) SZ _cS ^S`QWPS _cS Sa SZ ^`]TSa]ÒR] g ZO W\abWbcQW \ Z]a _cS ZS TOZbO\ aWabS[tbWQO[S\bS SZ `Sa^Sb]) SZ _cS \c\QO ZS VO UcabOR] W` O ZO SaQcSZO) SZ _cS O ^SaO` RS _cS ]RWO ZO SaQcSZO aWS[^`S ZS VO UcabOR] O^`S\RS` Q]aOa \cSdOa 1][] ^cSRS O^`SQWOàS ZO US]UÒT O RSZ TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` Sa dO`W]^W\bO S\ Tc\QW \ RS ac [OU\WbcR QcO\bWbObWdO g QcOZWbObWdO) O ac []ROZWROR R]\RS SZ `WSaU] W\QWRS S\ Oa^SQb]a RS Q]`bS [ta OQOR{[WQ] ] SRcQObWd] ] S\ Oa^SQb]a [ta Q]U\WbWd]a OTSQbWd]a ] a]QWOZSa) ] OZ QOcaO\bS RSZ TÒQOa]( OZc[\OR] ^`]TSa]ÒR] W\abWbcQW \ SaQ]ZO` S\b]`\] a]QWOZ¬ 2S b]R] VOg ^]`_cS ZOa QOcaOa aS S\b`S[ShQZO\ g ZOa `Sa^]\aOPWZWRORSa aS RWab`WPcgS\ Oc\_cS \] aWS[^`S Z] VOQS\ RS c\ []R] S_cWbObWd] \W aS `SQ]\]QS\ ^ PZWQO[S\bS aS OZO\R] Q]\ T`SQcS\QWO g RS [O\SÒ c\WRW[S\aW]\OZ ZO QcZÔPWZWhOQW \ RSZ OZc[\OR] 1OPS acPÒgO` _cS T`S\bS O ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO W\dSabWUOR]Ò R][W\O\bS _cS T]QOZWhO SZ PW\][W] {fWb] TÒQOa] OQOR{[WQ] S\ b{`[W\]a RS W\acTWQWS\QWOa g QO`S\QWOa RS RSbS`[W\OROa QOÔQWRORSa ] Q][^SbS\QWOa Sabt\ S[SÙWS\R] \cSdOa Z \SOa RS W\dSabWUOQW \ _cS aS ]QcÔ\ ^`W]`WbO`WO[S\bS RS Sf^Z]Ò` ZO RWabO\QWO _cS aSÔÒ Z]a W\bS`SaSa g aOPS`Sa RS Z]a X dS\Sa ³QVWQ]a g QVWQOa³ RS O_cSZZ] _cS ZSa ]T`SQS SZ QS\b`] SaQ]ZO` DOgO[]a O ZOa QWTÒa :O SabOR abWQO [ta ^`S]QcÔ\bS `Sa^SQb] OZ `WSaU] a]QWOZ g O ZO QcOZWTWQOQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ Sa ZO RSZ OPO\R]\] SaQ]ZO` ^`S[Obc`] ] RSZ OZc[\OR] _cS \] ]PbWS\S SZ UÒRcOR] RS 3A= O\bSa RS Z]a & O ]a( SZ ! S\ SZ O ] % SZ R]PZS _cS ZO [SRWO RS Z]a Ô aSa RS ZO C\W \ 3c`]^SO ¥:] ]PbWS\S\ ^]abS`W]`[S\bS bÒa RSXO` SZ QS\b`] RS aSQc\RO`WO- <] SfWabS\ ROb]a a]P`S SZ OZc[\OR] _cS Z] ]PbWS\S O bÒd{a RS Z]a >`]UÒ[Oa RS 5OÒ\b O A]QWOZ RSZ SfO[S\ ZWP`S ] RSZ UÒRcOR] RS 3A= ORO^bOR] S\ Z]a QS\b`]a RS SRcQOQW \ RS ^Sà]\Oa ORcZbOa ASU \ ROb]a RSZ ;W\WabS`W] RS 3RcQOQW \ a]QWOZWabO SabO bOaO RS TÒQOa] aS [O\bWS\S SabO\QORO RSaRS ''%) g aSU \ ROb]a RSZ >O`bWR] >]^cZO` QcO\R] U]PS`\OPO SZ ^]`QS\bOXS aS `SRcX] OZ # S\ =b`] ROb] WUcOZ[S\bS ^`S]QcÔ\bS( SZ ! & RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ RS & O " O ]a S\ SZ O ] # OPO\R]\O SZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] aW\ SabcRW]a ^]ab]PZWUOb]`W]a G ZO bOaO RSZ OZc[\OR] _cS aS UÒR O S\ 0OQVWZZSÒb] ] 1=C S\ Z]a O ]a O\bS`W]`Sa O ZO O^ZWQOQW \ RS ZO :=5A3 VO ÔaOR] RSZ !' OZ "" S\b`S ''" g # c\O QWTÒ [cg W\TS`W]` O ZO [SRWO Sc`]^SO :O SabOR abWQO RSZ TÒQOa] S\ ZO 3A= aS VO Q]\dS`bWR] S\ c\ ^`]PZS[O RS 3abOR] g Q]\abWbcgS SZ T]Q] RS ^`S]QcÔQW \ S W\bS`dS\QW \ ^`W]`WbO`WO ^]`

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

Ô`bS RSZ ;W\WabS`W] RS 3RcQOQW \ g RS ]b`]a ^]RS`Sa ^ PZWQ]a C\]a `SacZbOR]a _cS S\bc`PWO\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS [SX]Ò RSZ \WdSZ T]`[ObWd] RS ZO XcdS\bcR O\bSa aS OZOR]a g RWTWQcZbO\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS W\QZcaW \ g Q]VSaW \ a]QWOZ 3abS TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` Sa [Og]` S\ Z]a QVWQ]a _cS S\ ZOa QVWQOa( SZ !$ T`S\bS OZ # $ G Sa [cg RSaWUcOZ S\ ZOa RWdSàOa 1][c\WRORSa /cb \][Oa 3a \]b]`WO[S\bS [ta OZb] S\ O_cSZZOa h]\Oa bÒRWQW]\OZ g a]QWOZ[S\bS [ta RSaTOd]`SQWROa /\ROZcQ O 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO g 3fb`S[ORcÒ g S\ ZOa 1][c\WRORSa RS 1O\O`WOa g SZ ;SRWbS``t\S] 1ObOZc O >O a DOZS\QWO\] ;c`QWO g 0OZSO`Sa R]\RS Z]a X dS\Sa S\QcS\bÒ\ \c[S`]aOa g ObÒQbWdOa ]TS`bOa RS bÒPOX] \] QcOZWTWQOR] S\ Z]a aSQb]`Sa RS V]abSZS` O g RS ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \) Oc\_cS OV]Ò Q]\ ZO Q`WaWa SQ]\ [WQO g SZ RS``c[PS RSZ µP]][¶ W\[]PWZWO`W] [cQV]a RS Sab]a X dS\Sa S\ Ô`] bÒbO\ RS `SS\UO\QVOàS OZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] ÔÒ ]PbS\S` OZUc\O bWbcZOQW \ _cS ZSa ^S`[WbO OQQSRS` O ^cSab]a RS bÒPOX] [ta QcOZWTWQOR]a <] aWS[^`S Z] Q]\aWUcS\ ^]`_cS ZO RS[O\RO Sa bO\ TcS`bS _cS [cQVOa OcZOa RS SRcQOQW \ RS ^Sà]\Oa ORcZbOa Sabt\ aObcÒROa 1OaW ZO [WbOR RSZ OZc[\OR] `S^WbS OZU \ Qcà] a]P`S b]R] S\ ZO 3A= C\ ^]`QS\bOXS [cg OZb] Oc\_cS ZO `S^SbWQW \ \] Ô`SQS W\QWRW` S\ ZO [SX]Ò RSZ \WdSZ SRcQObWd] g SZ UÒR] RS {fWb] RSZ OZc[\OR] 3fWabS\ dO`WOa SdWRS\QWOa( Z]a `SacZbOR]a RS ZOa SdOZcOQW]\Sa >7A/ S\ \cSab`] Ô a) SZ OPO\R]\] RS ZO `S^SbWQW \ aOZd] QOa]a SfQS^QW]\OZSa S\ Ô aSa Q][] 4W\ZO\RWO _cS ]PbWS\S\ Z]a [SX]`Sa ^c\bcOQW]\Sa >7A/) ] ZOa `SQ][S\ROQW]\Sa RS \] `SQc``W` O SabO [SRWRO ^]` RS ZO =123 g ]b`]a ]ÙO\Wa[]a bÒa ZO `SOZWhOQW \ RS RWdSà]a SabcRW]a Q][ÔÒbWd]a 3fWabS ]b`] TOQb]` RS `WSaU] RW`SQbO ] W\RW`SQbO[S\bS Oa]QWOR] OZ TÒQOa] g OPO\R]\] SaQ]ZO`( SZ OPaS\bWa[] C\ TS\ [S\] VSbS`]U{\S] ^]Q] SabcRWOR] g Q]\ ^]Q]a ROb]a Oc\_cS O ^SaO` RS Z]a ^`]b]Q]Z]a RS Q]\b`]Z SfWabS\bS Sa ^`S]QcÔ\bS S\ OZUc\]a ZcUO`Sa <]a `STS`W[]a OZ OPaS\bWa[] T aWQ] O Z] _cS ^]^cZO`[S\bS aS Q]\]QS ^]` VOQS` QO[Ô\O ] \]dWZZ]a ^]`_cS SZ S[]QW]\OZ g OQbWbcRW\OZ ³SZ RSZ OZc[\OR] ÔaWd] W\dWaWPZS ] OcaS\bS³ OZQO\hO c\O [OU\WbcR ac^S`W]` g O \ Sa [cQV] [ta RWT QWZ [SRW` 3Z OPaS\bWa[] ac^]\S c\ ^`]QSa] RS `c^bcÒ RSZ OZc[\OR] Q]\ c\ RSbS`[W\OR] S\b]`\] :]a TOQb]`Sa g [O\WTSabOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ SZ Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ( Q]\RWQW]\Sa a]QW]SQ]\ [WQOa QcZbcÒZSa g TO[WZWO`Sa) g Q]\ ZOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa RS ZO W\abWbcQW \ SaQ]ZO` Q][] S\b]`\] RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa( QZW[O SQ]Z UWQ] g `SZOQW]\OZ S\ SZ OcZO aW\b]\ O S\b`S Z]a W\bS`SaSa g ZO QcZbcÒ Q]bWRWO\O RSZ OZc[\OR] g RS ZO SaQcSZO ObS\QW \ ^Sà]\OZWhORO O Z]a RWabW\b]a `Wb[]a g \SQSaWRORSa RS O^`S\RWhOXS aWbcOQW]\Sa _cS Q]\b`WPcgS\ O ZO Ocb]SabW[O g O ZO ^`]bSQQW \ OTSQbWdO SbQ

;ta OZZt RS Z]a \ [S`]a( ZOa VWab]`WOa RS dWRO 6Og c\ RWQV] ^]^cZO` _cS OTW`[O _cS SfWabS\ ZOa UÒ\RSa [S\bWÒa ZOa ^S_cS Oa [S\bWÒa g ZOa SabOR abWQOa 3\ STSQb] Z]a \ [S`]a aS `SQ]US\ aS Q][PW\O\ g aS [O\W^cZO\ RS [WZ [O\SÒa( ^]` Sa] \] aWS[^`S Q]W\QWRS\ AW`dS\ ÔÒ O^`]fW[O`\]a OZ Q]\]QW[WS\b] RS ZO `SOZWROR ^S`] \] Sf^ZWQO\ b]RO ZO `SOZWROR( S\ SZ QOa] _cS \]a Q]\QWS`\S \] ZZSUO\ O ZOa S\bÒ Oa \W O SaQZO`SQS` ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ RS Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] g ac Q]\aWUcWS\bS UÒR] RS ^`]bSQQW \ ] RSa^`]bSQQW \ >]`_cS \] aS ]QcÔ\ RS 3ZS\O ] RS 8Oc[S 2SZ QVWQ] OZc[\] ] RS ZO QVWQO OZc[\O Q]\Q`Sb] / aca VWab]`WOa RS

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

dWRO / Z] _cS 0S`\O`R 1VO`Z]b RS\][W\O aOPS`Sa dW\QcZOR]a O aca Sf^S`WS\QWOa RS acPXSbWdWROR O aca `SZOQW]\Sa Q]\ Z]a aOPS`Sa \] SaQ]ZO`WhOR]a / aca \O`ÒbWdOa acPXSbWdOa ZZS\Oa RS dWdS\QWOa Q]\TZWQb]a []bWdOQW]\Sa W\bS`SaSa ]^]`bc\WRORSa g RSaOT ]a 2S OV ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RS OP`W` ZOa \cSdOa ^Sà^SQbWdOa RS W\dSabWUOQW \ _cS VOQS\ c\O W\[SàW \ S\ ZO dWRO SaQ]ZO` g a]QWOZ RS X dS\Sa g OR]ZSaQS\bSa( _cS ZSa RO\ ZO d]h ÔÒ Q]\]QS` g O\OZWhO` aca ^`]QSa]a RS `c^bcÒ SaQ]ZO` g dWbOZ) Z]a S\QcS\b`]a g RSaS\QcS\b`]a) ac UÒR] RS Ocb]SabW[O) ZO Ocb]^S`QS^QW \ RS Z]a Oa^SQb]a ^]aWbWd]a g \SUObWd]a RS ac ^Sà]\OZWROR) Z]a SaÔQW]a RS ^`]gSQQW \ g \SUOQW \ RSZ aS`) ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RS Z]a d \QcZ]a OTSQbWd]a g RS Z]a ^S_cS ]a USab]a) ZO `SZOQW \ RSZ O^`S\RS` Q]\ SZ aS` g SZ aOPS`) Z]a QO[W\]a OPO\R]\OR]a RSaQcPWS`b]a ] `SS\Q]\bÒR]a ZZS\]a RS Q]\bÒRWQQW]\Sa g `SaWabS\QWOa c ]bÒa aSQcS\QWOa RS aca dWROa S\ Q]\bW\c] ^`]QSa] RS Q]\ab`cQQW \ g `SQ]\ab`cQQW \ 1][] RWQS FOdWS` 0]\OZ( µA Z] O bÒd{a RS ZO W\ROUOQW \ Sb\]U`tTWQO ^]RS[]a RSaQcP`W` ZOa Z UWQOa RS O^`]^WOQW \ SaQ]ZO` RS Z]a X dS\Sa OR]ZSaQS\bSa g ^S\SbÒ` S\ Z]a aWU\WTWQOR]a _cS SabO O^`]^WOQW \ bWS\S ÔÒ aca dWROa ¶ /c\_cS SabO ^Sà^SQbWdO \] ]T`SQS ZSQbcÒa aW[^ZSa RS Z]a TS\ [S\]a RS `WSaU] SaQ]ZO` g a]QWOZ :O bW^WTWQOQW \ RS Z]a b ^WQ]a R][W\O\bSa Sa [cg dO`W]^W\bO g UcO`RO `SZOQW \ Q]\ SZ `S^S`b]`W] RS aWbcOQW]\Sa RSaQ`WbOa `Sa^SQb] OZ TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` /_c aS `SQ]US\ d]QSa _cS Sf^`SaO\ a Z] c\ Ô` RS aWbcOQW]\Sa Oc\_cS [cg `S^`SaS\bObWdOa( ZO ^`W[SÒ SZ `WSaU] SaQ]ZO` _cS Q]``S SZ OZc[\OR] _cS aS OPc``S) _cS \] S\QOXO) _cS aS S\QcS\bÒ SfbÒ ] S\ ZO SaQcSZO Q][] c\ ^Sh TcSÒ RSZ OUcO) _cS \] Sa^SÒ \ORO RS ZO SaQcSZO g _cS a Z] OUcO`RO OZQO\hO` Z]a $ O ]a ÔÒ RSXO` RS SabcRWO` g ^]\SàS O bÒPOXO` c\O aWbcOQW \ _cS Q]\ T`SQcS\QWO WRSOZWhO( ³ ³ ³ ³ ³ ³ ³ ³

3\b`SdWabOR]`( µ¥?c{ Q`SSa _cS aOQO`ta RS bc Ôa] ^]` ZO SaQcSZO7a[OSZ( G]¬ Q`S] _cS QOaW \t /\bSa a ^S`] OV]Ò gO ¬ \ORO 3( ¥?c{ Sa Z] _cS [ta dOZ]Òa RS bc Ôa] ^]` ZO SaQcSZO7( BS\S` ÔQWS\QWO 6S O^`S\RWR] O bS\S` ÔQWS\QWO [WS\bÒa VS Sa^SÒR] O bS`[W\O` SZ Q]ZSUW] 3\b`SdWabOR]`( µ¥?c{ Q`SSa _cS dOa O aOQO` RS bc Ôa] ^]` ZO SaQcSZO/Z ( <] a{ SZ UÒRcOR] ac^]\U] 3( ¥>S`] bc Q`SSa _cS VOP`t aS`dWR] RS OZU] ÔaO` ^]` ZO SaQcSZO/( G] Q`S] _cS \] [S aS`dW`t¬ g] \] bÒPOXO`{ RS \ORO RS Sab] g] bÒPOXO`{ RS Z] _cS ^cSRO µAS OQOP /V]Ò gO \] bS\U] _cS ^S`RS` SZ bWS[^] V]Òa g V]Òa S\ SZ W\abWbcb] _cS Sf^ZWQO\ Q]aOa _cS \W S\bWS\R] \W [S W[^]`bO\ ;S OPc`` O RWaQcb O Q]\ Z]a ^`]TSa]`Sa _cS VOPZOPO\ RS [ O [Wa SaÔZROa S\ SaOa `Sc\W]\Sa S\ ZOa _cS Q`SS\ O``SUZO` SZ [c\R] 3abOPO VO`b] RS _cS [S ZZO[OaS\ W\ bWZ g ^S`Sh]a] RS `SQWPW` QOabWU]a QcO\R] aS [S ]Qc`` O [WÒ` ^]` ZO dS\bO\O ÔaO`ZS c\ Ô^SZ OZ Q][Ô S`] RS OZ ZOR] ] RWabÒS`[S c\ [][S\b] a Z] c\ [][S\b] <] aS ^cSRS SabO` ObS\b] b]R] SZ Òb]¬ 6O aWR] Rc`] <] VOQ O Z]a RSPS`Sa ^]`_cS \] Z]a S\bS\R O \] ^]`_cS \] _cWaWSÒ VOQS`Z]a Q][] b]R]a ^S\aOPO\ <] VOQ O TOZbO _cS [S bÒbOaS\ Q][] O Z]a W\ bWZSa QOabWUOR] OZ `W\Q \ RS Z]a b]`^Sa Q]\ O_cSZZOa QZOaSa Sa^SQWOZSa <W VOQ O\ TOZbO O_cSZZOa `Sc\W]\Sa Q]\ SZ bcb]` ] Q]\ SZ âWQ Z]U] S\ ZOa _cS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

aWS[^`S [S `S^Sb O\ Z] [Wa[]( _cS aW bS\ O _cS ^]\S` [ta ObS\QW \ g [ta W\bS`{a ÔÒ \] ^S`RS` SZ VWZ] _cS bS\ O _cS ^`SUc\bO` Z] _cS \] S\bS\RWSaS g bÒPOXO` b]R]a Z]a R Oa¬ AW VOg ]b`]a Q][] g] Sa ^]`_cS Z]a ^`]TSa]`Sa \] aS Sf^ZWQO\ PWS\ \W \]a Q][^`S\RS\ VOPZO\ RS Q]aOa _cS \] bWS\S\ \ORO _cS dS` Q]\ ZO dWRO g \] ZSa W[^]`bO 3ZZ]a dO\ O Z] acg] Q][] aW S\ Z]a ZWP`]a SabcdWSaS ZO a]ZcQW \ RS b]R]a Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa ¶ /\b]\W]

3Z aSUc\R] T]Q] RS ObS\QW \ aS `STWS`S O Z]a ^`]TSa]`Sa µaOZdOR]`Sa¶ O ZO W\bS`dS\QW \ R]QS\bS ÔÒ ObOXO` g a]`bSO` SZ `WSaU] SaQ]ZO` / [S\cR] aS [S\QW]\O SZ O^]g] RS c\ ^`]TSa]` ] ^`]TSa]Ò _cS ^]` ac QS`QO\ O ac W\bS`{a g ac W[^ZWQOQW \ ZS VO aS`dWR] ÔÒ `SOQQW]\O` b][O` Q]\QWS\QWO g O^`]dSQVO` ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa SRcQObWdOa ÔÒ S\RS`ShO` ac bÒgSQb]`WO SaQ]ZO` DSO[]a b`Sa SXS[^Z]a S\b`SaOQOR]a RS S\b`SdWabOa `SQWS\bSa( µ2S S\b`S SabOa h]\Oa ]aQcÒa S[SÙS c\O ^S_cS O Zch QcO\R] OÔ`SQS SabO ^`]TSa]Ò RS 1WS\QWOa A]QWOZSa pZ ZO ^`SaS\bO Q][] TZSfWPZS 3\aS O PWS\ Q`SO c\ QZW[O RS Q]\TWO\hO µ\] bS RO dSÙ S\hO ^`SUc\bO`ZS¶ g µbS VOQS TWO`bS RS _cS Z] dOa O VOQS` PWS\¶ /RS[ta Q]W\QWRS Q]\ OZU] _cS {Z aWS[^`S VO Q]\aWRSÒR] c\O RS aca VOPWZWRORSa g Ucab]a( ZOa []\bO Oa Z]a ÔWaOXSa AS ]`WS\bO PWS\ ZS UcabO\ Z]a [OÔa ¶ µF [O\bWS\S c\ `SQcS`R] [cg ^]aWbWd] RS ZO `SZOQW \ _cS bcd] Q]\ SZ bcb]` RS ZO SaQcSZO >O`SQS _cS SabO `SZOQW \ Sa ZO _cS [ta dOZ]Ò RS ZO SaQcSZO( µSÒ ZO \WQO Q]aO RS ZO SaQcSZO _cS [S UcabOPO ¶ >O`SQS _cS W\QZca] [O\bS\ O Q]\ {Z c\O `SZOQW \ TcSÒ RS ZOa QcOb`] Ô`SRSa RSZ OcZO ¶ µ>]` ^`W[SÒ dSh ZWbSÒZ[S\bS S\ [W dWRO c\ ^`]TSa]` [S ^`SaS\bOPO c\ bS[O RS c\ []R] _cS [S VWh] `SOQQW]\O` RS T]`[O W\[SRWObO g S\bcaWOabO ¶ 3\ SZ U{\S`] PW]U`tTWQ] g Ocb]PW]U`tTWQ] a]\ \c[S`]a]a Z]a QOa]a R]\RS aS aOQO O `SZcQW` ZO UÒbWbcR VOQWO SaO TWUcÒ µaOZdOR]Ò¶ 0OabO `SQ]`RO` O b bcZ] RS SXS[^Z] SZ µ>`W[S` V][P`S¶ RS /ZPS`b 1O[ca ] µ;OZ RS SaQcSZO¶ RS 2O\WSZ >S\\OQ( µC\ ZWP`] a]P`S SZ h]_cSbS A]P`S SZ R]Z]` RS \] Q][^`S\RS` g aca RO ]a Q]ZObSÒZSa¬ :]a ^`]TSa]`Sa _cS [S aOZdO`]\ ³g _cS VWQWS`]\ RS [ c\ ^`]TSa]`³ \] SabOPO\ T]`[OR]a ÔÒ VOQS`Z] <] aS ^`S]QcÔ`]\ RS Z]a ]` US\Sa RS [W W\QOÔQWROR SaQ]ZO` <] ^S`RWS`]\ SZ bWS[^] PcaQO\R] aca QOcaOa \W bO[^]Q] aS`[]\St\R][S 3Ò\ ORcZb]a S\T`S\bOR]a O OR]ZSaQS\bSa S\ ^SZWU`] AS RWXS`]\ _cS SÒ cÙS\bS AS hO[PcZZS`]\ <] Z]UÒ`]\ ObÒÔ`[S AS hO[PcZZS`]\ RS \cSd] R O bÒa R O [ta g [ta¬ G OQOPO`]\ aOQt\R][S RS OZZ G O [cQV]a ]b`]a Q]\[WU] :WbSÒZ[S\bS \]a `S^SaQO`]\ :Sa RSPS[]a ZO dWRO

/QS`QO RS ZOa QOcaOa RSZ TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` :Oa Sf^ZWQOQW]\Sa RSZ TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` RWdSàOa g Q][^ZSXOa aS T]QOZWhO\ S\ SZ Q]\bSfb] a]QW]TO[WZWO` g S\ SZ t[PWb] SaQ]ZO`) Sa RSQW` S\ Z] _cS ]Qc``S RS\b`] g TcSÒ RS ZO W\abWbcQW \ SaQ]ZO` 6Og bS]` Oa Q][] ZOa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

`S^`]RcQQW]\WabOa _cS ]b]ÙO\ c\ ^Sa] RSbS`[W\O\bS S\ Tc\QW \ RS ZO QZOaS a]QWOZ RS ]`WUS\( ZO SaQcSZO `S^`]RcQS ZOa RSaWUcOZRORSa a]QWOZSa g RS R][W\W] RS c\]a U`c^]a a]QWOZSa a]PS ]b`]a ^`]^WOa RS ZO a]QWSROR QO^WbOZWabO S\ T]`[O RS RSaWUcOZRORSa SaQ]ZO`Sa ZOa QcOZSa aO\QW]\O\ ZOa VS`S\QWOa QcZbcÒZSa 3abOa bSaWa RSaRS _cS acÙWS`]\ S\ Z]a O ]a aSaS\bO aS VO\ WR] QcSabW]\O\R] S\`W_cSQWS\R] g [ObWhO\R] /a VOg SabcRW]a _cS [cSabÒ\ _cS SZ RSbS`[W\Wa[] a]QWOZ aS Q]\dWS`bS a Z] S\ Q]\RWQW]\O\bS Sab`cQbcÒZ OZ bWS[^] _cS OR_cWS`S\ [Og]` ^`]bOU]\Wa[] ZO ^Sà^SQbWdO QcZbcÒZWabO RS ZO a]QWOZWhOQW \ TO[WZWO`) ZO bS]` O RS Z]a Q RWU]a ZW\U abWQ]a ³ZO ^`SaS\QWO ] OcaS\QWO RS ZOa QcZbcÒa ]ÒZ g SaQ`WbO RS Z]a RWabW\b]a U`c^]a a]QWOZSa g ac ^`SaS\QWO ] OcaS\QWO RS ZO SaQcSZO ) g ]bÒa ^Sà^SQbWdOa O\b`]^]Z UWQOa SRcQObWdOa S W\bS`RWaQW^ZW\O`Sa _cS a]abWS\S\ _cS VOg ]b`]a TOQb]`Sa S\ XcSU] S\b`S SZZ]a ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RSZ []RSZ] ^SROU UWQ] g RS ZO W\bS`dS\QW \ R]QS\bS G _cS b]R] SZZ] ^`]d]QO c\O [Og]` []dWZWROR SaQ]ZO` g a]QWOZ S\ ZOa bÒgSQb]`WOa SaQ]ZO`Sa 6Og ]bÒa W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa g SdOZcOQW]\Sa \OQW]\OZSa S W\bS`\OQW]\OZSa _cS aS OZO\ ZO Q`SQWS\bS W\TZcS\QWO RS ZO TO[WZWO S\ SZ {fWb] ] TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` RSZ OZc[\OR] >S`] gO \] aS ^]\S bO\b] SZ {\TOaWa S\ ac ]`WUS\ g ^S`bS\S\QWO a]QWOZ aW\] S\ ac QO^WbOZ QcZbcÒZ g \WdSZ RS SabcRW]a a]P`S b]R] RS ZO [OR`S /a Z] ObSabWUcO\ W\T]`[Sa Q][] SZ >7A/ c ]b`]a _cS [WRS\ SZ `S\RW[WS\b] RSZ OZc[\OR] :]a W\RWQOR]`Sa a]\ [cg Q]\Q`Sb]a( W\bS`{a ^]` Z]a SabcRW]a RS aca VWX]a) UÒR] RS Sf^SQbObWdOa) O^]g] STSQbWd] S\ ZOa bO`SOa SaQ]ZO`Sa ³VOg _cWS\ bWS\S Q]\]QW[WS\b]a acTWQWS\bSa g Z] VOQS) VOg _cWS\ ZS UcabO` O VOQS`Z] ^S`] \] ^cSRS) g VOg _cWS\ ^cSRS ^S`] \] _cWS`S ] \] bWS\S bWS[^] ) PWS\Sa g VtPWb]a QcZbcÒZSa S\ SZ V]UO` bW^] RS ]QW] QcZbcÒZ RcÒ\bS Z]a TW\Sa RS aS[O\O g ZOa dOQOQW]\Sa ³VOg _cWS\ aS O^c\bO O Q]Z]\WOa g O c\ Qcà] RS W\UZ{a S\ SZ SfbÒ\XS`] g VOg _cWS\ aS bWÒ b]R] SZ R O S\ ZO QOZZS ] bc[POR] S\ SZ a]Tt T`S\bS OZ bSZSdWa]` ] QVObSO\R] S\ 7\bS`\Sb 7UcOZ[S\bS aWU\WTWQObWdOa a]\ ZOa OQbWdWRORSa SfbÒSaQ]ZO`Sa( ZO []ROZWROR SZSUWRO g ac QOZWROR ^cSa S\ QWS`bO [O\SÒ aS bÒbO RS ZO ^`]Z]\UOQW \ RS ZO X]`\ORO SaQ]ZO` RS ]bÒ SaQcSZO TcSÒ RS ZO SaQcSZO /RS[ta \] VOg _cS ]ZdWRO` _cS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ g SZ Q]\]QW[WS\b] aS S\QcS\bÒ\ QORO dSh [ta TcSÒ RS ZO SaQcSZO @Sa^SQb] OZ Q]\bSfb] SaQ]ZO` Q]\dWS\S RWTS`S\QWO` S\b`S Z]a Oa^SQb]a Sab`cQbcÒZSa RSZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] ³Z] [OQ`]³ g ZO dWRO Q]bWRWO\O RSZ QS\b`] g RSZ OcZO Z] [WQ`] 3\ SZ ^`W[S` QOa] Q]\dWS\S RSabOQO` SZ W[ÔQb] _cS VO bS\WR] SZ []RSZ] RS S\aS O\hO Q][^`S\aWdO RS ZO :=5A3 ³ZO `ST]`[O a]QWOZWabO RS ZO SbOÔ RS 4SZW^S 5]\htZSh³ S\ ZO 3A= C\ []RSZ] bS `WQO[S\bS [cg dtZWR] g OQS^bOPZS ^]` ac O^cSabO ZO SaQ]ZO`WROR ]PZWUOb]`WO VOabO Z]a $ O ]a g ^]` ZO W\QZcaW \ RSZ OZc[\OR] Q]\ c\ Qc`` QcZ] Q][ \ g ZO \SQSaO`WO ObS\QW \ O ZO RWdSàWROR) ^S`] _cS S\ ZO ^`tQbWQO VO []abÒR] OZUc\Oa RSPWZWRORSa RS QOZOR] ÔÒ SdWbO` SZ SZSdOR] `WSaU] RS TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` g OPO\R]\] ^`S[Obc`] /ZUc\Oa RS SabOa RSPWZWRORSa bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ ZO TOZbO RS T]`[OQW \ RSZ ^`]TSa]ÒR] ÔÒ Oac[W` Z]a `Sb]a SRcQObWd]a ³\] a Z] W\ab`cQbWd]a³ RS ZO 3A= ) Q]\ ZO `WUWRSh RSZ Qc`` QcZ] g ac ]`WS\bOQW \ RS[OaWOR] âWQ]Z]UWabO) Q]\ ZO W[^ZS[S\bOQW \ RS `SQcà]a SaQOa]a S W\ORSQcOR]a) g Q]\ ZO Q]\TcaW \ US\SÒRO S\ b]`\] O Z]a ]PXSbWd]a WRS\bWbO`W]a RS SabO \cSdO SbOÔ _cS \ORO bWS\S _cS dS` Q]\ ZO >`W[O`WO ^S`] [cQV] [S\]a Q]\ SZ O\bWUc] 0C> 3ab] ZbW[] VO US\SÒR] [cZbWbcR RS S_c d]Q]a g [OZSabO`Sa

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

>S`] [ta OZZt RS SabO `ST]`[O aS Q]\abObO _cS ZO W\abWbcQW \ SaQ]ZO` aWUcS [O\bS\WS\R] c\ OcbWa[] S\ `SZOQW \ OZ S\b]`\] a]QWOZ Z]a W\bS`SaSa RSZ OZc[\OR] g Z]a \cSd]a RSaOT ]a RS ZO a]QWSROR RSZ Q]\]QW[WS\b] C\ RWQV] [cg SfbS\RWR] Z] aW\bSbWhO Q]\ QZO`WROR [S`WRWO\O( bS\S[]a c\O W\abWbcQW \ Q`SORO SZ aWUZ] F7F) Q]\ c\ ^`]TSa]ÒR] T]`[OR] SZ aWUZ] FF) g Q]\ c\ OZc[\OR] RSZ aWUZ] FF7 ¶ @Sa^SQb] O ZO dWRO Q]bWRWO\O RS Z]a QS\b`]a RS ASQc\RO`WO ZOa ^`W\QWÔZSa QO`S\QWOa UcO`RO\ `SZOQW \ Q]\ ZO OcaS\QWO RS ^`]gSQb]a SRcQObWd]a a ZWR]a g RS S_cW^]a R]QS\bSa Q]VSaW]\OR]a) Q]\ ZO TOZbO RS ZWRSÒhU] ÔÒ T][S\bO` SZ bÒPOX] Q]ZOP]ÒbWd] g SZ RWtZ]U] Q]\ ZOa TO[WZWOa g ]b`]a OUS\bSa RS ZO Q][c\WROR SRcQObWdO) ZO ^S`dWdS\QWO RS ^`tQbWQOa SaQ]ZO`Sa ^]Q] W\QZcaWdOa g SfQSaWdO[S\bS bÒRWQW]\OZSa) SZ TÒQOa] RS ZO bcb]` O Q][] SaÔQW] RS ]`WS\bOQW \ ^Sà]\OZ OQOR{[WQO g ^`]TSaW]\OZ) g ZO `SZOQW \ RSZ ^`]TSa]ÒR] Q]\ SZ OZc[\OR] RWabO\bS g [ta QS\bÒRO S\ ZO [SÒ bÒ\a[WaW \ RS Q]\bS\WR]a _cS S\ ZO SRcQOQW \ W\bSUÒZ( OZU] _cS Q]\bÒRWQS ZO SaS\QWO RS ZO TWZ]a]T O RS ZO 3A= >]`_cS Q][] [cg PWS\ RWQS 8Oc[S ;O`b \Sh 0]\OT{( µ1`SS` _cS c\] S\bÒ S\ SZ OcZO O S\aS O` 0W]Z]U O g \ORO [ta Sa c\ OÙc[S\b] ^SROU UWQ] W\a]abS\WPZS ¶

0`SdS RSQtZ]U] OZbS`\ObWd] O []R] RS Q]\QZcaW \ / Z] ZOÙ] RSZ bSfb] gO aS VO\ WR] O^c\bO\R] OZUc\Oa dWaW]\Sa []RSZ]a W\bS`dS\QW]\Sa g [SRWROa `Sa^SQb] O ZO ^`]bSQQW \ RSZ `WSaU] SRcQObWd] S\ ac dSàW \ \SUObWdO >]` ]b`] ZOR] aW ZS RO[]a ZO dcSZbO OZ QOZQSb \ O RWdSàOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] _cS VS[]a []abÒR] bO[PW{\ S\Q]\bÒ`S[]a dOZW]a]a SZS[S\b]a OZbS`\ObWd]a <] ]PabO\bS O []R] RS Q]Z]T \ VS[]a _cS`WR] aW\bSbWhO` Z]a ^c\b]a [ta SabÒb{UWQ]a ÔÒ dS`bSPÒ` c\O ^]Z bWQO [ta W\\]dOR]Ò QS`QO\O g STWQOh `Sa^SQb] O ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g ZO XcdS\bcR A]\ {ab]a( 1O[PW] RS [WÒRO >]` Ô`bS RS b]R]a Z]a OUS\bSa _cS bWS\S\ `SZOQW \ Q]\ Sab]a Q]ZSQbWd]a AS bÒbO RS c\O QcSabW \ RS OQbWbcR ^`SdWO O QcOZ_cWS` O\tZWaWa S W\bS`dS\QW \ ;WÒROa [ta ^]aWbWdOa g Sa^SÒ\hOR]Òa _cS \] dSO\ ZO XcdS\bcR Q][] c\O QOaQORO RS ^`]PZS[Oa aW\] RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa g `WSaU]a _cS RSPS\ O^`S\RS` O USabW]\O` ?cS S\bWS\RO\ _cS [cQV]a RS Z]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a _cS aS ZS Ob`WPcgS\ VO\ aWR] W\dS\bOR]a ^]` ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ORcZbOa ?cS aS RS\ QcS\bO _cS ZO QS`QO\ O ZO Q]\dSàOQW \ g ZO Q]\TWO\hO aWS[^`S a]\ PcS\Oa Q][Ô SÒa ?cS Q][^`S\RO\ _cS aS bÒbO RS ^Sà]\Oa S\ ^`]QSa] RS Q]\ab`cQQW \ g ^`]dWaW]\OZWROR Q]\ c\ O\aWO ³O dSQSa RSa[SacÒRO³ RS RSaQcP`W` Sf^S`W[S\bO` g O``WSaUO`

1]\]QW[WS\b] RS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g ZO XcdS\bcR AS VOPZO [cQV] RSZ Qc`` QcZ] RS ac \WdSZ SRcQObWd] g RS Z] _cS RSPS\ aOPS` ^S`] Q]\ T`SQcS\QWO aS ]ZdWRO OZU] _cS Sa SaS\QWOZ( SZ Q]\]QW[WS\b] RSZ acXSb] Aca W\bS`SaSa [O\WTWSab]a g ]QcZb]a) RSaS]a) T]`[Oa RS aS` g RS SabO` S\ Z]a RWabW\b]a SaÔQW]a a]QWOZSa) SaQOZO RS dOZ]`Sa) aSUc`WRORSa g TÒUWZWRORSa) QO`tQbS` g [OU\WbcR RS aca Q`WaWa) aca ÔZOPÒa g aca aWZS\QW]a ¬ 3Z ^]` _c{ a]\ Q][] a]\ AOPS` RS aca WRS\bWRORSa RWdSàOa g QO[PWO\bSa) RS aca ^`]QSa]a RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ QORO dSh [ta [SRWObWhOR]a ^]` SZ Q]\ac[] g ZOa B71 _cS Q]\T]`[O\ \cSd]a ZS\UcOXSa Q][c\WQObWd]a g aWabS[Oa RS `SZOQW \

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

! >SROU]U O RSZ RWtZ]U] :O Q]\dSàOQW \ ^S`[O\S\bS Sa W[^`SaQW\RWPZS ÔÒ aOPS` Q]\dWdW` g Q`SQS` >OÒ dWdW` Q]bWRWO\O[S\bS ZO RS[]QÒQWO Ô`bWQWÔbWdO S\ ZO W\abWbcQW \ SRcQObWdO O^`S\RWS\R] O SXS`QS` RS`SQV]a g O Oac[W` RSPS`Sa g `Sa^]\aOPWZWRORSa W\RWdWRcOZSa g Q]ZSQbWdOa >OÒ S\b`S\OàS S\ SZ ca] RS ZO ÔZOPÒ OÙc[S\bORO g S\ ZO SaQcQVO) S\ ZOa ^`SUc\bOa g ZOa RcROa) S\ ZO OQS^bOQW \ RS Q]\bÒbWS[^]a g T`cabÒQW]\Sa) S\ SZ `Sa^Sb] g SZ `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] RSZ ]b`]) S\ ZO Q` bWQO g ZO TSZWQWbOQW \ :O QOZWROR RS ZO S\aS O\hO aS [WRS bO[PW{\ ^]` ZO QO\bWROR g ZO `W_cShO RS ZOa W\bSÒQQW]\Sa _cS aS SabOPZSQS\ S\b`S SZ OZc[\OR] g SZ ^`]TSa]ÒR] S\ SZ bÒ\aQcà] RS ZO X]`\ORO SaQ]ZO` 3Z RWtZ]U] g ZO RS[]QÒQWO Q]\b`WPcgS\ OaW[Wa[] O Q]\ab`cW` SZ aS\bWR] SZ ^]RS` g SZ ]ÙcZZ] RS ^S`bS\SQS` O c\O Q][c\WROR SRcQObWdO c\O QO`S\QWO RS[OaWOR] ZZO[ObWdO S\ Z]a bWS[^]a _cS Q]``S\ :O ^SROU]U O RSZ RWtZ]U] ³Q]\ SZ S\b]`\] Q]\ Z]a RS[ta g Q]\aWU] [Wa[]³ U]hO RS a ZWRO bÒRWQW \ ^SROU UWQO " 2WTcaW \ g O^`S\RWhOXS RS ZOa PcS\Oa ^`tQbWQOa BO\b] ZO VWab]`WO Q][] SZ ^`SaS\bS \]a P`W\RO\ c\ O[^ZW] OPO\WQ] RS PcS\Oa ^`tQbWQOa W\\]dOR]Òa g RS Sf^S`WS\QWOa W\abWbcQW]\OZSa SfWb]aOa S\ ZO ^`]bSQQW \ RSZ `WSaU] :]a \][P`Sa RS ;OYO`S\Y] 4`SW\Sb ;WZO\W 2SZWU\g 4`SW`S RSaRS ^]aWQW]\Sa [cg RWabW\bOa a]\ `STS`S\bSa Q]\ aOP]` O QZtaWQ]( O_cSZZ]a _cS \] ^WS`RS\ c\ t^WQS RS dWUS\QWO Q]\ SZ Ôa] RSZ bWS[^] aOZd] ZOa ^SQcZWO`WRORSa Sa^SQ TWQOa RSZ Q]\bSfb] ;ta `SQWS\bS[S\bS VO\ S[SÙWR] W[^]`bO\bSa `SRSa SRcQObWdOa _cS ^]\S\ SZ OQS\b] S\ SZ Z]U`] RSZ {fWb] SaQ]ZO` ÔÒ b]R] SZ OZc[\OR] S\TObWhO\R] [ta aca ^]aWPWZWRORSa _cS aca RWTWQcZbORSa( 3aQcSZOa OQSZSÒROa Q][c\WRORSa RS O^`S\RWhOXS SaQcSZOa RS[]Q`tbWQOa `SRSa RS Q]ZOP]ÒQW \ R]QS\bS ^]` c\O SaQcSZO W\QZcaWdO SbQ # @S\]dOQW \ RS ZO 3A= g RS ]b`]a bÒ[]a SRcQObWd]a ^]abS`W]`Sa <] aS bÒbO RS QcSabW]\O` SZ []RSZ] RS SRcQOQW \ Q][^`S\aWdO _cS UOÒ\bWhO ZO SaQ]ZO`WROR Q][ \ g ]PZWUOb]`WO VOabO Z]a $ O ]a ^S`] aW RS `S]`WS\bO`Z] g OQbcOZWhO`Z] 1]\ Q]\bS\WR]a [S\]a OPabÒQb]a g [ta dW\QcZOR] O ZO `SOZWROR W\Q]`^]Ò\R] OZ ^`]^W] bWS[^] ZOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa g aOPS`Sa RS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO XcdS\bcR) Q]\ c\ Qc`` QcZ] _cS dW\QcZS [SX]` ZO bS]` O Q]\ ZO ^`tQbWQO Q]\ ZO `SOZWhOQW \ RS OZUc\Oa OQbWdWRORSa RS W\WQWOQW \ ZOP]ÒZ g RS aS`dWQW] O ZO Q][c\WROR) TZSfWPWZWhO\R] ZOa Sab`cQbcÒa ]ÙO\WhObWdOa Z]a bWS[^]a g Z]a SaÔQW]a OQbcOZ[S\bS RS[OaWOR] ` UWR]a g S\Q]àSbOR]a) Q]\ c\ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] _cS TOQWZWbS ZOa bÒ\aWQW]\Sa S\b`S Z]a RWdSà]a \WdSZSa g ]TS`bOa SRcQObWdOa C\ []RSZ] S\ RSTW\WbWdO R]\RS SZ OZc[\OR] aS aWS\bO OQ]UWR] g S\QcS\b`S aS\bWR] O Z] _cS aS ZS S\aS O S\ O_cSZ ZcUO` ZZO[OR] OcZO $ ;SRWROa RS Q][^S\aOQW \ SaQ]ZO` :Oa OR[W\WabÒQW]\Sa SRcQObWdOa [ta ^`]U`SaWabOa VO\ []abÒR] Sa^SQWOZ aS\aWPWZWROR ÔÒ RSaO``]ZZO` ^`]UÒ[Oa RS SRcQOQW \ Q][^S\aOb]`WO g [SRWROa RS RWaQ`W[W\OQW \ ^]aWbWdO ³RO` [ta O^]g] OZ _cS bWS\S [Og]`Sa RWTWQcZbORSa >S`] Z]a `SQcà]a a]\ aWS[^`S W\acTWQWS\bSa( ÔÒ ZO OQ]UWRO S W\bSUÒQW \ RSZ OZc[\OR] W\[WUÒ\bSa S\ QZOdS [ta W\bS`QcZbcÒZ _cS aSU`SUOR]Ò g OaW[WZOQW]\WabO) ÔÒ SZ `STcS`h] g ZOa ORO^bOQW]\Sa Qc``WQcZO`Sa _cS ^`SQWaO SZ OZc[\OR] Q]\ RWabW\bOa QO`S\QWOa) ÔÒ ZO bcb]`WhOQW \ W\bS\aWdO) ÔÒ ZO OgcRO S\ ZO `SOZWhOQW \ RS ZOa bO`SOa SaQ]ZO`Sa TcSÒ RSZ OcZO ¬ >OÒ [cZbWbcR RS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

aWbcOQW]\Sa _cS `S_cWS`S\ c\O W\bS`dS\QW \ Q]]`RW\ORO S\b`S SZ ^`]TSa]ÒR] g Z]a Sa^SQWOZWabOa( S_cW^]a RS ]`WS\bOQW \ SRcQObWdO RS OaSa]Ò[WS\b] âWQ]^SROU UWQ] RS [SRWOQW \ QcZbcÒZ RS Z]U]^SRWO RS TWaW]bSÒ^WO SbQ % /Q][Ô O[WS\b] SRcQObWd] <] a Z] OQOR{[WQ] aW\] ^S\aO\R] S\ b]ROa Z]a Oa^SQb]a RS ZO ^Sà]\OZWROR RSZ acXSb]( Q]U\WbWd]a a]QWOZSa {bWQ]a S[]QW]\OZSa aS\bW[S\bOZSa ¬ 1][] RWQS 8Oc[S 4c\Sa µ3\ ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO SRcQO` aWU\WTWQO OQ][Ô O` AS bÒbO RS VOQS` RS [S\b]`Sa RS bcb]`Sa RS ^Sà]\Oa ORcZbOa _cS Sabt\ QS`QO acg] aW\ W\b`][WaW]\Sa ^S`] Q]\ QOÔQWROR RS Q][^`S\RS` g OgcRO`ZSa O aOZW` RS ZOa W\QS`bWRc[P`Sa ¶ :O bcb]` O Sa SZ SaÔQW] RS O^`S\RWhOXS ÔÒ OT`]\bO` ^]aWbWdO[S\bS SZ Q]\TZWQb] [SRWO\bS ac WRS\bWTWQOQW \ `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] g [SRWOQW \ ^`]TSa]ÒR] OZc[\OR] ] S\b`S WUcOZSa) ÔÒ Q]\b`]ZO` ZOa O\UcabWOa _cS ^`]RcQS\ Z]a `WSaU]a g ÔÒ USabW]\O`Z]a) ÔÒ OgcRO`ZSa O ^`SdS\W` g `SRcQW` ZOa ^`]POPWZWRORSa RS `WSaU]) ÔÒ QcZbWdO` ZO W\bSZWUS\QWO []ÒZ _cS ^S`[WbS ZO T]`[OQW \ RS c\ []ÒZ Ocb \][] ZO OR_cWaWQW \ RS VOPWZWRORSa RWOZ UWQOa g c\O [SX]Ò RSZ S\bÒ[OR] `SZOQW]\OZ & >`]TSa]ÒR] Q][^`][SbWR] Q]\ ZO SRcQOQW \ >]`_cS S\aS O` ZO OaWU\ObcÒ \] POabO 1]\ OR]ZSaQS\bSa g X dS\Sa S\ ^`]QSa] RS [ORcÒQW \ ZOa W\bS`dS\QW]\Sa R]QS\bSa `S_cWS`S\ Q][^]\S\bSa {bWQ]a OTSQbWd]a g a]QWOZSa 3a bO\ W[^]`bO\bS _c{ aS S\aS O ^S`] bO[PW{\ Q [] aS S\aS O( [Sb]R]Z UWQO g {bWQO[S\bS >]`_cS ZOa dWROa RSZ OZc[\OR] Q]\ T`SQcS\QWO _cSRO\ [ta [O`QOROa ^]` ZO T]`[O RS aS` g Q][^]`bOàS c\ ^`]TSa]` ] ^`]TSa]Ò _cS ^]` Z]a Q]\bS\WR]a _cS W[Ô`bS S\ ac OaWU\ObcÒ 2S OV ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RSZ Qc`` QcZ] Sf^Z QWb] g RSZ ZZO[OR] Qc`` QcZ] ]QcZb] >OÒ Oac[W` Sa]a `]ZSa ZO T]`[OQW \ W\WQWOZ g ^S`[O\S\bS RSZ ^`]TSa]ÒR] `S_cWS`S c\ dcSZQ] ÒRWQOZ 3Z `Sb] Sa R]PZS( _cS SZ OZc[\OR] S\bWS\RO aca Sf^ZWQOQW]\Sa g _cS SZ ^`]TSa]ÒR] Q][^`S\RO OZ OZc[\OR] >OÒ Sa] VOg _cS SabO` OV QS`QO Q]\dS`bWàS S\ c\ ^c\b] RS `STS`S\QWO ;O` O HO[PÒ\] Z] Sf^`SaO Q]\ ZcQWRSh( µ<] bS\S` [OSab`] Sa \] bS\S` O _cWS\ ^`SUc\bO` g [ta V]\RO[S\bS b]ROd O \] bS\S` O\bS _cWS\ ^`SUc\bOàS ¶ ' 1]ZOP]ÒQW \ TO[WZWO SaQcSZO 2S \ORO aW`dS QcZÔPWZWhO` O ZO TO[WZWO ^]`_cS RW[WbO RS aca `Sa^]\aOPWZWRORSa SRcQObWdOa g ZOa RS`WdS O ZO SaQcSZO( c\O dS`ROR O [SRWOa ^]`_cS RS b]R] VOg Q][] RS\b`] RSZ Q]ZSQbWd] R]QS\bS :O ÔZOPÒ _cS [SX]` RSTW\S ZO OQbWbcR RS ZOa TO[WZWOa Sa RSaQ]\QWS`b]( \] VO\ OaW[WZOR] Z]a QO[PW]a OQOSQWR]a Q]\ bO\bO QZO`WROR g aS S\QcS\bÒ\ ^S`RWROa :O `SQSbO Sa QZOÒ( T][S\bO` g S\`W_cSQS` Z]a SaÔQW]a RS Q]ZOP]ÒQW \ g Ô`bWQWÔQW \ [SRWO\bS c\O [Og]` O^S`bcÒ RS ZO SaQcSZO OZ bWS[^] _cS ÔR`Sa g [OR`Sa Q`SO\ aca SaÔQW]a RS T]`[OQW \ g Ocb]T]`[OQW \ >OÒ Q][Ô`bW` ^`S]QcÔQW]\Sa VtPWb]a dOZ]`Sa g []RSZ]a SRcQObWd]a >OÒ SabOPZSQS` aW\SÙWOa g ^c\b]a RS S\QcS\b`] S\ QcOZ_cWS` t[PWb] g aWbcOQW \ >]`_cS SZ ]PXSbWd] Sa SZ [Wa[]( ZO SRcQOQW \ W\bSUÒZ RS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO XcdS\bcR 1WcROR SRcQOR]Ò 3Z ^`]QSa] RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ RWaQc``S S\ S\b]`\]a QORO dSh [ta RWdSàWTWQOR]a g ^]RS`]a]a [ta OZZt RS ZO W\abWbcQW \ SaQ]ZO` >]` Sa] gO \] aW`dS\ Z]a RWaQcà]a g ZOa ^`tQbWQOa TÒU[S\bOROa _cS TWXO\ T`]\bSÒa S\b`S ZO SRcQOQW \ T]`[OZ \]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

T]`[OZ S W\QWRS\bOZ >]` Sa] S\ Z]a ZbW[]a bWS[^]a acÙS\ \cSdOa W\WQWObWdOa _cS bÒbO\ RS O`bWQcZO` ZO Q]``Sa^]\aOPWZWROR SRcQObWdO ³RW`SQbO ] W\RW`SQbO³ RS b]R]a Z]a OUS\bSa a]QWOZSa RSZ bS``Wb]`W]( QWcRORSa SRcQOR]Òa ^`]gSQb]a SRcQObWd]a RS QWcROR aWabS[Oa T]`[ObWd]a W\bSUÒR]a ^ZO\Sa RS S\b]`\] ¬ Ac TWZ]a]T O Sa aW[WZO`( SZ W[^cZa] RS ^]Z bWQOa a]QWOZSa UZ]POZSa ÔÒ [SX]Ò` ZO Q]\dWdS\QWO ^`SdS\W` g USabW]\O` [ta STWQOh[S\bS Z]a `WSaU]a SRcQObWd]a g Z]UÒ` c\O [Og]` S_cWROR g Q]VSaW \ a]QWOZ AW`dO\ RS S^ Z]U] ZOa PSZZOa ÔZOPÒa RS ;O`W] 0S\SRSbbW( µ3Z [c\R] Sa bO\ QO[PWO\bS bO\ W\Sa^SÒR] _cS Sa PcS\] Q]\ab`cWàS c\O UcO`WRO¬ 3\ ZO UcO`WRO SabO[]a WZSa]a [WS\bÒa Qc\RS OZU \ RSaOab`S G \]a Q]\bO[]a QcS\b]a g S\QS\RS[]a ZO O\b]`QVO ¶ @343@3<17/A 070:7=5@È471/A 0`cZZSb 1 ) 5 [Sh 5Ò\SZZ 1 1]]`R & µ;OZSabO`Sa( W\TO\QWO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g TO[WZWOa¶ 0O`QSZ]\O 5Ò ³177;C 0]\OZ F RW` ! µ/^`]^WOQW]\a SaQ]ZOà¶ =QbOSR`]( 0O`QSZ]\O 0]aV[O 8 & µ5S\SÒQW \ 3W\abSW\¶ ;OR`WR( 5SabW \ 1OÒPO O 8 & µ3c`]^S]a¶ RS\b`] RSZ []\]U`tTWQ] µ;ta OZZt RS >7A/¶ S\ µ1cORS`\]a RS >SROU]U O¶ \ !& XcZW] OU]ab] & 0O`QSZ]\O( E]ZbSà 9ZceS` 1O`P]\SZZ 8 & µC\O SRcQOQW \ ÔÒ [O O\O¶ 0O`QSZ]\O( =QbOSR`] 1VO`Z]b 0 µ2O `SZOzO] Q][] aOPS`¶ >]`b] /ZSU`S 0ÒaWZ( /`bSa ;{RWQOa ¦=X] ( O ORW` aWU\] S\ ZO aSUc\RO µO¶ RS `SZOzO] 3Zh] 8 & µ:O d]h RS Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa¶ 0]ORWZZO RSZ ;]\bS ;OR`WR( >>1 4c\Sa 8 & µ/R]ZSaQS\bSa RS V]g C\ S\QOXS RWT QWZ S\ c\O a]QWSROR Q][^ZSXO¶ 3\ µ;OZSabO`Sa( W\TO\QWO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g TO[WZWOa¶ 0O`QSZ]\O( 5Ò 177;C 6S`\t\RSh 4 Q]]`R & µ1O^ O c\O SaQ]ZO aSQc\Ru`WO W\QZcaWdO( aOPSà W Sf^S`W|\QWSa RS X]dSa S\ aWbcOQW R SfQZcaW ¶ 7\{RWb] ;SU Oa 7) @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ 3 & µ8 dS\Sa S\ Z]a [SRW]a :O W[OUS\ [SRWtbWQO RS ZO XcdS\bcR RSaRS ac ^`]^WO [WÒRO¶ ;OR`WR( 4c\ROQW \ 4/2 7<8CD3 HO[PÒ\] ; % µ4WZ]a]T O g 3RcQOQW \ ;O\caQ`Wb]a¶ ;tZOUO( ÈU]Ò

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

9D8JB:CIDH

8Sa a 5O`Q O DS`RcU] >]ZWb Z]U]

?jkZcijY n g^Zh\dh# JcV b^gVYV ]VX^V Za [jijgd

:O ]^W\W \ ^ PZWQO VO WR] Q]\T]`[O\R] c\ RWaQcà] S\ b]`\] O ZO XcdS\bcR Q]\bÒRWQb]`W] gO _cS aS US\SÒ c\O W[OUS\ ^]` c\ ZOR] POaORO S\ SZS[S\b]a WRSOZSa RS SabO SbOÔ g _cS aS _cWS`S\ [O\bS\S` g ^`]Z]\UO` O Z] ZOÙ] RS b]RO ZO dWRO ^S`] ^]` ]b`] ZOR] aS US\SÒ c\ RWaQcà] `SQ`W[W\Ob]`W] VOQWO SabO Ô`bS RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ ^]` Ô`bS RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ORcZbOa `Sa^]\aOPWZWht\R]ZO RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a ] OQbWbcRSa ^SZWU`]a]a ÔÒ ZO ^Sà]\O X]dS\ S\ Ô`bWQcZO` ] ÔÒ ZO a]QWSROR S\ ac Q]\Xc\b] _cS aW\ S[POÙ] a]\ Q`SOR]a RSaRS ZO ^`]^WO a]QWSROR g S\ ZO _cS ZO ^Sà]\O X]dS\ ^WS`RS UÒ\ Ô`bS RS aca ]^QW]\Sa ÔÒ c\O OQbcOQW \ Q dWQO 3\ SabS aS\bWR] aS ^ZO\bSO\ OZUc\Oa ÔcbOa RSa[WbWTWQOR]Òa S\ b]`\] O ZO Q]\RWQW \ RS aS` X]dS\ g OZ bÒPOX] _cS Q]\ X dS\Sa aS ^cSRS VOQS` RSaRS ZOa OR[W\WabÒQW]\Sa ^ PZWQOa ] RSaRS ZOa ]ÙO\WhOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa >OZOPÒa QZOdS( a]QWOZWhOQW \ aS` X]dS\ ^S`QS^QW \ Sf^S`WS\QWO `WSaU] ]^]`bc\WRORSa ^]Z bWQO RS XcdS\bcR

3Z `WSaU] Q][] c\O Ô`bS g \] Q][] c\ b]R] 2S S\bÒRO bS\U] _cS [O\WTSabO` _cS RSa^c{a RS ZS R]a [cQV]a W\bS\b]a RS OQS`QO[WS\b] O c\ Q]\QS^b] QZO`] RS XcdS\bcR [S `SacZbO\ [ta TWOPZSa ZOa RSTW\WQW]\Sa _cS VOQS\ OZcaW \ O _cS Sa c\O SbOÔ RS b`t\aWb] Oc\_cS R]bORO RS QOÒQbS` abWQOa Sa^SQ TWQOa _cS O_cSZZOa T]`[cZOROa a]P`S dOZ]ÒQW]\Sa S\ \SUObWd] ] S\ ^]aWbWd] RS Z] _cS aWU\WTWQO SZ aS` X]dS\ 3a QWS`b] _cS SabO SbOÔ bÒ\aWb]`WO S\ ZO dWRO RS b]ROa ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ZZSUO O aS` RSbS`[W\O\bS S\ ZO Q]\T]`[OQW \ RS [cQV]a Oa^SQb]a ^Sà]\OZSa Q]\T]`[S O ZOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa dWdWROa R]bOROa S\ SaS [][S\b] RS [Og]` QOÔQWROR RS [O`QOXS _cS S\ ]b`]a [][S\b]a RS ZO dWRO :O SbOÔ S\b`S ZO W\TO\QWO g ZO [ORc`Sh RS ZO dWRO ORcZbO Sa QO[PWO\bS Q]\ ZO W\SabOPWZWROR _cS ZS Sa ^`]^WO g Q][] c\ ^`]QSa] RS P a_cSRO RSZ aWbW] RS QORO ^Sà]\O `Sa^SQb] O ZO ^`]^WO WRS\bWROR g ZO cPWQOQW \ S\ SZ aS\] RSZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO a]QWSROR 3abS Sa c\ ^`]QSa] Q][^ZSX] Q][^cSab] RS [ ZbW^ZSa Sf^S`WS\QWOa ^]aWbWdOa g \SUObWdOa _cS W`t\ RSbS`[W\O\R] ZO ^S`QS^QW \ _cS RS a g RSZ [c\R] aS ^cSRO W` bS\WS\R] VOQWO SZ Tcbc`] 3a c\ ^`]QSa] _cS Oc\_cS \] bS\UO TW\OZ [WS\bÒa aS dWdS aS W`t ÒZS\bWhO\R] S\ ac Sd]ZcQW \ bÒa ZO ac^SÒQW \ STSQbWdO RS ZO SbOÔ XcdS\WZ ;WS\bÒa S\ SZ ÔaOR] g S\ ]bÒa QcZbcÒa SabO SbOÔ aS VO WRS\bWTWQOR] Q]\ c\ ^S`W]R] RS bWS[^] `SZObWdO[S\bS P`SdS Q]W\QWRS\bS Q]\ ZS Sf^Z]aW \ V]`[]\OZ ^`]^WO RS ZO ^cPS`bOR R]\RS SZ QO[PW] RS W\TO\QWO O ORcZbSh Sa PW]Z UWQ] S\ SZ ^ZO\] a]QWOZ aS VO WR] RO\R] SfbS\aW \ O Z] _cS aS S\bWS\RS ^]` XcdS\bcR :O Q][^ZSXO Sd]ZcQW \ RS ZOa a]QWSRORSa []RS`\Oa VO VSQV] \SQSaO`W] O[^ZWO` SZ ^S`W]R] S\ SZ _cS ZO ^Sà]\O X]dS\ ^cSRS ]PbS\S` ZO Q`SRS\QWOZ RS S\bÒRO Q]\ ^ZS\] RS`SQV] O ZO Oac\QW \ RS b]ROa ZOa `Sa^]\aOPWZWRORSa _cS aS S\bWS\RS\ ^S`bS\SQWS\bSa OZ [c\R] ORcZb]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

:O bcbSZO SXS`QWRO ^]` ZOa US\SÒQW]\Sa O\bS`W]`Sa Q][] W\b{`^`SbSa RS ZOa \SQSaWRORSa ÔÒ RSaS\d]ZdSàS S\ ZO a]QWSROR g bÒ\a[Wa]Òa RS Z]a Q RWU]a _cS ZS a]\ ^`]^W]a aS ^`]Z]\UO S\ SZ bWS[^] SfWUWS\R] c\ [Og]` ^S`W]R] RS Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ g Q]\aW\bWS\R] ZO ^`cSPO S``]` bO[PW{\ ^`]U`SaWdO[S\bS VOabO c\O SROR [ta OdO\hORO AS Q]\aWRSÒ _cS ZOa QOÔQWRORSa ZOa VOPWZWRORSa g ZOa RSab`ShOa ÔÒ SZ RSaS\d]ZdW[WS\b] dWbOZ \] aS S\QcS\bÒ\ ^ZS\O[S\bS RSaO``]ZZOROa ^]` Z] _cS RSPS SabOPZSQSàS c\ OQ][Ô O[WS\b] T]`[ObWd] OZ \cSd] Q]\QWcRORO\] 3abS RSaS] RS ^`]bSQQW \ RS Z]a [Og]`Sa a]P`S _cWS\ aS Q]\aWRSÒ [S\]a ^`SÔÒR] T aWQO ] âWQ]Z UWQO[S\bS ÔÒ OT`]\bO` ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RS ZO dWRO Sa c\O QOÒQbS` abWQO Tc\RO[S\bOZ RS ZO Q`WO\hO RcÒ\bS ZO W\TO\QWO AW\ S[POÙ] QcSabO bÒPOX] `SOZWhO` SZ OPO\R]\] RS QWS`bO `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR W\RWdWRcOZ g Q]ZSQbWdO a]P`S _cWS\Sa \] aWS\R] \W ]a \] a]\ S\bS\RWR]a Q][] ORcZb]a Q][^ZSbO[S\bS RSaO``]ZZOR]a g R]bOR]a ^]` Z] bO\b] RS b]R]a Z]a Q RWU]a RS ac^S`dWdS\QWO S\ SZ S\b]`\] a]QWOZ SQ]\ [WQ] g QcZbcÒZ _cS \]a `]RSO :O Z UWQO RS ZO Q`WO\hO g OQ][Ô O[WS\b] VO Sd]ZcQW]\OR] Q]\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] Vc[O\] g QWS\b TWQ] 3Z Q]\]QW[WS\b] _cS RWTS`S\bSa RWaQW^ZW\Oa RS ZOa QWS\QWOa a]QWOZSa g \ObcÒZSa VO\ RSaO``]ZZOR] a]P`S ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa RS QOcaO STSQb] S\ ZO T`cabÒQW \ RS ^`]gSQb]a dWbOZSa RSPWRO O ZOa dWdS\QWOa RS `WSaU]a S\ QWS`bOa SbOÔa RS ZO dWRO Q]\ S\]`[Sa Q]abSa Ô`bWQcZO`Sa g Q]ZSQbWd]a RWT QWZSa RS Oac[W` {bWQO[S\bS VO ZZSdOR] O ^ZO\WTWQO` [SQO\Wa[]a RS ^`]bSQQW \ _cS OZSXOÒ\ OZ µR{PWZ¶ g \] ^`SÔÒR] RS ^]RS` S\bÒ` S\ Q]\bOQb] Q]\ aWbcOQW]\Sa ] OQQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] 3Z SabOPZSQW[WS\b] RS c\ Q]`R \ aO\WbO`W] S\ b]`\] O ZO ^Sà]\O X]dS\ aS VO [WbWTWQOR] ^]` aca ^]bS\QWOZSa `SacZbOR]a S\ ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS [ ZbW^ZSa `WSaU]a S\ b]`\] O ac RSaO``]ZZ] PcaQO\R] S\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` ZO Q]\aSQcQW \ RS c\O SaQ]ZO`WROR ^ZS\O Q]\T]`[S O ZO ^ZO\WTWQOQW \ T]`[cZORO Q][] [ta bWZ g dtZWRO g ^]` Z] bO\b] ]PZWUOb]`WO) [O\bS\WS\R] O ZO XcdS\bcR OZSXORO RS ZO aSfcOZWROR ^`S[ObcÒ g \] ^`]UÒ[ORO) OZSXO\R] WUcOZ[S\bS RSZ `WSaU] _cS ac^]\S SZ OQS`QO[WS\b] O QWS`bOa Q]\RcQbOa RS Q]\ac[] RS acPabO\QWOa ^S`XcRWQWOZSa ÔÒ SZ QcS`^] g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] âWQ]a]QWOZ) [O\bS\WS\R] c\O ^`]bSQQW \ a]P`S ZO T`cabÒQW \ RS`WdORO RS {fWb]a g TÒQOa]a S\ ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa ^Sà]\OZSa ] a]QWOZSa S\ SZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] S\ Z]a ^`W[S`]a bÒPOX]a SbQ 3abS Q]`R \ aO\WbO`W] QcS\bO Q]\ ZO ^`SbS\aW \ RS ^]RS` Q]\b`]ZO` g OZQO\hO` b]R]a Z]a Oa^SQb]a _cS ^cSRO\ QOcaO` QcOZ_cWS` _cWSPÒ S\ SZ ^`]QSa] RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ RS ZO XcdS\bcR _cS ^cSRO US\SÒ` QcOZ_cWS` RSadWOQW \ a]P`S ZOa Sf^SQbObWdOa ^cSabOa S\ Z]a `SacZbOR]a RS SaS ^`]QSa] RS RSaO``]ZZ] 3a ^cSa c\O ^`SbS\aW \ [cg OZbO c\O Sf^SQbObWdO [cg SZSdORO g _cS ^]` Z] bO\b] ^cSRS ZZSdO` O [cQVOa T`cabÒQW]\Sa ^]` Ô`bS RS Z]a ORcZb]a _cS ZOa VO\ US\SÒR] Oa Q][] OZ QV]_cS Q]\ _cWS\Sa \] `Sa^]\RS\ O SZZOa Q]\ ^]bS\QWOZSa Q]\TZWQb]a S\b`S O[P]a U`c^]a 3\ ^`W[S` ZcUO` ZO Sf^SQbObWdO g ZO SabÒbSUWO ÔÒ OZQO\hO`ZO S\ POaS O ZOa \SQSaWRORSa RSZ U`c^] RS ORcZb]a RS ac S\bS\RW[WS\b] RS ZO W[^]`bO\QWO Q]\T]`[S O aca ^S`QS^QW]\Sa \SQSaWRORSa QcZbcÒZSa ] SQ]\ [WQOa S\ ac ^`]^W] Q]\bSfb] AW\ S[POÙ] ZOa \SQSaWRORSa RSZ X]dS\ a]\ RWTS`S\bSa Sa RWT QWZ Q][Ô`bW` c\]a Q RWU]a RS O^`S\RWhOXS SabOPZSQWR]a S\ POaS O c\O T]`[cZOQW \ RS \SQSaWRORSa QcO\R] aS dWdS\ \SQSaWRORSa RWTS`S\bSa

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

AS ^`]RcQS c\ RSa^ZOhO[WS\b] RS Z]a Q`WbS`W]a RS cbWZWROR g RS dOZWRSh RS Z]a O^`S\RWhOXSa Q]\ T`cabÒQWÂ&#x201E;\ ÔÒ b]RO ^Sà]\O W\bS`dW\WS\bS S\ SZ ^`]QSa] SRcQObWd] TO[WZWO ^`]TSa]ÒR] g SZ ^`]^W] OZc[\OR] :Oa QOÔQWRORSa VOPWZWRORSa g RSab`ShOa bÒ\a[WbWROa Q][] W[^`SaQW\RWPZSa ÔÒ SZ RSaS\d]ZdW[WS\b] S\ c\ [c\R] SZ RS Z]a ORcZb]a bWS\S\ ZW[WbOQW]\Sa ÔÒ aS`dW` OZ [c\R] S\ SZ _cS aS S\QcS\bÒ W\[SàO ZO XcdS\bcR 3\ ]b`]a [][S\b]a RS ZO VWab]`WO ZO RWabO\QWO S\b`S ZOa \SQSaWRORSa RS O[P]a U`c^]a aS S\Q]\bÒPO\ [cg OQ]bOROa ^S`] ZO Sd]ZcQWÂ&#x201E;\ bSQ\]ZÂ&#x201E;UWQO R]bORO RS c\ RW\O[Wa[] aW\ ^`SQSRS\bSa VO OZbSÒR] QÂ&#x201E;RWU]a S W\ab`c[S\b]a Q][c\WQObWd]a Q][] \c\QO O\bSa aS VOP O ROR] W[ÔQbO\R] Q]\ [ta TcS`hO S\ ZO dWRO RS _cWS\ Sa [ta X]dS\ g aS ORO^bO Q]\ [Og]` QOÔQWROR O RWQVO RW\t[WQO 3ab] OQ`SQWS\bO ZO P`SQVO S\b`S O[P]a [c\R]a VOQWS\R] RWT QWZ c\ Q]\aS\a] S\ ZO RSbS`[W\OQWÂ&#x201E;\ QZOÒ _c{ VOPWZWRORSa aS`t\ [ta Â&#x2030;bWZSa g _c{ QÂ&#x201E;RWU]a aS`t\ RS [Og]` dOZWRSh S\ SZ [][S\b] ^]abS`W]` [S`[O\R] ZO aWbcOQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS Ocb]`WROR RS c\O [Og]` SROR >]` ]b`] ZOR] ZO RSbS`[W\OQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS c\ Q]`RÂ&#x201E;\ ^`SdS\bWd] S\ b]`\] O ZO W\Sf^S`WS\QWO RS ZO XcdS\bcR QcS\bO bO[PW{\ Q]\ c\O OZbSÒQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS ZO ^S`QS^QWÂ&#x201E;\ RS ZO `SOZWROR S\ SZ [c\R] OQbcOZ :O ]^W\WÂ&#x201E;\ ^Â&#x2030;PZWQO a]P`S ZO `SOZWROR XcdS\WZ aS Q]\T]`[O O bÒd{a RS ZO TcS`hO RSbS`[W\O\bS RS Z]a [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQWÂ&#x201E;\ Q][] \c\QO O\bSa VOP O acQSRWR] SabOPZSQWS\R] ^`W]`WRORSa RS OQbcOQWÂ&#x201E;\ g QÂ&#x201E;RWU]a ^`]^W]a S\ ZO [Og]` O RS ZOa ]QOaW]\Sa aW\ \W\UÂ&#x2030;\ aS\bWR] SabÒb{UWQ] aW\] SZ [S`] ]T`SQW[WS\b] RS c\ Q]\ac[] [ta Oc\_cS \] aSO ^S`QWPWR] Q][] bOZ :O W[OUS\ a]P`S ZO XcdS\bcR aS POaO S\ ac [Og]` O S\ SabS`S]bW^]a g US\SÒZWhOQW]\Sa S\ ZO PÂ&#x2030;a_cSRO RS bW^WTWQOQW]\Sa a]P`S OQbWbcRSa g Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a 3dWRS\bS[S\bS ZZO[O [cQV aW[] [ta ZO ObS\QWÂ&#x201E;\ [SRWtbWQO b]R] Z] _cS ac^]\UO c\O P`SQVO ] RWabO\QWO[WS\b] RS ZO bS\RS\QWO [Og]`WbO`WO RS ZO a]QWSROR Q]\a]ZWRORO Tc\RO[S\bOZ[S\bS S\ SZ [c\R] ORcZb] AW\ S[POÙ] \] aS ^`SaS\bO\ aWbcOQW]\Sa Q]\ SZ ]PXSbWd] RS `Sa]ZdS` aWbcOQW]\Sa aW\] Q][] [SÒ SfVWPWQWÂ&#x201E;\ O []R] RS Sa^SQbtQcZ] RS SaO W[OUS\ bÒ\aT]`[ORO g `SRcQWRO RS ZO dS`ROR XcdS\WZ <]a S\Q]\bÒ[]a S\ SabO aWbcOQWÂ&#x201E;\ [SRWtbWQO Q]\ c\ Q]\bÒabS \]bOPZS g _cS RSbS`[W\O Tc\RO[S\bOZ[S\bS ZO ^S`QS^QWÂ&#x201E;\ RS ZO XcdS\bcR S\ \cSabÒ a]QWSROR RSaRS ZO ZSXO\ O g SZ RSaQ]\]QW[WS\b] RSZ [c\R] XcdS\WZ OaS\bt\R]aS S\ Z] ^S`QS^bWd] dOZ]ÒbWd] g acPXSbWd] >]` c\ ZOR] ZO ZSQbcÒ dWbOZWabO RS ZO XcdS\bcR S\ ^]aWbWd] Q]\ c\ ]PXSbWd] RS [O`YSbW\U RSabW\OR] O ZO ^`][]QWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ Q]\ac[] S\ ZO _cS ZO W[OUS\ g ZOa OQbWbcRSa XcdS\WZSa a]\ dtZWROa gO S\ QcOZ_cWS` SbOÔ RS ZO dWRO Q]\ ZO `SU`SaWÂ&#x201E;\ bS[^]ÒZ Q]\bW\cO _cS ÔÒ b]RO ZO ^]PZOQWÂ&#x201E;\ Q]\ZZSdO SabO aWbcOQWÂ&#x201E;\ :]a ORXSbWd]a dW\QcZOR]a O Z] XcdS\WZ aS a]P`SdOZ]Ò\ O ZO Ô` _cS aS W\TÒdOZ]Ò\ Z]a ^`]^W]a RS ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO dWbOZ g ZO [ORc`Sh Q]\ ZO [Wa[O W\bS\aWROR _cS aS SfVWPS ZO W[OUS\ ^`]^WO RS ZO XcdS\bcR Q][] aW\Â&#x201E;\W[] RS PWS\SabO` g PSZZShO S\ c\ RSaS] Q]ZSQbWd] RS ÔÒRO RSZ QWQZ] dWbOZ 3\ c\ aS\bWR] Q]\bÒ`W] Oc\_cS bO[PW{\ Q]\ c\ ]PXSbWd] RS Q`SOQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS c\ ^`]RcQb] RSabW\OR] OZ Q]\ac[] aS T]`[cZO c\O W[OUS\ S\ \SUObWd] RS ZO XcdS\bcR S\ bO\b] S\ QcO\b] \] Sa aSUcWRWabO RS ZOa \]`[Oa SabOPZSQWROa Q]\ O\bS`W]`WROR S\ ZO a]QWSROR ] OZ [S\]a ZO ZSQbcÒ Â&#x2030;\WQO _cS RS RWQVOa \]`[Oa VOQS ZO ^]PZOQWÂ&#x201E;\ ORcZbO 3\ SabS aS\bWR] Z]a [SRW]a RS

8Â&#x201E;dS\Sa g USabWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ `WSaU]

Q][c\WQOQWย \ aW`dS\ RS QObOZWhOR]`Sa RS Z]a ^`SXcWQW]a RS\b`] RS c\O US\SÒZWhOQWย \ RS Z]a Xย dS\Sa g c\O dO\OZWhOQWย \ O\OZ bWQO a]P`S aWbcOQW]\Sa g \SQSaWRORSa 3Z {\TOaWa aS ^]\S S\ Z]a ROb]a [ta \SUObWd]a PcaQO\R] ZO ObS\QWย \ RSZ Q]\ac[WR]` RS Q][c\WQOQWย \ O QcOZ_cWS` ^`SQW] aW\ RcRO` S\ Q`SO` OZO`[O a]QWOZ ] ^]bS\QWOZSa QV]_cSa R][{abWQ]a S\b`S US\SÒQW]\Sa RWabW\bOa :O `S^`SaS\bOQWย \ RSaOXcabORO RS Z] XcdS\WZ ^]` Ô`bS RS Z]a [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQWย \ US\SÒ ^`]QSa]a Q][^ZSX]a S\ Z]a _cS ^SaS O _cS Z]a Xย dS\Sa g ZOa Xย dS\Sa \] aS dS\ WRS\bWTWQOR]a Q]\ SaS [c\R] bS`[W\O\ S\bS\RWS\R] RWQVO `S^`SaS\bOQWย \ g OR]^bO\R] Q][] ^`]^W]a OZUc\]a SabS`S]bW^]a Oa Q][] Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a :O XcdS\bcR bS`[W\O OQbcO\R] S\ ]QOaW]\Sa Q][] aS Sa^SÒ _cS OQbย S RS bOZ [O\SÒ _cS OZUc\]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a _cS QcOZ_cWS` a]QWSROR W\bS\bO` O SdWbO` ^]` Tc\QW]\OZWROR bS`[W\O\ aWS\R] []bWdOR]a ^]` c\ `STZSX] RSZ \cSd] OUS\bS a]QWOZWhOR]` _cS Oc\_cS \] ]TWQWOZ[S\bS VO RSa^ZOhOR] O b]R]a Z]a RS[ta 2S O_c _cS ZO ]PaSaWย \ aO\WbO`WO ^]` [O\bS\S` O ZO XcdS\bcR OZSXORO RS Z]a `WSaU]a bS`[W\O QOgS\R] S\ c\O Q]\bÒRWQQWย \ gO _cS ^]` c\ ZOR] aS ^]\S S\ dOZ]` ZO T`SaQcÒ RW\O[Wa[] TOZbO RS [ORc`Sh S\ ZOa OQbWbcRSa g QWS`bO W``Sa^]\aOPWZWROR OQS^bt\R]Z] ÔÒ ZO a]QWSROR S\ ac Q]\Xc\b] [WS\bÒa _cS ^]` ]b`] ZOR] aS ObOQO OZ U`c^] RS Xย dS\Sa ^]` OQbcOQW]\Sa `SZOQW]\OROa Q]\ Sa]a ORXSbWd]a _cS ZS a]\ ^`]^W]a ^S`] _cS RS [O\SÒ `SRcQQW]\WabO aS SfVWPS\ Q][] QOcaO\bSa RS Q]\TZWQb]a ^]` Ô`bS RS ZO ]^W\Wย \ ^ย PZWQO

2SZ ^`]bSQQW]\Wa[] RS ZO SdWbOQWย \ RSZ `WSaU] VOQWO ZO ^`][]QWย \ RS ZO Ocb]\][ O 3a S\bS\RWPZS _cS aS ^`SbS\RO ^`]bSUS` a]QWOZ[S\bS OZ [ta R{PWZ S W\QZca] Sa RSaSOPZS S\ ZO Q]\ab`cQQWย \ {bWQO RS c\O a]QWSROR ^S`] aWS[^`S _cS aS VOUO RSaRS c\ ^c\b] RS dWabO _cS bS\UO S\ QcS\bO Z]a ^`]^W]a W\bS`SaSa RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ^`]bSUWROa 2S c\O [O\SÒ Q]\bÒ`WO aS ^]R` O\ US\SÒ` aWbcOQW]\Sa ^S`\WQW]aOa g Q]\bÒRWQb]`WOa gO _cS QWS`bOa a]ZcQW]\Sa POaOROa S\ SZ Ocb]`WbO`Wa[] aS` O\ RS Q][^ZWQOR] S\QOXS S\ c\O a]QWSROR _cS PcaQO ZO ZWPS`bOR Q][] dOZ]` RS `STS`S\QWO 3\ ZOa a]QWSRORSa bÒRWQW]\OZSa SZ [c\R] aS S\Q]\bÒPO [ta ZW[WbOR] S\ ac SfbS\aWย \ [ta Q]\b`]ZOR] g [ta Q]\b`]ZOPZS Oa Q][] Z]a `WSaU]a RS`WdOR]a RS SaS ^S_cSย ] [c\R] _cS ^]R O `]RSO` O QcOZ_cWS` ^Sà]\O RSaRS SZ \OQW[WS\b] VOabO ZO [cS`bS 3Z UÒR] RS QS`bShO a]P`S Z] _cS SÒ ย bWZ ÔÒ RSaS\d]ZdSàS S\ RWQV] [SRW] SÒ [cg OZb] ^]` Z] _cS ZOa US\SÒQW]\Sa O\bS`W]`Sa ^]R O\ RWaT`cbO` RS c\O VSUS[]\ O S\ ZO bÒ\a[WaWย \ RS ÔcbOa RS Q]\RcQbO g Qย RWU]a RS W\bS`^`SbOQWย \ RS RWQV] [c\R] :]a `WSaU]a aS S\Q]\bÒPO\ TtQWZ[S\bS WRS\bWTWQOR]a g Z]a [SQO\Wa[]a RS ^`]bSQQWย \ U`cÔZ acTWQWS\bS[S\bS O`bWQcZOR]a SabO\R] acXSb]a aย Z] O Z]a QO^`WQV]a RS ZO \ObcÒZShO g aca Q]\aSQcS\QWOa :O Sd]ZcQWย \ VOQWO a]QWSRORSa []RS`\Oa VWh] _cS [cQVOa ^Sà]\Oa \] Q][Ô`bWSÒ\ SZ c\WdSà] SfWabS\QWOZ RS ZO US\SÒQWย \ ^`SQSRS\bS :]a ^`]QSa]a RS OPO\R]\] RSZ [SRW] `cÒZ g SZ Q`SQW[WS\b] RS ZOa QWcRORSa QO[PWO`]\ [cQVOa RS ZOa QS`bShOa VS`SROROa \SQSaWbt\R]aS c\O `SOZW\SOQWย \ RS ZOa QOÔQWRORSa ÔÒ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] dWbOZ RS\b`] RSZ [Wa[] RSaS] RS [O\bS\S` SZ `WSaU] g ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S Z] [ta OQ]bOR]a _cS aS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

^cRWSÒ >S`] ZO [Og]` Q][^ZSXWROR gO \SQSaWbOPO RS _cWS\ ^cRWSÒ bS\S` c\O [ta O[^ZWO Sf^S`WS\QWO ÔÒ _cS ^cRWSÒ W\bS`^`SbO` c\]a Q RWU]a RS [Og]` Q][^ZSXWROR g O[^ZWbcR ^cRWS\R] bÒaZORO` QZOdSa bWZSa ÔÒ OT`]\bO` Z]a RSaOT ]a dWbOZSa :]a ^`]TSaW]\OZSa RS ZO SRcQOQW \ QORO dSh R]bOR]a RS [Og]` bSQ\WTWQOQW \ S\ aca O^`S\RWhOXSa g S\ aca S\aS O\hOa aS `Sa^]\aOPWZWhOPO\ ]TWQWOZ[S\bS RS OQ][Ô O` SZ ^`]QSa] RS W\Q]`^]ÒQW \ XcdS\WZ O SaS [c\R] RS QO[PW] bÒ\_cWZ] AW\ S[POÙ] \]a S\Q]\bÒ[]a S\ ZO a]QWSROR OQbcOZ QO[PW]a _cS \W Z]a [ta X dS\Sa VcPW{Ò[]a Sa^SÒR] ^]`_cS Z]a RSaO``]ZZ]a bSQ\]Z UWQ]a Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS S\ ZOa Q][c\WQOQW]\Sa VO\ QO[PWOR] b]bOZ[S\bS \cSabÒ ^S`QS^QW \ RS ZO `SOZWROR >]` Z] bO\b] ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RS QS`bShO aS VO\ dWab] QcSabW]\OROa g RSa^ZOhOROa RS [O\SÒ [ta \]bOPZS _cS S\ [][S\b]a ^`SQSRS\bSa S\ ZO VWab]`WO RS ZO 6c[O\WROR 3a W[^]aWPZS R]bO` RS dOZWRSh OPa]ZcbO O Z]a W\ab`c[S\b]a Q]\ Z]a _cS c\O US\SÒQW \ _cWS`S R]bO` O ZO aWUcWS\bS ÔÒ dOZSàS S\ ac RSaO``]ZZ] dWbOZ 3a QOaW W[^]aWPZS VOPZO` RS c\O XcdS\bcR ^]`_cS aS RO\ [cQVOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RWTS`S\bSa `SOZWRORSa g \SQSaWRORSa \] a Z] S\ Tc\QW \ RS R]\RS aS dWdO _cS SÒ c\O dO`WOPZS RSbS`[W\O\bS S\ ]b`]a [][S\b]a AS ^cSRS\ Q][Ô`bW` WRS\bWRORSa Q]\ X dS\Sa OZSXOR]a US]U`tTWQO[S\bS S WRS\bWTWQOàS ^]Q] Q]\ c\ dSQW\] RS aW[WZO` SROR ^]` Z] _cS Sa RWT QWZ ac ObS\QW \ W\RWTS`S\QWORO RS\b`] RS c\O [Wa[O OQbcOQW \ ^`SdS\bWdO :O W[^]aWPWZWROR aS \]a ^ZO\bSO aW _cS`S[]a OWaZO` O ZO XcdS\bcR RS ZO a]QWSROR _cS ZS `]RSO g _cS VO\ Q]\ab`cWR] Tc\RO[S\bOZ[S\bS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ORcZbOa ^]aWPZS[S\bS Q]\ c\]a `SacZbOR]a [cg RWTS`S\bSa O Z]a ^`SbS\RWR]a ^S`] Sab] Sa acTWQWS\bS[S\bS Q][^ZSX] Q][] ÔÒ \] ]PaSaW]\OàS Q]\ SZZ] AW\ S[POÙ] \] ^cSRS Q]\aWRSÒàS _cS ZO XcdS\bcR aSO d QbW[O g dWQbW[O`WO W\RWabW\bO[S\bS RS ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] S\ ZOa _cS dWdS Q][] bO[^]Q] aS ^cSRS `SQ]\]QS` ^]` c\ ZOR] ZO ZWPS`bOR g ^]` ]b`] [O\bS\S` c\O Pc`PcXO aO\WbO`WO g ^`SdS\bWdO S\ b]`\] O _cWS\ Q][WS\hO ZO O\RORcÒ RS ac Ocb]\][ O a]QWOZ ;cQV]a RS Z]a ^]bS\QWOZSa `WSaU]a RS ZO XcdS\bcR bWS\S\ _cS dS` Q]\ aWbcOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa S\ Z]a _cS ZOa RSQWaW]\Sa RS ]b`]a OQb]`Sa ^]Z bWQ]a SQ]\ [WQ]a ] QcZbcÒZSa bWS\S\ STSQb]a `SOZSa a]P`S ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS dWRO RS b]RO ZO a]QWSROR W\TZcgS\R] RS T]`[O [ta W\QWaWdO a]P`S SabS U`c^] RS ^]PZOQW \ :O a]QWSROR ^`SbS\RWRO[S\bS ^`]bSQb]Ò Sa `SOZ[S\bS ZO _cS ]`WUW\O ZO [Og]` O RS ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] _cS ^`SbS\RS Q][PObW` 3ab] ZZSdO O ZO Q]\bÒRWQQW \ RS RO` Q]\ c\O [O\] Z] _cS Sabt O``SPObO\R] Q]\ ]bÒ [S`[O\R] ZO Q]\TWO\hO _cS ^cSRS aS` ]b]ÙORO OZ aWabS[O ^]` Ô`bS RS QcOZ_cWS` X]dS\ 3a W[^`SaQW\RWPZS _cS ^cSRO R]bOàS OZ X]dS\ RS [SQO\Wa[]a S\ Z]a _cS SZ Q]\bOQb] Q]\ aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] aSO aOZdOR] aW\ Q]\aSQcS\QWOa \SUObWdOa ] Q]\ ZO [S\]` W\QWRS\QWO RS SabOa a]P`S a [Wa[] bO\b] S\ SZ ^`SaS\bS Q][] S\ SZ Tcbc`] 6Og _cS Ô`bW` RS ZO POaS RS _cS ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] ^]R`t\ dWdWàS S\ QcOZ_cWS` [][S\b] g S\ QcOZ_cWS` Q]\bSfb] ^]`_cS \c\QO bS\R`S[]a b]ROa ZOa dO`WOPZSa OQ]bOROa \W ^]R`S[]a OZSXO` \c\QO OZ X]dS\ RS ZO Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ ^]` Z] _cS RSPS`t bS\S` ZOa acTWQWS\bSa VOPWZWRORSa ÔÒ \OdSUO` ^]` bO\ b]`bc]aOa OUcOa :O OQS^bOQW \ RS QWS`bOa VOPWZWRORSa ^]` Ô`bS RSZ X]dS\ aS POaO S\ ZO Q]\TWO\hO _cS ^cSRO RS^]aWbOàS S\ ZOa [Wa[Oa bS\WS\R] _cS dS` Tc\RO[S\bOZ[S\bS Q]\ ac dOZWRSh STSQbWdO 3\ [cQVOa ]QOaW]\Sa ZO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

US\SÒQW \ RS ORcZb]a \] ^cSRS Q]\TS`W` [ta OgcRO _cS SZ O^]g] S[]QW]\OZ Ô`bWS\R] RSZ S\bS\RW[WS\b] RS ZO `SOZWROR RS ZO SbOÔ XcdS\WZ Oc\_cS a Z] TcSÒ ^]` VOPS` ÔaOR] ^]` SZZO ^S`] aW\ ^S\aO` ] ^`SbS\RS` _cS ZOa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa a]\ ZOa [Wa[Oa g _cS Z]a W\ab`c[S\b]a dtZWR]a ÔÒ ObÒdSaO`ZO Q]\ {fWb] S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] bS\UO\ cbWZWROR S\ ]b`] RWTS`S\bS 2S VSQV] S\ ]QOaW]\Sa ZO ^`]^WO RSbS`[W\OQW \ QcZbcÒZ VS`SRORO a]P`S Z]a c[PÒZSa RS `WSaU] g ]^]`bc\WROR SabOPZSQWR]a ^]` SZ Q]ZSQbWd] a]QWOZ ^cSRS\ Q]\RWQW]\O` g RWab]àW]\O` O ZO ^Sà]\O S\ ac b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa ^]` Z] _cS RSPS` O RS QW`Qc\aQ`WPWàS S\ ZO [Og]` [SRWRO RS Z] ^]aWPZS O ZO dSÒQWROR SfQZcgS\R] Z]a SZS[S\b]a dOZ]ÒbWd]a g acPXSbWd]a a]P`S RWQV]a c[PÒZSa 3dWRS\bS[S\bS bO[PW{\ aS VO OdO\hOR] S\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a SRcQObWd]a aS VO ÔaOR] RS []RSZ]a W\bcWbWd]a [SÒ[S\bS O ]b`]a R]bOR]a RS [Og]` ÒQW]\OZWROR POat\R]\]a S\ Z] ^`]POPWZ abWQ] g ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa RS QOcaOa g STSQb]a S\b`S ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa g ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa aWS[^`S RS ZO [O\SÒ Z] [ta Q]\bÒabORO ^]aWPZS Q]\ Z] _cS ^cSRS\ O\ROàS [SX]` Z]a QO[W\]a ÔÒ ]PbS\S` ZO Q]\TWO\hO RS Z]a X dS\Sa O ZO V]Ò S\Q]\bÒ` S\ ac Q]\bSfb] Z]a c[PÒZSa RS `WSaU] _cS ZSa ^S`[WbO\ b][O` RSQWaW]\Sa ORSQcOROa a]P`S SZZ]a :O Q`SRWPWZWROR RSZ aWabS[O g RS aca OQb]`Sa ÔÒ ZO ^Sà]\O X]dS\ aS Tc\RO[S\bO S\ UÒ\ [SRWRO S\ Z] O\bS`W]` 3Z ZS[O RSZ >ZO\ <OQW]\OZ RS 2`]UOa µ;ta W\T]`[OQW \ [S\]a `WSaU]a¶ O`bWQcZO QZOÒ[S\bS Q [] RSPS RS ROàS SZ ^`]QSa] RS R]bOQW \ RS VS`Ò[WS\bOa ^`SdS\bWdOa Ocb \][Oa ^]` Ô`bS RS Z]a OUS\bSa RS a]QWOZWhOQW \ RS X dS\Sa ÔÒ P]`RSO` Z]a `WSaU]a aW\ Q]\aSQcS\QWOa \SUObWdOa :O Q]\ab`cQQW \ RS c\O WRS\bWROR a ZWRO Sa aWS[^`S c\ aSUc`] T`S\bS O Z]a `WSaU]a _cS SfWabS\ _cS Sabt\ g Q]\ Z]a _cS Q]\dWdW[]a :O Q]\QS\bÒQW \ RS ObS\QW \ S\ ZO ^]PZOQW \ X]dS\ aS RO ^]` ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR Q]\ ZO _cS Sa dWabO RWQVO SbOÔ Oc\_cS ^]R` O[]a S\Q]\bÒ`\]a WRS\bWRORSa dcZ\SÒPZSa S\ QcOZ_cWS` SbOÔ RS ZO dWRO Q]\ c\O \SQSaWROR W\QZca] [Og]` RS ObS\QW \ 3a ^cSa W[^`SaQW\RWPZS ^]\S` {\TOaWa S\ OQbcOQW]\Sa Q]\ Z]a _cS aS R]bS RS Ocb]\][ O OZ X]dS\ ÔÒ RSQWRW` g OQS`bO` S\ ac SZSQQW \ RS ZO [O\SÒ [ta TOd]ÒPZS O ac aOZcR âWQ]a]QWOZ >OÒ SZZ] Sa W[^`SaQW\RWPZS _cS aS R]bS RS VOPWZWRORSa a]QWOZSa a ZWROa g RS c\O Ocb]SabW[O `ST]`hORO RS bOZ [O\SÒ _cS ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR O[W\]`S ZOa `S^S`QcaW]\Sa \]QWdOa RS ^]bS\QWOZSa Sf^S`W[S\bOQW]\Sa _cS [cg ^`]POPZS[S\bS ^cSRO\ ROàS <] VOg _cS ^]\S` ^cSa c\O ]PaSaW \ []ÒZ S\ ZO Sf^S`W[S\bOQW \ aW\] _cS SabO aS ^`]RchQO S\ c\O aWbcOQW \ RS RSPWZWROR ^Sà]\OZ _cS [ObS`WOZWQS ZOa ^S]`Sa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RSZ `WSaU] Oac[WR] AW Z]a `WSaU]a aS Oac[S\ Sa ^]`_cS SfWabS ZO ZWPS`bOR QOÔQWROR RS SZSUW` g Q]\]QW[WS\b] ÒQW]\OZ ÔÒ `SOZWhO` c\ QtZQcZ] a]P`S Z]a Q]abSa g PS\STWQW]a ^`SaS\bSa g Tcbc`]a RS b][O` c\O RSQWaW \ :] W[^]`bO\bS Sa RSaO``]ZZO` SabÒbSUWOa _cS R]bS\ RS RWQVO VOPWZWROR OZ X]dS\ O [SRW` ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa g O Oac[W`ZOa Q][] ]`WUW\OROa ^]` a [Wa[] RS\b`] RS c\O aWbcOQW \ RS Ocb]\][ O

6OQWO c\ RWaQcà] Q]\ab`cQbWd] RSZ `WSaU] O bÒd{a RS ZO USabW \ RSZ `WSaU] g ]^]`bc\WRORSa 3\ SabS Q]\bSfb] Z] [ta W[^]`bO\bS Sa ZO Q]\QWS\QWO S\ b]`\] OZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS VOPWZWRORSa acTWQWS\bSa ÔÒ ZO XcdS\bcR S\ SZ S\T`S\bO[WS\b] O Z]a

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

`WSaU]a ^`]^W]a RS ac SROR g RS ZO dWRO []RS`\O RSaRS SZ S\bS\RW[WS\b] RS aca `SOZWRORSa aWbcOQW]\Sa g \SQSaWRORSa \] a]P`S ZOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa g SabS`S]bW^]a a]P`S ZO XcdS\bcR W\abOcÒR]a S\b`S ZO ^]PZOQWÂ&#x201E;\ ORcZbO _cS S\ [cQVOa ]QOaW]\Sa bS`[W\O XchUt\R]ZO g Q]\RS\t\R]ZO [ta _cS OgcRt\R]ZO >]` Sab] Sa W[^]`bO\bS SZ SabOPZSQW[WS\b] RS c\ RWtZ]U] Q]\abO\bS POaOR] S\ ZO Q]\TWO\hO aW\ ^`SXchUO` [SRWO\bS O^`W]`Wa[]a AW SZ ^c\b] RS Ô`bWRO RS ZO \SU]QWOQWÂ&#x201E;\ Sa _cS ZO XcdS\bcR bWS\S c\ Q]\TZWQb] ] c\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] O\bWa]QWOZ ZO `Sa^cSabO _cS ^cSRS Sa^SÒàS Sa ^]bS\QWOZ[S\bS \SUObWdO <] aS ^cSRS W\QZca] ^`SbS\RS` _cS O ^`W]`W \cSab`] W\bS`Z]Qcb]` Q][Ô`bO \cSab`]a QÂ&#x201E;RWU]a {bWQ]a g []ÒZSa S\b`S ]bÒa Q]aOa ^]`_cS bS\R`t dWdS\QWOa RWTS`S\bSa O ZOa \cSabÒa ^]` Z] _cS SaS SaTcS`h] RSPS RS S\Q]\bÒàS S\ SZ ]`WUS\ RS b]R] OQS`QO[WS\b] :O Q]\TWO\hO aS POaO S\ _cS SZ RWtZ]U] RSPS S\Q]\bÒàS OPWS`b] O QcOZ_cWS` `SacZbOR] RWOZ{QbWQ] RS\b`] RS Z] ÒQW]\OZ ^]` Z] _cS \] RSPS bÒbOàS RS c\ [S`] b`t[WbS ] SfQcaO ÔÒ W[^]\S` c\O a]ZcQWÂ&#x201E;\ POX] SZ dSZ] RS c\ ^`SbS\RWR] ÔQb] S\b`S Ô`bSa a]P`S b]R] ^]`_cS Sa ZO ^Sà]\O X]dS\ ZO Ô`bS R{PWZ RS ZO \SU]QWOQWÂ&#x201E;\ g S\ ZO W[^]aWQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS \]`[Oa \] VOg aSUc`WROR RS _cS dOgO O dSàS acXSb] ^]` SZZOa ^]` Z] bO\b] O `Sa^SbO`ZOa 3Z R]PZS RWaQcà] Sa ^S`QWPWR] ^]` ZO XcdS\bcR S\Q]\bÒ\R] S\ ZOa Q]\bÒRWQQW]\Sa SZS[S\b]a RS T]`bOZSQW[WS\b] RS ac Q]\RcQbO 1cO\R] aS VO RSPObWR] S\ b]`\] OZ TS\Â&#x201E;[S\] RSZ P]bSZZÂ&#x201E;\ aS VO bS\WR] S\ QcS\bO c\O Z \SO RS RWaQcà] ^Â&#x2030;PZWQ] ]TWQWOZ S\ b]`\] O ZO \SQSaWROR RS [O\bS\S` OZSXOR]a O ZOa XÂ&#x201E;dS\Sa RSZ Q]\ac[] RS acPabO\QWOa ^S`\WQW]aOa Q][] SZ OZQ]V]Z \]QWdOa ÔÒ ac aOZcR g ÔÒ aca `SZOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa 3\ ZOa SabÒbSUWOa _cS VO\ W\bS\bOR] Q]\dS\QS` RS SabO `SOZWROR O Z]a XÂ&#x201E;dS\Sa g VO\ `SQc``WR] O ZO `SUcZOQWÂ&#x201E;\ ^`]VWPWbWdO RS SabS Q][^]`bO[WS\b] Oa Q][] O ZO aO\QWÂ&#x201E;\ RS ZO OQbcOQWÂ&#x201E;\ O\bWXc` RWQO VO\ RS[]abÒR] ac \cZO STSQbWdWROR 3\ \W\UÂ&#x2030;\ [][S\b] ZO a]QWSROR VO `STZSfW]\OR] aS`WO[S\bS a]P`S ZO ^`SaS\QWO ]TWQWOZ g ]TWQWOZWhORO RSZ OZQ]V]Z S\ \cSabÒ QcZbcÒ 3\ O_cSZZ]a Q]\bSfb]a S\ Z]a _cS dS`RORSÒ[S\bS VO aWR] OP]`ROR] SZ ^`]PZS[O Ô`bWS\R] RS ZO SfWabS\QWO RS c\ Q]\TZWQb] g ^cU\O ^]` Z]a SaÔQW]a ^Â&#x2030;PZWQ]a ÔÒ ca]a g \SQSaWRORSa RWTS`S\bSa S\b`S US\SÒQW]\Sa Q]\ SZ Q]\aWUcWS\bS ^`]PZS[O RS Q]\dWdS\QWO aS VO\ Q]\aSUcWR] [SX]`Sa `SacZbOR]a :O XcdS\bcR \] ^S`QWPS ZO Q]\bÒRWQQWÂ&#x201E;\ RWaQcàWdO g S\bÒ O ZO \SU]QWOQWÂ&#x201E;\ Q]\ Ocb]`WRORSa g dSQW\RO`W]a Sf^]\WS\R] aca \SQSaWRORSa S W\bS\bO\R] Q][^`S\RS` ZO RS aca W\bS`Z]Qcb]`Sa O^]`bO\R] a]ZcQW]\Sa g OQS^bO\R] Z]a ÔQb]a `SacZbO\bSa AS bÒbO RS c\ OQS`QO[WS\b] RWTS`S\bS g ^]` Z] bO\b] bO[PW{\ RS Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RWTS`S\bSa 3Z ^`]PZS[O `SOZ _cS _cWS`S aS` OP]`ROR] aS RSTW\S [SX]` RSaRS ZO dSÒQWROR gO _cS ZO XcdS\bcR \] S\bÒ Q]\ TOQWZWROR O ZOa acbWZShOa RS Z]a QÂ&#x201E;RWU]a Q][c\WQObWd]a RS Z] ^]Z bWQO[S\bS Q]``SQb] 1]\ dSÒQWROR W\T]`[ObWdO g Q][c\WQObWdO aS RO c\O [Og]` `SQS^bWdWROR ^]` Ô`bS RS ZO ^]PZOQWÂ&#x201E;\ X]dS\ g ^cSRS\ Q]\aS\acOàS Z]a Z [WbSa ÔÒ QORO aWbcOQWÂ&#x201E;\ C\ aWabS[O RS ZWPS`bORSa bWS\S ZO Q][^ZSXWROR RS ZO \SU]QWOQWÂ&#x201E;\ T`S\bS O ZO Q][]RWROR _cS ZO W[^]aWQWÂ&#x201E;\ bWS\S ÔÒ QcOZ_cWS` ^Sà]\O _cS RWaT`cbS RS c\O aWbcOQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS ^]RS` ^S`] _cS \c\QO ^]R`t U]hO` RS ZO VSUS[]\ O Q][] ÔÒ Q]\b`]ZO` b]ROa ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa BWS\S\ _cS SabOPZSQSàS ZOa ÔcbOa ^SROUÂ&#x201E;UWQOa ÔÒ RSaS\d]ZdSàS S\ RWQVO `SOZWROR gO _cS Sa [cg

8Â&#x201E;dS\Sa g USabWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ `WSaU]

Q][^ZWQOR] RSaO``]ZZO` W\bcWbWdO[S\bS SZ W\ab`c[S\bOZ \SQSaO`W] ÔÒ SZ SXS`QWQW] `Sa^]\aOPZS RS ZO QWcRORO\ O Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS ÔÒ ZO XcdS\bcR 3\ c\ aWabS[O ÒQW]\OZWhOR] RS `WSaU]a g ]^]`bc\WRORSa RSPS\ SabOPZSQSàS [SQO\Wa[]a _cS ^S`[WbO\ WRS\bWTWQO` QZOÒ[S\bS SZ `WSaU] g [SRW`Z] RSTW\W` ZOa ]^QW]\Sa SfWabS\bSa ÔÒ `SRcQW`Z] ] SZW[W\O`Z] SabOPZSQWS\R] ZOa OQQW]\Sa ORSQcOROa g SdOZcO\R] ZO STWQWS\QWO g STSQbWdWROR RS ZOa OQbWdWRORSa ^]` aWabS[Oa RS W\T]`[OQWย \ ^S`bW\S\bSa 3Z RSaO``]ZZ] RS c\O QcZbcÒ RS ZO aSUc`WROR S\ ZO ^`SdS\QWย \ RS `WSaU]a SfWUS _cS Z]a dOZ]`Sa ZOa OQbWbcRSa ZOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa ZOa Q][^SbS\QWOa g Z]a Ôb`]\Sa RS Q]\RcQbO RS U`c^]a S W\RWdWRc]a aS OZW\SS\ OZ [tfW[] Q]\ ZO `SOZWROR C\O PcS\O Sf^]aWQWย \ g RWa^]aWQWย \ RS ZO W\T]`[OQWย \ ^S`[WbS ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa [ta ORSQcOROa /ZUc\]a W\bS\b]a ^]` W\b`]RcQW` ÔcbOa dOZ]ÒbWdOa RSZ `WSaU] ^]` Ô`bS RS OZUc\]a OQb]`Sa ^cSRS\ S\bÒ` S\ Q]\bÒRWQQWย \ Q]\ ]bÒa TcS\bSa RS W\T]`[OQWย \ Q]\ Q]\aSQcS\QWOa \STOabOa ÔÒ ZO ^Sà]\O X]dS\ _cS aS dS ]PZWUORO O RSQWRW` S\ SaS Q]\bSfb] RS Rc^ZWQWROR g Q]\bÒRWQQWย \ W\T]`[ObWdO :Oa Q]\bÒRWQQW]\Sa a]\ [cQV] [ta ^S`XcRWQWOZSa S\ Xย dS\Sa gO _cS ÔÒ SabS U`c^] Sa TtQWZ c\ S``]` RS QtZQcZ] gO _cS S\ SZ Q]`b] ^ZOh] \] [cQVOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa aS VOQS\ [O\WTWSabOa C\O RSQWaWย \ ^S`XcRWQWOZ ^]` SXS[^Z] S\ [ObS`WO RS aOZcR \] aS [O\WTWSabO VOabO _cS aS ^`]RcQS c\ ^`]QSa] RS RSbS`W]`] g _cS \] aS ^S`QWPS S\ SZ ^`W[S` [][S\b] >]` Z] bO\b] SZ QtZQcZ] RS Q]abSa PS\STWQW]a RS c\O RSQWaWย \ S\ OcaS\QWO RS Sf^S`WS\QWO dWbOZ ^`]^WO OZ `Sa^SQb] aย Z] ^cSRS S\Q][S\ROàS O ZO Q]\TWO\hO _cS aS SabOPZShQO Q]\ ZOa TcS\bSa RS W\T]`[OQWย \ a]P`S Z]a `SacZbOR]a S\ SZ ZOÙ] ^ZOh] RS RWQVOa RSQWaW]\Sa g Q]\RcQbOa AW Z] _cS Sa S\bS\RWR] ^]` Ô`bS RSZ X]dS\ Sa _cS ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa ZS dWS\S\ ROROa g bWS\S ^]Q] [OÙS\ ÔÒ ]^bO` aSUcÒ[S\bS ^cSRS bS\RS` O c\O a]ZcQWย \ S``ย \SO ÔÒ a [Wa[] g ÔÒ ac S\b]`\] aW\ Oac[W` ORS[ta ZO `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR a]P`S ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RS SZZ] ^]` Q]\aWRSÒàS `S^`]RcQb]` aW\ [ta RS c\ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] ] aWbcOQWย \ US\SÒZ :O aS\aOQWย \ RS \] ^]RS` QO[PWO` \ORO RS c\ S\b]`\] a]QWOZ SQ]\ย [WQ] ] QcZbcÒZ W[^cSab] ZZSdO O ZO OQS^bOQWย \ g aSUcWRWa[] RS ÔcbOa aW\ a]^SaO` ÒQW]\OZ[S\bS ZO Q]\dS\WS\QWO ] \] RS ZOa [Wa[Oa :O TOZbO RS Sf^S`WS\QWO RSZ X]dS\ VOQS\ _cS Q]\QWPO SZ [c\R] Q]\ Z]a ย \WQ]a W\ab`c[S\b]a RS Q]\]QW[WS\b] O ac OZQO\QS _cS S\ [cQVOa ]QOaW]\Sa dWS\S\ ROR]a RS [O\SÒ RWab]àW]\ORO ^]` OUS\bSa a]QWOZWhOR]`Sa _cS a]\ [S`]a SaQOÔÒbSa Q][] Z]a [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQWย \ g bSQ\]Z]U Oa Q][] 7\bS`\Sb aW\ VOPS` RSaO``]ZZOR] ^`SdWO[S\bS VOPWZWRORSa RS RWaQ`W[W\OQWย \ RS ZO W\T]`[OQWย \ `SQWPWRO AW SZ [c\R] Sa RS c\O RSbS`[W\ORO [O\SÒ aca Xย dS\Sa a]\ g aS Sa^SÒ _cS aSO\ RS [O\SÒ Q]\Q`SbO QORO ^Sà]\O X]dS\ S\Q]\bÒ`t [Og]`Sa W\QS\bWd]a O aSUcW` RWQVOa ÔcbOa SabOPZSQWROa g Q]\a]ZWROROa aSUย \ ac `SZObWdO[S\bS Q]`bO PW]UÒT O S\ ZcUO` RS ]^bO` ^]` ^S\aO` V]`Wh]\bSa OZbS`\ObWd]a ÔÒ a ] ÔÒ ac S\b]`\] A][]a Q]\aQWS\bSa QcO\R] [WÒ[]a Q]\ ObS\QWย \ ZO `SOZWROR QcO\R] OPO\R]\O[]a ZO bS\RS\QWO O SabOPZSQS` bW^]Z]U Oa `SRcQWROa g Qย []ROa ÔÒ ]^SÒ` a]QWOZ[S\bS QcO\R] \]a _cWbO[]a SZ S[Ôย OR] dWa]` RS ZO a]QWSROR _cS a]\ SabS`S]bW^]a g ^`SXcWQW]a ^`]^W]a ] Q]ZSQbWd]a ^cRWS\R] S\Q]\bÒ`\]a Q]\ [cXS`Sa g V][P`Sa Xย dS\Sa RS [O\SÒa RWTS`S\bSa _cS Oย \ Q][Ô`bWS\R] SZS[S\b]a \] `SOQQW]\O\ RS WUcOZ [O\SÒ O\bS ZOa

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

[Wa[Oa W\T]`[OQW]\Sa g Sab [cZ]a Z] _cS RSPS RS aS` aWS[^`S bS\WR] S\ QcS\bO O ZO V]`O RS ^ZO\bSO` OZbS`\ObWdOa

:O USabW \ RS ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa C\O ^`]^cSabO RS Tcbc`] 3Z RSaO``]ZZ] SQ]\ [WQ] g a]QWOZ _cS aS VO OZQO\hOR] S\ OZUc\Oa Ô`bSa RSZ ^ZO\SbO Q]\bÒabO \]bOPZS[S\bS S\ ]^]`bc\WRORSa Q]\ ZOa _cS RWaT`cbO`]\ S\ ]b`]a [][S\b]a US\SÒQW]\Sa ^`SQSRS\bSa g S\ ZOa _cS ^]` RSaUÒQWO O \ aS S\QcS\bÒ\ ]bÒa a]QWSRORSa S\ ZOa _cS VOPWbO ZO [Og]` O RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ [c\RWOZ 3ab] OP`S c\ OPO\WQ] RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa POaOROa S\ ZO RWa^]\WPWZWROR RS `SQcà]a RS b]R] bW^] _cS \]a ^S`[WbO _cS ZO Sd]ZcQW \ g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] aSO\ bO[PW{\ Q dWQ]a g QcZbcÒZSa g \] bO\ a]Z] [ObS`WOZ 2S [][S\b] Z]a W\bS`SaSa VO\ VSQV] ^`]U`SaO` c\O ^`S]QcÔQW \ ^]` SZ RSaO``]ZZ] [ObS`WOZ ^]` SZ OQQSa] O PWS\Sa RS Q]\ac[] Q]\T]`[S O ZOa ÔcbOa ^cPZWQWbO`WOa SabOPZSQWROa ^]` Z]a RWTS`S\bSa OQb]`Sa SQ]\ [WQ]a AS VO ROR] c\ QO[PW] ÒRWQOZ S\ ÔcbOa g Q]\RcQbOa S\ ^]Q]a O ]a RS\b`] RS c\O Q]\bW\cO bÒ\aT]`[OQW \ 2S VSQV] Z]a ^`]^W]a X dS\Sa RS c\O SROR RWQS\ \] S\bS\RS` ] Q][Ô`bW` Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a ^`]^W]a RS Z]a X dS\Sa RS [S\]` SROR Z] _cS [cSabÒ Z] dS`bWUW\]a] RS Z]a QO[PW]a :O XcdS\bcR Sa Q]\aWRSÒRO ZO ^`]bOU]\WabO RSZ W\RWdWRcOZWa[] RSZ VSR]\Wa[] g SZ Q]\ac[Wa[] aWS\R] aW\ [ta `SQS^b]`Sa g Ô`bS dcZ\SÒPZS RS c\ ^`]QSa] Sd]ZcbWd] RS ZO a]QWSROR S\ ac Q]\Xc\b] AW PWS\ ZO UZ]POZWhOQW \ VO WR] OZSXO\R] Z]a QS\b`]a RS b][O RS RSQWaW \ RS ZO [Og]` O RS Z]a QWcRORO\]a aWS[^`S ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ORcZbOa S\ POaS O ac Sf^S`WS\QWO bWS\S\ [Og]`Sa [SQO\Wa[]a ÔÒ VcW` RS ÔcbOa W[^cSabOa aW\ ac Q]\aS\bW[WS\b] aWS\R] X dS\Sa Z]a [ta dcZ\SÒPZSa S\ Sab]a Q]\bSfb]a / [SRWRO _cS Oc[S\bO\ Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS ^`]bSQQW \ S\ ZO dWRO RS c\O ^Sà]\O RWa[W\cgS\ Z]a `WSaU]a ] ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RS aca Q]\aSQcS\QWOa aWS\R] `SZSdO\bS ZO RWa^]aWQW \ RS ÔR`Sa ObS\b]a O^SU] O ZO SaQcSZO g R]QS\bSa QcOZWTWQOR]a ÔÒ S\bS\RS` ZOa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa RS ac OZc[\OR] ZO Q]\T]`[OQW \ RS c\O WRS\bWROR aSfcOZ PWS\ RSTW\WRO g `SRSa RS O[WabORSa PWS\ Sab`cQbcÒROa AW\ S[POÙ] Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] Oc[S\bO\ S\ aWbcOQW]\Sa RS SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ ] Q]\ S\b]`\]a TO[WZWO`Sa OPcaWd]a ac^]\WS\R] c\ RSaOT ] ORWQW]\OZ Q]\ c\O [Og]` W[^ZWQOQW \ ÔÒ W\dS`bW` S\ TOQb]`Sa RS ^`]bSQQW \ g ^`SdS\W` TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] 3\ [cQVOa ]QOaW]\Sa \] aS bÒbO RS `SOZWhO` c\ Oc[S\b] RS Z]a `SQcà]a aW\] RS c\O `S]`RS\OQW \ RS Z]a SfWabS\bSa Q]\ c\O [SX]` T]QOZWhOQW \ c\O [SX]` ORSQcOQW \ O ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa Ô`bWQcZO`Sa RS QORO Q]\bSfb] ] U`c^] RS X dS\Sa AS `S_cWS`S c\O [SX]` RSTW\WQW \ RS ]PXSbWd]a S\ ZOa OQbcOQW]\Sa g dS` _c{ `SZOQW]\Sa bWS\S\ Q]\ ]bÒa t`SOa RS W\bS`dS\QW \ RS bOZ [O\SÒ _cS aS ^cSRO\ OP]`RO` dO`W]a bW^]a RS Q]\RcQbO RS `WSaU] O ZO dSh ^]`_cS [cg ^]aWPZS[S\bS Q][Ô`bO\ ]`WUS\ `SRcQWS\R] Oa OQbcOQW]\Sa RS ^]Q] {fWb] Q]\ W[ÔQb]a ZSdSa ] \cZ]a S\ ac OQbcOQW \ 1cSabO [cQV] bÒPOX] ÔÒ QcOZ_cWS` USab]` b][O` ZO RSQWaW \ RS []RWTWQO` `S]`WS\bO` ] ac^`W[W` c\ ^`]UÒ[O ^]`_cS ^SaS O _cS \] Sab{ Q]\aWUcWS\R] c\ W[ÔQb] \]bOPZS ^cSRS _cS VOgO US\SÒR] OZU \ W[ÔQb] ^]aWbWd] Q][^ZS[S\bO`W] ] VOgO US\SÒR] c\]a W\bS`SaSa O TOd]` RS ac [O\bS\W[WS\b] AW\ S[POÙ] Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa ÔÒ X dS\Sa Q][]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

dS`S[]a [ta ORSZO\bS RSPS\ bS\S` c\O d]QOQWย \ RS ^S`[SOPWZWROR OZ QO[PW] gO _cS Oc\_cS aSO ZO XcdS\bcR ac RSabW\ObO`WO ^cSRS _cS Z]a Xย dS\Sa QO[PWS\ [cQV] S\ ^]Q] bWS[^]) Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa RS OV]Ò S\ ^]Q] aS Ô`SQS\ O Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa RS VOQS RWSh Oย ]a g Z]a Xย dS\Sa RS OV]Ò ^]Q] bWS\S\ _cS dS` WUcOZ[S\bS Q]\ Z]a RS S\b]\QSa :O [Wa[O ÔZOPÒ X]dS\ RSTW\S `SOZWRORSa OPa]ZcbO[S\bS RWTS`S\bSa 1]\ SabS ^c\b] RS Ô`bWRO g Q][] dW[]a O\bSa \] ^]RS[]a QS\bÒ`\]a a]ZO g SfQZcaWdO[S\bS S\ _cS ZO dWRO Sa Q][^ZSXO g O``WSaUORO gO _cS Sab] Sa c\O Ô`bS Q]\acPabO\QWOZ OZ ^`]QSa] dWbOZ ^]` Z] _cS T`S\bS O ZO ^`]bSQQWย \ POaORO S\ SZ OZSXO[WS\b] RSZ `WSaU] RSPS\ RS O^]abOàS ^]` SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS VOPWZWRORSa RS Q]\]QW[WS\b] g USabWย \ RS SabS S\ c\ Q]\bSfb] _cS OP`S [ta ]^]`bc\WRORSa _cS \W\Uย \ ]b`] O\bS`W]` O ZO ^]PZOQWย \ g Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS O ZO XcdS\bcR 3a ^`]^W] RSZ aS` Vc[O\] PcaQO` g _cS`S` QS`bShOa _cS ZS aOZdOUcO`RS\ RS ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S RS ZO O\aWSROR RS \] aOPS` QctZ ^cSRS aS` SZ aWUcWS\bS Ôa] 3a Q][^ZWQOR] VOQS` b]R] c\ ^`]QSa] RS T]`[cZOQWย \ ÒQW]\OZ RS OZbS`\ObWdOa ÔÒ SZSUW` ZO ]^QWย \ [ta ORSQcORO ^S`] Q][] b]R] Sa QcSabWย \ RS O^`S\RWhOXS RS Sf^S`WS\QWO g RS S\b`S\O[WS\b] >OÒ _cWS\ RWa^]\S RS [S\]` Sf^S`WS\QWO aWS[^`S aS ^cSRS ]T`SQS` ZO RS ]b`]a ÔÒ VOQS`ZO ^`]^WO O bÒd{a RS c\O aSQcS\QWO RS Q][^ZWQWROR g Q]\TWO\hO S\ ^`]QSa]a RS O^`S\RWhOXS AS RWQS _cS SZ ยตV][P`S Sa SZ ย \WQ] O\W[OZ _cS b`]^WShO R]a dSQSa a]P`S ZO [Wa[O ^WSRÒยถ ^S`] Sa Q]\dS\WS\bS S\bS\RS` ZO O\RORcÒ ^`]^WO Q][] c\ QO[W\] ^SR`SU]a] g SdWbO` ZOa ^WSRÒa aW\ \SQSaWROR RS W` [WÒ\R] Q]\abO\bS[S\bS VOQWO OPOX] aW\] [WÒ\R] OZ V]`Wh]\bS ^]`_cS SZ [SRW] g ZOÙ] ^ZOh] a]\ Tc\RO[S\bOZSa S\ c\ ^`]gSQb] dWbOZ OZU] _cS a]ZO[S\bS aS ^cSRS VOQS` QcO\R] VOg c\ OQ][Ôย O[WS\b] Q]]^SÒbWd] g \] RW`SQbWd] a]P`S Qย [] RWaQc``W` SaS QO[W\] ^`]^W] RS QORO c\] :O SaÔย ]ZO Sa c\O a]QWSROR _cS VO QO[PWOR] `SZObWdO[S\bS bO`RS Q][ÔÒRO Q]\ ]bÒa RS \cSab`] S\b]`\] ^]` Z] _cS VOg OZUc\]a RSaO``]ZZ]a a]QWOZSa _cS aS VO\ ROR] RS c\O [O\SÒ btQbWQO [ta _cS SabÒb{UWQO Q]^WO\R] []RSZ]a dtZWR]a S\ ]b`]a ZcUO`Sa <cSab`] SabOR] RSZ PWS\SabO` aS bcd] _cS W[^ZO\bO` S\ c\ ^S`W]R] RS bWS[^] `SZObWdO[S\bS Q]`b] g S\ Ô`bS aW\ OPO\R]\O` ZOa ÔcbOa ÔbS`\OZWabOa RSZ []RSZ] O\bS`W]` <cSabÒ SRcQOQWย \ Oย \ [cg O\QZORO S\ b{Q\WQOa O ZO bÒRWQW]\OZ aS dO ORO^bO\R] Q]\ \]bOPZSa RWTWQcZbORSa O ZO Sd]ZcQWย \ RS Z]a bWS[^]a O ZOa \cSdOa \SQSaWRORSa QO[PWO\R] SZ aWabS[O S\ aca SaÔQW]a [OQ`] Q]\ Q]\bW\cOa []RWTWQOQW]\Sa ZSUWaZObWdOa RSZ aWabS[O Q]\TWO\R] S\ _cS QO[PWO\R] c\O ZSg aS QO[PWO ZO `SOZWROR <]a S\Q]\bÒ[]a Q]\ c\ aWabS[O RS[]Q`tbWQ] g RS ZWPS`bORSa Q]\ab`cWR] S\ ZO RSPWZWROR RS Z]a O^`S\RWhOXSa QWcRORO\]a _cS ZS a]\ ^`]^W]a O c\ aWabS[O RS SabOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa QOaW OZ [Wa[] [][S\b] VWabย `WQ] S\ SZ _cS ZO b][O RS RSQWaW]\Sa aS OZSXO RS \]a]b`]a g \]a ]b]ÙO SZ d{`bWU] RS ZO W[^]aWPWZWROR RS aS` ^`]bOU]\WabOa RS \cSabÒa ^`]^WOa dWROa 2SaUÒQWORO[S\bS ZO `SOZWROR Sa [cQV] [ta Q][^ZSXO _cS c\O T]`[cZOQWย \ ZSUWaZObWdO Z] _cS RSXO S\ PcS\O [SRWRO OZUc\Oa `SROQQW]\Sa RS \cSab`] ]`RS\O[WS\b] S\ [S`]a OQb]a RSaWRSÒbWd]a ^S`] _cS RWT QWZ[S\bS `Sa^]\RS\ O \SQSaWRORSa RS ZO QWcRORO\ O S\ US\SÒZ g O Z]a Xย dS\Sa S\ Ô`bWQcZO` _cS RS^]aWbO\ c\Oa Sf^SQbObWdOa S\ SZ aWabS[O ^]bS\QWOZ[S\bS T`cabÒPZSa

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

1`S] _cS QcO\R] Z]a Q]\abWbcgS\bSa `SQ]UWS`]\ ZO T]`[cZOQW \ RSZ O`b QcZ] "& RS ZO 1O`bO ;OU\O SabOPO\ S\Q][S\RO\R] O ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa _cS Z]a X dS\Sa g ZOa X dS\Sa aS W\Q]`^]ÒÒ\ O Z]a ^`]QSa]a ^SROU UWQ]a RS ZO QWcRORO\ O RSaO``]ZZO\R] VOPWZWRORSa ÔÒ ZO bÒ\aT]`[OQW \ RS[]Q`tbWQO RS ZO a]QWSROR _cS VS`SROPO\ S\bÒ\R] O ZO \SU]QWOQW \ g OZ Q]\aS\a] ÔÒ ZO bÒ\aT]`[OQW \ a]QWOZ Q]\T]`[S O aca \SQSaWRORSa /a RSPS` O S\bS\RSàS SaO T]`[cZOQW \ RS ZO Ô`bWQWÔQW \ RS ZO XcdS\bcR S\ ZO dWRO ^]Z bWQO a]QWOZ SQ]\ [WQO g QcZbcÒZ ÔÒ _cS \] TcSÒ\ [S`]a `SQS^b]`Sa RS W\WQWObWdOa ^ PZWQOa 3abO[]a OQ]abc[PÒR]a O S\c\QWO` ZO RS[]QÒQWO S\ `SZOQW \ Q]\ SZ SabOR] RS RS`SQV] a]ZO[S\bS S\ Z] _cS Q]\QWS`\S O ZO Sf^SQbObWdO RS `Sa^cSabO RS ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa S\ SZ OaSUcÒ[WS\b] RS Z]a RS`SQV]a ÔÒ ZO QWcRORO\ O 3abO T]`[cZOQW \ OP`S [Og]`Sa V]`Wh]\bSa S\ ZO T]`[cZOQW \ RS S\ c\ SabOR] a]QWOZ g RS[]Q`tbWQ] RS RS`SQV] ^]`_cS W\Q]`^]Ò ZO Sf^`SaW \ RS RS`SQV]a a]QWOZSa SQ]\ [WQ]a g QcZbcÒZSa Q]\ ZO _cS [cQV]a ^cSRS\ _cSRO` bÒ\_cWZ]a g Sf^SQbO\bSa RS ZO ^`]bSQQW \ ÔbS`\OZWabO RS ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa 1][] RWXS [ta W\T]`[OQW \ [S\]a `WSaU]a Sa c\O PcS\O Sf^`SaW \ RS Q [] \] Oac[W` `WSaU]a W\\SQSaO`W]a g c\] RS SZZ]a Sa RSZSUO` SfQSaWdO[S\bS ZO ^`]bSQQW \ RS c\] [Wa[] S\ ]b`]a Oc\_cS aSO\ W\abWbcQW]\Sa a]ZdS\bSa g R]bOROa RS Q]\TWO\hO 6OP` O _cS `SQ]`RO` [ta O [S\cR] g Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS O ZO XcdS\bcR _cS ZO ^`]^WO 1]\abWbcQW \ \] ]T`SQS acTWQWS\bSa UOÒ\b Oa RS [cQV]a RS`SQV]a W[^`SaQW\RWPZSa ÔÒ S[^`S\RS` c\ ^`]gSQb] SfWb]a] RS dWRO aW\] _cS aS RSPS\ W` Q]\ab`cgS\R] g [ObS`WOZWhO\R] 3a Q]\dS\WS\bS `SQ]`RO` _cS SZ aWabS[O RS UOÒ\b Oa ÔÒ SZ Qc[^ZW[WS\b] RS Z]a RS`SQV]a `SQ]UWR] ^]` SZ O`b QcZ] #! S\QWS`Ò QZOÒa RWTS`S\QWOa bS[tbWQOa gO _cS [cQV]a RS Z]a RS`SQV]a _cS aS T]`[cZO\ Q][] bOZSa S[^ZS] dWdWS\RO aOZcR SbQ a]\ [S`]a ^`W\QW^W]a `SQb]`Sa RS ZO dWRO ^]Z bWQO g a]QWOZ _cS a Z] aS VOQS\ STSQbWd]a QcO\R] VOg ZSUWaZOQW]\Sa RS RSaO``]ZZ] g a]P`S b]R] ^]Z bWQOa ^ PZWQOa _cS [ObS`WOZWhO\ ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa _cS RWQV]a RS`SQV]a \]a ]TS`bO\ Q][] QWcRORO\]a

C\ \cSd] SaQS\O`W]( ^]Z bWQOa g ^`]UÒ[Oa RS USabW \ RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa >]` SZZ] Sa W[^`SaQW\RWPZS _cS ZO USabW \ RS ]^]`bc\WRORSa bS\UO ÔÒ Z]a X dS\Sa SZ ^WZO` RS ZO W[^ZWQOQW \ gO _cS a]\ Ô`bS bO\ W\bS`SaORO Q][] _cS RS^S\RWS\R] RS Q [] aS [O\WTWSabS\ [cQVOa ^]Z bWQOa g [cQV]a ^`]UÒ[Oa ^]R`t\ RSaO``]ZZO` Q]\ [Og]` ] [S\]` {fWb] ac ^`]^W] ^`]gSQb] dWbOZ :Oa ^Sà]\Oa RO\ dWUS\QWO O Z]a dOZ]`Sa g \] a]\ Sab]a Z]a _cS aS Sf^ZWQO\ ^]` a [Wa[]a ^]` Z] _cS Sabt\ R]bOR]a bO[PW{\ RS Z]a [SQO\Wa[]a RS Sf^`SaW \ RSZ Q]\TZWQb] _cS ac^]\UO ac W\abOcÒQW \ \SU]QWO\R] []RSZ]a OZbS`\ObWd]a aW\ \SUO` Z]a Q]\TZWQb]a SfWabS\bSa ÔÒ SZZ] 3\ c\ aWabS[O RS[]Q`tbWQ] W\QZca] Z]a [S\]`Sa RS SROR U]hO\ RSZ `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] RS aS` Ô`b QW^Sa OQb]`Sa ^`W\QWÔZSa S\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS Z]a Q]\aS\a]a ^]Z bWQ]a S\ b]`\] O ZOa ^`W]`WRORSa _cS aS bWS\S\ Q][] a]QWSROR gO _cS T]`[O\ Ô`bS RS SZZO ORS[ta RS bS\S` [cQV] _cS RSQW` QcO\R] a]\ SZZ]a Z]a RSabW\ObO`W]a RS ZOa OQbcOQW]\Sa ^ PZWQOa

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

3Z ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] RS c\O ^`]bSQQWย \ ÔbS`\OZWabO _cS W\TO\bWZWQS O Z]a Xย dS\Sa S\ c\ [][S\b] Tc\RO[S\bOZ RS aca RSaO``]ZZ] WRS\bWbO`W] g S\ ZO Q]\T]`[OQWย \ RS aca VOPWZWRORSa a]QWOZSa PtaWQOa \] SdWbO`t ZOa ^S]`Sa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RS ZO Oac\QWย \ RS `WSaU]a Aย Z] RSaRS SZ `SQ]\]QW[WS\b] RSZ ^`]bOU]\Wa[] RSZ X]dS\ S\ ZO RSbS`[W\OQWย \ RS aca ]^QW]\Sa dWbOZSa `SZSdO\bSa S\ ZOa _cS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ORcZbOa aย Z] RSPS\ aS` OQ][Ôย O\bSa g Q]\aSXS`]a \] RSQWa]`Sa ^cSRS `SOZ[S\bS R]bOàS RS ZO Ocb]SabW[O g `Sa^]\aOPWZWROR \SQSaO`WOa ÔÒ T]`[cZO` QtZQcZ]a ÒQW]\OZSa O ZO V]Ò RS Oac[W` g OT`]\bO` Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa 3abS ^`]QSa] RS Q]\ab`cQQWย \ POaOR] S\ SZ O^`S\RWhOXS S\ ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO ^`]^WO S\ ZO T]`[cZOQWย \ RS S``]`Sa Oa Q][] S\ ZO W\bS`W]`WhOQWย \ ^Sà]\OZ RS Z]a O^`S\RWhOXSa Q]ZSQbWd]a _cS aSO\ ย bWZSa Q]\T]`[S O aca \SQSaWRORSa dWbOZSa ^cSRS RSbS`[W\O` ZO T]`[O RS S\bS\RS` S\ US\SÒZ b]ROa ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RS XcdS\bcR 3\ SabS QO[^] RS ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RSabW\OROa O Xย dS\Sa aS VO WR] Sf^S`W[S\bO\R] Sd]ZcQW]\O\R] g Q]\]QWS\R] QORO dSh [ta Oc\_cS bO[PW{\ S\ OZUc\Oa ]QOaW]\Sa VS[]a aWR] d QbW[Oa RS ZOa T]`[cZOQW]\Sa RS`WdOROa RS \cSab`]a ^`]^W]a ^`SXcWQW]a RS \cSab`]a ^`]^W]a W\bS`SaSa Q][] ^ZO\WTWQOR]`Sa SXSQcb]`Sa ] SdOZcOR]`Sa RS Z]a ^ZO\Sa g ^`]UÒ[Oa ] RS \cSab`]a ^`]^W]a RWaQcà]a /Z TW\OZ Q]\ QWS`bO T`SQcS\QWO Z]a Xย dS\Sa _cSRO\ Q][] [S`]a RSabW\ObO`W]a RS OQbcOQW]\Sa _cS \] VO\ aWR] RS[O\ROROa g _cS S\ [cQVOa ]QOaW]\Sa \] ZSa VOQS\ \ORO [ta _cS `SQSZO` g RWabO\QWOàS RS ZOa OR[W\WabÒQW]\Sa ^ย PZWQOa ] RS ZOa ]ÙO\WhOQW]\Sa \] UcPS`\O[S\bOZSa _cS aย Z] _cS` O\ OgcRO` :Oa ^]Z bWQOa g ^`]UÒ[Oa RSabW\OR]a O Xย dS\Sa RSPS\ `SS\Q]\bÒ` ac Sf^ZWQOQWย \ ^SROUย UWQO S\ ac aS\bWR] [ta O[^ZW] 1][] c\ ^`]QSa] RS OQ][Ôย O[WS\b] RS ZO ^Sà]\O X]dS\ S\ ac b`t\aWb] VOQWO ZO QWcRORO\ O ^ZS\O g `Sa^]\aOPZS Z] _cS aWU\WTWQO aS` ORcZb] R]bt\R]ZO RS VOPWZWRORSa RS QOÔQWRORSa g RSab`ShOa ^`]^WOa ÔÒ RSaS\d]ZdSàS S\ ZO \cSdO `SOZWROR dWbOZ _cS Sa^SÒ 3abS ^`]QSa] \] RSPS SabOPZSQSàS RS ZO \]QVS O ZO [Oย O\O Q][] c\ Ôa] VOQWO c\ ^`SQW^WQW] RS W\QS`bWRc[P`S aW\] Q][] c\ Q]\bW\c] S\ SZ bWS[^] _cS R{ [OÙS\ O ZO Sf^S`W[S\bOQWย \ ^`]^WO 3\ OZUc\Oa ]QOaW]\Sa aS S\QcS\bÒ SabO ^`]PZS[tbWQO S\ ZO POaS RS ZO ^`]^WO T]`[cZOQWย \ g O`bWQcZOQWย \ RS ZOa ^]Z bWQOa AW OZ ^`W\QW^W] RSQ O _cS [S VOP O S\Q]\bÒR] [cQV]a OQS`QO[WS\b]a bS`[W\]Zย UWQ]a O ZO XcdS\bcR g O ZO ^Sà]\O X]dS\ bO[PW{\ S\ ^]Z bWQOa ^ย PZWQOa Sa TtQWZ S\Q]\bÒàS W\QZca] RSPObS a]P`S _cW{\Sa a]\ SaOa ^Sà]\Oa Xย dS\Sa a]P`S ZOa _cS W\QWRW` g Q]\ ZOa _cS bÒPOXO` 3Z SabOPZSQW[WS\b] RS Q]\bW\cWRORSa bS[^]ÒZSa g SZ RSaRWPcXO[WS\b] RS ZOa T`]\bSÒa S\b`S QOcaOa g STSQb]a Oa Q][] ZO Q]\TcaWย \ S\b`S ^`]PZS[Oa Sab`cQbcÒZSa ^`]^W]a RSZ aWabS[O g ZO ^`]PZS[tbWQO RS aca W\RWdWRc]a VO `S]`WS\bOR] g Q]\RWQW]\OR] [cQV]a RWaQcà]a g bÒa SZZ]a ZOa OQbcOQW]\Sa A]P`S _cW{\Sa a]\ Z]a RSabW\ObO`W]a RS ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RS XcdS\bcR g ^]` Z] bO\b] _cW{\Sa a]\ Z]a Xย dS\Sa ^cSRS RSQWàS _cS a]\ O_cSZZ]a a]P`S Z]a _cS ZO Q]ZSQbWdWROR _cWS`S `SOZWhO` c\ SaTcS`h] Q][^ZS[S\bO`W] RS O^]g] S\ POaS O ac dcZ\SÒPWZWROR Sbt`SO :O W\TO\QWO Sabt [ta QZOÒ ^]aWPZS[S\bS bO[PW{\ SZ W\WQW] RS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO ^S`] aS SabOPZSQS\ [ย ZbW^ZSa RWTWQcZbORSa O ZO V]Ò RS RSbS`[W\O` ZO TW\OZWhOQWย \ RS ZO SbOÔ XcdS\WZ g ^]` Z] bO\b] RS SabO ^`]bSQQWย \ ORWQW]\OZ RS ZO a]QWSROR O bÒd{a RS ^`]UÒ[Oa Sa^SQ TWQ]a

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 ยง aS^bWS[P`S & q \ ย &

/ZUc\]a ^`]PZS[Oa gO Sab`cQbcÒZSa RS \cSab`] aWabS[O SQ]\ [WQ] [ta _cS Q]gc\bcÒZSa Q][] Sa ZO RWTWQcZbOR ÔÒ OQQSRS` O c\ bÒPOX] S\ Q]\RWQW]\Sa ^bW[Oa RS SabOPWZWROR SdWbO\R] ZO `]bOQW \ Q]\bÒQbcOZ SZ Q]\bW\c] QO[PW] RS S[^ZS] Q]\ aca `Sa^SQbWd]a `WSaU]a RS Z]a _cS RSabOQO\ Z]a `WSaU]a a]P`S OQQWRS\bSa ZOP]ÒZSa _cS S\ [cQV]a aSQb]`Sa ^`]RcQbWd]a aS Oac[S\ ÔÒ [O\bS\S` SZ ^cSab] RS bÒPOX] Oa Q][] ZO RWTWQcZbOR RS OQQSa] O ZO dWdWS\RO ^]` ZOa `WUWRSQSa RS ]TS`bO g RS[O\RO _cS S\ SZ [Wa[] SfWabS\ VO\ RSadWOR] OZUc\Oa ^`W]`WRORSa S\ ZO T]`[cZOQW \ RS ^]Z bWQOa ÔÒ X dS\Sa 3a QWS`b] _cS ZO ^]PZOQW \ X]dS\ aS S\QcS\bÒ RS c\O [O\SÒ [ta \]bOPZS W\[SàO S\ Sab]a ^`]PZS[Oa Sab`cQbcÒZSa RSa[]bWdt\R]ZO `Sa^SQb] OZ Tcbc`] g Q]\RWQW]\O\R] [ ZbW^ZSa RS aca `Sa^cSabOa S\ \SUObWd] :O TOZbO RS Sf^S`WS\QWO g RS `SRSa a]QWOZSa ^`]^WOa RWTWQcZbO\ SZ OQQSa] OZ S[^ZS] S\ PcS\Oa Q]\RWQW]\Sa Oa Q][] ZO TOZbO RS a]ZdS\QWO POaORO S\ SZ OV]``] g ZO QOÔQWROR TWOPZS RS S\RScRO[WS\b] ^]` ac aWbcOQW \ ZOP]ÒZ Q]\RWQW]\O\ SZ OQQSa] O ZO dWdWS\RO RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa X dS\Sa S\ [Og]` [SRWRO _cS ÔÒ SZ `Sab] RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ Z] _cS ZSa OaS[SXO S\ RWTWQcZbORSa O OZUc\]a U`c^]a S\ `WSaU] RS SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ ^]` RWTS`S\QWOa {b\WQOa Q]Z]` RS ^WSZ ] S[WUÒ\bSa AW\ S[POÙ] Sab]a a]\ ^`]PZS[Oa RSZ aWabS[O g _cS SZ aWabS[O RSPS RS `Sa]ZdS` S\ ac Q]\Xc\b] ÔÒ RO` c\O [SX]` `Sa^cSabO O b]RO ac QWcRORO\ O aW\ RWaQ`W[W\OQW \ bO[^]Q] S\ ^]aWbWd] gO _cS aW\ SZ STSQbWd] SXS`QWQW] RS Z]a RS`SQV]a SQ]\ [WQ]a a]QWOZSa g QcZbcÒZSa RWT QWZ[S\bS ^cSRS RSaO``]ZZOàS c\O WUcOZROR RS OQQSa] O Z]a RS`SQV]a ^]Z bWQ]a _cS aS S\QcS\bÒ\ S\ ZO POaS RS c\ aWabS[O RS[]Q`tbWQ] >]` Ô`bS RS ZOa OR[W\WabÒQW]\Sa ^ PZWQOa aS VO ROR] Q][] `Sa^cSabO O\bS ZOa RWTWQcZbORSa ] ZO TOZbO RS d]Zc\bOR ÔÒ W\b`]RcQW` QO[PW]a \]bOPZSa S\ SZ aWabS[O SQ]\ [WQ] _cS RWTWQcZbO SZ OQQSa] O QWS`b]a RS`SQV]a ^]` Ô`bS RS aca QWcRORO\]a c\O ^` ``]UO RS SROR O aca QWcRORO\]a [ta X dS\Sa ?cS ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RS XcdS\bcR bÒbS\ RS Z]a QWcRORO\]a [ta X dS\Sa \] \SQSaO`WO[S\bS RSPS ZZSdO`\]a O S\bS\RS` O b]R]a SZZ]a Q][] X dS\Sa ^S`] ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa Q]\bSfbcOZSa VO\ ZZSdOR] O OQS^bO` _cS ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RS XcdS\bcR aS VOgO\ T]`[cZOR] Q][] ^]Z bWQOa RS S[O\QWÔQW \ g Q][] X dS\Sa b]R]a O_cSZZ]a \] S[O\QWÔR]a [ObS`WOZ[S\bS >SaS O _cS ZOa QWTÒa [OQ`] VOPZOPO\ RS RSaO``]ZZ] aS Sd]ZcQW]\OPO \SUObWdO[S\bS S\ aWbcOQW]\Sa [WQ`] _cS OTSQbOPO\ O c\O Ô`bS W[^]`bO\bS RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ Q]\ c\O aWbcOQW \ RWT QWZ 3ab] VO VSQV] _cS Q]\ SZ RWaQc``W` RSZ bWS[^] g RS ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa aS VOgO WR] OQS^bO\R] SZ W\Q`S[S\b] RS ZO SROR RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa RSabW\ObO`WOa RS ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RS XcdS\bcR RS Z]a $ O Z]a ! O ]a ÔÒ ^]abS`W]`[S\bS c\O dSh OQS^bOR] _cS S\ ^]Z bWQOa RS S[O\QWÔQW \ X]dS\ aS RWaQ`W[W\S S\ ^]aWbWd] VOabO Z]a !# O ]a aS dS ^]` _c{ \] VOQS` SfbS\aWdO SabO SROR O b]ROa g QORO c\O RS ZOa OQbcOQW]\Sa S\ [ObS`WO RS XcdS\bcR 2SaUÒQWORO[S\bS Z] \WQ] _cS VO aWU\WTWQOR] SabO cPWQOQW \ RSZ RSPObS a]P`S SRORSa VO aWR] ÔÒ _cS ZOa OR[W\WabÒQW]\Sa ^cRWSÒ\ Ocb]``SaWU\OàS S\ ac W\QOÔQWROR RS a]ZdS\bO` QWS`bOa aWbcOQW]\Sa g ROàS c\O ^` ``]UO RS QOaW RWSh O ]a ÔÒ a]ZcQW]\tàSZOa O aca [ta X dS\Sa 3abO ^` ``]UO VO Q]\bOR] bO[PW{\ Q]\ ZO S\bcaWOabO OQ]UWRO RS Z]a ^`]^W]a []dW[WS\b]a Oa]QWObWd]a XcdS\WZSa QcO\R] VO\ VSQV] acg] PcS\O Ô`bS RSZ RWaQcà] ÔÒ `SWdW\RWQO` b]ROa ZOa ^]Z bWQOa VOabO SaO SROR S W\QZca] ÔÒ

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

OQS^bO` _cS SZ ZWRSÒhU] RS ZO `S^`SaS\bOQW \ XcdS\WZ dS\UO RORO ^]` Z]a RS [ta SROR g [ta Sf^S`W[S\bOR]a S\ SZ _cSVOQS` ^]Z bWQ] :Oa ^]Z bWQOa RS XcdS\bcR RSPS\ `SQc^SÒ` ac d]QOQW \ SRcQObWdO RSaRS [ ZbW^ZSa T`S\bSa g [Sb]R]Z]U Oa ^]`_cS aWS\R] Q][^ZSXO g QO[PWO\bS ZO a]QWSROR S\ ZO _cS dWdW[]a SabO[]a ]PZWUOR]a O ]T`SQS` O \cSabÒ XcdS\bcR ZOa VS`Ò[WS\bOa ÔÒ [ObS`WOZWhO` ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa _cS SabS Q]\bSfb] bO[PW{\ \]a OP`S [W\W[WhO\R] Z]a `WSaU]a >S`] S\ b]R] QOa] aS RSPS bÒPOXO` Q]\ ZO [tfW[O RS µ\] RO` ^SQSa aW\] S\aS O` O ^SaQO`¶ O Q][^`S\RS` SZ ` ] QO[PWO\bS O Z]a ^SQSa _cS O \ [cbO\bSa a]\ \SQSaO`W]a ÔÒ S[^`S\RS` c\ ^`]gSQb] dWbOZ Q]\ [Og]`Sa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS {fWb] AS RSPS SRcQO` Q]\ dOZWRSh g V]`Wh]\bOZWROR ^]` Ô`bS RS Z]a [ ZbW^ZSa OQb]`Sa _cS Sabt\ ^`S]QcÔR]a g _cWS`S\ SZ PWS\SabO` RS ZO XcdS\bcR aW\ ÔbS`\OZWa[] W\TO\bWZWhO\bS \W ^` ``]UOa W\XcabWTWQOROa ObS\RWS\R] O ZOa \SQSaWRORSa RS Z]a X dS\Sa g \] RS ZOa OR[W\WabÒQW]\Sa c ]ÙO\WhOQW]\Sa \] UcPS`\O[S\bOZSa >cSRS Ô`SQS` bS\bOR]` O[^ZWO` ZOa SRORSa RS \cSabÒ ^]PZOQW \ RWO\O ÔÒ bOZ dSh [SX]Ò` \cSab`]a W\RWQOR]`Sa S\ b{`[W\]a OPa]Zcb]a ^S`] aSUcW`S[]a ]PaS`dO\R] ZO RSPWZWROR `SZObWdO RS \cSab`] W[ÔQb] 3\ SZ QOa] RS _cS _cSÒ[]a O[^ZWO` ZO Q]V]`bS RS SROR RS \cSab`]a RSabW\ObO`W]a bOZ dSh RSPS` O[]a [WÒ` _cS SZ ^`]QSa] Q]\bW\c] bWS\S \] a Z] c\ [][S\b] RS SROR OdO\hORO SaQO\ROZ]a] O STSQb]a RS ]^W\W \ ^ PZWQO ^]` SZ ^`]PZS[O RSZ S[^ZS] g ZO dWdWS\RO aW\] c\ [][S\b] O\bS`W]` ^`SdW] O ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO _cS Sa W[^]`bO\b aW[] ÔÒ ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS `WSaU]a g ZO [cZbW^ZWQOQW \ RS ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa O bÒd{a RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS VOPWZWRORSa a]QWOZSa RS Ocb]SabW[O ÔÒ Q]\]QS` SZ S\b]`\] a]QWOZ g \ObcÒZ `Sa^SbO`Z] g aOPS` []dSàS S\ {Z O^`S\RWS\R] ^`SQ]h[S\bS O aS` QWcRORO\] Q]\aQWS\bS RS aca ^]bS\QWOZWRORSa g RSaO``]ZZO`Z]a 3Z `Sa^Sb] O ZO VSbS`]US\SWROR XcdS\WZ g SZ OZSXO[WS\b] RS c\ bÒbO[WS\b] V][]US\SWhOR]` ^cSRS OgcRO` O _cS QORO ^Sà]\O Sd]ZcQW]\S Q]\T]`[S O ac `Wb[] ]PbS\WS\R] `Sa^cSabO O aca \SQSaWRORSa ^S`] SaT]`ht\R]aS ^Sà]\OZ[S\bS S\ RWQVO O\RORcÒ :O ^`]^WO Q]\RWQW \ XcdS\WZ \] RSPS RS ac^]\S` c\ `WSaU] S\ a [Wa[O aW\] c\O SbOÔ [ta ÔÒ aS` dWdWRO RWaT`cbORO ] Sf^S`W[S\bORO Q]\ OQ][Ô O[WS\b] S W\T]`[OQW \ ÔÒ dOZ]Ò` g RSQWRW` 3Z 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ S\ ac 7\T]`[S a]P`S SZ ^]bS\QWOZ RS ZO XcdS\bcR S\ /[{`WQO :ObW\O g SZ 1O`WPS S\ `SZOQW \ O ZO [W\W[WhOQW \ RS Z]a `WSaU]a RSaRS ZO SabÒbSUWO RS ZOa ^]Z bWQOa ^ PZWQOa VOQ O dOZ]ÒQW]\Sa ^S`TSQbO[S\bS W\Q]`^]ÒPZSa O \cSabÒa ^`W]`WRORSa S\ ^]Z bWQOa RS XcdS\bcR g RS ^`SdS\QW \ RS `WSaU]a Q]\ X dS\Sa 3\ c\ Q]\bSfb] RS `SQcà]a ZW[WbOR]a aS RSPS` O\ Q]\aWRSÒ` Sab]a ^`]UÒ[Oa Q][] c\O W\dSàW \ g RWaS O`Z]a Q][] bOZ VOQWS\R] VW\QO^W{ S\ ZO ^]bS\QWOZWROR RS [W\W[WhO` ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RS OQQW]\Sa \]QWdOa ÔÒ ZO ^Sà]\O g ZO a]QWSROR S\ SZ Tcbc`] :Oa Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] bWS\S\ c\ SZSdOR] Q]abS ^Sà]\OZ g a]QWOZ ^]` Z] _cS O\bS ac `SRcQQW \ aS ^`]RcQS c\ PS\STWQW] ÔÒ SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO a]QWSROR ^cRWS\R] ZZSdO` O _cS Z]a X dS\Sa bS\UO\ [SX]`Sa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS aOZcR W\U`Sa]a [ta OZb]a ^]` ac [Og]` QcOZWTWQOQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ g [SX]`Sa Q]\RWQW]\Sa ÔÒ RWaT`cbO` RS ZO dWRO ASU \ SabO ]PaS`dOQW \ ZO W\dSàW \ bS\R` O `S\bOPWZWROR ÔÒ b]R] SZ Ô a

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

gO _cS µSZ Ôb` \ WRSOZ RS W\dSàW \ Sa O_cSZ _cS W\dWS`bS Q]\ TcS`hO O Q][WS\h]a RS ZO dWRO RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa ÔÒ \] bS\S` _cS W\dS`bW` bO\b] [ta ORSZO\bS¶ :]a ^`]UÒ[Oa RSPS\ ObS\RS` ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] RSaRS SZ \OQW[WS\b] gO _cS S\ OZUc\Oa QcSabW]\Sa RSPS RS aS` bS\WR] S\ QcS\bO _cS aS` O bO`RS W\QWRW` a]P`S ^Sà]\Oa X dS\Sa RS ] " O ]a gO _cS ^`STS`S\QWOa g Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a aS RSTW\S\ O bS[^Ò\O SROR :O W\bS`dS\QW \ bS[^Ò\O RSPS bS\S` S\ QcS\bO Q][] RSabW\ObO`W]a \] a Z] O X dS\Sa aW\] bO[PW{\ O ac S\b]`\] a]QWOZ Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS O aca TO[WZWOa 3\ SabS W\T]`[S aS OP]UO ^]` SZ SabOPZSQW[WS\b] RS ^`]UÒ[Oa ÔÒ X dS\Sa Sf^cSab]a O `WSaU]a _cS \SQSaWbO\ aSUc\ROa ]^]`bc\WRORSa gO _cS ^SaS O _cS aS RS c\O PcS\O OQbcOQW \ ^ PZWQO RS [O\SÒ bS[^Ò\O aWS[^`S VOP`t X dS\Sa _cS bS\UO\ Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] ^]` Z] _cS RSPS\ SabOPZSQSàS [SQO\Wa[]a _cS [O\bS\UO\ OPWS`bOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa RS Tcbc`] ÔÒ Z]a [Wa[]a O^]gt\R]ZSa Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS S\ ac RSaO``]ZZ] ^Sà]\OZ 3dWRS\bS[S\bS \] OQbcO` RS [O\SÒ V][]U{\SO a]P`S ZO ^]PZOQW \ aW\] _cS RSPS RS ^`W]`WhOàS ZO OQbcOQW \ a]P`S O_cSZZOa ^Sà]\Oa X dS\Sa _cS aS S\QcS\b`S\ [ta Sf^cSab]a O Z]a `WSaU]a ^]` Q]\RWQW]\O\bSa âWQ]a]QWOZSa ?cWS\Sa ^`SaS\bS\ [ta Q]\RWQW]\O\bSa ^]bS\QWOZSa \SQSaWbO\ RS c\O [Og]` ObS\QW \ a]P`S b]R] RS^S\RWS\R] RS aca S\b]`\]a ] Q]\RcQbOa ^`SdWOa ]PaS`dO\R] g [WRWS\R] SZ W[ÔQb] `SOZ RS ZOa OQbcOQW]\Sa a]P`S SZZOa 2SPS RS ROàS ^`W]`WROR O ZOa ^]Z bWQOa ] OQbcOQW]\Sa _cS OP]`RO\ aW[cZbt\SO[S\bS dO`W]a `WSaU]a O\bS ZO RWTWQcZbOR SfWabS\bS RS ObS\RS` RS [O\SÒ Sa^SQ TWQO ÔÒ QORO bW^]Z]U O RS `WSaU] ^]` Z] _cS Sa W[^]`bO\bS c\O OQbcOQW \ UZ]POZ ÔÒ c\O [Og]` STWQWS\QWO 2S SabO `SOZWROR Sa c\ QZO`] SXS[^Z] ZO `SZOQW \ _cS aS RO S\b`S Ocb]SabW[O VOPWZWRORSa a]QWOZSa g [ ZbW^ZSa `WSaU]a ÔÒ ZO aOZcR aSfcOZWROR R`]UOa OZW[S\bOQW \ SbQ 3\ SabS aS\bWR] g O\bS SabO aWbcOQW \ RSPS RS ROàS c\O ^ZO\WTWQOQW \ UZ]POZ g SabÒb{UWQO _cS bS\UO S\ QcS\bO ZOa \SQSaWRORSa XcdS\WZSa RS QORO [][S\b] ÔÒ [W\W[WhO` Z]a `WSaU]a g Oc[S\bO` OZ [tfW[] ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa _cS SaS Q]\bSfb] ^cSRO ]T`SQS` <] aW`dS ^]` Z] bO\b] aW\ [ta VOQS` c\O `SQ]^WZOQW \ OR[W\WabÒbWdO RS Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa dWUS\bSa ÔÒ `SW\aS`bO`Z]a S\ c\O \cSdO ^`]UÒ[OQW \ aW\] _cS SfWUS SZ SaTcS`h] RS O\OZWhO` ZOa bS\RS\QWOa Q]\]QWS\R] ZO ]^W\W \ RS Z]a ^`W\QWÔZSa W[^ZWQOR]a Z]a X dS\Sa g ZOa X dS\Sa Oa Q][] RS Z]a ^`]TSaW]\OZSa _cS Sabt\ Q]\bW\cO[S\bS bÒPOXO\R] Q]\ SZZ]a /T]`bc\ORO[S\bS bS\S[]a O \cSab`] OZQO\QS [SQO\Wa[]a _cS \]a ^S`[WbS\ W` Q]\]QWS\R] ZO `SOZWROR O bÒd{a RS ZO cbWZWhOQW \ RS VS`Ò[WS\bOa RS SdOZcOQW \ RSZ W[ÔQb] RS Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa g ZO cbWZWhOQW \ RS aWabS[Oa RS W\dSabWUOQW \ a]QW]Z UWQO ÔÒ RSbSQbO` ZOa bS\RS\QWOa XcdS\WZSa ZOa ^`S]QcÔQW]\Sa g \SQSaWRORSa RS SabS U`c^] RS ^]PZOQW \ ÔÒ Q]ZOP]Ò` S\ ZO `SQ]\RcQQW \ RS ^ZO\Sa g ^`]UÒ[Oa RSabW\OR]a ÔÒ ZO XcdS\bcR 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ

AW Q]\aSUcW[]a [WÒ` [ta OZZt RS OZUc\]a W\RWQOR]`Sa QcO\bWbObWd]a g VOQS[]a SZ SaTcS`h] RS cbWZWhO` W\ab`c[S\b]a QcOZWbObWd]a ÔÒ Q]\]QS` _c{

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

^`S]QcÔ O ZO XcdS\bcR Q]\ aca RWTS`S\QWOa g Ô`bWQcZO`WRORSa R \RS aS S\QcS\bÒ\ ZOa ^`W\QWÔZSa bS\RS\QWOa [ta OZZt RS ZOa \SQSaWRORSa RS XcabWTWQOQW \ RS OQbcOQW]\Sa ] RS [O\bS\W[WS\b] RS ^`]UÒ[Oa W\OZbSÒR]a ^]` Ô`bS RS OR[W\WabÒQW]\Sa ] bSXWR] Oa]QWObWd] aS ^]R`t\ ObS\RS` S\ [Og]` [SRWRO ZOa \SQSaWRORSa RS ZO XcdS\bcR RS QORO [][S\b] 3\ SabS aS\bWR] Sa W[^`SaQW\RWPZS c\ Q][^`][Wa] ^]Z bWQ] TcS`bS S\b`S b]R]a Z]a OUS\bSa _cS Sabt\ W\bS`dW\WS\R] ÔÒ ^]RS` `SOZWhO` c\ \cSd] `SÔ`b] RS bO`SOa Tc\QW]\Sa g `Sa^]\aOPWZWRORSa QORO dSh _cS aS Q]\aWUO `S]`WS\bO` c\ ^ZO\ SabÒb{UWQ] Q]\ ZO RWTWQcZbOR RS _cS aS`t QORO b`Sa QcOb`] ] QW\Q] O ]a QcO\R] aS bS\UO _cS `SOP`W` aS`WO[S\bS SZ ^`]QSa] RS \SU]QWOQW \ ÔÒ ZZSdO` O PcS\ ^cS`b] Z]a ^ZO\Sa g ^`]UÒ[Oa RSabW\OR]a O X dS\Sa >SaS O _cS aS VO `SWbSÒR] S\ [ ZbW^ZSa SaÔQW]a g ^cPZWQOQW]\Sa _cS ZO ^]Z bWQO RS XcdS\bcR \] bWS\S c\O ^`W]`WROR S\ ZO OUS\RO ^ PZWQO a Z] QOPS RSQW` Q][] QWS``S _cS aWS[^`S RS^S\RS`t RS Z] _cS aSO ^`SaS\bOR] Q][] ^]Z bWQO RS XcdS\bcR ] Q][] ^]Z bWQOa RS XcdS\bcR S\ ^ZcÒZ gO _cS aW a Z] \]a RSRWQO[]a O W\bS\bO` `SWdW\RWQO` SaÔQW]a ^]` a [Wa[Oa ÔÒ SabOa ^]Z bWQOa \c\QO Z]a S\Q]\bÒ`t\ O \] aS` _cS ORSQcS\ ac `SZOQW \ S\b`S \SQSaWRORSa g `Sa^cSabOa >OÒ QcOZ_cWS` a]QWSROR aWS[^`S dO O aS` W[^]`bO\bS SabOPZSQS` ZOa SabÒbSUWOa g [SQO\Wa[]a ÔÒ _cS ac aWUcWS\bS US\SÒQW \ ^cSRO O^`]dSQVOàS OZ [tfW[] RS Z]a SaTcS`h]a g Q]\]QW[WS\b]a OQc[cZOR]a VOabO SZ [][S\b] Oc\_cS S\ ]QOaW]\Sa \] S\bWS\RO Q][^ZSbO[S\bS Q [] aS Sabt bÒPOXO\R] ZO XcdS\bcR @343@3<17/A 070:7=5@È471/A 0O\Q] ;c\RWOZ µ3Z ^]bS\QWOZ RS ZO XcdS\bcR( ^]Z bWQOa ÔÒ X dS\Sa S\ aWbcOQW \ RS `WSaU] S\ /[{`WQO :ObW\O g SZ 1O`WPS¶ Vbb^( aWbS`Sa]c`QSa e]`ZRPO\Y ]Ù 7<B:/17<A>/<7A6 @Sa]c`QSa G]cbVMAÔ\WaVM3fMAc[[O`g ^RT 1][Oa /`\Oc 2 % µ:Oa ^]Z bWQOa RS XcdS\bcR S\ ZO 3aÔ O RS[]Q`tbWQO¶ 7\abWbcb] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR ;OR`WR ;SU Oa ?cW` a 7 @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ 3 g 0OZZSabS`]a 5cS`Ò 8 1 & µ3Z Sa^SX] RS Z]a [SRW]a c\ SQ] RS WRO g dcSZbO¶ @SdWabO 7\bS\QW]\Sa <c[ 4c\ROQW \ 53 A]QWOZ ;OR`WR ;]\SRS`] 8 1 µ3Z [WabS`W] RS ZO bÒ\aWQW \ S[P`cXORO¶ 3\ >O\WOUcO A]b] 8 : g ;]\SRS`] 8 1 ''' 3\ b]`\] O ZO RS[]QÒQWO S\ 3aÔ O BSQ\]a ;OR`WR @SdWZZO 1Oab`] 8 1 µ:O Q]\ab`cQQW \ RWaQcàWdO RS ZO XcdS\bcR( Z] US\SÒZ g Z] Ô`bWQcZO`¶ >O^Sà $! $" 0O`QSZ]\O @WSdW|`S ; & µ<]bOa a]P`S Z]a X dS\Sa g Z]a [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQW \¶ @SdWabO 7\bS\QW]\Sa <c[ 4c\ROQW \ 53 A]QWOZ ;OR`WR BOPS\S` 5cOa^ 8 ! µA]QW]Z]U O g SRcQOQW \¶ BSQ\]a ;OR`WR

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

B6I:G>6A:H

? kZcZh n \Zhi^ c YZa g^Zh\d

B6I:G>6A:H

HZaZXX^ c YZ gZ[ZgZcX^Vh YdXjbZciVaZh hdWgZ ? kZcZh n \Zhi^ c YZa g^Zh\d 3abO `SZOQW \ Sabt T]`[ORO bO\b] ^]` ZWP`]a Q][] ^]` O`b QcZ]a RS `SdWabO ] R]Qc[S\b]a RS RWabW\bO ^`]QSRS\QWO aSZSQQW]\OR]a S\ ZO POaS RS ROb]a RS ZO 0WPZW]bSQO RSZ 7\abWbcb] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR RSZ =0A3@D/B=@7= 23 :/ 8CD3<BC2 3< 3A>/q/ 1Oa] RS SabO` W\bS`SaOR]a S\ OZUc\O RS SabOa `STS`S\QWOa ^cSRS\ a]ZWQWbO` Q]^WO RSZ [ObS`WOZ acaQS^bWPZS RS `S^`]RcQQW \ aSU \ ZO ZSUWaZOQW \ dWUS\bS Oa Q][] ZO `SOZWhOQW \ RS ]bÒa P a_cSROa `Sb`]a^SQbWdOa RW`WUW{\R]aS O( 070:7=B31/ 23 8CD3<BC2 ;O`_c{a RS @WaQOZ $ & ;/2@72 BSZ ( ' !$!%& ) 4Of( ' !$!%& 3 [OWZ( PWPZW]bSQO W\XcdS.[WUcOZROR Sa /a [Wa[] ^cSRS Q]\acZbO` {abO ] O\bS`W]`Sa @SdWabOa RS 3abcRW]a RS 8cdS\bcR Oa Q][] ZOa <]dSRORSa RS ZO 0WPZW]bSQO S\ ZO ^tUW\O eSP RSZ 7\abWbcb]( Vbb^( eee W\XcdS [WUcOZROR Sa 1O`ÒaQ] 2tdWZO /ZO\ 4`SRRg /RWQQW \ O W\bS`\Sb /ZO\ 4`SRRg 1O`ÒaQ] 2tdWZO ³ Ia Z K( 7\bS`âW_cWa % ^ ) ! Q[ /`b QcZ] RSZ & 1]\U`Sa] DW`bcOZ RS >aW_cWOb` O 7\bS`âW_cWa % 3Z ca] RS W\bS`\Sb VO ac^cSab] c\ QO[PW] ÒRWQOZ S\ ZO Q][c\WQOQW \ c\WdSàOZ ^]\WS\R] OZ OZQO\QS RS ZO [Og]` O bOZ QO\bWROR RS W\T]`[OQW \ _cS Sabt\ S[^ShO\R] O RSbSQbOàS QZO`]a a \b][Oa Ôb]Z UWQ]a RS ORWQQW \ _cS ^`]d]QO\ UÒdSa RWaTc\QW]\Sa S\ SZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] a]QWOZ RS OZUc\]a cacO`W]a Vbb^( eee âW_cWOb`WO Q][ O`bWQcZ]a ORWQQW]\Sa ' "# /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 0SÙO BW[]\SRO /\\O /R]ZSaQ|\QWO TS[S\W\O W `WaQ a]QWOZ /\\O 0SÙO W BW[]\SRO ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( 5S\SÒZWbOb RS 1ObOZc\gO ASQ`SbO`WO RS 8]dS\bcb % "% ^ ) Q[ ³ 1]Z ZSQQW /^]`bOQW]\a) ! >`S[W 8]dS\bcb # @Sac[S\ Sa_cS[tbWQ] RS c\ bÒPOX] RS bSaWa RS ZO ^`]^WO Ocb]Ò R \RS aS O\OZWhO\ ZOa QOcaOa US\SÒR]Òa RS `WSaU] a]QWOZ S\ RSbS`[W\OR]a t[PWb]a RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ g SZ STSQb] RSaWUcOZ a]P`S SZ aSf] TS[S\W\] S\ RWQV]a O[PWS\bSa 7A0< '%& &" !'! %" $ & Vbb^( eee US\QOb QOb R]Qa 8]dS\bcb 2]Qc[S\ba /`fWc >cPZWQOQW]\a 1]ZM/^]`bOQW]\a O^]`bO! ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] >cZWR] DOZS`] @]aO /R]ZSaQS\QWO g Q]\RcQbOa dW]ZS\bOa( TOQb]`Sa RS ^`]bSQQW \ g RS `WSaU] @]aO >cZWR] DOZS`]) RW`WUWRO ^]` ;O` O 8]a{ 2 Oh /UcOR] ³ ;OR`WR( C\WdSàWROR 4OQcZbOR RS >aWQ]Z]U O $ # $ ^ ( bOP UÒT ) ! Q[ BSaWa R]Qb]ÒZ C\Wd 1][^ZcbS\aS

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

7\dSabWUOQW \ `SOZWhORO O bÒd{a RS c\O [cSabÒ RS OR]ZSaQS\bSa [Og]`Sa RS " O ]a RS ZO 1][c\WROR RS ;OR`WR ÔÒ OV]\RO` S\ ZOa QOcaOa RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS S\ QS\b`]a SRcQObWd]a g S\ aca ^]aWPZSa a]ZcQW]\Sa /\OZWhO Z]a ^`W\QWÔZSa TOQb]`Sa RSZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] dW]ZS\b] Q][] a]\( ZO SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ OcaS\QWO RS Z [WbSa Sf^]aWQW \ O ZO dW]ZS\QWO O bÒd{a RS Z]a [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQW \ SbQ G ^]` ]b`] ZOR] aS O\OZWhO\ Q][] TOQb]`Sa RS ^`]bSQQW \( RWa^]\S` RS []RSZ]a a]QWOZSa ^]aWbWd]a Q]ZOP]ÒQW \ RS ZO SaQcSZO g TO[WZWO` Q]\bSfb]a RS ]QW] SbQ 2WOh /UcOR] 8OZ]\ ; O 8]a{ /R]ZSaQS\QWO aSfWa[] g dW]ZS\QWO RS U{\S`] IS\ Z \SOK ;O` O 8]a{ 2 Oh /UcOR] ³ ;OR`WR( >O^SZSa RSZ >aWQ Z]U] ! ! V /`b QcZ] ^cPZWQOR] S\ >O^SZSa RSZ >aWQ Z]U] S\S`] \ &" ! :O aS`WS RS W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa _cS O_c aS ^`SaS\bO aS ]`WS\bO S\ b]`\] O c\ R]PZS ]PXSbWd]( Q]\]QS` VOabO _c{ ^c\b] aS VO\ ac^SÒR] SZ aSfWa[] g SZ `WSaU] RS dW]ZS\QWO RS US\S`] S\b`S Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa OQbcOZSa) RSaO``]ZZO` g SdOZcO` c\ ^`]UÒ[O RS W\bS`dS\QW \ _cS ^S`[WbO `SRcQW` ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] RSbSQbOROa Vbb^( eee Q]^ Sa Ô^SZSa dS`\c[S`] Oa^-WR+ #! /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] @cbbS` >VWZW^ / /R]ZSaQS\b acWQWRS `WaY( T]c` âgQV]a]QWOZ TOQb]à >VWZW^ / @cbbS` O\R /\R`Se 3 0SV`S\Rb /R]ZSaQS\QS ³ d !' \ #" ac[[S` " ) ^ '# ! 7AA< &""' 3Z acWQWRW] Sa c\O RS ZOa ^`W\QWÔZSa QOcaOa RS [cS`bS S\b`S OR]ZSaQS\bSa 3abS SabcRW] SfO[W\ ZO ^ZO\WTWQOQW \ SZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] g SZ W\bS\b] RS acWQWRW] RS OR]ZSaQS\bSa S\b`S % g ' O ]a 3fWabS\ QcOb`] TOQb]`Sa âWQ]a]QWOZSa W[^]`bO\bSa ÔÒ O\OZWhO` SZ `WSaU] RS acWQWRW]( RSaSa^SÒQW \ V]abWZWROR Q]\QS^b] \SUObWd] RS a [Wa[] g OWaZO[WS\b] Vbb^( eee TW\RO`bWQZSa Q][ ^ O`bWQZSa [WM[ "& WaM #"M!' OWM\$!$" %% /QQSa] bSfb] Q][^ZSb] BO` \ ;O\cSZ /R]ZSaQS\bSa S\ `WSaU]( 1Oa]a ^`tQbWQ]a g SabÒbSUWOa RS W\bS`dS\QW \ a]QW]SRcQObWdO ;O\cSZ BO` \ 8]a{ 8OdWS` <OdO``] ³ ;OR`WR( 11A $ ! " ^ ) Q[ ³ 3RcQO`) !$ ;Sb]R]Z]U O g PcS\Oa ^`tQbWQOa ^`]TSaW]\OZSa ÔÒ W\QWRW` a]P`S Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa S\ `WSaU] RS [OÙW\OQW \ g SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ aS S\b`SZOhO\ Q]\ dWdS\QWOa g Sf^S`WS\QWOa Q]\Q`SbOa) QORO QO^ bcZ] aS OQ][Ô O RS c\ QOa] ^`tQbWQ] _cS `STZSXO ZO ^`]PZS[tbWQO Sa^SQ TWQO g ]T`SQS ^WabOa ÔÒ ZO OQQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ 7A0< &" &! $ '$' F <OdO``] 8]a{ /R]ZSaQS\bSa R`]UOa g XcSU]( TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] g ^`]bSQQW \ 8]a{ <OdO``] >`]gSQb] V][P`S ³ \ "$ Xc\W] ! ) ^ % !& 7AA< !$ ! %% 0WPZW]U` ( ^ !& 3abcRW] _cS Q]\bS[^ZO SZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa g ac `SZOQW \ Q]\ ZO ^`tQbWQO RS Z]a dWRS]XcSU]a g [t_cW\Oa bÒUO^S`Òa bO\ T`SQcS\bSa S\ SZ ]QW] RS Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa /c\_cS aS VO `SOZWhOR] S\ ZO 1][c\WROR RS /\ROZcQ O ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa _cS aS SabOPZSQS\ aW`dS\ ÔÒ Q]\]QS` Z] _cS acQSRS S\ c\ t[PWb] [ta US\SÒZ 3\ c\O ^`W[SÒ Ô`bS aS [cSabÒ\ ZOa ^`SdOZS\QWOa RSZ

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

Q]\ac[] RS ZOa RWabW\bOa R`]UOa g ZO RS Z]a XcSU]a ^`W\QWÔZSa Xc\b] O ZOa ^]ZWORWQQW]\Sa _cS aS SabOPZSQS\ g S\ c\O aSUc\RO Ô`bS Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] g ^`]bSQQW \ Oa]QWOR]a O SabS TS\ [S\] /R]ZSaQS\ba Ob `WaY T]` dW]ZS\QS( O\ W\WbWOZ dOZWRObW]\ ]T bVS ZWTS QVOZZS\USa _cSabW]\\OW`S O\R `WaY OaaSaa[S\b W\RSf 7ZgaS 5`W\PSÙ ISb OZ K /R]ZSaQS\QS ³ d]Z " \ #' TOZZ # ) ^ #%! #'' 7AA< &""' 3Z W\Q`S[S\b] RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO XcdS\WZ Sa c\ TS\ [S\] _cS Sabt RSaP]`RO\R] ZOa Sab`cQbcÒa bÒRWQW]\OZSa RS Z]a Ô aSa [ta RSaO``]ZZOR]a g Sabt US\SÒ\R] SabcRW]a RS W\dSabWUOQW \ ÔÒ ^]\S` S\ ^`tQbWQO [SRWROa Q]``SQb]Òa _cS OT`]\bS\ ZO aWbcOQW \ 1OabWZZ] 1O`P]\SZZ ;W_cSZ /ZUc\Oa Q]\abObOQW]\Sa S\ b]`\] O ZOa W\bS`dS\QW]\Sa a]QW]SRcQObWdOa RS Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa S\ [SRW] OPWS`b] Q]\ W\TO\QWO g OR]ZSaQS\QWO S\ `WSaU] a]QWOZ RSaRS SZ t[PWb] RS ^`]bSQQW \ ;W_cSZ 1OabWZZ] 1O`P]\SZZ @SdWabO RS bÒPOX] a]QWOZ ³ \ %" Xc\W] " ) ^ " # 7AA< % /\tZWaWa RS c\ ^`]UÒ[O SRcQObWd] S\ [SRW] OPWS`b] ^]\WS\R] O ZO dWabO ZO aS`WS RS RWTWQcZbORSa _cS ^ZO\bSO ZO UÒ\ SfbS\aW \ US]U`tTWQO _cS QcP`S Z]a UÒ\RSa [SRW]a Vc[O\]a _cS `S_cWS`S g ZO ^`]dWaW]\OZWROR RS Z]a `SQcà]a [ObS`WOZSa OaWU\OR]a 0SÙO BW[]\SRO /\\O /^`S\RWS\R] O aS` PcS\Oa( Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS `WSaU] a]QWOZ S\ ZOa OR]ZSaQS\bSa /\\O 0SÙO BW[]\SRO 8 dS\Sa( `SdWabO RS SabcRW]a a]P`S XcdS\bcR ³ \ ' XcZW] RWQ ! ) ^ $ !# 7AA< " # " $F 1]\ T`SQcS\QWO ZO W\bS`dS\QW \ a]QWOZ Sabt RW`WUWRO OZ Q]\b`]Z RS []R] _cS ZOa X dS\Sa OZ \] ^`]bOU]\WhO` Q]\RcQbOa O[S\OhO\bSa ] RS ^t\WQ] []ÒZ _cSRO\ S\ c\ aSUc\R] ^ZO\] 3Z O`b QcZ] O\OZWhO S\ _c{ QOa]a aS Q]\aWRSÒ _cS c\O aWbcOQW \ Sa RS `WSaU] S\ V][P`Sa g [cXS`Sa g QctZSa a]\ ZOa `Sa^cSabOa a]QWOZSa _cS aS ]T`SQS\ 6S`\O\RSh /`Wabc 8Sa a /aSa]Ò[WS\b] Q][] Sab`cQbcÒ g OQQW \ S\ Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS W\aS`QW \ ZOP]ÒZ g a]QWOZ RS Z]a X dS\Sa( c\O `STZSfW \ RSaRS ZO ^ÒfWa 8Sa a 6S`\t\RSh /`Wabc @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR ³ \ %% Xc\W] % ) ^ %! &% 7AA< "!$" :O XcdS\bcR Q][] bÒ\aWQW \ O ZO dWRO ORcZbO _cSRO Q]\RWQW]\ORO ^]` ZOa bÒ\aT]`[OQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa :O ^ZcÒZWROR RS T]`[Oa RS dWRO _cS b][O\ Z]a X dS\Sa `S_cWS`S \cSdOa Sab`cQbcÒa _cS acabWbcgO\ g Q][^ZSbS\ ZOa Tc\QW]\Sa RS O^]g] g OgcRO O aca bÒ\aWQW]\Sa _cS bÒRWQW]\OZ[S\bS Qc[^Z O\ aWabS[Oa Q][] ZO TO[WZWO ZO SaQcSZO ZO T]`[OQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa g _cS V]g `SacZbO\ ]Pa]ZSbOa Vbb^( eee W\XcdS [bOa Sa W\XcdS Q]\bS\WR]a R]e\Z]ORObb OQbW]\-WR+ '$'! !!" /QQSa] bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 1]`\SZZO W 1O\OZa 8]aS^ /a^SQb]a US\SÒZSa RS ZO aOZcR S\ ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g ZO XcdS\bcR( TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] g RS ^`]bSQQW \ 8]aS^ 1]`\SZZu W 1O\OZa ®ZSf :ZcaS\b W 5cWZZO[Sb ³ IA Z K( >aW_cWOb`WO Q][ " & ^

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

/\tZWaWa RSZ Q]\QS^b] RS aOZcR W\bSUÒZ RSZ OR]ZSaQS\bS Qcg] ]PXSbWd] Sa _cS SZZ]a ^cSRO\ RSa^ZSUO` b]ROa aca QOÔQWRORSa T aWQOa âWQ]Z UWQOa OTSQbWdOa S W\bSZSQbcOZSa Oa Q][] `SRcQW` ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] âWQ]a]QWOZ O ZOa _cS aS Sf^]\S\ RS [O\SÒ Sa^SQWOZ _cWS\Sa dWdS\ S\ aWbcOQW]\Sa [S\]a TOd]ÒPZSa Vbb^( eee âW_cWOb`WO Q][ Q]\U`Sa] " bÒab]`\]aMW\TO\bWZSa O`bWQcZ]a #$ % /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 0OaSa ÔÒ ZO SZOP]ÒQW \ RS c\O SabÒbSUWO W\bSUÒZ ÔÒ ZO W\TO\QWO g OR]ZSaQS\QWO S\ `WSaU] g RWTWQcZbOR a]QWOZ IS_cW^] W\dSabWUOR]` ;WUcSZ È\USZ @cWh 2 Oh 8]a{ /\b]\W] 2 Oh 6cS`bOa 8]a{ ;O\cSZ 6S`\t\RSh : ^Sh) O^]g] b{Q\WQ] A]\WO 1]\b`SÒa 4Z]`WR]K ³ ;OR`WR( 1S\b`] RS >aWQ]Z]U O /^ZWQORO C\WdSàWROR /cb \][O ! #$ ^ ( U`tT bOP >`]gSQb] Q]TW\O\QWOR] ^]` ZO 2W`SQQW \ 5S\SÒZ RS /QQW \ A]QWOZ RSZ ;S\]` g RS ZO 4O[WZWO RSZ ;W\WabS`W] RS BÒPOX] g /ac\b]a A]QWOZSa g ZO C\WdSàWROR /cb \][O RS ;OR`WR 3Z ]PXSbWd] RS SabS ^`]gSQb] Sa RWab`WPcW` S_cWZWPÒRO[S\bS Z]a `SQcà]a O \WdSZ \OQW]\OZ `SUW]\OZ g Z]QOZ g _cS b]ROa ZOa 1][c\WRORSa /cb \][Oa ^`]^]`QW]\S\ SZ [Wa[] \WdSZ RS ^]Z bWQOa g aS`dWQW]a a]QWOZSa ÔÒ Z]a U`c^]a [ta [OÙW\OR]a RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ S\ Ô`bWQcZO` TO[WZWOa ^]P`Sa TO[WZWOa []\]Ô`S\bOZSa Oa Q][] ÔÒ \W ]a UWbO\]a g \W ]a RS TO[WZWOa W\[WUÒ\bSa Vbb^( eee [W` Sa ^\R ^cPZWQO ^RT 3abÒbSUWOM7\TO\QWO ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 5tZdSh 0WSaQO ASÙW] 1O[PW]a g RW\t[WQOa S\ ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa W\bSÙS\SÒQW]\OZSa( Z]a STSQb]a RS ZO ^`SQO`WSROR S\ Z]a X dS\Sa ASÙW] 5tZdSh 0WSaQO BS`SaO 8cÒR] 5cS``S`] A]QWSROR g cb]^ O ³ \ ' % ) ^ !! " ! 7AA< !! $% $ 1]\bWS\S( :O US\SÒQW \ RS ZO µQcZbcÒ RS ZO ^`SQO`WSROR¶( c\O O^`]fW[OQW \ RSaRS ZO VWab]`WO RSZ []dW[WS\b] ]P`S`] ASÙW] 5tZdSh 0WSaQO) :O ^`SQO`WSROR bS[^]ÒZ aOZO`WOZ g aca STSQb]a a]P`S ZO T]`[OQW \ TO[WZWO` BS`SaO 8cÒR] 5cS``S`] :]a QO[PW]a SQ]\ [WQ]a Sabt\ US\SÒ\R] QO[PW]a a]QWOZSa _cS aS ^cSRS\ Q]\abObO` S\ Z]a \cSd]a []RSZ]a TO[WZWO`Sa ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa RS RS^S\RS\QWO Ô`S\bOZSa ] S\ Z]a \cSd]a Q][^`][Wa]a Q]\bÒQbcOZSa RSZ [c\R] RSZ bÒPOX] B]``S\bS 6S`\t\RSh 5W\SaO 1OÒQbS` abWQOa a]QWOZSa g TO[WZWO`Sa dW\QcZOROa OZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZO Q]\RcQbO RSZWQbWdO S\ ^`S OR]ZSaQS\bSa g OR]ZSaQS\bSa 5W\SaO B]``S\bS 6S`\t\RSh È\USZ @]R` UcSh 5]\htZSh 1cORS`\]a RS bÒPOX] a]QWOZ ³ d]Z % " ) ^ '' # 7AA< " ! " 3Z SabcRW] RS dO`W]a U`c^]a RS OR]ZSaQS\bSa S\ S\b]`\]a TO[WZWO`Sa ^`]PZS[tbWQ]a W\RWQO _cS O [Og]` UÒR] RS RSbS`W]`] a]QWOZ g QO`S\QWO SQ]\ [WQO Sa [Og]` SZ UÒR] RS ^`]^S\aW \ O ZO RSZW\QcS\QWO :{dg >WS``S 1WPS`QcZbcÒ( W\T]`[S OZ 1]\aSX] RS 3c`]Ô >WS``S :{dg ^` Z]U] RS ;O\cSZ ;SRW\O ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( /\bV`]^]a % FF7D ^ ! ^ ( bOP ) Q[ ³ 1WS\QWO bSQ\]Z]U O g a]QWSROR) $

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

:]a OdO\QSa bÒ R]a ^]` ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa Sabt\ QO[PWO\R] RS bOZ [O\SÒ ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa bÒRWQW]\OZSa _cS SabO[]a OaWabWS\R] OZ \OQW[WS\b] RS c\O SÒ QcZbcÒZ g a]QWOZ ÒRWQOZ[S\bS RWTS`S\QWORO RS ZO bÒRWQW]\OZ VS`SRORO 7A0< '%& &" %$#& & & $ 1]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] g Q]\]QW[WS\b] RS D76 A72/ S\ OR]ZSaQS\bSa( 3abcRW] ^`SZW[W\O` ;Oa 1]Z][P] 3RcO`R] ISb OZ K ³ IA Z K( 7\bS`âW_cWa & ! ^ ) ! Q[ /`b QcZ] RSZ ' 1]\U`Sa] DW`bcOZ RS >aW_cWOb` O 7\bS`âW_cWa & /QbcOZ[S\bS ZOa QOcaOa RS []`PW[]`bOZWROR S\ OR]ZSaQS\bSa VO\ QO[PWOR] 3Z %# RS ZOa [Wa[Oa aS RSPS O Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] S\b`S SZZOa SZ Q]\bOUW] RS D76 AS bÒbO RS SabOPZSQS` aW SfWabS `SZOQW \ S\b`S W\T]`[OQW \ g Q]\]QW[WS\b] aW Sab] W\TZcgS S\ ZO ^`SaS\QWO RS Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] g Q [] aS ^S`QWPS\ S\ `SZOQW \ O ZOa [Wa[Oa AOW\h 8OdWS` A 1]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] g RWaQcà] a]QWOZ( Z]a S\S[WU]a RS ZO ZWPS`bOR ÒQW]\OZ 8OdWS` A AOW\h @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR ³ \ %& aS^b % ) ^ # "! 7AA< "!$" C\ ^`]PZS[O _cS OTSQbO Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS O Z]a X dS\Sa Sa _cS SZ Q]\b`]Z _cS QORO acXSb] RSPS` O bS\S` a]P`S aca OQb]a SdWbO\R] b]RO ^]aWPZS Q]OQQW \ bS\bOQW]\Sa ^`]d]QOQW]\Sa ORWQQW]\Sa ac^]\S SZ SaTcS`h] RS a]P`S^]\SàS O ZO T`cabÒQW \ RS \] ]PbS\S` c\O `SQ][^S\aO W\[SRWObO AS O\OZWhO Q][] SZ {fWb] RS c\ acXSb] S\ SZ Q]\b`]Z RS ac Q]\RcQbO RS^S\RS RS ac Sf^S`WS\QWO g RS ac W\bSÒQQW \ Q]\ ]b`]a RS Q [] QOabWUO\ g `SQ][^S\aO\ aca OQQW]\Sa Vbb^( eee W\XcdS [bOa Sa W\XcdS Q]\bS\WR]a R]e\Z]ORObb OQbW]\-WR+ ''!'$&&%# /QQSa] bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 3aÔRO AO\QVSh 8]a{ >SR`] 1]\RcQbOa aSfcOZSa RS `WSaU] g ^`SdS\QW \ RSZ aWRO S\ ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO 8]a{ >SR`] 3aÔRO At\QVSh ;O` O 8]a{ ?cWZSa ASPOabWt\ g 4Ò\QWaQ] 8OdWS` ;{\RSh 1O``WZZ] ³ ;OR`WR( >O^SZSa RSZ âWQ Z]U] I !K V /`b QcZ] ^cPZWQOR] S\ >O^SZSa RSZ >aWQ Z]U] OU]ab] \ &# ! :O TOZbO RS W\T]`[OQW \ ^cSRS W\RcQW` O `SOZWhO` Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a Q]\ `WSaU] RS bÒ\a[WbW` SZ D76 g RS bS\S` S[POÒh]a \] RSaSOR]a aW PWS\ ]bÒa dO`WOPZSa RS bW^] a]QWOZ Q]\RcQbcOZ g Q]U\WbWd] bO[PW{\ Sf^ZWQO\ ZOa Q]\RcQbOa aSfcOZSa RS `WSaU] AS RSabOQO ZO W[^]`bO\QWO RS _cS SZ OR]ZSaQS\bS ^S`QWPO SabS `WSaU] ^]bS\QWOZ g _cS Z]a PS\STWQW]a RS b][O` [SRWROa ^`]bSQb]Òa aSO\ [ta dOZ]ÒR]a _cS Z]a Q]abSa Vbb^( eee Q]^ Sa Ô^SZSa W[^`W[W` Oa^-WR+ %$ /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 1]\ac[] `Sa^]\aOPZS( Q`SQW[WS\b] SQ]\ [WQ] g a]abS\WPWZWROR 4OQcO 1]\ac[WR]`Sa S\ OQQW \ ³ ;OR`WR( 4OQcO $ %& ^ ( WZ ) Q[ ³ 5c Oa RSZ Q]\ac[WR]` 1cORS`\] W\T]`[ObWd] a]P`S ZO \SQSaWROR RS ^`][]dS` c\O SRcQOQW \ `Sa^]\aOPZS S\ c\O a]QWSROR W\[SàO S\ c\ QO[PW] a]QWOZ _cS O[S\OhO Q]\ RSab`cW` UÒ\ Ô`bS RS Z]a `SQcà]a \ObcÒZSa VS`SROR]a _cS a]\ PtaWQ]a ÔÒ [O\bS\S` c\ RSaO``]ZZ] a]abS\WPZS Vbb^( eee TOQcO ]Ù UcWOaRSZQ]\ac[WR]` $ Q]\ac[]`Sa^]\aOPZSM eSP ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

1cZbcÒZ [SRWOb]à W\ O VSUS[]\WQ \WUVbZWTS( ]^^]`bc\WbWSa T]` R`cU ^`SdS\bW]\ OcbV]à /[OR]` 1OZOTOb ISb OZ K) Q]ZZOP]Òb]à ;OÙOZWRO @]a @cbV /`WOa ³ >OZ[O RS ;OZZ]`QO( 7@34@3/ I "K #& ^ ( U`tT bOP 0WPZW]UÒT O( ^ ## #& 3abcRW] `SOZWhOR] RcÒ\bS aWSbS O ]a S\ ]\QS QWcRORSa Sc`]^SOa S\ SZ _cS aS RO ZO OZO`[O ^]` SZ W[^]`bO\bS \ [S`] RS X dS\Sa _cS Sabt\ O^`S\RWS\R] O aS` ORcZb]a g aS Sabt\ W\WQWO\R] S\ SZ [c\R] RS ZOa R`]UOa g SZ aSf] S\ SaÔQW]a RS ]QW] \]Qbc`\] Q]\ZZSdO\R] QWS`b]a `WSaU]a Oa]QWOR]a Q][] ZO dW]ZS\QWO ] Z]a OQQWRS\bSa RS b`tTWQ] >]` SabO Òh \ aS VOQS \SQSaO`W] OR]^bO` [SRWROa RS ^`SdS\QW \ W\bSUÒROa _cS `Sa^SbS\ ZOa \SQSaWRORSa RS Z]a X dS\Sa g SabÒbSUWOa Q][c\Sa S\b`S b]R]a Z]a aSQb]`Sa W\d]ZcQÒR]a S\ SZ [c\R] RSZ ]QW] ÔÒ ZO bÒ\a[WaW \ RS c\]a [Wa[]a dOZ]`Sa POaOR]a S\ ZO {bWQO 7A0< &" '! '"% " ! 5O`Q O 1O\QZW\W <{ab]` 1cZbcÒa XcdS\WZSa S\ c\O {^]QO aW\ `Sa^cSabO <{ab]` 5O`Q O 1O\QZW\W 8]dS\Sa( `SdWabO RS SabcRW]a a]P`S XcdS\bcR ³ \ S\S XcZ " ) ^ " #! 7AA< " # " $F :]a QO[PW]a _cS aS VO\ ^`]RcQWR] S\ ZOa a]QWSRORSa OdO\hOROa VO\ RSXOR] aW\ `Sa^cSabOa Z]a `Sb]a ^ZO\bSOR]a ^]` ZOa \cSdOa US\SÒQW]\Sa _cS bWS\S\ dOZ]`Sa RWabW\b]a O aca ^`]US\Wb]`Sa g c\]a Sab [cZ]a S[]QW]\OZSa RWTS`S\bSa <WZO\ >O[SZO 1cZbcÒa XcdS\WZSa UZ]POZSa >O[ <WZO\ @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR ³ \ $" [O`h] " ) ^ !' "% 7AA< "!$" >OÒ O\OZWhO` SZ [Wb] RSZ µOR]ZSaQS\bS UZ]POZ¶ VOg _cS S\bS\RS` ZOa QcZbcÒa XcdS\WZSa UZ]POZSa Q][] OZU] _cS acÙS Q][] `SOQQW \ O ZOa ^S`QS^QW]\Sa g Sf^S`WS\QWOa RSZ µ`WSaU]¶ US\SÒQW]\OZ S\ ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS ZO UZ]POZWhOQW \ Q]\bS[^]`t\SO 3Z ^`]QSa] RS VWP`WROQW \ RS ZOa QcZbcÒa g bS\RS\QWOa XcdS\WZSa ZO [WUÒQW \ SZ [cZbWQcZbcÒZWa[] g ZO [ShQZO c`PO\O RO\ ZcUO` O c\O W\bS\aWTWQOQW \ RSZ Q]\TZWQb] Vbb^( eee [bOa Sa W\XcdS PWPZW] `SdWabOa >RTa \c[S`]$" bS[O! ^RT /QQSa] bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 9WSaSZPOQV BV][Oa 2SaS[^ZS] XcdS\WZ RS ZOÙO RcÒQW \ g `WSaU] RS SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ S\ 3c`]Ô( W\T]`[S QcOZWbObWd] RSZ ^`]gSQb] RS W\dSabWUOQW \ GCA323@ BV][Oa 9WSaSZPOQV @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR ³ \ $# Xc\W] " ) ^ ! "' 7AA< "!$" 0WPZW]UÒT O 2SaRS ZO Q`WaWa S\SÙ{bWQO RS Z]a O ]a aSbS\bO SZ RSaS[^ZS] XcdS\WZ aS VO US\SÒZWhOR] ^]` b]RO 3c`]Ô aWS\R] c\ TOQb]` RS RSaWUcOZROR a]QWOZ g ^`]RcQWS\R] ZO SfQZcaW \ S\ Z]a W\RWdWRc]a OTSQbOR]a Vbb^ eee [bOa Sa W\XcdS PWPZW] `SdcabOa ^RTa \c[S`]$# bS[Oa" ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 2SaS[^ZS] XcdS\WZ SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ g aOZcR( 7\dSabWUOQW]\Sa Sf^S`WS\QWOa g OQQW]\Sa W\abWbcQW]\OZSa S\ 3aÔ O 8]aS^ 3a^ZcUO ISb OZ K ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( 7QO`WO I2 : "K

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

'% ^ ³ /QORS[WO A]QWSROR g =^W\W \) "& 0WPZW]U` ( ^ &% '% /\OZWhO ZOa Sf^S`WS\QWOa ^Sà]\OZSa RS c\O [cSabÒ RS X dS\Sa Q]\ [ta RS c\ O ] S\ RSaS[^ZS] ÔÒ W\bS\bO` S\bS\RS` aca WbW\SÒ`W]a aca Sf^SQbObWdOa g ZOa SabÒbSUWOa Q]\ _cS aS S\T`S\bO\ O ZO aWbcOQW \ W\bS\bO\R] RSbS`[W\O` Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS O^]g] g dcZ\SÒPWZWROR ^`SaS\bSa S\ ac S\b]`\] a]QWOZ 7A0< &" %" $ %!% " EOZbVS` /\R`SOa 2WZS[Oa RS ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RS bÒ\aWQW \( RWaQ`SÔ\QWOa S\b`S ZOa ^Sà^SQbWdOa RS Z]a X dS\Sa g RS ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa /\R`SOa EOZbVS` @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR ³ \ $# Xc\W] " ) ^ !! # 7AA< "!$" 0WPZW]UÒT O :]a QO[PW]a ^`]RcQWR]a RS\b`] RS ZO a]QWSROR bWS\S\ _cS dS\W` OQ][Ô OR]a RS QO[PW]a S\ ZOa Sab`cQbcÒa RS SaO a]QWSROR) \] aS ^cSRS\ RO` ZOa [Wa[Oa `Sa^cSabOa O ZOa \cSdOa ^`SUc\bOa RS Z]a X dS\Sa aW\ dSàS OP]QOR]a O \] RO` aOZWRO O ZOa \cSdOa Sf^SQbObWdOa RS[O\ROROa AS VOQS \SQSaO`W] Q][ÔbWPWZWhO` ZO S\aS O\hO T]`[OZ Q]\ ZO \] T]`[OZ g ZO TZSfWPWZWROR Q]\ ZO SabOPWZWROR ZOP]ÒZ ÔÒ \] QS`Ò` SZ Tcbc`] RS ZO XcdS\bcR Vbb^( eee [bOa Sa W\XcdS PWPZW] `SdWabOa ^RTa \c[S`]$# bS[Oa" ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 0O``Wca] /Z]\a] ;O`b \ 2`]UOa WZ QWbOa dWRO `SQ`SObWdO g USabW \ RS `WSaU]a( SabcRW] RWOU\ abWQ] RS \SQSaWRORSa RS W\bS`dS\QW \ S\ ^`SdS\QW \ RS `WSaU]a S\ t[PWb]a Z RWQ] TSabWd]a RS ZO 1/>D ;O`b \ 0O``Wca] /Z]\a] ³ DWb]`WO 5OabSWh( AS`dWQW] 1S\bÒZ RS >cPZWQOQW]\Sa RSZ 5]PWS`\] DOaQ]+3caY] 8Oc`ZO`WbhO`S\ /ÙWbOZ^S\ HS`PWbhc <OUcaWO ! ^ ³ 7\T]`[S+Bf]abS\O) & :Oa [SRWROa RS ^SàSQcQW \ g ^`]VWPWQW \ bOfObWdO RSZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa aS VO\ []abÒR] W\STWQOQSa RSaRS _cS aS W\WQWO`]\ ZOa ^]Z bWQOa `S^`SaWdOa VOQS \]dS\bO O ]a 1][] OZbS`\ObWdO ÔÒ Q]\aSUcW` [Og]` STWQOQWO aS Sabt\ O^ZWQO\R] \cSdOa [Sb]R]Z]U Oa POaOROa S\ ZO ^`SdS\QW \ O bÒd{a RSZ Q]\]QW[WS\b] RS Z]a `WSaU]a _cS S\bÒ O ac Q]\ac[] g SZ SabOPZSQW[WS\b] RS c\]a Z [WbSa aOZcROPZSa 7A0< &" "#% '"' Vbb^( eee UWhOSbfS SXUd ScaYORW \Sb W\T]`[OQW]\ ^cPZWQOQW]\SaM]dRM W\TMbf]abS\O SaM' !! ORXc\b]a bf]abS\O& ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 5 [Sh 8Sa a 3Z O[]` S\ ZO a]QWSROR RSZ `WSaU]( c\O bS\bObWdO SRcQObWdO 8Sa a 5 [Sh ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( 3Z @]c`S " %! ^ ³ /^S`bcÒ :O OÔ`WQW \ RS ZO ObÒQQW \ S\ Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa Sa []bWd] RS `STZSfW \ a]P`S ZO W\QWRS\QWO S\ ZO OR]^QW \ RS QWS`b]a `]ZSa g ÔcbOa RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b] _cS RO\ ]`WUS\ O ZO dW]ZS\QWO g SZ [OZbÒb] S\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa OTSQbWdOa 7A0< &" %'%$ & 8]`\OROa a]P`S SZ 1O[PW] A]QWOZ S\ 3aÔ O # ASdWZZO 3Z QO[PW] a]QWOZ S\ 3aÔ O :cWa 3\`W_cS /Z]\a] 0S\Wb] ISb OZ K) Q]]`RW\OR] ^]` 3RcO`R] 0S`WQOb /ZOabcSg ³ ASdWZZO( 1S\b`] RS 3abcRW]a /\ROZcQSa 1]\aSXS` O RS ZO >`SaWRS\QWO 8c\bO RS /\ROZcQ O $ !%" ^ ) ! Q[

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

@SQ]US ZOa ^]\S\QWOa g Q]\QZcaW]\Sa RSZ aS[W\O`W] a]P`S SZ [Wa[] b bcZ] QSZSPÒR] S\ ASdWZZO =T`SQS c\O dWaW \ ^ZcÒZ RSZ Q]\Xc\b] RS bÒ\aT]`[OQW]\Sa g RWZS[Oa _cS Sabt\ OTSQbO\R] O ZO a]QWSROR SaÔ ]ZO S\ QcOb`] t[PWb]a( Z]a QO[PW]a S\ ZO TO[WZWO g S\ ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa a]QWOZSa) Z]a QO[PW]a S\ SZ [c\R] RSZ bÒPOX]) Z]a QO[PW]a S\ SZ 3abOR] RS PWS\SabO`) g Z]a QO[PW]a S\ ZO QcZbcÒ 7A0< &" $ % ! 1O`R a AOZdOR]` 3Z RSaQ]\QWS`b] RS ZO SRcQOQW \( ZOa QZOdSa ÔÒ S\bS\RS` SZ Ô^SZ RS ZO TO[WZWO ZO SaQcSZO Z]a dOZ]`Sa Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa ZO bSZSdWaW \ g ZO W\aSUc`WROR RSZ Tcbc`] AOZdOR]` 1O`R a ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( >OWR a % # ^ ) " Q[ ³ 1]\bSfb]a) " /\tZWaWa RS ZOa QOcaOa _cS VO\ ZZSdOR] O ZO ]^W\W \ ^ PZWQO O bS\S` c\ Q]\QS^b] S\`SdSaOR] RSZ aWabS[O SaQ]ZO` g QOS` S\ b ^WQ]a O\bWQcOR]a _cS gO \] aW`dS\ ÔÒ `Sa]ZdS` ZO bÒ\a[WaW \ RSZ Q]\]QW[WS\b] RSPWR] O ZOa \cSdOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa _cS Q]\T]`[O\ SZ S\bÒ[OR] a]QWOZ 7A0< '%& &" "'! ! ! 3Z ZOPS`W\b] RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO( QOcaOa bW^]a g STSQb]a 8]a{ AO\[O`b \ Q]]`R ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( /`WSZ " !$' ^ ( WZ ³ 3abcRW]a a]P`S dW]ZS\QWO) 3\ ZO ^tU " RS ZO QcP ( 1S\b`] @SW\O A]T O ÔÒ SZ 3abcRW] RS ZO DW]ZS\QWO ;O\cOZ _cS OP]`RO ZOa RWTS`S\bSa []ROZWRORSa RS ZO OU`SaW \ O\OZWhO\R] SZ ^]`_c{ g Z]a STSQb]a QOcaOa g Q]\aSQcS\QWOa RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO Q]\bÒ ZO [cXS` Q]\bÒ Z]a \W ]a Q]\bÒ ZOa ^Sà]\Oa [Og]`Sa S\ Z]a RS^]`bSa S\ Z]a [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQW \ S\ ZO ^]Z bWQO ZO dW]ZS\QWO ]ÙO\WhORO {b\WQO g bS``]`WabO S\b`S ]bÒa 7A0< &" !"" %"%# 1O[P`]\S`] At\QVSh /\b]\W] 3Z [Wb] RSZ {fWb] TtQWZ /\b]\W] 1O[P`]\S`] At\QVSh 8Sa a AOab`S 1O``SÒ @SdWabO RS >Oab]ÒZ 8cdS\WZ ³ \ " % TSP`S`] " ) ^ " 7AA< #%% %!F 3Z []RSZ] RS ZO TO[O g RSZ {fWb] TtQWZ aW\ SaTcS`h] Sabt S\ OcUS S\ \cSabÒ a]QWSROR /ZUc\Oa RS ZOa QOcaOa RS SabS TS\ [S\] a]\ ZO TOZbO RS OZbS`\ObWdOa QcZbcÒZSa g RS ]QW] ZOa RSTWQWS\QWOa W\bS`^Sà]\OZSa S\ SZ \ QZS] TO[WZWO` g ZO TOZbO RS OZbS`\ObWdOa ^]Z bWQOa aWS\R] ZO ^`W\QWÔZ d QbW[O ZO XcdS\bcR 3a \SQSaO`WO c\O SRcQOQW \ a ZWRO ÔÒ VOQS` T`S\bS OZ Q`SQWS\bS S[^cXS RS Z]a \cSd]a dOZ]`Sa POaOR]a S\ ZO [Wb][O\ O 1O`RS\OZ RS ZO <cSh ;O` O 3cUS\WO 3Z Ôa] O ZO dWRO ORcZbO( RWZS[Oa g SabÒbSUWOa O\bS SZ S[^ZS] TZSfWPZS ;O` O 3cUS\WO 1O`RS\OZ RS ZO <cSh ³ ;OR`WR( 1S\b`] RS 7\dSabWUOQW]\Sa A]QW]Z UWQOa) AWUZ] FF7 RS 3aÔ O $ ! ' ^ ( bOP U`tT ) Q[ ³ ;]\]UÒT Oa) ! 3Z Ôa] O ZO dWRO ORcZbO ^`SbS\RS `STZSXO` ZOa Q]\SfW]\Sa S\b`S SZ QO[PW] a]QWOZ g ZO Sf^S`WS\QWO W\RWdWRcOZ O\OZWhO\R] ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa a]QWOZSa RS ZO Q`WaWa RS ZO a]QWSROR aOZO`WOZ :]a X dS\Sa a]\ OQb]`Sa S\ ^ZS\] ^`]QSa] RS Q]Z]QOQW \ a]QWOZ aWbcOR]a S\ SZ QS\b`] RSZ RSPObS a]P`S c\O a]QWSROR _cS gO \] aS `SQ]\]QS O a [Wa[O S\ aca SZS[S\b]a Q]\abWbcbWd]a 7A0< &" %"%$ " % !

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

5]\htZSh 2c`] 3\`W_cS 3Z `WSaU] RS dWdW`( ZOa \cSdOa ORWQQW]\Sa RSZ aWUZ] FF7 3\`W_cS 5]\htZSh 2c`] Â³ ;OR`WR( BS[Oa RS 6]g # ! " ^ 1]ZSQQWÂ&#x201E;\ Âµ DWdW` ;SX]`Â¶ :]a \cSd]a dOZ]`Sa a]QWOZSa Sabt\ W\QWRWS\R] S\ ZO OÔ`WQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS ORWQQW]\Sa _cS RO\ c\ \cSd] ^S`TWZ O Z]a U`c^]a a]QWOZSa g `S_cWS`S\ ZO O^ZWQOQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS bSÒ^WOa O^`]^WOROa ÔÒ SdWbO` QOS` S\ aca `SRSa 7A0< &" &"$ " # # ;]ÒRWZZ] ;]ÒRWZZ] 4OPWt\ 3aQS\O`W]a RS dW]ZS\QWO g Q]\TZWQb] 4OPWt\ ;]ÒRWZZ] ;]ÒRWZZ] >OR`Sa g ;OSab`]a Â³ \ ! & aS^b & ) ^ % ! 7AA< "$%' /\tZWaWa RS ZOa RWTS`S\bSa QOcaOa _cS ^`]d]QO\ ZO dW]ZS\QWO XcdS\WZ VOQWS\R] VW\QO^W{ S\ Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS ^`]bSQQWÂ&#x201E;\ g RS `WSaU] aSO\ {ab]a RS QO`tQbS` ^Sà]\OZ TO[WZWO` U`cÔZ ] RSZ S\b]`\] O[PWS\bOZ 3aÔQW] Q]\ab`cQQWÂ&#x201E;\ g QWcRORO\ O DWQS\bS 7\UZORO ISb OZ K 3\b`SXÂ&#x201E;dS\Sa Â³ \ '" XcZW] OU]ab] aS^bWS[P`S $ ) ^ ! !% 7AA< 13A '$& ;]\]U`tTWQ] 1]\bWS\S( :O `Sd]ZcQWÂ&#x201E;\ c`PO\O( SaÔQW] ^Â&#x2030;PZWQ] g QWcRORO\ O 8]`RW 0]`XO) 8Â&#x201E;dS\Sa ZObW\]a RSa[O`QOR]a RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO AO\RÒ >SRÒZa) 2S PO\RO Q`W[W\OZ O ]ÙO\WhOQWÂ&#x201E;\ XcdS\WZ 4OPWO\ ;]VSRO\] :O XcdS\bcR Sabt acT`WS\R] c\ ^`]QSa] RS QO[PW] _cS ZS ]PZWUO O PcaQO` \cSd]a QOcQSa RS OTW`[OQWÂ&#x201E;\ RS ^Sà]\OZWROR _cS ZS VOUO\ aSUcW` Ô`bWQWÔ\R] S\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] a]QWOZ RS ZO Q][c\WROR g O^ZWQO\R] aca \cSd]a dOZ]`Sa ;O`bW\ AS]O\S 5S[O 3abÒbSUWOa RS OT`]\bO[WS\b] g `WSaU] S\ ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO 5S[O ;O`b \ AS]O\S) RW`WUWR] ^]` ;O` O 8]a{ 2 Oh /UcOR] Â³ ;OR`WR( C\WdSàWROR 1][^ZcbS\aS 4OQcZbOR RS >aWQ]Z]U O ! # % ^ ( bOP UÒT ) ! Q[ BSaWa R]Qb]ÒZ C\Wd 1][^ZcbS\aS :O OR]ZSaQS\QWO Sa c\O SbOÔ RS QO[PW]a g RWTWQcZbORSa g O dSQSa Q]\ZZSdO ^`]PZS[Oa Sa^SQWOZSa _cS RWTWQcZbO\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] Q][] a]\ ZO [Og]` Sf^]aWQWÂ&#x201E;\ O ZO dW]ZS\QWO SZ W\Q`S[S\b] S W\WQW] QORO dSh [ta bS[^Ò\] RSZ Q]\ac[] RS acabO\QWOa ] SZ Oc[S\b] RS Z]a bÒab]`\]a OZW[S\bO`W]a S\ ZO Â&#x2030;ZbW[O R{QORO :O W\dSabWUOQWÂ&#x201E;\ aS Q][^]\S RS c\O Ô`bS bSÂ&#x201E;`WQO g ]bÒ ^`tQbWQO S\ ZO _cS aS [cSabÒ SZ SabcRW] `SOZWhOR] a]P`S ZOa Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] RS c\O [cSabÒ RS OR]ZSaQS\bSa RS ZO 1][c\WROR RS ;OR`WR g ZOa ^]aWPZSa SabÒbSUWOa RS OT`]\bO[WS\b] S[]QW]\OZ @SUZS`] @ORO ;S`QSRSa 4OQb]`Sa RS SfQZcaWÂ&#x201E;\ a]QWOZ S\ Z]a XÂ&#x201E;dS\Sa ;S`QSRSa @SUZS`] @ORO ;WaWÂ&#x201E;\ X]dS\ Â³ \ !" Xc\W] # ) ^ # $ 7AA< $'$ $"! / RWTS`S\QWO RS US\SÒQW]\Sa O\bS`W]`Sa Z]a XÂ&#x201E;dS\Sa RS V]g dS\ [ta Q][] c\ ^SZWU`] RS SfQZcaWÂ&#x201E;\ a]QWOZ \] ZZSUO` O OZQO\hO` ZOa Sf^SQbObWdOa US\SÒROa S\ SZ S\b]`\] _cS SZ VSQV] RS QOS` S\ Q]bOa RS [OÙW\OQWÂ&#x201E;\ Vbb^( eee [WaW]\X]dS\ ]Ù 2STOcZbM Oa^ /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb]

8Â&#x201E;dS\Sa g USabWÂ&#x201E;\ RSZ `WSaU]

4OQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] g RS ^`]bSQQW \ T`S\bS OZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa( 6OQWO c\ []RSZ] Sf^ZWQObWd] RSZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa S\ X dS\Sa RS ZO 1/>D 1]]`RW\OQW \ g RW`SQQW \( 7\abWbcb] 2Scab] RS 2`]U]RS^S\RS\QWOa C\WdSàWROR RS 2Scab] ) @SROQQW \ g bÒPOX] RS QO[^]( BS`SaO :OSaÔRO 7]aSPO 7ÒcÙW g 3ZWaOPSbS /` abSUcW ³ 0WZPO]( 7\abWbcb] 2Scab] RS 2`]U]RS^S\RS\QWOa " !' ^ ( bOPZ TWU 0WPZW]U` ( ^ !# !' 7\bS\bO Q]\b`WPcW` O ZO Q`SOQW \ RS c\ []RSZ] bS `WQ] _cS ^cSRO O``]XO` Zch O ZO ^`SUc\bO RS ^]`_c{ OZUc\]a X dS\Sa Q]\ac[S\ g OPcaO\ RS ZOa R`]UOa g ]b`]a \] /RS[ta ^`SbS\RS []abÒ` _cW{\Sa g Q [] a]\ Z]a X dS\Sa RSZ >OWa DOaQ] _cS ZOa Q]\ac[S\ ac ^S`TWZ TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] `SZOQW]\OR]a g TOQb]`Sa _cS ^`]bSUS\ AW\ S[POÙ] \] a Z] ZO RWa^]\WPWZWROR RS R`]UOa QWS`bOa `SZOQW]\Sa TO[WZWO`Sa `SacZbOR]a OQOR{[WQ]a ] VtPWb]a RS ]QW] a]\ Z] _cS ^`SRWa^]\S\ OZ ca] RS R`]UOa aW\] QWS`bOa Q][PW\OQW]\Sa RS SaOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa Vbb^( eee UWhOSbfS SXUd ScaYORW \Sb `" %% Sa Q]\bS\WR]a W\T]`[OQW]\ %&! SaM " ORXc\b]a 4/1B=@M@73A5=M>@=B3117=<M1=;AC;=M2@=5/ ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 4OQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] g TOQb]`Sa RS ^`]bSQQW \ S\ SZ OR]ZSaQS\bS( ZO `SaWZWS\QWO []RSÒ 8]aS^ 1]`\SZZu W 1O\OZa ³ Ia Z K( 7\bS`âW_cWa " d ^tU dO` ( U`tT >]\S\QWOa ^`SaS\bOROa OZ D 1]\U`Sa] DW`bcOZ RS >aW_cWOb` O 7\bS`âW_cWa " QSZSPÒR] RSZ OZ & RS TSP`S`] 1]\bWS\S( C\ \cSd] S\T]_cS S\ZO ^`SdS\QW \ S\ ZO aOcR W\bSUÒZ RS Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa( ZO `SaWZWS\QWO 8]aS^ 1]`\SZZu W 1O\OZa ÈZSf :ZcaS\b W 5cWZZO[Sb /a^SQb]a US\SÒZSa RS ZO aOZcR S\ ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO g ZO XcdS\bcR( TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] g RS ^`]bSQQW \ 8]aS^ 1]`\SZZu W 1O\OZa ÈZSf :ZcaS\b W 5cWZZO[Sb /R]ZSaQS\QWO `WSaU] g ^`]bSQQW \( `SaWZWS\QWO 5cabOd] / 5WÒ`R @SaWZWS\QWO( RS _c{ SabO[]a VOPZO\R] QcO\R] VOPZO[]a RS SZZO 2WSU] AOZOhO` @]XOa 3abcRW] RSZ Q]\QS^b] RS aOZcR W\bSUÒZ RSZ OR]ZSaQS\bS Qcg] ]PXSbWd] Sa _cS SZZ]a ^cSRO\ RSa^ZSUO` b]ROa aca QOÔQWRORSa T aWQOa âWQ]Z UWQOa OTSQbWdOa S W\bSZSQbcOZSa Oa Q][] `SRcQW` ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] âWQ]a]QWOZ O ZOa _cS aS Sf^]\S\ RS [O\SÒ Sa^SQWOZ _cWS\Sa dWdS\ S\ aWbcOQW]\Sa [S\]a TOd]ÒPZSa Vbb^( eee âW_cWOb`WO Q][ W\bS`âW_cWa " ! " /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] : ^Sh /ÒcX] 0ZO\QO 4OQb]`Sa Sf^ZWQObWd]a RS ZO OQQWRS\bOZWROR S\ X dS\Sa( c\ O\tZWaWa RS ZO W\dSabWUOQW \ 0ZO\QO : ^Sh /ÒcX] /[Ô`] =aQO ASU]dWO @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR ³ \ %' RWQ % ) ^ %# &' 7AA< "!$" @SdWaW \ RS Z]a SabcRW]a a]P`S ZOa TOQSbOa Sf^ZWQObWdOa RS Z]a OQQWRS\bSa ZOP]ÒZSa g RS b`tTWQ] S\b`S Z]a X dS\Sa ^`SabO\R] Sa^SQWOZ ObS\QW \ OZ Ô^SZ RS ZOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa ^Sà]\OZSa dO`WOPZSa a]QW]RS[]U`tTWQOa g RS ^Sà]\OZWROR ^S`QS^QW]\Sa OQbWbcRSa Q`SS\QWOa Q][] QOcaO\bSa RSZ [Og]` `WSaU] RS OQQWRS\bOPWZWROR RS Z]a X dS\Sa Vbb^( eee W\XcdS [bOa Sa W\XcdS Q]\bS\WR]a R]e\Z]ORObb OQbW]\-WR+%%$ '"""& /QQSa] bSfb] Q][^ZSb]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

>{`Sh 0O``S`] ASÙW] / 4OQb]`Sa ^`]bSQb]`Sa RSZ acWQWRW] S\ Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa ASÙW] / >{`Sh 0O``S`] ³ IA Z K( 7\bS`âW_cWa $ " ^ 2SaQ`WPS Z]a ÒaU]a RS ^Sà]\OZWROR RS Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa Q]\ `WSaU] RS acWQWRW] g ZOa aWbcOQW]\Sa S\ ZOa _cS ^cSRS\ RSaS[P]QO` S\ c\O Q`WaWa acWQWRO ÔÒ VOQS` VW\QO^W{ S\ Z]a TOQb]`Sa ^`]bSQb]`Sa RS Sa]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a Vbb^( eee âW_cWOb`WO Q][ W[^`W[W` Oba- "&&& /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] AOZdOR /\b]\W 4]`SdS` g]c\U( ¥DcZ\SÒPWZWROR a]QWOZ XcdS\WZ ] dcZ\SÒPWZWROR a]QWOZ US\SÒQW]\OZ- /\b]\W AOZdOR g >Oc AS`ÒQO\b ³ I;OR`WRK( I4SRSÒQW \ 3aÔ ]ZO RS A]QW]Z]U OK " " V 2]Qc[S\b] SZSQb` \WQ] 1][c\WQOQW \ ^`SaS\bORO OZ D777 1]\U`Sa] 3aÔ ]Z RS A]QW]Z]U O) 5`c^] RS bÒPOX] %( A]QW]Z]U O RS ZO SROR g QWQZ] dWbOZ) Q]]`RW\OR]` :cWa 5O``WR] ;SRW\O /\OZWhO Z]a STSQb]a RSZ \cSd] Q]\bSfb] RS ZO UZ]POZWhOQW \ a]P`S SZ O\tZWaWa g Q]\QS^bcOZWhOQW \ RSZ Q]ZSQbWd] X]dS\ acUW`WS\R] ZO ^{`RWRO RS cbWZWROR RS ZO QObSU]` O µX]dS\¶ S\ TOd]` RS ZO QObSU]` O µUS\SÒQW \¶ 3\b`S ]bÒa Q]aOa aS ^ZO\bSO ZO \SQSaWROR RS RWabW\UcW` ZO RWTS`S\bS W\QWRS\QWO RS Z]a STSQb]a RS SROR US\SÒQW \ g QWQZ] SQ]\ [WQ] a]P`S Z]a RWabW\b]a aSU[S\b]a a]QWOZSa RS ZO XcdS\bcR Vbb^( eee TSa eSP ]Ù SRORgQWQZ]dWbOZ Q][c\WQOQW]\a 4]`SdS` G]c\U ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] @]dWÒ 8]aS^ 5SabW \ RSZ ^ZOQS` g RSZ `WSaU]( ] Q [] S\aS O` O RWaT`cbO` ZO \]QVS g \] ^S`SQS` S\ SZ W\bS\b] Ocb]`Sa 8]aS^ @]dWÒ g 3RcO`R] 6WROZU] ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( /a]QWOQW \ 0WS\SabO` g 2SaO``]ZZ] 3\SÙg 1]\b`]Z I !K I&K V >]\S\QWO ^`SaS\bORO O ZOa D777 8]`\OROa a]P`S >`SdS\QW \ RS 2`]U]RS^S\RS\QWOa RS /ZQ]`Q \ QSZSPÒROa S\ \]dWS[P`S RS ! AS ^ZO\bSO ZO \SQSaWROR RS `SRWaS O` Z]a SaÔQW]a RS ]QW] ÔÒ Q]\dS`bW`Z]a S\ h]\Oa [ta aSUcÒa g aOZcROPZSa Oa Q][] Q`SO` ÔÒ Z]a X dS\Sa Uc Oa dtZWROa ÔÒ RWaT`cbO` O Ô`bW` RS c\O USabW \ [ta STWQOh RSZ ^ZOQS` g Z]a `WSaU]a Oa]QWOR]a OZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa S\bS\RWS\R] _cS {abOa aWS[^`S VO\ bS\WR] c\ Ô^SZ W[^]`bO\bS S\ SZ S\b]`\] TSabWd] 5c O ÔÒ ZO RSbSQQW \ S W\bS`dS\QW \ bS[^Ò\O Q]\ [S\]`Sa S\ `WSaU] 1]]`RW\OR]`Sa( /\O 5]\htZSh ;S\{\RSh 8]a{ @O[ \ 4S`\t\RSh 6S`[WRO @]PS`b] ASQORSa DWZZO) 1]ZSUW] =TWQWOZ RS >aWQ Z]U]a ³ 5WX \( 1]ZSUW] =TWQWOZ RS >aWQ Z]U]a RSZ >`W\QWÔR] RS /abc`WOa " & ^ ( bOPZOa 0WPZW]UÒT O =T`SQS ÔcbOa ÔÒ ZO WRS\bWTWQOQW \ ^`SQ]h RS [S\]`Sa S\ aWbcOQW]\Sa dcZ\SÒPZSa g ^`]b]Q]Z]a RS W\bS`dS\QW \ STWQOh S\ RWabW\b]a t[PWb]a( ZO SaQcSZO Z]a aS`dWQW]a a]QWOZSa SZ aWabS[O XcRWQWOZ SbQ 3\ SabS Q]ZSQbWd] SZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa acSZS aS` c\O Q]\RcQbO RS `WSaU] [ta _cS aS O ORO O ]bÒa g T`SQcS\bS[S\bS ZOa OUÒdO Q][] ^cSRS\ aS` SZ TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` Z]a S[POÒh]a \] RSaSOR]a ] SZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] dW]ZS\b] S\b`S ]bÒa 7A0< &" ' !% % # %

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

=aQO ASU]dWO /[Ô`] 7\QZcaW \ a]QWOZ [S`QOR] RS bÒPOX] g aOZcR ZOP]ÒZ( ^Sà^SQbWdOa a]P`S SZ Sab`{a ZOP]ÒZ S\ Z]a X dS\Sa SaÔ ]ZSa /[Ô`] =aQO ASU]dWO AOUÒQW] ASUOR] At\QVSh 1OPShcR] 4Ò\QWaQ] 8OdWS` 5O`Q O 1OabWZZO ³ ;OR`WR( 7\XcdS $ !' ^ ( bOPZ ) ! Q[ 3RWQW \ SZSQb` \WQO :Oa RWTWQcZbORSa ÔÒ Z]UÒ` g [O\bS\S` c\ S[^ZS] SabOPZS ÔÒ VOQS` T`S\bS O ZOa \cSdOa SfWUS\QWOa RS Z]a ^cSab]a RS bÒPOX] g ÔÒ O^]`bO` ZO ^]ZWdOZS\QWO _cS aS SfWUS S\ c\O SQ]\][ O bSQ\]Z UWQO OdO\hORO aS c\S\ O ]b`]a TOQb]`Sa Q][] SZ ^`SQW] RS ZO dWdWS\RO ] SZ TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` _cS Q]\TWUcÒ\ c\ QO[^] RS XcSU] S\ SZ _cS Z]a X dS\Sa bWS\S\ _cS RSaO``]ZZO` ac ^`]gSQb] ^Sà]\OZ Vbb^( eee W\XcdS [bOa Sa W\XcdS Q]\bS\WR]a WbS[ OQbW]\-WR+$%"# &'$& [S\c7R+ ! $&% % /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 6S``SÒ >]\QS ;O` O A]ZSROR 7\RWdWRcOZWhOQW \ a]QWOZ g QO[PW]a RS[]U`tTWQ]a( ¥VOQWO c\O aSUc\RO bÒ\aWQW \ RS[]Q`tbWQO-( SabcRW] Q][ÔÒR] OQS`QO RS ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa S\b`S dOZ]`Sa g QO[PW]a RS[]U`tTWQ] TO[WZWO`Sa O TW\Sa RSZ aWUZ] FF ;O` O A]ZSROR 6S``SÒ >]\QS ³ ;OR`WR( 1S\b`] RS 7\dSabWUOQW]\Sa A]QW]Z UWQOa % %& ^ ) Q[ ³ ;]\]UÒT Oa) ! AS Q]\bÒabO ZO bS]` O RS ZO aSUc\RO bÒ\aWQW \ RS[]U`tTWQO O SaQOZO [c\RWOZ `SZOQW]\O\R] Z]a ^`]QSa]a RS W\RWdWRcOZWhOQW \ a]QWOZ Q]\ Z]a QO[PW]a RS[]U`tTWQ]a g TO[WZWO`Sa S\ ZO TSQc\RWROR SZ [Ob`W[]\W] g SZ RWd]`QW] 3Z Q]\QS^b] RS µW\RWdWRcOZWhOQW \¶ Sa O\OZWhOR] O Ô`bW` RS c\ ^`]QSaO[WS\b] RS ZO 3\QcSabO ;c\RWOZ RS DOZ]`Sa RcÒ\bS ZO R{QORO RS Z]a \]dS\bO AS VO cbWZWhOR] c\O [cSabÒ RS [ta RS aSaS\bO Ô aSa RS b]R] SZ [c\R] _cS `S^`SaS\bO\ ^`W\QWÔZ[S\bS OZ [c\R] RSaO``]ZZOR] g ]QQWRS\bOZ ORS[ta RS 3c`]Ô RSZ 3abS /[{`WQO :ObW\O g OZUc\]a Ô aSa OaWtbWQ]a 7A0< &" %"%$ " & ;O` \ At\QVSh ;O\cSZ 8 dS\Sa O\ROZcQSa RS h]\Oa c`PO\Oa( SabcRW] RS Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] RSZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] dW]ZS\b] ;O\cSZ ;O` \ At\QVSh ;O`Q]a @WdS`] 1cORÒR] ³ ASdWZZO( 7\abWbcb] /\ROZch RS ZO 8cdS\bcR ! '! ^ ³ 7\dSabWUOQW \ g 8cdS\bcR) ! BÒPOX] _cS aS ]QcÔ RS O\OZWhO` SZ ]`WUS\ RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO XcdS\WZ bO\b] S\ 3aÔ O Q][] S\ /\ROZcQ O >O`SQS QZO`] _cS Sa SZ Q]\bSfb] a]QWOZ g âWQ]Z UWQ] [ta _cS SZ QO`tQbS` ^`]^W] RS ZO ^Sà]\O SZ _cS RSTW\S ZOa Q]\RcQbOa OU`SaWdOa 3Z S\b]`\] TO[WZWO` SZ \WdSZ SRcQObWd] W\TZcS\QWOa RSZ QW\S ZO bSZSdWaW \ ] Z]a dWRS]XcSU]a a]\ SabcRWOR]a Q][] ^]aWPZSa US\SÒR]`Sa RS dW]ZS\QWO 7A0< &" &%$! % ! 0S\RWb @S\{ 8 dS\Sa S\ aWbcOQW \ RS RSadS\bOXO a]QWOZ( ^]Z bWQOa RS bÒ\aWQW \ S\b`S ZO Q]\ab`cQQW \ a]QWOZ g ZOa \SQSaWRORSa RS c\O XcdS\bcR dcZ\SÒPZS @S\{ 0S\RWb g 2S`[]b Ab]YSa @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR ³ \ $# Xc\W] " ) ^ # ! 7AA< "!$" 0WPZW]UÒT O

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

3Z bÒbO[WS\b] SRcQObWd] RS X dS\Sa RSaTOd]`SQWR]a W[^ZWQO c\O RSTW\WQW \ QZOÒ RS Z]a RWTS`S\bSa bW^]a RS U`c^]a _cS ^cSRS\ S\bÒ` O T]`[O` Ô`bS RS RWQVO RS\][W\OQW \ g QOZWPÒ` SZ `WSaU] RS Q]\Tc\RW` c\]a Q]\ ]b`]a g Q]\aSUcW` SZ `SacZbOR] Q]\bÒ`W] RS Z] _cS aS ^`SbS\RS Vbb^( eee [bOa Sa W\XcdS PWPZW] `SdWabOa ^RTa \c[S`]$# bS[Oa" ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 0`SeS` :OcÒ 8 dS\Sa S\ aWbcOQW \ RS `WSaU]( ZO Tc\QW \ RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS QOZWTWQOQW]\Sa Q][] d O ÔÒ TOQWZWbO` ZO W\Q]`^]ÒQW \ OZ [c\R] RSZ bÒPOX] :OcÒ 0`SeS` ³ 5W\SPÒ( =TWQW\O 7\bS`\OQW]\OZ RSZ BÒPOX] # $! ^ ) ! Q[ ³ AYWZZa 2]Qc[S\b] RS BÒPOX]) ' DSàW \ bÒRcQWRO RSZ W\UZ{a dS` @ : %& $ :Oa QWTÒa RS RSaS[^ZS] g RS S[^ZS] ^`SQO`W] S\b`S Z]a X dS\Sa a]\ OZO`[O\bSa >O`bWS\R] RS _cS ZO SRcQOQW \ g ZO T]`[OQW \ a]\ d Oa W[^]`bO\bSa ÔÒ OP]`RO` ac S[^ZSOPWZWROR S\ SabS bÒPOX] aS Oa^WÒ O OP]`RO` ZO QcSabW \ RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS QOZWTWQOQW]\Sa ÔÒ Z]a X dS\Sa S\ aWbcOQW \ RS `WSaU] S\b`S Z]a _cS ^`SaS\bO\ c\O dcZ\SÒPWZWROR SQ]\ [WQO ] acT`S\ SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ >OÒ SZZ] aS VO\ PcaQOR] SXS[^Z]a O^`]^WOR]a RS ^`]UÒ[Oa g ^`]gSQb]a RS T]`[OQW \ _cS VOgO\ Z]UÒR] WRS\bWTWQO` O Z]a X dS\Sa dcZ\SÒPZSa _cS aS VOgO\ ZZSdOR] O ZO ^`tQbWQO g _cS VOgO\ SdOZcOR] aca W\WQWObWdOa 7A0< ' ! $ #$ Vbb^( eee WZ] ]Ù ^cPZWQ S\UZWaV S[^Z]g[S\b gSbb R]e\Z]OR e^ 'a^ ^RT /QQSa] bSfb] Q][^ZSb] DSUO 3\`W_cS 8 dS\Sa T`S\bS O ZO ^`SQO`WSROR 3\`W_cS DSUO >S`TWZSa ³ \ Xc\W] $ ) ^ $ 7AA< !! % ! :O aWbcOQW \ ZOP]ÒZ RS Z]a X dS\Sa S\ 3aÔ O aS RSabOQO RS ZO RSZ `Sab] RS ZO C\W \ 3c`]^SO ^]` ZO OZbO bOaO RS bS[^]ÒZWROR _cS VO ZZSdOR] O `SOZWhO` `ST]`[Oa Q]\ SZ Q]\aS\a] RS ZOa Ô`bSa W\d]ZcQÒROa ASUcÒ ;]ÒZSa ;O\cSZ 8 dS\Sa g ORcZb]a Q]\ ^`]PZS[Oa RS Q]\RcQbO( RSaO``]ZZ] RS Q][^SbS\QWOa a]QWOZSa ;O\cSZ ASUcÒ ;]ÒZSa ³ ;OR`WR( <O`QSO % !! ^ ) & Q[ ³ A]QW]QcZbcÒZ =T`SQS c\O aS`WS RS OQbWdWRORSa O^ZWQOROa Q]\ {fWb] S\b`S U`c^]a RS X dS\Sa Q]\ ^`]PZS[Oa ^Sà]\OZSa Q]ZSQbWd]a SfQZcWR]a ] U`c^]a RSaSab`cQbcÒR]a a]QWOZ[S\bS 4OQWZWbO SZ _cS _cWS\Sa `SOZWhO\ ZOa aSaW]\Sa ^`]^cSabOa aS W[^ZW_cS\ S\ SZZOa Z]UÒ\R] Oa [SX]Ò` aca VOPWZWRORSa a]QWOZSa [SRWO\bS SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS aca ^`]^WOa TOQcZbORSa ^Sà]\OZSa bO\b] RSaRS SZ ^c\b] RS dWabO Q]U\WbWd] Q][] S[]QW]\OZ g []ÒZ ÓbWZ ÔÒ bÒPOXOR]`Sa a]QWOZSa âWQ Z]U]a g SRcQOR]`Sa _cS bÒPOXO\ S\ QS\b`]a RS [S\]`Sa ^`WaW]\Sa U`c^]a RS QOZZS ] S\ SRcQOQW \ aSQc\RO`WO Q]\ OZc[\]a Q]\ RWTWQcZbORSa Sa^SQWOZSa 7A0< '%& &" %% #"# # 8 dS\Sa g SabWZ]a RS dWRO( dOZ]`Sa g `WSaU]a S\ Z]a X dS\Sa c`PO\]a 2][W\U] 1][Oa /`\Oc Q]]`RW\OR]` ISb OZ K ³ ;OR`WR( 7\XcdS 4OR ! !# ^ 2SaQ`WPS Z]a SabWZ]a RS dWRO [ta QOÒQbS` abWQ]a RS Z]a X dS\Sa SaÔ ]ZSa ZO RWab`WPcQW \ RS ac bWS[^] _c{ VOQS\ O QORO V]Ò RSZ R O R \RS g Q [] Z]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

VOQS\ g Sf^ZWQO Q [] aS ^`]RcQS c\O W\TZcS\QWO [cbcO S\b`S ZO T]`[O RS dS` ZO dWRO g RS dWdW`ZO 1]\QZcgS Q]\ ZO WRSO RS _cS RSbS`[W\OR]a Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a g OQbWbcRSa Q]\QS\bÒ\ `WSaU]a Ô`bWQcZO`Sa 7A0< &" '# "& & F 8 dS\Sa g `SaWZWS\QWO /\\O 4]`{a ISb OZ K ;WaW \ X]dS\ ³ \ !%% Xc\W] & ) ^ # $# 7AA< $'$ $"! ;]\]U`tTWQ] 1]\bWS\S( >SROU]U O SRcQOQW \ g `SaWZWS\QWO /\\O 4]`{a :O ^]bS\QWO RS ZO VWS`PO ^Wa]bSORO 8cZW] GOU S 1O\bSÒ 1]\abcW` ZO `SaWZWS\QWO S\ ZO ^`tQbWQO SRcQObWdO >OQ] : ^Sh 8W[{\Sh >OÒ RSaO``]ZZO` g Q]\ab`cW` ZO `SaWZWS\QWO S\ ZO ^`tQbWQO SRcQObWdO aS aS OZO\ c\ Q]\Xc\b] RS ^`]^cSabOa _cS aS OU`cÔ\ S\ b]`\] O Z]a TOQb]`Sa _cS Q]\TWUcÒ\ ZO `SaWZWS\QWO( ^]bS\QWO` SZ O^]g] a]QWOZ ZO Ocb]SabW[O g ZOa Q][^SbS\QWOa ^Sà]\OZSa ZO QOÔQWROR RS RO` aS\bWR] O ZO dWRO SZ ]^bW[Wa[] g SZ aS\bWR] RSZ Vc[]` 3Z SRcQOR]` \SQSaWbO [O\bS\S` c\O OQbWbcR RS Q]\TWO\hO S\ SZ aS` Vc[O\] _cS ZS ZZSdS O c\O ]^QW \ [O`QORO ^]` SabÒbSUWOa W\bSUÒR]Òa g \] RS SfQZcaW \ :O ORWQQW \ O 7\bS`\Sb g OZ [ dWZ( ¥[]RO ] bÒab]`\]- FOdWS` At\QVSh 1O`P]\SZZ ISb OZ K /RWQQW]\Sa ³ d]Z \ ) ^ "' #' 7AA< " "&" 0WPZW]U` ( ^ #$ #' AS RSaQ`WPS\ Z]a a \b][Oa RSZ ca] \]QWd] RS 7\bS`\Sb g RSZ [ dWZ SfbÒ R]a O bÒd{a RS W\dSabWUOQW]\Sa ^cPZWQOROa S\b`S '' g # AS Q]\QZcgS _cS SZ ca] SfQSaWd] RS 7\bS`\Sb `S^`SaS\bO c\ bÒab]`\] [S\bOZ RS bW^] ORWQbWd] _cS ^cSRS OTSQbO` a]P`S b]R] O ^Sà]\Oa Q]\ \SQSaWRORSa S[]QW]\OZSa Sa^SQWOZSa g O X dS\Sa g OR]ZSaQS\bSa / RWTS`S\QWO RS 7\bS`\Sb SZ ca] RSaORO^bObWd] RSZ [ dWZ ^cSRS ZZSUO` O aS` c\ OPca] ^S`] \] c\O ORWQQW \ ^]`_cS \] aS ^`]RcQS\ \W ZOa OZbSÒQW]\Sa S[]QW]\OZSa `t^WROa \W SZ XcSU] RS WRS\bWRORSa _cS ^cSRS\ ^`]RcQWàS S\ QVOba g XcSU]a RS `]Z S\ Z \SO Vbb^( eee ORWQQW]\Sa Sa TWZSa AO\QVSh 1O`P]\SZZ ^RTT ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] :O QcOZWTWQOQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ PtaWQO( Q][^SbS\QWOa ÔÒ ZO W\QZcaW \ a]QW]ZOP]ÒZ RS X dS\Sa ;W\WabS`W] RS 3RcQOQW \ g 1WS\QWO ASQ`SbO` O 5S\SÒZ RS 3RcQOQW \ @SdWabO RS 3RcQOQW \ ³ \ !" aS^bWS[P`S RWQWS[P`S $ ) ^ ' ## 7AA< !" & & ;]\]U`tTWQ] 1]\bWS\S( :O T]`[OQW \ ÔÒ SZ S[^ZS] RS Z]a X dS\Sa aW\ UÒRcOR]( SRcQOQW \ QOÔQWbOQW \ g a]QWOZWhOQW \ ÔÒ ZO W\bSUÒQW \ a]QWOZ 4S`\O\R] ;O`VcS\RO 4ZcWft) 3\b`S SZ TÒQOa] SaQ]ZO` g ZOa RWTWQcZbORSa RS W\aS`QW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ( ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR RS Z]a X dS\Sa aW\ T]`[OQW \ S\ SZ W\WQW] RS ZO a]QWSROR RSZ Q]\]QW[WS\b] 6S\`W 3QYS`b) 3abÒbSUWOa aWab{[WQOa g acPXSbWdOa RS bÒ\aWQW \ ZOP]ÒZ RS Z]a X dS\Sa S\ /ÙS\bW\O 3Z Ô^SZ RS Z]a RWa^]aWbWd]a RS T]`[OQW \ ÔÒ SZ S[^ZS] 1ZOcRWO 8OQW\b] :]a ^`]UÒ[Oa RS SRcQOQW \ bO[PW{\ RSPS\ Q]\bS[^ZO` O Z]a U`c^]a RS OZc[\]a _cS ^]` ZOa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa _cS aSO\ \] Z]UÒ\ W\bSUÒàS S\ SZ aWabS[O PtaWQ] RS SRcQOQW \ g _cS aW \] aS ZSa ]T`SQS ]bÒ ]^]`bc\WROR ^cSRS\ dSàS OP]QOR]a O ZO [OÙW\OQW \ g SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ Vbb^( eee `SdWabOSRcQOQW]\ [SQ Sa `S!" M & Vb[ /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

:O QcZbcÒ RS ZOa R`]UOa S\ ZO a]QWSROR RSZ `WSaU] <WQY 6SObVS` ISb OZ K) IbÒRcQQW \ g `SdWaW \ b{Q\WQO /\\O @]R{a Sb OZ K ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( 5`c^ 7UWO I "K #% ^ AS VOPZO RS ZO `SRcQQW \ RS RO ]a Oa]QWOR]a OZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa Q][] c\ W\bS\b] RS [SX]Ò` ZO aOZcR OXS\O g ZOa Q]\aSQcS\QWOa a]QWOZSa g SQ]\ [WQOa RS ZOa acabO\QWOa _cS OZbSÒ\ SZ Vc[]` aW\ \SQSaO`WO[S\bS SfWUW` c\O `SRcQQW \ RSZ Q]\ac[] RS ZOa [Wa[Oa /RS[ta aS RS[cSabÒ ac W\TZcS\QWO S\ ZO ^`SdS\QW \ g S\ SZ bÒbO[WS\b] RS ZOa R`]U]RS^S\RS\QWOa ^]` Ô`bS RS Z]a ^`]TSaW]\OZSa aO\WbO`W]a g ^]` Z]a ZSUWaZOR]`Sa Vbb^( eee [W` Sa ^\R ^cPZWQO ^RT :O QcZbcÒ RS ZOa R`]UOa ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 5O`Q O /ZZS` ;O`bO :O US\SÒQW \ ^`SQO`WO ;O`bO 5O`Q O /ZZS` ³ ;OR`WR( 3a^SX] RS BW\bO $ %% ^ ) " Q[ :]a X dS\Sa aS S\T`S\bO\ O ZO dWRO S\ c\Oa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa RWTS`S\bSa O ZOa RS aca ÔR`Sa ^S`] Q]\ c\Oa RWTWQcZbORSa aW[WZO`Sa _cS ZSa ]PZWUO\ O cbWZWhO` SZ SaTcS`h] g SZ W\US\W] ÔÒ S\Q]\bÒ` ac aWbW] S\ SZ S\UÒ\OXS a]QWOZ 7A0< &" '$ & %& @SUcWZZ] @]aaO\O :O ^S`T]`[ObWdWROR RS ZOa QcZbcÒa XcdS\WZSa @]aaO\O @SUcWZZ] @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR ³ \ $" [O`h] " ) ^ "' #$ 7AA< "!$" 3Z ^`]PZS[O RS ZO Ô`bWQWÔQW \ XcdS\WZ Sa bÒbOR] Q][] c\O `S^`SaS\bOQW \ bSObÒZ S\ ZO _cS W\bS`dWS\S\ Z]a X dS\Sa S\ SZ SaQS\O`W] RS ZOa a]QWSRORSa Q]\bS[^]`t\SOa 3\ SabS Q]\bSfb] Ô`bWQWÔ\ Q][] OQb]`Sa( SZ `S^ZWSUcS RSZ 3abOR] PS\STOQb]` ZO TcS`hO RSZ [S`QOR] Z]a [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQW \ SZ RSaQ`{RWb] RS ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa Ô`bWR]a ^]Z bWQ]a `SZWUW]\Sa aW\RWQOb]a ZO UZ]POZWhOQW \ ZO [WUÒQW \ ZO dW]ZS\QWO Vbb^( eee [bOa Sa W\XcdS PWPZW] `SdWabOa >RTa \c[S`]$" bS[O" ^RT /QQSa] bSfb] Q][^ZSb] :O bÒ\aWQW \ O ZO a]QWSROR `SR ;O\cSZ 1OabSZZa ISb OZ K) 1]ZOP]ÒQW \ RS( ;O` O 7aOPSZ 2 Oh RS 7aZO 0O``g ESZZ[O\ ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( /`WSZ % " ^ ) Q[ ³ :O SÒ RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ S\ 1ObOZc\gO 3abS ^`]gSQb] Sa SZ `SacZbOR] RS c\O W\dSabWUOQW \ a]P`S ZO a]QWSROR RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ O Ô`bW` RSZ QOa] QObOZt\ :O bÒ\aWQW \ O ZO a]QWSROR `SR SabcRWO Z]a STSQb]a RS ZOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa RS ZO W\T]`[OQW \ g ZO Q][c\WQOQW \ S\ \cSabÒ a]QWSROR OQbcOZ bO\b] S\ SZ t[PWb] ^Sà]\OZ Q][] S\ SZ Q]ZSQbWd] 7A0< '%& &" !"" " % ' 5WZ @]R`WUcSh 5S`[t\ :Oa Q]\abSZOQW]\Sa RS RSadS\bOXO aS VOQS\ dWaWPZSa S\ 3aÔ O 5S`[t\ 5WZ @]R` UcSh @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR ³ \ %% Xc\W] % ) ^ ! 7AA< "!$" 2SaQ`W^QW \ RS R]a RS Z]a TS\ [S\]a _cS Sabt\ W\QWRWS\R] Q]\ [Og]` W\bS\aWROR S\ ZO dWRO RS Z]a X dS\Sa SaÔ ]ZSa( SZ OPO\R]\] SaQ]ZO`

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

^`S[Obc`] a \b][O RS `SQVOh] OZ aWabS[O SRcQObWd] g Q][] Q]\aSQcS\QWO SZ S[^ZS] ^`SQO`W] g bS[^]ÒZ _cS ^]\S O Z]a X dS\Sa S\ c\O aWbcOQW \ RS RSadS\bOXO g RSaWUcOZROR a]QWOZ Vbb^( eee W\XcdS [bOa Sa W\XcdS Q]\bS\WR]a R]e\Z]ORObb OQbW]\-WR+ $ &' %!$ /QQSa] bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 4OZQ]\ :WRWO :Oa \cSdOa SaÔ ]ZOa( :] _cS ZOa VWXOa VO\ UO\OR] g ^S`RWR] `Sa^SQb] O aca [OR`Sa :WRWO 4OZQ \ ³ ;OR`WR( :O 3aTSÒ RS Z]a :WP`]a " % ^ ) " Q[ :Oa [cXS`Sa [S\]`Sa RS b`SW\bO O ]a OdO\hO\ ZS\bO[S\bS S\ ZO \cSdO a]QWSROR RS[]Q`tbWQO ^S`] O ^SaO` RS Z] Q]\aSUcWR] g RS ac W\Q]`^]ÒQW \ [OaWdO O ZOa OcZOa ZO RWaQ`W[W\OQW \ S\ SZ bÒPOX] g ZOa RWTWQcZbORSa SQ]\ [WQOa ZSa W[^WRS\ OaS\bOàS ^`]TSaW]\OZ[S\bS :O W\Q][c\WQOQW \ S\ ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa Q]\ Z]a V][P`Sa ZOa `Sa^]\aOPWZWRORSa R][{abWQOa g ZOa RWTWQcZbORSa _cS O \ Q][^]`bO ZO [ObS`\WROR aWUcS\ aWS\R] PO``SÒa S\ SZ ZOÙ] g RWTWQcZb]a] QO[W\] O ZO WUcOZROR 3\ Z]a QOa]a [ta RÒ[tbWQ]a ZO dW]ZS\QWO RS ZO _cS bO\bOa dSQSa a]\ d QbW[Oa aS QSPO WUcOZ[S\bS S\ ZOa X dS\Sa 7A0< &" '%!" % & 8cZWS\\S 9ObWO :S ` ZS RSa T]\Ra R¸OWRSa Ocf XSc\Sa RO\a Z¸W\aS`bW]\ a]QWOZS Sb ^`]TSaaW]\\SZZS RSa XSc\Sa S\ RWTTWQcZb{ 9ObWO 8cZWS\\\S Sb ;c`WSZZS ;]\`]aS @SdcS TÒ\zOWaS RSa OTTOW`Sa a]QWOZSa ³ \ ! XcZW] aS^bWS[P`S " ) ^ " $# 7AA< !# '&# >OÒ OgcRO` O Z]a X dS\Sa S\ RWTWQcZbORSa a]QWOZSa O W\bSUÒàS S\ ZO OQbWdWROR ZOP]ÒZ aS VO\ W\abWbcWR] S\ 4Ò\QWO T]\R]a RS O^]g] S\ OZW[S\bOQW \ bÒ\a^]`bS g T]`[OQW \ _cS ZSa TOd]`ShQO\ S\ ZO P a_cSRO RS c\ [SX]` OQQSa] O ZO \]`[OZWROR a]QWOZ :] _cS SZ bÒPOX] SaQ]\RS( [ObS`WOZSa ÔÒ c\ `S^ZO\bSO[WS\b] RS Z]a O\tZWaWa a]P`S SZ bÒPOX] 0S`\O`R :OVW`S ISb OZ K) Q]]`RW\OQW \ RS 8]ÙS 5O`Q O : ^Sh ISb OZ K ³ ;OR`WR( BÒTWQO\bSa RS acS ]a # &! ^ ³ 0WTc`QOQW]\Sa) :Oa \cSdOa []ROZWRORSa RS bÒPOX] Sabt\ QO[PWO\R] SZ Q]\QS^b] QZtaWQ] RS RWQVO ÔZOPÒ g a]P`Sb]R] ZOa Q]\\]bOQW]\Sa {bWQOa g a]QW]Z UWQOa _cS VO `S^`SaS\bOR] S\ ZO [O\SÒ RS `SZOQW]\OàS SZ V][P`S Q]\ SZ aWabS[O ^`]RcQbWd] O Z] ZOÙ] RS ZO 6Wab]`WO 7A0< &" '!!### $ ' 2tdWZO :S \ =aQO` :]a RSaVS`SROR]a( bÒgSQb]`WOa RS dWRO g \cSdOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa XcdS\WZSa =aQO` 2tdWZO :S \ 4SZW^S 5VWO`R] A]b] 1O`Z]a ;SRÒ\] A]b] ³ DOZÔÒ a]( 172>/ # !# ^ <] Sa ^]aWPZS c\ ^ZS\] RSaO``]ZZ] a]QWOZ aW\ c\O Sab`cQbcÒ SRcQOQW]\OZ g T]`[ObWdO _cS Q]\aWUO RO` ZOa [Wa[Oa ]^]`bc\WRORSa O b]R]a aca QWcRORO\]a g O^`]dSQVS SZ ^]bS\QWOZ UÒbcWb] RS aca Q][^]\S\bSa 7A0< '#$ %' " #

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

:]a X dS\Sa S\ c\ [c\R] S\ bÒ\aT]`[OQW \( \cSd]a V]`Wh]\bSa S\ ZO a]QWOPWZWROR Vc[O\O Q]]`RW\OR]` ^`]T /\R`{a 1O\bSÒa ;c`WZZ] ³ ;OR`WR( 7\XcdS " " # ^ ) " Q[ @SQ]^WZOQW \ RS ZOa Q]\TS`S\QWOa QSZSPÒROa RcÒ\bS Z]a 1cà]a RS DSÒ\] RS 3Z 3aQ]`WOZ S\ ! S\ ZOa _cS aS bÒbOPO RS ZO `c^bcÒ RS ZOa T`]\bSÒa Q][c\WQOQW]\OZSa g SZ W\bS`QO[PW] QcZbcÒZ _cS ^S`[WbS\ \cSabÒa a]QWSRORSa OdO\hOROa 3Z ]PXSbWd] RSZ Qcà] Sa RSadSZO` ZOa Z \SOa [OSabÒa RS c\O {bWQO [ \W[O[S\bS Q][Ô`bWRO ^]` Z]a X dS\Sa acaQS^bWPZS RS Q]\b`WPcW` O O`bWQcZO` ZO RWTS`S\QWOQW \ QcZbcÒZ Tc\QW]\OZ g []ÒZ RS \cSabÒa a]QWSRORSa Vbb^( eee W\XcdS [bOa Sa W\XcdS Q]\bS\WR]a WbS[ OQbW]\-WR+""!$& "& [S\c7R+ " !' " /QQSa] bSfb] Q][^ZSb] <cUS\b @OQVSZ :]a X dS\Sa S\ c\ [c\R] UZ]POZWhOR] @OQVSZ <cUS\b ³ EOaVW\Ub]\( >]^cZObW]\ @STS`S\QS 0c`SOc $ & ^ ( U`tT ) ! Q[ :]a X dS\Sa S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR aS S\T`S\bO\ O c\O UÒ\ dO`WSROR RS Sf^S`WS\QWOa _cS RWTWS`S\ Q]\aWRSÒPZS[S\bS RS ZOa RS c\O ] R]a US\SÒQW]\Sa O\bS`W]`Sa 3ZZ] aS RSPS O Z]a STSQb]a RS ZO UZ]POZWhOQW \ O Z]a OdO\QSa bSQ\]Z UWQ]a g O ZO SfbS\aW \ RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] SQ]\ [WQ] Vbb^( eee ^`P ]Ù ^RT $ G]cbV7\/5Z]POZE]`ZRMA> ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] :c\O ;]\bO ] 7`Wa :]a [t`bW`Sa RS ZO PSZZShO( acWQWRW] g âWQ]Ôb]Z]U O Oa]QWORO O ZO W[OUS\ Q]`^]ÒZ 7`Wa :c\O ;]\bO ] ³ Ia Z K( 7\bS`âW_cWa % ^ ) ! Q[ /`b QcZ] RSZ & 1]\U`Sa] DW`bcOZ RS >aW_cWOb` O 7\bS`âW_cWa % C\ UÒ\ \ [S`] RS Z]a acWQWRW]a _cS aS ^`]RcQS\ OQbcOZ[S\bS dWS\S\ Q][] Q]\aSQcS\QWO a]P`S b]R] S\ Z]a X dS\Sa RS ZOa RS^`SaW]\Sa QOcaOROa ^]` ZO \] OQS^bOQW \ RS ZO W[OUS\ ^`]^WO T`S\bS O c\]a SabS`S]bW^]a [O`QOR]a ^]` ZO []RO g ZO ^cPZWQWROR `STZSXORO S\ Z]a [SRW]a RS Q][c\WQOQW \ RS [OaOa Vbb^( eee âW_cWOb`WO Q][ O`bWQcZ]a cÙS\QWOaMâW_ ' /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] :]a [S\]`Sa dcZ\SÒPZSa g ac `SZOQW \ Q]\ ZOa R`]UOa( /dO\QSa S\ R`]U]RS^S\RS\QWOa SRWQW \ O QOÙ] RS : >O\b]XO ³ 0WZPO]( C\WdSàWROR RS 2Scab] # '' ^ ) Q[ ³ 2`]U]RS^S\RS\QWOa) $ AS OP]`RO\ Oa^SQb]a Q]\QS^bcOZSa PtaWQ]a OQS`QO RSZ aWU\WTWQOR] RS ZO dcZ\SÒPWZWROR g aS W\ROUO a]P`S ZO SfWabS\QWO RS Z]a []RSZ]a _cS acPgOQS\ O ZOa W\bS`dS\QW]\Sa ^`]UÒ[tbWQOa S W\QZca] O ZOa RSQWaW]\Sa ^]Z bWQOa _cS aS b][O\ S\ Z]a ^ZO\Sa RS W\bS`dS\QW \ 3a W\RcROPZS _cS ZO ObS\QW \ O Z]a [S\]`Sa _cS ^`SaS\bO\ Q]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa g ZO ^`SdS\QW \ g bÒbO[WS\b] RS Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa Oa]QWOR]a O RWQV]a Q]\ac[]a RSPS\ OP]`ROàS RSaRS c\O ^Sà^SQbWdO O[^ZWO _cS ObWS\RO Tc\RO[S\bOZ[S\bS O Z]a TOQb]`Sa ^Sà]\OZSa g a]QWOZSa _cS W\QWRS\ S\ ac aWbcOQW \ RS RSadS\bOXO 7A0< &" %"&# ''" &

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

>ZObOT]`[O # g ;ta :]a ]PXSbWd]a RSZ [WZS\W]( []dWZWhOQW \ a]QWOZ g QO[PW] RS ^]Z bWQOa( 1cO`b] 7\T]`[S /\cOZ RS ZO >ZObOT]`[O # g [ta ³ ;OR`WR( :]a ZWP`]a RS ZO QObOÒbO $ $ ^ ) " Q[ ³ 7\dSabWUOQW \ g RSPObS) ! :O Sa^SQWOZ ObS\QW \ _cS aS ^`SabO S\ SabS []\]U`tTWQ] O Z]a ZZO[OR]a µ\cSd]a W\ab`c[S\b]a RS ZO Q]]^SÒQW \ SaÔ ]ZO¶ OgcRO O ^`Sac^cSab]a QO\XS RS RScRO ^]` SRcQOQW \ Ô`bWQWÔQW \ RS ZO a]QWSROR QWdWZ S\ ZOa SabÒbSUWOa RSZ Ô a W[^ZWQO OaW[Wa[] Oac[W` ZO W\RcROPZS W[^]`bO\QWO RS ZOa \cSdOa d Oa ] \cSdOa T]`[Oa RS VOQS` Q]]^SÒQW \ ÔÒ OZQO\hO` Sab]a Q][^`][Wa]a 7A0< &" &! ' %' ' AtSh DOQOa 4S`\O\R] ;ta OZZt RS W\bS`\Sb ZO `SR c\WdSàOZ RWUWbOZ( f SQ]\][ O g \cSd] S\b]`\] bSQ\]a]QWOZ 4S`\O\R] AtSh DOQOa ³ ;OR`WR( 1S\b`] RS 3abcRW]a @O[ \ /`SQSa I "K !' ^ ³ 2WtZSQbWQO a]P`S SZ Tcbc`] @STZSfW \ Q` bWQO OQS`QO RS Z]a STSQb]a bÒ\aT]`[OR]`Sa RS ZO bSQ\]Z]U O a]P`S ZOa T]`[Oa a]QWOZSa Sa^SQWOZ[S\bS Z]a QO[PW]a S\ ZO SQ]\][ O S\ ZO QcZbcÒ S\ ZO dWaW \ RS \]a]b`]a [Wa[]a Q][] Vc[O\]a S\ c\O a]QWSROR Q`SQWS\bS[S\bS bSQ\]Vc[O\O g RS Q [] \] SabO[]a RSPWRO[S\bS ^`SÔÒR]a ÔÒ RW`WUW` g RWUS`W` Sa]a QO[PW]a 7A0< &" & " $ ' # ;S ZZO[] ;O`Q]a( X dS\Sa g SabWZ]a RS dWRO ³ ;OR`WR( 4/2 % "& ^ ) Q[ 2D2 3abS ^`]UÒ[O ^`SbS\RS O[^ZWO` ZOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS bÒPOX] SRcQObWd] Q]\ X dS\Sa RS $ O & O ]a S\ SZ [O`Q] RS ZO SRcQOQW \ S\ dOZ]`Sa Q]\ ZO TW\OZWROR RS TOd]`SQS` ZO OÔ`WQW \ RS Q]\RcQbOa [S\]a ^`]QZWdSa OZ Q]\ac[] ^`]PZS[tbWQ] RS R`]UOa S\ Ô`bWQcZO` g O aWbcOQW]\Sa Q]\TZWQbWdOa S\ US\SÒZ 7A0< '%& &" '# "& & % 4`SW`S 3a^WR] ;WZSc`WabOa( `SbÒb] RS ZO US\SÒQW \ RS Z]a [WZ Sc`]a 3a^WR] 4`SW`S ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( /`WSZ % ! ^ ) Q[ @SbÒb] RS c\O US\SÒQW \ _cS Ô`bWS\R] RS c\O T]`[OQW \ Sa^SQWOZWhORO g Q]a[]^]ZWbO bWS\S _cS VOQS` UÒ\RSa SaTcS`h]a ÔÒ a]P`SdWdW` g RSPS OQS^bO` c\Oa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS bÒPOX] _cS \] aS Q]``Sa^]\RS\ Q]\ ZOa Sf^SQbObWdOa _cS aS ZS VOP O\ ]T`SQWR] 7A0< &" !"" ""'& 0XS``c[ <WSZaS\ 6O``WSb <]Wag UW`Za( \Se acPXSQbWdWbWSa O\R ]ZR US\RS` RWaQ]càSa 6O``WSb 0XS``c[ <WSZaS\ G]c\U ³ d]Z \ TSP`S`] " ) ^ ' ! 7AA< ! ! && 2Sa^c{a RS ac^SÒRO ZO []RS`\WROR ZOa [cXS`Sa X dS\Sa aS S\T`S\bO\ OZ \cSd] `Sb] RS RWTS`S\QWOàS Q][] U{\S`] g RSTW\W` c\O aS`WS RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b]a _cS aS`t\ SZ SXS RWabW\bWd] RS ZOa US\SÒQW]\Sa OQbcOZSa ÈUcWZO A]b] 1]`\SZW] =QW] X dS\Sa g ^]a[]RS`\WROR 1]`\SZW] ÈUcWZO A]b] ³ /Z[S` O( C\WdSàWROR RS /Z[S` O AS`dWQW] RS >cPZWQOQW]\Sa # !$ ^ ³ ;]\]UÒT Oa( 6c[O\WRORSa) "$

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

:Oa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa VO\ ^`]RcQWR] c\ QO[PW] QcZbcÒZ S\ SZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] RS Z]a X dS\Sa ^S`] ^SàWabS\ Z]a dWSX]a Sa_cS[Oa a]QWOZSa g RS QZOaS _cS VO\ RSTW\WR] bÒRWQW]\OZ[S\bS ZOa Sab`cQbcÒa SQ]\ [WQOa 7A0< &" & " %&# $ >OQWTWQO` dW]ZS\QWOa Q]bWRWO\Oa 4c\ROQW \ AS[W\O`W] RS 7\dSabWUOQW \ ÔÒ ZO >Oh 3Ra ³ HOÒU]hO( 2SÔ`bO[S\b] RS 1cZbcÒ g Bc`Wa[] I !K # " ^ ( WZ ³ /QbOa) $ /\tZWaWa RS ZOa Ò QSa âWQ]a]QWOZSa RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO _cS aS RO\ S\ ZO Ô`SXO S\ ZO XcdS\bcR S\ Z]a t[PWb]a SRcQObWd]a S\ SZ RS^]`bS g S\ ]bÒa aWbcOQW]\Sa Q]bWRWO\Oa `SQ]\]QWS\R] ZO SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ Q][] c\] RS Z]a gOQW[WS\b]a [ta T{`bWZSa ÔÒ W\QcPO`ZO Oa Q][] ZO TOZbO RS d \QcZ]a ZOa TÒQbcÒa a]QWOZSa ZO Q][^SbS\QWO Sfb`S[O SZ W\RWdWRcOZWa[] O cZbÒ\hO g ZO Vc[WZZOQW \ QcZbcÒZ 7A0< &" %%#! '' F @SWbS` 6SèWU >Oab ^`SaS\b Tcbc`S( PW]UÒ^VWQOZ bW[S ab`cQbc`W\U ]T RWaORdO\bOUSR g]c\U ^S]^ZS 6SèWU @SWbS` G]c\U ³ d]Z \ ! OcUcab ! ) ^ #! %' 7AA< ! ! && 2SaQ`W^QW \ RS Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa _cS bWS\S\ S\ ZO OQbcOZWROR Z]a X dS\Sa RSaTOd]`SQWR]a ÔÒ Q`SOàS c\ Tcbc`] ^` a^S`] g SabOPZSQS` c\Oa Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS dWRO SabOPZSa S\ c\O a]QWSROR QORO dSh [ta QO[PWO\bS 0SÙcO /[]`Sa 8]a{ /\USZ >Ob]Z]U Oa RS ZO ;]RS`\WROR 8]a{ È\USZ 0SÙcO /[]`Sa ³ =dWSR]( <]PSZ # ^ ³ 3\aOg]) " :Oa a]QWSRORSa Sabt\ RSaS[P]QO\R] S\ c\ ^ZO\bSO[WS\b] RS QcSabW]\Sa _cS ^]\S\ S\ bSZO RS XcWQW] [cQVOa QS`bShOa RSZ ÔaOR] g Sabt\ RO\R] ZcUO` O ZO OÔ`WQW \ RS \cSdOa bS]` Oa _cS ^S`[WbO\ Q][ÔbWPWZWhO` SZ RSaO``]ZZ] a]QWOZ Q]\ ZO QOZWROR RS dWRO 7A0< &" &"#' % % >S\aO\R] ?cSS`( aSfcOZWROR QcZbcÒ g SRcQOQW \ AcaO\ BOZPc`b AVW`ZSg @ AbSW\PSÙ SRa bÒRcQQW \ RS 0SU] O 8W[{\Sh /a^WhcO ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( 5Ò # ! ^ ³ 1` bWQO g Tc\RO[S\b]a) BS]` O g a]QW]Z]U O RS ZO SRcQOQW \) # 3\ ZO a]QWSROR OQbcOZ Sabt\ QO[PWO\R] Z]a []RSZ]a WRS\bWbO`W]a _cS RSTW\ O\ SZ [c\R] O\bS`W]` g Sabt\ ^`]d]QO\R] ZO OÔ`WQW \ RS Q]\QS^b]a QcZbcÒZSa g SRcQObWd]a _cS `][^S\ Q]\ Z]a Sa_cS[Oa RSZ ÔaOR] 7A0< &" %& % !% >`SdS\QW \ RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO g ZcQVO Q]\bÒ ZO SfQZcaW \ RSaRS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO( >`SdS\QW \ RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO S\b`S WUcOZSa S\ ZO SaQcSZO g S\ SZ ]QW]) /^`S\RWhOXS Q]]^SÒbWd]) 7\bS`dS\QW \ O bÒd{a RS ZO TO[WZWO IS_cW^] RW`WUWR] ^]` ; O 8]a{ 2 Oh /UcOR]K ³ I;OR`WRK( 7\XcdS $ 2D2 12 ' Q[ :O ^`SdS\QW \ RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO RSaRS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO RSPS aWbcOàS S\ Z]a ^`W\QWÔZSa Q]\bSfb]a S\ Z]a _cS bÒaQc``S SabO SbOÔ RS ZO dWRO( ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa Q]\ ORcZb]a S\ ZO SaQcSZO g S\ ZO TO[WZWO g ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa S\b`S WUcOZSa S\ ZO SaQcSZO g S\ SZ ]QW] 3ab]a ^`]UÒ[Oa Q]\TW`[O\ ac STWQOQWO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

`STZSXO\R] c\O dSh [ta _cS ^`SdS\W` Sa [SX]` _cS QcÒ` g _cS SRcQOQW \ S W\dSabWUOQW \ a]\ R]a RS ZOa ^`W\QWÔZSa VS`Ò[WS\bOa ÔÒ Q]\aSUcW`Z] Vbb^( eee W\XcdS [bOa Sa W\XcdS Q]\bS\WR]a bg^S OQbW]\-bg^S+'##!"%& [S\c7R+'# #!"%& ;c``WO : 4 >`SdS\QW \ aSZSQbWdO S\ SZ [SRW] SaQ]ZO` ÔÒ [S\]`Sa S\ aWbcOQW \ RS `WSaU] : 4 ;c``WO g A 0SZS\Y] 0]ZSb \ 122 ³ \ $ S\S`] $ ) ^ 7AA< !! $%" :]a X dS\Sa _cS ÔaO\ ^]` SZ aWabS[O XcRWQWOZ ^`]dWS\S\ RS c\O RSTWQWS\bS W\bSUÒQW \ S\ SZ [SRW] SaQ]ZO` Q][] Q]\aSQcS\QWO RS c\ S\b]`\] a]QWOZ S\ _cS SZ Q]\ac[] RS b]R] bW^] RS R`]UOa ZSa ZZSdO O QOS` S\ ZO RSZW\QcS\QWO Vbb^( eee aWWa \Sb P]ZQRR ^V^-bS[O+ /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 2WOh /UcOR] 8OZ]\ ; O 8]a{ >`SdS\QW \ g bÒbO[WS\b] RSZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] O\bWa]QWOZ RSaRS ZO SRcOQW \ ;O` O 8]a{ 2 Oh /UcOR] ³ IA Z K( 4c\ROQW \ =¸0SZ{\ " "' ^ ) ! Q[ 0WPZW]U` ( ^ "# "' 3ab`cQbcÒRO S\ b`Sa OÔ`bOR]a( /\tZWaWa RS ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa SRcQObWdOa g a]QWOZSa _cS `SRcQS\ ] W\Q`S[S\bO\ SZ `WSaU] RSZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] O\bWa]QWOZ RSaRS c\O R]PZS ^Sà^SQbWdO( ZO âWQ]Ôb]Z]U O Sd]ZcbWdO []RSZ] RS ZOa VOPWZWRORSa dWbOZSa PtaWQOa g ZO âWQ]Z]U O SQ]Z UWQO a]P`S ZO W\bSÒQQW \ W\RWdWRc] O[PWS\bS S\ Z]a RWabW\b]a \WdSZSa S\ Z]a _cS aS ^`]RcQS 2WSh ^`]^cSabOa ÔÒ ^`SdS\W` SZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] a]QWOZ RSaRS ZO SRcQOQW \ ! G c\ `Sac[S\ RSZ bW^] RS `SacZbOR]a ]PbS\WR]a OZ bÒbO` RS ZZSdO` O ZO ^`tQbWQO SRcQObWdO RWQVOa ^`]^cSabOa RSaO``]ZZO\R] ^`]UÒ[Oa O bÒd{a RS ZO W\dSabWUOQW \ OQQW \ Vbb^( eee ]PSZS\ Sa c^Z]OR $ 1 ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 5]\htZSh @]R`WUcSh 0S\XO[ \ >`]PZS[Oa S[SÙS\bSa S\ ZO aOZcR [S\bOZ RS ZO XcdS\bcR 0S\XO[ \ 5]\htZSh @]R`WUcSh g 3RcO`R] @SU] @]R`WUcSh ³ ;OR`WR( 7\abWbcb] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR # %& ^ ( bOP ³ 3 # 3Z RWOU\ abWQ] RS Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa RS ZO aOZcR [S\bOZ RS Z]a X dS\Sa Sc`]^S]a Sabt `SZOQW]\OR] Q]\ ZOa aWUcWS\bSa QW`Qc\abO\QWOa( SZ TcS`bS W\Q`S[S\b] RS ZOa Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] RS RWdSà]a bW^]a Oc[S\b] RS ZOa bOaOa RS acWQWRW] Oc[S\b] RS ZO O\aWSROR S\ Z]a X dS\Sa ^Sà^SQbWdOa RS c\ Tcbc`] W[^`SRSQWPZS S W\aSUc`] RS`WdOR] RS Z]a QO[PW]a a]QWOZSa `t^WR]a RSbS`W]`] RS ZOa W\abWbcQW]\Sa g `SRSa a]QWOZSa bÒRWQW]\OZSa OZOÙO[WS\b] g [Og]` Q][^ZSXWROR RS ZO bÒ\aWQW \ O ZO dWRO ORcZbO g \SQSaWROR RS RSa^ZSUO` SabÒbSUWOa ORSQcOROa ÔÒ OT`]\bO` ZO W\QS`bWRc[P`S RSZ Tcbc`] Vbb^( eee W\XcdS [bOa Sa W\XcdS Q]\bS\WR]a WbS[ OQbW]\-WR+' ""%%"&" [S\c7R+ ! $&% % /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 7\UZ{a AOcÒ 1t\RWR] 8 >`]UÒ[O >SVWO( 3\aS O\hO RS VOPWZWRORSa W\bS`^Sà]\OZSa ÔÒ OR]ZSaQS\bSa 1t\RWR] 8 7\UZ{a AOcÒ ³ ;OR`WR( >W`t[WRS ! % ^ ³ =X]a a]ZO`Sa ASQQW \ >`]UÒ[Oa 7\QZcgS 12 @=;( ;ObS`WOZSa RSZ >`]UÒ[O /^{\RWQS( 1cSabW]\O`W] RS SdOZcOQW \ RS RWTWQcZbORSa W\bS`^Sà]\OZSa S\ ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO 1327/

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

3Z ^`]UÒ[O >367/ VO aWR] RSaO``]ZZOR] ÔÒ ^]bS\QWO` ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa W\bS`^Sà]\OZSa RcÒ\bS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO ^`SdS\W` ^`]PZS[Oa RS ORO^bOQW \ g SZW[W\O` ] `SRcQW` ^]aWPZSa RWTWQcZbORSa S\ SabS t[PWb] bO\b] ÔÒ OR]ZSaQS\bSa aW\ ^`]PZS[Oa OÔ`S\bSa Q][] ÔÒ Z]a _cS aS S\QcS\bÒ\ S\ aWbcOQW]\Sa RS `WSaU] a]QWOZ 1]\abO RS ]QV] aSaW]\Sa _cS W\Q]`^]Ò\ c\O Uc O ÔÒ SZ []\Wb]` g c\ QcSabW]\O`W] RS SdOZcOQW \ /a [Wa[] c\ QR `][ W\QZcgS SZ [ObS`WOZ \SQSaO`W] ÔÒ ZZSdO` O QOP] QORO aSaW \ RSZ ^`]UÒ[O 7A0< &" !$& % >aWQ]Ôb]Z]U O g Q]\RcQbO acWQWRO S\ ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO 1 @OVSP ISb OZ K ³ IA Z K( 7\bS`âW_cWa $ " ^ BÒa STSQbcO` c\O `SaS O VWab `WQO aS RSaQ`WPS\ ZOa QOÒQbS` abWQOa QZ \WQOa RS Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa _cS Q][SbS\ acWQWRW] Oa Q][] Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] g ZOa Q]\RWQW]\Sa _cS ZZSdO\ OZ Q][^]`bO[WS\b] acWQWRO( TOQb]`Sa a]QWOZSa PW]Z UWQ]a âWQ]Z UWQ]a TO[WZWO`Sa SbQ Vbb^( eee âW_cWOb`WO Q][ O`bWQcZ]a bÒab]`\]aMW\TO\bWZSa "&&# /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] Ag[^]aWc[ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ a]P`S µ@SRcQQW \ RS `WSaU]a( UZ]POZWhOQW \ g R`]UOa¶ # AO\ ASPOabWt\ @SRcQQW \ RS `WSaU]a( UZ]POZWhOQW \ g R`]UOa ASÙS 0`]QVc ISb OZ K 3UchYWZ]`S ³ \ ' # ) ^ % ! 1]\bWS\S( 5Z]POZWhOQW \ SQ]\ [WQO g R`]UOa ASÙS 0`]QVOc g 1ZOcRWO HO[PÒ\O) 2`]UOa g Q]\TZWQb] O`[OR] 3Z QOa] Q]Z][PWO\] g SZ ÔÒRWU[O RS aSUc`WROR UZ]POZ @WQO`R] DOÙOa) :]QOZ Q]\aS_cS\QSa ]T W\bS`\ObW]\OZ R`cU Q]\b`]Z ;]ZZg 1VO`ZSa :O Oa]QWOQW \ RS R`]UOa g Q]\TZWQb] O`[OR] Sa c\ TS\ [S\] [c\RWOZ _cS Sf^ZWQO Z]a W\bS`SaSa SQ]\ [WQ]a SaQ]\RWR]a RSbÒa RS Z] _cS aS _cWS`S ^`SaS\bO` Q][] c\ ^`]PZS[O ^]Z bWQ] ] a]QWOZ Vbb^( eee aQ SVc Sa aQèeeWd SUchYW ' Vb[Z /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] >S`SWÒ @]PS`b] @SaWZWS\QWO W\RWdWRcOZ TO[WZWO` g a]QWOZ @]PS`b] >S`SWÒ ³ Ia Z K( 7\bS`âW_cWa % ^ ) ! Q[ /`b QcZ] RSZ & 1]\U`Sa] DW`bcOZ RS >aW_cWOb` O 7\bS`âW_cWa % 3abS \cSd] Q]\QS^b] `SaWZWS\QWO bÒbO RS Sf^`SaO` ZOa QOÔQWRORSa RS Z]a W\RWdWRc]a g RS ZOa TO[WZWOa ÔÒ O Ô`bW` RS aca ^`]^W]a RSTSQb]a ] QO`S\QWOa a]QWOZSa a]P`S^]\SàS O aca QW`Qc\abO\QWOa g Z]UÒ` OP`WàS c\ QO[W\] S\ ZO dWRO Vbb^( eee âW_cWOb`WO Q][ O`bWQcZ]a bÒbO[WS\b]a &' ! /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] @]dWÒ 5cO`RW]ZO 8]aS^ @SdWaW \ RS OZUc\]a RS Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa RS `SRcQQW \ RS `WSaU]a Oa]QWOR]a OZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa 8]aS^ @]dWÒ 5cO`RW]ZO ³ Ia Z K( 3\SÙg Q]\b`]Z ! # ^ 2SaRS Z]a O ]a \]dS\bO SZ bÒbO[WS\b] RSZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa VO ÔaOR] RS ZO `S^`SaW \ g ^SàSQcQW \ ^]` b]R]a Z]a [SRW]a O ZO O^ZWQOQW \ RS ZO ^`SdS\QW \ S W\T]`[OQW \ Q][] [SRW] RS Q][PObW`ZS BO\b] Oa]QWOQW]\Sa ^WdOROa Q][] W\abWbcQW]\Sa ^ PZWQOa VO\ QO[PWOR] ZO [WÒRO a]P`S SZ ^`]PZS[O g VO\ O^ZWQOR] ^]Z bWQOa RWabW\bOa g [ta OQ]`RSa Q]\ ac \ObcÒZShO Vbb^( eee S\SÙgQ]\b`]Z ]Ù /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

A]b][Og]` ;]ÒZSa 3dO @WSaU]a ZOP]ÒZSa RS Z]a X dS\Sa RSaRS SZ []RSZ] RS bÒ\aWQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ( ZOa SaQcSZOa bOZZS` g QOaOa RS ]TWQW] 3dO A]b][Og]` ;]ÒZSa @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR ³ \ %' RWQ % ) ^ # 7AA< "!$" /\tZWaWa RSZ Ô^SZ _cS bWS\S ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS `WSaU]a ZOP]ÒZSa S\ SZ [O`Q] RS ZOa ^]Z bWQOa RS S[^ZS] RW`WUWROa O X dS\Sa Q]\ POX]a \WdSZSa RS W\ab`cQQW \ g OZb]a \WdSZSa RS RSaS[^ZS] >OÒ OT`]\bO` ZO aWbcOQW \ RS `WSaU] RS SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ _cS OTSQbO O SabS Q]ZSQbWd] aS W\WQWO`]\ S\ '&# Z]a []RSZ]a [Wfb]a RS T]`[OQW \ g S[^ZS] RS Z]a _cS acÙWS`]\ Z]a ^`]UÒ[Oa RS 3aQcSZOa BOZZS` g 1OaOa RS =TWQW]a TW\O\QWOR]a ^]` SZ 4]\R] A]QWOZ 3c`]^S] Vbb^( eee W\XcdS [bOa Sa W\XcdS Q]\bS\WR]a R]e\Z]ORObb OQbW]\-WR+'!& "' #! /QQSa] bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 6]eO`R 2]\\O 3 @WaY ^`]TWZSa ]T OR]ZSaQS\b UW`Za eV] eS`S dWQbW[a ]T RObW\U dW]ZS\QS 2]\\O 3 6]eO`R O\R ;W\ ?W EO\U " ^ /R]ZSaQS\QS ³ d !& \ "' a^`W\U ! ) ^ " 7AA< &""' 0WPZW]U` ( ^ ! " 7\dSabWUO Z]a ^S`TWZSa RS `WSaU] RS ZOa [cXS`Sa X dS\Sa d QbW[Oa RS ZO dW]ZS\QWO AS SabcRWO ZO `SZOQW \ _cS SfWabS S\b`S ZOa [cXS`Sa X dS\Sa [OZbÒbOROa S\ `SZOQW \ Q]\ ]bÒa dO`WOPZSa Q][] ZO dW]ZS\QWO ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa aSfcOZSa W\aSUcÒa SZ acWQWRW] SZ ca] RS acabO\QWOa RS OZU \ bW^] ] SZ Q]\ac[] SfQSaWd] RS OZQ]V]Z 4]USZ A]\RÒ 8 @WaYa O\R =^^]`bc\WbWSa T]` AcQQSaa( >S`QS^bW]\a ]T C`PO\ G]cbVa W\ O 2Wab`SaaSR 1][[c\Wbg O\R :Saa]\a T]` /RcZba A]\RÒ 8 4]USZ 4O[WZWSa W\ a]QWSbg ³ d]Z &# \ ! XcZW] aS^bWS[P`S " ) ^ !!# !"" 7AA< "" !&'" :]a X dS\Sa RSPS\ OT`]\bO` ac W\bSUÒQW \ S\ SZ [c\R] ORcZb] [SRWO\bS c\O ^`SÔÒQW \ QcOZWTWQORO _cS ZSa VOUO W\[c\Sa O Z]a ^SZWU`]a _cS ZSa dO\ OQSQVO\R] O Z] ZOÙ] RS ac SbOÔ RS [ORcÒQW \ ASfcOZ caSa ]T OZQ]V]Z O\R R`cUa O\R bVS Oaa]QWObSR VSOZbV( `WaYa( / Q`]aa aSQbW]\OZ abcRg ]T g]c\U ^S]^ZS W\ \W\S 3c`]^SO\ QWbWSa ;O`Y / 0SZZWa ISb OZ K ³ IA Z K( 0W];SR 1S\bÒZ & ^ ) ! Q[ :]a X dS\Sa Sc`]^S]a Sabt\ Sf^S`W[S\bO\R] OZb]a \WdSZSa RS Q]\ac[] RS OZQ]V]Z g R`]UOa g aS Sabt\ SfbS\RWS\R] bO[PW{\ ZOa S\TS`[SRORSa RS bÒ\a[WaW \ aSfcOZ Z] _cS `S^`SaS\bO ^`W]`WRORSa W[^]`bO\bSa RS ZO aOZcR ^ PZWQO :O Q][^`S\aW \ RS ZO Oa]QWOQW \ S\b`S SZ aSf] g SZ ca] RS acabO\QWOa g Sa^SQ TWQO[S\bS ac ca] ÔÒ TOQWZWbO` ZO OQbWdWROR aSfcOZ aWUcS aWS\R] ZW[WbORO 3\ SabS SabcRW] [ta RS ! Ô`bWQWÔ\bSa RS \cSdS QWcRORSa Sc`]^SOa Q][^ZSbO`]\ QcSabW]\O`W]a RWaS OR]a ÔÒ `SQ]^WZO` ROb]a RS[]U`tTWQ]a a]QWOZSa g RS Q][^]`bO[WS\b] a]P`S ca] VWab `WQ] g OQbcOZ RS R`]UOa g Q][^]`bO[WS\b] aSfcOZ Vbb^( eee PW][SRQS\bÒZ Q][ Q]\bS\b ^RT "% "#& & ## ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb]

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

6S``SÒ 5][Sh ;O\cSZ A]QWSRORSa Q][^ZSXOa( QObSU]` Oa g \cSd]a SaQS\O`W]a ;O\cSZ 6S``SÒ 5 [Sh g /\b]\W] 8OW[S 1OabWZZ] ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( /`WSZ " ! " ^ ³ /`WSZ A]QW]Z]U O 0WPZW]UÒT O( ^ I &'K ! " @STZSfW \ a]P`S SZ ^`]PZS[O RS ZOa `S^`SaS\bOQW]\Sa RS ZO a]QWSROR S\ Q]\Q`Sb] SZ b`t\aWb] RS ZO a]QWSROR []RS`\O O ZO ^]ab[]RS`\O AS `SQ]US\ ]^W\W]\Sa a]P`S a]QW]Z]U O RS ZO QcZbcÒ g RS ZO `SZWUW \ a]P`S ZO RW[S\aW \ Q][c\WQObWdO g a]P`S ZO ]ÙO\WhOQW \ SQ]\ [WQO g ^]Z bWQO RS ZO a]QWSROR >]` ZbW[] aS ]T`SQS c\O ZSQbcÒ UZ]POZ RS Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa RSZ ]`RS\ g RSZ QO[PW] a]QWOZ 7A0< &" !"" % & A]QW]âWQ]Z]U O RSZ bÒPOX] /ZWQWO 5O``WR] :c_cS Q]]`RW\OR]Ò ISb OZ K ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( C=1 $ '# ^ ( bOP ) " Q[ ³ >aWQ]Z]U O) #" 3\ c\O a]QWSROR [O`QORO ^]` ZO W\SabOPWZWROR ZOP]ÒZ g SZ Ô`] W\bS`[WbS\bS SZ dOZ]` QS\bÒZ RSZ bÒPOX] S\ ZO RSTW\WQW \ WRS\bWbO`WO RSZ W\RWdWRc] Sabt a][SbWR] O c\ ^`]QSa] RS QO[PW] _cS O \ \] aS OQOPO RS Q]\Q`SbO` 7A0< &" '%&& ! % BÒPOXO` ^]` bWS[^]a [SX]`Sa( `S^S\aO` SZ bÒPOX] S\ SZ aWUZ] FF7 8SO\ ;WQVSZ AS`dOWa ISb OZ K ³ ;OR`WR( ;W\WabS`W] RS BÒPOX] g /ac\b]a A]QWOZSa AcPRW`SQQW \ 5S\SÒZ RS 7\T]`[OQW \ /R[W\WabÒbWdO g >cPZWQOQW]\Sa % &%# ^ ( bOP U`tT ) Q[ ³ 7\T]`[Sa =7B) %# / [SRWRO _cS Z]a []RSZ]a RS bÒPOX] Q]\bW\ O\ QO[PWO\R] Q][] `Sa^cSabO O ZOa RS[O\ROa RS ZO ^`]RcQQW \ g RSZ Q][S`QW] S\ c\O SQ]\][ O UZ]POZ VO\ acÙWR] \cSd]a `Sb]a \] a Z] ÔÒ ZOa dWROa RS Z]a bÒPOXOR]`Sa aW\] bO[PW{\ ÔÒ Z]a S[^`SaO`W]a Sf^cSab]a O ZO Q][^SbS\QWO UZ]POZ g ÔÒ Z]a [S`QOR]a a][SbWR]a O ^]Z bWQOa g ZSgSa \OQW]\OZSa S W\bS`\OQW]\OZSa 3Z ^c\b] QS\bÒZ RSZ RSPObS ÒRWQO S\ ZO RWTWQcZbOR RS S\[O`QO` Z]a Q]\QS^b]a g \]`[Oa ^]` ZOa QcOZSa ZO aSUc`WROR SQ]\ [WQO RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa g ZOa RW[S\aW]\Sa Vc[O\Oa RSZ bÒPOX] ^cSRS\ Q]\QWZWOàS Q]\ ZO Q`SQWS\bS \SQSaWROR RSZ [S`QOR] UZ]POZ RS Q]\aSUcW` c\O TZSfWPWZWROR RS [O\] RS ]PÒ 7A0< '%& &" &" % "$ & BÒPOX] S\ `SR g USabW \ RS `WSaU]a S\ SZ ]QW] XcdS\WZ 1O`[S\ /`S\Oa g 3abSZO DSZO Q]]`RW\OR]Òa ³ ;OR`WR( 572 ! # ^ 3Z ]QW] XcdS\WZ aS \]a ^`SaS\bO O dSQSa Q][] c\ ^SZWU`] ÔÒ ZO aOZcR g SZ RSaO``]ZZ] W\bSUÒZ RS Z]a OR]ZSaQS\bSa 1]\ SabS bÒPOX] aS _cWS`S VOQS` c\O ZOP]` ^`SdS\bWdO _cS OgcRS O RWaT`cbO` RSZ bWS[^] ZWP`S O bÒd{a RS ZO Q]]`RW\OQW \ RS b]R]a Z]a `SQcà]a RWa^]\WPZSa g ac W\bS``SZOQW \ ÔÒ \] RSaO^`]dSQVO` ZOa ]^]`bc\WRORSa _cS aS ]T`SQS\ D]USZ :Oc`S\b BÒPOX] g aOZcR S\ ZO US\SÒQW \ µ^`SQO`WO¶ :Oc`S\b D]USZ @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR ³ \ %' RWQ % ) ^ # ! 7AA< "!$" :]a ROb]a RS aOZcR g aSUc`WROR a]P`S bÒPOXOR]`Sa X dS\Sa a]\ [cg W``SUcZO`Sa ^S`] [cSabÒ\ c\O bS\RS\QWO QZOÒ S\ ZO _cS Sabt\ ^]` S\QW[O RS ZO [SRWO S\ SZ `WSaU] RS RO ]a S\ SZ bÒPOX] :Oa Òh]\Sa RS SabO

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

aWbcOQW \ aS RSPS\ O c\O OQc[cZOQW \ RS TOQb]`Sa RS ^`SQO`WhOQW \( Q]\RWQW]\Sa RS bÒPOX] RSaQcWROROa dcZ\SÒPWZWROR O ZO Sf^Z]bOQW \ g c\ [S\]` \WdSZ RS ]ÙO\WhOQW \ ÔÒ ZO OQQW \ Q]ZSQbWdO Vbb^( eee W\XcdS [bOa Sa W\XcdS Q]\bS\WR]a R]e\Z]ORObb OQbW]\-WR+ !"'''& " /QQSa] bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 2c 0]Wa @Sg[]\R ;O\cSZO BÒ\aWQW]\Sa bW^] g] g] g bÒgSQb]`WOa TOZZWROa( VOQWO ZOa >]Z bWQOa W\bSUÒROa RS bÒ\aWQW \ ÔÒ Z]a X dS\Sa Sc`]^S]a ;O\cSZO Rc 0]Wa @Sg[]\R g /\R`Sc : ^Sh 0ZOaQ] @SdWabO RS SabcRW]a RS XcdS\bcR ³ \ $# Xc\W] " ) ^ ' "!$" 0WPZW]UÒT O :Oa ^]Z bWQOa RS W\bSUÒQW \ RS Z]a X dS\Sa S\ SZ [c\R] ZOP]ÒZ VO\ acT`WR] c\ ^`]Tc\R] QO[PW] `Sa^SQb] RS R{QOROa O\bS`W]`Sa _cS ZZSdO\ O Q]\aSUcW` SZ STSQb] Q]\bÒ`W] RS ZO W\bSUÒQW \ a]QWOZ >]` SZZ] aS VOQS \SQSaO`W] `SdWaO` SaOa bÒ\aWQW]\Sa g PcaQO` ]bÒa ^]Z bWQOa [ta OQ]`RSa O ZOa RS[O\ROa OQbcOZSa Vbb^( eee [bOa Sa W\XcdS PWPZW] `SdWabOa ^RTa \c[S`]$# bS[Oa" ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 5S\bWZS /ZSaaO\R`] C\O ^`SQO`WO bÒ\aWQW \ O ZO SROR ORcZbO( W\SabOPWZWROR ZOP]ÒZ g Z [WbSa RSZ `{UW[S\ TO[WZWabO RS 3abOR] RSZ 0WS\SabO`( 3Z QOa] RS 3aÔ O /ZSaaO\R`] 5S\bWZS ³ IA Z K( 1A71 C\WROR RS >]Z bWQOa 1][ÔÒROa $ ! ^ ( bOP U`tT ) ! Q[ ³ 2]Qc[S\b] RS bÒPOX]) $ 0WPZW]U` ( ^ % ! :]a X dS\Sa SaÔ ]ZSa ]PbWS\S\ ac S[O\QWÔQW \ RS T]`[O QORO dSh [ta Q][^ZWQORO g ZS\bO <] Q]\aWUcS\ W\RS^S\RWhOàS g Q]\ab`cW` ac ^`]^W] ^`]gSQb] dWbOZ Tcbc`] ^]` ZO TOZbO RS c\ STWQWS\bS aWabS[O RS OgcRO g RS ^`]bSQQW \ a]QWOZ g O QOcaO RS c\ `SQ]``WR] ZOP]ÒZ Ob ^WQ] ^`SQO`W] g TÒU[S\bOR] 5S\SÒZ[S\bS aca ÔR`Sa ZSa aWUcS\ O^]gO\R] [O\bS\W{\R]ZSa S\ QOaO g ^`]^]`QW]\t\R]ZSa Z]a `SQcà]a OTSQbWd]a SQ]\ [WQ]a [ObS`WOZSa g Z]U abWQ]a _cS \SQSaWbS\ Vbb^( eee WSaO[ QaWQ Sa R]QbÒP Rb $ ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] Ca] g OPca] RS 7\bS`\Sb S\ X dS\Sa c\WdSàWbO`W]a 8]a{ / 5O`Q O RSZ 1OabWZZ] ISb OZ K /RWQQW]\Sa ³ d]Z \ ) ^ ! " 7AA< " "&" 0WPZW]U` ( ^ " " / bÒd{a RS QcSabW]\O`W]a ORO^bOR]a `SQ]US Z]a `SacZbOR]a a]P`S SZ ca] g ] OPca] RS 7\bS`\Sb Oa Q][] ZO `SZOQW \ S\b`S T`SQcS\QWO RS ca] g RSbS`[W\OROa dO`WOPZSa âWQ]a]QWOZSa RS X dS\Sa c\WdSàWbO`W]a 3Z ca] g OPca] RS 7\bS`\Sb aS `SZOQW]\ Q]\ SZ Q][^]\S\bS Q]U\WbWd] RS ZOa VOPWZWRORSa a]QWOZSa Vbb^( eee ORWQQW]\Sa Sa TWZSa UO`QWO RSZ QOabWZZ] ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] Ca]a W\ORSQcOR]a RS ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa S\b`S ZO ^]PZOQW \ ORcZbO SaÔ ]ZO( BSQ\]ORWQb]a /^^S\R ³ ;OR`WR( /^^S\R % % ^ ( bOP U`tT ) ! Q[ 3\ ^]`bORO( =;<70CA 7\T]`[S RS @SacZbOR]a 2 % :Oa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa O^]`bO\ [cQV] O ZO QOZWROR RS dWRO g O ZOa ^`]^WOa ^]aWPWZWRORSa RS RSaO``]ZZ] RS ZOa ^Sà]\Oa g ^]` SZZ] QOPS RSaSO` _cS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

SabOa aSO\ OQQSaWPZSa OZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO ^]PZOQW \ AW\ S[POÙ] Sa W\bS`SaO\bS `STZSfW]\O` a]P`S OZUc\]a RS Z]a `WSaU]a _cS Q][^]`bO c\ ca] W\ORSQcOR] RS ZOa [Wa[Oa 3abS W\T]`[S ]T`SQS OZUc\Oa ^W\QSZOROa QcO\bWbObWdOa a]P`S ^]aWPZSa Q]\RcQbOa RS `WSaU] OZ `Sa^SQb] Vbb^( eee O^^S\R Sa ROb]a SabcRW]a O`QVWd] ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] DWRO `SQ`SObWdO \]Qbc`\O RS Z]a X dS\Sa SaÔ ]ZSa Q][] TOQb]` RS `WSaU] T`S\bS O ]b`]a [ta bÒRWQW]\OZSa / 1OZOTOb ISb OZ K /RWQQW]\Sa ³ d]Z ' \ % ) ^ # ! 7AA< " "&" 3Z SabcRW] bÒbO RS Q]\]QS` ZOa []bWdOQW]\Sa _cS ZZSdO\ O QWS`b]a X dS\Sa O WRS\bWTWQO` SZ ]QW] \]Qbc`\] Q]\ SZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa bS\WS\R] S\ QcS\bO _cS ZO RWdSàO ^Sà]\OZWROR RS QORO c\] ZSa VOQS S\T]QO` ZO aWbcOQW \ RS [O\SÒ RWTS`S\bS Vbb^( eee ORWQQW]\Sa Sa TWZSa # ! @SQ`SObWd] ÔÒ /RWQQW]\Sa ^RT /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] 1]\RS : ^Sh DOZS\b \ 8]a{ ;O` O DcZ\SÒPWZWROR O bÒab]`\]a OZW[S\bWQW]a S\ OR]ZSaQS\bSa DOZS\b \ 8]a{ ;O` O 1]\RS : ^Sh 1O`Z]a 7[Oh @]\QS`] <c`WO 6WUcSÒ 5]\htZSh ³ IA Z K( 7\bS`âW_cWa # ! ^ /`b QcZ] RSZ $ 1]\U`Sa] DW`bcOZ RS >aW_cWOb` O 7\bS`âW_cWa # 1]\ Z]a QO[PW]a OQOSQWR]a S\ SZ [c\R] RSaO``]ZZOR] aS VO\ bÒ\aT]`[OR] Z]a TOQb]`Sa RS `WSaU] RSaRS SZ []RSZ] RS S\TS`[SRORSa W\TSQb] Q]\bOUW]aOa OZ []RSZ] PW] âWQ] a]QWOZ OQbcOZ Vbb^( eee âW_cWOb`WO Q][ W[^`W[W` Oba- $& /QQSa] O bSfb] Q][^ZSb] DS`Rc DWQS\bS G] g b ]PXSb]a RS ZcX]( SZ ^Sà]\Wa[]( ZO ^`W[SÒ `Sd]ZcQW \ QcZbcÒZ RSZ aWUZ] FF7 DWQS\bS DS`R ³ 0O`QSZ]\O( 2SP]ZaWZZ] % ^ ) ' Q[ 2SaRS SZ TW\ RS ZO aSUc\RO UcS`Ò [c\RWOZ VOabO ZO QO RO RSZ [c`] RS 0S`Z \ W[^S` ZO OdS\bcÒ Q]ZSQbWdO g `Sd]ZcQW]\O`WO _cS bÒa ac TÒQOa] RS`Wd S\ c\ W\RWdWRcOZWa[] Sfb`S[] :O \cSdO QcZbcÒ a]QWOZ Ô`SQS S\T`S\bORO O b]R]a Z]a dOZ]`Sa VS`SROR]a g ac^]\S c\O `SdWaW \ RS Z] _cS Q`S O[]a W\bO\UWPZS :O Q][c\WQOQW \ Q]\ Z]a RS[ta b][O c\ Ô^SZ `SZSdO\bS c\O \cSdO {^]QO [O`QORO ^]` ZO S[]bWdWROR g SZ Vc[O\WbO`Wa[] VOabWORO RS ^SàSUcW` ZO aObWaTOQQW \ S\ ZO OQc[cZOQW \ RS ]PXSb]a g OÔ`WS\QWOa 7A0< '%& &" &!"$ !#% " 0`SeS` :OcÒ G]cbV Ob `WaY( bVS `]ZS ]T aYWZZa RSdSZ]^[S\b W\ TOQWZWbObW\U bVS bÒ\aWbW]\ b] e]`Y :OcÒ 0`SeS` ³ 5W\SPÒ( 7\bS`\ObW]\OZ :OP]c` =TTWQS " # ^) ! Q[ ³ AYWZZa E]`YW\U >O^S`) ' DSàW \ S\ SaÔ ]Z dS` @ : 2 !%'# :Oa QWTÒa RS RSaS[^ZS] g RS S[^ZS] ^`SQO`W] S\b`S Z]a X dS\Sa a]\ OZO`[O\bSa >O`bWS\R] RS _cS ZO SRcQOQW \ g ZO T]`[OQW \ a]\ d Oa W[^]`bO\bSa ÔÒ OP]`RO` ac S[^ZSOPWZWROR S\ SabS bÒPOX] aS Oa^WÒ O OP]`RO` ZO QcSabW \ RSZ RSaO``]ZZ] RS QOZWTWQOQW]\Sa ÔÒ Z]a X dS\Sa S\ aWbcOQW \ RS `WSaU] S\b`S Z]a _cS ^`SaS\bO\ c\O dcZ\SÒPWZWROR SQ]\ [WQO ] acT`S\ SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ >OÒ SZZ] aS VO\ PcaQOR] SXS[^Z]a O^`]^WOR]a RS ^`]UÒ[Oa g ^`]gSQb]a RS T]`[OQW \ _cS VOgO\ Z]UÒR] WRS\bWTWQO` O Z]a

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

X dS\Sa dcZ\SÒPZSa _cS aS VOgO\ ZZSdOR] O ZO ^`tQbWQO g _cS VOgO\ SdOZcOR] aca W\WQWObWdOa 7A0< ' $ #$ " G]cbV W\ Q]\bSfb( TÒ[Se]`Ya aSbbW\Ua O\R S\Q]c\bSà ;O`bW\ @]PP SRWb]` ³ :]\R`Sa( A/53 % !!# ^ ( WZ ) # Q[ :O dWRO RS Z]a X dS\Sa S\ SZ @SW\] C\WR] Q][] S\ ]bÒa Ô`bSa RSZ [c\R] VO QO[PWOR] [cQV] S\ Z]a ZbW[]a O ]a( VO\ ]Qc``WR] QO[PW]a W[^]`bO\bSa S\ ZOa Sab`cQbcÒa a]QWOZSa g ^`]QSa]a _cS T]`[O\ ZO dWRO RS Z]a X dS\Sa W\QZcgS\R] QO[PW]a S\ ZO SRcQOQW \ g ZO S\aS O\hO ac^S`W]` ZO ^{`RWRO RSZ [S`QOR] RS bÒPOX] bÒRWQW]\OZ XcdS\WZ g []dW[WS\b]a S\ ZO \ObcÒZShO RS ZO TO[WZWO g S\ ZOa `SZOQW]\Sa ^Sà]\OZSa 3abS bÒPOX] W\b`]RcQS ZOa ^Sà^SQbWdOa QZOdS S\ SZ S\bS\RW[WS\b] RS ZO XcdS\bcR g ]T`SQS c\ OQS`QO[WS\b] W\bS`RWaQW^ZW\O`W] O ZOa dWROa RS Z]a X dS\Sa g OZ bÒPOX] Q]\ SZZ]a 7A0< '%& " ' ! $% ! =aUS`Pg 0WZZ G]cbV ;SRWO 0WZZ =aUS`Pg ³ :]\R]\( @]cbZSRUS " ! ^ 3Z W[ÔQb] RS ZOa \cSdOa bSQ\]Z]U Oa S\ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] QcZbcÒZ VO ^`]^WQWOR] ZO OÔ`WQW \ RS \cSdOa bS\RS\QWOa S\ ZO XcdS\bcR _cS VO\ ac^cSab] c\O `c^bcÒ Q]\ ZOa T]`[Oa bÒRWQW]\OZSa RS `SZOQW]\OàS g Sf^`SaOàS Q]\ SZ S\b]`\] a]QWOZ 7A0< " # !& % VPY 7A0< " # !& & ^PY G]cbV c\S[^Z]g[S\b O\R a]QWOZ SfQZcaW]\ W\ 3c`]^S( O Q][ÔÒbWdS abcRg B]`WZR 6O[[S` ISR K ³ 0`Wab]Z( >]ZWQg >`Saa ! !! ^ 7\T]`[S Q][ÔÒbWd] a]P`S SZ RSaS[^ZS] XcdS\WZ g ZO SfQZcaW \ a]QWOZ _cS /QO``SO O Z] ZOÙ] RS Z]a Ô aSa RS ZO C\W \ 3c`]^SO /\OZWhO ZOa RWTWQcZbORSa RS W\bSUÒQW \ a]QWOZ g ZOP]ÒZ RS Z]a X dS\Sa Z]a T]Q]a RS `WSaU] _cS ZSa OQSQVO\ g ZOa ^]Z bWQOa \SQSaO`WOa ÔÒ SdWbO` QOS` S\ SaOa aWbcOQW]\Sa 7A0< &$ !" !$& F Ô^S`POQY

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

8DA67DG68>âC

? kZcZh n \Zhi^ c YZa g^Zh\d

8DA67DG68>âC

8daVWdgVc Zc ZhiZ c bZgd 3dO /RO[ >WQOh] 5`c^] RS 7\dSabWUOQW \ 27//: 2W[S\aW \ 7\bS`QcZbcÒZ g /^`S\RWhOXS /QbWd] RS ZO :S\UcO 2SÔ`bO[S\b] RS :W\U abWQO /^ZWQORO 3BA711> C\WdSàWROR >]ZWb{Q\WQO RS DOZS\QWO 2]Qb]Ò S\ 4WZ]Z]U O @][t\WQO ^]` ZO C\WdSàWROR RS DOZS\QWO g B3C RS ZO C\WdSàWROR >]ZWb{Q\WQO RS DOZS\QWO BÒRcQb]Ò S\ :S\UcO 4Ò\QSaO ^]` ZO C\WdSàWROR 1][^ZcbS\aS RS ;OR`WR ;tabS` S\ >aWQ]^SROU]U O a]P`S µ/a^SQb]a Sd]ZcbWd]a âWQ]Ôb]Z UWQ]a âWQ]SRcQObWd]a g a]QWOZSa RS ZO OR]ZSaQS\QWO¶ ^]` ZO C\WdSàWROR RS DOZS\QWO 1]\ \c[S`]aOa ^cPZWQOQW]\Sa g Qcà]a RS T]`[OQW \ RSZ ^`]TSa]ÒR] W[Ô`bWR]a S\ 1Sâ g 1STW`Sa S\ bS[Oa `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ Z]a Oa^SQb]a âWQ]^SROU UWQ]a RS ZO S\aS O\hO /QbcOZ[S\bS Sa Q]]`RW\OR]Ò RSZ 5`c^] RS 7\\]dOQW \ 3RcQObWdO 5`Sd]Z 5`c^ RS `SQS`QO a]P`S SRcQOQW S\ dOZ]à S\ SZa SabcRWa QWS\b TWQ] b{Q\WQa S\ ZO C\WdSàWROR >]ZWb{Q\WQO RS DOZS\QWO 8cO\ 1O`Z]a 0OZZSabS`]a 5cS`Ò :WQS\QWOR] S\ 1WS\QWOa >]Z bWQOa g A]QW]Z]U O C1; g 3a^SQWOZWabO S\ W\dSabWUOQW \ a]QWOZ O^ZWQORO g O\tZWaWa RS ROb]a 17A ;WS[P`] RS A]QW]Z UWQO B`Sa >`]TSa]` RS ZO OaWU\ObcÒ RS W\dSabWUOQW \ RS ;S`QOR]a S\ ZO C\WdSàWROR RS DWZZO\cSdO ORaQ`WbO O ZO C\WdSàWROR 1][^ZcbS\aS RS ;OR`WR 1cS\bO Q]\ [ta RS QOb]`QS O ]a RS Sf^S`WS\QWO S\ W\dSabWUOQW \ a]QWOZ g RS [S`QOR]a _cS OPO`QO\ b]R] bW^] RS SabcRW]a a]P`S Q]\ac[] ]^W\W \ ^ PZWQO g O\tZWaWa SZSQb]ÒZSa >]\S\bS RS \c[S`]a]a aS[W\O`W]a g Qcà]a S\b`S Z]a _cS RSabOQO µ5SabW \ RS ZO W\dSabWUOQW \ a]QWOZ g RS [S`QOR]a¶ % g & ÔÒ 77@ 7\abWbcbS T]` 7\bS`\ObW]\OZ @SaSO`QV 1]Ocb]` RS RWdSàOa ^cPZWQOQW]\Sa S\b`S ZOa _cS RSabOQO\( µ/R]ZSaQS\bSa g OZQ]V]Z) ZO [WÒRO RS ÔR`Sa g [OR`Sa¶ % :O 1OWfO) µ2]QS\bSa g ;OSab`]a) ^S`QS^QW]\Sa RS ZO SRcQOQW \ RSaRS RS\b`] & 4/2 1OXO ;OR`WR /ZSXO\RÒ 0]\W /`WabWhtPOZ 5`c^] RS 3abcRW]a S\ 2SaO``]ZZ] 1]]^SÒQW \ 7\bS`\OQW]\OZ g pbWQO /^ZWQORO 2SÔ`bO[S\b] RS >`]gSQb]a RS 7\US\WS` O 3BA77 C\WdSàWROR >]ZWb{Q\WQO RS DOZS\QWO 2]Qb]Ò S\ 2S`SQV] ^]` ZO C\WdSàWROR RS DOZS\QWO g >`]TSa]Ò B3C RS ZO C\WdSàWROR >]ZWb{Q\WQO RS DOZS\QWO 3a 1]]`RW\OR]Ò RSZ 5`c^] RS 3abcRW]a S\ 2SaO``]ZZ] 1]]^SÒQW \ 7\bS`\OQW]\OZ g pbWQO /^ZWQORO g RW`SQb]Ò RSZ ;OabS` S\ >]Z bWQOa g >`]QSa]a RS 2SaO``]ZZ] RS ZO C>D 7\dSabWUOR]Ò W\dWbORO RSZ 72A S\ @SW\] C\WR] g SZ 7AA S\ 6]ZO\RO >`]TSa]Ò W\dWbORO S\ ZO >C17 RS ;W\Oa 5SÒSa S\ 0ÒaWZ ZO @S\{ ;]`S\] S\ 0]ZWdWO g ZO >]ZWb{Q\WQO AOZSaWO\O RS 3QcOR]` 7\dSabWUO S\ SZ QO[^] RS ZO SRcQOQW \ ÔÒ SZ RSaO``]ZZ] RSaO``]ZZ] Vc[O\] c\WdSàWROR g Q]]^SÒQW \ W\bS`\OQW]\OZ 3a Ocb]Ò RS RWdSàOa ^cPZWQOQW]\Sa \OQW]\OZSa S W\bS`\OQW]\OZSa a]P`S Sab]a bS[Oa [ta W\T]`[OQW \ S\ Vbbâ( eee c^d Sa S\bWRORSa 53213

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

8Oc[S 1O`P]\SZZ ASPO``]XO >SROU]U] ^S`W]RWabO g a]QW Z]U] 2W`SQb]` RS ZO `SdWabO [S\acOZ µ1cORS`\]a RS >SROU]U O¶ RS ZO _cS T]`[O Ô`bS RS ac S_cW^] RS `SROQQW \ RSaRS ac ^`W[S` \ [S`] S\ S\S`] RS '%# >`]TSa]` RS A]QW]Z]U O [WS[P`] RSZ U`c^] RS W\dSabWUOQW \ RS ZO 3RcQOQW \ RS ZO 4OQcZbOR RS 3RcQOQW \ RS ZO C\WdSàWbOb RS DWQ 6O aWR] [WS[P`] RSZ 1]\aSX] 3aQ]ZO` RSZ 3abOR] '&! '&& S W[Ô`bS Q]\TS`S\QWOa g Qcà]a S\ b]RO 3aÔ O g S\ RWdSà]a Ô aSa ZObW\]O[S`WQO\]a a]P`S QcSabW]\Sa `SZOQW]\OROa Q]\ ac Sa^SQWOZWROR 6O `SOZWhOR] [ ZbW^ZSa Q]ZOP]ÒQW]\Sa S\ RWdSàOa ^cPZWQOQW]\Sa SRcQObWdOa g ^S`W]R abWQOa g S\b`S aca ]PÒa ^cPZWQOROa QOPS RSabOQO`( :¸3aQ]ZO <]`[OZ RS ZO 5S\SÒZWbOb '%% ;O\cSZ 0O`b]Z][{ 1]aa ] C\O O\b]Z]U O ^SROU UWQO '&# :O `ST]`[O SRcQObWdO O Z] QZO`] '' :O SaQcSZO( S\b`S ZO cb]^ O g ZO `SOZWROR '%% :O OdS\bcÒ RS W\\]dO` 3Z QO[PW] S\ ZO SaQcSZO g Sa Q] Ocb]` RS( :¸3aQ]ZO \WQO c\WTWQORO '%% /^`S\RWS\R] RS ZOa W\\]dOQW]\Sa S\ Z]a QS\b`]a ''& ;OU`WPW\a O ZSa OcZSa 3Z []RSZ RS DWQ O RSPOb g µ:O SRcQOQW \ g ac `S^`SaS\bOQW \ S\ Z]a [SRW]a¶ $ Ac ZbW[] ZWP`] ^cPZWQOR] Sa µC\O SRcQOQW \ ÔÒ [O O\O¶ & S\ SZ _cS aS ^]\S\ RS `SZWSdS OZUc\]a RS Z]a ]PabtQcZ]a g ^]aWPWZWRORSa [ta `SZSdO\bSa RS ZO \SQSaO`WO `S\]dOQW \ S\ ZO SaQcSZO g S\ SZ Q]\Xc\b] RS ZO SRcQOQW \ ;S`RSQSa 5O`Q O @cWh 2]Qb]Ò S\ >aWQ]Z]U O ASf Z]UO BÒPOXO S\ SZ 1]\aSX] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR RS /abc`WOa Q][] `Sa^]\aOPZS RS >`]UÒ[Oa A]QWOZSa Q]\ X dS\Sa 6O Q]]`RW\OR] >`]UÒ[Oa RS 3RcQOQW \ ASfcOZ g >`SdS\QW \ RS D76 S\ 1S\b`]a RS ;S\]`Sa Q]\ /abc`WOa g >O a DOaQ] 6O Q]]`RW\OR] SZ >`]UÒ[O RS 3RcQOQW \ ASfcOZ Q]\ 1S\b`]a RS /^]g] O ZO 7\bSUÒQW \ RS ^Sà]\Oa Q]\ RWaQOÔQWROR W\bSZSQbcOZ RS /abc`WOa 7\dSabWUOR]Ò S\ RWTS`S\bSa Oa^SQb]a `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ ZO XcdS\bcR 8Sa a 5O`Q O DS`RcU] :WQS\QWOR] S\ 1WS\QWOa >]Z bWQOa g RS ZO /R[W\WabÒQW \ C\WdSàWROR 1][^ZcbS\aS RS ;OR`WR ! DWQS^`SaWRS\bS g Q]Tc\ROR]` RS ZO 4SRSÒQW \ RS /a]QWOQW]\Sa RS 8 dS\Sa 3abcRWO\bSa RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO 4/2/83 1:; OV]Ò 4/2/31/; ''& /RXc\b] O ZO >`SaWRS\QWO RS ZO 1]\TSRSÒQW \ RS /a]QWOQW]\Sa RS 3abcRWO\bSa 1/</3 D]QOZ RS 3RcQOQW \ =QW] g BWS[^] :WP`S RSZ 1]\aSX] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO >`SaWRS\bS RSZ 1]\aSX] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO $ 1]]`RW\OR]` RSZ RWaS ] RSZ >ZO\ 7PS`]O[S`WQO\] RS 1]]^SÒQW \ S 7\bSUÒQW \ RS ZO 8cdS\bcR S\ ZO =ÙO\WhOQW \ 7PS`]O[S`WQO\O RS ZO 8cdS\bcR =78 $ 1]]`RW\OR]` <OQW]\OZ RS ZO 1O[Ô O 3c`]^SO RS 8cdS\bcR ^]` ZO RWdSàWROR Z]a RS`SQV]a Vc[O\]a g ZO Ô`bWQWÔQW \ µA][]a 2WTS`S\bSa³ A][]a 7UcOZSa¶ S\ SZ 7\abWbcb] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR 7<8CD3 % 1]ZOP]ÒR]` RSZ ;OabS` 3c`]^S] RS ;WUÒQW]\Sa RS ZO C\WdSàWROR RS DOZS\QWO $ @Sa^]\aOPZS RSZ 777 >ZO\ 8]dS\ RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO S\ SZ 7\abWbcb] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO & ;WS[P`] RSZ 1]ZSUW] RS >]ZWb Z]U]a g A]QW Z]U]a RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO g ZO @SR 7PS`]O[S`WQO\O RS 3f^S`b]a S\ 8cdS\bcR @738 È\USZ 8 5]`R] : ^Sh >`]TSa]` BWbcZO` RSZ 2SÔ`bO[S\b] RS A]QW]Z]U O 7D S\ ZO C\WdSàWROR 1][^ZcbS\aS RS ;OR`WR Q]ZOP]ÒR]` RS 2WaQ]càS C\Wb g Q]]`RW\OR]` RS

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

c\ 5`c^] RS 7\dSabWUOQW \ C1; W\bS`SaOR] S\ SZ SabcRW] RS ZO 1cZbcÒ 2WUWbOZ g ;]dW[WS\b]a A]QWOZSa 1703@A=;=A/5C/A 6O ^cPZWQOR] Z]a aWUcWS\bSa ZWP`]a( >agQV]Z]Ug 2WaQ]càS >ÒQbWQS BOgZ]` 4Ò\QWa ''$ Q]\ 0c`[O\ Sb OZ ) BSQV\]aSfcOZ :O\RaQO^S Q]\ @ 1ZS[W\a]\ 4`SS /aa]QWObW]\ 0]]Ya " g 8 dS\Sa g 1cZbcÒ ;SaaS\US` 7<8CD3 4/2 $ Q]\ 7 ;SU Oa 3\b`S aca ^cPZWQOQW]\Sa [ta `SQWS\bSa aS W\QZcgS c\ bSfb] Q]]`RW\OR] Q]\ / AS`Ò\] 3abÒbSUWOa g >`tQbWQOa RS 7\dSabWUOQW \ 1cOZWbObWdO >SOà]\ & g ]b`] Q]\ 7 AtROPO 1cZbcÒ 2WUWbOZ g ;]dW[WS\b]a A]QWOZSa 1ObOÒbO & 7U\OQW] ;SU Oa ?cW` a 7\dSabWUOR]` a]QWOZ Q]\ SabcRW]a Tc\RO[S\bOZ[S\bS QS\bÒR]a S\ SZ QO[^] RS ZO XcdS\bcR SZ ]QW] ZO WRS\bWROR ZO QcZbcÒ g SZ Q]\ac[] ;WS[P`] RS A]QW]Z UWQO B`Sa /[^ZWO Sf^S`WS\QWO S\ W\dSabWUOQW \ QcOZWbObWdO :WQS\QWOR] S\ 11 3Q]\ [WQOa Sa^SQWOZWROR A]QW]Z]U O 3Q]\ [WQO C/; 3a^SQWOZWabO C\WdSàWbO`W] S\ A]QW]Z]U O RSZ 1]\ac[] C1; /cb]` g Q]Ocb]` S\b`S ]bÒa ^cPZWQOQW]\Sa RS µ:O WRS\bWROR XcdS\WZ RSaRS ZOa OTW\WRORSa [caWQOZSa¶ 7<8CD3 µ8 dS\Sa g `SZOQW]\Sa U`cÔZSa¶ 4/2 7<8CD3 µ6WX]a g ÔR`Sa( Q][c\WQOQW \ g Q]\TZWQb]a¶ 4/2 µ8 dS\Sa S\b`S a]\WR]a¶ 4/2 7<8CD3 ! µ:O ^S`QS^QW \ a]QWOZ RS Z]a ^`]PZS[Oa RS R`]UOa S\ 3aÔ O "¶ 4/2 " µ8 dS\Sa g aSf]¶ 4/2 7<8CD3 # µ:O P`SQVO US\SÒQW]\OZ S\ ZO SRcQOQW \ RS Z]a VWX]a¶ 4/2 # µ8 dS\Sa bWS[^] ZWP`S g Q]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa¶ 47A1/; # µ8 dS\Sa g QcZbcÒ [SaaS\US`¶ 4/2 7<8CD3 $ µ/R]ZSaQS\bSa O\bS SZ OZQ]V]Z¶ :O 1OWfO % g µ2]QS\bSa ] [OSab`]a( ^S`QS^QW]\Sa RS ZO SRcQOQW \ RSaRS RS\b`]¶ 4/2 & >]\S\bS S\ \c[S`]a]a T]`]a g X]`\OROa :OP]`Sa RS R]QS\QWO SZOP]ÒQW \ RS [ObS`WOZSa RWRtQbWQ]a g Q]]`RW\OQW \ RS RWdSà]a Qcà]a g [ObS`WOZSa ÔÒ Sf^S`b]a S\ XcdS\bcR 7<8CD3 C<32 C=1 4/2 C1:; AcaO\O ;{\RSh 5OU] :WQS\QWORO S\ >aWQ]Z]U O 1Z \WQO ^]` ZO C\WdSàWROR RS AOZO[O\QO 23/ ^]` ZO C\WdSàWROR 1O[WZ] 8]a{ 1SZO g 3a^SQWOZWabO C\WdSàWbO`W] S\ 3RcQOQW \ ÔÒ ZO AOZcR 3\ ZO OQbcOZWROR RW`WUS ZO 4c\ROQW \ 53 A]QWOZ RS 5@C>= 32C1/B7D= g Sa ^`]TSa]Ò RS µ>aWQ]Z]U O A]QWOZ g RS ZO =ÙO\WhOQW]\Sa¶ g µB{Q\WQOa RS =`WS\bOQW \ >aWQ]^SROU UWQO¶ S\ ZO C\WdSàWROR 1O[WZ] 8]a{ 1SZO 6O Ô`bWQWÔR] Q][] Q]Ocb]Ò g Q]RW`SQb]Ò RS RWabW\b]a ^`]UÒ[Oa g ^cPZWQOQW]\Sa S\b`S ]b`]a( µ;O\cOZ ÔÒ QcWROR] RS QcWROR]`Sa¶ % µ8 dS\Sa g aSf]( SZ SabS`S]bW^] _cS ]PZWUO g SZ `Wb] _cS WRS\bWTWQO¶ # µ0O\Q] RS VS`Ò[WS\bOa OcRW]dWacOZSa¶ # µG b ¥_c{ VOQSa-¶ " µ4O[W@SR¶ " µ<cSab`] SaQS\O`W]¶ ! µ<SQSaO`W]a¶ µ6WX]a g ÔR`Sa 1][c\WQOQW \ g Q]\TZWQb]a¶ µ>`SdS\W` ÔÒ dWdW`¶ µ:O ^`SdS\QW \ TO[WZWO` ;ObS`WOZ ÔÒ ^`]TSaW]\OZSa¶ ¶:]a dOZ]`Sa RS ZO a]QWSROR SaÔ ]ZO g ZOa R`]UOa¶ µ:Oa R`]UOa S\ ZO ^`SdS\QW \ RS `WSaU]a ZOP]ÒZSa¶ ''' ;O` ;]`]ZZ \ >O`R] B{Q\WQO Sa^SQWOZWabO S\ W\T]`[tbWQO RS USabW \ ;OR`WR '&% 2W^Z][ORO S\ 3RcQOQW \ A]QWOZ S\ ZO C\WdSàWROR RS 0O`QSZ]\O >]abUÒR] RS RS >O`bWQWÔQW \ g 2SaO``]ZZ] A]abS\WPZS S\ ZO C\WdSàWROR /cb \][O RS 0O`QSZ]\O 2cÒ\bS dO`W]a O ]a VO bÒPOXOR] Q][] ^`]TSa]Ò RS aSQc\RO`WO S\ [ RcZ]a T]`[OQW \ ^`]TSaW]\OZ RS W\T]`[tbWQO bO[PW{\ Q][] ^`]UÒ[OR]Ò g O\OZWabO RS aWabS[Oa S\ S[^`SaOa ^`WdOROa ;WS[P`]

8 dS\Sa g USabW \ RSZ `WSaU]

Tc\ROR]Ò RSZ 1]ZSQbWd] RS SRcQOQW \ /;/<7 2cÒ\bS dO`W]a O ]a [WS[P`] OQbWd] RS ZO =<5 0`WUOROa 7\bS`\OQW]\OZSa RS >Oh S\ 3aÔ O 3\b`S Z]a O ]a '&' g ''' VO dWdWR] g bÒPOXOR] S\ dO`W]a Ô aSa RS 1S\b`]O[{`WQO RSaO``]ZZO\R] g Q]ZOP]Ò\R] Q]\ ^`]gSQb]a `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ Z]a RS`SQV]a Vc[O\]a ZO SRcQOQW \ g ZO WUcOZROR g S_cWROR RS U{\S`] / Ô`bW` RSZ O ] VO bÒPOXOR] g Q]ZOP]ÒR] Q][] OaSa]Ò g Q]\acZb]Ò S\ ^`]UÒ[Oa RS W\QZcaW \ a]QWOZ S\ 1ObOZc O g Q]\ S[^`SaOa ^`WdOROa 3\ Z]a ZbW[]a O ]a VO aWR] ZO `Sa^]\aOPZS RSZ t[PWb] RS dW]ZS\QWO TO[WZWO` g RS U{\S`] RSZ 7@3A 7\abWbcb] RS @SW\aS`QW \ A]QWOZ /QbcOZ[S\bS Q]]`RW\O SZ >ZO\ RS W\bS`dS\QW \ W\bSUÒZ S\ SZ PO``W] RS ZO ;O`QO RS Z¸6O[ S\ 4WUcS`Sa g Q]ZOP]Ò Q]\ dO`WOa S\bWRORSa a]QWOZSa S\ bS[Oa `SZOQW]\OR]a Q]\ ZO Ô`bWQWÔQW \ ZO W\[WUÒQW \ g SZ U{\S`] 3ZS\O @]R` UcSh AO\ 8cZWt\ A]QW Z]UO ;WS[P`] RS A]QW]Z UWQO B`Sa >`]TSa]Ò Oa]QWORO RSZ 2SÔ`bO[S\b] RS A]QW]Z]U O 7D ;{b]R]a g B{Q\WQOa RS 7\dSabWUOQW \ A]QWOZ g BS]` O RS ZO 1][c\WQOQW \ RS ZO C1; g [WS[P`] RSZ 1]\aSX] RS 2W`SQQW \ RSZ 7\abWbcb] RS ZO 8cdS\bcR RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO 6O aWR] 8STO RSZ AS`dWQW] RS /\tZWaWa g >`]a^SQbWdO RS ZO 1]\aSXS` O RS AO\WROR RS 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO g 8STO RSZ 2SÔ`bO[S\b] RS 3abcRW]a S 7\dSabWUOQW \ RS ZO 4c\ROQW \ RS /gcRO Q]\bÒ ZO 2`]UORWQQW \ /cb]Ò g Q]Ocb]Ò RS \c[S`]a]a SabcRW]a a]P`S ZO `SOZWROR a]QW]QcZbcÒZ RS Z]a X dS\Sa a]P`S Oa^SQb]a a]QWOZSa RS ZO aOZcR ZO SRcQOQW \ g Z]a Q]\ac[]a RS R`]UOa 3\b`S aca ZbW[Oa ^cPZWQOQW]\Sa RSabOQO\ µ3Z 3a^SX] RS Z]a [SRW]a( c\ SQ] RS WRO g dcSZbO¶ 4c\ROQW \ 5SA]QWOZ & ¶ µ8 dS\Sa S\ Z]a [SRW]a( ZO W[OUS\ [SRWtbWQO RS ZO XcdS\bcR RSaRS ac ^`]^WO [WÒRO 4/2 7<8CD3 % µ/R]ZSaQS\bSa O\bS SZ OZQ]V]Z( ZO [WÒRO RS ÔR`Sa g [OR`Sa¶ :O 1OWfO % 3dOZcOQW \ RSZ ^`]UÒ[O RS ^`SdS\QW \ RSZ Q]\ac[] RS R`]UOa S\ 1OabWZZO :O ;O\QVO¶ 811; ><A2 %

@3D7AB/ 23 3ABC27=A 23 8CD3<BC2 § aS^bWS[P`S & q \ &

≥ Septiembre 08 | Nº 82

Jóvenes y gestión del riesgo

Durante las últimas décadas hemos definido el riesgo, acotado sus dimensiones, categorizado sus componentes, estandarizado sus niveles, determinado los perfiles y los ámbitos de riesgo, diseñado, aplicado y evaluado programas para prevenirlo. En definitiva, hemos tenido –y tenemos- un largo historial de compromiso y dedicación en el trabajo exhaustivo para la creación de herramientas que nos defiendan del riesgo. Hoy existe en el sentir colectivo una sensibilización hacia el término riesgo y una mejor predisposición hacia todo aquello que lo minimice o lo elimine. Es por eso quizá que ya no necesitamos aferrarnos tan fuertemente al término en sus distintas dimensiones, y podemos salirnos de la sombra de su presión para empezar a observarlo desde fuera. Incluso para poner en cuestión algunas de las supuestas “certezas” consensuadas. Este monográfico tiene la finalidad de aproximarse al riesgo con otra óptica, incorporando también su sinónimo, la oportunidad, y desde su otra función, la positiva. Para ello, en este documento se revisaran posiciones teóricas y se cuestionarán axiomas ampliamente aceptados con objeto de movilizar hacia una nueva aproximación al polisémico concepto del riesgo.