5.21.2018 by Iowa State Daily

IOWA STATE DAILY

MONDAY

‘A SYSTEMIC ABDICATION’

Title IX complaint filed by tennis player

MAY

SARAH HENRY/ ISD

New Sloss director chosen

2018

Vol 129 No. 163 HIKING HIGHLIGHT

BY K.RAMBO @iowastatedaily.com

JILL O’BRIEN/ ISD

If you need a break from Ames but don’t want to drive far, Don Williams Park offers recreational activities such as hiking, swimming and fishing.

pg7

SPECIAL OLYMPICS

KENNEDY DERAEDT/ IOWA STATE DAILY Sophomore Erin Freeman played for Iowa State Tennis on April 23. Freeman went 2-6 against Viadica Babic of OSU. The Cyclones fell 0-4 against Oklahoma.

BY NOAH.ROHLFING @iowastatedaily.com Iowa State women’s tennis player Erin Freeman has filed a Title IX complaint against Iowa State University through the United States Department of Education, Office of Civil Rights, according to her attorney, Don Maurice Jackson.

MIKINNA KERNS/ ISD

An Iowa Special Olympics athlete competes in the Women’s 100 Freestyle during the swimming portion of the summer games in Beyer Hall on May 18. pg6

DELTA TAU DELTA

JILL O’BRIEN/ ISD

Delta Tau Delta fraternity was charged with a level two sanction on May 15, according to the Office of Student Conduct. It is the fraternity’s third sanction since 2016, and one of 36 greek-related sanctions. pg8

The complaint filed on Wednesday alleges that, among other things, the Iowa State athletics department created a “hostile educational environment.” Freeman provides 67 statements in the complaint, naming Iowa State Athletic Director Jamie Pollard, Senior Associate Athletic Director Calli Sanders and assistant coach Olga Elkin. Former women’s tennis head coach Armando Espinosa was also named in the filing.

Freeman says that members of the university have attempted to “drive me out of the women’s tennis program and have deprived me of educational opportunities based upon my race.” Freeman mentions former assistant coach Olga Elkin multiple times in the complaint. According to Freeman, Elkin “frequently engaged in openly hostile behavior towards both African-American players,” and “stated that the [women’s tennis program] would save money if they were not required to include Liera Bender, the other African-American team member, on road trips.” The allegations involving Elkin do not stop there. According to Freeman, Elkin left her near the campus of Bethune-Cookman College in Daytona Beach, Florida, during a February 2018 trip. Bethune-Cook-

TITLE IX

pg6

Of Mud and Oil: The Dakota Access Pipeline BY ZACH.STREUBER @iowastatedaily.com LaVerne Johnson popped a Lifesaver mint into his mouth and motioned out in the direction of the field outside his house. “I want to tell you how brazen these people are,” he said. Johnson’s wrinkled face grew serious as he paused. “These sons-of-b*****s don’t have any care at all. They don’t have any care at all about anything,” he said. Johnson was upset — angry, even. Less than a football field length away, a giant valve sprouted from the ground. To a typical passerby, the valve might be the only sign of the Dakota Access Pipeline. But this is Johnson’s land, and he doesn’t need to look at the valve to see the pipeline’s impact on his property. In June, 2014, the Texas-based company Dakota Access LLC, a subsidiary of Energy Transfer Partners, announced its intentions to build a $3.8 billion, 1,172 mile-long pipeline from North Dakota to Illinois. Throughout the Dakotas, Iowa and Illinois, Dakota Access started buying up land. Across the Midwest, farmers, environmentalists and Native American tribes retaliated. Protests against the pipeline’s construction stretched along the route, exploding into an especially nasty confrontation

Zach Streuber/ IOWA STATE DAILY “I think the ground I have, what they did to it, I don’t think that it will ever come back to be what it could be,” said Steve Hickenbottom.

in North Dakota in November 2016. Dakota Access was able to continue its march to Illinois through a reversal by the Trump administration and agreements in Iowa with the Iowa Utilities Board to access land via eminent domain. What land Dakota Access couldn’t buy, it took through eminent domain. Through subcontractors Precision Pipeline and Ellingson Tile, the company began to start construction on the pipeline in June 2016.

PIPELINE

pg3

Ruxandra Looft was announced as the new director of the Margaret Sloss Women’s Center on Wednesday afternoon, after a series of forums and interviews. Looft, known to students, faculty and staff as Sandra, was born in Romania and holds a doctorate in German and comparative literature. Looft has been with Iowa State since 2010, as a lecturer of German and international studies and an Academic Advising Coordinator in the world languages and cultures department starting in 2013, though she began with the department in 2010. Looft also lectures in the women and gender studies department and leads a study abroad program in Germany for the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences. Alissa Stoehr, a sociology and women’s and gender studies professor and interim director of the Margaret Sloss Women’s Center, said she’s looking forward to working with Looft. “I am very excited that Dr. Looft has joined the staff at the MSWC,” Stoehr said. “She has a wide range of knowledge and experience that will lend well to the mission and values of the MWSC.” Stoehr moved into the role as interim director in February 2018, after the departure of Lorraine Acker. Looft said she has her goals and ideas but is deeply interested in hearing input from students, faculty and staff. She said she wants to continue the trend of the Sloss Women’s Center being open to all on campus. Looft said she applied to be the director for many reasons and had been involved with the Women’s Center since first arriving on campus. “My own research and writing in publications are all focused on gender studies,” Looft said. “Naturally, my scholarship factored heavily into what I teach, it also factors highly into my involvement on campus.” Check out the Daily’s events calendar inside.

Iowa State Daily Monday, May 21, 2018

Crossword

17 How poets write? 19 Like a classic French soup 20 Tree of Knowledge locale 21 How moonshine is made? 23 Quick summary 26 Learned 27 Actress Thurman 28 Bath bathroom 29 Go to the bottom

Sudoku

Down 1 One going downhill fast 2 __ Kush mountains 3 Port in a storm, so to speak 4 Score to shoot for 5 Taxing initials 6 Knitter’s coil 7 Part of LPGA: Abbr. 8 What the cold-blooded don’t feel 9 She performed between Creed-

by the Mepham Group

LEVEL:

1 2 3 4

Complete the grid so each row, column and 3-by3 box (in bold borders) contains every digit, 1 to 9. For strategies on how to solve Sudoku, visit www.sudoku. org.uk

IOWA STATE DAILY BUSINESS DIRECTORY Jackson Cleaning Service

•Residential Cleaning •Getting Your Home Ready For the Market

Call us at 231-3649 • RENTALS:

Guaranteed Your Rental Deposit Back!

•Windows •Deep Cleaning • Sorority& Fraternity

3 & 4 bedroom houses for rent.

Clean, good condition, appliances, new kitchens, hardwood floors in kitchens and dining rooms. Good locations, both walking distance to downtown. 4 Bedroom available immediately, 3 bedroom available Aug. 1. Call Joyce 515-460-2488 or Tim 515-450-2125

THUR WED

TUE

MON

70 54 79 63 86 65 85 64 84 64 86 60 82 58

FRI

ence and Sly at Woodstock 10 Sends away 11 Aloof 12 Napa vessels 13 Piggery 18 Last 22 Needs a fainting couch 24 Saudi neighbor 25 WWII female 28 Hard-hit ball 30 Clickable image 31 Coming up 32 Florida __ 33 Blue-and-yellow megastore 34 Stash finder 35 Willard of “Best in Show” 36 Brewpub 37 Pre-final rounds 42 Speaker between Hastert and Boehner 45 Coffee order 46 Pickup at a 36-Down 48 Picasso, for one 52 Justice Sotomayor 53 “Easy-peasy!” 54 Fictional Doone 55 Go through entirely 56 Small bite 57 Short notes? 58 Small bite 59 Lowers, as lights 61 X-ray kin 63 Ont. neighbor 64 L.A. campus

SAT

1 “That’s enough from you!” 4 City whose tower’s construction began in 1173 8 Pops out of the cockpit 14 Seoul-based automaker 15 Bulky boats 16 Hit one’s limit, in slang

33 How parts of a whole can be written? 38 Middling grade 39 “Doctor Who” actress Gillan 40 Taylor of fashion 41 Strong glue 43 Lyrical preposition 44 How a priest preaches? 47 Electrically flexible 49 Lyrical preposition 50 Feel crummy 51 World power until 1991: Abbr. 53 Spirits brand with a Peppar variety 57 How kangaroos travel? 60 Former Cubs slugger 61 Meadow lows 62 How some paper is packaged? 65 Land on two continents 66 Squeaker in Stuttgart 67 Big fan 68 1987 Beatty flop 69 Freelancer’s detail 70 Big primate

SUN

Across

WEATHER AT-A-GLANCE Cloudy during the day Partly cloudy

Isolated thunderstorms Morning thunderstorms Morning thunderstorms Partly cloudy

Partly cloudy

WEATHER COURTESY OF WEATHER.COM

CALENDAR Monday, May 21 6 p.m. to 8:30 p.m. Beginning photography classes, Reiman Gardens Wednesday, May 23-26 Odyssey of the Mind World Finals, Iowa State University Wednesday, May 23 3 p.m. to 6 p.m. North Grand Farmers’ Market, North Grand Mall, 2100 Grand Avenue, JC Penney’s parking lot Wednesday, May 23 7 p.m. to 9 p.m. First Generation Immigrants in Story County, Ames Historical Society

Saturday, May 26 8 a.m. Ames Main Street Farmers’ Market, 300 and 400 blocks of Main Street, Ames Saturday, May 26 8 a.m. North Grand Farmers’ Market, North Grand Mall, 2100 Grand Ave, JC Penney’s parking lot Saturday, May 26 12:00 p.m. to 12 a.m. Folk Music Festival, Durham Bandshell Park

CORRECTIONS Last week’s paper displayed an incorrect graphic on the percentage of students who reported experiencing unwanted sexual contact; the number for students who had experienced unwanted sexual conduct (11 percent) was displayed in the place of those who had experienced unwanted sexual contact (3 percent). The Daily regrets this error.

The Iowa State Daily welcomes comments and suggestions or complaints about errors that warrant correction. To submit a correction, please contact our editor at 515-2945688 or via email at editor@iowastatedaily. com.

IOWA STATE DAILY

The Iowa State Daily is an independent student news paper established in 1890 and written, edited and sold by students.

References • Insured & Bonded • 27 Years Experience • Gift Cards Available

Main Office Retail Advertising 294-4120 Newsroom 294-2003

Andrea Dahl Copy Chief

Jill O’Brien Managing editor of content Mikinna Kerns Visuals editor

Noah Rohlfing Sports editor

Sandeep Stanley Opinion editor

K. Rambo Editor in chief

294-2403

Editor

284-5688

PUBLICATION BOARD: Professional members Chris Conetzkey The Des Moines Business Record Kyle Oppenhuizen Greater Iowa Credit Union Andrew Pritchard Greenlee School Kim McDonough College of Liberal Arts and Sciences Paxton Williams Iowa Department of Justice

Story City

Lincoln Way Ames, 232-5715

Ames

Nevada

Ames

3300 North Grand Ames, 663-0819

Student members Grant Heineman Chairperson Qianqian Shan Graduate College Kingsley Jewett At Large Matt Tjaden College of Business Jennifer Poncelet At Large

Xue Bai College of Engineering Grant Heineman College of Ag and Life Sciences Savanna Falter College of Design Mackenzie Jones College of Human Sciences

Susan Kloewer State Historical Society of Iowa

Ames

1533 Broad St. Story City, 733-2844 Hwy 30/Dayton Exit Ames, 233-5550

WE ACCEPT

Publication: ISU students subscribe to the Iowa State Daily through activity fees paid to the Government of the Student Body. Fall & Spring sessions: The Iowa State Daily is published Monday through Friday during the nine-month academic year, except for university holidays, scheduled breaks and the nals week.

Summer sessions: The Iowa State Daily is published digitally on a daily basis. Opinions expressed in editorials belong to the Iowa State Daily Editorial Board. The Daily is published by the Iowa State Daily Publication Board, 2420 Lincoln Way, Suite 205, Ames, Iowa, 50014.

Subscription costs: Subscriptions are 40 cents per copy or $40 annually for mailed subscriptions to ISU students, faculty and sta . Subscriptions are $62 annually for the general public. The Publication Board meets at 5:15 p.m. on the fourth Wednesday of the month during the academic school year.

Postmaster: (USPS 796-870) Send address changes to: Iowa State Daily 2420 Lincoln Way, Suite 205 Ames, Iowa 50014 PERIODICALS POSTAGE

Monday, May 21, 2018 Iowa State Daily PIPELINE

pg1

The route was set and Dakota Access was in a hurry. Every day the pipeline was delayed, Dakota Access was losing upwards of $20 million dollars, they claimed. And hurry they did. It took only three years for oil to begin flowing through the Bakken pipeline, but the impact it made in Iowa might take a lifetime to fix. Muddy Domains It was not long after the pipeline was announced that Dakota Access came to part-time farmer Dave Lowman and offered to buy a right-of-way through a 100-acre parcel of his land outside of Ames. The right-of-way consists of a 150-foot long strip of land. The 30-inch pipeline is typically buried in a 50 foot segment, surrounded by two adjacent 50 foot segments that are used to keep the dirt while work is happening on the pipeline. Lowman refused, citing environmental and housing development concerns. “I didn’t like the offer...plus I thought it was an environmental accident waiting to happen,” said Lowman. Dakota Access proceeded through eminent domain. The pipeline ran through a 100-acre plot of land that contained some woodland and farmland, crossing a small stream twice in the process. Lowman had been agitated before by the company after they burned the trees they cut down instead of giving it to him like they promised but was astonished to see them working on the pipeline shortly after a flash flood warning had been announced in his area. “They went out and started pushing my topsoil...they pushed all of the topsoil when it was soaking wet, which was definitely something they said they would not do,” said Lowman. For Lowman, the ground was virtually destroyed, especially in areas that had previously been used for crops. They were “basically pushing mud and damaging the structure of the soil,” he said. A few miles west of Lowman, tenant and retired farmer Tom Ross had much the same experience. The oil company accessed Ross’ five acres of farmland through eminent domain after he refused offers of direct compensation. Ross saw firsthand the pipeline’s rapid progress but was not pleased when he found them working in wet conditions. “They were just ignorant with rain, and they would be out there pushing dirt and driving their Cats [equipment]...it just got packed as hard as a road; you probably couldn’t pound a hammer into the ground,” said Ross. “I think that [if ] you would ask anybody, they would agree with me on it, that as a farmer after a big rain, we obviously stay out of the field, because we knew the consequences that we would pack the ground hard,” he said. The pipeline’s construction practices were not confined to central Iowa, either. In Fairfield,

ZACH STREUBER/ IOWA STATE DAILY LaVerne Johnson was given the “Century Farm” award in 2016, just days before construction started on his property.

Iowa, Steve Hickenbottom said the pipeline wreaked havoc to his fields. The owner of about 1,000 acres of farmland, Hickenbottom also resorted to eminent domain when Dakota Access offered to buy a right-of-way on his land. On an eight-acre swath of land running across a 170-acre field, the pipeline was buried deep in the ground. It took six excavators and eight bulldozers to complete the job, which was too much weight on such a small area of land, Hickenbottom said. “When you dig [the pipeline] 25, 30 feet deep or even 10 feet deep, you’ve disrupted that normal flow of moisture going through the ground... and when you put the dirt back in and pack it down, the grains of soil aren’t like they were before so now that water, that was flowing through there, is not flowing through,” he said. Hickenbottom now says he has water containment issues, something that he has worked half his life to perfect. Terraced ridges built to contain the water flow have been destroyed and the tiling beneath the surface has been ripped apart, Hickenbottom said. “We’ve been in the drainage business and dirt works for about three generations, and you cannot move 30 feet of dirt and put it back like it was before. You might make it look like it on top, but it’s never going to be the same,” he said. For Hickenbottom, the drainage issues are more immediately concerning than the productivity of the soil. “It isn’t any good remediating the soil if the ground is too wet to farm on,” he said. Hickenbottom planted corn in the field last year and assessed the damage that he believes the pipeline had wrought. Although there was a drought throughout the growing season, it was

COURTESY OF DAKOTA ACCESS The proposed route of the Dakota Access Pipeline through 18 of Iowa’s 99 counties.

“It will never return to its original state. It is maginal if most of it can return to productive corn or soybean use... much of it will never be productive from an economic standpoint.” obvious to Hickenbottom where the pipeline lay. “Where they went through with the pipeline, [the yield] was like zero. It drew some stalk but there was no corn,” he said. “It Will Never Return to its Original State” For Boone native Keith Puntenney, soil health is a major concern and a negligible yield from farmland is a worst-case scenario. Owner of 610 acres, Puntenney did not hesitate to challenge Dakota Access’ right to eminent domain when the company came calling. A lawyer and farmer by trade, Keith Puntenney has been at the forefront of the charge against the oil company, helping to take a lawsuit challenging their right to eminent domain in Iowa to the Iowa Supreme Court. Therefore, when Dakota Access started construction on Puntenney’s and close friend and neighbor LaVerne Johnson’s land, Puntenney’s perspective was only affirmed. Using a commercial drone to gather pictures of the construction, the farmers said they found evidence of Dakota Access damaging their soil. “We know that there is a lot of really deep subsoil compaction based on the pictures and everything else we have discovered,” Puntenney said. Puntenney also discovered that Dakota Access had been mixing the topsoil and the subsoil, something that could be very damaging to crops. “They changed the till, they changed the composition of the soils, they totally disrupted the enzymes and the micronutrient activities that has been percolating there for over 10,000 years,” he said. Combined with other construction malpractices, such as soil compaction, poor drainage,

pipeline placement and soil remediation among other things, Puntenney believes that Dakota Access has effectively destroyed the productive capacity of much of the 6,000-acre route the pipeline took across Iowa. “It will never return to its original state. It is marginal if most of it can return to productive corn or soybean use... much of it will never be productive from an economic standpoint,” he said. The Silent Thief As a leading research university in agronomy, Iowa State is aware of the pipeline’s potential risks to cropland in Iowa. In a partnership with Dakota Access, scientists led by Mehari Tekeste at Iowa State are researching the pipeline’s impact upon the soil. The research project is aimed squarely at evaluating the effects of pipeline construction and soil compaction and remediation of the soil. This research is funded by a $600,000 subsidy from Dakota Access. A spokeswoman from parent company Energy Transfer Partners only responded to the Daily through email. “We are pleased to have partnered with Iowa State University on this research project and look forward to the project’s development over the next couple of years. Regarding the Dakota Access Pipeline, we are pleased to confirm that it has been safely operating for nearly a year. We understand that landowners and others have varying opinions on infrastructure projects such as Dakota Access. We always strive to work cooperatively with landowners, as we will be part of the communities through which we pass for decades,” the company said. Tekeste declined to disclose any information

Iowa State Daily Monday, May 21, 2018 PIPELINE

pg3

on the project to the Daily, stating only that findings of the study won’t be published for another year or two. While Tekeste looks into the impacts of the pipeline, other researchers such as Dr. David Kwaw-Mensah are also in the process of studying the effects of soil compaction. Kwaw-Mensah is a research associate at Iowa State who specializes in soil management and is not affiliated with the pipeline research project. “[Soil compaction] increases the soil bulk density, which in effect impacts the volume of roots that can grow in that soil,” he said. “When the roots of that plant cannot explore a wider volume of the soil, it means that the plant will not have enough nutrients, it will not have enough water and the plant won’t have enough air and this is what affects root growth,” he said. “Some people call it the silent thief,” he said. “It steals from a plant.” Central Iowa’s soil is composed largely of loam clay, which Kwaw-Mensah thinks is some of the worst soil to conduct construction in. “When they crush the soil like that, especially with a good clay content and it dries up, it becomes like concrete. It’s hard, like cement,” he said. “The amount of water that a soil can hold also reduces when subjected to compaction,” Kwaw-Mensah said. This will result in drainage issues, which can damage the crops surrounding the affected area, he said. Right now, the farmer say biggest issue confronting them is how to fix it. “It’s like you have a wound. The wound would take time to heal. But once it heals, the scar is the there. And in case you want to remove the scar... if you are going to use some products to remove the scar, it is going to take some time,” he said. According to Kwaw-Mensah, the soil could take anywhere from a minimum of three years to decades to start being remediated, and even then, it might never be fully restored to its original condition. For farmers, this often isn’t feasible economically. “A year that goes by without a farmer using his land to make an income is like slow death,” said Kwaw-Mensah. An Issue of Compensation The past few years, farmers have needed every scrap of land they own. According to figures released by Iowa State University, the average price of corn per bushel from 2015 to 2017 dropped 37 cents and soybean prices dropped nine cents. This, coupled with unproductive land and

increases in payments over time. Puntenney will be arguing that Dakota Access didn’t take into account the potential value of the land in a district court in 2019. “The problem is that when you destroy land, you are destroying the future value of the land... everything you put on it is losing money,” Puntenney said. Hickenbottom also thinks that the pipeline reduces the value of his land, due to its location in the fields. Since the pipeline cuts diagonally across the field, it significantly depreciates the rest of the 162 acres in the field, Hickenbottom said. “You’ve not only touched eight acres, you’ve affected the whole 170 acres... you can’t fill an eight acre strip out,” he said. Hickenbottom believes that Dakota Access did not take this into consideration when he was compensated. “They didn’t pay me near what that ground was worth,” he said. Hickenbottom was paid $15,000 for eight acres. According to the Iowa State University Farmland Value Survey, the value of eight acres of similar land in Southeast Iowa was estimated to be upwards of $30,000. In the survey, the average value of all the grades of farmland (low, medium and high grade for crop production) per acre in central Iowa was estimated to be $8,097. In southeast Iowa, the average value of all grades was approximated to be $6,864 per acre. Hickenbottom estimates that the tile that had to be repaired from the construction and other remediation costs have totalled more than $100,000 and will largely come out of his own pocket. As of May 2018, Hickenbottom has been paid for a blunder in the pipeline’s construction and for five years worth of crop damages. Ross has been paid for crop damages and says that he has been compensated fairly for his losses. “They have been very good at not questioning the payments for damages. They’ve been good about that,” he said. However, Puntenney and Johnson haven’t been paid yet. Those who have been fighting Dakota Access with lawsuits and haven’t made any side agreements have been ignored, Puntenney said. “We have not gotten paid for anything. For crop damage, for remediation, for anything. Dakota Access has just walked away from us and said ‘see you later,’” said Puntenney. Energy Transfer Partners responded, stating that “our restoration efforts along the route, including in Iowa are still in progress, which is why our easement agreements contained a payment schedule for crop loss, which is 100 percent the first year, 80 percent for loss year two, and 60 percent for year three.” In the end, however, Hickenbottom says that one of the most valuable things he has

“I spent 30 years fixing this [land] up. . . I don’t have another 30 years to fix it again.” expenses to repair the soil surrounding the pipeline, leave farmers in a daunting situation. Dakota Access is required by law to pay for taking land through eminent domain. The company paid Puntenney $16,000 for two and a half acres, a sum that Puntenney says is gross undersell. “That’s a very low amount for the land,” he said. Puntenney was planning on adding his sum of his farmland to the wind turbine field that surrounds his property, which would have made each acre worth more than $10,000 with

lost is time. “I spent 30 years fixing this [land] up... I don’t have another 30 years to fix it again,” he said. A Persistent Problem When the Iowa Utility Board granted Dakota Access the right to put a pipeline through Iowa, the Board required that the company follow an Agricultural Impact Mitigation Plan to help keep soil destruction to a minimum. Puntenney has compiled his findings on whether Dakota Access followed the guide-

ZACH STREUBER/ IOWA STATE DAILY Eminent domain and voluntary easement are both ways of acquiring property from landowners, but involve different negotiation processes.

lines to construction into a large case study. According to Puntenney, what he has seen so far indicates that Dakota Access has not. Independent inspection firm ISG is currently inspecting the surface and subsurface soils, drain tile and soil remediation in 13 of the 18 Iowa counties. Once the inspections are finished, the ISG reports will be sent to the county auditors where they can be accessed. The county supervisors will then decide whether Dakota Access followed the Mitigation Plan. While ISG could not give the Daily a timeline on when the reports would be completed, Puntenney is confident it will be within the next couple of months. “We are helping people get ready to go to the county and say ‘hell no’ and then the county will have to investigate,” he said. “We have 1,257 parcels and 910 landowners at risk here. That’s what we have in 17 counties. And most of them don’t know how much damage has been done, and we are trying to let them know,” Puntenney said. A Fight for the Future When the battle against Dakota Access started, Puntenney and Johnson knew that they were not going to be fighting for only themselves. “I’m old and LaVerne’s old — we’re both in our 70’s. Our farms were legacy farms to be

passed on to the next generation, and we were trying to protect those acres and our farms in general to be passed on to the next generation,” Puntenney said. Hickenbottom also has his kids in mind, and passing the farm down is his whole objective. But now, he is not sure that he wants to. “Right now, depending on what comes out of this whole thing, I don’t know if I want to try to pass it on to my children, I mean would you? Would you feel comfortable leaving them with that kind of liability?” he said. Three years ago, farmers across Iowa experienced Big Oil through the Dakota Access Pipeline. Some, like Ross, have had relatively minor issues compared to the experiences of Hickenbottom. “It’s taken hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of years for the soil to create its structure that it has, and when you go down that deep and tear everything up and put it back, it’s just not that simple,” said Ross. For farmers like Hickenbottom, the whole experience has left more than just a bad taste in their mouths. “I have not talked to one person who has had the pipeline go through even if they consented to it would do it again today if they had to do it over again,” he said. “The trouble is, it’s not over yet. But the media hype is done.”

Monday, May 21, 2018 Iowa State Daily

COLUMN

Phone replicas sacrifice quality BY SANDEEP.STANLEY @iowastatedaily.com

Cell phones have become one of the most ubiquitous sights in our interconnected society — they are one of the most versatile tools for both business and everyday life. With the astronomical prices that even mid-range name brand phones are, however (a new, unlocked iPhone 7 costs $549 when purchased from Apple, and a Samsung Galaxy S7 costs $399 from Walmart), there is a rapidly expanding market for low-cost cellular devices. Enter Goophone, a manufacturer of smartphones, tablets and smartwatches based in Shenzhen, China. Goophone is one of various Chinese and Thai electronics manufacturers that are creating knockoffs that look almost exactly the same for half the price. Their products can be easily found on almost any wholesale website — for example, the Goophone i7 (the knockoff version of the iPhone 7) costs only $71.25 on DHgate.com, a popular supplier.

Cheap lookalikes, nearly indistinguishable from the authentic product, for a fraction of the cost — sounds perfect, right? Not exactly. First of all, there is the issue of the internal components — after all, with a $470 price difference, some corners have obviously been cut; the drop in quality, however, is steeper than most believe. A major component that falls short in the Goophone i7 is the CPU itself. The iPhone 7 harnesses the A10 Fusion, which was designed by Apple and is manufactured by TSMC in Taiwan. This high-end processor costs a staggering $429 at Walmart, while the MediaTek MT6580 (the CPU utilized by the Goophone) is a modest $80. The A10 Fusion fully warrants its steep price, however, handily outperforming its Chinese competitor in almost every specification. The clock speed, which is an indicator of how fast the processor is able to perform tasks, sets the tone, with the Apple chip performing at an impressive 2.34 GHz while the MediaTek processor comes in at 1.3 GHz. Other numbers back up this suggestion that the maximum speed of the A10 is superior, boasting six CPU threads to the MT6580’s four and a front-end width of six over a measly two. Because of its relatively weak processor, the Goophone also loses some important features. Apple’s quad-core construction is designed with two high-capacity cores and two other low-power cores, meaning that a judicious user can assign simple tasks to the low-power cores to conserve battery. However, not only do the Goophone processor’s four cores all run at the same speed (meaning that power-saving mode is not an option!), the speed they clock in at is barely higher than that of the Fusion’s low-power cores. This is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to the Goophone’s deficiencies. The iPhone’s resolution is 1334 by 750 pixels while the Goophone’s is a measly 960 by 540; the iPhone has 128 GB of storage

while the Goophone only has 4 GB; the iPhone’s camera is a staggering 12MP while the Goophone can only claim 5MP; the list goes on and on. Goophone has also been the subject of some worrying legal and ethical controversies in the past. In 2012, Goophone used leaked images of the iPhone 5 found online to patent an iPhone 5 design in China before Apple could. They went so far as to aggressively threaten legal action against Apple — while no suit was filed, in no small part due to a provision in Chinese intellectual property law protecting any designs which “[have] been publicly disclosed in publications in the country or abroad”, it was only one incident in a growing series of patent infringement cases involving Apple and Chinese manufacturers. With China having long overtaken the United States as the world’s largest smartphone market — and with India in second — imitation is becoming more and more of a concern. Manufacturers of these knockoffs can sell them in bulk to unscrupulous street vendors and electronics stores in China and India for sale with an enormous markup, taking advantage of unsuspecting customers. In fact, the presence of Goophones and other imitations on wholesale sites like DHgate indicate this is already taking place. Not only are Goophones and other knockoff phones low quality products, the manufacturers use dubious practices to obtain their designs. The market for low-cost phones contains so many other options — reputable manufacturers like Huawei and Honor provide comparable quality to brands like Samsung and LG for a fraction of the price. Goophones also offer none of the security features that Apple and Samsung offer built into their operating systems; in fact, with how unethical their practices have been, it would be wise to check for invisible malware, spyware, and adware that have been installed in their place. So next time an ad pops up for something that looks like a Galaxy S7 for $60, just remember the old maxim: if it looks too good to be true, it probably is.

COLUMN

Suburban poverty fails to be addressed BY DANIEL.SHAW, djshaw@iastate.edu

Suburban poverty is a shrouded development that has blindsided the nation within the past couple decades. In the past, suburbs were understood to be regions where middle-class Americans could settle down and get away from the hustle and bustle of city life. However, in a recent Brookings Institution analysis of the 2015 U.S. Census and American Community Survey data, the population of people in poverty living in suburban communities surpassed 16 million — outnumbering the poor population in cities by more than 3 million. Despite this development, poverty continues to be generalized as an “inner-city problem.” In a Quartz article titled “American Poverty Is Moving to the Suburbs,” Dan Kopf explains how the geography of poverty in the United States is continually misrepresented. For example, in his inauguration speech in 2016, President Donald Trump painted a picture of “(m) others and children trapped in poverty in our inner cities.” While he was not wrong in stating that poverty is still an issue in our inner cities, he failed to bring the slightest attention to the larger population of people that struggle with poverty. This dangerous misrepresentation of the geography of poverty will lead to policies that end up doing more harm than good. People who struggle with poverty in the suburbs face very diverse challenges, much different than people who struggle with poverty in the inner cities. While some might argue that suburban surroundings provide a comparatively better chance for people to work their way out of poverty, due to lower crime rates and better schools, suburbs often fail to offer many of the same resources that inner cities do to help people in poverty. Some of these resources include access to public transportation, philanthropic aid and a strong safety net.

In a testimony given before the House Ways and Means Committee, Elizabeth Kneebone, research director at UC Berkeley’s Terner Center for Housing Innovation, discusses these challenges that are particular to suburban poverty. She reasons that the lack of public transportation means that, “by and large, suburban residents are dependent on owning and maintaining a car—and must bear the associated costs—to reach employment opportunities that are often growing in other parts of the region”. In addition, due to the common misconception that poverty is mainly an issue in the inner cities, “philanthropic resources continue to disproportionately flow to urban centers,” leaving suburban communities with less assistance, which further compounds the problem. The nonprofit safety net in suburban communities also, “tends to be stretched thin, with relatively fewer providers serving larger catchment areas than in cities.” These suburban challenges clearly differ from the difficulties found in the inner cities and serve to illustrate how suburbs are less prepared to provide assistance for those in poverty. In recent news, Trump signed an executive order, promoting work requirements for safety-net programs. It’s clear that Trump is pushing to decrease welfare dependency by attempting to promote employment with incentives; however, this would actually cause even more suffering to people who are already struggling. In a 2010 Brookings Institution analysis on unemployment, suburbs contained 6.4 million people that were unemployed - more than double the number in cities. The executive order would, in fact, be harder on suburban communities, due to their higher populations of unemployed people. On the flip side, there are many people who have jobs

but just aren’t making enough to get by. A study by GOBankingRates released earlier this year analyzed the cost of living in 35 major cities and their suburbs to determine where it was cheapest to live. The results revealed that living in the city was cheaper in 25 out of the 35 areas studied —clearly demonstrating that the cost of living is generally higher in suburban communities. Another Brookings Institution analysis from 2014, on the geography of low-wage work, revealed that 67 percent of workers in low-wage occupations lived in suburban communities. With a higher cost of living and large amounts of low-wage employment, being a working-class member of the suburban community often does little to change a person’s dependency on welfare. Clearly, Trump’s idea that being employed is all it takes to reduce welfare dependency is fundamentally flawed. In the future, it is imperative that more research in taken into consideration — and that much more time is spent crafting policy that will meet the needs of more people. It’s time to update Franklin D. Roosevelt’s “war on poverty” to keep up with the changes in the geography and challenges of poverty; making our suburbs better prepared to accommodate low-income populations is a vital part of this initiative. Society today finds it easier to keep generalizing poverty as an issue of the inner cities, when it is a critical issue in other places as well. Educating the public on the new challenges people face with poverty will help kickstart the conversation around solutions and help the American people to move forward as a less divided nation.

Iowa State Daily Monday, May 21, 2018

Special Olympics: More Than Medals

MIKINNA KERNS/ IOWA STATE DAILY Athletes competing in the Iowa Special Olympics enter Hilton Coliseum during the opening ceremony May 17. This is the 34th time Ames has hosted the Iowa Special Olympics.

BY TREVOR.HOLBROOK @iowastatedaily.com Billy Habermann earned a pair of gold medals in singles and doubles tennis at the Special Olympics this week. Habermann had his medal he won on Friday morning secure in his shorts pocket. Meanwhile, he sat with his friends and chatted, while watching other doubles teams compete. When asked to show his gold medal, Habermann threw it around his neck with a smile on his face. The gold medal was important to Habermann, but it took a backseat to other things gained from the Special Olympics. Through the Special Olympics, Habermann can cultivate friendships with the other competitors. Habermann connected with his doubles partner, but he also gets to meet thousands of athletes from across the state — in 2017, the Special Olympics Iowa report tallied 14,961 participants. “It’s a good way to keep in touch with friends that they normally wouldn’t see since they aren’t together everyday,” said Billy’s father, Bill. Iowa has been Habermann’s main location for competition, but he said that he plans to branch out by attending the National Special Olympics in Seattle in July. Habermann said he’ll stick to the tennis courts in Seattle. Special Olympics provides an opportunity for its athletes to not only branch out geographically, but also in the sports in which they participate.

Habermann said that tennis is his favorite sport, but he’s dipped his toes in other events as well. “Tennis, softball, basketball, bowling, golf [and] track,” Habermann said when he listed off the different events he’s done. Habermann said he doesn’t know when he’ll stop competing, but his father said he doesn’t think Billy has any plans to stop soon. The foundation of Habermann’s athletic experiences has been his family. Habermann — a Sioux City, Iowa native — had his mother and father, Bill and Cathy Habermann, in attendance in Ames. The Habermann family bonds throughout the Special Olympics, and Bill coaches other members of the Sioux City Knights. “Three years of tennis, but other sports [I’ve coached] six or seven years,” Bill Habermann said. “I got started because [of ] my son, Billy. It’s just something I love to do, it’s honestly the most rewarding thing I do.” Billy has a platform to grow as a person through new relationships, new locations and new sports. The Habermann family has a platform to grow as a family, but while Billy is building new friendships, so are the Habermanns. “It’s a great community of families, too,” Cathy Habermann said. “We have so many family friends that our family is friends with their family, because our children/adults compete and have competed for years, so it’s just an extension of our family.”

An exerpt from Erin Freeman’s Title IX filing.

TITLE IX

COURTESY OF DON MAURICE JACKSON

pg1

man College is a historically black college and Freeman said in the complaint that Elkin leaving Freeman there “appeared to be based upon both her hostility towards (Freeman) and her apparent lack of desire to be present on the campus of a historically black college.” Freeman also alleges that Elkin “engaged in conduct that was calculated to remove me from the women’s tennis program and to terminate my financial aid.” Freeman was sent a letter of suspension from Senior Associate Athletics Director Callie Sanders on April 11, court documents show. The letter from Sanders indicated that student-athletes on the team had come to Sanders of their own volition and that her behavior was “affecting your teammates.” According to Freeman, the meeting was set up by Elkin and a trainer named “Ashley” through a group text that Freeman says she inadvertently received. Freeman also provided photo evidence of the text conversation in the complaint. Subsequently, Freeman received another letter from Sanders on May 8 that reinstated her to the tennis program. The same day, head

coach Armando Espinosa and the Iowa State women’s tennis staff was informed that they would not have their contracts renewed. John McCarroll, Iowa State director of university relations, declined to comment when reached out via email. Sanders also declined to comment. “Ms. Freeman’s treatment within the ISU Department of Athletics represents one of the most troubling abdications of authority that I have seen in a university athletic department,” Jackson said in a statement provided to the Iowa State Daily. “She approached two senior level administrators in the ISU Department of Athletics and requested that they address her selectively harsh treatment. On each occasion, she was summarily dismissed. “The ultimate responsibility for her treatment rests on the shoulders of Jamie Pollard and Calli Sanders. There appears to be a systemic problem in the ISU Department of Athletics relative to the manner in which female and minority student-athletes are treated.” Jackson called the situation a “systemic abdication of responsibility in the athletics department.”

Marner: Overturn on sports gambling ban is good BY AARON.MARNER @iowastatedaily.com On May 14, the United States Supreme Court overturned a 25-year-old ban on sports gambling, effectively AARON allowing each state to make MARNER their own laws regarding wagering on sports. Almost immediately, bills were introduced in states across the country in an effort to legalize sports gambling. Per the Des Moines Register, State Rep. Jake Highfill already has plans to introduce a proposal in January. There are positives and negatives that come with the overturn on the sports gambling ban. From a sports perspective, the positives overwhelmingly defeat the negatives. I’m not going to drone on about how great it will be for the state of Iowa to use the money

for good. I’m speaking strictly from a sports perspective. The overturn on the ban is one of the greatest things to happen in the sports world... Ever. I was listening to The Sports Fanatics on KXNO radio this week, and Chris Williams summed it up nicely. “This is the same thing as fantasy football 15-20 years ago,” Williams said. “The NFL exploded when fantasy football became easy to use on the internet. Fantasy football in its purest form is a form of gambling. “People watch the NFL differently now.” Williams nailed it. Unlike the MLB and NBA, the NFL’s schedule makes playing fantasy sports easy. The rise of fantasy sports in the 1990s and 2000s coincided with the NFL’s popularity boom. This became something of a joke in recent years as fans would tweet at athletes about their fantasy performances. “Nobody cares about your

fantasy team” became a kind of rallying cry for fans, coaches and players who wanted to focus on the action on the field. But make no mistake — this will draw in casual fans by the thousands, increasing visibility for issues in the realm of sports and also highlighting its beauty. I think the same thing can happen for the MLB, NHL, NBA and college athletics as soon as sports gambling is made legal here in Iowa. Interest in sports will go up. Events like the NCAA Tournament, which already sees a ton of money wagered on it, will become even more intriguing. Professional baseball has struggled slightly in recent years with attendance and viewership. MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred has made it a goal to improve pace of play, as one of the common critiques of the game is that it’s played too slow, with too much downtime between the action.

Now? Games will be far more interesting to fans who have money on the action, leading to increased viewership and, hopefully, a better product on the field as leagues focus on improving themselves instead of adapting to draw more eyes. It’s been estimated by the American Sports Betting Coalition that $58 billion will be spent wagering on football games this year, with only $2 billion of that being wagered legally. Now that it’s open, less money will be exchanged under the table. If anything, overturning the federal ban will help with transparency and corruption. The ban being overturned is good for the sports world. It will change how sports are viewed for a long time, a change the world of sports desperately needed. Casual fans now have a reason to care about sports before the playoffs, and that will make the product on the field even better.

Monday, May 21, 2018 Iowa State Daily

HIKING HIGHLIGHT

Don Williams Park offers activities for all ages BY JILL.OBRIEN @iowastatedaily.com Named for the Iowan singer, Don Williams Park is located about 26 miles from Ames (about a 33 minute drive) and has hiking trails, a 150acre lake, campsites and a nine-hole golf course. The 600-acre park is located on the Don Williams Reservoir, which overflowed when a dam was being constructed just outside the park. The lake is open to those fishing, boating and swimming, according to the Iowa DNR. It is also the headquarters for Boone County Conservation, and the campgrounds are open from April 15 until Oct. 15. What Don Williams Has to Offer Before you drive out to Don Williams Park, get to know what the park has to offer so you can prepare for what you want to do: •

Self-registered campsites (first come, first serve)

•

128 electrical campsites with 30 amp breakers ($18/ night)

•

20 electrical campsites with 50 amp breakers ($20/

Rules at Don Williams If you’re interested in visiting, here are the do’s, don’t’s and need-to-know’s of Don Williams Park:

MIKINNA KERNS/IOWA STATE DAILY Don Wiilliams Park offers recreational opportunities, such as camping, swimming and hiking.

night) •

2 group campsites ($18/night)

•

27 non-electrical campsites ($11/night)

•

Boating

•

No wake lake

•

Hiking trails

•

Bait and tackle shop

•

Nine-hole golf course and restaurant

•

Swimming beach

Courtesy of mycountyparks.gov

Park hours: 5:30 a.m. to 10:30 p.m. Vehicles: Only licensed vehicles are allowed on park property. Camping: Camping is allowed, but campers cannot stay for longer than 14 days. Quiet hours: Quiet hours are enforced in campsites from 11 p.m. to 6 a.m. Pets: Must be leashed at all times Handicap accessible: Yes

Jethro’s BBQ All You Can Eat Graduation Brunch Buffet Saturday May 5th Sunday May 6th 8:30am-3pm HAND CARVED PRIME RIB AND PIT HAM CREATE YOUR OWN OMELET BAR

Jethro’s Slow Smoked Wings Bubba’s Boneless Wings

FRESH ATLANTIC SALMON TEXAS BRISKET PULLED PORK CHICKEN FRIED STEAK BISCUITS AND GRAVY LOADED EGGS CORN BEEF HASH HASHBROWN CASSEROLE

French Toast Bacon Sausage Mac & Cheese Green Beans Mashed Potatoes & Gravy Fresh Fruit Bread Pudding Strawberry Shortcake Cheese Cake Brownies Cookies Muffins Toast And Many More Jethro’s Favorites

1301 Buckeye Ave 515-598-1200 Call for Reservations of 6 or More

MIKINNA KERNS/IOWA STATE DAILY Don Williams Park is Boone County Conservation’s largest park and includes a 150 acre lake.

Iowa State Daily Monday, May 21, 2018

NEWS 08

FEATURE PHOTO

MIKINNA KERNS/ IOWA STATE DAILY

DON WILLIAMS PARK Emotional support dog Emma enjoys a drive to Don Williams Park for a night of camping with her human friends.

Delta Tau Delta sanctioned

Chapter receives third sanction since 2016

COURTESY OF WIKIMEDIA COMMONS

Men’s golf makes NCAA Championships BY NOAH.ROHLFING @iowastatedaily.com The Iowa State men’s golf team has qualified for the NCAA Championships, after a thirdplace finish in the Stockton Regional. The Cyclones had a final team store of -17 and finished the third day with a team score of 3-under-par 285. Senior Denzel Ieremia entered the day alone in third place on the individual leaderboard, but he shot a 2-over-par 74 and fell to ninth place. Sophomore Sam Vincent made a move up the leaderboard with a 2-under-par 70, finishing in a tie for fifth place at -8. Freshman Lachlan Barker finished with a final round 70 as well. Freshman Frank Lindwall shot an even-par 72 and sophomore Tripp Kinney shot a oneover-par 73 to round out the Cyclones’ scoring. The Cyclones are one of seven Big 12 teams to make the NCAA Championships, joining Kansas, Baylor, Texas, Texas Tech, Oklahoma State and Oklahoma. The NCAA Championships will be held on May 25-30 in Stillwater, Oklahoma.

JILL O’BRIEN/ IOWA STATE DAILY Delta Tau Delta will be required to hold an alcohol awareness workshop for new and active members prior to the first day of fall term classes, where there must be 90 percent attendence.

Delta Tau Delta fraternity has been charged with a level two sanction from the Office of Student Conduct, according to their website. It is the third sanction that they have received since 2016. The sanction, dated May 15, included the misuse of alcoholic beverages and contempt. According to the Student Disciplinary Regulations handbook, misuse of alcoholic beverages includes “the illegal possession, use, manufacture, distribution or sale of alcoholic beverages or controlled substances both on and off campus” and providing alcohol to anyone who is underage. According to the handbook, con-

tempt is defined as: Failure to appear before any university adjudicatory or regulatory body as summoned; Failure to comply with any disciplinary sanctions or interim measures; Failure to comply with the directive of authorized university officials or police officers; Failure to identify oneself or to show an identification card when requested to do so by authorized university officials or police officers; or Providing, procuring, or seeking to procure, false testimony in any university or administrative process.

According to the OSC website, Delta Tau Delta will be required to hold an alcohol awareness workshop for new and active members prior to the first day of fall term classes, where there must be 90 percent attendance and review risk management policies and prevent unregistered events from occurring by Sep. 14, 2018. In addition, the fraternity’s conduct probation and social host probation have been extended through Dec. 15, 2018. Of the 39 sanctions listed on OSC’s website, 36 of them are greek.