3 minute read
Do We Live in an Evil Universe?
Sophie Burley explores the cosmological axis of evil, and questions whether the Universe we live in can really be considered evil.
Why are we here? How do we exist? How did the universe come into being?
Advertisement
Some of life’s greatest questions are shared by philosophers and cosmologists alike. Physicists act as detectives, piecing together astronomical‘evidence’, turning back time, uncovering how things began. For now, the leading theory is the ‘Big Bang’ which suggests the Universe exploded out from a singlepoint, expanding and stretching in all directions. There are two strong pieces of evidence in support of this theory. The first is that even after all this time, the universe is still expanding. The second is the existence of the Cosmic Microwave Background.
itself. Since its accidental
“Physicists act as detectives, piecing together astronomical ‘evidence’, turning back time, uncovering how things began.”
You are more than likely thinking that this name is a little dramatic. So what?
Well, if everything did start with a Big Bang, one thing we generally expect is that no matter where you are or where you look, all the properties of the Universe will be the same. No obvious mappable features, no ‘landmarks’, nothing that would let you know your whereabouts. There certainly shouldn’tbe anything special about our little corner of the cosmos, and yet that is exactly what has been observed. This irregularity acts like a beacon, a ‘google maps pin’, or a comedically big cartoon arrow pointing out our location. In short, it’s a big problem for physicists. It threatens our most promising theory on the origin of the universe, which is why they named it the “Axis of Evil”. The Universe and its inhabitants (you and me) aren’t villains, but this real-life space oddity has the power to destroy everything we thought we knew.
This is far from the first time we’ve been forced to re-evaluate our position in the universe. Early astronomical observations and a strong sense of human significance led to Ptolemy’s geocentric view placing Earth at its centre. This thinking did not last, and the Copernican Revolution saw the Earth’s position downgraded for the first time, in favour of a heliocentric universe surrounding our Sun. Following further demotion, we now finally accept our place on an average planet, orbiting an average star, in just one part of a potentially infinite universe. With each paradigm shift, we have been forced to cast aside our importance and acknowledge that the Universe simply does not revolve around us. At least, we're fairly confident it didn't, but the Axis of Evil is raising questions, with physicists even describing it as “the ghost of Copernicus”. An astronomical haunting is rather unlikely, but definitely goes some way towards communicating the mystery surrounding this anomalous observation.
Initially, a large percentage of physicists assumed its existence was merely a mechanical error or fluke, but with repeated study and improved instrumentation, it is an ‘error’ that has yet to vanish. In fact, last summer a new and innovative sky survey was published. Rather than mapping the temperature of the CMB, this study mapped the spin direction of rotating galaxies and like its predecessors confirmed the ‘evil’ observation. It is reasonable to assume that errors can propagate through a CMB study, as the radiation itself is so faint and easily contaminated by light within our universe. However, Lior Shamir who conducted the galactic rotation survey, points out:
“We have two different sky surveys showing the exact same patterns, even when the galaxies are completely different. There is no error that can lead to that. This is the universe that we live in. This is our home.”
So, there we have it. It looks like we may officially live in an ‘evil’ universe, but then I suppose the next step is to determine what that actually means…
artwork: Patryk Starzykowski background artwork: Kiah Fisher
