Integration of transport & land-use The case of the Leiden - Gouda area
Delft, 24th Januari 2013
Jasper Bras: 1402579
Table of content
• Rationale & problem statement • Case study & research • Conclusions & design
2
Betuwelijn
Source: thomas Schlijper - www.vn.nl
3
Randstadrail
Source: thomas Schlijper - www.vn.nl
4
Complex technogical systems • Integration with the environment • Stakeholder participation
5
1: Integration of policies 2: Devolution of powers
6
Infrastructure
Land-use
Spatial interactions 7
Infrastructure
Land-use
Spatial interactions 8
Infrastructure
GOVERNANCE
Land-use
Spatial interactions Influenced by governance
9
NATIONAL Infrastructure PROVINCIAL Infrastructure MUNICIPAL Infrastructure
Three tiers of governance
GOVERNANCE
GOVERNANCE
GOVERNANCE
Land-use
Land-use
Land-use
10
NATIONAL Infrastructure PROVINCIAL Infrastructure MUNICIPAL Infrastructure
Changing power relations
GOVERNANCE
GOVERNANCE
GOVERNANCE
Land-use
Land-use
Land-use
11
1: Integration of policies
2: Devolution of powers
12
• Law reforms: Wro (2008) • National planning documents (2011)
Ministerie van Infrastructuur en Milieu
National
Ontwerp Structuurvisie Infrastructuur en Ruimte Nederland concurrerend, bereikbaar, leefbaar en veilig
Provincial
Ontwerp Structuurvisie Infrastructuur en Ruimte
Municipal
13
• Law reforms: Wro (2008) • National planning documents (2011) Top sectors & networks
t (inter)nationale bereikbaarheid van stedelijke regio’s met topsectoren
National Kaart (inter)nationale bereikbaarheid van stedelijke regio’s met topsectoren
Provincial
Stedelijke regio met topsectoren Mainport Schiphol Mainport Rotterdam
Municipal
Brainport Zuidoost Nederland Greenport Zuidas Stad van internationaal recht, vrede en veiligheid HSL /ICE station Overige luchthaven van nationale betekenis Zeehaven van nationaal belang Binnenhaven van nationaal belang Stedelijke regio met topsectoren
Voornaamste achterlandverbindingen
14
National
Provincial
‘Regional gap’
Municipal
15
Province
Railway line
Municipalities
Possible impact on regional infrastructure
16
Complex technological systems: binding story, institutional & operational structure
17
Complex technological systems: binding story, institutional & operational structure
18
Space
Railway line
Multi-dimensional
19
Space
Institutions
Railway line
Multi-dimensional
20
Space
Institutions
Railway line
Multi-dimensional
Process
21
Problem statement # Aim
What are the issues of governance between local planning agencies, around the integration of sectoral policies on mobility and land-use and around the implementation of a transport infrastructure project such as the Rijn Gouwe Lijn at regional level?
22
Problem statement # Aim
What are the issues of governance between local planning agencies, around the integration of sectoral policies on mobility and land-use and around the implementation of a transport infrastructure project such as the Rijn Gouwe Lijn at regional level? What planning mechanism could address issues of governance, facilitate integration of policies and support the implementation of such projects?
23
Theory # TIP-model
Space
Institutions Study & Design
1. Technical (spatial) design 2. Institutional design 3. Process design
Process
Source: Koppenjan, J. & Groenewegen, J. (2005)
24
Theory # TIP-model
Space
Institutions Study & Design
1. Technical (spatial) design 2. Institutional design 3. Process design
Process
Source: Koppenjan, J. & Groenewegen, J. (2005)
25
Theory # Integrated transport planning
Space
Institutions
Process
Single modes
Multi-modes
Accessibility modes (TOD)
Source: CURTIS, C. & JAMES, B. (2004)
26
Transit zones Source: www.zaanstreek.nl
27
Source: BALZ, V. & SCHRIJNEN, J. (2009)
28
1. Rural areas
2. Small towns
3. Outskirts of cities
4. Cities of the future
5. Business sites
6. Regional crossroads
7. Randstad hubs
8. Creative cities
9. City centres 29
Theory # Adjustment of policies
Space
Institutions
Process
Integration
Coordination
? Cooperation
Source: STEAD, D. & MEIJERS, E. (2004)
Fragmented field of interest
Degrees of adjustment 30
Theory # Institutional relations
Space
Institutions
Institutions
Process
Province
Municipality A
Municipality B
31
Theory # Institutional relations
Institutional structures
Space
Institutions
Process
Province
Project organization/ authority
Municipality A
Municipality B
32
Theory # Institutional relations
Institutional structures
Space
Institutions
Process
Nested territorial institutions
Strategies/ frameworks of flexible response Nested territorial institutions
Nested territorial institutions
Source: SALET, W. (2006)
33
Theory # Institutional capacity
Space
Institutional capacity
Institutions
Process
â‚Ź Material
Resources
Financial
Legal
Intellectual
34
Theory # Institutional capacity
Institutional capacity
Space
Institutions
Process
Do the instutions have the attitude to adjust their policies? ...or the attitude to collaborate?
Governance culture
Source: www.synobys.nl
Theory # Strategic spatial planning
Space
Institutions
Process
Long term vision
4-tracks
Long-term & short-term actions
Contact stakeholders
Involvement citizens/ interest groups Source: Albrechts (2004)
Case study area
37
Case study area # Location
Leiden
Alphen aan den Rijn Zoeterwoude Rijnwoude Boskoop
RGL West RGL East Rijn-Gouwelijn
Waddinxveen
RijnlandRoute (RR)
Gouda Zuidplas
N 38
Case study area # Location
39
Case study area # Location
40
Case study area # Project agreements Research Research Research Research Research on on on on on practice practice practice practice practice#### #Institutional Institutional Institutional Institutional Institutional analysis analysis analysis analysis analysis
Stops
Spatial program
Contribution per unit
Financial distribution RGL project agreement (2005) Source: Source: Source: Source: Source: 1st 1st 1st Project 1st 1st Project Project Project Project agreement agreement agreement agreement agreement RGL RGL RGL RGL RGL East East East East East (between (between (between (between (between all allall muncipalities, all muncipalities, all muncipalities, muncipalities, muncipalities, province, province, province, province, province, Rijkswaterstaat Rijkswaterstaat Rijkswaterstaat Rijkswaterstaat Rijkswaterstaat and and and and ProRail) and ProRail) ProRail) ProRail) ProRail) (2005) (2005) (2005) (2005) (2005)
Total sum
Key distribution ďƒžgures (municipal)
41 119 118 117 116 115
Case study area # Integration of policies
â‚Ź financial
Policies for compact development around transit zones
culture - policies - instruments
42
Empirical research
43
?
Empirical research # Studies
Spatial
?
?
?
?
• Spatial patterns of the region [mapping] • Station typologies [field/photo study] • Adjustment of plans between agencies [mapping]
Institutional & process
?
?
? ?
• Observation of the project agreements [desk research] • The adjustment of policies [interviews] • Institutional structures & capacity [mapping & interviews]
?
Empirical research # Spatial studies
Empirical research # Spatial studies
Empirical research # Spatial studies
47
Boskoop Small town
Source: GOOGLE STREET VIEW (2012) 48
Waddinxveen Zuid Industrial/business site
Source: GOOGLE STREET VIEW (2012) 49
Empirical research # Institutional structure Mileudienst West-Holland
Noordwijkerhout
Nieuwkoop
Hillegom Lisse
Actor
Rijnstreekberaad
Noordwijk
Partnership
Alphen a/d Rijn
Teylingen
General partnership
Holland Rijnland
Katwijk
Rijnwoude
Oegstgeest
Economic relation
Kraag en Braassem
Environmental relation
Greenport Boskoop
Voorschoten Leiden
Zoeterwoude Leiderdorp
Stichting Land van Wijk en Wouden
Stichting Groenfonds Midden-Delfland
Reeuwijk
Den Haag Zoetermeer
Planning relation
RGL-East
Bodegraven
Boskoop LeidschendamVoorburg
Schoonhoven
Oude Rijnzone
Waddinxveen
Water Board
Bergambacht
Midden-Holland
Vlist Province of Zuid-Holland
ZevenhuizenMoerkappelle Greenport Westland-Oostland
National government
Nieuwerkerk a/d IJssel
Midden-Delfland Private actors
Pijnacker-Nootdorp
Westland
Nederlek
Regionale ontwikkelingsorganisatie Zuidplas
Ouderkerk Moordrecht
Gouda
Natuur & recreatieschap Reeuwijkse Plassen
Partnership region Gouda
Lansingerland Rotterdam
50
Empirical research # Interviews
Interviews
• • • • • •
Province of Zuid-Holland (2x) Regional partnership Holland Rijnland Chamber of Commerce (KvK) ProRail Municipality of Zoeterwoude Involved alderman municpality of Leiden 51
Empirical research # Interviews Mutual competition between participants
“The interventions of the municipality where very limited - non-interventions. Each municipality had strong individual interest. The cohesive element was created by the province.” - Rep. C
“It was a project wherein everybody thought it could realize their aims but the aims where not always corresponding. Eventually the project became the aim itself and not the instrument anymore to achieve the aim.” - Rep. C
“The RGL-East does no appeal on the partnerships but on the partnerships, but on the municpalities. The first project agreement has been made between all municipal governments individual, which required a relatively comprehensive steering group. This can be seen as one of the issues regarding the institutional structure on the RGL-East.” - Rep. C
52
Empirical research # Interviews Insufficient integrative concepts, visions & policies
“Almost no one can explain anymore what the original ambitions, visions or reason behind the RGL was or everybody tells a different story: there is no shared vision, no shared ambition.” - Rep. C
“There has neither been a good supporting story for the RGL nor a good concept - never.” - Rep. C
“We now see that the project and its organizational structure was strongly oriented towards traditional infastructure policies: the project office had a strong focus on the technical aspects, but not on the areas around the stations.” - Rep. B
“The ‘Verordening Ruimte’ or ‘inpassingsplan’ is not integral, it is committed to one singel sector.” - Rep. B
53
Empirical research # Interviews Insufficient culture for public-private partnerships
“The provincial government has the right instrument and authority, but has an administrative culture which is not there to invite NGO´s and private actors regarding such projects...” - Rep. G
“For the RGL there was no publicprivate partnership, which has to do with the political and adminstrative culture of the province.” - Rep. D
“The province did neither exclude nor invate private actors directly.” - Rep. B
“The collaboration between the province and ProRail was one without trust. (…) This is mainly because the province did not have sufficient technical expertise regarding such projects, and did not want to give ProRail the room for contribution...” - Rep. E 54
Empirical research # Interviews Insufficient steering culture (province) & communication between participants
“The communication between the involved actors should have been better and should have been started in an earlier stage.” - Rep. D
“Origionally, there was alomost no mutual correspondance between the participating municipalities, the assumption was that the province would do the communication.” - Rep. C
“...the provincial government has the executive boards which are quite reserved in the use of instruments that would steer development on local level, that is not part of the administrative culture.” - Rep. B
“The municipalities had more contact with the provincial government than with each other. (...) In global lines we knew what the plans of other municipalities where, but often we did not know how far they were in their plans.” - Rep. F 55
Empirical research # Level of policy adjustment
Integration
Coordination
?
Cooperation
Fragmented field of interest
?
Conclusions
Spatial
?
?
?
?
• ‘Liberal’ planning policies at local level: dispersed development • Absence of strong (integral) vision for the region and no clear link with a supporting development concept for the project • Little adjustment of policies on mobility and land-use • Differentiation along the line: different station environments
Institutional & process • • • •
?
?
?
?
Province: appropriate legal authority and planning instruments Insufficient ‘governance culture’ for adjustment of policies Insufficient trust between public and private actors Presence of project organization, but with too little authority, and responsible for the implementation of the project • Absence of platform for negotiation - no clear communication among stakeholders and no joined vision
?
Design
58
Design # Spatial, institutional, process
Space
Institutions
Design
Process
59
Design # Process design
Track 1 Track 1 Long-term vision Long-term vision
Track 2 2 Track Long-term & Long-term & short-term actions
Track 3 Track 3 Contact with Contact with stakeholders
Define integrative concept
Policy adjustment Policy adjustment railway stations & land-use
Define institution. structure Invite NGO’s & civl committ. Define institution. structure environment Invite NGO’s & civl committ. province - regional partnerships - KvK
Define integrative concept TOD TOD
short-term actions
railway stations & land-use
Track Track 4 4 Basic process with Basic process with citizens/interest groups
stakeholders
Integration
Integration
citizens/interest groups
province - regional partnerships
environment - KvK
Coordination
Coordination
Define alliance (PPS) stakeholder alliance
Cooperation
Define alliance (PPS) stakeholder alliance
Cooperation
Define financial mechanism regional & pension funds + TDR
Define financial mechanism regional & pension funds + TDR €
€
60
Design # Process design Cooperation
?
Potential stakeholders local authorities (semi-)private actors NGO´s
Lower authority brings subject to higher agenda
Active participation
Transparancy
Open vision
Platform for discussion
Project authority
Legal framework
Process of decision-making in order facilitate collaboration and adjustment of policies
Regional authority Province
Interactive simulation
Policy adjustment
Governance culture: Willing to collaborate?
Responsibility
Planning instruments
Agreements
Monitoring
Integration
61
Design # Spatial design Regional structure vision + concept of TOD
Development conditions around stations Waddinxveen Zuid office - industrial site
A
A
1. Mix of functions 2. High densities:
r = 1200m
FSI 1,0 - 3,0 (depending on location) Section A-A
3 1
urbanizing corridors residential expans.
preserved cultivated landscape
green greenbuffers buffers
town hall
library
wo/hbo/mbo
intensive agriculture
commercial commercial
museum
(music) theater
swimming
H
hotel/ camping cultural landmark
62
Design # Spatial design Regional structure vision + concept of TOD
Development conditions around stations Boskoop small town - village
A
A
1. Mix of functions 2. High densities:
r = 1200m
FSI 1,0 - 2,0 (depending on location) Section A-A
3 1
urbanizing corridors residential expans.
preserved cultivated landscape
green greenbuffers buffers
town hall
library
wo/hbo/mbo
intensive agriculture
commercial commercial
museum
(music) theater
swimming
H
hotel/ camping cultural landmark
63
Design # Institutional design
Municipality Leiden
Municipality Zoeterwoude
Municipality Rijnwoude
Municipality Gouda Province Zuid-Holland
Municipality Alphen a/d Rijn
Municipality Waddinxveen Municipality Boskoop
64
Design # Institutional design
Province Zuid-Holland
Partnership Holland Rijnland
Partnership Midden-Holland
Involve regional partnerships instead of municipalities individually
65
Design # Ready for change?
Are the authorities open for changes? Are the authorities open for changes? Change your governance culture...
66
Design # Ready for change?
They have to!
Source: http://blog.eboardsolutions.com
67
Thank you!
68