Whatdowemeanbyvalue?
Valueisoneofthosetermsthateverybodyusesbutnobodycandefine.
Thedefinitionweuse:Whatsomeonewouldpayusfor.
Paymentcanbeinmoney,time,attention,orrespect.
Therearetwowaystocompeteinbusiness.
Havethelowestcosts.
Havethehighestquality.
Whenthinkingaboutvalue,therearefourpricepoints:
OurcostOCisthemoneywespendtomakeandsellourproduct.
CompetitorʼscostCCisthemoneyourcompetitorsspendtomakeand selltheirversion.
OurpriceOPandCompetitorʼspriceCParewhatcustomerspay.
CustomerperceivedvalueCWPisthemaximumthecustomerwillpay.
LowestpossiblecostLPCisthelowestanyonecouldspendtomakethe product.
Whencompetingoncosts,weaimtoreduceourcoststobelowerthanour competitors.
Thisway,ourpricetoourcustomerscanbelowerthantheircoststomakeand sell.
Theylosemoneyoneverysaleiftheytrytomatchourprice.
Wecanonlylowerourcoststothelowestpossiblecost.
Thislimitswhatwecandotocompete.
Whencompetingonquality,weaimtodiscoverandimproveaproductattribute thatraisesthecustomerʼsperceivedvalue.
Thatproductattributecanbeanythingmeaningfultothecustomer.
Suchasreliability,perceivedstatus,oruserexperience.
Peoplearewillingtopaymorewhenweraisethecustomerʼsperceivedvalue. Theyʼllpayforanyproductthathasthatmeaningfulattribute.
ThevalueofGreatUX
Whenweproduceexperiencesthatcausefrustration,weʼrecreatingPoorUXfor ourusersandcustomers.
Whenweproduceexperiencesthateliminatefrustration,wecallthatGoodUX.
Whenweproducedelightfulexperiences,wecallthatGreatUX.
PoorUXiswhenwemissexpectationsanddonʼtmeetourusers'andcustomersʼ needs.
GoodUXiswhenwemeetexpectationsandmeetthecustomerʼsactiveneeds.
GreatUXiswhenweexceedtheusersʼexpectationsandanticipatethe customersʼneeds.
Includingneedstheycouldnʼthaveexpressedbeforewemetthem.
PeoplewillpaymoremoneyforGoodUXthanforPoorUX.
TheyʼllpaythemostmoneyforGreatUX.
ThecostsofPoorUX
Wheneverwedeliverapoorexperience,itusuallyshowsupsomewhereinthe organization'sfinances.
Wecallthesethecostoffrustration.
Lostsales
Increasedsupportcosts
Increasedtrainingcosts
Decreasedproductivity
Increased“damagecontrolˮ
Increaseddevelopercosts
Increaseddeveloperwaste
Thesequantitiescanbeconvertedtomonetaryunits.
TheyreflectaquantityofUXdebt.
Discoveringthesenumbersmightneedtotakealittledetectivework.
Weoftenestimatethemintermsoflaborcosts.
Example:Tocalculateacostpersupportticket,use:
ThetotalcostofoperatingsupportinayearNumberoftickets handledinayear.
Toestimatethetotalcostofoperatingsupport:
Numberofsupportrepresentatives*Estimatedsalaryandemployment costs
Iʼveincludedalistofcostcalculationformulasyoucanuse.)
ConstructingProblem-valueMetrics
ThedefinitionsoftheOutcome-drivenUXMetricframework.
Measure:anobservablequantityofanobject'sstate.
Metric:measuresthatwetrack.
Analytics:measuresthatcomputerscantrack.
KPIs:Importantmetrics
Problem-valuemetricsareusuallyongoingcosts.
Thatmeanstheygoupifwedon'ttakeactiontocurbthem.
FixingtheUXissuesisusuallyaone-timefixedcost.
Thatmeansthatitwon'tcostanymoreonceit'sfixed.
Fixedcostsarealwaysbetterforabusinessthanongoingcosts.
Thisishowyouwintheheartsofthosewhocontrolpursestrings.
Remember:Animprecisenumbercanstillbeaccurate. Youonlyneedenoughprecisiontogettherightpeopleʼsattention.
Saying,“WeʼrespendingalmostamilliondollarsayearsupportingthisUX problem.ˮisaccurateyetimprecise.
Saying,“Wespent$974,371.45lastyeartosupportthisUXproblem.ˮis moreprecisebutdoesnʼtaddanyurgencyorimportancetotheclaim.
Donʼtbeafraidofstatinginaccuratenumbers.
Aback-of-the-envelopeguessisoftenagoodplacetostart.
FeelfreetouseSWAGsScientificWild-AssGuesses).
Ifitʼsclose,itmaybeaccurateenough.
Sometimes,thebestwaytogetamoreaccuratenumberistopresentanotso-accuratenumber.
Someonewillannounce,"That'snottherightnumber,"andgoofftofindthe rightonetoprovehowwrongyouare.
Whendealingwithanumberyoususpectisinaccurate,coptoit.
“IknowmyestimateofamilliondollarsislikelyoffsinceIguessedsome keyvalues.However,letʼssayitʼsonlyhalfthat.Spendinghalfamillion dollarsthisyear,andthenagainnextyear,isstillalotofmoney.Isthat whatwewant?ˮ
Bytrackingthesecosts,wecanshowthesizeofaproblemtotheorganization. Byconvertingthemtomoney(dollars,euros),wecancalibratethevalueto othercorporateexpenditures.
Thesenumbersbecomehelpfulinorganizationswhereshowingreturnon investmentROIisessential.
Often,apersonisalreadyinchargeofreducingtheexpenseweidentify. Wecallthesefolkshiddenchampions. Theymaynotbeimmediatelyvisibletous.
Theymaynotbeourmanagerorourmanagerʼsmanager.
Theycouldbeinacompletelydifferentpartoftheorganization.
Theymayhavealotofinfluenceintheorganization.
Oncetheylearnthatwefiguredoutawayforthemtosavemoney,theyget veryexcitedtohelpus.
Theybecomechampionsofourinitiativestomaketheproductbetter. Theycanusetheirinfluencetomakeourmetricmorevisible.
WhenpoorUXhasbeendeliveredforalongtime,thenumbersgrowsignificantly. WewinwhentheexecutiveleadershiprealizestheymustfixtheUX. Insteadofcontinuingtocosttheorganizationmoney.
ThisbecomestheseedweplantforwhybetterUXisanintelligentinvestment fortheorganization. ExampleProblem-valuemetricscalculations
SupportCosts
Lookforpeoplededicatedtomanagingclients.
OftencalledAccountmanagersorcustomersuccess. Youcancalculatetheircostssimply:
Estimatethesalaryofeachindividual.
$200,000ismygo-toSWAGScientificwild-assguess)forafullyburdenedsalary.
Multiplysalariesbynumberofpeople.
$200,000300people$60,000,000peryear.
IfdealingwithproblemscausedbypoorUXissuesisonlypartoftheir responsibility,estimatehowmuchoftheirtimeisspentdealingwiththat.
$60,000,000x½$30,000,000
LookforUXcallsorticketscomingintoasupportcenter.
Estimatethecostpercall.
Numberofsupportstaffxsalary
300supportstaffx$200,000/year$60,000,000
Dividethesupportcostbythenumberofcallsorticketstheyhandle eachyear.
$60,000,000600,000ticketsperyear$100/ticket
CalculatethenumberofticketshandledeachdayonUXissues.
200ticketsperdayx300businessdays60,000ticketsperyear.
60,000ticketsx$100/ticket$6,000,000/yearspenton supportingUXissues.
Trainingcosts
Trainingistheoppositeofusability.Lookfortrainingthatʼscompensatingfor anunusableexperience.
Estimatethenumberoftraininginstructorsthecompanyhas.
20instructorsx$200,000/year$4,000,000trainingcosts
Lookforemployeesbeingtrainedtouseinternalsystems.
Estimateemployeesbeingtrainedeachyear.
1,000newemployeeseachyear.
Calculatethecostofadayforanaverageemployee.
$200,000/year365daysx7$3,816/week
$3,816/week5workdays/week$767/day
Estimatethenumberofdaysoftraining.
1weekoftraining5days
5daysoftrainingx1,000employees/year5,000trainingdays/year
5,000trainingdays*$767/day$3,835,000
Donʼtforgettoaddinstructorcostsandanycostsfortheadministrative supportneededtorunthetrainingeffort.
Productivitycosts
LookforemployeesspendingtimeonactionsoractivitiesthatbetterUXcould eliminate.
Estimatethetimethe“unproductiveˮactivitytakes
Anactivitytakes60minutesbutshouldtake10. Unproductivetime50minutes
Estimatethenumberoftimesapersondoestheactivity.
Anemployeedoestheactivityonceperday.
300days/yearx50minutes15,000/year
Calculatethecostperminuteoftheemployee.
$767/day8hours/day60minutes/hour$1.60/minute
Estimatethenumberofemployeeswhodothisactivityeachday.
5employeesperstorex100store500employees
Calculatethetotalcost.
500employeesx15,000minutes/yearx$1.60/minute$1,200,000
“DamageControlˮ
Lookforproductmanagersorotherseniorstakeholdersdealingwithaclient whoisunhappyaboutwhatwasdelivered.
Itiscalculatedusingthesamemethodasproductivityloss.
Wasteddevelopmentefforts
Lookfordeveloperswhobuildfeaturesthatnobodyuses.
Estimatehowlongittooktobuildthefeature. Anunusedfeaturetook6months.
Estimatehowmanydevelopers,QApeople,andotherstaffwererequired tobuildthefeature.
2staffand½QAperson
Calculatethecost.
$200,000/yearx2½peoplex½year$250,000
Lookfortimespentredoingafeaturethatwasnʼtbuiltrightthefirsttime.
Itiscalculatedjustlikeunusedfeatures.
Lostsales
LookforsalesthatarelostbecauseUXisnʼtwhatcustomersneed.
Thesalesteamcanoftenestimateit.
Theycantellyouwhichdealswerelostbecauseofmissing capabilitiesorbecauseacompetitorhasaproductthathasabetter UX.
Theyusuallycanestimatethesizeofthosedeals.
Lookforcanceledsubscriptionsorlostrenewals.
Estimatethemonths(oryearsforannualsubscriptions)thecustomer wouldpayiftheproductmettheirneeds.
Theaveragecustomerwouldstay25%longerifwemettheirneeds.
Thecurrentaveragesubscriptionis12months.
12monthsx¼3additionalmonths.
Calculatesubscriptioncostsforadditionalmonths.
3additionalmonthsx$20month$60
Calculatesubscriberswhowouldstayforcapability.
¼subscriberswouldstayonifweprovidedafeature. Currently500,000subscribers
500,000x¼125,000subscriberswhowouldstayon. 125,00060$7,500,000
Resources
TheDiagramthatShowstheValueofGreatUX
OneofthequestionsIgetanawfullotthesedaysis,“Howdo weshowthatagreatexperienceproducesimmensevaluefor theorganization?ˮWecanthinkofexperienceasaspectrum https://articles.centercentre.com/the-diagram-that-shows-t he-value-of-great-ux/
AProvenMethodForShowingTheValueOfGoodUX
Forawhilenow,thishasbeenthemostcommonquestionIget: HowdoIconvincepeopleinmyorganizationtotakeuser experienceseriously?I'vetriedgivingbrown-bagsessionson https://articles.uie.com/a-proven-method-for-showing-thevalue-of-good-ux/
The$300MillionButton
Editor'snote:ThankstoMarcoDini,youcanreadthisarticlein Italian;thankstoYannickPrimel,youcanreadthisarticlein French;thankstoUweKeim,youcanreadthisarticlein https://articles.uie.com/three_hund_million_button/
Answersthequestion:Ifwedoagreatjobdeliveringawell-designedFeature, Product,orService],howwillweimprovesomeone'slife?
Theimprovementdeliverssome(hopefullydramatic)benefittoapersonor people.
UXSuccessMetrics
Howwillweknowtheexactmomentthatwe'veachievedourUXOutcome?
UXProgressMetrics
HowfarhavewecomeonthewaytoachievingourUXOutcomes?
HowmuchdowehavelefttogotoachieveourUXOutcomes?
Problem-ValueMetrics
WhatobstaclesarepreventingourusersfromachievingourUXOutcome?
Howmucharethoseobstaclescostingourorganization?
Therearefivepartstothisworkbook.Eachpartcontainsaseriesofreflectionand planningexercises.Youʼllusethosetocreateatransformationplan.
HomeworkGoogleDocversion:
https://bit.ly/Metrics-2024 Doc
Homework MicrosoftWordversion:
http://bit.ly/Metrics-2024Guide
Inthishomework,youʼllidentifypotentialProblem-Valuemetricsonwhichtobase yourOutcome-drivenUXMetrics.
Problem-Valuemetricsshowtheongoingcostsofpooruserexperiences.They areacrucialmethodforintroducingthevalueofUXtoourexecutiveleadership andkeystakeholders.Problem-Valuemetricsgettheirpowerfrombeing translatedintoauniteveryoneunderstands:money.
February5,12pmET17.00GMTor6pmET23.00GMT
Tuesday,February6,