FEB 2012
$4.99 US
Features 11
UNHAPPY ENDINGS
15
INSIDE THE MIND
The trial of Els Clottemans who is accused of killing Els Van Doren, with whom she shared a passion for skydiving and a lover.
The story quickly took a bizarre twist when investigators learned the motive behind the murder.
21
bizzare crimes
25
NOVELS OF THE MONTH
A robber shoots himself in the foot, a man refused to leave jail, and a man’s wife meets his girlfriend through a surprisingly brutal way
We go inside the minds of America s most popular novelists to explore the crossover from fact to fiction.
37
SCALE OF EVIL
45
new forensics
Take Hitler, Stone says. “He thought we were evil, we thought he was evil.” But, “in that particular case, we were right.”
From the scrime scene to the crime lab, forensics uncover some unsettling evidence this month.
The Juice 03
fictional versus reality
06
SUSPECTS: PROFILES
11
Do real P.I carry around guns from door to door?
Mr. Harvey ,our fictional criminal of the month
detective in traininG See the latest in technology and gear
76
KILLER INFOGRAPHICS Who exactly is being killed and where
From the most
infamous cold cases to
outrageous crimes in today’s courtrooms, delve into compelling cases on Investigation
Discovery and get the inside scoop.
This months issue may be less bloody but more psychotic. Sometimes it’s about the lure for mystery rather than blood. M.O. puts you in charge of the scene of the crime and gives you an inside perspective to detect a killer or to free the innocent. This periodical delves deep into the world of human motivation, and helps you to look darkness in the eye with all the tools of modern forensics.
A marriage without the fairy tale ending.
The case had everything: secret trysts, subterfuge and a sabotaged parachute. The victim, Els Van Doren, 38, perished after leaping from a Cessna to perform a routine with her skydiving club — only to find that her chute ropes had been cut. The investigation brought a bizarre love triangle to light: the married Van Doren was also sleeping with a Dutch member of the skydiving club, Marcel “Mars” Somers. Love crimes of passion sparked by a spurned lover’s snap from provocative paramour to predacious threat. See the dark side of love with a voyeuristic peek into the lust and obsession that fueled some of the most senseless, but definitely not emotionless, crimes to make front-page headlines. The stories featured in scorned pair sexual intrigue with bedded betrayal to form a recipe for murder. Dan and Trish Willoughby have the
11
12
INSIDE THE MIND OF A
That last feeling can be the real problem.
As Jon Ronson undertakes one of the journalistic escapades that make up “The Psychopath Test,” he describes renting a car and savoring its smell. This aroma “never fails to bring back happy memories of past sleuthing adventures.” The particular episode that springs to his mind is “trailing the conspiracy theorist David Icke around as he hypothesized his theory that the secret rulers of the world were giant, blood-drinking, child-sacrificing pedophile lizards that had adopted human form.” The word “psychopath” conjures up movie images of brutal, inexplicable violence: Jack Nicholson chasing his family with an ax in The Shining or Anthony Hopkins as Hannibal Lecter, his face locked into an armored mask to keep him from biting
According to Dr. J. Reid Meloy,
Dr. Meloy writes that in early
author of The Psychopathic Mind:
childhood development, there is a
Origins, Dynamics, and Treatment,
split in the infant psychopath: the
the psychopath is only capable
“soft me” which is the vulnerable
of sadomasochistic relationships
inside, and the “hard not-me” which
based on power, not attachment.
is the intrusive, punishing outside
Psychopaths identify with the
(neglectful or painful experiences.)
aggressive role model, such as an
The infant comes to expect that
abusive parent, and attack the
all outside experiences will be
weaker, more vulnerable self by
painful, and so he turns inward.
projecting it onto others. As multiple
In an attempt to protect himself
murderer Dennis Nilsen put it, “I was
from a harsh environment, the
killing myself only but it was always
infant develops a “character armor,”
the bystander who died.” t was
distrusting everything outside, and
always the bystander who died.”
refusing to allow anything in. The
child refuses to identify with parents, and instead sees the parent as a malevolent stranger. Soon, the child has no empathy for anyone. The wall has been built to last. “Human nature is a nuisance, and fills me with disgust. Every so often one must let off steam, as it were,” said “Acid Bath Murderer” John Haigh. In normal development, the child bonds with the mother for nurturing and love. But for the psychopath, the mother is experienced as an “aggressive predator, or passive
stranger.” In the case of violent
not a person, but again the image,
psychopaths, including serial
or something desirable, the last
killers, the child bonds through
thing we would expect him to want
sadomasochism or aggression.
to do would be to personalize this
According to Meloy, “This individual
person. ... Chattering and flattering
perversely and aggressively does to
and entertaining, as if seen through
others as a predator what may, at any
a motion picture screen.” And later,
time, be done to him.”
“They wouldn’t be stereotypes necessarily. But they would be
The Victim Through the Psychopath’s
reasonable facsimiles to women as
Eyes. When they are stalking a
a class. A class not of women, per
victim, psychopaths don’t consciously
se, but a class that has almost been
feel anger, “but the violence shows
created through the mythology of
the dissociated effect.” Many killers
women and how they are used as
seem to go into a trance during their predatory and killing phases.
The quiet is the problem,The anger and rage just get bigger and bigger
and seep into a fantasy life, and the person becomes increasingly alienated and isolated and contemptuous.
objects.” If Bundy got to know anything too personal about the
The psychopath seeks idealized
victim, it ruined the illusion.
victims in order to shame, humiliate, and destroy them.”’I must have’ ends
In a manic state, the psychopath is
with ‘It was not worth having,’” says
fearless and thinks he is omnipotent,
Meloy. By degrading the victim,
sometimes evil incarnate, as we have
the psychopath is attempting to
seen in Richard Ramirez’s “Night
destroy the hostile enemy within his
Stalker” run. They are completely out
own mind. At Gacy’s trial, forensic
of touch with reality. One psychopath,
psychiatrist Richard Rappaport said
while in custody, would dress himself
that “he is so convinced that these
as an Indian warrior using his own
qualities exist in this other person, he
feces as warpaint. Many serial
is completely out of touch with reality
killers identify with the myth of the
... and he has to get rid of them and
warrior. Calavaras County torturer
save himself ... he has to kill them.”
Leonard Lake was fascinated by medieval knights, and on a more
Richard Ramirez - The victim is seen
modern cinematic note, many serial
as a symbolic object. Bundy described
killers, including Gacy and Kemper,
it by using the third person: “Since
worshipped John Wayne, the
this girl in front of him represented
American archetype of the lone warr
Psychopaths know society’s rights
That is where the hard work of trying
That is where the hard work of trying
and wrongs, and will behave as
to make sense of a crime like that
to make sense of a crime like that
if they sincerely believe in these
at Virginia Tech always hits a wall.
at Virginia Tech always hits a wall.
values. “There are individuals who
We can debate, as we predictably
We can debate, as we predictably do
are so psychopathically disturbed
do in these cases,
in these cases,
that, in my opinion, no attempts
what an incident
what an incident
should be made to treat them,”
like this means for
like this means
says Meloy. Many psychopaths will
our endless national
for our endless
read psychology books, and become
argument about
national argu-
skilled at imitating other more
guns and violence
ment about guns
“sympathetic” mental illnesses, such
and the coarsening
and violence and
as schizophrenia. They will use any
of the culture. That’s
the coarsening
means possible to manipulate their
well-mapped ground.
of the culture.
evaluators. Do psychopaths ever
What remains un-
That’s well-
legitimately hear voices in their
charted is the unlit
mapped ground.
heads? According to Meloy, “most
places in the minds
What remains
functionally psychotic individuals
of the people who
uncharted is the
do not experience command
are capable of doing
unlit places in
hallucinations, and those who do
these things — and,
the minds of the
generally successfully resist them.”
by extension, in all our minds. What
people who are capable of doing these
is it that makes individual members
things — and, by extension, in all our
John Gacy was “a smooth talker and
of a usually empathetic species turn
minds. What is it that makes individ-
an obscurer who was trying to white-
rogue?
ual members of a usually empathetic
wash himself of any wrongdoing. He
species turn rogue?
has a high degree of social intel-
How does one of our most primal
ligence or awareness of the proper
faculties — the ability to understand
How does one of our most primal
way to behave in order to influence
that things that cause me pain or fear
faculties — the ability to understand
people,” said Eugene Gauron, who
would do the same to you and that
that things that cause me pain or fear
when there’s
TOOLS
1. HotShot Developer When we’re lying about emotion—pretending to be happy when we’re sad, for example—microexpressions can flash across our faces before we can get hold of them. And if most people aren’t great at lying about their emotions perfectly, then it’s also true that most people can’t detect those little facial lies. , then it’s also true that most people can’t detect those little facial lies. most people can’t detect those little facial lies.
Eye brows down and together. There is a glare in the eyes and a narrowing of the lips
2. Magnetic Applicator
When we’re lying about emotion—pretending to be happy when we’re sad, for example—microexpressions can flash across our faces before we can get hold of them. And if most people aren’t great at lying about their emotions perfectly, then it’s also true that most people can’t detect those little facial lies, then it’s also true that most people can’t detect those little facial lies. most people can’t detect those little facial lies.
3. MAGNIFYING EQUPTMENT 1 2 3
Classifying the scene Forensic evidence falls into two categories – physical and biological.
When we’re lying about emotion—pretending to be happy when we’re sad, for example—microexpressions can flash across our faces before we can get hold of them. And if most people aren’t great at lying about their emotions perfectly, then it’s also true that most people can’t detect those little facial lies. , then it’s also true that most people can’t detect those little facial lies. most people can’t detect those little facial lies.
Evidence Collection is the foundation of crime scene investigation. CSI Forensic Supply knows that wasted time and incomplete or unclear evidence collection is frustrating and counterproductive. Wouldn’t it be great to have the best quality supplies at your fingertips to enable you to get the job done effectively and efficiently every time?
Dexter:
Psychological Profile Take a look at the most notorious fictional characters on TV
Walter White
Walter Hartwell “Walt” White is a fictional character and the protagonist of the American television drama series Breaking Bad on AMC. He is portrayed by Bryan Cranston and was created by series creator Vince Gilligan.
Dexter is a forensic blood spatter analyst who works for the fictitious Miami-Metro Police Department; in his spare time, he is a serial killer who preys on other murderers who have escaped the justice system. He follows an elaborate code of ethics and procedures taught to him in childhood by his foster father, Harry Morgan (which he refers to as “The Code” or “The Code of Harry”), which hinges on two principles: Dexter can only kill people after finding evidence that they are guilty of murder, and he must dispose of all evidence so he never gets caught.
Theodore “T-Bag”
A native of Conecuh County, Alabama, Theodore Bagwell was born of both incest and rape after his father sexually assaulted his sister, who is implied to have been mentally handicapped;
Jimmy Darmody
Jimmy is the son of Commodore Louis Kaestner, a political power broker and one-time boss of Atlantic City, and the showgirl Gillian Darmody.
Dexter is a forensic blood spatter analyst who works for the fictitious MiamiMetro Police Department; in his spare time, he is a serial killer who preys on other murderers who have escaped the justice system. He follows an elaborate code of ethics and procedures taught to him in childhood by his foster father, Harry Morgan (which he refers to as “The Code” or “The Code of Harry”), which hinges on two principles: Dexter can only kill people after finding evidence that they are guilty of murder, and he must dispose of all evidence so he never gets caught.
BY JON TROCK PHOTOGRAPHED BY JASON KOFFLER
DIT
[DETECTIVE IN TRAINING]
ANGER Eye brows down and together. There is a glare in the eyes and a narrowing of the lips Eye brows down and together. There is a glare in the etogether. There is a glare in the
CONTEMPT
SADNESS A drooping of the upper eyelids. Losing focus in the eyes and a slight pulling down of the lip corners. Losing focus in the eyes and a slight pulling down of the lip corners.
Catching a lie The Real Science behind Lie to Me, Fox’s law enforcement-themed drama.
Lip corner tightened and raised on only one side of the face. and raised on only one side of the face. and raised on only one side of the face. and raised on
When we’re lying about emotion—pretending to be happy when we’re sad, for example—microexpressions can flash across our faces before we can get hold of them. And if most people aren’t great at lying about their emotions perfectly, then it’s also true that most people can’t detect those little facial lies. That’s where Ekman’s consultancy comes in— his programs help train FBI and TSA agents to tell when someone is lying. A very small percentage of people (less than 1 percent, according to Ekman are natural lie detectors who can detect microexpressions and lies without being trained. The show takes this into account in the form of character Ria Torres (Monica Raymund), a “natural” whom Lightman recruits from the TSA in the show’s pilot episode.
EVALUATING
Why are we so fascinated with true crime literature? The books about infamous criminals and crimes, recent and historical almost fly off the shelves. Investigators who solved the crimes are besieged with requests to share the details with reporters and authors. There can be no doubt that we are intensely curious about these crimes, and the criminals and crimes, recent and historical almost fly off the shelves. Investigators who solved the crimes are besieged with requests to share the details with reporters and authors. There can be no doubt that we are intensely curious BY DAN ROSEN
ruel intent is the basis for our fascination with evil, There are those who are clearly psychopathic and the ones that go in for the prolonged torture.
child endangerment, sexual harass-
called good and evil.
ment, and elder abuse. We have also
Because of this vulnerability we have
been guilty of our religion, national
questions that need to be answered to
origin, skin color, sexual prefer-
ensure our safety. One such question
ence, gender, and, now and then, of
is, what would happen if ‌? What
the blood in our veins. Guilt is the
if you saw a man shoot somebody?
mainstay of who we are and how we
Should you tell the police? Would they
are organized, and is, seemingly, our
protect you from murky vengeance?
undeniable destiny, along with Death
You saw a true-crime TV show once
and Taxes.Our relationship with guilt
that profiled a man who identified a
is as old as the DNA that defines our
murderer and was himself murdered
species. But the nature of culpability
for giving evidence. Would you be
of Nazi Germany.
changes with technology and tech-
guilty of being stupid for doing what
nique. These changes affect the way
you were taught was right? wealthy
In 2,000 years of Western civiliza-
we see the world and the way we seek
property owners, and local ministers.
Everybody is guilty of something. This is a truism of the West. It goes all the way back to Cain and original sin and has been a central topic of discourse among members of society from the construction of the laws of ancient Rome, through the Inquisition, into the Jim Crow system of the South (and North), stopping to wallow in the culture of the Soviet Union, and going right to the rotted heart of the race laws
to understand our predicament
tion we have been guilty of heresy, perversion, theft, and murder; of
fighting and refusing to fight;
of loving, lusting after,
and sometimes just looking. We have been
guilty of speaking
out and keeping silent,
of walking, marching,
and running away.
We have been found culpable for following orders and for refusing to follow them, for adultery,
This is because most of us see our-
Face-to-face meetings and friendly
selves as powerless cogs in a greater
gossip gave us at least the illusion
machine; as potential victims of a
of understanding where we stood
society so large and insensitive that
and what was right. But today the
we, innocent bystanders in the crowd,
working urban dweller gets all this
might be caught at any time in the
information from TV and computer
crossfire between the forces of so-
screens ‌ and so often, we know, the
eprived is guilty of something. This is a truism of the West. It goes all the way back to Cain and original sin from the construction of the laws of ancient Rome, through the Inquisition, into the Jim Crow system of the South (and North), stopping to wallow in the culture of the Soviet Because of this vulnerability we have questions that need to be answered to ensure our safety. One such question is, what would happen if …? What if you saw a man shoot somebody? Should you tell the police? Would they protect you from murky vengeance? You saw a true-crime TV show once that profiled a man who identified a murderer and was himself murdered for giving evidence. Would you be guilty of being stupid for doing what you were taught was right? wealthy property owners, and local ministers. Because of this vulnerability we have questions that need to be answered to ensure our safety. One such ques-
Because of this vulnerability we have
Because of this vulnerability we have
questions that need to be answered
questions that need to be answered
to ensure our safety. One such ques-
to ensure our safety. One such ques-
tion is, what would happen if …?
tion is, what would happen if …?
What if you saw a man shoot some-
What if you saw a man shoot some-
body? Should you tell the police?
body? Should you tell the police?
Would they protect you from murky
Would they protect you from murky
vengeance? You saw a true-crime TV
vengeance? You saw a true-crime TV
show once that profiled a man who
show once that profiled a man who
identified a murderer and was him-
identified a murderer and was him-
self murdered for giving evidence.
self murdered for giving evidence.
Would you be guilty of being stupid
Would you be guilty of being stupid
for doing what you were taught was
for doing what you were taught was
right? wealthy property owners, and
right? wealthy property owners, and
local ministers.Would you be guilty
local ministers.Would you be guilty
of being stupid for doing what you
of being stupid for doing what you
were taught was right? wealthy
were taught was right? wealthy
property owners, and local ministers.
property owners, and local ministers.
See if you can find which suspect has been doing too much clowning around. BY ROSIE SALZMAN