Copyright in Anonymous and Pseudonymous Works
Intellectual Property (IP) law protects any original creation born from the intellect and grants its author a series of rights that safeguard such creation. Anonymous and pseudonymous works are protected under Copyright Law. Anonymous works are those where the author's identity is not revealed at all. Pseudonymous works are those wherein the author uses a 'pen name,' for instance, Enid Blyton, George Eliot, Banksy, and many more, who are all well known to us. What is interesting about copyright law is that it protects such anonymous and pseudonymous works without revealing the real identity of the author. One might think that this is impossible since Copyright Registration would require revealing one's identity. However, this is not the case. Let us find out more.
International Framework Due to the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works, all the new creative works within the boundary of local laws are automatically subject to Copyright Protection, even if they are published with no author information or under a pseudonym on purpose. Article 7.3 of the Berne Convention provides that in the case of anonymous or pseudonymous works, the term of protection granted by the Convention shall expire fifty years after the work has been lawfully made available to the public. However, when the pseudonym adopted by the author leaves no doubt as to his identity, the term of protection shall be that provided in paragraph (1) [i.e., the life of the author and fifty years after his death]. If the author of an anonymous or pseudonymous work discloses his identity during the above-mentioned period, the term of protection applicable shall be that provided in paragraph (1) [i.e., the life of the author and fifty years after his death]. The countries of the Union shall not be required to protect the
anonymous or pseudonymous works in respect of which it is reasonable to presume that their author has been dead for fifty years. However, in most countries, if the author subsequently discloses his identity after publication, the normal term is granted automatically, like it was never even published anonymously. It is imperative to note here that only the case law in some countries has specified what could happen if the author revealed himself after the term ends.
The Position in Various Jurisdictions 1. The United States Many anonymous and pseudonymous works published before 1989 are in the public domain of the US, but only because the US law previously required a copyright notice, registration, and renewal to gain or maintain protection. If a work was published before 1989, with the permission of the author, but without copyright notice or copyright registration, the work got passed into the public domain in the US. However, anonymity itself does not prevent copyright. The work can still have a copyright notice and be registered in the US as an anonymous or pseudonymous work. Even when a work is credited as anonymous or pseudonymous, the US allows the option of providing or omitting the author's real name, birth year, and death year on the registration; so, if a creative work was registered, it might or might not be possible to determine the real author's death year. A work that was created after 1901 but not published and not registered can still retain the copyright for the following 120 years if the author is not known; unpublished works are copyrighted without needing copyright notices or registration. For works first published or registered in 1989 or later, the copyright protection terms are now 95 years from publication or 120 years from creation, whichever is less. 2. The European Union In most European Union countries, due to the harmonization of copyright terms, an anonymous work is given 70 years of protection from the day it gets published (which can often make anonymous works published before 1951 to be considered in the public domain). 3. The United Kingdom If the author is unknown, then the basic period to bear in mind is 70 years. If the work has an unknown author and was created after 30th August 1989, copyright protection expires either 70 years after creation or if during that period the work is made available to the public 70 years after that. If the work is a photograph with an unknown author taken before 1st June 1957, then copyright protection expires 70 years after creation, or if during that period the work is made available to the public 70 years after that. If the work was created before 1969 with an unknown author, then several scenarios can apply:
If the work was published before 30th August 1989, then the copyright expires 70 years after first publication. If the work is unpublished and was first made available to the public after 1968, then the copyright expires 70 years after the work was first made available to the public. If the work is unpublished and has never been made available to the public, then the copyright expires at the end of 2039. If the work is unpublished and was first made available to the public before 1969, then the copyright expires at the end of 2039. 4. India Anonymous works are protected in India for 60 years from the beginning of the calendar year next following the year in which the work gets published (This is valid for literary, dramatic, musical, or artistic works other than photographs that are published anonymously). In the case of photographic works, the copyright subsists for a term of 50 years from the beginning of the calendar year next following the year in which the work gets published.
Pseudonymous Works and Trademarks: Banksy's Case Banksy is the pseudonym behind which an anonymous British artist has created several artworks. He is one of the most famous and unknown artists, while at the same time, he is dedicated to street art with a vindictive background. Some time ago, the artist claimed his work, 'Flower Thrower,' in the hope of getting the right to it. Surprisingly, he got a negative answer from the European Union Intellectual Property Office, which ruled, "Banksy cannot claim the work as a trademark due to its anonymity."
- Banksy’s Flower Thrower Artwork The origin of the litigation began in 2014 when the company representing the author Banksy formalized a Trademark Application for one of his works - 'The Flower Thrower.' In this context, EUIPO granted such a request, but in 2019 a British company contradicted such a decision. Concerning the scenario mentioned above, EUIPO annulled the mark because of two reasons - the first reason being related to the fact that Banksy did not use the distinctive sign at the time of marketing his products. Secondly, EUIPO considered that at the time of applying for registration, there was bad faith since Banksy never had any intention to exploit his creations. So, this means that the protection of copyrighted pseudonymous or anonymous works is still very uncertain today.
Final Note Copyright protection is available to both anonymous and pseudonymous works in various countries, owing to the Berne Convention. However, once the author's identity is revealed, it is no longer considered to be an anonymous work. Anonymous authors can enforce their Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs) just as any other author. Since the date of death cannot be determined in such works, the term is calculated from the date of publication of the work unless the identity of the author is revealed.