Choosing the Best Baby Carrier: Wraps vs Soft
Structured Carriers
Babywearing has become an increasingly popular way for parents to bond with their infants while keeping their hands free. With so many options available on the market, choosing the right carrier for your newborn can be overwhelming. In this article, we will be comparing two popular types of baby carriers: wraps and soft structured carriers.
Section 1: Wraps
A wrap is a long piece of fabric that is wrapped around the parent and baby to create a snug, secure hold. There are three main types of wraps: stretchy, woven, and hybrid.
Stretchy wraps are made of soft, stretchy material and are ideal for newborns because they provide a snug, supportive fit. However, they can be less supportive as your baby grows.
Woven wraps are made of sturdier fabric and can be used for both newborns and older babies. They require a bit more practice to use but offer more versatility and support.
Hybrid wraps are a mix of stretchy and woven materials, providing the best of both worlds in terms of support and ease of use.
What to Like about Baby Wrap
Pros of using a wrap for newborns:
Proximity: Wraps keep your baby close to your body, providing a sense of security and warmth.
Comfort: Wraps distribute your baby's weight evenly across your body, reducing strain on your back and shoulders.
Adjustability: Wraps can be adjusted to fit any body type, allowing both parents to use the same carrier.
What to Dislike about Baby Wrap
Cons of using a wrap for newborns:
Learning curve: Wraps require some practice to master the different tying techniques and may be overwhelming for some parents. Not suitable for long periods of use: Wraps can become uncomfortable if worn for extended periods of time.
Image Credit: Boba Wrap
Section 2: Soft Structured Carriers
A soft structured carrier (SSC) is a structured carrier that uses buckles or ties to adjust and secure the carrier. There are three main types of SSCs: buckle carriers, Mei Tais, and Onbuhimos.
Buckle carriers are the most popular type of SSC and are known for their ease of use. They have a padded waistband and shoulder straps that can be adjusted to fit any body type.
Mei Tais have a structured waistband and shoulder straps that can be tied for a customizable fit. They provide good back support and are ideal for longer periods of babywearing.
Onbuhimos are similar to Mei Tais but lack a waistband, making them ideal for parents who are pregnant or have a Csection recovery.
What to Like about Soft Structured Carrier
Pros of using a soft structured carrier for newborns:
Ease of use: Buckle carriers are simple to put on and take off, making them ideal for parents who want a hasslefree carrier.
Back support: Soft structured carriers provide good back support and can be more comfortable for longer periods of use.
Longevity: Soft structured carriers can typically be used from newborn to toddlerhood.
What to Dislike about Soft
Structured Carrier
Cons of using a soft structured carrier for newborns:
Limited adjustability: Soft structured carriers may not fit all body types as well as a wrap can. Bulky: Some soft structured carriers can be bulky and take up more space than a wrap.
Image Credit: Ergobaby Omni 360
Section 3: Comparison
Wraps and soft structured carriers both have their pros and cons. Wraps provide a snug, comfortable fit for newborns but may be more challenging to use. Soft structured carriers are easier to use and can provide good back support, but they may not fit all body types as well as a wrap can.
When choosing between a wrap and a soft structured carrier, consider your own needs and preferences. If you value adjustability and a close, snug fit, a wrap may be the best option for you and your newborn.
However, if you prefer ease of use and good back support, a soft structured carrier may be a better fit.
It's also worth noting that some parents may prefer to have both a wrap and a soft structured carrier on hand, as each type of carrier has its own unique benefits. For example, a wrap may be more suitable for around-the-house use, while a soft structured carrier may be better for longer outings or walks.
When selecting a carrier, it's important to consider your baby's age, size, and developmental stage. Newborns may require a carrier with a more snug and supportive fit, while older babies may prefer a carrier with more room to move around.
In terms of safety, it's important to follow the manufacturer's instructions and guidelines for using the carrier. Always ensure that your baby's airways are clear and unobstructed and that they are in a comfortable and supported position.
It's also important to keep in mind that baby carriers come in a variety of materials, such as cotton, linen, or bamboo, and different materials may offer different benefits in terms of breathability, durability, and softness.
Final Thought
When it comes to wraps, some popular options include the Moby Wrap and the Boba Wrap. These wraps are made from stretchy, soft materials and are designed to be wrapped around your body and your baby for a snug and secure fit. They can be used from birth up to 35 pounds, and offer a variety of carrying positions to accommodate your baby's growth and development.
Soft structured carriers, on the other hand, offer a more structured and supportive design that can be easier to put on and take off than a wrap.
Some popular options include the Ergobaby Omni 360 and the Lillebaby Complete, both of which offer adjustable straps and a variety of carrying positions to support your baby from birth up to toddlerhood.
Ultimately, the best baby carrier for your newborn is the one that fits your lifestyle and meets your baby's needs. By doing your research and trying out different carriers, you'll be able to find the perfect carrier for you and your little one.
What are your thoughts? Share your experience and comments.
Choosing the Best Baby Carrier: Wraps vs Soft Structured Carriers
