기후행동2015 ‘대화2015’
지속가능발전목표(SDGs)와 기후변화
일시: 2015년 10월 6일 오전 10시-12시 장소: 환경재단 레이첼카슨홀 주최: 주관:
프로그램 시간
10:00-10:10 (10분)
10:10-10:40 (30분)
10:40-11:10 (30분)
11:10-11:50 (40분)
내용
기후행동2015와 KoFID의 소개, 세미나의 취지 소개 - 사회자: 문도운 KoFID 간사
SDGs의 논의 흐름과 주요 내용 - 이성훈 (KoFID 운영위원장 / 한국인권재단 상임이사)
시민사회 관점에서 바라본 환경분야 목표 - 박숙현 (환경운동연합 국제협력위원)
토론 및 청중과의 질의응답 - 토론자1: 이지언 (환경운동연합 팀장) - 토론자2: 조보영 (에너지기후정책연구소 연구원)
11:50-12:00
마무리 및 종료
(10분)
-1-
기후행동2015 ‘대화2015’ 지속가능발전목표(SDGs)와 기후변화
발표자료 1. SDGs의 논의흐름과 주요내용 - 이성훈 (KoFID 운영위원장/ 한국인권재단 상임이사) 2. 시민사회 관정에서 바라본 환경분야 목표 - 박숙현 (환경운동연합 국제협력위원)
-3-
-5-
-6-
-7-
-8-
-9-
- 10 -
- 11 -
- 12 -
- 13 -
- 14 -
- 15 -
- 16 -
- 17 -
- 18 -
- 19 -
- 20 -
- 21 -
- 22 -
기후행동2015 ‘대화2015’ 지속가능발전목표(SDGs)와 기후변화
발표자료 1. SDGs의 논의흐름과 주요내용 - 이성훈 (KoFID 운영위원장/ 한국인권재단 상임이사)
2. 시민사회 관정에서 바라본 환경분야 목표 - 박숙현 (환경운동연합 국제협력위원)
- 23 -
ᶈ◜▚ờ 2015 2015. 10 .6 ⁰↧▰ (◇ᴮ⊸ờ≶▏ ᵟ⌬△ᾜ⋏⋂)
⍼Ↄᳩẉ⁵⌤ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ⁵⌤ ╟⊗ ◇ᴮ≋ ᶈ◜₣◅ ≫Ḭ⍼ ↦⌂⋂ᵂ ∴⌤▋ ⇒↦ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ṕ≣ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ↂ⃥⊗ ⅏ℼ┬Ⓧ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ≚≣ ▒≓⅏Ⓚᴰ ⅏Ⓚᴰ €▻ ℹ`◅ ⁼⍼ ᶈ◜⌏〉ᵂ ᴩᾪ 2
- 25 -
ᴮ⌬
⍼Ↄᳩẉ ⁵⌤
ℹ◐
ℹέ έ (ᴮ⌬⍜⏾) ◇ᴮ
ℹ◐ ⍼ᵞ (ᵀờ⏾) (⋶ΐ⊗ ⅏Ⓚᴰ)
3
People-⌾≢Ⅺ-〉⋯ l ⌾≢Ⅺ 〉⋯ 〉⋯ ⃧ᴷ ▶╎Ⅺ ᴏᳵ/⇒↦/≫Ḭ⍼ ᵙ⋘
Community - ┠┊Ḭ⇘ ⏠≳, ⅏ℼᵂ ↂ⃥ ⏧⋻/▶╎Ⅺ (South-North) ᴮ⌬(Ṏⅈ)Ⅺ⌍ - ᶈ↪⍥⇗ ⌏〉, ᶈ↪ ⍼⋂ᵂ △ᾜ
Planet-₎≿ ồ⇑ - ⁼⌏ ◐₭ᾜ ᳵ◅ ᶈ◜,ẫᶈ,↦⎀,▒≓,⅏Ⓚ 4
- 26 -
Source: Policonomics – Externality MB: marginal benefit, MPC: marginal private cost, MSC: marginal social cost, MD: marginal damage curve.
https://www.ufz.de/export/data/1/19677_CMS_IMAGE.gif - 27 -
5
6
◇ᴮ≋ ╟ ṕ≣ – ⇒ᾈ⅏ℼ - #2 ↦⌂⋂ ᵄῦ⊗ ⋏⅏(⇒↦) - #6 ≫Ḭ⍼ - #7 Ṏⅈℼ≣ᵂ ᶈ↪, ⌏〉⍼⋂ - #9 ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ồ⇑-⁼⌏╓▎ - #11 ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ↂ⃥⊗ ⅏ℼ ┬Ⓧ - #12 ᶈ◜₣◅ - #13 ▒≓⌂⋂ - #14 ⌂⋂⋯ €⌤ᵂ ⅏⁆⍄ẙ≓Ⅺ-#15 7
2ଇ ⅅ⇐: ⇑ₗῦ∲ Ḕᵾ ṄⅣ Ἄ ▒⃭, ᶈ◜₣◅ ⊃ ᳩ⍼⌧(Tipping point)⋣ ḳᴜ Ứ. Æ ⅏⁆⍄ 20~30% •⍄, 10~20≛ ⁆⌽, ᶈᵿᵂ ◃↦, ╔≺⋠ᾨ ⇗⌍΅⃥ Ἄ ℹΌ⍻ᳩ
⩪ถ#⛒ᑮ#Ⅻ⍣/# 㘞⋂ᬞ#Ⅻ⍣/## ಿ⋂ᡳ#ᵪ㛾##
⌂Ά: UNEP/GRID-Arendal , US EPA ⌂Ά ⌏⋶⊵
- 28 -
8
13.1 ⋗≭ᶈ◜₣◅△≌ (UNFCCC)⋴ ⌤ Ⅼᴰ⌣⋶ ᶈ◜₣◅ ẫ⋨⁼ ∴⋣ ṏ⋯▉Ẃ ᳩ⌍ ␘ⅅ⋏⋯ ᵟ⌬⌣, 〉ᳫ ╓ᾍ⋻⋣ ⋶〉 13.1 ἅ ᵟᳩ≫⅝ ᶈ◜ ᵄᾝ ⋏▢ᵂ ⌂≶ ⌏▒≫ ẫ▋ ◐₭ᾜᵂ ⌣ ⋨ ≴ᾈ⋣ ᳵ◅ 13.2 ᵟᳩ 〉⏧, ⌤ᾅ, ᴰ◑ᵂ ᶈ◜₣◅ ẫ⋨⁼∴ἇ⋣ ⓩ▏
13.3 ᶈ◜₣◅ ⊙◅, ⌣⋨, ≿▜ ᳰↂ ⌼ᶈ ᴮ€≫ ᵄ▋ ᵙ⋘, ⋶ ⇒ ⍻⍾, ⋶⌣ ⌬ồ⌣ ≴ᾈ⋣ ⍻⍾
9
ẫ╟ṕồᴮᾨ(RCP) ⊗ CO2 2100Ṅ ⋴◜≫ồ ⍼Ↄ ⅅ⇐ 850Ⅱ≫⅝ ∴〉◅
650Ⅱ≫⅝ ∴〉◅
2100Ṅ 490 ⋴◜≫ ᳰↂ (2015 ⋴ℼ◅Ⓒↂ ṕồ: 400 ppm) IPCC ≫ ⋯▉‡, ⍼ḏ 150Ṅᳫ ≌ 0.85Gଇ ⅅ⇐, 2100Ṅ(BAU)≫Ẃ 3.7Gଇ ⅅ⇐ ⊃ⅅ, ▒↦‡⋢ 63cm ⅅ⇐ ⊃ⅅ 10
- 29 -
⊌⇕ᳩ⇈ ᳰ␢⋣ ⋏▒ ◅⅞≶Ά ⁾ ᳰ␢
##############
♺ ᆲ ⩪
###
㉊ ☻ ⠞ ❓ ᵪ 㛾
###
ሷ ♯
#
㑺 ᯦
11
Ⅼᴰ ≫Ḭ⍼⋂
ᵟḝ ≫Ḭ⍼⋂₤ 1⏛ ≫Ḭ⍼ ↂ⃥ᾈ
12
- 30 -
≫Ḭ⍼ 〉⋯ – ṩᵞḌ ⌨ᵿ/ℹ⊵ ᳩẉ▋ ≫Ḭ⍼
⇓⌏⅏≫Ḭ⍼ ⏾⌬ᾨ⋯ ⌤◇ ◅⅞≶Ά≫ ⋯▋ ≫Ḭ⍼ ⅏ℼ(▰ 80%) – ⊌⇕ᳩ⇈ ⁾ ⌢ᳰ⋣ ⋏▒ ἃ⇑ ▄⊮▋ ⌤◇
▓⁵⌤ↂ⊗ ▓╏ᶈ⁆⋯ ∴⌤ ⁄⌬ ẫỬ
⇓⌏⅏≫Ḭ⍼ - ᵟḝ ⌣⊵ 96% ▒⊦ ↦⋼ (≶ᳫ 200⌼ ◅⅞≶Ά⊗ ⊶Ὧṽ ⅏ℼ ṕ␢ ᵟᳩ≫ ⍜ᴵ ⋾⋥) – ᵟᳩ ᴮ⌗ᾜ ‡≫⅝ồ ▄⊮ ▓⁵⌤ↂ⊗ ╏ᶈ⁆⏵ῦ⌍ ␡ᳩ ᴏⅣ⋴ ᴍ⋯ ᳩẉ
↋⌤Ⓖ Ἄ ℹ◐⌣ ᳭Ἄ ⊮⋶ ⍼≴ ≫Ḭ⍼ ⌂Ύ 〉⏧ Å ᵟᳩ 〉⏧⋯ ⌤◇⋴ ≤⋠‡ ᳩẉ 13
Ử῞ ⋏▋ ⇒↦⊗ ⋏⅏⇑Ⅳ ⌨ᵿⅪ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ᵄῦ ◆Ύ (Ensure availability and sustainable management of water and sanitation for all)
6.1 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ∴⌤▉ᴵ ⋴⊵ ᳩẉ▋ ⇒↦≫ ẫ▋ Ử⋯ €╉⌣⋴ᴵ ╎Ἄ▋ ⌨ ᵿⅪ⋣ ◆€ 6.2 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ⋏⅏ ◇ᴮ/Ⅳ⃥≫ ẫ▋ Ử⋯ ⌣⌥▉ᴵ ᵀ╎▋ ⌨ᵿⅪ⋣ ◆€▉ ᴵ, ≌▋ ◇ᴮ≫ ⋾Ẃ ≳Ⅺᵂ ∲⋴ἇ⋯ ▄⊮≫ ┋₤▋ ⍜⋯῞ ᶈ⊹≳ ṍⅅ ⁾₣ ⋣ ⍄⇒ 6.3 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ᵀ▒ ⌢ᳰ, ⋏▢ ◅▊≌╪ ⋗▒⁆⎀⋯ ⓳ᶈ ᵿ⌥ ⁵⅏ ␘ↂ ◅, ⏵ῦ ╏↦⋯ ⃥⋚ ⌥ ⋴▉ᾨ ᳰↂ, ᵽῦᴵ ⌏◈⊵ ⌏ℹ⊵ῖ⋣ ⍻ᳩ⇑⑱ ↦⎀⋣ Ⅱ(x%) 6.4 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ἅ ≋≫⅝ ⊵↦ ◗⋚⋣ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▉ᴜ ⍻ᳩ⇑⒮ᴵ, ⁆ ⌽⋣ ▒ↂ▌ ↦ ⋾Ẃ ả↦⋯ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ⁾↦⊗ ᵀᶄ⋣ ◆€▉ᴵ, ⁆ ⌽ ⁄⌬῞ ᴦᴵ ⋾Ẃ ℹέἇ⋯ ↦῞ ⍼Ↄ⌣⋠ᾨ ᳰↂ
6.5 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ἅ ẜᴰ(␌ᵟᴮ⌣ ⌣⌥▋ △ᾜ Ἄ⋣ ╓▎)≫⅝ ⓩ▏Ủ ⁆⌂⋂ ᵄῦ῞ ⇑▚ 6.6 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ ⁆ ᵄᾝ ⅏Ⓚᴰ(ℼ῾, ℼῪ, ⇎⍼, ᳵ, ẫ↦⑀, ▻↦ Ἄ)῞ €▻▉ ᴵ €⌤ 14
- 31 -
ῦ╓ẏ∲ ℹᾤ - ᵾ⇗▋ ᳩ⁉⋠ᾨ ⌄Ἆ ╪⍄ ᵙ⏾ - ᳵ⌬ ⏸↦ ‥ᾣ - ⁆⌥≌▶ ⅬⒷᶈ Ⅼ⏶⍼ ᵙ⏾⇑ 〉⍼⋂ - ⇒ầ≫⅝ ▄⊮▋ ᴮ⊶≫ ⁆ ⌬ᵀ - ṕ≣⋶ἇ ⁆ ⋴⊵ᵺ⌬
- 17000≳ ⋷⌂ῦ ℹὯ⎂ - ↦⌂⋂ ⋴⊵ᾈ 20%(2014), 25%(2015) ᳰ␢ ╟
⌣Ⅳᾈ (▋ᵟ⋷€, 2015Ṅ 4⋃ 2⋷⌂ (AP⌬ᵀ)
15
16
- 32 -
⁆⌽ ᵟᳩ⋯ ẫᾈ ⍻ᳩ (ᵟ, ⍥ᵟ ∲╻ῦ ⋗ᾎ ᵟᳩἇ) ⁆ ⋴ờ ᵻ▶
17
ᳩ⁉(⁆⌽) ᵄῦ ▒↦‡ ⅅ⇐ – ▒∴ ⍼▉↦ ⊊≺ ẙ≓▋ ↦⌂⋂ ◆€, ⌢≿▜ ⁵ Ἄ ⋗≴ ₤ ⏠≳▶ ᶈ◜₣◅ ⌣⋨ ╻ᾨᵽ ◆ẫ ⁆◗⋚ ⌥≌ ╻ᾨᵽ – ᵙ⋘/◃€
↦⎀ᵄῦ ▉⏷↦῞ ᳩỬẂ ᴜ ∲ẏὯ ℼῪᵂ ⇎⍼῞ ◈⊵ ⃥⌧⊊≺⋂ ᵄῦ῞ ⋏▒⅝Ẃ ᵀờ⏾ ṍᾜ ⌥⇕
▉⏷ ⅏Ⓚᴰ ▉⏷ ⋗⍼⊵ᾈ ⋗⍼, ↦ᾨ ⍜₣ ⅝⇒⍼ €▻ (ℼά⍼)
◃↦ ≌⍼≴ ᵄῦ ᶈ◜₣◅ᾨ ╔⊶ ⃧ồ ⍻ᳩ Æ ⃬⁆ ⋴⊵ ᶈ↪ ṕ≣ ⌣⋨ ⁼∴ 18
- 33 -
2.1. 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ᶈ∲⍄⇒, ⃧ᴷ⑀ᵂ ≌ᴰ⑀, ≿⋗∲῞ ╓▎▋ ἅ ℹέἇ≫ ẫ▋ ≶⍥ ∴⌤▉ᴵ, ᴵ≿≓⋯ ▋ ⇒ᾈ ᵀᶄ €⌍ 2.2. ∲ờ⋯ ⁵ẞ⌢▒⊗ ⇓⏾↘≌⋣ ⁼⍼▉ồᾩ 2025Ṅᶔ⍼ ᵟ⌬⌣⋠ᾨ ▏⋯Ủ Ⅼ ╟ ẞⅪ⋣ ╓▎▋, 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ἅ ▶Ⓚ⋯ ≿≓⇕⌼ ⍄⇒ᵂ ⏽ↂṄᶈ ↂ Ṃ, ⋻ℼ, ↦⋗, ṍ⋶⋯ ≿≓ⅅⓀ Ⅱ ▄⊮ 2.3. 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ⓢ⍼ ᶈⒶ ⅏ℼ⌂⋂ᵂ, ⍼⇒, ᶃ⋞⅝⃥⇈, ⇑⌍ᵂ ᳩᳩ⑁ ⃥ṕ≣ ᴵ⊵ᶈ◐≫ ẫ▋ ∴〉⌣⋴ᴵ ╎Ἄ▋ ⌨ᵿⅪ ◆€῞ ⓩ▒ ≳Ⅺ, ⋂⍜, ᳩ ⌽ṕ, ␢, ≚ Ἄ⋯ ṕ≣⅏ℼᾈᵂ ↂᵺ ⇒ᾈ⅏ℼ⌂⋯ ↂἄ⋣ 2⁾ᾨ ⍻ẫ
2.4. 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ⅏ℼⅪᵂ ⇕⎀⌣⋶ ⅏ℼ⋣ ⍻ẫ▉ᴵ ⅏Ⓚᴰ῞ ⋗⍼▉‟ ᶈ◜₣ ◅, ᵾ⇗▋ ᶈ◜₣◅⊗ ◃↦, ᳩ⁉ Ἄ ᶈⒶ ⌂≶⌏▒≫ ẫ▋ ⌣⋨ᾜ⋣ ᳵ◅▉≳ ⌧ ⍾⌣⋠ᾨ ⓢ⍼⊗ ⓢ≓⋯ ⎀⋣ ▜ⅅ⇑⒮Ẃ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ⇒ᾈ⅏ℼ ⇑⇈ⓙ⋣ €ᳵ▉ᴵ ◐₭ᾜ⋴ ◆€Ủ ṕ≣◈ờ⋣ ⋴▒ 2.5. 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ ᵟᳩ, ⍼≴, ⍼ᵞ⌣ ⏛⋂≫⅝ ᴏ⌤▉ᴜ ᵄῦụᴵ ẙ≓Ⅺ⋴ €⌍ ụẂ ⇒⁆ ⍄⌂⋢▚⋣ ⓩ▋ ∪∽, ṕ⌃⁆, ᳩ␢ ⋴⊗ ᵄᾝ ⋾Ẃ ≋⅏⍄⋯ ⋗ ⌤⌂⌣ ẙ≓Ⅺ⋣ ⋗⍼▉ᴵ ⋗⌤⌂⌣ ⌂⋂ ⋴⊗ ᵄᾝỦ ⌤ⓩ ⍼⇒⋯ ◈⊵⋠ᾨ €⌍ụẂ ▷Ⓛ⋣ ᵀ〉▉ᴵ ⁾▉ᴵ ⋴≫ ẫ▋ ⌨ᵿⅪ €⌍ 19
20
- 34 -
ᵄṕ≣ (↦⌂⋂ ⌽) ẫᾈ ␢ℼ/⎀₨⁵⅏
⋗⌤⌂₣▶⁆⎀ (GMOs) ⓢ≓ ⊊≺ ⍼╟⑀ ⋗⇕ ⍄⌂ ↂ⋗ᵭ (⋂⍜ ᵀờ⏾ ┠ᵑ) ▉⏷ ▒≓⋯ ≿≓◅ 21
⊵ồ⌤⊵: 2010Ṅ 18732 ha (≳⋯ồ 22⁾) ℹὯ⎂. 4ẫᳵ ℹ≣ – ▉⏷⍼⋯ ṕ⍼ ẫᴍ ≤≆. 4ẫᳵ ℹ≣ ⌏⋂ ΅ᾝ⊵ ‘⑃↦ᵞ≴ ⁵┋₤ₓ’ ⌬〉, ▉⏷ ⍜₣ ⁵ℹ≣ ╎ᵻ ᴮℹ⋚ 15%⋴ⅅ⋶ ▋ᴰṕ⍼⋯ ⃥ṕ ↂ⋗ ◆ẫ (▋ᴰṕ⍼ 20ha + ⌂≶Ṏ⍼ 47ha) ⌤⊵ᳩẉ
ṕ≣⋴ ↦⌂⋂⋯ 50% ℹ⊵, ◗⋚⌣⋶ ↦⌂⋂ ᵀᶄ⋴ ⍥⊮. (ᵄᶈ↪, ᶈ◜⋴⊵-⇈⑩⍲῭, ᶈ◜⌣⋨ ╪⍄ Ἄ ⁼∴ ΅ᾝ)
ℼⓢ ⇒ GMOs ⋗⌤⌂ ₣▶ᵂ ṕ≌ ℹ⊵⋴ ᶈ◜₣◅≫ ẵ ≌▉ẙẂ ≶ᵞ ᴩᵂ≫ ⍜ Æ ⅏Ⓚṕ≣ ⍥⇗ ⅏ℼ ⍻ẫ ↂ⃥⌂ ⋯⇒ ⌬ᴵ (⊶ῦ⇠, ⊶ῦ ᶈ) – ⅏◈△ờ ⌼▏ Ἄ ⋗ⓩᵂ〉 Ⅱ⋣ ⓩ▋ ṕ ↂἄ ⍻ẫ 22
- 35 -
11.1. 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ▋ ↦⋯, ∴⌤▉‟, ⃥⊵⋴ ⌣ᴜ ἃẂ ⍜ᴍᵀᳫᵂ, ᶈ␌ ⅝⃥ ⇈≫ ẫ▋ ⌤‡⌣⋶ ⌬ᵀ ⃧␎⋯ ⌏⁵ ␡⍾
11.2. 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ≌ᴰ⑀, ≳Ⅺ, ≚Ῠ⋴, ⌍≂⋶, ṍ⋶⋶ᵞ⋯ ⊮ᵞ≫ ␌⌧⋣ Ữ ẫ ⍥ᵙⓩ⋯ ◆ẫ⊗ ồᾨ ∴⌤ Ⅱ⋣ ⓩ▒ ∴⌤▉ᴵ ⌣⋢ ⃥⊵⋯ ṩᵞḌ ℹ⊵⋴ ᳩẉ ▋ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ ᵙⓩ⏾ᴰ ⌬ᵀ 11.3. 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ἅ ᵟᳩ≫⅝ ╓⊵⌣⋴ᴵ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ồ⇑◅⊗ ⏠≳⌣·ⓩ▏⌣· ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ 〉⍜ ᴰ◑⊗ ᵄῦ ◆ẫ 11.4. Ⅼᴰ⋯ ⁄◅ ⌂≶⋗ℼ⋣ €▻▉ᾛẂ ṍᾜ ᳵ◅
11.5. ⃧ᴷ⑀ᵂ ≌ᴰ⑀≫ ⍥⌧⋣ Ữ 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ⁆ ᵄᾝ ⌏▒῞ ╓▎▋ ᳪ ⍄ ⌏ ▒≫ ⋯▒ ⁵⅏▉Ẃ ℹⅅ⌂⊗ ⍽ᳫ⌨⌣⋠ᾨ ≿▜⋣ ⁴⋢ ⋶ᵞ῞ ẫ╔ ␢ↂ▉ᴵ ᵟ ḝ␓⅏ℼᾈ≫ 〉⌣⋶ ≿▜⋣ ⍜Ẃ ᴮ⌬⌣ ↅ⇕⋣ x%ᶔ⍼ ᴮᳰ 11.6. 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ᵀᶈ⋯ ⎀ᵂ ⍼⌂⏾ ᶈⒶ ╏ᶈ⁆ ᵄῦ≫ ␌⌧⋣ Ὼ␡ᴵ ⋶ᵞ 1 ⋶ầ ồ⇑ᾨⓋ ⁵⅏▉Ẃ ◇ᴮ⌣ ∳≿▜⋣ ␢ↂ 11.7. 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ∴⌤▉ᴵ ╓⊵⌣⋴‟ ṩᵞḌ ⌨ᵿᳩẉ▋ ᵀờ⋯ Ṏⅈ ᵀᳫ⋣ ◆ ẫ▉ᴵ, ≳Ⅺ, ∲ờ ṍ⋶ᵂ ⌍≂⋶⋣ ⍥⇗⋠ᾨ Ṏⅈ ᵀᳫ ⌬ᵀ 23
ẫᶈ⊊≺ ⌢ᳰ – ⌢Ⓒↂ , ⏽〉, ᴏᳵ ồ⇑ ⇈΅┊ ⇑┘ (ICT, Smart Grid) – ᵙⓩᵂ ≫Ḭ⍼ Ṏ⍼ ᵀᳫ – ᵀ⋂ (Urban ecology – Biodiversity) ⍜⋴ ⏠≳▉Ẃ ᵀờ⏾ ồ⇑ ⌏▒ ≌Ⅺ⋣ Ⅱ▉Ẃ ◐₭ᾜ ⋾Ẃ ồ⇑
╻Ὧ⋴ Ί⒧
⊊ℹ 24
- 36 -
ồ⇑⋯ ⌏▒ ≌Ⅺ ồ⇑ ᳰồ (ồ⇑ᴰ◑)
ᶈ◜ṍ
ℹ◐ ⌂₯ ᵀờ⏾ ≴▌
Matrix
ồ⇑ ⌉⌏ ≌Ⅺ
⌣⋨ẉᾜ
ồ⇑⋯ ᶈ◜₣◅ ⌏▒ ≌Ⅺ 25
12.1 ἅ ᵟᳩἇ⋴ॊ⍼Ↄᳩẉ ↂ⃥⊗ ⅏ℼ⋣ ⋏▋ 10Ṅ ᴰ◑(10YFP)”⋣ ⋴▚. ⋴ ᵂ〉≫⅝ Ⅱ⍾ᵟἇ⋴ ↆⅡ↦ₒ▉‟, ⁵ồⅅᵟ⋯ ⁵ẜᴰ⊗ ≴ᾈ⋣ ᴵᾛ
12.2 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ⌂≶⌂⋂⋯ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ ᵄῦ⊗ ◗⋚⌣ ℹ⊵⋣ ẞⅪ 12.3 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ⌤Ⅼᴰ⌣⋠ᾨ ἅ ⋥⇒⁆ ∞ᾓᶈ῞ ⋠ᾨ ⍟⋴ᴵ, ↦◆ ẜᴰ ῞ ╓▎▋ ⅏ℼ ᵀᶄℹ⇋ᵂ〉≫⅝ ⁵⅏▉Ẃ ⇒ᾈ ↅ⇕⋣ ᳰ␢ 12.4 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ◅▊⁆⎀ᵂ ἅ ╏ᶈ⁆⋣ ᵟ⌬ᵺₒ≫ ἙὯ ⌄⌾ ≶▋ᶔ⍼ ◇ ᴮ⑃◅⌣⋠ᾨ ᵄῦ. ⋶ΐ⋯ ᴏᳵᵂ ◇ᴮ≫ Ḅ⑁Ẃ ∳≿▜⋣ ␘ↂ◅▌ ↦ ⋾ồᾩ ◅▊⁆⎀ᵂ ╏ᶈ⁆⋯ ẫᶈ, ⁆, ⓢ⍼≫ ẫ▋ ⁼⋣ ◆⇕☏ ᳰ␢
12.5 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ⊃⁼, ᳰ␢, ⌏◈⊵, ⌏ℹ⊵⋣ ⓩ▒ ╏ᶈ⁆ ⁵⅏⋣ ◑ᶈ⌣⋠ᾨ ᳰↂ 12.6 ẫᶈ≣ᵂ ẙᵟ⌣ᶈ≣⋣ ╓▎▋ ἅ ᶈ≣ἇ⋴ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ ᵄ▚⋣ ⏦Ⓛ▉ᴵ, ⍼ↃⅪ≫ ᵄ▋ 〉€῞ €ᴵ 12.7 (⍼Ↄᳩẉ⁵⌤≫ ᵄ▋) ᵟᳩ 〉⏧ᵂ ⊶Ⅱ↨⋏≫ ▏ụẂ ⁼▜⋠ᾨ ᵀᵀ⌼ ẞ ⁼⇒⋴ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▉ồᾩ ␡⍾ 12.8 Ⅼᴰ ồ⏵⋯ ἅ ⋶ΐᳩ 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ⌂≶ᵂ ⌼◅ᾨ⊸ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ⁵⌤ᵂ ⅏ ◈⁼⇒≫ ᵄ▋ ⌣⌥▋ 〉€῞ ⌨▉ᴵ, ⋶⇒▌ ↦ ⋾ồᾩ ▎ 26
- 37 -
े⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ↂ⃥⊗ ⅏ℼै⋴ά ⅝⃥⇈⊗ ⌬╪⋯ ℹ⊵⋴ ᶈ₯⌣
⊯ᵞ≫ ⋨▉ᴵ ⅏◈⋯ ⎀⋣ Ṗ⋴ụ ⅝⃥⇈⊗ ⌬╪⋯ ⌤⅏≂⍜ᶈ≫ ᴑ␆ ⌂≶⌂⋂ᵂ ⋗▒⁆⎀⋯ ℹ⊵ ╏ᶈ⁆ᵂ ⊊≺⁆⎀⋯ ⁾⋣ ⍟⋴ᴵ, ύⅬẫ⋯ ⊮ᵞ⌽⋴ ⋏△⁴⍼ ∶ồᾩ ▉Ẃ ◈ờ⋴ẙ. (⊊⇋ᾨ ⇗╓⍼≢, 1994) ⅏Ⓚ⁵⌂ᵟ - 1989Ṅ ▋ᵟ⋶⋯ ↂ⃥ᳩ 2.42gha≫⅝
1995Ṅ≫Ẃ 3.36ghaᾨ ≌ 39% ⍻ᳩ, 2012 ▰⌏ 4.5gha. ᶈ◜₣◅ᾨ ⋶▋ ⌂⋂ ᳰↂ (⊵ᾈ)⋏ᶈ≫⅝, ⅏ℼ≓⇒⋯ ₣◅⊗ ↂ⃥⌂ ⋶⇒ ⌤◇ ≤⋴Ẃ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ↂ⃥⊗ ⅏ℼ ᳩ 27
ᶈ◜₣◅ᾨ ᶈ ᶈ◜₣ ◜₣ ₣◅ᾨ ₣ ᾨ ⋶▋ ▋ ≿▜╓▎ ▎
The Limits to Growth (1972), Beyond the Limits (1992), Limits to Growth: the Thirty Year Update (2004) 28
- 38 -
Built up land 9% Cropland 21%
Fish Footprint 0.42(10%)
Built up land 0.06(<1%)
Cropland Footprint 0.68(15%) Grazing Footprint 0.14(3%)
Fishing ground 57%
Grazing land 0% Forest land 13%
Forest Product Footprint 0.23(5%)
Carbon Footprint 3.0(66%)
⌂Ά: GFN NFA Data Package 2015 (2011 data) 29
ᴶΐ Ⅷ≫⅝ ␢ℼ⁆ (ẜⁿ⎀) Ⅷᾨ ₣◅
30
- 39 -
⏵: http://ediblestartups.com/
⏵:Nina Rastogi, A rind is a terrible thing to waste (Slate.com) 31
2012Ṅ ▰⌏ ⋥⇒⁆ ∞ᾓᶈ 17100ⓤ ␡〉
• • • •
⋶ᵞ⍻ᳩ ↂἄ⍻ᳩ 1-2⋶ ᳩᵞ ⍻ᳩ ↂ⃥┬Ⓧ₣◅⊦⇒⍻ᳩ
╤ἃ⓳ể⋴⊗ ẫ▋≿≓ℹ△◐ ᵀờ╀⋶, 2011. 3. 4 (╤ἃ⓳ể⋴)
32
- 40 -
14.1 2025Ṅᶔ⍼ ἅ ⍄ΐ⋯ ▒≓ ⊊≺(┋☏, ▒≓∞ᾓᶈ ≿≓◅ Ἄ⋯ ⋘ⅅ ◈ờ Ἄ⋠ᾨ ≋ᶈụẂ ⊊≺)⋣ ⊃⁼▉ᴵ ▰⌢▉ᴜ ⍟⋻ 14.2 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ ▒≓ ▒∴ ⅏Ⓚᴰ⋯ ◐₭ᾜ⋣ ⍻⍾⇑⒮ᴵ, ᵽ ₭⋂⋣ ⋏▋ ⌼ ⑁῞ ⇕▚▎⋠ᾨ⅝ ⇗ᳪ▋ ∳≿▜⋣ `ᴵ, ᴏᳵ▉ᴵ ⅏ℼ⌣⋶ ▒≓ ◇ᴮ ⌼Ⅺ 14.3 ἅ ẜᴰ≫⅝ ᵂ▊⌣ △ᾜ⋣ ᳵ◅, ▒≓ ℼⅪ◅ ≿▜⋣ ␘ↂ◅▉ᴵ ▒ᴩ 14.4 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ ◗ᵂ⌣⋠ᾨ ≚◑ᾈ⋣ ᵺ⌬▉ᴵ, ᵂ⋿ ≚◑, ₓ, ⃥€ᴵ, ⃥ᵺ⌬ (IUU) ≚≣, ᵽῦᴵ ┠ᵑ⌣⋶ ≚◑⋣ ⍄⇒⇑⒮ᴵ, ⇕▚ ᳩẉ▋ ␘ẜ ᶈᳫ ḝ≫ ⌣≚ ồ ⅏⁆▊⌣ ┋Ⅺ⋠ᾨ ᴩ〉ụẂ ␘ẫ⋯ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ≓⋣ ⅏ℼ▒Ḡ ↦ ⋾Ẃ ↦⍞⋠ ᾨ ↦ℼ ⌂⋂ᾈ⋣ ◐₭▌ ↦ ⋾ồᾩ ᵂ▊ ᶈ ᵄῦᴰ◑⋣ ⇑▚ 14.5 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ ⌣≚ồ ▒∴ ▒≓ ≿≴⋯ 10%῞ ᵟḝₓ ᵟ⌬ₓ≫ ▏▉ồ ᾩ, ᵽῦᴵ ᳩ⌍ ⋗⊵▋ ᵂ▊⌣ 〉€≫ ᶈ␌▌ ↦ ⋾ồᾩ €⌤ 14.6 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ ᵂ⋿⅏ℼ ≚◑≫ ⋷⌼▉Ẃ ⋷ẜ⋯ ≚≣ €⌼ᶃ⋣ ᶃ⍼▉ᴵ, ₓ, ⃥€ᴵ, ⃥ᵺ⌬ ≚≣≫ ᶈ≳▉Ẃ €⌼ᶃἇ⋣ ≤≂ᴵ, ⅇᾨ⊸ €⌼ᶃἇ⋣ ồ⋼▉ Ẃ ᴕ⋣ ⌂⌬ (⁵ồⅅᵟᵂ ␘⃧ᵟἇ⋣ ⋏▋ ⌣⌥▉ᴵ ◗ᵂ⌣⋴ᴵ ⏛₤⌣⋶ ⌼⑁ ἇ⋴ WTO ≚≣ €⌼ᶃ △ⅅ⋯ ▄↦⌣⋶ ⁄⋴ ụ≚≋ ▎⋣ ⋶〉) 14.7 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ≚≣, ≓⇒≣, ᵄᵊ≣⋯ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ᵄῦ῞ ⓩ▒ ▒≓ ⌂⋂⋯ ⍼ Ↄᳩẉ▋ ◈⊵⋠ᾨⓋ ᵠↂồ⅝ᵟ ␘⃧ᵟ≫ᴜ ỗ∲ᳩẂ ᴮ⌬ ⋴⋵⋣ ⍻⍾ 33
▒↦‡ ⅅ⇐ ▒↦ ⊌ồ ₣◅ ℼⅪ◅ ▒≓⌂⋂ ᳰↂ – ≚◑ᾈ ᵄῦ ≶∴/ ᶈ↦≴ ᵄῦ ⇕┬
34
- 41 -
∲⋴⑁ ╟: 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ 10% ▒≓
2010▰⌏
ᵟḝ ╟: 2018Ṅᶔ⍼ 18ↂᾨ ▒≓€▻ᵞ≴ ⍼〉 ᵄῦ ⁄⌬:
ờ⅝Ḕ▒∴ ḝᵭ ⁵⌤ ┋₤ₓ ⋷〉∴ ⋼ₓ - ▒≓ᵄᵊ⍾☇⍼ᵞ – ᵺ⌬⊙◅ - ᵟⓢ⍄▏ᴰ◑ ↦〉(2013) ▒≓⁆ΐ ℼ≣ᴮ⌗ᾜ ᳵ◅῞ ⋏▒ ᵺ⌬⊙◅
2012Ṅ - ⊙ồᵠ ᶃầ‡ ⋘ℼῦ ↂ◅ồ ⍜₣▒≴ ▒≓€▻ᵞ≴ ⍼〉ᴵ⇑ - ⇓∴ᵠ ◾ℼ‡ ᳩᴍồ ⍜₣▒≴ 35
15.1 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ ⋘ⅅᵂ ḝ⋯ ả↦ ⅏Ⓚᴰ⊗ ᵽ ⏾ᴰ, ┋☏ ᵟ⌬△≌ ⋯⁁ℹ░ ≶ ⌍Ⅱⅅ⋯ ℼῪ, ⇎⍼, ℼ῾, ⋘⍼ Ἄ⋯ €⌤, ₭⋂, ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ⋴⊵⋣ ◆€ 15.2 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ ἅ ⍄ΐ⋯ ℼῪ⋯ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ▋ ᵄῦ ⋴▚⋣ ⍻⍾▉‟, ℹ`◅῞ ⁼⍼▉ᴵ, ◊╏◅Ủ ℼῪ⋣ ₭⋂▉ᴵ, ℼῪ◅⊗ ⌏ℼῪ◅῞ ⌤⍼ᵞ⌣⋠ᾨ ⍻⍾(x%). 15.3 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ ℹ`◅῞ ⁼⍼▉ᴵ, ⏶⁰▒⍾ ⓢ⍼⊗ ⓢ≓(ℹ`◅, ᳩ⁉ ◃↦≫ ≿▜⋣ ⁴Ẃ ⓢ⍼ Ἄ)⋣ ₭⋂▉‟, ⓢ⍼ ◊╏◅ ≤Ẃ Ⅼⅅ⋣ ⋴῁ồᾩ ṍᾜ 15.4 2030Ṅᶔ⍼ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ⁵⌤⋯ ▄↦⌣⋶ ▷Ⓛ⋣ ⌬ᵀ▉Ẃ ≴ᾈ⋣ ⍻⍾⇑⒮ᶈ ⋏ ▒ ℼῪ ⅏Ⓚᴰ €⌤(⅏⁆ẙ≓Ⅺ Ἄ)⋣ ◆€ 15.5 ⌂≶⅝⇒⍼⋯ ∳◅῞ ⊙◅⇑⒮ᶈ ⋏▋ ᶊᶄ▉ᴵ ⍥ẫ▋ ⌼⑁῞ ▉ᴵ, ⅏⁆ẙ ≓Ⅺ⋯ ↅ⇕⋣ `ᴵ, 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ ⌥• ⋏ᶈ ⍄⋯ •⍄⋣ €▻▉ᴵ ⊃⁼ 15.6 ⋗⌤(genetic)⌂⋂⋯ ◈⊵⋠ᾨ ⋶▋ ▷Ⓛ⋯ ᵀ╎▉ᴵ ╎Ἄ▋ ⁾῞ ⋴῁ᴵ, ⋗ ⌤⌂⋂⋠ᾨ⋯ ⌣⌥▋ ⌨ᵿⅪ⋣ ▜ⅅ 15.7 ờ⇒⁆ €▻⍄⋯ ╓◑ ᴍύ῞ ⍄⇒⇑⒮ᶈ ⋏▋ ᶊᶄ▋ ⌼⑁῞ ▉ᴵ, ₓ ≋⅏ ⅅ╪⋯ ↦⊮⊗ ᵀᶄ ⁄⌬῞ Ử ẙ 15.8 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ ⋘ⅅᵂ ⁆ ⅏Ⓚᴰ⋯ ⊦ύ⍄⋯ ⑇⇎⋣ `ᴵ ᵽ ≿▜⋣ ⒧ᴜ ᳰↂ⇑ ⒮‟, ⊶Ⅱ↨⋏ ⍄⋣ ᵄῦ▉ᴍḌ ᵿ⌥ 15.9 2020Ṅᶔ⍼ ⅏Ⓚᴰ⊗ ⅏⁆ẙ≓Ⅺ ᳩ⑁῞ ᵟᳩ ⍼⁼ ᴰ◑, ⁵⌤ ᵂ〉, ⃧ᴷ ᳰↂ ⌤ᾅ, ᴰ〉≫ ╓▎ 36 - 42 -
㚱 2/3 㡔⤱㢌 ⇌⽸㦹☘㢌 ㉐㐑㫴ᴴ 䆠᷀⏈ 150⫼㢰 ⺵ㇵ (Parmesan, 1996; Parmesan et al., 1999)
㜵ạ㢌 ㇼ ⺸䔠 㜡㐐 㜠⤠㦹☘㢨 ⺵ㇵ. 䓽ἔ 㚱 18. 9 km. (Thomas et al, 1999)
⸨㏘䉨 㐑Ɒ㠄㢌 ᷱ㟤㜄⓸ 1900-1920≸⸨␘ 2004≸ 䜸㣠 㚱 8㢰 ᵐ䞈㐐ὤᴴ 㚒ᷜ㦀㢀. (Primack et al,2004)
37
ᶈ◜₣◅≫ ⋯▋ ⅝⇒⍼ ₣◅ Ἄ ẏⓋ῭ ⇑ᶄ ג1Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴ : ẙ⋥≫ ▒ầ▉Ẃ ⍼≴ (⌂≶◇ᴮ €⌤ ₭⋂ ⍼≴) ≴)
- •⍄⋏ᶈ≋⅏ờ·⇒⁆⋯ ⍜Ủ ⅝⇒⍼·ồύ⍼ ⍜⊮ ⅏Ⓚ␢ ὃẂ ⍜⊮ ⅏Ⓚⓩᾨᳩ ụẂ ⍼≴ - ⅏Ⓚᴰᳩ ┋☏ ⊶↦▉ᴍḌ ᴮᵄ⋴ ┋☏ ↦ᾛ▋ ⍼≴ - ⅏⁆⋯ ⍼ῦ⌣ ╓▋ᴰ≫ ⋏⑁▉Ẃ ⅏Ⓚᴰ ⍼≴ ὃẂ ⍜⊮ ⇒⅏⋯ ⋗▶⋣ ẫ╟▉Ẃ ⍼≴ - ⅏⁆ẙ≓Ⅺ⋴ ┋☏ ╭▉ᴵ €⌤ᳩ⑁ᳩ ⒩ ⅏⁆⌂⋂⋴ ⌾⌏·╓▉ᴵ ⋾Ẃ ⍼≴ - ᵽ ⁱ≫ ⅏Ⓚ⌣ ᳩ⑁ᳩ ⋾Ẃ ⍼≴⋠ᾨ⅝ ⌂≶⋂⇑Ὺ⋴Ḍ ⋴≫ ᳩᶔ⊸ ℼῪ ὃẂ ᴵℼ␌⋂, ⌂≶ⅅⓀḌ ⋴≫ ᳩᶔ⊸ ▉⏷·▻ↂ ὃẂ ᳵ▉ᵞ ד2Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴ : 1Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴≫ ⍞▉Ẃ ⍼≴⋠ᾨ⅝ ⌍⏛ €⌤⋯ ᳩ⑁ᳩ ⋾Ẃ ⍼≴ ὃẂ 1Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴⋯ ⊦⍼≴⋠ᾨ⅝ 1Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴⋯ €▻῞ ⋏▉≳ ▄⊮▋ ⍼≴⋠ᾨ ẙ⋥≫ ▒ầ▉Ẃ ⍼≴ (⌂≶◇ᴮ €⌤ ⁵⋴⊵ ◩ↅ ␘ↂ◅ ⍼≴) - ⊙€⌤⍼≴ : 1Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴≫ ⍞▉Ẃ ⍼≴⋠ᾨ ⌍⏛ €⌤⋯ ᳩ⑁ᳩ ⋾Ẃ ⍼≴ ὃẂ 1Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴⋯ ⊦⍼≴⋠ᾨ⅝ 1Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴ €▻῞ ⋏▉≳ ▄⊮▋ ⍼≴ - ⊙ᵄῦ⍼≴ : 2Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴ ⍥ ⊙€⌤⍼≴⋣ ⌬⊦▋ ⍼≴ 38
- 43 -
ה3Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴ : 1Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴, 2Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴ ₤ồᵄῦ⍼≴⋠ᾨ ΐỦ ⍼≴ ⊦⋯ ⍼≴⋠ᾨ⅝ ⁵ ὃẂ ⋴⊵⋯ ẫⅅ⋴ ụẂ ⍼≴⋠ᾨ ẙ⋥ᵂ ᳸⋴ Ⅼ▌ ↦ ⋾ẙ. - ⁵ᵄῦ⍼≴ : ⁵ ὃẂ ⋴⊵⋯ ẫⅅ⋴ ụẂ ⍼≴⋴Ḍ ⌣⋠ᾨ ᵄῦᳩ ▄⊮▋ ⍼≴ - ⁵▝⊵⍼≴ : 3Ἄᶄ ᵭ≴ ⍥ ⁵ᵄῦ⍼≴⋣ ⌬⊦▋ ⍼≴
ו₤ồᵄῦ⍼≴ : ẙ῝ ₓῖ⋯ ᵺ〉≫ ⋯▉≳ €⌤ụẂ ⍼≴ ⍥ ≴ℹ⌣·⁄◅⌣·ᴮᵄ⌣ ᳩ⑁ᳩ ⋾Ẃ ⍼≴⋴ᴍḌ ồ⇑⋯ Ṏ⍼€⌤ Ἄ⋣ ⋏▉≳ ᵄῦụᴵ ⋾Ẃ ⍼≴⋠ᾨ⅝ ẙ⋥⋯ ≚Ẁ ▉Ḍ≫ ▒ầ▉Ẃ ⍼≴ - ℼῪ€▻ᵞ≴, ⌂≶ᵀ⋂, ⏷≶ᶈṆ⁆ᾨ ⍼〉Ủ ᵞ≴(ᵽ €▻ᵞ≴ ╓▎), ≋⅏ờ·⇒⁆┋₤€▻ᵞ≴ ὃẂ ≋⅏ờ·⇒⁆€▻ᵞ≴, ↦ℼ⌂⋂€▻ᵞ≴(▒≓≫ ╓▎ụẂ ⍼≴⋢ ⌬⊦), ⇎⍼€▻⍼≴(≶∴⇎⍼€▻⍼≴⋢ ⌬⊦), ⁿỬẫᳫ€▻⍼≴, ⅏Ⓚ·ᴮᵄ€⌤⍼≴, ⇑·ồ ⅏Ⓚ·ᴮᵄ€⌤⍼≴
39
40
- 44 -
GCF ⌏〉: ᵀ⌣⌂ᶃ⋠ᾨ ≶ᳫ 100Billion USD by 2020 ╟. ▉⍼ ▰⌏ 1.5 Billion USD ↦⍞. ᶈ◜₣◅ ⌏〉⋣ ⓩ▒ 17 SDGs ⍥≫⅝ ⃧ᴷ⍄⇒, ᵙ⋘ ≳Ⅺ ╎Ἄ Ἄ 14 ╟῞ ⍼⋂▌ ↦ ⋾ẙᴵ ᵟ⌬ ⇑ẜ⏾ἇ⋢ ⍜⌍.
41
42
- 45 -
⇑⇈ⓙ⌣ ⌨ᵿ - ⋶⇒⌤◇
⍼ᵞ⌣ ⋂⑂≫ ờ⋯, ╟⊗ ḝ⊵⋢ 〉(≶ᵞ⌂), ⇑ℹ◐, ⍼⌂⏾, ⍼≴ ᵀờ⏾, ᶈ≣ Ἄ⋯ ⌣ᵾ⌣⋶ ⏠≳ ▄⊮ (2015~16) ῦẵ⇘ (〉⋯ ⋯⍼⊗ ⍼Ↄᳩẉ⁵⌤⋏⋂◐ ᴥⅅ)
⃧ᴷ⁄⌬⊗ ≓ᵾ◅ ⍟⋴ᶈ ⋏▋ ṍᾜ (ℹ◐⌣ ᴮ⌬ ◇ᴮ〉⋯) ồ⇑ ⍼≴ ᵀờ⏾ ⏠≳⋗ồ (Inclusiveness)
≓⌣ Ⅺ⌍≫⅝ ⎀⌣ Ⅺ⌍⋠ᾨ⋯ ᴮ⌬⁵⌤ ⌤◇ (⅏ℼᵂ ↂ⃥ ┬Ⓧ ₣◅) ⏽〉(Ṏⅈ)ᶈ↪ ⁵⏾⌬ – ⓳⌂⊗ ┠┊Ḭ⇘
ᶈ◜₣◅ ⌣⋨ ◐₭ᾜ ᳵ◅ ≌⍼≴ᵂ ᴰ⑀ ⍼⋂ℹ≣ – ᴏᳵ, €ᴏ ᵀờ⏾ ⋗▒⁆⎀ ∴⌤ ⌏▒ ⁼⌏ ẫ⏧ Æ ◐₭ᾜ ᳵ◅ ⅏Ⓚ⌣/⅏⁆ ⍄/ ⋗⌤⌣ ẙ≓Ⅺ ⁄◅, ℼ≣, ᵙ⋘≫⅝ồ ẙ≓Ⅺ ◆€≫ ṍᾜ 43
- 46 -
MEMO
- 47 -
MEMO
- 48 -