The Lancashire & North West Magazine | April 2022

Page 52

CRIME STORIES

BY ANNA FOULDS

James Hanratty It was 60 years ago this year that James Hanratty, also known as the A6 Murderer, was one of the last people to be executed before Capital Punishment was abolished. Although the police insist on his guilt, an appeal campaign was launched that lasted decades.

After Hanratty was identified as a suspect he briefly went on the run before being recognized by two Detective constables in a fish and chip restaurant. Unlike Alphon, Hanratty was identified by Valerie Storie in the identification parade, but some argue this was because they were asked to say the phrase “shut up I’m thinking” and Hanratty was the only one in the parade to have a cockney accent like the Murderer.

n August 1961, 22-year-old Valerie Storie and, 36-yearold Michael Gregsten were sitting in their car in a field in Dorney Reach, Buckinghamshire. They were then approached by a man with a gun who ordered them to give him any valuables and start driving towards London. After driving for 60 miles and being told to pull into a layby on the A6 he shot Gregsten in the head and sexually assaulted Valerie Storie multiple times. She survived the ordeal after pretending to be dead but was paralysed from the chest down.

I

Hanratty changed his alibi during the case from initially saying he was in Liverpool at the time of the murder to later saying he was in Rhyl. This damaged his case even though there were possible witnesses to him being in Rhyl.

James Hanratty was born on 4 October 1936 in Farnborough, Kent but the family had moved to Wembley in northwest London early in his life. After a troubled childhood and an injury that led to him having to give up his first job, Hanratty got involved with the criminal underworld in SoHo by the time he was arrested for the A6 Murder he already had four convictions for motoring offences and housebreaking. Hanratty had been identified as a potential psychopath by two different Psychiatric institutions after being treated.

There continues to be discussion around whether Hanratty was guilty or not. The case has been investigated and reopened multiple times. Two of the detective superintendents involved were found to have withheld key statements and evidence from the trial and were accused by Hanratty’s family of influencing the investigation. Hanratty’s DNA was found on Valarie’s underwear and the gun, however, it was also said later that due to the degradation, small amounts of DNA and the fact that many of the items used as evidence were stored together in the same box there could have been contamination especially as a vial had been broken. There is also the argument that if Hanratty was innocent there should have been a third DNA profile picked up on the evidence. The evidence was enough to satisfy the court of appeal in 2002 of James Hanratty’s guilt was beyond all reasonable doubt.

Hanratty, however, wasn’t the initial suspect in the murder investigation it was a man called Peter Alphon. Peter Alphon and James Hanratty were both staying at the same Hotel before the murder was committed. There were Spent cartridges from the murder weapon were discovered in a sofa in the hotel room from before the murder took place. Later, William Nudds the hotel Manager admitted that Hanratty had asked him the way to the 36a bus route which was where the gun was found in the back seat. Charles France a former friend of Hanratty told the police that he had previously told him that the best place to hide something that connected you to a crime was at the back of a bus. Peter Alphon became a suspect after attacking a woman and saying, “I am the A6 Murderer”. When in an identification parade Valerie Storie did not identify Alphon instead identified an innocent man. 52

LANCASHIRE & NORTH WEST MAGAZINE

The trial was long-lasting 21 days. On the 17th February 1962, the Jury delivers a guilty verdict and Hanratty is condemned to death. An appeal is put forward along with a petition of 90,000 signatures but it is dismissed on the 9th March, and on 4 April 1962, 25-year-old James Hanratty is hanged.

Having researched this case in order to write this article, I have also tried to work out for myself whether I think that Hanratty was guilty or if at the very least there was enough evidence to convict him. I think the key with this case is that the two questions are more separate than in many other cases. Almost everything in the straightforward facts of this case makes me think that Hanratty was guilty but the fact that there was a possible alibi, the mistakes, possible contamination, and another suspect does make me think that the Jury were hasty to find him guilty. Guilt should be found if it is beyond reasonable doubt that they did it and to me, there is reasonable doubt in this case. www.lancmag.com


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook

Articles inside

New Drive to Promote Woodland Creation

6min
pages 206-207

Stop, Unwind & Reconnect- A Fabulous Retreat by The Purpose Pusher

7min
pages 200-201

SIR WILLIAM WALTON A Lancashire Musical

10min
pages 202-205

Flowers Attracting Our Vital Bees

2min
pages 198-199

“Would You Believe It”

27min
pages 166-173

Families Invited to Support Cumbria’s Special Wildlife at Free RSPB Events Happening Across the County

2min
pages 196-197

Adventures That Start and End at Beautiful

4min
pages 154-155

The Life and Legacy of the Remarkable KATHLEEN FERRIER

20min
pages 174-181

Thinking About Buying a New Home in or Around Lancashire? Here’s The Best Way to Go About it

4min
pages 194-195

TINBOX ANGEL

23min
pages 182-193

Dare to Dream

22min
pages 156-165

Eco-Friendly Gadgets for the Home that will Save You Money

4min
pages 152-153

Heart Research UK Healthy Heart Tip Establishing Positive Eating Habits for Children

16min
pages 134-141

Del Monte Recipes

4min
pages 130-133

Heart Research UK Healthy Heart Tip Stopping Smoking

2min
pages 118-119

£10,000 Grant Available for Healthy Heart Community Projects Across the UK

4min
pages 122-125

Your Best Sales Representatives Who Don’t Wear Suits

7min
pages 110-113

Northern Health Science Alliance responds to release of Government’s Levelling Up White Paper

1min
pages 120-121

GLENN TILBROOK Plays Spring 2022 UK Tour Dates

4min
pages 114-117

Ginger Accounts

2min
page 109

FLIRTATIOUS – Making Heads Turn

2min
page 108

North Fylde Photographic Society are bringing out the long guns

6min
pages 102-107

More Than £1 Million in National Lottery Funding Goes to North Lancashire’s FoodFutures Partners to Support Communities to Tackle Climate Change

3min
pages 92-93

Time to discover the good life with Rowland

5min
pages 94-97

PRIME MINISTERS - George Grenville to The Marquess of Rockingham

12min
pages 70-75

Tonia Bern Campbell’s Ashes Laid to Rest in Coniston

8min
pages 98-101

Three Sofa Trends Shaping 2022

7min
pages 88-91

Immersive Zombie Drive-In Cinema

2min
pages 68-69

There’s No Better Gift This Mother’s Day Than a Gift Voucher for The Woodland Spa

6min
pages 64-67

Lighting Inspired by... The Gilded Age

1min
pages 62-63

Coniston Stonecraft An Interview with

11min
pages 54-61

Contours Day Spa

16min
pages 34-41

ANDREW IRVINE - The North-West Hero

9min
pages 48-51

A Walk on the Wild Side YouTube channel

4min
pages 42-47

CRIME STORIES BY ANNA FOULDS - James

4min
pages 52-53

Live Forever - A Celebration of Music That

1min
pages 32-33

Lytham Gin

10min
pages 28-31

MORE THAN A WOMAN: The Local

11min
pages 8-13

Private Peaceful

2min
page 17

New Build Bungalows Offer Luxury Living for the Over 55’S in the Ribble Valley

1min
pages 20-21

Lesley Celebrates 40 Years of Safe School Crossings

2min
pages 18-19

Seal of Excellence for Leyland Site Manager

2min
pages 26-27

Langdale Chase, Lake Windermere

3min
pages 24-25

North Lakes Hotel & Spa, Penrith

3min
pages 22-23

Light up your life with CRACKING COMEDY at Blackpool Grand in 2022

2min
page 16
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.