z€tipv{pjGz{h{lzGa Architecture of economy as architecture of agency
Cornell University Department of Architecture, Art and Planning Bachelor of Architecture Thesis
sh|yhGhshulGrpttlsG
LAURA KIMMEL
SYMBIOTIC STATES : Architecture of economy as architecture of agency
Cornell University Department of Architecture, Art and Planning Bachelor of Architecture Thesis May 2017
Laura Alane Kimmel lak243@cornell.edu
Thesis Advisors: Andrea Simitch Leslie Lok
1
SYMBIOTIC STATES
2
LAURA KIMMEL
Acknowledgements I am deeply grateful to my advisors, Andrea Simitch and Leslie Lok, for encouraging me through an exploration that will continue to influence my work for years... Many thanks to my thesis helpers, Ibrahim Desooky and Claire Guffey
3
SYMBIOTIC STATES
4
LAURA KIMMEL
“Despina can be reached in two ways: by ship or by camel. The city displays one face to the traveler arriving overland and a different one to him who arrives by sea.� -Italo Calvino, Invisible Cities
5
SYMBIOTIC STATES
6
LAURA KIMMEL
CONTENTS I. R ESEARC H Borders + Migration Public Spaces + Private Borders “Safe Spaces” Generic Codes Excersizes in Misreading
II. C ONTEXT Thre Prototypical City of the Central Valley
III. INTER V ENTION Defining an Alternative Occupation of the City
SOURC ES
7
SYMBIOTIC STATES
8 Manifesto
LAURA KIMMEL
SYMBIOTIC STATES Architecture of Economy as Architecture of Agency For undocumented day laborers in the California’s Central Valley, exposure to the road is crucial for being hired. Residual suburban spaces such as parking lots or sidewalks are then critical thresholds of visibility in the routine of a day laborer. At the same time, these interstitial zones surrounding big box stores and strip malls alienate those who use space unconventionally, leaving them targets of surveillance. While the suburban landscape proliferates surveillance and exposure, its architecture alters perceptions through false facades and deceptive proportions. This thesis exploits these generic tactics to create a city of multiple readings, uses, and temporalities.
9
SYMBIOTIC STATES
10
LAURA KIMMEL
RESEARCH
MIGRATION + PUBLIC SPACE Contested spaces of labor in the Central Valley
11
SYMBIOTIC STATES
WA
ME
ND OR
WI
ID
MI OH VA
KY CA
AZ AL
Entrance + Destination States
12
TX
GA
FL
LAURA KIMMEL
MIGRATION
Common Routes
Restricted Circuit
Nomadic
Point-to-Point
Many farmworkers travel throughout a season within a relatively small geographic area.
Other farmworkers travel away from their home for a long periods of time (sometimes many years), working from farm to farm and crop to crop. Some of these farmworkers may eventually settle in the area where they migrated.
Farmworkers migrate to the same place or series of places along a fixed route during the course of a season. These people tend to live in home-base areas like FL, TX, PR, MX, or CA. 13
SYMBIOTIC STATES
BORDERS + SURVEILLANCE 100 MILE BORDER ZONE law enforcement may arbitrarily stop vehicles warrant / reasonable suspicion not needed immigration checkpoints allowed Over half of California is in this zone 14
LAURA KIMMEL
Sanctuary Counties 364 counties
Sanctuary Cities
15
SYMBIOTIC STATES
REGIONAL AGRICULTURAL NETWORKS Highway 99 + I-5
Stockton
Sacramento
Manteca
Modesto Stockton
San Francisco
Modesto
Turlock
Fresno
Merced Visalia Bakersfield
Madera Highway 99: dividing spine of agricultural towns
Los Angeles
16
Fresno
LAURA KIMMEL
THE CENTRAL VALLEY + MAJOR AGRICULTURAL ROUTES
The Central Valley
17
SYMBIOTIC STATES
18
Street Vending
Food Trucks
Day Labor
Civic Spaces + Parks
Neighborhoods
Home Depot
S. Alvarado St MacArthur Park Los Angeles, CA
York St. at 54th Ave Highland Park Los Angeles, CA
1200 S Flower St Burbank, CA
LAURA KIMMEL
add parking lots PUBLIC SPACE + INFORMAL LABOR The boundaries between public space and private commercial property, where jobs are often found by day laborers, is a contested zone.
Day Labor
Farm Labor
Home Depot
Off-Hours Parking Lots
5600 W Sunset Blvd, Hollywood, CA
Mecca, CA
On one hand, the exposure that these shopping centers and parking lots afford is crucial for being hired, but on the other, it is easily observed by law enforcement.
19
SYMBIOTIC STATES
signage risk / benefit depending on location
20
ammenities tables, shelter minimal- waste disposal
LAURA KIMMEL
cultural/religious
parking/mobile living
alter
parking allowance on lots
street food/ specialty stores
services via trucks
CONTESTED PUBLIC SPACE 21
SYMBIOTIC STATES
GENERIC STRUCTURE
tilt-up with steel frame roof
22
LAURA KIMMEL
URBAN development spans multiple blocks proximity to freeway + infrastructure surrounding shopping mall/ chain stores
ON SITE
CORPORATE
parking perpendicular to entrance loading zones in back 2 entrances - commercial loading + general interior/exterior garden zone
structure advertisement iconography
GENERIC CODES If shopping centers and parking lots are contested spaces for undocumented laborers, how can the generic code that forms these spaces be hacked to design space for the people who occupy it the most? 23
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Home Depot Mass Programming
24
LAURA KIMMEL
GENERIC CODES Home Depot App- Database of Plans
If shopping centers and parking lots are contested spaces for undocumented laborers, how can the generic code that forms these spaces be hacked to design space for the people who occupy it the most? 25
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Schools schools
26
LAURA KIMMEL
religious
Religious SAFE SPACES Churches, Schools, and Health clinics are known as “safe spaces�- places where law enforcement are ethically advised against entering or surveilling without threat. However, their known status makes them a target when the space around them- often parking lots- is free range.
hospital/clinic
Health Clinic
27
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Home Depot / Day Labor Shelter Day Labor
Home Depot / Sidewalk Day Labor
28
LAURA KIMMEL
Plaza Street Vending
Food Trucks Parking Spots + Residual Street Space
SPACES OF DAY LABOR 29
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Chain Stores
fast food restaurant
Fast Food Restaurants
30
(Isolated)
convenience store
LAURA KIMMEL
ARCHITECTURE OF ECONOMY Big Box Stores big-box
Strip strip mallMall
Built cheaply and lightweight but with deceptive facades and materials, the prosaic architecture that is isolated in parking lots - contested spaces 31
SYMBIOTIC STATES
property lines become flexible inhabitable boundary
32
LAURA KIMMEL
BORDER INTERVENTIONS The generic fence is the subject of an excersize: the border between public and private ownership influences the program and decorative pattern of the physical boundary 33
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Existing 34
LAURA KIMMEL
ramp extends from freeway parking ramp -> walkable path
ventilation + HVAC -> ammenities
ammenities external units for parking + shelter
volume as surface box is canopy
SYSTEMATIC MISREADINGS How can misreading the plan generate a different use of the space?
Potential Misreadings 35
SYMBIOTIC STATES
36
LAURA KIMMEL
CONTEXT
FRESNO, CA The Prototypical City of the Central Valley
37
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Highway 99 I-5
Highway 99: dividing spine of agricultural towns
FRESNO, CA FRESNO, CA City built around Highway 99 38
LAURA KIMMEL
FRESNO: A CITY DIVIDED Fresno can be read as a protoypical city of the Central Valley : it has developed in conjunction with Highway 99, which divides it, broken only by a series of overpasses. Agriculture and transportation are not only imperative to the economy, but become a defining physical characteristic of the city.
FRESNO + HIGHWAY 99 + FARMS
HIGHWAY 99 AS SPINE
DIVISION OF WEST FRESNO + DOWNTOWN
39
SYMBIOTIC STATES
RESIDENTIAL
40
SUBURBAN DEVELOMENT
LAURA KIMMEL
FRESNO AS THE GENERIC CITY, FRESNO ST. AS “MAIN STREET” If the divided, agricultural city is a condition that exists across the Central Valley, its components can also be seen as sites that are replicated in each city.
9
y9 wa gh Hi
Fresno’s version of “Main Street”appropriately named “Fresno Street” - bisects the highway and cuts a section through various suburban and urban conditions. This project uses these conditions, from residential to civic, as sites for prototypes that can be applied to various cities across the Central Valley.
Fresno Street
INDUSTRIAL
DOWNTOWN / CIVIC CENTER
Highway 99 x Fresno Street
41
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Fresno Street
Community Services Government Public Park Religious Retail/ Commercial
RESOURCES + INSITITUTIONS : “SAFE SPACES” of FRESNO ST.
Fresno Community Church
Using Fresno Street as a comparison to the “Main Streets” of the Central Valley, “safe spaces” (churches, schools, clinics, and other resources) are identified based on previous research.
Life Ministries of Fresno
What are the urban and architectural conditions where “safe spaces” occur? What opportunities are there to avoid “safe spaces” becoming targets of surveillance?
Kearny Park
Golden Cross Health Care Sunset Guest Home House Miracles Faith Ministries
Centro La Familia Advocacy Services
42 Religious
Schools
Health Clinic
4
LAURA KIMMEL
Fresno County Courthouse Fulton Mall CASA of Fresno County Fresno Housing Highway 99 FoodMaxx Fresno Produce Co.
Firest 5 Fresno County
El Concilio Immigration Project Transportes Intercalifornias
Burger King Panda Express Pizza Hut House of Zion Church New Beginning Apostolic Assembly Rising Stars Missionary Baptist
Highway 41 Fresno Rescue Mission Poverello House St. Agnes Holy Cross Center for Women Apostolic Holy Ghost Revival Tabernacle Greater Faith Missionary Church Fresno Temple Church of God
43
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Fresno Street
SAFETY VS EXPOSURE : ARCHITECTURES OF ECONOMY It becomes clear that spaces of intented refuge are put at risk by the architectures of economy surrounding them. Consumer-aimed urban space and its infrastructure of efficiency - large intersections, highways, advertisementsare places designed for surveillance that put those on the fringes of society- or those who use public space differently- at risk of harassment. If these public spaces surrounding “safe buildings� create more opportunities for their surveillance, alternative spaces of refuge are crucial. What if these generic consumer spacessuburban shopping developments, highway and advertisement infrastructure, and civic and economic districts become the site of a new architecture of safety and agency? Fast Food Restaurants
Big Box Stores
44
Strip Mall
LAURA KIMMEL
suburban shopping developments business/ government districts
highway infrastructure
45
SYMBIOTIC STATES
46
LAURA KIMMEL
INTERVENTION
THE PROSAIC CITY Defining an alternative occupation of the city
47
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Highway 99
Fresno Street
48
LAURA KIMMEL
PROSAIC AS SITE From the analysis of Fresno, 5 sites are opportunities for the union of the architecturally prosaic and commercial, with the program of the “safe space�- resources and gathering space for undocumented persons.
49
ARCHITECTURE OF ECONOMY
ARCHITECTURE OF AGENCY
SYMBIOTIC STATES
I. Fountain
50
II. Overpass
LAURA KIMMEL
DEFINING AN ALTERNATIVE OCCUPATION OF THE CITY Through their program and ownership, these architectures are inherently intertwined in the lives of the Central Valley’s undocumented workforce. Big box stores are points of labor pick-up, which reinforce a reciprocal relationship between contractors and laborers. Billboards advertise the farms in which many undocumented laborers work seasonally.
III. Billboard
IV. Strip Mall
V. Big Box Store
The prosaic is not only a component of the urban sphere that is overlookedit is also intricately related to the workforce which it often ignores or excludes.
51
SYMBIOTIC STATES
52
LAURA KIMMEL
I. FOUNTAIN Downtown / Civic Center
53
SYMBIOTIC STATES
54
LAURA KIMMEL
Fountain
Downtown / Civic Center Sculptures and public works populate a neglected pedestrian mall
55
SYMBIOTIC STATES
56
LAURA KIMMEL
Fresno Municipal Baths fountain as found
Downtown / Civic Center Public infrastructure - the prosaic fountain- is “misread” to provide ammenities for undocumented workers who utilize the goverment resources and community services in the downtown area. Channels the public drinking fountains and baths that historically provided hygeine and hydration to the masses.
embedded infrastructure : water supply
potential ‘misreading’of prosaic
57
SYMBIOTIC STATES
58
LAURA KIMMEL
Public Seating Downtown / Civic Center Sculptures and public works populate a neglected pedestrian mall
59
SYMBIOTIC STATES
60
LAURA KIMMEL
Fresno Municipal Baths Downtown / Civic Center Public infrastructure - the prosaic plaza- is “misread” to provide ammenities for undocumented workers who utilize the goverment resources and community services in the downtown area.
public plaza as found
Channels the public drinking fountains and baths that historically provided hygeine and hydration to the masses.
potential infrastructure : water supply
potential ‘misreading’of prosaic
61
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Fresno’s pedestrian mall circa 1960s
62
LAURA KIMMEL
Prosaic Fountain
63
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Fountain as found
64
LAURA KIMMEL
Potential Misuse of Infrastructure
65
SYMBIOTIC STATES
66
LAURA KIMMEL
II. OVERPASS Highway 99
67
SYMBIOTIC STATES
68
LAURA KIMMEL
Overpass Highway 99 The overpasses are the only element weaving together Fresno over Highway 99. They are a host of graffiti and advertisement.
69
SYMBIOTIC STATES
70
LAURA KIMMEL
Fresno St. Market Highway 99 The overpass is the only place pedestrian and auto both can cross the highway, and it is also one of the few places where surveillance - in the form of a parked government car- is difficult. At the same time, it is a platform for advertisement, bridging over the most travelled agriculture route in the U.S. The intervention uses advertisement for farms as an extension of the overpass structure, which provides stalls and shelter for temporary markets.
71
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Fresno Street Overpass Market
72
LAURA KIMMEL
73
SYMBIOTIC STATES
74
LAURA KIMMEL
III. BILLBOARD Highway 99
75
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Billboard, Generic
76
LAURA KIMMEL
Billboard Highway 99 The Billboard occupies an undesirable and overlooked zone between the highway and the city- but structurally has opportunities for more deliberate occupation. While advertisements lure people into farms with agricultural tourism and gimmicks, the aspect of labor which they survive on is rarely acknowledged outside of the farm.
77
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Market + Chapel + Disco
78
LAURA KIMMEL
Billboard Highway 99 If the prosaic, replicated aspect of the billboard is taken advantage of, it provides shelter with direct connection to the highway, where labor pickup and travel to farms occurs. This interstitial zone is an opportunity for farms to not only advertise, but provide a network of recognizable yet covert spaces along these critical routes for farmworkers to gather with shelter.
79
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Highway 99 Ad Park
80
LAURA KIMMEL
81
SYMBIOTIC STATES
82
LAURA KIMMEL
83
SYMBIOTIC STATES
84
LAURA KIMMEL
85
SYMBIOTIC STATES
86
LAURA KIMMEL
87
SYMBIOTIC STATES
88
LAURA KIMMEL
IV. STRIP MALL Suburban Shopping Development
89
STRUCTURE TO HACK
HACK; OVERHANG + COLUMN
SYMBIOTIC STATES
STRUCTURE VS SURFACE
GENERIC TACTIC: OVERHANG + COLUMN
GENERIC TACTIC: OVERHANG + COLUMN STRUCTURE TO HACK
HACK; OVERHANG + COLUMN
STRUCTURE VS SURFACE
GENERIC TACTIC: OVERHANG + COLUMN
GENERIC TACTIC: OVERHANG + COLUMN
STRUCTURE TO HACK
Strip Mall, Generic HACK; OVERHANG + COLUMN
90 STRUCTURE VS SURFACE
LAURA KIMMEL
Strip Mall
Suburban Shopping Development False facades, hollow overhangs, tall parapets, and deceptive proportions all characterize the strip mall aesthetic- dependent on concealing the lightweight and efficient structure below.
Proposed intervention
91
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Housing + Gathering 1: 25
92
LAURA KIMMEL
overhang
Kearney Palms Shelter + Community Center Suburban Shopping Development
parapet
The existing mis-use of the Kearney Palms strip mall is adapted structurally as a space for temporary housing, an extension of the parking lot which is used as a place of labor pick-up or overnight parking.
column / false facade
Structural Opportunity
93
SYMBIOTIC STATES
94
LAURA KIMMEL
V. BIG BOX STORE Suburban Shopping Development
95
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Big Box Store,
i Gi Gz SGn G G Generic XaG\WG
96
o
LAURA KIMMEL
Big Box Store Suburban Shopping Development ROOF Open Joist Framing
The Home Depot has been a site of day labor pick-up by both contractors and customers in the Central Valley and cities. Some stores have provided shelter on-site and designated pick-up zones separate from the customer entrance.
FALSE FACADE Tilt Up Construction
97
SYMBIOTIC STATES
Gz SGn GG XaG\WG
98
o GR
n GGR
t GRGw XaG\WG
LAURA KIMMEL
Home Depot Garden Center Extension + Market Suburban Shopping Development The Home Depot roof is deconstructed and its real estate becomes both a parking deck, temporary shelter, and an extension of the Garden Center, a pivotal part of Home Depot’s identity, now expanding to incorporate produce and plants from surrounding farms. The Home Depot Garden Extenision takes on the identity of the local farms, but also the farmworkers who are hosted in the inhabitable roof and the day laborers who use the on-site facilities for work opportunities.
TRUSS ADAPTATION 1 occupyable layer in unused air space
TRUSS ADAPTATION 2 air space as layer for mobile roof
99
SYMBIOTIC STATES
100
LAURA KIMMEL
101
SYMBIOTIC STATES
102
LAURA KIMMEL
103
SYMBIOTIC STATES
104
LAURA KIMMEL
105
SYMBIOTIC STATES
106
LAURA KIMMEL
107
SYMBIOTIC STATES
108
LAURA KIMMEL
109
SYMBIOTIC STATES
110
LAURA KIMMEL
111
SYMBIOTIC STATES
112
LAURA KIMMEL
113
SYMBIOTIC STATES
114
LAURA KIMMEL
115
SYMBIOTIC STATES
116
LAURA KIMMEL
117
SYMBIOTIC STATES
118
LAURA KIMMEL
119
SYMBIOTIC STATES
BOOKS / ARTICLES
Christopher Alexander, A City is not a Tree (from intro to Ladders) Marc Auge, Non-Places: Introduction to an Anthropology of Supermodernity Jamie Bartlett, The Dark Net Fazila Bhimji, Struggles, Urban Citizenship and Belonging: The Experience of Undocumented Street Vendors and Food Truck Owners in LA (essay) Buckley and Littman, A Contemporary Vernacular: Latino Landscapes in California’s Central Valley (essay) Mike Davis, Beyond Blade Runner (essay), Ecology of Fear Mike Davis, Magical Urbanism Nicholas De Monchaux, Local Code Temporary Urban Spaces, 2006 Keller Easterling Organization Space: Landscapes, Highways and Houses in America Call It Home: The House That Private Enterprise Built Extrastatecraft: The Power of Infrastructure Space Enduring Innocence: Global Architecture and its Political Masquerades Rem Koolhaus, SMLXL - imagining nothingness (from intro to Ladders) Lars Lerup, After the City, One Million Acres and No Zoning Kevin Lynch, The Image of the City Stephen Marshall, Streets & Patterns Albert Pope, ex nihilo urbanism James C. Scott, Seeing Like a State Scott-Brown + Venturi, Learning From Las Vegas William Vollman, Imperial William Whyte, The Social Life of Small Urban Spaces Xaveer De Geyter Architecture, After-Sprawl 120
LAURA KIMMEL
PROJECTS / FILM
David Lyon El Mojado El otro lado Llanito, Little Boy (subject, using vignettes) Norman Bel Geddes National Motorway Plan, Control Bridge, Magic Motorways, 1940 (p 104 organization space) William Whyte ‘Social Life’ film
ORGANIZATIONS Cornell Farmworker Program - Mary Jo Dudley CVHC - Coachella Valley Housing Coalition CARECEN - Los Angeles Valley LEAP - Latino Environmental Advancement Project Galilee Centers
121
SYMBIOTIC STATES
122