BORDERSCAPE: WEAVING POLITICAL BOUNDARIES IN THE AMAZON THROUGH WATER PERFORMANCE
LUCILA SILVA-SANTISTEBAN MLA CANDIDATE 2017 Rhode Island School of Design
A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Master of Landscape Architecture Degree in the Department of Landscape Architecture of the Rhode Island School of Design, Providence, Rhode Island. By Lucila Silva-Santisteban May 30, 2017
Approved by Masters Examination Committee:
Scheri Fultineer, Department Head, Landscape Architecture
Suzanne Mathew, Primary Thesis Advisor
Matt Donham, Secondary Thesis Advisor
To my Family for the love, To Lili for the support, To Scheri for the opportunity, and to Suzanne for the structure.
Contents
Overview Site Phase 1 | EXPLORATION Phase 2 | SUPERIMPOSITION Phase 3 | PUNCTURE Overall Assessment Bibliography
6 7 10 40 59 80 83
Overview This research project is about how to connect political bordering urban systems through the natural structure for a coherent occupation between the built environment, ecosystems and resources following the Landscape Architecture lens that can address different scale systems simultaneously to create a holistic approach between them. And the proposition of a new type of landscape of this threshold territory as its own kind. Specifically looking at the bordering cities in the heart of the Amazon Region in South America that fall between Colombia, Brazil and Peru. Why the Amazon? Not only because of the usual fascination, but because of the crucial importance it has in the Earth’s well being. Being one of the most ecological diverse places in the world: holding 1 in 10 of the world’s known species1, comprehending 40% of the South American continent 2 and holding 15% of the planet’s fresh water 3. These type of landscapes have been left under the crystal-category-and-seal of “conservation”where a stance is needed by the rapid urbanization processes happening now which are accelerating each time more. The Amazon region is composed of the watershed of the same name. This larger “water” system includes 9 countries with the Amazon River, the largest in the world, as the umbilical chord connecting and nurturing it.
6
1 “Amazon.” WWF. World Wildlife Fund, n.d. Web. 23 Feb. 2017. 2 Buttler. “Facts about the Amazon Rainforest.” The Amazon Rainforest. Mongabay, n.d. Web. 31 May 2016. <http://rainforests.mongabay.com/amazon/amazon-rainforest-facts.html>. 3 “Human Appropriation of the World’s Fresh Water Supply.” Human Appropriation of the World’s Fresh Water Supply. University of Michigan, 2006. Web. 31 May 2016.
Avenid
a Vásqu ez Cobo
Site
Calle
Avenid
Carrera 11
This border city is composed of 3 nationalities were political boundaries are overlooked by the people’s dynamics in it. It is located in the heart of the Amazon Region and most central part of the Amazon River totally disconnected from the corresponding capital cities.
14
o
uez Cob
a Vásq le 13
Calle
10
Calle 8
9
Calle 7
Calle 6
12
a8 Carrer
Cobo
Carrera
Vásquez
a6 Carrer
Avenida
Carrera
a7 Carrer
Calle 9
Calle 8
Calle 6
Perimet
ral Nort
so
rera
Carrera 11
Car
Ideal Afon 6
Rua Peri
n
Rua Peri
metral
Norte Um
Rua
Life is entirely weaved the use of the 2 majority languages (Spanish and Portuguese) plus the indigenous dialects is usual for the area as well as the 3 currencies: Pesos (COP), Sol (PEN) and Reais (BRP).
e Dois
do
on
lR
ha
ec Mar
Rua
Rosa
11
Calle
The 3 cities: Leticia, Colombia (North); Tabatinga, Brazil (South) and Santa Rosa Island, Peru (West)
e 11 a8 Carrer
Call Calle
11
l e 12
Santa
Cal
igues María Vieir a
era 11 C arr
Cal
María Rodr
Calle 14
Rua Santos Dumont Rua do Aterr o Rua Francisco
na
Romario
Rua Sargento
nicacoes
Rua Jerus
alem
Rua Carneiro
Rua Coron
Rua
Dois
Rua
el Berg
Rua Duarte
ont
sa
iro de Prime
nel Berg
Rua das comu
Rua
Rua Caste Aires da Cunha
Um
to de
Rua Dom
Adalber
Marzzia
Coelho
ao
Do Arlind
Rua da Arruda
Rua Expedicioná
João VI
Rua Coro
Coelho
Rua Sargent
Rua da
Rua Joao
o Oscar
Rua Duarte
Aires da Cunha
Rua Dom
lo Braco
ba Rua Ajurica
de
Alves
Rua Dois
Av. da Amiza
da Cu
os Dum
Lima
Fever
nga
Rua Duarte Coelho
Rua Sant
Gonçalo de
eiro
io Luce
Rua Fáb
Rua Tabati nel Berg
t
onio Barbo
Caxias
iro de Maio
Duque de
ral Samp Rua Gene
Rua Santos Dumont
Rua Coro
Patria
on
Rua Vinte Seis
ont
nha
hal Rond
Osvaldo Cruz
de Aragao
os Dum
Aires
Rua Marec
chal Malle
tes
en Tirad
Rua Ant
andaré irante Tam Rua Alm
Rondon
Rua Muñiz
Rua Sant
Rua Mare
Rua
entes
Osvald o Cruz
de Aragão
Rua Men de Sá
Rua Marechal Mallet
Rua Tirad
Lucena
Rua Marechal
o
Rua Fabio
Rua Muñiz
Bo
sc
Rua Diogo
Rua Marecha
Rua Vilagran Cabrita
Rondon
om
aio
aD
Rua Marechal Mallet
Rua Prime
Rua da
Avenida da
Patria
Amizade
sta
da Co
Ru
rio da Pátria
v Vidal Rua Viuva
Oscar
aia Samamb
Rua Gen
eral Osó
rio
Tri-national city. Border between Colombia, Brazil and Peru in the Amazon.
7
8
9
Phase 1 EXPLORATION Investigation of the different layers and systems that make up the Border City
10
Abstract In this first phase the investigation looked to adjust and revise the collected fieldwork and analysis done during Wintersession 2017 to feed into the new direction the investigation is taking. After having visited the place where the investigation is set and having done a preliminary analysis, issues that were intuited were reinforced as major components of this investigation. Being these: sanitation, water quality issues, lack of connectivity and lack of public space. The main objectives of this phase are to: 1. Create a body of Contextual Information to introduce the place and its complexity in a larger scale. 2. Thoroughly understand the systems that make up the place (City Scale) through map analysis of the tangible and intangible components. 3. Introduce the driver component of the investigation: the Water. The main research question for this phase: What are the systems of this place (urban and ecological) and how are they spatialized in the territory?
The systems that make up this landscape
11
Methods
Many scales had to be addressed to understand the systems that make up this place. The city scale which involves the 3 cities (Leticia-COL, Tabatinga,-BRA and Santa Rosa-PE) that function as 1 urban center and the regional scale that helps understand the context and reason of this settlement’s location and activities. During this phase there was an initial focus in the first part of the City scale systems which were thoroughly broken down for a better understanding of the dynamics of the city and their intrinsic relationships with the river and between the people. Then there was the exploration on how to visualize the regional relationships that are very much given by the physical context to reinforce the construct that this city and its closer urban settlements are in fact part of 1 region (The Amazon Region) and 1 identity. Mapping exercises as well as a modeling one tried to highlight the total integration of urban systems and ecological within the place.
In general the method used for this phase, that will continue throughout all 3, is the Projective Design Research. Where knowledge is created by alternating Deductive and Inductive methods which allows for accuracy and specificity at the same time. Being that Deductive strategies are characterized by being TOPDOWN where there is an intake of large groups of information to reach an specific goal and Inductive BOTTOM-UP, where there is the recognition of a particularity that drives the investigation.
12
Introduction
1. Literature Review + Theoretical Framework Definition During the Fall semester of 2016 there was an initial phase which focused on creating the theoretical base as well as an initial research of the site. In this phase concepts were explored to help aid the discourse of the investigation such as: border, borderland, fringe, ecotone, ecozone, Eco-regions. Taking from the Ecology field, the Urban Planning, Architecture and Landscape Fields definitions to be set as starting points of this possible new definition: “borderscape”. 2. Site Visit (Wintersession 2017) 3. Collection of Information and Classification 4. Analysis of the information through Mapping exercises. 5. Synthesis of analysis information through visualization methods as mapping and modeling.
Colombia
Peru
The Amazon Basin
Brazil
13
Phase 1 | CONTEXT Structure, Cover, Watershed, Connectivity
14
15
16
17
18
Phase 1 | CONTEXT The River’s History Brief historical summary of major events of the region. The location for this research, the border between Colombia, Peru and Brazil, has been subject to major political spatial enforcement, meaning changes in occupation by different groups and agendas that have modified the landscape throughout time. This place has always been in the ‘eye of the storm’ of political struggle, making this an element inherent to its essence as a place.
19
1713-1750
Utrecht Treaty + Madrid Treaty Tratado de Utrecht, Tratado de Madrid
Peace treaty between the Spanish and English Empires and definition of borders between the Spanish and Portuguese colonies in the Americas. Tabatinga appears as a military post defending the territory.
Vice-royalties of the Americas
1494
Louisiana of New Spain (Audience of Cuba)
June 7
British Colonies
Viceroyalty of New Spain
Tordesillas Treaty Tratado de Tordesillas
Spanish and Portuguese Empire distribution of navigation and conquest zones.
Viceroyalty of New Granada
Viceroyalty of Brazil
Viceroyalty of Peru Viceroyalty of La Plata
Tordesillas treaty first known planisphere map 1502
20
75° 0° Güepi
74°
72°
Río
Río
Pantoja
m tu Pu
Florida
etá
in arí
ara ná
ra
Pa
y
Santa María
Puerto Arica
Marandúa
E
3°
s
Río Yagua
Yaguas
3°
Francisco Orellana
IQUITOS
RÍO
Puerto Nariño
AM
AZ
Ma ra ñó n
ON
AS
Caballococha
LETICIA
4°
Tabatinga
Río
74°
2°
Remanso
Tarapacá
PERÚ
4°
Río Puré
Puerto Alfonso Barranquilla
Teniente Berggerie
San Antonio del Estrecho
o Nap Río
SE
S
75°
1°
qu
Leticia was ceded to Colombia in exchange of north western territories from the Putumayo river.
hu
ra
Puerto Limón
NE
SO
Ca
Salomon -Lozano Treaty signed (1922)
Ca
Ig
ra
Santa Mercedes
El Encanto
ío R
Cu N NO
O
oris
Río
La Chorrera
o ay
Río
2°
Apap
COLOMBIA
Puerto Espinoza Angusilla
1°
70°
Río
Yarí
Puerto Colombia
Na
po
71°
0° Río
Soplín Vargas Río
73°
Puerto Leguízamo
73°
72°
71°
70°
1853-1922 Apaporis-Tabatinga (or Leticia) Limit
Shifting of political border delineation between Brazil, Peru, Ecuador and Colombia. Time of warlike conflict due to rising economic interests created by recent independence from Spain and later the Amazon Rubber Boom.
21
1879-1912,1942-1945 Amazon Rubber Boom
Product of the Industrial Revolution in Europe and the US, natural rubber became a highly coveted commodity. Crops in the Brazilian and Peruvian Amazon of Hevea brasilenis or Rubber Tree, attracted enormous wealth displayed in the largest urban center’s architecture. Italian marble structures and Eiffel buildings were erected in Manaus and Iquitos. With this great economic development there was a need for labor force which was supplied by the unjust exploitation of indigenous peoples. Fordlandia: Ford-Land Industrial town established by American entrepreneur Henry Ford in the Brazilian Amazon for the extraction of rubber.
Peruvian Amazon Company HQ
Protest in Iquitos-Peru to round up resistance against Colombia, in the search to recover Leticia
1933-1934
Iquitos
Manaus Leticia
Indigenous slaves from the Huitoto tribe enslaved by the Peruvian Amazon Company ran by the Arana Brothers.
Fordlandia
‘Casa Arana’ rubber collection center of the Peruvian Amazon Company center of major atrocities done to the indigenous population forced into labor as well as for “entertainment”.
Colombian Peruvian War: The Leticia Incident Rio de Janeiro Protocol - Salomon-Lozano Treaty Reaffirmation
After territorial resolutions were determined in paper they had not yet been implemented on land and were not welcomed by the population living there. Peruvian settlers of Leticia took over the city defending it against Colombian forces. The agreement of 1922 determined that Leticia would be ceded to Colombia in exchange for NW territories from the Putumayo River, creating what is now known as the Amazonian Trapezoid.
22
‘Teatro Amazonas’ Opera venue in Manaus, Brazil made with marble brought from Italy.
A street in Iquitos-Peru, the first city in Peru to have street lighting as well as electricity for household use in 1905, many years before the rest of the country.
Iquitos Railway
LOCALE OF MULTIPLE POLITICAL SHIFTS THROUGHOUT TIME AROUND THE AMAZON RIVER AS A CRITICAL RESOURCE OF THE REGION COLOMBIA KINGDOM OF SPAIN
KINGDOM OF PORTUGAL
COLOMBIA
ECUADOR
ECUADOR
B
COLOMBIA BRAZIL
A
PERU
PERU EMPIRE OF BRAZIL
1 ≠ 2 1494 -1750
BRAZIL
A ≠ B ≠C ≠D 1830
PERU
BRAZIL
C ≠D 1880
A ≠ B ≠C 1904
A + B +C 1922-NOW
C
AMAZON TRI-NATIONAL BORDER CITIES - Fluid border: of goods and people - Amazon River as a shared critical resource in people’s livelyhoods and connection - Shared economies and interdependence
23
Phase 1 | SYSTEMS Scale: City The fringe urban settlementâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s systems in detail. A city made up of 3 different political jurisdictions. Leticia-Colombia , Tabatinga- Brazil and Santa Rosa-Peru
24
Base map showing the existent system of the fringe settlement. The most important points of the city, centralities, are shown in yellow. Green shows the open spaces and public spaces. Walking radius show the scale of the city that in an approximate calculation can be crossed from side to side in 1 hour in either North to South or East to West.
Base map
25
Centralities
26
Urban Morphology and Green Spaces
Model explorations done in the Fall 16â&#x20AC;&#x2122; semester showing the 4 different types of conditions. 1. The Social 2. The Environmental 3. The Political 4. The New
27
In this model explorations the objective was to interpret the existing systems of the different conditions of the site. Overlapping the conditions: 1. The first one is composed by the environment and the social fluxes in the city according to centralities (natural gathering places) mapped before. This is a fluid and flexible system defined by needs and the understanding of the place. This is an underlaying condition which defines the sense of place of this landscape. 2. The second one consists of the artificial urban fabric that has two functions constrain the environmental and social systems and at the same time being the container of it.
28
29
Phase 1 | BASIC INFORMATION Leticia - Colombia
Population: 32,450 people Predominant Economic Activity: Tourism and Trade Municipal Economic Activities: Commerce between adjacent cities Agricultural Production of Rice, Banana, Cassava, Corn. Aquaculture Wood production
Tabatinga - Brazil
Population: 59,684 people Predominant Economic Activity: Military Activity Municipality Economic Activity: Commerce between adjacent cities Agriculture Production of Nuts, Cacao, Natural Rubber, Avocado, Guaranรก, Banana, Coffee Wood production
Santa Rosa - Peru
Population: 2,500 people Predominant Economic Activity: Fishing Municipality Economic Activity: Commerce between adjacent cities Tourism 30
Phase 1 | WATER STRUCTURE Scale: City How water moves within the territory an initial approximation.
31
The water structure of the settlement. Water quality and conveyance is an issue in the 3 settlements. The Amazon river, contradictory to any belief, is not in optimal conditions to be used for consumption in this area. Although there is no heavy industries around the problem, lies in the deficient water treatment plants. People are forced to create wells to extract potable water.
Water Resource Yahuarcocha Lakes Leticia, COL
Aven ida Vá squez
Cobo
Water Treatment Plant Leticia, COL
14
uez Co
ida Vásq Aven
Carrera 11
Calle
bo
The hydrological structure of the settlement surpasses any political boundary but it presents problems when in interaction with the urban fabric. Where flooding occurs since the urban fabric has been imposed in some cases (Leticia) disregarding this system.
Calle 14
3
le 1
Cal
rera
11
11
le 11 Carre
Cal 11
ra Carre
Calle 8
7 ra 6
Calle 7
Calle 6
Perime
tral No
Ca
Rosa
ra 8
Ideal Afo
6
Carrera 11
ra rre
nso
Rua Peri
rte Dois
n
do
on
al R
ch
are a M
rigues
Carre
12 Calle 6
Santa
z Cobo Vásque
Carre
Calle 8
9
Avenida
Carrera
Carrera
Majority of streams in the urban center have been channelized disrupting the natural system
Calle 9
ra
10
María Viei
Calle
ra 8
Calle
Water Collection Santa Rosa, PER
Calle
l e 12
María Rod
C ar
Cal
Rua Per
imetral
Ru
Norte Um
Rua
Rua da
nto Oscar Rua Joao
Romario
Rua San
Barbo
Rua
Dois
Rua
e Coelho
tonio
g
Rua Duart
Rua An
onel Ber
ont
sa
de Fe vereiro
tos Dum
eiro Prim
Rua Cor
Rua
Rua Castelo
Braco
aba
da Cu
Patria
on chal Rond Rua Mare
eiro de Maio
g
nha
Rua Dom
Rua Prim
Duque de
eral Sam Rua Gen
Rua Tabatinga
Rua Ajuric
Rua Alm irante Tam andaré
Rua Santos Dumont
ade
Rua Marecha
Aires
nt Rua Santos Dumo Rua do Ater ro
Lucena
onel Ber
tes
en Tirad
Rua Fabio
Rua Vinte Seis ont
Rua Duarte Coelho
et
Osvaldo Cruz
tos Dum
Rua Cor
Rua Mar echal Mall
Rua
dentes
z
Rua San
Rua Men de Sá
Rua Marechal Mallet
Rua Tira
Osvald o Cru
iz de Aragão
al Rondon
o
Av. da Amiz
Rondon
sc
Rua Muñ
Rua Marech
Bo
Rua Marechal Mallet
Um
erto de
m Adalb
Rua Do
Rua Jeru
salem
Rua Sarge
om
paio
aD
Caxias
Rua da
Patria
Avenida da Amiz
ade
osta
da C
Ru
Do Arlindao
v
João VI
neral Os ório
aia
Samamb
Rua Ge
Water Treatment Plant Tabatinga, BRA Water Resource Amazon River Tabatinga, BRA 1500 ft
32
0
1500 ft
3000 ft
6000 ft
FLOODING AREAS
WATER STRUCTURE NATURAL + ARTIFICIAL COLLECTING POINTS
ia
Marzz
2
PERIPHERY OF THE URBAN SETTLEMENT TABATINGA-BRA
1 LETICIA AIRPORT COL
BORDER COL-BRA
TABATINGA AIRPORT COL
CITY
LETICIA COLONIAL DOWNTON
VEGETATION COVER
AIRSTRIP
COLLECTING AREA CORRESPONDING TO STREAM STRUCTURE
COLLECTING AREA CORRESPONDING TO STREAM STRUCTURE
LETICIA AIRPORT COL
CITY LIMIT BORDER COL-BRA
SECTION 1
TABATINGA AIRPORT COL
LOWEST INCOME TYPE HOUSING
LETICIA COLONIAL DOWNTON
AIRSTRIP
STREAM STREAM
SECTION 2
WATER STRUCTURE COLLECTION POINTS + TOPOGRAPHY
33
Phase 1 | SITE PHOTOGRAPHS Selected images
34
Santander Park_Leticia, Colombia Main Square
Port Leticia, Colombia 35
Border Milestone in the City Colombia-Brazil-Peru
Returning to Leticia to Tourist Dock near Main Marketplace Amazon River
Main Road Santa Rosa, Peru
Arriving to Santa Rosa Loading Bay
View from Santa Rosa to the NE Santa Rosa, Peru 36
â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Amizadeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; (Friendship) Avenue Tabatinga
Boardwalk to main road Santa Rosa, Peru
View of the Amazon River from ‘La Comara’ Tabatinga, Brazil
37
Findings + Conclusions
This phase allowed the collection of all the necessary information of the place as well as the essence of it. There were preconceptions before the investigation was initiated based on the initial research done in a distanced way, about how the territory worked. Some were confirmed and there were others that emerged. The confirmed hypothesis included the social fluxes of the people that don’t respond to any political boundary. The interdependence of these 3 settlements was also confirmed evidenced not only through visualization processes but during the site visit in commerce and interactions. These intangible relationships do not respond to political jurisdictions. Throughout a media research approach and during the site visit, the issues first proposed as focuses of the investigation were also confirmed. Deficient water quality, waste management, lack of public spaces and connectivity were evident. Things that emerged were the specific localization of the centralities in the territory as well as the connecting channels that together structure this place. A very important finding or later reflection, is that people in this urban center will not want to give up the character of it. Meaning this urban settlement can be located in the heart of the Amazon Region where the vocation is conservation, but it plays a role as a human centrality in a geopolitical sense.
38
One of the key findings is the driver of the investigation which is the element of water. ‘Water’ as in the hydrological system and as the set of landscape strategies that have to with this. Such as first, the rediscovering of that structure in the city then the punctual interventions that would lead to remediation, waste management treatment, water quality improvement, among others. Becoming this the strategy of weaving the conditions of the territory that has the ability to surpass almost all of them, political included and create a cohesive occupancy. In the next phase of the investigation, the main objective will be to spatially define the system that makes up these relationships, such as the centralities and connectors, overlaid upon the ‘water’ structure to find interstitial places where future interventions might be located. These points of intersection will be done by material explorations in concept models as well as drawings, to understand the relationships of the systems in these moments.
Assessment
One of the major adjustments that has to be done is the filtering of information and finding to focus on the matter that the investigation is heading which has to do with the ‘water’. The amount of work done has proven sufficient as a base but now needs further breakdown to be useful. Meaning that after the focus is determined the will be a selecting of key elements from the body of work already done. Another reflection of this first phase has to do with creating more vertical research that is not only focused on mapping and zooming in to understand the “section” layers of the place.
39
Phase 2 SUPERIMPOSITION Water as the construct of the BORDER-landscape
40
Abstract During Phase 2 of the process the main objective was to determine the interstitial and overlapping moments as strategic points that structure the Ecotone/Border Landscape that will be superimposed by the localization of specific areas that present deficiencies. This contrasted with the base of the water dynamics from the prior phase, to be used as a lens, in order to understand how the different type of systems function and identify where and how they are failing. The way the water system moves through the landscape with how the urban fabric exists, revealed a larger issue: a contradiction between both systems. The lack of synchronization, which was perceived at the beginning, was evidenced in one of the current issue the urban center goes through. Flooding, although a natural phenomena that occurs periodically in the area, is a major issue for both the people, their lively-hoods and the environmentâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s health since the urban settlement rejects and imposes on the natural structure. It is important to mention that currently, due to Global Warming effects, flooding has become more and more present as an issue in inner-continental urban settlements close to a river structure throughout the world affecting many key productive areas of many countries. (El NiĂąo Phenomenon 2017 in Peru, Colombia) And in contrast, another issue is the lack of Potable Water for the population ironically in a place that is located where 15% of the worldâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s fresh water is held and where there is an approximate of 2mm/hr of Rainfall. This is a result of a deficient infrastructure due to its location in the legislative periphery.
Area Considered for Study: 18 Square Km (7 Square Miles) 41
Introduction
Methods
In Phase 2 the focus was to identify the overlapping of the crucial moments of what constitutes the border condition (the human relationships within the landscape) with the mapped issue of flooding. For at the end have a set of initial strategies that recognize the dynamics of the landscape and use it as a leverage to solve issues related to the people and the environment.
The method of exploration was focused on 3 stages: 1. Visualizing the Issue 2. Understanding the Existent 3. Overlapping of Systems 4. Proposing Initial Strategies
This was done by first understanding how the territory works currently showing how the systems intertwine in a smaller scale and in a system view, throughout mapping and modeling. Specifically showing where the water system (streams) intercept the urban fabric. Then, mapping the flooding zones from journalistic accounts being the limited geographical information available to be then overlapped. The last step consisted on quantifying and visualizing initial strategies for the leverage of these issues, mainly rainfall, as advantages. Also exploring ways of managing flooding in urban areas that can be easily adapted to the context.
42
Phase 2 | VISUALIZING THE ISSUE
EXISTING STRUCTURE STREAMS + TOPOGRAPHY + GRID 43
FLOODING AFFECTED STREETS + AREAS 44
Phase 2 | VISUALIZING THE ISSUE
WATER’S BEHAVIOR IN THE LANDSCAPE: STORM WATER + RIVER’S GROWING THE PROBLEM
WHY IS THIS A PROBLEM?
The urban fabric of the settlement is not adapted to the natural water system flow, rainfall and the seasonal growing of the river making the natural phenomena of flooding affect people’s way of life and the environment.
Flooding of this Tri-national city, caused by heavy daily rainfall and seasonal growing of the river affects the 3 cities’ population’s safety, livelihoods, health-sanitation and pollution related issues in equal manner surpassing nationalities.
HOW MUCH DOES IT RAIN IN THE ECOTONE? Daily Average Rainfall of the Area: 1.83 mm/hour ~ 2mm/hr Source: https://www.worldweatheronline.com/leticia-weather/amazonas/co.aspx?day=0&tp=1
Area Included: 18 km sq [Leticia: 7.4km sq] [Tabatinga: 9.4km sq] [Santa Rosa: 1.2 km sq] Rainfall Water per Hour: 36,000,000 Liters/hr Source: https://water.usgs.gov/edu/activity-howmuchrain-meters.php
*AVERAGE RAINY DAYS IN THE ECOTONE AREA: 291 DAYS
HOW MUCH DOES IT RAIN IN OTHER PLACES? Manila, Philippines: 0.33 mm/hour 207 Rainy Days
http://sdwebx.worldbank.org/climateportal/index.cfm?page=country_historical_climate&ThisCCode=PHL
Seattle, WA: 1.34 mm/hour [211 Rainy Days] New Orleans, LA: 0.27 mm/hour [56 Rainy Days] http://sdwebx.worldbank.org/climateportal/index.cfm?page=country_historical_climate&ThisCCode=PHL
*Measured Rainfall Area *94,634 people
45
THE LIQUID BORDER: HOW CAN WATER BECOME A LEVERAGE FOR THE ENVIRONMENT + PEOPLE HOW MUCH WATER DOES A PERSON NEED PER DAY? 70 Liters - in an Emergency 100 Liters - To fulfill all necessities http://www.un.org/en/sections/issues-depth/water/
HOW MUCH WATER DOES THE AVERAGE COLOMBIAN, PERUVIAN AND BRAZILIAN USE PER DAY? COLOMBIAN: 500 Liters/day
http://revistas.udistrital.edu.co/ojs/index.php/tecges/article/view/4379/6601
PERUVIAN: 250 Liters/day
http://rpp.pe/lima/actualidad/peru-consume-250-litros-por-persona-casi-50-mas-que-madrid-noticia-751470
CONSUMED WATER IN THE AREA: 28’390,200 LITERS/DAY
BRAZILIAN: 160 Liters/day
http://redeglobo.globo.com/globoecologia/noticia/2013/05/brasileiro-consome-159-litros-por-dia.html
*AVERAGE: 300 LITERS/DAY
TOTAL RAINFALL WATER: 36’000,000 LITERS/HOUR TOTAL WATER NEEDED: 28’390,200 LITERS/DAY THE AMOUNT OF RAINFALL OF A DAY IN THE AREA CAN SUPPLY, WITH A LARGE BREADTH, THE DAILY WATER NEED FOR THE POPULATION. 46
47
Phase 2 | UNDERSTANDING THE EXISTENT OVERLAPPING B/N THE BORDERâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;S SYSTEM AND THE FLOODING AREAS
BORDER SYSTEM: FOCAL POINTS + CONNECTORS THAT CREATE THE RELATIONSHIPS
FLOODING AREAS + STREETS
48
Zones of possible analysis according to their different characteristics. Zone 1 - Consolidated urban downtown. Zone 2 - Border Zone 3 - Waterfront
Overlapping of the centralities of the border system city with the flooding issue. Highest points coincide with the most developed places of the city. Also, issues of flooding correspond to underground stream structure where city has been built upon. 49
Phase 2 | UNDERSTANDING THE EXISTENT
MAIN SQUARE PARK SANTANDER LETICIA-COL
Zone 1 - Urban Context Main Square Leticia-Colombia This area is one of the most important places in the urban center in general (the 3 cities) which is affected when flooding occurs because of large volumes of precipitation.
ZONE 1 - PARK SANTANDER
50
BORDER
Zone 2 - The Border Commercial Area - Port of Leticia - Thermoelectric Plant - Housing Zone for both Leticia and Brazil This zone compromises a tension between 3 systems the urban fabric, the hydrological structure and the flooding problematic issue.
ZONE 2 - THE BORDER
51
Phase 2 | UNDERSTANDING THE EXISTENT
MARKETPLACE TABATINGA, BR
Zone 3 - Waterfront Marketplace Tabatinga - Brazil The zone is the heart of the commercial and trade area for the Brazilian side and is also a liability when flooding, both by the river and precipitation happen. The market place was strategically located near to the Amazon river for easy access of loading goods.
ZONE 3 - WATERFRONT + COMMERCIAL CENTER
52
Phase 2 | STRATEGIES ZONE 1 - PARK SANTANDER STORM WATER MANAGEMENT STREETSCAPE DESIGN System of collection and diversion of water to be filtered and conveyed for household use. Constrains: Street Profile Dimension 60-70 Ft.
existent
road
to household
tank
tank 45’
15’
BIOSWALE IMPLEMENTATION
15’
existent
PERMEABLE PAVING + DIVERTION OF WATER
10’
15’
30’
10’
10’
to household tank
tank +0.5’ 0’ -0.5’
RAIN GARDEN COLLECTORS
-3’ -5’
Low Impact + applicable - time
53
Phase 2 | STRATEGIES ZONE 2 - THE BORDER FLOODABLE PUBLIC SPACE + INTERNATIONAL REGULATION Creation of buffer zone for the stream making it a public space that can collect water and divert excess to the river. Also creating a regulated international space. Constrains: People will not want to relocate, Presence of Thermoelectric Plant, Bureaucratic Inefficiency. 389 Ft
106 Ft
185 Ft
border Brazil Colombia
Partial Relocation
ZONE 2_FLOODABLE PUBLIC SPACE
680 Ft
EXISTING CONDITION Floodable Public Space border Permeable Ground Artificial Rain Collectors
PROPOSED CONDITION
High Impact - applicable + time 54
ZONE 3 - WATERFRONT + COMMERCIAL CENTER PERMEABLE PUBLIC WATERFRONT SPACE Creation of buffer zone for the stream making it a public space that can collect water and divert excess to the river. Also creating a regulated international space. Constrains: People will not want to relocate, Place is highly consolidated as key part of that side of the city. 100 Ft
46 Ft
100 Ft
463 Ft
Partial Relocation
707 Ft
EXISTING CONDITION
100 Ft
46 Ft
100 Ft
463 Ft
Wharf/Lookout
PROPOSED CONDITION
Medium Impact ~ applicable ~ time 55
Findings + Conclusions Phase 2 was a phase to experiment in a large scale a system approach solution. In some ways it is a collection of the detailed research done to be then be presented in a greater perspective. When overlapping the two kinds of systems (the border condition system with the issue system) the main expectation anticipated was for the areas affected by the issue also be centralities. This was somewhat confirmed since it does follow this pattern which is something logical since the imposition of the urban fabric disregards the natural systems. One of the greatest finding of the research was that of realizing how a deficiency can become an asset shared by the three international cities. This started when the mapping of the issue (flooding) was being done where a question emerged seeing how this was a problem of an urban scale: how much water is the city receiving from precipitation? Insomuch that it is one of the wetter locations in the world. This lead for further investigation about how much water is consumed by the population currently and contrasting it with the standard of how much a person needs to live with to get a dimension of the quantity. This resulted in the quantification of the need which is something that can be worked with and can be relied upon. For the next phase this is something that will be brought and visualized in an easier way to be easily understood. It is important to mention that in Latin America river’s and affluents, as well as rainfall, has not been regulated to such detail as in the US where there are some examples of maximum water consumption levels legislation. Such as the Colorado River Compact which does address the amount of water a state can deplete from the shared river. 56
In South America river ways have two roles: to some extent they define political borders between countries and they have been made up of many affluents coming from different countries creating a legislative/bureaucratic issue to be regulated. As a clear example the Amazon River is shared between 9 countries but the water basin volume is shared as well as protected from any intervention from any of the member countries without prior knowledge from the Amazon Treaty Organization. Though, internal affluents can be managed according to the country’s jurisdiction like in the case of Brazil that possess many energy producing dams. But in general the jurisdiction of water volume of a stream that crosses many political boundaries is not regulated. Having collected key factual information makes the next phase’s objective to focus on the possibilities of a new vision which is grounded in real information regarding a valuable resource.
Assessment Phaseâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s 2 method was very clear and helpful to achieve the level wanted for Phase 3. This was a method made in junction with the advisor which helped a lot in structuring the work following the overall intention. The findings made in this phase were valuable and revealing as such the method was effective. Although there was a lot of progress done, the amount of work envisioned was not achieved due to technical issues with resources outside the researchâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s reach. Also because of time-organizational issues when some of the work was underestimated time wise. Major adjustments had to be done to synthesize due the lack of time left, such as substitution of representation methods in drawings. Things that could be improved would be the time management of work that is possible to be produced vs. desired. Also taking in account external influences that can affect the work produced.
57
58
Phase 3 PUNCTURE
Landscape as Infrastructure: Visions of Storm-water and Flood management
59
Abstract During this phase the development of the work produced was focused on creating visions of a system (the 4th condition/the new) as the weaving mechanism between the different networks and systems. The main conceptual strategy of this network: Landscape as Infrastructure. Landscape Architecture as the missing link between the systems making water perform as the commons linking the people, the territory and the environment.
The Weaving System (The 4th Condition) Created of the crossing of the undeveloped spaces of the city and the flooding + centralities analysis.
60
Introduction
Methods
Phase 3 is the proposition phase of the research project where projective design strategies are implemented as a form of study of the issue. The main issue, reiterated before, was the inconsistencies between the urban fabric and the environment network.
The methods in this phase varied in scale from the urban to the local chosen area they were done simultaneously taking from each scale to the other not following a linear process. 1. Definition of the objective of the proposal : CATCH - FILTER - DIRECT - HOLD 2. Understanding the Existent in the Local Scale: The relationship of the building with the streetscape. Here the main exercise was to model reality to understand the architecture and the public space deficiencies of the space. This was done by drawing exercises and mapping. 3. Existent Typology Modeling of a generalization of the building types trying to be very close to reality to capture the characteristic sense of place. 4. Conceptual design strategy explored: PUNCTURE 5. Connecting the pedestrian/local proposal to the larger system. 6. Proposed vision creation.
There are 2 contradicting issues in the area: Lack of Potable Water and Flooding. In this struggle to accommodate people and build a city, major phenomena was overlooked, these 3 cities face a great potable water shortage because of the lacking infrastructure that exists but is in a deplorable state. And most depend on individual wells that connect directly to the aquifer giving a shortterm solution. Flooding, as a result of global warming effects, something customary of the tropics to some extent, has become problematic since the urban fabric is not a flexible element that can adapt to the hydrological dynamics of the site as fast and as ideal as it could. There are 2 Forces that cause the Flooding issue: 1. The Seasonal Growing of the River during the Summer months (December April) Where there is the preconception that the river behaves respecting the city boundaries, when in reality it expands and contracts affecting the urban fabric. 2. The Heavy tropical Rainfall Where again we have the idea that rain just stops when it hits the ground, when it follows its own process of infiltration.
61
Phase 3 THE WATER SYSTEMS Currently the 3 settlements that sit in this area have gone through major political spatial shift since their establishments in the past until now, where the main asset is the Amazon River being the most important resource for their livelihoods and connection. The River is a critical resource of economical, trade, cultural and ecological importance shared between the different nationalities.
THE AMAZON WATERSHED
62
The Amazon River corresponds to a larger ecological system which possess its own dynamics on the land affecting these settlementâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s state. The River not only as its own element but as the system it represents: the watershed, the precipitation behaviors, the vegetation, etc. And how these hydro-dynamics interconnect the territory, making water the underpinning element between systems.
THE LOCAL WATERSHED
63
Phase 3 THE TWO FORCES
GROWING OF THE RIVER 64
TROPICAL RAINFALL
The Placeâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Streetscape. Standing Water issues, emergent public space as a response of the climate, density.
65
Phase 3 OVERLAPPING THE SUPERIMPOSED SYSTEMS
The conditions or systems of the site overlayed once again as the base for the proposal. 66
The undeveloped areas as the base of the weaving network (the new condition).
Phase 3 LANDSCAPE AS INFRASTRUCTURE
THE WEAVING SYSTEM BETWEEN THE EXISTENT SYSTEMS
67
Phase 3 AREA OF INTERVENTION
BORDER
The area to focus on possess a mixture of different conditions that make it very appropriate to be used as test site. The overlapping conditions included were: - Flooding Issue - Existent Hydrological Structure - Consolidated part of the city - Closeness to the border It is important to mention that the area chosen shows that the flooding issue is caused by the existent hydrological structure as well as topographical which would explain the reason of constant flooding.
68
Phase 3 OBJECTIVE OF THE SYSTEM
CATCH - FILTER - DIRECT - HOLD
69
Phase 3 DESIGN CONCEPT STRATEGY
PUNCTURE
Disruption of the built system to allow for ecological processes to happen in conjunction with the human activity.
70
Undeveloped spaces become water collectors (sponges) in time of flooding preventing the city of flooding.
ZONAL PROPOSAL
Public Space Deficiency Solution: Spaces between buildings become gathering spots for the community.
Alternative circulation between the new undeveloped areas to be potentially used and the urban fabric, catering to the pedestrian which is the predominant mode of transportation.
Visible stream
Water circulation channel with filtering system based on a low-tech system of gravels and vegetation. This connects to the individual household system.
Overlayed impervious type sidewalk for efficient accessibility.
Access points for buildingâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s services 60 Ft
0
60 Ft
120 Ft
71
NATURALIZING THE URBAN GROUND
The intervention is composed of 3 elements or parts: 1. Naturalizing the urban ground by restoring it to its permeable characteristics as well as the filtering system for water. 2. Undeveloped spaces (lots) as designed sponges for flooding control. 3. Water flow circulation for the filtering processes and aeration.
UNDEVELOPED SPACES AS SPONGES
WATER FLOW CIRCULATION
72
Phase 3 IMPLEMENTATION VISION
73
The expansion and contraction of the design responds to the different types of zoning and buildings. Where the contraction creates a more limited access appropriate for private use and the expansion as the possibility for public engagement.
74
GRAVELS
RAIN WATER HARVESTING
HOUSEHOLD FILTER
FILTRATION SYSTEM
75
76
Findings + Conclusions During this last phase the main finding in terms of the project were many such as the potential of the undeveloped spaces or lots found. These spaces vary in nature since they might be owned or they might be remnants of the city. The city possess this type of undeveloped land because of the lack of attraction as an urban center in comparison with other cities. Since the only ways to access it are by plane or river, services and products have difficulty reaching these points. Also, the economic opportunities for the population which can become very specialized are very narrow based on tourism, military or scientific research. Another finding and conclusion was the importance of the siteâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s character and vocation. And how this is crucial to fully implement a successful project of any kind. What was found with this project was the underlying importance of the hydrological structure which creates a link to people without looking that much into cultural aspects that can expand the method of operation instead of synthesizing it. One important finding was the reinforcement that Landscape should be taken as Infrastructure that gives coherence to the built environment, not as an postaccessory to accommodate deficiencies.
77
Assessment The most important reflection of this phaseâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s developments was the need to create more explorations about the design phase. Both in design by exploring different methods as well as the materiality. Where there could be more detail to the design in itself for later evaluation. Also, it would have been helpful to recognize with more exactness the moments to shift scale to keep developing the project. Since this project evidences that the constant scale shift is needed for a thorough understanding of the place as well as the design solution. One last complement for this phase would have been the constructing of a plan of implementation thinking it from the Planning (Top-Down) side to the Community for this to become more tangible and valid as a tool to unite nations. There were a lot of enigmas in the research project that were not answered due to lack of time and focus. These were such as: the geological structure (soil structure) of the site that could have helped in the definition of the type of water collection system; cultural indigenous precedents in methods of water collection as well and a stronger vision of the productive alternative the proposal might have.
78
79
Overall Assessment
80
Final Conclusions This research project has been successful enough into creating the preamble for a more specialized and technical exploration. It has shown the theoretical potential as a physical realization of international relations in a very specific case which is this one, in the Amazon. There is a lot of work to be done and calibrated but the process has opened new ways of approaching an issue that has been taken on by other disciplines that unlike Landscape cannot handle multiple scales, temporality and system thinking design. With this first attempt to denominate these types of in-between landscapes (BORDERSCAPE) as their own not only shifts the conversation from consolidated cities but it starts to shift it in a more serious light to the developing world cities where there are a whole lot of factors that affect decision making based on economical resources. The more detailed spatialization of the proposal from the last phase is shown as a provocative vision with the aim to be challenged and modified to fit a suitable option. That falls into the details of the place.
81
Final Assessment The themes and topics of this thesis existed before the process begun where what was needed was a clear structure on how to develop the outcomes. This was a process of continued calibration from the beginning to end, thinking about the scope of the research as well as the capacity to produce. The tools to define the process, such as the schedule and weekly agendas helped clarify the direction of the thesis to a more focused one. One reflection about the outcomes was the difficulty of enlarging the scale to achieve a more attainable scale such as the pedestrian. The importance of the mapping exercises was very necessary but it would have been more successful to invest a lot more in the final outcome since the larger scale was somewhat resolved. This could have been done with more intensity in the 3-dimensional plane (physical model) since the relationships between materials in a model can mimic concepts of construct. The difficulty to enlarge the scale lies on the ‘where’ to begin and ‘how’ without having a larger scale road map. But this exercise of going between both helped nurture one another. But apart from this, it was necessary to create the larger scale work to really posses the vision of the larger system which is not perceivable in the pedestrian scale that was evidenced in the site visit. Another representation tool that helped clarify the direction of the thesis was the constant diagramming of relationships to explain concepts and intentions. This synthesis method is crucial when handling system thinking approaches.
82
Bibliography References: Ian L. McHarg. Design with Nature. USA: John Wiley and Sons. 1992 Jill Desimini & Charles Waldheim. Cartographic Grounds. New York: Princeton Architectural Press. 2016 Edited by Philipp Misselwitz and Tim Rieniets. City of collision : Jerusalem and the principles of conflict urbanism. Basel ; Boston : Birkhäuser, 2006. Precedents for Visualization: - Dredge Research Collaborative. http://dredgeresearchcollaborative.org/ “The Dredge Research Collaborative is an independent 501c3 nonprofit organization which investigates human sediment handling practices, through publications, an event series, and various other projects. Our mission is to advance public knowledge about sediment management; to provide platforms for trans-disciplinary conversation about sediment management; and to participate in envisioning and realizing preferred sedimentary futures.” - Lateral Office. (Several Projects) “Is an experimental design practice that operates at the intersection of architecture, landscape, and urbanism. The studio describes its practice process as a commitment to “design as a research vehicle to pose and respond to complex, urgent questions in the built environment,” engaging in the “wider context and climate of a project– social, ecological, or political.” LATERAL OFFICE is committed to an architecture that responds directly to the demands of the 21st century - and the subsequent new typologies made possible by an architecture that brazenly confronts today. Recent work and research focuses on powerful design relationships between public realm, infrastructure, and the environment.”
83
Historical References (Timeline) Bellis, Mary. “Charles Goodyear & The History of Rubber.” ThoughtCo. N.p., n.d. Web. 23 Apr. 2017. “Historia Medieval De Reyno De Granada.” Historia Medieval Del Reyno De Navarra. Fundacion Lebrel Blanco, n.d. Web. 23 Apr. 2017. Kingdom of Spain. “Tratado De Madrid.” Tratado De Madrid. 13 De Enero De 1750. Kingdom of Spain, 13 Jan. 1750. Web. 23 Apr. 2017. Laamericaespanyola. “Las Leyes De Indias.” La América Española. Wordpress, 22 Dec. 2016. Web. 23 Apr. 2017. Reino De España. RecopilacioÌ n De Leyes De Los Reinos De Las Indias Mandadas a Imprimir Y Publicar Por La Magestad Catolica Del Rey Don Carlos II: Nuestro Senor. Madrid: Boix, 1841. Print. “Rubber.” Rubber. New World Encyclopedia, n.d. Web. 23 Apr. 2017. “Tratado De Tordesillas.” Planisferio Cantino. Biblioteca Estense Universitaria, 21 May 2017. Web. 23 Apr. 2017. Search terms: Amazon River Rubber Boom Indies Laws Apaporis-Tabatinga Kingdom of Spain and Portugal New World
84
1.Conceptual-Theoretical Framework: ‘BORDERSCAPES’: Understanding what compromises a borderland, border and the new concept of ‘borderscape’. Brambilla, Chiara, and Holger Pötzsch. “iBorder, Borderscapes, Bordering: A Conversation – Chiara Brambilla and Holger Pötzsch.” Society and Space, 05 Mar. 2015. Web. 30 May 2016. <https://societyandspace.com/material/article-extras/iborder-borderscapes-bordering-a-conversation-chiara-brambilla-and-holgerpotzsch/>. Brambilla, Chiara. “Exploring the Critical Potential of the Borderscapes Concept.” Geopolitics 20.1 (2014): 14-34. Web. <http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/ 10.1080/14650045.2014.884561>. Brambilla, Chiara, Jussi Laine, James Wesley Scott, and Gianluca Bocchi. Borderscaping: Imaginations and Practices of Border Making. N.p.: Routledge, n.d. Print. Buoli, Alice. “Borderscaping: Design Patterns and Practices On/across Borderlands.” Territorio 72 (2015): 85-94. Research Gate. Web. <https://www. researchgate.net/publication/277614383_Borderscaping_Design_patterns_and_practices_onacross_borderlands>. “Definition of Borderland and Border.” Art & Architecture Thesaurus Full Record Display (Getty Research). Getty Research, n.d. Web. 30 May 2016. <http:// www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=border&logic=AND¬e=&english=N&prev_page=1&subjectid=300387143>. Dell’Agnese, Elena, and Anne-Laure Amilhat-Szary. Borderscapes: From Border Landscapes to Border Aesthetics. S.l.: S.n., 2015. Print. Rajaram, Prem Kumar., and Carl Grundy-Warr. Borderscapes: Hidden Geographies and Politics at Territory’s Edge. Minneapolis: U of Minnesota, 2007. Print. Sotiriou, Steven. “Borderscape: (re)defining the Customs.” Borderscape: (re)defining the Customs. University of Witwatersrand, 26 Nov. 2011. Web. 30 May 2016. <http://hdl.handle.net/10539/10658>. Turner, Nancy J. “Art & Architecture Thesaurus Full Record Display (Getty Research).” Art & Architecture Thesaurus Full Record Display (Getty Research). Human Ecology, n.d. Web. 31 May 2016. <http://www.getty.edu/vow/AATFullDisplay?find=border&logic=AND¬e=&english=N&prev_ page=1&subjectid=300387143>. Viljoen, H. “Crossing Borders, Dissolving Boundaries. Cross/Cultures: Readings in Post/Colonial Literatures and Cultures in English 157.” Tydskrif Vir Letterkunde Tyd Let 51.1 (2014): 178. Web. 85
2. Contemporary Relevant Articles of the Subject Matter: ARCHITIZER. “Can Architects Do For Borders What They’ve Done For Embassies?” CityLab. N.p., 20 June 2013. Web. 30 May 2016. <http://www.citylab.com/ design/2013/06/can-architects-do-borders-what-theyve-done-embassies/5976/>. THE DATA TEAM. “More Neighbours Make More Fences.” The Economist. The Economist Newspaper, 07 Jan. 2016. Web. 30 May 2016. <http://www. economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2016/01/daily-chart-5>. Henley, Jon. “Walls: An Illusion of Security from Berlin to the West Bank.” The Guardian. Guardian News and Media, 19 Nov. 2013. Web. 30 May 2016. <http:// www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/nov/19/walls-barrier-belfast-west-b-ank>. Swiatek, Lukasz. “Theorizing Borders through Analyses of Power Relationships.” Regions and Cohesions 4.3 (2014): n. pag. Web. Taylor, Adam. “Map: Europe Is Building More Fences to Keep People out.” Washington Post. The Washington Post, 28 Oct. 2015. Web. 30 May 2016. <https:// www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2015/08/28/map-the-walls-europe-is-building-to-keep-people-out/>. Vadjunec, Jacqueline M., Marianne Schmink, and Alyson L. Greiner. “New Amazonian Geographies: Emerging Identities and Landscapes.” Journal of Cultural Geography 28.1 (2011): 1-20. Taylor & Francis Online. Web. <http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/08873631.2011.548477>. Vergel-Tovar, Erik. Ciudades Gemelas En Fronteras Amazónicas: Estudio De Caso Leticia Y Tabatinga. Bogotá: CUADERNOS DE VIVIENDA Y URBANISMO. Vol. 1, No. 2, 2008: 348 - 393, 7 May 2008. PDF. 3. Contextual information and Support Resources: Dunning, John B., Brent J. Danielson, and H. Ronald Pulliam. “Ecological Processes That Affect Populations in Complex Landscapes.” Ecological Processes That Affect Populations in Complex Landscapes 65.1 (1992): 169-75. JStor. Oikos. Web. 30 May 2016. <http://www.jstor.org/stable/3544901>. Fisher, Max. “40 More Maps That Explain the World.” Washington Post. The Washington Post, 13 Jan. 2014. Web. 30 May 2016. <https://www.washingtonpost. com/news/worldviews/wp/2014/01/13/40-more-maps-that-explain-the-world/>. Kim, Dongsei. “The Demilitarized Zone: Redrawing the 151 Mile Border between North and South Korea.” Howard T. Fisher Prize in GIS (2012): n. pag. Harvard Graduate School of Design. Web. 30 May 2016. <https://cga-download.hmdc.harvard.edu/publish_web/Annual_Spring_Workshops/2012_Africa/posters/Kim_ Dongsei.pdf>. Meyer, Elizabeth. “The Expanded Field of Landscape Architecture.” Ecological Design and Planning (1997): 167-87. Print.
86
Secretariat, Permanent. “The Strategic Agenda for ACTO.” AMAZONIAN STRATEGIC COOPERATION AGENDA (2011): n. pag. Http://otca.info/portal/ apresentacao.php?p=agd. ACTO. Web. Schwägerl, Christian. “Along Scar from Iron Curtain, A Green Belt Rises in Germany.” By Christian Schwägerl: Yale Environment 360. Yale Environment 360, 04 Apr. 2011. Web. 30 May 2016. <http://e360.yale.edu/feature/along_scar_from_iron_curtain_a_green_belt_rises_in_germany/2390/>. Smith, Adrian, and Andy Stirling. “The Politics of Social-ecological Resilience and Sustainable Socio-technical Transitions.” Ecology and Society: The Politics of Social-ecological Resilience and Sustainable Socio-technical Transitions. Science & Technology Policy Research, University of Sussex, n.d. Web. 30 May 2016. <http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol15/iss1/art11/>. 4. Border Integration Colombia. Ministerio De Relaciones Exteriores. Comisiones Binacionales De Vecindad. Vol. 5. Santafé De Bogotá: Tercer Mundo Editores, 1994. Linares, Rosalba. “Zona De Integración Fronteriza (ZIF) Y Su Dimensión Territorial En La Frontera Táchira (Venezuela) - Norte De Santander (Colombia).” Redalyc. org. Aldea Mundo, Nov. 2005. Web. 07 Feb. 2014. EPYPSA EPYPSA. Plan Maestro De Integración Y Desarrollo Fronterizo Binacional En Argentina Y Bolivia. Tech. EPYPSA, n.d. Web. 14 Feb. 2014. <http://www.epypsa. com/entrada117.html>. Convenio Andrés Bello. A Integración Y El Desarrollo Social Fronterizo. 1st ed. Vol. 3. Bogota: Convenio Andrés Bello, 2006-2007. Print. García De La Torre, Clara Ines. Fronteras : Territorios Y Metáforas. 1st ed. Medellin: Hombre Nuevo Editores, 2002.
87
Search Terms: Natural Structure 1. Ecosystem 2. Eco-Region 3. Co-Habitation 4. Anthropologic Biomes 5. Ecozone 6. Freshwater Ecoregion Edges + Borders 1. Border 2. Borderscapes 3. Biosphere Reserves 4. Borderland 5. Permeable + Impermeable Social Component 4. Development 5. Social-ecological resilience 6. Endogenous Development 7. Urbanization
88
89